{"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_count": 105, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02734959", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02734959.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Filing # 158743660 E-Filed 10/06/2022 05:00:12 PM\n\nIN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE\nFIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND\nFOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA\nCA FLORIDA HOLDINGS, LLC,\nPublisher of THE PALM BEACH POST,\n\nCASE NO.: 50-2019-CA-014681-XXXX-MB\nDIVISION: AG\n\nPlaintiff,\nv.\nDAVE ARONBERG, as State Attorney of\nPalm Beach County, Florida; SHARON R.\nBOCK, as Clerk and Comptroller of Palm\nBeach County, Florida,\n\nco\n\nDefendants.\n\nDA HOLDINGS, LLC,\nWRITTEN CLOSING ARGUMENT OF C\nPUBLISHER OF THE PALM BEACH PO\nOlt ATE ATTORNEY DAVE\nARONBERG'S AMENDED MOTIO\nATTORNEYS' FEES UNDER\nFLORIDA STATUS\nTION 57.105\nPlaintiff, CA Florida Holdings,\n\"Post\"), pursuant to the Court's i\n\n\"Amended Motio\nL\n\nINT\n\nthe conclusion of the evidentiary hearing held on\nsubmits this Written Closing Argument opposing State\n\nSeptember 6 and 8, 2022, res\nAttorney Dave AronberIr\n\npu8ljsher of The Palm Beach Post (\"Plaintiff\" or the\n\nr,ovember 9, 2020 Amended Motion for Attorneys' Fees (the\n\nunder lorida Statutes § 57.105 [DE 50].\nON\nAttorney's Amended Motion should be denied with prejudice, as it is both\n\nprocedural) and substantively deficient. The evidence establishes that—in an effort to inform the\npublic how sexual predator Jeffrey Epstein received a highly unusual and extremely lenient plea\nagreement following his 2006 grand jury indictment by a former Palm Beach County State\nAttorney—the Post and its attorneys conducted an extensive factual and legal investigation,\nleading to the filing of this case seeking the Epstein grand jury materials. The Post relied upon\n1\n*** FILED: PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL\n\nABRUZZO, CLERK. 10/06/2022 05:00:12 PM ***\nEFTA02734959\n\n\f", "char_count": 1642}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "statutes and case law supporting disclosure of the grand jury materials under the unique and\nextraordinary circumstances of the Epstein case—including Miami Herald Pub. Co. v. Marko, 352\nSo. 2d 518 (Fla. 1977), in which the Florida Supreme Court recognized an exception to grand jury\nsecrecy under the First Amendment in the context of grand jury findings of public corruption—to\nargue that a similar exception to grand jury secrecy should be recognized in the E\nWhile ultimately denying the relief that the Post sought, in the Court's Final J\n\ncase.\nnt on the\n\ndeclaratory relief claim in Count I, Judge Hafele stated that the Post's ar\n\nre \"palatable\n\nand persuasive\" and presented \"strong arguments\" for a more expa iv\n\nction of the \"in\n\nfurtherance of justice\" language of Florida Statutes Section 90\n\nJ\n\ncase presented questions of \"first impression\" regardi\n\ntute's interpretation and the\n\nCourt's inherent authority over grand jury proceediV 'SS'c,\n\ne Hafele also noted the\n\nuestions also implicated \"issues of\n\nconstitutional import regarding the historic c \"Sloc\nsote tlw een grand jury secrecy and the First\nAmendment.\" Ex. J30 at pp. 5, 7, 11,\n\nI Th\n\nissues are now on appeal before the Fourth\n\nDistrict Court of Appeal.\n\nr\n\nAs was shown at the e\nmerit. It is the State Atto\n\nhearing, the State Attorney's Amended Motion has no\n\n' burden—and a heavy one—to prove sanctions are permitted and\n\nwarranted under\n\n'da S lutes Section 57.105 as to Count I of the Amended Complaint, the\n\ndeclaratory\n\nt claim. This is a burden the State Attorney not only failed to meet, but cannot\n\nmeet,\n\ndmitted in his Answer that the Count I declaratory judgment claim presented a\n\n\"good faith dispute\" between the parties. Ex. J09 at ¶ 72; Ex. J10 at ¶ 72.\nThe State Attorney's accusation that he was named in his official capacity—in a claim\n\nCitations to \"Ex. J_\" correspond to the hearing exhibit numbers set forth in the parties' Joint\nExhibit List, filed with the Court on September I, 2022.\n\n2\n\nEFTA027\n... [truncated, 2008 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/1 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=1]", "char_count": 2008}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "seeking access to grand jury materials from a prosecution by a former State Attorney—solely\nbecause of some \"personal vendetta\" against him has no factual basis. Hrg. Tr.2 at 58:6-59:25.3\nRather, the evidence shows a thoughtful, deliberate, and detailed factual investigation and legal\nanalysis by the Post's attorneys to determine what claims to bring and what parties were required\nto be joined to obtain public access to Epstein's grand jury materials.\nThe State Attorney was always a necessary party—the reasons requiring IA\n\npder were\n\nalleged in the initial Complaint, continued in the Amended Complain\n\nver changed,\n\ncontrary to the State Attorney's argument that the Post somehow \"mo e t\n\n'posts.\" Hrg. Tr.\n\nat 53:1-11, 59:15-25, 60:21-61:14. Unlike the Clerk, who wasc) edit\n\ns official capacity only\n\nas being \"in possession of documents that are the subjec\n\ni\n\nat ¶ 4], the State Attorney was named in his °MeliaS\n\nrimarily because of his \"authority\n\np2\n\nion,\" [Ex. J04 at ¶ 4; Ex. J09\n\nin grand jury proceedings pursuant to Fla. St\n\n*o\n\n7.03.\" See Ex. J04, ¶ 3; Ex. J09 at ¶ 3;\n\nsee also Ex. J16 (June 23, 2020 Letter f\n\nelsohn to D. Wyler, counsel for State Attorney\n\nDave Aronberg).\nAs the sole public offic 1 wi\nhad the right and authori\n\n2 Full transcri,\n\nfiled with'\nExhibit A.\n\nauthority over grand jury proceedings, the State Attorney\n\np so chose, to object to the release of grand jury materials by the\n\nevidentiary hearings on September 6 and 8, 2022 (\"Hrg. Tr.\") have been\nand condensed versions of the transcripts hereto are attached as Composite\n\n3 The Sta\n\nAttorney's belief that the only reason his Office was named as a defendant was because\nof a \"pe\nal vendetta\" and animus to \"go after\" him on behalf of the Post (Hrg. Tr. at 58:659:25) was not supported by any exhibit, nor any pleadings or filings. To the contrary, the Post's\nattorney, Stephen Mendelsohn, testified he had a great deal of respect for the State Attorney and\nhis Office. Hrg. Tr. at 136:17-137:13. Despi\n... [truncated, 2499 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/2 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=2]", "char_count": 2499}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Clerk. The State Attorney exercised his authority and objected to release of the grand jury\nmaterials by his motion to dismiss the initial Complaint, and again in his Answer to Count I and\nMotion to Dismiss Count 11 of the Amended Complaint. Ex. J06; Ex. J10.\nOnce the State Attorney changed his position, on October 14, 2020, by affirmatively stating\nthat he did not obiect to release of the grand jury materials if ordered by the Coup, the Post\ndismissed the State Attorney from the lawsuit on October 21, 2020. Yet, nineteeA4ls\n\nafter his\n\ndismissal, on November 9, 2020, the State Attorney filed the Amended M\nBecause the Amended Motion was filed after the State Atto\n\nn dismissed from\n\nthe case and because there was a lack of proper service of the\n\nd\n\nto address the merits of the State Attorney's Amended\n\nder the law, the Court lacks\n\njurisdiction to consider it, and the Amended Motio\nII.\n\nTHE COURT LACKS JURISD\nMOTION\nA.\n\nAmended Motion (the on\nplainly admitted,\n\nadmiss\nOlympus 1\n\n\"Sic\n\ndenied on that basis alone.\n\nO CONSIDER THE AMENDED\n\nTHE STATE ATTORNEt in rn HIS AMENDED MOTION AFTER HE WAS\nDISMISSED As A PA\n\nAs a threshold—but\n\ndismissed\n\nty nn\n\notion, there is no need\n\nI—point, the Court lacks jurisdiction to consider the\notion set for hearing before the Court) because, as the State Attorney\n\nled h Amended Motion on November 9, 2020, after he had already been\nOctober 21, 2020. Ex. J23,125; Hrg. Tr. at 44:3-6, 57:2-12. With that\nourt does not have jurisdiction to consider the Amended Motion. Sidlosca v.\n\nCo., 276 So. 3d 987, 989 (Fla. 3d DCA 2019) [Authorities TAB 26] (\"[A] trial court\n\nhas continuing jurisdiction to consider a section 57.105 motion for sanctions only where the motion\nfor sanctions was filed with the court before a voluntary dismissal\") (emphasis added).\n\n4\n\nEFTA02734962\n\n\f", "char_count": 1823}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "B.\n\nTHE AMENDED MOTION VIOLATED THE \"SAFE HARBOR\" NOTICE. PROVISION IN\nSECTION 57.105(4). AS IT WAS NEVER SERVED BEFORE IT WAS FILED.\n\nCompounding the above error, the State Attorney admitted that the Amended Motion was\nnot properly served before it was filed. Hrg. Tr. at 16:16-17:21; 92:2-93:25. As a result, the\nAmended Motion violated the strict \"safe harbor\" notice provision of section 57.105(4), which\nrequires a motion for fees to be served on the non-moving party at least 21 days bef\n\nit is filed.\n\nFla. Stat. § 57.105(4) (\"A motion by a party seeking sanctions under this sec\n\nust\n\nbut may not be filed with or presented to the court unless, within 21 d s a\n\nservice of the\n\nmotion, the challenged paper, claim, defense, contention, allegation,\n\nserved\n\ndenylal is not withdrawn or\n\nappropriately corrected.\") (Emphasis added).\nmended Motion before the Post\n\nThe State Attorney's admission that if he had s\n\nno motionforfees, is also fatal. Hrg.\n\ndismissed him as a party on October 21, 2020, he\n\na\n\nTr. at 93:3-25. Without proper safe harbor\n\nCourt does not have jurisdiction. See MC\n\nLiberty Express, Inc., 252 So. 3d at 40\n\ner to have properly complied with section 57.105,\n\n[the filing party] must have first\n\nproposed motion upon the party it sought to sanction.\")\n\nThis is because \"[t]he primary p\n\ne5e of section 57.105's safe harbor provision is to provide the\n\nrecipient of the moti n wi\nbefore sanctio\n2011) [A\nplaintiff's\nC.\n\nn ice and the opportunity to withdraw or abandon a frivolous claim\nt.\" Id.; see also Ferere v. Shure, 65 So. 3d 1141, 1145 (Fla. 4th DCA\n\nAB 6] (section 57.105(1) was not applicable where there was no way for\nnsel to withdraw an allegation after a post-trial motion).\nTHE STATE ATTORNEY MAY NOT RELY ON SERVICE OF A PRIOR \"PLACEMARKER\" MOTION FOR FEES TO AVOID TILE STRICT REQUIREMENTS OF 57.105.\n\nThe State Attorney relies on a prior—what he calls a \"place-marker\"—motion for\nattorneys' fees that was served on June 8, 2020 and filed on July I, 2020, \n... [truncated, 2042 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/4 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=4]", "char_count": 2042}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "the safe harbor requirements of 57.105(4). Ex. J14; Ex. J18; see also Ex. J21 at pp. 5, 13. His\nreliance is misplaced.\nService of that initial \"place-marker\" motion is not sufficient to comply with section\n57.105(4), because once the State Attorney filed his Amended Motion containing new arguments,\nthe 21-day safe harbor notice was required anew. See Lago v. Kame By Design, LLC, 120 So. 3d\n73, 75 (Fla. 4th DCA 2013) [Authorities TAB 14]. The Lago Court stated:\nWe hold that if a party files a subsequent or amended motion for\nsection 57.105 and raises an argument that was not raised in the ri\nsection 57.105 sanctions, the subsequent motion must indepe\nthe twenty-one-day 'safe harbor' provision of section 57.105(\nId. at 75; see also Moore v. Estate ofAlbee by Benzenhafe\n\nunder\non for\nply with\n\n.3d 192, 195, n.2 (Fla. 5th\n\nDCA 2018) [Authorities TAB 20] (court could not coms1 61amended motion for section 57.105\nfees because it raised additional grounds for san\nfor fees and there was \"no indication that\n\ntiCt\n\not\n\nised in the defendant's prior motion\n\nnd t] complied with the twenty-one-day 'safe\n\nharbor' provision of section 57.105\n\n147 So. 3d 569, 572 (Fla. 3d DCA\n\n2014) [Authorities TAB 22].\nLago and its pro eny\n\nish that the State Attorney was required to independently\n\ncomply with the 21\n\ny sloe fiarbor before filing his Amended Motion, because the Amended\n\nMotion made\n\nat\n\nents and referenced new evidence, including the State Attorney's August\n\n2020 mot\n\nmmary judgment and affidavit in support, which were not in existence at the\n\ntime of th\n\n\"place-marker\" motion. Compare Ex. J14 with Ex. J25; see also Hrg. Tr. at\n\n94:6-17.\n\n6\n\nEFTA02734964\n\n\f", "char_count": 1671}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "III.\n\nTHE INITIAL \"PLACE-MARKER\" MOTION CANNOT BE CONSIDERED, AND\nEVEN IF IT COULD IT WHOLLY FAILS TO SATISFY SECTION 57.105\nA.\n\nTHE INITIAL \"PLACE-MARKER\" MOTION FOR FEES WAS NEVER NOTICED FOR\nHEARING.\n\nApparently recognizing at the hearing that the State Attorney's violation of section\n57.105(4)'s safe harbor provision is fatal to the State Attorney's Amended Motion, in his opening\nstatement the State Attorney's counsel said he would now rely, in the alternativS the initial\n\"place-marker\" motion for attorneys' fees-i.e., the one-page motion and\nletter, served on June 8, 2020 [Ex. J14] and filed on July I, 2020 [Ex.\nThe State Attorney's July I, 2020 \"place-marker\" fee mot\nhearing. Hrg. Tr. at 128:1-4. The only motion that was s\nleast twice, is the November 9, 2020 Amended\nAccordingly, the Amended Motion is the onl\n\n\"trial court erred in ruling on a\nremand). While the State Atto\nbased upon Logo, that\nsanctions motion\nwhether con\n\nnever been set for\nng, and re-set for hearing at\n\nx. 325; Hrg. Tr. at 132:14-17.\n\n1226, 1226 (Fla. 4th DCA 2022) (holding the\nas not noticed for hearing,\" requiring reversal and\nthe Court should also now consider his initial fee motion\n\nion does not save him, as Lago did not address whether the first\n\nbeen roperly noticed for hearing and the appellate court did not consider\non f the first motion would violate the opponent's due process rights. See\n\nLago,\n\"motion,\n\n0\n\nhat may properly be considered by the\n\nv. Persighetti,\n\nCourt. See, e.g.,\n\n4;1,age enclosure\n\n• at 75. As stated above, were this Court to now address the \"place marker\nich was not noticed for hearing, it would violate the Post's and its attorneys' due\n\nprocess rights.\n\n7\n\nEFTA02734965\n\n\f", "char_count": 1705}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "B.\n\nTHE INITIAL \"PLACE-MARKER\" MOTION FOR FEES WHOLLY FAILS TO SATISFY\nSECTION 57.105.\n\nEven if the initial \"place-marker\" motion had been noticed for hearing (which it never was)\nand the Court could consider that motion (which it cannot), the initial motion does not help the\nState Attorney. The barebones \"place-marker\" motion fails to meet the high burden of section\n57.105. The Court must look at the substance, or lack thereof, of that motion, as of at moment\nin the timeline, to determine whether at that time the State Attorney met his bu\n\n11fOf s wing the\n\nclaim was frivolous or, in other words, that the Post knew or should have\n\now\n\nwas no longer any justiciable claim. See Chue v. Lehman, 21 So. 3d 8\n\n(Fla. 4th DCA 2009)\n\n(\"Thus, we must consider the evidence presented at the e\nI\n\n[plaintiff] and his attorney knew or should have known\nTAB 1]; Weatherby Assoc.'s, Inc. v. Ballack, 7138,\n\nthat time there\n\nhearing concerning what\npo tin the litigation.\") [Authorities\n1142-43 (Fla. 4th DCA 2001)\n\n(\"First, the court must determine whether th\n\ntw\n\nthen the court must determine whethe\n\name frivolous after the suit was filed.\") (finding\n\nthat \"[a]ny reasonable inferen\n\nrivolous when initially filed. If it was not,\n\ne defendant was working for plaintiff's competitor\n\ndisintegrated during discovery aifY.Q4tera deposition revealed the opposite, \"leaving no justiciable\nissues of law or fact\" and\nThere\n(technics\n\non\n\nn ering the suit frivolous\" at that point) [Authorities TAB 30].4\n\nne purported basis for sanctions stated in the first \"place-marker\" motion\n\nnclosure letter to that one-page motion) regarding the declaratory relief claim\n\n4 See also Tr. Mortg., LLC v. Ferlanti, 193 So. 3d 997, 1001 (Fla. 4th DCA 2016) (\"Instead, like\nhere, where the party reasonably believes the factual basis for its claim exists, it is entitled to\nproceed with its claims and seek to prove those facts. If attempts to prove those facts are fruitless,\nthat is still not cause for sanctions where th\n... [truncated, 2295 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/7 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=7]", "char_count": 2295}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "in Count 1—the argument that the State Attorney did not have possession or custody of the Epstein\ngrand jury materials. Ex. J14; Ex. J17. Did that argument alone end the matter as to the State\nAttorney? No. Did that argument alone make the State Attorney's joinder in this case so frivolous\nas to be completely untenable? Absolutely not.\nAt the time the first \"place-marker\" motion was filed on July 1, 2020, there w s no sworn\ntestimony in the record as to what grand jury materials the State Attorney and hi\n\ne actually\n\npossessed. It was not until August 18, 2020, more than six weeks after tha\n\nof the safe\n\nharbor period for the initial place-marker motion, that the State A\n\ne\n\nid\n\nhis motion for\n\nsummary judgment and affidavit in support, in which he stated\n\noaZlffor the first time that he\n\ndid not have possession of any grand jury materials soug\n\nn\n\nmplaint, and in which he first\n\nstated his position that he did not have the authorityi\n\nhat the Clerk provide access to the\n\ngrand jury materials. Ex. J18; Ex. J19. Morselpth\n%\n\nJuly 1, 2020, the State Attorney had not\n\nyet addressed the other main reasons his ' • der i\n\ne case was necessary. Indeed, it was not until\n\nOctober 14, 2020, more than three\n\ns\n\ner the expiration of the safe harbor period—and after\n\nbeing reminded in both a lette\n\nmg by the Post as to why the Post had joined him in the\n\ncase—that the State Attokt Jed his reply stating \"the State Attorney has no objection\" to the\nClerk producing gad jurf materials if ordered by the Court. The State Attorney's failure to\naddress th\nmotio\n\nprior to the filing of his \"place-marker\" motion would be fatal even if that\nper to consider.\n\nEven if the State Attorney could overcome the jurisdictional defects that prevent the Court\nfrom considering the Amended Motion (which he cannot), under the merits, the evidence shows\nthat there is absolutely no basis for sanctions under section 57.105.\n\n9\n\nEFTA02734967\n\n\f", "char_count": 1936}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "IV.\n\nTHE EVIDENCE SHOWS THE STATE ATTORNEY FAILED TO MEET HIS\nHEAVY BURDEN FOR SANCTIONS UNDER SECTION 57.105\nA.\n\nLEGAL STANDARD FOR SANCTIONS UNDER SECTION 57.105.\n\nUnder Florida Statutes Section 57.105, the Court may award reasonable attorneys' fees\nonly if \"the court finds that the losing party or the losing party's attorney knew or should have\nknown that a claim or defense when initially presented to the court or at any time efore trial:\n(a) Was not supported by the material facts necessary to establish the cla'\n\nr\n\n(b) Would not be supported by the application of then-existing law to th •\n\n1 facts.\" Fla.\n\n40\n\nse; or\n\nStat. § 57.105(1).\nBefore awarding sanctions, the trial court must make 'c\nwas 'frivolous or so devoid of merit both on the facts a\n. . . This burden is a heavy one.\" MC Liberty Ex\n397, 403 (Fla. 3d DCA 2018) [Authorities TerS18y\nsee also\n\nv. Bailynson, 268 So.\n\nit findings\" that \"the action\ns t be completely untenable.'\n\ns,1i I\n\nv. All Points Servs., Inc., 252 So. 3d\n\nernal citations omitted) (emphasis added);\n\n8 (Fla. 4th DCA 2019) (setting forth the same\n\nstandard for sanctions). Thus,\n\nt\n\nfindings\" that a claim was frivo\n\nd completely untenable, and those findings \"must be based\n\non substantial competent c\n\nmotion for sanctions, the Court must make \"explicit\n\nfce that is either contained in the record or is otherwise before the\n\ncourt.\" MC Lib2kryjress, Inc., 252 So. 3d at 397; see also Yakavonis v. Dolphin Petroleum,\nInc., 934\n\n5, 618 (Fla. 4th DCA 2006) (\"The trial court's finding must be based upon\n\nsubstanti competent evidence presented to the court at the hearing on attorney's fees or otherwise\nbefore the court and in the trial court record.\") [Authorities TAB 31].\nB.\n\nTHE STATE ATTORNEY HAS NOT PROVEN THE DECLARATORY JUDGMENT\nCLAIM WAS FRIVOLOUS OR DEVOID OF MERIT.\n\nThe State Attorney's Office—the executive branch office tasked with protection of\n=secrecy—did not meet its burden of proving that naming the State Attorney's Office as a part\n... [truncated, 2022 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/9 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=9]", "char_count": 2022}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "to a declaratory relief claim seeking access to grandjury records—from a prosecution and grand\njury proceeding conducted by the former State Attorney's Office—was \"frivolous or so devoid of\nmerit both on the facts and the law as to be completely untenable.\" See, e.g., MC Liberty Express,\nInc., 252 So. 3d at 397.\nRather, the evidence demonstrates the opposite of what the State Attorney was required to\nprove—it shows that the declaratory judgment claim was made in good fait\nAttorney, in his official capacity, was a necessary party. Recognizing this\nanswered the declaratory judgment claim and admitted that a good f\n\nt\n\nthe State\ntate Attorney\nexisted between\n\nthe parties. Ex. 309 at ¶ 72; Ex. 310 at ¶ 72. The merit of the\n\njudgment claim should\n\nbe undisputed, as the State Attorney admitted that \"the DAct )\n\nincluding the State Attorney]\n\nhave refused to provide, access to the testimony, mi\n\n,\n\nther evidence presented in 2006 to\n\nthe Palm Beach County grand jury\" and \"a\n\npute exists between the panics.\" Ex. J09\n\nat ¶ 72; Ex. J10 at ¶ 72. These admissio\nse • ...,\na raponsive pleading doom the Amended Motion.\nC.\n\nTHE STATE ArroRot)\nY\n\nr\n\nThe Post sued both the Cle\n\nA NECESSARY PARTY.\nho was charged by law with maintaining possession of\n\ngrand jury materials, and\n\ntate Attorney's Office, who conducted the grand jury proceedings\n\nand who by law\n\nwith the authority and control over the grand jury process, including\n\nthe obligatio\nthat this\n\ncharg\n\nt grand jury secrecy. At the hearing, the State Attorney incorrectly argued\nsolely about who has custody and possession of the grand jury materials and\n\naccused the Post and its attorneys of \"moving the goalposts\" by asserting other non-possessory\nreasons for naming the State Attorney. Hrg. Tr. at 45:2446:5. No evidence supports these\narguments. As Mr. Mendelsohn testified, the Post's legal team determined after months of\nintensive and careful legal and factual research that the State Attorney was a necessary party to\nany action t\n... [truncated, 2102 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/10 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=10]", "char_count": 2102}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "I.\n\nThe State Attorney's Office was the public office that conducted the\n\ngrand July proceeding in 2006 and obtained Epstein's indictment, and to the extent\nthe Office had custody or possession of any grand jury materials, the Post was\nrequesting that they be produced and disclosed to the public.\n2.\n\nThe State Attorney is the public official with authority and co trol\n\nover the grand jury system and, as such, has the power to object to release\njury materials by the Clerk.\n3.\n\nAS\"\n\nThere was nothing under Florida law thatC\n\nAttorney from requesting copies of grand jury materials\n\n)\n\na State\n\nthZlClerk during and\n\nafter close of criminal prosecution.\nSee Hrg. Tr. at 112:5-114:11; Ex. J04, Ex. J09, Ex.\n\n\\\n\nAs demonstrated in the timeline attac\n\nibit B and as shown at the evidentiary\n\nhearing, the Post never moved the goalKcc e\nhac grounds were set forth in both the original and\nthe Amended Complaints:\n\n20n\nalmatapleiall\nfall anal at\nI\nat %KM\n\nrmrar\n\nJan la mm\nYin' kaa•al\nMoo *On arI\n\ngilS••••• oaten Stead\nmoan •4 %pi wore:deli\nNowa salarlith\n\nlimo II —\nlist\nVs* fearg\n.\nPetaallallaelalanoneSteetall.\nMN I I alma le Ma aawm\nOn a\nma a Mona al MN Mai\nargall\nway agar ale an Oka\nMOMS\n• alba 0. MISS arrrq\na■\nas ea ate\n•apelbasinpolielin\n\nal\n\n411~ la MO\nalso loam\n\nI al\nMast\nPINION\n\narms\nal*\nYea\nCas al I\n\nreuse\narram\n\nea a mm\nOes Goa\n\n•\n\nOimil I\n\n—I MI\nLa Cana\n'Nullea Ibr Nam\nwas lito r ailat Scowl 0 a\na DMUS.' ft\nMUSA\n\noppnlimassiel\n\n• pippipmespillosins.\nMSS Is pal\njag oda IT Vs a\n• Dago iota as r asa\nanar\n\nl\n\nraara mm\n/ma a Mal\nSir\na\nNan Po ro •\namp\n\nOda/I\nMO a Nag an\nMai\nas\n\nIlea se la\n\n12\n\nEFTA02734970\n\n\f", "char_count": 1624}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Both the initial Complaint, filed in November 2019, and the Amended Complaint, filed in January\n2020, named the State Attorney in his official capacity and as having \"authority in grand jury\nproceedings pursuant to Fla. Stat. section 27.03.\" Ex. 304 at ¶ 3; Ex. J09, ¶ 3.\nOn June 23, 2020, the Post's attorney, Mr. Mendelsohn, responded to the State Attorney's\ninitial \"place-marker\" fee motion and specifically laid out the 3 reasons why the Sta e Attorney\nwas a necessary party, with citations to additional case law. Ex. J16. Mr. Mende\n2020 letter explained that the State Attorney has \"as its primary interest th\njury system,\" citing In re Grand Jury Proceedings, 832 F. 2d 554, 55\noriginal). Ex. J16. In that case, the federal government petitio\n\nI ) Flo\n\n1\n\nJune 23,\nn of its grand\n\n. 1987) (italics in\nState Attorney to turn\n\nover state grand jury transcripts, and the State Attorney\n\ns\n\n905.27. Later, a federal grand jury served a subpoe\n\nsame State Attorney seeking grand\n\njury transcripts. Reversing his position, the?\nthat he would produce the transcript\npossession, he had legal authority\n\no\n\n\\e tt\nere\nc;\n\n'\n\neir release, citing to section\n\ney in response advised the federal court\n\ndemonstrating that irrespective of physical\n\nnd deliver them pursuant to the subpoena. Ex. J16.\n\nMr. Mendelsohn then explain\n\nthad\n\non In re Grand Jury Proceedings, the \"State Attorney\n\nwas named as a party no '\n\ny as a custodian of grand jury records\" but rather, \"the relevant\n\nState Attorney is\n\neces ry party in order to protect the grand jury that the Office of State\n\nAttorney su\n\nand to make arguments, if need be, against release of the grand jury\n\nmateri\n\nJ16.\nWhile In re Grand Jury Proceedings dealt with a subpoena as opposed to service of a\n\nsummons and complaint, both a subpoena and a summons served with a complaint are forms of\nprocess. See, e.g., 28 C.F.R. §§ O. I I I (b); 0.114(e) (defining \"process\" as \"a summons and a\ncomplaint, subpoena, writ, orders, and the execution of court-\n... [truncated, 2051 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/12 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=12]", "char_count": 2051}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "commitments on behalf of a requesting party\" for the U.S. Marshals Service, tasked with \"[tjhe\nservice of all civil and criminal process emanating from the Federal judicial system\").5 As there\nwas no pending civil case in which the Post could issue a subpoena, the only form of process\navailable to the Post was through service of a complaint. See Hrg. Tr. at 184:2-185:12; 186:25187:14:.6 It is also worth noting that the State Attorney in In re Grand Jury Proceed! gs inserted\nhimself into the case for the purpose of objecting to disclosure of grand jury reco\nhe was served with a subpoena, demonstrating that, regardless of the fo\nthere is no service of process, a State Attorney may intervene for th\n\nen before\ns, or even if\n\nf asserting grand\n\njury secrecy. See 832 F. 2d at 559.\nThe State Attorney's counsel did not respond to M<t )n\n\nohn's June 23, 2020 letter nor\n\ndid the State Attorney address In re Grand Jury Pro jhs\ni s\ne\nOn August 18, 2020, the State AttomeS ritpi a\nI and an affidavit in support, in which\n\nted\n\notion for summary judgment as to Count\n\nder oath for the first time that he did not have\n\npossession of any grand jury mate\n\no\n\ntin the Complaint, and first stated his position that\n\nhe did not have the authority t\n\nthat the Clerk provide access to the grand jury materials.\n\nEx. J18; Ex. J19.\nThen, on\n\"place-mark'\n\nber , 2020, in its response memorandum to the State Attorney's initial\nion, the Post reminded the State Attorney that because he still objected to the\n\n5 See also Ajllpajc v. Atria Grp., LLC, No. 8:13-cv-2415-T-35JSS, 2016 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 178214,\nat *16 (M.D. Fla. Jan. 19, 2016) (stating process is \"defined to include a summons, complaint, and\nsubpoena\" and citing 28 C.F.R. § 0.114(e)).\n6 Florida Rule of General Practice and Judicial Administration 2.420(j) was similarly not an\n\navailable method for the Post to seek the grand jury materials because that Rule requires a motion\nseeking disclosure be tied to a pending civil or criminal case. See Fla\n... [truncated, 2262 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/13 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=13]", "char_count": 2262}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Clerk's release of materials, the State Attorney remained a necessary party. Ex. J20, p. 8. Finally,\non October 14, 2020, in response to the Post's October 2, 2020 filing, the State Attorney changed\nhis position, stating for the first time that his Office no longer objected to the Clerk's release of\ngrand jury materials if ordered by the Court. Ex. J21 at pp. 1, 2. At that point, once the State\nAttorney had sworn under oath that he did not possess the requested grand jury material and stated\nin a pleading for the first time that his Office was no longer objecting to the Cle\nrecords, the State Attorney's presence in the action was no longer required.0\n15, Mr. Mendelsohn responded that he was \"pleased\" to read the Sta\nstatement that his Office no longer opposed the Post's requ i 4)r\nmaterials. Ex. J22; Hrg. Tr. at 130:10-13. The Post dis '\n\nt\n\nosing the\nday, October\n\n's \"unequivocal\"\ny Epstein grand jury\n\ntate Attorney on October 21,\n\n2020. Ex. J23.\nD.\n\nTHE POST AND ITS ATTORNEY\nS istir\nor\n\nAlthough the Post has no burde\n\nvt\ni.....e\nthis\n\nis GOOD FAITH.\n\ntion—it is the State Attorney's heavy burden\n\nto prove a lack ofgoodfaith—the e\n\nc\n\nthe declaratory judgment clai\n\ne entire litigation, in good faith. The Post's attorneys\n\nresearched the proper me v\nwas a case of firs\n\nmonstrates that the Post and its attorneys prosecuted\n\njp,obtain the grand jury materials. This was a difficult analysis—it\n\nressidb, involving novel and complex issues, and matters of genuine public\n\nconcern.\nbefore filing the initial Complaint, from June 2019 through November 2019, the\nPost's attorneys conducted substantial fact investigation and legal research into possible claims\nand the parties to be named in a lawsuit, in addition to relying upon the Post's extensive prior\ninvestigation. The Post presented significant evidence, which it and its counsel uncovered through\npainstaking due diligence, that a former State Attorney likely misused a grand jury by undermining\na victim's credibility based \n... [truncated, 2087 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/14 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=14]", "char_count": 2087}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "to that former State Attorney. Hrg. Tr. at 195:16-23. In an effort to obtain materials that would\nshed light on how Epstein obtained the extraordinarily lenient non-prosecution agreement and\nsentence recommendation from the former State Attorney's Office, and in addition to the Post's\npublic records requests, Mr. Mendelsohn submitted to the State Attorney's Office specific\ndocument requests in a letter dated August 27, 2019. Ex. JOI. The State Attorney never responded.\nHrg. Tr. at 104:20-22. Attorney Mike Grygiel followed up on Mr. Mendelsohn's I\n9, 2019, and like Mr. Mendelson, did not receive a response from the St\nHrg. Tr. at 105:414. After other avenues proved unsuccessful, an\n\nOctober\ney. Ex. J37;\n\niderable research\n\nand analysis, the Post and its attorneys asserted thoughtful, C\ng\n\nait\n\nguments, supported by\n\nstatutes and case law from Florida and other jurisdictionsqso\n\ni Court to find a mechanism\n\nto obtain the Epstein grand jury materials.\nThere was room in the law for thee As\nc meb),\n„\nthe Post, as shown in the Florida\nSupreme Court's decision in Miami Her\n\nPu\nc . o. v. Marko, 352 So. 2d 518 (Fla. 1977), and\n\nvarious additional cases cited by t\n\n• • s filings throughout this case. While section 905.27\n\nsays nothing overtly about the\n\ngrand jury materials to the media, and codifies grand jury\n\nsecrecy, the Florida Supr\n\npurt held, where a grand jury identifies abuses and corruption by\n\npublic officials, t\n\nfirst A endment compels public disclosure of the grand jury's written report\n\nand the evid\n\nfore the grand jury. 352 So. 2d at 523. The Post argued, based on the same\n\nrationa\n\nd by the Florida Supreme Court in recognizing a disclosure exception to grand\n\njury secrecy in cases involving findings of public corruption, that the Court should make a similar\nexception to grand jury secrecy under the unique circumstances of the Epstein case. As in Marko,\nwhere the Court recognized a First Amendment exception to grand jury secrecy, the Post argued\nthat the uniqu\n... [truncated, 2102 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/15 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=15]", "char_count": 2102}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "grand jury secrecy in favor of the media. Hrg. Tr. at 75:19-77:3. The State Attorney ignores\nMarko and the First Amendment.\nIn the Court's Final Judgment relating to the declaratory relief claim, the Court noted there\nwas ambiguity in the law, and expressed curiosity about whether \"an appeal of this order might\npersuade a higher court to establish a less restrictive interpretation.\" Ex. 330 at p. 12. In the\npending appeal, there is no longer a need to name the State Attorney\n\nhe stated\n\naffirmatively on the record his Office does not object to the Clerk's release\nMoreover, in the appeal, the Clerk has now changed its position an\n\nno\n\nry materials.\ner\" objects to the\n\ndisclosure of the grand jury materials if ordered. Hrg. Tr. at 2\n\n2uritie actions of the Post\n\nand its attorneys, in seeking an exception to grand jury sC ih)\n\ner the First Amendment like\n\nthat recognized by the Florida Supreme Court ini\n\"establish a less restrictive interpretation\" ofS\n\nr ~•\n\nat\n\\,tt\n\nd in advocating for the Court to\nherance of justice\" language in section\n\n905.27, are not sanctionable under secti\"‘....„\n7.10\nE.\n\nTHE POST'S CLAI\nSECTION 57.10S\n\nAt the very least, in this\nfaith argument for e tens'\nsanctions cann\n\nCIFICALLY EXCEPTED FROM SANCTIONS UNDER\n\nf first impression, the claim for declaratory relief was a good\nmodification of the law, and according to section 57.105(3Xa),\n\ned. See Fla. Stat. § 57.105(3)(a) (monetary sanctions cannot be awarded:\n\n\"if the co\n\nnes that the claim or defense was initially presented to the court as a good faith\n\nargument\n\nthe extension, modification, or reversal of existing law or the establishment of new\n\nlaw, as it applied to the material facts, with a reasonable expectation of success\").\nIn the Court's Final Judgment relating to the declaratory judgment claim, as it remained\npending against the Clerk, Judge Hafele described the Post's arguments as \"sincere,\" and\n\"palatable and persuasive\" and noted this was a case of \"first impression\" that \"implica\n... [truncated, 2033 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/16 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=16]", "char_count": 2033}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "of constitutional import,\" in the context of \"genuine subjects of public interest and concern. .. .\"\nSee Ex. J30 at pp. 5, 11, 13. Thus, 57.105 sanctions are not appropriate.\nF.\n\nTHE STATE ATTORNEY'S FOCUS ON THE PREVIOUSLY DISMISSED STATUTORY\nCLAIM IN COUNT II IS MISGUIDED.\n\nWhile the State Attorney focuses on the previously dismissed claim under section 905.27\nin Count II, and the June 3, 2020 hearing before Chief Judge Marx on the motion toss\n\nCount\n\nII, that hearing has no relevance to the instant motion. The motion to dismiss a\n\nsed\n\n3, 2020 hearing dealt only with section 905.27, and did not address t\n\nI declaratory\n\njudgment claim. Moreover, in dismissing Count II, the Court's June\nholding that section 905.27 does not create an implied cau\nFurther, the comments by Chief Judge Marx during th\\\n\nthe June\n\n202 Order was limited to\nion for the media. Ex. JI5.\n\nin\n\nat are not memorialized in the\n\nJune 8, 2020 Order are dicta and do not constitut * •\n\n• ia determination as to whether the State\n\nAttorney had possession or custody of any\n\nd jury materials.\n\nin\n\nThe June 8, 2020 Order disIdle\n\nstatutory claim in Count II cited Horowitz v.\n\nPlantation Gen. Hosp. Ltd. P'sl\n\n2d 176 (Fla. 2007), which sets forth the standards for\n\ndetermining if a statute creates a\n\nied cause of action. In Horowitz, the Florida Supreme Court\n\naddressed whether a riva\nrequirements\n\"judges la\nor limit, i\n\nt\n\no\n\nuse of action against hospitals existed under medical practitioner\nFlorida Statutes § 458.320, and referenced the general principle that\n\ner `to construe an unambiguous statute in a way which would extend, modify,\nxpress terms or its reasonable and obvious implications,\" as such \"would be an\n\nabrogation of legislative power.\" (Emphasis in original).\nWhile Horowitz may be relevant to an analysis of Count II on the issue of whether section\n905.27 creates a private cause of action, Horowitz has no relevance to either the State Attorney's\nplace-marker motion or the Amended Motion, which s\n... [truncated, 2061 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/17 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=17]", "char_count": 2061}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "unlike the previously dismissed Count II—is not a pure statutory claim seeking to assert a private\ncause ofaction under 905.27, but it is a claim for declaratory relief based on the First Amendment,\nthe Court's inherent authority over grand juries to prevent and expose prosecutorial abuses as in\nMarko, and section 905.27, which allows for release of grand jury materials in the furtherance of\njustice. Second, Horowitz is not a sanctions case. Horowitz does not address whethe a plaintiff\nshould be subjected to sanctions if its claim to a private right of action under a stalelyultimately\nfails. See Minto PBLH, LLC v. 1000 Friends of Florida, Inc., 228 So. 3d\n2017), where the Court stated if that argument were taken to its log\nwould be subject to sanctions under section 57.105 every time\n\ne\n\nla. 4th DCA\ne, \"a losing party\n\nrt faCfid that a statute or legal\n\ndocument was unambiguous and that the losing party'sGi\n\nwas incorrect.\" That is not\n\nthe standard.\nG.\n\nOBLIGATION FOR FEE\nSANCTIONS.\n\nS\n\nNo\n\nL\n\nDespite the State Attorney's i\nAmended Motion to \"get the t\n\nadmitted on cross-examination\n\ny\n\nBECAUSE TIIIRF IN\n\nNo B %Sr.\n\nFOR\n\nony that he insisted on moving forward with his\ne of their money back\" for legal fees, he reluctantly\ndollars have not been spent on this lawsuit. Hrg. Tr. at\n\n59:15-25; 63:21-64: 5. Fttu the outset, no fee obligations arose unless them was a Court order\nawarding secti\nWyler, w\nsanctions\n\n5\n\nsanctions. Ex. J05.7 The only way the State Attorney's counsel, Mr.\naid fees was under a section 57.105 motion. However, there is no basis for\n\ner section 57.105, and thus no basis for attorney's fees.\n\n7 There is no need to address the amount of fees sought because the State Attorney is not entitled\n\nto any fees under section 57.105. However, even if the Court were to disagree, the majority of the\nfees sought are not recoverable under Florida law, as set forth in the Post's Bench Memorandum\nRegarding Attorney Fee Objections, delivered to the Court on September\n... [truncated, 2064 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/18 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=18]", "char_count": 2064}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Put simply, section 57.105 is for egregious conduct. Nothing even close to that conduct\nwas presented by the State Attorney here.\nCONCLUSION\nPlaintiff, CA Florida Holdings, LLC, publisher of The Palm Beach Post, respectfully\nrequests that the Court: (i) deny State Attorney Dave Aronberg's November 9, 2020 Amended\nMotion for Attorneys' Fees, with prejudice; (ii) decline to address State Attorney\n\nronberg's\n\nJuly 1, 2020 Motion for Attorneys' Fees, as it is not properly before the Co\n\nthe alternative,\n\nif the Court decides to address it, deny the July 1, 2020 Motion for Att\n\nwith prejudice;\n\nand (iii) and grant such other and further relief as the Court dee\nc\n\n)nec s\n\nor proper.\n\nAuy submitted,\nBERG TRAURIG, P.A.\nrneysfor CA Florida Holdings, LLC,\nublisher of The Palm Beach Post\n/s/ Lauren Whetstone\nLAUREN WHETSTONE\nFlorida Bar No. 45192\nMARK F. BIDEAU\nFlorida Bar No. 564044\nGREENBERG TRAURIG, P.A.\n777 South Flagler Drive, Suite 300 East\nWest Palm Beach, FL 33401\nTel.: 561.650.7900\nwhetstonel@gtlaw.com\nbideaum@gtlaw.com\nsandra.famadas@gtlaw.com\nthomasdegtlaw.com\nFLService@gtlaw.com\nSTEPHEN A. MENDELSOHN\nFlorida Bar No. 849324\nGREENBERG TRAURIG, P.A.\n401 East Las Olas Boulevard, Suite 2000\nFort Lauderdale, FL 33301\nTel.: 954.768.8225\n\n20\n\nEFTA02734978\n\n\f", "char_count": 1271}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "mendelsohns@gtlaw.com\nsmithl@gtlaw.com\nMICHAEL J. GRYGIEL\n(Admitted Pro Hac Vice)\nGREENBERG TRAURIG, LLP\n54 State Street, 6th Floor\nAlbany, NY 12207\nTel.: 518.689.1400\ngrvizielmegtlaw.corn\nNINA D. BOYAJIAN SA\n(Admitted Pro Hac ••\nGREENBERG TRAU\n1840 Century P\nuite 1900\nLos Angeles, C 9 1 1 67\nTel.: 310\n7\nbo\nw.com\nrive\n.com\n\nCERTIFICAT 14\\ICE\nI HEREBY CERTIFY that on thi\nthe foregoing has been filed with the\nwhich will send a notice of elecC\n\n)is\n\n\\ ay\n\nOctober, 2022, a true and correct copy of\n\ne Court using the State of Florida e-filing system,\nice for all parties of record herein.\nIs/ Lauren Whetstone. Esq.\nLauren Whetstone, Esq.\n\n21\n\nEFTA02734979\n\n\f", "char_count": 660}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Composite\nExhibitc;A\"\n(s.\n\nEFTA02734980\n\n\f", "char_count": 42}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\nIN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT\nIN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA\nCASE NO. 50-2019-CA-014681-XXXX-MB AG\n\nCA FLORIDA HOLDINGS, LLC,\nPublisher of the PALM BEACH POST,\n\nA\n\nCos\n\nPlaintiff,\nvs.\n\nDAVE ARONBERG, as State Attorney\nof Palm Beach County, Florida;\nSHARON R. BOCK, as Clerk and\nComptroller of Palm Beach Count\nFlorida,\nDefendants.\n\n?s,\nIPT OF HEARING\n\nAd4tp\n\nAtOCEEDINGS\n\nRE:\n\nDefendan\nD04ve Aronberg's Amended Motion for\nAttorneys\nFees\n\nEN:\n\nBEFORE:\n\nTuesday, September 6, 2022\n1:42 p.m. - 4:53 p.m.\nPALM BEACH COUNTY COURTHOUSE\n205 North Dixie Highway\nCourtroom 10D\nWest Palm Beach, Florida\n33401\nLUIS DELGADO, JR., Circuit Judge\n\nStenographically reported by:\nLisa Begley, RPR, RMR\n270569\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734981\n\n\f", "char_count": 814}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 2\n1\n2\n3\n4\n\n6\n7\n\nAPPEARANCES:\nOn behalf of the Plaintiff:\nGREENBERG TRAURIG\n777 South Flagler Drive\nSuite 300 East\nWest Palm Beach, Florida 31401\n561-650-6420\nBY: LAUREN R. WHETSTONE. ESQ.\nwhetetOnelOgtlaw.com\nMARK F. BIDEAU. ESQ.\nbideaumagtlaw.corn\nGERARD BUITRAGO. ESQ.\nbuitragogegtlaw.cce:\n\n10\n11\n12\n11\n\nThereupon,\n\n2\n\nthe foliating proceedings began at 1:42 p.m.:\n\n3\n\nTP18 CCURT: All right, please be seated.\n\n4\n5\n\nAll right, so we're here on the amended\n=la: for attorneys' fees.\n\n6\n7\n\n8\n9\n\nPage 4\n\n1\n\nOn behalf of Defendant, Dave Arenberg:\nJACOB, SCHOLZ 6 WYLER, LLC\n961687 Gateway Boulevard\nSuite 2011\nFernandina Beach, Florida 32034\n904-261-3693\nBY: DOUGLAS A. WYLER, ESQ.\ndougajsvflorida.com\nAlso present: Dave Aronberg, State Attorney\nDefendant\n\nLet's announce appearances.\nMS. WHITSTI0NE: Good after:XAaL Your Motor,\n\n8\n\nLauren Whetstone. With re is Mark Bideau and\n\n9\n\nGerard Buitrago and our paralegal, Jennifer\n\n10\n11\n\nThroat Exam Greenberg Traurig on behalf of CA\nFlorida Holdings, the pub her of the Palm Beach\n\n12\n\nPost.\nME. C*12R:\n\n13\n14\n\nGM'S Dcogl\n\n15\n\ndefendant,\n\n16\n\nState Attorney Cave\n\n17\n\n14\n15\n16\n17\n\n, Your Honor. My\nI'm here on behalf of\n\nHonor.\n\n18\n\nThank you very much. It's your\n\n19\nMR. WYLER: Thank you, Your Honor. May I\n\n20\n21\n\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n21\n24\n25\n\nroach?\nTHE OTURT:\n\nMods head vp and down.)\n\nR. WYLER: Hi, again, Your Honor. Thank\nyou. May it please the Court. As you know, we're\nhere today on Pt. Aronberg's amended motion for\n\nPage 3\n1\n\nINDEX\n\nAG\nPAGE\n\n2\n3\n4\n\nPage 5\n\n1\n\nattorney's fees. It was filed on November 9th,\n\n2\n\n2020, in conjunction with his 57.105 demand that\nwas made to the plaintiffs on June 8th, 2020.\nThat demand letter that was sent to the\n\nOpening Statement\nBy Mr. Wyler\n\n4\n\n3\n\nBy Ms. Whetstone\n\n23\n\n4\n\nS\n\n5\n\nplaintiff's counsel was sent on the same day that\n\n6\n7\n\nJudge Marx entered her order granting the\ndefendant's motion to dismiss Count 2 of this case\n\n8\n\nwith prejudice. And that motion, that\n... [truncated, 3177 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/23 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=23]", "char_count": 3177}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 6\n\n1\n2\n\nTHE OrET:\n\nPage 8\n\nGive me that cite one more\n\ntime.\n\nLLC, v. Ferlanti. That's found at 193 So.3d 997.\n2\n\nThat's also a Fourth DCA case from 2016. And it\n\nMR. WIER: Yes, sir. It's IIIII v.\n\n3\n\ncan guide the Court here. This case says that, in\n\n4\n\nBailynson, B-a-i-l-y-n-s-o-n, 268 So.3d 762. It's\n\n5\n\na Fourth DCA 2019. That case says, The central\n\n4\n5\n\ndetermining an award of sanctions under\nSection 57.105, the trial court's findings must be\n\n6\n7\n\nbased on substantial competent evidence and the\n\n3\n\n6\n\npurpose of 57.105 Florida Statute is and always\n\n7\n\nhas been to deter meritless filings and, thus,\n\nB\n\nstreamline the administration and the procedure of\nthe courts. Thus, the post-1999 version of the 57\n\n8\n\nlosing party knew or should have known daring the\n\n9\n\n9\n\nfact establishment process both before and after\n\n10\n11\n\n-- 57.105 has expanded the circumstances where\nfees should be awarded and the purpose is to defer\n\n10\n11\n\nthe suit was filed.\nSo, as to the 57.105(1)(a) c in,\n\n12\n13\n\nmeritless filings.\n57.105 -- The statute 57.105 provides the\n\n12\n13\n\nMr. Aronberg's position is\nshould have known when t\n\n14\n\nfollowing language authorizing the award of\n\n14\n\nresearch that it was\n\n15\n\nattorneys' fees such as in the present litigation.\n\n15\n\nno access, custody •\n\n1\n\n16\n\nIt says, spoon the Court's initiative or motion of\n\n16\n\nbut that fact\n\nune was drawn to that\n\n17\n\nany party, the Wart shall award a reasonable\n\n17\n\nfact by Judge\n\nin the June 3rd, 2020, motion\nhe made several statements\n\ntrial court must make an inquiry into what the\n\n18\n\nattorney's fee, including prejudgment interest, to\n\n18\n\nto dismiss he\n\n19\n\nbe paid to the prevailing party in equal mounts\n\n19\n\nthat\n\n20\n21\n\nby the losing party and the losing party's\nattorney on any claim or defense at any tire\n\n20\n21\n\na\n\n22\n\nduring a civil proceeding or action in which the\n\n23\n\nCourt finds that the losing party or the losing\n\n24\n25\n\nparty's attorney knew or should have know\n... [truncated, 4454 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/24 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=24]", "char_count": 4454}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 12\n\n1\n\nPage 10\nthrough 1. \"Mot for nothing\" -- This is all Judge\n\n1\n\n2\n\nMarx. 'Not for nothing, I think we all know that\n\n2\n\nYou were to -- If you were to get a judgnent\n\n3\n\nthey don't have control and custody of the\n\n3\n\nagainst then, how wild you expect then to\n\n4\n5\n\nrecords.'\nPage 5, lines 17 through 19. \"I think we\n\n4\n\nperform?'\n\n5\n\nAnd then finally, on page 17, line 23.\n\n6\n\ncan all agree that the state attorney doesn't have\n\n6\n\n'that do you seen? ithat do you mean? They're not\n\n7\n\nthese records.\"\n\n7\n\ntrying to block it? They're saying that, despite\n\nB\n\nPage 8, lire 4. \"I'm asking you, how are\n\nthat they have the records, we know they don't.\n\n8\n\nthe fact -- let's just talk about the clerk\n\n9\n\nthe clerk and the state attorney the proper\n\n9\n\nbecause we all lave the state attorney doesn't\n\n10\n11\n\ndefendants?\"\nPage 8, line 8. \"I'm puzzled by the\n\n10\n11\n\nhave it.'\n\n12\n13\n\nprocedural posturing of this case naming the state\nattorney, and, you know, I'm further stymied by\n\n12\n13\n\ntranscript found at J29, 135\nExhibit No. 1.\n\n14\n\nthe fact that you allege in your complaint that\n\n14\n\nTHE CCORT: k\n\n15\n\nthey have, particularly David Arenberg the state\n\n15\n\n16\n\nattorney, that he has these records.\"\n\n16\n\nin evidence,\n\n17\n\nMR.\n\n17\n\nPage 8, line 18. 'dray, let's run this all\n\nI would ask the Court to ent\n\nMS. klETSTCNE\n\n18\n\nthe way out. Let's say you win and you get a\n\n18\n\ndon't know if\n\n19\n\njudgment against the state attorney, Dave\n\n19\n\nper\n\n20\n21\n\nArenberg. What's he supposed to do with it? He\ncan't release the grand jury testimony. He has no\n\n20\n21\n\n22\n\nauthority whatsoever to do that.\"\n\nthe hearing\nas Defense's\n\noint exhibits are\nre in evidence, but I\ned to nark them for each\n\nI don't need to do that, then I'll\nthat.\nThese joint exhibits have all\npulated to?\n\n23\n\nPage 10, line 21. 'And the only thing\n\nMR. VILER: Yes.\n\n24\n\nwe're here today about is wty should the clerk and\n\nTHE COURT: NO need then.\n\n25\n\nthe state attorney have to defen\n... [truncated, 4459 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/25 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=25]", "char_count": 4459}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 16\n\nPage 14\n1\n\ntheir legal acAmmiates and employees. However,\n\n1\n\n2\n\nthe grand jury testimony afforded such persons by\n\n2\n\n3\n\nthe Cant can only be used in the defense or\n\n3\n\ndifferent.\n\n4\n\nprosecution of the civil or criminal case and for\nno other purpose whatsoever.\"\n\n4\n5\n\nSee, in the [ago case, the party who was\nserved with the 57.105 demand never withdrew from\n\n6\n\nThat arganont was ultimately utilized in\n\n7\n\nJudge Hafele's final judgtent in favor of the\n\n6\n7\n\nThe person that served the original 57.105 in\nsago, after serving it, served a seccad one, and\n\n5\n\nprovision.\nOkay, but the facts are different, totally\n\nthe case. They stayed in the case to the end.\n\nB\n\nclerk because, an top of other things, the\n\n8\n\n9\n\nplaintiff admitted that they weren't seeking to\n\n9\n\nwhen they served the second 57.105 -- well, they\n\n10\n11\n\nuse these reoposted records in an underlying civil\nor criminal case. They wanted to use it to -- for\n\n10\n11\n\ndidn't serve a second 57.105 demand letter. They\nfiled a second notion for atto\nfees, an\n\n12\n\n12\n\n13\n\npublic disclosure.\nChapter 905.17 of the Florida statutes also\n\n13\n\namended notion for attorneys\nproviding an additional\n\n14\n\napplies here. This has also been made evident and\n\n14\n\nbefore they filed the\n\n15\n\nvery clear to the plaintiff. That statute says,\n\n15\n\nhappen in this case\n\n16\n\nin pertinent part, \"The notes\" -- and this is all\n\n17\n\nregarding the grand jury materials -- \"The notes,\n\n16\n17\n\n-- our origi\n\nIn this\n\n18\n\nrecords and transcriptions are confidential and\n\n18\n\nHoverter 9th,\n\nexempt from the provisions of Chapter 119.07 and\n\n19\n\nMr.\n\n20\n21\n\nSection 24(a), Article 1 of the State Constitution\nand shall be released by the clerk only on a\n\n20\n21\n\n22\n\nrequest by a grand jury for use by the grand jury\nor an an order of the Own pursuant to\n\n24\n\nChapter 905.27.\"\n\n25\n\nletter\nnotion. That didn't\nour amended motion\n\nfor attorneys' fees on\n\n19\n\n23\n\nttout\n\nthen they dropped\n\nfrom the case on October 21s\n... [truncated, 4729 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/26 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=26]", "char_count": 4729}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage le\n\nPage 20\n\n1\n\npicked up the originally-filed motion for\n\nmodification or reversal of existing law or the\n\n2\n\nattorneys' fees in that case. And we would ask\n\n2\n\n3\n\nYour Honor, in the alternative, should you find\n\n3\n\nestablishment of new law, as it applied to the\nmaterial facts, and with a reasonable expectation\n\n4\n\nthat, that you would rule on our original notion\n\n4\n\nof success.'\n\n5\n\nfor attorneys' fees if it came down to it because,\n\n5\n\n6\n\nin the end, the arguments are the sane, and the\n\n7\n\nreal diffetcue in the filing of the amended\n\n6\n7\n\nSo here, the plaintiff tries to twist the\nlanguage of that statute in two different ways to\nsuit its argument. First, they entirely failed to\n\nB\n\nmotion for attorneys' fees is that it included the\n\n8\n\nrecognize that tht 57.103(a) (sic) defense applies\n\n9\n\nfinal tabulation of my firm's fees, as well as\n\n9\n\nonly to claims made under 57.105(1)(b), and that\n\n10\n11\n\naffidavits -- my affidavit of reasonable -- of\nfees and an affidavit of reasonable fees from our\n\n10\n11\n\nhas to do with the law not being correct as\napplied to the facts to establish he case.\n\n12\n13\n\nexpert.\n\n12\n\nThe ocher interesting thing here, the other\n\n13\n\nto the case\nin such a way that wouldAt the claim as I\n\n14\n\nargument that you'll hear plaintiff make is that\n\n14\n\nwent through with t\n\nes with you. That\n\n15\n\nMr. Aronberg was a proper party to the case. Now,\n\n15\n\nis the only scenari\n\n16\n\nagain, the clerk is the person -- the only entity\n\n16\n\nmaking a legal\n\n1) ), when you're\na factual argment,\n\n17\n\n17\n\nwhere you can\n\nwith a good faith defense.\n\n18\n\nthat has authority to provide these records under\nstatute, and that alone should be enough to show\n\n18\n\nSo there is no\n\nith defense at all that\n\n19\n\nthat Mr. Arenberg is not a proper party defendant.\n\n19\n\n20\n21\n\nBut Judge Hafele's final judgment actually helps\nout this because Judge Hafele's final judgment\n\n20\n21\n\naPP1\n1\n\n22\n\nactually instructed plaintiff en the right way to\n\n23\n\n... [truncated, 4780 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/27 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=27]", "char_count": 4780}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 22\n1\n\nabout -- it says, or creation of a rex law, okay?\n\nPage 24\n\n1\n\nthis Court has noted.\n\n2\n\nThey weren't asking to create a new law with their\n\n2\n\n3\n\ndeclaratory relief claim. 'The only place where\n\n3\n\nThe Post rated two defendants, ruiner one,\n\n4\n\nthey were trying to create a new statutory cause\n\n4\n\nwith custody of grand jury records and, =doer\n\n5\n\nof action was in their Camt 2 that was dismissed\n\n5\n\ntwo, the state attorney's office because it\n\n6\n\nwith prejudice by Judge Marx and is not at all a\n\n6\n\nactually ran the investigation and because it is\n\n7\n\npart of It. Armeerg's 57.105 demand.\n\n7\n\nthe public office tasked with protecting grand\n\nthe clerk of Omit as the public office tasked\n\nB\n\nThe 57.105 demand only regards the claim\n\n8\n\n9\n\nfor declaratory relief. So the defense under\n\n9\n\njury secrecy.\nThe state attorney's office says they\n\n10\n11\n\n57.105(3)(a) fails as to both of Mr. Arcnberg's\n57.105 claims.\n\n10\n11\n\nshould have never teen na-redapart\nOf course\nthey had to be rated a party.\nly were they\n\n12\n\nthe public office that\n\n13\n\nI would just like to reiterate to the Court\nthat the clerk is in actual possession of the\n\n13\n\nand presumably had passe\n\n14\n\nrequested records, is the only entity that is\n\n14\n\nat sore tine, but, no\n\n15\n\nstatutorily authorized to release grand jury\n\n15\n\npublic office with\n\n16\n\nrecords pursuant to a Court order, and despite\n\n16\n\nprevent the c\n\n17\n\nplaintiff's arganents to the contrary, the record\n\n17\n\nCoca:lents.\n\n12\n\nYour H\n\n18\n\nevidence will slow that plaintiff and its lawyers\n\n18\n\n19\n\nknew or should have known at the time they were\n\n19\n\nat\n\n20\n21\n\nserved -- at least at the tire they were served\nwith the 57.105 demand that the declaratory relief\n\n20\n21\n\ndocjtrgt\n\n22\n\nclaim fails under 57.105(1)(a) because it is\n\n23\n\nunsupported by the material facts necessary to\n\ninvestigation\nce in documents\nantly, they're the\nauthority to\n\n'\n\nmg grand jury\nrd in the state\nopening that this is about\n\nr the sta\n... [truncated, 4463 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/28 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=28]", "char_count": 4463}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 28\n\nPage 26\n1\n\nAnd we dismissed -- the Post had dismissed him as\n\n2\n\na party 19 days before, on October 21st, 2020.\n\n1\n\ncase, and that's tab 6 in Your Honor's binder and\n\n2\n\nthat's a Fourth DCA case. And in that case, the\n\nThe case law is clear that the Court has no\n\n3\n\nCourt said that 57.105 subsection (1) was not\n\n4\n\njurisdiction over a motion for sanctions after a\n\n4\n\napplicable where there was no way for plaintiff's\n\n5\n\nvoluntary dismissal, like the motion here. And\n\n5\n\ncounsel to withdraw an allegation after a\n\n6\n\nthis is case law, including Sidlcsca vs. Olympus,\n\n6\n\npost-trial motion. So if 57.105 -- the\n\n7\n\nand that is in Authorities tab -- the Authorities\n\n7\n\nsafe-harbor notice was not available, then 57.105\ndoesn't apply at all.\n\n3\n\nB\n\nbinder that Your donor has at tab 26, and I'll\n\n8\n\n9\n\nread the case cite for the record. 276 So.3d 987.\n\n9\n\n10\n11\n\nIt's a Third DCA 2019 case.\nNumber two, the Court also lacks\n\n10\n11\n\nmotion made new arguments not in t first\nplace-marker motion. And we're so ng to pull up\n\n12\n13\n\njurisdiction because the amended motion, which is\n\n12\n\nthe only motion we are here on, violated 57.105\n\n13\n\nthe first place-marker moti\nmotion to compare than, melee\n\n14\n\nsubsection (4)'s safe-harbor notice provision\n\n14\n\nJoint Exhibits 14 and\n\n15\n\nwhich requires a motion for fees be served at\n\n15\n\n16\n\nleast 21 days before its filed.\n\n16\n\nplace-marker\n\n14, it's -- the\n\n17\n\nmotion itself\n\nThere's an enclosure\n\n17\n\nIt is (undisputed that the state attorney\n\nAnd, here, it's obvious that the amended\n\nSo, first, he\n\n18\n\nnever served a copy of the amended motion for\n\n18\n\nletter that c\n\n19\n\nsanctions at any time before filing it on Hoverter\n\n19\n\nthr\n\n20\n\n9th. I believe Mr. Wyler also mentioned that and\nagreed with that in his opening. As a result, the\n\n20\n21\n\n21\n22\n\namended notion cannot be considered. The state\n\n23\n\nattorney tries to rely on a prior, what he calls,\n\namended\nexhibits,\nhe first\n\nit, and it's two pag\n... [truncated, 4671 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/29 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=29]", "char_count": 4671}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 32\n\nPage 30\n1\n\nif you could pull up paragraph 20 of the amended\n\nAnd, Your Honor, here's the standard for\n\n1\n\nsanctions under Florida Statute 57.105. The\nread from that.\n\n2\n\nmotion -- it says, \"The state attorney has no\n\n2\n\n3\n\nobjection to the clerk producing and disclosing\n\n3\n\nstatute is behind it.\n\n4\n\nthe requested materials should the Court grant an\norder to that effect.• And then in paragraph 25\n\n4\n\nAnd this is a case that interprets -- interprets\nthis high standard, and this is the same -- I note\n\n6\n\nit says, \"Likewise, the state attorney has no\n\n6\n\nthat IIIII vs. Bailynson -- I'm going to botch\n\n7\n\nobjection and never has had any objection to the\n\n7\n\nthat name, sorry, but the case that Mr. Wyler read\n\nB\n\nclerk releasing the records sought by the\nplaintiff.\"\n\n8\n\nfrom has the same exact standard as to how you --\n\n9\n\n9\n\nyou interpret whether somebody has met the\n\n10\n11\n\nThat's not true, though. M you will see\nin the evidence, the position that the state\n\n10\n11\n\nrequirements of 57.105. So this is a high burden.\nThis is not a who won. This is n4 a prevailing\n\n12\n13\n\nattorney had, quote, no objection, or, quote,\nnever had any objection to the clerk producing\n\n12\n13\n\nparty standard.\nThey have the\n\n14\n\ngrand jury materials was new, and you'll hear from\n\n14\n\nclaim was so frivol•\n\n•irr;•Chat the\n.•. . ..id of merit both on\n\nattorney Suephen Mendelsohn that\n\n5\n\n5\n\n15\n\nthe facts and the 1\n\nas\n\n16\n\nthis is exactly the position t:•at the Post was\n\n16\n\nuntenable, and\n\nthe lain w•as not\n\n17\n\ntrying to get and Mr. Mendelsohn was trying to get\n\n17\n\nfrivolous, n\n\n18\n\nfrom the state attorney.\n\n18\n\ntheir answer\n\nbecause they admitted in\nry claim --\n\n15\n\ncompletely\n\n19\n\nAnd you'll hear, in a June 23rd, 2020,\n\n19\n\nrand, if you could pull up the\n\n20\n21\n\nletter Mr. Mendelsohn wrote to the state attorney,\nhe said the state attorney is named here because\n\n20\n21\n\nadmitted in their answer to this very\n\n22\n\nthey are a party that is tasked with pro\n... [truncated, 4667 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/30 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=30]", "char_count": 4667}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 34\n1\n\nPage 36\nto request access to records from the clerk. This\n\nattorney, to inform the public what went wrong.\n\nwas not on a whim, rot to harass and certainly not\n\n2\n\nThe Post made a number of public records\n\n3\n\nrequests. No lurk. The limited dccurents they\n\n2\n3\n\n4\n\nreceived shed no light on hcw Epstein got off with\n\n4\n\nIn doing all this background research, you\n\n5\n\nsuch leniency.\n\n5\n\nwill hear that Mr. Mendelsohn care across Fourth\n\nfrivolous.\n\n6\n\nSo, in the sumer of 2019 -- we again have\n\n6\n\nDM and federal case law supporting the conclusion\n\n7\n\nthis timeline -- after years of investigation on\n\n7\n\nthat the state attorney was a necessary party.\n\nB\n\nEpstein, the Post brought in a team at Greenberg\n\n8\n\nMr. Mendelsohn provided the state attorney with\n\n9\n\nTraurig, including Stephen Mendelsohn here who you\n\n9\n\nthat case law and explained what we needed from\n\n10\n11\n\nwill hear Iran today, and other experienced\nattorneys in First Arendrent and constitutional\n\n10\n\nthe state attorney in this case. We needed the\n\n11\n\nstate attorney to represent that\n\n12\n13\n\nlaw and criminal law.\nThe Poet and its attorneys spent months\n\n12\n13\n\nobject to the release of gr\nthe clerk if ordered by\nthat request.\n\nwould not\nterials by\nignored\n\n14\n\nresearching and determining how do we get these\n\n14\n\n15\n\nrecords. And you'll see the first box is from\n\n15\n\n16\n\nJuly -- July 2019 through Mk:wester 2019, research\n\n16\n\nrbdinsit 16 --\n\n17\n\nand -- legal research and due diligence regarding\n\n17\n\nsent to the s\n\nrney in resper.se to the\n-marker =jai for fees that\n\nYou will hear\n3rd, 2020, letter he\n\n18\n\nwhat claims to bring and how. You will hear that\n\n18\n\nstate attorney\n\n19\n\nMr. merdelsam tried contacting the state\n\n19\n\nwas\n\nJune. And, in this letter dated\n\n20\n21\n\nattorney's office and requesting what was missing\nfrom the public records requests.\n\n20\n21\n\nJ\n\n. Mendelsohn set forth three reasons\ne attorney was pared as a party.\n\n22\n\nAnd if you want to pull up Dchibit \n... [truncated, 4706 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/31 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=31]", "char_count": 4706}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPege 38\n\nPage 40\n\n1\n\nExhibit 20.\n\n1\n\nnotion to dismiss Can 2, not the count we're on\n\n2\n\nIn that exhibit -- or, in that document,\nMr. Mendelsohn again raises the In re Grand Jury\n\n2\n\nhere today, which is Count 1 for declaratory\n\n3\n\nrelief.\n\ncase that you just saw in the June 23rd letter.\nIt was not until after this, on October 14th,\n\n4\n5\n\ndeclaratory relief involves issues of First\n\n6\n\n2020, that the state attorney's office finally\n\n6\n\nA:nen:bent and constitutimal law, not just that\n\n7\n\nstated in a court filing they weld not object to\n\n7\n\nFlorida Statute 905.27.\n\n8\n\nthe clerk's proobction if ordered, and he todc a\n\n8\n\nIn number two, respectfully, what -- what\n\n9\n\nposition of neutrality. Days later, we dismissed\n\n9\n\nJudge Marx said during a hearing is rot evidence\n\n10\n11\n\nthe state attorney.\n\n10\n11\n\nas to whether the state attorney actually has\ncustody or control of records. So we heard her\n\n12\n13\n\nstate attorney does not rake him a prevailing\nparty, not even under the 57.105 sanctions\n\n12\n13\n\nstatements on the record but\nwhether the state atto\n\nabout\nor di not have\nhe did say in his\n\n3\n4\n5\n\nIt's important to note the dismissal of the\n\nIt's important to note that Count 1 for\n\n14\n\nstandard, which is much higher than a prevailing\n\n14\n\ncustody of the\n\n15\n\nparty standard, but even under a regular\n\n15\n\nfilings he does mit t .ye\n\nt\n\n16\n\nprevailing party standard, the state attorney is\n\n16\n\ndocuments, but\n\nnot just here about\n\n17\n\nnot a prevailing party here. Just because a\n\n17\n\nhis own oust\n\nor\n\n18\n\nplaintiff voluntarily dismisses a defendant does\n\n18\n\nright as the s\n\n19\n\nnot make a defendant a prevailing party. Where a\n\n19\n\nrel\n\n20\n21\n\nplaintiff gets something or a carpranise out of\nlitigation, a dismissal becomes an appropriate\n\n20\n21\n\n22\n\ncourse of action as a result, then neither party\n\n23\n\nis the prevailing party for purposes of\n\nor control of the\n\ntrol; we're here about his\norney to object to the clerk\n\njury records.\nJudge Marx e\n... [truncated, 4618 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/32 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=32]", "char_count": 4618}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 42\n1\n\nand, at the very least, this is a case -- in this\n\nPage 44\nI'm David Arenberg. I Go by Dave. And\n\n1\n\n2\n\ncase of first impression, the claim for\n\n2\n\n3\n\ndeclaratory relief was a good faith argument for\n\n3\n\n4\n\nextension of the law. And, according to\n57.105(1)(a) sanctions cannot be awarded.\n\n4\n\namended motion for attorneys' fees filed November 9,\n\n5\n\n2020, against the plaintiff, correct?\n\n5\n7\n\nthe statutory -- the Florida statute at issue.\n\n6\n7\n\nB\n\nIt's constitutional and First imminent law at\n\n8\n\n9\n\nissue in the declaratory relief claim.\n\n6\n\nA reminder here, too, that it was not just\n\nI've been state attorney since I was elected in 2012.\nQ.\nThank you. We're here today on your\n\nA.\n\nCorrect.\n\nQ.\n\nAnd did you engage my law firm,\n\nScholz L Tyler, to defend you in this action?\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n10\n11\n\nare no sanctions imposed, there are no fees to be\n\n11\n\nI'm going to thew you our Joint Titbit 5.\nDo you recognize this as a copy o\nfin's engagement\n\n12\n13\n\npaid by the state attorney's office, by\nMr. Arcaberg personally or by taxpayers, by\n\n12\n\nletter with your office s\n\n13\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n14\n\nanybody.\n\n14\n\n4.\n\nThank /y\nW~\nMR. CO ACZPvExhibit 5, Your Honor,\n\n10\n\nFinally, it's worth noting that, if there\n\n15\n\nYr. Miler, who represents state attorneys\n\n15\n\n16\n\nacross the state of Florida, had a contingency\n\n17\n\nagteerent with the state of Florida in this case\n\n16\n17\n\nQ.\n\nHoward?\n\ncur fi\n\nt letter, contingency fee\n\n18\n\n-- sorry -- state attorney in this case and, from\n\n18\n\n19\n\nthe outset, no fee obligations arose unless there\n\n19\n\n20\n\nwas a Court order awarding fees. And that's\nExhibit 5 in the joint exhibit binder. So the\n\n20\n\nler. Arenberg, have you reviewed or are you\n\n21\n\n21\n\niar with the pleadings and filings\n\n22\n\nonly way they were going to get fees was under a\n\n23\n\n57.105 action. However, there has never been any\n\n24\n\nbasis for 57.105 sanctions.\n\n25\n\nwith the Court in this hearing?\nA.\nI am.\nQ.\n\nIn closing, Your Honor, 57.105 is reserved\n... [truncated, 4105 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/33 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=33]", "char_count": 4105}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1\n\nPage 48\nContrary, Defexiant Aronberg and the Office of the\n\nPege 46\n1\n2\n\ndocuments that are the subject of this actim7\n\n2\n\nState Attorney for the 15th Judicial Circuit are\n\n3\n\npossession, custody or control of these documents.\n\n3\n\nnot in custody or control of the records sought\n\n4\n\nThat's wiry they sued me and my office. AndInever had\npossession, custody or control of these documents.\n\n4\n\nherein, and, therefore, Defendant Arenberg is not\n\n5\n\na prcper party to this action. In fact, Defendant\n\n6\n7\n\nSharon R. Bock as clerk and captroller of Palm\n\n5\n6\n\nA.\n\nQ.\n\n7\n\nB\n\n8\n\ncustodian in possession of the docents that are\n\n9\n\nthe subject of this action.\"\n\nMR. WYLER: You can find it at IIIII stamp\n\n10\n\n118.\nBY MR. AMER:\nQ.\n\nBeach County, Florida, admits that she is the\n\n1%M COURT: Thank you.\n\non J9 of the amended omplaint if you're looking.\n\n10\n12\n13\n\nOkay.\nMR. %MIER: Your Fimor, you can find that\n\n9\n11\n\nThat's this whole case. It's whether I had\n\nIt. Arenberg, are you familiar with the\n\n3.1\n\nBY MR. WYLER:\nQ.\nMr. Arenberg, after\n\ninitial filings,\n\n12\n\ndid you take any other steps\n\nnotify the\n\n13\n\nnewspaper and its lawyers that you\n\n14\n\nnewspaper's allegation in their complaint that you,\n\n14\n\npossession, custody\n\n15\n\nquote, have denied to the Palm Beach Post and to the\n\n15\n\n16\n\npublic at large the grand jury materials sought to be\n\n17\n\ndisclosed?\n\n16\n17\n\n18\n\nA.\n\nI am.\n\n19\n\nQ.\n\nDid you ever deny the newspaper those\n\n20\n\nrequested materials?\n\n21\n\nA.\n\n18\n19\n\nA.\n\nYes,\n\ni\n\nause, when the articles\n\ncane out that\n\nstonewalling the Palm Beach\n\nPost and tryi\n\nlet public access to these\no get calls and texts from people\n\ndocuments, I s\n\nwas doing that. I had a Fa.cebeek message\nId resign.\n\nask\n\n20\n21\n\nPram the beginning, we informed the\n\nfice lacks\n\n1 of the requested records?\n\nPeter Antonacci, my predecessor down in\n\n22\n\nnewspaper that I've never had these documents. In our\n\n23\n\nnotion to dismiss, we had two argaments. The first one,\n\n24\n\nthe ve\n... [truncated, 4637 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/34 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=34]", "char_count": 4637}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1\n\nPage 50\nyears and aultiple state attorney administrations before\n\nPage 52\n1\n\nIf: COURT: Sustained.\n\n2\n\nI became Palm Beach County State Attorney in 2013.\" I\n\n2\n\n3\n\nwas elected as -- As an aside, I was elected in 2012, but\n\n3\n\n4\n\nI started in 2013. \"As such, I have never seen or had\n\n4\n\n5\n\naccess to the Epstein grand jury transcripts as the state\n\n5\n\nknown that you were not in possession, custody or control\n\n6\n\nattorney's office has never possessed them. As lawsuits\n\nof those records and that they should have towed you\n\n7\n\nand investigaticns continue to mote forward, I hope that\n\n6\n7\n\n8\n\nEpstein's victims are able to achieve justice and clips-sire\n\na\n\n9\n\nthey deserve.\"\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nBY MR. WILIER:\nQ.\n\nSo following those marks from Judge Marx,\n\ndo you believe that the newspaper knew or should have\n\nfrail the lawsuit even then?\nMR. BIrmAil: Objection. Again, Your Hoor,\nI don't know how Kr. Aronberg could know what the\n\n11\n\nrelease, did you make any other steps to further notify\n\n10\n11\n\nnewspaper knew or should have known.\n1113 COURT: So your jecticn is\n\n12\n\nplaintiff that you don't have the records they were\n\n12\n\n13\n\nseeking?\n\n13\n\nspeculation. Susta\n621. WYLER:\n\n14\n\nA.\n\nThank you. Now, in addition to that press\n\nIn addition to pitting out that press\n\n14\n\n119E\n\n15\n\nrelease and secding it to the Palm 13warh Post and every\n\n15\n\nwe have a j\n\n16\n\nother media outlet in our database from around the\n\n16\n\nshort.\n\n17\n\ncountry, I also vat that press release on my 7Mitter page\n\n17\n\nfor\n\n18\n\nand, not only that, I pinned it so it would be the first\n\n18\n\n19\n\nthing on my Twitter page.\n\n20\n21\n\nI also put it out on my Facebook page, and.\nas a result, it received national media coverage,\n\n19\n20\n\n22\n\nincluding coverage from the Sum-Sentinel, the ccmzetitor\n\nthese records?\n\n23\n\nto the Palm Beach Post. Tit, curiously, the one paper\n\nA.\n\n24\n\nthat did not report on this Web portal, the one paper\n\n25\n\nthat did not report at my releasing all the dcarnen\n\n1\n\n\n... [truncated, 4617 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/35 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=35]", "char_count": 4617}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 56\nin control, custed), or possession of the required' --\n\nstatute, you have to wait at least 21 days, and as\nyou'll see later, that was followed.\n\n2\n\nexcuse me\n\n7103 ODURT: The way this is -- I assure\nthis was attached to the letter?\n\n4\n\nthe plaintiff seeks materials that are impossible for me\n\n5\n\nor my office to produce. To be clear, neither myself nor\n\n6\n7\n\nthe SAO has the legal authority to obtain and deliver the\n\nwas not filed ai June 8th.\n\n2\n3\n4\n5\n\nPage 54\nPursuant to the\n\n1\n\n1\n\n6\n\nMR. NYIER:\n\n7\n\nStatic 235, yes, Your Honor.\n\nB\n\nIt's at\n\nBY MR. WYIER:\n\nrequested materials.\n\nI've repeatedly made these facts\n\n8\n\nevident to the plaintiff and the public through not only\n\nDo you recognize that, It. Arenberg, as a\n\n9\n\nthe pleadings and correspondence in this matter, but also\n\ncopy of the email to It. Mendelsohn and then the 57.105\ndemandthatwe issued to the plaintiff?\n\n10\n\nthrough an office press release erg my pane social\nmedia accounts.\"\n\nQ.\n10\n11\n\nIt is, Your Honor.\n\n\" of the requested materials.*\n\"As such, the declaratory relief sought by\n\n3\n\n12\n\nA.\nQ.\n\n13\n\nYes.\nAnd, in that letter, did we assert our\n\n11\n12\n13\n\n\"Despite the\nneither myself nor the\n\nof plaintiff,\nthe atority to demand\ncress to grand jury\n\n14\n\nposition that their demand to produce the 2006\n\n14\n\nthat the clerk grant\n\n15\n\nrecords, that there was no basis in fact or law?\n\n15\n\nmaterials after a c\n\n16\n\nA.\n\nCbrrecc.\n\n16\n\nawing my\n\n17\n\nQ.\n\nDo you ?mow if the newspaper dropped you\n\n17\n\nhas access to\noffice in this\n\nhas concluded. Moreover,\nither myself nor my office\nmaterials fran the clerk's\n\n18\n\nfro the lawsuit within the 21-day safe-harbor provision\n\n18\n\n19\n\nprovided by statute 57.105?\nA.\n'They did net.\n\n19\n\n\"As provided in Section 905.1711) Florida\n\n20\n21\n\nclerk has sole authority and possession of\ned materials, which can only be released by\n\n20\n21\n\nQ.\n\nHut they eventually did drop you?\n\n22\n\nA.\n\nA lag tine later, they did finally drop\nQ.\n\n23\n24\n25\n\nQ.\n\nOkay, b\n... [truncated, 4421 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/36 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=36]", "char_count": 4421}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 60\n\nPage 58\n1\n\nMR. BIDEAU: Cbjecticn, Your Honor,\n\n2\n\nirrelevant as to what the reason is.\nMR. WYLER: It goes to good faith, Your\n\n2\n3\n\nQ.\nLet's talk about that, moving the goal\nposts. We talked earlier about the wording in the\n\n4\n5\n\nHonor.\n\n4\n\nccuplaint against you. Do you recall the statements were\n\n6\n\nA.\n\n3\n\nBY KR. Hr1.67:\n\n5\n\nthat you somehow denied the Palm Beach Post and the\n\nLook, it was clear to me from the beginning\nthat this '.tole lawsuit was a twofer for the Palm Beach\n\n6\n7\n\ncitizens of Palm Beach County the grand jury records they\n\nB\n\nPost. tarter cm, they were able to try to mercane the\n\n8\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n9\n\nfact that the Miami Herald, a newspaper 90 miles away,\n\n9\n\nQ.\n\nAnd now it appears that we're hearing a\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT: All right, overruled.\n\n10\n\nscooped them al the Jeffrey Epstein story, and they\n\n10\n\n11\n\nwanted to catch up and be the hero of their an\n\n11\n\n12\n13\n\nnarrative. And so they rade themselves the center of\nthis whole thing by suing to get these transcripts.\n\n12\n\n14\n\nAnd, number two, they can do it on the back\n\nwere requesting? Do you recall that?\n\nwhole new argument from plaintiff today; is that correct?\nA.\nQ.\n\nYes.\n\n13\n\nis that they were fine\n\n14\n\nthe records being rel\n\nthat, for that reason,\nte?\n\n15\n\nof soceone they have extreme dislike for, and it's men\n\n15\n\nthey dropped you;\n\n16\n\nsecret in this amity\n\n16\n\nA.\n\n17\n\nhave had =eras battles over the years, usually\n\nthat the Palm Beach Post and I\n\n17\n\n18\n\none-sided, where the Paln Beach Post has, for the past\n\n18\n\n19\n\n12 years, has attacked me, written many misleading\n\n19\n\n20\n21\n\narticles, which stem from a personal vendetta fran a\nleader of the Palm Beach Poet, Randy\n, and me.\n\n20\n21\n\n22\n\nAnd then, after he was removed from his position, his\n\n23\n\nacolytes believed that I had something to do with it, and\n\n24\n\nthey -- the attacks continued.\n\n25\n\nt me if I'm unrog,\n\nAnd that\n4\n\nsaid\n\ndidn't object to\n\n: Cbjection, Your Honor,\nleadi\nME CCM:: Sustained.\nB\nC\n... [truncated, 4867 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/37 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=37]", "char_count": 4867}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1\n\nPage 62\nwanted this thing to caatinue, to continue to write\n\n2\n\narticles. It amid have been embarrassing for then to\n\n2\n\n3\n\nadmit that they filed a frivolous lawsuit and then ttay\n\n3\n\nPage 64\n\n1\n\nnot out any money, are they?\nA\nQ.\n\n:t is a contingency-fee basis.\nRight, and so the answer to question is:\n\n4\n\nhad to dismiss me. So they continued these articles way\n\n4\n\nThe taxpayers are not out any money, are they? You don't\n\n5\n\npast the 21-day period, and now, when they got called on\n\n5\n\nowe your counsel a nickel today, right?\n\n6\n\nit, they're trying to change the whole case into\n\n7\n\nsomething about how theyneededcm to stay silent so\n\nB\n\nwouldn't tell the clerk to do something.\n\n7\n8\n\n9\n\nI mean, this thing was about production,\n\n9\n\n10\n11\n\ncustody and control of grand jury documents, and I just\ndon't believe the Palm Beach Post should be able to\n\n10\n\n12\n13\n\nchange it after the fact.\nQ.\nSo do you believe they have an agenda\n\n12\n\n14\n\nagainst you end were intentionally targeting you when\n\n14\n\n15\n\nthey filed this lawsuit?\n\n16\n\nA.\n\n17\n18\n\n13\n\ntoday, right?\nA.\n\nWe have not.\n\nQ.\nAnd the only way that your counsel gets any\nmoney is if he wins this 57.105 nab\n, right?\nA.\n\nThat's a good\nSo under no\n\nA.\n\n16\n\nQ.\n\nMR. BICEAU: Cbjecticn, Your Honor,\n\n17\n\nago that you\n\n18\n\ntaxpayers back\n\n20\n21\n\ncovered it. So I'm going to sustain the\nobjection. That's fine.\n\n22\n23\n\nBY MR. %TIER:\nQ.\nHave your friends and family been impao\n\n24\n\nby the plaintiff's agenda-driven reporting?\n\nare the taxpayers\n\nflout any money,\n\n15\n\nTHE CURT: I think you have already\n\nYeah\n\nYou're right.\nyou testified a few minutes\ns motion in order to get the\n, that was wrong, right?\n\n19\n\nLook, the fact that or office --\n\n20\n\nIs that right, or wrong?\nbook, I have to dispute with you on that\n\n21\n\n, look, the fact that our office has spent\nhaving to deal with this frivolous lawsuit, that's\nyer rcney. And, yes, so perhaps I misspoke when I\n\nMR. BILEAT: Again, j'llge, objection,\n\n25\n\n2 t\n... [truncated, 4292 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/38 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=38]", "char_count": 4292}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1\n2\n3\n\nPage 66\ncase because they've been scooped by the Mini Herald, I\n\n2\n\nthink you said, right?\nA.\nYes.\nQ.\n\nPage 68\nMt. BIDEAD: Okay. Can we get an extra\n\n1\n\ncopy of it?\nVERITSTONE: We can pull it up on the\n\n3\n\nOn the Epstein matter. Imo, you agree\n\n4\n\n5\n\nthat an investigaticm into the Epstein matter and what\n\n5\n\n6\n\nyour predecessors did in the Epstein matter is a\n\n6\n\n1HE CURT\n\nI'm sorry, what number?\n\n7\n\nlegitimate matter of public interest, right?\n\n7\n\nMR. ELDEAD:\n\nExhibit 1, Your Honor.\n\n4\n\n8\n\nA.\n\n9\n\nAbsolutely.\n\n9\n\n10\n11\n\nQ.\nAbsolutely. And the -- And the\ninvestigation of what your office by your predecessor --\n\n10\n11\n\n12\n\nBy the way, nobody has ever suggested, Mr. Aronberg, in\n\n12\n\n13\n\nany of the pleadings filed in this case that you\n\n14\n\npersonally were involved in whatever happened with\n\n15\n\nWt. Epstein. That's not in the =plaint, right?\n\n15\n\nA.\n\n16\n\nIterate no reference to you personally having been\n\n16\n\nQ.\n\n17\n\ninvolved. In fact, the complaint makes it very clear\n\n17\n\nA.\n\n18\n\nthat this was your predecessor who was involved, correct,\n\n18\n\n19\n\nnot you?\n\n19\n\n20\n\nA.\n\n21\n\nQ.\n\nThe investigation of Jeffrey Epstein?\n\nscreen.\nMt. BIDBAU:\n\nCorrect.\nNat, BO the pleadings we drafted didn't --\n\n22\n\ndidn't accuse you of having done anything wring with\n\n23\n\nrespect to Mr. Epstein or the plea deal that got cut or\n\n8\n\nExhibit 1.\n\nMS. VELEISIINE: Your ibnor, may I approach\nwith the exhibit binder?\n1HE COURT: Yes.\nBY MR. RIDEAU:\n\n13\n\nIt. Aronberg, i\nO.\nif I just hand you the b\n\nokay?\n\n14\n\nhavetoturnaround\n\nit.\n\nbe a little quicker\ntway you don't\n\nis it?\n\nis en August 21, 2019, latter\nfrom\n\nto you, correct?\n\n20\n21\n\nCorrect.\nAnd this was a request for -- Nbw, prior to\noffice had received a umber of public records\nto from the Palm Beech Post, correct?\n\n24\n\nwhatever happened with the fads, correct? 14 =cowl\n\nA.\n\nAbout -- About this?\n\n25\n\nyou weren't around in the pleadings that we filed\n\nQ.\n\nAbout the Jeffrey Epstein matter. All my\n\n1\n\ncase\n... [truncated, 4089 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/39 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=39]", "char_count": 4089}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 72\n\nPage 70\nMR. BICEAU: You can look there, okay.\n\n1\n\nwhere it starts with, 'Plaintiff has\n\n2\n\nTIC COURT: I'm going to sloe you down a\n\n2\n\nimproperly...\" Dam at the bottom, last\n\n3\n\nlittle bit. I can't see the writing at the screen\n\n3\n\n4\n\nfrom that far, so I'm going to flip to 37.\n\n4\n\nParagaPh•\nBY MR. BD)EAU:\nQ.\nYou see you indicate -- your lawyer\n\n1\n\n5\n\nMR. BIDEAU: And, I apologize, I hate these\n\n6\n\n5\n6\n\nresponded by saying, 'Plaintiff,' that would be the Palm\n\n7\n\n0/URT: It's okay. I just want to see\n\n7\n\nBeach Post, 'is improperly seeking requested 2006 grand\n\n8\n\nout you're talking about as you're talking about\n\n8\n\njury materials for the purpose of public disclosure\n\n9\n\nit.\n\n9\n\npursuant to the Court's inherent authority and\n\n10\n\nsupervisory powers over the grand jury.' Do you see\nthat?\n\nbig binders.\n\n10\n11\n\nYou're right, they're not easy to navigate.\nAll right, please continue.\n\n12\n13\n\nBY MR. BICCAU:\nQ.\nExhibit 37 is an October 9th, 2019, letter\n\n13\n\nA.\nQ.\n\n14\n\nand that's from Mike Grygiel, another lawyer in my\n\n14\n\nobjecting saying the\n\n15\n\noffice, to your office, and it's following up o0\n\n15\n\nnot entitled to\n\n16\n\nIt. Mendelsohn's October (sic) 27th letter, okay, and his\n\n16\n\nwant to give\n\n17\n18\n\nSeptember 17th letter. Do you see that?\nA.\nYes.\n\n17\n\nwhat the see\n\n19\n\nQ.\n\n11\n12\n\n18\n\nOkay. And up to that point in time, we had\n\n20\n\nnot yet received responses to cur letters, correct? Do\n\n21\n\nyou knot?\n\n22\n\nA.\n\nI don't know.\n\n23\n\nQ.\n\nOkay. And then -- And then after that,\n\nsir, it was on January\n\n25\n\nshortly after that, November of 2019 that we filed\n\nit was on\n\n1\n\nfirst lawsuit against you, correct?\n\n2\n\nA.\n\nCorrect.\n\n3\n\nQ.\n\nSo, after having\n\n5\n6\n\nwe named you in your officl\n\n7\nB\n\nIs that what it says?\n\n20\n21\n\nLook, you are -- this is exactly the\nt you guys did. You filed a lawsuit against\nthe documents, bat because, as you know, in a notion\n\nit was in 2019,\n\ndismiss you have to argue as a matter of law. So the\nonly way we coul\n... [truncated, 4426 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/40 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=40]", "char_count": 4426}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n1\n\nA.\n\nPage 74\nCorrect, but also I do rant to challenge\n\nPage 76\n1\n\nsee that am of the allegations is that the Post\nrespectfully requests the Court declare that, pursuant to\nPlorida Statute 905.27(1), it is entitled to access to\n\n2\n\none part of that. When you say that we -- we were silent\n\n2\n\n3\n\nover and over again about responding to your public\n\n3\n\n4\n\nrecords requests, I have spoken to -- I've spoken to the\n\n4\n\nthe testimony, minutes and other evidence presented in\n\n5\n\npublic records person in my office who believes that she\n\n5\n\n2019 -- 2006 to the grand jury because such disclosure\n\n6\n\ndid say that ae didn't have the docanents to everyone who\n\n6\n\nand access would be in furtherance of justice, and then\n\n7\n\nhas requested them.\n\n7\n\nit cites to 905.27(1)06 (sic), correct?\n\nB\n\nMR. BILEU: Your Wafer, I'd MOM to strike\n\n9\n10\n11\n\nas hearsay.\n\n8\n9\n\nThE COURT: Sustained.\nBY MR. BIDEAU:\n\nYes.\n\nQ.\n\nAnd it says, because the Post is not\n\n10\n\nseeking these materials in connection with any civil or\n\n11\n\ncriminal case, it seeks a declare\n\n-- In other words,\n\nAnd, after you filed this notion, the Palm\n\n12\n\nit asks the Court, hey, construe\n\nparagraph, construe\n\n13\n\nBeach Poet filed an amended complaint, correct, and, in\n\n13\n\nthe statute to allow us\n\n14\n\nthat amended coplaint, the Post asserted two causes of\n\n14\n\nbecause we recognize\n\n15\n\naction, right? One was a statutory claim, and one vas a\n\n15\n\nprovision in that s rota,\n\n16\n\ndeclaratory judgment claim under the First Amendment and\n\n16\n\nA.\n\n17\n\nthe Court's inherent authority, correct?\nA.\nCorrect.\n\n17\n\nQ.\n\n12\n\n18\n\nQ.\n\n19\n\nQ.\n\n18\n\nAnd the motion to dismiss and the arguments\n\ngive this stuff to the public\ninterest of justice\nt7\n-t it says it is.\nthat's what it says, right, in\nThat's what the request was?\n\nfurtherance o\n\n19\n\nAgain, it is what it is.\n\n20\n\nin front of Judge Marx all went to the statutory claim,\n\n20\n\nOkay. And then paragraph 71, the Post\n\n21\n\nnot to the second claim, the declaratory\n... [truncated, 4290 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/41 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=41]", "char_count": 4290}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 7\n1\n\nQ.\n\n2\n\nAnd, in 72, we say, the Post has sought\n\n3\n\nfrom defendants, but defemdants have refused to provide,\n\n4\n\naccess to the testimony, minutes and evidence presented\n\n5\n\nin 2006 to the grand jury.\n\n6\n\nfiled potions to dismiss the ccmplaint and the reliefs\nsought under 50 -- 905.27(11. Accordingly, a good faith\ndispute exists between the parties. Do you see that?\nA.\nYes.\n\n7\n8\n9\n\n12\n13\n\n14\n15\n16\n\nIndeed, defendants have each\n\n4\n5\n6\n7\n\npresented, right? Nb qualification, you all just admit\nthat.\n\n16\n\nAnd you see in that case your office\n\nadmitted that, your lawyers admitted that at least,\nadmitting there was a good faith dispute between the\nparties and admitting that the defendants had refused to\nprovide access to the testimony, minutes and evidence\n\n17\n16\n\nA.\n\nAgain, it .s ,that it is.\n\n1?\n\nQ.\n\nNow, you said that this argueent that\n\n18\n\n19\n\nMs. Whetstone made during her opening statement, that the\n\n20\n\n22\n\nidea that you wouldn't object to disclosure, was\nsomething new, that just popped up at this hearing, that\n-- I think your phrase was, \"you moved the goal posts,*\n\n23\n\nright --\n\n21\n\n2\n\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n\nQ.\n\n10\n11\n\nPage SO\n\nBY MR. BICEAU:\n\n19\n20\n21\n\nYes.\n25\n\nQ.\n\n-- at this hearing? But that's not\n\nPage 719\n\n1\n2\n3\n4\n\neither, right, because that issue had been\nyou all the way back in June of 2020,\n\n5\n\nabout possession\n\n6\n\nQ.\n\nA.\n\nAre you saying this\n\nIs that that you're saying, or a\n\nthat?\nsay\n\nthat it was\n\n9\n\nthe request to have the\nrecords releaseE %MS an issue that bad been raised by\nMr. Mendel\n'Same of 2020, correct?\n\n-agree with -- I'm sorry\n\nQ.\nA.\n\nsae\n\ncaber reading this letter.\nlet\nere see if I can help you\nQ.\nto the middle of that paragraph\nout then.\n'The state attorney was named...• Can you\nt, where it says, 'The state attorney was\n-- Do you see it? Okay.\nnot\nDo you see It. Kendelsolm writes back, he\n'An*\nthe state attorney does not currently\nphysical possession of the Epstein grand jury\nmaterials' -- I man,\n... [truncated, 4375 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/42 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=42]", "char_count": 4375}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1\n\nPage 82\ninvestigation, mild have had those materials, it had to?\n\n2\n3\n\nA.\n\nAgain, I don't fnrw what Barry Krischer's\n\nQ.\n\n2\n3\n\nadministration had back then.\n\n4\n\n1\n\nWell, when you got the public records\n\n4\n\n5\n\nrequest, did you have somebody go back and look and see\n\n5\n\n6\n\nwhat they had?\n\n6\n\n7\n8\n\nA.\n\nWell, obviously, when we got public records\n\nrequests, we try to fulfill all of the:.\n\n9\n\nQ.\n\nRight, and you don't know personally\n\nIt. Mendelsohn's request or Mr. Grygiel's request, right?\nYou personally don't know?\nA.\n\nKell, again, you objected because of\n\nhearsay before, but, in speaking to an individual who\n\n8\n\ndoes public records in my office, I've been told that\n\n9\n\nthat person had said whether or not we've had those\ndm/mots, and so I believe that everyone who requested\ndocuments were told truthfully whe'`her we had those\n\nsitting here today what was dime to respond to any of\nMr. Mendelsohn or Mr. Gaygiel, my partners' letters\n\n10\n\n12\n13\n\nasking for materials from back during the Barry Krischer\ndays, correct? Because there's been no response to those\n\n12\n\n14\n\nletters even to today.\nMR. WYLER: Objection, Your Honor, those\n\nbeat you know, you don't have any personal knowledge as\nto 'tether or not -- what happened to those requests, to\n\n7\n\n10\n11\n\n15\n\nPage 84\nasking for stuff that you hadn't yet given out, and, as\n\n11\n13\n\ndocunents or not. And we\nin a broad way.\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nIn a\n\nA.\n\nCo\n\n16\n\nletters and the Chapter 119 request have nothing\n\n15\n16\n\n17\n\ndo with this lawsuit. They're not referenced in\n\n17\n\nis in a broad -, right?\nhave copies of any responses\n\nQ.\nor that went\noffice when\n\nMendelsohn or Mr. Grygiel in my\n\n18\n\nthe lawsuit. They have no bearing on the\n\n18\n\n19\n\nrequested relief that plaintiff is requesting\n\n19\n\nI ;amid think that Mx. Wyler would have\n\n20\n21\n\nhere.\n\n20\n\nt we produced.\nOkay. Now, Mr. Mendelsohn, back in June\n\n22\n\nBY MR. BICEAU:\n\nNB COURT: Overruled.\n\n23\n\nQ.\n\n21\n\ndocuments, correct?\n\nin response to your first\n... [truncated, 4645 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/43 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=43]", "char_count": 4645}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1\n\nPage 88\nback in Arne of 2020. And do you see in paragraph -- in\n\n2\n\nPage 86\n-- I mean, when Ms. Whetstone talked. In fact, all the\nway back to when the very first 57.105 motion was filed,\n\n2\n\nthe first paragraph, you indicate, quote, Nonetheless,\n\n3\n\nMr. Mendelsohn told you that me of the reasons that the\n\n3\n\nthe state attorney has no objection and never had any\nobjection to the Court releasing the records sought by\n\n1\n\n4\n\nPost sued you in this case was in order to address the\n\n4\n\n5\n\nsituation that you had the right, if you thought it was\n\n5\n\nplaintiff as to the disclosure of the requested materials\n\n6\n7\n\nappropriate, to object to the release of materials. Do\nyou see that?\n\n6\n\nsought herein lies within the province of the clerk\n\n7\n\npursuant to the order of the Ccurt. Do you see that?\n\n9\n10\n\n-- Strike that.\n\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n\n9_\n\nWas that in the =plaint?\n\nQ.\n\nI'm asking about the -- I'm asking about\nWell, the letter you wrote after -- well\n\n11\n\nafter the complaint, the letter you're showing re here\nthat was sent to Mr. Wyler is that it says it is.\n\n12\n\nA.\n\nQ.\n\nAnd this is the first time in any pleading\nFirst of all, obviously you knew this was\n\n13\n\nan issue back in October of 2020ini\nwas arguing that cos\n\nrfact that the Post\nto be in this case\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nCorrect.\n\n14\n\nwas because you had\n\nto object, because you\n\n15\n\nA.\n\nThat's on not in the complaint, right?\n\n15\n\naddress that issue\n\n2020, correct?\n\n16\n\nBut you told me that this idea of swing\nQ.\nthe goal posts, that the Post was suddenly making that\n\n17\n\n18\n\nargument, you told everybody in this courtroom a few\n\n18\n\n().\nargument had\n\n19\n\nminutes ago that just happened today, I mean, they're\n\n19\n\nbut\n\n20\n\njust roving the goal posts on me. Well, if the goal\n\n21\n\nposts are being roved, that was back on June 23rd of\n\n20\n21\n\n22\n\n2020, and you rumba seeing this, right?\n\n17\n\n23\n\nA.\n\nA.\n\nA.\n\nbut, again, this was not part of the cocplaint. This '\n\n25\n\nan after-the-fact letter fret tor. Mende\n... [truncated, 4692 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/44 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=44]", "char_count": 4692}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n1\n\nPage 90\ninconsistent. It said, again, that I was not aware of\n\nPage 92\n1\n\nA.\n\nYeah.\n\nQ.\n\nRight? Okay. And then 17 days later, you\n\n2\n\nyour moving the goal posts, and, besides, it doesn't\n\n2\n\n3\n\nmatter becausethistle thing is about possession,\n\n3\n\n4\n\ncustody and control, which you informed of that we didn't\nhave. Noe you're saying, cell, this whole thing was\n\n4\n\nnot set forth in your original motion back in June\n\n5\n\n5\n\nof 2020, correct?\n\n6\n\nabout you wanted me to talk to the clerk, or you didn't\n\n7\n\nwant me to talk to the clerk, and to me that's\n\n6\n7\n\nsiostance of that, but I know that the motion -- the\n\nfile an mended notion which makes a host of arguments\n\nA.\n\nWell, you have to ask Mr. Wyler about the\n\nB\n\ndisingenuous because that's not the subject of this\n\n8\n\n9\n\nlawsuit.\n\n9\n\n10\n11\n\nYou mentioned in a sentence that\nMr. Mendelsohn wrote to my lawyer notch later than the\n\n11\n\nme within the 21-day IIIII period.\nQ.\nNell, that's the 21-\n\n12\n\n12\n\nthe first notice that you fil\n\n13\n\ncomplaint, well after the complaint, in one sentence in a\nletter to my lawyer, and you're saying, aha, we wanted\n\n13\n\nA.\n\nColoetn, Co\n\n14\n\nthis the whole tine.\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nBut the,\n\n15\n\nQ.\n\nWell, certainly we wanted it the whole\n\n15\n\naccording to the\n\nand the notice, is your\n\n16\n\ntime, and we wanted it at the, as Mr. Mendelsohn will\n\namended notice\n\nriver served prior to being\n\n17\n\ntestify, and Mr. Mendelsohn wrote that when your lawyer\n\n16\n17\n\n10\n\namended notion was filed after I was already dismissed\nfrom the lawsuit and after your client failed to dismiss\n\ni\n\nIIIII period for\n\nWe're here on today,\n\nfiled, correc\ne you saying that the filing of the\n\n18\n\nsent a 57.105, saying our case isn't frivolous, we think\n\n18\n\n19\n\nyour office might have possession of the records, at\n\n19\n\nmeans that the first motion is DOW void, it\n\n20\n\nleast same of the records that we were seeking, and in\n\n21\n\naddition, your office has the right to object.\n\n20\n21\n\ny, it didn't exist?\n... [truncated, 4769 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/45 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=45]", "char_count": 4769}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n1\n2\n\nQ.\n\nPage 94\n-- as to whether we have an argument now.\n\nWe think the Fourth is pretty clear on that Coe.\n\nPage 96\n1\n2\n\n3\n\n'2. BEM': Baudyoubringup, please --\n\n3\n\n4\n5\n\njust last question -- Exhibit 25. paragraph 20?\nBY MR. BIDEAU:\n\n4\n\n6\n\nQ.\n\nMR. WIER: Thank you, Your Honor.\n\nAnd this is -- this is your amended motion,\n\n(Joint Exhibits 1 through 37 were admitted\ninto evidence.)\nDefense rests.\nTHE COCKY: But not this timeline, correct?\n\n5\n\nand you say, The state attorney has no objection to the\n\n6\n7\n\nThis is not?\n\n7\n8\n\nclerk producing and disclosing the requested material\n\n8\n\ndemonstrative. Thank you, Your Hoor.\n\n9\n\nshould the Court grant an order to that effect; however,\n\n9\n\n10\n11\n\nit is impossible for the state attorney to carply with\nthe relief, blab, blab, blab, because you'd made that\n\n10\n\n12\n\nargument before.\n\n12\n\n11\n\n13\n\nThat argument that you had no objection to\n\n13\n\n14\n\nthe clerk producing the requested materials was not set\n\n14\n\n15\n\nforth in your original notice, your original 57.105\n\n15\n\n16\n\nmotion, correct?\n\n16\n\n17\n\nA.\n\n17\n\nI believe that's correct.\n\n18\n\nMR. RIDEAU: That's all I have, Judge.\n\n18\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT: Redirect?\nMR. WYLER: Just real quick.\n\n19\n\n20\n21\n22\n23\n\njust being asked questions about the public records\nrequests that were made of your office.\n\n1\n\nTHE COURT: Before we Mllsia4how long is\nMr. Mendelsohn going to t\ntoda\nMS. UHETSTIONE:\n\nPage\np9\n\nTHE\n\nThirty minutes.\nAnd after Mr. Mendelsohn, are\nYes, Your Honor.\n\nPage 97\n1\n\nTomorrow I have another matter that I have to hear\nin the afternoon. But, in the event we need to go\n\n4\n\nTharsday or Friday in the afternoon, I'll bring\n\nexcused?\n\n5\n\nyou back.\n\nThank you, Your Honor.\n\n6\n\nIf the testimony is going to conclude today\n\n7\n\nor mostly conclude today and the only thing left\n\n8\n\nare your arguneras of law and your arganents as to\nthe findings of fact, then that might be something\n\n5\n\nTHE CCURT: Is Mr.\nTHE WIT=\n\n8\n\nMS.\n\nhb\n\nre excused.\nYour Honor, may we take a\n\n\n... [truncated, 4099 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/46 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=46]", "char_count": 4099}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 98\nMS. FEEDEIrliE: We would have no objection\n\n1\n\nPage 100\n\n1\n\nQ.\n\nto that if Your Minor would prefer. ktatever Your\nMawr prefers, we will do.\n\n2\n\ndo you practice?\n\n3\n\nA.\n\nWE =RP: If you gays don't mind writing.\nI mean, I think people are better in writing.\n\n4\n5\n\ncopyright, trademark, securities, real estate disputes,\ndisputes over employment, contract, fraud. Also, not\n\n6\n\nPeople overestimate their oratory skills, but\n\n7\n\nokay.\n\n6\n7\n\nFirst Amendment cases on defamation, and I do trial work\nand appellate work.\n\n2\n3\n4\n5\n\nB\n\nWE CLERIC: Do you solemnly swear or affirm\n\n8\n\n9\n\nthat the evidence you're about to give will be the\n\n9\n\n10\n\ntruth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth?\nTHE WITNESS: Yes.\n\n10\n11\n\n11\n\nA variety of commercial litigation,\n\njust simply culumrcial, but I also do defamation defense,\n\nQ.\n\n*en you were at the New York State\n\nAttorney General's Office, what types of cases did you\nhandle?\nA.\n\nI was in the Li\n\n12\n13\n\nThereupon,\n\nStatistics, and that's c\n\nBureau of Labor\ntigatrTp, primarily civil\n\n14\n\nhaving been daly acorn by the Clerk of the Ccurt,\n\n14\n\nrights and ccestituti\n\ncases involving 42 USC\n\n15\n\nresponded and testified as follows:\n\n15\n\nSection 1983, tere\n\n16\n17\n\nsued in their\n\n18\n\nAmend-tilt ccc\n\n19\n\nEau\n\nSTEPICEIrENcescm, EsQ.,\n\n16\n\nWE CURT: htenever you're ready.\n\n17\n\nMS. hBIETSTORE: Thank you, Your Horror.\n\n18\n\nDIRECT WAMINkTICN\n\n12\n13\n\nAt Greenberg Traurig, what types of cases\n\n19\n\nBY MS. hatElh-D10E:\n\n20\n\nQ.\n\nGood afternoon, Mr. Mendelsohn.\n\n20\n\n21\n\nA.\n\nHello.\n\n21\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\nPlease introduce yourself to the Court.\n\n23\n\nA.\n\nYes. I an Stephen WLendelsohn.\n\n24\n\nLet me just move a little closer.\n\n25\n\nYes, I'm Stephen Mendelsohn, and I'm\n\nate and its officials were\nity. That included cases\n\nunder the\n\nh\n\nt, cases under the Seventh\n, and the Eighth Menchent and\n\ns to the U.S. Constitution.\nAre you AV rated?\nYes, AV rated as well.\nQ.\n\nHave you ever been sanctioned or subject to\n\nlimry action?\nA.\n\nNever.\n\n\n... [truncated, 4208 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/47 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=47]", "char_count": 4208}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 102\n1\n2\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n1\n\nPage 104\nWe were very interested in finding out the conversaticns\n\nQ.\n\nAnd what did the Pest went to find out and\n\n2\n3\n\nbetween defense counsel, that's criminal defense counsel\nfor Mr. Epstein and, in particular, Alan Dershoritz and\nMr. Krischer's office.\nWe 'rna from investigation that\n\n3\n\ninform the public about with regard to Jeffrey Epstein?\n\n4\n\nA.\nRight, at that time, the Epstein matter was\nback in the nets. Mr. Epstein had been arrested by the\n\n4\n\n6\n\nFBI, and he was being prosecuted by the U.S. Attorney's\n\n6\n\nMr. Dershowitz had provided Mr. Krischer with exhibits or\n\n7\n\nOffice in the Southern District of New York and was in\n\n7\n\ndocuments which went to injure the testimony -- the\n\nB\n\ncustody.\n\n8\n\ncredibility and the testimony of the yarag woman who\n\n9\n\ntestified before the grand jury. I mean, we were looking\n\n5\n\n9\n\n5\n\nSo the issues of the plea deal that had\n\n10\n11\n\nbeen worked cut by Mr. Krischer's office back in 2006 was\nback in the mess, and, in particular, President Trup's\n\n10\n11\n\nfor those communications between Mr. Krischer's office\nand defense ccunsel, in particul where Mr. Dershowitz\n\n12\n\n12\n\nand others from the defense\n\nthose materials to\n\n13\n\nSecretary of Labor, Alexander Acosta, at that tine was\nthe U.S. Attorney in the Southern District of Florida who\n\n13\n\n14\n\nalso helped negotiate the plea and the non-prosecution\n\n14\n\ndamage the credibility o\nKe also\nt\n\nwitness.\ncations between\n\n15\n\nagreement, and there was a big firestorm as to utether or\n\n15\n\nMr. Krischer's off\n\n16\n\nnot Mr. Acosta should or should not resign as Secretary\n\n16\n\nOffice because\n\nwere caning to the fore\n\n17\n\nof Labor.\n\n17\n\nbecause of Al\n\n, and we did ;axe' that there were\nand we wanted those documents to go\n\nwhat was the Post interested in finding out\n\n18\n\nsuch communica\n\n19\n\n18\n\nwith regard to the prior grand jury investigation by the\n\nQ.\n\n19\n\nback\n\n20\n\nPalo Beach County State Attorney?\n\n20\n\n21\n\nA.\n\nWell, because of the \n... [truncated, 4815 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/48 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=48]", "char_count": 4815}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1\n\nPage 106\nSo what information -- what additional\n\nPage 108\n1\n\nMr. Dershowitz provided damaging information or\n\n2\n\ndocumentation to Mr. Krischer's office to destroy his own\n\n3\n\nwitness in front of the grand jury, which honestly,\n\nused in such a key as to result in a very lenient charge\nfor Mr. Dpstein, as well as the lenient sentence that was\n\n4\n5\n\nlooking at all of the materials we had received and based\nLimn my personal discussions with the chief of police of\n\npart of the rat-prosecution agreement.\nWe )mew from the Post's investigation and\n\n6\n\nthe Town of Palm Beach, we came to the ccoclusion\n\n7\n\nMr. Krischer had ahzased his authority as state attorney.\n\nfrom other materials we had assembled that there were -there was a grand jury that was enpaneled. In fact,\n\n8\n\n9\n\n9\n\nand when did it end as far as reviewing the facts?\n\n10\n11\n\nthere was two. The first one was canceled, and the\nsecond one was conducted, and a witness, a victim did\n\n10\n11\n\nA.\nStarted in the summer of 2019, and it -Well, the first phase resulted in he lawsuit, and that\n\n12\n13\n\ntestify. And we were on fairly certain ground that the\nstate attorney's office under Barry Krischer undermined\n\n12\n13\n\ncontained hundreds of hours'\nlegal work, but, as I sa\n\n14\n\nher credibility with materials provided to Mr. Krischer\n\n14\n\nwell. But it contin\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\ninformation was needed that the Post was seeking?\n\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\nB\n\nWe wanted to see why the grand jury was\n\nA.\n\nQ.\n\nWhen did the due diligence process start\n\nwork, not only\nual\n\ntigatory work as\n\nfter the lawsuit had teen\n\n15\n\nby defense counsel --\n\n15\n\nfiled as well. We\n\n16\n\nQ.\n\nDid you --\n\n16\n\nnew, and ulti\n\n17\n\nA.\n\n-- anri we did not get those raterials back\n\n17\n\ncase, which I an add later, but there were new\n\n18\n\nrevelations t\n\n18\n19\n20\n\nfrom the state attorney's office.\nQ.\n\nreach the conclusions about the\n\n21\n22\n\nDid you review any other infornetion to\n\nA.\n\n19\n\nindictment?\n\nini/tial complaint? And that was for the statutory\n\n... [truncated, 5212 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/49 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=49]", "char_count": 5212}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1\n\nPage 110\nbut did you engage in any other research before filing\n\n2\n\nthe initial complaint?\n\nPage 112\n1\n\npull that up.\n\n2\n\nBY MS. WHETSTONE:\n\nWell, federal as well, not only under the\n\n3\n\nQ.\n\nstate, but I wanted to see, you know, who to sue, to be\nhonest with you, in this case. we had a debate amongst\n\n4\n\nA.\n\nYes, that's CFR case.\n\n5\n\n5\n\nQ.\n\nSo what were the three -- what were the\n\n6\n\nourselves as to who the proper defendants were going to\nbe, and my principal responsibility was deteminirg under\n\n6\n7\n\ntenons the state attorney was named a defendant?\n\n7\nB\n\nFlorida law who that would be.\nSo I had extensive eicperience as an\n\n8\n\nattorney was Eras Broward County tamed in this case.\n\n9\n\nIt's a little explicated facts, but essentially there\n\n10\n11\n\nwas a federal grand jury that issued a subpoena to the\n\n11\n\nassistant attorney general on suing, at least in\ndefending state officials in not only 1983 cases, but\n\n12\n13\n\nmany other type of cases where state officials are sued\nin their official capacity. So this was certainly\n\n12\n13\n\ngrand jury materials for a pa\nthe Broward 0ounty atto.i\n\n14\n\nnothing new to ne.\n\n14\n\nparticipated in this\n\n15\n\nsuch under 905.27.\n\nA.\n\n3\n4\n\n9\n10\n\n15\n\nI probably handled 3, 400 cases like that,\n\nIs that the In re Grand Jury case?\n\nA.\n\nWell, this case particularly, the state\n\nBroward County State Attorney s\n\nng state attorney\nyou\n\ninvestigation, and\nn see here,\n\nobjected to the release of\n\n16\n\nall on the defense side. So I was very familiar with\n\n16\n\n17\n\narguments of who was the proper party and the role of a\n\n17\n\nlanguage from his\n\nwhich said that the state\n\n18\n\nstate official in litigation.\n\n18\n\nattorney's vol\n\nessential one because his or her\n\n19\n\nSo what did 1 do? I went to see wtather\nthere were other 905 cases, Chapter 905 cases where state\n\n19\n\nrole\n\n20\n21\n\nofficials had been sued, and in particular I ford two\n\n22\n\ncases. the was a state case and one was a federal case.\n\n23\n\nThe state case was James vs.\n... [truncated, 4785 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/50 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=50]", "char_count": 4785}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 116\nunderstood the role that they were playing because that\n\n1\n\nPage 114\nunder 905.27 and then, if so, ask the Court for an\n\n1\n\n2\n\nin-camera review before release to the public.\n\n2\n\nwas the role we gave them the opportunity to play in this\n\n3\n\ncase. So I was neither surprised, rertpset that they\nplayed that role, because that's the opportunity we gave\nthem.\n\n3\n\nSo those are the three issues we were\n\n4\n5\n\nconcerned with.\n\n4\n\nQ.\n\nDid Greenberg Traurig conclude that the\n\n6\n\nstate attorney was a necessary party to this case\n\n5\n6\n\n7\n\nregardless of whether it bed possession of the grand jury\n\n7\n\n8\n\nmaterials?\n\n8\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n9\n\nQ.\n\nAfter the state attorney filed his motion\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\nQ.\n\nDid the clerk file a motion to dismiss the\n\ninitial complaint as well?\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nkid was that conclusion a yes?\n\n10\n\nto dismiss the initial complaint, what did the Post do in\n\n11\n\nA.\n\nYes, it was.\n\n11\n\nresponse?\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\nSo, after the complaint -- the initial\n\n12\n\nA.\n\nAfter the init\n\n1, we filed an\n\n13\n\ncomplaint was filed in November of 2019, were discussions\n\n13\n\n14\n\nhad with the state attorney's counsel and the counsel for\n\n14\n\nanerdhent to the -- to t\nQ.\nDid you\n\noak at whether there were\n\n15\n\nthe clerk?\n\n15\n16\n\nother causes of action\nA.\n\nto develop the First\n\n17\n\nAmanclrent iss\n\n16\n17\n18\n\nQ.\n\nWhat were those discussions?\n\nA.\n\nWell, we had discussions about the case,\n\n18\n\nrights under\n\n19\n\nparticularly where this is going, did they have\n\n19\n\nin\n\n20\n21\n\nobjections and, if so, under what basis did they have\nobjections.\n\n20\n21\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\nlainassert?\n\nin rte e depth and argue that the Post had\nAmend:art, as well as the statute,\nwith the statute to obtain the materials,\naoganent that I had developed which was\n\nrt has inherent authority as the ultimate\n\nAfter the complaint -- the initial\n\nr of the grand jury system under the Florida\n\n23\n\ncomplaint was filed, what position did the state attorney\n\n24\n\ntake in the case?\n\n25\n\nA.\n\nitution to prevent abuse of\n... [truncated, 4422 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/51 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=51]", "char_count": 4422}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1\n2\n\nQ.\n\nPage 118\nWe'll pull that up. I think we've Seel it\n\na couple times. We'll pull it up.\n\n3\n\n4\n\nExhibit 9 and Exhibit 10 is the paragraph you're talking\n\n4\n\n5\n\nabout.\n\n5\n\n6\n\nA.\n\nand motion for fees?\n\n2\n\nPlease let an bra if this comparison of\n\n3\n\nPage 120\n1\n\nA.\n\nWithin hours of the order from Judge Marx\n\nwas issued, I believe, on June 8, 2020.\nAnd at that point why was the state\n\nQ.\n\nattorney kept in the case?\n\nRight, right, yes, that they refused to\n\n6\n\n7\n\nprovide access. That's through their objection to the\n\nB\n\nclerk to testimony, minutes and other evidence. Again,\n\n7\n8\n\ndisclosure under Gault 2, under the declaratory judgment.\nThey were still asserting that grand jury secrecy and the\n\nA.\n\nWell, they were still objecting to\n\n9\n\nthis was not just simply transcripts. It was such\n\n9\n\nstatute could not be overcome by the First kendrent or\n\n10\n11\n\nbroader than that. And that a good faith dispute exists,\nand they admitted all of that.\n\n10\n11\n\nby the Cant's inherent authority, and that the Cant's\ninherent authority was limited\nhe statute, which we\n\nDid Count 1 for declaratory relief seek to\n\n12\n\n13\n\nforce the state attorney to produce documents that he did\n\n13\n\nobviously thought was sort of\nr way, that the\nstatute or the legislator\nd not\nit the Court's\n\n14\n\nnot have?\n\n14\n\ninherent authority\n\njudiciary had its rights\n\n15\n\nA.\n\nNo.\n\n15\n\nand the legislature\n\ns. So that issue still\n\n16\n\nQ.\n\nDid the state attorney's position that his\n\n16\n\nremained.\n\nQ.\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\n17\n\noffice did not have possession or custody of the grand\n\n17\n\n18\n\njury materials end the need for his office to be a party\n\n18\n\ncounsel and 1\n\n19\n\nto the declaratory relief claim?\n\n19\n\ninch\n\nA.\n\nNo, and really the proof of that is what\n\nyou write to the state attorney's\nPoet's reasons for continuing to\n\ntate attorney in the case?\nYes. That's ray letter of June 23rd, 2020.\n\n20\n21\n\nactually occurred, which is they moved forward with their\n\n22\n\nmotion to dismiss and ultimatel\n... [truncated, 4326 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/52 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=52]", "char_count": 4326}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 53, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1\n\nPage 122\nIs he continuing to oppose us? Because I never received\n\n1\n\nPage 124\nwhat was in there, not really specifically what was in\n\n2\n\na response to my Jtme 23rd letter, and I wanted it to be\n\n2\n\nthere, but by category, whether it was a transcript,\n\n3\n\nunderstood that we honestly believed that the state\n\n3\n\nwhether there were exhibits and/or whether there were\n\n4\n\nattorney had a necessary role to play in their official\n\n4\n\n5\n\nraparity. We were hopeful that they would take a neutral\n\n5\n\naffidavits or whether there were deposition transcripts.\nWhatever there was in there, we wanted to understand.\n\n6\n\nposition, but they remained adamant that they had to\n\n6\n\n7\n\nprotect grand jury secrecy woder the statute, which we\n\n7\n\nkeep a log, so they couldn't tell us unless the seal was\n\nrespected.\n\n8\n\nbroken what was in there.\n\n9\n\nQ.\n\nAnd I don't want to )now the substance of\n\nThe clerk had responded that they don't\n\n9\n\nQ.\n\nIn August of 2020, the state attorney's\n\nsettlecent discussions, if there were any, but did\n\n10\n\noffice filed a motion for summary udgnent; is that\n\n11\n\nsettlecent discussions go on with the state attorney's\n\n11\n\ncorrect?\n\n12\n\ncounsel after the Jima 23rd letter?\n\n10\n\nA.\n\nYes.\nAnd Exhibi •.4 leese7 Is this the state\n\n13\n\nA.\n\nYes. Yes, they did.\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nAnd is that indicated on the timeline here\n\n14\n\nattorney's notice for\n\n15\n\nscreen?\n\n15\n\nof June, June 8th, 2020, to October 15th, 2020?\n\n16\n\nA.\n\nYes. With M.T. Wyler, yes.\n\n16\n\n17\n\nQ.\n\nIt. Wyler.\n\n17\n\n18\n\nA.\n\nHe was a very nice Mr. On the phone. We\n\n18\n\n19\n20\n\nhad very gccd rahversations, very professional.\nQ.\nThe state attorney filed his motion for\n\n21\n\nfees on July 1st, 2020; is that correct?\n\n23\n24\n\nQ.\n\n1\n2\n\nIt is.\n\nQ.\n\nDid the initial 57.105 mots\n\nA.\n\n4\n\nentitled to 57.105.\n\n5\n6\n7\n\nQ.\n\n8\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\nQ.\n\nAnd\n\n9\n\nA.\n\n10\n\nQ.\nA.\n\n11\n12\n\nwell, fi\n\n13\n\ntram the clerk?\n\nA.\n\nIt is.\n\nQ.\n\nPage 125\nAt this point, after the affidavit had been\n\nfiled, had the state attorn\n... [truncated, 4416 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/53 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=53]", "char_count": 4416}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 54, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 126\nWe never received any such, and we 'craw\n\n1\n\n1\n\nA.\n\nPage 128\nCorrect. What happened is the state\n\n2\n\nthey were out there. Exactly who had them, where they\n\n2\n\n3\n\nwere, we weren't sure. We learned in hindsight that the\n\n3\n\n4\n5\n\nU.S. Attorney's Office had been provided with such by the\nclerk's office. This is the Palm Beach County clerk's\n\n4\n\n6\n7\n\noffice.\n\n6\n7\n\n8\n\n2020, did Greenberg and the Post -- sorry -- did the Post\n\n8\n\nfor =wary jucklnent should be heard first, and there was\n\n9\n\nfile a response to the state attorney's first\n\n9\n\na caseTanager:ant conference beforeJudge Hafele, and\n\n10\n\nplace-narker 57.105 motion?\nA.\nWe did.\n\n10\n11\n\nJudge Hafele decided that the state attorney could decide\nthe order of when that would\nSo not knowing when\n\n12\n\n-- what hearing would go fi\n\n11\n\nQ.\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\n5\n\nSo fast forwarding a bit to October 2nd,\n\nAnd if you could pull up Exhibit 20.\n\nattorney never noticed the first motion they filed for\nfees for a hearing, and they still haven't done that. So\nit's never been noticed for hearing.\nThere was a little dispute between myself\nand Mr. Tyler as to whether or not the fee motion that he\nhad filed in June should be heard first or their motion\n\n13\n\nA.\n\nWhich one is this exhibit?\n\n13\n\ntheir fee motion that\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\n20.\n\n14\n\nwas Exhibit 20, and\n\n15\n\nA.\n\nThat's what I thought. Ckay.\n\n15\n\nQ.\n\n16\n\nQ.\n\nIs this the Poet's response, maroranchmo of\n\n16\n\n17\n\nlaw of the plaintiff to the state attorney's --\n\n18\n\nA.\n\nThat is correct.\n\n18\n\n19\n\nQ.\n\n-- 57.105 sanction motion?\n\n19\n\n20\n21\n\nA.\nQ.\n\nYes. I drafted this, yes.\nCo page 8 --\n\n20\n21\n\n22\n\nto page 8.\n\n24\n\nBY MS. WHEISTCRE:\n\n25\n\nQ.\n\ne it's highlighted on the\nYep, I see that.\nIt says, 'Nonetheless, the state attorney\nlactic@ and never has had any objection to the\nreleasing the records sought by the plaintiff.'\nWas this the first time the state attorney\n\nDid you again raise the state at\n\n-- the state attorney stated his office would not object\n\n1\n\nPage 129\nt\n... [truncated, 4224 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/54 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=54]", "char_count": 4224}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 55, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1\n2\n3\n\nQ.\n\nletter on October 15th in response to this October 14th\nposition in the reply?\nA.\n\n4\n5\n\nYes.\n\nI did it pretty quickly after I saw\n\nit.\n\n7\n\nPage 132\n1\n\nQ.\n\nNeill pull up Exhibit 23.\n\n2\n\nA.\n\nOkay, I've got it in front of me\n\n3\n\nOctober 21st, 2020.\n\n4\n\nQ.\nAnd is this Exhibit 23 the notice of\ndropping the state attorney as a party?\n\n5\nQ.\nA.\n\n6\n8\n\nPage 130\nDid you send a letter --asettlement\n\nThe next day?\nThe next day. Well, I started writing it\n\non the 14th, but, yes, we sent it on the next day.\nQ.\n\nOkay, and I'll pull W Exhibit 22.\n\n6\n7\n8\n9\n\nIs this your letter to Mr. Ifylerc with\n\nA.\nQ.\n\nit was\n\nCorrect.\nAfter this, 19 days after this, did the\n\nstate attorney file an amended notice for fees under\n57.105?\n\n10\n\nA.\n\nHe did.\n\n11\n\nregard to the reply?\n\n11\n\nQ.\n\nIs that the motion\n\nre here on today?\n\n12\n\nA.\n\n12\n\nA.\n\nCorrect. That'\n\ny one that the\n\n13\n\nYes. Since they had changed to a neutral\nposition, I didn't see a point in discussing whether or\n\n14\n\nnot they should remain in the case, and that's %%tat the\n\n14\n\nstate attorney has noti\nQ.\nWe're\n\n15\n\npurpose of this was.\n\n15\n\nup, I'd like you to\n\n16\n\nQ.\n\nfor sanction\n\n17\n\nthan changing --\n\n16\n17\n\n10\n\nA.\n\nAM in it you say you were pleased about\n\n13\n\nIn the sewed paragraph, I said\n\n18\n\n19\n\nI was pleased to read that they -- the state attorney's\n\n19\n\n20\n21\n\nclear and unemivocal statement in their response filed\nyesterday that their office will not oppose the Post's\n\n21\n\n22\n\nrequest for access to the Jeffrey }stein grand jury\n\n23\n\nmaterials. I was pleased.\n\n18\n\nYes, yes.\n\n20\n\nA.\nQ.\n\nExhibit 25, and, once it's\nthis the amended notice\nor today?\n\nes.\nWm this amended notion ever served on you\n\nor the Poet anytime before it was filed?\n11 A.\n\ntoo.\nDoes the amended motion set forth new and\n\nBCs for the motion for sanctions then compared\nfirst what they call place-marker notion?\n\nOnce the state attorney's office said\n\nA.\n\nPleolutely.\n\n25\n\nit would no longer object to release of the grand\n... [truncated, 4404 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/55 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=55]", "char_count": 4404}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 56, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 136\nNoce. There was a firehmll between the\n\nA.\n\nPage 134\nHe heard it for about two and a half boars,\n2\n\nlegal arguments we were making here and whatever the Pest\n\nQ.\n\nAnd was this the same declaratory judgment\n\n3\n\nwas writing both editorially and factually. I had\n\n4\n\ncount that had been asserted against the state attorney\n\n5\n\nthat had been dismissed against him after he said he had\n\n4\n5\n\nabsolutely no conversations with the Post, nor did any\nmeter of my team as to what they were going to write.\n\n6\n\nno objection to the clerk releasing documents?\n\n1\n2\n\nyes.\n\n3\n\n7\n\nA.\n\nIt was Count 1. That was the sane cart\n\nA.\n\n6\n\nIt's not ty role to tell the paper what it wants to, or\n\n7\n\nnot, write or not write, so the legal positions that we\n\nB\n\nthat we had against the state attorney and the clerk, and\n\n8\n\nadopted in this case were -- were the positions that we\n\n9\n\nthat had been dropped against the state attorney at the\n\n9\n\nas Greenberg IYaurig and the paper carte to the conclusion\n\n10\n11\n\ntime I argued the motion for summary judgment in front of\nJudge Hafele in September of 2020 or August of 2020.\n\n10\n11\n\nof based upon the facts and the law.\nAs to what the Post y have wanted to\n\nAnd Judge Hafele entered an order on a\n\n12\n\n13\n\nmotion for surnnary judgment which been this final\n\n13\n\nwrite or did write, I have z\nMr. Grygiel, nor did Ms.\n\n14\n\njudgment; is that right?\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\n14\n\nwhat was going to be\n\n15\n\npaper, so I did not\n\nAnd going through it, on page 5, the Court\n\n16\n\nin the paper.\n\n17\n\nnoted that the Post's position was -- Well, I'll ask you,\n\n17\n\nQ.\n\n18\n\nwhat was the Court's reaction in the final judgment to\n\n18\n\nattorney in\n\n19\n\nthe presentations given by the Post?\n\n19\n\nt the state attorney?\n\n20\n\nWell, I voted for Mr. Arenberg. No.\n\n21\n\nSo no?\n\nA\n16\n\nQ.\n\nA.\n\nt\n\ninto that, nor did\ndidn't even know\noil I read it in the\nthey were going to put\n\nt question. Did suing the state\ncaai have anything to do with a personal\n\n20\n21\n\nUltimately Jud\n... [truncated, 4642 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/56 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=56]", "char_count": 4642}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 57, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 140\n\nPage 138\n1\n\n30 cinutes, probably more like 45.\nTHE COURT: Okay, so, you know, fray krelia\n\n2\n3\n\n1\n\nIsland to here is five hours?\n\n2\n3\n\nYR. WYLER:\n\n7HE CURT: All right, so we'll ire back\nThursday, 1:00 p.m.\nHEE WrflrS: Pm I excused, Your Honor,\nfrom the stand?\n\nYes, sir.\nCCURT: You're almost in Georgia.\n\n4\n\n5\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT: Yes.\n\n6\n\nYR. EISR: Exactly. Your Honor, I will be\n\n6\n7\n\n7HE 14171.e S: Thank you.\n\n4\n\n7\n\nhere whenever you need ee to be here.\n\nB\n\nit happen.\n\nI'll make\n\nTHE CCURT.\n\nI /WS we have guests. You\n\n8\n\nkrow, the Wall Street Journal will write\n\nTHE COURT: Thursday or Friday?\n\n9\n\nreprobate.\n\n10\n11\n\nPR. WYLER: Honestly -ME OXIRT: How about Thursday?\n\n10\n11\n\nAll right, anything else?\nHave a great day, eve\n\n12\n\nPR. 'TILER:\n\n12\n\n13\n\nThursday would be better.\n\nrecess.\n(The hearing adjou9S\n\n14\n15\n\nback in Thursday.\nIn the afternoon, Your\n\nHonor?\nTHE OXIRT: ace back Thursday, probably\n\n4:53 .m.)\n\n16\n\nCO\n\n18\n19\n\n20\n21\n\n(Brief interruption.)\nTHE COURT: All right, so the only thing\n\n22\n\nleft is cross examination, redirect, and then are\n\n23\n\nthe parties going to write closing argrents?\n\n25\n\n're in\n\n14\n\n17\n\n1:00 p.m. Give me one minute.\n\n24\n\nIt's a big word.\n\n15\n\nYR. M:NDEL9CFRI:\n\n18\n19\n\n13\n\nTHE CYJRT: Okay, all right, we'll care\n\n16\n17\n\n-- how about Thursday? Yeah,\n\nIt's a big word.\n\n20\n21\n\nYS. ivirmISTCNE: If Your Falco would prefer\nit, we'd be fire with that.\n\nPage 141\n\n1\n\nTHE 03URT:\n\nCOURT CERTIFICATE\n\nI prefer closing argaren\n2\n\n2\n\nare written.\n\n3\n\nYou know, I thick the logic is ti\n\n1\n\nSTATE OF FLORIDA\n\n4\n\nparties don't mind writing closi\n\n4\n\nCOUNTY OF PALM BEACH\n\n5\n\nwould prefer that.\n\n6\n7\n\nI think things are more\n\n5\n\nOkay, do you want t\nargument? I man, I can\n\nring your closing\ne you probably\n\nknow what you're\n9\n10\n\nM.\n\nIf we could finish the\n\ndirect\nthe tes\n\nwe will have the transcript\n\n12\n\nand a\n\nclosings or make sure that we\n\n14\n\n7\n\ndo you think?\n\nI, Lisa Begley, RPR, RMR, certify that I\n\n8\n\nwas authorized to \n... [truncated, 2903 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/57 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=57]", "char_count": 2903}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 58, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n\nIN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT\nIN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA\nCASE NO. 50-2019-CA-014681-XXXX-MB AG\n\nCA FLORIDA HOLDINGS, LLC,\nPublisher of the PALM BEACH POST,\n\nA\n\nCos\n\nPlaintiff,\nvs.\n\nDAVE ARONBERG, as State Attorney\nof Palm Beach County, Florida;\nSHARON R. BOCK, as Clerk and\nComptroller of Palm Beach Count\nFlorida,\nDefendants.\n\nTRANS\n\nRE:\n\nF CONTINUATION OF\nG PROCEEDINGS\n\nDefendan\nye Aronberg's Amended Motion for\nAttorneys'— Fees\n\n:\n\nBEFORE:\n\nThursday, September 8, 2022\n1:06 p.m. - 2:42 p.m.\nPALM BEACH COUNTY COURTHOUSE\n205 North Dixie Highway\nCourtroom 10D\nWest Palm Beach, Florida\n33401\nLUIS DELGADO, JR., Circuit Judge\n\nStenographically reported by:\nLisa Begley, RPR, RMR\n271843\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02735017\n\n\f", "char_count": 812}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 59, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 145\n\nPage 143\n1\n2\n1\n4\n5\n6\n\nAPPEARANCES:\nOn behalf of the Plaintiff:\nGREENBERG TRAURIG\n777 South Plagler Drive\nSuite 300 Eaet\nKest Palm Beach, Florida 33401\n561-650-6420\nBY: LAUREN R. WHETSTONE, ESQ.\nwhetstonelegtlaw.eom\nMARK P. BIDEAIL ESQ.\nbideaumegtlaw.com\nGERARD BUITRAGO. ESQ.\nbuitragogsgtlaw.com\n\n10\n11\n12\n13\n\n2\n\nthe following proceedings began at 1:06 p.m.:\nTHE COURT: All right, please be seated.\n\n4\n\nAll right, announce your presence.\nMS. WifftERRCE: Good afternoon, Your Honor,\n\n5\n\nOn behalf of Defendant, Dave Arenberg:\nJACOB, SCHOLZ L WYLER, LLC\n961687 Gateway Boulevard\nSuite 2011\nFernandina Beach, Florida 32034\n904-261-3693\nBY: DOLGLAS A. WYLER, ESQ.\ndougajswflorida.con\nAlso present: Dave Arenberg. State Attorney\n\nDefendant\n14\nLeigh\nPublic Records Coordinator\nOffice of the State Attorney PBC\n\nIS\n16\n17\n18\n19\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nThereupon,\n\n3\n\n0\n9\n\n1\n\n6\n7\n\nLauren Whetstone, and with me, Mark Bideau, Gerard\n\n8\n\nbehalf of Greenberg Traurig, on behalf of CA\n\n9\n\nFlorida Holdings, the publisher of the Palm Beach\n\n10\n11\n\nEtst, the plaintiff, and air witness, Stephen\nMendelsohn.\n\nBuitrago and paralegal, Jennifer Thorson, on\n\nMR. EYLER:\n\n12\n13\n\nDouglas Eyler wi\n\n14\n\nEyler here on\n\n15\n\nAronberg,\n\n16\n17\n\ncross\n\n, Your Honor,\nScholz A\nthe State Attorney, Dave\n1 right, so we left off with\nIs that where we are?\n\n18\n\n: Yes, Your Honor.\n\n19\n\nMR. WYLER: Yes, sir.\nTHE COURT: Madam Clerk, please swear in\n\n20\n21\n\nwitness.\nSir?\nTHE WITNESS: II, I've been sworn in\nbefore.\nTHE CLERK: Do you solemnly swear or affirm\n\n4\n1\n\nINDEX\n\n2\n\nWITNESS\n\n3\n\nSTEPHEN MENDELSOHN, ESQ.\n\n4\n\nAGE\n\nCross Examination by Mr. Wy\n\n146\n\nRedirect Examination by Ma\n\n187\n\n6\nNon-movant rests\n\n204\n\nPage 146\n\n1\n\nthat the evidence that you're about to give will\n\n2\n\nbe the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the\n\n3\n\ntruth?\nTHE HITE215S: I do.\n\n4\n5\n\nThereupon,\n\n6\n7\n\nSTEPHEN NE2BX2f2101, ESQ.,\nhaving been duly sworn by the Clerk of the kart,\n\n8\n\nresponded and testified as foll\n... [truncated, 2861 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/59 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=59]", "char_count": 2861}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 60, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 147\n1\n\nPage 149\nMS. WIE7SaCEE: Objection, Your Fanor,\n\nMR. WYLER: That's fine.\nTHE COURT: All right.\n\n2\n3\n\ned, corpard.\nTHE CURT: Sustained as compound.\n\n4\n\nBY MR. XYLEM:\nQ.\nIsn't it true, though, that Mr. Arenberg\n\n4\n5\n\n6\n\nand Mike Edmondson contacted you to complain about an\n\n6\n\n7\n\narticle that was being written about him?\n\n7\n\n1\n\nfoundation.\n\n2\n3\n\nB\n\nA.\n\nNo, no. I've never spoken to Edmondson\n\nthat I remember.\nQ.\n\n10\n11\n\nWell, okay. That's fine. But you did\n\nspeak with Mr. Arenberg, right?\n\n12\n\nA.\n\nBY FR. WYLER:\nQ.\nAll right, I'll move on.\nSo, in your direct assignation the other\nday, isn't it true that you stated that you devoted\n\n8\n\nhundreds of hours to the research and development of\n\n9\n\nbringing this Lawsuit?\n\n10\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n11\n\nQ.\n\nOkay. Arid so, in\n\nNo. I don't recall speaking to anyone on\n\n12\n\nextensively put time into 1\n\n13\n\nthis matter, unless he was on the phone with you. Other\nthan that, no.\n\n13\n:4\n\nbefore you brought this\n\n14\n15\n\nQ.\n\nOkay, well, then part of when we spoke, and\n\n15\n\nA.\n\nYes, si\n\nQ.\n\nAnd,\n\nof that research, you\nto Chapter 905.27\n\nMarx's June 8th order\n\n16\n\nmaybe you didn't knot, Mr. Arenberg and Mike Edmondson\n\n16\n\non the motion\n\n17\n\nwere on the phone with us, but isn't it true that there\n\n17\n\n18\n\nwas a time, when you and I spoke in settlement\n\n18\n\nIsn't it also true that your client's\ncomplaint alleged awdinst -- that my client was in\n\n19\n\nnegotiations, that you offered CO hold an article pending\nour settlement negotiations?\n\n19\n\npresession ox control of the documents that are in this\n\n20\n\njest of this action?\n\n21\n\nI'm sorry, can -I'll repeat it. Isn't it true that your\n\n20\n21\n\nS. *LIST'S: Objection, Your Mc or,\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\nsettlement discussion.\n\n2 -- Let me scratch that.\n\n23\n\nMR. WYLER: They opened the door Co\n\nt's complaints alleged that my client and/or his\n\n24\n25\n\nsettlement negotiations by putting it into\n\nffiee is in, quote, possession and/or control of the\ndocuments that are subject of this\n... [truncated, 4214 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/60 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=60]", "char_count": 4214}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 61, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n\n1\n\nPage is:\nsought unlimited access to the requested materials under\n\n1\n\nQ.\n\n2\n\n905.27?\n\n2\n\nagainst the clerk?\n\n4\n\nAgain, that's a ccqxu.-cl question. I'm not\n\nA.\n\n3\n\nP4yr\nDid that argurmit succeed in your claim\nWhich cce?\n\n4\n\nQ.\n\nThat you had no connection with the civil\n\n5\n\nsure which one goes first.\nQ.\nIsn't it -- If you would look at\n\n5\n\nor criminal case and to get unlimited -- to get unlimited\n\n6\n\nstamp page 135.\n\n6\n\naccess.\n\n7\n\nA.\n\n8\n\nstamps in front of\n\nAll I have is the exhibits, sir.\n\n9\n\nQ.\n\n10\n11\n12\n\nQ.\n\n7\n8\n\nOkay. They should be on there, in the\n\nA.\n\nWell, again, we weren't seeking unlimited\n\naccess. As I just mentioned, we were always seeking an\n\n9\n\nin-mina inspection by the Ca= prior to release to us.\n\nbottom left corner.\n\n10\n\nSo we were not seeking unlimited access, nor immediate\n\nA.\n\nWhich one is it?\n135.\n\n11\n12\n\naccess to the docirrents.\nQ.\nYou weren't --\n\nA.\n\nOkay. I'm sorry, what is your question,\n\n13\n14\n\nnon on.\n\nQ.\n\nDidn't you admit on that page that you are\n\n15\n\ntestified that you\nnot to object\n\n13\n14\n\nI don't have the\n\nsir?\n\n15\n16\n\nnot seeking these requested materials in connection with\n\n16\n\n17\n\neither a civil or criminal case?\n\n17\n\nIsn't i\n\nt, we're going to\nthe other day you\nt because you needed him\n\nyty t for these materials?\n\nA.\n\nhim not to object? No. I gave\n\n18\n\nA.\n\nA pending -- Right, that is correct.\n\n18\n\nhim the opport\n\n19\n\nQ.\n\nOkay.\n\n19\n\nto syl\n\nA.\n\nThe Post was not seeking these documents in\n\n20\n\nion; or, three, they could have objected.\n\n21\n\nInitially, the state attorney's office took\n\n20\n21\n\napendingcriminal or civil case involving the Post.\n\n22\n\nThat is correct.\n\n23\n\nQ.\n\n24\n25\n\nr\n\no do actually three things. One is\n\nit request; two, they could have taken a\n\nion to object, and as I think I testified, they\n\nThank you. And did you also seek unlimited\n\nually changed the position in October of 2020 to\n\naccess to those requested materials for that reason?\nA.\nNo, that's not accurate.\n\ntrality.\nQ.\n\n\n... [truncated, 4194 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/61 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=61]", "char_count": 4194}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 62, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n\n1\n\nA.\n\nPage 155\nWell, there are circumstances where the\n\n1\n\nPage 157\nJudge Hafele, in his final judgment, said that he felt\n\n2\n\ncourts have implied causes of action. That's the famous\n\n2\n\nconstrained by the statute vis-a-vis his inherent\n\n3\n\nUnited States Supreme Court case of fort v. Ash where the\n\n3\n\nauthority as a judge.\n\n4\n\nCourt said that. even if Congress did not specifically\n\n4\n\nWhile he wanted as a judge to exercise his\n\n5\n\nauthorize a cause of action, that, in certain\n\n5\n\ninherent authority to allow for disclosure, he felt that\n\n6\n\ncircumstances, if Congress did not bar such, you could\n\n6\n\nthe statute constrained him in doing so because it did\n\n7\n\nhave an implied cause of action. That cores also for\n\n7\n\nnot expressly so state that it could be used outside of\n\nB\n\nSection 10(b)(5) of the securities laws.\n\n8\n\nthe civil or criminal case. That's what I believe Judge\n\nQ.\n\nOkay, but --\n\n9\n\nHafele said.\n\n10\n\nA.\n\nAnd Florida has that, too.\n\n10\n\n11\n\nQ.\n\nAll right. But, in your research. you\nstated that you rant through 905.27, right?\n\n11\n\n9\n\n12\n14\n\nQ.\n\nDo you have a ow 4 the final judgment in\n\nQ.\nfront of you?\n\n12\n\nA.\n\nYes. 'Fat\n\nExactly. yes.\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\nIt's tab 3\n\nOkay. And you ear across this language,\n\n14\n\nA.\n\nOkay\nAll\n\n15\n\nright? I'm going to read this to you: \"libel such\n\n15\n\nQ.\n\n16\n\ndisclosure is ordered by a Court pursuant to\n\n16\n\nA.\n\n17\n\nsubsection (1) for use in a civil case, it maybe\n\n17\n\nto advance\n\n18\n\ndisclosed to all parties to the case and to their\n\n18\n\n19\n\nattorneys and by the latter to their legal associates and\n\n19\n\nit.\n\nXor,\n\n1477.\n\nspacer makes strong arguments\nsir. No, sir.\nI'm sorry.\n\n20\n\nemployees; however, the grand jury testimony afforded\n\n20\n\nNo, sir. Let me redirect -- Let me direct\n\n21\n22\n\nsuch persons by the Court can only be used in the defense\nor prosecution of the civil or criminal case and for no\n\n21\n\nfirst paragraph here under Emphasis Added? Co\n\n23\n\nother purpose whatsoever.'\n\n24\n25\n\nit says, 'R\n... [truncated, 4273 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/62 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=62]", "char_count": 4273}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 63, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 159\ncontinue with this final judgment, Your Honor?\n\n1\n2\n\nBY MR. WYLER:\n\nPage 161\n1\n\nfirst paragraph starts with, The motes...\"\n\n2\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\nQ.\nA.\n\nMill you please read that for the Court?\n\nI would like you, Mr. Mendelsohn, to flip\n\n3\n4\n\n5\n\nto page 1479 of that same final judomasit. At the very\ntop of that page, could you read that first sentence for\n\n6\n\nme, too -- for me?\n\n6\n\nprovisions of Section 119.07 subdivision ill and\n\n7\n\nA.\n\n'Subsection (2) clearly limits\n\n7\n\nSection 24(a), Article 1 of the State COnstitution, and\n\n8\n\nSection 925.27's (sic) scope as to the instances in which\n\n8\n\nshall be released by the clerk only upon request by a\n\n9\n\ngrand jury testimony or materials need to be disclosed\n\n9\n\ngrand jury for use by the grand jury or on order of the\n\n10\n\nfor use in a criminal or civil case.\"\n\n3\n4\n\nQ.\n\n5\n\nSure. \"The notes, records and\n\ntranscriptions are confidential and exeunt from the\n\n10\n\nCourt pursuant to 905.27.°\n\n11\n\nQ.\n\nAnd then -- You can keep going.\n\n11\n\n12\n\nA.\n\n'Section (2) provides that, once grand jury\n\n12\n\nThank you, Mt.\nQ.\nrecall my client asserting\nclaim as well?\n\nmho. And do you\ndefense to your\n\n13\n\ntestimony is disclosed in the course of a court\n\n13\n\n14\n\nproceeding, it is then open to unlimited dissemination.\n\n14\n\nA.\n\nYes,\n\n15\n\nBefore that otters, the Court must determine that one of\n\n15\n\nQ.\n\nAnd\n\n16\n\nthe three needs prescribed in section (1) is present in a\n\n16\n\nfirm and you yourse\n\n17\n\ncriminal or civil case that requires disclosure. There's\n\n17\n\nthat Mr. Aronberg a$ his office have no ability to\n\nthat your client and your\nmade aware several tires\n\n18\n\nnothing in Section 905.27 that gives the Court carte\n\n18\n\ncomply with your declaratory relief claim because they\n\n19\n\nblanche,' which he has italics, 'authority to release\n\n19\n\nhave,\n\n20\n\ngrand jury materials in any situation that might bear\n\n20\n\n21\n\nsome relationship to, quote, furthering justice, end\n\n21\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\nquote, in its broadest sense.\"\n\n23\n\n\n... [truncated, 4336 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/63 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=63]", "char_count": 4336}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 64, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 163\n1\n\nQ.\n\n2\n3\n\n1\n\nQ.\n\nTHE CURT: Gentleman, so this is the\n\n2\n3\n\nEabibit Amber 14?\n:.:A.\nQ.\n\nsecond time, okay?\n\n4\n\nMR. MR: Thank you, Your Baer.\n\n4\n\n5\n\nDEB COURT: Let's maintain a little\n\n5\n\n6\n7\n\ncivility.\nBY MR. WYLER:\n\n8\n\nQ.\n\nPage 165\nOkay. would you please flip to our joint\n\nBut I didn't ask you that.\n\nMr. Mendelsohn, in your extensive\n\nIt's also found at IIIII stamp 232.\n\n6\n7\n\nOkay, do you -- do you recognize this as a\nQ.\ncopy of my client's 57.105 demand letter and a copy of\n\n8\n\nthe email when it was sent to you?\n\n9\n\ninvolvement in this case. how did you contribute to the\n\n9\n\nA.\n\nYes, I do.\n\n10\n\nJima 3rd, 2020, motion to dismiss hearing?\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nAnd what dry was it sent to you?\nJune 8th -Okay.\n\n11\n12\n\nA.\n\nHow did I?\n\n11\n\nA.\n\nQ.\n\nYeah, or did you?\n\n12\n\n13\n\nA.\n\nI didn't argue the motion, but certainly,\n\n13\n\nQ.\nA.\n\n-- of 2020\n\n14\n\nas part of the group, we had discussions as to how we\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nThank\n\n15\n\nthought it should be argued, the potential arguments from\n\n1.5\n\npeat the letter,\nA.\n\n16\n\nthe state attorney's office and what we thought would\n\n16\n\n17\n\noccur.\n\nQ.\nnotice for at\n\n19\n\nmod•\n\n18\n\nQ.\n\nDid you attend via Zoos or --\n\n17\n18\n\n19\n\nA.\n\n20\n\nQ.\n\nYes -Okay.\n\n20\n\n21\n\nA.\nQ.\n\n-- : did.\nAndhavey*0n ever read the transcript of\n\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nthen, if you flip to the --\n\nyou r. Do you recognize this as the\nI fees that was sent along with that\n\nor, with that 57.105 demand?\nA.\n\nWell, it wasn't a action. It was an\n\n21\n\noption that you were suggesting would\ni\n\nit?\n\n.\n\n's IIII stamp 235.\n\nif we did not act within the 21-day safe harbor\n57.105.\n\nA\nQ.\n\nQ.\n\nSete time ago, yes.\nOkay, so then you were aware of\n\nThat's right. And that -- Doyou/mowwhen\n\nthis motion for attorneys' fees was actually filed?\n\n4\n\nPage 166\n\n1\n\nMarx's statements, the ones that I read\n\n2\n\nin my opening statement regarding the\n\n3\n\nperformance for the records that\n\n4\n5\n\nA.\n\nI know she said\n\nQ.\n\nOkay. Did you\n\n6\n\nstatements as to an Lgws\n\n7\n\nable to ccaply?\n\n8\n\nA.\n... [truncated, 3735 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/64 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=64]", "char_count": 3735}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 65, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 167\n1\n\ngood faith element?\n\n1\n\nA.\n\n2\n\n2\n3\n4\n5\n\nQ.\nA.\n\n9\n\nQ.\n\n4\n5\n\nas being applicable.\nQ.\nMr. Nmadelsohn, you're skipping down to --\n\nI believe there is a good faith element\n\n6\n\nThat's not what I asked you.\n\n7\n\napply to 57.105(1)(a)? Does it say it in the statute?\n\nOkay, but in subsection 1 itself, is there\n\n8\n\na good faith element in that subsection?\n\n10\n\nA.\n\nNo, but there's an additional good faith\n\n11\n\n12\n\nletter.\n\n12\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nOkay. Now, are you referring to 57.105\n\nsubsection 4? I can show you the statute.\n\nIt doesn't say\n\nunder 131(a), but I\n\n13\n\ndon't remember the case\n\n14\n\nyou're suing both the\n\nthe lawyer under 57.105,\n\nr or not, when\nargument of geed faith.\n\n15\n\nA.\n\n15\n\nthat both of then •\n\nletter of Jun 23rd.\n\n57.105(3)(a), that's utat I was\n\n16\n\nBY YR. WYIER:‘14/\n\n17\n\n17\n\n18\n\nreferring to.\nQ.\nOkay. All right. And, now, we talked\n\n18\n\nt 0Orrect me if I'm wrong, it did say,\nunder paragraph (la), if the Court determines that the\n\n19\n\nstout this before. Can you -- 57.105(3)(a), can you read\n\n19\n\nclaim or &dense was initially presented to the Court as\n\n20\n\nabsentia (a) for the Court?\n\n20\n\nargument?\n\n21\n\n(1) Ibl has good faith in it as well, yes.\n\n22\n\nA.\n\nI don't have 57.105.\n\nI'm looking at my\n\nMR. NYLER: No. I'm just asking him to read\nit.\nA.\n\n16\n\n21\n\nLet rre just check here.\n\nlegal conclusion.\n\n10\n\nprovision in 57.105 that you didn't cite to in this\n\n57.105(3)(a), does that\n\nMS. AFETSPONE: Objection, calls for a\n\n9\n\n11\n13\n\nNo, no.\n-- and Greenberg attorneys, so I read that\n\nIn subsection (1), is there a good faith\n\nthat wraps =Lind the entire proceeding of 57.105.\n\n8\n\n4.\nA.\n\n3\n\nelement?\n\n6\n7\n\nNo, because you didn't quote the good faith\n\nelement of the statute.\n\nPage 169\nYou're seeking fees against oryself and --\n\nI have my letter\n\nwhich --\n\n23\n\nQ.\n\nI can hand it to you.\n\n24\n25\n\nA.\nQ.\n\nSure.\nYeah, absolutely.\n\n1\n\nThank you.\n\n2\n\nA.\nQ.\n\n3\n\nA.\n\n5\n\nYou're welcome. 3(a)\n'Notwithstanding\n\nand (2),\n\nmmetary sanctions nay no\n... [truncated, 4359 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/65 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=65]", "char_count": 4359}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 66, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n\nQ.\n\nThank you.\n\n1\n\nPage 173\ndisclosing the materials? Isn't there a difference\n\nA.\n\n-- there was more than one argument you\n\n2\n\nbetween that?\n\nwere making and rore than ore arament we were making.\n\n3\n\nPage 171\n1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n\n--\n\n6\n7\n\n16.\n\nA review of this letter makes crystal clear\nQ.\nsorry. All right. Okay, let's go to tab comber\n\n8\n9\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\nQ.\n\nDo you recognize this as the letter where\n\n4\n\nA.\n\n5\n\nI'll ask you again. Isn't there a\nO.\ndifference between accessing the materials and being able\n\n6\n7\n\nto disclose the materials?\nA.\nOnce the clerk provides --\n\n8\n9\n\nyou rejected our 57.105 demand?\n\nI don't understand what you're asking.\n\nQ.\n\nNo, no, no. It's a yes or no question.\n\nA.\n\nIbiza I don't understand what you're asking\n\n10\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n10\n\nme, to be honest with you.\n\n11\n12\n\nQ.\n\nCan I direct you to the very last paragraph\n\n11\n12\n\nIs there -- Is\nO.\nsaying, Bey, may I please\n\nof that letter?\n\n13\n\nA.\n\nFor these reasons, he decline' --\n\n13\n\nsaying, Here you go,\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nNo, sir. NO, sir. I'll point you. The\n\n14\n\nA.\n\n15\n\nis a twofold quest\n\n16\n\nQ.\ndifference\n\n15\n\nvery last paragraph of this letter, it starts with, °Also\n\n16\n17\n18\n19\n\nA.\n\n17\n\nII, no, I'm sorry, as the second page. I\nQ.\ndidn't need that one.\n\n20\n21\n\nThat's actually --\n\nA.\n\na difference between\nrecords, versus\n, Newspaper?\n\nWell,\n\n-- what you'reaskingme\nquestion. Is there a\nand disclosure?\n\n18\n\nyou access something, it's\n\n19\n\ndi\n\nThat's actually the penultirate --\n\n20\n\ns\n\nThen we'll start with the penultimate\n\n21\n\ndon't understand what you're asking me,\nly don't.\nMr. Mendelsohn, I'm sorry, and I do not\n\n22\n\nQ.\nparagraph on 245 --\n\n23\n\nA.\n\nRight, I see that, yes. It starts, Also\n\nve got to stop talking over each other. I'm\n\n24\n25\n\nQ.\n\nFirst sentence, plume.\n\nyou a simple question.\nYou stated here that Mr. Arenberg could get\n\n1\n\nA.\n\nAlso assuming the state a\n\nhave -- I do not want to asks the Court angry,\n\n1\n\nPage 174\naccess to these records through the Oaurt -- through t\n... [truncated, 4038 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/66 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=66]", "char_count": 4038}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 67, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 177\n\nPage 175\nto be disclosed to the public. In fact, we stated in the\n\n1\n\n2\n\nmyriad complaint that the Court should review such\n\n2\n\n3\n\ndocuments and redact anything that would identify\n\n3\n\nme give you this 57.105 statute again and ask you to look\n\n4\n\nwitnesses or potential witnesses or those who were not\n\n4\n\nat subsection (4) for me.\n\n5\n\ncharged with a crime.\n\n5\n\nA.\n\nOkay.\n\n6\n7\n\nQ.\n\nAnd if could you reed that to the Court.\n\n1\n\n6\n\nSo it's inaccurate for you to suggest that\n\n7\n\nthe paper just wanted it handed to them. That was never\n\n8\n9\n\nthe case.\nQ.\n\nA.\n\nRight.\n\nQ.\n\nThank you. So, if I give you this -- Let\n\nThank you.\n\n8\n\nA.\n\n\"A motion by a party seeking sanctions\n\nOkay. Let's look back at your complaint.\n\n9\n\nunder this section must be served bit may not be filed\n\n10\n\nIt's tab number 9. We're going to look at IIIII stamp\n\n10\n\nwith or presented to the Court unl ss, within 21 days\n\n11\n\n136, and we're going to look at your wherefore clause.\n\n11\n\nafter service of the motion, the\n\n12\n\nA.\n\nTab 9, you say?\n\n12\n\ndefense, contention, allegat\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\nYes.\n\n14\n\nA.\n\n136?\n\n13\n14\n\nwithdrinm or appropriate\nQ.\nThank\n\n15\n\nQ.\n\nYes.\n\n1.5\n\nwithdraw the claim\n\n16\n\nA.\n\nI see it.\n\n16\n\n21 days after\n\n17\n\nQ.\n\nOkay.\n\n17\n\nA.\n\n*Wherefore, the Post -- the Palm Beach Post\n\n18\n\nlenged paper, claim,\nal is not\n\nyou and your client did not\nrelief within that\ncorrect?\n\nA.\n\n. And then let me have you look\n\nrespectfully requests that the Court determine the rights\n\n19\n\n20\n\nand obligations of the parties by declaring that,\n\n20\n\nPlaintiff -- Yes, the notice of dropping\n\n21\n\npursuant to Florida Statute Section 905.27(1)(c) and the\n\n21\n\nDave Arenberg cc October 21st, 2020, that\n\n19\n\n22\n\nCcurt's inherent authority, the Palm Beach Post may gain\n\n23\n\naccess to the testimony, minutes and other evidence\n\n24\n\npresented in 2006 to the Palm Beach aunty grand jury\n\n25\n\nuse those materials for the purpose of informing\n\n1\n\npublic.*\n\n-- or, our Exhibit Mater 23.\n\nat\n\nyou wa\n... [truncated, 3800 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/67 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=67]", "char_count": 3800}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 68, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 179\n1\n\ncorrect?\nA.\nQ.\n\n3\n4\n\nThe statute gave me that, yes.\nOkay. And then when did you actually\n\nA.\n\nWe dropped Yr. Aronberg -- khan you say\n\n6\n\nchanged position, I don't ;cow what you're referring to.\n\n7\n8\n\nYe dropped Mx. Aronberg as a defendant in this case an\nOctober 21, 2020.\n\n9\n10\n\nQ.\n\nit. Yes, that is the position.\n\n2\n\nQ.\nCan you tell me, after dropping\nMr. Aronberg from the lawsuit, bow your position -- how\n\n3\n\nchange your position and drop Mr. Aronbeng?\n\n5\n\nPage lei\n1\n\nOkay, and October 21, 2020, is more than\n\n21 days after June 8th, 2020, right?\n\n4\n\nyour client's position could have changed if they were\n\n5\n\nserved with another letter being that he was already out\n\n6\n7\n\nof the lawsuit?\nA.\n\nWell, that's the problem you have because\n\n8\n\nyou served this motion without giving us the safe-harbor,\n\n9\n\nthe amended motion I'm referring to, as well as the fact\n\n10\n\nthat you served it after we\n\nhim. For\n\n11\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n11\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\nOkay. So then that fits with the statutory\n\n12\n\njurisdictional purposes, you can\nO.\nSW could I\n\ndo that.\na safe-harbor if\n\nlanguage then, correct, of what that 21-day -- it gives\nyou 21 days to withdraw, and you didn't withdraw within\n\n13\n\nyou had alreadydropped\n\n14\n\nA.\n\n15\n\n21 days, correct? The statute, 57.105 subsection (4),\n\n15\n\nactually raking my\n\n16\n\ngives you 21 days to withdraw the alleged --\n\n16\n\napplicable hi'\n\n17\n\ncase.\n\n13\n14\n\n17\n\nA.\n\nYou are confusing a number of thirgs that\n\n18\n\nare happening, so I cannot answer that question. You're\n\n18\n\n19\n\nassming certain things that are not accurate, so I\n\n19\n\n20\n\ncannot answer your question in the manner you put it to\n\n20\n\n21\n22\n\nMr. Myl\n\nQ.\n\nI guess we just have differing\nto interpret that statute, Mr. Mendelsohn.\n• All right, I just have a few more questions\nSure.\n\nMr. Mendelsohn, it's very simple. I'm just\n\ntrying to establish that that -- that you filed your drop\n\n24\n\ncure -- you dropped the claim against Mr. Aronberg\n\n25\n\noutside of the 21-day\n... [truncated, 4480 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/68 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=68]", "char_count": 4480}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 69, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 185\n\nPage 183\ncivil declaratory judgment action and has moved for\n\n1\n\ngunnery judgment under Florida Rule of Civil Procedure\n1.510. However, the proper procedure for obtaining\n\n3\n\ndoes say, which you just read to the Court, the proper\n\n4\n\ndisclosure of confidential Court records is set forth in\n\n4\n\n5\n\nFlorida Rule of General Practice and Judicial\n\n5\n\nprocedure for obtaining disclosure of ccofidential\nrecords is set forth in Florida Rule of General Practice\n\n6\n\nAdministration 2.420(j) which only requires the filing of\n\n6\n\nand Judicial Adednietratico 2.420(j), which only requires\n\n7\n\na, quote, motion, end quote, seeking disclosure, Florida\n\n7\n\nthe filing of a notion seeking disclosure; is that\n\n8\n9\n\nRule of General Practice and Judicial Administration\n\n8\n\ncorrect?\n\n2.420(j)(2).\"\n\n9\n\n1\n2\n3\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nThank you, /tr. Mendelsohn.\nIn the Court's final judgment, however, it\n\n2\n\nA.\n\nYes, but at this tire, the state attorney\n\nWant re to keep going?\n\n10\n\nwas not a party, and, in fact, the state attorney has\n\nYeah, just to the very end of that next\n\n11\n\nQ.\n\n11\n\nnever made any amprect under Ru\n\n12\n\nsentence, please.\n\n12\n\nIt has never made such an a\n\nA.\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\nnewspaper's complaint and motion for smeary judgment as\n\n14\n\nfiled this lawsuit?\n\n15\n\na notion for disclosure under Rule 2.42' -- excuse me --\n\n16\n\n\"2.420(j). As a result, the Court need not deterx:re as\n\nafter we\n\n17\n\na matter of law whether the clerk of the Court is a\n\n15\n16\n17\n\n18\n\nproper defendant to the declaratory judgment for the\n\n18\n\nrade this a\n\n19\n20\n\nrelease of the grand jury materials.\"\n\n19\n\nour motion for au:Teary judgant which\nr the state attorney had been dropped from\n\n13\n14\n\n\"Accordingly, the Court will treat the\n\nQ.\n\nThank you. All right.\n\n20\n\n21\n\nA.\n\nI'm sorry. was there a qastion?\n\n21\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\nfamiliar with Rule 2.420 of the Rules of Judicial\n\n25\n\nAdministration?\n\nA.\n\nAbsolutely.\n\nQ.\n\nThen why didn't you jus\n\nPage 186\nissue that either you addressed or we addres\n... [truncated, 4851 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/69 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=69]", "char_count": 4851}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 70, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n\n1\n\nPage 187\nthe final goal to have these requested grand jury\n\n2\n\nmaterials be able to be disclosed to the public?\n\n3\n4\n5\n\nA.\n\nAbsolutely.\n\nOkay. And that was without any connection\nO.\nto any underlying civil or criminal case, correct?\n\n6\n\nA.\n\nPage 189\n1\n\nthat are the subject of this action.'\n\n2\n3\n\nQ.\nSo comparing those two paragraphs, was the\nclerk named in a different capacity as the state attorney\n\n4\n\nin paragraph 3?\n\n5\n\nA.\n\nYes, because, in paragraph 3, I cited to\n\nIf you're asking me whether or not the Post\n\n6\n\nFlorida Statute 27.03, which is the broad grant of\n\n7\n\nwas part of a civil or criminal case pending at the time,\n\n7\n\nauthority to state attorneys to supervise and conduct\n\n8\n\nno, it was rot.\n\n8\n\ngrand jury investigations, and that's really what the\n\n9\n\nsituation involved in this case.\n\n9\n10\n\nQ.\n\nYou did not -- Did you request these\n\nrecords as part of a pending civil or criminal case?\nA.\n\n11\n\nInvolving the Post? No -MR. MILER: Thank you. No further\n\n12\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nSo you set asrth\n\nthat the state attorney was\n\nhaving authority\n\n12\n\nover grand jury proceedings; 1\n\ncorrect?\n\n13\n\nquestions.\n\n:3\n\n14\n\nA.\n\n-- ocher than this lawsuit.\n\n14\n\nA.\nQ.\n\n15\n\n7HE COURT: Thank you.\n\n15\n\ncomplaint that was\n\n16\n\nRedirect examination.\n\n16\n\nA.\n\nREDIRECT EDDIMIlaTICN\n\n17\n\nQ.\n\n17\n18\n\nBY MS. WHETSTCNE:\n\n19\n20\n\nQ.\n\nGood afternoon, Kr. 14mndelsohn.\n\n19\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n20\n\n21\n\nQ.\n\nMr. Wyler asked you to read a sentence in\n\n21\n\n22\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\nO.\n-- and I'd like to dram your attention\nthat, and it's kchibit 9. I'm going to look at\n\n1\n\nparagraph 3.\n\n2\n\nA.\nQ.\n\n4\n\nYes, I have that in f\nCan you read the en\n\n2\n3\n\nYes, I'd be happy\n\nPage 190\nand it appears that paragraph 3 appears the sane.\nQ.\n\nParagraph 3 of the original complaint is\n\n5\n\nthe same as the amended complaint; is that correct?\nA.\nYes. Both of them cite to Section 27.03\nFlorida Statutes creating jurisdiction by the state\n\nrida, pursuant to Florida\ny,\nand has authority in grand jury\n\n8\n\nattorney ov\n... [truncated, 4310 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/70 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=70]", "char_count": 4310}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 71, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 191\n1\n\nthe grand jury system?\n\n2\n\nA.\nQ.\n\nPage 193\n1\n2\n\nA.\n\n3\n\nthey were dicta.\n\nA.\nNo, I didn't cite to it because it was\nclear to anyone who looked at Florida Statute 27.03, they\n\n4\n\nQ.\nA.\n\n6\n\nwould see a litany of cases describing the authority of\n\n6\n\n7\n\nthe state attorney over the grand juries in their\n\nB\n\njudicial district. So it was obvious that -- what he\nwere getting at.\n\n3\n4\n5\n\n9\n10\n11\n\nYou mean paragraph 3?\nYes.\n\nalmeists that Kr. Wyler read?\n\nQ.\n\nand I respect Judge Marx. She's a very, very seasoned\n\n8\n9\n\nYou cited the statute that gives the state\n\nA.\n\nAnd what did Judge Marx's order rule?\nShe ruled on a very narrow area, which --\n\nand reasoned jurist.\n\nattorney power over the grand jury?\n\n12\n\n5\n\nNo, she did not. That's why I believe that\n\nCorneas, yes. In fact, there are cases\n\nShe determined that, under 905.27, that\nthere was not a private cause of action, and that,\n\n10\n\nbecause it was not a private cause,of action, we could\n\n11\n\nnot utilize that statute to seek\n\ngrand jury\n\n12\n\nmaterials. We disagreed wit\n\nand that is the\n\nsubject of the appeal.\n\n13\n\nthat say that, under this statute, that the grand jury is\n\n13\n\n14\n\nessentially the arm of the -- of the state attorney.\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\n15\n\nentered by Judge\n\n15\n\nQ.\n\nAnd now that we're back on the amended\n\n16\n\ncomplaint, I'll direct your attention to paragraph 21 --\n\n16\n\nA.\n\n17\n\nsorry -- page 21, wherein there is the wherefore clause.\n\n17\n\nQ.\n\n18\n19\n20\n\nMr. Wyler had you read from one of the\nwherefore clause on page 21 -Q.\n\nfinal judgment that was\nis -t 30, yes --\n\n18\n\nwherefore clauses, but I wanted to ask about the\n\n22\n\nSo\n\n19\n20\n\n-- It. Wyler asked you to read Iran page 7,\n\n21\n\nYes.\n\n-- and you had said that you had requested\n\nnumber ending 1477.\nQ.\n\nAnd I'm going to ask you to go ahead and\n\n23\n\nan in-camera inspection. Actually, could I just ask you\n\nthat paragraph, or read the whole paragraph if you\n\n24\n\nto read this wherefore clause?\n\nlike.\n\n25\n\nA.\n\nSure. \"The 2alm \n... [truncated, 4471 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/71 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=71]", "char_count": 4471}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 72, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 195\nsecrecy. And\n\n1\n\nPage 197\nthe right constitutionally to seek these materials.\n\n1\n\nthe public to hear a voice for\n\n2\n\nthe state attorney availed himself of that opportunity.\nNow, on appeal, we are of the belief that\n\n2\n\n3\n4\n\nthe Court has such inherent authority and that the\n\n4\n\n5\n\nCourt's inherent authority is, as I say, superior to the\n\n5\n\n6\n\nstatute. There are federal cases %rich say that, and\n\n7\n\nthere are state cases which say that. And, in fact, the\n\n6\n7\n\nB\n\nFlorida Supreme Court's case -- actually it's a Fifth DCA\n\n8\n\nback to the demand, the first motion for sanctions that\n\n9\n\ncase in Clayton says that, where a state attorney may\n\n9\n\nwas that one-page motion, and that was served on\n\n3\n\nI know I'm going off on a tangent, but it's\nimportant.\nTHE CCCRT: You are. So let's move on.\nTHE WITNESS: Thank you.\nBY MS. WHETS1tt'E\nQ.\nThank you, Mr. Mendelsohn.\n\n10\n\nhave abused his authority with the grand jury -- It's not\n\n10\n\nJune 8th, 2020.\n\n11\n\nMr. Krischer, and it's not Kr. Arenberg, so I'm not\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n12\n\nsuggesting they are -- but, in that case, it was the\n\n11\n12\n\nQ.\n\nAnd the demand tidbit\n\n13\n\nFifth DCA who said that, I don't care what the statute\n\n13\n\n14\n\nsays, the Court has authority to control ahme% of the\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nYes.\nAnd Mt.\n\n15\n\ngrand jury process, and ultimately that's why we're here.\n\n15\n\nabout the letter that was\n\n16\n\nwasthe basis for\n\n16\n\nWe believe that we've laid out a very\n\nNow let's go\n\n14.\n\nasked you smae questions\nwith that motion and\ncos motion that was attached\n\n17\n\ndetailed factual and legal reason why we think the prior\n\n17\n\ndealing with possess\n\nor custody of the grand jury\n\nmaterials by\n\nattorney's office.\n\n18\n\nstate attorney abused his authority. How did he do so?\n\n18\n\n19\n\nBy obtaining materials from the defense team that\n\n19\n\n20\n\nundermined the credibility of the witness and the victim\n\n20\n\n21\n\nbefore the grand jury. We assert that in paragraph 22 of\n\n21,t_\n\n22\n\nthe amended complaint. It stat\n... [truncated, 4719 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/72 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=72]", "char_count": 4719}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 73, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n\n1\n2\n4\n5\n\nQ.\n\nPage 199\nYes. And did the state attorney ever set\n\nthat motion, original motion for fees for hearing?\nA.\nsever.\n\nA.\nQ.\n\nneed in that appeal?\n\n2\n\nA.\nQ.\n\nNo.\nWhy not?\n\nA.\n\nWell, the appeal was taken on Octet 1 as\n\n3\n\nQ.\nAnd we are not here on that first motion;\nis that correct?\n\n7\n\nPage 20:\n1\n\nCorrect. They never set it for a hearing.\nSo we're here on the amended motion for\n\n4\n5\n\nyou say. ()stint 1 had a nu7ber of elements associated\n\n6\n\nwith it. That's the declaratory judgment provision. It\n\n7\n\nasserted that, under the First Amendment, both the U.S.\nConstitution and the Florida Constitution that the Post\n\n8\n\nsanctions which was filed November 9th, 2020; is that\n\na\n\n9\n\ncorrect?\n\n9\n\nhad standing or the right to seek these grand jury\n\n. And, in fact, the amended motion\n\n10\n\nmaterials, and the statute was\n\nlernentary to that\n\nand the notice of hearing does not mention the first cc*\niron July of 2020.\n\n11\n\nFirst Amendeent right by the 1a.\n\nge in the statute,\n\n12\n\n905.27, of it being in furt\n\n10\n11\n12\n\nA.\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\nCo\n\nSo you never got a notice of hearing that\n\n13\n\nWe also as\n\n14\n\nset the original first -- July 1st, 2020, notice for fees\n\n14\n\ninherent authority\n\n15\n\nfor hearing; is that correct?\n\n15\n\nappellate court we\n\n16\n\nconflict with\n\n16\n17\n\nA.\n\nThat is correct, yes.\n\n17\n\nauthority\n\n18\n\nAnd you never got a copy via mail or fax or\nhard copy of the amended motion for fees filed\n\n18\n\nSo there were\n\n19\n\nNovember 9th prior to the time it was filed, correct?\n\n19\n\nel\n\nQ.\n\n20\n\nA.\n\n21\n\n21-day safe harbor.\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\nThat is correct. We weren't given the\n\ndrop the state attorney +den it did?\n\n24\n\nA.\nThe state attorney's position changed f\nOCR of opposition to the release of the grand jury\n\n25\n\n1\n\nmaterials to one of neutrality. Once the\nWoe the state attorney changed the\n\n3\n\nPost re-evaluated Mather or not\ncase, and xe determined that he\n\n5\n\nthe case.\n\n6\n\nQ.\n\n905.27. If the\nthat 905.27 was in\nthority, that the Court's\nto 905.27. S\n... [truncated, 4366 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/73 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=73]", "char_count": 4366}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 74, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 203\n1\n\nMS. Nrobto.tra\n\nPage 205\n\nIf I may approach, I'll\n\n1\n\n2\n3\n\ntake the exhibit binder.\nTHE WITNESS: These are for Mr. Wyler.\n\n2\n\nthis as not on the witness list, which we have\n\n3\n\nagreed, and having no issue that needs to be\n\n4\n5\n\nThank you.\nTHE CUJRT: Next •witness.\n\n4\n\nraised. You could have asked Mr. Mendelsohn about\nand you could have asked Mr. Arenberg about his\n\n5\n\nMS. WETSTONE: Your Honor, we object to\n\n6\n\nMR. WYLER: May we call a rebuttal witness?\nMS. WE15\n-DINE: Your Honor, there's no\n\n6\n7\n\ncon recollection of that instance.\n\n7\n8\n9\n\nrebuttal witness listed on the -MR. WYLER: Well, as to the statements that\n\n8\n\nas a rebuttal.\n\n9\n\n10\n\n10\n\n11\n\nYr. Mendelsohn said at the beginning denying the\nconversation where he, you know, put it on us to\n\n11\n\nrelevant to the motion at all.\n\n12\n\n-- you know, he said that he would hold the filing\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT: I agree.\n\n13\n\nof an article while settlement negudations were\n\n13\n\n14\n\npending.\n\n14\n\nMR. WYLER:\n\n15\n\nTHE CURT:\n\n15\n\nMS. Vutia LW: And, Your Honor, those\n\nMR. WfLER: I could call Mr. Axcaerg then\nTHE COURT: I'm sorry?\nMS. FOWTSICUE: Objection, i 's not\n\nreconsider.\n\n16\n\nsettlement discussions were never entered into\n\n16\n\nnow, I think\n\n17\n\nevidence, never e•.en atterpted to enter into\n\n17\n\nhere has tha\n\n18\n\nevidence, and we object to those being entered\n\n18\n\narguments,\n\n19\n\ninto evidence now.\n\n19\n\ngive\n\nWE COURT: Settlement negotiations are\n\n20\n21\n\nour Honor.\n\nts. All right,\ned last time we were\nd give re your closing\nneeded to supplement, I'll\nsupplement in writing.\n\nhat you all want to do, or do you\n\n20\n\nexcluded by statute. All right, so no.\n\nI will not\n\n21\n\nlode today?\n\n22\n\nMR. WYLER: Okay.\n\n23\n\nFLS. VutioLUNE: Thank you, Your Honor.\n\nen closing aliment if pemsible.\n\n. WYLER: I would prefer to provide you a\n\n24\n25\n\nTHE WJRT: Is there anything else?\nW. WYLER: Other than -- No, Your Honor.\n\nME COURT: Instead of -MR. Mt R: Yeah, I absolutely would.\n\n1\n\nTHE 07JYT: Okay. Then\n... [truncated, 4075 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/74 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=74]", "char_count": 4075}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 75, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 207\n\nPage 209\nbecause there is a difference, Mr. Arenberg in his\n\n1\n\nTht COOK: Okay, I'm going to give you\n\n1\n\n2\n\nsome guidance because there's something I do %ant\nto hear fawn you.\n\n2\n\n4\n\nI do want you to address [ago. And,\n\n4\n\n5\n\nYs. Whetstone, when I read In re Grand Jury\n\n5\n\nstate attorney's was subpoenaed.\nAnd I also want you -- well, both parties\n\n6\n\nProceedings, in those cases the state attorney was\n\n6\n\nto address the Horowitz case where it says that\n\n7\n\nsubpoenaed, they were not a party to the case, and\n\n7\n\nthe judge can extend the law because it's an\n\n8\n\nI want you to address that as well.\n\na\n\nobligation of legislative authority.\n\n3\n\n9\n10\n11\n12\n\nHow arch tine do you need to prepare your\nclosings?\nMR. WYLER: If you could give us a week,\nYour Honor, that would be terrific.\n\n3\n\n9\n\nofficial capacity as a named party, and In re\nGrand Jury, I think in that case, I think the\n\nAll right, so you'll give me your arguments\n\n10\n\nand proposed orders within 21 days.\n\n11\n\nDo I need to bring you back \"n for a\nhearing?\n\n12\n\n13\n\nTHE CCURT: I'll give you a week.\n\n13\n\n14\n\nMs. Whetstone, is a week sufficient?\n\n14\n\nMR. MIER: No,\n\nr.\n\n15\n\nMS. WniabiLEE: Yes, Your Honor, a week is\n\n15\n\nTHE CCCRT:\n\nght, then we'll be\n\n16\n\nsufficient.\n\n17\n\n16\n\nTHE COURT: I'll give you 10 days. I world\n\n18\n\nalso like a copy of the transcript attached.\n\n18\n\nMR. WYLER: Then we might need a little\n\n19\n\n21\n22\n\nmore tire to get it.\n\nin recess.\n\n17\n\n19\n20\n\nMS. hREISTOR4E: No\n\nyou, Your Honor.\nMS\n\nThank you, Your Honor.\nHave a great day.\ning concluded at 2:42 p.m.)\n\n20\n\nMS. h14,151Ck€: Your Manor, could we ask\n\n21\n\nfor 20 days?\n\n23\n\nIHE COURT: I'll give you three weeks.\n\n24\n25\n\nI'll give you three weeks. Give re your -- your\nwritten closings and proposed orders.\n\n1\n\nGive me one more minute. There nd\n\nPage 210\n2\n\n2\n\nsomething else I want you guys to\n\n3\n\nIn the event that I agree ri\n\n4\n\nCOURT CERTIFICATE\n\nSTATE OF FLORIDA\n4\n\nMr. Arenberg, the amamts have\n\n5\n\n5\n6\n7\n8\n\n... [truncated, 3123 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/75 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=75]", "char_count": 3123}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 76, "text_content": "Exhibit \"B\"\nCP\n\nN\n\nS Ci\n\nI fe*\nO(S\n\nEFTA02735035\n\n\f", "char_count": 51}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 77, "text_content": "Timeline\n$ August 18. 2020\nAionberg's Motion for Summary Judgment and Affidavit\n• First record evidence supporting argument that konbergSA has\nno possession or control of documents, no authority to demand\nthat Clerk provide access to documents. and that his office has\nnever accessed grand pry materials from the Clerk's office in\ntluS or any matter.\nImportantly. does not address or admit that Arenberg or his\nOffice wood not block access or object to Clerk's production.\n\n\"fauna/.17. 2020\nFist Amended Complaint fikd\n'Count I Declaratory Rebel: Court\nFla. Stat §905,$)r\n416 July 1. 2020\nArenberg files\nFirst Motion for\nFees\n\nJanuary 24,\nArenberg's An\n!Anon to Dismi\n\nDerai led toren arid analas,s of Pan: ICCCrd of Epstein\nestiqat.ors and legal rescarcn and analysis\n\nsupporting request to obtain grand pry records\n\nJune 8.2020 40\nlieanng on\nMotion to\ns Count II\n\nqg October 14. 2020\nAronberg files Reply in support of First Motion for\nOctober 2. 2020 $\nFees\nPlaintiff fres\n• First time Aronberg states he has op\nObjection to the production of Epstein grand\nResponse to First\nMotion for Fees\nfury materials by the Clerk\nDescnbes his First Motion for Fees as a\n'place marker\n\n..r e8 2020\nder Granting Motion to Dismiss Count II\nr\n\nJune 8 020 dIr\nSeneceitplace-minopc First Motion for Fees and\nenclosure letterEp1m Arenberg's attorney. 0 Wyler\nInitial Compaq tiled (Fla\nStat. 4905.27)\nSettlement DiSCLISSieel\nJune 8. 2020\n\ni\n\nNovember 9. 2020\nArenberg Nes Amended\nfaobon for Fees (not\nserved any time prior to\n(ding)\n\n*October 21, 2020\nNotice of Dropping Party\nas to Arenberg\n\nOctober 15. 2020\n\nED Greenberg-fraurig\n\nEFTA02735036\n\n\f", "char_count": 1632}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 78, "text_content": "Exhibit \"C\"\n\nEFTA02735037\n\n\f", "char_count": 28}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 79, "text_content": "IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE\nFIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND\nFOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA\nCA FLORIDA HOLDINGS, LLC,\nPublisher of THE PALM BEACH POST,\n\nCASE NO.: 50-2019-CA-014681-XXXX-MB\nDIVISION: AG\n\nPlaintiff,\nv.\nDAVE ARONBERG, as State Attorney of\nPalm Beach County, Florida; SHARON R.\nBOCK, as Clerk and Comptroller of Palm\nBeach County, Florida.\n\nCO\n\nSA\n\nDefendants.\n\nBENCH MEMORANDUM REGARDING\n\n'4(\n\nPlaintiff, CA Florida Holdings, LLC (\"\n\nst\"), publisher of The Palm Beach Post, by\n\nand through undersigned counsel, and pu\n\ne\n\no tlTe Court's Order on Joint Motion to Continue\n\nEvidentiary Hearing on the State Amended\n5, 2021, hereby submits this\nscheduled on September 6, 202\nDE\nFor t\nMemoran.\n\nKREY FEE OBJECTIONS\n\nMotion for Attorneys' Fees dated August\n\nmorandum in connection with the evidentiary hearing\n:30 p.m.:\n\nNDY IS NOT ENTITLED TO ATTORNEY'S FEES\ndiscussed in The Post's February 24, 2022 Amended Response and\n\naw (\"Response in Opposition\"), The Office of State Attorney is not entitled to\n\nrecover an amounts under Florida Statutes § 57.105.\nMANY OF THE FEES REOUESTED ARE NOT COMPENSABLE\nShould this Court determine the State Attorney is entitled to fees, which he is not, many\nof the fees requested are not compensable and/or should be substantially discounted. Such\n\nEFTA02735038\n\n\f", "char_count": 1309}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 80, "text_content": "CASE NO.: 50-2019-CA-014681\ncategories and case authority are below:'\n•\n\nTravel Time in the amount of $10,412.50; see Exhibit A attached hereto.\no Mandel v. Decorator's Mart, Inc., 965 So. 2d 311, 315-316 (Fla. 4th DCA 2007)\n(\"[T]he award of fees should not have included the travel time of the attorneys ...\nwithout proof that a competent local attorney could not be obtained, an award of\nattorney's fees from an opponent should not include travel time over and above\nwhat a local attorney would charge.\").\no Palm Beach Polo Holdings, Inc. v. Stewart Title Guar. Co.,\n(Fla. 4th DCA 2014) (\"[T]ravel time is generally not compen\n\n•\n\n858, 862\n\nCosts in the amount of $1,482.77; see Exhibit B attached\no Ferdie v. Isaacson, 8 So. 3d 1246, 1251 (Fla. 4th\n2009), superseded by\nstatute on other grounds. (reversing award\ns and stating that Fla. Stat.\n§ 57.105 allows for \"reasonable attorney's\npaid to the prevailing party,\nbut makes no mention of costs.\" (intern\ns omitted)).\no Ferere v. Shure, 65 So. 3d 1141, 1\nis not allowed under section 57\n\n•\n\nth DCA 2011) (\"[A]n award of costs\n\ne amount of $3,485.00; see Exhibit C attached\n\nLitigation Time Re: Fee Amount\n\nhereto.\no Cox v. Great Am.\ncourt erred in\naward.\").\n\n'88 So. 3d 1048, 1049 (Fla. 4th DCA 2012) (\"The trial\ntomey's fees incurred in litigating the amount of the fee\n\no Yakavoni\ne\n\ne\n\n1phin Petroleum, Inc., 934 So. 2d 615, 620 (Fla. 4th DCA 2006)\nfees are only available for time spent litigating the issue of\nem, not for the time spent litigating the amount of fees to be awarded.\").\n\nBeach Polo Holdings; Inc., 132 So. 3d at 862 (\"Although fees incurred in\n, gating entitlement to attorneys' fees under section 768.79 are authorized, fees\nincurred in litigating the amount of fees are not recoverable.\") (emphasis in\noriginal).\no Oquendo v. Citizens Property Ins., 998 So. 2d 636, 638 (Fla. 3d DCA 2008) (fact\nthat retainer agreement obligated insureds to pay counsel for time expended in\n\nThe Post's objections against a multiplier are no\n... [truncated, 2183 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/80 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=80]", "char_count": 2183}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 81, "text_content": "CASE NO.: 50-2019-CA-014681\nlitigating the amount of attorneys' fees made no difference to issue of whether\nfees were compensable by other side).\n• Administrative Entries in the total amount of $7,522.50, also containing block billed\ntime entries where portions of the entry are administrative; see Exhibit D attached hereto.\no N. Dade Church of God Inc. v. JM Statewide, Inc., 851 So. 2d 194, 196 (Fla. 3d\nDCA 2003) (\"We do, however, conclude that the attorney's fee award must be\nreduced. . . . Likewise noncompensable is excessive time spcn on simple\nministerial tasks such as reviewing documents or filing notices ofgpp arance.').\nv. Sophia, 711 So. 2d 209, 212 (Fla. 4th DCA 1998)\nthe client is not standing over their shoulders as each time\nallow them to inflate the time spent on their client's •\nduplicative services by multiple members of the firm\n\nmere fact that\ngged does not\nor does it allow\n\no Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. v. Mickelson, 2018 F\nir.TEXIS 3017,'9 (Fla. Cir.\nCt. 2018) (\"Courts are clear that purely\nsks should not be billed at\nparalegal rates regardless of the qualific\ne biller. Where there was no\nevidence that work done was parale I\nr as opposed to secretarial work,\ncourts have reversed an award of pgrtffe\ns.\" (collecting cases)).\n•\n\nMedia time entries in the amount\n\n•\n\nSettlement time entries in t\no MacAlister v. Be\n(stating that c\nserves its inte\nchilling effect on\n\n$\n\n. ; see Exhibit E attached hereto.\n\noun of $1,835.00; see Exhibit F attached hereto.\n\nInc., 164 So. 3d 773, 776 (Fla. 2d DCA 2015)\napply Section 57.105 \"with restraint to ensure that it\nrpose of discouraging baseless claims without casting a\nof the courts.\").\n\nLLC v. 1000 Friends of Fla., Inc., 228 So. 3d 147 (Fla. 4th DCA\n(same).\n•\nhereto.?\n\nBack time entries in the amount of $27,540.00; see Exhibit G attached\n\nYakavonis, 934 So. 2d at 619-620 (\"Ulf the claim or defense is not initially\nfrivolous, the court must then determine whether the claim or defense became\nfrivolous after the suit was f\n... [truncated, 2495 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/81 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=81]", "char_count": 2495}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 82, "text_content": "CASE NO.: 50-2019-CA-014681\n\no Hustad v. Architectural Studio, Inc., 958 So. 2d 569, 570 (Fla. 4th DCA 2007)\n(\"The mere dismissal of a suit does not necessarily justify an attorney's fee award\nif the suit can be considered to have been non-frivolous at its inception.\").\no Fla. Stat. § 57.105(1)(a) (stating that fees are to be awarded \"on any claim . . . at\nany time during a civil proceeding . . . in which the court finds that the losing\nparty . . . knew or should have known that a claim . . . [w]its not supported by the\nmaterial facts [or law] necessary to establish the claim.\").\n• Clerk-Only Entries in the amount of $2,277.50; see Exhibit I att\ncovers fees claimed after the dismissal of the State Attorney and which rel\ninvolving the litigation with the Clerk of the Court.\n\nto. This\nec\nIely to matters\n\nRespectfully su\n\nLa\n\ntone\nNo. 45192\nideau\na Bar No. 564044\ncnberg Traurig, P.A.\n777 South Flagler Drive, Suite 300 East\nWest Palm Beach, FL 33401\nTel.: 561.650.7900\nwhetstonelQutlaw.com\nbideaum@gtlaw.com\nsandralamadasagtlaw.com\nthomasd@gtlaw.com\nFLService©gtlaw.com\nStephen A. Mendelsohn\nFlorida Bar No. 849324\nGreenberg Traurig, P.A.\n401 East Las Olas Boulevard, Suite 2000\nFort Lauderdale, FL 33301\nTel.: 954.768.8225\nmendelsohns©atlaw.com\nsmithl(agtlaw.com\nMichael J. Grygiel\n(Admitted Pro Hac Vice)\nGreenberg Traurig, P.A.\n54 State Street, 6th Floor\nAlbany, NY 12207\n\n4\n\nEFTA02735041\n\n\f", "char_count": 1404}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 83, "text_content": "CASE NO.: 50-2019-CA-014681\nTel.: 518.689.1400\ngrygielm@gtlaw.com\nNina D. Boyajian\n(Admitted Pro Hac Vice)\nGreenberg Traurig, P.A.\n1840 Century Park East, Suite 1900\nLos Angeles, CA 90067\nTel.: 310.586.7700\nboyajiann@gtlaw.com\nriveraalagtlaw.com\nCounselfor Plaintiff\nLLC, Publisher of Th\n\nHoldings,\neach Post\n\nCERTIFICATE OF SERVIC)\nI HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and accurate c\n\nforegoing has been served on\n\nall parties of record herein on this I' day of Septe\n\niti\n\na llrenrZetstWheotncteone\n\n6\"\n\n5\n\nEFTA02735042\n\n\f", "char_count": 516}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 84, "text_content": "EFTA02735043\n\n\f", "char_count": 15}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 85, "text_content": "Date\nEE\n07/15/2021 DW\n07/17/2021 DW\n03/03/2022 DW\n03/04/2022 DW\n\nActivity Description\nTravel Travel to West Palm Beach\nTravel Travel back to Amelia\nTravel Travel to West Palm Beach\nTravel Travel back to Amelia\n\nRate Hours\nLine Total\n$425.00\n5.5\n$2,337.50\n$2,337.50\n$425.00\n5.5\n$425.00\n8.0\n$3,400.00\n$425.00\n5.5\n$2,337.50\nTotal: 24.5 $ 10,412.50\n\nCos\n\nEX. A - Non Comp. TRAVEL\n\nEFTA02735044\n\n\f", "char_count": 392}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 86, "text_content": "Exhibit B\nNz\n\nEFTA02735045\n\n\f", "char_count": 29}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 87, "text_content": "Date\nEE\n07/15/2021 DW\n07/16/2021 DW\n07/17/2021 DW\n03/03/2022 DW\n03/04/2022 DW\n03/04/2022 OW\n03/04/2022 OW\n\nActivity Description\nExpense Gas\nExpense The Ben West Palm Beach, re: 7/16/21 hearing\n\nRate\n$42.02\n$557.46\n\nExpense\nExpense\nExpense\nExpense\nExpense\n\n$59.12\n$70.41\n$659.92\n$6.51\n$87.33\n\nGas\nGas\nHyatt Place West Palm Beach/Downtown, re: 3/4 hearing\nUber to Courthouse\nGas\n\nHours\n1.0\n1.0\n1.0\n1.0\n1.0\n1.0\n1.0\nTotal:\n\nLine Total\n$42.02\n$557.46\n$59.12\n$70.41\n$659.92\n$6.51\n$87.33\n1,482.77\n\n$\n\nA\n\ncos\n\nEX. B - Non Comp. COSTS\n\nEFTA02735046\n\n\f", "char_count": 542}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 88, "text_content": "EFTA02735047\n\n\f", "char_count": 15}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 89, "text_content": "Date\nEE\n11/05/2020 DW\n11/06/2020 DW\n\n11/09/2020 DW\n03/01/2022 DW\n03/08/2022 DW\n03/25/2022 OW\n\nActivity\nDraft\nDraft\n\nDescription\nDraft Amended Motion for Attorneys' Fees & Costs\nContinue drafting Motion for Attorneys' Fees & Costs and Affidavit of\nAttorneys Fees and Affidalvt of Reasonable Attorneys' Fees, sent to\nexpert for review\nVarious\nCall w/ expert, re: affidavit; Call w/ Client, re: filings; filed Motion &\nReview and reply to email from op. counsel, re: availability from 3/14 Various\n5/20; call w/ client call w/ expert\nVarious\nCall w/ Client, re: upcoming hearing, experts, plan; Meeting w/\nTeleconference Call to expert witness, re: fees, updated affidavits, hearing date\n\nC\n\nRate\n5425.00\n$42S.00\n\nHours\n3.0\n2.0\n\nLine Total\n$1,275.00\n5850.00\n\n5425.00\n5425.00\n\n1.0\n1.0\n\n5425.00\n$425.00\n\n1.0\n5425.00\n$425.00\n0.2\n7otaf~ &2 $\n\n$425.00\n585.00\n3,485.00\n\nO\n\nEX. C - Non Comp. FEE TIME\n\nEFTA02735048\n\n\f", "char_count": 907}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 90, "text_content": "Exhibttb\nA\n4\n\nEFTA02735049\n\n\f", "char_count": 29}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 91, "text_content": "Date\n11/26/2019\n11/26/2019\n12/06/2019\n01/24/2020\n\nEE\nDW\nOW\nDW\nDW\n\n01/24/2020\n06/03/2020\n06/23/2020\n07/01/2020\n\nDW\nDW\nDW\nDW\n\n08/18/2020\n\nDW\n\n09/18/2020\n\nOW\n\n09/22/2020\n\nDW\n\n10/14/2020\n\nDW\n\n10/21/2020\n\nOW\n\n11/09/2020\n\nDW\n\n12/03/2020\n\nDW\n\n12/10/2020\n07/23/2021\n\nOW\nDW\n\n07/23/2021\n07/29/2021\n08/12/2021\n\nOW\nDW\nDW\n\n09/13/2021\n\nDW\n\nActivity\nDraft\nReview\nDraft\nVarious\n\nDescription\nDrafted engagement letter and sent to client\nReviewed 15th circuit local rules\nCompleted final draft of motion to dismiss; filed with Court\nCompleted Answer/MTDismiss Amended Complaint; filed with Court;\nsent copy to Client\nDraft\nDrafted and filed Notice of Unavailability\nE-mail\nEmalled courtesy copies of Aronberg's Answer and MTDismiss to Judge\nE-mail\nSent client copy of Prs letter refusing to dismiss complaint\nVarious\nSpoke w/ client, re: filing of 57.105 motion for fees/sanctions; filed\nmotion for attorneys' fees based on PEs failure to voluntarily dismiss\namended complaint count 1\nDraft\nFinalized Motion for Summaryludgment; filed w/ court along with\nAronberg affidavit\nVarious\nDrafted and filed motion to set case management conference; re: MSJ\n1st or Fee hearing 1st\nvarious\nDrafted and filed Notice of Hearing on 10/15/20; set up Court Call;\nspoke w/ client, re: hearing date\nDraft\nFinalized and filed Response to Pi's Memo of Law\nDrafted and filed Motion to Set Hearing on Aronberg MSJ; dra\nVarious\nproposed order granting motion to set; checked court\nbility;\nemailed PI'S counsel. re: choose date for hearing\nVarious\n&\nCall w/ expert, re: affidavit; Call w/ Client, re: fill ; •Ion\nAffidavits\nDraft & File\nDraft and File Notice for Non-Jury Trial; e I t\n• e lh w/ opposing\ncounsel counsel to set meeting\nDraft & File\nDraft and File Amended Notice for\n.1 Tr\nen w/ AU to discuss; call to JA;\nVarious\nComplete and File Memo of law\no p\nunsel\ncall to Client; several emails\nTeleconference Call to Judge Hafale's JA, r\ning da\nemo of Law\nDraft & File\nComplete drafting and\nupdat\nVarious\nComplete draft of\nM o of Ow &\n... [truncated, 2616 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/91 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=91]", "char_count": 2616}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 92, "text_content": "EFTA02735051\n\n\f", "char_count": 15}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 93, "text_content": "Date\nEE\n10/21/2020 DW\n10/21/2020 DW\n10/21/2020 DW\n10/21/2020 DW\n10/21/2020 DW\n10/21/2020 OW\n10/21/2020 AU\n10/21/2020 DW\n\nActivity\nTelephone\nTelephone\n\nDescription\nSpoke w/ client, re: media response\nSpoke w/ client, re: media response\n\nTelephone\nTelephone\nTelephone\nE-mail\nMeeting\nMeeting\n\nSpoke w/ client, re: media response\nSpoke w/ client, re: media response\nSpoke w/ client, re: media response\nSent email w/ Aronberg statement to\nDiscussed media response w/ DAW\nDiscussed media response w/ ALI\n\nRate\n$425.00\n$425.00\n$425.00\n$425.00\n$425.00\n$425.00\n$475.00\n$425.00\nTotal:\n\nHours\n0.2\n0.1\n0.1\n0.1\n0.1\n0.1\n0.3\n0.3.\n\n4\n\nLine Total\n$85.00\n$42.50\n$42.50\n$42.50\n$42.50\n$42.50\n$142.50\n$127.50\n567.50\n\ncos\n\nEX. E - Non Comp. MEDIA\n\nEFTA02735052\n\n\f", "char_count": 741}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 94, "text_content": "Exhibit F\n\nEFTA02735053\n\n\f", "char_count": 26}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 95, "text_content": "Date\n10/15/2020\n10/15/2020\n10/15/2020\n10/15/2070\n10/16/2020\n10/16/2020\n10/16/2020\n10/16/2020\n10/19/2020\n10/19/2020\n10/19/2020\n10/19/2020\n10/20/2020\n\nEE\nDW\nDW\nAU\nDW\nOW\nDW\nDW\nAll\nDW\nOW\nAll\nDW\nDW\n\nActivity\nTelephone\nTelephone\nVarious\nMeeting\nTelephone\nTelephone\nMeeting\n\n10/20/2020\n10/20/2020\n10/20/2020\n10/20/2020\n10/20/2020\n\nDW\nDW\nDW\nDW\nAll\n\nTelephone\nTelephone\nTelephone\nMeeting\nMeeting\n\nMeeting\nTelephone\nTelephone\nMeeting\nMeeting\nVarious\n\nDescription\nSpoke w/ PI's counsel, re: settlement\nSpoke w/ client, re: Pi's settlement proposal\nDiscussed Pl's settlement proposal w/ DAW and then w/ Client\nDiscussed Pi's settlement proposal w/ All\nSpoke w/ PI's counsel, re: settlement\nSpoke w/ client, re: Plis settlement proposal\nDiscussed Plis settlement proposal w/ All\nDiscussed Plis settlement proposal w/ DAW\nSpoke w/ client, re: Pl's settlement proposal\nSpoke w/ Pl's counsel, re: settlement\nDiscussed Pl's settlement proposal w/ DAW\nDiscussed Pl's settlement proposal w/ All\nReviewed email from PI, re: settlement; sent copy to Client and\ncalled to discuss\nSpoke w/ client, re: settlement\nSpoke w/ Pl's counsel, re: settlement\nSpoke w/ client, re: settlement\nCl/\nDiscussed Pi's settlement proposal w/ All\nDiscussed Prs settlement proposal w/ DAW\nn\n\nRate\n$425.00\n$425.00\n$475.00\n$425.00\n5425.00\n$425.00\n$425.00\n$475.00\n$425.00\n$425.\n$47 .\nil k I\n4\n\n01\n\nHours\n0.1\n0.2\n0.4\n0.2\n0.2\n0.5\n0.2\n0.2\n\nLine Total\n$42.50\n\n0.2\n0.1\n\n$85.00\n$42.50\n\n0.2\n\n$95.00\n$85.00\n$212.50\n\n$85.00\n$190.00\n$85.00\n$85.00\n5212.50\n$85.00\n$95.00\n\n0.2\n0.5\n0.4\n\n25.00\n$425.00\n$425.00\n$475.00\nTotal:\n\n0.1\n0.1\n0.2\n0.2\n4.2 $\n\n$170.00\n$42.50\n$42.50\n$85.00\n595.00\n1,835.00\n\nEX. F - Non Comp. SETTLEMENT\n\nEFTA02735054\n\n\f", "char_count": 1680}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 96, "text_content": "Exhibit G\n\nEFTA02735055\n\n\f", "char_count": 26}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 97, "text_content": "Date\nEE\n11/26/2019 DW\n11/26/2019 DW\n11/26/2019 OW\n11/26/2019 DW\n11/26/2019 DW\n1126/2019 AU\n11/26/2019 AU\n1126/2019 DW_\n11/26/2019 AU\n12/02/2019 DW\n12/02/2019 OW\n12/02/2019 OW\n12/02/2019 All\n12/02/2019 AU\n12/03/2019 All\n12/03/2019 DW\n12/06/2019 DW\n12/06/2019 DW\n12/06/2019 DW\n12/06/2019 Al)\n12/06/2019 Al)\n12/13/2019 DW\n01/16/2020 DW\n01/16/2020 DW\n01/17/2020 DW\n01/17/2020 DW\n01/17/2020 DW\n01/20/2020 II\n01/71/7070 OW\n01/21/2010 DW\n01/21/2020 DW\n01/21/2020 Al)\n01/21/2020 DW\n01/22/2020 OW\n01/22/2020 OW\n01/23/2020 OW\n01/24/2020 DW\n01/24/2020\n01/24/2020\n01/27/1020\n02/03/2020\n02/03/2020\n03/13/2020\n03/13/2020\n03/18/2020\n03/18/2020\n03/18/2020\n03/19/2020\n03/20/2020\n04/21/2020\n04/21/2020\n04/21/2020\n05/22/2020\n05/22/2020\n05/27/2020\n05/27/2020\n05/28/2020\n05/29/2020\n06/01/2020\n06/02/2020\n06/02/2020\n06/03/2020\n06/03/2020\n06/03/2020\n\nDW\nAl)\nOW\nOW\nDW\nOW\nAl)\nDW\nOW\nOW\nDW\nDW\nD\nDW\nAl)\nDW\nOW\nOW\nDW\nDW\nDW\nOW\nDW\nDW\nOW\nOW\nOW\n\nActivity\nDescription\nReview\nInitial review of summons and complaint.\nReview\nReviewed motion for pro hac vice and Judge Hafele order granting\nTeleconference\nTeleconference w/ Client, re: response to lawsuit\nDrafted engagement letter and sent to client\nDraft\nReview\nReviewed 15th circuit local rules\nInitial review of complaint\nReview\nMeeting w/ DAW to discuss lawsuit and strategy\nMeeting\nMeeting__\nMeeting w/\nto discuss lawsuit and strategy\nTeleconference\nTeleconference w/ Client, re: response to lawsuit\nResearch & Preparation Research and prep for Motion to dismiss\nDraft\n1st Draft motion to dismiss\nTeleconference w/ Client, re: draft motion to dismiss\nTeleconference\nReview\nReviewed 1st Draft MTDIvniss\nTeleconference\nTeleconference w/ client, re: draft motion to dismiss\nMeeting w/ DAW, re: motion to dismiss\nMeeting\nMeeting\nMeeting w/ All, re: MTDismiss\nDraft\nCompleted final draft of motion to dismiss; filed with Court\nTeleconference\nSpoke w/ client, re: final draft of motion to dismiss\nTeleconference\nSpoke with Clerk's attorney, re: response\nReview\nReviewed final draft MTDism\n... [truncated, 5802 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/97 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=97]", "char_count": 5802}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 98, "text_content": "Date\n06/03/2020\n06/03/2020\n06/03/2020\n06/08/2020\n06/08/2020\n06/08/2020\n\nEE\nDW\nAll\nAl)\nOW\nDW\nOW\n\n06/08/2020\n06/08/2020\n06/08/2020\n06/10/2020\n\nAll\nOW\nAll\nDW\n\n06/23/2020\n\nOW\n\n06/23/2020\n06/23/2020\n07/01/2020\n\nDW\nAll\nDW\n\n07/02/2020\n07/08/2020\n07/08/2020\n07/10/2020\n07/10/2020\n07/10/2020\n07/13/2020\n07/13/2020\n07/27/2020\n07/27/2020\n07/28/2020\n07/29/2020\n07/29/2020\n07/30/2020\n07/30/2020\n08/05/2020\n08/07/2020\n\nDW\nDW\nAll\nOW\nAll\nOW\nOW\nDW\nOW\nOW\nOW\nDW\nDW\nOW\nOW\nOW\nOW\n\n08/10/2020\n08/17/2020\n08/17/2020\n08/18/2020\n08/27/2020\n09 01/2020\n09/021E020\n09/02/7020\n\nOW\nDW\nAl)\nDW\nDW\nDW\nOW\nOW\n\n09/02/2020\n09/02/2020\n09/16/2020\n\nAll\nOW\nOW\n\n09/17/2020\n09/17/2020\n09/18/2020\n\nD\nAl)\nOW\n\n09/18/2020\n\nOW\n\n09/18/2020\n09/18/2020\n\nOW\nDW\n\n09/18/2020\n09/22/2020\n\nOW\nOW\n\n10/02/2020\n\nOW\n\nDescription\nT Rate\nReviewed response from Client and replied\n5425.00\nAttended MTDismiss hearing via Zoom\n5475.00\nReviewed order granting MTDismIss w/ prejudice\n5475.00\nReviewed Court's Order Granting Defendants MTDiSmiss Count II w/ Prejudice\n$425.00\nShared order w/ Client and spoke w/. re: result and plan going forward, re:\n$425.00\nResearched § 57.105 Fla. Stat.; drafted 57.105 demand letter and proposed\n$425.00\nmotion for attorneys fees/sanctions; Served Pl's counsel with demand letter and\nProposed motion.\nMeeting\nMeeting w/ DAW, re: Order & 57.105\n$4750f)\nMeeting\nMeeting w/ All, re: Order & 57.105\n$425.00\nReview\nReviewed 57.105 demand and proposed motion for sanction\n5475.00\nVarious\nReviewed notice of change of attorney, re: Clerk; called and spoke w/ new\n$4\ncounsel Cynthia Guerra\nVarious\nReviewed PI% letter refusing to voluntarily dismiss amended complaint despite\n57.105 demand; called and spoke w/ client, re: PI% refusal & next steps\nE-mail\nSent client copy of Pl's letter relusing to dismiss complaint\n25.00\nReview\nReviewed PI% letter refusing to dismiss Count I/Am. Compl.\n75.00\nSpoke w/ client, re: filing of 57.105 motion for fees/sanctions; filed mots n for\nVarious\n425.00\nattorneys fees based on Pl's failure to voluntar\n... [truncated, 5490 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/98 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=98]", "char_count": 5490}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 99, "text_content": "Date\n10/02/2020\n\nEE\nDW\n\nActivity\nReview\n\n10/02/2020\n10/02/2020\n10/12/2020\n10/13/2020\n10/13/2020\n10/13/2020\n10 13 2020\n10/14/2020\n10/14/2020\n10/14/2020\n\nAU\nAll\nOW\nOW\nOW\nOW\nAU\nOW\nOW\nOW\n\nReview\nReview\nResearch\nResearch & nnalwe\nDraft\nMeeting\nvarious\nDraft\nTelephone\nTelephone\n\nDescription\nReviewed Pl's Response to Aronberg's request to schedule 57.105 motion for fees\nafter MS1\nReviewed Pl's Memo of Law opposing 57.105 motion\nReviewed Pis Response to Aronberg's request to schedule 57.105 motion after\nResearch caselaw & statutes, re: response to Prs Memo of Law\nContinued researching caselaw, re: response to Pl's memo Of law\nCreated 1st draft of Response to Pl's Memo of Law and shared w/ Client\nDiscussed w/ All caselaw and draft response to memo\nReviewed draft MS1, discussed draft w/ DAW and caselaw\nFinalized and filed Response to Pis Memo of Law\nSpoke w/ client, re: memo of law\nSpoke w/ client again, re: response to memo of law\n\ntine Total\n5212.50\n\nRate\n$425.00\n\nHours\n0.5\n\n$475.00\n$475.00\n$425.00\n$425.00\n$425.00\n$425.00\n$475.00\n$425.00\n$42500\n$4251W\n\n$237.50\n0.5\n0.4\n$190.00\n1.0\n$425.00\n1.0\n5425.00\n4.0\n51.700.00\n$212.50\n0.5\n0.7\n$332.50\n$425.00\n1.0\n0.2\n585.00\n0.1\n$42.50\n63.6 $ 27,$60.00\n\ncos\n\nEX. G - Non Comp. (cat 10.14.20\n\nEFTA02735058\n\n\f", "char_count": 1252}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 100, "text_content": "Exhibit H\n\nEFTA02735059\n\n\f", "char_count": 26}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 101, "text_content": "Date\nFE\nDescription\nActivity\n11/26/2019 OW\nReview\nInitial review of summons and complaint.\n11/26/2019 DW\nReview\nReviewed MOHOn for pro hac vice and Judge Hafele• order granting\n11/26/2019 DW\nTeleconference\nTeleconference w/ Client, re: response to lawsuit\n11/26/2019 OW\nDrafted engagement letter and sent to client\nDraft\n11/26/2019 OW\nReview\nReviewed 15th circuit local rules\nInitial review of complaint\n11/26/2019 All\nReview\n11/26/2019 411\nMeeting\nMeeting w/ DAW to discuss lawsuit and strategy\n11/26/2019 OW\nMeeting\nMeeting w/ All to discuss lawsuit and strategy\n11/26/2019 AU\nTeleconference\nTeleconference w/ Client, re: response to lawsuit\nResearch & Preparation Research and prep for Motion to dismiss\n12/02/2019 OW\n12/02/2019 DW\nDraft\nist Draft motion to dismiss\nTeleconference\nTeleconference w/ Client, re: draft motion to dismiss\n12/02/2019 DW\n12/02/2019 AU\nReview\nReviewed 1st Draft MTDismiss\n12/02/2019 AU\nTeleconference\nTeleconference w/ client, re: draft motion to dismiss\n12/03/2019 All\nMeeting\nMeeting w/ DAW, re: motion to dismiss\n12/03/2019 DW\nMeeting\nMeeting w/ All, re: MTDismiss\n12/06/2019 DW\nDraft\nCompleted final draft of motion to dismiss; filed with Court\nSpoke w/ client, re: final draft of motion to dismiss\n12/06/2019 DW\nTeleconference\n12/06/2019 DW\nTeleconference\nSpoke with Clerk's attorney, re: response\n12/06/2019 AU\nReview\nReviewed final draft MTDismiss\n12/06/2019 AU\nReview\nReviewed Clerk's MTDismiss\n12/13/2019 DW\nReview\nReviewed Clerk's Motion to Dismiss\n01/16/2020 DW\nReview\nReviewed Order Setting Hearing on Detention M is\n01/16/2020 DW\nReview\nReviewed motion for pro hac vice\n01/17/2020 DW\nReview\nReviewed Prs Amended Complaint\nTeleconference\nSpoke with client, re: Amended Co\n01/17/2020 DW\nI\nReview\nReviewed Prs notice of filing\n01/17/2020 DW\n01/20/2020 All\nReview\nReviewed Prs Am. Compl\n01/21/2020 DW\nReview\nReviewed Judge Marx's\nCance\nTDIsmiss Hearing\n01/21/2020 OW\nReview\nReviewed Prs Objection t De\nants' MTDismiss\n01/21/2020 DW\nSpoke with client, r\nTeleconf\n... [truncated, 5210 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/101 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=101]", "char_count": 5210}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 102, "text_content": "EE\nDate\n06/01/2020 DW\n06/02/2020 OW\n06/02/2020 DW\n06/03/2020 OW\n06/03/2020 DW\n06/03/2020 DW\n06/03/2020 DW\n06/03/2020 Ail\n06/03/2020 All\n06/08/2020 DW\n06/08/2020 DW\n06/08/2020 DW\n\nActivity\nE-mail\nVarious\nE-mail\nAttend Hearing\nTeleconference\nE-mail\nE-mail\nAttend Hearing\nReview\nReview\nVarious\nVarious\n\n06/08/2020\n06/08/2020\n06/08/2020\n06/10/2020\n\nAU\nDW\nAU\nDW\n\nMeeting\nMeeting\nReview\nVarious\n\n06/23/2020 DW\n\nVarious\n\n06/23/2020 DW\n06/23/2020 All\n07/01/2020 DW\n\nE-mail\nReview\nVarious\n\nDescription\nReviewed email from Judge MareslA and responded\nReviewed Prs 500. page binder, re: MTDismiss & prepped for bearing\nDrafted and sent email to client, re: MTO hearing tomorrow\nPrepped for and attended MTDismiss hearing via Zoom\nSpoke w/ Client, re: debrief MTDismiss hearing\nEmaded courtesy copies of Aronberes Answer and MTDismiss to Judge Marx\nReviewed response from Client and replied\nAttended MTDismiss hearing via Zoom\nReviewed order granting MTOismtss w/ prejudice\nReviewed Court's Order Granting Defendants MTDismiss Count II w/ Prejudice\nShared Order w/ Client and spoke w/, re: result and plan going foment re:\nResearched § 57.105 Fla. Stet; drafted 57.105 demand letter and proposed\nmotion for attorneys' fees/sanctions; Served Prs counsel with demand letter\nand proposed motion.\nMeeting w/ DAW, re: Order & 57.105\nMeeting w/ Alt re: Order & 57.105\nReviewed 57.105 demand and proposed motion for sanction\ns\nReviewed notice of change of attorney, re: Clerk; called and spo V7.. n\ncounsel Cynthia Guerra\nn\nReviewed Prs letter refusing to voluntarily dismiss amended co\ndespite 57.105 demand; called and spoke w/ client, re'\nusal & next\nSent client copy of Prs letter refusing to dismiss co aint\nI.\nReviewed Prs letter refusing to dismiss Count V\nes n i s; filed motion for\nSpoke w/ client, re: filing of 57.105 motion f\nattorneys' fees based on Prs failure to voiukan ism amended complaint\ncount 1\n..a.\n\nRate\n$425.00\n$425.00\n$425.00\n$425.00\n$425.00\n$425.00\n5425.00\n5475.00\n$475.00\n5425.00\n$42 .\n.\n\nHou\n... [truncated, 2394 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734959/102 or ?id=EFTA02734959&page=102]", "char_count": 2394}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 103, "text_content": "EFTA02735062\n\n\f", "char_count": 15}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734959", "page_number": 104, "text_content": "Date\n03/25/2021\n10/01/2021\n10/05/2021\n10/05/2021\n11/02/2021\n11/05/2021\n12/20/2021\n\nEE\nDW\nDW\nDW\nDW\nDW\nDW\nOW\n\nActivity\nReview\nReview & Analyze\nReview & Analyze\nReview & Analyze\nE-mail\nE-mail\nVarious\n\n12/20/2021\n12/21/2021\n01/04/2022\n01/04/2022\n01/12/2022\n01/19/2022\n01/26/2022\n01/26/2022\n01/27/2022\n01/28/2022\n03/10/2022\n03/30/2022\n\nAU\nDW\nOW\nOW\nDW\nDW\nDW\nDW\nOW\nOW\nDW\nDW\n\nMeeting\nE-mail\nReview\nReview\nE-mail\nReview & Analyze\nReview\nE-mail\nReview\nReview\nE-mail\nReview\n\nDescription\nReview Notice of Change of Counsel\nReview Clerk's response to MS1\nReview Order, re: MSJ hearing on 10/22/21\nReview PI'S Reply in support of MSJ\nReviewed several emalls b/w opposing counsel\nReviewed several entails b/w opposing counsel\nReview & Analyze Final Judgment in favor of Clerk, meeting w/\nAU, call client to discuss\nMeeting w/ DAW, re: MSI Order\nReview email from Op. Counsel\nReview Clerk's Motion to Amend Final Judgment\nReviewed Clerk's Notice of Appearance\nReviewed and replied to email from Op. Counsel\nReviewed and replied to email from Op. Counsel\nReview Notice of Withdrawing Motion to Amend PI\nEmailed Clerk's Motion for Sanctions to Client\nReview N's Notice of Appeal\nReviewed 40CA Order, re: abeyance\nReviewed and replied to email form Clerk's counsel\nReview Motion to Withdraw\n/ 1.11‘\n\nRate\n5425.00\n$425.00\n5425.00\n$425.00\n$425.00\n5425.00\n$425.00\n\nHours\n0.1\n0.5\n0.1\n0.5\n0.2\n0.2\n1.5\n\nline Total\n$42.50\n$212.50\n$42.50\n$212.50\n585.00\n$85.00\n$637.50\n\n$475.00\n$425.00\n$425.00\n$425.\n542 s. •\n$4 - 71\n, ,\nI\n•\nII\n$425.00\n$425.00\n5425.00\nTotal:\n\n0.5\n.1\n.1\n1\n0.\n0.5\n0.1\n0.1\n0.1\n0.1\n0.2\n0.1\n5.3\n\n$237.50\n$42.50\n$42.50\n542.50\n$85.00\n$212.50\n$42.50\n542.50\n$42.50\n$42.50\n585.00\n542.50\n2,277.50\n\nEX. I - Non Comp. CLERK\n\nEFTA02735063\n\n\f", "char_count": 1716}]}