{"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_count": 67, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02846321", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02846321.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 1 of 67\n\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK\nIn re:\nDocket #1:19-cv-07625: AJN-DCF\n\nVE,\nPlaintiff,\n- against NINE EAST 71ST STREET, et al.,\n\nNew York, New York\nFebruary 11, 2020\n\nDefendants.\nSCHEDULING CONFERENCE\n\nPROCEEDINGS BEFORE\nTHE HONORABLE JUDGE DEBRA C. FREEMAN,\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT MAGISTRATE JUDGE\nAPPEARANCES:\nFor Plaintiff VE:\n\nPOTTINGER LLC\nBY:\nJAMES\nESQ.\n425 N. Andrews Avenue - Suite 2\nFort Lauderdale, Florida 33301\n954-524-2820\n\nFor Other plaintiff:\n\nKAPLAN HECKER & FINK LLP\nBY: ROBERTA A. KAPLAN, ESQ.\n350 Fifth Avenue - Suite 7110\nNew York, New York 10118\n\nFor Other plaintiff:\n\nBOIS SCHILLER FLEXNER LLP\nBY: SIGRID S. MCCAWLEY, ESQ.\n401 East Las Olas Blvd. - Suite 1200\nFort Lauderdale, Florida 33301\n954-356-0011\n\nTranscription Service:\n\nCarole Ludwig, Transcription Services\n155 East Fourth Street, #3C\nNew York, New York 10009\nPhone: (212) 420-0771\n\nProceedings recorded by electronic sound recording;\nTranscript produced by transcription service\nAPPEARANCES - CONTINUED:\n\nEFTA02846321\n\n\n\n[═══ TRANSCRIPT ═══]\nCase 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF  Document 56  Filed 02/13/20  Page 3 of 67  INDEX  EXAMINATIONS  Witness  Direct  Cross  ReDirect  ReCross  None EXHIBITS Exhibit Number  Description  ID  In  Voir Dire  None  EFTA02846323", "char_count": 1343}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 2 of 67\n\nFor Other plaintiff:\n\nBOIS SCHILLER FLEXNER, LLP\nBY: JOSHUA I. SCHILLER, ESQ.\n55 Hudson Yards - 20th Floor\nNew York, New York 10001\n212-303-3520\n\nFor Other plaintiff:\n\nCUTI HECKER WANG LLP\nBY: MARIANN MEIER WANG, ESQ.\n305 Broadway\nNew York, New York 10007\n\nFor Other plaintiff:\n\nDavid\n\nFor the Defendants:\n\nTROUTMAN SANDERS LLP\nBY: BENNET JEROME MOSKOWITZ, ESQ.\n875 Third Avenue\nNew York, New York 10022\n212-704-6087\n\nEFTA02846322\n\n", "char_count": 503}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 3 of 67\n\nINDEX\n\nEXAMINATIONS\n\nWitness\n\nDirect\n\nCross\n\nReDirect\n\nReCross\n\nNone\nEXHIBITS\nExhibit\nNumber\n\nDescription\n\nID\n\nIn\n\nVoir\nDire\n\nNone\n\nEFTA02846323\n\n", "char_count": 217}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n\nPage 4 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n3\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nTHE CLERK:\n\n4\n\nVE v. Nine East 71st Street, et al,\n\nand other cases associated with this one.\n\n4\n\nCounsel, please state your name for the record.\n\n5\n\nMR. BENNET MOSKOWITZ:\n\n6\n\nHONORABLE DEBRA C. FREEMAN (THE COURT):\n\n7\n\nJust one at a time.\n\n8\n\nside, just one at a time?\n\n9\n10\n\nI -Sure.\n\nWhy don't we start on plaintiff's\n\nMR. JOSHUA SCHILLER:\n\nJosh Schiller from Bois\n\nSchiller.\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n12\n\nMS. SIGRID McCAWLEY:\n\n13\n\nBennet Moskowitz.\n\nOkay.\nSigrid McCawley from Bois\n\nSchiller.\n\n14\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n15\n\nMR. BRAD\n\nOkay.\n:\n\nBrad\n\nfrom\n\n16\n17\n\nII. MARIANN WANG:\n\n18\n\nMS. ROBERTA KAPLAN:\n\n19\n\nMariann Wang, Cuti Hecker Wang.\nRoberta Kaplan from Kaplan\n\nHecker.\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n21\n\nMR. DAVID (indiscernible):\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n23\n\nTurning to defendant's side.\n\n24\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n25\n\nAnyone else on plaintiffs' side?\nDavid (indiscernible).\n\nIs that it on plaintiffs' side?\n\nBennet Moskowitz, Troutman\n\nSanders, counsel for defendants, the co-executors, Darren\n\nEFTA02846324\n\n", "char_count": 1069}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n2\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 5 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n5\n\nIndyke and Richard Kahn.\n\n3\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n4\n\nOf the many cases that have been referred to me\n\nOkay.\n\nAll right, so good morning.\n\n5\n\nfor supervision, two have been stayed at the request of the\n\n6\n\nparties.\n\n7\n\nthey're not stayed.\n\n8\n\nplace.\n\n9\n\nrespect to potential for settlement.\n\n10\n\nvarious and assorted rumors about the difficulties of\n\n11\n\ntrying to progress with settlement.\n\n12\n\nI'll turn to on defendants' side first -- tell me what the\n\n13\n\nlatest is?\n\n14\n15\n\nAll of you who are here today on these cases,\nWe need to put discovery schedules in\n\nI would like to get the latest, though, with\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nYes.\n\nI've been hearing\n\nCan you give me a\n\nAnd do I recall correctly\n\nyou prefer that we stand?\n\n16\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSure.\n\nJust if you're talking for\n\n17\n\nsome long period of time and you need to be looking at\n\n18\n\nnotes --\n\n19\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n21\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nI prefer it.\n\n-- I'll let you sit.\nThank you.\n\nAnd I appreciate the\n\n22\n\nopportunity to explain what's going on in terms of\n\n23\n\npotential resolutions of these actions and specifically\n\n24\n\nwith respect to the Epstein victims compensation program,\n\n25\n\nwhich as the Court knows, is a completely voluntary\n\nEFTA02846325\n\n", "char_count": 1307}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n1\n2\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 6 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n6\n\nprogram.\n\n3\n\nWell, a lot has certainly happened since the last\n\n4\n\ntime we were before your Honor back on November 21, 2019.\n\n5\n\nWhat I'm pleased to report, before I get to some of the\n\n6\n\nmore difficult issues, is that the vast majority of\n\n7\n\nplaintiffs here today, and, in fact, the vast majority of\n\n8\n\nalleged victims of Mr. Epstein have, through their counsel,\n\n9\n\nvoiced unequivocal support for and intend to participate in\n\n10\n\nthe voluntary program, which is great.\n\n11\n\njust mentioned, though it's not even required and it was\n\n12\n\nnot something I asked, five plaintiffs, soon to be six,\n\n13\n\nbecause of a proposed amendment, in one case plaintiffs\n\n14\n\nhave already voluntarily stayed their litigation in favor\n\n15\n\nof their participation in the program.\n\n16\n\nsomething that's required but they saw the wisdom of doing\n\n17\n\nthat and conserving resources, which is something we\n\n18\n\nwelcome.\n\n19\n\nAnd as your Honor\n\nAgain, that's not\n\nThe plaintiffs' support for the program followed\n\n20\n\nthe numerous discussions we had since we appeared before\n\n21\n\nyour Honor and you suggested everyone should be speaking\n\n22\n\nand speaking often.\n\n23\n\nmyself and many attorneys in this room, as well as separate\n\n24\n\nmeetings between the claims program designers and\n\n25\n\nadministrators.\n\nThere were many discussions among\n\nAgain, that's Ken Feinberg is the\n\nEFTA02846326\n\n", "char_count": 1460}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 7 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n7\n\n2\n\ndesigner; Jordana\n\n3\n\nadministrator; and Camille Biros, who's also a designer.\n\n4\n\nThey met with, I understand, several times the various\n\n5\n\nplaintiffs' counsel here today and other ones not here\n\n6\n\ntoday.\n\n7\n\nthe past several months, we have a great showing of\n\n8\n\nparticipation or intended participation in a program which\n\n9\n\nhas great promise of resolving many of these claims.\n\n10\n\nfact, the protocol, which if your Honor may recall, that's\n\n11\n\nthe nuts and bolts of the program.\n\n12\n\nweighed in on that protocol.\n\n13\n\nsome of their input.\n\n14\n\nis the designer and the sole\n\nAnd through all of these, you know, efforts over\n\nIn\n\nPlaintiffs' counsel has\n\nThe current draft reflects\n\nAnd that's all great.\n\nBut here's the tricky part, if you will.\n\nThere is\n\n15\n\none reason, and only one reason, that the claims program\n\n16\n\nhasn't commenced, and that is because the attorney general\n\n17\n\nfor the Virgin Islands, the U.S. Virgin Islands, who we\n\n18\n\nfirmly understand represents no victims -- zero -- has, for\n\n19\n\nwhatever reason that we don't understand, impeded the\n\n20\n\nformal establishment of the program, against our wishes,\n\n21\n\nand more strikingly, against the wishes of the plaintiffs'\n\n22\n\ncounsel in this room and other plaintiffs' counsel not here\n\n23\n\ntoday.\n\n24\n25\n\nAnd if I can just -- and I'll try to do this\nsuccinctly as a matter of context of how we got to this\n\nEFTA02846327\n\n", "char_count": 1495}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 8 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n8\n\n2\n\nplace where the attorney general has done this -- on\n\n3\n\nNovember 14, 2019, the co-executors filed a motion in the\n\n4\n\nprobate court for the formal approval of the establishment\n\n5\n\nof the claims program.\n\n6\n\nthe probate court.\n\n7\n\nand authority over all assets of the estate, and hence, we\n\n8\n\nneeded to seek formal approval.\n\n9\n\nwith your Honor about a week later.\n\n10\n\nthat followed from that which I just went over, all the\n\n11\n\nefforts that yielded the almost uniform support for the\n\n12\n\nprogram among plaintiffs and alleged victims that I just\n\n13\n\ndescribed.\n\nOf course, everything runs through\n\nThe probate court has ultimate control\n\nWe then had the conference\nAll of the good things\n\n14\n\nVery regrettably, however, in the meantime and\n\n15\n\nmuch more recently, long after everyone in this room was\n\n16\n\nworking very diligently to come together on the program,\n\n17\n\nthe attorney general for the Virgin Islands has again, for\n\n18\n\nwhatever reason, decided to impede the program.\n\n19\n\nJanuary 15, which is by the way more than five months after\n\n20\n\nMr. Epstein died, the AG in the Virgin Islands publicly\n\n21\n\nannounced that earlier that day she filed a complaint\n\n22\n\nagainst Mr. Epstein's estate and certain related entities\n\n23\n\nunder what is known as the Virgin Islands Criminally\n\n24\n\nInfluence and Corrupt Organization Act, which I understand\n\n25\n\nis referred to as a CICO action.\n\nSo on\n\nSo in the CICO action,\n\nEFTA02846328\n\n", "char_count": 1534}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 9 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nvery briefly, although it's very difficult to follow and\n\n3\n\nfar from clear, the USVI government appears to seek\n\n4\n\nforfeiture of all assets in Mr. Epstein's estate even\n\n5\n\nthough he was never charged with, let alone convicted of,\n\n6\n\nthe underlying CICO allegations and notwithstanding that,\n\n7\n\nwith few exceptions, a lot of what's alleged has no nexus\n\n8\n\nto the Virgin Islands.\n\n9\n\nmonths later and says, \"We get everything.\"\n\n10\n\nthey represent no victims.\n\n11\n\n9\n\nYet, the government comes in five\nAnd, again,\n\nSo we understand, from counsel admitted in the\n\n12\n\nVirgin Islands, that this is without precedent in the\n\n13\n\nVirgin Islands or elsewhere, for that matter, as far as we\n\n14\n\ncan determine.\n\n15\n\nShortly after filing the complaint, the attorney\n\n16\n\ngeneral for the Virgin Islands purported to issue liens\n\n17\n\nagainst each of the defendants named in the CICO action,\n\n18\n\nokay, including the estate, and even including -- and\n\n19\n\neverything, by the way, everything within the estate,\n\n20\n\nincluding the estate's operating account that it needs to\n\n21\n\nfunction to pay lawyers, to pay house managers, people that\n\n22\n\nmow the grass, to simply function.\n\n23\n\ncame in and said, \"We have a priority lien over everyone\n\n24\n\nand anything that exists, and everything is within the\n\n25\n\nscope of these liens.\"\n\nThe attorney general\n\nEFTA02846329\n\n", "char_count": 1449}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n2\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\nPage 10 of 67\n10\n\nOn January 23, to make matters worse, the attorney\n\n3\n\ngeneral sought to intervene in the probate proceedings to,\n\n4\n\namong other things, oppose -- I mean, this is really\n\n5\n\namazing stuff -- oppose the establishment of the claims\n\n6\n\nprogram that the victims are for, the alleged victims that\n\n7\n\nhave already spoken about, almost uniformly, for the\n\n8\n\nestablishment.\n\n9\n\ngeneral said in the attorney general's various filings,\n\n10\n\nincluding the motion to intervene, about the claims program\n\n11\n\nwas just simply wrong.\n\n12\n\nmade a bunch of criticisms that would have only made sense\n\n13\n\nif it was an involuntary program.\n\n14\n\ncompletely voluntary; no one is forced to do anything.\n\n15\n\nUnfortunately, most of what the attorney\n\nFor example, the attorney general\n\nBut it's voluntary, it's\n\nOn February 4, last week, I observed a hearing at\n\n16\n\nwhich USVI counsel for the estate appeared and actually\n\n17\n\nseveral attorneys in this room -- I'm sure they will speak\n\n18\n\nfor themselves -- were also in attendance at this hearing\n\n19\n\nin the probate court.\n\n20\n\nmotions to date, some of which, including the one for the\n\n21\n\nestablishment of the claims program, had been pending for\n\n22\n\nquite some time, to say the least.\n\n23\n\nan important hearing.\n\n24\n\nintervene, the assumption of the claims program, everything\n\n25\n\nwas heard last Tuesday.\n\nAnd the hearing was on all pending\n\nSo this was, obviously,\n\nThe attorney general's motion to\n\nMr. Feinberg and\n\nEFTA02846330\n\n", "char_count": 1567}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 11 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\ntestified at the hearing to address the attorney general's\n\n3\n\nvarious concerns, again, from my view, not speaking for Mr.\n\n4\n\nFeinberg and\n\n5\n\nmisunderstanding of what the program is and does.\n\n6\n\nprobate judge acknowledged very clearly -- I don't have the\n\n7\n\ntranscript yet -- and as soon as I get it, I respectfully\n\n8\n\nrequest the opportunity to submit a copy to your Honor; I\n\n9\n\nthink it's very important for your Honor to see it directly\n\n10\n\nas it bears directly on all these cases here and the\n\n11\n\nprospect for settlement.\n\n12\n\njudge, she acknowledged that the estate wants the program\n\n13\n\nto go forward, the alleged victims want the program to go\n\n14\n\nforward, and that it would be much quicker, more cost\n\n15\n\neffective than drawn-out litigation.\n\n16\n\n11\n\nbut just based on complete\nThe\n\nGetting back to the probate\n\nThe testimony of Mr. Feinberg and\n\nwas\n\n17\n\nalso, from my viewpoint, well received and addressed just\n\n18\n\neverything that the attorney general purported to be\n\n19\n\nconcerned with.\n\n20\n\ngeneral did with these liens, the probate judge asked the\n\n21\n\nparties and voiced concern that the probate court's hands\n\n22\n\nare effectively tied.\n\n23\n\nhas done is asked the estate, asked the attorney general,\n\n24\n\nanyone else who's interested, to brief that court on the\n\n25\n\neffect of the liens.\n\nHowever, because of what the attorney\n\nAnd thus, what the probate judge\n\nEFTA02846331\n\n", "char_count": 1495}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n1\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 12 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\n12\n\nSo as I appear here today, I don't know when the\n\n3\n\nprogram will be established.\n\n4\n\nthe essence.\n\n5\n\nperceived impediments to the establishment of the program,\n\n6\n\nwe may miss the window for fulsome participation in the\n\n7\n\nprogram.\n\n8\n\nthat people wanted -- if there's going to be a program,\n\n9\n\nthey want it to move quickly.\n\n10\n\nto go, and the AG had a different idea, I suppose.\n\n11\n\nBut time is, of course, of\n\nIf the AG does not very quickly remove all\n\nThis is something your Honor heard last time,\n\nWell, we were all here ready\n\nI do want to be clear, since I mentioned these\n\n12\n\nliens, by the way, the estate's position is they're\n\n13\n\ninvalid.\n\n14\n\naddressed it in court, in the probate court.\n\n15\n\nsomething we will deal with, but in the meantime, like I\n\n16\n\nsaid, time is of the essence with the program.\n\n17\n\nWe briefed some of this with the Court already,\nAnd that's\n\nI do want to address an entirely related but\n\n18\n\nseparate issue that the AG's actions have caused.\n\nAnd this\n\n19\n\nis also something we just don't understand.\n\n20\n\nsaid, the AG has purported to put liens on everything in\n\n21\n\nthe estate, including the operating account.\n\n22\n\nnot the AG's intention, if she maintains those liens and\n\n23\n\nsays effectively, \"Estate, you can't pay anyone.\n\n24\n\npay your attorneys,\" well, then, the co-executors have no\n\n25\n\nway to litigate all of these cases that are here and in\n\nYou know, as I\n\nEven if it's\n\nYou can't\n\nEFTA02846332\n\n", "char_count": 1547}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n1\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 13 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n13\n\n2\n\nother courts.\n\nThat came up at the February 4 hearing, and\n\n3\n\nthe Court denied, by the way, the AG's motion to intervene.\n\n4\n\nIt was procedurally improper.\n\n5\n\naddressed the liens, acknowledging that they have potential\n\n6\n\ndisastrous effect if the AG contends that those liens\n\n7\n\nshould freeze all assets including those necessary for the\n\n8\n\nestate to simply function, pay taxes, attorneys, whatever.\n\n9\n\nCounsel for the AG on the record informed the Court that\n\n10\n\nthe AG did not intend for the liens to prohibit the co-\n\n11\n\nexecutors from paying the estate's administration expenses\n\n12\n\nor to preserve its assets.\n\nAnd the Court specifically\n\n13\n\nRegrettably, right after that hearing, counsel for\n\n14\n\nthe co-executors received formal notification from the bank\n\n15\n\nwhere the estate's operating account is, informing the co-\n\n16\n\nexecutors that, because of the lien, the bank has placed a\n\n17\n\nhold on the estate's accounts.\n\n18\n\na week later, after this representation in court by one of\n\n19\n\nher attorneys, has not lifted the lien.\n\n20\n\nestate's not going to be able to make payroll for people\n\n21\n\nthat help take care of the decedent's properties, attorneys\n\n22\n\nwill go unpaid, and everything is going to come to a\n\n23\n\nscreeching halt.\n\n24\n\nassure the Court I'm not for the inability of the estate to\n\n25\n\npay its counsel, but here we are.\n\nAnd the AG, as we sit here\n\nSo very soon the\n\nWe hope that doesn't happen.\n\nI can\n\nAnd there are various\n\nEFTA02846333\n\n", "char_count": 1571}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 14 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n14\n\n2\n\nconstitutional issues, of course:\n\nHow can someone be\n\n3\n\nforced to defend actions when they can't pay their counsel?\n\n4\n\nBut, again, we hope the AG will remove these impediments\n\n5\n\nand these actions won't need to be stayed; and, more\n\n6\n\nimportantly, the program will go forward.\n\n7\n\nthe estate is very diligently working to resolve these\n\n8\n\nissues with the attorney general, but it's been very\n\n9\n\ndifficult.\n\n10\n\nunfortunate mixed news that I have to report to your Honor\n\n11\n\nabout the claims program.\n\n12\n13\n\nAnd as I sit here today, this is the\n\nAnd thank you, by the way, for giving me the time\nto address it.\n\n14\n15\n\nUSVI counsel for\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnyone on plaintiffs' side want to\n\naddress anything that's just been said?\nMS. KAPLAN:\n\n16\n\nYes, your Honor, briefly.\n\nRoberta\n\n17\n\nKaplan.\n\nYour Honor, there's no small degree of irony in\n\n18\n\nwhat you just heard from my friend on the other side, given\n\n19\n\nthe fact that two days before he died, Mr. Epstein signed a\n\n20\n\nwill that specifically designated the Virgin Islands for\n\n21\n\nthe probate of his estate.\n\n22\n\nand his own making.\n\n23\n\ngoing to go well for them in the Virgin Islands and now it\n\n24\n\nhasn't is somehow unexpected.\n\n25\n\ndeliberate that the Virgin Islands was chosen as the\n\nThis is a problem of his will\n\nAnd the idea that they thought it was\n\nIt was obviously quite\n\nEFTA02846334\n\n", "char_count": 1457}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n2\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 15 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n15\n\njurisdiction.\n\n3\n\nIn terms of the settlement process and the\n\n4\n\nprocedures set up with Mr. Feinberg and others, we of\n\n5\n\ncourse, as you've heard, want it to work out.\n\n6\n\nthe reasons for the attorney general's objections are the\n\n7\n\nsame reasons that we said to your Honor at the first\n\n8\n\nhearing we had that it was done unilaterally, that there\n\n9\n\nwas no consultation.\n\n10\n\nconcerned about the amount in fees being paid out of the\n\n11\n\nestate to Mr. Feinberg and others.\n\n12\n\nconsultation\n\nBut one of\n\nThe Court seems to be extremely\n\nAgain, no\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI'm sorry, the court, the probate\n\n15\n\nMS. KAPLAN:\n\nThe court in the Virgin Islands --\n\n16\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThe probate court?\n\n17\n\nMS. KAPLAN:\n\n-- seems to be concerned about the\n\n13\n14\n\ncourt?\n\n18\n\namount that's being paid without any supervision.\n\nOn\n\n19\n\nFriday there was an article in The New York Times, which\n\n20\n\nI'm sure your Honor saw, about millions of dollars being\n\n21\n\nrun through a previously defunct bank that Mr. Epstein has\n\n22\n\nset up.\n\n23\n\nanyone about any of this.\n\n24\n\nfund to go forward, we certainly want people to have that\n\n25\n\noption, the concerns on the part of both the judge in the\n\nThere's no clarity, no diligence, no knowledge of\nAnd while we certainly want the\n\nEFTA02846335\n\n", "char_count": 1363}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 16 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n16\n\n2\n\nVirgin Islands and the attorney general in the Virgin\n\n3\n\nIslands are not unfounded.\n\n4\n\nwith respect to meetings with Mr. Feinberg, yes,\n\n5\n\nwe had those meetings.\n\n6\n\nprotocol based on those meetings.\n\n7\n\nwhether they were adopted.\n\n8\n\non the other side that they were, but we have not received\n\n9\n\na copy of that.\n\n10\n\nmeetings -- and I think it's very crucial -- we put this in\n\n11\n\nour letter to your Honor -- it was absolutely his explicit\n\n12\n\nrequirement that in order for him to do what he was going\n\n13\n\nto do, no plaintiff could be required or asked to stay the\n\n14\n\nlitigation in this court in order to proceed with the\n\n15\n\nproceedings.\n\n16\n\nof what he's doing, and there is no stay required or asked\n\n17\n\nof any plaintiff proceeding in these cases.\n\n18\n\nreasons -- and I'm sure we're going to talk about it today,\n\n19\n\ngiven what you've heard --\n\n20\n21\n22\n\nChanges were recommended to the\nI hadn't seen yet\n\nI'm glad to hear from my friend\n\nOne thing Mr. Feinberg did say at those\n\nSo that is an absolute explicit precondition\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd for those\n\nNo stay required or asked for by\n\ndefendants, is that what you're saying?\nMS. KAPLAN:\n\nSo that in order -- if a plaintiff\n\n23\n\nwants to participate in the settlement process, the\n\n24\n\ndefendant can't ask them to stay their cases.\n\n25\n\nthe cases is not a precondition or a requirement --\n\nAnd staying\n\nEFTA02846336\n\n", "char_count": 1479}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n\nPage 17 of 67\n17\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n3\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right, plaintiffs can ask; and if\n\nplaintiffs ask, defendants can agree.\n\n4\n\nMS. KAPLAN:\n\nOf course, plaintiffs can always ask.\n\n5\n\nIf it's by mutual agreement of the parties, that can always\n\n6\n\nhappen.\n\n7\n\nBut I think that only highlights the importance of\n\n8\n\ngetting these cases moving, getting discovery moving,\n\n9\n\nparticularly with what you've heard from the other side,\n\n10\n\nthat there's no prediction at this point of when any\n\n11\n\nsettlement process can even begin.\n\n12\n\nsitting here before on this side table, we have no idea how\n\n13\n\nlong these things will take in the Virgin Islands.\n\n14\n\nleast speaking for my client, we would prefer to have a\n\n15\n\njudgment, given the uncertainty in this court, and we'd\n\n16\n\nlike to get moving.\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n\nMR.\n\nAnd none of us, we're\n\nAt\n\nAnyone else?\n:\n\nBrad\n\n, your Honor.\n\nI'd only\n\n19\n\nlike to address a few points.\n\nI was in the Virgin Islands\n\n20\n\nlast week.\n\n21\n\nmet with the attorney general and explained what it was\n\n22\n\nabout the current setup of the protocol and the program\n\n23\n\nthat many of the victims liked.\n\n24\n\nspecifically addressed some of the things about the program\n\n25\n\nshe did not like, most notably the fact that all three of\n\nAnd after the hearing, we went and personally\n\nAnd the attorney general\n\nEFTA02846337\n\n", "char_count": 1410}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 18 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n18\n\n2\n\nthe administrators were chosen by the estate unilaterally.\n\n3\n\nAnd the attorney general did not say the lien is for the\n\n4\n\npurposes of taking everything into the Virgin Islands and\n\n5\n\nto disenfranchise the victims.\n\n6\n\nyesterday disseminated a letter to many of us -- I know to\n\n7\n\nthe estate counsel as well as to myself -- I think it's\n\n8\n\nmost appropriate probably to file it with your Honor so\n\n9\n\nthat you understand exactly where things stand with the\n\n10\n\nattorney general's position as to the claims protocol.\n\n11\n\nput in writing 13 what she called commitments that she\n\n12\n\nwants from the estate in order to allow the claims program\n\n13\n\nto -- a claims program to go forward.\n\n14\n\nfairly minor; it looks like it could be worked out.\n\n15\n\nof them may be more difficult to work out.\n\nWhat she has said and as of\n\nShe\n\nSome of them are\nSome\n\n16\n\nBut the probate judge recognized that there was\n\n17\n\ngoing to be this discrepancy; and until something is done\n\n18\n\nwith the attorney general's lien, the probate court simply\n\n19\n\ncan't allow any program to go forward.\n\n20\n\nboth the estate lawyers and the AG to continue working\n\n21\n\ntogether with one another to reach a compromise and allow a\n\n22\n\nprogram to go forward.\n\n23\n\ncommitments that the AG wants in writing from the estate;\n\n24\n\nand so long as those commitments are met, some of which are\n\n25\n\nfairly minor, she is willing to allow -- to withdraw some\n\nSo that court asked\n\nLike I said, we have very specific\n\nEFTA02846338\n\n", "char_count": 1584}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 19 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nmajor portion of her lien to allow the program to begin.\n\n3\n\n19\n\nSo I don't think it's as far apart as was\n\n4\n\nrepresented earlier, but I do think it would help your\n\n5\n\nHonor to have, you know, possession of the AG's recent\n\n6\n\nletter that she circulated yesterday.\n\n7\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nThis is Sigrid McCawley on behalf\n\n8\n\nof Bois Schiller.\n\n9\n\nof because of the dynamic with what's happening with the\n\n10\n\nestate and the AG, much of which is not within our\n\n11\n\ncontrol --\n\n12\n\nI just wanted to address the importance\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nHang on a second.\n\nJust move the mic\n\n13\n\na little closer for the sake of the recording of the\n\n14\n\nconference.\n\n15\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nOf course.\n\n-- so much of which is\n\n16\n\nnot within our control, what's going to happen with the\n\n17\n\nestate and the AG.\n\n18\n\njust emphasizes the importance of this Court's power to\n\n19\n\nmove these cases forward.\n\n20\n\nvictims to seek justice in this circumstance.\n\n21\n\nmove their cases forward.\n\n22\n\nthe claims program, if that comes to fruition.\n\n23\n\npoint there's a lot that needs to go on before that can\n\n24\n\nhappen.\n\n25\n\nWe've put forth, we think, reasonable schedules to your\n\nThere's clearly a division there.\n\nThat\n\nIt's really important to these\nThey want to\n\nOf course they're interested in\nBut at this\n\nWe're here to try to move our cases forward.\n\nEFTA02846339\n\n", "char_count": 1429}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 20 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nHonor that we'd like to move forward with as swiftly as\n\n3\n\npossible.\n\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\n20\n\nWell, I don't have much\n\n5\n\ncontrol over what happens in the Virgin Islands, as in\n\n6\n\nnone.\n\n7\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n9\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nCan I briefly respond, your Honor?\n\nGo ahead.\nYou know, it's interesting.\n\nI was\n\n10\n\nin the Virgin Islands last week, Mr.\n\n11\n\nMr. Schiller was there.\n\n12\n\ntone with respect to the same, assuming Ms. Kaplan, that\n\n13\n\nshe's not included in this -- clearly, she had some issues\n\n14\n\nwith the program, that's fine.\n\n15\n\nbest for her client.\n\n16\n\nwas there,\n\nYou heard a completely different\n\nThat's her view of what's\n\nThat's not for us to argue with.\n\nThe same attorneys I just mentioned, excluding\n\n17\n\nMs. Kaplan, their Virgin Islands counsel stood up and\n\n18\n\nunequivocally voiced that they want this program to go\n\n19\n\nforward.\n\n20\n\nI can assure you, speaking directly on behalf of the\n\n21\n\nestate, that we have tried to discuss this with the\n\n22\n\nattorney general.\n\n23\n\ndifficult in terms of being able to see eye to eye.\n\n24\n25\n\nThat's what they want.\n\nWe want it to go forward.\n\nAt every attempt things become more\n\nAnd I'd like to point out, in addition to the\nproblem of attorneys not being paid and the estate coming\n\nEFTA02846340\n\n", "char_count": 1377}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 21 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n21\n\n2\n\nto a screeching halt, everyone in this room I trust\n\n3\n\nrecognizes that, according to the attorney general, her\n\n4\n\nliens are number one.\n\n5\n\nthink you're going to get a judgment one day, you can try,\n\n6\n\nand maybe you will, maybe you won't.\n\n7\n\nattorney general, she goes first.\n\n8\n\nvictims, but she goes first.\n\n9\n\namorphous problem that's out there that's for me to deal\n\n10\n\nwith because Mr. Epstein's will is being probated there at\n\n11\n\nhis decision.\n\n12\n\nproblems for everyone in this room.\n\n13\n\nYou can get a judgment -- if you\n\nAccording to the\n\nShe represents no\n\nSo it's not just some\n\nNo, the attorney general's actions are\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right, again, I can't do anything\n\n14\n\nabout the attorney general in the Virgin Islands.\n\n15\n\nask counsel to keep reporting back to me as to what's\n\n16\n\nhappening.\n\n17\n\nwould benefit from seeing a transcript, seeing a letter, by\n\n18\n\nall means file whatever you think is useful.\n\n19\n\nI'd appreciate that.\n\nI can\n\nIf you think the Court\n\nI'm not going to worry right now about defendants\n\n20\n\nnot being able to represent themselves in these cases.\n\nIf\n\n21\n\nthat happens, it happens.\n\n22\n\nindividuals who could represent themselves pro se if they\n\n23\n\nwanted to.\n\n24\n\nentities, of course, would be in default if defendants stop\n\n25\n\nlitigating the matter and don't have counsel paid for and\n\nYou have potentially some\n\nIt might be rather difficult.\n\nAny corporate\n\nEFTA02846341\n\n", "char_count": 1525}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 22 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n22\n\n2\n\nable to appear.\n\n3\n\nto it.\n\n4\n\nyou won't get there.\n\n5\n\nknow, slew of motion practice on defaults.\n\n6\n\nthat's not going to happen, at least for the moment.\n\n7\n\nBut we'll jump off that bridge when we get\n\nIt seems to me that you're not there.\n\nHopefully\n\nIf you do, we'll have a whole, you\nLet's assume\n\nI do think I need to set discovery schedules. I'd\n\n8\n\nlike to get a feel for what the discovery would entail:\n\n9\n\nwhat we're talking about in terms of volume of documents;\n\n10\n\nwhat we're talking about in terms of number of witnesses on\n\n11\n\neach side; what we're talking about in terms of experts,\n\n12\n\njust to get a feel because understanding scope of potential\n\n13\n\ndiscovery helps the Court understand what a reasonable\n\n14\n\nschedule would be, as opposed to just saying this many\n\n15\n\nmonths, that many months, understanding.\n\n16\n\nIn addition, you all have proposed deadlines for\n\n17\n\nmotions to amend.\n\nI want to understand how likely it is\n\n18\n\nthat there'll be amendments, what you would need to know in\n\n19\n\norder for there to be an amendment, because the amendment\n\n20\n\ndeadlines, which I realize are largely guided by the\n\n21\n\nindividual rules of a lot of the district judges here who\n\n22\n\nhave very tight proposed deadlines, the amendment deadlines\n\n23\n\nthat are being proposed would come up fairly quickly, and I\n\n24\n\ndon't know that plaintiffs would have any more information\n\n25\n\navailable to them than they have now.\n\nIs there information\n\nEFTA02846342\n\n", "char_count": 1567}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 23 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nplaintiffs would need in discovery in order to determine\n\n3\n\nwhether they really need to amend, and what kind of\n\n4\n\ninformation is that?\n\n5\n\nso I can do something sensible.\n\n6\n\nthe schedules for these cases need not be identical.\n\n7\n\nI'd like to understand what differences there are if we're\n\n8\n\ngoing to have different schedules.\n\n9\n\n23\n\nI'd just like to get an overall feel\nAnd as I said in my order,\nBut\n\nOkay, so let me first get a feel for, on the\n\n10\n\namendment question, since that would be an early deadline.\n\n11\n\nThere's already one case where there's a proposed\n\n12\n\namendment.\n\n13\n\nthese cases.\n\n14\n\nwhether there's a likelihood of amendment and what they\n\n15\n\nwould need to know, what they would need to learn in\n\n16\n\ndiscovery, if anything, in order to determine if there\n\n17\n\nshould be an amendment?\n\nThere are some differently named defendants in\nWhat are plaintiffs thinking in terms of\n\n18\n\nAnyone want to field that?\n\n19\n\nMR.\n\n:\n\nSure.\n\nI don't mind.\n\nSo we have\n\n20\n\nsued not only the estate but several corporate entities.\n\n21\n\nAnd we would at least need 30(b)(6) depositions from the\n\n22\n\ncorporate entities to learn what other related corporations\n\n23\n\nperformed certain similar acts that we've alleged against\n\n24\n\nthese corporate entities in their negligence of simply\n\n25\n\nenabling Mr. Epstein's abuse.\n\nI think that it would go a\n\nEFTA02846343\n\n", "char_count": 1464}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 24 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nlong way to get a 30(b)(6) deposition of the estate, as\n\n3\n\nwell.\n\n4\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n24\n\nCould you do this by way of\n\ninterrogatory?\n\n6\n\nMR.\n\n:\n\nWe could.\n\nWe actually expected,\n\n7\n\nespecially given how long of extensions were given in order\n\n8\n\nto\n\n9\n\nwe expected to get a lot of that information in initial\n\n10\n\ndisclosures in terms of what other witnesses were available\n\n11\n\nand what other documents pertained to each one of our\n\n12\n\nclients.\n\n13\n\nor how much time passed before initial disclosures,\n\nInstead, we got back that there are none.\nNow, I realize with initial disclosures the\n\n14\n\nposition being taken is there are no documents that we\n\n15\n\nintend to produce to support our defenses, and we don't\n\n16\n\nnecessarily have to give you right now what you're asking\n\n17\n\nfor in terms of what's relevant to the claim.\n\nSo we're\n\n18\n\ngoing to have to at least propound discovery.\n\nI imagine if\n\n19\n\nthe current circumstance carries on in terms of what I feel\n\n20\n\nis a lack of production, that we're going to get basically\n\n21\n\nnothing, and then we're going to be left taking 30(b)(6)\n\n22\n\ndepositions, anyway, so that at least get a human being on\n\n23\n\nthe other side of the table to tell us what you know, what\n\n24\n\nyou don't know and why you don't know anything.\n\n25\n\nright now we're not being given any information, which just\n\nBecause\n\nEFTA02846344\n\n", "char_count": 1452}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 25 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nis totally unreasonable, especially given the breadth of\n\n3\n\ndocuments that we who have litigated these similar cases\n\n4\n\nknow exist out there.\n\n5\n\n25\n\nFor instance, I would expect flight logs that have\n\n6\n\nmy clients on them to have been listed as some documents\n\n7\n\nthat would be used either as a defense or that could\n\n8\n\npossibly be relevant to the claims.\n\n9\n\nback there are no documents.\n\n10\n\nMr. Epstein's server.\n\n11\n\ncontrol of those emails, but the appearance that we're\n\n12\n\nbeing given is that it's nobody.\n\nInstead we're getting\n\nThere are emails on\n\nSomebody has to be in possession or\n\n13\n\nSo if we continue down this course of having to\n\n14\n\nkind of pry open every single fact and detail, it's going\n\n15\n\nto take us a little while.\n\n16\n\nnegotiating a discovery schedule, I was asking for the\n\n17\n\namendment or the -- for the amendment of the complaint to\n\n18\n\nbe three months down the road for this exact point.\n\n19\n\na lot of information, at least some information, in order\n\n20\n\nto know what parties to add to this complaint or what\n\n21\n\ncauses of action need to be amended.\n\n22\n23\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd that's why when we were\n\nI need\n\nSo a couple of you have -- actually\n\nfor three of plaintiffs' counsel, Ms. Kaplan,\n\n24\n\nI believe, you seem to have an agreement on a\n\n25\n\nmotion to amend deadline, which is not very far away.\n\nEFTA02846345\n\n", "char_count": 1448}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 26 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n26\n\n2\n\nThey're not identical, but they're in March.\n\n3\n\nyou think that makes sense?\n\n4\n\nMS. KAPLAN:\n\nWhat makes\n\nYour Honor, we don't anticipate any\n\n5\n\namendments in our case.\n\nWe perceive intent to go against\n\n6\n\nthe estate.\n\n7\n\nmoney to be looking into other entities.\n\n8\n\nmore than sufficient assets to satisfy any judgment here.\n\nWe don't think it's worth our client's time or\nThe estate has\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\n10\n\nMS. KAPLAN:\n\nSo in our case we're very differently\n\n11\n\npositioned than Mr.\n\n12\n\nenough for us.\nMS. WANG:\n\n13\n\nand 30 days is more than\n\nAnd, your Honor, we take a slightly\n\n14\n\nmiddle-road view\n\nMariann Wang for three of the\n\n15\n\nplaintiffs -- we put the standard date down that the\n\n16\n\ndistrict judges have marked on our cases has -- primarily\n\n17\n\nbecause we don't anticipate amending; and if we do, it\n\n18\n\nwould be because we've really obtained new information that\n\n19\n\nmakes us think that actually the estate is not the right\n\n20\n\ndefendant.\n\n21\n\notherwise, we would do it not by right or -- you know, we\n\n22\n\nwould just make a motion that some new information came\n\n23\n\nout.\n\n24\n\nof -- and maybe I'm jumping ahead -- in terms of number of\n\n25\n\nwitnesses on our side probably having about three to five,\n\nSo we don't really anticipate amending;\n\nBut we would anticipate as a general matter in terms\n\nEFTA02846346\n\n", "char_count": 1434}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 27 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nmore like three, per plaintiffs' side, so a plaintiff and\n\n3\n\nrepresentatives of either therapists or medical providers\n\n4\n\nor individual emotional-harm witness.\n\n5\n\nother side, I would anticipate doing very early 30(b)(6)s\n\n6\n\nsimilarly to determine who if any is going to be put up or\n\n7\n\nwho we would want to put up on the defense side at trial,\n\n8\n\nbecause right now we similarly are getting nothing out of\n\n9\n\ninitial disclosures or any kind of information from the\n\n10\n\nestate about who is relevant for our clients' claims.\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nHang on a second.\n\n27\n\nAnd then on the\n\nI threw out a lot\n\n12\n\nof questions at once, so let's take them in pieces.\n\n13\n\nplaintiffs deposing defendants -- well, for what\n\n14\n\nplaintiffs need from defendants, documents, depositions,\n\n15\n\nhow voluminous are the demands that plaintiffs are\n\n16\n\nplanning to make on defendants, and how many witnesses are\n\n17\n\nyou looking for from defendants?\n\n18\n\nMS. KAPLAN:\n\nFor\n\nAgain, your Honor, I think there's\n\n19\n\ngoing to be -- you're going to see great variation, you\n\n20\n\nknow, which is what you see in the proposed schedules.\n\n21\n\nI'm not sure we need a 30(b)(6) from the estate.\n\n22\n\nclient knows what happened; she knows who was responsible.\n\n23\n\nI think maybe two witnesses on their side, both of whom I\n\n24\n\nassume will plead the Fifth.\n\n25\n\nthe two women who did scheduling for Mr. Epstein.\n\nMy\n\nThey're really non-parties,\nAnd\n\nEFTA02846347\n\n", "char_count": 1528}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 28 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n28\n\n2\n\nmaybe three witnesses on our side, and that's the whole\n\n3\n\nthing.\n\nI --\n\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nHow about documents?\n\n5\n\nMS. KAPLAN:\n\nAny documents they have relating to\n\n6\n\nour client, and that's it.\n\n7\n\nfind myself -THE COURT:\n\n8\n9\n\nWe're talking -- I mean, I\n\nYou're looking for something much\n\nmore streamlined?\nMS. KAPLAN:\n\n10\n\nYeah, I find it very unusual for\n\n11\n\nmyself saying this, having spent 20 years as a partner of\n\n12\n\nPaul Weiss, but this is not a case from our perspective\n\n13\n\nthat's going to take very much discovery or take very long\n\n14\n\nto get to trial.\n\n15\n\nabout what happened.\n\n16\n\nbe one or two corroborating witnesses.\n\n17\n\nwhole thing.\n\n18\n\nShe'll take the stand and she'll testify\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWe'll put on an expert.\n\nThere may\n\nAnd that's the\n\nAnd some of you are looking for a\n\n19\n\nlot of documents, and you're talking about potentially a\n\n20\n\nnumber of witnesses, right?\n\n21\n\ndocuments from defendants?\n\n22\n\nemails.\n\n23\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nWho's looking for a lot of\nI've heard flight logs and\n\nThis is -- yeah, this is Sigrid\n\n24\n\nMcCawley from Bois Schiller.\n\nI think \"a lot of documents\"\n\n25\n\nmay not be the correct characterization, but certainly we\n\nEFTA02846348\n\n", "char_count": 1286}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 29 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nput forth in our Rule 26 disclosures a good, substantial\n\n3\n\namount of information that we know exists based on the\n\n4\n\nwork that we've done over the last several years.\n\n5\n\nwe've already identified that as a body of documents\n\n6\n\nthat's relevant to the case.\n\n7\n\nHonor, is the information that we know exists from Jeffrey\n\n8\n\nEpstein's electronic files.\n\n9\n\nMindSpring accounts, he had house electronic accounts that\n\n10\n\nhe used to communicate with the employees, all of which he\n\n11\n\nclaimed the Fifth before he passed away.\n\n12\n\nobtained those in discovery unless it came from another\n\n13\n\nindividual who was copied on an email.\n\n14\n\nused other aliases for his email addresses, things of that\n\n15\n\nnature, all of which is now accessible and that we want.\n\n16\n\nSo we are going to seek that in discovery.\n\n17\n\nstreamlined in the sense it will be responsive to our\n\n18\n\nclients' claims and the claims that they have and the\n\n19\n\ntrafficking that was occurring with Jeffrey Epstein and\n\n20\n\nhis co-conspirators.\n\n21\n\n29\n\nSo\n\nBut what we don't have, your\n\nFor example, he had\n\nSo we have never\n\nWe know that he\n\nIt will be\n\nSimilarly, with respect to witnesses, we\n\n22\n\nanticipate that we will call not only someone from the\n\n23\n\nestate but a number of the co-conspirators that were\n\n24\n\ninvolved.\n\n25\n\nas they have in the past.\n\nWe anticipate many of them will take the Fifth,\nAnd then on our side we will\n\nEFTA02846349\n\n", "char_count": 1512}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 30 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nhave supportive witnesses, witnesses who saw our clients\n\n3\n\nin the places that they say they were; obviously, our\n\n4\n\nclients themselves to substantiate those claims; and a\n\n5\n\nvery limited number of experts.\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n30\n\nWhen you say \"a number of witnesses\n\n7\n\non defendants' side, some of whom would take the Fifth,\"\n\n8\n\nwhat are you talking about by \"a number\"?\n\n9\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\n10\n\nthe, you know, the main\n\n11\n\nwere part of the operation.\n\n12\n\nwas copied on documents with my clients; Leslie Groff, as\n\n13\n\nwell, who was doing the scheduling, communicating between\n\n14\n\nmy clients and Jeffrey Epstein.\n\n15\n\nbelieve were facilitating this along with Jeffrey Epstein\n\n16\n\nwould be part of our case.\n\n17\n18\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nJust a couple.\n\nI mean, really\n\nin my view, the main people who\nSo you have\n\n, who\n\nSo individuals that we\n\nAny possibility for having multiple\n\nlawyers sit in on any particular depositions?\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nYour Honor, we have five cases\n\n20\n\nbefore you.\n\nWe're happy to coordinate with other\n\n21\n\nplaintiffs' lawyers and have those, for example, if it's a\n\n22\n\n30(b)(6), have those coordinated.\n\n23\n\nwant an allocated amount of time to be able to take care\n\n24\n\nof our cases, but we would coordinate that certainly to\n\n25\n\nmake sure that we're streamlining that process.\n\nWe would, of course,\n\nEFTA02846350\n\n", "char_count": 1433}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 31 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nMS. KAPLAN:\n\n31\n\nYour Honor, one thing that may be\n\n3\n\nhelpful in that regard,\n\nand Groff, if we get an\n\n4\n\nearly -- if we can get an early indication, which we\n\n5\n\nassume has to be the case if they're going to take the\n\n6\n\nFifth, those are the only two witnesses that I would even\n\n7\n\nshare with some of these other cases.\n\n8\n\nknow, we may just be able to streamline that right out of\n\n9\n\nthe way.\n\nThen I don't -- you\n\n10\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\n11\n\nWell, to go back to -- but I'll try to hit on\n\n12\n\nwhat matters most.\n\nFirst, this notion that we're somehow\n\n13\n\nnot -- we're stonewalling.\n\n14\n\ndisclosures.\n\n15\n\nthe rule is very clear; the parties have to disclose\n\n16\n\nthings that they may use for their claims or defenses.\n\n17\n\nlot of people kind of gloss past that and give short\n\n18\n\nshrift to initial disclosures, but that's what they are so\n\n19\n\nthey can't sandbag people.\n\n20\n\nthat as an attorney for executors of an estate and not the\n\n21\n\nalleged tort feasor himself, that after due diligence that\n\n22\n\nwe're all required to do as counsel with regard to initial\n\n23\n\ndisclosures for the most part, but it's not true as to\n\n24\n\nevery action -- but for the most part, I don't have such\n\n25\n\ninformation or people to disclose at this time.\n\nMr.\n\nThese were initial\nwas correct when he said that\n\nA\n\nAnd it's hardly surprising\n\nIt's not\n\nEFTA02846351\n\n", "char_count": 1469}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n2\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 32 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n32\n\nthat unusual.\n\n3\n\nI actually agree with a lot of what Ms. Kaplan\n\n4\n\nsaid in terms of how she views the scope of discovery.\n\n5\n\nthat shows why the cases where people have a much broader\n\n6\n\nscope, relatively speaking, should not proceed on the same\n\n7\n\ntrack.\n\n8\n\nwhat we've done, and I'm sure your Honor appreciated this,\n\n9\n\nis we were on the plaintiffs' side we negotiated discovery\n\n10\n\nschedules with each set of plaintiffs' attorneys.\n\n11\n\nthink it makes sense for there to be coordination in those\n\n12\n\nactions for, say deposition.\n\n13\n\nfavor of people sharing discovery with each other across\n\n14\n\nthe cases.\n\n15\n\nadvantage if something's disclosed because it pertains to\n\n16\n\nperson X's claims but doesn't pertain to person Y, person Y\n\n17\n\nshouldn't get a free shot at discovery.\n\n18\n\nthat out there for now because it came up.\n\n19\n20\n21\n\nSo in terms of the Bois Schiller cases\n\nbecause\n\nAnd we\n\nI will say we are not in\n\nWe think that puts plaintiffs at an unfair\n\nI'll just throw\n\nBut in terms of the scope, yeah, the initial\ndisclosures were actually quite -THE COURT:\n\nHang on a second.\n\nYou would rather\n\n22\n\nhave one of your witnesses deposed multiple times rather\n\n23\n\nthan have one deposition where multiple lawyers sit in?\n\n24\n25\n\nAnd\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nWell, it depends how long the\n\ndeposition is, same what the scope is.\n\nSo related to that,\n\nEFTA02846352\n\n", "char_count": 1471}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 33 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nthe Bois Schiller firm has a much broader scope, according\n\n3\n\nto their initial disclosures, of what they want here.\n\n4\n\nlisted dozens -- dozens -- of people and categories of\n\n5\n\ndocuments:\n\n6\n\nthat's their disclosure, fine; but you don't get to proceed\n\n7\n\nthen, from our view, on the same track as someone like\n\n8\n\nMs. Kaplan, who says, \"I'm not doing all that.\"\n\n9\n\ndoesn't -- it doesn't seem reasonable to us for those kinds\n\n10\n\nof different views to proceed on the same track.\n\n11\n\ndon't see, to your Honor's question, how you can have a\n\n12\n\nsingle tenable deposition of a representative of the estate\n\n13\n\nwhen one person says these 20 categories are in the scope\n\n14\n\nand another plaintiff's attorney says, \"I just need to know\n\n15\n\nabout my client's allegations,\" which by the way -- and,\n\n16\n\nagain, I think Ms. Kaplan's view is the more reasonable\n\n17\n\none.\n\n18\n\nmovie stars, politicians.\n\n33\n\nThat's fine.\n\nThey\n\nIf\n\nit just\n\nAnd I\n\nAnd if I can -- I think it's related -- pardon me\n\n19\n\nfor just an extra moment.\n\n20\n\nthat I don't think lines up with the others and which you\n\n21\n\nmay have discerned a disagreement, there's relatively\n\n22\n\nspeaking, I think there is a lot of -- more agreement than\n\n23\n\ndisagreement in the proposed discovery schedules.\n\n24\n\nplace where we don't see eye to eye with the Bois Schiller\n\n25\n\nfirm is that in the\n\nYou know, one of the other cases\n\nAnd one\n\ncase they sued defendant\n\nEFTA02846353\n\n", "char_count": 1533}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 34 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n34\n\n2\n\nMaxwell.\n\nThey've made a motion to approve alternate\n\n3\n\nservice.\n\nI don't know what the status is.\n\n4\n\nthere's been an opposition yet.\n\n5\n\nyet.\n\n6\n\nthe same pace with discovery when, as they stated in their\n\n7\n\npapers, it's inevitable in their mind that Maxwell will\n\n8\n\nhave to deal with this case.\n\n9\n\nanother defendant who might have nothing to do with coming\n\n10\n\nafter things are already done and then want to do\n\n11\n\ndepositions and document requests.\n\n12\n\ndon't we build in some extra time, an extra 30 days of our\n\n13\n\nproposal for that action, which I think is absolutely\n\n14\n\nreasonable, given where they stand with serving Maxwell.\n\nI don't believe\n\nI don't know if one's due\n\nBut I don't see why that case should move forward at\n\n15\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nSo they're going to have\n\nWe just said hey, why\n\nYour Honor, just two things very\n\n16\n\nbriefly.\n\nFirst on the characterization of our discovery, I\n\n17\n\nwant to be very clear we took our Rule 26 disclosure\n\n18\n\nresponsibilities very seriously, and we identified those\n\n19\n\nindividuals who witnessed the crime, were around at the\n\n20\n\ntime, would have information that's relevant -- directly\n\n21\n\nrelevant to those claims.\n\n22\n\nthat we took that obligation seriously, and we put that\n\n23\n\nforth in our disclosures.\n\n24\n\nwill necessarily call at trial, but we did comply with that\n\n25\n\nobligation.\n\nSo they are fulsome in the sense\n\nThat's different than who we\n\nSo he's talking about politicians and famous\n\nEFTA02846354\n\n", "char_count": 1577}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 35 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n35\n\nThat is just the realm of what was going on in the\n\n2\n\npeople.\n\n3\n\ncircumstance, so if one of our clients came into contact\n\n4\n\nwith that person, they were listed on the Rule 26\n\n5\n\ndisclosures.\n\n6\n\nWith respect to Maxwell, our motion for\n\n7\n\nalternative service is -- under the general reference order\n\n8\n\nis before your Honor.\n\n9\n\ncases.\n\n10\n\naccept service, and we got the motion for alternative\n\n11\n\nservice granted there.\n\n12\n\nin front of Judge Preska two weeks ago, fighting to not\n\n13\n\ndisclose documents.\n\n14\n\nbe -- who is not found through her counsel.\n\n15\n\nphysically find her right now, she is actively litigating\n\n16\n\nin this courthouse.\n\n17\n\ndo is grant alternative service, which we think is\n\n18\n\nabundantly reasonable, considering that we've served her in\n\n19\n\nher email address, we've tried to go to the locations where\n\n20\n\nwe knew she had a residence, and we've approached her\n\n21\n\ncounsel, not only through email and phone, but also in\n\n22\n\nperson, and were denied the acceptance of service.\n\n23\n\nbelieve that, you know, this is not supposed to be a cat-\n\n24\n\nand-mouse chase; it's something where a defendant of this\n\n25\n\nkind, through their counsel, should accept service.\n\nWe have had that same issue in other\n\nIn Judge Koeltl's case, similarly, she would not\n\nShe has active counsel litigating\n\nThis is not an individual who cannot\nWhile we can't\n\nAnd so what we've asked this Court to\n\nSo we\n\nAnd we\n\nEFTA02846355\n\n", "char_count": 1531}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 36 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nbelieve we've taken all the steps necessary to move that\n\n3\n\nforward.\n\n4\n\nmoving discovery forward in our case.\n\n36\n\nSo we don't think that should be an impediment to\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right.\n\n6\n\nMS. KAPLAN:\n\nYour Honor, I forgot to mention one\n\n7\n\nthing, and I should mention it.\n\n8\n\nof the Southern District is -- obviously is in possession\n\n9\n\nof a lot of documents relevant to these claims, has been\n\n10\n\nvery cooperative and has told us all that there's a\n\n11\n\nprocedure where we can put in a form, and whatever\n\n12\n\ndocuments they have, subject to grand jury secrecy\n\n13\n\nrequirements, will be produced in the cases.\n\n14\n\nto give them those kudos.\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right.\n\nThe U.S. Attorney's Office\n\nI just wanted\n\nJust as a side note, the\n\n16\n\ntwo cases where discovery has been stayed, in light of\n\n17\n\nwhat's happening in the Virgin Islands, they may end up\n\n18\n\nunstayed.\n\n19\n\nsince I don't have those counsel here today.\n\n20\n\nto get them on -- I'll just tell defense counsel we may\n\n21\n\nneed to get them on a discovery track, as well.\n\n22\n\nSo I'm just going to address those separately\nWe may need\n\nAll right, so thank you, all, for background.\n\n23\n\nhave, I don't know how many cases at this point, 16, maybe,\n\n24\n\nin front of me.\n\n25\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nI counted 15, your Honor.\n\nEFTA02846356\n\n", "char_count": 1402}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\nTHE COURT:\n\n37\n\nWell, there's going to be 16 because\n\nthe one that was just filed before Judge Koeltl --\n\n4\n5\n\nPage 37 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n3\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nKoeltl, okay.\n\nThen that would\n\nbe --\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n-- I'm pretty sure that that's --\n\n7\n\nthat was designated to Judge Moses; it will be redesignated\n\n8\n\nto me.\n\n9\n\ngeneral pretrial supervision, so -- and I think I have\n\n10\n\nlocal counsel, at least, right here just as an observer\n\n11\n\ntoday.\n\n12\n\nthe case briefly.\n\nAnd I'm fairly certain Judge Koeltl will refer for\n\nSo you might want to meet each other and talk about\n\nOf these cases, a number of them are pending\n\n13\n14\n\nbefore district judges who have preferences in their\n\n15\n\nindividual rules regarding timelines for discovery, which\n\n16\n\nmay not be the same as what I typically do.\n\n17\n\ndo not.\n\n18\n\nrequirements.\n\n19\n\nthree months' time.\n\n20\n\nCastel, Failla, Engelmayer, Schofield, Liman, and\n\n21\n\nlike fact discovery done within four months, 120 days.\n\n22\n\nthen there are a few judges who don't seem to have the\n\n23\n\nindividual preferences stated in their own scheduling\n\n24\n\norders that they like to put in place.\n\n25\n\nSome of them\n\nJudge Gardephe has the most stringent\nHe generally likes fact discovery done in\nJudges, as I have reviewed it, Nathan,\n\nAnd\n\nGiven that I guess the majority of the district\n\nEFTA02846357\n\n", "char_count": 1403}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 38 of 67\n38\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\njudges whose cases these are ultimately like to see fact\n\n3\n\ndiscovery within no more than four months' time, 120 days,\n\n4\n\nand that pretty much accords with the range that I would --\n\n5\n\nI might go a little longer in some cases if they're really\n\n6\n\ncomplex, I might go five or six, but four or less is\n\n7\n\ncertainly fine with me.\n\n8\n\nshouldn't go beyond the 120 days for fact discovery.\n\n9\n\nIt seems to me for starters I\n\nNow, let me just say this about any discovery\nA couple of things.\n\nOne, it is not\n\n10\n\ndeadlines that I set.\n\n11\n\nuncommon for lawyers to ask for extensions.\n\n12\n\ngeneral philosophy and approach with respect to requested\n\n13\n\ndiscovery extensions.\n\n14\n\nefforts to get discovery done, if something outside your\n\n15\n\ncontrol holds it up, you know, you're looking for documents\n\n16\n\nfrom a third party who's being recalcitrant, someone falls\n\n17\n\nill, you know, something happens that really is not a\n\n18\n\nmatter of the parties not trying hard and counsel not\n\n19\n\ntrying hard, I'm reasonably generous about extensions.\n\n20\n\nit looks like you've been sitting on your hands, not really\n\n21\n\ntrying, then I'm less generous about extensions.\n\n22\n\nask for an extension, expect to show me why you need it,\n\n23\n\nthat there's some good reason for it.\n\n24\n25\n\nHere is my\n\nIf you've been making diligent\n\nIf\n\nSo if you\n\nSettlement is another reason why it might make\nsense to extend the deadlines, even to stay deadlines,\n\nEFTA02846358\n\n", "char_count": 1543}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n1\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 39 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n39\n\n2\n\ndepending upon what's going on.\n\n3\n\nwasting resources if cases are legitimately capable of\n\n4\n\nbeing settled and if parties are seriously working on it\n\n5\n\nand have some degree of optimism.\n\n6\n\nthere's no reason to stay a case or put things on hold or\n\n7\n\nextend out deadlines; but if things get on track and you\n\n8\n\nreally want to focus on that instead of spending the\n\n9\n\nresources on discovery, especially if it's joint, you come\n\n10\n\nto me together and say, \"This is what we are doing,\" I will\n\n11\n\ncertainly take a good look at that and may well move your\n\n12\n\ndeadlines out to give you a window to try to get the case\n\n13\n\nresolved.\n\n14\n\nI don't want people to be\n\nIf it looks pointless,\n\nThe other point I would make about discovery\n\n15\n\ndeadlines is especially when settlement is a possibility is\n\n16\n\nthat there is no magic about how discovery must be\n\n17\n\nstructured.\n\n18\n\nAnd it makes sense you want documents produced before\n\n19\n\ndepositions so you can put the documents in front of the\n\n20\n\nwitnesses at depositions; everyone understands that.\n\n21\n\nthere may be reasons why it makes sense to do something\n\n22\n\nearlier and something else later, including the cost of it.\n\n23\n\nIf you're trying to save some resources and you think some\n\n24\n\nparticular discovery is more costly, you want to put it\n\n25\n\nout, if an expert would be really useful for some reason,\n\nPeople tend to go in kind of a lockstep order.\n\nBut\n\nEFTA02846359\n\n", "char_count": 1533}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n1\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\nPage 40 of 67\n40\n\n2\n\nusually that starts out in the process.\n\nHere I'm not sure\n\n3\n\nhow that works with this concept of a fund and claims.\n\n4\n\nthere's no absolute reason why you must go exactly in a\n\n5\n\ncertain order.\n\n6\n\ndone by a certain point in time, not how did you get there.\n\n7\n\nSo if you want to modify interim deadlines among yourselves\n\n8\n\nby stipulation, that's fine with me if the end comes in the\n\n9\n\nsame place.\n\n10\n\namend, if I set a deadline, again, most of these judges\n\n11\n\nhave or many of them have sample scheduling orders that\n\n12\n\nhave 30 days.\n\n13\n\nsense if there's really a potential for amendment because\n\n14\n\nyou at least, I would think, would need to serve initial\n\n15\n\ndocument requests for interrogatories and get the responses\n\n16\n\nback.\n\n17\n\nsomething -- and you can always request to move an interim\n\n18\n\ndeadline if you can't get them to step on it -- what I care\n\n19\n\nabout more is where the end date comes out, where you're\n\n20\n\nall ready to move onto the next stage.\n\nBut\n\nWhat we usually look for is are you all\n\nSo, for example, on a deadline for a motion to\n\nTo me that doesn't make a huge amount of\n\nBut if you want to by stipulation agree to move\n\n21\n\nSo I'm going to start with that end date of 120\n\n22\n\ndays in most of the cases, and I'll hear about exceptions\n\n23\n\nwhen there should be exceptions, and then talk about\n\n24\n\ninterim deadlines within that period.\n\n25\n\nto have been agreed in Ms. Kaplan's case.\n\nThat 120 days seems\nThere seems to\n\nEFTA02846360\n\n", "char_count": 1575}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 41 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nhave been different proposals set forward in Ms. Wang's\n\n3\n\ncases.\n\n4\n\nabout that four-month period.\n\nDefendants were saying\n\n5\n\ninstead of June 10, June 30.\n\nI'm not sure I understand\n\n6\n\nwhat the difference is realistically between June 10 and\n\n7\n\nJune 30.\n\n8\n\nbe huge at this point in the game.\n\n9\n\nagreeing on June 10 there and saying June 30?\n\n10\n\ncase with Mr.\n\n11\n\nWhy did you kick it out beyond June 10?\n\n12\n\n41\n\nPlaintiff was proposing June 10, which would be\n\nIt's 20 days different.\n\nIt doesn't seem to me to\nWhy are you not\nAnd in the\n\nI've got June 30 as the agree date.\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nSure.\n\nSo for -- I agree that the\n\n13\n\n20 days doesn't really matter as much with respect to that\n\n14\n\none deadline.\n\n15\n\nkind of sequential over the whole period.\n\n16\n\ndifferences we had that then impacted going backwards was,\n\n17\n\nyou know -- and some of the district judges do have this; I\n\n18\n\ndon't understand it.\n\n19\n\ninsisted that expert reports coincide with the completion\n\n20\n\nof fact discovery.\n\n21\n\ndiscovery first and then, say, have 30 days for experts to\n\n22\n\nthen, based on all discovery, once it's completed, render\n\n23\n\ninitial reports and then have, in a case where it's not the\n\n24\n\nmost simple expert testimony, which this is not among\n\n25\n\nthose, in our view, have another 30 days for rebuttal\n\nThe difference with Ms. Wang that we had was\nAnd one of the\n\nThey insist -- Ms. Wang's firm\n\nI don't get that.\n\nYou should finish\n\nEFTA02846361\n\n", "char_count": 1554}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 42 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\nWe had disagreement on that.\n\n42\n\n2\n\nreports.\n\n3\n\neverything from the start back to that point.\nMR. WINTER:\n\n4\n\nIt kind of impacted\n\nJust to be clear, we weren't saying\n\n5\n\nthat the expert discovery had to be finished by fact\n\n6\n\ndiscovery; we were following the approach that the district\n\n7\n\njudges had, which is fact discovery within four months, and\n\n8\n\nthen that ends also with the disclosures of the names of\n\n9\n\nthe experts, and then an additional period of time for the\n\n10\n\nexpert discovery.\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nNo, both of your proposals -- just in\n\n12\n\nyour case, Ms. Wang, both your proposals have an expert\n\n13\n\ndiscovery period following the close of fact discovery.\n\n14\n\nMS. WANG:\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n16\n\nRight.\nYou had June 10 and July 27.\n\nYou had\n\nJune 30 and August 31.\n\n17\n\nMS. WANG:\n\n18\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes.\nSo just starting with the June 10 and\n\n19\n\nJune 30 -- and I'll also note that the parties seem to have\n\n20\n\nagreed with June 30 in the five cases that Mr.\n\n21\n\nWhy June 30 when you've got all these judges that are\n\n22\n\nsaying --\n\n23\n\nMR.\n\n:\n\nhas.\n\nYour Honor, we proposed 120 days,\n\n24\n\nand we're trying to bring to you an agreement.\n\n25\n\npersuade counsel to agree to the 120 days.\n\nI couldn't\n\nI, like you,\n\nEFTA02846362\n\n", "char_count": 1330}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 43 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nthought okay, 20 days is not the biggest deal, so to the\n\n3\n\nextent that we can agree.\n\n4\n\ndays, and so --\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n43\n\nBut we would much prefer 120\n\nAll right, look, unless we have a\n\n6\n\ncase with an exception, I'm going to go with the 120 days,\n\n7\n\nwhich will take us to, I'm assuming June 10.\n\n8\n\npeople came up with that date, I'm assuming that is the\n\n9\n\n120-day mark.\n\n10\n\ncan get an extension based on an actual need.\n\n11\n12\n13\n\nAnd, like I said, if you really need it, you\n\nHold on for a minute on expert discovery -- we'll\ntalk about that separately.\nThe case where Ms. Maxwell has been named --\n\n14\n15\n\nAnd so many\n\nthat's the -THE COURT:\n\nRight, right.\n\nThat case, that\n\n16\n\nmotion, is in front of me.\n\n17\n\nI haven't taken a thorough look at it.\n\n18\n\nis I'll likely grant the motion.\n\nI don't think it ought to\n\n19\n\nhold up the discovery schedule.\n\nIf there really is certain\n\n20\n\ndiscovery in that case where you are concerned that if an\n\n21\n\nattorney for Ms. Maxwell shows up on the scene is going to\n\n22\n\nwant to redo a deposition, you should be talking in that\n\n23\n\nparticular case about a scheduling of a particular\n\n24\n\ndeposition or something so it doesn't have to be redone.\n\n25\n\nAll right.\n\nI've taken a quick look at it.\nMy initial reaction\n\nBut I don't think that that should alter the\n\nEFTA02846363\n\n", "char_count": 1421}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 44 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nbasic time frame unless and until something happens that\n\n3\n\nthrows it off course.\n\n4\n\n44\n\nAs I understand on that case -- and I don't really\n\n5\n\nwant to hear argument on that motion particularly -- but I\n\n6\n\ngather you have made efforts to locate her and have been\n\n7\n\nunable to do so?\n\n8\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nThat's correct, your Honor.\n\nWe --\n\n9\n\nthrough investigation and also the other sources that we\n\n10\n\nhad of information of where she has been living.\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes, I'm likely going to approve the\n\n12\n\nalternate service, and I'll try to do that relatively soon.\n\n13\n\nIf I've had a problem with it, I will let counsel know; if\n\n14\n\nI have a change of heart before I -- you're suddenly going\n\n15\n\n(indiscernible).\n\n16\n\nAll right, so amendments, deadlines for\n\n17\n\namendments.\n\n18\n\nalready done them, great.\n\n19\n\nthem, within two weeks of today would be, I think, sensible\n\n20\n\nfor everybody.\n\nFirst of all, initial disclosures, if you've\nIf you haven't already done\n\nDoes anybody have a problem with that?\n\n21\n\nMR.\n\n:\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\n22\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\n23\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nNo.\n\n24\n\ntoday is what?\n\n25\n\nfor initial disclosures.\n\nAll right.\n\nSo two weeks from\n\nToday is what, February 11?\n\nSo February 25\n\nOnce you get in the initial\n\nEFTA02846364\n\n", "char_count": 1364}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n1\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 45 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n45\n\n2\n\ndisclosures, which you already have in some cases, you\n\n3\n\nshould know what it is you need to ask for that you haven't\n\n4\n\nalready gotten.\n\n5\n\ninitial document requests and your initial interrogatories.\n\n6\n\nI will let you all go outside of Local Rule 33.3A -- is it\n\n7\n\nA? -- with the three categories of interrogatories.\n\n8\n\nfirst category of interrogatories, those really basic ones;\n\n9\n\nand the second category, sort of what you ask throughout\n\n10\n\nthe rest of discovery; and the last category, the\n\n11\n\ncontention interrogatories, I'll let you skip the first\n\n12\n\ncategory to have things move a little bit more efficiently.\n\n13\n\nI really don't like those objections where you refuse to\n\n14\n\nanswer because it goes outside the local rule.\n\n15\n\none has to do is serve another set, and then you have to\n\n16\n\nanswer.\n\n17\n\nup a little bit.\n\n18\n\nimproperly.\n\n19\n\nnarrative responses; you know, be sensible.\n\n20\n\nthat will help the parties figure out if there is a\n\n21\n\npotential amendment before the need for a 3(b)(6) witness,\n\n22\n\nhopefully.\n\nSo I want a deadline for getting out your\n\nSo it seems silly.\n\nThe\n\nBecause all\n\nThat ought to help speed you\n\nThat doesn't mean use interrogatories\n\nDon't ask interrogatories that call for long,\nBut hopefully\n\n23\n\nSo you get in your initial disclosures.\n\nSome\n\n24\n\nalready have; others will have them by the 25th.\n\n25\n\ndeadlines for getting out your initial document requests\n\nThe\n\nEFTA02846365\n\n", "char_count": 1534}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 46 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n46\n\n2\n\nand interrogatories should be soon after that.\n\nAnd, you\n\n3\n\nknow, a week after that would be March 3; two weeks after\n\n4\n\nthat would be March 10.\n\n5\n\nthose out, just the requests for things?\n\nIs there any reason you can't get\n\n6\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n7\n\nquestion about that, your Honor.\n\n8\n\nwe even submitted to your Honor a joint proposed discovery\n\n9\n\nschedule with discovery requests.\n\n10\n\nhow we strongly found that to be improper.\n\n11\n\ndeadline be for those?\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n13\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n14\n\nThat's fine.\n\nAnd I do have a\n\nMs. Wang served us before\n\nI'm not going to rehash\nWhat should the\n\nRight.\nWe agreed that, to avoid burdening\n\nyour Honor, we agreed we'll\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\n16\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right.\n\nOkay.\n\nOkay.\n\n-- give it by February 28, but\n\nHold on.\n\nAny issue -- if I set a\n\n18\n\ndeadline for the requests to go out, any problem with\n\n19\n\nhaving those deemed to have been served as of that date?\n\n20\n\nMS. WANG:\n\nWell, your Honor, I just want to say we\n\n21\n\nvery carefully and thoroughly conducted a Rule 26(f) on\n\n22\n\nJanuary 8, and we then served discovery requests, which the\n\n23\n\nrules allow for, on January 15.\n\n24\n\nrespond in 30 days.\n\n25\n\nthey would respond by February 28.\n\nWe didn't say you have to\n\nWe came to an agreement with them that\nSo I don't see why we\n\nEFTA02846366\n\n", "char_count": 1427}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n47\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n1\n2\n\nPage 47 of 67\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\ncan't stick to the agreement.\nWe're also going to get document requests from\n\n3\n\nThey've agreed\n\n4\n\nthem and respond as quickly as possible.\n\n5\n\nthat they would respond by the 28th, by February 28th, so I\n\n6\n\ndon't see -No problem with that?\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n8\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nThat's fine, but I do want to\n\nYes, they did say 30 days.\n\nAnd I'm happy to\n\n9\n\ncorrect.\n\n10\n\nshare all correspondence with your Honor where we said,\n\n11\n\nwell, we need more time.\n\n12\n\nthe Court now -- that it stood to reason that, since your\n\n13\n\nHonor had said that one of the things that should be\n\n14\n\nnegotiated between counsel and then addressed with the\n\n15\n\nCourt were initial service of discovery requests -- that\n\n16\n\nwas in your order -- that it didn't make sense to us that\n\n17\n\nyou could already serve requests and it was improper.\n\n18\n\nwould like the additional time, actually.\nTHE COURT:\n\n19\n\nAnd we thought -- and I can ask\n\nHold on.\n\nSo I\n\nIf you've already agreed\n\n20\n\nthat you can respond to these things by February 28, is\n\n21\n\nthere some reason you cannot?\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\ndone.\n\nIt's very burdensome.\n\nIt can be\n\nIf we had a little more time, it would be better.\nTHE COURT:\n\nIs it burdensome to the extent that\n\nyou feel you need to negotiate the scope, in which case you\n\nEFTA02846367\n\n", "char_count": 1393}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 48 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nshould be conferring in good faith to negotiate the scope?\n\n3\n4\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nWe will do so.\n\n48\n\nThat is part of\n\nthe problem.\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWell, respond to the extent you're\n\n6\n\nable to do so by the 28th, since you've already agreed to\n\n7\n\nthat.\n\n8\n\ngeneral, if you have -- what do I have here on these\n\n9\n\ndifferent proposals?\n\n10\n\nother.\n\n11\n\nagreeing to serve by March 12, is that right?\n\n12\n\nthis right, counsel?\n\n13\n\nI'm not going to undo that agreement.\n\nLet me set them out next to each\n\nYou have March 12 for the most part; you're\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n14\n\nHonor's looking at.\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAm I reading\n\nI'm sorry, I don't know what your\n\nRequests -- I'm sorry -- a deadline\n\n16\n\nfor service of initial document requests and\n\n17\n\ninterrogatories.\n\n18\n\nproposals.\n\n19\n\nto each other.\n\n20\n\nwere agreeing to do that by March 12?\n\n21\n\nAnd in\n\nYou gave me different variations of\n\nI'm trying to summarize them and put them next\nAm I looking at the right date, that you\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n22\n\nMs. Wang's actions?\n\n23\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n24\n\nMS. WANG:\n\n25\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nWith -- I trust you mean in\n\nNo.\nNo.\nThat's my confusion.\n\nEFTA02846368\n\n", "char_count": 1236}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 49 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nMS. WANG:\n\n49\n\nI don't believe for most of our judges\n\n3\n\nwe only needed to put in a discovery deadline.\n\n4\n\nas your Honor advised, we can sort of work throughout\n\n5\n\nwithin those four months how things are done.\n\n6\n\nbelieve there's a deadline for that, but -- (Stopped\n\n7\n\ntalking.)\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\n8\n\nAnd then,\n\nBut I don't\n\nYour Honor, this is Sigrid McCawley\n\n9\n\nagain.\n\nOur five, we did have for the initial\n\n10\n\ninterrogatories and document requests, the March 12 date.\n\n11\n\nAnd then they had proposed -- they didn't agree with that\n\n12\n\none because 60 days from the entry.\n\n13\n14\n\nI thought a few of you had proposed\n\nMS. KAPLAN:\n\nYes, we had proposed 30 days from\n\nMarch 12.\n\n15\n16\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nentry of the order, as well, your Honor.\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWhich would be March 12?\n\n18\n\nMS. KAPLAN:\n\nIf I'm looking at the date correctly,\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\n19\n20\n\nyes.\nSo, look, here's what makes\n\n21\n\nsense to me.\n\nYou get your initial disclosures done.\n\nIf\n\n22\n\nyou've already done them, great; if not, by two weeks.\n\n23\n\nweeks is February 25.\n\n24\n\ngo out within two weeks after you get back -- after you get\n\n25\n\nin the initial disclosures.\n\nTwo\n\nAt most, the initial requests should\n\nYou see what you've got, you\n\nEFTA02846369\n\n", "char_count": 1327}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 50 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nfigure out what else you need, you serve your requests.\n\n3\n\nyou can do it sooner, that would be great.\n\nIf you can do\n\n4\n\nit within a week of that, that's March 3.\n\nIf you need two\n\n5\n\nweeks, March 10.\n\n6\n\nare proposing March 12.\n\n7\n\ndocument requests and interrogatories.\n\n8\n\nagreed to something, in one case perhaps or in a series of\n\n9\n\ncases -- I'm not sure -- where the requests were served\n\n10\n\nalready and you've negotiated a time to respond, live with\n\n11\n\nthat.\n\n12\n\nyou'll raise them.\n\n13\n\nI'm sorry -- by March 10, you're going to get in responses\n\n14\n\nto those hopefully by April 9.\n\n50\nIf\n\nI'll go with March 10, since a lot of you\nSo March 10 for service of initial\nIf you have already\n\nIf you have issues that come up along the way,\n\n15\n\nSo if you get them out by March 12 --\n\nNow, here's the thing:\n\nthe motion to amend\n\n16\n\ndeadline.\n\nYou're getting in those responses by April 9.\n\n17\n\nIt doesn't make sense to me to have a motion to amend\n\n18\n\ndeadline of a month earlier than that.\n\n19\n\nreally make sense.\n\n20\n\nabout that.\n\n21\n\nif there's a proposed amendment and your adversary isn't\n\n22\n\ngoing to fight it, isn't going to oppose it if you make a\n\n23\n\nmotion, I'm not going to require you to make the motion.\n\n24\n\nIt's silly.\n\n25\n\nyou think you have a potential amendment, draft it up, send\n\nIt just doesn't\n\nSo I am -- and here's another thing\n\nif there's a motion to amend -- I'm sorry --\n\nThere's not going to be an opposition.\n\nSo if\n\nEFTA02846370\n\n", "char_count": 1564}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 51 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n51\n\n2\n\nit to your adversary saying, \"Would you oppose it?\"\n\n3\n\nanswer is, \"No, I wouldn't oppose it,\" just let me know\n\n4\n\nthere would not be an opposition.\n\n5\n\nas consenting; it's just not opposing.\n\n6\n\ngoing to be an opposition, I'll just take it for filing; I\n\n7\n\nwill not require a motion.\n\n8\n\nopposition, then I need a motion for leave to amend.\n\n9\n\nIf the\n\nIt's not the same thing\nIf there's not\n\nIf there is going to be an\n\nSo the deadline I want to set is for motions.\n\nSo\n\n10\n\nyou have to back it up in your head and think, I have to\n\n11\n\ndraft it, send it to my adversary, give him a chance to let\n\n12\n\nme know if he's objecting or not; if there is an objection,\n\n13\n\nI've got to draft up a motion.\n\n14\n\nresponses to the initial document requests and\n\n15\n\ninterrogatories in the middle of April and you need time to\n\n16\n\nfigure out if there is an amendment, logically, end of\n\n17\n\nApril makes sense for motions to amend.\n\n18\n\nset April 30 for that deadline.\n\n19\n\nwith that?\n\n20\n\nMR.\n\n21\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo if you're getting in the\n\nI'd be inclined to\n\nAnybody have a problem\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\n:\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\nAll right, April 30.\n\nAnd the reason\n\n23\n\nwhy I'm doing it and not sticking with the earlier date is\n\n24\n\nbecause I know we have at least one amendment in one case.\n\n25\n\nI'm seeing different names of different defendants in these\n\nEFTA02846371\n\n", "char_count": 1473}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n1\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 52 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n52\n\n2\n\ncases.\n\nI think there is a possibility in at least some of\n\n3\n\nthe cases.\n\n4\n\nthe date comes, the date goes, there's no amendment.\n\n5\n\nIf there's not going to be an amendment, fine;\n\nIf you need more time to figure out if there is an\n\n6\n\namendment, put your hand in the air before that date comes\n\n7\n\nand ask for it to be extended.\n\n8\n\nparticular, of all the deadlines in a case scheduling\n\n9\n\norder, can come back and bite you because under Rule 15,\n\n10\n\namendments are very freely granted in the court.\n\n11\n\nRule 16, if you miss a deadline in a scheduling order, you\n\n12\n\nhave to show good cause why you couldn't have met the\n\n13\n\ndeadline.\n\n14\n\nyou're not in Rule 15 land anymore, you are in Rule 16 land\n\n15\n\nfirst.\n\n16\n\nis freely given standard can go out the window.\n\n17\n\nSo if something comes up that you really could not have\n\n18\n\nanticipated, some new name of some new person or new entity\n\n19\n\nyou couldn't have known about comes up late, you'll have\n\n20\n\ngood cause and you'll be able to meet a Rule 16 standard.\n\n21\n\nBut if it's something where it's right there in the\n\n22\n\ndocument staring you in the face earlier, someone might say\n\n23\n\nhey, you could have anticipated that sooner, you may be\n\n24\n\nstuck under Rule 16 not being able to show good cause for a\n\n25\n\nlate amendment.\n\nThat deadline in\n\nBut under\n\nSo if you miss a deadline for a motion to amend,\n\nIf you can't show good cause, that leave to amend\nAll right?\n\nSo if you really think you might need to\n\nEFTA02846372\n\n", "char_count": 1585}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 53 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\namend and you really are worried about that deadline, say\n\n3\n\nsomething before it runs, don't wait until later because\n\n4\n\nyou may end up being caught.\n\n5\n\nreason to move it out a little bit further so we try to\n\n6\n\navoid those issues.\n\n7\n\nAll right?\n\n53\n\nIt's another\n\nAll right, close of fact discovery, June 10.\n\nI'll\n\n8\n\ndeal with any exceptions, if you think your case has some\n\n9\n\nextraordinary reason why these shouldn't be the deadlines,\n\n10\n\nseparately.\n\n11\n\nBut for the most part, June 10.\n\nAnd expert discovery, what kind of experts are we\n\n12\n\ntalking about here?\n\n13\n\nexperts?\n\n14\n15\n\nMS. WANG:\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n24\n25\n\nAnd how about defendants' side, what\n\nkind of experts do you think you might --\n\n22\n23\n\nAnd that's the same for us, as\n\nwell.\n\n20\n21\n\nAll right, anyone else have any other\n\nsort of experts in mind?\n\n18\n19\n\nFor my plaintiffs, it would be\n\nemotional harm, mental health experts.\n\n16\n17\n\nOn plaintiffs' side, what kind of\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nIt would be rebuttal experts, your\n\nHonor.\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\nSo are you confident that you\n\nwould have such experts; it's just a matter of waiting to\n\nEFTA02846373\n\n", "char_count": 1248}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 53, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 54 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nsee what plaintiffs' experts say?\n\n3\n\nokay, you would want to have examinations done?\n\n4\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n54\nSo, in other words,\n\nYes, correct.\n\nDo you want for the examinations to\n\n6\n\nhave the plaintiffs' reports in hand before the\n\n7\n\nexaminations are done?\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n8\n\nThat's exactly right, your Honor,\n\n9\n\nto understand specifically.\n\n10\n\nwe're having, discovery hasn't started yet in earnest, so\n\n11\n\nit's not something to fully address now, but is a lack of\n\n12\n\nunderstanding of what are the alleged damages, in which\n\n13\n\ncategory, which is, unfortunately, a sneak preview,\n\n14\n\nsomething that I don't see eye to eye with, the\n\n15\n\ncompleteness of initial disclosures in that regard on\n\n16\n\nplaintiffs' side.\n\n17\n\nthose reasons and others, I would like to see the expert\n\n18\n\nreports first and have an opportunity to do a full\n\n19\n\nrebuttal.\n\n20\n\nI mean, one of the issues\n\nSo to answer your question, yes, for\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right, and on plaintiffs' side,\n\n21\n\nthis doesn't sound like the kind of expert that would need\n\n22\n\nfully discovery before you can have your clients examined\n\n23\n\nand have a report about emotional distress, is that right?\n\n24\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nThat's correct.\n\n25\n\nMR.\n\nI think that's right, your Honor.\n\n:\n\nEFTA02846374\n\n", "char_count": 1370}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 54, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 55 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n55\n\nBecause usually, in most cases I\n\n3\n\nwould say get the fact discovery done, and then 30 days\n\n4\n\nafter the close of fact discovery, have an expert report.\n\n5\n\nThat's not really what's needed here?\n\n6\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\n7\n\nMS. KAPLAN:\n\n8\n\nMS. WANG:\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nNo.\n\nThat's correct, your Honor.\n\nThat's correct.\nIs there any case represented by any\n\n10\n\nplaintiffs' counsel where you don't think you could get out\n\n11\n\nthe expert report the same time the fact discovery is done?\n\n12\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI think that's fine.\n\nDoes anyone think that's going to be\n\n14\n\na problem, to get it done by June 1?\n\n15\n\ndefendants 30 days after that, and we're not too slowed\n\n16\n\ndown.\n\n17\n\nMR.\n\n18\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n19\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n21\n\nMR.\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n:\n\nThen I can have\n\nOkay.\nYes?\nRight.\n\nOkay.\n:\n\nThank you.\nJune 10 for plaintiffs' expert\n\n23\n\nreports.\n\n24\n\nThe good thing about this schedule is you don't end up with\n\n25\n\nexperts in August.\n\nThirty days thereafter would take us to July 10.\n\nHaving experts in August is almost a\n\nEFTA02846375\n\n", "char_count": 1176}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 55, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 56 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nguarantee of falling behind on a schedule.\n\n3\n\nrebuttal experts.\n\n4\n\nif they're going to be deposed.\n\n5\n\ndiscovery, July 31.\n\n6\n\n56\nSo July 10 for\n\nEnd of July to get these people deposed\nJuly 31?\n\nClose of all\n\nI would not be surprised if some of these dates\n\n7\n\nmove, but that's not an invitation to go slowly.\n\nThe only\n\n8\n\ninvitation to go slowly is if the settlement process heats\n\n9\n\nup, and then I expect you to let me know about that and\n\n10\n\nthat it's realistic and that there's, you know, agreement\n\n11\n\non the need to slow down the cases to try to get the\n\n12\n\nsettlement process moving.\n\n13\n\nstill stalled, I don't see any reason why we can't stick to\n\n14\n\na schedule like this.\n\nBut, other than that, if that's\n\n15\n\nNow, on cases where there's any other\n\n16\n\nextraordinary circumstances, I already addressed the one\n\n17\n\nwith the additional defendant who hasn't been served.\n\n18\n\nOther than the scope of discovery requests, is there any\n\n19\n\nreason why in any of these defendants or anybody else\n\n20\n\nthinks there should be a different schedule?\n\n21\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\nOkay.\n\nWith respect to the scope of\n\n23\n\ndiscovery, I anticipate some discovery disputes.\n\nAgain,\n\n24\n\nit's not an invitation; I just expect that they will come\n\n25\n\nalong.\n\nI enforce the good-faith conference requirement.\n\nEFTA02846376\n\n", "char_count": 1442}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 56, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 57 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n57\n\n2\n\nBy that I mean you have to really talk to each other, and\n\n3\n\nyou have to really see if you can resolve your discovery\n\n4\n\ndisputes or at least narrow them before you bring them to\n\n5\n\nmy attention.\n\n6\n\nemail and you don't get a response right away.\n\n7\n\nyou pick up the phone, you talk to each other, you work\n\n8\n\nthrough them.\n\n9\n\nhappen -- I get a letter, motion to compel, all this\n\n10\n\ndetail; I get an opposition, all this detail; I get a\n\n11\n\nreply saying in light of what's said in opposition, never\n\n12\n\nmind on some of these issues.\n\n13\n\nwasted your time.\n\n14\n\ngood-faith conferences.\n\n15\n\nrequests, have that conversation.\n\nWhat's the heart of\n\n16\n\nwhat you're really looking for?\n\nHow can we get you that\n\n17\n\nwithout undue burden?\n\n18\n\nyou this first and can we produce the rest on a rolling\n\n19\n\nbasis?\n\n20\n\nto ways to, you know, alleviate that burden.\n\n21\n\nThat doesn't mean you send somebody an\n\nRight?\n\nPet peeve -- don't have this\n\nI've wasted my time, you've\n\nThat just tells me there's a failure of\nSo, really, on any discovery\n\nHow can we prioritize?\n\nHere's why this is a burden.\n\nWith respect to ESI, you have been -- I'm not sure\nif I've seen things come across my desk or not.\n\n23\n\nbeen talking about protocols?\n\n25\n\nCan we get\n\nHere are some ideas\n\n22\n\n24\n\nIt means\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nYou've\n\nWe've been negotiating with,\n\nagain, each group of plaintiffs' counsel, protective order,\n\nEFTA02846377\n\n", "char_count": 1516}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 57, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 58 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nand have agreed that it makes sense to have a standard ESI\n\n3\n\nprotocol.\n\n4\n\nthere should be a standard Clawback Provision in the\n\n5\n\nprotective order.\n\n6\n\ninability to come to agreement on those issues.\n\n7\n8\n9\n\n58\n\nAnd that -- I believe we're in agreement that\n\nSo as I sit here now, I don't foresee an\n\nDon't know how many email accounts you've got\naccess to?\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nYeah, it's -- among the many\n\n10\n\ndiscussions that counsel need to have with each other are\n\n11\n\nwhat they think needs to be searched, why, etc.\n\n12\n\nanswer your question, I don't know how many there are that\n\n13\n\nmatter, if any.\n\n14\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo to\n\nWell, if it was something in Jeffrey\n\n15\n\nEpstein's control, presumably it needs to be searched, and\n\n16\n\nyou're going to have to figure out how to get access.\n\n17\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n18\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nCorrect.\n\nBut if you've got other individuals,\n\n19\n\nif they're named defendants and they have email accounts or\n\n20\n\nother social media accounts --\n\n21\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nI only represent the co-executors\n\n22\n\nof the estate related to the alleged torts.\n\nI mean, we've\n\n23\n\nheard a lot about these other people who are out there,\n\n24\n\njust to be clear for\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThere are some other defendants named\n\nEFTA02846378\n\n", "char_count": 1344}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 58, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 59 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nin some of these papers\n\n3\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nWell, there are entities in\n\n4\n\nMr.\n\n5\n\nstill looking into it -- I don't think that that changes\n\n6\n\nthe landscape in those actions in terms of what emails are\n\n7\n\npotentially subject to review.\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n9\n\nAnd what I -- to my knowledge -- and I'm\n\nBut you're representing these\n\nentities?\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n10\n11\n\n'.\n\n59\n\nYes, correct.\n\nThey're all part of\n\nthe estate.\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\n13\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nI was speaking more about\n\n14\n\nknow, there's been discussion about the addition of\n\n15\n\nMaxwell,\n\n16\n17\n\nyou\n\nand others -THE COURT:\n\nNo, I wasn't assuming you were\n\nrepresenting that person.\n\nOkay.\n\n18\n\nMS. KAPLAN:\n\nJudge Freeman\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes.\n\n20\n\nMS. KAPLAN:\n\n-- one thing that may be helpful --\n\n21\n\nand we've encountered this issue in my Charlottesville\n\n22\n\nlitigation recently -- is it would be helpful to know from\n\n23\n\nthe estate whether there are any email accounts or other\n\n24\n\naccounts that Mr. Epstein was -- were in his name that they\n\n25\n\ndo not have passwords to.\n\nIn other words, do they actually\n\nEFTA02846379\n\n", "char_count": 1193}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 59, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 60 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nhave access to be able to search all the email accounts\n\n3\n\nthat he had, any social media accounts, texts, etc.\n\n60\n\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nIt's a conference issue first.\n\n5\n\nMS. KAPLAN:\n\nOkay.\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI mean, look, ESI is a subject you\n\n7\n\nshould be having conversation on.\n\nYou don't want to have\n\n8\n\nrequests, be responding in a limited way, have plaintiffs'\n\n9\n\ncounsel surprised at the way in which you're responding,\n\n10\n\nhave them jump up and down and say there were a million\n\n11\n\nother accounts that should have been searched.\n\n12\n\nif you see something you anticipate you're not going to be\n\n13\n\nable to do everything that's being asked for, well, you\n\n14\n\nshould be having conversation.\n\n15\n\naccounts and you're concerned there may not be passwords,\n\n16\n\nyou should be having conversations, try to talk about\n\n17\n\nthose issues.\n\n18\n\nconferred fully in good faith, you can't work it out,\n\n19\n\nwhoever's got the issue, put a letter on ECF and tell me\n\n20\n\nwhat the issue is.\n\n21\n\nresolve it on paper, I will.\n\n22\n\nor something if it's easy.\n\n23\n\ndeal with that issue.\n\n24\n\ncase by case; they might not.\n\n25\n\nthe board or in a number of cases, we'll do something like\n\nYou know,\n\nIf you know of certain\n\nif you run into a discovery issue, you have\n\nI'll wait for a response.\n\nIf I can\n\nI might just do a text order\n\nOr I'll set up a conference to\n\nThese issues might start varying\nIf I'm seeing issues across\n\nEFTA02846380\n\n", "char_count": 1522}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 60, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n2\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 61 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n61\n\nthis.\n\n3\n\nIf I'm seeing a discrete issue in a particular\n\n4\n\ncase, I might have a conference just in that case to deal\n\n5\n\nwith it, if I need to.\n\n6\n\nbe able to confer.\n\n7\n\nthings so far.\n\n8\n\ndiscovery disputes and get them at least as narrow as\n\n9\n\npossible.\n\n10\n\nsend me one of these letters that's all, you know, waving\n\n11\n\nyour arms around in general terms.\n\n12\n\nparticular request where you think the response is\n\n13\n\ninadequate, one side or the other, tell me what the\n\n14\n\nrequest is, tell me what the response was, tell me what\n\n15\n\nyour discussion has been, tell me where you're stuck; you\n\n16\n\nknow, let me look at it, let me understand each side's\n\n17\n\nposition.\n\n18\n\nthat lay out here's the dispute, here's each side's\n\n19\n\nposition.\n\n20\n\nforth and back and forth endlessly is not welcome.\n\n21\n\nright.\n\n22\n\nare great.\n\n23\n\nknow, 20 letters on one dispute is unnecessary, and I hope\n\n24\n\nyou will avoid that kind of approach.\n\n25\n\nI'm hoping that you are going to\n\nYou've been able to confer about other\n\nI'm hoping you'll be able to confer on\n\nIf you really are stuck on something, don't\n\nIf there's a\n\nJoint letters on discovery are always welcome\n\nA million letters back and forth and back and\n\nOne letter, one response is fine.\n\nAll\n\nJoint letters\n\nYou know, suddenly being overwhelmed with, you\n\nIs it useful to set -- this is a rhetorical\n\nEFTA02846381\n\n", "char_count": 1466}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 61, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 62 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nquestion -- of course, it's useful -- to set a follow-up\n\n3\n\ndate for a report on how it's going, both with respect to\n\n4\n\nsettlement and with respect to discovery, just to give me\n\n5\n\nan idea of how it's going?\n\n6\n\nquestion is what's the right touch-base point?\n\n7\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n62\n\nYes, I think so.\n\nSo the\n\nWell, in terms of the claims\n\n8\n\nprogram issues, I think the next 30 days are going to have\n\n9\n\na lot of movement one way or the other.\n\n10\n\nnecessarily know that that's the case with discovery.\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI don't\n\nWell, when there is a meaningful\n\n12\n\ndevelopment, I think a report would be in order.\n\n13\n\nsomething -- I don't mean every single development, but\n\n14\n\nsomething really significant as in \"we're back on track\"\n\n15\n\nor, you know, \"we can't litigate this case anymore because\n\n16\n\nthe lawyers are not being funded,\" something significant,\n\n17\n\nregardless of any date I set, let me know.\n\n18\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo if\n\nOkay.\n\nOtherwise, maybe we gear it to when\n\n20\n\nyou're expecting to get responses in on the written\n\n21\n\ndiscovery requests, just to see how things are looking at\n\n22\n\nthat point, maybe you have a little better idea.\n\n23\n\nWith respect to deposition -- by the way, what\n\n24\n\nwas that date?\n\n25\n\nApril.\n\nThat was -- that was right, middle of\n\nWhy don't we say end of April?\n\nIf nothing else, I\n\nEFTA02846382\n\n", "char_count": 1461}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 62, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 63 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n63\n\n2\n\nget status reports.\n\n3\n\nWhatever makes the most sense.\n\n4\n\nreports, written status reports.\n\nJoint would be nice.\n\n5\n\nfact, why don't I just say that?\n\nJoint status reports in\n\n6\n\nthese different cases.\n\n7\n8\n\nI'd welcome clusters of them.\n\nMS. KAPLAN:\n\nApril 30 for status\nIn\n\nWhen you say \"joint,\" your Honor,\n\nyou mean plaintiff and defendant?\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nPlaintiff and defendant, right.\n\nSo\n\n10\n\nyou can have -- if you have five cases on plaintiffs' one\n\n11\n\ncounsel, you can send me one and so it's spread across\n\n12\n\nfive cases.\n\n13\n\nlawyers, that's lovely, but that -- you know, I don't want\n\n14\n\nto make things impossible for you.\n\n15\n\nwith defendant.\n\n16\n\nsettlement was fine.\n\n17\n\nThat's fine.\n\n18\n\nIf you can do a joint one with all the\n\nBut at least joint\n\nThe way you did the joint reports on\nI had four of them or something.\n\nWhat was I going to say?\n\nI do not remember what\n\n19\n\nI was going to say.\n\nWhat was I going to say?\n\nWas I\n\n20\n\nstart -- my clerk tells me i was starting to talk about\n\n21\n\ndepositions.\n\n22\n\ndo.\n\n23\n\npeople don't plan early enough for what's coming later.\n\n24\n\nSo if you know who needs to be deposed, you can start\n\n25\n\ntalking about it.\n\nI don't know what I was going to say.\n\nII, I\n\nSo one reason why discovery schedules get extended is\n\nYou can open your calendars, you can\n\nEFTA02846383\n\n", "char_count": 1430}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 63, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n1\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 64 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n64\n\n2\n\nstart talking about availability of witnesses.\n\n3\n\nsketch out a plan how you're going to get these things\n\n4\n\ndone by June 10.\n\n5\n\nYou can\n\nSo it sounds like May will be a month when\n\n6\n\nyou'll be involved in depositions.\n\n7\n\nrather than later what witnesses' availability would be\n\n8\n\nfor May.\n\n9\n\nwhere it may make sense to have one deposition attended by\n\n10\n\nmultiple counsel, talk about that sort of thing.\n\n11\n\nwon't be a one-day deposition; you've got too many lawyers\n\n12\n\nwho want to ask questions.\n\n13\n\nhow that should be structured, talk about it; see if you\n\n14\n\ncan come up with a plan, reserve some time for it.\n\n15\n\nyou wait until the end of April to start talking about how\n\n16\n\nyou're going to conduct depositions in May, you're going\n\n17\n\nto find II, this person's not available or this other\n\n18\n\nperson has some commitment or whatever.\n\n19\n\nFigure out sooner\n\nWith respect to someone like a 30(b)(6) witness\n\nThat\n\nHow many days it should be,\n\nBut if\n\nSo the sooner you can block out time, come up\n\n20\n\nwith, you know, a general plan of how this is all going to\n\n21\n\nhappen, the better, because otherwise, I'll be hearing at\n\n22\n\nthe end of May, \"We have two weeks left on our schedule,\n\n23\n\nand we don't have dates yet for depositions.\"\n\n24\n\n-- (indiscernible) litigation, try to avoid it by advanced\n\n25\n\nplanning.\n\nAnd that's\n\nIf any depositions involve travel, figure it\n\nEFTA02846384\n\n", "char_count": 1504}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 64, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\n1\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 65 of 67\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n65\n\n2\n\nout sooner rather than later.\n\nTry to make the plans ahead\n\n3\n\nof time.\n\n4\n\nFifth, try to find that out; try to, you know, identify\n\n5\n\nwho you're talking about.\n\n6\n\nthat's going to happen, let plaintiffs' counsel know.\n\n7\n\nwill affect the planning, it will affect overall\n\n8\n\nscheduling.\n\n9\n\nfrom that kind of communication.\n\n10\n\neffective litigation in terms of efficiency are the ones\n\n11\n\nwhere the lawyers, you know, sit down, open their\n\n12\n\ncalendars -- old-fashioned? -- you know, smartphones,\n\n13\n\nwhatever they are, and try to figure it out.\n\n14\n\nEspecially if you want to coordinate any depositions.\n\n15\n\nRight?\n\n16\n\nsooner rather than later.\n\n17\n\nOkay.\n\nIf there are witnesses who are going to take the\n\nTry to find out on your side if\nIt\n\nYou know, everybody's schedules will benefit\nAll right?\n\nThe most\n\nAll right?\n\nYou've got a lot of people; start talking about it\nAll right?\n\nAnybody have anything else for me?\n\nAre\n\n18\n\nthere any other cases where I should diverge from this\n\n19\n\nschedule in any way?\n\n20\n\nMR.\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n22\n\nMS. WANG:\n\n23\n\nanything on the schedules.\n\n24\n\nthere was one set of briefing around which we jointly\n\n25\n\nsubmitted a briefing schedule and your Honor just said\n\nProbably not, right?\n:\n\nNo, your Honor.\nAll right, I will issue --\n\nI'm sorry to interrupt.\n\nI don't have\n\nI just wanted to flag that\n\nEFTA02846385\n\n", "char_count": 1456}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 65, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\nPage 66 of 67\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nthat you had wanted an update on settlement discussions\n\n3\n\nbefore entering that order.\n\n4\n\nit's --\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n6\n\nMS. WANG:\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n66\n\nSo I can just point out that\n\nThat's fine.\n\nI know what that is.\n\nIt's in the\nThat's fine.\n\ncase.\nEven though I said I\n\ni might well set different schedules in each case,\n\n8\n\nwas\n\n9\n\nI don't really see the need to do that.\n\n10\n\nsame track.\n\n11\n\nor two of them or three or four of them end up on a\n\n12\n\ndifferent schedule as we go, but for now let's keep them\n\n13\n\nwhere they are.\n\n14\n\nconference you're going to have about discovery will help\n\n15\n\nkeep you moving along.\n\n16\n\nright?\n\nYou know, it may happen that, you know, one\n\nAnd hopefully, all of that good-faith\n\n17\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n18\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n19\n20\n\nSo you're on the\n\nIf not, you know where I am.\n\nThank you.\n\nThank you, all.\n\nsettlement fund concept.\n\nAll\n\nGood luck with the\n\nI'm rooting for you.\n\n(Whereupon, the matter is recessed.)\n\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nEFTA02846386\n\n", "char_count": 1069}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02846321", "page_number": 66, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF\n\nDocument 56\n\nFiled 02/13/20\n\n1\n\nPage 67 of 67\n67\n\n2\n3\n\nCERTI\n\nF I\n\nC A T E\n\n4\n5\n\nI, Carole Ludwig, certify that the foregoing\n\n6\n\ntranscript of proceedings in the case of VE v. Nine East\n\n7\n\n71st Street et al, Docket #19-cv-07625-AJN-DCF, was\n\n8\n\nprepared using digital transcription software and is a true\n\n9\n\nand accurate record of the proceedings.\n\n10\n11\n12\n13\n\nSignature\n\n14\n15\n\neat\n\nLade-wiz-\n\nCarole Ludwig\nDate:\n\nFebruary 13, 2020\n\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nEFTA02846387\n\n", "char_count": 512}]}