{"efta_number": "EFTA02738011", "page_count": 13, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02738011", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02738011.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02738011", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-09610-PAE-DCF\n\nDocument 24-1\n\nFiled 11/08/19\n\nPage 1 of 13\n\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK\nCASE NO. 1:19-cv-09610-PAE\nJANE DOE 17,\nPlaintiff,\nv.\nDARREN K. INDYKE AND\nRICHARD D. KAHN, AS JOINT\nPERSONAL REPRESENTATIVES OF\nTHE ESTATE OF JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN,\nNINE EAST 71st STREET CORPORATION,\nLAUREL, INC., FINANCIAL TRUST COMPANY,\nINC., NES, LLC, MAPLE, INC., LSJE, LLC,\nHBRK ASSOCIATES, INC., NAUTILUS, INC.,\nCYPRESS, INC. and JEGE, INC.\nDefendants.\n\nMOTION TO PROCEED ANONYMOUSLY ON BEHALF OF JANE DOE 17\nAND SUPPORTING MEMORANDUM OF LAW\nPlaintiff, Jane Doe 17, herein files her Motion to Proceed Anonymously and Supporting\nMemorandum of Law and in support thereof states:\nI.\n\nPLAINTIFF IS PERMITTED TO PROCEED ANONYMOUSLY IN THIS\nCIRCUIT.\nThis action involves Jeffrey Epstein's sexual assault of Plaintiff (\"Plaintiff') in violation\n\nof the New York Law and/or the Trafficking Victims Protection Act under 18 U.S.C. §§ 1591\nthrough 1595. Plaintiff submits this Memorandum of Law in support of Plaintiff's Motion for\nLeave to Proceed Anonymously. Allowing Plaintiff to proceed anonymously will protect her\nhighly sensitive personal information that will remain the focus of this litigation. There is no\nprejudice to Defendants in allowing Plaintiff to proceed anonymously, nor is there any significant\npublic interest in the disclosure of the Plaintiffs identity. In fact, the public interest in this case\nPage 1 of 7\n\nEFTA02738011\n\n\f", "char_count": 1474}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738011", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-09610-PAE-DCF\n\nDocument 24-1\n\nFiled 11/08/19\n\nPage 2 of 13\n\nweighs in favor of granting Plaintiff's request to proceed anonymously for her protection.\nFederal Rule of Civil Procedure 10(a) requires a Complaint to \"include the names of all\nthe parties.\" However, the court has discretion to allow a plaintiff to proceed anonymously.\nSealed Plaintiffit. Sealed Defendant. 537 F.3d 185, 190 (2d. Cir. 2008). \"[C]ourts have granted\nanonymity to protect against disclosure of a wide range of issues involving matters of the utmost\nintimacy, including sexual assault.\" Doe. No. 2 v. Kolko, 242 F.R.D. 193, 196 (EDNY 2006); see\nalso 1991 McKinney's Sessions Laws of N.Y. at 2211-2212 (\"sexual assault victims have\nunfortunately had to endure a terrible invasion of their physical privacy. They have a right to\nexpect that this violation will not be compounded by a further invasion of their privacy\").\n\"When determining whether a plaintiff may be allowed to maintain an action under a\npseudonym, the plaintiffs interest in anonymity must be balanced against both the public\ninterest in disclosure and any prejudice to the defendant.\" /d. at 189. The balancing of interests\nentails the consideration of ten non-exhaustive factors, though the court has discretion to\nconsider \"other factors relevant to the particular case under consideration.\" Id. at 189-190. The\nten factors are:\n(1) whether the litigation involves matters that are highly sensitive and of a\npersonal nature; (2) whether identification poses a risk of retaliatory physical or\nmental harm to the party seeking to proceed anonymously or even more\ncritically, to innocent non-parties; (3) whether identification presents other harms\nand the likely severity of those harms, including whether the injury litigated\nagainst would be incurred as a result of the disclosure of the plaintiff's identity;\n(4) whether the plaintiff is particularly vulnerable to the possible harms of\ndisclosure, particularly in light of [her] age; (5) whe\n... [truncated, 2715 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02738011/1 or ?id=EFTA02738011&page=1]", "char_count": 2715}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738011", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-09610-PAE-DCF\n\nDocument 24-1\n\nFiled 11/08/19\n\nPage 3 of 13\n\nlitigants' identities; and (10) whether there are any alternative mechanisms for\nprotecting the confidentiality of the plaintiff.\nId. at 190 (internal citations and quotations omitted).\nII.\n\nALL TEN ANONYMITY FACTORS WEIGH IN FAVOR OF\nPERMITTING PLAINTIFF TO PROCEED ANONYMOUSLY.\nIn this case, all delineated Sealed Plaintiff factors support Plaintiff's application for\n\nanonymity, which should be granted for her protection. Plaintiff is a victim of multiple instances\nof sexual assault. The acts that were committed against Plaintiff are highly sensitive in nature\nand are particularly difficult for her to address in a public forum.\nFor those reasons, among many others (some of which, if revealed in a public filing might\ndisclose Plaintiff's identity), identification of Plaintiff in this matter may pose a risk of\nretaliation. See Sealed Plaintiff; 537 F.3d at 190. In order to warrant anonymity, the possible\nretaliatory harm may be either physical or psychological in nature. See Doe v. Del Rio, 241\nF.R.D. 154, 158 (S.D.N.Y. 2006) Epstein's vast wealth and far reaching connections make it\nclear that retaliation could be employed against individuals pursuing claims against the Estate\nof Jeffrey Epstein. In addition to exposing Plaintiff to physical or psychological harm, retaliation\ncould also silence potential witnesses from coming forward.\nThe public exposure ofPlaintiff's identity would certainly cause her to suffer additional\nor exacerbated emotional or psychological harm including shame, embarrassment, depression,\nanxiety, and the array of side effects that go along therewith. Should Plaintiff's real identity be\nrevealed, her safety could also be at risk as the media and the press worldwide are currently laser\nfocused on Jeffrey Epstein and his sexually exploitative escapades.\nDespite the fact that Defendants are private parties and not Government entities,\nDefendants are not \"ordinary\" private pa\n... [truncated, 2169 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02738011/2 or ?id=EFTA02738011&page=2]", "char_count": 2169}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738011", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-09610-PAE-DCF\n\nDocument 24-1\n\nFiled 11/08/19\n\nPage 4 of 13\n\npredator with substantial financial influence for many years. For years before his death, Epstein\nhad been investigated by various state prosecutors and the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI)\nfor his sexual assaults on young girls.\nGiven Epstein's notoriety, Plaintiff's allegations of sexual abuse and the widespread\nconcealment of the same \"raise concerns affecting a larger association rather than the interest of\nan individual plaintiff.\" See id. at 195. In this case, the \"larger association\" is society in general.\nSociety has an interest in eradicating the predatory practices of powerful men against vulnerable,\nsusceptible women— including the practice of luring young girls for sexual purposes. This case\nis therefore more \"analogous to one involving a government defendant, where personal\nanonymity is more readily granted because of the existence of a public interest in the action.\" EW\nv. New York Blood Center, 213 F.R.D. 108, 112 (EDNY 2003).\n\"The public right to scrutinize governmental functioning is not so completely impaired\nby a grant of anonymity to a party as it is by closure of the trial itself . . . Party anonymity does\nnot obstruct the public's view of the issues joined or the court's performance in resolving them.\"\nSee Doe v. Stegall, 653 F.2d 180, 185 (5th Cir. 1981). The public's interest in this legal question\nis not furthered by requiring Plaintiff to disclose her identity. See Sealed Plaintiff 537 F.3d at\n190 (citing DelRio, 241 F.R.D. at 154 (\"whether, because of the purely legal nature of the issues\npresented or otherwise, them is an atypically weak public interest in knowing the litigants'\nidentities\")); see also Free Speech v. Reno, Case No. 98 Civ. 2680 MBM, 1999 WL 47310 at *3\n(SDNY Feb. I, 1999) (\"because the particular plaintiffs in this constitutional challenge are\nessentially interchangeable with similarly situated persons, there appears little public interest in\nwh\n... [truncated, 2310 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02738011/3 or ?id=EFTA02738011&page=3]", "char_count": 2310}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738011", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-09610-PAE-DCF\n\nDocument 24-1\n\nFiled 11/08/19\n\nPage 5 of 13\n\nsexual assault victims so that other victims will not be deterred from reporting such crimes.\"\nKolko, 242 F.R.D. at 195.\nFinally, [t]he Second Circuit directed district courts to evaluate \"whether there are any\nalternative mechanisms for protecting the confidentiality of the plaintiff.\" Sealed Plaintiff 537\nF.3d at 190 (citing Roe v. Aware Woman Center for Choice, Inc., 253 F.3d 678, 687 (11th Cir.\n2001)):\nThe only justification the defendants offer for stripping Roe of her privacy is the\nargument that they will not be able to adequately conduct discovery without\nknowing her true identity. However, that argument is eviscerated by Roe's offer\nto disclose her name to the defendantsfor discovery purposes on condition that\nthey do not disclose it to the general public. That is a reasonable way to\nreconcile the competing interests, and the district court can enter an appropriate\nprotective order. The district court should have granted Roe's motion to proceed\nanonymously.\nHere, Plaintiff will cooperate with the court and the Defendants and reveal Plaintiff's\nidentity to Defendants for discovery purposes on the condition that Defendants do not disclose\nPlaintiff's name to the general public.\nJust recently, under circumstances virtually identical to that of Jane Doe 17, Judge Castel\ngranted a Motion to Proceed Anonymously in the matter of Katlyn Doe v. Darren K. Indyke, et\nat, Case No 19-cv-7771-PKC finding the presence of at least 7 of the 10 Sealed Plaintiff factors\nwhich either supported or weighed strongly in favor of permitting the Plaintiff to proceed\nanonymously. The Court held that \"the public right to know is substantially outweighed by the\nplaintiff's legitimate need for anonymity and that prejudice to a defendant can be mitigated by\norders of the Court.\" A copy of Judge Castel's Order of September 11, 2019 is annexed hereto\nas Exhibit A.\nIII. CONCLUSION\nThe balancing factors articulated by t\n... [truncated, 2075 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02738011/4 or ?id=EFTA02738011&page=4]", "char_count": 2075}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738011", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-09610-PAE-DCF\n\nDocument 24-1\n\nFiled 11/08/19\n\nPage 6 of 13\n\nPlaintiff's identity by allowing her to proceed anonymously. For the foregoing reasons, Plaintiff\nrespectfully requests that the Court grant her Motion for Leave to Proceed Anonymously.\nDated: November 8, 2019\nBy: /s/ Andrew S. Buzin\nAndrew S. Buzin\nBUZIN LAW, P.C.\n111 Broadway, Suite 1204\nNew York, NY 10006\nTel: (646) 470-4878\nFax: (347) 736-9490\nEmail: abuzin@buzinlaw.com\nAttorneys for Plaintiff, Jane Doe 17\nBy: /s/ David H. Brodie\nDavid H. Brodie, Esq., FBN 0813168\nLaura J. Stan•, Esq., FBN 0491888\nWEISMAN, BRODIE, STARR\n& MARGOLIES, P.A.\n1301 N. Federal Highway\nLake Worth, FL 33460\nTelephone: (561) 588-9500\nFacsimile: (561) 588-9500\nEmail: dbrodie@vourfloridacounsel.com\nEmail: Istarr@yourfloridacounsel.com\nAttorneys for Plaintfff, Jane Doe 17\nBy: /s/ Alan Goldfarb\nAlan Goldfarb, Esq., FBN 146924\nDavid Appleby, Esq., FBN 500089\nALAN GOLDFARB, P.A.\n100 S.E. 2nd Street\nMiami Tower,45th Floor\nMiami, FL 33131\nPh: 305-371-3111\nFax: 305-577-8375\nEmail: agoldfarb@goldfarbpa.com\nEmail: dappleby@goldfarbpa.com\nAttorneys for Plaintiff, Jane Doe 17\nCERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\nI HEREBY certify that on November 8, 2019, I electronically filed the foregoing with the\n\nPage 6 of 7\n\nEFTA02738016\n\n\f", "char_count": 1271}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738011", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-09610-PAE-DCF\n\nDocument 24-1\n\nFiled 11/08/19\n\nPage 7 of 13\n\nCourt by using the CM/ECF system which will send a notice of electronic filing to all CM/ECF\nparticipants. I further certify that I mailed the foregoing document and the notice of electronic\nfiling by first-class mail to any non-CM/ECF participants.\nBy: Is/ David H. Brodie\nDavid H. Brodie, Esq., FBN 0813168\nLaura J. Stan•, Esq., FBN 0491888\nWEISMAN, BRODIE, STARR\n& MARGOLIES, P.A.\n1301 N. Federal Highway\nLake Worth, FL 33460\nTelephone: (561) 588-9500\nFacsimile: (561) 588-9500\nEmail: dbrodie@yourfloridacounsel.com\nEmail: Istarr@yourfloridacounsel.com\nAttorneys for Plaintiff, Jane Doe 17\n\nPage 7 of 7\n\nEFTA02738017\n\n\f", "char_count": 695}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738011", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case 1,19-cv-09610-PAE-DCF\n\nDocument 24-1\n\nFiled 11/08119\n\nPage 8 of 13\n\nEXHIBIT A\n\nEFTA02738018\n\n\f", "char_count": 99}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738011", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case tagecitAftileinsfarSic Dtkowswiteat\n\n1FilelitifiV\n\n/49agellilt 6\" of 13\n\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK\nx\nICATLYN DOE,\n19-cv-7771 (PKC)\n\nPlaintiff,\n\nORDER\n\n-againstDARREN K. INDYKE, et al..,\nDefendant.\nx\nCASTEL, U.S.D.J.\n\nPlaintiff seeks leave to proceed in this action without disclosing her identity using\ninstead a pseudonym. She alleges that Jeffrey Epstein, with the assistance of associates and\nentities, engaged in \"manipulate[ion],\" \"control,\" \"sexual exploitation,\" \"sexual assault[],\"\n\"sexual abuse,\" and \"forced... intercourse\" of or with plaintiff; she was seventeen when the\ncourse of conduct began. (Complaint\n\nin 58-68.) At this juncture, no defendant has been served.\n\nRule 10(a), Fed. R. Civ. P., provides that \"[t]he title of [a] complaint must name\nall the parties.\" The Second Circuit has recognized that the use of a pseudonym is, however,\nappropriate in limited circumstances where the reasons for anonymity outweigh the public's right\nof access to judicial proceedings and any prejudice to a defendant. Sealed Plaintiff v. Sealed\nDefendant. 537 F.3d 185, 189 (24 Cir. 2008). The Circuit's opinion in Sealed Plaintiff lays out\nten non-exhaustive factors to be considered in determining whether to allow a case to proceed on\nan anonymous basis. Id. at 190. The Court analyzes the Complaint in light of these factors.\n\n-1-\n\nEFTA02738019\n\n\f", "char_count": 1392}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738011", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Case tia€1&iiklaiefra531kC Db)trettinikftt Vt1AS\n\ngo of 13\n\n(1) whether the litigation involves matters that are\nhighly sensitive and of a\npersonal nature.\nThe Complaint alleges an on-going pattern of sexual assault and abuse beginning\nwhen plaintiff was seventeen years-old and asserts that she has and is continuing to suffer\npsychological injury as a result. (Complaint 11 52-65.) These are highly sensitive allegations of\na personal nature.\n\n(2) whether identification of the plaintiff poses a risk of\nphysical or mental retaliation to the plaintiff or to a\nthird party.\nNo risk of retaliation is alleged. Jeffrey Epstein is dead and there is no credible\nevidence of a risk of retaliation from others. There is an allegation of threats of retaliation in the\npast if she did not comply with demands for sex acts that she would suffer financial,\npsychological, and reputational harm (Id. 1 84) but no facts are alleged that those threats arc\nlikely to continue after the death of Epstein.\n\n(3) whether identification of plaintiff poses the risk of other\nharms, their likely severity and whether they are of the type\nthat the litigation seeks to redress.\nThe nature of the allegations make it logical to conclude at this early stage that\ndisclosure of plaintiffs identity would cause further psychological harm to plaintiff which is the\nprecise harm the litigation seeks, in part, to redress.\n\n-2-\n\nEFTA02738020\n\n\f", "char_count": 1415}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738011", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Case 1CliketairaarnWC DataiStatielRertikonkatIlitaggfia la of 13\n\n(4) whether there are other factors that make the\nplaintiff particularly vulnerable to harm of\ndisclosure, for example. because of her age.\nBy the Court's calculation, the plaintiff is 29 or 30. She is described in the\ncomplaint as having physical conditions that make her particularly vulnerable. all\n\n54-55.)\n\nShe alleges that she has incurred and will continue to incur \"medical and psychological\nexpenses\" as a result of the conduct alleged. GIL. 9132.)\n(5) whether the action challenges the actions of government or\ngovernment actors, or merely private parties.\nThe actions alleged are not the actions of a government actor or instrumentality\nbut rather those of private parties.\n\n(6) the nature of any prejudice to a defendant from\nallowing the plaintiff to proceed anonymously and\nwhether any prejudice can be mitigated by the court.\nThe Complaint alleges that the representatives of the estate of Epstein have\nliability for his actions. It also alleges that various non-natural persons are liable for acts and\nomissions causing plaintiff harm. In such circumstances it is critical that the accused defendants\nknow the identity of the plaintiff in order to investigate and defend against the claim. The Court\ncan mitigate the prejudice to defendants by requiring the disclosure of the actual name of the\nplaintiff in a document to be sewed on defendants and also filed under seal with the Court.\nPlaintiff does not object to disclosure \"for discovery purposes on the condition that Defendants\ndo not disclose Plaintiff's name to the general public.\" (P. Mem. 6; Doc 3-1.)\n\n-3-\n\nEFTA02738021\n\n\f", "char_count": 1666}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738011", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Case tthetirodiao1W§CarCDiSilliti*lFitithOlikiMilbaewii V of 13\n\n(7) whether the plaintiffs identity has thus far been\nkept confidential,\nInsofar as the Court is aware, the identity of the plaintiff is not widely known.\n\n(8) whether there is a legitimate public interest or\nbenefit in requiring the plaintiff\nto disclose her identity.\nThere is public interest in the litigation because of the notoriety of Epstein and\nthose with whom he associated, but disclosure of the identity of the plaintiff is not likely to be of\na legitimate importance or benefit to the public.\n\n(9) Whether the issues in the action are predominately\nor purely legal nature suggesting that the public\ninterest in the plaintiff's identity may be weak.\nThe issues in the case are not purely or predominately of a legal nature. This case\nturns principally on its facts.\n\n(10) whether there are any alternative mechanisms for\nprotecting the confidentiality of the plaintiff.\nft is the disclosure of her identity that would exacerbate any preexisting harm to\nplaintiff and hence there is not alternative mechanism for protecting her confidentiality.\nCONCLUSION\nFactors 1 and 3 tilt strongly in favor of permitting plaintiff to proceed\nanonymously and are supported by factors 4, 6, 7, 8 and 10. Factors 2, 5, 9 are either neutral or\n\n-4-\n\nEFTA02738022\n\n\f", "char_count": 1324}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02738011", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Case iciaallicigittitcHkC cataviMitti4-1Fitidaelitftlibaggettig g3 of 13\n\nweakly support denying the motion. The Court concludes that, at this juncture, the public right to\nknow is substantially outweighed by the plaintiff's legitimate need for anonymity and that\nprejudice to a defendant can be mitigated by orders of the Court. The Court reserves the right to\nmodify this Order as the case progresses.\nPlaintiff's motion (Doc 3) is GRANTED. Within seven days of the appearance of\na defendant, plaintiff shall disclose her identity to the appearing defendant in a document to be\nsubmitted to the Court for sealing. No defendant may disclose the identity of plaintiff to any\nperson other than counsel without further order of this Court.\nSO ORDERED.\n\nP. Kevin Castel\nUnited States District Judge\nDated: New York, New York\nSeptember 11, 2019\n\n-5-\n\nEFTA02738023\n\n\f", "char_count": 862}]}