{"efta_number": "EFTA02822271", "page_count": 17, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02822271", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02822271.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02822271", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "IN THE SUPERIOR COURT\nOF THE VIRGIN ISIANDS\n\nFILED\nSeptember 22, 2020\n\nTAMARA CHARLES\nCLERK OHNE COURT\n\nIN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS\nDIVISION OF ST.\nAND ST. JOHN\n********************************\n\nGHISLAINE MAXWELL,\n\n)\n)\nPlaintiff,\n)\n)\nvs.\n)\n)\nESTATE OF JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, DARREN )\nK. INDYKE, in his capacity as EXECUTOR OF )\nTHE ESTATE OF JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN,\n)\nRICHARD D. KAHN, in his capacity as\n)\nEXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF JEFFREY E. )\nEPSTEIN, and NES, LLC, a New York Limited\n)\nLiability Company,\n)\n)\nDefendant.\n)\n\nCase No. ST-20-CV-155\n\nGOVERNMENT OF THE UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS'\nREPLY BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO INTERVENE\nThe Government of the United States Virgin Islands (\"Government\"), by and through its\nundersigned counsel, hereby submits this Reply Brief in support of its motion for an order\npermitting the Government to intervene in this action as of right pursuant to V.I. R. Civ. P. 24(a)\nor else by leave pursuant to V.I. R. Civ. P. 24(b). The Government states in further support of its\nmotion as follows.\nPRELIMINARY STATEMENT\nThe Government moves to intervene in this action by Plaintiff Ghislaine Maxwell seeking\nindemnification and advancement of legal expenses from Defendants the Estate of Jeffrey E.\nEpstein and its Co-Executors—Darren K. Indyke and Richard D. Kahn—on two distinct but\nclosely related grounds. First, the Government has an interest in preserving Epstein Estate funds\nto satisfy a judgment in its pending action against Defendants alleging that Epstein and others\n\nEFTA02822271\n\n", "char_count": 1544}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822271", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "engaged in a criminal sex-trafficking enterprise in the Virgin Islands for which the Government\nseeks forfeiture, divestiture, disgorgement, and payment of civil penalties and damages under the\nCriminally Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (\"CICO\"), 14 V.I.C. §§ 601 et seq. Second,\nthe Government has an investigatory interest in Maxwell's involvement with Epstein's criminal\nsex-trafficking and sexual abuse conduct pursuant to its authority under CICO, 14 V.I.C. § 612,\nwhich Maxwell has thwarted by resisting and evading service of the Government's investigatory\nsubpoena, even while she has invoked the jurisdiction of the Virgin Islands Courts to obtain\nindemnification for the very same alleged conduct.\nMaxwell opposes the Government's motion to intervene on numerous grounds, none of\nwhich have merit. First, Maxwell contends she lacks sufficient notice of the Government's claims\nbecause it failed to attach a pleading as required by V.I. R. Civ. P. 24(c). This is incorrect. The\nGovernment attached as Exhibit A to its motion the Amended Complaint in its CICO action setting\nforth all of its claims against Defendants and the factual bases therefor. The CICO Complaint\nserves Rule 24's purpose of giving the parties notice of what the Government's claims and interests\nare. See, e.g., U.S. v. Metro St. Louis Sewer Dist, 589 F.3d 829, 834 (8th Cir. 2009) (\"Appellees\nargue that MIEC's failure to submit a pleading is sufficient to deny its motion to intervene, but we\nconclude that the statement of interest satisfies Rule 24(c) because it provides sufficient notice to\nthe court and the parties of MIEC's interests.\"); Massachusetts v. Microsoft Corp., 373 F.3d 1199,\n1236 n.19 (D.C. Cir. 2004) (\"The Government and Microsoft make no claim they had inadequate\nnotice of the intervenors' appeal, and we find no reason to bar intervention based solely upon this\ntechnical [lack of pleading] defect, if defect it be.\"). Maxwell and the Epstein Estate have ample\nnotice of the Governmen\n... [truncated, 2044 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822271/1 or ?id=EFTA02822271&page=1]", "char_count": 2044}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822271", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Second, Maxwell argues that the Government's pending CICO claims against Defendants\ndo not provide a sufficient interest because they are contingent, not yet having been litigated to\njudgment. Maxwell relies almost entirely on federal court cases within the Third Circuit for this\nargument. These cases are not controlling. See Bruni v. Alger, 71 V.I. 71, 76 n.11 (Super. Ct.\n2019) (decisions interpreting federal rules of procedure are persuasive, not binding, authority as to\nanalogous Virgin Islands Rules provisions). Here, far more persuasive are decisions in at least six\nother federal Circuits rejecting the Third Circuit's analysis and holding that a pending claim may\nprovide a sufficient interest for intervention in the defendant's coverage action. See, e.g., Utahns\nfor Better Transp. v. U.S. Dept. of Tramsp., 295 F.3d 1111, 1115-16 (10th Cir. 2002) (\"The threat\nof economic injury from the outcome of litigation undoubtedly gives a petitioner the requisite\ninterest [in intervention as of right].\"); Security Ins. Co. v. Schipporeit, Inc., 69 F.3d 1377, 138081 (7th Cir. 1995); Teague v. Baker, 931 F.2d 259, 261 (4th Cir. 1991); TIG Specialty Ins. Co. v.\nFin. Web.com, Inc., 208 F.R.D. 336, 338 (M.D. Ha. 2002); St. Paul Fire & Marine Ins. Co. v.\nSummit\n\nInd's Co., 143 F.R.D. 129, 134 (N.D. Ohio 1992); New Hampshire Ins. Co. v.\n\n110 F.R.D. 549, 552 (D.R.1. 1986). The Government has a clear and sufficient interest\nin the outcome of this action.\nThird, Maxwell argues that intervention is unnecessary because the Government's interest\nin ensuring availability of the Epstein Estate's funds is secured by the Government's Criminal\nActivity Liens placed pursuant to 14 V.I.C. § 610. This is incorrect because the Government's\nCriminal Activity Liens under CICO are limited to Epstein's funds or property situated or owned\nin the Virgin Islands, see 14 V.I.C. § 610(e)(1)-(2), and because the Epstein Estate is fighting\nenforcement of the Government's Liens at every turn. See Exhibit M\n... [truncated, 2144 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822271/2 or ?id=EFTA02822271&page=2]", "char_count": 2144}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822271", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Court to ... issue an Order for the Attorney General to release the liens on the Estate's FirstBank\naccount in the amount [$7,200,000] requested in the Estate's correspondence with the Attorney\nGeneral.\").\nFinally, Maxwell argues that the Government's interest in the outcome of this case is\nadequately protected by the Epstein Estate's interest in protecting its own funds. This, too, is\nincorrect. Numerous of the above-cited federal courts reject the same argument that the parties to\na coverage action can adequately represent the interests of a tort claimant. See, e.g., Security Ins.,\n69 F.3d at 1381; Teague, 931 F.3d at 262. Here, the Epstein Estate and its Co-Executors clearly\nare inadequate to represent the Government's interest in preserving Estate funds because\n•\n\nMaxwell herselfpleads that \"Indyke, in his capacity as Executor of the Estate, also\nmade assurances to Maxwell that Maxwell's legal fees and obligations would be\nreimbursed by Epstein and the Estate ....\" Complaint, ¶ 21; and\n\n•\n\nIndyke and Kahn admit that \"the Estate is indemnifying certain current and former\nemployees of and professionals on behalf of one or more defendants in the Attorney\nGeneral's suit.\" Ex. M (Letter of Counsel for Epstein Estate and Co-Executors to\nProbate Court, Sept. 15, 2020) at 2.\n\nThere thus is no question that the Co-Executors are not acting to preserve Estate funds. The\nGovernment's interest in preservation thus is not adequately represented by the Epstein Estate or\nits Co-Executors, the Defendants in the Government's CICO enforcement action.\nFor all of these reasons and as set forth more fully below, the Court should grant the\nGovernment's motion to intervene.\nARGUMENT\nA.\n\nThe Motion Gives Ample Notice of the Government's Claims and Interests.\n\nMaxwell begins her opposition by arguing that the Government's motion to intervene is\n\"procedurally defective\" because it does not attach a pleading as required by Rule 24(c) and that,\nbecause of this alleged failure, the motion \"d\n... [truncated, 2071 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822271/3 or ?id=EFTA02822271&page=3]", "char_count": 2071}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822271", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "precise nature of [the Government's] claims.\" Opposition at 3-4. This argument is factually\nand/or legally incorrect.\nRule 24 provides that a motion to intervene \"must state the grounds for intervention and be\naccompanied by a pleading that sets out the claim or defense for which intervention is sought.\"\nV.I. R. Civ. P. 24(c). The Government satisfied this requirement by attaching as Exhibit A to its\nmotion its First Amended Complaint in its CICO action against Defendants the Epstein Estate and\nits Co-Executors and others. The CICO Complaint is 54 pages, contains 114 paragraphs of factual\nallegations, and states 24 separate counts setting forth the legal grounds for each item of relief the\nGovernment seeks from Defendants. The Government also attached as Exhibit B its CICO\nSubpoena Duces Tecum, the service of which Maxwell previously resisted and evaded, which\nstates clearly that the Government is seeking documents from her related to \"the rape, abuse,\nexploitation and trafficking of young women and underage girls by Jeffrey E. Epstein and his\nassociates\" in violation of Virgin Islands law. Maxwell does not even address the Government's\nsubmission of its CICO Complaint or Subpoena, let alone explain how or why they do not satisfy\nthe Rule's requirement of a pleading to give notice of interest.\nSince Maxwell ignores the Government's attached CICO Complaint and Subpoena, she\ndoes not address whether or how Rule 24(c) contemplates something different. But even if it did,\nthis would be purely a matter of form, not substance, because the CICO Complaint and subpoena\nclearly satisfy the pleading provision's purpose—to give the litigating parties notice of the\nintervening party's claims and interest. See generally In re LO.F., 62 V.I. 655, 665 (2015) (\"It is\na settled rule that in the construction of statutes an interpretation is never to be adopted that would\ndefeat the purpose of the enactment.\") (internal quotation marks and citation omitted).\n\n5\n\nEFTA02822275\n\n", "char_count": 1991}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822271", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "This is the conclusion reached by numerous federal circuit courts of appeal in applying the\nidentical pleading provision of Fed. R. Civ. P. 24(c). See Peaje fm's. LLC v.\n\n-Padilla, 845\n\nF.3d 505, 515 (1st Cir. 2017) (\"Accordingly, denial of a motion to intervene based solely on the\nmovant's failure to attach a pleading, absent prejudice to any party, constitutes an abuse of\ndiscretion.\"); Metro St. Louis, supra, 569 F.3d at 834 (\"[T]he statement of interest satisfies Rule\n24(c) because it provides sufficient notice to the court and the parties of MIEC's interests.\");\nProvidence Baptist Church v. Hillandale Comm., Ltd., 425 F.3d 309, 314 (6th Cir. 2005)\n(\"Furthermore, neither party has ever claimed that any prejudice would result from granting the\nmotion to intervene despite the failure to attach a pleading; the parties are clearly on notice as to\nHillandale Committee's position and arguments.\"); Mass. v. Microsoft, supra, 373 F.3d at 1236\nn.19 (\"The Government and Microsoft make no claim they had inadequate notice of the\nintervenors' appeal, and we find no reason to bar intervention based solely upon this technical\ndefect, if defect it be.\").\nSince Maxwell cannot plausibly claim lack of notice of the Government's interests in\npreservation of the Epstein Estate's funds and in service of its CICO investigatory subpoena, her\nargument for denial of intervention based upon Rule 24(c) fails and should be rejected.\nB.\n\nThe Government Has a Clear and Sufficient Interest in the Outcome of this\nAction.\n\nMaxwell next argues that the Government's interest in preservation of Epstein Estate funds\nis insufficient for intervention because the interest is \"contingent\" until a judgment is entered in\nthe Government's CICO action against the Estate. The Court should reject this argument because\nit relies upon an overly rigid and stringent conception of the \"interest\" that supports intervention\nas of right under Rule 24(a)(2).\n\n6\n\nEFTA02822276\n\n", "char_count": 1958}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822271", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Maxwell cites as support for her argument decisions of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the\nThird Circuit and the U.S. District Court for the District of the Virgin Islands, which was bound\nby Third Circuit precedent. See Opposition at 6-7 (citing Mountain Top Condo Assn v. Dave\nStabbert\n\nBuilder, Inc., 72 F.3d 261, 366 (3d Cir. 1995); Gen. Star Indem. Co. v. V.I. Port\n\nAuth., 224 F.R.D. 372, 375-76 (D.V.I. 2004)). These decisions, however, both applying Federal\nRule 24, are not controlling on this Court's application of Virgin Islands Rule 24. See, e.g., Bnini\nv. Alger, supra, 71 V.I. at 76 n.11 (decisions applying Federal Rules of Civil Procedure are\npersuasive, not binding authority, as to analogous Virgin Islands Rules).\nHere, the Court should not find the Third Circuit's interpretation of Federal Rule 24\npersuasive because it is contrary to decisions of courts in at least six other federal circuits—the\nFirst, Fourth, Sixth, Seventh, Tenth, and Eleventh Circuits—which find that the holder of a\npending claim may have a sufficient interest to intervene in a related coverage case. See Utahns\nfor Better Transp., supra, 295 F.3d at 1115 (\"The threat of economic injury from the outcome of\nlitigation undoubtedly gives a petition the requisite interest\" to intervene); Security Ins. Co., supra,\n69 F.3d at 1380-81 (affirming grant of intervention by tort claimant in coverage action); Teague,\nsupra, 931 F.2d at 261 (\"[O]ther [courts] have allowed intervention in a dispute between an insurer\nand its insured even when the intervenor's interest is contingent on the outcome of other litigation.\nWe find the reasoning of this latter authority persuasive.\") (citations omitted); TIG Specialty Ins.\nCo., supra, 208 F.R.D. at 338 (potential deprivation of source of recovery if intervenor prevails on\nits claim is a sufficient interest); St. Paul Fire & Marine, supra, 143 F.R.D. at 134 (\"There is\nnothing in the wording or history of Rule 24 which indicates intent to exclude would be inter\n... [truncated, 2215 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822271/6 or ?id=EFTA02822271&page=6]", "char_count": 2215}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822271", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "2016) (\"[T]he Tenth Circuit and numerous other Courts of Appeal have permitted intervenors with\na contingent interest to intervene.\").\nIn Teague, supra, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit held that class action\nplaintiffs seeking to intervene in a coverage action involving the class action defendant had a\nsufficient interest because they \"stand to gain or lose by the direct legal operation of the district\ncourt's judgment\" in the coverage case. 931 F.2d at 261. That same conclusion applies here. If\nthis Court rules that the Epstein Estate must indemnify Maxwell for claims related to her\nrelationship with Epstein and to \"advance\" her attorneys' fees (while she is in prison awaiting trial\non federal criminal charges), then the Government stands to lose funds for the satisfaction of a\njudgment in its CICO action against the Epstein Estate.\nMaxwell also argues that the Government's separate but related investigatory interest under\nCICO as to her involvement with Epstein's conduct is not sufficient to support intervention. See\nOpposition at 12-14. Maxwell focuses primarily on the Government's ability to enforce its CICO\nsubpoena by other means, rather than on the investigatory interest itself. The Government's\ninterest is established by statute, 14 V.I.C. § 612(a), and involves the same subject matter as this\naction—Maxwell's relationship to the Epstein Enterprise's conduct.\n\nCompare Maxwell\n\nComplaint, ¶ 1 (\"This is an action for indemnification for and advancement of the attorneys' fees,\nsecurity costs, costs to find safe accommodation, and all other expenses Maxwell has reasonably\nincurred and will incur by reason of her employment relationship with Jeffrey E. Epstein\n('Epstein') and his affiliated businesses . . . .\"); with Gov't Ex. B (CICO Subpoena) (seeking\ndocuments from Maxwell related to \"the rape, abuse, exploitation and trafficking of young women\nand underage girls by Jeffrey E. Epstein and his associates\" in violation of Virgin Islands law).\nTh\n... [truncated, 2114 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822271/7 or ?id=EFTA02822271&page=7]", "char_count": 2114}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822271", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Based on the substantial weight and persuasive force of the foregoing authority applying\nthe analogous federal rules provision, the Court should hold that the Government's pending CICO\nclaims against the Epstein Estate provide it with a clear and sufficient interest to intervene to ensure\npreservation of Estate funds.\nC.\n\nThe Government's Interest in Preserving Epstein Estate Funds for Payment\nof a Judgment May Be Impaired Absent Allowance of Intervention.\n\nMaxwell separately argues that the Government's interest in preservation of Epstein Estate\nfunds will not be impaired by any judgment or resolution of this action because the Government\nhas placed Criminal Activity Liens on certain Estate assets pursuant to 14 V.I.C. § 610. See\nOpposition at 10-11. The Court should reject this argument because it ignores the difference in\nscope between all Epstein Estate assets and those covered by the Government's Criminal Activity\nLiens.\nCICO's Criminal Activity Lien provisions permit the Government to place liens upon a\nCICO defendant's property that is \"situated in the Territory of the Virgin Islands\" or its \"beneficial\ninterest\" that is \"located in the Territory of the Virgin Islands.\" 14 V.I.C. § 610(e)(1)-(2). Maxwell\nacknowledges this territorial limitation. See Opposition at 10 (\"These liens cover all real and\npersonal property located in the Virgin Islands in the name or under the signatory authority of\nthe Estate.\") (emphasis in original).\nThe Government's claims for forfeiture, divestiture, maximum civil penalties per violation,\ntreble and punitive damages, and disgorgement of ill-gotten gains under CICO, see Ex. A-CICO\nComplaint at 53-54 (Prayer for Relief), are not so limited. See 14 V.I.C. § 607(c), (e) (provisions\nfor awarding damages and civil penalties, without territorial limit).\nSince the Epstein Estate assets covered by the Government's Criminal Activity Liens are\nnot co-extensive with the relief the Government may obtain through a judgment on its CICO\n9\n\nEFT\n... [truncated, 2011 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822271/8 or ?id=EFTA02822271&page=8]", "char_count": 2011}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822271", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "claims, the Court should reject Maxwell's argument that the Liens alone are sufficient to secure\nthe Government's interests without intervention.\nAlthough the foregoing suffices to reject Maxwell's argument, it also bears emphasis that\nDefendants the Epstein Estate and its Co-Executors are resisting and seeking to evade the\nGovernment's Criminal Activity Liens at every turn. As just one example, even though the\nAttorney General and the Superior Court in the CICO action have sole and exclusive authority to\nrelease funds covered by the Liens, see 14 V.I.C. § 610(r) (Attorney General's authority), (t)\n(CICO Court's authority), the Co-Executors repeatedly have asked and currently are asking the\nProbate Court to order release of over $7,000,000 covered by the Government's Criminal Activity\nLiens. See Ex. M hereto (Letter of Counsel for Epstein Estate and Co-Executors to Probate Court,\nSept. 15, 2020) at 2 (\"[W]e urgently ask the Court to . . . issue an Order for the Attorney General\nto release the liens on the Estate's FirstBank account in the amount [$7,200,000] requested in the\nEstate's correspondence with the Attorney General.\"). While these requests have no legal merit,\ntheir existence is at least relevant to Maxwell's assertion that the Government's interest are\nabsolutely secured by the Criminal Activity Liens.\nMaxwell also argues that the Government's investigatory interest under CICO as to her\ninvolvement with Epstein's conduct will not be impaired absent intervention because the\nGovernment may protect this interest by other means—by enforcing its CICO subpoena in the\nstate where she resides. See Opposition at 14 (citing 14 V.I.C. § 612(k)). In so arguing, Maxwell\nadmits that she avoided service of the Government's CICO Subpoena by refusing to authorize her\nattorney in the Virgin Islands to accept service. See Opposition at 14 (Government's subpoenas\n\"were served to persons who did not have authority to accept them.\"). She also does not deny that\nshe resisted or \n... [truncated, 2099 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822271/9 or ?id=EFTA02822271&page=9]", "char_count": 2099}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822271", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "arrest. See Gov't Motion at 4-6. She also does not consent to service or to a court's personal\njurisdiction over her as a citizen of New York where she is imprisoned. She has, however,\nconsented to this Court's jurisdiction over her claims related to her relationship with Jeffrey\nEpstein. This action in this Court thus is the one venue in which the Government's investigatory\ninterest is certain not to be impaired.\nFor all of these reasons, the Court should reject Maxwell's argument and should hold that\nthe Government's interests in preservation of Epstein Estate funds and in advancement of its\ninvestigation of Maxwell may be impaired absent intervention.\nD.\n\nThe Epstein Estate Does Not Adequately Represent the Government's\nInterests.\n\nMaxwell also argues that the Government may not intervene because the Epstein Estate\nand its Co-Executors, in her telling, share and thus adequately represent the Government's interest\nin preserving Estate funds. See Opposition at 15-17 (\"To the extent that the Government is\nconcerned with the dissipation of the Estate's assets, the Trustees adequately represent the\nGovernment's interest here.\"). They do not.\nMaxwell's own Complaint allegations undercut this argument. As one of the grounds for\nher alleged right to indemnification and advancement of legal costs, Maxwell alleges that separate\nand apart from Epstein's promises, Defendant \"Indyke, in his capacity as an Executor of the Estate,\nalso made assurances to Maxwell that Maxwell's legal fees and obligations would be reimbursed\nby Epstein and the Estate, and that Maxwell's legal fees and expenses would be paid going\nforward.\" Complaint, ¶ 21 (emphasis added). How this promise by Indyke squares with his\n\"fiduciary duties to all who may have a beneficial interest in the estate,\" Opposition at 15, or to\notherwise preserve Epstein Estate funds, Maxwell does not say.\n\n11\n\nEFTA02822281\n\n", "char_count": 1897}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822271", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Nonetheless, her allegation that Indyke is offering up Epstein Estate funds for the legal\ndefense of persons not specifically identified as Estate beneficiaries is borne out by Indyke and\nKahn's recent admission to the Probate Court that this is exactly what they are doing. Their\ncounsel's September 15, 2020 letter to the Probate Court acknowledges that \"the Estate is\nindemnifying certain current and former employees of and professionals on behalf of one or more\ndefendants in the Attorney General's suit.\" Ex. M hereto (Sept. 15, 2020 letter) at 2. Specifically,\nthe Government has learned that the Estate is paying the legal fees for an immigration attorney it\nbelieves may have obtained visas for Epstein's trafficking victims. Paying the legal fees of\nindividuals alleged to have participated in Epstein's trafficking enterprise demonstrates the\nEstate's interest in preventing the disclosure of information relevant to the Government's case in\nthe Government's case, and belies Maxwell's assertion that the Government's and the Estate's\ninterests in preservation of funds are perfectly aligned.\nAt risk of stating the obvious, the Estate of Jeffrey E. Epstein and its Co-Executors are not\nadequate representatives for the Government's interest in preserving the availability of Estate\nfunds to satisfy a CICO action judgment based upon Epstein's sex-trafficking and other related\ncriminal conduct. The Court therefore should grant the Government intervention as of right under\nRule 24(a).\nE.\n\nThe Government Also Satisfies Rule 24(b)'s Requirements for Permissive\nIntervention.\n\nMaxwell's arguments for denying permissive intervention pursuant to V.I. R. Civ. P. 24(b)\nalso have no merit and should be rejected if intervention as of right is denied (which it should not\nbe).\nMaxwell first argues that permissive intervention should be denied because the\nGovernment's claims do not share \"a common question of law or fact,\" V.I. R. Civ. P. 24(b)(1)(B),\n12\n\nEFTA02822282\n\n", "char_count": 1979}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822271", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "with the claims in her indemnification action. See Opposition at 17. This is incorrect. The\nGovernment's CICO claims against Defendants, its investigated claims against Maxwell, and\nMaxwell's claims against Defendants all present the common question of: Who is liable to pay a\njudgment on the Government's CICO claims against Defendants (and/or Maxwell) for their\ninvolvement in or connection to the rape, abuse, exploitation, and trafficking of young women and\nunderage girls by Epstein and his associates?\nNumerous federal courts have addressed the question of whether a tort claim and an\nindemnification claim present a common question of law or fact, and concluded that they do. See\nSecurity Ins. Co., supra, 69 F.3d at 1381 (common question and independent jurisdiction\nrequirements \"are clearly met in this case\"); Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co. v. Nat'l REO Mgmt,\n205 F.R.D. 1, 6 (D.D.C. 2000) (\"Thus, while the insurance contract may not be an issue in the\nunderlying case in Superior Court, the factual similarities between the two cases are enough to\nestablish a common question of fact. Specifically, both the present case and the underlying case\narise from alleged carbon monoxide emissions from a furnace in the defendant's building that\nbegan on February 23, 1995. In addition, neither case can be decided without determining the\nsource of the applicant's injuries. Accordingly, for purposes of [Federal] Rule 24(b), the court\nfinds a common question of fact in the present lawsuit and the underlying lawsuit in Superior\nCourt.\"). This Court should hold the same here.\nMaxwell's next and final argument is that the Government's intervention will cause undue\ndelay and prejudice because the Government \"proposes to inject legal issues that diverge\nsubstantially from those involved in this indemnification action.\" Opposition at 18. Not so.\nThe only such issues Maxwell identifies are those \"concerning the Government's intent to\nconduct a criminal investigation of Plaintiff within the contex\n... [truncated, 2053 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822271/12 or ?id=EFTA02822271&page=12]", "char_count": 2053}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822271", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "question, however, would be answered by the intervention itself. Once intervention is granted, the\nGovernment will seek to: (a) oppose unauthorized expenditures of Epstein Estate's funds, which\nMaxwell contends already is or should be the Estate's position, see Opposition at 16; and (b)\nenforce its investigatory subpoena against Maxwell, which raises a discrete question clearly\nanswered under 14 V.I.C. § 612(a), as Maxwell also appears to recognize (but nonetheless wants\nto be answered in any other court where she has not yet consented to jurisdiction), see Opposition\nat 13-14.\nAt bottom, the only thing the Government's intervention threatens is to provide facts\nanswering the questions already raised by Maxwell's indemnification claim in this action.\nMaxwell seeks indemnification from the Epstein Estate based upon her purported \"prior\nemployment relationship\" with Epstein and his businesses in connection with any claim \"related\nto Epstein, his affiliated businesses, and his alleged victims.\" Complaint, I 1 (emphasis added).\nThe Epstein Estate's Co-Executors already are \"indemnifying certain current and former\nemployees of and professionals on behalf of Epstein's companies. Ex. M (Sept. 15, 2020 letter\nto Probate Court). Only the Government stands at the ready to determine:\n•\n\nwhat actual conduct by Epstein and Maxwell is at issue in connection with claims\nby Epstein's \"alleged victims;\"\n\n•\n\nwhether the criminal sex-trafficking and sexual abuse conduct that is alleged would\nfall within the scope of any purported employment relationship; and/or\n\n•\n\nwhether, employment relationship or no, it is a legitimate expenditure of Epstein\nEstate funds to provide legal representation to persons connected to an alleged\ncriminal sex-trafficking enterprise instead of preserving funds for the Estate's true\nbeneficiaries and claimants.\n\nThus, rather than unduly complicate this litigation, the Government's intervention would guide it\ntowards a fact-based resolution of the issues Maxwe\n... [truncated, 2065 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822271/13 or ?id=EFTA02822271&page=13]", "char_count": 2065}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822271", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "For each of these reasons, the Court should grant permissive intervention under Rule 24(b)\nif intervention as of right under Rule 24(a) is denied (which it should not be).\nCONCLUSION\nFor all of the reasons set forth herein and in the moving papers, the Court should grant the\nGovernment's motion to intervene as of right under Rule 24(a) or else by permission under Rule\n24(b).\nRespectfully submitted,\nDENISE N.\nESQUIRE\nATTORNEY GENERAL\n\nDated: September 22. 2020\n\nBy:\n\nIa\no\nCAROL\nESQ.\nChief Deputy Attorney General\nVirgin Islands Department of Justice\nOffice of the Attorney General\n3438 'Cron rindsens Gade\nSt.\nU.S. Vi in Islands 00802\nEmail:\n(340) 774-5666 ext. 10101\n\n15\n\nEFTA02822285\n\n", "char_count": 690}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822271", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\nIT IS HEREBY CERTIFIED that the foregoing Reply Brief in Support of Motion to\nIntervene complies with the word and page requirements of V.I.R. Civ. P. 6-1(e) and a true and\ncorrect copy of the Motion was served via regular mail, postage prepaid, with a courtesy copy sent\nby email to counsel of record on September 22, 2020 to:\nKYLE R. WALDNER, ES\nQUINTAIROS, PRIETO,\n& BOYER, P.A.\n9300 S. Dadeland Blvd., 4 Floor\nMiami, FL 33156\nE-mail: kwaldner@qpwblaw.com\nDAVID CATTIE, ESQ.\nTHE CATTIE LAW FIRM, P.C.\n1710\nGade\nSt.\nV.I., 00802\ne-mail: david.cattie@cattie-law.com\nKROBLIN, ESQ.\nANDREW W. HEYMANN, ESQ.,\nWILLIAM BLUM, ESQ.\nSHARI D'ANDRADE, ES .\nKROBLIN PLLC\nKELLERHALS\nPalms Professional Building\n9053 Estate M,\nSuite 101\nSt.\n, V.E. 00802-3602\nEmail: ckroblin@kellfer.com\naheymann@solblum.com\nwblum@solblum.com\nsdandrade@kellfer.com\nmwhalen@kellfer.com\nANDREW TOMBACK\nMcLaughlin & Stem, LLP\n260 Madison Avenue\nNew York, New York 10016\nUnited States\nEmail: ATomback@mclaughlinstern.com\n\n16\n\nEFTA02822286\n\n", "char_count": 1028}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822271", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "DANIEL WEINER\nMARC A. WEINSTEIN!\nHUGHES HUBBARD & REID, LLP\nOne Battery Park Plaza\nNew York, NY 10004-1482\nUnited States\nEmail: daniel.weiner@hugheshubbard.com\nmarc.weinstein@hugheshubbard.com\n\n/S/ Carol\nCAROL\nESQ.\nChief Deputy Attorney General\nVirgin Islands Department of Justice\nOffice of the Attorney General\n3438 !Cron rindsens Gade\nSt.\nU.S. Virgin Islands 00802\nEmail:\n(340) 774-5666 ext. 10101\n\n17\n\nEFTA02822287\n\n", "char_count": 420}]}