{"efta_number": "EFTA02822177", "page_count": 20, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02822177", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02822177.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02822177", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "PlItIOlt( Ill Kt\nI. IIII\n(1/ III/ %WI% IN %%DS\n\nFILED\nJuly\n\n12,\n\nTAMARA CHARLES\nCLERK OF THE COURT\n\nIN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS\nDIVISION OF ST.\nAND ST. JOHN\n*St** *****\n\n**** ******\n\nGHISLAINE MAXWELL,\n\n******\n\n***\n\nCase No. ST-20-CV-155\nPLAINTIFF,\n\nV.\nESTATE OF JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, DARREN\nK. INDYKE, in his capacity as EXECUTOR OF\nTHE ESTATE OF JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN,\nRICHARD D. KAHN, in his capacity as\nEXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF JEFFREY E.\nEPSTEIN, and NES, LLC, a New York Limited\nLiability Company,\nDEFENDANTS.\n\nGOVERNMENT OF THE UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS'\nMOTION TO INTERVENE\nThe Government of the United States Virgin Islands (\"Government\"), by and through its\nundersigned counsel, hereby moves for an order permitting the Government to intervene in this\naction as of right pursuant to V.I. R. Civ. P. 24(a) or else by leave pursuant to V.I. R. Civ. P.\n24(b). The Government states in support of its motion as follows.\nPRELIMINARY STATEMENT\nPlaintiff Ghislaine Maxwell (\"Maxwell\") filed this action seeking indemnification for and\nadvancement of expenses incurred by reason of her prior employment relationship with decedent\nJeffrey E. Epstein and his affiliated businesses \"in connection with any threatened, pending, or\ncompleted suit, proceeding, or investigation relating to Epstein, his affiliated businesses, and his\nalleged victims.\" Complaint ¶ I. Since the filing of this action, Maxwell has been arrested by\n\nEFTA02822177\n\n", "char_count": 1455}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822177", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "federal authorities on charges that she assisted, facilitated, and participated in Epstein's sexual\nabuse of underage girls.\nThe Government has two distinct but closely related interests that support intervention in\nthis action. First, the Government has a pending action in the Virgin Islands against Defendants\nherein—the Estate of Jeffrey E. Epstein, Darren K. Indyke, and Richard D. Kahn—and others\nunder the Criminally Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (CICO), 14 V.I.C. §§ 601 et seq.\nSee Ex. A (Gov't of the U.S. Virgin Islands v. Indyke et al., No. ST-20-CV-14 (First Amended\nComplaint, filed 2/5/20)) (\"FAC\"). The Government alleges that Defendants committed and\nconspired to commit criminal sex-trafficking and sexual abuse activity. The Government's\nprimary interest for intervention is to ensure that the Epstein Estate's assets are not wrongfully\ndissipated by Maxwell's suspect claims for indemnification and \"advancement\" of legal\nexpenses, and instead are preserved to satisfy the CICO judgment, which seeks forfeiture,\ndivestiture, disgorgement, and payment of maximum civil penalties and damages by the Epstein\nEstate.\nSecond, the Government also is investigating Maxwell's participation in Epstein's\ncriminal sex-trafficking and sexual abuse conduct pursuant to its authority under CICO, 14\nV.I.C. § 612, to investigate reasonably suspected criminal activity. The Government has\nattempted to serve a CICO Subpoena Duces Tecum on Maxwell stating that:\nPursuant to 14 V.I.C. § 612(c), the documentation requested is in reference to an\nongoing investigation by the Virgin Islands Department of Justice of the rape,\nabuse, exploitation and trafficking of young women and underage girls by Jeffrey\nE. Epstein and his associates in violation of 14 V.I.C. § 133 and 1624, as well as\nother Virgin Islands statutes.\nEx. B (Government's CICO Subpoena Duces Tecum to Ghislaine Maxwell, dated March 19,\n2020) at 1. Maxwell resisted and evaded service of the subpoena during the three an\n... [truncated, 2027 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822177/1 or ?id=EFTA02822177&page=1]", "char_count": 2027}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822177", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "months after its issuance. The Government's second intervention interest thus is to ensure that\nMaxwell is compelled to respond to its investigatory subpoena through this action in which she\nis a party and has consented to the Court's jurisdiction.\nThe Government's need to intervene is further fueled by Maxwell's inappropriate use of\nthe Virgin Islands courts to seek payment and reimbursement from the Epstein criminal\nenterprise, while she circumvents the service of process of Government subpoenas related to her\ninvolvement in that criminal enterprise.\nBased upon either or both of the Government's interests with respect to all parties in this\naction and for the reasons set forth herein, the Court should grant the Government intervention as\nof right under V.I. R. Civ. P. 24(a) or else by leave under V.I. R. Civ. P. 24(b).\nSTATEMENT OF FACTS RELATED TO INTERVENTION\nA.\n\nMaxwell's Arrest on Federal Criminal Sex-Trafficking Charges Related to\nHer Involvement with Epstein's Conduct.\n\nOn July 2, 2020, federal authorities arrested Ms. Maxwell on six federal criminal charges\nrelated to her involvement with Epstein's alleged sex-trafficking and sexual abuse conduct. See\nEx. C (Indictment, United States of America v. Ghislaine Maxwell, No. 20-CR-330 (S.D.N.Y.)).\nMaxwell is charged with Conspiracy to Entice Minors to Engage in Illegal Sex Acts\n(Count One), Enticement of a Minor to Travel to Engage in Illegal Sex Acts (Count Two),\nConspiracy to Transport Minors with Intent to Engage in Criminal Sexual Activity (Count\nThree), and Transportation of a Minor with Intent to Engage in Criminal Sexual Activity (Count\nFour). Id. All of these charges stem from Maxwell's role \"in the sexual exploitation and abuse\nof multiple minor girls by Jeffrey Epstein.\" Id.,111; see &soli 2 (\"GHISLAINE MAXWELL,\nthe defendant, and Jeffrey Epstein enticed and caused minor victims to travel to Epstein's\n\n3\n\nEFTA02822179\n\n", "char_count": 1916}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822177", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "residences in different states, which MAXWELL knew and intended would result in their\ngrooming for and subjection to sexual abuse.\").\nMaxwell also is charged with two counts of Perjury for giving false testimony concealing\nthe foregoing conduct of both Epstein and herself. See id, Counts Five and Six.\nB.\n\nThe Government's CICO Investigation of Maxwell's Participation in the\nEpstein Enterprise.\n\nThe Government is and has been actively investigating Maxwell's participation in the\ncriminal sex-trafficking and sexual abuse conduct of the Epstein Enterprise. See Ex. B\n(Government's CICO Subpoena) (seeking documentation \"in reference to an ongoing\ninvestigation by the Virgin Islands Department of Justice of the rape, abuse, exploitation and\ntrafficking of young women and underage girls by Jeffrey E. Epstein and his associates in\nviolation of 14 V.I.C. § 133 and 1624, as well as other Virgin Islands statutes\").\nPrior to Maxwell's arrest, the Government made repeated but unsuccessful attempts to\nserve its CICO subpoena on her. On March 24, 2020, the Government served the subpoena on\nMaxwell's counsel in this action, Kyle R. Waldner, Esq. See Ex. D (Certificate of service).\nOn April 15, 2020, David J. Cattie, Esq. notified the Government that Ms. Maxwell had\nretained him in regard to the Government's subpoenas. See Ex. E (Cattie to\n\nemail,\n\n4/15/20). The subpoena was clearly received by Maxwell, and Attorney Cattie contacted the\nGovernment on her behalf to negotiate a possible resolution of the subpoena. Given that\nAttorney Cattie nonetheless raised concerns about service on Maxwell, the Government asked\nthat Maxwell authorize him to accept service of the subpoena or disclose her whereabouts, so\nthat it could serve her personally. See Ex. F (email from L.\n\nto D. Cattie, May 1, 2020).\n\nOn May 12, 2020, almost two months after the Government's initial attempts at service, Mr.\nCattie responded that he \"cannot waive the issue of service of the subpoenas, nor can I disclose\n4\n\nEF\n... [truncated, 2012 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822177/3 or ?id=EFTA02822177&page=3]", "char_count": 2012}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822177", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "my client's location to anyone at this time.\" Ex. G (email from D. Cattie to L.\n\nMay 12,\n\n2020) (emphasis added).\nAfter Mr. Cattie refused to accept or waive service, the Government -- in good faith -continued to negotiate for release of the requested documents in lieu of enforcing the CICO\nSubpoena. See Ex. H (Email from L.\n\nto D. Cattie, May 28, 2020). Those negotiations\n\nalso failed, and the Government attempted service of a second CICO Subpoena on Ms.\nMaxwell's counsel on June 11, 2020. See Ex. I (second subpoena).' Mr. Cattie once more stated\nthat he was not \"authorized\" to accept service on her behalf. Ex. J (Email from D. Cattie to L.\nJune 17, 2020). And again, Mr. Cattie did not offer to provide Maxwell's location to\nallow the Government to effectuate service. Id. To date, Maxwell has not acknowledged or\nresponded to either of the Government's CICO Subpoenas.\nAfter Epstein's most recent arrest on July 8, 2019 and his death in prison on August 10,\n2019, see Complaint, ¶ 23, and before her own arrest on July 2, 2020, Maxwell was in hiding.\nNumerous media outlets reported on her unknown whereabouts, including The Sun, the\nWashington Examiner, Vanity Fair, BBC, CNN, CNBC, the Telegraph, The Guardian, and Page\nSix.2 At the same time, her counsel was actively litigating in other Courts to keep shielded from\npublic view thousands of pages of court records that would expose her involvement and\n\nI The second CICO Subpoena, see Ex. I is identical to the fast one served on March 24, 2020.\n2 See, e.g., hups://wynv.vanityfair.coin/news/2019/11/hunt-for-jeffrey-epstein-alleged-enabler-ghislaine-maxwell;\nhttps://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/nov/18/ghislaine-maxwell-prince-andrew-friend-jeffrey-epsteincontroversy-hiding; hups://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/decil 2/she-was-so-dangerous-where-in-the-worldis-the-notorious-ghislaine-maxwell; httpsJ/www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-50927651;\nhilps://edition.cnn.com/2019/12/08/uk/who-is-ghislaine-maxwell-jeffrey-epstein-i\n... [truncated, 2383 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822177/4 or ?id=EFTA02822177&page=4]", "char_count": 2383}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822177", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "participation in Epstein's heinous crimes. See, e.g.,\n\nv. Maxwell, 15-cv-7433-LAP\n\n(S.D.N.Y.).\nMaxwell also was actively litigating this action with counsel appearing on her behalf.\nSee, e.g., Joint Motion to Stay proceedings, filed June 2, 2020 in Maxwell v. Estate of Jeffrey E.\nEpstein, et al Case No.: ST-20-CV-15, in the Superior Court of the United States Virgin Islands.\nEven before Epstein's 2019 arrest and death, locating and serving Maxwell was\nimpracticable. In 2017,\n\na victim suing Maxwell in yet another matter related to\n\nMaxwell's participation in Epstein's sex trafficking scheme, attempted to serve Maxwell in a\nnumber of ways, including by providing Maxwell's attorneys at Haddon\n\na copy of the\n\nsummons and complaint, emailing a copy of the summons and complaint to gmax@ellmax.com,\nand attempting to effectuate service at three locations associated with Maxwell in New York and\nNew Jersey. See Ex. K (Jane Doe 43 v. Epstein. et al., 17 Civ. 00616-JGK (S.D.N.Y.), ECF No.\n\n•\n\n97) at 2-3.\nDespite those attempts,\n\nwas unable to personally serve Maxwell and filed a\n\nmotion asking the court to approve alternative service. Id. On January 30, 2018, the Honorable\nJohn G. Koeltl of the Southern District of New York held that\n\nhad demonstrated that\n\nserving Maxwell was impracticable under New York law and that providing copies of the\nsummons and complaint to her counsel, was reasonably calculated to provide Maxwell with\nnotice of the lawsuit given that they were presumably in contact with Maxwell. See Ex. L\nv. Epstein, No. 17-CV-616 (JGK), 2018 WL 637421, at *1 (S.D.N.Y. Jan. 30, 2018)).\nMaxwell thus has engaged in repeated instances of avoiding service of the type that the\nGovernment has encountered in its CICO investigation of her alleged criminal sex-trafficking\nconduct that also is at issue in this coverage action filed by none other than Maxwell herself.\n\n6\n\nEFTA02822182\n\n", "char_count": 1907}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822177", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "C.\n\nThe Government's CICO Acton Against Defendants the Epstein Estate,\nIndyke, and Kahn, and Others.\n\nThe Government alleges in its CICO action against Defendants herein—the Epstein\nEstate, Indyke, and Kahn—that Epstein was a resident of the Virgin Islands and maintained a\nresidence on Little St. James Island, which he owned, from 1998 until his death in prison in\n2019. Ex. A (FAC) ¶ 5. In 2016, Mr. Epstein purchased a second island—Great St. James. Id.\nBy this time, he was a registered sex offender, having been convicted in Florida of procuring a\nminor for prostitution. Id., ¶ 6.\nThe Government alleges that Epstein for decades conducted an enterprise (the \"Epstein\nEnterprise\") whereby he used his web of businesses in the Virgin Islands to transport female\nvictims, many of them children, to his privately-owned Little St. James Island, where they were\nsexually abused, injured, and held captive. Id ,¶1 40-41. Flight logs show that between 2001\nand 2019, Defendants transported girls and young women to the Virgin Islands and then\nhelicoptered them to Little St. James. ld.,1 46. Air traffic controller reports state that some\nvictims appeared to be as young as 11 years old. Id., ¶ 51. Epstein and his associates lured these\ngirls and young women to his island with promises of modeling and other career opportunities.\nId.,1149. Once they arrived, they were sexually abused, exploited, and held captive. Id.\nEpstein's privately-owned islands in the Virgin Islands were essential to the sextrafficking enterprise. Little St. James is a secluded, private island, nearly two miles off-shore\nfrom St.\n\nwith no other residents. Id., ¶ 66. It is accessible only by private boat or\n\nhelicopter, with no public or commercial transportation servicing the island. Id. When two of\nthe victims, one age 15, attempted to escape from Little St. James, Epstein was able to organize\nsearch parties, locate them, return them to his house, and then confiscate the 15-year old girl's\npassport to hinder her \n... [truncated, 2057 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822177/6 or ?id=EFTA02822177&page=6]", "char_count": 2057}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822177", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "The Government alleges that Epstein and the CICO Defendants violated CICO by\ncommitting and conspiring to commit criminal human trafficking offenses based upon the\nforegoing conduct. See id., ¶¶ 115-170 (Counts 1-VIII). The Government further alleges that\nthey violated CICO by committing and conspiring to commit various child-abuse, neglect, rape,\nunlawful-sexual-contact, prostitution, and sex-offender-registry-related offenses based upon the\nforegoing sexual-abuse conduct. See\n\n171-258 (Counts IX-XIX). The Government also\n\nalleges that Defendants engaged in a civil conspiracy to conceal the unlawful sexual abuse\nalleged. See id.,111281-287 (Count XXII).\nThe Government is seeking civil penalties for each violation of law, treble damages, and\ncompensatory and punitive damages for civil conspiracy. Id., Prayer for Relief ¶11J-L, O. The\nGovernment also seeks equitable relief, including but not limited to disgorgement of all ill-gotten\ngains, as warranted pursuant to 14 V.I.C. § 608(c)(4), to protect the rights of victims and\ninnocent persons in the interest of justice and consistent with CICO's purposes. Id.. Prayerfor\nRelief¶¶ N, P. The Government further seeks forfeiture and divestiture in favor of the\nGovernment as to all CIC Defendants' interests in any real and personal property in the Virgin\nIslands used to facilitate or further the goals of the criminal Epstein Enterprise, including but not\nlimited to Little St. James and Great St. James Islands, and in any proceeds or funds obtained by\nthem during the course of the criminal Epstein Enterprise. Id., Prayer for Relief ¶¶ D-F.\nARGUMENT\nA.\n\nLegal Standards\n\nThe Virgin Islands Rules of Civil Procedure provide for a person to intervene as of right\nin a pending action as follows:\nOn timely motion, the court must permit anyone to intervene who:\n\n8\n\nEFTA02822184\n\n", "char_count": 1841}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822177", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "(2) claims an interest relating to the property or transaction that is the subject of\nthe action, and is so situated that disposing of the action may as a practical matter\nimpair or impede the movant's ability to protect its interest, unless existing parties\nadequately represent that interest.\nV.I. R. Civ. P. 24(a)(2).\nThe civil rules also provide for a person to intervene by permission of the court in a\npending action as follows:\nOn timely motion, the court may permit anyone to intervene who:\n\n(B) has a claim or defense that shares with the main action a common question of\nlaw or fact.\nV.I. R. Civ. P. 24(b)(1)(B).\n\"The purpose of the rule governing intervention is to enable one not named as a party\nwho has a direct, substantial, and legally protectable interest in the subject matter of the litigation\nto protect himself from an action that might be detrimental to him.\" Hendricks v. Clyne, No. ST16-cv-147, 2019 WL 918607, at \"1 (V.I. Super. Ct. Feb. 20, 2019).\nB.\n\nThe Government Satisfies Rule 24(a)'s Requirements to Intervene of Riaht.\n\nA party seeking to intervene as of right must establish three elements: \"(1) a sufficient\ninterest in the subject matter of the pending litigation, (2) a substantial risk that the disposition of\nthe litigation will impair the interest, and (3) the existing parties do not adequately protect that\ninterest.\" Id. The Government satisfies all of these requirements.\n1.\n\nThe Government Has Sufficient Interests in the Subject Matter of this\nAction.\n\nThe Government has two distinct but related interests in the subject matter of this action-Maxwell's claim against the Epstein Estate for indemnification and \"advancement\" of legal\n\n9\n\nEFTA02822185\n\n", "char_count": 1698}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822177", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "expenses for any suit involving her relationship with Epstein and his affiliated businesses.\nComplaint ¶ 1; see also id., ¶¶ 17-19 (Epstein indemnified and advanced Maxwell's costs for\nsuits and investigations \"relating to Epstein, his affiliated businesses, and his alleged victims.\").\nEither or both of the Government's interests is sufficient for its intervention as of right.\nFirst, the Government has an interest as a litigant against Defendants to ensure that the\nEpstein Estate's assets are preserved to satisfy the judgment it seeks on its CICO claims. The\nGovernment is seeking an order requiring forfeiture, divestiture, disgorgement, and payment of\nmaximum civil penalties and damages. See Ex. B (CICO FAC), Prayer for Relief¶¶ D-P.\nMaxwell's claims in this action threaten the Government's litigation interests by seeking to\nwrongfully dissipate the Epstein Estate's assets on a joint tortfeasor's undocumented and\notherwise suspect claim of entitlement to indemnification and \"advancement\" of legal expenses\nfor criminal or civil actions addressing her involvement in Epstein's sex-trafficking and sexual\nabuse conduct.\nNumerous federal courts applying the identically worded Fed. R. Civ. P. 24(a) have held\nthat a tort claimant has a sufficiently developed interest to intervene as of right in a coveragerelated action involving the tort defendant. In Teague v. Bakker, 931 F.2d 249 (4th Cir. 1991),\nthe appeals court reversed denial of intervention as of right by class action plaintiffs in a separate\ndeclaratory judgment action by the insurer of the class action defendant seeking to disavow\ncoverage. See id. at 260. The appeals court addressed the proposed intervenors' interest, which\nwas contingent since they had not obtained a judgment at the time their intervention was denied,\nand, after weighing the relevant arguments, held that \"the Teague Intervenors stand to gain or\nlose by the direct legal operation of the district court judgment on [the insurer's] complaint\" and\ntha\n... [truncated, 2119 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822177/9 or ?id=EFTA02822177&page=9]", "char_count": 2119}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822177", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Id.; see also Security Ins. Co. v. Schipporeit, Inc., 69 F.3d 1377, 1381 (7th Cir. 1995) (permitting\ntort claimant to intervene in insurer's declaratory judgment action against tort defendant).\nBased on the Fourth Circuit's Teague decision, a federal district court permitted sexabuse tort claimants to intervene in an action brought by the tort defendant seeking a declaration\nas to coverage by an insurer. See\n\nv. Fireman's Fund Ins. Co., No. 11-1258, 2011 WL\n\n3241452, at *I (D. Md. July 28, 2011). Following Teague, the court held that the sex-abuse tort\nclaimants had a sufficiently protected interest to intervene as of right.\" See id. at •2 (\"Plainly, it\nis of great importance to the tort plaintiffs to persuade this Court that Fire[man]'s Fund is\nobligated to indemnify\n\nIf this Court ultimately determines that Fireman's Fund is not\n\nrequired to indemnify\n\n, the Does will only be able to satisfy any judgment they obtain\n\nagainst\n\nfrom his assets, rather than from the resources of the insurer.\").\nThe only difference between the Government's position here and the tort claimant\n\nintervenors' positions in Teague and\n\nis that here the CICO Defendants are in the role of\n\npotential insurer. In Maxwell's suit against the Epstein estate, the Estate's assets are similar to\nthose of an insurer, as both the Government and Maxwell are seeking recovery from the same\nEstate proceeds, which Maxwell is attempting to use as insurance. Thus, the Government's\ninterest in ensuring the availability of hinds to satisfy its own judgment would be threatened here\nnot by the denial of coverage (as in Teague), but by the provision of coverage using the Estate's\nassets to indemnify Maxwell. But this is a distinction without a difference, as the interest itself is\nthe same—ensuring the availability of Estate funds to satisfy the Government's potential\n\n11\n\nEFTA02822187\n\n", "char_count": 1871}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822177", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "judgment against a possible co-conspirator in the CICO enterprise. This interest by itself\nsupports intervention.3\nSecond, the Government also has an interest as a potential litigant authorized by statute to\ninvestigate Maxwell's involvement in the same criminal sex-trafficking and sexual abuse\nconduct that is the subject of the CICO action against the Epstein Estate, Indyke, and Kahn.\nUnder CICO, \"[w]henever any person is reasonably suspected to have engaged in . . . any\nconduct constituting a violation of any of the provisions of [14 V.I.C. § 605] the Attorney\nGeneral may, in [her] discretion, conduct an investigation of the conduct.\" 14 V.I.C. § 6I2(a).\nThe Attorney General is expressly authorized \"before the commencement of and during any civil\nor criminal proceeding or action under this chapter to subpoena witnesses . . . or to require the\nproduction of any books, documents, records, writings, recordings or tangible things . . . relevant\nor material to the investigation . ...\" Id.\nPursuant to this express statutory authority, the Attorney General is and has been\ninvestigating Maxwell's involvement with Epstein's criminal sex-trafficking and sexual abuse\nconduct in anticipation of a potential action against her. See Ex. B (CICO Subpoena) (describing\ninvestigation of \"the rape, abuse, exploitation and trafficking of young women and underage\ngirls by Jeffrey E. Epstein and his associates\"); see also 14 V.I.C. § 612(a) (\"The Attorney\nGeneral is authorized before the commencement of and during any civil or criminal proceeding\nor action under this chapter to subpoena witnesses . . . or to require the production of any ...\ndocuments . . . relevant or material to the investigation ....\"). Thus, to the extent the\n\n3 Although the Government at present has Criminal Activity Liens on certain Estate Assets pursuant to 14 V.I.C. §\n610, limitations on the scope of pre-trial restraints mean that the Liens do not and cannot ensure the availability of\nsufficient funds to satisfy\n... [truncated, 2032 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822177/11 or ?id=EFTA02822177&page=11]", "char_count": 2032}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822177", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Government may intervene as of right to assert its interest in its statutory enforcement action, it\nalso may do so to assert its statutory investigative interest related to much the same conduct.\nIn sum, the Government has both active litigation interests and statutorily authorized\ninvestigatory interests with respect to the parties on both sides of this action. Either or both of\nthese interests in the conduct and outcome of this action is sufficient for the Government to\nintervene of right under Rule 24(a).\n2. The Government's Interests Will Be Impaired Absent Intervention.\nThere is considerable risk bordering on near certainty that the disposition of this action\nwill impair the Government's litigation and/or investigatory interests if the Court denies\nintervention. In Teague, supra, the Fourth Circuit held that the tort-claimant intervenors\ndemonstrated impairment of their interest based upon the possibility of the tort defendant's loss\nof coverage. See 931 F.2d at 261 (\"We also find that the Teague Intervenors' ability to protect\ntheir interest would be impaired or impeded by disposition of ERC's action\" as they would have\nto satisfy their judgment from other assets of the insureds and the existence and amount of such\nassets are questionable.\").\nHere, there is far greater likelihood that the Government's interests will be impaired if it\nis denied intervention. As to its litigation interest, if Maxwell succeeds on her undocumented\nand otherwise suspect claim against the Epstein Estate for indemnification and \"advancement\" of\nlegal expenses, this will diminish the Estate's available funds to satisfy the judgment the\nGovernment seeks against it in the CICO action. This potential impairment due to a loss of\nfunds available to the tort defendant is identical to that found by the U.S. Court of Appeals to\nsupport intervention as of right in Teague.\n\n13\n\nEFTA02822189\n\n", "char_count": 1896}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822177", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "As to its separate but related investigatory interest against Maxwell, the Government has\ndemonstrated that she repeatedly and deliberately evaded service of its CICO subpoena prior to\nher arrest. See supra, Preliminary Statement and Factual Background § B. She also has resisted\nservice in other civil actions brought by Epstein's and her victims. By virtue of her lawsuit,\nMaxwell has already subjected herself to the jurisdiction of this Court. It would be supremely\ninequitable to allow Maxwell to make use of the courts of the Virgin Islands to assert her\naffirmative claims for indemnification for her involvement in the Epstein criminal enterprise, and\nyet still avoid complying with a lawful subpoena authorized by the laws of the Virgin Islands as\npart of an investigation into this very criminal conduct. If the Government cannot intervene in\nthis action that she initiated, Maxwell may refuse to comply with the Government's subpoena,\nyet still proceed in her separate action and leave the Government with little to no recourse. As a\nresult, the Government's investigatory and enforcement interests will be irreparably impaired.\nFor either or both of these reasons, the Court should find that the Government's interests\nwill likely be impaired if intervention is denied, and for this reason too the Government may\nintervene of right under Rule 24(a).\n3.\n\nThe Epstein Estate Cannot Adequately Represent the Government's\nInterests.\n\nFinally, there is no serious question but that the Government's enforcement and\ninvestigatory interests under CICO are not adequately represented by the current parties to this\ncase— Ghislaine Maxwell, the Epstein Estate, and its Co-Executors.\nThe Epstein Estate and its Co-Executors are defendants in the Government's existing\nCICO action involving Epstein's and his associates' criminal sex-trafficking and sexual abuse\nconduct, and show no inclination to be anything but adversarial to the Government's interests.\nThey are refusing to comply with discover\n... [truncated, 2068 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822177/13 or ?id=EFTA02822177&page=13]", "char_count": 2068}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822177", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "from issuing subpoenas to key fact witnesses, such as the house managers for Little St. James,\nwhere Epstein (and likely Maxwell) sexually abused girls and women in the Virgin Islands. See\nGov't of the U.S. Virgin Islands v. Indyke et al., No. ST-20-CV-I4, Co-Executors' Opp. to\nGovernment's Motions for Issuance of Letters Rogatory (filed 6/17/20).\nAlthough the Epstein Estate nominally has an interest in preserving its own funds as\nagainst Maxwell's claim for indemnification, Maxwell's evident involvement in Epstein's\nalleged criminal conduct makes her a critical fact witness with whom the Estate is very likely to\ntry to cooperate. Cf. Teague, 931 F.2d at 262 (\"[T]here is a significant chance that [the tort\ndefendants] might be less vigorous than the Teague Intervenors in defending their claim to be\ninsureds under the ERC policy.\"). That Maxwell and the Epstein Estate are not truly adversarial\nis demonstrated by the fact that they jointly moved to stay the Estate's pending motion to dismiss\nuntil a date when its primary grounds for dismissal (the one-year time bar from the granting of\nletters of administration under 15 V.I.C. § 606(a)) will no longer apply. See Joint Motion to Stay\nProceedings (filed 6/1/20).\nMaxwell likewise has evaded and refused to accept service of the Government's CICO\nsubpoena for months before she was arrested by federal authorities on charges identical to those\nunder investigation. She therefore is demonstrably adverse to the Government with respect to\nboth the availability of the Epstein Estate's funds and conduct of the Government's investigation.\nThe Government therefore has no potential ally in this action between likely tortfeasors\nas to its interests in both uncovering and obtaining redress for the criminal conduct of Epstein,\nMaxwell, and/or their associates. The conduct of both parties—Maxwell and the Epstein\nEstate—demonstrates clearly that both have a far stronger interest in obstructing the\nGovernment's investigation and enforcemen\n... [truncated, 2071 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822177/14 or ?id=EFTA02822177&page=14]", "char_count": 2071}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822177", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "For all of these reasons, the Court should grant the Government intervention as of right\nunder Rule 24(a).\nC.\n\nThe Government Also Satisfies Rule 24(b)'s Requirements for Permissive\nIntervention.\n\n\"Rule 24(b) applies a substantially more relaxed standard for permissive intervention,\nsince the proposed intervenor need not demonstrate the sort of interest required for intervention\nas of right.\" Meyers v.\n\nNo. ST-I2-cv-394, 2017 WL 10636962, at *3 (V.I. Super. Ct.\n\nApril 24, 2017). The proposed intervenor need only demonstrate that the proposed intervention\nis timely and that the intervenor's claim shares a common question of law or fact with the claims\nalready in the case. See, e.g., Hendricks, supra, 2019 WL 918607, at *1. The Government\nreadily satisfies both of these requirements.\nFirst, the Government's motion to intervene is timely. The Court assesses timeliness\nbased on the length of delay in seeking intervention, the prejudicial impact of delay on existing\nparties, prejudice to the would-be intervenor if intervention is denied, and other factors affecting\nfairness. Id. Here, all of these factors favor permitting the Government to intervene. Maxwell\nfiled this action less than four months ago, on March 12, 2020. During this time, Defendants\nhave not yet answered the Complaint. Instead, they filed a motion to dismiss and shortly\nthereafter, in lieu of Maxwell opposing the Estate's motion, the Estate and Maxwell moved\njointly to stay the action until September 7, 2020. See Joint Motion to Stay Proceedings (filed\n6/1/20). The Government's intervention thus will not disrupt or slow down active litigation.\nBy contrast, denial of intervention would be highly prejudicial to the Government for the\nreasons discussed above. First, the Government's CICO claims against Defendants, its potential\nclaims against Maxwell, and Maxwell's claims against the Defendants all present a common\nquestion of law or fact—Who is liable to pay a judgment on the Government's CICO claims\n16\n\nE\n... [truncated, 2013 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822177/15 or ?id=EFTA02822177&page=15]", "char_count": 2013}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822177", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "against Defendants and/or Maxwell for their involvement in or connection to the rape, abuse,\nexploitation, and trafficking of young women and underage girls by Epstein and his associates?\nIn Security Ins. Co., supra, the Seventh Circuit addressed federal Rule 24(b)'s identical\nrequirement that there be a \"common question of law or fact,\" and found that it was \"clearly met\nin this case\" involving intervention by a tort claimant in the tort defendant's coverage action.\nSee 69 F.3d 1381; cf. also Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co. v. Nat'l REO Mgmt., Inc., 205 F.R.D. 1, 6\n(D.D.C. 2000) (\"Thus, while the insurance contract may not be an issue in the underlying case in\nSuperior Court, the factual similarities between the two cases are enough to establish a common\nquestion of fact. Specifically, both the present case and the underlying case arise from alleged\ncarbon monoxide emissions from a furnace in the defendant's building that began on February\n23, 1995. In addition, neither case can be decided without determining the source of the\napplicant's injuries. Accordingly, for purposes of Rule 24(b), the court finds a common question\nof fact in the present lawsuit and the underlying lawsuit in Superior Court.\").\nSecond, if Maxwell succeeds on her undocumented and suspect claims for\nindemnification by the Epstein Estate, that will threaten the availability of Estate funds to satisfy\nthe Government's potential judgment in its CICO action. Second, since Maxwell has repeatedly\nand deliberately evaded service of the Government's investigatory subpoena during the past four\nmonths, as she has resisted service in other civil actions brought by Epstein's and her victims,\nthis action is her only known connection to the Virgin Islands through which the Government\ncan enforce its investigatory subpoena against her. Denial of intervention therefore would also\nharm the Government's investigatory and enforcement interests. For each of these reasons, the\nCourt should hold that the Government's motio\n... [truncated, 2038 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02822177/16 or ?id=EFTA02822177&page=16]", "char_count": 2038}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822177", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Since the Government's motion is timely and its actual and potential CICO claims\nconcerning Epstein's sex-trafficking enterprise and Maxwell's involvement in it present common\nquestions of law and/or fact to those presented in this action for coverage as to those claims, the\nCourt should grant the Government's motion to intervene and deem its CICO subpoena attached\nas Exhibit B to be served on Maxwell. This will allow the Government both to ensure its interest\nin preventing the dissipation of the Epstein Estate's assets and to enforce its subpoena and pursue\npotential and as appropriate independent claims against Maxwell. For either or both of these\nreasons, the Government may intervene by leave pursuant to Rule 24(b).\nCONCLUSION\nFor all of the reasons set forth, the Government's Motion to Intervene in this action\nshould be granted.\n\nRespectfully submitted,\nESQUIRE\nDENISE N.\nATTORNEY GENERAL\nVIRGIN ISLANDS DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE\n\nDated: July 10, 2020\n\nBy:\n\ns/Ariel M\nESQUIRE\nARIEL M.\nAssistant Attorney General\nVirgin Islands Department of Justice\nOffice of the Attorney General\n34-38 Kronprindsens Gade\nU.S. Vir in Islands 00802\nSt.\nEmail:\n(340) 774-5666 ext. 10155\n\n18\n\nEFTA02822194\n\n", "char_count": 1199}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822177", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\nIT IS HEREBY CERTIFIED that the foregoing Motion to Intervene complies with the\nword and page requirements of V.I.R. Civ. P. 6-1(e) and a true and correct copy of the Motion\nwas served via regular mail, postage prepaid, with a courtesy copy sent by email to counsel of\nrecord on July 10, 2020 to:\nKYLE R. WALDNER, ES\nQUINTAIROS, PRIETO,\n& BOYER, P.A.\n9300 S. Dadeland Blvd., 41b Floor\nMiami, FL 33156\nE-mail: kwaldner@qpwblaw.com\nDAVID CATTIE, ESQ.\nTHE CATTLE LAW FIRM, P.C.\n171aiens Gade\nSt.\n, V.I., 00802\ne-mail: david.cattie@cattie-law.com\nKROBLIN, ESQ.\nANDREW W. HEYMANN, ESQ.,\nWILLIAM BLUM, ESQ.\nSHARI D'ANDRADE ES .\nKELLERHALS\nKROBLIN PLLC\nPalms Professional Building\n9053 Estate\n, Suite 101\nSt.\nV.I. 00802-3602\nEmail: ckroblin@kellfer.com\naheymann@solblum.com\nwblum@solblum.com\nsdandrade@kellfer.com\nmwhalen@kellfer.com\nANDREW TOMBACK\nMcLaughlin & Stem, LLP\n260 Madison Avenue\nNew York, New York 10016\nUnited States\nEmail: ATomback®mclaughlinstem.com\nDANIEL WEINER\nMARC A. WEINSTEIN\nHUGHES HUBBARD & REID, LLP\nOne Battery Park Plaza\n19\n\nEFTA02822195\n\n", "char_count": 1081}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02822177", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "New York, NY 10004-1482\nUnited States\nEmail: daniel.weiner®hugheshubbard.com\nmarc.weinsteinathuv..heshubbard.com\n\nBy:\n\ns/Ariel M.\nARIEL M.\nESQUIRE\nAssistant Attorney General\nVirgin Islands Department of Justice\nOffice of the Attorney General\n34-38 Kron rindsens Gade\nSt.\nU.S. Virgin Islands 00802\nEmail:\n(340) 774-5666 ext. 10155\n\n20\n\nEFTA02822196\n\n", "char_count": 349}]}