{"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_count": 43, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02839460", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02839460.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 1 of 43\n\n1\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK\nx\nUNITED STATES OF AMERICA,\nv.\n\n4\n5\n\n20-cr-330 (AJN)\n\nGHISLAINE MAXWELL,\n\n6\n\nDefendant.\n\nHearing\n\n7\n\nx\n\n8\n\nNew York, N.Y.\nNovember 23, 2021\n9:40 a.m.\n\n9\n10\n11\n\nBefore:\nHON. ALISON J. NATHAN\n\n12\n\nDistrict Judge\n\n13\nAPPEARANCES\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n\nDAMIAN\nUnited States Attorney for the\nSouthern District of New York\nBY: MAURENE COMEY\nALISON MOE\nLARA POMERANTZ\nANDREW ROHRBACH\nAssistant United States Attorneys\nHADDON\nAND\nAttorneys for Defendant\nBY: JEFFREY S. PAGLIUCA\nCHRISTIAN R. EVERDELL\nLAURA A. MENNINGER\n-andBOBBI C. STERNHEIM\nAttorney for Defendant\n\n23\n24\n25\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839460\n\n", "char_count": 779}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 2 of 43\n\n2\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n(Case called)\nTHE CLERK:\n\nCounsel, please state your name for the\n\nrecord, starting with the government.\n4\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\nGood morning, your Honor.\n\nMaureen Comey,\n\n5\n\nAlison Moe, Andrew Rohrbach, and Lara Pomerantz for the\n\n6\n\ngovernment.\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nGood morning, everyone.\n\n8\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nGood morning.\n\nBobbi C. Sternheim,\n\n9\n\nJeffrey Pagliuca, Christian Everdell, Lara Menninger for\n\n10\n\nGhislaine Maxwell, who is present at counsel table.\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nGood morning, everyone.\n\n12\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n14\n\nAll right, we are here for a final pretrial conference\n\nGood morning, your Honor.\n\nPlease be seated.\n\n15\n\nin this matter, jury selection to be completed first thing on\n\n16\n\nMonday morning, the 29th.\n\n17\n\nthe last process, at the recommendation of the jury department,\n\n18\n\nwe have kept the unexcused jurors on -- the unused jurors at\n\n19\n\nthis point on call in case we need them, and once we have our\n\n20\n\njury finally selected on the 29th, the jury department will\n\n21\n\nexcuse the remaining jurors.\n\n22\n\nmake.\n\n23\n\nI did note, counsel, after we had\n\nThat was one note I wanted to\n\nFor purposes of today's conference, there are a few --\n\n24\n\nI have tried to give written guidance on as much as I could on\n\n25\n\nthe outstanding issues.\n\nThere are a few remaining issues that\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839461\n\n", "char_count": 1452}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 3 of 43\n\n3\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nI got supplemental briefing on to discuss.\n\nThe motion in\n\nlimine 7 of the defense, which is Government Exhibit 52, I got\nsupplemental briefing on that; supplemental briefing on a few\n4\n\nexemplars of co-conspirator statements; the remaining disclosed\n\n5\n\ndefense experts perhaps, so we'll discuss that.\n\n6\n\nother things just to tick off the list, and go over logistics\n\n7\n\nfor Monday, and take your questions or hear your issues.\n\nI have a few\n\n8\n\nMs. Comey, anything before we get underway?\n\n9\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nWe do have a few issues\n\n10\n\nto raise.\n\n11\n\nneed to ask for a briefing schedule to preclude\n\n12\n\ncross-examination on certain topics of government witnesses.\n\n13\n\nOn Friday afternoon, the government conferred with defense\n\n14\n\ncounsel.\n\n15\n\nclearly improper topics for cross-examination.\n\n16\n\ndefense counsel told us that they're not in a position to tell\n\n17\n\nus that they will not cross on any of those topics.\n\n18\n\nthere are many of them and because they include things like\n\n19\n\ncriminal convictions that are beyond the scope of 609 and other\n\n20\n\npersonal information that might either identify anonymized\n\n21\n\nwitnesses or embarrass witnesses, we would ask to be able to\n\n22\n\nsubmit briefing rather than raise those issues on the public\n\n23\n\nrecord.\n\n24\n25\n\nThe first is that unfortunately I do think we will\n\nWe presented about a dozen topics that we believe are\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYesterday\n\nBecause\n\nYou can, but not until you have further\n\ndiscussion and narrow disputes, because that's going to happen.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839462\n\n", "char_count": 1681}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 4 of 43\n\n4\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nMS. COMEY:\nattempted to.\n\nYour Honor, I can assure you we've\n\nWe raised issues that we thought are clearly not\n\nproper ground for cross-examination, like arrests as a juvenile\n4\n\nfor curfew violations, misdemeanor convictions that are more\n\n5\n\nthan ten years old, things that have nothing do with\n\n6\n\ncredibility, and the defense told us that they cannot assure us\n\n7\n\nthat they will not raise those issues on cross.\n\n8\n\nneed a pretrial ruling so that we know whether we have to raise\n\n9\n\nthose things on direct to draw the sting.\n\n10\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nWe obviously\n\nYour Honor, this is not a surprise to\n\n11\n\nme that this is being raised, but this is a surprising issue, I\n\n12\n\nthink, to be raised.\n\n13\n\ngovernment wants to talk about include things that are clearly\n\n14\n\nwithin the rules, and --\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThe list, laundry list of things that the\n\nI don't want a speech.\n\nWhat I want, it\n\n16\n\nsounds like they're saying there are things that are clearly\n\n17\n\noutside of the rules, in their view.\n\n18\n\nthings that are clearly within the rules.\n\n19\n\nmature, reasonable discussion, and come to some agreement where\n\n20\n\nagreement can be had.\n\n21\n\nfaith and reasonable and based on available interpretations of\n\n22\n\nthe law, you'll submit to me in writing and I'll be happy to\n\n23\n\nresolve it.\n\n24\n25\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nAnd you say there are\nYou'll have a\n\nWhen you have disputes that are good\n\nThat's totally fine, your Honor.\n\nI\n\nguess the problem is -- and this is where we're going to end\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839463\n\n", "char_count": 1641}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 1:2O-cr-OO33O-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 5 of 43\n\n5\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nup, which is why I'm telling you this now -- we can't predict\nwhat people are going to say on either direct or\ncross-examination.\n\nAnd of course we will follow the rules.\n\n4\n\nBut here's an example:\n\nIf someone were to say on direct\n\n5\n\nexamination, \"I've never been in trouble in my entire life,\"\n\n6\n\nwell, then that opens up the whole panoply of what is or is not\n\n7\n\npermissible under Rule 609.\n\n8\n\nAnd so that's where we end up here.\n\n9\n\nfrankly, these are not issues that need to be briefed.\n\n10\n\nare issues that simply come up during trial, and if someone\n\n11\n\ndoes something that one side or the other thinks is not\n\n12\n\nappropriate, there's an objection and it's resolved.\n\n13\n\nassure you that we are not going to do anything that is outside\n\n14\n\nof the rules, and if we think it's even close, we would of\n\n15\n\ncourse approach and address the issue with the Court.\n\n16\n\nAnd I think,\nThese\n\nI can\n\nIf the government wants, I am happy to confer more\n\n17\n\nabout this.\n\n18\n\nBut I think we end up in that place, which is, these are\n\n19\n\ntrial-time decisions.\n\n20\n\nIf the government wants to brief it, they can.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat may be true, and I suspect if you\n\n21\n\nhave a conversation where the government says, you can't raise\n\n22\n\nunder the rule a juvenile conviction for -- what was it?\n\n23\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\nA curfew violation, your Honor.\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n-- a curfew violation, and you say, well,\n\n25\n\nof course it could be that they say, I've never been in trouble\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839464\n\n", "char_count": 1619}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 6 of 43\n\n6\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nin my life, I think you can come to point of agreement, can't\nyou?\nMS. COMEY:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nIndeed we told the\n\n4\n\ndefense that we by no means mean to bind the defense against\n\n5\n\nraising an issue that comes up during direct.\n\n6\n\nto know ex ante as things stand, do they have a good-faith\n\n7\n\nbasis to believe that there's a grounds for cross-examination\n\n8\n\nalong those topics.\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWe just wanted\n\nIt sounds like, I bet, this conversation\n\n10\n\ncould happen without me and everybody else in this room.\n\nBut\n\n11\n\nI'm glad to be here for you.\n\n12\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\n13\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\n14\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWhat's next?\n\n15\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\nYour Honor, the other issue was, we've\n\nThank you, your Honor.\nThank you, your Honor.\n\nThank you.\n\n16\n\nbecome aware recently of a number of subpoenas that the defense\n\n17\n\nhas served on witnesses.\n\n18\n\nwanted raise at this juncture, which is, the defense has served\n\n19\n\nthe attorney who currently represents Minor Victim 4 with a\n\n20\n\nsubpoena, seeking his testimony at this trial.\n\n21\n\nto confer on this issue because the government has no idea what\n\n22\n\nadmissible testimony that attorney could possibly offer at this\n\n23\n\ntrial that would not be covered by attorney-client privilege.\n\n24\n\nWe would move to preclude it, but we cannot fathom what the\n\n25\n\ntestimony would be.\n\nThere's one in particular that we\n\nWe've attempted\n\nAnd so we're raising it with your Honor\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839465\n\n", "char_count": 1558}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 7 of 43\n\n7\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nbecause of the obvious issue that would arise with\nattorney-client privilege and with Minor Victim 4's right to\nrepresentation of counsel.\n4\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nWell, first, your Honor, I don't think\n\n5\n\nthat it's appropriate for me to have to discuss defense\n\n6\n\nstrategy in this context.\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nHowever\n\nThat's fine.\n\nThere will be no -- without\n\n8\n\nbriefing, you will not call an attorney for a witness, period.\n\n9\n\nI'm happy to see briefing, but until that happens, you won't.\n\n10\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nThat's fine, your Honor.\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOK.\n\n12\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\n13\n\nWe had one other question for your Honor, which is\n\n14\n\nwhether the Court intends to, in its preliminary instruction,\n\n15\n\ninform the jury that certain witnesses will be testifying under\n\n16\n\npseudonyms.\n\n17\n\nto approach that issue in our opening statement.\n\n18\n\nWe wanted to know that so that we understand how\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI think we have a pending proposal, with\n\n19\n\nthe two sides having slightly different views as to what\n\n20\n\nlanguage to use for those instructions.\n\n21\n\nthat yet, but I will.\n\n22\n\nyou're asking is, will I include that in my preliminary\n\n23\n\ninstructions as opposed to at the time the first witness is\n\n24\n\ncalled.\n\n25\n\nyou'll refer to witnesses pursuant to pseudonyms during\n\nI haven't dealt with\n\nAnd then I guess the second question\n\nIt should come before opening, I presume, because\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839466\n\n", "char_count": 1555}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 8 of 43\n\n8\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nopening.\n\n4\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\nPrecisely, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOK.\n\nDefense, any objection to me including, in pre-opening\n\n5\n\npreliminary instructions, what I determine is an appropriate\n\n6\n\ninstruction regarding witnesses testifying under pseudonyms?\n\n7\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThank you.\n\n9\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\n10\n\nNo.\n\nThere was just one\n\nmore issue that I believe Ms. Moe was going to address.\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n12\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nThank you.\n\nMs. Moe.\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\nI'm going to bring\n\n13\n\nto the Court's attention an issue that came to our attention\n\n14\n\nregarding prospective Juror No. 93.\n\n15\n\ndire, based on publicly available information, that that\n\n16\n\nprospective juror is an attorney at a financial institution.\n\n17\n\nAt trial, there will be a witness from that financial\n\n18\n\ninstitution.\n\n19\n\nthat he is an executive director at that financial institution.\n\n20\n\nAnd he'll be talking about certain financial transactions.\n\n21\n\nWe learned, following voir\n\nHe is more than a records custodian in the sense\n\nDuring our meetings with this witness, an attorney for\n\n22\n\nthe financial institution had been present along with outside\n\n23\n\ncounsel for the financial institution.\n\n24\n25\n\nSo we want to just bring that to the Court's\nattention.\n\nWe flagged that for the defense as well.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839467\n\n", "char_count": 1466}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 9 of 43\n\n9\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nTHE COURT:\nMS. MOE:\n\nWhat do you propose?\nYour Honor, I think at a minimum we propose\n\nsome additional follow-up guess for the juror about her role,\n4\n\nwhether she interfaces with folks dealing with compliance,\n\n5\n\nwhich is within the scope of what this witness does, whether\n\n6\n\nthere would be any issues about hearing testimony about the\n\n7\n\nfinancial institution where she works.\n\n8\n\nWe have not flagged for our witness that there is a\n\n9\n\njuror, of course, who works with the institution, so it's hard\n\n10\n\nfor us to gauge whether they may have overlapped or whether\n\n11\n\nthey would recognize one another in the courtroom.\n\n12\n\nrecognize it would be difficult to probe this issue without\n\n13\n\ncreating an issue, but we think at a minimum a question about\n\n14\n\nsort of her role and any issues about being fair or discomfort\n\n15\n\nabout witnesses who are testifying from the financial\n\n16\n\ninstitution might address this issue.\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\n19\n\nI think it is a little late.\n\nSo I\n\nWho will I hear from?\nYou'll hear from me, Judge.\nThe publicly available\n\n20\n\ninformation would have revealed that there are other people who\n\n21\n\nare in that same institution or have been affiliated with that\n\n22\n\ninstitution, some of which were excused, and at least one that\n\n23\n\nis still here.\n\n24\n\nwishes.\n\n25\n\ninappropriately at this stage of the game.\n\nThe government can exercise a challenge if it\n\nBut I think it's unnecessary.\n\nAnd it flags something\nIt will highlight\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839468\n\n", "char_count": 1632}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 10 of 43 10\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nsomething, and this witness is technically, I believe, a\nrecords custodian.\n\nHe may be of a higher level than your\n\nstandard records custodian, but his testimony is sort of\n4\n\nancillary to the charges in this indictment.\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n6\n\nThe purpose of me asking the parties to submit a list\n\n7\n\nof entities or addresses that may be mentioned during trial was\n\n8\n\nto capture this sort of issue.\n\n9\n\nfailed to include a financial institution that will be\n\n10\n\nmentioned during trial.\n\n11\n\nI agree.\n\nAll right.\n\nIt's too late to go back and redo that,\n\n12\n\nhaving failed to do so.\n\n13\n\nit's a peremptory.\n\n14\n\nWhat else?\n\n15\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\n16\n\nIt sounds like the government\n\nSo I think if you think it's an issue,\n\nNo other issues, your Honor, other than\n\nthe outstanding ones your Honor outlined.\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\n19\n\nYour Honor, I wanted to talk a little bit about use of\n\nOK.\n\nAny -- go ahead.\n\nYes.\n\n20\n\nimpeachment material during trial.\n\nI have a concern -- well,\n\n21\n\nwhat I am proposing is that if we are going to be either\n\n22\n\nimpeaching or refreshing recollection of a particular witness,\n\n23\n\nthat we be able to do it electronically.\n\n24\n\nwould be fine, and that's typically how we would do this.\n\n25\n\nproblem with using impeachment material during the course of\n\nI think that that\nThe\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839469\n\n", "char_count": 1463}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 11 of 43 11\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nthis trial in paper format is that there's just too much paper\ninvolved.\n\nAnd the plan would be, if we're going to be\n\nimpeaching the witness, you know, on an inconsistent statement\n4\n\nor something else, that we would simply display that\n\n5\n\nelectronically to the Court, counsel, and here at the podium,\n\n6\n\nand the witness, do the impeachment, and then take it down.\n\n7\n\nThese would not be things that would be shown to the jurors.\n\n8\n\nBut I want to make sure that that's an acceptable process to\n\n9\n\nthe Court.\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThere are times when the witness will want\n\n11\n\nto see the full document, so you'll have those available should\n\n12\n\nthey ask for them or need them.\n\n13\n\nwith standard practice to show the document electronically,\n\n14\n\nand, again, say, you want to see more, either the whole\n\n15\n\ndocument in paper or the page before or after, you'll\n\n16\n\naccommodate that.\n\n17\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nBut it's certainly consistent\n\nBut otherwise, I don't see an issue.\nYes, your Honor.\n\nAs the Court may have\n\n18\n\nrecalled, when the parties submitted a joint proposal with\n\n19\n\nrespect to issues regarding witness anonymity, one of the joint\n\n20\n\nproposals was that exhibits under seal which contain\n\n21\n\nidentifying information or victims or other relative witnesses\n\n22\n\nwould be handled in paper copies with binders for the jurors?\n\n23\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n24\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n25\n\nBecause the screens are visible.\n\nExactly, your Honor.\n\nAnd so to the extent\n\nany of those exhibits fall within that category, our view is\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839470\n\n", "char_count": 1658}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 12 of 43 12\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nthat those should be treated similarly.\n\nTo the extent there's\n\nan exhibit that can otherwise be shown electronically, like\nother exhibits that can be shown electronically, of course we\n4\n\nhave no objection to that.\n\n5\n\nidentifying information, given the location of the jurors'\n\n6\n\nscreens in this courtroom and how they would be visible to\n\n7\n\nmembers of the public, we would request that they be treated\n\n8\n\nlike other sealed exhibits.\n\n9\n10\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nBut for documents that contain\n\nThese are not exhibits, your Honor, so\n\nthey won't be admitted into evidence.\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n12\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n14\n\nanonymity, which is my order.\n\n15\n\nthat be an issue with respect to anything you want to show for\n\n16\n\nrefreshing recollection, why not show that on -- you'll show\n\n17\n\nthat on paper.\n\n18\n19\n\nSame issue, right?\n\nWhatever they are, we're protecting\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n21\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n24\n25\n\nScreens are visible.\n\nShould\n\nIt's an unwieldy and impossible project\n\nhere, your Honor.\n\n20\n\n23\n\nYes.\n\nTo use paper?\nTo use --\n\nThe way trials have been done for a very\n\nlong time?\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nIt is likely there will be -- there are\n\nthousands of pages of potential material that will be at issue.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839471\n\n", "char_count": 1395}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 13 of 43 13\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nAnd in order to accommodate paper, there will be, I think,\nsubstantial delays during the process.\n\nIt will require handing\n\nout of copies.\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nGet to the solution.\n\nSo the problem we\n\n5\n\nknow is that I have ordered anonymity with respect to some\n\n6\n\nwitnesses.\n\n7\n\nthe way the courtroom is constructed, screens are available\n\n8\n\nthat may show names or identifying information, which I'm not\n\n9\n\npermitting to be made public.\n\n10\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\n11\n\njurors, so that's not an issue.\n\n12\n13\n14\n15\n\nThe second portion of the problem we know is that\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWell, they won't be shown to the\n\nWe're not keeping the names from the\n\njurors, so that's certainly not an issue.\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nImpeachment information won't be on the\n\nscreen to the jurors because it's not an admitted exhibit.\n\n16\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n17\n\non counsel's table.\n\n18\n\nWhat's the solution?\n\nRight.\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nOK.\n\nI think the issue is the screens\n\nI don't believe -- and I was trying to\n\n19\n\nsee this from the back of the courtroom -- I don't believe that\n\n20\n\nyou can see, you know, a paper document from the back of the\n\n21\n\ncourtroom when it's up on the screen.\n\n22\n\nCertainly, we could turn off these screens over here,\n\n23\n\nor, alternatively, I can give the government paper copies and\n\n24\n\nthe government can look at paper copies.\n\n25\n\nthe problem.\n\nSo that takes care of\n\nAnd then that way, we don't have to be\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839472\n\n", "char_count": 1546}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 14 of 43 14\n\nLBNAMAXTps\ndisplaying -- we don't have to be approaching the witness and\nwe can move seamlessly through this.\nThese are all documents that are in the government'\n4\n\npossession to begin with, your Honor.\n\n5\n\nthat are unknown at this point.\n\n6\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThese are not things\n\nAgain, that seems off topic.\n\nBut\n\nso\n\nit's manageable to give the government paper.\n\n8\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nIt should be.\n\nAny reason you can't -- how about this.\n\n10\n\nPrepare it as a binder for potential use, even if it's not the\n\n11\n\nfull document, but anything that you might use -- that you\n\n12\n\nthink you might use.\n\n13\n\nhave it in a binder and you could direct them to turn to it.\n\n14\n\nIf it turns out there's something that you do want to show that\n\n15\n\nyou didn't put in the binder, we'll deal with that and you'll\n\n16\n\nbe able to show it, either by turning off the counsel screens\n\n17\n\nand showing it on the monitor or we'll hand up paper at that\n\n18\n\npoint.\n\n19\n20\n\nAs you know, it's a known quantity.\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nI think there is going to be a real\n\nproblem, your Honor, to do it like that.\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYou\n\nIt just\n\nHelp me understand this as a practical\n\n22\n\nmatter.\n\nYou will have your outline for your cross, and you're\n\n23\n\ngoing to know enough to tell your paralegal, Put up document\n\n24\n\nnumber so-and-so, page 7.\n\n25\n\ngoing to pull that up and put it on the screen, right?\n\nAnd that's how your paralegal is\nWhy\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839473\n\n", "char_count": 1566}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 15 of 43 15\n\nLBNAMAXTps\ncan't you just have put that in a binder, a paper binder, in\nadvance?\n\nAnd as I said, if there's something that comes up or\n\nyou realize you neglected to put it in, we could deal with\n4\n\nthat.\n\n5\n\nbinder, just like you would direct your paralegal to show a\n\n6\n\nparticular document on the screen.\n\nBut by and large, you're directing them to a tab in a\n\n7\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\n8\n\nwe'll see how it goes.\n\n9\n\nways.\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWhat am I missing?\n\nWell, we can try that, your Honor.\n\nAnd\n\nI mean, we'll be prepared to do it both\n\nAnd I assure you, if for some reason\n\n11\n\nthere's something you want to show that's not in the binder, we\n\n12\n\nwill work that out and you won't be precluded from showing it.\n\n13\n\nBut to the extent you've prepared your cross outline and you\n\n14\n\nknow what you're going to ask about, just like you would call\n\n15\n\nit up, just have that in a tabbed binder so they can turn to\n\n16\n\nit.\n\n17\n\nAnd, again, to be completely clear, should there be\n\n18\n\nanything you need to do that wasn't in the binder, you'll be\n\n19\n\nable to do it and we'll either hand up paper in those few\n\n20\n\ninstances or we'll turn off the table monitors and show it on\n\n21\n\nthe screen.\n\n22\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\n23\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n24\n\nWhat else?\n\n25\n\nNo?\n\nOK, your Honor.\n\nThank you.\n\nThank you.\n\nOK.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839474\n\n", "char_count": 1431}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 16 of 43 16\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nSo defense seeks to preclude, in motion in limine 7,\nGovernment Exhibit 52.\n\nI'm not going to preclude, but I do\n\nthink this needs to play out at trial.\n\nI need to hear the\n\n4\n\nwitness testimony and I'll allow voir dire, given factually\n\n5\n\nwhat I understand to be the issues surrounding this item, and\n\n6\n\nas I understand it -- the witness is going to -- tell me if I\n\n7\n\nhave this wrong.\n\n8\n\nis for you, Ms. Comey -- the anticipated testimony is that not\n\n9\n\nthis exact book but a similar-looking book, characteristically\n\n10\n\nsimilar, binding, pages, font, etc., was seen by this witness,\n\n11\n\nand she can attempt to authenticate by describing the\n\n12\n\nsimilarities between what is Government Exhibit 52 and what she\n\n13\n\nsaw.\n\n14\n\nThe anticipated testimony, Ms. Comey -- this\n\nIs that the idea?\nMS. MOE:\n\nThat's correct, your Honor.\n\nBecause this\n\n15\n\nwitness has not been informed about how that exhibit came into\n\n16\n\nthe government's possession, I just wanted to clarify one small\n\n17\n\nthing, which is that this witness won't say that this isn't one\n\n18\n\nof the -- you know, in particular, that because she recognizes\n\n19\n\nit as one in a series, but doesn't know how it came to the\n\n20\n\ngovernment's possession, it's just identifying it in that way.\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo your understanding is, by the time\n\n22\n\nframe, this wouldn't have been the one that she saw, but she\n\n23\n\nwon't know that because you anticipate her testimony to be\n\n24\n\nthere were several versions of these and they are all the same.\n\n25\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nThat's correct, your Honor.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839475\n\n", "char_count": 1702}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 17 of 43 17\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nTHE COURT:\nadmissible.\n\nSo I will allow -- I don't know if it's\n\nI think, from what I see, it's a close question.\n\nIt's going to turn on the testimony.\n\nSo I'll allow that\n\n4\n\ntestimony to take place.\n\nI'll allow voir dire.\n\nAnd then I'll\n\n5\n\nmake a ruling, depending on how that goes, as to whether it\n\n6\n\nmeets the threshold for admissibility, and the questions that\n\n7\n\nhave been raised go to weight.\n\n8\n\nuntil I hear that testimony.\n\nBut as I sit here, I don't know\n\n9\n\nI do think that the government needs to make it\n\n10\n\navailable for inspection to the defense, and so you'll work out\n\n11\n\nthe logistics of that pretrial.\n\n12\n\nforensic expert to look at it, a document forensic expert to\n\n13\n\nlook at it, you'll work out the logistics to make it available.\n\n14\n\nOK?\n\n15\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n16\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n17\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nTo the extent that they want a\n\nYes, your Honor.\nAny questions about that?\nNo, your Honor, other than one of my\n\n18\n\nrequests was that the actual document be here at trial and not\n\n19\n\na photocopy of one page.\n\n20\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nThe actual exhibit will be\n\n21\n\nhere in the courtroom at trial.\n\n22\n\nexhibit available for the defense for inspection.\n\n23\n\npersonally inspected it, I believe that was on November 1st.\n\n24\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nGreat.\n\nAnd we have already made that\nThey have\n\nI'm happy to hear that.\n\nAnd not\n\njust the page but the whole book.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839476\n\n", "char_count": 1535}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 18 of 43 18\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nMS. MOE:\n\nThat's correct, your Honor.\n\navailable for inspection this summer.\n\nWe made it\n\nWe notified the defense\n\nin a letter that it was available for inspection.\n\nThe defense\n\n4\n\nasked for an inspection the week before our conference on\n\n5\n\nNovember 1st.\n\n6\n\nThey personally inspected it.\n\n7\n\nthat available for inspection to the defense.\n\nI made it available for inspection that day.\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n9\n\ni appreciate that.\n\n10\n\nnow.\n\n11\n\nWe're happy to continue to make\n\nI'm very happy to hear that.\n\nThank you.\n\nAnd I think that takes care of that for\n\nI guess one question:\n\nI think, given the uncertainty\n\n12\n\nas to admission, the government should not mention it in its\n\n13\n\nopening.\n\n14\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nOf course, your Honor.\n\nThank you.\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n16\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n\nco-conspirator statements.\n\n19\n\nto reasonable agreement, of course, with the defense preserving\n\n20\n\nobjections as to ultimate admissibility.\n\n21\n\ncourse the government has to make the showing that's required\n\n22\n\nduring the course of the trial.\n\nAnything before we move on?\nNo, your Honor.\n\nThank you.\n\nSo next is the admissibility of\nI do appreciate the efforts to come\n\nBased on the law, of\n\n23\n\nThere are two statements that are exemplars that\n\n24\n\nremain in issue, and I think, starting with the second one\n\n25\n\nfirst: so the second one, it seems to me, is not being offered\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839477\n\n", "char_count": 1525}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 19 of 43 19\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nfor the truth, that it is being, as I understand it, being\noffered for the effect on the listener, and so really there\nis -- it's a potential relevance issue and not a hearsay issue.\n4\n\nI think this needs to play out at trial, but tell me if anybody\n\n5\n\ndisagrees with that.\n\n6\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\n7\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWe agree, your Honor.\nAgreed.\n\nAnd then the other one, the government is\n\n9\n\nseeking admission pursuant to 801(d)(2)(E), and in question is\n\n10\n\nwhether the statement was made during the course of and in\n\n11\n\nfurtherance of that conspiracy.\n\n12\n13\n\nI don't think I have enough to answer that before me.\nSo I can either hear more now or let it play out at trial.\n\n14\n15\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\nI think it should play out at trial, your\n\nHonor.\n\n16\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n\nGreat.\n\nI agree, your Honor.\nThank you.\n\nAll right.\n\nThat takes\n\ncare of that.\n\n19\n20\n\nYes.\n\nNext are the four additional individuals that the\ndefense disclosed as potential experts.\n\nSo we've got Kelso and\n\n21\n\n, who, it strikes me, are primarily potentially fact\n\n22\n\nwitnesses and not expert witnesses, with the exception of that\n\n23\n\nKelso tes -- so I think first, let's see if we get agreement\n\n24\n\non:\n\n25\n\nwould be fact testimony, correct?\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nThat's the government's understanding,\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839478\n\n", "char_count": 1445}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 20 of 43 20\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nyour Honor, although it's not clear from the expert notice\nwhether they anticipate going beyond pure fact testimony.\nMR. EVERDELL:\n4\n\nYour Honor, at this point we anticipate\n\nhim being a fact witness.\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n6\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nYes.\n\n7\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nI think.\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n9\n10\n\nSummary and fact witness.\n\nDoesn't sound like expert to me, so I\n\ndon't think there's anything to do on that now.\nKelso also seems largely anticipated to summarize data\n\n11\n\ndocuments and photographs on electronic devices either as a\n\n12\n\nfact witness or summary testimony under 1006.\n\n13\n\nKelso's testimony that may cross over into expert testimony is,\n\n14\n\nI'm going to quote from the notice, \"generally about computer\n\n15\n\nforensic principles associated with the creation of document\n\n16\n\nstorage and retrieval of digital documents and photographs,\n\n17\n\nincluding the limits to the information that can be gleaned\n\n18\n\nfrom the metadata.\"\n\n19\n\nAnd except\n\nI don't think there's been a sufficient disclosure at\n\n20\n\nthis point pursuant to Rule 16.\n\n21\n\nwhat Kelso's opinions actually are about, as to any of these\n\n22\n\ntopics, or provide any basis for those opinions.\n\n23\n\nfurther disclosure would be necessary before I would allow\n\n24\n\nexpert testimony.\n\n25\n\nThe disclosure doesn't say\n\nSo certainly\n\nIs that anticipated?\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nYour Honor, this is my witness.\n\nHe\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839479\n\n", "char_count": 1517}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 21 of 43 21\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nwould largely be in rebuttal to a government witness.\nMr. Flatley was disclosed by the government for similar\npurposes to talk about the retrieval of metadata from some of\n4\n\nthe devices that were seized from Epstein's home.\n\nTo the\n\n5\n\nextent Mr. Flatley talks about the retrieval of metadata or\n\n6\n\nwhat that metadata means, Mr. Kelso may then be a rebuttal\n\n7\n\nwitness, but we don't know yet from the government's disclosure\n\n8\n\nexactly what documents Mr. Flatley intends to refer to.\n\n9\n\nthat's why there isn't more information about what Mr. Kelso\n\n10\n\nmight or might not say.\n\n11\n\nfactual.\n\n12\n\noffers opinions along those grounds, and we think that it's not\n\n13\n\naccurate.\n\n14\n\ndisclosure, once we've heard Mr. Flatley's testimony.\n\nAnd so\n\nFrankly, we think it would largely be\n\nIt may stray into areas about metadata if Mr. Flatley\n\nIf that's true, we can provide an updated\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nMr. Rohrbach.\n\n16\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nYour Honor, the exhibits that\n\n17\n\nMr. Flatley is going to talk about are now marked as government\n\n18\n\nexhibits, and the defense has Mr. Flatley's 3500 information as\n\n19\n\nwell as examples the government has pointed to where\n\n20\n\nMr. Flatley has offered similar testimony in other cases in\n\n21\n\nthis district and in the Eastern District.\n\n22\n\ngovernment has given ample notice about what Mr. Flatley will\n\n23\n\ntestify about.\n\n24\n25\n\nSo I think the\n\nBut as a more general matter, to the extent that the\ndefense provides supplemental notice at some point about\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839480\n\n", "char_count": 1643}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 22 of 43 22\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nwhether they're going to cross the line from pure fact\ntestimony to expert testimony, I think we can deal with it at\nthat time.\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOK.\n\nWhat I would just say is, if your\n\n5\n\nexpert, looking at the 3500 material and the disclosure, has\n\n6\n\ndifferent expert views, you need to notice those now.\n\n7\n\nthe extent it's something that comes out at trial, that\n\n8\n\ncouldn't have been anticipated, then you can notice down the\n\n9\n\nroad.\n\n10\n\nBut to\n\nSo just in terms of what, if your expert has testimony\n\n11\n\nnow that's different from what's anticipated in light of the\n\n12\n\ngovernment's notice and the marked exhibits and 3500 material,\n\n13\n\nwhen would you like to provide additional notice?\n\n14\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nYour Honor, some of the \"marked\n\n15\n\nexhibits\" are a placeholder for an entire hard drive that has\n\n16\n\nany number of documents on it.\n\n17\n\nrepresenting they will only be referring to the documents that\n\n18\n\nare separately marked and not to exhibits that say \"hard drive\n\n19\n\n58,\" \"hard drive 85,\" \"hard drive 96,\" we could do that, but\n\n20\n\nthey haven't made that representation.\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n22\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nIf the government is now\n\nFair enough.\nThose drives are marked for\n\n23\n\nidentification for authentication purposes, but to the extent\n\n24\n\nthat the point is that Mr. Kelso is going to testify about\n\n25\n\ngeneral principles associated with the creation of documents\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839481\n\n", "char_count": 1547}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 23 of 43 23\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nand the extraction of metadata as his expert testimony,\nMr. Flatley's views on those questions should be available\nthrough the 3500 material and through his other expert\n4\n\ntestimony, so there's really no need for any sort of further\n\n5\n\nidentification by the government of anything before Mr. Kelso\n\n6\n\nshould be able to let us know his views on those questions.\n\n7\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nYour Honor, the 3500 material doesn't\n\n8\n\nsay Mr. Flatley is going to describe the extraction of user\n\n9\n\ndata this way.\n\n10\n\nthe user data, but he hasn't talked about the methods that he's\n\n11\n\nused it.\n\n12\n\ngovernment.\n\n13\n\nhave provided thus far exactly what Mr. Flatley's testimony is\n\n14\n\ngoing to be.\n\n15\n\nHe's talked about the fact that he has observed\n\nIt's not that type of 3500 material from the\nSo I don't agree that we could tell from what they\n\nAnd frankly, they said Mr. Flatley was largely a fact\n\n16\n\nwitness as well.\n\n17\n\nintending to offer something along the lines Mr. Kelso is, they\n\n18\n\ndidn't provide sufficient notice for Mr. Flatley's expertise in\n\n19\n\nthat area either.\n\n20\n21\n22\n\nSo if I'm understanding now that they're\n\nTHE COURT:\nnotice.\n\nWell, I have to go back and look at the\n\nBut are you using Flatley as an expert?\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nWe think Mr. Flatley is primarily a\n\n23\n\nfact witness, but the line between a fact witness in a setting\n\n24\n\nlike this and someone testifying on the basis of their\n\n25\n\nexpertise is not well settled, and so we've given expert notice\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839482\n\n", "char_count": 1629}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 24 of 43 24\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nin an abundance of caution, and also identified for the defense\nfour other cases in which Mr. Flatley has testified on a\nsimilar topic so they can see -4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat includes his ex-- to the extent it\n\n5\n\ncrossed over into expert opinion about methodology, for\n\n6\n\nexample --\n\n7\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n8\n\nMr. Flatley is qualified as an expert in some of those\n\n9\n\nfour cases, which highlights the vagaries of this line, and it\n\n10\n\nprovides information about the bases of his opinion about these\n\n11\n\ntopics.\n\n12\n\nIf I may have a minute, your Honor.\n\nTo the extent that there is an issue that is not\n\n13\n\nraised, either in the government's expert notice or 3500, or in\n\n14\n\nthe similar exemplars we've given the testimony, that might be\n\n15\n\nsomething that's outside the bounds of the government axe pert\n\n16\n\nnotice, depending on exactly what it is.\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo I think what we need to do is, you have\n\n18\n\nyour expert look at the testimony that he's provided.\n\n19\n\ngot some differing expert opinion as to forensic principles or\n\n20\n\ncreation of documents or storage and retrieval of digital\n\n21\n\ndocuments, or what information can be gleaned from metadata\n\n22\n\ngenerally, I think you should notice those opinions.\n\n23\n\nabsent that, we'll let it play out.\n\n24\n25\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nIf he's\n\nBut\n\nOK.\n\nCertainly, your Honor.\n\nAnd obviously\n\nif Mr. Flatley attempts to offer opinions during his testimony\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839483\n\n", "char_count": 1557}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 25 of 43 25\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nthat are not disclosed, I will raise that with the Court at\nthat time.\nTHE COURT:\n4\n\nAll right.\n\nJust with respect to what you have as anticipated\n\n5\n\nopinion about those subjects, when will you -- give me the date\n\n6\n\nby which you'll tell me if your expert has different expert\n\n7\n\nopinions to offer with respect to those areas.\n\n8\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n10\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nThis Saturday, your Honor?\n\nAll right.\nAnd I don't\n\nI guess what I'm\n\n11\n\nhearing is, the only opinions he may offer are those disclosed\n\n12\n\nin other cases.\n\n13\n\ncase.\n\n14\n\nopinions in those testimony that our client -- our expert\n\n15\n\ndisagrees with we can provide them by this Saturday.\n\nThey haven't disclosed an opinion from this\n\nSo we will look at those other trial testimony, and any\n\n16\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat sounds very reasonable to me.\n\n17\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nOK?\n\nAlthough we know\n\n18\n\nthat, again, in addition to the other -- his testimony in other\n\n19\n\ncases, we would point the defense expert to the 3500 material\n\n20\n\nas well in this case and the government's exhibits.\n\n21\n22\n23\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWell, I mean, your notice should provide\n\nthe opinions that he's going to offer.\nIt's not a scavenger hunt.\n\nDoes it?\n\nYou're required, as the\n\n24\n\nfirst matter, to provide, pursuant to Rule 16, the opinions\n\n25\n\nthat he's going to offer.\n\nHave you done that?\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839484\n\n", "char_count": 1513}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 26 of 43 26\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nYes.\n\nThe government believes that its\n\nnotice, in combination with its 3500 materials and the cases\nit's pointed the defense to, should give the defense an\n4\n\nunderstanding of Mr. Flatley's opinions, to the extent that\n\n5\n\nthey're expert opinions at all and not just fact opinions.\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWell --\n\n7\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nYour Honor, my point is that\n\n8\n\nMs. Menninger says that she would have her expert review\n\n9\n\nMr. Flatley's testimony in other cases to see if there are\n\n10\n\nopinions he disagreed with, and I just wanted to clarify that\n\n11\n\nthe defense expert should review the material the government\n\n12\n\nhas provided them.\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n14\n\nThat's fine, but it's your notice that\n\nsets up the opinions that your expert is offering.\n\n15\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n16\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nSo what they should do is look at the\n\n17\n\nnotice, and if their expert has different views than what's in\n\n18\n\nthe notice, they should provide those views.\n\n19\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nIf your notice is insufficient under Rule\n\n21\n\n16 to tell us now what opinions your expert is going to\n\n22\n\nprovide, then you may have problems down the road.\n\n23\n\ngoing to have them held to a different standard than what the\n\n24\n\ngovernment has done here.\n\n25\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nBut I'm not\n\nOf course, your Honor.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839485\n\n", "char_count": 1488}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 27 of 43 27\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo, Ms. Menninger, with respect to\n\nSaturday, if there's anything in the notice that's suggested\nthat your expert has different expert opinions on, please\n4\n\nprovide notice.\n\nOtherwise we'll see how it plays out.\n\n5\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOf course.\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\nAnd then LaPorte and Naso, I don't have\n\n7\n\nany sense, based on the disclosures, what evidence this will go\n\n8\n\nto, and the defense says that's because they don't know what\n\n9\n\nevidence the government will produce.\n\n10\n\nimagine you would have these experts analyze?\n\n11\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nWhat documents do you\n\nI think it's unlikely that they will\n\n12\n\ntestify, your Honor.\n\n13\n\nissue relates to Accuser No. 2.\n\n14\n\ndoubt that that's going to become an issue during trial.\n\n15\n\nendorsed them just out of an abundance of caution, and I don't\n\n16\n\nreally see it playing out.\n\n17\n\nup, if it becomes an issue, certainly I'll give as much notice\n\n18\n\nas I can.\n\n19\n\ntestifying at trial.\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n21\n\nMr. Rohrbach.\n\n22\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nThe only document that was potentially at\nAnd I doubt that that -- I\nWe\n\nBut I think if it -- if it comes\n\nBut I don't really think they're going to be\n\nGood enough for me.\n\nI'd like to say it's good enough, your\n\n23\n\nHonor.\n\nThe concern is that if the defense decides mid trial\n\n24\n\nthat they would like to call these experts, it's going to\n\n25\n\ncreate a difficult situation for the government to file the\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839486\n\n", "char_count": 1586}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 28 of 43 28\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nappropriate Daubert motion, identify responsive experts if\nnecessary.\n\nAnd so the government asks that the Court preclude\n\nthe defense experts at this time unless they give at least more\n4\n5\n6\n\nspecific notice about what they might testify to.\nTHE COURT:\nspecific notice.\n\nWell, they are precluded without more\n\nThat's true.\n\n7\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n8\n\ngovernment, your Honor.\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOK.\n\nYes.\n\nThen that's fine for the\n\nI mean, plainly, Rule 16 hasn't been\n\n10\n\nmet at this stage, and the representation is, they're not\n\n11\n\nanticipating anything coming up.\n\n12\n\nwould have to first provide sufficient notice in order for us\n\n13\n\nto be able to resolve this.\n\n14\n\nhave been anticipated at this point.\n\nIf something comes up, they\n\nSo it can't being is that could\nOK?\n\n15\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\n16\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOK.\n\n17\n\nAll right.\n\nNext thing on my checklist, the limiting\n\nYes.\n\nTotally understood, your Honor.\n\nThank you.\n\n18\n\ninstructions related to witness 3 that I proposed.\n\n19\n\ntaking this one?\n\n20\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWho's\n\nI am, your Honor.\n\nSo Mr. Rohrbach, you propose -- so I\n\n22\n\nsuggested, \"However, you may not convict the defendant on the\n\n23\n\nbasis of the testimony regarding the sexual conduct between\n\n24\n\nthis witness and Mr. Epstein.\"\n\n25\n\nstatement of the law, yes?\n\nYou agree that's a correct\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839487\n\n", "char_count": 1472}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 29 of 43 29\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nI apologize, your Honor.\n\ntrying to pull find that.\nTHE COURT:\n4\n5\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nFor witness 3.\n\nYes, your Honor, we\n\nagree that's a correct statement of the law.\nTHE COURT:\n\n7\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n9\n\nThis is for the --\n\nFor witness 3.\n\n6\n\n8\n\nI'm just\n\nBut you want to add \"solely.\"\nYes.\n\nThe government thinks that that\n\nclarification -THE COURT:\n\nLet me ask you this.\n\nSo if you add\n\n10\n\n\"solely,\" then, to my ear, it would mean that you can convict\n\n11\n\nthe defendant on the basis of the testimony of witness 3\n\n12\n\nregarding the sexual conduct between this witness and\n\n13\n\nMr. Epstein, and other evidence regarding the sexual conduct\n\n14\n\nbetween this witness and Mr. Epstein.\n\n15\n\nstatement of law?\n\n16\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nIs that a correct\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nInsofar as the Court\n\n17\n\nhas ruled that evidence related to witness 3 is direct evidence\n\n18\n\nof the offense, if that is offered in combination with other\n\n19\n\nevidence in the case that goes --\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nNo, I think maybe you misunderstood my\n\n21\n\nquestion.\n\n22\n\nbetween Mr. Epstein and this witness took place over all\n\n23\n\nrelevant ages of consent.\n\nThe government has said that the sexual conduct\n\n24\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nCorrect?\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nSo the defendant can't be convicted based\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839488\n\n", "char_count": 1436}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 30 of 43 30\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n\non the sexual conduct between this witness and Mr. Epstein.\nCorrect?\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes.\n\nMy question is, I think if you add\n\n5\n\n\"solely,\" this is what I hear: that the defendant can be\n\n6\n\nconvicted based on this witness's testimony regarding the\n\n7\n\nsexual conduct between Mr. Epstein and this witness, and other\n\n8\n\nevidence regarding the sexual conduct between this witness and\n\n9\n\nMr. Epstein.\n\nIs that a correct statement?\n\n10\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nI see your Honor's point.\n\n11\n\nwould be a correct statement.\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n13\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n14\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n15\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n16\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes, that\n\nThat would be in, in-That would be incorrect.\n\nThat would be wrong.\n\nAs a matter of law.\n\nYes.\n\nAnd that doesn't solely give it that\n\n17\n\nmeaning, that potential meaning?\n\n18\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nI see your Honor's point that if\n\n19\n\n\"solely\" is read to modify the sexual-conduct point, then that\n\n20\n\ncreates a -- it becomes amenable to that reading.\n\n21\n\ngovernment's point is that --\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n23\n\nThe\n\nAnd should the jury be instructed that\n\nway, that would be, in my mind, reversible error.\n\n24\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n25\n\nlaw, yes, your Honor.\n\nThat would be an incorrect statement of\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839489\n\n", "char_count": 1356}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 31 of 43 31\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo we won't add \"solely,\" because we don't\n\nwant to wrongly instruct the jury about the law.\n\nSo we'll keep\n\nthat one as it is.\n4\n\nI need to think about the other one.\n\nIn my mind, this\n\n5\n\nis an issue that pertains -- I understand there's a witness\n\n6\n\nwhere the only sexual conduct took place in New Mexico, and I\n\n7\n\nhad understood previously that that witness was above the age\n\n8\n\nof consent in New Mexico, but that the government was offering\n\n9\n\nthat evidence as enticement to engage in illegal sexual conduct\n\n10\n\nin New York.\n\n11\n\ninstruction, so that that evidence could be relevant, the jury\n\n12\n\ncould see that evidence as relevant to the enticement to\n\n13\n\nillegal sexual activity as defined under New York law, which is\n\n14\n\nthe only way that the government has charged this case, other\n\n15\n\nthan the trafficking count -- well, including the trafficking\n\n16\n\ncount, yes.\n\n17\n\nAnd that's what I was trying to capture in the\n\nAnd that's what I was trying to capture.\n\nAnd I'll\n\n18\n\nconsider the alterations you're suggesting.\n\n19\n\nis infuse the instruction with the government's case and\n\n20\n\narguments.\n\n21\n\njurors can't do and then, to the extent they otherwise deem the\n\n22\n\nevidence relevant, they can consider it and we'll give them the\n\n23\n\ncharge at the end of the day.\n\n24\n\nsuggestions.\n\n25\n\nWhat we can't do\n\nThe point here is just to make clear what the\n\nBut I'll consider the\n\nI haven't -- just haven't had time.\n\nAnything on that?\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839490\n\n", "char_count": 1615}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 32 of 43 32\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nI mean, it's the\n\ndefense's position that the Court's instruction is a correct\nstatement of law.\n\nIt's concise, it's clear, and will clarify\n\n4\n\nthe issues for the jurors as opposed to confuse the issues.\n\nI\n\n5\n\nthink the government's instruction is exactly the opposite.\n\nIt\n\n6\n\nis cumbersome, it is difficult to follow, and it will confuse\n\n7\n\nrather than to clarify.\n\n8\n\nAnd I will just point out, I think your Honor\n\n9\n\nidentified the correct example, which is Accuser 2, which is\n\n10\n\nalleged events that took place in New Mexico when she was above\n\n11\n\nthe age of consent for those acts in New Mexico.\n\n12\n\nAnd so this illustrates the problem of trying to prove\n\n13\n\na conspiracy where the illegal sexual activity is a violation\n\n14\n\nof New York law with acts that took place in other\n\n15\n\njurisdictions which were legal and have nothing to do with New\n\n16\n\nYork law.\n\n17\n\nSo as I think you've discussed before, your Honor, if\n\n18\n\nthe witness is going to testify to these events that took place\n\n19\n\nin New Mexico, even though they're legal under New York law\n\n20\n\nthere's no issue there -- they're going to --\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n22\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n23\n\nmisspoke.\n\nNot under New York law.\nUnder New Mexico law.\n\nI'm sorry.\n\nI\n\nUnder New Mexico law.\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nRight.\n\n25\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThey're going to assume that the\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839491\n\n", "char_count": 1511}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 33 of 43 33\n\nLBNAMAXTps\npurpose of this testimony is that these are illegal acts that\nthey're talking about, and unless they're instructed otherwise\n. Maxwell on an improper\n\nby the Court, they\n4\n\nbasis, which is that this witness's testimony is talking about\n\n5\n\nillegal sexual activity, as that's charged in the indictment.\n\n6\n\nSo there has to be a clarification on this point.\n\n7\n\nAnd I just would note, your Honor, the reason why\n\n8\n\nwe're here in this position is because the government has\n\n9\n\nchosen to add Accuser 2, Accuser 3, people who have nothing to\n\n10\n\ndo with violations of New York law, in this conspiracy, and if\n\n11\n\nthey're going to do that and you try to use that as evidence of\n\n12\n\na violation of New York law --\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWell, the charge is enticement.\n\nAnd, in\n\n14\n\nmy mind, this witness is in a very different position than\n\n15\n\nwitness 3.\n\n16\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes.\n\nBut it's certainly relevant evidence to\n\n18\n\nthe enticement charge with respect to New York law.\n\n19\n\ndoubt about that.\n\n20\n\nThere's no\n\nBut I agree, we have to make sure that the jury\n\n21\n\nunderstands, though it can be relevant evidence for that, if\n\n22\n\nthey want to take it into account for whatever they want to\n\n23\n\ntake it into account for, what they can't take it into account\n\n24\n\nfor is itself the New Mexico activity -- sexual activity as\n\n25\n\nitself illegal conduct charged in the indictment.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839492\n\n", "char_count": 1544}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "Case 1:2O-cr-OO33O-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 34 of 43 34\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nBut it seems to me these witnesses are in very\ndifferent postures, and therefore different risk of prejudice.\nBut I propose an instruction that I think gets to the point.\n4\n\nAnd it's a different instruction precisely for this reason,\n\n5\n\nthat that sexual conduct can be relevant evidence of the\n\n6\n\nenticement charge to violate New York law.\n\n7\n\ncharge with respect to that witness, some limiting instruction\n\n8\n\nwith respect to that witness, is necessary.\n\n9\n\nconfusing, and I won't allow the government to just insert its\n\n10\n\ntheory into the charge.\n\n11\n\nis any additional clarification.\n\n12\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nSo I do think some\n\nI won't make it\n\nBut I'll take a look to see if there\nThat would be helpful.\n\nJust in response to Mr. Everdell's\n\n13\n\npoint, your Honor, the government is not prepared to concede\n\n14\n\ntoday that the sexual activity that occurred in New Mexico was\n\n15\n\nabove the relevant age of consent.\n\n16\n\nletter, that's a complex question of New Mexico state law.\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAs we briefed in our\n\nSo, I mean, if there's a factual question\n\n18\n\nthat the government intends to put on, as to whether that was\n\n19\n\nillegal sexual activity under New Mexico law, then certainly\n\n20\n\nI'm not going to -- again, that's not how you charged it.\n\n21\n\nThat's not how you charged it here.\n\nRight?\n\n22\n\ncharged pursuant to New Mexico law.\n\nBut if what the government\n\n23\n\nis saying is, I shouldn't give that charge because in fact\n\n24\n\nyou're going to show that it was illegal sexual activity -- I'm\n\n25\n\nnot going to misinform the jury that it wasn't illegal under\n\nYou haven't\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839493\n\n", "char_count": 1737}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 35 of 43 35\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nNew Mexico law if that's something the government is going to\nshow.\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nYour Honor, we completely agree that\n\n4\n\nour charging theory is just a violation of the New York statute\n\n5\n\nand not the New Mexico statute, or any particular New Mexico\n\n6\n\nstatute.\n\n7\n\nquestion that any sexual activity that occurred in New Mexico\n\n8\n\nwas necessarily above New Mexico's own age of consent.\n\n9\n\nleast the legal accuracy of that has not been established at\n\n10\n\nthis point.\n\nOur point is that it is not a straightforward\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n12\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nSo at\n\nWill it be an issue in trial?\nNo, your Honor, because the government\n\n13\n\nis not planning to put on evidence aimed at meeting any\n\n14\n\nparticular New Mexico offense, since that's not the charges\n\n15\n\nthat we've established in this case.\n\n16\n\nterms of the accuracy of the proposed jury instruction -- that\n\n17\n\nis, whether the sexual conduct was legal or illegal within New\n\n18\n\nMexico.\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat's just a point in\n\nSo what I had said was, \"I anticipate\n\n20\n\nyou'll hear testimony from the next witness about sexual\n\n21\n\nconduct that she says she had with Mr. Epstein in New Mexico.\"\n\n22\n\nAnd then I had suggested, because it's what I understood from\n\n23\n\nthe parties, \"I instruct you that because the witness was over\n\n24\n\nthe age of consent in New Mexico at the relevant time period,\n\n25\n\nthe sexual conduct she says occurred with Mr. Epstein was not\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839494\n\n", "char_count": 1575}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 36 of 43 36\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nillegal sexual activity, as the government has charged in the\nindictment.\"\n\nSo it sounds to me, from what you're saying, is\n\nthat the first part of that sentence may be factually in\n4\n\ndispute.\n\n5\n\nsentence, which is that the sexual conduct she says occurred\n\n6\n\nwith Mr. Epstein was not illegal sexual activity as the\n\n7\n\ngovernment has charged in the indictment.\n\nBut the key, I think, goes to the latter part of the\n\n8\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYou agree with that.\n\nThat's correct, your Honor.\n\nSo let me work on this one, and I'll\n\n10\n\npropose -- I mean, I'll put out a new proposal after I've had\n\n11\n\nsome time to absorb.\n\n12\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nIf I may make just one other point,\n\n13\n\nyour Honor, related to this, which is that, given that we've\n\n14\n\ncharged this as a -- minor Victim 2 is only charged in the\n\n15\n\nconspiracy counts of the indictment.\n\n16\n\nevents that took place in New Mexico constitute illegal sexual\n\n17\n\nactivity within the meaning of the\n\n18\n\nwhether there was an independent to engage -- sorry.\n\n19\n\non whether there was an intent to engage in illegal sexual\n\n20\n\nactivity in New York but only insofar as that sexual activity\n\n21\n\nin New Mexico would satisfy the New York definition of --\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n23\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n25\n\nAnd so whether or not\n\nAct doesn't bear on\nIt bears\n\nYes.\nAnd so whether or not --\n\nI understand.\n\nThe only fear of confusion\n\nis if they think that you've established the illegal sexual\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839495\n\n", "char_count": 1613}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 37 of 43 37\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nactivity by having put on evidence of the sexual conduct in New\nMexico.\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n4\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nAnd we, for the\n\nreason --\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI understand your point, which is whether\n\n6\n\nor not it violated New Mexico law, that witness, in her\n\n7\n\ntelling, was under the age of consent in New York, and\n\n8\n\ntherefore it goes to the conspiracy to -- the\n\n9\n\nconspiracy count.\n\nAct\n\n10\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n12\n\nI will absorb this information and propose\n\n13\n\nthink a charge is necessary, but it has to be correct, and it\n\n14\n\nsounds like it may not be entirely correct as written.\n\n15\n\npropose.\n\n16\n17\n\nRight, yes.\n\nI get it.\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nI do\n\nSo I'll\n\nYour Honor, if I could just be heard\n\nbriefly.\n\n18\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n19\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nSure.\nOn the point about not being illegal\n\n20\n\nunder New Mexico law, this is really an eleventh-hour issue the\n\n21\n\ngovernment is raising.\n\n22\n\nimagine if they thought this was really a violation of New York\n\n23\n\nlaw there would be a substantive --\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n25\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThey haven't charged it this way.\n\nI\n\nNew Mexico law.\nI'm sorry.\n\nI keep misstating, your\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839496\n\n", "char_count": 1282}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 38 of 43 38\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nHonor.\n\n-- New Mexico law, that we would have a substantive\n\nviolation in addition for this witness.\n\nWe don't.\n\nAnd in fact\n\nI believe the government, bassed on the case law they're\n4\n\nciting, the issue they're raising is that there has to be force\n\n5\n\ninvolved or coercion involved for this to be something illegal.\n\n6\n\nAnd that's not how they charge it.\n\n7\n\nin this case.\n\n8\n\nSo I think it is a correct statement of law to say this is not\n\n9\n\nillegal sexual activity under New Mexico law, and that's what\n\n10\n\nthe instruction should reflect to the jury.\n\n11\n\nThat's never been an issue\n\nWe've litigated that issue quite extensively.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI think the important point has to be\n\n12\n\ncaptured in \"as charged by the government and for purposes of\n\n13\n\nestablishing the elements that the jury has to consider.\"\n\n14\n\nhear your point.\n\n15\n\nprovide clarity to the jury so that they know what they can and\n\n16\n\nwhat they can't do with this evidence.\n\nI'm going to think about the best way to\n\n17\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n18\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n19\n\nafter I re-propose.\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\nI'll do my best.\n\n20\n\nAnything else on that?\n\n21\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n23\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n25\n\nSo I\n\nNo.\n\nAnd I'll hear from you\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\nAnything else, Mr. Everdell?\nNo, your Honor.\n\nAll right.\n\nThank you.\n\nSo next is just to go over,\n\nmake sure we're all on the same page -- that's all I have for\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839497\n\n", "char_count": 1567}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 39 of 43 39\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nlegal issues.\n\nThe next is to make sure we're on the same page\n\nabout logistics for Monday.\n\nSo we'll be here, as you know.\n\nThe jurors will be assembled in two different courtrooms, and\n4\n\nthey -- when they left, we gave them instructions as to where\n\n5\n\nthey should go.\n\n6\n\nthat -- jurors in the two different courtrooms.\n\nSo we'll have -- and you've been provided\n\n7\n\nWe'll meet here at 8:30, by the way.\n\n8\n\nSo once we have all of the jurors assembled, we'll\n\n9\n\nhave the video feed, and I will say good morning to them and\n\n10\n\nthen say I'm going to ask two questions and if they have a\n\n11\n\n\"yes\" response to either of the questions they should raise\n\n12\n\ntheir hand.\n\n13\n\nAnd as we discussed, the two questions are:\n\n\"(1) Since you were here for individual questioning by\n\n14\n\nme, have you read, heard, seen, researched anything about the\n\n15\n\ncase or discussed the case with anybody?\n\n16\n\nyour hand.\n\n17\n\n\"(2) Do you feel for any reason that you could not be\n\n18\n\na fair and impartial juror in this case?\n\n19\n\nyour hand.\"\n\n20\n21\n22\n\nIf yes, please raise\n\nIf yes, please raise\n\nIf any jurors raise their hand, we'll bring them in\none at a time and see what the issues are.\nOnce we get through that, then we'll have our pool,\n\n23\n\nand your peremptories will be exercised on the first 40 jurors\n\n24\n\nin ascending order.\n\n25\n\nAny questions about that?\n\nAnd we'll have the board and you'll do alternate\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839498\n\n", "char_count": 1554}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 40 of 43 40\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nstrikes.\nMS. COMEY:\n\nNo questions, your Honor.\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nNo.\n\nThank you.\n\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOK.\n\n5\n\nI always ask at the final pretrial conference if there\n\n6\n\nare any issues to discuss regarding exclusion of witnesses\n\n7\n\nunder Federal Rule of evidence 615.\n\n8\n\nparties have feeds into their war rooms, I want to make sure\n\n9\n\nwe're all on the same page that anybody who may testify, other\n\n10\n\nthan the parties, who would potentially be needing to discuss\n\n11\n\nwhether they can listen to testimony or be excluded, experts or\n\n12\n\ncase agents, or you tell me.\n\n13\n14\n\nAnd especially because the\n\nAre there any potential witnesses who the government\nanticipates would be listening to some or all of the testimony?\n\n15\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\nNo, your Honor, certainly not before they\n\n16\n\ntestify.\n\nAfter certain victims testify, they may choose to be\n\n17\n\npresent after the completion of their testimony pursuant to\n\n18\n\ntheir rights under the Crime Victims' Rights Act, but otherwise\n\n19\n\nno witnesses that we know of will be listening to testimony.\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOK.\n\n21\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nMs. Menninger.\nYour Honor, I would note that the\n\n22\n\ngovernment has\n\nand we've litigated -- whether any of the\n\n23\n\naccusers' prior inconsistent statements may be admitted after\n\n24\n\ntheir credibility has been attacked.\n\n25\n\nthere is later introduction of inconsistent -- I'm sorry, I\n\nPursuant to the rule, if\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839499\n\n", "char_count": 1546}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 41 of 43 41\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nmean -THE COURT:\n\nYou mean prior consistent.\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\n-- prior consistent -- we've got a\n\n4\n\nproblem at this table misspeaking -- of prior consistent\n\n5\n\nstatements, that the declarant be made available, subject to\n\n6\n\nrecross -- or recall to the stand, to explain those supposed\n\n7\n\nprior consistent statements.\n\n8\n\nSo I don't know how that bears on the Court's thinking\n\n9\n\nabout permitting those accusers who may be subject to recall to\n\n10\n\nlisten in on testimony following their release from their\n\n11\n\noriginal testimony, your Honor.\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWell, I guess the first question is, under\n\n13\n\nthe rule, which reads, \"At a party's request, the court must\n\n14\n\norder witnesses excluded so they cannot hear other witnesses'\n\n15\n\ntestimony\" -- or I could do it on my own.\n\n16\n\nquestion is, is the defense -- so the government says alleged\n\n17\n\nvictim witnesses, after they testify, may want to listen to\n\n18\n\ntestimony after that.\n\n19\n\nnot do that because of the possibility that they may be\n\n20\n\nrecalled for rebuttal?\n\n21\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\n22\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\n23\n\nMs. Menninger, are you requesting they\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nYour Honor, if we may, we would ask to put\n\nin a letter on this issue, to look into it.\n\n24\n25\n\nBut I guess the\n\nTHE COURT:\nright.\n\nYes.\n\nFair enough.\n\nAnd I think you're\n\nThere may be an intersection between the Crime Victim\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839500\n\n", "char_count": 1509}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 42 of 43 42\n\nLBNAMAXTps\n\nProtection Act and 615.\n\nWhy don't you both look at it, confer,\n\nsee if you can come to agreement, and if not, put in a letter.\nMS. COMEY:\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThank you.\n\n5\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nYour Honor, one other issue on\n\n6\n\nsequestration.\n\n7\n\nDr. Rocchio's testimony to either Dr. Dietz or Dr. Loftus,\n\n8\n\nbecause I anticipate there may be issues that come up that they\n\n9\n\nneed to address during their testimony.\n\n10\n\npurpose I would ask for a limited exclusion from Rule 615 for\n\n11\n\nthose witnesses.\n\n12\n13\n\nI was hoping to be able to provide a copy of\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nAnd so for that\n\nThat's fine with the government, your\n\nHonor.\n\n14\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThank you.\n\n15\n\nsure we're on the same page.\n\nThis is why I asked.\n\nMake\n\n16\n\nAnything else in that regard?\n\n17\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\nNot from the government, your Honor.\n\n18\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWhen may I have an order-of-witness list?\n\n19\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\nWe would propose by Saturday, your Honor?\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOK.\n\nAnd, as I always do, I ask at the\n\n21\n\nfinal pretrial conference if any plea offers were communicated\n\n22\n\nto the defense.\n\n23\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\nNone were communicated, your Honor.\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd Ms. Sternheim, that's accurate; none\n\n25\n\nwere communicated?\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839501\n\n", "char_count": 1381}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839460", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 739\n\nFiled 08/10/22\n\nPage 43 of 43 43\n\nLBNAMAXTps\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nNone were communicated.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThank you.\n\nWhat else?\n\nAnything?\n\n4\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\nNothing from the government, your Honor.\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnything from the defense?\n\n6\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n8\n\nYes.\n\nNo.\n\nThank you.\n\nGive me one second?\n\nJust on the point, Ms. Comey, regarding the\n\n9\n\nwitnesses who may be recalled for rebuttal, you'll, both sides\n\n10\n\nwill look into it, you'll confer, and when would you like to\n\n11\n\nput in a letter if there's disagreement?\n\n12\n\nwe submit it by Saturday, your Honor?\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes.\n\n14\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\nThank you.\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right.\n\n16\n\nThank you, everyone.\n\n17\n18\n\nNothing further?\n\nHave a good Thanksgiving.\n\nI'll\n\nsee you on Monday.\n(Adjourned)\n\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02839502\n\n", "char_count": 899}]}