{"efta_number": "EFTA02778303", "page_count": 7, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02778303", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02778303.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02778303", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF\n\nBSF\n\nDocument 115\n\nFiled 01/21/21\n\nPage 1 of 7\n\nBOIES\nSCHILLER\nFLEXNER\nSigrid S. McCawley\nTelephone: (954) 377-4223\nEmail: smccawley@bsfllp.com\nJanuary 21, 2021\n\nVIA ECF\nThe Honorable Lorna G. Schofield\nDistrict Court Judge\nUnited States District Court\nSouthern District of New York\n500 Pearl Street\nNew York, NY 10007\nRe:\n\nv. Darren K. hulyke, Richard I). Kahn, & Ghislaine Maxwell\n19-10475-LGS-DCIE\n\nDear Judge Schofield:\nPlaintiff\nmoves to dismiss this action with prejudice pursuant to Rule\n41(a)(2).\nincorporates her prior letters on this issue, including her November 17, 2020\nrequest for a premotion conference on this motion. ECF Nos. 97, 103, 106, 109.\nThe issue before the Court is narrow and straightforward:\nwants to dismiss\nthis lawsuit with prejudice so that she can conclude her participation in the Epstein Victims'\nCompensation Program (the \"Program\"). Defendant Ghislaine Maxell has refused to stipulate to\ndismissal (even though she would be getting out of this lawsuit for nothing) contending that she is\nentitled to know the amount of compensation that\nis to receive from Jeffrey Epstein's\nEstate (even though she is in no way contributing to that com ensation Maxwell's position is\nuntenable unsupported by law, and a clear attempt to frustrate\nability to resolve her\nclaims.\nrespectfully requests that the Court enter an order dismissing this case with\nprejudice in the form of the proposed order attached hereto.'\nBACKGROUND\nAfter Judge Freeman encouraged the parties to resolve this dispute,\nagreed\nto participate in the Program. Declaration of Sigrid S. McCawley (\"McCawley Decl.\") Ex. A at\n24:1-23 (\"I think that settlement is an important track.\"); 50:16-19 (\"These are serious claims....\nLet's see if we can get them on a settlement track that eve body is comfortable with.\"). On June\n22, 2020, Judge Freeman stayed this case so that\ncould participate in the Program.\nThe Program, the terms of which counsel for the Estate, the victims, and th\n... [truncated, 2690 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02778303/0 or ?id=EFTA02778303&page=0]", "char_count": 2690}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02778303", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF\n\nDocument 115\n\nFiled 01/21/21\n\nPage 2 of 7\n\nThe Honorable Lorna G. Schofield\nJanuary 21, 2021\nPage 2 of 7\nthe U.S. Virgin Islands negotiated at length over several months, \"is a voluntary, independent\nProgram that has been established to compensate and resolve the claims of victims-survivors of\nsexual abuse by Jeffrey Epstein.\" See McCawley Decl. Ex. B at I (Independent Epstein Victims'\nCompensation Program Protocol).\nPrior to agreeing to participate in the Program, victims (including )\nwere\nensured that all compensation offers and any information submitted to the Program would be\nconfidential. Id. at 6, 8. In order to receive payment, however, a victim must first (1) execute a\nform release waiving all of the victim's rights to assert claims against the Estate, any entities owned\nor controlled by the Estate, and any employees of the Estate, Mr. Epstein, or any entities owned or\ncontrolled by the Estate, among others (the \"General Release\") and (2) dismiss with prejudice any\nexisting lawsuits against the Estate or related entities and individuals. Id. at 3, 7. All parties to\nthis action, including Maxwell, have had access to the form General Release and its terms since at\nleast June of 2020. McCawley Decl. Ex. C (June 19, 2020, email from B. Moskowitz to L.\nMenninger attaching copy of General Release).\nOn June 26, 2020,\nsubmitted a claim to the Program. On Au ust 27, 2020,\nreceived an offer of compensation from the Program, which\naccepted on\nOctober 5, 2020.\nalso executed the General Release. Proof of dismissal with prejudice\nn civil claims is required by the Program's protocol. Accordingly, on October 14, 2020,\ninformed the Estate and Maxwell that she had accepted an offer of compensation and asked\nthe Defendants to stipulate to a dismissal of this action with prejudice pursuant to Rule\n41(a)(1)(A)(ii) with each party to bear its own fees and costs. See McCawley Decl. Ex. D at 7\n(October 14, 2020, email from S. Mariella to B. Moskowitz and\n... [truncated, 3865 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02778303/1 or ?id=EFTA02778303&page=1]", "char_count": 3865}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02778303", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF\n\nDocument 115\n\nFiled 01/21/21\n\nPage 3 of 7\n\nThe Honorable Lorna G. Schofield\nJanuary 21, 2021\nPage 3 of 7\nARGUMENT\nRule 41(a)(2) provides that \"an action may be dismissed at the plaintiff's request only by\ncourt order, on terms that the court considers proper.\" Fed. R. Civ. P. 41(aX2). \"[The\npresumption in this circuit is that a court should grant a dismissal pursuant to Rule 41(a)(2) absent\na showing that defendants will suffer substantial prejudice as a result.\" Paulino v. Taylor, 320\nv. SEC, 298 U.S. I, 19 (1936) (\"The\nF.R.D. 107 (S.D.N.Y. 2017) (emphasis added); see also\ngeneral rule is settled for the federal tribunals that a plaintiff possesses the unqualified right to\ndismiss his complaint . . . unless some plain legal prejudice will result to the defendant.\").\nIn light of\nsuccessful participation in the Program, she seeks to dismiss this\ncase on the two conditions reflected in the Proposed Order attached to this letter: (1) withprejudice\nand (2) with each party to bear its own fees and costs. Maxwell takes issue with\nsecond proposed condition: that each party bear its own fees and costs. She also asks the Court\nto\nse an additional condition on dismissal to which\ndoes not consent: that\ndisclose the amount of co\nnsation that she has been offered through the Program. ECF\nNo. 108 at 6. The conditions that\nproposes are appropriate in this case and will not\nlegally prejudice Maxwell whatsoever, and Maxwell cannot impose additional conditions on\ndismissal if\ndoes not agree to those conditions.\nI.\n\nMaxwell Will Not Be Prejudiced by Dismissal Pursuant to\nConditions.\n\nProposed\n\nMaxwell objects to dismissal of\nclaims with each party to bear its own fees\nclaims against her are \"frivolous.\" But Maxwell\nand costs because she contends that\nhas to date (after submitting three letters on this issue) not cited any authority for her argument\nthat she would be entitled to collect fees and costs from\nAlthough courts periodically award fees and costs wh\n... [truncated, 3615 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02778303/2 or ?id=EFTA02778303&page=2]", "char_count": 3615}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02778303", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF\n\nDocument 115\n\nFiled 01/21/21\n\nPage 4 of 7\n\nThe Honorable Lorna G. Schofield\nJanuary 21, 2021\nPage 4 of 7\ndismissed with prejudice, fees \"have almost never been awarded\" because \"the defendant, unlike\na defendant against whom a claim has been dismissed without prejudice, has been freed of the risk\nof relitigation of the issues just as if the case had been adjudicated in his favor after a trial, in which\nevent (absent statutory authorization) the American Rule would preclude such an award\").\nAnd even in cases where plaintiffs move for voluntary dismissal without prejudice,\n\"[c]ourts within this circuit have refused to award fees and costs following a Rule 41(a)(2)\ndismissal absent circumstances evincing bad faith or vexatiousness on the part of the plaintiff.\"\nBD ex rel. Jean Doe v. DeBuono, 193 F.R.D. 117, 125 (S.D.N.Y. 2000) (declining to award fees\ndismissal without prejudice absent showing of bad faith or vexatiousness); see also, e.g.,\nv. Brooklyn Indus. LLC, No. 13 Civ. 3695, 2015 WL 1726489, at *3 (S.D.N.Y. Apr. 15,\n2015) (same); Ogden Power Dev.-Cayman, Inc. v. PM!? Co., No. 14 Civ. 8169, 2015 WL 2414581,\nat *9-10 (S.D.N.Y. May 21, 2015) (same). Maxwell has not inted to any such bad faith or\nvexatiousness here, aside from her unremarkable contention that\nclaims are meritless\n(as the vast majority of defendants accused of sexual assault contend). Thus, Maxwell would not\nbe entitled to fees and costs even if\nwere seeking to dismiss this case without prejudice.\nrecognizes that this is not the forum in which to litigate whether her claims are\n\"frivolous,\" but briefly highlights several facts that directly refute Maxwell's characterization of\nher claims as such. First, Maxwell has been indicted for the very conduct described in the\nComplaint\nis one of the minor victims in the Government's July 2020 Indictment of\nMaxwell. Second, this Court rejected the notion that\nclaims are frivolous at the premotion conference held on Maxwell's anticip\n... [truncated, 3930 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02778303/3 or ?id=EFTA02778303&page=3]", "char_count": 3930}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02778303", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF\n\nDocument 115\n\nFiled 01/21/21\n\nPage 5 of 7\n\nThe Honorable Lorna G. Schofield\nJanuary 21, 2021\nPage 5 of 7\nMaxwell and it is not her burden to otherwise provide Maxwell with a forum in which Maxwell\ncan test\nallegations.3\nMaxwell has failed to demonstrate any substantial, legal prejudice that she would face if\nhas proposed: with prejudice and with\nthis case were dismissed on the conditions that\neach party to bear its own fees and costs.\nII.\n\nMaxwell's Request that the Court Require\nto Disclose Confidential\nInformation About\nCompensation Offer is Improper.\n\nIn Maxwell's res nse to Judge Freeman's Order to Show Cause, she asked the Court not\nonly to strike from\nproposed order of dismissal \"any reference to each party to bear\nits own costs and attorneys' fees,\" but also asked the Court to \"[r]equire that plaintiff disclose the\nsubstantial sum of money that she expects to receive\" from the Program. ECF No. 108 at 5-6.\nBut Maxwell cannot, under Rule 41(a)(2), propose her own conditions for the Court to impose in\ndismissing this case. As the Second Circuit has held:\n[Rule 41(a)(2)] empowers the district court to either dismiss the case on its own\nterms or to deny a requested dismissal, if those terms are not met. But acceptance\nof the court's terms, like the motion to dismiss itself, must be voluntary. . .. [W]hen\na plaintiff files a motion for dismissal under Rule 41(a)(2), it takes on the risk that\nits motion will be denied, not that the motion will carry additional consequences to\nwhich the plaintiff does not consent. Like our sister Circuits, we emphasize that it\nis the plaintiff, rather than the court, who has the choice between accepting the\nconditions and obtaining dismissal and, if [she] feels that the conditions are too\nburdensome, withdrawing [her] dismissal motion and proceeding with the case on\nthe merits.\nPaysys Intl, Inc. v. Atos IT Servs. Ltd., 901 F.3d 105, 108-09 (2d Cr. 2018) (internal citations\nomitted). Thus, the Court should \n... [truncated, 3216 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02778303/4 or ?id=EFTA02778303&page=4]", "char_count": 3216}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02778303", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF\n\nDocument 115\n\nFiled 01/21/21\n\nPage 6 of 7\n\nThe Honorable Lorna G. Schofield\nJanuary 21, 2021\nPage 6 of 7\nwould eviscerate the confidentiality promised to victims who chose to participate in the Program,\nand would deter continued participation in the Program.\nDuring the conference before this Court, Maxwell's counsel stated that she has been\n\"unable to find any precedent for refusing to provide a release to the purportedly released party.\"\nShe has repeatedly made similar statements in letter briefing on this issue. See ECF No. 103 at 2.\nBut this argument is misleading, as it mischaracterizes what\nhas agreed to provide\nMaxwell.\nhas at least twice offered Maxwell a copy of the executed General Release,\nand in fact will still agree to including a provision in an order of dismissal that would provide for\nMaxwell receiving a copy of the executed General Release (as reflected in the proposed order\nattached hereto . Maxwell would have the terms of the General Release. Maxwell would know\nexactly who\nhas released, and from what claims she has released them.5 The only\ninformation\nhas refused to provide Maxwell is the amount of compensation she would\nreceive once this case is dismissed. It is, in fact, Maxwell who has cited no legal precedent for her\nposition: that a party who is not a party to a settlement agreement, and is not contributing any\nmoney or other consideration to that settlement, is entitled to know the settlement amount.\nThe only alle ed reudice Maxwell points to based on not knowin the amount of\ncorn s nsation that\nhas been offered is that Maxwell seeks to use\nduring her criminal trial. But, as this Court recognized, Maxwell's attempt to\nimpede settlement of this action to serve her interests in a separate criminal action is inappropriate.\nIf Maxwell contends that\ncompensation offer is relevant and admissible evidence in\nher criminal action (which\ntakes no position on at this time), she can attempt to obtain\nthat information through t\n... [truncated, 2838 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02778303/5 or ?id=EFTA02778303&page=5]", "char_count": 2838}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02778303", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF\n\nDocument 115\n\nFiled 01/21/21\n\nPage 7 of 7\n\nThe Honorable Loma G. Schofield\nJanuary 21, 2021\nPage 7 of 7\nAndrew Villacastin\nSabina Mariella\nBOIES SCHILLER FLEXNER LLP\n55 Hudson Yards\nNew York, NY 10001\n(212) 446-2300\n\ncc: Counsel of Record (via ECF)\n\nCounselfor Plaints\n\nEFTA02778309\n\n", "char_count": 312}]}