{"efta_number": "EFTA02734396", "page_count": 11, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02734396", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02734396.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02734396", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Filing # 136506318 E-Filed 10/13/2021 04:53:44 PM\n\nIN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE\nFIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND\nFOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA\nCA FLORIDA HOLDINGS, LLC,\nPublisher of THE PALM BEACH POST,\n\nCASE NO.: 50-2019-CA-014681-XXXX-MB\nDIVISION: AG\n\nPlaintiff,\nv.\n\nDAVE ARONBERG, as State Attorney of\nPalm Beach County, Florida; SHARON It\nBOCK, as Clerk and Comptroller of Palm\nBeach County, Florida,\n\nE O SA\n\nDefendants.\n\nc\n\nPLAINTIFF CA FLORIDA HOLDINeCLL S REPLY IN\nFURTHER SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR SUMMARY\nJUDGMENT AND INCORPORATED MEMORANDUM OF LAW\nI.\n\n\\\n\nI N\n\nThe Clerk does not dispute any,4e 7 statements of fact set forth in The Palm Beach\nPost's Motion for Summary Jud\nthat it may not, without a court\nas The Palm Beach Post\ncomplaint. And\nclaims tha\n\nag\n\nad, the Clerk belabors the uncontested point of law\nlease the Jeffrey Epstein grand jury records. That is correct,\nledged at the June 2020 hearing on the motions to dismiss its\n\nwhy it is before this Court — to obtain such an order. The Clerk further\naware of any authority or standing granted to its office to advocate for or\nof any grand jury materials,\" but then proceeds for 23 pages of its Opposition\n\nto argue that this Court should deny The Palm Beach Post's request to release the grand jury\nrecords. This position represents a complete about-face from its position at the June 2020 motion\nto dismiss hearing, during which it unequivocally stated that it was \"not trying to block acrecs to\nthe records.\" Appendix at 13 (June 3 Hearing Transcript at 18:23-19:5).\n\nGreenberg Trautig, P& • 401 East Las Olas Boulevard, Suite 2000 • FL Lauderdale, Florida 33301 • Tel 95,1.765.0500 • Fax 954.765.1477 • www.ttlaw.cont\n\nFILED: PALM BEACH COUNTY. FL\n\nABRUZZO, CLERK, 10/13/2021 04 53 44 PM\n\nEFTA02734396\n\n\f", "char_count": 1776}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734396", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case No.: 50-2019-CA-014681-MCC-MB\nReply In Further Support of Motion for Summary Judgment\n\nMore remarkably, the Clerk wrongly asserts that \"[t]he specific subject matter of the\nunderlying grand jury proceedings is irrelevant to th[e] preliminary question concerning the\nlegality of The Palm Beach Post's suit against the Clerk.\" Opp. at 2 (emphasis added). The\nunderlying subject matter of the grand jury records sought is precisely what allows for their\nexceptional release and what justifies this Court's exercising its discretion to ord\n\nu lic access.\n\nThe underlying subject matter is thefundamental basis for the relief sought\n\ne Palm Beach\n\nPost. The undisputed facts support the Court's exercise of its discretio\n\nthe Clerk of this\n\nCourt to release the Jeffrey Epstein grand jury records.\nII.\n\nUNDISPUTED FACTS & PRO\n\nThe Palm Beach Post's Motion identified 76\n\nHISTORY\ncts, relying on evidence such as\n\npolice reports, sworn deposition testimony, cot\n\ni pscripts, and a voluminous United States\n\nDepartment of Justice inquiry into the mis an\n\nof the Epstein prosecution — a report which\n\nwas compiled after \"review[ing] m\nEpstein, including sealed plea\nAppendix at 3 (OPR R\nThe Clerk\n\nIs to\n\nmg to the state investigation and prosecution of\nd jury transcripts, and grand jury audio recordings ... \"\n\np. 2\ndress a single one of these 76 facts. Instead, it characterizes the\n\ncomprchensi\n\naDgssertions as \"somewhat slanted and argumentative.\" Opp. at 4. The Clerk\n\ndoes no\n\nich of the factual assertions were \"somewhat slanted and argumentative,\" in\n\nwhat way t y were \"somewhat slanted and argumentative,\" or to challenge the evidence on which\nany of the facts were based. The Clerk, though, attempts to dispute the material facts — again\nwithout identifying any fact in particular — by stating in a footnote that The Palm Beach Post's\nassertion that the material facts are uncontested is \"clearly not accurate.\" Opp. at 3 n.4. The Clerk's\nvague argument is deficient.\n2\nGreening' Traurlg, P\n... [truncated, 2145 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734396/1 or ?id=EFTA02734396&page=1]", "char_count": 2145}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734396", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case No.: 50-2019-CA-0146814COCC-MB\nReply In Further Support of Motion for Summary Judgment\nBecause the Clerk's commentary should be disregarded, its intentional avoidance of the\nevidence means that The Palm Beach Post's facts are undisputed. Under Florida Rule of Civil\nProcedure 1.510(a), \"[t]he court shall grant summary judgment if the movant shows that there is\nno genuine issue as to any material fact and the movant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law.\"\nIn Florida, the moving party no longer needs to conclusively disprove the nonmo\n\ntheory of\n\nthe case in order to eliminate any issue of fact. See In re Amendments to Fla.\n\nCiv. P. 1.510,\n\n309 So. 3d 192, 193 (Fla. 2020). Rather, \"the burden on the moving\n\ndischarged by\n\n`showing'—that is, pointing out to the I] court—that there is an absen\n\nidence to support the\n17, 325 (1986). Then, the\n\nnonmoving party's case.\" Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 47\nnonmoving party \"must do more than simply show th\nmaterial facts.\" Matsushita Elec. Indus. Co. v.\nalso\n\n7-48 (1986) (\"[T]he mere existence of some\nnot defeat an otherwise properly supported motion\n\nfor summary judgment; the req\n\nthat there be no genuine issue of material fact.\"). Under\n\nthis standard, The Palm B ch Post\nthat the law suppo\nc\n\nleas\n\nfills the first summary judgment prong. Below, it will show\n\nf the Epstein grand jury materials.\nIII.\n\nA.\n\nio Corp., 475 U.S. 574, 586 (1986); see\n\nv. Liberty Lobby, Inc., 477 U.S.\n\nalleged factual dispute between the\n\nARGUMENT\n\n0 IS INAPPLICABLE\n\nR\nCo\n\nome metaphysical doubt as to the\n\nry to the Clerk's argument, Rule 2.420 of the Florida Rules of Judicial\n\nAdministration is inapplicable. Rule 2.420 establishes procedures for maintaining the\nconfidentiality of certain records and granting public access to non-confidential records. It lists 23\npresumptively\n\nconfidential\n\ncategories,\n\nwhich\n\ninclude\n\ngrand\n\njury\n\nmaterials.\n\nRule\n\n2.420(d)(1)(3Xxvi). For records not automatically confidential, Rules 2.420 (e), (0, (g) and (h)\n\n... [truncated, 2169 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734396/2 or ?id=EFTA02734396&page=2]", "char_count": 2169}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734396", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case No.: 50-2019-CA-0146814COCC-MB\nReply In Further Support of Motion for Summary Judgment\ninclude procedures to determine confidentiality. Poole v. South Dade Nursing & Rehab. Ctr., 139\nSo. 3d 436, 440 (Fla. 3d DCA 2014). As grand jury materials are automatically confidential, they\ndo not fall within the procedures of subsections (e), (f), (g), and (h). Further, the Epstein materials\nare not \"trial court records in non-criminal cases\" subject to subsection (e). Nor are they \"trial\ncourt records in criminal cases\" subject to subsection (f), which is limited to motio s ade by the\n\"state, a criminal defendant or an affected non-party.\" None of these requires\n\ntha Rule 2.420 is the\n\nThe Clerk's citations to subsections (j), (I), and (m), and its\nexclusive method to seek grand jury materials, are also inaccurate.\nterm \"must\" for subsection (j), that subsection expressly s\nto confidential court records may be obtained by filth\nrule assumes an on-going criminal or civil actio\n\npresent.\n\ngh the Clerk uses the\ncourt order allowing access\n\nmotion.\" (Emphasis added). That\nng \"court records.\" Rule 2.420(b)(1)(A).\n\nAs the Clerk alleges that grand jury matt\n\nN\" ministrative records,\" Rule 2.420(b)(1)(8),\n\nthey are not included in subsection\n\ne Clerk's argument refutes itself.\n\nThe Clerk further mi\n\nzes subsection (1) by claiming that \"an action for\n\nmandamus\" is the only p\n\ns for seeking administrative records. However, subsection (I) states\n\nthat while an acti\n\ndamus may be brought, so may \"other appropriate relief.\" And,\n\nsubsection (I)C\n\nfor\ne\n\nms to instances where a party is seeking \"expedited review,\" which is not\n\nsought*\nSim arly, subsection (m) does not create a condition precedent for seeking grand jury\nmaterials. Subsection (m) merely provides that where a request is made for documents, it must be\nin a reasonable manner and in writing to the custodian. Nowhere does subsection (m) make these\nactions a condition precedent to suit. In any event, this lawsuit fulfills th\n... [truncated, 2292 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734396/3 or ?id=EFTA02734396&page=3]", "char_count": 2292}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734396", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case No.: 50-2019-CA-0146814COCC-MB\nReply In Further Support of Motion for Summary Judgment\n\ntheir production.\nFinally, the Clerk's reliance upon Times Publishing Co. v. Ake, 660 So. 2d. 255 (Fla. 1995),\nis misplaced. Ake did not address grand jury materials nor Fla. Stat. Section 905.27. It merely holds\nthat the Florida Public Record Act is not applicable to requests for judicial databases while Rule\n2.420 is applicable.\nB.\n\nA DECLARATORY JUDGMENT ACTION IS PROPER\nThe Clerk complains that this declaratory judgment action is im\n\nIt is well-settled that where constitutional or statutory rights are in dis\naction is appropriate. Rosenhouse v. 1950 Spring Term Gran\nHildebrandt v. Dep't. of Nat. Resources, 313 So. 2d\n\ndeclaratory judgment\nSo. 2d 445, 448 (Fla. 1952);\n\n3d DCA 1975). Ironically, the\n\nClerk ignores its previously relied-upon Ake\n\na clerk brought a declaratory judgment\n\naction to determine the applicability of Rule\n\nthe Florida Public Record Act. The Clerk's\n\nopposition to The Palm Beach Pos,\n\nto Epstein grand jury materials also proves the\n\nrelevance of this declaratory ju\nC.\n\nTHE CLERK\n\nIn its\n\ni PLICITLY CONCEDES THAT THE PALM BEACH POST HAS\nPUBLIC ACCESS TO THE EPSTEIN GRAND JURY\n\nn,\"%4e Palm Beach Post argued that it has standing under Section 905.27. See\n\nMotion at\n\n. This is a related — but separate — issue from whether Section 905.27 provides\n\na private n\n\nt of action. The Clerk addresses the latter argument, but aside from acknowledging\n\nthat \"The Post's Motion repeats the same arguments about its alleged standing ... that it alleged\nin the Amended Complaint and which it argued in its Opposition to the Clerk's Motion to Dismiss\n\nIn a case discussing a clerk's role as custodian of grand jury materials, a federal court observed that a clerk is a\nproper party to receive a subpoena for state grand jury materials. Whiffler v. Clay ofSunrise, No. 07-60476, 2007\nU.S. Dist. LEXIS 114239, at •12 n.4 (S.D. Fla. Aug. 22, 2007).\n5\nGreenberg Trautle, PA. ■ 401 E\n... [truncated, 2136 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734396/4 or ?id=EFTA02734396&page=4]", "char_count": 2136}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734396", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case No.: 50-2019-CA-0146814COCC-MB\nReply In Further Support of Motion for Summary Judgment\n\nCount II\" (Opp. at 14 n.10), does not address The Palm Beach Post's standing arguments or the\nauthorities supporting standing. Similarly, in granting the State Attorney and Clerk's motions to\ndismiss Count II of the Amended Complaint, former Chief Judge Marx relied on arguments that\nthere is no private right of action under Section 905.27, but did not address the threshold standing\narguments In ignoring the First Amendment bases supporting The Palm Beach P st standing,\nthe Clerk implicitly concedes that The Palm Beach Post has standing to purst\n— whether that be under the private right of action implicit in Section 9\nbelow), under the Constitution, or by invoking the Court's inherent a\nD.\n\nFLA. STAT. SECTION 905.27 CREATES A PR\nAt all times in this proceeding, The Palm Beach\n\ndoes not explicitly create a private right of a\n\nrelief it seeks\nlaborated further\n\nand discretion.\nAUSE OF ACTION\n\nknowledged that Section 905.27\nno excessive boldfacing, italicizing, or\n\nunderscoring is necessary on that undispu\n\nint. See Opp. at 17. But that does not end the\n\ninquiry, as former Chief Judge\n\nowledged in her June 2020 Order. See June 3,\n\n2020 Order at 3-4.\nWhere there is n expres\nprimary factor3 tha\ni\nv. N. Sinha C)\n\nost\nt c\n\nght of action in a statute, legislative intent has become the\n\nrts rely on to determine whether a cause of action exists. See Marshy\n\nSo. 2d 983, 985 (Fla. 1994). Given the dearth of legislative history\n\nNotably in this regard, during the hearing on the motions to dismiss, former Chiefludgc Marx stated, \"I don't think\nanybody is saying that there isn't a cause of action [under Section 905.27] or that the press doesn't have standing.\"\nAppendix at 13 (June 3, 2020 Hearing Transcript before the Honorable Krista Marx (\"June 3 Hearing Transcript\")),\nat 8:2-4; see also 8:7-8 (\"nowhere have I said there isn't a cause of action.\"); 15-16 (\"So I'm not telling you, you\ndon'\n... [truncated, 2842 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734396/5 or ?id=EFTA02734396&page=5]", "char_count": 2842}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734396", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case No.: 50-2019-CA-0146814COCC-MB\nReply In Further Support of Motion for Summary Judgment\n\nsurrounding the enactment of Section 905.27, it is appropriate to consider acts passed at other\nlegislative sessions.° Fischer, 543 So.2d at 790. In 1994, at the same time Section 905.27 was\nreenacted to expressly provide three exceptions to grand jury secrecy, including furthering justice,\nthe Florida legislature also reenacted Fla. Stat. § 905.395, which concerns the secrecy of statewide\ngrand juries. 1994 Fla. ALS 285, 1994 Fla. Laws ch. 285, 1994 Fla. SB 114; Fla.\n\nat. § 905.395.\n\nLike Section 905.27, Section 905.395 has a general prohibition on disc\n\nof grand jury\n\nproceedings, absent a court order. Fla. Stat. § 905.395. Tellingly, how\n\non 905.395 does\n\nnot provide any specific exceptions to nondisclosure. Through the i\n\nnal omission of these\n\nexceptions, including the fundamental \"furthering justice\"\nlegislature did not intend for court-ordered disclosu\njustice, and did not anticipate such disci\nlegislature's decision to include the catchicf\n1\nreflects an intent to protect and info\nsystem — by providing a m\nlegitimacy of the grand j\na private right of\nChapter 900 Cy\n\ns ionr i\n\n¶\n\nit can be understood that the\nde grand jury records to further\n\nId benefit the public. By contrast, the\nering justice\" exception in Section 905.27\n777777\n—\"' the ultimate benefactors of the criminal justice\n\ncess in those rare situations where the integrity and\n\nrocess have been called into serious question. Accordingly, implying\nnsistent with the purposes underlying the legislative scheme in\n\nlo da Statutes.'\n\nNeither the Clerk nor Judge Marx addressed or challenged this analysis.\nThere arc a number of cases where litigants have sought grand jury materials under Section 905.27 and its\npredecessors with varying degrees of success. In none of these cases did the court question or hold that the statute\ndid not create a private right of action. See State cc rel.\nv. Dewell, 167 So. 687, 689-90 (Fl\n... [truncated, 2610 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734396/6 or ?id=EFTA02734396&page=6]", "char_count": 2610}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734396", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case No.: 50-2019-CA-0146814COCC-MB\nReply In Further Support of Motion for Summary Judgment\n\nE.\n\nSECTION 905.27, THE FIRST AMENDMENT, AND THIS COURT'S INHERENT\nPOWER CONSTITUTE THREE INDEPENDENT GROUNDS FOR RELEASING\nTHE GRAND JURY RECORDS\nAs set forth in The Palm Beach Post's Motion, even in the absence of Section 905.27's\n\nstatutory framework, disclosure is appropriate pursuant to this Court's inherent authority over\ngrand jury proceedings because of the exceptional public interest in this case and\n\nmpelling\n\ncircumstances supporting transparency rather than continued secrecy.\nUnlike the cases the Clerk cites for the proposition that \"more th\nabout what the grand jury records may contain is needed to lift the vet\noverwhelming and undisputed evidence before this Court\nabout what the grand jury records may contain. B\n\ne or speculation\"\ny (Opp. at 21), the\n\"surmise or speculation\"\n\njust one example, during his\n\ninvestigation of the Epstein sex crimes, the DepS\nt , hie of the Criminal Division of the U.S.\nAttorney's Office told Criminal Chief Matt e\ncase] in the grand jury so it was b\ncannot credibly maintain that 7'Ce a\n\nh\n\nchel: `The state intentionally torpedoed [the\n\nQ 3.' Appendix at 3 (OPR Report, p. 26). The Clerk\neach Post has not laid a \"proper predicate\" (Opp. at 22),\n\nfr)\n\nor that the relief it seeks i based o 'surmise or speculation.\" The Palm Beach Post does not deny\nthat it bears the bu\nS\nthat the extra\nregardin\n\n'\n\nn of\n\ntifying this exceptional release of grand jury records, but maintains\n\ntd serial criminal acts at issue, and the evidence already publicly revealed\nisconduct in prosecuting Epstein, has \"satisfactor[ily] establish[ed] [its] right\n\nto its use.\" ate v. Tillett, 111 So. 2d 716, 724 (Fla. 2nd DCA 1959).\nThe Clerk does not dispute that this Court has the inherent power to release the records,\nonly that it should not do so because such release would conflict with other laws. It does not. First,\nas set forth above, the release of grand jury re\n... [truncated, 2317 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02734396/7 or ?id=EFTA02734396&page=7]", "char_count": 2317}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734396", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case No.: 50-2019-CA-0146814OOOC-MB\nReply In Further Support of Motion for Summary Judgment\nstatutory provision that serves as an exception to the secrecy of grand jury records. Third, because\nThe Palm Beach Post is not seeking these materials \"for use in a criminal [or civil] case,\" the\nlimitations on its use of those materials (i.e., \"only ... in the defense or prosecution of the civil or\ncriminal case and for no other purpose whatsoever\") is not so limited. See Fla. Stat. § 905.27(2).\nIn sum, The Palm Beach Post has constitutional standing to request the\n\ne of the\n\nEpstein grand jury records, and such request should be granted in the furtherati;tfjus ice.\nIV.\n\nCONCLUSION\n\n0\nC\n\nThe Palm Beach Post respectfully requests that this Court, p\n905.27(1) and the Court's inherent authority, order the Cle\ncopies of the testimony, minutes, and other evidence\ngrand jury during the first Epstein sex ab\n\nIt to Fla. Stat. Section\n\nourt to lodge with this Court\n2006 to the Palm Beach County\n\nlion so that, following an in camera\n\ninspection, it can be made available to The\n\nch Post and the public.\nespectfully submitted,\nGREENBERG TRAURIG, P.A.\nAttorneysfor CA Florida Holdings, LLC,\nPublisher of The Palm Beach Post\n\n+6s\n\nStephen A. Mendelsohn, Esq.\n401 East Las Olas Blvd., Ste. 2000\nFort Lauderdale, Florida 33301\nTelephone: (954) 768—8225\nFacsimile: (561) 338-7099\nBy: a/Stephen A. Mendelsohn\nSTEPHEN A. MENDELSOHN\nFlorida Bar No. 849324\nmendelsohns®gtlaw.corn\nsmithlegtlaw.com\nFLService@gtlaw.com\nBy: /s/ Michael J Grygiel\nMICHAEL J. GRYGIEL\n9\n\nGreenbefg 'fraud& PA. • 401 fast Las Olas Beulevard,Suae 2000 • Ft. Lauderdale, Ftodda 33301 • Tel 954.765.0500 • Fax 954.765.1477 •\n\n*WO elaw tom\n\nEFTA02734404\n\n\f", "char_count": 1716}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734396", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Case No.: 50-2019-CA-0146814000C-MB\nReply In Further Support of Motion for Summary Judgment\n(Admitted Pro Hac Vice)\n54 State St., 6th Floor\nAlbany, New York 12207\nTelephone: (518) 689-1400\nFacsimile: (518) 689-1499\ngrvaielmegtlaw.com\nBy: /s/ Nina D. Boyajian\nNINA D. BOYAJIAN\n(Admitted Pro Hac Vice)\n1840 Century Park East, Ste. 1\nLos Angeles, California 90\nTelephone: (310) 586-7\nFacsimile: (310) 586—\nbovai iann(agtlaw.co\nriveraal\nlaw\n\nis)\n\n10\nGreening Trawl& PA. • 401East las Olas Boulevard, kite 2000 • Ft Lauderdale. Honda 33301 • Te195a.765.0500 • Fax 954.165.1477 • wend 40aw cam\n\nEFTA02734405\n\n\f", "char_count": 604}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02734396", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Case No.: 50-2019-CA-0146814COCC-MB\nReply In Further Support of Motion for Summary Judgment\nCERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\nI HEREBY CERTIFY that on this 12th day of October, 2021, a true and correct copy of\nthe foregoing has been filed with the Clerk of the Court using the State of Florida e-filing system,\nwhich will send a notice of electronic service for all parties of record herein\n\n40:Ar\n/s/ Stephen A. Mendelsohn\nSTEPHEN A. MENDELS\n\nAC77VE 80572600v7\n\n11\nGreenberg Trawl& PA. • ICI East Las Olas Boulevard, Sukte 2000 • Ft Lauderdale. Honda33301 • Te1954.765.0500 • Fax 954.165.1477 • wend elaw tom\n\nEFTA02734406\n\n\f", "char_count": 615}]}