{"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_count": 69, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02822837", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02822837.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 1 of 69\n\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK\nCITY OF MIAMI GENERAL\nEMPLOYEES & SANITATION\nEMPLOYEES RETIREMENT TRUST\nand\nOPERATING ENGINEERS\nCONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY AND\nMISCELLANEOUS PENSION FUND\n\nCivil Case No: 1:23-cv-03903\nJURY TRIAL DEMANDED\n\nPlaintiffs,\nv.\n\nJAMES DIMON, STEPHEN B.\nTODD A. COMBS, JAMES S. CROWN,\nTIMOTHY P. FLYNN, MELLODY\nHOBSON, JOHN W. KESSLER, PHEBE\nN. NOVAKOVIC, and JAMES E.\nSTALEY,\n\nDefendants,\nand\nJPMORGAN CHASE & CO.,\nNominal Defendant.\n\nVERIFIED AMENDED STOCKHOLDER DERIVATIVE COMPLAINT\nPlaintiff City of Miami General Employees & Sanitation Employees Retirement Trust and\nPlaintiff Operating Engineers Construction Industry and Miscellaneous Pension Fund\n(\"Plaintiffs\"), for the benefit of nominal defendant JPMorgan Chase & Co. (\"JPM\" or the\n\"Company\"), bring the following Verified Amended Stockholder Derivative Complaint (the\n\"Complaint\") against Defendants James Dimon, Stephen B. =,\n\nTodd A. Combs, James S.\n\nEFTA02822837\n\n", "char_count": 1049}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 2 of 69\n\nCrown, Timothy P. Flynn, Mellody Hobson, John W. Kessler, Phebe N. Novakovic, and James E.\nStaley. The allegations of this Complaint are based on the knowledge of Plaintiffs as to themselves\nand the investigation of counsel, including the review of publicly available information and\ndocuments.\nINTRODUCTION\n1.\n\nWhen an otherwise reputable financial institution learns that a client is using bank\n\nfacilities to further a criminal scheme, the ensuing appropriate steps are clear: the bank terminates\nits relationship with the client, immediately reports the incident to regulators, and informs the\nboard of directors of the problem. But what should this Court infer when those commonsensical\n— and legally required — actions do not occur?\n2.\n\nThe bank at issue in this stockholder derivative action (the \"Action\") is JPM, one\n\nof the world's largest financial institutions. Based on Plaintiffs' investigation, it appears that the\nCompany did have appropriate internal controls in place to identify suspicious activity, such as\nmassive cash withdrawals and wires by Jeffrey Epstein (\"Epstein\"), a known felon convicted for\nsoliciting a minor for prostitution and clouded by allegations of rampant sexual abuse. Indeed,\nbeginning in 2006, JPM's compliance staff repeatedly flagged the need to end the bank's ties to\nEpstein, sending distress calls all the way up to the Company's second most-powerful decisionmaker, Defendant James \"Jes\" Staley (\"Staley\").\n3.\n\nFor instance, in 2011, JPM's own General Counsel, Stephen Cutler (\"Cutler\"),\n\ndocumented his unambiguous recommendation about Epstein, emailing Staley and CEO of JPM's\nAsset and Wealth Management business, Mary Erdoes (\"Erdoes\"), among others: \"This is not an\nhonorable person in any way. He should not be a client\" Despite these calls to cut ties with\nEpstein making it to the Company's C-suite — and, some of these cries coming from the C-suite\nitself - Epstein remained a\n... [truncated, 2089 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/1 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=1]", "char_count": 2089}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 3 of 69\n\nregulators, and there is no evidence that JPM's board of directors (the \"Board\") ever discussed\nEpstein prior to his death by apparent suicide in 2019.\n4.\n\nThe fundamental question that this Action presents is, why? Why didn't Staley, his\n\nboss, Defendant Chief Executive Officer (\"CEO\") and Chairman Jamie Dimon (\"Dimon\"), and\nthe JPM Board fire Epstein and his affiliates after the imperative of terminating the relationship\nwas recognized throughout the organization? JPM has proffered one answer, although it is both\nimplausible and unsatisfying. In recent litigation, the Company has tried to lay all of the blame on\nStaley for the Company's ongoing relationship with Epstein, which facilitated Epstein's payments\nto victims and network of enablers. In particular, JPM faults Staley for not reporting his alleged\nknowledge of— and personal participation in — Epstein's crimes to the Company.\n5.\n\nEven assuming that Staley obscured his relationship with Epstein, Staley's\n\nmisconduct does not tell the whole story. JPM executives — who presumably attended Board\nmeetings and reported to directors — plainly were aware of the Company's compliance\ndepartment's urges to fire Epstein. And, the Board — comprised of intelligent people at the\nforefront of the business world — very likely were aware of rampant allegations of sexual\nmisconduct levied against a purported billionaire deeply integrated into the highest reaches of the\nfinancial and political communities.\n6.\n\nSo, again, why did none of the JPM fiduciaries take action? As detailed below,\n\nEpstein was anything but a \"regular\" counterparty and client. Independent of the child sex rings\nthat made him one of the world's most notorious criminals, he had a uniquely diverse set of\nconnections to the people who shaped the JPM of today and who still control its operations. These\nconnections may explain why these fiduciaries proverbially \"put their heads in the sand\" and \n... [truncated, 2024 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/2 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=2]", "char_count": 2024}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 4 of 69\n\nthe Company's (and their own) ties to Epstein would go unnoticed—a far more plausible story\nthan JPM's tale making Staley the lone scapegoat.\n7.\n\nAt bottom, the failure by the individuals at the very top of JPM to do the obvious\n\nthing their fiduciary duties required, i.e., to cut Epstein off at the very latest by his 2008 guilty plea\nfor soliciting a minor for prostitution, likely reflects something worse than a \"mere\" failure of\ninternal controls or poor oversight. Instead, it reflects, at a minimum, a bad faith disregard for\ntheir duties.\n*_*_*_*_*_*\n8.\n\nEpstein was anything but a \"run of the mill\" JPM client. After a young Jeffrey\n\nEpstein suddenly left Bear Steams in 1980, he audaciously opened a financial advisory firm, J.\nEpstein & Co., premised on only representing billionaires. Somewhat inexplicably, he succeeded\nin not only advising, but often gaining the full power of attorney over the fortunes of some of the\nworld's richest and most powerful people. Those (presumably legitimate) connections and the\nbanking services needed to cater to that clientele would make him a marquee client that should get\nthe attention of any bank CEO and board.\n9.\n\nBeyond the profits his advisory firm could generate, Epstein also had alleged ties\n\nto some of the darker corners of the geo-political community, including personal entanglement in\nsome of the most notorious financial and political schemes of the 1980s and 1990s. It is almost\ninconceivable that a person whose entire career implicates so many widely reported scandals (such\nas infamous hedge fund Ponzi schemes, stealing software with national security implications, and\neven financing weapons and drug trade in the Iran-Contra affair) can go through any respectable\nKnow Your Customer (\"KYC\") bank vetting process without being tagged from the outset as a\nhigh-risk client.\n\n4\n\nEFTA02822840\n\n", "char_count": 1931}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\n10.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 5 of 69\n\nBut Epstein's reach also extended to the events and people who made JPM the\n\ninstitution it is today. In fact, by using his close friendship with apparel giant Leslie \"Les\" Wexner\n(\"Wexner\") as an entryway into the business and social elite circles of Columbus, Ohio, Epstein\ndeveloped direct or one-step-removed financial or personal ties to a range of individuals who\nserved or currently serve on the JPM Board.\nI.\n\nThese entanglements start no later than the 1980s, when Epstein salvaged a major\n\nfinancing and real estate transaction in which a number of power players in the Columbus, Ohio\nbusiness community participated. During that period, Wexner worked with prominent local\nexecutives, including future JPM directors James S. Crown (\"Crown\") and John W. Kessler\n(\"Kessler\") and the\n\nfamily (which founded and controlled Bank One Corporation (\"Bank\n\nOne\"), the largest bank in Ohio), to develop an idyllic community called New Albany, Ohio, which\nsought to house some of the most influential names in American business.\n12.\n\nThe Crown family had inherited via merger General Dynamics Corporation\n\n(\"General Dynamics\"), a weapons manufacturer with deep governmental ties, and enjoyed seats\non the board of First Chicago, another prominent Midwestern bank, before it was acquired by Bank\nOne and Crown joined the Bank One board. Kessler was a well-connected and prominent\ncorporate lawyer in Columbus, Ohio, who advised on a wide range of deals for Wexner, the\nMcCoys, and the Crowns alike, and enjoyed a seat on the Bank One board.\n13.\n\nDespite being backed by a marquee lineup of Columbus citizens, the New Albany\n\nproject struggled initially. Its early development was exceedingly expensive and complex, and\nwas mishandled by its original financial leadership. That changed after Epstein came along.\nEpstein was given a partnership interest in the New Albany project for a nominal investment.\n\n5\n\nEFTA02822841\n\n", "char_count": 1992}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 6 of 69\n\nEpstein promptly re-organized and restructured the New Albany development project so it could\ntake hold, be completed, and ultimately flourish.\n14.\n\nUntil 2000, Dimon had established his Wall Street reputation by serving as second-\n\nin-command in helping Sanford \"Sandy\" Weill (\"Weill\") transform his purchase of several\nfinancial institutions with links to both Epstein and British financier Robert Maxwell (whose\ndaughter Ghislaine remains in jail for her critical role in Epstein's sex trafficking ring) into the\ncurrent-day global banking behemoth Citigroup. After Dimon and Weill split up in 1998, Dimon\nre-emerged as Bank One's CEO, replacing a member of the\n\nfamily. Crown and Kessler\n\nboth sat on the Bank One board and, as detailed below, had glowing things to say about Dimon.\nThereafter, Dimon ingratiated himself in and publicly praised the Columbus business community,\nto which Epstein was described as \"ubiquitous.\" While Dimon denies ever meeting Epstein, his\nprofessed ignorance of the man's existence strains credibility.\nIS.\n\nAfter JPM's 2003 acquisition of Bank One, several former Bank One directors and\n\nofficers joined the highest ranks of the Company, including Dimon, Crown, Kessler, Stephen B.\n(\"=\"),\n\nand Linda B. Bammann (\"Bammann\"). It also appears that even before the\n\nmerger, JPM knew that Epstein was not a \"typical\" client, be it his line to banking services for\nbillionaire clients or more controversial issues. Staley, the head of JPM's private bank at the time,\nclaims that he was told in 2000 to \"get to know\" his new (and presumably important) client.\n16.\n\nPut simply, Defendants may not have known that Epstein catered to the worst\n\nproclivities of some of the world's most powerful people. But it appears that numerous people at\nthe apex of Bank One's, and later JPM's, decision-making structure not only knew of Epstein, but\nalso either had direct dealings with him or understood that they we\n... [truncated, 2142 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/5 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=5]", "char_count": 2142}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 7 of 69\n\nthe outset, and any functioning KYC onboarding process would make him a high-risk client\ngarnering extra monitoring and attention from the outset.\n17.\n\nWhether or not he was so designated from the outset, it did not take long for JPM\n\nemployees to begin openly questioning the Company's ongoing relationship with Epstein. A\nSeptember 2006 New York Times article about Epstein's arrest for soliciting a minor for\nprostitution triggered emails among JPM executives, including Erdoes, where she observed\n(sarcastically) that Epstein was \"a lovely guy to work with.\"\n18.\n\nBy the time of Epstein's 2008 guilty plea to the solicitation charge, JPM labeled\n\nEpstein a \"high-risk\" client, and many employees expressed the obvious need to terminate the\nrelationship. In fact, a mid-July 2008 internal risk function memorandum documented that\n\"Catherine [Keating, the CEO of the Company's Private Bank] will go back to Jes [Staley, then\nthe CEO ofJPM's Asset Management Division] to tellhim we are uncomfortable with Epstein...\"\n19.\n\nEven more striking, in August 2008, a JPM employee wrote that she \"would count\n\nEpstein's assets as a probable outflow for '08 ($120mm or so?) as I can't imagine it will stay\n(pending [Jamie) Dimon review).\" Whether Staley blocked the expected \"Dimon review\" or\nsomeone with authority (such as Dimon or a Board member) provided informal and tacit support\nto Epstein and thus obviated the formal \"Dimon review\" process, Epstein remained with JPM.\n20.\n\nDespite Epstein's 2008 guilty plea and ongoing sex crime allegations, neither JPM\n\nnor Staley ended their relationship with Epstein. Between 2008 and 2013, Staley and Epstein\nexchanged 1,200 emails (including pictures of young girls in seductive poses). Inexplicably, the\nbank's risk reviews of Epstein's accounts uncovered precisely zero of his grossly improper\ncommunications with Staley.\n\n7\n\nEFTA02822843\n\n", "char_count": 1951}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\n21.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 8 of 69\n\nBy mid-2010, a risk management division employee referred to \"new allegations\n\nof an investigation related to child trafficking,\" and asked whether JPM was \"still comfortable\nwith this client who is now a registered sex offender.\" Other JPM compliance employees decided\nthat Epstein \"should go.\"\n22.\n\nFar from breaking off relations with the man who served as power of attorney for\n\nWexner (a known JPM billionaire client) and unknown other billionaires and who played a role in\nbringing the New Albany, Ohio business elite to the heights of Wall Street and global finance, in\nDecember 2010, JPM granted Epstein a new $50 million line of credit.\n23.\n\nAs Epstein's notoriety as an international criminal became more obvious, internal\n\nefforts to distance the Company from the criminal client only grew louder. Yet no amount of risk\nmanagement could overcome the failure (or refusal) of senior management and the Board to\nintervene to protect the Company.\n24.\n\nAn internal March 2011 report explained that a company named \"MC2 Model\n\nManagement and Jeffrey Epstein engaged in racketeering that involved luring in minor children\nfor sexual play for money,\" and that MC2 Model Management's owner was a \"frequent passenger\non Epstein's private jet and often visited Epstein in jail.\"\n25.\n\nOn July 20, 2011, JPM's General Counsel Cutler emailed Staley and Erdoes, among\n\nothers, writing of Epstein: \"This is not an honorable person in any way. He should not be a\nclient.\" The next day, Cutler emailed Erdoes again, describing Epstein as: \"Not a person we\nshould do business with, period.\" Nevertheless, Epstein's accounts with the bank remained open\nand functional.\n26.\n\nJPM continued doing business with Epstein personally until 2013, and potentially\n\ncontinued to engage with Epstein related entities until his death in jail in 2019. In fact, the\n\n8\n\nEFTA02822844\n\n", "char_count": 1933}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 9 of 69\n\nCompany actively concealed Epstein's crimes by failing to file any legally required Suspicious\nActivity Reports (\"SARs\"), which are mandated for large cash withdrawals and other suspicious\ntransactions.\n27.\n\nThe Company's refusal to timely cut off its relationship with Epstein has harmed\n\nthe Bank already and is continuing to do so. JPM recently agreed to pay $290 million to settle a\nclass action lawsuit brought by Epstein's victims.\n\nJPM faces an ongoing lawsuit by the\n\ngovernment of the U.S. Virgin Islands in connection with harm it suffered due to the Company\nfinancing Epstein's use of a home base in the U.S. Virgin Islands until his arrest in 2019.\n28.\n\nIn sum, the story of Epstein using Company bank accounts and resources to support\n\nhis child sex trafficking ring was not a single client slipping through the cracks in the system.\nCompany fiduciaries knew about Epstein and his admitted and alleged crimes, but Epstein was not\n\"just\" a client. He was a business partner and colleague to various members of JPM management\nand the Board. The bank's delay and refusal to address (and end) its unacceptable relationship\nwith Epstein thus likely reflects a \"head in the sand\" attitude, with JPM officers and directors\nhoping the world would not discovery the Company's facilitation of Epstein's crimes.\nUnfortunately for them, the Company's ties to Epstein have come to light and caused significant\ndamage to JPM. Demand is excused, and the defendant fiduciaries should be accountable.\n\n9\n\nEFTA02822845\n\n", "char_count": 1582}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 10 of 69\n\nPARTIES AND RELEVANT NON-PARTIES\nI.\n\nPARTIES\nA. Plaintiffs\n29.\n\nPlaintiff City of Miami General Employees' & Sanitation Employees' Retirement\n\nTrust is a pension fund providing retirement benefits to active and retired employees of the City\nof Miami, Florida.\n30.\n\nCity of Miami General Employees' & Sanitation Employees' Retirement Trust\n\nowns 27,950 shares of JPM common M,\n\nhas continuously held JPM common since December\n\n2016, and is currently a stockholder of the Company. City of Miami General Employees' &\nSanitation Employees' Retirement Trust brings this Action derivatively on behalf of JPM and its\nstockholders to redress injuries that the Company suffered and will suffer as a direct result of\nDefendants' breaches of fiduciary duty. City of Miami General Employees' & Sanitation\nEmployees' Retirement Trust intends to retain JPM shares throughout the duration of this\nlitigation.\n31.\n\nPlaintiff Operating Engineers Construction Industry and Miscellaneous Pension\n\nFund is a stockholder of JPM, and has held JPM\n\nsince 2010.\n\nB. Nominal Defendant\n32.\n\nNominal defendant JP\n\nChase & Co. (as previously defined, \"JPM\" or the\n\n\"Company\") is a Delaware corporation headquartered in New York, New York, that operates as a\nglobal investment bank, providing financial services in the United States and across the globe.\nJPM's principal bank subsidiary is JP\non the New York\n\nChase Bank, N.A. The Company is publicly traded\n\nExchange under the ticker \"JPM.\"\n\n10\n\nEFTA02822846\n\n", "char_count": 1550}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 11of 69\n\nC. Director Defendants\n33.\n\nDefendant James S. Crown (as previously defined, \"Crown\") was a director of JPM\n\nfrom 2004 until June 2023. He served as a member of both the Public Responsibility Committee\nand the Risk Committee of the Board. Prior to its merger with JPM, Crown served as a director\nof Bank One from 1991 to 2004. Crown was one of the key people who selected Dimon as the\nCEO of Bank One in 2000 and advocated for his ascent at JPM. From 1987 to June 2023, Crown\nserved as a director for General Dynamics, an aerospace defense giant inherited by the Crown\nfamily following its merger with MSC in 1959. He joined General Dynamics as lead director in\n2010. Crown was a resident of Chicago, Illinois.\n34.\n\nDefendant John W. Kessler (as previously defined, \"Kessler\") was a director of\n\nJPM from 2004 to 2007. Prior to joining JPM's board, Kessler served as a director of Bank One\nfrom 1995 to 2004. From 1998 to present, he has been the chairman of the New Albany Company.\nKessler also served on the board of Wexner's company, Abercrombie & Fitch.\n\nKessler is an\n\nindividual and is believed to be a resident of New Albany, Ohio.\n35.\n\nDefendant Stephen B.\n\n(as previously defined, `=\")\n\nof JPM since 2004. Prior to its merger with JPM,\n\nhas been a director\n\nserved as a director of Bank One while\n\nDimon was Bank One's CEO. From 2011 until his retirement in 2020,\n\nwas the Chairman\n\nand COO of NBCUniversal, LLC and NBCUniversal Media, LLC.\n\nmade headlines at\n\nNBCUniversal during the Harvey Weinstein scandal after Ronan Farrow alleged that\n\nwas\n\nwarned in 2015 about a culture of sexual harassment at NBC's news division.\n\nis an\n\nindividual and is believed to be a resident of Dillon, Montana.\n36.\n\nDefendant Phebe N. Novakovic (\"Novakovic\") has been a director of JPM since\n\n2020. From 2013 to present, Novakovic has served as the Chairman and CEO of General\nDynamics, the aerospace defense company affiliated with the Cr\n... [truncated, 2051 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/10 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=10]", "char_count": 2051}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 12 of 69\n\nCrown had been a member of General Dynamics board since 1987. Novakovic has served in a\nvariety of leadership roles at General Dynamics since her start in 2002. Before joining General\nDynamics, Novakovic worked for the United States Department of Defense from 1997 to 2001\nand prior to that she served as an officer for the Central Intelligence Agency. Novakovic is an\nindividual and is believed to be a resident of Annapolis, Maryland.\n37.\n\nDefendant Timothy P. Flynn (\"Flynn\") has been a director of JPM since 2012. He\n\nis also a member of the Audit Committee of the Board. In his professional career, Flynn held\nvarious leadership roles at KPMG LLC in the US and finished his career as the Chairman ofKPMG\nInternational in 2011. Flynn has been a director of United Health Group since 2017 and of WalMart Stores, Inc since 2012. He was previously a director of the Alcoa Corporation and Chubb\nCorporation, and a member of the World Economic Forum's International Business Council.\nFlynn is an individual and is believed to be a resident of Marana, Arizona.\n38.\n\nDefendant Todd A. Combs (\"Combs\") has been a director of JPM since 2016.\n\nCombs was a member of the Risk Policy Committee of the Board from 2017 to 2019. Combs is\nan individual and is believed to be a resident of Omaha, Nebraska.\n39.\n\nDefendant Mellody Hobson (\"Hobson\") has been a director of JPM since 2018.\n\nShe serves a member of both the Public Responsibility Committee and the Risk Committee of the\nBoard. Hobson was a member of the Audit Committee of the Board in 2019. Hobson is presently\nthe Co-CEO of Ariel Investments, LLC (\"Ariel Investments\") where she has served as President\nand director since 2000. Ariel Investments was founded by John Rogers, a former Bank One\ndirector who served with Defendant Crown, among others, and was on the Bank One board at the\nsame time Dimon served as Bank One's CEO and one of its directors. Hobson is an individual\nand i\n... [truncated, 2069 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/11 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=11]", "char_count": 2069}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\n40.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 13 of 69\n\nAs used herein, \"Director Defendants\" refers to Dimon, Crown, Kessler,\n\nNovakovic, Flynn, Combs, and Hobson.\nD. Officer Defendants\n41.\n\nDefendant James \"Jamie\" Dimon (as previously defined, \"Dimon\") has been a\n\ndirector of JPM since 2004. Dimon has been JPM's CEO since 2005 and Chairman of the Board\nsince 2006. Until 1998, Dimon served as the President of Citigroup, under the leadership of his\nlong-term mentor, Weill. Amidst growing tensions between the two, Dimon was fired by Weill\nthat year. In 2000, Dimon was selected to become the new CEO of Bank One. In 2003, JPM\npurchased Bank One, launching Dimon into his role as JPM's CEO, which he assumed in 2005.\nDimon is an individual and is believed to be a resident of New York, New York.\n42.\n\nDefendant James E. Staley (as previously defined, \"Staley\") was the CEO of JPM's\n\nInvestment Bank from September 2009 through January 2013. Previously, Staley was the CEO\nof JPM's Asset Management division from 2001 to 2009 and was the head of JPM's Private\nBanking division from 1999 to 2001. Staley is an individual and is believed to be a resident of\nManhattan, New York.\n43.\n\nAs used herein, \"Officer Defendants\" refers to Dimon and Staley.\n\n44.\n\nAs used herein, \"Individual Defendants\" refers to the Directors Defendants and the\n\nOfficer Defendants.\nII.\n\nRELEVANT NON-PARTIES\n45.\n\nMary C. Erdoes (as previously defined, \"Erdoes\") joined JPM in 1996 as head of\n\nfixed income for high-net-worth accounts. She became CEO of JPM's Private Bank in 2005. In\nSeptember 2009, Erdoes obtained her current role as CEO of JPM's Asset & Wealth Management\ndivision. Besides Dimon, Erdoes is the longest serving member of the JPM operating committee,\nwhich is comprised of the Company's most senior executives.\n13\n\nEFTA02822849\n\n", "char_count": 1842}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 14 of 69\n\nJURISDICTION AND VENUE\n46.\n\nThe Court has jurisdiction over this action pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1332. The Court\n\nhas supplemental jurisdiction over the state law claims asserted herein pursuant 28 U.S.C. §\n1367(a). This action is not a collusive one to confer jurisdiction on a court of the United States\nwhich it would not otherwise have.\n47.\n\nVenue is proper in this Court because JPM has its principal place of business in this\n\nDistrict, Plaintiffs' claims arose in this District, and JPM has suffered and will continue to suffer\nharm in this District.\n48.\n\nPursuant to Local Civil Rule 1.6(a), the undersigned believe that this action is\n\nrelated to Jane Doe / Doe v. JP\n\nChase Bank, N.A., 22-cv-10019 (JSR) (the \"Jane Doe\n\nAction\") and Government ofthe United States Virgin Islands v. JP\n\nChase Bank, N.A., 22-\n\ncv-10904 (CSR) (the \"USV/ Action\"), which are currently pending before this Court. This Action\nand those actions arise from a common nucleus of operative fact involving JPM's participation,\ndirectly or indirectly, in Epstein's sex-trafficking venture by facilitating payments to women and\ngirls, channeling funds to Epstein to fund the operation, and concealing Epstein's criminal conduct\nby violating federal banking regulations.\nSUBSTANTIVE ALLEGATIONS\nI.\n\nCOMPLIANCE WITH BANKING LAWS AND REGULATIONS IS MISSIONCRITICAL TO JPM'S BUSINESS\n49.\n\nAs a global financial institution, compliance with banking laws and regulations is\n\nmission-critical to JPM's business. The Company acknowledges that it \"is subject to extensive\n\n14\n\nEFTA02822850\n\n", "char_count": 1629}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 15 of 69\n\nand comprehensive regulation under U.S. federal and state laws, as well as the applicable laws of\nthe jurisdictions outside the U.S. in which the Firm does business.\"'\n50.\n\nJPM's national bank subsidiary, JP\n\nChase Bank, N.A., \"is supervised and\n\nregulated by the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (`OCC') and, with respect to certain\nmatters, by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (the `FDIC').\"2\n51.\n\nFailure to comply with this \"extensive and comprehensive regulation\" could have\n\nsevere consequences on JPM's business. Indeed, the first \"Risk Factor\" that the Company\nidentifies in its annual report is \"Regulatory,\"3 and JPM proceeds to warn that \"[r]esolving\nChase to significant penalties and collateral\n\nregulatory investigations can subject JP\n\nconsequences,\" including \"greater exposure to litigation\" and damage to JP\n\nChase's\n\nreputation.\"4 Accordingly, JPM — and each of the Defendants — knew that regulatory compliance\n(including with the laws and rules discussed herein) was \"mission-critical\" to the Company.\n52.\n\nBecause financial institutions like JPM are susceptible to serving as conduits for\n\nsignificant financial crimes, the federal government has established a series of anti-money\nlaundering (\"AML\") laws and regulations. The primary federal laws governing banks with respect\n\nJPMorgan Chase & Co., Annual Report (Form 10-K), at t(FS. 21, 2023). Since at least 2006,\nthe Company has made similar disclosures. See, e.g., JP\nChase & Co., Annual Report\n(Form 10-K), at 6 (Mar. 9, 2006) (\"JPMorgan Chase operates within a highly regulated industry\nand its business and results are significantly affected by the regulations to which it is subject.\").\n2 JPMorgan Chase & Co., Annual Report (Form 10-K), at 4 (Feb. 21, 2023).\n3 Id. at 9.\n4 Id. at 11. Since at least 2006, the Company has made similar disclosures. See, e.g., JP\n\nChase & Co., Annual Report (Form 10-K), at 6 (Mar. 9, 2006) (\"JPMorgan\n... [truncated, 2461 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/14 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=14]", "char_count": 2461}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 16 of 69\n\nto AML are the Federal Bank Secrecy Act (\"BSA\") and certain provisions of the USA Patriot Act\n(the \"Patriot Act\").5\n53.\n\nThe BSA and Patriot Act require financial institutions to implement adequate risk-\n\nbased AML policies and systems to detect and prevent money laundering and other uses of a bank's\nservices and resources to facilitate criminal activities. Such requirements include maintaining a\ndue diligence program, filing SARs after detecting suspicious behavior, filing currency transaction\nreports (\"CTRs\") for currency transactions or series of currency transactions that exceed $10,000\nin a 24-hour period, preventing structuring or assistance with structuring of transactions\nundertaken for the purpose of evading federal reporting requirements, and maintaining systems to\nprevent money laundering.\n54.\n\nThe Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council (\"FFIEC\") — a formal U.S.\n\ngovernment interagency body of banking regulators that is empowered to prescribe uniform\nprinciples, standards, and report forms to promote uniformity in the supervision of financial\ninstitutions — has published a Bank Secrecy Act / Anti-Money Laundering Examination Manual\n(the \"FFEIC Manual\") to provide further guidance to financial institutions on BSA / AML\ncompliance.6 FFIEC is comprised of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, the\nFDIC, the National Credit Union Administration, the OCC, and the Consumer Financial Protection\nBureau.\n55.\n\nThe FFEIC Manual makes clear that ultimate responsibility for regulatory\n\ncompliance lies with the financial institution's board ofdirectors: \"The board of directors, acting\n\n5 United Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and\nObstruct Terrorism Act of 2001, Pub. L. No. 107-56, 115 Stat. 272.\n6 FFIEC regularly updates the FFEIC Manual. Given the relevant period for this Complaint, cites\nherein are to the 2006 edition of the FFEIC \n... [truncated, 2027 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/15 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=15]", "char_count": 2027}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 17 of 69\n\nthrough senior management, is ultimately responsible for ensuring that the bank maintains an\neffective BSA/AML internal control structure, including suspicious activity monitoring and\nreporting.\"' Such controls should include:8\n•\n\n\"Identify[ing] banking operations . . . more vulnerable to abuse by money\nlaunderers and criminals; provid[ing] for periodic updates to the bank's risk profile;\nand provid[ing] for a BSA / AML compliance program to manage risks.\"\n\n• \"Informfingl the board of directors, or a committee thereof, and senior\nmanagement, of compliance initiatives, identified compliance deficiencies, and\ncorrective action taken, and notify directors and senior management of [SARs]\nfiled.\"\n• \"Implementfing/ risk-based customer due diligence (CDD) policies, procedures,\nand processes.\"\n• \"IdentiMingl reportable transactions and accurately file all required reports\nincluding SARs, [CTRs], and CTR exceptions.\"\n• \"Provid[ing] sufficient controls and monitoring systems for timely detection and\nreporting of suspicious activity.\"\n56.\n\nThe FFEIC Manual explains that effective CDD policies are \"critical\" because they\n\nare needed for. (a) \"[d]etecting and reporting unusual or suspicious transactions that potentially\nexpose the bank to financial loss, increased expenses, or reputational risk\"; (b) \"[a]voiding\ncriminal exposure from persons who use or attempt to use the bank's products and services for\nillicit purposes\"; and (c) \"[a]dhering to safe and sound banking practices.\"9\n57.\n\nWith respect to \"high-risk customers,\" the FFEIC Manual instructs that\n\n\"[e]nhanced due diligence . . . is especially critical in understanding their anticipated transactions\n\n7 Bank Secrecy Act / Anti-Money Laundering Examination Manual, Federal Financial Institutions\n\nExamination\nCouncil,\nat\n29\n(2006),\nhttps://www.ffiec.gov/pdfibsa_aml_examination_manual2006.pdf.\n\navailable\n\nat\n\n8 Id. at 29-30.\n9 Id. at 56.\n\n17\n\nEFTA02822853\n\n", "char_count": 1998}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 18 of 69\n\nand implementing a suspicious activity monitoring system that reduces the bank's reputation,\ncomplaint, and transaction risks.\"10 Moreover, \"due diligence is an ongoing process\" and risk\nprofiles should be adjusted as necessary.\"\nClosely related to a bank's CDD policies is its suspicious activity reporting, which\n\n58.\n\nthe FFEIC Manual calls \"the cornerstone of the BSA reporting system.\"' Banks arc required to\nfile a SAR with respect to, among other things:13\n•\n\n\"Criminal violations aggregating $5,000 or more when a suspect can be identified.\"\n\n•\n\n\"Criminal violations aggregating $25,000 or more regardless of a potential\nsuspect.\"\n\n•\n\n\"Transactions conducted or attempted by, at, or through the bank . . . aggregating\n$5,000 or more, if the bank .. . knows, suspects, or has reason to suspect that the\ntransaction\": (a) \"Imlay involve potential money laundering or other illegal\nactivity; (b) \"Ns designed to evade the BSA or its implementing regulations\"; or\n(c) \"Alas no business or apparent lawfulpurpose or is not the type of transaction\nthat the particular customer would normally be expected to engage in, and the bank\nknows of no reasonable explanation for the transaction after examining the\navailable facts, including the background and possible purpose of the transaction.\n\n59.\n\nThe FFEIC Manual continues: \"Appropriate policies, procedures, and processes\n\nshould be in place to monitor and identify unusual activity.\"10 When a bank detects suspicious\nactivity, it must file a SAR within 30 days to the U.S. Department of the Treasury's Financial\nCrimes Enforcement Network.\" Moreover, where there is continuing suspicious activity, a bank\nshould file a SAR at least every 90 clays.\"\n\n10 Id. at 57.\nII Id. at 58.\n12 Id. at 60.\n\"\n\nId. at 60-61.\n\n14 1d. at 61.\n\n15 Id. at 66, 68.\n16 Id. at 69.\n\n18\n\nEFTA02822854\n\n", "char_count": 1897}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\n60.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 19 of 69\n\nBanks are required to notify their boards of directors when SARs have been filed,\"\n\nand the FFEIC Manual advises that \"management should provide sufficient information on its\nSAR filings to the board of directors or an appropriate committee in order to fulfill its fiduciary\nduties.\"I8 Under the laws of Delaware — JPM's state of incorporation — the Board's fiduciary\nduties require them to implement adequate oversight systems to ensure compliance with laws and\nregulations, including the BSA and the Patriot Act.\nIL\n\nEPSTEIN'S PRE-JPM PROFESSIONAL BACKGROUND MADE HIM A \"HIGH\nRISK-HIGH REWARD\" CLIENT FROM THE OUTSET\n61.\n\nHistorical context is necessary to appreciate why and how Epstein could thrive\n\nwithin JPM even though a person without links to the bank's power centers would surely have\nbeen reported to authorities and terminated as a client when his status as a child sex trafficker\nbecame known within the Company.\n62.\n\nEpstein's history and notoriety at the time of his earliest interactions with JPM\n\nsupports the inference that, from the outset, he would have been recognized as a high-risk, but\nhigh-reward, client, and would likely have been reported to the highest levels within the Company.\nWhat already was known around the time Epstein was onboarded at JPM in 1998 — not to mention\nwhat came to light in 2002 to 2003 — begs the question of whether plentiful red flags were\nintentionally ignored by those in positions of power to retain Epstein as a client, overriding the\nmany concerns that his history should have raised.\n63.\n\nBased solely on the sheer volume of money for an exceedingly high-profile\n\nclientele that Epstein purported to handle, it is probable that his seeking to open an account would\nhave been brought to the attention ofany bank CEO. Even when the JPM onboarding process for\n\n17 Id. at 67.\n18 Id. at 68.\n\n19\n\nEFTA02822855\n\n", "char_count": 1938}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 20 of 69\n\nEpstein was taking place around 1998, there were already an array of reasons that his desire to\nbank with JPM would have garnered attention from the highest levels of the Company, and should\nhave triggered KYC measures.\n64.\n\nAmong these red flags were a trail of financial irregularities and crimes left in\n\nEpstein's wake among those he was known to be close to, including an SEC investigation into\ninsider trading during his time at Bear Steams, his proximity to the Tower Financial Ponzi scheme,\nand his incredibly close ties to Robert Maxwell, whose theft of over $1.2 billion of his clients'\nmoney had recently come to light. Epstein's history even at this time also included early red flags\nof his horrific sexual abuses, still being unearthed and litigated to this day.\nA. The Founding and Expansive Reach of J Epstein & Co\n65.\n\nIn the summer of 1974, Epstein found himself within the halls of the prestigious\n\nDalton School on Manhattan's Upper East Side, teaching physics and calculus, despite the fact\nthat he was 21 years old and had no college degree. Epstein's foray into education, however,\nproved short-lived. In 1976, he traded his classroom for the financial sphere, securing a position\nat Bear Steams — an institution that would later be subsumed by JPM.\n66.\n\nWorking under the direct tutelage of Wall Street legends Alan \"Ace\" Greenberg\n\nand James \"Jimmy\" Cayne, Epstein rapidly ascended the Bear Stems ranks, attaining the title of\nsenior partner by 1980. However, shortly thereafter, the Securities and Exchange Commission\n(\"SEC\") initiated a formal investigation into Bear Steams about insider trading around a tender\noffer placed on March 11, 1981, by the Seagram Company Ltd. for St. Joe Minerals Corp. Epstein\nleft Bear Stearns the next day, March 12, 1982. This investigation included at least one personal\ninterview with Epstein by the SEC on April I, 1981, regarding potential charges, and it has been\nre\n... [truncated, 2159 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/19 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=19]", "char_count": 2159}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\n67.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 21 of 69\n\nIn fact, according to his SEC interview and a contemporaneous Bear Stearns\n\nmemorandum from the Executive Committee, Epstein left the company because he had illicitly\nlent money to clients. The transcript of this interview and its exhibits (including the memorandum\nfrom the Executive Committee) are publicly available. After being fined and suspended by the\nExecutive Committee, Epstein resigned.\n68.\n\nEpstein opened his own financial advisory firm, named J Epstein & Co., in 1982.\n\nThe company did not employ any analysts or portfolio managers, operating instead with\napproximately twenty accountants.\n\nDespite lacking any marketing efforts, grand opening\n\nannouncements, or even simple promotional flyers, J Epstein & Co. mysteriously thrived a mere\nyear after its establishment, boasting a client base consisting of a large number of ultra-high net\nworth individuals. The firm purported to cater exclusively to clients with a net worth of $1 billion\nor more — a striking anomaly in the financial industry at the time when billionaires were\nconsiderably rarer.19 In fact, a 2002 article in New York Magazine reported that Epstein was known\nto scoff at offers to manage accounts of less than $1 billion, flatly — and often rudely — turning\ndown requests to manage accounts of $500 million or $700 million as \"too small.\"2°\n69.\n\nWhile some have questioned his veracity, Epstein consistently claimed that the\n\nworld's wealthiest and most influential people flocked to give Epstein control over their finances.\n70.\n\nImportantly, according to those acquainted with him or under his employment,\n\nEpstein's business model hinged on maintaining absolute control over his clients' assets. He went\nso far as to assume power of attorney over his clients' assets, providing him with total control over\nthese immense pools of wealth, and unfettered authority over the finances of some of the world's\n\n19 Landon\nJr., Jeffrey Epstein: Inte\n... [truncated, 2130 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/20 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=20]", "char_count": 2130}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 22 of 69\n\nwealthiest individuals. 21 At the time, Epstein's most significant confirmed client was Wexner, the\nbillionaire behind Limited Brands and Victoria's Secret — and a director of Columbus-based Bank\nOne. As discussed below, Epstein's close connection with Wexner paved the way for his\nentanglement with the Bank One and later JPM boards.\nB. Epstein's Known Ties to the Maxwells Should Have Made Him a \"High Risk\"\nClient From the Time of His Onboarding at JPM\n71.\n\nIn the early 1980s, Epstein spent his days traveling between England and the United\n\nStates where he integrated into social circles comprised of socialites, arms-dealers, spies,\nbillionaires, politicians, gangsters, and various other influential figures. While in England, Epstein\nfirst encountered British media baron Robert Maxwell, the father of Ghislaine Maxwell (with\nwhom Epstein would later partner in running his sex trafficking rings).\n72.\n\nThroughout his life, Robert Maxwell was renowned as a media proprietor, a\n\nmember of the British Parliament, a suspected spy, and, later on, a notorious fraudster. Most\nimportantly, he was eye-poppingly rich and offered Epstein the connections and money that helped\nto turn J Epstein & Co into a massive financial advisory business. As explained in more detail\nbelow, some of these connections included General Dynamics and the Crown Family, a member\nof which sat on the Bank One board and currently sits on the JPM Board, i.e., Defendant Crown.\n73.\n\nPrior to his mysterious death on his yacht in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean in\n\n1991, Robert Maxwell faced allegations of espionage for the Israeli Intelligence Directorate\n(\"HD\"). Following his death, these accusations were corroborated by former HD employees and\nan unnamed U.S. intelligence official 22\n21 Id.\n22 Whitney M,\nFormer Israeli Intel Official Claims Jeffrey Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell Worked\nfor Israel, MINTPRESS NEWS (Oct. 2, 2019), https://www.mintpr\n... [truncated, 2109 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/21 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=21]", "char_count": 2109}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\n74.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 23 of 69\n\nWhether or not he had links to intelligence agencies, Robert Maxwell served as a\n\nmentor to Epstein, even hoping that Epstein would become his son-in-law. As Ari Ben Menashe,\nthe former IID employee who claimed to be Maxwell's \"handler,\" put it, \"Robert Maxwell saw in\nJeffrey Epstein a potential husband for his daughter and a potential business partner for himself.\"23\nIt appears that Ghislaine Maxwell's father introduced her to Epstein in the 19805.24\n75.\n\nEpstein presented himself to Ghislaine Maxwell as a financial expert who could\n\nhelp her family finance its business. During that time period, Robert Maxwell allegedly needed a\n$50 million bridge loan, which Epstein secured.25\n76.\n\nAccording to reporting by, among others, Seymour Hersh, under Robert Maxwell's\n\nguidance, both Ghislaine Maxwell and Epstein participated in a clandestine operation involving\narms dealing, blackmail, and financial fraud, which ultimately played a role in the Iran-Contra\nscandal. But that connection also provided the basis for a more strengthened Epstein-Ghislaine\nMaxwell link.\n77.\n\nRobert Maxwell's involvement with Israeli intelligence became evident following\n\nhis meeting with Epstein in London in the 1980s. Maxwell was allegedly involved in the PROMIS\nscandal, also known as the \"Inslaw Affair.s26 PROMIS, short for \"Prosecutors Management\nInformation System,\" was a software developed by U.S.-based Inslaw Inc. and designed to help\n\n23 Michael McKinley & Barbara Shearer, Ghislaine Maxwell: Privilege, Power, Perversion,\nhttps://www.inkshares.com/booksIghislaine-maxwell-privilege-powerINKSHARES,\nperversion/book_segments/meeting-jeffrey.\n24 Id.\n25 Id.\n26 Emma North-Best, Sir Robert Maxwell's FBI File is Getting More Classified By the Minute,\nMUDROCK (June 28, 2017), https://www.muckrock.com/news/archives/2017/jim/28/sir-robertmaxwells-fbi-PROMIS/.\n\n23\n\nEFTA02822859\n\n", "char_count": 1947}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 24 of 69\n\nfederal and state prosecutors track and flag potential money laundering operations and suspicious\nwire transfers.27\n78.\n\nAccording to investigative journalist covering the Inslaw Affair, Earl Brian, an\n\nassociate of President Ronald Reagan, and his Attorney General Edwin Meese (\"Meese\"), sought\nto acquire access to this software. Meese and members of the Department of Justice covertly\nobtained the PROMIS software intending to use it to help U.S. intelligence organizations indirectly\nfacilitate the very crimes that the program was supposed to prevent.\n79.\n\nThe software also landed in the hands of Israeli agents, who installed a backdoor\n\ninto the program and attempted to sell it to U.S. military-industrial companies, including General\nDynamics (affiliated with the Crown family that later enjoyed seats on the Bank One and JPM\nboards of directors). The alleged intermediary for this operation was Robert Maxwell.\n80.\n\nGiven the high volume of publicity surrounding Ghislaine Maxwell and Epstein's\n\nrelationship in the 1990s, Epstein's ongoing dealings with the Maxwell family would inevitably\nhave come up in any adequate bank onboarding or KYC due diligence process.\nC. Epstein's Role in the Tower Financial Ponzi Scheme and Affiliation With\nFounder Steve Hoffenberg Should Have Raised Major Red Flags During his\nJPM Onboarding\n81.\n\nIn 1993, Steven Hoffenberg (\"Hoffenberg\"), one of Epstein's early mentors, was\n\nconvicted for perpetrating one of the largest Ponzi schemes prior to Bernie Madoff.\n82.\n\nTower Financial Corporation (\"Towers\") came into existence in the early 1970s as\n\na debt collection agency stationed in Manhattan, New York. Hoffenberg was the driving force\nbehind its creation, taking on the roles of Chairman, CEO, and President. In 1987, shortly after\n\n27 Richard L. Fricker, The INSLAW Octopus, WIRED (JAN. I, 1993, 12:00 PM),\nhttps://www.wired.com/ 1993/01/inslaw/.\n\n24\n\nEFTA02822860\n\n", "char_count": 1986}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 25 of 69\n\nEpstein's departure from Bear Stearns, Hoffenberg was introduced to Epstein by Sir Douglass\nLeese, who had ties to Robert Maxwell.\n83.\n\nRegarding Epstein, Leese told Hoffenberg: \"He's great at selling securities. And\n\nhe has no moral compass.\"28 Hoffenberg thereafter welcomed Epstein into the fold as a consultant,\nproviding him with a monthly salary of $25,000 (roughly $67,000 in today's dollars). When\nprompted about his association with Epstein years later, Hoffenberg stated, \"He was my best friend\nfor years. My closest friend for years.\"\"\n84.\n\nIn February 1993, the SEC lodged charges against Towers, Hoffenberg, and the\n\nremaining executive committee for perpetrating a $460 million Ponzi scheme that defrauded nearly\n200,000 Americans. Hoffenberg pleaded guilty to fraud, obstruction of justice, and tax evasion in\n1995, and was sentenced to a 20-year prison term.\n\nHoffenberg's co-conspirators received\n\nsentences ranging from seven to nine years.\n85.\n\nWhile Epstein escaped charges, numerous press articles and court documents\n\nsuggest Epstein was initially implicated in the scheme, with some witnesses even naming him as\nthe true architect. Yet, his name mysteriously disappeared from the court records.30 In any event,\n\n28 Marc Fisher & Jonathan O'Connell, Jeffery Epstein: The Trail of Ruined Lives, Misery and\nBankruptcy Arch-Swindler and Paedophile Left in His Wake, INDEPENDENT (Aug. II, 2019, 2:23\nPM), https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/jeffrey-epstein-death-sex-traffickingminors-victims-justice-us-courts-fbi-investigation-a9051911 .html.\n29 Brian Pascus & Mola Lenghi, Jeffrey Epstein Worked at Financial Firm That Engaged in\nMassive Portz' Scheme in 1980s and 1990s, CBS (August 13, 2019 9:12 AM),\nhttps://www.cbsnews.com/news/jeffrey-epstein-worked-at-towers-financial-with-stephenhoffenberg-who-committed-ponzi-scheme-crimes/.\n30 Marc Fisher & Jonathan O'Connell, Final Evasion:\n\nFor 30 Yea\n... [truncated, 2416 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/24 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=24]", "char_count": 2416}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 26 of 69\n\nEpstein's role as a consultant to Towers should have been red flags to a bank with proper AML\nsystems in place and conducting adequate KYC due diligence.\n86.\n\nFollowing Epstein's arrest and subsequent incarceration in 2019, Hoffenberg,\n\nhaving served 18 years in prison, alleged that Epstein had in fact been the true mastermind behind\nthe entire scheme. When questioned about his silence on Epstein's involvement, Hoffenberg\nclaimed that Epstein had significant sway within the United States Department of Justice, further\nemphasizing, \"You cannot grasp the magnitude of (Epstein's] controlling effect.i31 Given the\nsheer scale of the scheme and the extensive media coverage it attracted, it is hard to believe that\nmajor players in the financial world who worked with Epstein remained ignorant of Epstein's\nidentity by 1995.\nIII.\n\nEPSTEIN'S \"UBIQUITOUS\" BUSINESS TIES TO THE COLUMBUS, OHIO\nBUSINESS ELITE THAT CREATED AND COMPRISE JPM'S CURRENT BOARD\nAND LEADERSHIP MAY EXPLAIN HIS SPECIAL TREATMENT AT JPM\nA. Epstein Salvages and Successfully Turns Around the \"New Albany\" Project\nCreated by Wexner and Kessler\n87.\n\nSometime in the early 1980s, Epstein was introduced to Wexner, the billionaire\n\nbehind Limited Brands and Victoria's Secret. Wexner was one ofEpstein's earliest confidants and\nwealthiest clients, and close associates of Wexner found it perplexing that he would so quickly\nentrust his fortune to a relative newcomer like Epstein. However, Epstein soon demonstrated his\nworth, providing timely assistance to Wexner's business venture in New Albany, Ohio.\n88.\n\nThe New Albany project was the redevelopment of thousands of acres of farmland\n\noutside of Columbus, Ohio into a town modeled after an 18th-century Georgian village. The\n\n31 Gina Tron, Jeffrey Epstein Allegedly Took Part In Ponzi Scheme Before Creating 'Molestation\nPyramid Scheme,' OXYGEN (June 3, 2020, 6:30 PM), https://www.oxygen.com/true-crimebunIste\n... [truncated, 2085 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/25 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=25]", "char_count": 2085}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 27 of 69\n\ndevelopment includes multi-million dollar homes built around a Jack Nicklaus-designed golf\ncourse. Wexner and his business partner Kessler invested significant capital into the project.\n89.\n\nBy 1988, Wexner and Kessler's ambitious real estate project had become a financial\n\ndebacle. To salvage the venture, Wexner enlisted Epstein's help. A Columbus-based investigative\njournalist has stated that \"Before Epstein came along in 1988, the financial preparations and\ngroundwork for the New Albany development were a total mess\" and that \"Epstein cleaned\neverything up.\"32\n90.\n\nThe New Albany venture marked the first interaction between Kessler and Epstein,\n\nestablishing a link to Epstein's future relationship with JPM. Kessler was a future supporter of\nDimon who helped him reach the highest echelons of Bank One and JPM, placing Epstein at just\none degree of separation from Dimon (at most).\n91.\n\nKessler was a co-founder ofNew Albany and was a director on the Bank One board\n\nduring its merger with JPM and stayed on as a director of JPM. He was also on the search\ncommittee that appointed Dimon as CEO of Bank One in 2000. He has described Dimon as the\n\"best banker in the country\" and stated that Dimon loves Columbus and that \"he'd move\neverybody\" at JPM to Columbus if he could.33 Kessler, of course, knew Epstein and owed the\nsuccess of the New Albany project to Epstein.\n92.\n\nAdditionally, John G. =,\n\nthe father of John B. =,\n\nreal estate in the New Albany development. John G.\n\nwas an early buyer of\n\nhad appointed Kessler to the Bank\n\nOne board and they had a close relationship, with Kessler calling the senior John G.\n\nhis\n\n32 Landon\nJr., Jeffrey Epstein: International Moneyman of Mystery, N.Y. MAG (Oct. 28,\n2002), nymag.com/nymetro/news/peoplein_7912.\n33 CEO Jack Kessler: Local Visionary: It's How You Treat People, COLUMBUS DISPATCH (Aug.\n24, 2014, 12:01 AM), https://www.dispatch.comistoryibusiness/2014/08/24/ce\n... [truncated, 2063 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/26 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=26]", "char_count": 2063}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nmentor.34 John G. =,\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 28 of 69\n\nas a former executive of Bank One, close friend of Kessler, and early\n\ninvestor in New Albany, on information and belief interacted with Epstein.\nB. Epstein's Success Ingratiated Him to Bank One, the Columbus Elite, and l uture\nDecision Makers at JPM\n93.\n\nEpstein's connections to Bank One, the Columbus elite, and JPM goes even further.\n\nAs a gesture of gratitude for saving the New Albany project, Wexner and Kessler welcomed\nEpstein as a general partner in New Albany Co.'s holding company. This move came at a nominal\ncost to Epstein, despite both Wexner and Kessler having already invested billions into the project.\n94.\n\nWexner even let Epstein build a 10,000 square foot home on Wexner's personal\n\nestate within the New Albany development. Epstein, Kessler, Wexner, and John G.\n\nwere\n\nall property owners (and neighbors) in this new and exclusive community.\n95.\n\nEpstein's connections to Columbus continued to develop — in fact, one article notes:\nMr. Epstein became ubiquitous in Ohio. His black book of\ncontacts filled up with phone numbers with Columbus's 614 area\ncode. That included dozens of numbers for Mr. Wexner, his\npersonal staff and L Brands executives — even a couple of local\ndoctors. Mr. Epstein, who would fly in and out of Columbus on his\nprivate plane, became a fixture at Mr. Wexner's parties and an\nannual fund-raiser for the Wexner Center for the Arts, which\nincluded a luncheon at the billionaire's home.\nMr. Epstein became deeply involved in Mr. Wexner's upscale realestate development in New Albany, about 15 miles outside\nColumbus. He set up shop in the same downtown Columbus\nskyscraper as Jack Kessler.\n\n96.\n\nThis same group of the Columbus elite helped Dimon become CEO of Bank One\n\nin 2000. The Bank One board of directors that appointed Dimon included Kessler, who knew\nEpstein from the New Albany project. Former Bank One board members and executives including\n\n34 M.\n\n28\n\n... [truncated, 2015 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/27 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=27]", "char_count": 2015}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nWexner and John G.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 29 of 69\n\nhad New Albany property neighboring Epstein. And the Columbus\n\nelite that did business with Bank One ran in the same social circles as Epstein.\nC. Bank One Merges with First USA and First Chicago\n97.\n=,\n\nIn 1997, John B.\n\na native of Columbus, Ohio and the son of John G.\n\nthe founder of Banc One Corporation (which later became Bank One), served as Bank\n\nOne's Chairman and CEO. As the 1990s drew to a close, Bank One undertook a sequence of\nsignificant, high-profile mergers that redefined its corporate identity.\n98.\n\nIn January 1997, Bank One agreed to merge with Texas-based First USA Bank.\n\nFollowing the closing of this transaction, in 1998, Bank One embarked on another significant\nmerger, this time with First Chicago Bank. While completing the First Chicago deal, John B.\nwas secretly meeting with Dimon in an attempt to bring him to Bank One as his number\ntwo.\n\n99.\n\nAt the time, John B.\n\nwas fully aware of Epstein's dealings in Ohio and with\n\nWexner and Kessler, his Bank One colleagues who had worked with Epstein on creating the New\nAlbany development.35 Additionally, his father owned property in the New Albany development\nalong with Wexner, Kessler, and Epstein.\n100.\n\nUnfortunately for John B. =,\n\nBank One suffered a series of adverse financial\n\nresults, leading to his resignation as CEO and Chairman in December 1999. This void in leadership\nlead to speculation that Dimon would step in to lead Bank One, having recently been fired from\nCitigroup.\n\n35The\n\nReal\n\nCOLUMBUS\n\nMONTHLY\n\nFeb.\n\n9.\n\n2014.\n\n11:01\n\nPM)\n\n29\n\nEFTA02822865\n\n", "char_count": 1638}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\n101.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nIndeed, the New York Post wrote: \"John\n\nPage 30 of 69\n\nstepped down as CEO of Banc\n\nOne, the Ohio based superregional bank. Dimon's name leapt to the top of the list of possible\nsuccessors. But as one bank analyst pointed out to Bull's Eye, `Why would Jamie want to move\nto Ohio? He's a New York boy.\"'\nD. Dimon's Move to New York and Into the Midwest Power Circle\n102.\n\nThe New York Post's skepticism proved misguided. In early 2000, Dimon was\n\nvying for the CEO position at Bank One. Dimon's fate rested in the hands of a group ofindividuals\nlike Kessler, who would not only shape his forthcoming leadership trajectory but also, as discussed\nabove, were already quite familiar with the comings and goings of Epstein, who had become\n\"ubiquitous in Ohio.\"\n103.\n\nFollowing Dimon's interview for the role of CEO at Bank One, Kessler was in\n\nfavor of hiring Dimon, stating, \"He's just a fabulous leader. He's the best banker in the country,\nthere's no question.\"36 Crown, one of the new Bank One directors with ties back to Robert\nMaxwell through his family link to General Dynamics, stated that the CEO Search Committee\nnarrowed the search to two candidates, and that: \"Jamie met with the board and made a very\nconvincing presentation about where he would focus his energy in the beginning. It was clear he\nhad seen this movie before. He had the experience of cutting costs and bringing organizations\ntogether, something we clearly needed.\"37\n\n36 CEO Jack Kessler: Local Visionary: It's How You Treat People, COLUMBUS DISPATCH (Aug.\n\n24, 2014, 12:01 AM), https://www.dispatch.com/story/business/2014/08/24/ceo-jack-kesslerlocal-visionary/23336557007/.\n37 Whitney\n\nCrowning the\n\nWall Street. UNLIMITED HANGOUT (April 27. 2023),\n\nPaul W. Marshall & Todd H. Thedinga, Jamie Dimon and Bank One (A), Harvard Business School\nCase 804-107, (Dec. 2003, rev. July 2012).\n\n30\n\nEFTA02822866\n\n", "char_count": 1938}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\n104.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 31of 69\n\nCrown would go on to serve as head of JPM's risk committee during the Epstein\n\nsaga. Despite a massive failure in his role, Crown continued to serve on the Board, with his\ndirectorship spanning nearly two decades.\n105.\n\nWexner was no longer on the board of Bank One when Dimon arrived, and it is\n\nunclear if Dimon ever personally knew of or interacted with Epstein during that time. However,\nit is clear that Wexner, Kessler, Crown, and the McCoys were very much connected to Epstein's\ndealings in Ohio (including, of course, the New Albany project). Considering Epstein's consistent\ninvolvement with the Columbus business elite, it is fair to infer that Dimon, as the CEO of Bank\nOne, with a board populated with Columbus's business elite, was aware of Epstein and likely\ncrossed paths with him, at the least. Indeed, in a 2014 interview, Kessler referred to Dimon's\naffinity for Columbus, Ohio, stating, \"Jamie loves it here because he said the work ethic is so good.\nHe said he'd move everybody here if he could.\"38\n106.\n\nIn January 2004, Bank One announced its acquisition by JPM for $58 billion. The\n\ninitial announcement did not envisage Dimon assuming the top position. According to the initial\ndeal press release: [T]he newly merged entity was to be led by William B. M,\nexisting chairman and chief executive of J.P.\n\n60, the\n\nChase. James Dimon, 47, then the chairman\n\nand chief executive ofBank One, was slated to become president and chief operating officer of the\ncombined company.39 Fortunately for Dimon, his colleagues from Bank One had no plans to\noperate under\n\nleadership for long.\n\n38 CEO Jack Kessler: Local Visionary: It's How You Treat People, COLUMBUS DISPATCH (Aug.\n\n24, 2014, 12:01 AM), https://www.dispatch.com/story/business/2014/08/24/ceo-jack-kesslerlocal-visionary/23336557007/.\n39 Andrew R. Sorkin & Landon\n\nJr., J.P.\nChase to Acquire Bank One in $58 Billion\nDeal,\nN.Y.\nTIMES\n(Jan.\n14,\n2004),\nhtt\n... [truncated, 2174 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/30 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=30]", "char_count": 2174}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\n107.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 32 of 69\n\nOnly six months after closing the merger, Dimon was invited by the Board to take\n\nover as CEO of the combined company, and a short time thereafter he took on the role of Chairman.\nThe directors who moved from the Bank One board to the JPM Board — Kessler, Crown, Stephen\n, Robert Lipp, Richard Manoogian, and David Novak — helped Dimon rise to the Company's\nCEO role.\n108.\n\nDimon's tenure as CEO of JPM has been rife with management failures. A 2020\n\narticle raised a troubling question: \"Why hasn't JPMorgan Chase's Board sacked Jamie Dimon as\nthe bank accumulated five felony counts?\" The piece recognizes that Dimon has not forgotten\nwho afforded him the opportunity to become CEO, and the connection with Bank One continues\nto exert a significant influence on JPM's current board. The author responds to this question with:\n\"Turns out Jamie Dimon has been taking very good care of the Directors on his Board and they\nhave been taking very good care of Dimon — turning him into a billionaire, notwithstanding the\nworst criminal record of any major bank in the history of the United States.nm\nIV.\n\nJPM PURSUES EPSTEIN\nA. Onboarding Epstein As A Client\n109.\n\nEpstein's association with JPM began in 1998. In 2000, the Company entrusted\n\nthe task of managing Epstein as a client to Staley, the then-new head of JPM's private banking\ndivision. Staley has explained that, when he was told to work with Epstein, he was specifically\nadvised to \"get to know him.\" The head of a global bank's private banking division presumably\nis not tasked with \"getting to know\" all of the bank's private bank clients.\n\n4° Pam Martens & Russ Martens, If You're Baffled As To Why JPMorgan Chase's Board Hasn't\nSacked Jamie Dimon as the Bank Racked Up 5 Felony Counts — Here's Your Answer. WALL ST.\nON\nPARADE:\nA\nCITIZEN\nGUIDE\nTO\nWALL\nST.\n(Oct.\n12,\n2020),\nhttps://wallstreetonparade.com/2020/ Wif-youre-baffled-as-to-why-jpmorgan-chases-boardhasnt-\n... [truncated, 2095 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/31 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=31]", "char_count": 2095}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\n110.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 33 of 69\n\nWhat began as Staley's professional endeavor to build a relationship with Epstein\n\ntransitioned into a personal one, as discussed below in more detail. By 2003, it would become\nvery quickly apparent to Staley that doing business with Epstein would include a level of\nreputational and legal risk unlike anything JPM had ever or should ever accept.\n111.\n\nAs previously noted, JPM, like any major financial institution, has a duty to perform\n\na high degree of due diligence on the individuals it does business with. Indeed, that duty should\nhold even greater importance when a new client like Epstein, who claims to managing billions of\ndollars for world elite, has little to no digital or public footprint. Moreover, Epstein's onboarding\nshould have revealed his involvement with a slew of shady characters and financial dealings.\n112.\n\nFor instance, if JPM even conducted this most rudimentary due diligence prior to\n\nonboarding Epstein as a client they would have learned that he departed Beams Stems under a\nshadow of financial inpropriety and was connected to Hoffenberg and the Towers Ponzi scheme.\nThose two connections alone should have warranted escalating Epstein to senior management or\nthe JPM risk committee.\nB. 2003 Vanity Fair Article Raises Major Concerns About Epstein\nIn March 2003, Vicky\n\n113.\n\nof Vanity Fair published an article entitled \"The\n\nTalented Mr. Epstein.'TM' The piece initially spotlights Epstein's roster of high-profile admirers\nand clients, including Wexner, Bill Clinton, Prince Andrew, and Alan Dershowitz. However, the\narticle simultaneously carries a more sinister undertone, which should have raised alarm bells for\nanyone conducting business with Epstein. The following are several points from the article that\nshould have set off significant concerns across JPM about its client:\n\nM,\n\n41\nVicky\nThe Talented Mr. Epstein, VANITY\nhttps://www.vanityfair.cominews/2003/03/jeffrey-epstein-200\n... [truncated, 2049 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/32 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=32]", "char_count": 2049}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 34 of 69\n\n•\n\n\"He's reckless,\" says a former business associate, \"and he's gotten more so. Money\ndoes that to you. He's breaking the oath he made to himself — that he would never\ndo anything that would expose him in the media.\"\n\n•\n\nAccording to S.E.C. and other legal documents unearthed by VANITY FAIR,\nEpstein may have good reason to keep his past cloaked in secrecy: his real mentor,\nit might seem, was not Leslie Wexner but Steven Jude Hoffenberg, 57, who, for a\nfew months before the S.E.C. sued to freeze his assets in 1993, was trying to buy\nthe New York Post. He is currently incarcerated in the Federal Medical Center in\nDevens, Massachusetts, serving a 20-year sentence for bilking investors out of more\nthan $450 million in one of the largest Ponzi schemes in American history.\n\n•\n\nIn 1987, Hoffenberg, according to sources, set Epstein up in the offices he still\noccupies in the Villard House, on Madison Avenue, across a courtyard from the\nrestaurant Le Cirque. Hoffenberg hired his new protégé as a consultant at $25,000\na month, and the relationship flourished. \"They traveled everywhere together— on\nHoffenberg's plane, all around the world, they were always together,\" says a\nsource. Hoffenberg has claimed that Epstein confided in him, saying, for example,\nthat he had left Bear Steams in 1981 after he was discovered executing \"illegal\noperations.\"\n\n•\n\nHoffenberg claimed in a 1993 hearing before a grand jury in Illinois that Epstein\nwas the \"technician\" at Towers, executing illicit schemes, although, having no\nbroker's license, he had to rely on others to make the trades.\n\n•\n\nEpstein, according to Hoffenberg, also came up with a scheme to manipulate the\nin an attempt to minimize the losses that occurred\nprice of Emery Freight\nwhen Hoffenberg's bid went wrong, and the share price began to fall. This was\nalleged to have involved multiple clients' accounts controlled by Epstein.\n\n•\n\nSeveral of Epstein's Bear Steams \n... [truncated, 2849 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/33 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=33]", "char_count": 2849}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 35 of 69\n\nC. Epstein Brokers JPM's Purchase of Highbridge Capital And Helps Put JPM\nExecutives on the Board of the Robin Hood Foundation\n114.\n\nEven if the 2003 Vanity Fair article never came to Defendants' attention and, as a\n\nresult, they were unaware of Epstein's true character at the time, there is a deal from the early\n2000s leaving any such claim of unfamiliarity with Epstein implausible.\n115.\n\nThe Epstein private jet flight logs, spanning from 1990 to 2005, have received\n\nconsiderable media coverage due to the inclusion of names of former presidents and other\nprominent figures. However, less publicly recognized names, such as that of Eva\n('a\"),\n\nhave managed to elude intensive scrutiny. Currently a practicing physician,\nis the former Miss Sweden, a Miss Universe Contestant, and, from at least the 1980s to\n\nthe early 1990s, was Epstein's girlfriend.\n116.\n\nIn 1994,\n\nmarried Glenn\n\nthe co-founder of both\n\nHighbridge Capital (\"Highbridge\"), an alternative asset management firm, and the non-profit The\nRobinhood Foundation. Epstein reportedly invested millions of dollars into Highbridge in 1998,\nand it is possible that Epstein himself introduced\n117.\n\nand\n\nOne of Epstein's most prominent accusers,\n\n, alleged in her lawsuit\n\nagainst Ghislaine Maxwell that in 2001, Ghislaine Maxwell had directed her to have sex with\neven though he had been married since 1994 and\n118.\n\nwas only 16.\n\nJust a few years following this incident, in 2004, Epstein allegedly facilitated a\n\nmeeting between Staley and\n\nto broker the sale ofHighbridge to JPM for a majority interest\n\nvalued at over $1 billion.42 As reported by The Telegraph, \"Epstein personally introduced the two\nmen while Staley was head of the private bank at JP M.\n\nJP\n\nlater purchased\n\n42\n\nA. Giannone, JPMorgan Buys Rest of Highbridge, REUTERS (June 11, 2009, 9:43 AM),\nhttps://www.reuters.com/article/us-jpmorganchase-highbridge-idUSTRE55A3PX20090611.\n\n35\n\nEFTA02822871\n\n", "char_count": 1999}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 36 of 69\n\nHighbridge Capital in a $1bn deal that enhanced Staley's status at the bank — and netted Epstein a\nfee of $10m.\"43\n119.\n\nJPM now suggests that Staley somehow concealed Epstein's name and relationship\n\nwith the bank from his superiors, Dimon and the Board itself. However, it is unlikely that a\nfinancial institution like JPM would approve a transaction exceeding a billion dollars without\ninstituting some sort of top-level due diligence review.\n120.\n\nHighbridge was not the only conduit through which Epstein leveraged\n\nto\n\nextend his influence over key members at JPM. Two prominent figures in the Epstein saga, Staley\nand Erdoes, both served on the board of\nFoundation. Founded by\n\nNew York City children's charity, The Robinhood\n\nin the early 1980s, the charity also currently has Kristen Lemkau,\n\nthe CEO of U.S. Wealth Management for JPM, serving as the co-chair of the organization's\nleadership council. Following Epstein's arrest in 2019, The Robinhood Foundation faced intense\npublic scrutiny for its connections to Epstein, and for allowing Staley to remain on its board.\n121.\n\nTo truly comprehend the extent of involvement by\n\nand\n\nwithin\n\nEpstein's network of enablers, it is instructive to examine their actions following Epstein's 2008\nconviction as a pedophile. As Business Insider revealed:\nThe Dubins invited Epstein to their Palm Beach home for\nThanksgiving dinner in 2009. In an email to Epstein's probation\nofficer, Eva\nwrote, \"I am 100% comfortable with Jeffrey\nEpstein around my children,\" while acknowledging Epstein was\nconvicted of procuring a minor for prostitution. At the time, the\ncouple's three kids were underage.'\n43 Helen Cahill, Jeffrey Epstein Scandal Casts A Shadow Over Glittering New York Charity,\nTELEGRAPH (Jan. 2, 2022 3:00 PM), https://www.telegraph.co.uldbusiness/2022/01/02/jeffreyepstein-scandal-casts-shadow-glittering-new-york-charity/.\n\" Kate Briquelet & Michael Daly, NYC Power Coupl\n... [truncated, 2241 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/35 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=35]", "char_count": 2241}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\n122.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nMerely months prior to the Thanksgiving dinner at the\n\nPage 37 of 69\n\nresidence, Epstein\n\nhad assisted Staley and JPM in finalizing the purchase of the remaining stake in Highbridge, which\nat the time had assets under management of approximately $21 billion.45 Considering the size of\nthe initial investment and eventual purchase, the Highbridge deal would have a certainly been a\nmaterial transaction that warranted due diligence from the highest levels of JPM.\nD. Epstein Brokered a Meeting Between JPNI and the Prime Minister of Israel\n123.\n\nBetween 2009 and 2011, Epstein helped Staley schedule meetings for Dimon to\n\nmeet with Israeli Prime Minister\n\nNetanyahu, Microsoft founder Bill Gates, and Britain's\n\nPrince Andrew. Despite Epstein and Staley's collaboration in setting up these meetings with such\nhigh-profile individuals, Dimon purportedly testified that he never heard of Epstein until 2018 or\n2019.46 Dimon's unequivocal assertion rings untrue.\n124.\n\nIt is almost unfathomable that the CEO and Chairman of JPM would not be aware\n\nof how an in-person meetings with some of the world's most prominent leaders was arranged,\nincluding who set it up.\n\n45\n\nA. Giannone, JPMorgan Buys Rest ofHighbridge, REUTERS (June 11, 2009, 9:43 AM),\nhttps://www.reuters.com/article/us-jpmorganchase-highbridge-idUSTRE55A3PX20090611.\n46 Kate Briquelet, Epstein Connected JPMorgan Exec to Netanyahu, Prince Andrew, DAILY BEAST\n(June\n20,\n2023,\n3:30\nPM),\nhttps://archive.is/20230620224740/https://wvvw.thedailybeast.com/jeffrey-epstein-epsteinhooked-up-jpmorgan-exec-jes-staley-with-benjamin-netanyahu-prince-andrew-emailsshow#selection-1243.0-1243.59.\n\n37\n\nEFTA02822873\n\n", "char_count": 1723}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nV.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 38 of 69\n\nEPSTEIN REMAINS A JPM CLIENT WHILE THE TRUTH ABOUT HIM COMES\nINTO THE PUBLIC EYE\nA. The Highest Reaches of JPM Unambiguously Knew that Epstein Was a\nConvicted Sex Offender Accused of Continuing Sexual Abuse\n125.\n\nIn March 2005, press reports emerged reporting that Epstein paid a 14-year-old girl\n\nin Palm Beach, Florida for a \"massage\" and then molested her. Following the release of these\nallegations, a number of underage girls — many of them high school students — told police that\nEpstein also hired them to give sexual massages.\n126.\n\nIn July 2006, Epstein was arrested in Palm Beach, Florida, after a grand jury\n\nindicted him for soliciting a minor for prostitution. JPM — including Staley and Erdoes — were\nimmediately aware of Epstein's arrest and his pedophilia. For instance, on August 27, 2006, Staley\nemailed Erdoes: \"Last night went to the Huggy Bear concert. The age difference between\nhusbands and wives would have fit in well with Jeffrey. What a joke.'\n127.\n\nEpstein's arrest received national news coverage, leaving no doubt about the\n\nheinous nature of his crimes. For instance, on September 3, 2006, The New York Times reported:\nIn the summer and autumn of last year, when most of the mansions\nhere stood empty behind their towering hedges, the police stealthily\nwatched one at the end of a waterside lane. They monitored the\ncomings and goings of its owner's private jet, subpoenaed his phone\nrecords and riffled through his trash.\nThe owner was Jeffrey Epstein, 53, an intensely private New York\nmoney manager with several billionaire clients. Months earlier, the\nstepmother of a 14-year-old girl told the Palm Beach police that a\nwealthy older man, whom the girl later identified as Mr. Epstein,\nmight have had inappropriate sexual contact with her.\nIn sworn statements to the police, the 14-year-old and other teenage\ngirls said a friend had arranged for them to visit Mr. Epstein's home\n\n47 Deposition \n... [truncated, 2174 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/37 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=37]", "char_count": 2174}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 39 of 69\n\nand give him massages, usually in their underwear, in exchange for\ncash.\nMost of the girls, according to the police, said Mr. Epstein had\nmasturbated during the massages, and a few said he had penetrated\nthem with his fingers or penis. They identified him in photos and\naccurately described the inside of his home. Some recalled that his\nemployees had fed them snacks or rented them cars.\nMr. Epstein pleaded not guilty in August to the crime he was\nultimately charged with, soliciting prostitution. But at a time when\nprosecutors around the nation have become increasingly severe in\ndealing with people accused of sex offenses, the case has raised\nquestions about whether Mr. Epstein's prominence won him\npreferential treatment.\nBy the account of the police, they found probable cause to charge\nMr. Epstein with much more serious offenses: one count of lewd\nand lascivious molestation and four counts of unlawful sexual\nactivity with a minor.08\n128.\n\nThe fact of Epstein's ongoing relationship with JPM was hardly a secret within the\n\nbank. Indeed, JPM employees — including Erdoes — circulated this New York Times article\ninternally. The first line in the email read: \"Did you see this article in the NYT this weekend?\nLovely guy to work with.\"49\n129.\n\nOn October 17, 2006, the Company's Global Corporate Security Division\n\ndesignated Epstein a \"high-risk client\" because \"[s]everal newspaper articles were found that detail\nthe indictment of Jeffrey Epstein in Florida on felony charges of soliciting underage prostitutes.\"59\nAs a result, JPM determined not to \"proactively solicit new investment business from Mr.\nEpstein.\"51\n\n48\n\nAbby Goodnough, Questions ofPreferential Treatment Are Raised in Florida Sex Case, N.Y.\nTIMES (Sept. 3, 2006), https://www.nytimes.com/2006/09/03/us/03epstein.html.\n\n49 Dimon Tr. at 98.\n5° Dimon Tr. at 127-28.\nSi Dimon Tr. at 18-19.\n\n39\n\nEFTA02822875\n\n", "char_count": 1955}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\n130.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 40 of 69\n\nHaving so designated Epstein, internal review and approval processes were\n\nnecessarily triggered. Nevertheless, the Company continued to retain Epstein as a client.\n131.\n\nKnowledge of Epstein's crimes (and his associated massive cash withdrawals to\n\nfund his sexual abuse) extended to the top of JPM's organization. At her recent deposition, Erdoes\nadmitted that the Company was aware by 2006 not only that Epstein was abusing women and\nunderage girls, but that Epstein paid these victims in cash. 52 This was the same year that a JPM\nRapid Response Team noted that Epstein routinely withdrew $40,000 to $80,000 in cash from his\naccounts several times each month, and more than $750,000 per year.\"\n132.\n\nErdoes knew Epstein personally. Indeed, Erdoes visited Epstein at his New York\n\nhome in both 2011 and 201354 Erdoes is also reported to have exchanged \"dozens of emails\" with\nEpstein, including with regard to a charitable fund that JPM considered launching together with\nEpstein.\"\n133.\n\nIn June 2008, Epstein pled guilty to soliciting a minor for prostitution. As part of\n\nthe plea agreement, Epstein was sentenced to an I8-month jail term, followed by one year of\ncommunity confinement, and was required to register as a sex offender. As with his 2006 arrest,\nEpstein's plea deal received national media attention (and concomitant attention within JPM).56\n\n52 IISVICompl.¶ 92.\n53 USVICompl.¶ 92.\n54 IChadeeja Safdar & David Benoit, JPMorgan's Ties to Jeffrey Epstein Were Deeper That the\n\nBank Has\nAcknowledged,\nWALL ST. J.\n(Apr.\nhttps://www.wsj.com/articlesipmorgan-jeffrey-ep.525febe3?mod—Searchresults_pos9&page=1.\n\n21,\n\n2023,\n\n3:55\n\nPM),\n\n55 Id.\n56 See, e.g., Samuel Goldsmith, Jeffrey Epstein Pleads Guilty to Prostitution Charges, N.Y. POST\n(June 30, 2008, 5:04 PM), https://nypost.com/2008/06/30/jeffrey-epstein-pleads-guilty-toprostitution-chargest\n\n40\n\nEFTA02822876\n\n", "char_count": 1955}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\n134.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 41of 69\n\nAccording to JPM, \"[p]er bank policy, felons are considered high risk and require\n\nadditional approval.\"57\n135.\n\nEpstein's guilty plea led some JPM employees to assume that the Company would\n\nimmediately terminate its relationship with the now-convicted sex offender. As of July 15, 2008,\na JPM Rapid Response Team document indicated that \"Catherine [Keating, the CEO of the\nCompany's Private Bank] will go back to Jes [Staley, then the CEO of JPM's Asset Management\nDivision] to tell him we are uncomfortable with Epstein and do not want to go to [Stephen] Cutler\n[JPM's General Counsel] for approval.\"58 In other words, the most senior members of the Private\nBank knew that trying to retain Epstein as a client was an absurd ask to the General Counsel, given\nall of the red flags surrounding Epstein.\n136.\n\nThe next month, in August 2008, a JPM employee wrote that she \"would count\n\nEpstein's assets as a probable outflow for '08 ($120mm or so?) as I can't imagine it will stay\n(pending Mamie) Dimon review).\"59 The fact that Epstein's account status was expected to be\npresented to Dimon suggests either that it was (as per known internal protocols) or that the matter\nwas resolved in favor of keeping Epstein without forcing Dimon to leave a paper trail of his\ninvolvement in the matter.\n137.\n\nThus, a plausible conclusion arising from that August 2008 email is that Dimon -\n\nthe Company's CEO and Chairman - was aware of Epstein's crimes by that time and would decide\nwhether the Company would retain Epstein as a client. Yet, the bank chose to keep doing business\nwith Epstein.\n\n\"\n\nUSVJ Compl. 1 50.\n\n58 Dimon Tr. at 138.\n\n\" USW Comp1.1 51.\n\n41\n\nEFTA02822877\n\n", "char_count": 1739}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\n138.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 42 of 69\n\nIn 2009, a once-secret 2008 non-prosecution agreement between Epstein and the\n\nUnited States became public. It revealed allegations that Epstein may have used interstate\ncommerce to induce minors to engage in prostitution, engaged in illicit sexual conduct with\nminors, and trafficked minors.\n139.\n\nEpstein's guilty plea in 2008, jail sentence, and additional allegations of sex crimes\n\ndid not put an end to his relationship with Staley, who allegedly participated in Epstein's crimes.60\nBetween 2008 and 2013, Staley used his Company email account to exchange 1,200 emails with\nEpstein:\" And, both before and after Epstein's arrest and prison sentence, Staley frequently called\nEpstein's Palm Beach, Florida home, according to the below messages included in the complaint\nin the Jane Doe Action (including at least one call when Staley called with Wexner):62\n\n60 Doe 1 v. Deutsche Bank Aktiengesellschaft, 2023 WL 3167633, at •4 n.3 (S.D.N.Y. May 1,\n2023).\n61 USV/Comp1.1 53.\n62 Jane Doe Compl. ¶¶ 148-49.\n\n42\n\nEFTA02822878\n\n", "char_count": 1101}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "Document 17\n\nCase 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nPage 43 of 69\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nMESSAGE]\n\nI IMPORTANT\n\n2r...\n\nK. ,C4\n\nd\n\net*\n\nTr i Cmy\n\ni.....7en\ncgs\n\n.............-- --r..,.....\nEg 1-2,P 2S0186)\n\nMlefr\n\nMIMS\n\nSOWS\n\nQ\n\n.....\nMESSAGE]\n\nIMPORTANT\n\nSaeII\ngo _\n\nMc EPSTEIN\n\nv.,\n\neeeS\n\nOnin\n\n4\n..,,\n,.., 4 . mg ,mr\nof/a./O\n.; TIPS STALLS\nc... it\nINS_Rigt_l_Lot AI 0 it\n\n,g•\n\n-nce _..s., 4-4-\n\n0. tri2)\noar\n....\nSa\n\n74 4 - o 770\n\n..........\n\nop lea So\nSs\nes\n\nSae SS\nsissant\n\nI\n\nmums\n\nsues...SW\n\nCS\n\nas\n\nSSW\n\ngam\n\nMania\n\nMI\n'W\n\nSS\n\ngin\nOs\n\nSlaieggiug\n,smso\n\ninane\n\nCALF\n\nSAMSAMIS\nAS\nISSIMPOOP\nMe,\n\n.\n\n-\n\nSAMIII4\n\nam\n\n-r\n\nIMPORTANT MESSAGE I\n\nIf( eatF.H*4\n\nAS\nPM\n\n.51F7 S/Arly\n=\n\n74* 07,0\n\n- Pagesia\n\nr\nVal\n\nalma\n\nail\n\nSL\n\nI IMPORTANT MESSAGE I\n- 1\nT .\nmg ILI gginer nee \" 7\no or\n',an SU,\n±.O_)9\nce\n\nCALL\n\n1Z -114r\nIMMOILL\n\nVIM Cat AWIll\n\nYOU\n\nMVOS\nVgNI0N Me\n\nWPM C. MIMS\ngmalaa\n\n--.\n\n..In\n\ngmm\n\nDori\n\nGann.\n\nI\n\nMESSAGE\n\nI IMPORTANT\n\n\".\n\nMammogram\n\nan -la\n\n(RI LE a\n\nAM\n\n%MOUS\n\nMJ\n\nRIM\n\nas\n\nSIM\n\nalIMMOt\n\nOS\nA\nTqfpnO\n\nbra\n\nCA\n\nMma\n\n.\n\nU\n\n43\n\nEFTA02822879\n\n", "char_count": 1036}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 44 of 69\n\nANLMESSAGE\n\nFr -27CW a\nC-11\n\n4SE\ninellte\n\nr\n\nCan Ma ICU\n00111•10 OM MI\n\nail\nOill•Mill\nMON\n\nPineal.1001.1•A\n\nS\n\nCSI-\n\nvan\n\n140.\n\nIn December 2008, Epstein and Staley discussed Staley visiting Epstein at his\n\nFlorida home. Although Epstein was not going to be in Palm Beach at the time, Epstein invited\nStaley to use his house.\" In early January 2009, around the time that Staley was staying at\nEpstein's Palm Beach house, Epstein wired $2,000 from his JPM account to a woman with an\nEastern European surname (many of the women that Epstein trafficked were from Eastern\nEurope).\"\n141.\n\nLater in 2009, Epstein and Staley again discussed getting together, this time in\n\nLondon. In late August 2009, Epstein asked Staley whether he would need anything while he was\nin London. Staley said yes.\" Just two days later, Epstein again used his JPM account to wire\n$3,000 to the same woman with an Eastern European surname he had paid while Staley was in\nPalm Beach.\"\n142.\n\nJust months later, in November 2009, while Epstein was already in jail, Staley again\n\ntook advantage of Epstein's hospitality — this time at Epstein's now-infamous private island, Little\n\n63 USVI Compl. ir 54.\n64 USV/ Compl. ¶ 54.\n65 USV/ Compl. i 55.\n\n\" USW Comp1.1 55.\n\n44\n\nEFTA02822880\n\n", "char_count": 1320}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 45 of 69\n\nSt. James, Virgin Islands. While there, Staley emailed Epstein: \"So when all hell breaks lo[o]se,\nand the world is crumbling, I will come here, and be at peace. Presently, I'm in the hot tub with a\nof\n\nwine. This is an amazing place. Truly amazing. Next time, we're here together. I\n\nowe you much. And I deeply appreciate our friendship. I have few so profound.\"67\n143.\n\nThe following month, Staley made clear that he was fully aware of the risk that his\n\nongoing relationship with Epstein posed to him. On December 4, 2009, Staley met with Epstein\nin New York, and then emailed him: \"I realize the danger in sending this email. But it was great\nto be able, today, to give you, in New York City, a long heartfelt, hug.\"68\n144.\n\nDespite recognizing it, Staley continued to disregard the \"danger\" of Epstein. The\n\nnext day and later in December 2009, Epstein sent pictures of young women to Staley, to which\nStaley responded with cryptic commentary.69 Staley again visited Little St. James the following\nmonth, in January 2010.7° Later that year, in July 2010, Staley had the following exchange with\nEpstein via email, strongly suggesting that Epstein was procuring victims for Staley:7'\nStale\n\nMaybe they're tracking u? That was fun. Say hi to Snow\n\nEpstein: [W]hat character would you like next?\nStaley: Beauty and the Beast.\nEpstein: [W]ell one side is available.\n145.\n\nAlso in July 2010, a news article from The Daily Beast reported that, since his\n\nrelease from jail, Epstein had settled more than a dozen lawsuits brought by underage girls, and at\n\n67 USV/Compl. 1 56.\n68 USVI Compl. I 57.\n\n69 USW C,ompl. y¶ 58-59.\n7° USW Compl. 1 60.\n71 USV/ Comp1.1 61.\n\n45\n\nEFTA02822881\n\n", "char_count": 1747}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 46 of 69\n\nleast seven victims received well over SI million. 72 That same article noted allegations that\nEpstein was involved with Eastern European women in particular and that a modeling agency he\nhelped fund brought \"young girls . .. often from Eastern Europe\" to the United States on Epstein's\nprivate jets.73\n146.\n\nJPM was aware of these allegations. Memos from JPM compliance meetings\n\nspecifically referenced articles regarding a federal investigation into \"whether a modeling agency\nrun by a friend ... fed his appetite for underage foreign girls\" and noted that \"Epstein was known\nto fly young women from Eastern Europe to Palm Beach where they'd massage him, among other\nservices.\"74\n147.\n\nIn an internal email, an employee in the Company's risk management division\n\nreferred to \"new allegations of an investigation related to child trafficking,\" and asked whether\nJPM was \"still comfortable with this client who is now a registered sex offender.s75 Other JPM\ncompliance employees decided that Epstein \"should go.\"76\n\nBut reflecting the Company's\n\nfundamental attitude towards Epstein's crimes, a different JPM risk management employee\ndismissed these disturbing reports as routine: \"In my short tenure working on the account these\nstories pop up including these from the summer.\"77\n\n72\n\nJeffrey Epstein Pedophile Billionaire and His Sex Den, DAILY BEAST (July\n22, 2010 7:46 PM), https://www.thedailybeast.comijeffrey-epstein-pedophile-billionaire-and-hissex-den.\n73 Id.\n\n74 USVI Comp1.1 101.\n75 USVICompl. 1 45.\n76 USVI Compl. 1 98.\n77 USVIComp1.1 45.\n\n46\n\nEFTA02822882\n\n", "char_count": 1639}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 47 of 69\n\n148.\n\nIn December 2010, JPM granted Epstein a new $50 million line of credit.78\n\n149.\n\nThe next year, in January 2011, JPM once again was made keenly aware of yet\n\nmore allegations of human trafficking against Epstein. And yet again, JPM brushed off the\nallegations. That month, the Company conducted a review of Epstein's accounts because a \"few\nnews stories during 2010 connect[ed] Jeffrey Epstein to human trafficking.\"79 According to the\ncomplaint in the USV/ Action, JPM's coverage team \"met to discuss the situation and agreed to\nenhance monitoring and document a discussion with the client.\"B0\n150.\n\nStaley — Epstein's apparent co-conspirator and accomplice —was the JPM executive\n\nthat the Company entrusted to hold this \"discussion\" with Epstein.81\n\nAccording to the\n\ndocumentation of the discussion, Epstein claimed \"there was no truth to the allegations\" against\nhim and \"no evidence.\"82 JPM internally concluded that it would \"continue to monitor the\naccounts and cash usage closely going forward.\"S3 The Company did not file a SAR.\n151.\n\nIn March 2011, JPM's Global Corporate Security Division again internally reported\n\nthat \"[n]umerous articles detail various law enforcement agencies investigating Jeffrey Epstein for\nallegedly participating, directly or indirectly, in child trafficking and molesting underage girls.s80\nThis report also noted that Epstein had \"settled a dozen civil lawsuits out of court from his victims\nregarding solicitation?\"8S\n\n78 USV/ Compl. 1 46.\n79 USVI Compl. 1 47.\n80 USV/ Compl. 1 47.\n\n8I USV/ Compl. 1 47.\n82 USV/ Compl. 1 47.\n83 USV/ Compl. 1 47.\n\n\" USV/ Compl. 1 48.\n85 USV/ Compl. 1 48.\n\n47\n\nEFTA02822883\n\n", "char_count": 1723}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\n152.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 48 of 69\n\nThis same March 2011 report also noted that the owner of a company named \"MC2\n\nModel Management and Jeffrey Epstein engaged in racketeering that involved luring in minor\nchildren for sexual play for money[,]\" and that MC2 Model Management's owner was a \"frequent\npassenger on Epstein's private jet and often visited Epstein in jail.\"\" The March 2011 report also\nnoted that Epstein paid MC2 Model Management SI million in 2005, and that it was \"unknown if\nthe money was given as a secret investment or payment for services as a procurer.\"S7\n153.\n\nMC2 Model Management's owner was Jean-Luc Brunel (\"Brunel\"), a\n\nmodel scout who faced allegations of sexual assault spanning three decades. Brunel allegedly\ngroomed young females and partook in Epstein's sex trafficking ring. On December 16, 2020,\nprosecutors charged Brunel with rape of minors, but he died from an apparent suicide\nbefore his trial could proceed?\n154.\n\nAlso in 2011, a senior JPM compliance official who reviewed the Company's\n\nrelationship with Epstein warned that there was \"Mots of smoke\" and \"Mots of questions\"\nsurrounding Epstein's criminal behavior.89 According to the complaint filed in the USW Action,\nthese issues included that:\"\n•\n\nEpstein \"is alleged to be involvedin the human trafficking ofyoung girls and law\nenforcement is also allegedly investigating his involvement in this activity.\"\n\n•\n\n\"He is also an alleged personal associate of the CEO of the Investment Bank (Jes\nStaley).\"\n\n\" USW Compl. 1 48.\n87 USW Compl. 1 48.\njail cell, NPR (Feb. 19,\n88 Jeffrey Epstein associate Jean-Luc Brunel is found dead in a\n2022, 12:20 PM), https://www.npr.org/2022/02/19/1081961087/Jeffrey-epstein-jean-luc-bruneldead.\n\" USV/ Compl. 1 98.\n9° USW Compl. 1 98 (emphases added) (alterations in original).\n\n48\n\nEFTA02822884\n\n", "char_count": 1863}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 49 of 69\n\n•\n\n\"AML Operations went to a [Private Bank] risk meeting late last week requesting\nthat we exit this relationship.\"\n\n•\n\n\"[W]hether Epstein is further exposed could have a potential serious impact.\"\n\n•\n\n\"The one new concerning thing is the one article about the DOJ investigation is\nsaying they brought under age girls to the US via a modeling agency M2 that is\nowned by a guy named Brand. Turns out the banker said today we extended\nEpstein a loan in relation to this modeling agency.\" The writer claims that the\nagency is \"legit\" and that \"it would be hard for us to tell\" if \"girls were exploited\nvia their contract or arrangement.\" The loan was a letter of credit provided by JPM\nto MC2 Model Management.\n\n•\n\nIn 2004, Epstein sponsored private bank accounts and credit curds for two 18\nyear olds \"that appear to be part of his inner entourage. One is mentioned in many\nof the recaps of the escapades as a willing participant and assistant when hosting\nvisitors. She has received about 450,000 since opening from Epstein .... Both\ncan be put in Palm Beach during 2004, by way of debit charges, which was when\nmost allegations were from . . . . He did pay other girls, many models no huge\namounts. Sugar Daddy!\"\n\n•\n\n\"His foundation account did pay donations to the Palm Beach Police Dept as\nreported just before the case started. The samefoundation account didpay monies\ndirect to models andpayments direct to specialty schools (massage, culinary) and\nuniversity's [sic] on behalf of models/aspiring actresses. Nothing was\nastronomical.\"\n\n•\n\n\"His business accounts Fiduciary we saw no client activity. I know his biggest\nclient, Wexner parted ways when he was convicted. His [Due Diligence Reports]\nsay he manages a few private clients [sic] money but never says who. I would like\nto know if in fact he is managing anyone's money at this point or is it all his\nmoney. We saw no evidence of disbursements even in the rocky years 08-\n... [truncated, 2415 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/48 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=48]", "char_count": 2415}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 50 of 69\n\nThe next day, July 21, 2011, Cutler emailed Erdoes again, writing about Epstein: \"I wouldlike to\nput it and hint behind us. Not a person we should do business with, period.\"92\n156.\n\nYet, JPM continued doing business with Epstein, as well as his partners in crime.\n\nIn August 2011, Ghislaine Maxwell applied to open a new account with JPM for a \"personal\nrecruitment consulting business.\"93 Internally, the Company's AML director asked: \"What does\nshe mean by personal recruitment?? Areyou sure this will have nothing to do with Jeffrey? If\nyou want to proceed, I suggest that weflag this as a High Risk Client.”54\n157.\n\nIn fact, the Company retained Epstein as a client well into 2013. John Duffy — who\n\nserved as Vice Chairman of JPM and as the CEO of the Company's private bank for ultrawealthy\nclients — visited Epstein at his New York home in April 2013.\" Just one month later, the private\nbank that Duffy ran re-authorized Epstein to borrow up to S50 million against his accounts.\"\n158.\n\nAt bottom, despite unequivocally knowing that Epstein was a serial sex offender,\n\nand despite the obviously suspicious nature of Epstein's activity with the Company, JPM took no\ncorrective action against Epstein for years. Finally, later in 2013, the Company purportedly\n\n92 Dimon Tr. at 184.\n93 USW Compl. 149.\n\" USV/ Compl. ¶49.\nKhadeeja Safdar & David Benoit, JPMorgan's Ties to Jeffrey Epstein Were Deeper That the\nBank Has Acknowledged,\nWALL ST. J.\n(Apr.\n21,\nPM),\n2023\n3:35\nhttps://www.wsj.com/articles/jpmorgan-jeffrey-a\n525febe3?mod=Searchresults_pos9&page=1.\n\" USW Compl. ¶70; Khadeeja Safdar & David Benoit, JPMorgan's Ties to Jeffrey Epstein Were\nDeeper That the Bank Has Acknowledged, WALL ST. J. (Apr. 21, 2023 3:35 PM),\nhttps://www.wsj.com/artieles/jpmorgan-jeffrey-ep.525febe3?mod=Searehresultspos98cpage=1.\n\n50\n\nEFTA02822886\n\n", "char_count": 1902}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 51 of 69\n\nterminated its relationship with Epstein. That same year, Staley left the Company.B7 The U.S.\nVirgin Islands has alleged that JPM continued business with Epstein affiliated entities.\nB. .Adequate Compliance Systems Plainly Should Have At Least Resulted in the\nFilings of SARs and Reporting to the Board\n159.\n\nAs alleged above, JPM employees — including those at the highest reaches of the\n\nCompany, such as Staley and Erdoes — knew Epstein was a felon convicted for sexual abuse, a\npedophile who allegedly trafficked young girls from all over the world (including on his private\nplane), and regularly wired and withdrew large sums of cash from his JPM accounts. Those facts\nalone should have triggered the filing of SARs and reporting to the Board. Again, federal banking\nlaws require a SAR filing in connection with:\nTransactions conducted or attempted by, at, or through the bank .\naggregating 15,000 or more, if the bank .. . knows, suspects, or has\nreason to suspect that the transaction\": (a)\"Inday involvepotential\nmoney laundering or other illegal activity\"; (b) \"[i]s designed to\nevade the BSA or its implementing regulations\"; or (c) \"[hies no\nbusiness or apparentlawfulpurpose or is not the type of transaction\nthat the particular customer would normally be expected to engage\nin, and the bank knows of no reasonable explanation for the\ntransaction after examining the available facts, including the\nbackground and possible purpose of the transaction.98\n160.\n\nNevertheless, upon information and belief, JPM never filed a SAR related to\n\nEpstein. And, according to the complaint filed in the USVI Action, it does not appear that JPM\nengaged in any investigation of the source of Epstein's funds.\"\n\n, Ex-JPMorgan executive Staley to be questioned under oath about Epstein ties,\nREUTERS (June 9, 2023, 1:08 PM), https://www.reuters.corn/legal/ex-jpmorgan-executive-staleybe-questioned-under-oath-about-epstein-ties-2023-0609/\n... [truncated, 2336 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/50 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=50]", "char_count": 2336}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\n161.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 52 of 69\n\nMoreover, according to Dimon's deposition testimony, between 2006 — when\n\nEpstein was arrested for soliciting a minor for prostitution — and 2013, the Board never discussed\nEpstein's relationship with JPM.100 Indeed, in connection with the Jane Doe Action, Dimon\nsubmitted a sworn answer to an interrogatory that, between 2000 and 2018, he received no\ninformation from any officer, director, employee, or agent of JPM concerning Epstein.101\n162.\n\nDimon not only continues to profess ignorance, but he also seeks to deflect blame\n\nentirely from JPM. During his deposition, Dimon said, concerning a victim, \"I hope she gets\njustice against the people who perpetrated the crime, which was not ns,\"102 and later quipped, \"we\ncannot do law enforcement's job.\"103 Of course, JPM interfered with law enforcement doing its\njob (and the Company affirmatively violated the law) by notfiling a single SAR related to Epstein.\n163.\n\nAlso at his deposition, Dimon testified that Epstein's cash activity would have been\n\nvisible to JPM in real time.104 Had the Company focused on Epstein's specific transactions - some\nof which are discussed below in more detail — JPM should have filed SARs and provided specific\nupdates to the Board.\n164.\n\nIn total, between 2003 and 2013, at least 20 women trafficked and abused by\n\nEpstein were paid through JPM accounts.105 These women received payments, typically multiple\npayments, in excess of $1 million collectively during this period.106 According to the complaint\n\n100 Dimon Tr. at 53-54.\n1°1 Dimon Tr. at 67-68.\n1°2 Dimon Tr. at 211.\n103 Dimon Tr. at 225-26.\n\"Dimon Tr. at 149.\n1°5 USVICompl. ¶ 42.\n1°6 USV/ Compl. ¶ 42.\n\n52\n\nEFTA02822888\n\n", "char_count": 1745}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 53 of 69\n\nin the USV/ Action, \"among the recipients of these payments were numerous women with Eastern\nEuropean surnames who were publicly and internally identified as Epstein recruiters and/or\nvictims.\"107 For example, Epstein paid more than $600,000 (including more than $165,000 after\nEpstein's 2008 plea) to a woman who — according to news reports contained in JPM's due diligence\nreports — Epstein purchased at the age of 14.106 Like other women who received payments from\nEpstein, that victim listed Epstein's apartment on 66th Street in New York City as her address,\nwhich should have been a glaring red flag to the Company.109\n165.\n\nEpstein also withdrew more than $775,000 in cash between 2003 and 2013 from\n\nJPM accounts, which is especially significant as Epstein was known to pay for \"massages,\" or\nsexual encounters, in cash.' 10 Financial information evaluated in connection with the USV/ Action\nalso reflects payments drawn from JPM accounts of nearly $1.5 million to known recruiters,\nincluding to the MC2 Model Management (a company which, as discussed above, JPM compliance\nhad flagged in 2011), and another $150,000 to a private investigative firm.'\"\n166.\n\nEpstein and/or his associates also made 95 foreign remittances with no known\n\npayee during this same time period — all transactions which JPM should have flagged and\ninvestigated.12 For example, Hyperion Air, Inc. (\"Hyperion\") — the Epstein-controlled company\nthat owned Epstein's private jet used to traffic his victims — issued over $547,000 in checks\n\n1°7 USV/ Compl. ¶ 66.\nl°8 USV/Compl. ¶ 99.\nI\" USV/ Compl. ¶ 66.\n' 10 USV/Compl. 1 42.\n\"' USV/Compl. ¶ 42.\n112 USV/ Compl. ¶ 67.\n\n53\n\nEFTA02822889\n\n", "char_count": 1736}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 53, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 54 of 69\n\npayable to cash purportedly for \"fuel expenses when traveling to foreign countries.\"13\nAdditionally, between January 2012 and June 2013, Hyperion converted more than $120,000 into\nforeign currency.114 Many of these cash withdrawals \"either exceeded the $10,000 reporting\nthreshold or were seemingly structured to avoid triggering the reporting requirement.\"n5\n167.\n\nEpstein also used other entities under his control and with accounts at JPM,\n\nincluding his purported charitable organizations C.O.U.Q. Foundation and Enhanced Education,\nto funnel payments to his victims and associates.116 JPM seemingly did no due diligence on the\nnature of these various business entities, which appear to have no legitimate business purpose and,\nupon information and belief, were part of Epstein's criminal enterprise.\n168.\n\nFor example, Epstein and/or his representatives \"used the C.O.U.Q. Foundation\n\naccount to pay $29,464.66 to three young women, including two known victims, and over $20,000\nto a company called Phoenix Realty Home Inc.\"'\"\n169.\n\nIt is clear that JPM's compliance systems, at least between 2006 until Epstein's\n\n2019 arrest, were grossly deficient and failed to comply with both banking laws and regulations\nand Delaware fiduciary duty law. As detailed above, there were screaming red flags concerning\nEpstein — including his conviction, innumerable press reports, various government investigations,\nand highly suspicious activity in his Company accounts — yet JPM did nothing about it, besides\nsitting on their hands until belatedly firing Epstein as a client. Simply put, that was plainly\ninadequate under the law.\n\n13\n\nUSVI Compl. ¶ 67.\n\n114 USV/ Compl. ¶ 67.\n115 USV/Compl. ¶ 67.\n116 USV/Compl. ¶ 68.\nI\" USV/ Compl. ¶ 68.\n\n54\n\nEFTA02822890\n\n", "char_count": 1821}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 54, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nVI.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 55 of 69\n\nA BROKEN AML COMPLIANCE SYSTEM: JPM \"FAILED TO IDENTIFY\nSIGNIFICANT VOLUMES OF SUSPICIOUS ACTIVITY,\" IS ORDERED TO PAY\n$350 MILLION IN FINES, AND PLEADS GUILTY TO TWO FELONY COUNTS\n170.\n\nIn January 2014, JPM settled two felony violations of the BSA with the Department\n\nof Justice stemming from its failure to alert authorities to suspicious activity after red flags about\nBernie Madoff's illegal conduct were raised at the bank.' i8 As part of the settlement agreement,\nJPM agreed to pay $1.7 billion in penalties.\"9 Federal prosecutors noted that \"the Madoff Ponzi\nscheme was conducted almost exclusively\" through various accounts held at JPM.129 In fact, in\nthe early 2010s, JPM's board of directors risk committee lacked any directors who had worked at\na bank or as financial risk managers.121\n171.\n\nAdditionally, the 0CC ordered JPM to pay a $350 million fine for deficiencies in\n\nJPM's BSA and AML compliance programs. The penalty was based in part on JPM's failure to\nreport suspicions about Bernie Madoff to U.S. law enforcement and regulators.\n172.\n\nEven after it faced these highly publicized penalties, JPM has continued its illicit\n\nconduct, servicing funds for notorious bad actors:\n•\n\nFrom 2003 through 2014, JPM handled hundreds of transactions totaling nearly $2\nbillion for Dmytro Firtash, a Ukrainian oligarch who is wanted on criminal charges\nin the United States.I22\n\n\" 8 Ben Protess & Jessica Silver-Greenberg, JPMorgan Is Penalized $2 Billion Over Madoff,N.Y.\nTIMES\n2014,\nPM),\n(Jan.\n7,\n9:37\nhttps://archive.nytimes.com/dealbook.nytimes.com/2014/01/07/jpmorgan-settles-with-federalauthorities-in-madoff-case/.\n\" 9 /d.\n120 id.\n121\n\nDawn Kopecki & Max Abelson, JPMorgan Gave Risk Oversight to Museum Head,\nBLOOMBERG\nBUSINESSWEEK\n(May\n24,\n2012),\nhnp://vvww.law.harvard.edu/programs/corp_gov/MediaMentions/05-24-12_Businessweek.pdf.\n122 Alicia Tatone, Global Banks Defy U.S. Crackdowns by Serving Oligarchs, Cr\n... [truncated, 2111 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/54 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=54]", "char_count": 2111}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 55, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 56 of 69\n\n•\n\nFrom 2010 through 2015, a shell company operated by Semion Mogilevich, a\nRussian mafia figure described as the \"Boss of Bosses,\" sent and received more\nthan $1 billion in transactions through JPM. Mogilevich has been at the top of the\nFBI's most wanted listed since 2009.123\n\n•\n\nFrom 2012 through 2016, JPM moved more than $63 million for companies linked\nto Alejandro \"Piojo\" Isturiz, a former Venezuelan government official who has\nbeen charged by U.S. authorities as a player in an international money laundering\nscheme.124\n\n•\n\nFrom 2013 through 2016, Jho Low, a financier accused by authorities in multiple\ncountries of being the mastermind behind the embezzlement of more than $4.5\nbillion from a Malaysian economic development fund called 1Malaysia\nDevelopment Berhad, or I MDB, moved over $1.2 billion through JPM.125\n\n•\n\nFrom 2016 through 2017, JPM shuttled at least $6.9 million in transactions for Paul\nManafort in the 14 months after he resigned from Donald Trump's 2016\npresidential campaign amid allegations of money laundering and corruption\n\"spawning from his work with a pro-Russian political party in Ulcraine.\"128\n\n•\n\nEven after JPM allegedly closed Epstein's accounts with the bank in 2013, a current\nJPM employee continued to meet with Epstein at this Manhattan townhouse until\nat least 2017.127\n\n•\n\nIn December 2019, JPM faced a regulatory penalty for its KYC deficiencies.\nFINRA fined JPM $200,000 for failure to supervise custodian accounts resulting in\nviolations of KYC rules from 2014 to 2018.'28\n\n173.\n\nIn addition to its AML and KYC woes, earlier this month, June 2023, the SEC fined\n\nJPM $4 million for mistakenly deleting 47 million electronic records, including emails and instant\n\nhttps://www.icij.org/investigations/fincen-files/global-banks-defy-u-s-crackdowns-by-servingoligarchs-criminals-and-terrorists/.\n123 /d.\n124 /d.\nM.\n126m.\n127 Khadeeja Safdar & David Benoit, JPMorgan's Ties to Jeffrey\n... [truncated, 2262 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/55 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=55]", "char_count": 2262}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 56, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 57 of 69\n\nmessages, dated from January to April 2018, i.e., right when allegations concerning Epstein were\nsquarely in the public eye. As a result of the deletion, the SEC stated that JPM could not come up\nwith requested documents in eight SEC investigations and four other regulatory probes.129\nVII.\n\nTHE JANE DOE AND USV/ACTIONS BRING TO LIGHT JPM'S PARTICIPATION\nIN EPSTEIN'S CRIMES\n174.\n\nOn November 24, 2022, the initial complaint in the Jane Doe Action was filed.\n\nThat suit arose from \"JP\n\nChase Bank, N.A.'s ... participation and intentional involvement\n\nin Jeffery Epstein's widespread and well-publicized sex-trafficking operation, as well as the direct\nfinancial benefits it received therefrom.\"130 The complaint in the Jane Doe Action publicized, for\nthe first time, JPM's alleged involvement in and facilitation of Epstein's crimes.\n175.\n\nOn December 27, 2022, the initial complaint in the USVI Action was filed. That\n\nsuit arose from the Attorney General of the U.S. Virgin Islands' \"ongoing effort to protect public\nsafety and to hold accountable those who facilitated or participated in, directly or indirectly, the\ntrafficking enterprise Epstein helmed.\"131 According to the operative complaint in that action:\nThe [U.S. Virgin Islands'] investigation revealed that JP\nknowingly, negligently, and unlawfully provided and pulled the levers\nthrough which recruiters and victims were paid and was indispensable to\nthe operation and concealment of the Epstein trafficking enterprise.\nFinancial institutions can connect — or choke — human trafficking networks,\nand enforcement actions filed and injunctive relief obtained by attorneys\ngeneral are essential to ensure that enterprises like Epstein's cannot flourish\nin the future.I32\n\n129 Austin Weinstein, JPMorgan (JPM) Mistakenly Deleted 47 Million Records, SEC Alleges,\nBLOOMBERG (June 22, 2023, 10:50 AM), https://www.bloomberg.cominewearticles/2023-0622/jpmorgan-mistakenly-d\n... [truncated, 2313 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/56 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=56]", "char_count": 2313}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 57, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\n176.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 58 of 69\n\nOn March 20, 2023, this Court granted in part and denied in part the motions to\n\ndismiss filed in the Jane Doe and USV/ Actions.\n177.\n\nOn May 26, 2023, Dimon sat for a deposition in connection with the Jane Doe and\n\nUSV/ Actions. During the weekend of June 10-11, 2023, Staley sat for a deposition in connection\nwith the Jane Doe and USV/ Actions.\n178.\n\nThe following Monday, June 12, 2023, JPM announced that it had settled the Jane\n\nDoe Action for $290 million. 133 That settlement, if approved by this Court, would be one of the\nlargest ever for a civil sex-trafficking case.' 34\n179.\nVIII.\n\nThe USV/ Action remains pending.\n\nDEFENDANTS BREACHED THEIR FIDUCIARY DUTY AND HAVE CAUSED\nHARM TO JPM\n180.\n\nAs fiduciaries of JPM, a Delaware corporation, Defendants' fiduciary duties\n\nrequired them to institute an adequate oversight system in order to ensure compliance with positive\nlaw, including federal laws (such as the BSA and Patriot Act) concerning AML. Defendants\nplainly did not do so.\n181.\n\nAs discussed above in detail, JPM's compliance team repeatedly flagged that\n\nEpstein was a convicted felon, accused of running a sex trafficking ring financed primarily in cash,\nand withdrew and transferred huge sums of money. Executives at the highest reaches of the\nCompany were aware of these facts. It is indisputable that Staley (who allegedly participated\npersonally in Epstein's sex ring) and Erdoes were aware of the allegations levied against Epstein,\nas was Cutler, the General Counsel who vociferously advocated for JPM to sever ties with Epstein.\n\n'33\n\nKhadeeja Safdar & David Benoit, JPMorgan to Pay $290 Million to Settle Jeffrey Epstein\nAccusers' Suit, WSJ (June 12, 2023, 12:42 PM), https://www.wsj.com/articles/jpmorgan-chaseagrees-to-settle-jeffrey-epstein-accusers-suit-9dbbabff\n134 Id.\n\n58\n\nEFTA02822894\n\n", "char_count": 1898}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 58, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 59 of 69\n\nMoreover, it is inferable from the Company's own documents that Dimon personally reviewed\nEpstein's account in 2008 and decided to retain him as a JPM client.\n182.\n\nNevertheless, the Board and Company officers never acted on this information,\n\nterminated the Company's relationship with Epstein, or filed the legally required SARs. It was a\nclear breach of duty for JPM fiduciaries to be willfully blind and deaf to the highly publicized\nallegations against Epstein, who was a prominent figure in the financial world.\n183.\n\nThese breaches of fiduciary duty occurred at least from Epstein's 2008 guilty plea\n\nthrough his 2019 death, a period over which the JPM filed zero SARs related to Epstein.\n184.\n\nDefendants' breaches of fiduciary duty have caused massive harm to the Company.\n\nThe Company already has agreed to settle the Jane Doe Action for $290 million, and the USVJ\nAction remains pending. Moreover, JPM's deep and lasting affiliation with Epstein has caused\nincalculable reputational harm (as the Company's own filings warn is a severe risk of not\ncomplying with its regulatory obligations).\nDEMAND FUTILITY ALLEGATIONS\n185.\n\nPlaintiffs did not make a demand on the Board to institute this Action because pre-\n\nsuit demand is excused.\n186.\n\nPlaintiffs repeat and reallege each allegation above as if set forth in full in this\n\nDemand Futility Allegations section.\n187.\n\nDemand is excused because there exists a reasonable doubt that, at a minimum, at\n\nleast half of the Board at the time that this Complaint is filed could properly exercise independent\nand disinterested business judgment in responding to a demand.\n188.\n\nThe demand Board has 12 members: Bammann, =,\n\nCombs, Crown,\n\nDimon, Flynn, Alex Gorsky (\"Gorsky\"), Hobson, Michael A. Neal (\"Neal\"), Novakovic, and\nRometty. Demand is therefore futile if at least six of the 12 directors either lack independence,\n59\n\nEFTA02822895\n\n", "char_count": 1964}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 59, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 60 of 69\n\nare not disinterested, or both. Here, at least nine directors lack independence, are not disinterested,\nor both: Bammann, M,\n189.\n\nBammann,\n\nCombs, Crown, Dimon, Flynn, Hobson, Neal, and Novakovic.\nCombs, Crown, Dimon, Flynn, Hobson, and Neal are not\n\ndisinterested because they face a substantial likelihood of liability, whether in this Action, the\nUSV/ Action or in the Jane Doe Action. Each of these directors have served on the Board at times\nbetween Epstein's 2008 plea and his 2019 death. Yet, the Company plainly failed to comply with\npositive law, as evidenced by the fact that the Board never discussed JPM's relationship with\nEpstein and the Company did not file a single SAR related to Epstein over this timeframe.\n190.\n\nBammann, Crown, Dimon,\n\n, and Flynn face an even more heightened\n\nlikelihood of liability, given that they all served on the Board before the Company purportedly\nterminated its relationship with Epstein in 2013.\n191.\n\nMoreover, and separately, Dimon faces a substantial likelihood of liability because\n\nit appears that he knew about JPM's relationship with Epstein as of at least 2008 (if not earlier,\nduring his days in Columbus, Ohio and at Bank One) and knew about Epstein's guilty plea, yet\nDimon failed to cause the Company to terminate its relationship with Epstein, failed to address\nEpstein with the Board, and failed to cause the Company to file a single SAR concerning Epstein.\n192.\n\nAdditionally, Bammann, Crown, and Novakovic are not independent from Dimon\n\nand/or Crown.\n193.\n\nBammann owes a significant portion of her professional success to Dimon. While\n\nDimon was the CEO of Bank One, Bammann reached the status of Bank One's Executive Vice\nPresident and Chief Risk Management Officer from 2001 to 2004. Then, after JPM acquired Bank\nOne, when Dimon was JPM's President and Chief Operating Officer, Bammann served as the\nCompany's Deputy Head of Risk Management. Moreover, the Board \n... [truncated, 2043 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/59 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=59]", "char_count": 2043}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 60, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 61of 69\n\n2013, while Dimon attained his current roles of CEO and Chairman.\n\nBammann's only\n\nemployment since 2013 has been her role as a JPM director.\n194.\n\nCrown served on the board of directors of Bank One from 1991 until its sale to JPM\n\nin 2004, and Crown was one of the people who selected Dimon to be Bank One's CEO in 2000.\nCrown also advocated for Dimon to assume a leadership role at JPM. Moreover, Crown was\ninvolved in the New Albany project, which relied on Epstein for its success.\n195.\n\nNovakovic, in turn, is not independent from Crown. Novakovic is the Chairman\n\nand CEO of General Dynamics, Crown's family business. Thus, Crown likely had the influence\nto fire Novakovic, and it is not plausible that Novakovic would be willing to bring litigation against\nCrown concerning the allegations of this Complaint.\nPLAINTIFFS' CLAIMS ARE TIMELY\n196.\n\nPlaintiffs did not know, and could not have known, that Epstein used JPM to\n\nfacilitate his trafficking enterprise or that the Company turned a blind eye to unusual cash\ntransactions and wires and failed to carry out or follow up on basic due diligence and to timely\ncomply with federal banking regulations until the filing of the complaint in the Jane Doe Action\non November 24, 2022.\n197.\n\nTo the extent the statute of limitations even began to run before November 24,\n\n2022, any perceived delay in Plaintiffs' filing of this Action arises due to the Board's and Company\nmanagement's concerted and long-running efforts to conceal critical facts necessary to put\nPlaintiffs on notice of the specific facts showing the Board's and Company management's\nsustained and systemic breaches of fiduciary duty.\n198.\n\nAs discussed above, despite knowing Epstein was a felon convicted for sexual\n\nabuse, a pedophile who allegedly trafficked young girls from all over the world (including on his\nprivate plane), and wired and withdrew large sums of cash from his JPM accounts, the Company\n61\n\n... [truncated, 2015 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822837/60 or ?id=EFTA02822837&page=60]", "char_count": 2015}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 61, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 62 of 69\n\nfailed to file a single SAR concerning Epstein and his accounts. Additionally, JPM employees —\nincluding those at the highest reaches of the Company, such as Dimon, Staley, and/or Erdoes —\nactively concealed concerns about Epstein and failed to report them to the Board and/or timely fire\nEpstein as a client.\n199.\n\nMoreover, JPM continues to try to avoid accountability for its role in Epstein's sex-\n\ntrafficking ring. Dimon even repeatedly denied knowing who Epstein was until 2018 or 2019,\nwhich appears to be false given the allegations above. Instead, JPM has tried to lay all blame\nexclusively on Staley, and the Company has asserted claims against him — but not against other\nexecutives still at the Company and who clearly had knowledge of Epstein's crimes.\nCLAIMS FOR RELIEF\nCOUNT I\nBreach of Fiduciary Duty\n(Against the Director Defendants)\n200.\n\nPlaintiffs reallege the preceding paragraphs as set forth above and incorporate them\n\nherein by reference.\n201.\n\nThe Director Defendants, as directors of JPM, were and/or are fiduciaries of the\n\nCompany and its stockholders. As such, the Director Defendants owed and owe the Company and\nits stockholders the highest duties of good faith, due care, loyalty and candor.\n202.\n\nThe Company was and is subject to numerous AML laws and KYC regulations.\n\nThe Director Defendants' fiduciary duties oblige them to put systems in place to manage risk and\nensure compliance with these laws.\n203.\n\nThe Director Defendants, consistent with their fiduciary duties, were required to\n\nimplement and maintain effective controls to ensure the Company's compliance with AML laws\nand KYC regulations.\n\n62\n\nEFTA02822898\n\n", "char_count": 1726}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 62, "text_content": "Case 1:23-Cv-03903-JSR\n\n204.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 63 of 69\n\nThe Director Defendants consciously breached their fiduciary duties and violated\n\ntheir corporate responsibilities to ensure the Company's compliance with the applicable laws even\nwhen Epstein's criminal activity and criminal use of his JPM accounts and funds put them on\nnotice, either by ignoring red flags related to Epstein's actions and failing to adhere to their own\ninternal controls or by knowingly disregarding their own internal controls and intentionally\nallowing the Company to continue facilitating Epstein's criminal conduct.\n205.\n\nAs a result of the Director Defendants' conscious failure to perform their fiduciary\n\nduties and exercise their oversight responsibilities, the Company has sustained significant\ndamages, both financial and reputational. Such damages include, and will include, damage\nawards, settlements, expenses, penalties, fines, increased regulatory scrutiny, and other liabilities\ndescribed herein.\n206.\n\nThe Director Defendants' continuing decision not to correct this failure exposes the\n\nCompany to comparable and continuing risks of damages in the future.\n207.\n\nAs a result of the bad faith misconduct alleged herein, the Director Defendants are\n\nliable to the Company.\nCOUNT II\nBreach of Fiduciary Duty\n(Against the Officer Defendants)\n\n208.\n\nPlaintiffs reallege the preceding paragraphs as set forth above and incorporate them\n\nherein by reference.\n209.\n\nThe Officer Defendants, as officers of JPM, were and/or are fiduciaries of the\n\nCompany and its stockholders. As such, the Officer Defendants owed and owe the Company and\nits stockholders the highest duties of good faith, due care, loyalty and candor.\n\n63\n\nEFTA02822899\n\n", "char_count": 1740}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 63, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\n210.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 64 of 69\n\nThe Company was and is subject to numerous AML laws and KYC regulations.\n\nThe Officer Defendants' fiduciary duties oblige them to put systems in place to manage risk and\nensure compliance with these laws.\n211.\n\nThe Officer Defendants, consistent with their fiduciary duties, were required to\n\nimplement and maintain effective controls to ensure the Company's compliance with AML laws\nand KYC regulations.\n212.\n\nThe Officer Defendants consciously breached their fiduciary duties and violated\n\ntheir corporate responsibilities to ensure the Company's compliance with the applicable laws even\nwhen Epstein's criminal activity and criminal use of his JPM accounts and funds put them on\nnotice, either by ignoring red flags related to Epstein's actions and failing to adhere to their own\ninternal controls or by knowingly disregarding their own internal controls and intentionally\nallowing the Company to continue facilitating Epstein's criminal conduct.\n213.\n\nAs a result of the Officer Defendants' conscious failure to perform their fiduciary\n\nduties and exercise their oversight responsibilities, the Company has sustained significant\ndamages, both financial and reputational. Such damages include, and will include, damage\nawards, settlements, expenses, penalties, fines, increased regulatory scrutiny, and other liabilities\ndescribed herein.\n214.\n\nThe Officer Defendants' continuing decision not to correct this failure exposes the\n\nCompany to comparable and continuing risks of damages in the future.\n215.\n\nAs a result of the bad faith misconduct alleged herein, the Officer Defendants are\n\nliable to the Company.\n\n64\n\nEFTA02822900\n\n", "char_count": 1708}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 64, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 65 of 69\n\nCOUNT III\nUnjust Enrichment\n(Against the Individual Defendants)\n216.\n\nPlaintiffs re-allege the preceding paragraphs as set forth above and incorporate them\n\nherein by reference.\n217.\n\nAs a result of the conduct described herein, the Individual Defendants breached\n\ntheir fiduciary duties to the Company and its stockholders. The Individual Defendants were in a\nposition to benefit from their misconduct in the form of profits, benefits, and other compensation.\n218.\n\nThe Individual Defendants have been unjustly enriched at the expense and to the\n\ndetriment of Plaintiffs and the Company.\n219.\n\nIt would be unconscionable and against fundamental principles of justice, equity,\n\nand good conscience for the Individual Defendants to retain the benefits that they received only\nby virtue of breaching their fiduciary duties.\n220.\n\nAll profits, benefits, and other compensation that accrued to the Individual\n\nDefendants, collectively or individually, as a result of their misconduct should be disgorged.\nRELIEF REQUESTED\nWHEREFORE, Plaintiffs, on behalf of the Company, request judgment as follows:\nA.\n\nDeclaring that this Action is a proper derivative action maintainable under the law\n\nand that Plaintiffs are proper and adequate representatives of the Company;\nB.\n\nDeclaring that demand on the JPM Board is excused as futile;\n\nC.\n\nFinding the Director Defendants and Officer Defendants liable for breaching their\n\nfiduciary duties owed to the Company;\nD.\n\nAwarding damages sustained by the Company as a result of the breaches of\n\nfiduciary duty set forth above, together with pre- and post-judgment interest, from each of the\nIndividual Defendants, jointly and severally;\n65\n\nEFTA02822901\n\n", "char_count": 1758}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 65, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nE.\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 66 of 69\n\nDirecting JPM to take all necessary actions to reform and improve its compliance\n\nprocedures and governance policies to comply with applicable laws and to protect the Company\nand its stockholders from a repeat of the damaging events described herein;\nF.\n\nOrdering immediate disgorgement of all profits, benefits, and other compensation\n\nobtained by the Individual Defendants as a result of their breaches of fiduciary duty and unjust\nenrichment;\nG.\n\nAwarding Plaintiffs' costs and expenses incurred in this Action, including, but not\n\nlimited to, reasonable attorneys' fees, accountants' fees, consultants' fees, experts' fees, and costs\nand expenses; and\n221.\n\nGranting such other and further relief as the Court deems just and proper.\n\nJURY DEMAND\nPlaintiffs demand a trial by jury on all claims so triable.\n\nDate: June 30, 2023\n\nRespectfully submitted,\nBERNSTEIN LITOWITZ BERGER\n& GROSSMANN LLP\nIsl Mark Lebovitch\nMark Lebovitch\nSara Swartzwelder\n1251 Avenue of the Americas\nNew York, New York 10020\n(212) 554-1400\n\nBERNSTEIN LITOWITZ BERGER\n& GROSSMANN LLP\nDaniel Meyer\n500 Delaware Avenue, Suite 901\nWilmington, DE 19801\n(302) 364-3600\n\nCounselfor PlaintiffCity ofMiami General\nEmployees & Sanitation Employees\nRetirement Trust\n\n66\n\nEFTA02822902\n\n", "char_count": 1324}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 66, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 67 of 69\n\nGRANT & EISENHOFER P.A.\nIsl Rebecca A. Musarra\nRebecca A. Musarra\nJ. Orrico\nVivek Upadhya\n485 Lexington Ave., 29th Floor\nNew York, New York 10017\nrmusarra@gelaw.com\ncorrico@gelaw.com\nvupadhya@gelaw.com\n(646) 722-8500\nMichael J. Barry (admitted pro hac vice)\nChristine M. Mackintosh (admitted pro hac vice)\n123 Justison St.\nWilmington, DE 19801\nmbarry@gelaw.com\ncmackintosh®gelaw.com\n(302) 622-7000\nCounselfor Plaintiff Operating Engineers\nConstruction Industry and Miscellaneous Pension Fund\n\n67\n\nEFTA02822903\n\n", "char_count": 579}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 67, "text_content": "Case 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nDocument 17\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 68 of 69\n\nVERIFICATION\nI, Edgard Ma\n\nAdministrator for the City of Miami General Employees' &\n\nSanitation Employees' Retirement Trust (the \"Trust\"), hereby verify that the Trust currently holds\nJPMorgan Chase & Co. (the \"Company\") common\n\nand has held such stocks at all legally\n\nrequired times pertinent to this action. The Trust is ready, willing, and able to pursue this\nstockholder derivative action on behalf of and for the benefit of the Company.\nI have reviewed the allegations in the attached Verified Amended Stockholder Derivative\nComplaint, and as to those allegations of which I have personal knowledge, I know those\nallegations to be true, accurate, and complete. As to those allegations of which I do not have\npersonal knowledge, I rely on my counsel and their investigation, and for that reason I believe\nthem to be true. Having received and reviewed a copy of the Verified Amended Stockholder\nDerivative Complaint, and having reviewed it with my counsel, 1 hereby authorize its filing.\nI declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.\nExecuted on this 30 day of June, 2023.\n\nEdg•r.\n\nandez, Pension Administrator\n\n2901 Bridgeport Avenue • Coconut Grove, Florida 33133-3607 • ilephone (305) 441.2300 • Fax (305) 441.2307 • vowu.gese.ow\n\nEFTA02822904\n\n", "char_count": 1349}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822837", "page_number": 68, "text_content": "Document 17\n\nCase 1:23-cv-03903-JSR\n\nFiled 06/30/23\n\nPage 69 of 69\n\nVERIFICATION\nI, M. Scott\n\n. Trustee for the Operating Engineers Construction Industry\n\nOperating Engineers have held\n\n=\n\nand Miscellaneous Pension Fund (the \"Operating Engineers\"), hereby verify that the\nin JPMorgan Chase & Co. at all relevant times\n\nherein. The Operating Engineers are ready, willing, and able to pursue this stockholder\nderivative action on behalf of and for the benefit of JP\n\n. I have reviewed the\n\nallegations in the attached Verified Amended Stockholder Derivative Complaint, and as\nto those allegations of which I have personal knowledge, I know those allegations to be\ntrue, accurate, and complete. As to those allegations of which I do not have personal\nknowledge, I rely on my counsel and their investigation, and for that reason I believe them\nto be true. Having received a copy of the Verified Amended Stockholder Derivative\nComplaint, and having reviewed it with my counsel. I hereby authorize its filing.\nI declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.\nExecuted on:\nJune 3(0. 2023\n\nM. Scott-,\nAdministrator\nOperating Engineers Construction\nIndustry and Miscellaneous Pension\nFund\n\nEFTA02822905\n\n", "char_count": 1221}]}