{"efta_number": "EFTA02800799", "page_count": 8, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02800799", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02800799.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02800799", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP\n\nDocument 422\n\nFiled 09/06/16\n\nPage 1 of 8\n\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK\nX\n\nPlaintiff,\nv.\n15-cv-07433-RWS\n\nGHISLAINE MAXWELL,\nDefendant.\n\nX\n\nDEFENDANT'S RENEWED MOTION TO COMPEL SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT\n\nLaura A. Menninger\nJeffrey S. Pa iuca\nHADDON,\n150 East 10 Avenue\nDenver, CO 80203\n303.831.7364\n\nAND\n\n, P.C.\n\nEFTA02800799\n\n", "char_count": 376}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02800799", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP\n\nDocument 422\n\nFiled 09/06/16\n\nPage 2 of 8\n\nDefendant Ghislaine Maxwell (\"Ms. Maxwell\"), pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 37(a)(3),\nfiles this Renewed Motion to Compel Settlement Agreement regarding the confidential\nsettlement agreement between Plaintiff and Jeffery Epstein, and states as follows:\nINTRODUCTION\nAs part of her scorched earth litigation practice, Plaintiff, without any legal basis,\ncontinues to withhold production of a settlement agreement and the amount of her settlement\nbetween herself and Jeffrey Epstein. Initially, Plaintiff improperly conditioned production of the\ndocument by requiring that counsel for Ms. Maxwell obtain a \"waiver from Mr. Epstein.\"\nAlthough it was not Ms. Maxwell's burden to do so, in an attempt to avoid filing this Motion,\ncounsel for Ms. Maxwell obtained the waiver from counsel for Mr. Epstein. These efforts were\napparently useless because, although counsel for the Plaintiff promised the Court that she would\n\"gladly\" produce the documents with a \"waiver from Mr. Epstein,\" she has reneged on that\npromise, forcing Ms. Maxwell to file yet another motion to compel production of relevant,\ndiscoverable information in Plaintiff's possession. Plaintiff's refusal to produce the document is\ngroundless and the Court should order production of the document forthwith and sanction\nPlaintiff for her conduct.\nSTATEMENT OF CONFERRAL\nThe undersigned has conferred extensively with Plaintiff's counsel on this issue by\ntelephone and email, as demonstrated in the correspondence attached hereto in Menninger Decl.\nEx. B. The parties have been unable to reach a resolution without the need for Court\nintervention.\nI.\n\nPROCEDURAL HISTORY\n•\n\nOn February 12, 2016 Ms. Maxwell served her First Set of Discovery Requests on\nPlaintiff. Request Number 19 requested \"Any Document reflecting a confidentiality\nagreement, settlement agreement, or any contractual agreement of any kind, between You\n1\n\nEFTA02800800\n\n", "char_count": 1963}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02800799", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP\n\nDocument 422\n\nFiled 09/06/16\n\nPage 3 of 8\n\nand Jeffrey Epstein, or any attorneys for You and/or Mr. Epstein.\" Menninger Decl. Ex.\nA.\n•\n\nOn March 16, 2016 Defendants responded to the Request for production stating `.\nis in possession of a document that contains a confidentiality provision. If\nDefendant obtains, and produces to\na written waiver from ... Mr. Epstein,\nof the confidentiality provision, she will produce the document.\" Menninger Decl. Ex. A\n\n•\n\nOn March 31, 2016, Ms. Maxwell moved to compel production of, inter alia. the\nSettlement Agreement between Plaintiff and Mr. Epstein. Doc. #75.\n\n•\n\nOn April 4, 2016, Plaintiff represented in Response that she \"is willing to produce the\nSettlement Agreement and all documents concerning the Settlement Agreement if\nDefendant gets a waiver of liability from Jeffrey Epstein for its disclosure.\" Doc. #78 at\n15. Indeed, with a \"waiver of the confidentiality clause from Jeffrey Epstein,\" she said\nshe would \"gladly turn over\" information regarding the amount of her settlement with\nMr. Epstein. Id. at 2.\n\n•\n\nOn April 21, 2016, the Court held a hearing on the Motion to Compel. At the hearing,\nPlaintiff's counsel represented to the Court:\n\"The other things, your Honor, that she has raised is, for example, she had\nasked for the Epstein settlement agreement and that was one of the things\nshe had asked for. We agreed to produce that if we got the waiver from\nMr. Epstein because we can't produce it without that waiver. I believe\nthat covers it, your Honor.\" (Transcript of April 21, 2016 at 19).\n\n•\n\nThe Court did not specifically issue a ruling on the Motion to Compel concerning\nRequest for Production 19, presumably relying upon Plaintiff's counsel's representation.\n\n•\n\nOn August 16, 2016, Mr. Epstein's counsel provided a written waiver of claims\nconcerning the confidentiality provision of the settlement agreement as requested by\nPlaintiff. Mr. Poe, Mr. Epstein's counsel stated \"I am authorized to state that Jeffrey\nEpstein is willing to agree not to sue plaintiff's counsel/plaintiff if the settlement\nagreement is disclosed to defendant Maxwell's counsel provided that (I) the settlement\nagreement is designated as confidential under the protective order; (2) the settlement\nagreement is deemed fully subject to the protective order; and (3) the settlement\nagreement (including individual terms) will not be publicly disclosed or used in court\nproceedings without notice to Mr. Epstein and an opportunity to be heard.\" Menninger\nDecl. Ex. B.\nDespite Mr. Epstein's specific waiver of any claim concerning the confidentiality\n\nprovision of the settlement agreement between himself and Plaintiff based on the production of\nthe document, Plaintiff continues to refuse to produce this document. Plaintiff now claims that\nMs. Maxwell must obtain the document from a third party — Mr. Epstein. Menninger Decl., Ex.\n2\n\nEFTA02800801\n\n", "char_count": 2919}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02800799", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP\n\nDocument 422\n\nFiled 09/06/16\n\nPage 4 of 8\n\nB. She requires this despite acknowledging that Ms. Maxwell has no right to demand these\ndocuments from a third party instead of Plaintiff because it is an improper use of a third party\nsubpoena. Zoological Soc. ofBuffalo, Inc. v. Carvedrock, LLC, No. 10-CV-35A SR, 2013 WL\n5652759, at *3 (W.D.N.Y. Oct. 15, 2013) (imposing sanctions under Rule 45 where party\nimposed an undue burden on a third party by, among other things, failing to seek documents\nfrom party to the action);\n\nv. Bank ofAmerica, 2007 WL 1589437, at *4 (S.D.N.Y. June 4,\n\n2007) (if documents available from a party, preferable to obtain them pursuant to Rule 34 rather\nthan subpoenaing them from a non-party witness pursuant to Rule 45).\nMr. Epstein will likely move to quash as he has specifically stated. Plaintiff has no basis\nfor non-production. The Settlement Agreement is readily available and within her control.\nPlaintiff's failure to abide by her representations to Ms. Maxwell and the Court have forced this\nunnecessary Motion to Compel.\nII.\n\nTHE SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT IS RELEVANT TO THE CLAIMS AND\nDEFENSES\nNo one contests that the Settlement Agreement between Plaintiff and Mr. Epstein is\n\nrelevant. Plaintiff sued Mr. Epstein in 2009 under various theories for his alleged sexual abuse\nof her from 1998 to 2002. Plaintiff's damages claims alleged:\nPlaintiff has in the past suffered, and will in the future continue to suffer, physical\ninjury, pain and suffering, emotional distress, psychological and/or psychiatric\ntrauma, mental anguish, humiliation, confusion, embarrassment, loss of\neducational opportunities, loss of self-esteem, loss of dignity, invasion of her\nprivacy, separation from her family, and other damages\nMenninger Decl. Ex. C.\nPlaintiff alleges the same damages in this case. She claims that \"Nile defamation caused\nto re-live the sexual abuse she previously endured\" as alleged against Mr. Epstein,\nwhich claims have been settled. Plaintiff's Rule 26(a) Disclosures, Menninger Decl. Ex. D.\n3\n\nEFTA02800802\n\n", "char_count": 2075}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02800799", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP\n\nDocument 422\n\nFiled 09/06/16\n\nPage 5 of 8\n\nPlaintiff's settlement with Mr. Epstein is relevant to multiple issues including, but not limited to:\nI) Plaintiff's own valuation of her damages for the types of damages alleged in that matter, 2)\nwhether Plaintiff has already been fully compensated for any past and future alleged pain and\nsuffering relating to the alleged sexual abuse she endured, 3) the scope of the parties and claims\nreleased in the agreement, and 4) Ms. Maxwell's defenses, including other intervening causes\nand acts of others causing any and all alleged damages. Indeed, in Plaintiff's Discovery\nResponses, she does not raise any relevance objection to production of the Settlement\nAgreement, thereby waiving any objection as to its relevance. Menninger Decl., Ex. A, Resp.\nNo. 19. A failure to respond or object to a discovery request in a timely manner waives any\nobjection which may have been available. See Cohalan v. Genie Industries, Inc., 276 F.R.D.\n161, 163 (S.D.N.Y. 2011) (noting that failure to timely object to discovery\nv. Conway Organization, Inc., 154 F.R.D.\n\nrequest waives objections and collecting cases);\n\n73 (S.D.N.Y.1994). Plaintiff cannot and does not contest that the Settlement Agreement is\nrelevant and must be produced.\n\nIII.\n\nPLAINTIFF MUST COMPLY WITH HER DISCOVERY OBLIGATIONS AND\nREPRESENTATIONS TO THE COURT\nPlaintiff made the unreasonable demand that Mr. Epstein provided a waiver of any claim\n\nrelating to a purported confidentiality provision in the Settlement Agreement prior to production.\nMs. Maxwell has never seen the Agreement, but presumably, it contains a confidentiality clause,\nas do most settlement agreements. What is unclear is if that clause would permit the disclosure\nof the Agreement in this litigation pursuant to validly issued discovery requests, as most\nsettlement agreements contain. It is also unclear if Plaintiff was permitted to turn over the\ndocument upon giving notice to Mr. Epstein, again a common provision. Regardless, Mr.\nEpstein has been notified and consented to the production of the document pursuant to the terms\n4\n\nEFTA02800803\n\n", "char_count": 2146}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02800799", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP\n\nDocument 422\n\nFiled 09/06/16\n\nPage 6 of 8\n\nof the blanket protective order in the matter, which both parties have agreed is appropriate.' He\nhas stated he will not sue Plaintiff for the production of the document. Plaintiff has gotten\nexactly what she requested. Despite her promises to this Court and Ms. Maxwell that production\nwould be made immediately after receiving this assurance, she now refuses to produce the\nAgreement without any reason or justification. Plaintiff should be required to comply with her\nrepresentations and produce the Settlement Agreement between her and Mr. Epstein.\nIV.\n\nCONFIDENTIAL SETTLEMENT AGREEMENTS ARE NOT PROTECTED\nFROM DISCOVERY\nThe demand for a waiver from Mr. Epstein, however, was unnecessary and inappropriate.\n\nConfidential \"'Settlement agreements,' and related documents, `are governed by Rule 26, which\nallows discovery thereof so long as such disclosure 'appears reasonably calculated to lead to the\ndiscovery of admissible evidence.\"' Casagrande v. Norm Bloom & Son, LLC, No. 3:1 I-CV1918 CSH, 2014 WL 5817562, at *7 (D. Conn. Nov. 10, 2014) (quoting Rates Tech. Inc. v.\nCablevision Sys. Corp., No. 05 cv 3583(DRH)(WDW), 2007 WL 1176732, at *2 (E.D.N.Y. Apr.\n20, 2007) (dismissing case where, after court order, Plaintiff refused to turn over confidential\nsettlement agreement relevant to the pending litigation)); see also Laforest v. Honeywell Ina\nInc., No. 03-CV-6248T, 2004 WL 1498916, at *7 (W.D.N.Y. July I, 2004) (\"the mere fact that\nthe third-party defendants designated their indemnification agreement as confidential does not\nshield it from discovery\"); Tribune Co. v. Purcigliotti, 1996 WL 337277 at *3; Weissman v.\nFruchtman, 1986 WL 15669, *19 (S.D.N.Y.1986) (\"parties' intention that agreement remain\nconfidential is not controlling.\"). In sum, a third-party's desire to maintain confidentiality as to a\n\nMr. Epstein's counsel does re 'test that if the Agreement is to be used at trial that he be given notice and\nMaxwell has agreed to this request to notify Mr. Epstein's counsel,\nopportunity to be heard prior to\nand there is no reason to object to this notice request.\n5\n\nEFTA02800804\n\n", "char_count": 2176}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02800799", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP\n\nDocument 422\n\nFiled 09/06/16\n\nPage 7 of 8\n\nSettlement Agreement is immaterial if the agreement itself is relevant to the proceeding and\nreasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence.\nPlaintiff does not contest that the Settlement Agreement is relevant. She therefore had\nand has no basis for refusing to produce the Agreement. There is certainly no reason to refuse\nthe request now since she has been assured that the production will not result in any claim for\nbreach of the confidentiality provision. The Court should compel production of the Settlement\nAgreement between Plaintiff and Jeffery Epstein.\nWHEREFORE, Defendant Ghislaine Maxwell request that this Court compel Plaintiff\nto produce the Settlement Agreement between her and Jeffery Epstein and all associated\ndocuments concerning her receipt of money from that settlement within two business days of the\nOrder on this Motion, for fees and costs associated with the filing of this motion and such other\nand further relief as this Court deems appropriate.\nDated: September 6, 2016\n\nRespectfully submitted,\n\n/s/ Laura A. Menninger\nLaura A. Menninger (LM-1374)\nJeffrey S. 010\n(pro hac vice\nHADDON,\n\nAND\n\nP.C.\n\n150 East 10 Avenue\nDenver, CO 80203\nPhone: 303.831.7364\nFax:\n303.832.2628\nlmenninger@hmflaw.com\nAttorneys for Ghislaine Maxwell\n\n6\n\nEFTA02800805\n\n", "char_count": 1363}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02800799", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case 1:15-cv-07433-LAP\n\nDocument 422\n\nFiled 09/06/16\n\nPage 8 of 8\n\nCERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\nI certify that on September 6, 2016, I electronically served this Defendant's Renewed\nMotion to Compel Settlement Agreement via ECF on the following:\nSigrid S. McCawley\nMeredith\nBOIES, SCHILLER & FLEXNER, LLP\n401 East Las Olas Boulevard, Ste. 1200\nFt. Lauderdale, FL 33301\nsmccawley@bsfllp.com\nmschultz@bsfllp.com\n\nPaul G. Cassell\n383 S. University Street\nSalt Lake City, UT 84112\ncassellp@law.utah.edu\n\nJ. Stanley Poltinger\n49 Twin Lakes Rd.\nSouth Salem, NY 10590\nStanPottinger@aol.com\n\nJAFFE, WEISSING,~,\nFISTOS & LEHRMAN, P.L.\n425 North Andrews Ave., Ste. 2\nFt. Lauderdale, FL 33301\nbrad@pathtojustice.com\n\nIs/ Nicole\nNicole\n\n7\n\nEFTA02800806\n\n", "char_count": 736}]}