{"efta_number": "EFTA02738215", "page_count": 12, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02738215", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02738215.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02738215", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 9:09-cv-80591-KAM Document 16 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/11/2009 Page 1 of 12\n\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA\nCASE NO.: 09-80591-MARRa\nJANE DOE No. 101,\nPlaintiff,\nv.\nJEFFREY EPSTEIN,\nDefendant,\n\nRESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO PROCEED ANONYMOUSLY\nAND\nEPSTEIN'S MOTION TO COMPEL AND/OR IDENTIFY JANE DOE #101 IN\nTHE STYLE OF THIS CASE AND MOTION TO IDENTIFY JANE DOE #101 IN\nTHIRD-PARTY SUBPOENAS FOR PURPOSES OF DISCOVERY. WITH\nINCORPORATED MEMORANDUM OF LAW\nDefendant, JEFFREY EPSTEIN (\"Epstein\" or \"Defendant\"), by and\nthrough his undersigned attorneys, hereby files his Response In Opposition to\nPlaintiff, Jane Doe #101's Motion to Proceed Anonymously and files his Motion\nrequesting that this Court enter an order identifying in the style of this case the\ncomplete legal name of the Plaintiff, JANE DOE #101 (\"JANE DOE\"), to\nsubstitute her complete legal name in this case in place of \"JANE DOE\" and,\nequally important, allowing Defendant to identify her in various subpoenas that\nEpstein must serve so Epstein can defend this case. In support, Mr. Epstein\nstates as follows:\n\n1\n\nEFTA02738215\n\n\f", "char_count": 1136}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738215", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 9:09-cv-80591-KAM Document 16 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/11/2009 Page 2 of 12\n\nI. Response In Opposition With Incorporated Motion And Incorporated\nMemorandum Of Law\na.\n1.\n\nBackground\n\nOn April 17, 2009, Plaintiff filed this action against Epstein. The\n\nComplaint (DE 1) alleges three causes of action against him: Count I - Coercion\nand Enticement of a Minor to Engage in Prostitution or Sexual Activity Pursuant\nto 18 U.S.C. §§2255 and 2422(b); Count II — Cause of Action for Travel With\nIntent to Engage in Illicit Sexual Conduct Pursuant to Pursuant to 18 U.S.C.\n§§2255 and 2423(b); Count III — Cause of Action for Sexual Exploitation of\nChildren Pursuant to 18 U.S.C. §§2255 and 2251(b); Count IV - Cause of Action\nfor Visual Depiction of Minor Engaging in Sexually Explicit Conduct Pursuant to\n18 U.S.C. §§2255 and 2251(a)(1); Count V — Cause of Action for Transport of\nChild Pornography Pursuant to 18 U.S.C. §§2255 and 2252A(a)(1); and Count VI\n— Cause of Action for Engaging in a Child Exploitation Enterprise Pursuant to 18\nU.S.C. §§2255 and 2252A(g).\n2.\n\nPlaintiff alleges, among other things, that she is entitled to money\n\ndamages pursuant to 2255 (in the wherefore clause), as well as actual and\ncompensatory.\n3.\n\nObviously, Plaintiff alleges separate counts against Mr. Epstein, on\n\nwhich he must conduct discovery to defend this case. Therefore, for the reasons\nset forth herein, not only must JANE DOE'S Motion to Proceed Anonymously be\ndenied, but Epstein's Motion to Identify Jane Doe must be granted. Despite\nPlaintiff's allegations in the Motion to Proceed Anonymously, this Court has not\n\"allowed\" any Plaintiff to proceed anonymously. Quite simply, that is the way\n\n2\n\nEFTA02738216\n\n\f", "char_count": 1710}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738215", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 9:09-cv-80591-KAM Document 16 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/11/2009 Page 3 of 12\n\neach Plaintiff chose to file each of their respective cases, all of which are\ncurrently being challenged in those other matters by Motion to Identify.\n4.\n\nImportantly, JANE DOE claims that she has and will suffer\n\n.\n\n.physical injury, pain and suffering, emotional distress, psychological and\npsychiatric trauma, mental anguish, humiliation, confusion, embarrassment, loss\nof educational opportunities, loss of self-esteem, loss of dignity, invasion of her\nprivacy . . . , and medical and psychological expenses. . . , loss on income, loss\nof the capacity to earn income in the future, and loss of the capacity to enjoy life\"\n¶¶28, Comp., DE 1; see also ¶¶32, 36, 41, 46 and 50, Comp., DE 1.\n5.\n\nEpstein has a constitutional due process right to defend himself and\n\nto seek the production of information that will assist in his defense of the\nallegations in the Complaint. In this case, Plaintiff's counsel intends on serving\nsubpoenas on Plaintiff's treating physicians and other third parties. Thus, this\nmotion seeks not only a denial Plaintiff's Motion to Proceed Anonymously but to\nidentify JANE DOE in the style of this case and to identify JANE DOE in various\nthird-party subpoenas for discovery purposes.\n6.\n\nThe undersigned's experience in \"Jane Doe\" lawsuits is that once a\n\nPlaintiff is identified, other individuals come forward in the discovery phase with\ninformation which often directly contradicts allegations as to the events and\ndamages. For instance, witnesses may testify that Plaintiff was paid by others\nfor similar sexual acts she claims Mr. Epstein forced upon her or that she willingly\nparticipated in certain act(s) that would negate or lessen her damages. This goes\ndirectly to Plaintiffs damage claim.\n\n3\n\nEFTA02738217\n\n\f", "char_count": 1832}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738215", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 9:09-cv-80591-KAM Document 16 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/11/2009 Page 4 of 12\n\n7.\n\nLikewise, subpoenas must be issued to third-party treaters and\n\ncurrent and former employers, and those subpoenas will seek to obtain records\nrelated directly to Plaintiffs claims and her damages (i.e., her claim for severe\nand permanent traumatic injuries, including mental, psychological and emotional\ndamages and loss of self-esteem as referenced above).\n\nCherenfant v.\n\nNationwide Credit, Inc., 2004 WL 5315889 (S.D. Fla. 2004)(order allowing\ndiscovery of medical records consistent with Plaintiffs allegations in complaint).\nThis too goes directly to Plaintiff's damage claims. Medical providers, employers,\nco-employees, etc... have direct and relevant personal knowledge and\nobservations regarding damages, i.e., emotional state, activities, self-esteem,\netc....\n8.\n\nFed.R.Civ.Pro. 26 allows for broad discovery.\n\nEpstein is not\n\nrequired to rely solely on Plaintiffs discovery responses in defending this case,\nnor is Epstein required by any statute or law to rely only upon what Plaintiff may\nproduce in discovery or may obtain from her own medical treaters through her\ncounsel, and to then provide to Epstein only after Plaintiff has reviewed same. In\ncertain related state court actions involving Epstein, the undersigned offered to\nserve certain subpoenas on the medical treaters and other third-parties with full\nname, date of birth and Plaintiffs social security number (last four digits), but\nagreed that the subpoenas filed with the clerk would be redacted.\n\nSeveral\n\nattorneys agreed to this procedure in those cases. In Federal Court, subpoenas\nare not filed with the clerk. Thus, in this matter, the undersigned offered to serve\nthe third-party subpoenas with plaintiffs full name, date of birth and social\n\n4\n\nEFTA02738218\n\n\f", "char_count": 1832}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738215", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 9:09-cv-80591-KAM Document 16 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/11/2009 Page 5 of 12\n\nsecurity number (last four digits) and would\n\nagree to redact any identifying\n\ninformation on any documents filed with this court if that ultimately became\nnecessary.\n9.\n\nMoreover, when an order from the court is attached to the\n\nSubpoena, treaters and other third parties produce the records and show up to\nthe depositions with the records requested because the deponent knows what to\nbring by virtue of knowing the identity of the Plaintiff.\n10.\n\nEpstein's counsel intends to serve and depose witnesses duces\n\ntecum. If Epstein is not permitted to identify JANE DOE (thus allowing her to\nproceed anonymously), how will any deponent know who the parties are and\nwhat to bring to the deposition pursuant to the duces tecum? Further, how will\nEpstein be able to defend the claims. Just like the Plaintiff, Epstein is entitled to\ndue process. If the Court allows Jane Doe to proceed anonymously, Jane Doe\nwill be permitted to present her case and Epstein will be limited in his defenses.\n11.\n\nWhile it is within the sound discretion of this court to allow a party to\n\nproceed anonymously, Plaintiff should not attempt to utilize that discretion as a\nshield from legitimate and necessary discovery. Epstein has a fundamental due\nprocess right to conduct discovery.\nb. Response in Opposition And Motion To Identify JANE DOE In Style\nOf This Case\n12.\n\nAs discussed below, Epstein has fundamental due process right to\n\ndefend himself in this civil litigation.\n\nWhile JANE DOE travels under a\n\npseudonym, various newspaper articles identifying Epstein have been released\ndiscussing the alleged claims against him. Allowing JANE DOE to litigate this\n\n5\n\nEFTA02738219\n\n\f", "char_count": 1744}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738215", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 9:09-cv-80591-KAM Document 16 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/11/2009 Page 6 of 12\n\nmatter under a pseudonym is preventing Epstein from defending this suit\nincluding, but not limited to, preventing him from locating individuals that may\nhave information about this lawsuit and information about JANE DOE that may\ndiscredit her allegations and/or lessen the monetary damages she seeks to\nrecover. It is the undersigned's experience that once identified, witnesses begin\nto come forward. See supra.\n13.\n\nIn Doe v. Lepley, 185 F.R.D. 605 (D. Ct. NV 1999), a sexual\n\nharassment case, the court reasoned that there is no express or implied right to\nbring an action anonymously.\n\nId. at 606.\n\nMoreover, Fed. R. Civ. P 10(a)\n\nrequires that the complaint include the names of the parties. Id. When Plaintiffs\nare permitted to proceed anonymously, the court must employ a balancing test to\ndecide if the plaintiff has a substantial privacy interest that outweighs the\npresumption of openness in judicial proceedings. Id., citing, Doe v.\n\n951\n\nF.2d 320, 323 (11th Cir. 1992)(requiring complaint to include the names of the\nparties serves more than administrative convenience, it protects the public's\nlegitimate interests in knowing all the facts involved, including the identity of the\nparties - thus denying request to proceed anonymously). The factors include:\na.\n\nwhether the plaintiff is challenging governmental activity;\n\nb.\n\nwhether the party defending the suit would be prejudiced;\n\nc.\n\nwhether the plaintiff is required to disclose information of\nutmost intimacy;\n\nd.\n\nwhether the plaintiff is compelled to admit an intention to\nengage in illegal conduct, thereby risking criminal\nprosecution;\n\ne.\n\nwhether the Plaintiff would risk suffering injury if identified;\n\n6\n\nEFTA02738220\n\n\f", "char_count": 1782}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738215", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 9:09-cv-80591-ICAM Document 16 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/11/2009 Page 7 of 12\n\nf.\n\nwhether the interests of children are at stake; and\n\ng.\n\nwhether there are less drastic means of protecting the\nlegitimate interests of either party.\n\nDoe\n\n951 F.2d at 323.\n\nPlaintiff does not fall under any of the factors. Moreover, even if she did\nmeet one of the factors, \"[t]he fact that [a] Doe [Plaintiff] may suffer some\npersonal embarrassment, standing alone, does not require the granting of a\nrequest to proceed under a pseudonym.\" Id; see also Doe v. Rostker 89 F.R.D.\n159 (N.D. Calif. 1981).\n\nAny substantial privacy interests JANE DOE has must\n\noutweigh the customary and constitutionally embedded presumption of openness\nto judicial proceedings. Doe v.\n\n951 F.2d at 323; Doe v. Berqstron 2009\n\nWL 528623 (C.A.9(Or.))(denying request to proceed anonymously in civil action\nby Plaintiff where Plaintiffs arrest, prosecution and acquittal were matters of\npublic record).\n14.\n\nIn Sweetland v. State, 535 So.2d 646 (Fla. 1st DCA 1988), the court\n\nreasoned that the purpose of discovery is to eliminate the likelihood of surprise\nand to insure a fair opportunity to prepare for trial. Florida Rule of Civil Procedure\n1.280(b)(1)• see also Surf Drugs. Inc.. v. Vermette 236 So.2d 108, 111 (Fla.\n1970)(stating that the rules of discovery should be afforded broad and liberal\ntreatment to effectuate their purpose), citing, Hickman v. Taylor 329 U.S. 495,\n501, 507 (1947).\n15.\n\nNext, the right to go to court to resolve disputes is a fundamental right.\n\nD.R. Lakes, Inc. v. Brandsmart U.S.A. of West Palm Beach, 819 So.2d 971 (Fla. 4th\n\n7\n\nEFTA02738221\n\n\f", "char_count": 1648}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738215", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case 9:09-cv-80591-ICAM Document 16 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/11/2009 Page 8 of 12\n\nDCA 2002). All litigants are afforded an equal opportunity. Lingle v. Dion 776\nSo.2d 1073 (Fla. 4th DCA 2001). The Florida Constitution establishes the right\ncommonly known as access to courts. Mitchell v. Moore, 786 So.2d 521 (Fla.\n2001). Courts shall be open to any person for the redress of any injury and justice\nshall be administered without sale, denial or delay. Art. I, §21, Fla. Const.; 10A Fla.\nJur. 2d, Constitutional Law, §360.\n16.\n\nIf Jane Doe's name is not disclosed and identified, Mr. Epstein will not\n\nbe afforded his fundamental right to fairly litigate this dispute and prepare for trial.\nAccordingly, Epstein requests that JANE DOE be identified by her legal name in the\npleadings.\nc. Response In Opposition And Motion To Identify JANE DOE In ThirdParty Subpoenas\n17.\n\nEpstein will be effectively denied his due process rights to conduct\n\nbroad, open and liberal discovery in that Plaintiffs counsel has objected to,\namong other things, Epstein identifying JANE DOE in various third-party\nsubpoenas to her medical providers and other third parties.\n18.\n\nThe undersigned must serve subpoenas on medical doctors to\n\nobtain medical information on JANE DOE's alleged psychological and physical\ndamages as same goes to the heart of Epstein's defenses and Plaintiffs\ndamages. Plaintiff is claiming emotional/psychological damages.\n\nTherefore,\n\nEpstein is entitled to know her psychological condition(s) before and after the\nalleged incident(s) she references in the Complaint. In particular, JANE DOE\nalleges specific disorders as a result of Epstein's alleged conduct — suffer \".\n.physical injury, pain and suffering, emotional distress, psychological and\n\n8\n\nEFTA02738222\n\n\f", "char_count": 1774}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738215", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case 9:09-cv-80591-KAM Document 16 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/11/2009 Page 9 of 12\n\npsychiatric trauma, mental anguish, humiliation, confusion, embarrassment, loss\nof educational opportunities, loss of self-esteem, loss of dignity, invasion of her\nprivacy . . . , and medical and psychological expenses. . . , loss on income, loss\nof the capacity to earn income in the future, and loss of the capacity to enjoy life.\"\n(Emphasis Added). See supra. Epstein is also entitled to know, among other\nthings, whether she had any physical complaints or whether there was ever any\nevidence of physical battery on JANE DOE's body from the acts she complains\nof in the Complaint. The need to serve third-party subpoenas on medical doctors\nis a basic discovery need related to the claims alleged by JANE DOE for which\nPlaintiffs counsel refuses to compromise. Balas v. Ruzzo, 703 So.2d 1076 (Fla.\n5th DCA 1997), rev. denied, 719 So.2d 286 (Fla. 1998)(discoverability of\nPlaintiffs history of sexual activity is relevant to damages); United States v. Bear\nStops, 997 F.2d 451 (8th Cir. 1993)(deals with \"admissibility of other acts of\nsexual abuse by individuals other than the defendant to explain why a victim of\nabuse exhibited behavioral manifestations of a sexually abused child.\")\n\nIf\n\nPlaintiff saw a psychologist or other physician during or after the time periods she\nclaims she was assaulted by Epstein but either did not discuss or did discuss the\nincidents (or lack thereof) would be directly relevant to her damage claims.\nPlaintiff seeks physical and emotional/mental personal injury type damages, and\nthe Epstein must conduct his own discovery thereon. See supra. No valid\ndiscovery objections or exemptions exist preventing necessary and reasonable\ndiscovery. To hold otherwise prevents Mr. Epstein from preparing and defending\nthis matter.\n\n9\n\nEFTA02738223\n\n\f", "char_count": 1861}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738215", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Case 9:09-cv-80591-KAM Document 16 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/11/2009 Page 10 of 12\n\n19.\n\nIn defending this lawsuit, Mr. Epstein should be permitted broad\n\ndiscovery, whether admissible at trial or not. Fed.R.Civ.Pro. 26 provides, in\npertinent part, that \"parties may obtain discovery regarding any matter, not\nprivileged, which is relevant to the subject matter involved in the pending action.\"\n20.\n\nIn addition, subpoenas must also be served upon various local and\n\nstate institutions in order to determine what crimes, if any, JANE DOE has\ncommitted (i.e., crimes that involve dishonesty and/or false statement).\nObviously, this goes directly to the heart of JANE DOE's damages she claims\nsuffer \". . .physical injury, pain and suffering, emotional distress, psychological\nand psychiatric trauma, mental anguish, humiliation, confusion, embarrassment,\nloss of educational opportunities, loss of self-esteem, loss of dignity, invasion of\nher privacy . . . , and medical and psychological expenses. . , loss on income,\nloss of the capacity to earn income in the future, and loss of the capacity to enjoy\nlife\" — caused by Epstein or other events in her life) for which a jury is entitled to\nhear about at trial, and certified records must be obtained from the clerk should\nJANE DOE answer certain questions regarding her crimes incorrectly.\n21.\n\nEpstein is entitled to know whether Jane Doe committed and/or\n\nwas charged with any crimes. If Jane Doe was charged with crimes, Epstein is\nentitled to obtain certified copies of those crimes Plaintiff may have committed for\npurposes of discovery and impeachment. Questions will be asked regarding\nthose crimes (e.g., Have you been convicted of a crime of dishonesty or false\nstatement? If so, how many times? Have you been convicted of a felony? If so,\nhow many times?) To hold otherwise would not only prevent broad discovery but\n\n10\n\nEFTA02738224\n\n\f", "char_count": 1898}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738215", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Case 9:09-cv-80591-KAM Document 16 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/11/2009 Page 11 of 12\n\nwould ultimately result in reversible error at any trial.\nII. Conclusion and Prayer for Relief\n22.\n\nEpstein requests the following relief:\na.\n\nThat JANE DOE's Motion to Proceed Anonymously be denied;\n\nb.\n\nThat this Court grant Epstein's Motion and that JANE DOE be\nidentified by her legal name in the style of this case; and\n\nc.\n\nThat Epstein be granted leave to identify JANE DOE by her\nlegal name in Third-Party Subpoenas (but not file them in Court\nor, if required, in a redacted form).\n\nWHEREFORE, Epstein, Jeffrey Epstein, respectfully requests that this\nCourt enter said order granting the relief requested above, and for such other\nand further relief as this Court may deem just and proper\nBy: /\nR ON, JR., ESQ.\nROBERT\nMICHAEL J. PIKE, ESQ.\nCertificate of Service\nI HEREBY CERTIFY that a true copy of the foregoing was electronically\nfiled with the Clerk of the Court using CM/ECF. I also certify that the foregoing\ndocument is being served this day on all counsel of record identified on the\nday of\nfollowing Service List in the manner specified by CM/ECF on this\nMav, 2009\nRobert C. Josefsberg, Esq.\nKatherine W. Ezell, Esq.\nPodhurst Orseck, P.A.\n25 West Flagler Street, Suite 800\nMiami, FL 33130\n305 358-2800\nFax: 305 358-2382\nriosefsberqApodhurst.com\nkezellftpodhurst.com\nCounsel for Plaintiff\n\nJack Alan Goldberger, Esq.\nAtterbury Goldberger & Weiss, P.A.\n250 Australian Avenue South\nSuite 1400\nWest Palm Beach, FL 33401-5012\n561-659-8300\nFax: 561-835-8691\njaqesa@bellsouth.net\nCounsel for Defendant Jeffrey Epstein\n\n11\n\nEFTA02738225\n\n\f", "char_count": 1632}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738215", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Case 9:09-cv-80591-KAM Document 16 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/11/2009 Page 12 of 12\n\nRespectfully sub itt\nBy:\n. CRITTON, JR., ESQ.\nRO\nFlorida Bar No. 224162\nrcrita.bcIclaw.com\nMICHAEL J. PIKE, ESQ.\nFlorida Bar #617296\nmoikeAbciclaw.com\nBURMAN, CRITTON, LU1TIER &\nCOLEMAN\n515 N. Flagler Drive, Suite 400\nWest Palm Beach, FL 33401\n561/842-2820 Phone\n561/515-3148 Fax\n(Counsel for Defendant Jeffrey Epstein)\n\n12\n\nEFTA02738226\n\n\f", "char_count": 424}]}