{"efta_number": "EFTA02818795", "page_count": 9, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02818795", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02818795.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02818795", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 357-1 Filed 04/03/24 Page 1 of 9\n\nUNITED STATES\nDISTRICT\nCOURT\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK\nx\nGOVERNMENT OF THE UNITED\nSTATES VIRGIN ISLANDS,\nPlaintiff,\n-againstJP\n\nCHASE BANK, N.A.,\nCase No. 22-cv-10904 (JSR)\nDefendant.\nx\n\nMEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT OF PROPOSED\nINTERVENORS' MOTION TO INTERVENE AND DISCLOSE THE\nFILINGS TO THE LITIGANTS AND COUNSEL IN THE RELATED\nACTION OF DOE V. USVI, ET AL, 23-CV-10301-AS\n\nEFTA02818795\n\n", "char_count": 460}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02818795", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 357-1 Filed 04/03/24 Page 2 of 9\n\nTABLE OF CONTENTS\nTABLE OF AUTHORITIES\n\nii\n\nPRELIMINARY STATEMENT\n\n3\n\nUNDERLYING FACTS\n\n3\n\nARGUMENT\n\n5\n\nPROPOSED INTERVENORS ARE ENTITLED TO ACCESS TO THE CONFIDENTIAL\nFILINGS PURSUANT TO THE PROTECTIVE ORDER\n\n5\n\nA.\n\nProposed Intervenors May Intervene.\n\n5\n\nB.\n\nThe Doe Plaintiffs Here Have The Same Interests As The Doe Plaintiffs In The\nAction Before This Court And Should Not Be Prevented From Using\nDiscovery In This Case To Prosecute Their Claims In Their Recent Action\n\n6\n\nPlaintiffs Do Not Seek To Disturb The Protective Order As The USVI Was A\nParty To The Within Action And Many Defendants In The Proposed\nIntervenors Case Or Nonparty Witnesses In The Within Matter.\n\n7\n\nC.\n\nCONCLUSION\n\n8\n\nEFTA02818796\n\n", "char_count": 778}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02818795", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 357-1 Filed 04/03/24 Page 3 of 9\n\nTABLE OF AUTHORITIES\nPage(s)\nCases\nAT & T Corp. v. Sprint Corp.,\n407 F.3d 560 (24 Cir. 2005)\nE.E.O.C. v. Nat'! Children's Ctr., Inc.,\n146 F.3d 1042 (D.C. Cir. 1998)\nNML Capital, Ltd. v. Republic ofArg.,\nNo. 2:14-cv-492-RFB-VCF, 2014 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 173780 (D. Nev. Dec. 12, 2014)\n\n3\n3\n3\n\nRules\nFed. R. Civ. P. 24(b)(2)\nRule 24(b)\n\n3\n3\n\nEFTA02818797\n\n", "char_count": 417}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02818795", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 357-1 Filed 04/03/24 Page 4 of 9\n\nPRELIMINARY STATEMENT\nProposed Intervenors seek an Order granting them access to the unredacted filings in\nthis action to the parties and their counsel in accordance with the same Protective Order\nentered in this action. A copy of the Proposed Protective Order is submitted as Exhibit A.\nProposed Intervenors are Plaintiffs, proceeding anonymously, in the action Doe v.\nUSVI. et at, Case Number 23—CV-10301 (S.D.N.Y.) (\"the Doe action\"). By the Class Action\nComplaint in the Doe action, Proposed Intervenors seek damages from the Defendants for\ntheir conspiracy with Jeffrey Epstein and others and facilitation of the sex trafficking venture\nthat was the subjection of this action. Proposed Intervenors were victims of that enterprise.\nOf note, the USVI is a Defendant in the Doe action and was the Plaintiff in this action.\nUNDERLYING FACTS\nThe Protective Order in this action permitted the parties to deem confidential \"any\ninformation of a personal or intimate nature regarding any individual.\" The same Protective\nOrder was entered in two other actions: Doe v. Deutsche Bank Aktieneesellschaft 22-cv10018-JSR, Document 41; Doe 1 v. JP\n\nChase & Co.. 22-cv-10019-JSR Document\n\n35. All three actions were consolidated before this Court for pretrial purposes. Exhibit B,\nOrder in Doe 1 v. JP\n\nChase & Co.. 22-cv-10904-JSR, Document 5.\n\nThe Protective Order's broad and vague language resulted in the parties shielding the\nvast majority of discovery from public disclosure. Proposed Intervenors are now hamstrung\nby their ability to prosecute their claims against Defendants in the Doe action, including the\nUSVI.\nIndeed, those Defendants are capitalizing on the lack of available evidence in the\npublic domain, as Plaintiffs have been served with Proposed Intervenors have been served\nwith four motions to dismiss in the Doe action. There, the USVI and several other Defendants\nhave insisted upon dismissal without the benefit of even jurisdictional discovery. Doe v.\nUSVI, a at, Case Number 23-CV-10301, Documents LE, 68, 72, & 78.\n\nEFTA02818798\n\n", "char_count": 2114}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02818795", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 357-1 Filed 04/03/24 Page 5 of 9\n\nThe USVI, which benefitted from the Protective Order in this action, is using it as both\na sword and a shield. When it served the USVI's interest to consent to confidentiality, it did\nso in order to prosecute claims, ostensibly on behalf of the victims of the sex trafficking\nventure. In the Doe action, the USVI is now using it as a shield, by moving to dismiss on\ngrounds including a failure to plead with specificity. It is the height of hypocrisy for the\nUSVI to use the Protective Order to prevent the victims that gave the USVI standing to sue JP\nand others from accessing evidence supporting their claims. Even a cursory review of\nthe redactions on the docket reveals that the redactions pertained to the privacy of many of the\nDefendants in this action -- the government officials who benefited from the sex trafficking\nscheme.\nIt would also rub salt in the wounds of the real victims of the sex trafficking scheme -Proposed Intervenors — to bar them from the evidence needed to prosecute their claims against\nthe other conspirators in the scheme.\nThe right to anonymity of the Doe Plaintiffs in the consolidated actions before this\nCourt would not be impacted by the grant of this relief. For example, one of the Plaintiffs in\nthat case, Doe 1, opposed the New York Times recent application to unseal the entirety of the\nfile for public view, but that position is not incompatible with Proposed Intervenors' position\nin this case -- to maintain the confidentiality of the documents by limiting disclosure to the\nparties and their counsel in Doe v. USVJ.\nPlaintiffs have a unique and urgent need to review these documents. They are entitled\nto access.\n\nEFTA02818799\n\n", "char_count": 1741}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02818795", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 357-1 Filed 04/03/24 Page 6 of 9\n\nARGUMENT\nPROPOSED INTERVENORS ARE ENTITLED TO ACCESS TO THE CONFIDENTIAL\nFILINGS PURSUANT TO THE PROTECTIVE ORDER.\nA. Proposed Intervenors May Intervene.\nUnder Rule 24(b)(2), \"(o]n timely motion, the court may permit anyone to intervene\nwho is given a conditional right to intervene by a federal statute or has a claim or defense that\nshares with the main action a common question of law or fact.\" Fed. R. Civ. P. 24(b)(2)\n(cleaned up). Permissive intervention is permitted where, as here, a member of the public\nseeks intervention to modify a Protective Order and inspect court documents. AT & T Corp. v.\nSprint Corp., 407 F.3d 560, 562 (2d Cir. 2005) (\"[P]ermissive intervention is the proper method\nfor a nonparty to seek a modification of a protective order.\"); see also E.E.O.C. v. Nat'l\nChildren's Cm, Inc., 146 F.3d 1042, 1045 (D.C. Cir. 1998) (collecting cases and stating,\n\"despite the lack of a clear fit with the literal terms of Rule 24(b), every circuit court that has\nconsidered the question has come to the conclusion that nonparties may permissively intervene\nfor the purpose of challenging confidentiality orders.\").\nHere, Proposed Intervenors are seeking access to all records in this action in order to\nprosecute their claims against Defendants in their action, subject to the same Protective Order\nthat remains in effect in this case. To balance against the privacy interests of the parties in this\naction, Proposed Intervenors ask that disclosure be limited to litigants and their counsel in the\nDoe action only.\nThe motion is timely. \"When a member of the public moves to intervene to unseal\njudicial records, the motion to intervene is timely as long as the documents remain under seal\nbecause sealing places the public's interest in open access in controversy.\" NML Capital. Ltd.\nv. Republic of Arg., No. 2:14-cv-492-RFB-VCF, 2014 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 173780, at *11 (D.\nNev. Dec. 12, 2014). Here, the action was resolved with the settlement so there are no\nongoing or unknown concerns that may bar intervention in disclosure.\nGiven this tailored request, there is no proper basis to deny Proposed Intervenors\naccess.\n\nEFTA02818800\n\n", "char_count": 2219}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02818795", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 357-1 Filed 04/03/24 Page 7 of 9\n\nB. The Doe Plaintiffs Here Have The Same Interests As The Doe Plaintiffs In\nThe Action Before This Court And Should Not Be Prevented From Using\nDiscovery In This Case To Prosecute Their Claims In Their Recent Action.\nRecently, the New York Times moved for an unsealing of the entire action before this\nCourt. In opposition, Doe 1 argued that victims of sexual crimes are entitled to anonymity:\nAs the victim of rampant, horrific sexual abuse that has changed the course of her\nlife, Jane Doe 1 is entitled to the protection of her identity despite the presumption\nof public access. See, e.g., Kemp v. Noeth, No. 20-CV-9121 (RA)(SN), 2021 WL\n1512712, at *2 (S.D.N.Y. Apr. 15, 2021) (\"the privacy interest the Court must\nconsider here—the identity of a sexual assault victim— is an important and\nv.\nrecognized basis to limit public access to the documents in question\");\nWarden of Attica Con. Facility, No. 20CV3076PAEJLC, 2020 WL 6866403, at\n*2 (S.D.N.Y. Nov. 23, 2020) (\"Although a presumption in favor of public access\nexists, the basis for sealing the records at issue—protecting the identity of the\nsexual assault victim—provides a compelling Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document\n353 Filed 03/12/24 Page 2 of 5 3 reason to limit such access. Indeed, it is common\nfor courts in this District toirfitrequests for sealing orders to protect a sexual\nv. Dershowitz, No. 15 CIV. 7433 (LAP), 2020\nassault victim's identity.\");\nWL 5439623, at *2 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 9, 2020) (finding that \"the gravity of the\nprivacy interests\" of Epstein victims weighed heavily against public disclosure);\nScott v. Graham, No. 16CV2372KPFJLC, 2016 WL 6804999, at *1 (S.D.N.Y.\nNov. 17, 2016) (\"Here, there is a compelling reason to limit the general public's\naccess to the documents filed in this case: safeguarding the identity of a rape\nvictim.\"); Kavanaugh v. Zwilling, 997 F. Supp. 2d 241, 256 (S.D.N.Y. 2014)\n(sealing records of decisions \"as the decisions contain sensitive and personal\ninformation about the sexual abuse of minor\"). 22-cv-10904-JSR, Document 353.\nProposed Intervenors agree that they are entitled to such anonymity. However, Proposed\nIntervenors' motion will not disturb the privacy of other victims, because they seek to maintain\nthe confidentiality of the discovery and filings in this case in order to facilitate the prosecution\nagainst others who facilitated Epstein's crimes.\nProposed Intervenors are seeking essentially a de facto consolidation of their case with\nthis case. As this Court will recall, this Court consolidated the within action with other actions\nbrought by women who were victims, just as Proposed Intervenors were, of the sex trafficking\nventure. This Court therefore ordered:\nBarring any objection from plaintiff Government of the United States Virgin\nIslands, which must be made by joint telephone call to\nno later than\n\nEFTA02818801\n\n", "char_count": 2921}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02818795", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 357-1 Filed 04/03/24 Page 8 of 9\n\n5:00 PM on January 4, 2023, this case is hereby consolidated for all\npurposes with Doe v. Deutsche Bank, 22- cv-10018 and Doe v. .11'\nChase\n& Co., 22-cv-10019.... Exhibit B, 22-cv-10904-JSR. Document 5.\nC. Plaintiffs Do Not Seek To Disturb The Protective Order As The USVI Was\nA Party To The Within Action And Many Defendants In The Proposed\nIntervenors Case Or Nonparty Witnesses In The Within Matter.\nThe USVI is in possession of all of the filings in this case and so can hardly oppose an\norder which places Proposed Intervenors on the same footing as them. Further, the remaining\nDefendants in the Proposed Intervenors' case were nonparty witnesses in this action. They have\nreceived the benefits of confidentiality and would continue to do so in this case.\n\nEFTA02818802\n\n", "char_count": 843}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02818795", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 357-1 Filed 04/03/24 Page 9 of 9\n\nCONCLUSION\nThe privacy interests implicated by the Protective Order are not harmed or threatened\nby this application. This action arises out of the same events and is based on the actions of the\nsame parties and nonparties with the exception of the witnesses from the banking industry\nwho may be nonparties in this action. Notwithstanding, if the Protective Order is continued\nbut expanded to apply to the parties in the Doe v. USVI action, the victims of the horrible\ncrimes will be permitted to seek redress using hard-won discovery from the earlier actions.\nDated: April 3, 2024\nNew York, New York\nRespectfully submitted,\nMERSON LAW PLLC\nBy:\n\n/s/ Jordan Merson\nJordan Merson, Esq.\n950 Third Avenue, 18th Floor\nNew York, NY 10022\nTelephone: (212) 603-9100\nFax: (347)- 441-4171\nJMerson@MersonLaw.Com\nCounselfor Proposed Intervenors\n\nEFTA02818803\n\n", "char_count": 914}]}