{"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_count": 31, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02857732", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02857732.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Memorandum\nSubjectDate\n\nRe: Operation Leap Year\n\nMay I, 2007\n(Revised 9/13/07)\n(2nd Revision 2/19/08) a\n\nToFrom\nR. Alexander Acosta, United States Attorney\nJeff Sloman, First Assistant United States Attorney\nChief, Criminal Division\nMAUSA, Northern Region\nChief, Northern Region\n\nM,\n\nI. Introduction\nThis memorandum seeks a royal for the attached indictment charging Jeffrey Epstein,\na/k/a\nJEGE Inc., and Hyperion Air, Inc.\nThe proposed indictment contains 60 counts and seeks the forfeiture of Epstein's Palm Beach home and\ntwo airplanes. F-'\nThe FBI has information regarding Epstein's whereabouts on May 16th and May 19th and\nthey would like to arrest him on one of those dates. Epstein is considered an extremely high flight\nrisk F3 and, from information we have received, a continued danger to the community based upon\nhis continued enticement of underage girls. For these reasons, we would like to present a sealed\nindictment to the Grand Jury on May 15, 2007 , and we would like the presentation of that\nindictment and the status of the investigation to remain confidential. Epstein's crimes are\nconsidered crimes of violence and negotiation with his attorneys may undermine our arguments\nfor pretrial detention.\nThe investigation initially was undertaken by the City of Palm Beach Police Department in\nres nse to a coin laint received from the parents of a 14-year-old girl,\n., from\n. When\n. and another girl began arguing at school because the other girl accused\nof\nbeing a prostitute, one of the school princi als intervened. The principal searched\npurse and\nwhere the money came from.\ninitially claimed that\nfound $300 cash. The principal asked\nshe earned the money working at \"Chik-Fil-A,\" which no one believed.\nthen claimed that she\nmade the money selling drugs; no one believed that either.\nfinally admitted that she had been paid\nparents approached the Palm Beach\n$300 to give a massage to a man on Palm Beach Island.\nPolice Department (\"PBPD\") about pressing charges.\nPBPD began inve\n... [truncated, 3048 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/0 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=0]", "char_count": 3048}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "On October 18, 2005, PBPD obtained a search warrant with the assistance of the Palm Beach\nCounty State Attorney's Office (\"PBSAO\"). By this time, PBSAO had already been contacted by\nEpstein's cadre of lawyers. When PBPD arrived at Epstein's home two days later (10/20/05) to execute\nthe search warrant, they found several items conspicuously missing. For example, computer monitors\nand keyboards were found, but the CPUs were gone. F4 Similarly, surveillance cameras were found, but\nthey were disconnected and the videotapes were gone. Nonetheless, the search did recover some\nevidence of value, including message path showing messages from many girls over a two-year span.\nThe messages show girls returning phone calls to confirm appointments to \"work.\" Messages were\ntaken by\n, and\n. Fs The search also recovered numerous\nphotos of Epstein sitting with naked girls whose ages are undetermined.\nPhotographs taken inside the home show that the girls' descriptions of the layout of the home and\nmaster bedroom/bathroom area are accurate. PBPD also found massage tables and oils, the high school\ntranscript of one of the girls, and sex toys.\nIn sum, the PBPD investigation showed that girls from a local high school F6 would be contacted\nby one of Epstein's assistants to make an appointment to \"work.\" Up to three appointments each day\nwould be made. The girls would travel to Epstein's home in Palm Beach where they would meet\nEpstein's chef and Epstein's assistant—usually _—in the kitchen. The assistant normally would\nescort the girls upstairs to the master bedroom/bathroom area and set up the massage table and massage\noils. The assistant would leave and Epstein would enter the room wearing a robe or a towel. He would\nremove the clothing and lie face down and nude on the massage table. Epstein would then instruct the\ngirl on what to do and would ask her to remove her clothing. After some time, Epstein would turn over,\nso that he was lying face up. Epstein would masturbate himself and fond\n... [truncated, 4243 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/1 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=1]", "char_count": 4243}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Epstein's conduct violates a number of federal statutes, all of which are discussed herein. None\nof the statutes or their penalties changed during the time period charged (early 2004 through mid-2005),\nalthough many have changed since then. I use the language of the statutes as they appeared while\nEpstein was committing the offenses.\nIn addition to conspiracy charges, there are five statutes related to sexual activity that have been\nviolated. First, Epstein traveled in interstate commerce with the intent to engage in illicit sexual\nconduct, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2423(6). Second, Epstein and his assistants used a facility of\ninterstate commerce to induce or entice minors to engage in prostitution and sexual activi for which\nany person can be charged, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2422(b). Third, Epstein transported\nin interstate commerce with the intent that\nengage in sexual activity for which a person can\nbe charged, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2421. For these three offenses, knowledge of the victim's age\ndoes not need to be proven, although a reasonable belief that a person is over 18 is an affirmative\ndefense to a limited portion of § 2423(b). FIO\nIn those instances where Epstein and/or the assistants knew the ages of the girls (or had reason to\nknow their ages but willfully blinded themselves to that knowledge), they can be char ed with sex\ntraffickin , in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1591(a)(1). In such instances,\n, and\nalso can be charged with benefitting from their participation in a venture engaged in human\nsex trafficking, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1591(a)(2).\nA. Violations of the Mann Act: 18 U.S.C. §§ 2421-2423\n1. Knowledge of Age Is Not Required.\nThe Mann Act criminalizes traveling in interstate commerce to engage in \"illicit sexual conduct,\"\n(§ 2423(b)), using a facility of interstate commerce to entice a minor to engage in sexual activity or\nprostitution (§ 2422(b)), and transporting a person to engage in sexual activity (§ 2421). Sections\n2423(b) and\n... [truncated, 4055 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/2 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=2]", "char_count": 4055}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Section 845 of 21 U.S.C.A. provides that anyone who knowingly or intentionally\ndistributes controlled substances to a person under twenty-one is subject to enhanced\npenalties. . . . [T]he court instructed the jury that it is not an essential element of the\ncrime that the person who distributes be knowledgeable that the person to whom he\ndistributes is under twenty-one years old; it is the distribution that must be knowing,\nalthough it is an essential element that the person to whom the distribution is made is\nunder twenty-one.\nUnited States v. Pruitt , 763 F.2d 1256, 1261 (11th Cir. 1985). In reaching this decision, the Eleventh\nCircuit relied upon the Third Circuit's Hamilton decision, supra :\nThere is, however, a precise analogue to this statute, 18 U.S.C.A. § 2421 et seq. (White\nSlave Traffic Act), which prohibits the interstate transportation of persons in order to\nengage in immoral practices including prostitution, and which provides enhanced penalties\nfor the knowing transportation of persons under the age of eighteen years. Under this\nstatute, knowledge of the victim's age is not an element of the crime; the \"knowing\"\ncomponent applies to the transportation itself.\nId. at 1262 (citing Hamilton ). See also United States v. Williams , 922 F.2d 737, 739 (11th Cir. 1991)\n(using same rationale to decide that Government need not prove knowledge of age for a charge of\nknowingly employing, using, persuading, inducing, enticing, or coercing a person under eighteen years\nof age in the commission of a drug offense).\nIn United States v. Taylor , 239 F.3d 994 (9th Cir. 2001), the Ninth Circuit addressed a\ndefendant's assertion that knowledge of minority is required to convict him of transporting a minor for\npurposes of prostitution. The Ninth Circuit held that the \"more natural reading of the statute, however,\nis that the requirement of knowledge applies to the defendant's conduct of transporting the person rather\nthan to the age of the person transported.\" Id. at 997. In\n... [truncated, 4226 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/3 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=3]", "char_count": 4226}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "defendant \"reasonably believed that the person with whom the defendant engaged in the commercial sex\nact had attained the age of 18 years.\" 18 U.S.C. § 2423(g). The inclusion of that affirmative defense\nshows that Congress considered the issue and decided that the United States does not have to make an\ninitial showing of knowledge of age for violations of 2423(b). Congress likewise considered the same\nissue for the other portions of the Mann Act and reached the same conclusion. If Congress had intended\nto place the burden of proving age on the United States — or if it had decided that it should create an\naffirmative defense to those charges — it could have done so. Congress' use of similar offense language\nfor the other sections of the Mann Act shows that Congress likewise did not intend to require proof of\nknowledge of age to violate those sections either. See Gustafson v. Alloyd Co., Inc. , 513 U.S. 561, 570\n(1995) (noting the \"normal rule of statutory construction\" that \"identical words used in different parts of\nthe same act are intended to have the same meaning\").\nIn United States v. Scott , 999 F.2d 541, 1993 WL 280323 (6th Cir. 1993), the defendant argued\nthat the Mann Act was unconstitutional for failing to include a requirement that the Government prove\nthe defendant's knowledge of the age of the minor. The Sixth Circuit rejected the argument. First, it\nfound that \"[k]nowledge that a girl is under 18 years of age when transported interstate is not part of the\nproof required of the government in order to sustain a conviction under 18 U.S.C. § 2423. The\ngovernment proved, as it must, that [the victim] was in fact a minor at the time of the interstate\ntransportation . . . The Mann Act does not require more.\" Id. , 1993 WL 280323 at *6 (citation\nomitted). The Sixth Circuit then stated:\nit does not offend due process for Congress to draft a statute that does not require the\nprosecution to show that a defendant believed the victim to be under the age of 18 when\ns\n... [truncated, 4525 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/4 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=4]", "char_count": 4525}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Whoever, using the mail or any facility or means of interstate . . . commerce, . . .\nknowingly persuades, induces, [or] entices . . . any individual who has not attained the age\nof 18 years, to engage in prostitution or any sexual activity for which any person can be\ncharged with a criminal offense, or attempts to do so, shall be fined under this title and\nimprisoned not less than 5 years and not more than 30 years.\n18 U.S.C. § 2422(b).\nThe United States must show either:\nFirst: That the Defendant knowingly used a facility of interstate commerce to persuade, induce,\nor entice a person to engage in prostitution; and\nSecond: That the person so persuaded was under the age of 18;\nor\n\nFirst: That the Defendant knowingly used a facility of interstate commerce to persuade, induce,\nor entice a person to engage in sexual activity;\nSecond: That the person so persuaded was under the age of 18; and\nThird: That the Defendant could have been charged with a criminal offense under the law of\nFlorida based upon the sexual activity. !F\nThe statute does not define \"facility or means of interstate commerce\" or \"prostitution.\"\na. A telephone is a \"facility of interstate commerce.\"\nThe Eleventh Circuit has ruled that evidence of the use of a telephone satisfies the element of\nusing a facility or means of interstate commerce. United States v. Drury , 396 F.3d 1303, 1311 (11th\nCir. 2005) (the term \"facility of interstate commerce . . . establishes federal jurisdiction whenever any\n\"facility of interstate commerce\" is used in the commission of [the] offense, regardless of whether the\nuse is interstate in nature ( L e. , the telephone call was between states) or purely intrastate in nature ( i.e.\n, the telephone call was made to another telephone within the same state).\"). In Drury , the defendant\nused his land-line telephone to call an undercover agent's cellular telephone. Although both the\ndefendant and the agent were in Georgia, the signals to the agent's cell phone had to pass through\nV\n... [truncated, 3936 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/5 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=5]", "char_count": 3936}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Id. at 1180-81 (citations omitted).\nb. \"Prostitution\"\nAs noted above and discussed more thoroughly below, almost none of the girls engaged in\ntraditional sexual intercourse with Epstein. The common activity included allowing Epstein to fondle\nthe girl while he masturbated himself, Epstein's digital penetration of the girl, and Epstein's use of a\nvibrator on the girl while he masturbated himself. It is clear that this activity was done in exchange for\nmoney, but the defense will likely argue that some of the activity was not \"sexual enough\" to qualify as\n\"prostitution.\"\nTitle 18 carries no definition of \"prostitution.\" In United States v. Prince , the Fifth Circuit\napproved of the generic definition \"sexual intercourse for hire\". Prince , 515 F.2d 564, 566 (5th Cir.\n1975). FI2 In 1946, the Supreme Court defined prostitution as the \"offering of the body to\nindiscriminate lewdness for hire.\" Cleveland v. United States , 329 U.S. 14, 17 (1946). Black's Law\nDictionary contains several definitions of prostitution:\nProstitution: Act of performing, or offering or agreeing to perform a sexual act for hire.\nEngaging in or agreeing or offering to engage in sexual conduct with another person\nunder a fee arrangement with that person or any other person. Includes any lewd act\nbetween persons for money or other consideration. Within meaning of statute proscribing\nprostitution, comprises conduct of all male and female persons who engage in sexual\nactivity as a business.\nBlack's Law Dictionary (6th Ed. 1990) at 1222. The term \"lewd\" is especially broad, and probably\ncovers all of the acts described below.\nThe district court may decide to limit the term to the definition contained in Florida law. The\nFlorida Statutes define prostitution as \"the giving or receiving of the body for sexual activity for hire . .\n.\" Fl. Stat. § 796.07(1)(a) (2004).\nSexual activity, in turn, means \"oral, anal, or vaginal penetration\nby, or union with, the sexual organ of another, anal or vaginal penetratio\n... [truncated, 4080 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/6 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=6]", "char_count": 4080}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "4. \"Lewd or lascivious exhibition\" occurs when a person intentionally masturbates or exposes his\ngenitals in a lewd or lascivious manner in the presence of a victim who is less than 16 years of age. Fl.\nStat. § 800.04(7)(a) (2004). Eli\nAll of these offenses are classified as second degree felonies when perpetrated by an adult. Fl. Stat. §§\n800.04, 800.04(5)(c)(2), 800.04(6)(b), 800.04(7)(c) (2004).\nSection 800.04 affirmatively bars two defenses to these charges. First, \"[n]either the victim's\nlack of chastity nor the victim's consent is a defense to the crimes proscribed by this section.\" Fl. Stat. §\n800.04(2) (2004).\nSecond, the \"perpetrator's ignorance of the victim's age, the victim's\nmisrepresentation of his or her age, or the perpetrator's bona fide belief of the victim's age cannot be\nraised as a defense in a prosecution under this section.\" Fl. Stat. § 800.04(3) (2004).\nFlorida law also bars \"sexual activity\" between adults over the age of 24 and minors who are 16\nor 17 years' old. Fl. Stat. § 794.05(1) (2004). In those cases, \"sexual activity\" is defined as \"oral, anal,\nor vaginal penetration by, or union with, the sexual organ of another.\" Id. With this offense, ignorance\nof the victim's age, misrepresentation of the victim's age, and a bona fide belief that the victim is over\nthe age of 17 are not defenses. Fl. Stat. § 794.021 (2004).\nd. Charging Decisions\nAll of the girls were enticed into committing prostitution and some were also enticed into\nengaging in criminal sexual activity. I have charged the defendants with enticing each girl into\nprostitution or criminal sexual activity.\ne. Conspiracy to Violate Section 2422(b) [Count\nUnlike most of the other statutes discussed herein, Section 2422(b) does not include its own\nconspiracy prohibition. Accordingly, a conspiracy to violate Section 2422(b) requires the allegation of a\nSection 371 conspiracy. While, generally speaking, it is nice to avoid the trouble of alleging a 371\nconspiracy, in this case it actua\n... [truncated, 4171 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/7 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=7]", "char_count": 4171}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "available through enabling provisions.\n3. Traveling with Intent to Engage in Illicit Sexual Conduct: 18 U.S.C. § 2423(6)\n[Counts 17 to 50]\nA person who travels in interstate commerce . . . for the purpose of engaging in any illicit\nsexual conduct with another person shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more\nthan 30 years, or both.\n18 U.S.C. § 2423(b).\nThus, the United States must prove that Epstein knowingly traveled in interstate commerce and\nthat he did so for the purpose of engaging in illicit sexual conduct, as defined below.\na. Proof of intent to travel\nIn apparent anticipation of this charge, In Appendix A, Epstein's attorneys assert that Epstein's\ntrips to Florida were not undertaken for the sole purpose of engaging in illicit sexual conduct—he\ntraveled just to visit his home and attend meetings, etc.— and, therefore, he lacked the requisite intent to\nviolate Section 2423(b).\nThe Eleventh Circuit has held that, in order to be convicted of violating Section 2423(b), the\nUnited States must prove that the defendant \"had formed the intent to engage in sexual activity with a\nminor 19\nF when he crossed state lines.\" United States v. Hersh , 297 F.3d 1233, 1246 (11th Cir. 2002).\nSee also United States v. Han , 230 F.3d 560 (2d Cir. 2000) (defendant could be convicted of violating\nSection 2423(b) even though no sexual activity occurred and \"minor\" was really an undercover officer\nbecause the defendant had formed the necessary intent by developing a plan to cross state lines to\nengage in sexual acts with the minor); United States v. Root , 296 F.3d 1222, 1231-32 (11th Cir. 2002).\nJust a few weeks ago, the Eleventh Circuit addressed for the first time the issue of a \"combined\nmotive\" for traveling, and approved the following instruction:\nthe Government [] does not have to show that engaging in criminal sexual activity with a\nminor was the Defendant's only purpose, or even his primary purpose, but the\nGovernment must show it was one of the purposes for tran\n... [truncated, 3979 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/8 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=8]", "char_count": 3979}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "purposes for the trips); United States v. Snow , 507 F.2d 22, 24 (7th Cir.1974); United States v. Harris ,\n480 F.2d 601, 602 (6th Cir.1973); United States v. Cole , 262 F.3d 704, 709 (8th Cir. 2001) (\"The illicit\nbehavior must be one of the purposes motivating the interstate transportation, but need not be the\ndominant purpose,\" and a defendant's intent may be inferred from all of the circumstances) (citations\nomitted).\nFor each substantive count of violating § 2423(b), we have evidence that Epstein or one of his\nassistants called a girl a day or two before traveling to Florida, and called again while he was in Florida.\nThe evidence consists of cell phone records from the assistants and the girls, the message pads\nrecovered from the search of Epstein's home and from trash pulls, the flight manifests from Epstein's\nprivate planes, and testimony from the girls about how the appointments were made. So, if\ncalled Jane Doe #8 to make an appointment on January 1st; Epstein traveled to Florida on January 2nd;\nand\ncalled Jane Doe #12 on January 3rd (when they were already in Florida) to make an\nappointment, I have charged a travel count but have listed only Jane Doe #8 as the victim of that\noffense. 2\nF0\nb. Illicit Sexual Conduct\nThe United States must prove that one of the purposes of the defendant's travel was to engage in\n\"illicit sexual conduct.\" \"Illicit sexual conduct\" means:\n(1) a sexual act (as defined in section 2246) with a person under 18 years of age that\nwould be in violation of chapter 109A if the sexual act occurred in the special maritime\nand territorial jurisdiction of the United States; or (2) any commercial sex act (as defined\nin section 1591) with a person under 18 years of age.\n18 U.S.C. § 2423(f).\n(I) A \"sexual act\"\nTitle 18, United States Code, Section 2246(2) defines \"sexual act\" as:\n(A) contact between the penis and the vulva or the penis and the anus, and for purposes of\nthis subparagraph contact involving the penis occurs upon penetration, however\n... [truncated, 3811 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/9 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=9]", "char_count": 3811}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "predominantly women and girls, involving activities related to pmstitution , pornography, sex tourism,\nand other commercial sexual services .\" Id. at § 102(b)(2). The highlighted language shows that\n\"commercial sexual services\" is a broader term than \"prostitution,\" and is meant to include prostitution,\nthe creation of pornography, and other [undefined] acts.\nWhen the Sentencing Commission amended the Sentencing Guidelines to correspond with this\nnew legislation, it replaced the term \"prostitution\" with \"commercial sex acts\" in the heading of part G\nof Section 2 and throughout that section.\nThe Commission gave a stated reason for the amendment:\nThis amendment ensures that appropriately severe sentences for sex trafficking crimes\napply to commercial sex acts such as production of child pornography, in addition to\npmstitution . It proposes several changes to § 2G 1.1 . . . to address more adequately the\nportion of section 112(b) of the Victims of Trafficking and Violence Protection Act of\n2000 . . . The amendment proposes three substantive changes to § 2G1.1. First, this\namendment broadens the conduct covered by the guideline beyond prostitution to\nencompass all commercial sex acts, consistent with the scope of the Act. . . .\nU.S.S.G. App. C, Vol II, Amendment 641 (emphasis added).\nThe reference to child pornography is especially helpful to us, because the child pornography\nstatutes use the term \"sexually explicit conduct,\" which is extremely broad, and includes masturbation\nand the \"lascivious exhibition of the genitals or pubic area of any person.\" 18 U.S.C. § 2256(2)(A).\nOne can certainly argue that a commercial sex act included receiving payment in exchange for\nengaging in \"sexually explicit conduct.\"\nc. Charging Decisions\nCharging decisions, I have charged traveling to engage in \"illicit sexual conduct.\" I have elected\nto treat all of these sexual massages as \"commercial sex acts\" regardless of whether there was any\npenetration. Epstein exchanged money for the op\n... [truncated, 3992 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/10 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=10]", "char_count": 3992}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "affirmative evidence that he reasonably believed that the girls were 18 or older. The defense cannot be\nasserted for the sex acts with girls under the age of 16.\nCongress's decision to include an affirmative defense to part of the statute shows that it has\nconsidered the issue and determined that the Government does not have to prove that the defendant\nknew the victims were underage for the other portions of the statute. This is consistent with the cases\ninterpreting various sections of the Mann Act.\nThus, for that instance where we know that a 17-year-old girl affirmatively told Epstein that she\nwas 18 — and it would have been reasonable for Epstein to believe that statement — I have not charged\nEpstein with violating 2423(b). Jane Doe #5 was 17 when she met Epstein and told him that she was\n18. She says that she believes that Epstein \"knew better,\" but Epstein can probably raise the affirmative\ndefense as to her.\nalso told Epstein that she was 18. She was only 14 at the time and one girl described her as\nby far the youngest-looking girl whom Jane Doe #1 recruited. As with all the girls, Esptein and\nnever asked anyone to present identification or did anything to try to confirm that they were over 18.\nFor all of the other girls, they either told Epstein their ages or didn't say anything and he never asked.\nFor a number of girls, Epstein provided taxicabs or Town Cars because the girls could not drive.\nEpstein talked about high school events (like prom and soccer practice) with the girls; he sent roses to\nHigh School to Jane Doe #8 when she was performing in a play. Jane Doe #8 also\ngave Epstein a copy of her transcript on three separate occasions. He told Jane Doe #5, \"the younger\nthe better.\" The evidence certainly is enough to give rise to a deliberate ignorance instruction and it also\ndefeats the affirmative defense, if raised.\ng. Penalties and forfeiture\nA violation of section 2423, including the conspiracy provision of 2423(e), has no mandatory\nminimum sentence\n... [truncated, 3972 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/11 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=11]", "char_count": 3972}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Since the transported individual is considered a \"victim\" under this statute,\ncannot be\ncharged, so Epstein is named alone. See, e.g., United States v. Love , 592 F.2d 1022, 1025 (8th Cir.\n1979) (citing Gebardi v. United States , 287 U.S. 112, 118-19 (1932)). Just as with Section 2423(b), the\nGovernment must prove that the defendant had the requisite intent prior to the travel, but the\nGovernment does not have to prove that the defendant's sole purpose for traveling and transporting the\nindividual was to have the individual engage in illegal sexual activity. Mortensen v. United States , 322\nU.S. 369, 374 (1944); Crespo v. United States , 151 F.2d 44, 46 (1st Cir. 1945).\nThis offense carries a statutory maximum of ten years in prison. During the relevant time period,\nthe forfeiture provision of 18 U.S.C. § 2253(a)(3) applied, which mandates the forfeiture of assets used\nin the commission of the violation of Section 2421.\nB. Sex Trafficking of Children: 18 U.S.C. § 1591(a)\nFor those cases where there is evidence that the defendants either knew or, but for their willful\nblindness, would have known that the victim was under 18, the defendants can be charged with violating\ntwo subsections of the child sex trafficking statute. Section 1591(a)(1) prohibits recruiting or obtaining\nchildren to engage in a commercial sex act. Section 1591(a)(2) punishes those who benefit financially\nfrom child sex trafficking.\n1. Obtaining Children to Engage in Commercial Sex Acts: 18 U.S.C. § 1591(a)(1)\n(Counts 51 to 58)\nSection 1591(a)(1) makes it illegal for any person to knowingly, in or affecting interstate or\nforeign commerce, recruit, entice, transport, provide, or obtain by any means a person knowing that the\nperson has not attained the age of 18 years and will be caused to engage in a commercial sex act. The\nterm \"commercial sex act\" has the same meaning as discussed above (\"any sex act, on account of which\nanything of value is given to or received by any person \").\nThis charge has f\n... [truncated, 4344 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/12 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=12]", "char_count": 4344}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Id. at 845.\nThus, the evidence of Epstein's violation of this statute includes his travel in interstate commerce\nto commit the offense; directing his assistants to make interstate telephone calls to set up the\nappointments; and wiring money interstate to some of the girls as \"bonuses.\"\nIn United States v. Evans , 476 F.3d 1176 (11th Cir. 2007), and United States v. Sims , 161 Fed.\nAppx. 849 (11th Cir. 2006), the Eleventh Circuit affirmed Section 1591(a)(1) convictions for \"pimps\"\nwho obtained underage girls and forced the girls to engage in prostitution. In Evans , the defendant\nargued that his purely intrastate activity was not \"in or affecting interstate commerce.\" The Eleventh\nCircuit found that Evans' \"conduct substantially affected interstate commerce\" based on his \"use of\nhotels that served interstate travelers and distribution of condoms that traveled in interstate commerce.\"\nEvans , 476 F.3d at 1179.\nEvans shows that\nand\nare equally liable for violating Section\n1591(a)(1), since their actions were in and affecting interstate commerce (using the telephone and\ntraveling with Epstein), and they recruited, enticed, provided, and obtained underage girls to work as\nprostitutes for Epstein.\nI have charged counts relating to Jane Does 3 through 8, 12, and 13. With all of those girls, there\nis affirmative evidence of some knowledge of age when the appointments were made.\n2. Benefitting Financially from Participating in a Venture Engaged in Sex\nTrafficking: 18 U.S.C. § 1591(a)(2) [Count 41\nSection 1591(a)(2) makes it illegal for a person to knowingly benefit \"financially or by receiving\nanything of value, from participation in a venture which has engaged in an act described in violation of\nparagraph (1), knowing that . . . the person has not attained the age of 18 years and will be caused to\nengage in a commercial sex act.\"\nThe term \"commercial sex act\" has the same meaning as discussed above. The statute defines\n\"venture\" as \"any group of two or more individuals asso\n... [truncated, 4075 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/13 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=13]", "char_count": 4075}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "3. Conspiracy\nThe Child Sex Trafficking statutes do not include a separate conspiracy charge, so, if charged, it\nwould have to be an object of a Section 371 conspiracy. In light of Section 1591(a)(2), which is directed\nto \"ventures,\" a separate conspiracy charge might be subjected to a multiplicity challenge. That\nchallenge would probably be fruitless, as evidenced by the fact that Epstein cannot be charged in the\nSection 1591(a)(2) count but certainly could be charged in a conspiracy to violation Section 1591(a)(1),\nbut I have erred on the side of caution and have not included violating Section 1591(a)(1) as a second\nobject of the Section 371 conspiracy.\n4. Penalties and Forfeiture\nThese violations of Section 1591(a) carry a statutory maximum of 40 years' imprisonment,\nsupervised release of up to life, and a $250,000 fine. 18 U.S.C. § 1591(b)(2). As discussed further\nbelow, one of the girls was told that she would only have to \"model lingerie.\" A violation of Section\n1591(a) carries a harsher penalty if the offense was \"effected by fraud.\" There still is no mandatory\nminimum, but the maximum term of imprisonment is life. 18 U.S.C. § 1591(b)(2).\nAs part of the sex trafficking legislation, Congress included a separate forfeiture provision, which\nstates:\nThe court, in imposing sentence on any person convicted of a violation of this chapter,\nshall order, in addition to any other sentence imposed and irrespective of any provision of\nState law, that such person shall forfeit to the United States—(1) such person's interest in\nany property, real or personal, that was used or intended to be used to commit or to\nfacilitate the commission of such violation . . .\n18 U.S.C. § 1594(b). Section 1594 also makes contraband any property used or intended to be used to\ncommit or to facilitate the commission of slavery violations. See 18 U.S.C. § 1594(c)(1)(A). Thus,\nthese violations are another basis for forfeiting the Palm Beach home and the two airplanes.\nD. Charges that Were Consid\n... [truncated, 4012 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/14 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=14]", "char_count": 4012}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "and he then would keep a detailed accounting of how the money was spent and, when the $1500 was\nused up, he would send a copy of the accounting to Epstein's accountant and he maintained a copy for\nhimself. A review of those records showed a number of entries that would simply have a girl's name a 4\nand a round dollar amount — usually $200. Banasiak explained that on several occasions when Epstein\nwas \"in residence,\" Epstein or\nwould ask Banasiak to pay one of the girls after a massage was\nwere not in Florida,\nwould call\ncompleted. On other occasions when Epstein and\nBanasiak to say that a girl was coming to the house and Banasiak should give the girl $200 in an\nenvelope. Banasiak stated that he would follow these instructions and that he knew that the money was\nfor \"massages,\" but he insisted that he did not know that sexual activity was occurring. Why Epstein\nwould pay \"masseuses\" when he was out of town has not been explained.\nEpstein also sent funds via Western Union as \"bonuses\" for some of the girls. These transactions\ncould also be considered to \"facilitate\" the criminal activity by insuring the girls' loyalty and continued\navailability to Epstein for his sexual gratification.\nEpstein's behavior seems to fall squarely within the language of the statute as written, including\nthe Eleventh Circuit's pattern jury instruction. F In conducting research, however, all cases charged\nunder this section involved undercover \"sting\" operations. I contacted the Department's Money\nLaundering Section and learned that subsection 1956(a)(3) was drafted specifically to apply to money\nlaundering \"sting\" operations, and was not intended to reach the activity that Epstein was involved in.\nAccordingly, I chose the more conservative route and decided not to charge Epstein with this offense.\n2. Aiding and Abetting an Unlawful Money Transmitter: 18 U.S.C. § 1960\nSection 1960(a) makes it a crime for someone to knowingly conduct or direct all or part of an\n\"unlicensed money transmitting \n... [truncated, 4314 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/15 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=15]", "char_count": 4314}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "banks to fail to file Currency Transaction Reports (\"CTRs\") by structuring transactions. Fz7 Over a sixhour period, Tobon-Builes and an accomplice went to ten different banks in Northern Florida where they\neach purchased a $9,000 cashier's check with cash. Because each individual purchase was less than\n$10,000, thereby escaping the banks' duty to file a CTR for each transaction. Tobon-Builes was\narrested and admitted that he had won over $100,000 playing poker and was purchasing cashier's check\nin amounts less than $10,000 to avoid bank reporting requirements because he did not want to pay\nfederal taxes on his winnings. Tobon-Builes argued that he could not be charged with concealment of\nmaterial information in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1001 because he did not have a duty to file a CTA —\nonly the financial institution has that legal obligation.\nThe Eleventh Circuit rejected the argument, stating that the government:\ncharged and proved that Tobon willfully and knowingly caused financial institutions not to\nreport currency transactions that they had a duty to report and would have reported if they\nhad known about such transactions. Support for this holding is found in 18 U.S.C. § 2(b)\nwhich provides that one who \"willfully causes an act to be done which if directly\nperformed by him or another would be an offense against the United States, is punishable\nas a principal.\"\nId. at 1099 (quoting 18 U.S.C. § 2(b)). Further, \"it is well established that § 2(b) was designed to\nimpose criminal liability on one who causes an intermediary to commit a criminal act, even though the\nintermediary who performed the act has no criminal intent and hence is innocent of the substantive\ncrime charged, in this case concealment.\" Id. (citations omitted). The operation of Section 2(b)\nforeclosed Tobon-Builes' legal incapacity argument, and the Eleventh Circuit noted a series of cases\nwhere someone without a legal duty used an innocent agent to violate that agent's legal duty. In each of\nthose \n... [truncated, 4126 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/16 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=16]", "char_count": 4126}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Some time in early 2004, the exact date being unknown,\nwas approached by two\nindividuals,\nand Tony, while at a beach club on Singer Island.\nwas a classmate of\nat\nHigh School.\nif she wanted to make some money giving a\nasked\nmassage to a wealthy man on Palm Beach Island.\nwas told that she would be aid $200, she\nwould have to remove some of her clothlind that there mit, some \"fondling.\"\nagreed to\nand Tony, and all three drove to\ngo to the house. Within a few days,\nwas called by\nEpstein's home on Brillo Way in Palm Beach.\nThe three were admitted through the ate and went to the \"back entrance\" of the house, entering\nthrough the kitchen. In the kitchen,\nwas met by\nand some other members of the\nhousehold.\nupstairs to Epstein's dressing area Fzswhere the massage table was already\nled\nset u .\nthen left the room and Epstein entered wearing a towelaitein laid face down and\nwas told to remove her clothes (she remained in her panties).\nthen began to massage\nEpstein as he directed her. After massaging his back area for some time, Epstein turned over so that he\nwas laying face up. Epstein began masturbating and tried numerous times to touch =,\ngrabbing her\nrear end and trying to touch other places in a sexual manner.\npulled away several times, telling\nEpstein that she did not want him to touch her. Epstein continued to masturbate, and instructed\nto\npinch his nipples, which she did. Epstein climaxed and the massage ended. Epstein stood up and wiped\nhimself off. ign went into the master bathroom while\ngot dressed. After both were dressed,\nEpstein\n$200 in cash (2 $100 bills). Because\nwould not let Epstein touch her, Epstein\ntold\nthat she shouldn't give him any more massages, but she could bring girls to the house and\nshe would get paid $200 for every girl that she brought.\nWhen\nwent downstairs,\nfor her telephone number so that\nasked\ncould\ncontact\ndirectly.\ngave her telephone number to M, and all future communications were\ndirectly with\nsays that she received the first call from\nsoon \n... [truncated, 4038 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/17 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=17]", "char_count": 4038}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "also reports that\nhad told\nto tell Epstein that she was 18 if he asked and that\ntold that to the ils whom she recruited.\nsaid that she told Epstein that she was 18 but that\n\"he knew better.\"\nalso said that she was never instructed by Epstein or\nto make sure that\nthe girls that she brought were over 18 and was never asked to rovide identification/proof of her age\nfor herself or for any of the girls whom she brought. One of\nas \"the\nfriends described\nyoungest-looking._igkl\" that\nhad brought to Epstein's house. Yet\nmade another\nappointment for\nto come to Epstein's house without either\nor Epstein asking about\nage.\nwas 14 years' old.\nOn March 11, 2004,\ncalled Tony at 9:13 M. Epstein arrived the same day, at 11:20\ncalled Tony at 8:59 a.m. and 9:21 a.m. At 3:38 that afternoon,\nOn March 12, 2004,\nreceived her first call from\nprovided one sexual masse e where Epstein masturbated while trying to fondle =.\nwas 17 years' old at the time.\ntold Epstein that she was 18 years' old, but believes that\nEpstein \"knew better,\" based on her appearance and their discussion during the massage.\nPossible Credibility Challenges\nhas been granted 6001 imma l by the Department and has appeared before the Grand\nJury. After her experiences with Epstein,\nbecame a stripper and worked in various clubs in West\nPalm Beach and Orlando.\nis currently working as a waitress at a regular restaurant in the Fort\nLauderdale area. She currently is living with her parents but is scheduled to move out soon.\nprimary credibility challenge is that she brought several girls to Epstein's home — knowing that they\nsuffers from depression and\nwere underage — and she has been given immunity for her testimony.\ntakes medication for that condition.\nThe grand jurors listened attentively to\nand seemed to believe her. After her testimony\nthey were anxious to indict Epstein, asking when an indictment would be forthcoming.\nis very\nstraightforward abot.itein's actions, and her own.\nB.\nAs mentioned above,\nparents originally brought E\n... [truncated, 3762 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/18 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=18]", "char_count": 3762}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "states that the assistant told her to take her top off. Epstein entered shortly\nout massage lotions.\nthereafter and forcefully ordered\nto take her pants off\nremoved her pants while Epstein left\nthe room. When Epstein returned, he was wearing only a towel. Epstein laid face down and told\nto straddle him to massife his back.\nbare buttocks touched Epstein's\nlower back/top of his\nl\nsaid that she was 18 and\nbuttocks. Epstein asked\nage and where she went to school and\nwas a senior at Wellington. Epstein got up from the massage table and went to the toilet area where he\nmasturbated and made moannoises. Epstein then returned and laid down facm up. He continued to\nmasturbate while directing\nto massage his chest. Epstein then told\nto grab a large back\nmassager/vibrator that was across the room. At Epstein's request,\nremoved her underwear.\nakin used the massager on\nvagina while he masturbated. Epstein then digitally penetrated\nlooked at Epstein to express her displeasure with the penetration and Epstein looked at her\nand sarcastically said, \"What's the matter?\"\nlooked away. When Epstein ejaculated, the contact\n$300, ex laining that the extra $100 was because he \"fingered her\" and\nstopped. Epstein gave\nto leave her telephone\nused a vibrator on her. Esptein left\nto get dressed. Epstein also asked\nand\nreceived $200 for\nnumber.\ngot dressed, went downstairs, and left with\nbringing\nIn the car on the way home,\nthat Epstein \"fingered\" her and paid her $300.\ntold\nconfirms this, which should be admissible as a prior consistent statement.)\njoked that they\ncould et\nif the went to Epstein's house every weekend. The girls went shopping and\nthen\nanything\ntook\nhome.\nwith the $300 she had received from Epstein.\ndid not purchase\nWhen\nreturned to school on Monday, she told a friend what had happened. As discussed in\nthe introduction, rumors started flying around the school and\nand another girl got into an\nargument. One of the school administrators searched\npurse and found the $300. When\nconfront\n... [truncated, 4078 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/19 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=19]", "char_count": 4078}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "feel more secure about the interviewer. In addition, there is the prior consistent statement that\nmade to\nwhile they were in the car drinaway from Epstein's home.\nWith respect to the MySpace page,\nsays that it is inaccurate. When she was confronted\nwith the page before the state grand jury, she denied putting certain items on the page. When we met\nwith her, she again said that she did not remember putting certain things on the me and she believed\nthat it wasn't her page. After that meeting, we tried to verify\nstatement, M., whether someone\nreally had doctored her page. We were able to determine that the page was created on a single da and\nhad never been accessed since the date of its creation. Some of the information was identical to\n\"active\" MySpace page, and other parts were different. Unfortunately, because of the passage of time,\nthe ISP no longer had information about the specific IP address used to create the page, so we could not\ntrace the creation back to a particular persons address.\nEven if\nreally did create the MySpace page and simply forgot about it, in my opinion, most\nof the information that they are focused on doesn't really undermine\ncredibility in this case.\nMySpace pages are notorious for \"puffing,\" so claims that she was 18 and made $250,000 a year are\nnot statements that a reasonable person would rel on to avoid engaging in criminal conduct. Certainly\nEpstein never visited the site before molesting so he did not rely upon the claim that\nwas 18\nwhen he decided to digitally penetrate her.\nadmittedly drank and was sext• active with her\nboyfriend. If\nwere not a person who engaged in these types of activities,\nwouldn't have\napproached\nto recruit her to give a sexual massage to Epstein. The photograph of the nude girl on\nthe beach is obviously a picture that was digitally created (there is a cruise ship headed directly towards\nthe girl on the beach) and also is obviously not\nC. Jane Doe #15 (\n)-(\nJane Doe #15 also attended\nHigh School with\nand\nrecruite\n... [truncated, 4405 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/20 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=20]", "char_count": 4405}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "-\n\n1\n\nD\n\nback. Epstein then reached through her legs to masturbate himself. Epstein tried to rub his penis\nagainst JD#15's vagina but never penetrated her.\nJD#15 stated that she was usually contacted by M,\nvia her cellular phone, to set up\nappointments.\nwould sometimes call from New York or the U.S. Virgin Islands stating, \"we will\nwould call when the already were in town\nbe coming into town, can you work?\" Sometimes\nasking if JD#15 was able to work the same day or the following day.\nsometimes made\nappointments before Epstein left town for the next time that they would be in town. On several\noccasions,\nmade the appointments with JD#15.\nEpstein gave JD#15 three Victoria's Secret bra and panty sets and gave her a \"Pocket Rocket\"\nvibrator for her 18th birthday.\nJane Doe #15 never told Esptein her age, but she also never told him that she was 18. They\ndiscussed her high school soccer games and her plans to attend college in the future. In addition, as\nI was a close friend of JD#15 and they often went to Epstein's house together.\ndiscussed below,\ntold Epstein that she and JD#15 went to the same school and were in the same class, and\ntold Epstein that she was a junior in high school. There also is evidence that Epstein gave JD#15 a\nvibrator for her 18th birthday, knowing that it was her 18th birthday and offered to fly JD#15 to his\nhome in the Virgin Islands after she was 18.\nWith respect to the enticement charge and the human trafficking charge, I included\nand\nbecause of the number of calls that they were involved with. There were a total of 156 calls\nbetween\nand JD#15, and there were 28 calls between\nand JD#15. Although\nwas aboard the plane during several trips, there is no evidence that she ever had contact with JD#15 or\narranged for JD#15 to engage in sexual activity with Epstein; thus, I have not charged her in connection\nwith any of this activity. Rather than try to parse out each instance where JD#15 was enticed, I elected\nto charge the enticement and sex trafficki\n... [truncated, 3914 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/21 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=21]", "char_count": 3914}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Jane Doe #14 also attended\nHigh School. She was recruited to give sexual\nmassa es to Epstein in the fall of 2004, when she was 17 years' old. She was recruited indirectly by\nJane Doe #14 reported that she entered the home through the kitchen and was introduced to\nbrought JD#14 upstairs to the dressing area, where she met Epstein. JD#14 performed\nmultiple sexual massages for Epstein. During the first massage, Epstein asked JD#14 how old she was\nand she said that she was 18. During that massage, she removed her clothes, and he masturbated.\nJD#14 also describes how Epstein would verbally push her to engage in more and more sexual activity.\nJD#14 states that Epstein began fondling her vagina and digitally penetrating her, and the activity\nescalated to full sexual intercourse in his bedroom. Epstein asked JD#14 to straddle him and pinch his\nnipples while he reached through her legs to masturbate himself. He used the vibrator/massager on her\nvagina. When JD#14 told Epstein that she didn't like it, he responded that she was \"scared to have\npleasure.\" Epstein digitally penetrated her and performed oral sex on her.\nJD#14 was paid $300 during her visits to Epstein's home. On one occasion she received $500\nand on another occasion she received $600. Epstein always paid her except for one occasion when he\ndidn't have any cash. Epstein then asked one of his employees to pay her. (This is consistent with the\nrecord of a payment by the house manager to JD#14.)\nJD#14 received a $200 \"Christmas present\" via Western Union on December 23, 2004. Epstein\noffered her David Copperfield tickets and she spoke with Copperfield on the telephone. M Around the\nthird or fourth visit, Epstein began asking JD#14 about plans for her 18th birthday, and he said to her,\n\"So you're really not eighteen.\" JD#14 states that they laughed a little and continued with the session.\nJD#14 received 31 calls from\nand 15 calls from\n. JD#14 states that she received\nthe payments from Epstein. JD#14 says that Epstein \n... [truncated, 4180 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/22 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=22]", "char_count": 4180}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "into the activity. He instructed JD#9 to perform oral\nJD#9 described how Epstein brought\n. When JD#9 refused, Epstein promised an additional $200 if JD#9 would perform\nsex on\noral sex for five minutes. JD#9 agreed, and E stein masturbated while watching them. JD#9 said that\nuse of a strap-on dildo. JD#9 also said that\nvarious sex toys were used on her, including\nEpstein forced her to have vaginal sex on one occasion when he became very excited. JD#9 screamed\nfor him to stop. Epstein did so and apologized.\nJD#9 said that she received varying amounts of money for the sexual massages, depending on\nhow much sexual activity took place, ranging from $300 to $1000 on the day that Epstein forced\nintercourse on her.\nEpstein asked JD#9 how old she was. JD#9 said that she was 18 and Epstein told her that he\nknew she was not 18. Epstein knew that she attended\nHigh School. He sent roses to\na high school play performance that JD#9 gave. They discussed JD#9's plans to attend college. JD#9\ngave Epstein a copy of her transcript on three occasions. JD#9 believed that Epstein would help her get\ninto NYU and that he would pay for her tuition there. Epstein also paid for a trip to New York for JD#9\nfor her 18th birthday. JD#9 went to Epstein's house to pick up an envelope of money to pay for the trip.\nEpstein also gave her tickets to the Phantom of the Opera in New York. Epstein did not accompany\nJD#9 on this trip.\nEpstein provided JD#9 with other gifts including a Louis Vuitton purse, a bathing suit, Victoria's\nSecret bra and panty sets, and cash gifts. JD#9 said that most of the time\nwould call to set up the\nappointments for her to \"work.\"\nwould call from one day to several days in advance.\nSometimes the appointments were made before Epstein arrived. Other times,\nwould call when\nthey were already in Palm Beach. JD#9 was shown a photo array containing\nphotograph.\nShe positively identified\nCredibility Issues\nAttached at Tab 5 is Jane Doe #9's MySpace page. Attached at Tab 6 is the repor\n... [truncated, 4200 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/23 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=23]", "char_count": 4200}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "undress but she only removed her top. She was paid $200 and Epstein asked her for her phone number,\nwhich she provided. Epstein asked her about her plans to attend college in the future. On the third visit,\nEpstein again asked Jane Doe #10 to get undressed and she did. Jane Doe #10 says that from this point,\neach visit became more sexual and Epstein would try to go farther each time. Epstein placed his hand\non Jane Doe #10's vagina and breasts while he masturbated; he also used the vibrator/massager on her\nva ina. E stein asked Jane Doe #10 to touch his nis - she said \"no.\" On at least two occasions,\nwas part of the activity. Epstein and\nperformed sexual acts on each other,\nincluding oral sex.\nplaced her hand on Jane Doe #10's vagina and used the\nvibrator/massager on Jane Doe #10's vagina.\nusually would call to set up the appointments prior to their trip to Florida. On two\noccasions, Epstein wired money to Jane Doe #10 when she was on vacation and had no funds to get\nhome. Both of these wire transfers occurred after her 18th birthday.\nH. JANE DOE #a\ni r)\nJane Doe #16 attended\nHigh School and was recruited by Jane Doe #9. She\nestimated that she started going to Epstein's house in November 2004, but phone calls with\ndo\nnot begin until February 2005. Jane Doe #9 approached her and asked if she wanted to make money\nmassaging Epstein. Jane Doe #16 had heard of other girls at school making money that wa and she\nand\nagreed to go to Epstein's house. Jane Doe #9 took her to the house and introduced her to\nEpstein in the kitchen. Jane Doe #9 led her upstairs to the dressing area where the massage table was\nalready set up. Jane Doe #9 left and Epstein entered wearing a towel. Epstein told her to undress and\nJane Doe #16 performed the massage wearing only panties. Epstein masturbated until he ejaculated,\nwhich ended the massage. Jane Doe #16 received $200, so did Jane Doe #9.\nJane Doe #16 estimates that she went to Epstein's home 10-15 times. Each time Epstein pushed\nfor more s\n... [truncated, 4053 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/24 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=24]", "char_count": 4053}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Jane Doe #16 approached Jane Doe #17 telling her that she could make $200 massaging Epstein.\nJane Doe #16 told Jane Doe #17 that she would have to perform the massage topless. Jane Doe #16\narranged that first appointment with\n. Jane Doe #16 and Jane Doe #17 went to Epstein's house\ntogether and entered through the kitchen. Jane Doe #16 led Jane Doe #17 upstairs to the dressing area.\nEpstein entered wearing only a towel. The two girls undresses down to their panties. Epstein selected\nthe massage oils and lay face down on the massage table. Both girls began massaging Epstein's back,\nlegs, and feet. After some time, Epstein turned over and instructed Jane Doe #16 to leave the room.\nEpstein then began to masturbate as he instructed Jane Doe #17 to massage his chest. After Epstein\nejaculated, he used the towel he had been wearing to wipe himself off, and told Jane Doe to get dressed\nand meet him downstairs. Jane Doe #17 did so and met Epstein in the kitchen, where he paid here $200.\nJane Doe #16 received the same amount.\nThe second appointment also was made via Jane Doe #16 approximately one month later. They\nreturned to the house the same way and Jane Doe #16 again led her upstairs, but left Jane Doe #17 to do\nthe massage alone. Epstein entered wearing only a towel. Jane Doe #17 stripped down to her panties,\nbut Epstein told her that she had to get completely naked, which she did. Jane Doe #17 massaged\nEpstein's back and legs for a while and the he turned over and began masturbating as she rubbed his\nchest. This time Epstein to the massager/vibrator and began using it on Jane Doe # 17's vagina. Epstein\ndid that for a while and then stopped so he could focus on himself. After he ejaculated, he wiped\nhimself off and told Jane Doe #17 that the massage was over. Jane Doe # 17 got dressed and went\ndownstairs to the kitchen, where she met Epstein and Jane Doe #16. Epstein paid her $200.\nJane Doe #17 reports that Epstein asked about school. She told him that she attended\nHigh S\n... [truncated, 4114 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/25 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=25]", "char_count": 4114}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "digitally penetrated her. After he ejaculated, Epstein wiped himself off with his towel and told\nthat there was $200 on the dresser for her and $100 for\nfor bringing her. Epstein asked\nto leave her phone number because he wanted to see her again.\nadvised that she never went back and she stopped talkin to\nbecause she was\nphone records show three calls to\non 12/18/04, which is\nupset over what happened.\nconsistent with her recollection of the time frame.\nL. JANE DOE #7\nJane Doe # 7 attended\nHigh School. She was recruited by\nto go to\nEpstein's house when she was 16 years' old.\nalso went to Epstein's house and performed sexual\nservices starting when she was 15.\nrefused to speak to police and the FBI, telling them that she\nwas still in love with Epstein.\nwas compelled via 6001 immunity to provide information. She\nadmitted that she brought around 30 girls to Epstein's house, including Jane Doe #7.\nsays that\nshe considers Epstein to be \"the awesomest guy in the world,\" and she would marry him if he asked her.\nWhen asked if she ever brought a girl that Epstein did not like, she said:\nYeah, once. I made a mistake.\nI brought a black girl. Not that\nJeffrey is a racist. He still paid\nher, but he wouldn't let her\nmassage him.\nis too volatile and hostile to be called as a witness for the United States, but her statement is so\ndamagilhat Epstein can't use her either.\napproached Jane Doe #7 in Ma.une 2004 and was told that she could model lingerie\nfor a wealthy Palm Beach man for money.\nand Jane Doe #7 traveled by Yellow Cab from Jane\nDoe #7's house in West Palm Beach to Epstein's house. They met Epstein outside the house and he took\nthem in to the kitchen where the chef made them something to eat. Epstein and\nled Jane Doe #7\nupstairs to the dressing area. Eistp\nwent into the bathroom and came out wearing only a towel.\nEpstein laid on his stomach and\nand Jane Doe #7 began massaging his legs and feet. Jane Doe\n#7 asked\nwhy they were doing this and\nreplied that it was part of the rout\n... [truncated, 3804 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/26 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=26]", "char_count": 3804}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "rest of her clothes; Jane Doe #13 complied. Epstein told Jane Doe #13 to talk dirty to him, and Epstein\nmasturbated.\nJane Doe #13 estimates that she went to Epstein's home about 10 times. After the first massage\nwas completed, Epstein asked for her telephone number. Jane Doe #13 wrote the information, down on\na notepad bearing Epstein's name. Jane Doe #13 was paid $200 for each massage. She also brought 2\nother girls was paid $200 for each girl she brought. Epstein always made the payments. Epstein asked\nJane Doe #13 to have sexual intercourse and promised to pay more money if she did. Jane Doe #13\ndeclined.\nIn addition to masturbating himself, Epstein used the back massager/vibrator on Jane Doe #13's\nvagina. Epstein fondled Jane Doe #13's breasts and buttocks, and digitally penetrated her vagina.\nEpstein asked Jane Doe #13 how old she was and she said she would be turning 18 in the spring.\nShe told Epstein several times that she was 17, she gave Epstein a school photo and wrote on the back\nthat she couldn't wait to turn 18. Jane Doe #13 and Epstein discussed Jane Doe #13's age. Epstein said\nhe couldn't wait until she turned 18 so they could travel to Paris together and so she could be his\npersonal masseuse.\nand\nto set up appointments, usually at least one a\nJane Doe #13 received calls from\nday in advance, sometimes the appointments were made before E stein arrived in Palm Beach. There\nare records of approximately 40 calls between Jane Doe #13 and\nand 6 calls between Jane Doe\n#13 and\nnumber programmed into her cell phone. Jane Doe #13\n. Jane Doe #13 still had\ncame forward after press coverage revealed that Epstein passed a lie detector test saying that he didn't\nknow any girls were under 18. Jane Doe #13 repeated that Epstein knew she was under 18 and also\nthought that Epstein knew that the recruiter also was 17.\nCredibility Issue\nWhile she was a juvenile, Jane Doe #13 was arrested for marijuana possession and shoplifting.\nIV. 404(b) EVIDENCE\nThe FBI's investigation\n... [truncated, 3962 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/27 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=27]", "char_count": 3962}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "When you review the cover letter from Gerald Lefcourt (Appendix A), you will see that most of\nthe letter is an attack on the police report and probable cause affidavit drafted by Det.\nfrom\nPBPD. Neither document is ideal and his interviews of the girls and other investigative steps had some\nproblems (although did an incredibly in-depth investigation for such a small police department). The\ndefense also has complained repeatedly about the decision of the Palm Beach Police Chief to release\ninformation to the press and to complain loudly about State Attorney Barry Krisher's handling of the\ncase. Giving the information to the press definitely did not help our investigation because it caused\nsome of the girls to clam up, fearing more embarrassment. (It did, however, lead other girls to come\nforward and tell their stories.)\nVery early in the investigation, the FBI and I decided to put\npolice report and PC\nAffidavit to the side and to look at the case with fresh eyes. The facts discussed herein are based upon a\npersonal review of the audiotapes and videotapes of the girls' interviews, the tape of the state grand jury\nproceedings, follow-up interviews conducted by the FBI, and physical evidence seized during the search\nof Epstein's home, obtained via trashpulls, and obtained via grand jury subpoenas.\nCONCLUSION\nBased on the fore oin , I recommend that the Office approve the attached indictment charging\nEpstein,\n, JEGE, and Hyperion. I also recommend that the Office refuse a\npre-indictment interview to Epstein or his counsel and that no information about the status of the case be\nshared to keep Epstein from fleeing from the jurisdiction.\n\n(\n\nThe second revision amends the Jane Doe numbering system to correspond with the most recent\nindictment. It also removes the references to the overt acts and substantive allegations related to each Jane Doe\nbecause the indictment has been revised to group the overt acts related to each Jane Doe.\nBEach of the airplanes is held in a separat\n... [truncated, 4355 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/28 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=28]", "char_count": 4355}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "F2Attached as Appendix A are materials received from counsel for Epstein, including their legal analysis.\nThe points they raise are addressed in this memo.\nF IISection 2421 was originally referred to as the Mann Act. Sections 2422 and 2423 are more recent\nadditions, which focus on children. All three sections are sometimes jointly referred to as the Mann Act.\n!F Note that there is an Eleventh Circuit Pattern Jury Instruction for attempted enticement of a minor. In\nthat instruction, the Eleventh Circuit included a willfulness requirement — including a requirement that the\ndefendant believe that the individual was under eighteen. Those additional requirements apply to a charge of\nattempted enticement because attempt is a specific intent offense that requires the United States to prove that the\ndefendant \"knowingly and willfully intended to commit the offense\" — i.e. , that he intended to commit the crime.\n11th Cir. Pattern Jury Instr., Special Instr. 11 (\"Attempt(s)\") (2003). Where, as here, the offense is completed,\nthe statutory language requires only that the defendant knowingly persuade, induce, or entice someone to engage\nin prostitution or criminal sexual activity.\nBonner v. City of Prichard , 661 F. 2d 1206 (11th Cir. 1981), the Eleventh Circuit adopted as\nbinding precedent all Fifth Circuit decisions rendered prior to October 1, 1981.\nFI3I have used the Florida Statutes in effect at the time that the offenses occurred. They have not\nchanged since then although, as shown below, amendments are currently pending.\nF IThere currently is legislation pending before the Florida Legislature increasing the penalties related to\nchild prostitution. The section defining \"prostitution\" has been renumbered but the language remains the same.\nThat chapter also has an offense of obtaining a person for \"lewdness,\" (Proposed Fl. Stat. 796.07), which is\ndefined as \"any indecent or obscene act.\" (Proposed Fl. Stat. 796.011(4))\nwe restricted charges to instances where Epstein stroke\n... [truncated, 4386 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/29 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=29]", "char_count": 4386}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02857732", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Eleventh Cir. Pattern Jury Instr., Offense Instr. 70.4 (2003).\nF Tobon-Bitiles was decided prior to the enactment of 31 U.S.C. § 5324(a), which created a criminal\noffense for causing a domestic financial institution to fail to file a required report, such as a CTR.\nFrom the descriptions provided by the girls and by the police officers who conducted the search of the\nhome, attached to Epstein's master bedroom was a large room that contained a steam shower, dressing area, and\nclosets. This space was adjacent to the regular master bathroom. Because some activity occurred in the\nbedroom itself, I will use the term \"dressing area\" to refer to the space where the sexual massages occurred.\na=received $200 each time she brought a girl to Epstein's house, even if it was the second or third\ntime she brought that girl.\nMore telephone calls occurred, but calls placed to\nJD#1's home telephone from Epstein's\nhome telephone (or vice-versa) were not captured in the cellular phone records in our possession. The same is\ntrue for all of the victims.\nF3 I Dwing her interview with the police,\ncaught herself and said \"He likes girls who are 18 to\n20,\" but in talking with the federal agents, she admitted that the only girls she brought (other than the 23-yearold) were girls under 18, Epstein really liked the youngest girl MI who was 14), and he preferred young girls,\nnot 18- to 20-year-olds.\nAlso attached at Tab 10 are two police reports showing that\nwas under the influence of Xanax in\nMarch 2006 and that her\ncalled the police fearing that she had run away in January 2006. Both of these\nevents occurred well after the events occurred with Epstein and after the matter was reported to PBPD and ■\nwas interviewed.\nparents report that once the rumor at school started that MN was a prostitute,\nstarted having behavioral problems and had to change schools twice. She has successfully completed a drug\ntreatment programs since the reported events at Tab 10.\nAttached at Tab 11 is a booking photo of\nfa\n... [truncated, 2954 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02857732/30 or ?id=EFTA02857732&page=30]", "char_count": 2954}]}