{"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_count": 53, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02817624", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02817624.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 1 of 53\n\nIN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK\nGOVERNMENT OF THE UNITED\nSTATES VIRGIN ISLANDS,\nPlaintiff;\nv.\nJPMORGAN CHASE BANK, N.A.,\nDefendant/Third-Party\nPlaintiff;\n\nCase No. 22-cv-10904 (JSR)\n\nv.\nJAMES EDWARD STALEY,\nThird-Party\nDefendant.\nJANE DOE, individually and on behalf of all\nothers similarly situated,\nPlaintiff,\nv.\n\nJPMORGAN CHASE BANK, N.A.,\n\nCase No. 22-cv-10019 (JSR)\n\nDefendant/Third-Party\nPlaintiff,\nv.\nJAMES EDWARD STALEY,\nThird-Party\nDefendant.\n\nJPMORGAN CHASE BANK, N.A.'S LOCAL CIVIL RULE 56.1(B) RESPONSE TO\nTHIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT'S STATEMENT OF UNDISPUTED MATERIAL FACTS\nPursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 56 and Local Civil Rule 56.1, Defendant/Third-Party Plaintiff\nJPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. (\"JPMC\" or \"JPMorgan\") hereby responds to the Third-Party\n\nEFTA02817624\n\n", "char_count": 877}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 1 22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 2 of 53\n\nDefendant James Staley's LocalRule 56.1 Statement ofUndisputed Material Facts In Support Of\nSummary Judgment. See Dkt. 310.1 JPMC incorporates by reference the below JPMorgan\nChase Bank, N.A. 's Local CivilRule 56.1(b) Counterstatement ofAdditional Material Facts\n(\"CSMF\") and the supporting exhibits cited therein. JPMC further incorporates into its\nresponses its objection that Third-Party Defendant James E. Staley's cited materials cannot be\npresented at trial in a form that would be admissible as evidence. All allegations contained in\nheadings, which are not supported by a citation to admissible evidence, are also disputed for the\nreasons set forth in the accompanying responses to paragraphs.2\nI.\n\nPARTIES\n\nI.\n\nJames E. \"Jes\" Staley (Mr. Staley) worked at JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. from 1979 to\n\n2013 and held several senior positions in the later part ofhis tenure.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed.\n2.\n\nJPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. (JPMorgan) is a national bank whose main office is located\n\nin Columbus, Ohio, as designated in its Articles ofAssociation.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed.\nII.\n\nSTALEY'S TENURE AT JPMORGAN\n\n3.\n\nMr. Staley became head ofJPMorgan's Private Bank in 1999. Ex. 1, at 27:24-28:3.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed.\n\n4.\nEt 2, at 45:1847:8; 78:21-79:12.\n\n'Staley filed his motion for summary judgment and supporting materials in both Case No. 22-cv-10904\n(JSR) and Case No. 22-cv-10019 (JSR). All docket entry numbers herein refer to Case No. 22-cv-10904 (JSR).\n2 Unless otherwise specified, all citations in this document to \"JPMC Ex. _\" refer to exhibits filed by\nJPMC in opposition to Mr. Stalcy's motion for summary judgment. Citations herein to \"Staley Ex. 2\" refer to\nexhibits submitted by Mr. Staley in support of his motion for summary judgment.\n\n2\n\nEFTA02817625\n\n", "char_count": 1850}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 3 of 53\n\nJPMC Res onse: Undi uted that Stale testifi\nDisput to e extent e un er pug ct, w c is supported o y y\nSta ey's eposition testimony, requires a credibility determination.\n5.\nEx. 2, at 45:18-50:14; 248:16-249:1.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that Staley testified as such. Disputed to the extent\nthe underlying fact, which is supported only by Staley's deposition testimony,\nrequires a credibility determination.\n6.\n\nMr. Staley did not have a relationship with Epstein before meeting with him in or around\n\n2000. Ex. 2, at 45:18-50:14.\nJPMC Response: Disputed. Staley testified that he first met Jeffrey Epstein in\nthe mid-1990's at the offices of The Limited. JPMC Ex. 1 at 54:17-55:6.\n7.\n\nMr. Staley became CEO JPMorgan 's Asset and Wealth Management division in 2001. Ex.\n\n2, at 11.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed.\n8.\n\nMr. Staley became CEO of JPMorgan 's Investment Bank in 2009. Ex. 2, at 11:16-12:6.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed.\n\n9.\n\nMr. Staley ended his employment with JPMorgan in January 2013. Er. 3.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that the cited document from January 8, 2013, states\nthat Staley would be \"leaving JPMorgan Chase to join BlueMountain Capital\nManagement.\" Disputed insofar as Staley's actual employment with JPMC ended\nin February 2013. JPMC Ex. 2 at -144_R; JPMC Ex. 3 at -392.\n\n10.\n\nEpstein introduced Mr. Staley\n\nEx. 2, at 86:19-88:4.\n\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that Staley testified to being introduced tin\nla\ny Epstein.\nw Disri uted if and insofar as Staley appears to contend that any\nintroduction to\nwas the equivalent of a referral of a client by Epstein to\nthe bank. JPM x. 1 at 386:14-17 (\"I don't think [Epstein] referred clients to the\nbank. I met clients through him, but I don't think he was making a referral.\").\nDisputed if and insofar as Stale a ears to contend that this fact supports an\ninference that Epstein referred\nto be a client of the Private Bank or\nintroduced other JPMC employees to\n. JPMC Ex. 4 at 1\n... [truncated, 2030 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02817624/2 or ?id=EFTA02817624&page=2]", "char_count": 2030}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 4 of 53\n\n(testifying that he has \"not seen any evidence or an documents that would indicate\nthat Jeffrey Epstein was involved in bringing\nto JPMorgan as a Private\nBank client\"); JPMC Ex. 5 at 189:16-190:16 testifyin that Epstein never\nnor offered to introduce him to\n; JPMC Ex. 6 at\nintroduced hint to\n391:17-392:15 (testi rng that JPMC did not \"need Je Epstein to talk tin\n11.\n\nEpstein introduced Mr. Staley\n\nEx. 2, at 86.19-88:13.\n\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that Staley testified to being introduced t\nby E tein. Di uted if and insofar as Staley appears to contend 1,\nt\nas the equivalent of a referral of a client by Epstein\nto the bank. JPMC Ex. 1 at 386:14-17 (\"I don't think [Epstein] referred clients to\nthe bank. I met clients through him, but I don't think he was making a referral.\").\nFurther disputed as to materiality in light of the fact that JPMC is not aware of any\nevidence in the record tha\nis a client of the Private Bank.\n12.\n\nEpstein introduced Mr. Staley\n\nEx. 2, at 86:19-87:6.\n\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that Staley testified to being introduced t\nby Epstein. Disputed if and insofar as Staley appears to contendiPtny\nintroductions t\nwere the equivalent of referrals of\nclients by Epstein to the bank. JPMC Ex. 1 at 386:14-17 (\"I don't think [Epstein]\nreferred clients to the bank. I met clients through him, but I don't think he was\nmaking a referral.\"). Disputed if and insofar as Staley appears to contend that this\nfact supports that Epstein referred\nto be clients of the\nPrivate Bank or introduced other JPMC employees to them. JPMC Ex. 7 at 52:21were already clients of the Private\n53:18 (testifying tha\nBank when Epstein purported to be advising titem).\n13.\n\nMr. Staley used his corporate email account to communicate withEpstein. Ex. 2, at 254:4-\n\n21, 385:5-12; Ex. 4, at -1998-2019.\nJPMC Res onse:\n\nx.\nJPMC Exs. 11. 12. Ot erwise, undisputed.\n\nx.\n\nat\n\n4\n\nEFTA02817627\n\n", "char_count": 1955}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 1 22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 5 of 53\n\nDLL\n\nRELEVANT POLICIES AND PRACTICES AT JPMORGAN\n\n14.\n\nAt the relevant tittles, JPMorgan had policies implementing its Anti-Money Laundering\n\n(AML) and Sponsorship Policies known as the Anti-Money Laundering/Know Your Client Policy\n(KYC). Ex. 5, at -9752; Er. 6, at -162-163.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed to the extent that these policies were in place during\nthe relevant times. Disputed if and insofar as Staley appears to contend that the\ncited policies represent the entire universe of AML and KYC practices during the\nrelevant time period.\n15.\n\nThe policy's principles included that:\n\nx. 6, at -164.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that the cited policy contains the quoted language.\nDisputed insofar as Staley omits the fourth principle which reads\nta ey Ex.\nat -164. Disputed if and insofar as Sta ey appears to conten tat e cited policy\nor its principles represent the entire universe of AML and KYC practices during\nthe relevant time period.\n16.\n\nThe client sponsorship policy required generally tha\n\nEr. 6, at -164-165; Et 7, at 57:255S:10.\n5\n\nEFTA02817628\n\n", "char_count": 1124}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 6 of 53\n\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that the quoted language appears in the cited\nnsorship nolic\ney Ex. 6 at -162. Further pu\ninsofar\nas St ey appears to conten that the cited policy represents the entire universe of\nAMC. and KYC policies or practices during the relevant time period.\n17.\n\nThe due diligence outlined in the policy required tim\n\nEx. 6, at -164-167; Ex. 8, at 61:9-24; Ex. 9, at-1937; Et 10, at 155:20-157:7.\nJPMC Res onse: Undis tiled that bankers were ex\nut\n\nan' luso\n\nas Sta e a' ars to su est\n\na\n\ntaley Ex. 11 at -571\n\ney x. 6 at -167: to ey Ex. 11 at -571.\n18.\n\nEx. 6, at -0170; Er. 8, at 79:14-80:2; Er. 10, at 461:9-16; Et 7, at 54:20-23.\n\n-Ex.\n\n7, at 54:16-19; Er. 11, at -570.\nJPMC Res onse: Dis 'uted if and to the extent that Stale a\n\nrs to assert that\n\ne certain J MC executives to\naut i onty to exit a c lent, in practice, exit ecisious were a collective process and\nnot made unilaterally at JPMC. JPMC Ex. 13 at 155:4-156:10, 196:5-10, 199:126\n\nEFTA02817629\n\n", "char_count": 1043}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 1 22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 7 of 53\n\n201:12; JPMC Ex. 14 at 36:15-18, 46:22-47:8; JPMC Ex. 7 at 141:1-2, 143:12-25,\n216:8-217:10; JPMC Ex. 15 at 110:17-111:2, 122:22-124:1.\n19.\n\nEx. 6, at -164; Er. 12, at -576; Ex. 13,\nat -159.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed except if and insofar as Staley appears to contend\nthat the cited policies represent the entire universe of AML and KYC policies\nduring the relevant time period and to the extent the statement does not reflect the\nimportant role that other senior leadership at the bank may have with respect to\nJPMC's due diligence process. JPMC Ex. 7 at 41:5-43:8. See CSMF 111 86-90.\n20.\n\nJPMorgan had additionalpolicies andprocedures for clients who were designated \"high\n\nrisk.\" Ex. 11\n\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that the quoted language appears in the cited policy.\nDisputed if and insofar as Staley appears to contend that the cited policy represents\nthe entire universe of AML and KYC policies and procedures during the relevant\n7\n\nEFTA02817630\n\n", "char_count": 1019}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 8 of 53\n\ntime period. Further disputed to the extent that Stale omits lan\nhitch risk policy clarifying tha\n\ne from JPMC's\nSta ey\n\n.\n\nat -\n\n571.\n21.\n\nla 6, at -170; Ex. 1, at 88:19-89:19.\nJPMC Res onse: Undis • uted that\nDisput\ney\nappears to content t t t ecit • po cy represents the entire universe of AML and\nKYC policies and practices during the relevant time period. Further, disputed if\nand to the extent that Staley appears to suggest that this policy applied to clients\noutside the Private Bank as unsupported by the cited document.\n22.\n\nRisk management and compliance also had account monitoring roles at least for high-risk\n\nclients. Ex. 11, at -571; Ex. 14, at -938-939\n\nEx 11, at -571.\nJPMC Res onse: Undis uted that under the cited .lici\n\nSt ey Ex. 11 at -571. Dispu\nan\ninso ar as Sta ey appears to conten t t the cited policies represent the entire\nuniverse of AML and KYC policies and practices during the relevant time period.\nFurther, disputed if and to the extent that Staley appears to suggest that this policy\napplied to clients outside the Private Bank as unsupported by the cited documents.\n23.\n\nJPMorgan's policy for identifying and investigating unusual or suspicious activity\n\ninstructed that\n\n8\n\nEFTA02817631\n\n", "char_count": 1290}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 9 of 53\n\nEx. 9, at -134\n\nEr. 9, at -134.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that the cited policy contains the noted Ian\nDi uted to the extent Stale omits the li 's conclusion tha\n\n.\n\nSta ey Ex. 9 at -134.\n24.\n\nEr. 9, at -138; Ex. 15, at 25:22-26:4; Er.\n10, at 82:19-83:7; 100:1-102:19.\nEr. 15,\nat 27:5-16; Ex. 10, at 99:13-24.\nEr. 15, at\n257:16-258:16; Ex. 10, at 485:8-486:24.\nEr. 10, at 104:11, 485:8-486:24.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed.\n25.\n\nMr. Staley did not have responsibilities to conduct due diligence on any individual private\n\nbanking clients while he was head of the Private Bank or Asset & Wealth Management, or CEO\nof the firmament Bank Ex. 1, at 44:8-47:17.\nJPMC Response: Disputed. JPMC's due diligence process was comprehensive\nand holistic, and senior executives, like Staley was at the time, had important roles\nto play in the process. Staley was Epstein's primary contact and was intimately\ninvolved in Epstein's due diligence process, including by communicating directly\nwith Epstein about concerns JPMC employees had stemming from news stories\nconnecting Epstein to sex crimes. JPMC Ex. 7 at 41:5-43:8, 119:10-13; JPMC Ex.\n16; JPMC Ex. 15 at 63:8-65:3. See CSMF\n56-62, 86-90. Moreover, any\n9\n\nEFTA02817632\n\n", "char_count": 1275}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 10 of 53\n\nemployee who learned of client misconduct that could negatively impact the\nreputation of the bank had an obligation to share that infommtion. See, e.g., JPMC\na. 17.\n26.\n-Ex.\n\n7, at 58:13-24.\nJPMC Res onse:\n\nJPMC Ex. 5 at 32:8-12.\n\nJPMC Ex. 15 at 21.11-24: JPMC a. 7 at 23:20-24:4;\n:8-16.\n\n27.\nlEx. 7, at 16:17-19:25; Er. 16, at -617-622.\nJPMC Res onset Dis r uted mso\n\nJPMC Ex. 15 at 21:11-24; JPMC Ex. 7 at 23:20-24:4;\nJPMC Ex. 5 at 32:8-12. 42:8-16.\n28.\n\n7, at 18:14-19:13; Ex. 17, 747:14-750:9; Ex. 18, at - 722-766; Ex. 19, at 008-011.\nJPMC R\nJPMC Ex. 15 at 21:11-24• JPMC Ex. 7 at\n32:8-12, 42:8-16.\n\n. - 4. , JPMC Ex. 5 at\n\n29.\n\nF.x. 20, at 180:15-24.\n\nEr. 20, at 326:1-330:23.\n10\n\nEFTA02817633\n\n", "char_count": 767}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 11 of 53\n\nJPMC Res NM: Dis uted\nMr. Cut er's approv or, potential y, e approva\nicer) was also required for JPMC to retain a client\nEx. 5 at -758 -759.\nStaley Ex. 20 at 326:21-25;\n328:7-10; 329:23-330:22; JPMC Ex. 7 at X79:1-6; 86:7-87:4; JPMC Ex. 18\nat 112:5-114:14; JPMC Ex. 19 at 110:25-111:8, 117:7-17, 118:23-119:6, 122:6132:16. Where no legal or compliance concern was at issue, it was appropriate for\na JPMC businessperson, such as Staley, to decide whether to retain the client.\nJPMC Ex. 6 at 326:21-327:4, 333:15-334:5. See CSMF ¶ 120.\nIV.\n\nJPMORGAN'S RELATIONSHIP WITH EPSTEIN\n\n30.\n\n'Ex. 21, at -203; Ex. 22, at 30:24-31:9, 195:8-18; Et 71.\nJPMC Res once: Undis uted that Stale\n\nEx. 21 states that the\nt oes not support t e assertion t t\nStaley Ex. 21 at -204. Otherwise,\n\nspit\nE.Y. 13.\n\n31.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed.\n32.\nEx. 24, at 6:17-8:8.\nJPMC Res once:\n\nSee JPMC Ex. 20; JPMC Ex. 21. See\na so CSMF\n\n79.\n\n33.\nEt 25, at 7:22-25, 56:17-23; Et 12, at -577.\nJPMC Res onse\n\n11\n\nEFTA02817634\n\n", "char_count": 1057}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 12 of 53\n\nStaley Ex. 6. See also CSMF 176.\n34.\nEr. 26, at 11:12-17; a\n\n12, at -577.\n\nJPMC\n\nSta ey Ex. 6. See a so CS\n\n75.\n\n35.\n\nEx. 26,\n\nat 26:•17-18.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed.\n36.\n\nEr. 12, at\n\n-577. I\n\nEr. 12, at Et 12, at -577\n\n577.\n\nEx. 12. at 577\n\nIEr.\n\n12, at -577.\nJPMC Res onse: Undis uted tha\nDisputed if and to the extent Staley appears to contend that these facts support an\ninference that DDR approvals were a decision point that could lead to the exit of\nEpstein from the bank. Ms. Keating testified that \"[n]ot approving a DDR isn't\nhow you exit a client.\" JPMC Ex. 7 at 141:1-2; see JPMC Ex. 15 at 110:17-111:2.\n\ntaley Ex. 12 at -575.\nemployees viewed eir approva\nas carrying out the decision to retain Epstein as a client. JPMC\no pstem's\nEx. 7 at 140:13-18, 141:12-23; 142:25-143:10; JPMC Ex. 15 at 242:16-20; 243:812. See CSMF 11 87-90.\n37.\nEr. 27, at -977; Ex. 28, at -554-555.\n12\n\nEFTA02817635\n\n", "char_count": 970}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 13 of 53\n\nJPMC Res onse: Undis uted that\nDisputed if and to the extent Staley appears to contend that these facts support an\ninference that DDR approvals were a decision point that could lead to the exit of\nEpstein from the bank. Ms. Keating testified that \" not\nrovin a DDR isn't\nat\n141:1-2\nhow on exit a client.\" JPMC Ex. 7\ney Ex. 12 at -57\nemp oyees view t eu approv o Epstem's DDRs as carrying out the\ndecision to retain Epstein as a client. JPMC Ex. 7 at 140:13-18, 141:12-23; 142:25143:10; JPMC Ex. 15 at 242:16-20; 243:8-12. See CSMF ¶¶ 87-90.\n38.\nlEx. 1, at 157:23-58:13.\nJPMC Response: Disputed. The cited de sition testimon of JPMC 's co\ndesi ee Francis Pearn establishes onl\n\nrate\n\nJPMC Ex. 22 at 157:23-158:13. See a so JPMC Ex. 19 at 16:\ntesti mg t i t\nhe was not aware that Mr. Staley visited Epstein's property in New Mexico).\n39.\n\nlEx. 68.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed.\nV.\n\nJPMORGAN'S RESPONSE TO DEROGATORY INFORMATION REGARDING\nEPSTEIN\n\n40.\n\nEpstein was indicted in Florida state court forfelony solicitation ofprostitution on July\n\n19, 2006. Er. 30.\nJPMC Response: Disputed to the extent the cited document does not support the\nassertion that Epstein was indicted on July 19, 2006. Otherwise, undisputed.\n\n13\n\nEFTA02817636\n\n", "char_count": 1296}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 14 of 53\n\n41.\nEx. 8, at 65:9-66:15; Ex. 31, at -285-288.\nJPMC Res onse\ntae\n\nx. at 65:9-66:15.\n\n42.\n\nEx. 32\nEx. 8, at 65:9-66:10.\nJPMC Res onse: Undis uted that the cit\n\ney Ex. 6 at -168. See a so\nSta ey Ex. 11.\n43.\n\nMr. Staley did not object to the determination of keeping Epstein solely as a banking client\n\nand on a reactive, client service basis. Et 8, at 386:5-390:2; Ex. 2, at 123:13- 25.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed.\n44.\n\nMr. Staley did not object to Epstein's designation as high-risk, nor did he ever ask anyone\n\nto change Epstein's high-risk designation. Ex. 1, at 146:16-148:17.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed.\n45.\nEx. 33.\nla. 33.\nJPMC Res onse: Dis uted if and to the extent that Stale a\n\nars to su est that\nThat\nconclusion was necessarily written later as the contemporaneous \"outcome\" of the\n14\n\nEFTA02817637\n\n", "char_count": 873}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 15 of 53\n\nmeeting was that \"Catherine will go back to JES to tell him we are uncomfortable\nwith Epstein and do not want to go to Cutler for approval.\" JPMC Ex. 143. See\nCSMF1/1 100-02.\n46.\nEx. 34, at -787; Ex. 35; Er. 36;\nEx. 37; Ex. 38, at 133:5-17.\nJPMC Re\n\nuse: Undis uted that\n\nspute' to e\nextent t t to ey ne ects i sown mvo vement m t i e easion to retain Epstein.\nJPMC Ex. 24; JPMC Ex. 25. See CSMF 7I 100-02.\n47.\nEr. 37; Ex. 72, at -30-31.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed.\n48.\nEx. 39, at - 305-306;\nEx. 40, at -738-742; Er. 41, at -038-041; Er. 42, at -661-666; Ex. 43, at - 816-17; Er. 44; Er. 45,\nat -272-273; Er. 46, at -30-31; Ex. 47, at -179-180.\nJPMC Response:\n49.\nEx. 48, at -305; Er.\n49, at -761-762; Er. 50, at -519-520; Ex. 51; Er. 52, at -651-660; Ext 53.\nJPMC R\n\n50.\n\nMr. Staley was unaware of Epstein's practice of withdrawing large amounts of cash. Ex.\n\n2, at 30:12-31:3.\n15\n\nEFTA02817638\n\n", "char_count": 962}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 16 of 53\n\nJPMC Response: Disputed. Epstein emailed Mary Erdoes on September 7, 2011,\nrelaying that \"jes told me there was [an] [issue] reg cash with drawals\" [sic]. JPMC\na. 26; see also JPMC Ex. 27.\n51.\n\nJPMC Ex. 15 at 255:4-17.\n52.\nEx. 3; Er. 55.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed.\nVI.\n\nJPMORGAN INQUIRIES INTO EPSTEIN AND MR. STALEY\n\n53.\n\nIn July 2019, Epstein was arrested on a sex-trajficking charge. Ex. 56, at iv.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed.\n\n54.\n\nlEr. 57, at 9:2-11:15.\n\n55.\nEr. 58; Er. 4; Et 57,\nat 19:2-11, 38:18-40:1.\n16\n\nEFTA02817639\n\n", "char_count": 593}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 17 of 53\n\nJPMC Response: Undisputed.\n56.\n\nEr. 4, at -2000, -2005.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed.\n57.\nEr. 61; Er. 57, at 41:144:25.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed.\n58.\n\nlEr. 57,\nat 37:18-38:2, 41:3-45:8; Ex. 61, at -702.\nEr. 59; Ex. 60; Er.\n29.\nJPMC Res\n\nnse\n\n59.\nlEx. 58; Er. 4; Er. 57, at 19:2-11.\n\n17\n\nEFTA02817640\n\n\n\n[═══ TRANSCRIPT ═══]\nCase 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 19 of 53  63.  -Ex.  64, at 221-223.  JPMC Res onse  64.  F&. 64, at -221-223. JPMC Res i onse  taley Ex. 64 at -221  . at 223.  ee i . at -223; JPMC Ex. 28 at 5. 65.  lEx. 64, at 221-223.  19  EFTA02817642", "char_count": 650}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 18 of 53\n\nJPMC Res onse\nSta es'\nx. 4 at -998. -012.\n\n60.\n\nEx. 4, at -20°51\n\nEx. 4, at -1998, -2000.\nJPMC Re i i use.\n\ney x. 4 at -005, -998,\n-000.\n\nto ey Ex. 4 at -998, -012.\n61.\n\nEx. 12, at -596; Ex. 62, at -903; Er. 63, at -548.\nJPMC Res onse:\nStaley Ex. 62 at -903: Staley Ex. 63 at -548\n\n62.\nF.x. 64, at -221-223; Er. 57, at 22:21-23:4.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed.\n18\n\nEFTA02817641\n\n\n\n[═══ TRANSCRIPT ═══]\nCase 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 20 of 53  JPMC Res onse eStaley  .  66.  [Ex. 57, at 8:21-9:15.  67.  JPMC Ex. 29 at 27:5-28:20. 68.  SY  61.  20  EFTA02817643", "char_count": 648}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 19 of 53\n\n63.\n\n-Ex.\n\n64, at 221-223.\n\nJPMC Res onse\n\n64.\n\nF&. 64,\nat -221-223.\nJPMC Res i onse\n\ntaley Ex. 64 at -221\n\n. at 223.\n\nee i . at -223; JPMC Ex. 28 at 5.\n65.\n\nlEx. 64, at 221-223.\n\n19\n\nEFTA02817642\n\n", "char_count": 264}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 20 of 53\n\nJPMC Res onse\neStaley\n\n.\n\n66.\n\n[Ex. 57, at 8:21-9:15.\n\n67.\n\nJPMC Ex. 29 at 27:5-28:20.\n68.\n\nSY\n\n61.\n\n20\n\nEFTA02817643\n\n", "char_count": 185}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 21 of 53\n\nJPMC Res onse:\n\nJPMC Ex. 31 at -690\n\nWNW Ex. 31 at -\n\n.1 M\n\nx. 32 at -705; JPMC Ex. 33.\n\n69.\nEX. 66, at -580; Er. 57. at 53:4-54:2.\nJPMC Response\nJPMC Ex.\n29 at 53:24-54:2, 60:17-23; JPMC Ex. 34.\n70.\n\nr. 17, at\n\n750:10-19; Er. 7, at 20:17-20.\nJPMC Res a onse\nt ey\nnot\ny c ose\nt e extent o Is consi era e re awns alp\nwit\na\na\npstein, including to important\ndecisionmakers within JPMC who believed Staley had only a close professional\nrelationship with Epstein. JPMC Ex. 19 at 13:11-16:20, 17:21-18:3, 31:8-18;\nJPMC Ex. 7 at 119:5-13, 200:17-19, 23:20-24:4; JPMC Ex. 35 at 31:19-32:1.\nJPMC was not aware that Staley's relationship with Epstein extended far beyond\nprofessional matters. See JPMC Ex. 36 at 435:18-444:8; JPMC Ex. 37; JPMC Ex.\n38; JPMC Ex. 39. See CSMF f¶ 6-43.\nVII.\n\nTHE CURRENT LITIGATION\n\n71.\n\nJPMorgan did not sue Mr. Staley before 2023. Ex. 67.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed.\n\n72.\n\nJPMorgan sued Mr. Staley in 2023, after it was sued by the Government of the U.S. Virgin\n\nIslands and the Jane Doe plaintiff Et 67.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed.\n21\n\nEFTA02817644\n\n", "char_count": 1137}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 22 of 53\n\n73.\n\nThe bank has identified seven instances starting in \"late 2009 or early 2010\" in which Mr.\n\nStaley allegedly \"vouch[edf\"for Epstein's character and conduct. Ex. 68.\nJPMC Response: Disputed. JPMC stated that Staley \"vouched for Epstein's good\ncharacter and conduct on at least the\" specified seven occasions starting in late\n2009 or early 2010. Staley Ex. 68 at Resp. to Topic No. 25 (emphasis added). See\nCSMF 63-73.\n\n9\n\n74.\n\nThe alleged \"vouching\" lists Mr. Staley telling other bank employees things like \"that he\n\nknew and trusted Epstein\"; that Epstein \"had paid his debt to society\"; and that Mr. Staley had\n\"a goodrelationship with him.\" Ex. 68.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that JPMC identified the quoted language as\nexamples of Staley's vouching for Epstein's character and conduct. Disputed to\nthe extent Staley contends that his vouching for Epstein using this language during\nthese cited conversations was the extent of his defense of Epstein. Staley was an\nintegral part of the Epstein relationship and JPMC employees relied on Staley's\njudgment in making decisions related to Epstein's retention. See JPMC Ex. 19 at\n163:3-164:11, 38:12-16 (\"I relied on, you know, Mr. Staley's sense of the client\nbecause Mr. Staley was in close — had a close relationship with him.\"); JPMC Ex.\n15 at 63:8-24. (\"As a senior member of the firm and a member of the operating\ncommittee, who continued to work on [Epstein's] account in some way or fashion,\nsome of it visible to me, some of it not visible to me, Jes was part of that\nrelationship. And I would have expected, if there was something that I should have\nknown, he would have told me. We relied upon Jes, in this instance and in . . .\nothers, as it related to his judgment about an account. And in this case we're talking\nabout Mr. Epstein's account.\"); JPMC Ex. 18 at 50:20-22 (\"No one had a senior\nrelationship with Mr. Epstein like Mr. Staley.\"); JPMC Ex. 7 at 119:10-13, 20\n... [truncated, 3194 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02817624/21 or ?id=EFTA02817624&page=21]", "char_count": 3194}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 23 of 53\n\nconduct\nthat he did not share with JPMC. See,\ne.g., Staley Ex. 69 at Resp. to Topic II; JPMC Ex. 36 at 435:18-444:8; JPMC Ex.\n42. See CSMF ¶¶ 6-43. JPMC does not concede any argument as to Staley's\npersonal knowledge with respect to Epstein's alleged sex trafficking.\n76.\n\nMr. Staley's asserted vouchingfor Epstein did not violate any policy at the bank. Ex. I, at\n\n112:4-22.\nJPMC Response: Disputed. Each version of the JPMC Code of Conduct in effect\nfrom 2006 through 2012 emphasized that all JPMC employees must \"conduct the\nfirm's business in accordance with the highest ethical standards, respecting the\nfirm's customers, suppliers, and other business counterparties, dealing responsibly\nwith the firm's assets, and complying with applicable legal and regulatory\nrequirements.\" E.g., JPMC Ex. 17. JPMC's Code of Conduct also expressly\nprohibited, among other things, engaging in outside activities that, even if outside\nthe scope of employment, \"reflect adversely on JPMorgan Chase or give rise to a\nreal or apparent conflict of interest with your duties to the firm.\" E.g., JPMC Ex.\n17. JPMC employees are also \"expected to conduct the firm's business in full\ncompliance with both the letter and the spirit of the law, the Code, and any other\npolicies and procedures that may be applicable.\" E.g., JPMC Ex. 17. A reasonable\njury could conclude that Staley's ongoing advocacy for Epstein to be retained as a\nclient, in the face of resistance by other members of the Private Bank, while\nwithholdin material information about one or more of Epstein's conduc\nand Staley's close personal relationship with Epstein and his affiliates\ne to con orm to both the letter and the spirit of the firm's high ethical standards.\nSee also Staley Ex. 69 at Resp. to Topic II; JPMC Ex. 43; JPMC Ex. 44; JPMC\nEx. 45; JPMC Ex. 46; JPMC Ex. 47; JPMC Ex. 48; JPMC Ex. 49; JPMC Ex. 50;\nJPMC Ex. 51 JPMC Ex. 17; JPMC Ex. 52; JPMC Ex. 53 JPMC Ex. 54.\n77.\n... [truncated, 2799 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02817624/22 or ?id=EFTA02817624&page=22]", "char_count": 2799}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 24 of 53\n\nbeyond \"the amount JPMorgan will pay to the [Doe class] to settle this action, in\nthe amount of $290,000,000.00\" JPMC Ex. 55 at 8-9; JPMC Ex. 56 at 13.\nOtherwise, undisputed.\n\n24\n\nEFTA02817647\n\n", "char_count": 260}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 25 of 53\n\nJPMORGAN CHASE BANK, N.A.'S LOCAL CIVIL RULE 56.1(B)\nCOUNTERSTATEMENT OF ADDITIONAL MATERIAL FACTS\nI.\n\nJane Doe 1 testified tha\nJane Doe 1 further testified that she\nJPMC Ex. 57 at 140:6-149:20. Jane Doe 1\n\ntestified that sh\n\nJPMC Ex. 57 at 151:9-20,\n\n154:3-155:17.\n2.\n\nOn July 7, 2021, Jane Doe 1 emailed\n\nJPMC Ex. 58.\n3.\n\nStaley testified that h\nStaley further testified that he did not\nJPMC Ex. 36 at 433:3-444:8.\n\n4.\n\nStaley testified that he did not \"observe anything that caused [him] to question\n\nwhether Epstein was engaged in sex trafficking.\" JPMC Ex. 36 at 522:19-22.\n5.\n\nMultiple women excluded Staley by name from releases they signed with the\n\nEpstein Estate. JPMC Ex. 59; JPMC Ex. 60.\n1.\n\nJes Staley Had a Close Personal Relationship With Epstein\n\nStaley Exchanged Suggestive Emails with Epstein About Women\n6.\n\nOn August 30, 2009, Epstein emailed Staley, \"how long London? do you need\n\nanything there?\" Staley responded, \"Yep.\" JPMC Ex. 61.\n7.\n\nOn September 2, 2009, Epstein emailed\nJPMC\n\nEx. 62.\n\nEFTA02817648\n\n", "char_count": 1094}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 26 of 53\n\n8.\n\nOn December 4, 2009, Epstein emailed Staley, \"you were with laity , [sic] and I\n\nhad to put up with .\n\n.\" and attached the following suggestive photograph of a young woman:\n\nJPMC Ex. 63; JPMC Ex. 64.\n9.\n\nThat same day, Staley responded to Epstein, writing \"Don't tell me a\n\nwine.\" JPMC Ex. 63.\n10.\n\nOn December 20, 2009, Epstein emailed Staley the following photograph of a\n\nyoung woman:\n\n2\n\nEFTA02817649\n\n", "char_count": 476}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 27 of 53\n\nJPMC Ex. 65; JPMC Ex. 66.\n11.\n\nOn June 16, 2010, Staley wrote to Epstein \"[i]s she free tonight?\" Epstein\n\nresponded, \"call me.\" Staley replied, \"I'm with A.\" JPMC Ex. 67.\n12.\n\nOn July 9, 2010, Staley e-mailed Epstein, \"That was fun. Say hi to Snow =.'.)\n\nEpstein responded, \"what character would you like next.\" Staley replied, \"Beauty and the Beast\n....\" Epstein responded, \"well one side is availble [sic].\" JPMC Ex. 68.\nStaley Had a Close Persona! Relationship with Epstein\n13.\n\nOn August 3, 2008, Staley emailed Epstein shortly after he began serving his\n\ncriminal sentence and wrote, \"Just thinking about you.\" JPMC Ex. 69.\n14.\n\nOn February 26, 2009, Epstein sent an email\n\nI.IPMC Ex. 70.\n15.\n\nOn May 27, 2010, Epstein emailet:l\nJPMC Ex. 71.\n3\n\nEFTA02817650\n\n", "char_count": 831}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 28 of 53\n\n16.\n\nOn January 22, 2011, Epstein emailed\nJPMC Ex. 72.\n\n17.\n\nOn February 26, 2011, Staley emailed Epstein calling him \"Family.\" JPMC Ex.\n\n18.\n\nOn March 3, 2011, Epstein emailed Staley, writing, \"Told you ----family.\" Staley\n\n73.\n\nresponded the same day, writing \"family.\" JPMC Ex. 39.\n19.\n\nOn March 4, 2011, Staley emailed Epstein saying that he counted Epstein \"as one\n\nof our deepest friends. And most honest of people.\" JPMC Ex. 38.\n20.\n\nOn March 5, 2011, Epstein emails Staley in response, calling him \"family.\"\n\nJPMC Ex. 38.\n21.\n\nOn March 7, 2011, Epstein emailed Staley saying \"[I] forgot to say thanks . .\n\nFamily.\" JPMC Ex. 74.\n22.\n\nOn March 10, 2011, Epstein emailed Staley, writing \"yup family dont [sic]\n\nworry.\" JPMC Ex. 75.\n23.\n\nOn March 18, 2011, Epstein emailed Staley saying \"Dear family member„ don't\n\nfret[.]\" JPMC Ex. 76.\n24.\n\nOn May 3, 2011, Epstein emailed\n\nJPMC Ex. 77 (emphasis added).\n25.\n\nOn May 19, 2011, Epstein emailed\nJPMC Ex. 78.\n\n26.\n\nOn September 2, 2011, Epstein emailed\nJPMC Ex. 79.\n\n4\n\nEFTA02817651\n\n", "char_count": 1101}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 29 of 53\n\n27.\n\nOn August 23, 2012, Staley emailed Epstein, writing, \"I can't tell you how much\n\nyour friendship has meant to me. Thank you deeply for the last few weeks. All will be fine, and\nTo my most cherished friend, Jes.\" Epstein responded, \"I\nappreciate you and your thoughts.\" JPMC Ex. 80.\n28.\n\nEpstein named Stale)\nJPMC Ex. 81; JPMC Ex. 82.\n\nEpstein Provided Assistance with\n29.\n\nGraduate School Admissions\n\nOn April 27, 2009. Epstein emailed Staley, writing `-can\n\nmeet have dinner\n\nlunch a weekend with any of the following seth lloyd mit quantum computing.. murray gell-man\n, santa-fe institute quarks „ brian\ntheory,\n\nColumbia -string theory„ leonard Suaskind „ strings\n\nkrause, origins institute phoenix arizona.. lee smolin perimiter institute, loop\n\nquantum gravity . she can see the large hadron collider in switzerland. private tour [sic].\" JPMC\nEx. 83.\n30.\n\nStaley forwarded the email tc\n\n, writing \"This is from\n\nuncle Jeffrey. Add Lisa Randell at Harvard.\" JPMC Ex. 83.\n31.\n\nOn October 24, 2009, Staley forwarded\n\nfeedback Epstein provided\n\non a draft of her scholarship essay. JPMC Ex. 84.\n32.\n\nOn January 11, 2010.\n\nforwarded to Staley an email exchange she\n\nhad with Epstein, thanking him for inviting her to a physics conference in California. JPMC Ex.\n85.\n33.\n\nOn September 24, 2010, Staley forwarded to Epstein an email froa\n\nabout a professor at Columbia University and asking Epstein if he could \"get to this professor at\nColumbia.\" On September 25, 2010, Epstein responded, \"in a snap.\" JPMC Ex. 86.\n\n5\n\nEFTA02817652\n\n", "char_count": 1603}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 30 of 53\n\n34.\n\nOn November 11, 2010, Epstein emailed Staley in response to an email chain\n\nabout\n\napplication to Columbia University, writing \"she can sit with Richard\n\nAxel when I get back, he won the Nobel prize .. he has guaranteed me.\" JPMC Ex. 87.\nOn January 19, 2011, Staley forwarded to Epstein an email exchange between a\n\n35.\n\nColumbia professor and\n\nregarding her GRE scores \"not seem[ing] to be a problem\n\naccording to my sources.\" JPMC Ex. 88.\n36.\n\nAlso on January 19, 2011, Epstein emailed Staley, writing'\n\nis now 70-30\n\nup from 45-55.\" JPMC Ex. 89.\nStaley Made Personal Visits/Vacations to Epstein Properties\n37.\n\nStaley visited Epstein on July 25, 2006, a day after Epstein's indictment. JPMC\n\n38.\n\nOn December 31, 2008, while Epstein was incarcerated, Staley made plans to\n\nEx. 90.\n\nvisit Epstein in Palm Beach, Florida. JPMC Ex. 91.\nOn October 23, 2009, Epstein emailed\n\n39.\n\nJPMC Ex. 92.\n40.\n\nOn October 30, 2009, Staley emailed Epstein asking if Epstein could go to Santa\n\nFe, while Staley himself was at Epstein's New Mexico ranch. Epstein responded, \"not today.\"\nJPMC Ex. 93.\n41.\n\nOn November I, 2009, Staley emailed Epstein from Epstein's Zorro Ranch in\n\nNew Mexico, writing \"So when all hell breaks lose [sic], and the world is crumbling, I will come\nhere, and be at peace. Presently, I'm in the hot tub with a\n\nof\n\nwine. This is an\n\n6\n\nEFTA02817653\n\n", "char_count": 1431}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 31 of 53\n\namazing place. Truly amazing. Next time, we're here together. I owe you much. And I deeply\nappreciate our friendship. I have few so profound.\" JPMC Ex. 37.\n42.\n\nOn January 8, 2010, Epstein emailed Staley about a visit to his private island in\n\nUSVI, writing, \"my car and driver, former dea armed. will pick you up in st\n\nwe have all\n\nthe on field permits.. helicopter also availble for a tour around , ... remember I own the two big\nmarinas.. yacht haven grand, in st\n\nand the marina at red hook... you can use my atv's jet\n\nski ,gym etc. , i will organize the harbor at Norman island if you like, in the bvil . as well as\nlunch at guana.\" JPMC Ex. 94.\n43.\n\nOn January 22, 2011, Staley emailed Epstein about a visit to Epstein's island in\n\nUSVI, writing \"What a paradise. When I retire, I'm going to put a mooring in front of your dock\nfor my boat[.] Amazing place.\" JPMC Ex. 95.\nStaley Shared ConfidentialInformation With Epstein\n44.\n\nStaley shared details of his salary negotiations with JPMC with Epstein, and\n\nsought his advice regarding the salary demands he would make of JPMC. JPMC Ex. 96.\n45.\n\nOn multiple occasions, Staley shared with Epstein confidential information about\n\ntransactions the Bank was structuring or exploring. JPMC Ex. 97; JPMC Ex. 98; JPMC Ex. 99;\nJPMC Ex. 100; JPMC Ex. 101; JPMC Ex. 102.\n46.\n\nStaley discussed the confidential status of other Bank clients with Epstein. JPMC\n\nEx. 103.\n47.\n\nStaley shared information protected by the attorney-client privilege about\n\nEpstein's ongoing litigation against JPMC with Epstein. JPMC Ex. 104.\n48.\n\nStaley solicited feedback from Epstein o\n\nJPMC Ex. 105.\n\n7\n\nEFTA02817654\n\n", "char_count": 1710}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 32 of 53\n\n49.\n\nStaley kept Epstein informed about the status of the Bank's investigation into the\n\nallegations against him i\n\nMarch 2011. JPMC Ex. 106; PMC Ex. 107.\n\nStaley Maintained a Close Relationship With Epstein Even After Leaving JPMC\n50.\n\nStaley testified that he had last spoken to Epstein in either October or November\n\n2015 because he became the CEO of Barclays. JPMC Ex. 1 at 393:21-394:2.\n51.\n\nOn October 17, 2015, Staley emailed\n\nJPMC Ex. 108.\n52.\n\n, writing,\n\nOn November 27, 2016, Epstein emailed Staley's\n\n\"could you ask\n\n[sic] if he would like to considered for treasury.\"\n\nresponded that\n\n\"[s]poke with him. He said not yet, but thanks.\" JPMC Ex. 109.\n53.\n\nOn February 6, 2017, Epstein emailed\n\n, writing, \"can you ask.\n\nhis opnion [sic] of veronique Weill she wants to join rothschild.\"\n\nresponded, \"He\n\nthinks she is great and is a big fan of hers. Good recommendation for rothschild.\" JPMC Ex.\n110.\n54.\n\nOn February 23, 2017, Epstein emailed\n\nJPMC Ex. 111.\n55.\n\nOn February 13, 2020, Barclays PLC issued a Director effectiveness assessment\n\ndisclosing a regulatory investigation into Staley's relationship with Epstein. The assessment\nstated that \"Mr. Staley also confirmed to the Board that he has had no contact whatsoever with\nMr. Epstein at any time since taking up his role as Barclays Group CEO in December 2015.\"\nJPMC Ex. 112. That same day, Staley told the U.K. press It has been very well known I had a\n\n8\n\nEFTA02817655\n\n", "char_count": 1508}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 33 of 53\n\nprofessional relationship with Jeffrey Epstein. It goes back to 2000 when I was asked to run the\nJP\n\nprivate bank and he was already a client when I joined the private bank. The\n\nrelationship was maintained during my time at JP\n\nbut as I left JP\n\nthe\n\nrelationship tapered off quite significantly... Obviously I thought I knew him well and I didn't.\nFor sure, with hindsight with what we know now, I deeply regret having any relationship with\nJeffrey.\" JPMC Ex. 23.\nII.\n\nStaley Was Responsible for JPMC's Relationship With Epstein\n\nStaley Was the Most Senior JPMC Employee Responsiblefor Epstein's Accounts\n56.\n\nJPMC's former General Counsel, Stephen Cutler, testified: Q: \"Between 2007 and\n\n2012, what was your understanding of Mr. Staley's relationship with Jeffrey Epstein?\" A: \"My\nunderstanding at that time was that he had a close business relationship, that he was the primary\ninterface with Mr. Epstein among JPMorgan personnel, that he liked Mr. Epstein, that he trusted\nMr. Epstein, and he thought highly of Mr. Epstein.\" JPMC Ex. 19 at 13:11-20.\n57.\n\nThe head of JPMC's Asset & Wealth Management division, Mary Erodes,\n\ntestified that \"Mr. Staley was the most-senior representative and relationship person for Mr.\nEpstein.\" JPMC Ex. 18 at 75:17-19. Ms. Erdoes further testified that \"[n]o one had a senior\nrelationship with Mr. Epstein like Mr. Staley did.\" JPMC Ex. 18 at 50:20-22.\n58.\n\nFormer Global Head of Compliance, William Langford, testified that \"Epstein\n\nwas Jes Staley's client\" and that \"Jes owned the client relationship\" with Epstein. JPMC Ex. 113\nat 309:20-23, 336:4-14.\n59.\n\nMary =,\n\nwho was one of Epstein's private bankers in JPMC's Private Bank,\n\ntestified that \"Jes was one of the primary people to work with Jeffrey's account.\" JPMC Ex. 114\nat 64:10-11.\n\n9\n\nEFTA02817656\n\n", "char_count": 1869}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 34 of 53\n\n60.\n\nFormer CEO of JPMC's U.S. Private Bank, John Duffy, testified that \"Jes was the\n\nsenior person on that [Epstein] relationship.\" JPMC Ex. 15 at 62:3-5, 64:14-21, 143:9-17.\n61.\n\nWilliam Sheridan, who was a market manager and region head for the Northeast\n\nregion in JPMC's U.S. Private Bank while Epstein was a client, testified that \"Jes was intimately\ninvolved in really every aspect of what we did with Jeffrey Epstein, and was viewed as the senior\nbanker by virtue of the things that they did with respect to certain introductions of prospects,\ninvolvement in the [Highbridge] transaction.\" JPMC Ex. 14 at 74:2-7.\n62.\n\nCatherine Keating, who preceded John Duffy as CEO of JPMC's U.S. Private\n\nBank, testified \"Jes was the sort of de facto primary relationship person with Jeffrey Epstein.\"\nJPMC Ex. 7 at 200:17-19. Keating further testified that she believed \"Mr. Epstein viewed\n[Staley] as his relationship manager. Jes would raise our questions with him.\" JPMC Ex. 7 at\n119:10-13.\nStaley Vouchedfor Epstein\n63.\n\nStephen Cutler, testified that \"Jes Staley was vouching for [Epstein].\" JPMC Ex.\n\n19 at 169:7-12. Cutler further testified that Staley, in response to the desires of others that JPMC\nexit Epstein as a client, told him that Epstein had \"turned a page\" \"paid his debt to society\"\n\"turned a comer\" and \"was on the straight and narrow.\" JPMC Ex. 19 at 58:23-60:4, 163:3164:11.\n64.\n\nMary Erdoes testified that Staley \"was Mr. Epstein's advocate in the [Blank and\n\nwas the senior relationship manager for Mr. Epstein.\" JPMC Ex. 115 at 165:6-8. Ms. Erdoes\nfurther testified that Staley had a \"very different\" characterization of Epstein than the press\nreports following his arrest. JPMC Ex. 115 at 213:17-21.\n\n10\n\nEFTA02817657\n\n", "char_count": 1808}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 35 of 53\n\n65.\n\nWilliam Langford testified that, with respect to Epstein's conviction in 2008 on\n\nstate charges for solicitation of prostitution and procurement of a minor for prostitution, Staley\ntold him that Epstein \"didn't do it, shouldn't have pled guilty, et cetera, wasn't responsible for it\"\nand that Epstein's lawyers were working to get the guilty plea \"thrown out.\" JPMC Ex. 113 at\n323:6-14, 370:10-17.\n66.\n\nJustin Nelson, another of Epstein's private bankers in the U.S. Private Bank,\n\ntestified that he raised his concerns about Epstein to Staley prior to becoming Epstein's private\nbanker and that Staley told him \"that it was okay to do this and I trust [Epstein], have a good\nrelationship with him\" and that Nelson \"accepted that and moved on.\" JPMC Ex. 5 at 117:1822.\n67.\n\nJohn Duffy testified that after recommending to Staley that the Bank exit Epstein\n\nas a client in 2011, \"Jes rebuffed me, said, don't see the need for that. I would trust Jeffrey with\nmembers of my family, his daughters.\" JPMC Ex. 15 at 69:5-8.\n68.\n\nLisa Waters, who led the supervisory management team in JPMC's U.S. and\n\nGlobal Private Bank, testified that Staley told her, \"I did speak with him—Mr. Epstein—and he\nsaid it was a misunderstanding and he made a mistake. And I do feel comfortable. I have\nsocialized with him and my family.\" JPMC Ex. 116 at 106:24-107:23.\n69.\n\nWilliam Sheridan testified that \"our recommendations were to fire this client in\n\n2008, but we were unable to execute on that because of Jes's stated comfort level with his client,\nand that somehow he had turned the corner, and that he would be comfortable in monitoring\nbusiness activity closely. So, unfortunately, this is why we are where we are in 2010 or 2011.\"\nJPMC Ex. 14 at 184:21-185:5.\nJPMC Employees and Executives Relied on Staley's Views About Epstein\n\n11\n\nEFTA02817658\n\n", "char_count": 1906}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 36 of 53\n\n70.\n\nStephen Cutler testified that he \"absolutely\" relied on Jes Staley's views in\n\nevaluating the Bank's relationship with Epstein because Staley was a \"respected member of the\noperating committee\" and knew Epstein. JPMC Ex. 19 at 167:1-19.\n71.\n\nJohn Duffy testified that the Private Bank \"relied upon Jes\" and \"his judgment\"\n\nabout Epstein's accounts. JPMC Ex. 15 at 63:19-24. Duffy further testified that Staley had the\n\"final word\" and was the \"final court of appeal\" on matters concerning Epstein's accounts.\nJPMC Ex. 15 at 82:11-16, 118:2-9.\n72.\n\nWilliam Sheridan testified that \"Jes called the shots in terms of our business\n\ndealings with Epstein and the decision to retain him as a client.\" JPMC Ex. 14 at 74:15-18.\nSheridan further testified that \"[t]here were no substantive decisions made with respect to Jeffrey\nEpstein without Jes's input.\" JPMC Ex. 14 at 126:23-25.\n73.\n\nWilliam Langford testified that he was told that \"Jes owned the client\n\nrelationship\" and \"from that perspective, I supposed he would be the one to help make that\ndecision or to make that decision.\" JPMC Ex. 113 at 336:4-14.\nIII.\n\nStaley Played an Active Role in the Coverage of Epstein's Accounts\n74.\n\nStephen Cutler testified that, with respect to Epstein's accounts, \"Staley was\n\ninvolved every step of the way,\" and was \"putting his stamp on the question of whether we\nshould—how we should interact with Mr. Epstein.\" JPMC Ex. 19 at 103:20-104:10, 141:17145:10.\nStaley Approved or Selected Epstein's Coverage Teams\n75.\n\nOn December 7, 2001, Tad\n\nsent an email to Staley with the subject \"Jeffrey\n\nEpstein,\" writing, \"Jennifer Mitchell would like to transfer the Epstein and Wexner relationship\nto my team. 1 thought Mary Reith would be a good banker to help Laurie Cameron and me cover\n\n12\n\nEFTA02817659\n\n", "char_count": 1861}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 37 of 53\n\nJeffrey. She is smart, aggressive and I think would be able to interact well w/ Jeffrey. Is this\nO.K. w/ you? We would like to have a quick sit down w/ you to review our relationship w/\nJeffrey.\" That same day, Staley responded, \"Mary would be great.\" JPMC Ex. 117.\n76.\n\nOn March 9, 2010, Mary\n\nsent an email to Staley, copying Staley's\n\nassistant, Rosa da Silva, and Paul Moths, who had become Epstein's new private banker, with\nthe subject \"Jeffrey Epstein,\" writing, \"Jes — just a quick note to let you know that Jeffrey is now\nset up for business in the Private Bank (incl w/ an ISDA) on the GIO desk. Paul\n\nand Jeff\n\nMatusow are co-covering him on the GIO desk and Paul Morris will be his banker. Paul is a\nformer investment banker from Barclays who joined our team last year. I'll make sure you get to\nmeet him soon. So Jeffrey is well covered and hopefully the relationship will grow from here.\nWe'll keep you posted.\" JPMC Ex. 118.\n77.\n\nOn April 9, 2010, Epstein emailed Staley, writing \"paul moths seems nice , but\n\nnot very experienced,. is he really the person you want to cover me, [sic]\" JPMC Ex. 119.\n78.\n\nOn October 4, 2012, Mary\n\nemailed John Duffy with the subject, \"Jeffrey\n\nEpstein note,\" writing, \"John — whichever option we choose, we should definitely run it by Jes\nfirst to ensure he's on board. Let me know when to reach out or if you want to put a call into\nhim this morning. Thanks again for your help on this one. I welcome your thoughts!\" JPMC\nEx. 120.\n79.\n\nOn October 10, 2012, John Duffy emailed Staley, writing, \"We need a new\n\nbanker for J. Epstein. Paul Morris left to join DB. We have a banker with lots of Wall St\nexperience under his belt who has thick skin. Do you want/need to meet him first?\" Staley\nresponded, \"How about Justin?\" Duffy answered, \"Could work — I think he is quick to say 'yes'\n\n13\n\nEFTA02817660\n\n", "char_count": 1918}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 38 of 53\n\nto clients and with JE that worries me a bit — we would need to coach him on that. If you prefer\nto go with him we will provide the needed 'education.\"' JPMC Ex. 21.\n80.\n\nOn December 17, 2012, Mary\n\nsent Justin Nelson an email with the subject\n\n\"Epstein account move,\" writing, \"Justin — just a quick heads up that Jeffrey's account\nrelationship will now be moving over to you as we start the new `metric' year. Best of luck —\nalways happy to help here if I can as issues come up.\" JPMC Ex. 20.\nEpstein Raised Concerns or Issues Concerning His JPMC Accounts With Staley\n81.\n\nOn May 6, 2010, Epstein emailed Staley, writing, \"fyi„ almost every position put\n\non by the oig group is down subsatnailly [sic].. in two weeks im [sic] off 6 million.\" Staley\nresponded, \"Do you mean GIO?\" Epstein answered, \"yes.\" Staley told Epstein he was \"talking\nto them now\" and Epstein responded, \"be gentle„ I should have simply ignored their advice , and\nkept my own.\" JPMC Ex. 121.\n82.\n\nOn August 24, 2010, Paul\n\nemailed Epstein about his investments. That\n\nsame day, Epstein replied to the email, copying Staley, writing, \"yen? „ so far jpm\nrecomendations [sic] are a disater [sic].\" JPMC Ex. 122.\n83.\n\nOn December 21, 2010, Epstein forwarded an email from other JPMC employees\n\nto Staley with the subject, \"Fwd: DivStoxx,\" writing, \"fyi .. you can see why I am frustrated with\nthis group.\" JPMC Ex. 123.\n84.\n\nOn March 11, 2011, Epstein emailed Staley, writing, \"is there a problem with the\n\nletttr [sic] of credit in favor of the modeling agency„ I was just told that Paul morris is not\nreturning my guys calls. I called him twice myself today „ If you get a chance , nothing urgent.\"\nJPMC Ex. 124.\n\n14\n\nEFTA02817661\n\n", "char_count": 1770}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 39 of 53\n\n85.\n\nOn September 7, 2011, Epstein emailed\nJPMC Ex. 27.\n\nStaley's Views and Approvals ofEpstein Informed.IPMC's Due Diligence Process\n86.\n\nOn January 27, 2011, Paul Morris emailed James Dalessio with the subject,\n\n\"DDR addition for Jeffrey Epstein,\" writing, \"Jim, I was planning to add the following update,\nlet's talk tomorrow. Thanks. January 27, 2011 update: A few news stories during 2010 connects\nJeffrey Epstein to human trafficking. The coverage team along with Catherine Keating and\nWilliam Langford all met to discuss the situation and agreed to enhance monitoring and\ndocument a discussion with the client. Jes Staley discussed the topic with Jeffrey Epstein who\nreplied there was no truth to the allegations, no evidence and was not expecting any problems.\nWe will continue to monitor the accounts and cash usage closely going forward.\" JPMC Ex. 16.\n87.\n\nCatherine Keating testified that she approved Epstein's DDR in 2007 \"because we\n\nretained him as a client.\" JPMC Ex. 7 at 140:13-141:23. Keating further testified that \"[n]ot\napproving a DDR isn't how you exit a client.\" JPMC Ex. 7 at 141:1-2.\n88.\n\nJohn Duffy testified that \"the basis of my approving [Epstein's] DDR was my\n\nconversation with Mr. Staley.\" JPMC Ex. 15 at 117:9-17. Duffy further testified that his\napproval of Epstein's DDRs \"reflects my conversations with Mr. Staley as an operating\ncommittee member and someone who has a fiduciary responsibility to the Bank, its clients, its\nshareholders.\" JPMC Ex. 15 at 118:11-16. Duffy further testified that a refusal to approve a\nDDR would \"not necessarily\" have resulted in the exit of that client. JPMC Ex. 15 at 110:17111:2.\n89.\n\nMary\n\ntestified that Catherine Keating would have approved Epstein's\n\nDDRs after taking reasonable steps which \"would include conversations, particularly with Mr.\n\n15\n\nEFTA02817662\n\n", "char_count": 1906}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 40 of 53\n\nStaley, who knew Mr. Epstein best.\" JPMC Ex. 125 at 541:10-20.\n\nfurther testified that\n\nStaley \"would be part of the diligence I would do\" regarding the approval of Epstein's DDRs.\nJPMC Ex. 125 at 559:19-560:19.\n90.\n\nWilliam Sheridan testified he signed-off on language in a DDR in 2011 which\n\nstated \"our view is that Mr. Epstein has served his time and has completed his duties to society,\"\ndespite his own disagreement \"because this was a conclusion reached by senior management.\"\nSheridan further testified that he did not ask anyone to revise that language because \"it was\ndiscussed amongst a number of my private bank colleagues, including Catherine Keating and\nJohn Duffy. And I think we all felt fairly strongly, going back to 2008, we never should have\nbeen in this position in 2011. That the correct decision would have been to offboard him as a\nclient in 2008. But that — that was not done because of one individual named Jes Staley.\" JPMC\nEx. 14 at 177:13-178:10. Sheridan also testified that a refusal to sign a DDR for a client or\nprospective client would \"not necessarily\" mean the client had to be exited from the Bank.\nJPMC Ex. 14 at 36:15-18.\nIV.\n\nStaley Interfered With JPMC's Efforts to Investigate or Exit Epstein\n91.\n\nOn July 26, 2006, Mary Erdoes forwarded a news article about Epstein's arrest to\n\nStaley, writing \"so painful to read.\" The same day, Staley responded, \"I went and saw him last\nnight. I've never seen him so shaken. He also adamently [sic] denies the ages.\" JPMC Ex. 90.\n92.\n\nOn October 17, 2006, following news of Epstein's arrest for felony solicitation of\n\nprostitution under Florida state law, JPMC documented a series of internal discussions about its\nrelationship with Epstein. The \"rapid response team\" memorandum states: \"After internal\ndiscussions with Jes Staley, Mary Erdoes, Catherine Keating, John Duffy, and Mary\n\nit\n\nwas decided that we will keep Mr. Epstein solely as a banking c\n... [truncated, 2053 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02817624/39 or ?id=EFTA02817624&page=39]", "char_count": 2053}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 41 of 53\n\nservice basis. We will not proactively solicit new investment business from him.\" JPMC Ex.\n126.\n93.\n\nCatherine Keating testified, \"I know that Jes was involved in the discussions.\"\n\nJPMC Ex. 7 at 68:19-22.\n94.\n\nOn October 5, 2007, Anne Verdon emailed Shawna Gilmore-Orr, Tamyka Clarke,\n\nLisa Waters, and Vincenza Lucignano, writing, \"Hi — Brent says that JES would like to have a\nmeeting with Mary Erdoes, Brent, me, and and [sic] Lisa re Jeffrey Epstein next week.\nVincenza, can you coordinate please?\" JPMC Ex. 127 at -1895; see also JPMC Ex. 128.\n95.\n\nOn January 4, 2008, Lisa Waters sent Mary\n\nan email writing, \"Tonight's\n\npost was a source for updated info. Page 6 confirms epstein's court date is `pushed to march\nwhile he tries to \"hammer our' details of his 18 month prison sentence following by house\narrest.'\"\n\nresponded, \"Interesting — I am going to speak to Mary next week about moving\n\nhim. When is the decision due to be made by Cutler — now not until March?\" Water answered,\n\"We need to have the felony he pleads guilty to. So march. No one wants him.\" JPMC Ex. 158.\n96.\n\nOn June 30, 2008, Epstei\n\nJPMC Ex. 130.\n97.\n\nOn July 1, 2008, Lisa Waters sent an email to\n\nLencyk and Theresa\n\nSchnepf with the subject, \"Fw: epstein,\" writing \"Jes would like to retain as a client so\nAnnVerdon [sic] or Kevin will need to go through the process.\" JPMC Ex. 131.\n98.\n\nOn July 15, 2008, Kevin McClecrey, a risk manager in JPMC's U.S. Private\n\nBank, forwarded an email with the subject \"Fw: Rapid Response Memo — Epstein\" to Anne\nVerdon, then General Counsel to JPMC's U.S. Private Bank, writing \"FYI Jes spoke to Lisa\n\n17\n\nEFTA02817664\n\n", "char_count": 1706}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 42 of 53\n\nWaters and told her he wants to keep his accounts. Lisa is on vacation and cannot join today.\"\nJPMC Ex. 132.\n99.\n\nOn July 15, 2008, JPMC employees held a rapid response meeting to discuss\n\nEpstein's relationship following his guilty plea. JPMC Ex. 133.\n100.\n\nFollowing the July 15, 2008 rapid response meeting, it was decided that\n\n\"Catherine [Keating] will go back to JES to tell him we are uncomfortable with Epstein and do\nnot want to go to Cutler for approval.\" JPMC Ex. 134.\n101.\n\nWilliam Sheridan testified that there was \"a very strong preference to exit this\n\nrelationship. But that — that was out of our hands. And that — that — that decision rested largely\nwith Jes Staley.\" JPMC Ex. 14 at 125:4-7.\n102.\n\nIn December 2008, a DDR for an account opened for Epstein noted that, \"Jes\n\nStaley conferred with Stephen Cutler and the decision was made to keep Mr. Epstein as a client.\"\nJPMC Ex. 24.\n103.\n\nIn response to new negative media on Epstein, JPMC held another rapid response\n\nmeeting on January 7, 2011. JPMC Ex. 129.\n104.\n\nAt the January 7, 2011 rapid response meeting, Catherine Keating \"made sure\"\n\nthat the meeting participants knew that nobody at the meeting \"was in favor of having retained\n[Epstein] as a client,\" but that it was all \"due to Jes's personal relationship.\" JPMC Ex. 135 at 31040.\n105.\n\nThe outcome of the January 7, 2011 meeting was for, \"discussions to be held with\n\nWilliam and Nina to determine how to approach the issue with Jes Staley, who is friends with\nEpstein. He needs to understand the potential backlash to the firm given all of the work done to\nroot out clients involved in human trafficking.\" JPMC Ex. 134.\n\n18\n\nEFTA02817665\n\n", "char_count": 1739}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 43 of 53\n\n106.\n\nFollowing that meeting, \"PB discussed the Epstein relationship with Jes Staley,\n\nwho called Mr. Epstein to discuss the human trafficking allegations in press [sic], which he\nclaimed were without merit.\" JPMC Ex. 136. \"Further meetings [were] held with Jes Staley to\ndiscuss LOB decision for re-approval.\" JPMC Ex. 137.\n107.\n\nOn January 10, 2011, Maryanne Ryan sent an email to William Langford, Phillip\n\nDeLuca, and Nina Nichols with the subject, \"Re: Jeffrey Epstein,\" writing, in part, \"Seems PB\nwas not so thrilled with retaining him, it was all due to Jes.\" JPMC Ex. 135.\n108.\n\nOn January 14, 2011, Catherine Keating and William Langford met with Staley to\n\ndiscuss Epstein. JPMC Ex. 138.\n109.\n\nWilliam Langford testified that during this meeting, with respect to Epstein's\n\nconviction in 2008 on state charges for solicitation of prostitution and procurement of a minor\nfor prostitution, Staley stated that Epstein \"didn't do it, shouldn't have pled guilty, et cetera,\nwasn't responsible for it\" and that Epstein's lawyers were working to get the guilty plea \"thrown\nout.\" JPMC Ex. 113 at 323:6-14, 370:10-17. Langford further testified that the \"takeaways\"\nfrom his meeting with Staley \"were that we would go and speak with Mr. Epstein's attorney.\"\nJPMC Ex. 113 at 370:21-24.\n110.\n\nOn January 20, 2011, Epstein's assistant, Lesley Groff, emailed Staley's assistant,\n\nRosa da Silva, with the subject, \"Jeffrey Epstein — Ken Starr,\" writing, \"Hi Rosa. Jeffrey\nrequested I send you Ken Starr's office phone number at Baylor University.\" That same day, da\nSilva forwarded the message to Stephen Cutler. JPMC Ex. 139.\nIII.\n\nOn February 9, 2011, Staley forwarded an email\nPMC\n\n106.\n\n19\n\nEFTA02817666\n\n", "char_count": 1773}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 44 of 53\n\n112.\n\nOn March 7, 2011, Stephen Cutler emailed Jonathan\n\nthen-General\n\nCounsel to JPMC's Investment Bank, with the subject, \"[d]id you go back to Jes re:\" writing,\n\"Ken Starr's best friend?\" That same day,\n\nreplied, \"Yes and didn't get anything back\n\nfrom him, so I just called him again. He said he'll call Epstein and get me a live name and\nnumber for a current lawyer. The recent headlines (it FBI reopening its investigation in Daily\nMail and NY Post over the weekend, and guilt-by-being-friends stories about Prince Andrew and\nformer President Clinton) aint [sic] great. Cc'ing William.\" JPMC Ex. 140.\n113.\n\nOn March 20, 2011, Epstein emailed Staley, writing, \"I [a]m working on getting\n\nsteve cutler the comfort he needs.\" Staley responded, \"Agree.\" JPMC Ex. 107.\n114.\n\nStephen Cutler recommended exiting Epstein as a client in March or April 2011.\n\nJPMC Ex. 141; JPMC Ex. 142 at 395:6-8.\n115.\n\nOn August 4, 2011, JPMC held a fourth rapid response meeting about the Bank's\n\nrelationship with Epstein. JPMC Ex. 143.\n116.\n\nThe outcome of the August 4, 2011 rapid response meeting was for \"Duffy to\n\nreach out to Jes Staley and advise that we exit while things are a bit settled.\" JPMC Ex. 134.\n117.\n\nOn August 19, 2011, John Duffy met with Staley to discuss the Bank's\n\nrelationship with Epstein. JPMC Ex. 144.\n118.\n\nJohn Duffy testified that at his meeting with Staley, he (Duffy) recommended\n\nexiting Epstein, but that \"it was very clear from that conversation with Jes, Jes wanted Mr.\nEpstein to remain a client\" Duffy further testified that \"the last thing I said to Jes about it was,\nwell, Jes, if I were asked why is Jeffrey Epstein a client of the Bank at this stage, I would have to\nanswer, because of Jes Staley.\" JPMC Ex. 15 at 67:8-75:10.\n\n20\n\nEFTA02817667\n\n", "char_count": 1839}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 45 of 53\n\n119.\n\nStephen Cutler testified that Staley asked Cutler to \"hear [Epstein] out,\" and the\n\n\"at the behest of Staley,\" he met with Epstein twice in the fall of 2011, during which Epstein\ntried to convince Cutler that \"he was a decent guy.\" Cutler further testified that he did not\nchange his mind about Epstein at these meetings. JPMC Ex. 142 at 312:10-320:23; JPMC Ex.\n19 at 114:18-119:23.\n120.\n\nStephen Cutler further testified that Epstein would have been exited as a client of\n\nJPMC if not for Staley vouching for him. JPMC Ex. 19 at 167:21-169:12.\nV.\n\nSetting Staley Apart, JPMC Employees Did Not Know of Epstein's Misconduct\n121.\n\nJamie Dimon testified, \"There are terrible allegations, which, if true, meant that\n\nhe knew a lot of things sometime during that period that we didn't. And I would include in that\nSteve Cutler and Mary Erdoes.\" JPMC Ex. 6 at 357:17-22.\nJPMC Employees Investigated Epstein's Cash Activity\n122.\n\nIn 2011, Epstein informed Paul Morris, his private banker at the time, that his\n\ncash withdrawals were to pay for fuel expenses for his personal airplane when traveling to\nforeign countries. JPMC Ex. 137.\n123.\n\nIn August 2011, after becoming CEO of JPMC's Private Bank, John Duffy\n\ninvestigated Epstein's cash usage. JPMC Ex. 145.\n124.\n\nIn 2011 and 2013, John Duffy spoke to Epstein about his cash withdrawals and\n\nbusiness activities. JPMC Ex. 27; JPMC Ex. 146; JPMC Ex. 147. JPMC 15 at 225:13-226:10.\n125.\n\nEpstein informed John Duffy that his cash withdrawals were for fuel expenses for\n\nhis personal airplane when traveling to foreign countries. JPMC 15 at 207:12-16, 212:11-20;\nJPMC Ex. 148.\n\n21\n\nEFTA02817668\n\n", "char_count": 1711}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 46 of 53\n\n126.\n\nDuffy believed Epstein's explanation that he used the cash withdrawals to\n\npurchase aviation fuel. JPMC Ex. 15 at 176:18-177:5, 345:23-346:7; JPMC Ex. 148.\n127.\n\nBonnie\n\ntestified that Epstein's explanation that he used the cash\n\nwithdrawals to purchase aviation fuel \"seemed reasonable.\" JPMC Ex. 149 at 187:2-21.\n128.\n\nWith respect to\n\n, Phillip DeLuca testified that\nJPMC Ex. 150 at 298:24-\n\n299:1.\n129.\n\nMaryanne Ryan testified tha\nand tha\n\nJPMC Ex. 151 at 133:22-134:10, 208:24-209:2.\n130.\n\nJohn Duffy testified: \"I wasn't concerned about [Epstein's) use of cash. Large\n\nclients use cash in different ways. They are different than, you know, the average person on\nMain Street. ... It wasn't — it wasn't outsized in relation to what clients of Mr. Epstein's net\nworth or asset base has. And it wasn't unusual, as it related to what was expected in that\naccount, and he was pretty consistent in the use of that.\" JPMC Ex. 15 at 174:15-175:10.\n131.\n\nFrancis Peam, JPMC's former Global Chief Compliance Officer sitting by\n\ndesignation as the Bank's Corporate Representative, testified: \"I have seen very large amounts of\ncash be taken out of the bank by Private Bank clients over my time at the bank.\" JPMC Ex. 22 at\n153:21-24.\n132.\n\nWilliam Langford testified that large cash withdrawals were not the focus on the\n\nuse of cash as part of JPMC's Human Trafficking Initiative, which was focused on \"the business\nof trafficking. That is, people who set up the criminal enterprise to capture, imprison, move, and\n\n22\n\nEFTA02817669\n\n", "char_count": 1602}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 47 of 53\n\nsell the services, right, and generate the criminal proceeds, just like drug trafficking.\" JPMC Ex.\n113 at 169:12-170:10.\nJPMC Employees Investigated Other Epstein Account Activity\n133.\n\nJPMC employees investigated Epstein's account activity, including his\n\ninvolvement with MC2 Models Management. As part of that investigation, AML investigator\nMaryanne Ryan noted that MC2 \"appear[ed] to be a legit modeling agency.\" JPMC Ex. 135.\n134.\n\nWilliam Langford stated that the modeling agency \"really tells us little\" about any\n\n\"possible linkages between the JPM accounts and bad activity.\" JPMC Ex. 135.\n135.\n\nLangford testified that \"Nile modeling agency is just that it didn't tell us\n\nanything, and our ability as a bank to know what's really going on in a modeling agency is\nextremely limited.\" JPMC Ex. 113 at 356:20-24.\n136.\n\nOn January 13, 2011, Maryanne Ryan emailed Langford and Phillip DeLuca\n\nregarding her investigation into Epstein, in which she concluded that there were \"no smoking\nguns.\" JPMC Ex. 152.\n137.\n\nAmong the conclusions reached by Maryanne Ryan in her investigation was that\n\nEpstein had sponsored the opening of accounts for two adult women, including one described as\na \"willing participant\" in the \"recaps of the escapades.\" JPMC Ex. 152.\n138.\n\nMaryanne Ryan did no\n\nJPMC Ex. 151 at 139:7-18.\n139.\n\nMaryanne Ryan did not view these transactions as \"underhanded,'\nat the time. JPMC Ex. 151 at 225:5-231:12.\n\n23\n\nEFTA02817670\n\n", "char_count": 1517}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 48 of 53\n\n140.\n\nWilliam Langford testified that this activity was \"in many respects ...\n\ninconsistent with the types of things that we saw in human trafficking. You know, having her\nown account, providing money, providing documented expenses. The human trafficking\nenterprises that we were focused on were designed to traffic the individuals, keep them down,\ndo—do the business and keep it off the radar. This was different. I mean it's—it's pretty—I\ndon't like the behavior. But it's different from the typology of human trafficking that we had\nbeen focused on.\" JPMC Ex. 113 at 325:15-326:16.\n141.\n\nWilliam Langford further testified tha\nJPMC Ex. 113 at 488:9-\n\n18.\nJPMC Employees Did Not Believe EL\n142.\n\nTransactions Were Related to His Misconduct\n\nPaul Morris testified that it \"never occurred\" to him that Epstein was withdrawing\n\ncash \"for the payment related to sexual abuse or sex trafficking\" and he had \"absolutely not,\nnever heard\" anyone at JPMC indicate a suspicion that Epstein's cash withdrawals were being\nused or could be used for sexual abuse or sex trafficking. JPMC Ex. 153 at 337:15-338:4.\n143.\n\nJohn Duffy testified: \"I had no reason to believe that Mr. Epstein—and at no point\n\nin time did I believe Mr. Epstein was committing criminal acts through JPMorgan, such as sex\ntrafficking.\" JPMC 15 at 365:3-8.\n144.\n\nMaryanne Ryan also noted that Epstein \"pa[id] other girls, many models no huge\n\namounts\" and described Epstein as a \"Sugar Daddy.\" JPMC Ex. 152. Ryan testified that she\nunderstood the term \"sugar daddy\" to mean \"[s]omebody that likes to spend his money on\nladies\" but that she did not believe it \"impl[ied] financial support in exchange for sexual favors.\"\nJPMC Ex. 151 at 229:12-22.\n\n24\n\nEFTA02817671\n\n", "char_count": 1794}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 49 of 53\n\n145.\n\nWilliam Langford testified that Maryanne Ryan's findings in her investigation of\n\nEpstein's account activity did not \"establish a link between JPMorgan and the operation by\nEpstein of a sex trafficking ring through the bank, on its face, in my opinion.\" JPMC Ex. 113 at\n492:19-493:1. Langford further testified that he did not believe that Epstein \"was engaging in\ncontinued illegal activity after his 2008 plea.\" JPMC Ex. 113 at 487:24-488:4.\n146.\n\nStephen Cutler testified that, \"If Mr. Epstein was continuing to engage in\n\nunlawful activity, we didn't want him as a client.\" JPMC Ex. 142 at 363:3-15.\n147.\n\nMary Erdoes testified: \"[T]he concern was the cash payments, and at the time, the\n\ncash payments were related to airplane usage. And never at the time was that something that I\nwas connecting in my mind with anything to do with any of the allegations of what he may or\nmay not have done, and I wasn't aware of any ongoing things that Mr. Epstein was doing, and\nthe two things never — they never came to my mind to connect them.\" JPMC Ex. 115 at 182:1019. Erdoes further testified that if she had \"learned and believed that [Epstein] was sexually\nabusing young children, yes, he would be — I would ask to have him exited from the bank.\"\nJPMC Ex. 115 at 180:19-21.\nJPMC Employees Did Not Know Whether Epstein Was Under Investigation\n148.\n\nOn February 17, 2011, Jonathan\n\nand William Langford spoke with\n\nEpstein attorney Ken Starr.\nJPMC Ex. 154; JPMC Ex. 142 at 351:7-17.\n149.\n\nOn March 9, 2011, Jonathan\n\ndiscussed with Stephen Cutler the need to\n\ndetermine where \"there's actually a live federal investigation\" into Epstein. JPMC Ex. 155 at 274529.\n\n25\n\nEFTA02817672\n\n", "char_count": 1750}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 50 of 53\n\n150.\n\nemailed Stephen Cutler that he contacted\n\nOn March 15, 2011, Jonathan\n\nEpstein attorney Jay Lefkowitz to inquire whether there was any such investigation. Mr.\ntestified that Mr. Lefkowitz \"reported [] that to his knowledge there was not an active\ninvestigation of his client. But as you would expect someone sophisticated like him to say, you\nknow, we don't necessarily know.\" JPMC Ex. 35 at 39:17-25, 40:1-6. As to any suggestion in\nthe media of an ongoing investigation, \"according to Jay, [they] don't seem to have any basis.\"\nJPMC Ex. 155 at -274528.\n151.\n\nOn or about March 22, 2011, Jonathan\n\nspoke to the United States\n\nAttorney for the Southern District of Florida, who did not disclose any investigation into Epstein.\nJPMC Ex. 156; JPMC Ex. 157 at 18.\n152.\n\nJPMC also reached out to the FBI to ask for a contact at the agency to determine\n\nwhether there was any ongoing investigation into Epstein. The FBI never returned the phone\ncall. JPMC Ex. 157 at 19; JPMC Ex. 150 at 151:19-152:24; 329:5-330:21.\n153.\n\nWilliam Langford testified that he recommended exiting Epstein as a client due to\n\nreputational risk concerns and not legal concerns or concerns about Epstein's account activity.\nJPMC Ex. 113 at 436:10-20, 488:5-489:10. Langford further testified that he did not believe that\nEpstein \"was engaging in continued illegal activity after his 2008 plea.\" JPMC Ex. 113 at\n487:24-488:4. Langford also testified that had he believed there were ongoing violations of law\nand others disagreed over exiting a client, he would have escalated that decision to JPMC's\nboard of directors. JPMC Ex. 113 at 283:6-284:16.\n154.\n\nStephen Cutler recommended exiting Epstein as a client and refraining from\n\nengaging in further business with him due to the reputational risk he created for the Bank. JPMC\nEx. 142 at 209:24-210:7, 299:6-11; JPMC Ex. 19 at 76:2-6.\n\n26\n\nEFTA02817673\n\n", "char_count": 1949}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 51 of 53\n\n155.\n\nMaryanne Ryan testified that she and Phillip DeLuca advocated exiting Epstein as\n\na client because \"[h]e was a reputational risk to the bank.\" JPMC Ex. 151 at 70:24-71:17,\n129:12-18.\n156.\n\nMary\n\n\"escalated concerns for reputational risk.\" JPMC Ex. 114 at 34:10-\n\n14, 93:4-6.\n157.\n\nPhillip DeLuca testified that AML Investigations' recommendation to exit Epstein\n\nwas based on \"reputational risk.\" JPMC Ex. 150 at 85:6-10.\n158.\n\nWith respect to Epstein's status as a client, John Duffy testified: \"I was of the\n\nopinion his reputational risk was not worth having him as an account, that's correct.\" JPMC Ex.\n15 at 125:5-7.\n159.\n\nKevin McCleerey testified that \"Mr. Epstein represented a reputational risk to the\n\nfirm.\" JPMC Ex. 13 at 38:8-10.\n160.\n\nJustin Nelson testified that he understood that Epstein was terminated as a client\n\ndue to considerations of \"reputational risk.\" JPMC Ex. 5 at 8:6-9.\nVI.\n\nJPMC Exited Epstein Shortly After Staley Left the Bank\n161.\n\nOn January 8, 2013, JPMC employees received a \"[m]essage from Jamie Dimon\"\n\nwith the subject \"Jes Staley\" and which stated that Staley was leaving JPMC to join\nBlueMountain Capital Management. The same day, Phillip DeLuca forwarded the message to\nMaryanne Ryan, writing, \"Should we get rid of Epstein now?' Ryan responded, \"As a matter of\nfact, at W's [William Langford's] going away hje [sic] told me Jes was on his way out. He\nmentioned to PJ the case. So, I think in a few weeks, I will circulate again for discussion.\"\nJPMC Ex. 159.\n\n27\n\nEFTA02817674\n\n", "char_count": 1594}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 52 of 53\n\n162.\n\nMary Erdoes testified that she exited Epstein as a client when \"Jes Staley was no\n\nlonger at the Firm, and Jes Staley was the most senior client coverage person for Mr. Epstein.\nAnd there was no one there to vouch for Mr. Epstein. And I made the decision that it was — we\nwere exiting the relationship with Mr. Epstein.\" JPMC Ex. 115 at 61:4-11. Erdoes further\ntestified that \"when Mr. Staley left the Firm, there was no one there to give the reasons why we\nwould want to keep Mr. Epstein as a client of the Firm.\" JPMC Ex. 18 at 50:24-51:2.\n163.\n\nJohn Duffy testified that in August 2013, \"Mr. Staley had left the Bank. He was\n\nno longer a sponsor or vouching for Mr. Epstein. And we chose to terminate the relationship at\nthat point in time.\" JPMC Ex. 15 at 370:2-6. Duffy further testified that \"there was a process\" to\nexiting Epstein that took time to execute. JPMC Ex. 15 at 371:11-19.\n\nDated: September 8, 2023\n\nRespectfully submitted,\n\nMASSEY & GAIL LLP\n\nWILMER CUTLER PICKERING\nHALE AND DORR LLP\n\nLeonard A. Gail (pro hac vice)\nRachel Morse (pro hac vice)\n50 East Washington Street, Suite 400\nChicago, IL 60602\n(t) (312) 283-1590\nIgail®masseygail.com\nrmorse®masseygail.com\nDAY\nBethany K. Biesenthal (pro hac vice)\n110 North Wacker Drive\nSuite 4800\nChicago, IL 60606\n(t) (312) 269-4303\n(0 (312) 782-8585\nbbiesenthal@jonesday.com\nCharlotte Taylor\n51 Louisiana Ave. NW\n\nIs/ Felicia H. Ellsworth\nFelicia H. Ellsworth\nJohn J. Butts\nAndres O'Laughlin\n60 State Street\nBoston,\n02109\n(t) (617) 526-6000\n(0 (617) 526-5000\nfelicia.ellsworth@wilmerhale.com\njohn.butts@wilmerhale.com\nandy.olaughlin@wilmerhale.com\n\nM.\nIII\nRobert L. Boone\nAlan E. Schoenfeld\nBouchoux\n7 World Trade Center\n250 Greenwich Street\nNew York, NY 10007\n28\n\nEFTA02817675\n\n", "char_count": 1813}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02817624", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 325 Filed 09/08/23 Page 53 of 53\n\nWashington, DC 20001\n(t) (202) 879-3872\n(f) (202) 626-1700\nctaylor®jonesday.com\n\n(t) (212) 230-8800\nm (212) 230-8888\nrobert.boone@wilmerhale.com\nalan.schoenfeldAwilmerhale.com\n\nAttorneysfor .IPMorgan Chase Bank N.A.\n\n29\n\nEFTA02817676\n\n", "char_count": 301}]}