{"efta_number": "EFTA02839201", "page_count": 13, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02839201", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02839201.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02839201", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 723\n\nFiled 07/12/22\nHaddon,\n\nII\n\nPage 1 of 13\nand\nP.0\nJeffrey S. PagPrima\n150 East 10th Avenue\nDenver, Colorado 80203\nPH 303.831.7364\nFX 303.832.2628\nwww.hmflaw.com\njpogliucaahmtlaw.com\n\na I) I) t, N\n\nN\n\nDecember 16, 2021\nVIA Email\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nUnited States District Court\nSouthern District of New York\n4O Foley Square\nNew York, NY 10007\nRe:\n\nUnited States v. Ghislaine Maxwell, 20 Cr. 330 (AJN)\n\nDear Judge Nathan,\nI write in response to the government's motion to preclude testimony from Eva =,\n, and\n\nThe government claims that testimony from Eva,\n\nand Kelly is inadmissible because: (1) it does not contradict Jane's testimony; and (2) it is\nimproper impeachment on a collateral matter. The government is wrong.\nBACKGROUND\nOn the stand, Jane alleged that several other women were involved in sexual conduct and\ngroup sexualized massages with her, Mr. Epstein, and Ms. Maxwell. These women included Eva,\nand Kelly. TR. at 523-30. Although Jane has not always been consistent with the\ngovernment about the involvement of these women, she testified that all these women were\ninvolved in or could \"confirm\" what happened in the group sexualized massages that are the\n\n'The government also moved to preclude certain testirrafrom John\nof the motion is moot because Ms. Maxwell will not call Mr.\nas a witness.\n\n. That part\n\nEFTA02839201\n\n", "char_count": 1387}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839201", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 723\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nPage 2 of 13\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nDecember 16, 2021\nPage 2\nvery basis ofthe charges in this case. Id. But Eva,\n\nand Kelly will all testify they were\n\nnot involved in and cannot \"confirm\" the group sexualized massages. Their testimony\ncontradicts Jane's testimony, and it is relevant, material, and exculpatory. Finally, the details of\nthe group sexualized messages, which form the very basis of the charges in this case, are not\ncollateral matters. They are what this case is about.\nARGUMENT\n\"Whether rooted directly in the Due Process Clause ..., or in the Compulsory Process or\nConfrontation clauses of the Sixth Amendment, the Constitution guarantees criminal defendants\na meaningful opportunity to present a complete defense.\" Crane v. Kentucky, 476 U.S. 683, 690\n(1986) (quoting California v. Trombetta, 467 U.S. 479, 485 (1984)); see U.S. Const. amends. V,\nVI. A court violates a defendant's right to present a defense when it excludes competent and\nreliable evidence that is central to the defense. See Crane, 476 U.S. at 690. The exclusion of such\nevidence \"deprives a defendant of the basic right to have the prosecutor's case encounter and\n'survive the crucible of meaningful adversarial testing.\"' Id. at 690-91 (quoting United States v.\nCronic, 466 U.S. 648, 656 (1984)).\nThe Constitution also affords Ms. Maxwell the right to confront her accusers. U.S.\namend. VI; Olden v. Kentucky, 488 U.S. 227, 231 (1988). \"[A] criminal defendant states a\nviolation of the Confrontation Clause by showing that [she] was prohibited from engaging in\notherwise appropriate cross-examination designed to show a prototypical form of bias on the part\nof the witness, and thereby 'to expose to the jury the facts from which jurors ... could\nappropriately draw inferences relating to the reliability of the witness.\"' Delaware v. Van\nArsdall, 475 U.S. 673, 680 (1986) (quoting\n\nv. Alaska, 415 U.S. 308, 318 (1974)). \"Cross-\n\nexamination is the\n... [truncated, 2095 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02839201/1 or ?id=EFTA02839201&page=1]", "char_count": 2095}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839201", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 723\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nPage 3 of 13\n\ntestimony are tested.\"\n\nM,\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nDecember 16, 2021\nPage 3\n415 U.S. at 316. The importance of cross-examination cannot be\n\noverstated where, as here, the government's proof depends almost entirely on the uncorroborated\ntestimony of the accusers. Poventud v. City of New York, No. 07 CIV. 3998 DAB, 2015 WL\n1062186, at *8 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 9, 2015) (\"Second Circuit case law ... clearly establishe[s] that\nimpeachment evidence constitutes exculpatory evidence that must be disclosed. The disclosure\nof impeachment evidence, where `the [g]overnment's case depended almost entirely on [the\nvictim's] testimony,' goes to the heart of Brady and Giglio.\" (quoting Giglio v. United States,\n405 U.S. 150, 154-55 (1972))).\nThe standard for relevance is \"very low,\" United States v.\n\n692 F.3d 235, 246 (2d\n\nCir. 2012) (explaining that Rule 401 prescribes a \"very low standard\"), and the definition of\nrelevance is \"very broad,\" United States v. Certified Enwl. Servs., Inc., 753 F.3d 72, 90 (2d Cir.\n2014). \"Evidence is relevant if: (a) it has any tendency to make a fact more or less probable than\nit would be without the evidence; and (b) the fact is of consequence in determining the action.\"\nFed. R. Evid. 401. \"To be relevant, evidence need not be sufficient by itself to prove a fact in\nissue....\" United States v. Abu-Jihaad, 630 F.3d 102, 132 (2d Cir. 2010). \"[U]nless an\nexception applies, all 'relevant evidence is admissible.\"' M,\nThe testimony of Eva,\n\n692 F.3d at 246.\n\n, and Kelly, is relevant, because it makes it less likely that\n\nJane engaged with sexualized massages with Mr. Epstein and Ms. Maxwell. During her\ntestimony, Jane claimed that Eva,\n\nand Kelly were all involved in or could confirm the\n\nsexualized massages involving Jane, Mr. Epstein, and\n\nand Kelly\n\nare going to testify that they were not involved in sexualized massages and cannot \"confirm\"\nJane's story. The testimony of Eva,\n\n, and K\n... [truncated, 2064 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02839201/2 or ?id=EFTA02839201&page=2]", "char_count": 2064}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839201", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 723\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nPage 4 of 13\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nDecember 16, 2021\nPage 4\nthat the alleged sexualized massages occurred. These alleged sexualized massages are the basis\nofthe charges in this case.\nThe government seeks to preclude testimony from Eva,\n\nand Kelly on the\n\nground that their testimony does not contradict Jane's allegations and that, in any event, their\ntestimony concerns \"collateral matters\" The government is wrong on both counts.\nA.\nEva\n\nEva\n\ntestimony will contradict Jane's testimony.\ntestimony will contradict Jane's testimony. As to Eva, this is what Jane\n\ntestified to on the stand:\n•\n\n\"[A] woman named Eva ... joined in\" the group sexualized massages. TR at 525.\n\n•\n\nEva \"joined in [the group sexualized massages] with Sophie.\" Id. at 526.\n\n•\n\nEva \"joined in the group scenario.\" Id.\n\n•\n\nEva \"knew the routine.\" Id.\n\n•\n\nEva \"could confirm her story.\" Id.\nIn her interviews with the government, Jane had this to say about Eva. In a February 2020\n\ninterview with the government, see 3509-008, p 4, Jane said:\n•\n\nJane's first sexual encounter with Mr. Epstein occurred in the pool house. Id. at 4.\n\n•\n\nThe next sexual encounter occurred in the bedroom or the massage room. Id.\n\n•\n\nThere was a short period of time in which the encounters only involved Mr. Epstein. Id.\n\n•\n\nMs. Maxwell then became involved. Id.\n\n•\n\nThe first time Ms. Maxwell was involved, there were two other girls as well—Sophie and\nEva, who joined in. Id.\n\nEFTA02839204\n\n", "char_count": 1510}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839201", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 723\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nPage 5 of 13\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nDecember 16, 2021\nPage 5\n•\n\nThe first time Ms. Maxwell was involved, Ms. Maxwell guided it, but the Sophie and Eva\n\"knew the routine.\" Id.\n\n•\n\nSometimes it started with Mr. Epstein wanting a massage and saying, \"you girls come\nwith me.\"\n\n•\n\nSometimes the girls would make out with each other during these encounters. Id.\n\nEva will contradict this testimony.\nContrary to the government's argument, there is no doubt that Eva\nMaxwell intends to call as a witness, is the same \"Eva\" Jane claimed both during her testimony\nand the February 2020 interview was involved in group sexualized massages with Mr. Epstein\nand \"could confirm her story.\"\n•\n\nVisoski testified that Eva\n\nwas \"one of Mr. Epstein's original first\n\ngirlfriends,\" now his ex-girlfriend, a former Miss Sweden, who went on to marry Glenn\nTR at 262-63.\n•\n\nJane told the government that \"Eva\" was Mr. Epstein's \"ex-girlfriend and they stayed\nfriends.\" See 3509-008 p 7.\n\n•\n\nIn an August 2021 interview with the government, see 3509-020, Jane told the\ngovernment that \"Eva\" was the \"Ms Sweden Lady.\" Id. at 1. Jane said she \"does not\nremember\" Eva \"being involved in massages,\" but maybe Eva \"aged out of that.\" Id.\n\n•\n\nAlthough Jane did not recall Eva being involved in the massages when she spoke with the\ngovernment in August 2021, she admitted that she did \"not recall there being another\nEva.\" Id. at 2.\n\nThe upshot of Jane's statements is this:\n\nEFTA02839205\n\n", "char_count": 1524}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839201", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 723\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nPage 6 of 13\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nDecember 16, 2021\nPage 6\n•\n\nIn February 2020, Jane told the government that Eva was Mr. Epstein's ex-girlfriend and\nthey stayed friends, just as Mr. Visoski testified. When the group massages began to\ninvolve others beyond Mr. Epstein, Ms. Maxwell joined in with Sophie and Eva. Sophie\nand Eva \"knew the routine.\"\n\n•\n\nIn August 2021, Jane told the government that Eva was the \"Ms Sweden Lady\" (Mr.\nVisoski testified that Eva\n\nwas a former Ms. Sweden). At the time, Jane did \"not\n\nremember\" Eva \"being involved in massages,\" but maybe Eva \"aged out of that.\" Id. At\nthe same time, Jane \"did not recall there being another Eva.\"\n•\n\nIn her testimony in this case, Jane told the jury that Eva was involved in the group\nsexualized massages with Mr. Epstein, Sophie, and Ms. Maxwell, that she \"knew the\nroutine,\" and that she \"could confirm her story.\"\nThe record is clear that Jane has previously claimed (in February 2020) and testified (in\n\nthis case) that Eva\n\nwas involved in the sexualized massages with Mr. Epstein and Ms.\n\nMaxwell. Given that allegation, Ms. Maxwell has a constitutional right to call Eva\n\nto the\n\nstand and present her testimony, which will deny the allegations and contradict Jane's claims.\nPerhaps hoping this Court won't notice, the government buries most of the facts about\nJane's allegations about Eva in a footnote. Gov. Letter, pp 5-6 n. 1. But even that footnote\nmischaracterizes what Jane said about Eva. Jane did not tell the government that Eva\n\nwas\n\nnot involved in group sexualized massages. At most, Jane said she \"does not remember\nbeing involved in massages.\" See 3509-020, p 1. But that's contrary to what she said in February\n2020, and it's contrary to what she said on the stand. And it's wholly inconsistent with Jane's\nstatement that she \"does not recall there being another Eva.\" Id. at 2.\n\nEFTA02839206\n\n", "char_count": 1946}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839201", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 723\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nPage 7 of 13\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nDecember 16, 2021\nPage 7\nMs. Maxwell has a right to present the testimony of Eva, who will deny Jane's\nallegations of being involved in the group sexualized massages that are the basis of the charges\nin this case.\nB.\n\nMichell\n\ntestimony will contradict Jane's testimony.\n\ntestimony will also contradict Jane's testimony. As to la\n\nthis is what\n\nJane testified to on the stand:\n•\n\nThere was a fourth woman Jane remembers, named\n\n•\n\nJane hung out with\n\nwho was short. TR at 526.\n\nand Emmy and sometimes went out with\n\nand\n\nEmmy. Id. at 527. 2\n•\n\n\"was also involved in the sexual contact.\" Id.\n\n•\n\nwas also involved in \"group massages.\" Id.\nThe government did not examine Jane on any of these points, and it did not ask Jane\n\nwhether\n\nwas only involved in group massages with Mr. Epstein after Jane attained the\n\nage of 17.3 Nor did the government ask Jane during its interviews when\n\nwas involved\n\n2 The government's letter convenient) omits this testimony from Jane, which, as\nis the\nwho Jane alleged was involved\ndescribed below, establishes that\nin group sexualized massages.\n3 The government's attempt to bootstrap Rule 412 into its motion fails. Gov. Letter, p 7.\nIn her interview with the government, Jane said she was involved with sexualized massages with\nin New York when she was \"young.\" See 3509-001, p 4. Even if, based on Jane's trial\ntesumon , one might infer she was 17 years old at the time of the sexualized massages with\n,she\nsaid something different in her interviews with the government. And in any event,\nbecause the sexualized massages are the very conduct at issue in this case and are not collateral,\nMs. Maxwell does not have to accept Jane's trial testimony as the last word on the issue. \"The\nlaw of evidence has long recognized that a cross-examiner is not required to 'take the answer'\nof a witness on a non-collateral issue, United States v. Harvey, 547 F.2d 720, 722 (2d C\n... [truncated, 2095 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02839201/6 or ?id=EFTA02839201&page=6]", "char_count": 2095}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839201", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 723\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nPage 8 of 13\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nDecember 16, 2021\nPage 8\nin the group massages. To the contrary, in a September 2019 interview, Jane told the government\nthat Emmy and\n\n\"were involved in the sexual contact.\" See 3509-001, p 4. Jane made\n\nthis claim about\n\nwhen discussing the abuse she claims to have suffered in New York\n\nwhen she was \"young.\" Id.\ntestimony will contradict Jane's testimony because she will deny being\ninvolved in the sexualized massages that Jane claims she was a part of.\nContrary to the government's argument, there is no doubt\nMaxwell intends to call as a witness, is the same''\n\nwho Jane claimed both during her\n\ntestimony and her September 2019 interview was involved in group sexualized massages with\nMr. Epstein. Jane told the government in September 2019 that\nintroduced Jane to''\nshort, and\n\nwas \"short\" and that she\n\nRussians,\" a vodka cocktail. See 3509-001, p 4.\n\nwill testify that she drinks\n\nis\n\nRussians. And, as Jane testified on the\n\nwill testify that she was good friends with Emmy Taylor, a point the government\n\nstand,\n\nignores in its letter.\nAs with Eva, Ms. Maxwell has a right to present the testimony of\n\nwho will\n\ndeny Jane's allegations of being involved the group sexualized massages that are the basis of the\ncharges in this case.'\n\n4\n\nhas other relevant testimony to offer, in addition to contradicting Jane's\naccount of the group sexualized massages. The government does not challenge this other\ntestimony.\n\nEFTA02839208\n\n", "char_count": 1537}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839201", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 723\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nPage 9 of 13\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nDecember 16, 2021\nPage 9\ntestimony will contradict Jane's testimony.\n\nC.\n\nKelly's testimony will also contradict Jane's testimony. As to Kelly, this is what Jane\ntestified to on the stand:\n•\n\nKelly was \"another person [Jane] remembered.\" TR at 527.\n\n•\n\nJane remembered Kelly's last name. Id.\n\n•\n\nKelly was a model who was older than her. Id.\n\n•\n\nKelly could \"back up what [Jane] was talking about.\" Id.\nDuring her February 2020 interview with the government, Jane told agents that Kelly's\n\nlast name was 'n\n\nand that Jane \"felt [Kelly] could back up what [Jane] had talked about\n\nregarding Maxwell. Jane described Kelly as being a model, who was older than [Jane] and knew\nEpstein and Maxwell before she did.\" See 3509-008, p 5-6.\nKelly's testimony will contradict Jane's testimony because Kelly will nor back up Jane's\naccount of the sexualized group massages. And there is no doubt\nMaxwell intends to call as a witness, is the same \"Kelly\" who Jane claimed was \"back up\" what\nJane alleged. Jane admitted that Kelly's last name was 'n.'\nAs with Eva and\n\n,\n\nMaxwell has a right to present the testimony of Kelly,\n\nwho will contradict Jane's testimony about the sexualized massages that are the very basis of the\ncharges in this case.\nD.\n\nThese are not collateral matters.\n\nThe government's invocation of Rule 608 and the phrase \"collateral issue\" miss the mark\nentirely. As to Rule 608, the testimony of Eva,\n\n, and Kelly is not being offered \"to prove\n\nspecific instances of a witness's conduct in order to attack or support the witness's character for\n\nEFTA02839209\n\n", "char_count": 1668}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839201", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 723\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nPage 10 of 13\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nDecember 16, 2021\nPage 10\ntruthfulness.\" Fed. R. Evid. 608(b). Their testimony is direct evidence about the very conduct at\nissue in this case—the alleged sexualized massages that form the basis of the charges. Jane says\nshe was abused during group sexualized massages with Mr. Epstein and others and that these\nother people could confirm her story or back up what she was saying. Ms. Maxwell is entitled to\ncall Eva,\n\nand Kelly, who will deny being involved in the group sexualized massages,\n\nwhich are the basis of the charges in this case, and will do anything but \"back up\" or \"confirm\"\nwhat Jane has alleged.\nThese are not \"collateral\" issues. As the Notes to Rule 608 make clear, the bar on\n\"extrinsic evidence applies only when the sole reason for proffering that evidence is to attack or\nsupport the witness' character for truthfulness.\" Fed. R. Evid. 608, Advisory Committee Notes,\n2003 Amendments. Here, Eva,IMM, and Kelly's testimony is not being offered to attack\nJane's \"character for truthfulness.\" To the contrary, it is being offered to show that the\nsexualized massages did not happen.\nJane has claimed that Eva,\n\n, and Kelly are essentially eyewitnesses to the abuse\n\nshe allegedly suffered at the hands of Mr. Epstein and\n\nand Kelly\n\nwill deny that. The testimony of an \"eyewitness\" to the very conduct alleged to be criminal is not\na \"collateral issue.\"\nRule 608 bars \"extrinsic evidence only if the sole purpose for offering the evidence was\nto prove the witness' character for veracity.\" Id. Contradiction testimony about the conduct at\nissue, which is what Eva,\n\nand Kelly will provide, is never collateral. Id. (\"By limiting\n\nthe application of the Rule to proof of a witness' character for truthfulness, the amendment\nleaves the admissibility of extrinsic evidence offered for other grounds of impeachment (such as\n\nEFTA02839210\n\n", "char_count": 1955}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839201", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 723\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nPage 11of 13\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nDecember 16, 2021\nPage 11\ncontradiction, prior inconsistent statement, bias and mental capacity) to Rules 402 and 403.\").5\nCf. United States v. Schuler, 458 F.3d 1148, 1155 (10th Cir. 2006) (\"[A] matter is collateral if it\ncould not have been introduced in evidence for any purpose other than impeachment.\").\nE.\n\nThe government's other arguments fail.\n\nThe government offers three other arguments. First, the government faults Ms. Maxwell\nfor not showing Jane pictures of Eva,\n\nand Kelly. Nothing required Ms. Maxwell to do\n\nthat, and the government cites no authority for its argument.\nWhat's more telling is that the government never showed Jane their photographs. The\ngovernment's deliberate choice to muddy the waters is not Ms. Maxwell's fault or her problem.\nThe record shows Eva =,\n\nMI, and\n\nare the \"Eva,\" `1\n\n1,\" and\n\n\"Kelly\" who Jane testified about. Their testimony is admissible.\nSecond, it's irrelevant that Ms. Maxwell did not use last names in her examination of\nJane. For one thing, Jane also did not use last names in her interviews with the FBI. For another\nthing, Eva\n\nname was already on the record from Mr. Visoski's testimony, and Jane\n\nadmitted knowing Kelly's last name. Finally, Ms. Maxwell did not use\n\nlast name in\n\npart because she intended to ask this Court for anonymity. It's immaterial that this Court\nsubsequently denied that request.\nFinally, the government mistakenly relies on cases purporting to hold that a defendant,\nthrough cross-examination, cannot open the door to proving collateral issues by extrinsic\n\n5 The government quite rightly does not make a 403 argument. And its relevance\nargument—that the testimony of Eva,\n, and Kelly does not contradict Jane's\ntestimony—is wrong, as described above.\n\nEFTA02839211\n\n", "char_count": 1855}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839201", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 723\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nPage 12 of 13\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nDecember 16, 2021\nPage 12\nevidence. Gov. Letter, pp 3, 8. Even if that is what those cases hold (which Ms. Maxwell\ndisputes), the cases have no applicability here, because the details of the sexualized massages are\nnot collateral issues. They are the central issues in this case.\nAt best, the government's arguments go to weight, not admissibility. If the government\nwants to argue that Eva M,\n\nand\n\nare not the Eva,\n\nand\n\nKelly who Jane was referring to, the government is free to make that argument. In fact, the\ngovernment has already made precisely that argument as to\nflight logs' use of the name\n\n, responding to the\n\nBut that argument is no basis for denying Ms. Maxwell her\n\nconstitutional right to present a defense. U.S. Const. amends. V, VI.\nCONCLUSION\nThis Court should deny the government's motion.\n\nEFTA02839212\n\n", "char_count": 927}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839201", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 723\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nPage 13 of 13\n\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nDecember 16, 2021\nPage 13\n\nJeffrey S. Pagliuca\nLaura A. Mennin er\nHADDON,\n&\n150 East 10th Avenue\nDenver, CO 80203\nPhone: 303-831-7364\n\nP.C.\n\nChristian R. Everdell\n& GRESSER LLP\n800 Third Avenue\nNew York, NY 10022\nPhone: 212-957-7600\nBobbi C. Sternheim\nLaw Offices of Bobbi C. Sternheim\n225 Broadway, Suite 715\nNew York, NY 10007\nPhone: 212-243-1100\nAttorneysfor Ghislaine Maxwell\n\ncc: Counsel of record (via email)\n\nEFTA02839213\n\n", "char_count": 530}]}