{"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_count": 55, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02838374", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02838374.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 1 of 55\n\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK\n\nUNITED STATES OF AMERICA\nS2 20 Cr. 330 (AJN)\nGHISLAINE MAXWELL,\nDefendant.\nx\n\nTHE GOVERNMENT'S SENTENCING MEMORANDUM\n\nDAMIAN\nUnited States Attorney\nSouthern District of New York\nAttorney for the United States of America\n\nMaurene Comey\nAlison Moe\nLara Pomerantz\nAndrew Rohrbach\nAssistant United States Attorneys\n- Of Counsel -\n\nEFTA02838374\n\n", "char_count": 469}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 2 of 55\n\nTable of Contents\nPRELIMINARY STATEMENT\nI.\n\nBackground\n\n1\n3\n\nA.\n\nThe Investigation\n\n3\n\nB.\n\nThe Charges\n\n4\n\nC.\n\nSummary of Proof at Trial\n\n5\n\n1.\n\nSexual Abuse of Jane\n\n2.\n\nSexual Abuse of Kate\n\n8\n9\n\n3.\n\nSexual Abuse of\n\n10\n\n4.\n\nSexual Abuse of\n\n12\n\n5.\n\nSexual Abuse of Carolyn\n\n12\n\n6.\n\nSexual Abuse of Melissa\n\n14\n\nII.\n\nThe Pre-Sentence Report and Sentencing Guidelines\n\n14\n\nThe 2004 Sentencing Guidelines Manual Applies\n\n16\n\nA.\nI.\n\nThe Court, and not the Jury, Determines Which Manual to Apply\n\n19\n\n2.\n\nThe Sex Trafficking Conspiracy Continued to 2005\n\n19\n\n3.\n\nThe Court Should Apply the 2004 Manual\n\n21\n\nB.\n\nThe Four-Point Leadership Enhancement Applies\n\n28\n\nC.\n\nThe Two-Point \"Undue Influence\" Enhancement Applies\n\n28\n\nD.\n\nThe Five-Level Enhancement in Section 4B1.5 Applies\n\n31\n\nIII.\n\nDiscussion\n\nA.\n\nB.\nIV.\n\n34\n\nThe Defendant's Conduct Warrants a Term of Imprisonment Within the Guidelines\nRange of 360 to 660 Months' Imprisonment\n34\nI.\n\nThe Nature and Seriousness of the Offense\n\n34\n\n2.\n\nHistory and Characteristics of the Defendant\n\n41\n\n3.\n\nThe Need to Promote Respect for the Law and to Afford Adequate Deterrence\n\n43\n\nThe Defendant's Arguments for a Lenient Sentence Are Unpersuasive\nFinancial Penalties\n\nCONCLUSION\n\n44\n50\n53\n\nEFTA02838375\n\n", "char_count": 1317}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 3 of 55\n\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK\n\nUNITED STATES OF AMERICA\nS2 20 Cr. 330 (AJN)\nGHISLAINE MAXWELL,\nDefendant.\nx\nPRELIMINARY STATEMENT\nGhislaine Maxwell played an instrumental role in the horrific sexual abuse of multiple\nyoung teenage girls. As part of a disturbing agreement with Jeffrey Epstein, Maxwell identified,\ngroomed, and abused multiple victims, while she enjoyed a life of extraordinary luxury and\nprivilege. In her wake, Maxwell left her victims permanently scarred with emotional and\npsychological injuries. That damage can never be undone, but it can be accounted for in crafting\na just sentence for Maxwell's crimes.\nThe Government respectfully submits this memorandum in connection with the sentencing\nof Maxwell in the above-captioned case, which is scheduled for June 28, 2022, and in response to\nthe defendant's June 15, 2022 sentencing memorandum and objections to the Pre-Sentence\nInvestigation Report prepared by the United States Probation Office. For the reasons set forth\nbelow, the Government maintains that under the United States Sentencing Guidelines (the\n\"Guidelines\" or \"U.S.S.G.\"), the applicable sentencing range is 360 months to life imprisonment.\nBecause the statutory maximum penalty is 660 months' imprisonment, the Guidelines range\nbecomes 360 to 660 months' imprisonment.\n\nEFTA02838376\n\n", "char_count": 1419}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 4 of 55\n\nGiven the exceptionally serious nature of the defendant's years-long participation in the\nsexual abuse of minors, consideration of the relevant factors under 18 U.S.C. § 3553(a) weighs\nheavily in favor of a sentence within the Guidelines range of 360 to 660 months' imprisonment.\nMost significantly, the nature and seriousness of the offense, the harm to victims, the need to\npromote respect for the law, and the history and characteristics of the defendant weigh heavily in\nfavor of a Guidelines sentence.\nThe Government addresses each of these factors in turn below. However, certain aspects\nof the defendant's submission bear addressing up front. First, the Court should reject the\ndefendant's request for a reduced sentence in light of conditions at the Metropolitan Detention\nCenter. The defendant's claims are inaccurate—and in fact, the defendant has enjoyed remarkable\nprivileges as a high-profile inmate that vastly exceed the benefits accorded to the average inmate.\nIt is unsurprising that a woman who had led a life of incredible luxury should complain about her\nlife as a prisoner, but that fact does not come close to meriting leniency at sentencing, much less\nthe extraordinary degree of leniency the defendant seeks.\nIf anything stands out from the defendant's sentencing submission, it is her complete\nfailure to address her offense conduct and her utter lack of remorse. Instead of showing even a\nhint of acceptance of responsibility, the defendant makes a desperate attempt to cast blame\nwherever else she can. On that score, the defendant's attempt to cast aspersions on the Government\nfor prosecuting her, and her claim that she is being held responsible for Epstein's crimes, are both\nabsurd and offensive. Maxwell was an adult who made her own choices. She made the choice to\nsexually exploit numerous underage girls. She made the choice to conspire with Epstein for years,\nworking as partners in crime and ca\n... [truncated, 2162 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/3 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=3]", "char_count": 2162}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 5 of 55\n\nThe Government agrees that the defendant should be sentenced for her own conduct: she\ncommitted terrible crimes that caused irreparable harm to vulnerable children. Her own criminal\nactions demand that she serve every day of a Guidelines sentence in prison.\nI.\n\nBackground\nA.\n\nThe Investigation\n\nThe U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York opened its investigation\ninto Jeffrey Epstein and his co-conspirators in late November 2018. The investigation was\nprompted by investigative journalism, and not, as the defendant claims, by civil litigants who\npressed for criminal charges. In light of the covert nature of the investigation, the Government\ninterviewed a small group of witnesses and charged Epstein as soon as it was able to, obtaining an\nindictment against Epstein approximately six months later, on July 2, 2019, and arresting Epstein\non July 6, 2019. (PSR1 21). That initial phase of the investigation remained intentionally narrow\nin order to keep the circle of people aware of a federal investigation into Epstein small to avoid\njeopardizing the investigation before Epstein could be apprehended.\nThe Government's investigation expanded upon charging Epstein, and several additional\nvictims came forward after the charges were announced. After Epstein's death in August 2019,\nthe Government continued that same investigation, which included interviewing several victims.\nAmong the victims the Government interviewed were individuals identified on the record in this\ncase as \"Jane\" and \"Kate\" (both of whom agreed to be interviewed by the Government for the first\ntime) as well as\n\n. The Government obtained the original Indictment against the\n\ndefendant—which related to the abuse of Jane, Kate, and\n\n—in late June 2020. In\n\nMarch 2021, the Government obtained a superseding indictment charging the defendant—which\nadded counts relating to the defendant's abuse of an additional minor victim, Caroly\n... [truncated, 2029 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/4 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=4]", "char_count": 2029}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 6 of 55\n\nnew evidence that was not available to the Government at the time the defendant was indicted in\nlate June 2020 or at the time Jeffrey Epstein was indicted in 2019. Throughout its investigation,\nthe Government followed the facts where they led, without fear or favor.\nB.\n\nThe Charges\n\nOn June 29, 2020, a grand jury sitting in this District returned an indictment charging the\ndefendant in six counts. (Dkt. No. 1). On July 2, 2020, the Federal Bureau ofInvestigation (\"FBI\")\narrested the defendant. (PSR 1 77). On July 8, 2020, a grand jury sitting in this District returned\na superseding indictment containing the same charges, with ministerial corrections. (Dkt. No. 17).\nOn March 29, 2021, a grand jury sitting in this District returned a superseding indictment\n(the \"Indictment\") which charged the defendant in eight counts. (Dkt. No. 187). Count One of\nthe Indictment charged the defendant with conspiring with Jeffrey Epstein and others to entice\nminors to travel to engage in illegal sex acts from in or about 1994 through in or about 2004, in\nviolation of 18 U.S.C. § 371. Count Two charged the defendant with enticing Minor Victim-1 to\ntravel to engage in illegal sex acts, and aiding and abetting the same, in violation 18 U.S.C. §§ 2422\nand 2. Count Three charged the defendant with conspiring with Epstein and others to transport\nminors to participate in illegal sex acts from in or about 1994 through in or about 2004, in violation\nof 18 U.S.C. § 371. Count Four charged the defendant with transporting Minor Victim-I to\nparticipate in illegal sex acts, and aiding and abetting the same, in violation of 18 U.S.C. §§ 2423\nand 2. Count Five charged the defendant with participating in a sex trafficking conspiracy between\napproximately 2001 and 2004, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 371. Count Six charged the defendant\nwith sex trafficking ofMinor Victim-4, and aiding and abetting the same, in violation of 18 U.S.C.\n§§ 15\n... [truncated, 2121 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/5 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=5]", "char_count": 2121}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nC.\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 7 of 55\n\nSummary of Proof at Trial\n\nOn November 29, 2021, the defendant proceeded to trial on Counts One though Six.' On\nDecember 29, 2021, the jury returned a guilty verdict on Counts One, Three, Four, Five, and Six.\nThe proof at trial established that over the course of a decade, the defendant facilitated and\nparticipated in the sexual abuse of multiple young girls. From 1994 to 2004, the defendant and\nEpstein worked together to identify girls, groom them, and then entice them to travel and transport\nthem to Epstein's properties in New York, Florida, New Mexico, and elsewhere. (PSR ¶ 22). The\ngirls—some of whom were as young as 14 years old—were then sexually abused, often under the\nguise of a \"massage.\" (Id.).\nBeginning in approximately 1991, the defendant had a close and intimate relationship with\nEpstein. (PSR ¶ 23). The defendant was Epstein's girlfriend for many years, until in or about the\nearly 2000s; after that point, the defendant and Epstein remained close friends. (Id.). For over a\ndecade, the defendant traveled with Epstein, a multi-millionaire, on his private planes and mingled\nwith rich and famous people. (Id.). As the defendant wrote in an essay, she and Epstein were \"a\ncouple\" who were \"rarely apart,\" \"great partners,\" and \"the best of friends.\" (Id.). The defendant\nenjoyed a life of extraordinary luxury with Epstein. (Id.). The defendant and Epstein spent time\ntogether in Epstein's various properties, including his mansion on the Upper East Side in\nManhattan, his villa in Palm Beach, his ranch in New Mexico, his apartment in Paris, and his\nprivate island in the U.S. Virgin Islands. (Id.). During the timeframe of the conspiracy, Maxwell\nreceived exceptional benefits from Epstein. Beyond the lavish lifestyle that she enjoyed side-by-\n\nOn April 16, 2021, the Court granted the defendant's motion to sever the perjury charges for a\nseparate trial. (Dkt. No. 207). The Government intends to mo\n... [truncated, 2219 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/6 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=6]", "char_count": 2219}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 8 of 55\n\nside with Epstein, Maxwell also received a townhouse that Epstein bought for her in New York\nCity, and Epstein transferred a total of approximately $23 million to Maxwell during the timeframe\nof the conspiracy. (Id.).\nIn addition to her role as Epstein's girlfriend, the defendant also supervised Epstein's\nhouseholds and enjoyed a lifestyle of extraordinary wealth. (Id.). The defendant relished her role\nas \"the lady of the house.\" (PSR 1 24). When the defendant took charge of Epstein's homes, she\nimposed strict rules for staff. For example, the defendant helped author and implement a\nhousehold manual, which contained rules for operating the Palm Beach house to \"anticipate the\nneeds of Mr Epstein, Ms Maxwell and their guests.\" (Id.). Staff were directed to have two sizes\nof notepads marked \"Ghislaine Maxwell\" and \"Lady Ghislaine,\" in addition to Epstein's notepads.\n(Id.). Staff were also instructed on Epstein and the defendant's breakfast preferences, and the\nitems to keep in Epstein and the defendant's respective bathrooms. (Id.). The defendant's\ninstructions extended to massages: she specified the massage oils and lotions for the Palm Beach\nhouse. (Id.). In short, the defendant was waited on hand and foot.\nTo protect her criminal activities from exposure, the defendant also fostered a culture of\nsilence at Epstein's homes. (PSR ¶¶ 25, 79). The Palm Beach household manual made clear that\nstaff were to \"see nothing, hear nothing, say nothing, except to answer a question directed at\" that\nstaff member. (PSR 25; see also PSR at 49 (manual instructed employees to \"NEVER disclose\nMr Epstein or Ms Maxwell's activities or whereabouts to anyone\")). And the defendant reinforced\nthe messages of the household manual. She directed Juan Alessi, the former manager of Epstein's\nPalm Beach villa, to speak to Epstein only when spoken to and not to look Epstein in the eyes.\n(PSR 1 25). Alessi explained during his tria\n... [truncated, 2129 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/7 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=7]", "char_count": 2129}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 9 of 55\n\nThis culture of silence provided space for the defendant and Epstein to operate a playbook\nthrough which they sexually abused young girls. At trial, Dr. Lisa Rocchio, an expert in\npsychology with a specialized expertise in traumatic stress and interpersonal violence, explained\nthat children are most frequently sexually abused through grooming and coercion in the context of\na relationship. (Tr. 713). Dr. Rocchio explained that abusers use a series of deceptive tactics to\nengage a child in sexual abuse. (Tr. 715-20). The defendant and Epstein used such tactics\nthroughout the life of the conspiracy. In the early phase of the conspiracy, from at least\napproximately 1994 through approximately 2001, the defendant identified vulnerable girls,\ntypically from single-mother households and difficult financial circumstances. (PSR ¶ 26). The\ndefendant and Epstein then isolated the girls, spending time with them away from their family and\nfriends. (Id.). During that time, they groomed the girls through techniques such as giving them\ngifts, pretending to be friends, and building trust. (Id.). The defendant and Epstein then\nnormalized sexual situations and sexual touching. (Id.). Finally, they transitioned to sexual abuse,\noften through the pretext of giving Epstein a massage. (Id.). This earlier phase required the\ndefendant and Epstein to identify one girl at a time to target for grooming and abuse.\nIn the later phase, from approximately 2001 until at least approximately 2004, the\ndefendant and Epstein developed a scheme that created a constant stream of girls who recruited\neach other to visit Epstein at his Palm Beach residence. (PSR ¶ 27). This new approach replaced\nsome of the early grooming and trust-building steps with money provided to girls from struggling\nfamilies. (Id.). Specifically, the defendant and Epstein paid young girls hundreds of dollars in\ncash in exchange for meeting Epstein to be sexually abus\n... [truncated, 2245 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/8 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=8]", "char_count": 2245}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 10 of 55\n\nEpstein. (PSR • 28). As a result, the defendant and Epstein no longer had to identify and recruit\nvictims themselves. (Id.). Instead, they used money to convince impoverished girls to bring other\nvictims to provide Epstein with sexualized massages. (Id.). Once the girls were in Epstein's home,\nthe defendant engaged in grooming behavior that normalized the sexualized massages that were\ntaking place with Epstein. (Id.).\nAs set forth in the PSR, the defendant targeted vulnerable victims for sexual abuse, causing\nsignificant and lasting harm. The trial evidence focused on six girls who suffered abusive sexual\ncontact as a result of the defendant's criminal actions: Jane, Kate, Annie, Carolyn, Virginia, and\nMelissa. Details concerning the evidence at trial with respect to the abuse by the defendant and\nEpstein of the six girls are provided in the PSR at ¶¶ 30-74, 80-82. The defendant was instrumental\nin the abuse of these girls. She personally engaged in sexual abuse when she fondled the breasts\nof Jane, Annie, and Carolyn. And she used her role as a supposedly respectable, glamorous, older\nwoman to lure these victims into a false sense of security. By behaving as though the sexual abuse\nwas normal, the defendant prevented these girls from understanding just how wrong the abuse was.\nThe defendant also provided Epstein with the cover of an age-appropriate romantic partner, to put\nother adults at ease when interacting with Epstein and when allowing their children to spend time\nwith him.\nI. Sexual Abuse of Jane\nThe defendant and Epstein met Jane when she was just 14 years old in the summer of 1994\nat a summer camp for talented kids. (PSR ¶ 30). Jane was particularly vulnerable, as her father\nhad just passed away (a fact which she had told both Epstein and the defendant upon meeting\nthem), and her family was struggling financially. (PSR ¶¶ 30-31). The defendant and Epstein\ncultivated a relationship with Jan\n... [truncated, 2077 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/9 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=9]", "char_count": 2077}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 11 of 55\n\ntaking her to the movies and on shopping outings. (PSR ¶ 32). The defendant and Epstein gave\nJane gifts, and Jane came to look up to the defendant like an older sister figure. (PSR 1132-33).\nThe defendant and Epstein abused that relationship of trust in the worst way imaginable.\nThey sexually abused Jane starting when she was just 14 years old, and the sexual abuse continued\nfor years. (PSR ¶ 36). When Jane was still only 14 years old, the defendant and Epstein instructed\nJane to follow them to Epstein's bedroom where the defendant and Epstein fondled each other,\ncasually giggling about it, while Epstein asked Jane to take her top off. (PSR ¶ 34). While this\nwas happening, \"there were hands everywhere,\" Epstein began to masturbate, and the defendant\nrubbed, kissed, and fondled Epstein. (Id.). After this initial sexual interaction, the defendant and\nEpstein continued to sexually abuse Jane. (PSR ¶ 35). The defendant and Epstein taught Jane\nhow Epstein liked to be massaged and gave Jane instructions about touching Epstein's penis. (Id.).\nJane was 14 years old, and the defendant tried to make Jane feel like this was \"very normal\" and\n\"not a big deal.\" (Id.). Jane was repeatedly sexually abused by Epstein between the ages of 14\nand 16 years old, and the defendant was frequently in the room when the abuse happened. (PSR\n¶ 36). Over time, the abuse escalated, and Epstein used vibrators on Jane, masturbated, put his\nfingers in Jane's vagina, and asked Jane to straddle his face. (Id.). The defendant sometimes\ntouched Jane during these incidents; in particular, Jane recalled that the defendant touched her\nbreasts. (Id.). The sexual abuse was not limited to Palm Beach, Florida, as Jane traveled with the\ndefendant and Epstein to Epstein's townhouse in New York City and his ranch in New Mexico.\n(PSR ¶ 37). Jane was sexually abused during those trips. (Id.).\n2. Sexual Abuse of Kate\nThe defendant and Epstein's s\n... [truncated, 2170 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/10 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=10]", "char_count": 2170}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 12 of 55\n\nyears old, told the defendant that she lived alone with her mother and that things were difficult at\nhome, the defendant introduced Kate to Epstein in London. (PSR ¶¶ 39-40). The defendant\ndelivered Kate to a naked Epstein in the defendant's own home for massages and told Kate to\n\"have a good time.\" (PSR ¶¶ 41-42). During these massages, Epstein initiated sexual contact with\nher, putting her hand on his penis and grabbing Kate's breasts and in between her legs. (Id.).\nKate traveled to meet both Maxwell and Epstein in Palm Beach, Little Saint James, and\nNew York City when she was between approximately 18 and 24 years old. (PSR ¶ 43). Epstein\ninitiated sexual activity with Kate every time she spent time with him from when she was 17 years\nold through her early thirties. (Id.). The defendant brought up sexual topics with Kate, ranging\nfrom talking about how sexually demanding Epstein was to asking if Kate knew of anyone to give\nEpstein a blow job to remarking that Epstein liked cute, young, pretty girls like Kate. (PSR ¶ 44).\nWhen Kate was approximately 18 years old, Kate visited Epstein and Maxwell at Epstein's\nvilla in Palm Beach. (PSR ¶ 45). The defendant had left a schoolgirl outfit for Kate in the guest\nroom and told Kate that she thought it would be fun for Kate to take Epstein his tea in the outfit.\n(Id.). Kate—alone with only Epstein and the defendant in a place she had never previously\nvisited—complied. (Id.). Epstein raped Kate by engaging in forced intercourse with her. (Id.).\nLater that day, Maxwell asked Kate if she had fun and told Kate that she was a \"good girl\" and\n\"one of [Epstein's] favorites.\" (Id.). Epstein engaged in unwanted sexual activity with Kate\nmultiple times during that same trip. (Id.).\n3. Sexual Abuse of\nThe defendant also took steps to normalize sexual contact with\n\nwho was\n\nthen 16 years old. In the spring of 1996, Annie's mother, at Epstein's request, agreed to send\nA\n... [truncated, 2115 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/11 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=11]", "char_count": 2115}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 13 of 55\n\nand girls) that were academically gifted to discuss college plans and international trips. (PSR\n¶ 49). Annie did not want to go to New Mexico after Epstein had caressed and held Annie's hand\nand rubbed her foot and leg while watching a movie at a theater in New York in December 1995.\n(PSR ¶ 48). Despite those misgivings, Annie felt more comfortable going to New Mexico once\nshe understood that the defendant, a grown woman in a romantic relationship with Epstein, would\nbe there with Annie. (PSR ¶ 49). Yet, when Annie found herself alone at Epstein's ranch in New\nMexico with just Epstein and the defendant, she found that the defendant was anything but a\nprotector. (PSR ¶ 50). Instead, Annie found that the purpose of the trip was to groom her for\nsexual abuse.\nDuring the New Mexico trip, the defendant took steps to normalize sexual contact under\nthe ruse of massage. The defendant asked Annie if she had ever had a professional massage, and\nsaid that she wanted Annie to have that experience and that she would be happy to give Annie a\nmassage. (PSR ¶ 52). After telling Annie to get undressed, the defendant gave Annie a massage\non a massage table while Annie was naked. (Id.). During the massage, the defendant rubbed\nAnnie's body and directed Annie to roll over so that Annie was laying on her back. (Id.). After\nAnnie complied and rolled to her back, the defendant pulled the sheet down and exposed Annie's\nbreasts. (Id.). Then, while Annie was naked and isolated on a ranch in the middle of nowhere, the\ndefendant rubbed Annie's breasts. (Id.). Annie testified that she wanted \"badly to get off of the\ntable and have this massage be done.\" (Id.). The defendant sexually abused a teenage girl in an\neffort to groom her for further abuse.\nFollowing through on that plan on this same New Mexico trip, Epstein later got into\nAnnie's bed, cuddled with her, pressed his body into her, and rubbed against her. (PSR ¶ 53). But\n... [truncated, 2020 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/12 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=12]", "char_count": 2020}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 14 of 55\n\nwhen Annie managed to extricate herself from the situation by running to the bathroom, thereby\ndenying Epstein further sexual contact, the defendant seemed \"very disinterested\" in Annie. (Id.).\n4. Sexual Abuse of\nBeginning in or about the summer of 2000, the defendant and Epstein entered a new phase\nof their scheme to sexually abuse teenage girls. That summer, Maxwell recruited a 17-year-old\ngirl named\n\nfrom the parking lot of Mar-a-Lago to provide Epstein with massages.\n\n(PSR ¶ 56). Over the next several months, Virginia was paid to provide Epstein with sexualized\nmassages at his Palm Beach residence, in exchange for hundreds of dollars in cash for each\nmassage. (PSR ¶ 55). Virginia also traveled with Epstein and Maxwell to other locations,\nincluding New York and the Virgin Islands, on Epstein's private plane. (PSR ¶ 57). Virginia\nbrought other teenage girls to Epstein's Palm Beach house. (PSR ¶ 58). One of those girls was a\n14-year-old girl named Carolyn who Virginia introduced to the defendant and Epstein at the Palm\nBeach villa in 2001. (PSR ¶¶ 58, 59). Thus began the pyramid scheme phase of the defendant and\nEpstein's abuse of teenage girls.\n5. Sexual Abuse of Carolyn\nCarolyn visited Epstein's Palm Beach residence more than 100 times, during each of which\nshe was sexually abused during paid sexualized massages. (PSR ¶ 59). Carolyn met the defendant\nthe very first time she went to Epstein's house, and she interacted with the defendant multiple\ntimes thereafter. (Id.). On Carolyn's first visit to the house, the defendant greeted Virginia, who\nintroduced Carolyn to the defendant. (PSR ¶ 62). The defendant then told Virginia, \"You can\nbring her upstairs and show her what to do,\" after which Virginia showed Carolyn how to perform\na sexual massage on Epstein. (PSR ¶¶ 62-63). Carolyn performed over 100 paid sexualized\nmassages for Epstein when she was between 14 and 18 years old. (PSR 164). The vast \n... [truncated, 2028 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/13 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=13]", "char_count": 2028}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 15 of 55\n\ninvolved the same course of abuse. At some point during each massage, Epstein rolled over and\nbegan masturbating himself. (Id.). Epstein then directed Carolyn to touch his nipples and he\ntouched Carolyn's breasts and buttocks. (Id.). On one occasion, Epstein attempted to touch\nCarolyn's vagina with a vibrator, but Carolyn pulled away, so he stopped. (Id.). On two occasions,\nEpstein brought other females into the room with Carolyn, who engaged Carolyn in oral sex, and\non one occasion Epstein raped Carolyn by penetrating her vagina with his penis. (PSR ¶ 72).\nEvery massage ended with Epstein ejaculating. (PSR 1 64).\nThe defendant personally scheduled Carolyn's massages for approximately the first year\nor two, when Carolyn was between the ages of 14 and 15. (PSR ¶ 66). When the defendant\nscheduled Carolyn for an appointment, she sometimes sent a car to pick Carolyn up. (Id.). At the\ntime, Carolyn was 14 or 15 years old and did not have a license. (Id.). Indeed, the defendant knew\nCarolyn's age and much of her background because she had multiple conversations with Carolyn\nabout Carolyn's life. (PSR ¶ 67). During these conversations, Carolyn revealed that she had\npreviously been sexually abused by a relative, that her parents were separated, and that her mother\nstruggled with addiction. (Id.). The defendant invited Carolyn to travel with the defendant and\nEpstein, but Carolyn explained that because she was only 14 years old, she would not be able to\nget permission to travel. (PSR 1 68). Carolyn was paid several hundred dollars in one-hundreddollar bills after each massage. (PSR ¶ 65). Usually, the money was laid out on the table or by\nthe sink in the bathroom, but the defendant personally paid Carolyn after a few massages. (Id.).\nThe defendant saw Carolyn fully nude in the massage room on approximately three\noccasions. (PSR ¶ 69). This happened when Carolyn had already undressed in preparation for the\nm\n... [truncated, 2209 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/14 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=14]", "char_count": 2209}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 16 of 55\n\nfully nude when the defendant walked into the massage room. (Id.). The defendant told Carolyn\nthat she had a nice body and touched Carolyn's breasts. (Id.).\nAt some point, Epstein asked Carolyn if she had any young friends she could bring for\nmassages. (PSR ¶ 71). Carolyn ended up bringing multiple girls to massage Epstein, including\nmultiple minors. (Id.). When Carolyn brought girls to massage Epstein, both the girl and Carolyn\nwould be paid hundreds of dollars in cash. (Id.). During those massages, Epstein masturbated and\ntouched Carolyn's and her friend's breasts and buttocks. (Id.).\n6. Sexual Abuse of Melissa\nOne of the minor girls Carolyn brought to provide paid sexualized massages to Epstein was\nnamed Melissa. (PSR ¶ 80). Melissa was just 16 years old when she went with Carolyn to\nEpstein's Palm Beach residence. (Id.). Melissa went to Epstein's residence to provide Epstein\nwith massages on multiple occasions when she was under the age of 18. (Id.). When Melissa and\nCarolyn went to the Palm Beach house, they remained in the home for about an hour and then\nreturned with hundreds of dollars in cash. (Id.). An entry entitled \"Melissa's cell (Carolyn's\nfriend),\" as well as multiple entries with Carolyn's full name and an entry entitled \"Virginia\n(parents)\" were listed in the defendant and Epstein's black address book under the heading\n\"Massage — Florida.\" (Id.; PSR ¶ 57). Thus, as a direct result of the pyramid scheme that began\nwith Virginia and continued with Carolyn, Melissa suffered repeated sexual abuse.\nII.\n\nThe Pre-Sentence Report and Sentencing Guidelines\nThe United States Probation Office, in its Pre-Sentence Investigation Report, recommends\n\na sentence of twenty years' imprisonment. In making that recommendation, the Probation Office\ncharacterized the defendant's offense conduct as \"heinous and predatory in nature.\" (PSR at 67).\nRegarding the defendant's role, the Probation Office emphas\n... [truncated, 2057 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/15 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=15]", "char_count": 2057}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 17 of 55\n\ninvolvement in the offense is immense,\" and that she was essential to \"fostering a culture for the\nabuse to continue.\" (Id.). Moreover, the Probation Office observed that the defendant's conduct\nreflected a dark world view: \"it appears that the defendant viewed the victims as objects who could\nbe manipulated for her and Epstein's own selfish purposes without any regard for their personal\nwellbeing, health, or safety.\" (Id.).\nAs the PSR reflects, the United States Probation Office has calculated an applicable\nsentencing range under the advisory United States Sentencing Guidelines of 292 to 365 months,\nbased on a total offense level of 40. The Government does not object to the calculation set forth\nin the PSR, except that the Government respectfully submits that, as noted in the Government's\nobjections to the PSR, the Guidelines calculation should include two additional groups relating to\ntwo victims:\n\nand the victim identified at trial as Melissa. (PSR at 45). Pursuant\n\nto the Court's discovery order, the Government notified the defense by letter on September 13,\n2022 that the Government intended to prove at trial that the conspiracy involved six victims,\nincluding\n\nand Melissa. The Government did just that at trial. (See, e.g., Tr. 2874,\n\n2882-84 (discussing evidence demonstrating the abuse of\nsummation); PSR 11 55-58, 80). The PSR notes that\n\nand Melissa in\nand Melissa do not appear\n\nby name in the indictment, but Application Note 6 to U.S.S.G. § 2G1.3 expressly instructs that if\nthe relevant conduct of an offense of conviction includes \"prohibited sexual conduct in respect to\nmore than one minor, whether specifically cited in the count ofconviction, each such minor shall\nbe treated as if contained in a separate count of conviction.\" (emphasis added).\nAccordingly, the offense level should be increased by two levels, pursuant to U.S.S.G.\n§ 2G1.3(dX1). As a result, the applicable sentencing range is\n... [truncated, 2086 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/16 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=16]", "char_count": 2086}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 18 of 55\n\nIn a memorandum dated June 15, 2022, the defendant urges the Court to adopt a sentencing\nrange of 51 to 63 months' imprisonment, which reflects a small fraction of the applicable\nsentencing Guidelines range. The defendant reaches this low number by disputing four aspects of\nthe Probation Office's calculation. For the reasons set forth below, the Court should reject the\ndefendant's Guidelines objections in their entirety. It would be both strange and anomalous for\nthe Sentencing Guidelines to recommend such a short sentence for a defendant who spent years\nsexually exploiting teenage girls. The Sentencing Guidelines do not provide for a such an\noutcome.\nA.\n\nThe 2004 Sentencing Guidelines Manual Applies\n\nIn the ordinary course, the Sentencing Guidelines instruct courts to use the Guidelines\nManual in effect on the date that the defendant is sentenced, which here would result in applying\nthe 2021 Guidelines Manual (the \"2021 Manual\"). U.S.S.G. § 1B1.11(a). Where, as here, the\ncurrent Guidelines Manual provides a higher range than the Manual in effect at the time of the\noffense conduct, using the current manual would violate the Ex Post Facto clause. U.S.S.G.\n§ 1B1.11(b)(1); Peugh v. United States, 569 U.S. 530, 544 (2013). Here, the 2021 Manual calls\nfor a substantially higher guidelines calculation than the Government seeks. For example, under\nthe 2021 Manual, the base offense level would be 30 before any enhancements are applied,\nwhereas the 2004 Sentencing Guidelines Manual (the \"2004 Manual\") provides for a base offense\nlevel of 24 before enhancements. In other words, under the 2021 Manual, the offense level is at\nleast six levels higher. Compare U.S.S.G. § 2G1.3(a) (2004) with U.S.S.G. § 2G1.3(a)(2) (2021).\nAs a result, the Court may not apply the 2021 Manual, but the Supreme Court has made clear that\nsubsequent increases in the Guidelines may be a reason the sentencing court may deviate upwards\nf\n... [truncated, 2119 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/17 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=17]", "char_count": 2119}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 19 of 55\n\ncurrent version of the Guidelines as representing the most recent views of the agency charged by\nCongress with developing sentencing policy.\" Peugh, 569 U.S. at 549.\nWhere the Guidelines have increased after the offense conduct has concluded, \"the court\nshall use the Guidelines Manual in effect on the date that the offense of conviction was\ncommitted.\" U.S.S.G. § 1B1.11(bX1). Furthermore, Application Note 2 provides that \"the last\ndate of the offense of conviction is the controlling date\" for determining which manual to apply.\nU.S.S.G. § 1B1.11(bX1), app. n.2. That is true even if the Guidelines were amended during the\ncourse of the offense conduct. The Second Circuit has explained that \"[w]here a conspiracy began\nwhile one version of the Guidelines was in effect and ended after another version became effective,\napplication of the later version to the coconspirators does not violate the Ex Post\nFacto Clause.\" United States v. Meneilly, 28 F. App'x 26, 32 (2d Cir. 2001) (citations omitted).\nHere, the offenses of conviction spanned from 1994 up to and including 2004, as set forth\nin the Indictment, and as the proof established at trial. As a result, for Guidelines purposes,\nDecember 31, 2004 is legally the last date of the offense conduct, and the 2004 Manual applies.\nIn her objections to the PSR, the defendant claims that the Ex Post Facto clause requires the July,\nand not the Court, to determine the last date of the offense of conviction. The defendant further\nclaims that, as a factual matter, the offense conduct ended before November 1, 2004, the date upon\nwhich the 2004 Manual became effective. For the reasons set forth below, the defendant is wrong\nas a matter of law and as a matter of fact. The Court should apply the 2004 Manual.\n\n17\n\nEFTA02838392\n\n", "char_count": 1852}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 20 of 55\n\nI. The Court, and not the Jury, Determines Which Manual to Apply\nThe defendant claims that a jury must determine which version of the Sentencing\nGuidelines to apply, but the defendant offers not a single case that has ever so held. That argument\nis inconsistent with the plain text of the Guidelines and established Second Circuit precedent. The\nCourt should reject this argument.\nAs an initial matter, it is well settled that a question of fact that increases a defendant's\noffense level under the Guidelines need not be submitted to a jury. United States v. Fusco, 560 F.\nApp'x 43, 45-46 (2d Cir. 2014); United States v. Morel, No. 10 Cr. 798 (PAC), 2021 WL 2821107,\nat •2 (S.D.N.Y. July 7, 2021). In addition, with respect to the sentencing court's determination of\nwhich Guidelines Manual to apply, the text of the Guidelines expressly contemplates that the court\nshould determine the last date of the conspiracy. Application Note 2 provides the following\nexample of a calculation of the last date of the offense: \"For example, if the offense of conviction\n(i.e., the conduct charged in the count of the indictment or information of which the defendant was\nconvicted) was determined by the court to have been committed between October 15, 1991 and\nOctober 28, 1991, the date of October 28, 1991 is the controlling date for ex postfacto purposes.\"\nU.S.S.G. § 1B1.11(b)(1), app. n.2 (2004) (emphasis added). As the underlined language makes\nplain, the Guidelines direct sentencing courts to make this factual determination, and not juries.\nAs the defendant acknowledges, not one of the cases cited in the defendant's motion\ninvolved increases in the Sentencing Guidelines, and instead, the defendant rests her argument\nentirely on cases involving Er Post Facto challenges to increases of the applicable statutory\npenalties. (Dkt. No. 662 (\"Def. Mem.\") at 3-4). The law is clear that, so long as a fact at sentencing\ndoes not incr\n... [truncated, 2104 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/19 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=19]", "char_count": 2104}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 21 of 55\n\nto resolve, and not the jury. Fusco, 560 F. App'x at 45-46 (citing United States v. Norris, 281 F.3d\n357, 369 (2d Cir. 2002)).\nLacking any authority for her argument, the defendant cites Peugh and offers her own\nsweeping conclusion that, essentially, the Sixth Amendment requires that all Ex Post Facto issues\nbe resolved by juries. But as the Supreme Court explained in Peugh, \"the Sixth Amendment and\nEx Post Facto Clause inquiries are analytically distinct\" and In]othing that we say today\n'undo[es]' the holdings of Booker, Rita, Gall, Kimbrough, or our other recent sentencing cases.\"\nPeugh, 569 U.S. at 549-50. It is thus unsurprising that the defendant has not located a single case,\nanywhere in the nation, that has concluded, in the nine years since Peugh was decided, that the\ndetermination of which Guidelines Manual to apply implicates the Sixth Amendment. Thus, even\nafter Peugh, a sentencing judge's fact-finding authority continues to include the authority to find\nwhen an offense ended for purposes of deciding which Guidelines Manual to apply.\n2. The Sex Trafficking Conspiracy Continued to 2005\nThe Indictment charged that the defendant participated in a conspiracy \"from at least in or\nabout 1994, up to and including at least in or about 2004,\" and that is exactly what the Government\nproved at trial. (Dkt. No. 187 at 1). There can be no question that the evidence establishes that\nthe conspiracy ran past November 1, 2004, consistent with the charging language in the Indictment.\nAt trial, Carolyn testified that she continued to perform sexualized massages for Epstein when she\nwas 18, which was in 2005. Carolyn's birth certificate was admitted at trial as GX 11. Carolyn\nturned 18 in 2005, which is after November 1, 2004, the day that the 2004 Manual went into effect.\nIn particular, Carolyn gave the following testimony:\n\n19\n\nEFTA02838394\n\n", "char_count": 1936}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 22 of 55\n\nQ: And about how old were you the last time you went over to his house?\nA: Eighteen\n(Trial Tr. 1525). Carolyn further testified:\nQ: Why did you stop going to Jeffrey Epstein's house?\nA: Because I became too old.\nQ: How old were you?\nA: 18.\n(Tr. 1549). That testimony alone confirms that the offense conduct spanned the entirety of 2004,\nand thus that the 2004 Manual applies.\nThe thrust of the defendant's argument is that the Court should, at sentencing, discredit the\ntestimony of a crime victim, when a jury has credited that victim and found the defendant guilty.\nIndeed, the jury convicted the defendant of Count Six, which solely relates to Carolyn. In service\nof her lawless argument, the defendant asks the Court both to reject Carolyn's testimony and to do\nso in the face of documentary evidence that establishes that Carolyn told the truth at trial about\nwhen the offense conduct ended. As the defendant acknowledges, a message book seized from\nthe Palm Beach residence contains two messages from Carolyn, using her first and last name: one\nin November 2004 (GX 4B), and one dated March 1, 2005 (GX 4F). The defendant asks the Court\nto ignore this evidence that Carolyn told the truth at trial, speculating that perhaps the message\nbook is not authentic, because the Government did not offer these excerpts at trial. That\nspeculation is baseless. As the defendant knows, the Government streamlined its proof at trial and\nelected not to call several witnesses, including employees who worked for Epstein in 2005 when\nthis book was used. Given the volume of messages relating to Carolyn that were admitted at trial,\nand her own testimony about the duration of the conspiracy, the testimony from the additional\n\n20\n\nEFTA02838395\n\n", "char_count": 1806}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 23 of 55\n\nemployees was unnecessary. The book is authentic, and the defendant offers no basis for\nconcluding otherwise.2\nThe Court should reject the defendant's argument and make its determination regarding\nthe final date of the conspiracy based on the language of the Indictment (which plainly\nencompasses all of 2004) and the trial testimony of Carolyn (who testified that the offense conduct\nran past 2004). The 2004 Manual applies.\n3. The Court Should Apply the 2004 Manual\nThe defendant also claims that the \"goals of sentencing are not served\" by applying the\n2004 Manual. (Def. Mem. 8 (capitalization removed)). Not so. The law plainly provides that the\n2004 Manual applies here, and it would be unjust to provide a substantial break in the Sentencing\nGuidelines for a defendant who engaged in an extensive child exploitation scheme, especially\nwhen both Congress and the Sentencing Commission have since further increased the applicable\npenalties for these offenses.\nMoreover, the Court should not credit the defendant's claim that she broke away from\nEpstein in 2002, based on the testimony of a sole defense witness who said that the defendant had\n\"moved on\" in 2002. (Def. Mem. 9). To be clear, \"once it has been established that there existed\na conspiracy of which the defendant was a member, [her] membership is presumed to continue\nunless and until the defendant proves that the conspiracy was terminated or that [she] took\n\n2 In any event, the Government will bring the message book to sentencing so that the Court may\n\nexamine it if it deems such an assessment necessary. If the Court desires additional testimony in\nthe record, a case agent would be prepared to testify at the sentencing hearing based on the FBI's\ninvestigation that this message book was seized by the Palm Beach Police Department along with\nthe other three message books admitted at trial, and was transferred into the custody of the FBI,\nwhich has mainta\n... [truncated, 2320 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/22 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=22]", "char_count": 2320}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 24 of 55\n\naffirmative steps to withdraw.\" Meneilly, 28 F. App'x at 32 (citations omitted). The defendant\nhas not claimed, as a legal matter, that there is any evidence that she withdrew from the conspiracy,\nnor could she. Instead, she argues, as a policy matter, that the 2004 Manual should not be applied\nbecause the defendant had \"moved on,\" an expression that has no legal meaning.\nMore importantly, documentary evidence establishes that the defendant remained a close\nassociate of Jeffrey Epstein for multiple years after 2002. In particular:\n•\n\nFlight records reflect that the defendant flew on Epstein's private jet 49 times in 2003, 19\ntimes in 2004, and 16 times in 2005. Regarding 2004 in particular, the flight records for\nthat year reflect that the defendant flew on Epstein's private jet twice in November 2004\nand once in December 2004, which makes clear that the defendant was still traveling with\nEpstein after the Guidelines were amended and while the conspiracy was ongoing. (GX\n662).\n\n•\n\nIn October 2005, the Palm Beach Police Department executed a search warrant at the Palm\nBeach residence, and discovered the defendant's desk, upon which a notepad with her\nnamed stationary was sitting. (GX 285).\n\nThe setup of the defendant's desk—and\n\ninstructions that make clear the defendant was a forceful presence in the house—are set\nforth in the household manual, which is dated February 14, 2005. (GX 606).\n•\n\nTravel agency records from Shopper's Travel—offered by the defendant at trial—reflect\nthat Epstein paid for the defendant's flights through at least 2006. (DX RS-1 (listing a May\n1, 2006 flight on Epstein's account)).\n\n•\n\nBank records reflect that, as of 2007, Epstein transferred $7,759,793.40 to the defendant's\npersonal bank account.\n\n22\n\nEFTA02838397\n\n", "char_count": 1839}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 25 of 55\n\nWhat the record makes clear is that the defendant remained a close associate of Jeffrey\nEpstein and continued to profit from their criminal relationship, long past 2004. There is nothing\npunitive about applying the 2004 Guidelines, which apply here as a matter of law. If anything, the\nfact that the defendant will be sentenced under the 2004 Guidelines, and not the higher range under\nthe 2021 Guidelines, should be a factor that warrants a higher sentence. Indeed, the Supreme Court\nhas expressly noted that sentencing courts may consider subsequent increases in offense levels for\nprecisely that purpose. See Peugh, 569 U.S. at 549.\nB.\n\nThe Four-Point Leadership Enhancement Applies\n\nThe Government agrees with the Probation Office that the enhancement in U.S.S.G.\n§ 3B1.1 applies because the defendant was the organizer or leader of a criminal activity that was\n\"otherwise extensive.\" The defendant's conspiracy spanned at least five victims in three states,\nthe United Kingdom, and the U.S. Virgin Islands, including at Epstein's various properties, which\nthe defendant ran, over the course of a decade. It involved the participation of numerous members\nof the defendant and Epstein's staff, whether knowing or unknowing, and the use of minor victims\nto recruit other minor victims. See U.S.S.G. § 3B1.1 app. n.3 (\"In assessing whether an\norganization is 'otherwise extensive,' all persons involved during the course of the entire offense\nare to be considered,\" and use of \"the unknowing services of many outsiders could be considered\nextensive.\"). For instance, Carolyn testified that she was recruited by Virginia and that Carolyn\nrecruited other minor victims. Juan Alessi testified that he was driving when the defendant stopped\nto recruit Virginia. Two pilots testified about transporting minor victims on Epstein's planes. That\nalone is five individuals involved in the criminal activity, without even counting the defen\n... [truncated, 2200 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/24 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=24]", "char_count": 2200}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 26 of 55\n\n\"one involving five or more knowing participants\" (internal quotation marks and emphasis\nomitted)). Accordingly, there is ample basis in the record to impose this enhancement.\nThe text of U.S.S.G. 3B1.1(a) calls for the application of its enhancement if \"the defendant\nwas an organizer or leader of a criminal activity that\" either \"involved five or more participants,\"\nor \"was otherwise extensive.\" The defense correctly points out that Application Note 2 to this\nGuidelines provides, \"To qualify for an adjustment under this section, the defendant must have\nbeen the organizer, leader, manager, or supervisor of one or more other participants. An upward\ndeparture may be warranted, however, in the case of a defendant who did not organize, lead,\nmanage, or supervise another participant, but who nevertheless exercised management\nresponsibility over the property, assets, or activities of a criminal organization.\" Application Note\n1 defines a \"participant\" as \"a person who is criminally responsible for the commission of the\noffense, but need not have been convicted.\" Despite those Application Notes, however, the\nGovernment is not aware of any Second Circuit case requiring that, where the enhancement turns\non the \"otherwise extensive\" prong, rather than the \"five or more participants\" prong, the defendant\nmust supervise a knowing participant. Indeed, the defense fails to cite a single case holding that\nthe \"otherwise extensive\" prong requires that the defendant supervised a knowing participant.\nInstead, the Second Circuit has articulated three factors that sentencing courts should\nconsider when evaluating whether the \"otherwise extensive\" enhancement applies. See United\nStates v. Carrozzella, 105 F.3d 796, 803-04 (2d Cir. 1997), abrogated in part on other grounds,\nUnited States v. Kennedy, 233 F.3d 157, 160-61 (2d Cir. 2000); see also M, 821 F.3d at 369\n(applying Carrozzella factors); United States v. Archer, \n... [truncated, 2243 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/25 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=25]", "char_count": 2243}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 27 of 55\n\n82 (2d Cir. 2008) (same). Specifically, when evaluating whether the \"otherwise extensive\" prong\napplies, the sentencing court must consider \"(i) the number of knowing participants; (ii) the\nnumber of unknowing participants whose activities were organized or led by the defendant with\nspecific criminal intent; (iii) the extent to which the services of the unknowing participants were\npeculiar and necnsary to the criminal scheme.\" Carrozzella, 105 F.3d at 803-04. In setting out\nthese factors, the Circuit emphasized that \"[t]he number of knowing participants\" is \"relevant\" to\nthe analysis \"because a criminal scheme with four knowing participants that is aided by unknowing\nparticipants is more likely to be `otherwise extensive' than a scheme with a single knowing\nparticipant.\" Id. at 804. Additionally, when evaluating the number of unknowing participants, the\nCircuit emphasized distinguishing between service providers, such as taxi drivers, from individuals\nwho function more like knowing participants who receive direction from a defendant \"with the\nspecific intent\" to further the criminal activity.\nIn this analysis, the Circuit did not articulate or rely on any requirement that a defendant\nmust have supervised at least one knowing participant. Id.\n\nRather, the Court expressly\n\ncontemplated that the enhancement might apply to an organization involving multiple unknowing\nparticipants. See id. Consistent with that understanding, and contrary to the defense's proposed\ninterpretation, the Circuit has affirmed the application of § 3B1.I under the \"otherwise extensive\"\nprong to two defendants who were themselves the only two knowing participants identified in the\nscheme. Rubenstein, 403 F.3d at 99. That outcome makes clear that the Circuit does not require\na defendant to supervise any other knowing participant in the scheme. Of particular note, the\nRubenstein case applied the \"otherwise extensive\" enhancement\" \n... [truncated, 2218 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/26 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=26]", "char_count": 2218}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 28 of 55\n\ndefendants' direction. Rubenstein, 403 F.3d at 99. The same analysis applies with equal force\nhere. Even if the defendant and Epstein were the only two knowing participants—which, as\ndiscussed below, they were not—their joint supervision and organization of a large array of\nunknowing participants created an otherwise extensive organization that qualifies for the\nenhancement under U.S.S.G. §3B1.1.\nHere, the defendant acted as an organizer and leader of a massive operation that spanned\nmany years. In operating as the lady of the house and as Epstein's right hand, the defendant was\nresponsible for overseeing and organizing extensive logistics involved in facilitating the sexual\nabuse ofmultiple minors and ensuring a culture of silence that prevented that scheme from being\nuncovered. Epstein and the defendant were two knowing participants who took the lead in\nidentifying, enticing, and grooming minor girls to be abused. Additionally,\n\n, who\n\nhandled the responsibilities of scheduling sexualized massages and took nude photographs of\nCarolyn (PSR ¶ 66; Tr. 1554-55), constituted a third knowing participant, which number the\nCircuit has found sufficient, together with additionally necessary unknowing participants, to be\nsufficient for the enhancement. See Archer, 671 F.3d at 166.\nBeyond those three knowing participants, Virginia and Carolyn both recruited other minor\ngirls to provide paid sexualized massages to Epstein, thereby furthering the scheme and filling a\ncrucial role in the scheme's later pyramid phase.\n\nJuan Alessi provided an essential role\n\ntransporting Jane and Virginia to see Epstein, as well as scheduling appointments for massages,\ncleaning up the massage room after Epstein received sexualized massages, and putting away sex\ntoys in the defendant's bathroom after Epstein received sexualized massages. (PSR ¶¶ 24, 57; Tr.\n836-38). Those duties were essential both to the continued functioning of\n... [truncated, 2141 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/27 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=27]", "char_count": 2141}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 29 of 55\n\nsomeone who had been trained not to ask questions and who worked in a culture of silence carried\nout those necessary tasks. Both Larry Visoski and David Rodgers played the essential role of\ntransporting minor victims to different locations, providing a discreet means of ensuring that\nEpstein had access to minor girls for his sexual gratification when he traveled. The defendant\norganized all of those individuals by telling Virginia to show Carolyn what to do, by scheduling\nCarolyn's appointments, by giving Alessi innumerable directions, and by providing instructions to\nboth pilots. (PSR ¶¶ 24, 62, 66). Additionally, the defendant supervised all of Epstein's staff for\nyears, thereby running an extensive operation. Those individuals more than satisfy the definition\nof an extensive operation in which the defendant served as an organizer.\nIn any event, this enhancement applies even under the defense's interpretation ofU.S.S.G.\n§ 3B1.I because Maxwell also supervised at least one other knowing participant in\nLarry Visoski testified that he understood\n140). Even if he was not certain that\n\nto be one of Maxwell's assistants. (Tr.\nhad that precise title, his understanding is consistent\n\nwith Maxwell's role as second in command beneath Epstein over all other employees. (Tr. 139).\nConsistent with Visoski' s recollection, David Rodgers testified his understanding was that \"Sarah\nwas more of Ghislaine's assistant, but actually she was probably both,\" an assistant to the\ndefendant and an assistant to Epstein, again confirming that the defendant supervised\n\n(Tr.\n\n1890). Rodgers also testified that Maxwell was \"number two\" below Epstein among Epstein's\nemployees. (Tr. 1809-10). Alessi testified that he did not know exactly what\nresponsibilities were, but\n\njob\n\ntook over the \"scheduling of massages\" in approximately 2002.\n\n(Tr. 833). Carolyn also recalled that even after\n\ntook over calling to schedule massages,\n\nMa\n... [truncated, 2202 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/28 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=28]", "char_count": 2202}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 30 of 55\n\nwas still the lady of the house, supervising other staff, (GX 606), and flight records make clear that\nthe defendant and\n\nflew together on Epstein's private planes approximately thirty-nine times\n\nin 2003 and approximately ten times in 2004, confirming their continued overlap, (GX 662).\nThe combination of this evidence demonstrates that\n\njoined the conspiracy when\n\nMaxwell was still second in command under Epstein. Given Maxwell's role in the household and\nin the conspiracy, she certainly exercised authority over\nrecord is that Maxwell instructed\n\nThe clear inference from this\n\nregarding how to schedule massages and run the part of\n\nthe scheme that Maxwell had previously handled, at which point\n\nswitched to making calls\n\nto schedule appointments following Maxwell's directions. Thus, even if the defense were correct\nthat the defendant needed to supervise a knowing participant in the scheme for the leadership\nenhancement to apply, the record amply supports the conclusion that Maxwell did so with respect\nto\nGiven the breadth of the defendant's criminal scheme, spanning multiple continents,\nabusing multiple victims, and employing numerous underlings to accomplish the conspiracy's goal\nover the course of multiple years, the defendant clearly warrants the enhancement under U.S.S.G.\n§ 3B1.I contemplated by the PSR.\nC.\n\nThe Two-Point \"Undue Influence\" Enhancement Applies\n\nPursuant to U.S.S.G. § 2G1.3(b)(2)(B), two levels are added if \"a participant . . . unduly\ninfluenced a minor to engage in prohibited sexual conduct.\" This enhancement applies where \"a\nparticipant's influence over the minor compromised the voluntariness of the minor's behavior.\"\nId. app. n.3(B). Where, as here, \"a participant is at least 10 years older than the minor,\" the\nGuidelines provide for \"a rebuttable presumption . . . that such participant unduly influenced the\nminor to engage in prohibited sexual conduct. In such a case, some de\n... [truncated, 2047 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/29 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=29]", "char_count": 2047}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 31 of 55\n\nbe presumed because of the substantial difference in age between the participant and the minor.\"\nId.\nOn the facts, the defendant does not resist application of this enhancement to any victim\nother than Carolyn. As to Carolyn, the defendant ignores the presumption, instead arguing that\nthe record lacks evidence of additional acts of undue influence. (Def. Mem. 21-22). None is\nrequired: the age difference alone provides a basis for the Court to apply the enhancement. See\nUnited States v. Watkins, 667 F.3d 254, 264-65 (2d Cir. 2012) (applying the presumption and\nnoting that the defendant \"failed to offer any evidence rebutting the presumption on this basis,\"\neven though the defendant argued that the \"evidence demonstrated that [the defendant] failed to\ncompromise the voluntariness of [the victim]\" (internal quotation marks and alteration omitted)).\nAnd, in any event, the record shows that the defendant directed Virginia to show Carolyn how to\nsexually gratify Epstein (Tr. 1521), called to set up appointments with Carolyn at Epstein's lavish\nPalm Beach mansion (Tr. 1527), sent cars or cabs to pick her up (Tr. 1532), gave Carolyn what, to\nCarolyn, were large sums of money needed to fuel her drug addiction (Tr. 1528-31, 1541), and\nhelped Epstein send Carolyn gifts, including lingerie (Tr. 1541-42). The record also shows that\nthe defendant talked with Carolyn about her family problems, traumatic personal experiences, and\ngoals (Tr. 1534-35), and complimented her body (Tr. 1536), which—as Dr. Rocchio explained—\ncan help to build a relationship of trust and attachment. Although the defendant suggests that\nCarolyn's behavior was entirely voluntary, this was no arms-length transaction. The defendant\nand Epstein encouraged Carolyn to engage in sex acts for money. That is undue influence. See,\ne.g., United States v. Patterson, 576 F.3d 431, 443 (7th Cir. 2009) (affirming application of an\nundue influence guidel\n... [truncated, 2196 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/30 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=30]", "char_count": 2196}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 32 of 55\n\nbehavior was voluntary, the defendant argues that Carolyn did not do \"whatever [Epstein and\nMaxwell] asked of her\"—noting that Carolyn did not travel with them to Little Saint James. (Def.\nMem. 21). But that shows only that their undue influence was not all-consuming, not that they\nlacked influence whatsoever. The standard is \"'undue influence,' not coercion.\" United States v.\nMontijo-Maysonet, 874 F.3d 34, 52 (1st Cir. 2020).\nThe defendant also argues that application of this enhancement would constitute doublecounting because the base offense level for Counts Three, Four, and Six covers her conduct\nenticing and coercing minors. (Def. Mem. 20). This argument lacks merit. As the defendant\ncorrectly notes, \"[i]mpermissible double counting occurs when one part of the Guidelines is\napplied to increase the defendant's sentence to reflect the kind of harm that has already been fully\naccounted for by another part of the Guidelines.\" Watkins, 667 F.3d at 261. But \"when the\nchallenged part of the Guidelines aim[s] at different harms emanating from the same conduct, there\nis no impermissible double counting,\" and \"[e]nhancements are not duplicative when they reflect\ndifferent facets of the defendant's conduct.\" Id. at 261-62 (alterations, citations, and internal\nquotation marks omitted).\nThe relevant inquiry therefore is whether the base offense level is aimed at the same harm\nas the enhancement. Here, it is not: the base offense level (which refers to § 2G1.3) captures the\ncategory of sex offenses against minors, and § 2G1.3(b)(2)(B) applies to the use of undue\ninfluence. See United States v. Kohlineier, 858 F. App'x 444, 446-47 (2d Cir. 2021) (describing\nthe focus of § 2B1.3(b)(2XB)); United States v. Arbaugh, 951 F. 3d 167, 173 (4th Cir. 2020) (\"By\nits plain terms, § 2G1.3(bX2XB) focuses on a different aggravating factor (undue influence) than\n§ 2G1.3 (minor victims) .... As such, subsection (bX2)(B) doe\n... [truncated, 2092 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/31 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=31]", "char_count": 2092}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 33 of 55\n\nThe defendant's argument to the contrary—that her particular crime involved undue\ninfluence of minors—does not demonstrate double-counting. The fact that the defendant's course\nof conduct triggers both the harm targeted by the base offense level and the harm triggered by an\nenhancement shows that the enhancement applies, not that the enhancement is redundant with the\nbase offense level.3\nD.\n\nThe Five-Level F hancement in Section 4B1.5 Applies\n\nSection 4B1.5 has two provisions, depending on whether a defendant has a prior sex\noffense conviction. Where, as here, the defendant does not have a prior conviction, § 4B1.5(b)\nadds five offense levels and sets a minimum offense level of 22, so long as the defendant satisfies\nthat section's three requirements: (1) the offense of conviction must be a \"covered sex crime,\" (b)\nthe defendant is neither a career offender nor a repeat offender, and (c) the defendant \"engaged in\na pattern of activity involving prohibited sexual conduct.\" Id. § 4B1.1(b). \"Prohibited sexual\nconduct,\" in turn, covers any offense under Chapters 117, 109A, or 110, and any state law offense\nthat would be a federal offense under those chapters if committed \"within the special maritime and\nterritorial jurisdiction of the United States.\" 18 U.S.C. § 2426 (2003); see U.S.S.G. § 4B1.5 app.\nn.4(A) (incorporating that definition); see also, e.g., United States v. M,\n\n431 F.3d 86, 90 &\n\nn.6 (2d Cir. 2005) (applying these requirements).\n\n3 The defendant also argues that the enhancement does not apply as to Jane and Annie because,\nunder the 2003 Guidelines, the undue influence must occur with the object of having the minor\nengage in a commercial sex act. (Def. Mem. 21). As explained above, the 2004 Guidelines manual\napplies, and it contains no such provision. In any event, Jane testified that she received money\nduring the course of her abuse (Tr. 301-02), and Annie testified that she was promised \n... [truncated, 2362 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/32 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=32]", "char_count": 2362}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 34 of 55\n\nAll three of these requirements are satisfied here. The offense of conviction is a \"covered\nsex crime.\" See U.S.S.G. § 4B1.5 app. n.2 (stating that offenses in Chapter 117 of Title 18 are\ncovered sex crimes); 18 U.S.C. § 2423 (located in Chapter 117). The defendant is neither a career\noffender nor a repeat offender. And the defendant \"engaged in a pattern of activity involving\nprohibited sexual conduct.\" As discussed at length above, the defendant transported Jane to New\nYork, a Chapter 117 offense, she transported Virginia, and she touched Jane and Carolyn's\nbreasts—which would be Chapter 109A offenses had they occurred within the territorial\njurisdiction of the United States. See 18 U.S.C. §§ 2243, 2244, 2246 (2003) (defining \"sexual\ncontact\" to include the touching of the breast with the intent to \"gratify the sexual desire of any\nperson,\" and criminalizing knowingly engaging in sexual contact with a minor under the age of\n16). This is well more than required by the Guidelines. See United States v. Telles, 18 F.4th 290,\n303 (9th Cir. 2021) (applying the enhancement where \"Telles sexually abused T.B. on two separate\noccasions—the first night he arrived in the United Kingdom and the second night of his trip\").\nThe defendant has no serious argument that the text of the Guidelines is inapplicable on\nthese facts. Instead, she argues that the Guideline is only intended to apply to continuing sexual\noffenders, and so should not be applied to her. (Def. Mem. 11-14). The background commentary\nincorporates her principle, she adds, and such commentary is \"authoritative.\" (Id. at 14). This\nargument fails at each step.\nFirst, applying § 4B1.5(b) to the defendant is entirely consistent with the Guidelines\ncommentary. That commentary explains that the enhancement is meant to prevent repeat sexual\noffenders from committing further crimes, as the defendant notes. But it also explains that the\nGuideline was enact\n... [truncated, 2192 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/33 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=33]", "char_count": 2192}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 35 of 55\n\nminors.\" U.S.S.G. § 4B1.5 background cmt.; see Protection of Children from Sexual Predators\nAct of 1998, Pub. L. 105-314 § 505 (\"Pursuant to its authority . . . the United States Sentencing\nCommission shall. . . promulgate amendments to the Federal Sentencing Guidelines to increase\npenalties applicable to [certain offenses] in any case in which the defendant engaged in a pattern\nof activity involving the sexual abuse or exploitation of a minor.\"); see id. § 502 (directing the\nSentencing Commission to \"ensure that the sentences, guidelines, and policy statements for\noffenders convicted of [Chapter 117 offenses] are appropriately severe and reasonably consistent\nwith other relevant directives with other Federal Sentencing Guidelines\"). That is, while one\nconcern motivating the Guideline is protection of the public from future offenses, another is just\npunishment for the seriousness of criminal conduct involving the abuse of multiple minors or a\nminor on multiple occasions. See also, e.g., U.S.S.G. Amend. 615 (explaining that this Guideline\nwas promulgated to \"increase penalties in any case in which the defendant engaged in a pattern of\nactivity of sexual abuse or sexual exploitation of a minor\" (emphasis added)); Protection of\nChildren from Sexual Predators Act of 1998, Proceedings and Debates Before the Senate, 105th\nCong., 2nd Session (Sept 17, 1998) (statement of Sen. Orrin Hatch), available at 144 Cong. Rec.\nS10518-02, 510521, 1998 WL 636904 (\"[T]he bill will also recommend that the Sentencing\nCommission reevaluate the guidelines applicable to these offenses, and increase them where\nappropriate to address the egregiousness of these crimes.\"). In any event, Guidelines commentary\nis not binding over the text of the relevant Guideline. The commentary on which the defendant\nrelies is not \"interpretive or explanatory,\" but \"background\" commentary. United States v. Sash,\n396 F.3d 515, 523 (2d Cir. 2005\n... [truncated, 2262 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/34 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=34]", "char_count": 2262}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 36 of 55\n\nquotation marks omitted); see United States v. Parkins, 935 F.3d 65, 67 (2d Cir. 2019) (citing\nSash). And even when Guidelines commentary is explanatory and binding, it is \"akin to an\nagency's interpretation of its own legislative rules,\" and therefore does not control where it is\n\"inconsistent with the regulation.\" Stinson v. United States, 508 U.S. 36, 45 (1993) (quoting\nBowles v. Seminole Rock & Sand Co., 325 U.S. 410, 414 (1945)). If the Guidelines commentary\nwere flatly inconsistent with the plain text of the Guideline itself—because the Guideline squarely\napplies where the commentary says it should not—the Guideline itself would control. See Sash,\n396 F.3d at 522 (\"We need not resort to background commentary interpretations when the\nlanguage of the Guidelines is plain.\").\nFinally, the defendant's argument that the public does not need to be protected from her is\nan available argument under § 3553(a), but it is not a justification for deviating from the text of\nthe Guidelines.°\nIII.\n\nDiscussion\n\nA. The Defendant's Conduct Warrants a Term of Imprisonment Within the\nGuidelines Range of 360 to 660 Months' Imprisonment\nI. The Nature and Seriousness of the Offense\nThe defendant stands convicted of sexually exploiting multiple underage girls. Her crimes\nwere monstrous, and the Court should impose a sentence that reflects her role in serious federal\n\n4 The defendant also argues that application of the Guideline to her would yield absurd results,\n\nbecause she would have a lower sentencing range if she had been convicted of a prior sex offense,\nand (she claims) the same sentencing range that Epstein would face. (Def. Mem. 14-16). But\nSection 4B1.5(a) is structured differently than Section 4B1.5(b), setting floors for the offense level\nand criminal history category rather than imposing a five-level increase. See U.S.S.G. Amend.\n615 (explaining that § 4B1.5(a)'s penalties rely on the prior conviction but\n... [truncated, 2386 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/35 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=35]", "char_count": 2386}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 37 of 55\n\ncrimes. For the reasons set forth below, the nature and seriousness of the offense weigh in favor\nof a Guidelines sentence, in light of the role the defendant played in the conspiracy and the\nirreparable harm the defendant caused to her victims.\nThe Defendant's Role in the Conspiracy\nMaxwell's conduct was shockingly predatory. She was a calculating, sophisticated, and\ndangerous criminal who preyed on vulnerable young girls and groomed them for sexual abuse.\nAlthough there are many unsettling aspects of the defendant's conduct, what stands out\nfrom the trial record is that she worked with Epstein to select victims who she knew were\nvulnerable to exploitation. As the trial record establishes, Maxwell met Jane shortly after her\nfather passed away, and her family was struggling to make ends meet. Annie's mother was\nstruggling to raise her daughters alone. Carolyn was living alone with her mother, who was an\naddict. It is not a coincidence that all of Maxwell's victims came from single-mother households.\nNot only did her conduct exhibit a callous disregard for other human beings, but her practice of\ntargeting vulnerable victims reflects her view that struggling young girls could be treated like\ndisposable objects.\nOnce the victims were selected, Maxwell played an essential role in the conspiracy by\ngrooming victims for abuse. Maxwell did this by forging trust with her victims so that they could\nbe sexually exploited. As Dr. Rocchio explained, the psychological harms of sexual abuse are\ngreater where, as here, the abuse arises from a relationship of trust with the abuser:\nTrust is central often in the treatment of someone who's been\nsexually abused, because it's often the part that is most confusing\nand also causes the most — the most harm. We know that the more\nthey trusted the individual, then, of course, the more they feel\nbetrayed, the more betrayal there's been. And to the extent there's\nbeen betray\n... [truncated, 2134 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/36 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=36]", "char_count": 2134}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 38 of 55\n\nunderstand what happened, how it happened and why, and what its\neffect is certainly.\n(Tr. 742-43). Maxwell's victims trusted her: she was a seemingly respectable woman who showed\ninterest in them and promised to help them. She was key to the entire operation of the scheme,\nand Epstein could not have committed these crimes without her.\nMaxwell befriended her victims, won their trust, slowly broke down their boundaries, and\nnormalized sexual abuse. For example, Jane testified that the defendant showed her how Epstein\nliked to be massaged and how he liked his penis touched. The defendant did this when Jane was\nonly 14 years old. The defendant was an adult, in her thirties, helping to normalize abusive sexual\nconduct with a young teenager. The defendant's demeanor was \"casual, like it was — like it was\nvery normal, like it was not a big deal.\" (Tr. 309). When Jane was in her twenties, she described\nMaxwell this way to her boyfriend, who remembered years later how Jane told him that Epstein\nhad abused her, and the defendant had made her feel comfortable. (Tr. 644).\nThe degree to which the defendant manipulated her victims is an aggravating factor in this\ncase. But her abusive conduct did not end with the grooming and manipulation of the victims.\nShe also participated in the sexual abuse of her victims. Not only was Maxwell the person who\nwas most frequently in the room when Epstein abused Jane (Tr. 289), but multiple victims testified\nthat the defendant groped their breasts. (Tr. 310 (Jane), 2224 (Annie), 1536 (Carolyn)). In\nparticular, Annie described a terrifying encounter in which she found herself alone with Maxwell\nat Epstein's ranch in New Mexico, and Maxwell told her to remove her clothing so she could give\nAnnie a \"massage\" during which she rubbed Annie's breasts. (Tr. 2224; PSR ¶ 52). That socalled massage was the defendant sexually abusing a teenage girl.\nThe conspiracy in this case was extens\n... [truncated, 2168 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/37 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=37]", "char_count": 2168}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 39 of 55\n\noperate the scheme, Maxwell and Epstein used many employees: pilots, household staff, personal\nassistants, and drivers. Maxwell was central to operating the scheme and managing employees at\nthese properties. Most importantly, the offense conduct was extensive because so many young\ngirls were sexually exploited as a direct result of the defendant's conduct. At trial, the evidence\nestablished that Jane, Annie, Kate, Carolyn, Virginia, and Melissa were all exploited as a direct\nresult of the defendant's actions.\nThe trial record also makes clear that there were many other victims who were harmed by\nthis conspiracy. First, Carolyn testified that she brought multiple additional minors, including\nMelissa, to provide paid sexualized massages to Epstein.\n\nAlthough these minors did not\n\nnecessarily interact directly with Maxwell, they were subjected to sexual abuse as a result of the\npyramid scheme that Maxwell and Epstein set in motion. Carolyn specifically recalled bringing\ngirls named\n\nand Amanda when they were under the age of 18 to provide paid sexualized\n\nmassages for Epstein. (Tr. 1543-44). Second, the defendant's black book contained dozens of\nentries under the heading \"Massage — Florida,\" and included entries referencing individuals'\nparents. (GX 52). Third, records recovered from Epstein's Palm Beach residence during a 2005\nsearch by the Palm Beach Police Department reveal that additional minors provided Epstein with\nsexualized massages between 2001 and 2004. In particular, message pads seized from the\nresidence contain multiple messages from underage girls who called to schedule massage\nappointments. (GX 1, 2, 3, and 4). Lest there be any doubt that the individuals named in the\nmessage pads were in fact minors providing sexualized massages to Epstein, many of the girls\nidentified in the messages were listed as identified minor victims of Epstein in connection with his\nresolution of the investigat\n... [truncated, 2176 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/38 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=38]", "char_count": 2176}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 40 of 55\n\nidentified a total of thirty-two minor victims, including Carolyn and Virginia.3 Of those thirtytwo individuals, thirteen appear in the message pads, again including Carolyn and Virginia.\nThe Government notes that, from interviewing many of these victims during the course of\nits investigation, the Government has learned that, in the later phases of the conspiracy, victims\nprimarily scheduled appointments with—and interfaced with—Epstein's personal assistants, who\nwere in their early twenties.' Although the Government does not seek to include these minors as\nvictims for purposes of the Guidelines calculation, the scope of the pyramid scheme that the\ndefendant helped devise with Epstein bears emphasis when evaluating the harms that the\ndefendant's criminal conduct ultimately caused.\nVictim Impact\nIt is difficult to capture in words the harm that Maxwell caused to her victims. They were\nchildren who experienced what can only be described as a recurring nightmare: again and again,\nthey found themselves alone with Maxwell and Epstein in terrifying mansions where they were\nsexually abused and physically violated. They were trapped in an exploitative relationship with\nMaxwell and Epstein that, for many victims, lasted for years.\nOften, in cases involving sexual exploitation, the Court is left to consider the harms the\nvictims have suffered during the offense conduct and to predict the likely effects on their lives\ngoing forward. What is remarkable in this case is that the Court need make no such predictions\n\n3 The letter was marked with Jencks Act control number 3505-022. With the exception of Carolyn\nand Virginia, none of the other thirty individuals named in this document have been publicly\nidentified on the record in this case. Those victims retain significant privacy interests.\nOf course, there can be no comparison between the defendant—a woman in her forties in the\n2000s—and the young women (often in\n... [truncated, 2171 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/39 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=39]", "char_count": 2171}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 41 of 55\n\nhere. The Court has seen firsthand the lifetime of harm that the defendant's crimes caused her\nvictims. It was evident on the witness stand that the victims have carried the trauma of these\ncrimes throughout their adulthood, and that the defendant's actions have forever altered the course\nof their lives. As Dr. Rocchio testified at trial, victims of child sexual abuse suffer ongoing trauma:\nWe know that although all adverse events that occur during\nchildhood can place children at higher risk for adverse outcomes,\nwe know that among those, child sexual abuse in particular increases\nrisk for a very, very high number of various health problems and\nmental health problems and also increases risk for the severity of\nthose problems.\n(Tr. 741-42). That is true for all of the victims in this case.\nThe repeated sexual abuse that Jane experienced has had lasting effects. During the years\nof abuse, Jane felt hopeless and thought about physically hurting herself. (PSR ¶ 38). Jane\ncontinues to struggle with the abuse. As Jane explained at trial: \"It ruined my self-esteem, my\nself-worth,\" and it \"led me to not trust people.\" (Id.). She remarked: \"How do you navigate a\nhealthy relationship with a broken compass? I didn't even understand what real love is supposed\nto look like.\" (Id.). Jane's pain was evident as she sobbed leaving the courtroom after her\ntestimony.\nIn a letter7 to the Court in connection with sentencing, Annie explained: \"One of the most\npainful and ongoing impacts of Maxwell and Epstein's abuse was a loss of trust in myself, my\nperceptions, and my instincts. When predators groom and then abuse or exploit children and other\nvulnerable people, they are, in a sense, training them to distrust themselves.\" She further\n\n7 The victim impact statements referenced in this submission have been provided to defense\ncounsel in accordance with the Court's June 21,2022 Order (Dkt. No. 668). Subject to the proces\n... [truncated, 2091 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/40 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=40]", "char_count": 2091}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 42 of 55\n\nexplained: \"This toxic combination of being sexually exposed and exploited, feeling confused and\nnaïve, blaming myself all resulted in significant shame.\"\nKate has explained that \"the consequences of what Ghislaine Maxwell did have been far\nreaching for me.\" In a letter to the Court in connection with sentencing, Kate shared: \"I have\nstruggled with, and eventually triumphed over, substance use disorder. I have suffered panic\nattacks and night terrors, with which I still struggle. I have suffered low self esteem, loss of career\nopportunities. I have battled greatly with feeling unable to trust my own instincts, in choosing\nromantic relationships.\"\nCarolyn's testimony at trial made clear that she, too, has suffered greatly as a result of the\ndefendant's crimes. Over her years of abuse at Epstein's hands, Carolyn fell deeper into drug\naddiction, and she has experienced significant struggles with mental health and addiction\nthroughout her adult life. (PSR ¶ 59). When explaining the trauma she experienced, Carolyn\nexpressed, \"my soul is broken and so is my heart.\" (Tr. 1678). Her pain was palpable on the\nwitness stand as she described the horrifying years of abuse she suffered.\nAs the foregoing makes clear, the defendant played an essential role in a child exploitation\nconspiracy that caused lasting harm to many young girls. The defendant preyed on vulnerable\nyoung girls, manipulated them, and served them up to be sexually abused by Epstein, a prolific\npredator and abuser of children.\n\nYears of sexual abuse, multiple victims, devastating\n\npsychological harm: none of this could have happened without Maxwell. A Guidelines sentence\nis necessary to reflect the gravity of the offense conduct and the pain and trauma the defendant\ninflicted upon her many victims.\n\n40\n\nEFTA02838415\n\n", "char_count": 1870}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 43 of 55\n\n2. History and Characteristics of the Defendant\nThe history and characteristics of the defendant also weigh in favor of a Guidelines\nsentence.\nAlthough many defendants come before sentencing courts with compelling mitigating\nfactors from difficult upbringings, Maxwell is not among them. She has enjoyed a remarkable life\nof privilege, having lived in luxury and moved in social circles among the famous and powerful.\nAnd while the defendant may have had a marginally less positive experience than other\nexceptionally wealthy children, it is difficult to see how stern conversation at the family dinner\ntable is an excuse for participating in a child exploitation scheme.\nMoreover, the record at sentencing makes clear that the defendant has engaged in a\nsignificant pattern of dishonest conduct, which speaks volumes about her character.\n\nThe\n\ndefendant's record includes the following:\n•\n\nIn 2016, the defendant testified under oath in a civil deposition in connection with\na lawsuit brought by\n\nand lied repeatedly during her testimony.\n\nFor example, she denied, among other things, having given\n\na\n\nmassage. (PSR ¶ 75-76). As the evidence at trial established, that was a lie.\n•\n\nUpon her arrest, the defendant was interviewed by Pretrial Services, and told them\nthat the home she owned in New Hampshire was owned by a corporation, and that\nshe was \"just able to stay there.\" (PSR ¶ 149). That was a lie, as were her\nstatements to Pretrial Services about her finances.\n\nIn an Order denying the\n\ndefendant's renewed application for bail, the Court remarked on the defendant's\n\"lack of candor\" about her finances and concluded that the defendant had\n\n41\n\nEFTA02838416\n\n", "char_count": 1740}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 44 of 55\n\n\"misrepresent[ed] key facts to Pretrial Services and, by extension, the Court.\" (PSR\n172, December 28, 2020 Opinion at 14-16).\n•\n\nOn November 1, 2021, the Court allocuted the defendant about whether she had\nengaged in plea discussions with the Government. Although the Court's question\ncalled for a yes or no answer about plea offers, the defendant elected to volunteer\nthe following: \"I have not committed any crime.\" (November I, 2021 Tr. at 113).\nThat was a lie.\n\n•\n\nIn preparation for sentencing, the defendant was interviewed by the Probation\nOffice, and she refused to provide any information about the circumstances of her\nmarriage and, accordingly, the Probation Office was unable to verify these facts.\n(PSR at 145). Moreover, the defendant reported that she had almost no assets, a\nsharp contrast from the defendant's earlier representation to the Court—in pursuit\nof bail—that she had approximately $22 million in assets. (PSR ¶ 172). In short,\nthe defendant apparently decides when she wishes to disclose facts to the Court,\nand those facts shift when it serves the defendant's interests.\n\nMoreover, even now, at sentencing, the defendant has shown no acceptance of\nresponsibility, and her submission fails to even mention, much less accept responsibility for, the\nharm she has caused her victims. Instead, her entire submission is an effort to cast herself as a\nvictim: of her father, of Epstein, of the media, of prosecutors, of the Bureau of Prisons. Although\nmuch of the defendant's sentencing memorandum aims to cast aspersions on the Government,\nthese claims are baseless. This Office did what it always does in any case: it followed the facts\nand law. The investigation uncovered that the defendant committed terrible crimes, and that is\nwhat this case is about. The Court should see the defendant's attack on the Government's motives\n\n42\n\nEFTA02838417\n\n", "char_count": 1942}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 45 of 55\n\nfor exactly what it is: a desperate attempt to shift the blame for her own crimes and distract from\nthe gravity of her offense conduct.\nIn short, the defendant has lied repeatedly about her crimes, exhibited an utter failure to\naccept responsibility, and demonstrated repeated disrespect for the law and the Court. The\ndefendant's history and characteristics weigh in favor of a Guidelines sentence.\n3. The Need to Promote Respect for the Law and to Afford Adequate Deterrence\nThe importance of promoting respect for the law and affording adequate deterrence further\nsupports imposing a sentence within the Guidelines range. Given the magnitude, breadth, and\nsophistication of the conduct in this case, those interests are best served by a significant term of\nimprisonment. The defendant's pattern of exploitative conduct, and her lies to evade responsibility\nfor her crimes, should be met with punishment that holds her accountable for the full measure of\nher criminal conduct and the abuse and horror for which she is responsible.\nA Guidelines sentence would also deter those who would facilitate sexual abusers in\npositions of power. As the Government has emphasized throughout this case, Jeffrey Epstein\ncould not have committed these crimes without the defendant. The defendant, an adult woman,\nwas able to provide a cover of respectability to Epstein that lulled the victims and their families\ninto a false sense of security. This case sends the important message that those who would conspire\nwith sexual predators will be held responsible for their significant role in these crimes.\nAccordingly, a Guidelines sentence is necessary to afford deterrence.\nThe lenient sentence the defendant seeks would send the message that there is one system\nof laws for the rich and powerful, and another set for everyone else. It would also send the message\nto victims that, even if they have the courage to report their abusers and under\n... [truncated, 2135 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/44 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=44]", "char_count": 2135}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 46 of 55\n\nOffice recognized in its report, a significant sentence \"should promote general deterrence against\nthe exploitation and degradation of humans made possible by this offense, as well as untouchable\nindividuals who feel their privilege and affluence entitle them to victimize others without fear of\nconsequence.\" (PSR at 67).8\nB. The Defendant's Arguments for a Lenient Sentence Are Unpersuasive\nThe defendant spends the majority of her sentencing submission complaining that her\nconditions of pretrial confinement warrant a downward variance. Not only are the defendant's\nclaims inaccurate, but the defense overlooks the extraordinary steps that the Court has taken\nthroughout the pendency of this case to oversee the conditions of this defendant's confinement.\nIndeed, the Court received regular updates regarding the defendant's conditions of confinement\nthroughout this case, which were based on regular communications between the Government and\nBureau of Prisons (\"BOP\") legal counsel. As a result, the Court already has exceptional insight\ninto the defendant's conditions of pretrial confinement and is well aware of the many privileges\nthe defendant has received while in custody. Although the defendant has clearly disliked her\nexperience at the Metropolitan Detention Center (\"MDC\"), the conditions she in fact experienced\ndo not rise to a level of extremity that warrant a downward variance, much less the extent of a\nvariance the defendant seeks.\n\n8 The defendant argues that she should not be \"sentenced as if she were Harvey Weinstein\" who\n\nwas convicted of forcible rape following a state jury trial. (Dkt. No. 663 at 20). These are different\ncases, under different sentencing regimes, with different facts. It is pointless to compare a state\nrape case involving adults to a federal case involving child exploitation. The defendant should be\nsentenced under the applicable federal Sentencing Guidelines for her extensive\n... [truncated, 2477 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/45 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=45]", "char_count": 2477}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 47 of 55\n\nUnlike the vast majority of inmates at the MDC, the defendant has been able to receive\nalmost immediate attention from legal counsel at the MDC, the Court, and the Government when\nraising issues regarding her confinement. Her lawyers have not hesitated to alert the Court to\nissues requiring its attention, and the Court has ensured that the defendant was able to prepare for\ntrial and participate in her defense. In addition, the defendant has filed numerous administrative\ncomplaints with the BOP, all of which have apparently been evaluated as unfounded. For example,\nthe Government understands from legal counsel at the MDC that the BOP has investigated the\ndefendant's complaints of physical abuse and concluded that they are unfounded. Legal counsel\nat the MDC further informed the Government that all pat-down searches of the defendant that took\nplace pretrial were, in fact, video recorded.\nTaken together with the defendant's perjury in her civil deposition, her lies to Pretrial\nServices, and her blatant lies about her own weight while in BOP custody, the Court can fairly\nreject many of the defendant's complaints about her conditions of confinement. Simply put, the\ndefendant lies when it suits her. It apparently suits her to spread horror stories about her\nexperiences in jail to the press in an attempt to gamer public sympathy. See, e.g., Laurence\nDollimore, Exclusive: Ghislaine Maxwell Speaksfrom Behind Barsfor the First Time in the Mail\non Sunday: Heiress Tells How 'Creepy' Guards Have Forced Her to Stop Taking Showers, Rats\nLive in Her Cell, and Why She Has No Hope ofa Fair Trial, DAILY MAIL, Nov. 15, 2021 (available\nat\n\nhttps://www.dailymaiI.co.uldnews/article-10198309/Ghislaine-MaxwelI-speaks-bars-time-\n\nMail-Sunday.html) (last visited June 20, 2022). She is trying the same tactic now with the Court.\nThe defense's attempts to compare the defendant's conditions of confinement to that of a\ndefendant \n... [truncated, 2200 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/46 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=46]", "char_count": 2200}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 48 of 55\n\ncell into a day room for thirteen hours per day, seven days per week. In the day room, the defendant\nhad exclusive access to a telephone, a television, a desktop computer, a laptop computer, and a\nshower. The defendant had access to recreation time and programming, as well as multiple hours\neach day to meet with her attorneys. Those conditions are a far cry from the 23-hour-per-day\nlockdown experienced by inmates in =,\n\nand indeed, a far cry from many inmates in general\n\npopulation during the COVID-19 pandemic, who were often locked in their cells for significant\nperiods of time to prevent the spread of the virus.\nThe defendant baselessly claims that her conditions of detention \"thwart[ed] her ability to\nparticipate in and prepare her defense.\" (Dkt. No. 663 at 25). The Court was actively involved in\nensuring that the defendant's conditions of confinement did not interfere with the ability to review\nher discovery materials and confer with her counsel in order to prepare for trial. (See, e.g., Dkt.\nNos. 49, 92, 116, 131, 265, 268, 282). Indeed, the Court repeatedly found that the defendant has\nhad sufficient time to confer with defense counsel and review her discovery. (See, e.g., Dkt. Nos.\n49, 106). As the Government has repeatedly informed the Court throughout the pendency of this\ncase, Maxwell received more time to review her discovery than any other inmate at the MDC. She\nwas permitted to review her discovery thirteen hours per day, seven days per week. During her\npretrial confinement, Maxwell had access to both a desktop computer provided by the MDC and\na laptop computer provided by the Government in November 2020 on which to review discovery.\nAlso during those thirteen hours per day, the defendant had access to the MDC desktop computer\nto send and receive emails with her attorneys. Maxwell also had as much, if not more, time as any\nother MDC inmate to communicate with her attorneys. She receiv\n... [truncated, 2193 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/47 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=47]", "char_count": 2193}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 49 of 55\n\nAdditionally, the defendant's attorneys had full copies of her discovery and were able to\nreview all discovery material with her during their ample time for attorney visits both by VTC and\nin person. The Government also took numerous steps to address the defendant's complaints about\nunreadable files within her discovery, including by providing a laptop (in addition to the BOPprovided desktop computer) on which to review her discovery, providing new copies of discovery,\nand conferring with defense counsel regarding specific files the defendant had difficulty viewing.\nAs the Government has previously informed the Court in response to the defendant's allegations\nregarding her emails, legal counsel for the MDC has conveyed that per BOP policy, all inmate\nemails are routinely purged every six months. In response to complaints from the defense\nregarding prematurely deleted emails, MDC staff examined the defendant's inmate email account.\nAccording to legal counsel for the MDC, that examination revealed that the defendant had herself\ndeleted some of her emails and had archived others, but it revealed no evidence to suggest that\nMDC staff deleted any of the defendant's emails. As the Government has previously informed the\nCourt in response to the defendant's complaints about delivery of mail, Maxwell's legal mail was\nprocessed and delivered to her in the same manner as mail for other inmates at the MDC. During\ntrial, MDC legal counsel permitted the Government to bring hard drives and disks containing legal\nmaterials to court and Maxwell was permitted to bring those materials back with her to the MDC.\nAs the Government has previously informed the Court in response to the defendant's\ncomplaints regarding nighttime checks, legal counsel for the MDC had indicated that staff conduct\nflashlight checks at nightfor all inmates as a matter of course throughout the facility for the safety\nand security of the inmates \n... [truncated, 2292 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/48 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=48]", "char_count": 2292}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 50 of 55\n\nstaff conduct flashlight checks every 30 minutes for inmates housed in the Special Housing Unit\nand conduct flashlight checks of inmates in the general population multiple times each night at\nirregular intervals, but at an average of at least once per hour.\nThe defendant's repeated claims about jail food and her weight should be rejected out of\nhand as a basis for a downward variance.\n\nLegal counsel for the MDC has informed the\n\nGovernment that when the defendant was housed outside of the general population, her meals\narrived in containers that were both microwavable and oven safe, and her meals were heated in a\nthermal oven as of at least April 6, 2021. As the Government previously informed the Court in\nresponse to the defendant's complaints about her weight, during her time at the MDC, the\ndefendant's weight has fluctuated between the 130s and the 140s. Medical records reflect that the\ndefendant weighed 146 pounds when she was arrested, and she weighed 144.5 pounds when she\nwas last weighed in April 2022. In short, the defendant's claims of extreme weight loss are not\ntrue.\nAt bottom, the defendant's complaints about jail seem to come down to the vast gulf\nbetween the conditions of her confinement and the defendant's lived experience up until her arrest\nand detention on July 2, 2020. Until July 2020, the defendant spent her entire life living in\nextraordinary luxury. Her childhood and adolescence were filled with wealth and privilege. That\naccess to wealth continued into adulthood when the defendant found a benefactor in Epstein, who\nprovided her with millions of dollars and invited her to share in his luxurious lifestyle of mansions,\nhouse staff, private chefs, and private planes. After leaving that relationship, the defendant\nremained exceptionally wealthy, residing in palatial estates and owning multiple homes. It is no\nwonder, then, that she found jail jarring. Going from being waited on hand\n... [truncated, 2122 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/49 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=49]", "char_count": 2122}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 51 of 55\n\nbetween the defendant's prior life and the life of an inmate may feel extreme to the defendant, but\nwhen compared to the experiences of other pretrial detainees in this District, her experience is by\nno means so shocking as to merit a downward variance.\nIf anything, the defendant's privilege remained intact while at the MDC, as demonstrated\nby the exceptional benefits she received. No other inmate received the kind of access to discovery\nand to counsel that the defendant did. The defendant had her own shower, her own television, her\nown desktop computer, her own laptop, and her own space to spend the day outside of her cell.\nThe defendant was able to get any concerns, no matter how small, immediately brought to the\nattention of MDC legal counsel through her attorneys. Comparing that treatment to\nof touch with reality.\n\nis out\n\nIn many respects, the defendant's conditions of confinement were\n\npreferential and more beneficial than those experienced by other inmates.\nTellingly, the defendant's complaints about the MDC seem internally inconsistent. On the\none hand, she complains that she was removed from general population. On the other hand, she\nclaims that she should not have been moved abruptly into general population after the conclusion\nof her trial.9 On the one hand, she claims that she would have had more freedom in general\npopulation. On the other hand, she asks the Court for a lesser sentence because the general\npopulation lost visitation and was locked into their cells for excessive periods because of COVID19. On the one hand, she complains that a camera was always on her. On the other hand, she\n\n9 The defendant also makes the sensational claim that she was the target of a \"credible death\n\nthreat.\" (Dkt. No. 663 at 7). The Government has conferred with legal counsel for the MDC and\nhas been informed that the MDC conducted an internal investigation of the purported threat and\ndetermined the fo\n... [truncated, 2407 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/50 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=50]", "char_count": 2407}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 52 of 55\n\nclaims that multiple abuses, all of which BOP has concluded were unfounded, were somehow not\ncaught on camera. At bottom, the defendant does not like jail. But the defendant's experiences at\nthe MDC come nowhere near justifying a downward variance from the Guidelines range.\nFinally, it bears emphasizing that the defendant has told blatant lies about her conditions\nof confinement. She repeatedly claims to have suffered significant hair loss, but anyone who has\nseen the defendant in court can easily see that is not true. She repeatedly claims to have lost an\nextreme amount of weight, but, as noted above, BOP medical records make clear that she has not.\nThe defendant is perfectly healthy, with a full head of hair. Throughout trial, she was visibly\nengaged in her defense, often actively communicating with defense counsel throughout each stage\nof the trial. Given the defense's exaggerated claims that the conditions of confinement somehow\ndeteriorated the defendant to the point of struggling to assist in her own defense, the Government\nrespectfully requests that the Court put on the record at sentencing the Court's own observations\nof the defendant's appearance and demeanor throughout the proceedings in this case.\nIV.\n\nFinancial Penalties\nIn addition to a Guidelines sentence of incarceration, the Government respectfully submits\n\nthat the Court should impose the maximum fine allowable under statute. Because each of the three\ncounts of conviction carries a maximum fine of $250,000, the maximum total allowable is\nS750,000. That amount constitutes a mere drop in the bucket for a multi-millionaire like the\ndefendant. but it nevertheless sends the message that a defendant who uses wealth to accomplish\ncriminal activity will suffer financial losses in addition to the loss of liberty. No amount of money\ncan undo the harm that the defendant's crimes have done, but given the defendant's substantial\nmeans, the majo\n... [truncated, 2129 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/51 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=51]", "char_count": 2129}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 53 of 55\n\nMoney is a key theme underlying the criminal conduct in this case. The defendant's access\nto wealth enabled her to present herself as a supposedly respectable member ofsociety, who rubbed\nshoulders with royalty, presidents, and celebrities. That same wealth dazzled the girls from\nstruggling families who became the defendant and Epstein's victims. That same wealth enabled\nthe defendant and Epstein to hire a parade of staff to transport victims and maintain the fabulous\nproperties where those victims were abused. That same wealth motivated the defendant to make\nsure that Epstein's repulsive desire for sexual contact with teenage girls was always met. That\nwealth was the defendant's reward. The defendant has lived a life of extraordinary privilege, and\nshe profited from her relationship with Epstein. It is only right that she should suffer some small\nfinancial penalty for the incalculable harm she has caused.\nThe defense's submissions to the Probation Office suggest that the defendant is attempting\nto make the outrageous claim that she cannot afford a fine. (Dkt. 106). This Court has already\nfound that the defendant has attempted to conceal the full extent of her assets in connection with\nthis case. After getting caught in her lie to Pretrial Services that her only asset was her London\ntownhouse, the defendant provided a very different picture when seeking bail in December 2020.\nThe breakdown of the defendant's finances provided then demonstrated that the defendant is a\nremarkably wealthy woman. (See Dkt. No. 97, Ex. O). That wealth appears to have primarily\ncome from Epstein. The primary source of funds reflected in that financial breakdown was the\nsale of the defendant's Manhattan townhouse. Kate testified at trial that the defendant told Kate\nthat Epstein obtained the New York townhouse for the defendant. (Tr. 1194). Additionally, the\nevidence at trial demonstrated that Epstein transferred a total \n... [truncated, 2247 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02838374/52 or ?id=EFTA02838374&page=52]", "char_count": 2247}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 53, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 54 of 55\n\nthe multiple millions of dollars. A $750,000 fine will hardly impact her financial outlook, but it\nis the most the law will allow in this case. The Court should impose it without hesitation.\nWith respect to forfeiture, the Government is not seeking to forfeit any property because\nthe Government has not identified specific property used in the offense conduct that the defendant\nherself owned.\nFinally, because each of the identified victims has already received monetary compensation\nfor the harms caused to them by the defendant's criminal conduct, the Government does not seek\nrestitution in this case. Restitution is not available where victims have received compensation for\ntheir losses from another source. Each of the six victims identified at trial—Jane, Annie, Kate,\nCarolyn, Virginia, and Melissa—has received funds from the Epstein Victim Compensation Fund\nand/or civil settlements as compensation for the harms they suffered as a result of the defendant's\nand Epstein's crimes. The Government is not aware of any otherwise recoverable losses for which\nthese victims have not received monetary compensation. Accordingly, there is no legal basis for\nrestitution in this case.\n\n52\n\nEFTA02838427\n\n", "char_count": 1276}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02838374", "page_number": 54, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 670\n\nFiled 06/22/22\n\nPage 55 of 55\n\nCONCLUSION\nGhislaine Maxwell sexually exploited young girls for years. It is difficult to overstate the\nmagnitude of her crimes and the harm she caused. Her crimes demand justice. The Government\nurges the Court to impose a sentence within the applicable Guidelines range of 360 to 660 months'\nimprisonment.\n\nDated: New York, New York\nJune 22, 2022\nRespectfully submitted,\nDAMIAN\nUnited States Attorney\n\nBy:\n\ns/\nMaurene Comey\nAlison Moe\nLam Pomerantz\nAndrew Rohrbach\nAssistant United States Attorneys\n\n53\n\nEFTA02838428\n\n", "char_count": 588}]}