{"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_count": 50, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02822203", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02822203.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "IN THE SUPERIORCOIGT\nOF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS\n\nFILED\nSeptember 08, 2020\n\nTAMARA CHARLES\nCLERK OF THE COURT\n\nIN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS\nAND ST. JOHN\nDIVISION OF ST.\nCIVIL CASE NO.: ST-20-CV-155\n\nGHISLAINE MAXWELL,\nPlaintiff,\nvs.\n\nESTATE OF JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN,\nDARREN K. INDYKE, in his capacity as\nEXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF JEFFREY\nE. EPSTEIN, RICHARD D. KAHN, in his\ncapacity as EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE\nOF JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, and NES, LLC, a\nNew York Limited Liability Company,\nDefendants.\n\nPLAINTIFF'S OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO INTERVENE\nPlaintiff GHISLAINE MAXWELL (\"Plaintiff), by counsel, pursuant to V.I.R.Civ.P. 24,\nhereby opposes the Motion to Intervene' (the \"Motion to Intervene\") filed by nonparty, the\nGovernment of the United States Virgin Islands (the \"Government\").\nL\n\nPRELIMINARY STATEMENT\nThe Motion to Intervene must be denied because it is procedurally defective and the\n\nGovernment has no sufficient basis to intervene in this case. The Government seeks to intervene\nfor two reasons. First, it vaguely seeks to \"ensure that the Epstein Estate's assets are not\nwrongfully dissipated,\" without articulating how it proposes to do so. GVI Mtn. at 2. Second, it\nasks this Court to enforce its unserved criminal CICO Subpoenas to Plaintiff and, more\ngenerally, to investigate Plaintiff in order to establish a predicate for future criminal charges\n\nI The Government Motion to Intervene is cited herein by page number as \"GVI Mm.\"\n\nEFTA02822203\n\n", "char_count": 1468}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "CIVIL CASE NO.: ST-20-CV-155\nPage 2 of 20\nagainst her. GVI Mtn. at 2-3. These grounds are meritless and do not provide a sufficient basis to\nintervene in this case.\nFirst, the Government failed to comply with Rule 24(c)'s requirement that its motion be\naccompanied \"by a pleading that sets out the claim or defense for which intervention is sought.\"\nV.I.R.Civ.P. 24(c) (emphasis added). This failure alone disposes of the Government's motion.\nEven on its merits, the Government's motion is fatally flawed. The Government's\ncontingent claim to the \"Epstein Estate's assets\" is not a sufficient interest for intervention. The\nGovernment ignores law from this jurisdiction that an interest contingent upon a favorable\njudgment in an underlying suit is insufficient to sustain intervention of right under Rule 24. Even\nif it were, such interest would not practically be impaired here since the Government has filed\nCriminal Activity Liens covering the Estate's assets.2\nNext, the Government's extraordinary and unprecedented request that it be allowed to\ncommandeer this civil case to function as an ann of its criminal investigation of Plaintiff and lay\nthe predicate for future criminal charges against her is flatly contrary to law and cannot justify\nintervention.. Intervention is not appropriate where the party seeking to intervene has other\nmeans to protect its interests. The Government, of course, is no ordinary would-be intervenor in\na civil action between private parties. Here, the Government has a number of investigatory tools\n2 In making its argument that intervention is necessary to prevent the dissipation of Estate\nassets, the Government repeatedly disparages Plaintiff's claim for indemnification as\n\"undocumented and otherwise suspect.\" GVI Mtn. at 10, 13. The Government is in no place to\nassess the merits of Plaintiff's claims, nor is such an inquiry appropriate under Rule 24.\nMoreover, we note that certain of the Government's own claims in its Motion to Intervene and\nCICO com\n... [truncated, 2336 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/1 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=1]", "char_count": 2336}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "CIVIL CASE NO.: ST-20-CV-155\nPage 3 of 20\nat its disposal to obtain any information it deems necessary, including the power to issue CICO\nsubpoenas (which it has done) and compel compliance (which it has not attempted to do). The\nGovernment should not be allowed to bypass this process by intruding into this civil action so\nthat it can use this Court to help enforce its criminal subpoenas, which have nothing whatsoever\nto do with the simple contract dispute over indemnification at issue in this case. The Government\nshould likewise not be allowed to act beyond its already considerable statutory authority. The\nappropriate scope and manner of the Government's criminal investigation of a private, nonresident of the Virgin Islands is not a matter for this Court; rather, it a question that should be\naddressed by the courts having proper jurisdiction over the criminal investigation.\nIn sum, the Government's purported interests do not fit anywhere in this case. Instead, it\nshould continue to use the broad statutory powers it already has to protect its alleged interests.\nThe Court should therefore deny the Government's motion with prejudice.\nII.\n\nARGUMENT\nA.\n\nThe Motion is Procedurally Defective Because the Government Failed to File\na Proposed Pleading in Intervention in Compliance With Rule 24(c)\n\nRule 24(c) requires that a motion to intervene \"must state the grounds for intervention\nand be accompanied by a pleading that sets out the claim or defense for which intervention is\nsought.\" V.I..R.Civ.P. 24(c) (emphasis added).; This identical provision under the federal rules is\nintended to ensure that parties receive advance notice of the claims that an intervenor plans to set\nforth if intervention is permitted. SEC v. Investors Sec. Leasing Corp., 610 F.2d 175, 178 (3d\nCir. 1979).\n3 The Reporter's Note to the rule restates the mandatory nature of this requirement. See\nReporter's Note to V.I.R.Civ.P. 24 (\"Plhe intervention application must attach a copy of the\npleading which the\n... [truncated, 2060 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/2 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=2]", "char_count": 2060}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "CIVIL CASE NO.: ST-20-CV-155\nPage 4 of 20\nThe Court may deny a motion to intervene that is not accompanied by a proposed\npleading in intervention. See, e.g., id. at 178 (\"Because the requirements of [R]ule 24(c) were not\ncomplied with, the owners were not proper parties in the district court.\"); JLS Equities LLC v.\nRiver Funding, LLC, 2020 WL 1503403, at *1-2 (D.N.J. Jan. 2, 2020) (\"Affinity's motion to\nintervene is [denied without prejudice] to refiling with a proposed pleading setting forth the\nclaim or defense for which intervention is sought\"); Aetna Inc. v. Insys Therapeutics, Inc., 330\nF.R.D. 427, 431-32 (E.D. Pa. 2019); Montanez v. Beard, No. 04-2569, 2015 WL 2451770, at *4\n(M.D. Pa. May 21, 2015); Surety Admen, Inc. v. Samara, No. 04-5177, 2006 WL 891430, at *3\n(E.D. Pa. June 20, 2006); Sch. Dist. of Phila. v. Pa. Milk Mktg. Bd., 160 F.R.D. 66, 67 (E.D. Pa.\n1995); Hecker v. Wierzba Insulation LLC, No. 12-CV-682-WMC, 2013 WL 12234527, at *I\n(W.D. Wis. Mar. 20, 2013) (\"Since Rural Mutual failed to file a proposed pleading with its\nmotion, the court will deny Rural Mutual's motion to intervene without prejudice to refiling.\");\nKubiak v. Meltzer, 2013 WL 1114203, at *2 (N.D. 111. Mar. 15, 2013) (\"Because Mr. Leventhal\nfails to attach a proposed pleading, his motion to intervene is denied.\"); State Farm Mut. Auto.\nIns. Co. v. Tara Follese, Charles Case, 2010 WL 11646738, at *2 (D. Minn. May 7, 2010).\nHere, the Government's failure to provide its proposed complaint in intervention requires\nthe Court to deny its motion. As further explained below, this is no harmless error. The\nGovernment's Motion to Intervene itself does not adequately provide notice to Plaintiff of the\nprecise nature of its claims. Without a proposed pleading, Plaintiff cannot discern whether the\nGovernment has a \"sufficient interest in the litigation\" that \"may be affected or impaired, as a\npractical matter by the disposition of the action\" as required for intervention under Rule 24(a),\nand cann\n... [truncated, 2099 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/3 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=3]", "char_count": 2099}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "CIVIL CASE NO.: ST-20-CV-155\nPage 5 of 20\naction a common question or law or fact\" as required for permissive intervention under Rule\n24(b)( I )(B). Specifically, it is not clear to Plaintiff how the Government's purported interests\nwould be integrated into this litigation, how it proposes to \"ensure that the Epstein Estate's assets\nare not wrongfully dissipated,\" how it proposes to advance its so-called \"investigatory interests\"\nin the context of this civil case, or what ultimate relief it purports to seek from this Court. Since\nthe Government has not sufficiently provided notice to the existing parties of the basis and nature\nof its claims in this Court, its motion to intervene must be denied.4\nB.\n\nThe Government Fails to Satisfy Rule 24's Requirements for Intenention of\nRight\ni.\n\nThe Government cannot demonstrate a cognizable interest that would\nbe impaired absent its intervention as required by Rule 24(a)(2)\n\nThe Government did not file a proposed pleading in intervention under Rule 24(c)\nbecause it cannot — it has no protectable interest in this case. Rule 24(a) requires the \"claim or\ndefense\" to relate to an interest \"relating to the property or transaction that is the subject of the\naction\" and that it \"is so situated that disposing of the action may as a practical matter impair or\nimpede [the Government's] ability to protect its interest.\" V.I.R.Civ.P. 24(a)(2). The\nGovernment here suggests that intervention \"will allow [it] both to ensure its interest in\npreventing the dissipation of the Epstein Estate's assets and to enforce its subpoena and pursue\npotential and as appropriate independent claims against Maxwell.\" GVI Mm. at 18 (emphasis\n4\n\nShould this Court require the Government to comply with Rule 24(c) to file a proposed\ncomplaint in intervention, Plaintiff asks that she be afforded a further opportunity to address the\nGovernment's Motion to Intervene after reviewing the proposed pleading, and hereby reserves\nthe right to do so. As stated herein, Plaint\n... [truncated, 2188 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/4 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=4]", "char_count": 2188}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "CIVIL CASE NO.: ST-20-CV-155\nPage 6 of 20\nadded). The Government thus concedes that any potential \"claims\" it may have at this point are\npurely speculative. In short, the Government effectively concedes it has no protectable interest\nwithin the meaning of Rule 24(a)(2) by failing to proffer a proposed pleading as required by Rule\n24(c).\nNevertheless, in its brief, the Government vaguely identifies two distinct \"interests\" that\nform the basis of its Motion to Intervene:\nFirst, the Government suggests that its \"primary interest for intervention is to\nensure that the Epstein Estate's assets are not wrongfully dissipated by\nMaxwell's suspect claims for indemnification and 'advancement' of legal\nexpenses, and instead are preserved to satisfy the CICO judgment, which\nseeks forfeiture, divestiture, disgorgement, and payment of maximum civil\npenalties and damages by the Epstein Estate.\" GVI Mtn. at 2.\nSecond the Government asks this Court to compel Plaintiff's compliance with\ncertain criminal CICO subpoenas and otherwise aid in its criminal\ninvestigation of Plaintiff so that it can \"pursue potential and as appropriate\nindependent claims against [Plaintiff].\" GVI Mtn. at 3; 18.\nNeither of these interests justifies intervention.\na.\n\nThe Government's contingent claim to the Estate's assets is not\na sufficient interest for intervention\n\nFirst, the Government's contingent claim to the Epstein Estate's assets is not a sufficient\ninterest for intervention.5 The Government lays claim to these assets in its recently filed civil\n\nAgain, it is unclear how the Government proposes to vindicate this interest in the\ncontext of this litigation since it has not filed a proposed pleading in intervention.\n\nEFTA02822208\n\n", "char_count": 1723}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "CIVIL CASE NO.: ST-20-CV-155\nPage 7 of 20\nforfeiture action in the Virgin Islands against Defendants herein—the Estate and the Trustees—\nunder the Criminally Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (CICO), 14 V.I.C. §§ 601 et seq.\nThe parties to that action are not at issue as no answer has yet been filed by the defendants.6 The\nGovernment thus merely has a claim that is contingent upon its success in a separate action.\n\"[C]ourts in this circuit that have been confronted with the issue have consistently held that\nintervention pursuant to Rule 24(aX2) is inappropriate where the proposed intervenor's interest is\ncontingent upon prevailing on a tort claim in a separate action.\" Gen. Star Indem. Co. v. Virgin\nIs. Port Auth, 224 F.R.D. 372, 375-376 (D.V.I. 2004) (\"Proposed Intervenors cannot deny that\nany interest they have or may have in this matter is purely contingent upon a favorable judgment\nin their underlying suit . . . . The Court finds that such a contingent interest is insufficient to\nsustain intervention of right\"); Mountain Top Condo. Ass'n v. Dave Stabbert\n\nBuilder,\n\nInc., 72 F.3d 361, 366 (3d Cir. 1995) (citations omitted) (\"In general, a mere economic interest in\nthe outcome of the litigation is insufficient to support a motion to intervene.\")\nCiting two cases, the Government claims that \"numerous\" courts have held that \"a tort\nclaimant has a sufficiently developed interest to intervene as of right in a coverage-related action\ninvolving the tort defendant.\" GVI Mm. at 10-11 (citing Teague v. Bakker, 931 F.2d 249 (4th\nCir. 1991);\n\nv. Fireman's Fund Ins. Co., 2011 WL 3241452, at *1 (D. Md. July 28,\n\n2011)). However, neither of the cases that the Government cites hails from this jurisdiction.\nAnd, needless to say, neither case involves a government entity proposing to intervene in a civil\n\n6 The Government's operative pleading in the civil forfeiture action is attached as Exhibit\nA to the Motion to Intervene. The Estate and Trustees moved to dismiss this ple\n... [truncated, 2022 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/6 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=6]", "char_count": 2022}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "CIVIL CASE NO.: ST-20-CV-155\nPage 8 of 20\naction between private parties in order to investigate a potential target for CICO liability and to\nsecure its position in an unrelated CICO action.7\nEven assuming that cases involving intervention by individual claimants in coveragerelated matters are sufficiently analogous to the novel circumstances here, the Government's\nargument still fails. The Government conspicuously ignores cases from this jurisdiction that are\ndirectly on point. In General Star Indemnity Co. v. Virgin Islands Port Authority, 224 F.R.D. 372\n(D.V.I. 2004), the Virgin Islands District Court held that an interest that is contingent upon a\nfavorable judgment in an underlying suit \"is insufficient to sustain intervention of right\" under\nthe federal equivalent to Rule 24:\nProposed Intervenors' only interest in the matter at bar is to ensure\nthat VIPA has sufficient resources to satisfy any judgment\nProposed Intervenors may be able to obtain in the underlying suit\nagainst VIPA. Accordingly, the Court finds that Proposed\nIntervenors have asserted a purely economic interest.\n\n7 The Government suggests in its Motion to Intervene that its civil forfeiture action\nagainst the Estate is designed to \"protect the rights of victims,\" casting itself as akin to a \"tort\nclaimant\" and the Estate as an \"insurer,\" the Government did not file its CICO complaint against\nthe Estate on behalf of any victims. GVI Mtn. 10-11. The operative pleading in that action\nexpressly states at Paragraph 39 that:\n\nThe Attorney General brings this action to seek all remedies\navailable to the Government of the Virgin Islands in enforcing its\nlaws and protecting the public interest and public safety. These\nclaims are distinct from, and are not intended to supplant the\nclaims of victims who were unconscionably harmed by Jeffrey\nEpstein and his associates.\nMoreover, the alleged victims of Jeffrey Epstein already have a perfectly adequate mechanism in\nplace to protect their interests vis-a-vis th\n... [truncated, 2203 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/7 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=7]", "char_count": 2203}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "CIVIL CASE NO.: ST-20-CV-155\nPage 9 of 20\nId., at 376. The General Star Court found that \"courts in this circuit that have been confronted\nwith the issue `have consistently held that intervention pursuant to Rule 24(a)(2) is inappropriate\nwhere the proposed intervenor's interest is contingent upon prevailing on a tort claim in a\nseparate action.'\" Id. (citing Continental Casualty Co. v. SSM Group, Inc., 1995 WL 422780 at\n*3 (E.D.Pa. July 13, 1995) and Liberty Mutual Ins. Co. v. Pacific Indemnity Co., 76 F.R.D. 656,\n658-59 (W.D.Pa.1977)).\nThe Government also conveniently ignores precedent from the Third Circuit Court of\nAppeals reaching the same conclusion. For example, in Liberty Mut. Ins. Co. v. Treesdale, Inc.,\n419 F.3d 216 (3d Cir. 2005), the Third Circuit concluded that a contingent interest in insurance\nproceeds is too remote and speculative to satisfy the interest requirement under the federal\nequivalent to Rule 24. The Treesdale Court noted that \"the mere fact that a lawsuit may impede\na third party's ability to recover in a separate suit does not ordinarily give the third party a right\nto intervene.\" Id., at 223. It ultimately found that\nAppellants [i.e., the tort plaintiffs] have no contractual relationship\nwith either Liberty Mutual [i.e., the insurer] or PMP [Le., the\ninsured tort defendant], and the declaratory judgment action\nbetween Liberty Mutual and PMP will not have an immediate,\nadverse effect on them. Rather, the impact is collateral and (given\nthe dispute about PMP's solvency) speculative. At most, the\ndeclaratory judgment action may impact their ability to collect any\njudgment obtained in their personal injury actions. However, that\nis not enough to support intervention of right under Mountain Top.\nId., at 225 (citing Mountain Top, supra, 72 F.3d 361).\nIn 2010, the Virgin Islands District Court again rejected a tort claimant's attempt to\nintervene in a coverage action between the insured and its insurer. See ACE Am. Ins. Co. v.\nAxiom Constr. & D\n... [truncated, 2080 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/8 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=8]", "char_count": 2080}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "CIVIL CASE NO.: ST-20-CV-155\nPage 10 of 20\nApplying Treesdale, the ACE Court denied the motion to intervene on the grounds that the\nproposed intervenor's interest was \"a mere economic interest in the proceeds of Axiom's policy\nwith ACE, and not a property interest or a legally protectable interest\" Id.\nThe holdings in General Star, Treesdale, and ACE are consistent with decisions in\nsimilar cases across the country finding generally that an intervenor must demonstrate more than\n\"a mere provable claim\" in order to be entitled to intervention of right, see Independent\nPetrochemical Corp. v. Aetna Casualty & Sur. Co., 105 F.R.D. 106, 110 (D.D.C.1985), and\nspecifically that a contingent interest in insurance proceeds is too remote and speculative to\njustify intervention in a coverage action under Rule 24(a). See In re HealthSouth Corp. Ins.\nlitigation, 219 F.R.D. 688 (N.D.Ala. 2004); Ace American Ins. Co. v. Paradise Divers, Inc., 216\nF.R.D. 537 (S.D.Fla. 2003); Redland Ins. Co. v. Chillingsworth Venture, Ltd., 171 F.R.D. 206\n(N.D.Ohio 1997).\nSecond, the Government's purported interest in the Estate would not be affected or\nimpaired as a practical matter by the disposition of this lawsuit. That is because the Government\non January 30, 2020 filed certain Criminal Activity Liens on Estate assets pursuant to 14 V.I.C. §\n610. These liens cover all real and personal property located in the Virgin Islands in the name\nor under the signatory authority of the Estate. See Criminal Activity Liens bearing document\nnumbers 2020000423 and 2020000424, copies of which are collectively attached hereto as\nExhibit \"1.\" These Criminal Activity Liens provide that\nAny trustee, executor, person or institution who moves,\ntransfers or conveys title to personal or real property upon\nwhich a Criminal Activity Lien Notice has been filed in the\niudicial subdivision in which the personal or real property is\nlocated, and who transfers or conveys such property while\n\nEFTA02822212\n\n", "char_count": 1980}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "CIVIL CASE NO.: ST-20-CV-155\nPage 11 of 20\nhaving actual notice of the Criminal Activity Lien Notice, shall\nbe liable to the Attorney General in accordance with Title 14\nV.I.C. § 610(1)(1)(2) or (3).\n(Emphasis in original.) The Government's position is that these Criminal Activity Liens are\neffective for up to twelve years, or until January 23, 2032, if properly renewed, that only the\nAttorney General can release these liens, that this Court may not vacate them, and that the liens\ncover all assets and property used in connection with the alleged unlawful activity.In the\nGovernment's view, that apparently includes all of the Estate's assets and property. See\nGovernment's Opposition to Motion to Vacate Criminal Activity Lien Notices, filed on June 11,\n2020 in the Government's CICO action against the Estate, et al., a copy of which is attached\nhereto as Exhibit \"2.\" The Motion to Intervene self-servingly seeks to downplay the scope of\nthese liens, asserting vaguely in a one sentence footnote that the Court should ignore them for the\npurpose of deciding its Motion to Intervene due to \"limitations on the scope of pretrial restraints\"\nthat the Government does not explain. GVI Mtn. at 12 n. 3. It is impossible to credit this\nassertion in light of the government's detailed defense of the breadth of these liens in its CICO\naction against the Estate.\nBy their own terms, the Criminal Activity Liens subject the Executors to liability under\n14 V.I.C. § 610 for any transfer or conveyance of Estate property. Again, the Government has\nalready availed itself of sweeping, statutory powers designed to secure its interests in the Estate\nand accomplish everything that it purports to do by intervening in this case.\nIn sum, the Government's purely contingent interest of a possible favorable judgment in\nanother suit is not a significant interest authorizing intervention. Even assuming that it was. there\n\nEFTA02822213\n\n", "char_count": 1928}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "CIVIL CASE NO.: ST-20-CV-155\nPage 12 of 20\nis no chance it would be impaired as a practical matter. Accordingly, for this reason, the\nGovernment's Motion to Intervene should be denied.8\nb.\n\nThe Government's interest in advancing its criminal\ninvestigation of Plaintiff through this civil proceeding is\nimproper and not a sufficient interest for intervention\n\nThe Government's so-called \"investigatory interest against [Plaintiff]\" is not an\nappropriate or sufficient interest to support intervention here. By the Government's own\nadmission, it seeks to intervene here to supplement its broad investigatory powers under the\nVirgin Islands CICO statute, 14 V.I.C. § 600, et seq., and coopt this Court to help enforce its\n\n8 By inserting itself in this action, the Government also seeks to circumvent issues of\n\npersonal jurisdiction as to any claim it may seek to assert against Plaintiff—a non-resident of the\nVirgin Islands—relating to any recovery from the Estate. It is well-established that a litigant's\nconsent to jurisdiction in one case does not constitute consent to personal jurisdiction in that\nforum ad infinitum. See, e.g., Klinghoffer v. S.N.C. Achille Lauro Ed Altri-Gestione Motonave\nAchille Lauro in Amministrazione Straordinaria, 937 F.2d 44, 50 n.5 (2d Cir. 1991) (\"A party's\nconsent to jurisdiction in one case, however, extends to that case alone. It in no way opens that\nparty up to other lawsuits in the same jurisdiction in which consent was given, where the party\ndoes not consent and no other jurisdictional basis is available.\"); Funai Elec. Co. v. Personalized\nMedia Cornmc'ns, LLC, 2016 WL 370708, at *2-3 (D. Del. Jan. 29, 2016) (defendant that filed\ntwo earlier patent suits in Delaware against unrelated defendants did not consent to jurisdiction\nin Delaware); Fesniak v. Equifax Mortgage Servs. LLC, 2015 WL 2412119, at *6 (D. N.J. May\n21, 2015) (\"Plaintiff cites no authority to support the theory that Credit Plus' participation in a\nprior lawsuit in this forum conce\n... [truncated, 3027 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/11 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=11]", "char_count": 3027}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "CIVIL CASE NO.: ST-20-CV-155\nPage 13 of 20\ncriminal subpoenas in order to establish a predicate for criminal charges against Plaintiff.9 This\ninvestigation is unrelated to any matter at issue in this civil proceeding. Not surprisingly, the\nGovernment cites no case supporting this basis for intervention, nor could it. Needless to say, the\nGovernment's extraordinary proposition is improper and not a sufficient interest for intervention.\n\"Intervention generally is not appropriate where the applicant can protect its interests\nand/or recover on its claim through some other means.\"\n526 (5th Cir. 1994). In\n\nv. Allstate Ins. Co., 15 F.3d 506,\n\n, a third party moved to intervene to gain access to documents and\n\ntestimony to use those materials in its own action against the same defendant. Id. at 525-26. The\ncourt denied the motion to intervene \"as a matter of law,\" reasoning that the movant had \"no\nrights or claims that [it] wanted the district court to adjudicate.\" Id. A movant-in-intervention\nthat is in collateral litigation with the same defendant can protect any interest it has by filing\ndiscovery requests in its own case. Id. See also Head v. Jellico Housing Auth., 870 F.2d 1117,\n1124-25 (6th Cir. 1989) (affirming denial of intervention where intervenor had substantially\nsimilar complaint pending elsewhere and therefore had \"availed herself of other adequate means\nof asserting her rights\").\nHere, the Government seeks to take the unprecedented step of intervening in this case for\nthe purpose of aiding its criminal investigation of Plaintiff \"in anticipation of a potential action\nagainst her.\" GVI Mtn. at 12. The Government, however, has a number of \"other means\"\navailable to protect its interests, even more so than the private litigants in\n\nand Head. The\n\nGovernment, as prosecutor, has a host of investigatory tools at its disposal to obtain any\n\n9 The Government states that it is \"investigating Maxwell's participation in Epstein's\ncriminal sex-trafficking and sexual abus\n... [truncated, 2150 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/12 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=12]", "char_count": 2150}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "CIVIL CASE NO.: ST-20-CV-155\nPage 14 of 20\ninformation it deems necessary for a potential prosecution, including those available under the\nVirgin Islands CICO statute. In fact, the Government even admits to using them, stating that it\nhas already attempted service of CICO Subpoenas to Plaintiff for certain materials. GVI Mtn. at\n4-5. Contrary to the Government's repeated suggestion, Plaintiff did not \"evade service\" of the\nCICO Subpoenas. Rather, these were served to persons who did not have authority to accept\nthem. In any case, the Government does not explain why it has not made efforts to serve Plaintiff\nnow that it presumably knows the jurisdiction where she is presently located.10\nDespite complaining that Plaintiff has not responded to the unserved CICO Subpoenas,\nthe Government ignores the availability of statutory remedies to address this issue. Specifically,\nthe CICO statute provides that \"the Attorney General may petition the court of the judicial\nsubdivision where the witness resides for an order requiring the witness to attend and to testify\nor to produce the documentary material.\" 14 V.I.C. § 6I2(k) (emphasis added). The Government\nthus has the power to initiate an original action to address issues of compliance with its CICO\nSubpoenas, and therefore need not resort to shoehorning this issue into this unrelated civil action.\nNotably, the Virgin Islands CICO statute requires that the Government bring an action to\ncompel compliance with its process in the judicial subdivision where the witness resides. The\nGovernment would ask the Court here (in this unrelated civil action between private parties) to\nignore this statute and the protections it affords a non-resident accused, like Plaintiff. The\nGovernment's deliberate attempt to exercise the powers given to it under the CICO statute, while\n\n10 Instead, the Government spends three full pages explaining how it delivered the CICO\nSubpoenas to persons who did not have authority to accept them. See GVI Mtn. at 4\n... [truncated, 2281 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/13 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=13]", "char_count": 2281}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "CIVIL CASE NO.: ST-20-CV-155\nPage 15 of 20\nseeking to avoid the statutory limitations on those powers, sets an ominous precedent and should\nnot be lightly condoned.\nThere is simply no support for the Government's remarkable request. In fact, courts\ntypically only allow government intervention in civil cases for the opposite purpose — so the\ngovernment can seek a stay of discovery in order to prevent discovery in the civil case from\nbeing used to circumvent the more limited scope of discovery in a parallel criminal matter. See,\ne.g., Sec. & Exch. Commit v. Fishoff, 2016 WL 1262508, at *2 (D.N.J. Mar. 31, 2016) (citing\ncases). Even then, courts require that the issues in the criminal and civil cases \"substantialnyi\noverlap\" before entering a stay. Id. Here, on the other hand, the Government seeks an \"end run\"\naround the criminal process that already exists so it can use the civil process as one more tool\nagainst Plaintiff.\nIn sum, the Government's unprecedented request to intervene in this case to advance its\nso-called \"investigatory interest\" must be denied because it is patently improper and because the\nGovernment has a number of other tools at its disposal to obtain any information it believes is\nnecessary. This Court should require the Government to employ the tools available to it as\ninvestigator and prosecutor and deny its attempt to bypass judicial scrutiny in those cases to\nwhich it is already a party.\nThe Government's claimed interest in the outcome of this case is\nadequately protected by Estate within the meaning of Rule 24(a)\nThe Government is not entitled to intervene under Rule 24(a) for the additional reason\nthat \"existing parties adequately represent [the Government's] interest.\" V.I.R.Civ.P. 24(a)(2).\nRule 24(a) does not require that Defendants here have \"identical\" interests to a would-be\n\nEFTA02822217\n\n", "char_count": 1850}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "CIVIL CASE NO.: ST-20-CV-155\nPage 16 of 20\nintervenor. The issue is whether they have \"the same ultimate objective.\" Virginia v.\nWestinghouse Elec. Corp., 542 F.2d 214, 216 (4th Cir. 1976). For example, \"if there is a party\ncharged by law with representing [a would-be intervenor's] interest, then a compelling showing\nshould be required to demonstrate why this representation is not adequate.\" Mountain Top, 72\nF.3d at 368-69 (emphasis added) (citing 7C =,\n\n& Kane, Federal Practice &\n\nProcedure § 1908, at 318-19).\nHere, as the Government concedes, the Trustees have \"an interest in preserving Ithe\nEstate's] funds against [Plaintiff's] claim for indemnification.\" GVI Mm. at 15. In fact, the\nTrustees are \"charged by law\" to \"faithfully and diligently perform the duties of [their] trust\" at\nthe risk of their removal. 15 V.I.C. § 240. Under Virgin Islands law, the Executors owe fiduciary\nduties to all who may have a beneficial interest in the estate. In re Estate ofCummings, 1985 WL\n1177815, at *5 (Ten. V.I. Nov. 26, 1985). Further, \"[t]he Virgin Islands Probate Code prescribes\nstringent ethical standards of a person holding the trust office of executor or administrator.\"\nEstate of Christensen, 1998 WL 242722, at *3 (Ten. V.I. Mar. 25, 1998). Finally, as noted\nabove, the Government's Criminal Activity Liens subject the Executors to liability under 14\nV.I.C. § 610 for any transfer or conveyance of Estate property. To the extent that the\nGovernment is concerned with the dissipation of the Estate's assets, the Trustees adequately\nrepresent the Government's interest here.\nThe Government's suggestions that Plaintiff and Defendants \"are not truly adversarial\"\nare unsupported innuendos. The Government asserts that Plaintiff's \"evident involvement in\nEpstein's alleged criminal conduct makes her a critical fact witness with whom the Estate is very\nlikely to try to cooperate.\" Such a statement is not only improper—Plaintiff is innocent until\n\nEFTA02822218\n\n", "char_count": 1973}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "CIVIL CASE NO.: ST-20-CV-155\nPage 17 of 20\nproven guilty and has maintained her innocence from the beginning—but provides no coherent\nexplanation for why Plaintiff and Defendants are somehow not \"adversarial.\" As explained\nabove, Defendants have every incentive to defend Plaintiff's claim vigorously. Indeed,\nDefendants have moved to dismiss Plaintiff's Complaint in this action. Defendants further\napparently take no position as to the instant Motion to Intervene. Putting aside the Government's\npure speculation, there is no actual support for the notion that the Executors would fail to\n\"faithfully and diligently perform the duties of [their] trust\" as required by Virgin Islands law.\nIn sum, any interest the Government arguably has is coextensive with Defendants and is\nthus adequately represented by Defendants.\nC.\n\nThe Government Fails to Satisfy Rule 24's Requirements for Permissive\nIntervention\ni.\n\nThe Government cannot articulate a \"claim or defense\" required for\npermissive intervention\n\nThe Government also fails to satisfy the standards for permissive intervention under Rule\n24(b). Rule 24(b)(1)(B) permits intervention, in a court's discretion, where the proposed\nintervenor has a \"claim or defense\" that shares \"a common question of law or fact\" with the main\naction. V.I.R.Civ.P. 24(b)(1)(B). Here, the Government's CICO complaint against the Estate and\nits Trustees and criminal CICO investigation of Plaintiff do not share common questions of law\nor fact with this indemnification action. Indeed, the matters could not be more distinct. The\nGovernment's stated intent for intervention is to \"investigat[e] [Plaintiff's] [alleged] participation\nin the criminal sex-trafficking and sexual abuse conduct of the Epstein Enterprise.\"at GVI Mtn.\n\nIt Plaintiff categorically denies all allegations of personal conduct in the Motion to\nIntervene.\n\nEFTA02822219\n\n", "char_count": 1877}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "CIVIL CASE NO.: ST-20-CV-155\nPage 18 of 20\nat 4. This inquiry will involve a completely different set of witnesses, different operative facts,\ndifferent procedural rules, and different (novel) legal issues, than the instant action, which does\nnot involve \"conduct of the Epstein Enterprise\" and is governed by principles of contract law.\nThere is no question of law or fact that these matters would share.12\nii.\n\nThe Government will cause undue delay and prejudice if it is allowed\nto intervene under Rule 24(b)\n\nRule 24(b) is also clear that the Court \"must\" consider whether the proposed intervention\n\"will unduly delay or prejudice the adjudication of the original parties' rights.\" V.I.R.Civ.P.\n24(6)(3).13 Unwittingly, the Government's Motion to Intervene demonstrates why its\nintervention would cause \"undu[e] delay and prejudice\" to Plaintiff, if not completely derail this\ncase. Throughout its motion, the Government proposes to inject legal issues that diverge\nsubstantially from those involved in this indemnification action. These would include novel,\ncomplex issues of first impression concerning the Government's intent to conduct a criminal\ninvestigation of Plaintiff within the context of this civil action. These issues would assuredly and\n\n12 Notably, Rule 24 also expressly contemplates intervention by government entities. The\n\nrule allows the Government to officially intervene on behalf of the public interest in any case\nwhere a party's claim or defense is based on:\n(A)\n(B)\n\na statute or executive order administered by the officer,\nemployee or governmental body, agency or board; or\nany regulation, order, requirement, or agreement issued or\nmade under a statute or executive order.\n\nV.I.R.Civ.P. 24(b)(2). The Government does not even mention this rule, nor can there be any\nargument that it applies here.\n13 See also 7C Charles Alan =,\n\nArthur R.\n, & Mary ■\nKane, Federal\nPractice and Procedure § 1911 (citing Chadima v. Nat'l Fid. Life Ins. Co., 848 F. Supp. 1418,\n1423 (D.\n... [truncated, 2029 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/17 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=17]", "char_count": 2029}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "CIVIL CASE NO.: ST-20-CV-155\nPage 19 of 20\nunnecessarily clog this Court's docket. This indemnification action will take longer and cost\nmore if the parties are required to litigate such unrelated, collateral issues. The Government's\nMotion to Intervene shows exactly why its participation would cause the very delay and\nprejudice that Rule 24(b) prohibits.\n\"Additional parties always take additional time that may result in delay and that thus may\nsupport the denial of intervention.\" 7C Charles Alan In\n\nArthur R.\n\n& Mary\n\nKane, Federal Practice and Procedure § 1913, at p. 481. That fact requires this Court to consider\nwhether the Government's intervention would add value to the litigation. See 6 James Wm.\nMoore, Moores Federal Practice § 24.10[2][b] (1998). For the reasons discussed above, the\nGovernment's intervention would not. Because anything that the Government's wants to do can\nbe adequately done in the other proceedings in which it is involved and by using the enormous\nstatutory powers at its disposal that are not available to private civil litigants, its Motion to\nIntervene should be denied.\nHI.\n\nCONCLUSION\nFor the reasons set forth above, the Government's motion is procedurally defective and\n\nits grounds for relief are meritless. The Government simply has not met its burden of showing\nthat it has standing to assert any \"claim or defense,\" much less one that is appropriate in the\ncontext of this proceeding. The Government's intervention would unduly delay this case and\nprejudice Plaintiff. Its Motion to Intervene therefore should be denied.\n\nEFTA02822221\n\n", "char_count": 1587}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "CIVIL CASE NO.: ST-20-CV-155\nPage 20 of 20\nDated: September 8, 2020\n\nQUINTAIROS, PRIETO,\n\n& BOYER, P.A.\n\nAttorneysfor Plaintiff\n9300 S. Dadeland Blvd., 4th Floor\nMiami, FL 33156\nT: (340) 693-0230\nF: (340) 693-0300\n\nBy:\n\nIs/ Kyle R. Waldner\nKyle R. Waldner, Esq.\nkwaldner@qpwblaw.com\nV.I. Bar No.: 1038\n\nCERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\nI HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing, which complies with\nthe word and page requirements of V.I.R.Civ.P. 6-1(e), was served via email and U.S. Mail this\n8th day of September, 2020 to:\nii•Croblin, Esq.\nKELLERHALS\nKROBLIN PLLC\nPalms Professional Building\n9053 Estate IME, Suite 101\nSt.\n, V.I. 00802\nckroblin@kellfer.com\nAriel M. =,\nEsq. (AAG)\nVIRGIN ISLANDS DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE\nOffice of the Attorney General\n34-38 Kronprindsens Gade\nSt.\nU.S. Virgin Islands 00802\n'.vi. ov\n/s/ Kyle R. Waldner\nKyle R. Waldner, Esq.\nkwaldner@ciowblaw.com\nV.I. Bar No.: 1038\n\nEFTA02822222\n\n", "char_count": 923}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Doc 4* 2020000423\nN Pages 3\n01/30/2020 10:40 Ni\n/ ST 30114\nOfficial Records of ST\nERICA DOVER M.P.A., REC0RIER OF ((HG\nFees 10.00\n\nVIRGIN ISLANDS DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE\nOFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL\n34.38 Eronprindsens Cade\nGERS Complex, 2 Floor\nSc.\nv.i. 00802\n(340) 774-5666 En: (340) 776-3494\n\n#213 Estate La Rein.\nRR I Roe 6151, KIngshill\nSt. Croix, V.I. 00850\n(310)773.0295 Fax: (340) 773-1425\n\nCRIMINAL ACTIVITY LIEN NOTICE\nTitle 14 V.I.C. §610\nCRIMINALLY INFLUENCED AND CORRUPT ORGANIZATIONS ACT\n\nTO:\n\nMs. Erica Dover\nDirector, Recorder of Deeds\nOffice of the Lieutenant Governor\n5049 Kongens Gade\nSt.\n, VI 00802\n\nRE:\n\nParcel Number 109803010100, consisting of 3.1 million square feet of land\n(Commonly known as \"Little St. James\")\n\nLET IT BE KNOWN THAT the Attorney General of the United States Virgin\nIslands hereby files a Criminal Activity Lien Notice pursuant to Chapter 30, Title 14 V.I.C. § 610,\nbased on a civil proceeding, Case No. ST-2020-CV-14, having been instituted by the Government\nof the United States Virgin Islands under Chapter 30 of the Virgin Islands Code, namely, the\n\n8\n\nCriminally Influenced and Corrupt Otgankations Act (C/CO), is pending in the Superior Court of\nthe Virgin Islands naming the ESTATE OF JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN; THE 1953 TRUST;\n\nC4\n\nPLAN D, LLC; GREAT ST. JIM, LLC; NAUTILUS, INC.; HYPERION AIR, LLC.; AND\nPOPLAR, INC. as defendants.\n\nEXHIBIT \"1\"\n01130/202010:40 AM\n\n2020000423\n\nPage 1 of 3\n\nEFTA02822223\n\n", "char_count": 1449}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Attorney General\nCriminal Activity Licn - ST-2020-CV-I4.\nOffice of the Lt. Governor Recorder of Deeds\nJanuary 29. 2020\nPage 2\n\nIn conformity with Title 14 V.I.C. §610(e), from the time of the filing of this Criminal\nActivity Lien Notice, a Criminal Activity Lien in favor of the Government of the United States\nVirgin Islands is created on the following:\n\n1.\n\nAny and personal or real property located in the Territory of the Virgin Islands in the name\nof, or under the signatory authority of the ESTATE OF JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN;\nJEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, THE 1953 TRUST; PLAN D, LLC; GREAT ST. JIM, LLC;\nNAUTILUS, INC.; HYPERION AIR, LLC.; AND POPLAR, INC.\n\n2.\n\nAny beneficial Interest of the ESTATE OF JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN; JEFFREY E.\nEPSTEIN; THE 1953 TRUST; PLAN D, LLC; GREAT ST. JIM, LLC; NAUTILUS,\nINC.; HYPERION AIR, LLC.; AND POPLAR, INC. in any personal or real property\nlocated in the Territory of the Virgin Islands.\n\n3.\n\nAny and all bank accounts, certificates of deposits and any other accounts in the name of,\nor under the signatory authority of the ESTATE OF JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN; JEFFREY\nEPSTEIN; THE 1953 TRUST; PLAN D, LLC; GREAT ST. JIM, LLC; NAUTILUS,\n\nO\n\nn\n\nINC.; HYPERION AIR, LLC.; AND POPLAR, INC.\n\nra\n\nO\n\nPursuant to Title 14 V.I.C. § 610(a), the Director of the Record of Deeds, of the Office\nO\nof the Lieutenant Governor shall, upon the presentation of a Criminal Activity Lien Notice,\n\nO\n\nimmediately record it in the official records.\n\n01/30/2020 10:40 AM\n\n2020000423\n\nPage 2 of 3\n\nEFTA02822224\n\n", "char_count": 1513}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Attorney General\nCriminal Activity Lien - ST-2020-CV-14.\nOffice of the Li. Governor - Recorder of Deeds\nJanuary 29, 2020\nPage 3\nAny trustee, executor, person or institution who moves, transfers or conveys title to\npersonal or real property upon which a Criminal Activity Lien Notice has been filed in the\njudicial subdivision in which the personal or real property is located, and who transfers or\nconveys such property while having actual notice of the Criminal Activity Lien Notice, shall\nbe liable to the Attorney General in accordance with Title 14 V.LC.\n\n610(1)(1)(2) or (3).\n\nDENISE N.\nESQ.\nATTORNEY GENERAL\n\nDATED: January 02,, 2020\n\nBy:\n\nRIITIL\n\nAR I, 1.\nSQ.\nAssistant Attorney General\nVirgin Islands Department oflustice\n3438 Kronprindsens Gade\nGERS Building, 2nd Floor\nSt.\nV.I. 00802\n(340) 774-5666 Ext. 10101\n\nM,\n\n0\n\n(1\nN\nN\n\nSO\n\n.ts\nN\n\n0113012020 10:40 AM\n\n2020000423\n\nPage 3 of 3\n\nEFTA02822225\n\n", "char_count": 907}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Doc $4 2020000424\n0 Pages 3\n01/30/2020 10:40 AM\n/ ST JOIN\nOfficial Records of ST\nERICA DOVER M.P.A., RfOORDER OF DEEDS\nFees $0.00\n\nVIRGIN ISLANDS DEPARTNIENT OF JUSTICE\nOFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL\n8213 Estate La Rene\nRRI Box 6151. Kingshill\nSt. Croix, V.1.00850\n(340) 773-0295 Fax: (340) 773-1425\n\n34.38 KronprIndsens Gade\nGERS Complex, 2\" Floor\nV.I. 00802\nSt. M.\n(340) 774-5666 In: (340) 776-3494\n\nCRIMINAL ACTIVITY LIEN NOTICE\nTitle 14 V.I.C. §610\nCRIMINALLY INFLUENCED AND CORRUPT ORGANIZATIONS ACT\n\nTO:\n\nMs. Erica Dover\nDirector, Recorder of Deeds\nOffice of the Lieutenant Governor\n5049 Kongens Gade\nSt.\nVI 00802\n\nRE:\n\nParcel Number 109801010100, consisting of 3.5 million square feet of land\nParcel Number 109801010200, consisting of 450,000 square feet of land\nParcel Number 109801010300, consisting of 1.2 million square feet of land\n\n(Collectively known as \"Great St. James\")\n\nLET IT BE KNOWN THAT the Attorney General of the United States Virgin\nIslands hereby files a Criminal Activity Lien Notice pursuant to Chapter 30, Title 14 V.I.C. 610,\nbased on a civil proceeding, Case No. ST-2020-CV-I4, having been instituted by the Government\nof the United States Virgin Islands under Chapter 30 of the Virgin Islands Code, namely, the\nCriminally Influencedand Corrupt Organizations Act ICICOA is pending in the Superior Court of\nthe Virgin Islands naming the ESTATE OF JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN; THE 1953 TRUST;\nPLAN D, LLC; GREAT ST. JIM, LLC; NAUTILUS, INC.; HYPERION AIR, LLC.; AND\nPOPLAR, INC. as defendants.\n\n01/30/2020 10:40 AM\n\n2020000424\n\nPage 1 of 3\n\nEFTA02822226\n\n", "char_count": 1575}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Attorney General\nCriminal Activity Lien - ST-2020-O/-14.\nOffice of the Lt. Governor - Recorder of Deeds\nJanuary 29.2020\nPage 2\nIn conformity with Title 14 V.I.C. §610(e), from the time of the filing of this Criminal\nActivity Lien Notice, a Criminal Activity Lien in favor of the Government of the United States\nVirgin Islands is created on the following:\nAny and personal or real property located in the Territory of the Virgin Islands in the name\n\n1.\n\nof, or under the signatory authority of the ESTATE OF JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN;\nJEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, THE 1953 TRUST; PLAN D, LLC; GREAT ST. JIM, LLC;\nNAUTILUS, INC.; HYPERION AIR, LLC.; AND POPLAR, INC.\nAny beneficial Interest of the ESTATE OF JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN; JEFFREY E.\n\n2.\n\nEPSTEIN; THE 1953 TRUST; PLAN D, LLC; GREAT ST. JIM, LLC; NAUTILUS,\nINC.; HYPERION AIR, LLC.; AND POPLAR, INC. in any personal or real property\nlocated in the Territory of the Virgin Islands.\n3.\n\nAny and all bank accounts, certificates of deposits and any other accounts in the name of,\nor under the signatory authority of the ESTATE OF JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN; JEFFREY\nEPSTEIN; THE 1953 TRUST; PLAN D, LLC; GREAT ST. JIM, LLC; NAUTILUS,\nINC.; HYPERION AIR, LLC.; AND POPLAR, INC.\nPursuant to Title 14 V.1.C. § 610(a). the Director of the Record of Deeds, of the Office\n\nof the Lieutenant Governor shall, upon the presentation of a Criminal Activity Lien Notice,\nimmediately record it in the official records.\n\n01/30/2020 10:40 AM\n\n2020000424\n\nPage 2 of 3\n\nEFTA02822227\n\n", "char_count": 1492}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Attorney General\nCriminal Activity Lien - ST-2020-CV-14.\nOffice of the Lt. Governor Recorder of Deeds\nJanuary 29. 2020\nPage 3\nAny trustee, executor, person or institution who moves, transfers or conveys title to\npersonal or real property upon which a Criminal Activity Lien Notice has been filed in the\njudicial subdivision in which the personal or real property is located, and who transfers or\nconveys such property while having actual notice of the Criminal Activity Lien Notice, shall\nbe liable to the Attorney General in accordance with Title 14 V.I.C. § 610(11( I )(2) or (3).\n\nDENISE N.\nESQ.\nATTORNEY GENERAL\n\nDATED: January 025/ , 2020\n\nBy:\nKIEL 111. M1TH, ESQ.\nAssistant Attorney General\nVirgin Islands Department of Justice\n3438 Kronprindsens Gade\nGERS Building, 20 Floor\nSt. MI,\nV.I. 00802\n(340) 774-5666 Ext. 10101\n\n0\n\na\n\n8\na\n\naA\nA\n\n0113012020 10:40 AM\n\n2020000424\n\nPage 3 of 3\n\nEFTA02822228\n\n", "char_count": 905}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS\nDIVISION OF ST.\nAND ST. JOHN\n********************************\nGOVERNMENT OF THE UNITED STATES\nVIRGIN ISLANDS,\n\nCase No.: ST-20-CV-14\n\nPLAINTIFF,\nACTION FOR DAMAGES\nV.\nDARREN K. INDYKE, in his capacity as the\nEXECUTOR FOR THE ESTATE OF JEFFREY E.\nEPSTEIN and ADMINISTRATOR OF THE 1953\nTRUST; RICHARD D. KAHN, in his capacity as\nthe EXECUTOR FOR THE ESTATE OF JEFFREY\nE. EPSTEIN, and ADMINISTRATOR OF THE\n1953 TRUST; ESTATE OF JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN;\nTHE 1953 TRUST; PLAN D, LLC; GREAT ST.\nJIM, LLC; NAUTILUS, INC.; HYPERION AIR,\nLLC; POPLAR, Inc.; SOUTHERN TRUST\nCOMPANY, INC.; JOHN AND JANE DOES,\n\nJURY TRIAL DEMANDED\n\nDEFENDANTS.\n\nGOVERNMENT OF THE UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS' OPPOSITION\nTO MOTION TO VACATE CRIMINAL ACTIVITY LIEN NOTICES\nThe Government of the United States Virgin Islands (\"Government\") hereby responds in\nopposition to the motion filed March 17, 2020 by Defendants Darren K. Indyke and Richard D.\nKahn, Co-Executors of the Estate of Jeffrey E. Epstein (\"Epstein Estate\") and Co-Administrators\nof the 1953 Trust, to vacate the Government's Criminal Activity Lien Notices. The Government\nstates in opposition as follows.\n\nEXHIBIT \"2\"\nEFTA02822229\n\n", "char_count": 1208}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "INTRODUCTION\nOn January 15, 2020, the Government filed this action under the Criminally Influenced and\nCorrupt Organizations Act (\"CICO\"), 14 V.I.C. §§ 600 et seq. against the Epstein Estate and\nvarious Epstein-controlled entities. On February 5, 2020, the Government filed its Amended\nComplaint, adding, inter alia, Indyke and Kahn as Defendants in their capacities as Co-Executors\nof the Epstein Estate and Co-Administrators of the 1953 Trust.\nThe Government alleges that decedent Jeffrey E. Epstein engaged in a criminal sexual\ntrafficking enterprise in the Virgin Islands, wherein he used his vast wealth and property holdings\nand a deliberately opaque web of corporations and companies to transport young women and girls\nto his privately-owned islands where they were held captive and subject to severe and extensive\nsexual abuse. Epstein committed suicide in prison in August 2019 after he was indicted and\nincarcerated on federal charges of trafficking and sexually abusing girls as young as 14.\nDefendants Indyke and Kahn, in addition to being Co-Executors of the Epstein Estate, also are\nofficers in several of the companies Epstein used in his criminal enterprise.\nPursuant to its authority under 14 V.I.C. § 610, the Government filed Criminal Activity\nLien Notices establishing liens in its favor on Epstein-owned property or beneficial interests\ntherein located in the Virgin Islands and on the accounts of specified Epstein entities based in the\nVirgin Islands.\nIn their motion to vacate the Criminal Activity Liens, lndyke and Kahn seek for the Epstein\nEstate to proceed wholly unfettered as though none of Epstein's credibly-alleged conduct ever\noccurred. They seek a blank check for the Epstein Estate by urging the Court to vacate the\nGovernment's Criminal Activity Liens in their entirety. As evidence of the free reign they seek for\nthe Epstein Estate, the Government has approved and offered to permit future releases of Estate\n\n2\n\nEFTA02822230\n\n", "char_count": 1966}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "funds for administration and asset preservation upon a proper accounting of these items. See Ex.\nA (Government's Notice to Probate Court, filed Feb. 11, 2020), at 1-3. But Indyke and Kahn\nrefused to provide this. Instead, they first filed an Emergency Motion with the Probate Court,\nasking that Court to vacate the Government's Liens even though it lacked jurisdiction because this\nCourt's jurisdiction over the Government's Criminal Activity Liens under CICO is exclusive.\nNow, Indyke and Kahn ask this Court to vacate the Liens in their entirety, arguing that both\nthey as Executors and the Epstein Estate itself are exempt from CICO's Criminal Activity Lien\nprovisions based on various legal and factual contentions, none of which has merit. Their position,\nat bottom, is that any restraint on their use of Epstein Estate funds is impermissible. This position\nis inconsistent with the Government's express authority under CICO, the egregious conduct of the\ndecedent and his associated entities, and the substantial claims asserted against the Estate by both\nthe Government and individual victims.\nThe Court thus should reject Indyke and Kahn's motion as both legally baseless and\nfactually untenable.\nSTATEMENT OF FACTS\nA.\n\nJeffrey Epstein's Alleged Child Sex-Trafficking Enterprise\n\nThe Government filed its operative First Amended Complaint (\"FAC\") against the Epstein\nEstate, Indyke, Kahn, and various Epstein-owned entities on February 5, 2020. The Government\nalleges that decedent Jeffrey E. Epstein was a resident of the Virgin Islands and maintained a\nresidence since 1998 on Little St. James Island, which he owned. FAC, ¶ 5. In 2016, he purchased\na second island—Great St. James. Id. By this time, he also was a registered sex offender because\nhe was convicted in Florida of procuring a minor for prostitution. Id., ¶ 6.\n\n3\n\nEFTA02822231\n\n", "char_count": 1851}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "The Government alleges that Mr. Epstein for decades conducted an enterprise (the \"Epstein\nEnterprise\") whereby he used his web of businesses in the Virgin Islands to transport female\nvictims, many of them children, to his privately-owned Little St. James Island, where they were\nsexually abused, injured, and held captive. Id., ¶¶ 40-41. Flight logs show that between 2001 and\n2019, girls and young women were transported to the Virgin Islands and then helicoptered to Little\nSt. James. Id.,1 46. Air traffic controller reports state that some victims appeared to be as young\nas 11 years old. Id., ¶ 51. Mr. Epstein and his associates lured these girls and young women to\nhis island with promises of modeling and other career opportunities. Id., ¶ 49. Once they arrived,\nthough, they were sexually abused, exploited, and held captive. Id.\nMr. Epstein's privately-owned islands in the Virgin Islands were essential to the sextrafficking enterprise. Little St. James is a secluded, private island, nearly two miles off-shore\nfrom St.\n\nwith no other residents. Id., ¶ 66. It is accessible only by private boat or\n\nhelicopter, with no public or commercial transportation servicing the island. Id. When two\nvictims, one age 15, attempted to escape from Little St. James, Mr. Epstein organized search parties\nthat located them, returned them to his house, and then confiscated the I5-year old girl's passport\nto hinder her ability to escape again. Id., ¶¶ 57-58. Mr. Epstein's acquisition of the second\nisland—Great St. James—in 2016 provided an additional layer of security, allowing him to better\nensure that authorities could not observe the sex-trafficking activity on Little St. James and that\nthe victims could not escape. Id., 1 67.\nMr. Epstein's Virgin Islands-based corporations and companies also played central roles\nin the criminal sex-trafficking enterprise. Defendant Plan D, LLC knowingly and intentionally\nfacilitated the trafficking scheme by flying underage girls and young women into the\n... [truncated, 2118 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/29 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=29]", "char_count": 2118}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Nautilus, Inc.—for which Defendants Indyke and Kahn served, respectively, as Secretary and\nTreasurer—knowingly participated in the Epstein Enterprise and facilitated the trafficking and\nsexual servitude of underage girls and young women by providing the secluded properties at, from,\nor to which Epstein and his associates could transport, transfer, maintain, isolate, harbor, provide,\nentice, deceive, coerce, and sexually abuse them. Id., ¶¶ 23-29, 98.\nDefendant Southern Trust Company, Inc., of which Epstein was President/Director and\nDefendants Indyke and Kahn were respectively Secretary/Director and Treasurer/Director,\nfraudulently obtained tens of millions of dollars in tax exemptions from the Virgin Islands between\n2012 and 2019. Id., ¶¶ 37, 112. Southern Trust Company held itself out as providing \"cutting\nedge consulting services\" in the area of \"biomedical and financial informatics.\" Id.,111104-106.\nIn fact, it had only one full-time employee working on information technology before 2019, while\nnumerous other administrative or support employees performed personal services for Epstein, and\nthe company itself existed solely or primarily to secure tax benefits that helped support his criminal\nactivities and properties in the Virgin Islands. Id., ¶¶ 107-111, 113-114.\nB.\n\nThe Government's Criminal Activity Lien Notices\n\nPursuant to 14 V.I.C. § 610, the Government filed and served Criminal Activity Lien\nNotices covering Mr. Epstein's Virgin Islands-based properties, beneficial interests therein, and\naccounts. Specifically, the Government's notices created liens on the following:\nI. Any personal or real property located in the Territory of the Virgin Islands in the\nname of, or under the signatory authority of the ESTATE OF JEFFREY E.\nEPSTEIN; JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN; THE 1953 TRUST; PLAN D, LLC;\nGREAT ST. JIM, LLC; NAUTILUS, INC.; HYPERION AIR, LLC; AND\nPOPLAR, INC.\n2. Any beneficial interest of the ESTATE OF JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN; JEFFREY\nE. EPSTEIN; THE 1953 TRUST; PLAN D, L\n... [truncated, 2174 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/30 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=30]", "char_count": 2174}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "3. Any and all bank accounts, certificates of deposits and any other accounts in the\nname of, or under the signatory authority of the ESTATE OF JEFFREY E.\nEPSTEIN; JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN; THE 1953 TRUST; PLAN D, LLC;\nGREAT ST. JIM, LLC; NAUTILUS, INC.; HYPERION AIR, LLC; AND\nPOPLAR, INC.\nEx B (Criminal Activity Lien Notice, dated Jan. 23, 2020).\nC.\n\nThe Attorney General's Attempts to Ensure Lawful Administration of the\nEpstein Estate\n\nOn February 5, 2020, Shauna Betz, Legal Assistant at Kellerhals\n\nKroblin PLLC\n\n(Attorneys for the Epstein Estate, Indyke, and Kahn) sent email correspondence to the Attorney\nGeneral from attorney\n\nKroblin, Esq., objecting to the Criminal Activity Lien hold\n\n(\"Lien\") the Government placed on accounts in the name of \"The Estate of Jeffrey E. Epstein,\"\n\"Nautilus, Inc.,\" and \"Great St. Jim, LLC\" at the First Bank of Puerto Rico on January 31, 2020.\nSee Ex. A (Government's Notice to Probate Court, filed Feb. 11, 2020) at 1. The next day,\nFebruary 6, 2020, the Attorney General responded by email and offered to schedule a meeting for\nthe following day, which Attorney Kroblin accepted. See id. at 2.\nOn February 7, 2020, the Attorney General and Attorney Kroblin met in person. Attorney\nKroblin expressed concern that the Lien would prevent the Epstein Estate from paying its expenses\nto maintain and preserve its assets. See id. The Attorney General recognized the importance of\nthe Epstein Estate meeting its expenses for maintenance and preservation and so offered, pursuant\nto her express and exclusive and express authority under 14 V.I.C. § 610(r), to release sufficient\nfunds to meet such expenses once the Epstein Estate identifies the expenses and the amounts of\nfunds needed to satisfy them. See id.\nOn Sunday February 9, 2020, the Attorney General followed up and memorialized the\nmeeting by sending an email again conveying her willingness to accommodate an immediate\n6\n\nEFTA02822234\n\n", "char_count": 1933}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "release of funds sufficient to pay necessary expenses to manage, maintain, and preserve estate\nassets, and stating that the Attorney General's Office eagerly awaited the listing of expenses to\nfacilitate the prompt release of funds for payment. See id. In that same email, the Attorney General\nalso stated her intent to follow up about the proposed Epstein victims' compensation program fund\nthat also was discussed briefly at the in-person meeting. See id.\nRather than provide the requested itemization, however, Counsel for the Epstein Estate,\nIndyke, and Kahn (Attorney Kroblin) sent an email to the Attorney General on Monday February\n10, 2020 stating that the Estate had that morning filed to seek an emergency Order from the Probate\nCourt because FirstBank had conveyed that the hold would remain in place absent a court order.\nSee id. at 3. The Attorney General has opposed the Epstein Estate's emergency motion, which is\npending before the Probate Court.\nAfter the Epstein Estate filed its Probate Court emergency motion, the Attorney General\ncontinued to try to reach a common understanding with the Estate over what constitutes reasonable\nadministration expenses. See Ex. C (March 17, 2020 email to Estate's counsel).\nOn March 17, 2020, Defendants Indyke and Kahn filed their motion for this Court to vacate\nthe Government's Criminal Activity Liens.\nDespite Defendants' motions, the Attorney General has approved release of $14.76 million\nfrom the Government's Criminal Activity Liens--$10.4 million for Estate administration,\nmaintenance expenses, and attorneys' fees, and has continued to seek a common understanding\nwith the Estate on how to verify such expenses in the future, see Ex. D (May 18-27, 2020 emails\nbetween counsel) (5/20/20 email), plus an additional $4.36 million for administration of a victims\ncompensation fund. Defendants, however, continue to refuse to cooperate. They insist that the\nGovernment's Criminal Activity Liens cannot be enforced against them and that they\n... [truncated, 2031 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/32 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=32]", "char_count": 2031}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "unfettered control over funds used and obtained in connection with the Epstein Enterprise. See id.\n(5/21/20 email).\nD.\n\nUnexplained Estate Transactions Involving Tens of Millions of Dollars\n\nOn May 14, 2020, Counsel for the Government wrote Counsel for the Epstein Estate\ninquiring about irregularities in the Estate's accounting involving tens of millions of dollars. See\nEx. E (May 14, 2020 letter by Government's Counsel). The first of these involves the Estate's\npayment of $15.5 million to Epstein-owned Southern Country International, Ltd. (\"SCI\"), which\nthe Estate represents to be repayment of a loan by SCI to Epstein for his legal expenses after his\narrest in July 2019, but for which there is no record of any loan made by SCI. See id. at 1-2. This\ntherefore is an unaccounted-for disbursement of $15.5 million by the Epstein Estate.\nThe second irregularity involves the Estate's transfer of $24 million from Epstein-owned\nSCI to Epstein-owned Defendant Southern Trust Company. The Estate made this transfer from\nSCI to Southern Trust on December 18, 2019—the day before it made the above $15.5 million\npayment to SCI—but did not disclose this payment until over four months later. See id. at 2-3.\nNone of these transactions are consistent with SCI's banking license, which limits its activities,\nexcept in narrow circumstances, to non-resident individuals and entities, see 9 V.I.C. § 726(b),\nwhich excludes both Epstein and Southern Trust.\nDefendants have not explained these irregularities involving tens of millions of dollars of\nEpstein Estate funds. They also refuse to provide a basis for their requests for additional releases\nof funds covered by the Government's Criminal Activity Liens, insisting instead that they have\ncomplete control over these funds used and obtained in connection with the Epstein Enterprise.\n\n8\n\nEFTA02822236\n\n", "char_count": 1854}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "ARGUMENT\nIn their Motion to Vacate, Defendants Indyke and Kahn raise a series of arguments that, if\naccepted, would effectively nullify the Attorney General's enforcement authority under CICO and\nother laws where a primary wrongdoer is deceased and his or her property and assets used in\nconnection with the wrongful conduct go to probate. These arguments are contrary both to CICO's\nexpress provisions giving the Attorney General statutory authority to enforce Criminal Activity\nLiens and to the estate administration statutes that Defendants invoke. The Court therefore should\nreject each of Defendants' arguments as set forth below.\nA.\n\nThe Court Should Not Vacate or Release the Government's Criminal\nActivity Liens Against Defendants While This CICO Action is Pending.\n\nUnder CICO, where the Government has filed a civil or criminal action against a party and\nconcurrently filed a Criminal Activity Lien Notice, only the Attorney General may release the liens\nthereunder while the action is pending. The relevant CICO sections provide first that \"[u]pon the\ninstitution of any criminal or civil proceeding or action under this chapter, the Attorney General .\n. may file . . . a Criminal Activity Lien Notice\" and that the \"clerk of the trial court shall upon the\npresentation of a Criminal Activity Lien Notice, immediately record it in the official records.\" 14\nV.I.C. § 610(a). The Government has done this here. See Ex. B (Criminal Activity Lien Notice,\ndated Jan. 23, 2020).\nThe Government's \"filing of a Criminal Activity Lien Notice creates from the time of its\nfiling, a lien in favor of the Government of the Territory of the Virgin Islands\" on the named\nperson or entity's \"personal or real property situated in the Territory of the Virgin Islands\" and on\n\"any beneficial interest in it located in the Territory of the Virgin Islands.\" 14 V.I.C. § 610(c)(1)(2) (emphasis added); see also 14 V.1.C. § 610(f) (\"The lien shall commence and attach as of the\ntime of filing of the Criminal A\n... [truncated, 2081 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/34 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=34]", "char_count": 2081}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "Liens thus already are attached to all of the Epstein Estate's known property and interests located\nwithin the Virgin Islands connected to his criminal enterprise.\nOnce the Government's Criminal Activity Liens were filed and attached, they \"shall\ncontinue thereafter until expiration, termination or release as provided herein.\" 14 V.I.C. § 610(0.\nThe Act provides with respect to expiration that \"[t]he term of a Criminal Activity Lien Notice\nshall be for a period of 6 years from the date of filing\" and subject to renewal for one additional\n6-year period upon Notice filed by the Attorney General. 14 V.I.C. § 610(q). The Government's\nLiens on the Epstein Estate thus shall continue in effect until either January 23, 2026, or January\n23, 2032, absent a termination or release as provided in the Act.\nWhere, as here, the Government's underlying CICO action still is pending, only the\nAttorney General may release any property or interestfrom the Criminal Activity Liens. This is\nthe express command of the statute, which provides in relevant part that:\nThe Attorney General . . . filing the Criminal Activity Lien Notice may release, in\nwhole or in part, any Criminal Activity Lien Notice or may release any personal or\nreal property or beneficial interest in it from the Criminal Activity Lien Notice upon\nsuch terms and conditions as he may determine.\n14 V.I.C. § 610(r) (emphasis added). The Act thus is unambiguous that where a Criminal Activity\nLien Notice has commenced and attached upon the Attorney General's filing of an action and\nNotice, the Attorney General has sole authority to vacate or release the Liens upon terms and\nconditions she deems appropriate. This means that the Court may not, with the one exception\naddressed below, vacate or release the Government's Criminal Activity Liens.\nThe one instance where CICO permits the Court to release or extinguish a Criminal\nActivity Lien does not apply here. The Act provides that where \"no criminal or civil proceeding\nor action under\n... [truncated, 2198 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/35 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=35]", "char_count": 2198}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "a release or extinguishment of the notice,\" which a court may grant upon the appropriate factual\nfindings. 14 V.I.C. § 610(t)(1)-(3). This exception does not apply here because the Government's\nCICO action against the Epstein Estate is pending. The Court therefore may not vacate or release\nthe Government's Criminal Activity Liens as Defendants request.\nThis statutory remedial scheme enables the Attorney General to ensure that property and\nassets used in or obtained from unlawful conduct are not shielded from law enforcement. It also\nprotects defendants by allowing them to challenge the underlying allegations through, for example,\na motion to dismiss or for summary judgment to ensure there is sufficient legal and factual basis\nfor the Government's action. Where no action is pending, the § 610(t) review process likewise\nprotects a lien defendant's due process rights. Where an action is pending, like here, the Criminal\nActivity Liens are to remain in place until the Government's claims are resolved.\nIn sum, Defendants' request that the Court vacate or release the Government's Criminal\nActivity Liens is contrary to CICO's lien-enforcement statutory provisions. In light of the\nLegislature's purpose in enacting CICO to \"curtail criminal activity and lessen its economic . . .\npower in the Territory of the Virgin Islands by . . providing to law enforcement . . . new civil\nsanctions and remedies,\" 14 V.I.C. § 601, the Court may not grant this relief while the\nGovernment's CICO action against the Epstein Estate is pending. The Defendant's motion to\nvacate therefore must be summarily denied.\nB.\n\nThe Government's Criminal Activity Liens are Valid.\n1.\n\nThe Criminal Activity Liens Apply to the Estate's Property.\n\nDefendants Indyke and Kahn contend that CICO \"excludes executors of estates from the\nreach of Criminal Activity Lien Notices.\" Motion to Vacate at 8 (citing 14 V.I.C. § 604(r))\n\n11\n\nEFTA02822239\n\n", "char_count": 1925}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "(emphasis in original). This is incorrect. Although § 604(r) excludes executors from the Act's\ndefinition of \"Trustee,\" this is immaterial to the Government's claims and Liens for two reasons.\nFirst, § 610(e)'s \"trustee\" provisions do not support vacature of the Government's Criminal\nActivity Liens on Epstein Estate assets. These provisions merely exempt the personal or real\nproperty ofthe trustees themselves from a Criminal Activity Lien where the trustees are not named\nin their personal capacity. See V.I.C. § 610(m). That has no relevance to this case because the\nGovernment's Liens are not on Defendant Indyke or Kahn's personal property, but on the Epstein\nEstate's property and assets.\nSecond, and closely related, CICO also does not apply only to trustees. Rather, its Criminal\nActivity Lien Notice provisions apply broadly to any \"person or other entity named in the [Lien]\nnotice . . ..\" 14 V.1.C. § 610(e) (emphasis added). Thus, even if the Co-Executors are not deemed\ntrustees under CICO, they do not have to be because the Act applies far more broadly to any other\nperson or entity named—such as the Epstein Estate, each Epstein-controlled company, and each\nindividual named in this lawsuit.\nSection 604(r)'s exclusion of executors from the Act's definition of a \"trustee\" thus is\nirrelevant to the validity and scope of the Government's Criminal Activity Liens.\n2.\n\nThe Government Sued the Proper Parties in Interest\n\nDefendants Indyke and Kahn also argue that it was improper for the Government to name\nthe Epstein Estate and the 1953 Trust as defendants in the CICO action because neither is a legal\nentity that can be sued. See Motion to Vacate at 8-9. This argument that the Epstein Estate and\n1953 Trust are not \"persons\" that can be sued under CICO makes no reference to Virgin Islands\nlaw, under which both entities clearly can be sued for two separate and independent reasons.\n\n12\n\nEFTA02822240\n\n", "char_count": 1923}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "First, in Ottley v. Estate of Bell, 61 V.1.480 (2014), the Supreme Court addressed a lawsuit\nnaming an estate as defendant. See id. at 486 (\"Ottley named Bell's estate, Eboni, and Gerard\n(collectively, 'Appelles') as defendants in the action.\"). In deciding the appeal, the Supreme Court\nsquarely held that it was permissible for the plaintiff to sue the estate. See id. at 500 (\"Ottley\ncorrectly named Bell's estate as the defendant, and although not necessary, additionally listed the\ntwo heirs entitled to inherit her interest in the [disputed] property.\"). In Francis v. Ruan Living\nTrust, No. ST-15-cv-177, 2016 V.I. LEXIS 160, 2016 WL 5867452 (Super. Ct. Oct. 5, 2016), this\nCourt held the same with respect to a plaintiff's claims against a trust. See id. at *13 (\"Plaintiff\nhas pled sufficient facts to support her claim of negligence . . . against Defendant Ruan Trust.\")\n(emphasis added). These decisions thus demonstrate that both the Epstein Estate and the 1953\nTrust are properly subject to suit.\nSecond, the Court also should reject the argument that the Epstein Estate and 1953 Trust\ncannot be sued because this would undermine CICO's enforcement scheme by shielding Epstein's\negregious conduct and the property and assets he used to carry it out from law-enforcement. The\nGovernment seeks to preserve the Estate's assets to satisfy claims for civil penalties, repayment of\nfraudulently obtained tax benefits, and restitution for victims. As discussed, supra, § A, the\nLegislature enacted CICO to \"curtail criminal activity and lessen its economic and political power\nin the Territory of the Virgin Islands by establishing new penal prohibitions and providing to law\nenforcement and the victims of criminal activity new civil sanctions and remedies.\" 14 V.I.C. §\n601. Exempting the Epstein Estate and 1953 Trust from the Act's Criminal Activity Lien remedy\nwould thwart these purposes by allowing the wrongdoer's estate and beneficiaries to retain\nproperty and assets used for egregiou\n... [truncated, 2042 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/38 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=38]", "char_count": 2042}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "In sum, the Epstein Estate and its Co-Executors' arguments on the alleged impropriety of\nthe Government's CICO action against the Epstein Estate and the 1953 Trust are legally incorrect.\nThe Court should reject these arguments as grounds for vacating the Government's Criminal\nActivity Liens.\n3.\n\nCivil Forfeiture is an Available Remedy to the Government Under\nCICO, Though Not Necessary to Maintain its Criminal Activity Liens.\n\nDefendants Indyke and Kahn next argue that the Court must vacate the Government's\nCriminal Activity Liens because CICO does not permit civil forfeiture, and \"[w]ithout a valid\nforfeiture claim, the Attorney General has no basis to freeze the Estate's assets pending the\noutcome of this action.\" Motion to Vacate at 10-12. Both parts of this argument are incorrect.\nCICO does provide for the Attorney General to obtain civil forfeiture, and the Criminal Activity\nLiens would be valid even if it did not. Each of these arguments is taken in turn.\nFirst, CICO provides for civil forfeiture. The Supreme Court squarely has recognized this.\nSee In re Najawicz, 52 V.1.311, 333 (2009) (\"CICO provides for both civil and criminal forfeitures\n. . . .\"). Defendants ask this Court to ignore the Supreme Court's statement on this point as dictum\nthat is incorrect. See Motion to Vacate at 10. The Supreme Court did not err on this point.\nUnder 14 V.I.C. § 607, the Government's remedies in civil cases where it proves conduct\nviolating the Act include a judgment \"ordering any defendant to divest himself of any interest in\nany enterprise, or in any real property[.]\" 14 V.I.C. § 607(a)(1). Defendants acknowledge this\nremedy,but try to dismiss it as irrelevant because \"the Decedent no longer has an interest to be\ndivested.\" Motion to Vacate at 11. This cavalier assertion does nothing to differentiate between\ndivestiture andforfeiture as civil remedies available to the Government. Whether the Government\nseeks forfeiture, divestiture, or both (as here), Jeffrey Epstein still\n... [truncated, 2151 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/39 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=39]", "char_count": 2151}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "Moreover, even if Defendants could meaningfully distinguish between divestiture and\nforfeiture under § 607 (which they cannot), the Government still could obtain forfeiture in this\ncivil action. This is because § 607 also provides that \"[n]one of the above provisions shall be held\nto limit the existing equitable powers of the trial court.\" 14 V.I.C. § 607(a)(6). The Court's\nretained equitable powers include the power to order forfeiture based upon proven misconduct.\nSee generally Ottley, supra, 61 V.I. at 496 n.12 (\"[A] court may properly find that an administrator\nforfeited the right to raise [15 V.I.C.] section 606 as a defense due to equitable considerations.\");\nsee also Sheppard, Mullin, Richter & Hampton, LLP v. J -M Mfg. Co., Inc., 6 Cal. 5th 59, 237\n(2018) (\"The law takes these case-specific factors into account because forfeiture of compensation\nis, in the end, an equitable remedy.\"); Prozinski v. Northeast Real Estate Set-vs., LLC, 797 N.E.2d\n415, 424 n.9 (Mass. App. Ct. 2003) (\"Forfeiture is an equitable remedy.\"); Burrow v. Arce, 997\nS.W.2d 229, 237 (Tex. 1999) (\"[W]e look to the jurisprudential underpinnings of the equitable\nremedy of forfeiture.\").\nIt is true that equity sometimes disfavors forfeiture. See, e.g.,\n\nv. Domain, 6 V.I.\n\n599, 604 (1968) (\"Equity relieves against a forfeiture where no real fault is committed . . . .\")\n(internal quotation marks and citation omitted). This, however, is not a case where no fault was\ncommitted. Just the opposite, the appalling, numerous, and well-documented allegations by the\nGovernment and dozens of Epstein's victims confirm that equity commands that Epstein's Estate\nbe denied the ability to deplete or transfer these assets to Epstein's beneficiaries. Forfeiture thus\nis and should be an available civil or equitable remedy.\nSecond, Defendants' \"no civil forfeiture\" argument for vacating the Government's\nCriminal Activity Liens also fails because the Liens are expressly authorized by statute without\nregard to civi\n... [truncated, 2106 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/40 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=40]", "char_count": 2106}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "Lien Notice \"[u]pon the institution of any criminal or civil proceeding or action under this\nchapter[.]\" 14 V.I.C. § 610(a). The Legislature thus did not condition the availability of Criminal\nActivity Liens on the assertion of forfeiture claims.\nIndeed, if Defendants were correct both that the Liens require a forfeiture claim and that\nforfeiture is unavailable in civil actions, then the Government could never file a Lien Notice in a\ncivil action. The plain language of § 610 permitting Criminal Activity Liens in criminal and civil\nactions alike thus clearly refutes these arguments. And for good reason, as the Government's Liens\nwill ensure the availability of Epstein Estate assets to satisfy its claims not only for forfeiture and\ndivestiture, but also for maximum civil penalties, treble damages, disgorgement, restitution, and\nsuch other relief as the Court deems proper. See FAC, Prayer for Relief, y¶ D, E, F, J, K, N, P.\nFor each of these reasons, the Court should reject Defendants Indyke and Kahn's \"no civil\nforfeiture\" arguments for vacature and should reaffirm the validity of the Government's Criminal\nActivity Liens.\n4.\n\nThe Criminal Activity Liens are not Overbroad.\n\nThe Government's Criminal Activity Liens are appropriately tailored to property used in\nthe course of Mr. Epstein's alleged child sex-trafficking enterprise in the Virgin Islands. Under\nCICO, the Government may place a lien upon any personal or real property situated in the Virgin\nIslands where the notice is filed which then or thereafter was owned by the person named and upon\nany beneficial interest therein then or thereafter owned by the person named. 14 V.I.C. §\n610(e)(1)-(2). In In re Najawicz, supra, the Supreme Court clarified that \"on its face, CICO clearly\nallows for pre-trial restraint only of 'real or personal property used in the course of, intended for\nuse in the course of, derived from, or realized through, conduct in violation of [CICO].\"' 52 V.I.\nat 343 (quoting 14 V.I.C. § 606(c) for\n... [truncated, 2039 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/41 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=41]", "char_count": 2039}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "The Government's Criminal Activity Liens here do no more than this. With respect to the\nassets beyond Mr. Epstein's islands and aircraft referenced in Defendants Indyke and Kahn's\nmotion, see Motion to Vacate at 14, the Lien Notices placed a hold on accounts held by the Estate\nof Jeffrey E. Epstein; Nautilus, Inc.; and Great St. Jim LLC. See Ex. F (Feb. 4, 2020 letter of\nFirstBank to Co-Executors). Mr. Epstein and both named entities are central to the alleged child\nsex-trafficking enterprise in the Virgin Islands. See FAC, ¶ 40 (\"Epstein, through and in\nassociation with Defendants, trafficked, raped, sexually assaulted and held captive underage girls\nand young women at his properties in the Virgin Islands.\"); ¶ 27 (\"Great St. Jim, LLC . . . owns at\nleast three properties that make up Great St. James .. . .\"); ¶ 28 (\"Epstein is listed as manager and\na member of Great St. Jim, LLC and the nature of its business is described as `holding assets.\"');\n¶ 98 (\"Great St. Jim, LLC and Nautilus, Inc. knowingly participated in the Epstein Enterprise and\nfacilitated the trafficking and sexual servitude of young women and underage girls by providing\nthe secluded properties at, from, or to which Epstein and his associates were able to transport,\ntransfer, receive, maintain, isolate, harbor, provide, entice, deceive, coerce, and sexually abuse\nunderage girls and young women.\").\nIn light of these allegations specifically connecting each accountholder to the Epstein sextrafficking enterprise, Defendants' argument that \"at best the Liens might attach to Little St. James\nIsland and the three identified aircraft,\" Motion to Vacate at 14, is incorrect. Although Mr.\nEpstein's privately-owned islands clearly were central to the enterprise, so too were the activities\nand resources of the companies he controlled. The Criminal Activity Liens thus are appropriately\ntailored to the conduct of the Epstein Enterprise.\nThe Court also should reject Defendants' undeveloped argument about the geogra\n... [truncated, 2111 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/42 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=42]", "char_count": 2111}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "Defendants request that the Court's Order specifically state that the Liens do not cover real or\npersonal property or accounts located outside of the Virgin Islands.\"). Since Defendants do not\nspecify which property or accounts they allege to be located outside of the Virgin Islands, the\nCourt should decline this invitation to issue a blanket advisory opinion. Cf. In re Media Ventures\nInc., 30 V.I. 43, 45 (Terr. Ct. 1994) (Hodge, V.) (\"The Court therefore finds that no actual case or\ncontroversy exists which needs to be addressed, and that Petitioner is in effect asking this court for\nan advisory opinion. This request must therefore be denied.\"). The Government's Criminal\nActivity Liens are appropriately tailored to property and assets used in connection with the\nunlawful conduct alleged, and thus should not be vacated either in whole or in any part.\nC.\n\nThe Government's Criminal Activity Liens Do Not Conflict with Legitimate\nEstate Administration.\n\nFinally, the Court also should reject Defendants Indyke's and Kahn's separate argument\nthat the \"expenses of Estate administration have priority\" over the Government's Criminal Activity\nLiens. Motion to Vacate at 15. This question is not presented on the facts before the Court because\nthe Government does not seek to prohibit the Epstein Estate from making truly administrative and\npreservation-related expenditures.\nRather, the Attorney General repeatedly has sought an accounting from Defendants Indyke\nand Kahn to ensure that any Estate funds they release are used for these and only these legitimate\npurposes. See supra, Statement of Facts §§ C-D. The requested accounting would ensure that\nboth the Estate's administrative and preservation purposes and the Government's law-enforcement\ninterests are served. CI 15 V.I.C. § 161 (requiring Probate Court to administer justice in all matters\nrelating to the affairs of decedents \"in the manner prescribed by law.\") (emphasis added).\nDefendants Indyke and Kahn, however, refuse to pro\n... [truncated, 2162 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/43 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=43]", "char_count": 2162}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "their Motion to Vacate or elsewhere makes their argument for a determination of \"priority\" nothing\nmore than another improper attempt to obtain an advisory opinion by this Court.\nMoreover, the \"manner prescribed by law\" for disposition of the Epstein Estate's property\nand assets subject to the Government's Criminal Activity Liens is set forth in CICO itself,\nspecifically 14 V.I.C. § 610. This provision gives the Attorney General sole authority to set the\nterms and conditions for release of property subject to a Criminal Activity Lien while a CICO\naction is pending:\nThe Attorney General or United States Attorney filing the Criminal Activity Lien\nNotice may release, in whole or in part, any Criminal Activity Lien Notice or may\nrelease any personal or real property or beneficial interest in it from the Criminal\nActivity Lien Notice upon such terms and conditions as he may determine.\n14 V.I.C. § 610(r) (emphasis added). Thus, any release of Epstein Estate property or assets covered\nby the Government's Criminal Activity Liens must be upon such terms and conditions as the\nAttorney General permits.\nThe Attorney General is appropriately exercising her authority under CICO by requesting\nan accounting to ensure that released Epstein Estate funds are put to legitimate administration and\npreservation uses. She does not seek to prohibit the Epstein Estate from making necessary\nadministrative and preservation expenditures. Just the opposite, she seeks to ensure that released\nEstate funds are used for these legitimate purposes and no other. Toward this end, the Attorney\nGeneral has approved release of $10.4 million for Epstein Estate administration and preservation\nexpenses to date. See supra, Statement of Facts § C. This is both her exclusive right and her duty\nunder CICO to ensure that the statute's law-enforcement objectives are served and not evaded.\nSince Defendants Indyke and Kahn as Co-Executors have refused to provide the Attorney\nGeneral or this Court with any accounting \n... [truncated, 2171 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822203/44 or ?id=EFTA02822203&page=44]", "char_count": 2171}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "an advisory opinion and/or is contrary to CICO's Criminal Activity Lien provisions. For either or\nboth reasons, their motion to vacate should be denied.\nThe Government credibly alleges that Jeffrey Epstein used his Virgin Islands properties\nand network of Virgin Islands-based companies to fund (through fraudulently-obtained tax\nbenefits) and operate an unlawful sex-trafficking enterprise in which dozens of underage girls and\nyoung women were sexually abused and held captive. The Epstein Estate Co-Executors' motion\nto vacate the Government's Criminal Activity Liens is nothing less than an attempt to use Epstein's\njailhouse suicide as a vehicle to sweep this sordid history under the rug and allow Epstein's\nbeneficiaries to retain the instrumentalities of the enterprise at the expense of its victims. The\nCourt should reject the motion and enforce the Government's Liens against the Epstein Estate.\nCONCLUSION\nFor all of the reasons set forth, Defendants Indyke and Kahn's motion to vacate the\nGovernment's Criminal Activity Liens should be denied.\n\nRespectfully submitted,\nESQUIRE\nDENISE N.\nATTORNEY GENERAL\nVIRGIN ISLANDS DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE\n\nDated: June 11, 2020\n\nBy:\nARIEf.\nMITH, ESQUIRE\nAssistant Attorney General\nVirgin Islands Department of Justice\nOffice of the Attorney General\n34-38 Kronprindsens Gade\nSt.\nU.S. Vir in Islands 00802\nEmail:\n20\n\nEFTA02822248\n\n", "char_count": 1377}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "(340) 774-5666 ext. 10155\n\n21\n\nEFTA02822249\n\n", "char_count": 45}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\nIT IS HEREBY CERTIFIED that the foregoing Opposition to Motion complies with the\nword and page requirements of V.I.R. Civ. P. 6-1(e) and a true and correct copy of the\nOpposition was served via regular mail, postage prepaid, with a courtesy copy sent by email to\ncounsel of record on June 11, 2020 to:\nKROBLIN, ESQ.\nANDREW W. HEYMANN, ESQ.,\nWILLIAM BLUM, ESQ.\nSHARI D'ANDRADE. ESQ.\nKELLERHALS\nKROBLIN PLLC\nPalms Professional Building\n9053 Estate\n, Suite 101\nSt. IM,\nV.1.00802-3602\nEmail: ckroblin@kellfer.com\naheymann®solblum.com\nwblum@solblum.com\nsdandrade@kellfer.com\nmwhalen@kellfer.com\n\nANDREW TOMBACK\n& CASE, LLP\n1221 Avenue of the Americas\nNew York, New York 10020-1095\nUnited States\nEmail: andrew.tomback@whitecase.com\n\nDANIEL WEINER\nMARC A. WEINSTEIN\nHUGHES HUBBARD & REID, LLP\nOne Battery Park Plaza\nNew York, NY 10004-1482\nUnited States\nEmail: daniel.weiner@hugheshubbarcl.com\nmarc.weinstein®hugheshubbard.com\n\nBy:\nIEL M. S I , ESQUIRE\nAssistant Attorney General\nVirgin Islands Department ofJustice\nOffice of the Attorney General\n34-38 Kronprindsens Gade\n22\n\nEFTA02822250\n\n", "char_count": 1106}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "St.\nU.S. Vir 'n Islands 00802\nEm •\n(340) 774-5666 ext. 10155\n\n23\n\nEFTA02822251\n\n", "char_count": 80}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822203", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS\nDIVISION OF ST.\nAND ST. JOHN\nCIVIL CASE NO.: ST-20-CV-155\nGHISLAINE MAXWELL,\nPlaintiff,\nvs.\n\nESTATE OF JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN,\nDARREN K. INDYKE, in his capacity as\nEXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF JEFFREY\nE. EPSTEIN, RICHARD D. KAHN, in his\ncapacity as EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE\nOF JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, and NES, LW, a\nNew York Limited Liability Company,\nDefendants.\n\nORDER\nThis matter comes before the Court on the Motion to Intervene (the \"Motion\") filed by\nnonparty, the Government of the United States Virgin Islands (the \"Government\"). The Court\nbeing fully advised in the premises, it is hereby\nORDERED, that the Government's Motion is hereby DENIED; and it is further\nORDERED, that a certified copy of this Order shall be distributed to counsel of record.\n\nDated:\nATTEST:\nTamara Charles\nClerk of the Court\nBy:\nDated:\n\nJUDGE OF THE SUPERIOR COURT\nOF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS\n\nEFTA02822252\n\n", "char_count": 918}]}