{"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_count": 30, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02769339", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02769339.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE\n15th JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN AND\nFOR PALM BEACH COUNTY,\nFLORIDA\nComplex Litigation, Ha. R. Civ. Pro.120I\n\nJEFFREY EPSTEIN,\n\nCase No. 50 2009CA040800XXXXMB AG\n\nPlaintiff,\nv.\n\nP•4\n0\n\nJ.\n\nTHSTEIN, individually,\nindividually, and L.M.,\n\nrrl\nCu\n\nDefendants.\n\nCO\n\nAMENDED AND SUPPLEMENTAL\nMOTION OF PLAINTIFF TO OVERRULE OBJECTIONS AND)\nCOMPEL DEFENDANT\nTO ANSWER QUESTIONS\nAND APPEAR FOR FURk RER DEPOSITION\nPlaintiff Jeffrey Epstein (\"Epstein\") t Soct\nom ourt, pursuant to Rule 1.380(a), Fla. R.\nCiv. P., for entry of an order directing\n\nml\n\nJ.\n\nfurther deposition before a court a\n\npecial\n\nand to respond to questions asked of\n\nhim at his deposition taken on\nappropriate. This motior\n2010 seeking the\n1.\nRothst\n\n'\n\n(\"\n\n) to appear for\n\narch 3, 2010 and to answer such follow up questions as are\n\naddition to and supplements a previously filed motion on May 10,\n\nlar re ef. The grounds for this motion are:\nast year, Epstein filed this action to recover damages from Defendants, Scott\n\nstein\") and a,\n\nbased on Epstein's well founded belief that the two, and\n\npossibly others, had perpetrated an illegal pyramid scheme directed toward unwitting investors\nwho were defrauded into investing in settlements allegedly concerning Epstein as its centerpiece\ndefendant who reportedly had settled and was expected to settle cases worth millions of dollars\nwith clients of Rothstein Rosenfeldt & Adler (\"RRA\").\n\nEFTA02769339\n\n", "char_count": 1438}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "2.\n\nSpecifically, targets were told by Rothstein that\n\n- then a member of RRA\n\n- represented under-aged women who claimed that they had had intimate relationships with\nEpstein, a wealthy man, and that this conduct had resulted in felony convictions against Epstein\nand civil cases leading to multi-million dollar settlements and that numerous other such women\nhad sued or made demands of Epstein, who, the investors were told, would have little choice but to\nsettle by paying them large sums of money or be exposed to further criminal and\nThe scheme seems to have been based on the notion that tO\n\n3.\n\na lesser settlement if paid promptly and that the investors who funde\n\nese\n\ndin\n\narges.'\n\ns. would take\ny payments would\n\nbe paid when Epstein paid the greater amounts to settle these\n4.\n\nRothstein lured investors into turning ov\n\nothstein group approximately\n\n$13 million as investments into fabricated settlethen\\s,b using one or two real cases then\npending against Epstein that had been flied' by 1M.\n\nIn effect, Rothstein and his\n\nco-conspirators sought to trade on Epstein's perceived \"bad\" name in much the same way as\nunauthorized persons sometimes misrepresent their connections and trade on the \"good names\" of\n\\\n7\nothers.\nOn Mark/237 2010, counsel to Epstein deposed =.\n\n5.\nexamination,\n\nDuring that\n\nrefused to answer numerous questions to which he or his counsel Jack\n\nScarola °bleated. For example, he was asked generically about RBA's document storage system:\nCc„\n\nAnd what type of information did you put into Q-task regarding the claims against\n\nMr. Epstein?\n\nhad filed suits against Epstein on behalf of Jane Doe, L.M. and E.W. before joining\nRRA, but some months after he joined the firm, he filed a second suit, a federal court action, on behalf of\nL.M.\n2\n\nEFTA02769340\n\n", "char_count": 1792}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "MR. SCAROLA: We're going to object . . . I will instruct you not to answer on the\nbasis of both attorney-client and work-product privileges.\nId. at 54. This question in no way threatened either privilege and could have been answered\nwithout disclosing any client confidence, strategy or manner of handling the litigation.\ncounsel made it clear that his client would not answer any question when\n\n6.\n\ninstructed not to answer. Id. at 55, lines 4-8. Epstein's counsel then asked Edwards how he came\nto join RRA. His counsel - based on a \"privacy right\" that is not a recognize.d privilege - would not\npermit questions to be answered about the terms of\n\nhire by Roth.\n\ncompensation.\n\nRothstein:\n\nwas asked about his job interview wi\n\nQ.\n\nDid [Rothstein] ask you how much you w\n\nA.\n\nI believe so.\n\nQ.\n\nWhat did you tell him?\nMR. SCAROLA: Obj\n\nIns\n\n, including his\n\n?\n\nct you not to answer on the basis of economic\n\nprivacy.\n\nWhat did MASI him that you expected?\n\nQ.\n\nMR.NROLA: Objection, economic privacy.\nId. at 724-\n\n.O\nIII am interested now. . . [is] what you told him . . .\nMR. SCAROLA: Objection, economic privacy, instruct you not to answer. It's\n\nneither relevant nor material nor reasonably likely to lead to relevant material information\nand invades the economic privacy of the witness.\n3\n\nEFTA02769341\n\n", "char_count": 1309}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Id.\n\nQ.\nor\n\nAnd was the number that you gave him more than you had earned for the year 2008\n\nless?\nMR. SCAROLA: Same objection.\n\nQ.\n\nDid you tell him that you . . . wanted to make more money than you had in the\n\nproceeding year?\nMR. SCAROLA: Same objections and instructions.\nI\n\nId, at 72-74; see also id 73, lines 20-24.\n\nacknowledged that he was given yrnurtbefrbut was instructed on\n!)\nmultiple questions not to answer because the question was deemed tily his attorney to be irrelevant\n7.\n\nand invasive of\n\nprivacy rights. Id. at 7``3t Clearly, there was no basis for\n\nlawyer to direct\n\nnot to answer questiohNbo\n\nthe job offer he received from Rothstein.\n\nMoreover, relevancy is not a sufficient ground to silence a witness, especially in a case like this\nwhere incentives offered to\n\nand accepted by\n\nare plainly relevant to a\n\ndetermination of whether he was privy to the Rothstein Ponzi scheme and why he decided even to\njoin RRA. It is significantly relevant to his counterclaim since he is claiming loss of profits and\ninjury to his professional reputation.2\n8.\n\nthen proceeded not to answer at least sixteen other questions claiming\n\nattomey=client privileges. (Copies of the applicable transcript pages are attached hereto as Exhibit\n\nat the same time claim monetary damages\n2\ncannot reply on privilege to shield disco\nshould\nbe well versed on the Sword/Shield\nrelating to the subject of the privilege claim. At this point\nSo. 3d 855, 856 (Fla. 5th DCA 2009); BranDoctrine. See Boys and Girl's Club ofMarian County, Inc. v. A ,\ncaccio v. Mediplex Mandarin, Inc., 7l I So. 2d 1206, 1210 (Fla. 4ib DCA 1998) (\"the law is well settled that a plaintiff\nis not entitled to both his silence and his lawsuit\")\n\n4\n\nEFTA02769342\n\n", "char_count": 1732}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "attorney instructed him when\n\n1.) For example,\n\nwas asked how one plaintiff,\n\nE.W., came to contact referring attorney Howell. Id. at 89, lines 9-19. Edward's attorney told\nhim he could not even answer the threshold \"yes\" or \"no\" question: Did [Mr. Howell] ever relate\nthat to you.\" Id.\n9.\n\nin one instance when asked what his client E.W. told him o the phone,\n\nhimselfclaimed privilege. Id. at 90. Later, when asked \"for what purpo\noriginally hire you?,\" his attorney objected based on so-called atto\ncould have answered the question without disclosing infi\n\ns. L.M.\nege, although\ntended to be kept\n\nconfidential by his client L.M3 Id. at 99.\n10.\n\nMr. Scarola also erroneously counseled\n\nnot to answer a series of question\n\nabout his communications with federal prosecutors{\". .\\.do you know whether, at the time that\nyou represented Jane Doe. . . whether she was considered a victim by the U.S. Attorney's Office?\"\nand then re-phrased: \". . .[D]id you learn'whether [Jane Doe 1] was listed as a, or deemed to be a\nvictim by the U.S. Attorney's Officer 1d. at 100-104. Although contrary to law, Mr. Scarola's\nstated position was that any thing learned in the course of representation of a client is privileged,\nregardless of whether the'information came from the client or was in the nature of work product or\nsimply told to the client in a discussion about another case. He announced Iv* are not going to\ndiscuss anytl ng that Mr.\n\ndid in the course of the prosecution of his claims on behalf of\n\n'3‘facts are only protected by the attorney-client privilege if they arc intended by the client to be\nmaintained in confidence and are communicated by one seeking legal advice from the attorney to whom\nthe communication is made. Section 90.502\nFla. Stat.; Slate V. Rabin, 475 So. 2d 257, 260 (Fla. 3d\nDCA 1986); see Hoch v. Rissman, Weisberg,\n, 742 So. 2d 451 Fla. 5ih DCA 1999. Therefore, if\nto seek redress from Jeffrey\nthe answer was evident from the complaint eventually filed by\nEpstein\"), it wou\n... [truncated, 2204 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02769339/4 or ?id=EFTA02769339&page=4]", "char_count": 2204}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "his clients. Id. at 100-104. Conceding only that the court might give some instruction on how it\nwill interpret work product privilege \"in this context,\"\n\nlawyer asserted that questions\n\ninteraction with the U.S. Attorney's Office \"exert[ed] a chilling effect\" on the\n\nabout\n\nwork he continued to do for his three clients.4 Id. at 104.\n\nthrough counsel also raised\n\nrelevance which is not an objection that would support a directive not to answer at all. See, e.g.,\nid. at 105. This claim of privilege is also frivolous, because\n\nhas lfitea.adversary\n\nlawsuits against The United States of America for alleged violations of the Criminal Victims\nRights Act. 5\n11.\nby\n\nNext, Epstein's counsel asked about Rothstein) involverhent in the cases brought\nagainst Epstein.\n\ntestified that he bid fewer than three conversations with\n\nRothstein about the Epstein cases. Id. at 112-113. ,Edwards described one, after conferring with\nhis counsel to determine if it could be disci\n\nwas privileged, which was merely a passing\n\ncomment by Rothstein, \"I want you to\ncomment: \"did you get that Ping\n\nQ.\n\nophile.\" Id. at 114. The next was another such\net?\" Id. at 116. Counsel continued:\n\nDo you remember a third occasion that [Rothstein] spoke to you regarding\n\nEpstein related c\nA.\nattorney-c i\n\ning e se that he ever spoke with me about related to Epstein related issues is\nt an work-product privileged information that I am not going to divulge.\n\nId. at\nThe three cases referred to above have concluded as of this time and there seems to be no way\nnow former\ndisclosure about communications with government lawyers could adversely effect\nclients.\nS See Jane Does No. I andNo. 2, Petitioners v. United Stares ofAmerica, Respondent, Case No.\n08-CV-80736-CIV-Marra' United States District Court, Southern District Court of Florida.\n6\n\nEFTA02769344\n\n", "char_count": 1832}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Q.\n\nWhat was the legal issue [raised by Rothstein about Epstein]?\nMR. SCAROLA: Work product privilege.\n\nId. at 126-127.\nwrongfully claimed the work product privilege for these questions as well:\nWhat connection, if any, did Ghislaine Maxwell have to [your three clients]?\n\nQ.\n\nMR. SCAROLA: Objection, work product. Instruct you not to\nId. at 155.6\nWho did [Mike Fisten] go to California to interview?\n\nQ.\n\nMR. SCAROLA: That is work product and I ins/\n\nyou not to answer.\n\nId at 170.\nQ.\n\nDid Mr. Fisten interview a person ,t\nbb\n.,c\nMR. SCAROLA: That is wo\n\nAS\n\nQ.\n\nd I instruct you not to answer.\n\nDid Mr. Fisten interview\n\n*vi\n\nMR. SCAROLA:.\n\nproduct and I instruct you not to answer .. . any and\n\nall questions about investigativ\nId. at 170-171.\n\nQ.\n\nof Michael Sanka?\n\nWj\n\n1 by the name of Michael\n\nwill meet with the same objection and same instruction.\n\n\\,*\n\nvas the first investigator that you believe was involved in investigating the\nin cases? ...\n\n+MR.\n\nSCAROLA: Work-product, instruct you not to answer.\n\nId. at 179.\n6\n\nhad by this time already put considerable allegations concerning the answer to this\nquestion into the records. Obviously, his clients' interaction with Maxwell was not intended to be kept in\nconfidence.\n7\n\nEFTA02769345\n\n", "char_count": 1249}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Q.\n\nWho other than Mr. Fisten from an investigator, from an internal investigator at\n\nRRA employee worked on doing investigation on the Epstein files?\nMR. SCAROLA: Same objection [work product], same instruction.\nId. at 181.\nDid you ever tell them or direct [your investigators] to go through Mi r Epstein's\n\nQ.\ntrash?\n\nMR. SCAROLA: . . . Same objection [work-product, attorney-client privilege].\nId. at 185.\nDid you ever direct the investigators to go through the &ash of the lawyers who\n\nQ.\n\nwere representing Mr. Epstein including myself?\nMR. SCAROLA: Same objection\n\nt, attorney-client privilege].\n\nId. at 185-186.\nDid you ever direct thexiffifestiga\nS ors to, during the time you were at RRA, to\n-conduct a surveillance on\neth's property?\n\nQ.\n\nMR. SCAROLAt\nId at 186. [repeats simil\nQ.\n\nD.\n\ne objection [work-product, attorney-client privilege].\n\nons and same objections, p. 187].\n\nu authorize your investigators to hire . . . informants?\nCAROLA: Same objection [work-product, attorney-client privilege]\n\nAgeDid you authorize your investigators to do electronic eve's dropping [sic]\nMR. SCAROLA: Same objection [work-product, attorney-client privilege]\nId. at 192.\n\n8\n\nEFTA02769346\n\n", "char_count": 1188}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Q.\n\nDid you ever authorize any investigators to enter . . . Mr. Epstein's property on\n\nMarch 17, 2010?\nMR. SCAROLA: Objection . . .work-product privilege.\nId. at 198.\n\nQ.\n\nAre you aware of any investigators who entered Mr. Epstein's property on March\n\n17ih, 2010.\nMR. SCAROLA: Same objection as well as, attorney-client privilege. . . .\nId.\nQ.\n\n. . . did you authorize any investigators to trespass on Mr. Epstein's property on\n\nMarch 17ih of 2010?\nMR. SCAROLA: Same objection Work-product, attorney-client privilege] and\ninstruction.\nId. at 198-199.\nQ.\n\nDid you authorize investigators to hide in the bushes at Mr. Epstein's house in order\n\nto take photographs . . .?\nMR. SCAlr.\n\n• Same objection [work-product, attorney-client privilege] and\n\ninstruction.\nId. at 199,\n\n(S\ne\n1-12.\nregarding\n\nI Did he ever perform investigation work on any of the\n\nEpstein files?\nMR. SCAROLA: Same objection [work-product, attorney-client privilege] and\ninstruction.\n9\n\nEFTA02769347\n\n", "char_count": 968}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Id. at 200.\n[regarding investigator named \"Rick\"] . . . did you authorize Rick to perform any\n\nQ.\n\ninvestigation on the Epstein files?\nMR. SCAROLA: Same objection [work-product, attorney-client privilege] and\ninstruction.\nId at 200-201.\nWould it be a correct statement that you have never autho\n\nyone from Blue\n\nLine Research and Development, LLC, to conduct any inves gati\n\nJeffrey Epstein?\n\nQ.\n\nMR. SCAROLA: Same objection [work-prod\n\nomey-elient privilege].\n\nId, at 201.\n\nQ.\n\n[D]id you ever authorize or direct\n\n: Je\n\\$ e o perform any investigation on the\n\nEpstein files?\n( Sir\n\\ [work-product, attorney-client privilege] and\nMR. SCAROLA: Same 411jectio\ninstruction.\n12.\n\nCounsel to botliKparties agreed that\n\nwould identify investigators who\n\nworked at the direction of Edwards if the Court were to determine Epstein is entitled to this\ninformation. Id. at 202-203. Counsel to Epstein clarified that by moving on to other subject\nmatter, he was not sysiving his right to pursue inquiry about these individuals. Mr. Scarola agreed.\nId. at 203a4-16.\n13\n\nEpstein's counsel proceeded to other areas of inquiry. He asked if\n\nhad\n\never spoken to Alfredo Rodriguez during the hiatus between the deposition sessions with\nRodriguez. A claim of work product privilege was made. Id. At 205-206.\n\nrefused to\n\n10\n\nEFTA02769348\n\n", "char_count": 1320}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "answer any questions about his communications with Rodriguez. Id at 208-210. He similarly\nrefused to say if he was cooperating with any other lawyers. Id. at 223 (citing work product)\nHave you had any discussion with any of the other lawyers who represent clients in\n\nQ.\n\nthe . . . matters regarding Mr. Epstein's probation?\nMR. SCAROLA: Same objection (work-product, attorney-client privilege) and\ninstruction and joint prosecution interest.\nId. at 223\n14.\n\nThe court must overrule the foregoing objections rais\n\nbeiNuse 'many were never\n\nsought to discover privileged information and the privileges\n\nt absolute. In fact, the cases\n\nreferred to - - L.M., E.W. and Jane Doe - - have all been\n\nthere is no longer any basis to\n\nseek to protect most information gleaned in pr\"\nparticularly true given the allegations of thisc\nthe circumstances surrounding the Po\nresponses to information directed t\nA..\n15.\n\nS*\n\n.cover,\n\nthem as work product.\n\nThis is\n\neven where work product is raised,\n\nsche e perpetrated at the Rothstein firm require\ns and perpetrators.'\n\nA special masteishould preside at the further deposition of\n\nin order to rule\n\non objections and order answers where no valid objection is made and the Court or the designated\nshould (a) examine in camera any documents referred to by\n\nSpecial\n\nand which he\n\nclaims are work product to determine if they deserve protection from discovery in this case; and\n\\\\:\nj\n(b) taketektimony in camera on any question that\n\nrefuses to answer based on privilege.\n\nV\n\nand others\nThe sensational nature of the charges against Epstein in the cases brought by\nought not diminish the fact that Epstein was used as bait by Rothstein and others to entrap third parties\nseeking investments. In this, those investors as well as Epstein - all victims in this scenario - have a\ncompelling need to discover all of the evidence known to those who surrounded Rothstein and his cohorts.\n11\n\nEFTA02769349\n\n", "char_count": 1933}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "LEGAL MEMORANDUM\nA. Objections Based on the Attorney Client Privilege Generally Should Be\nOverruled\nand/or his counsel invoked a claim of attorney\n\nDuring his deposition,\n\nclient privilege more than 15 times in response to questions that seemingly cove\n\nbeen\n\nanswered without divulging confidential information obtained from clients t to t th time the\ninformation was given were seeking legal services from\n\ne.g., Deposition\n\nTranscript at 54, 89, 91, 98, 114, 116-117, 208; Exhibit A. In nearly\nthe questions outlined above,\n\nobjection should be\n\nto answer the questions. He can do this without disci\nThe attorney-client privilege applies\n\nv leged information.\n\n.5 , Fla. Stat.; Southern Bell Tel & Tel. Co. v.\n\nDeason, 632 So. 2d 1377 (Fla.1994).\n\nprovide legal services to the die\n\nd and he should be required\n\nCit9\\ id ntial communications made in the\n\nrendition of legal services to the client. Sect'\n\nprotects those confidential co\n\nn\n\nese, as evidenced by\n\n0.502 codifies the attorney-client privilege which\nns between attorney and client made to obtain or to\ntate v. Rabin, 495 So. 2d 257, 260 (Fla. 3d DCA 1986); see\n\nU.S.\nS. v. Kelly, 569 F. {vo\nd 928; 93 (5th Cir. 1978).\nIn ord\n(1) the asse\n\nin ke the attorney-client privilege, one must establish the following elements:\ner of the privilege is or sought to become a client; (2) the person to whom the\n\ncommunication was made (a) is a member of a bar of a court, or his subordinate, and (b) in\nconnection with this communication is acting as a lawyer; (3) the communication relates to a fact\nof which the attorney was informed (a) by his client (b) without the presence of strangers (c) for the\npurpose of securing primarily either (I) an opinion on law or (ii) legal services or (iii) assistance in\n12\n\nEFTA02769350\n\n", "char_count": 1781}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "some legal proceeding, and not (d) for the purpose of committing a crime or tort; and (4) the\nprivilege has been (a) claimed and (b) not waived by the client. In re Grand Jury Proceedings, 517\nF.2d 666, 670 (5th Cir. 1975), quoting United States v. United Shoe Machinery Corp., 89 F.Supp.\n357, 358-59 (D. Mass.1950). The burden of proof is in the first instance on the individual\nasserting the privilege to demonstrate an attorney-client relationship. C. McCormick Evidence, s\n88, p. 179 (Cleary ed. 1972).\n\n,\n\n'\nThe privilege does not apply to all communications between attorney and client. For\nexample, where a client shared confidential communications with ahiattorney to confer about his\nclient, her former husband, a client of that attorney, the confidential communications were not\nprivileged.\n\nState v. Rabin, 495 So. 2d 257, 260 (Fla. 3d•DCA 1986)(even if the giving of such\n\nadvice constitutes the rendering of legal services, it could irt serve as a basis for protecting\nearlier communications because those conununitationsIvere not made for the purpose of receiving\nsaid legal services). See Fisher v. U.S., 425 U.S. 391, 403 (attorney-client privilege \"protects only\nthose disclosures necessary to obt4 informed legal advice which might not have been made\ns k/ 7\"\nabsent the privilege\").\nMoreover, not all ccsnrnunications between attorney and client are privileged. For\nexample, in Kilbourne & Son v. Kilbourne, 677 So. 2d 855 (Fla 1st DCA 1995), the court held that\na worker's compensation attorney's advice given to a client that he was statutorily required to\nperform it -good faith job hunt in order to receive benefits for lost wages, was not a confidential\ncommunication within the ambit of the privilege; see also Watkins v. State, 516 So. 2d 1043 (Fla.\n1st DCA 1987), rev. denied, 523 So.2d 579 (Fla. 1988) (defendant's former attorney not barred\n\n13\n\nEFTA02769351\n\n", "char_count": 1888}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "from testifying at trial that he gave notice to client about the trial dates where defendant failed to\nappear).\nOnce a good faith claim of privilege is made, the burden shifts to the adverse party to\nshow that the communication was not privileged. Leithauser v.\n\n168 So. 2d 95 (Fla. 2d\n\nDCA 1964); see also Nationwide Mut. Fire Ins. Co. v. Harmon, 580 So. 2d 192, 192-93 (Fla. 4th\nDCA 1991) (\"[N]othing in the record indicates that any documents are protected by the\nattorney/client privilege. If petitioner thought some documents might be protected by either\nprivilege, it should have listed the specific documents to which it cld rted he privilege attaches.\nOtherwise, neither the trial court nor this court has anything\nprocedure is for the trial court to examine the dispute\ndocuments which fall into the privileged category.\n\nto address.\"). \"The proper\nis in-camera and remove those\n\nte arm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v. Kendrick,\n\n780 So. 2d 231, 233 (Fla. 3d DCA 2001)\n\nal court to order production of documents\n\nallegedly protected by attorney-clientp\n\nlege with instruction to counsel seeking discovery to\n\nr\nsee Parton v. Wiggs Contracting Co., Ltd., Inc., 698\ndecide whether the document waspi411f\\eged);\nSo. 2d 933, 934 (Fla. 4th DC\n\nI'L947) (error to deny motion for protective order concerning\n\n,\nsubpoena duces tecum seeking records on basis of attorney-client and work product privilege\n7\n\nwithout condu\nprivileges\n\ncamera inspection of items in question to determine whether claimed\nkorman v. Hovnanian of Florida, Inc., 382 So. 2d 1376, 1378-79 (Fla. 4th\n\nDCA 1981 h Use of an in camera examination also applies to testimony a witness seeks to protect\nas privileged. State v. Young, 654 So. 2d 962, 963 (Fla. 3d DCA 1995) (trial court properly\nconducted in camera hearing outside of the State's presence to determine whether testimony was\nprotected by attorney-client privilege).\n14\n\nEFTA02769352\n\n", "char_count": 1909}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Here,\n\ntestimony is required and a further deposition should be conducted\n\nbefore a judge or special\n\nso that privilege determinations can be made as required by\n\nFlorida law.\nB.\n\nThe Work Product Doctrine Does not Prevent\nQuestions at Deposition\n\nfrom Responding to\n\nalso claims that he could not respond to a host of questions at his deposition\n\n0\n.\n\nbecause to answer them would reveal work product. See, e.g., Deposition Tramcc\nr. t at 50, 54, 91,\n100-104, 114, 126,-127, 155, 170, 181, 184-187, 192, 198-202, 205-2 ,\n\n, 212, 215-217;\n\nExhibit I.\nForty years ago, the Florida Supreme Court, in Sur\n108, 112 (Fla. 1970), gave this general definition of w\\ k\n\nInc. v. Vermette, 236 So. 2d\nsaying what it is and what it is\n\nnot:\n[T]hose documents, picttc 4statments and diagrams which are to be\npresented as evidence are not wor products anticipated by the rule for\nexemption from discovery. Personal views of the attorney as to how and when\nto present evidence, his evaluation of its relative importance, his knowledge of\nwhich witness will give certain testimony, personal notes and records as to\nwitnesses, jurors, legal citations, proposed arguments, jury instructions,\ndiagrams and charts hemay refer to at trial for his own convenience, but not to\nbe used as evidence, come within the general category of work product.\nId. at 112 (emphasis added). The \"work product\" doctrine protects documents and papers\nof an attorney or a party prepared in anticipation of litigation, regardless of whether they pertain to\nconfidential -communications between attorney and client.\n\nFla.R.Civ.P. 1.280(6)(2).\n\nSee\n\nSouthern Bell Tel. & TeL Co. v. Deason, 632 So. 2d 1377 (Fla. 1994). The privilege may also\nprotect an attorney's mental impressions which may be disclosed through testimony.\n\nv.\n\nRamos, 796 So. 2d 1269, 1270 (Fla. 4th DCA 2001) (error to compel deposition answers over\n15\n\nEFTA02769353\n\n", "char_count": 1896}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "claim of fact and opinion work product without conducting an in camera hearing); State v. Rabin,\n475 So. 2d 257 (Fla. 3d DCA 1986).\nNotwithstanding the general rule, a party may obtain discovery of documents and tangible\nthings prepared in anticipation of litigation or for trial by another party ( i.e., \"fact\" work product)\nupon a showing of (a) need for the materials to prepare the party's case, and (b) inability to obtain\nthe substantial equivalent of such materials without undue hardship. Metric Engineering, Inc. v.\nSmall, 861 So. 2d 1248, 1250 (Fla. 1st DCA 2003) (to show 'need,' a party\nor evidence demonstrating that the requested material is critical to\n\na th\n\nnt testimony\nof his case, or to\n\nsome significant aspect of the case after which the trial court s\n\ncon uct an in camera review\n\nto evaluate whether the contested materials provide the\n\ndentiary value alleged by the\n\nrequesting party and determine whether the re\n\niii ite\nc\n\nerials are substantially similar to\n\nmaterials already available.)\n( S \\ o discovery upon a showing of \"need.\" Rule\nGenerally, fact work product irllibject\n1.280(b)(3), Florida Rules of Civil Prpeediire, provides for a limited privilege for \"fact\" work\nr-\\ /\nli\nproduct - factual information concerning\nthe client's case and prepared or gathered in connection\n_ 17\nwith its preparation. Wal-Mari Stores, Inc. v. Weeks, 696 So. 2d 855, 856 (Fla. 2d DCA 1997)\n(trial judge did not depart from essential requirements of by not protecting materials from\ndiscovery when plaintiff retailer presented no evidence to support its claim, but only made \"a\nblanket statement that the requested items were prepared in anticipation of litigation.\").\nOn the other hand, opinion work product is absolutely, or nearly absolutely, privileged.\nThe Rule requires courts to protect against disclosure respecting mental impressions, conclusions,\nopinions, or legal theories of an attorney ( i.e., \"opinion\" work product). The difference between\n16\n\nEFTA02769354\n\n", "char_count": 1991}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "the degrees of protection given oral and written statements is based partially upon this distinction\nbetween fact and opinion work product.\nWork product protection is limited to materials which are not intended to be used as\nevidence at trial. Northup v. Acken, 865 So. 2d 1267, 1270 (Fla. 2004) (\"when a party reasonably\nexpects or intends to utilize an item before the court at trial, for impeachment or otherwise, the\nA\n\n4\\\n\nvideo recording, document, exhibit, or other piece of evidence is fully discoverable' and is not\nprivileged work product.\"). In Northup, the court remarked that a litigant must decide whether\nthe material is going to be used only for strategy and trial preparation purposes prior to the entry of\na pretrial case management order by the trial court. If it is, the work product protection can\ncontinue. See also Gabriel v. Northern Trust Bank of Florida, NA., 890 So. 2d 517 (Fla. 4th\nDCA 2005) (request for production of documents that required party to produce all documents that\n24\n\\\n\"relate to or otherwise support\" each allegation-fin\\ the] complaint\" and required attorney to make a\ndetermination of relevance are protected`work product unless the attorney expects or intends\ndocuments to be used at trial.) On t/Cother hand, if the party reasonably expects or intends to use\nthe evidence at trial, for impeachment, or otherwise, the work product protection ceases and the\nmaterial must be identified and disclosed.)\nIf the co\n\netermines that a particular request or question calls for the disclosure of\n\nprotected wot product, before determining whether a requesting party has shown sufficient need\nand h\n\ntrial court must first decide whether the material involved was prepared in\n\nanticipation of litigation. Airocar, Inc. v.\n\n474 So. 2d 269, (Fla. 4th DCA1985) (citing\n\nCotton States Mutual Insurance Company v. Turtle ReefAssociates, Inc., 444 So. 2d 595 (Fla. 4th\n\n17\n\nEFTA02769355\n\n", "char_count": 1921}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "M,\n\nDCA 1984); Selected Risks Insurance Company v.\n\n447 So.2d 455 (Fla. 4th DCA\n\nI 984)(urging trial court to make findings on that issue).\nIf the requested material or information was prepared in anticipation of litigation and its\ndisclosure has not been waived, then the requestor must allege \"need and hardship\" in the motion\nto compel supported by evidence such as an affidavit to establish both. Whealton v. M rshall, 631\ne factual\n\nSo. 2d 323, 325 (Fla. 4th DCA 1994) (because motion \"contained no claim\ninformation in the memorandum is needed in the forthcoming evidenti\n\ng or that the\n\ninformation cannot be obtained from any other source without undgE hacrihip, the motion was\nfacially insufficient to compel production and should have bee\nIn this case, the questions that\n\nrefused t\n\nan y denied\").\nestions concern the handling\n\nof cases that are now resolved while he was at the RRA criminal enterprise. There is a split of\nauthority as to whether the work-product privilege extends beyond the case for which the work\nproduct was gathered. State v. Rabin, 495 So. 2d at 262; Alachua Gen. Hosp. v. Zimmer USA, Inc.,\n403 So. 2d 1087, 1088 (Fla. 1st D&O981) (privilege continues after case concludes); United\nStates v. International Business Machs. Corp., 66 F.R.D. 154, 178 (S.D.N.Y.I974) (privilege\napplies only if the work pyoduct was gathered in anticipation of the very case in which the\nprivilege is sought); Hanover Shoe, Inc. v. United Shoe Mach. Corp., 207 F.Supp. 407, 410 (M.D.\nPa.1962) (sarie); cf; Hercules Inc. v Exxon Corp., 434 F.Supp. 136, 153 (D.De1.1977) (privilege\nN —\nextends trkorily those subsequent cases which are closely related); Midland Inv. Co. v. Van Alstyne,\nNoel & Co., 59 F.R.D. 134 (S.D.N.Y.1973) (same). In this case, there is good cause to overrule the\nobjections bases on the work product doctrine and require\n\nto answer.\n\n18\n\nEFTA02769356\n\n", "char_count": 1886}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "The Rabin Case. One Florida court of appeal has carefully distinguished the difference\nbetween fact and opinion work product. In Rabin, the court of appeal concluded that the State\nwas entitled to all of the factual information which the witness M, the former wife of Rabin's\nclient, had transmitted to attorney Rabin during their conversation while Rabin was preparing her\nex-husband's case. Because\n\ndid not come to see Rabin to obtain legal advice, their\n\nconversation was not that of attorney and client and thus not privileged, so the substan'ce of her\nstatements was discoverable. In Rabin, the trial court had ordered that Ra\n\nt have to\n\nrespond to questioning regarding the initial conversation that took pla\n\nand him. On\n\npetition for writ of certiorari, the Third District concluded that t\nessential requirements of the law by directing that Rabin\n\nbet\n\nI court had departed from the\n\nec*a_ spond to questions about what\n\nsaid and that, because Rabin could have had no significant interest in the substance of\nstatements, the State should have been permitted to question Rabin regarding\ncommunications. The court clarified that Rabin did not need not to respond to questions\nconcerning his half of the conversationor to questions which would require him to reveal either his\nmental impressions of the conversation, or his conclusions, opinions, or theories drawn from the\nconversation -- he needed only to respond to questions concerning the content of\n5 So. 2d at 263-26, citing In re Grand Jury Subpoena Served upon Doe, 781\n\nstatements. R\n\nir.), cert. denied, 475 U.S. 1108 (1986Xattomeys are not exempted from duty\n\nF.2d 238,\nto ap\n\nve evidence before grand jury merely because they are attorneys).\nAs for the trial court's decision to require Rabin to produce documents relating to his\n\nconversation with\n\nother than his notes, the court of appeal found no departure from the\n\n19\n\nEFTA02769357\n\n", "char_count": 1910}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "essential requirements of law and that the State was entitled to Rabin's fact work product but not\nhis opinion work product. 495 So. 2d at 263.\nC.\n\nNo Objection Based on a Non-Existent Privilege Should be Sustained.\nalso raised something called economic privacy as a basis\n\nDuring his deposition,\n\nmay have som interest in\n\nnot to answer questions. See Transcript at 72-74. While\n\nkeeping his earnings to himself, in this case he has raised a Counterclaim\ndamages to his earnings due to the filing of this action. Moreover, w\n\neh\n\nsuffered\n\noffered and\nhis practice to RRA\n\nactually received while at RRA is relevant to explain how he came\n\nracy. Finally, even if these\n\nand what his motives may have been to assist Rothstein in\n\nlege and a confidentiality order\n\nfactors did not exist, there is no recognized economic p\n\np\n\nlimiting the use of compensation information to\n\nuld reasonably resolve any legitimate\n\nconcerns.\n\nin this case.\n\nis not entitled simply to\n\nCONCLUSION\nWHEREFORE, based on\nenter an order (I) appointing a special\n\nforigoing grounds, Jeffrey Epstein requests that the Court\nto consider objections of\n\nmade at\n\nhis deposition in March 2010 and overruling those that are unfounded, (2) directing Mr.\nto submit to a further deposition to answer questions he previously refused to answer and permit\nfollow up'sku\n\ns as counsel to Plaintiff deems appropriate, (3) examine in camera any\n\nx\ndocuments referred by\n\nin his claims of work product, and (4) awarding Epstein his\n\nreasonable expenses incurred in obtaining such order and such other relief as the Court deems\nproper.\n\n20\n\nEFTA02769358\n\n", "char_count": 1612}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\nI HEREBY CERTIFY that the foregoing Motion to Overrule Objections and Compel\nDefendant\nthis\n\nto Answer Questions and Appear for Further Deposition was served by mail\n\n3 rrday of February, 2011 on:\n\nA\n\nJack Scarola\nSearcy Denne\nrola Barnhart & Shipley\nAttorneysfor\nJ.\n2139 Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard\nWest Palm Beach, FL 33409\n\nCos\n\nMarc S. Nurik,\nLaw Offices of Marc S. Nurik\nAttorneysfor Scott Rothstein\nOne E. Broward Blvd., Ste 700\nFort Lauderdale, FL 33301\n\nckerman, Jr.\nar #235954\nKnight\nBar #607363\n\ns *rida\n)\nC\n\nBURNE'fT, PA\ns for Plaintiff\nPoint, West Tower\n777 South Flagler Drive, Suite 901 West Tower\nWest Palm Beach, FL 33401\n(561) 802-9044\n(561) 802-9976\n\nM\n\nw:%0743NIOTCompet.docc\n\n21\n\nEFTA02769359\n\n", "char_count": 736}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Epstein v. Rothstein, et al.\nCase No.: 50 2009CA040800XXXXMB AG\nDEPOSITION OF\n\nJ.\n\nPage/Line\n\nTestimony\n\n50/5-11\n\nQ. When I describe both the Jane Doe versus Jeffrey Epstein case/a4 the L.M.\nversus Jeffrey Epstein case being on Qtask, I don't necessarily mearijuist the\npleadings. I mean any aspect of it, not necessarily the pleadings or the fact that the\ncase was there but the factual circumstances surrounding either case.\n\n50/12-15\n\nA. I am not going to into what my work-product privilege, I am not going to\nallow you to pierce that privilege. I am not going to tell you what, regarding those\ncases, was or was not on Qtask.\n.7-----:\\\nv\nin‘to ,Qtask regarding the claims\nQ. And what type of information did youyptit :k.,\nagainst Mr. Epstein?\n\n54/9-10\n\n54/14-17\n\nA. SCAROLA: We're going to object and that I will instruct you not to answer\non the basis of both attorney-client and work-product privileges.\n'\n\n72/10-12\n\nQ. Did he ask you how muckyou were making at that time or how much you had\nmade the preceding year, k/8?\n\n72/13\n\nA. I believe so. (\nI,,N,,,_\n\n72/14\n\nQ. What did you tell him?\n\n72/15-16\n\nA. SCAROLA: Objection. Instruct you not to answer on the basis of economic\nprivacy.\n\n73/2\n\nQ. What did you tell him that you expected?\n\n73/3\n\nA. Objection, economic privacy.\n\n73/5-8\n\nQ. All I am interest now, not necessarily what you were earning but what you\ntold him, i.e., Mr. Rothstein that you wanted to get or expected to earn if\nconsidered a job at RRA.\n\nEXHIBIT \"A\"\n1\n\nEFTA02769360\n\n", "char_count": 1501}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "73/9 -14\n\nA. SCAROLA:Objection. Economic privacy, instruct you not to answer. It's\nneither relevant nor material nor reasonably likely to lead to relevant material\ninformation and invades the economic privacy of the witness.\n\n74/2-4\n\nQ. Did you tell him that you — did you tell him that you wnated to make more\nmoney than you had the proceeding year?\n\n74/5-6\n\nA. SCAROLA: Same objections and instructions.\n\n89/2-3\n\nQ. Why did E.W. come, why did she hire you in the first placChat as the\npurpose?\n—\n\n89/4-8\n\nA. This is going to get into attorney-client privileged information as to why she\nhired me which would incorporate the things that she told me that related to my\nrepresentation, therefore, I am invoking the privilege and not answering.\nI\nQ. What kind of - what has he [Mr. Howell] done?'\n\n90/25\n91/1-3\n\nA. SCAROLA: Objection. Attorney-client privilege and work-product. Instruct\nyou not to answer.\n\n98/22-23\n\nQ. And what, for what purpose did Ms. L.M. originally hire you?\n\n98/24-25\n\nA. SCAROLA: I am going to object. That calls for attorney-client privilege.\n/\n\\\nQ. At the time do you,know whether, at the time that you represented Jane Doe\n1, do you know Whether,h‘r name, whether she was considered a victim by the\nUnited States Anomey's Office?\n\n„7\n\n100/9-14\n\nA. SCAROLA; If that information you obtained in the course of the\nperformance of you responsibilities in representation of any client, I would\ninstruct you not to answer.\n\n100/15-23\n\nIf that information was obtained through some public source independent of\n\\ the work that you performed as counsel, then you may respond.\n\\\n100/25-101\n/1-12\n\nTHE WITNESS: I cannot respond.\nQ. With regard to the question, I am not interested in what you learned from\nE.W. All right. Did you learn from either any correspondence or a telephone call\nwith any third party that whether again prior to the - let me start again.\nEXHIBIT \"A\"\n2\n\nEFTA02769361\n\n", "char_count": 1906}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Prior to the filing of the lawsuit against Jane Doe 1 and Jane Doe 2 against\nthe United States Government, did you learn from any source, maybe a document,\nmaybe a telephone call or a conversation that you had with a third party separate\nfrom your client, that E.W. was a victim or was deemed to be a victim by the\nUnited States Government or the United States Attorney's Office?\nA. SCAROLA: Samc objection and instruction.\n101/16\n\nQ. Same question with regard to L.M.\n\n101/17-18\n\nA. SCAROLA: Same objection and instruction.\n\n101/20\n\nQ. And same question with regard to Jane Doe.\n\n101/21-22\n\nA. Same objection and instruction.\n\n101/24-25\n- 102/1-6\n\nitefl'States Government, did you\nQ. Prior to your filing the lawsuit with\nomey's Office-regarding the\never any conversations with the United Sst\nsubject of the lawsuit or Jeffrey EpsS t? „ ,\n\n102/7-8\n\nA. Same objection and instru\n\n102/24-25\n- 103/9-16\n\nQ. All right. Did you everipealc ith =Villafana during the pendency of\nthat litigation which instill pending today.—\nSCAROLA: Are-you asking whether such conversations occurred that were\nrelevant to his pivecution of the claims on behalf of his three clients?\n\nTHel: Sure.\nSCAROLA: Then the instruction remains the same. The objection remains the\n\n103/18-22\n\nQ. So, even if, do ou - even if you talked about it with Mrs. Villafana, even if\nspoke with Mrs. Villafana about a scheduling issue, it's\nyour client Mr.\nyour position that its what, work-product?\n\n103/23-25\n- 104/1\n\nA. SCAROLA: That's correct. We are not going to discuss anything that Mr.\ndid in the course of the prosecution of his claims on behalf of his clients.\nEXHIBIT \"A\"\n3\n\nEFTA02769362\n\n", "char_count": 1658}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "104/2-9\n\nany questions that I ask you with regard to conversations that Mr.\nhad with the USAO's office, whether it was Mrs. Villafana or anyone\nna to the Jane Doe 1 and Jane Doe 2 versus USA case,\nelse from the time, with sal\nyou would instruct Mr.\nnot to answer those questions?\n\n104/10104/14-25\n- 105/1-12\n\nA. SCAROLA That is correct. Obviously pending some instructions or\nguidance from the court with regard to how the court will interpret the\nsition that\nwork-product privilege in this context. I might also add that it is o\nthe\nwork\nthat\nMr.\ninquiry\nexerts\na\nchilling\neffect\nupon\nany such\ncontinues to do on behalf of his three clients.\nIt is intended to as a means to obtain discovery t oul , not othersie be\n• d embarrass Mr.\navailable in those pending claims. It intended to annoy\nEpstein in a lawsuit that has absolutely no foundation a ever, and was filed\n.\nfor purposes other than a legitimate claim agai\nbased upon any\nper or tortious conduct and\ngood faith belief that he engaged in any fo\n— those inquiries are not reasonably calc t t -, . to the discovery of\nse reasons we object.\nadmissible and relevant evidence. So foioc,\n\n114/11\n\nQ. What did he [Rothst\n\n114/12-19\n\nA. SCAROLA: T\nt that you can answer that question without\nions with regard to the lawsuit or any\ndisclosing any\ncommunications, you can answer. To the extent that it\nattorney-client vile\nmay invade eithe\nwork-product or attorney-client privilege, you should not\nrespond.\n\n116/21-23\n\nQ.\nre\n\n116/24-25\n- 117/1,..\n\n126/13\n\ny\n\nyou member a thrid occasion that he spoke to you regarding Epstein\nion, cases?\n\n. Anything else that he ever spoke with me about related to Epstein related\nissues\nis attorney-client and work-product privileged information that I'm not\nih\ngoing to divulge.\n\nQ. What was the legal issue?\n\nEXHIBIT \"A\"\n4\n\nEFTA02769363\n\n", "char_count": 1824}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "126/20 -25\n- 127/2-7\n\nA. SCAROLA: If this was an issue that was identified during the course of the\nlegal proceedings to opposing counsel, then I am going to allow you to identify\nthe issue without getting into any of the substance of the discussion regarding that\nissue.\nIf this was an issue that was identified in the course of the proceedings to\nopposing counsel, I am going to object and instruct you not to answer on the basis\nof the work-product privilege.\n\n155/19-23\n\nQ. What was, what is the purpose; that is, with regard to your threim4nts and\nonly your three clients — what connection if any, did Ghislaine Mltwelniave to\nthose individuals?\n-\n\n155/24-25\n\ni\nA. SCAROLA: Objection, work-product. Instruct yoir not to answer.\n\n170/19-20\n\nQ. Did Mr. Fisten interview a person by the name of Michael Sanka?\n\n170/21-22\n\nA. SCAROLA: That is work-product and) instruct you not to answer.\n/\nQ. Who other than Mr. Fisten from an interthil'investigator at RRA employee\nworked on doing investigation on the pstein files?\n\n181/19/23\n\n181/24-25\n\nA. SCAROLA: Same objection, same instruction.\n\n184/20-23\n\nQ. Did you ever direct your investigators to go through Mr. Epstein's trash?\n/\nA. SCAROLA: I am going to object, work-product, attorney-client privilege.\n/-/\nQ. Have you directed - this is the investigators during the time you were at RRA\nand that's the question you're claiming the privilege over, correct?\n\n184/24-25\n185/2-5\n\n185/11-13\n\nA. SCAROLA: I am claiming the privilege with respect to any action that was\ntaken \\by Mr.\nor at Mr. Edward's direction - in connection with the\nstrgation in prosecution of the claims against Mr. Epstein.\n\n185/15-26\\\n\n. With regard to your investigators, you gave direction with regarding the\nEpstein cases, during the time you were with RRA did you ever tell them or direct\nthem to go through Mr. Epstein's trash?\n\n185/21-22\n\nA.\n\nSCAROLA: Same objection, same instruction.\n\nEXHIBIT \"A\"\n5\n\nEFTA02769364\n\n", "char_count": 1942}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "185/24 -25\n\nQ. Did you ever direct the investigators to go through the trash of the lawyers who\nwere representing Mr. Epstein including myself?\n\n186/2-3\n\nA. SCAROLA: Same objection, same instruction.\n\n186/19-22\n\nQ. Did you ever direct the investigators to, during the time you were at RRA to\nconduct a surveillance on Mr. Epstein's property?\n\n186/23-24\n\nA. SCAROLA: Same objection, same instruction.\n\n187/2-4\n\nQ. Since the time you have left RRA in your current firm, havCy u eluded\nsurveillance on Mr. Epstein's property?\n\n187/5-6\n\nA. SCAROLA: Same objection, same instruction.\n\n187/8-10\n\nQ. Have you instructed anyone, either of the i\nsurveillance of Mr. Epstein's property?\n\n187/11-12\n\nA.\n\n187/14-17\n\nQ. Have you authorized inves\nloyed by RRA, either employees of\nthe firm or an outside investi\n, to walk around the perimeter of Mr.\nEpstein's home on or about R 17 of 2010?\n\n187/18-19\n\nA. SCAROLA: Str\n\n192/11 -14\n\nQ. Did you au\n\n192/15\n\nA. S\n\n198/11-13\n\nSCAROLA: Same objection,\n\n,)\n\n0\n\ninvestigators to conduct\nn.\n\nsame instruction.\n\nis6 your investigators to hire informants?\n\nO A. ame objection, same instruction.\nyou ever authorize any investigators to enter Mr. Epstein's property on\nh 17, 2010?\n\n198/14+ ek. SCAROLA: Objection. Instruct you not to answer on the basis of\nwork-product privilege.\n198/18-20\n\nQ. Are you ware of any investigators who entered Mr. Epstein's property on\nMarch 17, 2010?\n\nEXHIBIT \"A\"\n6\n\nEFTA02769365\n\n", "char_count": 1437}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Case No. 50 2009CA040800XXXXMB AG\n198/21-23\n\nA. SCAROLA: Same objection as well as attorney-client privilege and instruct\nyou not to answer.\n\n199/1-2\n\nQ. Did you authorize any investigators to trespass on Mr. Epstein's property on\nMarch 17, 2010?\n\n199/3\n\nA. SCAROLA: Same objection and instruction.\n\n199/6-10\n\nQ. Mr.\ndid you authorize investigators to hide in the buses at Mr.\nEpstein's house in order to take photographs of either Mr. Epsteinyor any\nassociated objects on his property?\n\n199/11\n\nA. SCAROLA: Same objection and instruction.\n\n200/7-8\n\nQ. Did he [Mr.\nfiles?\n\n200/9\n\nA. SCAROLA: Same objection and instruction.\n\n200/22-24\n\nQ. Did you authorize Rick to perform any investigation on the Epstein files?\n\n200/25\n\nA. SCAROLA: Same.p\n\n201/3-6\n\nQ. Did you everaulA9zI or direct Mr. Jenne to perform any investigation on\nthe Epstein files?\n\nM I ever perform investigation work on any of the Epstein\n\n6lion and instruction.\n\nA. SCAROLA: Same objection and instruction.\n201/19-24\n\nQ. 7 If you're unaware of the existence of the entity called Blue Line Research and\nDevelopment, LLC, would it be a correct statement that you have never\nauttioriied anyone from Blue Line Research to conduct any investigation of\nJefftJey Epstein?\n\n201/25\n\nA. SCAROLA: Same objection and instruction.\n\n202/4-11\n\nto answer any\nSCAROLA: We're not going to permit Mr.\nquestions about either what he did or what he didn't do that are part of the work\nproduct involved in his re resentation of the Plaintiffs with claims against Mr.\nEpstein whom Mr.\nis representing.\n\nEXHIBIT \"A\"\n7\n\nEFTA02769366\n\n", "char_count": 1575}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "Case No. 50 2009CA040800XXXX1v1B AG\n205/13-16\n\nQ. Between July 29th and August 7th 2009, did you speak with Mr. Rodriguez at\nall?\n\n205/17-21\n\nA. SCAROLA: Same objection, same instruction to the extent that any such\nconversation may have occurred in connection with your representation of the\nPlaintiffs and claims against Mr. Epstein.\n\n206/2-5\n\nA. If I did or didn't, either way that's going to be protected by the\nand I'm not going to give you that information because you're no\n\n208/46\n\nQ. After Mr. Rodriguez's deposition, did Mr. Rodriguez\n\n208/7-8\n\nA. SCAROLA: Objection, instruct you not to answe\n\n208/18-25\n\n'y have done in\nA. SCAROLA: Anything that Mr.\nconnection with his investigation and prosecu\ne claims against Mr.\nect matter of inquiry in the\nRothstein, it is our position is not the appr\ncontext of this lawsuit, and is an attempt to`rnvOe the attorney-client and\nwork-product privileges. I am instructing him of to answer.\nASi‘ \"Pr\nWe have an obligation to\nclients' rights and for that\nMr\nprivileges\nin\ntheir broadest sense unless\nreason we are obliged to int\ntho\nore restrictive interpretation should be\nand until the court dece\napplied.\n\n209/23-24\n\nQ. Did you speC\nA. SCAROLA:\n\n210/3-7\n\n210/8\n\n\\\n\nC\n\nr -privilege\nto it.\nou.\n\nRodriguez between his first and second?\ne objection, same instruction.\n\nnguez ever make a request of you at any time for any type of\nfort mony, documents, or any other information associated with any\nr potential claimants directed to Mr. Epstein?\n\nCAROLA: Same objection, same instruction.\n\n210/1;EIt Q. Did you after Mr. Rodriguez's completion of his deposition on August 7,\n2009, id you have an occasion to speak with any representative, a professional\nattorney, for the US Attorney's office?\n210/24\n\nA. SCAROLA: Same objection, same instruction.\n\n212/12-15\n\nQ. Did you sign any affidavit or give any sworn testimony associated with the\ncriminal complaint that was filed by USA versus Mr. Rodriguez?\nEXHIBIT \"A\"\n8\n\nEFTA02769367\n\n", "char_count": 1974}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02769339", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "Case No. 50 2009CA040800XXXXMB AG\n\n212/16-24\n\nA. I am not here to divulge any anything that may waive my attorney-client or\nwork-product privilege or otherwise jeopardize the claims that my three clients\nare pursuing against Jeffrey Epstein.\n\n215/6-9\n\nQ. Before you filed a lawsuit against the USA, did you ever speak with Ms.\nVillafana?\nA. I believe any communications that I would have had with respect to Ms.\nVillafana would have only been in the interest of pursuing clannsl ozbehalf of the\nuct privilege\nclients that I represented. Therefore, I am going to claim a\nas to those communications.\n\n215/16-20\n\nQ. My question was is only did you speak with her\nComplaint?\n\nfiling that\n\nA. SCAROLA: Same objection, same i\n\n216/8-13\n\nQ. Have the only conversations\nthe context of Jane Doe 1 and\nA. SCAROLA: Same\n\nhave had with Ms. Villafana only been in\nA only in the context of that case?\n\nion.\n\n216/22-25\n\nQ. Have you had an oceasi n to speak with Ms. Villafana with regard to the\ncriminal compl 'lit invted Alfredo Rodriguez?\n\n217/1-2\n\nA. SCA OLA: Smote objection, same instruction.\n\n217/7-8\n\nQ(\n\n217/10\n\ny of e three clients who have claims against Mr. Epstein?\nSCAROLA:\nAROLA: Same objection, same instruction.\nS\n\nO\n\nEXHIBIT \"A\"\n9\n\nEFTA02769368\n\n", "char_count": 1248}]}