{"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_count": 95, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02827058", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02827058.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 1 of 95\n\n2739\n\nLCI1MAX1\n\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK\nx\nUNITED STATES OF AMERICA,\nv.\n\n20 CR 330 (AJN)\n\n4\nGHISLAINE MAXWELL,\n5\nJury Trial\n\nDefendant.\n6\n\nx\nNew York, N.Y.\nDecember 18, 2021\n9:10 a.m.\n\n7\n8\nBefore:\n9\n\nHON. ALISON J. NATHAN,\n\n10\n\nDistrict Judge\n\n11\n\nAPPEARANCES\n\n12\n\nDAMIAN\nUnited States Attorney for the\nSouthern District of New York\nBY: MAURENE COMEY\nLARA POMERANTZ\nANDREW ROHRBACH\nAssistant United States Attorneys\n\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n\nHADDON\nAND\nAttorneys for Defendant\nBY: JEFFREY S. PAGLIUCA\nLAURA A. MENNINGER\n-andBOBBI C. STERNHEIM\n-and& GRESSER\nBY: CHRISTIAN R. EVERDELL\n\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827058\n\n", "char_count": 763}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 2 of 95\n\n2740\n\nLCI 1MAX1\n(In open court; jury not present)\nTHE COURT:\n\nGood morning, everyone.\n\nALL COUNSEL:\n\nGood morning.\n\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nPlease be seated.\n\n5\n\nAll right.\n\nLooks like we have everybody.\n\n6\n\nmake sure we're set up.\n\n7\n\nOkay.\n\nLet me just\n\nThank you, everyone, for the Saturday charging\n\n8\n\nconference, a first for me, but it helps us use our time well,\n\n9\n\nI think, so thank you for that.\n\n10\n\nI circulated to the parties the draft charge, which we\n\n11\n\ndocketed last night.\n\nIn the draft verdict form, the way I do\n\n12\n\nthis is to just ask, starting with the first page on which you\n\n13\n\nhave a request that you want to make, and give me the page and\n\n14\n\nline number and we'll discuss it.\n\n15\n\nwill be entered in redline by my law clerk.\n\n16\n\nwe're finished, I'll send to the parties the redline so you can\n\n17\n\nhelp me make sure that everything got entered properly.\n\n18\n\nAll right.\n\n19\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n20\n\n22\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n25\n\nThe government's first request is on\n\npage 32.\nTHE COURT:\n\n24\n\nAnd then once\n\nSo Mr. Rohrbach, first page that you have.\n\n21\n\n23\n\nIf I accept the change, it\n\nBefore that?\n\nMr. Everdell?\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nDefense's first\n\nrequest -THE COURT:\n\nIt may be best to -- you're welcome to\n\nremain seated --\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827059\n\n", "char_count": 1371}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 3 of 95\n\n2741\n\nLCI1MAX1\nMR. EVERDELL:\nTHE COURT:\n\nI can pull this up a little bit?\n\n-- if I'm going to hear from you a lot.\n\nBut yes, pull up the mic and -- yes.\n4\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n6\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n8\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n9\n\nindictment charge, your Honor.\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n11\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nFirst page, Mr. Everdell.\n\nDefense's first page is page 15.\n\nOkay.\n\nLine?\n\nWell, we'll start with line 8 and 9.\n\nOkay.\nSo this was the summary of the\n\nYes.\nAnd on 8 and 9, there's a reference to\n\n12\n\ntravel to both interstate and foreign commerce.\n\nI think\n\n13\n\nthroughout the charge there's a bit of an inconsistency.\n\n14\n\nSometimes we're talking about just interstate, sometimes we're\n\n15\n\ntalking about interstate and foreign.\n\n16\n\nthat there's any evidence, especially with respect to Count One\n\n17\n\nor the\n\n18\n\n\"and foreign commerce.\"\n\n19\n\ndon't think the \"and foreign\" is necessary.\n\nI actually don't think\n\nAct charges or any of them, we're talking about\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n21\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nI think it's interstate commerce, so I\n\nI think we have -- Mr. Rohrbach?\nYour Honor, this actually relates to\n\n22\n\nthe government's later request, but the government's view is\n\n23\n\nthat there are flight records that show\n\n24\n\ntraveling with the defendant and Jeffrey Epstein overseas while\n\n25\n\nshe is 17, I believe, and so that would be sufficient, at least\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827060\n\n", "char_count": 1494}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 4 of 95\n\n2742\n\nLCI1MAX1\nas to Counts Five and Six.\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo the government's request is that I\n\ninclude \"foreign\" in each instance and the defense's request\n4\n\nthat I remove \"foreign\" in each instance.\n\n5\n\ninconsistency.\n\n6\n7\n8\n\nAs we stand, there's\n\nDo I have that right, Mr. Everdell?\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nI'm sorry, your Honor.\n\nCan you say\n\nthat again?\nTHE COURT:\n\nSure.\n\nRight now there's inconsistency as\n\n9\n\nto whether \"foreign commerce\" is included or not, and the\n\n10\n\ndefense's request is that \"foreign\" be excluded in each\n\n11\n\ninstance and the government's request is that \"foreign\" be\n\n12\n\nincluded in each instance.\n\n13\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n14\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n15\n16\n\nThat's correct, your Honor.\n\nOkay.\n\nMr. Everdell, do you want to\n\nrespond to the government's point about flight records.\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nYour Honor, the flight records, I\n\n17\n\nthink -- I'm trying to think of the references to -- you said\n\n18\n\nit relates to which individual?\n\n19\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nI'm sorry, your Honor.\n\nIt relates to\n\nwhile\n\n20\n\nshe was 17, and so that, at a minimum, in the government's\n\n21\n\nview, means \"foreign commerce\" should be included in Counts\n\n22\n\nFive and Six.\n\n23\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nYour Honor, there's no testimony about\n\n24\n\nthe purpose of those trips or any enticement with respect to\n\n25\n\nthose trips.\n\nI think\n\nthe sum total of her\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827061\n\n", "char_count": 1457}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 5 of 95\n\n2743\n\nLCIlMAX1\ntestimony was that she recruited Carolyn, and she didn't\ntestify, and I don't think -- this is not the theory that the\ngovernment's been proceeding on on these counts.\n\nThese counts\n\n4\n\nrelate to the four accusers that testified.\n\n5\n\njury to infer then that there's enticement with respect to\n\n6\n\nwhen there's no evidence in the record of\n\n7\n\nMs. Maxwell or anybody enticing her, there's just testimony\n\n8\n\nthat she enticed Carolyn, if anything, that's not an\n\n9\n\nappropriate theory for the jury to base their conviction on\n\n10\n\nforeign commerce, if she's the one who traveled.\n\n11\n12\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nI think for the\n\nIf I may, your Honor.\n\nI think for\n\ncounts --\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n14\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nWe're talking 18 U.S.C. 1591, correct?\nYes.\n\nThe government does not -- if the\n\n15\n\nCourt and defense prefer to remove \"foreign commerce\" from One\n\n16\n\nthrough Four,\n\n17\n\nWhile that's a legally proper instruction to leave \"foreign\n\n18\n\ncommerce,\" it's at least available to the jury as to Counts\n\n19\n\nFive and Six because of 18 U.S.C. 1591).\n\n20\n21\n22\n\nconduct doesn't show that.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nBut the text of 18 U.S.C. 1591 doesn't\n\ninclude \"in foreign commerce,\" does it?\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nYes.\n\nIt says, \"Whoever knowingly, in\n\n23\n\nor affecting interstate or foreign commerce, recruits, entices,\n\n24\n\nharbors,\" etc.\n\n25\n\nII, I see.\n\nIt appears that --\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827062\n\n", "char_count": 1496}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 6 of 95\n\n2744\n\nLCI1MAX1\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThere is a --\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n-- there was a statutory change that\n\nadded \"foreign commerce.\"\n4\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n6\n\nYeah.\n\nIt depends on what the operative time\n\nperiod for the inclusion of it is.\n\n7\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nIn light of that, your Honor, I think\n\n8\n\nthe government would withdraw its request as to Counts Five and\n\n9\n\nSix.\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n11\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n12\n13\n\nOkay.\nTo avoid any ambiguity about that\n\npoint.\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\nAll right.\n\nSo you'll help me,\n\n14\n\nMr. Everdell, find each instance in which we need to remove\n\n15\n\n\"and foreign\"?\n\n16\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n19\n20\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nThe first one you've identified\nIf you like, on this charge, I can go\n\nthrough the ones I see on this page.\nTHE COURT:\n\nLet me just note the first one we've\n\n21\n\ndiscussed, because my clerk is going to wait for me to say the\n\n22\n\nchange in order to make it.\n\n23\n\nlines 8 and 9 -- on line 8, deleting the word \"and,\" on line 9,\n\n24\n\ndeleting the word \"foreign.\"\n\n25\n\nSo let me just note on page 15,\n\nNext one, Mr. Everdell?\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827063\n\n", "char_count": 1232}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 7 of 95\n\n2745\n\nLCI1MAX1\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\nTHE COURT:\n\nLine 12, your Honor.\n\nLine 12, deleting the word \"and,\" deleting\n\nLhe words \"and foreign\"?\n\nGo ahead, Mr. Everdell.\n\n4\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n6\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n8\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n10\n\nThat's it for that, for the summary, correct?\n\n11\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n13\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n14\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n15\n\non this.\n\n16\n\nappears?\n\n17\n18\n\nLine 15, same change, your Honor.\n\nLine 15, deleting \"and foreign.\"\nYes, your Honor.\n\nAnd line 19?\nCorrect, your Honor.\n\nDeleting \"and foreign.\"\n\nThat's it for the \"and foreign,\" yup.\n\nOkay.\nWe have a few others.\n\nAll right.\n\nWell, let's be comprehensive\n\nAre there any other places in the charge where that\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nII, the other places in the whole\n\ncharge.\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n20\n\nSo what else on 15?\n\nActually, we'll hit it when we get there.\n\n21\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n23\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n25\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nSure.\n\nOkay.\n\nSo line 10, your Honor\n\nJust one second.\n\nOkay.\n\nGo ahead.\nThank you, your Honor.\n\nOn line 10, it\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827064\n\n", "char_count": 1197}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 8 of 95\n\n2746\n\nLCIlMAX1\nnow reads, \"Count One relates to multiple alleged victims in\nthe time period 1994 into 2004.\"\n\nWe believe it should read,\n\n\"Count One relates solely to Jane and the time period 1994 to\n4\n\n2004.\"\n\nAnd I can explain, if you like, your Honor.\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nLet me just get my eyes on it.\n\n6\n\nOkay.\n\n7\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nSo, your Honor, this is an issue I\n\n8\n\nthink we've gone back and forth on quite a bit in the motions\n\n9\n\nin limine.\n\n10\n\nconspiracy and of the substantive counts, enticement and\n\n11\n\ntransportation, so Counts One through Four, is that the\n\n12\n\nunderlying object was a violation of New York law, right,\n\n13\n\nSection 130.55.\n\n14\n\nconspiracy is a violation of New York law.\n\n15\n\nKate, there was no violation of New York law.\n\n16\n\nalready instructed the jury that they can't consider that\n\n17\n\nevidence for purposes of conviction because she was above the\n\n18\n\nage of consent.\n\n19\n\nthing with --\n\n20\n\nBut with respect to the government's theory of the\n\nSo there has to be -- the object of this\nWith respect to\nYour Honor\n\nThere was no violation of New York law.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSame\n\nWell, just to be slightly more precise,\n\n21\n\nthey can't convict on that count based solely on the evidence\n\n22\n\nof the conduct involving her.\n\n23\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nCorrect.\n\nAnd with respect to Annie,\n\n24\n\nthe Court also instructed that this is -- whatever conduct they\n\n25\n\nmay find that she talked about in New Mexico, was not illegal\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827065\n\n", "char_count": 1573}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 9 of 95\n\n2747\n\nLCIlMAX1\nsexual activity as charged in the indictment, which is a\nreference to the violation of New York law, because that is the\ntheory we're proceeding under.\n4\n\nWith respect to Carolyn, there was no limiting\n\n5\n\ninstruction, but it's evident we were talking about Florida\n\n6\n\nconduct.\n\n7\n\nonly evidence we have that goes to -- that actually establishes\n\n8\n\na violation of New York law, which is the object of this\n\n9\n\nconspiracy, and the object of the transportation conspiracy, is\n\n10\n\nwhat Jane said.\n\n11\n\nThere is no violation of New York law there.\n\nSo the\n\nNow the Court did instruct the jury that they can\n\n12\n\nconsider the testimony of Kate and of Annie for whatever\n\n13\n\nrelevant purpose they see fit, and I suppose that could be\n\n14\n\nevidence of a conspiracy, correct, but for them to actually\n\n15\n\nconvict on this, they have to believe that somebody committed a\n\n16\n\nviolation of New York law, and that relates solely to Jane, and\n\n17\n\nso we don't think -- there are no multiple alleged victims of\n\n18\n\nthis conspiracy other than Jane that's been established by the\n\n19\n\nevidence at trial.\n\n20\n\nconsider the testimony of Annie and Kate as evidence of some\n\n21\n\nsort of relevant evidence that speaks to this conspiracy, that\n\n22\n\nis not -- they are not victims of this conspiracy, there was no\n\n23\n\nviolation of New York law that they testified to, and that is\n\n24\n\nJane alone.\n\n25\n\nsubstantive count, your Honor.\n\nSo we believe while they may be able to\n\nSo this count relates solely to Jane, as does the\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827066\n\n", "char_count": 1654}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 10 of 95\n\n2748\n\nLCI1MAX1\nTHE COURT:\n\nMr. Rohrbach?\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nYour Honor, this is a place where the\n\ndefense confuses conspiracy violations and substantive\n4\n\nviolations.\n\n5\n\nNew York law as to any of the minor victims.\n\n6\n\nan agreement to accomplish that purpose.\n\n7\n\ninstance, was invited to travel by the defendant.\n\n8\n\nreadily find that that invitation to travel included an\n\n9\n\ninvitation to New York, where the abuse would continue, as it\n\n10\n\ndid for Jane.\n\n11\n\nEpstein to New Mexico and New York.\n\n12\n\nfind that that was a conspiracy that existed, and as part of\n\n13\n\nthat grooming conduct, the plan would be to continue to abuse\n\n14\n\nher, including back in New York.\n\n15\n\ninferences to the jury, and that's all that's required for the\n\n16\n\nconspiracy count.\n\n17\n18\n19\n\nThere does not have to be a proven violation of\nIt just has to be\n\nCarolyn, for\nThe jury can\n\nAnnie was in fact transported by the defendant\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThe jury could readily\n\nThese are available\n\nThat's precisely why there was a different\n\nlimiting instruction for Annie than there was for Kate.\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nWell, your Honor, I would dispute the\n\n20\n\nfacts a little bit there, because they said that Carolyn's\n\n21\n\ntestimony was that she was invited to travel to the island.\n\n22\n\nShe was not invited to travel anywhere; she specifically\n\n23\n\ntestified she was given an invitation to the island.\n\n24\n\nnot travel to New York.\n\n25\n\nable to go.\n\nThat's\n\nAnd her mother said she couldn't be\n\nSo I don't think that is evidence -- if the object\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827067\n\n", "char_count": 1648}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 11 of 95\n\n2749\n\nLCI1MAX1\nof the conspiracy is to violate New York law, then an\ninvitation to an island that's not New York doesn't count.\nAnd also, an invitation to travel to New Mexico to do\n4\n\nwhatever it is they were planning on doing in New Mexico is\n\n5\n\nalso not a goal of violating New York law.\n\n6\n\nArizona.\n\n7\n\nto Annie's testimony either.\n\nI'm sorry, from\n\nSo there's no connection to New York law with respect\n\n8\n\nAnd so whatever purpose they want to glean from those\n\n9\n\ntwo witnesses' testimony, Kate and Annie, or even Carolyn, the\n\n10\n\nobject of this conspiracy, for this to be a crime, it can only\n\n11\n\nbe hung on the testimony, at least in the evidence in the\n\n12\n\nrecord, the testimony of Jane.\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd --\n\nYou're doing precisely what Mr. Rohrbach\n\n14\n\nsaid, which is you're switching back and forth between the\n\n15\n\nconspiracy and the substantive count.\n\n16\n\nthe evidence is the conduct occurred in New Mexico.\n\n17\n\nI gave the limiting instruction.\n\n18\n\nwith other evidence of the conspiracy with respect to New York,\n\n19\n\nthe violation of New York law.\n\n20\n\nviolation of New York law to establish the elements of the\n\n21\n\nconspiracy count.\n\nSo Annie, for example,\n\nBut that could be considered\n\nYou don't have to have the\n\n22\n\nSo the objection is overruled.\n\n23\n\nNext.\n\n24\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n25\n\nThat's why\n\nAll right.\n\nNext is line 13, your\n\nHonor, same page.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827068\n\n", "char_count": 1511}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 12 of 95\n\n2750\n\nLCI1MAX1\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nWe would add, the last sentence, \"Count\n\nTwo relates solely to Jane and the time period 1994 to 1997.\"\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n5\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nOkay.\n\nMr. Rohrbach?\n\nI think that's redundant, but the\n\n6\n\ngovernment is fine with that.\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\nPage 15, line 13, adding \"solely\"\n\n8\n\nbetween \"Count Two\" and \"relates.\"\n\n9\n\n\"relates\" and the word \"to.\"\n\n10\n\nTwo relates solely to Jane.\"\n\n11\n\nNext.\n\n12\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n13\n\nThis is on Count Three.\n\n14\n\nNo, I'm sorry.\n\nBetween\n\nSo the sentence will read, \"Count\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nI'll just go back to line 14.\n\nSame page, line 15.\n\nCount \"Three of the\n\n15\n\nindictment charges the defendant with conspiring with others to\n\n16\n\ntransport an individual,\" and we would add \"under the age of\n\n17\n\n18,\" \"in interstate commerce,\" because we've eliminated \"and\n\n18\n\nforeign.\"\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nMr. Rohrbach.\n\n20\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nI believe that the elements that the\n\n21\n\nCourt has set forth for that count is an individual under the\n\n22\n\nage of 17.\n\n23\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nI'm sorry.\n\n24\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nIs that --\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWe've adopted the Sand suggestion.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827069\n\n", "char_count": 1285}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 13 of 95\n\n2751\n\nLCI 1MAX1\nMR. EVERDELL:\nTHE COURT:\n\nRight.\n\nSo just rather than give the jury two\n\nelements with two different ages, which I think makes sense.\n4\n\nBut so then the suggestion is \"to transport an individual under\n\n5\n\nthe age of 17.\"\n\n6\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n8\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n9\n\nelement of the offense.\n\n10\n\nof the elements into the summary.\n\n11\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\nasking this one.\n\n13\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nMr. Rohrbach?\nThe government agrees that that's an\nThere is no reason to incorporate all\n\nWell, he's not asking all.\n\nHe's just\n\nSo --\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nThat's fine, your Honor, although the\n\n14\n\ngovernment would note that that creates an asymmetry between\n\n15\n\nCounts One and Three, so we think it should be in both or\n\n16\n\nneither.\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right.\n\n18\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nWell, it's not an element of the\n\n19\n\noffense in Count One.\n\nI add it there because it says \"an\n\n20\n\nindividual\" and \"an individual\" seems sort of vague.\n\n21\n\nthere's testimony about lots of individuals traveling, and\n\n22\n\ntransporting here and there.\n\n23\n\nto the jury that we're talking about individuals under the age\n\n24\n\nof 17 rather than all these people on the flight logs that we\n\n25\n\nsaw who we have no evidence of their ages.\n\nI mean,\n\nWe just wanted to make it clear\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827070\n\n", "char_count": 1402}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 14 of 95\n\n2752\n\nLCIlMAX1\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nIf this is the defense's preference,\n\nyour Honor, the government is fine with it.\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\nI'll accept that request.\n\nPage 15,\n\n4\n\nline 15, after the word \"individual,\" adding \"under the age of\n\n5\n\n17.\"\n\n6\n\nNext?\n\n7\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n10\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nMr. Rohrbach?\nNo objection.\n\nOkay.\n\nLet me just give my law clerk a moment to get it\nentered.\n\n15\n\nOkay.\n\n16\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n\nfull sentence for clarity.\n\n19\n\nMaking that same change, page 15,\n\nline 18, after \"individual,\" adding \"under the age of 17.\"\n\n13\n14\n\nAnd then similar request: line\n\n18, after the word \"individual,\" add \"under the age of 17.\"\n\n9\n\n12\n\nYeah.\n\nAnd then line 20, it's a similar --\n\nHang on.\n\nHang on.\n\nLet me just read that\n\nSo page 15, line 18, first sentence of the paragraph,\n\n20\n\n\"Count Four of the indictment charges the defendant with\n\n21\n\ntransporting an individual under the age of 17 in interstate\n\n22\n\ncommerce.\"\n\n23\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n25\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nGo ahead.\nNext line, line 20, similar to what we\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827071\n\n", "char_count": 1239}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 15 of 95\n\n2753\n\nLCI1MAX1\nasked for before, last sentence, \"Count Four relates solely to\nJane and the time period --\"\nTHE COURT:\n4\n\nOkay.\n\nI'll accept that.\n\nPage 15, line 20, the sentence that begins, \"Count\n\n5\n\nFour,\" adding \"solely\" after \"relates,\" so the sentence would\n\n6\n\nread, \"Count Four relates solely to Jane.\"\n\n7\n\nOkay.\n\n8\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n9\n\nNext?\nPage 16, line 2, similar request:\n\n\"Count Six relates solely to Carolyn.\"\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\n11\n\nPage 16, last line, adding \"solely\" after \"relates\"\n\n12\n\nand before \"to Carolyn.\"\n\n13\n\nOkay.\n\n14\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n15\n\nI'll accept that.\n\nNext page.\nPage 17, this is a small one, your\n\nHonor.\n\n16\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n17\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nOkay.\nLines 2 to 3, \"Each count charges the\n\n18\n\ndefendant,\" since we're using \"Ms. Maxwell\" in the other parts\n\n19\n\nof this charge, we'll just say, \"Each count charges Ms. Maxwell\n\n20\n\nwith a different crime.\"\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n22\n\nSo instruction 11, page 17, line 3, changing\n\nAll right.\n\nThat's fine.\n\n23\n\n\"defendant\" to \"Ms. Maxwell.\"\n\n24\n\ncount charges Ms. Maxwell with a different crime.\"\n\n25\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nSo the sentence reads, \"Each\n\nYour Honor, can I just have one moment.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827072\n\n", "char_count": 1292}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 16 of 95\n\n2754\n\nLC1lmAxl\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes.\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nYour Honor, I'm sorry.\n\nCould we just\n\nreturn to page 15.\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSure.\n\n5\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n7\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nLine 23.\n\nOkay.\nThere, it says -- and it's also on the\n\n8\n\nnext page, but we'll get to that.\n\n9\n\nindictment charges the defendant with conspiring to engage in\n\n10\n\nsex trafficking of minors.\n\n11\n\njurisdiction, and it creates a lot of ambiguity because we've\n\n12\n\ngot allegations, especially because the time period of the\n\n13\n\nconspiracy, 2001 to 2004, you know, the word \"minors\" is going\n\n14\n\nto create an ambiguity, and it raises issues with the age of\n\n15\n\nconsent, because you're not a minor unless, you know --\n\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\nunder the age of 17?\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nYeah, either under the age of 17 or\n\nunder the age of consent.\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nWell, your Honor, first, for the sex\n\ntrafficking counts, the relevant age of consent is 18.\nTHE COURT:\n\n23\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n25\n\nAnd the word \"minors\" depends on\n\nYou want to change it to an individual\n\n22\n\n24\n\nIt says, \"Count Five of the\n\nRight.\n\nSorry.\n\nThank you.\n\nYeah, actually, that's right\n\nThat's\n\nin the language of the statute itself.\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nYeah.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827073\n\n", "char_count": 1339}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 17 of 95\n\n2755\n\nLCI1MAX1\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nSo why don't we say \"under the age of\n\n18,\" if we could, your Honor.\nTHE COURT:\n4\n\nIs that okay, Mr. Rohrbach?\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nSince it relates to multiple\n\n5\n\nindividuals here, it would have to be \"individuals under the\n\n6\n\nage of 18,\" but the government would be fine with that change\n\n7\n\nto avoid ambiguity.\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\nSo page 15, line 23, it will read\n\n9\n\n\"to engage in sex trafficking of individuals under the age of\n\n10\n\n18.\"\n\nJust one moment.\n\n11\n\nOkay.\n\n12\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nAnd your Honor, next page, it's a\n\n13\n\nsimilar request.\n\n14\n\nindictment charges the defendant with sex trafficking of\n\n15\n\nindividuals under the age of 18.\"\n\nOn line 1, we would say, \"Count Six of the\n\n16\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n17\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nOkay.\nWell, your Honor, for this one, since\n\n18\n\nit just relates to Carolyn, it could just be an individual, but\n\n19\n\notherwise that's fine.\n\n20\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAn individual under the age of 18.\n\nThat's right.\n\nAll right.\n\nSo we'll change\n\n22\n\npage 16, line 1 to read, \"Count Six of the indictment charges\n\n23\n\nthe defendant with sex trafficking of an individual under the\n\n24\n\nage of 18.\"\n\n25\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827074\n\n", "char_count": 1335}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 18 of 95\n\n2756\n\nLCI1MAX1\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\nTHE COURT:\n\nWe've made it to 19, in fact.\n\n19.\n\n4\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n6\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nHave we made it to 17?\n\nWow.\n\nPage 19 is the next one, your Honor.\n\nOkay.\n\nGo ahead.\n\nFirst, on line 5, there's another \"or\n\n7\n\nforeign,\" which we can omit.\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n9\n\nYeah.\n\n10\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n11\n12\n\nProgress.\n\nOkay.\n\nLet me just look.\n\nOkay.\nIt would need to be ellipses since this\n\nis the statutory text, but that's fine with the government.\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo we'll do, page 19, line 5, it will\n\n13\n\nread, \"Travel in interstate... commerce,\" cutting \"or foreign\"\n\n14\n\nand replacing with the ellipses.\n\n15\n\nOkay.\n\n16\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nSame page, your Honor, line 4.\n\n17\n\nDon't worry.\n\nI tried to be efficient about this.\n\n18\n\nNext page.\n\nWe'll go quickly.\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat's fine.\n\n20\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nLine 4.\n\nThere is the inclusion of the\n\n21\n\nstatutory text \"or coerces,\" and since we don't have any\n\n22\n\nevidence of coercion, our proposal would be to add -- have it\n\n23\n\nread \"knowingly persuades, induces, or entices... any\n\n24\n\nindividual.\"\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOr in brackets.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827075\n\n", "char_count": 1268}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 19 of 95\n\n2757\n\nLC1lmAxl\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nOr in brackets because it's an addition\n\nto the statutory text.\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nYour Honor, the government does not\n\n4\n\nagree with this one.\n\n5\n\nhad been coerced for the enticement counts.\n\n6\n\ntestimony from Dr. Rocchio about how these relationships sort\n\n7\n\nof evolved; there's testimony from Jane in the record about\n\n8\n\nhow, toward the end of her relationship with Mr. Epstein, she\n\n9\n\nfelt like she was compelled to continue answering the phone and\n\n10\n\nwould drop everything because she had no other choice.\n\n11\n\nthe jury could conclude that these victims were coerced.\n\n12\n\n\"Coercion\" in this context just bears its ordinary and natural\n\n13\n\nmeaning, and there's no reason to delete it from the charge.\n\n14\n\nThe jury could conclude that the minors\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThere's expert\n\nI think\n\nWell, your Honor, I agree I know we\n\n15\n\ngive normal meanings to these words, and coercion in my normal\n\n16\n\nmeaning implies some sort of force, or at least of violence or\n\n17\n\nsomething, and there's no evidence of that in the record.\n\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nIt's an argument that the defense is\n\nfree to make to the jury.\nTHE COURT:\n\nWell, what's the legal basis for the\n\nnotion that coercion as used here textually requires force?\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nYour Honor, as in Sand, they just say\n\n23\n\n\"given the normal everyday meaning.\"\n\nIt's not particularly\n\n24\n\nhelpful, but I guess that can differ by person.\n\n25\n\neveryday meaning of \"coercion\" means some sort of force being\n\nMy normal\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827076\n\n", "char_count": 1645}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 20 of 95\n\n2758\n\nLCI1MAX1\nused, and if that's not the Court's opinion, then -THE COURT:\n\nI'm just asking if you have any legal\n\nsupport for that principle.\n4\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nYour Honor, one good reason to think\n\n5\n\nthat coercion does not involve force is that the sex\n\n6\n\ntrafficking statute includes criminal activity by force, fraud,\n\n7\n\nor coercion, and in that statute, \"force\" and \"coercion\" carry\n\n8\n\ndifferent meanings.\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n10\n\nobjection.\n\nOkay.\n\nI'm going to overrule the\n\nSo that will remain.\n\n11\n\nNext page, Mr. Everdell.\n\n12\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nBefore I get to the\n\n13\n\nnext page, just for purposes of clarity, if the Court overrules\n\n14\n\na proposed edit, I would still note that I have that same\n\n15\n\nproposal going through my changes.\n\n16\n\nBut I would like to just preserve those, preserve my\n\n17\n\nsuggestions, similar ones in similar charges.\n\n18\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI just won't reiterate it.\n\nSo you would repeat your request to remove\n\n\"coercion\" from every instance, so that is preserved.\n\n20\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nCorrect, your Honor.\n\n21\n\nAll right.\n\nSo we can go to page 20 now, your Honor.\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\n23\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nAll right.\n\nSo on this one, your Honor,\n\n24\n\nI understand, we're talking about the substantive count, and I\n\n25\n\ndo understand that because the way the charge is organized and\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827077\n\n", "char_count": 1467}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 21 of 95\n\n2759\n\nLCIlMAX1\nthe conspiracy counts come later, I think there is an attempt\nhere to generalize the wording of the elements because it's\ngoing to be applied later to the conspiracy counts, right?\n\nBut\n\n4\n\nthis is the substantive count, and if we look at the line 5, it\n\n5\n\nsays first that the defendant knowingly persuaded or induced or\n\n6\n\nenticed or coerced an individual to travel in interstate\n\n7\n\ncommerce.\n\n8\n\nThe defense request is for it to say not \"an individual,\"\n\n9\n\nreplace that with \"Jane to travel in interstate commerce from\n\n10\n\nFlorida to New York, as alleged in the indictment.\"\n\nThe individual in the substantive count is Jane.\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n12\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nMr. Rohrbach.\nSo, your Honor, I don't think the jury\n\n13\n\nwill be confused.\n\nBoth in the summary and later on in this\n\n14\n\nsection, it says this relates to Jane.\n\n15\n\nlike it to say it relates solely to Jane here as in the\n\n16\n\nsummary, that would be fine, but the Court is just laying out\n\n17\n\nthe elements of the offense and there's no need to put all of\n\n18\n\nthe factual predicates of the offense into the statement of the\n\n19\n\nelements.\n\n20\n\nMr. Everdell can correct me, but an issue in the parties'\n\n21\n\nproposed requests to charge is whether things like the name\n\n22\n\nJane, travel to New York, the name Jeffrey Epstein should all\n\n23\n\nbe included in the recitation of the elements.\n\n24\n\ndefense is getting that because it's in the \"to wit\" clause of\n\n25\n\nthe indictment, and the law is quite clear -- and I have\n\nIf the defense would\n\nI think here and elsewhere, the defense --\n\nI think the\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827078\n\n", "char_count": 1711}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 22 of 95\n\n2760\n\nLCI1MAX1\nauthority if the Court would like -- that the fact that there\nare proper nouns in the \"to wit\" clauses does not mean the\ngovernment is bound by them as elements of the offense, as long\n4\n\nas the government is proceeding on the essential elements of\n\n5\n\nthe crime as charged by the grand jury.\n\n6\n\nsuggestion -- it's quite clear that the government has been\n\n7\n\ntrying to prove the offenses in the indictment and there's no\n\n8\n\nneed to include words like \"travel from Florida to New York,\"\n\n9\n\nor \"Jane,\" to avoid any suggestion of a variance.\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd I think there's no\n\nYes, I agree with that.\n\nObviously this\n\n11\n\ndispute was in the parties' proposed charge, and I balanced I\n\n12\n\nthink, as appropriate, including the name of the individual\n\n13\n\nwhere a particular count applies only to them, but not\n\n14\n\notherwise restating factually in the explanation of the counts\n\n15\n\nand the elements each of the factual points to be proved.\n\n16\n\nthink here, Mr. Rohrbach, you didn't disagree with substituting\n\n17\n\nJane for an individual?\n\n18\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nSo I\n\nWell, that just creates the -- the\n\n19\n\ngovernment thinks the charge is fine as it is because, in\n\n20\n\nline 11, it says it relates to Jane, and the government would\n\n21\n\nbe fine with adding \"solely to Jane,\" or \"relates,\" if that's\n\n22\n\nwhat the defense would like.\n\n23\n\nwould create a problem when it's later incorporated by the\n\n24\n\nconspiracy instruction.\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\nI do think adding Jane in line 6\n\nI agree with that.\n\nAnd that's the\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827079\n\n", "char_count": 1669}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 23 of 95\n\n2761\n\nLC1lmAxl\nusefulness of line 11, which states expressly Count Two, and\nI'll add, \"Count Two relates solely to Jane during the time\nperiod 1994 to 1997,\" for the reason indicated.\n\nBecause the\n\n4\n\nconspiracy count requires looking back to the substantive count\n\n5\n\nfor the object of the conspiracy.\n\n6\n7\n\nI won't adopt the requested change within the\nstatement of the elements.\n\n8\n\nAnything else on page 20?\n\n9\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nWith the addition of solely, your\n\n10\n\nHonor, on line 11, there is just, on line 7, another \"or\n\n11\n\nforeign\" that we need to omit.\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\nThank you.\n\nSo from the second\n\n13\n\nelement, page 20, line 7, the sentence that begins with\n\n14\n\n\"Second,\" cutting \"or foreign.\"\n\n15\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nOkay.\n\nPage 21, your Honor.\n\nOn line 4, I'll\n\n16\n\njust reiterate, I understand this has been overruled by the\n\n17\n\nCourt but we would propose replacing \"an individual\" with the\n\n18\n\nword \"Jane.\"\n\n19\n\nomitted.\n\n20\n21\n\nOn line 5, there is \"or foreign,\" which should be\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThank you.\n\nPage 21, line 5, \"to travel in\n\ninterstate commerce,\" cutting \"or foreign.\"\n\n22\n\nOkay.\n\n23\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n24\n\nobjection to the word \"coerced.\"\n\n25\n\noverruled.\n\nOn line 6 we would just reiterate our\nI understand that's been\n\nBut then, your Honor, generally I would say the\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827080\n\n", "char_count": 1432}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 24 of 95\n\n2762\n\nLCI1MAX1\nword \"coerced\" we would like to remove.\n\nWe understand that's\n\nbeen overruled by the Court.\nOkay.\n\nBut there is some additional language we would\n\n4\n\npropose at the end of line 6, and this is something that I\n\n5\n\nraised I think in a letter submission in -- or not in a\n\n6\n\nletter -- orally at the Rule 29 argument.\n\n7\n\nv. Broxmeyer, which, as I argued to the Court at the Rule 29\n\n8\n\nargument, the words \"persuade,\" \"induce,\" and \"entice\" are\n\n9\n\nwords of causation and they need to cause an effect, and so\n\n10\n\nwhat we would propose after the sentence, \"The terms\n\n11\n\n'persuaded,'\n\n12\n\nordinary, everyday meanings,\" we would propose adding the\n\n13\n\nfollowing language:\n\n14\n\n'persuasion,'\n\n15\n\ntravel in interstate commerce as alleged in the indictment.\"\n\n16\n\nWe're basing that on U.S. v. Broxmeyer, interpreting those\n\n17\n\nwords from a different but related statute.\n\ninduced,\"enticed,' and 'coerced' have their\n\n\"This element is satisfied only if the\n\ninducement,' or 'enticement' caused Jane to\n\n18\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n19\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n20\n\nGive me one moment.\nI have a copy of Broxmeyer, your Honor,\n\nif you'd like to see it.\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n22\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n23\n\nIt's based on U.S.\n\nSure.\n\nI'll take it.\n\nYour Honor, I believe it's on page 125\n\nof the opinion.\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\n25\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nThe relevant language.\n\nYour Honor, this is not just a\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827081\n\n", "char_count": 1507}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 25 of 95\n\n2763\n\nLCIlMAX1\ndifferent statute, it's quite a different statute.\nproduction of child pornography statute.\n\nIt's the\n\nAnd also, the\n\nquestion in Broxmeyer was somewhat different.\n\nIt was a\n\n4\n\nsufficiency of the evidence question about whether the\n\n5\n\ngovernment's evidence showed that the persuasion or inducement\n\n6\n\noccurred before the production of the child pornography, and so\n\n7\n\nthat's -- I don't think that this case stands for a particular,\n\n8\n\nlike, form of causal nexus that's required between\n\n9\n\n\"persuasion,\" \"inducement,\" or \"coercion\" and the travel\n\n10\n\nitself.\n\n11\n\nalong those lines because it suggests that some amount of\n\n12\n\ncausation is required above the inherent causation in the\n\n13\n\nstatutory terms of inducement or enticement.\n\n14\n\nof causation, but they are sort of words of causation in the\n\n15\n\nplain and ordinary sense and not in any greater or more\n\n16\n\nsignificant sense that I think a further instruction on that\n\n17\n\npoint would suggest.\n\n18\n\nI think the jury will be confused by an instruction\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThose are words\n\nYour Honor, if I could just respond.\n\nI\n\n19\n\ndon't think this is heightening the level of proof.\n\nI think\n\n20\n\nthis is simply -- the opinion is simply explaining what is\n\n21\n\nrequired by those words, \"persuasion,\" \"inducement,\"\n\n22\n\n\"enticement,\" and those words are the exact same words that are\n\n23\n\nused in the statute, so I don't think the context of the case\n\n24\n\nreally matters in terms of what those words mean.\n\n25\n\nsome inherent causation built into these words, but this is\n\nThere may be\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827082\n\n", "char_count": 1694}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 26 of 95\n\n2764\n\nLCIlMAX1\nexplaining the fact that that causation needs to exist.\n\nIn\n\ncase there's any doubt in the minds of the jurors, there does\nneed to be causation.\n4\n\nThere has to be an effect from the\n\ninducement, the persuasion, the enticement.\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n5\n\nFirst there has to be some sort of\n\n6\n\ncausal relationship.\n\n7\n\nfor example, as a form of a causal relationship.\n\n8\n\nnot aware of any case or treatise that provided this\n\n9\n\ninstruction.\n\n10\n\nthe fact that it is in Broxmeyer does not mean it's appropriate\n\n11\n\nto give a further and more specific instruction about causation\n\n12\n\nthan is already inherent in the ordinary meaning of these\n\n13\n\nwords.\n\n14\n15\n16\n\nThat's what the word \"inducement\" means,\n\nMaybe perhaps defense counsel is.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI'm certainly\n\nBut, you know,\n\nJust so I have my head around it, the\n\nspecific suggestion was what, Mr. Everdell?\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n\"This element is satisfied only if the\n\n17\n\npersuasion, inducement, or enticement caused Jane,\" or we can\n\n18\n\nsay \"caused the individual,\" \"to travel in interstate commerce\n\n19\n\nas alleged in the indictment.\"\n\n20\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nThe problem, your Honor, is that to the\n\n21\n\nextent that those words already mean to cause, inducement has a\n\n22\n\ncausal meaning, persuasion has a causal meaning.\n\n23\n\nin the instruction.\n\n24\n\nwords if she caused the travel suggests that there are two\n\n25\n\nrequirements -- there's the requirement that the defendant\n\nIt's already\n\nAnd to say, you can only satisfy those\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827083\n\n", "char_count": 1621}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 27 of 95\n\n2765\n\nLCI1MAX1\ninduced the travel, and a separate requirement that she caused\nthe travel.\n\nAnd there's no causal obligation or causal\n\nrequirement in the statute above and beyond the persuasion,\n4\n\ninducement type causal requirement.\n\n5\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nI mean, your Honor, if the objection is\n\n6\n\nto the preamble by saying, \"This element is satisfied only if,\"\n\n7\n\nwe could modify that a bit, if the government's saying that is\n\n8\n\ntoo strong, but the guts of the suggestion is that the\n\n9\n\npersuasion, inducement, or enticement must have caused the\n\n10\n\nindividual to travel in interstate commerce, as alleged in the\n\n11\n\nindictment.\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n13\n\nof cases.\n\n14\n\n2010.\n\n15\n\nI mean, I've seen this charge in a variety\n\nI've never seen that language.\n\nThis decision is\n\nHave you ever seen it in a charge?\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nI can't say that I have, your Honor\n\n16\n\nBut it is interpreting the very words of the statute that are\n\n17\n\nat issue here, and I don't think this is the way that -- the\n\n18\n\nproposal I'm proposing is not trying to belabor the point, but\n\n19\n\nit is trying to raise the issue of causation.\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI mean, the opinion includes further\n\n21\n\ndefinition of the words that are subject to the ordinary\n\n22\n\nmeaning, the paragraph above that you point to.\n\n23\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nYour Honor, I'll add that it is\n\n24\n\npossible to be persuaded, induced or enticed, and then not\n\n25\n\nactually travel.\n\nI mean, the persuasion does have to cause the\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827084\n\n", "char_count": 1599}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 28 of 95\n\n2766\n\nLCI1MAX1\ntravel, so that there has to be a causation, some effect of the\npersuasion.\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nWell, the instructions say that there\n\n4\n\nhas to be persuasion and inducement or enticement to travel,\n\n5\n\nand the individual has to actually travel.\n\n6\n\nall already captured in the instruction.\n\n7\n\nfor this element are just -- or this offense are quite standard\n\n8\n\nthat are in the Court's jury charge.\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThose concepts are\n\nThese instructions\n\nYeah, I think that's right.\n\nIt seems to\n\n10\n\nme -- well, one, it's a standard charge for this provision;\n\n11\n\ntwo, it's accurate; three, adding -- I mean, it seems to me\n\n12\n\nthat the basic suggestion applies additional causation beyond\n\n13\n\nwhat's required by the ordinary meaning, and I don't see a\n\n14\n\nbasis for that.\n\nSo I will overrule the request.\n\n15\n\nWhat's next?\n\n16\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n20\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n21\n\nYes.\n\nThis is at line 15 through 22, which is\n\nthe instruction on significant or motivating purpose -THE COURT:\n\n23\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n25\n\nYour Honor, next request is at page 23.\n\nOkay.\n\n22\n\n24\n\nOne moment, your Honor?\n\nYes.\n-- which was a suggestion from the\n\ndefense, and we appreciate the Court's inclusion.\nTHE COURT:\n\nWell, I think you'd suggested significant\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827085\n\n", "char_count": 1427}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 29 of 95\n\n2767\n\nLCI1MAX1\nand, if I'm remembering correctly -MR. EVERDELL:\nTHE COURT:\n4\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nYes.\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThat may be true.\n\nGo ahead.\n\nSo we have found a different\n\n5\n\ninstruction on this point which we would ask the Court to\n\n6\n\nconsider, and it comes from United States v.\n\n7\n\nhand that up to the Court and the government.\n\n8\n9\n10\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nand I can\n\nJust to be clear, I adopted your\n\nsuggestion and now you're asking me to do something different.\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nWell, it is true, your Honor, and I\n\n11\n\nwill keep what I have, if this is objectionable to the Court.\n\n12\n\nBut we only found this one as we were looking through with\n\n13\n\nrespect to the charge.\n\n14\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nIt happens.\n\nto my notes on this one.\n\n16\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n17\n\nproposed instruction.\n\n18\n19\n\ngiven by Judge Rakoff.\nTHE COURT:\n\n21\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n23\n\nYour Honor, I can give a typewritten\n\nPage 211 of the opinion is the instruction that was\n\n20\n\n22\n\nJust give me a moment to get\n\nAnd what's the charge in the\nWell, your Honor,\n\ncase?\nwas found\n\nguilty of 2422 and 2423, the same statutes we're talking about.\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\nSo the proposal is, in order to\n\n24\n\nestablish the element, the government must prove that it was\n\n25\n\npart of Ms. Maxwell's conscious purpose in having Jane travel\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827086\n\n", "char_count": 1419}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 30 of 95\n\n2768\n\nLCIlMAX1\nacross state lines to have her engage in criminal sexual\nconduct, in violation of New York law.\n\nIt need not have been\n\nher only purpose or motivation, but it must have been more than\n4\n\nmerely incidental.\n\n5\n\npurposes of the trip.\n\n6\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nIt must have been one of the dominant\n\nYour Honor, all that the law requires\n\n7\n\nis that it be one of the dominant purposes of the trip, which\n\n8\n\nis the instruction that the defense originally sought and the\n\n9\n\nCourt gave.\n\n10\n\n\"dominant\" as \"significant or motivating purpose\" to avoid\n\n11\n\nconfusion, because it doesn't have to be the sole dominant\n\n12\n\npurpose, it just has to be a dominant purpose, and so from\n\n13\n\nSand, that creates ambiguity that it has to be a sufficient\n\n14\n\nsuch a big purpose that it's the dominant purpose, which is not\n\n15\n\nwhat is required by the statute.\n\n16\n\nthere's an additional requirement, which is that it be some\n\n17\n\nsort of conscious purpose to engage in the particular criminal\n\n18\n\nviolation suggesting knowledge of the criminal statute and\n\n19\n\ncriminal prohibition.\n\n20\n\nthis instruction is not error.\n\n21\n\nthe required instruction by -- at least as I'm reading the --\n\n22\n\nI'm reading the\n\n23\n\nan appeal from a conviction on that instruction.\n\n24\n\nsuggesting that it's required by --\n\n25\n\nIt's the practice, as Sand endorses, to rephrase\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThis instruction suggests\n\nAll the\n\ncase does is affirm that\nIt does not say that that is\n\ncase for the first time now, but it is\n\nLet me look.\n\nIt is not\n\nI've only read the --\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827087\n\n", "char_count": 1674}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 31 of 95\n\n2769\n\nLCIlMAX1\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nI've only read portions of it too, but\n\nthat's my quick read.\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo the defendant's argument in\n\nwas\n\n4\n\nthat the prostitution or other criminal sexual activity must be\n\n5\n\nthe dominant purpose of the interstate travel rather than only\n\n6\n\none of the dominant purposes as the judge charged.\n\n7\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nIn fact, your Honor, I think in light\n\n8\n\nof that conclusion, the final sentence of the defense's\n\n9\n\nproposed instruction would be suggestive of error because the\n\n10\n\npoint is that -- or at least creates the very confusion that\n\n11\n\narose in\n\n12\n\npurposes.\n\n13\n\nconfusion, as Sand has explained.\n\n14\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nabout whether it has to be one of the dominant\nThe use of the word \"dominant\" is a source of\n\nWell, your Honor, on that point, the\n\n15\n\n-anguage \"significant or motivating purpose\" is completely\n\n16\n\ninvented by Sand, right, and now people have used it because\n\n17\n\nSand is an authority in this area, but that does not -- that\n\n18\n\ndid not come from case law.\n\n19\n\nwith the issue of the dominant purpose versus one dominant\n\n20\n\npurpose.\n\n21\n\nthe instruction \"one dominant purpose\" is accepted instruction,\n\n22\n\nand the\n\n23\n\nthe charge that was given by Judge Rakoff and they said it was\n\n24\n\nperfectly proper to give that charge.\n\n25\n\nthere is more support in the case law for the \"one dominant\n\nThat is Sand's proposal to deal\n\nThere is, however, case law in many circuits where\n\ncase endorses that instruction because that was\n\nSo I actually think\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827088\n\n", "char_count": 1649}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 32 of 95\n\n2770\n\nLC1lmAxl\npurpose\" language than language that happened to have been\ninvented by Sand.\n\nAs smart as Judge Sand was, that did not\n\nactually come from any circuit case law.\n\nSo we propose going\n\n4\n\nwith what the courts have actually said on this issue rather\n\n5\n\nthan a proposal in Sand.\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI'm just going to read for a moment.\n\n7\n\nI think I want to start by asking what's wrong with\n\n8\n\nthe current instruction, the one that you proposed that I\n\n9\n\nadopted?\n\nThat's the one that I've seen in\n\n10\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n12\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nWell --\n\n-- in charges.\nYour Honor, there's nothing wrong with\n\n13\n\nit per se.\n\n14\n\nand we proposed it, so we obviously think it's acceptable.\n\n15\n\nI think the new proposed charge is a charge that is more\n\n16\n\naccurate and also tracks the case law development on this point\n\n17\n\nbecause the dominant purpose is actually something that was in\n\n18\n\na Second Circuit opinion and it's, you know -- Judge Rakoff has\n\n19\n\ntried to craft an instruction in\n\n20\n\nof one dominant purpose versus the dominant purpose, but the\n\n21\n\nway that I think the case law has developed in the Second\n\n22\n\nCircuit, it started with \"dominant purpose\" was the language\n\n23\n\nused and then we had to deal with this issue of ambiguity\n\n24\n\nthere, and this is how Judge Rakoff came out, but was still\n\n25\n\nkeeping the \"dominant purpose\" language but clarifying it was\n\nIt is a charge that has been used in other cases,\nBut\n\nto deal with the issue\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827089\n\n", "char_count": 1613}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 33 of 95\n\n2771\n\nLC1lmAxl\nonly one of the dominant purposes.\nTHE COURT:\n\nLet me just note my remarkably crack law\n\nclerks have found the following case:\n\nUnited States v. An Soon\n\n4\n5\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n7\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n9\n\n82 (2d Cir. 2012).\n\nSummary order, obviously, but it says a\n\n10\n\ncouple of things.\n\nOne -- ooh, I lost what my crack law clerk\n\n11\n\nsent there.\n\n12\n\n\"These instructions are legally sound.\n\n13\n\n'predominant' appear in the statutory language.\n\n14\n\nhave previously approved a jury charge that included the phrase\n\n15\n\n\"one of the dominant purposes,\" (see, e.g.,\n\n16\n\nrequired such language to appear in a jury charge on 2421.\n\n17\n\nIndeed, Judge Sand recommends excluding the word 'dominant'\n\n18\n\nfrom the charge so as to avoid confusion.\"\n\n19\n\nof the opinion, \"The charge given by the district court, which\n\n20\n\nclosely tracks the charge outlined by Judge Sand, accurately\n\n21\n\nand thoroughly conveyed the second element of the crime.\n\n22\n\nAccordingly, we find no error, much less plain error, in the\n\n23\n\njury charge.\"\n\n24\n25\n\nYes.\n\nYou're aware of it.\nYes.\n\nBut that case --\n\nJust let me give the cite.\n\n471 F. App'x\n\nIt endorses the Sand language over \"dominant.\"\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nYes.\n\nNeither 'dominant' nor\nAlthough we\n\n) we've never\n\nAnd then at the end\n\nSo the way I read that case, your\n\nHonor, is that there are two variants on how this charge has\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827090\n\n", "char_count": 1525}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "Case 1:2O-cr-OO33O-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 34 of 95\n\n2772\n\nLCI1MAX1\nbeen given in the Second Circuit, both of which have been\nendorsed by the Second Circuit, neither of which is required\nbut both are permissible.\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nBut I think what we have here is Second\n\n5\n\nCircuit agreeing with Sand that \"dominant\" can be confusing.\n\n6\n\nAnd so I will stick with your original proposal and not the\n\n7\n\nrequest to change that out now for the language adopted by\n\n8\n\nJudge Rakoff because it would include the -- although deemed\n\n9\n\nnot error, it would include the \"one dominant purpose\"\n\n10\n\nlanguage, which is potentially confusing and not moored to the\n\n11\n\ntext of the statute.\n\n12\n\nWhat's next?\n\n13\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n14\n\nThe next page, your Honor?\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n16\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n17\n\nYes, please.\nPage 24.\n\nSo this is the page where the\n\ncharge describes the violation of New York law.\n\n18\n19\n\nUnderstood, your Honor.\n\nTHE COURT:\nversion.\n\nPage?\n\nII, I'm sorry.\n\nI'm on my annotated\n\nJust a second.\n\n20\n\nYes.\n\n21\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nWell, first, this one very small change\n\n22\n\non line 19, if we could replace \"the defendant\" with\n\n23\n\n\"Ms. Maxwell.\"\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n25\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nOkay.\nBut there's a larger request.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827091\n\n", "char_count": 1300}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 35 of 95\n\n2773\n\nLCI1MAX1\nTHE COURT:\nthat change.\n\nAll right.\n\nPage 24, line 19, I'll adopt\n\nSo instead of \"the defendant,\" \"Ms. Maxwell.\"\n\nJust one moment.\n4\n\nOkay.\n\n5\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nOkay.\n\nSo the additional request is --\n\n6\n\nthis is where the issue of the fact that Kate was above the age\n\n7\n\nof consent and about the fact that -- well, Annie's testimony\n\n8\n\nwas not a violation of New York law.\n\n9\n\ngave the limiting instruction to the jury on.\n\n10\n\nis appropriate to incorporate those limiting instructions into\n\n11\n\nthe jury charge and that this is the place where it should be\n\n12\n\ngiven.\n\n13\n\nat the time of the testimony -- that is what we asked for and\n\n14\n\nwe appreciate the Court doing that -- but I think that they\n\n15\n\nneed to be instructed again before they go into deliberations,\n\n16\n\nnow having heard 12 plus days of testimony, that what those\n\n17\n\nconsiderations -- that testimony they are allowed to consider\n\n18\n\nfor what purpose, because if they're given an instruction on\n\n19\n\nNew York law, I think it's time to reiterate in the charge to\n\n20\n\nthem that Kate was over the age of consent and was not\n\n21\n\ninvolved -- it cannot be considered illegal sexual activity,\n\n22\n\nbecause this is where the illegal sexual activity is defined.\n\n23\n\nAnd same with Annie.\n\n24\n\nhere, but it tracks the language of the limiting instruction\n\n25\n\nthe Court gave, so I don't think it's adding any language.\n\nThat's what the Court\nWe think that it\n\nBecause it's one thing to give the limiting instruction\n\nI have a proposed instruction to add\n\nI\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827092\n\n", "char_count": 1668}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 36 of 95\n\n2774\n\nLCIlMAX1\ncan hand it up.\nTHE COURT:\n\nSure.\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nAnd your Honor, as you consider that,\n\n4\n\nthere is one proposed addition I just want to request to what's\n\n5\n\non that page, but I want to handle that slightly separately.\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n7\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThe representation is these are -Yeah.\n\n-- my limiting instructions given before\n\n9\n\nKate and\n\n10\n\ninclusion -- repetition of those limiting instructions where\n\n11\n\nthe violation of New York criminal law is provided.\n\n12\n\ntestified, and you're asking for\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThat's correct, your Honor.\n\nAnd we\n\n13\n\nwould propose just putting it at the end after the discussion\n\n14\n\nthat's already there.\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nMr. Rohrbach.\n\n16\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nI think that among other things, your\n\n17\n\nHonor, I think that would be -- the instruction as you've\n\n18\n\ncrafted it is a correct statement of New York law and the\n\n19\n\nrelevant issues.\n\n20\n\nconfusing to the jury.\n\n21\n\nis the place where there's no reason to give the Kate\n\n22\n\ninstruction because these jury instructions state specifically\n\n23\n\nthat the jury may not convict based solely on overt acts that\n\n24\n\nrelate to Kate, and so there is no risk, when these full set of\n\n25\n\ninstructions is read to the jury, that they will think that\n\nAdding these instructions would be quite\nThe jury has already heard them.\n\nThis\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827093\n\n", "char_count": 1491}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 37 of 95\n\n2775\n\nLC1lmAxl\nthey can convict based on the illegal sexual activity as it\nrelates to Kate and as it relates to Annie.\n\nAnnie only relates\n\nto the conspiracy counts, at least as to these\n\nAct\n\n4\n\ncharges, and the jury is going to be instructed here that the\n\n5\n\nrelevant illegal sexual activity has to be the violation of the\n\n6\n\nNew York offense.\n\n7\n\nthink that the sexual contact that happened in New Mexico is\n\n8\n\nsomething that on its own is sufficient to show the illegal\n\n9\n\nsexual activity required by the statute.\n\n10\n\nset of instructions, there's no need for an additional\n\n11\n\ninstruction, especially on top of the fact that the Court has\n\n12\n\nalready given these limiting instructions to the jury.\n\nSo again, there's no risk that the jury will\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right.\n\n14\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nSo, here, in the full\n\nI agree with that.\n\nWell, your Honor, there's one other\n\n15\n\nissue, which is the part that's not in the typewritten\n\n16\n\ninstruction I handed you, which is the fact that Jane testified\n\n17\n\nabout traveling to New Mexico at various times in her\n\n18\n\ntestimony.\n\n19\n\nshe was under the age of 16, which -- 15 or 16 I think is what\n\n20\n\nshe said as to that trip, which we believe is the actual legal\n\n21\n\nage of consent in New Mexico; but she also testified about\n\n22\n\nother travel to New Mexico, where events took place, where\n\n23\n\nsexual contact took place, and so I think with respect to that,\n\n24\n\nwe are going to need some kind of instruction to the jury that\n\n25\n\nif she's above the age of consent in New Mexico, that can't be\n\nAnd there was I think one trip she may have said\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827094\n\n", "char_count": 1736}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 38 of 95\n\n2776\n\nLCIlMAX1\nconsidered illegal sexual activity for the purposes of their\ndeliberations.\n\nIt's not as charged in the indictment.\n\nWe're\n\ntalking about New York law, so I don't know if that was made\n4\n\nclear to the jury.\n\n5\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nYour Honor, these instructions do not\n\n6\n\nput before the jury any violation of any New Mexico offense\n\n7\n\nwhatsoever above or below the age of consent, so I think\n\n8\n\nthere's no risk that the jury is going to convict the defendant\n\n9\n\nbased on their concerns about a violation of a New York\n\n10\n\noffense.\n\n11\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThat's not really the issue about what\n\n12\n\ninstructions to put before the jury.\n\n13\n\nthe jury, sexual contact between Jane and Epstein in New Mexico\n\n14\n\nafter what we believe is the age of consent in New Mexico, and\n\n15\n\nso if --\n\n16\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThe testimony put before\n\nThat's why, I think, it's the same reason\n\n17\n\nI gave limiting instructions as asked with respect to the\n\n18\n\ntestimony of Kate and Annie.\n\n19\n\nis, you meant to ask for a limiting instruction at that time?\n\n20\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nI think what I'm hearing you say\n\nWell, your Honor, we knew from the\n\n21\n\nproffered 3500s for the other witnesses what they were planning\n\n22\n\non testifying to, so we were able to request those at the time\n\n23\n\nbefore the witnesses testified and brief those in limine.\n\n24\n\ndidn't think we -- what we knew about Jane ahead of time was\n\n25\n\nthat she alleged that she traveled to New Mexico but that\n\nI\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827095\n\n", "char_count": 1599}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 39 of 95\n\n2777\n\nLC1lmAxl\nnothing happened on the New Mexico trips, and then I think it\ncame out in the testimony -- unless the government wants to\ncorrect me if we're wrong about that, but I think that our\n4\n\nstatus of our knowledge was that we weren't expecting to hear\n\n5\n\nabout testimony about sexual contact in New Mexico.\n\n6\n\ncan correct me if I'm wrong about that.\n\n7\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nBut they\n\nI believe that Jane only testified as\n\n8\n\nto one sexual incident of sexual abuse in New Mexico and that\n\n9\n\nthat was reflected in the 3500 material.\n\n10\n\nis looking for it, but it should not have been a surprise to\n\n11\n\nthe defense.\nYeah.\n\nI think Ms. Pomerantz\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI mean, the problem -- the\n\n13\n\ninstructions are accurate.\n\n14\n\nYork law.\n\n15\n\nthe limiting instructions that I gave with respect to Annie and\n\n16\n\nKate, but I did give those instructions.\n\n17\n\nthere was an instance in which the defense might have requested\n\n18\n\none following a particular piece of testimony.\n\n19\n\nnow, having not -- well, let me put it this way.\n\n20\n\nasked for a limiting instruction then I don't think provides a\n\n21\n\nbasis for inclusion of limiting instructions, repetition of\n\n22\n\nlimiting instructions in the charge, and even without it, which\n\n23\n\nwas the government's original argument, it's clear that the\n\n24\n\nviolation of law is as charged in New York.\n\n25\n\npersuaded to include it.\n\nIt's clear it's a violation of New\n\nThis was the government's argument for not giving\n\nIt sounds like maybe\n\nTo add that\nHaving not\n\nSo I'm not\n\nI'm not persuaded to include it.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827096\n\n", "char_count": 1689}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "Case 1:2O-cr-OO33O-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 40 of 95\n\n2778\n\nLCI1MAX1\nMR. EVERDELL:\nOkay.\n\nUnderstood, your Honor.\n\nNext page, your Honor?\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes.\n\n4\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n6\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThe next one we have is on page 26.\n\nOkay.\nWe would reiterate, just for the\n\n7\n\npurposes of the record, of including \"Jane\" as opposed to \"an\n\n8\n\nindividual\" or \"the individual.\"\n\n9\n\nwill ask that the word \"solely\" be included on line 12, so,\n\n10\n\n\"Count Four also relates solely to Jane.\"\n\n11\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n13\n\n16\n17\n18\n19\n\nNo objection.\n\nOkay.\n\nWe'll make that change.\n\nAnd my\n\nclerk tells me we missed an \"and foreign\" on page 25.\n\n14\n15\n\nThat's been overruled, but we\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\npage 25.\n\nYes, yes.\n\nSo we do have to go back to\n\nSo on line 5, there's an \"or foreign.\"\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo that will be with the ellipses.\n\nSo\n\npage 25, line 5, \"interstate... commerce...\"\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nYes.\n\nAnd there's one other thing on\n\nthat page, your Honor, I forgot to mention.\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nJust a moment.\n\n21\n\nOkay.\n\n22\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nGo ahead.\nYour Honor, on line 4 of that same\n\n23\n\npage, 25, I know it's a quote from the statute, which does say,\n\n24\n\n\"knowingly transports any individual under the age of 18,\" but\n\n25\n\nthis is the issue with New York law being under the age of 17,\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827097\n\n", "char_count": 1386}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "Case 1:2O-cr-OO33O-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 41 of 95\n\n2779\n\nLCI1MAX1\nwhich is on the next page, page 26.\n\nThe third element says\n\nthat the defendant knew that Jane was less than 17 years old.\nTHE COURT:\n\nDo you want to do bracket?\n\n4\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n6\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nYeah, I think we should do a bracket.\n\nMr. Rohrbach?\nThat's fine.\n\nThe government proposed\n\n7\n\nperhaps an awkward instruction I think to perhaps explain this\n\n8\n\nto the jury.\n\n9\n\nThis is an elegant solution.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI spent an inordinate amount of time\n\n10\n\nthinking through precisely this question, and I decided that\n\n11\n\nit's best just to do this because it would just be confusing.\n\n12\n\nI mean, it is a separate element, but it would just be\n\n13\n\nconfusing.\n\n14\n\nSo I think this is a good suggestion.\n\nPage 25.\n\nSo we'll take out -- well, why don't we do\n\n15\n\nthis.\n\n16\n\ninterstate commerce.\"\n\n17\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThat's fine, your Honor.\n\n18\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nThat's fine with the government.\n\n19\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThat's perfectly acceptable.\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n21\n\nWhy don't we do \"under [the age of 17 years] in\n\nSo page 25, line 4, \"Any individual under\n\n[the age of 17 years] in interstate commerce.\"\n\n22\n\nOkay.\n\n23\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n24\n25\n\nWhat's next?\nWe covered page 26 already, so -- and\n\non page 27, I believe there's an \"or foreign\" issue, so line 5.\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes.\n\nPage 27, line 5, deleting \"or\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827098\n\n", "char_count": 1471}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "Case 1:2O-cr-OO33O-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 42 of 95\n\n2780\n\nLCI1MAX1\nforeign.\"\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nAnd then also on lines 7 to 8, it said,\n\n\"from one state to another or between the United States and a\n4\n\nforeign country,\" so we should eliminate \"or between the United\n\n5\n\nStates and a foreign country.\"\n\n6\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nNo objection.\n\nOkay.\n\nPage 27, lines 7 through 8 -- II,\n\n8\n\nand also the sentence above has \"or foreign\" in the quote, so\n\n9\n\nwe'll ellipses I guess the phrase \"transport an individual in\n\n10\n\ninterstate,\" cutting \"or foreign,\" adding \"... commerce.\"\n\n11\n\nthen the next line, ending the sentence after \"another,\" so it\n\n12\n\nwould read \"from one state to another,\" cutting \"or between the\n\n13\n\nUnited States and a foreign country.\"\n\nAnd\n\n14\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n16\n\n■. My clerk makes a good point. We should just cut\n\n17\n\n\"or foreign\" in that quote, not do ellipses, because I'm just\n\n18\n\nquoting myself.\n\nHang on one second.\n\n19\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n21\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nThat's right.\n\nOkay.\n\nSo line 6 is just \"transporting an\n\nindividual in interstate commerce.\"\n\n22\n\nOkay.\n\n23\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nNext.\nAnd your Honor, I did just notice\n\n24\n\nsomething, because I always forget to focus on the titles\n\n25\n\nsometimes, but for Count Four, they all refer to transportation\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827099\n\n", "char_count": 1401}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "Case 1:2O-cr-OO33O-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 43 of 95\n\n2781\n\nLCIlMAX1\n\nof a minor to engage in, so I think we need to change the\ntitles for Count Four, and I can get you the pages in a second,\nbut \"transportation of an individual under 18 to engage in\n4\n\nillegal sexual activity.\"\n\n5\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nThat's fine, your Honor, but this\n\n6\n\nactually raises a related question, which is just whether the\n\n7\n\nCourt sends the indictment back with the jury, since I think\n\n8\n\nthe indictment has the same issue.\n\n9\n\noffenses in their captions as \"of a minor.\"\n\n10\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nIt describes some of the\n\nWell, what are the parties' positions on\n\nthat?\n\n12\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nThe government is not seeking to send\n\n13\n\nthe indictment back, your Honor.\n\n14\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n16\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nOne moment, your Honor.\n\nYes.\nYour Honor, the defense would not like\n\n17\n\nthat to happen.\n\n18\n\nabout what they need to know about the law.\n\n19\n20\n\nWe think that the instructions advise the jury\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYou're saying you don't want to send the\n\nindictment back.\n\n21\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n23\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n24\n25\n\nThat's so rare.\n\nRight.\n\nYou're in vigorous agreement.\nII, I thought we were disagreeing.\n\nYes, we're in agreement with that.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI don't send it back unless the parties\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827100\n\n", "char_count": 1380}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 44 of 95\n\n2782\n\nLCI1MAX1\nagree.\nMR. ROHRBACH:\nagreement.\n4\n\nHow about that?\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n6\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n7\n\npages 25, 26, 27 --\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo then the edit to this title is\n\nAnd this one\nSo, your Honor, this would apply to\n\nCan you give me the instruction numbers,\n\nbecause my clerk's pages are off now that we made edits.\n\n10\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n11\n\nme get the first one.\n\n12\n\nit.\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n14\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n15\n\nWe're in\n\nfine and there's no need to make it track the indictment.\n\n5\n\n9\n\nThat's fine, your Honor.\n\nYes, sure.\n\nIt's Instruction No. -- let\n\n18, 19, 20, 21, 22, and I think that's\n\nOkay.\n\nAnd the request here is?\n\nWe would change the title to\n\n\"Transportation of an Individual Under 18 to Engage In\n\n16\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nIt would be 17.\n\n17\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n17, yes.\n\n18\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\nSo for all of the Count Four\n\n19\n\ntitles, we'll change \"a Minor\" to \"an Individual Under the Age\n\n20\n\nof 17.\"\n\n21\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nAnd I'm sure the Court will likely make\n\n22\n\nthis change automatically, but just to note that that change\n\n23\n\nwould need to be reflected in the Table of Contents as well.\n\n24\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI believe that auto-populates it.\n\nI\n\nwouldn't know how to do that, but I believe that's what\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827101\n\n", "char_count": 1351}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "Case 1:2O-cr-OO33O-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 45 of 95\n\n2783\n\nLCI1MAX1\n\nhappens.\n\nBut we will double-check it.\nOkay.\n\nWhat's next, Mr. Everdell?\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n4\n\ncharge.\n\nWe understand that's been overruled.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n8\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n11\n\nLines 11\n\nto 17.\n\n7\n\n10\n\nWell, your Honor, just page 28, to\n\npreserve our suggestion, we would request to substitute the\n\n5\n6\n\nThank you.\n\nOkay.\nThen I think we can skip to page 32.\n\nThat was your first one, right,\n\nMr. Rohrbach?\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nIt was, although, your Honor, we have,\n\n12\n\nin the course of our conversations, resolved that, so the\n\n13\n\ngovernment has no -- our next edit, our next request, is on\n\n14\n\npage 69, actually.\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n16\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n17\n\nOkay.\n\nPage 32, Mr. Everdell.\n\nYes, still on 32 for the defense.\n\nWe\n\nrequest on line 10, \"This count relates solely to Carolyn.\"\n\n18\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nNo objection.\n\nOkay.\n\nThank you.\n\nWe'll make that change.\n\n20\n\nInstruction No. 25, line 10, \"This count relates,\" adding the\n\n21\n\nword \"solely,\" \"to Carolyn.\"\n\n22\n\nAll right.\n\n23\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n25\n\nMr. Everdell, next page.\nOne moment, your Honor.\n\nMy clerk notes that we have \"Minor\" in the\n\nheading of all the Count Six --\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827102\n\n", "char_count": 1317}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "Case 1:2O-cr-OO33O-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 46 of 95\n\n2784\n\nLCI1MAX1\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nSo this one, because the statute is 18,\n\nit would have to be sex trafficking of an individual under the\nage of 18.\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n5\n\nMr. Rohrbach?\n\n6\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n8\n\nOkay.\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\nNos.\n\n11\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n15\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThat is Instruction\n\nSo for all of those, we'll take out\n\nRight.\n\nNext page.\nOkay.\n\nSo we just dealt with page 32,\n\nwhich is the addition of the word \"solely\" on line 10?\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\nedit.\n\nYes.\nAll right.\n\nThen on page 35, small\n\nAt line 13, replace \"the defendant\" with \"Ms. Maxwell.\"\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\nPage 35, line 13, replacing \"the\n\n21\n\ndefendant\" with \"Ms. Maxwell.\"\n\n22\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n23\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n24\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n25\n\nYou want to call them\n\n\"a Minor\" and replace with \"an Individual Under the Age of 18.\"\n\n14\n\n20\n\nSure, your Honor.\n\nOkay.\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n19\n\nSo go ahead.\n\njust a minute -- 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, and 29.\n\n13\n\n16\n\nNo objection, your Honor.\n\noff, the instruction numbers for that, Mr. Everdell?\n\n9\n10\n\nI agree with that.\n\nYeah.\n\nOkay.\nOkay.\n\nYes.\n\nAnd just for clarity's\n\nsake, your Honor, we're not replacing every instance of the\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827103\n\n", "char_count": 1306}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "Case 1:2O-cr-OO33O-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 47 of 95\n\n2785\n\nLC1lmAxl\n\nword \"defendant\" with \"Ms. Maxwell.\"\n\nWe tried to pick the ones\n\nwhich made sense, and I understand the Court did the same.\nTHE COURT:\n\nI was trying to do that as well, as is\n\n4\n\ntypical in my charges.\n\n5\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n6\n\nSo I think our next one is not until\n\nYes, understood.\nI'm just\n\n7\n\nchecking with my colleagues -- is not until page 49, but give\n\n8\n\nme one minute.\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n10\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n11\n\nOkay.\nOkay.\n\nActually, your Honor, if we go\n\nback to page 44.\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n13\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n14\n\n\"minors\" again, right?\n\n15\n\nthe conspiracy, but, \"Count One charges Ms. Maxwell with\n\n16\n\nparticipating in a conspiracy\" etc., etc. \"to entice minors to\n\n17\n\ntravel and engage in sexual activity.\"\n\n18\n\ninstances of \"minors\" in line 15.\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n44?\n\nOkay.\n\nSo this is line 4.\n\nThis is a discussion of the elements of\n\nAnd there are other\n\nIt's \"to transport minors.\"\n\nSo for all of these, this would be \"an\n\n20\n\nindividual under the age of 17.\"\n\n21\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n22\n\nline 6, line 15, and line 19.\n\n23\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n24\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n25\n\nWe have the word\n\nWell, yes.\n\nSo it's going to be line 4,\n\nMr. Rohrbach?\nThat's fine, your Honor.\n\nAnd I would\n\nnote in the next paragraph, there is a reference to \"minor,\"\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827104\n\n", "char_count": 1381}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "Case 1:2O-cr-OO33O-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 48 of 95\n\n2786\n\nLCI1MAX1\n\nand there the change should be \"under the age of 18\" rather\nthan 17, but the conforming changes make sense.\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\n4\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nLet me just articulate these.\n\nThat's fine.\n\nSo Instruction No. 34 on lines 4, 6, 15,\n\n6\n\nand 19, we're going to replace \"minors\" with \"individuals under\n\n7\n\nthe age of 17.\"\n\n8\n9\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\nyour Honor.\n\n10\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n12\n\nAnd there's one on line 10 as well,\n\nAs well as line 13, your Honor.\n\nCome on.\n\nThe clerks are good, but, you\n\nknow, it's Saturday, after all.\n\n13\n\nWe'll do a search and replace also, but I think it is\n\n14\n\nworth doing, since some of them are under 17 and some are under\n\n15\n\n18.\n\n16\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThat's right, your Honor.\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n\nSo Instruction 34, lines 4, 6, 10, 13, 15, and 19, we\n\n19\n\nwill replace \"minors\" with \"individuals under the age of 17.\"\n\nOkay.\n\n20\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo let me just repeat.\n\nCorrect, your Honor.\n\nAnd then moving to replacing the word\n\n22\n\n\"minor\" with \"an individual under the age of 18,\" Mr. Everdell,\n\n23\n\nthat's line 24.\n\n24\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nAnd what else?\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827105\n\n", "char_count": 1307}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "Case 1:2O-cr-OO33O-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 49 of 95\n\n2787\n\nLCI1MAX1\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nAnd then the next page, page 45,\n\nline 1, there's the word \"minor,\" which would be \"an individual\nunder the age of 18.\"\n4\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nYour Honor, in this paragraph, since\n\n5\n\nthis is the conspiracy that applies to multiple minors, I think\n\n6\n\nit should be \"individuals under the age of 18\" rather than just\n\n7\n\none.\n\n8\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat's fine.\n\nFor the second -- yeah.\n\nRight.\n\n10\n\nis important that we're doing these one at a time.\n\n11\n\nit's \"an individual under the age of 18.\"\n\n12\n\npage, page 45, line 1, it's --\n\n13\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n14\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n\nSo that\n\nSo line 24,\n\nAnd then the next\n\nI think they both should be\n\nThey both should be \"an individual under\n\nthe age of --\"\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nI think they both should be\n\n\"individuals under the age of 18.\"\nTHE COURT:\n\nI'm sorry.\n\nYou're right.\n\nThey're both\n\nthe conspiracy.\n\n20\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat's right, your Honor.\n\nOkay.\n\nI apologize.\n\nLet me start again.\n\n22\n\nSo Instruction No. 34, line 24, \"individuals under the age of\n\n23\n\n18,\" on line 24; and then the following page, line 1, same\n\n24\n\nchange, \"individuals under the age of 18\"; and then same change\n\n25\n\non line 3.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827106\n\n", "char_count": 1347}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 50 of 95\n\n2788\n\nLCIlMAX1\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nSlightly different.\n\nThat would be \"an\n\nindividual under the age of 18,\" because that's the substantive\ncount.\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\"an --\" wait.\n\nYes.\n\nLine 3, replacing \"minors\" with\n\nLet me just read that sentence again.\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nI think these are all references to the\n\nconspiracy.\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThat's right.\n\nI'm sorry, your Honor.\n\n9\n\nThis is still talking about the conspiracy.\n\n10\n\nline 3 would still be \"sex trafficking of individuals under the\n\n11\n\nage of 18.\"\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n13\n\nOkay.\n\nYes.\n\nSo that one on\n\nI agree with that.\n\nSo for all of Instruction 34, all of the\n\n14\n\ninstances -- well, in the second paragraph -- no, I'm sorry.\n\n15\n\nwon't repeat it.\n\n16\n\nunder the age of 18.\"\n\nWe got it.\n\n17\n\nOkey dokey.\n\n18\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nI\n\nPage 45, line 3, \"individuals\n\nNext.\n\n19\n\ninstruction No. 36.\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n21\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo, your Honor, now we have page 49, or\n\nIt's -I'm sorry.\n\nWhat page?\n\n49?\n\nPage 49, Instruction 36.\n\nOkay.\n\nActually, before you start, I'll\n\n23\n\njust note, there's an extra word, \"Two,\" T-W-O, in the title.\n\n24\n\nSo line 1, it's just Counts One, Three, and Five, deleting the\n\n25\n\nword \"Two.\"\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827107\n\n", "char_count": 1328}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 51 of 95\n\n2789\n\nLCI1MAX1\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nII, yeah.\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nYes.\n\nTHE COURT:\n4\n\nAgreed, your Honor.\n\nWhat do you have, Mr. Everdell?\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nSo this is where it gets a little\n\n5\n\ncomplicated, your Honor.\n\nI mean, I know that in lines 11\n\n6\n\nthrough 22, we're listing -- and in the next page as well,\n\n7\n\nwe're listing out the overt acts in the indictment.\n\n8\n\nlisting them verbatim, but they're talking about ages, under\n\n9\n\nthe age of 18, under the age of 18, and we've already talked\n\n10\n\nabout how the ages are sort of different depending on the\n\n11\n\nstatutes.\n\n12\n\nreplace the -- instead of the ages -- and I know -- it's less\n\n13\n\nof an issue because I think we've agreed that the indictment is\n\n14\n\nnot going back to the jurors, so they're not going to be\n\n15\n\nreading the language, but maybe instead of \"under the age of\n\n16\n\n18,\" \"when Jane was under the relevant age of consent in the\n\n17\n\nrelevant jurisdiction,\" or something to that effect.\n\nThat's one issue.\n\nRight.\n\nWe're\n\nSo we might want to\n\n18\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nYour Honor, if I may.\n\n19\n\nconcern the defense is raising.\n\n20\n\nThree, since the relevant age of consent I think everyone\n\n21\n\nagrees is 17, the government would be fine with saying \"under\n\n22\n\nthe age of 17,\" and we'd have to say \"the indictment alleges\"\n\n23\n\nor something like that, because it would no longer be following\n\n24\n\nthe text of the indictment.\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes.\n\nI understand the\n\nI think for Counts One and\n\nI mean, we could do \"alleges\" or\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827108\n\n", "char_count": 1622}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 52 of 95\n\n2790\n\nLCIlMAX1\nbrackets or something.\nSo are you okay with \"alleges\" there, Mr. Everdell?\nMR. EVERDELL:\n4\n\nWell, let me see about that.\n\nAre we talking just about the overt acts with respect\n\n5\n\nto Jane or are we talking about with Annie as well?\n\n6\n\nthe overt act with respect to Annie is, she's saying she's\n\n7\n\nunder the age of 18, but the age of consent there is 16, so --\n\n8\n\nand Kate -- there are a few issues here, so I'll just lay them\n\n9\n\nout.\n\n10\n\nBecause\n\nThe instruction with Annie is, you know, there's the\n\n11\n\nage of consent issue with Annie.\n\nBut skipping to Kate, which\n\n12\n\nis No. 4, on line 18, I don't think that should be in there at\n\n13\n\nall because that invites them to base an overt act and convict\n\n14\n\nthe defendant based on Kate's testimony, which the Court has\n\n15\n\nalready instructed that the jury can't.\n\n16\n\nfound that this element was satisfied solely with Kate's\n\n17\n\ntestimony, that would be an improper conviction.\n\n18\n\nshouldn't be included.\n\n19\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nSo, I mean, if they\n\nSo that\n\nInsofar as we're no longer following\n\n20\n\nthe exact text of the indictment, the government would be fine\n\n21\n\nwith deleting the overt act relevant to Kate for the reason\n\n22\n\nMr. Everdell stated.\n\n23\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n24\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n25\n\nOkay.\n\nAll right.\n\nAll right.\n\nSo then I think we could\n\nprobably say with respect to 1 and 2, which we're talking about\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827109\n\n", "char_count": 1516}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 53 of 95\n\n2791\n\nLCI1MAX1\n\nJane, Jane was -- we would say the indictment alleges that Jane\nwas under the age of 17, in both 1 and 2.\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right.\n\n4\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n6\n\nSo let me just\n\nYeah.\n\nHang on.\n\nSo this is Instruction 36,\n\nline 11.\n\n7\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nCorrect.\n\nPage 49.\n\nI'm going to change \"reads\" to\n\n9\n\n\"alleges,\" and then line 12, we're going to say \"when Jane was\n\n10\n\nunder the age of 17,\" correct?\n\n11\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n13\n\nAnd then the next instance of that is line 14.\n\n14\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n16\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThat's correct.\n\nSo that's line 12, subbing 17 for 18.\n\nCorrect, your Honor.\n\n\"When Jane was under the age of 17.\"\nMm-hmm.\n\nAnd then we get to line 16.\nFor this one, I would propose that we\n\n19\n\nsimply, you know, eliminate the age, if they want to keep this\n\n20\n\nas an overt act and if we think it's proper for the jury to\n\n21\n\nconsider Annie's testimony as a potential overt act in\n\n22\n\nfurtherance of the conspiracy, even though the goal of the\n\n23\n\nconspiracy is a violation of New York law.\n\n24\n\nobjection is that I don't think you can actually consider\n\n25\n\nAnnie's testimony as the overt act if what's described there is\n\nSo my first\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827110\n\n", "char_count": 1388}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 53, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 54 of 95\n\n2792\n\nLCI1MAX1\nnot the violation of New York law.\n\nSo that is our objection to\n\nthat.\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nWell, I think, understanding that\n\n4\n\nMr. Everdell is I think preserving the earlier objection about\n\n5\n\nAnnie's testimony, as far as the suggestion to resolve the\n\n6\n\nredacting issue is just to remove her age from this clause, I\n\n7\n\nthink that would be fine and the jury can make its own\n\n8\n\nconclusions about, you know, Annie's age and how it relates to\n\n9\n\nthe offense.\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI understand the broader suggestion, but\n\n11\n\nin light of my earlier conclusion, this third overt act would\n\n12\n\nread, \"In or about 1996, Maxwell provided Annie with an\n\n13\n\nunsolicited massage in New Mexico.\"\n\n14\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nThat's my understanding of\n\n15\n\nMr. Everdell's suggestion, and the government would be fine\n\n16\n\nwith that.\n\n17\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nAnd I guess to clarify, Judge, I'm\n\n18\n\nunderstanding the Court's logic to be that the testimony of\n\n19\n\nAnnie about the topless massage can be considered by the jury\n\n20\n\nas evidence of the conspiracy to violate New York law.\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n22\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThat's right.\nOkay.\n\nAnd understanding that's the\n\n23\n\nCourt's logic and ruling, then we would -- but then we would\n\n24\n\nlike the redaction.\n\n25\n\nbut -- yes.\n\nWe preserve our objection from before,\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827111\n\n", "char_count": 1441}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 54, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 55 of 95\n\n2793\n\nLCI1MAX1\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd again, noting that that's why I gave\n\nthe limiting instruction for Annie's testimony, that's why the\nlimiting instruction did differ from the limiting instruction\n4\n\nfor Kate, because that is the Court's legal conclusion.\n\n5\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nUnderstood, your Honor.\n\nSo let me just make sure my clerks --\n\n7\n\nyeah.\n\n8\n\ncutting the comma, \"when Annie was under the age of 18,\" comma.\n\nRight.\n\nMy clerk has adopted the change on line 16,\n\n9\n\nNext.\n\n10\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nYour Honor, just to confirm, we are\n\n11\n\nalso eliminating, with the government's consent, No. 4, which\n\n12\n\nrefers to Kate, the overt act referring to Kate.\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes.\n\nSo eliminating entirely the overt\n\n14\n\nact on line 18 through 20.\n\nAnd then we'll have to change the\n\n15\n\nfifth one to 4\n\n16\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nCorrect, your Honor.\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n\ncan stay as is with the age.\n\n-- on line 20.\n\n19\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n21\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nAnd that one looks like it\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nOkay.\nYour Honor, I think that that should\n\n22\n\nbe -- on line 21, it should still be changed to 17, even\n\n23\n\nthough --\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n25\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nBecause of the -Because of the legal count.\n\nIt's the\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827112\n\n", "char_count": 1362}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 55, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 56 of 95\n\n2794\n\nLC1lmAxl\nconspiracy to violate the offense with the age of consent of\n17, even though elsewhere Carolyn is charged with an age of\nconsent of 18.\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n5\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n7\n\nI see.\n\nI presume you have no objection?\nNo objection, your Honor.\n\nYes.\n\nOkay.\n\nLet me just think about that.\n\nAll right.\n\nSo Instruction 36, line 21,\n\n8\n\nchanging \"Carolyn was under the age of 18\" to \"the age of 17.\"\n\n9\n\nYeah, that's right.\n\n10\n\nOkay.\n\nNext.\n\n11\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nNext one, lines, on that page, 23 to\n\n12\n\n24, and on the following page, lines 1 through 10, it tracks\n\n13\n\nthe same changes for the transportation charge.\n\n14\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat makes sense, I think, your Honor.\n\nOkay.\n\nLet me see if I can do these.\n\n16\n\nLine 24, changing \"age of 18\" to \"age of 17,\" and then line 2,\n\n17\n\nchanging \"age of 18\" to 17.\n\n18\n\nAnnie was under the age of 18,\" and then cutting overt act\n\n19\n\nregarding Kate at No. 4.\n\n20\n\nthen line 19, changing 18 to 17.\n\n21\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nCorrect, your Honor.\n\n22\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nJudge, you would also want to change\n\nLine 4, cutting the clause \"when\n\nSo that's lines 6 through 8.\n\n23\n\nthe bracketed No. 5 to No. 4.\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n25\n\nThank you, Ms. Sternheim.\n\nAnd\n\nChanging the\n\nfifth listed overt act to the fourth listed overt act.\n\nJust\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827113\n\n", "char_count": 1442}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 56, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 57 of 95\n\n2795\n\nLCI1MAX1\none moment.\nII, and we'll again change, on line 23, page 49, the\nword \"reads\" to \"alleges.\"\n4\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n6\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nOkay.\n\nNext.\n\nSame page, page 50, your Honor,\n\n7\n\nline 18, just going back, these are overt acts with respect to\n\n8\n\nCount Five.\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nMm-hmm.\n\n10\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThe third one, which begins on line 17,\n\n11\n\nbetween -- II, yes.\n\n12\n\n2004, Epstein's employees, including at times Maxwell, sent\n\n13\n\nCarolyn gifts, including lingerie, etc.\"\n\n14\n\nany evidence in the record that Maxwell sent any gifts.\n\n15\n\nfact, I think the FedEx records show that it wasn't Maxwell\n\n16\n\nsending anything.\n\n17\n\nrecord that Maxwell was sending the gifts, so I think that\n\n18\n\nshould be excluded.\n\n19\n\n\"Between in or about 2001 and in or about\n\nI don't think there's\nIn\n\nI don't think there's any testimony in the\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nThat's fine, your Honor.\n\nThis is what\n\n20\n\nthe grand jury charged, but that is fine, given the state of\n\n21\n\nthe record.\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\n23\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nBut to be clear, the government is fine\n\n24\n\nwith including the clause\n\n25\n\ntimes Maxwell.\"\n\ncutting the clause \"including at\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827114\n\n", "char_count": 1318}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 57, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 58 of 95\n\n2796\n\nLCI1MAX1\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo I think that's the request.\n\nSo line 18\n\non my page 50, which is the second page of Instruction No. 36,\nwe will cut comma, \"including at times Maxwell,\" comma.\n4\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nAnd in light of that change, your\n\n5\n\nHonor, on line 11 of that page, it should say, \"The indictment\n\n6\n\nalleges as follows.\"\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n8\n\nRight.\n\nOn line 11, changing \"reads\" to\n\n\"alleges.\"\n\n9\n\nWhat's next, Mr. Everdell?\n\n10\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nIt's on page 51,\n\n11\n\nline 15.\n\nI think we've been using \"Ms. Maxwell\" in this\n\n12\n\ncharge, so we'll change on line 15 \"the defendant\" to\n\n13\n\n\"Ms. Maxwell.\"\n\n14\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat's fine, your Honor.\n\nOkay.\n\nSo we're on Instruction No. 36.\n\n16\n\nClose to the end of that, the second to last paragraph of that\n\n17\n\ninstruction, line 15, changing \"the defendant\" to\n\n18\n\n\"Ms. Maxwell.\"\n\n19\n\nSo one question.\n\n20\n\nacts.\n\n21\n\nsense.\n\nPage 51, lines 13 through 16 are no longer seem to make\n\n22\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n23\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n24\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n25\n\nWe've taken Kate out of the overt\n\n51, your Honor?\n\nYeah.\n\nRight?\n\nWell, I understand what you're saying\n\nwith respect to reference to overt acts because she's not in\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827115\n\n", "char_count": 1335}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 58, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 59 of 95\n\n2797\n\nLCI1MAX1\nthe overt acts, but I do think it's important to instruct the\njury here that they can't convict solely on the basis of Kate's\ntestimony.\n\nThat I think is --\n\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n5\n\nin the indictment.\n\nRight, because it's not just about what's\n\n6\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nRight.\n\n7\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nThat's right, your Honor.\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\n9\n10\n\nI just have one moment with\nMr. Everdell?\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n12\n\na 10-minute break.\n\nYes, please.\n\nActually, why don't we take\n\n13\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\n14\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\n15\n\nTHE LAW CLERK:\n\nAll rise.\n\n16\n\n(Recess)\n\n17\n\n(Continued on next page)\n\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827116\n\n", "char_count": 795}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 59, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 60 of 95\n\n2798\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\n(Jury not present)\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right.\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nMr. Everdell.\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\nThe next page\n\n4\n\nwe have is page 54, instruction 39, the conscious avoidance\n\n5\n\ninstruction.\n\n6\n\nbeing included, this instruction being included in the charge.\n\n7\n\nI think, as the Court is aware, to include an\n\n8\n\ninstruction on conscious avoidance, you have to establish two\n\n9\n\nprongs.\n\n10\n\nspecific aspect of knowledge required for conviction.\n\n11\n\nthink we're disputing that.\n\n12\n\nmust be an appropriate factual predicate for the charge.\n\n13\n\nhere, your Honor, the government's theory of the case and the\n\n14\n\nproof that's been elicited through the testimony is that she\n\n15\n\nwas an active participant in all aspects of the charges.\n\n16\n\nhas been testimony by all of the witnesses that she was not\n\n17\n\nonly participating and facilitating the sexual encounters but\n\n18\n\nthat she participated.\n\n19\n\nwas involved, that Ms. Maxwell was involved in the group\n\n20\n\nsexualized massages.\n\n21\n\ntopless massage was done by Ms. Maxwell; she rubbed the top\n\n22\n\npart of her chest during the topless massage.\n\n23\n\nfrom Carolyn that Ms. Maxwell groped her breasts and commented\n\n24\n\nupon her hips.\n\n25\n\nThis is someone that's not consciously avoiding.\n\nYour Honor, on that, the defense objects to this\n\nFirst is that the defendant has to assert some lack of\nI don't\n\nBut the second prong is that there\nAnd\n\nThere\n\nSo we have testimony from Jane that she\n\nWe had testimony from Annie that the\n\nWe had testimony\n\nThese are all active-participant measures.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827117\n\n", "char_count": 1692}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 60, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 61 of 95\n\n2799\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nThe theory they are proceeding on is that she is an\nactive participant.\n\nThey can't have it both ways.\n\nThe proof\n\nat trial that they have elicited is that she was actively\n4\n\ninvolved.\n\nThis seems to be here as some sort of backup option.\n\n5\n\nAnd that's not permissible, your Honor.\n\n6\n\nAnd I would add that, in a case like this in\n\n7\n\nparticular, there is a real concern that the jurors are going\n\n8\n\nto look at this evidence and, given the subject matter of the\n\n9\n\ncase, they're going to think, well, she must have known and\n\n10\n\nthat's enough for me because this is conduct that really I\n\n11\n\ncan't countenance because it involves children.\n\n12\n\nconscious avoidance instruction will give them license to\n\n13\n\nconvict the defendant on an improper basis simply because of\n\n14\n\nthe nature of the subject matter.\n\n15\n\nSo that's an overlay, your Honor.\n\nAnd then the\n\nBut at the basis,\n\n16\n\nit's that the proof and the theory of the charging in this case\n\n17\n\nand the proof that's gone with it is that she's an active\n\n18\n\nparticipant o, so we do not think that there is an appropriate\n\n19\n\nfactual predicate for this charge.\n\n20\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nA few responses to that, your Honor.\n\n21\n\nFirst of all, the witnesses testified that she was an active\n\n22\n\nparticipant.\n\n23\n\nactively participated and can still convict based on her\n\n24\n\nfacilitation of the various offenses, including through a\n\n25\n\nconscious avoidance theory.\n\nThe jury may reject their testimony that she\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827118\n\n", "char_count": 1619}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 61, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 62 of 95\n\n2800\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nSecond of all, there are particular factual knowledge\nelements that the defense is contesting.\n\nOne is her knowledge\n\nof the age of the victim.\n\nAnother is her mens III with regard\n\n4\n\nto the purposes of travel.\n\nAnd so for those things the jury\n\n5\n\ncould reasonably conclude that she had sufficient -- that she\n\n6\n\nwas engaging in conscious avoidance as to those particular\n\n7\n\nfacts.\n\n8\n\nSo, for example, to take the knowledge of age issue,\n\n9\n\nthe defense has elicited testimony from several witnesses that\n\n10\n\nthe defendant could not, was not aware that the various victims\n\n11\n\nwere minors.\n\n12\n\nthat knowledge.\n\n13\n\nconsciously avoided having that knowledge.\n\n14\n\nreasonable theories available for the jury for which there is\n\n15\n\nan adequate factual predicate in the record, your Honor.\n\n16\n\nThe jury could conclude that she in fact did have\nThe jury could also conclude that she\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThose are both\n\nYour Honor, I think this is inviting\n\n17\n\nthe jury, by considering the conscious avoidance charge, to\n\n18\n\nconvict on an improper basis that she must have known.\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nCould you just respond to the specific\n\n20\n\nargument, because I think you started by saying there's been no\n\n21\n\ncontention as to a lack of knowledge with respect to any aspect\n\n22\n\nof the crimes charged.\n\n23\n\nreason I had in my head to include it rather than not include\n\n24\n\nit -- which, for reasons you've indicated, is a case-by-case\n\n25\n\nanalysis depending on what factual issues are in play.\n\nSo the specific contention and the\n\nBut on\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827119\n\n", "char_count": 1689}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 62, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 63 of 95\n\n2801\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nthe question of knowledge as to age, what's your response?\n\nWhy\n\nisn't it applicable with respect to what the defense has put in\nissue with regard to that?\n4\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n5\n\nthemselves -- sorry, your Honor.\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n7\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\n8\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nThe witnesses\n\nOne moment.\n\nYes.\nIf you don't mind, your Honor, it's\n\neasier for me --\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n10\n\none-lawyer-per-issue rule.\n\n11\n\nSince it's Saturday, I will break my\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nI appreciate it.\n\nMy recollection is\n\n12\n\nthe testimony from each of the four witnesses, I will call\n\n13\n\nthem, is that they said that they told Ms. Maxwell their age.\n\n14\n\nCarolyn said that she told Ms. Maxwell her age.\n\n15\n\ntold Ms. Maxwell her age.\n\n16\n\nMs. Maxwell her age.\n\n17\n\nJane said she\n\nSimilarly, Kate said she told\n\nSo there is no \"I'm not trying to find out what her\n\n18\n\nage is\" evidence in this case.\n\n19\n\nelicited -- I think this is, you know, largely through\n\n20\n\nMr. Alessi.\n\n21\n\nhouse that he thought were under the age of 18, and that was\n\n22\n23\n\nThe evidence that was\n\nMr. Alessi said that he only saw two people at the\n\nand Jane.\n\nI'm trying to remember everybody's\n\nnames.\n\n24\n\nSo that's that testimony.\n\n25\n\nI don't think there's any other testimony in the\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827120\n\n", "char_count": 1387}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 63, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 64 of 95\n\n2802\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nrecord that relates to that topic.\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo I think that --\n\nSo the defense has questioned multiple\n\nwitnesses on their perceptions of individual ages, of relevant\n4\n\nindividuals' ages, so that puts into question the knowledge\n\n5\n\nelement with respect to ages, and it's true there's testimony\n\n6\n\nfrom each of the alleged victims as to what they told\n\n7\n\nMs. Maxwell, but of course I don't know whether the jury will\n\n8\n\naccept that testimony or not, or any of those individual pieces\n\n9\n\nof testimony.\n\n10\n\nwhether there are specific elements, knowledge elements that\n\n11\n\nare in issue, either because it's what some of the evidence\n\n12\n\ngoes to or because the defense has made cross-points or will\n\n13\n\nmake arguments regarding that.\n\n14\n\nthe case that the defense won't -- will it not argue during\n\n15\n\nclosing anything with respect to whether Ms. Maxwell knew of\n\n16\n\nthe relevant ages?\n\nSo it seems like having -- the question here is\n\n17\n\nI mean, I don't suppose it's\n\nwe have a moment, Judge?\n\n18\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSure.\n\n19\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nHere's the -- I'm going to try to\n\n20\n\naddress -- there's a larger concern.\n\n21\n\ntwo pieces.\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n23\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nI need to break this into\n\nOK.\nOne that I view as an evidentiary issue\n\n24\n\nwith the indictment and the evidence in the case is that there\n\n25\n\nwas testimony about multiple females being at the Palm Beach\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827121\n\n", "char_count": 1531}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 64, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 65 of 95\n\n2803\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nresidence.\n\nAnd I think the testimony that was elicited by the\n\ndefense went to what the ages of these multiple females looked\nlike, because the inference is that there are, you know,\n4\n\nliterally hundreds of under-age women at Epstein's house.\n\n5\n\nAnd so the testimony from Mr. Alessi was, he only saw\n\n6\n\ntwo people that he thought looked under age, as opposed to the\n\n7\n\nrest of these people.\n\n8\n\nThere was no testimony elicited that, you know,\n\n9\n\nMs. Maxwell did or didn't know what -- I mean, the contention\n\n10\n\nis that these folks were older.\n\n11\n\ncontention is she wasn't under age.\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nKate, for example, the\n\nYesterday, I think\n\n13\n\nJane appeared to her.\n\n14\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nwas asked how\n\nCorrect, at the office.\n\nBut I also\n\n15\n\nthink that that's a tension here, is that Jane was older than\n\n16\n\nshe is saying.\n\n17\n\nsays she was 14, 15.\n\n18\n\ntime.\n\n19\n\nYou know, the actual factual dispute is, Jane\nWe disagree.\n\nWe believe it's later in\n\nSo this is not an avoidance issue.\n\nThis is a factual\n\n20\n\ndispute as to how old these people actually were.\n\n21\n\nexception of Carolyn, who says, you know, I was this age, and\n\n22\n\nwe say, we never, you know, had anything to do with Carolyn.\n\n23\n\nThat's the factual dispute.\n\n24\n25\n\nWith the\n\nAnd so I think there is a legitimate argument that\ndoesn't relate to conscious avoidance, which is, simply, there\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827122\n\n", "char_count": 1520}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 65, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 66 of 95\n\n2804\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nwere lots of women there and, you know, there are many -- no\none -- no one observed women that they thought were under age.\nBut it's not -- I don't believe there is going to be\n4\n\nan argument, Ms. Maxwell is not guilty because she couldn't\n\n5\n\nhave known that these four people were whatever age they are.\n\n6\n\nI think the argument is going to be, they weren't that age.\n\n7\n\nThat's what I think the defense's position is here, your Honor,\n\n8\n\nnot, you know, gee, Mr. Epstein slipped in a couple of\n\n9\n\nteenagers on me here.\n\n10\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nYour Honor, unless the defense is\n\n11\n\nstipulating that Ms. Maxwell knew the ages of these victims,\n\n12\n\nand it's an open issue.\n\n13\n\nVisoski, Kimberly\n\n14\n\nThey elicited from Carolyn that she was told not to tell -- or\n\n15\n\ntold to tell people at the house that she was 17 or 18, when\n\n16\n\nshe was younger than that.\n\n17\n\nelicited certainly puts the defendant's knowledge of the\n\n18\n\nvictims' age at issue.\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThe defense has elicited from Larry\nthe appearance of the victims.\n\nYes.\n\nSo the evidence that's been\n\nThere are two issues.\n\nThere's the\n\n20\n\nfirst question, what age were they.\n\nAnd you contest that.\n\nBut\n\n21\n\nthen there's the second question of, let's assume the jury\n\n22\n\nconcludes that they were under the age of 17, then there is the\n\n23\n\nquestion of Ms. Maxwell's knowledge, and that seems to me to\n\n24\n\nhave been put in issue through argument and -- through openings\n\n25\n\nand questions asked on cross.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827123\n\n", "char_count": 1626}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 66, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 67 of 95\n\n2805\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\nHonor.\n\nI think I disagree with that, your\n\nAnd let's take Carolyn as the example.\n\nCarolyn, the\n\ngovernment affirmatively elicited that she was told by Virginia\n4\n\nto say that she was, you know, whatever age she was told to\n\n5\n\nsay.\n\nThat's, I think, the government's testimony.\n\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\nHonor.\n\nI believe that came out on cross, your\n\nIt's on page 1569.\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nIf it came out on cross, it was her\n\nvolunteering that information, I think.\nBut anyway, that doesn't have anything to do with\n\n11\n\nMs. Maxwell.\n\n12\n\nmy name -- whatever the age I'm supposed to say.\"\n\n13\n\nMs. Maxwell saying to Virginia, \"Say this age.\"\n\n14\n15\n16\n\nI mean, that's simply \"Virginia told me whatever\nIt's not\n\nSo I just disagree as a factual matter that this has\nanything to do with conscious avoidance.\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nThe defense also elicited testimony\n\n17\n\nthat the defendant was from -- through Mr. Alessi -- that the\n\n18\n\ndefendant was going to legitimate hotels to identify massage\n\n19\n\ntherapists.\n\n20\n\nthat she didn't know the ages of people coming to the house as\n\n21\n\nmassage therapists, and so she could have confused some of them\n\n22\n\nwho were under the age of consent with ones who were older than\n\n23\n\nthe age of consent.\n\n24\n\nwould be in service of.\n\n25\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nI assume that that's in service of an argument\n\nI'm not sure what other evidence that\n\nWell, that's in service of\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827124\n\n", "char_count": 1563}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 67, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 68 of 95\n\n2806\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nbeing -- that's a factual dispute as well: when did we -- you\nknow, when did\n\nappear?\n\nHow old was\n\nwhen she appeared and then allegedly recruited other people?\n4\n\nThat's in service of that argument.\n\n5\n\nsome other argument.\n\n6\n\nwas, you know, we went to Mar-a-Lago, we went to these other\n\n7\n\nspas, Mr. Alessi collected cards from people.\n\n8\n\nwhat that testimony was.\n\n9\n\nthe others that relate to Carolyn.\n\n10\n\nIt's not in service of\n\nAnd that's what that testimony went to,\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nI mean, that's\n\nIt had nothing to do with Carolyn or\n\nIf the issue is just, how old was\n\n11\n\nwhen she met the defendant, there would be no\n\n12\n\nneed for testimony about whether the defendant also went to the\n\n13\n\nBreakers to recruit massage therapists.\n\n14\n\nwhat date did the encounter happen with\nTHE COURT:\n\n15\n\nAll right.\n\nIt would just be, on\n\nI'm going to take a careful\n\n16\n\nlook through the transcript to see how and when and to what\n\n17\n\nextent the defense, I think, reasonably -- I could reasonably\n\n18\n\ninterpret to put in question Ms. Maxwell's knowledge as to the\n\n19\n\nage of the individuals.\n\n20\n\nAm I hearing you correctly that, in the absence of\n\n21\n\nthis instruction, that the defense would make no argument at\n\n22\n\nclosing regarding specifically Ms. Maxwell's knowledge of the\n\n23\n\nage of any individuals that the jury might conclude are alleged\n\n24\n\nvictims?\n\n25\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nI would like to consult with the person\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827125\n\n", "char_count": 1578}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 68, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 69 of 95\n\n2807\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nwho's going to be giving the closing argument.\nTHE COURT:\n\nI think she's standing over your shoulder.\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nNo.\n\n4\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nNo.\n\n5\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nSurprise.\n\n6\n\nMR. PAGLIUCA:\n\nI can give the Court that answer before\n\n7\n\nIt's not me.\n\nwe leave today, if that's all right with the Court.\n\n8\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nIf I may just say, your Honor, I'm not\n\n9\n\neven sure that these things can be pulled apart.\n\n10\n\nthat these people were older is so intertwined with an argument\n\n11\n\nthat she thought these people were older that, even if they\n\n12\n\ndidn't say the words about that in their closing, I think the\n\n13\n\njury would assume that, absent some more affirmative\n\n14\n\nstipulation, so the government would have to rebut it.\n\n15\n\nconscious avoidance theory is an appropriate way to do so.\n\n16\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes.\n\nIt's a fair point.\n\nAn argument\n\nA\n\nAnd I'm going to\n\n17\n\nlook carefully at relevant portions of the transcript, but I do\n\n18\n\nthink it is sufficiently in issue that it's appropriate to give\n\n19\n\nthe instruction.\n\n20\n\ncoming to a final resolution, if the defense were to indicate\n\n21\n\nit wouldn't specifically make that argument.\n\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nI would consider, as part of my calculus in\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\nwe can.\n\nBut --\n\nWe'll get you that answer as soon as\n\nIt will be following the break, I think.\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nYour Honor, the other -- we've also\n\narticulated a theory that there are flight records showing the\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827126\n\n", "char_count": 1585}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 69, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 70 of 95\n\n2808\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\ndefendant traveling with some of the minor victims.\n\nI assume\n\nthe defendant is going to say that she didn't know the purposes\nof the trips.\n\nTo the extent the purpose was sexual abuse, the\n\n4\n\ngovernment would argue that at a minimum this she did know, if\n\n5\n\nshe didn't she consciously avoided knowing, why Jeffrey Epstein\n\n6\n\nwas traveling repeatedly with these minors.\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThe other point is, from the openings, I\n\n8\n\ndon't know if it will be a theme of the closing, but the\n\n9\n\ndistancing of Ms. Maxwell from Mr. Epstein and what he did was\n\n10\n\nclearly a theme of the opening, and so that implicates\n\n11\n\nknowledge throughout the counts.\n\n12\n\nSo my strong inclination is that it's appropriate\n\n13\n\nhere.\n\nThat's my conclusion.\n\n14\n\nto look back through relevant portions of testimony on the age\n\n15\n\nissue, but I think even the age issue -- well, not the age\n\n16\n\nissue.\n\n17\n\nof age aside, knowledge of age is intertwined with arguments\n\n18\n\nregarding age.\n\n19\n\nopening, questions about Ms. Maxwell's knowledge of what\n\n20\n\nMr. Epstein is alleged to have been doing that I think it's\n\n21\n\nsort of a standard instance of the applicability of a conscious\n\n22\n\navoidance instruction.\n\nKnowledge of age.\n\nThat's my conclusion.\n\nI'm going\n\nSpecific arguments as to knowledge\n\nAnd in any event, there are, as a result of the\n\n23\n\nSo my conclusion is to include it.\n\n24\n\nNext.\n\n25\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nNext, your Honor -- let me make sure.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827127\n\n", "char_count": 1594}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 70, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 71 of 95\n\n2809\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\n\nI believe the next one is at page 61.\nTHE COURT:\n\nDid you have something before that?\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nNo, page 69.\n\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n5\n\nI have something before that.\n\n6\n\nOK.\n\nPage 61.\nThere is a pronoun on\n\npage 60, line 5, \"he\" should be replaced with \"she.\"\n\n7\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThat's fine, your Honor.\n\n8\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n10\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n11\n\nAnd what page was it, Mr. Everdell?\nThe next page is 61, your Honor.\n\nThat's instruction 44, credibility of witnesses.\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n13\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nOK.\nYour Honor, we would just propose that\n\n14\n\nthere were a number of witnesses who, it came out, had felony\n\n15\n\nconvictions, and there is a Sand instruction on this.\n\n16\n\ninstruction 7-12.\n\n17\n\nleast in part, in the credibility of witnesses instruction.\n\n18\n\ncan read that to you, your Honor, if you like.\n\n19\n20\n\n23\n24\n25\n\nAnd we would ask that it be included, at\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI\n\nI gather this was not an original\n\nproposal.\n\n21\n22\n\nIt's\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nNo.\n\nWe didn't know if it would come\n\nin.\nTHE COURT:\n\nOops.\n\nAll right.\n\nI'll take your -- my\n\nclerks will submit language, but go ahead.\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nSure.\n\nI have Sand in front of me, and\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827128\n\n", "char_count": 1331}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 71, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 72 of 95\n\n2810\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nI can read the full instruction.\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd the proposal is to include it where?\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n4\n\nIn instruction 44, in the credibility\n\nof witnesses.\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n6\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nRight.\n\nWhere?\n\nI think it could be either after the\n\n7\n\nsecond paragraph, before the third paragraph, or after the\n\n8\n\nthird paragraph, which goes on to the next page before the\n\n9\n\nfirst full paragraph on that page.\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n11\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n12\n\nOK.\nI'm happy to read it if you like, or\n\nyou can just -- it's up to the Court.\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n14\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nI don't have it yet.\nOK.\n\nSo go ahead.\n\nSo the way it reads in Sand is,\n\n15\n\n\"You have heard the testimony of a witness who was previously\n\n16\n\nconvicted of a crime punishable by more than one year in jail.\n\n17\n\nThis prior conviction was put into evidence for you to consider\n\n18\n\nin evaluating the witness's credibility.\n\n19\n\nfact -- you may consider the fact that the witness who\n\n20\n\ntestified is a convicted felon in deciding how much of his\" --\n\n21\n\nI think maybe \"his or her testimony to accept and what weight\n\n22\n\nif any it should be given.\"\n\n23\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nYou may consider that\n\nYour Honor, we're not familiar with\n\n24\n\nthis instruction being given in this district, and obviously\n\n25\n\nwitnesses with felony convictions testify regularly.\n\nThe\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827129\n\n", "char_count": 1471}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 72, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 73 of 95\n\n2811\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\ncommentary as it stands suggests that the point of this\ninstruction is just to tell the jury why this was -- the felony\nconviction was even put before them in the first place.\n\nAnd I\n\n4\n\ndon't think a jury is going to be confused or misled about why\n\n5\n\nthat testimony was offered.\n\n6\n\nfor this sort of instruction.\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n8\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n9\n\nfingertips.\n\n10\n\nDo you have any examples of it being used?\nYour Honor, I don't have at my\n\nI can try to find some if there are.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThis is my standard credibility\n\n11\n\ninstruction.\n\n12\n\nfelony convictions came in.\n\n13\n\nor been asked to give it.\n\n14\n\nSo I don't think there is a need\n\nCertainly given in multiple trials in which\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nI don't think I've ever given it\n\nYour Honor, I would point out, I think\n\n15\n\nin a lot of trials, maybe in the ones you've done before, there\n\n16\n\nwas probably an instruction about cooperating witnesses which\n\n17\n\nbuilds in this language, and obviously you don't have one here,\n\n18\n\nso it's often included in the charge in a separate instruction.\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWell, this is a new request.\n\n20\n\nlook.\n\nWe'll look at it.\n\n21\n\nyou'll either see it or not.\n\nAnd when I send you the redline\n\n22\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n23\n\nto find other examples if I can.\n\n24\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOK.\n\nI'll take a\n\nIn the meantime, your Honor, I'll try\n\nLooks like I have given it as a\n\nseparate instruction, testimony of felons.\n\n\"You've heard the\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827130\n\n", "char_count": 1575}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 73, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 74 of 95\n\n2812\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\ntestimony of witnesses who were previously convicted of crimes\npunishable by more than one year in jail.\n\nThis prior\n\nconviction was put into evidence for you to consider in\n4\n\nevaluating the witness's credibility.\n\n5\n\nfact that the witness who testified was a convicted felon in\n\n6\n\ndeciding how much of his testimony to accept and what weight if\n\n7\n\nany it should be given.\"\n\n8\n\nthe United States v. Berry.\n\n9\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nYou may consider the\n\nLooks like I gave that in my -- in\n\nI think we've been using that as a\n\n10\n\nmodel in this charge, your Honor, so we would request a similar\n\n11\n\ninstruction here.\n\n12\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI would add it, as I did in that last\n\ncase, as a standalone instruction.\n\n14\n\nMr. Rohrbach.\n\n15\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n16\n\nhoard of this proposal.\n\n17\n\nthe charge conference to give it some thought.\n\n18\n\nletter saying either, we agree, or, if we have objections to\n\n19\n\nit, articulating those.\n\nYour Honor, this is the first we've\nSo if we could have a few hours after\nWe can file a\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI think that's fair, and I will look too\n\n21\n\nsince it's a new suggestion.\n\n22\n\njust do it as a standalone instruction at, maybe what would be\n\n23\n\n45-A?\n\n24\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI think my proposal would be to\n\nThat's fine, your Honor.\n\nBetween 45 and '6.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827131\n\n", "char_count": 1443}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 74, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 75 of 95\n\n2813\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nSo that's the proposal.\n\nAnd when would you like to\n\nput in a letter?\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nDepends on what time we finish.\n\n4\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nFirst thing, your Honor.\n\n5\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nIf we finish by noon, by 2 or 3?\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n7\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n9\n\nNext.\n\n10\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nOK.\n\nLet's do 2 o'clock.\n\nOK.\n\nThank you.\n\nNext, your Honor, is page 68,\n\n11\n\ninstruction no. 50, the uncalled witnesses charge.\n\n12\n\nhere is that this not be included, and I think the reason being\n\n13\n\nthat, in this case, it isn't really accurately summarizing the\n\n14\n\nstate of play, because, you know, for example, there were\n\n15\n\nwitnesses who took their Fifth Amendment rights and refused to\n\n16\n\ntestify as defense witnesses because they invoked their Fifth\n\n17\n\nAmendment rights.\n\n18\n\ngiving those witnesses immunity to testify.\n\n19\n\nactually control, more than we do, whether or not a witness can\n\n20\n\nappear --\n\n21\n22\n23\n\nThe request\n\nThe government does have the option of\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd so they\n\nTo be clear, that didn't happen.\n\nThey\n\ndidn't call that witness.\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nWe had a witness who invoked their\n\n24\n\nFifth Amendment rights or had written the Court that they\n\n25\n\nplanned to invoke, and that we called and was under subpoena\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827132\n\n", "char_count": 1393}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 75, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 76 of 95\n\n2814\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nthat we intended to call as a witness.\nTHE COURT:\n\nThere was a lawyer letter indicating that\n\nthey had received a subpoena and they intended to invoke.\n\nI\n\n4\n\nasked many, many times if there was an application with respect\n\n5\n\nto it.\n\n6\n\nIt's certainly true that, if someone invokes, the defense can't\n\n7\n\noffer immunity the way that the government can.\n\n8\n\nevery case.\n\n9\n\nobjected to, but I don't know that I see anything in this case\n\n10\n\nthat would distinguish its application based on what you've\n\n11\n\njust indicated.\n\nI never got one.\n\n12\n\nSo I'm not sure how to think of that.\n\nThat's true in\n\nThis charge is quite standard, though standardly\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nIn addition to what I had just\n\n13\n\nindicated, just for purpose of completeness, there are a number\n\n14\n\nof witnesses who, based on the witness testimony in this case,\n\n15\n\nthere would be people who the government -- who we normally may\n\n16\n\nhave considered calling as a witness but who the government\n\n17\n\nclearly could have charged, criminally, based on the testimony\n\n18\n\nwe heard.\n\n19\n\nBut I think we probably know who we're talking about here.\n\n20\n\nthat is, you know, had we tried to call that witness or those\n\n21\n\nwitnesses, they undoubtedly would have invoked their Fifth\n\n22\n\nAmendment rights.\n\n23\n\nnot called by the government and would have had to have been\n\n24\n\ngiven statutory immunity or granted immunity to be able to\n\n25\n\ntestify, by the government, if they had decided to call them.\n\nAnd I won't name names if we don't want to do that.\nAnd\n\nIn fact, as some of them -- one of them was\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827133\n\n", "char_count": 1716}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 76, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 77 of 95\n\n2815\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nSo there is more than just the one witness who indicated that\nshe was going to invoke had the defense called her.\n\nThere were\n\nother co-conspirators who the government chose not to call, not\n4\n\nto immunize, and we couldn't possibly call in our defense\n\n5\n\nwithout -- because we can't give any immunity ourselves.\n\n6\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nYour Honor, this is true in basically\n\n7\n\nevery conspiracy case and every gang case that is prosecuted in\n\n8\n\nthis district.\n\n9\n\ninstruction is given and is the run-of-the-mill instruction, as\n\n10\n\nthe Court said, in cases in this district.\n\n11\n12\n\nThere are unindicted co-conspirators.\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nYet this\n\nYour Honor, if the Court is inclined to\n\ngive the instruction, I can propose an alternative.\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI will take an alternative.\n\n14\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nIf we can just eliminate the language\n\n15\n\nin the title of the charge that says \"equally available to both\n\n16\n\nsides\" and just have \"the uncalled witnesses.\"\n\n17\n18\n\nI believe there's also language that says \"equal\nopportunity.\"\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOr lack of opportunity.\n\n20\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nYes.\n\n21\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nThis is the uncalled witness\n\n22\n\ninstruction, your Honor.\n\n23\n\nsuggested by Sand and given by this Court.\n\n24\n\nexamples right here where the Court has given this instruction.\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThis is the instruction given,\nI have five\n\nAs I say, it's always given, always\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827134\n\n", "char_count": 1540}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 77, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 78 of 95\n\n2816\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nobjected to.\nSo here's just a slight change.\n\nLine 4.\n\n\"Each party\n\nhad an opportunity to call any of these witnesses.\"\n4\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWe would accept that, your Honor.\n\nIt's a similar meaning.\n\n6\n\nequal.\n\n7\n\ncall any of the witnesses.\"\n\n8\n9\n\nI'll adopt that.\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nIt's not quite\n\n\"Each party had an opportunity to\n\nIf your Honor is thinking of that\n\nchange, we would ask to just include that in our letter later.\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat's fine.\n\nSo the proposal would be\n\n11\n\nthat, line 1, cut \"equally available to both sides\" from the\n\n12\n\nheading, and then, line 4, cut \"equal opportunity or lack of\n\n13\n\nopportunity\" and change to \"an opportunity.\"\n\n14\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nI think it's clearly true, Mr. Rohrbach,\n\n16\n\nthis is standard language, and I've given it a slightly,\n\n17\n\nslightly altered meaning, to take emphasis off of \"equal\n\n18\n\nopportunity.\"\n\n19\n\ncharge.\n\n20\n\nSo I think it still captures the meaning of the\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nI just -- we will think about it and\n\n21\n\ninclude it in our letter.\n\n22\n\npart of our concern is that the most obvious witness who was\n\n23\n\navailable to both sides and who we expect the defense to\n\n24\n\ncomment on is\n\n25\n\nbut did not testify and she was fully available to the\n\nBut just to preview for the Court,\n\nwho was described as a victim\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827135\n\n", "char_count": 1491}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 78, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 79 of 95\n\n2817\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\ndefendants.\n\nThey did not call her.\n\nissue here is\n\nTo the extent the main\n\ntestimony, that she was equally\n\navailable to both sides.\n4\n5\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nIt's not\n\nthinking of, your Honor.\n\nthat I'm\n\nI'm happy to say the name.\n\nIt's\n\n6\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOK.\n\nI mean, suppose -- look, as I said,\n\n8\n\nI've only slightly changed the meaning.\n\n9\n\nbut it takes emphasis off of \"equal.\"\n\n10\n\ndefense is going to focus on in its closings, how much of the\n\n11\n\nfocus will be the absence of individuals.\n\n12\n13\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nIt's the same meaning\nI don't know what the\n\nI expect we'll be talking about the\n\nabsence of individuals, your Honor.\n\n14\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right.\n\nI'll hear from you in your\n\nI'm keeping the charge.\n\nAnd it will either be the\n\n15\n\n-otter.\n\n16\n\nstandard charge or the very slight modification I've proposed.\n\n17\n\nNext.\n\n18\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n20\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nYour Honor, page 69.\n\nOK.\nThat's the particular investigative\n\n21\n\ntechniques charge.\n\n22\n\nand from eliciting evidence and from arguing this point about\n\n23\n\nparticular investigative techniques, and so we\n\nWe were prohibited from the Court's rulings\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n25\n\nrespect to witnesses called.\n\nWell, to be clear, not on cross with\nBut I don't need to repeat my\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827136\n\n", "char_count": 1404}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 79, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 80 of 95\n\n2818\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nruling.\n\nBut the ruling is what the ruling is.\n\nWhat's the\n\nrequest?\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThe request is to eliminate the charge\n\n4\n\non this point because we couldn't -- we weren't supposed to,\n\n5\n\nand nor did -- I think we tried to abide by the Court's ruling\n\n6\n\nto not talk about particular investigative techniques or elicit\n\n7\n\nevidence on that point.\n\n8\n\npermitted to elicit or argue that point to the jury, then it\n\n9\n\ndoesn't seem like they need to be instructed on that point.\n\n10\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nAnd so if we're not going to be\n\nThis is a legally correct instruction.\n\n11\n\nAs the Court has ruled many times now in this case, particular\n\n12\n\ninvestigative techniques are not required.\n\n13\n\nthat point, as they could, on cross through the case, and I\n\n14\n\nassume it will be, as they can in the defense's summation.\n\n15\n\nthis is a correct statement of the law on which the jury should\n\n16\n\nbe instructed.\n\n17\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThe defense made\n\nAnd\n\nSand has filled three volumes of\n\n18\n\ncorrect statements on law, your Honor.\n\n19\n\nthey get into a jury charge.\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat doesn't mean that\n\nI think I've always included this charge,\n\n21\n\nso it's not just a rarely invoked Sand charge.\n\n22\n\ntalked about yesterday, there were questions you were going\n\n23\n\nto -- ask.\n\n24\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI mean, as you\n\nSpecial Agent Young.\n\n-- Young, thank you -- that either -- some\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827137\n\n", "char_count": 1541}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 80, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 81 of 95\n\n2819\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nof which were asked of the relevant investigative agents or\narguments that could be made based on the absence of evidence\nin the record and the like.\n\nAnd my ruling was what it was,\n\n4\n\nwhich didn't foreclose entirely the opportunity with respect to\n\n5\n\ncross-examination and the like.\n\n6\n\nthe defense's arguments in closing, so it's appropriate to\n\n7\n\ninclude the charge.\n\nI suspect this will be part of\n\n8\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n9\n\nJust as long as we're allowed to argue, are permitted\n\n10\n\nto argue in closing about absence of evidence consistent with\n\n11\n\nthe Court's ruling.\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n13\n\nUnderstood.\n\nAbsolutely, so long as the inference is\n\navailable in the record.\n\n14\n\nAnd I'll just pause, because I made a note to say\n\n15\n\nthis.\n\nI have a decent memory, and my afternoon and tomorrow\n\n16\n\nwill be spent reviewing much of the trial testimony.\n\n17\n\nwant objections during closings, but that requires -- I gather\n\n18\n\nit's Ms. Menninger that's doing the closing and Ms. Moe, who\n\n19\n\nare absent today.\n\n20\n\nbetter be from the transcript or the documents, and any\n\n21\n\nobjections should be rare and not based on your interpretation\n\n22\n\nof the available evidence but the fact of the available\n\n23\n\nevidence.\n\nI don't\n\nSo for both sides, any inference argued had\n\nWe should get through closings without objections.\n\n24\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nUnderstood, your Honor.\n\n25\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nUnderstood on our part, your Honor.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827138\n\n", "char_count": 1568}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 81, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 82 of 95\n\n2820\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nTHE COURT:\n\nThank you.\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nThis is the instruction where the\n\ngovernment also has a request, unless Mr. Everdell has anything\n4\n\nelse on 69.\n\n5\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nI do not.\n\n6\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nHere the government would request that\n\n7\n\nthe Court include the traditional \"government is not on trial\"\n\n8\n\nsentence.\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat I didn't permit.\n\n10\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nI saw that, your Honor.\n\nWe just wanted\n\n11\n\nto raise it with your Honor again.\n\n12\n\nsomething the defense put in issue in their\n\n13\n\nto the line of putting in issue in their opening and has been a\n\n14\n\ntheme of the defense case so far, and we assume they will come\n\n15\n\nclose to the line but hopefully not cross the line in their\n\n16\n\ndefense summation.\n\n17\n\nthat the circuit has said is appropriate.\n\n18\n\nanticipation of what we expect in the defense's summation, we\n\n19\n\nthink it is an appropriate inclusion in this instruction.\n\n20\n\nOur view is that it's\ncame very close\n\nAnd in light of that, it is an instruction\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nAnd so we think, in\n\nYour Honor, I don't think there's any\n\n21\n\nneed to anticipate.\n\n22\n\nwe're going to be very careful about the Court's ruling.\n\n23\n\ngoing to do our level best to make sure we stay within the four\n\n24\n\ncorners of the ruling.\n\n25\n\nis appropriate.\n\nIf there's an issue about what we say,\nWe're\n\nBut I think this instruction as written\n\nI suppose the government, if they want to\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827139\n\n", "char_count": 1556}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 82, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 83 of 95\n\n2821\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\n\nraise something before the charge is given based on the\nclosing, they can.\nTHE COURT:\n\nI think this is what I typically use, so\n\n4\n\nwe'll stick with that.\n\nAnd obviously closings will not cross\n\n5\n\nthe line as to what I've forbidden, or that may become\n\n6\n\nnecessary.\n\n7\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\n8\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nUnderstood, your Honor.\n\nI think that,\n\n9\n\njust to sort of complete the point, the government's particular\n\n10\n\nconcern is the argument about the empty chair and the\n\n11\n\ngovernment's motivations for this prosecution, which is\n\n12\n\nsomewhat different than the particular investigative techniques\n\n13\n\npoint that's elsewhere in this instruction, which is why we\n\n14\n\nthought the additional sentence is necessary.\nTHE COURT:\n\n15\n16\n\nI didn't permit and there will be no\n\nargument about the government's motivation.\n\n17\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nThat's clear, your Honor.\n\n18\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\n19\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nAll right.\n\n20\n\nYour Honor, we're all set.\n\nPage 73.\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n22\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n23\n\ngovernment, actually.\n\nAnything before that?\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n25\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nNo.\n\nOK.\n\nThat was the last edit from the\n\n73.\n\nThis is the preparation of witnesses\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827140\n\n", "char_count": 1353}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 83, "text_content": "Case 1:2O-cr-OO33O-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 84 of 95\n\n2822\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\n\ninstruction, instruction 55.\nI'm wrong.\n\nThe government can correct me if\n\nI don't think we had any testimony about preparing\n\nwitnesses, so I don't know if this instruction is necessary.\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n5\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n7\n\nNo.\n\nOK.\n\nFor sure.\n\nMaybe I'm mistaken about that.\n\n\"How many times did you meet with the\n\ngovernment?\"\n\n8\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n10\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n12\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n13\n\nAll right.\n\n14\n\nThere was.\n\nOK.\n\nFor example.\nOK.\n\nMaybe every, every --\n\nI stand corrected.\n\nOther than that, you've got it.\nOther than that, OK.\n\nI think that's all we have, apart from the\n\nverdict sheet.\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOK.\n\nAnything else, Mr. Rohrbach?\n\n16\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n19\n\ntracking some of the changes.\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nNo.\n\nOK.\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\nThe verdict sheet.\n\nThe verdict sheet, your Honor, is just\n\nWait, wait.\n\nSorry.\n\nYes.\n\n21\n\nmore that we caught this morning.\n\n22\n\n\"solely be,\" but it should be \"solely by.\"\n\n23\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n25\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nII, I had two\n\nPage 78, line 13, it says\n\nSorry, what line is that, your Honor?\n\n13.\nOK.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827141\n\n", "char_count": 1300}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 84, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 85 of 95\n\n2823\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd then there was one more heading, that\n\nhad that errant \"Two\" in it.\n\nII, page 52, instruction 37, that\n\nheading also has the word \"Two\" in it for some reason.\n4\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n6\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nYes, your.\n\nVerdict sheet.\nYour Honor, the edits here are just to\n\n7\n\ntrack changes we've adopted elsewhere.\n\n8\n\n\"conspiracy to entice an individual under the age of 17 to\n\n9\n\ntravel.\"\n\n10\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n12\n13\n\nSo as to Count One,\n\nThat's fine, your Honor.\n\nOK.\n\n\"An individual.\"\n\nRight.\n\nAll right.\n\nSo Count One, we'll adopt that and add \"under the age of 17.\"\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nThis is actually in Count One also,\n\n14\n\nshould be \"individuals,\" plural, I think, in light of the\n\n15\n\nchanges we've made?\n\n16\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n17\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n18\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n19\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n21\n\nRight.\n\nIt's a conspiracy count.\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nOK, Mr. Everdell.\nCount Two, the same thing.\n\nSorry.\n\nI just wanted your adoption,\n\n\"conspiracy to entice individuals under the age.\"\n\n22\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n23\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n24\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nSo we'll cut \"an\" and make it plural.\nYes, your Honor.\n\nGo ahead.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827142\n\n", "char_count": 1326}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 85, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 86 of 95\n\n2824\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nCount Two, \"enticement of an individual\n\nunder the age of 17.\"\n\nAnd then we would propose \"(Jane only),\"\n\nto add the word \"only,\" your Honor.\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo adding, after \"an individual,\" \"under\n\n5\n\nthe age of 17,\" adding in the parentheses, after the word\n\n6\n\n\"Jane,\" \"only.\"\n\n7\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n9\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nCorrect.\n\nOK.\nCount Three, to transport and then take\n\n10\n\nout the word \"a minor,\" this would be, I guess, \"individuals\n\n11\n\nunder the age of 17.\"\n\n12\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n14\n\nAgreed, your Honor.\n\nOK.\n\nI will make that change to\n\n\"individuals under the age of 17,\" taking out \"a minor.\"\n\n15\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nAnd then Count Four, \"transportation of\n\n16\n\nan individual,\" adding \"under the age of 17\" and adding the\n\n17\n\nword \"only\" after \"Jane.\"\n\n18\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOK.\n\n19\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat's fine, your Honor.\n\nAll right.\n\nMake that change, adding\n\n21\n\n\"under the age of 17\" and then adding \"only\" after the word\n\n22\n\n\"Jane.\"\n\n23\n24\n25\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\nsecond.\n\nLet's just skip over Count Five for a\n\nCount Six.\nTHE COURT:\n\n\"Only.\"\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827143\n\n", "char_count": 1251}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 86, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 87 of 95\n\n2825\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nCarolyn only, and it would say \"sex\n\ntrafficking of.\"\nTHE COURT:\n\n\"An individual.\"\n\n4\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n\"Under the age of 18.\"\n\n5\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nThat's fine, your Honor.\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nTaking out \"a minor,\" adding \"an\n\n7\n\nindividual under the age of 18,\" and then adding \"only\" after\n\n8\n\n\"Carolyn.\"\n\n9\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n11\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nCorrect, your Honor.\n\nOK.\nMoving back to Count Five, it's a\n\n12\n\nlittle cumbersome, I understand, the way the language is.\n\n13\n\nit would say \"sex trafficking conspiracy of individuals under\n\n14\n\nthe age of 18.\"\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOK.\n\n16\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nBut\n\nMr. Rohrbach.\n\nWe think it's a little unclear to say\n\n17\n\n\"conspiracy to commit sex trafficking of individuals under the\n\n18\n\nage of 18\"?\n\n19\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n21\n22\n23\n\nThat's fine.\n\nSo we'll change Count Five to \"conspiracy\n\nto commit sex\" -- how do you want to say it?\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n\"conspiracy to commit sex trafficking\n\nof individuals under the age of 18.\"\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n17.\n\n25\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\n18 for this.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827144\n\n", "char_count": 1204}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 87, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 88 of 95\n\n2826\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nTHE COURT:\n\nSorry.\n\nAll right.\n\nSo we'll make that change.\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n4\n\n18, Count Five.\n\nThe government has just one edit, if\n\nMr. Everdell is finished on the other.\n\n5\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nWhich one?\n\n6\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nWhich is on the top of the verdict\n\n7\n\nsheet.\n\n8\n\nit's a \"T\" in parentheses.\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n10\n\nAfter \"please indicate your verdict with a checkmark,\"\n\nThat's so odd.\n\nYes.\n\nWe'll convert that\n\nto a checkmark.\n\n11\n\nOK.\n\n12\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nNothing from the government.\n\n13\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nNothing from the defense, your Honor.\n\n14\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nJudge, I have something unrelated to\n\n15\n\nthe charge in the verdict sheet.\n\n16\n\nThat's it from the verdict sheet?\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right.\n\nGive me one moment just to go\n\n17\n\nthrough my to do list.\n\n18\n\nhear from the government by letter by 2.\n\n19\n\nI'll make my conclusions with respect to those.\n\n20\n\nparties a redline version of the changes made and a clean\n\n21\n\nversion, which will be the final version, unless -- I'll set a\n\n22\n\ntime when I send it to you, by a certain time.\n\n23\n\nany errors that were implemented in the implementation of the\n\n24\n\nchanges.\n\n25\n\nsheet.\n\nSo I have two open issues that I'll\n\nOtherwise that will be final.\n\nOnce I have that,\nWe'll send the\n\nYou indicate\n\nSame for the verdict\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827145\n\n", "char_count": 1426}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 88, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 89 of 95\n\n2827\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nMs. Sternheim, go ahead.\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nThank you, Judge.\n\nI don't know if the\n\nCourt has found out if any of the jurors are having issues\n4\n\nabout staying later on Monday.\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n6\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nThey were all fine.\nOK, because I just wanted to say that\n\n7\n\nwe are motivated, and I think the government would join me, in\n\n8\n\nhaving us complete all of the closing arguments and the charge\n\n9\n\non Monday.\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes.\n\nI think we can do that.\n\n11\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWhich gets to my next to-do item, which\n\n13\n\nis -- I realize we don't have the relevant people, but I think\n\n14\n\nMs. Moe had indicated two to three hours.\n\n15\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\nThat's right, your Honor.\n\n16\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nTwo sounds about right to me.\n\n17\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\n18\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n19\n20\n\nThat's even better to us.\n\nI mean, length of trial, the complexity of\n\nthe charges, this should be a two-hour closing.\nMS. COMEY:\n\nYour Honor, understood.\n\nWe did, I will\n\n21\n\nnote, streamline our case significantly, and there were a\n\n22\n\nnumber of exhibits that were not published to the jury, and I\n\n23\n\nthink we were explicitly told, that's for closing, when we\n\n24\n\nwanted to do it with witnesses.\n\n25\n\nbecause there is more work to be done connecting up a number of\n\nSo it's a little cumbersome,\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827146\n\n", "char_count": 1452}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 89, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 90 of 95\n\n2828\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\npaper exhibits that we were not able to show to the jury.\nthat's what might push it back two hours.\n\nSo\n\nSo I would ask for\n\nthe Court's indulgence to two and a half hours, in light of the\n4\n\nfact that we really didn't get to show the jury all of the\n\n5\n\nexhibits, and it's going to take more time to walk them through\n\n6\n\nthose exhibits that they haven't even seen.\n\n7\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right.\n\nSo two and a half, and two and\n\na half.\n\n9\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nThey should five minutes for rebuttal.\n\n10\n\nAnd it will be fine.\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nCan you do 30 for the rebuttal?\n\n12\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\nI would ask for the Court's indulgence for\n\n13\n\na little more than 30 if I may, just to have a little bit of a\n\n14\n\ncushion.\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right.\n\n35.\n\n16\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo we're going to start at 9.\n\nWe're going\n\n18\n\nto do a very short midmorning break.\n\n19\n\nlunch.\n\n20\n\nLet's say 30 minutes for you all to have lunch too.\n\n21\n\nthat, we should get through closings and the charge tomorrow\n\n22\n\nand potentially they can start deliberating, depending on what\n\n23\n\ntime it is.\n\n24\n25\n\nWe're going to do a short\n\nThe jurors' lunch will be here, I think, 20 minutes.\nGiven\n\nBut I agree --\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nYour Honor, just on the issue of\n\ntiming, thinking it through, so we start at 9, we start right\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827147\n\n", "char_count": 1478}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 90, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 91 of 95\n\n2829\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nat 9 and the government has a two and a half hour closing, that\nputs us at 11:30, roughly, give or take.\n\nIt would be the\n\ndefense's request we don't break the defense closing through\n4\n\nlunch.\n\n5\n6\n\nSo I don't know how that impacts the schedule.\nTHE COURT:\n\nWe do the best we can, is what I always\n\nsay.\n\n7\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n9\n\ntry to not break anything.\n\n10\n11\n\nUnderstood.\n\nWe'll see where we are.\n\nI'll have lunch here early, so that that's a\npossibility.\n\n12\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\nBut, yes, I agree.\n\n14\n\ncharge, I think it was about 80 pages.\n\n15\n\njob is reading the charge.\n\n16\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n\nor so, we should get there.\n\n19\n\nWe'll adjust and\n\nOK.\n\nAnd, you know, the\nMy favorite part of the\n\nAnd ours to listen.\n\nNothing better.\n\nBut I would guess an hour\n\nAnd the other thing I have on my to-do list, I\n\n20\n\nalways have the parties agree on the exhibits that are going\n\n21\n\nback to the jury, and I get that on the record, so forgive me\n\n22\n\nthat I'm not sure exactly where we are under COVID protocols.\n\n23\n\nThere was a time under COVID protocols where only electronic\n\n24\n\nexhibits went back.\n\n25\n\ntell me what's what, but I think now paper can go.\n\nI think, and\n\nisn't here to\nWhy don't\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827148\n\n", "char_count": 1415}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 91, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 92 of 95\n\n2830\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nyou all confer.\n\nGo ahead, Ms. Sternheim.\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nI'm going to wait until you finish and\n\nthen I'll -4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWhat I'd like to do, when we meet, before\n\n5\n\nthe jury comes in tomorrow -- not tomorrow -- Monday, as much\n\n6\n\nas I'd like to do it tomorrow.\n\n7\n\nand I would like to get on the record the parties' agreement as\n\n8\n\nto exactly what's going back to the jury, and\n\n9\n\ngive you our -- actually, we'll try to get that to you today or\n\n10\n\ntomorrow -- list of what we have as admitted exhibits, and you\n\n11\n\ncan agree or tell us if we've got anything wrong.\n\n12\n\nyour agreement on that list of admitted exhibits as well.\n\n13\n\nGo ahead.\n\n14\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nWe'll meet at 8:30 on Monday,\n\nThank you, Judge.\n\nwill\n\nAnd I'll get\n\nMy recommendation\n\n15\n\nfor efficiency purposes would be for the parties to agree on\n\n16\n\nwhat portions of the transcript should be redacted in case the\n\n17\n\njury wants it, so that we don't have to do readback and then\n\n18\n\nmake copies of the transcript could go in.\n\n19\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\nAgreed, your Honor.\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat is understood.\n\n21\n\nyou'll have that ready by Monday.\n\n22\n\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\n23\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n24\n\nYes.\n\n25\n\nAbsolutely.\n\nSo\n\nYes.\n\nGreat.\n\nThank you.\n\nAnd it is my practice to get that agreement and\n\nthen send the paper back.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827149\n\n", "char_count": 1442}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 92, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 93 of 95\n\n2831\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nMS. STERNHEIM:\n\nWe'll work on that.\n\nI know that the\n\ncourt reporters have often been very helpful in helping us do\nthat as well.\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n5\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nAll right.\n\nAnything else?\n\nOn that point, your Honor, the parties\n\n6\n\nare conferring on the redacted exhibits, and I anticipate we'll\n\n7\n\nget a letter probably later today if not hopefully later today\n\n8\n\nabout exactly what the proposed redacted exhibits are, so\n\n9\n\nthat's finished in advance of the closing.\n\n10\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n12\n13\n\nOK.\n\nWe're working on that.\nAnd have you worked out logistics on\n\nclosings for the sealed material?\nMS. COMEY:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nI believe the plan is to\n\n14\n\ndo what we did with the video exhibits, which is to have the\n\n15\n\npresentation from the parties up on the jurors' screens but not\n\n16\n\ndisplayed on the public screens or in the overflow room.\n\n17\n\nwe've also been working to get podium turned so that it's\n\n18\n\nfacing the jurors.\n\n19\n\nAnd\n\nAnd then I think there will be paper copies of the\n\n20\n\npresentations of the parties, for counsel who have screens that\n\n21\n\nare facing the gallery.\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nRight.\n\nSo there will be no\n\norally,\n\n23\n\nyou're not going to refer to any real names of witnesses who\n\n24\n\ntestified by pseudonym, etc.\n\n25\n\nthe jury during the presentation, but that won't be publicly\n\nThat will at times be shown to\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827150\n\n", "char_count": 1515}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 93, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 94 of 95\n\n2832\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\n\nhone.\nMS. COMEY:\n\nThat's exactly right, your Honor.\n\nAnd to\n\nthe extent there are images that were sealed, those would also\n4\n\nnot be shown to the public but would be shown to the jury.\n\n5\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOK.\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAny demonstratives of any kind planned,\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\nThe PowerPoint presentation, your Honor,\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n-- the PowerPoint, that does anything\n\nbut --\n\n12\n13\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\nother than --\n\n10\n11\n\nAny questions about\n\nthat?\n\n7\n\n9\n\nUnderstood.\n\nother than show admitted evidence or testimony?\n\n14\n\nbe some portions of the charge,\n\n15\n\nonce it's finalized.\n\nIt's possible that there would be text of\n\n16\n\nthe final charge on the slides.\n\n17\n\nbe anything beyond that, or excerpts of the transcript from the\n\n18\n\ntrial.\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n20\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nBut I don't think there would\n\nRight.\nActually on that point I didn't know\n\n21\n\nwhat the Court's practice was on that, whether the Court allows\n\n22\n\nthe final charge excerpts to be used in the closing or whether\n\n23\n\nwe do something else.\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI do allow it.\n\n25\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nOK.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827151\n\n", "char_count": 1238}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02827058", "page_number": 94, "text_content": "Case 1:20-cr-00330-AJN Document 765 Filed 08/10/22 Page 95 of 95\n\n2833\n\nLCIAMAX2ps\nTHE COURT:\n\nBut I'll hear if anybody has an objection.\n\nMS. COMEY:\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n5\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\n6\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\nOK.\n\nAnything else on that?\n\nNo.\n\nI think we just have to work a few\n\nredactions out.\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n8\n\nIt was just a minor thing, but we can't find it.\n\n9\n\nLet me just note, I want to thank the court staff who\n\nAnd I think we have one more minor edit.\n\n10\n\nworked on Saturday to make this possible, and my thanks to\n\n11\n\ncounsel and the parties for doing it.\n\n12\n\nwillingness to work on a Saturday.\n\n13\n\nI appreciate everybody's\n\nThank you.\n\nPage 51, line 13, missing the word \"at.\"\n\n\"The\n\n14\n\ngovernment has to prove that at least one of the overt acts.\"\n\n15\n\nSo inserting \"at.\"\n\n16\n\nMR. EVERDELL:\n\nNo objection, your Honor.\n\n17\n\nMR. ROHRBACH:\n\nYes.\n\n18\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n19\n\nWith that, thank you, everyone.\n\n20\n21\n\nAll right.\n\nWe'll make that change.\nI will see you Monday\n\nat 8:30.\n(Adjourned to 8:30 a.m., December 20, 2021)\n\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02827152\n\n", "char_count": 1139}]}