{"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_count": 25, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02737424", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02737424.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10788-GHW-DCF\n\nDocument 43\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nPage 1 of 25\n\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK\n\nIn re:\nDocket #1:19-cv-10788: GHW-DCF\n\n.\nPlaintiff,\n- against INDYKE, DARREN K. et al,\n\n:\n\nNew York, New York\nMay 22, 2020\n\nDefendants.\nTELEPHONE CONFERENCE\n\nPROCEEDINGS BEFORE\nTHE HONORABLE JUDGE DEBRA C. FREEMAN,\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT MAGISTRATE JUDGE\n\nAPPEARANCES:\nFor Plaintiffs:\n\nCuti Hecker Wang, LLP (NYC)\nBy: Mariann M. Wang, Esq.\nDaniel Mullkoff, Esq.\n305 Broadway, Suite 607\nNew York, NY 10007\n212-620-2603\n\nFor the Defendants:\n\nTroutman Sanders LLP (NYC)\nBy: Bennet J. Moskowitz, Esq.\nMatthew J. Aaronson, Esq.\nValerie Sirota, Esq.\n875 Third Avenue\nNew York, NY 10022\n212-704-6087\n\nTranscription Service:\n\nCarole Ludwig, Transcription Services\n155 East Fourth Street #3C\nNew York, New York 10009\nPhone: (212) 420-0771\nEmail: Transcription420@aol.com\n\nEFTA02737424\n\n\f\n\n[═══ TRANSCRIPT ═══]\nCase 1:19-cv-10788-GHW-DCF  Document 43  Filed 06/01/20  Page 3 of 25  INDEX  EXAMINATIONS  Witness  Direct  Cross  ReDirect  ReCross  None EXHIBITS Exhibit Number  Description  ID  In  Voir Dire  None  EFTA02737426", "char_count": 1153}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10788-GHW-DCF\n\nDocument 43\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nPage 2 of 25\n\nAPPEARANCES - CONTINUED:\nFor the Defendants:\n\nTroutman Sanders\nBy: Molly S. DiRago, Esq.\n27 West Monroe Street - Suite 3900\nChicago, IL 60606\n312-759-1926\n\nProceedings conducted telephonically and recorded by\nelectronic sound recording;\nTranscript produced by transcription service\n\nEFTA02737425\n\n\f", "char_count": 369}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10788-GHW-DCF\n\nDocument 43\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nPage 3 of 25\n\nINDEX\n\nEXAMINATIONS\n\nWitness\n\nDirect\n\nCross\n\nReDirect\n\nReCross\n\nNone\nEXHIBITS\nExhibit\nNumber\n\nDescription\n\nID\n\nIn\n\nVoir\nDire\n\nNone\n\nEFTA02737426\n\n\f", "char_count": 218}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-1O788-GHW-DCF\n1\n\nDocument 43\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nPage 4 of 25\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\n4\n\nHONORABLE DEBRA C. FREEMAN (THE COURT):\n\nAll\n\n3\n\nright, so this is Judge Freeman.\n\n4\n\ncalendared right, this should be a conference in three of\n\n5\n\nthe cases involving the Jeffrey Epstein Estate:\n\n6\n\nv. Indyke, 19-cv-10653; Mary Doe v. Indyke, 19-cv-10758;\n\n7\n\nand\n\n8\n9\n\nAnd if I've got this\n\nJane Doe\n\nv. Indyke, 19-cv-10788.\nAnybody have a different understanding as to why\n\nyou're here?\n\n10\n\n(No response.)\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nNo.\n\nCan I have your appearances,\n\n12\n\nstarting with the first of the cases that I listed, the\n\n13\n\nJane Doe case?\n\n14\n\nMS. MARIANN M. WANG:\n\nSo for plaintiffs, Mariann\n\n15\n\nWang.\n\nAnd I believe my colleague, Dan Mullkoff, is on the\n\n16\n\nline.\n\nAnd we represent the plaintiffs in all three cases,\n\n17\n\nso\n\n(Stopped talking.)\n\n18\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\nAnd on defendants' side?\n\n19\n\nMR. BENNET J. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nGood morning, your Honor.\n\n20\n\nBennet Moskowitz, Troutman Sanders, for the co-executors.\n\n21\n\non the line should be my colleagues, Matthew Aaronson, Valerie\n\n22\n\nSirota, and Molly DiRago.\n\n23\n\nthe actions.\n\n24\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n4, 5, 6 people.\n\nAnd\n\nAnd that's true for all three of\n\nOkay.\n\nSo that would count for 1, 2, 3,\n\nIs my law clerk on?\n\nEFTA02737427\n\n\f", "char_count": 1282}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-1O788-GHW-DCF\n1\n\nDocument 43\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nPage 5 of 25\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\n5\n\nYes, Judge, I'm here.\n\n3\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay, that's Hannah\n\n4\n\nof my clerks.\n\n5\n\nwhat I heard when i joined the call.\n\n6\n\nthe call?\n\n.\n\nShe's one\n\nThere should be still more people on, based on\n\n7\n\nMS. EMILY FALL:\n\n8\n\nreporter with 3M Canny 4 Productions.\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n10\n\nMR. JAMES\n\nHi.\n\nIs there anyone else on\n\nMy name is Emily Fall; I'm a\nI'm also on the call.\n\nOkay, is there anyone else on?\n:\n\nYour Honor, this is James\n\n11\n\nI'm a reporter with ABC News, and I am monitoring the call and\n\n12\n\nwill keep my line on mute.\nTHE COURT:\n\n13\n\nOkay.\n\nI've slightly lost count.\n\nIf\n\n14\n\nthere's anyone else on the call from the public or press, you\n\n15\n\nare, of course, welcome to listen in.\n\n16\n\nif you would keep your phones on mute, which you seem to have\n\n17\n\nbeen doing until I asked who was here.\n\n18\n\nDo we have a court reporter?\n\nI would appreciate it\n\nI know that in one of\n\n19\n\nthe conferences scheduled today -- it may have been the one\n\n20\n\nthat's at 11 o'clock -- there was a request to have a court\n\n21\n\nreporter.\n\n22\n\nNo?\nAll right.\n\nSo the conference is being recorded\n\n23\n\nthrough the AT & T conference system.\n\nAnd if anyone wants a\n\n24\n\ntranscript, you can get it through us through that system.\n\n25\n\nBecause someone may be trying to transcribe it from an audio\n\nEFTA02737428\n\n\f", "char_count": 1388}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10788-GHW-DCF\n\nDocument 43\n\n1\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nPage 6 of 25\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n6\n\n2\n\nrecording, if you do speak, please state your name before you\n\n3\n\nspeak so someone can keep the voices straight and be able to\n\n4\n\nmake a transcript that makes sense if there should be a need.\n\n5\n\nAll right, so what I thought I would do, rather than\n\n6\n\nhave a conference in all of the cases that I have in front of\n\n7\n\nme for supervision, I thought I would take them in clusters\n\n8\n\nwhere issues had arisen.\n\n9\n\nwas a consent letter filed for an extension of time.\n\n10\n\nthough it was on consent, I thought I would hear from you as\n\n11\n\nto this concept of an informal stay and just what was\n\n12\n\nhappening.\n\n13\n\nbut I wanted to get a sense of where things were with respect\n\n14\n\nto potential settlement.\n\n15\n\nmuch as anyone else, but that doesn't really tell me the full\n\n16\n\nstory.\n\n17\n\ngeneral status here?\n\n18\n\nMS. WANG:\n\nIn each of these three cases there\nAnd even\n\nAnd I don't mind a 30-day extension of deadlines,\n\nAnd, you know, I read in the news as\n\nSo can I just hear from plaintiffs' counsel about\n\nSure, your Honor\n\nThis is Mariann Wang\n\n19\n\nagain.\n\n20\n\nlitigation; that is, we've exchanged discovery responses,\n\n21\n\ninterrogatory responses\n\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nSo we have made some progress in terms of the\n\nTHE COURT:\ncall?\n\nNo?\n\nHold on a second.\n\nDid someone join the\n\nI want to make sure\n\nMS. LAURA MENNINGER:\nin, your Honor.\n\nHi.\n\nI'm just -- I'm listening\n\nIt's counsel for another party.\n\nEFTA02737429\n\n\f", "char_count": 1510}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-1O788-GHW-DCF\n\nDocument 43\n\n1\nTHE COURT:\n\n3\n\nMS. WANG:\n\nOkay.\n\nCan I just ask counsel for which party?\n\nJust to know.\n, I'm sorry.\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAre you counsel in another case that's\n\n7\n\npending in front of me?\n\n8\n\nMS. MENNINGER:\n\n9\n\nin front of you at nine o'clock AM.\n\n10\n\nfor Ms. Maxwell.\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nI have a hearing\n\nThis is Laura Menninger\n\nAt nine o'clock?\n\nYou must mean 11\n\no'clock New York time?\n, I'm sorry, yes.\n\n13\n14\n\n7\n\nII, that's fine.\n\n5\n\n12\n\nPage 7 of 25\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\n4\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nColorado.\n\nYeah, 11 o'clock Eastern time.\nOkay.\n\nThank you.\n\n15\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n16\n\nAll right, you were saying, counsel?\n\n17\n\nMS. WANG:\n\nSure.\n\nI'm in\n\nYou're welcome.\n\nSo, again, Mariann Wang for\n\n18\n\nplaintiffs.\n\nSo we have made some progress.\n\nWe're also\n\n19\n\nwe were kind of on the cusp of about to exchange a lot of\n\n20\n\npaper discovery and starting to talk about depositions.\n\n21\n\nAnd so there was progress being made on the litigation\n\n22\n\nside.\n\n23\n\nnot -- was hindered a bit because of the pandemic, just in\n\n24\n\nterms of communications and timeliness and ease of\n\n25\n\ngathering things because of, obviously, not being able to\n\nAt the same time that aspect of litigation was\n\nEFTA02737430\n\n\f", "char_count": 1245}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-1O788-GHW-DCF\n\nDocument 43\n\n1\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nPage 8 of 25\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n8\n\n2\n\nmeet in person with the clients.\n\n3\n\nhave some essentially, I guess, one would say some\n\n4\n\nconflicts potentially with defense counsel about whether\n\n5\n\nand how depositions can proceed, in person or remotely.\n\n6\n\nWe had also started to\n\nIn any event, because of the kind of -- the\n\n7\n\ncombination of perfect storm of both the hindrance of the\n\n8\n\npandemic and logistics -- should I stop?\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYes.\n\n10\n\nMALE:\n\nInner City Press.\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n12\n\nYes.\n\nOkay.\n\nDid someone just join the call?\n\nFine.\n\nNot a participant.\n\nIf you could keep your\n\nphone on mute, I would appreciate that.\n\n13\n\nMALE:\n\nI will.\n\nThanks.\n\n14\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nGo ahead, Ms. Wang.\n\n15\n\nMS. WANG:\n\nAgain, Ms. Mariann Wang.\n\nAnd, at the\n\n16\n\nsame time, our understanding that in the Virgin Islands\n\n17\n\nthere seems to be potential progress and potentially in the\n\n18\n\nshort term a possibility, really, of getting the claims\n\n19\n\nresolution process started.\n\n20\n\nmake sense to put a pause and see whether that would have\n\n21\n\nsome, you know, traction and whether we could get going on\n\n22\n\nthat before essentially, really, both working extremely\n\n23\n\nhard and potentially draining resources on the estate front\n\n24\n\nof, you know, having apparently four or five lawyers\n\n25\n\nworking nonstop on fighting us to some degree.\n\nWe just felt that it might\n\nIt just\n\nEFTA02737431\n\n\f", "char_count": 1446}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10788-GHW-DCF\n1\n\nDocument 43\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nPage 9 of 25\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n9\n\n2\n\nseemed to make sense to hit pause for a little while.\n\n3\n\nthat's the basic concept.\nTHE COURT:\n\n4\n\nSo\n\nI will say on defendants' side you\n\n5\n\nseem to have four attorneys on this call.\n\nI hope you're\n\n6\n\nkeeping costs under control under the circumstances.\n\n7\n\nSo I gather what you want to do is you don't want\n\n8\n\nan extension of discovery; what you want to do is basically\n\n9\n\nhave a hiatus of discovery and then put the same amount of\n\n10\n\ntime back on the clock as you had before?\n\n11\n\neverything for 30 days and have another 30 days thereafter\n\n12\n\nto finish discovery if you need it?\n\n13\n\nMS. WANG:\n\n14\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nYou want to stop\n\nThat was the idea, yes, your Honor.\nHow much optimism do you have during\n\n15\n\nthis 30-day period this process is going to get rolling and\n\n16\n\nyou'll be able to enter into it and get these cases\n\n17\n\nresolved?\n\n18\n\nMS. WANG:\n\nWell, this is where it is a little bit\n\n19\n\ntrying to balance.\n\nAnd I think that -- I mean, I have -- I\n\n20\n\nguess I probably would have more optimism -- I have\n\n21\n\noptimism that in 30 days we will know much more and we will\n\n22\n\nbe able to then -- at least that's my hope -- be able to\n\n23\n\nreally say okay, let's turn back to the litigation; or,\n\n24\n\nokay, let's really, you know, put this on hold/pause for\n\n25\n\nmore amount of time because it looks like that's going.\n\nEFTA02737432\n\n\f", "char_count": 1445}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10788-GHW-DCF\n\nDocument 43\n\n1\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\nPage 10 of 25\n10\n\n2\n\nThat's my hope, at least.\n\n3\n\nbetter, in fact, what -- you know, whether or not my\n\n4\n\noptimism is warranted.\n\n5\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nPerhaps the estate would know\n\nYour Honor, Bennet Moskowitz.\n\n6\n\nI may, I'm happy to provide an update about the Epstein\n\n7\n\nVictims Compensation Program.\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n9\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nIf\n\nI'd appreciate it.\nSure.\n\nAnd I'd first, since you've\n\n10\n\nraised it, like to address the issue of keeping costs --\n\n11\n\nand I can assure your Honor that the sole reason the\n\n12\n\nattorneys are on who are on is because it is more efficient\n\n13\n\nin terms of managing all the 15 or so active cases for only\n\n14\n\nthose who are on to be on rather than have lengthy back-\n\n15\n\nand-forth follow-ups with each other.\n\n16\n\nvery concerned about litigation costs.\n\n17\n\ndriving those costs have been various plaintiffs' firms.\n\n18\n\nwill not necessarily pin that on Ms. Wang, as she is\n\n19\n\nactually trying to be reasonable here with the stay of some\n\n20\n\nsort, although -- which I'll get to -- we disagreed on how\n\n21\n\nto best do that.\n\n22\n\nAnd, in fact, we are\nAnd the people\nI\n\nBut it bears mentioning the biggest drivers have\n\n23\n\nbeen the plaintiffs' firms, including making the estate\n\n24\n\nfight for months over whether they can get punitive\n\n25\n\ndamages, which Judge Engelmayer in two cases ruled that no,\n\nEFTA02737433\n\n\f", "char_count": 1434}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10788-GHW-DCF\n\nDocument 43\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nPage 11 of 25\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nthey can't; and as we've been saying all along, it's black\n\n3\n\nletter law.\n\n4\n\nmeeting for you now.\n\n5\n\nby plaintiffs' counsel attributing cost concerns to us.\n\n6\n\nThe other culprit is the U.S. Virgin Islands attorney\n\n7\n\ngeneral, which I'll get to.\n\n11\n\nAnd those are two of the cases on which we're\nSo I'm surprised to hear any comment\n\n8\n\nBut to get back to the program, we are confident\n\n9\n\nthat the program will commence by June 15, at the latest.\n\n10\n\nTo date, counsel for around 69 individual claimants have\n\n11\n\ncome forward, including through the U.S.V.I. Probate Court,\n\n12\n\nin support of the program.\n\n13\n\nconstitutes the vast majority of claimants.\n\n14\n\nare only aware of one claimant through her counsel who has\n\n15\n\nstated that she does not intend to participate.\n\n16\n\nof the state court plaintiffs, not one of the cases before\n\n17\n\nyour Honor.\n\n18\n\nposition of that individual.\n\n19\n\nWe believe that figure\nIn fact, we\n\nThat's one\n\nAnd I don't even know if that's the current\n\nAs your Honor is probably aware, we're now up to\n\n20\n\nseven Southern District of New York plaintiffs in three\n\n21\n\nlawsuits who have formally stayed their actions pending\n\n22\n\ntheir participation in the program, including most recently\n\n23\n\n, whom Boies Schiller represents.\n\nMs. Wang's\n\n24\n\nthree clients, of course, as they put it, sought this\n\n25\n\ninformal stay, and they intend to participate in the\n\nEFTA02737434\n\n\f", "char_count": 1502}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10788-GHW-DCF\n1\n\nDocument 43\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nPage 12 of 25\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n12\n\n2\n\nprogram.\n\nThe program administrator and the designers have\n\n3\n\nnearly finalized the protocol for the program.\n\n4\n\nthat's the nuts and bolts of how the program actually\n\n5\n\nworks.\n\n6\n\nclaimants' counsel and with input from the co-executors.\n\nRecall\n\nThey've done that in close consultation with\n\n7\n\nSo to recall, the only reason that the program did\n\n8\n\nnot formally commence several months ago, which is what we\n\n9\n\nwanted, which would have avoided all these litigation\n\n10\n\ncosts, is that in January 2020, the U.S. Virgin Islands\n\n11\n\nattorney general, who again does not represent a single\n\n12\n\nalleged victim, unilaterally imposed liens on the estate's\n\n13\n\nbank accounts in the Virgin Islands, freezing then-\n\n14\n\navailable funds for administration of the estate and\n\n15\n\nimplementation of the program.\n\n16\n\nsolely attributable to the attorney general of the Virgin\n\n17\n\nIslands.\n\n18\n\nThat caused a huge delay\n\nI am pleased to report that just a few days ago,\n\n19\n\nthe estate and the U.S. Virgin Islands attorney general\n\n20\n\nhave reached a resolution in principle, which I understand\n\n21\n\nwould involve the attorney general finally stepping aside\n\n22\n\nso the program can finally formally proceed.\n\n23\n\nfew, I'd say, less contentious matters that still need to\n\n24\n\nbe ironed out in that regard, but we expect that that\n\n25\n\nresolution would be finalized by next week and that we\n\nThere are a\n\nEFTA02737435\n\n\f", "char_count": 1507}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10788-GHW-DCF\n1\n\nDocument 43\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nPage 13 of 25\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n13\n\n2\n\nwould notify the U.S.V.I. Probate Court about that sometime\n\n3\n\nnext week.\n\n4\n\nbecause the need for the program has grown increasingly\n\n5\n\nurgent, and with the overwhelming support of claimants'\n\n6\n\ncounsel, the co-executors in any event intend to seek\n\n7\n\ncommencement of the program on June 15, absent some\n\n8\n\ncontrary direction from the U.S.V.I. Probate Court, which\n\n9\n\nwe do not expect.\n\n10\n\nIf, however, something unexpected occurs, and\n\nAnd, indeed, it bears mentioning that during the\n\n11\n\nFebruary 4 hearing at the U.S.V.I. Probate Court, the judge\n\n12\n\nsaid, quote, \"I think we agreed that everybody believes\n\n13\n\nthis program is a great program,\" end quote.\n\n14\n\nthe sole holdup here has been the attorney general of the\n\n15\n\nVirgin Islands.\n\n16\n\nprogram will formally move forward soon, that it will have\n\n17\n\nan overwhelmingly successful participation rate and be a\n\n18\n\ngreat success, which we always expect and that's what\n\n19\n\neveryone's been working hard towards.\n\nSo, again,\n\nSo I am confident in saying that the\n\n20\n\nMeanwhile, I agree with Ms. Wang -- and, actually,\n\n21\n\ncounsel for Maxwell has said this in a letter to the Court,\n\n22\n\nas well -- that every dollar spent on litigation, which\n\n23\n\nagain plaintiffs' counsel in some of the other matters\n\n24\n\nbefore your Honor have been driving up through, you know,\n\n25\n\nunnecessary motions, unnecessary requests to make discovery\n\nEFTA02737436\n\n\f", "char_count": 1512}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10788-GHW-DCF\n1\n\nDocument 43\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nPage 14 of 25\n14\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nmotions, that is money that will never possibly be\n\n3\n\navailable to fund the program, which we have been trying to\n\n4\n\ndo since day one.\n\n5\n\nplaintiffs' counsel, different plaintiffs' counsel, who\n\n6\n\nresisted stays of litigation.\n\n7\n\nto hear the comments about cost concerns.\n\nYou may recall, your Honor, that it was\n\nSo, again, I was surprised\n\nBut we agree with where Ms. Wang is at this now,\n\n8\n9\n\nit would be a disservice to claimants and a waste of\n\n10\n\njudicial resources during a time when such resources are,\n\n11\n\nas evidenced by, you know, this conference call, stretched\n\n12\n\nvery thin due to the unprecedented situation we find\n\n13\n\nourselves in with the pandemic, for money to be spent on\n\n14\n\nlitigation.\n\n15\n\napproached us, which also bears mentioning that they\n\n16\n\napproached us about this concept of an informal stay, we\n\n17\n\nproposed that we do the same stay that we've done in some\n\n18\n\nof the other actions before your Honor, which if your Honor\n\n19\n\nrecalls, those orders -- basically, people can lift them at\n\n20\n\nany time if they decide they don't want to participate in\n\n21\n\nthe program or for whatever reason.\n\n22\n\nHonor and request a lift of the stay.\n\n23\n\nagree to that; and, therefore, we, you know, agreed to what\n\n24\n\nwas offered, which was this kind of informal stay, followed\n\n25\n\nby a --\n\nIt was for that reason that when Ms. Wang\n\nThey can go to your\nMs. Wang didn't\n\nEFTA02737437\n\n\f", "char_count": 1511}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10788-GHW-DCF\n\nDocument 43\n\nPage 15 of 25\n15\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n1\nTHE COURT:\n\n2\n3\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nHold on one second.\n\nDid someone join\n\nthe call?\nMember of the press here.\n\n4\n\nMALE:\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n6\n\nI'm sorry, please continue.\n\n7\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nHello.\n\nOkay.\n\nFine.\n\nSo I was about to wrap up, your\n\nSo, in any event, you know, like I said, I'm\n\n8\n\nHonor.\n\n9\n\npleased to report that I have confidence the program will\n\n10\n\nstart soon, matter of weeks, not months, finally.\n\n11\n\nagree with the call's concerns, which is that all these\n\n12\n\nactions to be stayed for people that intend to participate\n\n13\n\nin the program, which as I understand it, is every\n\n14\n\nplaintiff in every action that's before your Honor,\n\n15\n\nincluding the ones that we're here talking about now.\nTHE COURT:\n\n16\n\nOkay.\n\nAnd I\n\nSo on the deadlines, what\n\n17\n\nyou're looking for -- correct me if I'm wrong on this --\n\n18\n\nfor fact discovery, you want deadline extension from\n\n19\n\nJuly 10 to October 8, is that right?\nMS. WANG:\n\n20\n21\n\nThere's a\n\nletter --\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n23\n\nlooking at the wrong\n\n24\n\n30-days?\n\n25\n\nI believe that's correct.\n\nMS. WANG:\n\nThat's -- II, I'm sorry, I may be\nno, I think so. Yes. That's not a\n\nI apologize, your Honor.\n\nThis is --\n\nEFTA02737438\n\n\f", "char_count": 1262}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10788-GHW-DCF\n\nDocument 43\n\n1\n2\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nPage 16 of 25\n\nPROCEEDINGS\nTHE COURT:\n\n16\n\nThe letter -- I pulled up the letter\n\n3\n\nin, I think it's the same letter that was written in all\n\n4\n\nthree cases.\n\n5\n\nfor -- II, I'm sorry, you're looking for 90 days.\n\n6\n\nlooking for 90 days and an extension\n\nAnd it says in the letter that you're looking\nYou're\n\n7\n\nMS. WANG:\n\nThat's correct.\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n-- on the answer deadline for 30.\n\n9\n\nMS. WANG:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\nAnd if I may -- this\n\n10\n\nis plaintiffs' counsel, Mariann Wang, again.\n\n11\n\nfor this informal stay of 30 days and essentially to kind\n\n12\n\nof reassess at that time; and, therefore, we were building\n\n13\n\nin a larger cushion at the back end.\n\n14\n\nThe idea was\n\nAnd just for the record, for purposes of the\n\n15\n\nrecord, I just will have to say that I dispute some of the\n\n16\n\nthings that Mr. Moskowitz said.\n\n17\n\nworth going into now.\n\n18\n\nthe estate's part not to produce any documents or cooperate\n\n19\n\nuntil it decided that it could put four or five attorneys\n\n20\n\non this matter.\n\n21\n\nBut I don't think it's\n\nI think there was a lot of effort on\n\nBut, in any event, for purposes of what's going on\n\n22\n\nright now, that is correct.\n\n23\n\nlittle bit of extra cushion at the back end.\n\n24\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThe idea was to build in a\n\nSo let me see if I understand this.\n\nWhat you're saying is kick all the deadlines out by 90\n\nEFTA02737439\n\n\f", "char_count": 1421}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10788-GHW-DCF\n\nDocument 43\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nPage 17 of 25\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\ndays, discovery deadlines; don't do anything for 30 -- and\n\n3\n\nsome time has already passed since you wrote the letter,\n\n4\n\nperhaps you're not even looking at 30 anymore -- and then\n\n5\n\nonce those 30 days go by, start up again but at a more\n\n6\n\nleisurely pace because you have another 60 days?\n\n7\n\nMS. WANG:\n\nNo, your Honor.\n\n17\n\nThe idea would be in\n\n8\n\n30 days we would report back to the Court about what the\n\n9\n\nbest approach -- what the best approach would be -THE COURT:\n\n10\n\nLet me ask again if someone's joined\n\n11\n\nthe line.\n\n12\n\nbeeps might mean someone left or someone joined.\n\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n\nHas someone joined on the line?\n\nHello?\n\nThose\n\nLet me just make sure defense counsel is still\npresent.\n\nMr. Moskowitz?\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nI'm here, your Honor, Bennet\n\nMoskowitz.\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\nAll right.\n\nI haven't set this\n\n18\n\nup with the computer dashboard that identifies people and\n\n19\n\nlets me know who joined and who dropped.\n\n20\n\nthis as a straight phone call, so that's why I keep asking\n\n21\n\nthe questions, to try to figure out who's present in my\n\n22\n\ncourtroom, so to speak.\n\n23\n\nargument suddenly gets up and walks out of the courtroom,\n\n24\n\nthat's something I can see; but on the phone call, I have\n\n25\n\nto just make sure that that's not what happened, you know,\n\nWe're just doing\n\nIf a lawyer who's making an\n\nEFTA02737440\n\n\f", "char_count": 1439}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10788-GHW-DCF\n1\n2\n\nDocument 43\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nPage 18 of 25\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n18\n\nthrough some kind of dropped call or something.\n\n3\n\nOkay, so you were saying, counsel?\n\n4\n\nMS. WANG:\n\nYes, of course.\n\nI'm sorry.\n\nSo, your Honor, the\n\n5\n\nidea was really basically a stay for 30 days and then\n\n6\n\nessentially an opportunity to reassess and confer with\n\n7\n\nopposing counsel and basically report to the Court about\n\n8\n\nthe next steps of, you know, whether we are going back\n\n9\n\ninto, you know, full-on litigation because everything seems\n\n10\n\nto be falling apart in the other -- in the other method of\n\n11\n\nresolution; or if, you know, it would appear that we can go\n\n12\n\nback or we can even enter into a more formal permanent\n\n13\n\nstay.\n\n14\n\nAnd to be clear, the reason I didn't like the\n\n15\n\nothers -- and which -- and my clients were not amenable to\n\n16\n\nit is that my understanding is and the way it appeared is\n\n17\n\nthat those other actions are essentially stays that don't\n\n18\n\nallow to pick up as easily.\n\n19\n\ndifferent method of approach, I'm happy to confer with my\n\n20\n\nclients and opposing counsel and see if there's, you know,\n\n21\n\na different method of doing this.\n\n22\n\nmy clients' perspective is the ability, essentially to, you\n\n23\n\nknow, step back into litigation full bore if things are\n\n24\n\nseeming to not go in the right direction.\n\n25\n\nhear -- it's the first I'm hearing from Mr. Moskowitz,\n\nIf your Honor prefers a\n\nBut the main thing from\n\nI'm very glad to\n\nEFTA02737441\n\n\f", "char_count": 1502}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10788-GHW-DCF\n\nDocument 43\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nPage 19 of 25\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nalthough I had asked him earlier about, you know, news on\n\n3\n\nthe V.I. proceeding\n\n4\n\nprogress.\n\n5\n\nJune 15 start time.\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n19\n\nI'm glad to hear that there is\n\nAnd this is the first I'm hearing of this\n\nOkay.\n\nSo I am still not quite\n\n7\n\nunderstanding your letter in light of what you're saying,\n\n8\n\nbecause you wrote the letter May 11.\n\n9\n\nit immediately upon its receipt, your informal stay would\n\n10\n\nhave lasted until June 10.\n\n11\n\nwould have given you an opportunity to report back shortly\n\n12\n\nthereafter -- let's say you would have reported back to me\n\n13\n\nby, say, June 12 or maybe June 15, if not June 10, you're\n\n14\n\nasking for an extension, based on this letter, to submit a\n\n15\n\njoint status report regarding, including, you know, among\n\n16\n\nother things, the progress of settlement discussions, to be\n\n17\n\nextended from June 1 to August 31.\n\n18\n\naround the middle of June.\n\n19\n\nSo if I had granted\n\nAnd then if what you say is it\n\nAugust 31 is not in and\n\nwhy don't I just kick out the dates by some\n\n20\n\nreasonable period of time from now and ask for a status\n\n21\n\nreport by a certain date?\n\n22\n\nneed more time because, you know, things are logistically\n\n23\n\ndifficult to get done because of the pandemic or something,\n\n24\n\nyou can let me know, and I'll kick out the dates\n\n25\n\nspecifically so that you can have a hiatus and save\n\nAnd if you find that you still\n\nEFTA02737442\n\n\f", "char_count": 1495}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10788-GHW-DCF\n\nDocument 43\n\n1\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nPage 20 of 25\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n20\n\n2\n\nresources and still have time on the clock to get discovery\n\n3\n\ndone if you need it.\n\n4\n\nmaking sense to me, and I'm not sure I'm understanding why\n\n5\n\nthe 90 is necessary, why we need more time than the hiatus\n\n6\n\ntime.\n\n7\n\nBut some of these dates aren't quite\n\nAnd if the more time is needed because you're\n\n8\n\nhaving problems agreeing on whether depositions can proceed\n\n9\n\nby remote means, I'll tell you what I'm telling everyone\n\n10\n\nelse in the city of New York who's trying to litigate cases\n\n11\n\nright now, which is learn how to take depositions by remote\n\n12\n\nmeans.\n\n13\n\nup that learning curve, and things seem to be moving pretty\n\n14\n\nwell.\n\n15\n\nurging it.\n\n16\n\nyou're in that kind of situation where you're trying to\n\n17\n\nnegotiate protocol for remote depositions, I can give you a\n\n18\n\ncase cite that I've been passing around.\n\n19\n\neven know, I'm sure, that I've been passing it around.\n\n20\n\nof my colleagues sent around a proposed remote deposition\n\n21\n\nprotocol that litigants had submitted in a case, didn't\n\n22\n\nbless it, didn't endorse it.\n\n23\n\nmentioned, and certainly the Court's not endorsing any\n\n24\n\nparticular provider or anything, but it showed some\n\n25\n\nthought.\n\nEverybody is learning, and the providers have gone\n\nI'm not forcing people's hands, but I am strongly\nAnd it seems to be pretty successful.\n\nAnd if\n\nThe parties don't\nOne\n\nThere was particular provider\n\nAnd I've been passing this citation onto other\n\nEFTA02737443\n\n\f", "char_count": 1551}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10788-GHW-DCF\n\nDocument 43\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nPage 21 of 25\n\n1\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nlawyers as something to glance at as maybe giving rise to\n\n3\n\nideas and having a basis for discussion.\n\n4\n\nshowed that some time and effort was put into considering\n\n5\n\nthe issues that can arise.\n\n6\n\ncitation.\n\n7\n\nCommunication.\n\n8\n\nMarrero and Magistrate Judge Moses, and it's Docket 51 in\n\n9\n\nthat case, 18-cv-12296.\n\n10\n\njust pointing it out as people wrestle with these kinds of\n\n11\n\nconcepts.\n\n12\n\n21\n\nI thought it\n\nSo let me give you that\n\nIt's Campus Productions International v. Charter\nIt's 18-cv-12296.\n\nIt's a case before Judge\n\nAgain, I'm not blessing it; I'm\n\nBut so why don't I just extend your deadlines\n\n13\n\nsomewhat?\n\nIt's now already May 22, so I could kick them\n\n14\n\nout to, let's say -- or by 45 days or something like that;\n\n15\n\nask for a status report by the middle of June; and you'll\n\n16\n\ntell me what's going on.\n\n17\n\nout is with the understanding that you want to pause\n\n18\n\nthings, try to preserve resources, and I'm putting another\n\n19\n\n45 days at the end of the schedule to enable you to get\n\n20\n\nthings done.\n\n21\n\nschedule if you have to for that time.\n\n22\n\nlogistical problems, you can get back to me and tell me\n\n23\n\nwhat those logistical problems are.\n\n24\n\nBut, you know, what you put out here doesn't seem to quite\n\n25\n\nhold together.\n\nAnd the reason for me to kick it\n\nAnd you can, you know, map out a deposition\nAnd if you run into\n\nOr maybe even 60.\n\nEFTA02737444\n\n\f", "char_count": 1494}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10788-GHW-DCF\n1\n\nDocument 43\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nPage 22 of 25\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n2\n\nMS. WANG:\n\n3\n\nenough, your Honor.\n\n4\n\nperspective.\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThis is plaintiffs' counsel.\n\n22\nFair\n\nThat makes perfect sense from our\n\nOkay, look, so here's what I'm going\n\n6\n\nto do.\n\nI'm going to move out all deadlines on your\n\n7\n\nscheduling order by 60 days, with the understanding that if\n\n8\n\nfor the next, well, until the middle of June when you know\n\n9\n\nif this program is starting, anyway, whatever makes sense,\n\n10\n\nwhether it's 30 days or until June 15, you can discuss that\n\n11\n\nbetween you, for some period of time you're going to hold\n\n12\n\noff on incurring costs.\n\n13\n\nin time, maybe by June -- why don't I just say by June\n\n14\n\n19 -- by June 19, which is the end of that week that starts\n\n15\n\nJune 15 -- by June 19, send me a status report, which is\n\n16\n\neither things are going great, we want to stay this longer\n\n17\n\nbecause we really are participating in this program; or\n\n18\n\nthings look grim, it's taken a downturn in the Virgin\n\n19\n\nIslands, and we want to get back on the calendar and we've\n\n20\n\nstarted talking about that; and because of some logistical\n\n21\n\nissues, we think we need more time or we think we're okay\n\n22\n\nor whatever.\n\n23\n\nunderstanding that you're going to pause things\n\n24\n\ncooperatively and give me a status report by June 19.\n\n25\n\nRational?\n\nAnd then, at the end of that point\n\nBut 60 days on the dates, with an\n\nEFTA02737445\n\n\f", "char_count": 1465}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10788-GHW-DCF\n\nDocument 43\n\n1\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n23\n\n2\n\nMS. WANG:\n\nYes, your Honor.\n\n3\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nDefendants' side?\n\n4\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n5\n\nPage 23 of 25\n\nMoskowitz.\n\n6\n\nThank you.\n\nThat is acceptable to us.\n\nBennet\n\nThank you.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\nI will issue an order, probably\n\n7\n\njust a text order on the docket, that will confirm that for\n\n8\n\nyou.\n\n9\n\ndates on that are 60 days out so you have definite dates\n\n10\n\nfor various and assorted things.\n\n11\n\nalready gone by, don't worry about it because they'll have\n\n12\n\nkicked out 60, you know, retroactively.\n\n13\n\nthat neither of you is going to start jumping up and down,\n\n14\n\nsaying this week we must now have depositions happening.\n\n15\n\nassume that you're going to wait until approximately\n\n16\n\nJune 15 to see if it's really necessary and report by\n\n17\n\nJune 19.\n\n18\n19\n\nI will look at the schedule we have and put firm\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\nIf some dates have\n\nAnd I am assuming\n\nBennet Moskowitz here.\n\nI\n\nWe have,\n\nyes, no intention of that, your Honor, and I just --\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n21\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n23\n\nintention is to balance things.\n\n24\n\nrealistic chance of it getting settled, any of these cases\n\n25\n\ngetting settled, that's great.\n\nI'm sure.\nYes.\n\nI'm sure.\n\nNot what I want.\nI'm sure.\n\nLook, my\n\nYou know, if there's a\n\nAnd I don't want you\n\nEFTA02737446\n\n\f", "char_count": 1362}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-1O788-GHW-DCF\n\nDocument 43\n\n1\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\nPage 24 of 25\n\nPROCEEDINGS\n\n24\n\nBut if there are problems with\n\n2\n\nspending unnecessary funds.\n\n3\n\nit, I want to keep discovery moving in a rational way,\n\n4\n\nkeeping costs reasonably under control, keep you talking,\n\n5\n\nkeep you planning.\n\n6\n\nthat's the balancing act.\n\nThat was the concept all along.\n\nAnd so\n\nOkay?\n\n7\n\nMS. WANG:\n\nUnderstood.\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\n9\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\nAnd I --\n\nThank you, your Honor.\n\n-- realize different cases may be\n\n11\n\nhandled somewhat differently with different counsel, and so\n\n12\n\nbe it.\n\n13\n\non the same track, but there are always going to be some\n\n14\n\ndivergences.\n\nI was thinking I'd try to get you all more or less\n\n15\n\nOkay.\n\n16\n\nMS. WANG:\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n\nThank you, all.\nThank you.\nI will talk to at least certain of you\n\nagain in half an hour.\n\n19\n\nMR. MOSKOWITZ:\n\n20\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n21\n22\n\nThank you.\n\nAll right.\n\nTake care, everybody.\n\nBe\n\nwell.\n(Whereupon, the matter is recessed.)\n\n23\n24\n25\n\nEFTA02737447\n\n\f", "char_count": 1064}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02737424", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Case 1:19-cv-10788-GHW-DCF\n\nDocument 43\n\nFiled 06/01/20\n\n1\n\nPage 25 of 25\n25\n\n2\n3\n\nCERTIFICATE\n\n4\n5\n\nI, Carole Ludwig, certify that the foregoing\n\n6\n\ntranscript of proceedings in the case of\n\n7\n\net al, Docket #19-cv-10788-GHW-DCF, was prepared using\n\n8\n\ndigital transcription software and is a true and accurate\n\n9\n\nrecord of the proceedings.\n\nv. Indyke\n\n10\n11\n12\n13\n\nsignature\n\n14\n15\n\neattale Diuelet\nCarole Ludwig\n\nDate:\n\nMay 29, 2020\n\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nEFTA02737448\n\n\f", "char_count": 484}]}