{"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_count": 127, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02834890", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02834890.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 1 of 127\n\n1\n\nLB1TMAX1\n\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK\nx\nUNITED STATES OF AMERICA,\nv.\n5\n\n20 CR 330 (AJN)\n\nGHISLAINE MAXWELL,\n\n6\n\nDefendant.\n\n7\n\nx\nNew York, N.Y.\nNovember 1, 2021\n11:05 a.m.\n\n8\n9\nBefore:\n10\n\nHON. ALISON J. NATHAN,\n11\nDistrict Judge\n12\n13\n\nAPPEARANCES\n\n14\n\nDAMIAN\nUnited States Attorney for the\nSouthern District of New York\nALISON MOE\nMAURENE COMEY\nANDREW ROHRBACH\nLARA POMERANTZ\nAssistant United States Attorney\n\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n\n& GRESSER\nAttorneys for Defendant\nCHRISTIAN EVERDELL\n\n20\n21\n22\n23\n\nHADDON\nAttorneys for Defendant\nJEFFREY PAGLIUCA\nLAURA MENNINGER\nBOBBI C. STERNHEIM\nAttorney for Defendant\n\n24\n25\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834890\n\n", "char_count": 776}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 1:2O-cr-OO33O-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 2 of 127\n\n2\n\nLB1TMAX1\n(Case called)\nDEPUTY CLERK:\n\nCounsel, please state your name for the\n\nrecord, starting with the government.\n4\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nGood morning, your Honor, Alison Moe for the\n\n5\n\ngovernment, joined at counsel table by Lara Pomerantz, Maurene\n\n6\n\nComey, Andrew Rohrbach and Sunny Drescher, a paralegal\n\n7\n\nspecialist in our office.\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nGood morning.\n\n9\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nGood morning, Judge Nathan, Bobby C.\n\n10\n\nSternheim appearing for Ghislaine Maxwell.\n\nNext to me at\n\n11\n\ncounsel table also present are part of the defense team,\n\n12\n\nJeffrey Pagliuca, Laura Menninger and Christian Everdell.\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nGood morning, everyone.\n\n14\n\nGood morning, Ms. Maxwell.\n\n15\n\nI am told, consistent with the protocols, that I can\n\nPlease be seated.\n\n16\n\nremove my mask while seated here at the bench, and counsel,\n\n17\n\nwhen they're at the podium, if you wish to speak from the\n\n18\n\npodium, you may remove your mask.\n\n19\n\nSo I will do that.\n\nWe're here today for a pretrial conference in this\n\n20\n\nmatter.\n\n21\n\nquestionnaire process beginning this Thursday, November 4.\n\n22\n\nI have indicated, we will begin trial on November 29.\n\n23\n\nTrial is scheduled to commence with the jury\nAs\n\nAs I see it, the primary purpose of today's conference\n\n24\n\nis largely to address the parties' motions in limine and then\n\n25\n\ndiscuss some additional logistical issues.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834891\n\n", "char_count": 1496}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 1:2O-cr-OO33O-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 3 of 127\n\n3\n\nLB1TMAX1\nCounsel, I'm prepared to turn to the motions first,\nunless there's any reason to deviate from that.\nMs. Moe?\n4\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n6\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nNo, your Honor, thank you.\nMs. Sternheim?\nNot at this time, Judge.\n\nAll right.\n\nI am in receipt of the\n\n8\n\nparties' various motions in limine, responses in opposition,\n\n9\n\nand replies in support.\n\n10\n\npapers on the public docket with their proposed redactions so\n\n11\n\nthat the public could have immediate access to the documents.\n\n12\n\nI'll rule on the proposed redactions as quickly as I\n\n13\n\ncan, including some that I will discuss today, but we will use\n\n14\n\nthe same process going forward so as not to delay public access\n\n15\n\nto the bulk of materials related to pretrial filings.\n\n16\n\nthank counsel for that, as well as the submission to me of the\n\n17\n\nunredacted versions with the color coding indicating requested\n\n18\n\nredactions.\n\n19\n\nI did require the parties to file the\n\nAnd I\n\nThe government filed 11 motions in limine and the\n\n20\n\ndefense 13, so there's a lot of ground to cover.\n\n21\n\nto discuss all the motions now with the exception of the\n\n22\n\nDaubert motion.\n\n23\n\nthis morning, I will hold a Daubert hearing before resolving\n\n24\n\nthat motion.\n\n25\n\nI am prepared\n\nAs I indicated in an order that was docketed\n\nAs to the rest, some I want to hear further from the\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834892\n\n", "char_count": 1495}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 4 of 127\n\n4\n\nLB1TMAX1\nparties on issues, some I'm prepared to resolve without further\ndiscussion.\n\nFor all of them, to the extent I can resolve them\n\nor give guidance today, I will.\n4\n5\n\nIn some cases, by necessity, I\n\nwill reserve.\nOf course, as with all in limine motions, those are\n\n6\n\npreliminary rulings based on what I know now about the\n\n7\n\nanticipated evidence and arguments.\n\n8\n\nto guide the parties in advance of trial, to guide opening\n\n9\n\nstatements and the like.\n\n10\n\nchange during trial and you must reraise issues if you think\n\n11\n\nthe other side has opened the door or that premises of certain\n\n12\n\npretrial holdings no longer hold.\n\n13\n\nMy preliminary rulings are\n\nFacts on the ground, of course, can\n\nWith that, I'm going to move slightly out of order and\n\n14\n\nbegin with the defendant's 12th motion in limine because it\n\n15\n\ninvolves terminology questions that apply throughout.\n\n16\n\nthat motion I will address the government's motions in order\n\n17\n\nand then address the remaining defense motions in order.\n\n18\n\nAfter\n\nIn the defendant's 12th motion in limine, the defense\n\n19\n\nasked the Court to preclude use of the terms \"victim\" and\n\n20\n\n\"minor victim.\"\n\n21\n\nuse the word \"victim\" if they're referring to someone alleged\n\n22\n\nto be a victim of the crimes charged in the indictment, and\n\n23\n\nthey may use the word \"minor\" to describe individuals that\n\n24\n\nwere, at the relevant time period, under the age of consent.\n\n25\n\nThe motion is denied.\n\nGovernment counsel can\n\nAs my colleague, Judge Furman, has explained,\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834893\n\n", "char_count": 1660}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 5 of 127\n\n5\n\nLB1TMAX1\nprecluding the term \"victim\" is both unnecessary and\nimpractical.\n\nUnited States v. Dupigny, 18 CR 528, transcript\n\nof October 17, 2019, Docket No. 198 at 50.\n\nIt is appropriate\n\n4\n\nfor the government to use the terms as representative of its\n\n5\n\nlitigating position.\n\n6\n\nthat is atypical or unduly prejudicial, I will revisit.\n\n7\n\nIf the government does this in any way\n\nDefense only cites out-of-circuit or state court\n\n8\n\ndecisions for the proposition that those terms are inherently\n\n9\n\nprejudicial and harm the presumption of innocence.\n\n10\n\ncourts of appeal disagree with that argument, particularly when\n\n11\n\nthe presentation of evidence and the court's instructions\n\n12\n\n\"taken as a whole clarify the government's burden of proving\n\n13\n\nall elements of the crime.\"\n\n14\n\nF.3d, 1007, 1113 (8th Cir. 2006); see also, Server v. Mizell,\n\n15\n\n902 F.2d 611, 615, (7th Cir. 1990); United States v. Granbois,\n\n16\n\n119 F.App'x 35, 38-39 (9th Cir. 2004).\n\n17\n\nNumerous\n\nUnited States v. Washburn, 444\n\nDefendant's lone district court opinion does not tip\n\n18\n\nthe balance of this authority.\n\n19\n\njury repeatedly that the defendant is presumed innocent and\n\n20\n\nthat it is the government's burden and the government's burden\n\n21\n\nalone to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.\n\n22\n\ninstructions will eliminate any potential prejudice.\n\n23\n\nJudge Furman's decision in Dupigny, Docket No. 198 at 49\n\n24\n25\n\nI will, of course, instruct the\n\nThose\nSee again\n\nThat matter resolved, I will turn to the government's\nfirst motion.\n\nThis goes to pseudonyms.\n\nThe government moves\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834894\n\n", "char_count": 1714}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 6 of 127\n\n6\n\nLB1TMAX1\npursuant to the Crime Victims Rights Act, 18 USC Section 3771,\nto permit certain witnesses and certain non-testifying\nwitnesses to be referred to by pseudonyms.\n\nAnd there is also\n\n4\n\nthe issue of redacting related exhibits that contain the names\n\n5\n\nor specifically identifying information.\n\n6\n\ngovernment requests that eight individuals be referred to by\n\n7\n\npseudonyms or their first name.\n\n8\n\nSpecifically, the\n\nThe defense is already aware of the identities of all\n\n9\n\nof these individuals, and as the government proposes it, the\n\n10\n\njury will also be aware of the individuals' real identities.\n\n11\n\nThe request only implicates how those individuals are referred\n\n12\n\nto in open court.\n\n13\n14\n15\n\nThis is well-tread territory, and I will grant the\nrequest for the following reasons:\nThe burden to justify this type of request, of course,\n\n16\n\nstarts with the government.\n\n17\n\nlimitation.\"\n\n18\n\nat *1, an Eastern District decision citing United States v.\n\n19\n\nMarti, 421 F.2d 1283 (2d Cir. 1970).\n\n20\n\nIt \"must provide a reason for the\n\nUnited States v. Marcus, which is 2007 WL 330388\n\nI agree with the government that limiting disclosure\n\n21\n\nhere would protect the alleged victims from potential\n\n22\n\nharassment from the media and others, undue embarrassment and\n\n23\n\nother adverse consequences.\n\n24\n\nthe Crime Victims Rights Act to take certain measures at trial\n\n25\n\nto protect the dignity and privacy of alleged victims.\n\nThe Court has an obligation under\n\n18 USC\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834895\n\n", "char_count": 1621}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 7 of 127\n\n7\n\nLB1TMAX1\nSection 3771(a)(8).\nIt is quite common for alleged victims, both in cases\nthat have garnered media attention and those involving\n4\n\nallegations of sex abuse, to testify or be referred to by\n\n5\n\npseudonyms or first names.\n\n6\n\nnot the alleged victims are minors or adults or adults\n\n7\n\ntestifying about abuse that allegedly occurred when they were\n\n8\n\nminors.\n\n9\n\nCourts have allowed this whether or\n\nLet me give a bit of a string cite here.\n\nSee, for\n\n10\n\nexample, United States v. Kelly, No. 19 CR 286, which is a high\n\n11\n\npublicity trial involving adults testifying about sex abuse as\n\n12\n\nminors, and that's in the Eastern District of New York; United\n\n13\n\nStates v. Raniere, No. 18 CR 204, a high-publicity trial\n\n14\n\ninvolving at least one adult testifying about sex abuse as\n\n15\n\nminor; United States v. Dupigny, No. 18 CR 528, involving sex\n\n16\n\ntrafficking, United States v. Kelly, No. 7 CR 374, and that\n\n17\n\ncould be found at 2008 WL 5068820, which is an Eastern District\n\n18\n\ncase involving an adult testifying about sex abuse as a minor;\n\n19\n\nUnited States v. Graham, No. 14 CR 500, found at 2015 WL\n\n20\n\n6161292 (S.D.N.Y., October 2015), that involved adults\n\n21\n\ntestifying about sex trafficking as minors; United States v.\n\n22\n\nGardner, No. 16 CR 20135, found at 2016 WL 5404207, an Eastern\n\n23\n\nDistrict case from 2016 involving adults and adults testifying\n\n24\n\nabout sex abuse as a minor, and collecting similar cases.\n\n25\n\nThe practice has been widely permitted because\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834896\n\n", "char_count": 1635}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 8 of 127\n\n8\n\nLB1TMAX1\nrequiring alleged victims to publicly provide their names could\nchill their willingness to testify for fear of having their\npersonal histories publicized.\n4\n\nRaniere, Docket No. 622 at 32.\n\nGiven the sensitive and inflammatory nature of the\n\n5\n\nconduct alleged, such publicity may cause further harassment or\n\n6\n\nembarrassment, and other alleged victims of sex crimes may be\n\n7\n\ndeterred from coming forward.\n\n8\n\n(E.D.N.Y. 2017), Docket No. 34.\n\n9\n\n, 17 CR 281,\n\nSee,\n\nLimiting the disclosure of alleged victims' identities\n\n10\n\nin this case furthers these important interests.\n\n11\n\ntrue with the identities of certain witnesses, although not\n\n12\n\nalleged victims themselves, because the disclosure of their\n\n13\n\nidentities would necessarily reveal the identities of the\n\n14\n\nalleged victims.\n\n15\n\nThe same is\n\nI'm not persuaded by defense counsel's arguments to\n\n16\n\nthe contrary.\n\n17\n\nnot pose a threat to any of the witnesses.\n\n18\n\ntrue, and the government does not argue or suggest or allege\n\n19\n\notherwise, but just because that reason for limiting\n\n20\n\ndisclosures is absent in this case does not eliminate the\n\n21\n\npossibility of other justifications.\n\n22\n\nneed here to prevent undue embarrassment, harassment from the\n\n23\n\npress and third parties, and any resistance of others to come\n\n24\n\nforward and report alleged abuse.\n\n25\n\nsufficient\n\nFirst, the defense notes that Ms. Maxwell does\nThat is plainly\n\nAnd again, there is a\n\nCases establish that this is\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834897\n\n", "char_count": 1611}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 9 of 127\n\n9\n\nLB1TMAX1\nMoreover, any potential prejudice in this regard can\nbe cured with an appropriate instruction explaining that the\nreason for the precaution is regard for the witnesses' and\n4\n\nalleged victims' privacy, and that no inference can or should\n\n5\n\nbe drawn against the defendant because of these precautions\n\n6\n\nMy colleagues in this district and elsewhere have used\n\n7\n\nsuch an instruction in similar cases.\n\n8\n\nthat this sort of instruction affords \"Court-sanctioned\n\n9\n\nsympathy and credibility\" is unfounded.\n\n10\n\nlaw will clearly and repeatedly instruct the jury on the\n\n11\n\npresumption of innocence and their sole role in assessing\n\n12\n\nwitness credibility\n\n13\n\nThe defense's concern\n\nMy instructions on the\n\nNor am I persuaded by the defense's arguments that the\n\n14\n\nfact that some alleged victims have previously publicly\n\n15\n\ndisclosed some of their allegations obviates the need to limit\n\n16\n\ndisclosure.\n\n17\n\nsome victims' names are publicly available does not mean that\n\n18\n\nthe details of their experience are already available.\"\n\n19\n\nRaniere, Docket No. 662 at 34, n. 17\n\nAs another district court has held, \"just because\n\n20\n\nAs I acknowledged in my protective order for this\n\n21\n\ncase, \"Not all accusations and public statements are equal.\n\n22\n\nDeciding to participate in or contribute to a criminal\n\n23\n\ninvestigation or prosecution is a far different matter than\n\n24\n\nsimply making a public statement relating to Ms. Maxwell or\n\n25\n\nJeffrey Epstein.\"\n\nDocket No. 37 in this case at 2.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834898\n\n", "char_count": 1644}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 10 of 127\n\n10\n\nLB1TMAX1\nThe government anticipates that the alleged victims\nwill \"testify in explicit detail and/or be the subject of\nhighly sensitive and personal testimony concerning illegal\n4\n\nsexual abuse.\n\n5\n\ndisclosure of their names and specifically identifying\n\n6\n\ninformation during trial in this highly publicized case\n\n7\n\ninvolving highly sensitive issues.\"\n\nThus, there's good reasons to limit public\n\n8\n\nSince there is a valid reason to limit disclosure in\n\n9\n\nthis case, the defense must proffer a particularized need for\n\n10\n\nthe disclosure of the relevant information, which is weighed\n\n11\n\nagainst the risks to the witnesses.\n\n12\n\nexample, United States v. Marcus, again citing the Second\n\n13\n\nCircuit case in United States v. Marti.\n\n14\n\nI'll cite here, for\n\nAs both parties acknowledge, the government's request\n\n15\n\npotentially implicates the defendant's right under the Sixth\n\n16\n\nAmendment's confrontation clause which guarantees defendants\n\n17\n\nthe right to cross-examine adverse witnesses.\n\n18\n\nCircuit has identified two central interests defendants have in\n\n19\n\nthe public airing of identifying information about witnesses.\n\n20\n\nAgain referencing the Marti case, 421 F.2d 1263.\n\n21\n\nThe Second\n\nThe first is not relevant here because, as I have\n\n22\n\nnoted, the defense is aware of the alleged victims' and\n\n23\n\nwitnesses' identities.\n\n24\n25\n\nThe defendant argues that the second interest,\nhowever, is implicated.\n\nNamely, defense may need the witness\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834899\n\n", "char_count": 1601}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 11 of 127\n\n11\n\nLB1TMAX1\nto reveal identifying information because knowledge of that\ninformation by the jury might be important to its deliberations\nas to the witness's credibility or knowledgability.\n\nThat's\n\n4\n\nquoting the Marti case again.\n\n5\n\nargues that revealing the alleged victims' and witnesses'\n\n6\n\nidentities is necessary to probe the nature of the alleged\n\n7\n\nvictims' occupations as relevant to the credibility and elicit\n\n8\n\ncertain impeachment evidence.\n\n9\n\nIn particular, the defense\n\nI agree that such cross-examination cannot be unduly\n\n10\n\nlimited and the government concedes the same.\n\n11\n\nmotions in limine 15, n. 6; government reply at 17 to 18.\n\n12\n\nI will ensure that it is not.\n\n13\n\nThe government's\nAnd\n\nMy decision today grants the government's request to\n\n14\n\nlimit the public disclosure of the alleged victims and some\n\n15\n\nwitnesses' names and other specifically identifying\n\n16\n\ninformation, such as the specific names of current and past\n\n17\n\nemployers, names of family members and addresses.\n\n18\n\nLimiting disclosure of the specifically identifying\n\n19\n\ninformation does not limit the anticipated cross-examination\n\n20\n\nthat the defense described in its papers.\n\n21\n\nthe defense outlined in its response are available without\n\n22\n\ndisclosing specific names of employers or other specifically\n\n23\n\nidentifying information.\n\n24\n\nthe genre, nature, and trajectories of witnesses' careers\n\n25\n\nwithout eliciting the specific employer name, but the defense's\n\nAll lines of inquiry\n\nFor example, the defense can probe\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834900\n\n", "char_count": 1668}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 12 of 127\n\n12\n\nLB1TMAX1\ncross-examination should not include specifically identifying\ninformation, and counsel must act responsibly doing so.\n\nIf,\n\nafter good faith effort in that regard is made and the defense\n4\n\nat some point feels they have hit a wall and can articulate a\n\n5\n\nspecific need with respect to a particular line of questioning,\n\n6\n\nthey can reraise the issue with opposing counsel and with me.\n\n7\n\nSo that's my ruling on that motion.\n\nThat said, I do\n\n8\n\nstrongly encourage the government to speak candidly with the\n\n9\n\nanticipated witnesses so that they're clear eyed about what\n\n10\n\nthis process will entail, the fact that cross-examination will\n\n11\n\nnot be curtailed beyond the specific identifying information\n\n12\n\nthat form the basis of the government's request, and the\n\n13\n\npossibility that despite these measures their identities may\n\n14\n\nbecome known and revealed to the public.\n\n15\n\nShould any of those witnesses or the government choose\n\n16\n\nnot to proceed by pseudonym, the government shall let defense\n\n17\n\ncounsel and the Court know.\n\n18\n\nand defense counsel shall confer about names that will be used\n\n19\n\nand any additional process for facilitating the clear\n\n20\n\npresentation of evidence.\n\n21\n\nstraightforward approach and the parties are admonished to come\n\n22\n\nto agreement on the use of pseudonyms and/or first names.\n\nIn the meantime, the government\n\nThe Court will adopt a clear and\n\n23\n\nFirst assignment, there will be others, by November 10\n\n24\n\nthe parties shall submit a joint letter to the Court under seal\n\n25\n\nexplaining the nomenclature that they propose be employed with\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834901\n\n", "char_count": 1742}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 13 of 127\n\n13\n\nLB1TMAX1\nrespect to the actual identity of each witness.\nAs I mentioned, I do agree with the government that a\nlimiting instruction explaining the reasons for the precautions\n4\n\nis appropriate.\n\n5\n\nconfer and jointly propose such a limiting instruction.\n\n6\n\nHomework No. 2.\n\n7\n\nNovember 10, and that can be filed on ECF.\n\n8\n\nIn light of my ruling, I expect the parties to\n\nThis shall also be filed jointly by\n\nThere are some logistics of voir dire related to this.\n\n9\n\nSome of my colleagues have used the list method that the\n\n10\n\ngovernment proposes on page 15, footnote 5 of their motion, and\n\n11\n\nI agree that this proposal makes sense.\n\n12\n\nparties shall confer and submit on ECF by November 10 a joint\n\n13\n\nproposal for any logistical issues related to this for voir\n\n14\n\ndire.\n\n15\n\nOnce again, the\n\nThat leaves the issue of sealing unredacted exhibits\n\n16\n\nand the limited redacting of exhibits containing specific\n\n17\n\npersonal identifying information.\n\n18\n\nthe logistics of this process throughout trial.\n\n19\n\nthrough and include in your November 10 submission on ECF the\n\n20\n\nspecifics of this part of the process so that the trial\n\n21\n\nexhibits can be contemporaneously marked with the appropriate\n\n22\n\nlimited redactions, and the government will need to manage this\n\n23\n\non an ongoing basis throughout trial.\n\n24\n25\n\nThe government shall manage\nSo think\n\nGovernment's motion 2, the alleged victims' prior\nconsistent statements.\n\nSo this goes to the admissibility of\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834902\n\n", "char_count": 1616}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Case 1:2O-cr-OO33O-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 14 of 127\n\n14\n\nLB1TMAX1\nany alleged victims' prior consistent statements.\n\nAs I can\n\ntell from the cross papers here, I don't think there's an issue\nto resolve now.\n\nThe government's reply notes it's not seeking\n\n4\n\nto admit any particular prior consistent statements at this\n\n5\n\ntime.\n\n6\n\nMs. Moe, let me confirm there will be no mention of\n\n7\n\nany such statements in the government's openings, is that\n\n8\n\ncorrect?\n\n9\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat's correct, your Honor.\nOkay.\n\nOf course, the admissibility of any\n\n11\n\nprior consistent statement hinges on defense counsel's\n\n12\n\narguments and the purpose for which any statements are being\n\n13\n\noffered.\n\n14\n\nI think the parties agree on the applicable law here.\n\n15\n\nIf this does become an issue, as they have outlined in their\n\n16\n\npapers, Rule 801(d)(1)(B)(i) excludes from the rule against\n\n17\n\nhearsay a witness's prior consistent statement offered to rebut\n\n18\n\nthe charge of recent fabrication or improper influence or\n\n19\n\nmotive.\n\n20\n\ngovernment seek to have any admitted, must have been made\n\n21\n\nbefore the motive to fabricate that's alleged arose, or else it\n\n22\n\nhas no relevance in rebutting the fabrication charge.\n\n23\n\nU.S., 513 U.S. 150, (1995).\n\n24\n25\n\nOf course, the prior consistent statement, should the\n\nTome v.\n\nThe rule's second subsection excludes prior consistent\nstatements from the rule against hearsay when they're offered\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834903\n\n", "char_count": 1530}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 15 of 127\n\n15\n\nLB1TMAX1\nto rehabilitate a witness attacked on another ground.\n801(d)(1)(B)(ii).\n\nIt's\n\nFor example, the statement could be admitted\n\nto explain what would otherwise appear to be an inconsistency\n4\n\nin the witness's statement and rebut a charge of faulty memory.\n\n5\n\nUnited States v. Purcell, 967 F.3d 159, (2d Cir. 2020).\n\n6\n\nIf it becomes relevant, the government may offer prior\n\n7\n\nstatements before the witness testifies if the defense attacks\n\n8\n\nthe credibility in opening statements and it's clear that the\n\n9\n\nwitness will be subject to cross-examination.\n\n10\n\nFlores, 945 F.3d 687, (2d Cir. 2019).\n\n11\n\napplicable law here that the parties appear to agree to in the\n\n12\n\nbriefs.\n\n13\n\noffer such statements at this time and won't mention any in\n\n14\n\nopening beyond that.\n\n15\n16\n\nThat's restating the\n\nThe government doesn't anticipate any such effort to\n\nIs there anything specific to flag or discuss here,\nfrom the government's perspective?\n\n17\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n18\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n19\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\n20\n\nUnited States v.\n\nNo, your Honor, thank you.\nMs. Sternheim?\nYour Honor, Laura Menninger.\n\nthe defense at this time.\n\nNone for\n\nThank you.\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n22\n\nThe government's 3 and 4, which I'm going to group,\n\nAll right.\n\nThank you.\n\n23\n\nthe government seeks to preclude evidence and arguments by the\n\n24\n\ndefense, (1) about the investigation in Florida, including the\n\n25\n\nnon-prosecution agreement, (2) that Ms. Maxwell was not charged\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834904\n\n", "char_count": 1585}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 16 of 127\n\n16\n\nLB1TMAX1\nby the U.S. Attorney's Office in the Southern District of\nFlorida, (3) about the scope and timeline of investigation in\nNew York, and (4) other evidence that demonstrates the\n4\n\ngovernment's motives for investigating Ms. Maxwell.\n\n5\n6\n\nThe Court's analysis here is guided by four principles\nset by the Second Circuit and the Supreme Court.\n\n7\n\nFirst, because the government has no duty to employ,\n\n8\n\nin the course of a single investigation, any particular\n\n9\n\ninvestigative technique, the failure to utilize some particular\n\n10\n\ntechnique does not tend to show that a defendant is not guilty\n\n11\n\nof the crime of which he's been charged and is therefore\n\n12\n\nirrelevant.\n\nUnited States v. Saldarriaga, 204 F.3d 50, (2d\n\n13\n\nCir. 2000).\n\nThat's the first legal principle that frames the\n\n14\n\ndiscussion here.\n\n15\n\nSecond, arguments that the government had an improper\n\n16\n\nmotive generally must be directed to the Court rather than the\n\n17\n\njury.\n\n18\n\nsee also, United States v. Farhane, 634 F.3d 127 (2d Cir.\n\n19\n\n2011).\n\n20\n\nUnited States v. Regan, 103 F.3d 1072, (2d Cir. 1997);\n\nThird legal principle:\n\nThere is no per se bar on\n\n21\n\nadmitting evidence of the government's charging decisions.\n\n22\n\nRather, the Court must -- I will quote here -- \"inquire into\n\n23\n\nits relevance and probative value to the respective case.\"\n\n24\n\nUnited States v.\n\n25\n\nUnited States v. Ngono, 801 F.App'x. 19 (2d Cir. 2020).\n\n, 692 F.3d 235 (2d Cir. 2012); see also,\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834905\n\n", "char_count": 1600}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 17 of 127\n\n17\n\nLB1TMAX1\nFourth, the confrontation clause of the Sixth\nAmendment guarantees a criminal defendant the right to\nmeaningful cross-examination of government witnesses at trial.\n4\n\nUnited States v.\n\n5\n\nIndeed, cross-examination is the principal means by which the\n\n6\n\nbelievability of a witness and the truth of his testimony are\n\n7\n\ntested.\n\n8\n\n, 548 F.3d 222, (2d Cir. 2008).\n\nv. Alaska, 415 U.S. 308, 316, (1974).\nWith this legal framework in mind, and in light of the\n\n9\n\nparties' extensive briefing on these issues, I think the\n\n10\n\nadmissibility of some of the proposed evidence can be\n\n11\n\ndetermined now, but the admissibility of other evidence will\n\n12\n\nrequire additional facts and the context of trial to decide,\n\n13\n\nbut I think it's important for me to give guidance.\n\n14\n\nBased on the papers before me, I provide the following\n\n15\n\nguidance:\n\n16\n\nby the defense that goes to the thoroughness of the\n\n17\n\ninvestigation.\n\n18\n\nof the government's investigation can in some cases be relevant\n\n19\n\nand may in some cases be admissible, it's not relevant or\n\n20\n\nadmissible if not probative of the defendant's guilt of the\n\n21\n\ncrimes charged.\n\nFirst, the Court will preclude affirmative evidence\n\nAlthough evidence that goes to the thoroughness\n\n22\n\nIn its briefing, the defense relies heavily on Kyles\n\n23\n\nv. Whitley, 514 U.S. 4 (1995), in which the Supreme Court held\n\n24\n\nthat an informant's statements to police were material for\n\n25\n\npurposes of Brady disclosures because the statements could be\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834906\n\n", "char_count": 1644}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 18 of 127\n\n18\n\nLB1TMAX1\nused to \"attack the thoroughness and even the good faith of the\ninvestigation.\"\nThat holding has only limited relevance here.\n\nFirst,\n\n4\n\nthe statement at issue in Kyles was probative because it\n\n5\n\nsuggested the defendant's innocence, not because it was\n\n6\n\nevidence of the reasons for the charging decision or the\n\n7\n\ninvestigation's timeline.\n\n8\n\nSecond, the Second Circuit in\n\nv.\n\n9\n\nnarrowly construed the holding in Kyles by clarifying that it\n\n10\n\n\"addresses only the prosecution's obligations to disclose Brady\n\n11\n\nmaterial\" and \"provides no guidance about what evidence must be\n\n12\n\nadmitted at trial or what lines of questioning must be\n\n13\n\npermitted to ensure a meaningful opportunity to cross-examine\n\n14\n\nadverse witnesses.\"\n\n15\n\n(2d Cir. 2011).\n\nv.\n\n640 F.3d 501, 512, n. 11\n\nNow the Second Circuit's decision in\n\n16\n\ndoes,\n\n17\n\nhowever, suggest that some arguments about the thoroughness of\n\n18\n\nthe investigation are probative of guilt in some circumstances.\n\n19\n\nIn that case, law enforcement had received a tip that the\n\n20\n\ndefendant was innocent because another individual shot the\n\n21\n\nvictim.\n\n22\n\nthe lead investigating officer on that tip was probative\n\n23\n\nbecause the jury could conclude that law enforcement had\n\n24\n\nprematurely concluded the defendant was the shooter and it\n\n25\n\nfailed to investigate diligently the possibility that it was\n\nThe Second Circuit stated that cross-examination of\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834907\n\n", "char_count": 1572}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 19 of 127\n\n19\n\nLB1TMAX1\nthe other individual.\n\n, 640 F.3d, 511-12.\n\nOther courts in this Circuit have described challenges\nLo the thoroughness of the investigation as a \"common method of\n4\n\nundermining a prosecution\" by, for example, cross-examining\n\n5\n\nofficers on which leads they followed and which they did not.\n\n6\n\nSee, for example, Gray v. Ercole -- I don't have that full\n\n7\n\nquote -- 2011 WL 5082868 (E.D.N.Y 2008).\n\n8\n\nmay, on cross, examine investigating officers if they\n\n9\n\nconsidered alternative suspects.\n\n10\n\nCR 98, 1996 WL 192924 at *7, that's the District of the\n\n11\n\nVermont, 1996.\n\n12\n\nF.3d 1230.\n\n13\n\ninvestigation, the investigative techniques used, and the fact\n\n14\n\nthat the defendant was not initially a target of the\n\n15\n\ninvestigation are all irrelevant pursuant to\" the principle\n\n16\n\nthat the government's failure to use particular investigative\n\n17\n\ntechniques does not tend to show that the defendant is not\n\n18\n\nguilty.\n\n19\n\n289, 2019 WL 2210663 (S.D.N.Y. 2019); see also, United States\n\n20\n\nV. Aleynikov, 785 F.Supp.2d 46, 65 (S.D.N.Y. 2011).\n\n21\n\nOr defense counsel\n\nUnited States v. Birbal, 92\n\nThat was affirmed by the Second Circuit at 113\n\nAnd I will quote here, \"The length of the\n\nSee, for example, United States v. Duncan, No. 18 CR\n\nThe other two cases the defense cites, neither of\n\n22\n\nwhich is binding on the Court, don't suggest anything different\n\n23\n\nthan the law I just referred to.\n\n24\n\nCircuit held that Brady evidence in the government's possession\n\n25\n\nwas material because it suggested that another likely suspect\n\nIn Bowen v. Maynard, the 10th\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834908\n\n", "char_count": 1722}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 20 of 127\n\n20\n\nLB1TMAX1\ndid not have an alibi and suggested that a photo lineup was\nunduly suggestive.\n\n799 F.2d 593, (10th Cir. 1986).\n\nThe court\n\nstated that, if disclosed, \"the defense could have\n4\n\ncross-examined the detectives about their decision to use the\n\n5\n\nphotographs\" that they did as well about their failure to\n\n6\n\ncorroborate the other suspect's alibi.\n\n7\n\nAnd the defense cites another Brady violation in\n\n8\n\nLindsey v.\n\n9\n\nreport was material under Brady because it showed key witnesses\n\n10\n\nto a murder had changed their story, which on cross-examination\n\n11\n\nwould have meant the destruction of the witness's\n\n12\n\nidentification and the discrediting in some degree of the\n\n13\n\npolice methods employed in assembling the case against the\n\n14\n\ndefendant.\n\n15\n\nwhere the Fifth Circuit found that a police\n\nLindsey v.\n\n, 769 F.2d 1034, (5th Cir. 1985)\n\nThese two examples of focused cross-examination to\n\n16\n\nimpeach a witness that testified to the defendant's guilt and\n\n17\n\nthereby throw the product of the government's investigation\n\n18\n\ninto doubt are far afield from the specifics of what the\n\n19\n\ndefense proposed here.\n\n20\n\naffirmatively -- and I will quote from their brief -- \"call FBI\n\n21\n\ncase agents as witnesses\" to ask who they talked to, what\n\n22\n\ndocuments they subpoenaed, and when.\n\n23\n\nat 40.\n\n24\n\ngovernment's use or non-use of certain investigative techniques\n\n25\n\ndoes not tend to show the defendant's innocence of the charges.\n\nIn its brief, the defense seeks to\n\nSee, defense's response\n\nBut as the Second Circuit explained in Saldarriaga, the\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834909\n\n", "char_count": 1707}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 21of 127\n\n21\n\nLB1TMAX1\nThe defense also seeks to elicit evidence of the\npublic outcry and scrutiny that preceded the decision to charge\nthe defendant.\n\nThe defense refers to public statements made by\n\n4\n\nassistant United States attorneys -- not those appearing in the\n\n5\n\ncase -- to suggest that Ms. Maxwell was charged for improper\n\n6\n\nreasons.\n\n7\n\nThe Court finds that this specific proffered evidence\n\n8\n\nis irrelevant to the charged conduct and, therefore,\n\n9\n\ninadmissible.\n\n10\n\nTo the extent that the defense's affirmative evidence\n\n11\n\nin this regard would have some marginal probative value, it is\n\n12\n\nsubstantially outweighed by 403 prejudice.\n\n13\n\nUnited States v.\n\n14\n\n2014), affirmed by the Second Circuit, 658 Fed. Appx. 600.\n\n15\n\nHere's the reason for that 403 analysis:\n\n16\n\nFirst, investigative details are likely to confuse the\n\nSee, for example,\n\n12 CR 214, 2014 WL 198813 (E.D.N.Y.\n\n17\n\njury about the proper standard for determining Ms. Maxwell's\n\n18\n\nguilt by suggesting that the government's choices of\n\n19\n\ninvestigative techniques are relevant to whether guilt is\n\n20\n\nproved beyond a reasonable doubt.\n\n21\n\njurors, as is standard, to the effect that the government is\n\n22\n\nnot on trial.\n\n23\n\ncases.\n\n24\n\nthe jury once it's received that instruction.\n\n25\n\nMoreover, I will instruct\n\nAnd that standard charge can be found in many\n\nAdmitting testimony on the investigation would confuse\n\nSecond, these lines of argument are likely to\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834910\n\n", "char_count": 1581}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 22 of 127\n\n22\n\nLB1TMAX1\nsubstantially confuse and delay the trial.\n\nThe evidence\n\noutlined in the defense's papers, including who was interviewed\nand when, what documents were subpoenaed and other details of\n4\n\ninvestigations in two different states and different time\n\n5\n\nperiods would substantially expand the scope of the trial.\n\n6\n\nExactly what steps investigators took is not a simple question,\n\n7\n\nof course.\n\n8\n\naccount of events, leading to trials within trials on what law\n\n9\n\nenforcement did over the course of years.\n\n10\n\nsubstantially outweigh any minimum probative value that might\n\n11\n\nbe gained from such a far-flung endeavor.\n\nThe government would likely present a contrary\n\nThis prejudice would\n\n12\n\nThird, as to prejudice, the evidence would be\n\n13\n\ncumulative, demonstrating that an investigation was \"hasty\" and\n\n14\n\nnot thorough is at best repetitive of the defense's arguments\n\n15\n\nthat the government collected insufficient evidence of guilt.\n\n16\n\nThat point is made most clearly and directly by focusing on the\n\n17\n\nevidence or lack of evidence and credibility or lack of\n\n18\n\ncredibility of the witnesses presented at trial.\n\n19\n\nThe second piece of guidance I can provide now is that\n\n20\n\nthe Court will exclude much of the evidence outlined in the\n\n21\n\ndefense's papers of the government's alleged motives for\n\n22\n\ninvestigating and charging Ms. Maxwell.\n\n23\n\nbut is not limited to the Miami Herald article, statements from\n\n24\n\nAttorney General William Barr and the like.\n\n25\n\nThis evidence includes\n\nThe evidence presented by the government in this trial\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834911\n\n", "char_count": 1708}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 23 of 127\n\n23\n\nLB1TMAX1\nis the relevant basis for the jury's determination of guilt or\ninnocence.\n\nWhy and when the government conducted the\n\ninvestigation is not relevant.\n\nIf the defense believes the\n\n4\n\ngovernment has a legally improper motive for prosecuting\n\n5\n\nMs. Maxwell or somehow fabricating evidence or suborning\n\n6\n\nperjury or the like, the Second Circuit has made clear that the\n\n7\n\nproper remedy is to file a motion for the Court to consider.\n\n8\n\nSee, Regan, 103 F.3d 1082.\n\n9\n\nfor purposes of the jury, \"the government is not on trial.\"\n\n10\n\nUnited States v. Knox, 687 F.App'x 51, (2d Cir. 2017).\n\n11\n\nAbsent that, the law is clear that\n\nMoreover, evidence of motive would be highly\n\n12\n\nprejudicial.\n\n13\n\nwould confuse jurors as to the proper standard of guilt to be\n\n14\n\napplied in the case.\n\n15\n\nof improper motives is strongly suggestive of jury\n\n16\n\nnullification because it suggests a vindictive or political\n\n17\n\nprosecution which is rightly a matter reserved to the Court.\n\nFor the reasons I explained a moment ago, it\n\nIndeed, the defense's outlined evidence\n\n18\n\nCalling witnesses to testify to the government's\n\n19\n\nmotive would substantially expand the scope of trial, rely\n\n20\n\nlikely on hearsay and other inadmissible evidence.\n\n21\n\nmotivated a particular investigative step or charging decision\n\n22\n\nof course doesn't have a black or\n\n23\n\nwould have one story and the government another, neither of\n\n24\n\nwhich would assist of the jury in deciding Ms. Maxwell's guilt\n\n25\n\nor innocence of the charges here based on of the government's\n\nSo what\n\nanswer, and the defense\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834912\n\n", "char_count": 1722}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 24 of 127\n\n24\n\nLB1TMAX1\nability to prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt.\nThird piece of guidance:\n\nThe Court will exclude from\n\nevidence the non-prosecution agreement, both its existence and\n4\n\nits particular terms.\n\n5\n\nto the bias and financial interest of two witnesses.\n\n6\n\nanticipated witness received immunity from criminal prosecution\n\n7\n\nunder the NPA.\n\n8\n\npay for a lawyer for an alleged victim who was anticipated to\n\n9\n\ntestify and agreed not to contest her civil suit against him.\n\n10\n\nThe civil suit ended in a settlement with respect to an alleged\n\n11\n\nvictim.\n\n12\n\nThe defense argues the NPA is relevant\nOne\n\nAdditionally, under the NPA, Epstein agreed to\n\nOf course, defendants are always able to cross-examine\n\n13\n\nwitnesses about relevant bias.\n\nFor example, cross-examination\n\n14\n\nabout civil litigation or civil claims against Epstein or\n\n15\n\nothers and related financial incentive are fair grounds.\n\n16\n\nMoreover, cooperating witnesses are commonly cross-examined\n\n17\n\nabout how testimony may affect the sentence that they receive.\n\n18\n\nAnd if it were the case that any witness were to receive\n\n19\n\ntestimonial immunity in this case, the defense may\n\n20\n\ncross-examine about that.\n\n21\n\nany bias or incentive to fabricate that results from or relates\n\n22\n\nto the NPA.\n\n23\n\nmight testify, that witness will remain protected under the NPA\n\n24\n\nin the Southern District of Florida, and as I already ruled,\n\n25\n\nthe NPA does not provide protection in the Southern District of\n\nBut the defense has not explained\n\nRegardless of how the witness covered by the NPA\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834913\n\n", "char_count": 1704}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 25 of 127\n\n25\n\nLB1TMAX1\nNew York.\nSimilarly, no matter how a witness who has a\nsettlement or financial incentive testifies, those benefits are\n4\n\nnot received under the NPA, so I don't see any theory of bias\n\n5\n\nthat would be relevant that the defense has articulated with\n\n6\n\nrespect to the NPA.\n\n7\n\nMoreover, even if there were some relevance, it would\n\n8\n\nbe substantially outweighed by a significant risk of 403\n\n9\n\nprejudice from introducing the NPA.\n\n10\n\ninstructed on what the non-prosecution agreement is, and would\n\n11\n\nneed to have its terms explained.\n\n12\n\ncourse, is controversial and complicated and has a complicated\n\n13\n\nbackground.\n\n14\n\nand improper suggestions of sympathy or nullification made to\n\n15\n\nthe jury on the basis of the NPA.\n\n16\n\nThe jury would need to be\n\nIn particular, NPA, of\n\nThere's a risk of undue delay, juror confusion,\n\nI will be clear, it's not clear to me the NPA could\n\n17\n\nnever be admitted, but the rationale now provided by the\n\n18\n\ndefense in its papers does not justify admission based on the\n\n19\n\nbalancing of 401 and 403 factors.\n\n20\n\nFourth guidance:\n\nThe government's charging decisions\n\n21\n\nare likely not relevant and therefore inadmissible.\n\n22\n\ngovernment didn't indict Ms. Maxwell by the end of the Florida\n\n23\n\ninvestigation, and the government didn't indict Ms. Maxwell\n\n24\n\nwhen it indicted Jeffrey Epstein originally in New York.\n\n25\n\nthe Second Circuit stated in\n\nThe\n\nAs\n\n, charging decisions can be\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834914\n\n", "char_count": 1586}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 26 of 127\n\n26\n\nLB1TMAX1\nadmissible under the usual rules of relevance.\n\nIn\n\nthe\n\ncourt determined that a prior charging decision was admissible\nbecause it bore directly on the credibility of a witness that\n4\n\ntestified at the defendant's trial.\n\n5\n\nAs currently proffered by the defense, the rationale\n\n6\n\ndoesn't apply here.\n\n7\n\nalleged victim's statement to the FBI previously did not\n\n8\n\nimplicate or exculpate Ms. Maxwell, but her statement today\n\n9\n\ndoes implicate her.\n\n10\n\nassumedly other evidence available to them and a host of\n\n11\n\nreasons, officials in the Southern District of Florida decided\n\n12\n\nto not indict Ms. Maxwell at that time.\n\n13\n\ncould be understood as a determination that in 2008 the\n\n14\n\ngovernment lacked sufficient evidence of Ms. Maxwell's guilt,\n\n15\n\nbut the decision not to charge -- or it could mean any number\n\n16\n\nof a host of reasons, but the decision not to charge has little\n\n17\n\nprobative value that the Court can see as to this case.\n\n18\n\nFor example, according to the defense, an\n\nOn the basis of that statement, and\n\nThat charging decision\n\nCharging decisions, as I said, are made for a host of\n\n19\n\nreasons.\n\n20\n\nprejudicial pursuant to 403 both because they would require\n\n21\n\nsignificant time to explore and because juror confusion would\n\n22\n\nbe likely.\n\n23\n\nwould also likely rely on hearsay or other inadmissible\n\n24\n\nevidence.\n\n25\n\nassessments of the evidence in Florida in 2008 is not relevant\n\nTrying to sort through those reasons would be\n\nAny consideration of the government's decisions\n\nMore importantly, unlike in\n\n, those officials'\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834915\n\n", "char_count": 1713}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 27 of 127\n\n27\n\nLB1TMAX1\nto the jury's decision now, which is whether there is evidence\nof Ms. Maxwell's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt as the\ngovernment will put its case to the jury.\n4\n\nNow there is a difference between admitting a witness'\n\n5\n\nprior statements for impeachment purposes, which is protected\n\n6\n\nby the confrontation clause, and admitting prior charging\n\n7\n\ndecisions.\n\n8\n\nUnited States v. Borrero, another district court judge held\n\n9\n\nthat a defendant could permissibly cross-examine a witness\n\n10\n\nabout their prior statement to law enforcement in which they\n\n11\n\naccused a different individual of the crime for which the\n\n12\n\ndefendant was later charged.\n\n2013 WL 6020773 (S.D.N.Y. 2013).\n\n13\n\nThat case docket is 13 CR 58.\n\nBut the court there did not\n\n14\n\nadmit the charging decision that the early investigation had\n\n15\n\nended in a nolle, because it would confuse jurors, require\n\n16\n\nextended factual disputes, and was, at best, cumulative of the\n\n17\n\nwitness's statement.\n\n18\n\nappear to be true here.\n\n19\n\nIn a case analogous to this one on this issue,\n\nAs I have explained, the same would\n\nFifth piece of guidance:\n\nIn contrast to what I\n\n20\n\nindicated may not come in, the Court will permit relevant\n\n21\n\ncross-examination of the government's witnesses.\n\n22\n\nto impeach the credibility of some witnesses by admitting those\n\n23\n\nwitnesses' prior statements to the government that purportedly\n\n24\n\ndid not implicate Ms. Maxwell.\n\n25\n\nto impeach a witness that has allegedly changed her story to\n\nDefense seeks\n\nThis use of cross-examination\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834916\n\n", "char_count": 1691}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 28 of 127\n\n28\n\nLB1TMAX1\nlaw enforcement is exactly the kind of attack on the\nthoroughness of the government's investigation that the Fifth\nCircuit approved in Lindsey v.\n\n.\n\nProvided that the rules\n\n4\n\nfor admitting prior inconsistent statements are satisfied, the\n\n5\n\nCourt concludes that this line of evidence is relevant and\n\n6\n\nadmissible.\n\n7\n\nThe defense may also cross-examine about witnesses'\n\n8\n\nmotives or biases for testifying, including, for example, the\n\n9\n\nwitnesses' motives for implicating Ms. Maxwell after Jeffrey\n\n10\n\nEpstein's death.\n\n11\n\ncross-examination may require providing the jury some\n\n12\n\nbackground information about the prior investigations so that\n\n13\n\nthe prior statements are understood in the proper context and\n\n14\n\nthe jury is provided necessary background to understand that\n\n15\n\nevidence.\n\n16\n\nAdmitting prior statements on\n\n(Continued on next page)\n\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834917\n\n", "char_count": 1040}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 29 of 127\n\n29\n\nLB15MAX2\nTHE COURT:\n\n(Continuing)\n\nI imagine this can be done through cross-examination\nquestions if the witness has personal knowledge.\n\nI would also\n\n4\n\nencourage the parties to discuss stipulations in this regard to\n\n5\n\nprovide the jury any necessary and non-prejudicial context or\n\n6\n\nbackground, or other proposals for permitting the jury to\n\n7\n\nunderstand the background or context without crossing over into\n\n8\n\nthe 403 prejudice line.\n\n9\n\nI also would permit the defense to cross-examine law\n\n10\n\nenforcement officers about the investigative steps that were\n\n11\n\ntaken if the government puts the thoroughness of the\n\n12\n\ninvestigation into issue as this, too, would be permissible\n\n13\n\nimpeachment and cross.\n\n14\n\nThese articulated lines of cross-examination of\n\n15\n\ngovernment witnesses would be relevant to impeach a witness by\n\n16\n\nsuggesting bias or otherwise implicating their credibility.\n\n17\n\nMoreover, denying Ms. Maxwell these lines of questioning would\n\n18\n\nhave implications under the confrontation clause.\n\n19\n\nexpects that the probative value would not be substantially\n\n20\n\noutweighed by 403 prejudice if done along the lines of what I\n\n21\n\nhave indicated, especially if accompanied by a limiting\n\n22\n\ninstruction by the Court that, for example, prior inconsistent\n\n23\n\nstatements are to be considered for their impeachment value and\n\n24\n\nthe like.\n\n25\n\nThe Court\n\nSimilarly, the Court may instruct the jury that\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834918\n\n", "char_count": 1574}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 30 of 127\n\n30\n\nLB15MAX2\ncounsel made only a good faith -- actually, I will retract that\nlast sentence.\nAt base, the Court encourages the parties to confer on\n4\n\nappropriate process for putting background information in front\n\n5\n\nof the jury, as necessary, to allow the kinds of\n\n6\n\ncross-examination that would be permissible and required under\n\n7\n\nthe relevant law.\n\n8\n\nLet me pause and ask counsel if they have any\n\n9\n\nquestions with respect to the guidance I have offered at this\n\n10\n\ntime.\n\n11\n\nwe go.\n\nObviously there may be issues we will need to take up as\n\n12\n\nMs. Moe?\n\n13\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n14\n\nNot from the government, your Honor.\n\nThank\n\nyou.\n\n15\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n16\n\nNot at this time, your Honor.\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n\nNo. 6, evidence that goes to consent issues.\n\n19\n\nThe government requests to exclude evidence or\n\nYour Honor, Christian Everdell.\n\nThank you.\n\n20\n\nargument regarding consent.\n\n21\n\nto me the issues implicated in this motion overlap, at least\n\n22\n\npotentially, to the issues raised and to be discussed in the\n\n23\n\n412 motion and I am wondering if we should at least begin by\n\n24\n\ntaking it up at that time, as necessary.\n\n25\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nNow let me ask counsel, it seems\n\nYour Honor, the government agrees that makes\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834919\n\n", "char_count": 1359}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 31 of 127\n\n31\n\nLB15MAX2\nsense to address this issue at the same time.\nMS. STERNHEIM:\nTHE COURT:\n\nWe agree.\n\nSo we will defer on that.\n\nIn light of the\n\n4\n\noverlap on the 412 issues we will take that up at the 412\n\n5\n\nhearing.\n\n6\n\nGovernment's 7.\n\nThe government argues that before\n\n7\n\noffering evidence or argument of Ms. Maxwell's failure to\n\n8\n\ncommit other bad acts it should require the defense to proffer\n\n9\n\nthe basis and the relevance of such evidence.\n\n10\n\nthe government what the specific concern is here and then I\n\n11\n\nwill speak to the defense.\n\n12\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n13\n\nThe concern here is what the defense has flagged in\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nLet me hear from\n\nThank you.\n\n14\n\nits opening papers relating to statements by other victims who\n\n15\n\nwere interviewed during the course of the government's\n\n16\n\ninvestigation.\n\n17\n\nopening statement, or if asked about in cross-examination of a\n\n18\n\nlaw enforcement officer, would be inappropriate and hearsay.\n\n19\n\nSuch evidence could only come in at trial, if at all, if the\n\n20\n\ndefense called, as defense witnesses, victims who were not at\n\n21\n\nissue in this case.\n\n22\n\ndefense should be precluded from opening on this issue unless\n\n23\n\nand until they proffer which victims these statements would\n\n24\n\ncome through, who they would anticipate calling as defense\n\n25\n\nwitnesses at trial so the Court can assess whether that is\n\nEvidence along those lines, if proffered in an\n\nAnd so, for that reason, your Honor, the\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834920\n\n", "char_count": 1590}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 32 of 127\n\n32\n\nLB15MAX2\nrelevant at all.\nAs the government set forth in its moving papers, the\ndefendant is not charged with trafficking certain victims and\n4\n\nso whether or not the defendant is guilty of those crimes is\n\n5\n\nirrelevant before this jury.\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n7\n\nrespect to this line of --\n\n8\n9\n\nMs. Sternheim, any mention on opening with\n\nWe will ask everyone please make sure your masks are\non -- counsel, fully on -- unless you are at the podium.\n\n10\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nJudge, I just want to say that we are\n\n11\n\nhonoring your one counsel rule but we have designated various\n\n12\n\ntopics.\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAppreciate it.\n\n14\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n16\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nSo if you will allow us?\n\nGo ahead.\nYour Honor, I don't believe that we\n\n17\n\nwill be opening on these issues but I think the government is\n\n18\n\nunderstating what is charged in the indictment.\n\n19\n\nforth an indictment that does not just allege the four main\n\n20\n\naccusers, rather they have set forth a conspiracy that they\n\n21\n\nclaim involves a number of other unnamed individuals, and I\n\n22\n\nbelieve they have proffered an intent to put other evidence\n\n23\n\nabout unnamed individuals in their exhibits, in their trial\n\n24\n\ntestimony.\n\n25\n\nthey've set forth that come from a time period outside of the\n\nThey have put\n\nFor example, there are a number of exhibits that\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834921\n\n", "char_count": 1477}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 33 of 127\n\n33\n\nLB15MAX2\nconspiracy and so forth.\n\nSo it is our position that if they\n\nopen the door to evidence about anyone other than these four\nthen we would, likewise, be able to talk about the fact that\n4\n\nthose other individuals were interviewed by the government and\n\n5\n\nsaid that Ms. Maxwell is not involved, was not there, and was\n\n6\n\nnot a part of the activities that they're talking about.\n\n7\n\nof the cases that the government cited had to do with a\n\n8\n\nco-conspirator.\n\n9\n\nnot act in conformity with the charged conduct on a separate\n\n10\n\noccasion, couldn't be set forth by the defense.\n\nNone\n\nThe evidence was just because a defendant did\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nDo you agree with that principle?\n\n12\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nIf it is good\n\n13\n\ncharacter evidence, generally I understand the rules of\n\n14\n\nevidence wouldn't apply, but what we have here is a 10-year\n\n15\n\ncharged conspiracy with an intent by the government to allude\n\n16\n\nto other individuals.\n\n17\n\nevidence in the form of message pads or other types of evidence\n\n18\n\nthat refer to other people, then I think we have the ability to\n\n19\n\nconfront that evidence with the fact that Ms. Maxwell was\n\n20\n\nreported by those individuals not to have been involved.\n\nTo the extent they try to put on\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n22\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n23\n\nThe government agrees that this issue can be deferred\n\nMs. Moe?\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\n24\n\nuntil trial unless and until this becomes an issue, provided\n\n25\n\nthe defense counsel doesn't intend to open on this issue.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834922\n\n", "char_count": 1649}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 34 of 127\n\n34\n\nLB15MAX2\nHowever, even if this became an issue at the trial, the remedy\nwould be to permit the defense to call these relevant witnesses\nto talk about whether the defendant was or was not involved in\n4\n\ntheir sex trafficking.\n\nThe remedy would not be to permit\n\n5\n\ndefense from cross-examining law enforcement agents about\n\n6\n\nhearsay statements that other individuals provided to them.\n\n7\n\nwould be extremely confusing for the jury to be hearing,\n\n8\n\nthrough law enforcement agents, the statements of these\n\n9\n\nindividuals to assess whether or not those individuals\n\n10\n\nimplicated the defendant or simply said nothing about the\n\n11\n\ndefendant.\n\n12\n\nthat this could come in at trial would be if the defense called\n\n13\n\nthose witnesses themselves and, of course, it is difficult to\n\n14\n\ndetermine the potential relevance, if any, of testimony along\n\n15\n\nthose lines, and so the government respectfully submits that\n\n16\n\nnone of this should be offered at trial unless and until there\n\n17\n\nis an offer of proof along those lines.\n\nAnd so, the government submits that the only way\n\n18\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n19\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nMs. Menninger?\nYour Honor, whether someone said no\n\n20\n\none else involved or didn't implicate our client is not\n\n21\n\nhearsay, it is the absence of a statement.\n\n22\n\nunderstand the government's position that if an investigator\n\n23\n\nIt\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo I don't\n\nIt is not the absence of the statement,\n\n24\n\nright?\n\nIf you are trying to put in an out-of-court statement\n\n25\n\nfrom someone who said that Ms. Maxwell wasn't involved, it is\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834923\n\n", "char_count": 1686}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 35 of 127\n\n35\n\nLB15MAX2\nan out-of-court statement you are putting on for the truth, it\nis hearsay.\nMS. MENNINGER:\n4\n\nSlightly different, your Honor.\n\nIf a witness says they interviewed -- if a law\n\n5\n\nenforcement says they interviewed another accuser and that\n\n6\n\naccuser never said that Ms. Maxwell was involved, that's not a\n\n7\n\nhearsay statement.\n\n8\n\nabsence of a statement.\n\n9\n\nof the thoroughness of the investigation, if there is evidence\n\n10\n\nthat the government puts on about these other accusers I think\n\n11\n\nthat's what opens the door.\n\n12\n\nwould be them submitting evidence that other people were\n\n13\n\nvictims without putting those people on, putting on message\n\n14\n\npads that had their names on it, and then precluding us from\n\n15\n\nintroducing evidence that none of those individuals implicated\n\n16\n\nMs. Maxwell.\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThey just didn't mention her, it is the\nAnd as your Honor just ruled in terms\n\nRight.\n\nIt is not us opening the door, it\n\nSo, if the government does that\n\n18\n\nyou are not precluded from putting other evidence on.\n\n19\n\nquestion is what evidence would it be and would it be\n\n20\n\nadmissible under the relevant rules of evidence.\n\n21\n\nI can resolve that in the abstract.\n\n22\n\nside intends to open with respect to this issue and I think we\n\n23\n\nlargely agree on the legal principles.\n\n24\n\nmore guidance for purposes of opening or preparing your case.\n\n25\n\nThe\n\nI am not sure\n\nIt sounds like neither\n\nTell me if you need\n\nMs. Menninger?\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834924\n\n", "char_count": 1597}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 36 of 127\n\n36\n\nLB15MAX2\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\nI think it depends on\n\nthe trial testimony.\nTHE COURT:\n4\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nMs. Moe?\nNo, your Honor.\n\nThank you.\n\nIt sounds like the government does need to\n\n6\n\nthink about its opening and whether reference to non-testifying\n\n7\n\nalleged victims would open the door, potentially, to the issue.\n\n8\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nAnd it remains the\n\n9\n\ngovernment's position that, to the extent the defense is\n\n10\n\noffering anything along these lines, it would be for the truth\n\n11\n\nand, therefore, hearsay.\n\n12\n\ndon't intend to open on this issue, we don't believe our\n\n13\n\nopening statements would open the door to this issue either, we\n\n14\n\nare happy to raise this issue at the appropriate time.\n\nBut given the fact that the parties\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOK.\n\n16\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n\nNext is government 8 which are prior statements of\n\nThank you, your Honor.\nOK.\n\nThank you.\n\n19\n\nMs. Maxwell.\n\nI think I come away from the papers agreeing with\n\n20\n\nthe defense that this one may be premature but, Ms. Moe, what\n\n21\n\nis the specific concern?\n\n22\n\nare worried about here?\n\nWhat are prior statements that you\n\n23\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n24\n\nFor example, the government has produced to the\n\n25\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\ndefense in discovery a large volume of electronically-stored\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834925\n\n", "char_count": 1448}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 37 of 127\n\n37\n\nLB15MAX2\ninformation including e-mails between the defendant and Jeffrey\nEpstein.\n\nIt is difficult for the government to determine in\n\nthe abstract what the defense might point to, but that night\n4\n\ninclude, for example, a false exculpatory statement.\n\n5\n\nthe government's view is unless and until there is a proffer\n\n6\n\nfrom the defense about a specific statement, that the defense\n\n7\n\nshould be precluded from offering a statement along those lines\n\n8\n\nin opening statements or otherwise.\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n10\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\n11\n\nAnd so\n\nWho is taking this one?\nYour Honor, good morning.\n\nJeffrey\n\nPagliuca for Ms. Maxwell.\n\n12\n\nYour Honor, this is a trial time decision.\n\n13\n\non what witness is testifying and whether or not there is a\n\n14\n\nrelevant exception to the hearsay rule.\n\n15\n\nthe rules, we will follow the rules, and if the witness\n\n16\n\ntestifies and it becomes relevant, we will ask the question.\n\n17\n\nIf there is an objection, the Court will resolve the objection.\n\n18\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nIt depends\n\nI mean, we understand\n\nAnd you understand you are going to be\n\n19\n\nrestrained by what one might say is an asymmetry between the\n\n20\n\ngovernment's ability to use out-of-court statements by the\n\n21\n\ndefendant and the defense's inability to do that, absent some\n\n22\n\nother --\n\n23\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n25\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nAbsolutely, your Honor.\n\nOK.\nWe understand the hearsay rules.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834926\n\n", "char_count": 1536}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 38 of 127\n\n38\n\nLB15MAX2\nTHE COURT:\n\nFrom your perspective, anything further\n\nthat could be addressed at this time or needs to be addressed?\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n5\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n7\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOn this topic your Honor?\n\nYes.\nNo.\n\nMs. Moe?\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\nThank you.\n\nThe next is government 9 which is to\n\n9\n\npreclude evidence or argument sounding in nullification.\n\n10\n\nagree with the defense that there is no need for me to rule on\n\n11\n\nthis presently.\n\n12\n\nclear rules around any such arguments so it is a bit hard to\n\n13\n\nthink about what guidance I can offer here.\n\n14\n15\n\nI\n\nI trust that defense counsel knows well the\n\nMs. Moe, is there a specific concern you want to\nraise?\n\n16\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\n17\n\nAside from the examples we proffered in our motion,\n\n18\n\nthere is nothing in particular that this motion is aimed at and\n\n19\n\nso I don't think anything more along those lines to address\n\n20\n\ntoday.\n\n21\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nNothing at this time.\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo nothing referenced with respect to\n\nOK.\n\n23\n\nthe government's concerns about nullification would be\n\n24\n\nimplicated in the anticipated opening?\n\n25\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nThat is correct.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834927\n\n", "char_count": 1330}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 39 of 127\n\n39\n\nLB15MAX2\nTHE COURT:\n\nGovernment 10.\n\nLet me say, as a\n\npreliminary matter, the government requests that the entirety\nof this motion be sealed.\n\nI have read the government's letter\n\n4\n\nand the footnote 11 in the motion.\n\n5\n\njustify sealing.\n\n6\n\ngovernment is saying that the defense should be precluded from\n\n7\n\nmake a certain argument because there is no evidence in support\n\n8\n\nof it.\n\n9\n\npublicity would amount to coverage that there is no evidence of\n\n10\n\nthat argument.\n\n11\n\nevidence in argument comes in so there is no prejudice either\n\n12\n\nway.\n\n13\n\ncounter to the whole project of pretrial motion in limine\n\n14\n\npractice which is to litigate, for purposes of trial\n\n15\n\npreparation and trial efficiency and opening statements and the\n\n16\n\nlike, what's in and what's out.\n\n17\n\nrequire litigation on what's out.\n\n18\n\nseal this and I think we can discuss it today.\n\n19\n\nIn my mind they don't\n\nAs best I can understand the argument the\n\nIf the government is right about that then pretrial\n\nIf the government is wrong about that then the\n\nFrankly, I think the theory of prejudice here runs\n\nThat's going to sometimes\nSo I don't see a basis to\n\nBut let me begin by simply asking the defense if it\n\n20\n\nintends to make the argument that is outlined in the\n\n21\n\ngovernment's motion 10.\n\n22\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nYour Honor, it is too soon to say what\n\n23\n\nwe are going to do at trial.\n\nCertainly we have no burden of\n\n24\n\nputting on a case and I know the government is well aware of\n\n25\n\nthat, but insofar as the government seeks to preclude us from\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834928\n\n", "char_count": 1683}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 40 of 127\n\n40\n\nLB15MAX2\nraising any issues concerning Ms. Maxwell, I think it is\nentirely premature and it will depend upon testimony from their\nwitnesses and they know well what their witnesses have said\n4\n\nthat could support that.\n\n5\n\nthat at this point.\n\n6\n\nWe need to see how the evidence plays out.\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n8\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nI don't think we need to delve into\n\nIt is not anything that we are opening on.\n\nOK.\nYour Honor, if the defense is not opening on\n\n9\n\nthis issue we are certainly happy to raise it during the trial.\n\n10\n\nWe would ask that the defense be required to front this issue\n\n11\n\nbefore asking witnesses questions about this on\n\n12\n\ncross-examination because for the reasons set forth in the\n\n13\n\ngovernment's moving papers, the government submits that\n\n14\n\nevidence along these lines would not be relevant.\n\n15\n\nBriefly, your Honor, with respect to the sealing\n\n16\n\nissue, the government understands the Court's concerns and\n\n17\n\nwould certainly not object to unseeing this portion of the\n\n18\n\nmotion at the conclusion of the trial but I --\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI don't see why -- I just don't see how\n\n20\n\nobviously some sealing on issues is appropriate in order to\n\n21\n\nprotect interests that are in play during the course of the\n\n22\n\ntrial.\n\n23\n\nis, no -- and I have not had the ability to go through the\n\n24\n\ncomplicated set of sometimes overlapping, sometimes not\n\n25\n\noverlapping redaction requests contained throughout these\n\nThis just doesn't fall within that.\n\nSo my inclination\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834929\n\n", "char_count": 1632}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 41of 127\n\n41\n\nLB15MAX2\npapers which is why I ordered you just get them up on the\ndocket rather than deprive the public of seeing the bulk of\nwhat is contained in the motions, but I looked at this one and\n4\n\nI don't see a basis for sealing it in its entirety and I don't\n\n5\n\nsee a basis for redaction so I'm not going to grant that\n\n6\n\nrequest.\n\n7\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nUnderstood, your Honor.\nI think there is nothing further on 10.\n\n9\n\nNo issue for opening.\n\n10\n\nhave had a chance to rule on the remainder of the sealing\n\n11\n\nrequests, for putting on the docket any redactions that I don't\n\n12\n\napprove of and we will take this up if it arises.\n\n13\n\neverybody understands, obviously, that I trust, again, the\n\n14\n\ndefense will have a basis for an argument that they're making\n\n15\n\nand to the extent this issue arises, raise it, so that we can\n\n16\n\ndeal with it.\n\nWe will figure out a process, once I\n\n17\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\n18\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n19\n\nGovernment 11.\n\nI think\n\nWe will\n\nThank you.\nThe final issue in the government's\n\n20\n\nmotion is request to preclude the defense from arguing that the\n\n21\n\ndefendant was a \"prevailing party in civil litigation.\"\n\n22\n\ngrant this motion.\n\n23\n\nprevailing party after a settlement in civil litigation seems\n\n24\n\nirrelevant and highly prejudicial.\n\n25\n\nunderstand it, was deemed a prevailing party following a\n\nI will\n\nThe fact that the defendant was deemed a\n\nThe defendant, as I\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834930\n\n", "char_count": 1545}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "Case 1:2O-cr-OO33O-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 42 of 127\n\n42\n\nLB15MAX2\nvoluntary dismissal of civil litigation pursuant to a\nsettlement agreement, and after the dismissal the defendant\nsought costs as a prevailing party under Federal Rule of Civil\n4\n\nProcedure 54(d)(1), and at least as described in the papers the\n\n5\n\nalleged victims opted to pay the fairly minimal amount sought\n\n6\n\nrather than burden the court and other resources with continued\n\n7\n\nlitigation.\n\n8\n\nThe fact that the defendant received costs pursuant to\n\n9\n\ncivil procedure 54(d) after a civil settlement just has no\n\n10\n\nrelevance to the charges at hand as far as I can tell and there\n\n11\n\nis substantial danger of confusing the issues and misleading\n\n12\n\nthe jury.\n\n13\n\nprevailing party, a layjuror would almost certainly assume that\n\n14\n\nthat was some kind of adjudication on the merits relevant to\n\n15\n\nthis case but there is no evidence that there was any relevance\n\n16\n\nadjudication on the merits and certainly none relevant to the\n\n17\n\ncase.\n\n18\n\nsubstantially outweighed by juror confusion and the waste of\n\n19\n\ntime needed to explain the differing postures of the current\n\n20\n\ncase and the prior civil litigation.\n\n21\n\nbalancing grounds the government's motion in this regard is\n\n22\n\ngranted.\n\nIf the defense elicited that the defendant was the\n\nAny probative value gained by the introduction would be\n\nSo on those 401/403\n\n23\n\nAny questions before I turn to the defense motions?\n\n24\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n25\n\nNot from the government, your Honor.\n\nThank\n\nyou.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834931\n\n", "char_count": 1605}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 43 of 127\n\n43\n\nLB15MAX2\nMS. MENNINGER:\nissue.\n\nYour Honor, very briefly on the last\n\nI assume that there won't be any argument by the\n\ngovernment or their witnesses that they believe that they had\n4\n\nan adjudication on the merits, in other words both the victims'\n\n5\n\ncompensation fund and the civil litigation, there was no right\n\n6\n\nof confrontation, Ms. Maxwell wasn't a party to those\n\n7\n\nsettlement agreements.\n\n8\n\nto suggest to the jury that they somehow had an adjudication,\n\n9\n\nsomeone else found that their claims had merit, I think that\n\n10\n\nwould be confusing to the jury as well and I assume it would\n\n11\n\nalso be deemed by this Court to open the door to an explanation\n\n12\n\nfrom the defense about what really happened in those\n\n13\n\nproceedings.\n\nSo, to the extent the government tries\n\n14\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\n15\n\nThe government does not intend to elicit any testimony\n\n16\n\nfrom the victims about being a prevailing party in any civil\n\n17\n\nlitigation or otherwise.\n\n18\n\nany testimony about civil litigation from the victims it would\n\n19\n\nonly be in order to front that issue for the jury in\n\n20\n\nanticipation of cross-examination along those lines.\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n22\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nTo the extent the government elicits\n\nRight.\n\nThe government certainly wouldn't be\n\n23\n\noffering that evidence to suggest to the jury in any way that\n\n24\n\nthose were adjudications on the merits, nor could we, those\n\n25\n\nwere civil settlements.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834932\n\n", "char_count": 1575}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "Case 1:2O-cr-OO33O-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 44 of 127\n\n44\n\nLB15MAX2\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnything further on that, Ms. Menninger?\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nI didn't hear any reference to the\n\nvictim's compensation fund but there certainly was no\n4\n\nadjudication on the merits by a fund that Ms. Maxwell had no\n\n5\n\nparty to the settlement.\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nCorrect.\n\n7\n\nSame response, Ms. Moe?\n\n8\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nAnd in fact, again, we\n\n9\n\nwould only be eliciting information about that on direct\n\n10\n\nexamination to front that issue for the jury in anticipation of\n\n11\n\ncross-examination along those lines.\n\n12\n\nwishes not to cross-examine the victims about the victims\n\n13\n\ncompensation program, we certainly agree not to address that at\n\n14\n\nall on direct examination.\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nTo the extent the defense\n\nI imagine the defense does anticipate\n\n16\n\nreferring to civil settlements and the victims' compensation\n\n17\n\nfund as part of its cross of anticipated witnesses, correct?\n\n18\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat is correct, your Honor.\n\nSo the government can front those issues\n\n20\n\nto take out the sting.\n\n21\n\nimplication -- it would not be remitted to make any implication\n\n22\n\nas to what those settlements or receiving of funds would mean\n\n23\n\nas to the issues relevant here.\n\n24\n\nas I see it, goes to incentive for bias and credibility issues.\n\n25\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nTo the extent there is any\n\nThe only issue relevant here,\n\nIt just depends on what the witness\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834933\n\n", "char_count": 1553}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "Case 1:2O-cr-OO33O-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 45 of 127\n\n45\n\nLB15MAX2\nsays, your Honor.\n\nI agree that these are issues that it's\n\nimportant for the Court to be aware of before trial but I can't\npredict, and I'm not really sure that the government can\n4\n\npredict, what their witnesses will say or suggest in their\n\n5\n\nactual testimony.\n\n6\n\nit may be that they say something that suggests that there was\n\n7\n\nsomeone who believed them, that there was a victims'\n\n8\n\ncompensation fund that believed them.\n\n9\n\nare used by the witness, then that becomes problematic in terms\n\n10\n\nof our ability to be hamstrung in cross-examination that there\n\n11\n\nwas no actual confrontation during that process.\n\n12\n\nupon what the witnesses say we would re-raise this but I do\n\n13\n\nthink it's important for the Court to sort of have that in mind\n\n14\n\nwhen the government is trying to use evidence to front an issue\n\n15\n\nbut then potentially opening the door to us being open to cross\n\n16\n\non the same type of language that their witnesses used.\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nWhen they open the door through fronting it,\n\nIf those kinds of words\n\nSo, depending\n\nMs. Moe?\nYour Honor, again, the government doesn't\n\n19\n\nanticipate that the testimony would come out that way but, in\n\n20\n\nany event, I think with respect to the specific concern defense\n\n21\n\ncounsel has raised, to the extent it opened the door I don't\n\n22\n\nbelieve it would open the door to separate collateral issues\n\n23\n\nabout a separate civil lawsuit and resolution of that civil\n\n24\n\nlawsuit.\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834934\n\n", "char_count": 1639}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 46 of 127\n\n46\n\nLB15MAX2\nMS. MOE:\n\nBut, beyond that, your Honor, we don't\n\nanticipate this would be an issue.\nTHE COURT:\n4\n\nOK.\n\nI think we are in agreement.\n\nMy clerk noted I inadvertently skipped over Government\n\n5\n\n5 so we will return to that.\n\n6\n\nexpectation that the testimony of certain witnesses would\n\n7\n\ninclude statements by individuals that are not testifying and\n\n8\n\nthe government argues that the defense can't attack the\n\n9\n\ncredibility of those non-testifying individuals because their\n\n10\n\nstatements would not be admitted for their truth but, for\n\n11\n\nexample, their effect on the testifying witness and the like.\n\n12\n\nAgain, I think without more specificity it is\n\nThis is the government's\n\n13\n\ndifficult to make a definitive ruling but I'm happy to hear\n\n14\n\nexamples to give some guidance.\n\n15\n\nMs. Moe?\n\n16\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n17\n\nI think there will be limited testimony from a victim\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\n18\n\nabout her interaction with other victims.\n\nI think the\n\n19\n\nstatements that would come in from those other victims would be\n\n20\n\noffered not for their truth but because they are instructions,\n\n21\n\nthey would be offered for that effect on listener and to\n\n22\n\nexplain the course of events that followed.\n\n23\n\nanticipate offering any statements from non-testifying victims\n\n24\n\nfor their truth and so we don't anticipate opening the door to\n\n25\n\na line of cross-examination about their credibility.\n\nWe don't\n\nAnd so,\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834935\n\n", "char_count": 1565}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "Case 1:2O-cr-OO33O-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 47 of 127\n\n47\n\nLB15MAX2\nfor that reason, we would ask that the defense be precluded\nfrom opening on this issue or otherwise raising issues related\nto the credibility of individuals who would not be testifying\n4\n\nat this trial including not only non-testifying victims but\n\n5\n\nalso attorneys.\n\n6\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nYour Honor, even the statement \"a\n\n7\n\nnon-testifying victim\" is very loaded because who is going to\n\n8\n\ntestify that that person is a victim and on what ground?\n\n9\n\nThat's the problem.\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWell, I wouldn't allow testimony by a\n\n11\n\nwitness about a characterization that goes to a legal issue so\n\n12\n\nof course they could testify about observations involving other\n\n13\n\npeople.\n\n14\n\nstatements of others not offered for the truth but I wouldn't\n\n15\n\nanticipate the government would attempt to do any of that via\n\n16\n\nany characterization of those individuals that go to legal\n\n17\n\nconclusions relevant to the jury's role.\n\n18\n\nDo I have that right, Ms. Moe?\n\n19\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n20\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nI can imagine instances in which they testify about\n\nYes, your Honor.\nIt is interesting, because in their\n\n21\n\noffer of proof they actually say that one witness is going to\n\n22\n\ntalk about another person being a victim of sexual abuse and\n\n23\n\nthat second person isn't going to testify, and the question of\n\n24\n\nwhether that person was a victim of sexual abuse would turn on\n\n25\n\nthe age at which they were conducting certain activities.\n\nAnd\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834936\n\n", "char_count": 1584}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 48 of 127\n\n48\n\nLB15MAX2\nso, just as we were arguing earlier, your Honor, if the\ngovernment is trying to put on evidence about other people\nbeing victims, then that opens the door to us challenging that\n4\n\nother person's credibility.\n\n5\n\nway we briefed it which was it just depends on what is said by\n\n6\n\nthe witness and we will certainly re-raise these issues.\n\n7\n\nthe government can't have their cake and eat it, too.\n\n8\n\nwant to put on evidence about a broad number of supposed\n\n9\n\nvictims then we have the obligation, ethically, to challenge\n\n10\n\nwhether or not those other individuals are in fact victims.\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI don't have any issue with the\n\nBut,\n\nIf they\n\nWell, I think maybe speaking in the\n\n12\n\nabstract is where the fine points get lost.\n\n13\n\nwitness testifies about something that she observed involving\n\n14\n\nthe defendant and another individual, that doesn't open the\n\n15\n\ndoor to attacking the credibility of that other individual.\n\n16\n\nAgree to that basic premise?\n\n17\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\n18\n19\n\nSo if a testifying\n\nCorrect, your Honor; an observation\n\nalone.\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd if the witness testifies that another\n\n20\n\nindividual, using the name or pseudonym -- if that is what is\n\n21\n\nappropriate in light of the Court's ruling, I don't have it\n\n22\n\nfirmly in mind at this point but, just as an example:\n\n23\n\ntold me to go to somebody's home.\n\n24\n\ncredibility of the out-of-court witness in issue, does it?\n\n25\n\nBecause that is not being offered for the truth.\n\nSomeone\n\nThat doesn't put the\n\nNow, if it\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834937\n\n", "char_count": 1652}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "Case 1:2O-cr-OO33O-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 49 of 127\n\n49\n\nLB15MAX2\nsays go to so and so's home at the following address -MS. MENNINGER:\n\nOr what is going to happen there and\n\nwhy do I think it is going to happen there -- those kinds of\n4\n\nthings -- that is really getting into the circumventing the\n\n5\n\nnot-for-the-truth issue.\n\n6\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI don't think those other points could\n\ncome in because they would be for the truth.\n\n8\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n10\n\nattack credibility.\n\nHearsay, right.\n\nSo they don't come in, obviously you can't\n\n11\n\nMs. Moe, do you disagree with any of that?\n\n12\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\nThe government agrees.\n\nAnd\n\n13\n\nif this issue arises, we would certainly agree to a limiting\n\n14\n\ninstruction about those out-of-court statements not being\n\n15\n\noffered for their truth.\n\n16\n\nbe any testimony from an out-of-court declarant who is a victim\n\n17\n\noffered for its truth at this trial, and so we don't anticipate\n\n18\n\noption the door.\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWe don't anticipate that there would\n\nIf the government thinks any of these, of\n\n20\n\nwhat it does intend to offer, is close to the line on that\n\n21\n\nquestion, it must raise them before inquiring or raising it in\n\n22\n\nopening.\n\n23\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n25\n\nAnything further on that?\n\nCertainly, your Honor.\nOK.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834938\n\n", "char_count": 1391}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 50 of 127\n\n50\n\nLB15MAX2\nMS. MENNINGER:\nTHE COURT:\n\nNo.\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\nAll right.\n\nAnything else before turning to the defense motion?\n4\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n5\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nNo, your Honor.\nNo, thank you.\n\nDefense 1 relates to the government's\n\n7\n\ndisclosure of co-conspirator statements.\n\n8\n\nlot of ink about the meaning of prior orders and whether the\n\n9\n\ngovernment has fully met its disclosure obligations as set out\n\n10\n\nby those orders.\n\n11\n\nthe defense motion to preclude the government from introducing\n\n12\n\nany alleged co-conspirator statements is denied.\n\n13\n\nThe parties spill a\n\nThe government did not violate my orders and\n\nI do think the schedule, as set out in this case, has\n\n14\n\nprovided for certainly a vastly earlier disclosure schedule\n\n15\n\nthan any other trial over which I have previously presided and\n\n16\n\nI do think the defense is well equipped to know what is coming\n\n17\n\nand can responsibly raise issues that can be dealt with in\n\n18\n\nadvance of trial.\n\n19\n\nco-conspirators who will be mentioned by the government at\n\n20\n\ntrial and it has the government's marked exhibits, and although\n\n21\n\nit doesn't feel like it, we still have a month to go before\n\n22\n\ntrial.\n\n23\n\nand this is another homework assignment.\n\n24\n25\n\nHere, the defense has the names of the\n\nThat said, here is how we will proceed on this point --\n\nBy this Thursday, November 4, the government will\nprovide to the defense the categories of the kinds of\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834939\n\n", "char_count": 1585}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 51 of 127\n\n51\n\nLB15MAX2\nco-conspirator statements that it intends to introduce at trial\npursuant to 801(d)(2)(E) and specifically representative\nexemplars of each category whether by exhibit number or\n4\n\nanticipated testimony.\n\n5\n\nbefore, I think not infrequently used, in order to try to\n\n6\n\nlitigate anything that could be litigated.\n\n7\n\nwill do that by November 4th.\n\n8\n\nmind the well-established law regarding conditional admission\n\n9\n\nof the co-conspirator statements, the defense should indicate\n\n10\n\nto the government, by November 8, any good faith, non-frivolous\n\n11\n\nobjections to the introduction of any such statements.\n\n12\n\nconferring, if there are disputes remaining that wouldn't\n\n13\n\nobviously fall into the law regarding conditional admission,\n\n14\n\nthe government shall file a letter, by November 10, justifying\n\n15\n\nadmission of exemplars and statements over which the parties\n\n16\n\ndisagree.\n\n17\n\nin an opposition, in writing, by November 12th.\n\nThat is a process that I have used\n\nSo the government\n\nThe defense, bearing fully in\n\nAfter\n\nSo that's the 10th, and then the defense could put\n\n18\n\nAny questions about that, Ms. Moe?\n\n19\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n21\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\nThank you.\n\nMs. Sternheim?\nWe are clear, your Honor.\n\nThank you.\n\nI think it is probably worth maybe just a\n\n23\n\nmoment, because it impacts this issue and some other ones, to\n\n24\n\njust discuss one category of potential statements that's been\n\n25\n\nflagged and that's alleged co-conspirator statements that date\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834940\n\n", "char_count": 1664}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 52 of 127\n\n52\n\nLB15MAX2\nafter what's alleged in the indictment as of the date of the\nconspiracy.\nLet me ask, Ms. Moe, if are you in position to say,\n4\n\ndoes the government intend to seek admission of alleged\n\n5\n\nco-conspirator statements that post-date the dates of the\n\n6\n\nconspiracy alleged in the indictment?\n\n7\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYour Honor, I think I would want a moment to\n\n8\n\nconfer with my colleagues about that and so, if possible, we\n\n9\n\nwould like to address that in our November 10th letter.\n\n10\n\nIn brief, as a preview, I think to the extent there\n\n11\n\nwere any statements that post-dated the time frame of the\n\n12\n\ncharged conspiracy we would be offering them only to the extent\n\n13\n\nthey reference the charged conduct.\n\n14\n\nto confer with my colleagues and think through that in detail\n\n15\n\nbefore making a representation to the Court, and so we ask to\n\n16\n\nbrief that as well at the same time.\n\n17\n18\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nBut, again, I would like\n\nAnyone want to take this now?\n\nOr just\n\nwait?\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nYour Honor, I am happy to wait but it\n\n20\n\nis clear to me that there are post-alleged-conspiracy\n\n21\n\nstatements that the government will attempt to introduce and I\n\n22\n\nthink we attach what were the representative samples of those\n\n23\n\nstatements.\n\n24\n\nwe sit here today, what those statements may or may not be.\n\n25\n\nthink whether or not you want to say that those statements go\n\nAnd so I don't think it should be a surprise, as\nI\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834941\n\n", "char_count": 1569}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 53 of 127\n\n53\n\nLB15MAX2\nto something alleged in the indictment doesn't change the\n801(d)(2)(E) analysis and that is it has to be made in the\ncourse of and in furtherance of a conspiracy.\n\nSo post-event\n\n4\n\nstatements that don't have anything to do with furtherance of\n\n5\n\nthe conspiracy are simply hearsay and inadmissible.\n\n6\n7\n8\n\nI think that's a pretty simple proposition, your\nHonor.\nMS. MOE:\n\nYour Honor, among other reasons why we would\n\n9\n\nlike time to think about this further and address it in more\n\n10\n\ndetail, is that Rule 801(d)(2)(E) is not limited to the charged\n\n11\n\nconspiracy at trial, a statement said in furtherance of the\n\n12\n\nconspiracy even if it is not the charged conspiracy.\n\n13\n\nwould want to think through that as well.\n\n14\n\nwant to think through, even if a statement is offered by a\n\n15\n\nco-conspirator, whether it is being offered under Rule\n\n16\n\n801(d)(2)(E) at all.\n\n17\n\ntime to think through that to make sure we give an accurate and\n\n18\n\nthorough representation to the Court.\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd so we\n\nAnd we would also\n\nAnd so we would just ask for additional\n\nSo, I will stick with the process and\n\n20\n\nschedule that I have indicated but I do think we will separate\n\n21\n\nout statements that post-date the conspiracy as charged in the\n\n22\n\nindictment and the government will indicate grounds for the\n\n23\n\nspecific introduction of any of those anticipated statements.\n\n24\n\nOK, Ms. Moe?\n\n25\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nThank you.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834942\n\n", "char_count": 1589}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 53, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 54 of 127\n\n54\n\nLB15MAX2\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nThat's fine.\n\nThank you.\n\nDefendants 2 is the admission of certain evidence\n4\n\noutlined in the government's 404(b) letter dated October 11,\n\n5\n\n2021.\n\n6\n\ninadequate notice under 404(b), I disagree because the\n\n7\n\ngovernment's letter and briefing between the government's\n\n8\n\nletter and the briefing here, the defendant has \"reasonable\n\n9\n\nnotice\" of any 404(b) evidence so the question is whether the\n\n10\n\nevidence can be properly admitted.\n\n11\n\ncategories of evidence, the first goes to e-mails, and I will\n\n12\n\nspeak in the just general description which I think is\n\n13\n\nappropriate.\n\n14\n\ngeneral description and to the extent that you have, I disagree\n\n15\n\nwith that but I will speak generally -- I'm sorry, the defense\n\n16\n\nrequested redaction as to some general description but I don't\n\n17\n\nthink it's appropriate.\n\n18\n\nthis understanding is correct, that the e-mails reflect\n\n19\n\ninstances of the defendant setting up dates that involve women\n\n20\n\nover the age of consent.\n\n21\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nFirst, as to the defense argument that there has been an\n\nI think there is two\n\nThe government may have attempted to redact some\n\nSo I'm going to ask the government, if\n\nYour Honor, I think as we noted in our\n\n22\n\nbriefing, for some of the documents it is unclear what the age\n\n23\n\nrange is.\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n25\n\nwas under the age of consent?\n\nSo you wouldn't be able to prove that it\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834943\n\n", "char_count": 1571}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 54, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 55 of 127\n\n55\n\nLB15MAX2\nMS. MOE:\n\nExactly, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nFor our purposes I think we need to assume\n\nover the age of consent, correct?\n4\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYour Honor, I think it would be ambiguous\n\n5\n\nfrom the evidence but we are not proffering them as evidence of\n\n6\n\nconduct with respect to other minors.\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n8\n\nfollowing statement:\n\n9\n\ninvolve the defendant setting up people on dates with women\n\n10\n\nover the age of consent?\n\n11\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n12\n\nOK.\n\nSo, let's just start with the\n\nYou are seeking to introduce e-mails that\n\nYour Honor, because we are not able to\n\ndetermine the age of those individuals --\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n14\n\nthem.\n\n15\n\nthat the women involved are over the age of the consent.\n\n16\n\nyou seeking to introduce those e-mails?\n\n17\n18\n\nRight?\n\nLet's assume that you could for some of\n\nAre you seeking to introduce those?\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nIt is clear\nAre\n\nI think the e-mails that the defense has\n\nmoved to preclude don't say one way or the other the age --\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n20\n\nclear, it is a hypothetical.\n\n21\n\nthe defendant setting someone up on a date with someone who the\n\n22\n\ngovernment knows is over the age of consent on the basis of the\n\n23\n\nargument made here, are you seeking to introduce it?\n\n24\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYou are fighting my hypo.\n\nSo, to be\n\nIf you have an e-mail involving\n\nYes, your Honor.\nAnd why?\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834944\n\n", "char_count": 1480}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 55, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 56 of 127\n\n56\n\nLB15MAX2\nMS. MOE:\n\nThe government respectfully submits that\n\nalthough the defense is free to characterize these as dates,\nthe tenor of the e-mail suggests that she is offering up women\n4\n\nlargely based on descriptions based on physical descriptions\n\n5\n\nand not in sort of a matchmaking capacity.\n\n6\n\njury would be free to conclude from those e-mails that the\n\n7\n\ndefendant is serving a particular role with respect to the men\n\n8\n\nthat she is e-mailing with.\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n10\n\nAnd so, I think the\n\nAre you suggesting like some kind of\n\nfinancial arrangement?\n\n11\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n12\n\nI think the issue, as reflected in our briefing, is\n\n13\n\nthat a jury may wonder at this trial about the relationship\n\n14\n\nbetween Ms. Maxwell and Mr. Epstein and why Ms. Maxwell would\n\n15\n\nbe willing to serve in a particular role with respect to\n\n16\n\nMr. Epstein, and it is probative of that issue that she is\n\n17\n\nserving a similar role, albeit in a different context, with\n\n18\n\nother men during that same time frame.\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOn the e-mails, I am excluding them.\n\n20\n\nThe indictment charges the defendant with conspiring\n\n21\n\nand aiding and abetting the transport and enticement of minors\n\n22\n\nto engage in illegal sex acts and the commercial sex act\n\n23\n\ne-mails setting up dates between non-minors or meetings,\n\n24\n\nhowever you want to describe it, involving non-minors are not\n\n25\n\ndirect evidence of the crimes charged, they don't arise out of\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834945\n\n", "char_count": 1593}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 56, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 57 of 127\n\n57\n\nLB15MAX2\nthe same transaction or series of transactions as the charged\noffenses, they're not inextricably intertwined with the\nevidence nor necessary to complete the story of the crime on\n4\n\ntrial.\n\nThe government doesn't allege that the individuals in\n\n5\n\nthese e-mails have anything to do with the crimes charged nor\n\n6\n\ncould they on the assumption that they can't establish that any\n\n7\n\nof the individuals are below the age of consent.\n\n8\n\nAs for 404(b), I am also not convinced.\n\nThe\n\n9\n\ngovernment argues that the e-mails show motive, intent, plan,\n\n10\n\nand knowledge.\n\n11\n\nsubstantially outweighed by the possibility of confusing the\n\n12\n\njury.\n\n13\n\nExhibits 401 through 404, 409, 410, and 413.\n\nAny potential probative value here would be\n\nThus, I grant the defendant's motion as to Government's\n\n14\n\nThe next category is the anticipated testimony that --\n\n15\n\nand this involves someone who has knowledge based -- this goes\n\n16\n\nto the post-date conspiracy charged.\n\n17\n\nunderstand it, has knowledge that post dates the conspiracy\n\n18\n\nalleged; is that right?\n\n19\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nThis is someone who, as I\n\nThat's correct, your Honor; and that\n\n20\n\ntestimony will be proffered principally authenticate certain\n\n21\n\nevidence relevant to the charged conduct.\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n23\n\nWho is taking this?\n\n24\n25\n\nOK.\nWith respect to authenticating\n\nevidence, do you have an objection, Ms. Menninger?\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nYes, your Honor, because it is\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834946\n\n", "char_count": 1582}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 57, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 58 of 127\n\n58\n\nLB15MAX2\npost-dating the alleged conspiracy.\n\nFor example, there are\n\ndocuments -- I don't know, they weren't specified which\ndocuments that this witness intends to authenticate, but among\n4\n\nthe documents that I believe the witness may attempt to\n\n5\n\nauthenticate, they are dated in 2005 and beyond.\n\n6\n\nquestion really is whether you can -- it is an authentication,\n\n7\n\none, whether that relates to the conspiracy or not.\n\n8\n\nforth in our reply, your Honor, there is a real concern because\n\n9\n\na number of, I think, the entire first series of exhibits, are\n\n10\n\nlargely taken from a period outside of the charged conspiracy.\n\n11\n\ni think this witness may attempt to authenticate some of those\n\n12\n\nexhibits and they haven't established why that will be relevant\n\n13\n\nto the charged time period of the conspiracy.\n\n14\n\ndidn't argue 404(b) on this point and we asked for additional\n\n15\n\ntime in terms of the direct evidence because we had just\n\n16\n\nreceived these 400 pages that relate to that particular\n\n17\n\nwitness, your Honor.\n\n18\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd so the\n\nAs we set\n\nThey really\n\nSo the basic contention would be if we\n\n19\n\nhave a document that, on its face, that post-dates the charged\n\n20\n\nconspiracy.\n\n21\n\nyour objection, right?\n\n22\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\n23\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI mean that, alone, is I think the first point of\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nThe authentication issue aside.\n\nWhat is\n\n24\n\nthe relevance of a document that, on its face, post-dates the\n\n25\n\ncharged conspiracy?\n\nLet's start with that, Ms. Moe.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834947\n\n", "char_count": 1647}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 58, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 59 of 127\n\n59\n\nLB15MAX2\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nThe category of exhibits that this witness would be\nauthenticating would include, among other things, contact\n4\n\ninformation for the minor victims and so the fact that that\n\n5\n\ncontact information and messages from those victims was in\n\n6\n\nMr. Epstein's residence and, in part, in the defendant's\n\n7\n\npossession is relevant regardless of the time frame and is\n\n8\n\ncorroborative of the other evidence at trial.\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThe charged conspiracy ends and then\n\n10\n\nMr. Epstein maintains addresses of individuals alleged to be\n\n11\n\nvictims here.\n\n12\n\nIs that the context?\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor; but more specifically with\n\n13\n\nrespect to the two categories of exhibits, the first would\n\n14\n\ninclude messages that were left at the residence during the\n\n15\n\ntime frame of the charged conspiracy, they are dated and\n\n16\n\ninclude a name of a victim and her contact information and so\n\n17\n\nthis witness will be authenticating those.\n\n18\n\ncome from the time frame of the charged conspiracy and were\n\n19\n\ncreated at the time frame of the charged conduct.\n\nThose documents\n\n20\n\nWith respect to a second category of information --\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd you have a witness who would\n\n22\n\nauthenticate that they were created at the time of the charged\n\n23\n\nconduct which, presumably, wouldn't be somebody who doesn't\n\n24\n\ncome onto the scene until after the time period of the charged\n\n25\n\nconduct.\n\nFair to say?\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834948\n\n", "char_count": 1584}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 59, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 60 of 127\n\n60\n\nLB15MAX2\nMS. MOE:\n\nYour Honor, those records would be\n\nauthenticated through number of different witnesses; in part,\nlaw enforcement officer describing those exact records being\n4\n\nseized from the residence in 2005 in their general description\n\n5\n\nand format, witnesses describing the practice for maintaining\n\n6\n\nthose records contemporaneously and doing so in the course of\n\n7\n\ntheir employment.\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n9\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n11\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nContemporaneous to what?\n\nAt the time the message was made.\nDuring the period of the conspiracy?\nYes, your Honor.\n\nAnd that testimony would\n\n12\n\ninclude testimony about the format of these documents, where\n\n13\n\nthey were kept, and the practice for keeping messages along\n\n14\n\nthese lines.\n\n15\n\nCircuit's rulings on authentication being based on the\n\n16\n\nparticulars of a document and their formatting and their\n\n17\n\ncontents.\n\n18\n\nwitnesses and, collectively, at the conclusion of that\n\n19\n\ntestimony, we would offer those exhibits based on that\n\n20\n\nfoundation.\n\n21\n\nWe think that is consistent with the Second\n\nSo I think this would come in through a number of\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd I don't think I can rule on that in\n\n22\n\nadvance until we hear the authentication evidence being\n\n23\n\noffered.\n\n24\n\nthe defense -- but it seems like those pieces could add up to\n\n25\n\nauthentication.\n\nWhat you have proffered I think -- I will hear from\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834949\n\n", "char_count": 1528}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 60, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 61 of 127\n\n61\n\nLB15MAX2\nBut take the example, if you would, that a document\nthat, on its face, post-dates the charged conspiracy, for what\npurpose would you be offering that?\n4\n\nAnd let's use the address\n\nbook as an example.\n\n5\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n6\n\nWith respect to that particular document, the\n\n7\n\ntestimony would be that that document belonged to the defendant\n\n8\n\nand that she -- and the document itself would include contact\n\n9\n\ninformation for some minor victims under a certain heading that\n\n10\n\nhas relevance to the case and organized in a certain way that\n\n11\n\nis consistent with victim testimony.\n\n12\n\nheld on to that or maintained it following the conclusion of\n\n13\n\nthe charged conspiracy, it would nonetheless be relevant to\n\n14\n\nestablish the defendant's knowledge to confirm her contact with\n\n15\n\nthose victims and to be corroborative of other exhibits at\n\n16\n\ntrial.\n\n17\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo, whether the defendant\n\nIf the evidence were that it wasn't\n\n18\n\ncreated or maintained until after the charged conspiracy, is it\n\n19\n\nrelevant?\n\n20\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\n21\n\nIf, at the conclusion of the conspiracy, the defendant\n\n22\n\nnonetheless memorialized that information about those victims,\n\n23\n\nit would nonetheless be relevant to her knowledge to rebut\n\n24\n\narguments that she didn't know the victims or have contact with\n\n25\n\nthem and so certainly that would be relevant, your Honor.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834950\n\n", "char_count": 1537}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 61, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 62 of 127\n\n62\n\nLB15MAX2\nTHE COURT:\n\nMs. Menninger?\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nYour Honor, I am a little confused but\n\nwhat I think I understand the government is saying is that\n4\n\nknowledge after the conspiracy is relevant to the time frame of\n\n5\n\nthe conspiracy.\n\n6\n\ntalking about, who didn't start working until after the time of\n\n7\n\nthe conspiracy for Mr. Epstein, would be able to set forth the\n\n8\n\nfoundation that they're claiming.\n\n9\n\nlikely to be a trial-time testimony decision because I think\n\n10\n\nthere will be some pretty substantial objections to the ability\n\n11\n\nof this witness to authenticate the document which I know your\n\n12\n\nHonor is aware from other briefing, is what we consider to be\n\n13\n\nfrom a very suspect source and obtained years later.\n\n14\n\na lot of notations and things on it that will not be anything\n\n15\n\nthat this witness can attest to.\n\nI don't believe that the witness we are\n\nI believe that this is more\n\nThere is\n\nI think it is Exhibit 52.\n\n16\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n17\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\n18\n\ntime period of the conspiracy.\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n20\n\nI guess the question, given the pieces of\n\n21\n\nauthentication that the government intends to offer through\n\n22\n\ndifferent witnesses and what sounds like lines of\n\n23\n\ncross-examination as to those pieces, I think at that point I\n\n24\n\nam potentially -- at least the government will have to proffer,\n\n25\n\nput forward questions and get answers from the witness that\n\nYes.\nI don't think it is relevant to the\n\nRight.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834951\n\n", "char_count": 1596}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 62, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 63 of 127\n\n63\n\nLB15MAX2\nwould go to authentication.\n\nI just don't know if I am in a\n\nposition to rule at this point but let me ask both sides if\nanybody intends -- I mean, take Exhibit 52, is that going to be\n4\n5\n\nmentioned in opening?\nMS. MOE:\n\nYour Honor, the government doesn't\n\n6\n\nanticipate opening with respect to Government Exhibit 52 but\n\n7\n\nmay address, in opening, other categories of exhibits, for\n\n8\n\nexample, the message pads that I just referenced.\n\n9\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nYour Honor, that's a problem.\n\nIn\n\n10\n\nterms of the message pads that have a post-conspiracy date on\n\n11\n\nthem without a witness who can authenticate them under any\n\n12\n\nexception under hearsay in opening statements, we would\n\n13\n\nstrongly object to that.\n\n14\n\ngrounds to lay a foundation or relevance for those.\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n16\n\nwill authenticate?\n\n17\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes.\n\nI still have not heard appropriate\n\nLet's take the message pads.\n\nYour Honor, a number of witnesses.\n\nWho\n\nI think\n\n18\n\nwe would be offering those messages at the conclusion of a\n\n19\n\nseries of witnesses laying foundation for their authenticity\n\n20\n\nincluding law enforcement witnesses and employees talking about\n\n21\n\nthe circumstances under which messages were maintained but we\n\n22\n\ndon't anticipate offering messages in those message books that\n\n23\n\npost-date the time frame of the charged conspiracy.\n\n24\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOK.\n\nSo the government will not mention\n\nany message pads that post-date the charged conspiracy in its\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834952\n\n", "char_count": 1610}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 63, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 64 of 127\n\n64\n\nLB15MAX2\nopening.\nMS. MOE:\n\nThat's correct, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nMs. Menninger, anything further on that?\n\n4\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n6\n\nAnything further in this general category that needs\n\n7\n\nNothing further on that, your Honor.\n\nOK.\n\nto be addressed now, Ms. Menninger?\n\n8\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nIf there is no other evidence that the\n\n9\n\ngovernment intends to offer via Rule 404(b), then no.\n\nThere\n\n10\n\nwas a reference to another exhibit -- GX- 416 -- in the\n\n11\n\ngovernment's briefing.\n\n12\n\nwas mentioned in the Rule 404(b) letter.\n\n13\n\nwas not mentioned in that letter it cannot be offered through\n\n14\n\n404(b).\n\n15\n\nthat your Honor has excluded so I don't know what the intent is\n\n16\n\nthere.\n\nThat was not one of the exhibits that\nI assume because it\n\nIt is of a same type and characteristic of the e-mail\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nMs. Moe?\n\n18\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n19\n\nWe didn't include that exhibit in our notice.\n\n20\n\noffering it as direct evidence, unlike the other evidence which\n\n21\n\nwere included in our notice.\n\n22\n\nnotes.\n\n23\n\ndefendant created that series of notes but, unlike the other\n\n24\n\nexhibits outlined in our letter, it doesn't appear that that\n\n25\n\nwas directed at a third-party as opposed to Mr. Epstein,\n\nYes, your Honor.\nWe are\n\nThat document is a series of\n\nThe metadata for that exhibit reflects that the\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834953\n\n", "char_count": 1461}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 64, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 65 of 127\n\n65\n\nLB15MAX2\nalthough it is not clear from the document to whom it's\ndirected.\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nIt relates to individuals in their 30s\n\n4\n\nand 20s, your Honor.\n\n5\n\ncharged conduct or direct evidence of a conspiracy to abuse\n\n6\n\nunderage females.\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI'm just unclear how it relates to\n\nIt seems like it falls within my -- it\n\n8\n\nwasn't specifically moved for exclusion but because of the\n\n9\n\ngovernment not including it in its notice but I'm not seeing\n\n10\n\nI am pulling it up but I'm not seeing a notice -- a basis, from\n\n11\n\nwhat I am hearing, distinguishing it from my ruling on the\n\n12\n\ne-mails.\n\n13\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYour Honor, the government submits that\n\n14\n\nalong with other exhibits at trial, which will establish the\n\n15\n\ndefendant's role with respect to Mr. Epstein and her role in\n\n16\n\nparticular in setting up sexualized massages for him, that this\n\n17\n\nis corroborative of other exhibits and other testimony at trial\n\n18\n\nthat the defendant did in fact serve that role, was willing to\n\n19\n\ndo -- take steps along those lines.\n\n20\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd so, for that reason --\n\nBut it involves, clearly, people over the\n\nage of consent?\n\n22\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nThat's correct, your Honor.\n\n23\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n24\n\nFor the same reasons, 416 is excluded.\n\n25\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nLet me just pull it up.\n\nUnderstood, your Honor.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834954\n\n", "char_count": 1454}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 65, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 66 of 127\n\n66\n\nLB15MAX2\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnything else on this?\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\nTHE COURT:\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\nThank you.\n\nNext is Defendant's Exhibit 3 which is the\n\n4\n\nmotion to exclude the excerpt which, as I have indicated, we\n\n5\n\nwill take up at the Daubert hearing.\n\n6\n\nLet's take a short comfort break.\n\n7\n\n(Recess)\n\na\n\n(Continued next page)\n\n10-minute break.\n\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834955\n\n", "char_count": 535}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 66, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 67 of 127\n\n67\n\nLB1TMAX3\nTHE COURT:\n\nWe'll pick up with Defense 4.\n\nThis is the\n\nissue of evidence related to alleged Victim-3.\nDefense seeks to exclude evidence related to this\n4\n\nindividual that's not probative of the charged conspiracy and\n\n5\n\ninadmissible under 404(b) and 403.\n\n6\n\nhere.\n\n7\n\npermissible here.\n\n8\n\ngeneral background information that does not reveal specific\n\n9\n\nidentifying information regarding the alleged victims is\n\n10\n\nnecessary, but we'll proceed bearing in mind the requested\n\n11\n\nredactions.\n\n12\n\nThere are redactions issues\n\nRedactions of specific identifying information is\nI don't think that redactions as to some\n\nI want to begin this one with questions for the\n\n13\n\ngovernment.\n\n14\n\nstatute of limitations issues, but setting the statute of\n\n15\n\nlimitations issue aside, if the only evidence in the case\n\n16\n\npertained to this individual, if all the testimony of this\n\n17\n\nindividual is accepted by the jury, could the defendant be\n\n18\n\nfound guilty of any crimes charged in the indictment?\n\n19\n\nMs. Moe, so it's a hypothetical.\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nI gather there's\n\nWith respect, just so I understand the\n\n20\n\nhypothetical, if the only count in the indictment were the\n\n21\n\nAct conspiracy --\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nNo, any of the crimes charged, just\n\n23\n\nstipulate to that, but if the only evidence pertains to this\n\n24\n\nindividual.\n\n25\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nThe answer is no.\n\nIn\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834956\n\n", "char_count": 1532}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 67, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 68 of 127\n\n68\n\nLB1TMAX3\nparticular, because with respect to -- that's why I was\nclarifying, your Honor.\n\nWith respect to the\n\nAct\n\nconspiracies, the particular criminal sexual activity relates\n4\n\nto a particular statute in New York.\n\n5\n\nsex trafficking --\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n7\n\nAnd with respect to the\n\nThe particular statute in New York that\n\nthe government here -- that's 130.053(a), right?\n\n8\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd that establishes 17 as the age of\n\n10\n\nconsent for the underlying sexual activity that's charged in\n\n11\n\nthe indictment.\n\n12\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat's correct, your Honor.\nSo the\n\nAct is going to -- the case\n\n14\n\nthat the government is going to prove here is going to\n\n15\n\nincorporate that as the illegal sexual conduct.\n\n16\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n19\n\nThat's correct, your Honor.\nSo couldn't be convicted with respect to\n\nthat count.\nMS. MOE:\n\nThat's correct, your Honor.\n\nAnd that's\n\n20\n\namong the many reasons why we submit there's very little\n\n21\n\npotential prejudice of offering this testimony considering its\n\n22\n\nrelevance to the counts charged, because given the elements of\n\n23\n\nthe offense standing alone and the statute of limitations\n\n24\n\nissue, we think there's no 403 issue here.\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWell, not just with respect to the\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834957\n\n", "char_count": 1425}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 68, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 69 of 127\n\n69\n\nLB1TMAX3\nAct, there's no count charged in the indictment for which the\ndefendant could be convicted -- again, setting aside -- I'm not\ndealing with the statute of limitations issue, put it out of\n4\n\nyour mind.\n\n5\n\nthe defendant be convicted of any count charged in the\n\n6\n\nindictment based on the evidence as it pertains to this?\n\n7\n\nSo assuming no statute of limitations issue, could\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nNo, your Honor, we have not charged the case\n\n8\n\nthat way, and that testimony alone wouldn't satisfy those\n\n9\n\ncrimes charged.\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd is the government's position that this\n\n11\n\nindividual could be deemed a victim for restitution purposes or\n\n12\n\nany legal purpose with respect to the crimes charged in this\n\n13\n\ncase and the case that the government is going to put on?\n\n14\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYour Honor, with apologies, I haven't\n\n15\n\nthought through the restitution issue.\n\n16\n\nwith my office about that.\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI would want to confer\n\nI'm not certain, your Honor.\n\nWell, if the defendant can't be indicted\n\n18\n\nbased on this conduct -- again, assuming no statute of\n\n19\n\nlimitations issue, assuming that the jury adopts and accepts\n\n20\n\nall of the testimony as true, the defendant couldn't be\n\n21\n\nconvicted of any of the crimes charged based on that conduct,\n\n22\n\nhow could that individual be deemed a victim of the crime\n\n23\n\ncharged?\n\n24\n25\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nI understand the Court's point, your Honor.\n\nI guess my concern is that the distinction between charging\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834958\n\n", "char_count": 1615}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 69, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 70 of 127\n\n70\n\nLB1TMAX3\nbased on that conduct alone and the evidence based on that\nconduct alone, we submit that, given the course of conduct in\nthe charged conspiracy, that Minor Victim-3 is a victim of an\n4\n\nongoing conspiracy, which is one of agreement and intent.\n\n5\n\nWe submit that her testimony alone wouldn't establish\n\n6\n\na violation of the\n\n7\n\ncircumstances of other victim testimony, we couldn't establish\n\n8\n\nthat there was an ongoing intent to transport minor victims.\n\n9\n\nBut given that the crime here is conspiracy and one of\n\n10\n\nagreements and mental states and not about attempts to violate\n\n11\n\ncertain statutes or agreements to do so, it's about the\n\n12\n\nintention at the time of agreement during the course of a span\n\n13\n\nof conduct.\n\n14\n15\n\nAct, and without the other\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nBut it has to be an intention to engage in\n\nan illegal act.\n\n16\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat's correct, your Honor.\nAnd so I think I need an answer to the\n\n18\n\nquestion.\n\nThere is a distinction, surely, between criminality\n\n19\n\nand evidence of criminality.\n\n20\n\nwhich is not itself criminality, for sure.\n\n21\n\nquestions and the like.\n\n22\n\nposition I think for a number of things in issue, including\n\n23\n\nDefendant's 4.\n\n24\n\ncouldn't be found guilty of any crimes charged based on the\n\n25\n\nconduct alleged with respect to what you refer to as alleged\n\nYou have evidence of criminality,\nYou have 403\n\nBut I need to know the government's\n\nSo you have confirmed that the defendant\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834959\n\n", "char_count": 1606}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 70, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 71of 127\n\n71\n\nLB1TMAX3\nVictim-3.\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd you're not sure what the government's\n\n4\n\nposition is as to whether alleged Victim-3 could in any legal\n\n5\n\nsense be deemed a victim of any of the counts charged, despite\n\n6\n\nthe I think necessary, but I wasn't sure of the government's\n\n7\n\nposition, with respect to the illegality of conduct involving\n\n8\n\nthe victim.\n\n9\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYour Honor, with apologies, may I have one\n\n10\n\nmoment to confer with my colleagues?\n\n11\n\nnot misunderstanding the Court's question and want to confer\n\n12\n\nwith them about a specific issue.\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n14\n\n(Pause)\n\n15\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n16\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI want to make sure I'm\n\nOkay.\n\nThank you, your Honor.\nOne moment, because I want to pull up this\n\n17\n\nportion of the government's briefing on this which triggered\n\n18\n\nthese questions.\n\n19\n\n(Pause)\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n21\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nOkay, go ahead.\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\nAs my colleagues\n\n22\n\nhave pointed out to me, the definition of a victim for purposes\n\n23\n\nof the element of the statute and pursuant to the restitution\n\n24\n\nstatute are different.\n\n25\n\nto issues of restitution is because that implicates the Crime\n\nAnd part of our hesitation in speaking\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834960\n\n", "char_count": 1342}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 71, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 72 of 127\n\n72\n\nLB1TMAX3\nVictims' Rights Act, so we want to confer with victims' counsel\non that issue as well before we reach a conclusion on that.\nThe definition set forth in the restitution statute,\n4\n\nwhich is 18 USC 3663(a)(2), for purposes of the section, the\n\n5\n\nterm \"victim\" means a person directly and proximately harmed as\n\n6\n\na result of the commission of an offense for which restitution\n\n7\n\nmay be ordered.\n\n8\n\nSo that's the particular issue that we just want to\n\n9\n\nthink through before we reach a conclusion on in particular\n\n10\n\nbecause we're mindful of the Crime Victims' Rights Act.\n\n11\n\napologize, it's not my intention, certainly, to fight the\n\n12\n\nhypothetical, we wanted to be thoughtful about that issue.\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo I\n\nYou will get me your views on that\n\n14\n\nquestion with respect to restitution, but as I understand your\n\n15\n\ninitial point, for purposes, as you said, of the elements of\n\n16\n\nestablishing any of the offenses, the government's view is that\n\n17\n\nthis individual is not a victim in the sense -- granting that\n\n18\n\nrestitution's definition of \"victim\" could be broader than\n\n19\n\nthose for whom the government's proof of elements as to the\n\n20\n\ncharged account would show to be victims, I think that's the\n\n21\n\ndistinction you're trying to draw.\n\n22\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYour Honor, our position is that we\n\n23\n\nrecognize Minor Victim-3's testimony alone would not satisfy\n\n24\n\nthe elements of the conspiracy count in which the overt acts\n\n25\n\nappear, our view is nonetheless that it's direct evidence.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834961\n\n", "char_count": 1662}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 72, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 73 of 127\n\n73\n\nLB1TMAX3\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat's because the relevant age of consent\n\nfor purposes of the case that the government is trying to prove\nis the New York statute, which sets 17 as the age of consent,\n4\n\nand this individual was -- sorry, under 17 is the age of\n\n5\n\nconsent, and this individual, when the government understands\n\n6\n\nsexual conduct to have occurred, was 17, correct?\n\n7\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n9\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n10\n\nThat's correct, your Honor.\nOkay.\nIt's nonetheless our position this is direct\n\nevidence for a number of reasons.\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n12\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nFirst, it's --\n\nDirect evidence of what?\n\nOf the charged conspiracy.\n\nIn part because\n\n13\n\nthis conduct occurred at the same time the defendant was\n\n14\n\nengaged in conduct with respect to the other victims, and her\n\n15\n\ntestimony will establish a pattern that is corroborative of\n\n16\n\ntheir testimony and demonstrates the defendant's knowledge and\n\n17\n\nintent.\n\n18\n\nWith respect to the issue --\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n20\n21\n\nYou've slid between direct evidence and\n\n404(b), right, knowledge and intent?\nMS. MOE:\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\nThe government will\n\n22\n\ncertainly be required to prove at trial the defendant's\n\n23\n\nknowledge and intent to commit these crimes.\n\n24\n\ndefendant's conduct with respect to this victim goes directly\n\n25\n\nto that issue.\n\nSo the\n\nIn particular, I take the Court's point with\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834962\n\n", "char_count": 1497}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 73, "text_content": "Case 1:2O-cr-OO33O-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 74 of 127\n\n74\n\nLB1TMAX3\nrespect to the issue of 17 or under 17, but more broadly, I\nthink the question at trial will be about, among other things,\nthe defendant's knowledge of Jeffrey Epstein's preference for\n4\n5\n6\n7\n\nvery young girls.\nTHE COURT:\n\nWell, let's say this individual were 20,\n\nis it direct evidence of the crimes being charged?\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor, but for a different reason.\n\n8\n\nUnder those circumstances, it would nonetheless be our\n\n9\n\nposition, even if the victim were 18, 19 or 20, that the\n\n10\n\ndefendant's specific conduct towards that victim proves other\n\n11\n\naspects of the course of conduct.\n\n12\n\nparticular pattern --\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nIn other words, the\n\nThis seems to move into the email issue,\n\n14\n\nwhich I have excluded.\n\n15\n\nemails of the defendant setting up individuals with other\n\n16\n\nindividuals over -- in some cases well over the age of consent,\n\n17\n\nand I have excluded that.\n\n18\n\ndistinguishing this here?\n\n19\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n20\n\nnumber of reasons.\n\n21\n\nintertwined.\n\n22\n\nthis victim closely mirror actions with other victims, for\n\n23\n\nexample, introducing sexual topics in a slow and gradual way.\n\n24\n25\n\nThat is to say, you wanted to put in\n\nSo is there a basis for\n\nYes, your Honor, there certainly is for a\nHere, the course of conduct is closely\n\nIn other words, the defendant's interactions with\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWhen you say \"victim\" there, do you mean\n\nthat in a legal sense?\n\nBecause I still want to understand the\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834963\n\n", "char_count": 1582}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 74, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 75 of 127\n\n75\n\nLB1TMAX3\npoint.\nNow one might have all kinds of moral judgments and\nconcerns, but is there a legal sense in which the government\n4\n\nright now in talking to me is just identify the person, or is\n\n5\n\nthere a legal sense in which you're proffering this individual\n\n6\n\nas an victim of the crimes charged, setting aside you don't\n\n7\n\nhave an answer yet as to whether they may meet some basis for\n\n8\n\nrestitution should the defendant be convicted.\n\n9\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor, I'm using that term both\n\n10\n\nfor identification purposes and because I think, as the\n\n11\n\nvictim's testimony will illustrate, she will describe a course\n\n12\n\nof unwanted conduct, and the way in which she came to engage in\n\n13\n\nthat conduct is as a direct result of the defendant's behavior\n\n14\n\nin a way that closely mirrors the way the defendant secured\n\n15\n\naccess for Mr. Epstein to the other minor victims in this case.\n\n16\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat is an argument about consent being\n\n17\n\nthe basis for which -- we have put it aside to 412, but as a\n\n18\n\ngeneral matter you have argued consent is irrelevant because\n\n19\n\nthe age of consent is the only thing in issue for these\n\n20\n\ncharges, but you're saying the relevance of this individual's\n\n21\n\ntestimony turns on the government establishing nonconsensual\n\n22\n\nsexual conduct?\n\n23\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nNo, your Honor, I'm simply explaining why we\n\n24\n\nare using that term \"victim,\" because that's the way she\n\n25\n\ncharacterizes that experience, and I think that will come\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834964\n\n", "char_count": 1626}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 75, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 76 of 127\n\n76\n\nLB1TMAX3\nacross when she describes it.\nWhat I mean is not that the relevance turns on whether\nor not she consented to that conduct, but the way in which that\n4\n\noccurred closely mirrors exactly how that occurred with other\n\n5\n\nvictims.\n\n6\n\nthe means they employed, the defendant's role in the\n\n7\n\nconspiracy, all of which is direct proof of the defendant's\n\n8\n\nguilt, this victim's testimony will be corroborative and\n\n9\n\nestablish the defendant's knowledge.\n\n10\n\nSo in terms of proving the methods of the conspiracy,\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYou're saying that would be true\n\n11\n\nregardless of the age of this individual.\n\nI could keep doing a\n\n12\n\nhypothetical, 25, 30, it doesn't matter, from your perspective,\n\n13\n\nit would be relevant to establishing the conspiracy because it\n\n14\n\noccurred at the same time?\n\n15\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYour Honor, I could see universe in which\n\n16\n\nthere were an outer limit on the age a hypothetical victim\n\n17\n\nwhere this would be relevant.\n\n18\n\nvictim makes it particularly relevant, but it's the other\n\n19\n\naspects of the course of conduct which are corroborative and\n\n20\n\nmake this direct evidence.\n\n21\n\nproximity to the age of the other victims, and so her\n\n22\n\ntestimony, among other things, establishes the defendant's\n\n23\n\nknowledge and awareness of a certain sexual preference for\n\n24\n\ngirls under the age of 18.\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOur view is that the age of this\n\nHere, this victim was 17, in close\n\nBut under the age of 18 is legally\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834965\n\n", "char_count": 1599}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 76, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 77 of 127\n\n77\n\nLB1TMAX3\nirrelevant to the crimes charged, correct?\n\nUnder the age of 17\n\nis what is legally relevant.\nMS. MOE:\n\nThat's certainly true with respect to the\n\n4\n\nelements as to the other victims, but I think as a matter of\n\n5\n\ncommon sense, a jury understanding that the defendant is\n\n6\n\nwilling to provide Epstein with a girl at the age of 17 would\n\n7\n\ncertainly speak to her knowledge of his sexual preferences.\n\n8\n9\n10\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWhy doesn't it speak to a knowledge of\n\nsexual preferences to someone just above the age of consent?\nMS. MOE:\n\nWell, your Honor, I think the close\n\n11\n\nproximity of ages, it speaks to her knowledge about his\n\n12\n\npreference for very young girls.\n\n13\n\nI would also note that, although the age of 17 is\n\n14\n\nrelevant with respect to the\n\n15\n\nthe trafficking counts, the applicable age is there is 18.\n\n16\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAct counts, with respect to\n\nI began this whole series by asking, like\n\n17\n\neight times and very clearly, is there any sense in which this\n\n18\n\nindividual, the conduct that's -- assuming it to all be true\n\n19\n\nwith respect to this individual, could establish an element of\n\n20\n\nany of the crimes charged?\n\n21\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nWith respect to that\n\n22\n\nvictim, that's certainly the case.\n\nBut speaking to direct\n\n23\n\nevidence of knowledge and preferences, it's certainly also\n\n24\n\ndirect evidence of the defendant's knowledge with respect to\n\n25\n\nthe sex trafficking counts where the age of consent there is\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834966\n\n", "char_count": 1606}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 77, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 78 of 127\n\n78\n\nLB1TMAX3\n18.\n\nAnd so the fact that the defendant was taking these steps\n\ntowards a girl who was 17 years old certainly speaks to her\nknowledge and willingness to provide such a girl to Epstein\n4\n\nwith respect to the sex trafficking counts as well.\n\n5\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nwe're talking Count Five and Count Six, right?\n\n7\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n9\n\nYes, your Honor.\nOn this one, for sex trafficking, you have\n\nto prove what with respect to H in order to get a conviction?\n\n10\n11\n\nSo to prove the sex trafficking count,\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nThat the victims were less than 18 years\n\nold.\n\n12\n\nI would note on that score, your Honor, with respect\n\n13\n\nto the trafficking counts, the issue is about commercial sex\n\n14\n\nacts in exchange for something of value involving individuals\n\n15\n\nunder 18.\n\n16\n\nsexualized massages with Epstein at the defendant's urging and\n\n17\n\nreceiving compensation in part.\n\n18\n\nother reasons why her testimony is corroborative of other\n\n19\n\nvictim testimony in this case and direct evidence of the\n\n20\n\ncharged crimes.\n\n21\n\nMinor Victim-3 would testify about participating in\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd that's one of the many\n\nSo the conduct took place -- the sexual\n\n22\n\nconduct took place at the age of 17.\n\n23\n\nindividual who says -- the government can't establish under the\n\n24\n\nage of 18 for purposes of travel.\n\n25\n\nFactually, this is an\n\nI guess that goes to the\n\nAct, not to the trafficking count.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834967\n\n", "char_count": 1546}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 78, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 79 of 127\n\n79\n\nLB1TMAX3\nSo on trafficking, the government would seek to have\nthis testimony as direct evidence with respect to the\ntrafficking count, because the individual of legal age in all\n4\n\nrelevant jurisdictions was under the age of 18.\n\n5\n\nto have to spell it out for me.\n\n6\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nYou're going\n\nIf the defense were to\n\n7\n\nargue that the defendant didn't know that victims with respect\n\n8\n\nto the trafficking count were under the age of 18 or wouldn't\n\n9\n\nhave done this if they were under 18 or that she did not know\n\n10\n\nthat Epstein had a preference for underage girls or his\n\n11\n\nsexualized massages were with girls under the age of 18, this\n\n12\n\nwould certainly speak to that issue.\n\n13\n\nIn particular, if the defendant were to argue that she\n\n14\n\ndidn't know that the massages she was arranging were\n\n15\n\nsexualized, I think the testimony of the victim speaking to\n\n16\n\nthat issue would certainly make that all the more relevant.\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nRight.\n\nOkay.\n\nI'm not sure the government\n\n18\n\nhad previously argued this constituted direct evidence of the\n\n19\n\ntrafficking count, is that right?\n\n20\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYour Honor, I would have to review our\n\n21\n\nbriefing.\n\n22\n\ncharged crimes.\n\n23\n\nour view is the entire course of conduct speaks to the\n\n24\n\ndefendant's role and knowledge, and the proof here is mutually\n\n25\n\nsufficient.\n\nI believe we said that it was direct evidence of the\nI apologize if we were vague about that, but\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834968\n\n", "char_count": 1590}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 79, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 80 of 127\n\n80\n\nLB1TMAX3\nTHE COURT:\n\nWho am I hearing from on this one?\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nMe, your Honor.\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\nI think your Honor hit it right on the head right from\n4\n\nthe outset, which is if all we had were allegations related to\n\n5\n\nthis particular individual, we would not have a charged crime\n\n6\n\nhere because there was no criminal activity at all.\n\n7\n\nThe only basis for which -- I think the government has\n\n8\n\ntried to articulate some basis for its relevance as direct\n\n9\n\nevidence of the charged crimes is her subjective experience of\n\n10\n\nwhat happened to her.\n\n11\n\njurisdiction where these events allegedly took place.\n\n12\n\nissue of consent, while we may have moral objections to this,\n\n13\n\nit was entirely legal and the government can't prove otherwise.\n\n14\n\nSo all she's going to testify to, presumably, is how she felt\n\n15\n\nabout those instances, and that is not proof that is probative\n\n16\n\nof the defendant's guilt of these charges.\n\n17\n\nShe was of legal age in every single\nSo the\n\nMoreover, your Honor, it is quite inflammatory and\n\n18\n\nmisleads the jury to hear when someone feels a certain way what\n\n19\n\nhappened to her, even though legally it doesn't make a\n\n20\n\ndifference, that is going to encourage them to feel sympathy\n\n21\n\nfor her and convict the defendant potentially on a false ground\n\n22\n\nbecause there is no illegal conduct here.\n\n23\n\nYour Honor, I think the government has articulated or\n\n24\n\nat least tried to articulate at the Court's urging a basis why\n\n25\n\nthis may be direct evidence of the sex trafficking conspiracy.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834969\n\n", "char_count": 1696}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 80, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 81 of 127\n\n81\n\nLB1TMAX3\nThat really was not spelled out in the briefing.\nTHE COURT:\n\nI think for sure it wasn't, because just\n\nnearing it for the first time, it strikes me as having\n4\n\npotential plausibility.\n\n5\n\nI certainly will need briefing and to think about that question\n\n6\n\nmore.\n\n7\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThat was not present in the papers, so\n\nI can assure you if it had been really\n\n8\n\nteed up, I would have addressed it.\n\nBut I would note that\n\n9\n\nthere is a time difference between the\n\n10\n\nand the sex trafficking counts.\n\nAct conspiracies\n\n11\n\nThe sex trafficking counts are 2001 to 2004, and this\n\n12\n\nparticular individual was well over the age of consent by the\n\n13\n\ntime 2001 to 2004 is going on.\n\n14\n\nplace in '94 and '95 when she's 17 and 18.\n\n15\n\nwell past the age of consent in any of these relevant\n\n16\n\njurisdictions.\n\nShe's alleging events that took\n2001 to 2004 is\n\n17\n\nI don't see how it is probative of the defendant's\n\n18\n\nintent -- when someone is presumably allegedly engaging in\n\n19\n\nperfectly legal sex acts, how that is probative of intent,\n\n20\n\nknowledge, or any of the above of a sex trafficking conspiracy.\n\n21\n\nAnd by the way, there's no allegation that she got paid, so how\n\n22\n\nare we talking about sex trafficking?\n\n23\n\nIt seems like the government is trying to take an\n\n24\n\nepisode of legal conduct and make it sound salacious for the\n\n25\n\njury and use it as direct evidence of conspiracies for which it\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834970\n\n", "char_count": 1563}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 81, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 82 of 127\n\n82\n\nLB1TMAX3\nis entirely irrelevant, every single one of them.\nSo our view, Judge, is that her testimony should not\ncome in as direct evidence of the conspiracy.\n\nAt best, what\n\n4\n\nthe government has articulated -- they keep talking about\n\n5\n\npattern, intent, knowledge.\n\n6\n\nwe're going to talk about this witness's testimony at all, we\n\n7\n\nshould be talking about it in terms of 404(b) and whether it\n\n8\n\nmeets that test.\n\n9\n\nprobative of knowledge or intent.\n\nThat's classic 404(b).\n\nAnd it doesn't, your Honor.\n\nSo if\n\nIt is not\n\n10\n\nFor a crime that charges causing someone to travel to\n\n11\n\nengage in a legal sex act as a minor, if that person is neither\n\n12\n\na minor, did not travel with the intent of doing something\n\n13\n\nillegal because it was not illegal in any of those\n\n14\n\njurisdictions, whatever happened, according to her own\n\n15\n\ntestimony, it is not probative of any of those crimes and for\n\n16\n\n404(b) purposes, too.\n\n17\n\nPattern, Judge, if it's modus operandi, that need to\n\n18\n\nbe extremely specific before that can come in as modus operandi\n\n19\n\nevidence.\n\n20\n\nand polite conversation with someone as a pattern.\n\n21\n\na pattern that passes muster.\n\n22\n\nWe can't talk about engaging in social pleasantries\nThat is not\n\nFurthermore, there are huge 403 issues with this\n\n23\n\nwitness's testimony.\n\nIf she talks about how she felt about\n\n24\n\nthese experiences, that is eliciting sympathy from the jury.\n\n25\n\nIt is not legally probative and it will lead them to think that\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834971\n\n", "char_count": 1621}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 82, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 83 of 127\n\n83\n\nLB1TMAX3\nshe felt, in her words, sexually abused in these circumstances,\nthat she was in fact engaging in illegal conduct.\n\nAnd it\n\nraises a real problem that the jury will convict on a false\n4\n\npremise, on a legally incorrect assumption that the conduct\n\n5\n\nthat was occurring was illegal when it wasn't.\n\n6\n7\n8\n\nSo your Honor, we object to her testimony for any\npurpose at this trial.\nMS. MOE:\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\nJust to taking those\n\n9\n\npoints one by one, with respect to the time difference, we\n\n10\n\nthink that it is nonetheless relevant with respect to the sex\n\n11\n\ntrafficking counts.\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAm I right -- point me to the page.\n\n13\n\nnot argued in the papers.\n\n14\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nIt's\n\nI apologize, your Honor, we should have been\n\n15\n\nmore specific, and I do apologize about that.\n\n16\n\nthe way we framed it was about preference for girls under the\n\n17\n\nage of 18 and about the course of conduct, but I apologize, we\n\n18\n\nshould have been more specific about that.\n\nI do think that\n\n19\n\nBut with respect to the timeframe and the course of\n\n20\n\nconduct, I think the jury would be free to conclude, based on\n\n21\n\nthis direct evidence, that in 2002 and 2003 when Minor Victim-4\n\n22\n\nwas being trafficked, that the defendant knew that Epstein had\n\n23\n\na preference for girls under the age of 18 and knew that he\n\n24\n\nwould engage in sexual contact with them because she knew in\n\n25\n\n1994 when she was involved in transporting Minor Victim-1 that\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834972\n\n", "char_count": 1597}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 83, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 84 of 127\n\n84\n\nLB1TMAX3\nshe knew about that preference because of her conduct with\nrespect to Minor Victim-2 and with respect to Minor Victim-3.\nThat course of conduct continued throughout a decade and is\n4\n\nconsistent.\n\n5\n\nthat is powerful proof of her knowledge and intent and why it's\n\n6\n\ndirect evidence of the crimes charged.\n\nAnd I think the consistency of that is part of why\n\n7\n\nWith respect to the question of prejudice, the\n\n8\n\ngovernment doesn't see any risk that this jury could convict on\n\n9\n\nthis conduct for a number of reasons.\n\n10\n\nFirst, with respect to the concern that there's a risk\n\n11\n\nthat the jury would convict based on this conduct alone, I\n\n12\n\nthink we're confident that the Court's jury instructions will\n\n13\n\nexplain to the jury what the elements of the charges in the\n\n14\n\nindictment are and what they aren't.\n\n15\n\ncase in many trials that there's evidence of lawful conduct\n\n16\n\nthat is nonetheless offered as direct evidence of the charged\n\n17\n\ncrimes.\n\n18\n\nrobbery and there were evidence that on the morning of the\n\n19\n\nrobbery the defendant bought a ski mask, that would be lawful\n\n20\n\nconduct but nonetheless offered as direct evidence of the\n\n21\n\ncrimes charged, and it would be peculiar to either exclude that\n\n22\n\nevidence or introduce it with a limiting instruction that that\n\n23\n\nis lawful conduct to suggest that in some way the Court\n\n24\n\nendorses that conduct.\n\n25\n\nAnd it's certainly the\n\nFor example, if this were a case involving a Hobbs Act\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThe hypo is interesting.\n\nIf the ski mask\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834973\n\n", "char_count": 1670}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 84, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 85 of 127\n\n85\n\nLB1TMAX3\nis bought that day, it's direct evidence, if it's bought three\nyears earlier or three years later, at best it's 404(b)\nevidence, not direct evidence.\n4\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nWell, here the pattern would be much\n\n5\n\nstronger, that the defendant participated -- again, to play out\n\n6\n\nthe analogy -- in a robbery in 1994 involving ski masks, and\n\n7\n\nanother robbery in 1995 involving ski masks, and again another\n\n8\n\nrobbery in which the defendant bought ski masks, and then a\n\n9\n\nrobbery years later in which the perpetrator was wearing a very\n\n10\n\nsimilar ski mask.\n\n11\n\ndirect evidence of the defendant's methods and her knowledge\n\n12\n\nand intent.\n\nThat's the pattern here and why this is\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n14\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nThat's 404(b), evidence of methods, of MO.\n\nHere, your Honor, the government certainly\n\n15\n\nsubmits that this would otherwise be admissible under Rule\n\n16\n\n404(b), but here where the conduct is intertwined with the\n\n17\n\nconduct on trial, that it speaks to her knowledge about\n\n18\n\npreferences and the role that she played and the similarity,\n\n19\n\nand the fact this happened during the course of the charged\n\n20\n\nconspiracy the same time the defendant was involved in this\n\n21\n\nconduct with respect to other --\n\n22\n23\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nDuring the time of the\n\nAct charged\n\nconspiracy.\n\n24\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat's correct, your Honor.\nNot the trafficking charged conspiracy.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834974\n\n", "char_count": 1536}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 85, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 86 of 127\n\n86\n\nLB1TMAX3\nMS. MOE:\n\nThat's correct, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo I need to get something in writing on\n\nthe trafficking count, because you haven't raised it directly\n4\n\nbefore and the defense hasn't had an opportunity to respond to\n\n5\n\nit before.\n\n6\n\nWith respect to how this has been argued, I don't\n\n7\n\nthink there's a basis to exclude entirely, but let me tell you\n\n8\n\nmy thinking and I will hear a reaction to it.\n\n9\n\nThe evidence related to alleged Victim-3, as the\n\n10\n\ngovernment describes her, is not direct evidence of the\n\n11\n\nconspiracy charged in Counts One and Three of the indictment.\n\n12\n\nCounts One and Three charge the defendant with conspiracy to\n\n13\n\nentice minors to travel to engage in illegal sex acts and\n\n14\n\nconspiracy to transport minors with intent to engage in\n\n15\n\ncriminal sexual activity.\n\n16\n\nThe parties agree that alleged Victim-3 was 17 at the\n\n17\n\ntime she was acquainted with the defendant and Epstein in\n\n18\n\nLondon, England where the age of consent is 16.\n\n19\n\ncan't recall, and the government wouldn't be able to establish\n\n20\n\nthat she was invited to travel with the defendant when she was\n\n21\n\n17 or 18.\n\n22\n\nconsent in all relevant jurisdictions and, therefore, any\n\n23\n\nalleged sexual activity was lawful, the alleged conduct does\n\n24\n\nnot arise out of the same transactions or series of\n\n25\n\ntransactions as the charged offense.\n\nMoreover, she\n\nAnd because the alleged victim was over the age of\n\nIt's not inextricably\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834975\n\n", "char_count": 1601}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 86, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 87 of 127\n\n87\n\nLB1TMAX3\nintertwined with the evidence, again with respect to the\nAct, and it's not necessary to complete the story of the crime\non trial, so I don't think it can be direct evidence of the\n4\n5\n\nAct counts.\nThere's a prejudice analysis that I will get to in a\n\n6\n\nmoment, but as proffered, it strikes me the testimony may serve\n\n7\n\na proper purpose under 404(b) as relevant testimony of the\n\n8\n\ndefendant's knowledge, intent and alleged MO.\n\n9\n\nproffered testimony could tend to establish that the defendant\n\n10\n\nwas aware of, for example, the sexualized nature of the alleged\n\n11\n\nmassages.\n\n12\n\nthere's no knowledge, this witness might have evidence and\n\n13\n\ntestimony that could refute that point.\n\n14\n\nsupport that the defendant asked the witness to recruit\n\n15\n\nunderage girls to engage in similar sexualized massages which\n\n16\n\ntends to make the alleged MO more probable.\n\n17\n\nFor example, the\n\nSo if the argument is massages are not sexual or\n\nThe testimony could\n\nThe testimony that this witness was allegedly groomed\n\n18\n\nby the defendant does not tend to establish the defendant's\n\n19\n\nknowledge, intent or MO to groom minor victims alone without\n\n20\n\nmore, the kind of testimony I indicated, because this witness\n\n21\n\nwas not a minor pursuant to the age of consent laws in any of\n\n22\n\nthe relevant jurisdictions.\n\n23\n\nI will say I think there may be room for 404(b)\n\n24\n\ntestimony, but there's a risk of a prejudice, the risk of\n\n25\n\nconfusing issues and misleading the jury.\n\nA limiting\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834976\n\n", "char_count": 1637}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 87, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 88 of 127\n\n88\n\nLB1TMAX3\ninstruction that makes clear that any alleged conduct was\nlawful and cannot form the basis of a conviction in this case\ncertainly would be required to ensure that probative value is\n4\n5\n\nnot substantially outweighed by potential prejudice.\nSo that's my thinking.\n\nI'm going to need more from\n\n6\n\nthe government on the anticipated testimony.\n\n7\n\nproposed limiting instruction that would go to that, and I want\n\n8\n\nbriefing on whether there might be a basis for direct evidence\n\n9\n\nas to the trafficking count.\n\n10\n\nI want to see a\n\nSo I will ask the government here for a submission\n\n11\n\nthat outlines anticipated testimony that would be potentially\n\n12\n\n404(b) with respect to the\n\n13\n\na proposed limiting instruction in that regard, and to the\n\n14\n\nextent the government does have I think a not-yet-really-\n\n15\n\nthought-through argument about direct evidence as to the\n\n16\n\ntrafficking act, I'm open to hearing it.\n\n17\n\nSo let me look at the calendar.\n\nAct counts, as I've indicated,\n\nI will get briefing\n\n18\n\nfrom the government and then a response time from the defense.\n\n19\n\nGovernment by the 5th, defense response by the 10th.\n\n20\n\nQuestions about that, Ms. Moe?\n\n21\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n23\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nNo, your Honor, thank you.\nMr. Everdell?\nNo questions on this schedule or the\n\n24\n\nCourt's direction.\n\nWe would like to clarify one thing, which I\n\n25\n\nbelieve the Court said that the parties agree that this\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834977\n\n", "char_count": 1574}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 88, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 89 of 127\n\n89\n\nLB1TMAX3\nparticular individual was 17.\nshe was 17.\n\nWe agree that she alleges that\n\nIt's quite possible, in fact likely, that she was\n\nolder than that, but I wanted to clarify that.\n4\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\nagree.\n\nFair enough.\n\nAt least 17, the parties\n\nThank you.\n\n6\n\nAnd I should say on that, Ms. Moe, I don't know if the\n\n7\n\ngovernment anticipated putting in evidence about the sort of\n\n8\n\nsubjective feelings of the individual.\n\n9\n\nrelevance in light of the fact of the legality of the conduct\n\n10\n\nhere and my ruling, and certainly 403 prejudice would be a\n\n11\n\nconcern.\n\n12\n\ncontemplating, despite what I've indicated here, you'll have to\n\n13\n\ninclude briefing with respect to that.\n\n14\n\nI can't say I see the\n\nSo if that is something that the government is still\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nMy point was simply I\n\n15\n\nthink it would be obvious based on the way that she presents\n\n16\n\nthat this is a difficult thing to discuss, and so that was my\n\n17\n\npoint on that issue.\n\n18\n\nintending to elicit any testimony about that, we would\n\n19\n\ncertainly find that for the Court, particularly in light of the\n\n20\n\nCourt's ruling.\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nBut I take the Court's point, if we were\n\nYou see the potential, given the legality\n\n22\n\nof the conduct with respect to this individual, that the sort\n\n23\n\nof feelings as to the immorality or wrongness or damage done to\n\n24\n\nthis individual, all of which may be true, would have the\n\n25\n\npotential to prejudice the jury by convicting on a basis for\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834978\n\n", "char_count": 1627}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 89, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 90 of 127\n\n90\n\nLB1TMAX3\nwhich conviction the government has conceded would be\ninappropriate, would be unlawful.\nMS. MOE:\n\nI understand the Court's concern and we\n\n4\n\ncertainly don't anticipate eliciting testimony about the\n\n5\n\nvictim's conclusions about the event or suggesting that it was\n\n6\n\nunlawful or satisfied certain elements.\n\n7\n\ndescribing it, which would be difficult for Minor Victim-3,\n\n8\n\nthat sort of her feelings about that or the circumstances that\n\n9\n\nthat -- in narrating the facts of the event would I think come\n\n10\n\nto light at trial, but we certainly don't intend to elicit\n\n11\n\ntestimony about conclusions, about things like consent or\n\n12\n\nwhether it was lawful, and particularly in light of the Court's\n\n13\n\nruling, and in any event, we wouldn't be seeking to proffer\n\n14\n\nlegal conclusions from a witness.\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\n16\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n17\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n18\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nMy point was simply in\n\nAnything further on that, counsel?\n\nNot from the government, your Honor.\nNo, your Honor, thank you.\n\nDefendant's 5 I think we determined is a\n\n19\n\nnon-issue.\n\n20\n\nconcerned in the government presenting regarding flight, and\n\n21\n\nthe government has represented that it will not offer evidence\n\n22\n\nas to flight.\n\nThis goes to evidence that the defense was\n\nIs that correct, Ms. Moe?\n\n23\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n25\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nAnything else we need to address here?\nNo, your Honor.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834979\n\n", "char_count": 1558}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 90, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 91 of 127\n\n91\n\nLB1TMAX3\nTHE COURT:\n\nDefendant's 6 is evidence of the\n\ndefendant's alleged false statements and regarding redacting\nallegations related to the perjury counts in the indictment,\n4\n\nwhich I severed.\n\nThe government has agreed not to introduce\n\n5\n\nevidence of these alleged false statements and agrees to the\n\n6\n\nproposed redaction.\n\n7\n\nAnything else that we need to address here, Ms. Moe?\n\n8\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n9\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n11\n\nDefendant's 7 is Exhibit 52, which I think we have\n\n12\n\naddressed.\n\n13\n\npoint?\nMS. MOE:\n\n15\n\nHonor, thank you.\n\n17\n\nNo, your Honor, thank you.\n\nThank you.\n\nDo we need to discuss that any further at this\n\n14\n\n16\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\nNothing further from the government, your\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nYour Honor, I think we do need to\n\ndiscuss this a little bit further.\n\n18\n\nThe problem that we have on the defense side of this\n\n19\n\nis that the government says that we can establish a foundation\n\n20\n\nfor this, but I'm quite frankly very skeptical about the\n\n21\n\nprovenance of that foundation.\n\n22\n\nThis is an exhibit that surfaces in 2009, and we don't\n\n23\n\nknow how it surfaced.\n\nAssuming it was stolen by now deceased,\n\n24\n\ntwice convicted felon Alfredo Rodriguez and sold to the\n\n25\n\ngovernment, assume that for a moment, we don't know where it\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834980\n\n", "char_count": 1414}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 91, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 92 of 127\n\n92\n\nLB1TMAX3\ncame from or how it was created.\nThe government says that it has a witness that is\ngoing to say that that was Ms. Maxwell's book.\n\nI'm highly\n\n4\n\nsuspect of that to begin with.\n\n5\n\nwasn't around in 2004.\n\n6\n\nthis purported foundation, both of whom were not employed\n\n7\n\nduring the relevant timeframe of the conspiracy.\n\n8\n\nloss, frankly, to understand how anyone could either\n\n9\n\nauthenticate that document or admit it as some non-hearsay\n\n10\n\ndocument.\n\nAnd secondarily, that witness\n\nAnd so we have now two witnesses for\n\nSo I'm at a\n\n11\n\nThe government says well, even if it's not admissible,\n\n12\n\nthen they will say as a business record -- the government says\n\n13\n\nwe'll admit it for some other purpose, which I don't know what\n\n14\n\nthat is.\n\n15\n\ndon't understand the relevance of this, given the inability to\n\n16\n\nestablish a foundation and to tie it with any alleged conduct\n\n17\n\nthat is part of the indictment in this case.\n\n18\n\nAnd if they're admitting it for another purpose, I\n\nSo I don't think we can just leave this here and then\n\n19\n\nhave a discussion about this in the middle of trial.\n\n20\n\nseems to me that in this type of hearing, a pretrial hearing,\n\n21\n\nthe government should say here's the witness that is going to\n\n22\n\nauthenticate it, here's how they're going to authenticate it,\n\n23\n\nthat is what we're authenticating it for, here are the pages\n\n24\n\nthat we think are relevant and here's why.\n\n25\n\nWe don't have anything of that information.\n\nAnd it\n\nWe are\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834981\n\n", "char_count": 1628}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 92, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 93 of 127\n\n93\n\nLB1TMAX3\nleft with:\n\nYeah, we think we can admit this.\n\nGiven this lack\n\nof evidentiary foundation, I think we should address this issue\nnow.\n4\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n5\n\nWith respect to the particulars in the exhibit, the\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\n6\n\ngovernment has marked and produced to the defense excerpts from\n\n7\n\nthat book that it intends to offer at trial.\n\n8\n\nknows the limited number of pages from that book that the\n\n9\n\ngovernment intends to offer at trial.\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n11\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nSo the defense\n\nWhat pages?\n\nYour Honor, I don't have the exhibit numbers\n\n12\n\nin front of me, but they're included in the subset that we\n\n13\n\nprovided to the Court.\n\n14\n\nto guess, but somewhere between four and six particular pages,\n\n15\n\none in particular relating to victims in this case.\n\n16\n\nhappy to confer with the defense about those particular\n\n17\n\nexhibits and then raise those issues to the Court if there is\n\n18\n\nstill confusion on that score.\n\n19\n\nI think there are about -- I don't want\n\nSo we are\n\nWith respect to the question of authentication, I\n\n20\n\nthink the defense's argument confuses the question of chain of\n\n21\n\ncustody with the question of authentication.\n\n22\n\nCircuit has rejected essentially exactly the argument that the\n\n23\n\ndefense is advancing here.\n\n24\n\nStates v. Al Farekh, 810 F.App'x 21, (2d Cir. 2020), the\n\n25\n\ndefense argued the government shouldn't be able to offer\n\nI know the Second\n\nFor example, in a case of United\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834982\n\n", "char_count": 1582}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 93, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 94 of 127\n\n94\n\nLB1TMAX3\ncertain documents that were obtained by an FBI agent on a USB\ndrive, and the authentication testimony was about the\nfamiliarity with the witnesses with things like handwriting on\n4\n\nthe documents, their structure and the like.\n\n5\n\ntrue here.\n\nThe same will be\n\n6\n\nAnd in that case, the Second Circuit said although the\n\n7\n\ngovernment did not present evidence regarding the circumstances\n\n8\n\nsurrounding the seizure of the USB drive, Federal Rule of\n\n9\n\nEvidence 901(b)(4) permits authentication based on the\n\n10\n\nappearance, contents, substance, internal patterns or other\n\n11\n\ndistinctive characteristics of the items taken together with\n\n12\n\nall the circumstances.\n\n13\n\ntestimony at trial will satisfy all of the aspects of Rule 901\n\n14\n\nAnd the government submits that the\n\nWe're happy to submit additional briefing on this\n\n15\n\nduring the trial, but in particular, given we don't intend to\n\n16\n\noffer any evidence from this book in our opening statement\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nWhat is it going to be offered for?\n\nYour Honor, the evidence from that book will\n\n19\n\nbe offered in particular related to the minor victims in this\n\n20\n\ncase, so that's the relevance of those documents.\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n22\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nBut why?\nIt would be a page of that book that\n\n23\n\ncontains contact information for several victims, including\n\n24\n\ntheir names, in a section marked \"Massage\" that includes the\n\n25\n\nnames of -- I think it's exclusively female girls with\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834983\n\n", "char_count": 1609}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 94, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 95 of 127\n\n95\n\nLB1TMAX3\nparentheticals like \"Mom\" or \"Parents,\" showing that the\ncontact number for the individuals in a section marked\n\"Massage\" is for people's parents.\n\nThat list includes some of\n\n4\n\nthe minor victims in this case that the jury will learn about\n\n5\n\nin this trial.\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nIt's not going to be talked about in\n\n7\n\nopenings, but before in front of the jury this full\n\n8\n\nauthentication process happens, I would like the government to\n\n9\n\nput out specifically what it intends to enter into evidence\n\n10\n\nwith respect to this, and with specificity, who will provide\n\n11\n\nauthentication and the proffer as to that testimony.\n\n12\n\nwill deal with the timeframe questions that have been raised as\n\n13\n\nwell.\n\n14\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd you\n\nCertainly, your Honor.\nI need to see a little bit more than\n\n16\n\nwhat's been suggested, and I need to have a better\n\n17\n\nunderstanding of what is potentially being offered for.\n\n18\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n20\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n22\n\n(Pause)\n\n23\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n24\n25\n\nUnderstood, your Honor, certainly.\nSo when would you like to do that?\n\nYour Honor, may I confer with my colleagues?\nSure.\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\nCould we possibly\n\nsubmit it on November 10, along with other briefing that date?\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat's fine.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834984\n\n", "char_count": 1418}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 95, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 96 of 127\n\n96\n\nLB1TMAX3\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\nTHE COURT:\n\nRespond in the same timeframe.\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n4\n\nThat's fine, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nUnderstood.\n\nDefendant's 8 is the search, the El Brillo\n\n5\n\nWay search.\n\n6\n\nof any items seized during an October 2000 search of Jeffrey\n\n7\n\nEpstein's Palm Beach residence.\n\n8\n\nThe defendant seeks to prohibit the introduction\n\nThe defense raises concerns, including how and where\n\n9\n\nthe evidence was maintained, the lack of authenticating\n\n10\n\nwitnesses and the lack of relevance to the charges against\n\n11\n\nMs. Maxwell.\n\n12\n\nintends to call witnesses to establish the authenticity of the\n\n13\n\nevidence.\n\nHere, again, the government states that it\n\n14\n\nSo how do we take this up now, Ms. Moe?\n\n15\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nThe government submits\n\n16\n\nthat at trial law enforcement witnesses will discuss the search\n\n17\n\nand lay a foundation for the admission of this evidence.\n\n18\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo as to authentication, you have\n\nwitnesses that did exactly what with respect to the search?\n\n20\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nThey were personally involved in the search.\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\nSo they will describe the process\n\n22\n\nby which they engaged in the search and the evidence that they\n\n23\n\nobtained and how it was maintained and the like.\n\n24\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes, your Honor.\nAnd the relevance of the search result\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834985\n\n", "char_count": 1484}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 96, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 97 of 127\n\n97\n\nLB1TMAX3\nevidence is what?\nMS. MOE:\n\nYour Honor, a number of exhibits were seized\n\nfrom that residence and there are a number of marked\n4\n\nphotographs from the interior of that residence which are\n\n5\n\nrelevant both to give context to the jury about what the\n\n6\n\ninterior looked like but in particular about certain\n\n7\n\ndecorations in the residence that are both consistent with what\n\n8\n\nwitnesses will describe but also illustrate for the jury the\n\n9\n\nnumber of, for example, nude images in the house and otherwise\n\n10\n\nthat give context to sort of the knowledge that certain people\n\n11\n\nwould have while inside the house.\n\n12\n\ncorroborative of witness testimony and, for the same reasons,\n\n13\n\ncertain items seized from the residence will be as well.\n\n14\n\nexample, a massage table was seized from that residence and is\n\n15\n\nmarked as a government exhibit.\n\n16\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\n17\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nI think all that will be\n\nFor\n\nWho is taking this one?\n\nThis would be me, your Honor.\n\nAgain,\n\n18\n\nthis is very, I suppose, aspirational by the government that\n\n19\n\nthey can lay these foundations.\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThis sounds like pretty standard stuff.\n\n21\n\nLaw enforcement had a search warrant, engaged in a search, this\n\n22\n\nis what they found, here's how they marked it, here it is.\n\n23\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nThe affiant who conducted the search\n\n24\n\nand who took the items into evidence is deceased.\n\n25\n\nbelieve, two officers who participated in the search, but in a\n\nThere are, I\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834986\n\n", "char_count": 1620}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 97, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 98 of 127\n\n98\n\nLB1TMAX3\ndiscrete fashion, and I believe they do not have knowledge\nabout what the other officers did or didn't do as part of that\nsearch.\n\nSo what we end up with is this piecemeal approach of:\n\n4\n\nI was over here and did this, somebody over there did that, but\n\n5\n\nI can't put it all together for you 20 years after the fact.\n\n6\n\nAnd look, I understand if they have a witness who\n\n7\n\ncould say I was there, I saw this, I can authenticate, that's\n\n8\n\nfine.\n\n9\n\nhaven't identified that witness or what pieces of this that\n\n10\n\nwitness is going to talk about.\n\n11\n\nI don't have a problem with that.\n\nBut again, they\n\nSo that's problem number one.\n\nProblem number two is the timing of this.\n\nThis is an\n\n12\n\nOctober 2005 search where they seized items that they're trying\n\n13\n\nto now relate back to a 1994 to 2004 timeframe.\n\n14\n\ntable has to do with 1994, I don't know.\n\n15\n\nWhether it was there in 2004, we don't know.\n\n16\n\nthat in a moment in time, in October 2005, someone says these\n\n17\n\nitems were seized and that ends up on a search warrant\n\n18\n\ninventory from a deceased detective that doesn't have any\n\n19\n\nfoundation to it.\n\nWhat that\n\n2004, I don't know.\nAll we know is\n\nThat's my problem, your Honor.\n\n20\n\nAnd there may be discrete pieces of evidence that a\n\n21\n\ncertain witness might be able to identify, but I think we're\n\n22\n\njust short shrifting the whole evidentiary process here with\n\n23\n\nthese proffers where they're saying we can do it, and I'm not\n\n24\n\nconvinced they can.\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWe're not short shrifting because it\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834987\n\n", "char_count": 1684}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 98, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 99 of 127\n\n99\n\nLB1TMAX3\nhasn't happened yet.\n\nWhat you're making are cross points.\n\nMs. Moe, obviously you're dealing with a time\nquestion, and it sounds like one of the primary investigators\n4\n\nor law enforcement who engaged in the search is deceased.\n\n5\n\nwhat's the proffer to the Court as to what specifically the\n\n6\n\ngovernment will do to authenticate these items?\n\n7\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nSo\n\nOn this score, I would\n\n8\n\nnote there is a difference, certainly, between authentication\n\n9\n\nand chain of custody.\n\n10\n\nenforcement witnesses who personally participated in the search\n\n11\n\nwill describe what they observed in the search and how they --\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWith respect to authentication, law\n\nThe government's proffer to the Court is\n\n13\n\nthat even though one of the law enforcement relevant here is\n\n14\n\ndeceased, that you have other law enforcement who have personal\n\n15\n\nknowledge of these items being found where they were and seized\n\n16\n\nwhen they were, et cetera?\n\n17\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nI additionally note that\n\n18\n\nthe search was video recorded, that video has been produced to\n\n19\n\nthe defense, and so some of these items also appear on the\n\n20\n\nvideo walk through of that search.\n\n21\n\ntheir direct testimony about their experiences in the search\n\n22\n\nsatisfies our obligations with respect to authenticity.\n\n23\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd so our view is that\n\nI'm not going to prohibit this in limine,\n\n24\n\nbut questions remain as to the government's ability to\n\n25\n\nauthenticate the items, and there will be an opportunity for\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834988\n\n", "char_count": 1679}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 99, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 100 of 127\n\n100\n\nLB1TMAX3\nthe defense to engage in the full set of questions that counsel\nhas indicated, but for purposes of the in limine motion, it's\ndenied.\n4\n\nDefense 19.\n\nHere, the defense seeks to suppress\n\n5\n\nalleged Victim-4's identification of Ms. Maxwell on the ground\n\n6\n\nthat the government used unduly suggestive photo array\n\n7\n\nprocedures that violate due process rights.\n\n8\n\nI am prepared to deny this motion.\n\nEyewitness\n\n9\n\nidentifications should be excluded when improper police conduct\n\n10\n\ncreated a substantial likelihood of misidentification.\n\n11\n\nv. New Hampshire, 565 U.S. 228, (2012).\n\n12\n\nI follow a two-step analysis in ruling on the\n\n13\n\nadmissibility of identification evidence.\n\n14\n\ndetermine whether the pretrial identification procedures were\n\n15\n\nunduly suggestive.\n\n16\n\ninclude using a very small number of photographs, making\n\n17\n\nsuggestive comments, or the display of the accused in a way\n\n18\n\nthat so stood out from all other photographs to suggest to an\n\n19\n\nidentifying eyewitness that the person was more likely to be\n\n20\n\nthe culprit.\n\n21\n\n(2d Cir. 1992).\n\n22\n\nFirst, I must\n\nSome examples of suggestive procedures\n\nSee, United States v.\n\n983 F.2d 369,\n\nLooking at the photo array, neither the photos used or\n\n23\n\nthe procedure itself was unduly suggestive.\n\nThe array\n\n24\n\ncontained a sufficient number of photos larger than many arrays\n\n25\n\nthat courts have held were not unduly suggestive.\n\nDefense's\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834989\n\n", "char_count": 1570}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 100, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 101 of 127\n\n101\n\nLB1TMAX3\nargument that the Ms. Maxwell's photo looks like a mugshot and\nis different from the others doesn't persuade me here.\n\nAlleged\n\nVictim-4 identified at least one other photo in the array that\n4\n\nshe thought could be Ms. Maxwell but she ultimately chose\n\n5\n\nMs. Maxwell's photo, and there were several photos in the array\n\n6\n\nthat were of roughly the same quality and angle as\n\n7\n\nMs. Maxwell's photo.\n\n8\n\nThe defense fails to identify any suggestive comments\n\n9\n\nmade during the identification that would deem the procedures\n\n10\n\nunduly suggestive.\n\n11\n\nwhether the individual recognized anyone in the book.\n\n12\n\nconclude the identification procedure was not unduly\n\n13\n\nsuggestive.\n\nThe government appears to have asked\nSo I\n\n14\n\nEven assuming the photo array was unduly suggestive,\n\n15\n\nthe identification here had independent reliability factors I\n\n16\n\nmust consider under the totality of circumstances that include\n\n17\n\nthe opportunity of the witness to view the individual at the\n\n18\n\ntime of the alleged crime, the witness's degree of attention,\n\n19\n\nthe accuracy of the the witness's prior description of the\n\n20\n\nindividual, the level of uncertainty demonstrated, the length\n\n21\n\nof time between the alleged crime and the confrontation.\n\n22\n\nNeil v. Biggers, 409 U.S. 188, (1972).\n\n23\n\nSee,\n\nHere, the alleged Victim-4 had the opportunity to view\n\n24\n\nMs. Maxwell.\n\n25\n\nyears.\n\nThey interacted several times over the span of\n\nAs the government points out, the alleged interactions\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834990\n\n", "char_count": 1638}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 101, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 102 of 127\n\n102\n\nLB1TMAX3\nwith Ms. Maxwell make the alleged victim's identification more\naccurate than other instances where identification has been\ndeemed admissible, like when a witness saw the defendant in the\n4\n\ndistance under street-lit illumination and was familiar with\n\n5\n\nthe individual seeing them in the neighborhood.\n\n6\n\n(Continued on next page)\n\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834991\n\n", "char_count": 537}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 102, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 103 of 127\n\n103\n\nLB15max4\nTHE COURT:\n\n(Continuing)\n\nThe government also correctly notes that the delay in\ntime between the alleged misconduct and identification is not\n4\n\ndeterminative because of the frequency of interactions between\n\n5\n\nthe alleged individual and Ms. Maxwell.\n\n6\n\nable to identify Ms. Maxwell when she got to the photo in the\n\n7\n\narray with little hesitation.\n\n8\n\nleave it at that.\n\n9\n\nAlleged Victim 4 was\n\nThe argument that\n\nI will\n\nThe defense requested an evidentiary hearing on this\n\n10\n\nissue but I don't see facts put forward by the defense that\n\n11\n\nputs, in genuine dispute, any facts that would support\n\n12\n\nsuppression of the identification so there would be nothing\n\n13\n\ngained from an evidentiary rehearing, see United States v.\n\n14\n15\n\n, 784 F. App'x 1 (2d Cir. 2019) so the request is denied.\nDefense 10.\n\nExpert testimony by law enforcement\n\n16\n\nofficers which the defense moves to exclude and the government\n\n17\n\nhas noticed intent to call three law enforcement officers as\n\n18\n\nfact witnesses but not as experts.\n\n19\n\nthat it will not elicit expert testimony from any of them.\n\nThe government represents\n\n20\n\nSo, the law enforcement officers can testify as fact\n\n21\n\nwitnesses to the facts that they personally perceived but not\n\n22\n\nprovide testimony that summarizes parts of the investigation\n\n23\n\nwhich the officer did not personally experience and may not\n\n24\n\nprovide testimony that relies on specialized training and\n\n25\n\nexperience.\n\nThe government's example of a law enforcement\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834992\n\n", "char_count": 1647}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 103, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 104 of 127\n\n104\n\nLB15max4\nofficer testifying as to what the officer himself found and\nparticipated in while executing a search seems to me\npermissible fact testimony.\n4\n5\n\nAnything to take up here from the defense,\nMs. Menninger?\n\n6\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n8\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\nThank you.\n\nMs. Moe?\nNo, your Honor.\n\nThank you.\n\nDefense 11 is anticipated testimony\n\n10\n\nregarding an alleged rape by Jeffrey Epstein.\n\nLet me ask the\n\n11\n\ngovernment to explain what it intends to do with respect to\n\n12\n\nthis and for what purpose the testimony would be sought to be\n\n13\n\nintroduced.\n\n14\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nCertainly, your Honor.\n\n15\n\nAs a threshold matter, your Honor, I would note that\n\n16\n\nthere is an overlap here between the arguments in the\n\n17\n\ndefendant's motion in limine and the 412 motion.\n\n18\n\nmotion seeks to introduce some of this evidence but\n\n19\n\ncharacterize it as consensual and the other motion seeks to\n\n20\n\npreclude it, reference it to be non-consensual.\n\n21\n\nwould be happy to address that now, but it may be easier to\n\n22\n\naddress that issue in the context of the 412 briefing.\n\n23\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n24\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n25\n\nI think one\n\nAnd so, I\n\nCounsel, do you agree?\nYour Honor, we can wait until the 412\n\nbriefing.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834993\n\n", "char_count": 1381}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 104, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 105 of 127\n\n105\n\nLB15max4\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo to the extent there is overlap in these\n\nissues, it's best to take it up in the 412 proceeding so that\nwe can discuss the issues without violating that rule.\n4\n\nDefendant's 13.\n\nThis is a motion to preclude the\n\n5\n\nadmission of several exhibits.\n\nI'm going to grant the motion\n\n6\n\nwith respect to Exhibit 251 and 288.\n\n7\n\nbefore me, 401 relevance is minimal, at best, and outweighed by\n\n8\n\n403 prejudice.\n\n9\n\nauthentication issue so I think that ruling holds.\n\n10\n\notherwise preclude this evidence.\n\n11\n\ncorroborative evidence of testimony and 403 prejudice does not\n\n12\n\nrule out 401 but the defense can maintain the search and\n\n13\n\nauthentication issues that we have discussed.\n\nBased on the briefing\n\n294, so some of the same questions around the\nI won't\n\nIt is potentially\n\n14\n\nExhibit 403 I won't preclude, it's potentially\n\n15\n\nprobative of the relationship between the defendant and\n\n16\n\nMr. Epstein.\n\n17\n\nand that the photo would corroborate anticipated witness\n\n18\n\ntestimony and I don't -- so, there is 401 relevance and not\n\n19\n\nsubstantially outweighed by any 403 prejudice.\n\n20\n\nThe government proffers that it will corroborate\n\nOn this last one I may have said the wrong number.\n\nI\n\n21\n\nhad 403 on mine.\n\n22\n\nindicated I am not excluding, it is potentially probative of\n\n23\n\nthe relationship between the defendant and Mr. Epstein and not\n\n24\n\noutweighed by prejudice.\n\n25\n\nSo, Exhibit 313 is the photograph that I have\n\nAnd then 606, this is the issue on authentication and\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834994\n\n", "char_count": 1653}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 105, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 106 of 127\n\n106\n\nLB15max4\nhearsay grounds that I have already indicated I'm going to have\nthe parties address further, correct?\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n5\n\nAny questions about any of those rulings?\n\n6\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n7\n\nAll right.\n\nNot from the government, your Honor.\n\nThank\n\nyou.\n\n8\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\nThank you.\n\nAnd about the time frames I have set on\n\n10\n\nthe different pieces that I require briefing on after everybody\n\n11\n\nhas.\n\nAnd, you will get the transcript.\n\n12\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n14\n\nWith that, I think we can pick up some outstanding\n\nUnderstood, your Honor.\n\nThank you.\n\nAll right.\n\n15\n\nlogistics issues and I will hear from counsel as to any issues\n\n16\n\nthey want to raise.\n\n17\n\nSo, we begin our questionnaire process on Thursday.\n\n18\n\nThe government -- my\n\nwill produce the copies as an\n\n19\n\noriginal matter.\n\n20\n\nfrom the jury department -- the completed questionnaires with\n\n21\n\nno identifying information and make copies for the defense and\n\n22\n\nfor the Court.\n\n23\n\nelectronic copy.\n\n24\n\ndocument since we have got multiple people looking at them, and\n\n25\n\nthen of course return the originals to the Court.\n\nThe government will take the completed copies\n\nMy request is to give both a paper copy and an\nI think that will aid everybody's use of the\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834995\n\n", "char_count": 1446}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 106, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 107 of 127\n\n107\n\nLB15max4\nAny questions from the government on its obligations\nthere?\nMS. MOE:\n4\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThank you.\n\nThe video remarks, at our last conference,\n\n5\n\nas we discussed, my plan is to video record the preliminary\n\n6\n\ninstructions to be played for each panel before the\n\n7\n\nquestionnaire.\n\n8\n\nobjections.\n\n9\n\njust want, does either party request to see the video before\n\n10\n\nit's played for the prospective jurors on Thursday?\n\n11\n\nI'm going to record it exactly as stated in the script.\n\nI sent the parties my script and there were no\n\nI'm actually going to record that tomorrow.\n\n12\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n13\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nI\n\nObviously\n\nNo, your Honor.\nJudge, unless you are wearing some\n\n14\n\nfunky t-shirt, no.\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n16\n\nJust in thinking ahead to the voir dire process, I\n\n17\n\nhave preliminary instructions that I'm drafting that I will\n\n18\n\ngive to each panel before they are individually brought in for\n\n19\n\nthe voir dire.\n\n20\n\npurposes, what I propose is we do another video of that so that\n\n21\n\nit is played for each panel -- there is a morning panel and\n\n22\n\nafternoon panel.\n\n23\n\ncomplicated.\n\n24\n\nscript, let me know if you have any comments or objections, and\n\n25\n\nonce we all agree I will record it so that the jury staff can\n\nIt's just a robe.\n\nThank you.\n\nThinking ahead again, just for time-saving\n\nAnd the logistics of all of this is\n\nSo, what I propose I will send out, again, my\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834996\n\n", "char_count": 1555}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 107, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 108 of 127\n\n108\n\nLB15max4\njust play it once each panel is assembled.\nAny concerns with that, Ms. Moe?\nMS. MOE:\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n5\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThank you.\n\nMs. Sternheim?\nNo.\n\nI think what I am also going to do, we\n\n7\n\nhaven't talked through the specifics of the logistics of the\n\n8\n\nvoir dire days -- I think I did generally -- but we are going\n\n9\n\nto have a morning panel, the jurors are going to come in to a\n\n10\n\ncourtroom which is sort of the holding courtroom.\n\n11\n\npreliminary instructions will be played and then we bring them\n\n12\n\nin one at a time.\n\n13\n\nsomewhere else so there is no overlap, they'll be played the\n\n14\n\ninstructions.\n\n15\n\nthey'll be brought in and the like.\n\n16\n\nThe\n\nThe afternoon panel is going to assemble\n\nOnce we are finished with the morning panel,\n\nWe will do the individual voir dire, obviously if\n\n17\n\nanyone is struck for cause following that they'll be excused.\n\n18\n\nThose who are not struck for cause, what I propose is that we\n\n19\n\ngive them an instruction sheet that tells them where and when\n\n20\n\nthey're returning for the final stage of the process and remind\n\n21\n\nthem the basic instructions about media restrictions and the\n\n22\n\nlike just so they have that and they take it with them.\n\n23\n\ncourse I would show you what I am thinking before we do it but\n\n24\n\nthat basic idea.\n\n25\n\nOf\n\nI want to see if anybody has any concerns or\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834997\n\n", "char_count": 1531}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 108, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 109 of 127\n\n109\n\nLB15max4\nobjections.\nMS. MOE:\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThank you.\n\nNo objection.\n\nI do think once we do that, the non-struck\n\n5\n\njurors, with that information, can then be excused for the day\n\n6\n\nand returning on -- and obviously I haven't indicated yet\n\n7\n\nthe 19th or the 29th, those instructions.\n\n8\n\nto sit around for the rest of the day while we do the other\n\n9\n\nindividuals.\n\nBut they don't need\n\n10\n\nAny objections to that process, Ms. Moe?\n\n11\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n13\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\n14\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nNo.\n\nThank you.\n\nMs. Sternheim?\nNo, thank you.\n\nThere are logistical issues we are dealing\n\n15\n\nwith for bringing the full panel back for the exercised\n\n16\n\nperemptories as well as setting up the courtroom with\n\n17\n\ndistancing issues which turns, to some extent, on the vaccine\n\n18\n\nstatus of the individuals because we have different spacing\n\n19\n\nrequirements under the current protocols for the vaccinated\n\n20\n\nversus unvaccinated.\n\n21\n\nthat question in voir dire and I rejected that because I don't\n\n22\n\nthink there is any proper basis for striking based on\n\n23\n\nvaccination status.\n\n24\n\nfacilitate the Court's logistical process which is complicated,\n\n25\n\nis that for our non-struck jurors, as we give them the\n\nNow, the parties have proposed that I ask\n\nBut what I would propose, in order to\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834998\n\n", "char_count": 1476}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 109, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-0O330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 110 of 127\n\n110\n\nLB15max4\ninstruction, they're handed a sheet of paper which says write\nyour juror number and check a box, vaccinated, not vaccinated,\nI don't want to say, and the Court gets that but not the\n4\n\nparties.\n\n5\n\nfigure out where we are going to put everybody for peremptories\n\n6\n\nand the like.\n\nAnd that way we can set up the courtroom, we can\n\n7\n\nMs. Moe?\n\n8\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n9\n\nThe government has no objection to that,\n\nyour Honor.\n\n10\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nNo objection.\n\nI do think we are going to do the\n\n12\n\nperemptories on the 29th, as I have indicated.\n\n13\n\nworking through the logistics.\n\n14\n\nthere are pros and cons to both, but I think that the safest\n\n15\n\ncourse for proceeding with a full jury is to bring them back on\n\n16\n\nthe 29th -- I will give you my final resolution as to that when\n\n17\n\nI have it -- but my thinking is we are in the courtroom, all of\n\n18\n\nus.\n\n19\n\nback are in two other courtrooms because we can't get them all\n\n20\n\nin one place, with a video, in which I ask some very\n\n21\n\npreliminary questions:\n\n22\n\nand has anybody had media exposure, etc.\n\n23\n\nanybody does raise their hands, we will have staff in each of\n\n24\n\nthose rooms who we can bring in one at a time to deal with.\n\n25\n\nAnd assuming not, or once we deal with that, that's our panel,\n\nWe are still\n\nThis piece helps.\n\nAs I said,\n\nThe panel, approximately 50 to 60 people who I will bring\n\nDoes anybody need to change any answers\nHands raised.\n\nIf\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02834999\n\n", "char_count": 1583}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 110, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 111 of 127\n\n111\n\nLB15max4\nthe parties exercise the peremptories by list, and we are done.\nSo, as I say, I am still working through the specific\nlogistics of that but that's my thinking as to how we will do\n4\n\nit.\n\n5\n\nAny reactions, Ms. Moe?\n\n6\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n8\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\nThank you.\n\nMs. Sternheim?\nYes.\n\nMy only reaction is are we going\n\n9\n\nto be able to see the jurors as they respond to the Court's\n\n10\n\nquestioning?\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo, I think what we can do is have staff\n\n12\n\nin each of the courtrooms, I will ask my question, anyone who\n\n13\n\nraises their hand will be brought in individually.\n\n14\n\nwould like to have someone in each of those rooms for the\n\n15\n\nhand-raising, that's fine with me.\n\n16\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nIf you\n\nOK.\n\nWe would be happy to do that.\nThank you.\n\nBut because there are other trials being\n\n20\n\nselected on the 29th we can't use the jury assembly room and,\n\n21\n\nin any event, it would slow us down.\n\n22\n\nway to go logistically but that's what it will entail for the\n\n23\n\nexercised peremptories.\n\n24\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo I think this is the\n\nThank you.\n\nOne of the obstacles to the jury selection\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02835000\n\n", "char_count": 1352}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 111, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-0O330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 112 of 127\n\n112\n\nLB15max4\nhere is length of trial and the timing of trial.\n\nI would like\n\nthe parties, in light of -- you have gotten some rulings,\nobviously not everything yet\n\nto think about whether what we\n\n4\n\ninclude in the questionnaire is still the six-week time frame\n\n5\n\nthat we have indicated.\n\n6\n\nany basis to suggest a lower estimate as the parties have\n\n7\n\ncontinued preparing their cases and in light of any rulings, I\n\n8\n\nwould certainly be open to hearing it if we could safely put a\n\n9\n\nshorter time frame in the questionnaire.\n\n10\n\ncan't.\n\n11\n\nin a letter by November 2nd, on ECF, indicating whether the\n\n12\n\nparties agree that there should be any different estimate to\n\n13\n\nthe trial length than what we have indicated in the current\n\n14\n\ndraft of the questionnaire.\n\n15\n\nthat but for jury selection purposes it won't help us if a few\n\n16\n\ndays later we decide that we could say four weeks instead of\n\n17\n\nsix weeks.\n\nSo you will let me know and I will ask the parties\n\n18\n\nto confer.\n\nYou don't need to put in specific reasons, just if\n\n19\n\nyou can put in a joint submission as to the parties' best\n\n20\n\noverall estimate of length of trial is to see if it can be\n\n21\n\nrealistically any shorter than what is in the questionnaire to\n\n22\n\nhelp facilitate jury selection.\n\n23\n24\n25\n\nAnd if it is, it is, but if there is\n\nAgain, maybe we\n\nSo I just ask you to think about it and confer and put\n\nThat's what I have.\nother issues.\n\nI recognize that may change after\n\nI will hear from counsel any\n\nMs. Moe?\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor; very briefly on two\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02835001\n\n", "char_count": 1690}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 112, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 113 of 127\n\n113\n\nLB15max4\nadministrative items.\nFirst, it is the practice in this district to place on\nthe record at a final pretrial conference the status of plea\n4\n5\n\ndiscussions and so I just wanted to place on the record -THE COURT:\n\nI guess I hadn't assumed this is our final\n\n6\n\npretrial conference and I do usually do that, but there is no\n\n7\n\npoint in not at least doing that now in case we don't get\n\n8\n\ntogether again, which seems unlikely.\n\n9\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nBut, go ahead.\n\nYes, your Honor; for that reason we wanted\n\n10\n\nto place on the record that the government has not issued any\n\n11\n\nplea offers to the defense and the defense has not requested\n\n12\n\nany plea offers from the government, and we would respectfully\n\n13\n\nrequest that the Court confer with the defendant that that is\n\n14\n\naccurate.\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n16\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n19\n\nOK.\n\nMs. Sternheim?\nDo you want to hear from me?\n\nI will hear from you first and then I will\n\nask Ms. Maxwell.\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nThat is correct.\n\nWe take the position\n\n20\n\nthat our client has not committed a crime so plea bargaining\n\n21\n\nwas not an issue.\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nMs. Maxwell, what Ms. Sternheim indicated\n\n23\n\nis accurate and correct?\n\n24\n\nTHE DEFENDANT:\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI have not committed any crime and --\n\nAnd what Ms. Sternheim indicated is\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02835002\n\n", "char_count": 1447}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 113, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 114 of 127\n\n114\n\nLB15max4\naccurate?\nTHE DEFENDANT:\nTHE COURT:\n\nII sorry.\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nAnything else on that, Ms. Moe?\n\n4\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n5\n\nJust with respect to the second administrative item,\n\n6\n\nthe government has received the Court's order related to the\n\n7\n\nDaubert hearing.\n\n8\n\nfocused on the question of grooming it would be helpful to\n\n9\n\nunderstand the scope of the hearing and, in particular, whether\n\n10\n\nthe Court would like the government to present evidence with\n\n11\n\nrespect to the full scope of the expert's findings and\n\n12\n\nconclusions that were addressed in the motions or whether the\n\n13\n\nhearing would be focused on the question of grooming.\n\n14\n15\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\nBecause the defense's Daubert briefing was\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI guess I think it goes to each of the\n\nproffered opinions being offered --\n\n16\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n-- in part because of overlap in those\n\n18\n\nissues.\n\n19\n\nthem out at this point.\n\n20\n21\n\nThank you.\n\nI don't know that it's obvious to me how to separate\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\nIt is very helpful\n\nto know in advance of the hearing.\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n23\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\n24\n\nThese, I guess you put them under the housekeeping\n\n25\n\nMs. Sternheim, anything on that?\nYes, Judge.\n\ncategory and I know tomorrow the government is to respond to a\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02835003\n\n", "char_count": 1448}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 114, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-0O33O-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 115 of 127\n\n115\n\nLB15max4\nletter that I raised concerning legal mail, but we still have\nthe issue that Ms. Maxwell has not received trial-related\ndiscovery that is imperative for her to review to consult with\n4\n\ncounsel.\n\nIt also has bearing on some of the issues --\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWhat hasn't been received?\n\n6\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nRecent disclosures that the government\n\n7\n\nhas made, she still has not received some of them.\n\n8\n\nsent by the government to the MDC.\n\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes.\n\nThey're\n\nBut, specifically, what are you\n\ntalking about?\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\n3500 material that we\n\ncounsel\n\nreceived electronically the other day.\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd by the other day what do you mean,\n\nMs. Sternheim?\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nIt was Monday, Judge.\n\nShe has still\n\n16\n\nnot received the production made by the government which I\n\n17\n\nbelieve they send via federal express.\n\n18\n19\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo, Ms. Moe, the government made a 3500\n\nproduction a week ago?\nMS. MOE:\n\nYour Honor, the government has been\n\n21\n\nsupplementing its 3500 productions on a rolling basis.\n\n22\n\nrecall the exact date but we have been supplementing them and\n\n23\n\nhave made productions last week.\n\n24\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI don't\n\nAnd do you know why -- the representation\n\nis a production made a week ago has not made its way to\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02835004\n\n", "char_count": 1425}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 115, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 116 of 127\n\n116\n\nLB15max4\nMs. Maxwell.\n\nDo you know anything about that?\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYour Honor if I could have one moment?\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSure.\n\n4\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n5\n\n(Counsel conferring)\n\n6\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nThank you.\n\nYour Honor, I don't have particular\n\n7\n\ninformation about the series of disclosures we made last week\n\n8\n\nand whether or not they've been processed by the MDC but we\n\n9\n\nwill certainly be conferring with the MDC in connection with a\n\n10\n\nresponse to the defense's letter on Friday.\n\n11\n\nis that, generally, that drives have been received by MDC,\n\n12\n\nprocessed through their warehouse, picked up by legal counsel\n\n13\n\nand produced to the defense in regular time frame.\n\n14\n\nspeak to any particular package that was mailed last week\n\n15\n\nbecause I am hearing about it now for the first time.\n\n16\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWell, OK.\n\nOur understanding\n\nI can't\n\nYou will include in your\n\n17\n\nletter -- I mean, I think at this point a week is too long.\n\n18\n\nthink the representation in the prior letter was one to two\n\n19\n\ndays for legal mail, maybe this is different because this is\n\n20\n\ndifferent?\n\n21\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nI don't believe so, your Honor.\n\nI\n\nPart of the\n\n22\n\nreason why I want to look into this and confer with my\n\n23\n\ncolleague is we are not quite sure whether the date was Monday\n\n24\n\nor Wednesday that we produced this material to the defense and\n\n25\n\nwe want to just double-check the mailing date to make sure we\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02835005\n\n", "char_count": 1540}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 116, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-0O330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 117 of 127\n\n117\n\nLB15max4\nhave all our facts straight about the exact timeline.\n\nSo I am\n\nhappy to address that in the letter.\nTHE COURT:\n4\n\nYes, do address that in the letter.\n\nIs there anything the government can do -- you know,\n\n5\n\nthere is going to be some time built in for the facilities\n\n6\n\nscreening process and it getting to the defendant.\n\n7\n\nthere are other individuals in the same situation pretrial,\n\n8\n\nheading into trial, and there are a lot of inmates, but -- so\n\n9\n\nyou will address what's happening on the institution side in\n\n10\n\nthe letter.\n\n11\n12\n\nObviously\n\nWhat can the government do to facilitate the process\ngoing forward?\n\n13\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYour Honor, we have been trying to produce\n\n14\n\nmaterials as quickly as possible.\n\n15\n\nmaterials promptly to the facility.\n\n16\n\nthe facility that, in particular, a disclosure for this\n\n17\n\ndefendant is in-bound to the facility so that legal counsel\n\n18\n\nknows about it and can keep an eye out for it which I think is\n\n19\n\nunusual but we are happy to continue to take that step in this\n\n20\n\ncase.\n\n21\n\nWe have been FedExing those\nWhen we do so, we notify\n\nMy understanding is that materials have been received\n\n22\n\nby the defendant at the facility.\n\nWe will continue to check on\n\n23\n\nthat issue.\n\n24\n\ngoing to be frequent but also small as we continue to meet with\n\n25\n\nwitnesses and produce small amounts of rolling materials.\n\nI would note that our rolling productions are\n\nI\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02835006\n\n", "char_count": 1564}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 117, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-0O330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 118 of 127\n\n118\n\nLB15max4\nthink the defense is well equipped to print those materials and\nmeet with the defendant in person about it as they have been\ndoing.\n\nThey can certainly discuss those documents in the video\n\n4\n\nconferences that they're having with the defendant.\n\nOur\n\n5\n\nunderstanding is that this defense team has a large amount of\n\n6\n\naccess to video conferencing sessions with this defendant and\n\n7\n\nso when the defense receives those materials, they're certainly\n\n8\n\nfree to review those with the defendant in real-time in their\n\n9\n\nsessions.\n\n10\n\nAnd so, we are taking every step that we can to ensure\n\n11\n\nthat the defense and the defendant have those materials but we\n\n12\n\nthink those steps are all that is required here and certainly\n\n13\n\nmore than is necessary to make sure the defendant is apprised\n\n14\n\nof those materials in anticipation of trial.\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAs to the steps, if you have a new\n\n16\n\nsubmission we are talking about newly produced 3500 material,\n\n17\n\nlimited volume; correct, Ms. Moe?\n\n18\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n20\n\nYes, your Honor.\nAnd you are going to send that by FedEx --\n\nso overnight -- to the facility in each instance, correct?\n\n21\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes, your Honor.\nAnd you alert BOP counsel, MDC Legal\n\n23\n\ncounsel that something is coming for Ms. Maxwell so they can be\n\n24\n\non alert.\n\n25\n\nit's been received and delivered?\n\nDo you get indication back from legal counsel that\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02835007\n\n", "char_count": 1565}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 118, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 119 of 127\n\n119\n\nLB15max4\nMS. MOE:\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\nWe have not been asking to\n\ndo that mindful of their obligations towards all of the other\ninmates at the facility but we appreciate the steps they have\n4\n\ntaken to be responsive to our alerts and about the defense's\n\n5\n\nrequests.\n\n6\n\nhas been e-mailing legal counsel noting certain tracking\n\n7\n\nnumbers and asking them to check at the particular warehouse.\n\n8\n\nSo that process seems to be working.\n\n9\n\ncreate a system where the defendant is receiving, in jail, on a\n\n10\n\n24-hour basis, all disclosures.\n\n11\n\npractical but I think especially because, in some instances, we\n\n12\n\nmay be uploading to the defense through a file sharing program\n\n13\n\ncertain disclosures on one day and they may be meeting with the\n\n14\n\ndefendant in person the very next day, they certainly have the\n\n15\n\nability to talk about those materials with the defendant, to\n\n16\n\nprovide her with paper copies if they wish, and I think that is\n\n17\n\nmore than sufficient.\n\n18\n\nFor example, in some instances I think the defense\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI don't think we can\n\nI don't think that is\n\nWell, you are not suggesting that instead\n\n19\n\nof government sending the materials to the facility and working\n\n20\n\nwith the facility to facilitate timely movement of the\n\n21\n\nmaterials to Ms. Maxwell, are you?\n\n22\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nOf course, your Honor.\n\n23\n\nOur view is in combination of the fact that, in the\n\n24\n\nshort-term, the defense has the opportunity to talk to the\n\n25\n\ndefendant immediately about it if they wish to, and in longer\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02835008\n\n", "char_count": 1667}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 119, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 120 of 127\n\n120\n\nLB15max4\nterm the defendant will have those materials in a reasonable\ntime frame.\n\nI think in combination with those efforts, that's\n\nsufficient.\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo in your letter tomorrow you will\n\n5\n\nindicate your understanding of the time frame including the\n\n6\n\nspecific 3500 material sent last week because, again, the\n\n7\n\nrepresentation I have is that you sent it to the defense on\n\n8\n\nMonday and we are here a week later and Ms. Maxwell hasn't\n\n9\n\nreceived it.\n\n10\n\ninquire as to whether there are any additional steps that can\n\n11\n\nbe taken in light of where we are in advance of trial to\n\n12\n\nfurther facilitate the speedy transmission of the materials to\n\n13\n\nMs. Maxwell.\n\nYou will find out what the story is with that and\n\n14\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n16\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nMs. Sternheim?\nJudge, the procedure is such that even\n\n17\n\nif I were to hand-deliver it myself she would not get it.\n\n18\n\nthe government hand delivers it, she will get it.\n\n19\n\nrequested that if they are going to do late-breaking\n\n20\n\ndisclosures, given that we are within weeks now of trial, that\n\n21\n\nit be hand-delivered with a call to the MDC legal department to\n\n22\n\nfacilitate that.\n\n23\n\nI can't just give her papers.\n\nIf\n\nAnd we have\n\nAs the Court well\n\n24\n\nknows, even when I put them in the legal mail box, there is an\n\n25\n\nissue as to when she gets that.\n\nAnd I know the government will\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02835009\n\n", "char_count": 1540}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 120, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-0O330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 121 of 127\n\n121\n\nLB15max4\nrespond to those issues tomorrow.\n\nBut this is an issue -- and\n\nI will give the government the benefit of the doubt -- they do\nnot know what we do when we have a conference with Ms. Maxwell\n4\n\nso to assume what we are doing is erroneous.\n\n5\n\ncomplete that topic and move on to another one.\n\n6\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nBut, I will\n\nI want to understand the specific\n\nsuggestion.\n\n8\n\nSo, presumably now, on a daily basis, the government\n\n9\n\nmay be meeting with witnesses and taking notes.\n\n10\n\nthose notes, an additional 3500 material during trial, it is\n\n11\n\none or two pages of chicken scratch, handwriting.\n\n12\n\nproposal is that every day that one of those is produced it's\n\n13\n\nhand delivered to the MDC by government staff?\n\n14\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nI mean, I get\n\nSo your\n\nThat would be ideal but I'm not asking\n\n15\n\nthat and I don't think it comes that way, I think it comes more\n\n16\n\nin these clumps.\n\n17\n\nhand-delivered but if they know they are making a substantial\n\n18\n\nproduction, that should be hand-delivered.\n\n19\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\na hundred pages?\n\n21\n22\n\n25\n\nAnd what do you mean by substantial?\n\nOver\n\nWhat are we talking about?\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nLook.\n\nYou know, it is not the\n\nquantity, it is what is in it that may have significance here.\n\n23\n24\n\nI'm not asking for every single page to be\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nMs. Sternheim, you have to be realistic on\n\nthis.\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nI'm trying to be.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02835010\n\n", "char_count": 1536}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 121, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-0O330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 122 of 127\n\n122\n\nLB15max4\nTHE COURT:\n\nI mean, you have made a lot of this noise\n\nabout not having received it, not having received it in time.\nI am asking for a specific request that's realistic.\n4\n5\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nEvery day I would like whatever\n\nthey're producing to be hand-delivered.\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n7\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nWell, I deny that request.\nI understand that.\n\nThat's why I\n\n8\n\ndidn't raise it but I think there needs to be some mechanism\n\n9\n\neither if a FedEx comes to the facility that it be\n\n10\n\nspeed-delivered to Ms. Maxwell.\n\n11\n\nhave been sent to her, when we follow the tracking, they are\n\n12\n\nleft in a facility, they're not being picked up.\n\n13\n14\n15\n\nBoxes of legal materials that\n\nI am not privy to what the mail operation is there.\nPerhaps the government can get some insight.\nTHE COURT:\n\nWhen you say they're not being picked up\n\n16\n\nyou are saying that there are some that she has never received?\n\n17\n\nYou are saying she is not receiving it in the one to two to\n\n18\n\nthree-day time frame that you are asking for.\n\n19\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nI submitted a letter to the Court the\n\n20\n\nother day.\n\nIn it there were four indications of items that\n\n21\n\nwere available for pickup.\n\n22\n\nafter the second request on Friday, they sent me back\n\n23\n\nsomething, We are going to go pick them up.\n\n24\n\nto push them to go to the post office.\n\n25\n\nstuff myself because it's not going to be given to her.\n\nWhen I alerted the MDC to that,\n\nI shouldn't have\n\nI can't deliver the\nSo you\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02835011\n\n", "char_count": 1611}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 122, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 123 of 127\n\n123\n\nLB15max4\ndo it through the United States post office, I don't know what\nthe situation is how the MDC receives its packages, but if the\ntracking information says available for pick up and days go by\n4\n\nand it's not picked up, what am I to do to put a candle under\n\n5\n\nthe MDC to get those packages?\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n7\n8\n\nI guess I'm still trying to understand\n\nwhat it is that you are asking the Court to do.\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nI'm asking the Court to have the MDC\n\n9\n\nretrieve its mail in a timely manner.\n\n10\n\nnext-day delivery is on the way, and that it be picked up for\n\n11\n\nnext-day and not languish in the post office.\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n13\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nI will notify them if a\n\nMs. Moe?\nYour Honor, we will confer with MDC legal\n\n14\n\nabout this issue and their practices and happy to provide the\n\n15\n\nCourt with additional information about our disclosures last\n\n16\n\nweek and the ongoing practices.\n\n17\n\nI can't speak to the particular mail sorting practices\n\n18\n\nof the MDC, but I want to assure the Court we have been working\n\n19\n\ndiligently with the defense and with MDC legal on this issue\n\n20\n\nand have been taking extraordinary efforts to make sure the\n\n21\n\ndisclosures are produced promptly and that they're sent to the\n\n22\n\ndefendant quickly and we will continue to do so.\n\n23\n\nlearn of a practical way of expediting this, we would certainly\n\n24\n\nbe open to exploring that but that's all the information that I\n\n25\n\nhave at this point.\n\nAnd if we\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02835012\n\n", "char_count": 1594}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 123, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 124 of 127\n\n124\n\nLB15max4\nTHE COURT:\n\nThank you.\n\nCan I ask the government, if you have a substantial\nproduction, let's say over 50 pages of documents to review, can\n4\n\nthe government have those hand-delivered to the facility?\n\n5\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n6\n\nRespectfully, that is extremely resource intensive, it\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\n7\n\nrequires asking either a member of the prosecution team or\n\n8\n\ntheir colleagues who are also working on cases to, instead of\n\n9\n\npursuing law enforcement activities or preparing for trial,\n\n10\n\nspend the day driving to the MDC to hand deliver a drive to the\n\n11\n\ndefendant personally which is a remedy that I'm not aware of\n\n12\n\nbeing implemented in any other case and would be sort of an\n\n13\n\nextraordinary step for this defendant that would be out of step\n\n14\n\nwith the ordinary practice.\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWe are a month away from trial but if we\n\n16\n\nare a few days away from trial and suddenly the government has\n\n17\n\na substantial production of material for some reason, 50 pages,\n\n18\n\na hundred pages, would the government take those steps?\n\n19\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYour Honor, without having a sense of what\n\n20\n\nthose materials are, what their sensitivities are, whether it\n\n21\n\nis sort of a relevant matter that we are producing in an\n\n22\n\nabundance of caution or something that is sensitive that is\n\n23\n\nurgent that is hard to troubleshoot that issue in advance but\n\n24\n\nwe are mindful of Court's concern and that, even as we approach\n\n25\n\ntrial, that the issue of timing is of particular concern and so\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02835013\n\n", "char_count": 1648}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 124, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-0O330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 125 of 127\n\n125\n\nLB15max4\nwould be attentive to that issue in those circumstances but I\nthink it is difficult assess that in a hypothetical.\nTHE COURT:\n4\n\nOK.\n\nI will wait for the government's\n\nletter.\n\n5\n\nMs. Sternheim.\n\n6\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nOne other issue, Judge; it has to do\n\n7\n\ngoing forward with the production of Ms. Maxwell to the court\n\n8\n\nhouse.\n\n9\n\nShe is woken up at approximately 3:45.\n\nShe is taken\n\n10\n\nhere and this morning she arrived at 5:38.\n\n11\n\ncellblock, very cold, she cannot bring any warmer garments.\n\n12\n\nShe is not allowed to look at her legal materials.\n\n13\n\ngiven very little food and whatever she is given doesn't even\n\n14\n\nhave a utensil for her to use.\n\n15\n\nshe had to get on her hands and knees to climb into the van\n\n16\n\nbecause her leg shackles would not permit her to step up.\n\n17\n\nis just not the right thing.\n\n18\n\nforward to trial five days a week --\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n20\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nShe sits in a\n\nShe is\n\nAnd, she is shackled.\n\nToday\n\nThis\n\nThe wear and tear on her going\n\nWhat is the application, Ms. Sternheim?\nThe application is for her to be\n\n21\n\nbrought here later.\n\n22\n\nher to be let out on bail but I'm not going to make that\n\n23\n\napplication right here, I will make it in writing, but these\n\n24\n\nconditions are just terrible.\n\n25\n\nout, she was poked to be woken up just because she's the only\n\nThe real application, obviously, is for\n\nAnd today, when she was nodding\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02835014\n\n", "char_count": 1542}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 125, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 126 of 127\n\n126\n\nLB15max4\nperson sitting in a cell.\n\nThat's not necessary.\n\nNutrition is important, sleep is important.\n\nWe all\n\nare going to be fatigued but we all get to go home, and\n4\n\nsomething needs to be done to ensure that she is not\n\n5\n\ndebilitated during the trial.\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n7\n8\n\nAre you making any allegations of\n\ndifferential treatment as to Ms. Maxwell?\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nYes.\n\nI don't know any other client I\n\n9\n\nhave ever had who has been woken up every 15 minutes at night\n\n10\n\nand then --\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nNo, I'm talking about what you are talking\n\n12\n\nabout which is the transport to the court house for\n\n13\n\nproceedings.\n\n14\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nI don't know any clients who have ever\n\n15\n\narrived that early.\n\nI can't speak to that.\n\nThey've never been\n\n16\n\ntaken individually as she has so I don't have a big history\n\n17\n\nabout that.\n\n18\n\neither the clients come from the MCC, which is no longer here\n\n19\n\nand they're transported one way, or when I come here in the\n\n20\n\nmorning for a court proceeding or trial, and I will get here at\n\n21\n\n9:00, I'm told they haven't arrived yet.\n\n22\n\nbetween getting here at 5:38 and not being here at 9:00 for\n\n23\n\nanother defendant seems extraordinary.\n\nIn other cases that I have had in this court house\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n25\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nSo, the differential\n\nMs. Moe?\n\nYour Honor, the government is learning of\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02835015\n\n", "char_count": 1493}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02834890", "page_number": 126, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-PAE\n\nDocument 465\n\nFiled 11/15/21\n\nPage 127 of 127\n\n127\n\nLB15max4\nthis concern for the first time at this conference.\n\nI would be\n\nhappy to reach out to both the MDC and the Deputy U.S. Marshal\nassigned to this particular trial to ask, as a general matter,\n4\n\nwhat time they anticipate producing the defendant on trial days\n\n5\n\nand can provide the defense with that information.\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes; and whether there is any differential\n\n7\n\ntreatment between Ms. Maxwell and other defendants being\n\n8\n\nproduced from the MDC to the court house under COVID protocols\n\n9\n\nand currently.\n\nYou will inquire as to that.\n\n10\n\nMS. MOE:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAs well as differential or not, what the\n\n12\n\ntiming issue is, availability of food and comfort items, as\n\n13\n\nnecessary, and the like.\n\n14\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n16\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n\nMS. MOE:\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n20\n\nCertainly, your Honor.\nMs. Sternheim, anything further?\nThank you, Judge.\n\nNo.\n\nAnything, Ms. Moe?\nNo, your Honor.\n\nThank you.\n\nWe are adjourned.\no0o\n\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02835016\n\n", "char_count": 1151}]}