{"efta_number": "EFTA02839091", "page_count": 12, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02839091", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02839091.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02839091", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 706\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nPage 1 of 12\n\nU.S. Department of Justice\nUnited States Attorney\nSouthern District ofNew York\n\nThe Silvio J. Mello Building\nOne Saint Andrew's Plaza\nNew York New York 10007\n\nDecember 15, 2021\nThe Honorable Alison J. Nathan\nUnited States District Court\nSouthern District of New York\nUnited States Courthouse\n40 Foley Square\nNew York, New York 10007\nRe:\n\nUnited Stain v. Ghislaine Maxwell, S2 20 Cr. 330 (AJN)\n\nDear Judge Nathan:\nThe Government respectfully submits this motion to preclude certain testimony of certain\ndefense witnesses. After reviewing the defendant's witness list and related material, it appears\nthat certain witnesses are expected to testify about matters that are irrelevant, prejudicial, or\nimproper impeachment.\nSpecifically, the Government moves to preclude the following:\n•\n\nTestimony from Eva MI,\n\nor\n\nabout whether they\n\nparticipated in a sexualized massage with Jane;\n•\n\nTestimony from Alexander\n\nas contained in the affidavit attached as Exhibit\n\nA;\n•\n\nTestimony from Dr. Loftus about suggestive activities that did not occur in this case;\n\nEFTA02839091\n\n", "char_count": 1136}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839091", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 706\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nPage 2 of 12\n\nand\n•\n\nTestimony from John\n\nI.\n\nApplicable Law\n\nabout undisclosed exhibits.\n\nFederal Rule of Evidence 402 provides that \"Dimlevant evidence is not admissible.\"\nAccordingly, any evidence that does not bear on the defendant's guilt or innocence of the charges\nin the indictment should be excluded as irrelevant. Rule 403 further states that the Court may\n\"exclude relevant evidence if its probative value is substantially outweighed by a danger of one or\nmore of the following: unfair prejudice, confusing the issues, misleading the jury, undue delay,\nwasting time, or needlessly presenting cumulative evidence.\"\nAs a general matter, \"extrinsic evidence is not admissible to prove specific instances of a\nwitness's conduct in order to attack or support the witness's character for truthfulness.\" Fed. R.\nEvid. 608(b). The Rules permit extrinsic evidence for \"other grounds of impeachment (such as\ncontradiction, prior inconsistent statement, bias, and mental capacity).\" United States v. M,\n469 F. Supp. 3d 193, 227 (S.D.N.Y. 2019) (quoting Fed. R. Evid. 608(b) Advisory Committee\nNotes). But even then, \"[e]xtrinsic evidence offered for impeachment on a collateral issue is\nproperly excluded.\" UnitedStates v.\n\n, 144 F.3d 241, 245-46 (2d Cir. 1998); see UnitedSates\n\nv. Dore, No. 12 Cr. 45 (RJS), 2013 WL 3965281, at *6 (S.D.N.Y. July 31, 2013) (M,\n\nJ.)\n\n(\"[T]he Second Circuit has held . . . that introduction of extrinsic proof of a prior inconsistent\nstatement is only appropriate as it relates to matters which are not collateral, i.e., as to those matters\nwhich are relevant to the issues in the case and could be independently proven.\" (internal quotation\nmarks omitted)).\nSpecifically, while the doctrine of \"impeachment by contradiction . .. operates as a limited\n2\n\nEFTA02839092\n\n", "char_count": 1856}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839091", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 706\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nPage 3 of 12\n\nexception to Rule 608(b),\" United States v. Ramirez, 609 F.3d 495, 499 (2d Cir. 2010) (internal\nquotation marks omitted), it is permitted in only narrow circumstances. As an initial matter,\nimpeachment by contradiction is only available when a witness \"in his direct testimony falsely\nstates a specific fact.\" United States v.\n\n, 900 F.2d 571, 575 (2d Cir. 1990) (emphasis added);\n\nsee also Ramirez, 609 F.3d at 500 n.1 (explaining the Court's \"reluctan[ce] to extend\" the\nimpeachment-by-contradiction doctrine to the situation where the testimony to be contradicted is\nfirst elicited on cross-examination); United States v. Benedetto, 571 F.2d 1246, 1250 (2d Cir. 1978)\n(impeachment by contradiction available after a witness testifies to a \"specific fact on direct\ntestimony\" (emphasis added));\n\nFed. Prac. & Procedure § 6119 (explaining that\n\n\"if the cross-examiner is able to open the door for himself on cross, this would undermine the\nexclusionary rules avoided, such as Rule 608(b)\"). Accordingly, if a party elicits a statement on\ncross-examination that did not come out on direct examination, the party is bound by the answer\nand may not offer extrinsic evidence to contradict it. See United States v. Crowley, 318 F.3d 401,\n416 (2d Cir. 2003) (explaining that defense counsel could inquire on cross about alleged false\naccusations by a victim whose credibility was \"obviously a critical issue at trial,\" but could not\noffer extrinsic evidence to refute denials); Jack B. Weinstein & Margaret A. Berger, Weinstein's\nFederal Evidence § 608.22[1] (2d ed. 1997) (noting that, under Rule 608(b), if a witness denies\nhaving engaged in alleged untruthful conduct on cross-examination, \"the examiner must take (or\nis bound by) the witness's answer\").\n\nImpeachment by contradiction, like other bases of\n\nimpeachment, is not available \"on a collateral issue.\" United States v. M,\n\nNo. 10 Cr. 627\n\n(KAM), 2013 WL 5423748, at •28 (E.D\n... [truncated, 2071 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02839091/2 or ?id=EFTA02839091&page=2]", "char_count": 2071}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839091", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nII.\n\nDocument 706\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nThe Court Should Preclude Testimony by Eva\nAbout Sexualized Massages with Jane\n\nPage 4 of 12\n\n, or\n\nIt appears that the defendant seeks to offer testimony from Eva =,\n\nand\n\nthat they did not participate in sexualized massages with Jane. This testimony would\nnot contradict Jane's testimony at all. But even if it did, such contradiction is impeachment about\na collateral matter through extrinsic evidence, and it is impeachment of supposedly contradictory\nstatements made on cross examination, rather than on direct examination, each of which renders\nimpeachment improper. Such testimony should be precluded.\nA. Factual Background\nOn cross-examination, the defense asked Jane a series of questions about what she had told\nthe Government about other participants in group sexual encounters with Epstein and the\ndefendant. Tr. 523-24. In the course of that testimony, Jane confirmed that she \"told the\nGovernment\" there was \"a woman named Eva\" who \"joined in\" with another woman. Tr. 525-26.\nShe also \"remembered\" another participant \"named n\n\nwho was \"short.\" Tr. 526-27. And\n\nfinally, Jane \"remembered\" a participant \"name Kelly,\" whose last name Jane also \"remembered,\"\nand who Jane thought was \"a model who was older than [Jane].\" Tr. 527.\nDefense counsel confirmed that Jane told the Government that Jane thought she could\nrecognize photos of at least a few of the participants, but the Government had not shown her photos\nof Eva.\n\nor Kelly. Tr. 527, 530. Despite this line of questioning, defense counsel did not\n\nshow Jane photos on the stand or ask Jane for last names of any of these individuals or any other\nidentifying information.\nB. Discussion\nThe Government expects that the defendant plans to call Eva =,\n\n=,\n\nand\n\n4\n\nEFTA02839094\n\n", "char_count": 1804}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839091", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 706\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nPage 5 of 12\n\nto testify that they did not participate in group sexualized massages with Jane,\nEpstein, and the defendant. The Court should preclude this testimony, which does not contradict\nJane's, and is in any event improper impeachment about a topic of cross-examination that is\ncollateral to the case.\nFirst, the anticipated testimony does not contradict Jane's. Jane testified that she had told\nthe Government that she remembered group sexualized massages involving \"Eva,\" '\n\n19\n\nand \"Kelly.\" Defense counsel did not ask Jane, and Jane did not testify, that these people were\nEva =,\n\nor\n\n. The defense had an opportunity to elicit specific\n\nnames or identities from Jane, such as by eliciting a last name or pointing to a photograph, but they\nchose not to do so. Indeed, defense counsel elicited no description of Eva, and only elicited that\nwas \"short.\" (Tr. 527). With respect to Kelly, defense counsel only asked whether Jane\ntold the Government that Kelly was an older model whose last name Jane knew—but then chose\nnot to elicit that last name. (Id.)\nHaving failed to develop the record, defense counsel cannot now attempt to impeach Jane's\ntestimony by calling specific individuals they claim are Eva,\n\nand Kelly. Indeed, as\n\ndefense counsel is aware, Jane had previously been asked in meetings with the Government about\nEva\n\nand she answered that she knew\n\nand \"does not remember\n\ninvolved in massages.\" See 3509-020 at 1. That is, Jane knows who Eva\nthat Eva\n\nbeing\n\nis and has denied\n\nwas involved in sexualized massages. See id.' Testimony from Eva\n\nthat\n\nIn her interviews with the Government, Jane has not always agreed that another \"Eva\" exists who\nparticipated in massages, as she testified on the stand. Compare 3509-008 at 4 (recalling that Eva\nwould join in) and 3509-009 at 7 (unclear notation in the notes underlying 3509-008 about the\nname of the person who joined the massage) with 3509-020 at 2 (not recalling another \n... [truncated, 2111 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02839091/4 or ?id=EFTA02839091&page=4]", "char_count": 2111}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839091", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 706\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nPage 6 of 12\n\nshe did not engage in sexualized massages with Jane therefore in no way contradicts Jane's\ntestimony.\nSimilarly, attempting to identify\nbasis in the record.\n\nas the\n\nwas far from the only\n\nJane mentioned lacks a\nin the defendant and Epstein's\n\nworld. For instance, the list of masseuses in the exhibit marked for identification as Government\nExhibit 417 includes three entries for various people named\nname\n\n, none identified with the last\n\n. And although Jane has previously told the Government that\n\nwas\n\ninvolved in group sexualized encounters with her, she did not so testify under oath, and that fact\nwas not put before the jury. Contrary testimony now from\n\nwould only confuse the\n\njury, and not contradict any of Jane's testimony.'\nSecond, even if the anticipated testimony did impeach Jane's testimony, it does so only on\na collateral matter, namely, Jane's adult sexual activity. The only time marker the defendant\nelicited in connection with any of Eva, a\n\nor Kelly is testimony that Jane knew\n\nwhile Jane was living in New York. (Tr. 533). As Jane testified on direct, she moved to New\n\nknowledge of sexualized massages involving Eva =.\nSee 3509-008 at 7 (explaining that Jane\nwas \"not sure if [the Eva on the flight records—that is Eva\nI was part of the massages\");\n3509-020 (explaining that Jane \"does not remember\nbeing involved in massages\").\n2 Even if the defense had elicited the last names of the individuals Jane had in mind, their testimony\nstill would not contradict Jane's. Defense counsel asked Jane whether she told the Government\nabout Eva,\n, and Kelly. Jane was not asked, and did not testify, that these individuals in\nfact participated in the group sexualized massages. If\n, M, and\ntestify that they\ndid not, it in no way contradicts Jane's testimony about what she did and did not tell the\nGovernment in a prior interview. Although defense counsel asked Jane whether Eva and Kelly—\nbut not _--could\nconf\n... [truncated, 2379 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02839091/5 or ?id=EFTA02839091&page=5]", "char_count": 2379}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839091", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 706\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nPage 7 of 12\n\nYork when she was 17 to attend Professional Children's School. (Tr. 349).\nJane's sexual activity when she was an adult is entirely collateral to this case. Consistent\nwith Rule 412, the parties could not have offered independent evidence about who else participated\nin Jane's sexual activity over the age of consent. See Dore, 2013 WL 3965281, at *6 (defining\n\"matters which are not collateral\" as \"those matters which are relevant to the issues in the case and\ncould be independently proven.\"). Accordingly, as the Government explained as part of the\nlitigation over Rule 412, the Government offered only brief testimony on direct about Jane's\nrelationships after the age of consent in order to conclude the narrative. (See 11/10/21 Tr. at 160).\nSpecifically, the Government asked about five questions establishing that, after Jane moved to\nNew York and turned 18, she spent time with the defendant and Epstein and continued engaging\nin sexualized massages. (Tr. 349-50).\nThe defendant proposes to do something quite different. The anticipated testimony is, at\nleast in part, an attempt to substantively impeach Jane on the identities of individuals with whom\nshe had adult sexual contact.\n\nBoth are not relevant or subjects of independent proof in\nthis case—they are collateral.\nThird, even if the anticipated testimony did impeach Jane, and even if the testimony were\nabout a non-collateral matter, it is impeachment by contradiction of a fact elicited on crossexamination. This is precisely the sort of impeachment that the rules are intended to prohibit.\nAbsent Jane's testimony on cross, it would be irrelevant and improper for the defendant to call\nwitnesses to say that they did not have sexual activity with Jane and the defendant. Through\n7\n\nEFTA02839097\n\n", "char_count": 1834}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839091", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 706\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nPage 8 of 12\n\nleading questions about what Jane told the Government, the defendant has attempted to establish\na basis for impeachment by contradiction. As the Second Circuit explained in Ramirez and as\nagree, it undermines the Federal Rules ofEvidence to use cross to open a door to\nput extrinsic evidence before the jury that is otherwise prohibited by those Rules. See Ramirez,\n609 F.3d at 500 n.1;\n\n&\n\nFed. Prac. & Procedure § 6119. The Court should not permit\n\nit.\nIII.\n\nThe Court Should Preclude Testimony by Alexander\nBy His Affidavit\n\nThe defendant intends to call Alexander\n\nAs Captured\n\nand, in Rule 26.2 discovery, produced\n\nan affidavit from him that is attached as Exhibit A. This appears to be the signed declaration the\ndefense referenced on cross of Kate, in which the\nNone of the topics in the affidavit are\nadmissible evidence, and the Court should preclude testimony from\n\nalong those lines.\n\nSecond, the affidavit says that Kate was a \"coke head.\" (Ex. A l 14). Kate already testified\nthat she was addicted to cocaine during the relevant time period. Tr. 1205. This evidence is\ntherefore not impeaching as to the relevant time period.\n\n8\n\nEFTA02839098\n\n", "char_count": 1226}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839091", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nLW' I\n\nDocument 706\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nPage 9 of 12\n\nI\n\n3 When the defense did ask Kate about these statements on the stand,\n\nTot e\nextent\ntestimony on t s point rs o e as a pnor inconsistent statement o Kate's, she\nwas not given an opportunity to deny it, as required by Rule 613(b).\n9\n\nEFTA02839099\n\n", "char_count": 324}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839091", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 706\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nPage 10 of 12\n\nJust as extrinsic evidence on this point was improper during Kate's cross, so it\nis improper now.\nFinally,\n\nrank speculation about Kate's motives and intent are not probative\nof any issue in the case.\nThe remainder of the affidavit is simply background information about\n\nand his\n\nrelationship with Kate. Accordingly, the affidavit reflects no admissible testimony that\nmight offer, and he should be precluded from testifying to its contents.\nIV.\n\nThe Court Should Preclude Testimony from Dr. Loftus That Does Not Fit the\nFacts of the Case\n\nThe Government understands that the Court has ruled that Dr. Loftus may testify and is not\nseeking to relitigate that issue. However, in reviewing transcripts of Dr. Loftus's testimony in\nother trials, it appears that Dr. Loftus has testified about the suggestive effects of (a) the use of\nleading questions by Government investigators and (b) pressure from therapists to provide more\ndetails about prior experiences (known as \"response pressure\"). Although it is unclear precisely\nwhat \"suggestive activities\" Dr. Loftus will discuss while on the stand, she should be precluded\nfrom any testimony about activities which do not fit the case.\nAs the Court has concluded, \"one aspect of the Rule 702 and Dauber: inquiry is 'fit,' which\nasks 'whether expert testimony proffered in the case is sufficiently tied to the facts of the case that it\nwill aid the jury in resolving a factual dispute.'\" (11/22/21 Mem. Op. & Order at 4). For an expert\nopinion to \"fit,\" the opinion must \"assist the jury's decision on a relevant question of fact .\n\n.\"\n\n(Id.); see Fed. R. Evid. 702 advisory committee notes (explaining that generalized testimony must\n10\n\nEFTA02839100\n\n", "char_count": 1768}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839091", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 706\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nPage 11 of 12\n\n\"'fit' the facts of the case\"). \"Expert evidence can be both powerful and quite misleading because\nof the difficulty in evaluating it. Because of this risk, the judge in weighing possible prejudice\nagainst probative force under Rule 403 . . . exercises more control over experts than over lay\nwitnesses.\" Daubert v. Metre!! Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc., 509 U.S. 579, 595 (1993) (internal\nquotation marks and citations omitted).\nDr. Loftus has elsewhere testified that leading questions by the Government and response\npressure can create suggestive memories. But at no time has the defendant elicited testimony from\nJane, Kate, Carolyn, or Annie that they were asked such questions or subject to such pressure.\nAccordingly, testimony from Dr. Loftus on that point does not fit the facts of the case and has no\nprobative value. It also would substantially prejudice the Government by suggesting to the jury—\nwithout evidence—that the Government or a therapist manufactured false memories in the Minor\nVictims. Dr. Loftus's opinion on suggestive activities therefore should not contain testimony\nabout Government questioning or response pressure exerted by therapists.\nV.\n\nThe Court Should Preclude Testimony from John\nExhibits\n\nFinally, the Court should preclude testimony from John\n\nAbout Undisclosed\nabout undisclosed exhibits.\n\nis expected to testify about financial records in the case. Although the defendant sent a\nletter purporting to notice\n\nas an expert witness in an abundance of caution, the Government\n\nunderstands from conferring with the defense that the defendant does not plan to elicit expert\ntestimony from him.'\n\nThe Government has also received no supplemental expert notice for\nAs the Government\nexplained in its motion to preclude expert testimony from =,\nthe original expert notice was\ninsufficient.\nII\n\nEFTA02839101\n\n", "char_count": 1906}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02839091", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 706\n\nFiled 07/12/22\n\nThe Government has no objection to fact testimony from\n\nPage 12 of 12\n\nabout the admitted\n\nexhibits. On December 13, however, defense counsel informed the Government that they may\nreceive and produce financial records about which they would ask John\n\nto testify. Such\n\nrecords have not been produced to the Government as of the time of this letter. The Court should\nnot permit the defense to produce and introduce additional financial records between now and\ntestimony. The account statements showing the financial transactions that the Government\nproved at trial were all produced to the defense more than a year before trial. Production of new\nexhibits at this late date would violate Rule 16 and would likely prejudice the Government.\nVI.\n\nConclusion\n\nFor the reasons set forth above, the Court should deny the defendant's motion.\n\nRespectfully submitted,\nDAMIAN\nUnited States Attorney\n\nBy:\n\ns/\nMaurene Comey\nAlison Moe\nLam Pomerantz\nAndrew Rohrbach\nAssistant United States Attorneys\nSouthern District of New York\n\nCc: Defense Counsel (by e-mail)\n\n12\n\nEFTA02839102\n\n", "char_count": 1123}]}