{"efta_number": "EFTA02778283", "page_count": 12, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02778283", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02778283.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02778283", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF\n\nDocument 112\n\nFiled 01/19/21\n\nPage 1 of 12\n\nI.\n\nL1E1FARC\n\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK\nx\n\nPlaintiff,\nv.\n\n5\n6\n\n19 Civ. 10475 (LGS)\n\nDARREN K. INDYKE, RICHARD D.\nKAHN, GHISLAINE MAXWELL,\n\n7\nDefendants.\n\nPremotion Conference\n(Via Teleconference)\n\n8\nx\n9\n\nJanuary 14, 2021\n10:39 a.m.\n\n10\nBefore:\n11\nHON. LORNA G. SCHOFIELD,\n12\nDistrict Judge\n13\nAPPEARANCES\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n\nBOIES, SCHILLER & FLEXNER LLP\nAttorneys for Plaintiff\nBY: SIGRID S. McCAWLEY, ESQ.\nANDREW VILLACASTIN, ESQ.\nTROUTMAN PEPPER\nSANDERS LLP\nAttorneys for Defendants Indyke, Kahn\nBY: BENNET J. MOSKOWITZ, ESQ.\nHADDON,\nAND\nP.C.\nAttorneys for Defendant Maxwell\nBY: LAURA A. MENNINGER, ESQ.\n\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.••\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02778283\n\n", "char_count": 797}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02778283", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF\n\nDocument 112\n\nFiled 01/19/21\n\nPage 2 of 12\n\n2\n\nL1E1FARC\n(Case called)\nTHE DEPUTY CLERK:\n\nBefore we begin, I'd like to remind\n\nthe parties and the press that recording or rebroadcasting of\n4\n\nthis proceeding is prohibited.\n\n5\n\nmay result in sanctions.\n\n6\n\nViolation of this prohibition\n\nCounsel's appearances have been noted for the record.\n\n7\n\nI'm just going to ask counsel to state your name before you\n\n8\n\nspeak each time you speak, as we have a court reporter present.\n\n9\n\nWe're here before the Honorable Lorna G. Schofield.\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo good morning again, everyone.\n\nBefore\n\n11\n\nwe get started, I wanted to make full disclosure.\n\n12\n\nif I did this on the one other occasion we met.\n\n13\n\ndocket, I realized that one of the plaintiff's lawyers is a\n\n14\n\nformer law clerk of mine, Mr. Villacastin.\n\nHe clerked for me\n\n15\n\nfor a year beginning in the fall of 2015.\n\nWe're still in\n\n16\n\ntouch, as is the case with many of my former law clerks.\n\n17\n\nappearance, as you know, is as one of several lawyers from the\n\n18\n\nBoies Schiller firm, which is representing plaintiff, and his\n\n19\n\nappearance here is not grounds for recusal and also will not\n\n20\n\naffect my adjudication of the case.\n\n21\n\nunderstand Ms. McCawley is speaking today on behalf of\n\n22\n\nplaintiff.\n\n23\n\nI'm not sure\n\nLooking at the\n\nHis\n\nI would also note that I\n\nSo I wanted to turn to the possible motion here.\n\nThe\n\n24\n\nway this started out is that plaintiff seeks to dismiss the\n\n25\n\ncase under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 41(a)(1)(A)(ii),\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.••\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02778284\n\n", "char_count": 1614}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02778283", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF\n\nDocument 112\n\nFiled 01/19/21\n\nPage 3 of 12\n\n3\n\nL1E1FARC\nmeaning pursuant to stipulation.\n\nBut Ms. Maxwell does not\n\nconsent absent certain conditions, which, as I understand it,\nthe plaintiff refuses.\n4\n\nAnd so I'll hear from the parties in just a moment,\n\n5\n\nbut what I would like to observe is that it seems to me that\n\n6\n\ndismissal under that provision is probably not appropriate\n\n7\n\nbecause there is no agreement between the parties to dismiss,\n\n8\n\nand it may be more appropriate for us to proceed construing\n\n9\n\nthis as plaintiff's motion to dismiss pursuant to\n\n10\n\nRule 41(a)(2), the other subsection, which is pursuant to a\n\n11\n\ncourt order.\n\n12\n\nunderstand the plaintiff simply wants to be able to execute on\n\n13\n\nand collect on the settlement with the Epstein estate, and she\n\n14\n\ncan't do that until this case, I gather, is dismissed.\n\n15\n\ncan correct me if I'm wrong after I hear from Ms. Maxwell.\n\n16\n\ncounsel?\n\nAnd so let me hear from Ms. Maxwell.\n\nI\n\nBut you\nSo\n\nMs. Menninger?\n\n17\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\n18\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n19\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nGood morning, your Honor.\n\nGood morning.\nI think that's correct, your Honor.\n\n20\n\nWe have not been able to reach an agreement to stipulate to a\n\n21\n\ndismissal.\n\n22\n\nplaintiff would be intending to move under 41(a)(2) for\n\n23\n\ndismissal by court order.\n\n24\n\nto the Court to order dismissal on any terms that the Court\n\n25\n\nconsiders proper or just, and we have set forth the terms that\n\nAnd so I think at this point it appears that\n\nPursuant to that provision, it is up\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.••\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02778285\n\n", "char_count": 1615}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02778283", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF\n\nDocument 112\n\nFiled 01/19/21\n\nPage 4 of 12\n\n4\n\nL1E1FARC\nwe think, if a motion under Rule 41(a)(2) is brought or an\norder by the Court is entered, should include striking the\nportion where each party should bear its own costs and fees and\n4\n\nalso requiring that plaintiff disclose to Ms. Maxwell, as she\n\n5\n\nand the estate defendants all have, a copy of her signed\n\n6\n\nrelease, unredacted, authentic, for use in any future court\n\n7\n\nproceedings.\n\n8\n\nand proper, as we were unable to find any precedent for\n\n9\n\nrefusing to provide a release to the purportedly released\n\n10\n\nparty.\n\n11\n\nonly to pay for her own fees and costs in this case, which\n\n12\n\nincluded, I might add, discovery that plaintiff pressed to\n\n13\n\noccur early on in the case -- responses to document requests,\n\n14\n\ninterrogatories and the like -- but she also filed a motion to\n\n15\n\ndismiss, as your Honor is aware.\n\n16\n\na stipulated dismissal, we think an order by this Court under\n\n17\n\n41(a)(2) should include both of those provisions.\n\n18\n19\n\nThose are the terms that we submit would be just\n\nAnd we think the -- Ms. Maxwell has been forced not\n\nSo unless we're able to reach\n\nWe are prepared to submit full briefing on this topic,\nyour Honor.\n\n20\n\nI did bring to the Court's attention in my\n\n21\n\nDecember 23rd letter, I think it was -- sorry, December 30th\n\n22\n\nletter -- that we had a similar proceeding in front of Judge\n\n23\n\nKoeltl recently.\n\n24\n\nreach a stipulation.\n\n25\n\nto do so in that case, but in the absence of such a\n\nHe asked the parties to go back and try to\nI don't know yet whether we will be able\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.••\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02778286\n\n", "char_count": 1676}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02778283", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF\n\nDocument 112\n\nFiled 01/19/21\n\nPage 5 of 12\n\n5\n\nL1E1FARC\nstipulation, he's asking for briefing from the parties to\ncommence on January 15th.\nTHE COURT:\n4\n\nCould I just interrupt you for a second.\n\nThere are a couple things I wanted to follow up on\n\n5\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n7\n\nI also had requested\n\nSure.\n\n-- and I don't want to get too far in our\n\ndiscussion before I ask you about them.\n\n8\n\nFirst of all, it seems to me a little bit of a moving\n\n9\n\ntarget as to what you're actually asking for.\n\nFirst, in your\n\n10\n\noriginal request, you asked that you be provided with a copy of\n\n11\n\nthe signed and executed release, and as I understand it, the\n\n12\n\nplaintiff had agreed to provide that but simply with the dollar\n\n13\n\namount of the settlement redacted.\n\n14\n\nthe discussion at great length in your letter is that that was\n\n15\n\nunacceptable because what you were very much interested in was\n\n16\n\nthe dollar amount, and it wasn't just a matter of having an\n\n17\n\nauthentic release because, as Judge Freeman pointed out, you\n\n18\n\ncould simply put the release language in another document, have\n\n19\n\nthat signed, and you would have an authentic ink copy, if\n\n20\n\nnecessary, of the release.\n\n21\n\nreally trying to get at is the dollar amount here.\n\n22\n\nunderstand why you might be interested in that, particularly\n\n23\n\nfor the criminal action, but I'm not sure why it's appropriate\n\n24\n\nto hold up the settlement here to serve an interest in another\n\n25\n\ncase.\n\nAnd what I understood from\n\nSo it seems to me that what you're\nI\n\nSo do you want to address that first.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.••\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02778287\n\n", "char_count": 1665}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02778283", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF\n\nDocument 112\n\nFiled 01/19/21\n\nPage 6 of 12\n\n6\n\nL1E1FARC\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nCertainly, your Honor.\n\nI think it has\n\nbeen plaintiff herself who has long taken the position that\neverything related to her and this case is a matter of public\n4\n\ninterest.\n\n5\n\njustification for keeping the amount of the settlement secret\n\n6\n\nwhen she's the one who has, for example, gone on Netflix and to\n\n7\n\nThe New York Times, etc., with her story, and then now is\n\n8\n\nasking to keep the fact that she's receiving sums of money -- I\n\n9\n\ndon't know the amount, but I imagine substantial sums of\n\n10\n\nmoney\n\n11\n\nAnd I think there has not been sufficient\n\nfrom the estate secret from the public.\nSo yes, your Honor, you are correct that at the outset\n\n12\n\nwe would have agreed to a stipulated dismissal with just the\n\n13\n\nexecuted, unredacted, signed release, but if we're not able to\n\n14\n\nreach that as a matter of agreement, then it's our position, in\n\n15\n\nasking this Court under Rule 41(a)(2) for terms, that the\n\n16\n\namount should be public and should be available not just to\n\n17\n\nMs. Maxwell, who's the purportedly released party, but also to\n\n18\n\nthe press, who has shown great interest in plaintiff's story.\n\n19\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\nSo I understand your position\n\nthere.\n\n21\n\nThe other issue or matter that was a condition is you\n\n22\n\nwanted to strike the provision that said that each party would\n\n23\n\nbear its own costs and fees, and as I understand it, the\n\n24\n\ncounsel for the estate as well as counsel for plaintiff in this\n\n25\n\ncase had agreed to certain language preserving your ability to\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.••\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02778288\n\n", "char_count": 1678}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02778283", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF\n\nDocument 112\n\nFiled 01/19/21\n\nPage 7 of 12\n\n7\n\nL1E1FARC\nseek indemnification from Mr. Indyke and Richard Kahn, who are\nthe executors of the Epstein estate, and so it strikes me that\nthat is no longer an issue; is that correct?\n4\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nYour Honor, again, we would have\n\n5\n\nsigned a stipulated dismissal with that language in exchange\n\n6\n\nfor the other terms that we were seeking.\n\n7\n\npractical matter, more likely that if your Honor orders\n\n8\n\ndismissal under 41(a)(2) that we will pursue simply our\n\n9\n\nindemnification request that is the subject of a, you know,\n\n10\n\nlawsuit that has been filed in the Virgin Islands from the\n\n11\n\nestate.\n\n12\n\nand costs against her, and we are not in agreement to do that.\n\n13\n\nIf the Court orders it, then the Court orders it.\n\n14\n\nto me that to the extent there are perhaps somewhat limited\n\n15\n\navenues for seeking fees and costs from plaintiff herself for\n\n16\n\nchoosing to bring this lawsuit against Ms. Maxwell, we don't\n\n17\n\nsee a reason why we should be precluded from doing so.\n\n18\n\nIt is, as a\n\nBut plaintiff is asking us to agree not to seek fees\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nBut it seems\n\nWell, so let me just preface that by\n\n19\n\nsaying that I think your legal position is not as strong as the\n\n20\n\nvery substantial demands you are making suggest.\n\n21\n\nprejudging this, but I did take a look at the applicable law\n\n22\n\nlast night, and I did see that courts have generally subjected\n\n23\n\nmotions for voluntary dismissal, with prejudice, to far less\n\n24\n\nscrutiny than motions for voluntary dismissal without\n\n25\n\nprejudice, and the reason is obvious, and that is that the case\n\nI'm not\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.••\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02778289\n\n", "char_count": 1722}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02778283", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF\n\nDocument 112\n\nFiled 01/19/21\n\nPage 8 of 12\n\n8\n\nL1E1FARC\nwill go away with finality and cannot be alleged, or the same\nclaims cannot be brought in some other court, and so for that\nreason, there simply isn't as in-depth an inquiry as you might\n4\n5\n\nhave when the dismissal is without prejudice.\nFurthermore, it seems to me that under the law, the\n\n6\n\nquestion is, here, if it were simply a motion for a court order\n\n7\n\ndismissing the case coming from the plaintiff, the question\n\n8\n\nwould be, what is the prejudice to the defendant from the\n\n9\n\ndismissal of the case, and what we're talking about here is\n\n10\n\nlegal prejudice.\n\n11\n\nWhat is the legal prejudice your client suffers that flows from\n\n12\n\nthe dismissal of this case?\n\n13\n\nSo my question to you, Ms. Menninger, is:\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nOne, your Honor, she's had to expend\n\n14\n\nfees and costs to get to this point, and some of it was in what\n\n15\n\nwe believe were frivolously opposed motions -- for example, our\n\n16\n\noriginal motion to stay discovery.\n\n17\n\nknow, her having to incur tens of thousands of dollars to\n\n18\n\ndefend herself against this is prejudicial, and for her to be\n\n19\n\nasked to bear those costs and not obtain any relief at the\n\n20\n\nconclusion of the case is one.\n\n21\n\nAnd we think that, you\n\nSecondly, and with all candor, it precludes us from\n\n22\n\ntaking discovery from plaintiff, and so we would otherwise, in\n\n23\n\na civil suit, have the ability to clear Ms. Maxwell's name in\n\n24\n\nthis civil suit by confirming what we already suspect, which is\n\n25\n\nthat plaintiff does not have information concerning Ms. Maxwell\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.••\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02778290\n\n", "char_count": 1686}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02778283", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF\n\nDocument 112\n\nFiled 01/19/21\n\nPage 9 of 12\n\n9\n\nL1E1FARC\nto back up her claims and she would be vindicated at the\nconclusion of that civil case with, you know, a public airing\nof\n4\n\nfalse claims against her.\nTHE COURT:\n\nWell, I guess my reaction to that is that\n\n5\n\nhaving to incur expenses in litigation is the way the American\n\n6\n\nsystem works, and it's only in the exceptional case when there\n\n7\n\nis explicit authorization for fee shifting that that is not the\n\n8\n\ncase.\n\n9\n\nAnd then with respect to discovery, discovery is\n\n10\n\nsupposed to be in aid of claims, and there's no right to\n\n11\n\ndiscovery if there are no claims.\n\n12\n\npersuaded, but I know I in some way put you on the spot by\n\n13\n\nasking you this question, so here's the way I would like to\n\n14\n\nproceed.\n\n15\n\nmaybe I should hear from the plaintiff, because I haven't given\n\n16\n\nyou a chance to say anything at all.\n\nSo I guess I'm not\n\nWhat I would like is, I would like -- well, first,\n\n17\n\nSo Ms. McCawley, could I hear from you, please.\n\n18\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\n19\n\nJust to highlight a few points that you raised to make\n\n20\n\nsure that the procedural background is well known, and that is,\n\n21\n\nobviously, you know, we initiated this case, and we were\n\n22\n\nreferred by you to Magistrate Freeman, and there has been\n\n23\n\nsignificant letter practice, as you've seen, in front of her,\n\n24\n\nas well as a very fulsome hearing, at which time Maxwell said\n\n25\n\nthat the two items that she needed was the authentication, a\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.••\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02778291\n\n", "char_count": 1592}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02778283", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF\n\nDocument 112\n\nFiled 01/19/21\n\nPage 10 of 12\n\n10\n\nL1E1FARC\nstatement from us authenticating the document, and then the\nagreement, the release, which Judge Freeman had said we would\nbe allowed to redact that amount.\n\nWhen we tried to follow up\n\n4\n\nwith both of those things, that didn't happen, and then she\n\n5\n\nissued her order to show cause, which now brings us here.\n\n6\n\nSo just to highlight a couple other points,\n\n7\n\nMs. Maxwell has raised the issue of fees and costs.\n\n8\n\nHonor well cited, the Colombrito v. Kelly case, which is the\n\n9\n\nSecond Circuit case, makes very clear that under the rule of\n\n10\n\ndismissal with prejudice, that attorney's fees are almost\n\n11\n\n\"never awarded\" in that instance.\n\n12\n\nprotection of seeking indemnification for her fees and costs\n\n13\n\nfrom the estate, and in the proposed order that we submitted to\n\n14\n\nJudge Freeman, it sets forth that agreement that the estate\n\n15\n\nagreed to where that issue is still left open, and Ms. Maxwell\n\n16\n\nhas that means to seek that, as well as the stipulation with\n\n17\n\nrespect to us providing the general release with only the\n\n18\n\namount redacted and the authentication of that release, which\n\n19\n\nwe agreed to.\n\n20\n\nAs your\n\nAs well, Ms. Maxwell has the\n\nSo your Honor, I don't see an issue for this being\n\n21\n\nheld up any further.\n\n22\n\nOctober 14th, initially, and we're now in January, and we would\n\n23\n\nhope that the Court would allow us to move this forward to\n\n24\n\nconclusion.\n\n25\n\nWe sought this dismissal back on\n\nThank you.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\nSo let me just make one comment\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.••\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02778292\n\n", "char_count": 1655}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02778283", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF\n\nDocument 112\n\nFiled 01/19/21\n\nPage 11 of 12\n\n11\n\nL1E1FARC\nabout a motion under Rule 41(a)(2).\n\nAnd you may know this, or\n\nwould you know it, and that is that there's a relatively recent\nSecond Circuit case that says that basically the Court rules on\n4\n\nthe terms of dismissal as presented and doesn't have the\n\n5\n\nauthority to force the parties to accept other terms, that the\n\n6\n\nCourt could simply accept it and grant the dismissal or deny\n\n7\n\nit.\n\n8\n\nXY reason and therefore, if you change it, I would grant it.\n\n9\n\nBut I don't have the power to simply impose conditions.\n\nOf course, in denying it, I could say I'm denying it for\n\n10\n\nI would also say that if your latest offer, as you\n\n11\n\njust described it, is what you would propose as the terms of\n\n12\n\ndismissal, I suggest you just make that very clear and attach\n\n13\n\ncopies of anything that you would be proposing to your motion.\n\n14\n\nI am aware that this has been held up for some time,\n\n15\n\nso what I would like to do is I will take simultaneous letters\n\n16\n\nfrom the parties in five days, and that is plaintiff's motion\n\n17\n\nto dismiss pursuant to Rule 41(a)(2), in other words, pursuant\n\n18\n\nto court order, not pursuant to stipulation.\n\n19\n\neverybody knows what the issues are.\n\n20\n\nhearing from Ms. Maxwell's counsel what the legal prejudice is\n\n21\n\nthat would be suffered, with case citations as to why that's\n\n22\n\nappropriate, and I would also appreciate, of course, case law\n\n23\n\ncitations from the party seeking dismissal.\n\n24\n\nI'll issue an order today that makes clear what I'm asking for,\n\n25\n\nbut I think it's relatively clear now.\n\nI think that\n\nSo I would look to\n\nSo let's do that.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.••\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02778293\n\n", "char_count": 1754}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02778283", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF\n\nDocument 112\n\nFiled 01/19/21\n\nPage 12 of 12\n\n12\n\nL1E1FARC\n\nAnd if there's nothing else, I think we're finished.\nIs there anything else from Ms. Maxwell?\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nNo.\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\nIt's\n\nclear.\nTHE COURT:\nI\n7\n8\n9\n10\n\nOkay.\n\nII. McCAWLEY:\n\nNo.\n\nAnd anything else from\nThank you, your Honor.\n\nWe\n\nappreciate it.\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\nThank you, counsel.\n\nThis matter is\n\nadjourned.\noOo\n\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.••\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02778294\n\n", "char_count": 539}]}