{"efta_number": "EFTA02732754", "page_count": 21, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02732754", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02732754.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02732754", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Filing # 104805004 E-Filed 03/12/2020 04:17:41 PM\n\nIN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE\nF1141 EENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR\nPALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA\nCA FLORIDA HOLDINGS, LLC,\nPublisher of THE PALM BEACH POST,\n\nCASE NO.: 50-2019-CA-014681-XXXX-MB\nDiv.: AG\n\nPlaintiff;\nv.\nDAVE ARONBERG, as State Attorney of\nPalm Beach County, Florida; SHARON R.\nBOCK, as Clerk and Comptroller of Palm\nBeach County, Florida,\n\nCO SA\n\nDefendants.\n\nPLAINTIFF'S OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT\nATTORNEY OF PALM BEACH COUNTY,\nCOUNT II OF THE FIRST\nPlaintiff CA Florida Holdings, LLC,\n\nC\n\nONBERG, AS STATE\nS MOTION TO DISMISS\nCOMPLAINT\n\nThe Palm Beach Post (\"The Palm Beach\n\nPast) files this opposition to Defendan\n\na\n\nMotion to Dismiss Count II of The\n\nch Post's First Amended Complaint (\"Motion\"):\n\nI.\n\nnberg, State Attorney of Palm Beach County's\n\nY OF ARGUMENT\n\nThe State Attorney btieyes this action to be \"frivolous.\" Motion at 13. Far from it. This action\nis an opportunity\nsordid and\n\ninstitution of the State of Florida to exercise its authority, not to shield the\nbut instead to further justice and restore the public's confidence in the criminal\n\njustices,\nThe State Attorney pushes the general rule of grand jury secrecy too far. The State Attorney\ndoes so by arguing that Florida Statute § 905.27 does not allow The Palm Beach Post to seek relief\nunder that statute, and even if it did, disclosure of the grand jury records in furtherance of justice\ncannot solely be made for purposes of informing the public. The State Attorney also appears to argue\n\nFILED: PALM BEACH COUNTY. FL. SHARON R BOCK. CLERK, 03/12/2020 04:17:41 PM\n\nEFTA02732754\n\n\f", "char_count": 1620}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02732754", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "that the Court lacks the inherent authority and supervisory powers over the grand jury to order such\ndisclosure. Motion at 12.1 Both arguments fail.\nThe Palm Beach Post has sufficiently pled the existence of its right to maintain an action under\nSection 905.27, as it does so for the benefit of the public and consistent with the general legislative\nscheme. The Palm Beach Post has the right to use the grand jury materials to inform the ublic, which\nis consistent with Section 905.27.\nThe Palm Beach Post has further stated a claim that either together W\nl\nSection 905.27, the Court has inherent authority to order the release\ne\nexercise of such authority is regularly made for purposes as v •\n\nependently of,\nl\njury records. The\n\noting court efficiency to\n\nproviding transparency for the judicial system.\nThe Palm Beach Post has therefore stated a c\nthe Court's inherent powers by which this Courtpia\n\n%O f\n\noth Section 905.27 and pursuant to\n\ne release of the grand jury records sought\n\nin this action.\nII. tt\nThe facts underlying th\nAnswer of Clerk. Indeed, t\n\nacti\n\nrl, BACKGROUND\nare largely uncontested. See Answer of State Attomey;\n\nnow largely a matter of public record as a result of the extensive\n\nlegal proceedings\n\ng out of the various crimes of Epstein and his co-conspirators over the course\n\nof more than\n\ne. While the complete factual allegations are set forth in the First Amended\n\nCompla.\nA.\n\nmary of the relevant facts is set forth below.\n\nFirst Epstein Sex Crimes Investigation, Indictment, and Plea Agreement: 2005 - 2008\nThe investigation into Epstein's sex crimes began more than fifteen years ago, when a 14-\n\nI\n\nThe State Attorney also contends that it is \"not in custody or control of the records sought.\" Motion at 12. Whether\nthe State Attorney possesses custody or control over the records is a disputed issue of fact that cannot be determined\nat the motion to dismiss stage.\n\n2\n\nEFTA02732755\n\n\f", "char_count": 1925}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02732754", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "year-old girl's stepmother reported to police in the Town of Palm Beach, Florida, that Epstein and\nothers who worked for him arranged for her to give Epstein a \"massage.\" Epstein required the girl to\nstrip, exposed himself, and masturbated while touching her. The girl was paid $300. Epstein was 52\nyears old at the time. First Amended Complaint (\"FAC\") ¶ 11.\nFollowing this initial report in 2005, the Town of Palm Beach Police, and later in 2006, the\nFBI, investigated Epstein. Interviews under oath with five additional alleged victitseventeen\nwitnesses revealed that the events described by the I4-year-old girl occurred,O\ndetails, with each of the other victims. Id.1 12.\nc5\nBoth the victim/witness interviews, as well as eviden\nEpstein's home, showed that some of the girls involved w\nof Epstein's residence also found two hidden cameri \\n,\nnude photos of girls, including victims whom\n\nR\nos)\n\n(4\n\ntrie\n\nrbingly similar\n\nfollowing a search of\n\ne age of 18. The police search\n\nh ughout the house, large numbers of\n\n8,4i had not interviewed in the course of their\n\ninvestigation. Id. 1113.\nIn March 2006, a State gran\ntestify. The proceeding was pos\nand Epstein's prominent c\n\ncheduled at which all of the victims were expected to\nwever, due to meetings between the State Attorney's office\n\ndefense lawyer and personal friend, Alan Dershowitz. Id.1 14.\n\nAnother grand jury<vric\ncony ed in April 2006, but canceled the day before it was to begin receiving\nevidence. Id.1\n\na\nPolice Chief Reiter's Letter to the State Attorney\n\n14.\n1‘\nOn May I, 2006, Town of Palm Beach Police Chief Michael Reiter wrote a \"personal and\nconfidential\" letter to then Palm Beach County State Attorney Barry Krischer, stating:\nI must renew my prior observation to you that I continue to find your office's treatment of\n[the Epstein] cases highly unusual. It is regrettable that I am forced to communicate in this\nmanner, but my most recent telephone calls to you and those of the lead detective to your\nassigned attorne\n... [truncated, 2092 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02732754/2 or ?id=EFTA02732754&page=2]", "char_count": 2092}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02732754", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "much thought and consideration, I must urge you to examine the unusual course that your\noffice's handling ofthis matter has taken and consider if good and sufficient reason exists\nto require your disqualificationfrom the prosecution ofthese cases. (Emphasis supplied)\nId.¶ 16.\nChief Reiter's letter to State Attorney Krischer enclosed the Town of Palm Beach Police\nDepartment's probable cause affidavits charging Epstein and two of his assistants with multiple\ncounts of unlawful sex acts with a minor and one count of sexual abuse, and requesl6i at either an\narrest warrant be issued for Epstein or the State Attorney directly initiate tJ>uges against him,\nwhich would be public. Id.117.\n2. The July 2006 State Grand Jury Presentatiq\nInstead, State Attorney Krischer elected to refer theme\nfor capital cases but rarely used for all other crimes.\n\n•\n\nd jury, which is mandatory\no an official spokesperson, this was\n\nthe first time that a sex crimes case was presentyd,'S„ rtd jury in Palm Beach County. M.1 18.\nIn July 2006, after State Attorney\nvictim, the grand jury returned an i\nno mention in the indictment of\nsupposed to testify before l\nprovided as to wh\nvictims to the\nprovid\n\nsche\n\nresented testimony and evidence from just one\n\nn a sole count of solicitation of prostitution. There is\nbeing a minor. Id.119. Another of Epstein's victims was\n\nd jury, but did not. M. ¶ 20. No reasonable explanation has been\n\ne num rous other known victims were not presented as witnesses and crime\nconvened in July 2006. M. ¶ 21. Nor has any reasonable explanation been\n\nhy State Attorney Krischer, who was initially eager to investigate and prosecute\n\nEpstein for his crimes, over time lost the desire to do so. M.\nDuring the grand jury appearance of the single victim who testified, the State Attorney\npresented evidence that vilified the victim and attacked her credibility, including soliciting testimony\nregarding underage drinking and questionable personal behavior that was unrelated to the charges\na\n... [truncated, 2124 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02732754/3 or ?id=EFTA02732754&page=3]", "char_count": 2124}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02732754", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "office by Epstein's defense counsel. Id.\n3. The FBI's Investigation and Epstein's Non-Prosecution Agreement\nWith Federal Authorities\nFollowing the deficient July 2006 indictment, and with Chief Reiter's encouragement, the FBI\nbegan its own investigation of Epstein. Id. ¶ 23. Records unsealed in 2015 revealed that the FBI\ncompiled reports on \"34 confirmed minors\" that were victims of Epstein's sexual pred$tions. Based\non evidence gathered by the FBI, a 53-page indictment was prepared by the U ‘\nin June 2007. Id. ¶ 24. However, at the request of Epstein's lawyers, t\n\ntto\nc\n\ny's Office\n\nent was never\n\npresented to a federal grand jury. Id.\nInstead, then U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of\na plea deal with Epstein's team of lawyers to grant imm\n\nAlexander Acosta, negotiated\n(along with four named co-\n\nconspirators and any unnamed potential co-conspigal\n\nall federal criminal charges. Id. ¶ 25.\n\nThroughout the remainder of 2007 and through the fi\n\nhalf of 2008, Epstein's lawyers and the U.S.\n\nAttorney continued negotiating the plea arrangement. Upon information and belief, Epstein's lawyers\ninsisted that (1) the victims not bpt of\n\nf(2) the deal be kept confidential and under seal, and (3)\n\nall grand jury subpoenas (includald.ahe that had already been issued for Epstein's computers) be\nwithdrawn. Id.1 26.\nOn June\n\n2\n\nEpstein pled guilty to State charges: one count of solicitation of prostitution\n\nand one co\n\nitation of prostitution with a minor under the age of 18. He was sentenced to 18\n\nmonths in j\n\nfollowed by a year of community control or house arrest, and was adjudicated as a\n\nconvicted sex offender required to register twice a year in Florida. Id. ¶ 27.\nThe plea deal, called a non-prosecution agreement (\"NPA\"), allowed Epstein to receive\nimmunity from federal sex-trafficking charges that could have sent him to prison for life. Public\nrecords reveal that former State Attorney Krischer communicated with then U.S. Attorney Acosta\n\n5\n\nEFTA02732758\n\n\f", "char_count": 1988}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02732754", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "concerning the NPA's negotiation with Epstein's lawyers. Id.1 28.\nIndeed, Epstein was not incarcerated in a Florida prison for the State crimes for which he was\nconvicted. Instead, he was placed in a private wing of the Palm Beach County Stockade, where, after\n3 12 months, he was allowed to leave the jail on \"work release\" for up to 12 hours a day, 6 days a\nweek. His private driver provided his transportation to and from \"work.\" Id. ¶ 29. Epstein was also\nknown to have violated the terms of his probation, but was not prosecuted. Id.\nreleased five months early. Id. ¶ 30.\n\nwas then\n\ng\n\nFollowing publicity exposing the extraordinary leniency of the\nwere brought against Epstein, most of which Epstein's lawyers\n\nozens of civil suits\nf-court. Id.1 34.\n\n4. The Crime Victims' Rights Act Litiea\nDuring the course of the Town of Palm Beac\ninvestigators to follow, harass, and photograph\n(\n\nI, vestigations, Epstein retained private\n\nta' ti\n\nS\nand the Town of Palm Beach detective w lRr\n'....y\nves\n\nc\n\nand their families, as well as Chief Reiter\n\nted the case against Epstein. Id. ¶ 36. Epstein's\n\nvictims were threatened against c\n\nt'\n\ncompensated only if they did no\n\nto with law enforcement. Id.1 37.\n\nTo add insult to inj\ncourt and filed an\nRights Act (1\nthe right\n\nwith law enforcement and told that they would be\n\ntein's victims only learned after the fact about his plea deal in State\npetition to force federal prosecutors to comply with the Crime Victims'\n\n3771, \"CVRA\"), which mandates certain rights for crime victims, including\nformed about plea agreements and the right to appear at sentencing. U.S. District\n\nJudge Kenneth A. Marra ruled in 2019 that federal prosecutors violated the CVRA by failing to notify\nEpstein's victims before allowing him to plead guilty to only the two State offenses. Id. ¶ 32. The\nprosecution's failure to keep the victims apprised, among other things, also contravenes the Florida\nConstitution, Article I, § 16(b) and Fla. Stat. § 960.001.k/1133.\n\n6\n\nEFTA02\n... [truncated, 2009 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02732754/5 or ?id=EFTA02732754&page=5]", "char_count": 2009}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02732754", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "B.\n\nSecond Epstein Sex Crimes Investigation, Indictment, Suicide: 2019\nOn July 6, 2019, Epstein was arrested on federal sex trafficking charges. Id. ¶ 38.\n\nThe United States government's prosecution of Epstein based on new allegations and charges\nstemmed, in part, from continued press investigations and reporting on the mishandling of the 2006\ncharges and the civil suits that followed. Id. ¶ 39.\nIn a July 8, 2019, letter to the federal district court by the U.S. Attorney for the4iikhern District\nof New York, Epstein was described as \"a serial sexual predator who preyed\nover a period of years.\" The letter emphasized that \"the Government h\npast experience with this defendant — that if allowed to remain out\nto pressure and intimidate witnesses and potential witnes\nfamilies, and otherwise attempt to obstruct justice.\" It\nEpstein's Manhattan townhouse: evidence of\n\nt\nlls„\n\nt\n\nbat\n\ns of minor girls\nems — grounded in\ndefendant could attempt\n\nincluding victims and their\nd the results of the FBI's search of\n\ng in the form of \"hundreds—and perhaps\n\nthousands-of sexually suggestive phot\n\nphs\n\nunderage females. In a locked safe,\n\n'scs were found with handwritten labels including the\n\ndescriptions: \"Young [Name] +\nOn July 8, 2019, pri\nthe Southern Di\n\nof N\n\nac\n\nf fully- or partially-nude females,\" including\n\narea, \"Misc nudes 1,\" and \"Girl pies nude.\" Id. ¶ 40.\nors with the Public Corruption Unit of the U.S. Attorney's office for\n\nYork charged Epstein with sex trafficking and conspiracy to traffic\n\nminors for se\n\nTh\n\nd jury indictment alleges that \"dozens\" of underage girls were brought into\n\nEpstein'\n\nns for sexual encounters. A few days later, owing to public outcry over the NPA with\n\nEpstein entered into by the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of Florida, Alexander Acosta, who\nby then was serving as U.S. Secretary of Labor in the Trump administration, resigned from office. Id.\n¶41.\nOn or about August 6, 2019, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis ordered a state criminal probe\n... [truncated, 2123 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02732754/6 or ?id=EFTA02732754&page=6]", "char_count": 2123}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02732754", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Epstein underage sex trafficking case. Id.1 43.\nOn August 20, 2019, Epstein was found dead, by apparent suicide, at the federal Metropolitan\nCorrection\n\nCenter\n\nin\n\nlower\n\nManhattan\n\nwhere\n\nhe\n\nwas\n\nbeing\n\nheld\n\nwithout\n\nbail.\n\nId. 11142, 44.\nThe August 27. 2019. SDNY Henri ne: Enstein's Victims Sneak\n\nC.\n\nCI\n\nFollowing Epstein's death, prosecutors sought to dismiss the indictment aga\nmaintaining that they would continue to investigate his co-conspirators. Id.\n\n•ted\n\nDistrict Judge Richard M. Berman ordered a hearing on August 27, 201\nto\n\ndismiss\n\nthe\n\nindictment\n\nand\n\nallowed\n\nId. ¶ 46.\nIn the course of the hearing, more than two d\npain, frustration, and sexual abuse at the hands\nEpstein. Many more victims were present •\nWhile some questioned the\n\nvictims\n\nwhile\nStates Senior\n\nsecutors' decision\nat\n\nthe\n\nhearing.\n\nS\n\nic it4 delivered their personal stories of\n\n. Several victims spoke of violent rape by\n\ne\n\nm but did not testify. Id. ¶ 47.\n\nhind the court's decision to give the victims voice after\n\nEpstein's death, Judge Berman\n\nted\n\n\"a public hearing is [the] preferred vehicle of resolution,\"\n\nemphasizing that \"public Irs •\n\nare exactly what judges do. Hearings promote transparency and\n\nthey provide the co\n\nwith • ights and information which the court may not otherwise be aware of\"\n\nIndeed, even\n\n's efense lawyer noted at the hearing that the court \"is the institution that most\n\npeople\n\nrdence in, in these very troubled times.\" Id. ¶ 48.\nAt the August 27th hearing, the girls, now women, spoke about their \"exploitation and\n\ncoercion,\" and to the fact that many of them \"were in very vulnerable situations and in extreme\npoverty, circumstances where [they] didn't have anyone on [their] side, to speak on [their] behalf....\"\nOne victim lamented that \"as a victim, [she] never got to see what the agreement was or why the\nspecial treatment got approved\" in the Florida case years earlier. Another noted how \"completely\n8\n\nEFTA02732761\n\n\f", "char_count": 1961}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02732754", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "different\" the investigators leading to the 2019 federal indictment were from the prosecutors in the\nFlorida case, both in their treatment of her and their investigation of her victimization by Epstein. Id.\n¶ 49. A former federal judge in attendance at the August 27th hearing emphasized that \"transparency\nis one of the overriding objectives in our criminal justice system.\" Id. ¶ 50.\nNearly all of the victims expressed the conviction that the secrecy that shielded Epstein has\ncaused them \"irreparable harm\" and that an opportunity to address his criminal wron\nof the individuals who enabled his sexual racketeering, would allow for\njustice to be served after his death. Indeed, one victim stated: \"Any e\nname and legacy send a message to the victims that he wins\nvictim expressed fear that this is a world \"where there are q\n\nme measure of\nto protect Epstein's\n\nat\nat\n)0\n\ns and those\n\nis untouchable.\" Another\n\nn power, a world where people\n\ncan avoid justice if their pockets run deep enough.\" /\nIn short, the \"unusual\" treatment Epstei\n\n' Florida in 2006 based on his wealth, social\n\nstatus, and connections severely eroded\n\npub 's faith in the integrity and impartiality of the\n\ncriminal justice system. Allowing T\n\nach Post's claims to proceed in this action would allow\n\nfor public examination and and\nI pa,,p, III.\nA.\n\nLEGAL ARGUMENT\n\nLe al Sta\nFla. R.\n\na short\n\nof the operation of the criminal justice system in Florida.\n\n1.110(b) provides that a pleading that sets forth a claim for relief shall contain\nstatement of the grounds of the ultimate facts showing that the pleader is entitled to\n\nrelief. Fla. R. Civ. P. 1.110(g) permits a party to \"set up in the same action as many claims or causes\nof action ... as the pleader has, and claims for relief may be stated in the alternative.\" The Rule further\nprovides \"[a] party may also state as many separate claims or defenses as that party has, regardless of\nconsistency and whether based on legal or equitable grounds or both.\" Fla. R. C\n... [truncated, 2037 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02732754/8 or ?id=EFTA02732754&page=8]", "char_count": 2037}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02732754", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Here, The Palm Beach Post brings two claims: one pursuant to Fla. Stat. § 905.27, and one for\ndeclaratory relief based on the principles set forth in Section 905.27 as well as constitutional principles\nof freedom of the press as protected by the Court's inherent authority and supervisory powers. The\nState Attorney concedes that the declaratory relief claim is adequately plead. For the same reasons\nrequiring that concession—and those set forth below—the Court should, respectfully, find that both\nclaims have been sufficiently plead.\nB.\n\nRelevant Legal Framework: Fla. Stat. ti 905.27\nCO\n\n1. Grand Jury Secrecy Is Not Absolute\nTypically, grand jury proceedings are conducted and ma'\nc\nBut this secrecy has never been—and was never intended t\ngrand jury proceedings are already subject to public\nfree to disclose her grand jury testimony. In ic\nB\nweighing the competing interests of grand •\nSection 905.27's purported prohibit'\n(1990).2 The \"secrecy\" of grand\n\n•!‘ed\n\nS\n\nsecret. Fla. Stat. § 905.24.\n\nute. First, as a practical matter,\ns, , as a testifying grand jury witness is\n\nlos r„ .M, the United States Supreme Court,\n\nsec\n\ny and the First Amendment, held unconstitutional\n\nfitness revealing her own testimony. 494 U.S. 624, 626\nFlorida is thus qualified — not absolute — based on principles\n\nembodied in the First Ame\nSecond, S\ntestimony of\ndisclo\n\n2\n\n90 .27(1) specifically provides exceptions to grand jury secrecy: \"the\ns examined before the grand jury or other evidence received by it\" may be\n\nrequired by a court ... for the purpose of: (a) Ascertaining whether it is consistent\n\nThe Florida Supreme Court has similarly confirmed that grand jury secrecy is not absolute and that any \"harm to\npublic officeholders\" from disclosure will be the product of their own conduct, and not the consequence of an\nunrestrained body ofmisguided citizens.\" MiamiHeraldPub. Co. v. Marko, 352 So. 2d 518 (Fla. 1977). The decision\nin Marko emphasized that a grand jury's important role in \"expos[ing) of\n... [truncated, 2524 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02732754/9 or ?id=EFTA02732754&page=9]", "char_count": 2524}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02732754", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "with the testimony given by the witness before the court; (b) Determining whether the witness is guilty\nof perjury; or (c) Furthering justice.\" Fla. Stat. § 905.27(1Xa)-(c). The Florida legislature therefore\nclearly intended to empower a court to order the disclosure of grand jury proceedings to, among other\nthings, further justice, as this Court should do here.\nSubsequent to such disclosure, The Palm Beach Post is not, as the State Attorney argues,\nconstrained by the statute from using the materials for public disclosure—nor coup\n\nunder the\n\nFirst Amendment.; Motion at 13. The State Attorney argues that \"grand j\n\no y `can only be\n\nused in the defense or prosecution of the civil or criminal case and for n\n\nse whatsoever'...\"\n\nt\n\nMotion at 12-13. But that limitation only applies \"[w]hen such disctI; ) re\nto subsection (1)for use in a civil case.\" Fla. Stat. § 905.27\nt e\nPost is not asking the Court to order the disclosurei\nrather, it seeks disclosure for the express r\njustice by allowing the public, through th\n2. The Pahn Reach\nThe Palm Beach Post\nfurtherance of justice, an e\n\nSIT\n\n7 rts\n\nLanding\nht\n\nd\n\ny\n\nrdered by a court pursuant\n\nadded). Here, The Palm Beach\nrecords \"for use in a civil case;\"\n\nth in Section 905.27(1XO—i.e., to further\n\nhe Palm Beach Post, access to this information.\nUnder Section 905.27\n\nto maintain this private right of action because the\n\negislative exception to grand jury secrecy, is intended for the public\n\nbenefit, and The\n\nBe ch Post seeks access on behalf of the public it serves. Fla. Stat.\n\n§ 905.27(IXc) It is\n\nrt er mandated in Fla. Stat. § 905.27 that the legislature intended for a court to\n\nbe the\n\nake the determination of disclosure. Fla. Stat. § 905.27(1). In other words, the\n\nlegislature granted the courts the power to consider and determine the propriety and scope of grand\n\n3\n\nIn this regard, the State Attorney's interpretation of Section 905.27 would render the statute a prior restraint, \"the\nmost serious and the least tolerable i\n... [truncated, 2404 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02732754/10 or ?id=EFTA02732754&page=10]", "char_count": 2404}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02732754", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "jury secrecy.\nThe Supreme Court of the United States has \"recognized that the invocation of grand jury\ninterests is not \"'some talisman that dissolves all constitutional protections.\" Butterworth, 494 U.S.\nat 630-31 (quoting U.S. v. Dionisio, 410 U.S. 1, 11 (1973)); see also Landmark Communications, at\n838 (balancing state's interest in preserving confidentiality of judicial review proceedings against\nrights of newspaper reporting on such proceedings).\nAs explained in the FAC\n\n(¶y 56-59), the Supreme Court has further( ecocized that the press\n\nhas a constitutional right of access to criminal proceedings, see, e.g., tc n ncnVewspapers, Inc. v.\nVirginia, 448 U.S. 555, 573 (1980), including pre-trial crimina\n,4 ;44 eeaRfp.\n\nv. Graddick,\n\n696 F.2d 796 (11th Cir. 1983). 'Indeed, \"the integrity of th\n\nis\n\nrocess, which public scrutiny is\n\nsupposed to safeguard, is just as much at issue in prpCre\n\nf this kind [pre- and post-trial] as at\n\ntrial.\" Id. at 801; see also Miami Herald Publ.? S\n\nri\n.\n\n, 426 So. 2d 1, 6-7 (Fla. 1982) (identifying\n\nthe news media as a \"public surrogate\" inAtt.....,\ners\n\ncerning the closure of judicial proceedings). The\n\npress also has a First Amendment ' cp\ne tt receiving information from willing speakers. See Va.\nState Bd. of Pharmacy v. Va. Ci ens\n\nsource and to its\nSupreme Cou\nwishing l\n\nafforded [by the First Amendment] is to the communication, to its\nh.\"); Pittman v.\n\n267 F.3d 1269, 1283 n.12 (11th Cir. 2001) (\"The\n\nM,\n\na speaker exists . .. the p\n\nnsumer Council, Inc., 425 U.S. 748, 756-57 (1976) (\"Where\n\ngnized that the First Amendment offers protection to both speakers and those\nre speech.\"); see also Stephens v. Cty. ofAlbemarle, VA, 524 F.3d 485, 492 (4th Cir.\n\n2008) (providing that a plaintiff has \"standing to assert a right to receive speech\" by \"show[ing] that\nthere exists a speaker willing to convey the information to her\").\nBecause of the unique role performed by the press as a \"public surrogate\" (=,\n\n426 So. 2d\n\nat 6-7) in protectin\n... [truncated, 2099 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02732754/11 or ?id=EFTA02732754&page=11]", "char_count": 2099}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02732754", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "proceedings, news organizations \"presumptively have a right to access judicial records,\" Comm 'r, Ala.\nDep't of Corr. v. Advance Local Media, LLC, 918 F.3d 1161, 1166 (11th Cir. 2019), and \"standing to\nquestion the validity of an order restricting publicity because its ability to gather news is directly\nimpaired or curtailed.\" M,\n\n426 So. 2d at 4; see also Carlson v. United States, 837 F.3d 753, 757-\n\n58 (7th Cir. 2016) (\"[a]s a member of the public, [the Reporters Committee] has standing to assert [its]\nclaim\" to grand jury materials because such materials are \"public records to which t\naccess, even if that effort is ultimately unsuccessful\").\n\nc may seek\n\nACt\"\nBeach Post on behalf\n\nHere, the continued denial of access to information sought by\nof its journalists and the public \"unquestionably constitutes irre\nV\n\n1\n\nCare, LLC v. State of Florida, 210 So. 3d 1243, 1263 (Fla c\n\ne also Zerilli v.M, 656 F.2d\n\n) ,\n\nury.\" Gainesville Woman\n\n705, 711 (D.C. Cir. 1981) (noting that \"the press'\n/S itti\ns '43\nv as a vital source of information is\nweakened whenever the ability of journalists to\n( s Ars\nh , e,\nrefusal to disclose unredacted report\n119and\n\nis impaired,\" as it is by Attorney General's\n\nlyin grand jury materials).\n\nd\n\nthat Section 905.27 makes no express provision for a\n\ncivil suit or civil liability, but tha 's jus\n\ne start of the inquiry. In determining whether a private right\n\nThe Palm Beach Post does\n\nof action lies in a statute,\n\nn Florida consider: (1) whether the plaintiff is one of the class for\n\nwhose special ben\n\nthe st\n\nimplicit, of a I\n\ne mtent to create or deny such a remedy; and (3) whether judicial implication is\n\nconsiste\n\nto was enacted; (2) whether there is any indication, either explicit or\n\ne underlying purposes of the legislative scheme. Fischer v. Metcalf, 543 So. 2d 785\n\n(Fla. 3d DCA 1989) (adding the second and third factors; previously, courts considered solely the\n\"class benefited\" factor). \"Courts must strike a balance; neither `fashionin\n... [truncated, 2262 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02732754/12 or ?id=EFTA02732754&page=12]", "char_count": 2262}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02732754", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Roger Rankin Enters., Inc. v.M, 433 So. 2d 1248, 1250 (Fla. 3d DCA 1983);\n\nv. Piezo Tech.\n\nand Prof! Adm'rs, 427 So. 2d 182, 184 (Fla. 1983) (Supreme Court of Florida implied a statutory\ncause of action for the wrongful discharge of employees who sought workers' compensation benefits).\nConsideration of these three factors weighs in favor of finding a private right of action in\nSection 905.27. First, the statutory exception to grand jury secrecy embodied in Sec 'on 905.27 —\n\"furthering justice\" — is intended to benefit the public at large, not just those prey\ngrand jury proceeding at issue. Because, as set forth above, members\nsurrogate[s]\" (=,\n\n426 So. 2d at 6-7) and play a vital role in gathe\n\nSecond, there is a dearth of legisle\n\nation and reporting\n\n.\n\naide, 561 So. 2d 1319 (Fla. 4th\n\nS n:,to cause of action as the persons the\n\nDCA 1990) (finding plaintiffs \"had the right to mai\nlegislature intended to protect by the enactment\n\ns, are \"public\n\nclan or whose especial benefit\n\non the criminal justice system, The Palm Beach Post is \"one of\nthe statute was enacted\"—namely, the public itself. See MRQa\n\ng1\n\narty to the\n\ne\n\nevant statute).\n\ntisto surrounding Section 905.27, and The Palm Beach\n\nPost was unable to locate any do\n\nring any legislative intent regarding the possibility of a\n\nprivate right of action. There is\n\nlit statement in favor of such a right, but to be clear, there is\n\nalso no intent—express or\ndisclosure of gran\nvessel. See M\ncase of\n\nise—prohibiting a private right of action, in the absence of which\nals to \"further justice\" under the statute would be rendered a hollow\n\n61 So. 2d at 1320 (\"The absence of express provision for civil liability in the\nf a statute does not negative the existence of a legislative intent that the statute shall\n\neffect private rights.\") (quoting Florida Statutes, Section 475.482 (1989)).\nIn such circumstances, consideration of the third factor — whether judicial implication is\nconsistent with the underlying purposes of the le\n... [truncated, 2178 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02732754/13 or ?id=EFTA02732754&page=13]", "char_count": 2178}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02732754", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "subsequent sessions. Fischer, 543 So. 2d at 790. In 1994, at the same time Section 905.27 was\nreenacted to expressly provide for the three exceptions to grand jury secrecy, including furthering\njustice, the Florida legislature also reenacted Fla. Stat. § 905.395, which concerns the secrecy of\nstatewide grand juries. 1994 Fla. ALS 285, 1994 Fla. Laws ch. 285, 1994 Fla. SB 114; Fla. Stat. §\n905.395. Like Section 905.27, Section 905.395 has a general prohibition on disclosure of grand jury\nproceedings, absent a court order. Fla. Stat. § 905.395. Tellingly, however, Sectio\n\n95 does not\n\nprovide any specific exceptions to nondisclosure, including the fiwtheran\n\ni e. Through the\n\nintentional omission of these exceptions, including the fundamental \"\n\ntice\" exception, it\n\ncan be understood that the legislature did not intend for court-o\njury records to further justice, and did not anticipate suc\ncontrast, the legislature's decision to include the ca\n905.27 reflects an intent to protect and inform\n\ne\n\nr lo\n\"\n\nb\n\nd\n\nosure of statewide grand\nwould benefit the public. By\n\nering justice\" exception in Section\nthe ultimate benefactors of the criminal\n\njustice system—by providing a means of a\n\nm\n\njury process has been called into s\n\nion. Accordingly, implying a private right of action is\n\nconsistent with the purposes and\nC.\n\nse rare situations where the integrity of the grand\n\ne legislative scheme in Chapter 900 of the Florida Statutes.\n\nt Power to Release Grand Jury Records in Order to Further\nThis Court has i\nJustice and %Indica e Confidence in the Judicial Process\nAs set f\n\ninNipFAC (VI 60-64), even in the absence of the statutory framework in Section\n\n905.27, di\n\ns appropriate pursuant to this Court's inherent authority over grand jury\n\nproceedings\n\ncause of the exceptional public interest in this case and the compelling circumstances\n\nsupporting transparency rather than continued secrecy.\n1. The Grand Jury is Under the Court's Sunervision and Jurisdiction\nIt is well-settled th\n... [truncated, 2196 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02732754/14 or ?id=EFTA02732754&page=14]", "char_count": 2196}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02732754", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "(quoting Craft v. State, 42 Fla. 567, 29 So. 418 (1900)). Indeed, it is the court that gives the grand jury\nits initial charge and advises the grand jury about its legal duties. Fla. Stat. § 905.18.\n\"It has long been understood that Iciertain implied powers must necessarily result to our\nCourts of justice from the nature of their institution,' powers `which cannot be dispensed with in a\nCourt, because they are necessary to the exercise of all others.\"\n\nv. NASCa nc., 501 U.S.\n\n32, 43 (1991). \"There can be no question of the inherent power of a court `to prot\n\nand hence\n\nsociety, as an instrument of justice.\"' In re Osborn, 376 F.2d 808, 810 (6th •\nThus, in a variety of contexts, it has been held that \"courts hav\n\nt power to protect\n\nthe integrity of the judicial process from perversion and abuse.\" v.\n\n.-\n\n2d 1094, 1099-1100 (Fla. 4th DCA 2001); Attwood v. t\n\n, 661 So. 2d 1216 (Fla. 1995)\n\ne\n\n(invoking court's inherent authority to prevent \"abus'\n\"S tic\nin '\ninterference with orderly process of judicial\nDCA 1996) (invoking court's inherent a\n\nc\n\nS\nt\n\nchine v. Valchine, 793 So.\n\nm filing additional cases to prevent\n\n); Tramel v. Bass, 672 So. 2d 78 (Fla. 1st\n\ntrike pleadings to sanction fraud perpetrated on\n\nthe court).\nThe Florida Supreme Co\nthe integrity of both the\n\nhas 6ted that it is \"of vital importance to maintain the dignity and\nand the presiding judge.\" State v. Clemmons, 150 So. 2d 231, 233-\n\n34 (Fla. 1963).4\n\nstates such as Florida, where the grand jury is preserved, it is an important\n\nappendage of a co\n\nwhich impanels it...[and] it should not be forgotten that the judge of that court\n\nis equal\n\ntent and he is generally charged with the supervision of the grand jury's activities...\"\n\nId. \"The importance of public confidence in the integrity of judges stems from the place of the judiciary\nin the government.\"\n\n-Yulee v. Fla. Bar, 575 U.S. 433, 445 (2015). Courts do not command\n\narmies and have \"no influence over either the sword or the purse[.]\" Id. (citing T\n... [truncated, 2149 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02732754/15 or ?id=EFTA02732754&page=15]", "char_count": 2149}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02732754", "page_number": 16, "text_content": ")). \"The judiciary's authority therefore depends in large\n\np. 465 (C. Rossiter ed. 1961) (A.\n\nmeasure on the public's willingness to respect and follow its decisions.\" Id.; see also In re Petition to\nInspect & Copy Grand Jury Materials, 735 F.2d 1261, 1269-70 (11th Cir. 1984) (upholding the\nexercise of the court's inherent power to release grand jury records to further \"a matter of great societal\nimportance\" that affected \"the public confidence in the judiciary\"). \"The perception of a viable healthy\njudiciary is of critical importance to our system of justice.\" Id. at 1271. This '\nimportance with respect to state courts, which are invested with primary itsTes\n\n\" is of equal\nty for overseeing\n\nthe investigation and prosecution of crimes.\nThe Supreme Court of the United States, while acknowled • ) the\nhas long authorized the disclosure of grand jury records w\nany remaining interest in secrecy. Douglas Oil Co. o\ni\n\need for transparency outweighs\n\nSdfi(?c a v. Petrol Stops Northwest, 441 U.S.\n\n211, 223 (1979). Courts around the country ha lllic,\n\nsuit. See, e.g.. In re Petition of Nat? Sec.\n\nsooN.Y. Aug. 26, 2008) (release of grand jury records\n(S.\n\nArchive, No. 08 CIV. 6599, 2008 WL 898\nconcerning the indictment of Julius\n\n;t\n\nues in grand jury secrecy,\n\ne\n\nosenberg); In re Petition ofNat? Sec. Archive, 104 F.\n\nSupp. 3d 625 (S.D.N.Y. 2015)\n\nme\n\n(release of President Nixo\n\nd jury deposition testimony in connection with the third Watergate\n\ngrand jury); In re\nClinton, 308\ninvestig\n\nn re Petition of Kutler, 800 F. Supp. 2d 42 (D.D.C. 2011)\n\nckets Related to the Indep. Counsel's 1998 Investigation of President\nd 314 (D.D.C. 2018) (release of records related to independent counsel's\n\nresident Clinton). Most recently, the D.C. Circuit ordered the Trump administration\n\nto provide the House Judiciary Committee redacted portions of grand jury materials from former\nspecial counsel Robert Mueller's probe into Russian election interference. In Re: Application of\nthe Committee on t\n... [truncated, 2199 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02732754/16 or ?id=EFTA02732754&page=16]", "char_count": 2199}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02732754", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "v. U.S. Department ofJustice, No. 19-5288 (D.C. Cir. March 20, 2020). There is no evidence that the\ndisclosures resulting from these cases have adversely affected the grand jury process. On the other\nhand, there is no doubt that the release of these materials has contributed greatly to the historical record\nof significant events in our country's history, as well as exposing failures in our justice system.\n2. This Court has inherent Power to Release Grand Jury Records in Order to\nFurther Justice and Vindicate Confidence in the Judicial Process\nCourts have identified nine \"non-exhaustive\" factors that a court\ndetermining whether their inherent authority should be exercised to ord\n\natimOStider\nc\nwhen\ne of grand jury\n\ndocuments. These factors include:\n(i) the identity of the party seeking disclosure; (ii) w\ne defendant to the grand jury\nproceeding or the government opposes the disclosu\ny disclosure is being sought in\nthe particular case; (iv) what specific informatio\nought for disclosure; (v) how long\nago the grand jury proceedings took place; (vi\nstatus of the principals of the grand\nth extent to which the desired material—\njury proceedings and that of their famili\neither permissibly or impermissibly\npreviously made public; (viii) whether\nwitnesses to the grand jury proceedin\nt be affected by disclosure are still alive; and\n(ix) the additional need for maintayri\ncy in the particular case in question.\nKutler, at 47-48 (quoting In re Petit'\nThe vast majority of the\nseeking disclosure does so\ninform the public.St\ndefendant to\ndisclos\n\ng, 131 F.3d 99,106).5\nweigh in favor of disclosure in this case. First, the party\n\nuant to its First Amendment right to receive information in order to\n\nP rmacy Bd., 425 U.S. at 756-57; Pittman, 267 F.3d at 1283. Second, the\nd'jury proceeding is deceased, although the government is opposed to the\n\nalm Beach Post respectfully submits that the government's opposition should be\n\nWhile it is largely federal courts that have applied these nine fa\n... [truncated, 2953 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02732754/17 or ?id=EFTA02732754&page=17]", "char_count": 2953}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02732754", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "given little weight where, as here, the disclosure of records is sought to uncover the alleged misconduct\nof a prior State Attorney (as opposed to, for example, witness perjury). Third, disclosure is being\nsought—based on information learned by The Palm Beach Post from (1) a series of Florida Public\nRecords Law requests, (2) law enforcement sources with direct knowledge of the grand jury evidence\nand proceedings, (3) judicial documents obtained from independent but related court proceedings, and\n(4) documents otherwise available in the public record—to inform the public as o\nState Attorney for Palm Beach County presented truncated evidence of Epste\nto the 2006 grand jury in a manner that precluded Epstein's indic\ncommitted, including sex trafficking and sexual assault. Fourt\ntestimony, minutes, and other evidence presented in 2006 t\nappear to have been whitewashed so that Epstein wo\nthere was ample evidence. Fifth, the grand jury\nthe current status of the principals of the %\n\ntter the then\nal wrongdoing\n\ne serious crimes he\ne\n\nrds being sought are the\neach County grand jury, which\n\ncharged with serious crimes of which\ntook place nearly fifteen years ago. Sixth,\n\nj „ croceedings are unknown. Seventh, because much\n\nof the requested information has\n\nt\n\nmistreatment by and misgivin\n\ning prosecutors (both state and federal), other lawsuits\n\nsurrounding Epstein and hi\nthis factor weighs\nunknown—in\nthat the\n\nthe public domain through victims protesting their\n\npirators, and public records requests and extensive news reporting,\nf MI disclosure. Eighth, the status of the witnesses who appeared is\n\ne Palm Beach Post's request is made, in part, to learn who the witnesses were\nrney did decide to call. 6 Finally, The Palm Beach Post submits that with the death\n\nof the defendant, the widely-known and litigated acts of his co-conspirators, the length of time that has\npassed, and the widely reported nature of this miscarriage of justice, there is no additional need for\nmaintaining s\n... [truncated, 2281 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02732754/18 or ?id=EFTA02732754&page=18]", "char_count": 2281}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02732754", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "jury's functions are ended, disclosure is wholly proper where the ends of justice require it.\").\nCourts have long realized that a transparent criminal justice system, affords \"significant\ncommunity therapeutic value.\" Richmond Newspapers v. Virginia, 448 U.S. at 570-71. \"[T]he open\nprocesses ofjustice serve an important prophylactic purpose, providing an outlet for community\nconcern, hostility, and emotion.\" Id. at 571. \"The crucial prophylactic aspects of the ad inistration\nofjustice cannot function in the dark; no community catharsis can occur if justice i\n[or] in any covert manner.\" Id.\n\neS'\ns inherent authority\n\nThe Palm Beach Post has accordingly stated a claim pursuant to\nand supervisory powers, which allow the Court to take appropri it\n\nin a corner\n\ncessary action to preserve\n\nand promote the integrity of the justice system. The citizens\n\na 7 each County and throughout the\n\nState of Florida are entitled to nothing less in this cas\n\nonal importance and public interest.\n\nIV.\n\nCctk\n\n, ION\n\n's\n\nrt's inherent supervisory authority, The Palm\n\nPursuant to Fla. Stat. § 905.27\nBeach Post has sufficiently pleaded •\nDated: March 13, 2020\n\n•\n\n.\nRespectfully submitted,\nGREENBERG TRAURIG, P.A.\nAttorneysfor CA Florida Holdings, LLC, Publisher of\nThe Palm Beach Post\nStephen A. Mendelsohn, Esq.\n5100 Town Center Circle, Suite 400\nBoca Raton, Florida 33486\nTelephone: (561) 955-7629\nFacsimile: (561) 338-7099\n\nBy: Is/ Stephen A. Mendelsohn\nSTEPHEN A. MENDELSOHN\nFlorida Bar No. 849324\nmendelsohns@gtlaw.com\nhasenhegtlaw.com\nFLService@gtlaw.com\n\n20\n\nEFTA02732773\n\n\f", "char_count": 1574}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02732754", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "By: Is/ Michael J Grvgiel\nMICHAEL J GRYGIEL\n(Admitted Pro Hac Vice)\n54 State St., 6th Floor\nAlbany, New York 12207\nTelephone: (518) 689-1400\nFacsimile: (518) 689-1499\ngrvnielmQgtlaw.com\nBy: /s/ Nina D. Bovaiian\nNINA D. BOYAJIAN\n(Admitted Pro Hac Vice)\n1840 Century Park East\nLos Angeles California\nTelephone: (310) 5\nFacsimile: (310\nbo **aim\nriveraa\nACTIVE 492958.871M\n\n21\n\nEFTA02732774\n\n\f", "char_count": 389}]}