{"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_count": 57, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02737823", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02737823.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 1 of 57\n\n1\n\nK5m2FarC\n\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK\nx\n,\n\nPlaintiff,\n\nNew York, N.Y.\n\n4\nv.\n\n19 CV 10475 (LGS)\n\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n\nDARREN K. INDYKE, in his\ncapacity as executor of the\nEstate of Jeffrey Edward\nEpstein; RICHARD D. KAHN, in\nhis capacity as executor of\nthe Estate of Jeffrey Edward\nEpstein; and GHISLAINE\nMAXWELL,\nDefendants.\n\n10\n\nTeleconference\nMay 22, 2020\n11:00 a.m.\n\nx\n19 CV 10476 (PGG)\n\n.\n11\nPlaintiff,\n12\nv.\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n\nDARREN K. INDYKE, in his\ncapacity as executor of the\nEstate of Jeffrey Edward\nEpstein and RICHARD D. KAHN, in\nhis capacity as executor of\nthe Estate of Jeffrey Edward\nEpstein,\nDefendants.\nx\n\n18\n\n'\n\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\n19 CV 10479 (ALC)\n\nPlaintiff,\nv.\nDARREN K. INDYKE, in his\ncapacity as executor of the\nEstate of Jeffrey Edward\nEpstein and RICHARD D. KAHN, in\nhis capacity as executor of\nthe Estate of Jeffrey Edward\nEpstein,\nDefendants.\nx\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737823\n\n\f", "char_count": 1030}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 2 of 57\n\n2\n\nK5m2FarC\n\nx\nJANE DOE 1000,\n\n19 CV 10577(LJL)\nPlaintiffs,\n\nv.\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n\nDARREN K. INDYKE, in his\ncapacity as executor of the\nEstate of Jeffrey Edward\nEpstein and RICHARD D. KAHN, in\nhis capacity as executor of\nthe Estate of Jeffrey Edward\nEpstein,\nDefendants.\nx\n\n9\n10\n11\n12\n\nBefore:\nHON. DEBRA C. FREEMAN,\n\n13\n\nMagistrate Judge\n\n14\n15\nAPPEARANCES\n16\n17\n18\n19\n\nBOIES, SCHILLER & FLEXNER, LLP\nAttorneys for Plaintiff\nBY: SIGRID S. McCAWLEY\nSABINA MARIELLA\nANDREW VILLACASTIN\n\n20\n21\n22\n\nTROUTMAN SANDERS, LLP\nAttorneys for Defendants Indyke and Kahn\nBY: BENNET J. MOSKOWITZ\nMATTHEW J. AARONSON\nVALERIE SIROTA\n\n23\n24\n25\n\n, P.C.\nHADDON,\n&\nAttorneys for Defendant Maxwell\nBY: LAURA A. MENNINGER\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737824\n\n\f", "char_count": 826}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 3 of 57\n\n3\n\nK5m2FarC\nTHE COURT:\n\nThis is Judge Freeman.\n\nWe might have a\n\ncourt reporter, but I'm going to record this call anyway, so\nhold on while I set that up.\n4\n\nAll right.\n\nSo this is Judge Freeman, and this is a\n\n5\n\nconference in four of the cases against the Jeffrey Epstein\n\n6\n\nestate:\n\n7\n\n19 Civ. 10476;\n\n8\n\nIndyke, 19 Civ. 10577.\n\n9\n10\n11\n\nv. Indyke, 19 Civ. 10475;\n\nv. Indyke,\n\nv. Indyke, 19 Civ. 10479; and Doe 1000 v.\n\nIf you are here for some other case or you think I got\nthose numbers wrong, please make sure I know about it.\nBut I'm going to ask for your appearances.\n\nWe have\n\n12\n\nquite a number of people on the line.\n\n13\n\nappearance first by plaintiff's counsel in these cases.\n\n14\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nLet me have the\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nGood morning.\n\nThis\n\n15\n\nis Sigrid McCawley from the law firm of Boies, Schiller &\n\n16\n\nFlexner, and I'm representing the plaintiffs in the actions\n\n17\n\nthat you listed.\n\n18\n\nMariella and Andrew Villacastin.\n\n19\n\nsummer associates who have joined the line as well.\n\nAlong with me, I have my colleague Sabina\nWe also have a few of our\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n21\n\nDo I have a court reporter on the line?\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT REPORTER:\n\n23\n24\n25\n\nAll right.\n\nYes.\n\nGood morning, Judge.\n\nThis\n\nis Kristen Carannante.\nTHE COURT:\n\nI'm going to ask anyone who is giving\n\nappearances for the record to please spell your name.\n\nSo,\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737825\n\n\f", "char_count": 1489}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 4 of 57\n\n4\n\nK5m2FarC\n\nMs. McCawley, if you could please spell your name and the names\nof your colleagues.\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nOf course.\n\nSigrid McCawley, which is\n\n4\n\nspelled S-I-G-R-I-D, and the last name is McCawley,\n\n5\n\nM-c-C-A-W-L-E-Y.\n\n6\n\nS-A-B-I-N-A M-A-R-I-E-L-L-A and Andrew Villacastin, and that's\n\n7\n\nA-N-D-R-E-W and Villacastin is V-I-L-L-A-C-A-S-T-I-N.\n\n8\n9\n\nI also have with me Sabina Mariella, which is\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYou are counsel in all of the cases that\n\nare on for today?\n\n10\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n12\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nCorrect.\n\nCorrect, your Honor.\n\nCan I have defendants' counsel, please?\nHi, your Honor.\n\nAgain, this is Bennet\n\n13\n\nMoskowitz, B-E-N-N-E-T, last name M-O-S-K-O-W-I-T-Z, at\n\n14\n\nTroutman Sanders, for the co-executors in each of these cases.\n\n15\n\nMy colleagues who handle the day-to-day discovery,\n\n16\n\nMatthew Aaronson and Valerie Sirota, are on.\n\nThat's Matthew is\n\n17\n\nM-A-T-T-H-E-W, last name is Aaronson, A-A-R-O-N-S-O-N; and\n\n18\n\nValerie, V-A-L-E-R-I-E, last name Sirota, S-I-R-O-T-A, and we\n\n19\n\nare counsel for the co-executors in each of these cases.\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right.\n\n21\n\nDo I have any other attorneys who are on or\n\n22\n\nrepresenting plaintiffs in any of the other cases that are\n\n23\n\npending before the court?\n\n24\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nNo.\n\nAll right.\n\nYour Honor --\n\nYes.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737826\n\n\f", "char_count": 1471}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 5 of 57\n\n5\n\nK5m2FarC\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nSorry.\n\nThis is a defendant's counsel\n\nfor Ms. Maxwell, Laura Menninger.\nTHE COURT:\n4\n\nII. MENNINGER:\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n6\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\n7\n\nM-E-N-N-I-N-G-E-R.\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n9\n10\n\nI am in the 10475 case.\n\nCan you spell your name, please?\nYes.\n\nOkay.\n\nIt is L-A-U-R-A\n\nAnd, again, are there any other\n\nattorneys on the line in any of the cases?\nAll right.\n\nI'm going to assume, then, that anyone\n\n11\n\nelse on the phone is public or press and just ask you to please\n\n12\n\nkeep your lines muted.\n\n13\n\nSometimes on these calls we hear beeps which suggest\n\n14\n\nthat someone else may have joined in the call.\n\n15\n\nsuggest that someone may have dropped off the call.\n\n16\n\nbecause of that, I will probably interrupt anyone who is\n\n17\n\nspeaking just to try to make sure that we didn't lose anybody\n\n18\n\nor we didn't gain anyone we should know about.\n\n19\n\ncourtroom where I can see people coming and going, so I just\n\n20\n\nlike to make sure we didn't accidentally lose one of the\n\n21\n\ncounsel who is supposed to be present.\n\n22\n\nadvance for the interruptions.\n\n23\n24\n25\n\nIt can also\nAnd\n\nIt is not a\n\nAnd I apologize in\n\nDo I have\n:\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes, Judge, I'm here.\nOkay.\n\nThat's one of my law clerks, just\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737827\n\n\f", "char_count": 1359}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 6 of 57\n\n6\n\nK5m2FarC\nso you know.\nAll right.\n\nSo I have letters in these cases.\n\nThey\n\nhave come in clusters of letter and response and reply in the\n4\n\nthree cases where Ms. Maxwell is not a party, and then there\n\n5\n\nare letters relating to her in the case where she is a party.\n\n6\n7\n\nLet me start with the other cases where she is not the\nparty and deal with those letters first.\n\n8\n\nCan I have, from Ms. McCawley, just a status update\n\n9\n\nfrom you where things stand with your current request, with\n\n10\n\nyour understanding about potential settlements?\n\n11\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\n12\n\nSo with respect to the requests, we have presented to\n\n13\n\nthe court a main threshold issue which has been unresolved at\n\n14\n\nthis point by the parties, and that is the issue of the time\n\n15\n\nperiod within which the defendants, the estate, will produce\n\n16\n\ndocuments.\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nThat issue remains unresolved.\n\n17\n\nIt is the plaintiffs' position that documents for the\n\n18\n\nentire relevant time period for each plaintiff, which runs from\n\n19\n\nthe date of their abuse, that year, to the present, are\n\n20\n\nresponsive and relevant to discovery in the case.\n\n21\n\nthe evidence with respect to any of the conduct that Epstein\n\n22\n\nwas engaging in over those years that would prove the abuse,\n\n23\n\nnot simply, as in a car crash case, you don't just get the\n\n24\n\nevidence of the date of the car crash, you get all evidence\n\n25\n\nrelating to anything that's relevant and could be used\n\nThat goes to\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737828\n\n\f", "char_count": 1601}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 7 of 57\n\n7\n\nK5m2FarC\npotentially at trial.\n\nSimilarly, here, the defendants have\n\nattempted to limit the production to simply the year of the\nabuse or years of the abuse, if it happened in more than one\n4\n\nyear.\n\n5\n\nover 20-year span of Epstein's abuse of not only our clients\n\n6\n\nbut other clients that are similarly situated, other women that\n\n7\n\nare similarly situated, is highly relevant to the discovery in\n\n8\n\nthis matter.\n\nIt is our position that all evidence relating to the\n\n9\n\nAnd of course, as your Honor knows, the plaintiff has\n\n10\n\nthe burden of proving her case in each of these instances, and\n\n11\n\nthe estate has taken the position of attempting to prove\n\n12\n\nEpstein's innocence, therefore making all of this information\n\n13\n\nhighly relevant for the entire time period.\n\n14\n\nThis is similar to other cases that have come before\n\n15\n\nin the Southern District of New York.\n\n16\n\nSweet, in his case with one of the victims, allowed discovery\n\n17\n\nfor the entire time period from 2000 to the present; and that\n\n18\n\nis, again, because, under 415, evidence of other abuse can be\n\n19\n\nadmissible at trial.\n\n20\n\nis highly relevant, and those documents need to be produced.\n\n21\n\nFor example, Judge\n\nSo we believe that the entire time period\n\nThe status of this, as of the date of filing our\n\n22\n\nletters, no documents have been produced.\n\nIn the last couple\n\n23\n\nof days, in\n\n24\n\nthere has been one document produced by the defendants.\n\n25\n\ncase of\n\ncase and in the Jane Doe 1000 case,\nIn the\n\nthere have been three documents produced,\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737829\n\n\f", "char_count": 1668}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 8 of 57\n\n8\n\nK5m2FarC\none of which was clawed back.\n\nAnd in the case of\n\nthere have been 90 documents produced, and that is on\ntheir side.\n4\n\nSo we are still in a position where we have not\n\n5\n\nreceived any substantial document production in this case.\n\n6\n\ncourt will remember that, back on January 28 -- the cases were\n\n7\n\nfiled in November.\n\n8\n\nhearing that you had in December asking them to preserve\n\n9\n\ndocuments, we sent a document preservation letter that outlined\n\n10\n\nin very specific detail the e-mail accounts for which we were\n\n11\n\naware of that Mr. Epstein had utilized.\n\n12\n\nThe\n\nBack on January 28 we sent -- after your\n\nYou are going to hear today, and you saw in the\n\n13\n\nfilings from the defendant about their claims of burdens, they\n\n14\n\nhave not justified burden at this point.\n\n15\n\naround a number of 700,000 documents.\n\n16\n\nhave already gone through 600,000 documents in just Annie's\n\n17\n\ncase alone for our production.\n\n18\n\nlist to show burden or otherwise establish why our request\n\n19\n\nwould be so burdensome.\n\n20\n\nThey have thrown\n\nI will tell you that we\n\nThey have not produced a hit\n\nSo with respect to -- and that is only -- now, they\n\n21\n\nare only still responding to the time period that is the one-\n\n22\n\nor two-year window, depending on the particular plaintiff.\n\n23\n\nat this stage we do not have -- that is still the threshold\n\n24\n\nissue that we are asking this court to resolve.\n\n25\n\nissue resolved before we can undertake depositions or get this\n\nSo\n\nWe need that\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737830\n\n\f", "char_count": 1624}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 9 of 57\n\n9\n\nK5m2FarC\ncase moving, because we at this point have no documents of any\nsubstance from the other side.\n\nSo that is the key issue that\n\nwe have put before the court for resolution.\n4\n\nThey have produced supplemental interrogatory\n\n5\n\nresponses.\n\n6\n\nthat they have set forth.\n\n7\n\ninformation for the entire time period at this point.\n\nAgain, those are still limited to the time period\nThey have not agreed to produce\n\n8\n\nSo that is the key issue that we put before the court\n\n9\n\nthat we need resolution on it in order to be able to move these\n\n10\n\ncases forward at this point.\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right.\n\nBefore I ask some questions\n\n12\n\nabout that, let me just ask about potential for settlement of\n\n13\n\nthese cases.\n\n14\n\nWhat is plaintiffs' understanding?\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nPotential for settlement in these\n\n15\n\ncases, as your Honor knows, there was the proposal of a\n\n16\n\npotential claims administration program that came about in the\n\n17\n\nfall of this past year.\n\n18\n\nof back-and-forth between the U.S. Virgin Islands' A.G. and the\n\n19\n\nestate, with input from the various plaintiffs' attorneys, as\n\n20\n\nwell.\n\n21\n\nheadway, but it has not yet been approved to move forward.\n\n22\n\nThere are still issues with respect to a release and other\n\n23\n\nmatters, so that has not gotten off the ground at all.\n\n24\n\nthere have been no substantive settlement discussions of any\n\n25\n\nkind in these cases.\n\nThat program has been through a series\n\nThe program has not yet been approved.\n\nIt has made\n\nSo\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737831\n\n\f", "char_count": 1626}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 10 of 57\n\n10\n\nK5m2FarC\nAnd, again, if -THE COURT:\n\nIf the program --\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSorry.\n\nIf the program gets off the ground, the\n\n5\n\nprogram as you understand it to be fashioned, would these\n\n6\n\nplaintiffs be likely to participate in it?\n\n7\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nWe would still have to have those final\n\n8\n\nconversations with the clients pending what the final outcome\n\n9\n\nof the program is, but they have all been interested in trying\n\n10\n\nto participate in a program if it does go forward.\n\n11\n\nOur concern, of course, is that that program has been\n\n12\n\ndelayed and has not moved forward, so we have had the need to\n\n13\n\npress\n\n14\n\nany offer that could be made could be very substandard, where\n\n15\n\nour clients would want to proceed with the merits of their\n\n16\n\naction, which is why we are here before the court trying to\n\n17\n\nseek resolution of our clients' claims, because there is no\n\n18\n\nguarantee with respect to that program whatsoever.\n\n19\n\nin a position where we need to and want to move forward with\n\n20\n\ndiscovery without further delay to be able to get to the merits\n\n21\n\nof our clients' claims.\n\n22\n\nforward with our case.\n\nOf course, in that program, too,\n\nSo we are\n\nAny discovery they would receive in these matters\n\n23\n\nwould be relevant anyway to those discussions with our\n\n24\n\npresenting claims to the claims administrator.\n\n25\n\nas coinciding and being relevant and responsive to Epstein\n\nSo we see that\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737832\n\n\f", "char_count": 1563}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 11 of 57\n\n11\n\nK5m2FarC\nbeing able to establish our claim, again, before the claims\nadministrator.\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right.\n\nAnd going back to your request\n\n4\n\nto compel discovery from defendant, you say that the time frame\n\n5\n\nis the issue.\n\n6\n\nto say in general you hadn't gotten discovery responses to\n\n7\n\ndocument requests or interrogatories, and then you highlighted\n\n8\n\nthis issue.\n\n9\n\nare there other issues with respect to just not getting\n\n10\n\nresponses?\n\n11\n\nI believe the letter was presented, it appeared\n\nIs this really the key issue or the only issue or\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nWell, you are correct, your Honor.\n\nAt\n\n12\n\nthe time we wrote the initial letter, the responses were\n\n13\n\nthere were not responses, there were just objections.\n\n14\n\nhave since supplemented their responses but, again, limiting it\n\n15\n\nonly to the time frame.\n\n16\n\nresponses, because at this point we only can see them as to the\n\n17\n\ntime period within which they are saying the abuse victims --\n\n18\n\nthat time period where they were abused, so we don't believe\n\n19\n\nthat they are fulsome at this point.\n\n20\n\nresolve the threshold issue of whether or not they have to\n\n21\n\nproduce for the entire time period, they would then supplement,\n\n22\n\nor our assumption is that they would supplement their responses\n\n23\n\nboth to interrogatories and to the requests for production, and\n\n24\n\nthen we could evaluate at that point if it appears there is\n\n25\n\nanything missing.\n\nThey\n\nSo we still may have issues with those\n\nBut if the court could\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737833\n\n\f", "char_count": 1637}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 12 of 57\n\n12\n\nK5m2FarC\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd why would it not be the case that,\n\ndocument request by document request or interrogatory by\ninterrogatory, the inquiry might be different as to what time\n4\n\nframe would be appropriate to look at?\n\n5\n\ndepending upon how the request is framed, where it would be\n\n6\n\nappropriate to look at a longer time frame; and there may be\n\n7\n\nsome, based on the nature of the request, where that would not\n\n8\n\nmake sense to look at a longer time frame.\n\n9\n\ndoing this on a global basis?\n\n10\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nThere might be some,\n\nWhy should I be\n\nWell, that's a very fair question, your\n\n11\n\nHonor.\n\n12\n\nrelated -- like the request number one is information related\n\n13\n\nto the plaintiff including diary, diaries, journals, calendars,\n\n14\n\nany information, travel itineraries that relate to that\n\n15\n\nplaintiff, and that could be in any time period.\n\n16\n\nif Epstein's last year was talking about one of our client's\n\n17\n\nand had information that he had recorded in an e-mail about one\n\n18\n\nof our clients, that would be responsive.\n\n19\n\nSo the requests, for example, seek information\n\nFor example,\n\nSo the time period does pertain, in my view, to all of\n\n20\n\nthe requests.\n\nWe have not -- they have not come to us and said\n\n21\n\na particular request only applies for these reasons to one\n\n22\n\nparticular year.\n\n23\n\nflight logs, if there are not flight logs in a certain year,\n\n24\n\nthey would only produce what they have, obviously.\n\n25\n\nhave flight logs for the entire time period, we would want\n\nIn my view, the request, for example, for\n\nBut if they\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737834\n\n\f", "char_count": 1701}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 13 of 57\n\n13\n\nK5m2FarC\nthose.\n\nSo it is -- your Honor is correct that there can be\n\nsome request-specific issues, but they haven't agreed to\nproduce anything outside of the year of the abuse at this\n4\n\npoint.\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAre there some requests that relate to\n\n6\n\npeople other than your clients?\n\n7\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n9\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\n10\n\nSo as I said before, it is our position that, with\n\nYes.\n\nOther than -For example -- yes.\n\n11\n\nrespect to our clients' claims in each of the cases,\n\n12\n\ninformation relating to Epstein's abuse of other victims is\n\n13\n\nhighly relevant under 415, particularly to establish that this\n\n14\n\npattern of luring in young girls in the same way, for example,\n\n15\n\nwith saying they are interviewing for a modeling job or saying\n\n16\n\nthey are coming for an assistant's interview, the pattern of\n\n17\n\nhow he lured girls in, then abused them is relevant to our\n\n18\n\nclients presenting their claims to the jury to prove the truth\n\n19\n\nof the fact that they have before, as well, abused in a similar\n\n20\n\nmanner.\n\n21\n\nrelevant to the case.\n\n22\n\nSo we firmly believe that that information is highly\n\nAgain, the estate has taken the position, and you have\n\n23\n\nseen it in our filings, that Epstein is innocent, and we have\n\n24\n\nto prove the truth of that, as well as with respect to all of\n\n25\n\nthese cases.\n\nSo we are in a position where we are having to\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737835\n\n\f", "char_count": 1519}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 14 of 57\n\n14\n\nK5m2FarC\nfight to get discovery from the estate.\n\nI would was certainly\n\nhoping it would not be this kind of a battle.\n\nI was hoping\n\nthat now that he is no longer taking his Fifth Amendment\n4\n\nprivileges, no longer with us, that we would be able to get\n\n5\n\nsubstantive discovery in a more streamlined manner, but that is\n\n6\n\nnot the case.\n\n7\n\nAnd any threshold issue is very important because it\n\n8\n\nimplicates our clients' ability to be able to present their\n\n9\n\ncase and to be able to substantively be able to depose witness.\n\n10\n\nAs your Honor knows our discovery deadline is looming in early\n\n11\n\nJuly.\n\n12\n\npeople who either interacted with our clients or who were\n\n13\n\nwitnesses to the abuses that occurred in Epstein's various\n\n14\n\nhomes, and we need the information and the documents from his\n\n15\n\nfiles that establish and relate to the abuse, and those are the\n\n16\n\nrequests that we have put forward.\n\n17\n18\n\nWe need to be able to take the depositions of various\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right.\n\nI have some thoughts on this,\n\nbut let me hear from defendants first.\n\n19\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nHi, your Honor.\n\nBennet Moskowitz.\n\n20\n\nIf I may, I would like to address the program issue\n\n21\n\nfirst, which I think is much quicker than the discovery.\n\n22\n\ncolleague, Matt Aaronson, will discuss the discovery issues, if\n\n23\n\nthat's okay.\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n25\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nMy\n\nOkay.\nSo I am very, very surprised to hear\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737836\n\n\f", "char_count": 1552}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 15 of 57\n\n15\n\nK5m2FarC\nMs. McCawley give a presentation that seems like her clients\nare lukewarm on the program.\nweek where Brad\n\nShe is on the e-mails from this\n\n, who represents five plaintiffs and we\n\n4\n\nunderstand the vast majority of claimants all of whom want to\n\n5\n\nparticipate in the program according to him, announced to us on\n\n6\n\nthe estate side that he was able to get the Attorney General to\n\n7\n\nfinally step aside and let the program move forward.\n\n8\n\nfirst surprise is hearing that Ms. McCawley thinks that the\n\n9\n\nprogram is still in some vast limbo.\n\n10\n\nreasons that I discussed this morning, which Ms. McCawley is\n\n11\n\naware of.\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nHold on a second.\n\nSo my\n\nIt is not for all of the\n\nWe have two separate\n\n13\n\nconferences.\n\n14\n\nyou say that we discussed this morning, Ms. McCawley, unless\n\n15\n\nshe didn't announce herself, was not on that call and doesn't\n\n16\n\nknow what you said at that conference.\n\nOne was at 10:00 and this one is 11:00.\n\n17\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nSure.\n\n18\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\n(Inaudible).\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n20\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\n21\n\nI was unaware of the 10:00 conference call.\n\n22\n23\n\nSo when\n\nI'm sorry?\nI'm sorry.\n\nThis is Sigrid McCawley.\nI'm\n\nsorry.\nTHE COURT:\n\nWe had a conference call in certain of the\n\n24\n\nother cases with different plaintiffs' counsel where there were\n\n25\n\nsomewhat different issues raised.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737837\n\n\f", "char_count": 1483}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 16 of 57\n\n16\n\nK5m2FarC\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\nTHE COURT:\n\nSure.\n\nAnd I am trying --\n\nI'm trying to cluster these so we don't\n\nhave to have a marathon session with all cases at once.\n4\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nI am happy to concisely, as best I\n\n5\n\ncan, go through the same points, and I will say now that I know\n\n6\n\nMs. McCawley knows all of the following with perhaps one\n\n7\n\nexception, which I will explain.\n\n8\n\nMs. McCawley knows that around 69 individual\n\n9\n\nclaimants, including her clients, have publicly come forward to\n\n10\n\nvoice overwhelming support for the program, including to the\n\n11\n\nUSVI probate court.\n\n12\n\nclaimants.\n\n13\n\ncourt plaintiff who has publicly said that she is not\n\n14\n\nparticipating, and that was through her counsel, and I don't\n\n15\n\neven know if that's that person's current position.\n\n16\n\nWe know that is the vast majority of known\n\nWe are aware of only one claimant who is a state\n\nMs. McCawley also knows that seven plaintiffs in the\n\n17\n\nSDNY action, including one of her clients,\n\n18\n\nrecently stayed their actions in favor of the program.\n\n19\n\nbears mentioning that\n\n20\n\nstipulation in that regard goes contrary to everything\n\n21\n\nMs. McCawley just said.\n\n22\n\n, most\nIt\n\n-- you know, the\n\nYour Honor entered that order, so I don't think I need\n\n23\n\nto repeat it verbatim.\n\nBut mentioned in there was the notion\n\n24\n\nof conserving resources, and in that regard, as a side note, it\n\n25\n\nbears mentioning that Boies Schiller has been the biggest\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737838\n\n\f", "char_count": 1589}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 17 of 57\n\n17\n\nK5m2FarC\nculprit in driving up the estate's litigation cost, money that\nwill never be available for their clients or other alleged\nvictims in the program.\n\nWe don't understand that.\n\nWe were\n\n4\n\nstaffed very leanly until recently, just me and an associate.\n\n5\n\nFive attorneys on their side, including three partners.\n\n6\n\nlawyers, my colleagues are on now for the team more recently,\n\n7\n\nbecause Boies Schiller takes the most unreasonable positions on\n\n8\n\ndiscovery, grossly overbroad view -- again, Mr. Aaronson will\n\n9\n\nget to that -- and they make the most constant threat to motion\n\n10\n\npractice notwithstanding their clients participating in the\n\n11\n\nprogram.\n\nI have\n\n12\n\nMs. McCawley also knows that the protocol for the\n\n13\n\nprogram, which was done in close consultation between the\n\n14\n\nadministrator and designers and claimants' counsel, including\n\n15\n\nhers, her firm, and with -- in between co-executors is nearly\n\n16\n\nfinalized.\n\n17\n\nAnd Ms. McCawley also knows the only reason this\n\n18\n\nhasn't gone forward until now was because of the USVI Attorney\n\n19\n\nGeneral.\n\n20\n\nin an email that Ms. McCawley is on that that last, quote,\n\n21\n\nlingering issue, as Mr.\n\n22\n\nagain, there are a few less contentious matters to iron out,\n\n23\n\nbut it is our firm expectation that by sometime next week that\n\n24\n\nresolution in principle will be formalized.\n\n25\n\nBut again, Mr.\n\nThe sole thing that\n\nannounced a couple of days ago\n\nput it, is now resolved.\n\nAnd,\n\nnot be aware of\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737839\n\n\f", "char_count": 1613}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-1O577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 18 of 57\n\n18\n\nK5m2FarC\nis that if something unexpected happens and that resolution in\nprinciple is not finalized, then by June 15, our current intent\non the estate side is to move forward with the program absent\n4\n\nthe probate court entering an order directing us not to or\n\n5\n\notherwise impeding that, and I don't think that's going to\n\n6\n\nhappen because another person who has voiced support for the\n\n7\n\nprogram is the probate judge who, on February 4, at a hearing\n\n8\n\nthat Ms. McCawley attended, as did David Boies, the probate\n\n9\n\njudge said the following:\n\n10\n\nbelieves this program is a great program.\"\n\n\"I think we agreed that everybody\n\n11\n\nSo I will say that I don't understand why we get one\n\n12\n\ndisplay of overwhelming support from Boies Schiller and others\n\n13\n\nwhen we are not before your Honor, and then we come before your\n\n14\n\nHonor and I hear a different story.\n\n15\n\nforward very soon.\n\n16\n\nthat, per Ms. McCawley's own statements, all of her clients,\n\n17\n\nnot just the one who stayed her action already, are going to\n\n18\n\nparticipate.\n\n19\n\nmeantime is money that will never be available for that\n\n20\n\nprogram.\n\n21\n\nThe program is going to go\n\nI am confident of that.\n\nAnd I'm confident\n\nSo, again, every dollar we are spending in the\n\nThat's all I have to say on the program aspect.\n\n22\n\nUnless your Honor has questions, I will refer to my colleague,\n\n23\n\nMr. Aaronson, to address the discovery issues.\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n25\n\nMR. AARONSON:\n\nLet me hear the discovery issues.\nGood morning, your Honor.\n\nMatthew\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737840\n\n\f", "char_count": 1653}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 19 of 57\n\n19\n\nK5m2FarC\nAaronson.\nI want to correct a couple of misstatements that\nMs. McCawley made.\n4\n\nIt is not the estate's position that documents that\n\n5\n\nrelate to the claims asserted by the plaintiffs will not be\n\n6\n\nproduced.\n\n7\n\nidentified that to the extent the request seeks information\n\n8\n\nabout plaintiffs, they will be produced.\n\n9\n10\n\nWe also identified to your Honor in the letter that we\nsent to you --\n\n11\n12\n\nIn fact, all of our discovery responses have\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nHold on.\n\nLet me interrupt you.\n\nWithout\n\nregard to time frame or only within a specific time frame?\n\n13\n\nMR. AARONSON:\n\nI was about to clarify that.\n\nWe said\n\n14\n\nin our letter to your Honor without regard to time frame with\n\n15\n\nrespect to the plaintiffs.\n\n16\n\nthat, your Honor, the problem we have here is, we were still\n\n17\n\nunder the impression we were meeting and conferring with\n\n18\n\nplaintiffs' counsel on these issues, and we put that in our\n\n19\n\nletter.\n\n20\n\nwould consider their positions, and before we could even\n\n21\n\nconclude that, they filed a letter with the court.\n\n22\n\nare aware, our initial letter to the court said that we were\n\n23\n\nsort of surprised by that and we are saying it is premature.\n\n24\n\nWe still think these issues are premature.\n\n25\n\nAnd in fact, that is something\n\nAnd before we could even -- you know, we told them we\n\nI think you\n\nBut the simple fact is, your Honor, our position is we\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737841\n\n\f", "char_count": 1533}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 20 of 57\n\n20\n\nK5m2FarC\nare producing any documents that reference orally to the\nplaintiffs.\n\nAnd in fact we have searched documents for that.\n\nSo there is no dispute there, there is no issue there.\n4\n\nWe are not saying that the time period for documents\n\n5\n\nrelating to plaintiff is limited in that way, shape, or form.\n\n6\n\nWhat we did say was, these are events in some situations,\n\n7\n\n, incidents that happened on one day in 2002, and\n\n8\n\nwe are saying it is not proportional to ask for our client, the\n\n9\n\nestate, to search for documents relating to a 20 -- I guess it\n\n10\n\nwould be a 19-year period, your Honor, relating to people who\n\n11\n\nmay have worked at a property that Mr. Epstein owned and in\n\n12\n\nfact property that Mr. Epstein --\n\n13\n\never visited.\n\ndoesn't allege she\n\nYou know, it's a scope issue.\n\n14\n\nBut, again, to the extent there is an allegation that\n\n15\n\n-- I'm sorry, there is a document that references\nwe have agreed to produce it.\n\n16\n17\n\ndocuments.\n\n18\n19\n\nWe searched for those\n\nAnd the same applies for all of the plaintiffs.\n\nSo I want to make it very clear that that is a\nmisstatement of what our position is.\n\n20\n\nYou know, again, the scope here is just so overbroad,\n\n21\n\nbeyond plaintiff, that we think it is not proportional to the\n\n22\n\ncase.\n\n23\n\nthat any of that discovery is necessary for her to prove her\n\n24\n\nclaims.\n\n25\n\nThat's the claim in this case.\n\nWe disagree completely with Ms. McCawley's statement\n\nHer claims in this case are a simple claim of battery.\nThat's her burden to prove and\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737842\n\n\f", "char_count": 1658}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 21 of 57\n\n21\n\nK5m2FarC\nthat is it.\n\nAnd we have agreed to provide documents that\n\nrelate to her claims.\n\nIf she says she was at a property on a\n\ncertain date, we have identified to the best of our ability\n4\n\npeople who may have been at that property that date.\n\n5\n\nYou know, I'm not sure what more we are obligated to\n\n6\n\ndo, your Honor.\n\n7\n\nhave complaints about search terms, then meet with us to talk\n\n8\n\nabout search terms.\n\n9\n\nran into court.\n\n10\n\nbeen open to a dialogue to try to resolve these issues.\n\n11\n\nas we told you, they prematurely went to court to try to -- you\n\n12\n\nknow, to try to get in front of your Honor before we could even\n\n13\n\nfinish that.\n\n14\n\nAnd this is a part of the problem.\n\nIf they\n\nBefore we could finish the process, they\n\nWe are open to a dialogue.\n\nWe have always\nBut,\n\nWe have a lot of requests, your Honor, that are just\n\n15\n\ncompletely unrelated to these cases.\n\n16\n\nappropriate now to go through each one right now.\n\n17\n\nwanted to clarify that this concept that it is a -- we are not\n\n18\n\nagreeing to produce documents about the plaintiffs is wholly\n\n19\n\nuntrue, and I just wanted to make that very clear.\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\nI don't think it's\nBut I just\n\nSo let me go back on plaintiffs'\n\n21\n\nside.\n\nI'm not going to make any blanket ruling, and I'm not\n\n22\n\npersuaded that you have conferred fully in good faith before\n\n23\n\nbringing the motion, in part, because you have already said\n\n24\n\nthat some of it is moot because in fact when you got responses,\n\n25\n\nyou no longer had a complete absence of information, and now\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737843\n\n\f", "char_count": 1691}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 22 of 57\n\n22\n\nK5m2FarC\nyou are really just focused on the time frame issue.\n\nThat\n\ntells me that when you wrote the initial letter you hadn't\nconferred fully in good faith to see what really had to be put\n4\n5\n\nbefore the court.\nWith respect to the time frame issue, it sounds like\n\n6\n\ndefendant is prepared to and planning to produce documents\n\n7\n\nwithout regard to time frame that refer to your clients or\n\n8\n\nrelate to your clients, and it also sounds like defendants are\n\n9\n\nwilling to confer with respect to other requests.\n\n10\n\nAs far as those other requests go, the test for\n\n11\n\nrelevance is not whether something is relevant to a general\n\n12\n\nsubject matter of a case, it's whether it is relevant to a\n\n13\n\nclaim or defense asserted in the case.\n\n14\n\nto some of the requests where time frame is at issue that the\n\n15\n\ndocuments sought are in fact highly relevant to a defense\n\n16\n\nthat's been asserted in the case, for example.\n\n17\n\nthey are tangentially relevant.\n\nIt may be the burden is great.\n\n18\n\nIt may be the burden is modest.\n\nIt may be that\n\n19\n\nmake sure I didn't lose counsel.\n\nIt may be with respect\n\n20\n\nDo I still have plaintiffs' counsel?\n\n21\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n23\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n25\n\nIt may be that\n\nlet me just\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nDo I still have defendants' counsel?\nYes, your Honor.\n\nOkay.\n\nIf anyone joined from the public or\n\npress, I will please ask you to mute your phone.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737844\n\n\f", "char_count": 1558}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 23 of 57\n\n23\n\nK5m2FarC\nDid anyone join who is an attorney in one of the cases\nin front of me?\n\nNo.\n\nAll right.\n\nI lost the thread a little bit of what I was saying,\n4\n\nbut the point is that if this is in front of me with\n\n5\n\nparticularized disputes, I'm going to have to look at each\n\n6\n\ndocument request at issue or each interrogatory at issue, hear\n\n7\n\nfrom the parties about the particular relevance to a claim or a\n\n8\n\ndefense, hear from the defendant about the particular arguable\n\n9\n\nlack of relevance or burden, and make item-by-item\n\n10\n\ndeterminations.\n\n11\n\nand you are going to have to confer on that kind of level to\n\n12\n\nget it focused for me, if it comes back to me, so that I\n\n13\n\nunderstand just what the documents are that are being sought,\n\n14\n\njust what the claim of relevance is, just what the purported\n\n15\n\nburden is, just what the proportionality is so that I can make\n\n16\n\nthat assessment balancing relevant factors.\n\n17\n\nI'm not going to do it in a blanket fashion,\n\nNow, the other issue that we have is resources and\n\n18\n\nsettlement and whether the dollars that are spent by\n\n19\n\ndefendants in litigating the case and responding to discovery\n\n20\n\nrequests might be better spent by being put into a fund if\n\n21\n\nplaintiffs are planning to participate in that and whether it\n\n22\n\nis a consideration that I should take into account, whether we\n\n23\n\nshould have any kind of extended period of time for the\n\n24\n\nresponses so that you can see if you are going to participate\n\n25\n\nin the program if the kinks are worked out.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737845\n\n\f", "char_count": 1668}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 24 of 57\n\n24\n\nK5m2FarC\nIn the earlier conference we had today, what I did was\nallow the parties to have a bit of a hiatus in their cases, to\nconserve resources, asking for a status letter by June 19 with\n4\n\nthe understanding that the estate was planning to move forward\n\n5\n\nwith the program no later than June 15 absent something they\n\n6\n\nthought would be extraordinary to stop it from doing so.\n\n7\n\nSo on plaintiffs' side, let me hear whether you think\n\n8\n\nit makes sense to give it a window of time before there is\n\n9\n\nincreased attorney's fees spent to see if in fact that program\n\n10\n\nis moving forward and you might be participating in it.\n\n11\n\nAnd in any event, let me hear what you have to say\n\n12\n\nabout my view that perhaps you should be conferring further in\n\n13\n\ngood faith about these time frame issues on a\n\n14\n\nrequest-by-request basis.\n\n15\n16\n17\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nOf course, your Honor.\n\nThis is Sigrid\n\nMcCawley for the plaintiff.\nWith respect to the issue of a hiatus, my concern\n\n18\n\nthere would be that we, as you know, back in November, talked\n\n19\n\nabout this program, and while Mr. Moskowitz has made\n\n20\n\nrepresentations on this call, you will understand that those\n\n21\n\nwere the same representations that he was making back in\n\n22\n\nDecember and January and, for a number of reasons, that program\n\n23\n\nhas just not moved forward.\n\n24\n\nthis June 15 date that I have not heard before.\n\n25\n\nNow I'm hearing for the first time\n\nThe problem I see with any kind of hiatus\n\nand, to\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737846\n\n\f", "char_count": 1620}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 25 of 57\n\n25\n\nK5m2FarC\nbe clear, we don't want to, of course, expend unnecessary\nestate resources.\n\nThe issue that I have with that is it is the\n\ncontinued delay and the part of the disadvantage to my clients\n4\n\nin that they don't have information, all of the information\n\n5\n\nthey need relevant to their claims because they haven't\n\n6\n\nreceived\n\n7\n\nreceived substantial production in the case of any kind.\n\n8\n\neven though we have tried diligently, they have not\n\nSo with respect to a hiatus, my concern would be that\n\n9\n\nright now our discovery deadline is set for early July.\n\n10\n\nwere hoping to get documents in order to be able to start\n\n11\n\ntaking some of the necessary depositions to get information for\n\n12\n\nour case to be able to move it forward, and I believe that is\n\n13\n\nsomething that we would be entitled to.\n\n14\n\nconcern is that, again, it would be a July 15 date, then it\n\n15\n\nwould be -- I'm sorry, a June 15 date, then a July 15 date, and\n\n16\n\nit would continue without us being able to move the case\n\n17\n\nforward.\n\nWe\n\nI think that my\n\n18\n\nAlso, as you know, the claims program is voluntary\n\n19\n\nSo to the extent that a client does participate in that and\n\n20\n\ngets paused, we don't know what that claims administration\n\n21\n\nprogram is going to ultimately prove to be.\n\n22\n\nthat a client participates and is offered something or not\n\n23\n\noffered anything, their case should be moving forward so that\n\n24\n\nthey are able to go to trial on the merits of their claims, if\n\n25\n\nthey need to, against the estate.\n\nSo to the extent\n\nSo that would be my concern\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737847\n\n\f", "char_count": 1696}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 26 of 57\n\n26\n\nK5m2FarC\nwith making any change at this point.\nAgain, we are not -- the discovery, in my view, has\nmoved very, very slowly.\n\nSo just to pull back and not have\n\n4\n\nthem continue to engage with us on discovery, in my view, would\n\n5\n\nbe problematic, because it would just further delay the case.\n\n6\n7\n\nSo those are my concerns generally with respect to\nthat.\n\n8\n\nAnd, again, I'm hearing from the other side this June\n\n9\n\n15 date that I have no confidence that that is something that\n\n10\n\nwill necessarily move forward because we don't have anything in\n\n11\n\nwriting with respect to that or any statement from the court in\n\n12\n\nthe USVI that they have approved that or anything of that\n\n13\n\nnature.\n\n14\n\nSo that was my concern there.\nWith respect to the issue before the court, we are in\n\n15\n\na position where the time frame issue is significantly\n\n16\n\nproblematic to us for the reasons that I have outlined.\n\n17\n\nthey are representing to the court today that they will produce\n\n18\n\ndocuments related to the plaintiff, you will remember that we\n\n19\n\nhave --\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWhile\n\nWhat did they say in their responses that\n\n21\n\nyou got in?\n\n22\n\nis it just they are saying this for the first time to the court\n\n23\n\ntoday?\n\n24\n25\n\nDid they say these documents will be produced or\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nWith respect to the plaintiff, they\n\nrepresented they would run the name of the plaintiff in their\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737848\n\n\f", "char_count": 1528}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 27 of 57\n\n27\n\nK5m2FarC\ndiscovery searches and produce with respect to the plaintiff,\nyes, that they did.\nTHE COURT:\n\nWhy --\n\n4\n\nMS.McCAWLEY:\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nBut the problem --\n\nWhy did you tell me earlier on in the call\n\n6\n\nthat they were refusing to produce any documents for the later\n\n7\n\ntime frame even with regard to the plaintiff?\n\n8\n\nMS.McCAWLEY:\n\n9\n\nposition, your Honor.\n\n10\n\nwell, first of all, they have only produced one document for\n\n11\n\nThat is my understanding of their\nI am hearing now that they are saying\n\ncase, one document for Jane Doe's case.\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWait a minute, wait a minute.\n\nThis is\n\n13\n\ncomplete lack of meaningful dialogue between the parties,\n\n14\n\nbecause I'm hearing opposite things from the parties about what\n\n15\n\ndefendants' position is.\n\n16\n\nthis call, has said that they will, and have told you that they\n\n17\n\nwill, produce documents regardless of time frame if they refer\n\n18\n\nor relate to the plaintiff, and that they are doing that in\n\n19\n\nfact in all cases and have not taken a position that they would\n\n20\n\nnot.\n\n21\n\nposition, that they will not.\n\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nDefendant, as I understand it from\n\nAnd you are saying that is your understanding of their\n\nHow can that be if you have had a good conference\nbetween you?\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nYour Honor, as we set forth in our\n\nletter, we did have a two-hour conference where we asked them\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737849\n\n\f", "char_count": 1505}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-1O577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 28 of 57\n\n28\n\nK5m2FarC\nabout the time frame issues and made sure to get the full\nposition on that because that was our biggest concern.\n\nAnd\n\nthat is what we discretely presented to the court because that\n4\n\nwas the concern we have, that they were not going to be\n\n5\n\nproducing anything beyond the time period of the abuse.\n\n6\n\n(Indiscernible crosstalk)\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n-- discretely presented to the court.\n\nYou\n\n8\n\npresented to the court in your opening letter that there was a\n\n9\n\ncomplete failure to respond to any of the requests, and now you\n\n10\n\ntell me on the call that since then there has been a response,\n\n11\n\nand so what is now being discretely presented on this telephone\n\n12\n\ncall is what you say is a remaining issue, which seems like it\n\n13\n\nis only a remaining issue in part because it seemed like if\n\n14\n\nthere are documents specifically relating or referring to the\n\n15\n\nplaintiff, defendants have agreed to produce it and according\n\n16\n\nto defendants have told you they have agreed to produce it in\n\n17\n\ntheir responses that you have since gotten.\n\n18\n\nseen those responses.\n\n19\n\nsorry, I have not reviewed them.\n\n20\n\nFor that matter, I'm not sure I have all of the requests, I'm\n\n21\n\nnot sure I have an item-by-item explanation of relevance, and\n\n22\n\nI'm not sure that your discussion has been adequate between the\n\n23\n\nlawyers.\n\n24\n25\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nNow, I haven't\n\nIf they have been put before me, I'm\nI don't think I have them.\n\nYour Honor, this is Sigrid McCawley for\n\nthe plaintiff.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737850\n\n\f", "char_count": 1635}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 29 of 57\n\n29\n\nK5m2FarC\nI appreciate that.\n\nI am hearing your Honor.\n\nWe will\n\ngo back and address these issues again with the defendants in\nthe hopes of being able to resolve them and not hopefully have\n4\n\nto come before the court with respect to them.\n\n5\n\nhopeful to be able to get discovery in this case.\n\n6\n\nbelieve that has been the situation that we are in presently,\n\n7\n\nand that's why we have presented it to the court.\n\n8\n\nunderstand your point, your Honor, and we will make sure to\n\n9\n\nengage further in the hopes of being able to resolve this.\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right.\n\nWe are, again,\nWe do not\n\nBut I\n\nLet me ask, on defendants'\n\n11\n\nside, by when do you plan to produce -- assuming we have no\n\n12\n\nstay of discovery here and no hiatus, by when do you plan to\n\n13\n\nproduce the documents referring or relating to plaintiff?\n\n14\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nWe have already started that, your\n\n15\n\nHonor.\n\n16\n\nLet me let Mr. Aaronson address that question.\n\n17\n\ncan, I would like to just very quickly respond to something\n\n18\n\nMs. McCawley said about the program.\n\nBennet Moskowitz, excuse me.\n\nAnd in fact, I apologize.\nAnd then, if I\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nLet me hear first about the documents --\n\n20\n\nMR. AARONSON:\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n22\n\nMR. AARONSON:\n\n23\n\nWe have already started the production.\n\nYes --\n\n-- regarding the production.\nYes, your Honor.\n\nMatthew Aaronson.\nWe made a\n\n24\n\nproduction I believe on Wednesday of documents, and I think in\n\n25\n\nparticular\n\nit was over 100 documents.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737851\n\n\f", "char_count": 1614}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 30 of 57\n\n30\n\nK5m2FarC\nSo with the process underway -- and, again, I think,\nyour Honor, you have gotten this correct, is that we have told\nthem that we will produce and search for -- search for and\n4\n\nproduce documents that relate to their clients.\n\n5\n\nthat they think we need to add additional search terms, we\n\n6\n\nsearched the individual plaintiffs' names.\n\n7\n\nadditional search terms, we are open to a dialogue to discuss\n\n8\n\nthat.\n\n9\n\nor not we can reach agreements on those terms.\n\n10\n\nthing --\n\n11\n\nTo the extent\n\nIf there are\n\nIf there are additional terms, as in every case, whether\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYou know, the\n\nI would like to put a deadline on getting\n\n12\n\nthe production complete with respect to any documents that in\n\n13\n\nany way refer or relate to the plaintiffs after you have had\n\n14\n\nsome further discussion perhaps on search terms, if necessary.\n\n15\n\nBut I would like to have a firm date when you are not just\n\n16\n\nproducing a few documents and a few documents and say it is\n\n17\n\nunderway, that that actually gets produced.\n\n18\n\nMR. AARONSON:\n\nOnce --\n\nThat's fair, your Honor.\n\nPart of that\n\n19\n\ngoes back to the same issue you raised earlier about the\n\n20\n\nexpenditure of time and money on discovery issues versus\n\n21\n\nputting it towards the program.\n\n22\n\nSo to the extent the court is not inclined to issue a\n\n23\n\npause or some sort of temporary issue on that, it's hard to\n\n24\n\nsay.\n\n25\n\nsearch all of our files, given the pandemic.\n\nThe problem we have is that, you know, it is difficult to\nSome files have\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737852\n\n\f", "char_count": 1653}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 31 of 57\n\n31\n\nK5m2FarC\nnot been able to be collected yet.\n\nSo I can tell you that, of\n\nthe electronic documents that we have collected, I think we can\nkeep that probably within 30 days of what we have collected\n4\n5\n6\n7\n\nalready.\nBut I will tell you, we have done the initial pass of\nthat, and we have made those productions.\n\nAs I said,\n\nthere was a significant number of documents.\n\nPresumably\n\n8\n\nother plaintiffs there were not.\n\n9\n\nit would be appropriate (unintelligible) some of this, but to\n\n10\n\nthe extent the court is not inclined to do that, you know, I\n\n11\n\nthink 30 days for what we have.\n\n12\n\ndon't know that we have collected every, you know, source at\n\n13\n\nthis point in time, given our inability to collect documents\n\n14\n\ndues to the pandemic.\n\n15\n16\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo, again, we do believe that\n\nBut to be clear, your Honor, I\n\nHow has the pandemic affected your ability\n\nto collect documents specifically?\nMR. AARONSON:\n\nI will let Mr. Moskowitz speak to that,\n\n18\n\nbut my understanding is, you know, that we have not been able\n\n19\n\nto access and people are not traveling to different locations.\n\n20\n\nSo we have collected electronic documents.\n\n21\n\nI'm deferring to Mr. Moskowitz on that, whether or not the\n\n22\n\nadditional documents are still out there.\n\n23\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n24\n\nclarify that point, your Honor.\n\n25\n\nYes.\n\nI'm not\n\nBennet Moskowitz.\n\nagain,\n\nHappy to\n\nThere are two -- let me take a step back.\n\nYes.\n\nIt is\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737853\n\n\f", "char_count": 1568}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 32 of 57\n\n32\n\nK5m2FarC\ntrue that we have collected over 700 and I think 40,000\ndocuments, and we did search them for the plaintiffs' names.\nAnd we did produce what we found that wasn't privileged, and we\n4\n\nwill go back and make sure that that is complete.\n\n5\n\nthat we located many documents for\n\n6\n\ndated to as late as I believe last year and have already been\n\n7\n\nproduced, so I don't understand Ms. McCawley's confusion about\n\n8\n\nthe time frame issue.\n\n9\n\nthose but didn't find such documents for the other cases just\n\n10\n\nevidences a lack of documents, not something wrong with the\n\n11\n\nsearch process.\n\n12\n\nBut the fact\n, which were\n\nBut in any event, the fact that we found\n\nIn terms of the pandemic difficulties, my problem with\n\n13\n\nmaking a 30-day blanket representation is that there are at\n\n14\n\nleast some hard copy files that I would like certain people to\n\n15\n\nlook through, and while I have no reason one way or the other\n\n16\n\nto expect their responsive materials are there, I would like\n\n17\n\nthat to happen before such deadline, and I'm not 100 percent\n\n18\n\ncertain that it can, because at least some of the documents are\n\n19\n\nin places that are still under lockdown or there are still\n\n20\n\nhealth concerns.\n\n21\n\nIn addition to that, this is somewhat subject to the\n\n22\n\ndisputes about the scope of the discovery.\n\nIf Ms. McCawley is,\n\n23\n\nlet's say, correct and these cases -- everything related to any\n\n24\n\nallegedly bad thing Mr. Epstein ever did is relevant in each\n\n25\n\naction, well, then, it could take me, you know, six months or a\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737854\n\n\f", "char_count": 1679}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 33 of 57\n\n33\n\nK5m2FarC\nyear to finish looking for every piece of paper and every\nproperty Mr. Epstein owned.\n\nSo, again, it's with the context\n\nof just searching for names.\n\nMr. Aaronson is correct, that can\n\n4\n\nbe done in the next 30 days, with the exception of anything\n\n5\n\nthat we can't actually access to look through.\n\n6\n\nAnd again I have --\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n8\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYou have already -Yes.\n\nYou already have the documents\n\n10\n\nelectronically, at least certain of the documents, most of the\n\n11\n\ndocuments.\n\n12\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes.\n\nAnd you have already gone through them and\n\n14\n\nyou have already made some production.\n\n15\n\nanother 30 days before you can get to the end of that\n\n16\n\nparticular road?\n\n17\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nWe may not.\n\nWhy would you need\n\nIt really depends on the\n\n18\n\nrest of the meet-and-confer process which never completed.\n\nIt\n\n19\n\ndepends on the search terms that are proposed, whether there\n\n20\n\nare any additional search terms proposed.\n\n21\n\nwanted to happen during a full meet-and-confer process, which\n\n22\n\nis what we strive to do in every case, and what we are actually\n\n23\n\ndoing in other actions against the estate, that Boies Schiller\n\n24\n\nis not involved with, is suggest search terms to us that you\n\n25\n\nthink would satisfy your view of what a particular request\n\nFor example, what we\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737855\n\n\f", "char_count": 1488}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 34 of 57\n\n34\n\nK5m2FarC\nentails, let us run the report.\n\nIf the report comes back and\n\nsays 500 documents or even a thousand, we may deem that\nreasonable for that request.\n4\n5\n\nIf it comes back at 10,000, we\n\nmay not deem that reasonable.\nSo this is part of what an ongoing discussion, I hope,\n\n6\n\nwould have entailed, which gives me pause to, again, say a\n\n7\n\nblanket yes, we will get it all done in 30 days.\n\n8\n\nsearching for things, I mentioned the plaintiffs in what we\n\n9\n\nhave already collected, to the extent we didn't complete that,\n\n10\n\nyou know, we don't need 30 days.\n\n11\n\nwill satisfy Ms. McCawley.\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n13\n\nIf this case goes all the way forward in litigation\n\nAs to\n\nBut I don't know that that\n\nOkay.\n\n14\n\nand goes to trial, you are going to try this case.\n\n15\n\ngoing to try ever case that is before this court or any other\n\n16\n\ncourt at the same trial.\n\n17\n\nregarding others who are claiming to have been victims of\n\n18\n\nMr. Epstein might not have relevance to some claim or defenses\n\n19\n\nbeing raised, and I understand that it may, in some documents,\n\n20\n\nmay have relevance.\n\n21\n\nYou are not\n\nThat doesn't mean that evidence\n\nBut you are going to have to get, on plaintiffs' side,\n\n22\n\na lot more focused with what you want and why you want it.\n\nAnd\n\n23\n\nif you are going to come back and make a renewed application to\n\n24\n\nme, that application is going to have to be more focused on\n\n25\n\nwhat kind of documents you are talking about, what claim or\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737856\n\n\f", "char_count": 1601}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 35 of 57\n\n35\n\nK5m2FarC\ndefense they are relevant to, why they are relevant to that\nclaim or defense, giving me an example of some case law that\nshows how it could be relevant, and I will make a decision on a\n4\n\nrequest-by-request basis about what appropriate time frames\n\n5\n\nshould be used.\n\n6\n\ninstance you need to talk to each other about that because you\n\n7\n\ndon't want the court coming up with search terms or trying to\n\n8\n\nmake judgment calls on that if it's not necessary.\n\n9\n\nyou are much better off trying to figure it out between you,\n\n10\n\ngetting an agreed protocol, an agreed list of custodians, an\n\n11\n\nagreed list of search terms, and then go from there, as\n\n12\n\ngenerally happens in cases where there might be a lot of\n\n13\n\ndocuments that are kept electronically.\n\n14\n\nthrough that process as you would in any other case.\n\n15\n\nAnd with respect to search terms, in the first\n\nYou know,\n\nSo I expect you to go\n\nI am open to kicking out your deadlines a bit to give\n\n16\n\nyou time to talk this through and to see if we can get some\n\n17\n\nprogress.\n\n18\n\nalready have a known universe of documents, if there are any\n\n19\n\nyou have not yet produced, get them produced within two weeks.\n\n20\n\nIf there are additional search terms, you will talk with each\n\n21\n\nother in good faith about time frame for running any additional\n\n22\n\nsearches and getting any additional documents produced.\n\n23\n\nplaintiff wanted to come back to me on a renewed motion that's\n\n24\n\nmore specifically laid out on particular categories of\n\n25\n\ndocuments or responses to interrogatories, you will do that\n\nI'm going to ask defendants, to the extent you\n\nAnd if\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737857\n\n\f", "char_count": 1762}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 36 of 57\n\n36\n\nK5m2FarC\nafter you have tried to work these things through with an eye\ntoward what is what is reasonable.\n\nPlaintiff may reasonably\n\nneed more than defendants want to give.\n\nDefendants may have a\n\n4\n\nreasonable point about conserving resources for the sake of a\n\n5\n\nsettlement program which should be taken seriously because it\n\n6\n\nseems that very serious efforts are underway to try to get that\n\n7\n\nprogram off the ground.\n\n8\n\nI'm going to ask for a status letter by June 19, which\n\n9\n\nis the date that I gave in other cases.\n\n10\n\nMr. Moskowitz's representation that this program should launch,\n\n11\n\nhe thinks, by June 15.\n\n12\n\nhave a better idea and you will also have a better idea of\n\n13\n\nwhere you are with respect to these discovery issues.\n\n14\n\nIt is geared to\n\nSo it seems to me by June 19 you will\n\nI'm going to caution plaintiffs' counsel in the\n\n15\n\nfuture, please do not send me something without being sure you\n\n16\n\nare at the end of the road in talking to your adversary.\n\n17\n\ndon't want to get a response that says it is premature, we\n\n18\n\nhaven't really talked.\n\n19\n\npoint-by-point basis that you have talked about specific\n\n20\n\nrelevance, that you have talked about specific burden issues,\n\n21\n\nthat you have talked about specific search terms, at least you\n\n22\n\nhave try to engage in that kind of dialogue.\n\n23\n\nstymied, you are stymied, and I will hear from you.\n\n24\n\ndon't think you are at that point.\n\n25\n\nI\n\nMake sure you are clear on a\n\nIf you are\nBut I\n\nAnd I think that's it with respect to those disputes,\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737858\n\n\f", "char_count": 1671}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 37 of 57\n\n37\n\nK5m2FarC\nand I should probably turn to the dispute regarding\nMs. Maxwell.\n\nWhat I am going to do is I am going to -- I don't\n\nknow if the letters were framed as a motion for a conference or\n4\n\na motion to compel.\n\n5\n\nconference, I will say granted.\n\n6\n\nthe underlying issue about compelling, go talk or in if\n\n7\n\nactually framed as a motion, I will say denied without\n\n8\n\nprejudice to renew, and I'm going to ask for a status letter by\n\n9\n\nJune 19.\n\n10\n11\n\nIf they were framed as a motion for a\nWe had a conference.\n\nAs to\n\nAnybody want to say anything else on that before I\nturn to Ms. Maxwell's issue?\n\n12\n\nNo?\n\nOkay.\n\nI'm hearing no, or I am hearing nothing.\n\n13\n\nHopefully I haven't lost everybody on the entire call.\n\n14\n\nhearing laughs, so hopefully that means not.\n\nI'm\n\n15\n\nLet me turn to Ms. Menninger's issue.\n\n16\n\nwant to understand, because there was a reference to a\n\n17\n\npotential criminal prosecution which of course could impact\n\n18\n\nwhether there should be a stay as to a defendant who is being\n\n19\n\ncriminally prosecuted.\n\n20\n\ncorrectly,\n\n21\n\nor you may be concerned she is the target of an investigation\n\n22\n\nbut there are no actual criminal charges pending, is that\n\n23\n\nright?\n\n24\n25\n\nOne thing I\n\nCurrently, if I'm understanding\nbe the target of an investigation,\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nYes, that's correct, your Honor.\n\nWe\n\ndo not have any criminal charges pending anywhere, but we have\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737859\n\n\f", "char_count": 1543}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 38 of 57\n\n38\n\nK5m2FarC\na number of public statements by the U.S. Attorney's office in\nthe Southern District, as well as statements made by\nplaintiffs' counsel to the press that suggest that those -4\n\nthat that investigation is underway and that it would encompass\n\n5\n\nMs. Maxwell, and so that is our concern.\n\n6\n\nsay that there is no active criminal charges that I am aware\n\n7\n\nof.\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right.\n\nBut it is correct to\n\nSo if there were active\n\n9\n\ncriminal charges filed or if that should happen, that might\n\n10\n\ninfluence the thinking about whether or not there should be a\n\n11\n\nstay, because of course if a defendant ends up taking the\n\n12\n\nFifth, that could have consequences in a civil case and\n\n13\n\ndefendant may feel there is little choice but to do that if the\n\n14\n\nperson is under a criminal indictment or if plaintiffs have\n\n15\n\nfiled.\n\n16\n\nSo I just want to just note that if that circumstance\n\n17\n\nchange -- if that circumstance changes, let me know.\n\nIf it\n\n18\n\naffects any ruling I make, let me know, because I may need to\n\n19\n\nrevisit a ruling.\n\n20\n\nLet me hear what -- given the last conference, the\n\n21\n\nlast subject, where there seem to be some changed landscapes\n\n22\n\nsince the application was initially made, let me make sure that\n\n23\n\nI am aware of the current circumstance.\n\n24\n25\n\nLet me just hear from Ms. Maxwell's counsel first on\nthis.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737860\n\n\f", "char_count": 1499}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 39 of 57\n\n39\n\nK5m2FarC\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nThank you, your Honor, Ms. Menninger\n\nhere on behalf of Ms. Maxwell.\nThe landscape has not changed since our letters.\n\nWe\n\n4\n\nhave filed a motion to dismiss the claims which we believe are\n\n5\n\ndistinct and different from any sort of example that the estate\n\n6\n\nmay have, and we believe that they are strong grounds for\n\n7\n\ndismissal.\n\n8\n\nthis case involve an allegation of battery that occurred one\n\n9\n\ntime in 1996 in New Mexico, and the statute of limitations and\n\n10\n\nvenue issues, you know, in New York versus New Mexico are very\n\n11\n\ndifferent for Maxwell than perhaps for the estate and we think\n\n12\n\nprovide the grounds for dismissal.\n\n13\n\nThe case -- the allegations against Ms. Maxwell in\n\nThe other two bases that we raise for a stay are the\n\n14\n\nclaims program that your Honor has already spent some time\n\n15\n\ndiscussing on this call and the earlier call today.\n\n16\n\nbelieve -- we don't have any independent information.\n\n17\n\nnot party to the calls in the Virgin Islands, as were counsel\n\n18\n\nfor plaintiffs and for the estate.\n\n19\n\ncall today the representations made by the estate that they\n\n20\n\nbelieve that the program will be getting off the ground in a\n\n21\n\nmatter of a few weeks, June 15, or three weeks or so from\n\n22\n\ntoday.\n\n23\n\nWe\nWe were\n\nBut I have heard on the\n\nGiven that plaintiff has indicated an intent to\n\n24\n\nparticipate in that program, at least in filings in the Virgin\n\n25\n\nIslands, and the fact that that program would -- if she\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737861\n\n\f", "char_count": 1628}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 40 of 57\n\n40\n\nK5m2FarC\nparticipates and it is successful, would render this entire\nlawsuit moot, we think we believe balancing that fact against\nthe extremely broad discovery demands that your Honor has heard\n4\n\nsomething about, although not with respect to Ms. Maxwell yet,\n\n5\n\nwould counsel in favor of at least a short stay similar to the\n\n6\n\nones that other plaintiffs' counsel have agreed to, promoted,\n\n7\n\nor\n\neven stipulated to in other cases pending before your Honor.\n\n8\n\nWe have received extensive discovery demands.\n\nWe have\n\n9\n\nbeen advised that plaintiffs' counsel intends to take a number\n\n10\n\nof depositions, including around the country, including for\n\n11\n\npeople that plaintiff in our case never met and had no dealings\n\n12\n\nwith.\n\n13\n\nwith that same type of discovery happening with the same\n\n14\n\nplaintiffs' counsel in the\n\n15\n\ncounsel for in front of Judge Sweet.\n\n16\n\nsignificant discovery disputes in that case and we had\n\n17\n\ndepositions that occurred not only across the country, from\n\n18\n\nCalifornia to New York and Florida and many places in between,\n\n19\n\nbut also abroad in that case, and the litigation costs were in\n\n20\n\nthe hundreds of thousands easily in that case.\n\n21\n\nat the pattern of discovery that I believe plaintiff intends to\n\n22\n\npursue here, balancing the costs of those to someone like my\n\n23\n\nclient, who is not a multimillionaire, and then viewing the\n\n24\n\nclaims program as something that could be successful in\n\n25\n\nresolving this case in a short period of time, we would ask\n\nAnd, your Honor, I can speak from personal experience\n\nv. Maxwell action that I was\nWe had a number of\n\nAnd so looking\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737862\n\n\f", "char_count": 1768}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 41 of 57\n\n41\n\nK5m2FarC\n\nYour\n\nHonor to consider putting a stay on discovery in the\ncase that I am party to, or I am counsel for a party to.\nI think I can second or third some of the things that\n\n4\n\nhave already been said earlier, so I don't want to waste the\n\n5\n\ncourt's time with those.\n\n6\n\nspent on this litigation is going to reduce the amount of money\n\n7\n\nthat would be available to any of the accusers in the Virgin\n\n8\n\nIslands, and we don't think it makes sense to spend the money\n\n9\n\non these broad discovery requests if we can get the case\n\n10\n\nresolved shortly.\n\nBut we have concerns that any money\n\n11\n\nI think the only objection that I heard from\n\n12\n\nplaintiffs' counsel to something like a hiatus was that there's\n\n13\n\na pending discovery cutoff of early July, and it seems to me\n\n14\n\nreasonable that of course if the claims program gets off the\n\n15\n\nground in a few weeks, that discovery cutoff could be set out\n\n16\n\nto see if it is successful or not.\n\n17\n\nfalse premise to say that the discovery cutoff in July is the\n\n18\n\nreason we should be forging ahead full steam with this\n\n19\n\nexpensive discovery, rather than just taking the more logical\n\n20\n\napproach, to me, which would be to at least put it on hold to\n\n21\n\nsee if the claims program is successful in the first instance;\n\n22\n\nand, if not, then the cases can proceed with the court's\n\n23\n\nblessing, pick back up where we left off.\n\nAnd so it is sort of a\n\n24\n\nIn this particular case, I think it also bears noting\n\n25\n\nthat the claim allegedly occurred in 1996, so it has been some\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737863\n\n\f", "char_count": 1680}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 42 of 57\n\n42\n\nK5m2FarC\n24 years since the allegations supposedly happened, and so I\ndon't see that waiting one or two or three months balanced\nagainst 24 years is -- it's not as though we think documents\n4\n\nwill go missing in those three months that weren't already\n\n5\n\nsomehow lost to the winds of time over the last 24 years, your\n\n6\n\nHonor.\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nSo you are -- I will just note, by the\n\n8\n\nway, that in your initial letter you ask for an opportunity to\n\n9\n\ndo full briefing, but it is all laid out in the letters.\n\n10\n\nlet me just get some clarification on that.\n\n11\n\nwould you be looking to do beyond what's in these letters?\n\n12\n\nhave case citations in these letters and you lay out the bases\n\n13\n\nfor a stay.\n\n14\n\ntrying to conserve resources?\n\n15\n\nbriefing.\n\n16\n\nSo\n\nWhat more briefing\nYou\n\nWhat would you be looking to do when you are\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nDo you really need full\n\nI think it could be abbreviated\n\n17\n\nbriefing; but, yes, there are more cases in support of the\n\n18\n\nrequest that we are making.\n\n19\n\nthe criminal investigation versus active prosecution, and then\n\n20\n\nthere is certainly a fair amount of exhibits that I could\n\n21\n\ntender to your Honor to display the breadth of discovery that\n\n22\n\nis part of the traditional balancing test when looking at a\n\n23\n\nmotion to stay -- or good cause -- of grounds for good cause as\n\n24\n\nbalanced against the breadth of discovery.\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThere are more cases in terms of\n\nI don't remember if at the beginning of\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737864\n\n\f", "char_count": 1620}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 43 of 57\n\n43\n\nK5m2FarC\nthis call I asked if my law clerk\n\nwas on.\n\nare you there?\n:\n4\n5\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes, I'm here, Judge.\nOkay.\n\nWell, for the court reporter, it is\n\n, H-A-N-N-A.\nAnd\n\nand I were conferring before this conference\n\n7\n\nabout some case law about some criminal prosecution as opposed\n\n8\n\nto criminal investigation, and we weren't finding, at least on\n\n9\n\nan initial look, cases where the courts tended to stay civil\n\n10\n\nproceedings when there was an investigation proceeding.\n\n11\n\nhave cases that say the opposite?\n\n12\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n15\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\n17\n18\n19\n\nThey are not\n\nin the Southern District, so there are --\n\n14\n\n16\n\nYour Honor, I have some.\n\nYou\n\nOkay.\n-- cases that have occurred in various\n\nfederal and state cases across the country.\nTHE COURT:\n\nAnd you are looking for a stay of the\n\nentire case, not just as to proceedings against your client?\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nYour Honor, it seems to me best to\n\n20\n\nstay the case, but I would be amenable just in regards to my\n\n21\n\nclient or, as I said towards the end of my letter, there are\n\n22\n\nother alternatives that, you know, I think I would view as\n\n23\n\nintermediate steps, for example, bifurcation of discovery on\n\n24\n\nthe statute of limitations issue, for example, if that were\n\n25\n\nsomething the court thought were appropriate or a stay on party\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737865\n\n\f", "char_count": 1468}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 44 of 57\n\n44\n\nK5m2FarC\ndepositions until later in the discovery process to see where\nthe claims program and the criminal investigation end up, and\ncertainly with regard to the motion to dismiss, that should be,\n4\n\nI would think, decided at some point.\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nI might consider, because there is a lot\n\n6\n\nto do in this case, I might consider putting a hold on\n\n7\n\nMs. Maxwell having to make statements, so either responding to\n\n8\n\nsubstantive interrogatories or being deposed because of Fifth\n\n9\n\nAmendment issues, because it may be that she ends up the\n\n10\n\nsubject of prosecution even if she is not yet and because there\n\n11\n\nare other things that can meanwhile be going forward.\n\n12\n\nput her deposition further down the pike, maybe we will have\n\n13\n\ngreater clarity on that before that issue actually comes to the\n\n14\n\nfore.\n\n15\n\nIf we\n\nI'm also thinking that there are other interests\n\n16\n\nbesides hers in this case.\n\n17\n\nI'm sure that although your point is well taken that it's not\n\n18\n\nthat likely that documents will now not be preserved within\n\n19\n\nthese few months as opposed to not being preserved over the\n\n20\n\nyears, I'm sure plaintiff does not want to hear that after all\n\n21\n\nof these years she must wait more time in order to have what\n\n22\n\nshe considers to be serious wrongs redressed.\n\n23\n\ncan cut in more than one direction.\n\n24\n25\n\nThere are plaintiffs' interests and\n\nSo the factors\n\nSo right now I'm not inclined to stay the whole case,\nbut I am inclined to keep one eye on settlement, to keep one\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737866\n\n\f", "char_count": 1653}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 45 of 57\n\n45\n\nK5m2FarC\neye -- I'm not sure how many eyes I have -- to keep an eye on\nthe -- any criminal investigation and ask to have updates if\nthere are charges filed, and maybe put some things more at the\n4\n\nfront end of the discovery period, some things more at the back\n\n5\n\nend of the discovery period.\n\n6\n\ndates out some to accommodate the parties if the parties are\n\n7\n\nengaged in good-faith discussions, if there is a desire to\n\n8\n\nconserve resources because it looks like the claims program is\n\n9\n\nin fact going forward.\n\n10\n\nthat another cases.\n\n11\n\nextended deadlines in other cases.\n\n12\n\nresources going to litigation if it's not necessary.\n\n13\n\nnow I'm not inclined to have a complete stay of everything.\n\n14\n\nAnd I am willing to move the\n\nI am willing to do that.\n\nI have stayed other cases.\n\nI have done\nI have\n\nI don't really want to see\nBut right\n\nMs. Menninger, what would be your reaction to saying\n\n15\n\nhold off on anything that could be in the category of\n\n16\n\naffirmative statements made by Ms. Maxwell for now and having\n\n17\n\nother discovery going forward?\n\n18\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\n19\n20\n\nIt does address -- this is\n\nMs. Menninger, again, Laura Menninger.\nIt does address many of my concerns.\n\nI would say, you\n\n21\n\nknow, the costs related to the broad discovery demands that\n\n22\n\nwere propounded, written discovery requests and the like, are\n\n23\n\nstill of concern to me.\n\n24\n\nevery calendar she has had for the last 24 years and every\n\n25\n\nAmazon account she has ever used for the last 24 years.\n\nAs I mentioned, we have been asked for\n\nSo\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737867\n\n\f", "char_count": 1686}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 46 of 57\n\n46\n\nK5m2FarC\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThat sounds to me, again, like you need to\n\nhave a discussion with plaintiffs' counsel and, plaintiffs'\n4\n\ncounsel, it sounds like you need to have a discussion with\n\n5\n\nMs. Menninger about what you really need, why you really need\n\n6\n\nit, how it can be done in a way that's manageable with no\n\n7\n\nabsolute yeses and no absolute nos with respect to those sorts\n\n8\n\nof requests.\n\n9\n\nIt may be that there is something about Amazon\n\n10\n\naccounts that's really critical, and you can explain that.\n\n11\n\nmaybe there is something else that's not really critical, and\n\n12\n\nyou can, you know, bend a bit on it.\n\n13\n\nkind of discussion to keep, you know -- you know, to keep\n\n14\n\ndiscovery tailored to the case and proportionate to the needs\n\n15\n\nof the case.\n\n16\n\nwith the scope of what's being claimed in a particular case,\n\n17\n\nand to some extent it has to do with Mr. Epstein's accused\n\n18\n\nconduct over time.\n\n19\n\nthat conversation and try to balance it.\n\n20\n\nthen I will.\n\nSo you need to have that\n\nThat has to do with time frame, that has to do\n\nSo you are going to have to try to have\nAnd if you can't,\n\n21\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nI appreciate that, your Honor.\n\n22\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nYour Honor, this is\n\n23\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n24\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\n25\n\nAnd\n\nYes.\nI'm sorry.\n\nThis is Ms. McCawley.\n\nCan\n\nI address --\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737868\n\n\f", "char_count": 1457}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 47 of 57\n\n47\n\nK5m2FarC\nTHE COURT:\n\nAbsolutely.\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\nTHE COURT:\n4\n\nThank you.\n\nPlease go ahead.\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nWith respect to the motion to stay that\n\n5\n\nMs. Maxwell is proposing, one of the bases that she has filed\n\n6\n\nmotion to dismiss, Judge Schofield held a premotion conference\n\n7\n\nwith respect to that --\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nHold on a moment, please.\n\nDo I still\n\n9\n\nhave -- do I still have -- I know I still have Ms. McCawley.\n\n10\n\nDo I still have Ms. Menninger?\n\n11\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n13\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n14\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nDo I still have Mr. Moskowitz?\nYes, your Honor.\n\nDid anyone join us who is another\n\n15\n\nattorney?\n\n16\n\njoined from the public or press, welcome.\n\n17\n\nphone on mute.\n\n18\n\nOkay.\n\n19\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nOkay.\n\nHopefully we didn't lose anybody.\n\nGo ahead.\n\nIf anyone\n\nPlease keep your\n\nYou were saying, Ms. McCawley?\n\nYes.\n\nSo we did hold in front of\n\n20\n\nJudge Schofield a premotion conference on Ms. Maxwell's motion\n\n21\n\nto dismiss.\n\n22\n\ndiscouraged Ms. Maxwell from filing a motion to dismiss, giving\n\n23\n\nher preliminary views that they -- the arguments that she was\n\n24\n\nputting forth were not meritorious.\n\n25\n\nfiling a motion to dismiss and has done that now, just this\n\nAs Judge Schofield did with the estate, she\n\nMs. Maxwell insisted on\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737869\n\n\f", "char_count": 1433}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 48 of 57\n\n48\n\nK5m2FarC\nweek.\n\nSo in my view, that is -- bodes against any sort of stay\n\nbased on the motion to dismiss because the district judge has\nset forth her views with respect to that at least as an initial\n4\n\nmatter.\n\n5\n\nWith respect to the case law, your Honor is correct,\n\n6\n\nthe case law in New York is clear that unless there is an\n\n7\n\nindictment put forward, which there has not been, it doesn't\n\n8\n\nallow somebody in a civil case to stay the case on the basis of\n\n9\n\na possible investigation.\n\n10\n\nWith respect to your Honor's statements about the\n\n11\n\ninvestigation and potentially allowing Ms. Maxwell to not have\n\n12\n\nto make statements in this civil action, the concern I have\n\n13\n\nthere is that we have no indication of any time frame with\n\n14\n\nrespect to the Southern District of New York, how long that\n\n15\n\ninvestigation could go on or will go on or anything of that\n\n16\n\nnature.\n\n17\n\nalleged, worked in concert with Mr. Epstein to abuse my client.\n\n18\n\nWe brought those claims under the Child Victims Act, as we are\n\n19\n\nallowed to do, because she was a minor, and to not be able to\n\n20\n\nget a discovery and ask Ms. Maxwell questions and get responses\n\n21\n\nand keep the case moving forward puts us in handcuffs with\n\n22\n\nrespect to being able to establish our claims because, as your\n\n23\n\nHonor has seen from the complaint, the allegations are that\n\n24\n\nthey worked together hand in hand with respect to the abuse of\n\n25\n\nSo the concern, for me, is Ms. Maxwell, as we have\n\n.\n\nSo I would have concerns about some form of that\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737870\n\n\f", "char_count": 1674}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 49 of 57\n\n49\n\nK5m2FarC\nkind of a path for defendant Maxwell in the case at this time\nuntil there is a criminal indictment that's put forward.\nTHE COURT:\n4\n5\n\nAll right.\n\nLet me just say a few things\n\nabout that.\nFirst of all, if the investigation is going on here in\n\n6\n\nNew York, or for that matter wherever it may be going on,\n\n7\n\nbecause what we have in New York is not only in New York with\n\n8\n\nrespect to COVID-19, the grand jury process is understandably\n\n9\n\ndelayed because it is very difficult to have jurors convene.\n\n10\n\nSo there may be additional time before any case that is being\n\n11\n\ninvestigated is indicted, and so we just have to recognize that\n\n12\n\nwe are in somewhat unusual circumstances.\n\n13\n\nThe second thing is that any stay that I might put in\n\n14\n\nplace with respect to any aspect of the claims against\n\n15\n\nMs. Maxwell would be temporary and would be revisited.\n\n16\n\nnot allow it to drag on indefinitely.\n\n17\n\nthings can be done to move the case forward and the case is not\n\n18\n\ncompletely stalled, I don't see any harm in putting some things\n\n19\n\na little bit further down the road.\n\nI would\n\nBut in a case where some\n\n20\n\nThe third thing I will say is this is also an unusual\n\n21\n\ncircumstance because of the potential of this claims process in\n\n22\n\nwhich plaintiff may well participate and which may well get off\n\n23\n\nthe ground soon; and, if it does, I'm not sure whether it would\n\n24\n\nmoot claims against Ms. Maxwell or not, but it might.\n\n25\n\nyou balance those factors, you have this situation where we may\n\nAnd as\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737871\n\n\f", "char_count": 1672}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 50 of 57\n\n50\n\nK5m2FarC\nknow in the relatively near future whether plaintiff is\nactively participating in the claims process, whether it looks\nlike it is going to resolve her claims, and we may never have\n4\n\nto get to the point where we jeopardize, potentially jeopardize\n\n5\n\nsomebody's Fifth Amendment rights.\n\n6\n\nSo I might be inclined to do this, to say, look, you\n\n7\n\ncan carry on with discovery in the case after a conference on\n\n8\n\nall kinds of things, to try to keep costs under control and try\n\n9\n\nto focus on what's most important.\n\n10\n\nif you would like if you are feeling pressure from that.\n\n11\n\nwill hold off on -- not on production of documents from\n\n12\n\nMs. Maxwell but on the statements that she makes, whether sworn\n\n13\n\nstatements or interrogatories or deposition, we will put that a\n\n14\n\nlittle bit further down.\n\n15\n\nregarding the process of settlement, and we will take\n\nI will extend deadlines out\nWe\n\nYou will give me status report\n\n16\n\nAnd with respect to holding off on interrogatory\n\n17\n\nresponses or deposition by Ms. Maxwell, that will not be a\n\n18\n\npermanent situation, that will be revisited.\n\n19\n\nstretching out too far and if there is no indictment, then I\n\n20\n\nmay take further briefing on the subject and I will make a\n\n21\n\ndecision as to whether in fact that part of the case should\n\n22\n\nalso go forward.\n\n23\n\nThat is my current thinking.\n\nAnd if time is\n\nBut I will not let it drag out indefinitely.\n\n24\n\nWhat say both of you on that?\n\n25\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nYour Honor, this is Laura Menninger.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737872\n\n\f", "char_count": 1653}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 51 of 57\n\n51\n\nK5m2FarC\nThat would be -- we would welcome that ruling, your Honor.\nTHE COURT:\n\nPlaintiff?\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nYour Honor, obviously we disagree with\n\n4\n\nthat because we believe that it's important to have\n\n5\n\nMs. Maxwell's participation in this case.\n\n6\n\nfor a deposition already and that got moved because she -- you\n\n7\n\nknow, the issue of just being able to be in person, things of\n\n8\n\nthat nature.\n\n9\n\nconcerned about there being extended delay and are concerned\n\n10\n\nabout not being able to get information from her through her\n\n11\n\ntestimony.\n\n12\n\nWe have noticed her\n\nWe were trying to accommodate.\n\nSo we are\n\nWe respect the court's concerns about a Fifth\n\n13\n\nAmendment privilege but, again, we would ask that if you are\n\n14\n\ngoing to be inclined to do something like this, you tie it to a\n\n15\n\ndate like the June 15 date, or something along those lines, so\n\n16\n\nthat we are not in a position where she is able to take\n\n17\n\ndepositions of all of our people and we are, you know,\n\n18\n\nhandcuffed with respect to any discovery with respect to\n\n19\n\nMs. Maxwell.\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nLike I said, I have no desire to have this\n\n21\n\ndrag out.\n\nIf all things -- if we didn't have this potential\n\n22\n\nclaim process out there with a fairly soon, seemingly likely,\n\n23\n\nstart date, according to defendants, then I think the balance\n\n24\n\nwould be different.\n\n25\n\ncircuit would generally support the stay when there is no\n\nBecause I don't think the case law in this\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737873\n\n\f", "char_count": 1595}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 52 of 57\n\n52\n\nK5m2FarC\nprosecution pending yet.\nBut nonetheless, there are a number of factors one\nmight look at on that, and whether or not an indictment is\n4\n\npending is only one of the factors.\n\nThere are several factors\n\n5\n\nthat could be relevant, including, and I'm going to refer you\n\n6\n\nto the Louis Vuitton Malletier case.\n\n7\n\nL-O-U-I-S V-U-I-T-T-O-N M-A-L-L-E-T-I-E-R v. Ly, L-Y, U.S.A.,\n\n8\n\nInc., and the case number is 676 F.3d 83 from 2011.\n\n9\n\nSecond Circuit noted that courts often take a look at a number\n\n10\n\nof factors in deciding whether there should be a stay,\n\n11\n\nincluding the extent to which the issues in the criminal case\n\n12\n\noverlap with those presented in the civil case.\n\n13\n\nwould be, I assume, a very strong overlap to the status of the\n\n14\n\ncase, including whether the defendants have been indicted.\n\n15\n\nthat's a factor.\n\nFor the court reporter,\n\nSo the\n\nHere, there\n\nSo\n\n16\n\nThree, the private interests of the plaintiff in\n\n17\n\nproceeding expeditiously weighed against the prejudice to\n\n18\n\nplaintiffs caused by the delay.\n\n19\n\npotential settlement process and that, to me, is an unusual\n\n20\n\nfactor that suggests that the plaintiffs' interests may be\n\n21\n\ndivided here in proceeding fast with this case when there is a\n\n22\n\npotential settlement within the next few months potentially\n\n23\n\navailable to plaintiffs and plaintiff may go for that.\n\n24\n25\n\nHere I'm looking at the\n\nAnother factor is the private interest of and burden\non the defendants.\n\nWe do have an individual here.\n\nWe are not\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737874\n\n\f", "char_count": 1654}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 53 of 57\n\n53\n\nK5m2FarC\ntalking about the estate, and there is somewhat more burden for\ndiscovery.\nThere are the interests of the courts.\n\nThe interest\n\n4\n\nof the court is not to have unnecessary litigation if the\n\n5\n\nmatters can be resolved amicably, and not to have it stretch\n\n6\n\nout forever.\n\n7\n\nThat's also an interest of the court.\n\nWe also have this strange overlay of COVID-19 which\n\n8\n\naffects the ability for criminal prosecutors to take matters to\n\n9\n\na grand jury.\n\n10\n\nThe public interest, I think the public interest is\n\n11\n\nwould be well served by a claims process.\n\n12\n\ncase in terms of there being a number of claim victims, and\n\n13\n\nthat is something that I definitely am looking at and is\n\n14\n\nweighing into my consideration as to how any and all of these\n\n15\n\ncases should be litigated.\n\n16\n\nclaims that are no more recent than the claims here, a lot of\n\n17\n\nplaintiffs' counsel have agreed to stays or partial stays or\n\n18\n\nare holding off on certain things to conserve resources and\n\n19\n\nallow that process to play out a bit, and I think that those\n\n20\n\nare factors that are unusual in this case.\n\n21\n\ncase-by-case, specific analysis that has to be made as to\n\n22\n\nwhether there should be a stay.\n\n23\n\nIf you look at this\n\nAnd in several of the cases, which\n\nThis is a\n\nSo in this particular case, at this particular time,\n\n24\n\nwith these particular circumstances, it seems to me to make\n\n25\n\nsense not to stay the case in its entirety, to send counsel\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737875\n\n\f", "char_count": 1599}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 53, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 54 of 57\n\n54\n\nK5m2FarC\noff to have the kind of good-faith conference you should have\nhad before contacting me in the first place and that you should\nalways have about anything and everything as you try to work\n4\n\nthrough discovery issues, but to hold off on the most serious\n\n5\n\nof the issues with respect to Ms. Maxwell, which are her\n\n6\n\nconstitutional rights, and not forever, but at least long\n\n7\n\nenough to let us know whether the claims process is likely to\n\n8\n\ngo forward.\n\n9\n\nintervals that are reasonable and that does not put you in\n\n10\n\nlimbo where you will never be able to get discovery from\n\n11\n\nMs. Maxwell if this case proceeds.\n\n12\n\nAnd I will revisit it, and I will revisit it at\n\nAll right?\n\nSo let me ask straight out, are you, under the\n\n13\n\ncircumstances I have described and the way in which I would\n\n14\n\nenvision this, which is some discovery going forward,\n\n15\n\ngood-faith conference, report to me by June 19 about the\n\n16\n\nstatus, are you looking to have me move out the discovery\n\n17\n\nschedules at all and, if so, by how long?\n\n18\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nYour Honor, this is Sigrid McCawley.\n\n19\n\nWould it be possible to have some time to consider\n\n20\n\nthat?\n\nRight now the discovery deadline is set for July 10, I\n\n21\n\nbelieve, and I of course have anticipated taking depositions\n\n22\n\nthroughout June and into early July.\n\n23\n\ntime to consider what that would look like and confer with the\n\n24\n\nother side, then if we can't agree, then maybe present\n\n25\n\nsomething to the court with the timing of that?\n\nSo if I could have some\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737876\n\n\f", "char_count": 1673}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 54, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 55 of 57\n\n55\n\nK5m2FarC\nTHE COURT:\n\nYeah.\n\nI mean, I'm not usually in the\n\nhabit of suggesting extensions, but I think here, rather than\nbe crunched with depositions and panicking at the end of June\n4\n\nand beginning of July, putting another 30 days on it to give\n\n5\n\nyou time to talk through your issues and for me to have fuller\n\n6\n\nbriefing on the issue of a stay, should it come to that, it\n\n7\n\nmight make sense to at least give you another 30.\n\n8\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n10\n\nThat would be fine, your Honor.\n\nMr. Moskowitz, do you want to say\n\nanything?\n\n11\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\n12\n\nThat 30-day initial extension for the further\n\nJust very quickly, your Honor.\n\n13\n\ndiscussion makes perfect sense to us.\n\n14\n\nout -- your Honor laid out very compelling reasons, one of\n\n15\n\nwhich is unique to this action, but the others equally apply to\n\n16\n\nthe other actions that we are here now before you on, so I\n\n17\n\nwould hope that we could also discuss with Ms. McCawley keeping\n\n18\n\nthe extensions in line for each case with those other\n\n19\n\nconsiderations in mind.\n\n20\n\nI would say you laid\n\nIt's something we will discuss.\n\nThe only other thing I wanted to mention is -- which I\n\n21\n\ndidn't get a chance to mention earlier is that Ms. McCawley\n\n22\n\nmentioned various concerns about the program.\n\n23\n\nmore convincing from someone but for the fact that they already\n\n24\n\nstayed one of their clients' actions in favor of the program.\n\n25\n\nSo I just don't -- it doesn't square with us that those\n\nThat could be\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737877\n\n\f", "char_count": 1630}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 55, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 56 of 57\n\n56\n\nK5m2FarC\nconcerns are such that they can't take the same reasoned\napproach in the other actions when they found it reasonable for\none of them already.\n4\n5\n\nBut other than that, I have nothing to add, your\nHonor.\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\nSo I'm going to ask for a status\n\n7\n\nreport by June 19.\n\n8\n\nhear about how discovery is going and how settlement prospects\n\n9\n\nare looking.\n\n10\n\nwith counsel for Ms. Maxwell and mapping out of how the parties\n\n11\n\nwould anticipate things moving further from that point, and,\n\n12\n\nyou know, Ms. Maxwell permitting not to respond to\n\n13\n\ninterrogatories and not to have her deposition until the\n\n14\n\nparties have had a chance to confer, until I have had that\n\n15\n\nstatus report June 19, until I hear again from counsel as to\n\n16\n\nthe next logical way to proceed with that, and I will kick out\n\n17\n\ndiscovery deadlines 30 days, which is modest.\n\n18\n\nare going to be kicked out longer.\n\n19\n\nplanning you do for depositions to be happening a little\n\n20\n\nfurther down the road in July, and you will get back to me.\n\n21\n\nneed be, we will have another conference and we will take in\n\n22\n\nthe next piece.\n\nIn that status report, I not only want to\n\nI also want to hear about further discussions\n\nOthers, I think,\n\nYou can do whatever\n\nAs\n\nOkay?\n\n23\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n25\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\nAll right.\n\nAnything else\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737878\n\n\f", "char_count": 1540}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737823", "page_number": 56, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF Document 57 Filed 06/03/20 Page 57 of 57\n\n57\n\nK5m2FarC\nTHE COURT:\n\n-- before we end this call?\n\nAll right.\n\nLet me just say one last thing, which is,\n\nI did record this call into the conferencing system, but you\n4\n\nalso have a court reporter on the call.\n\n5\n\na transcript made from the telephone recording.\n\n6\n\naware that if there are two transcripts made -- one from AT&T\n\n7\n\nand one from the court reporter -- and there is any\n\na\n\ndiscrepancy, the court reporter's transcript will be the\n\n9\n\nofficial transcript and will control.\n\nYou don't need to have\n\nOkay?\n\n10\n\nMS. McCAWLEY:\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\n11\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n13\n14\n\nAll right.\n\nAnd just be\n\nThank you all.\n\nTake care,\n\neverybody.\noOo\n\n15\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.\n(212) 805-0300\n\nEFTA02737879\n\n\f", "char_count": 869}]}