{"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_count": 45, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02809392", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02809392.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 1 of 45\n\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK\nGOVERNMENT OF THE UNITED\nSTATES VIRGIN ISLANDS\nPlaintiff,\nv.\nJPMORGAN CHASE BANK, N.A.\nDefendant/Third-Party Plaintiff.\n\n)\n)\n)\n)\n)\n)\n)\n)\n)\n)\n\nCase Number: 1:22-cv-10904-JSR\n\n)\n)\nJPMORGAN CHASE BANK, N.A.\nThird-Party Plaintiff,\nv.\nJAMES EDWARD STALEY\nThird-Party Defendant.\n\n)\n)\n)\n)\n)\n)\n)\n)\n)\n\nGOVERNMENT OF THE UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS'\nMEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT OF\nMOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT\n\nEFTA02809392\n\n", "char_count": 556}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 1 22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 2 of 45\n\nTABLE OF CONTENTS\nINTRODUCTION\n\n1\n\nLEGAL STANDARD\n\n3\n\nARGUMENT\n\n4\n\nI.\n\nJPMORGAN PARTICIPATED IN EPSTEIN'S SEX-TRAFFICKING VENTURE IN\nVIOLATION OF TVPA 18 U.S.C. § 1591(aX2)\n4\nA. Epstein Engaged in a Sex-Trafficking Venture\n\n4\n\nB. JPMorgan Knew or Recklessly Disregarded that Epstein Ran a Sex-Trafficking Venture 5\ni. In 2006, JPMorgan Knew Epstein Was Engaged in Sex-Trafficking\n\n5\n\na. Epstein Admitted the Conduct (but Not the \"Ages\") to Staley\n\n6\n\nb. JPMorgan's Own Diligence Gave It Reason to Suspect Epstein and Ghislaine\nMaxwell Early On\n\n7\n\nc. JPMorgan Had Corroborating Information on\n\nand\n7\n\nd. JPMorgan Had Information about Epstein's Cash Withdrawals\n\n9\n\nii. After July 2006, JPMorgan Learned More Information that Fed Its Knowledge of\nEpstein's Sex-Trafficking, including that Epstein's High-Powered Lawyers Helped\nHim Avoid Federal Sex-Trafficking Charges\n10\niii. JPMorgan Knew Epstein Was Connected to the MC2 Modeling Agency He Was\nAccused of Using to Traffic and Abuse \"Underage Models\"\n\n11\n\niv. JPMorgan Knew of Reports that Epstein Settled Dozens of Civil Lawsuits Alleging\nChild Sex-Trafficking\n12\nv. JPMorgan Knew Epstein's 2008 Conviction Covered Sex-Trafficking Conduct\n\n13\n\nvi. Based on Its Own Human Trafficking Work, JPMorgan Knew Epstein Was Engaged\nHuman Trafficking\n13\nvii. In 2008, JPMorgan Knew the Feds Were Connecting Certain Transactions to\nEpstein's Sex-Trafficking\nviii.\n\n14\n\nJPMorgan Employees Had Personal Knowledge of Epstein's Sex-Trafficking 15\n\nC. JPMorgan Participated in Epstein's Sex-Trafficking Venture\n\n16\n\nD. JPMorgan Benefited from Participation in Epstein's Sex-Trafficking Venture\n\n21\n\nII.\n\nJPMORGAN OBSTRUCTED ENFORCEMENT OF THE TVPA IN VIOLATION OF\n18 U.S.C. § 1591(d)\n24\n\nIII. THE USVI'S REQUESTED RELIEF FOR VIOLATIONS OF THE TVPA\n\n27\n\nIV. JPMORGAN'S EQUITABLE AND FAULT-SHIFTING DEFENSES DO NOT APPLY\nTO THE GOVERNMENT'S TVPA PARENS PATRIAE CLAIMS\n27\n\nEFTA02809393\n\n", "char_count": 1986}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 1 22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 3 of 45\n\nA. JPMorgan's Defenses are Barred as Applied to Sex Offender Registry Issues\n\n30\n\ni. The Government's Investigations or Monitoring of Epstein Cannot Form the Basis of\nViable Affirmative Defenses\n31\nii. The Discretionary Act of Granting a Waiver of Notification Periods for Overseas\nTravel is Not Grounds to Shift Fault to the Government\n33\nB. JPMorgan's Defenses are Barred as Applied to the Economic Development\nCommission's Grant of Tax Benefits to Epstein's Companies\n\n35\n\nC. JPMorgan Has No Viable Defenses Based on Activity of Cecile De Jongh\n\n38\n\nCONCLUSION\n\n39\n\nii\n\nEFTA02809394\n\n", "char_count": 652}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 4 of 45\n\nTABLE OF AUTHORITIES\nCases\nAlfred L. Snapp v. Puerto Rico,\n458 U.S. 592 (1982)\n\n27\n\nCity ofNew York v. FedEx Ground Package System, Inc.,\n314 F.R.D. 348 (S.D.N.Y. 2016)\n\n27, 29, 30, 34\n\nCoffey v. C.LR.,\n663 F.3d 947 (8th Cir. 2011)\n\n35\n\nDonovan v. Fed. Clearing Die Casting Co.,\n655 F.2d 793 (7th Cir. 1981)\n\n31\n\nFTC v. Crescent Publ. Grp., Inc.,\n129 F. Supp. 2d 311 (S.D.N.Y. 2001)\n\n29\n\nGroh v. Ramirez,\n540 U.S. 551 (2004)\n\n31\n\nHarlow v. Fitzgerald,\n457 U.S. 800 (1982)\n\n35\n\nHH v. G6 Hospitality, Inc.,\nNo 2:19-cv-755, 2019 WL 6682152 (S.D. Ohio Dec 6, 2019)\n\n21\n\nMaldonado by and through Ochoa v. City ofSibley,\n58 84th 1017 (8th Cir. 2023)\n\n34\n\nMcGaughey v. District of Columbia,\n684 F.3d 1355 (D.C. Cir. 2012)\n\n34, 37\n\nOlin Corp. v. Lamorak Ins. Co.,\n332 F. Supp. 3d 818, 839 (S.D.N.Y. 2018) (Rakoff, J.)\nv. Gov't ofthe Virgin Islands,\n847 F.2d 104 (3d Cir. 1988)\n\n4\n34, 36\n\nState ofNew York v. UPS, Inc.,\n160 F. Supp. 3d 629 (S.D.N.Y. 2016)\n\n30\n\nU.S. v. One\nCrystal Covered Bat Tour Glove & Other Michael\n2013 WL 12196595 (C.D. Cal. Aug. 19, 2013) ..\n\nMemorabilia,\n32\n\nUnited States v. Angell,\n292 F.3d 333 (2d Cir. 2002)\n\n29\n\nUnited States v. Philip Morris Inc.,\n300 F. Supp. 2d 61 (D.D.C. 2004)\n\n29\n\nUnited States v. Vineland Chem. Co., Inc.,\n692 F. Supp. 415 (D.N.J. 1988)\n\n30\n\niii\n\nEFTA02809395\n\n", "char_count": 1371}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 5 of 45\n\nStatutes\n14 V.I.C. § 1724\n\n31\n\n14 V.I.C. § 1724(bX4)\n\n33\n\n14 V.I.C. § 1728(a)\n\n33\n\n18 U.S.C. § 1591(a)(1)\n\n4, 7\n\n18 U.S.C. § 159I(a)(2)\n\n3, 4, 27\n\n18 U.S.C. § 1591(c)\n\n7\n\n18 U.S.C. § 1591(d)\n\n3, 24, 27\n\n18 U.S.C. § 1595(d)\n\n29, 30\n\n26 U.S.C. § 934(b)(1)\n\n35\n\n29 V.I.C. § 701(a)\n\n35\n\n29 V.I.C. § 701(c)\n\n37\n\n29 V.I.C. § 705(a)\n\n36\n\n29 V.I.C. § 708\n\n37\n\n29 V.I.C. § 722(4)\n\n37\n\n29 V.I.C. § 1101(a)\n\n35\n\n29 V.I.C. § 1101(b)\n\n35\n\nRules\nFed. R. Civ. P. 56(c).\n\n3\n\nRegulations\n12 C.F.R. § 21.11(c)(2)\n\n20\n\n12 C.F.R. § 21.11(d).\n\n20\n\niv\n\nEFTA02809396\n\n", "char_count": 610}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 6 of 45\n\nINTRODUCTION\nIn July 2006, after his arrest for felony sex crimes and extensive news coverage detailing\nunlawful sex acts with underage girls, Jeffrey Epstein admitted to James (Jes) Staley (then CEO\nAsset and Wealth Management (\"AWM\")), who reported it to Mary Erdoes (then CEO Global\nPrivate Bank (\"PB\")), that he had engaged in sex with multiple young women for money, only\ndenying the girls' \"ages.\" At that time, JPMorgan could have immediately exited Epstein—but the\nBank knew, from Douglas (Sandy) Warner, when he was head of JPMorgan, Epstein is \"one of\nthe most connected people I know in New York.\" In 2003, Epstein was, by double, the top revenue\ngenerator in the Private Bank, and the source of Google co-founder Sergey\n[relationships] in the Private Bank, of +$4BN\"), Glenn\n\n(\"one of the largest\n\n(billionaire founder of Highbridge),\n\nand many other ultra-wealthy clients and connections, which would come to include Bill Gates,\nBlack, Larry Summers, the Sultan of Dubai, Prince Andrew, Ehud Barak,\n\nPritzker,\n\nLord Peter Mandelson, and Prime Minister Netanyahu. In 2004, Epstein—together with Jamie\nDimon (then CEO-in-waiting)—was an integral part of JPMorgan's game-changing acquisition of\nHighbridge. The next year,\n\nEpstein was too big to fail.\nSo, JPMorgan did not exit Epstein in 2006. Or 2007. Or 2008. Or 2009. Or 2010. Or 2011.\nOr 2012. Or the first half of 2013,\n\nSUF 1386.'\n\nAnd, even after his exit right up until his arrest in 2019, JPMorgan continued to work with Epstein.\nOnly months before his arrest in July 2019,\n\n\"SUF' references are to the Statement of Material Facts as to which Government of the United\nStates Virgin Islands Contends there is No Genuine Dispute (filed concurrently).\n\nEFTA02809397\n\n", "char_count": 1799}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 7 of 45\n\nI\n\nRather than exit Epstein in 2006, JPMorgan handled millions of dollars in payments to\nEpstein's other \"rock star\" lawyers who the Bank knew were working to discredit Epstein's\nvictims and help Epstein avoid federal sex-trafficking charges.\n\nJPMorgan banked all the girls and women publicly alleged in 2006 to be recruiters,\naccomplices, or victims, including\nMaxwell. JPMorgan knew that\n\nand Ghislaine\nwho Epstein was reported to have referred to as his\n\n\"Yugoslavian sex slave\"—in fact came from Yugoslavia as a teenager in 2004 supposedly to work\nas a \"model\" and was sponsored by Epstein. For years, JPMorgan handled Epstein business with\nMC2 Model Management knowing Epstein was accused of using the supposed modeling agency\nto traffic and abuse underage girls.\nAt the same time, and for the next seven years, JPMorgan—self-described as Epstein's \"#1\nbank\" at the time, SUF 1174-c ontinued to participate in Epstein's sex-trafficking venture. It\n\"really never stopped\" handling his excessive cash withdrawals despite tying them to his felony\nsex crimes; did not question his cash-for-fuel to travel to foreign countries explanation, even when\nhe was in jail and on house arrest; made millions of dollars more in payments to co-conspirators,\nincluding Maxwell, recruiters and victims, including many girls and women with Eastern\nEuropean surnames or located in Eastern Europe, from where JPMorgan knew Epstein was\nreported to have trafficked girls; and continued to extend the loan to MC2, which, for all it knew,\n\n2\n\nEFTA02809398\n\n", "char_count": 1603}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 8 of 45\n\nwas a \"payment for services as a procurer.\" Even when JPMorgan knew that federal prosecutors\nhad subpoenaed Bear Stearns (which it acquired in 2008) for account and specific transaction\ninformation tied to Epstein, JPMorgan\n\nand\n\nwent right on handling many more. The entire time, the cynical jokes within the company also\nnever stopped—from\n\nasking if Epstein was at a party with \"Miley Cyrus,\" to\n\nDavid Brigstocke (then CFO AWM) comparing another client's house to Epstein's: \"Reminded\nme ofJE's house, except it was more tasteful, andfewer nymphettes.\" SUF f1181-82, 190. .see\nalso SUF11179-180, 183-89. Only in August 2019-after Epstein's arrest and death and when\nthere were no more referrals or other benefits to be had\n\nthough it had all the information\nin real-time, not \"[h]indsight\" as Dimon (CEO) misrepresented to CNN. SUF1418. Accordingly,\nthe Government is entitled to judgment as a matter of law forJPMorgan's participation in Epstein's\nsex-trafficking venture and obstruction of federal prosecutors' enforcement of the law in violation\nof the Trafficking Victims Protection Act (\"TVPA\"), 18 U.S.C. §§ 1591(a)(2) and (d).\nThe Government also is entitled to judgment as a matter of law on JPMorgan's equitable\nand fault-shifting affirmative defenses (Defenses 5 to 8). The legal deficiencies that left the Court\n\"skeptical\" that the defenses would survive summary judgment persist and no facts have been\ndeveloped during discovery that would revive these deficient defenses.\nLEGAL STANDARD\nSummary judgment is appropriate \"if the pleadings, the discovery and disclosure materials\non file, and any affidavits show that there is no genuine issue as to any material fact and that the\nmovant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law.\" Fed. R. Civ. P. 56(c). \"Where the moving party\n\n3\n\nEFTA02809399\n\n", "char_count": 1878}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case 1 22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 9 of 45\n\nhas documented particular facts in the record, the burden shifts to the opposing party to adduce\ncontrary record evidence sufficient to create a genuine dispute of material fact.\" Olin Corp. v.\nLainorak Ins. Co., 332 F. Supp. 3d 818, 839 (S.D.N.Y. 2018) (Rakoff, J.). \"To do so, the opposing\nparty cannot merely make conclusory assertions to the contrary[.]\" Id.\nARGUMENT\nI.\n\nJPMORGAN PARTICIPATED IN EPSTEIN'S SEX-TRAFFICKING VENTURE\nIN VIOLATION OF TVPA 18 U.S.C. § 1591(a)(2)\nA.\n\nEpstein Engaged in a Sex-Trafficking Venture\n\nJPMorgan does not dispute Epstein was engaged in sex-trafficking: \"Epstein was engaged\nin horrendous criminal activity, including sex trafficking. That's not something being contested at\nall by JPMorgan.\" SUF II. \"Epstein's behavior was monstrous ... the survivors ... suffered\nunimaginable abuse at the hands of this man ...[who] commit[ted] heinous crimes.\" SUF 12.\nJPMorgan acknowledged\n\nin its own due diligence, respectively,\n\nthat Epstein\n\nand ran a \"sex-trafficking ring.\" SUF 113-5.\n\nEpstein was arrested on July 6, 2019 on federal charges of sex-trafficking of minors and on August\n10, 2019 died in prison. SUF 116-7. Ghislaine Maxwell was convicted in 2022 for conspiring with\nEpstein to engage in sex-trafficking. SUF q8. In 2008, Epstein was convicted for solicitation of an\nunderage girl for prostitution, SUF19, a covered act under the TVPA. 18 U.S.C. § 1591(a)(1). In\nupholding his Level 3 sex offender status imposed with that conviction, a New York appeals court\nfound \"clear and convincing\" evidence Epstein had \"committed multiple offenses against a series\nof underage girls.\" SUF 1110-11. Over the years, many victims have come forward and described\nbeing sex-trafficked by Epstein, including in the U.S. Virgin Islands (\"USVI\").\n\n4\n\nEFTA02809400\n\n", "char_count": 1862}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 10 of 45\n\nSUF 1112-31. JPMorgan also\nhandled millions of dollars in payments from Epstein to known co-conspirators, recruiters, victims,\ngirls and women until 2019, including payments to women in years that coincided with their trips\nto the USVI. SUF132 and infra Part I.C.\nB.\n\nJPMorgan Knew or Recklessly Disregarded that Epstein Ran a SexTrafficking Venture\n\nJPMorgan had \"knowledge of Epstein's sex-trafficking venture, either directly or by\nrecklessly disregarding what was plainly to be seen.\" Op. and Order, May 1, 2023 (Dkt. 130) at\n28 (\"Order\"). The Government uses \"knew\" or \"knowledge\" herein to mean direct knowledge or\nreckless disregard.\ni.\n\nIn 2006. J PNIorgan Knew Epstein Was Engaged in Sex-Trafficking\n\nIn July 2006, Epstein was indicted for felony solicitation of prostitution and arrested.\nNumerous JPMorgan senior executives (including Staley, Erdoes, Catherine Keating (then CEO\nUS PB)) knew of Epstein's arrest and related news coverage, including a Palm Beach Post article\nwhich stated: \"Epstein paid to have underage girls and young women brought to his home, where\nhe received massages and sometimes sex\" and \"police thought there was probable cause to charge\nEpstein with unlawful sex acts with a minor and lewd and lascivious molestation.\" SUF1133, 4146. JPMorgan's own due diligence process required that it monitor news reports about customers.\nSUF1134-40. The Palm Beach Post article detailed evidence from police documents, including:\no A college student gave Epstein a naked massage and then \"brought him six girls, ages 14 to\n16, for massage and sex-tinged sessions\" at Epstein's home.\no Police obtained statements from five alleged victims and 17 witnesses. Police contend Epstein\n\"had sex with the girls\" on three occasions.\nmet Epstein at age 17 and was recruited to massage him. Epstein told her he\nwould \"pay her to bring him more girls—the younger the better.\" She stated she once brought\n\n5\n\nEFTA02809401\n... [truncated, 2002 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02809392/9 or ?id=EFTA02809392&page=9]", "char_count": 2002}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 11of 45\n\na 23-year-old woman to him and \"Epstein said she was too old....\" She brought six girls to\nEpstein and said the girls were paid $200 for each session.\ntold police, \"I'm like a Heidi Fleiss.\"\no A 27-year-old Epstein employee.\nmassage table.\n\nwould arrange the sessions and prepare the\n\no One 14-year-old victim recounted the details of her encounter in February 2005 inch,\naid $300 for a massage in her bra and panties. For bringing this child to Epstein,\nreceived $200.\n\nM\n\no Police scoured the trash from Epstein's house and found notes with names and phone numbers,\nsex toys and female hygiene products. Notes stated that one girl could not \"come over at 7 p.m.\nbecause of soccer. Another said a girl had to work Sunday—'Monday after school?' Another\nsaid a girl leaves school at 11:30 a.m. and would come over the next day[.)\"\nSUF TI43-46. Another July 2006 news report said the police submitted arrest warrant requests for\nand\n\nThe same report stated a girl told police she was paid by Epstein\n\nto have sex with\n\nas Epstein watched, and \"Epstein bragged he brought\n\ninto the United States to be his Yugoslavian sex slave.\" SUF1148-49; see also SUF\n150 (August news report). JPMorgan knew from its own work on human trafficking that \"Sexual\nSlavery\" means \"the coercion of the unwilling into various sexual practices.\" SUF 151. News\naround the time of Epstein's arrest also reported that \"[tiwo of Epstein's former employees told\ninvestigators that young-looking girls showed up to perform massages two or three times a day\nwhen Epstein was in town.\" SUF152. The news explained that Epstein paid $200 or $300 cash to\nthe girls and $200 cash to\na.\n\nfor recruiting the girls. SUF1143, 45.\nEpstein Admitted the Conduct (but Not the \"Ages\") to Staley\n\nOn July 25, 2006, Staley met with Epstein in person, and Epstein admitted to the alleged\nconduct of engaging in sex for money with young women—only denying the \"ages.\" SUF 153.\nStaley \n... [truncated, 2199 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02809392/10 or ?id=EFTA02809392&page=10]", "char_count": 2199}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 12 of 45\n\nfor prostitution is a covered act under the TVPA, and Epstein \"had a reasonable opportunity to\nobserve [the victim],\" so it need not be proved \"the defendant knew, or recklessly disregarded the\nfact, that the person had not attained the age of 18 years.\" 18 U.S.C. §§ 1591(a)(1) and (c). Staley\nalso spoke to Dimon about the \"very public\" indictment of the Bank's client, Epstein. SUF 155.\nb.\n\nJPMorgan's Own Diligence Gave It Reason to Suspect Epstein\nand Ghislaine Maxwell Early On\n\nBy 2006, JPMorgan already had reason to suspect Epstein's sex-trafficking—and\nMaxwell's involvement. In 2003, as part of the Bank's due diligence for an Epstein account,\nJPMorgan reviewed the Vanity Fair profile \"The Talented Mr. Epstein,\" which reported Epstein's\npenchant for \"young,\" \"foreign,\" \"model types,\" and his \"best friend\" Maxwell \"summon[ing]\" a\nyoung woman for him and throwing a party attended by Prince Andrew and \"filled\" with \"young\nRussian models.\" SUF 1156-59. In 2003, JPMorgan also knew that Maxwell was involved with\nEpstein in structuring cash withdrawals, SUF1160-62, a red flag for trafficking, SUF1163-64.\nYet, the Private Bank opened an account for Maxwell in 2003, on Epstein's referral, noting\nMaxwell was a \"companion/long-time friend of Jeffrey Epstein.\" SUF 165. By Epstein's arrest,\nJPMorgan knew it had made over $25 million in payments to Maxwell from Epstein. SUF 167.\nNews reports related to Epstein's 2006 arrest again described Epstein's relationship with Maxwell.\nSUF152. JPMorgan continued to handle payments from Epstein to Maxwell, including $7 million\nfor the purchase of a helicopter. SUF1223. Later reports again alleged Maxwell \"solicited young\ngirls for Epstein\"—identified as a \"human rights\" issue by JPMorgan. SUF166.\nc.\n\nJPMorgan Had Corroborating Information on\nand\n\nJPMorgan had significant corroborating evidence of Epstein's sex crimes by July 2006—\nand knowledge of ongoing conduct after Jul\n... [truncated, 2064 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02809392/11 or ?id=EFTA02809392&page=11]", "char_count": 2064}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 13 of 45\n\nworked for Epstein and had—just months prior to his arrest—\nSUF 168.\n\nwas\n\nalso a customer of the Bank. SUF TI69-70. JPMorgan, in 2005, made two separate $25,000\npayments from Epstein's accounts to\n\nSUF 171. After police reports identified her as a\n\nrecruiter in 2006, JPMorgan continued to handle payments to\n\ntotaling over $675,000 from\n\nEpstein's accounts. SUF 172.\nJPMorgan also had information related to trafficking victim and accomplice\nalso a customer of the Bank. SUF173. In 2004, sponsored by Epstein, JPMorgan opened accounts\nand credit cards for two teenagers,\n\n, another victim, SUF 123, and\n\n\"models in NYC and friends of Jeffrey Epstein.\" SUF 1174, 75, 77. JPMorgan's Due Diligence\nReport (\"DDR\") on\n\nwas approved by the Private Bank even though the report had no\n\nbirthdate, confirmed SSN, or a Passport or Driver's License Number. SUF176. Epstein's Banker\nat the time (Mary (Rieth)\n\nnever met\n\nas JPMorgan's process contemplated—\n\neven after news reports that Epstein referred to her as his \"Yugoslavian sex slave.\" SUF 176.\nJPMorgan knew that Epstein said\n\ncame to the US from Yugoslavia and lived at a\n\nbuilding owned by Epstein's brother. SUF 9177, 79. Further, JPMorgan knew it had made more\nthan $36,000, $67,000, and $82,000 in payments from Epstein's account to\n\nin 2004,\n\n2005, and 2006, respectively, even though Epstein represented her net worth was $100,000 from\nsupposed \"modeling assignments.\" SUF 1180, 78. JPMorgan also knew\n\n\"debit\n\ntransactions\" at the time—which AML compliance only reviewed more than four years later—\nwere \"enlighting [sic] as compared to countless stories related to [Epstein's] escapades. Lots of\nsalon, lingerie shops, drug stores ny palm beach and in st\nlots of video like girls gone\n\n(his places of residence). Plus\n\nand some other shops not fit for my good catholic upbringing!\"\n\n8\n\nEFTA02809404\n\n", "char_count": 1923}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 14 of 45\n\nSUF 181. JPMorgan's own Human Trafficking\n\npaper discussed \"upscale\" sex-trafficking\n\noperations \"incurr[ing] expenses such as jewelry, lingerie, cosmetics, [and] sex toys.\" SUF182.\nEven after she was identified in 2006, JPMorgan continued to handle payments to\ntotaling over $600,000 from Epstein's JPMorgan accounts. SUF 183. JPMorgan\n\n\" SUF\n1184-85. JPMorgan also knew that Epstein sponsored credit cards for\n\nand\n\nfor\n\n\"travel[] through Paris, Europe and US Virgin Islands and US monthly.\" SUF186.\nd.\n\nJPMorgan Had Information about Epstein's Cash Withdrawals\n\nOn October 17, 2006, in light of the derogatory information related to Epstein's \"felony\ncharges of soliciting underage prostitutes,\" JPMorgan Private Bank held a \"Rapid Response\"\nmeeting, which were \"escalations of derogatory information to management.\" Private Bank\nidentified Epstein's frequent cash withdrawals as worthy of note in conjunction with his \"felony\ncharges of soliciting underage prostitutes.\" \"Cash withdrawals are routinely made in amounts for\n$40,000 to $80,000 several times a month, which total over $750,000 year to date.\" SUE ¶9[90-93.\nJPMorgan compliance staff acknowledged Epstein was \"known to pay cash for his massages\" and\n\"minors are the issue.\" SUF 194. Three \"massages\" a day with girls paid $200-$300 cash and\nrecruiters paid $200 cash—as JPMorgan knew was reported—is about $40,000 cash per month.\nJPMorgan knew that in the time period of the incidents investigated by the Palm Beach police, and\nprior to Epstein's plea, it had handled nearly $1.75 million in cash withdrawals for Epstein. SUF\n195.\nSUF 1196-97.\n\n9\n\nEFTA02809405\n\n", "char_count": 1694}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 15 of 45\n\nThe large cash withdrawals \"really never stopped\"—and were ultimately the claimed\nreason for JPMorgan's parting with Epstein in 2013 when \"combined with his personal history.\"\nSUF1198-99. Epstein's 2011 explanation that the cash was for jet fuel for his foreign travel was\nand not supported by any receipts\nor other documentation.\nFurther, JPMorgan knew Epstein was in jail and on house arrest from July 2008 through\nJuly 2010 and thus not traveling overseas. SUF 11100-106. In any event, JPMorgan's diligence\ncited reports that Epstein traveled to foreign countries to traffic young women, SUF 1107, so\nwhether to pay for that travel, or to pay victims and recruiters, or both, JPMorgan knew the cash\nwas connected to Epstein's sex-trafficking.\nii.\n\nAfter July 2006, JPMorgan Learned More Information that Fed Its\nKnowledge of Epstein's Sex-Trafficking, including that Epstein's HighPowered Lawyers Helped Him Avoid Federal Sex-Trafficking Charges\n\nJPMorgan also knew that Epstein's wealth and \"high-powered\" lawyers allowed him to\nescape more serious charges including federal sex-trafficking charges. In 2006, JPMorgan's\ndiligence included multiple news reports that Epstein \"assembled a team of star lawyers\"—\nincluding Alan Dershowitz, Gerald Lefcourt, Roy Black, and Jack Goldberger—\"to undermine the\ncredibility of the 14- to 17-year-old girls\" and challenge the \"distorted\" view of the case \"presented\nby the Palm Beach Police.\" SUF 11 108, 110. Reports said Epstein used Black to hire private\ninvestigators to \"poste] as police officers\" and to review with witnesses what to say to actual police\nofficers. SUF 1110. In 2006 and 2007, JPMorgan reviewed reports that federal prosecutors were\nlooking to bring child sex-trafficking charges against Epstein and that his lawyers were\n\"negotiating a deal\" to avoid those charges. SUF 1112, see also SUF 150 (FBI considering\ninvestigating for federal child sex crimes). JPMorgan lat\n... [truncated, 2056 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02809392/14 or ?id=EFTA02809392&page=14]", "char_count": 2056}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 16 of 45\n\n\"supposedly bought his way to a lesser sentencing\" and \"paid a whole series of girls to stay quiet.\"\nSUF1113. JPMorgan was handling millions of dollars in payments to those lawyers at that time—\nincluding numerous\n\n$100,000 payments—and continued to handle tens of millions in\n\npayments to lawyers. SUF11 127.\nOn September 24, 2007, Epstein agreed to plead guilty to two prostitution charges in state\ncourt, including the solicitation of a minor to engage in prostitution, in exchange for a federal nonprosecution agreement (\"NPA\") providing him with immunity from federal child sex-trafficking\ncharges. Under the NPA, Epstein also waived his right to contest liability and damages in civil\nlawsuits by minor girls identified by the NPA. The NPA identified\n\n=,\n\nand Lesley\n\nGroff as Epstein's co-conspirators in soliciting underage girls for commercial sex. SUF 11114,\n118-21. JPMorgan knew of reports of the plea deal beginning in 2007. SUF11115; see also SUF\n11 1 16-17 (2008). The NPA later became public, and JPMorgan was aware of it. SUF11122-24.\nIn October 2007, Anne Verdon (then General Counsel PB) received requested information\nabout Epstein, his transactions, and the news coverage. This research connected the dots between\nEpstein's financial transactions at the Bank—his large, frequent cash withdrawals, credit cards for\nand transfers to wand\n\nand =,\n\nhis illegal conduct. The diligence showed\n\nwho had talked to police (\"I'm like a Heidi Fleiss\"), had a \"revoked\" credit card, while\n, who did not talk to police, still had an \"active\" credit card under Epstein. SUF11 125-27,\n43. JPMorgan continued with business as usual.\niii.\n\nJPMorgan Knew Epstein Was Connected to the MC2 Modeling Agency\nHe Was Accused of Using to Traffic and Abuse \"Underage Models\"\n\nA news report surfaced in 2007 of \"industry speculation that massage maven Jeffrey\nEpstein is a secret financial backer of the agency being run by scandal-scarred \n... [truncated, 2131 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02809392/15 or ?id=EFTA02809392&page=15]", "char_count": 2131}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 17 of 45\n\nto start MC2, which opened in October 2005.\" \"[Epstein's] a desperate old man that fantasizes and\ntakes advantage of young girls.\" Epstein's rep, Howard Rubenstein, said, \"He has no business\nrelationship with [Brunel and MC2].\" SUF1128. But JPMorgan knew at the time of the report that\nRubenstein was covering up for Epstein. In 2005, JPMorgan had extended a $1 million Stand By\nLetter of Credit (\"SBLC\") for Epstein to backstop a loan to MC2. SUF1129.\nOnly two weeks after the news about Epstein's ties to Brunel and ma, =,\n\namong\n\nothers, discussed the MC2 SBLC, which the Bank renewed through March 2011. SUF11 130-32.\nEven though Epstein was set to plead guilty to felony sex crimes, 'Morgan did not determine—\nand as late as 2011 still did not know—if the $1 million was a \"payment for services as a procurer.\"\nSUF 11138-39. JPMorgan would review multiple reports about child sex-trafficking by Epstein,\nBrunel, and MC2—\"Brunel, owner of MC2 and Jeffrey Epstein engaged in racketeering that\ninvolved luring in minor children for sexual play for money\"—all the while continuing to extend\nthe $1 million SBLC. SUF11130-31, 134-39.\n\nwho JPMorgan was supposed to but\n\ndid not meet with\nSUF1140.\niv.\n\nJPMorgan Knew of Reports that Epstein Settled Dozens of Civil\nLawsuits Alleging Child Sex-Trafficking\n\nThen came the reports of the civil lawsuits—another category of information that was\nsupposed to be part of JPMorgan's due diligence. SUF 114. In 2007, Epstein was \"bracing for a\nslew of lawsuits from as many as 40 young women[.]\" SUF1142. By early 2008, Erdoes and Lisa\nWaters (then a Managing Director AWM), among others, knew of multiple news outlets reporting\nthe first lawsuit \"against JE- sexual abuse of minor etc. etc.\" Then the next: \"the teen ... says she\nwas lured to Epstein's Palm Beach mansion and then sexually assaulted in his massage room.\"\nSUF1114345. In 2010, JPMorgan knew of reports that \"Epstein had settled \n... [truncated, 2038 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02809392/16 or ?id=EFTA02809392&page=16]", "char_count": 2038}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 18 of 45\n\nlawsuits and claims against him by teen-agers who say they were lured to his Palm Beach mansion\nto give him sexually charged massages and/or sex in exchange for money.\" \"These same civil\ncomplaints allege that young girls from South America, Europe, and the former Soviet republics\n... were recruited for Epstein's sexual pleasure.\" SUF 19[137-38.\nv.\n\nJPMorgan Knew Epstein's 2008 Conviction Covered Sex-Trafficking\nConduct\n\nOn June 30, 2008, Epstein pled guilty to felony solicitation of prostitution and procurement\nof a 14-year-old minor to engage in prostitution and was \"sentenced to 18 months in jail\" and\n\"required to register as a sex offender.\" SUF1146-47.\n\nas described above,\nSUF 113-4, 148. In 2011, William Langford (then Global Head of Compliance)\ncommunicated to Steve Cutler (then General Counsel) \"concern\" about retaining Epstein as a\nclient. Cutler testified: \"Those concerns are heightened, if you will, by the human trafficking\ninitiative that we're doing, given that he was convicted of these crimes.\" SUF1149.\nvi.\n\nBased on Its Own Human Trafficking Work, JPMorgan Knew Epstein\nWas Engaged Human Trafficking\n\nAround the time of Epstein's conviction in 2008, JPMorgan's AML (Anti-Money\nLaundering) compliance group (under Langford) created a \"Human Trafficking Overview.\" The\noverview reported that \"nearly two-thirds of the women trafficked for prostitution worldwide come\nfrom Eastern Europe\" and \"former Eastern bloc countries such as Albania, Moldova, Romania,\nBulgaria, Russia, Belarus and Ukraine have been identified as major trafficking source countries\nfor women and children.\" SUF 1151. JPMorgan knew and had assembled evidence that Epstein\nhad made at least tens of thousands of dollars of payments to\n\nand was reported to refer\n\n13\n\nEFTA02809409\n\n", "char_count": 1847}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 19 of 45\n\nto her as his \"Yugoslavian sex slave.\" SUF $148-50, 125-26. JPMorgan also knew it had made\nmore than $1.2 million in payments to girls or women, many with Eastern European surnames,\nfrom Epstein's accounts from 2003 to 2008. SUF 1225.\nSUP\n41'112227.229. Beginning in 2008, several payments were sent to high-risk locations, such as Belarus,\nLithuania, and Russia. SUF $230.\nAML compliance—JPMorgan's in-house human trafficking experts—wanted Epstein\ngone from the Bank. SUF11162-66. In 2010, when additional \"news stories ... connect[ed] Jeffrey\nEpstein to human trafficking,\" SUF 11152-53, AML compliance was concerned about continuing\nto bank a human trafficker while trumpeting the Bank's efforts to rein in human trafficking through\nthe bank. \"My fear is will all our touting of good will on the [Human Trafficking] work, if anyone\nshould ever say yet we bank Epstein, a known child sleaze.\" SUF 11154-55, 159-60. \"I sent you\nan e-mail yesterday on that scum Epstein .... I reminded McCleerey [then Head of PB Risk\nManagement] that he listened to 2 days of [Human Trafficking] at the forum and this account could\nbe problematic in several ways.\" SUF $157. AML compliance requested the Bank \"responsor this\nclient in light of the new allegations of human trafficking which the firm has been actively assisting\nlaw enforcement in uncovering others engaged in this practice.\" SUF1158. Langford, the public\nface of JPMorgan's human trafficking initiative and the Global Head of Compliance, believed\nJPMorgan \"should exit Jeffrey Epstein as a client.\" SUF 1164. But business—including Erdoes\n(then CEO AWM)—decided otherwise. SUF 11167-68, 260, 262-63.\nvii.\n\nIn 2008, JPMorgan Knew the Feds Were Connecting Certain\nTransactions to Epstein's Sex-Trafficking\n\nJPMorgan also knew that it made many payments from Epstein's accounts that federal\nprosecutors believed could be evidence of sex trafficking. In 2008, JPMorgan acquired Bear\n14\n\n... [truncated, 2015 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02809392/18 or ?id=EFTA02809392&page=18]", "char_count": 2015}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 20 of 45\n\nStearns, where it knew Epstein conducted his brokerage business. SUF11169-70. Around the time\nof Epstein's guilty plea, Arthur Middlemiss, formerly a compliance officer at Bear Stearns,\nassumed a similar role at JPMorgan and worked on Epstein investigations. SUF11171-72.\n\nSUF11173, 175.\n\nSUF11 176-77.\nSUF 1236,\nSUF 11235, 178.\nSUF ¶11235-36.\nviii.\n\nJPMorgan Employees Had Personal Knowledge of Epstein's SexTrafficking\n\nMany e-mails over JPMorgan e-mail between Staley and Epstein demonstrate that Staley\nhad personal knowledge of Epstein's sex-trafficking. SUF 11 195, 197-203. Staley met Epstein's\nco-conspirators at Epstein's townhouse. SUFI] 204-06.\n\nSUF1207. JPMorgan handled more than $210,000 in payments to\n\nfrom Epstein. SUF1231.\n\nJPMorgan admits Staley was \"the senior person at JPMorgan with a business relationship with\nEpstein,\" SUF 11191-92, 208-13; thus, Staley's knowledge is imputed to JPMorgan. Order at 29.\nBrigstocke (CFO of AWM) wrote Erdoes comparing a client's house to Epstein's: \"Reminded me\nof JE's house, except it was more tasteful, and fewer nymphettes.\" SUF 1190.\n\n15\n\nEFTA02809411\n\n", "char_count": 1181}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 21 of 45\n\nC.\n\nJPMorgan Participated in Epstein's Sex-Trafficking Venture\n\nEven if participation requires active engagement, Order at 24, there is no genuine dispute\nthat JPMorgan actively participated in Epstein's sex-trafficking venture from 2006 until 2019. The\nCourt found allegations that the Bank allowed Epstein to use its accounts to send dozens of\npayments to then-known co-conspirators;\n; provided excessive and unusual amounts of cash to Epstein; and structured\ncash withdrawals so that those withdrawals would not appear suspicious \"went well beyond merely\nproviding their usual (banking] services to Jeffrey Epstein and his affiliated entities\" and were\nsufficient to allege active engagement. Order at 25-26. The New York State Department of\nFinancial Services (\"NYSDFS\") entered into a Consent Order and issued a $150 million penalty\nto Deutsche Bank for its \"inexcusable faillure( to detect or prevent millions of dollars of suspicious\ntransactions\" related to Epstein, including: payments to publicly alleged co-conspirators;\nsettlement payments and dozens of payments to law firms for legal expenses of Epstein and coconspirators; payments to Russian models, including for school tuition and hotel and rent expenses,\nand to numerous women with Eastern European surnames; and periodic suspicious cash\nwithdrawals totaling more than $800,000 over four years. SUF1214.\n\nPayments to Co-Conspirators\n\nand •\n\nFrom August 2006\n\nthrough 2013, JPMorgan handled $678,741.57 and $607,804.30 in payments, respectively, from\nEpstein's JPMorgan accounts to\nrecruiters, and/or victim (\n\nand\n\nEpstein's co-conspirators,\n\n). SUF 11216, 218. Even after it decided to terminate\n\nEpstein's accounts in July 2013, JPMorgan still handled a payment of $15,000 from Epstein's\nJPMorgan accounts to =.\n\nSUF 1217.\n\n16\n\nEFTA02809412\n\n", "char_count": 1879}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 22 of 45\n\nSUE11220, 84. In addition to payments from Epstein, JPMorgan also opened credit\ncards for\n\n\"through NES, LLC do Jeffrey Epstein\" only months after\n\nand\n\nEpstein was indicted. NES, LLC is an Epstein entity for which JPMorgan had not conducted the\nrequired due diligence, and\nSUF1186, 88-89, 60-61.\nPayments to Co-Conspirator Ghislaine Maxwell:\n\nAfter August 2006, JPMorgan\n\ncontinued to handle payments to Maxwell, who, by July 2006, it had reason to suspect was\ninvolved with Epstein in the alleged sex crimes. See supra Part 1(B)(i)(b). JPMorgan's payments\nto Maxwell included more than $7 million to purchase a helicopter. SUF91222-23.\nMillions of Dollars in Payments to Girls and Women, Many with Eastern European\nSurnames and/or Located in Eastern Europ\n\nSUF1226,\n\nSUF 11107, 151, 153, 48-50, 125-26. JPMorgan sent several of the\npayments by foreign wire to girls or women to locations in Eastern Europe including Belarus,\nLithuania, and Russia. SUF 1230. JPMorgan also handled payments to women for school tuition\nand rent expenses. SUF 191232. 234.\n\nSUF 1228.\n\nSUF 1229.\n\n17\n\nEFTA02809413\n\n", "char_count": 1162}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 23 of 45\n\n$1000 and Smaller Dollar Payments to Girls or Women and $100,000 Payments:\n\nSUF 11235-36. As explained\nabove, JPMorgan knew from the federal prosecutors' subpoena to Bear Stearns that law\nenforcement considered these payments suspicious and evidence of Epstein's federal sex crimes.\nSUF 91911 76-177.\nMC2 Modeling Agency SBLC: As described above, from 2005 to March 2011, JPMorgan\nextended an SBLC to Brunel and MC2 despite reports it supported \"payment for services as a\nprocurer.\" By 2007, there were reports that Epstein was engaged in sexual abuse of minors through\nMC2, yet JPMorgan continued to extend the SBLC.\nSUF1237, who it knew was covering up Epstein's\ninvolvement with MC2. See supra Part I(B)(iii).\nPayments to \"High-Powered\" Lawyers Covering Up Epstein's Sex Crimes: Following\nEpstein's arrest for felony sex crimes and confession to Staley and prior to the NPA,\n\nSUF T[238-39. After the NPA through 2013,\n\nExcessive and Unusual Cash Withdrawals: The NYSDFS found inexcusable Deutsche\nBank's failure to monitor \"suspicious cash withdrawals [of] more than $800,000 over four years.\"\nSUF1214. Between September 2003 and November 2013, or approximately ten years, JPMorgan\nhandled more than $5 million in outgoing cash transactions for Epstein, SUF 1242—ignoring its\n\n18\n\nEFTA02809414\n\n", "char_count": 1364}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 24 of 45\n\nown policy discouraging large cash withdrawals, SUF1241. From August 2006 to 2013, JPMorgan\nfacilitated nearly $2.5 million in cash withdrawals for Epstein, SUF 1247, even though it was\nwidely publicized that Epstein paid for sexual encounters with minors in cash and\n\nSee supra Part I(B)(i)(d).\nSUF ¶249.\n\nJPMorgan did not seek an explanation for Epstein's excessive\ncash withdrawals until 2011, again in violation of its own policy. SUF1241.\n\nSUF 1101; see also supra Part I(B)(i)(d).\n\nJPMorgan\nmust file SARs to report suspicious financial transactions \"[w)henever the national bank detects\n... a transaction or transactions conducted through the bank and involving or aggregating $5,000\nor more in funds or other assets where the bank believes . . . that it was used to facilitate a criminal\n\n19\n\nEFTA02809415\n\n", "char_count": 881}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 25 of 45\n\ntransaction, and the bank has a substantial basis for identifying a possible suspect.\" 12 C.F.R. §\n21.11(c)(2). JPMorgan must file a SAR \"no later than 30 calendar days after the date of the initial\ndetection of facts that may constitute a basis for filing a SAR. 12 C.F.R. § 21.11(d).\nFrom 2003 to 2013, JPMorgan helped Epstein withdraw over $5 million in cash, make\nmillions of dollars in payments to co-conspirators and accomplices, send more than $3 million in\nwires to women and girls, and\n\nAt the 2006 Rapid Response meeting following Epstein's indictment on \"felony charges\nof soliciting underage prostitutes,\" JPMorgan explicitly noted \"[c] ash withdrawals ... made in\namounts for $40,000 to $80,000 several times a month\"\n\nSee supra Part I(B)(iXd) and (ii).\n\nSUF 197.\n\n20\n\nEFTA02809416\n\n", "char_count": 862}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 26 of 45\n\nD.\n\n.finlorgan Benefited from Participation in Epstein's Sex-Trafficking Venture\n\nJPMorgan argued the Government must allege that it received revenue from Epstein in\nexchange for the Bank's furtherance of Epstein's sex-trafficking venture. The Court \"is not\nconvinced that the benefit element should be read in this way,\" Order at 31, and, indeed, \"the\nstatutory language imposes no such [causal relationship] requirement.\" HH v. G6 Hospitality, Inc.,\nNo 2:19-cv-755, 2019 WL 6682152, at ■2 (S.D. Ohio Dec 6, 2019). JPMorgan admits it received\nfees and other revenue from providing services to Epstein and his affiliated entities. Order at 31;\nSUF 11252-53. In any event, from at least 2006 to Epstein's arrest in 2019, JPMorgan knowingly\nbenefited from furthering Epstein's sex-trafficking venture.\nIn or about the 2000 time period, Sandy Warner, then head of JPMorgan, told Staley (then\nhead PB), \"[Y]ou should meet Epstein. He's one of the most connected people I know of in New\nYork.\" SUF1275. Warner was right. By 2003, Epstein introduced Staley and Google's founders,\nSergey Brin and Larry Page, and helped source billionaire hedge fund (Highbridge) owner Glenn\nSUP 11280-81, 311, 314-16. By then, Epstein was also bringing in over $8 million in\nrevenues to the Private Bank—the top revenue and nearly double the amount of the next highest\nclient. In 2003, \"Epstein, through the trading of his accounts and that of Leslie Wexner, generates\none of the largest annual revenue flows of private clients in the private bank.\" SUF TH.254-58.\nThe following year, Epstein facilitated JPMorgan's acquisition of Highbridge, a gamechanging acquisition for JPMorgan. Highbridge, a hedge fund with $7 billion in assets under\n\n21\n\nEFTA02809417\n\n", "char_count": 1803}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 27 of 45\n\nmanagement, was co-founded by Epstein's close friend =,\n\nand Epstein was a founding\n\ninvestor. Epstein advised both JPMorgan and Highbridge on the acquisition and worked with\nDimon, then CEO-in-waiting, Bill\n\nthen CEO, and other \"JPMorgan Chase Executive\n\nManagement\" on the acquisition. Epstein was paid a $15 million consulting fee for his work on\nthe acquisition. SUF 11370-381. Epstein also continued to facilitate introductions to the Bank,\nincluding a meeting between Staley and the Sultan of Dubai. SUF T1333-35.\nThis sets the stage for 2006, after Epstein was arrested for felony sex crimes and confessed\nhis conduct to Staley, when JPMorgan could have exited Epstein but did not. Instead, at the Rapid\nResponse meeting, the Private Bank imposed a condition on his accounts supposedly to \"mitigate\nthe risk\"—he could remain a \"banking\" but not an investment client. SUF 11382-84. But, when it\nlater benefited the Bank, the restrictions were ignored, and by 2011, Epstein was the Private Bank's\ninvestment arm's \"biggest revenue producer.\" SUF 11385, 267-72. The Rapid Response meeting\nwas a fiction in other respects. Though JPMorgan was supposedly considering terminating its\nrelationship with Epstein, at precisely the same time, the Bank was actively trying to find a New\nYork home for Epstein's accounts \"as the advisor to the Google founders\"—a relationship that\nwould become \"one of the largest in the Private Bank, of +$4BN.\" SUF X322, 314-327, 331-32.\nThe Bank was also actively growing the Epstein relationship—between post-indictment\nand post-conviction Rapid Response meetings, Epstein's assets under management increased fourfold from $32 million to over $120 million. SUF 11 259, 264. By September 3, 2008, when\nEpstein's Private Banker (M)\n\nthought his assets were a \"probable outflow (pending Dimon\n\nreview),\" Epstein's accounts were worth more than $156 million—and, needless to say, were not\n\"outflow[ed).\" SU\n... [truncated, 2193 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02809392/26 or ?id=EFTA02809392&page=26]", "char_count": 2193}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 28 of 45\n\nMC2. The Bank's only concern: \"Are we comfortable taking on additional credit exposure just\nahead of his pending plea arrangement?\" SUF1133.\nJPMorgan also kept banking Epstein, despite its knowledge of his sex-trafficking, because\nit was trying to settle lawsuits he had against the bank—one related to his investments at Bear\nStearns and another in\n\n. In 2011, as JPMorgan had near-settled Epstein's\n\nclaims against Bear Steams, Cutler wrote to Erdoes \"I would like to put it and HIM behind us. Not\na person we should do business with — period.\" But-as Shenker (then General Counsel AWM),\nexplained to Erdoes—\"[Cutler] at conclusion of JE approval [of Bear Stearns settlement], asked\nwhen we are offboarding JE. I reminded him that we have the other matter outstanding.\" At the\ntime, the Bank was still trying to settle\n\nSUF 11387-98.\n\nIn 2008, Bear Stearns, now part of JPMorgan, had made it known that it wanted to keep\nEpstein as a brokerage client despite his felony conviction. Alan \"Ace\" Greenberg, former\nChairman of Bear Stearns (and now with JPMorgan), also \"wanted to continue to do business with\nEpstein\" and sought an \"exception to the felon policy,\" which, on paper, required that the GC\n(Cutler) approve retaining Epstein. SUF 11399-403. In addition, throughout spring and summer\n2011, Epstein helped Erdoes and Staley—who JPMorgan admits were involved in the decision to\nmaintain Epstein at the Bank—put together a proposal for a $100 billion Donor Advised Fund for\nthe Gates Foundation, which Erdoes and Staley presented to the Gates Foundation on August 31,\n2011. Erdoes communicated frequently and familiarly with Epstein\n—during the DAF development and pitch process. SUF11404-12.\nThroughout, Epstein continued to connect JPMorgan with the world's dignitaries and\nwealthiest people, including, among others, Gates, Boris Nikolic (advisor to Gates), Summers, the\nSultan of Dubai, Prince Andrew, Barak, Netanyahu, Da\n... [truncated, 2059 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02809392/27 or ?id=EFTA02809392&page=27]", "char_count": 2059}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 29 of 45\n\nReagan, and Clinton), Pritzker, and Mandelson. SUF /1276-313. Epstein also continued to bring\nin significant revenues to the Bank. SUF 11267-74.\nEpstein was also a personal resource to Staley and Erdoes, two business executives who\nJPMorgan does not dispute were involved in the decision to maintain Epstein at the Bank. Epstein\nhelped Staley with\n\n. In 2005, Erdoes personally\n\nsought Epstein's help in resolving a $600 million tax issue for\n\nIn December 2008, after Bernie Madoff's investment scandal was uncovered,\nErdoes wrote Staley: \"glenn and I have been going back and forth all night. We have HUNDREDS\nof clients .... Can you call JE to get the scoop from down there?' SUF11413-17.\nPost-exit, JPMorgan continued to benefit from Epstein until months before his 2019 arrest.\nDuffy (then CEO US PB) gave Epstein's former JPMorgan Banker (Justin Nelson) permission to\ncontinue a relationship with Epstein as \"a potential source of referrals.\" Nelson met with Epstein\n8-10 times, twice as many times as\n\nwho had been his main Banker for a decade prior to his\n\nexit, including about business with\n\nBlack, CEO of private equity behemoth Apollo Global\n\nManagement. SUF11353-65, 369. In 2019, a few months before Epstein was arrested, JPMorgan\nwas still taking referrals from Epstein.\n\nSUF n366-68.\nAll the while, JPMorgan continued to\nH.\n\nJPMORGAN OBSTRUCTED ENFORCEMENT OF THE TVPA IN VIOLATION\nOF 18 U.S.C. § 1591(d)\nBy 2007, JPMorgan knew of \"an effort to enforce the TVPA\" and \"intentionally\n\nobstruct[ed] or attempt[ed] to obstruct that enforcement effort.\" Order at 33. Though Epstein\n24\n\nEFTA02809420\n\n", "char_count": 1676}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 30 of 45\n\nconfessed the conduct (except the \"ages\"), JPMorgan\nand, instead, actively handled payments to Epstein's lawyers who it knew were\ndiscrediting the victims, hiring private investigators to target witnesses, and negotiating a deal\nwhere federal prosecutors would (and did) defer prosecution of TVPA charges. Supra Part 1(B)(ii).\nFurther,\n\nSupra Part I.\nJPMorgan\nand Maxwell; the credit cards to\n\nthe payments to\nand\n\nincluding for monthly travel \"through\n\nParis, Europe and US Virgin Islands and US;\" the revoked credit card to\nto police; the DDR information Epstein provided for\n\nwho had talked\n\n(or any of the other girls Epstein\n\nreferred to the Bank); the payments to the girls and women, including with Eastern European\nnames, or their names and location, which it also had. JPMorgan\nthat it helped Epstein financially back Brunel and MC2 since 2005. Supra Part I. In\n2019, Brunel was charged with rape of minors and under investigation for trafficking tied to\nEpstein and was widely known, including by JPMorgan, years earlier as \"among the sleaziest\npeople in the fashion industry ... a conveyor belt, not a casting =.\"\n\nSUF 1421-22.\n\n25\n\nEFTA02809421\n\n", "char_count": 1224}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 31of 45\n\nEven when it knew that the feds had subpoenaed Bear Stearns for Epstein's account and\ntransaction information related to its investigation,\n\nSupra Part I. In 2010, JPMorgan learned of new federal investigations of\nEpstein for child sex-trafficking, but\n\nSupra Part I.\nJPMorgan's own due diligence on Epstein shows it knew that \"names and contact\ninformation of material witnesses and additional victims\" would have been \"extremely useful in\ninvestigations and prosecuting the [federal] case.\" SUF 1420. JPMorgan had the names and\ninformation for dozens of accomplices, victims, and other material witnesses—including, for\nexample, his pilots, SUF 187, his assistants, and his accountant, who JPMorgan later\nacknowledged \"controlled the movement of Epstein funds that potentially assisted in facilitating\nthe sex trafficking ring,\" SUF 15, as well as the long list of dignitaries and ultra-wealthy men\nEpstein referred or connected to the Bank\n. Supra Part I. By Epstein's arrest in 2006, there should have been \"a constant stream of\ninformation from JPMC to the FBI about Epstein's ongoing\n\n.... Human\n\ntrafficking is an ongoing crime, with harm incurred every day that the crime continues.\" ■\n\n26\n\nEFTA02809422\n\n", "char_count": 1278}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 32 of 45\n\nthere is no genuine\ndispute Epstein would have been federally charged with sex-trafficking much earlier. SUF1419.\nIII.\n\nTHE USVI'S REQUESTED RELIEF FOR VIOLATIONS OF THE TVPA\nDeclaratory Judgment and Injunction: The Government requests that the Court declare\n\nJPMorgan violated TVPA §§ 1591(a)(2) and (d) by participating in Epstein's sex-trafficking\nventure and obstructing federal law enforcement efforts to enforce the TVPA against Epstein from\n2006 to 2019. The Government seeks an injunction to prevent JPMorgan from participating in\ntrafficking ventures in the future and obstructing efforts to stop such ventures in violation of the\nTVPA. See Alfred L Snapp v. Puerto Rico, 458 U.S. 592, 598-99 (1982).\nCivil Penalties: The Government has proven even greater participation by JPMorgan in\nEpstein's sex-trafficking than the NYSDFS found against Deutsche Bank and seeks at least $150\nmillion in civil penalties.\nOther Remedies: The Government defers its request for disgorgement, compensatory and\npunitive damages, and other appropriate relief for JPMorgan's TVPA violations until trial.\nIV.\n\nJPMORGAN'S EQUITABLE AND FAULT-SHIFTING DEFENSES DO NOT\nAPPLY TO THE GOVERNMENT'S TVPA PARENS PATRIAE CLAIMS\nThis is an action by the Government of the Virgin Islands to vindicate public rights. While\n\nJPMorgan seeks to shift focus away from its own failings and point blame on the Government,\nsuch equitable or fault-shifting defenses are legally barred. See, e.g., City of New York v. FedE.r\nGround Package System, Inc., 314 F.R.D. 348, 357 (S.D.N.Y. 2016) (m[W]hen acting in a capacity\nto enforce public rights in the public interest ... government entities are not subject to all equitable\ndefenses—such as !aches or estoppel—that could ordinarily be invoked against a private actor.')\n(quoting State of New York v. UPS, Inc., 160 F. Supp. 3d 629, 640 (S.D.N.Y. 2016)); id. at 359\n27\n\nEFTA02809423\n\n", "char_count": 1967}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 33 of 45\n\n(contention that government plaintiffs were \"negligent in their discretionary tax enforcement . . .\nis impermissible where the government seeks to vindicate the public interest via enforcement of a\npublic statutory right\"). The Court therefore should grant summary judgment for the Government\non JPMorgan's Affirmative Defenses No. 5 (\"in pall delicto\"), 6 (\"unclean hands\"), 7 (\"laches\"),\nand 8 (\"comparative and contributory negligence or fault\"). Answer and Affirmative Defenses\n(Dkt. 124) at 26, because they seek to do precisely what the law prohibits-shift fault to a\ngovernment plaintiff bringing suit to vindicate public rights.2\nJPMorgan's attempts to distract from its violations of the TVPA described above by\nclaiming that the Government should have done more are particularly galling. The Government\nmust comply with constitutional and legal principles that protect all individuals by ensuring that\ninvestigations cannot proceed without concrete evidence. JPMorgan had that evidence—in\nspades—in its own files; the Government did not. JPMorgan knowingly handled virtually every\nfinancial transaction Epstein needed to operate his sex-trafficking venture, from the millions in\ncash withdrawals and payments to co-conspirators, recruiters, and victims, to the millions in\npayments to lawyers and publicists for the ongoing cover-up. JPMorgan had virtually every\nfinancial detail of Epstein's venture—from payments to young women in Lithuania and Russia, to\ntransfers for the purchase of a helicopter by Maxwell, to a \"revoked\" credit card for an alleged\nrecruiter who talked to the police—in real-time and kept virtually all of it, and thus its own outsized\nrole, under wraps until Epstein was dead and gone. Supra Part 1.\n\n2 The Government previously moved to strike these same defenses. See Dkt. 138, 139, 168, 205.\n\nThe Court denied the motion to strike without prejudice to the USVI's right to move for summary\njudgment\n... [truncated, 2266 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02809392/32 or ?id=EFTA02809392&page=32]", "char_count": 2266}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 34 of 45\n\nThe Government's causes of action against JPMorgan arise under the TVPA's parens\npatriae provision for state attorneys' general, which provides that where:\n[T]he attorney general of a State has reason to believe that an interest of the\nresidents of that State has been or is threatened or adversely affected by any person\nwho violates section 1591, the attorney general of the state, as parens patriae, may\nbring a civil action against such person on behalf of the residents of the State in an\nappropriate district court of the United States to obtain appropriate relief.\n18 U.S.C. § 1595(d). The TVPA makes clear that a State Attorney General plaintiff brings suit not\nas a private litigant on behalf of itself, but \"as parens patriae\" (i.e., the sovereign) \"on behalf of\nthe residents of the State\" to \"obtain appropriate relief' for \"an interest of [those] residents\" that\n\"has been or is threatened or adversely affected\" by JPMorgan's prohibited conduct.\nIn denying JPMorgan's motion to dismiss, the Court confirmed this plain reading of the\nTVPA. The Court found that the Government satisfies the elements of parens patriae standing,\nincluding that it \"allege[s] an injury to a quasi-sovereign interest that affects a sufficiently\nsubstantial segment of its population[.]\" Order at 17 (citing Snapp, 458 U.S. at 607). The Court\nexplained that the Government's asserted interest in protecting residents \"from the harmful effects\nof criminal sex-trafficking enterprises flourishing in the Islands . . . directly parallels the interest\nthat Puerto Rico successfully asserted in Snapp[.]\" Id. at 18 (cleaned up). Having found that the\nGovernment alleges a quasi-sovereign interest and is vindicating public rights, the Court now\nshould hold that JPMorgan's equitable and fault-shifting defenses do not apply as a matter of law.3\n\n3 See, e.g., United States v. Angell, 292 F.3d 333, 338 (2d Cir. 2002) (\"[L]aches is not available\n\nag\n... [truncated, 2791 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02809392/33 or ?id=EFTA02809392&page=33]", "char_count": 2791}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 35 of 45\n\nThe Government's TVPA claim under section 1595(d) is one exclusively pursued by state\ngovernments, and not by private parties, just as under the CCTA in FedEx and UPS. The TVPA\nmakes this clear by predicating a state's claim upon its showing that \"an interest of the residents\nof that State has been or is threatened or adversely affected by any person who violates section\n1591[.]\" 18 U.S.C. § 1595(d). The dismissal opinion makes it clearer still that the Government is\nacting in a public enforcement capacity by holding that the Government \"allege[s] an injury to a\nquasi-sovereign interest\" and \"seek[s] relief to the territory's injury that would be unavailable to\nindividual plaintiffs.\" Order at 18. Since the Government is enforcing the TVPA in its capacity as\nsovereign, not as a privately-interested litigant, JPMorgan's equitable and fault-shifting defenses\nare barred as a matter of law and discovery has not shown otherwise.\nJPMorgan has generally cited three issues forming the basis of its fault-shifting affirmative\ndefenses: (I) Epstein's registration as a sex offender; (2) the Virgin Islands Economic\nDevelopment Commission's (\"EDC's\") provision of tax benefits to Epstein's companies under a\nfederally-authorized tax benefit program; and (3) actions taken by Cecile de Jongh, whom Epstein\nemployed. As explained below, JPMorgan's claims of a Government-wide conspiracy to protect\nEpstein are both legally unsound and factually unsupported. The defenses based on these\nallegations cannot survive summary judgment.\nA.\n\nJPMorgan's Defenses are Barred as Applied to Sex Offender Registry Issues\n\nJPMorgan argues that the Government's purportedly improper enforcement of sexoffender registry requirements with respect to Epstein supports its equitable and/or fault-shifting\n\npublic interest.\") (quoting Nevada v. U.S., 463 U.S. 110, 141 (1983)); United States v. Vineland\nChem. Co., Inc., 692 F. Supp. 415, 423 (D.N.J. \n... [truncated, 2187 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02809392/34 or ?id=EFTA02809392&page=34]", "char_count": 2187}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 36 of 45\n\ndefenses. See Opp' n Mot. Strike (Dkt. 157) (\"MTS Opposition\") at 8-11. This argument is without\nbasis.\ni.\n\nThe Government's Investigations or Monitoring of Epstein Cannot\nForm the Basis of Viable Affirmative Defenses\n\nJPMorgan essentially argues that the Government should have more aggressively\ninvestigated Epstein or monitored his whereabouts. But that argument suffers from a fatal flaw.\nEven as a convicted sex offender, Epstein possessed constitutional rights that the Government was\nrequired to respect. (Nothing, however, granted Epstein a constitutional right to conduct business\nwith JPMorgan or to be free from JPMorgan's scrutiny.) JPMorgan's attempts to equate its own\ncompliance failures with the Government's actions have no legal basis and thus amount to little\nmore than a brazen attempt to distract from its own regulatory failings. The officials within the\nVirgin Islands Government responsible for sex offender registration and monitoring are not\nresponsible for Epstein's crimes. SUF1424. The laws required Epstein to register—which he did—\nand to provide notification of travel overseas. 14 V.I.C. § 1724. But the Government could not\nenter his island or conduct searches without concrete evidence that crimes were being committed.\nAll witnesses confirmed that the Government never received such evidence. SUE11429-30.\nJPMorgan has attempted to point to news articles or complaints filed by anonymous victims\nin other states as \"evidence\" that the Virgin Islands Government failed to pursue. But those\ndocuments do not and cannot underpin a government investigation. The Government could not\nsearch Epstein's property without a warrant, which can only issue upon probable cause. See, e.g.,\nGroh v. Ramirez, 540 U.S. 551, 557 (2004). Newspaper reports or anonymous statements do not\nconstitute sufficient basis for probable cause because \"[m]ere journalistic prose is not the kind of\nunderlying factual data upon\n... [truncated, 2178 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02809392/35 or ?id=EFTA02809392&page=35]", "char_count": 2178}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 37 of 45\n\npoint that all newspaper reports are not of sufficient reliability to form the basis of Fourth\nAmendment probable cause determination\"); see also U.S. v. One\nGlove & Other Michael\n\nCrystal CoveredBat Tour\n\nMemorabilia, 2013 WL 12196595, at *4 (C.D. Cal. Aug. 19,\n\n2013). These cases are consistent with the undisputed witness testimony confirming that the\nDepartment of Justice could not initiate investigations or pursue warrants based upon these types\nof hearsay statements. SUF 1426-27. As witnesses confirmed, absent an actual complaint from a\nvictim or eyewitness evidence brought to the Department of Justice's attention, the Department\ncould not initiate investigations. SUF1428.\nJPMorgan's complaints concerning the adequacy of address verification checks fare no\nbetter. No provision in the law requires the Virgin Islands to perform such checks, which are done\nto confirm that the registrant resides at the address provided to the Government. The checks were\nperformed roughly annually in conjunction with U.S. Marshalls and other federal partners. SUF\n1431. The applicable law required address checks to verify that an offender is living where\nreported. They do not, however, authorize entry onto private property or dispense with the\nrequirements of the Fourth Amendment. Government officials may not enter a sex offender's\nproperty or conduct a search absent consent or a warrant based on probable cause. SUE1432.\nThat protection is the reason that, in certain years, the U.S. Marshalls and Virgin Islands\nofficials did not proceed beyond Epstein's dock. If an offender refused entry, the government\nofficials performing the check did not possess authorization to enter. SUF1433. One Virgin Islands\nwitness testified that she conferred with the federal government concerning this practice and was\ntold that it was similar to a situation where a landowner has placed a gate at the border to his\nproperty. The officials wer\n... [truncated, 2086 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02809392/36 or ?id=EFTA02809392&page=36]", "char_count": 2086}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 38 of 45\n\n1434. Nor was it improper or unusual for the Government to confirm addresses at a sex offender's\nplace of employment, as was done one year with Epstein. SUF1435.\nii.\n\nThe Discretionary Act of Granting a Waiver of Notification Periods for\nOverseas Travel is Not Grounds to Shift Fault to the Government\n\nFollowing his conviction in Florida, Epstein was required to register as a sex offender with\nthe Virgin Islands Department of Justice. In 2012, the Legislature amended its sex offender laws,\nin pan to obtain federal funding for its sex offender unit. SUF 1436. The U.S. Government\napproved the changes to the law in advance. SUF 1437. JPMorgan has sought to make\n\nof the\n\nfact that Epstein's attorneys consulted with lawmakers concerning the proposed changes. But those\narguments prove nothing. The Legislature rejected Epstein's proposed changes. SUF1438.\nThe amended statute required that \"[a[11 sex offenders required to register in this\njurisdiction shall appear in person at the Department of Justice at least twenty one (21) calendar\ndays prior to any intended travel outside of the United States and provide information about their\nintended travel as provided in [14 V.I.C.] section 1726[.]\" 14 V.I.C. § 1724(b)(4) (emphasis\nadded). The same provision then states that \"that Attorney General may at his discretion reduce\nthis twenty-one (21) day notice requirement if a sex offender requests such a reduction and\nprovides information in support of his request.\" Id. (emphasis added). Other statutory provisions\nconfirm that \"[n]othing under this chapter shall be construed as a waiver of sovereign immunity\nfor the United States Virgin Islands, its departments and agencies.\" 14 V.I.C. § 1728(a).\nEpstein applied for and received a discretionary waiver of his travel notification\nrequirements pursuant to these statutory provisions. SUF1439. But this waiver does not constitute\nmisconduct or otherwise form the basis of a va\n... [truncated, 2263 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02809392/37 or ?id=EFTA02809392&page=37]", "char_count": 2263}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 39 of 45\n\nshifting fault to the Government. See, e.g., City ofNew York v. FedEx, 314 F.R.D. at 359; see also\nv. Gov't of the Virgin Islands, 847 F.2d 104, 107 (3d Cir. 1988) (Virgin Islands law\nrecognizes the \"public duty doctrine,\" which \"preclud[esj suit for governmental negligence based\nonly on the Government's failure to comply with a duty owed to the public in general[.]\").4\nThe defense fails as a factual matter as well. The statutory waiver of which JPMorgan\ncomplains applied only to international travel. While the Government had a \"policy in place\" to\nrequire notification of travel outside of the Territory but within the United States, nothing in the\nfederally-approved Virgin Islands statute required such notification. SUF 1442. Nor did the\nprovision of such a waiver somehow enable Epstein's crimes. Testimony is clear that Epstein never\nfailed to register as a sex offender and there is no evidence that he failed to notify of travel. SUF\n1425. There is no evidence that permitting Epstein to email his international travel notifications 24\nhours in advance instead of appearing in person 21 days in advance somehow enabled him more\nlatitude to commit his crimes. Notifications are not authorizations or requests; the Government has\nno ability to restrict his travel. SUF 1443. Moreover, entry into the Territory from overseas is\ncontrolled by federal authorities, not the Virgin Islands Governments. SUF1444.\nAny attacks on the granting of the waiver itself are meritless. Then-Attorney General\nFrazer testified that he relied on representations of Epstein's counsel in forming his decision, and\nthat those \"representations\" were \"satisfactory to conclude that there was not an undue risk to the\ncommunity\" that would arise from the waiver. SUF 1440. Epstein's lawyers represented to Mr.\n\n4 See also Maldonado by and through Ochoa v. City ofSibley, 58 F.4th 1017, 1022 (8th Cir. 2023)\n(\"[T]he public-duty doctrine generally \n... [truncated, 2564 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02809392/38 or ?id=EFTA02809392&page=38]", "char_count": 2564}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 40 of 45\n\nFrazer that other states permitted Epstein to provide email notification of his travels and affirmed\nthat \"there is no public safety necessity in requiring Epstein to notify the Department in person\neach time he travels to or from the jurisdiction.\" SUF 1441. JPMorgan's defense thus rests not on\nwhether the decision was authorized under law—it most certainly was—but on whether the\nAttorney General in 2012 exercised sufficient discretion in granting the waiver. This is precisely\nwhat the caselaw cited above precludes. Cf. Harlow v. Fitzgerald, 457 U.S. 800, 817-818 (1982)\n(\"(G]overnment officials performing discretionary functions generally are shielded from liability\nfor civil damages insofar as their conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or\nconstitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have known\").\nB.\n\nJPMorgan's Defenses are Barred as Applied to the Economic Development\nCommission's Grant of Tax Benefits to Epstein's Companies\n\nThe EDC operates under the umbrella of the USVI Economic Development Authority\n(\"EDA\"), which is a \"semi-autonomous instrumentality of the Government\" and is governed by a\nboard of individuals appointed by the Governor. 29 V.I.C. § 1101(a). The EDA \"is a public\ncorporation having legal existence and personality separate and apart from the Government of the\nVirgin Islands and the officers controlling it.\" 29 V.I.C. § 1101(6). Thus, to the extent IPMorgan\nconflates entities and treats EDC actions as attributable to the Government, see MTS Opp'n at 2,\nits arguments find no support in Virgin Islands law.\nThe tax benefits are authorized by a federal statute (26 U.S.C. § 934(b)(1)), pursuant to\nwhich, the EDC administers \"a unique economic development program for the USVI,\" allowing\nresidents of the Territory to exempt certain income if it is \"'connected with the conduct of a trade\nor business within the Virgin Islands.\"' Coffey v. C.LR., 663 F.3d 947, \n... [truncated, 2246 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02809392/39 or ?id=EFTA02809392&page=39]", "char_count": 2246}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 41 of 45\n\nthe Government of the Virgin Islands that certain industrial development benefits should be made\navailable for development and expansion of such industrial or business activities as are determined,\npursuant to this subchapter, to be in the public interest by advancing the growth, development\nand/or diversification of the economy of the Territory of the Virgin Islands.\"); 29 V.I.C. § 705(a)\n(\"The Commission shall[,] [biased upon the investigation and recommendations of the Director,\nreview all applications for economic development benefits, hold public hearings thereon as\nprovided in section 717 of this chapter, and (1) grant certificates for same, or (2) deny such\ncertificate, subject to reconsideration in accordance with section 717.\"). The provision,\ncontinuation, and/or revocation of economic development-related tax benefits thus is statutorily\nmandated and/or vested in the EDC's discretion, not evidence of government misconduct or\ngrounds for fault-shifting. SeeM, 847 F.2d at 107?\nThe factual record bears this out. The EDC granted tax incentives to two of Epstein's\ncompanies: Financial Trust Company and Southern Trust Company. SUF1445. The first grant of\nbenefits to an Epstein-owned company occurred in 1999 to Financial Trust. SUF 1446. In 2009,\nFinancial Trust applied for and received an extension of benefits. SUF1447. Epstein formed a new\ncompany—Southern Trust—which applied for and received tax benefits in 2012. SUF 1448. In\neach of those cases, the grant of benefits was performed in compliance with all statutory and\nregulatory procedures and requirements. The companies submitted applications for the benefits.\nSUF1449. EDC held public hearings during which the benefits were discussed and the applicants\nwere provided the opportunity to present their case and answer questions. SUF1450. The EDC\nthen held decision meetings where the board considered the applications and rendered decisions.\n\n3 The E\n... [truncated, 2291 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02809392/40 or ?id=EFTA02809392&page=40]", "char_count": 2291}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 42 of 45\n\nSUF 1451. To the extent JPMorgan questions the reasoning behind those decisions, that is\nprecisely the type of second-guessing the law precludes. See McGaughey, supra, 684 F.3d at 1358\n(\"Courts and juries are ill-equipped to review legislative and executive decisions about how to\nallocate limited municipal resources to best protect the public.\").\nOnce benefits are granted, Virgin Islands law limits the EDC's ability to modify them.\n\"The Commission may not require an applicant to meet qualifications or requirements in excess\nof those representations made by the applicant to the Commission during the application process\nas a condition of granting an initial certificate.\" 29 V.I.C. § 708. Indeed, the law specifies that\nbenefits granted are \"consider[ed] .. . as being in the nature of a contract between [the] government\nand the beneficiary.\" 29 V.I.C. § 701(c).\nThe EDC could not revoke, suspend or modify the benefits based upon a felony conviction\nunless it concerned conduct \"connected with the operation of the beneficiary's business or\nindustry.\" 29 V.I.C. § 722(4). Thus, Epstein's Florida conviction was not grounds for revocation\nat that time because no evidence was available to the EDC that Epstein's solicitation of a minor\nfor prostitution in Florida was \"connected with the operation\" of his USVI businesses. SUF1452.\nUnlike JPMorgan, the EDC did not have access to Epstein's companies' daily financial\ntransactions, and was not aware of any connection between his conduct and the operations of his\nbusiness. SUF1453. Indeed, the EDC reached out to Epstein's attorney in January 2015 to inquire\nwhether media reporting regarding allegations of misconduct had any connection to the business\nof Epstein's Southern Trust Company. His attorney responded to confirm \"[w]e do not believe that\nthese media discussions will have any impact on the business activities of STC.\" SUF ¶454.\nJPMorgan has pointed to a \"cost-ben\n... [truncated, 2171 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02809392/41 or ?id=EFTA02809392&page=41]", "char_count": 2171}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 43 of 45\n\nwitness testimony, however, shows this analysis to be irrelevant because it uses an artificial\nbaseline. A long-tenured EDC employee who was personally involved in the granting of benefits\ntestified that the ratio \"doesn't give the full picture\" and \"can be misleading\" because, unless the\nbusiness already operated in the Territory, the Government would not receive the tax revenue in\nthe first place and has not \"lost\" anything. SUF 1¶455-56. This analysis applies to both the initial\ngrants of benefits to both companies and to Financial Trust's extension request. During a March\n2009 public hearing, Epstein's attorney explained that a denial of an extension would likely cause\n\"a responsible business person ... to seriously consider relocating the business\" if another territory\noffered similar benefits. SUF¶458. Thus, the EDC could not assume that it would collect Epstein's\ntax revenue if the benefits were not extended. SUF ¶459. The ratio further ignores ancillary\nbenefits that accrue to the Territory from the presence of high-net-worth individuals, who engage\nin economic activity unrelated to their businesses that benefits the territory. SUF1457.6\nC.\n\nJPMorgan Has No Viable Defenses Based on Activity of Cecile De Jongh\n\nJPMorgan also argues that the activity of Cecile de Jongh, former First Lady of the U.S.\nVirgin Islands and Office Manager for Epstein, supports its defenses. MTS Opp'n at 20. Not so.\nAs First Lady, Ms. de Jongh had no statutory or regulatory authority. Ms. de Jongh\nconfirmed that \"there's no office of the first lady with a budget,\" and she did not have an office.\nFirst Lady was largely a ceremonial position that entailed giving speeches and attending social\nevents. SUF 1461. Moreover, the factual record shows that during the time her husband was\nGovernor, Ms. de Jongh was widely known and recognized to be employed by Epstein's\nbusinesses and acting on their behalf. SUF ¶462. Unlike the \n... [truncated, 2201 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02809392/42 or ?id=EFTA02809392&page=42]", "char_count": 2201}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 44 of 45\n\nM, de Jongh's employment with Epstein was widely reported and numerous witnesses\nconfirmed their familiarity with her employment. SUF¶463.\nMost importantly, Ms. de Jongh had no responsibility for governmental decisions that form\nthe basis of JPMorgan's flawed affirmative defenses. She had no contact with Department of\nJustice personnel responsible for sex offender registration and monitoring. SUF ¶464. Decisions\nconcerning tax benefits were made by the EDC's board members. SUF1465. Although the law at\nthe time required the Governor (her husband) to sign tax benefit certificates, that process was a\nformality and could not happen without the EDC's recommendation in the first place. SUF ¶465.\nMs. de Jongh vehemently denied knowing about or facilitating Epstein's crimes in the\nVirgin Islands. SUF1467. Although JPMorgan has pointed to emails about arranging an ESL class\nfor women in the Virgin Islands, Ms. de Jongh testified that she was not aware these individuals\nwere potential trafficking victims, and documents make clear that the University merely agreed to\noffer an existing class for them. SUF ¶¶468-69. Although Ms. de Jongh's emails may have\nprovided salacious fodder for JPMorgan, she ultimately was not responsible for any government\ndecisions.\nCONCLUSION\nFor the foregoing reasons, the Court should grant the Government's motion for partial\nsummary judgment.\n\n39\n\nEFTA02809435\n\n", "char_count": 1466}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02809392", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "Case 1:22-cv-10904-JSR Document 220 Filed 07/24/23 Page 45 of 45\n\nDated: July 24, 2023\n\nARIEL\nESQ.\nATTORNEY GENERA!.\nlsl Mimi Liu\nMIMI LIU\nAdmitted Pro Hac Vice\nMotley Rice LLC\n401 9th Street NW, Suite 630\nWashington, DC 20004\nTel: (202) 232-5504\nmliu@motleyrice.com\nVENETIA VELAZQUEZ\nAdmitted Pro Hac Vice\nActing Chief, Civil Division\nVirgin Islands Department of Justice\nOffice of the Attorney General\n213 Estate La Reine, RR1 Box 6151\nKingshill, St. Croix\nU.S. Virgin Islands 00850\nTel: (340) 773-0295 ext. 202481\nvenetia.velazquez@doj.vi.gov\nLINDA\n(Admitted Pro Hac Vice)\nDAVID I. ACICER1VIAN\nPAIGE BOGGS (Admitted Pm Hac Vice)\nMotley Rice LLC\n401 9th Street NW, Suite 630\nWashington, DC 20004\nTel: (202) 232-5504\nIsinger@motleyrice.com\ndackerman@motleyrice.com\npboggs@ motleyrice.com\nAttorneysfor Plaintiff Government of the\nUnited States Virgin Islands\n\n40\n\nEFTA02809436\n\n", "char_count": 878}]}