{"efta_number": "EFTA02737772", "page_count": 4, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02737772", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02737772.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02737772", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF\n\nDocument 52\n\nTroutman Sanders LLP\n875 Third Avenue\nNew York, New York 10022\ntroutman.com\n\nFiled 05/13/20\n\nPage 1 of 4\n\ntroutmar?\nsanders\n\nMatthewl Aaronson\nMatthew.aaronson@troutman.com\n\nMay 13, 2020\nVia ECF\nHon. Debra C. Freeman\nDaniel\nMoynihan\nUnited States Courthouse\n500 Pearl St.\nNew York, NY 10007\nRe:\n\nJane Doe 1000, 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF\n\nDear Judge Freeman:\nWe represent Defendants Darren K. Indyke and Richard D. Kahn, Co-Executors\nof the Estate of Jeffrey E. Epstein (together, the \"Co-Executors\"), in the above-referenced\naction (the \"Action\"). We write to address the substantive issues raised in Plaintiffs letters\nto the Court dated May 7 and May 11, prematurely requesting a pre-motion conference\non Plaintiffs anticipated motion to compel. For the reasons set forth below and in our\nMay 8 letter, we respectfully request that the Court deny Plaintiffs request.\nThe picture Plaintiff paints is a false one. On their face, Plaintiffs interrogatories\nare clearly overbroad and unduly burdensome. However, as a compromise and as the\nCo-Executors said they would do before Plaintiff filed her letter, the Co-Executors have\nsupplemented their responses to those interrogatories. Notwithstanding that Plaintiff has\nprovided no transparency into her own efforts to produce responsive materials (something\nthe Co-Executors hope to resolve before filing letters with the Court), the Co-Executors\nhave collected and are, in connection with this and the numerous other cases against\nthem before Your Honor, reviewing a database of over 730,000 documents. We\naddress Plaintiffs specific points below.\nFirst, Plaintiff's proposed 21-year time frame for discovery is not proportional to\nthe needs of this case and would impose an undue burden on the Co-Executors.\nAlthough Plaintiff asserts that her alleged abuse by Mr. Epstein occurred from 1999 to\n2002, she demands discovery from 1999 through the present. Plaintiffs proposed time\nframe is contrary to the goals of the 2015 amendments to the Federal Rules of Civil\nProcedure, which emphasize the pre-existing but often-unheeded requirement that all civil\ndiscovery be proportional to the needs of the case. See State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co.\nv. Fayda, No. 14CIV9792WHPJCF, 2015 WL 7871037, at *2 (S.D.N.Y. Dec. 3, 2015),\n\n42294643v1\n\nEFTA02737772\n\n\f", "char_count": 2333}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737772", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF\nMay 13, 2020\nPage 2\n\nDocument 52\n\nFiled 05/13/20\n\nPage 2 of 4\n\ntroutmaril\nsanders\n\naffd, No. 14CV9792, 2016 WL 4530890 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 24, 2016) (\"[T]he amended rule\nis intended to encourage judges to be more aggressive in identifying and discouraging\ndiscovery overuse; by emphasizing the need to analyze proportionality before ordering\nproduction of relevant information.\"). Requiring the Co-Executors to conduct a search for\nand produce documents over an 21-year time period is not proportional to the needs of\nthis case — which relates to Mr. Epstein's alleged conduct over a four-year period that\nconcluded in 2002. The Co-Executors advised Plaintiffs counsel that the appropriate\ntime period for discovery is the time period during which Plaintiff alleges she was abused\nand during which time her claims would have accrued. Moreover, the Co-Executors will\nsearch for and produce all non-privileged communications between Mr. Epstein and\nPlaintiff or otherwise conceming Plaintiff, regardless of the year.\nPlaintiffs position, that all information relating to what Plaintiff describes as a \"sex\ntrafficking\" scheme -- which is based on unproven allegations in the S.D.N.Y.'s 2019\nindictment of Mr. Epstein -- is relevant to Plaintiffs alleged abuse, is untenable. Plaintiff\ndoes not assert sex trafficking claims. Rather, her claims are limited to battery and\nintentional infliction of emotional distress.\nMoreover, conduct that occurred after Plaintiffs alleged abuse cannot possibly be\nused to support her claims. While Plaintiff posits that discovery relating to Mr. Epstein's\nconduct with other individuals is \"relevant\" to her claims, that does not mean that such\ndiscovery is proper. See Mamakos v. United Airlines, Inc., No. CV147294JFBAKT, 2018\nWL 4861392, at *2 (E.D.N.Y. Sept. 28, 2018) (\"[A]lthough Rule 26 still permits a wide\nrange of discovery based upon relevance and proportionality, the provision authorizing\nthe court ... to order discovery of any matter relevant to the subject matter involved in the\naction has been eliminated.\") (internal citations omitted). Accordingly, the Court should\nreject Plaintiff's attempt to grossly expand the scope of discovery to obtain documents\nthat extend \"far beyond the scope of Plaintiffs claims and would significantly burden\" the\nCo-Executors. See Robertson v. People Magazine, No. 14 CIV. 6759 (PAC), 2015 WL\n9077111, at *2 (S.D.N.Y. Dec. 16, 2015) (denying discovery requests that are\n\"burdensome and disproportionate\" where Plaintiff sought \"nearly unlimited\" discovery\nthat was not addressed to alleged discriminatory conduct and/or comments).\nContrary to her counsel's assertion, Plaintiff does not need discovery about Mr.\nEpstein's interactions with other individuals to meet her burden to prove her claims for\nbattery or intentional infliction of emotional distress allegedly committed against her. The\nmere fact that certain testimony regarding a defendant's prior conduct could theoretically\nbe admissible at trial does not mean that Plaintiff is entitled to wide-ranging discovery.\nPlaintiff cites no authority for that proposition.\nNor does Plaintiff need discovery about Mr. Epstein's interactions with other\nindividuals to invoke her equitable estoppel defense to the Co-Executor's assertion that\nher claims are barred by the statute of limitations. In order to prevail on her equitable\nestoppel defense, Plaintiff is required to show that Mr. Epstein's conduct towards Plaintiff\n\n42294643v1\n\nEFTA02737773\n\n\f", "char_count": 3512}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737772", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF\nMay 13, 2020\nPage 3\n\nDocument 52\n\nFiled 05/13/20\n\nPage 3 of 4\n\ntroutmaril\nsanders\n\nprevented her from bringing her suit earlier; his conduct towards others has no bearing\non such a defense. \"To invoke equitable estoppel, a plaintiff must show that: '(i) the\ndefendant made a definite misrepresentation of fact and had reason to believe that the\nplaintiff would rely on it; and (ii) the plaintiff reasonably relied on that misrepresentation\nto h[er] detriment.- See Yesh Diamonds, Inc. v. Yashaya, No. 09-CV-2016 (DLI) (RER),\n2010 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 101744, at *5 (E.D.N.Y. Sept. 27, 2010) (quoting Kavowras v. New\nYork Times Co., 328 F.3d 50, 56-57 (2d Cir. 2003).\nSecond, Plaintiff suggests that the Co-Executors agreed to produce only\ndocuments that expressly reference Plaintiff. That is an inaccurate representation of the\nparties' conversations during the meet-and-confer sessions. As we explained during the\nparties' April 27 and May 5 meet-and-confers, the Co-Executors have and will continue\nto search for and produce documents that relate to Plaintiff and her claims of battery and\nintentional infliction of emotional distress, regardless of whether they specifically\nreference Plaintiff. For example, if the Complaint alleges that Plaintiff traveled on Mr.\nEpstein's plane, then flight logs for the relevant time period will be produced. Similarly,\nwhere phone records exist from the relevant time period and Plaintiff provides CoExecutors with phone numbers that she used during the Relevant Time Period, CoExecutors will search for calls to/from such phone numbers. To the extent Plaintiff bases\nher argument on the Co-Executors' search-term proposal for ESI, her counsel never\nengaged with us. Rather than continue discussions that include bilateral search-term\nproposals — as is customary in this District and something other counsel in the other\nlawsuits against the Estate have done — Plaintiff burdened the Court in an apparent effort\nto obtain a wide-ranging Court order that would unduly burden the Co-Executors. If\nPlaintiff had simply made a single proposal or engaged in any effort to compromise on\nher positions, this could have all been avoided.\nThird, Plaintiffs request that the Co-Executors supplement their interrogatory\nresponses is moot. Again, this is exactly the situation the Court warned against. The CoExecutors supplemented their interrogatory responses earlier today, as they agreed to do\nbefore Plaintiff went ahead and burdened the Court with her initial lengthy letter on this\nissue. The Co-Executors provided their initial and supplemental responses to Plaintiffs\ninterrogatories in the capacity in which they were sued. Plaintiff provides no support for\nher position that the Co-Executors' responses should be made in their personal or other\nprofessional capacity. Plaintiff also misrepresents the parties' communications regarding\ninformation provided by Co-Executors in connection with their interrogatory responses.\nAs we advised Plaintiff on several occasions, the Co-Executors reviewed and approved\nthe interrogatory responses before they were served.\nPlaintiff incorrectly states that counsel for Co-Executors represented that the CoExecutors \"do not know where to look for responsive documents.\" To the contrary, we\nstated that, despite the fact that obtaining documents and information from a large,\ncomplicated estate is more involved and thus takes longer than the collection of\ndocuments from an individual party such as Plaintiff, the Co-Executors retrieved hundreds\n42294643v1\n\nEFTA02737774\n\n\f", "char_count": 3573}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737772", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10577-LJL-DCF\nMay 13, 2020\nPage 4\n\nDocument 52\n\nFiled 05/13/20\n\nPage 4 of 4\n\ntroutmarn1\nsanders\n\nof thousands of documents and were reviewing the voluminous database in preparation\nfor production, but that the task had been complicated by the need to track down such\ninformation and the attendant delays caused by the current pandemic. The Co-Executors\nhave compiled a database with over 730,000 documents that they have been searching\nfor documents responsive to this and discovery requests in numerous other lawsuits.\nSubject to the execution of a mutually acceptable ESI protocol and confidentiality order\n(something made abundantly clear in the Co-Executors' written responses to Plaintiffs\nrequests for production), they expect to begin production within the next week. The only\nreason a confidentiality order was not already entered in this action (but was in several\nother lawsuits against the Co-Executors) is that, unlike the plaintiffs' counsel in the other\nactions, Plaintiffs counsel here insisted until shortly before filing their letter that the CoExecutors accept unsupportable changes, such as the removal of several categories of\nconfidentiality that the Co-Executors require but which Plaintiff does not believe she\nneeds—a vexatious tactic.\nFinally, contrary to her representations to the Court, Plaintiff has not complied with\nher discovery obligations. Rather, Plaintiff produced a small set of self-selected, and\nuseless materials so she could rush to Court under the guise of having made a meaningful\nproduction in the face of what she falsely claims was stonewalling from her adversaries.\nApproximately half of the documents Plaintiff produced are irrelevant documents from\nanother case that was handled by Plaintiffs counsel that has nothing to do with Plaintiffs\nclaims in this action.' There appears to have been no reason for the production of these\ndocuments other than to inflate the size of Plaintiffs production. Those same documents\nwere also produced by the other Plaintiffs that Plaintiffs counsel represents in actions\nagainst Mr. Epstein's estate. They do not appear to be documents that were in Plaintiffs\npersonal possession.\nAccordingly, we request that the Court deny Plaintiffs request for a pre-motion\nconference and instead direct Plaintiff to engage in a good-faith meet-and-confer session\nto resolve the parties' discovery disputes.\nRespectfully submitted,\ns/Matthew J. Aaronson\nMatthew J. Aaronson\n\ncc: Counsel of Record (via ECF)\n\nThe Court should be aware that the Hon. Lorretta A. Preska disqualified Plaintiffs counsel from\nacting as counsel in a subsequent action related to that other action.\n\n42294643v1\n\nEFTA02737775\n\n\f", "char_count": 2687}]}