{"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_count": 279, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02734651", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02734651.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Filing # 158593126 E-Filed 10/04/2022 05:27:21 PM\n\nIN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE\nFIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND\nFOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA\nCA FLORIDA HOLDINGS, LLC,\nPublisher of THE PALM BEACHPOST,\n\nCASE NO.: 50-2019-CA-01468 I -XXXX-MB\nDIVISION: AG\n\nPlaintiff,\nv.\nDAVE ARONBERG, as State Attorney of\nPalm Beach County, Florida; SHARON R.\nBOCK, as Clerk and Comptroller of Palm\nBeach County, Florida.\n\no\nG\n\nDefendants.\n\nSEPTEMBER 8. 2022\nEEDINGS\n\nJOINT NOTICE OF FILING SEPTEMBER\nOF HEAR\n\n2\n\nPlaintiff, CA Florida Holdings, LLC( cc\n\" \\aof i\n\n, publisher of The Palm Beach Post, and\n\nDefendant, Dave Aronberg, as State\n\ney\n\n(collectively, the \"Parties\"), by\n\nundersigned counsel, and pursuant to the Court's\n\nt\n\ninstructions at the conclusion\nSeptember 6 and Septem\nAttorneys' Fees. (S\nRespectful!\n\nPalm Beach County, Florida (\"Defendant\")\n\nearing, hereby files the attached transcripts from the\n\nr 2022 hearing proceedings on Defendant's Amended Motion for\n\n,t\n\nSued,\n\nIs/ Laure hetstone\nLAUREN WHETSTONE\nFlorida Bar No. 45192\nMARK F. BIDEAU\nFlorida Bar No. 564044\nGREENBERG TRAURIG, P.A.\n777 South Flagler Drive, Suite 300 East\nWest Palm Beach, FL 33401\n\n*** FILED: PALM BEACH COUNTY, FL\n\nIilDou Las A. W\nARTHUR I.\nFlorida Bar No. 10249\nRICHARD J. SCHOLZ\nFlorida Bar No. 0021261\nDOUGLAS A. WYLER\nFlorida Bar No. 119979\nSCNOLZ & WYLER, LLC\n961687 Gateway Blvd., Suite 201-I\n\nABRUZZO, CLERK. 10/04/2022 05:27:21 PM ***\nEFTA02734651\n\n\f\n\n[═══ TRANSCRIPT ═══]\nCERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and accurate copy of the foregoing has been electronically filed with the Florida E-File Portal for e-service on all parties of record herein on this 4th day of October, 2022. Is/ Lauren Whetstone Lauren Whetstone  O  3  EFTA02734653", "char_count": 1746}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Tel.: 561.650.7900\nwhetstonel@gtlaw.com\nbideaumagtlaw.com\nsandra.famadasAztlaw.com\nthomasd@gtlaw.com\nFLService@gtlaw.com\n\nFernandina Beach, FL 32034\nTel.: 904.261.3693\niacobsscholzlawecomcast.net\nCounselfor Defendant Dave Aronberg, as\nState Attorneyfor Palm Beach County,\nFlorida\n\nSTEPHEN A. MENDELSOHN\nFlorida Bar No. 849324\nGREENBERG TRAURIG, P.A.\n401 East Las Olas Boulevard, Suite 2000\nFort Lauderdale, FL 33301\nTel.: 954.768.8225\nmendelsohns@gtlaw.com\nsmithl®gtlaw.com\n\nA\nCo's\n\nMICHAEL .1. GRYGIEL\n(Admitted Pro Hac Vice)\nGREENBERG TRAURIG, LLP\n54 State Street, 6th Floor\nAlbany, NY 12207\nTel.: 518.689.1400\ngrvizielmAgtlaw.coin\nNINA D. BOYAJIAN\n(Admitted Pro Hac Vice)\nGREENBERG TRAURIG, LLP\n1840 Century Park East, Suite\nLos Angeles, CA 90067\nTel.: 310.586.7700\nbovaiiannQatlaw.com \\ t ile\nriveraal\nlaw.co\nCounselfor P\nPublisher o\n\n'se\n\nFlorida Holdings, LLC,\nlm Beach Post\n\n'\n\n2\n\nEFTA02734652\n\n\f", "char_count": 903}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\nI HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and accurate copy of the foregoing has been\nelectronically filed with the Florida E-File Portal for e-service on all parties of record herein on\nthis 4th day of October, 2022.\nIs/ Lauren Whetstone\nLauren Whetstone\n\nO\n\n3\n\nEFTA02734653\n\n\f", "char_count": 288}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "CA Florida Holdings, L.L.C.\n\nvs.\n\nHearing B\nJudge L\nSep\n\n461Ar\n\noN\nC\n\nDave Aronberg\n\ngado\n06, 2022\n\nEFTA02734654\n\n\f", "char_count": 115}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\nIN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT\nIN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA\nCASE NO. 50-2019-CA-014681-XXXX-MB AG\n\nCA FLORIDA HOLDINGS, LLC,\nPublisher of the PALM BEACH POST,\nPlaintiff,\nVS.\n\ncos\n\nDAVE ARONBERG, as State Attorney\nof Palm Beach County, Florida;\nSHARON R. BOCK, as Clerk and\nComptroller of Palm Beach County,\nFlorida,\nDefendants.\n\nTRANSCRIP\nPROC\nRE: Defendant\nAttorneys' Fe\n\n? Sv\nARING\nnberg's Amended Motion for\n\nSS\n\nDAT\nT\n\n*\n\nKEN: Tuesday, September 6, 2022\n1:42 p.m. - 4:53 p.m.\nPALM BEACH COUNTY COURTHOUSE\n205 North Dixie Highway\nCourtroom 10D\nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33401\nEFORE:\nLUIS DELGADO, JR., Circuit Judge\n\nStenographically reported by:\nLisa Begley, RPR, RMR\n270569\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734655\n\n\f", "char_count": 801}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 2\n\n1\n\nAPPEARANCES:\n\n2\n\nOn behalf of the Plaintiff:\nGREENBERG TRAURIG\n777 South Flagler Drive\nSuite 300 East\nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33401\n561-650-6420\nBY: LAUREN R. WHETSTONE, ESQ.\nwhetstonel@gtlaw.com\nMARK F. BIDEAU, ESQ.\nbideaum@gtlaw.com\nGERARD BUITRAGO, ESQ.\nbuitragog@gtlaw.com\n\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n\nOn behalf of Defendant, Dave Aronberg:\nJACOB, SCHOLZ & WYLER, LLC\n961687 Gateway Boulevard\n10\nSuite 2011\nFernandina Beach, Florida 3203x.\n11\n904-261-3693\nBY: DOUGLAS A. WYLER,\n12\ndoug@jswflorida.com\n9\n\n13\n\nAlso present: Dave Aro\nDefendant\n\nate Attorney\n\n14\n15\n16\n\nC /C)*\n\n17\n18\n19 AS\n\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734656\n\n\f", "char_count": 694}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 3\n1\n\nINDEX\n\n2\n3\n4\n\nPAGE\nOpening Statement\nBy Mr. Wyler\nBy Ms. Whetstone\n\n4\n23\n\n5\nWITNESS\n6\nDAVID ARONBERG, STATE ATTORNEY\n7\nDirect Examination by Mr. Wyler\n43\nCross Examination by Mr. Bideau\n63\n8\nRedirect Examination by Mr. Wyler\n9\n9\n\nSTEPHEN MENDELSOHN, ESQ.\nDirect Examination by Ms. Whetstone\n\n4\n1\nO\n\n10\n11\n\nDefense Rests\n\n12\n\na\n\nA\\\n\n13\nEXHIBITS ENTE\n\nEVIDENCE\n\n14\nJoint Exhibits 1 - 37\n\n95\n\n17\n\nCertificat\n\n141\n\n18\n\nO\n\n15\n16\n\n19\n\nf Reporter\n\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734657\n\n\f", "char_count": 557}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 4\n\n1 Thereupon,\n2 the following proceedings began at 1:42 p.m.:\n3\n\nTHE COURT: All right, please be seated.\n\n4\n\nAll right, so we're here on the amended\n\n5\n\nmotion for attorneys' fees.\n\n6\n\nLet's announce appearances.\n\n7\n\nMS. WHETSTONE: Good afternoon, Your Honor,\n\n8\n\nLauren Whetstone. With me is Mark Bideau an\n\n9\n\nGerard Buitrago and our paralegal, Jennifer\n\n10\n\nThomson, from Greenberg Traurig on\n\n11\n\nFlorida Holdings, the publisher o\n\n12\n\nPost.\n\n13\n\nMR. WYLER: Goot\n\nha if CA\nBeach\n\nn, Your Honor. My\n\n14\n\nname's Douglas\n\n. I' here on behalf of\n\n15\n\ndefendant, D\n\nerg.\n\n16\n\nMR. A\n\n17\n\nAronb\n\nG: State Attorney Dave\nour Honor.\n\n18\n\n11,TH COURT: Thank you very much. It's your\n\n19\n\non.\n\nOn.\n\nMR. WYLER: Thank you, Your Honor. May I\n\napproach?\n22\n\nTHE COURT: (Nods head up and down.)\n\n23\n\nMR. WYLER: Hi, again, Your Honor. Thank\n\n24\n\nyou. May it please the Court. As you know, we're\n\n25\n\nhere today on Mr. Aronberg's amended motion for\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734658\n\n\f", "char_count": 1034}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 5\n\n1 attorney's fees. It was filed on November 9th,\n2 2020, in conjunction with his 57.105 demand that\n3 was made to the plaintiffs on June 8th, 2020.\n4\n\nThat demand letter that was sent to the\n\n5 plaintiffs counsel was sent on the same day that\n6 Judge Marx entered her order granting the\n7 defendant's motion to dismiss Count 2 of this case\n8 with prejudice. And that motion, that 57.105\n9 demand letter asserted that the plaintiffs so\n10 remaining count for declaratory actio Qy o\n11 basis in fact or law pursuant to 5\n\ne0\n\n12\n\noted in\n\nTheir declaratory relief cis\n\n13 Chapter 905.27 Florida\n\nat governs the\n\n14 exceptions for the rei( +c .....e\ne o grand jury -- grand\n15 jury materials.\nIn our 57. 05 I ffer, we specifically told\n\n16\n\n17 the plaint\n\nhat, under 57.105(1)(a), their\n\n18 dec\n\nelief claim is unsupported by the\n\n19\n\n< ri facts necessary to establish it and also,\n\n2\n\nr 57.105(1)(b), that their declaratory relief\n\n2\n\nclaim is unsupported by the application of the law\n\n22 to those material facts:\n23\n\nThere's a case,\n\nv. Bailynson, it's\n\n24 found at 268 So.3d 762. It's a Fourth DCA case\n25 from 2019.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734659\n\n\f", "char_count": 1219}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 6\n\n1\n\nTHE COURT: Give me that cite one more\n\n2 time.\n3\n\nMR. WYLER: Yes, sir. It's\n\nv.\n\n4 Bailynson, B-a-i-I-y-n-s-o-n, 268 So.3d 762. It's\n5 a Fourth DCA 2019. That case says, The central\n6 purpose of 57.105 Florida Statute is and always\n7 has been to deter meritless filings and, thus,\n8 streamline the administration and the proced\n9 the courts. Thus, the post-1999 version of t\n10 -- 57.105 has expanded the circumst•\n11 fees should be awarded and the\n\nwhere\nis to defer\n\n12 meritless filings.\n13\n\n57.105 -- The statut\n\nprovides the\n\n14 following language\n\nrim g the award of\n\n15 attorneys' fees s\n\nthe present litigation.\n\n16 It says, \"Upo\n17 any partylc\n18 atto\n\nhe\n\nurt's initiative or motion of\n\njrCourt shall award a reasonable\n\ny's r,e including prejudgment interest, to\n\n19\n\ni\n\no the prevailing party in equal amounts\n\n2\n\ne losing party and the losing party's\n\n2\n\nattorney on any claim or defense at any time\n\n22 during a civil proceeding or action in which the\n23 Court finds that the losing party or the losing\n24 party's attorney knew or should have known that a\n25 claim or defense, when initially presented to the\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734660\n\n\f", "char_count": 1227}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 7\n\n1 Court or at any time before trial, was not\n2 supported by the material facts necessary to\n3 establish the claim or defense, or would not be\n4 supported by the application of then existing law\n5 to those material facts.\"\n6\n\nSo, notably, the statute includes a lot of\n\n7 key words in there, but here, the key words that\n8 I'm focusing on is \"knew or should have know .\n9\n\nHere, the plaintiff had a due diligence\n\n10 obligation to know what the law was\n\ny\n\n11 filed the lawsuit. They should h.\n\nthe\n\npik\n\n12 ultimate facts of the case all\n13 should have known the\n14 obtaining the record\n15\n\nNonetheles\n\n16 multiple times\n\ne\n\nd they\nal mechanism for\n\nt th y were seeking.\n'\n\nnformed the plaintiff\nout this case that not --\n\n17 that Mr. la ir\nberg is an improper party, not only\n18 -- b IS use\nof only is it impossible for him to\n.,\n19\n\nthe requested records since he has no\n\n2\n\nession, custody or control over them, but also\n\n2\n\nbecause the statutes that govern the disclosure of\n\n22 grand jury records clearly and unambiguously do\n23 not grant such authority or power to the state\n24 attorney.\n25\n\nAnother case for you is Trust Mortgage,\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734661\n\n\f", "char_count": 1239}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 8\n\n1 LLC, v. Ferlanti. That's found at 193 So.3d 997.\n2 That's also a Fourth DCA case from 2016. And it\n3 can guide the Court here. This case says that, in\n4 determining an award of sanctions under\n5 Section 57.105, the trial court's findings must be\n6 based on substantial competent evidence and the\n7 trial court must make an inquiry into what the\n8 losing party knew or should have known durin ii..,0\n9 fact establishment process both before and\n\ne)\n\n10 the suit was filed.\n11\n\nSo, as to the 57.105(1)(a) cl, i1(•,)\ntm.‘\n\n12 Mr. Aronberg's position is th\n13 should have known whe\n14 research that it was\n15 no access, cust\n16 but that fact -\n\ne\n\nspaper\nre doing their\nsibility, that he had\n\nntrol of these records,\nbr\n\nt line was drawn to that\n\n17 fact by JurtikrMarx in the June 3rd, 2020, motion\n18 to 6 sss\ni t earing. She made several statements\n4n\n19\n\ntaiTu he plaintiff on notice, if they weren't\n\n2\n\nready.\n\n2\n\nAnd, if it would please the Court, I would\n\n22 like to read those onto the record. You can find\n23 these -- We've submitted a joint binder to you,\n24 and if you -- -25\n\nTHE COURT: I have it here. Tell me where\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734662\n\n\f", "char_count": 1229}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 9\n\n1 I'm looking.\n2\n\nMR. WYLER: Yes, sir. If you look at J13,\n\n3 that's the condensed version of the transcript.\n4 You can find the full version if you look at J29,\n5 and I can give you the =\n6\n\nstamp numbers.\n\nTHE COURT: Tell me where to look, and I'll\n\n7 look.\n8\n\nMR. WYLER: Absolutely, Your Honor. L cCI)\n\n9 at =\n\nstamp 1353, and that will start you\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT: Of what exhibit?\n\n11\n\nMR. WYLER: Okay, Exhibit\n\n12 version. I thought that mightAt\n\ncull\nr for you\n\n13 to read it. At 1353.\n\n(S \\\n\n14\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nsai pJ29.\n\n15\n\nMR. WYLE\n\n, J29, and, if you look in\n\n16 the lower left\n17 says CA,\n18 sta?\n\nnumber that\n\nph, Aronberg, and you'll see the -\n\nnu\n,E bers.\n\n19 CS1\n2\n\n'there's a\n\nCOURT: What's the number?\n\nR. WYLER: 1353.\n\n2\n\nTHE COURT: Go ahead.\n\n22\n\nMR. WYLER: Thank you, Your Honor. I'm\n\n23 going to go through this transcript, and I'll\n24 direct you to the actual page number of the\n25 transcript itself, okay? Page 3, lines 18 -- 4\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734663\n\n\f", "char_count": 1048}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 10\n\n1 through 1. \"Not for nothing\" -- This is all Judge\n2 Marx. \"Not for nothing, I think we all know that\n3 they don't have control and custody of the\n4 records.\"\nPage 5, lines 17 through 19. \"I think we\n\n5\n\n6 can all agree that the state attorney doesn't have\n\nA.„,„ _\n\n7 these records.\"\n8\n\nPage 8, line 4. \"I'm asking you, how are\n\n'S .'\n\n9 the clerk and the state attorney the proper\n10 defendants?\"\n11\n\nPage 8, line 8. \"I'm puzzled\n\nc\n\n12 procedural posturing of this\n\nn ning the state\n\n13 attorney, and, you knower\n\nstymied by\n\n14 the fact that you alleclt....,\nyo r complaint that\n15 they have, parti\n\ny\n\n16 attorney, that\n\nthese records.\"\n\n17\n\nPag\n\nvid Aronberg, the state\n\nine 18. \"Okay, let's run this all\n\n18 the\n\ny o . Let's say you win and you get a\n\n19 •\n\nt against the state attorney, Dave\n\n2'\n\nberg. What's he supposed to do with it? He\n\n2\n\ncan't release the grand jury testimony. He has no\n\n22 authority whatsoever to do that.\"\n23\n\nPage 10, line 21. \"And the only thing\n\n24 we're here today about is why should the clerk and\n25 the state attorney have to defend a civil action\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734664\n\n\f", "char_count": 1192}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 11\n\n1 when it's an impossibility of performance? They\n2 even -- If you were to win and get a judgment\n3 against them, they cannot give you what they don't\n4 have.\"\nPage 11, line 12. \"I'm simply saying, why\n\n5\n\n6 should these two entities have to defend this\n7 lawsuit when, even down the road, if you win, the AS\n8 can't give you what they don't have?\"\n9\n\nPage 16, line 12. \"And, you know, reall\n\n10 I want to you boil it down for me as t\n11 Let's take it all the way down the\n12 You get a judgment against tl\n\nle\n\nou win.\nand the state\n\n13 attorney. I know there's ic e\nsons why you\n/\n14 might have filed it th'\ny, ut I'm just simply\n15 puzzled becaus\n16 state attorney re\n17 performa\n18 re\n\nr what the clerk and the\ning, and that is,\n\nis impossible. They don't have the\n\nan cannot, absolutely. There's not even\n\n19\n\nc\n\n2\n\nrds even if you got a judgment. It is solely\n\n2\n\nf wiggle room that they could release the\n\na determination for the Court. I frankly think\n\n22 you know there's ways to get your records.\n23 There's ways to get confidential records, but it\n24 isn't by suing the state attorney and the clerk.\"\n25\n\nPage 17, line 6. \"Even assuming, arguendo,\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734665\n\n\f", "char_count": 1260}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 12\n\n1\n\nthat they have the records, we know they don't.\n\n2 You were to -- If you were to get a judgment\n3 against them, how would you expect them to\n4 perform?\"\n5\n\nAnd then finally, on page 17, line 23.\n\n6 \"What do you mean? What do you mean? They're not\n7 trying to block it? They're saying that, despite\n8 the fact -- let's just talk about the clerk\n\n0\n\n9 because we all know the state attorney doe 't\n10 have it.\"\n11\n\nring\n\nI would ask the Court to ent\n\n12 transcript found at J29, 135\\\n\nas Defense's\n\n13 Exhibit No. 1.\n14\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n15\n\nMS. WHETS\n\ntion?\nI\n\nAll the joint exhibits are\n\n16 in evidence, s\n17\n\nMR. 1\n\nER: They're in evidence, but I\n\n18 don' no ' you wanted to mark them for each\n19\n\nn So if I don't need to do that, then I'll\n\n2\n\npense with that.\n\n2\n\nTHE COURT: These joint exhibits have all\n\n22 been stipulated to?\n23\n\nMR. WYLER: Yes.\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT: No need then.\n\n25\n\nMR. WYLER: Then I'll leave it alone.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734666\n\n\f", "char_count": 1024}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 13\n\n1 Thank you, Your Honor.\n2\n\nThese statements, along with the upcoming\n\n3 examination of Mr. Aronberg and Mr. Mendelsohn,\n4 along with everything that's presented to the\n5 Court, it shows that these sanctions are\n6 justified, and there is no arguable basis in fact\n7 or law the way those statutes are written that\n8 Mr. Aronberg could ever provide the requeste\n\nO\n\n9 materials that he was sued for.\n10\n\nAs to the 57.105(1)(b) argument,\n\n11 Mr. Aronberg's position here is t\n12 newspaper, plaintiffs and the'\n\nys, they\n\n13 should have also known( S h11,\n\nginning when they\n\n14 were doing their res\n15 precluded Mr. Ar\n\nh th t those statutes\nr\n\nrom actually providing\n\n16 these records Th s what they sued for. They\n17 asked for\n18 tha\n\nAronberg to provide these records so\n\ny could then be disclosed to the public.\n\n19\n\nh\n\n2\n\nthis -- this argument has been presented in\n\n2\n22\n\nter -- or, Statute 905.27 states this:\n\neverything that we've said to the newspaper.\n\"When such disclosure is ordered by a Court\n\n23 pursuant to subsection (1) for use in a civil\n24 case, it may be disclosed to all parties to the\n25 case and to their attorneys and by the latter to\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734667\n\n\f", "char_count": 1259}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 14\n\n1 their legal associates and employees. However,\n2 the grand jury testimony afforded such persons by\n3 the Court can only be used in the defense or\n4 prosecution of the civil or criminal case and for\n5 no other purpose whatsoever.\"\nThat argument was ultimately utilized in\n\n6\n\n7 Judge Hafele's final judgment in favor of the\n8 clerk because, on top of other things, the\n9 plaintiff admitted that they weren't seeking t\n10 use these requested records in an u\n\ng civil\n\n11 or criminal case. They wanted t\n\n— for\n\n12 public disclosure.\n13\n\nChapter 905.17 of ttS4 )cl statutes also\n\n14 applies here. This\n\nteen\n\nmade evident and\n\n15 very clear to the\n\ntj . That statute says,\n\n16 in pertinent p\n\ne notes\" -- and this is all\n\n17 regarding rand jury materials -- \"The notes,\n18 re\n19\n2\n2\n\nan transcriptions are confidential and\n\nC\n\np rom the provisions of Chapter 119.07 and\n\nilon 24(a), Article 1 of the State Constitution\n\nand shall be released by the clerk only on a\n\n22 request by a grand jury for use by the grand jury\n23 or on an order of the Court pursuant to\n24 Chapter 905.27.\"\n25\n\nSo, like I said, these legal arguments have\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734668\n\n\f", "char_count": 1231}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\nPage 15\n\n1 been presented to plaintiff and its lawyers\n2 several times. It was in the 57.105 demand\n3 letter, but plaintiff dropped Mr. Aronberg from\n4 the case too late. The statute had already taken\n5 effect. There's a 21-day safe-harbor provision in\n6 that statute. And the testimony and evidence\n7 today will show that a motion for attorneys' fees\n8 was filed appropriately with that statute, and\n\nsi\n\n'4\n\n1\n\n'\n\n9 then following that, Mr. Aronberg was droppc fr m\n10 the case. After that, an amended m\n\nr\n\n11 attorneys' fees was filed.\n12\n\nPlaintiff has an argumen\n\nto deal\n\n13 with the timing of when ?lc'Nt9\n,\nded motion for\n14 attorneys' fees was\n\n. T ey claim that we\n\n15 don't comply wit\n\nday safe-harbor\n\n16 provision, an\n\n-ep,7\n\n17 Lago v K\n18 K-a-\n\nse this case of Lago v Kame,\nBy Design. It's K-a-m, like Mary,\n\nB Design, LLC. That's found at 120 So.3d\n\n2\n\ne\n\n2\n\nsubsequent or amended motion for sanctions under\n\n19\n\nt t' also a Fourth DCA case from 2013.\no that case held that, if a party files a\n\n22 Section 57.105 and raises an argument that was not\n23 raised in the original motion for Section 57.105\n24 sanctions, then the subsequent motion must\n25 independently comply with the 21-day safe-harbor\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734669\n\n\f", "char_count": 1310}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 16\n\n1 provision.\n2\n\nOkay, but the facts are different, totally\n\n3 different.\n4\n\nSee, in the Lago case, the party who was\n\n5 served with the 57.105 demand never withdrew from\n6 the case. They stayed in the case to the end.\n7 The person that served the original 57.105 in\n8 Lago, after serving it, served a second one, a\n9 when they served the second 57.105 — well,\n10 didn't serve a second 57.105 deman•\n11 filed a second motion for attorne\\\n\nThey\n\nw a. an\n\nithout\ns(\n13 providing an additional I er, . 105 letter\n12 amended motion for attornek ,fc\n\n14 before they filed the\n\nndcTd motion. That didn't\n\n15 happen in this\n16\n\nIn this cad, w\n\niled our amended motion\n\n17 -- our ongc' 1,pmotion\n,\nfor attorneys' fees on\n18 Nov\n\nber7 th, 2020, and then they dropped\n\n19\n\nr\n\n2\n\n, we filed -- I'm sorry. I apologize, Your\n\n2\n\nberg from the case on October 21st --\n\nHonor. We filed our original motion for\n\n22 attorneys' fees on July 1, 2020. I apologize.\n23 They dropped Mr. Aronberg from the case on\n24 October 21, 2020, and then we filed our amended\n25 motion for attorneys' fees on November 9th, 2020.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734670\n\n\f", "char_count": 1196}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 17\n\n1\n\nSo the significant thing about this, Your\n\n2 Honor, is the 21-day safe-harbor provision is\n3 there to provide the -- provide an opportunity to\n4 reevaluate your position and change your position\n5 and withdraw your case based on the demands in the\n6 57.105.\nThere was no opportunity for the plaintiff\n\n7\n\n8 to reevaluate and change their position. The\n9 already made their mind up. They had acre\n10 dropped Mr. Aronberg from the case.\n11 or saying that we failed to provid\n12 safe-harbor provision, that is\n\ni\n\n13 Honor, because there w\n\ny asking\nday\n\nd1ng, Your\ny they could change\n\n14 their position with\n‘ca\"\n\n......,\nr demand letter sent to\n\n15 them. They had r\n\nmade their decision and\n\n16 dropped Mr.\n\nonb g from the case. It was\n\n17 impossib t\n\nroythem to change their position. So\n\n19\n\nposr\n\nligation to serve his amended motion\n\n2\n\nready dropped, and a previous motion for\n\n18 he\n\n2\n22\n\nno\n\nto ding with the Court because he was\n\nattorneys' fees was already filed.\nAnother interesting part of that Lago case\n\n23 is that, in that case, the Court did find that the\n24 amended motion was filed improperly because they\n25 were still in the case, but, instead, the Court\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734671\n\n\f", "char_count": 1280}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 18\n\n1 picked up the originally-filed motion for\n2 attorneys' fees in that case. And we would ask\n3 Your Honor, in the alternative, should you find\n4 that, that you would rule on our original motion\n5 for attorneys' fees if it came down to it because,\n6 in the end, the arguments are the same, and the\n7 real difference in the filing of the amended\n8 motion for attorneys' fees is that it included th O\n9 final tabulation of my firm's fees, as well as\n\nJ\n\n10 affidavits -- my affidavit of reasonabl\n11 fees and an affidavit of reasonab\n\nom our\n\n12 expert.\n13\n\nThe other interestinNp re, the other\n\n14 argument that you'll\n\nr p1 ntiff make is that\n\n15 Mr. Aronberg wash\n\ner party to the case. Now,\n\n16 again, the cle\n17 that has\n18 stat\n19\n\nc\n\nis\n\na person -- the only entity\n\nority to provide these records under\n\n,a\n, nlthat alone should be enough to show\nAronberg is not a proper party defendant.\n\n2\n\nJudge Hafele's final judgment actually helps\n\n2\n\nout this because Judge Hafele's final judgment\n\n22 actually instructed plaintiff on the right way to\n23 go about trying to get the records that they were\n24 seeking. It points out that they followed -25 failed to follow the right procedure.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734672\n\n\f", "char_count": 1290}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 19\n\n1\n\nIn that final judgment, Judge Hafele makes\n\n2 it clear that all that they had to do was file -3 follow the Rules of Judicial Administration\n4 Rule 2.42 and file a motion seeking disclosure in\n5 the underlying case, and then serve the parties to\n6 that case and anybody who might be interested in\n7 it.\n8\n\nThat underlying case is State of Florida\n\nC)\n\n9 vs. Jeffrey Epstein. It's case number\n10 2006-CF-9454, and Mr. Aronberg no\n11 party to that case. So he is an i\n12 They never needed to sue hi\n13\n\nThere's a big differe\n\n.arty.\n\nt5Skthese records.\n\nc,\n\neen suing the\n\n14 state attorney to get,\n\nrd\n%\n\n15 motion in a case\n\nalready open.\n\n16\n\nOkay, no\n\nice is a\n\nersus filing a\n\nake one other defense here\n\n17 under 57.v7 k 3)(a), but that does not apply here\n\n2\n\n;kc\net\n\n2\n\n\"Notwithstanding subsections (1) and (2), monetary\n\n18 in a\n19\n\nsioen e, and I'll explain to you why. First,\n\ne\n\nad you the statutory language.\n\nhis is 57.105(3)(a), and it says,\n\n22 sanctions may not be awarded; (a), Under\n23 paragraph (1)(b) if the Court determines that the\n24 claim or defense was initially presented to the\n25 Court as a good faith argument for the extension,\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734673\n\n\f", "char_count": 1261}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 20\n\n1 modification or reversal of existing law or the\n2 establishment of new law, as it applied to the\n3 material facts, and with a reasonable expectation\n4 of success.\"\n5\n\nSo here, the plaintiff tries to twist the\n\n6 language of that statute in two different ways to\n7 suit its argument. First, they entirely failed to\n8 recognize that the 57.103(a) (sic) defense ap\ncit.i\n9 only to claims made under 57.105(1)(b), an\n\na)\n\n10 has to do with the law not being corr\n11 applied to the facts to establish t\\\n12\n\nThe law here cannot be\n\n13 in such a way that woul\n\nt\n'e\n\no the case\n\ntheir claim as I\n\n14 went through with thRgt.statutes\n...,\nwith you. That\n15 is the only scen\n\nn r (1)(b), when you're\n\n16 making a leg\n\nent, not a factual argument,\n\n17 where yo\n18 So\n\nn come up with a good faith defense.\n\ne is o good faith defense at all that\n\n19\n\n•e o the factual argument that it is\n\n2\n\nssible for Mr. Aronberg to provide these\n\n2\n\nmaterials, that he has no access, custody or\n\n22 control over them and he never has. That is\n23 unchanged by this defense of theirs.\n24\n\nBut the interesting thing is that this\n\n25 defense fails in another way, too, because, if you\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734674\n\n\f", "char_count": 1261}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 21\n\n1 recall, their only remaining count is for\n2 declaratory relief, and when declaratory relief is\n3 asked of the Court, that is an asked for\n4 interpretation, and admittedly so by the\n5 plaintiff. Their -- They state that -- Where did\n6 I just put it? They argue that their declaratory\n7 relief claim was presented to the Court as a,\n8 quote, good faith argument for the interpretati\n9 of existing law or at least the establishment\n10 new law. But that doesn't work here\n\ne, if\n\n11 you go back to the statutory Ian\n12 statute, it's only for the exten\n\nii edification\n\n13 or reversal of existing la\n\nsn't say\n\n14 anything about inter\n15\n\nThey did no\n\n16 57.105 -- or,\n\ntio\nfp he extension of\n\n90 V.17. They didn't ask for it\n\n17 to be moiit• oitor\nd. They didn't ask for it to be\n18 rev\nAOt\n19\n2\n2\n\n,od.\nttl\n\npli e\n\nhey asked the Court to interpret it\n\nem whether or not they had the ability\n\nye the grand jury records disclosed to them.\nThat is totally -- That is an interpretation that\n\n22 they asked for. The Court only got to address\n23 that as to the clerk because, again, we were\n24 dropped before then.\n25\n\nSo the other part of that statute talks\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734675\n\n\f", "char_count": 1254}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1 about -- it says, or creation of a new law, okay?\n\nPage 22\n\n2 They weren't asking to create a new law with their\n3 declaratory relief claim. The only place where\n4 they were trying to create a new statutory cause\n5 of action was in their Count 2 that was dismissed\n6 with prejudice by Judge Marx and is not at all a\n7 part of Mr. Aronberg's 57.105 demand.\nThe 57.105 demand only regards the clai\nc O\n\n8\n\n9 for declaratory relief. So the defense under\n10 57.105(3)(a) fails as to both of Mr. Ar\n11 57.105 claims.\n12\n\nI would just like to reitera\n\nNe Court\n\n13 that the clerk is in actual os\n\nion of the\n\n14 requested records, i\n15 statutorily author\n16 records pursu nt t\n17 plaintiffs\n\non entity that is\n\n5ft\nt ....'\nelease grand jury\nCourt order, and despite\n\nments to the contrary, the record\n\n12'`Pir\n\n18 evi\n\nce • I show that plaintiff and its lawyers\n\n19\n\no should have known at the time they were\n\n2\n\ned -- at least at the time they were served\n\n2\n\nwith the 57.105 demand that the declaratory relief\n\n22 claim fails under 57.105(1)(a) because it is\n23 unsupported by the material facts necessary to\n24 establish it, and under 57.105(1)(b) because it is\n25 unsupported by the application of the law to the\nwww.phippgreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734676\n\n\f", "char_count": 1307}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 23\n\n1 material facts.\n2\n\nPlaintiff and its attorneys have exposed\n\n3 themselves to sanctions under 57.105, and\n4 Mr. Aronberg requests such relief.\n5\n\nTHE COURT: Thank you.\n\n6\n\nMR. WYLER: Thank you, Your Honor.\nI approach, Your Horii:\n\n7\n8\n\nTHE COURT: Please.\n\n9\n\nMS. WHETSTONE: And if I may, I'll flip()\n\n10 over this timeline. Your Honor shoul\n\nA\n\n0\n\na copy\n\n11 in your binder.\n12\n\nTHE COURT: Is that the(\n\ngive me --\n\n13 I think I actually...\n14\n\nIs this it?\n\n15\n\nMS. WHET\n\n16\n\nTHE CO\n\n17\n\n2\n2\n22\n\nT:\n\nhenever you're ready.\nit please the Court.\n\nt\nri\nC5\n\n18 The\n19\n\nYes.\n\nst &d a complaint seeking access to\nfrom Jeffrey Epstein's grand jury\n\nstigation which was run by the Palm Beach\n\nCounty's former state attorney in 2006.\nThe Post felt a duty to inform the public\n\n23 as to how this sexual predator got the deal of the\n24 century and got off with such leniency. It is a\n25 matter of genuine public interest and concern as\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734677\n\n\f", "char_count": 1027}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 24\n\n1 this Court has noted.\n2\n\nThe Post named two defendants, number one,\n\n3 the clerk of Court as the public office tasked\n4 with custody of grand jury records and, number\n5 two, the state attorney's office because it\n6 actually ran the investigation and because it is\n7 the public office tasked with protecting grand\n8 jury secrecy.\n9\n\nThe state attorney's office says they\n\n10 should have never been named a part\n11 they had to be named a party.\n12 the public office that conduct\n13 and presumably had po\n14 at some time, but,\n\ncourse\nere they\n\ne\n\nvestigation\n\nn of certain documents\nim\n\nrtantly, they're the\n\n15 public office with\n\n• er and authority to\n\n16 prevent the cl k fr\n\nproducing grand jury\n\n17 documen\n18\n\nur\n\n19\n\ne s counsel's opening that this is about\n\n2'\n\nody, whether the state attorney had the\n\n2\n\nnor, we heard in the state\n\ndocuments, whether he had possession or custody of\n\n22 the documents, but it's not just about that. It\n23 is not just about custody. And it's -- We'll get\n24 into this, but the important point is, the state\n25 attorney's office has as its task the protection\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734678\n\n\f", "char_count": 1203}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 25\n\n1 of the grand jury system.\n2\n\nAnd it's important to remember, we're here\n\n3 today on a motion for 57.105 sanctions relating to\n4 the declaratory relief claim, not the statutory\n5 claim. We heard reading from the transcript\n6 before Judge Marx relating to the motion to\n7 dismiss Count 2, which was on a statutory claim\n8 under Florida Statute 905.27.\n9\n\n0\n\nOf course, we are here on the declarato\n\n10 relief claim that also involved constitu\n\naw\n\n11 and First Amendment law, not ju\n12 statutory law.\n13\n\nSo, starting off, we v rlt\n\n,tb the merits,\n\n14 but you don't even n\n\nto cat there, Your Honor.\n\n15 There are two n\n\ne, case dispositive\n\ni\nt\nsgy\ncr\\tr\n\n16 jurisdictional i\n17 motion w\n\nhich require denial of the\n\nt any consideration of underlying\n\n18 fa\n\nAn\n\nhis is not just an argument. These\n\n19 an\n\ndictional defects.\n\n2\n\number one, the Court lacks jurisdiction\n\n2\n\nbecause the amended motion for sanctions was filed\n\n22 after the state attorney was dismissed as a party.\n23 And I'll indicate -- Hopefully you can hear me,\n24 but here is where the state attorney filed his\n25 amended motion for fees. It was November 2020.\nwww.phippgreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734679\n\n\f", "char_count": 1234}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1 And we dismissed -- the Post had dismissed him as\n\nPage 26\n\n2 a party 19 days before, on October 21st, 2020.\n3\n\nThe case law is clear that the Court has no\n\n4 jurisdiction over a motion for sanctions after a\n5 voluntary dismissal, like the motion here. And\n6 this is case law, including Sidlosca vs. Olympus,\n7 and that is in Authorities tab -- the Authorities\n8 binder that Your Honor has at tab 26, and I'll\n9 read the case cite for the record. 276 So.3\n10 It's a Third DCA 2019 case.\n11\n\nNumber two, the Court also\n\n12 jurisdiction because the\n\nion, which is\n\n13 the only motion we are\n\nuolated 57.105\n\n14 subsection (4)'s saf\n\nrbor otice provision\n\n15 which requires a\n\nor fees be served at\n\n16 least 21 days t\n17\n\nIt is u\n\n18 nev\n\nery\n\no\n\nits filed.\n\ns•uted that the state attorney\ncopy of the amended motion for\n\n19\n\n< tio s at any time before filing it on November\n\n2\n\nI believe Mr. Wyler also mentioned that and\n\n2\n\nagreed with that in his opening. As a result, the\n\n22 amended motion cannot be considered. The state\n23 attorney tries to rely on a prior, what he calls,\n24 quote, unquote, place-marker motion for fees that\n25 was served on June 8th, 2020, in an attempt to get\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734680\n\n\f", "char_count": 1281}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 27\n\n1\n\naround the safe-harbor requirement of 57.105. He\n\n2 cannot do so. First, the statute is in derogation\n3 of the common law, so it must be strictly\n4\n\nconstrued.\n\n5\n\nMore importantly, the case law says, and\n\n6 this is Lago vs. Kame, the case law says that the\n\nAws,\n\n7 initial place-marker motion is not sufficient to\n8 comply with 57.105 because, once they filed\n9 amended motion making new arguments, th\n10 21-day safe-harbor notice was require\n\nw. And,\n\n11 again, Lago says -- this is tab 14j\n\nonor's\n\n12 binder -- that they must inde\n\ncomply with\n\n13 the 21-day safe harbor.\n14\n\nThe state attorn\n\nies o argue that,\n\n15 because we disn\n\ndl m prior to him filing the\n\n16 amended mot\n\nr ees, he's no longer required\n\n17 to comply\n18 dis\n\n' ir\nh the 21-day safe harbor, but the\n\nal i exactly what the 21-day safe-harbor\n\n19\n\nsi\n\nis aimed at encouraging from parties in\n\n2\n\nafion.\n\n2\n\nThere was nothing to ask us to withdraw\n\n22 with a 21-day notice because it had already been\n23 withdrawn, so 57.105 doesn't even apply to the\n24 situation here, and that's actually a situation\n25 that came up in the Ferere, F-e-r-e-r-e, vs. Shore\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734681\n\n\f", "char_count": 1235}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 28\n\n1 case, and that's tab 6 in Your Honor's binder and\n2 that's a Fourth DCA case. And in that case, the\n3 Court said that 57.105 subsection (1) was not\n4 applicable where there was no way for plaintiffs\n5 counsel to withdraw an allegation after a\n6 post-trial motion. So if 57.105 -- the\n7 safe-harbor notice was not available, then 57.105\n8 doesn't apply at all.\n9\n\n\"4\\ ,,\n\n0\n\nAnd, here, it's obvious that the amende\n\n10 motion made new arguments not in t\n11 place-marker motion. And we're\n\npull up\n\n12 the first place-marker motion\n\nt\n\namended\n\n13 motion to compare them,,S.,\n\nse are exhibits,\n\n14 Joint Exhibits 14 an\n15\n\nSo, first, her\n\n16 place-marker\n\nthe first\n, Exhibit 14, it's -- the\n\n17 motion itst Ai\n's\nr one page. There's an enclosure\n18 lett\n\nat aeme with it, and it's two pages. So\n\n19\n\n< p ges total. The motion itself says nothing\n\n2\n\npt we're going to prevail, and this is your\n\n2\n22\n\nnotice, we want fees.\nBut the enclosure letter says, along the\n\n23 lines I believe Mr. Wyler said this in his\n24 opening, that the defendant Aronberg nor the\n25 office of the state attorney is in custody or\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734682\n\n\f", "char_count": 1211}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 29\n\n1 control of the 2006 grand jury materials sought\n2 therein.\n3\n\nHowever, the first motion completely failed\n\n4 to address the main reason why the state attorney\n5 was a party to the lawsuit, because it could\n6 object to the clerk providing the grand jury\n7 records.\n8\n\nSo now let's pull up Exhibit 25, which is\n\n9 the amended motion. And, Your Honor, her\n\nO\ns you\n\n10 can have an idea, here's the first mot\n11 Joint Exhibit 14. Here's the ame\n\ntion.\n\n12 This is three pages. This is\n13 exhibits, 11 pages of a\n\nwith\nnd one page of a\n\n14 motion. So clearly t\n\n's\\ new stuff in the\n\n15 amended motio\nn`\n16 said the sam\n\n. But Mr. Wyler said they\nents. That's not -- That's not\n\n17 true.\n18\n19\n2'\n2\n\neStri\n\ne atded motion clearly makes new\nts not in the first place-marker motion.\n\no references new documents, like the state\nattorney's motion for summary judgment and\n\n22 Mr. Aronberg's affidavit, both which were filed in\n23 August of 2020. So here (indicating).\n24\n\nImportantly, the amended motion also raises\n\n25 new positions. Just as an example -- and, Gerard,\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734683\n\n\f", "char_count": 1165}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1 if you could pull up paragraph 20 of the amended\n\nPage 30\n\n2 motion -- it says, \"The state attorney has no\n3 objection to the clerk producing and disclosing\n4 the requested materials should the Court grant an\n5 order to that effect.\" And then in paragraph 25\n6 it says, \"Likewise, the state attorney has no\n7 objection and never has had any objection to the '4S ,\n8 clerk releasing the records sought by the\n9 plaintiff.\"\n10\n\nC O\n\nThat's not true, though. As you\n\n11 in the evidence, the position that\n12 attorney had, quote, no obje\n\n,, quote,\n\n13 never had any objection\n\nrk producing\n\nh\n\n14 grand jury materials\n\nne , and you'll hear from\n\n15 Greenberg Traur\n\ntt4 ey Stephen Mendelsohn that\n\n1,‘„,\n,,s\n\n16 this is exactly the ao>;ition that the Post was\n17 trying to\n\nnd Mr. Mendelsohn was trying to get\n\n18 fro\n\ne, st to attorney.\n\n19\n\nn you'll hear, in a June 23rd, 2020,\n\n2\n\nr Mr. Mendelsohn wrote to the state attorney,\n\n2\n\nhe said the state attorney is named here because\n\n22 they are a party that is tasked with protection of\n23 the grand jury system. You have the right to\n24 object to the release of grand jury materials.\n25 That's why you're here. And, once we had this\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734684\n\n\f", "char_count": 1278}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 31\n\n1 notice right here of saying they don't object, we\n2 dismissed him.\n3\n\nSo he first said on the record, on\n\n4 October 14th, I have no objection to the\n5 production of the Epstein grand jury materials.\n6 We dismissed him October 21st.\n7\n\nSo, to close out on the jurisdictional\n\n8 argument, the amended motion raised new ar\n9 and cited new record evidence that did not\n10 at the time of the first place-marker\n11 the amended motion had indepe\n\nSo\nomplied with\n\n12 the strict 21-day safe-harbor\n\nit\n\n13 state attorney failed to s\n\nfore filing;\n\n14 therefore, the amend\n\nent, and the\n\nmo n must be denied\n\n15 outright.\n16\n\nYour Hon\n\nif the Court -- sorry --\n\n17 even if thii:,topyte attorney could overcome the\n18 juri fi tion\ni I defects, the evidence will show\n19\n\n's bsolutely no basis for sanctions under\n\n2\n\ntatute, and let's turn to the statute now and\n\n2\n\nthe standard under it as applied by the case law.\n\n22\n\nAnd this will be tab 18.\n\n23\n\nTHE COURT: Are you talking to me, or --\n\n24\n\nMS. WHETSTONE: Sorry, I was indicating to\n\n25 Gerard.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734685\n\n\f", "char_count": 1145}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1\n\nAnd, Your Honor, here's the standard for\n\nPage 32\n\n2 sanctions under Florida Statute 57.105. The\n3 statute is behind it. Mr. Wyler read from that.\n4 And this is a case that interprets -- interprets\n5 this high standard, and this is the same -- I note\n6 that\n\nvs. Bailynson -- I'm going to botch\n\n7 that name, sorry, but the case that Mr. Wyler read\n8 from has the same exact standard as to how\n9 you interpret whether somebody has met th\n10 requirements of 57.105. So this is a\n11 This is not a who won. This is n\n\nrden.\niling\n\n12 party standard.\n13\n\nThey have the burd\n\ning that the\n\n14 claim was so frivolo\n\nd devoid of merit both on\n\n15 the facts and th\n\no be completely\n\n16 untenable, an\n\now the claim was not\n\n17 frivolous,I r\n\nrber\n, one, because they admitted in\n\n18 thei\n\nto this very claim --\n\nsw\n\n19\n\nn , Gerard, if you could pull up the\n\n2'\n\nparison.\n\n2\n\nThey admitted in their answer to this very\n\n22 claim that a good faith dispute exists between the\n23 parties. And here you're seeing -- Your Honor is\n24 seeing a comparison of Exhibit 9, which is the\n25 amended complaint, this count for declaratory\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734686\n\n\f", "char_count": 1212}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 33\n\n1 relief, and Exhibit 10, which is the state\n2 attorney's answer. And it says, \"The Palm Beach\n3 Post has sought from defendants, and defendants -4 but defendants have refused to provide access to\n5 the testimony, minutes and other evidence\n6 presented in 2006 to the Palm Beach County grand\n7 jury. Indeed, defendants have each filed motions\n8 to dismiss the complaint and the relief it soug\n9 under Florida Statute Section 905.27(1).\n10 Accordingly, a good faith dispute exis 1,\n\neen\n\n11 the parties.\" And, in response, t\n12 attorney simply said, \"Admitted'\n13\n\nBy that admission, t\n\nI\n\nhis motion\n\n14 for sanctions. They\n\nnot ow argue this claim\n\n15 was without me '\n\nin addition, we will go\n\n16 through the e 'den\n17 Greenbe\n18 wit\n\nthat shows the Post and\n\naurig acted only in good faith and\n\nug tful deliberation and that this was not\n\n19\n\no\n\n2\n\no backing up a bit and to what we believe\n\n2\n\ns claim by any means.\n\nthe evidence will show. After Epstein's arrest\n\n22 here in Palm Beach County in 2005, the Post began\n23 an investigation into Epstein and then what\n24 happened with the prosecution in 2006, how he got\n25 this sweetheart deal from the former state\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734687\n\n\f", "char_count": 1270}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\nPage 34\n\n1 attorney, to inform the public what went wrong.\n2\n\nThe Post made a number of public records\n\n3 requests. No luck. The limited documents they\n4 received shed no light on how Epstein got off with\n5 such leniency.\nSo, in the summer of 2019 -- we again have\n\n6\n\nAO•Aak'\n\n7 this timeline -- after years of investigation on\n8 Epstein, the Post brought in a team at Green\n\n4(0\n\n9 Traurig, including Stephen Mendelsohn herE\n\n1\nyou\n\n10 will hear from today, and other expe\n11 attorneys in First Amendment an\n\ntional\n\n12 law and criminal law.\n13\n\nThe Post and its att\n\nent months\n\n14 researching and det\n\n*nin how do we get these\n\n15 records. And y\n\nhe first box is from\n\n16 July -- July 2\n17 and -- leg\nle\n18\n19\n2'\n2\n\nh\n\n9t\n\nI\n\nugh November 2019, research\n\nesearch and due diligence regarding\n\naim to bring and how. You will hear that\ne delsohn tried contacting the state\nrney's office and requesting what was missing\n\nfrom the public records requests.\n\n22\n\nAnd if you want to pull up Exhibit 1.\n\n23\n\nExhibit 1 is an example of such, and it was\n\n24 a letter from Mr. Mendelsohn that you'll hear\n25 about where he requests specific documents. And\nwww.phippgreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734688\n\n\f", "char_count": 1242}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 35\n\n1 you will hear that\n\nwas not the only\n\n2 attorney to write the state attorney's office in\n3 addition to the Post. You will hear that\n4 Mr. Mendelsohn's specific records request to the\n5 state attorney's office went unanswered, and you\n6 will hear from Mr. Mendelsohn and the Post that\n7 the Post was left with no other option. So the\n8 Post filed this lawsuit seeking access to gran\n\n6\n\nS1Al'\"\n\n9 jury materials naming two defendants, the c\n10 and the state attorney.\n\nk\n\nry\n\n12 party to the claim here. I bef\n4\n\n,I\n\no gone over\n\n13 that, but, quickly, numbe 41S(,,\n\ne state attorney\n\n11\n\nAnd the state attorney was\n\n14 ran -- conducted the\n15 2006. At some\n16 had to have r\n17 importantr\n18 res\n19\n\nnd ry investigation in\nstate attorney's office\n\nrd\n\nBut, number two, more\n\nip,\ns the public official with\n\nsibi ty and control over the grand jury\nhe state attorney had to be named. As\n\n2\n\npublic office with that control, the state\n\n2\n\nattorney had the power to object to the clerk\n\n22 producing records. And this is something that the\n23 state attorney has never refuted or even\n24 addressed, and that goes hand in hand with number\n25 two, that the state attorney also had the ability\nwww.phippgreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734689\n\n\f", "char_count": 1289}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 36\n\n1 to request access to records from the clerk. This\n2 was not on a whim, not to harass and certainly not\n3 frivolous.\n4\n\nIn doing all this background research, you\n\n5 will hear that Mr. Mendelsohn came across Fourth\n6 DCA and federal case law supporting the conclusion\n7 that the state attorney was a necessary party.\n8 Mr. Mendelsohn provided the state attorney\nyw\n\nAs,\n\n9 that case law and explained what we need\n10 the state attorney in this case. We n\n\nthe\n\n11 state attorney to represent that h\n\nI\n\n12 object to the release of gran\n\nerials by\n\n13 the clerk if ordered by th\n\no\n\nof\n\nThey ignored\n\n14 that request.\n15\n\nYou will hea\n\n16 Exhibit 16 --\n\nlair. Mendelsohn -June 23rd, 2020, letter he\n\n17 sent to thit i ate\n, attorney in response to the\n18 stat\n\nttor\n\ny's place-marker motion for fees that\n\n19\n\n'n arly June. And, in this letter dated\n\n2\n\n23rd, Mr. Mendelsohn set forth three reasons\n\n2\n\nwhy the state attorney was named as a party.\n\n22 Again, number one, custody; number two, they had\n23 the power to make arguments against release of\n24 grand jury materials; number three, there was\n25 nothing that prohibits the state attorney from\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734690\n\n\f", "char_count": 1252}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 37\n\n1 requesting copies of the clerk during and after\n2 the close of criminal prosecution.\n3\n\nSo, as Mr. Mendelsohn says in this letter,\n\n4 even if the state attorney's office did not have\n5 possession or custody of the\n\nmaterials,\n\n6 that did not end the need for his office to be a\n7 party to the declaratory relief claim. The state\n8 attorney still had the right to object to the\n9 clerk producing records. That's exactly wh\n10 included them in the case.\n11\n\nYou'll hear they previously d'\n\n12 release by filing a motion to\n\ns\n\n13 Count 2, I'm sorry, the sj iat\n\nount -- and\n\n14 then, by filing the an\n15 that a good faith\n\n- this is\n\nr to ount 1 admitting\nuj exists as to this very\n\n16 claim.\n17\n\nSo inI ly irtimeline, for months after\n\n18 Mr. rtcnde\nt, sohn's letter, they -- they refused to\n19\n\nn , and we also reminded them on October 2nd,\n\n2'\n\n, in a later filing, what we needed. What we\n\n2\n\nneeded from the state attorney to release him from\n\n22 this case was that he would not object to the\n23 clerk's release of materials, and this was in our\n24 reply -- sorry -- response to the first\n25 place-marker motion for fees, and that was\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734691\n\n\f", "char_count": 1242}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 38\n\n1 Exhibit 20.\n2\n\nIn that exhibit -- or, in that document,\n\n3\n4\n\nagain raises the In re Grand Jury\ncase that you just saw in the June 23rd letter.\n\n5 It was not until after this, on October 14th,\n6 2020, that the state attorney's office finally\n7 stated in a court filing they would not object to\n8 the clerk's production if ordered, and he took ,....,\n9 position of neutrality. Days later, we dismis\n\nd)\n\n10 the state attorney.\n11\n\nIt's important to note the dis\n\nf the\n\n12 state attorney does not make\n\nrevailing\n\n13 party, not even under th\n\nsanctions\n\n14 standard, which is rrlikLy\nh'\n\ner than a prevailing\n\n15 party standard,\n\nunder a regular\n\n16 prevailing pa\n\ndard, the state attorney is\n\n17 not a prei 'c'ng party here. Just because a\n18 plai tff voz ntarily dismisses a defendant does\n19\n\na e a defendant a prevailing party. Where a\n\n2\n\ntiff gets something or a compromise out of\n\n2\n\nlitigation, a dismissal becomes an appropriate\n\n22 course of action as a result, then neither party\n23 is the prevailing party for purposes of\n24\n\ncontractual attorneys' fees. And that's pursuant\n\n25 to the Kelly vs. BankUnited case that is -- it\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734692\n\n\f", "char_count": 1241}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1 should be in tab 38 of Your Honor's Authorities\n\nPage 39\n\n2 binder. We sent it included in the supplement.\n3\n\nTHE COURT: I think I --\n\n4\n\nMS. WHETSTONE: It should have been on last\n\n5 Thursday, but -6\n\nTHE COURT: I got it.\n\n7\n\nMS. WHETSTONE: As Mr. Wyler even said, t\n\n8 purpose of 57.105 is to deter misuse of the\n9 judicial system and to discourage needless\n10 litigation, but here, to declare the stat\n11 attorney a prevailing party and eis xi\n12 attorneys' fees under these f t\n\nd be\n\n13 contrary to that goal.\n14\n\nAgain, you'll he\n\n15 the Post dismiss\n16 it got what it n\n\nni1f ‘tiendelsohn that\nate attorney only after\nrom him, changing his\n\n17 oppositioIFT.p.\nrelease\n,\nof grand jury records to\n18 g\n\nhis `affirm\n\n19\n\nbject. And, Your Honor, the cases here\n\n2\n\n-- the Court's rulings here actually\n\n2\n\nstatement that his office\n\nsupport this finding of no basis for sanctions\n\n22 even further.\n23\n\nWith regard to -- We heard a lot from the\n\n24 transcript before Judge Marx from the motion to\n25 dismiss Count 2. First, that was with regard to a\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734693\n\n\f", "char_count": 1148}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 40\n\n1 motion to dismiss Count 2, not the count we're on\n2 here today, which is Count 1 for declaratory\n3 relief.\n4\n\nIt's important to note that Count 1 for\n\n5 declaratory relief involves issues of First\n6 Amendment and constitutional law, not just that\n7 Florida Statute 905.27.\nIn number two, respectfully, what -- whate\n\n8\n\n9 Judge Marx said during a hearing is not evi\n\nc\n\n10 as to whether the state attorney actu\n11 custody or control of records. S\n12 statements on the record bu\n\nrd her\nv\n\nnce about\n\n13 whether the state attorne iidbr did not have\n14 custody of the docu\n\nts. Xnd he did say in his\n\n15 filings he does n\n\n\" ustody or control of the\n\n16 documents, b t, a\n\nn, we're not just here about\n\n17 his own\n18 rig\n\ngr,\ndy or control; we're here about his\n\nthTs\n\ntate attorney to object to the clerk\n\n19\n\nsi\n\ngrand jury records.\n\n2\n\nAnd when Judge Marx entered an order on\n\n2\n\nCount 2 dismissing Count 2, that was a limited\n\n22 order on whether there was a private cause of\n23 action under that statute.\n24\n\nIn addition, there was Judge Hafele's final\n\n25 judgment that was Exhibit 30 in the binder, and\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734694\n\n\f", "char_count": 1212}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 41\n\n1 Judge Hafele, when he entered the final judgment,\n2 that was as to the same claim that's at issue\n3 here, the declaratory relief claim as it remained\n4 against the clerk, because you'll recall the state\n5 attorney had already been dismissed as a party\n6 once they said they had no objection to the clerk\n7 releasing grand jury materials.\n8\n\nIn the final judgment, Judge Hafele notec(\nb)\n(3 S\n\n9 this was a case of first impression involving\n10 issues of genuine public concern. T\n\nments\n\n11 by the Post's attorneys in suppo\n12 declaratory relief claim were\n13 palatable and persuasiv\n\nncere,\nmmended everyone\n\n14 for their hard work.\n\nis\n\n15 frivolous claim.\n\nle the Court ultimately\n\n16 did not rule in\n\ne opposite of a\n\nee R st's favor for declaratory\n\n17 relief as tie irclerk, we respectfully disagree,\n18 and\n19\n2\n2\n22\n\ntd\n\nision is currently on appeal. But,\n\nortantly, that is not the standard for\n05. Again, it is not a prevailing party\nstandard.\nThey have not met the high burden for\n\n23 sanctions to prove that the fact -- the claim was\n24 so frivolous or so devoid of merit under both the\n25 facts and the law as to be completely untenable,\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734695\n\n\f", "char_count": 1255}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 42\n\n1 and, at the very least, this is a case -- in this\n2 case of first impression, the claim for\n3 declaratory relief was a good faith argument for\n4 extension of the law. And, according to\n5 57.105(3)(a) sanctions cannot be awarded.\nA reminder here, too, that it was not just\n\n6\n\n7 the statutory -- the Florida statute at issue.\n8 It's constitutional and First Amendment law a O\n9 issue in the declaratory relief claim.\n10\n\nFinally, it's worth noting that, if t\n\n11 are no sanctions imposed, there\n\nes to be\n\n12 paid by the state attorney's\n13 Mr. Aronberg personally r b\n\nakpayers, by\n\n14 anybody.\n15\n\nMr. Wyler,\n\nA\n\n...;ents state attorneys\n\n16 across the st a of Florida, had a contingency\n17 agreeme\n\nith the state of Florida in this case\n\n18\n\nate attorney in this case and, from\n\n19\n2\n2\n\n—s\n\nu et, no fee obligations arose unless there\ns a Court order awarding fees. And that's\nExhibit 5 in the joint exhibit binder. So the\n\n22 only way they were going to get fees was under a\n23 57.105 motion. However, there has never been any\n24\n25\n\nbasis for 57.105 sanctions.\nIn closing, Your Honor, 57.105 is reserved\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734696\n\n\f", "char_count": 1212}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 43\n\n1\n\nfor egregious conduct. There's nothing even\n\n2\n\nremotely close to that conduct that exists here.\n\n3\n\nThe motion must be denied, and the Post\n\n4\n\nrespectfully requests the Court deny the amended\n\n5\n\nmotion for sanctions in its entirety.\n\n6\n\nThank you, Your Honor.\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT: How many witnesses are you\n\n8\n\ncalling?\n\nCO\n\n9\n\nMR. WYLER: Just one. Mr. Aronberg.\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT: All right.\n\n11\n\nTHE CLERK: Do you sole\n\nor affirm\n\n12\n\nthat the evidence you area\n\ne will be\n\n13\n\nthe truth, the whole trut\n\ning but the\n\n14\n\ntruth?\n\n15\n\n/--,\n\nTHE WITNESS:\\ tdo.\n\n16 Thereupon,\n\nL\n\ni\n\n17\n\nD\n\nARONBERG, STATE ATTORNEY,\n\n18 havi\n\neen my sworn by the Clerk of the Court,\n\n19 rOd\nrliSfd and testified as follows:\nDIRECT EXAMINATION\n\n2\n21\n22\n\nY MR. WYLER:\nQ.\n\nGood afternoon, Mr. Aronberg.\nWill you please introduce yourself to the\n\n23\n\n24 Court and tell us how long you've held your position.\n25\n\nA.\n\nGood afternoon.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734697\n\n\f", "char_count": 1011}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 44\n\nI'm David Aronberg. I go by Dave. And\n\n1\n\n2 I've been state attorney since I was elected in 2012.\nQ.\n\n3\n\nThank you. We're here today on your\n\n4 amended motion for attorneys' fees filed November 9,\n5 2020, against the plaintiff, correct?\n6\n\nA.\n\nCorrect.\n\n7\n\nQ.\n\nAnd did you engage my law firm,\n\n8 Scholz & Wyler, to defend you in this action?\n9\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nI'm going to show you our Join\n\n5.\n\n11 Do you recognize this as a copy of o\n12 letter with your office signed by\n\ngagement\nward?\n\n13\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nThank you.\n\n\\\n\nMR. WY\n\nt Exhibit 5, Your Honor,\n\n15\n16\n\nour firm's\n\n17\n\nagrees\n\n18\n19\n2\n2\n\nent letter, contingency fee\nt\n\nTI-IE COURT: Thank you.\n\n(\n\nY \\. WYLER:\nQ.\n\nMr. Aronberg, have you reviewed or are you\n\ntherwise familiar with the pleadings and filings\n\n22 submitted with the Court in this hearing?\n23\n\nA.\n\nI am.\n\n24\n\nQ.\n\nSo then you're familiar with the\n\n25 newspaper's original summons and complaint filed against\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734698\n\n\f", "char_count": 1039}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 45\n\n1 you on November 14th, 2019, and then the amended\n2 complaint filed January 17, 2020?\n3\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n4\n\nQ.\n\nAnd what has the newspaper sued you for?\n\n5\n\nA.\n\nThey sued me to obtain the Jeffrey Epstein\n\n6 grand jury documents.\n7\n\nQ.\n\nDid they sue to just obtain them, or to\n\n8 also produce them and provide them to them?\n9\n\nA.\n\nThey wanted me to produce them and t\n\nC)ASIC\niv\n\n10 it — give those documents to them.\n11\n\nQ.\n\nAnd do you know what the,\n\no do with\n\n12 those documents once they got t\n13\n\nA.\n\nThey wanted top\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nOkay. And\n\nA.\n\ndocuments.\n\nu h e possession, custody\n\n15 or control of those r\n16\n\nIh\n\ngrand jury documents?\n\nNo. I~nefv r had possession, custody or\n\n17 control oft z c documents.\n18\n\nA A , by control of those documents, do you\n\ncan that you couldn't -- you have no power to release\nAoe\n19\n2\n21\n\nm if you had them?\nA.\n\nI have no power to release these documents.\n\n22 I don't have them. I've never had them. They knew I've\n23 never had them.\n24\n\nQ.\n\nBut, in their complaint, didn't they allege\n\n25 that you and your office are, quote, in possession of the\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734699\n\n\f", "char_count": 1184}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 46\n\n1 documents that are the subject of this action?\n2\n\nA.\n\nThat's this whole case. It's whether I had\n\n3 possession, custody or control of these documents.\n4 That's why they sued me and my office. And I never had\n5 possession, custody or control of these documents.\n6\n\nQ.\n\n7\n8\n\nOkay.\nMR. WYLER: Your Honor, you can find that\n\non J9 of the amended complaint if you're Iooki\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT: Thank you.\n\n10\n\nMR. WYLER: You can find it at\n\n11\n\n118.\n\n12 BY MR. WYLER:\n13\n\nQ.\n\nMr. Aronberg, are Npc\\ mr with the\n\n14 newspaper's allegation\n\nit\n\n15 quote, have denied\n\nlm Beach Post and to the\n\n16 public at large t\n\ngra\n\nplaint that you,\n\njury materials sought to be\n\n17 disclosed?\n18\n19\n2\n21\n\n:id you ever deny the newspaper those\nuested materials?\nA.\n\nFrom the beginning, we informed the\n\n22 newspaper that I've never had these documents. In our\n23 motion to dismiss, we had two arguments. The first one,\n24 the very first one was that we do not possess, have\n25 custody or control of these documents.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734700\n\n\f", "char_count": 1095}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\nPage 47\n\n1\n\nIn the second argument, we then make an\n\n2 argument of law, because it's a motion to dismiss and we\n3 have to argue as a matter of law and we couldn't rely on\n4 the matter of fact that I didn't have the documents. So\n5 they put us in a position to argue as a matter of law\n6 that, even if we did have them, under the law we could\n7 not provide them.\n8\n\nQ.\n\nOkay.\n\n9\n\nA.\n\nAnd, since then, they've been using that\n\n10 a cudgel.\n11\n\nMR. WYLER: And, Your Ho\n\nn, I'll\n\n12\n\ndirect you to J6 and J10. T\n\n13\n\nmotions to dismiss that\n\n14\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nd 10?\n\n15\n\nMR. WYL\n\nYour Honor. And I'll read\n\n•\n\n16\n\nthat on the ecoorj J6,\n\n17\n\n\"It is\n\n18\n\ninti\n\n19\n2\n21\n\nO\n\ne two\n\nSnilloa at assertion.\n\nstamp 103, it says,\n\n'cant to note that, despite\nallegations to the contrary, Defendant\nerg is not in custody or control of the\n\nrecords\nr\nsought and is, therefore, not a proper\nparty to this action.\"\n\n22\n\nAnd, in the second motion to dismiss, I'll\n\n23\n\nread that to the Court as well. That's at J10,\n\n24\n\nIMI stamp 222. \"It is significant to emphasize\n\n25\n\nthat, despite plaintiff's allegations to the\nwww.phippgreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734701\n\n\f", "char_count": 1193}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 48\n\n1\n\ncontrary, Defendant Aronberg and the Office of the\n\n2\n\nState Attorney for the 15th Judicial Circuit are\n\n3\n\nnot in custody or control of the records sought\n\n4\n\nherein, and, therefore, Defendant Aronberg is not\n\n5\n\na proper party to this action. In fact, Defendant\n\n6\n\nSharon R. Bock as clerk and comptroller of Palm\n\n7\n\nBeach County, Florida, admits that she is the\n\n8\n\ncustodian in possession of the documents that\n\n9\n\nthe subject of this action.\"\n\n10 BY MR. WYLER:\n11\n\nQ.\n\nMr. Aronberg, after these in\\t c\n\n12 did you take any other steps to fu\n13 newspaper and its lawyers t\n14 possession, custody an\n15\n\nA.\n\nYes, and\n\n16 came out that I v\n\no\n\n,\n\nthe\n\nyo p ice lacks\nthe requested records?\n-cause, when the articles\n\nsq ehow stonewalling the Palm Beach\n\n17 Post and try' iiiiir\nto prevent public access to these\n18 docu\n19\n2\n21\n\nts, I tarted to get calls and texts from people\nI was doing that. I had a Facebook message\naid I should resign.\nPeter Antonacci, my predecessor down in\n\n22 Broward, reached out to me, wanted to know why I was\n23 covering for the grand jury -- or, for Barry Krischer or\n24 for others. And I told him I don't have the documents,\n25 because that seemed to be lost in the articles written.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734702\n\n\f", "char_count": 1323}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 49\n\n1\n\nAnd so I took an extraordinary step. I\n\n2 made a decision to create a Web portal and to release\n3 every document that my office had relating to Jeffrey\n4 Epstein and put it on the Internet, and that was -- and I\n5 have just to refresh my recollection, the dates up here\n6 -- that was January 30th.\n7\n\nQ.\n\nOkay, great. On January 30th, did -- I'm\n\n8 going to show you joint Exhibit No. 12. Do you reco\n9 this as the press release that your office released t\n10 you were just explaining?\n11\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\nAnd can you read it to t\n\n13\n\nA.\n\nThis is a press rel sS9 my office put\n\n, please?\n\n14 out when we establishe\n\nW\n\n15 this: \"Palm Beach\n\nate Attorney Dave Aronberg\n\n16 creates Web po\n\nportal, and it says\n\nublic access to Jeffrey Epstein\n\n17 records.\"\n18\n19\n2\n\nS then\nAn\n\nthere's a statement from me: \"In\n\ns Pto a large number of requests, my office is\n\n411g online all the public records from the\n\n21 nvestigation and prosecution of Jeffrey Epstein. These\n22 records, which have all been released previously pursuant\n23 to public records requests, can be accessed through the\n24 following link,\" and it gives the link.\n25\n\n\"The Jeffrey Epstein case occurred several\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734703\n\n\f", "char_count": 1278}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 53, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 50\n\n1 years and multiple state attorney administrations before\n2 I became Palm Beach County State Attorney in 2013.\" I\n3 was elected as -- As an aside, I was elected in 2012, but\n4 I started in 2013. \"As such, I have never seen or had\n5 access to the Epstein grand jury transcripts as the state\n6 attorney's office has never possessed them. As lawsuits\n7 and investigations continue to move forward, I hope that 4S .,\n8 Epstein's victims are able to achieve justice and dos\n9 they deserve.\"\nQ.\n\n10\n\nThank you. Now, in addition to\n\n•t p ss\n\n11 release, did you make any other stepNoy\n\nnotify\n\n12 plaintiff that you don't have the re\n\nwere\n\n13 seeking?\n14\n\nA.\n\nIn addition to\n\n15 release and sendin\n\n14\nng (\n\nthat\nr press\n\nPalm Beach Post and every\n\n16 other media outllt in q database from around the\n17 country, I a\n18 and,\n\nt that press release on my Twitter page\n\nonly' at, I pinned it so it would be the first\n\n2\n\ntO\n\n2\n\ns a result, it received national media coverage,\n\n19\n\nn y Twitter page.\nI also put it out on my Facebook page, and,\n\n22 including coverage from the Sun-Sentinel, the competitor\n23 to the Palm Beach Post. But, curiously, the one paper\n24 that did not report on this Web portal, the one paper\n25 that did not report on my releasing all the documents in\nwww.phippgreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734704\n\n\f", "char_count": 1373}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 54, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 51\n\n1 my possession was the Palm Beach Post.\n2\n\nTo this day, they still have never\n\n3 acknowledged that I posted every document onto my Web\n4 page, onto my Twitter page, onto my Facebook page, onto\n5 our Web portal. To this day, even though I've had that\n6 tweet pinned to my page for months in the past, they have\n7 never acknowledged that it existed.\n8\n\nQ.\n\nThank you, Mr. Aronberg. I'm going to s gO\n\n9 you our joint Exhibit No. 11. Do you recognize thi\n10 the Twitter post that you were just referen\n11\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\nAnd does it say the \"Whin\n\ns the press\n\n13 release?\n14\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n15\n\nQ.\n\nThank y\n\n16\n\nA.\n\nIt alsoflooks like this could be from\n\n17 Facebook ... ell.\n18\n\neic. it Okay. All right, are you aware and\n\n19 fel\n2\n\nr\n\nh the June 3rd motion to dismiss hearing and\n\nNements made on the record by Judge Marx, the ones I\n\n21 ust read to the Court previously?\n22\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n23\n\nQ.\n\nWhat did you think of those remarks?\n\n24\n\nMR. BIDEAU: Objection, Your Honor,\n\n25\n\nirrelevant what Mr. Aronberg thinks of remarks.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734705\n\n\f", "char_count": 1125}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 55, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 52\n\n1\n\nTHE COURT: Sustained.\n\n2 BY MR. WYLER:\n3\n\nQ.\n\nSo following those remarks from Judge Marx,\n\n4 do you believe that the newspaper knew or should have\n5 known that you were not in possession, custody or control\n6 of those records and that they should have dropped you\n410;41\"\"c\n\n7 from the lawsuit even then?\n8\n\nMR. BIDEAU: Objection. Again, Your Ho\n\n9\n\nI don't know how Mr. Aronberg could know w\n\n10\n\nnewspaper knew or should have kno\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT: So your obje\n\n12\n\nspeculation. Sustained.\n\n13\n\nMR. WYLER: Oka\n\n14\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n15\n\nwe have a ju\n\n16\n\nshort. I'll\n\n17\n\nfor m\n\n18\n\nM\n\n19 Cr\n\nYLER:\n\n2\n21\n\n.\n\nrO\nth\n\nou know, generally,\nlet's keep objections\nem if I need to, or I'll ask\n\nBIDEAU: Okay, Your Honor.\n\nCan you -- Mr. Aronberg, can you please\n\nxplain to the Court how it is impossible for you to\n\n22 provide these records?\n23\n\nA.\n\nWell, first, I never had these records, so\n\n24 obviously it's impossible for me to provide them. I told\n25 them that. They knew that.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734706\n\n\f", "char_count": 1076}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 56, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 53\n\n1\n\nSecondly, I have no custody or control over\n\n2 these documents. I've never had them. They know that,\n3 which is why they now are moving the goal posts to change\n4 this whole lawsuit, this whole action from custody,\n5 possession, control, into keeping me on the sidelines so\n6 I don't object to the clerk's ability to release the\n7 documents. So it's a new -- it's a new ball game now\n8 apparently.\n9\n\n0\n\nBut the newspaper obviously knew that I\n\n10 never had these documents, that I never h\n\ndy or\n\n11 control over them because I repeated\n12\n\nQ.\n\nAll right. And then so\n\nI wi\n\nJudge\n\n13 Marx's order that I just referee. une 3rd, what\n14 action did you then direr,I\n\n.e\nto\n\n15\n\narx's order and I was\n\nA.\n\nWell, aft\n\n16 dismissed from\n\ne?\n\ne o t e two counts, I asked you to seek\n\n17 sanctions, 1\\6 1,4to\n,0, start the ball rolling, 57.105, so to\n18 send letter hat gives the 21-day notice.\n19\n2\n21\n\nThat's correct. And let me show you a copy\nletter.\nMR. WYLER: Your Honor, if you see our J14,\n\n22\n\nit's a copy of the 57.105 demand letter and the\n\n23\n\nemail to Mr. Mendelsohn that accompanied it, and\n\n24\n\njust for a point of clarification, there is the\n\n25\n\nmotion for attorneys' fees at the end, but that\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734707\n\n\f", "char_count": 1310}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 57, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1\n\nwas not filed on June 8th. Pursuant to the\n\n2\n\nstatute, you have to wait at least 21 days, and as\n\n3\n\nyou'll see later, that was followed.\n\n4\n5\n\nPage 54\n\nTHE COURT: The way this is -- I assume\nthis was attached to the letter?\nMR. WYLER: It is, Your Honor. It's at\n\n6\n\nstamp 235, yes, Your Honor.\n\n7\n\n8 BY MR. WYLER:\n9\n\nQ.\n\nDo you recognize that, Mr. Aronberg, as(..)\n\n10 copy of the email to Mr. Mendelsohn and the 1; .7.105\n11 demand that we issued to the plaintiff? ''<,)\n12\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\nAnd, in that letter i)Itt'Sgert\n4\nour\n\n14 position that their dema\n\nproduce the 2006 grand jury\n\n15 records, that there\n\nsis in fact or law?\n\n16\n\nA.\n\nCorre\n\n17\n\nQ.\n\nG\n\nou know if the newspaper dropped you\n\n18 from e law it within the 21-day safe-harbor provision\n19\n\n' e\n\ny statute 57.105?\n\n2\n\nA.\n\nThey did not.\n\n21\n\nQ.\n\nBut they eventually did drop you?\n\n22\n\nA.\n\nA long time later, they did finally drop\n\nQ.\n\nOkay, but, before they dropped you, did we\n\n23 me.\n24\n\n25 not file a motion for summary judgment?\nwww.phippgreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734708\n\n\f", "char_count": 1101}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 58, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 55\n\n1\n\nA.\n\nCorrect.\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nAnd did that include an accompanying\n\n3 affidavit from you?\n4\n\nA.\n\nCorrect.\n\n5\n\nQ.\n\nLet me show you a copy of that affidavit.\n\n6 That's at J18. Do you recognize this as a copy of your\n410\n4\"\"c\n\n7 affidavit?\n8\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n9\n\nQ.\n\nWill you please read it aloud for the\n\n10 Court?\n11\n\nA.\n\nThe entire page?\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\n13\n\nA.\n\nYep.\n\"My name is Davi\n\n\\\nS8$1. ronberg, and I'm\n\n14 the State Attorney for thii th\n.eJ icial Circuit, Palm\n15 Beach County, Flo\n16 above-captione\n\n'\n\n2013 and a defendant in the\nPlaintiff is seeking declaratory\n\n17 relief pursuI\n\nif,, lorida\n,\nStatute 905.21(1)(c) and the\n\n18 CouNher\n'nt\n\nt authority allowing plaintiff access to\n\n19\n\nti\n\n2nd\n\nto the Palm Beach County grand jury, the requested\n\n21\n\nny, minutes and other evidence presented in\n\naterials, and to use those materials for the purpose of\n\n22 informing the public.\"\n23\n\n\"Despite plaintiffs above-described action\n\n24 for declaratory relief, neither myself nor the Office of\n25 the State Attorney for the 15th Judicial Circuit (SAO) is\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734709\n\n\f", "char_count": 1142}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 59, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 56\n\n1 in control, custody or possession of the required\" -2 excuse me -- \" of the requested materials.\"\n3\n\n\"As such, the declaratory relief sought by\n\n4 the plaintiff seeks materials that are impossible for me\n5 or my office to produce. To be clear, neither myself nor\n6 the SAO has the legal authority to obtain and deliver the\n7 requested materials. I've repeatedly made these facts\n8 evident to the plaintiff and the public through not onl\n\nO\n\n9 the pleadings and correspondence in this matter, b al\n10 through an office press release and my pu\n\nal\n\n11 media accounts.\"\n12\n\n\"Despite the contention\n\nf%ttiff,\n\n13 neither myself nor the SAO g&h\nit dthority to demand\n14 that the clerk grant the\n\na\n\n15 materials after a cri\n\ne has concluded. Moreover,\n\n16 during my admi\n\ns to grand jury\n\ntrati , neither myself nor my office\n\n17 has accessltji rand jury materials from the clerk's\n18 offs\n\n• this dr any other instance.\"\n\n19\ne c\")\n2\n\nAs provided in Section 905.17(1) Florida\nes, the clerk has sole authority and possession of\n\n21 he requested materials, which can only be released by\n22 the clerk pursuant to an order of the Court.\"\n23\n\nQ.\n\nThank you. Do you know of any other\n\n24 substantive action regarding plaintiffs claim for\n25 declaratory relief after you filed your motion for\nwww.phippgreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734710\n\n\f", "char_count": 1385}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 60, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 57\n\n1 summary judgment?\n2\n\nA.\n\nAfter we filed the motion for summary\n\n3 judgment, we included the affidavit, and then there was a\n4 -- at some point I was dismissed, and then there was an\n5 amended motion after that.\n6\n\nQ.\n\nThat's correct. And I'm going to show you\n\n7 J23. Do you recognize this as a copy of the notice where\n8 you were dropped as a party from the lawsuit?\n9\n\nA.\n\nCorrect.\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nWhat date is that? It's on the to\n\nC....)\n\n11 very, very top.\n12\n\nA.\n\nThis was October 21st\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\nThank you. And,\n\n.\n\n)144,u ere dismissed,\n\n14 are you aware -- yeah,\n\nou ere dismissed, are you\n\n15 aware that the Cou\n\nIly granted the clerk summary\n\n16 judgment in thei avsummary judgment in favor of\n17 the clerk? \\....\n7.,,,\n18\n\n.\n\nYes.\n\n19\n\n.\n\nOkay. Just a couple more questions for\n\n2\n21\n\n.\nThere's been some references to maybe the\n\n22 newspaper not just suing you just to get these records\n23 for public disclosure. Even Judge Marx said that she\n24 thought that there was something else going on. What do\n25 you think is the underlying reason here for this lawsuit?\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734711\n\n\f", "char_count": 1171}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 61, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 58\n\n1\n\nMR. BIDEAU: Objection, Your Honor,\n\n2\n\nirrelevant as to what the reason is.\n\n3\n\nMR. WYLER: It goes to good faith, Your\n\n4\n\nHonor.\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT: All right, overruled.\n\n6\n\nA.\n\nLook, it was clear to me from the beginning\n\n7 that this whole lawsuit was a twofer for the Palm Beach\n8 Post. Number one, they were able to try to overcom\n9 fact that the Miami Herald, a newspaper 90 miles\n10 scooped them on the Jeffrey Epstein story,\n11 wanted to catch up and be the hero of\n12 narrative. And so they made the Se e he center of\n13 this whole thing by suing to\n14\n\nAnd, number\n\nt illf. ranscripts.\nthe\n\n15 of someone they h\n\nn do it on the back\n\ne dislike for, and it's no\n\n16 secret in this corlmuni that the Palm Beach Post and I\n17 have had n\n18 one-\n\nw re the Palm Beach Post has, for the past\nrs as attacked me, written many misleading\n\n19\n2\n\nrous battles over the years, usually\n\n'\n\ns, which stems from a personal vendetta from a\n\n21 eader of the Palm Beach Post, Randy\n\n, and me.\n\n22 And then, after he was removed from his position, his\n23 acolytes believed that I had something to do with it, and\n24 they -- the attacks continued.\n25\n\nI mean, they continue even today where\nwww.phippgreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734712\n\n\f", "char_count": 1281}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 62, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 59\n\n1 there's a front page article about some exaggerated -- a\n2 misleading front-page article about a criminal defendant\n3 in Broward who is making claims and trying to get my\n4 ex-wife's deposition. And the Palm Beach Post, instead\n5 of writing the facts about it, sued to get the ex-wife's\n6 deposition released.\n7\n\nI mean, for years, this has been an ongoing\n\n8 issue between the Palm Beach Post and me, and it's\n9 secret. For example, when they hired a reporter\n10 my office, who my office, prior to my being\n11 prosecuted for crack cocaine. So I w\n\nmaybe at\n\n12 some point they could find a repo\n\ner our office\n\n13 who our office did not prose?4c,\ne\n\nck cocaine. So\n\n14 this has been an ongoi\n\n'ng.\n\n15\n\nr stems from two things:\n\nSo this w\n\n16 The Palm Beac\n\ning to get the Jeffrey Epstein\n\n17 story back,'i loir\nnewspapers and to go after me, and\n18 they'\n\nblel t do it. And that's why I insisted that we\n\n2\n19 ‘ Itse t\n\nthe taxpayers some of their money back\n\nse they had to fight and pay for your legal fees to\n21\n\nght a lawsuit that was, in my mind, frivolous from the\n\n22 beginning because this newspaper knew I never had these\n23 documents, I never had control or custody. And it's very\n24 telling that now they're trying to move the goal posts\n25 and make this about something entirely different.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734713\n\n\f", "char_count": 1408}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 63, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 60\n\n1 BY MR. WYLER:\n2\n\nQ.\n\nLet's talk about that, moving the goal\n\n3 posts. We talked earlier about the wording in the\n4 complaint against you. Do you recall the statements were\n5 that you somehow denied the Palm Beach Post and the\n6 citizens of Palm Beach County the grand jury records they\n7 were requesting? Do you recall that?\n\n( SS\n\n8\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n9\n\nQ.\n\nAnd now it appears that we're hearing aC.)\n\n10 whole new argument from plaintiff today; is\n11\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\nAnd that argument, co\n\n13 is that they were fine once y\n\nrrect?\n\nI'm wrong,\nu didn't object to\n\n14 the records being relea1\n\nnd at, for that reason,\n....e\n\n15 they dropped you; i,s-.`i.\n\nurate?\n\n16\n\nA.\n\nCorrea.\n\n17\n18\n\nA,..\\\n\nl '\n\nIDEAU: Objection, Your Honor,\n\ni ding\nT\n\n19 Qi\n\nHE COURT: Sustained.\n\n2\n\n. WYLER:\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nCan you please explain your -- your\n\n22 perception of how they moved the goal posts?\n23\n\nA.\n\nLook, I mean, this lawsuit from the\n\n24 beginning was about whether I had possession, custody,\n25 control of the Jeffrey Epstein grand jury transcripts.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734714\n\n\f", "char_count": 1136}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 64, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 61\n\n1 That's a series of articles they wrote about this. They\n2 wrote a long series of articles attacking me for trying\n3 to obstruct. Those articles were misleading.\n4\n\nThe fact that we're here today and now it's\n\n5 not about that, it's about keeping me on the sidelines so\n6 I didn't have -- that I didn't object to the clerk's\n7 production of these documents is something that I haven't\n8 heard before, and I think is so misleading because t\n9 whole thing was about the grand jury transcripts. I\n10 not about trying to prevent me from saying\n\ning to\n\n11 the clerk.\n12\n\nIt was clear from the be\n\n13 these documents. Judge M\n14 and that's why we purs\n15\n\nQ.\n\nThank y\n\n16 big difference b\n17 intervening '\n18 relea\n\n'\n\nnever had\nt clear on the record,\n\nsanctions.\nn't it -- isn't there a\njecting to the release or\n\nir\ne release and actually being able to\n\nthetr ords?\n\n19\n\n.\n\nThey sued me to get the records. They\n\n21\n\nsue me to prevent me from speaking up.\n\n21\n\nQ.\n\nThere's nowhere in the complaint that says\n\n22 that they're suing to you keep you from objecting to the\n23 release?\n24\n\nA.\n\nNot only is there nothing in the complaint,\n\n25 there's nothing in all the articles they wrote. They\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734715\n\n\f", "char_count": 1290}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 65, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\nPage 62\n\n1 wanted this thing to continue, to continue to write\n2 articles. It would have been embarrassing for them to\n3 admit that they filed a frivolous lawsuit and then they\n4 had to dismiss me. So they continued these articles way\n5 past the 21-day period, and now, when they got called on\n6 it, they're trying to change the whole case into\n7 something about how they needed me to stay silent so I 4\nS„\n8 wouldn't tell the clerk to do something.\n0\nI mean, this thing was about production,\n9\n10 custody and control of grand jury docume\n11 don't believe the Palm Beach Post s\n\nI just\nale to\n\n12 change it after the fact.\n13\n\nQ.\n\nSo do you believ\n\n14 against you and were i\n\ne\n\ne an agenda\n\n'ona y targeting you when\n\n15 they filed this laws\n16\n\nA.\n\n17\n18\n\nThey\n\nalyuffys had an agenda against me.\n\nft i,r,\nBIDEAU: Objection, Your Honor,\nleva e.\nHE COURT: I think you have already\n\n2\n19 °\n\ncovered it. So I'm going to sustain the\n\n2\n\nobjection. That's fine.\n\n22 BY MR. WYLER:\n23\n\nQ.\n\nHave your friends and family been impacted\n\n24 by the plaintiffs agenda-driven reporting?\n25\n\nMR. BIDEAU: Again, Judge, objection,\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734716\n\n\f", "char_count": 1210}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 66, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 63\n\n1\n\nrelevance.\n\n2\n\nTHE COURT: Sustained as to relevance.\n\n3\n\nMR. WYLER: Thank you.\n\n4 BY MR. WYLER:\n5\n\nQ. Do you believe that plaintiffs\n\n6 relationship with you prevented them from accepting the\n7 ultimate fact that you have no legal right to possession,\n\nA9 so,\n\n8 custody or control of the release of the requested gr\n9 jury records?\nMR. BIDEAU: Objection, cumu\n\n10\n11\n\nI think we've been over this. He\n\n12\n\nquestion before.\n\nsame\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT: We'\n\n14\n\nMR. VVYLER:\n\n15\n16\n\nTHE CO T.\nss examination.\n,---\"'\nMR. ByEA . Thank you, Judge.\n\n17\n\n'-- -,,13\n\n18 BY\n\ndge.\n\nd this.\n\nfud r questions.\n\nEXAMINATION\n\nBIDEAU:\nGood afternoon, Mr. Aronberg.\n\n19\n2\n\nA.\n\nHi.\n\n21\n\nQ. You said a couple minutes ago to your\n\n22 lawyer that you filed this motion to get the taxpayers\n23 back some of their money, right?\n24\n\nA.\n\nUh-huh.\n\n25\n\nQ. That's what you said? The taxpayers are\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734717\n\n\f", "char_count": 969}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 67, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 64\n\n1 not out any money, are they?\n2\n\nA.\n\nIt is a contingency-fee basis.\n\n3\n\nQ.\n\nRight, and so the answer to question is:\n\n4 The taxpayers are not out any money, are they? You don't\n5 owe your counsel a nickel today, right?\n6\n\nA.\n\nI think that's fair to say.\n\n7\n\nQ.\n\nYou haven't paid your counsel a nickel\n\n8 today, right?\n\n4I1\nC\n\n9\n\nA.\n\nWe have not.\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nAnd the only way that your cou\n\nC)\n)\n\n.'\n\nany\n\n11 money is if he wins this 57.105 motio\n12\n\nA.\n\nThat's a good point.\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\nSo under no cir\n\nSAS1p re the taxpayers\n\n14 out any money, correct?\n15\n\nA.\n\nYeah, I\n\n16\n\nQ.\n\nOkay So,\n\n17 ago that yo\n\nYou're right.\nen you testified a few minutes\n\n(rr5d,,this motion in order to get the\n\n18 taxp\n\nrs bItheir money, that was wrong, right?\n\n19\n\n. Look, the fact that our office --\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nIs that right, or wrong?\n\n2\n\nA.\n\nLook, I have to dispute with you on that\n\n22 one. Look, look, the fact that our office has spent\n23 months having to deal with this frivolous lawsuit, that's\n24 taxpayer money. And, yes, so perhaps I misspoke when I\n25 said that because the money wouldn't go directly to him\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734718\n\n\f", "char_count": 1196}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 68, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 65\n\n1 unless we got something today. But it's clear the\n2 taxpayers are out money when you divert my attention from\n3 real business to focus on your frivolous lawsuit that has\n4 been filed for nothing more than to sell newspapers and\n5 make a profit for your client.\n6\n\nQ.\n\nSo the only person involved in this lawsuit\n\n7 -- I haven't seen you — Have you testified in any\n8 hearings in this case?\n9\n\nA.\n\nNo.\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nHave you been deposed in this\n\n11\n\nA.\n\nNo.\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\nOkay. So the only thi\n\n\\done in\n\n13 this case presumably is chat\n14\n\nA.\n\nAre you sayir\n\nawyer, correct?\nro\n\ne has done nothing,\n\n15 has not been distracted abdut this case?\n16\n\nQ.\n\nI'm talking about you, Mr. Aronberg.\n\n17\n\nA.\n\nq lifir\n'ye\n, spent plenty of time about this\n\n18 caseekthavtpent way more time than I ever should have\n19 in a case that I had nothing to do with.\nMr. Aronberg, you said that this idea that\n\n2\n\nii.-Q.\n\n21\n\nWell, let me back up for a second.\n\n22\n\nYou said that you thought the Palm Beach\n\n23 Post brought this case for two reasons: One, they\n24 brought this case because they don't like you and they\n25 wanted to embarrass you somehow, and they brought this\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734719\n\n\f", "char_count": 1251}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 69, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 66\n\n1 case because they've been scooped by the Miami Herald, I\n2 think you said, right?\n3\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n4\n\nQ.\n\nOn the Epstein matter. I mean, you agree\n\n5 that an investigation into the Epstein matter and what\n6 your predecessors did in the Epstein matter is a\n7 legitimate matter of public interest, right?\n8\n\nA.\n\nThe investigation of Jeffrey Epstein?\n\n9 Absolutely.\n10\n\nQ.\n\nAbsolutely. And the -- And the\n\n11 investigation of what your office by yo\n12 By the way, nobody has ever sug\n\nSSOr --\n\nr. Aronberg, in\n\n13 any of the pleadings filed in\n14 personally were involve\n\natgver happened with\n\n15 Mr. Epstein. That\n\ncomplaint, right?\n\n16 There's no refer\n\nou personally having been\n\n17 involved. I\n18 that\n\nthe complaint makes it very clear\n\nwas our predecessor who was involved, correct,\n\n19\nCorrect.\n\n2\n\nAL\n\n21\n\nQ. Now, so the pleadings we drafted didn't --\n\n22 didn't accuse you of having done anything wrong with\n23 respect to Mr. Epstein or the plea deal that got cut or\n24 whatever happened with the feds, correct? We acknowledge\n25 you weren't around in the pleadings that we filed in this\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734720\n\n\f", "char_count": 1194}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 70, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 67\n\n1 case, right?\n2\n\nA.\n\nYou acknowledged that I had nothing to do\n\n3 with the stuff in the past, but you are accusing me of\n4 hiding grand jury transcripts that I've never possessed.\n5\n\nQ.\n\nThere's nothing in the pleading that said\n\n6 you hid grand jury transcripts, correct? The request -7 The lawsuit for declaratory relief was to declare that\n8 you either turn over what you had, correct?\n9\n\nA.\n\nThen you don't read your own newspa\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nI'm talking about the pleadings t\n\n11 filed in this case. I understand that yo\n12 about the press side of this. I'm\n\ncerned\nabout the\n\n13 legal side, okay?\n14\n\nA.\n\nThe legal sd\n\n15 transcripts, and the\n16 them.\n17\n\nSm to get grand jury\ne accused me of hiding\n\nC.)\n, so, we can agree that the legal side,\n\nQ.\n\n18 the\n\ne' here on in this case today, is about\n\n19\n\nnd jury testimony, correct, getting grand jury\n\n2\n\nripts?\n\n21\n\nA.\n\nPossession, custody and control, correct.\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\nIncidentally, when my firm first got\n\n23 involved -- Do you have the exhibit binder in front of\n24 you?\n25\n\nA.\n\nI do not.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734721\n\n\f", "char_count": 1146}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 71, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1\n2\n\ncopy of it?\n\n3\n4\n\nPage 68\n\nMR. BIDEAU: Okay. Can we get an extra\n\nMS. WHETSTONE: We can pull it up on the\nscreen.\n\n5\n\nMR. BIDEAU: Exhibit 1.\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT: I'm sorry, what number?\n\n7\n\nMR. BIDEAU: Exhibit 1, Your Honor.\n\n8\n\nMS. WHETSTONE: Your Honor, may I ap\n\n9\n\nwith the exhibit binder?\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT: Yes.\n\n4,401\n4188\\ 1\n\ne\n\n11 BY MR. BIDEAU:\n12\n\nQ.\n\nMr. Aronberg, it might\n\n'' i tt 'C\nquicker\n\n13 if I just hand you the binder, acy\na ,\nhave to turn around an\n15\n\nA.\n\nOkay, whoxhf\n\n16\n\nQ.\n\nExhi\n\n17\n\nA.\n\n18\n\n.\n\nat way you don't\n\nat IT\nis it?\n\n6hibit 1 is an August 27, 2019, letter\n\nr.r. endelsohn to you, correct?\n19 tofftt\n2\n\nA.\n\nCorrect.\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nAnd this was a request for -- Now, prior to\n\n22 this, your office had received a number of public records\n23 requests from the Palm Beach Post, correct?\n24\n\nA.\n\nAbout -- About this?\n\n25\n\nQ.\n\nAbout the Jeffrey Epstein matter. All my\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734722\n\n\f", "char_count": 983}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 72, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 69\n\n1 questions are about the Jeffrey Epstein matter.\n2\n\nA.\n\nOkay, yes.\n\n3\n\nQ.\n\nOkay, and this was the first letter you\n\n4 received from my office, correct? From Mr. Mendelsohn\n5 about the Jeffrey Epstein matter, right?\n6\n\nA.\n\nI don't know if this is the first letter.\n\n7 If you say it, I assume that's true.\n8\n\nQ.\n\nAnd, in this letter, Mr. Mendelsohn\n\n9 requests a number of documents and records with\n10 to the grand jury matter concerning Mr. Ep\n11\n\nA.\n\nrrect?\n\nI'd have to read it, but, yes\n\n12 your -13\n\nQ.\n\nBy the way, your\n\n14 responded to this partic\n15\n\nA.\n\nI don't\n\n16\n\nQ.\n\nAnd,\n\nr actually\n, did it?\n\nfter this letter, if you\n\n17 look at tab 4 ic hich is the very last tab -- and I\n18 apol\n\ne, tht binder is so big, it's hard to move\n\n19 Cd\n\nhis letter is dated of August of 2019.\n\n2\n\nTHE COURT: What exhibit?\n\n2\n\nMR. BIDEAU: Exhibit 37, Your Honor.\n\n22\n\nMS. WHETSTONE: It's also on the screen if\n\n23\n24\n25\n\nthat's easier.\nTHE WITNESS: Maybe I can look at the\nscreen.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734723\n\n\f", "char_count": 1077}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 73, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 70\n\n1\n\nMR. BIDEAU: You can look there, okay.\n\n2\n\nTHE COURT: I'm going to slow you down a\n\n3\n\nlittle bit. I can't see the writing on the screen\n\n4\n\nfrom that far, so I'm going to flip to 37.\nMR. BIDEAU: And, I apologize, I hate these\n\n5\n\nbig binders.\n\n6\n7\n\nTHE COURT: It's okay. I just want to see\n\n8\n\nwhat you're talking about as you're talking about...,)\n\n9\n\nit.\n\n10\n\nYou're right, they're not easy to n\n\n11\n\nAll right, please continue.\n\n12 BY MR. BIDEAU:\n13\n\nQ.\n\nExhibit 37 is an O\n\n14 and that's from Mike G\n\ne\n\n, 2019, letter\n\nanother lawyer in my\n\n15 office, to your office\n\ni\n\nollowing up on\n\n16 Mr. Mendelsohn' Oct er (sic) 27th letter, okay, and his\n17 September\n18\n\nA Ye .\n\n19\n\n'\n\n2\n\ns letter. Do you see that?\n\nNOkay. And up to that point in time, we had\nt received responses to our letters, correct? Do\n\n21\n\nou know?\n\n22\n\nA.\n\nI don't know.\n\n23\n\nQ.\n\nOkay. And then -- And then after that,\n\n24 sir, it was on January -- it was on -- it was in 2019,\n25 shortly after that, November of 2019 that we filed the\nwww.phippgreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734724\n\n\f", "char_count": 1114}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 74, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 71\n\n1 first lawsuit against you, correct?\n2\n\nA.\n\nCorrect.\n\n3\n\nQ.\n\nSo, after having sent your office two\n\n4 letters, you don't know if we ever got responses to those\n5 letters, we went and filed a lawsuit, and in that lawsuit\n6 we named you in your official capacity, correct, not a\n7 personal capacity?\n8\n\nA.\n\nCorrect.\n\n9\n\nQ.\n\nAnd whenever you sue the state attom\n\n10 office, and your office gets sued for things\n11 time, it doesn't have anything to do wi\n\nnally,\n\n12 right?\n13\n\nA.\n\nCorrect.\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nYou sue — Y\n\nue a entity like the state\n\n15 attorney's office in\n\ne state attorney who is\n\n16 in his official capbcitv,i rrect?\n17\n\nA.\n\n18\n\nc\n\n19\n2\n21\n\n, t;\n\nft[ou talked about your original motion\n\nt , J6, so let's take a look at J6, if you want\n\nat Exhibit 6 in the binder, or can you look at it\np there. I don't really care.\n\n22\n\nA.\n\nOkay.\n\n23\n\nQ.\n\nLet's look at the second page. On the\n\n24 second page, you -25\n\nMR. BIDEAU: Could you highlight, Gerard,\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734725\n\n\f", "char_count": 1056}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 75, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 72\n\n1\n\nwhere it starts with, Plaintiff has\n\n2\n\nimproperly...\" Down at the bottom, last\n\n3\n\nparagraph.\n\n4 BY MR. BIDEAU:\n5\n\nQ.\n\nYou see you indicate -- your lawyer\n\n6 responded by saying, \"Plaintiff,\" that would be the Palm\n7 Beach Post, \"is improperly seeking requested 2006 grand\n8 jury materials for the purpose of public disclosure\n9 pursuant to the Court's inherent authority and\n10 supervisory powers over the grand jury.\"\n11 that?\n12\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n4\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\nSo at least at tha\n\nn,\n\nwere\n\n14 objecting saying the Po\n\noul\n\n15 not entitled to them\n\ney can't -- because they\n\n16 want to give the\n17 what the s\n\nt get these, they're\n\nthe public, right? And that's\n\np4,e says.\n\nA S\n' NIs that what it says?\n\n18\n19\n2\n\nO\n\nA.\nQ\n\nLook, you are -- this is exactly the\n\n21\n\nroblem, what you guys did. You filed a lawsuit against\n\n22 us, and the first defense that we had was that we didn't\n23 have the documents, but because, as you know, in a motion\n24 to dismiss you have to argue as a matter of law. So the\n25 only way we could dismiss this frivolous lawsuit is to\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734726\n\n\f", "char_count": 1158}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 76, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 73\n\n1 argue as a matter of law. And this -- this was the legal\n2 position that says, by the way, under the law you're not\n3 entitled to these documents. And then you -- then your\n4 client then wrote all these articles saying, see, he's\n5 trying to block us, he's trying to obstruct us, without\n6 mentioning the number one defense, which was he doesn't\n7 have the documents. That could have gone a long way.\n8 That could have shown maybe some good faith if yo\n9 have done that.\n10\n\nQ.\n\ne\n\nMr. Aronberg, in connection wit\n\n11 time of the motion to dismiss, you had\n12 your office had done no indicatio\n13 the documents, did you, up t\n\n9,\ny\n\ndidn't have\n\n4? tin time? Up to\n\n14 this point in time. And t\n\non -- this is only\n\n15 late 2019. You had\n(-'`\n16 any motion.\n\nn answer. You hadn't filed\n\n17\n\nA.\n\n18\n\nc\n\nIn our motion to dismiss.\n\n. tsYou hadn't responded to any of our three\n\n19 prior lett\n\n, and the first pleadings you filed\n\n2\n\ndicated that your objection was that we were improperly\n\n21\n\neeking these materials under the Court's inherent\n\n22 authority and supervisory powers over the grand jury for\n23 public disclosure. That was the official position filed\n24 by your lawyer, and I understand, you were taking a legal\n25 position to dismiss the lawsuit.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734727\n\n\f", "char_count": 1362}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 77, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 74\n\n1\n\nA.\n\nCorrect, but also I do want to challenge\n\n2 one part of that. When you say that we -- we were silent\n3 over and over again about responding to your public\n4 records requests, I have spoken to -- I've spoken to the\n5 public records person in my office who believes that she\n6 did say that we didn't have the documents to everyone who ...4„,.. ,\n7 has requested them.\n8\n\nMR. BIDEAU: Your Honor, I'd move to st •\n\n9\n\nas hearsay.\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT: Sustained.\n\n11 BY MR. BIDEAU:\n12\n\nQ.\n\nc\n\nAnd, after you filed thi\n\n' 'ottrt e Palm\n\n13 Beach Post filed an amendepS r\n14 that amended complain\n\nt, correct, and, in\n\nPo asserted two causes of\n\n15 action, right? One\n\n1ffiutory claim, and one was a\n\n16 declaratory judg~en\n\nunder the First Amendment and\n\n17 the Court's •\n\nrent authority, correct?\n\n18\n\nA C ect.\n\n19\n\n' Q\n\n2\n21\n\nNAnd the motion to dismiss and the arguments\n\n'\n\nt of Judge Marx all went to the statutory claim,\nof to the second claim, the declaratory judgment claim,\n\n22 correct?\n23\n\nA.\n\nThe Marx hearing was about Count 2.\n\n24\n\nQ.\n\nCount 2, the statutory claim, correct?\n\n25\n\nA.\n\nCorrect.\nwww.phippgreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734728\n\n\f", "char_count": 1203}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 78, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 75\n\n1\n\nQ.\n\nAnd, so, when we look at -- I've got the\n\n2 complaint here because I want to read it. The first\n3 amended complaint, which is J9, and if you take a look at\n4 J9 -THE COURT: Let me stop you for one second.\n\n5\n6\n\nSo I'm flipping through these, but, like, for\n\n7\n\nexample, right there, I can't — I can't see that.\n\n8\n\nMR. BIDEAU: Right, I know.\n\nc)\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT: But I saw that you were a\n\nto\n\n10\n\nblow up a portion of —\n\n11\n\nMR. BIDEAU: He is.\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT: -- and l'\n\n13\n\ndo that, that way I don\n\n14\n\nMR. BIDEAU:\n\n15\n\nit up so you\n\n16\n\nTHE\n\n17\n\nappre . 10.\n\n-:\\tit\ng 'C\nask\n) him to\n\nto ask him to blow\n\nUR :'Thank you very much. I\n\n18 BY XBID'6,AU:\n19\n\ns \\ 7' So let's take a look here at Count 1 for\natory relief.\n\n2\n21\n0\n\nMR. BIDEAU: Gerard, it's on page 19.\n\n1\n\n22\n\nOkay, just blow up the Count 1 for declaratory\n\n23\n\nrelief, please, that section.\n\n24 BY MR. BIDEAU:\n25\n\nQ.\n\nThen, with respect to paragraph 7, do you\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734729\n\n\f", "char_count": 1032}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 79, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 76\n\n1 see that one of the allegations is that the Post\n2 respectfully requests the Court declare that, pursuant to\n3 Florida Statute 905.27(1), it is entitled to access to\n4 the testimony, minutes and other evidence presented in\n5 2019 - 2006 to the grand jury because such disclosure\n6 and access would be in furtherance of justice, and then\n7 it cites to 905.27(1)06 (sic), correct?\n8\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n9\n\nQ.\n\nAnd it says, because the Post is not\n\n10 seeking these materials in connection with\n\nit or\n\n11 criminal case, it seeks a declaration —\n\nords,\n\n12 it asks the Court, hey, construe\n\nra\n\nph, construe\n\n13 the statute to allow us to giv\n\nto the public\n\n14 because we recognize\n\n's a interest of justice\n\n15 provision in that sta\n\nct?\n\n16\n\nA.\n\nWell, is w\n\nit says it is.\n\n17\n\nQ.\n\nO\n\nAnd that's what it says, right, in\n\n18 furtherance of justice? That's what the request was?\n19\n\n(v. Again, it is what it is.\n\nOkay. And then paragraph 71, the Post\n\n2\n\n6.-Q.\n\n21\n\neeks a further declaration that disclosure of the\n\n22 testimony, minutes and other evidence presented to the\n23 grand jury is appropriate pursuant to the Court's\n24 inherent authority over grand jury proceedings because of\n25 the exceptional public interest in this case and\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734730\n\n\f", "char_count": 1334}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 80, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 77\n\n1 compelling circumstances supporting transparency. Do you\n2 see that?\n3\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n4\n\nQ.\n\nOkay, and, with respect to paragraph 71, do\n\n5 you know what the answer was -6\n\nA.\n\nNo --\n\n7\n\nQ.\n\n-- that you filed?\n\n8\n\nA.\n\n-- not offhand.\n\n9\n\n4•A'\n\nMR. BIDEAU: Okay. Can we pull up thsC\nanswer to 71? That's J2, page 10, 7\n\n10\n\n11 BY MR. BIDEAU:\n12\n\nQ.\n\n''\nAs to 71, you admit tha iijsZk\n\n13 declaration, but you deny th\n\nr of paragraph 71\n\n14 So, in fact, although we were asRCng in 71 that the Court\n15 uses its inherent authority over grand jury proceedings,\n16 because of the exceptional interest in this case and\n17 compelling •\n\n:wr\n\nmstances, that the Court declare that\n\n18 we'r\n\nlow7o use this testimony, your answer was,\n\n19\n\na\n\n2'\n21\n\nyour declaration, but we deny paragraph 71.\n\n• •u asked the Court to deny that relief?\nA.\n\nIt is what it is.\n\n22\n\nMR. BIDEAU: Okay. And then we'll go to\n\n23\n\nparagraph 72. I think you have a slide on that,\n\n24\n\n72.\n\n25\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734731\n\n\f", "char_count": 1060}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 81, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 78\n\n1 BY MR. BIDEAU:\n2\n\nQ.\n\nAnd, in 72, we say, the Post has sought\n\n3 from defendants, but defendants have refused to provide,\n4 access to the testimony, minutes and evidence presented\n5 in 2006 to the grand jury. Indeed, defendants have each\n6 filed motions to dismiss the complaint and the reliefs\n7 sought under 50 -- 905.27(1). Accordingly, a good faith\n8 dispute exists between the parties. Do you see that? O\n9\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nAnd you see in that case your o\n\n11 admitted that, your lawyers admitted t dCl\ne\n\nt,\n\n12 admitting there was a good faith\n\n\\e\n\n13 parties and admitting that th\n\nis had refused to\n\neen the\n\n14 provide access to the toIt ...,\nny, inutes and evidence\n15 presented, right?\n\nIj ation, you all just admit\n\n16 that.\n17\n\nA.\n\n18\n\nS .itzt Now, you said that this argument that\n\n19\n\n.\n\nArir1, it is what it is.\n\ntone made during her opening statement, that the\n\n2t7\n\nat you wouldn't object to disclosure, was\n\n21\n\nomething new, that just popped up at this hearing, that\n\n22 -- I think your phrase was, \"you moved the goal posts,\"\n23 right -24\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n25\n\nQ.\n\n-- at this hearing? But that's not true\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734732\n\n\f", "char_count": 1226}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 82, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 79\n\n1 either, right, because that issue had been raised with\n2 you all the way back in June of 2020, right?\n3\n\nA.\n\nAre you saying this lawsuit was about that?\n\n4 Is that what you're saying, or are you saying that it was\n5 about possession?\n6\n\nQ.\n\nThe issue — The issue of your position\n\n7 with respect to whether you would agree with -- I'm sorry\n8 -- whether you would object to the request to have th\n9 records released was an issue that had been raise\n10 Mr. Mendelsohn back in June of 2020, CAR\n11\n\nA.\n\nCan you restate the questi\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\nSure. Let me -- Let m\n\nit a\n\n13 little more articulately beca(s tha\n\ns pretty\n\n14 terrible. Let me get the\n\nr outto make it easier\n\n15 for all of us. J16, p\nYou'v\n\n16\n\nee this letter, right, Exhibit 16?\n\nof sure if I've seen this one.\nPil igiwy\n\n17\n\nA.\n\n18\n\n4i. t 0 ay, well, did you know that, when your\n\n19 I\n\nlirr trd his 57.105 motion back in early June and\n\n2Q\n\nfad that two-page letter that he served it with,\n\n21\n\n'ght, and he laid out, we don't have the records, right?\n\n22\n\nA.\n\nCorrect.\n\n23\n\nQ.\n\nWhich is the basis for your 57.105 --\n\n24\n\nA.\n\nYeah, correct.\n\n25\n\nQ.\n\n-- we don't have it, leave me alone.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734733\n\n\f", "char_count": 1254}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 83, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 80\n\n1\n\nA.\n\nWell...\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nBasically.\n\n3\n\nA.\n\nYeah, no possession, custody or control.\n\n4\n\nQ.\n\nOkay, no possession, custody or control.\nMr. Mendelsohn, a couple weeks later, wrote\n\n5\n\n6 a letter back, right? Do you remember seeing that?\n: o7C\n\n7\n\nA.\n\nThis is the letter you're referring to?\n\n8\n\nQ.\n\nThat's the letter, and it's under tab 16 in\n\n9 the binder.\n\n(..)\n\n10\n\nA.\n\nAgain, I don't remember seeing t\n\n11\n\nQ.\n\nCan you flip to the second\n\n12\n\nA.\n\nThis letter was written\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\nTo your attorney, • t\n\n14\n\nA.\n\n-- back in June\" 202 .\n\n15\n\nQ.\n\nJune 23\n\n16\n\nA.\n\nNo, I\n\n17\n\nQ.\n\n18 out\n19\n2\n\nO\n\n\\jomey —\n\nember reading this letter.\n, well, let me see if I can help you\n\nW uld you go to the middle of that paragraph\n\nC\n\nlit\n\nys, \"The state attorney was named...\" Can you\n\nabove that, where it says, \"The state attorney was\n\n21\n\named as a party, not simply\" -- Do you see it? Okay.\n\n22\n\nDo you see Mr. Mendelsohn writes back, he\n\n23 says, \"Assuming the state attorney does not currently\n24 have physical possession of the Epstein grand jury\n25 materials\" -- I mean, by the way, the Office of State\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734734\n\n\f", "char_count": 1194}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 84, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 81\n\n1 Attorney at some point would have had possession of the\n2 materials that were going to be presented to the grand\n3 jury, right? I mean, the office presented this stuff to\n4 the grand jury. You would have had possession.\n5\n\nA.\n\nIf you're talking about the transcripts,\n\nQ.\n\nNo, but I'm talking about the other\n\n6 no.\n7\n\n4O\n4 Alik'\n\n8 materials, the investigative materials, the exhibits, th O\n9 minutes, the other things like that.\n10\n\nA.\n\nThe minutes?\n\n11\n\nQ.\n\nYour office would have haktO\n\n12\n\nA.\n\nThe minutes? I don't\n\n)\n\n13 it depends. I don't know ho\n14 Krischer's administratio\n15 asked for, I've nev\n16 had.\n17\n\nin t\n\n19\n\nrip\n\n2\n\nA.\n\n21\n\nit back in Barry\nt th\n\\ endocuments that you\nthat's the only question I\n\nC.)\nhold on. You mean the transcripts,\n\nQ.\n\n18 beca\n\nAD. I guess\n\ncomplaint, we actually ask for more than\n\nRight, but those are documents I've never\n\nad, and that's the whole thing.\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\nYou personally never had them, but --\n\n23\n\nA.\n\nRight.\n\n24\n\nQ.\n\n-- you agree with me, the Office of State\n\n25 Attorney would have, during the course of the\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734735\n\n\f", "char_count": 1168}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 85, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1 investigation, would have had those materials, it had to?\n2\n\nA.\n\nPage 82\n\nAgain, I don't know what Barry Krischer's\n\n3 administration had back then.\n4\n\nQ.\n\nWell, when you got the public records\n\n5 request, did you have somebody go back and look and see\n6 what they had?\n7\n\nA.\n\nWell, obviously, when we got public records\n\n8 requests, we try to fulfill all of them.\n9\n\nQ.\n\nP\n\nRight, and you don't know personally\n\nC\n\n10 sitting here today what was done to respo\n11 Mr. Mendelsohn or Mr. Grygiel, my p\n\nI ers\n\n12 asking for materials from back du\n\narry Krischer\n\n13 days, correct? Because the Aso no response to those\n14 letters even to today.\n15\n\nMR. WY\n\nction, Your Honor, those\n\n16\n\nletters and the Chapter 119 request have nothing\n\n17\n\ndo wit\n\n18\n\nla\n\n19\n\nested relief that plaintiff is requesting\n\n2\n\ns lawsuit. They're not referenced in\nit. They have no bearing on the\n\nere.\nTHE COURT: Overruled.\n\n21\n\n22 BY MR. BIDEAU:\n23\n\nQ.\n\nAnd so --\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT: Can you repeat the question?\n\n25\n\nMR. BIDEAU: Sure, I'll repeat the\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734736\n\n\f", "char_count": 1122}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 86, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\nPage 83\n\n1 question.\n2 BY MR. BIDEAU:\n3\n\nQ.\n\nYou don't know what anybody in your office\n\n4 did to respond to Mr. Mendelsohn or Mr. Grygiel's\n5 letters, Exhibit 1 and Exhibit 37, correct? You don't\n6 personally know?\n7\n\nA.\n\nIt is my understanding, based on\n\n8 conversations I had with the office, that every public\nl )O\n9 records request has been responded to and that p\n\nle\n\n10 were told, who requested Jeffrey Epstein\n11 transcripts, that we did not have them\n12\n\nQ.\n\nMr. Mendelsohn and\n\n13 letters, request a lot more th\n14 They wanted evidence.\n15 that sort of material\n\ncJleI, in those\nscripts, right?\n\ny w ted exhibits. They wanted\ntec . That was Exhibit 1 and\n\n16 37, we looked a\n17\n\nA.\n\nI say \"transcripts,\" I mean records, I\n\n18 mead rd , that anything we had, we put then out on\n19\n2\n21\n\nthat your client refused to acknowledge.\nQ.\n\nWell, the portal was things you'd already\n\nroduced. That's what -- Your press release says this is\n\n22 all the stuff we've already given out, right? That's\n23 already been in the public, right?\n24\n\nA.\n\nYeah.\n\n25\n\nQ.\n\nOkay, well, but you understand, we were\nwww.phippgreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734737\n\n\f", "char_count": 1193}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 87, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 84\n\n1 asking for stuff that you hadn't yet given out, and, as\n2 best you know, you don't have any personal knowledge as\n3 to whether or not — what happened to those requests, to\n4 Mr. Mendelsohn's request or Mr. Grygiel's request, right?\n5 You personally don't know?\n6\n\nA.\n\nWell, again, you objected because of\n\n7 hearsay before, but, in speaking to an individual who\n8 does public records in my office, I've been told that\n9 that person had said whether or not we've had tho\n10 documents, and so I believe that everyone\n\n.uested\n\n11 documents were told truthfully whethe\\\n\nose\n\n12 documents or not. And we can u\n\nn\nc\n\nents in a broad --\n\n13 in a broad way.\n14\n\nQ.\n\nIn a broad sej\n\n15\n\nA.\n\nCorrect.\n\n16\n\nQ.\n\nBut y\n\n17 or that went\n\n( Sh.\n.,ig\n\nhave copies of any responses\n\nk to Mr. Mendelsohn or Mr. Grygiel in my\n\n18 offic..c,\nen t y requested documents, correct?\n19\n\nA.\n\nI would think that Mr. Wyler would have\n\n2\n\nhing that we produced.\n\n21\n\nQ.\n\nOkay. Now, Mr. Mendelsohn, back in June\n\n22 of 2020, in response to your first 57.105 letter, he\n23 says, The state attorney was named as a party, not simply\n24 as custodian of the grand jury -- the grand jury records.\n25 The state attorney was named in his official capacity as\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734738\n\n\f", "char_count": 1327}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 88, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 85\n\n1 his office has, quote, as his primary interest,\n2 protection of its grand jury system, and he cites to a\n3 11th Circuit decision. Do you see that?\n4\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n5\n\nQ.\n\nOkay. And, in that case, the U.S. petition\n\n6 -- he goes on to explain it. He goes on to explain that\n7 the Broward County State Attorney was involved in this\n8 case, and so Mr. Mendelsohn was indicating to youci .)\n9 case where you were named not only whether you\n\nd\n\n10 custody; you were named in that case basic\n\nuse\n\n11 you're in charge of the grand jury pr\n12 right to object if the clerk wanted\n\nad the\nthose\n\n13 records or not.\n14\n\nA.\n\nWhere does jWa\n\n15\n\nQ.\n\nIt's in the(%ase indicates that,\n\n16 when one seeks ran\n\n.\n\nry materials, the relevant state\n\n17 attorney is t:k.r,\ncessary party in order to protect the\n18 gran\n\nry sy tern, and the Office of State Attorney\nit to make arguments if needed against release\n\n2\n\ngrand jury materials. Do you see that?\n\n21\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\nSo Mr. Mendelsohn was telling you, as\n\n23 opposed to what you said a few minutes ago in here, that\n24 the first time you saw these goal posts being moved,\n25 Mr. Mendelsohn -- was today when Ms. Whetstone testified\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734739\n\n\f", "char_count": 1274}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 89, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1 -- I mean, when Ms. Whetstone talked. In fact, all the\n\nPage 86\n\n2 way back to when the very first 57.105 motion was filed,\n3 Mr. Mendelsohn told you that one of the reasons that the\n4 Post sued you in this case was in order to address the\n5 situation that you had the right, if you thought it was\n6 appropriate, to object to the release of materials. Do\n7 you see that?\n8\n\nA.\n\nWas that in the complaint?\n\n9\n\nQ.\n\nI'm asking about the -- I'm asking about\n\n10 the -11\n\nA.\n\nWell, the letter you wrote a\n\n12 after the complaint, the letter you'\n13 that was sent to Mr. Wyler is\n\na\n\nI\ng me here\nys it is.\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nCorrect.\n\n15\n\nA.\n\n-0 ---,\nThat's on not in the complaint, right?\n\n16\n\nQ.\n\nBut y\n\ntold me that this idea of moving\n\n17 the goal poit,,,p,\nthat the Post was suddenly making that\n18 argu\n\nt, yo told everybody in this courtroom a few\n\n19\n\no that just happened today, I mean, they're\n\n2\n\noving the goal posts on me. Well, if the goal\n\n21\n\nsts are being moved, that was back on June 23rd of\n\n22 2020, and you remember seeing this, right?\n23\n\nA.\n\nAgain, I don't remember seeing this letter,\n\n24 but, again, this was not part of the complaint. This is\n25 an after-the-fact letter from Mr. Mendelsohn to my\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734740\n\n\f", "char_count": 1303}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 90, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 87\n\n1 lawyer.\n2\n\nQ.\n\nCorrect, and so --\n\n3\n\nA.\n\nOkay.\n\n4\n\nQ.\n\n-- you -- neither you nor your lawyer ever\n\n5 responded to this letter, right?\n6\n\nA.\n\nWell, you'll have to talk to my lawyer\n\n7 about that. Obviously I don't personally respond to\n8 letters written to my lawyer.\n9\n\nQ.\n\nCorrect. But you told us you're familiar\n\n10 with the pleadings, but you're not familiar wi\n\nO\n\nC\n\n11 particular letter?\n12\n\nA.\n\nAgain, I don't rememb\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\nNow, Mr. Mendel\n\nNilf\n\n-this letter.\nes in the last\n\n14 sentence, These are so\n\nif th same reasons why the\n\n15 state attorney was\n\ni his case. Do you see that?\n\n16 Very last sentenof\n\nt paragraph.\n\n17\n\nA.\n\n18\n\nS ib/A BIDEAU: Can we take a look at\n\n19\n\nit 21? Do you have Exhibit 21 up?\n\n22\n\nCan you -- Can you blow up the part that's\n\n21\n\nY54,\n\nhighlighted, please, and I'll read it?\n\n22 BY MR. BIDEAU:\n23\n\nQ.\n\nNow, Exhibit 21 is Defendant David\n\n24 Aronberg's response to plaintiffs memorandum in\n25 opposition to the 57.105 motion, the original one filed\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734741\n\n\f", "char_count": 1096}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 91, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 88\n\n1 back in June of 2020. And do you see in paragraph -- in\n2 the first paragraph, you indicate, quote, Nonetheless,\n3 the state attorney has no objection and never had any\n4 objection to the Court releasing the records sought by\n5 plaintiff as to the disclosure of the requested materials\n6 sought herein lies within the province of the clerk\n7 pursuant to the order of the Court. Do you see that?\n8\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n9\n\nQ.\n\nAnd this is the first time in any pleading\n\n10 -- Strike that.\n11\n\nC\n\nC .4)\n.)\n\nFirst of all, obviously you kn\n\n12 an issue back in October of 202\n\naZ4that the Post\n\n13 was arguing that one reason c ,\n\ned to be in this case\n\n14 was because you had t\n\nht t object, because you\n\n15 address that issue i\n\nof 2020, correct?\n\nHere. L\n\n16\n\nA.\n\n17\n\nQ. It\" kright, as of October 2020. So that\n\n18 argu\n\nt ha been raised not for the first time today,\n\n19\n\n2020, right, Mr. Aronson?\n\n2\n\nA.\n\nAronberg.\n\n21\n\nQ.\n\nAronberg. I'm sorry.\n\n22\n\nA.\n\nThis is what it says it is.\n\n23\n\n.'\n\nAnd, again, I felt that this sentence was\n\n24 consistent with what our position always has been\n25 because, when we were forced to do the motion to dismiss,\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734742\n\n\f", "char_count": 1243}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 92, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1 we were forced, because of a matter of law, to make the\n\nPage 89\n\n2 legal argument as a legal matter that the Post is not\n3 entitled to this, but as far as my belief of whether I\n4 care whether these grand jury documents are released,\n5 I've never cared one way or the other, but, because of\n6 this, in my view, bad faith lawsuit, you forced us to do\n7 a motion to dismiss that told you we don't have this\n8 stuff, and, secondly, we had to do a response as a\n\ntO\n\n9 of law.\n10\n\nQ.\n\nOkay, now let me get back to m\n\n11 My question was: You told the Court 4\n12 this moving the goal posts, this id\n13 right to object and we wante\n14 going to object was so\n\nay that\nou had the\n\nsure you weren't\ng tlTat came up for the first\n\n15 time today, and tha\n\n'\n\n16 came up back in une\n\n2020 at the -- at the latest when\n\n17 Mr. Mendel>\n\ne, was it? That issue\n\ni put it in his letter, and you saw it\n\n18 nece\n\nry to ddress it in October of 2020, right?\n\n19\n\n. So the letter that I said I don't remember\n\n2\n\ng is the letter that you say put me on notice that\n\n21\n22\n\nis argument was being made?\nQ.\n\nWell, that letter certainly put you on\n\n23 notice if you didn't know it before that, sir, because it\n24 says it clear as day.\n25\n\nA.\n\nBut it doesn't make my statement\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734743\n\n\f", "char_count": 1346}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 93, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 90\n\n1 inconsistent. It said, again, that I was not aware of\n2 your moving the goal posts, and, besides, it doesn't\n3 matter because this whole thing is about possession,\n4 custody and control, which you informed of that we didn't\n5 have. Now you're saying, well, this whole thing was\n6 about you wanted me to talk to the clerk, or you didn't\n7 want me to talk to the clerk, and to me that's\n8 disingenuous because that's not the subject of this\n9 lawsuit.\n\nO\n\nc)\nYou mentioned in a sentence tha\n\n10\n\n11 Mr. Mendelsohn wrote to my lawyer\n12 complaint, well after the complain\n\nhan the\nentence in a\n\n13 letter to my lawyer, and you'iiS Ng, aha, we wanted\n14 this the whole time.\n15\n\nQ.\n\nWell, ce\n\n•\n\n16 time, and we wa ted i\n17 testify, and\n\nwanted it the whole\nthe, as Mr. Mendelsohn will\n\nMendelsohn wrote that when your lawyer\n\n18 sent\n\n7.10t , saying our case isn't frivolous, we think\n\n19\n\nffi\n\n2\n\nsome of the records that we were seeking, and in\n\n21\n22\n\nmight have possession of the records, at\n\nddition, your office has the right to object.\nA.\n\nDid you put that in the complaint? You\n\n23 didn't put that in the complaint.\n24\n\nQ.\n\nI know it's hard for a lawyer to not ask\n\n25 questions, but -www.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734744\n\n\f", "char_count": 1294}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 94, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 91\n\n1\n\nA.\n\nFair enough. Fair enough.\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nAnd try not to argue because our court\n\n3 reporter is going to kill us.\n4\n\nOkay, in any event, Mr. Aronberg, in the\n\n5 October 14th, 2020, response, you indicate that the state\n6 attorney has no objection, okay, to the clerk producing\n7 these records if the clerk produces them, right?\n8\n\nA.\n\nRight.\n\n9\n\nQ.\n\nAnd you know, by the way, that the clerIC\n\nO AS'A\n\n10 had already produced them without -- well,\n\nly --\n\n11 nobody could find a court order -- had\n\nto the\n\n12 U.S. Attorney and the FBI years\n13\n\nA.\n\nI guess so. I me\n\nt\n\nht?\nthere years\n\n14 earlier, so if that's what\n\nen\n\n15\n\nhortly after you filed\n\nQ.\n\nAnd, by\n\n16 Exhibit 21 is why\n\nyes, sure.\n\nalm Beach Post dismissed the\n\n17 case, rights\n\nwithin 14 days of that, correct?\n\n18\n\ndo it up there. Maybe 17 days?\n\n19\n\n.\n\nWhatever your timeline says.\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nRight. All right, you indicated on the\n\n21 20th is the first time you stated you had no objection to\n22 production of the materials, okay, and then on\n23 October 21st, now that you said you don't have them and\n24 you don't object, the Post dropped you as a party seven\n25 days later, see that?\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734745\n\n\f", "char_count": 1253}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 95, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\nPage 92\n\n1\n\nA.\n\nYeah.\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nRight? Okay. And then 17 days later, you\n\n3 file an amended motion which makes a host of arguments\n4 not set forth in your original motion back in June\n5 of 2020, correct?\n6\n\nA.\n\nWell, you have to ask Mr. Wyler about the\n\n7 substance of that, but I know that the motion — the\n8 amended motion was filed after I was already dismisse\n9 from the lawsuit and after your client failed to dism\n10 me within the 21-day IM period.\n11\n\nQ.\n\nWell, that's the 21-day gra\n\nor\n\n12 the first motion that you filed, corr\n13\n\nA.\n\nCorrect, correct.\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nBut the moti\n\n're Rere on today,\n\n15 according to the Co\n\nand the notice, is your\n\n16 amended motion\n\nwas never served prior to being\n\n17 filed, corre\n18\n\nW I, are you saying that the filing of the\n\n19\n\nd ction means that the first motion is now void, it\n\n2Q\n\noes away, it didn't exist?\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nWe're going to be arguing that to the\n\n22 Judge, but the filing, under the law, the filing of a\n23 second motion that raises new and different arguments\n24 absolutely goes away, the first motion goes away.\n25\n\nA.\n\nBut the whole purpose of the 21-day notice\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734746\n\n\f", "char_count": 1216}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 96, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 93\n\n1 is to give you a chance to dismiss me, and I was already\n2 dismissed by that point, so -3\n\nQ.\n\nSo let's take that to its logical -- Let's\n\n4 assume you had gone ahead and served this back, say, back\n5 here in October, okay, and then you filed that response\n6 and we looked at it and said,,, he's now admitting -7 he's now saying he's not going to oppose it. If we had\n8 dismissed you right then, you'd have no fee claim, ri\n9 because under the rule, we're allowed to dismiss.\n10\n\nA.\n\nYou get 21 days.\n\n11\n\nQ.\n\nWe get 21 days, right. So)St\n\n12 served it all the way back here in\n13 gotten your response and di\n14 claim, right? We would,\n15 within the\n\nperi\n\nand if we had\nou'd have no fee\n\ngo en your 57.105, and\n\nwg ould have dismissed it,\n\n16 right?\n17\n\nA.\n\nIf the second one was filed before I was\n7\n18 dism sed, within the 21 days -Yes, sir.\n\n19\n\n-- and the case was still pending? Then,\n\n2\n\nvA.\n\n21\n\neah, you'd have a much better argument. But you don't\n\n22 have an argument now because, under the first -23\n\nQ.\n\nWe'll argue -- We'll argue that to the\n\n24 Judge -25\n\nA.\n\nAll right, fair enough.\nwww.phippgreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734747\n\n\f", "char_count": 1203}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 97, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 94\n\n1\n\nQ.\n\n-- as to whether we have an argument now.\n\n2 We think the Fourth is pretty clear on that one.\n3\n4\n\nMR. BIDEAU: Would you bring up, please -just last question -- Exhibit 25, paragraph 20?\n\n5 BY MR. BIDEAU:\n6\n\nQ.\n\nAnd this is -- this is your amended motion,\n\n7 and you say, The state attorney has no objection to the\n8 clerk producing and disclosing the requested materi\n9 should the Court grant an order to that effect; how\n10 it is impossible for the state attorney to co\n11 the relief, blah, blah, blah, because yo\n\nthat\n\n12 argument before.\nThat argument tha\n\n13\n\nno objection to\n\n14 the clerk producing the west\n15 forth in your original\n\n•\n\nmaterials was not set\n\nour original 57.105\n\n16 motion, correct?\n17\n\nA.\n\n18\n\nIviSreve that's correct.\nM\n\nBIDEAU: That's all I have, Judge.\n\nM\n2\n19 0\n\nHE\nCOURT: Just\nRedirect?\nR. WYLER:\nreal quick.\n\n21y\n\nREDIRECT EXAMINATION\n\n22 BY MR. WYLER:\n23\n\nQ.\n\nMr. Aronberg, you were just talking -- or,\n\n24 just being asked questions about the public records\n25 requests that were made of your office.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734748\n\n\f", "char_count": 1145}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 98, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 95\n\n1\n\nDid the plaintiff ever file a Chapter 119\n\n2 lawsuit against your office for those records?\n3\n\nA.\n\nNo.\n\n4\n\nMR. WYLER: No further questions.\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT: Is Mr. Aronberg excused?\n\n6\n\nTHE WITNESS: Thank you, Your Honor.\n\n7\n\nMR. WYLER: Yes, you're excused.\n\n8\n\nMS. WHETSTONE: Your Honor, may we t O\n\n9\n\nfive-minute break?\n\n10\n\nTHE COURT: We'll be back in a\n\n11\n\nbe in recess, we'll say 5 to 10 ml„s ty\n\n12\n\n(Off the record from 3:39.\n\n13\n\n3:57 p.m.)\n\n14\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n15\n\nMR. WYL\n\nS \\'-please\n' be seated.\nLe.....,\night,\n\n• Y\n\nHonor, before I rest, I\n\no the Court that plaintiff and\n\n16\n\njust wante\n\n17\n\ndefentwrel, we've -- we've agreed on all\n\n18\n\nseethilpits,\nt\nthat joint exhibit book. We just\n\n19\n\na ed to make sure that all exhibits, 1 through\n\n2\n\n7, are recognized by the Court.\n\n21\n\nTHE COURT: All right, so Exhibits 1\n\n22\n\nthrough 37 of this joint binder have been\n\n23\n\nstipulated to and are in evidence, and that's the\n\n24\n\nan agreement of the parties.\n\n25\n\nMS. WHETSTONE: Yes, Your Honor.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734749\n\n\f", "char_count": 1103}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 99, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 96\n\n1\n\nMR. WYLER: Thank you, Your Honor.\n\n2\n\n(Joint Exhibits 1 through 37 were admitted\n\n3 into evidence.)\n4\n\nDefense rests.\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT: But not this timeline, correct?\n\n6 This is not?\nMS. WHETSTONE: That's correct. That's a\n\n7\n\n8 demonstrative. Thank you, Your Honor.\n9\n\nTHE CLERK: Thank you.\n\n10\n\nMS. WHETSTONE: The plaintiff\n\n5)\n\n(\n\nephen\n\n11 Mendelsohn.\n12\n\nTHE COURT: Before w\n\n13 Mr. Mendelsohn going t\n14\n\n)illis, how long is\n\neSsf_ day?\n\nMS. WHETSTOQtL1 W will make this as fast\n\n15 as possible.\nTHE CO\n\n16\n\n1E\n\n17 through\n18\n19\no\n\nhing, but we're done at 5:00 today.\n\n.\n\n)\n\nT\n\nm not trying to rush you\n\nHETSTONE: Thirty minutes.\nCOURT: And after Mr. Mendelsohn, are\n\n2\n\ndone?\n\n2\n\nMS. WHETSTONE: Yes, Your Honor.\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT: Okay. In the event that you're\n\n23 going past 5 -- we're not going to go past 5, but\n24 in the event you need to go past 5, I'll bring you\n25 back in later in the week. It won't be tomorrow.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734750\n\n\f", "char_count": 1029}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 100, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 97\n\n1 Tomorrow I have another matter that I have to hear\n2 in the afternoon. But, in the event we need to go\n3 past 5, even if it's for argument, probably\n4 Thursday or Friday in the afternoon, I'll bring\n5 you back.\n6\n\nIf the testimony is going to conclude today\n\n7 or mostly conclude today and the only thing left\n\n,0 41k-\n\n8 are your arguments of law and your argumen\nZ oo\n\nN\n\n9 the findings of fact, then that might be some 'n\n10 that we end up doing on Thursday or\n11 afternoon, okay?\n12\n\nMR. WYLER: Yes, Your\n\ni:i t,' I think it\n\n13 might be worthwhile to p %.,l4t, o the Court that\n14 the reasonableness\n\nse\n\nthis, if we get there,\n\n15 we've already a\n\nt there would be no\n\n16 experts, so I t\n\nt could dispense with that.\n\n, up in Amelia Island, Florida,\n17,,0,ted\n18 so I, n—\n' TAt COURT: Fifteen minutes away.\n19\n17\n\nI am\n\n2\n\nQA\n\n2\n\nif it would be possible, if we finished with the\n\nR. WYLER: Super close. So I don't know\n\n22 testimony today, if maybe we could make written\n23 closing arguments to the Court instead of coming\n24 back?\n25\n\nTHE COURT: How do you feel about writing?\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734751\n\n\f", "char_count": 1188}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 101, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1\n\nMS. WHETSTONE: We would have no objection\n\n2\n\nto that if Your Honor would prefer. Whatever Your\n\n3\n\nHonor prefers, we will do.\n\n4\n\nPage 98\n\nTHE COURT: If you guys don't mind writing.\n\n5\n\nI mean, I think people are better in writing.\n\n6\n\nPeople overestimate their oratory skills, but\n\n7\n\nokay.\n\n8\n\nTHE CLERK: Do you solemnly swear or a\n\n9\n\nthat the evidence you're about to give will be\n\n10\n\ntruth, the whole truth and nothing but\n\n11\n\nTHE WITNESS: Yes.\n\n12 Thereupon,\n13\n\nSTEPHEN MENE)g 6\n\n, ESQ.,\n\n14 having been duly sworn,414Z ....e\ne C rk of the Court,\n15 responded and tes\n\ns\n\nlows:\n\n16\n\nTHE\n\n17\n\nMf 4r,HETSTONE: Thank you, Your Honor.\n\n18\n\nUR :'Whenever you're ready.\n\ntRECT EXAMINATION\n\n19 t('-ii)VHETSTONE:\n2\n\n.\n\nGood afternoon, Mr. Mendelsohn.\n\n21y\n\nA.\n\nHello.\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\nPlease introduce yourself to the Court.\n\n23\n\nA.\n\nYes. I am Stephen Mendelsohn.\n\n24\n\nLet me just move a little closer.\n\n25\n\nYes, I'm Stephen Mendelsohn, and I'm an\nwww.phippgreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734752\n\n\f", "char_count": 1039}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 102, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 99\n\n1 attorney at Greenberg Traurig in the Fort Lauderdale\n2 office.\n3\n\nQ.\n\nPlease let us know your educational\n\n4 background.\n5\n\nA.\n\nI have a bachelor's degree from Colgate\n\n6 University in Upstate New York, graduated in 1980 and --\n\nA\n\n7 in economics, and I have a J.D. degree from Hofstra\n8 University School of Law from 1983.\n9\n\nQ.\n\nIC.:\n\nAnd what's your work experience going\n\n10 backwards in time?\n11\n\nA.\n\nI've been at Greenberg Tra\n\n12 commercial litigator for approxim\n13 that time I've been a shareh\n\n'\nars, and all\neenberg. As I\n\n14 said, I work out of the F9 ...fly\nud dale office at\n15 present. Previous to\n\nZ\n\nas in the Boca Raton\n\n16 office of Greenb\n\nrig, so going back 20 years.\n\n17\n\nBr r that, I was an attorney with\n\n18 Ruth\n\nd\n\n19 Ii\n2O\n21\n\n, (hull & Wargo in Boca Raton, also commercial\nnd, prior to that, I was a named partner a\n\n-in Miami. That was Carolonga, Langen, Lorenza\nphonetic) & Mendelsohn, and before that, I was an\n\n22 assistant attorney general for the State of New York.\n23\n\nQ.\n\nIn what states are you licensed to practice\n\nA.\n\nNew York and Florida.\n\n24 law?\n25\n\nwww.phippgreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734753\n\n\f", "char_count": 1196}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 103, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 100\n\n1\n\nQ.\n\nAt Greenberg Traurig, what types of cases\n\n2 do you practice?\n3\n\nA.\n\nA variety of commercial litigation,\n\n4 copyright, trademark, securities, real estate disputes,\n5 disputes over employment, contract, fraud. Also, not\n6 just simply commercial, but I also do defamation defense,\n\nA„k\n\n7 First Amendment cases on defamation, and I do trial work\n8 and appellate work.\n9\n\nQ.\n\n0\n\nWhen you were at the New York State\n\n10 Attorney General's Office, what types of ca\n\nyou\n\n11 handle?\n12\n\nA.\n\nI was in the Litigation\n\n13 Statistics, and that's civil liti\n\n\\t f- abor\narily civil\n\n14 rights and constitutionalj‘\n\ncaste\n..., involving 42 USC\n\n15 Section 1983, wher\n\nrk State and its officials were\n\n16 sued in their offs\n\ncity. That included cases\n\n17 under\n18 Amendrnent\n\ncasionally, and the Eighth Amendment and\n\n19 F ( nth Amendments to the U.S. Constitution.\nAre you AV rated?\n\n2\n\nvQ.\n\n21\n\nA.\n\nYes, AV rated as well.\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\nHave you ever been sanctioned or subject to\n\n23 disciplinary action?\n24\n\nA.\n\nNever.\n\n25\n\nQ.\n\nEver -www.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734754\n\n\f", "char_count": 1129}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 104, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 101\n\n1\n\nA.\n\nIn any jurisdiction.\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nEver had 57.105 sanctions or Rule 11\n\n3 sanctions awarded in any case that you've worked on?\n4\n\nA.\n\nThis is the first motion ever under 57.105\n\n5 or Rule 11 under the federal rules or any of that.\n6\n\nQ.\n\nSo besides this case, no?\n\n7\n\nA.\n\nNo.\n\n8\n\nQ.\n\nYou've never had any motion raised?\n\n9\n\nA.\n\nNo. No, M.\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nHow did you first get involved w\n\n11 Jeffrey Epstein case on behalf of the ,P̀\n12\n\nA.\n\nI was contacted by M'\n\n13 Albany office. He represent\n\nel from our\nr of media and\n\n14 newspapers throughout\n\nUnit d States, and essentially\n\n15 he heads the medi\n\nGreenberg Traurig. And he\n\n16 was looking for\n\nto help the Palm Beach Post in\n\n17 obtaining dents from at that time the state\n18 atto\n\ns offlee here in Palm Beach County.\n.\n\n19\n\nWhen were you contacted by Mike Grygiel?\nWhen approximately?\n\n2\n\nvA.\n\n21\n\nQ.\n\n(Nods head up and down.)\n\n22\n\nA.\n\nIn the summer of 2019. It's Grygiel,\n\n23 G-r-y-g-i-e-l.\n24\n\nQ.\n\nThank you. So here, around -- on the\n\n25 timeline, I'm indicating July 2019?\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734755\n\n\f", "char_count": 1134}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 105, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 102\n\n1\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nAnd what did the Post want to find out and\n\n3 inform the public about with regard to Jeffrey Epstein?\n4\n\nA.\n\nRight, at that time, the Epstein matter was\n\n5 back in the news. Mr. Epstein had been arrested by the\n6 FBI, and he was being prosecuted by the U.S. Attorney's\n7 Office in the Southern District of New York and was in\n8 custody.\n9\n\n0\nSo the issues of the plea deal that had\n\n10 been worked out by Mr. Krischer's office b\n11 back in the news, and, in particular, P\n12 Secretary of Labor, Alexander Acct\n13 the U.S. Attorney in the Sou\n\n106 was\nrump's\n\na\n\nat time was\n\nlOt ict of Florida who\n\n14 also helped negotiate\n\na aiTd the non-prosecution\n\n15 agreement, and th\n\nig firestorm as to whether or\n\n16 not Mr. Acosta s\n\nshould not resign as Secretary\n\n17 of Labor.\n18\n\n.\n\nV at was the Post interested in finding out\n\n19\n\nird\n\nto the prior grand jury investigation by the\n\n2\n421\n\neach County State Attorney?\n:t A.\n\nWell, because of the firestorm surrounding\n\n22 Alex Acosta and the re-arrest, or new arrest, I should\n23 say, of Jeffrey Epstein, the Post was interested in\n24 looking back again as to what Barry Krischer's office as\n25 state attorney did in terms of using or misusing the\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734756\n\n\f", "char_count": 1317}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 106, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 103\n\n1 grand jury process, in terms of the prosecution of\n2 Jeffrey Epstein both in terms of the very light\n3 non-prosecution agreement that they allowed him to enter\n4 into, as well as the extremely lenient sentence that he\n5 had.\n6\n\nQ.\n\nWere you involved in drafting letters to\n\n7 the state attorney's office seeking documents relating to ''S ,\n8 the Epstein prosecution?\n9\n\nA.\n\n10\n11\n\nYes.\n\nC O\n\nMS. WHETSTONE: Would you\n\nfiring up\n\nExhibit 1?\n\n12 BY MS. WHETSTONE:\n13\n\nQ.\n\nWe're pulling up tii\n\n14 exhibit binder. It's an A\n\n.i the joint\n\nt 27th letter.\n\n15\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n16\n\nQ.\n\nOr, a uall , r. Mendelsohn, please let me\n\n17 know what ' letter is.\n18\n\nY , this is Joint Exhibit 1. This is a\n\n19 I\n\nto on August 27, 2019, to State Attorney Dave\n\n2\n\nberg on behalf of the Post requesting specific\n\n21\n\nocuments related to the grand jury investigation of\n\n22 Jeffrey Epstein.\n23\n\nQ.\n\nWhat were you seeking in this letter?\n\n24\n\nA.\n\nParticularly, we were interested in items\n\n25 stated on pages 2 and 3, some of what we were looking at.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734757\n\n\f", "char_count": 1132}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 107, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 104\n\n1 We were very interested in finding out the conversations\n2 between defense counsel, that's criminal defense counsel\n3 for Mr. Epstein and, in particular, Alan Dershowitz and\n4 Mr. Krischer's office.\n5\n\nWe knew from investigation that\n\n6 Mr. Dershowitz had provided Mr. Krischer with exhibits or\n\n,..4,..\n\n7 documents which went to injure the testimony -- the\n8 credibility and the testimony of the young woman wh\n9 testified before the grand jury. I mean, we were\n10 for those communications between Mr. Kn\n\niffice\n\n11 and defense counsel, in particular wh\n12 and others from the defense prov\n\nrshowitz\ne materials to\n\n13 damage the credibility of thee ikSji,r witness.\n14\n\nWe also want\n\n15 Mr. Krischer's off\n\n7,\n,c,\n,\n\n16 Office because t\n17 because of\n18 such\n19\n2\n21\n\nm\n\nnications between\n\nBI and the U.S. Attorney's\ndues were coming to the fore\n\nAcosta, and we did know that there were\n\nmu ications, and we wanted those documents to go\n\no ate Post for public disclosure.\n\nQ.\n\nWhat was the state attorney's office's\n\nesponse to this August 27th letter?\n\n22\n\nA.\n\nI never received a response to this letter.\n\n23\n\nQ.\n\nWere there other letters from Greenberg\n\n24 Traurig to the state attorney's office following up?\n25\n\nA.\n\nYes. Mr. Grygiel wrote a letter to the\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734758\n\n\f", "char_count": 1368}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 108, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 105\n\n1 state attorney's office as well. When I didn't receive a\n2 response, I guess he felt whatever, but he did send that\n3 next letter.\n4\n\nQ.\n\nOkay, so I'm pulling up Exhibit 37. Is\n\n5 this -- Let me know what this is.\n6\n\nA.\n\nYes, this is Mr. Grygiel, from our Albany\n\n41,11\nl 4y\n\n7 office, this is his letter to State Attorney Dave\n8 Aronberg, October 9, 2019, reiterating some of the t '\n\nii .\"2)\n\n9 that we thought were in the possession of the stat\n10 attorney's office but had not been provided\n\nalin\n\n11 Beach Post.\n12\n\nQ.\n\nDid you get a respons\n\nen) a\n\n13 response to this letter?\n14\n\nA.\n\nNo.\n\nS'\\'\n\n15\n\nCI\n\nDid you rE\n\ndocuments that were\n\n16 provided by the\n17\n18 this,\n\nA.\n\norney's office to the Post?\nBefore -- Sort of in the middle of\n\nPal\n\neach Post, before I had written, had made\n\n19\n\nis cords request of the state attorney's office,\nICt\n\n2\n\nome materials had been provided, and we did go\n\n21 hrough that, those materials. They did not include\n22 those that I mentioned in Joint Exhibit 1, which\n23 particularly were missing the Dershowitz communications\n24 and the communications with Mr. Krischer's office, the\n25 FBI and the U.S. Attorney's Office.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734759\n\n\f", "char_count": 1267}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 109, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 106\n\n1\n\na\n\nSo what information\n\nwhat additional\n\n2 information was needed that the Post NO3 seeking?\n3\n\nA.\n\nWe wanted to see why the grand jury was\n\n4 used in such a way as to result in a very lenient charge\n5 for Mr. Epstein, as well as the lenient sentence that was\n6 part of the non-prosecution agreement.\n7\n\nWe knew from the Post's investigation and\n\n8 from other materials we had assembled that there w\n9 there was a grand jury that was empaneled. In fa\n10 there was two. The first one was canceled\n11 second one was conducted, and a wit\n\ntim did\n\n12 testify. And we were on fairly ce\n\nrdlmd that the\n\n13 state attorney's office under\n\nCher undermined\n\n14 her credibility with mate '\n\npro\n\ned to Mr. Krischer\n\n15 by defense counsel\n16\n\nQ.\n\n17\n\nA.\n\nDid y\nd we did not get those materials back\n\n18 from 10\\-e.,stat attorney's office.\n19\n2\n21\n\nCI\n\nDid you review any other information to\n\nA.\n\nYes. I wanted to say that I was not the\n\nhe conclusions about the grand jury indictment?\n\n22 only one working on this at Greenberg Traurig. In\n23 addition to Mr. Grygiel, Nina Boyajian of our Los Angeles\n24 office, who is a First Amendment expert, was also part of\n25 our team. She is very well versed in First Amendment\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734760\n\n\f", "char_count": 1314}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 110, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 107\n\n1 issues, especially when it comes to representing the\n2 media's interest under the First Amendment.\nSo we also had paralegals tasked with that\n\n3\n\n4 responsibility, too. We had assembled deposition\n5 transcripts, affidavits that had been submitted in\n6 various cases. I personally have spoken with the Town of\n7 Palm Beach County -- the Town of Palm Beach Chief of\n8 Police Reiter and discussed his testimony with him i\n9 civil cases. I've obtained his deposition transcripts\n10 We spoke to only a few of the plaintiffs' la\n\nthe\n\n11 cases, but some of them did provide\n12\n\nerials.\n\nThere was a voluminou\n\nof materials\n\n13 we used. We also went bac (4;SI5\not\n\nminal case where\n\n14 the materials were in th\n\nlic\n\nmain and read through\n\n15 those items as well\n16\n\nQ.\n\nAnd,\n\ner t i team at Greenberg reviewed\n\n17 all this inforiTiv\n'on and did due diligence, what was\n18 deci\n\nnext\n\n19\n\n. Ultimately, the team decided that it was\n\n2\n\nnary\n\nto bring a lawsuit to obtain what we call grand\n\n21 ury materials. It's not just simply the transcripts of\n22 what occurred in front of the grand jury, but all of the\n23 ancillary or corollary materials related to that. And\n24 that, as we stated in Exhibit 1, included, but not\n25 limited to, the communications where we believe\nwww.phippgreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734761\n\n\f", "char_count": 1369}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 111, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 108\n\n1 Mr. Dershowitz provided damaging information or\n2 documentation to Mr. Krischer's office to destroy his own\n3 witness in front of the grand jury, which honestly,\n4 looking at all of the materials we had received and based\n5 upon my personal discussions with the chief of police of\n6 the Town of Palm Beach, we came to the conclusion\n7 Mr. Krischer had abused his authority as state attorney.\n8\n\nQ.\n\nWhen did the due diligence process start\n\n9 and when did it end as far as reviewing the facts?\n10\n\nA.\n\nStarted in the summer of 2019,\n\n11 Well, the first phase resulted in the la\n\nthat\n, not only\n\n12 contained hundreds of hours' wo\n13 legal work, but, as I said, fac\n\nigatory work as\n\n14 well. But it continued e\n\n....e\nfter e lawsuit had been\n\n15 filed as well. We d'\n\n1t\n\nn case we found something\n\n16 new, and ultima\n\nid find new things out in this\n\n17 case, whichor\n18 revel\n\nsy\nn add later, but there were new\n\nns t t had occurred.\n\n19\n\n.\n\nAnd the initial complaint was filed in...?\n\n2\n\nA.\n\nThe end of November of 2019.\n\n21\n\nQ.\n\nWhat legal research was done before filing\n\n22 the initial complaint? And that was for the statutory\n23 count under 905.27.\n24\n\nA.\n\nSure. The way we divided the work between\n\n25 myself primarily and Ms. Boyajian was that we would\nwww.phippgreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734762\n\n\f", "char_count": 1368}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 112, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\nPage 109\n\n1 handle the First Amendment issues in the case. So the\n2 U.S. Supreme Court cases involving the rights of the\n3 media to be the public surrogate or be the public\n4 mouthpiece and to obtain and participate in all facets of\n5 criminal proceedings, she helped me and provided that -6 I was aware of all of that, but she certainly had a\n7 greater in-depth knowledge than I did. I was tasked with\n8 the responsibility of fleshing out Section 905.27 of th\n9 Florida statutes primarily.\n10\n\nQ.\n\nWhat did you personally resear\n\n11 out Florida Statute 905.27?\n12\n\nA.\n\nI read every word of C\n\n13 at Law Review articles. Ire\n14 University, Valparaiso a\n15 process, grand ju\n\n. Hooked\ne from Catholic\n\nthereabout the grand jury\noth federal cases and state\n\n16 cases. I found fi ery qe orted case under 905.27, which\n17 particularly\n18 disc\n\nIt with the issues that we were\n\ngo b fore and that Mr. Aronberg testified about,\n\n19\n\nat ent back to even the predecessor statute to\n\n2\n\n, which is into the 1920s. And I tried to find\n\n21 egislative history on the statute, but there wasn't any.\n22\n\nSo I amassed 50, 60 cases under the statute\n\n23 going back from the '20s, '30s, '40s, '50s, '60s, et\n24 cetera, under 905.27. I read all of them.\n25\n\nQ.\n\nIt sounds like a great deal of research,\nwww.phippgreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734763\n\n\f", "char_count": 1379}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 113, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 110\n\n1 but did you engage in any other research before filing\n2 the initial complaint?\n3\n\nA.\n\nWell, federal as well, not only under the\n\n4 state, but I wanted to see, you know, who to sue, to be\n5 honest with you, in this case. We had a debate amongst\n6 ourselves as to who the proper defendants were going to\n\nAk\n\n7 be, and my principal responsibility was determining under AS\n8 Florida law who that would be.\n9\n\nCO\n\nSo I had extensive experience as an\n\n10 assistant attorney general on suing, at leas\n11 defending state officials in not only 19\\\n12 many other type of cases where\n13 in their official capacity. So yes\n\npsi\nals are sued\nertainly\n\n14 nothing new to me.\n15\n\nI probabl\n\n16 all on the defen\n\nct 3, 400 cases like that,\n\nsidQ So I was very familiar with\n\n17 arguments mho\n‘ ir was the proper party and the role of a\n18 state\n\ncial I litigation.\n\n19Ok\n2\n\n21\n\no what did I do? I went to see whether\n\nwere other 905 cases, Chapter 905 cases where state\n\nfficials had been sued, and in particular I found two\n\n22 cases. One was a state case and one was a federal case.\n23 The state case was James vs. Wille and, coincidently,\n24 actually involved the predecessor to Barry Krischer, and\n25 that case involved the beating of an inmate at the Palm\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734764\n\n\f", "char_count": 1352}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 114, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 111\n\n1 Beach County Jail out by Belle Glade, and that individual\n2 sought grand jury testimony, and the state attorney was\n3 named as a party in the case and, in fact, participated\n4 in the case as to whether or not grand jury secrecy under\n5 the statute -- you know, the extent of it and made legal\n6 arguments opposing such.\n7\n\nQ.\n\nSo we're talking about some of the cases\n\n,010A'\n\n8 you relied upon -9\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\n-- in determining that the state a'\n\n11 was a necessary party defendant, an\n12 -- you mentioned James vs. — W\n\nto pull up\ne\n\nmes vs. Wille\n\n13 case?\n14\n\nA.\n\nYeah, James*\n\nWille, correct.\n\n15\n\nQ.\n\nAnd that'\n\nt.\"36. Can you just let me\n\n16 know if Exhibit 3\n\ncase you were talking about?\n\n17\n\nA.\n\nl t, e4r,\nthat's the case.\n\n18\n\n4 it A\n\n19\n\np ifically with regard to the state attorney\n\n2\n\ncsarily being a party?\n\n21\n\nA.\n\nwere there any other cases you relied\n\nYes. An 11th Circuit case called In re\n\n22 Grand Jury. It's a Federal 11th Circuit Court of Appeals\n23 case.\n24\n25\n\nMS. WHETSTONE: And that's in Your Honor's\nbinder, the Authorities binder at tab 11. We'll\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734765\n\n\f", "char_count": 1187}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 115, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 112\n\n1\n\npull that up.\n\n2 BY MS. WHETSTONE:\n3\n\nQ.\n\nIs that the In re Grand Jury case?\n\n4\n\nA.\n\nYes, that's the case.\n\n5\n\nQ.\n\nSo what were the three -- what were the\n\n6 reasons the state attorney was named a defendant?\n7\n\nA.\n\nWell, this case particularly, the state\n\n8 attorney was from Broward County named in this ca .O\n9 It's a little complicated facts, but essentially there\n10 was a federal grand jury that issued a sub\n\nthe\n\n11 Broward County State Attorney seeki\n12 grand jury materials for a particul\n13 the Broward County attorne\n14 participated in this case,\n\norney\n.ation, and\nn see here,\n\nbo jected to the release of\n\n15 such under 905.27.\nAnd I\n\n16\n\n17 language fr>\n18 atto\n\ncularly interested in the\nhis case which said that the state\n\ns ro was an essential one because his or her\n\n19 r\n\nas\n\n2\n\ned grand jury secrecy.\n\n2\n\nprotect the grand jury process, which\n\nSo, based upon the James vs. Wille case and\n\n22 this case and my background in defending state officials,\n23 I felt that the state attorney here in his official\n24 capacity was a necessary party because someone had to\n25 advocate one way or the other for grand jury secrecy if\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734766\n\n\f", "char_count": 1247}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 116, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 113\n\n1 the state attorney decided that's what he wanted to do.\n2 But, if we didn't name the state attorney, we were\n3 denying that state official and that office the right to\n4 object under secrecy laws.\n5\n\nSo the purpose was to allow the state\n\n6 attorney, if he chose to do so, to object to the\n7 disclosure under 905.27 and to advocate for the state\n8 secrecy interest, and that was a prime issue of wh\n9 was named.\n10\n\nQ.\n\nWere there other reasons?\n\n11\n\nA.\n\nWell, we weren't sure wha\n\n12 attorney's office had. We knew\n13 state attorney's office had\n\n16 completely sure\n17\n\nS\n\ne point the\naterials because\n\n14 that's -- under Mr. Kris\n15 He presented this\n\nt\n\nwhat had occurred.\nd jury. So we weren't\n\nodwhat.\n\ne also believed, and I still believe,\nsy\n\n18 that\n\nstazdoes not prohibit the state attorney\n\n19\n\nesting the state attorney to look at grand jury\n\n2\n\nerials, not disclose it to the public, but merely to\n\n2\n\nisclose it to the state attorney if the state attorney\n\n22 wanted to look at it.\n23\n\nSo we were hopeful that, if the state\n\n24 attorney was interested in looking at these materials,\n25 that he would say that he had the right to look at them\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734767\n\n\f", "char_count": 1260}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 117, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 114\n\n1 under 905.27 and then, if so, ask the Court for an\n2 in-camera review before release to the public.\n3\n\nSo those are the three issues we were\n\n4 concerned with.\n5\n\nQ.\n\nDid Greenberg Traurig conclude that the\n\n6 state attorney was a necessary party to this case\n7 regardless of whether it had possession of the grand jury 4S ,\n\ncip\n\n8 materials?\n9\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nAnd was that conclusion a yes?\n\n11\n\nA.\n\nYes, it was.\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\nSo, after the complain\n\n13 complaint was filed in Nove\n14 had with the state attor\n\ni 'hal\n19, were discussions\n\ncou sel and the counsel for\n\n15 the clerk?\n16\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n17\n\nQ.\n\n18\n\n.\n\nWhat were those discussions?\n\\/ ----'7\nWell, we had discussions about the case,\n\n19\n\n< la\n\n2\n\nwhere this is going, did they have\n\nions and, if so, under what basis did they have\n\n21\n\nbjections.\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\nAfter the complaint -- the initial\n\n23 complaint was filed, what position did the state attorney\n24 take in the case?\n25\n\nA.\n\nTook two -- Took two positions. He filed\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734768\n\n\f", "char_count": 1087}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 118, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 115\n\n1 an answer, and that answer contained a motion to dismiss.\n2\n\nQ.\n\nBacking up. Sorry. After the initial\n\n3 complaint was filed, what was the -- what was the\n4 position taken by the state attorney to the initial\n5 complaint, just the Count 2?\n6\n\nA.\n\nOkay.\n\n7\n\nQ.\n\nSorry, just Count 1.\n\n8\n\nA.\n\nHis position was that grand jury secrecy\n\n410•\n\n9 was preeminent under 905.27, and that statute bardt\n10 release of the materials. He also argued t\n11 statute was only operative where ther\n\nnding\n\n12 civil case and a pending criminal\n\na\n\nsince the\n\n13 Epstein case was not pendi\n\nvolving the Post,\n\n14 or the criminal case, the\n\nas n>5 criminal case in Palm\n\n15 Beach County, we\n\ne any position or standing\n\n16 under the statut to s\n\nthe materials on behalf of the\n\n17 Palm Beac\n18\n\n.\n\nst.\n\nDi the state attorney file a motion to\n\n19 ¢iSf<• s e initial complaint?\n2\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n21\n\nQ.\n\nWhat was your reaction to that?\n\n22\n\nA.\n\nWell, I was hopeful that they wouldn't\n\n23 object or seek to dismiss it, but I understood that they\n24 had a statutory obligation to protect grand jury secrecy,\n25 so I didn't take it personally or anything like that. I\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734769\n\n\f", "char_count": 1241}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 119, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 116\n\n1 understood the role that they were playing because that\n2 was the role we gave them the opportunity to play in this\n3 case. So I was neither surprised, nor upset that they\n4 played that role, because that's the opportunity we gave\n5 them.\n6\n\nQ.\n\nDid the clerk file a motion to dismiss the\n\n7 initial complaint as well?\n8\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n9\n\nQ.\n\nAfter the state attorney filed his motion\n\n10 to dismiss the initial complaint, what did th\n\no in\n\n11 response?\n12\n\nA.\n\nAfter the initial -- Well,\n\n13 amendment to the -- to the\n14\n\nQ.\n\nDid you take\n\n15 other causes of ac •\n16\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n'Shit.\nka\n\nhether there were\n\nuld assert?\ndd\n\ned to develop the First\n\n17 Amendmen kue\nr in more depth and argue that the Post had\n18 righ\n\nder e First Amendment, as well as the statute,\n\n19 iCy •*u\n2\n\nion with the statute to obtain the materials,\n\nII as an argument that I had developed which was\n\n21 hat the Court has inherent authority as the ultimate\n22 supervisor of the grand jury system under the Florida\n23 Constitution to prevent abuse of the grand jury system,\n24 and we felt that the Court had such authority. That was\n25 the Clayton case that I was relying on.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734770\n\n\f", "char_count": 1255}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 120, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 117\n\n1\n\nQ.\n\nWe're going to pull up Exhibit 9, which is\n\n2 the amended complaint in this matter.\n3\n\nCould you confirm to me that's the first\n\n4 amended complaint?\n5\n\nA.\n\nYes, I see that. That's on the board here.\n\n6 Yes, it's in front of me as well.\n7\n\nQ.\n\nAnd we'll turn to it, but the state\n\n8 attorney answered Count 1 of this amended complai O\n9 which was the count for declaratory judgment; is th\n10 correct?\n11\n\nA.\n\nThat is correct. They mov\n\ns,\n\n12 they moved to dismiss Count 2,\n\nre statutory\n\n13 claim, and they answered th\n\nory judgment which\n\n14 was the mixture of First11 ndrrlhnt, statute, inherent\n15 authority of the Cou\n16\n\nQ.\n\nWhat\n\n17 answer to tl\n\nrecall about reviewing the\n\nst amended complaint for declaratory\n\n18 relief['\n19\n2\n21\n\n'\n\noZ\n\n,Well, they continued to oppose the release\n\nmaterials under 905.27 asserting grand jury\n\necrecy and asserting that we didn't have a claim under\n\n22 the statute. I did note that they admitted in\n23 paragraph 72 that the case was brought in good faith, and\n24 that's particularly the declaratory judgment one. That\n25 stood out to me.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734771\n\n\f", "char_count": 1192}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 121, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 118\n\n1\n\nQ.\n\nWe'll pull that up. I think we've seen it\n\n2 a couple times. We'll pull it up.\nPlease let me know if this comparison of\n\n3\n\n4 Exhibit 9 and Exhibit 10 is the paragraph you're talking\n5 about.\nA.\n\n6\n\nRight, right, yes, that they refused to\n\n7 provide access. That's through their objection to the\n8 clerk to testimony, minutes and other evidence. Aga'\n9 this was not just simply transcripts. It was much\n10 broader than that. And that a good faith d'\n\n'sts,\n\n11 and they admitted all of that.\n12\n\nQ.\n\nDid Count 1 for decla\n\n13 force the state attorney to pr\n\nc\n\nseek to\numents that he did\n\n14 not have?\n15\n\nA.\n\nNo.\n\n16\n\nQ.\n\nDid t\n\n17 office did n\n18 jury\n19\n2\n21\n\n•\n\nsta attorney's position that his\nye possession or custody of the grand\n\nrial\nnd the need for his office to be a party\n? lr\nde aratory relief claim?\nA.\n\nNo, and really the proof of that is what\n\nctually occurred, which is they moved forward with their\n\n22 motion to dismiss and ultimately a motion for summary\n23 judgment.\n24\n\nSo they opposed the release of the\n\n25 materials, as was their right, under the statute\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734772\n\n\f", "char_count": 1190}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 122, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 119\n\n1 asserting grand jury secrecy. So it actually proved why\n2 we put them in the case, which is to give them the\n3 opportunity on behalf of the office officially to assert\n4 grand jury secrecy, which is what they did. So, in\n5 effect, it worked. They took advantage of the\n6 opportunity and asserted that we were not entitled to it\n7 under the statute's grand jury secrecy provisions.\n8\n\nQ.\n\nOn June 8th, 2020, Judge Marx -- did Jud\n\n9 Marx enter an order on the motion to dismiss Cou\n10 under Florida Statute 905.27?\n11\n\nA.\n\nShe did.\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\n13\n\nA.\n\nAnd what was -- what\nA\nShe determined t?iSh\n\n14 well, that the statute did\n\nNr4ling?\nst lacked --\n\ncreate a private right of\n\n15 action, that it was li\n\nt those who were seeking the\n\n16 materials in the\n\ncivil case and a pending\n\n17 criminal caet o she did it on a very narrow ground.\n18\n\nA. T t order -- sorry.\n\n19\n\nNGo right ahead.\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\n21y\n\nMr. Mendelsohn, go ahead.\nOkay, that order did not address the\n\n22 declaratory judgment claim in Count 1, did it?\n23\n\nA.\n\nNo.\n\n24\n\nQ.\n\nWhen did the state attorney send its\n\n25 initial what he calls place-marker 57.105 demand letter\nwww.phippgreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734773\n\n\f", "char_count": 1232}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 123, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\nPage 120\n\n1 and motion for fees?\n2\n\nA.\n\nWithin hours of the order from Judge Marx\n\n3 was issued, I believe, on June 8, 2020.\n4\n\nQ.\n\nAnd at that point why was the state\n\n5 attorney kept in the case?\n6\n\nA.\n\nWell, they were still objecting to\n\n7 disclosure under Count 2, under the declaratory judgment.\n8 They were still asserting that grand jury secrecy and\n9 statute could not be overcome by the First Amend\n10 by the Court's inherent authority, and that t'\n11 inherent authority was limited by the s\n12 obviously thought was sort of the\n\nrt'\nich we\n\n, that the\n\n13 statute or the legislature cou np\n\nit the Court's\n\n14 inherent authority beca\n\ne\n\n15 and the legislature\n\nhts. So that issue still\n\niciary had its rights\n\n16 remained.\n17\n\nQ.\n\n18 coun\n\nQ•\n\nou write to the state attorney's\n\nandVey\nl yout the Post's reasons for continuing to\n\n19 i Clt a\n\nstate attorney in the case?\n\n2\n\nA.\n\nYes. That's my letter of June 23rd, 2020.\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nAnd we'll go ahead and pull that up.\n\n22 That's Exhibit 16.\nIs that the letter that you're referring\n\n23\n24 to?\n25\n\nA.\n\nYes.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734774\n\n\f", "char_count": 1158}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 124, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\nPage 121\n\n1\n\nQ.\n\nAnd your letter set forth the reasons why\n\n2 the state attorney was named as a party in the case -3\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n4\n\nQ.\n\n-- and continued to be named?\n\n5\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n6\n\nQ.\n\nDid the state attorney's office ever\n\n7 address the second reason for keeping the state attorney \"4\\\n8 in the case in response to this letter?\nA.\n\n9\n\nI never received a written response to th\n\n0\n\n,‘\n\n10 letter.\n11\n\nQ.\n\nAnd that second reason w\n\n12 -- that the state attorney's office won\n13 tasked with protect\n14\n\nA.\n\nCorrect.\n\n15\n\nQ.\n\nAnd, in\n\nas the\ncial\n\ngrand ' rNcr cy?\n\ni\n\n.\"'\ndid you cite a case to\n\n16 the state attome\n17\n\nA.\n\nI cited to In re Grand Jury\n\n18 Pro c ings, he 11th Circuit case.\n19\n2\n\nDid you have discussions with the state\n)Q.\ney's counsel after this point, after writing this\n\nc\n\n21 etter?\n22\n\nA.\n\nYes, with Mr. Wyler.\n\n23\n\nQ.\n\nAnd what were they?\n\n24\n\nA.\n\nWhat are we going to do about this case\n\n25 essentially. Is the state attorney going to oppose us?\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734775\n\n\f", "char_count": 1062}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 125, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\nPage 122\n\n1 Is he continuing to oppose us? Because I never received\n2 a response to my June 23rd letter, and I wanted it to be\n3 understood that we honestly believed that the state\n4 attorney had a necessary role to play in their official\n5 capacity. We were hopeful that they would take a neutral\n6 position, but they remained adamant that they had to\n7 protect grand jury secrecy under the statute, which we\n8 respected.\n9\n\nQ.\n\n0\nAnd I don't want to know the substance\n\n10 settlement discussions, if there were any,\n11 settlement discussions go on with the\n\ney's\n\n12 counsel after the June 23rd lette\n13\n\nA.\n\nYes. Yes, they dIS h\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nAnd is that i\n\n15 of June, June 8th, 2\n16\n\nA.\n\n17\n\nQ.\n\nte\n\nthe timeline here\n\ntq ctober 15th, 2020?\n\nYes. With M. Wyler, yes.\nler.\n\n18\n\nH was a very nice man on the phone. We\n\n19\n\nood conversations, very professional.\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nThe state attorney filed his motion for\n\n21 ees on July 1st, 2020; is that correct?\n22\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n23\n\nQ.\n\nAnd is this the state attorney's first\n\n24 motion for fees that was filed on July 1st, 2020?\n25\n\nA.\n\nIt is.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734776\n\n\f", "char_count": 1175}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 126, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 123\n\n1\n\nQ.\n\nDid the initial 57.105 motion as filed set\n\n2 forth any of the grounds for the motion?\n3\n\nA.\n\nNo, it didn't. It just said that they were\n\n4 entitled to 57.105.\n5\n\nQ.\n\nSo, after this point, did you -- did the\n\n6 Post and Greenberg seek discovery from the clerk?\n4,44,\nAlik'\n\n7\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n8\n\nQ.\n\nAnd this was in the litigation?\n\n9\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nWhat discovery did you seek fr\n\nthe lerk?\n\n11\n\nA.\n\nWe wanted to know wheth\n\nt\n\nO\n\ny—\n\n12 well, first, whether the state attor\n13 Mr. Krischer had asked for a\n14 clerk had had, and, also\n\nNip aterials that the\n\netheTthe FBI and U.S.\n\n15 Attorney's Office h\n\ne clerk to provide such\n\n16 materials. And eradicated to us in response to\n17 a request th\n\nie clerk's office had done so, though\n\nY\n18 they jre va9uee as to why and when.\nAnd what — did you serve\n\n19\n2\n\ngatories —\n\n21\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\n-- and document —\n\n23\n\nA.\n\nRequests, yes. We wanted to see a log of\n\n24 the materials in the grand jury sealed -- that the clerk\n25 had sealed. We hoped that there was a log indicating\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734777\n\n\f", "char_count": 1138}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 127, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 124\n\n1 what was in there, not really specifically what was in\n2 there, but by category, whether it was a transcript,\n3 whether there were exhibits and/or whether there were\n4 affidavits or whether there were deposition transcripts.\n5 Whatever there was in there, we wanted to understand.\n\nti\n\nThe clerk had responded that they don't\n\n6\n\n7 keep a log, so they couldn't tell us unless the seal was\n8 broken what was in there.\n9\n\nQ.\n\n0\n\nIn August of 2020, the state attorney's\n\n10 office filed a motion for summary judgmen\n\ntiw\n\n11 correct?\n12\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\nAnd Exhibit 19,\n\n14 attorney's motion for s\n\nas\n\nthis the state\n\nary f dgment that's on the\n\n15 screen?\n16\n\nA.\n\n17\n\nQ.\n\n18 judg\n19\n2\n2\n\nA.\n\nO\n\nYes,\n\ns.\n\nAnd, in support of this motion for summary\n\\/t, did Mr. Aronberg file an affidavit in support?\nHe did.\nMS. WHETSTONE: If you could go to 18,\n\nplease.\n\n22 BY MS. WHETSTONE:\n23\n\nQ.\n\nAnd is 18 the State Attorney Dave\n\n24 Aronberg's affidavit in support?\n25\n\nA.\n\nIt is.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734778\n\n\f", "char_count": 1077}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 128, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 125\n\n1\n\nCI\n\nAt this point, after the affidavit had been\n\n2 filed, had the state attorney responded to another one of\n3 the reasons that he had been named as a necessary party\n4 to the action?\n5\n\nA.\n\nNo. They focused exclusively on possession\n\n6 rather than their position protecting the grand jury's\n7 secrecy issue which they had advocated for.\n8\n\nCI\n\nSo did the state attorney's affidavit and\n\nC)ACIC\n\n9 motion for summary judgment address In re Grand\n10 Proceedings or any of that — any point in y\n11 about his office being able to prevent\n12 releasing grand jury materials?\n13\n\nA.\n\nNo, they never re\n\n14\n\nCI\n\nWas there sf\n\n15 time in August 202\n\nthat.\nactu issue\n\nAt this\n\nre still a factual issue as\n\n16 to whether the s to aft mey had physical possession of\n17 copies of grand 9ry materials?\n18\n\nWall, we knew at one point Mr. Krischer\n\n19 obvious had to have had such. We also had -- We were\n2\n\nthe belief that there were communications, on very\n\n21\n\ntrong grounds, between Mr. Krischer's office and\n\n22 Mr. Dershowitz and other defense counsel, as well as the\n23 FBI and U.S. Attorney leading up to and including the\n24 indictment, the non-prosecution agreement, as well as the\n25 sentencing report.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734779\n\n\f", "char_count": 1306}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 129, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 126\n\nWe never received any such, and we knew\n\n1\n\n2 they were out there. Exactly who had them, where they\n3 were, we weren't sure. We learned in hindsight that the\n4 U.S. Attorney's Office had been provided with such by the\n5 clerk's office. This is the Palm Beach County clerk's\n6 office.\n7\n\nQ.\n\nSo fast forwarding a bit to October 2nd,\n\n8 2020, did Greenberg and the Post -- sorry -- did the P\n9 file a response to the state attorney's first\n10 place-marker 57.105 motion?\n11\n\nA.\n\nWe did.\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\nAnd if you could pull u\n\n13\n\nA.\n\nWhich one is this\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\n20.\n\n15\n\nA.\n\nThat's whbtlKh sght. Okay.\n\n16\n\nQ.\n\nIs thi the Q is response, memorandum of\n\nq 0\n\nib\n\n17 law of the pt' trff to the state attorney's -18\n\nT t is correct.\n\n' IQN-- 57.105 sanction motion?\n19 CIN\n2\n\nNh-) A.\n\n21\n\nQ.\n\n22\n23\n\nYes. I drafted this, yes.\nOn page 8 -MS. WHETSTONE: Gerard, do you mind going\n\nto page 8.\n\n24 BY MS. WHETSTONE:\n25\n\nQ.\n\nDid you again raise the state attorney's\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734780\n\n\f", "char_count": 1052}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 130, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 127\n\n1 ability to object to release of grand jury records?\n2\n\nA.\n\nYes. I cited to In re Grand Jury\n\n3 Proceedings again.\n4\n\nQ.\n\nIf you look at the screen, is that on page\n\n5 8? Is that where you cited to?\n6\n\nA.\n\nCorrect.\n\n7\n\nQ.\n\nAnd at this point, the state attorney still\n\n8 had not responded to this reason he was named as\n9 is that correct?\n10\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n11\n\nQ.\n\nSo then on October 14th,\n\n12 state attorney file a reply to this r\n13\n\nA.\n\n14\n15\n\nYes.\nMS. WHETST\n\nI\n\nuld you pull up\n\nExhibit 21.\n\n16 BY MS. WHETS\n17\n\nQ.\n\nMp\n\n18 sup c of,th\n\ns the state attorney's reply in\nrst place-marker motion for fees?\n\n19\n0\n\nNk.\n\n2\n\nion for fees.\n\n21\n\nQ.\n\nYes, it's in response to their June 2020\n\nSo this is not a reply to the 57.105 motion\n\n22 we're here on today, right?\n23\n\nA.\n\nThat's correct.\n\n24\n\nQ.\n\nThis is a reply to the original June\n\n25 place-marker motion for fees, correct?\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734781\n\n\f", "char_count": 975}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 131, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1\n\nA.\n\nPage 128\n\nCorrect. What happened is the state\n\n2 attorney never noticed the first motion they filed for\n3 fees for a hearing, and they still haven't done that. So\n4 it's never been noticed for hearing.\nThere was a little dispute between myself\n\n5\n\n6 and Mr. Wyler as to whether or not the fee motion that he\n7 had filed in June should be heard first or their motion\n8 for summary judgment should be heard first, and the\n9 a case management conference before Judge Haf\n10 Judge Hafele decided that the state attom\n\ndecide\n\n11 the order of when that would occur.\n12 -- what hearing would go first, I fil\n13 their fee motion that they file\n\nd\n\ning when\nonse to\nune, and that\n\n14 was Exhibit 20, and the\n\nres nded in Exhibit 21.\n\n15\n\nention to pages 1\n\nQ.\n\nAnd I'll\n\n16 through 2 of Ex\n17\n\nnd the state attorney's reply --\n\nA.\nI\n\n18\n\nnd here it's highlighted on the\n\n19\n2\n\nA.\n\nYep, I see that.\n\n211.\n\nQ.\n\nIt says, \"Nonetheless, the state attomey\n\n22 has no objection and never has had any objection to the\n23 clerk releasing the records sought by the plaintiff.\"\n24\n\nWas this the first time the state attorney\n\n25 -- the state attorney stated his office would not object\nwww.phippgreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734782\n\n\f", "char_count": 1268}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 132, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 129\n\n1 to the release of grand jury materials if ordered by the\n2 Court?\n3\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n4\n\nQ.\n\nSo, after your reply -- sorry -- after your\n\n5 response on October 2nd, then on October 14th, the state\n6 attorney for the first time stated in a filing that he\n7 had no objection to the production of Epstein grand jury\n8 materials by the clerk?\n\nAgRe\n\nCP\n\n9\n\nA.\n\nThat's accurate, yes.\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nWas this a change from the stat:\n\n11 prior position about releasing grand ju\n12\n\nA.\n\nAbsolutely.\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\nHow would you d\n\n14 initial -- from his initial re\n\nnse\n\ney's\ns?\n\nchange from the\nthe initial\n\n15 complaint to this rep\n16\n\nA.\n\nInitiall\n\nfilled why they were in\n\n17 the case, w1 • ‘ is they objected to the release of the\n\ne c\ns\n\n18 mate '\n19\n2\n21\n\nun7 er 905.27, and now they were taking a\n\nI p sition, and they were no longer advocating the\n\nIC\n\nmacy of 905.27 and its secrecy provisions as a bar\n\nr prevention or preventive for the release of grand jury\n\n22 materials. They were no longer taking that position.\n23 They were no longer taking any position.\n24\n\nQ.\n\nWhat was your reaction to this change?\n\n25\n\nA.\n\nWell, I was pleased.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734783\n\n\f", "char_count": 1227}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 133, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 130\n\n1\n\nQ.\n\nDid you send a letter -- a settlement\n\n2 letter on October 15th in response to this October 14th\n3 position in the reply?\n4\n\nA.\n\nYes. I did it pretty quickly after I saw\n\n6\n\nQ.\n\nThe next day?\n\n7\n\nA.\n\nThe next day. Well, I started writing it\n\n5 it.\n\n8 on the 14th, but, yes, we sent it on the next day.\n9\n\nQ.\n\nOkay, and I'll pull up Exhibit 22.\nIs this your letter to Mr. Wyler wi\n\n10\n\n11 regard to the reply?\n12\n\nA.\n\nYes. Since they had\n\n13 position, I didn't see a point\n14 not they should remain •\n\nec<' o)a neutral\nling whether or\n\ne\n\ne, and that's what the\n\n15 purpose of this wa\n16\n\nQ.\n\nAnd\n\nit y\n\nsay you were pleased about\n\n17 them chap\n18\n\n.\n\n19\n\nI sed to read that they -- the state attorney's\n\n21\n\nand unequivocal statement in their response filed\n\n2\n\nYbs, yes. In the second paragraph, I said\n\nyesterday that their office will not oppose the Post's\n\n22 request for access to the Jeffrey Epstein grand jury\n23 materials. I was pleased.\n24\n\nQ.\n\nOnce the state attorney's office said that\n\n25 it would no longer object to release of the grand jury\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734784\n\n\f", "char_count": 1166}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 134, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 131\n\n1 materials by the clerk, what was\n\ns and\n\n2 the Post's response?\n3\n\nA.\n\nWe had a team meeting and ultimately\n\n4 discussion with the Post as to whether or not the state\n5 attorney should remain in the case. We had, for the\n6 first time, Mr. Aronberg's affidavit. He had previously\n7 stated that position, but for the first time in a\n8 pleading or an affidavit filed in the case, he said he\n\nO\n)\n\n4S\"\n\n9 clearly didn't have possession. And he's now takinc a\n10 neutral position. Because of the change in\n\nn that\n\n11 this neutrality had now created, we h\n\nerious\n\n12 discussion as to whether or not h\n\nemain in the\n\n13 case because, remember, o\n\necessary party prongs\n\n14 that I had mentioned pr\n\nsly as to give Mr. Aronberg\n\n15 the opportunity as\n\ney to voice either his\n\n16 objection to the\n\nor his neutrality or maybe his\n\n17 support.\n18\n\nNotw he decided to change from opposition to\n\n19\n\nli , and, since that was the case, we determined\n\n2 Ot\n\nely to drop him from the case, that there was no\n\n21\n\nhe had exercised his option and made a decision, and\n\n22 we were happy that he had done so.\n23\n\nQ.\n\nWas -- What date was the state attorney\n\n24 dropped as a party to the action?\n25\n\nA.\n\nIt was in October. Was it October 21st?\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734785\n\n\f", "char_count": 1329}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 135, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 132\n\n1\n\nQ.\n\nWe'll pull up Exhibit 23.\n\n2\n\nA.\n\nOkay, I've got it in front of me. It was\n\n3 October 21st, 2020.\n4\n\nQ.\n\nAnd is this Exhibit 23 the notice of\n\n5 dropping the state attorney as a party?\n6\n\nA.\n\nCorrect.\n\n7\n\nQ.\n\nAfter this, 19 days after this, did the\n\n8 state attorney file an amended motion for fees under\n9 57.105?\n10\n\nA.\n\nHe did.\n\n11\n\nQ.\n\nIs that the motion we're he\n\n12\n\nA.\n\nCorrect. That's the on\n\nthe\n\n13 state attorney has noticed fo\n14\n\nWe're pulling\n\n...e\nxhi t 25, and, once it's\n\n15 up, I'd like you to co r ,\n\nhis the amended motion\n\nQ.\n\n16 for sanctions th\n17\n\nA.\n\n18\n\n%. t‘t\n\n19 TrIRNP\n2\n\n.-)A.\n\n21\n\nQ.\n\nere on today?\n\nY,\n'\nthis amended motion ever served on you\nanytime before it was filed?\nNo.\nDoes the amended motion set forth new and\n\n22 different BCs for the motion for sanctions than compared\n23 to the first what they call place-marker motion?\n24\n\nA.\n\nAbsolutely.\n\n25\n\nQ.\n\nWhat were some of those new arguments?\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734786\n\n\f", "char_count": 1041}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 136, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 133\n\n1\n\nA.\n\nWell, ultimately the major new argument was\n\n2 that he now had neutrality in the case. That was a\n3 massive change in the position of the state attorney\n4 which was not the situation back when they first made\n5 their place-holder motion, and this is the words they\n6 used back in June. This was a sea change as far as we\n7 were concerned in the status of the case.\n8\n\nQ.\n\nAnd you told the state attorney that was te\n\nCSS'\n\n9 the basis for its joinder back in the beginning of th\n10 case?\n11\n\nA.\n\nAs a necessary party, yes.\n\n12 were no longer advocating secret\n13 neutrality, that's why we droppS\ned\n14\n\nQ.\n\nAnd I'll move\n\n15 be my last exhibit, t\n\nthey\nw had adopted\nfrom the case.\n\nhatTthink is going to\ndgment, which is\n\n16 Exhibit 30.\n17\n\nA.\n\n18\n\nA. Dt the Post -- So did the Post file a\n\n19\n\n' br summary judgment against the clerk --\n\n2\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n21\n\nQ.\n\n-- as to the declaratory relief claim?\n\n22\n\nA.\n\nYes. They were the remaining party in the\n\nQ.\n\nAnd Judge Hafele heard argument on that\n\n23 case.\n24\n\n25 motion for summary judgment?\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734787\n\n\f", "char_count": 1152}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 137, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 134\n\n1\n\nA.\n\nHe heard it for about two and a half hours,\n\nQ.\n\nAnd was this the same declaratory judgment\n\n2 yes.\n3\n\n4 count that had been asserted against the state attorney\n5 that had been dismissed against him after he said he had\n6 no objection to the clerk releasing documents?\n7\n\nA.\n\nIt was Count 1. That was the same count\n\n8 that we had against the state attorney and the clerk,\n9 that had been dropped against the state attorney a\n10 time I argued the motion for summary jud\n\nfront of\n\n11 Judge Hafele in September of 2020 0\n\n2020.\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\nAnd Judge Hafele ent\n\n13 motion for summary judgme\n\nn rder on a\ncame this final\n\n14 judgment; is that right?\n15\n\nA.\n\nCorrect.\n\n16\n\nQ.\n\nAnd g ng ifough it, on page 5, the Court\n\n17 noted that ti\n18 what,yc\ns ith\n\nost's position was -- Well, I'll ask you,\n4r\nourt's reaction in the final judgment to\n\n19\n\ns tations given by the Post?\n\n2\n\nA.\n\n21\n\nUltimately Judge Hafele determined that his\n\nands were — while he recognized that the Court had\n\n22 inherent authority and that inherent authority covered\n23 the supervision of prosecutorial abuse of the grand jury\n24 process, he felt constrained by the statute, which was\n25 905.27. So he felt ultimately that he could not exercise\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734788\n\n\f", "char_count": 1323}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 138, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 135\n\n1 inherent authority because of the limitations that he\n2 thought 905.27 contained, though, without sounding too\n3 egotistical, he was very effusive to the work that\n4 Greenberg Traurig had done, as well as the work done by\n5 the clerk's counsel.\n6\n\nQ.\n\nSo I'll draw attention to page 7. It says,\n\n7 \"The newspaper makes strong arguments to advance its WS,\n8 expansive construction of Section 905\" -9\n\nA.\n\nRight.\n\nCP\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\n-- \"27 as part of furthering justi\n\n11 then page 11, it says, \"The Court ack\n\nthe\n\n12 newspaper's vibrant and sincere\nWas that — Was tf\n\n13\n\nil nt with regard to\n\n14 Count 1?\n15\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n16\n\nQ.\n\nAnd t is\n\n17\n\nA.\n\ncount we're here on today?\n\nct. That matter is on appeal. The\n\n18 final dgme is on appeal.\n19 ryks N Thank you. That was my next question.\n2\n\nA.\n\nOkay.\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nOkay. Okay, one last question -- sorry --\n\n22 two.\n23\n\nDid you have any discussions with the\n\n24 editorial side of the Post having anything to do with the\n25 decision to sue the state attorney?\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734789\n\n\f", "char_count": 1098}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 139, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 136\n\nA. None. There was a firewall between the\n\n1\n\n2 legal arguments we were making here and whatever the Post\n3 was writing both editorially and factually. I had\n4 absolutely no conversations with the Post, nor did any\n5 member of my team as to what they were going to write.\n6 It's not my role to tell the paper what it wants to, or\n7 not, write or not write, so the legal positions that we\n8 adopted in this case were -- were the positions that\n9 as Greenberg Traurig and the paper came to the\n\nion\n\n10 of based upon the facts and the law.\n11\n\nAs to what the Post may ha\n\nto\n\n12 write or did write, I have zero inp\n\nt t, nor did\n\n13 Mr. Grygiel, nor did Ms. Boy\n\nWt even know\n\n14 what was going to be p '\n\nun I read it in the\n\n15 paper, so I did not\n\nword they were going to put\n\n16 in the paper.\n17\n\nQ.\n\n18 atto\n\nI\n\nquestion. Did suing the state\n\nin th case have anything to do with a personal\n\n19\n\ngainst the state attorney?\n\n2\n\nOtt A.\n\n21\n\nQ.\n\nSo no?\n\n22\n\nA.\n\nWe have a mutual friend. So I have no\n\nWell, I voted for Mr. Aronberg. No.\n\n23 animus against him at all. I'm not happy he has me\n24 sitting up here, to be honest with you, but, you know, I\n25 understand why he has me up here. I get that. He's not\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734790\n\n\f", "char_count": 1312}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 140, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 137\n\n1 happy being associated with Mr. Epstein. The man was\n2 reprobate. He was one of the lowest forms of humanity.\n3 So even having my name in an article, even if I'm not\n4 accused of something, I can understand why he's not happy\n5 about it.\n6\n\nBut I don't -- we didn't do this out of\n\n7 animus or lack of preparation. This was a sober decision\n8 against someone in their official capacity. I'm sorry\n9 that he feels personally offended by this, but we t\n10 great pains to make sure that there were n\n\ntions\n\n11 in the amended complaint and the co •\n\ncusing him\n\n12 of anything or of any wrongdoing e\n\ny\n\nd because\n\n13 that's just not the case that\n\nfront of us.\n\n14\n\nMS. WHETST\n\nTRank you, Mr. Mendelsohn.\n\n15\n\nSorry, w\n\nle long.\n\n16\n\nTHE\n\n. No, it's okay.\n\n17\n\nA\n\ns:v going to finish in the next 10\n\n18\n\n!luta?\n\n19\n2\n2\n22\n\nR. WYLER: No, Your Honor. That's\nimpossible for me.\nTHE COURT: So then we're not going to get\nstarted.\n\n23\n\nMR. WYLER: I don't think it would be\n\n24\n\nworthwhile for me to start and then stop in 10\n\n25\n\nminutes. It's going to take me at least\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734791\n\n\f", "char_count": 1168}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 141, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 138\n\n1 30 minutes, probably more like 45.\n2\n\nTHE COURT: Okay, so, you know, from Amelia\n\n3 Island to here is five hours?\n4\n\nMR. WYLER: Yes, sir.\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT: You're almost in Georgia.\n\n6\n\nMR. WYLER: Exactly. Your Honor, I will be\n\nAk\n\n7 here whenever you need me to be here. I'll make\n8 it happen.\n\nCO\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT: Thursday or Friday?\n\n10\n\nMR. WYLER: Honestly --\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT: How about T\n\n12\n\nMR. WYLER: -- how ab\n\nsday? Yeah,\n\n13 Thursday would be bett\n14\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n, al right, we'll come\n\n15 back in Thursda\n16\n\nMR. M\n\nOHN: In the afternoon, Your\n\n17 Honor?\n18\n19\n2\n2\n\nIHE COURT: Come back Thursday, probably\n. Give me one minute.\n‘6. (Brief interruption.)\nTHE COURT: All right, so the only thing\n\n22 left is cross examination, redirect, and then are\n23 the parties going to write closing arguments?\n24\n\nMS. WHETSTONE: If Your Honor would prefer\n\n25 it, we'd be fine with that.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734792\n\n\f", "char_count": 988}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 142, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nPage 139\n\n1\n\nTHE COURT: I prefer closing arguments that\n\n2 are written. I think things are more coherent.\n3 You know, I think the logic is tighter. If the\n4 parties don't mind writing closing arguments, I\n5 would prefer that.\n6\n\nOkay, do you want to bring your closing\n\n7 argument? I mean, I can anticipate you probably\n8 know what you're going to argue.\n9\n\n0\nMS. WHETSTONE: If we could finish ttC)\n\n10 direct -- the redirect and just make s\n\nhave\n\n11 the testimony, that we will have t\n\nript\n\n12 and add it into the closings o\n\nfr\n\nk sure that we\n\n13 have -- What do you thi\n14\n\nMR. WYLER: YNi\n„el leo\n\nr, it's going to be\n\n15 really hard for m\n\nri\n\n16 write it and th\n\nback down here again.\n\n17\n\nback, and then hand\n\nTHE \"5/4)r\nURT:\n,\nWhy don't we do this: Cross\n\n18 exa ;1;cri\natio , redirect. You'll give me a closing\n19\n2'\n2\n\nt, and you can supplement your closing\nments in writing. If I need to have an\nadditional hearing, we can do that via Zoom since\n\n22 the evidence and presentation will have concluded.\n23\n\nMS. WHETSTONE: Sounds good.\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT: Sound good?\n\n25\n\nMR. WYLER: Sounds good, yes.\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734793\n\n\f", "char_count": 1201}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 143, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\nPage 140\n\n1\n2\n3\n\nTHE COURT: All right, so we'll come back\nThursday, 1:00 p.m.\nTHE WITNESS: Am I excused, Your Honor,\n\n4 from the stand?\n5\n\nTHE COURT: Yes.\n\n6\n\nTHE WITNESS: Thank you.\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT: I know we have guests. You\n\n8 know, the Wall Street Journal will write\n9 reprobate. It's a big word. It's a big word.\n10\n\nAll right, anything else?\n\n11\n\nHave a great day, everybod\\\n\nin\n\n12 recess.\n13\n\n(The hearing adjour\n\n3 p.m.)\n\n14\n15\n16\n\nC -S)ACCLI\n\n17\n18\n\n'7*\n\n19\n\n22\n23\n24\n25\nwww.phippgreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734794\n\n\f", "char_count": 573}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 144, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1\n\nPage 141\n\nCOURT CERTIFICATE\n\n2\n3 STATE OF FLORIDA\n4 COUNTY OF PALM BEACH\n5\n6\nAelAsc\n\n7\n\nI, Lisa Begley, RPR, RMR, certify that I\n\n8\n\nwas authorized to and did stenographically rep\n\n9\n\nthe foregoing proceedings and that the tran\n\npt\n\n10\n\nis a true and complete record of my\n\nphic\n\n11\n\nnotes.\n\nN\n\n12\n13\n\nDated this 12th da\n\ntiApmber,\neC\nc\\\n2022.\n\n14\n15\n\nL\n\n16\n17\n\nRPR, RMR\n\n18\n19\n*2\n\n0\n\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734795\n\n\f", "char_count": 495}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 145, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n1\n11:5 29:13\n\n(\n\n17\n\n51:9 101:2,5\n\n10:5 11:25\n\n111:25 135:11\n\n12:5 45:2\n\n(1)\n13:23 19:21\n\n91:18 92:2\n\n118\n46:11\n\n28:3\n\n17th\n\n19:23 20:15\n\n82:16 95:1\n\n14:19\n\n19:21\n\n85:3 111:21,\n\n26:14\n\n128:14\n\n31:22 124:20,\n\n05\n:22\n2006\n\n10:5 26:2\n\n22 121:18\n12\n\n19:22\n\n9:25 10:17\n\n19\n\n(a)\n11:5,9 49:8\n\n33:6,24 35:15\n\n132:7\n\n54:14 55:20\n72:7 76:5\n\n1\n\n78:5 102:10\n\n120\n1\n\n2006-CF-9454\n\n15:18\n10:1 12:13\n\n19:10\n\n1353\n\n14:20 16:22\n\n9:9,13,20Assy\n\n980\n\n34:22 23\n\n12:12\n\n99:6\n\n37:14 40:2,4\n68:5,7,16,18\n\n12.\n\n83:5,15\n28:14,\n\n95:19,21 96:2\n91:17\n\n:8\n\n118:1\n\n9:22\n\n31:4 38:5\n\n.7\n\n45:1 91:5\n\n2013\n\n99:8 100:15\n\n15:19 50:2,4\n\n110:11\n\n55:15\n2016\n\n138:19 140:2\n\n4:2\n\n5:25 6:5\n26:10 34:6,16\n\n1st\n122:21,24\n\n130:2,8\n\n48:2 55:14,25\n\n95:11 118:4\n\n122:15 130:2\n\n137:17,24\n103\n47:16\n11\n\n2\n\n16\n\n25 103:19\n\n2\n5:7 22:5 25:7\n\n105:8 108:10,\n\n37:13 39:25\n\n20 114:13\n\n40:1,21\n\n11:9 36:16\n79:16 80:8\n120:22\n\n24,25 73:15\n76:5 101:22,\n\n15th\n\n47:14 77:10\n\n45:1 68:18\n69:19 70:13,\n\n127:11 129:5\n\n-23 33:1\n\n8:2\n2019\n\n1:42\n\n14th\n\n115:7 1\n128\n\n44:2 50:3\n\n1:00\n\n29:11\n\n103:11,13,18\n\n2012\n\n1983\n\n1374\n\n75:19,22\n\n105:22 107:\n\n23:21 29:1\n\n75:21\n\n192\n\n58:19\n\n20\n\n126:12,14\n\n23\n\n11th\n\n(4)' a\n\n19:4\n\n94:4 99:12,16\n\n18\n\n119.07\n\n(2)\n\n2.42\n\n30:1 38:1\n\n70:17\n\n119\n\n(1)(b)\n\n120:7 128:16\n\n74:23,24\n\n2020\n5:2,3 8:17\n\n103:25 115:5\n\n16:18,22,24,\n\n117:12 119:9\n\n25 25:25\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734796\n\n\f", "char_count": 1400}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 146, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n26:2,25 29:23\n30:19 36:16\n37:20 38:6\n44:5 45:2\n\n2\n22\n\n100:14\n3\n\n130:9\n222\n47:24\n\n9:25 103:25\n\n23\n80:14,15\n\n110:15\n\n12:5 132:1,4\n\n84:22 86:22\n88:1,12,15,\n17,19 89:16,\n18 91:5 92:5\n\n54:7\n23rd\n\n20 122:15,21,\n\n20 38:4 80:15\n\n24 124:9\n\n86:21 120:20\n\n125:15 126:8\n\n122:2,12\n\n20s\n\n30s\n\n.4 4i;5\n\n109:23\n30th\n\n111-\n\n78:7 109:22\n,21\n.4,13 83:5,\n6 95:20,22\n\n132:14\n26\n\n21\n10:23 16:24\n26:16 54:2\n\n96:2 105:4\n38\n\n26:8\n268\n\n128:14,16\n\n:18 103:19\n\n15:5,1\n\n95:13\n\n26:9\n\n17:2,\n27. 0, 1,17,\n:12\n\nAliPe\n54:18\n\n.5s892:10,\n\n11,25\n\n21st\n\n15:2,22,23\n16:5,7,9,10,\n\n53:13\n\n22:7,8,11,21\n23:3 25:3\n\n70:16 103:14\n\n4\n\n32:2,10 38:13\n\n4\n\n29\n9:11\n\n9:25 10:8\n400\n\n2nd\n\n31:6 57:12\n\n129:5\n\n26:13 27:1,8,\n23 28:3,6,7\n\n104:21\n\n37:19 126:7\n\n91:23 131:25\n\n8:17 51:19\n\n13 17:6 21:16\n\n27th\n\n16:19 26:2\n\n132:3\n\n6:6,10,13 8:5\n\n135:10\n276\n\n6:9\n\n5:2,8,11,16\n\n3rd\n\n21-day\n\n57\n\n57.105\n\n3:57\n\n11,18 127:15\n\n109:23\n\n20:8\n\n95:12\n\n91:16 93:10,\n\n50s\n\n57.103(a)\n\n39:1\n3:39\n\n87:19,23\n\n24 97:3\n\n50\n\n14:20\n\n30:5 94:4\n\n91:21\n\n4 :10,15\n\n134:16\n\n36\n24(a)\n\n42:21\n\n95:11 96:23,\n\n49:6,7\n\n28:14 29:8\n\n20th\n\n5\n\n138:1\n\n25\n\n109:23\n\n140:13\n\n40:25 133:16\n\n30:19 36:16,\n\n132:3 134:11\n\n4:53\n\n30\n\n235\n\n119:8 120:3,\n\n127:11,19\n\n138:1\n\n3\n\n57:12 79:2,10\n\n45\n\n110:15\n\n39:8 41:20\n42:23,24,25\n53:17,22\n54:10,19\n\n40s\n109:23\n42\n\n64:11 79:19,\n23 84:22 86:2\n87:25 90:18\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734797\n\n\f", "char_count": 1383}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 147, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n93:14 94:15\n\n3\n73\n\n101:2,4\n119:25 123:1,\n\n15:19\n762\n\n4 126:10,19\n\n5:24 6:4\n\n127:21 132:9\n8\n\n5:17 8:11\n8\n\n117:20 119:10\n\n35:8 36:1\n\n129:18,20\n\n48:17 49:16\n\n134:25 135:2\n\n50:5 55:18\n56:14,17\n\n33:9 76:3\n\n76:3,6 78:4,\n\n78:7\n\n14 118:7\n\nceased\n\n76:7\n\n120:3 126:21,\n\n5:20 13:10\n\nA9\n\n987\n\n23 127:5\n\n20:9 22:24\n\n0\n\n26:9\n8th\n997\n\n5:3 26:25\n\n19:17 20\n\n8:1\n\n54:1 119:8\n\n22:10 42:5\n\n130:22\n\n905.27(1)06\n10:8,11,17\n\n57.105(1)(b)\n\n57.105(3)(a)\n\n23:18 33:4\n\n905.27(1)\n\n57.105(1)(a)\n22:22\n\n114:1 115:9\n\n9th\n\n122:15\n59\n29:12\n9\n\n:23\n\naccompanied\n53:23\naccompanying\n55:2\n\n:18,25\n\naccounts\n\n70:13\n\n56:11\n\n5:00\n\naccurate\n\n96:17\n\n9\n\nA\n32:24\n:8 44:4,\n\n6\n\n105\n\n1;\n\naccuse\nspr,\n\n118:4\n6\n\n60:15 129:9\n\nability\n53:6 127:1\n\n90\n\n66:22\n\n21:19 35:25\naccused\n67:15 137:4\n\n11:25 28:1\n\nabove-captioned\n\n47:14 71:20\n\n55:16\n\naccusing\n67:3 137:11\n\n60\n\n9:12 110:20\n\n109:22\n\n5:8\n\nabove-described\n55:23\n\nachieve\n50:8\n\n60s\n109:23\n\n905.17\n\nabsolutely\n\n14:13\n\n9:8 11:18\n\n905.17(1)\n56:19\n(::!)\n135:6\n\n31:19 66:9,10\n\nacknowledged\n\n132:24 136:4\n\n51:3,7 67:2\n\nabuse\n116:23 134:23\n\n71\n\n905.27\n\n76:20 77:4,\n\n5:13 13:19\n\n10,12,13,14,\n\n14:24 21:16\n\n19\n\n25:8 40:7\n\n72\n\n108:23 109:8,\n\n77:23,24 78:2\n\n11,16,20,24\n\n117:23\n\n112:15 113:7\n\n66:24 83:19\n\n92:24 129:12\n\n905.21(1)(c)\n55:17\n\nacknowledge\n\nabused\n108:7\naccepting\n63:6\naccess\n\nacknowledges\n135:11\nacolytes\n58:23\nAcosta\n102:12,16,22\n104:17\n\n8:15 20:21\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734798\n\n\f", "char_count": 1445}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 148, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nacted\n\n4\n82:3\n\n33:17\n\n131:6,8\n\nadministrations\n\naction\n\naffidavits\n\n50:1\n\n5:10 6:22\n\nadmission\n\n10:25 22:5\n\n33:13\n\n38:22 40:23\n\n18:10 107:5\n124:4\n\naimed\n27:19\nAlan\n\naffirm\n\n104:3\n\n43:11 98:8\n\nadmit\n\n120:21\n\nAlbany\n\n44:8 46:1\n62:3 77:12\n47:21 48:5,9\n\naffirmative\n39:18\n\n78:15\n\nex\n\n53:4,14 55:23\nadmits\n\nafforded\n\n100:23 116:15\n\n48:7\n\n14:2\n\n119:15 125:4\n\nadmitted\n\n56:24 74:15\n\n131:24\nactual\n9:24 22:13\n\n14:9 32:17,21\n\n86:25\n\n33:12 78:11\n\nafterno\n\n96:2 117:22\n\n4:7 13\n\nadamant\nadmittedly\n\n122:6\n\n7.\n\n21:4\n\n102:12\nallegation\n28:5 46:14\nallegations\n\n19\n\n47:18,25 76:1\n\n,11\n\n137:10\n\n0 138:16\nallege\n\nadd\n108:17 139:12\n\nadmitting\n\nnda\n\n37:14 78:10444se\n\naddition\n\n62:13,16\n\n13 93:6\n\nagenda-driven\n\n33:15 35:3\n40:24 50:10,\n14 90:21\n\nadopt\n\n62:24\n\n13\n\nagree\n\n106:23\n\n10:6 66:4\n\nadditional\n\n67:17 79:7\n\n16:13 106:1\n\n^\n21:22 4A1\n\nadvocate\n\n86:\n\nadvocated\n\naddress\n\n9:21\n7 125:9\neased\n\n35:24\nadjourned\n140:13\nadministration\n\n10:14 45:24\nallowed\n77:18 93:9\n103:3\nallowing\n55:18\naloud\n\ntage\n119:5\n\n139:21\n\nad\n\n02:22 104:17\nAl\n\nafter-the-f\n\n118:11\n\n101:13 105:6\n\n112:25 113:7\n\n125:7\nadvocating\n129:19 133:12\n\ni\n\n81:24\n55:9\nagreed\n26:21 95:17\n\namassed\nagreement\n\n7 57:3\n\n109:22\n\n42:17 44:17\n95:24 102:15\n103:3 106:6\n125:24\n\n29:22 55:3,5,\n\n18:3\n\n97:15\n\naffidavit\n18:10,11\n\nalternative\n\naha\n90:13\n\nAmelia\n97:17 138:2\namended\n4:4,25 15:10,\n13,21 16:12,\n14,16,24\n\nahead\n\n6:8 19:3\n\n124:18,24\n\n9:21 93:4\n\n56:16 81:14\n\n125:1,8\n\n119:19,20\n\n17:18,24 18:7\n25:21,25\n26:12,18,22\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734799\n\n\f", "char_count": 1546}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 149, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n27:9,16 28:9,\n12 29:9,11,\n15,18,24 30:1\n\n5\n4:6\n\n68:8\n\nanticipate\n139:7\n\nappropriately\n15:8\n\n31:8,11,14\n32:25 43:4\n48:21\n\n92:3,8,16\n\n99:12 101:20\n\n132:19\napologize\n\narguable\n13:6\nargue\n\n94:6 117:2,4,\n8,17 132:8,\n\n69:18 70:5\n\n33:14 47:3,5\n\namendment\n\napparently\n5?,:8\nappeal\n\n25:11 34:11\n\n41:18 135:17,\n\n40:6 42:8\n\n18\n\n74:16 100:7,\n17,18 106:24,\n\n17,18 117:14\n120:9\nAmendments\n100:19\n\namounts\n6:19\nancilla\n107:\n\nappears\n60:9\n\n23 17:10,16\n18:15,19\n\nargument\n13:10,20 14:6\n15:12,22\n\nap\n18:14 19:25\n20:7,16,19\ncable\n:4\napplication\n\n21:8 25:18\n31:8 42:3\n47:1,2 60:10,\n\n5:21 7:4\n\n12 78:18\n\n22:25\n\n86:18 88:18\n89:2,21\n\n20:2,11,12\n\n93:21,22\n\n31:21\n\n94:1,12,13\n\napplies\n\nAngeles\n\n19:10 20:20\n23:4 28:24\n42:13 43:9,\n\n133:1,24\n\n28:8\n\n48:1,4,11\n49:15 51:8,25\n52:9,20 54:9\n55:13 63:19\n65:16,20\n66:12 68:12\n73:10 88:20,\n21 91:4 94:23\n95:5 103:20\n105:8 109:18\n124:18 131:14\n136:20\nAronberg's\n4:25 8:12\n13:11 22:7,10\n\napply\n\n136:23 137:7\n\n46:13 47:19\n\n97:3 116:20\n139:7,19\n\n19:17 27:23\n\narguments\n14:25 18:6\n\n29:22 87:24\n124:24 131:6\n\n22:17 27:9\napproach\n\nannounce\n\n1\n\n17,22 44:1,20\n\n14:14 20:8,19\n\nanimus\n\n15:3,9 16:19,\n\n88:13 92:21\n\nw\n\n106:23\n\n13:3,8,15,17\n\nargued\n\ning\n\napplied\n\n27:10\n\n10:15,20\n\n116:17\n\nappearances\n\napp\n\n15,16,17\n\n7:17 9:17\n\n5\n\namount\n107:12\n\nnberg\n\n-1,\n\n91:2 93:2\n\n111:22\n\n4:6\n\n136:2 138:23\n\n72:24 73:1\n\nAppeals\n\n25 107:2\n109:1 116:13,\n\n135:7,12\n4 2L39:1,4,20\n\n21:6 27:14\n\n137:11\n\n23 110:17\n111:6 132:25\n\nanytime\n\n16:20,22\n\n15,18,21\n\n74:19 85:19\n\napproximately\n\n44:4 45:1\n74:13,14 75:3\n\n41:10 46:23\n92:3,23 97:8,\n\nAntonacci\n\n46:8 57:5\n\n19 31:8 36:23\n\n28:10 29:16,\n\n4:21 23:7\n\nAronson\n88:19\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734800\n\n\f", "char_count": 1689}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 150, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\narose\n42:19\narrest\n33:21 102:22\narrested\n102:5\narticle\n14:20 59:1,2\n\n6\nassuming\n\n50:1,2 55:14,\n\n38:6 42:12\n\n25 71:15\n\n50:6 71:9,15\n\nattached\n\n80:12,13,19,\n\n101:18 102:6\n\n54:5\n\n20,23 81:1,25\n\n103:7 104:15,\n\n84:23,25\n\n20,24 105:1,\n\n85:7,17,18\n\n10,16,19,25\n\n87:15 88:3\n\n106:13,18\n\nattacking\n\n91:6,12 94:7,\n\n112:18\n\n61:2\n\n10 99:1,17,22\n\n11:25 80:23\n\nattacked\n58:19\n\n13:12,13\n\nt\n\n137:3\n\nattacks\n\narticles\n\n58:24\n\n102:13,20,25\n\n1\n\nattempt\n\n103:19 105\n\n12,20 122:11,\n\n26:25\n\n108:7 110\n\n23 123:15\n\n111:2,\n\n124:9,14\n\n48:15,25\n58:20 61:1,2,\n3,25 62:2,4\n73:4 109:13\narticulately\n79:13\nasks\n76:12\nassembled\n106:8 107:4\nassert\n54:13 116:15\n\nattention\n65:2 128:15\n135:6\nattorney\n4:16 6:21,24\n7:24 10:6,9\n13,16,19,\n11:13,1\n12:9\n23:\n\n5:9 74:14\n119:6 134:4\n\n,23\n:14 28:25\n:4 30:2,6,\n\n117:2\n119\nas\n\n21 31:13,17\n33:12 34:1\n35:2,10,11,\n13,19,21,23,\n25 36:7,8,10,\n\nas\n\nstant\n\n99:22 110:10\nassociates\n14:1\n\n11,17,21,25\n38:10,12,16\n40:10,13,18\n\nassume\n54:4 69:7\n93:4\n\n41:5 42:18\n43:17 44:2\n48:2 49:15\n\n:17 121:6,\n\n125:8 126:4,\n9,17,25\n\n,19,21,\n\n127:17 128:16\n\n4:6,23\n:4,18\n16:9 117:8\n\n129:10\n130:19,24\nattorneys\n\n118:13 119:24\n\n13:12,25 23:2\n\n120:5,19\n\n34:11,13\n\n121:2,7,16,25\n\n41:11 42:15\n\n125:2,16,23\n127:7,12\n\nattorneys'\n4:5 6:15\n15:7,11,14\n16:11,12,17,\n\n128:2,10,21,\n22,25 17:21\n24,25 129:6\n18:2,5,8\n131:5,15,23\n132:5,8,13\n\n38:24 39:12\n44:4 53:25\n\n133:3,8\n134:4,8,9\n\nAugust\n\n135:25\n\n29:23 68:18\n\n136:18,19\n\n69:19 103:14,\n\n37:8,21\n39:11,15\n\n14:14 118:16\n\n113:1,\n\n123:12 124:23\n\n12,15,18,20,\nasserting\n\n112:6,\n\n122:4,20\n\n119:3\nasserted\n\n100:10\n\n19 104:21\nattorney's\n5:1 6:18\n\n124:9 125:15\n134:11\n\n24:5,9,19,25\n29:21 33:2\n\nAuthorities\n\n34:20 35:2,5,\n\n26:7 39:1\n\n15 36:18 37:4\n\n111:25\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734801\n\n\f", "char_count": 1756}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 151, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n7\n\nauthority\n\n10,19 80:6,\n\n82:2,12\n\n7:23 10:22\n\n14,22 81:13\n\n102:24 106:13\n\n18:17 24:15\n\n82:3,5,12\n\n110:24\n\n55:18 56:6,\n\n84:17,21\n\n13,20 72:9\n\n86:2,21 88:1,\n\n8:6 17:5 83:7\n\n73:22 74:17\n\n12,19 89:10,\n\n108:4 112:21\n\n76:24 77:15\n\n16 92:4 93:4,\n\n136:10\n\n108:7 116:21,\n\n12 95:10\n\n24 117:15\n\n96:25 97:5,24\n\nbased\n\n10,11,24\n\nauthorized\n22:15\nauthorizing\n6:14\nAV\n\naward\n\nbasis\n\n:6 59:22\n\n104:19 106:17\n\n60:24 61:12\n\n107:13\n\n31:19 39:\n\n133:9\n\n109:19,23\n\n42:24\n\n128:13 133:4,\n\n64:2 7\n\n6,9 138:15,18\n\n114x20 175:\n\nbehalf\n4:10,14\n101:11 103:20\n115:16 119:3\n\nbackground\n\n10 47:16,\n54:7\n\n36:4 99:4\n\nbelief\n89:3 125:20\nbelieved\n\n112:22\n\nbattles\n\n6:11 19:22\n\nbacking\n\n58:17\n\n42:5 101:3\n\n33:\n\nawarding\n\n3:13 46:21\n\n5:11 13:6\n\n,16,17\n\nawarded\n\n4:2 33:22\nginning\n\n140:1\n\n6:14,17 8:4\n\n110:25\n\nbasically\n\n139:15,16\n\n100:20,21\n\n82:18\n\nbegan\n\n99:16 102:5,\n\n134:22 135:1\n\nbearing\n\nbeating\n\n80:2 85:10\n120:10,11,14\n\n17 126:5\n\n58:23 113:17\n122:3\n\nBCS\n\nbelieves\n\n132:22\n\nb\n\n74:5\n\n42:20\n\nBeach\nBelle\n\naware\n51:18 57:14,\n\n::\nad\n(;)\nad\n89:6\n\n15 90:1 109:\n\n4:11 23:20\n46:15 48:7,16\n\nBailynson\n\n-N-S-\n\n53:7,17\nBankunited\n38:25\n\nbachelor's\n99:5\nback\n21:11 58:14\n59:17,19\n63:23 64:18\n65:21 79:2,\n\nbar\n129:20\n\n4:8 51:24\n\n15,23 51:1\n\n52:8,18 58:1\n\n55:15,20\n\n60:17 62:17,\n\n58:7,16,18,21\n\n25 63:10,16,\n\n59:4,8,16\n\n18 68:1,5,7,\n\n60:5,6 62:11\n\n11 69:21\n\n65:22 68:23\n\n70:1,5,12\n\n72:7 74:13\n\n71:25 72:4\n\n91:16 101:11,\n\n74:8,11 75:8,\n\n16,18 102:20\n\n11,14,18,21,\n\n105:11,18\n\n24 77:9,11,22\n\n107:7 108:6\n\n78:1 82:22,25\n\n111:1 115:15,\n\n83:2 87:18,22\n\nbarred\n115:9\nBarry\n48:23 81:13\n\nBideau\n\n49:15 50:2,\n\n5:23 6:4 32:6\nball\n\n111:1\n\n33:2,6,22\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734802\n\n\f", "char_count": 1689}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 152, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n94:3,5,18\n\n8\nbottom\n\n11,15 20:11,\nC\n\n72:2\n\nbig\n19:13 61:16\n69:18 70:6\n102:15 140:9\n\n12 25:15\n26:3,6,9,10\n\nbox\n\nCA\n\n34:15\n\n27:5,6 28:1,2\n\n4:10 9:17\n\n31:21 32:4,7\n\nBoyajian\ncall\n\nbinder\n\n106:23 108:25\n\n8:23 23:11\n26:8 27:12\n28:1 39:2\n\n136:13\nbreak\n\n103:14 111:25\n\n42:1,2,17,18\n\n8:16\n\nO\n\n43:8\n\n34:18 94:3\n\ncalls\n\n24 66:1,13\n\n26:23\n\n8:1\n1\n96: I\n\n103:10 107:20\n139:6\n\nc\n0\n\nbroad\n84:12,13,14\n\n126:7\nbroader\nblah\n118:10\n94:11\nbroke\nblock\n\n12 .\n\nc\n\ncity\n\n34.\n75:10,14,22\n\n65:23,\n\n2 ,25 117:23\n\n87:20\nBroward\nboard\n\n48:22 59:3\n\n117:5\n\n99\nBoo\n8:\nboil\n11:10\nbook\n95:18\nbotch\n32:6\n\n11,13\n:\n\nBuitrago\n4:9\nburden\n\n15 86:4 87:15\n\n1:6,7,16\n\n91:17 93:20\n\n110:13 112:24\n\n101:3,6,11\n\n122:5 137:8\n\n107:13\n108:15,17\n109:1,16\n110:5,22,23,\n\ncared\n\n25 111:3,4,\n\n89:5\n13,16,17,21,\nCarolonga\n\n23 112:3,4,7,\n\n99:20\n\n8,14,17,21,22\n\n85:7 112:8,\nBoca\n\n85:5,8,9,10,\n\n84:25 100:16\n\n71:21 89:4\n\nblow\n\n76:11,25\n\n88:13 90:18\n\ncare\n\n12:7 73:5\n\n67:1,11,18\n77:16 78:10\n\n6\n\n33:20 70:3\n\n65:8,10,13,\n15,18,19,23,\n\nbring\n\n70:6\nbit\n\n6:2 49:25\n:15 62:6\n\ncalling\n\n96:24 97:4\nbinders\n\n38:4,25 41:9\n\n62:5 111:21\n\nbright\n\n69:18 71:20\n80:9 95:22\n\n37:10,22\n\n132:23\ncalled\n\n95:9\n\n40:25 42:21\n67:23 68:9,13\n\n36:6,9,10\n\n107:20 128:15\n\ncase\n\n114:6,18,24\n\n5:7,23,24 6:5\n\n115:12,13,14\n\n7:12,16,25\n\n116:3,25\n\n8:2,3 10:12\n\n117:23 119:2,\n\n13:24,25\n\n16,17 120:5,\n\n32:10,13\n\n14:4,11 15:4,\n\n19 121:2,8,\n\n41:22\n\n10,16,19,20\n\n15,18,24\n\n16:4,6,15,16,\n\n128:9 129:17\n\n19,23 17:5,\n\n130:14 131:5,\n\n10,16,22,23,\n\n8,13,19,20\n\n25 18:2,15\n\n133:2,7,10,\n\n19:5,6,8,9,\n\n13,23 136:8,\n\nBureau\n100:12\nbusiness\n65:3\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734803\n\n\f", "char_count": 1629}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 153, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n18 137:13\n\n9\n5:13 13:19\n\nclaim\n\n36:1,13 37:1,\n\n14:13,19,24\n\n5:12,18,21\n\n9 40:18 41:4,\n\n39:19 100:1,\n\n82:16 95:1\n\n6:21,25 7:3\n\n6,17 43:11,18\n\n7,10,14,16,17\n\n109:12 110:20\n\n8:11 15:14\n\n48:6 56:14,\n\ncases\n\n107:6,9,11\n109:2,15,16,\n22 110:11,12,\n15,20,22\n111:7,18\ncatch\n\ncharge\n85:11 106:4\nchat\n65:13\nchief\n107:7 108:5\n\n58:11\n\nchose\n\ncategory\n\n113:6\n\n124:2\n\nCircuit\n\nCatholic\n\n48:2 55:14,25\n\n109:13\n\n85:3 111:21,\n\ncenter\n\n17 61:11 62:8\n\n22 25:4,5,7,\n\n85:12 88:6\n\n10 32:14,16,\n\n90:6,7 91:6,\n\n18,22 33:14,\n\n9 94:8,14\n\n19 35:12\n\n6:9 98:8,14\n\n37:7,16 41:2,\n\n1 4:15 116:6\n\n3,12,15,23\n\n118:8 123:6,\n\n42:2,9 56\n\n10,14,15,16,\n\n74:15,\n\n24 124:6\n\n21,24\n\n14\n,21\n119:22\n\n1\n\ncircumstance\n\ncentral\n\ncircumatanc\n\ncentury\n\n6:10 77\n\n23:24\n\ncite\n\ncetera\n\n6:\n\n:9 121:17\n127:2,5\n\nchance\n93:1\n\ncites\n76:7 85:2\n\nchange\n13717\n\ncitizens\n\n6,12\n\n60:6\n\n• •,13,24\n\ncivil\n\n1:10,18\n1 3:3,6\n\n6:22 10:25\n13:23 14:4,10\n\nchanged\n\n76:10 100:13\n\n130:12\n\n107:9 115:12\n\nchanging\n39:16 130:17\n\n119:16\ncivilly\n115:13\n\n8\n\n34:18 59:3\n\n53:6 56:17\n\nclarification\n\n61:6 123:17\n\n116:25\n\n74:1\n\n133:19 134:6,\n\n37:23 38:8\n\nClayton\n\nchallenge\n\n129:8 131:1\n\n20:9 22:11\n\n53:24\n\n109:24\n\n125:11 128:23\n\nclerk,s\n\n64:13\n\n6:5\n\nchapter\n\n20,22 57:15,\n\n22 121:18\n\n58:12\n\n17:\n\n19:24 20:13\n21:7 22:3,8,\n\nclear\n14:15 19:2\n\n126:5 135:5\nclient\n65:5 73:4\n83:19 92:9\nclose\n\n26:3 56:5\n\n31:7 37:2\n\n58:6 61:12,13\n\n43:2 97:20\n\n65:1 66:17\n\ncloser\n\n89:24 94:2\n\n98:24\n\n130:20\nclerk\n\nclosing\n42:25 97:23\n\n10:9,24\n\n138:23 139:1,\n\n11:12,15,24\n\n4,6,18,19\n\n12:8 14:8,21\n\nclosings\n\n18:16 21:23\n\n139:12\n\n22:13 24:3,16\nclosure\n29:6 30:3,8,\n50:8\n13 35:9,21\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734804\n\n\f", "char_count": 1663}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 154, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\ncocaine\n59:11,13\ncoherent\n139:2\ncoincidently\n110:23\n\n10\n32:25 33:8\n44:25 45:2,24\n46:8,14 60:4\n\n99:5\n\n36:6 108:6\n114:10 136:9\n\n41:13\ncomment\n135:13\ncommercial\n99:12,18\n100:3,6\n\nconstruction\n135:8\nconstrue\n\nconclusions\n\n76:12\n\n106:20\n\nconstrued\n\ncondensed\n\n7:4\n\n81:18 86:8,\n12,15,24\n\ncommended\n\n134:24\n\nconclusion\n\n66:15,17\n75:2,3 78:6\n\nColgate\n\n56:15 139:22\n\n61:21,24\n74:13,14\n\nconstrained\n\nconcluded\n\n90:12,22,23\n108:19,22\n110:2 114:12,\n13,22,23\n\n9:3\n\ntacted\n\nconduct\n\n1\n\n43:1,2\n\n:12,19\n\nontacting\n\nconducted\n\n34:19\n\n115:3,5,19\n\n24:12\n\ncontained\n\n116:7,10,13\n\n106:11\n\n108:12 115:1\n\n117:2,4,8,17\n\n135:2\n\n129:15 137:11\ncommon\n\ncontentions\ncompletely\n\n27:3\n\n29:3 32:15\ncommunications\n105:23,24\n\n94:10\n\n38:20\ncomptroller\n48:6\n\nling\nconcern\n23:25 41:10\ncompetent\n\n50:7 58:25\n62:1 70:11\n\nconsideration\n\ncontinued\n\n25:17\n\n58:24 62:4\n108:14 117:19\n\nconsidered\n26:22\n\n121:4\n\nconsistent\n\ncontinuing\n120:18 122:1\n\n88:24\n\ncontract\n\nConstitution\n\n100:5\n\n14:20 100:19\n116:23\n\nI\n\nconcerned\n67:11,12\n114:4 133:7\n\n50:22\nconclude\ncomplaint\n\ncontinue\n\n73:10 76:10\n\n32 -\n\ncompetitor\n\n64:2\n\n:15,25\n\ncompromise\n\n8:6\n\ncontingency-fee\n\nconnection\n\n132:22\n\n7 :1,17\n\n117:3 132:15\n\n5:2 116:19\n\n27:8,12,17\n\ncompari\n\n42:16 44:16\n\nconjunction\n\ncompare\n\n56:12\ncontingency\n\n112:9\n\n58:16\n\ncompared\n\n11:23 14:18\nconfirm\n\ncomplicat\n\ncommunity\n\n28:13\n\nI\n\n41:25 113:\n\n104:10,14,18\n107:25 125:20\n\ndential\n\nconstitutional\n25:10 34:11\n\ni\n\ncontractual\n38:24\ncontrary\n\n40:6 42:8\n\n22:17 39:13\n\n100:14\n\n47:18 48:1\n\n97:6,7 114:5\n\n10:14 23:18\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734805\n\n\f", "char_count": 1591}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 155, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n11\n\ncontrol\n\n69:4,10 70:20\n\n7 117:8,9,12\n\n31:16,23\n\n7:20 8:15\n\n71:1,2,6,8,\n\n118:12 119:9,\n\n36:13 38:7\n\n10:3 20:22\n\n13,16 74:1,\n\n22 120:7\n\n39:3,6 41:15\n\n29:1 35:18,20\n\n13,17,18,22,\n\n134:4,7\n\n42:20 43:4,7,\n\n40:11,15,17\n\n24,25 76:7,15\n\n135:14,16\n\n10,18,24\n\n45:15,17,18\n\n79:10,22,24\n\n46:3,5,25\n\n82:13 83:5,15\n\n47:19 48:3,14\n\n84:15,18\n\n52:5 53:1,5,\n\n86:14 87:2,9\n\n44:18,22 46:9\n\ncountry\n\n47:14,23\n\n50:17\n\n49:12 51:21\n\ncounts\n\n2:1,11,14,21\n53:16\n\n11 56:1 59:23\n\n88:15 91:17\n\n60:25 62:10\n\n92:5,12,13,17\n\n63:8 67:21\n80:3,4 90:4\nconversations\n83:8 104:1\n122:19 136:4\n\n4:4 55:10\nCounty\n\n:22 57:15\n\n94:16,17\n\n33:6,22 48:7\n\n58:5 60:19\n\n96:5,7 111:14\n\n49:15 50:\n\n62:19 63:2,\n\n117:10,11\n\n55:15,\n\n13,15 68:6,10\n\n121:14 122:21\n\n85:7 1\n\n124:11 126:18\n\n10\n\n0\n\n127:6,9,23,25\n\ncopies\n\n128:1 132:6,\n\n37:1 84:16\n\n69:20 70:2,7\n:7\n\n74:10 75:5,9,\n\n112:8,\n\n12,16 76:2,12\n\nAct i4:5 115:15\n\n12 134:15\n\n125:17\n\n135:17\ncopy\ncorrespon\n\n23:10 26:18\n\n56:9\n\n44:11 53:19,\n\nCO=\n\n22 54:10\n\n82:21,24\nunty's\n\n88:4,7 89:11\n\n23:21\n\n91:2,11 92:15\n\ncouple\n\n94:9,19 95:5,\n\n57:19 63:21\n\n10,14,16,20,\n\n80:5 118:2\n\n21 96:5,12,\n\n55:5,6 57:7\n,10\n\n68:2\ncopyright\n100:4\n\n(\n\n4:3,18,22,24\n\n106:15\n\n6:1,17,23 7:1\n\n114:14 120:18\n\n8:3,7,21,25\n\n121:20 122:12\n\n9:6,10,14,19,\n\n125:22 135:5\n\n21 11:21\n\n24:19\nt\n:10 44:5,6\n53:19 54:16\n\ncourt\n\n: 02: 7 104:2,\n\ncounsel's\n\n12:11,14,21,\n24 13:5,22\n14:3,23\n\ncount\n17:19,23,25\n5:7,10 21:1\n22:5 25:7\n\n55:1,4 57:6,9\n\n32:25 37:13,\n\n60:10,12,16\n\n14 39:25\n\n64:14 65:13\n\n40:1,2,4,21\n\n66:18,20,24\n\n74:23,24\n\n67:6,8,19,21\n\n75:19,22\n\n68:19,20,23\n\n108:23 115:5,\n\n77:14,17,20\n\n19:23,25\n21:3,7,18,22\n22:12,16\n23:5,8,12,16,\n17 24:1,3\n\n16,19,22\n97:13,19,23,\n25 98:4,14,\n16,22 109:2\n111:22 114:1\n116:21,24\n117:15 129:2\n134:16,21\n135:11\n137:16,21\n138:2,5,9,11,\n14,18,21\n139:1,17,24\n140:1,5,7\ncourt's\n\n25:20 26:3,11\n\n6:16 8:5\n\n28:3 30:4\n\n39:20 55:18\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734806\n\n\f", "char_count": 1910}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 156, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n72:9 73:21\n\n12\nCross\n\ndate\n\n74:17 76:23\n\n63:15,17\n\n120:10,13\n\n138:22 139:17\n\n134:18\n\ndebate\n\n57:10 131:23\n\ncudgel\n\ndated\n\ndecide\n\n36:19 69:19\n\ncourtroom\n\n47:10\n\n86:18\n\ncumulative\n\ndates\n49:5\n\n107:18,19\n\n63:10\n\n6:9\n\ncuriously\n\n4:16 10:19\n\ncover\n\n50:23\n\n44:1 49:15\n\ncustodian\n\n55:13 103:19\n\ncoverage\n50:21,22\n\n113:1 116:16\n\nDave\n\n48:8 84:24\n\n105:7 124:23\n\n128:10 131:18\nd cision\n:15 41:18\n49:2 85:3\n131:21 135:25\n\nDavid\n\ncustody\n\n128:10\ndecided\n\ncourts\n\n59:9,12\n\n110:5\n\n137:7\n\n7:20 8:15\n\n4:15 1\n\n62:20 63:13\n\n10:3 20:21\n\n43:17\n\n134:22\n\n24:4,20,21,23\n\n76:11,21\n\ncovering\n\n28:25 36:22\n\n77:13,19\n\n48:23\n\n37:5 40:11,\n\ncovered\n\n6:3 32:6\n\n14,15,17\n\ncrack\n59:11,13\ncreate\n\ndeclaration\n\ndeclaratory\n5:10,12,18,20\n\n45:14,16\n\n5:5 51:2,5\n\n21:2,6 22:3,\n\n46:3,5,2\n\n89:24 130:6,\n\n9,21 25:4,9\n\n47:19\n\n7,8 140:11\n\n32:25 37:7\n\n22:2,4 49:2\n\n52:\n\n119:14\n\n1\n\ndays\n9:23\n\ncreated\n\n2:10\n\n131:11\n\n26:2,16 38:9\n54:2 82:13\n\n67:21\n\n40:2,5 41:3,\n12,16 42:3,9\n55:16,24\n56:3,25 67:7\n\n91:17,18,25\n:3,4 85:10\n\ncreates\n\n90:4 102:8\n\n49:16\n\n11,18 132:7\n\n118:17\n\ncreation\n\ncut\nty\n\n119:22 120:7\n\n15:19 26:10\n\n133:21 134:3\n\n28:2 36:6\ndeclare\n\nD\ndeal\ncriminal\n14:4,11 34:12\n37:2 56:15\n59:2 76:11\n\ndamage\n104:13\ndamaging\n108:1\n\n104:2 107:13\n109:5 115:12,\n14 119:17\n\n24 118:12,19\n\n5:24 6:5 8:2\n\n66:23\n\n,\n\n74:16,21\n75:20,22\n117:9,13,17,\n\nDCA\n\n22:1\ncredibi\n\n92:2 93:10,\n\ndatabase\n50:16\n\n15:12 23:23\n\n39:10 67:7\n76:2 77:17\n\n33:25 64:23\n66:23 102:9\n\ndefamation\n100:6,7\n\n109:25\ndealt\n109:17\n\ndefects\n25:19 31:18\ndefend\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734807\n\n\f", "char_count": 1565}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 157, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n10:25 11:6\n44:8\ndefendant\n\n13\ndemand\n\ndeserve\n\n5:2,4,9 15:2\n\n50:9\n\n100:23\n\n16:5,10 17:14\n\nDesign\n\ndisclose\n\n4:15 18:19\n\n22:7,8,21\n\n28:24 38:18,\n\n53:22 54:11,\n\n19 47:18\n\n14 56:13\n\n48:1,4,5\n\n119:25\n\n15:17,18\n\ndemands\n\n87:23 111:11\n\n17:5\n\ndisclosed\n\n108:2\n\n13:18,24\n21:20 46:17\n\n6:7 39:8\ndetermination\n\n5:7\ndefendants\n10:10 24:2\n\ndetermined\n\n7:21 13:22\n\n119:13 1\n\n14:12 19:4\n\ndenial\n25:16\ndenied\n31:14 43:3\n\n78:3,5,13\n\n46:15 60:5\n\n134:20\ndetermin\n\n78:20 88:5\n104:19 113:7\nning\n\ndeny\n\ndefense\n6:21,25 7:3\n14:3 19:16,24\n\n57:23 72:8\n73:23 76:5,21\n\n110:6\n\n110:11 112:22\n\n0:3 94:8\nAdid losure\n\n96:8\n\n33:3,4,7 35:9\n\ndefending\n\nd'sclosing\n\ndemonstrative\n11:21\n\ndefendant's\n\n113:20,21\n\ndestroy\n\ndeter\n55:15 59:2\n112:6\n\ndisciplinary\n\n120:7\n\n34:14\n\n43:4 46:19\n\ndiscourage\n10:7 111:10\n\n77:13,19,2\n\n39:9\ndevelop\n\ndenying\n\ndiscovery\n116:16\n\n113:3\n\n123:6,10\ndeveloped\n\ndepe\n\n20:8,17,18,\n\n116:20\n\ndiscussed\n107:8\n\n23,25 22:9\n\ndevoid\n\n72:22 73:6\n\n32:14 41:24\n\n95:17 96:4\n\n:10\n\n100:6 104:2\n\ndeposition\n\ndiscussing\n109:18 130:13\n\ndifference\n18:7 19:13\n\n11,12 106:15\n\n59:4,6 107:4,\n\n110:16.425:22\n\n9 124:4\n\ndiscussion\n131:4,12\n\n61:16\ndiscussions\ndiligence\n\nDefe\n\ndepth\n\n108:5 114:13,\n7:9 34:17\n\n116:17\n\n1\n\n17,18 121:19\n107:17 108:8\n\nderogation\n11\ndegree\n99:5,7\ndeliberation\n\n27:2\nDershowitz\n104:3,6,11\n\n122:10,11\ndirect\n\n135:23\n\n9:24 43:20\n47:12 53:14\n\ndisingenuous\n90:8\n\n98:18 139:10\n\n105:23 108:1\n\ndislike\ndirectly\n\n33:18\n\n125:22\n\ndeliver\n\ndescribe\n\n56:6\n\n129:13\n\n58:15\n64:25\ndismiss\ndisagree\n41:17\n\n5:7 8:18 25:7\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734808\n\n\f", "char_count": 1588}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 158, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n14\n\n33:8 37:12\n\ndisputes\n\n39:25 40:1\n\n100:4,5\n\n4:14\n\n46:23 47:2,\n\ndistracted\n\ndrafted\n\n13,22 51:19\n\n65:15\n\nDouglas\n\n66:21 126:20\n\n62:4 71:19\nDistrict\n72:24,25\n\ndrafting\n\n102:7,13\n\n103:6\n\nearly\n36:19 79:19\neasier\n9:12 69:23\n79:14\neasy\n\n73:11,17,25\n74:19 78:6\n\ndivert\n\n88:25 89:7\n\n65:2\n\n92:9 93:1,9\n\ndivided\n\ndrawn\n\n115:1,19,23\n\n108:24\n\n8:16\n\ndocument\n\ndrive\n\n116:6,10\n\ndraw\n135:6\n\n117:12 118:22\n\n38:2 49:3\n\n119:9\n\n51:3 123:22\n\ndismissal\n26:5 27:18\n38:11,21\ndismissed\n\n139:15t 5:)\n\n70:10\neconomics\n9:7\noriel\n135:24\neditorially\n136:3\n\nop\n54:21,\n\ndocumentation\n\neducational\n99:3\n\n108:2\ndocuments\n\neffect\n\n24:13,17,21,\n\n5 3,9 16:18,\n\n15:5 30:5\n\n22:5 25:22\n\n22 29:20\n\n3 17:10,16,\n\n94:9 119:5\n\n26:1 27:15\n\n34:3,25\n\n20 21:24 52:6\n\neffusive\n\n31:2,6 38:9\n\n40:14,1\n\n54:17,24 57:8\n\n135:3\n\n39:15 41:5\n\n45:6,\n\n60:15 91:24\n\n53:16 57:4,\n\n13,\n\n131:24 133:13\n\n13,14 91:16\n\n/3,5,\n47:4\n\n92:8 93:2,8,\n13,15,18\n\n:5,18,24\n\n134:5\n\n:25 53:2,7,\n\nI\n\negregious\ndropping\n\ndismissla\n\nEighth\n\n10 59:23\n\n84:10,11,12,\n\n25:15\ndispute\n32:22 33:10\n37:15 64:21\n78:8,12\n\n107:17 108:8\n\n69:9 72:23\n73:3,7,13\n\ndie ositive\n\n100:18\n\n7:9 34:17\n\n74:6 81:14,20\n97:16\n\n43:1\n\n132:5\n\n61:7,13 62:10\n\n38:18\n\n135:3\n\n134:9\n\ndue\ndismisses\n\negotistical\n\n18 89:4\n\n44:2 50:3\nI\n\nduly\n43:18 98:14\n\n53:23 54:10\n23:22\n\nembarrassing\n62:2\n\n105:15 118:13\n\n107:14\n\nembarrass\n65:25\n\n21 104:7,18\n\ndomain\n\nemail\n\nduty\n\n101:17 103:7,\n\n134:6\n\nelected\n\nearlier\n60:3 89:11\n\nempaneled\n106:9\n\n91:12,14\nemphasize\n\n118:10 128:5\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734809\n\n\f", "char_count": 1547}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 159, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n47:24\n\n15\nEpstein\n19:9 31:5\n\nemployees\n\n33:23 34:4,8\n\n14:1\n\n97:2\n\n14:19\n\neventually\n\nexercise\n\n54:21 57:15\n\n134:25\n\n45:5 49:4,16,\n\nemployment\n\nevidence\n\nexercised\n\n21,25 50:5\n100:5\n\n8:6 12:16,17\n58:10 59:16\n\nenclosure\n\n60:25 66:4,5,\n\n28:17,22\n\n6,8,15,23\n\nencouraging\n\n68:25 69:1,5,\n\n27:19\n\n83:10 101:11\n\n16:6 18:6\n\n102:3,4,5,23\n\n37:6 53:25\n\n103:2,8,22\n\n97:10 108:9,\n\n104:3 106:5\n\n20 118:18\n\n115:13 129:7\n130:22 137:1\n\nevi\n\n68:5,7,9,15,\n\n3 :11 72:15\n\n73:3 76:3\n\n89:3 119:6\n\nESQ\n\n59:1\n\n98:\n\nexamination\n\ne\n8\nntially\n\n87:19,23\n95:18 103:11,\nI\n\n13,14,18\n105:4,22\n\n13:3 43:20\n\n107:24\n\n63:15,17\n\n111:15,16\n\n94:21 98:18\n\n117:1 118:4\n\n138:22 139:18\n\n120:22 124:13\n\n101:14 112:9\n121:25\nexceptional\n76:25 77:16\nexceptions\n5:14\nestablished\n49:14\n\n126:12,13\n127:15\n128:14,16\n130:9 132:1,\n4,14 133:15,\n\nexclusively\n\n16\n\n125:5\nestablishment\n8:9 20:2 21:9\n\nexhibits\nexcuse\n56:2\n\nestate\n\nentity\n\n100:4\n\n71:14\n\n83:5,15\n91:16 94:4\n\n123:4\n\n18:16 22:14\n\n71:20 79:16\n\nexaggerated\n\n20:11 22:24\n\nM\n\n21 70:13\n\n32:8\n\n6:19\n\n5:19 7:3\n\ned\n\n44:10,15 49:8\n51:9 67:23\n\nact\n\nestablish\n\nenti\n\n40:25 42:21\nii\n\n:4,5\n\n50:8\n\n41:1 134:12\n\n43:5\n\n36:16 38:1,2\n\n95:23 96:\n\nIs\n\nentered\n\nentirety\n\n.22,23\n\n78:4,14 83:1\n\n23:19 33:21\n\n12:11 103:3\n\n55:11\n\n2:24 33:1\n\n55:19 76:4,22\n\n16,18 69:20,\n\nequal\n\nentire\n\n8:16 29:8,11\n\n40:9,12 43:12\n\nEpstein's\n\n44:11,16\n\n5:6 40:20\n\n9:10,11 12:13\n\n33:5,16,21\n\n139:22\n\nengagement\n\n119:9\n\nexhibit\n\n30:11 31:9,18\n\n98:9 11010\n\nengage\n\nenter\n\n15:6 22:18\n\n10 80:24\n\nend\n\n44:7 110:1\n\n131:21\n\nexcused\n95:5,7 140:3\n\nevent\n91:4 96:22,24\n\nexempt\n\n12:15,21\n28:13,14\n29:13 81:8\n83:14 95:18,\n19,21 96:2\n104:6 124:3\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734810\n\n\f", "char_count": 1688}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 160, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nexist\n31:9 92:20\nexisted\n51:7\n\n16\n15 42:4\n\n23:1 25:18\n\nextensive\n\n32:15 39:12\n\n110:9\n\n41:25 56:7\n\n14:7 41:16\n\n59:5 108:9\n\n57:16\n\nextent\n\nfavor\n\n112:9 136:10\n\nexisting\n\n111:5\n\n7:4 20:1\n21:9,13\n\nFBI\nfactual\n\nextra\n68:1\n\nexists\n\nextraordinary\n\n32:22 33:10\n37:15 43:2\n78:8 118:10\n\n91:12 102:6\n\n20:16,19\n\n104:15 105:25\n\n108:13\n\n123:14 125:23\n\n125:14,15\ndotal\n\n49:1\nextreme\n\nfactually\n\n:6 101:5\n\n136:3\n\n109:15 110:3,\n\n58:15\nfailed\n\nexpanded\n6:10\n\n22 111:22\n\nextremely\n\n17:11\n\n103:4\n\n20:7 2\n\nexpansive\n\n31\n\n135:8\n\n112:10\n9\n\nfeds\n66:24\n\nF\nfee\n\nexpect\n22:10,\n\nF-E-R-E-R-E\n\n12:3\nexpectation\n\nexperience\n99:9 110:9\nexperienced\n\n48:19 5\n51:4,1\nface\n\nair\n64:6 91:1\n93:25\nfairly\n106:12\n\n34:10\nfaith\nexpert\n18:12 106:24\n\nexplain\n: 1\n:6\nned\n3'4:9\nexplaining\n49:10\nexposed\n23:2\n\n19:25 21:12,\n\n97:25\nfeels\n137:9\nfees\n4:5 5:1 6:11,\n15 15:7,11,14\n\n33:10,17\n\n16:11,12,17,\n\n47:4 48:5\n\n37:15 42:3\n\n22,25 17:21\n\n54:15 58:9\n\n58:3 73:8\n\n18:2,5,8,9,11\n\n61:4 62:12\n\n78:7,12 89:6\n\n25:25 26:15,\n\n117:23 118:10\n\n24 27:16\n\n63:7 64:19,22\n66:17 69:16\n\nfamiliar\n\n28:21 29:15\n\n77:14 86:1\n\n44:21,24\n\n36:18 37:25\n\n88:12 97:9\n\n46:13 51:19\n\n38:24 39:12\n\n106:9 111:3\n\n87:9,10\n\n42:11,20,22\n\n110:16\n\n44:4 53:25\n\nfacts\n5:19,22 7:2,\n5,12 16:2\n\nextension\n\nfeel\n\n18 21:8 32:22\n\n11 8:9,16,\n13:6 41:23\n\n97:16\n\n128:6,13\n\n19:25 20:17,\n\n17 10:14 12:8\nexperts\n\n6:18 42:19\n44:16 93:8,13\n\n27:25\nFacebook\n\n20:3\n\n19\n\n96:14 126:7\n\n20:3,11 22:23\n\nfamily\n62:23\nfast\n\n59:20 120:1\n122:21,24\n127:18,20,25\n128:3 132:8\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734811\n\n\f", "char_count": 1548}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 161, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n17\n\nfelt\n\n79:19 86:2\n\n108:16 109:20\n\n25:8,11 32:2\n\n23:22 88:23\n\n87:25 91:15\n\n105:2 112:23\n\n92:8,12,17\n\n39:21 102:18\n\n42:7,16,17\n\n116:24\n\n93:5,17\n\n104:1\n\n48:7 55:15,17\n\n134:24,25\n\n108:15,19\n\nFerere\n\n114:13,23,25\n\n27:25\n\n115:3 116:9,\n\nFerlanti\n\nfight\n\n33:9 40:7\n\n56:19 76:3\n97:17 99:25\n102:13 109:9,\n\n123:1 124:10\n\n6:23\n\n11 110:8\n16:22 119:10\n\nfine\n\n,i\nus\n\n7,12,13\n\n60:13 62:21\n\n130:20 131:8\n\n138:25\n\n132:19\n\n59:20,21\n\n8:5 97:9\n\n12 122:20,24\n125:2 128:2,\n\n97:19\n\nfindings\n\nfinds\n\n8:1\nFifteen\n\nfinding\n\n6 :3\nocused\n\nfinish\n\n125:5\n\n137:17\n\nfiles\n\nfocusing\n\nfile\n\n15:20\n\n19:2,4 54:25\n\nfinished\n\nfollow\n\n92:3 95:1\n\n17:19 18:7\n\nrm\n\n115:18 116:6\n\n19:14 26:19\n\n:15,21\n\n124:18 126:9\n\n27:15 31:13\n\n127:12 132:8\n\n37:12,14,\n\n133:18\nfiled\n11:14 15:8,\n\nforced\n\n99:20\n\n24 26:16 27:\n\n40:15\n:21 48:11\nnal\n14:7 18:9,20,\n21 19:1 40:24\n\n35:227\n5\n\n41:1,8 133:15\n134:13,18\n\n4\n7:2\n2:3,15 63:22\n\n135:18\n\nfirm's\n18:9 44:11,16\n\nforms\n137:2\n\nfive-minute\n95:9\n\nFort\n99:1,14\n\nflesh\n109:10\n\nforward\n50:7 118:21\n\nfleshing\n109:8\n\nforwarding\n126:7\n\nfinally\n\nflip\n\n6 :17 65:4\n\n12:5 38:6\n\n23:9 70:4\n\n66:13,25\n\n42:10 54:22\n\n80:11\n\n67:11 70:25\n\nfore\n104:16\n\nf\n\n24 17:21,24\n23:18 25:21,\n\n88:25 89:1,6\n\n44:7 67:22\n\n129\n\n11,14 16:11,\n14,16,20,21,\n\n118:13\n\n136:1\nfirm\n\n108:21\n\n5:1 7:11 8:10\n\n18:25 19:3\nforce\n\nrewall\n\n38:7 92:\n\n35:\n\n7:8\n\nfiling\n\nfound\n5:24 8:1\n12:12 15:18\n\nfind\n\n71:5 72:21\n\n8:22 9:4\n\n73:11,15,19,\n\n17:23 18:3\n\n23 74:12,13\n\n46:7,10 59:12\n\n77:7 78:6\n\n91:11 102:2\n\nflipping\n\n108:15 109:16\n\n75:6\n\n110:21\n\nFlorida\n\nFourteenth\n\n4:11 5:13 6:6\n\n100:19\n\n14:13 19:8\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734812\n\n\f", "char_count": 1627}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 162, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nFourth\n5:24 6:5 8:2\n\n18\nfurthering\n135:10\n\n15:19 28:2\n36:5 94:2\n\na\n\n11:21\nfraud\n100:5\nFriday\n97:4,10 138:9\nfriend\n136:22\nfriends\n62:23\nfrivolous\n32:14,17\n33:19 36:3\n41:15 24\n\nG-R-Y-G-I-E-L\n101:23\ngame\n53:7\ngave\n116:2,4\ngeneral\n99:22 110:10\n\nfull\n9:4,11\nfurtherance\n76:6,18\n\n23,24 77:15\n\n32:22 33:10,\n\n78:5 80:24\n\n17 37:15 42:3\n\n81:2,4 83:10\n\n43:22,25 58:3\n\n4:24 85:2,\n\n63:19 64:12\n\n1,16,18,20\n\n73:8 78:7,12\n\n:4 102:19\n\n98:20 117:\n\n103:1,21\n\n118:10 1\n\n104:9,13\n\n139:23\n\n106:3,9,20\n\n15 111:2,4,22\n112:3,10,12,\n\n23:25 41:1Asse\n\necs,\n\nGera\n\n113:13,15,19\n\n92:10,11\n\n114:7 115:8,\n\n93:15\n\n24 116:22,23\n\ngraduated\n\n117:20 118:17\n\n99:6\n32:19\n5 75:21\n\n26:22\n\ngrand\n5:14 7:22\n10:21 14:2,\n17,22 21:20\n\ngive\n6:1 9:5 11:3,\n8 23:12 43:12\n45:9,10 72:16\n\n119:2 131:14\n138:19 139:18\nGlade\n111:1\ngoal\n\n19,20,25\n\nace\n\n5\n\n93:1 98:9\n\n129:16\n\n20:17,18 21:8\n\n107:20,22\n\n76:13 85:12\n\nful illed\n\n73:22 76:5,\n\ngenuine\n\n74:20 107:22\n\nf\n\n4:7,13 19:25\n\n3\n\n59:1 67:23\n\n59.\n\n69:10 72:7,10\n\n108:3 109:14,\n\nfront\n\nfront-p\n\n67:4,6,14,19\n\n52:14\n\n138:6\n\n137:13\n\n89:12 90:2\n\ngenerally\n\n64:23 65:3\n\n132:2 134:13\n\n62:10 63:8\n\ngovern\n\n100:10\n\nGeorgia\n\n108:3 117:6\n\n86:17,20\n\nGeneral's\n\n59:21 62:3\n72:25 90:18\n\n60:6,25 61:9\n\ngood\n\n100:17\nfrankly\n\n78:22 85:24\n\n22:15 23:19\n24:4,7,16\n25:1 29:1,6\n30:14,23,24\n31:5 33:6\n\n119:1,4,7\n120:8 121:13,\n17 122:7\n123:24 125:6,\n9,12,17\n127:1,2\n129:1,7,11,21\n130:22,25\n134:23\ngrant\n\n35:8,14,18\n\n7:23 30:4\n\n36:12,24 37:5\n\n56:14 94:9\n\n38:3 39:17\n\ngranted\n\n40:19 41:7\n\n57:15\n\n45:6,15 46:16\n48:23 50:5\n\n39:13 53:3\n\n54:14 55:20\n\n59:24 60:2,22\n\n56:14,17\n\ngranting\n5:6\ngreat\n49:7 109:25\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734813\n\n\f", "char_count": 1667}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 163, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n19\n\n137:10 140:11\n\nhate\nH\n\ngreater\n109:7\n\nhead\n\nheads\n\n4:10 30:15\n\n128:9,10\n\n33:17 34:8\n\n133:24\n\n99:1,11,13,16\n\n134:11,12,20\n\n104:23 106:22\n107:16 114:5\n\nhear\n\nhiding\n\n11:15 18:14\n\n7:4,15\n\n14:7 18:20,21\n\nh\n\n40:24\n\n19 34:10,18,\n\n:5,10 41:22\n\n24 35:1,3,6\n\nhalf\n\nigher\n\n36:5,15 3\n38:14\n39:14 9 .1\n\nhand\n\nground\n106:12 119:17\n\nhighlight\nheard\n\n35:24 68:13\n\n( :1.4)\n25:5\n\n2.\n\n139:15\ngrounds\n\n40:11\n\n123:2 125:21\n\nAg\n\nhandle\n\n.:4\n\n100:11 109:1\ngroup\nhandled\n\n101:15\n\nAN\n\nGrygiel\n70:14 82:11\n83:12 84:17\n101:12,19,22\n\nhands\n134:\n\n( S\n\ne\n\nha\n38:8\nhapp\n\ned\n\n:24 66:14,\n\nGrygiel's\n83:4 84:4\n\n24 84:3 86:19\n91:14 128:1\n\nguess\n\n:24 134:1\n\nv\n\n71:25\nhighlighted\n87:21 128:18\nhindsight\n126:3\n\n8:18 12:11\n\nhired\n\n40:9 44:22\n\n59:9\n\n51:19 60:9\n\nhistory\n\n74:23 78:21,\n\n104:25 105:6\n106:23 136:13\n\n128:7,8\n\nBaring\n\n110:15\n\n25 128:3,4,12\n132:13 139:21\n\n109:21\nHofstra\n99:7\n\n140:13\nhold\nhearings\n\n81:17\n\n65:8\nHoldings\n\nhappy\n\n64:15\n91\n\n67:6\n\n25:23 30:14,\n\nHafele's\n\n134:1\n\n136:9\n\n76:12\nhid\n\n101:15\n\n123:6 126:8\n131:1 135:4\n\nhey\n\n4:22 101:21\n\n19:1 41:1,8\n\n100:1 101:15\n\n58:11\n\n70:5\n\nHafele\n\nGreenberg\n\nhero\n\n5.2\n\n131:22 136:23\n137:1,4\n\nTie\nharass\nguise\n8:3\nguys\n72:21 98:4\n\n36:2\nharbor\n27:13,17\nhard\n41:14 69:18\n90:24 139:15\n\nhearsay\n\n4:11\n\n74:9 84:7\nhonest\nheld\n\n110:5 136:24\n\n15:20 43:24\nhonestly\nhelped\n102:14 109:5\nhelps\n18:20\nHerald\n58:9 66:1\n\n108:3 122:3\n138:10\nHonor\n4:7,13,17,20,\n23 9:8,22\n13:1 16:21\n17:2,13 18:3\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734814\n\n\f", "char_count": 1494}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 164, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n20\n\n23:6,7,10\n\n137:2\n\ninch\n\n24:18 25:14\n\nhundreds\n\n26:8 29:9\n\n108:12\n\nI\n\n43:6 44:15\n46:7 47:11,15\n53:21 54:6,7\n\n78:20 86:16\n\n69:21 74:8\n\n89:12\nimpacted\n62:23\n\n82:15 95:6,8,\n15,25 96:1,8,\n21 97:12\n98:2,3,17\n137:19 138:6,\n\nimportant\n24:24 25:2\n\n140:3\n\n29:24 35:17\n\n27:11 28:1\n39:1 111:24\n\n42:11\n\n50:7\n\nhopeful\n113:23 115:2\n122:5\nhost\n92\n\nimpos\n8\n\n:4\n7:1\n\n11:17\n\n:17 20:20\n52:21,24 56:4\n\n138:3\nhours'\n108:12\nHoward\n44:12\nhumanity\n\n5:18 72:9\n\n39:2 57:3\n\n:24 77:15\n\n100:16 107:2\n\n116:21 117:14\n\n112:20\n\n120:10,11,14\n\nincludes\n\n134:22 135:1\n\n7:6\n\ninhibit\n120:13\n6:6\n50:22\n\n5:23\n\ninitial\n27:7 48:11\n108:19,22\n\nnconsistent\n\n110:2 114:12,\n\n90:1\n\n22 115:2,4,19\n\nindicating\n29:23 31:24\n85:8 101:25\n123:25\n\n94:10 137:20\nindication\nimpression\n\ninherent\n3:21 74:17\n\n31:11\nle\n\n55:22\n\n18:8 37:10\n\n15:25 27:12\n\n73:12\n\n41:9 42:2\n\n116:7,10,12\n119:25 123:1\n129:14\ninitially\n6:25 19:24\n129:16\ninitiative\n6:16\ninjure\n104:7\n\nindictment\nimproper\n\n20:2 134:1\n\nincluded\n\nindependently\n\nhoped\n123:25\n\ninforming\n\n41:19\nimposed\n\nhope\n\ninclude\n\nimportantly\n24:14 27:5\n\nHonor's\n\n90:4\n\n38:11 40:4\n\n17,24 139:14\n\n7:15 46:21\n\n67:22\n\n120:19\n\n29:10 65:20\n\n62:17 68:7,8\n\ninformed\n\n55:2 105:21\nidea\n\n51:24 52:8,18\n58:1,4 60:17\n\n11:19\nIncidentally\n\n31:16 32:1,23\n39:19 42:25\n\n107:17 108:1\n\n106:20 125:24\n\n7:17 19:11\nindividual\nimproperly\n\n84:7 111:1\n\n17:24 72:2,7\n73:20\n\ninform\n23:22 34:1\n\nin-camera\n\n102:3\n\n114:2\ninformation\nin-depth\n\n106:1,2,19\n\ninmate\n110:25\ninput\n136:12\ninquiry\n8:7\ninsisted\n59:18\n\n109:7\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734815\n\n\f", "char_count": 1565}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 165, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\ninstance\n\n21\ninvestigation\n\n56:18\n\nissues\n\nJames\n\n23:20 24:6,12\n\n25:16 40:5\n\n110:23\n\ninstructed\n\n33:23 34:7\n\n41:10 102:9\n\n111:12,14\n\n18:22\n\n35:14 49:21\n\n104:16 107:1\n\n112:21\n\n66:5,8,11\n\n109:1,17\n\n82:1 102:19\n\n114:3\n\nintentionally\n62:14\n\n103:21 104:5\ninterest\n\n106:7 112:12\n\n6:18 23:25\n66:7 76:14,25\n\nitems\n103:24 107:15\n\nJanuary\n45:2 49:6,7\n70:24\nJeanne\n\ninvestigations\n\n4:12\n\n50:7\n77:16 85:1\n107:2 113:8\ninterested\n19:6 102:18,\n23 103:24\n104:1 112:16\n\nJe\ninvestigative\nJ.D.\n\n81:8\n\n99:7\ninvestigatory\n\n19:9 23:19\n45:5 49:3,16,\n21,25 58:10\n\nJ10\n\n108:13\n\nrey\n\n47:12,\ninvolved\n31\n\n59:16 60:25\n66:8 68:25\n69:1,5 83:10\n\n113:24\n\n25:10 65:6\n\ninteresting\n\n66:14,17,18\n\n101:11 102:3,\n\n67:23 85:7\n\n23 103:2,22\n\n17:22 18:13\n20:24\n\n101:10 103:\n110:24,2\n\nInternet\n\ninterpret\n21:18 32:9\n\n40:\n\ninterpretatiop\n\n55:6\n0:14\n97.2 115:13\nelevant\n\n51:25 58:2\n\n21:14\n\nIsland\n\ninterpr\n32:\n\n318\n\nin\n\ninterpretation\n21:4,8,21\n\ntw4-c,\n\nin\n\ntories\n\n97:17 138:3\nissue\n41:2 42:7,9\n\nin\n\nrruption\n\n138:20\nintervening\n61:17\nintroduce\n43:23 98:22\n\n316\n79:15\n\ninvolve\n\n49:4\n\n3:21\n\nJ2\n77:10\nJ23\n57:7\n\n9:4,14,15\n12:12\nJ6\n47:12,16\n\n88:12,15\n\n71:19\n\n116:17 120:15\n\nJennifer\n4:9\njoinder\n133:9\njoint\n8:23 12:15,21\n28:14 29:11\n42:21 44:10,\n15 49:8 51:9\n\nJ29\n\n59:8 79:1,6,9\n89:15 113:8\n\n130:22\n\n95:18,22 96:2\n103:13,18\n105:22\nJournal\n140:8\nJudge\n\nJ9\n46:8 75:3,4\n\n125:7,14,15\n\n5:6 8:17 10:1\n14:7 18:20,21\n19:1 22:6\n\nissued\n\n44:7\n\n54:11 112:10\n120:3\n\nJail\n\n25:6 39:24\n40:9,20,24\n41:1,8 51:20\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734816\n\n\f", "char_count": 1541}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 166, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n22\n\n52:3 53:12,15\n\n79:2,10,19\n\n83:10 84:24\n\n53:5 61:5\n\n57:23 61:13\n\n80:14,15\n\n85:2,11,16,\n\n121:7\n\n62:25 63:10,\n\n84:21 86:21\n\n18,20 89:4\n\n16 74:20\n\n88:1 89:16\n\n102:19 103:1,\n\n92:22 93:24\n\n92:4 119:8\n\n21 104:9,13\n\n94:18 119:8\n\n120:3,20\n\n106:3,9,20\n\n120:2 128:9,\n\n122:2,12,15\n\n107:21,22\n\n10 133:24\n\n127:19,24\n\n108:3 109:14,\n\n134:11,12,20\n\n128:7,13\n\n15 111:2,4,22\n\n91:3\n\n133:6\n\n112:3,10,12,\n\nd\n\njudgment\n10:19 11:2,\n12,20 12:2\n14:7 18:20,21\n19:1 29:21\n40:25 41:1,8\n54:25 57:1,3,\n16 74:16,21\n117:9,13,24\n118:23 119:22\n\n10,13,14,18\n\new\n\n101:1\n\n114:7 115\n\n6:24 7:8 8:8\n\n24 116\n\n22:19 45:22\n\njurisdictional\n25:16,19\n\n2,\n\n117:20\n\n31:7,18\njury\n\n53:9 59:22\n88:11 104:5\n\n5:14,15 7:22\n\n:24 125:9,\n\n10:21 14:2,\n\n2,17 127:1,2\n\n17,22 21:\n\n129:1,7,11,21\n\n22:15 2\n\n130:22,25\n\n24:4,\n\n134:23\n,24\n\n125:6\n\n38:3 39:17\n\n18 135:10\n\n40:19 41:7\n45:6,15 46:16\n\njustified\n13:6\n\n48:23 50:5\n55:20 56:14,\n\n:21,24\n\n17 60:6,25\n\nK-A-M\n15:17\n\n63:9 67:4,6,\n\nK-A-M-E\n\n14,19 69:10\n\n15:18\n\n36:16,19,20\n53:13 54:1\n\nknowledge\n\n76:5,23,24\n\n104:6 106:13,\n14 108:7\n110:24 113:14\n123:13 125:18\nKrischer's\n\n104:4,10,15\n105:24 108:2\n125:21\n\nL\nKame\n15:16,17 27:6\n\n77:15 78:5\n80:24 81:3,4\n\nKrischer\n\n102:10,24\n\n61:9 62:10\n\n72:8,10 73:22\n38:4 51:19\n\n128:11\n\n81:14 82:2\n\n52:15 54:14\n\nS\n\n26:25 30:19\n\nknowing\n\n48:23 82:12\njustice\n\n48:2 55:14,\n\n5:3 8:17\n\n125:18 126:1\n\njury's\n\n50:8 76:6,14,\n\nJune\n\n106:7 113:12\n\n84:2 109:7\n\n25:\n\n6:12,24 37:5\n\n:16\n\n52:4,10,25\n\n121:13,\n\n19:3 39:9\n\nJuly\n\n:12\n\n4,7\n2:7\n\n:,14,18\n\n120:1\n\nkill\n\n113:13,15,i\n:!)\n\n3:7\n\njudicia\n\n7:7\n\n25:20 26:4,12\n\n135:18\njudicial\n\nkey\n\n1\n\n14,18 125:9\n19,25 134:3,\n\n38:25\n\n19,20,25\n\njurisdiction\n\n120:7 124:10,\n128:8 133:15,\n\nKelly\n\nkeeping\n\nLabor\n100:12\n102:12,17\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734817\n\n\f", "char_count": 1764}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 167, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nlack\n\n23\n40:6 41:25\n\n137:7\nlacked\n119:13\n\n42:4,8 44:7\n\nlay\n\n38:4 44:12,16\n\n120:18\n\n47:2,3,5,6\n\nleader\n\n54:15 72:24\n\n58:21\n\n54:5,13 68:18\n69:3,6,8,14,\n\n73:1,2 89:1,9\nlacks\n\n16,19 70:13,\n\nleading\n\n25:20 26:11\n48:13\nLago\n15:16,17\n\n92:22 97:8\n\n60:18 125:23\n\n99:8,24\n100:14 109:13\n110:8 126:17\n\n126:3\n\n136:10\n\n8,10,12,16\n4:22 86:11,\n\nleave\n12:25 79:25\n\n2,23,25\n8\n5,11,12\n\nleft\n\n89:17,19,20,\n\nlaws\n27:6,11\n113:4\nlaid\n79:21\n\n9:16 35:\n\nlawsuit\n7:11 11:7\n\n97:7 1 8:2\n\nLangen\n\n29:5 35:8\n\nlegal\n\n99:20\n\n52:7 53:4\n\n7\n\n4:1,25\n\nA34:17\n\n6:14 19:19\n\n58:7 59:21\n\n6 • 59:20\n\n20:6 21:11\n\n60:23 62:3,1\n\n:7 67:13,\n\n112:17\n\n64:23 65:3```6\n\n14,17 73:1,24\n\n67:7 71. ,5\n\n89:2 108:13,\n\n72:21, 5\n73:\n9:3\n\n21 111:5\n136:2,7\n\nlarge\n\n22 90:13\n103:14,17,19,\n23 104:21,22,\n\n54:18 57:8,25\n\nlanguage\n\n16,17 79:14,\n16,20 80:6,7,\n\nlearned\n\n16:4,8 17:22\n\n53:18,20,22\n\n25 105:3,7,13\n119:25\n120:20,23\n121:1,8,10,\n15,21 122:2,\n12 125:10\n130:1,2,10\n\n46:16 49:19\nlate\n\n89:6\n:9\n\n15:4 73:15\nlatest\n\n:\n\n89:16\nLauderdale\n99:1,14\nLauren\n\n107:20\n\n8:11,14\nlawsuits\n50:6\nlawyer\n\n4:8(7)\nla\n\n63:22 65:13\n\nlegislative\n109:21\n\n13:7 20:1,\n\n73:24 79:19\n87:1,4,6,8\n\n2,10,12 21:9,\n\n90:11,13,17,\n\n10,13 22:1,2,\n\n24\n\n25 25:10,11,\n\n120:13,15\nlegitimate\n66:7\nleniency\n23:24 34:5\n\n12 26:3,6\n27:3,5,6\n31:21 32:15\n34:12 36:6,9\n\nlenient\n103:4 106:4,5\nletter\n5:4,9,16 15:3\n\nlawyers\n15:1 22:18\n48:13 78:11\n107:10\n\n70:20 71:4,5\n73:19 82:11,\n14,16 83:5,13\n\nlegislature\n\n70:14 72:5\n21 7:4,\n\nletters\n\n87:8 103:6\n104:23\nlicensed\n99:23\nlies\n88:6\nlight\n34:4 103:2\nLikewise\n30:6\n\n16:10,13\n17:14 28:18,\n22 30:20\n34:24 36:16,\n19 37:3,18\n\nlimitations\n135:1\nlimited\n34:3 40:21\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734818\n\n\f", "char_count": 1690}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 168, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n107:25 119:15\n120:11\n\n24\n99:20\nLos\n\nlines\n\n106:23\n\n9:25 10:5\n28:23\n\nlose\n\n38:12,19\n\n20:3 22:23\n\n47:1,13 50:11\n\n23:1 83:15\n\n59:25 65:5\n\n94:8\n\n79:14 85:19\n\nmaterials\n\n89:1,13,25\n\n5:15 13:9\n\n95:19 96:14\n\n14:17 20:21\n\n97:22 137:10\n\n23:19 29:1\n\n138:7 139:10,\n\n30:4,14,24\n\n33:13\n\nlink\n\nlosing\n\n49:24\n\n6:20,23 8:8\n\nlitigation\n6:15 27:20\n38:21 39:10\n99:19 100:3,\n\nlost\n\n12\n\n48:25\n\nAlimmat\n1:5 35:9\n\nmakes\n\nlot\n\n6:12,24\n\n19:1 29:18\n\n3 :5,23 41:7\n\n7:6 39:23\n\n66:17 92:3\n\n46:16,20\n\n83:13\n\n135:7\n\n55:21 56:2,4,\n\n12,13 110:18\n123:8\nlower\nlitigator\n\n9:16\n\n20:16 2\n\n99:12\n\n6:17\n\nlowest\nLLC\n\n7,15,17,21\n\nmaking\n\n8:1 15:18\n\n12 85:16,20\nluck\n22\n\n34:3\n\n:18 137:1\n\nmanagement\nlog\n\n128:9\n\n123:23,25\nmark\n\n124:7\n\n4:8 12:18\nlogic\n17:9,15\n\n139:3\n\n.22\n\n61:\n9\n\n39:24 40:9,20\n\n114:8 115:10,\n\n51:20 52:3\n\n16 116:19\n\n58:12 61:13\n\n57:23 61:13\n\n117:20\n\n78:19 89:21\n\n74:20,23\n\n118:18,25\n\n119:8,9 120:2\n\n119:16\n\n105:18 111:5\n131:21 133:4\n\n7:16 129:19,\n22,23 130:25\n\nmain\n29:4\n\n133:12\nmajor\nlooked\nmake\n8:7 18:14\nLorenza\n\nMarx's\n53:13,15\n\n19:16 36:23\n\n123:13,16,24\n125:12,17\n129:1,8,11,\n\nMary\n15:17\nmassive\n\n83:16 93:6\n109:12\n\n107:11,12,14,\n21,23 108:4\n113:13,20,24\n\n94:11,25\n7:15\n\n106:8,14,17\n\n22:6 25:6\n\n51:20 56:7\n43:24\n\n105:20,21\n\n112:12\n\n4:2 49:2\n\nlong\n\nMarx\n\n104:12\n\n5:6 8:17 10:2\n\n:9 28:10\n\n93:3\n\n86:6 88:5\n91:22 94:14\n\n97:17\n\nlogical\n\n76:10 80:25\n81:2,8 82:1,\n\n137:2\n\nlocated\n\n72:8 73:21\n\n133:3\nmaterial\n5:19,22 7:2,5\n\n18,22 130:23\n131:1\nmatter\n23:25 47:3,4,\n5 55:16 56:9\n59:15 66:4,5,\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734819\n\n\f", "char_count": 1554}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 169, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n25\n\n6,7 68:25\n\n99:21 103:16\n\n69:1,5,10\n\n119:20 137:14\n\n72:24 73:1\n\n138:16\n\n89:1,2,8 90:3\n\nminute\n\nMortgage\n\n138:19\n\n7:25\n\nminutes\n\nmotion\n\nMendelsohn's\n\n33:5 55:19\n\n97:1 102:4\n\n35:4 37:18\n\n63:21 64:16\n\n5:7,8 6:16\n\n117:2 135:17\n\n70:16 84:4\n\n76:4,22 78:4,\n\n8:17 15:7,10,\n\n14 81:9,10,12\n\n13,21,23,24\n\n85:23 86:19\n\n16:11,12,14,\n\n105:22 111:12\n\n95:11 96:18\n\n6,17,21,25\n\n131:14\n\n97:19 118:8\n\n7:18,20,24\n\nmeans\n\nmentioned\n\n33:19 92:19\n\n26:20 90:10\n\nmechanism\n7:13\nmedia\n\nI\n\n50:16,21\n\nI\n\n56:11 101:13,\n\nmentioning\n73:6\n\n15 109:3\n\n32:14 33:15\n\nmedia's\n\n41:24\n\n107:2\n\n25:13\n\n136:5\n\nmessage\n\nmemorandum\n87:24 126:16\n\nI\n\n19,24 35:1,\n36:5,8,15,20\n\nmet\n:22\n\n:9 66:1\n99:20\nMichael\n101:12\n\n39:14\n::T9\n9:10\n22 82:11\n.4,12\n84:17,21\n85:8,22,25\n86:3,25 87:13\n89:17 90:11,\n16,17 96:11,\n13,19 98:13,\n\n15,18,22,24\n27:7,9,16\n\nMike\n70:14 101:19\nmiles\n\n11,13,14,15,\n18,19,21,24\n11,14 33:13\n\n102:25\n\n36:18 37:12,\n\n117:14\n\n25 39:24 40:1\n42:23 43:3,5\n44:4 46:23\n\nmodification\n20:1 21:12\n\n47:2,22 51:19\n53:25 54:25\n\nmodified\n\n56:25 57:2,5\n\n21:17\n\n63:22 64:11,\n\nmonetary\n19:21\nmoney\n59:19 63:23\n64:1,4,11,14,\n18,24,25 65:2\n\n17 71:18\n72:23 73:11,\n16,17 74:12,\n19 79:19 86:2\n87:25 88:25\n89:7 92:3,4,\n7,8,12,14,16,\n\nmind\nmonths\n17:9 59:21\n139:4\n\n19 29:3,9,10,\n\nmisusing\n\n58:9\n\n98:4 126:22\n\n12,13,16,17,\n\n30:2 31:8,10,\n\nmiddle\n80:18 105:17\n\n28:6,10,11,\n\n39:8\n\nmixture\n\n37:3 38\n54.\n\n59:2 61\n\nmisuse\n\n13:3 30:15,\n17,20 34:9,\n\n26:4,5,12,13,\n\n64:24\n\n441%,/\n\n6,17,21,25\n\n17:12\n\npoke\n\n48:19\n\nMendelsohn\n\n19:4,15 25:3,\n\nAci\n\nmerits\n\nmember\n\n138:1\n\n4:w 105:23\n\n6:7,12\n\n131:3\n\n1 :1,4,8\n\nm\n\nmeritless\n\nmeeting\n\n137:18,25\n\nmisleadi\n\nmerit\n\n4:5,19,25\n\n34:13 37:17\n51:6 64:23\n\n19,23,24\n94:6,15,16\n101:4,8\n\n20,23,25\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734820\n\n\f", "char_count": 1762}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 170, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n26\n\n115:1,18\nN\n\n116:6,9\n118:22 119:9\n120:1 122:20,\n24 123:1,2\n124:10,14,17\n\n122:5 129:19\n\nnotably\n\n130:12 131:10\n\n7:6\n\nneutrality\n\nname's\n4:14\nnamed\n\nnote\n\n38:9 131:11,\n\n32:5 38:11\n\n16,19 133:2,\n\n40:4 47:17\n\n13\n\n117:22\n\n125:9 126:10,\n\n24:2,10,11\n\n19 127:18,20,\n\n30:21 35:19\n\n21,25 128:2,\n\n36:21 71:6\n\n6,7,13 132:8,\n\n80:19,21\n\n11,15,18,21,\n\n84:23,25\n\n8:12 13:12,21\n\n22,23 133:5,\n\n85:9,10 87:15\n\n45:4 46:19,2\n\n19,25 134:10,\n\n99:19 111:3\n\n48:13 52:\n\n13\n\n112:6,8 113:9\n\n53:9 5\n\n8:19 26:14\n\n121:2,4 125:3\n\n57:22\n\n27:10,22\n\n127:8\n\n59•\n\nmotions\n33:7 47:13\n\nnews\n\nnoted\n\n102:5,11\nnewspaper\n\n6\n\nmouthpiece\n\ner's\n\n10:12 35:9\nAt\n\nnarrative\n\n109:4\n\n58:12\n\nmove\n50:7 59:24\n69:18 74:8\n98:24 133:14\n\nnarrow\n119:17(<:\n\n34:17\n\n14:16,17\nnotice\n\n28:7,21 31:1\n53:18 57:7\n\nnaming\n\n78:6\n\n24:1 41:8\n\nSK\n\n89:20,23\n\n125 46:14\n\n92:15,25\n\n35:12\n\n132:4\n\nnewspapers\n\nnoticed\n\n59:17 65:4\n\n128:2,4\n\n101:14\n\n132:13\n\nnat\nnice\n\nnotify\n\nmoved\n122:18\n\n48:12 50:11\n\n60:22 78:22\nnickel\n\n85:24 86:21\n117:11,12\n118:21\n\nnoting\n42:10\n\nnecessarily\n111:20\n\nNina\n106:23\n\nmoving\n\nNotwithstanding\n19:21\n\nneeded\n\n53:3\n\n19:12 36:9,10\n\nnods\n\nNovember\n\n4:22 101:21\n\n5:1 16:18,25\n\n39:16 62:7\n\nnon-prosecution\n\n25:25 26:19\n\n85:19 88:13\n\n102:14 103:3\n\n34:16 44:4\n\n9 :18\n\n106:2\n\n106:6 125:24\n\n45:1 70:25\n\nmultiple\n\nneedless\n\nnoncurable\n\n39:9\n\n25:15\n\n86\n\n37:20,21\n0:2\n\nhu 1\n•\n\n64:5,7\n\n7:16 50:1\nmutual\n136:22\n\nnegotiate\n\nNonetheless\n\n102:14\n\n7:15 88:2\n\nneutral\n\n128:21\n\n108:20 114:13\nnumber\n9:16,19,24\n19:9 24:2,4\n25:20 26:11\n32:17 34:2\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734821\n\n\f", "char_count": 1576}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 171, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n27\n\n35:13,16,24\n\n88:3,4 91:6,\n\n89:18 91:5,23\n\n16,19,24,25\n\n36:22,24 40:8\n\n21 94:7,13\n\n93:5,12 105:8\n\n106:13,18,24\n\n49:19 58:8,14\n\n98:1 118:7\n\n122:15 126:7\n\n108:2 113:3,\n\n68:6,22 69:9\n\n128:22 129:7\n\n127:11 129:5\n\n12,13 118:17,\n\n73:6 101:13\n\n131:16 134:6\n\n130:2 131:25\n\n18 119:3\n\n132:3\n\n121:6,12\n\noffended\n\n123:15,17\n\nnumbers\n\nobjections\n\n9:5,18\n\n52:15 114:20,\n21\n\nnumerous\n58:17\n\nobligation\n7:10 17:18\n115:24\n\nO\n\nobligations\nobject\n\n36:12 37:8,22\n38:7 39:19\n\n130:21,24\n\n19:10 24:\n28:25\n\noffice's\n104:20\n\n61:3 73:5\n\n35\n\n5,1T,20\n\n107:20 109:4\n\n78:20 79:8\n\n116:19\n\n85:12 86:6\n\nobtained\n\n88:14 89:13,\n\n107:9\nobta\n\n91:24 113:4,6\n\n35:17 71:6,16\n\n42:12\n\n73:23 84:25\n\n12 45:25\n:4 48:1,13\n\n:9\nobjected\noccasionally\n100:18\n\n50:6 55:24\n\n121:12 122:4\n\n56:5,10,16,18\n\n137:8\n\n59:10,12,13\n\noccur\n128:11\n\n61\n0:6\nion\n1 :14 30:3,7,\n12,13 31:4\n41:6 51:24\n\noccurred\n\n119:3\nofficials\n100:15\n\n70:15 71:3,\n\n110:11,12,21\n\n10,15 73:12\n\n112:22\nOlympus\n\n80:25 81:3,\n26:6\n11,24 83:3,8\n84:8,18 85:1,\n\none-sided\n\n49:25 107:22\n\n18 90:19,21\n\n58:18\n\n108:18 113:14\n\n94:25 95:2\n\nongoing\n\n118:21\n\n99:2,14,16\n\nOctober\n\n100:10\n\n16:19,24 26:2\n\n101:13,18\n\n60:17 62:17,\n\n31:4,6 37:19\n\n102:7,10,24\n\n21,25 63:10\n\n38:5 57:12\n\n103:7 104:4,\n\n73:20 82:15\n\n70:13,16\n\n10,15,16,24\n\n88:12,15,17\n\n105:1,7,10,\n\n52:8,11 58:1\n\nofficially\n\n68:22 69:4,13\n\n74:5 78:10\n\nobjecti g\n\n110:13,18\n112:23 113:3\n\n65:14 66:11\n\n128:25 130:25\n\n100:16\n\n49:3,9,13,19\n\n64:19,22\n\n115:23 127:1\n\nofficial\n\n38:6\n\nobtain\n\n60:13 61:6\n\n129:17\n\n:25\noffice\n\nobstruct\n\n45:5,7 56:6\n\n84:6 112:14\n\n26:4,5,6\n\n77:8\n\n7,9,12\n\n40:18 53:6\n\n14 90:21\n\n25:11,21\n\noffhand\n\n42:19\n\n29:6 30:24\n31:1 35:21\n\n124:10\n\n137:9\n\n59:7,14\nonline\n49:20\nopen\n19:15\nopening\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734822\n\n\f", "char_count": 1756}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 172, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n28\n\n24:19 26:21\n\n38:8 129:1\n\n28:24 78:19\n\nI\n\noriginal\n\noperative\n\n15:23 16:7,\n\n115:11\n\n17,21 18:4\n\nopportunity\n\n44:25 71:18\n\nI\n\npains\n\npart\n\n137:10\n\n14:16 17:22\n\npalatable\n\n21:25 22:7\n\n41:13\n\n74:2 86:24\n87:20 106:6,\n\nPalm\n\n17:3,7 116:2,\n\n87:25 92:4\n\n4:11 23:20\n\n4 119:3,6\n\n94:15 127:24\n\n33:2,6,22\n\n131:15\noppose\n117:19 121:25\n\n49:15 50:2,\n15,23 51:1\n55:14,20\n58:7,16,1\n\n50:16\nI\n\nopposing\n\nfiled\n\noutlet\n\n122:1 130:21\n\n85:23 118:24\n\n46:15 48:6,16\n\n18:1\n\n37:11 93:7\n\nopposed\n\noriginally-\n\noutright\n\nI\n\n31:15\n\nI\n\noutset\n42:19\n\nopposite\n\novercome\n\n41:14\nopposition\n39:17 87:25\n131:18\n\n120:9\noveresti\n98:6\n\noption\n\noratory\n98:6\n\n:5\n\n13:24 19:5\n\n95:24 138:23\n139:4\n\n101:11,\n\nA(401\n\npartner\n\n8 102:20\n99:19\n\n5:10,18\n\n107:7 108:6\n110:25\n115:14,17\n\npartners'\n82:11\nparty\n6:17,19,20,23\n7:17 8:8\n\n50:23,24\n\n15:20 16:4\n\n136:6,9,15,16\n\n18:15,19\n19:11 24:10,\n\nparagraph\n\norder\n\n11 25:22 26:2\n19:23 30:1,5\n\nP\n\n5:6 14:2\n\n72:3 75:25\n\n22:16\np.m.\n\n40:\n4\n\nparties\n\n65:22\n\npaper\n\n35:7 131:21\n\n1:3 112:14\n\n27:19 32:23\n\n126:5\n\nova\n\np rticipated\n\n33:11 78:8,13\n\n6\n\nti\n\n109:4\n\n60:5,6\n\n:;\n\n31:17 58:8\n\nparticipate\n\n59:4,8,\n\n4:12\n\n111:6\n\n24 135:10\n\n:13,\n2\n\n4:17 85:17\n8\":4 88:7\n\n4:2 95:12,13\n\n77:4,13,19,23\n\n138:19 140:2,\n\n80:18 87:16\n\n13\n\n88:1,2 94:4\n\npages\n\n117:23 118:4\n\n91:11 92:15\n\n28:18,19\n\n94:9 119:9,\n\n29:12,13\n\n18,21 120:2\n\n103:25 128:15\n\n128:11 134:12\nordered\n13:22 36:13\n\n76:12,20\n\npaid\n6:19 42:12\n\n29:5 30:22\n32:12 35:12\n36:7,21 37:7\n38:13,15,16,\n17,19,22,23\n39:11 41:5,20\n47:21 48:5\n\ni\n\n130:18\nparalegal\n4:9\n\n57:8 80:21\n84:23 85:17\n91:24 110:17\n\nparalegals\n\n111:3,11,20\n\n107:3\n\n112:24 114:6\n\n64:7\n\n118:18 121:2\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734823\n\n\f", "char_count": 1692}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 173, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n29\n\n125:3 127:8\n\n83:6 84:5\n\n127:18,25\n\n131:13,24\n\n87:7 107:6\n\n132:23\n\n44:21 56:9\n\n132:5 133:11,\n\n109:10 115:25\n\nplaintiff\n\n66:13,21,25\n\n22\n\n137:9\n\n7:9,15 8:19\n\n67:10 73:19\n\nparty's\n\npersons\n\n14:9,15 15:1,\n\n87:10\n\n6:20,24\n\ni\n\n14:2\n\npast\n\n3,12 17:7\n\npersuasive\n\n51:6 58:18\n\n41:13\n\n62:5 67:3\n\npertinent\n\n96:23,24 97:3\n\npleadings\n\npleased\n\n18:14,22 20:5\n\n129:25\n\n21:5 22:18\n\n130:16,19,23\n\n23:2 30:9\n38:18,20 44:5\n\n14:16\n\np enty\n.17\n\n50:12 54:11\npay\n\npoint\n\nPeter\n\n59:20\n\n55:16,18\n\n48:21\n\npending\n93:20 115:11,\n12,13 119:16\npeople\n\nI\n\npetition\n\n60:10\n\n85:5\n\n82:19\n\n98:5,6\n\nphone\n122:18\n\nperception\nphonetic\n60:22\n99:21\nperform\n\nti\n\nphras\n12:4\n\n6 96:10\n128:23\n\nAcTe\n\n113:12 120:4\n\n5,9 22:17\n\n121:20 123:5\n\n28:4 47:18,25\n\n125:1,10,18\n\n55:23 56:24\n\n127:7 130:13\n\n62:24 63:5\n87:24\n\nplaintiffs'\ned\n\n18:24\n\npinned\n\n49:2,14,16\nplayed\n\n1\n\n:6\n\nplace\n\n7\n\n:9\n\n22:3\nplace-holder\n\n116:4\n\nportion\n\n116:1\n\n75:10\n\nplea\n\n136:18\n\n26:24 27:7\n\npersonally\n\n28:11,12,16\n\n42:13 66:14,\n\n29:19 31:10\n\n16 71:11\n\n36:18 37:25\n\n81:22 82:9\n\n119:25 126:10\n\n50:24 51:5\n83:19,20\n\nplaying\n133:5\nplace-marker\n\nportal\n\n116:2 122:4\n\n50:18 51:6\n12:\n\npopped\n78:21\n\nplay\n\nperson\n\n107:8 108:5\n\n107:10\n\n18:1\n\n93:15\n\n84:2 108:5\n\npoints\n\npolice\n: 4 125:16\n\n51':20 71:7\n\n93:2 97:13\n\nk iff's\n\n5:3,17 13:12\n\n11:1,17\n\nsonal\n\n73:13,14 81:1\n\nplaintiffs\n\nperformance\n\n62:5 92:10\n\n53:24 57:4\n59:12 64:12\n\n7\n\nperiod\n\n24:24 35:15\n\n70:19 72:13\n9\n\nphase\n97:14 108:11\n\n48:18 83:9\n\n56:4,8,1\n\nposition\n\n66:23 102:9,\n\n8:12 13:11\n\n14\n\n17:4,8,14,17\n\npleading\n\n30:11,16 38:9\n\n67:5 88:9\n\n43:24 47:5\n\n131:8\n\n54:14 58:22\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734824\n\n\f", "char_count": 1645}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 174, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n30\n90:2\n\n73:2,23,25\n\n51:1,10 58:8,\n\n79:6 88:24\n\n16,18,21\n\nposturing\n\n134:19\n\n114:23 115:4,\n\n59:4,8,16\n\n10:12\n\npresented\n\n8,15 118:16\n\n60:5 62:11\n\n122:6 125:6\n\n65:23 68:23\n\n129:11,19,22,\n\n72:7,14\n\n23 130:3,13\n\n74:13,14\n\n131:7,10\n\n76:1,9,20\n\n133:3 134:17\n\n78:2 86:4,17\n\npresentations\n\n6:25 13:4,20\n\npower\n\npositions\n\n88:12 89:2\n91:16,24\n\n136:7,8\n\n101:11,16\n\n35:21 36:23\n45:19,21\n\n55:19 76:4,22\n78:4,15 81:2,\n\npowers\n72:10 73:22\n\n113:15\n\npractice\n102:11\n\n102:2,18,23\n103:20 104:19\n\n46:24\n105:11,16,18\npossessed\n\n15:1 19:24\n21:7 33:6\n\nident\n\n29:25 114:25\n\npossess\n\n7:23 24:15\n\n99:23 100:\npress\nprecluded\n49:9,13\n\n13:15\n\n50:10,14,17\npredator\n\n106:2 115:13,\n\n51:12 56:10\n\n50:6 67:4\n\n17 116:10,17\n\n67:12,15\n\npossession\n\n119:13 123:6\n\n7:20 22:13\n\n126:8 131:4\n\n24:13,21 37:5\n\n132:19 133:\n\n45:14,16,25\n\n134:19 1\n\n46:3,5 48:8,\n\n136:2,\n\n14 51:1 52:5\n53:5 56:1,20\n\nssor\n21 66:11,\n\n79:13 94:2\n\n110:24\n\n130:4\n\n66:6\npreeminent\n\n4\n\n60:24 63:7\n\n20:18\n\n115:9\n\n67:21 79:5\n\n130:21\n\nprefer\n\n80:3,4,24\n\n1:2 134:17\n\n81:1,4 90:3\n19 105:9\n114:7\n125:5;\n\npost-1999\n6:9\npost-trial\n28:6\n\n13\n\n23:18,22\n\nprefers\n98:3\nprejudgment\n\nprejudice\n\nposting\n\n5:8 22:6\n\n30:16 33:3,\n\n49:20\n\npreparation\n\n53:3 59:24\n60:3,22 78:22\n\n46:15 48:17\n\n85:24 86:17,\n\n50:15,23\n\n20,21 89:12\n\n6:19 32:11\n38:12,14,16,\n39:11 41:20\n\n51:3\n\n39:15 43:3\n\nprevailing\n\n17,19,23\n\n6:18\n\n13 35:3,6,7,8\n\n28:20\n\n139:1,5\n\nposted\n\nposts\n\nprevail\n\n98:2 138:24\n\n':2 26:1\n27\n16,22 34:2,8,\n\npretty\n\n8 109:19\n\npredecessors\n\nPost'\n\n83:21\n\nprevent\n24:16 48:17\n61:10,20\n116:23 125:11\nprevented\n63:6\nprevention\n\n137:7\n\n129:21\n\npresent\n\npreventive\n\n6:15 99:15\n\n129:21\n\npresentation\n\nprevious\n\n139:22\n\n17:20 99:15\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734825\n\n\f", "char_count": 1726}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 175, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n31\n\npreviously\n\n103:1 108:8\n\n37:11 49:22\n\n109:15 112:19\n\n51:21 131:6,\n\n134:24\n\n14\n\nproduce\n\nprimarily\n\nproviding\n\n59:13\nprosecuted\n59:11 102:6\nprosecution\n\n13:15 16:13\n29:6\nprovince\n\n7:19 45:8,9\n\n14:4 33:24\n\n88:6\n\n100:13 108:25\n\n54:14 56:5\n\n37:2 49:21\n\nprovision\n\n109:9\n\n118:13\n\n103:1,8\n\nprimary\n\nproduced\n\n85:1\n\n83:21 84:20\n\nprosecutorial\n\n:15\n\nprotect\n\n113:8\n\nproduces\n\n85:17 112:\n\nprincipal\n\n91:7\n\n115:24 12\n\n110:7\n\nproducing\n24:16 30:3,13\n\nprinted\n\n17:19 26:23\n\nproduction\n\n27:15 59:10\n\n31:5 38:8\n\n68:21 73:19\n\n61:7 62:9\n\n92:16 99:19\n\n91:22 12\n\n102:19 129:11\n\nprofessi\n122\n\nprivate\n40:22 119:14\n\n13:18 14:12\n\n5 30:22\n\nbit\n\n23:22,25\n24:3,7,12,15\n34:1,2,21\n\n:2\n35:17,20\nprove\n\n41:10 46:16\n\n41:23\n\n48:17 49:16,\n\nproved\n\n20,23 55:22\n\nprovide\n\nproblem\n72:21\n\non\n\n119:1\n\np\n\n14:19 119:7\n\npublic\n\n24:7 1\n\n91:6 94:8,14\n\nprior\n\nprovisions\n129:20\n\nprotect\n\n35:22 37:9\n\n136:14\n\n17:2,12 26:14\n7:19 54:18\n\n134:23\n\n91:10\n\nprime\n\n15:5,16 16:1\n\n56:8,10 57:23\n66:7 68:22\n\n13:8,17 17:3,\n\n72:8,16 73:23\n\n11 18:17\n\n74:3,5 76:13,\n\nprocedural\n\n13:18\n\n20:20 33:4\n\n25 82:4,7\n\n10:12\n\nprohibits\n\n45:8 47:7\n\n83:8,23 84:8\n\nprocedu\n\n36:25\n\n52:22,24\n\n94:24 102:3\n\n78:3,14\n\n104:19 105:19\n\n107:11 118:7\n\n107:14 109:3\n\n123:15\n\n113:20 114:2\n\n6:8\n\n2\n\nprongs\n131:13\n\nPr\n\nproof\npr\n\needings\n\n4:2 76:24\n77:15 109:5\n\n118:20\nproper\n7:13 10:9\n\n121:18 125:10\n\n18:15,19\n\n127:3\n\n47:20 48:5\n\nprocess\n8:9 85:11\n\n110:6,17\n\nprovided\n\npublish\n\n36:8 54:19\n\n45:13\n\n56:19 104:6,\n\npublisher\n\n12 105:10,16,\n\n4:11\n\n20 106:14\n\npull\n\n108:1 109:5\n\n28:11 29:8\n\n126:4\n\n30:1 32:19\n\nprosecute\n\n34:22 68:3\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734826\n\n\f", "char_count": 1640}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 176, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n32\n\n77:9 111:11\n\n11 127:8\n\n112:1 117:1\n118:1,2\n120:21 126:12\n127:14 130:9\n\nqualification\n\n58:21\n\n103:13 105:4\n\n79:11 81:15\n89:10,11 94:4\n\npurely\n\nRaton\n\n136:17\n\npurpose\n39:8 55:21\n\n57:19 63:14\n\nre-arrest\n\n5:23 86:3\n\n102:22\n\n:14 112:6\n113:10 120:18\n\nreach\n\n121:1 125:3\n\n106:20\n\nrecall\n\nreached\n\n21:1 41:4\n\n69:1 90:25\n\n72:8 92:25\n\nreasons\n1:13 36:20\n\nquestions\n\n6:6,11 14:5\n\n48:22\n60:4,7 117:16\n\n94:24 95:4\nr\n\n113:5 130:15\n\nreceive\n\nquick\npurposes\n\n1\n4 4 31 :18\n\nquicker\n\nad\n\n68:12\n\n8:22 9:13\n\n5:11 13:23\n14:23 22:16\n38:24 49:22\n\n129:24\n105:1\n\n94:20\n\n38:23\npursuant\n\n32:3,7 47:15,\n23 49:12\n\n56:22 72:9\n\n51:21 55:9\n45:25\n:15 85:1\n\nput\nR\n\n8:19\n47:\n\n75:2 87:21\n\n3\n\nl\n\n22 90:22,\n119:2\n\n136:15\n\nputting\n50:14\npuzzled\n10:11 11:15\n\nraise\n126:25\nraised\n15:23 31:8\n\nraises\n15:22 29:24\n38:3 92:23\n\n108:4 121:9\n122:1 126:1\nrecess\n95:11 140:12\nrecognize\n20:8 44:11\n\n130:19 136:14\n\n49:8 51:9\n\n25:5 80:16\nready\n23:16 98:16\nreal\n\n79:1,9 88:18\n101:8\n\n70:20 104:22\n\n109:12,24\n\nreading\n4\n\n8 89:17,\n\n2\n\n67:9 69:11\n107:14\n\n88:2\n\n61:14\n\n34:4 50:21\n\n19:19 26:9\n\n35:1\n\n76:2,23 88:7\n\nreceived\n68:22 69:4\n\nquickly\n\n54:1 55:17\n\npursued\n\n97:14\n\n99:15,18\n\n135:19,21\n\n117:12\n\nreasonableness\n\n100:20,21\n\n82:24 83:1\n\n132:14\n\n20:3\n\nrated\n\n63:12 64:3\n\npulling\n\nreasonable\n6:17 18:10,11\n\nRandy\n\n78:15\nquestion\n\n132:1\n\n24:6 35:14\n\nQ\n\n54:9 55:6\n57:7 76:14\nrecognized\n95:20 134:21\nrecollection\n\n18:7 65:3\n\n49:5\n\n94:20 100:4\n\nrecord\n\nreason\n\n8:22 22:17\n\n29:4 57:25\n\n26:9 31:3,9\n\n58:2 60:14\n\n40:12 47:16\n\n88:13 121:7,\n\n51:20 61:13\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734827\n\n\f", "char_count": 1585}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 177, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n95:12\n\n33\nreferenced\n53:13 82:17\n\nrecords\n7:14,19,22\n8:15 10:4,7,\n16 11:18,20,\n22,23 12:1\n\nreferences\n29:20 57:21\nreferencing\n51:10\n\n13:16,17\nreferring\n14:10,18\n\n80:7 120:23\n\n18:17,23\n19:12,14\n\nrefresh\n\n11:19 22:15\n\n41:3,12,17\n\n30:24 36:12,\n\n42:3,9 55:17,\n\n23 37:12,21,\n\n24 56:3,25\n\n23 39:17\n\n67:7 75:20,23\n\n45:19,21\n\n77:20 82:19\n\n49:2,9,13\n\n94:11 117:18\n\n50:11,15,17\n\n118:12,19\n\n51:13 53:6\n\n133:21\n\n56:10 61:16,\n\nliefs\n\n17,18,23 63:8\n\n8:6\n\n21:20 22:14,\n\n49:5\n\n83:21 85:19\n\n16 24:4 29:7\n\nrefused\n\n86:6 112:1\n\n30:8 34:2,15,\n\n33:4 37:18\n\n114:2 115\n\n21 35:4,16,22\n\n78:3,13 83:19\n\n117:19\n\n36:1 37:9\n\n118:6\n\n127:1\n\n39:17 40:11,\n19 47:20\n48:3,14\n49:17,20,22,\n23 50:12\n52:6,22,23\n54:15 57:22\n\n102:3,19\n111:19\n135:1\n\n60:6,14\n61:18,19 63:9\n\nAS7\n\ned\n:21 49:9,22\n\n116:25\n\n12\nremainder\n\n56:21 59:6\n\n77:13\n\n60:14 79:9\n\nremained\n\n89:4\nreleasing\n\nre\n\nrelying\n\n130:14 131:5,\n\n35:23\n\n39:23,25\n\n26:23 47:3\n\nremain\n\nrefuted\n\nregard\n\nrely\n\n30:8 40:19\n\n41:3 120:16\n122:6\nremaining\n\n68:22 69:9\n\n41:7 50:25\n\n5:10 21:1\n\n74:4,5 79:9,\n\n88:4 125:12\n\n133:22\n\n21 82:4,7\n\n7:8\n\n83:9,17,18\n\nreiterate\n\n84:8,24 85:1\n\n22:12\n\n88:4 99,20\n91:\n9\n\nreiterating\n105:8\n\n•:19\n\n1\n\n28:23\n\nrelated\n103:21 107:23\n\nirect\n9 :19,21\n138:22\n139:10,18\nreevaluate\n17:4,8\nreference\n66:16\n\nrelating\n25:3,6 49:3\n103:7\nrelationship\n63:6\nrelease\n5:14 10:21\n\n128:23 129:11\n134:6\nrelevance\n62:18 63:1,2\n\nremarks\n51:23,25 52:3\nremember\n25:2 80:6,10,\n\nrelevant\n\n16 86:22,23\n\n85:16\n\n87:12 89:19\n\nrelied\n111:8,18\nrelief\n\n109:13 131:13\nreminded\n37:19\n\n5:12,18,20\n\nreminder\n\n21:2,7 22:3,\n\n42:6\n\n9,21 23:4\n25:4,10 33:1,\n\nremotely\n43:2\n\n8 37:7 40:3,5\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734828\n\n\f", "char_count": 1676}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 178, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n34\n\nremoved\n\n14:10 22:14\n\nreserved\n\n58:22\n\n30:4 45:15\n\n42:25\n\nrepeat\n\n46:20 48:14\n\nresign\n\n55:20 56:2,7,\n\n82:24,25\n\n70:20 71:4\n84:16\n\n48:20 102:16\n\n21 63:8 72:7\n\nrepeatedly\n53:11 56:7\n\nI\n83:10 84:10,\n\nreply\n\n18 88:5 94:8,\n\n37:24 127:12,\n\n66:23 69:9\n75:25 77:4\n\n109:8 110:7\nrest\n\n79:7\n\n95:15\n\nrespected\n\nr state\n\n14\n\n17,21,24\n128:16 129:4,\n\nresponsibility\n35:18 107:4\n\nrespect\n74:7 82:19\n\nresponses\n\nrequesting\n122:8\n\n:11\n\n34:20 37:1\n15 130:3,11\n60:7 82:19\nreport\n\n103:20 113:19\n\n50:24,25\n\nrespectfully\n40:8 41:1\n43:4 7\n\nrequests\n\n125:25\n\n23:4 34:3,21,\n\nrespond\n\n25 43:4\n\n82:10\n\n109:16\n\n49:19,23\n\n7:7\n\n68:23 69:9\n\n59:9,12 91:3\n\nceded\n\n74:4 76:2\n\n:19 69:14\n\nreporting\n\n82:8 84:3\n\n72:6 73:18\n\n62:24\n\n94:25 1\n\n83:9 87:5\n\nrepresent\n\nrequir\n\n36:11\n\n25:\n\n98:15 124:6\n\nrepresenting\n\nresulted\n108:11\nrevelations\n108:18\nreversal\n20:1 21:13\nreversed\n\nresponding\n74:3\n\nirement\n\n42:15 101:1\n\n50:21 106:4\n\n21:18\n,16 56:1\n\nrepresents\n\nresult\n\n125:2,13\n127:8 128:14\n\n107:1\n\n96:4\n\n26:21 38:22\n\nreported\n\nreporter\n\nrests\n\n27:1 31:12\n\nreview\n105:15 106:19\n\nresponse\n\n109:13 114:2\n\n33:11 36:17\nrequirements\n\nreprobate\n137:2\n\n:9\n\nrequ\n\n32:10\n\n37:24 49:19\n82:13 84:22\n87:24 89:8\n\n:4\n\nrequires\n26:15\n\n14 67:6\n\nresearch\n\n104:21,22\n\n.21 76:18\n\n91:5 93:5,13\n\nreviewed\n44:20 107:16\nreviewing\n108:9 117:16\nrights\n\n8:14 13:14\n\n105:2,12,13\n\n100:14 109:2\n\n79:8 82:5,16\n\n34:16,17 36:4\n\n116:11 121:8,\n\n116:18\n\n83:9,13 84:4\n\n108:21\n\n9 122:2\n\n120:14,15\n\n105:19 123:17\n\n109:10,25\n\n123:16 126:9,\n\n130:22\n\n110:1\n\n16 127:12,19\n\nrequested\n7:19 13:8\n\nresearching\n34:14\n\nroad\n11:7,11\n\n128:12 129:5,\n14 130:2,20\n131:2\n\nrole\n110:17\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734829\n\n\f", "char_count": 1683}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 179, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n35\nsell\n\n112:18,19\n\nsanctioned\n\n116:1,2,4\n\n100:22\n\n24:8 109:15\n\nsanctions\n\n111:4 112:20,\n\n122:4 136:6\nrolling\n53:17\n\n11:19\nrooted\n5:12\nrule\n\n53:18 105:2\n119:24 130:1\n\n15:21,24\n\n115:8,24\n\n19:22 23:3\n\n117:21 119:1,\n\n25:3,21 26:4,\n\n4,7 120:8\n\n19 31:19 32:2\n\n121:13 122:7\n\n33:14 38:13\n\n125:7 129:20\n\n39:21 41:23\n\n133:12\n\n43:5 53:17\n\n41:16 93:9\n\n61:14 101:2,3\n132:16,22\nSAO\n\n19:3 101:5\nruling\n\n39:20\n\nScholz\n\nrun\n\n44:8\n\n10:17 23:20\n\nc;:'\n\n1\n\nscreen\n68:4 69:22,25\n\nor\n\n5:5,15,25\n1\":2,12 26:14\n27:1,10,18\n28:7 31:12\n\n126:19\n\nsecurities\n100:4\n\nsea\n133:6\nseal\n124:7\nsealed\n123:24,25\nseated\n4:3 95:14\n\nSeptember\n70:17 134:11\nseries\n61:1,2\nserve\n16:10 17:18\n\n53:16 77:12\n\n19:5 31:13\n\n115:16,23\n\n123:19\n\n118:12 123:6,\n\nserved\n\n10\n\n16:5,7,8,9\n\nseeking\n\n22:20 26:15,\n\n7:14 14:9\n\n18,25 79:20\n\n18:24 19:4\n\n92:16 93:4,12\n\n23:18 35:8\n\n132:18\n\n50:13 55:16\n\nserving\n\n72:7 73:21\n\n16:8\n\n70:3 124:15\n127:4 128:19\n\nsanction\n\n,23 33:9\n\n135:8\n\n58:10 66:1\n\n54:18\n\nsentencing\n\n00:15 109:8\n\noped\n\n27\n\n103:4 106:5\n\n:20\n\ntI4!\n\n96:16\n\nsafe\n\n72:17 87:14,\n90:10,12\n\n102:12\n\nseek\n\n99:18\n\n9:18 84:14\n\n16 88:23\nSecreta\n\n019 75:23\n\nSchoo\n\nRutherford\n\nsense\n\n125:25\n\nrush\n\nof\n\n58:16 59:9\n\n)\n\nscenario\n20:15\n\n50:15\n\nonce\n\n55:25 56:6,\n\nrulings\n\nsending\n\nsecret\n\nsect\n\n13,14\n\n119:12\n\nsend\n\n8:4 13:5\n\n18:4 19:4\n\nrules\n\n59:17 65:4\n\n25 113:4,8\n\n42:5,11,24\n\n101:2,5\n\nsecrecy\n\n76:10 90:20\n\nset\n\n103:7,23\n\n36:20 92:4\n\n106:2 112:11\n\n94:14 121:1\n\n119:15\n\n123:1 132:21\n\nseeks\n\nsettlement\n\n56:4 76:11,21\n\n122:10,11\n\n85:16\n\n130:1\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734830\n\n\f", "char_count": 1572}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 180, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\nSeventh\n100:17\n\n36\nSidlosca\n26:6\n\nsexual\n\nsigned\n\n23:23\n\n44:12\n\nshareholder\n99:13\nSharon\n\nsole\n\nsignificant\n\nsolely\n\n17:1 47:17,24\n\nShore\n27:25\nshort\n52:16\nshortly\n70:25 91:15\n\n43:11 98:8\n\n15:7 18:18\n\n11:5,14 33:12\n\n83:15 105:17\n\n80:21 84:23\n\n120:12\n\n22:18 31:18\n\n118:9\n\n29:1 3\n\nsincere\n\n33:3,8\n\n41:12 135:12\nsir\n\n33:21 44:10\n49:8 51:8\n53:19 55:5\n\nsitting\n82:10_136\n\n57:6\n\n139:24\nsounding\n\nsounds\n109:25\n\nshowing\n32:13 86:12\n\nis\n\nshown\n\n98:6\n\n73:8\n\nslash\n\nshows\n13:(14\nd i%v\n\n9:17\nslide\n77:23\n\n70:16\n7\nside\n\nslow\n70:2\nSo.3d\n\n31:21 32:1,5,\n15,16 41:19,\n\n135:2\n\nsit\n\nstandard\n\n8:2,7\n6 111:2\n\nv\n\nstand\n\n8,12 38:14,\n\nound\nAN\n\n54:7\n\n48:3\n\n8:23\n\n138:4\n\n:5,9,18\n\n140:4\n\nsought\n\n89:23 93:19\n\nstamp\n6:10 47:16,\n\nsort\n\n6:3 9:2 70:24\n\nshow\n\n74:4 107:6\n\nsolemnly\n\n100:6 107:21\n\n107:10\nspoken\n\n11:20\n\nsimply\n\n34:4\n\nspoke\n\n5:9 56:20\n\n62:7 74:2\n\nshed\n\n65:17,18\n\n56:10\n\nsilent\n\n48:6\n\n34:13 64:22\n\nsocial\n\n139:23,25\nSouthern\n102:7,13\nspeaking\n61:20 84:7\nspecific\n34:25 35:4\n103:20\nspecifically\n\n21\nstanding\n115:15\nstart\n9:9 53:17\n108:8 137:24\nstarted\n48:18 50:4\n108:10 130:7\n137:22\nstarting\n25:13\nstarts\n72:1\nstate\n4:16 7:23\n10:6,9,12,15,\n\n67:12,13,14,\n\n5:24 6:4 8:1\n\n5:16 111:19\n\n19,25 11:12,\n\n15,17 110:16\n\n124:1\n\n16,24 12:9\n\n15:18 26:9\n\n135:24\nsidelines\n53:5 61:5\n\nsober\n137:7\n\nspeculation\n52:12\n\n14:20 19:8,14\n21:5 23:21\n24:5,9,18,20,\n\nspent\n\n24 25:22,24\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734831\n\n\f", "char_count": 1436}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 181, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n37\n\n26:17,22\n\n7,11,13,18,\n\n27:14 28:25\n\n19,21,23\n\n29:4,20 30:2,\n\n114:6,14,23\n\n6,11,18,20,21\n\n115:4,18\n\n31:13,17\n\n116:9 117:7\n\n33:1,11,25\n\n118:13,16\n\n34:19 35:2,5,\n\n119:24 120:4,\n\n10,11,13,15,\n\n17,19 121:2,\n\nStatistics\n100:13\n\nstayed\n\n133:7\n\n16:6\n\nstatute\n\nstems\n\n5:13 6:6,13\n7:6 13:19\n\n6,7,12,16,19,\n8 18:18 20:6\n\n36:7,8,10,11,\n17,18,21,25\n\n25 122:3,11,\n\n62:7\n\nstatus\n\n14:15 15:4,6,\n19,20,23,25\n\nstay\n\n58:20 59:15\nstep\n9:1\nephen\n\n21:12,25 25:8\n\n20,23 123:12\n\n:15 34:9\n27:2 31:20\n\n37:4,7,21\n38:6,10,12,16\n\n96:10 98:13,\n\n124:9,13,23\n\n32:2,3 33:\n23,25\n\n125:2,8,16\n\n39:10,15\n\n126:9,17,25\n\n40:7,23\nsteps\n\n54:2,1\n40:10,13,18\n\n127:7,12,17\n\n41:4 42:12,\n\n128:1,10,16,\n\n15,16,17,18\n\n21,24,25\n\n43:17 44:2\n\n129:5,10\n\n48:2 49:15\n\n130:19,24\n\n50:1,2,5\n\n131:4,15,23\n\n76:3 13\n,19,21,\n2\n\n:5\n\n1 :18 115:9,\nA<; ,16 116:18,\n55:14,25\n\n19 117:14,22\n\n132:5,8,\n\n71:9,14,15\n\n133:3,\n\n80:19,20,23,\n\n134:\n\n25 81:24\n\n13\n\n118:25\n\nstipulated\n12:22 95:23\nstonewalling\n48:16\nstood\n117:25\n\n119:10,14\n120:9,11,13\n122:7 134:24\n\n84:23,25\n\nstop\n75:5 108:15\n137:24\n\nstatute's\n\n85:7,16,18\n87:15 88:3\n\n48:12 50:11\n\n119:7\n:7 91:21\n\nstory\n58:10 59:17\n\nstatutes\n\n91:5 94:7,1\n\n103:25 107:24\n\n99:22 100:9,\n\n128:25 129:6\n\n7:21 13:7,14\n\n15 101-\n\n14:13 20:14\n\n6:8\n\n131:7\n\n56:20 109:9\n\nStreet\n\n102:2\n\nstatement\n\n10 46\nA4?\n\n4,..1.\n\n39:18 49:18\n4\n\n78:19 89:25\n\n,7,9,16,\n130:20\n1\n\nI\n\n106:13,18\n\nstatutorily\n22:15\nstatutory\n\nstreamline\n\n140:8\nstrict\n31:12\n\n19:19 21:11\n\nstrictly\n\n8:18 13:2\n\n22:4 25:4,7,\n\n27:3\n\n40:12 51:20\n\n12 37:13 42:7\n\n18,20,22,23\n\nstrike\n\n111:2,10,19\n\n60:4\n\n74:15,20,24\n\n112:6,7,11,\n\nstates\n\n108:7 109:15\n\nstatements\n\n110:4,11,12,\n\n108:22 115:24\n117:12\n\n74:8 88:10\nstrong\n\n17,22,23\n\n13:19 99:23\n\n41:12 125:21\n\n113:1,2,3,5,\n\n101:14\n\n135:7\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734832\n\n\f", "char_count": 1799}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 182, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n38\n\nstuff\n\n5 46:4 59:5\n\n29:14 67:3\n\n61:19 67:14\n\n76:13 81:3\n\n71:10 86:4\n\n83:22 84:1\n\n100:16\n\n89:8\n\n110:12,21\n\nsupervisory\n72:10 73:22\n\n35:19 39:9\n85:2,18\n116:22,23\n\nsupplement\n39:2 139:19\n\nT\n\nsupport\nstymied\n\nsufficient\n\n20:13 39:21\n\n10:13\n\n27:7\n\n41:11 124:17,\n\nsubject\n\nsuggested\n\n18,24 127:18\n\n46:1 48:9\n\n66:12\n\n90:8 100:22\n\nsuing\n\nsubmitted\n\n131:17\n\n7:2,4\n\n8:23 44:22\n\n57:22 58:13\n\nsupportin\n\n107:5\n\n61:22 110:10\n\n36:6 7\n\n136:17\n\nsubpoena\n\nsuit\n\n112:10\n\n:8 111:25\ntabulation\n\n0\n\nsupposed\n1\n\nsummary\n\n28:3\n\n:20\nr0/1113\n\nsubsections\n\n57:1,2,15,AL\n\n19:21\nsubsequent\n\n118:22\n\n15:21,24\n\n109:2\n\n56:24\nout)\n\nsurrogate\n\ntalking\n\n109:3\n\n102:21\nsustain\n\nsummons\n\n62:20\n\n44:25\n\nSustained\n\n50:22\n\n81:5,7 94:23\n118:4\ntalks\n21:25\n\n52:1,12 60:19\n63:2 74:10\n\ntargeting\n62:14\n\nSuper\n97:20\n\nswear\n43:11 98:8\n\ntask\n24:25\n\nsupervised\n\nsweetheart\n\n85:19\n\n33:25\n\ntasked\n24:3,7 30:22\n\n61:20 71:9,14\nsupervision\n134:23\nsued\n13:9,16 45:4,\n\n31:23 65:16\n67:10 70:8\n111:7,16\n\n108:10\n\nSun-sentinel\nI\n\n60:3 71:18\n86:1\n\n6 101:22\n\nsubstanti e\n\ntalked\n\n116:3\n\nsurrounding\n\n8:6\n\n87:6 90:6,7\n\n125,,2::\n:1T13\n'\n\nsubstantial\n\n12:8 60:2\n\nsurprised\n\n92:7 122:9\n\n110:4 135:25\n\n73:24 129:18,\n\n124:104cN\n1\n\nsubstance\n\n19:12 45:7\n\ntaking\n22,23 131:9\n\n29:21 54:25\n\nsue\n\n18:9\n\ntalk\n\n13:23 26:14\n\n17\n\n8:1 31:22\n\n8:10 20:7\n\nsubsection\n\nly\n\n26:7,8 27:11\n9:1 69:17\n\nsupported\n\n11:24 19:13\n\ntab\n\nsupervisor\n116:22\n\nsworn\n43:18 98:14\nsystem\n\n107:3 109:7\n121:13\ntaxpayer\n\n25:1 30:23\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734833\n\n\f", "char_count": 1529}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 183, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n39\n\n64:24\n\n50:19 51:12\n\n70:19 71:11\n\n83:10 84:8,11\n\ntaxpayers\n\n58:13 59:14\n\n73:11,13,14\n\n86:3,16,18\n\n42:13 59:19\n\n61:9 62:1,9\n\n85:24 88:9,18\n\n87:9 89:7,11\n\n63:22,25\n\n65:12 67:18\n\n89:15 90:14,\n\n133:8\n\n64:4,13,18\n\n81:21 90:3,5\n\n16 91:21\n\n65:2\n\n97:7 138:21\n\n99:10,13\n101:17 102:4,\n\nthings\n\nteam\n\ntomorrow\n96:25 97:1\ntop\n\n34:8 106:25\n\n14:8 59:15\n\n12 125:15\n128:24 129:6\n\n107:16,19\n\n71:10 81:9\n83:20 105:8\n\n131:6,7\n\n131:3 136:5\n\n134:10\n\n:19\n\n108:16 139:2\n\ntimeline\n\ntotally\n\ntelling\n59:24 85:22\n\nthinking\n\n23:10 34,\n\n59:11\n\nterms\n\n14:8 57:10,11\n\n37:17\n\n102:25 103:1,\n\nt tal\n\n16:2 21:21\nTown\n\nthinks\n96:5 1\n\n107:6,7 108:6\n\n51:25\n\n2\n\ntrademark\nThirty\n\nterrible\n79:14\n\n96:18\n\ntestified\n\nThomson\n\n100:4\n15:2\n\n43:19 64:16\n\n4:10\n\n65:7 85:25\n\nthought\n\n8:2\ntiming\n\n98:15 104:9\n\n9:12 5\n\n109:18\n\n65:\n\n15:13\ntoday\n4:25 10:24\n15:7 25:3\n\n39:24 124:2\n139:11\ntranscriptions\n14:18\n\n34:10 40:2\n\ntranscripts\n\ng tful\n\n44:3 58:25\n\n50:5 58:13\n\n:18\n\n60:10 61:4\n\n60:25 61:9\n\n64:5,8 65:1\n\n67:4,6,15,20\n\n39:5 97:4,10\n\n67:18 82:10,\n\n81:5,17,19\n\n138:9,11,12,\n\n14 85:25\n\n83:11,13,17\n\n7 :18\n\n13,15,18\n\n86:19 88:18\n\n107:5,9,21\n\n97:6,\n\n140:2\n\n89:11,15\n\n118:9 124:4\n\n106:12\ntestimony\n10:21 14:2\n15:6 33\n\no\n\n12:12 25:5\n\n135:2\n\n90:17 96:13\n\n76\n\n9:3,23,25\n\n:12\n\ntestify\n\n55:19\n\ntranscript\n\n9\n\nAli?k\n\nThursday\n\n4:7,8\n\ntighter\n\n92:14 96:13,\n\n7:8 111:2\n\n139:3\n\n17 97:6,7,22\n\n118:8 139:11\n\ntexts\n48:18\nthing\n\ntime\n6:2,21 7:1\n22:19,20\n24:14 26:19\n\ntransparency\n77:1\n\n127:22\n132:11,16\n135:16\n\nTraurig\n4:10 30:15\n33:17 34:9\n\ntold\n\n10:23 17:1\n\n31:10 54:22\n\n5:16 48:24\n\n18:13 20:24\n\n65:17,18\n\n52:24 53:11\n\n99:1,11,16\n100:1 101:15\n104:24 106:22\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734834\n\n\f", "char_count": 1690}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 184, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n40\n\n114:5 135:4\n\n115:23 116:1\nO\n\n136:9\nTraurig's\n131:1\ntrial\n\nU.S.\n85:5 91:12\n100:19 102:6,\n\n7:1 8:5,7\n\n13 104:15\n\n100:7\n\n105:25 109:2\n123:14 125:23\n\ntrue\n29:17 30:10\n69:7 78:25\n\n126:4\nUh-huh\n\n89:15\n\n63:24\n\nTrump's\n\nultimate\n\n102:11\n\n7:12 63:7\n116:21\n\nTrust\n7:25\n\n122:3\n\n106:25\n\nundisputed\n\n6:9 9:3,4,12\n\nunequivocal\n130:20\n\n107:19 108:16\n\n98:10\n\n118:22 131:3\n\ntruthfully\n84:11\n\n20 133:1\n134:20,A>\nuaambiQu u\n\nturn\n31:20 67:8\n\n7:2\n\nversus\n19:14\n\nUnited\n\nvibrant\n\n101:14\n\n:: :12\n\nUniversity\n\nunquote\n\n4644\nctim\n\n99:6,8 109:14\n(;)\n\n26:24\n\n1\n\n:11\n\nvictims\n50:8\n\nunsuppo\n\ned\n\n5:18,21\n\nview\n89:6\n\n25\n\nviolated\n\ne\n\n26:13\n\n14:6 41:15\n\n43:13,14\n\nversion\n\n26:17\n\nultimately\n\ntruth\n\nversed\n\n16 41:25\ncoming\n13:2\n\nvoice\n131:15\nvoid\n\nupset\n\n92:19\n\n116:3\n\nvoluminous\n\nUpstate\n\n107:12\n\n99:6\n\nvoluntarily\n\n68:14 117:7\ntweet\nanged\n\n51:6\n\n20:23\n\ntwist\n\nunderlying\n\n20:5\nTwitter\n\n14:10 19:5,8\n\nUSC\n\n38:18\n\n100:14\n\nvoluntary\n\nutilized\n\n26:5\n\n14:6\n\nvoted\n136:20\n\n25:17 57:25\n\n50:\n\nV\n\nundermined\nge\nz20\ntwofer\n58:7\n\n106:13\nunderstand\n\ntype\n110:12\n\nValparaiso\n\n83:25 124:5\n\n109:14\n\nunderstanding\n83:7\n\ntypes\n100:1,10\n\n123:18\n\n67:11 73:24\n136:25 137:4\n\nunderstood\n\nW\n\nvague\nwait\n54:2\nWall\n\nvariety\n\n140:8\n\n100:3\n\nwanted\n\nvendetta\n58:20 136:19\n\n12:18 14:11\n45:9,11,13\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734835\n\n\f", "char_count": 1339}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 185, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n41\n\n48:22 58:11\n\n137:14 138:24\n\n99:9,14\n\n62:1 65:25\n\n139:9,23\n\n100:7,8\n\n30:20 61:1,2,\n\n108:12,13,24\n\n25 73:4 80:5\n\n135:3,4\n\n86:11 90:11,\n\n83:14 85:12\n89:13 90:6,\n\nwhim\n36:2\n\n13,15,16\n\n101:3 102:10\n\n11:19\n\n104:14,18\n110:4 111:11\n\n110:23\n\n113:1,22\n\n111:12 14\n\n122:2 123:11,\n\n112:21\n\n:3 9:2,8,11,\n\n97:13\n\n11:22,23 20:6\n\n42:15 43:9,21\n2:1\n136:5,\n\nwithdraw\n\n138:23\n\n17:5 27:21\n\nWeb\n\nAc X 9:16 140:8\n\n28:5\n\n49:2,14,16\n50:24 51:3,5\n\nwithdrawn\n27:23\n\nweek\n\n\\\nwithcAk me\n\n96:25\n\n136:3 139:4,\n\n10:22 14:5\n\n20\n\n4:7,8 1\n\nwritten\n15\n\n23:7,\n31:'\n\n17\n:\n\n7\n\n•9:22\n85:25\n1995:8,25\n96:7,10,14,\n\nwon\n\n13:7 48:25\n\n32:11\n\n58:19 80:12\n\nword\n109:12 136:15\n140:9\nwording\n60:3\n\n60:1,20 62:22\n63:3,4,14\n82:15 84:19\n86:13 92:6\n94:20,22\n95:4,7,15\n96:1 97:12,20\n\n104:8\n\nWhetstone\n\n48:10 52:2,\n54:6,8 58:3\n\n121:20 130:7\n\nwhatsoever\n\n47:11,15\n\n80:22\n\n97:25 98:4,5\n\n1\n\n46:7,10,12\n\n13,19 53:21\n\n59:5 70:3\n80:5\n\n44:8,15,19\n\nwrites\n\nwriting\n\nweeks\n\n28:23 29:15\n32:3,7 39:7\n\nwrite\n\n64:11\n\nways\n\n1:17,23,25\n23:6 26:20\n\nworthwhile\n\nwins\n\n99:18\n\n106:22\n\n42:10 108:12\n\n11\n\nWargo\n\n4:13,14,20,23\n5,20,22\n\n10:18 11:2,7,\n\n136:11\n\nworking\n\nworth\n\nwin\n\n23 124:5\n\n104:25\nWyler\n\n119:5\n\nWille\n\n106:3,21\n\n17 103:19\n\nworked\n\nwiggle\n95:16,19\n\nwrote\n\n87:8 97:22\nI\n\n105:18 121:9\n139:2\n\n121:22\n122:16,17\n128:6 130:10\n137:19,23\n138:4,6,10,12\n139:14,25\n\nwrong\n34:1 60:12\n\ny\n\n18,21 98:1,\n17,19 103:10,\n12 111:24\n112:2 124:20,\n22 126:22,24\n127:14,16\n\nwords\n7:7 76:11\n133:5\nwork\n\n64:18,20\n66:22\nwrongdoing\n137:12\n\nyears\n34:7 50:1\n58:17,19 59:7\n91:12,13\n\n21:10 41:14\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734836\n\n\f", "char_count": 1601}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 186, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 06, 2022\n\n42\n\n99:12,16\nyesterday\n130:21\nYork\n99:6,22,25\n100:9,15\n102:7\nyoung\n104:8\n\nZ\nZOOM\n139:21\n\nCos\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734837\n\n\f", "char_count": 188}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 187, "text_content": "CA Florida Holdings, L.L.C.\nvs.\nDave Aronberg\n\nHearing Be4c),\nJudge L\nSep\n\nlgado\n8\n\n2022\n\nPHIPPS REPORTING\nRaising the Bar!\n\nEFTA02734838\n\n\f", "char_count": 140}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 188, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n\nIN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT\nIN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA\nCASE NO. 50-2019-CA-014681-XXXX-MB AG\n\nCA FLORIDA HOLDINGS, LLC,\nPublisher of the PALM BEACH POST,\n\nA\n\nPlaintiff,\nvs.\n\nDAVE ARONBERG, as State Attorney\nof Palm Beach County, Florida;\nSHARON R. BOCK, as Clerk and\nComptroller of Palm Beach Count[,\nFlorida,\nDefendants.\n\n( 4;:\nTRANS\n\nRE:\n\nDefen\nAttorn\n\nTAKEN:\nCE:\n\n+\n\nBEFORE:\n\nAS 4 \\\n\nSK\n\nF CONTINUATION OF\nNG PROCEEDINGS\nve Aronberg's Amended Motion for\nFees\n\nThursday, September 8, 2022\n1:06 p.m. - 2:42 p.m.\nPALM BEACH COUNTY COURTHOUSE\n205 North Dixie Highway\nCourtroom 10D\nWest Palm Beach, Florida\n33401\nLUIS DELGADO, JR , Circuit Judge\n\nStenographically reported by:\nLisa Begley, RPR, RMR\n271843\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734839\n\n\f", "char_count": 832}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 189, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 143\n1\n\nAPPEARANCES:\n\n2\n\nOn behalf of the Plaintiff:\nGREENBERG TRAURIG\n777 South Flagler Drive\nSuite 300 East\nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33401\n561-650-6420\nBY: LAUREN R. WHETSTONE, ESQ.\nwhetstonel@gtlaw.com\nMARK F. BIDEAU, ESQ.\nbideaum@gtlaw.com\nGERARD BUITRAGO, ESQ.\nbuitragog@gtlaw.com\n\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n\nAilAr\n\n8\n\n12\n\nOn behalf of Defendant, Dave Aronb rgO:\nJACOB, SCHOLZ & WYLER, LLC\n961687 Gateway Boulevard\nSuite 2011\nFernandina Beach, Flori\n904-261-3693\nBY: DOUGLAS A. WYL\ndoug@jswflorida.co\n\n13\n\nAlso present:\n\n9\n10\n11\n\nDav\nDef n\n\nAS\n\ng, State Attorney\n\n14\n15\n\nPublic Records Coordinator\nAgi le of the State Attorney PBC\n\n16\n17\n18\n19\n\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734840\n\n\f", "char_count": 747}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 190, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 144\n1\n\nINDEX\n\n2\n\nWITNESS\n\nPAGE\n\n3\n\nSTEPHEN MENDELSOHN, ESQ.\nCross Examination by Mr. Wyler\nRedirect Examination by Ms. Whetstone\n\n146\n187\n\nNon-movant rests\n\n204\n\n4\n5\n6\n7\n\nSA\n\n8\n0\n9\n\n210\n\nCertificate of Reporter\nc)\n\n10\n11\n'S\n\n12\n\nSA))\n\n13\n? S'\n\n14\n15\n16\nC AS)*\n17\n18\n19\n\n2\n2\n\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734841\n\n\f", "char_count": 386}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 191, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 145\n\n1\n\nThereupon,\n\n2\n\nthe following proceedings began at 1:06 p.m.:\n\n3\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right, please be seated.\n\n4\n\nAll right, announce your presence.\n\n5\n\nMS. WHETSTONE:\n\nGood afternoon, Your Honor,\n\n6\n\nLauren Whetstone, and with me, Mark H\n\n7\n\nBuitrago and paralegal, Jennifer T\n\nson, on\n\n8\n\nbehalf of Greenberg Traurig,\n\nlf of CA\n\n9\n\nFlorida Holdings, the publis\n\nf the Palm Beach\n\n10\n\nPost, the plaintiff, a\n\n11\n\nMendelsohn.\n\n12\n\nMR. WYLER-\n\nou\n\nau, Gerard\n\nwitness, Stephen\n\nafternoon, Your Honor,\nthe law firm\n\nDouglas Wyl\n\n14\n\nWyler he\n\nn behalf of the State Attorney, Dave\n\n15\n\nAronb\n\nfendant.\n\n16\n\nCOURT:\n\n17\n\n20\n21\n\nAll right, so we left off with\n\noss examination?\n\n18\n19 AS\n\nwl\n\n, Scholz &\n\n13\n\nMS. WHETSTONE:\nI\n\nYes, sir.\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nMadam Clerk, please swear in\n\nthe witness.\nSir?\n\n23\n\nTHE WITNESS:\n\n25\n\nYes, Your Honor.\n\nMR. WYLER:\n\n22\n\n24\n\nIs that where we are?\n\nII, I've been sworn in\n\nbefore.\nTHE CLERK:\n\nDo you solemnly swear or affirm\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734842\n\n\f", "char_count": 1055}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 192, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 146\n1\n\nthat the evidence that you're about to give will\n\n2\n\nbe the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the\n\n3\n\ntruth?\n\n4\n5\n\nTHE WITNESS:\n\nI do.\n\nThereupon,\n\n6\n\nSTEPHEN MENDELSOHN, ESQ.,\n\nAilac\n\n7\n\nhaving been duly sworn by the Clerk of th0q urt,\n\n8\n\nresponded and testified as follows:\n\n9\n\nCROSS EXAMINATI\n\n10\n\nBY MR. WYLER:\n\n11\n\nQ.\n\nGood afterno\n\n12\n\nA.\n\nGood afte\n\n,\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\nSo I'\n\nto start off with this:\n\n14\n\nit true that par\n\n15\n\non that are h\n\n16\n\nportions o\n\noi\n\nA\n\n?endelsohn.\n\nr. Wyler.\n\nf tkTe exhibits that we've all agreed\npart of evidence are some of the\n\nsettlement negotiations?\n\n17\n\nThere is one letter, yes.\n\n18\n\nOkay.\n\n19\n\nIsn't\n\nAnd isn't it true you and I talked\n\neral times regarding settlement?\n\n20\n\nA.\n\nSure.\n\n21\n\nQ.\n\nAnd isn't it also true that, during the\n\n22\n\npendency of our settlement negotiations, Mr. Aronberg was\n\n23\n\ncontacted by the same reporter that the SAO had\n\n24\n\npreviously prosecuted for illegal substances?\n\n25\n\nMS. WHETSTONE:\n\nObjection, Your Honor, no\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734843\n\n\f", "char_count": 1098}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 193, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 147\n\n1\n\nfoundation.\n\n2\n\nMR. WYLER:\n\nThat's fine.\n\n3\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nAll right.\n\n4\n\nBY MR. WYLER:\n\n5\n\nQ.\n\nIsn't it true, though, that Mr. Aronberg\n\n6\n\nand Mike Edmondson contacted you to complainaigout an\n\n7\n\narticle that was being written about him?\n\n8\n\nA.\n\n9\n\nthat I remember.\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\n11\n\nNo, no.\n\nI've never spo =jEdmondson\n\nWell, okay.\n\nTha\n\nne.\n\nBut you did\n\nspeak with Mr. Aronberg, r\n\n12\n\nA.\n\nNo.\n\nI doM\n\n13\n\nthis matter, unless\n\n14\n\nthan that, no.\n\neSv\n\nrZxall speaking to anyone on\non the phone with you.\n\nOther\n\n15\n\nQ.\n\n16\n\nmaybe you\n\ndo t know, Mr. Aronberg and Mike Edmondson\n\n17\n\nwere on'S\n\nphone with us, but isn't it true that there\n\n18\n\nwa\n\n19\n\ny, well, then part of when we spoke, and\n\ntittle, when you and I spoke in settlement\nations, that you offered to hold an article pending\n\n20\n\nsettlement negotiations?\n\n21\n\nMS. WHETSTONE:\n\n22\n\nsettlement discussion.\n\n23\n\nMR. WYLER:\n\nObjection, Your Honor,\n\nThey opened the door to\n\n24\n\nsettlement negotiations by putting it into\n\n25\n\nevidence.\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734844\n\n\f", "char_count": 1100}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 194, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 148\n\n1\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n2\n\nWhat exhibit are you talking\n\nabout?\nMR. WYLER:\n\n3\n\nI don't actually have an\n\n4\n\nexhibit that is part of evidence, but I do have an\n\n5\n\nexhibit that is not part of evidence that I will\n\n6\n\noffer to the Court.\n\n7\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n8\n\nis sustained.\n\n9\n\nA.\n\n10\n\nThat is absolutely unt0 e.\n\nBY MR. WYLER:\n\n11\n\nQ.\n\nSo you're sa\n\n12\n\nA.\n\nNo.\n\n13\n\nthat in the settlem\n\n14\n\nfavorable articl\n\n15\n\nYou suggested\n\n16\n\nthe other,\n\nMr. A\n\nt never happened?\nibe, , through you, suggested\nt the paper would write a\n\nout him if we were able to settle.\n\nAqt,71\n\nt.\n\nut\n\n17\n18\n\nA\n\nThat is good th40RObjection\n\nI didn't make a comment one way or\n\nabsolutely advised my client of it.\n\nI don't make editorial decisions for the\npa,\n\ns\n\nI have no authority to make such.\n\nQ.\n\n19 ^\n\nSo you're saying there was never a\n\n20\nversation between you and i where we discussed\n-..A.ISIL\n\\3\nMr. Aronberg creating a comment to go into the newspaper\n\n2\n\n22\n\nas part of those settlement negotiations where you wanted\n\n23\n\nus to drop our 57.105 demand and you offered to get an\n\n24\n\narticle held while we determined whether we would do\n\n25\n\nthat?\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734845\n\n\f", "char_count": 1227}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 195, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 149\n\n1\n\nMS. WHETSTONE:\n\n2\n\ncompound, compound.\n\n3\n4\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nObjection, Your Honor,\n\nSustained as compound.\n\nBY MR. WYLER:\nQ.\n\n6\n\nAll right, I'll move on.\nSo, in your direct examination\n\ne other\n\n7\n\nday, isn't it true that you stated that\n\nevoted\n\n8\n\nhundreds of hours to the research and\n\nopment of\n\n9\n\nbringing this lawsuit?\n\n10\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n11\n\nQ.\n\nOkay.\n\n4\n\nAnd s ,\n\n12\n\nextensively put time in\n\n13\n\nbefore you brought\n\n14\n\nA.\n\n15\n\nQ.\n\n16\n\nC\n\n1 of that research, you\n\nNk\no ing into Chapter 905.27\nion?\n\n•rior to Judge Marx's June 8th order\n\non the motion to dismiss Count 2 -- Let me scratch that.\n\n17\n\nIsn't it also true that your client's\n\n18\n\ncopplaint alleged against -- that my client was in\n\n19\n\npossession or control of the documents that are in this\n\n20\n\ntion, the subject of this action?\n\n21\n\nA.\n\nI'm sorry, can --\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\nI'll repeat it.\n\nIsn't it true that your\n\n23\n\nclient's complaints alleged that my client and/or his\n\n24\n\noffice is in, quote, possession and/or control of the\n\n25\n\ndocuments that are subject of this action?\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734846\n\n\f", "char_count": 1147}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 196, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 150\n\n1\n\nA.\n\nAre you reading from the amended complaint?\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nThat is found at page 117,\n\nstamp\n\n3\n\nnumber 117, paragraph 3 of the first amended complaint.\n\n4\n\nI'll be happy to show it to you.\n\n5\n6\n\nA.\n\nWell, if you'll just let me know where in\n\nthe amended complaint it is, what paragraph\n\n7\n\nParagraph 3.\n\nQ.\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nWhat's the\n\n9\n\nMR. WYLER:\n\n117, Your\n\n10\n\nA.\n\nYes, sir, that's\n\n11\n\nparagraph 3.\n\n12\n\nBY MR. WYLER:\nBut t\n\nstamp?\non r\n\nof what I said in\n\nre.S \\ an allegation that my client\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\n14\n\nis in possession\n\n15\n\nA.\n\n16\n\nin possess\n\nn\n\n17\n\nsubjec\n\nthis action.\n\n18\n\nqu\n\n/off control of the documents?\nofficial capacity as his office is\n/or control of documents that are the\nAnd in the prior sentence, I\n\ndellF i‘r\norida Statute 27.03 which provides for the\n\n19\n\nor ey -- excuse me -- the state attorney to have\n\n20\n\nhority over grand jury proceedings in the state of\n\n21\n22\n\nFlorida.\nQ.\n\nOkay.\n\nIsn't it also true in the first\n\n23\n\namended complaint that your client admitted that it is\n\n24\n\nnot -- it is not seeking these materials in connection\n\n25\n\nwith either a civil or criminal case and, therefore,\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734847\n\n\f", "char_count": 1229}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 197, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 151\n\n1\n\nsought unlimited access to the requested materials under\n\n2\n\n905.27?\nA.\n\n3\n4\n\nQ.\n\nIsn't it -- If you would look at\n\nstamp page 135.\n\n7\n8\n\nI'm not\n\nsure which one goes first.\n\n5\n6\n\nAgain, that's a compound question.\n\nA.\nme.\n\nI don't have the\n\nstamen\n\nront of\n\nAll I have is the exhibits, sir.\n\n9\n\nQ.\n\n10\n\nbottom left corner.\n\n11\n\nA.\n\nWhich one isAss: 4(;:'\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\n135.\n\n13\n\nA.\n\nOkay.4,9 rry, what is your question,\n\n14\n\nOkay.\n\nThey should be\n\nhere, in the\n\nsir?\n\n15\n\nQ.\n\nyou admit on that page that you are\n\n16\n\nnot seekin\n\nth se requested materials in connection with\n\n17\n\neither\n\nevil or criminal case?\n\n18\n\n.\n\nA pending -- Right, that is correct.\n\n19\n\nQ.\n\nOkay.\n\n20 O\n\nA.\n\nThe Post was not seeking these documents in\n\n21\n\na pending criminal or civil case involving the Post.\n\n22\n\nThat is correct.\n\n23\n\nQ.\n\n24\n25\n\nThank you.\n\nAnd did you also seek unlimited\n\naccess to those requested materials for that reason?\nA.\n\nNo, that's not accurate.\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734848\n\n\f", "char_count": 1051}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 198, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 152\n\n1\n2\n\nQ.\nat that\n\nIf you look -- Would you look at\nstamp I just provided you?\n\n3\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n4\n\nQ.\n\nI believe it's on here.\n\n5\n\nA.\n\nAre you looking at 135 --\n\n6\n\nQ.\n\nUh-huh.\n\n7\n\nA.\n\n-- on Exhibit 9?\n\n8\n9\n10\n11\n\nALAr\nYes, I'm\n\nsir.\nQ.\n\nOkay, and if you woul\n\ning at that,\n\n0\nlo k at\n\nparagraph 70.\nA.\n\nSure.\n\n13\n\n,/^A\\4 49\nAnd then, Ooky\nsee\none, two, three -,\nthe fourth line down; in the sentence that starts with,\n\n14\n\n\"Because...\"\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\n15\n\nA.\n\n16\n\nQ.\n\nay.\n\nIt says, \"Because the Palm Beach\n\n17\n\nPost ig not seeking these materials in connection with\n\n18\n\neither a civil or criminal case, it seeks a declaration\n\n19\n\nt the scope of its use of the disclosed materials is\nii\n20 'tot limited.\"\n21\n\nA.\n\nRight, not limited to a civil or criminal\n\n22\n\ncase, but that the Post had the right under section (c)\n\n23\n\nof 905.27 in furtherance of justice.\n\n24\n\nseeking an in-camera inspection of the documents by the\n\n25\n\nCourt prior to any release to the Post.\n\nWe were always\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734849\n\n\f", "char_count": 1074}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 199, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 153\n\n1\n\nQ.\n\nDid that argument succeed in your claim\n\n2\n\nagainst the clerk?\n\n3\n\nA.\n\nWhich one?\n\n4\n\nQ.\n\nThat you had no connection with the civil\n\n5\n\nor criminal case and to get unlimited -- to get unlimited\n\n6\n\naccess.\n\n7\n\n4...\\r\nA.\n\nWell, again, we weren't see\n\nunlimited\n\n8\n\naccess.\n\n9\n\nin-camera inspection by the Court p 'or to release to us.\n\n10\n\nSo we were not seeking unlimit\n\n11\n\naccess to the documents.\n\n12\n13\n\nAs I just mentioned, we were\n\np\n\nQ.\n\n-\n\ness, nor immediate\n\n11 right, we're going to\n\nmove on.\n\n14\n\nIs\n\n15\n\ntestified tha\n\n16\n\nnot to obj\n\n17\n18\n\nYou weren\n\ns seeking an\n\nit\n\nrue that the other day you\n\nued my client because you needed him\no your request for these materials?\nI needed him not to object?\n\nhi\n\nhet\n\nNo.\n\nportunity to do actually three things.\nP.\n\nI gave\nOne is\n\n19\n\nport our request; two, they could have taken a\n\n20\n\ntral position; or, three, they could have objected.\n\n21\n\nInitially, the state attorney's office took\n\n22\n\nthe position to object, and as I think I testified, they\n\n23\n\neventually changed the position in October of 2020 to\n\n24\n\nneutrality.\n\n25\n\nQ.\n\nAnd you believe that's a proper basis for\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734850\n\n\f", "char_count": 1242}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 200, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 154\n\n1\n\nfiling this lawsuit against my client?\n\n2\n3\n\nA.\n\nThat they adopted a neutrality position?\n\nI'm not clear what you're asking me.\n\n4\n\nQ.\n\nII, no, that you needed him not to object.\n\n5\n\nA.\n\nThat I needed him not to object?\n\n6\n\nQ.\n\nUnless you wanted --\n\n7\n\nA.\n\nI'm sorry, did I step on yod\n\n8\n\nQ.\n\nNo, you're fine.\n\n9\n\nA.\n\nNo.\n\nNo --\n\nA\nir?\n\n0\nThat I needed hi&ioj to object?\n\nNo,\n\n10\n\nI gave the state attorney's of\n\n11\n\ntheir discretion, to make\n\n12\n\nwanted to do vis-à-vis\n\nd\n\n13\n\nstated -- You know\n\nlook at the paragraph you\n\n14\n\nquoted before, t\n\n15\n\ncomplaint, I\n\n16\n\nthe state\n\n17\n\nif you\n\nk at the cases cited under 27.03, there are a\n\n18\n\nnu\n\nthem which say that the state attorney has\n\nsion as to what they\nury secrecy.\n\nAnd as I\n\n's paragraph 3 of the first amended\nFlorida Statute 27.03, which gives\n\nto\n\nr o\nt\n\nhe option to make, in\n\ney the authority over grand juries, and\n\n19 ma y, very broad powers in the conduct of a grand jury,\n20\n21\n\nQ.\n\nThank you, Mr. Mendelsohn.\n\n22\n\nA.\n\nOkay.\n\n23\n\nQ.\n\nIn your long practice as an attorney, is it\n\nLet's move on.\n\n24\n\nyour understanding that clear, unambiguous statutory\n\n25\n\nlanguage has to be enforced as written?\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734851\n\n\f", "char_count": 1276}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 201, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 155\n\n1\n\nA.\n\nWell, there are circumstances where the\n\n2\n\ncourts have implied causes of action.\n\n3\n\nUnited States Supreme Court case of Cort v. Ash where the\n\n4\n\nCourt said that, even if Congress did not specifically\n\n5\n\nauthorize a cause of action, that, in certain\n\n6\n\ncircumstances, if Congress did not bar such\n\n7\n\nhave an implied cause of action.\n\n8\n\nSection 10(b)(5) of the securities 1\n\n9\n\nQ.\n\nOkay, but\n\n10\n\nA.\n\nAnd Florida has\n\n11\n\nQ.\n\nAll right.\n\n12\n\nstated that you went th\nA.\n\nExact\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nOk\n\nI'm\n\ncould\n\nThat cot R:\n\"also for\n\ntoo.\nyour research, you\n\nh\n\n) ss.\n\n13\n\nThat's the famous\n\n05.27, right?\n\nd you came across this language,\n\n15\n\nright?\n\nread this to you:\n\n\"When such\n\n16\n\ndisclosure\n\n17\n\nsubset\n\n18\n\ndiscloser 4r\nto all parties to the case and to their\n\n19\n\na ctor\ni\neys and by the latter to their legal associates and\n\nered by a Court pursuant to\n(1) for use in a civil case, it may be\n\n2_1,\n4,\n5 cL ployees; however, the grand jury testimony afforded\n2\n'\\3\n\nsuch persons by the Court can only be used in the defense\n\n22\n\nor prosecution of the civil or criminal case and for no\n\n23\n\nother purpose whatsoever.\"\n\n24\n25\n\nYou came across that language when you were\ndoing the research, right?\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734852\n\n\f", "char_count": 1312}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 202, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 156\n\n1\n\nA.\n\nAbsolutely.\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nAnd do you recall my client asserting that\n\n3\n\nas a defense from the beginning, from our first\n\n4\n\ninteraction, first legal filing in this?\n\n5\n6\n\nA.\n\nYes, you made a motion to dismiss arguing\n\nthat the Post did not --\n\nAilAr\n\n7\n\nQ.\n\nWe'll take a yes.\n\n8\n\nA.\n\nWell, you asked me if YQ t\n\n9\n\nand I was answering it.\n\nient did that,\n\nSo the ans\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nI'll take it as\n\n11\n\nA.\n\nMay I finish\n\n12\n\nor no.\n\nIt was a\n\nor no.\ner without\n\ninterruption?\nThe a\n\n13\n\n, yes, you made a motion to\n\n14\n\ndismiss under 90\n\n7 a d asserted that the materials\n\n15\n\ncould only b\n\nn a civil or criminal case.\n\n16\n\ncourse, we ispu ed that because of (c), which is the\n\n17\n\nfurthe\n\nOf\n\ne of\n• justice language.\n\n18\n\nAnd did that -- did that argument -- was\n\n19\n\ns\n\nrgument successful in your action against the\n\n20\n\nrk?\n\n21\n\nA.\n\nIt was never addressed by the Court.\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\nSo you're telling me that Judge Hafele\n\n23\n24\n25\n\nnever brought up 57 -- or, 905.27 in his final judgment?\nA.\n\nNo.\n\nI'm suggesting the way you\n\ncharacterize it was not the way Judge Hafele decided.\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734853\n\n\f", "char_count": 1181}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 203, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 157\n\n1\n\nJudge Hafele, in his final judgment, said that he felt\n\n2\n\nconstrained by the statute vis-à-vis his inherent\n\n3\n\nauthority as a judge.\n\n4\n\nWhile he wanted as a judge to exercise his\n\n5\n\ninherent authority to allow for disclosure, he felt that\n\n6\n\nthe statute constrained him in doing so beca\n\nit did\n\n7\n\nnot expressly so state that it could be uS\n\noutside of\n\n8\n\nthe civil or criminal case.\n\nelieve Judge\n\n9\n\nHafele said.\n\n10\n11\n\nDo you have a co=t\n\nQ.\n\nthe final judgment in\n\nfront of you?\n\n12\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\nIt's\n\nASSP\n\n14\n\nA.\n\n012\n\nay.\n\n15\n\nQ.\n\n16\n\nA.\n\n17\n\nThat's w\n\nto adva\n\nght, tab -- or,\nuYe.\n\n1477.\n\nThe newspaper makes strong arguments\n\n--\n\n18\n\nNo.\n\n19 6S\n20\n\nWhabebit is it?\n\nNo, sir.\n\nA.\n\nI'm sorry.\n\nQ.\n\nNo, sir.\n\nNo, sir.\n\nLet me redirect -- Let me direct\n\n21\n\nyou to the first paragraph here under Emphasis Added?\n\n22\n\nyou see it says, \"Reading subsection (1)(c)...\"?\n\nDo\n\n23\n\nA.\n\nRight.\n\n24\n\nQ.\n\nCould you read that until the cite for the\n\n25\n\namended complaint, please?\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734854\n\n\f", "char_count": 1097}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 204, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 158\n\n1\n\nA.\n\nRight.\n\n\"Reading subsection (1)(c),\n\n2\n\nfurthering justice,\" which is in quotes and parentheses,\n\n3\n\n\"in tandem with section (2), it is evident that the\n\n4\n\nphrase, quote, furthering justice, end quote, is to be\n\n5\n\ninterpreted in the context of seeking disclosure of the\n\n6\n\ngrand jury materials for use in a pending cr\n\n7\n\ncivil case.\"\n\n8\n\nQ.\n\nKeep going.\n\n9\n\nA.\n\nYep.\n\n\"The newspaper a\n\n10\n\nis not seeking the disclosure\n\n11\n\npurpose.\n\nal or\n\n(:.s..?'\nn ledges that it\n\nh materials for such\n\nInstead\"\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\nThat's it\n\naZk you, Mr. Mendelsohn.\n\n13\n\nA.\n\nBut i\n\nthe --\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nMr\n\n15\n\nsohn -NOGRAPHER:\n\n16\n\ntill()\n\n17\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n18\n\nGentleman, gentleman, we're\n\nre for trial, and you're being cross-examined\n\n19\n\nA\n\n20\n)\n21\n\ni -)\n\nTHE WITNESS:\n\nYour Honor, maybe, for the\n\nrule of completeness, I would like to be able to\nread the entire sentence.\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n23\n\nIt's your witness.\n\n24\n25\n\nI'm sorry, I can't take\n\nSo right now you're testifying.\nWhat's your next\n\ninquiry?\nMR. WYLER:\n\nThank you, Your Honor.\n\nMay I\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734855\n\n\f", "char_count": 1139}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 205, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 159\n\ncontinue with this final judgment, Your Honor?\n\n1\n\n2\n\nBY MR. WYLER:\n\n3\n\nQ.\n\nI would like you, Mr. Mendelsohn, to flip\n\n4\n\nto page 1479 of that same final judgment.\n\nAt the very\n\n5\n\ntop of that page, could you read that first sentence for\n\n6\n\nme, too -- for me?\n\n7\n\nA.\n\n\"Subsection (2) clearly lim\n\n8\n\nSection 925.27's (sic) scope as to t\n\n9\n\ngrand jury testimony or materials n\n\n10\n\nfor use in a criminal or civil\n\nances in which\ndjo be disclosed\n\n11\n\nQ.\n\nAnd then\n\n12\n\nA.\n\n\"Section N\n\n13\n\ntestimony is disclo\n\n14\n\nproceeding, it i\n\n15\n\nBefore that\n\n, the Court must determine that one of\n\n16\n\nthe three rdq\n\nrescribed in section (1) is present in a\n\n17\n\ncrimin\n\n18\n\nno iing\nalt' .'Section 905.27 that gives the Court carte\n\n19\n\n< nc e,\" which he has italics, \"authority to release\n\n20\n\nnd jury materials in any situation that might bear\n\n21\n\nsome relationship to, quote, furthering justice, end\n\n22\n\nquote, in its broadest sense.\"\n\n23\n\nkeep going.\np\n\nvides that, once grand jury\n\nhe course of a court\nen open to unlimited dissemination.\n\nr civil case that requires disclosure.\n\nQ.\n\nThank you.\n\nThere's\n\nAll right, so moving on from\n\n24\n\n905.27, in your extensive research of this case, did you\n\n25\n\nalso come across Chapter 905.17?\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734856\n\n\f", "char_count": 1337}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 206, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 160\n\n1\n\nA.\n\nSure.\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nOkay, and let me provide that to you, sir.\nMR. WYLER:\n\n3\n4\n5\n\nof the Authorities, Your Honor, tab 33.\nBY MR. WYLER:\n\n6\n7\n\nQ.\n\nDo you have it, Mr. Mendelsohn4Ar would\n\nyou like me to provide it?\n\n8\n9\n\nThis is tab 32 of the -- or, 33\n\nA.\n\nIt's the amended and su\n\ntal affidavit\n\nof attorneys' fees and costs?\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nYou don't have t\n\nhorities binder?\n\n11\n\nA.\n\nNo, I don't\n\nAuthorities binder.\n\n12\n\nMR. WYLER\n\n13\n\nTHE C\n\n14\n\nI approach?\n\nBY MR. WYLER:\n\n15\n\nQ.\n\n16\n\nA. l\n\n17\n\na copy of 905.17.\n76e's, I'm familiar with this provision.\nGreat, okay.\n\nAnd then the very last\n\n18\n\nsenfence of that first paragraph, it starts with, \"The\n\n19\n\nnotes, records and transcriptions...\"\n\n20\n\nmead that for the Court?\n\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nWould you please\n\nA.\n\nI'm not sure where you're directing me,\n\nQ.\n\nLet me approach again and show you here.\n\nsir.\n\nI'm sorry, I didn't have this highlighted for you.\nRight here, very last sentence of that\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734857\n\n\f", "char_count": 1050}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 207, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 161\n\n1\n\nfirst paragraph starts with, \"The notes...\"\n\n2\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n3\n\nQ.\n\nWill you please read that for the Court?\n\n4\n\nA.\n\nSure.\n\n\"The notes, records and\n\n5\n\ntranscriptions are confidential and exempt from the\n\n6\n\nprovisions of Section 119.07 subdivision (1)\n\n7\n\nSection 24(a), Article 1 of the State Con\n\n8\n\nshall be released by the clerk only\n\n9\n\ngrand jury for use by the grand ju1-/ or on order of the\nC)\n\n10\n\nCourt pursuant to 905.27.\"\n\n11\n\nQ.\n\nThank you,\n\n.\n\nlsohn.\n\nution, and\nquest by a\n\nAnd do you\n\nk\n12\n\nrecall my client assert'\n\n13\n\nclaim as well?\n\n14\n\nA.\n\nY\n\n15\n\nQ.\n\nt 's as a defense to your\n\n( Ses.\nA\\\nn't it true that your client and your\n\n16\n\nfirm and yi yqu self have been made aware several times\n\n17\n\nthat Melilror\nronberg and his office have no ability to\n\n18\n\ncomply w\n\n19\n20\n\nh your declaratory relief claim because they\n\nwave no possession, custody or control of those requested\nind jury materials?\n\n21\n\nA.\n\nI'm aware that's your argument.\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\nYou're aware that we've made that argument\n\n23\n24\n25\n\nto you several times, are you?\nA.\n\nYes, you made a motion to dismiss and a\n\nmotion for summary judgment.\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734858\n\n\f", "char_count": 1229}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 208, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 162\n\n1\n2\n\nQ.\n\nAnd did we also put that argument in our\n\n57.105 demand?\n\n3\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n4\n\nQ.\n\nOkay.\n\nAnd isn't it true that you and your\n\n5\n\nclient have admitted that the clerk is the only one in\n\n6\n\npossession and control of those requested gralliyury\n\n7\n\nmaterials?\n\n8\n\nA.\n\nI don't believe so.\n\n9\n\nQ.\n\nAll right.\n\nIf I coul\n\n10\n\nyou, Mr. Mendelsohn, to tab 20\n\n11\n\n262.\n\nit's\n\nstamped\n\n12\n\nA.\n\n262?\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\nAnd ISHSIte second paragraph starts with,\n\n14\n\n\"Also...\"\n\n15\n\nfirst sentenc\n\n16\n\nsays, Also\n\n17\n\nand co\n\n18\n\nfo1\n\n19\n\nCan y\n\n22\n\nsr.\n\nus\n\nread -- Can you just read that\n\ne?\n\nOr I'll just read it here.\n\nIt\n\nclerk, who admittedly has both possession\n\n1 of the Epstein grand jury materials, has not\n\nwed\nhe state attorney's lead in seeking sanction of\nliZ air\n\nStLn Beach Post.\n\n20\n21\n\nYes\n\nO S\ndi ect the Court and\n\nIt says that in there, correct?\nA.\n\nWell, you didn't read it verbatim, but\n\nessentially that's what it says, yes.\n\n23\n\nIt also says the clerk's decision --\n\n24\n\nQ.\n\nI didn't ask you what else it says.\n\n25\n\nA.\n\nI know, because it doesn't help you.\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734859\n\n\f", "char_count": 1168}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 209, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 163\n\nQ.\n\nBut I didn't ask you that.\n\n2\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n3\n\nGentleman, so this is the\n\nsecond time, okay?\n\n4\n\nMR. WYLER:\n\nThank you, Your Honor.\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nLet's maintain a little\n\ncivility.\n\n6\n7\n\nBY MR. WYLER:\n\n8\n\nQ.\n\n'O A\nMr. Mendelsohn, in your\n\n9\n\ninvolvement in this case, how did y\n\n10\n\nJune 3rd, 2020, motion to dism\n\n11\n\nA.\n\nHow did I?\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\nYeah, or\n\n13\n\nA.\n\nI did\n\nsive\nc ntribute to the\n\naring?\n\nie the motion, but certainly,\n\n14\n\nas part of the\n\ne had discussions as to how we\n\n15\n\nthought it sh\n\nargued, the potential arguments from\n\n16\n\nthe state\n\n17\n\n.\noccur.\n\n18\n\nCV:\n\nto ney s office and what we thought would\n\n1r\n\nDid you attend via Zoom or\n\n19 c)\n\nA.\n\nYes\n\nje\n\nQ.\n\nOkay.\n\n21\n\nA.\n\n-- I did.\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\nAnd have you ever read the transcript of\n\n24\n\nA.\n\nSome time ago, yes.\n\n25\n\nQ.\n\nOkay, so then you were aware of Judge\n\n23\n\nit?\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734860\n\n\f", "char_count": 946}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 210, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 164\n\n1\n\nMarx's statements, the ones that I read onto the record\n\n2\n\nin my opening statement regarding the impossibility of\n\n3\n\nperformance for the records that you requested?\n\n4\n\nA.\n\nI know she said that, yes.\n\n5\n\nQ.\n\nOkay.\n\nDid you agree with Judge Marx's\n\n6\n\nstatements as to an impossibility of Mr. Arcab4v\n, being\n\n7\n\nable to comply?\n\n8\n\nA.\n\nI took her statements a\n\nom.lete dicta\n\n9\n\nsince they were not before her as a\n\nue tion on the\n\n10\n\nmotion to dismiss.\n\nhat personal\n\n11\n\nknowledge she had of what\n\n12\n\nor nonpossession was.\n\n13\n\nanything but a dict\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\n15\n\nthose stateme\n\n16\n17\n\nA.\n\n20\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nst\nO\n\ne attorney's possession\n'id not credit it as being\nent from her.\n\nyour firm, no one objected to\n\nn, correct?\nhere wasn't -- I'm not sure what you're\n\nreferrit549.\n\n18\n19\n\nSo\n\nI did not\n\nWas there any objections made to any of\n- se statements made -- objections or appeals made as to\n\n(1:c\n\nhose statements made on the record in that hearing?\nA.\n\nI don't follow, because you don't make\n\nobjections to a judge's comments.\nQ.\n\nWell, through an appeal, you would.\n\nDid\n\nyou file an appeal as to that motion to dismiss?\nA.\n\nNo.\n\nIt wasn't necessary.\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734861\n\n\f", "char_count": 1270}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 211, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nOkay.\n\nPage 165\nWould you please flip to our Joint\n\n1\n\nQ.\n\n2\n\nExhibit Number 14?\n\n3\n\nA.\n\nSure.\n\n4\n\nQ.\n\nIt's also found at\n\n5\n\nA.\n\nYes, sir.\n\n6\n\nQ.\n\nOkay, do you -- do you recogn\n\nstamp 232.\n\n7\n\ncopy of my client's 57.105 demand letter\n\n8\n\nthe email when it was sent to you?\n\n9\n\nA.\n\nYes, I do.\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nAnd what day was\n\n11\n\nA.\n\nJune 8th --\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\nOkay.\n\n13\n\nA.\n\n-- of\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\n15\n\npast the lett\n\n17\n18\n\nthis as a\n\nnt to you?\n\n2\nyo .\n\nAnd then, if you flip to the --\n\nt's\n\nstamp 235.\n\nDo you -- Do you recognize this as the\nmo\n\nn far attorneys' fees that was sent along with that\n\n19 (INi\n\nto -- or, with that 57.105 demand?\n\n20\n\nA.\n\nWell, it wasn't a motion.\n\nIt was an\n\n21\n\nunsigned proposed motion that you were suggesting would\n\n22\n\nbe filed if we did not act within the 21-day safe harbor\n\n23\n\nunder 57.105.\n\n24\n25\n\nQ.\n\nThat's right.\n\nAnd that -- Do you know when\n\nthis motion for attorneys' fees was actually filed?\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734862\n\n\f", "char_count": 1017}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 212, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n1\n2\n\nbelieve.\n\n3\n4\n\nPage 166\nJuly, the beginning of July of 2020, I\n\nA.\n\nIf I told you July 1, 2020, does that sound\n\nQ.\n\ncorrect to you?\n\n5\n\nA.\n\nYes, it does.\n\n6\n\nQ.\n\nOkay.\n\n7\n\nAnd is that more than 24,st\n\nJune 8th, 2020?\n\n8\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n9\n\nQ.\n\nIt's 23 days beyond,\n\n10\n\nA.\n\nI have no reason\n\n11\n\nQ.\n\nCS\n\n12\n\nIf you look\nc\n57.105 demand, you'll s\n\n13\n\nsubsection (1).\n\n14\n\nA.\n\n15\n\nQ.\n\n16\n\nletter, st\n\ne\n\nW\n\nre\n\n•'ubt that.\nquoted in our -- In the\n\note of the Chapter 57.105\nr\nil\n\nou referring to now?\n\nsee in my\n1\n\nth.\n\nthe 57.105 demand\n\nibit 14?\n\n17\n\nThe demand letter that's Exhibit 16?\n\n18\n\nNo, no, no.\n\n19\n\nrINN A.\n\n20\n\nNh....)\n\nStill on 14.\n\n14.\n\nQ.\n\nstamp 233.\n\n21\n\nA.\n\n233?\n\nYes.\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\nOkay.\n\nDo you see where the 57.105\n\n23\n\nafter\n\nstatute's quoted there in the middle of the page?\n\n24\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n25\n\nQ.\n\nCan you tell me anywhere in there there's a\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734863\n\n\f", "char_count": 954}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 213, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 167\n\n1\n\ngood faith element?\n\n2\n\nA.\n\n3\n\nelement of the statute.\n\n4\n5\n\nQ.\n\nA.\n\nI believe there is a good fai\n\nthat wraps around the entire proceeding o\n\n8\n9\n\nIn subsection (1), is there a good faith\n\nelement?\n\n6\n7\n\nNo, because you didn't quote the good faith\n\nQ.\n\nOkay, but in subsectionK\n\nA.\n\nNo, but there's\n\n11\n\nprovision in 57.105 that y\n\n12\n\nletter.\nQ.\n\n13\n\nsubsection 4?\n\nOkay., o\nI\n\ne f, is there\n\nA.\n\n16\n17\n\nletter of C ne 23rd.\nL\n)\nreferri\nto.\n\n18\n\n.\nu\n\nitional good faith\nt cite to in this\n\nre you referring to 57.105\n\ns ow you the statute.\n\n15\n\n19\n\n.105.\n\na good faith element in that subsec\n\n10\n\n14\n\nement\n\njust check here.\n\nOkay.\n\nthis before.\n\nI'm looking at my\n\n57.105(3)(a), that's what I was\n\nAll right.\n\nAnd, now, we talked\n\nCan you -- 57.105(3)(a), can you read\n\n20 Osection\n(a) for the Court?\nub\n21\n\nA.\n\nI don't have 57.105.\n\n23\n\nQ.\n\nI can hand it to you.\n\n24\n\nA.\n\nSure.\n\n25\n\nQ.\n\nYeah, absolutely.\n\n22\n\nI have my letter\n\nwhich --\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734864\n\n\f", "char_count": 1047}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 214, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 168\n\n1\n\nA.\n\nThank you.\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nYou're welcome.\n\n3\n\nA.\n\n\"Notwithstanding subsections (1) and (2),\n\n3(a) is right there.\n\n4\n\nmonetary sanctions may not be awarded; (a), under\n\n5\n\nparagraph (1)(b) if the Court determines that the claim\n\n6\n\nor defense was initially presented to the Cq\n\n7\n\nfaith argument for the extension, modificaen or\n\n8\n\nreversal of existing law or the estab\n\n9\n\nas it is applied -- as it applied t\n\nth\n\n10\n\nfor the reasonable expectation\n\nccess; (b), under\n\n11\n\nsection\" -- excuse me -- \"\n\n12\n\nparagraph (1)(b) agains\n\n1\n\n13\n\nor she has acted in\n\noo\n\nith based upon the\n\n14\n\nrepresentations\n\nis or her client as to the existence\n\n15\n\nof material\n\n), under\" --\n\n16\n\nQ.\n\n17\n\n~\n\n£~\n\nt of new law\nmaterial facts\n\nragraph (1)(a) or\ning party's attorney, if he\n\nst -- I just needed you to read (a).\n\nThank\nII, I wasn't sure.\n\n18\n19\n\n=\n\nas a good\n\n)\n\nQ.\n\nSo under (3)(a), does that apply to\n\n20\n\nNimbsection (1)(a) of the statute, or does it only say\n\n+21\n\n(1)(b) there?\n\n22\n\nA.\n\nNo, if you look at (3)(a) -- if you look at\n\n23\n\n(3)(b), it says, under paragraph (1)(a) or\n\n24\n\nparagraph (1)(b) against a losing party's attorney if he\n\n25\n\nor she has acted in good faith.\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734865\n\n\f", "char_count": 1281}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 215, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 169\n\n1\n\nYou're seeking fees against myself and --\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nNo, no.\n\n3\n\nA.\n\n-- and Greenberg attorneys, so I read that\n\n4\n\nas being applicable.\n\n5\n\nQ.\n\nMr. Mendelsohn, you're skipping down to --\n\n6\n\nThat's not what I asked you.\n\n7\n\napply to 57.105(1)(a)?\n\n8\n\nDoes it say it in\n\nMS. WHETSTONE:\n\n9\n\nlegal conclusion.\n\n10\n\nMR. WYLER:\n\nNo,\n\nIt doesn\n\ny\n\n11\n\nit.\n\n12\n\nA.\n\n13\n\ndon't remember the\n\n14\n\nyou're suing bat\n\n15\n\nthat both of\n\n16\n\nBY MR. WYL\n\n17\n18\n\n57.105(3)(m),\n\nObjecti\n\nt1\n\nthat\nstatute?\ns for a\n\nst asking him to read\n\n1)(a) under (3)(a), but I\n\nas to whether or not, when\nclient and the lawyer under 57.105,\nn t make the argument of good faith.\n\nBut correct me if I'm wrong, it did say,\nun\n\nparagraph (1)(b), if the Court determines that the\n\n19\n\nLm or defense was initially presented to the Court as\n\n20\n\nood faith argument?\n\n21\n\nA.\n\n(1)(b) has good faith in it as well, yes.\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\nIt doesn't say (1)(a) in there, does it?\n\n23\n\nA.\n\nI'm confused now as to what you're asking\n\n24\n25\n\nme.\n\nNo offense.\nQ.\n\nMr. Mendelsohn, that's okay.\n\nI'll move on\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734866\n\n\f", "char_count": 1157}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 216, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 170\n\n1\n\nfrom that.\n\n2\n\nsaying.\n\n3\n\nI believe the Court understands what I'm\n\nSo back to that 57.105 demand letter.\n\n4\n\nIsn't it true in that demand letter that we asserted that\n\n5\n\nyour client's declaratory relief claim is not supported\n\n6\n\nby the material facts to establish it?\n\n7\n\nA.\n\nThat's what you say, yes.\n\n8\n\nQ.\n\nOkay, we made that asse\n\n9\n\nA.\n\nThat's what the state\n\ntt rney asserted.\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nYes, sir, okay.\n\nin making that\n\nvim yes?\n\n12\n\nher him or his office\n'\\\nhas custody or control dei.hSge records and that's it's\n\n13\n\nimpossible for him\n\ns ty\np\nde them?\nPiS y\n\n14\n\nto you in that 1\n\nr?\n\n15\n\nA.\n\n16\n\nQ.\n\n11\n\nassertion, didn't he say t\n\nHe made that known\n\nwhat he said, yes.\ny.\n\nDidn't that letter also say that\n\n17\n\nyour clam's declaratory relief claim is unsupported by\n\n18\n\nth\n\n19\n20\nATe\n21\n\npplication of the law to those facts?\nA.\n\nWell, in a conclusory way, yes, but not in\n\nspecifics as to why we were wrong.\nQ.\n\nWell, then maybe you should keep looking at\n\n22\n\nthat because, if you flip to the second page of that\n\n23\n\n57.105 demand letter, do you see Section 905.27(2) quoted\n\n24\n\nas the reason for that assertion?\n\n25\n\nA.\n\nYes, but if you recall, there was more --\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734867\n\n\f", "char_count": 1292}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 217, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 171\n\n1\n\nQ.\n\nThank you.\n\n2\n\nA.\n\n-- there was more than one argument you\n\nwere making and more than one argument we were making.\n\n3\n4\n\nQ.\n\n5\n\n-- I'm sorry.\n\n6\n\n16.\n\nA review of this letter makes crystal clear\nAll right.\n\nOkay, let's go to tab number\n\nAR0,\n\n7\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n8\n\nQ.\n\nDo you recognize this a\n\n9\n\nletter where\n\nyou rejected our 57.105 demand?\n\n10\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n11\n\nQ.\n\nCan I direct\n\n12\n\nthe very last paragraph\n\nof that letter?\n\n13\n\nA.\n\n\"For\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nNo\n\n15\n\nvery last par\n\n16\n\nassuming..\n\neNSip asons, we decline\" -'r.\n\nNo, sir.\n\nI'll point you.\n\nThe\n\nof this letter, it starts with, \"Also\n\n17\n\nThat's actually --\n\n18\n\nII, no, I'm sorry, on the second page.\n\n19\n\nn't need that one.\nA.\n\nThat's actually the penultimate --\n\n21\n\nQ.\n\nThen we'll start with the penultimate\n\n22\n\nparagraph on 245 --\n\n23\n\nA.\n\n20\n\n24\n25\n\nI\n\nV\n\nRight, I see that, yes.\n\nIt starts, \"Also\n\nassuming...\"\n\nQ.\n\nFirst sentence, please.\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734868\n\n\f", "char_count": 1007}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 218, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 172\n\n1\n\nA.\n\n\"Also assuming the state attorney does not\n\n2\n\nhave physical possession of the grand jury materials,\n\n3\n\nthere is nothing in Florida law that prohibits the state\n\n4\n\nattorney from requesting the clerk provide copies to the\n\n5\n\nstate attorney.\"\n\n6\n7\n\nDo you want me to keep readin\nQ.\n\nNo, sir.\n\nThank you.\n\nBut I\n\nld like to\n\n8\n\nredirect your attention, again, back\n\n9\n\nstatement that you read earlier.\n\n10\n\nrecords and transcriptions are\n\n11\n\nfrom the provisions of Sec\n\n12\n\nSection 24(a) Article 1\n\ntIe State Constitution and\n\n13\n\nshall be released b\n\nerk only on request by a grand\n\n14\n\njury for use by\n\n15\n\npursuant to\n\n16\n\nA.\n\nI\n\n.17 and that\nsa s, \"The notes,\n\ndential and exempt\n.07(1) and\n\nd jury or on order of the Court\n905.27.\"\n\night, I'm familiar with that.\n\n17\n\nOkay.\n\n18\n\nAnd that section refers to the clerk, not\n\n19\n\nstate attorney.\n\n20\n\n4.\n\nThank you.\n\n21\n\nA.\n\nSo there's nothing to prohibit the state\n\nExactly.\n\nThank you.\n\n22\n\nattorney in this statute from asking the clerk for these\n\n23\n\nmaterials.\n\n24\n\nQ.\n\n25\n\nAll right, isn't there a big difference\n\nbetween getting access from the clerk for materials and\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734869\n\n\f", "char_count": 1239}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 219, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 173\n\n1\n\ndisclosing the materials?\n\n2\n\nbetween that?\n\nIsn't there a difference\n\n3\n\nA.\n\nI don't understand what you're asking.\n\n4\n\nQ.\n\nI'll ask you again.\n\nIsn't there a\n\n5\n\ndifference between accessing the materials and being able\n\n6\n\nto disclose the materials?\n\n7\n\nA.\n\nOnce the clerk provides\n\n8\n\nQ.\n\nNo, no, no.\n\n9\n\nA.\n\nThen I don't understa\n\n10\n\n'OA\n\nIt's a yes\n\nquestion.\nat you're asking\n\nme, to be honest with you.\nQ.\n\n11\n\nIs there -- Is\n\nHerea difference between\n\n12\n\nsaying, Hey, may I pleas\n\nave these records, versus\n\n13\n\nsaying, Here you go\n\nthese records, Newspaper?\n\n14\n\nA.\n\n15\n\nyou're -- what you're asking me\n\nWe,\n\nis a twofold\n\n16\n17\n\na\n\nQ.\ndiffer\n\nasked you one question.\n\nbetween access and disclosure?\n\n18\n\nNo.\n\nOnce you access something, it's\n\n19\n\ncl sed.\n\n20\n\n, I honestly don't.\n\n21\n\nIs there a\n\nQ.\n\nI don't understand what you're asking me,\n\nMr. Mendelsohn, I'm sorry, and I do not\n\n22\n\nwant to have -- I do not want to make the Court angry,\n\n23\n\nbut we've got to stop talking over each other.\n\n24\n\nasking you a simple question.\n\n25\n\nI'm\n\nYou stated here that Mr. Aronberg could get\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734870\n\n\f", "char_count": 1204}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 220, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 174\n\n1\n\naccess to these records through the Court -- through the\n\n2\n\nclerk, correct?\n\n3\n\nA.\n\nHe could ask the clerk for them, and I\n\n4\n\ndidn't -- and I argued that there was nothing in the\n\n5\n\nstatute prohibiting him from asking the clerk for the\n\n6\n\nclerk to give his office these documents, y\n\n7\n8\n\nQ.\n\nOkay, sure.\n\nOkay, thank yo4Q An\n\njust say that happened.\n\n9\n\nA.\n\nOkay.\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nThe clerk gives\n\n11\n\nclerk for the records and\n\nir.\nso let's\n\n4)\n\nAronberg asks the\nk gives them to him.\n\n12\n\nA.\n\nOkay.\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\nThat'sinS‘w at you asked for in your\n\n14\n\n8 -\n\nlawsuit, is it?\n\n15\n\nA.\n\n,\n\nf course it is.\n\n16\n\nQ.\n\n. Mendelsohn, did you not -- does not\n\n17\n\nyour cdpplaint request the complete -- the disclosure of\n\n18\n\nth\nrebords from my client?\n4\n(c,\nA.\nBut --\n\n19\n20 0\n21\n\nQ.\n\nYou asked -- Did you ask in your lawsuit\n\nfor my client to hand these records over?\n\n22\n\nA.\n\nNo, no.\n\n23\n\nQ.\n\nNo?\n\n24\n\nA.\n\nNo, because we had asked for the records to\n\n25\n\nOkay.\n\nbe examined by the Court in camera before they were ever\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734871\n\n\f", "char_count": 1116}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 221, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 175\n\n1\n\nto be disclosed to the public.\n\n2\n\namended complaint that the Court should review such\n\n3\n\ndocuments and redact anything that would identify\n\n4\n\nwitnesses or potential witnesses or those who were not\n\n5\n\ncharged with a crime.\n\n6\n\nIn fact, we stated in the\n\nSo it's inaccurate for you to west\n\nthat\n\n7\n\nthe paper just wanted it handed to them. AR,;I ,t was never\n\n8\n\nthe case.\n\n9\n\nQ.\n\n10\n\nIt's tab number 9.\n\n11\n\n136, and we're going to lo,\n\nOkay.\n\nLet's look bac\n\n0\nat your complaint.\n\nWe're goin\n\nook at\n\nCC\n\nstamp\n\nur wherefore clause.\n\n12\n\nA.\n\nTab 9, you<ky.\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\nYes.\n\n14\n\nA.\n\n1W\n3\n\n15\n\nQ.\n\n16\n\nA.\n\n17\n\n15h7\n\nOkay.\n\n18\n\nSc\n\n\"Wherefore, the Post -- the Palm Beach Post\n\nre\n\nsee it.\n\n19\n\neZctfully requests that the Court determine the rights\n\n20\n\nobligations of the parties by declaring that,\n\n21\n\npursuant to Florida Statute Section 905.27(1)(c) and the\n\n22\n\nCourt's inherent authority, the Palm Beach Post may gain\n\n23\n\naccess to the testimony, minutes and other evidence\n\n24\n\npresented in 2006 to the Palm Beach County grand jury and\n\n25\n\nuse those materials for the purpose of informing the\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734872\n\n\f", "char_count": 1209}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 222, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 176\n\n1\n\npublic.\"\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nOkay, thank you.\n\nAnd so in there it says\n\n3\n\nthat you're asking for the Palm Beach Post to gain access\n\n4\n\nto the testimony; is that correct?\n\n5\n\nA.\n\n6\n\nYes, after the Court examined them in\n\ncamera.\n\n7\n\n4A r\nQ.\n\n8\n\nHow else would you gain acc\n\nunless it was disclosed to you?\n\n9\n\nA.\n\nI'm\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nYou would not.\n\n11\n\nA.\n\nI'm not foll‹:19!\n\n12\n\nC\n\nO\n\nyou're asking me,\n\nI'm really not.\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\nWould\n\n14\n\nA.\n\nD\n\n15\n\nQ.\n\n16\n\nA. Cy\n\n17\n\n'IT,sr\n\n18\n\nou\n\nase look at tab J17.\nerg's motion for attorneys' fees?\n\ny\nIt's at\nRight.\n\nstamp 247.\nThis is the one you made on July 1,\n\nSr\n\n19\n20\n\nto testimony\n\nQ.\n\nV\n\nCorrect.\n\nAnd we went through that.\n\n21\n\nBefore, you said that was filed at least 21 days after\n\n22\n\nyou received the 57.105 demand, correct?\n\n23\n24\n25\n\nA.\n\nWell, you said it was 23, and I agreed with\n\nQ.\n\nAnd I said at least 21 days.\n\nyou.\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734873\n\n\f", "char_count": 972}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 223, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 177\n\n1\n\nA.\n\nRight.\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nThank you.\n\nSo, if I give you this -- Let\n\n3\n\nme give you this 57.105 statute again and ask you to look\n\n4\n\nat subsection (4) for me.\n\n5\n\nA.\n\nOkay.\n\n6\n\nQ.\n\nAnd if could you read that to\n\n7\n\nThank you.\n\n8\n\nA.\n\nCourt.\n\nAS ,\n\"A motion by a party se\n\nsanctions\n\n9\n\nunder this section must be served b\n\n10\n\nwith or presented to the Court\n\ns, within 21 days\n\n11\n\nafter service of the motio ,\n\nhallenged paper, claim,\n\n12\n\ndefense, contention, al\n\nNt ern or denial is not\n\n13\n\nwithdrawn or approp\n\ncorrected.\"\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nTh\n\nm y not be filed\n\notT: And you and your client did not\n\n15\n\nwithdraw the\n\n'\n\n16\n\n21 days af\n\neing served, correct?\n\n17\n\nYes.\n\n18\n19\n\nor declaratory relief within that\n\nIt\nt\n\n20\n\nnumber\nA.\n\nAll right.\n\nAnd then let me have you look\n\nor, our Exhibit Number 23.\nPlaintiff -- Yes, the notice of dropping\n\n21\n\nState Attorney Dave Aronberg on October 21st, 2020, that\n\n22\n\nis the one you want me to look at?\n\n23\n\nQ.\n\nYes, that's right.\n\nYep.\n\nAnd that's the\n\n24\n\ndate it was filed, October 21, 2020; is that what you\n\n25\n\nsaid?\n\nwww.phippereporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734874\n\n\f", "char_count": 1164}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 224, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 178\n\n1\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nOkay.\n\n3\n\nAnd is that filing date more than\n\n21 days beyond when you were served with the 57.105?\n\n4\n\nA.\n\nYou're confusing a lot of things there.\n\n5\n\nQ.\n\nNo, I'm not.\n\n6\n\nA.\n\nI cannot answer that question.\n\n7\n\nQ.\n\nOkay.\n\n8\n\nA.\n\n-- because it's makin\n\n9\n\nQ.\n\nNo, no, no.\n\nA.\n\nWhich on\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\nNo,\n\ner of\n\nn\n\none simple question.\n105 demand?\n\nYou were only served with one\n\n57.105 demand.\n\n15\n\nA.\n\n16\n\nQ.\n\n17\n18\n\nTh\n\nWhen were you served with At\n\n12\n\n14\n\ncan't --\n\nassumptions that are inaccurate.\n\n10\n11\n\nI asked you a question.\n\ns correct.\nay.\nRight.\n\nI'm just asking which one.\nI wanted you to pin down what you\n\ndi\n\n19\n\nQ.\n\nOkay, you were served with one 57.105\n\n21\n\nA.\n\nRight.\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\nWhat day was that?\n\n23\n\nA.\n\nThe letter was June 8th, 2020.\n\n24\n\nQ.\n\nOkay.\n\ntQand.\n\n25\n\nAnd this -- And that gave you\n\n21 days from that date to change your position; is that\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734875\n\n\f", "char_count": 988}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 225, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 179\n\n1\n\ncorrect?\n\n2\n\nA.\n\nThe statute gave me that, yes.\n\n3\n\nQ.\n\nOkay.\n\n4\n\nAnd then when did you actually\n\nchange your position and drop Mr. Aronberg?\n\n5\n\nA.\n\nWe dropped Mr. Aronberg -- When you say\n\n6\n\nchanged position, I don't know what you're xf\n\n7\n\n11 s case on\nWe dropped Mr. Aronberg as a defendant in4;\n\n8\n\nOctober 21, 2020.\n\n9\n\nQ.\n\n10\n\nOkay, and October 21,\n\nrring to.\n\n0\n022, is more than\n\n21 days after June 8th, 2020,\n\n11\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\nOkay.\n\nSo\n\n1that fits with the statutory\n\n13\n\nlanguage then, correc4t%hf what that 21-day -- it gives\n\n14\n\nyou 21 days to w'\n\nraw, and you didn't withdraw within\n\n15\n\n21 days, corr\n\nW\n\nhe statute, 57.105 subsection (4),\n\n16\n\ngives you\n\ns to withdraw the alleged --\n\n17\n18\n\nYou are confusing a number of things that\nar\n\napp\n\ning, so I cannot answer that question.\n\nYou're\n\n19\n\num ng certain things that are not accurate, so I\n\n20\n\nnot answer your question in the manner you put it to\n\n21\n22\n\nme.\nQ.\n\nMr. Mendelsohn, it's very simple.\n\nI'm just\n\n23\n\ntrying to establish that that -- that you filed your drop\n\n24\n\ncure -- you dropped the claim against Mr. Aronberg\n\n25\n\noutside of the 21-day safe-harbor period, correct?\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734876\n\n\f", "char_count": 1268}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 226, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 180\n\n1\n2\n\nA.\n\nBut you never moved -- you never filed a\n\nmotion on the first motion you made for fees.\n\n3\n\nQ.\n\nOkay.\n\n4\n\nA.\n\nThat's not before us.\n\nSo you're confusing\n\n5\n\na safe-harbor for something you've never moved on versus\n\n6\n\ndropping your client as a defendant after sing\n\n7\n\nhappened.\n\n8\n\nQ.\n\nOkay, so --\n\n9\n\nA.\n\nSo you're mixing two\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nI'm not.\n\nI beli-\n\n11\n\nit your position then thatA\n\n12\n\nAronberg as a client, t\n\nelse\n\nO S\nin s together.\n•u are.\n\nOkay, so is\n\nX you dropped Dave\n\n13\n\nA.\n\nHe's\n\nient.\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nAf\n\n15\n\nyou dropped Dave°A\n\n16\n\nit's your\n\n17\n\nanothe1 .105 demand letter should have been sent to\n\n18\n\nyo\n\ns it your position that, after\nnberg as a party from this lawsuit,\n\ntion that, after you dropped him, that\np'o%..,}\n\n4V\n\n19 O\n\nA.\n\nYou didn't give us --\n\n20\n\nQ.\n\nJust answer my question.\n\nAfter you dropped\n\n21\n\nMr. Aronberg from this lawsuit, is it your position that\n\n22\n\nyou should have been served with another 57.105 demand\n\n23\n\nletter?\n\n24\n25\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\nYou didn't comply with 57.105 for\n\nyour amended motion for 57.105.\n\nYou did not comply with\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734877\n\n\f", "char_count": 1186}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 227, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n\nPage 181\n1\n\nit.\n\nYes, that is the position.\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nCan you tell me, after dropping\n\n3\n\nMr. Aronberg from the lawsuit, how your position -- how\n\n4\n\nyour client's position could have changed if they were\n\n5\n\nserved with another letter being that he was already out\n\n6\n\nof the lawsuit?\n\n7\n\nA.\n\nAiiAr\n\nWell, that's the problem yo4\n\n8\n\nyou served this motion without givin\n\n9\n\nthe amended motion I'm referring to, as)well as the fact\nC\n\n10\n\nthat you served it after we dr\n\nhim.\n\n11\n\njurisdictional purposes, y\n\ndo that.\n\n12\n13\n\nQ.\n\nHow could\n\nr\n\ntie\n\nve because\nsafe-harbor,\n\nFor\n\nide you a safe-harbor if\n\n14\n\nyou had already drop elS5\nAC:\n1.1.;I. from the lawsuit?\nc\nA.\nMr\nle , with all due respect, you're\n\n15\n\nactually mak'\n\n16\n\napplicable\n\n17\n\ncase.\n\n20\n21\n\nour client is no longer part of the\n\nWell, then I guess we just have differing\n\n18\n19\n\nrgument, which is that 57.105 is not\n\nat\n\non how to interpret that statute, Mr. Mendelsohn.\nAll right, I just have a few more questions\n\nfor you.\n\n22\n\nA.\n\nSure.\n\n23\n\nQ.\n\nI'd like to go -- I think I'd like to go\n\n24\n25\n\nback to that final judgment.\nA.\n\nThat was tab 30.\n\nOkay.\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734878\n\n\f", "char_count": 1217}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 228, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 182\n\n1\n\nQ.\n\nAll right, all right, I'm on\n\nstamp\n\n2\n\n1473, and I'm at the top of that page, that first\n\n3\n\nsentence.\n\n4\n\nA.\n\n5\n\nThe clerk's position?\n\nIs that what you're\n\nreading from?\n\n6\n\nQ.\n\nYes, yes.\n\nThat's correct.\n\n7\n\nA.\n\n\"The clerk's position is th\n\n8\n\na custodian of the materials, and, as\n\n9\n\nreal interest in the issues before\n\n10\n\nidentified.\n\n11\n\nCourt on whether or not he\n\n12\n\nmaterials.\n\n13\n\nadvocated the posit\n\n14\n\ngrand jury secre\n\n15\n\nRule 2.420(d\n\n16\n\nPractice a\n\n17\n\nrequire\n\n18\n\nreds.\nI r 4r\n\n19\n20\n21\n\nThe clerk only ne= e\n\nNonetheless\n\n11\n\ne is merely\ne has no\n\nourt\nrection from the\n\nproduce or disclose the\nerk has zealously\nnst disclosure based upon\n\nnd confidentiality because\nvii) of the Florida Rules of General\ncial Administration, the clerk is\n\no maintain the confidentiality of grand jury\n\nQ.\n\nYes, will you read the next paragraph, too,\n\nA.\n\n\"The clerk is correct that his role as\n\nase?\n\n22\n\ncustodian of the materials is only to follow the Court's\n\n23\n\ndirection once confidentiality is determined.\n\n24\n\nclerk's role in this proceeding has been complicated or\n\n25\n\nexpanded because the newspaper filed this action as a\n\nThe\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734879\n\n\f", "char_count": 1258}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 229, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 183\n\n1\n\ncivil declaratory judgment action and has moved for\n\n2\n\nsummary judgment under Florida Rule of Civil Procedure\n\n3\n\n1.510.\n\n4\n\ndisclosure of confidential Court records is set forth in\n\n5\n\nFlorida Rule of General Practice and Judicial\n\n6\n\nAdministration 2.420(j) which only requires\n\n7\n\na, quote, motion, end quote, seeking disc\n\n8\n\nRule of General Practice and Judicial\n\n9\n\n2.420(j)(2).\"\n\nHowever, the proper procedure for obtaining\n\n10\n\nfiling of\nre, Florida\n\nistration\n\nWant me to keep\n\n11\n\nQ.\n\n12\n\nsentence, please.\n\n13\n\nA.\n\n14\n\nnewspaper's comp\n\nt\n\n15\n\na motion for\n\nure under Rule 2.42\" -- excuse me --\n\n16\n\n\"2.420(j).\n\n17\n\na matt\n\n18\n\np\n\n19\n\nYeah, just t\n\n\"Acco\n\nAs\n\nin\n\nry end of that next\n\n, the Court will treat the\nd motion for summary judgment as\n\nresult, the Court need not determine as\n\nf law whether the clerk of the Court is a\n\nreiZ\nd t4r\nendant to the declaratory judgment for the\ne of the grand jury materials.\"\n\n20 V\n\nQ.\n\nThank you.\n\n21\n\nA.\n\nI'm sorry, was there a question?\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\nNo.\n\n23\n\nAll right.\n\nThere's going to be.\n\nJust one second.\n\nWhen you filed this lawsuit, were you\n\n24\n\nfamiliar with Rule 2.420 of the Rules of Judicial\n\n25\n\nAdministration?\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734880\n\n\f", "char_count": 1284}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 230, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 184\n\n1\n\nA.\n\nAbsolutely.\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nThen why didn't you just file a motion like\n\n3\n\nthe rule says -- says you're supposed to if you want\n\n4\n\nconfidential Court records and sued my client instead?\n\n5\n\nA.\n\nFirst off, the rule doesn't actually say\n\n6\n\nthat.\n\nIt says you may file a motion in a pe\n\n7\n\ncriminal or civil procedure.\n\n8\n\npending criminal or civil proceeding,\n\n9\n\nmotion as being necessary to be mad\n\n10\n\nNow, this issue\n\n11\n\nthe present time, and the\n\n12\n\nits answer brief that Rt e4\n\n13\n\nthe actual procedur\n\n14\n\nuncertain.\n\n15\n\nthat the Supr\n\n16\n\ngrand jury\n\n17\n18\n\nAnd,\n\nSince there\n\ng\nn't a\n't view that\n\nb= ore the Fourth DCA at\ntaken the position in\n- 2.420 is ambiguous and\nto be followed is\n\nfa\n\n, the clerk's position is now\n\nrt must reassess how one would seek\nals.\nThat was in their answer brief, which I'd\n\nbe4\n\npy\n\no provide to the Court along with our initial\n\n19\n\ne\n\nand reply brief, which extensively discusses\n\n20\n\ne 2.420, but also argue that the clerk has now adopted\n\n21\n\na position of neutrality when it comes to the release of\n\n22\n\nthe grand jury materials.\n\n23\n\nit no longer opposes release of the materials.\n\nIn its answer brief, it says\n\n24\n\nQ.\n\nOkay.\n\n25\n\nA.\n\nIt is now neutral on that issue.\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734881\n\n\f", "char_count": 1324}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 231, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 185\n\n1\n\nQ.\n\n2\n\nThank you, Mr. Mendelsohn.\nIn the Court's final judgment, however, it\n\n3\n\ndoes say, which you just read to the Court, the proper\n\n4\n\nprocedure for obtaining disclosure of confidential\n\n5\n\nrecords is set forth in Florida Rule of General Practice\n\n6\n\nand Judicial Administration 2.420(j), which p\n\n7\n\nthe filing of a motion seeking disclosure;A\n\n8\n\ncorrect?\n\n9\n\nA.\n\nrequires\n\nfL,\nr that\n\n0\nYes, but at this time, th state attorney\n\n10\n\nwas not a party, and, in fact,\n\ntate attorney has\n\n11\n\nnever made any argument un\n\n2.420 in this case.\n\n12\n\nIt has never made such a\nQ.\n\n14\n\nfiled this lawsu'\n\n15\n\nA.\n\n16\n\nafter we d\n\n17\n\nwas th0t544't time the clerk had made such.\n\n18\n\nma\nthiSs argument that the rule was applicable in\nIct\nos tion to our motion for summary judgment which\n\n20\n21\n22\n\nw\n\nment.\n\n13\n\n19\n\nBut y?\n\nr\n\naware of that rule before you\n\nt, and the clerk made this argument\nthe state attorney from this case.\n\nThat\n\nThe clerk\n\nurred after the state attorney had been dropped from\nthe case.\nSo this was not an issue in the case either\n\n23\n\nbecause your client did not raise it, the clerk did not\n\n24\n\nraise it, and it was not before the Court until after\n\n25\n\nyour client was no longer a party.\n\nSo it was not an\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734882\n\n\f", "char_count": 1333}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 232, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 186\n\n1\n\nissue that either you addressed or we addressed as part\n\n2\n\nof your demand that we withdraw the case.\n\n3\n4\n\nQ.\n\nBut you still knew about it before you\n\nfiled the lawsuit, right?\n\nYou knew about that rule?\n\n5\n\nA.\n\nOf course.\n\n6\n\nQ.\n\nAll right, last question for ypa Isn't it\n\nOf course.\n\n7\n\ntrue that your client's goal in obtainin•\n\nse records\n\n8\n\nfrom my client was for public disclosq\n\nas that your\n\n9\n\nend goal?\n\n10\n\nA.\n\n( 14.)\ned them in camera and\n\nAfter the Court\n\n11\n\nremoved witness identifica\n\n12\n\nindicted, that was actu\n\n13\n\nextensively in the\n\na\n\n14\n\nand, in fact, he\n\nd hls particularly if I were -- and\n\n15\n\nusing Judge H\n\nwords -- inclined to release these\n\n16\n\nmaterials\n\n17\n\njust tWra er; it was simultaneously to the public --\n\n18\n\nho Qoul\n\n19\n\ne\n\n20\n\nld I go about doing it?\n\nArss,\n\npeople who hadn't been\n\nscussed very much\nument before Judge Hafele,\n\nnewspaper and the public -- it wasn't\n\nI go about redacting them?\n\nomeone else, a\n\n21\n\nWould I need to\n\n, possibly review them?\n\nAnd we had about a half hour's worth of\n\n22\n\ndiscussion as to how to accomplish that if he were\n\n23\n\ninclined to grant disclosure.\n\n24\n\nissue before Judge Hafele.\n\n25\n\nHow\n\nQ.\n\nGreat.\n\nSo that absolutely was an\n\nSo then the final goal was -- Was\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734883\n\n\f", "char_count": 1354}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 233, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 187\n\n1\n\nthe final goal to have these requested grand jury\n\n2\n\nmaterials be able to be disclosed to the public?\n\n3\n\nA.\n\nAbsolutely.\n\n4\n\nQ.\n\nOkay.\n\n5\n\nAnd that was without any connection\n\nto any underlying civil or criminal case, correct?\n\n6\n\nA.\n\nIf you're asking me whether o\n\nt the Post\n\n7\n\nwas part of a civil or criminal case pendICSat the time,\n\n8\n\nno, it was not.\n\n9\n10\n\nQ.\n\nO\n\nYou did not -- Did yo\n\nrecords as part of a pending c\n\n11\n\nA.\n\n12\n13\n\nquestions.\n\n14\n\nA.\n\nyou.\n\nNo further\n\nhan this lawsuit.\n\nURT:\n\nThank you.\n\nirect examination.\nREDIRECT EXAMINATION\n\n17\nBY\n\n19 n\n4 $11.1\n21\n22\n\nh\n\nA\\„\ner\n\n15\n\n18\n\nr criminal case?\n\nInvolving th\nMR. WYLER\n\n16\n\nest these\n\nW ETSTONE:\nQ.\n\nGood afternoon, Mr. Mendelsohn.\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\nQ.\n\nMr. Wyler asked you to read a sentence in\n\nthe amended complaint --\n\n23\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n24\n\nQ.\n\n-- and I'd like to draw your attention to\n\n25\n\nthat, and it's Exhibit 9.\n\nI'm going to look at\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734884\n\n\f", "char_count": 1018}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 234, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 188\n\n1\n\nparagraph 3.\n\n2\n\nA.\n\nYes, I have that in front of me.\n\n3\n\nQ.\n\nCan you read the entire paragraph 3,\n\nA.\n\nYes, I'd be happy to.\n\n4\n\nplease?\n\n5\n6\n\n\"Defendant Dave Aronberg is t\n\nly\n\n7\n\nelected State Attorney for the 15th Judic\n\n8\n\nand for Palm Beach County, Florida,\n\n%itto Florida\n\n9\n\nStatute Section 27.01 and has autho\n\nan grand jury\n\n10\n\nproceedings pursuant to Florid-\n\n11\n\nHe is sued in his official\n\n12\n\npossession and/or contr\n\n13\n\nsubject of this act\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nSoel\n\n15\n\n17\n\nY\n\nor\n\nf\n\nocuments that are the\n\nm actually going to compare -And it's on the screen for\n\ntoo, if that's easier to see.\n\nTSTONE:\n\nBY MS.\n\n18\n19\n\nute Section 27.03.\ny as his office is in\n\nETSTONE:\n\n16\n\nDistrict in\n\nBut we're going to look at paragraph 4 next\n\n0\n\na\n\ne paragraph 4 names the clerk; is that correct?\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n21\n\nQ.\n\nCould you read paragraph 4, please?\n\n22\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n20\n\n\"Defendant Sharon R. Bock is the duly\n\n23\n\nelected clerk and comptroller of Palm Beach County,\n\n24\n\nFlorida.\n\n25\n\nher office is in possession and/or control of documents\n\nShe is sued here in her official capacity as\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734885\n\n\f", "char_count": 1189}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 235, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 189\n\n1\n\nthat are the subject of this action.\"\n\n2\n\nQ.\n\nSo comparing those two paragraphs, was the\n\n3\n\nclerk named in a different capacity as the state attorney\n\n4\n\nin paragraph 3?\n\n5\n\nA.\n\nYes, because, in paragraph 3, I cited to\n\n6\n\nFlorida Statute 27.03, which is the broad g\n\n7\n\nauthority to state attorneys to supervise\n\nconduct\n\n8\n\ngrand jury investigations, and that's\n\nwhat the\n\n9\n\nsituation involved in this case.\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nSo you set forth\n\ne amended complaint\nas having authority\n\n11\n\nthat the state attorney wad\n\n12\n\nover grand jury proceedik s; 's that correct?\n\n13\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nWa\n\n15\n\ncomplaint tha\n\n16\n\nA.\n\n17\n\nN!llor\n\n18\n19\n\n.',\ne game language in the first\niled in November 2019?\non't recall.\n\nLet's go ahead and pull that up.\nMS. WHETSTONE:\n\ni .04S\n\nAnd, Gerard, if you don't\n\nmind, it's Exhibit 4.\n\n20\n\nMS. WHETSTONE:\n\n21\n\nQ.\n\nAnd, while you're turning to that, was the\n\n22\n\nclerk only named in its official capacity as having\n\n23\n\npossession?\n\n24\n\nA.\n\n25\n\nYes, that is correct.\n\nI'm looking at\n\nparagraph 3 of the original complaint dated 11/14/2019,\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734886\n\n\f", "char_count": 1173}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 236, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 190\n\n1\n\nand it appears that paragraph 3 appears the same.\n\n2\n3\n\nQ.\n\nwe can close the loop on this.\n\n4\n5\n\nAnd let's go ahead and blow that up just so\n\nParagraph 3 of the original complaint is\nthe same as the amended complaint; is that correct?\n\n6\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\nBoth of them cite to Se\n\n7\n\nFlorida Statutes creating jurisdiction b\n\n8\n\nattorney over all grand juries withi\n\n9\n\njudicial district.\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\nSo the state att\n\n27.03\nstate\n\nSi\n\nparticular\n\nwas named -- never\n\n11\n\nnamed solely because he\n\npossession, custody\n\n12\n\nor custody of the grand\n\necords from the Epstein\n\n13\n\ngrand jury investig\n\nthat correct?\n\n14\n\nA.\n\n15\n\nbecause the\n\n16\n\ngrand jury\n\nTh\n\nis correct.\n\nThe primary reason was\n\natk1 % 71torney has such authority over the\nss in this judicial district.\n\n17\n\nNow, granted, Mr. Aronberg was not the one\n\n18\n\nthe Jeffrey Epstein grand jury proceeding.\n\n19\n\nwe didn't sue Mr. Aronberg in his\n\n20\n21\n22\n\n0\n\nividual capacity, only in his official capacity\n\nbecause he's the successor to State Attorney Krischer.\nQ.\n\nWas there any case law cited in the amended\n\n23\n\ncomplaint -- We'll go back to Exhibit 9, please -- any\n\n24\n\ncase law cited in the amended complaint dealing with the\n\n25\n\nstate attorney's official capacity as the protector of\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734887\n\n\f", "char_count": 1348}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 237, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 191\n\n1\n\nthe grand jury system?\n\n2\n\nA.\n\nYou mean paragraph 3?\n\n3\n\nQ.\n\nYes.\n\n4\n\nA.\n\nNo, I didn't cite to it because it was\n\n5\n\nclear to anyone who looked at Florida Statute 27.03, they\n\n6\n\nwould see a litany of cases describing the d\n\n7\n\nthe state attorney over the grand juries i\n\n8\n\njudicial district.\n\n9\n\nwere getting at.\n\n10\n\nQ.\n\n11\n\nSo it was obvious\n\nYou cited the st\n\nattorney power over the gr\n\n12\n\nA.\n\n13\n\nthat say that, unde\n\n14\n\nessentially the\n\nheir\n-- what we\n\nthat gives the state\nu\n\nCorrect,\n\nOrity of\n\n?\n\nn fact, there are cases\ntatute, that the grand jury is\n\nf\n\nh\n\n-- of the state attorney.\n\n15\n\nQ.\n\n16\n\ncomplaint,\n\n17\n\nsorry -- page 21, wherein there is the wherefore clause.\n\n18\n19\n20\n\nw that we're back on the amended\nirect your attention to paragraph 21 --\n\nMr. Wyler had you read from one of the\nrebore clauses, but I wanted to ask about the\ntherefore clause on page 21 --\n\n21\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\n-- and you had said that you had requested\nActually, could i just ask you\n\n23\n\nan in-camera inspection.\n\n24\n\nto read this wherefore clause?\n\n25\n\nA.\n\nSure.\n\n\"The Palm Beach Post respectfully\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734888\n\n\f", "char_count": 1206}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 238, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 192\n\n1\n\nrequests that this Court, pursuant to Florida Statute\n\n2\n\nSection 905.27(1) and the Court's inherent authority,\n\n3\n\norder the state attorney and clerk of the Court to file\n\n4\n\nwith this Court files of testimony, minutes and other\n\n5\n\nevidence presented in 2006 to the Palm Beach County grand\n\n6\n\njury during the first Jeffrey Epstein sex a\n\n7\n\ninvestigation so that, following an in-ca\n\n8\n\nit can be made available to the Palm\n\nPost and the\n\n9\n\npublic on an expedited basis, and g\n\nsuch other and\n\n10\n\nfurther equitable or legal rel\n\n11\n\nand proper.\"\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\nSo, in the\n\n13\n\nrequest an in-camer\n\n14\n\nA.\n\ne\n\ninspection,\n\ne Court deems just\n\ned complaint, did you\n\nASO\nn\n\ne tion?\n\nInAt t, in our motion for summary judgment\n\n15\n\nthat we made\n\n16\n\non that.\n\n17\n18\n\nAnd Mr. Wyler asked you about the\n\\Sr\ntreecript -- the hearing before Judge Marx and that\n\n19\n\nns ript, and during that hearing, Judge Marx made\n\n20\n21\n\n0\n\nJudge Hafele, there's a whole section\n\naliments about possession and custody of the grand jury\n\nrecords by the state attorney.\n\n22\n\nI wanted to ask you about the order on that\n\n23\n\nmotion to dismiss.\n\nThe order was Exhibit 15.\n\n24\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n25\n\nQ.\n\nAnd did Judge Marx's order address those\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734889\n\n\f", "char_count": 1317}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 239, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 193\n\n1\n\ncomments that Mr. Wyler read?\n\n2\n\nA.\n\nNo, she did not.\n\n3\n\nthey were dicta.\n\n4\n\nQ.\n\nAnd what did Judge Marx's order rule?\n\n5\n\nA.\n\nShe ruled on a very narrow area, which --\n\n6\n\nand I respect Judge Marx.\n\n7\n\nand reasoned jurist.\n\nThat's why I believe that\n\nShe's a very, vez.\n\neasoned\n\n8\n\nShe determined that,\n\n9\n\nthere was not a private cause of ac\n\n10\n\nbecause it was not a private c\n\n11\n\nnot utilize that statute t\nhe grand jury\nj'sliir\nmaterials. We disagree k 't that, and that is the\n.4ssy\ncal\nsubject of the appe\n\n12\n13\n14\n15\n\nQ.\n\n16\n\n19 n\n}ea\n\nf action, we could\n\nele, which is --\n\nA.\n\n17\n18\n\nand that,\n\nixTg to the final judgment that was\n\nSo\n\nentered by Ju\n\n5.27, that\n\n-- Exhibit 30, yes\nS\n\nli\nt '\nQ.\n\nt was\n\nYes.\n-- Mr. Wyler asked you to read from page 7,\nnumber ending 1477.\n\n21\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\nAnd I'm going to ask you to go ahead and\n\n23\n\nfinish that paragraph, or read the whole paragraph if you\n\n24\n\nwould like.\n\n25\n\nA.\n\nRight.\n\n\"The newspaper makes strong\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734890\n\n\f", "char_count": 1083}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 240, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 194\n\n1\n\narguments to advance its more expansive construction of\n\n2\n\nSection 905.27 as part of, quote, furthering justice,\n\n3\n\nunquote.\n\n4\n\nsurrounding Mr. Epstein's conduct, the circumstances of\n\n5\n\nhis resolution of the 2006 state charges and potential\n\n6\n\nfederal charges and his 2008 guilty plea an\n\n7\n\nincarceration are matters of public intere\n\nand\n\n8\n\ndisclosure of the materials may argua%\n\nwithin the\n\n9\n\nconcept of, quote, furthering justi\n\n10\n\nbroadest social sense of the\n\nUnquestionably, the established matters\n\n11\nQ.\n\n13\n\ns\n\nWere Kir\n\nher portions of the final\n\njudgment that yo\n\n15\n\nDid the --\n\n16\n\nA.\n\n18\n\n, or not?\n\nI think t\n\n14\n\n17\n\nii\n\nShould I kee\n\n12\n\nnd quote, in the\n\nine for now.\n\nt d to discuss and needed to finish?\n\nC II\n\nII\n\nIt\n\nGo ahead, sorry.\nI take issue with the state attorney's\n\n19\n\ner ion that this was only about possession and\n\n20\n\ntody.\n\nWe were asserting that the Court has inherent\n\n21\n\nauthority over the grand jury process and that inherent\n\n22\n\nauthority superseded or was preeminent over the statute,\n\n23\n\n905.27.\n\n24\n\nopportunity to participate in this case, because we felt\n\n25\n\nit was only fair to, not only the state attorney, but to\n\nThat is why we gave the state attorney the\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734891\n\n\f", "char_count": 1327}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 241, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 195\n\n1\n\nthe public to hear a voice for grand jury secrecy.\n\nAnd\n\n2\n\nthe state attorney availed himself of that opportunity.\n\n3\n\nNow, on appeal, we are of the belief that\n\n4\n\nthe Court has such inherent authority and that the\n\n5\n\nCourt's inherent authority is, as I say, superior to the\n\n6\n\nstatute.\n\n7\n\nthere are state cases which say that.\n\n8\n\nFlorida Supreme Court's case -- actua\n\n9\n\ncase in Clayton says that, where a\n\nat\n\n10\n\nhave abused his authority with\n\nrand jury -- It's not\n\n11\n\nMr. Krischer, and it's not\n\n12\n\nsuggesting they are --\n\nthat case, it was the\n\n13\n\nFifth DCA who said tea\n\ndon't care what the statute\n\n14\n\nsays, the Court\n\nauthority to control abuses of the\n\n15\n\ngrand jury pr\n\n, and ultimately that's why we're here.\n\n16\n\nThere are federal cases which say\nAn\n\nt, and\nn\n\nact, the\n\ns a Fifth DCA\nattorney may\n\n•nberg, so I'm not\n\nbelieve that we've laid out a very\n\n17\n\ndetail\n\n18\n\nst\n\nactual and legal reason why we think the prior\n\nat orney abused his authority.\n\nHow did he do so?\n\n19\n\nob aining materials from the defense team that\n\n20\n\nermined the credibility of the witness and the victim\n\n21\n\nbefore the grand jury.\n\nWe assert that in paragraph 22 of\n\n22\n\nthe amended complaint.\n\nIt states that in there.\n\n23\n\nyou look at the exhibits, you'll see that.\n\nAnd, if\n\n24\n\nWe now know, based upon the Department of\n\n25\n\nJustice, the U.S. Department of Justice's report, that\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734892\n\n\f", "char_count": 1498}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 242, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n1\n\nPage 196\nthe clerk's office in Palm Beach County shared these\n\n2\n\nreported secret grand jury materials with the federal\n\n3\n\ngovernment without a court order, without notice\n\n4\n\napparently to Mr. Aronberg's office or to the public.\n\n5\n\nNow, why they did that, under what\n\n6\n\nauthority they did that, I don't know.\n\nNow\n\n7\n\nasked Mr. Krischer or whether he consente\n\n8\n\ntime of the U.S. Attorney's interacti\n\nr\n\nther they\nring the\n\nth the state\n\nattorney, Mr. Krischer's office, we\n\non't know that\non't\n\neither.\n\nBut we do know that t\n\nve been disclosed.\n\nQ.\n\nAnd you're t\n\nget those materials\n\n13\n\nA.\n\nWe wa\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nRi\n\n15\n\nA.\n\n16\n\nQ. l\n\n10\n11\n12\n\nand\n\n17\n18\n19\n\nt\n\n.\n\ni\nthe public.\nThe public.\n\nth\n\nubl'c.\n\n4C4I\nIIll\nn\n\n20\n\nent.\n\nublic to have those materials.\n\nThe Post is only a conduit for\n\nThat's what the media is under the First\nWithout the media acting as the conduit for\n\npublic, the public does not have the authority, the\n\n21\n\ntime or the resources to inform the public of what's\n\n22\n\ngoing to happen.\n\n23\n\nImagine if Joe Public or Jane Public came\n\n24\n\nand brought this lawsuit.\n\n25\n\nNo.\n\nWould it have gone anywhere?\n\nThank God for the First Amendment that the Post has\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734893\n\n\f", "char_count": 1280}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 243, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 197\n\n1\n\nthe right constitutionally to seek these materials.\n\n2\n3\n\nI know I'm going off on a tangent, but it's\nimportant.\n\n4\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n5\n\nTHE WITNESS:\n\n6\n\nBY MS. WHETSTONE:\n\n7\n\nQ.\n\nYou are.\n\nSo let's move on.\n\nThank you.\nAweic\n\nThank you, Mr. Mendelsohn\n\n8\n\nback to the demand, the first motion\n\n9\n\nwas that one-page motion, and that\n\n10\n\nJune 8th, 2020.\n\nlet's go\nctions that\n\ns erved on\n/4:1)\n/4\n\n11\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n12\n\nQ.\n\nAnd the de4IffaiPE:llibit 14.\n\n13\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\nAn\n\nler had asked you some questions\n\n15\n\nabout the let\n\nrk\n\nat was enclosed with that motion and\n\n16\n\nwas the badle fo\n\nthe sanctions motion that was attached\n\n17\n\ndealing with possession or custody of the grand jury\n\n18\n\nma\n\n19\n\nby the state attorney's office.\nA.\n\nI'm sorry, I don't understand your\n\nQ.\n\nSure.\n\nleestion.\n21\n\nHe had asked you whether there was a\n\n22\n\nbasis for the first motion for fees, and the basis is set\n\n23\n\nforth in this enclosure letter; is that correct?\n\n24\n25\n\nA.\n\nRight.\n\nTheir position was that the\n\nStatute, 905.27, and -- yes, 905.27 did not provide a\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734894\n\n\f", "char_count": 1160}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 244, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 198\n\n1\n\nprivate right of action, yes.\n\n2\n3\n\nQ.\n\nthat we're here on today, correct?\n\n4\n5\n\nSo 905.27, that statute is not the claim\n\nA.\n\nThat is correct.\n\nQ.\n\nAnd, when it comes to -- Mr. Wyi\n\nCount 1 was broader than\n\nthat.\n\n6\n7\n\nsomething about possession or custody of\n\n8\n\nattorney.\n\n9\n\nhave possession or custody in this\n\nHe referenced that the st\n\nsaid\n\nstate\norney does not\n\nttjr, correct?\n\n10\n\nA.\n\nCorrect\n\n11\n\nQ.\n\nBut the reason46rlfiaming the state\n/\n\n12\n\nattorney in the complainctlie initial complaint and the\n\n13\n\namended complaint,\n\n14\n\ncustody?\n\n15\n\nA.\n\n16\n\nlaw with t\n\n17\n\nthat i\n\n18\n\nse\n\ns broader than his own possession or\n\nt.\n\nAs the entity charged by Florida\n\npervision of the grand jury proceeding,\n\nded as well the protection of grand jury\n\ny, ier\nnd we named him in his official capacity, if he\nt\n\n19\n\nse, to protect grand jury secrecy, which he did in\n\n20\n\notion to dismiss and the motion for summary judgment\n\n21\n\nhe filed opposing the release of the materials to the\n\n22\n\npublic.\n\n23\n24\n25\n\nQ.\n\nSo that first motion for fees was filed\n\nJuly 1st, 2020; is that correct?\nA.\n\nThe first motion, yes.\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734895\n\n\f", "char_count": 1219}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 245, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 199\n\n1\n\nQ.\n\nYes.\n\nAnd did the state attorney ever set\n\nthat motion, original motion for fees for hearing?\n\n2\n3\n\nA.\n\nNever.\n\n4\n\nQ.\n\nAnd we are not here on that first motion;\n\n5\n\nis that correct?\n\n6\n\nA.\n\nCorrect.\n\n7\n\nQ.\n\nSo we're here on the amende\n\nThey never set it fearing.\n\n8\n\nsanctions which was filed November 9tA,\n\n9\n\ncorrect?\n\n10\n\nA.\n\nCorrect.\n\nAnd,\n\ntion for\n• is that\n\n, the amended motion\n\n11\n\nand the notice of hearing\n\n12\n\nfrom July of 2020.\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\n14\n\nset the original\n\nst -- July 1st, 2020, motion for fees\n\n15\n\nfor hearing;\n\ncorrect?\n\n16\n\nA.\n\n17\nha}\n\n19\n\nyh t is correct, yes.\n\ncop' of the amended motion for fees filed\nS5 er 9th prior to the time it was filed, correct?\n\nV\n\nA.\n\nThat is correct.\n\n21\n\n21-day safe harbor.\n\n22\n\nQ.\n\n23\n24\n25\n\nr got a notice of hearing that\n\nAnd you never got a copy via mail or fax or\n\n18\n\n20\n\nSo yo\n\nmention the first one\n\nWe weren't given the\n\nWhy did you -- Why did the Post decide to\n\ndrop the state attorney when it did?\nA.\n\nThe state attorney's position changed from\n\none of opposition to the release of the grand jury\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734896\n\n\f", "char_count": 1171}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 246, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 200\n\n1\n\nmaterials to one of neutrality.\n\nOnce the grand jury --\n\n2\n\nOnce the state attorney changed the position, then the\n\n3\n\nPost re-evaluated whether or not he should remain in the\n\n4\n\ncase, and we determined that he should be dropped from\n\n5\n\nthe case.\n\n6\n\nQ.\n\nf\nAt that point, had the Post actwisished\n\n7\n\neverything that it needed from the state 4R, rney in the\n\n8\n\namended complaint?\n\n9\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\nWe had given hi\n\n10\n\nvoice objection or non-objectie\n\n11\n\nobjection, then he changed\n\n12\n\nhis decision, and there\n\n13\n\nto be stated.\n\n14\n\nQ.\n\n0\nth opportunity to\nie originally voiced\n\neutrality.\n\nThat was\n\nthing further that needed\n\nat point, when the Post decided\n\n15\n\nto dismiss th\n\nattorney on October 21st, 2020, had\n\n16\n\nthe Post adComplished everything that was set forth in\n\n17\n\nyour J\n\n23rd, 2020, letter, those three reasons?\nYes.\n\n18\n\nWe had given the state attorney his\n\n19\n\nor unity to be heard, and he took it and then decided\n\n20\n\nno longer needed it.\n\n21\n\nQ.\n\nAnd, finally, the -- you mentioned that the\n\n22\n\nfinal judgment on Count 1 regarding declaratory relief is\n\n23\n\ncurrently on appeal.\n\n24\n\nA.\n\nYes, Count 1 is, yes.\n\n25\n\nQ.\n\nAnd does the state attorney need to be\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734897\n\n\f", "char_count": 1292}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 247, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 201\n\n1\n\nnamed in that appeal?\n\n2\n\nA.\n\nNo.\n\n3\n\nQ.\n\nWhy not?\n\n4\n\nA.\n\nWell, the appeal was taken on Count 1 as\n\n5\n\nyou say.\n\nCount 1 had a number of elements associated\n\n6\n\nwith it.\n\nThat's the declaratory judgment p\n\n7\n\nasserted that, under the First Amendment,\n\n8\n\nConstitution and the Florida Constit\n\n9\n\nhad standing or the right to seek t\n\n10\n\nmaterials, and the statute was\n\n11\n\nFirst Amendment right by t\n\n12\n\n905.27, of it being in\nWe al\n\n13\n14\n\ninherent authori\n\n15\n\nappellate co\n\n16\n\nconflict w\n\n17\n\nauthoril\n\n18\n\nSoAhere\n\nion.\n\nIt\n\nh the U.S.\nhat the Post\n\ngrand jury\nementary to that\n\nage in the statute,\nance of justice.\nted that the Court had\n\nand above 905.27.\n\nIf the\n\nto determine that 905.27 was in\nhe Court's authority, that the Court's\n\nrs superior to 905.27.\n\nSo if it's unclear\n\na number of elements, a constitutional\n\n19\n\nmelt, the Court's constitutional inherent authority as\n\n20\n\ncribed by the Florida Supreme Court and that we\n\n21\n\nbelieve that the reading of the statute that read out in\n\n22\n\nfurtherance of justice or tied it exclusively to a\n\n23\n\npending civil or criminal case was too narrow a reading\n\n24\n\nof the statute.\n\n25\n\nQ.\n\nSo the state attorney has stated his\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734898\n\n\f", "char_count": 1295}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 248, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 202\n\n1\n\naffirmative non-objection to the clerk releasing the\n\n2\n\ngrand jury materials from the Jeffrey Epstein case if\n\n3\n\nordered by the Court?\n\n4\n\nA.\n\n5\n\nattorney.\n\n6\n\nQ.\n\nOn October 14th\n\n7\n\nA.\n\nCorrect, yes.\n\n8\n\nQ.\n\n-- that was the first t\n\n9\n\nYes.\n\nThat was why we dropped the state\n\nlv\nt h= filed that\n\naffirmative statement --\n\n10\n\nA.\n\nYes.\n\n11\n\nQ.\n\n-- that he\n\nAlliPect?\n\n12\n\nA.\n\nThat's ab\n\ny right, yes.\n\n13\n\nQ.\n\nAnd t\n\n14\n\nrelease of the g\n\njiTry materials if ordered by the\n\n15\n\nCourt in the\n\nDCA appeal?\n\n16\n\nA.\n\n.\n\nno longer objects to the\n\nIn their answer brief, the clerk took\n\n17\n\nthe podt541 that it had no opposition at all to the\n\n18\n\nre\n\n19\n\nse lerf the materials, which was contrary to the\n)46‘t\nit on they took against our motion for summary\n\n20\n\ngment.\n\n21\n\nMS. WHETSTONE:\n\n22\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n23\n\nTHE WITNESS:\n\n24\n\nMS. WHETSTONE:\n\n25\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nNo further questions.\n\nIs this witness excused?\nThank you, sir.\nYes.\n\nAll right, thank you, sir.\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734899\n\n\f", "char_count": 1063}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 249, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 203\n\n1\n\nMS. WHETSTONE:\n\nIf I may approach, I'll\n\n2\n\ntake the exhibit binder.\n\n3\n\nTHE WITNESS:\n\n4\n\nThese are for Mr. Wyler.\n\nThank you.\n\n5\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nNext witness.\n\n6\n\nMR. WYLER:\n\nMay we call a rebut\n\n7\n\nMS. WHETSTONE:\n\n8\n\nYour Honor, d'i\n\nrebuttal witness listed on the MR. WYLER:\n\n9\n\nWell, as to\n\n10\n\nMr. Mendelsohn said at th\n\n11\n\nconversation where he,\n\n12\n\nof an article wh' e\n\n14\n\npending.\n\n15\n\nMS.\n\n16\n\nsettlement\n\n17\n\nevide\n\n19\n20\n21\n\nt\n\nNE:\n\nO\ntatements that\n\nnning denying the\n\ne would hold the filing\n\nlement negotiations were\n\nAnd, Your Honor, those\n\ncussions were never entered into\n\nnever even attempted to enter into\n\nen\n\n18\n\ni7v\n\ne's no\n\now, put it on us to\n\nyou know, he said1a.\n\n13\n\nwitness?\n\n, and we object to those being entered\n\nevidence now.\nTHE COURT:\n\nSettlement negotiations are\n\nexcluded by statute.\n\nAll right, so no.\n\n22\n\nMR. WYLER:\n\nOkay.\n\n23\n\nMS. WHETSTONE:\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nIs there anything else?\n\n25\n\nMR. WYLER:\n\nOther than -- No, Your Honor.\n\nThank you, Your Honor.\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734900\n\n\f", "char_count": 1101}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 250, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 204\n\n1\n2\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay.\n\nThen, I guess, both\n\nparties have rested at this point?\n\n3\n\nMS. WHETSTONE:\n\nI was going to ask if Your\n\n4\n\nHonor wanted copies of the appeal brief and the\n\n5\n\nreply that had been filed in the Fourth DCA?\n\n6\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n7\n\nMS. WHETSTONE:\n\n8\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n9\n\nrested.\n\nAll right.\n\nCan we\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n13\n\nback in five minutes\n\n14\n\n(Off thSr;\n\nybody's\n\njust a moment,\n\n'\n\n44e.ke a moment.\n\nI'll be\n\nd from 2:20 p.m. to 2:35\n\np.m.)\n\n16\n\nTH\n\n17\n\nCO\n\nT:\n\nPlease be seated.\n\neryone get a chance to confer with who\n\ntr\n\n18\n\nn\n\n19\n\nMR. WYLER:\n\n20\n\nS\n\nant rests.\n\nplease?\n\n12\n\n15\n\nThen the non-\n\nI have your joint --\n\n10\n11\n\nIt's not in evidenc\n\n(::)\n\nd to confer with?\nYour Honor, thank you.\n\nWe'd\n\nk if you might reconsider the rebuttal witness.\n\n21\n\nIt's not based on settlement.\n\n22\n\non the direct testimony yesterday of\n\n23\n\nMr. Mendelsohn saying that there was a firewall\n\n24\n\nbetween the legal team and the news team, and our\n\n25\n\nwitness can directly contradict that.\n\nIt's really based\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734901\n\n\f", "char_count": 1112}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 251, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 205\n\nMS. WHETSTONE:\n\n1\n\nYour Honor, we object to\n\n2\n\nthis as not on the witness list, which we have\n\n3\n\nagreed, and having no issue that needs to be\n\n4\n\nraised.\n\n5\n\n-- and you could have asked Mr. Aronberg about his\n\n6\n\nown recollection of that instance.\n\n7\n8\n\nYou could have asked Mr. Mendelsohn about\n\nMR. WYLER:\n\nI could call Mr.\n\nas a rebuttal.\n\nCO\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n10\n\nMS. WHETSTONE:\n\nI'm sorry?\nit's not\n\nObj\n\n11\n\nrelevant to the motion\n\n12\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n13\n\nberg then\n\nI4e\n\na 1\nAll right, I will not\n\nreconsider.\n\n14\n\nMR. WYL\n\n15\n\nTHE\n\n16\n\nnow, I t\n\n17\n\nhere\n\n18\n\na\n\n(4<;\nT ank\n%dr you, Your Honor.\nT:\n\nClosing arguments.\n\nAll right,\n\nhat we discussed last time we were\nthat you would give me your closing\n\ne\n\ns, and, if you needed to supplement, I'll\n\n19\n\nyou time to supplement in writing.\n\n20\n\nIs that what you all want to do, or do you\n\n21\n\nwant to conclude today?\n\n22\n\nMR. WYLER:\n\n23\n\nI would prefer to provide you a\n\nwritten closing argument if possible.\n\n24\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nInstead of --\n\n25\n\nMR. WYLER:\n\nYeah, I absolutely would.\n\nI\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734902\n\n\f", "char_count": 1142}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 252, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 206\n\n1\n\nthink that there's a lot of -- there's a lot going\n\n2\n\non here, and I think it might be beneficial to the\n\n3\n\nCourt if you would -- if you would allow us\n\n4\n\nwill give you -- I'd be happy to give you a\n\n5\n\nwritten closing argument.\n\n6\n\nyou in formulating your final judgment„\n\n7\n\nway you go.\n\n8\n\nI\n\nI think it could help\nhichever\n\nAcIr\n\nMS. WHETSTONE:\n\nYour Honor\n\n9\n\nclosing argument, but -- and I\n\n10\n\nI was planning on doing a\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n12\n\nMS. WHETSTONE:\n\ni\n\nepared a\n\nalso write one.\nemental one anyway.\n\nWell\n\nsking you, you know.\nink it would probably\n\n13\n\nbe more -- if yo\n\nwe\n\n14\n\nother, I thin\n\nit en closing arguments, we could\n\n15\n\nreally lay\n\nou know --\n\n16\n\nTH\n\nCO\n\nT:\n\ngoing to do one or the\n\nYeah, I joked about it earlier,\n\n17\n\nI thi\n\neople are better in writing.\n\n18\n\npile\n\nwhen they try to go off the cuff or deal\n\n19\n\nt\n\n20\n\ney miss things.\n\n21\n22\n\nA lot of\n\nthe changes they experienced during a trial,\nI do think people are better in\n\nwriting.\nHow much time do you need to prepare a\n\n23\n\nwritten argument?\n\n24\n\nMR. WYLER:\n\n25\n\nthat would be great.\n\nIf you could give us a week,\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734903\n\n\f", "char_count": 1214}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 253, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 207\n\n1\n\nTHE COURT:\n\nOkay, I'm going to give you\n\n2\n\nsome guidance because there's something I do want\n\n3\n\nto hear from you.\n\n4\n\nI do want you to address Lago.\n\n5\n\nMs. Whetstone, when I read In re Grand Jury\n\n6\n\nProceedings, in those cases the state,\n\norney was\n\n7\n\nsubpoenaed, they were not a party t6Qe\n\ncase, and\n\n8\n\nI want you to address that as we\n\n9\n10\n11\n\nHow much time do you nee\n\nAnd,\n\nprepare your\n\nclosings?\nMR. WYLER:\n\nIf y\n\no ld give us a week,\n\n12\n\nYour Honor, that wo\n\n13\n\nTHE COURT\n\nS:\n\n14\n\nMs. Whe\n\nne, is a week sufficient?\n\n15\n\nMS.\n\n16\n\nsufficie\n\n17\n18\n\nI'll give you 10 days\n\nMR. WYLER:\n\n20\n\nre time to get it.\n\n21\n\nMS. WHETSTONE:\n\n23\n\nI would\n\ne a copy of the transcript attached.\n\n19\n\n22\n\nweek\n\nYes, Your Honor, a week is\n\nE COURT:\n1\n\nterrific.\n\nThen we might need a little\n\nYour Honor, could we ask\n\nfor 20 days?\nTHE COURT:\n\nI'll give you three weeks.\n\n24\n\nI'll give you three weeks.\n\nGive me your -- your\n\n25\n\nwritten closings and proposed orders.\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734904\n\n\f", "char_count": 1070}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 254, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 208\n\n1\n\nGive me one more minute.\n\nThere might be\n\n2\n\nsomething else I want you guys to address.\n\n3\n\nIn the event that I agree with\n\n4\n\nMr. Aronberg, the amounts have been stipulated to,\n\n5\n\ncorrect?\n\n6\n\nMS. WHETSTONE:\n\nNo, Your Honor,\n\n7\n\nnot been stipulated to.\n\n8\n\nthat objects to the majority of\n\n9\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n10\n\nMS. WHETSTONE:\n\n11\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n12\n\nMR. BIDEAU:\n\nhave\n\nWe submitt\n\nI saw that.\n\nbench memo\n\nlees.\nr\n\nel time.\n\nHonor.\n\nYes,\n\nOkay\nrates have been\n\nWe're n\n\nagreed.\n\n14\n\ndidn't need t\n\nin\n\n15\n\nrate.\n\nnt was on legally whether some of\n\n16\n\nthese -\n\n17\n\nrecov4tA4).e.\n\nOur\n\n11)HE COURT:\n\n19\n\nd.\n\n20\n\n22\n\nan expert to talk about the\n\nof these fees were -- were\n\n18\n\n21\n\nesting the rate.\n\nThey\n\n13\n\nYou can be seated.\n\nGive me a\n\n, okay.\nTHE COURT:\nWeatherby.\n\nI want you to address\n\nOne of the cases submitted, Weatherby.\n\n23\n\nMR. WYLER:\n\n24\n\nAnd, Ms. Whetstone, I want you to address\n\n25\n\nWeatherby?\n\nYes, sir.\n\nIn re Grand Jury on that issue regarding --\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734905\n\n\f", "char_count": 1071}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 255, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 209\n\n1\n\nbecause there is a difference, Mr. Aronberg in his\n\n2\n\nofficial capacity as a named party, and In re\n\n3\n\nGrand Jury, I think in that case, I think the\n\n4\n\nstate attorney's was subpoenaed.\n\n5\n\nAnd I also want you -- well, both parties\n\n6\n\nto address the Horowitz case where it ,4s\n\n7\n\nthe judge can extend the law becaus\n\n8\n\nobligation of legislative author\n\n9\n10\n\nAll right, so you'll giv\nand proposed orders withi\n\n11\n12\n\nDo I need to brin\n\n's an\n\nme your arguments\n\n1 lays.\nU sack in for a\n\nhearing?\n\n13\n\nMS. WHETST\n\n14\n\nMR. WYLEfl\n\nN\n\n15\n\nTHE C\n\nOkay.\n\n16\n\nthat\n\nin reces\n\nT:\n\nYour Honor.\nYour Honor.\nAll right, then we'll be\n\nank you very much, everybody.\n\n17\n\n. WYLER:\n\nThank you, Your Honor.\n\n18\n\nS. WHETSTONE:\n\n19\n\nTHE COURT:\n\n4\n\n(The hearing concluded at 2:42 p.m.)\n\nThank you, Your Honor.\n\nHave a great day.\n\n21\n)O;:\n\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734906\n\n\f", "char_count": 946}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 256, "text_content": "EFTA02734907\nJudge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nPage 210\n1\n\nCOURT CERTIFICATE\n\n2\n\nCOUNTY OF PALM BEACH\n\n4\n\nSTATE OF FLORIDA\n\n3\n\n5\n6\n7\n\nI, Lisa Begley, RPR, RMR, c\n\nthe foregoing proceedings ai\n\n9\n\nwas authorized to and did st\n\n8\n\nnotes.\n\n11\n\nis a true and complet-\n\n10\n\nify that I\nhically report\n\ntJiat the transcript\n\nrd of my stenographic\n\n12\n13\n\nDatele4th\n\nday of September, 2022.\n\n14\n15\noftgi...50/\n16\nC.,\n__\n\nLisa Begley, RPR, RMR\n\n17\nIlli!IIIV\n18\n19\n2\n21\n22\n23\n24\n25\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\n\f", "char_count": 518}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 257, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n\n1\n200:22,24\n201:4,5\n\n166:17 171:6\n\n155:17 159:16\n161:6 166:13\n167:4 168:3\n\n198:24 199:8,\n\n1:06\n\n1.510\n\n(1)\n\n168:11,20,23\n169:12,22\n\n12,14 200:15,\n\n145:2\n\n17\n\n183:3\n\n1st\n\n10\n\n198:24 199:14\n\n24 178:3,25\n\n155:8\n\n79:8,9,10,\n\n2\n\n4,15,16\n\n149:16\n\n189:25\n2.42\n\n168:5,12,21,\n24 169:18,21\n\n117\n\n183:15\n\n150:2,3,9\n2.420\n\n(1)(c)\n\n119.07\n\n157:22 158:1\n(2)\n\n183:24\n\n0\n\n161:6\n\n12 168:3\n\nd) (1) (b) (\nA4:42\n\n151:6,12\n\n168:19,22\n\n152:5\n\n169:12\n\n182:15\n2.420(j)\n\n136\n\n183:6,16\n\n(3)(b)\n\n185:6\n\n168:23\n\n2.420(j)(2)\n\n(4)\n\n66:16,\n\n177:4 179:15\n\n9 197:12\n\n(a)\n\n3\n\n167:20 168:\n16\n\n182:2\n1477\n\neS\n\ny\n\n16\n\n157:15 193:20\n1479\n159:4\n\n2 156:16\n:15\n\n14th\n202:6\n15\n\n1\n\n1\n\n15th\n161:7 166:3\n167:8 172:12\n176:18 198:4\n\n188:7\n16\n\n183:9\n20\n162:10 207:22\n2006\n175:24 192:5\n194:5\n2008\n194:6\n2019\n189:15\n2020\n\n192:23\n\n209:10\n21-day\n165:22\n199:21\n\n172:11\n135\n\n(3)(a)\n\n1 1:16,17,20\n\n179:13,25\n\n119.07(1)\n\n158:3 159:7,\n\n(b)\n\n25 177:10,16,\n\n2\n\n11/14/2019\n\n(1)(b)\n\n21\n166:6 176:21,\n\n207:17\n10(b)(5)\n\n(1)(a)\n\n9,10 197:10\n\n153:23 163:10\n165:13 166:1,\n3,7 176:19\n177:21,24\n\n21st\n177:21 200:15\n22\n195:21\n23\n166:9 176:23\n177:19\n232\n165:4\n233\n166:20,21\n235\n165:15\n23rd\n167:16 200:17\n24(a)\n161:7 172:12\n245\n171:22\n247\n176:17\n262\n\n178:23 179:8,\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734908\n\n\f", "char_count": 1289}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 258, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n\n2\n\n162:11,12\n\n189:19\n\n205:25\n9\n\n27.01\n5\n\n188:9\n27.03\n\n156:23\n\n154:15,17\n188:10 189:6\n\n148:23 162:2\n\n2:20\n204:14\n2:35\n204:14\n2:42\n\n159:25 160:15\n\n166:12,15,22\n\n172:8\n\n167:7,11,13,\n\n905.27\n\n21 169:14\n\n149:12 157.-\n\n172:25\n\n170:3,23\n\n152:23 15\n\n173:17,18\n\n171:9 176:22\n\n156:14\n\n174:1 175:23\n\n159:18,\n\n176:3,7\n\n172:15\n194:2,\n\n180:17,22,24,\n\n7:25\n\n25 181:15\n150:3,7,11\n\n57.105(1)(a)\n\n154:14 188:1,\n\n:2 201:12,\n\n57.105(3\n\n192:2\n\naccomplish\n186:22\n\n200:6,16\naccurate\n\n905.27(1)(c)\n\n3(a)\n\n173:5\n\naccomplished\n905.27(1)\n\n167\n\naccessing\n\n14,15,17\n\n169:7\n\n3 189:4,5,25\n190:1,4 191:2\n\n:Tess\n51:1,24\n\n179:15\n\n3\n\n195:10,18\n\n195:14\n\n905.17\n\n11,14,19\n3\n\nAbused\n\nAbuses\n\n165:7,19,23\n\n177:3 178:3,\n\n209:20\n\n12 187:25\n190:23\n\n57.105\n\n190:6 191:5\n\n192:6\n\n9\n152:7 175:10,\n\n57\n\n150:18\n\nabuse\n\n151:25 179:19\n\n175:21\nacknowledges\n\n168:2\n905.27(2)\n30\n\n158:9\n\n170:23\nact\n\n157:13 181:24\n193:16,17\n\n925.27's\n\n7\n193:19\n\nacted\n9th\n\n70\n152:10\n\n165:22\n\n159:8\n168:13,25\n\n199:8,19\nacting\n196:19\n\n8\n8th\n149:15 165:11\n\nA\naction\nability\n\n149:13,20,25\n\n161:17\n\n150:17 155:2,\n\n166:7 178:23\n\nabsolutely\n\n5,7 156:19\n\n179:10 197:10\n\n148:9,16\n\n182:25 183:1\n\n156:1 167:25\n\n188:13 189:1\n\n167:14 184:12\n\n184:1 186:23\n\n193:9,10\n\n188:18,19,21\n\n187:3 202:12\n\n198:1\n\n4\n4\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734909\n\n\f", "char_count": 1316}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 259, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nactual\n184:13\nAdded\n157:21\nadditional\n167:10\naddress\n192:25 207:4,\n\n3\n188:12,25\n\nafternoon\n145:5,12\n146:11,12\n\nannounce\nagree\n\n145:4\n\n164:5 205:12\nanswering\n208:3\n\n156:9\n\nagreed\n\napparently\n\n146:14 176:23\n\n209:6\n\n205:3 208:13\n\n156:21 186:1\nAdministration\n182:16 183:6,\n8,25 185:6\nadmit\n151:15\nadmitted\n150:23 162:5\n\n173:22\n\n187:19\n\n8 208:2,21,24\n\naddressed\n\nangry\n\nallegation\n\n4 202:\n\n150:13 177:12\n\n181:15\n185:11,12,15,\n\nalleged\n\n2\ni70)\n\n149:18,23\n\n6 :19\n\n179:16\nears\nambiguous\n\narguments\n\namende\n\nappellate\n\n157:16 163:15\n\n201:15\n\n194:1 205:15,\n\napplicable\n57:25\n\n169:4 181:16\n185:18\n\n0:25 181:9\n7:22 189:10\n190:5,22,24\n\n199:7,10,18\n200:8\nAmendment\n\n155:20\n\n9,23 208:15\n\n190:1\n\nAronberg\n\napply\n168:19 169:7\napproach\n\n201:7,11\n\n203:1\n\nand/or\n149:23,24\n\narm\n191:14\n\n160:12,23\n\n208:4\n\n209:9\n\n170:18\n\n196:19,25\n\namounts\n\n18 206:14\n\napplication\n\n168:9\n\nafforded\n\n18 186:13\n205:23 206:5,\n\n195:22 198:13\n\n202:1,9\n\n:1 156:18,\n\n169:15,20\n\nadvocat\n\naffirmative\n\nent\n\n171:2,3\n\napplied\n\n145:25\n\n56:5\n\n200:23\n\n191:15 192:12\n\naffirm\n\narguing\n\n162:1 168:7\n\n148:16\n\nof\n\n163:15 174:4\n\n193:13 1\n\n175:2\n\n18\n\nargued\n\n19 161:21,22\n\n193:22 194:17\n\n154:2 184:20\n\nadvised\n\n163:13 184:20\n\n164:23,24\n\n189:17 190:2\n\nadopted\n\n157:17 194:1\n\nargue\n\n196:4\n\n184:12\n\nadvance\n\n194:8\n\nappeal\nahead\n\nadmittedly\n162:16\n\narguably\n\n145:15 146:22\n147:5,11,16\n148:12,21\n161:17 164:6\n173:25 174:10\n177:21 179:4,\n5,7,24\n180:12,15,21\n\nappropriately\n177:13\narea\n193:5\n\n181:3 188:6\n190:17,19\n195:11 205:5,\n7 208:4 209:1\n\n150:14,16\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734910\n\n\f", "char_count": 1581}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 260, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n\n4\n190:15 191:6\n\n176:17 182:1\n\n145:14 150:19\n\n192:2 194:21,\n\n193:20\n\n154:16,18,23\n\n22 195:4,5,\n\n147:7,19\n\n168:12,24\n\n10,14,18\n\n145:9 152:16\n\n148:14,24\n\n170:9 172:1,\n\n196:6,20\n\n162:19\n\n161:7 172:12\n\n4,5,19,22\n\n201:14,16,17,\n\n175:18,22,24\n\n203:13\n\n177:21 185:9,\n\n19 209:8\n\n176:3 188:8,\n\nAronberg's\n176:14 196:4\narticle\n\nattorney\n\n10,16,20\n\nAsh\n\n188:7 189:3,\n155:3\n\nauthorize\n\nBeach\n\n23 191:25\n\n155:5\n\n92:5,8 196:1\n\n11 190:8,10,\navailed\n\nasks\n\n15,21 191:7,\n195:2\n\n174:10\n\n159:20\n\n11,14 192:3,\n\nassert\n\n21 194:23,25\n\n195:21\n\n195:2,9,18\n\nawarded\n168:4\n\n196:9 198:8,\n\naware\n\n156:14 170:4,\n\n12 199:1,23\n\n1•_x\n\n9 201:7,13\n\n200:2,7,15,\n\nasserted\n\nasserting\n156:2 161:12\n\nbegan\n‘;:!)\n\nbeginning\n•,21,22\na\n185:13\n\n18,25 201:25\n\nassertion\n170:8,11,24\n\n153:21 1\n162:18\n164.\n\n194:19\n\n1\nassociates\n\nB\nback\n170:3 172:8\n175:9 181:24\n\nassuming\n\norneys\n\n171:16,24\n172:1 179:19\nassumpt\n\n155:19 169:3\n189:7\nattorneys'\n\n178\n\n160:9 165:18,\n\nat\n\n25 176:14\n207:18\n\nathpmpted\n203:17\nattend\n163:18\nattention\n\nAuthorities\n160:4,10,11\n\n154:16 157:3,\n5 159:19\n\n172:8 187:24\n\n175:22 188:9\n\n191:16\n\n189:7,11\n\n145:8,14\nbelief\n195:3\nbench\n208:7\n\n197:8 204:13\n\nbeneficial\n\nbar\n155:6\nbased\n168:13 182:13\n195:24 204:21\nbasis\n153:25 192:9\n197:16,22\n\n206:2\nBideau\n145:6 208:12\nbig\n172:24\nbinder\n160:10,11\n203:2\nblanche\n159:19\n\nauthority\n148:18 150:20\n\n203:10\n\n190:23 191:15\n209:11\n\n155:19\n\n156:3 166:1\n\nbehalf\n\n202:5 207:6\nattorney's\n\n194:20\n\n145:2\n\n150:2,8\n151:5,7\n\nblow\n190:2\n\n152:1,2\n157:15 162:10\n165:4,15\n\nBock\n188:22\n\n166:20 175:10\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734911\n\n\f", "char_count": 1593}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 261, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nbottom\n\n5\ncase\n\n151:10\n\n150:25\n151:17,21\n\nbring\n208:14 209:11\nbringing\n\n152:18,22\n\n175:5 198:15\ncharges\n\n191:17,20,24\nclauses\n\n194:5,6\n\n191:19\n\n153:5 155:3,\ncheck\n17,18,22\n\n149:9\n\n175:11\n\ncharged\n\nClayton\n\n167:15\n\n195:9\n\n156:15 157:8\nbroad\n\n158:7 159:10,\n\n154:19 189:6\nbroader\n198:4,13\nbroadest\n159:22 194:10\nbrought\n149:13 156:23\n196:24\n\n17,24 163:9\n169:13 175:8\n179:7 181:17\n185:11,16,21,\n\nchose\n\nclear\n\n198:19\n\n145:7\n\n155:1,6 194:4\n\n154:15 1\n\n146:7 153:2\n\n187:5,7,10\n\n167:11\n\n156:20 161:8\n\n189:9 190:22,\n\n191:4\n\n162:5,16\n\n24 194:24\n\nci\n189:5\n\n200:4,5\n\n22,24\n\ncases\n12\n2\n\ncall\n203:6 205:7\n\n169:8\n\n12,16,21\n\n186•\ncaDa\n\n150:25\n\n188:19,23\n189:3,22\n\n153:4 155:17,\n\n192:3 202:1,\n\n22 156:15\n\n13,16\n\nce\n\n159:10,17\n\n204:17\n\n183:1,2\n\nchange\n178:25 179:4\n\n14 196:1\n187:5,7,10\n201:23\n\nchanged\n\n88:11,24\n189:3,22\n\n200:2,11\n\n195:13\ncarte\n\nclient\n148:16\n\n163:6\n\ncare\n\n162:23 182:4,\n\n184:7,8\n\n181:4 199:24\n\n198:18 209:2\n\nclerk's\n7,24 184:11,\n\ncivility\n\n190:20,25\n\n185:15,17,23\n\n152:18,21\n\n153:23 179:6\n\n1\n\n183:17 184:20\n\n151:17,21\n\n157:8 158:7\n\ncamera\n174:25\n\n174:2,3,5,6,\n10,11 182:10,\n\n177.11\ncalls\n\n172:4,13,18,\n22,25 173:7\n\n1:10\ncivil\n\n154:17\n\n145:8\n\nk\n\n145:20,25\n\ncite\n\n207:7 209:3\n\nCA\n\ncl\n\n22 186:2\n\n201:23 202:2\nC\n\n1:4 191:5\n\ncircumstances\n\n195:8,9,12\nBuitrago\n\n:\n154:3,24\n\n149:18,23\n150:13,23\n\nclaim\n\n153:15 154:1\n\n153:1 161:13,\n\n156:2,8\n\n149:12 159:25\n\n18 168:5\n\n161:12,15\n\n166:12\n\n169:19 170:5,\n\n162:5 168:14\n\n17 177:11,15\n\n169:14\n\n179:24 198:2\n\n174:18,21\n\nChapter\n\ncharacterize\n156:25\n\nclause\n\n177:14 180:6,\n\n159:18\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734912\n\n\f", "char_count": 1608}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 262, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n\n6\n\n12,13 181:16\n\ncomplaints\n\n161:5 172:10\n\ncontext\n\n184:4 185:23,\n\n149:23\n\n183:4 184:4\n\n158:5\n\n25 186:8\n\n185:4\n\ncomplementary\n\nclient's\n149:17,23\n165:7 170:5,\n\n201:10\n\nconfidentiality\n\n159:1\n\ncomplete\n\n182:14,17,23\n\ncontradict\n\n164:8 174:17\n\nconflict\n\n204:25\n\n201:16\n\ncontrary\n\n158:20\n\nconfused\n\n02:18\n\ncomplicated\n\n169:23\n\n182:24\n\nconfusing\n\n17 181:4\ncompleteness\n186:7\nclose\n190:3\nclosing\n\ncontinue\n\ntribute\n\n(\n178:4 179:\n\ncomply\n\n205:15,17,23\n161:18 164:7\n180:24,25\n\n149:19,24\n\n155:4,\n\n149:2,3 151:3\n\n151:16\n\ncomptroller\n\n5 :17 153:4\n\n188:23\n\ncomments\n\nconcept\n\n164:22 192:20\n\n194:9\n\n193:1\nconclud\ncompare\n\n7:4\n\nti\n\n205,gre\n\nconsented\n196:7\nConstitution\n\n188:14\n\n161:7 172:12\nco\n\n201:8\n\n:2\n189:2\n\nconstitutional\nusion\n\ncomplain\n\n201:18,19\n\n9:9\n147:6\nconclusory\n170:19\n\n149:1\n\n0:1,\n\n3,6\n\n1\n\n15\n\n74:17\n\n15\n\nconstitutionall\n197:1\n\nconduct\n154:19 189:7\n\nconstrained\n157:2,6\nconstruction\n\n189:10,15,25\n190:4,5,23,24\n191:16 192:12\n195:22\n198:12,13\n\n188:12,25\n195:14\nconversation\n148:20 203:11\ncopies\n172:4 204:4\ncopy\n\nconducted\n194:1\n190:18\nconduit\n\nconfer\n204:17,18\n\n200:8\nconfidential\n\n165:7 199:17,\n18 207:18\ncorner\n\ncorrect\n151:18,22\n162:20 164:15\n166:4 169:17\n174:2 176:4,\n20,22 177:16\n\ncontacted\n196:17,19\n\n157:10 160:15\n\n151:10\n\ny\n\n194:4\n4 187:22\n\n17 170:12\n\nu\n\ncomparing\n\ncomplaint\n\n150:14,16\n161:19 162:6,\n\nco 111, on\n\ncomment\n148:15,21\n\n244\n)\n\nCongres\n\ncompound\n\n207:10,25\n\nontrol\n\n180:4\n\n206:5,9,14\nclosings\n\n441S:9\n\n146:23 147:6\ncontention\n177:12\ncontesting\n208:13\n\n178:15 179:1,\n13,15,25\n182:6,21\n185:8 187:5\n188:19\n189:12,24\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734913\n\n\f", "char_count": 1631}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 263, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n\n7\n\n190:5,13,14\n\n10 182:9,11\n\n158:6 159:10,\n\n191:12 197:23\n\n183:4,13,16,\n\n17 184:7,8\n\n166:6,9\n\n198:3,4,9,10,\n\n17 184:4,15,\n\n187:5,7,10\n\n176:21,25\n\n15,24 199:5,\n\n18 185:3,24\n\n201:23\n\n177:10,16\n\n6,9,10,15,16,\n\n186:10 187:15\n\n19,20 202:7\n\n192:1,3,4,10\n\n208:5\n\n194:20 195:4,\n14 196:3\n\ncorrected\n\n178:3,25\n\nCross\n145:17 146:9\ncross-examined\n158:18\n\n197:4 201:13,\n\n177:13\n\n15,20 202:3,\nCort\n15,22,25\ncosts\n\n204:1,6,8,12,\n\n160:9\n\n16 205:9,12,\n\nCount\n\n15,24 206:3,\n\n149:16 198:4\n\n11,16 207:1,\n\n200:22,24\n\n13,17,23\n\n201:4,5\n\n208:9,11,18,\n\n16 207:17,22\n209:10\n\n84:10 195:8,\n\n171:4\n\n1;\n\ncuff\n\n202:15\n\n204:5\n\n206:18\ndeal\ncure\n\n206:18\n\n179:24\ndealing\n190:24 197:17\n22\ndecide\ndy\n\n21 209:15,19\n\nCounty\n\n179:10,14,15,\n\nAtal\n\ncrystal\n\n155:3\n203:5,20,24\n\ndays\n\n199:22\n\n61:19 170:12\n175:24 188:8,\n23 192:5\n196:1\n\nCourt's\n175:22 1\n185:2\n195:\n\ncourt\n145:3,16,20\n\ndecided\n190:11,12\n156:25\n192:20 194:20\n200:14,19\n197:17 198:7,\ndecision\n\n9,14\n\n2\n\n154:11 162:23\n\n146:7 147:3\n\nD\n\n148:1,6,7\n149:3 150:8\n152:25 153:\n\ndecisions\nating\n148:21 190:7\n\n155:3,4, 6,2\ncredibility\n156:2\n195:20\n\n158\n1\n\n5,18\n20\n\n61:3,10\n12:9 163:2,5\n167:20 168:5,\n6 169:18,19\n170:1 172:14\n173:22 174:1,\n25 175:2,19\n176:5 177:6,\n\n200:12\n\ncredit\n164:12\ncrime\n175:5\n\ndate\n177:24 178:2,\n25\ndated\n189:25\nDave\n\n152:18,21\n153:5 155:22\n156:15 157:8\n\n152:18\ndeclaratory\n161:18 170:5,\n17 177:15\n183:1,18\n\n177:21\n\n200:22 201:6\n\n188:6\n\n150:25\n151:17,21\n\ndeclaration\n\n145:14 176:14\n180:11,15\n\ncriminal\n\n148:17\n\nday\n149:7 153:14\n\ndeclaring\n175:20\ndecline\n171:13\n\n165:10 178:22\n209:19\n\ndeems\n192:10\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734914\n\n\f", "char_count": 1624}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 264, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\ndefendant\n\n8\ndevoted\n\n145:15 179:7\n180:6 183:18\n188:6,22\ndefense\n\n186:8,23\n\n149:7\n\ndiscretion\n\n164:8,13\n\n154:11\n\n193:3\n\n155:21 156:3\n\ndifference\n172:24 173:1,\n\n169:19 177:12\n\n5,11,17 209:1\n\ndemand\n148:23 162:2\n\nDouglas\n145:13\ndraw\n\ndiscuss\n\n161:12 168:6\n195:19\n\n166:10\n\n194:8\n\ndicta\n\ndoubt\n\n194:14\n\n187:24\n\ndiscussed\n\ndrop\n\n148:20 186:12\n\n148:23 179:4,\n\ndiffering\n\n205:16\n\nh3 199:23\n\n181:18\n\ndiscusses\n\ndirect\n\n184:19\n\ndrdliped\n179:5,7,24\n\n165:7,19\n149:6 157:20\n\ndiscussio\n\n180:11,15,16,\n\n162:9 171:11\n\n147:22\n\n20 181:10,13\n\n166:12,15,17\n170:3,4,23\n\n191:16 204:22\n\n178:11,14,20\n180:17,22\n186:2 197:8,\n\ndirecting\n\n203:16\n\n160:21\ndirection\n\n4 :16 156:5,\nA<II1\n4;7\n4 1161:24\n163:10\n\n204:25\n\n177:12\n\n164:10,24\n192:23 198:20\n\ndisagr,\n\ndenying\n\n200:15\n\n19\n\n203:10\n\ndisputed\n\nDepartment\n\ndescribing\n\n159:14\ndistrict\n\n159:9,13\n\ndetailed\n195:1\ndete\n\n173:19 175:1\n\n188:7 190:9,\n\n176:8 187:2\n\n16 191:8\n\n196:10\n\ndocuments\n\n75:19\n6 201:15\n\ndisclosing\n\n149:19,25\n\n173:1\n\n150:14,16\n\ndetermined\n148:24 182:23\n193:8 200:4\n\n151:20 152:24\n\ndisclosure\n155:16 157:5\n\n153:11 174:6\n\n158:5,10\n\n175:3 188:12,\n\n159:17 173:17\n\n25\n\ndetermines\n168:5 169:18\ndevelopment\n149:8\n\n174:17 182:13\n183:4,7,15\n\n181:14\nduly\n146:7 188:6,\n22\n\ndissemination\n\nlosed\n152:19 155:18\n\n191:6\n\ndue\n\n156:16\n\n182:11\n\n195:24,25\n\n177:20 180:6\n181:2\n\ndirectly\n\ndenial\n\n200:4 202:4\ndropping\n\n182:10,23\n\n12\n\n185:16,20\n\ndiscussi\n\n171:9 176:22\n\nI\n\ndoor\n147:23\n\n185:4,7\n\nearlier\n172:9 206:16\neasier\n188:16\neditorial\n148:17\nEdmondson\n147:6,8,16\nelected\n188:7,23\nelement\n167:1,3,5,6,9\n201:19\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734915\n\n\f", "char_count": 1625}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 265, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n\n9\nESQ\n\nelements\n\nexcused\n\n146:6\n\n201:5,18\nemail\n\nessentially\n\n165:8\n\n162:22 191:14\n\nEmphasis\n\nestablish\n\n157:21\n\n170:6 179:23\n\nemployees\n\nestablished\n\n155:20\n\n194:3\n\nenclosed\n\nestablishment\n\n197:15\n\n168:8\n\nenclosure\n\nevent\n\n202:22\nexempt\n161:5 172:10\nexercise\n157:4\nexhibit\n\n158:4 159:21\n183:7,11\n\n153:23\n\nending\n\n17 177:19\n\n193:17\n\n193:20\nenforced\n154:25\n\n186:13\n\nF\nfa t\n175:1 181:9\n184:14 185:10\n186:14 191:12\n192:14 195:7\n\n20\n\n199:10\n\n204:8\nevidence\n\n149:12 184:19\n\n165:2 166:16,\n\neverybody's\n\n186:9 194:9\n\nextensively\n\n148:1,4,5\n\n190:23\neventually\n\n159:24 163:8\n\n152:7 157:12\n\n208:3\n\nend\n\n168:7\nextensive\n\n187:25 18\n\n197:23\n\nextension\n\n• 151:8\n:23\n\nfacts\n168:9,15\n170:6,18\n\n146:1,15\n\nistence\n\n147:25 14\n\n168:14\n\nfactual\n195:17\n\n5 175:\nexisting\n192:\n\nenter\n\n168:8\n\n18\n\n203:17\n\nfair\n194:25\n\nexpanded\nentered\n\n182:25\n\n167:1,2,4,6,\n\n193:15\n203:16,18\nentire\n158:21\n188:3\n\n7:7\nc\n\nenti S\n\n( Ll ination\n145:17 146:9\n149:6 187:16,\n17\nexamined\n174:25 176:5\n\nexpansive\n194:1\nexpectation\n168:10\nexpedited\n192:9\n\n186:10\n\nexperienced\n\n:17\n\nexcluded\n\n206:19\n\n190:12,18\n\n203:21\n\n1\n\n192:6 202:2\nEpstein's\n194:4\nequitable\n192:10\n\nfaith\n\nexpert\n\n9,10 168:7,\n13,25 169:15,\n20,21\nfall\n194:8\nfamiliar\n160:16 172:16\n183:24\nfamous\n\nexclusively\n\n208:14\n\n155:2\n\n201:22\n\nexpressly\n\nfavorable\n\n157:7\n\n148:14\n\nexcuse\n150:19 168:11\n183:15\n\nextend\n209:7\n\nfax\n199:17\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734916\n\n\f", "char_count": 1434}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 266, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nfederal\n\n10\nfinally\n\n194:6 195:6\n196:2\n\n200:21\n\n147:2,10\n\n160:9 165:18,\n25 169:1\n\n154:8 194:12\n\nfront\n151:7 157:11\n188:2\n\nfinish\n\n176:14 180:2\n\n156:11 193:23\n\n197:22 198:23\n\n194:14\n\n199:2,14,18\n\n152:13 184:10\n202:15 204:5\n\nfine\n\nfees\n\nfourth\n\nfurtherance\n152:23 156:17\n\n145:13 161:16\n\n159:21 19\n\n2,4,6,9,10\n\n164:14\n\n9\n\n168:6,13,25\n187:19\n\n179:12\n\ngovernment\n196:3\n:22 176:3,\ngrand\n\n14 170:22\n\n176:21 177:9,\nFlorida\n\n150:20\ngave\n\n180:1 182:25\n\n145:9 1\n\n153:17 154:10\n\n183:23 185:14\n\n21 15\n\n178:24 179:2\n\n186:4 189:15\n\n15\n\n194:23\n\n198:21,23\n\nGeneral\n\n199:8,18,19\n\n;5,7\n\n202:8 204:5\n\n5:5 188:8,\n\n182:15 183:5,\n8 185:5\n\n,24 189:6\n190:7 191:5\n\n192:4\n192:1 195:8\n198:15 201:8,\n\n154\n\n5\n\n12:\n\n:3:6\n03:12\n\nf\n\nal\n\n158:17 163:2\nGerard\n\n154:12,16,19\n155:20 158:6\n159:9,12,20\n161:9,20\n162:6,17\n172:2,13,14\n175:24\n182:14,17\n183:19\n184:16,22\n187:1 188:9\n189:8,12\n\nfollow\n164:21 182:22\nformulating\n206:6\n\n10 159:1,4\n186:25 187:1\n\ngentleman\n\n145:6 189:18\n\n20\n\n1 6:23 157:1,\n181:24 185:2\n\n45:5,12\n\n169:15,20,21\n\n159:3 165:1,\n\nfiling\n\ngod\n\n148:7 167:1,\n\nflip\n\nfiles\n\n196:25\n\n158:2,4\n\n6 192:3\n\n24 179:23\n\nGod\n\n:11,12\n\nfits\n\n165:22,25\n\n187:1\n\nfurthering\n\n194:24\n\nfiled\n\n186:7,9,25\n\n204:23\nfirm\n\n164:24 184:2,\n\ngoal\n\n201:12,22\n\n157:1,5\n\nfile\n\n181:8\n\nfirewall\n\n208:8,16\nfelt\n\ngiving\n\ngive\n146:1 174:6\n177:2,3\n180:19\n205:17,19\n\nfound\n150:2 165:4\n\n206:4,24\n207:1,11,13,\n\n193:14 194:13\n\nfoundation\n\n17,23,24\n\n200:22 206:6\n\n147:1\n\n208:1,18\n\n190:8,12,13,\n16,18 191:1,\n7,11,13\n192:5,20\n193:11 194:21\n195:1,10,15,\n21 196:2\n197:17\n198:16,17,19\n\n209:9\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734917\n\n\f", "char_count": 1614}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 267, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n\n11\n\n199:25 200:1\n\nhanded\n\nhonestly\n\nimportant\n\n201:9 202:2,\n\n175:7\n\n173:20\n\n197:3\n\n14 207:5\n208:25 209:3\ngrant\n\nhappen\n\nHonor\n\n196:22\n\n145:5,12,18\n146:25 147:21\n\nhappened\n\n186:23 189:6\n192:9\ngranted\n\n148:11 174:8\n\n149:1 150:9\n\n180:7\n\n158:19,25\n159:1 160:4\n\nhappening\n\n190:17\n\nimpossibility\n\n163:4 188:16\n\n179:18\n\n203:7,15,23,\ngreat\n206:25 209:19\nGreenberg\n\n25 204:4,19\n\n150:4 184:18\n188:5 206:4\nharbor\n\n145:8 169:3\ngroup\n\n205:1,14\n206:8 20\n\n165:22 199:21\n\n10 209\n\nguidance\n\n195:1 207:3\nheard\n\n207:2\n\n200:19\n\nguilty\n\n'SS.,\n\nhearicifillir\n\n194:6\n\n1\n\n:\n\n4:20\n\n.1 ,19\n\nguys\n208:2\n\nheld\n148:24\n\n15 :21,c\n\n5 193:15\nHa\n\nle's\n\n186:15\nhalf\n186:21\nhand\n167:23 174:21\n\n175:6 178:9\n\n194:7\n\n198:17\n\n186:21\n\nindicted\n186:12\n\nhours\n149:8\n\nindividual\n\nhundreds\n\n190:20\n\n149:8\n\ninform\n196:21\nI\n\nidentification\n186:11\nidentified\n\nHey\n4\n\ninaccurate\n\nr's\n\n20\n\n15\n\nA3/41\n\n:23 192:7,\n\nincluded\n\n1 ,15 209:12,\n\nHafele\n\n9\n\n6\n\n(Cl\n44\nw,; /\n1\n4 ,6,11,\n\nH\n\n2:24 153:9\n\n186:15,23\n\nhear\n\n181:18 204:1\n\nin-camera\n\ninclined\n\n199:18\n\nguess\n\n170:13\n\nincarceration\n\n15,21\n\nhard\n\n163:14\n\nimpossible\n\n3,-\n\nhappy\n\n160:17 186:25\n\n164:2,6\n\n173:12\nhighlighted\n160:24\nhold\n147:19 203:12\nHoldings\n145:9\nhonest\n173:10\n\n182:10\n\ninforming\n175:25\ninherent\n157:2,5\n175:22 192:2\n194:20,21\n\nidentify\n175:3\nillegal\n146:24\nImagine\n196:23\nimplied\n\n195:4,5\n201:14,19\ninitial\n184:18 198:12\ninitially\n153:21 168:6\n169:19\n\n155:2,7\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734918\n\n\f", "char_count": 1470}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 268, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n\n12\n\ninquiry\n\nissues\n\n158:24\n\n182:9\n\ninspection\n\n183:1,2,14,18\n\n183:19\n\n185:2,19\n\n184:16,22\n\nitalics\n\n192:14 193:14\n\n187:1 188:9\n\n159:19\n\n194:14 198:20\n\n189:8,12\n\n191:23 192:7,\n\n200:22 201:6\n\n190:12,13,16,\n\n13\n\n202:20 206:6\n\n18 191:1,11,\n\n152:24 153:9\n\nJ\n\n205:6\n\n13 192:6,20\n\njudicial\n\ninstance\nJ17\n176:13\ninstances\n\n182:16 183:5,\n\n193:11 194:21\n\n8,24 185:6\n\n95:1,10,15,\n\n188:7 190:9,\n\n1 196:2\n\n159:8\n145:13\ninteraction\n156:4\n\nJane\n196:23\n\ninteractions\n196:8\n\nJeffrey\n190:18 192:6\n\ninterest\n\n198:16,17,19\n\nJuly\n166:1,3\n\n201:9 202:2,\n199:12,\n\n163:10\n\nJennifer\n\n67:16 178:23\n196:23\n\n165\n\n156:12\n\ne\n149:15\n156:22,25\n\ninvolved\n\n157:1,3,4,8\n\n189:9\n\n163:25 164:5\n186:13,15,24\n192:15,18,19,\n\nvo\n\ning\n\n1$1:21 187:11\nissue\n184:10,25\n185:22 186:1,\n\n158:2,4\n9 195:25\n201:12,22\n\njuries\n154:16 190:8\n\nJustice's\n195:25\n\njurisdiction\n\n190:13 192:7\n\ninvo\n\n200:17\n\n191:7\n\ninvestigation\n\n189:8\n\n152:23 156:17\n159:21 194:2,\n\njoint\n\ninvestigations\n\njustice\n\n179:10 197:10\n\n158:5\ninterruption\n\n:11 166:7\n\n145:7\nJoe\n\ninterpreted\n\n14 207:5\n208:25 209:3\n\n202:2\n\n181:19\n\n199:25 200:1\n\n176:18(198:24\n\n182:9 194:7\ninterpret\n\n:17\n\n16 191:8\n\n25 193:4,6,15\n209:7\njudge's\n164:22\n\n190:7\njurisdictional\n181:11\njurist\n193:7\njury\n\nknew\n186:3,4\nknowledge\n164:11\nKrischer\n\n150:20\n\n190:21 195:11\n\n154:12,19\n\n196:7\n\n155:20 158:6\n\nKrischer's\n\n159:9,12,20\n\n196:9\n\n161:9,20\njudgment\n\n24 194:18\n\n156:23 157:1,\n\n205:3 208:25\n\n10 159:1,4\n161:25 181:24\n\n162:6,17\n\nL\n\n172:2,14\n175:24\n182:14,17\n\nLago\n207:4\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734919\n\n\f", "char_count": 1553}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 269, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nlaid\n\n13\n149:15 164:1,\n\nlegislative\n\n195:16\n\n209:8\n\nlanguage\n\nletter\n\n154:25\n\n146:17 165:7,\n\n155:14,24\n\n15 166:16,17\n\n156:17 179:13\n\n167:12,16,21\n\n189:14 201:11\n\n170:3,4,14,\n16,23 171:4,\n\nLauren\n\n8,12,15\n\n145:6\n\n178:23\n\nlaw\n\n180:17,23\n145:13 168:8\n169:13 170:18\n172:3 183:17\n\n181:5 197:15,\n23 198:9\n200:17\n\n190:22,24\n198:16 209:7\n\nlimited\n\n5 192:25\n193:4\nMadam\n145:20\n186:19\nmade\n156:5,13\n161:16,22,24\n164:18,19,20\n170:8,13\n\n174:14,20\n\n205:2\n\n180:15,21\n\nlisted\n\n181:3,6,13\n\n203:\n\n183:23 185:14\n186:4 187:14\n196:24\n\n19 153:16\n\n192:8,\n\n4:23\n\n169:14\nlonger\nlay\n\n5es\n\n,\n\n206:1\nlead a\n\n181:16 184:23\n185:25 200:20\n202:13\nlooked\n191:5\n\n1\n\n:16 151:10\n\nlegal\n155:19 156:4\n169:9 192:10\n\nloop\n190:3\nlosing\n168:12,24\n\n195:17 204:24\nlot\nlegally\n\nmail\n\n161:20 162:7,\n17 172:2,23,\n25 173:1,5,6\n5 182:17\nority\n208:8\nmake\n\n208:15\n\n175:25 182:8,\n12,22 183:19\n184:16,22,23\n186:16 187:2\n\n148:15,17,18\n\n193:12 194:8\n\n154:10,11\n\n195:19 196:2,\n\n164:21 169:15\n\n11,13 197:1,\n\n173:22\n\n18 198:21\n\n157:16 171:4\n193:25\nmaking\n170:10 171:3\n178:8 181:15\nmanner\n179:20\nMark\n145:6\nMarx\n192:18,19\n193:6\n\n178:4 206:1,\n\n156:14 158:6,\n10 159:9,20\n\nmakes\n\nlawyer\n\n:24 151:1,\n\n12,15,17,\n\n159:7\nlist\n\nterials\n16,24 152:17,\n\nlimits\n\n149:9 154:1\n\n170:6\n\n184:9 185:1\n\nlaws\n\nlawsuit\n\n168:9,15\n\n176:18 180:2\n\n152:20,21\n155:8\n\nmaterial\n\nMarx's\n\n200:1 201:10\n202:2,14,18\nmath\n166:9\nmatter\n147:13 183:17\nmatters\n194:3,7\nmedia\n196:18,19\nmemo\n208:7\nMendelsohn\n145:11 146:6,\n\n17\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734920\n\n\f", "char_count": 1523}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 270, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n\n14\n\n11 154:21\n\n13 161:24,25\n\n158:12,14\n\n163:10,13\n\n153:15,17\n\n159:3 160:6\n\n164:10,24\n\n154:4,5,9\n\n161:11 162:10\n\n165:18,19,20,\n\n168:16 194:14\n\n163:8 169:5,\n\n21,25 176:14\n\n200:7,12,20\n\n25 173:21\n\n177:8,11\n\n205:18\n\n174:16 179:22\n\n180:2,25\n\nnegotiations\n\n181:19 185:1\n\n181:8,9\n\n146:16,22\n\n187:19 197:7\n\n183:7,14,15\n\n147:19,20,24\n\nneeded\n\n199:11,13\nNotwithstanding\n168:3\nNovember\n189:15 199:8,\n\n203:10 204:23\n\n184:2,6,9\n\n148:22\n\n205:4\n\n185:7,19\n\n203:13,20\n\nmention\n\n192:14,23\n197:8,9,15,\n\n199:11\n\n153:8 200:21\nmiddle\n\nnumber\n50:3 154:18\n65:2 171:5\n:10 177:19\n178:8 179:17\n\nneutral\n153:20\n\n16,22 198:20,\nmentioned\n\n19\n\n23,25 199:2,\n\nneutral\n\n4,7,10,14,18\n\n15\n\n193:20 201:5,\n18\n\n4\n\nO\n\n202:19 205:11\nobject\n\n166:23\nmove\nNike\n\n153:16,17,22\n\n149:5 153:13\n\n147:6,16\n\n154:21 169\n\n180,4R493:1\n\n158:9 173:13\n182:25 186:16\n\n189:19\n\n193:25\nminute\n\nC\n\n208:1\nminutes\n\nnewspapers\n183:14\nN\n\nnamed\n189:3,11,22\n\nmixin\n\n190:10,11\n\n18\n\n68.\nmoment\n204:10,12\nmonetary\n168:4\nmotion\n149:16 156:5,\n\n209:2\n\n153:20 164:14\nobjection\n146:25 147:21\n148:7 149:1\n11 205:10\n\n204:7\nobjections\nnon-objection\n\n164:18,19,22\n\n200:10 202:1\nobjects\n\n198:18 201:1\nion\n\nobjected\n\n169:8 200:10,\nnon-movant\n\n175:23 192:4\n204:13\n\n205:1\n\n148:21 157:16\n\nmoved\n\nmind\n\n154:4,5,9\n202:11 203:18\n\nnewspaper\n\n197:4\n204:10\n\n04:24\n\nNonetheless\n\n202:13 208:8\n\n182:12\nobligation\n\nnames\n188:19\n\nnonpossession\n\n209:8\n\n164:12\nobligations\n\nnaming\n198:11\n\nnotes\n\n175:20\n\n160:19 161:1,\nnarrow\n\n4 172:9\n\nobtaining\n183:3 185:4\n\n193:5 201:23\nnotice\n\n186:7 195:19\n\n177:20 196:3\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734921\n\n\f", "char_count": 1602}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 271, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n\n15\n\nobvious\n\nopening\n\n191:8\n\n164:2\n\noccur\n\noccurred\n185:20\noccurs\n\nparties\n\n153:18 194:24\n\n155:18 175:20\n\n195:2 200:9,\n\n176:3 188:8,\n\n204:2 209:5\n\n19\n\n23 191:25\n\n184:23\n\nOctober\n\nopposing\n\n153:23\n\n198:21\n\n177:21,24\n\n162:19\n\n194:24\n\n175:18,22,24\n\nopposes\n\n159:15\n\nparticipate\n\n145:9 152:16\n\nopportunity\n\n163:17\n\nPalm\n\n192:5,8 196:1\npaper\n\nparty\n177:8 180:15\n185:10,25\n\n148:13,18\n\n07:7 209:2\n\n175:7 177:11\n\nIs\n\n186:17\n168:12,24\n\nopposition\nparagraph\n\n179:8,9\n\n185:19 199:25\n\n200:15 202:6\n\n202:17\n\npast\n150:3,6\n\n165:15\n\n152:10\noffense\n\noption\n\n169:24\noffer\n\noral\n186:13\n\n146:22\n\n162:13\n\npending\n\n6 :5,11,12,\n\n147:19\n\nt:\"\n\n,24 169:18\n\norder\n\npendency\n\n160:18\n\n154:10\n\n148:6\noffered\n\n154:13,\n\n151:18,21\n\n149:15 16\n\n171:11,15,22\n\n158:6 184:6,8\n\n172:14\n\n182:19 188:1,\n\n187:7,10\n\n149:24 150:15\n\n22,23\n\n3,18,19,21\n\n201:23 203:14\n\n153:21 154:10\n\n19\n\n189:4,5,25\n\n147:19 148:23\noffice\n\n161:17 163:16\n\n190:1,4\n\n0\n\n170:11 174:6\n\n6 202:3,\n\n193:23 195:21\n\n188:11,25\n196:1,4,9\n197:18\nofficia\n\nparagraphs\n\norders\n207:25 209:10\noriginal\n\n150-\n\n189:25 190:4\n\n18\n\n199:2,14\noriginally\n200:10\n\n1\n\n:18 209:2\np\n\n197:9\n\n159:14\nopened\n\n189:2\nparalegal\n145:7\nparentheses\n158:2\npart\n146:14,15\n\none-page\n\nopen\n\n191:2,16\n\n147:15 148:4,\n\npenultimate\n171:20,21\npeople\n186:11\n206:17,18,20\nperformance\n164:3\nperiod\n179:25\npersonal\n164:10\npersons\n155:21\n\n5,22 150:10\np.m.\n\n163:14 181:16\n\n145:2 204:14,\n\n186:1 187:7,\n\n15 209:20\n\n10 194:2\n\nphone\n147:13,17\nphrase\n158:4 194:10\n\n147:23\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734922\n\n\f", "char_count": 1541}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 272, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\nphysical\n\n16\n145:10\n\n172:2\n\n151:20,21\n\npin\n178:17\n\npreviously\n146:24\n\n192:11\n\n152:17,22,25\n\nprimary\n\nproposed\n\n156:6 162:19\n\n190:14\n\n175:18,22\n\nplaintiff\n\n176:3 187:6,\n11 191:25\n\nplanning\n\n192:8 196:17,\n\n206:10\n\n149:15 150:17\n\nprosecuted\n\n152:25 153:9\n\n146:24\n\n195:17 199:19\n\np osecution\n\n25 199:22\n\nplea\n\n200:3,6,14,16\n\n194:6\n\n201:8\n\npoint\n\nprivate\n\n55:22\n\n193:9,10\n\n14 204:2\n\n163:15 175:4\n194:5\n\nportions\n\npower\n\n146:16 194:13\n\npr\n\nect\n\n198:1\n\n198:19\n\nproblem\n\nprotection\n\n181:7\n\n198:17\n\nprocedur\n\nprotector\n\npotential\n\n171:14 200:6,\n\n165:21 207:25\n209:10\n\nprior\n\n145:10 177:20\n\n18 185:3\n\n190:25\n\n191:11\n13\n\nposition\n\nprovide\n\npowers\n\n153:20,22,23\n154:2 178:25\n179:4,6\n\n154:19\n\nceeding\npractice\n154:23 1\n\n180:11,14,16,\n\n183:5,\n\n21 181:1,3,4\n182:4,7,13\n\n•\n\npreen\n\n160:2,7\n170:13 172:4\n\n159:14 167:7\n\n181:12 184:18\n\n182:24 184:8\n\n197:25 205:22\n\n190:18 198:16\nproceedings\n\n184:11,14,21\n\n145:2 150:20\n\n197:24 199:24\n\n188:10 189:12\n\n200:2 202:17,\n\n5.22\n\n207:6\n\n19\n\npare\n\nprocess\n\nprovided\n152:2\nprovision\n160:16 167:11\n201:6\n\n206:22 207:9\n\npossession\n\nprovisions\n190:16 194:21\n161:6 172:11\n\n149:19\n\nprepared\n\n150:1\n\n206:8\n\n16\n\n:6,\n\nAre\n\n1\n\n.4.2 188:12,\n\n195:15\npublic\nproduce\n182:11\n\n159:16\n\nprohibit\n\n187:2 192:9\n\npresence\n\n172:21\n\n194:7 195:1\n\n145:4\n\nprohibiting\n\n196:4,13,16,\n\n189:23\n\n190:11 192:20\n194:19 197:17\n\n198:7,9,13\npossibly\n186:19\n\n175:1 176:1\n\nprescribed\n\npresent\n159:16 184:11\npresented\n168:6 169:19\n175:24 177:10\n\nPost\n\n174:5\nprohibits\n172:3\nproper\n153:25 183:3,\n\n186:8,16,17\n\n17,18,20,21,\n23 198:22\npublisher\n145:9\npull\n\n192:5\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734923\n\n\f", "char_count": 1635}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 273, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n\n17\n\n189:17\n\nquotes\n\npurpose\n\n158:2\n\n155:23 158:11\nR\n\n175:25\npurposes\n\nraise\n\n181:11\n\n185:23,24\n\npursuant\n\nraised\n\n155:16 161:10\n\n205:4\n\n172:15 175:21\n208:13,15\n\n192:1\n\n192:21\n\n168:10\n\nrecoverable\n\nreasoned\n\n208:17\n\n193:7\n\nredact\n\nreasons\n\n175:3\n\n171:13 200:17\n\nredacting\n\nreassess\n\n186:18\n\n184:15\n\ndirect\n\nrebuttal\n\nrate\n\n188:8,10\n\nreasonable\n\n57:20 172:8\n\n203:6,8\n204:20 205:\n\neferenced\n\nrates\n\nput\n149:12 162:1\n179:20 203:11\n\nrecall\n\n208:12\n\n147:12 156:\nre-evaluated\n\n161:12\n\n200:3\n\nputting\n\n198:8\ni\n\nreferring\n164:17 166:14\n167:13,17\n\nread\n\n147:24\n\n179:6 181:9\n\n155:15 157:24\n\n:22\n\n158:21 159:5\n\nQ\n\n160:20 161:\nquestion\n\n162:14,1\n\n151:3,13\n\n163:22\n\n164:9 173:8,\n15,16,24\n\n167:\n\n168\n\ness\n\n172:18\n\n209:16\n\nrejected\n\nrecognize\n\n171:9\n\n165:6,17\n171:8\n\n168:\n\nrelationship\n159:21\n\n178:5,6,10\n\n9\n\n179:18,20\n\n9 185:3\n\n205:6\n\n152:25 153:9\n\n7:21 188:3,\n\nreconsider\n\n159:19 183:19\n\n180:20 183:21\n186:6 197:2\n\n7:6\n\nrefers\n\n21 191:18,24\n\nrecollection\n\n204:20 205:13\n\n193:1,19,23\n\nquestions\n181:20\n\n87:13\n\n197jL\n\n2\n\n21\n\n201:21 207:5\nreading\n\nrecord\n\n158:4\n59:21,22\n\n158:1 172:6\n182:5 201:21,\n23\n\n183:7 194:2,9\n\nreal\n\n204:14\n\n202:14,18\n\nquoted\n150:18 154:14\n\nrecords\n160:19 161:4\n172:10\n\n182:9\nreason\n\n186:15 198:21\n199:25\n\n164:3 170:12\n\n16:12 167:2\n\n184:21,23\n\n164:1,20\n150:1 157:22\n\ngu t\n\nrelease\n\n173:12,13\n174:1,11,18,\n\nreleased\n161:8 172:13\nreleasing\n202:1\nrelevant\n205:11\n\n21,24 182:18\nrelief\n\n166:11,23\n\n151:24 166:10\n\n183:4 184:4\n\n170:23\n\n170:24 190:14\n\n185:5 186:7\n\n195:17 198:11\n\n187:10 190:12\n\n161:18 170:5,\n17 177:15\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734924\n\n\f", "char_count": 1612}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 274, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n192:10 200:22\n\n18\nresearch\n149:8,11\n\nremain\n\nRules\n\n158:3 159:8,\n\n182:15 183:24\n\n161:6,7\n\n155:11,25\n\n200:3\n\n159:24\n\nremember\n147:9 169:13\n\n168:11 170:23\n\nS\n\n172:11,12,15,\n\nresolution\nsafe\n\n194:5\n\nremoved\n\n18 175:21\n\n165:22 199:21\nresources\n\n186:11\n\n196:21\n\nrepeat\n\nrespect\n\n149:22\n\n12,16,18\n\nsafe-harbor\n\n177:9 188:9,\n10 190:6\n\n179:25 180:5\n\n92:2,15\n\n181:8,12\n\n94:2\n\n181:14 193:6\n\nreply\n184:19 204:5\n\nrespectfully\n\nsanction\n\nsethsrities\n\n162:18\n\n155:8\n\n175:19 191:25\n\nreport\n\n146:8\n\n168:4\n\nrested\n\n196:2\n\n:23\n\n204:7\n\nholz\n\nrepresentations\nresult\n\n168:14\n\n1\n\nrequest\n153:16,19\n\n145:13\n?<: >\nI '\n\nreveres\n\n152:19 159:8\nscratch\n\n174:17 187:9\n\n149:16\n171.4 175:2\n6:19\n\nrequested\n151:1,16,24\n2:6\n\n164:3\n19\n\nrights\n175:19\nrole\n182:21,24\nrule\n\n4\nredneste\n175:19 192:1\nrequired\n182:17\nrequires\n159:17 183:6\n\n158:20 182:15\n183:2,5,8,15,\n24 184:3,5,\n12,20 185:5,\n\n150:24\n151:16,20\n152:17,24\n153:7,8,10\n\nscope\n\n161:8 172:13\n192:13\n\n193:11 197:1\n\nseeking\n\nrests\n\n146:23\n\n151:23 184:15\n201:9\n\n204:2,9\n\nreporter\n\n185:6\n\n77:\n\nclikr,\n197- ,1\n\nreported\n\n161:19\n\nseek\n\nsanction\nresponded\n\n195:25\n\nscreen\n188:15\nseasoned\n193:6\nseated\n\n158:5,10\n162:18 169:1\n177:8 183:7\n185:7\nseeks\n152:18\nsense\n159:22 194:10\nsentence\n\n145:3 204:16\n\n150:17 152:13\n\n208:18\n\n158:21 159:5\n\nsecrecy\n\n160:18,25\n\n154:12 182:14\n\n162:15 171:25\n\n195:1 198:18,\n\n182:3 183:12\n\n19\n\n187:21\n\n11,13,18\n186:4 193:4\n\nsecret\n196:2\n\nruled\n193:5\n\nsection\n152:22 155:8\n\nserved\n177:9,16\n178:3,11,13,\n19 180:22\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734925\n\n\f", "char_count": 1545}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 275, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n\n19\n\n181:5,8,10\n\n160:2,22\n\n197:9\n\n162:12 165:5,\n16 170:10\n\nservice\n\n182:1\n\n155:12 173:25\n\nstamped\n\n175:1 200:13\n\n162:10\n\n171:14 172:7\n\n177:11\n\nstatement\n\nstamps\n173:20 174:6\n\nset\n183:4 185:5\n189:10 197:22\n199:1,6,14\n\nstanding\n\n164:1,6,8,15,\n\nstart\n146:13 171:21\n\nskipping\n\nsettle\n\n169:5\n\n148:14\n\n146:16,19,22\n147:18,20,22,\n\nsocial\n161:1 (16:\n:\n0)\n194:10\n171:15 23\nsolely\n190:11\n\n203:13,16,20\n\nsolemnly\n\n204:21\n\n145:25\n\nsex\n\nsought\n\n192:6\n\n151:1\n\nshared\n\nsound\n\n196:1\n\n166:3\n\nSharon\n\n/S\n\nAS\n\n,20\n\n5 :21\n\n157:7 161:7\n162:18 163:16\n164:11 170:9\n\n185:9,10,16,\n\nshow\n\napes\n\n150:4 160:23\n167:14\n\n147:12\nspecifically\n\nsic\n\n78:10\n\n189:3,7,11\n\n181:19 188:9,\n10 189:6\n191:5,10,13\n192:1 193:11\n194:22 195:6,\n13 197:25\n198:2 201:10,\n11,21,24\n\n190:7,10,15,\n203:21\nstatute's\n\n170:20\n\n21 194:5,18,\n\n166:23\n\n23,25 195:2,\n\nStatutes\n\n7,9,18 196:8\n\n190:7\n\n197:18 198:7,\n\nstatutory\n\nspoke\n\nspoken\n\nstamp\n\n8,11 199:1,\n\nSTENOGRAPHER\n7,15,18,25\n201:25 202:4\n\n152:2 165:4,\n\n207:6 209:4\n\n15 166:20\n175:10 176:17\n\n154:24 179:12\n\n23,24 200:2,\n\n150:2,8 151:6\n\n151:8,14\n157:18,20\n\n20 188:7\n\n179:2,15\n\n10,14 192:3,\n\n149:14 150:10\n152:8 154:7\n\n175:21 177:3\n\nspecifics\n\n147:8\n145:19,22\n\n172:22 174:5\n\n21,25 191:7,\n\n16:17\nsir\n\n168:20 169:7\n\n155:4\n\n147:15,18\nsiwultaneously\n\n150:18 154:15\n\n4:10,16,18\n\n19,21 177:21\n\n188:22\n\nstatute\n\n167:3,14\n\n172:1,3,5,12,\n\nape\n\n155:3 195:22\n\n157:2,6\n\nstate\n24 148:13,22\n\n9,20 203:9\nstates\n\nstarts\n152:13 160\n\nsettlement\n\n172:9 202:9\nstatements\n\n201:9\nsituation\n159:20 189:9\n\n200:16\n\n164:2,13\n\n151:7\n\n202:23,25\n208:23\n\n201:25\n\n158:15\nstep\n154:7\n\nstated\n149:7 154:13\n\nStephen\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734926\n\n\f", "char_count": 1669}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 276, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n145:10 146:6\nstipulated\n208:4,7\n\n20\nsued\n\nSupreme\n\n153:15 184:4\n\n155:3 184:15\n\n146:8 153:15,\n\n188:11,24\n\n195:8 201:20\n\n22\n\nsufficient\n\nStop\n173:23\nstrong\n157:16 193:25\nsubdivision\n\nsurrounding\n\n207:14,16\nsuggest\n\nsuggested\n\nsubject\n\nsuggesting\n156:24 165:21\n\n150:17 188:13\n\n195:12\n\n208:7,22\n\nsummary\n\n155:17 157:22\n158:1 159:7\n166:13 167:4,\n8,9,14,20\n\nsubsections\n\nti\n\n195:5 201\n\nsup ficilede\n\nThomson\n\n160:3,4\n162:10 171:5\n\n163:15,16\ntied\n201:22\n\n175:10,12\n176:13 177:19\n181:24\n\ntime\n147:18 149:12\n163:3,24\n\nise\n9:7\n\nsubstance\n\n198:16\n\n146:241\n\nsupplement\n205:18,19\nsupplemental\n160:8 206:10\nsupport\n\nsuccessful\n\n153:19\n\n156:19\n\nsupported\n\nsuccessor\n\n170:5\n\n190:21\n\nsupposed\n\n190:19\n\n180:9 206:20\n\nthought\n:13,15\n\ntalk\n\nsupervision\n\nsue\n\nC\n\n179:17,19\n\n145:7\n\n192:14 198:2\n\n168:3\n\n:10\n\nthings\n153:18 178:4\n\n168:20 177:4\n179:15\n\n145:23 146:\n\n14 185:19\n\nsuperior\n\n76:4,7 192:4\n:22\n\n161:25 183:2,\n\n202:19\n\n155:20 159:9,\n13 175:23\n\n145:20,25\n\n191:1\n\n169:14\n\nsubsection\n\ntestimony\n\nsystem\n\nsuing\n\nsubmitted\n\n207:7 209:4\n\nsustained\n\nsworn\n\n149:20,25\n\nsubpoenaed\n\n158:22\n\nswear\n\n148:12,15\n\ntestifying\n\n194:4\n\n148:8 149:3\n\n175:6\n\n161:6\n\n189:1 193:13\n\ntestified\n\n184:3\n\n208:14\ntalked\n146:18 167:18\ntalking\n148:1 173:23\ntandem\n158:3\ntangent\n197:2\nteam\n195:19 204:24\ntelling\n156:22\nterrific\n207:12\n\n184:11 185:9,\n17 187:7\n196:8,21\n199:19 202:8\n205:16,19\n206:22 207:9,\n20 208:9\ntimes\n146:19\n161:16,23\ntoday\n198:3 205:21\ntold\n166:3\ntop\n159:5 182:2\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734927\n\n\f", "char_count": 1529}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 277, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n\n21\n\ntranscript\n\nunambiguous\n\n163:22\n\n154:24\n\n192:18,19\n207:18\ntranscriptions\n160:19 161:5\n172:10\nTraurig\n145:8\nTravel\n208:9\ntreat\n183:13\ntrial\n158:18 206:19\ntrue\n146:14,18,21\n147:5,17\n149:7,17,22\n\nuncertain\n184:14\nunclear\n201:17\nunderlying\n187:5\nundermined\n195:20\nunderstand\n173:3,9,19\n\n175:11,18\nV\n\n24\nverbatim\n162:21\n\n145:5,6,18\n146:25 147:21\n\n173:12 180:5\n\n187:18\n\n195:20\nview\n184:8\n\n4\n\n:8 :15,17\n89:18,20\n1 7:6 202:21,\n24 203:1,7,\n\nviews\n181:19\n\n15,23 204:3,7\n205:1,10\n\nvia-A-v\n\n206:8,12\n\nunderstanding\n\n207:5,14,15,\n\n154:24\n\n21 208:6,10,\n\nunderstands\n\n200:10\n\n170:1\n\n20,24 209:13,\n18\n\nced\n200:10\n\n155:3\n\nwhichever\n206:6\n\n161:15 162:4\n\nunlimit\n\n170:4 186:7\n\n151:\n1\n\nW\nwanted\n\ntruth\n\n148:22 154:6,\n\n146:2,3\ntionably\n4:3\n\n189:21 193:14\nunquote\ntwofold\n\n149:1 169:8\n\nvictim\n\n150:22 153:14\n\nturning\n\nWhetstone\n\nversus\n\n197:19\n\nUnited\n\n191:17,19,20,\n\n194:3\n\n173:15\n? ‹;;.,\nunsigned\n165:21\n\n12 157:4\n\nwithdraw\n177:15\n179:14,16\n186:2\n\n175:7 178:17\n\nwithdrawn\n\n191:19 192:22\n\n177:13\n\n194:14 204:4\n\nwitnesses\n\nWeatherby\n208:22,23\nweek\n\n175:4\nwords\n186:15\n\nunsupported\n170:17\n1,5:25 196:8\n201:7\nUh-huh\n152:6 176:15\nultimately\n195:15\n\n206:24\n207:11,13,14,\n\nuntrue\n\n15\n\n148:9\nweeks\nutilize\n\n207:23,24\n\n193:11\nwhatsoever\n155:23\nwherefore\n\nworth\n186:21\nwraps\n167:7\nwrite\n148:13 206:9\nwriting\n205:19\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734928\n\n\f", "char_count": 1384}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734651", "page_number": 278, "text_content": "Judge Luis Delgado\nSeptember 08, 2022\n\n22\n\n206:17,21\nwritten\n147:7 154:25\n205:23 206:5,\n14,23 207:25\nwrong\n169:17 170:20\nWyler\n145:12,13,14,\n19 146:10,12\n147:2,4,23\n148:3,10\n149:4 150:9,\n12 158:25\n159:2 160:3,\n\no\nG\n\n5,12,14\n163:4,7\n169:10,16\n181:14\n187:12,21\n191:18 192:17\n193:1,19\n197:14 198:6\n203:3,6,9,22,\n25 204:19\n205:7,14,22,\n25 206:24\n207:11,19\n208:2!\neS\n209:1 ,\n\nye@terday\n264:22\n\nzealously\n182:12\n\nwww.phippsreporting.com\n(888) 811-3408\n\nEFTA02734929\n\n\f", "char_count": 462}]}