{"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_count": 86, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02815448", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02815448.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10.4-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 1 of 86\n\nATTACHMENT B\nPART 4\n\nEFTA02815448\n\n", "char_count": 104}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n432.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 2 of 86\n\nThe Virgin Islands Department of Justice performed address verification checks (also\n\ncalled \"sweeps') roughly annually in conjunction with U.S. Marshes. Ex. 280 at 52:1-54:12,\n105:20-106:3, 398:18-400:12.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that Pinney testified that that sweeps with the U.S.\nMarshals Service occurred \"perhaps once a year depending on finding\" that the U.S.\nMarshals received \"to conduct the operational sweeps.\" USVI Ex. 280 at 400:11-17.\nDisputed to the extent USVI suggests that the \"roughly annual[]\" checks were the only\nchecks required by USVI DOJ's policy. According to one of USVI's 30(6)(6) designees,\nUSVI DOJ's policy is to perform random checks on offenders weekly, as well as an\nannual \"sweep\" once a year. See CSMF ¶ 307. Pinney also testified that \"during the\nyear, we would also verify the addresses of offenders ... if they relocated, if they had a\nnew address. Within that time, I think it's seven days, that we would also go out to verify\ntheir addresses.\" USVI Ex. 280 at 410:16-23.\n433.\n\nThe address checks are riot warrants; government officials do not possess the ability to\n\nenter a ser offender's property or conduct a search. Ex. 280 at 49:21-50:25; 440:1-441:3.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that Pinney testified to the substance of the paragraph.\nDisputed insofar as USVI suggests that the cited testimony establishes the proposition as\na legal conclusion. USVI Ex. 280 at 49:21-50:25; 440:1-441:3.\n434.\n\nIn certain years, the U.S. Marshalls and Virgin Islands officials did not proceed beyond\n\nEpstein's dock. If an offender refused entry, the government officialsperforming the check did not\npossess authortation to enter. Ex. 280 at 43:7-46:24, 47:12-48:11, 49:4-50:25.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that Pinney testified to the substance of the paragraph.\nUSVI Ex. 280 at 43:7-46:24, 47:1248:11, 49:4-50:25. Disputed insofar as USVI\nsuggests that the cited testimony establishes the propos\n... [truncated, 2620 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02815448/1 or ?id=EFTA02815448&page=1]", "char_count": 2620}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 3 of 86\n\ntestimony shows ambiguity as to whether the federal government confirmed that this\nanalogy applied to Epstein's dock. See USVI Ex. 280 at 46:5-47:5, 124:9-23.\n436.\n\nIt was not improper or unusualfor the Government to confirm addresses at a sex offender's\n\nplace of employment, as was done one year with Eps►ein. Ex. 280 at 409:7-410:4; 438:15-439:20.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that Pinney testified that there was an Stance where\nEpstein's verification was conducted at his office. USVI Ex. 280 at 438:15-18. Also\nundisputed that Pinney testified that she verified other sex offenders in the USVI at their\nemployer's address. Id. at 439:17-20. Disputed to the extent USVI suggests that such\ntestimony establishes that this conduct was not \"improper or unusual\" as unsupported and\ndisputed by other testimony in the record. See CSMF 1 313.\n437.\n\nIn 2012, the Virgin Islands Legislature amended its sec offender laws, in part to obtain\n\nfederalfundingfor its sex offender unit. Ex. 278 at 79:12-80:10, 119:9-121:12; Er. 280 at 125:21126:6.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that USVI amended its sex offender laws in 2012 and that\nPinney testified that by enhancing USVI's laws in 2012, \"that made us eligible to — us\nbeing the Virgin Islands — eligible to receive funding for employees to — to monitor\noffenders in the Virgin Islands.\" USVI Ex. 280 at 125:21-126:6.\n438.\n\nThe U.S. Government approved all changes to the Virgin Islands sec offender laws in\n\nadvance. Ex. 278 at 122:1-9; Ex. 280 at 306:22-307:12, 452:21-453:4.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that the cited testimony supports that the United States\nDepartment of Justice had to approve the amendment to USVI's sex offender laws in\norder for USVI to receive the funding. USVI Ex. 278 at 122:1-9; USVI Ex. 280 at 307:212.\n439.\n\nAlthough Epstein's attorneys sought to coordinate with legislators concerning proposed\n\nchanges to the Virgin Islands laws, the Legislature ultimately re\n... [truncated, 2139 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02815448/2 or ?id=EFTA02815448&page=2]", "char_count": 2139}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n440.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 4 of 86\n\nEpstein appliedfor and received a waiver in 2012 of his travel notification requirements\n\npursuant to these statutory provisions. Er. 278 at 11:13-13:23, 187:16-188:15, 189:18-190:24,\n192:4-10, 193:14-24; Ex. 279 at 12480-12491.\nJPMC Response: Disputed. The USVI's sex offender law states, \"the Attorney General\nmay at his discretion reduce this twenty-one (21) day notice requirement if a sex offender\nrequests such a reduction and provides information in support of the request\" JPMC\nEx. 84 (emphasis added). Attorney Frazer testified that Epstein's attorneys provided\n\"correspondence and information\" concemin E stein's need to travel USVI Ex. 278 at\n12:9-13:7.\nat - 02; see\na so\n2 2, 4- 5. Accor\ny, rt remains sputed whether Epstein applied\nfor and receive approval for relaxation of his notification requirements \"pursuant to these\nstatutory provisions.\"\n441.\n\nThen-Attorney General Vincent Frazer testified that he relied on representations of\n\nEpstein's counsel in forming his decision, because he \"was satisfied with the representations,\"\nwhich were \"satisfactory to conclude that there was not an undue risk to the community\" that\nwould arisefrom the waiver. Ex. 278 at 190:8-24, 191:3-12, 193:14-24, 250:11-255:13; Ex. 281\nat 12246-12250, 12263-65.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that Attorney Frazer testified that he relied on\nrepresentations of Epstein's counsel with respect to Epstein's need to travel for business\nactivities and how Epstein provided notice of his travel via email to Florida, New\nMexico, and New York authorities. USVI Ex. 278 at 190:8-191:12. Disputed as to the\nwhether the cited representations are accurate as a legal or factual matter. Further\ndisputed to the extent USVI suggests this testimony supports an inference that the\nwaivers were legitimately granted and appropriate. See CSMF wi 288, 292, 294-95, 29899.\n442.\n\nEpstein's lawyers themselves represented to Attorney Frazer that other \n... [truncated, 2338 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02815448/3 or ?id=EFTA02815448&page=3]", "char_count": 2338}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 5 of 86\n\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that Epstein's lawyers made such representations to\nAttorney Frazer. USVI Ex. 278 at 251:16-255:13; USVI Ex. 281 at -246, -250, -270.\nDisputed as to the whether the cited representations are accurate as a legal or factual\nmatter or that Epstein's lawyers were the appropriate individuals to determine what\npublic safety requires. Further disputed to the extent USVI suggests this testimony\nsupports an inference that the waivers were legitimately granted and appropriate. See\nCSMF ¶1288, 292, 294-95, 298-99 .\n443.\n\nAs Ms. Pinney explained, and as the statute provides, the travel notification statute only\n\nrequired notification of travel outside the United States. While the Government had a \"policy in\nplace\" to require notification oftravel outside of the Territory but within the United States, nothing\nin the Virgin Islands statute required such notification. Ex. 280 at 363:3-365:12.\nJPMC Response: Disputed as to \"and as the statute provides\" as unsupported by the\ncited evidence. Undisputed that Pinney testified that \"I'm remembering now that within\nthe statute, it spoke about notifying VI DOJ if any offender has notified any — of any\ntravel outside of the United States\" and that \"we got a policy in place where we wanted\nthe offenders to notify us of, you know, any travel to include outside the territory.\" USVI\nEx. 280 at 364:9-12; 364:22-365:1.\n444.\n\nTravel notifications are not authortations or requests; the Government had no ability to\n\nrestrict Epstein's travel. Er. 278 at 135:6-17, 200:14-201:4.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that Attorney Frazer testified that his \"understanding of\nthe SONAR law, purpose was not to restrict a person's movement. It was to follow, to\nmonitor the movement.\" USVI Ex. 278 at 135:13-16. Disputed insofar as USVI\nattempts to use Frazer's understanding of the law to establish a legal conclusion on the\nUSVI's authority.\n445.\n\nEntry into the Virgin Islan\n... [truncated, 2856 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02815448/4 or ?id=EFTA02815448&page=4]", "char_count": 2856}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 6 of 86\n\nFacts Concerning Tax Benefits Granted to Epstein's Companies\n446.\n\nThe EDC granted tax incentives to two ofEpstein's companies: Financial Trust Company\n\nand Southern Trust Company. Ex. 283 at 29:10-19, 34:2-10, 42:3-21; Exs. 284-286.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that Financial Trust Company and Southern Trust\nCompany were granted tax incentives. USVI Ex. 284; USVI Ex. 285; USVI Ex. 286.\nDisputed to the extent USVI su' gists these were the onl E\ntities that received\nbenefits from USVI.\nee\n447.\n\nt-\n\nThe first grant of benefits to an Epstein-owned company occurred in 1999 to Financial\n\nTrust Company. Ex. 283 at 29:10-19; Ex. 284.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that the first grant of EDC benefits to an Epstein-owned\ncompany occurred in 1999 to Financial Trust Company. USVI Ex. 284.\n448.\n\nIn 2009, Financial Trust appliedfor andreceived an extension ofbenefits. Er. 283 at 34:2-\n\n10; Er. 285.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that in 2009, Financial Trust applied for and received an\nextension of EDC benefits. USVI Ex. 285.\n449.\n\nEpstein fornted a new company—Southern Trust—which applied for and received tax\n\nbenefits in 2012. Er. 283 at 42:3-21; Ex. 286.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that Southern Trust applied for EDC tax benefits in 2012.\nDisputed that Southern Trust Company received tax benefits in 2012. USVI Ex. 286 at 011.\n450.\n\nEach time that Financial Trust or Southern Trust sought benefits, the companies submitted\n\napplicationsfor the benefits. Ex. 287 at 42:3-21; Exs. 288-289.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that each time Financial Trust or Southern Trust sought\nEDC benefits, someone submitted an application for benefits on behalf of the company.\nUSVI Ex. 288; USVI Ex. 289.\n451.\n\nEach time that Financial Trust or Southern Trust sought benefits, EDC held public\n\nhearings during which the benefits were discussed and the applicants were provided the\n223\n\nEFTA02815453\n\n", "char_count": 1946}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 7 of 86\n\nopportunity to present their case and answer questions. Er. 287 at 42:3-21, 67:15-69:7, 169:21170:2; Ex. 288-290; a\n\n291 at 29:12-20; Ex. 292.\n\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that the EDC held public hearings regarding Financial\nTrust's original application for benefits, Financial Trust's application for modification of\nbenefits, and Southern Trust Company's on\napplication for benefits. USVI Ex. 289.\nDisputed to the extent USVI suggests E\nwas in attendance at each of these\nmeetin • s. See JPMC Ex. 90 69\nac\now\ne as to w e er eEDC e\nc eanngs unngw c\nnefits were\ndiscussed and applications were provided the opportunity to present their case and answer\nquestions each time that Financial Trust or Southern Trust sought benefits.\n452.\n\nEach time that Financial Trust or Southern Trust sought benefits, the EDC then held\n\ndecision meetings where the board considered the applications and rendered decisions. Er. 287\nat 22:18-23:10, 42:3-21; Ers. 288-289.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that the EDC held decision meetings regarding Financial\nTrust's original application for benefits, Financial Trust's application for modification of\nbenefits, and Southern Trust Company's original application for benefits. USVI Ex. 289.\nJPMC lacks knowledge as to whether the EDC held decision meetings each time\nFinancial Trust or Southern Trust sought benefits. Disputed that the board rendered\ndecisions at each decision meeting. Id.\n453.\n\nEpstein's Florida conviction was not a sufficient basis for revocation of benefits at that\n\ntime because there was no evidence available to the EDC that Epstein's solicitation ofa minorfor\nprostitution in Florida was \"connected with the operation\" ofEpstein's USVI businesses. Ex. 287\nat 157:6-24, 159:10-15, 170:3-172:3.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that\ntestified that \"the type of charge . . . was not\nconnected to the business operations.\" USVI Ex. 287 at 171:24-172:1. Disputed that\nEpstein's Florida convict\n... [truncated, 2474 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02815448/6 or ?id=EFTA02815448&page=6]", "char_count": 2474}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 8 of 86\n\nat 61:4-24, 148:11-149:7, 157:6-24, 159:10-15, 170:3-172:3; Ex. 283 at 53:22-54:4, 55:9-21; Ex.\n291 at 295:25-297:18.\nJPMC Response: Disputed that the EDC was not aware of any connection between\nEpstein's conduct and the operations of his business. See CSMF /1 383-84. Disputed\nthat the EDC could not request access to Epstein's companies' transactions. See JPMC\nEx. 88 at -028\n455.\n\nIndeed, the EDC reached out to Epstein's attorney in January 2015 to inquire whether\n\nmedia reporting regarding allegations of misconduct had any connection to the business of\nEpstein's Southern Trust Company. His attorney responded to confirm \"[wJe do not believe that\nthese media discussions will have any impact on the business activities of STC.\" Ex. 287 at\n172:17-174:10; Ers. 293-294.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that the EDC corresponded with Epstein's attorney in\nJanuary 2015 to inquire whether media reporting regarding allegations of misconduct had\nany connection to the business of Epstein's Southern Trust Company. USVI Ex. 287 at\n172:17-174:10; USVI Ex. 293 at -432; USVI Ex. 294 at -186. Undisputed that Epstein's\nattorney responded with the quoted language. USVI Ex. 294 at -186. Disputed to the\nextent USVI contends that this testimony establishes as a legal matter that the cited\noutreach discharged EDC's obligations to follow up on allegations of wrongdoing.\n456.\n\nMargarita\n\n, a witness with more than 30 years' experience at the EDC, testified\n\nthat the cost-benefit ratios provided to board members cannot be analyzed in isolation because\nthe ratio \"doesn't give the fill picture ►o anyone\" and \"can be misleading.\" Ex. 287 at 78:2579:21, 80:23-81:13. Governor Albert Bryan testified that the ratios were not intendedfor \"smaller\nfinancialfirms\" like Epstein's companies. Ex. 291 at 47:22-49:6.\nJPMC Response: Disputed that\ntestified that the cost-benefit ratios provided\nto board members cannot be analyzed in isolation beca\n... [truncated, 2577 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02815448/7 or ?id=EFTA02815448&page=7]", "char_count": 2577}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 9 of 86\n\ntestified that \"[for these smaller financial firms, we were really interested in making sure\nthat we have viable firms that come here and tax residents that have a high net worth.\"\nUSVI Ex. 291 at 48:24-49:1-2. Disputed as to the underlying suggestion that the costbenefit ratios were not relevant to the EDC's considerations. See JPMC Ex. 90 11[59-66.\n457.\n\nflusher explained that the cost-benefit ratios can be misleading because,\n\nunless the business was already operating in the Territory, the Government would not have\nreceived the tax revenue in the first place and has not \"lost\" anything. Er. 287 at 81:1443:2.\nGovernor Bryan agreed testifiing that \"the government didn't give up anything \" because \"halfof\nsome is better than allofnone.\" Ex. 290 at 49:7-23.\nJPMC Response: Disputed that\ntestified that the cost-benefit ratios \"can be\nmisleading.\" Undisputed that\ntestified to the meaning of \"not favorable ratios\"\ncan depend on whether the company was operating in the territory because \"if a company\nwas not existing in the territory, there was no tax dollars being paid to the territory. So\nwhere it says, taxes foregone, it is not realistically foregone because the company would\nnot have been in the territory and be in a tax-paying coin an .\" USVI Ex. 287 at 81:14testimony. Further\n82:9. Disputed that Governor Bryan \"agreed\" with\ndisputed to the extent USVI has to support this statement with evidence from the record.\nThe cited USVI Exhibit 290 does not contain the cited pages. Undisputed Governor\nBryan stated the quoted text at an EDC public hearing in November 2012. Disputed as to\nthe underlying suggestion that the cost-benefit ratios were not relevant to the EDC's\nconsiderations. See JPMC Ex. 90 ¶1 59-66 .\n458.\n\nThe ratiofurther ignores ancillary benefits that accrue to the Territoryfrom the presence\n\nofhigh net-worth individuals, who engage in economic activity unrelated to their businesses that\nbene\n... [truncated, 2798 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02815448/8 or ?id=EFTA02815448&page=8]", "char_count": 2798}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 10 of 86\n\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that cited document USVI Ex. 296 contains the quoted\ntext. Disputed that Epstein would have relocated if the benefits were not extended. See\nJPMC Ex. 91 at 135:8-136:18.\n460.\n\nThus, the EDC could not assume that it would collect Epstein's tax revenue if the benefits\n\nwere not extended. Ex. 290 at 49:7-23.\nJPMC Response: Disputed to the extent USVI has failed to support this statement with\nevidence from the record. The cited USVI Exhibit 290 does not contain a page 49.\nFurther disputed that Epstein would have relocated if the benefits were not extended. See\nJPMC Ex. 9 lat 135:8-136:18.\n461.\n\nThe EDC did not treat Epstein dWerently than any other beneficiary. Ex. 290 at 280:3-17.\nJPMC Response: Disputed. See JPMC Ex. 9011 66, 67, 90. Disputed to the extent\nstatement consists of USVI's summary of USVI Ex. 290. Further disputed to the extent\nUSVI has to support this statement with evidence from the record. The cited USVI\nExhibit 290 does not contain the cited pages.\n\nFacts Concerning Cecile de Jongh's Employment with Epstein\n462.\n\nCecile de Jongh became First Lady when her husband was elected Governor. She testified\n\nthat \"there's no office of thefirst lady with a budget,\" and she did not have an office. First Lady\nwas largely a ceremonial position that entailed giving speeches and attending social events. Ex.\n297 at 17:12-21:19.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that Cecile de Jongh became First Lady when her husband\nwas elected Governor. USVI Ex. 297 at 17:12-16. Disputed that cited document\ncontains quoted text. See USVI Ex. 297. Disputed that First Lady was largely a\nceremonial position that entailed giving speeches and attending social events. See CSMF\n11 394-403.\n463.\n\nDuring the time her husband was Governor, Ms. de Jongh was widely known and\n\nrecognized to be employed by Epstein's businesses and acting on their behalf. Et 287 at 130:1214; Ex. 298 at 6:12-9:11, 10:10-23, 11:2\n... [truncated, 2295 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02815448/9 or ?id=EFTA02815448&page=9]", "char_count": 2295}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n464.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 11 of 86\n\nHer employment with Epstein had been widely reported and numerous witnesses confirmed\n\ntheir familiarity with her employment. Ex. 287 at 130:12-14; Et 298 at 6:12-9:11, 10:10-23,\n11:21-13:3; Ex. 299 at 49:4-21; Ex. 291 at 14:21-15:17; Ex. 283 at 36:12-37:2.\nJPMC Response: Disputed that USVI Ex. 287 supports the statement. See USVI Ex.\n287 at 130:12-14 (\"Q. What's the relationship between Cecile de Jongh and Governor\nJohn de Jongh? A. It's publicly known that it is his wife.\"). Otherwise, undisputed.\n465.\n\nMs. de Jongh had no contact with personnel at the Department of Justice responsiblefor\n\nsex offender registration and monitoring. Ex. 280 at 158:7-12, 179:20-24.\nJPMC Response: Disputed to the extent the cited testimony does not support the broad\nproposition. Pinney testified, \"during my time\" she could not say that she was aware of\nwhether Cecile de Jongh ever interacted with the USVI DOJ regarding Epstein. USVI\nEx. 280 at 158:7-12.\n466.\n\nDecisions concerning whether or not to grant tax benefits were first made by the board\n\nmembers of the EDC. Ex. 287 at 22:18-23:10, 27:25-28:6.\nJPMC Response: Disputed.\ntestified that \"the board would make\nrecommendations to the Governor and the Governor had the final decision.\" USVI Ex.\n287 at 22:21-24. See also CSMF 11 356-61.\n467.\n\nAlthough the Governor (her husband) signed the tax benefit certificates, that process was\n\nlittle more than a formality and could not happen without the EDC's recommendation in thefirst\nplace. Ex. 287 at 22:18-23:10, 27:25-28:6.\nJPMC Response: Disputed. The cited testimony does not support the proposition that\nthe Governor's approval was \"little more than a formality.\" On the contrary,\ntestified that from 1998 — 2013, the Governor held the \"final decision.\" USVI Ex. 287 at\n22:18- 23:3; 27:25-28:6. See also CSMF ¶t 356-61. Undisputed that the cited testimony\nstates that \"after the change\" the \"beard [sic] of directors of the\n... [truncated, 2362 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02815448/10 or ?id=EFTA02815448&page=10]", "char_count": 2362}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 12 of 86\n\nJPMC Response: Disputed that Cecile de Jongh \"vigorously\" denied knowing about or\nfacilitating Epstein's crimes in the Virgin Islands. Further disputed that Ms. De Jongh in\nfact did not know about or facilitate Epstein's crimes. See CSMF 321-350. Ms. de\nJongh's cited testimony included statements, such as \"if somebody is introduced as\nsomebody's girlfriend, I took it as face value that that's their girlfriend,\" USVI Ex. 297 at\n218:3-5, and \"I looked him in the eye and asked him, you know `What the hell is going\non,' that I had a daughter and, you know, what's going on, and what he said was just a\nmistake. Mistook somebody to be older than they were,\" id. at 213:4-9. Ms. de Jongh\nfurther testified that she believed Epstein's explanation that it was \"just a mistake.\" Id. at\n213:4-21.\n469.\n\nWith respect to efforts to establish an English as a Second Language class, Ms. de Jongh\n\ntestified that she was not aware any of the women were potential trafficking victims. Er. 297 at\n131:16-132:16, 136:10-137:1.\nJPMC Response: Undisputed that Cecile de Jongh testified as such. Disputed as to the\nunderlying fact that Cecile de Jongh was not aware any of the women were potential\ntrafficking victims. See CSMF 321-350.\n470.\n\nThe documents also make clear that the University merely agreed to offer an already-\n\nexisting class to individuals. Ex. 297 at 129:11-14; Ex. 300.\nJPMC Response: Disputed. Cecile de Jongh wrote to Epstein that UVI was \"structuring\nthe class around the ladies.\" See CSMF 1340.\n\n229\n\nEFTA02815459\n\n", "char_count": 1596}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 13 of 86\n\nJPMORGAN CHASE BANK, N.A.'S LOCAL CIVIL RULE 56.1(B)\nCOUNTERSTATEMENT OF ADDITIONAL MATERIAL FACTS\nI.\n\nSUMMARY JUDGMENT CANNOT ENTER ON USVPS CLAIMS\nA.\n\nJPMC Did Not Know Of Or Recklessly Disregard Epstein's Alleged SexTrafficking Venture\n\nRapid Response Meelinks\n1.\n\nJPMC employees regularly held \"rapid response meetings\" in light of derogatory\n\nor notable information about a client. JPMC Ex. 66 at 194:22-195:12; JPMC Ex. 92 at 53:2154:4; JPMC Ex. 93.\n2.\n\nWhen allegations are made against a client, the employees responsible for the\n\nclient relationship would be tasked with staying on \"high alert\" and monitoring how those\nallegations develop towards a formal resolution, such as a criminal conviction. JPMC Ex. 94 at\n95:22-96:20.\n3.\n\nEpstein was indicted in Florida state cowl for felony solicitation of prostitution on\n\nJuly 19, 2006. JPMC Ex. 2; JPMC Ex. 3 at i. USVI's law enforcement agencies did not open an\ninvestigation into Epstein. JPMC Ex. 4 at 25:17-21.\n4.\n\nOn October 17, 2006, following news of Epstein's arrest for felony solicitation of\n\nprostitution under Florida state law, JPMC documented a series of internal discussions about its\nrelationship with Epstein into a \"rapid response team\" memorandum. The memorandum states:\n\"After internal discussions with Jes Staley, Mary Erdoes, Catherine Keating, John Duffy, and\nMary\n\nit was decided that we will keep Mr. Epstein solely as a banking client and on a\n\n`reactive,' client service basis. We will not proactively solicit new investment business from\nhint\" JPMC Ex. 95.\n5.\n\n230\n\nEFTA02815460\n\n", "char_count": 1636}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n6.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 14 of 86\n\nFollowing media reports about Epstein's pending guilty plea, JPMC employees\n\nheld another meeting in October 2007 to discuss the Bank's relationship with Epstein. JPMC\nEx. 96; JPMC Ex. 97.\n7.\n\nEpstein\n\nJPMC Ex. 11.\n\nJPMC Ex. 12 at\n\nVI-JPM-000012204. USVI's law enforcement agencies did not open an investigation into\nEpstein. JPMC Ex. 4 at 25:17-26:18, 32:16-35:21.\n8.\n\nAfter Epstein pleaded guilty to state charges for solicitation of prostitution and\n\nprocurement of a minor for prostitution, JPMC held a rapid response meeting to discuss the\nBank's relationship with Epstein on July 15, 2008. JPMC Ex. 98.\n9.\n\nAt the conclusion of the July 15, 2008 rapid response meeting, it was determined\n\nthat then-CEO of the US Private Bank, Catherine Keating, would \"go back to JES to tell him we\nare uncomfortable with Epstein and do not want to go to Cutler for approval.\" JPMC Ex. 93 at 26008.\n10.\n\nIn summer 2010 and early 2011, media reports suggested that there may have\n\nbeen a current investigation into Epstein. JPMC Ex. 15; JPMC Ex. 31; JPMC Ex. 32; JPMC Ex.\n99.\n\n231\n\nEFTA02815461\n\n", "char_count": 1160}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n11.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 15 of 86\n\nJPMC employees did not view these reports as a determination that Epstein was\n\nengaged in ongoing unlawful conduct. JPMC Ex. 100 at JPM-SDNYL1T-00157092; JPMC Ex.\n101; JPMC Ex. 102 at 52:19-53:8, 107:22-108:20.\n12.\n\nKevin McCleerey testified that \"My view was it was — the reputational risk of the\n\nfirm was increasing with these allegations, if they were true. We knew in previous news articles\nsome of the information was not true. So we needed to get the facts. But until then, we should\nhave a meeting to review the current allegations in the press. That was my view.\" JPMC Ex. 103\nat 234:12-23; see also JPMC Ex. 103 at 236:7-18, 238:9-239:1.\n13.\n\nJPMC employees did not view these reports as a determination that Epstein was\n\nin fact under federal investigation. JPMC Ex. 99; JPMC Ex. 101.\n14.\n\nIn response to the new negative media on Epstein, JPMC held another rapid\n\nresponse meeting on January 7, 2011. JPMC Ex. 104; JPMC Ex. 105; JPMC Ex. 106.\n15.\n\nJPMC Ex. 102 at 92:13-16.\n16.\n\nOn January 14, 2011, William Langford and Catherine Keating had a meeting\n\nwith Jes Staley to discuss the status of Epstein's accounts. JPMC Ex. 107; JPMC Ex. 108 at\n370:10-17.\n17.\n\nOn August 4, 2011, JPMC held a fourth rapid response meeting about the Bank's\n\nrelationship with Epstein. JPMC Ex. 109.\nEpstein's Cash Usame\n18.\n\nBetween 2003 and 2013,\nJPMC Ex. 110 at 24.\n\n232\n\nEFTA02815462\n\n", "char_count": 1458}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n19.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 16 of 86\n\nThese cash transactions and direct and indirect payments to women constituted\n\n1% of the nearly $900 million of funds that flowed through Epstein's accounts between 2003 and\n2013. JPMC Ex. 110 at 15-16; JPMC Ex. 60 at 1 92.\n20.\n\nIn 2011, Epstein informed Paul Morris, his private banker at the time. that his\n\ncash withdrawals were to pay for fuel expenses for his personal airplane when traveling to\nforeign countries. JPMC Ex. 106.\n21.\n\nIn August 2011, after becoming CEO of JPMC's Private Bank, John Duffy\n\ninvestigated Epstein's cash usage. JPMC Ex. 111.\n22.\n\nIn 2011 and 2013 Duffy spoke to Epstein about his cash withdrawals and business\n\nactivities. JPMC Ex. 112; JPMC Ex. 113; JPMC Ex. 114; JPMC Ex. 77 at 225:13-226:10.\n23.\n\nEpstein informed John Duffy that his cash withdrawals were for fuel expenses for\n\nhis personal airplane when traveling to foreign countries. JPMC Ex. 77 at 207:12-16, 212:11-20;\nJPMC Ex. 115.\n24.\n\nDuffy advised Epstein to conduct cash withdrawals for fuel expenses from his\n\naviation account, after which Epstein began conducting cash withdrawals out of his Hyperion Air\naccount. JPMC Ex. 115.\n25.\n\nIt is not uncommon to speak to a client about unusual cash activity. JPMC Ex. 77\n\nat 225:20-21; JPMC Ex. 116 at 105:7-22; JPMC Ex. 108 at 401:16-23.\n26.\n\nJPMC employees previously had advised Epstein to cease structuring cash\n\nwithdrawals below the $10,000 reporting threshold. JPMC Ex. 116 at 106:6-107:7.\n27.\n\nDuffy believed Epstein's explanation that he used the cash withdrawals to\n\npurchase aviation fuel. JPMC Ex. 77 at 176:18-177:5, 345:23-346:7; JPMC Ex. 115.\n\n233\n\nEFTA02815463\n\n", "char_count": 1697}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n28.\n\nBonnie\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 17 of 86\n\ntestified that Epstein's explanation that he used the cash\n\nwithdrawals to purchase aviation fuel \"seemed reasonable.\" JPMC Ex. 92 at 187:2-21.\n29.\n\nEpstein's former accountant, Richard Kahn, testified that Epstein's pilots would\n\nrequest cash to pay for fuel in order to secure more favorable rates. JPMC Ex. 117 at 75:3-19,\n105:5-16, 109:5-110:2.\n30.\n\nEpstein's former pilot\n\nVisoski submitted a sworn declaration that until\n\nat least 2003, cash was used to pay for fire at John F. Kennedy International airport in order to\ntake advantage of a significant cash discount. JPMC Ex. 118.\n31.\n\nWith respect to Epstein's cash withdrawals, Phil DeLuca testified that,\nJPMC Ex. 119 at 298:24-\n\n299:1.\n32.\n\nMaryanne Ryan testified that\nJPMC Ex. 102 at 278:10-17.\n\n33.\n\nJPMC Ex. 102 at 133:22-134:10, 208:24-209:2.\n34.\n\nWilliam Langford testified: \"But at the end of the day, withdrawal of cash is a\n\nwithdrawal of cash. And so especially small dollars, wealthy people withdraw cash. They do a\nlot of different things?' JPMC Ex. 108 at 221:2-7.\n35.\n\nJohn Duffy testified: \"I wasn't concerned about [Epstein's] use of cash. Large\n\nclients use cash in different ways. They are different than, you know, than the avenge person on\nMain Street. . . . It wasn't — it wasn't outsized in relation to what clients of Mr. Epstein's net\n\n234\n\nEFTA02815464\n\n", "char_count": 1423}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 18 of 86\n\nworth or asset base has. And it wasn't unusual, as it related to what was expected in that\naccount, and he was pretty consistent in the use of that.\" JPMC Ex. 77 at 174:15-175:10.\n36.\n\nPearn testified: \"I have seen very large amounts of cash be taken out of the\n\nbank by Private Bank clients over my time at the bank.\" JPMC Ex. 94 at 153:21-24.\n37.\n\nJPMC's human trafficking expert, Dr. Kimberly Meblman-Orozco testified that\n\n\"high-net-worth individuals making significant payments to their victims is atypical of\ntrafficking.\" JPMC Ex. 120 at 229:24-230:1.\n38.\n\nDr. Mehlman-Orozco further testified: \"If you could sort of give me a subset of\n\nwhat you're saying that it would have corroborated. Because, for example, if you're asking me\nwould victim payments in cash corroborate an allegation of trafficking, I would say, no, that's\natypical or inconsistent with trafficking. So you typically would not see that as a corroborating\npiece of evidence. I would typically see that in something that would be used by the other side to\nshow that they were not a victim.\" JPMC Ex. 120 at 263:21-264:7.\n39.\n\nWilliam Langford testified that large cash withdrawals were not the focus on the\n\nuse of cash as part of JPMC's Human Trafficking Initiative, which was focused on \"the business\nof trafficking. That is, people who set up the criminal enterprise to capture, imprison, move, and\nsell the services, right, and generate the criminal proceeds, just like drug trafficking.\" JPMC Ex.\n108 at 169:12-170:10.\n40.\n\nPaul Morris testified that it \"never occurred\" to him that Epstein was withdrawing\n\ncash \"for the payment related to sexual abuse or sex trafficking\" and he had \"absolutely not,\nnever heard\" anyone at JPMC indicate a suspicion that Epstein's cash withdrawals were being\nused or could be used for sexual abuse or sex trafficking. JPMC Ex. 121 at 337:20-338:4.\n\n235\n\nEFTA02815465\n\n", "char_count": 1955}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n41.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 19 of 86\n\nJohn Duffy testified: \"I had no reason to believe that Mr. Epstein—and at no point\n\nin time did I believe Mr. Epstein was committing criminal acts through JPMorgan, such as sex\ntrafficking.\" JPMC Ex. 77 at 365:3-8.\n42.\n\nFormer Head of the Global Private Bank and current CEO of Asset and Wealth\n\nManagement Mary Erdoes testified: \"[T]he concern was the cash payments, and at the time, the\ncash payments were related to airplane usage. And never at the time was that something that I\nwas connecting in my mind with anything to do with any of the allegations of what he may or\nmay not have done, and I wasn't aware of any ongoing things that Mr. Epstein was doing, and\nthe two things never — they never came to my mind to connect them.\" JPMC Ex. 61 at 182:1019. Erdoes further testified that if she had \"learned and believed that [Epstein] was sexually\nabusing young children yes, he would be — I would ask to have him exited from the bank.\" JPMC\nEx. 61 at 180:19-21.\nInvestigation of Other Epstein Account Activity\n43.\n\nJPMC employees were aware of media reports in which the owner and president\n\nof MC2 Models Management denied receiving financial support from or having a working\nrelationship with Epstein. JPMC Ex. 122 at -36593, -36596.\n44.\n\nJPMC employees investigated Epstein's account activity, including his\n\ninvolvement with MC2 Models Management. As part of that investigation, AML investigator\nMaryanne Ryan noted that MC2 \"appear[ecl] to be a legit modeling agency.\" JPMC Ex. 123 at 25203.\n45.\n\nWilliam Langford stated that the modeling agency \"really tells us little\" about any\n\n\"possible linkages between the JPM accounts and bad activity.\" JPMC Ex. 123 at -25201.\n\n236\n\nEFTA02815466\n\n", "char_count": 1774}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n46.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 20 of 86\n\nLangford testified that \"Nile modeling agency is just that it didn't tell us\n\nanything, and our ability as a bank to know what's really going on in a modeling agency is\nextremely limited.\" JPMC Ex. 108 at 356:20-24.\n47.\n\nOn January 13, 2011, Ryan emailed Langford and Phil DeLuca regarding her\n\ninvestigation into Epstein, in which she concluded that there were \"no smoking guns.\" JPMC\nEx. 124 at -152809.\n48.\n\nIn March 2011, JPMC informed Epstein that it was not going to renew the\n\nSI million standby letter of credit (\"SBLC\") issued to Epstein to backstop a loan from Mellon to\nMC2 Models Management. JPMC Ex. 105 at -274776; JPMC Ex. 93.\n49.\n\nPrior to the SBLC expiring, it had never been drawn on. JPMC Ex. 102 at 221:5-\n\n222:15.\n50.\n\nAmong the conclusions reached by Ryan in her investigation was that Epstein had\n\nsponsored the opening of accounts for two adult women, including one described as a \"willing\nparticipant\" in the \"recaps of the escapades.\" JPMC Ex. 124 at -152809.\n51.\n\nIn opening accounts for\n\n, JPMC had information regarding her\n\ndate of birth, her social security number, driver's license number, and home address. JPMC Ex.\n58.\n52.\n\nJPMC Ex. 102 at 139:7-18.\n53.\n\nRyan also noted that Epstein \"pa[idj other girls, many models no huge amounts\"\n\nand described Epstein as a \"Sugar Daddy.\" JPMC Ex. 124 at -152809.\n\n237\n\nEFTA02815467\n\n", "char_count": 1432}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n54.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 21 of 86\n\nRyan testified that she understood the term \"sugar daddy\" to mean \"[s]omebody\n\nthat likes to spend his money on ladies\" but that she did not believe it \"impl[ied] financial\nsupport in exchange for sexual favors.\" JPMC Ex. 102 at 229:12-22.\n55.\nJPMC Ex. 102 at 225:5-231:12.\n56.\n\nWilliam Langford testified that this activity was \"in many respects . . .\n\ninconsistent with the types of things that we saw in human trafficking. You know, having her\nown account, providing money, providing documented expenses. The human trafficking\nenterprises that we were focused on were designed to traffic the individuals, keep them down,\ndo—do the business and keep it off the radar. This was different. I mean it's—it's pretty—I\ndon't like the behavior. But it's different from the typology of human trafficking that we had\nbeen focused on.\" JPMC Ex. 108 at 325:15-326:16.\n57.\n\nWilliam Langford testified that he did not believe that\nJPMC Ex. 108 at 488:9-\n\n18.\n58.\n\nWilliam Langford further testified that Maryanne Ryan's findings in her\n\ninvestigation of Epstein's account activity did not \"establish a link between JPMorgan and the\noperation by Epstein of a sex trafficking ring through the bank, on its face, in my opinion.\"\nJPMC Ex. 108 at 492:19-493:1.\nRecommendations la Evil Were Based on Rev:national Risk\n59.\n\nWilliam Langford testified that he recommended exiting Epstein as a client due to\n\nreputational risk concerns rather than legal concerns or concerns about Epstein's account\nactivity. JPMC Ex. 108 at 436:10-20, 488:5489:10. Langford further testified that he did not\n\n238\n\nEFTA02815468\n\n", "char_count": 1669}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 22 of 86\n\nbelieve that Epstein \"was engaging in continued illegal activity after his 2008 plea.\" JPMC Ex.\n108 at 487:24-488:4. Langford also testified that if he believed there were ongoing violations of\nlaw and others disagreed over exiting a client, he would have escalated that decision to the board.\nJPMC Ex. 108 at 283:6-284:16.\n60.\n\nStephen Cutler recommended exiting Epstein as a client and refraining from\n\nengaging in further business with him due to the reputational risk he created for the Bank JPMC\nEx. 79 at 209:24-210:7, 299:6-11; JPMC Ex. 126 at 76:2-6. Cutler further testified that, \"If Mr.\nEpstein was continuing to engage in unlawful activity, we didn't want him as a client.\" JPMC\nEx. 79 at 363:3-19.\n61.\n\nMaryanne Ryan testified that she and Phil DeLuca advocated exiting Epstein as a\n\nclient because \"[h]e was a reputational risk to the bank.\" JPMC Ex. 102 at 70:24-71:17, 129:1218.\n62.\n\nEpstein's former private banker, Mary\n\n\"escalated concerns for reputational\n\nrisk\" JPMC Ex. 66 at 34:10-14, 93:4-6.\n63.\n\nPhil DeLuca testified that AML Investigations' recommendation to exit Epstein\n\nwas based on \"reputational risk.\" JPMC Ex. 119 at 85:6-10.\n64.\n\nWith respect to Epstein's stabs as a client, John Duffy testified: \"I was of the\n\nopinion his reputational risk was not worth having him as an account, that's correct.\" JPMC Ex.\n77 at 125:5-7.\n65.\n\nKevin McCleerey testified that \"Mr. Epstein represented a reputational risk to the\n\nfirm.\" JPMC Ex. 103 at 38:8-10.\n66.\n\nJustin Nelson testified that understood that Epstein was terminated as a client due\n\nto considerations of \"reputational risk.\" JPMC Ex. 76 8:6-9.\n\n239\n\nEFTA02815469\n\n", "char_count": 1720}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 23 of 86\n\nStain\n67.\n\nFormer JPMC executive Jes Staley was the most senior and primary JPMC\n\nemployee responsible for the Bank's relationship with Epstein. JPMC Ex. 126 at 13:14-20;\nJPMC Ex. 127 at 75:17-19; JPMC Ex. 108 at 309:20-23, 336:4-14.\n68.\n\nJane Doe 1 testified that\nJPMC Ex. 128 at 140:6-149:20.\n\n69.\n\nStaley testified that he did not \"observe anything that caused [him] to question\n\nwhether Epstein was engaged in sex trafficking.\" JPMC Ex. 129 at 522:19-22.\nStaley Exchanged Suggestive Emails with Epstein About Women\n70.\n\nOn August 30, 2009, Epstein emailed Staley, \"how long London? Do you need\n\nanything there?\" Staley responded, \"Yep.\" JPMC Ex. 130.\n71.\n\nOn September 2, 2009, Epstein emailed\n\n,jes\n\nstaley is staying at the berkeley hotel in London tonight.\" JPMC Ex. 131.\n72.\n\nOn December 5, 2009, Epstein emailed Staley, \"you were with larry , [sic] and I\n\nhad to put up with . . . .\" and attached the following suggestive photograph of a young woman:\n\n240\n\nEFTA02815470\n\n", "char_count": 1051}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 24 of 86\n\nJPMC Ex. 132; JPMC Ex. 133.\n73.\n\nThat same day, Staley responded to Epstein, writing \"Don't tell me a\n\nwine.\" JPMC Ex. 132.\n74.\n\nOn December 20, 2009, Epstein emailed Staley the following photograph of a\n\nyoung woman:\n\n241\n\nEFTA02815471\n\n", "char_count": 309}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 25 of 86\n\nJPMC Ex. 134; JPMC EX. 135).\n75.\n\nOn June 16, 2010, Staley wrote to Epstein \"is she free tonight?\" Epstein\n\nresponded, \"call me.\" Staley replied, \"I'm with A.\" JPMC Ex. 136.\n76.\n\nOn July 9, 2010, Staley e-mailed Epstein, \"That was fun. Say hi to Snow =.\"\n\nEpstein responded, \"what character would you like next.\" Staley replied, \"Beauty and the Beast .\n...\" Epstein responded, \"well one side is available.\" JPMC Ex. 137.\nStaley Had a Close Personal Relationship with Epstein\n77.\n\nOn February 26, 2011, Staley emailed Epstein calling him \"Family.\" JPMC Ex.\n\n78.\n\nOn March 3, 2011, Epstein emailed Staley, writing, \"Told you—family.\" Staley\n\n138.\n\nresponded the same day, writing \"family.\" JPMC Ex. 139.\n79.\n\nOn March 4, 2011, Staley emailed Epstein saying that he counted Epstein \"as one\n\nof our deepest friends. And most honest of people.\" JPMC Ex. 140.\n\n242\n\nEFTA02815472\n\n", "char_count": 945}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n80.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 26 of 86\n\nOn March 5, 2011, Epstein emails Staley in response, calling him \"family.\"\n\nJPMC Ex. 140.\n81.\n\nOn March 7, 2011, Epstein emailed Staley saying \"[I] forgot to say thanks . .\n\nFamily.\" JPMC Ex. 141.\n82.\n\nOn March 10, 2011, Epstein emailed Staley, writing \"yup family dont [sic]\n\nworry.\" JPMC Ex. 142.\n83.\n\nOn March 18, 2011, Epstein emailed Staley saying \"Dear family member„ don't\n\nfret[.]\" JPMC Ex. 143.\nEpstein Provided Assistance with\n84.\n\nGraduate School Admissions\n\nApril 27, 2009, Epstein emailed Staley, writing\n\ncan meet have dinner lunch\n\na weekend with any of the following seth lloyd mit quantum computing..\nsanta-fe institute quarks „ brian\n\ngell-man ,\n\nColumbia -string theory„ leonard Susskind „ strings\n\nkrause„ origins institute phoenix arizona.. lee smolin premiter institute, loop\n\ntheory,\n\nquantum gravity , she can see the large hadron collider in switzerland. private tour [sic].\" JPMC\nEx. 144.\n85.\n\nStaley forwarded the email a,\n\nAlexa Staley, writing \"This is from\n\nuncle Jeffrey. Add Lisa Randell at Harvard.\" JPMC Ex. 144.\n86.\n\nOn October 24, 2009, Staley forwarded his _r\n\nfeedback Epstein provided\n\non a draft of her scholarship essay. JPMC Ex. 145.\n87.\n\nOn January 11, 2010,\n\nforwarded to Staley an email exchange she\n\nhad with Epstein, thanking him for inviting her to a physics conference in California. JPMC\n146.\n\n243\n\nEFTA02815473\n\n", "char_count": 1439}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n88.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 27 of 86\n\nOn September 23, 2010, Staley forwarded to Epstein an email froa\n\nabout a professor at Columbia University and asking Epstein if he could \"get to this professor at\nColumbia.\" On September 24, 2010, Epstein responded, \"in a snap.\" JPMC Ex. 147.\n89.\n\nOn November 11, 2010, Epstein emailed Staley in response to an email chain\n\nabout\n\napplication to\n\nwriting \"she can sit with Richard\n\nAxel when I get back, he won the Novel prize .. he has guaranteed me.\" JPMC Ex. 148.\n90.\n\nOn January 19, 2011, Staley forwarded to Epstein an email exchange between a\n\nprofessor and\n\nregarding her GRE scores \"not seem[ing] to be a problem\n\naccording to my sources.\" JPMC Ex. 149.\n91.\n\nAlso on January 19, 2011, Epstein emailed Staley, writing'-\n\nis now 70-30\n\nup from 45-55.\" JPMC Ex. 150.\nStaley Made Personal Visits/Vacations to Epstein Properties\n92.\n\nOn December 31, 2008, while Epstein was incarcerated, Staley made plans to\n\nvisit Epstein in Palm Beach, Florida. JPMC Ex. 151.\n93.\n\nOn October 23, 2009, Epstein emaib\n\n, writing that \"jes staley\n\nand wife are going to be at the ranch next weekend„ please coordinate= they get to stay in blue\nroom. [sic]\" JPMC Ex. 152.\n94.\n\nOn October 30, 2009, Staley emailed Epstein asking if he could go to Santa Fe. to\n\nwhich Epstein responded \"not today.\" JPMC Ex. 153.\n95.\n\nOn November 1, 2009, Staley emailed Epstein, writing \"So when all hell breaks\n\nlose [sic], and the world is crumbling, I will come here, and be at peace. Presently, I'm in the\nhot tub with a\n\nof\n\nwine. This is an amazing place. Truly amazing. Next time, we're\n\n244\n\nEFTA02815474\n\n", "char_count": 1658}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 28 of 86\n\nhere together. I owe you much. And I deeply appreciate our friendship. I have few so\nprofound.\" JPMC Ex. 154.\n96.\n\nOn January 8, 2010, Epstein emailed Staley about a visit to his private island in\n\nUSVI, writing, \"my car and driver, former dea armed. will pick you up in st\n\nwe have all\n\nthe on field permits.. helicopter also availble for a tour around , ... remember I own the two big\nmarinas.. yacht haven grand, in st\n\nand the marina at red hook... you can use my acv's jet\n\nski ,gym etc. , i will organize the harbor at Norman island if you like, in the boil . as well as\nlunch at guana..\" JPMC Ex. 155.\n97.\n\nOn January 22, 2011, Staley emailed Epstein about a visit to Epstein's island in\n\nUSVI, writing \"What a paradise. When I retire, I'm going to put a mooring in front of your dock\nfor my boat[.] Amazing place.\" JPMC Ex. 156.\nStaley Shared Confidential Information With Epstein\n98.\n\nOn multiple occasions, Staley shared with Epstein confidential information about\n\ntransactions the Bank was structuring or exploring. JPMC Ex. 157; JPMC Ex. 158; JPMC Ex.\n159; JPMC Ex. 160; JPMC Ex. 161; JPMC Ex. 162.\n99.\n\nStaley discussed the confidential status of other clients at the Bank with Epstein.\n\nJPMC Ex. 163.\n100.\n\nStaley shared information protected by the attorney-client privilege about\n\nEpstein's ongoing litigation against JPMC with Epstein. JPMC Ex. 164.\n101.\n\nStaley solicited feedback from Epstein on confidential drafts of shareholder\n\nletters. JPMC Ex. 165.\n102.\n\nStaley kept Epstein informed about the status of the Bank's investigation into the\n\nallegations against him. JPMC Ex. 166; JPMC Ex. 167.\n\n245\n\nEFTA02815475\n\n", "char_count": 1709}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 29 of 86\n\nStaley Vouched for Epstein\n103.\n\nJes Staley vouched for Epstein on multiple occasions by telling other JPMC\n\nexecutives and employees that Epstein was not engaged in criminal conduct. JPMC Ex. 126 at\n169:7-12.\n104.\n\nMaly Erdoes testified that Jes Staley had a \"very different\" characterization of\n\nEpstein than the press reports following his arrest. JPMC Ex. 61 at 213:17-21.\n105.\n\nWilliam Langford, JPMC's former General Counsel for Global Compliance and\n\nRegulatory Management, testified that Jes Staley told him that, with respect to Epstein's\nconviction in 2008 on state charges for solicitation of prostitution and procurement of a minor\nfor prostitution, Epstein \"didn't do it, shouldn't have pled guilty, et cetera, wasn't responsible for\nit\" and that Epstein's lawyers were working to get the guilty plea \"thrown out.\" JPMC Ex. 108\nat 323:6-14, 370:10-17.\n106.\n\nJPMC's former General Counsel, Stephen Cutler, testified that Jes Staley told him\n\nthat Epstein had \"turned a page\" \"paid his debt to society\" \"turned a corner\" and \"was on the\nstraight and narrow.\" JPMC Ex. 126 at 58:23-60:4, 163:3-164:11.\n107.\n\nStephen Cutler relied on Jes Staley's views in evaluating the Bank's relationship\n\nwith Epstein because Staley was a \"respected member of the operating committee\" and knew\nEpstein. JPMC Ex. 126 at 167:1-19.\nB.\n\nJPMC Did Not \"Participate\" In Any Epstein Sex-Trafficking Venture\n\nAttempts to Verily OngoingInvestigation\n108.\n\nFollowing the January 2011 rapid response meeting, employees within JPMC's\n\nPrivate Bank discussed the Epstein relationship with Staley, who spoke to Epstein about the\nmedia allegations, which Epstein \"claimed were without merit.\" JPMC Ex. 105 at -274776.\n\n246\n\nEFTA02815476\n\n", "char_count": 1789}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 30 of 86\n\n109.\n\nJPMC Ex. 33; JPMC Ex. 34 at -274529; JPMC Ex. 79 at 351:7-17; JPMC Ex. 168.\n110.\n\nOn March 7, 2011, Stephen Cutler emailed Jonathan\n\nasking if he spoke\n\nto Staley about \"Ken Staff's best friend?\" That same day, Jonathan\n\nreplied, \"Yes and\n\ndidn't get anything back from him, so I just called him again. He said he'll call Epstein and get\nme a live name and number for a current lawyer. The recent headlines (re FBI reopening its\ninvestigation in Daily Mail and NY Post over the weekend, and guilt-by-being-friends stories\nabout Prince Andrew and former President Clinton) aint [sic] great. Cc'ing William.\" JPMC\nEx. 168.\n111.\n\nOn March 9, 2011, Jonathan\n\ndiscussed with Stephen Cutler, then-\n\nGeneral Counsel for JPMC, the need to determine where \"there's actually a live federal\ninvestigation\" into Epstein. JPMC Ex. 34 at JPM-SDNYLIT-00274529.\n112.\n\nOn March 15, 2011, Jonathan\n\nemailed Stephen Cutler that he contacted\n\nJay Leflcowitz, Epstein's attorney, to inquire whether there was any such investigation. Mr.\nLefkowitz explained that he and Epstein had heard nothing to suggest that there was a current\nFBI or other law enforcement agency investigation. As to any suggestion in the media of an\nongoing investigation, \"according to Jay, [they] don't seem to have any basis.\" JPMC Ex. 34 at\nJPM-SDNYLIT-00274528.\n\n247\n\nEFTA02815477\n\n", "char_count": 1415}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n113.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nOn or about March 22, 2011, Jonathan\n\nPage 31 of 86\n\nspoke to the United States\n\nAttorney for the Southern District of Florida, who did not disclose any investigation into Epstein.\nJPMC Ex. 35; JPMC Ex. 36 at 18.\n114.\n\nJPMC also reached out to the FBI to ask for a contact at the agency who may\n\nhave been working on any ongoing investigation into Epstein. The FBI never returned the phone\ncall. JPMC Ex. 36 at 19; JPMC Ex. 37 at 151:19-152:24; 329:5-330:21.\nCurrency Transaction Reports Related to Epstein\n115.\n\nBetween 2002 and 2013, JPMC filed approximately 150 CTRs related to Epstein\n\nand his accounts in which JPMC identified its relationship with Epstein, flagged his large cash\nwithdrawals. JPMC Ex. 39 at 195; JPMC Ex. 41.\n116.\n\nSeventy-three of these CTRs were filed before Epstein was arrested in July 2006.\n\nJPMC Ex. 41.\n117.\n\nLaw enforcement never contacted JPMC in response to any CTR. JPMC Ex. 38\n\nat 136:23-137:11; JPMC Ex. 39 at 130 n.28.\n\n118.\nJPMC Ex. 108 at 353:2-9.\n119.\n\nJPMC Ex. 102 at 23:14-19.\n120.\n\nMaryanne Ryan testified: \"The SAR decision lies solely with the investigations\n\ndepartment. Could an employee under me have discussed it with another person within\n\n248\n\nEFTA02815478\n\n", "char_count": 1271}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 32 of 86\n\ninvestigations? Sure. But they weren't going back to the business to discuss the merits of SAR\nfiling.\" JPMC Ex. 102 at 27:10-16.\n121.\n\nIn her expert report, Terry Pesce opined that,\nAt times banks will conduct transaction reviews or \"lookbacks.\"\nBanks may conduct lookbacks if they are looking for a particular\nkind of past activity or if they receive a request from law\nenforcement. This entails a much more granular and pointed\nreview of historical activity. The bank would see activity it would\nnot have reviewed in the ordinary course of monitoring, and\nnotably, the bank would likely file SARs it would not have filed in\nfulfilling its day-to-day AML program obligations.\nJPMC was required to perform a transaction lookback in\nconnection with the 2013 Consent Order. However regulators\nrequired the Bank to examine activity with non-bank financial\ninstitutions. There is nothing in the required lookback to suggest\nexaminers were concerned that the bank failed properly to monitor\nhigh-risk Private Bank clients or to detect human trafficking.\nMoreover, it is unlikely that even a broader-scoped lookback\nwould have uncovered Epstein's transactions with individuals. I\nhave supervised numerous lookbacks. They require applying\nadditional scenarios or more precise thresholds to past activity that\nmight not have alerted under a bank's monitoring systems. They\ndo not general) entail settin thresholds at the low dollar amounts\nat issue here.\nImportantly, lookbacks are conducted with information that might\nnot have been available or meaningful when the underlying\ntransactions occurred. Banks act with the information they have\nbefore them. The USVI created demonstrative exhibits for use in\ndepositions that collect granular information now available. What\nmay seem relevant in hindsight may not have been apparent at the\ntime.\n\nJPMC Ex. 60 at 11 121-23.\n\n249\n\nEFTA02815479\n\n", "char_count": 1954}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n122.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 33 of 86\n\nWilliam Langford testified that nobody from JPMC's business ever tried to\n\ndissuade him from filing a SAR related to a customer and that he was not aware of any instance\nin which an employee in JPMC's lines of business ever tried to dissuade a colleague from filing\na SAR related to a customer. JPMC Ex. 108 at 486:18487:4.\n123.\n\nWilliam Langford testified that he never decided against filing a SAR related to a\n\ncustomer that he believed was warranted \"because the customer was particularly large or\nvaluable\" and that he was not aware of any instance in which any JPMC employee believed a\nSAR should be filed but failed to do so \"because the client was particularly large or valuable.\"\nJPMC Ex. 108 at 487:5-11.\n124.\n\nJPMC Ex. 119 at 332:5-11.\n125.\n\nJPMC Ex. 108 at 486:7-17.\n126.\n\nPhil DeLuca testified that nobody from JPMC's Private Bank ever tried to\n\ndissuade him from filing\n\n\"doing anything at all in connection with\" Epstein and\n\nthat he was not aware of any instance in which an employee in JPMC's Private Bank ever tried\nto dissuade a colleague from\n\n\"doing anything in connection with\" Epstein.\n\nJPMC Ex. 119 at 330:24-332:4.\n\n250\n\nEFTA02815480\n\n\n\n[═══ TRANSCRIPT ═══]\nCase 1:22-cv-10904-JSR  Document 284-5  Filed 08/14/23  Page 34 of 86  127. JPMC Ex. 39 at 1¶19-21, 30. 128.  JPMC Ex. 42. 129.  MEJPMC Ex. 43. 130.  JPMC Ex. 44. 131.  JPMC Ex. 169; JPMC Ex. 170. 132. JPMC Ex. 102 at 25:5-7.  251  EFTA02815481", "char_count": 1504}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 34 of 86\n\n127.\nJPMC Ex. 39 at 1¶19-21, 30.\n128.\n\nJPMC Ex. 42.\n129.\n\nMEJPMC Ex. 43.\n130.\n\nJPMC Ex. 44.\n131.\n\nJPMC Ex. 169; JPMC Ex. 170.\n132.\nJPMC Ex. 102 at 25:5-7.\n\n251\n\nEFTA02815481\n\n", "char_count": 246}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 35 of 86\n\n133.\n\nJPMC Ex. 45.\n134.\n\nOn June 19, 2013, Phil DeLuca sent an email to Cynthia Arnim describing the\n\nhistory of escalations of the Bank's relationship with Epstein. JPMC Ex. 171.\n135.\n\nOn July 19, 2013, Maryanne Ryan sent an email to Kevin McCleerey, James\n\nDalessio, and Phil DeLuca \"to follow up on the Epstein withdrawals\" and noted that she believed\nhis explanation that the withdrawals for fuel \"seeuiredi odd.\" JPMC Ex. 172.\n136.\n\nJPMC Ex.\n173.\n137.\n\nJPMC Ex. 173.\n\n252\n\nEFTA02815482\n\n\n\n[═══ TRANSCRIPT ═══]\nCase 1:22-cv-10904-JSR  Document 284-5  Filed 08/14/23  Page 36 of 86  138. JPMC Ex. 173. 139.  JPMC Ex. 102 at 202:21-203:4. 140.  JPMC Ex. 46 at IPM-SDNYLIT-W-0001908600019096. 141. JPMC Ex. 174. 142.  JPMC Ex. 47 at JPM-SDNYL1T-W-00018180-00018196. 143.  253  EFTA02815483", "char_count": 861}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 36 of 86\n\n138.\nJPMC Ex. 173.\n139.\n\nJPMC Ex. 102 at 202:21-203:4.\n140.\n\nJPMC Ex. 46 at IPM-SDNYLIT-W-0001908600019096.\n141.\nJPMC Ex.\n174.\n142.\n\nJPMC\nEx. 47 at JPM-SDNYL1T-W-00018180-00018196.\n143.\n\n253\n\nEFTA02815483\n\n", "char_count": 277}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 37 of 86\n\nJPMC Ex. 48 at JPM-SDNYLIT-W-00002185-00002196.\n144.\n\nIPMC Ex. 38 at 136:23-137:11; JPMC Ex. 39 at 130 n.28.\n145.\n\nUSVI's law enforcement expert, Shaun O'Neill ■\n\nFJPMCEx. 80 at 11:4-13.\n146.\n\nMr. O'Neill testified that\n\nJPMC Ex. 80 at 58:13-59:2.\n147.\n\nMr. O'Neill further testified that\n\nJPMC Ex. 80 at 59:8-60:2.\n148.\n\nOn July 9, 2019, JPMC employees began an investigation into Epstein's banking\n\nrelationship with the Bank. JPMC Ex. 175 at -37464.\n149.\n\nJPMC Ex. 176.\n\n254\n\nEFTA02815484\n\n\n\n[═══ TRANSCRIPT ═══]\nCase 1:22-cv-10904-JSR  Document 284-5  Filed 08/14/23  Page 38 of 86  150.  JPMC Ex. 177 at -17206. 151.  JPMC Ex. 178 at -8097. 152.  255  EFTA02815485", "char_count": 740}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 38 of 86\n\n150.\n\nJPMC Ex. 177 at -17206.\n151.\n\nJPMC Ex. 178 at -8097.\n152.\n\n255\n\nEFTA02815485\n\n\n\n[═══ TRANSCRIPT ═══]\nCase 1:22-cv-10904-JSR  Document 284-5  Filed 08/14/23  Page 39 of 86  PMC Ex. 335 at -8820. 153.  JPMC Ex. 179 at -21053, -21055. 154.  JPMC Ex. 180 at 207. 155.  256  EFTA02815486", "char_count": 359}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 39 of 86\n\nPMC Ex. 335 at -8820.\n153.\n\nJPMC Ex. 179 at -21053, -21055.\n154.\n\nJPMC Ex. 180 at 207.\n155.\n\n256\n\nEFTA02815486\n\n\n\n[═══ TRANSCRIPT ═══]\nCase 1:22-cv-10904-JSR  Document 284-5  Filed 08/14/23  Page 40 of 86  JPMC Ex. 181 at -175. 156.  JPMC Ex. 182 at -223. 157.  PMC Ex. 183 at -548. 158.  JPMC Ex. 184 at -8121.  257  EFTA02815487", "char_count": 401}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 40 of 86\n\nJPMC Ex. 181 at -175.\n156.\n\nJPMC Ex. 182 at -223.\n157.\n\nPMC Ex. 183 at -548.\n158.\n\nJPMC Ex. 184 at -8121.\n\n257\n\nEFTA02815487\n\n", "char_count": 197}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 41 of 86\n\n159.\n\nJPMC Ex. 185 at -22630.\n160.\n\n(JPMC Ex. 186 at -8142.\n161.\n\nJPMC Ex. 187 at 8162.\nJPMC Exiled Epstein as a Client\n162.\n\nMary Erdoes testified that in 2013 she became concerned with Epstein's cash\n\nusage and \"thought the explanation was an outsized amount of cash, and even though that was\nhis explanation for where the cash was being used, that in conjunction with the culmination of\n\n258\n\nEFTA02815488\n\n", "char_count": 481}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 42 of 86\n\neverything else and the fact that I didn't know or like Mr. Epstein, I had no reason to vouch for\nMr. Epstein to be a client of the bank, and I recommended exit and we exited.\" JPMC Ex. 61 at\n183:8-15.\n163.\n\nIn explaining the factors that went into Epstein's exit in 2013,\n\nPearn\n\ntestified: \"A number of factors, in no particular order. There was continued negative media that\nthe line of business and the risk department continued to see. There was continued cash and wire\nactivity in many of Epstein's accounts. There was, I'll say, a long-time view of many of the\npeople in the line of business, in the risk and compliance organization, that Mr. Epstein should\nbe exited or should have been exited, as I'm sure we'll cover, and Jes Staley was no longer at the\nbank. And I'd say the last thing was at that time the industry, the regulatory environment, was—\nhad changed. JPMorgan had received AML consent orders earlier in 2013, along with a number\nof other banks. The regulatory view of bank's role in combating money laundering, terrorist\nfinancing, was—had changed. And as part of that, our institution was looking at our portfolio or\nour book of high-risk clients and taking a fresh look at whether or not we should maintain those\nrelationships. So a number of factors.\" JPMC Ex. 94 at 116:15-117:19.\n164.\n\nOn July 17, 2013, JPMC employees and executives, including John Duffy, Mary\n\nErdoes, Stephen Cutler, and Justin Nelson met to discuss the status of Epstein's relationship with\nthe Bank, and decided to terminate the relationship. JPMC Ex. 188; JPMC Ex. 189.\n165.\n\nOn July 19, 2013, John Duffy emailed Mary Erdoes a draft of talking points to\n\ncommunicate the Bank's decision to exit Epstein as a client. Duffy wrote: \"1. The repetitive\nnature of your cash transactions is a problem for us and our relationship with you. 2. The\nregulatory standards in the banking industry continue to evolve with a very low tolerance\n... [truncated, 2120 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02815448/41 or ?id=EFTA02815448&page=41]", "char_count": 2120}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 43 of 86\n\ncircumstances we are in a uniquely challenged situation. Remediation is required and we need to\nask you — in an orderly manner — to find another bank for your needs.\" JPMC Ex. 190.\n166.\n\nOn August 9, 2013, Mary Erdoes emailed several JPMC employees and\n\nexecutives, including Cynthia Armine, Stephen Cutler, Nina Shenker, Donna Dellosso, John\nDuffy, and Phil Dilorio, writing, \"Re our client exit, the conversation went well and was very\nprofessional. I suspect the call last night might have helped. It will move in an orderly process.\nJohn did an excellent job.\" JPMC Ex. 191.\n167.\n\nOn August 14, 2013, John Duffy emailed Justin Nelson, writing, \"Thanks. He and\n\nI spoke as well about his advisory business and whether our [sic] not we would work with him. I\nsaid 'yes', as long as we were not transacting in JE accounts.\" JPMC Ex. 192.\n168.\n\nOn September 13, 2013, John Duffy emailed Justin Nelson regarding a request\n\nfrom Epstein for \"more credit,\" writing, \"the answer needs to be `no,' followed by this is a great\nopportunity to move forward with you [sic] new bank.\" JPMC Ex. 193.\n169.\n\nOn September 20, 2013, John Duffy emailed Mary Erdoes about Epstein, writing,\n\n\"Spoke with him. Good conversation. Told JE no on sole trustee or POA, yes for advisory role\nwithout discretion. Yes for custody in the client's name. Tough one he brought up regarding\nGates — JE and JPM as co-trustee. While I expect that this would be hard to get through — its\n[sic] like co-branding with him. We should still discuss it — Let's talk. He understood.\" JPMC\nEx. 75.\nC.\n\nJPMC Did Not Knowingly Benefit From A Sex-Trafficking Venture\n\n170.\n\nJamie Dimon testified that he did not \"recall any involvement on [Epstein's] part\"\n\nin JPMC's acquisition of Highbridge Capital Management, LLC and that he was not \"informed\n\n260\n\nEFTA02815490\n\n", "char_count": 1894}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 44 of 86\n\nthat Jeffrey Epstein received a $15 million fee for his work in connection with that transaction.\"\nJPMC Ex. 55 at 57:6-58:16.\n171.\n\nEpstein's company, Financial Trust Company, Inc., had been retained as a\n\nconsultant by Highbridge Capital Management, LLC. JPMC Ex. 194.\n172.\n\nFinancial Trust Company, Inc. received a $15 million fee from\n\n& Swieca\n\nHoldings, Inc. related to JPMC's acquisition of a majority interest in Highbridge Capital\nManagement in 2004. JPMC Ex 194; JPMC Ex. 195; JPMC Ex. 116 at 164:17-20.\n173.\n\nEpstein did not receive a fee from JPMC in connection with JPMC's acquisition\n\nof a majority interest in Highbridge Capital Management. JPMC Ex. 116 at 164:10-16.\n174.\n\nBy 2014,\n\nBlack was a \"longstanding client of the private bank.\" JPMC Ex.\n\n196 at -902716.\n175.\n\nPearn testified: \"As the founder and one of the senior leaders at Apollo\n\nGlobal Management, the bank had a long established relationship with Apollo and with Mr.\nBlack. My understanding is that\n\nBlack was one of Mr. Epstein's clients as a money\n\nmanager. And as far as I've been able to determine, we don't see any—or I don't see any\nintroduction of\n\nBlack as a private bank client through Mr. Epstein.\" JPMC Ex. 116 at\n\n182:5-19; see also JPMC Ex. 70 at 386:14-17.\nH.\n\nJPMC Did Not Obstruct Or Attempt To Obstruct An Effort To Enforce The TVPA\n176.\n\nOn August 15, 2007, Bear Steams received a Grand Jury Subpoena from the U.S.\n\nDistrict court for the Southern District of Florida seeking \"all documents referring or relating to\nJeffrey Epstein.\" JPMC a. 197 at -373075.\n177.\n\nOn August 27, 2007, members of Bear Steams AML and Litigation departments\n\nspoke to Assistant U.S. Attorney Ann\n\nVillafana \"regarding the scope of the Grand Jury\n\n261\n\nEFTA02815491\n\n", "char_count": 1816}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 45 of 86\n\nSubpoena.\" \"During the conversation, the AUSA stated that Bear Stearns was not a target of the\ninvestigation. Moreover, a member of the AML Group asked the AUSA if any of the activity\nconcerning the Epstein investigation might have triggered a reporting requirement for the Finn.\nThe AUSA answered that question in the negative.\" JPMC Ex. 197.\n178.\n\nOn August 27, 2007 and September 6, 2007, Assistant U.S. Attorney\n\nVillafana sent letters to Bear Stearns clarifying the scope of the Grand Jury Subpoena. JPMC\nEx. 198.\n179.\n\nIn response to the Grand Jury Subpoena, Bear Steams reviewed transfers out of\n\nEpstein's accounts in the amounts of 51,000 or 3100,000 and concluded that the \"account(s) does\nnot appear to be implicated in the alleged wrongdoing\" and that the review \"revealed no\nsuspicious or unusual third party wire transfers consistent with those mentioned in the abovedescribe [sic] Probable Cause Affidavit or news articles. Based upon the available facts, this\ninvestigation is closed and nothing further is deemed necessary.\" JPMC Ex. 197 at -373076.\nM.\n\nSUMMARY JUDGMENT CANNOT ENTER ON JPMC'S AFFIRMATIVE\nDEFENSES\nA.\n\nEpstein Made Payments To USVI Officials And Entities\n\n180.\n\nOn December 21, 2017, Epstein wrote to Dawn Henry of the USVI Department of\n\nPlanning and Natural Resources (\"DPNR\") that he had given \"25 k to the home for girls in st\ncroix\" and asked Henry for suggestions on where he could donate. JPMC Ex. 199.\n181.\n\nOn December 27, 2017, Epstein directed Richard Kahn (Epstein's accountant) to\n\nwrite a $25,000 check from Southern Trust Company, Inc. (\"STC\") to the DPNR for a donation\nto a public library. JPMC Ex. 200.\n182.\n\nIn connection with that donation, Dawn Henry wrote to Epstein on December 27,\n\n2017, to suggest specific libraries to which Epstein could donate. She additionally wrote to\n\n262\n\nEFTA02815492\n\n", "char_count": 1924}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 46 of 86\n\nEpstein: \"If you prefer to donate to school libraries I can connect you with the Commissioner for\nEducation. Either way the Territory wins.\" JPMC Ex. 200.\n183.\n\nThe USVI government \"review[ed] its corporate sponsorships after it emerged\n\nthat Jeffrey Epstein, the convicted sex offender ... gave gifts to school pupils and financed\nevents for young children.\" JPMC Ex. 201.\n184.\n\nEpstein provided funding for a science fair for children in grade school in the\n\nUSVI run by the USVI Department of Education. He also specifically paid for travel and\naccommodations for prize-winning children to attend the science fair in St.\n\n. JPMC Ex.\n\n201.\n185.\n\nEpstein provided funding for a summer camp for children with intellectual\n\ndisabilities through his USVI-based corporations. JPMC Ex. 201 at 1, 2.\n186.\n\nEpstein funded a prize for the winners of a school essay-writing competition.\n\nJPMC Ex. 201 at 2.\n187.\n\nEpstein paid for computers to be given to two 14-year-old students attending high\n\nschool in the USVI. JPMC Ex. 201 at 2.\n188.\n\nEpstein purchased Kindle e-readers for use by a school library. JPMC Ex. 201 at\n\n189.\n\nEpstein purchased over 100 Microsoft Surface tablets for use by children in USVI\n\n2.\n\nschools. JPMC Ex. 201 at 2.\n190.\n\nEpstein provided funding through his USVI businesses for a basketball\n\ntournament in the USVI, which included children as young as six. JPMC Ex. 201 at 2.\n\n263\n\nEFTA02815493\n\n", "char_count": 1486}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n191.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 47 of 86\n\nOn December 16, 2018, Cecile de Jongh wrote to Epstein that Governor Albert\n\nBryan had suggested two schools, Coral Reef Academy and Junior Achievement, to which\nEpstein could make a $50,000 donation. JPMC Ex. 202; JPMC Ex. 203 at 162:20-167:1.\n192.\n\nOn December 20, 2018, Cecile de Jongh wrote to Epstein that Governor Albert\n\nBryan had requested that Epstein donate $30,000 to the USVI Little League. JPMC Ex. 204.\n193.\n\nIn 2010, one of Epstein's USVI-based businesses, Financial Trust Company, Inc.\n\n(\"FTC\") donated $3,500 to the Virgin Islands Police Department. JPMC Ex. 205 at -6070.\n194.\n\nIn August 2012, Epstein was asked to provide finding for two USVI police\n\nofficers to attend a homicide investigation training program in New York. He wrote to Cecile de\nJongh that he \"always would like to support these things\" but that \"in the past\" it had been\n\"looked upon with suspicious [sic].\" Cecile de Jongh responded: \"Suspicion locally? My\nthought was that this would be ok because it is specifically homicide training.\" Epstein\nresponded \"face to face.\" JPMC Ex. 206.\n195.\n\nOver multiple election cycles, Epstein donated $5,400, the maximum amount\n\nallowed, to the campaign of Congresswoman Stacey Plaskett, the Delegate to the United States\nHouse of Representatives from the USVI. JPMC Ex. 207 at 148:8-17; JPMC Ex_ 244.\n196.\n\nCongresswoman Plaskett previously worked for the USVI Economic\n\nDevelopment Authority (\"EDA\") and for a law firm that represented Epstein related to his USVI\nbusinesses. JPMC Ex. 207 at 14:24-15:5; 86:4-24; JPMC Ex. 208 at 101:4-13.\n197.\n\nCecile de Jongh asked Epstein to donate money to Congresswoman Stacey\n\nPlasket. JPMC Ex. 208 at 189:4-12.\n198.\n\nCecile de Jongh asked Epstein to donate $13,000 to the Democratic Party on\n\nbehalf of Congresswoman Stacey Plaskett. JPMC Ex. 208 at 195:2-8.\n\n264\n\nEFTA02815494\n\n", "char_count": 1925}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n199.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 48 of 86\n\nCongresswoman Plaskett also asked Epstein to donate the maximum amount to\n\nthe Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee (\"DCCC\"), which was approximately\nS30,000. JPMC Ex. 207 at 219:7-221:13.\n200.\n\nEpstein attempted to donate $30,000 to the DCCC, but the donation was returned\n\nafter Epstein failed to meet the DCCC's vetting requirements. JPMC Ex. 207 at 226:10-227:12;\nJPMC Ex. 208 at 195:17-197:9.\n201.\n\nEpstein requested that Congresswoman Plaskett's campaign keep his donations\n\nanonymous. JPMC Ex. 209.\n202.\n\nOn June 19, 2014, Cecile de Jongh emailed Epstein that his \"help [was] needed\"\n\nbecause \"[w]e are trying to get Stacey Plaskett elected to Congress.\" She further stated that \"we\nwould have a friend in Stacey\" and asked Epstein if \"any of [his] friends would give to her\ncampaign.\" JPMC Ex. 210.\n203.\n\nEpstein requested, through Cecile de Jong'', that his employees and other\n\nindividuals donate to Congresswoman's Plaskett's campaign. JPMC Ex. 210; JPMC Ex. 208 at\n191:1-20, 194:2-195:1.\n204.\n\nEpstein and his employees donated over S30,000 to Congresswoman Plaskett's\n\ncampaigns across three congressional election cycles. JPMC Ex. 207 at 303:17-305:20.\n205.\n\nOn June 23, 2014, Erika Kellerhals emailed Cecile de Jongh with the subject\n\n\"help!!\" \"I need to raise S20k by Wednesday for Stacey. Think I can ask JEE? Anyone else you\ncan think of?\" Cecile de Jongh replied \"I asked him already.\" JPMC Ex. 211.\n206.\n\nOn October 24, 2014, Cecile de Sough wrote to Epstein to confirm \"that STC will\n\nsend $13k to the Democratic Party for the benefit of Stacey Plaskett.\" JPMC Ex. 212.\n\n265\n\nEFTA02815495\n\n", "char_count": 1695}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n207.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 49 of 86\n\nOn October 17, 2014, Cecile de Jongh and Epstein exchanged emails regarding a\n\n$15,000 donation from Epstein's personal account to the St. Croix District Democratic Party.\nJPMC Ex. 213; JPMC Ex. 208 at 187:18-189:3.\n208.\n\nAs part of that email thread, on October 16. 2014, Cecile de Jongh wrote that\n\n\"[future Governor] Kenn Mapp and [Senator] Celestino\n\nwould like to see you.\" JPMC\n\nEx. 213.\n209.\n\nOn November 10, 2016, Epstein emailed Cecile de Jongh to ask \"how did our\n\ncandidates do?\" Cecile de Jongh responded that \"[t]en of the twelve candidates that we gave\ncontributions to won\" and that she \"personally raised funds for two candidates ... whom STC did\nnot contribute to and they won as well.\" She also attached a list of candidates and stated that\n\"the names in bold and above the line the line [sic] are the winners?' JPMC Ex. 214; JPMC Ex.\n215.\n210.\n\nOn February 16, 2018, Cecile de Jongh emailed Epstein regarding upcoming\n\nelections and candidates and stated that his \"best bet is to give wide but nominal support in the\nprimary to solidify relationships and then strongly support the winner of the primary going into\nthe general election.\" JPMC Ex. 216.\n211.\n\nOn October 2, 2018, Cecile de Jongh emailed Richard Kahn that she \"discussed\n\nthe political contributions with him. I asked about writing checks from STC and he said to talk\nto you but his guess is yes\" and includes a list of four candidates: Alicia Barnes, Donna FrettGregory, Stedman Hodge Jr., and Athneil Bobby M.\n\nKahn replies that he \"spoke with jee\n\nyesterday and ok to cut all checks (4) from STC.\" Ms. de Jongh forwards that email to Una\nPascal and asks her to \"cut the checks ($1,000 each) indicated below.\" JPMC Ex. 217.\n\n266\n\nEFTA02815496\n\n", "char_count": 1805}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n212.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 50 of 86\n\nCecile de Jongh agreed to list her telephone number on the DCCC website as the\n\ncontact information for donations from Jeffrey Epstein. JPMC Ex. 218.\n213.\n\nOn November 9, 2018, Ms. de Jongh emailed Jeanne\n\ncopying Richard\n\nKahn with the subject \"PAC Check.\" She asks\n\nto \"[p]lease prepare a check in the\n\namount of S25,000 to the below entity from STC as per JE\n\n. From Adriane Dudley: The Pac is\n\nIslands Engaged, Inc.\n214.\n\n\" JPMC Ex. 219.\n\nOn November 10, 2014, Cecile de Jongh wrote to Epstein that the \"Mapp\n\ncampaign is going to take the S that you gave to attack John\" and asked: \"Can we stop payment\non the check to send a message?' JPMC Ex. 220.\n215.\n\nOn September 1, 2016, Epstein asked to prepare a check to donate $75,000 to a\n\nsuper PAC associated with Governor Kenneth Mapp. JPMC Ex. 221; JPMC Ex. 208 at 197:17198:20.\n216.\n\nOn December 18, 2014, Sebastiano Palewonsky Cassinelli wrote to Cecile de\n\nJongh \"[r]egarding a contribution to the Mapp-Potter Inaugural Committee\" and stated the\nCommittee \"would welcome any donation that Mr. Epstein would be so inclined to make.\"\nCecile de Jongh then wrote to Epstein to confirm that he wanted \"to donate S10,000 to the MappPotter Inaugural committee and that it should come from Southern Trust.\" JPMC Ex. 222;\nJPMC Ex. 223 at 101:25-103:3.\n217.\n\nOn December 20, 2018, Cecile de Jongh wrote to Epstein regarding a request\n\nfrom the Bryan/Roach Inaugural Committee for a $25,000 donation from Epstein for inaugural\nevents. JPMC Ex. 315; JPMC Ex. 203 at 172:11-176:5.\n\n267\n\nEFTA02815497\n\n", "char_count": 1622}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n218.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 51 of 86\n\nOn August 29, 2016, Ms. Una Pascal emailed Ms. Cecile de Jongh that \"[Epstein]\n\nadded three more Senators to the list\" after \"he met with the Governor last week in St. Croix.\"\nJPMC Ex. 225.\n219.\n\nIn January 2014, at the request of Cecile de lough, Epstein donated $15,000 to the\n\nSpecial Events Fund for Governor John de Jongh related to Governor de Jongh's State of the\nTerritory reception. JPMC Ex. 226; JPMC Ex. 208 at 186:3-187:17; JPMC Ex. 224 at 101:6103:21.\n220.\n\nEpstein paid S10,000 to USVI Senator Celestino\n\nto consult on changing the\n\nname of one of Epstein's islands. JPMC Ex. 228; JPMC Ex. 208 at 102:6-13, 106:20-107:13;\nJPMC Ex. 229.\n221.\n\nFrom January 2007 to January 2015, Cecile de lough was the First Lady of the\n\nUSVI. JPMC Ex. 208 at 16:9-17:16.\n222.\n\nCecile de Jongh was the manager for two of Epstein's USVI-based businesses,\n\nFTC and STC. JPMC Ex. 224 at 39:25-40:11.\n223.\n\nIn 2007, Cecile de Jongh was paid $200,904 in salary, bonuses, and other benefits\n\nfor her work as a manager for one of Epstein's USVI-based businesses. JPMC Ex. 230.\n224.\n\nBetween 2000 and 2014, Epstein paid over $325,000 in tuition payments for John\n\nand Cecile de Jongh's children to attend the Antilles school, and more than $300,000 for their\nchildren to attend Skidmore and American universities. JPMC Ex. 231; JPMC Ex. 230; JPMC\nEx.233; JPMC Ex. 234; JPMC Ex. 224 at 142:3-144:5.\n225.\n\nOn September 21, 2010, Cecile de Jongh wrote to Epstein that she and Governor\n\nJohn de Jongh \"have put money into the campaign based on what [they] thought was going to\nhappen with the tuition payments.\" JPMC Ex. 235; JPMC Ex. 224 at 144:13-145:24.\n\n268\n\nEFTA02815498\n\n", "char_count": 1738}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n226.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 52 of 86\n\nOn September 25, 2015, Epstein wrote to Cecile de Jongh to offer to lend money\n\nto Governor John de Jongh \"so he immediatly has it [sic]\" in connection with a criminal case\nbrought against Governor de Jongh. Epstein stated he would \"play any role in this you guys\nlike\" and stated he would \"gladly be on thephone (anonymouse) with john quinn and the\nprosecutor offering suggestions. [sic]\" JPMC Ex. 236; JPMC Ex. 208 at 159:3-160:25.\n227.\n\nOn December 27, 2015, Governor John de Jongh wrote to Epstein to state that he\n\nwas \"near to an agreement on the [USVI Department of Justice's] acceptance of 5380k\" and that\nGovernor de Jongh \"would like to take [Epstein] up on [his] offer and request to borrow S215k.\"\nJPMC Ex. 237.\n228.\n\nEpstein loaned Cecile de Jongh and John de Jongh $200,000 related to a criminal\n\ncase brought against Governor John de Jongh. JPMC Ex. 208 at 89:23-92:7; JPMC Ex. 224 at\n39:15-21; 82:7-18; 292:22-298:24.\n229.\n\nOn June 27, 2017, Governor John de Jongh wrote to Epstein to \"again express my\n\nappreciation and thank you for the assistance at a very difficult time, it made matters much\neasier.\" JPMC Ex. 238.\n230.\n\nAfter Epstein's death, Cecile de Jongh was provided a lump sum payment of\n\n$305,763.89 in\n\npayments for her termination from Southern Trust Company. JPMC\n\nEx. 239.\n231.\n\nOn November 19, 2019, Cecile de lough emailed Jeanne\n\nwith the subject\n\n\"Talking Points.\" The attachment, \"11.19.19 Talking Points,\" contains talking points for\nrequested\n\nand states that \"all the employees were loyal to Jeffrey Epstein\"; that \"we\n\nare put a[t] further disadvantage to the loyalty that was exhibited\"; and that \"[t]he requested\nis not a pay-off but an acknowledgement of our tenure with the company and its early\n\n269\n\nEFTA02815499\n\n", "char_count": 1839}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 53 of 86\n\ndissolution while we transition to other employment. (Cannot be seen as a pay-off as we were\nnot complicit in any acts.).\" JPMC Ex. 240; JPMC Ex. 241.\n232.\n\nOn February 5, 2015, Cecile de Jongh emailed Lesley Groff to ask her to\n\n\"[p]lease include on JE's schedule a meeting with former Senator Celestino\n\non Tuesday,\n\nFebruary 10th at 2 PM at the STC Office. The POC will be me.\" JPMC Ex. 242. On February\n11, 2015, Cecile de Jongh wrote to Epstein stating he \"might want to consider putting [USVI\nSenator] Celestino 1=]\n\non some sort of monthly retainer\" because it would \"get [Epstein] his\n\nloyalty and access.\" JPMC Ex. 243; JPMC Ex. 208 at 107:20-109:12.\n233.\n\nFrom 2002 through 2006, Financial Trust Company \"spent more than S5 4 million\n\ninto the local economy.\" JPMC Ex. 245 at VI-JPM-000021922.\n234.\n\nOn January 12, 2017, Sharon McCollum, the Commissioner of the USVI\n\nDepartment of Education wrote to Everett Barnes, who worked for RMC Research Corporation,\nand Cecile de Jongh, \"I have asked Mrs. deJongh to include her employer, Jeffery Epistien [sic],\nin reviewing a list of potential donors to see if he is familiar with individuals to facilitate `inside'\ncontacts. RMC will supply a list of possible contacts for review. We are planning a meeting,\nFebruary 19, 2017, to bring to the table all parties that can assist DOE with making this vision a\nreality.\" JPMC Ex. 247.\n235.\n\nOn January 17, 2017, Everett Barnes wrote to Cecile de Jongh copying Sharon\n\nMcCollum, the Commissioner of the USVI Department of Education, with the subject\n\"Introduction; DOE Public Private Partnerships.\" He writes: \"We will need `influencers,' like\nMr. Epstien [sic] and others, who can open the doors and get the Commissioner an audience ....\nIt would be wonderful if we could build a small core group of `influencers' who have a personal\ncommitment to the VI and who would be willing to provide some resources to get some\n\n270\n\nEFTA\n... [truncated, 2010 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02815448/52 or ?id=EFTA02815448&page=52]", "char_count": 2010}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 53, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 54 of 86\n\ninitiatives off the ground without all the politics and bureaucracy associated with govt or\nfoundation funding.\" JPMC Ex. 247; JPMC Ex. 248.\n236.\n\nOn February 27, 2017, Ms. Karen Pulliam Turnbull, of the Office of the\n\nCommissioner for the USVI Department of Education, wrote to Ms. Cecile de Jongh\n\"Commissioner McCollum requested that I contact you relative to your assurance to speak with\nMr. Jeffrey Epstein regarding other individuals who the Department of Education can possibly\ncontact for funding.\" JPMC Ex. 249.\nB.\n\nEpstein Gave USVI Government Officials And Entities Non-Monetary\nBenefits\n\n237.\n\nCecile de Jongh stayed at Epstein's apartment in New York for about a month in\n\n2017. JPMC Ex. 250; JPMC Ex. 208 at 42:17-24.\n238.\n\nIn February 2017, Epstein wrote Cecile de Jongh to state that \"the vi govt is\n\ndesperate for cash\" and asked if former Governor John de Jongh knew of USVI government\nproperties that could serve as collateral for a S50 million dollar loan from Epstein. Cecile de\nJongh stated that she would \"get a list of GOVI properties.\" JPMC Ex. 251; JPMC Ex. 208 at\n202:23-206:2; JPMC Ex. 224 at 342:14-346:19.\n239.\n\nGovernor Kenneth Mapp testified that he discussed eCommerce issues with\n\nEpstein and asked him for assistance in \"spreading the word that the Virgin Islands had\" a\n\"unique attribute that it was pushing for business investment\" regarding \"a redundant platform\nthat was tied in by fiber-optic and undersea cables into Florida and into New York\" that could\nbenefit businesses. JPMC Ex. 223 at 119:2-120:7.\n240.\n\nGovernor Mapp testified that he sought \"Epstein's advice about how to increase\n\nbusiness investment in the Virgin Islands.\" JPMC Ex. 223 at 120:21-122:7.\n\n271\n\nEFTA02815501\n\n", "char_count": 1796}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 54, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n241.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 55 of 86\n\nGovernor Mapp testified that he sought Epstein's advice on \"how to be successful\n\nin issuing what was some really critically-needed bonds for financing some critical financing\nneeds of the territory.\" JPMC Ex. 223 at 40:2-42:21.\n242.\n\nGovernor Mapp testified that he sought Epstein's assistance in legislative efforts\n\nto allow EDC beneficiaries to repatriate their income to make USVI's EDC program more\nattractive. He further testified that William Blum, one of Epstein's attorneys, helped draft\nlegislation regarding these repatriation efforts. JPMC Ex. 223 at 61:22-65:23.\n243.\n\nOn December 20, 2019, Celina D. Morris emailed Ms. Cecile de Jongh with the\n\nsubject \"Introduction to the VIEDA Business Ambassador.\" She attached a \"letter from VIEDA\nCEO, Kamal M,\n\nrequesting your company's assistance with promoting the VIEDC tax\n\nincentive program, as well as introducing you to our Business Ambassador, Yolanda Bryan. Ms.\nBryan is available to assist you with any challenges you may encounter as you do business in the\nU.S. Virgin Islands. She will be contacting you to schedule a meeting in the new year.\" JPMC\nEx. 246.\nC.\n\nUSVI Had Knowledge Of Epstein's Crimes\n\n244.\n\nIn October 2007, Page Six published an article titled \"Epstein's Tropic Isle of\n\nBabes,\" which stated that the \"sordid sex scandals surrounding Jeffrey Epstein are making waves\nin the Caribbean, where the billionaire owns a private 900-acre getaway and has deep financial\nties to the governor of the U.S. Virgin Islands.\" The article further stated that Epstein \"regularly\nferried boatloads of young women there.\" JPMC Ex. 252.\n245.\n\nUSVI's 2010 sex offender file on Epstein contained a copy of a Daily Beast\n\narticle titled \"Billionaire Pedophile Goes Free\" that Florida law enforcement faxed to USVI DOJ\nin July 2010. JPMC Ex. 253 at 74:24-75:16; JPMC Ex. 254 at 12215. Among other things, it\n\n272\n\nEFTA02815502\n\n", "char_count": 1967}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 55, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 56 of 86\n\nstated that Epstein had a \"private Caribbean island,\" that victims made allegations about trips\n\"out of state and abroad on Epstein's private jets\" that would have been evidence of sex\ntrafficking, that the FBI's investigation reached as far back as 2001, and that the FBI had\nidentified roughly 40 victims. JPMC Ex. 253 at 75:16-76:21; JPMC Ex. 254 at 12215.\n246.\n\nThe Government's 30(6)(6) witness on sex offender monitoring, Ms. Inais\n\nBorque, testified that the Government was aware of the contents of Epstein's sex offender files,\nincluding the Daily Beast article. JPMC Ex. 253 at 75:17-76:21.\n247.\n\nOn May 1, 2009, Jane Doe No. 102 filed a lawsuit in the Southern District of\n\nFlorida alleging that Epstein was transporting victims to the USVI. JPMC Ex. 255.\n248.\n\nOn January 13, 2015, the Guardian published an article titled \"Jeffrey Epstein's\n\nDonations to Young Pupils Prompts US Virgin Islands Review.\" It stated that the USVI was\ngoing to \"review its corporate sponsorships after it emerged that Jeffrey Epstein, the convicted\nsex offender and friend to Prince Andrew, gave gifts to school pupils and financed events for\nyoung children.\" The article further stated that a woman had alleged that she was \"made to\nengage sexually with Andrew at Epstein's Virgin Islands property.\" JPMC Ex. 201 at 1, 2.\n249.\n\nJPMC Ex. 256, JPMC Ex. 257; JPMC Ex. 258 at\n42:10-44:02.\n250.\n\n273\n\nEFTA02815503\n\n", "char_count": 1473}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 56, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 57 of 86\n\nJPMC Ex. 259 at 61109.\n\nJPMC Ex. 259 at 61132-61144.\n251.\n\nOn January 26, 2017, Jane Doe 43 filed a lawsuit in the Southern District of New\n\nYork against Epstein and others alleging that she was required to perform sexual acts on Epstein\nin the USVI and that on one occasion after suffering verbal abuse and threats by Epstein and\nothers she attempted to escape from his private island only for a search party to locate her and\nphysically return her to the main house on the island. JPMC Ex. 260\n252.\n\nr 42, 46.\n\nMs. Pinney testified that anyone, including USVI DOJ, could have run a search\n\nfor online media articles on Epstein. JPMC Ex. 261 at 222:18-223:12.\n253.\n\nFormer Attorney General Denise\n\ntestified that she reviewed civil\n\ncomplaints against Epstein when she became the Attorney General. JPMC Ex. 262 at 74:1976:25.\n254.\n\nFormer Attorney General Carol\n\ntestified that she is \"sure the\n\nVirgin Islands would be aware of any national press accounts.\" JPMC Ex 263 at 127:13-17.\n255.\n\nAttorney General Carol\n\nfurther testified that if the USVI knew of\n\nallegations in civil lawsuits they had a \"responsibility to follow up\" on the allegations. JPMC\nEx. 263 at 131:3-132:4.\nD.\n\nUSVI's Lax Sex Offender Monitoring Of Epstein Facilitated His Crimes\n\n256.\n\nUSVI's 30(bX6) witness on sex offender monitoring, Ms. Maui Pinney, testified\n\nthat there was never any investigation by USVI DOJ into Epstein. JPMC Ex. 261 at 207:9208:24.\n\n274\n\nEFTA02815504\n\n", "char_count": 1524}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 57, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n257.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 58 of 86\n\ntestified that when she became AG in April 2019, there was a lot of\n\ninformation \"swirling around the media\" with respect to what had been occurring on LSJ, and\nUSVI DOJ was receiving a lot of media inquiries on the subject. JPMC Ex. 264 at 159:9-162:2,\n164:3-171:17; JPMC Ex. 262 at 75:2-76:25.\n258.\n\nShe \"want[ed] to find out what happened because ... this thing went by for so\n\nmany years\" which was \"mind-boggling.\" JPMC Ex. 264 at 163:07-16. She started to make\n\"inquir[ies]\" into the allegations, including inquiring with USVI DOJ, and the USVI Police\nDepartment to find out if there were any complaints about Epstein. During the same period, she\nstarted keeping up with media reports and civil lawsuits involving Epstein. JPMC Ex. 264 at\n164:3-171:17; JPMC Ex. 262 at 75:2-76:25.\n259.\n\ntestified that USVI DOJ did not have the resources it needed to\n\ninvestigate Epstein. JPMC Ex. 264 at 164:3-170:3.\n260.\n\nThe USVI's 3\n\nShani Pinney, testified that budget constraints\n\ndid not \"in any way\" impact USVI's ability to monitor Epstein. JPMC Ex. 261 at 126:7-129:2.\n261.\n\nIn April 2009, First Lady Cecile de Jongh wrote to Epstein about transferring his\n\nparole from Florida to USVI. Ms. de Jongh wrote that she \"forwarded the document [he] sent\n[her] last week to John and he tried to send it to Vincent\" but it was \"corrupted — Vincent can't\nopen either.\" Later in the email chain, Epstein resends the attachment and she writes, back\n\"Thanks — sending again to John . . . John will email to Vincent.\" JPMC Ex. 265.\n262.\n\nGovernor John de Jongh testified that he emailed the parole request to the\n\nAttorney General and told the First Lady to speak directly to the Attorney General about it.\nJPMC Ex. 224 at 227:19-25, 228:12-229:7.\n\n275\n\nEFTA02815505\n\n", "char_count": 1833}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 58, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n263.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 59 of 86\n\nFirst Lady Cecile de Jongh testified that she never spoke to the Attorney General\n\nabout it but that the Governor did and relayed to her how Epstein should proceed as to the parole\nrequest. JPMC Ex. 208 at 163:1-164:9.\n264.\n\nThe Attorney General claimed he had no memory of the outreach by either of the\n\nde Jonghs regarding transferring Epstein's parole to the USVI. JPMC Ex. 266 at 39:20-40:16.\n265.\n\nOn\n\nde Jongh forwarded an email to Epstein with \"suggested\n\nlanguage\" for USVI's Sex Offender Registration and Notification Act (SORNA) legislation.\nThe original sender information is cutoff, but the author writes: \"I considered the language you\nshared with me. I believe this language may be best. We need to be able to know whether a\nperson is at the address or not. To waive the notice requirement all together will not be\nacceptable to the federal DOJ program managers. Remember they must review and determine if\nwe are in compliance. This is the suggested language; will it work for you?\" JPMC Ex. 267 at\n024493. Epstein replied that \"we should add out of country for more than 7 days, otherwise I\ncould not go for a day trip to Tortola ,at the last minute.\" JPMC Ex. 267. Ms. de Jongh replies\nthat \"This needs to be settled by Thursday because J goes away for a week and AG needs to\nsubmit by June 1. Don't want to email back and forth.\" JPMC Ex. 267.\n266.\n\nOn\n\nde Jongh emailed Epstein \"If you could only change one\n\nthing in the bill, what would it be? The question of your lop priority' came up.\" Epstein replies\nthat \"I would add that the attorney general can waive the notice requirement if the offenders\nvocation requires more than three intl trips per year.\" JPMC Ex. 268.\n267.\n\nOn June 19, 2012, Ms. Maria Hodge, Epstein's attorney, emailed Attorney Ayala,\n\nthe legal counsel to the USVI legislature, the following: \"As promised, I attach a copy of my\n\n276\n\nEFTA02815506\n\n", "char_count": 1966}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 59, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nnotes on the amendments to the bill I understand Senator\n\nPage 60 of 86\n\nhas agreed to support ....\"\n\nJPMC Ex. 269; JPMC Ex. 270; JPMC Ex. 271; JPMC Ex. 266 at 9:8-22.\n268.\n\nOn June 22, 2012, Ms. Hodge emailed Wayne\n\na USVI DOS legal\n\ncounsel, and Monica Carbon, legal counsel to the Attorney General. Ms. Hodge writes that \"in a\nphone call I received from the AG today . . . we had discussed communicating with Attorney\nCarbon about\" the legislation. Ms. Carbon responds with USVI's \"counterproposal\" to the\nlegislation that Attorney Carbon had requested. JPMC Ex. 272.\n269.\n\nOn June 25, 2011, Ms. Hodge emailed USVI Senator Ronald\n\nblind\n\ncopying Epstein, that she believes that Attorney Carbon's \"counter-proposal\" still has \"a number\nof problems.\" She states that she sent the \"attached compromise proposal to Attorney Carbon\"\nand that it was specifically prepared to cover the \"DOS concern that there be no off island travel\nwithout some notice, even in emergency situations, but to allow notice by expedited means in\nthose cases, and also to adopt some reasonable criteria for frequent travelers.\" She states that she\nhopes he will \"offer this language rather than the draft the DOJ prepared.\" JPMC Ex. 227;\nJPMC Ex. 273.\n270.\n\nMs. Hodge's counterproposal requests the following exceptions to the 21-day\n\nrequirement: \"provided, however, that a sex offender who provides reasonable and reliable\nproof satisfactory to the Department of Justice, that he travels outside the United States\nfrequently for work or other legitimate purposes, and a sex offender who travels outside the\nUnited States for emergency situations, shall notify the [DOJ] prior to departure, by telephone or\nin writing, of travel outside the United States for periods of forty-eight (48) hours or less, and\nshall notify the [DOJ] in writing at least twenty four (24) hours before traveling outside of the\nUnited States for periods of more than forty-eight (48) hours, \n... [truncated, 2056 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02815448/59 or ?id=EFTA02815448&page=59]", "char_count": 2056}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 60, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 61 of 86\n\nthe [Dal] in writing upon the sex offender's return to this jurisdiction; and provided further, that\nthe Attorney General may at his discretion reduce the twenty-one (21) day notice requirement if\na sex offender requests such a reduction and provides information in support of the request,\nsatisfactory to the [DOJ][.]\" JPMC Ex. 273.\n271.\n\nMs. Hodge's counterproposal also requests the following language concerning\n\ninformation the sex offender must provide: \"Within twenty-one (21) days prior to travel away\nfrom the Virgin Islands, the sex offender shall provide the information set forth below in writing\nto the Department of Justice, provided, however, that a sex offender who provides reasonable\nand reliable proof satisfactory to the Department of Justice that he travels frequently for work or\nother legitimate purposes, and a sex offender who travels for emergency situations, shall provide\nsuch information to the Department of Justice prior to departure by telephone or in writing, for\ntravel away from the Virgin Islands for periods of forty-eight (48) hours or less, and shall\nprovide such information in writing to the Department of Justice in writing . . . at least twenty\nfour (24) hours before traveling away from the Virgin Islands for periods of more than forty []\neight (48) hours; and provided further, however, that the Attorney General may at his discretion\nreduce this twenty-one (21) day notice requirement if a sex offender requests such a reduction\nand provides information in support of the request: (i) identifying information of the temporary\nlodging locations, including addresses and names, or, in the case of a sex offender who provides\nreasonable and reliable proof to the [DOJ] that he travels frequently for work or other legitimate\npurposes, reliable information regarding general travel locations and areas of work in lieu of\nspecific addresses, and contact telephone information at which th\n... [truncated, 2152 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02815448/60 or ?id=EFTA02815448&page=60]", "char_count": 2152}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 61, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 62 of 86\n\nthe sex offender will be staying at each temporary lodging location, or in such general locations\nand areas of work.\" JPMC Ex. 273.\n272.\n\nMs. Monica Carbon, legal counsel to the Attorney General, stated that at the time\n\nshe was not concerned about receiving input from Ms. Hodge on the sex offender legislation\nbecause she \"knew that anything submitted had to be approved by US DOJ.\" JPMC Ex. 274;\nJPMC Ex. 261 at 54:14-55:14.\n273.\n\nMs. Pinney testified that \"anyone seeing that draft [sex offender legislation\n\noutside of DOJ] would . . . have been a problem definitely\" and that she \"definitely\" would have\nbeen \"surprised\" to hear that it had been shared with Epstein. JPMC Ex. 261 at 294:10-296:7.\n274.\n\nFirst Lady de Jongh testified that she spoke to her husband, Governor de Jongh,\n\nabout Epstein's preferences for the SORNA legislation. JPMC Ex. 208 at 165:19-166:24. She\ntestified that she never spoke with the Attorney General about Epstein in relation to the\nlegislation, but her husband did. JPMC Ex. 208 at 165:19-166:24.\n275.\n\nGovernor de Jongh initially testified that he never spoke to the First Lady or the\n\nAttorney General regarding Epstein and the proposed legislation. JPMC Ex. 224 at 245:10-12,\n242:25-244:07. After being confronted with documents, he acknowledged speaking to both Ms.\nde Jongh and the Attorney General regarding Epstein and the proposed legislation. JPMC Ex.\n224 at 270:17-278:7.\n276.\n\nAttorney General Frazer claimed not to recall any interactions with the Governor\n\nor First Lady regarding the sex offender legislation. JPMC Ex. 266 at 178:6-179:2.\n277.\n\nAttorney General Frazer testified that he believes that at some point a compromise\n\nwas worked out between Epstein's team and USVI DOJ on the language of the amendments.\nJPMC Ex. 266 at 173:5-25.\n\n279\n\nEFTA02815509\n\n", "char_count": 1884}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 62, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n278.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 63 of 86\n\nMs. de Jongh testified that Epstein's team and USVI DOJ reached an agreement\n\non the language of the amendments, but that Senator\n\nchanged his mind, and also that\n\nAttorney General Frazer did not push hard enough for the agreed language. JPMC Ex. 208 at\n177:2-180:11.\n279.\n\nOn June 28, 2012, the legislature of the USVI passed Act No. 7372, an act\n\namending chapter 86 of title 14 of the Virgin Islands Code, which contains the laws of the USVI\nregarding the monitoring and tracking of sex offenders within USVI. JPMC Ex. 275 at 65.\nGovernor de Jongh approved the bill on July 18, 2012. Id. at 66.\n280.\n\nThe Act deleted and replaced subsection 1724(bX4) with the following language:\n\n\"All sex offenders required to register in this jurisdiction shall appear in person at the [DO.1] at\nleast twenty one (21) calendar days prior to any intended travel outside of the United States and\nprovide information about their intended travel as may be required by the Attorney General;\nprovided, however, that the Attorney General may at his discretion reduce this twenty-one (21)\nday notice requirement if a sex offender requests such a reduction and provides information in\nsupport of the request.\" JPMC Ex. 275 at 37.\n281.\n\nIt also deleted and replaced subsection 1726(2)(bX16) with the following\n\nlanguage: \"Within twenty-one (21) days prior to Travel for 7 days or more, the sex offender\nshall provide the following information; provided, however, that the Attorney General may at his\ndiscretion reduce this twenty-one [Q21) day notice requirement if a sex offender requests such a\nreduction and provides information in support of the request. (i) identifying information of the\ntemporary lodging locations including addresses and names, and (ii) the dates the sex offender\nwill be staying at each temporary lodging location. (iii) the Attorney General at his discretion\n\n280\n\nEFTA02815510\n\n", "char_count": 1962}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 63, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 64 of 86\n\nmay require other information in lieu of the above information upon the request of a sex\noffender.\" JPMC Ex. 275 at 49.\n282.\n\nOn July 1, 2012, Ms. de Jongh sent Epstein an email with the subject line \"Next\n\nsteps.\" She stated: \"I know this was a horrible week and I am really sorry about how things\npanned out . . . However, all is not lost and [] we will figure something out by coming up with a\ngame plan to get around these obstacles ... We will need to work through Dowe and\n\nto\n\nget this accomplished. In the mean time, we will work with Vincent to give the discretion for\nstatus quo for you — that's the least he can do.\" JPMC Ex. 276.\n283.\n\nOn July 30, 2012, Epstein wrote to Ms. de Jongh: \"I appreciate you keeping[] a\n\nclose watch on the Mincent issue. We will have to go for an amendment soon, I do not want to\nalienate him so he whispers in nissells ear.\" JPMC Ex. 277.\n284.\n\nOn December 14, 2012, another amendment to chapter 86 of title 14 passed.\n\namending section 1724(b) as follows: \"striking in paragraph (4) `may be required by the\nAttorney General' and inserting `provided in § 1726; however, a sex offender who provides\nreasonable and reliable proof satisfactory to the Department of Justice, that he travels frequently\noutside the United States for work or other legitimate purposes, or a sex offender who travels\noutside the United States for emergency situations, shall notify the Department of Justice prior to\ndeparture, by telephone or in writing, of travel outside the United States for periods of 48 hours\nor less, and shall notify the Department of Justice in writing at least 24 hours before traveling\noutside of the United States for periods of more than 48 hours, and, in any such case, shall notify\nthe Department of Justice in writing upon the sex offender's return to this jurisdiction.\" JPMC\nEx. 278 at 2.\n\n281\n\nEFTA02815511\n\n", "char_count": 1933}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 64, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n285.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 65 of 86\n\nIt also amended 1726(b) by \"striking the language in (16) in its entirety and\n\ninserting new language that read as follows: 'A sex offender who provides reasonable and\nreliable proof satisfactory to the Department of Justice, that he travels frequently outside the\nUnited States for work or other legitimate purposes, and a sex offender who travels outside the\nUnited States for emergency situations, shall notify the Department of Justice prior to departure,\nby telephone or in writing, of travel outside the United States for periods of 48 hours or less, and\nshall notify the Department of Justice in writing at least (24) hours before traveling outside of the\nUnited States for periods of more than (48) hours, and, in any such case, shall notify the\nDepartment of Justice in writing upon the sex offender's return to this jurisdiction; however, the\nAttorney General may, at his discretion, reduce the 21-day notice requirement, if a sex offender\nrequests such a reduction and provides information in support of the request, satisfactory to the\nDepartment of Justice. The information must include: identifying information of the temporary\nlodging locations, including addresses and names, or, in the case of a sex offender who provides\nreasonable and reliable proof satisfactory to the Department of Justice, that he travels for work or\nother legitimate purposes frequently, reliable information regarding general travel locations and\nareas of work in lieu of specific addresses, and contact telephone information at which the sex\noffender can be contacted without unreasonable delay at all times while traveling away from the\nVirgin Islands; and (ii) The dates the sex offender will be staying at each temporary lodging\nlocation, or in such general locations and areas of work. . .'\" JPMC Ex. 278 at 2.\n286.\n\nIn a July 25, 2012 letter, Attorney General Frazer informed Ms. Maria Hodge that\n\nhe was granting Epstein a wa\n... [truncated, 2183 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02815448/64 or ?id=EFTA02815448&page=64]", "char_count": 2183}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 65, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 66 of 86\n\nand that it may be given in person, by facsimile correspondence which is signed by him, or by email with an electronic signature. JPMC Ex. 279 at -12263.\n287.\n\nIn an August 14, 2012 letter, Attorney General Frazer informed Ms. Hodge that\n\n\"[tr]fler careful review of your letter giving additional information to support ... Jeffrey\nEpstein's request\" he was allowing Epstein to notify the DOJ of his intention to travel out of\nUSVI within 24 hours prior to departure; to notify when he was staying in one of his stateside\nhomes and to provide a current list and addresses of each of his stateside homes; when staying in\na non-private lodging, to provide the specifics of the name, city and address of the establishment;\nand when he was staying in the home of an associate, to notify the department of the city and\nstate or country in which he is temporarily staying and his period of stay in the jurisdiction.\nJPMC Ex. 279 at -12275.\n288.\n\nMs. Pinney testified that she was not aware of any other sex offender who\n\nreceived or requested a more permanent waiver similar to what Epstein requested. JPMC Ex.\n261 at 306:8-21; 450:14-19. She further testified that \"I do want to say though — you said if they\n— if anyone ever made requests. We got complaints all the time, you know. So offenders, you\nknow, complain about the frequency, everything all the time.\" JPMC Ex. 261 at 306:8-21.\n289.\n\nMr. Frazer testified that during his tenure as Attorney General he never granted\n\nspecial treatment to Epstein because of Mr. or Mrs. de Jongh. JPMC Ex. 266 at 247:12-248:3.\n290.\n\nHe considered (and continues to consider) Mr. de Jongh his friend. JPMC Ex.\n\n266 at 43:19-20; 243:11-13.\n291.\n\nMr. Frazer testified that he gave Epstein the waiver based on the representations\n\nof Epstein's lawyers that he was a businessman, and online research Mr. Frazer's staff did for\nhim. JPMC Ex. 266 at 199:3-14; 252:23-253:18.\n\n283\n\nEFTA02815513\n\n", "char_count": 1996}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 66, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n292.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 67 of 86\n\nMs. Carbon does not recall \"doing any research or work on this request for a\n\nwaiver.\" JPMC Ex. 274. Ms. Pinney testified she does not know what was provided to Mr.\nFrazer in support of the waiver. JPMC Ex. 261 at 61:19-63:11.\n293.\n\nIn a March 14, 2019 letter, Former Attorney General\n\nwrote to\n\nEpstein that \"while provisions were granted in the past\" USVI1DO.1 was now requiring\nnotification of any travel outside of the U.S. Virgin Islands in person at USVI DOJ when Epstein\nwas in USVI at least 21 calendar days prior to the travel. JPMC Ex. 280 at -12328; JPMC Ex.\n263 at 39:23-40:15.\n294.\n\nFormer Attorney General\n\ntestified that she was \"surprised\" and\n\n\"concerned\" to see the waivers that had been granted to Epstein in the past. JPMC Ex. 263 at\n39:3-20; 40:17-23. She testified that she \"did not see anything in [his] file to support the waiver\"\nand that the \"better course\" would have been to have him adhere closely to the statute. JPMC\nEx. 263 at 23:21-24:2; 40:22-41:6.\n295.\n\ntestified that she reviewed Epstein's file and never saw proof of a\n\nlegitimate reason for frequent travel and that that made her think that maybe Epstein did not have\nany. JPMC Ex. 262 at 214:14-216:4.\n296.\n\nA couple of weeks after\n\nbecame Attorney General in April 2019,\n\nGovernor Bryan approached her (either by phone or in person, she could not recall) to let her\nknow that Epstein was planning to ask her to reinstate the notification requirements that had\napplied to him under Former Attorney General Frazer. He \"expressed [a] position\" on the\nrequest, and \"encouraged\" her to meet with Epstein's attorneys to discuss the request. JPMC Ex.\n264 at 104:7-16; JPMC Ex. 262 at 173:19-174:13.\n\n284\n\nEFTA02815514\n\n", "char_count": 1780}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 67, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n297.\n\nAfter\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 68 of 86\n\nhad received the request, Governor Bryan texted her to remind\n\nher to make a decision on the request. JPMC Ex. 262 at 223:1-10.\n298.\n\ntestified that she believes that such outreach was \"improper\" because\n\nthe Governor should not have been involved in a law enforcement matter. JPMC Ex. 262 at\n221:19- 222:14. She testified that it indicated to her that Epstein was \"flexing his political\ninfluence over or with the Governor in an effort to get a favorable result in ... a law enforcement\nissue\" which was a \"red flag\"; that the \"fact that the request was made on behalf of a \"convicted\nchild . . . molester, [] predator\" through \"the Governor instead of the regular channels was . . .\nconcerning\"; and that it showed that it was the \"Governor's priority\" for \"some reason\" and that\nthere \"exist[ed] some degree of political influence\" by Epstein over Governor Bryan. JPMC Ex.\n262 at 219:21-221:24; 222:2-13; 232:05-235:13.\n299.\n\nAfter denying Epstein's request, she sent an email to Governor Bryan explaining\n\nthe reasons for her decision and explaining that the statute was there to \"protect the community.\"\nShe did so because she felt that Governor Bryan \"needed an understanding as to the importance\nand the magnitude of the [notification] requirement.\" JPMC Ex. 262 at 229:06-230:11.\n300.\n\nShe testified that her refusal to reinstate the notification requirements \"likely\"\n\nimpacted her standing with Governor Bryan, because she was \"doing [her] job without respect to\nany political interference,\" and irrespective of what \"political influence\" Epstein may have had,\nand that that may have been the first time that Governor Bryan was faced with that. JPMC Ex.\n262 at 236:23-238:9.\n301.\n\nMs. Pinney testified that USVI DOJ never asked for Epstein's lawyers input into\n\nwhat Tier he should be classified as. JPMC Ex. 261 at 329:17-330:15; 333:7-12.\n\n285\n\nEFTA02815515\n\n", "char_count": 1955}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 68, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n302.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 69 of 86\n\nOn September 6, 2012, Darren Indyke wrote to Ms. Shaul Pinney stating \"As you\n\nrequested when Mr. Epstein appeared at the Department of Justice on Tuesday, I have attached\ncopies of Mr. Epstein's two U.S. Passports and a Memorandum explaining why Mr. Epstein\nqualifies as a tier 1 offender.\" JPMC Ex. 279 at -12286.\n303.\n\nMs. Pinney testified that, although she thinks all sexual offenses are \"serious\n\nalike,\" the statute classifies certain crimes at higher tier levels depending on the \"details of the\ncase.\" JPMC Ex. 261 at 230:23-231:18.\n304.\n\nEpstein served a 13-month sentence and was convicted of solicitation of a minor.\n\nJPMC Ex. 11; JPMC Ex. 12. Under USVI's Sex Offender Legislation, a \"Tier 1\" offense\nincludes any sex offense that is not a \"Tier 2\" or \"Tier 3\" offense. JPMC Ex. 281, §\n172113(a)(1). And a Tier 2 offense includes any sex offense against a minor that involves \"the\nuse of minors in prostitution, including solicitations.\" Id. §1721B(b)(2).\n305.\n\nA summary of a meeting with Ms. Carbon indicates that Ms. Carbon \"want[ed]\n\nhim to be classified higher but . . . believed they weren't able to put him as a level 3.\" JPMC\nEx. 274. It also states that Ms. Carbon \"can't recall whether she considered [his] 13 month\nsentence when looking at the tier assignment for Epstein\" and \"can't recall\" her analysis about\nthe fact that solicitation of minors is designated as a Tier 2 offense under the statute. JPMC Ex.\n274. It further states that she \"can't recall the process to which a tier was assigned\" nor \"who\nmade the determination but believed it was likely her.\" JPMC Ex. 274.\n306.\n\nMs. Pinney, USVI's 30(bX6) designee on sex offender monitoring of Epstein,\n\ntestified that she did not know why Epstein was classified as a Tier I offender and did not know\nanyone else in the USVI government who would know or could explain what the basis for\nclassifying Epstein as a Tier I was. JPMC Ex. 261 at 324:\n... [truncated, 2031 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02815448/68 or ?id=EFTA02815448&page=68]", "char_count": 2031}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 69, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n307.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 70 of 86\n\nMs. Borque testified that sex offenders are \"usually\" checked \"once a week,\" in\n\naddition to an \"annual operation\" that performs compliance checks for all of the offenders in that\nweek. Thus, she estimated that it was possible that \"the average offender would be checked [] 50\ntimes in a year because there's [sic] 52 weeks in the year.\" JPMC Ex. 253 at 199:10-200:23.\n308.\n\nMs. Pinney testified that there are no weekly checks; only the annual operation.\n\nJPMC Ex. 261 at 400:1-12; 441:10-21.\n309.\n\nMs. Borque testified that \"part of the reason for doing compliance checks\" is so\n\nthat \"if an investigator is there and sees something suspicious, they can report it\" and that more\nfrequent checks make it less likely that offenders will engage in criminal activity because \"they\nknow they're being checked on.\" JPMC Ex. 253 at 202:11-15; 205:3-14.\n310.\n\nMs. Pinney testified that the purpose is to \"confum that what the offender has\n\nprovided as their permanent residence, and also . . . their employer address . . . is true and []\ncorrect.\" JPMC Ex. 261 at 437:14-22.\n311.\n\nUSVI DOJ performed a total of five compliance checks on Epstein. JPMC Ex.\n\n282; JPMC Ex. 253 at 220:2-7 (does not know of any compliance checks being lost for Epstein).\nOf those five checks, he was present on the island only once. JPMC Ex. 282 at -12619-12620.\n312.\n\nNone of the compliance boxes were checked \"Needs Investigation\" or \"Not in\n\nCompliance\". JPMC Ex. 282.\n313.\n\ntestified that investigators should have followed up after the\n\nissues with Epstein's compliance checks. JPMC Ex. 262 at 114:11-115:21. Mr. Frazer testified\nthat he might have filed charges or a complaint in court had he known that Epstein was denying\nthe investigators access to LSJ. JPMC Ex. 266 at 217:15-218:21.\n\n287\n\nEFTA02815517\n\n", "char_count": 1864}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 70, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n314.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 71 of 86\n\nMs. Pinney testified that even when an offender is not present they are not in\n\nnoncompliance, and that even though the policy was to follow up and check on an offender when\nhe wasn't there, USVI DOJ lacked access to a boat so it could not do so for Epstein. JPMC Ex.\n261 at 407:9-410:4.\n315.\n\nJPMC Ex. 304.\n316.\nJPMC Ex. 261 at 419:07420:10; JPMC Ex. 283.\n317.\n\nMs. Pinney is not aware of any follow-up actions that were taken to respond to the\n\ntip about Epstein's criminal activity. JPMC Ex. 261 at 420:11-421:3; JPMC Ex. 258 at 51:552:14.\n318.\n\nWhen asked if she found the complaint credible, she testified that she \"made the\n\ndecision to forward it on;\" and that it \"may have been\" credible but also that the offender was\n\"very questionable.\" JPMC Ex. 261 at 443:14-444:07.\n319.\n\nMs. Borgne testified that this sex offender is \"known for sending these kind of\n\nthreatening emails.\" JPMC Ex. 253 at 233:16-234:05.\n320.\n\nagreed that the USVI \"should have\" followed up on the\n\nprivate chef's email and that \"audio and video of what was going on on Little St. James would be\nof interest if there were interest in finding out whether Mr. Epstein was engaged in any sexual\nmisconduct.\" JPMC Ex. 263\n\nTr. at 125:23-126:16.\n\n288\n\nEFTA02815518\n\n", "char_count": 1318}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 71, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 72 of 86\n\nE.\n\nGovernment-Affiliated Officials Gave Epstein Influence And Access In Ways\nThat Facilitated His Crimes And His Transport of Victims\n\n321.\n\nEpstein leased hangar space from the Virgin Islands Port Authority (\"VIPA\") for\n\nhis aircrafts. JPMC Ex. 284.\n322.\n\nCecile de Jongh negotiated a lease with VIPA for a hangar for Epstein's aircrafts.\n\nJPMC Ex. 208 at 16:3-8.\n323.\n\nVIPA granted one of Epstein's employees a VIPA badge, allowing ramp access at\n\na USVI airport with a VIPA escort. JPMC Ex. 285.\n324.\n\nAn Epstein employee was granted a U.S. Customs and Border Protection Security\n\nSeal. That seal allowed the employee to \"escort passengers through U.S. Customs & Border\nProtection.\" JPMC Ex. 286 at -44492.\n325.\n\nCecile de Jongh and Governor John de Sough enlisted Epstein's support in having\n\nCarlton Dowe appointed as the Executive Director of VIPA. JPMC Ex. 287; JPMC Ex. 208 at\n96:8-98:15; JPMC Ex. 224 at 127:23-129:11.\n326.\n\nOn several occasions, Epstein had meetings with Executive Director Dowe.\n\nJPMC Ex. 288.\n327.\n\nGovernor de Jongh testified that VIPA \"over[saw] all the airports and the seaports\n\nin the Virgin Islands,\" was responsible for security within USVI's airports, and oversaw the\nairport's security officers. JPMC Ex. 224 at 129:24-131:3.\n328.\n\nUSVI's expert Bridgette Can\n\nJPMC Ex. 289 at\n\n¶q 222-24.\n\n289\n\nEFTA02815519\n\n", "char_count": 1419}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 72, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n329.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 73 of 86\n\nOn June 22, 2010, Epstein wrote to Cecile de Jongh to ask \"who is [in] charge of\n\ncustoms in the v.i.\" and stated that he \"used to have a great relationship with gloria Lambert the\nairport supervisor.\" He additionally stated: \"there is a mr carpenter ,who has been difficult\nlately.\" Cecile de Jongh responded that she \"spoke to Kenn\" who would call the head of\ncustoms, Louis Harrigan, to find out who Mr. Carpenter was and discuss with Epstein later.\nJPMC Ex. 290; JPMC Ex. 208 at 84:1-86:21.\n330.\n\nKenn Hobson was the \"head of VIPA\" at one point in time. JPMC Ex. 208 at\n\n331.\n\nEpstein sought Cecile de Jongh's assistance to gift the 78 customs employees in\n\n60:5-6.\n\nthe St.\n\nCustoms and Border Protection office a turkey for Thanksgiving. JPMC Ex. 291.\n332.\n\nCecile de Jongh said that it would be \"ok\" for Epstein to give that gift to the\n\ncustoms officers. JPMC Ex. 291; JPMC Ex. 208 at 86:22-87:11.\n333.\n\nCecile de Jongh did not check with anyone before stating it would be \"ok\" for\n\nEpstein to gift turkeys to customs officers in the USVI. JPMC Ex. 208 at 87:12-88:17.\n334.\n\nOn January 24-25, 2011, Epstein wrote to Cecile de Jongh and Richard Kahn to\n\nask if there was an EB5 visa regional center in the USVI. Cecile de Jongh responded that she\nwas \"trying to find out from someone at Immigration (Hillary Hodge, Special Agent in Charge).\"\nJPMC Ex. 292.\n335.\n\nOn March 6, 2012, Cecile de Jongh wrote to Epstein that she had spoken to an\n\nattorney, Vince Fuller, \"pertaining to the immigration matter\" for a female individual employed\nby Epstein. JPMC Ex. 293.\n\n290\n\nEFTA02815520\n\n", "char_count": 1666}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 73, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n336.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 74 of 86\n\nCecile de Jongh assisted Epstein in enrolling three women in English as a Second\n\nLanguage (\"ESL\") courses with the University of the Virgin Islands (\"uvr). JPMC Ex. 294;\nJPMC Ex. 295; JPMC Ex. 296; Ex. 208 at 131:3-15.\n337.\n\nCecile de Jongh worked with Dionne M,\n\nthe Vice President for Institutional\n\nAdvancement at the UVI, to help enroll three women in ESL classes with the UVI. JPMC Ex.\n296 at 20207-20209.\n338.\n\nAs part of the process for enrolling the young women in ESL courses, Cecile de\n\nJongh wrote to Epstein on May 29, 2013 to ask: \"What kind of visas do these ladies currently\nhave?\" She additionally suggested that the women could enroll in the UVI to acquire an I-20\nform for a student visa if required. Epstein responded that Renata had an F-I visa and\n.1 visa. JPMC Ex. 2%.\n339.\n\nAn I-20 form is required for a citizen of a foreign country to obtain a student (F or\n\nM) visa. The form must be \"present[ed] ... to the consular officer when [a person] attend[s]\n[their] visa interview.\" JPMC Ex. 297.\n340.\n\nOn June 27, 2013, Cecile de Jongh wrote to Epstein to state that UVI was\n\n\"structuring the class around the ladies\" in regard to the ESL classes in which she helped Epstein\nenroll three women. JPMC Ex. 298.\n341.\n\nOn November 22, 2013,\n\nCecile de Jongh \"The 2\n\nfive thousand $ checks we wrote to UVI are still outstanding. Do you think we should follow up.\nThey were written in August.\" JPMC Ex. 299.\n342.\n\nOn February 10, 2015, Cecile de Jongh emailed Epstein information on how an\n\nindividual could obtain an I-20 form through the UVI for a student visa. JPMC Ex. 300.\n\n291\n\nEFTA02815521\n\n", "char_count": 1690}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 74, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n343.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 75 of 86\n\nOn May 11, 2015, Cecile de Jongh wrote to Carlton Dowe in connection with a\n\nletter of support for an O-1 visa application for a woman named-.\n\nShe provided him\n\nresume and the visa guidelines\" and asked him to \"[p]lease let me if you are willing\nto do this and then we can talk about sample letters.\" JPMC Ex. 301.\n344.\n\nOn June 21, 2016, Cecile de Jongh was copied on an email with the subject\n\n\"Jeffrey has given me Schedule!\" in which Lesley Groff emails that Jeffrey \"will go to the\nisland on Monday June 27th\" and states\nWill all be okr Ms.\n\nI know you will be on holiday June 24-July 1.\n\nreplies \"I might just drop off the girls and come back to\n\nSTr.\" Copied on the email are several of Epstein's victims, including\nand\n345.\n\n. JPMC Ex. 302.\n\nOn February 13, 2014, Cecile de Jongh emailed\n\nMukamal, the CEO of\n\nIsland Global Yachting Facilities Ltd., which owned American Yacht Harbor,-,\n\nwith the subject \"AYH P dock\" that \"I have been giving this subject some thought\n\nand I think you should consider having Celestino\n\ngo with you and Jamie to the hearing. I\n\ndo not think the members of the CZM Commission will go against Celestino. Just a thought.\"\nMr. Mukamal writes back \"I had already discussed the matter with Celestino and asked for his\nadvice as it was developing — I will see if he is available.\" Ms. de Jongh replies \"Ok. Great. I\nthink he can be very helpful.\" JPMC Ex. 303; JPMC Ex. 87 at -6475, -6482.\n346.\n\nIn April 2014, Epstein and Cecile de Jongh discussed \"a new practice act\"\n\nregarding dental licenses that would have \"significant changes and allowances for reciprocity\"\nwith Deborah\n\nPeter, the Director for the Office of Professional Licensure and Health\n\nPlanning at the USVI Department of Health.\n\nPeter discussed the issue during a\n\nphone call with Epstein and conferred with the dental licensing board for additional information\n\n292\n\nEFTA02815522\n\n", "char_count": 1962}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 75, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 76 of 86\n\nfor Epstein. She wrote that the new act was \"slated to go before the Senate Committee on health\non May 9th, once that process is vetted the board will have a clearer idea on what her options are\nmoving forward.\" JPMC Ex. 305.\n347.\n\nOn May 27, 2015, Cecile de Jongh wrote to Epstein: \"Bad news re the dental\n\nlicensure rules and regs — the AG's office does not have them\" and stated she would \"let Donald\nknow via text and await his response.\" She additionally stated that the \"Acting Solicitor General\nis a good friend of mine, Mac M'\n\nand that once she received a response from Donald, she\n\nwould \"alert Mac and try to get it fast tracked.\" JPMC Ex. 306.\n348.\n\nOn August 5, 2015, Cecile de Jongh wrote to Epstein that Celestino\n\ngoing to work on\"\n\n\"is\n\ndental licensing issue and that she \"sent him some of\n\ns info.\" She additionally wrote that\n\nhad stated \"that it would be easier for him to\n\nlook into and resolve these things for you if he had a contract with a retainer so that he could\nstate to whomever that he has your permission to have info released to him.\" JPMC Ex. 307.\n349.\n\nBetween September 30, 2015 and October 1, 2015, Epstein and Cecile de Jongh\n\nexchanged emails regarding the dental license application for\n\nEpstein asked if\n\nhe should call Randy Knight, the Governor's Chief of Staff, regarding the application. Cecile de\nJongh suggested that he should not because \"Randy is not exactly a light touch or diplomatic and\nI don't want the board members to feel that they are threatened into approving-a.\"\nstated that she had reached out to Deborah\nwould \"call Donald as well\" regarding\n350.\n\nShe\n\nPeter and would \"call every day\" and\napplication. JPMC Ex. 308.\n\nUSVI dental license was approved in November 2015. JPMC\n\nEx. 309.\nF.\n\nUSVI Funded The Businesses It Claims Were Fronts For Sex Trafficking By\nGranting Them S300M In Tax Incentives\n\n293\n\nEFTA02815523\n\n", "char_count": 1952}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 76, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n351.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 77 of 86\n\nThe USVI has alleged that \"Epstein formed an association in fact with both\n\ncompanies and non-profit organizations he owned and operated\" to aid his criminal efforts. The\nUSVI has specifically alleged that one of these companies was STC, which received economic\nbenefits from the USVI Economic Development Commission (\"EDC\"), and acted \"as a conduit\nfor payment to foreign women, credit cards, airplanes, and other instrumentalities.\" JPMC Ex.\n310 r 24-28.\n352.\n\nMargarita\n\ntestified on behalf of the USVI government that the USVI\n\nEconomic Development Authority (\"EDA\") is a \"semiautonomous entity under the Government\nof the U.S. Virgin Islands.\" JPMC Ex. 311 at 24:9-24:14.\n353.\n\nBenefits awarded by the EDA must be approved by the Governor of the USVI.\n\nJPMC Ex. 224 at 154:6-155:4.\n354.\n\nGovernor John de Jongh approved the award of EDC benefits to STC in 2012.\n\nJPMC Ex. 224 at 167:9-168:12.\n355.\n\nGovernor John de Jongh approved a renewal of benefits to FTC. JPMC Ex. 224\n\nat 176:10-16.\n356.\n\nGovernor John de Jongh testified that the governor's office's review of EDC\n\nbenefits applications for approval involved \"reviewing the decision that the board made to make\nsure they complied with Economic Development Authority rules and regulations.\" JPMC Ex.\n224 at 155:5-14.\n357.\n\nGovernor John de Jongh testified that, when considering EDC benefit\n\napplications, he would \"review the cover memorandum ... of what was provided\" by legal\ncounsel and \"may get a little bit more into the activities and understand the type of business\" that\nwas applying. JPMC Ex. 224 at 157:5-13.\n\n294\n\nEFTA02815524\n\n", "char_count": 1678}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 77, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n358.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 78 of 86\n\nGovernor John de Jongh testified that, when reviewing applications, he would not\n\n\"reach out to the person who is applying to ask them questions\" and would not \"look at the\nfinancial projections that they submitted.\" JPMC Ex. 224 at 157:20-25.\n359.\n\nGovernor John de Jongh testified that he would \"look if — the overview would\n\nprovide the business, the type of activity. I may or may not look at the application just to\nunderstand if it was an unusual business\" and that he would review It]he legal opinion, malting\nsure it is consistent with the rules and regulations, looking at the business activity, looking at the\neconomic development, diversification that was taking place in the territory.\" JPMC Ex. 224 at\n157:14-19; 158:15-21.\n360.\n\nGovernor de Jongh testified that if the underlying business activity struck him as\n\n\"unusual,\" \"I would, then, more than likely not call the individual. I'd probably call my attorney\nand ask him to look into it\" and they would \"report back\" to Governor de Jongh. 'INC Ex. 224\nat 159:10-17.\n361.\n\nGovernor John de Jongh testified that he was looking to see if the business\n\nactivity \"was unusual\" and that, as an example, one year they had \"someone that applied that\nwanted to do manufacturing. We don't have very many manufacturers in the Virgin Islands, so I\njust looked at the application to make sure I understood. Some were looking at foreign\ndestinations to sell their products. I wanted to see, you know, what percentage of their business\nactivity they were looking at. Was it — did they consider the U.S. foreign or where are they\nselling? So I would look at things like that.\" JPMC Ex. 224 at 158:22-159:12.\n362.\n\nWhen approving benefits for Financial Trust, including considering Epstein's\n\ncriminal conviction in conjunction with those benefits, Governor John de Jongh testified that he\n\n295\n\nEFTA02815525\n\n", "char_count": 1937}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 78, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 79 of 86\n\n\"went solely on the recommendations of the [Governor's] staff — of my legal counsel.\" JPMC\nEx. 224 at 161:4-13.\n363.\n\nWhen considering the EDC applications for FTC and STC, Governor John de\n\nJongh testified that he did not \"fmd any of their activity unusual\" and did not \"ask anyone to do\nany further investigation into them.\" JPMC Ex. 224 at 159:18-160:4.\n364.\n\nGovernor de Jongh testified that he \"didn't give ... much thought beyond\" the\n\nrecommendation of the EDC and his legal counsel to Epstein's character when approving EDC\nbenefits for FTC. JPMC Ex. 224 at 188:14-190:14.\n365.\n\nGovernor Albert Bryan was the Chairman of the EDC when FTC's application for\n\na renewal of benefits was approved in 2012. JPMC Ex. 312 at 17987.\n366.\n\nGovernor Albert Bryan was the Chairman of the EDC when STC's application for\n\nbenefits was approved in 2014. JPMC Ex. 313 at -18010.\n367.\n\nThe original benefits granted to FTC by the EDC in 1999 awarded FTC a 100%\n\nreduction in income taxes. JPMC Ex. 314.\n368.\n\nWhen FTC's benefits were extended, FTC was granted an 81% reduction in\n\nincome taxes by the EDC. JPMC Ex. 314 at -19064; JPMC Ex. 312 at -17988.\n369.\n\nIn 2013, the EDC awarded a certificate to STC granting a 90% reduction in\n\nincome taxes. JPMC Ex. 314 at 19065; JPMC Ex. 313 at 18011.\n370.\n\nThrough the EDC program, the EDC granted over $300 million in tax breaks to\n\nFTC and STC. JPMC Ex. 90 1 60, Exhibit 1.\n371.\n\nJPMC's expert Carlyn Irwin has opined that \"from 1999 to 2018, neither\n\nFinancial Trust nor Southern Trust came close to generating sufficient benefits to USVI to offset\n\n296\n\nEFTA02815526\n\n", "char_count": 1678}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 79, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 80 of 86\n\nthe tax incentives granted to Mr. Epstein and these companies let alone reach the thresholds the\nEDC considered\n372.\n\n.\"' JPMC Ex. 90 ¶159-66.\n\nWhen Governor de Jongh approved the award of EDC benefits to STC, his wife\n\nCecile de Jongh was an employee of EDC. JPMC Ex. 224 at 174:8-10.\n373.\n\nThe Special Conditions for STC as part of its EDC benefits that were approved by\n\nGovernor de Jongh mandated that STC \"provide its full-time employees and dependents with\none hundred percent employer paid medical insurance coverage\" as well as other benefits,\nincluding tuition reimbursement. JPMC Ex. 224 at 173:21-175:25.\n374.\n\nOn June 30, 2009, while Epstein was incarcerated in Florida, Cecile de Jongh\n\nsigned a certification related to FTC's benefits received from the EDC stating that Epstein was a\nbona-fide resident of the USVI. JPMC Ex. 316 at -13521-13522.\n375.\n\nOn several occasions, official correspondence from the EDA and EDC related to\n\nbenefits awarded to Epstein's companies was addressed to Cecile de Jongh. JPMC Ex. 317;\nJPMC Ex. 318; JPMC Ex. 319; JPMC Ex. 232.\n376.\n\nSandra Bess, the EDA Program Compliance Officer who oversaw the compliance\n\nreports for FTC and STC, testified that the person she \"dealt with\" was Cecile de Jongh as the\noffice manager for FTC and STC. Those interactions included during unannounced visits when\nshe would \"ask to see the compliance person\" and would speak with de Jongh. JPMC Ex. 320 at\n36:1-17.\n377.\n\nOn April 10, 2012, in response to a media request received by Governor John de\n\nJongh regarding Cecile de Jongh's employment with FTC while it was EDC benefits, Cecile de\nJongh suggested to Epstein that the response be: \"Cecile de Jongh currently works for Financial\nTrust Company in the capacity of office manager. She had nothing to do with Financial Trust\n\n297\n\nEFTA02815527\n\n", "char_count": 1900}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 80, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 81 of 86\n\nCompany receiving EDC Tax benefits.\" Epstein responded that \"he would simply state that\n[Cecile de Jongh is] an office manager,\" to which Cecile de Jongh responded: \"That's what John\nwent with.\" JPMC Ex. 321.\n378.\n\nGovernor de Jongh did not \"perceive any conflict of interest in approving\n\nbenefits\" for Epstein's companies for which his wife, Cecile de Jongh, was an employee. JPMC\nEx. 224 at 162:19-25.\n379.\n\nGovernor de Jongh did not request that legal counsel provide an opinion on any\n\npotential conflict of interest related to his approval of benefits for companies for which his wife\nwas an employee. JPMC Ex. 224 at 163:1-10.\n380.\n\nGovernor de Jongh testified that he was not aware of any investigation undertaken\n\nto assess any potential conflict of interest related to his approval of benefits for companies for\nwhich his wife was an employee. JPMC Ex. 224 at 163:20-164:1.\n381.\n\nGovernor de Jongh did not request any assessment of any potential conflict of\n\ninterest related to his approval of benefits for companies for which his wife was an employee.\nJPMC Ex. 224 at 163:11-19.\n382.\n\nMargarita\n\ntestifying on behalf of the USVI government, testified that\n\nno investigations into Epstein and his companies were undertaken by the EDC other than normal\ncompliance audits. JPMC Ex. 311 at 56:22-57:22.\n383.\n\nOn January 7, 2015, USVI EDA Director of Compliance Stephanie Berry wrote a\n\nletter to Epstein stating that, \"[g]iven the current media discussions surrounding a principal of\nSTC, the EDA was requesting \"an assessment of the potential impact, if any, on the business\nactivities\" of STC \"as approved by the\" EDC. JPMC Ex. 322.\n\n298\n\nEFTA02815528\n\n", "char_count": 1734}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 81, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 82 of 86\n\n381\n\nJPMC Ex. 259 at 61108-61109.\n385.\n\nSandra Bess testified that compliance reports for EDC beneficiaries \"should be\n\ndone annually.\" JPMC Ex. 320 at 15:9-13.\n386.\n\nThe first compliance review of FTC was completed on April 17, 2008, covering\n\n\"the period of April 1, 1999 to December 31, 2006.\" JPMC Ex. 323.\n387.\n\nSandra Bess testified that the compliance process for EDC benefits relied on\n\n\"information provided by the certificate holder\" and sought to confirm that numbers provided \"in\nthe cover sheet of the annual report matche[d] what the company ha[d] provided ... in the\nsupport behind the cover sheet.\" JPMC Ex. 320 at 22:2-23:8.\n388.\n\nThe compliance officer was not tasked with \"reviewing the character of the\n\npeople who are the owners of the companies receiving tax benefits.\" JPMC Ex. 320 at 23:9-13.\n389.\n\nOn January 24, 2019, Carlos Rodriguez emailed Ms. Cecile de Jongh with the\n\nsubject \"Carlos work obligations.\" He stated the following: \"Greetings Cecile, her is a list of\nthings Im doing for LSJ/GSJ and STC ... Take care of STC vehicles and vehicles and vehicles\nat hangar, keep them fueled and clean. Every time JE visits all his vehicles are washed and\ndetailed, also hangar vehicles are washed and detailed. Go on JE Denali to airport on his arrival\nto ensure there is a spare vehicle in case hell has issues , help with luggage and bring to red hook\nfor pik up. Keep hangar bedroom sheets always fresh laundered. I bring them to lsj for washing\nand ironing . . . also been doing most shopping for LSJ/GSJ for most departments. Some of my\nother obligations include, picking up guests and contractors from airport and bring them to and\nfrom to hotels and LSJ, some early morning some late at night. I've been dealing with boat\n\n299\n\nEFTA02815529\n\n", "char_count": 1844}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 82, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nrepair contractors in Tortola to help Randy and\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 83 of 86\n\n. I do all boat registrations, some pickups\n\nat tropical and anything requested from me.\" JPMC Ex. 324.\n390.\n\nThe public hearings of the EDC related to awarding benefits to EDC reflect that\n\nthe Commissioners did not ask questions regarding Epstein's criminal history when considering\nan award of benefits to STC. JPMC Ex. 325; JPMC Ex. 326; JPMC Ex. 327; JPMC Ex. 328;\nJPMC Ex. 329; JPMC Ex. 330.\n391.\n\nOn October 2, 2019, Margarita\n\nthe Managing Director of the EDA,\n\nwrote to EDA employees Joy Penn and Sandra Bess that questions regarding Epstein's receipt of\nbenefits from the EDC \"are opening us up to public scrutiny.\" JPMC Ex. 331.\n392.\n\nA \"Draft Report on USVIEDA Responses to Media Inquiries about Jeffrey\n\nEpstein and his businesses under the VI Economic Development Commission Tax Incentive\nProgram\" dated December 5, 2019 states that the USVI Economic Development Authority\nreceived 55 total inquiries from 8 publications, 1 television station, and 14 reporters and\ninvestigative journalists, \"in relation to Jeffrey Epstein and his EDC businesses.\" \"Three (3)\ninterviews were [also] conducted for the New York Times.\" USVIEDA never reached out to\nlaw enforcement in connection with these inquiries. JPMC Ex. 311 at 185:19-188:19; JPMC Ex.\n332 at -22697.\n393.\n\nThe EDC and EDA terminated STC's benefits early, effective December 31,\n\n2019, at STC's request. JPMC Ex. 333.\nG.\n\nCecile de Jongh Had Official Responsibilities Within the Government As\nFirst Lady\n\n394.\n\nAs First Lady of the USVI, Cecile de Jongh was the chair of the Children's\n\nCabinet, which also included \"senior government officials\" from the Department of Education,\n\n300\n\nEFTA02815530\n\n", "char_count": 1787}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 83, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 84 of 86\n\nthe Department of Labor, and the USVI police department. The Children's Cabinet worked to\nimplement government policy regarding children's issues. JPMC Ex. 208 at 92:8-95:9.\n395.\n\nOne of the initiatives of the Children's Cabinet chaired by Cecile de Jongh was to\n\n\"make sure that every child caretaker, at least, had a high school degree, and that they worked\ntowards an associate degree[.]\" JPMC Ex. 208 at 93:21-94:14.\n396.\n\nCecile de Jongh testified that, as first lady, she was \"very involved in the National\n\nGovernors Association.\" JPMC Ex. 208 at 19:3-19:9.\n397.\n\nCecile de Jongh testified that, as First Lady, she had a Twitter account that was\n\nnamed \"the official Twitter account of U.S. Virgin Islands' First Lady, Cecile de Jongh.\" She\nfurther testified that she \"didn't hire someone separate from the government to manage\" the\naccount and that it was likely managed by a government employee. JPMC Ex. 208 at 22:323- 17.\n398.\n\nCecile de Jongh testified that she had a website as First Lady of the USVI that\n\nwas set up by the public relations department for the Governor of the USVI. JPMC Ex. 208 at\n23:3-25:2.\n399.\n\nThe website for First Lady Cecile de Jongh listed the address for the \"Office of\n\nthe First Lady\" as the governor's office and the phone number for the general switchboard at the\nGovernment House. JPMC Ex. 208 at 26:6-27:15.\n400.\n\nCecile de Jongh testified that, as First Lady, she worked with protocol officials for\n\nthe USVI Government House regarding social events related to her duties as First Lady. JPMC\nEx. 208 at 20:24-21:19.\n401.\n\nCecile de Jongh testified that, as First Lady, she saw her role as \"working on\n\nbehalf of all the Virgin Islanders.\" JPMC Ex. 208 at 26:3-26:5.\n\n301\n\nEFTA02815531\n\n", "char_count": 1804}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 84, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n402.\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 85 of 86\n\nOn December 27, 2012, Carole Chapman, the Executive Assistant to the CEO of\n\nthe USVI EDA, ema lied Jennifer Nugent-. and\n\nClouden of the EDA that the CEO\n\n\"had a call from the First Lady and she has asked that Epstein be on the Board agenda (public\nhearing) for the January 9th meeting.\" Cecile de Sough testified that she called the CEO of the\nEDA regarding placing Epstein's issue on the board agenda. JPMC Ex. 334; JPMC Ex. 208 at\n80:12-83:7.\n403.\n\nGovernor John de Sough testified that he \"assum[ed]\" that Cecile de Sough\n\n\"tr[ied] to avoid things coming to [Governor de Jongh's] desk that would impact Epstein[.]\"\nJPMC Ex. 224 at 212:3-11.\n\nDated: August 7, 2023\n\nRespectfully submitted,\n\nMASSEY & GAIL LLP\n\nWILMER CUTLER PICKERING\nHALE AND DORR LLP\n\n/s/ Leonard A. Gail\nLeonard A. Gail (pro hac vice)\nRachel Morse (pro hac vice)\n50 East Washington Street, Suite 400\nChicago, IL 60602\n(t) (312) 283-1590\nlgail@masseygail.com\nrmorse@masseygail.corn\nAttorneysfor JPMorgan Chase Bonk, NA.\n\nIs/ Felicia H. Ellsworth\nFelicia H. Ellsworth\nJohn J. Butts\nAndres O'Laughlin\n60 State Street\nBoston,\n02109\n(t) (617) 526-6000\n(f) (617) 526-5000\nfelicia.ellsworth@wilmerhale.com\njohn.butts@wilmerhale.com\nandy.olaughlin@wihnerhale.com\nM.\nRobert L. Boone\nAlan E. Schoenfeld\nBouchoux\n7 World Trade Center\n250 Greenwich Street\nNew York, NY 10007\n(t) (212) 230-8800\n(0 (212) 230-8888\n\n302\n\nEFTA02815532\n\n\n\n[═══ TRANSCRIPT ═══]\nCase 1:22-cv-10904-JSR  Document 284-5  Filed 08/14/23  Page 86 of 86  robert.boone@wilmerhale.com alan.schoenfeldawilmerhale.com  Attorneysfor JPMorgan Chase Bank N.A.  303  EFTA02815533", "char_count": 1680}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02815448", "page_number": 85, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\nDocument 284-5\n\nFiled 08/14/23\n\nPage 86 of 86\n\nrobert.boone@wilmerhale.com\nalan.schoenfeldawilmerhale.com\n\nAttorneysfor JPMorgan Chase Bank N.A.\n\n303\n\nEFTA02815533\n\n", "char_count": 189}]}