{"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_count": 22, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02730996", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02730996.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "EX-99.1 2 d118102dex991.htm EX-99.1 \nExhibit 99.1 \nDecheLLPrt \nMEMORANDUM \nDATE \nJanuary 22, 2021 \nTO \nApollo Conflicts Committee \nFROM \nDechen LLP \nRE \nInvestigation Of Epstein/Black Relationship And Any Relationship Between Epstein and Apollo Global Management, Inc. \nIn October 2020, the Conflicts Committee of Apollo Global Management, Inc. (\"Apollo\") retained Dechert LLP (\"Dechert\") as \nindependent counsel to conduct a thorough investigation into (1) the relationship between Leon Black (\"Black\") and Jeffrey Epstein (\"Epstein\"), \nincluding any financial, business or personal dealings between Black and any Black affiliate, on the one hand, and Epstein and any Epstein affiliate on \nthe other; (2) any work performed for, or services rendered to, Black or any Black affiliate by Epstein or any Epstein affiliate; (3) the financial or other \nrelationship, if any, between Apollo or any Apollo affiliate, and Epstein and any Epstein affiliate, including without limitation, any financial or other \ndealings between them; and (4) any statements made by or on behalf of Black or Apollo referring, relating to or characterizing either Black's or Apollo's \nrelationship with Epstein. The Committee placed no restriction on Dechert's investigation. This memorandum summarizes Dechen's findings. \nI. \nEXECUTIVE SUMMARY \nOver the past three months, Dechen has reviewed over 60,000 documents obtained from Black, Apollo, Elysium Management LLC \n(Black's \"Family Office\"), and Paul, Weiss, Rilkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP, outside legal counsel to Black and the Family Office (\"Paul Weiss\"). \nSuch documents include emails, text messages, banking statements, and other forms of communication. Potentially relevant documents were collected \nfrom Apollo for current and former employees of Apollo dating back to 1998 as well as for all current and former employees of the Family Office, \nincluding from the inception of the Family Office and prior to implementation of the separate Family Office (Elysium)\n... [truncated, 2090 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02730996/0 or ?id=EFTA02730996&page=0]", "char_count": 2090}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "DecheLLPrt \nApollo Conflicts Committee \nJanuary 22, 2021 \nPage 2 \nDechen was assisted in its document collection efforts by Paul Weiss, as well as by Apollo's legal counsel for the purpose of this \ninvestigation, Milbank LIP (\"Milbank\"),I Both Paul Weiss and Milbank fully cooperated in the investigation and agreed to provide every category of \ndocuments that Dechen requested. Paul Weiss and Milbank also assisted Dechert in providing access to not only materials but also various witnesses \nthought to be relevant to the investigation. \nSpecifically, Dechert interviewed more than 20 witnesses (some more than once), including Black, current and former Apollo employees, \nthe co-founders of Apollo, current and former Family Office employees, and current and former legal counsel to obtain their recollection of events that \nmay have been relevant to Dechert's investigation. With only one exception, Dechen interviewed every witness that it had requested; that witness, a \nformer employee of the Family Office, declined to participate in the investigation but is not believed to have any additional information likely to be \nmaterial to the investigation. Based on Dechen's thorough review of the documents and witness testimony, Dechert has made the following findings, \neach of which is set out in more detail below: \n1. \nDechert has seen no evidence that Black or any employee of the Family Office or Apollo was involved in any way with Epstein's criminal \nactivities at any time. There is no evidence that Epstein ever introduced Black, or offered to introduce Black, to any underage woman. \n2. \nBlack and others at Apollo and the Family Office were aware that Epstein had been convicted in 2008 for the charges of solicitation of \nprostitution and procuring a person under 18 for prostitution. There is no evidence suggesting knowledge of any other of Epstein's \ncriminal activity or the scope and details of such activity, at any time prior to such activities being publicly \nPaul Weiss has\n... [truncated, 2126 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02730996/1 or ?id=EFTA02730996&page=1]", "char_count": 2126}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "DecheLLPrt \nApollo Conflicts Committee \nJanuary 22, 2021 \nPage 3 \nreported in late 2018 and culminating with Epstein's arrest in July 2019. When Black first retained Epstein, he believed that Epstein had \nserved his time for the originally charged offenses and believed that it was not inappropriate to give Epstein a second chance, as many \nother prominent figures in business, science, politics and academia had done. \n3. \nFrom approximately the mid-1990's to 2018, Black had a social relationship with Epstein, and from 2012 to 2017, Epstein provided \nprofessional services to Black as well. There is no evidence that Black paid Epstein for any services after April 2017, although the two \nmen did continue to communicate until October 2018. Professionally, Black retained Epstein to advise Black and the Family Office on a \nvariety of topics related to trust and estate planning, tax issues, philanthropic endeavors, and the operation of the Family Office. Socially, \nBlack was friendly with Epstein and confided in Epstein regarding personal matters. Epstein would, at times, allude to their personal \nrelationship when attempting to negotiate aspects of their business relationship, but Dechert has seen no evidence suggesting that either \ntheir professional or personal relationships ever touched upon Epstein's criminal activities or any other illegal activity. \n4. \nEpstein regularly advised Black on a variety of issues related to trust and estate planning, tax, philanthropy, and the operation of the \nFamily Office. Although witnesses agreed that: (a) not all of Epstein's advice was useful and (b) Epstein was generally a disruptive and \ncaustic force within the Family Office, many witnesses believed that Epstein had creative ideas that no other advisor had proposed and \nwould push Family Office employees to achieve greater performance than they might have achieved on their own. As a result of Epstein's \nwork, Black believed, and witnesses generally agreed, that Epstein provided a\n... [truncated, 2110 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02730996/2 or ?id=EFTA02730996&page=2]", "char_count": 2110}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "DecheLrt \nL P \nApollo Conflicts Committee \nJanuary 22, 2021 \nPage 4 \n5. \nBlack compensated Epstein for his work in amounts that were intended to be proportional to the value provided by Epstein. Those \npayments for work performed over the period 2012 through 2017 totaled $158 million. In 2013, payments were memorialized in signed \nand unsigned agreements. After that point, payments were made on an ad hoc basis based on Black's perceived value of Epstein's work. \nDechert has seen no evidence suggesting that Black ever compensated Epstein for any service other than Epstein's legitimate advice on \ntrust and estate planning, tax issues, issues relating to artwork, Black's airplane, Black's yacht, and other similar matters, philanthropic \nissues, and the operation of the Family Office. Moreover, such advice was vetted consistently by Black's other advisors, including Family \nOffice employees, Paul Weiss, and other outside legal, accounting and tax professionals. \n6. \nBeginning in 2016, Black and Epstein's professional and personal relationship deteriorated over a payment dispute that had long been \nbrewing, with Black refusing to pay Epstein tens of millions of dollars that Epstein believed he had earned. Black's last payment to \nEpstein was made in April 2017; in 2018, Epstein repaid a portion of two loans that were outstanding to Black but never repaid the \nbalance. Black and Epstein ceased communications in or around the fall of 2018, prior to the renewed public revelations of Epstein's \nconduct and Epstein's arrest and suicide. \n7. \nEpstein and his entities did not invest in any Apollo-managed funds. However, in 2011, one of Epstein's entities, Financial Trust Company, \npurchased 263,257 shares of Apollo's stock in its initial public offering. Those shares appear to have later been transferred to a second \nEpstein entity, Southern Financial LLC, and appear to have been held through at least September 2019. Aside from this stock purchase, \nand the tangential matters d\n... [truncated, 2452 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02730996/3 or ?id=EFTA02730996&page=3]", "char_count": 2452}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "DecheLLPrt \nApollo Conflicts Committee \nJanuary 22, 2021 \nPage 5 \n11. \nBLACK AND EPSTEIN DEVELOP A \nPERSONAL AND THEN A BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP \nBlack was introduced to Epstein in the mid-1990's by a mutual friend. Following the introduction, they grew to know each other better and \ndeveloped a personal relationship. While Black and Epstein discussed estate planning, philanthropy, and related issues over the years, Black did not \nengage Epstein to provide him with any services until 2012. Initially, Black viewed Epstein as someone who was very intelligent and knowledgeable \nregarding issues relating to estate planning and taxation. Black also was impressed by Epstein's connections to many prominent figures in business, \npolitics, and science. Epstein spoke knowledgeably about scientific innovation and technology. He introduced Black to well-regarded researchers at \nHarvard University and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and encouraged Black to donate to charitable causes that supported scientific \ndevelopment. In 1997, Black appointed Epstein as one of the initial directors of the Black Family Foundation, which was established for the purpose of \nfacilitating contributions by Black and his family to philanthropic endeavors. Black was further impressed when he learned that David Rockefeller had \nappointed Epstein as a director to the Board of Rockefeller University. This appointment was consistent with Black's understanding that Epstein was \nextremely knowledgeable about science and technology, as well as a strong proponent of scientific research and development. \nIn the mid-I 990's, Black's business and net worth were growing and his children were young so Black was less focused on matters related \nto estate planning. Although he may have discussed such matters with Epstein, such discussions were peripheral at the beginning of their relationship. \nAs the importance to Black of effective tax and estate planning grew over time in the 2000's, Epstein eventually \n... [truncated, 2290 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02730996/4 or ?id=EFTA02730996&page=4]", "char_count": 2290}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "DecheLLPrt \nApollo Conflicts Committee \nJanuary 22, 2021 \nPage 6 \nIn mid-2007, Epstein resigned from the Black Family Foundation. However, due to an oversight, the IRS Form 990s filed for the Black \nFamily Foundation during the period 2008-2012 failed to reflect his resignation. Following discovery of the error in or around 2013, the Black Family \nFoundation issued a confirmation of his earlier resignation. \nIn 2008, Epstein pled guilty in Florida to two felony offenses: procuring a person under the age of 18 for prostitution and solicitation of \nprostitution. As a result, he received a I3-month sentence, the majority of which was spent on work release, and one year of house arrest before being \nreleased in August 2010. Black was aware of Epstein's guilty plea and understood from Epstein that these offenses arose out of a single instance in \nwhich Epstein had received a massage from a 17 year old prostitute. According to Black, Epstein had told him that the woman had shown Epstein false \nidentification suggesting that she was not underage. Black had no client relationship with Epstein at the time. \nBlack formed the Family Office in 2008 to better manage his finances, trusts, and estate planning. At its inception, the Family Office \nincluded only a single employee, but it gradually grew over time as Black hired additional management, legal counsel, and staff. By 2014, the Family \nOffice had approximately 10 employees. \nFollowing Epstein's prison sentence, Black believed that Epstein had served his time and that it would not be inappropriate to maintain a \npersonal and professional relationship with Epstein. This decision appears to have been informed by at least three factors. First, Black believed that the \nseverity of Epstein's offenses was limited to a single instance of soliciting a 17 year old prostitute that Black believed Epstein had mistakenly \nunderstood was older. Second, numerous prominent figures, including CEOs, banking institutions, leading figures in t\n... [truncated, 2441 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02730996/5 or ?id=EFTA02730996&page=5]", "char_count": 2441}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "DecheLLPrt \nApollo Conflicts Committee \nJanuary 22, 2021 \nPage 7 \nBlack agrees, in hindsight, that he should not have given Epstein a second chance and that he would not have done so if he had known \nmore about Epstein's criminal activity. Dechert has not found any evidence to suggest that Black, during the period of their relationship, knew anything \nabout Epstein's criminal activity aside from the one instance described above, to which Epstein had admitted when he pleaded guilty in 2008. \nIn 2012, Epstein and Black began to discuss a business arrangement pursuant to which Epstein would advise Black and the Family Office \non trust and estate planning, tax issues, philanthropic issues, and the operation of the Family Office. The terms of this arrangement, a description of the \nwork provided, and a summary of the payments for this work are set forth below. Black and Epstein's relationship deteriorated between 2016 and 2018 \nover a dispute that had long been simmering regarding payment for Epstein's work, which also is described in more detail below. Black severed all ties \nwith Epstein in approximately October 2018. \nThroughout Epstein and Black's relationship, Black viewed Epstein as a friend worthy of his trust. They attended social events together, \nBlack confided in Epstein on personal matters, and Black introduced Epstein to his family. Black regularly visited Epstein's townhouse in New York to \neither discuss business or to meet other prominent guests who were visiting Epstein, including well known businessmen, political figures, diplomats, \nscientists and celebrities. In general, one-on-one breakfast meetings between Black and Epstein would be more common for business meetings, whereas \nafternoon meetings with other guests would be more common for social visits. \nEFTA02731002\n", "char_count": 1813}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "DecheLLPrt \nApollo Conflicts Committee \nJanuary 22, 2021 \nPage 8 \nRegarding travel, Black and his wife briefly visited Epstein at his residence in Paris for drinks on a single occasion. Black and his wife \nalso visited Epstein at his property in Santa Fe on a single occasion, while Black and his wife were on their way to California on Black's personal \nairplane.2 Black also briefly visited Epstein in Florida on one or two occasions. Black recalls visiting Epstein's island in the Caribbean on two occasions \nand was accompanied by his wife and one or more of his children on both. Black never spent the night at any property owned by Epstein. Black only \nrecalls flying on Epstein's private airplane on a single occasion, when he and one or more of his children went to meet with professors at academic \ninstitutions in the Boston area. \nBlack viewed Epstein as a confirmed bachelor with eclectic tastes, who often employed attractive women. However, Black did not believe \nthat any of the women in Epstein's employ were underage. Black has no recollection of ever seeing Epstein with an underage woman at any time. \nBlack stated that he was repulsed by the details of Epstein's crimes that were published in late 2018 and regretted ever having worked with \nEpstein. Other witnesses agreed that Black was shocked when the allegations became public. Some witnesses noted specifically that they did not believe \nBlack would have allowed Epstein to be introduced to Black's wife and children if Black had had any suspicion that Epstein had done anything \ninappropriate or illegal with girls or young women. \nIII. \nEPSTEIN PROVIDED SUBSTANTIAL \nVALUE TO BLACK AND THE FANIHN OFFICE \nMany witnesses believed Epstein provided significant value to Black and the Family Office in the areas of estate and tax planning. \nAlthough witnesses had different opinions about the extent of Epstein's value on specific projects, it was generally agreed that Epstein was an active \nparticipant who provided unique s\n... [truncated, 2481 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02730996/7 or ?id=EFTA02730996&page=7]", "char_count": 2481}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Dechert \nLLP \nApollo Conflicts Committee \nJanuary 22, 2021 \nPage 9 \nadvisors, including employees of the Family Office, Paul Weiss, and other outside accountants, lawyers and tax professionals would vet his ideas, and he \nwould regularly challenge them to think outside the box as well as to defend their positions from both a legal and pragmatic standpoint. In short, there is \nno question that Epstein performed substantive work for Black and that Black genuinely believed that Epstein was extremely smart, capable, and saved \nhim substantial amounts of money. \nIn addition, Epstein helped manage, and provided oversight to, the Family Office between late 2012 and 2017. In that capacity, he worked \non a variety of projects. Witnesses described the following as being the most significant projects during Epstein's tenure, although there were a number \nof other estate and tax-related projects and issues with which Epstein was involved during this time period. \nA. 2006 Grantor Retained Annuity Trust (-GRAT\") \nThere was a consensus among witnesses that Epstein offered a unique solution to a potential estate planning problem that arose out of a \ntrust known as the 2006 Grantor Retained Annuity Trust (\"2006 GRAT\"). Many witnesses opined that this solution — which Epstein offered in the \nbeginning of Black and Epstein's working relationship in late 2012 — was the most valuable piece of work Epstein provided Black. \nA GRAT is an estate planning mechanism that allows a grantor of a trust to transfer to his or her beneficiaries that portion of the assets \ncontributed to the trust that have appreciated in excess of an assumed growth rate set by the Internal Revenue Service (\"IRS\"). If done properly, the \nassets should be transferred out of the estate without gift or estate tax liability. The grantor retains the right to receive a series of annuity payments from \nthe GRAT for a specified period of time. Each annuity payment is based on a percentage of the fair market value of the asse\n... [truncated, 2067 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02730996/8 or ?id=EFTA02730996&page=8]", "char_count": 2067}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "DecheLLPrt \nApollo Conflicts Committee \nJanuary 22, 2021 \nPage 10 \nBlack was interested in establishing GRATs because they would allow him to transfer certain assets outside of his taxable estate as well as \nto accomplish other financial and estate planning objectives. Originally, the 2006 GRAT was established by Black's former trusts and estates attorney \nwho had been recommended to Black by Epstein. However, it appears that because of the way the 2006 GRAT had been stnictured,3 there was a serious \nrisk that, absent additional action, the GRAT would carry a future risk of a large estate tax assessment and thus would not perform as Black understood it \nwould. Both a former Family Office employee and outside counsel agreed that, at the time the issue was identified, the estate tax would have been \naround $500 million. Witnesses differed on what the value of the estate tax would have been today or in the future if the issues had not been resolved, \nbut they believed the estate tax liability could have been as much as $1 billion or more. \nOnce the potential issues were identified, Black and his advisors attempted to find a way to resolve them. Although Family Office \nemployees and outside counsel offered various solutions, all witnesses agreed that Epstein proposed the best and most creative solution to the problem. \nEpstein approached Black with his solution — which Epstein asserted was proprietary — and Black agreed to pay Epstein to implement this solution. \nOutside legal counsel described the solution as a \"grand slam\" and one that met all of Black's financial and estate planning goals. \nBy solving an estate tax problem potentially worth at least $500 million, and possibly substantially more, Epstein contributed significant \nvalue to Black and his estate. This was the first project that Epstein worked on for Black and Epstein's success on this project appears to have validated \nBlack's trust in him and strongly influenced Black's decision to continue to use Epstei\n... [truncated, 2676 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02730996/9 or ?id=EFTA02730996&page=9]", "char_count": 2676}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "DecheLrt \nL P \nApollo Conflicts Committee \nJanuary 22, 2021 \nPage II \nvalue of this transaction because the extent of savings was not likely to be known until the future, witnesses agreed that this transaction provided \nsignificant value. Epstein estimated that this transaction had saved $600 million in value and Black appears to have agreed with that estimate. Outside \ncounsel stated that this was a complicated transaction that took approximately nine months to plan and execute. \nWitnesses noted that there was a dispute following this transaction over whether Epstein had come up with the idea for this transaction on \nhis own or if the transaction had first been proposed by outside counsel. Outside counsel stated that this transaction did not originate from Epstein but \nthat Epstein had nevertheless played an instrumental role in completing it. The extent of Epstein's role in this transaction led to a dispute over Epstein's \nfees, which is described more fully below. \nC. Other Estate Planning Advice \nLeveraging his success on the GRAT issue, Epstein continued to provide ongoing advice on a variety of issues regarding Black's estate. \nThis general estate planning advice touched on many different subjects, including providing further advice and planning with respect to various trusts, \ngeneration planning, establishing additional GRATs, tax planning, enhancing the Family Office (which, until that time was, by all accounts, inadequate \nto handle Black's growing estate), and preparing detailed \"fire drill\" plans that would test how Black's estate would be treated in multiple different \nscenarios based on a variety of assumptions regarding timing of death, price of Apollo stock and other variables. Witnesses, including outside counsel, \nremarked that, despite Epstein's lack of formal training in law or accounting, his fire drill plans were more detailed and comprehensive than any similar \nplans they had seen prepared for other clients. \nIn describing Epstein's contributi\n... [truncated, 2635 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02730996/10 or ?id=EFTA02730996&page=10]", "char_count": 2635}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "DecheLrt \nL P \nApollo Conflicts Committee \nJanuary 22, 2021 \nPage 12 \nOne area where witnesses believed Epstein provided value to Black's estate included being able to motivate Black to concentrate on \ncertain Family Office issues in a way that others could not. Epstein played an active role in convincing Black to bring Black's family members into the \nconversation about estate planning, trust formation, and philanthropy. As confirmed by both witnesses and the documentary evidence, Epstein played a \ncentral role in meeting with Black's family and explaining to them how Black's estate was organized and to encourage them to be more engaged in the \nplanning process and philanthropy. \nD. Tax Planning, Compliance And Audit Advice \nAlthough Epstein had no formal tax training, witnesses agreed that he was very knowledgeable on a variety of issues relating to tax \nplanning, tax compliance, and managing and responding to audit inquiries from taxing authorities. Both witness testimony and the documentary record \nconfirm that Epstein played an important role in resolving a number of potentially significant tax-related issues for Black during the time period 2013 \nthrough 2017, which included, among others: (1) addressing an IRS audit letter relating to the 2013 tax year; (2) planning and coordinating the \nsubmission of statements of reasonable cause for a series of tax years to address an apparent failure to file certain tax forms, including IRS Forms 8865, \nrelating to Black's interests in BRH Holdings L.P., a partnership through which Black and the other Apollo co-founders hold their ownership interests in \nApollo and related foreign partnerships; (3) addressing an IRS audit letter regarding Black's 2012 tax filings, including interfacing with the IRS to \nachieve a positive resolution; and (4) advising on tax matters related to Phaidon, a UK publishing entity that Black had acquired and that had a \nparticularly complex organizational structure. Epstein would not draft materi\n... [truncated, 2179 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02730996/11 or ?id=EFTA02730996&page=11]", "char_count": 2179}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Dechert \nApollo Conflicts Committee \nJanuary 22, 2021 \nL L P \nPage 13 \nE. Epstein's Other General Advice \nEpstein also appears to have provided substantive advice to the Family Office on myriad esoteric issues, which included (i) managing \nBlack's artwork, (ii) advising on issues relating to Black's yacht, and (iii) advising on issues relating to Black's airplane. While witnesses had differing \nopinions on the precise value added, there was general consensus that Epstein would get into the weeds on obscure issues about which otherwise highly \ncompetent Family Office employees were not knowledgeable, such as aspects of specific regulations governing airplane usage, and frequently provided \nvaluable assistance. \n1. Managing  Black's Artwork \nFamily Office witnesses generally agreed that Epstein advised Black in a few areas related to Black's artwork, including: (i) the formation \nof a new art partnership, (ii) the contested ownership of a Picasso sculpture, (iii) Black's art loans, (iv) like-kind exchanges, and (v) obtaining a potential \nadvisory opinion from the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance regarding a contemplated transaction involving Black's art. The value \nprovided from each project differed depending on the project. Although Family Office employees generally agreed that Epstein was not an expert in art \nmanagement or art law, witnesses also opined that he was helpful in the formation of the art partnership and was fairly involved in assisting Black in \nconnection with the sale of certain pieces of artwork. \n2. Advice Regarding Black's Yacht \nWitnesses confirmed that Epstein advised Black on the management of Black's yacht. One witness said that Epstein was involved with \nBlack's initial purchase of his yacht, which involved assisting in structuring the entity that owned the vessel and moving it. Mother witness recalled \nEpstein advising Black on how to charter the vessel. A third witness said Epstein generally flagged issues regarding the ve\n... [truncated, 2238 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02730996/12 or ?id=EFTA02730996&page=12]", "char_count": 2238}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "DecheLLPrt \n3. Advice Regaftilftft-ififtdnillgang \nApollo Conflicts Committee \nJanuary 22, 2021 \nPage 14 \nFamily Office employees opined that Epstein was very knowledgeable about selling and purchasing airplanes, the organization of airplane \nentities, and the relatively complex and obscure regulations and requirements applicable to airplane usage. Witnesses confirmed that Epstein added \nvalue in the restructuring of airplane entities and advising on the certification of the airplane. One Family Office employee recalled that an airplane \nbroker was not pleased when Epstein got involved in the negotiation for an airplane purchase because the broker knew Epstein was sophisticated when it \ncame to airplanes and that it would be hard to negotiate against Epstein. Although the Family Office regularly vetted Epstein's views and advice with \noutside counsel, Family Office employees agreed that Epstein often pointed Black in the right direction regarding airplanes. There thus appears to be a \ngeneral consensus that Epstein's input regarding a range of issues pertaining to airplanes was valuable to Black. \nF. Improving  The Family Office \nIn addition to assisting on specific projects, Epstein also played an important role in developing, managing and improving the Family \nOffice, improving recordkeeping, and locating misplaced assets. Witnesses agreed that in 2012, when Epstein began working for Black, the Family \nOffice was ill-equipped to manage Black's growing estate at the sophisticated and expert level that Black expected and needed. Epstein appears to have \ntaken the reins in developing the Family Office by extensively reviewing its operations, advising on personnel changes, including interviewing \ncandidates for employment and recommending terminations of those he felt were inadequate performers, and consistently pushing the employees to \nimprove the quality of their work. Family Office employees were instructed to run most decisions relating to tax and estate planning\n... [truncated, 2314 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02730996/13 or ?id=EFTA02730996&page=13]", "char_count": 2314}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "DecheLrt \nL P \nApollo Conflicts Committee \nJanuary 22, 2021 \nPage 15 \nBy all accounts, Epstein was a strict taskmaster who could be difficult to work with. Epstein was often quick to criticize Family Office \nemployees and had a habit of overdramatizing even minor perceived errors. At the same time, Epstein would seek to take credit for good ideas, \nregardless of his level of involvement, which likely was intended to bolster his perceived value to Black. As a result of these actions, some witnesses \ndescribed a toxic and destructive work environment under Epstein. That being said, several witnesses agreed that the pressure that Epstein exerted upon \nthe employees did drive an improvement in their performance. \nBlack also found Epstein difficult to work with and would often grow frustrated with the frequency and length of Epstein's \ncommunications, in which he would identify long lists of perceived issues and problems within the Family Office. Black knew Epstein was greedy and a \nself-promoter and was likely attempting to prove his own value. At the same time, Black also felt that Epstein was identifying genuine issues that needed \nto be resolved. As their business relationship continued, Black wanted to \"wean\" the Family Office off Epstein so that he was less reliant on Epstein's \nservices, but Black found it difficult to do so because, from Black's perspective, Epstein was identifying and solving significant issues that were not \nbeing addressed by other employees or advisors. As Black explained, he was annoyed by how often Epstein would complain about the \"cavities\" that \nEpstein was finding in Black's \"mouth\" (the Family Office), but, at the same time, they were all \"real cavities\" that needed to be filled. \nThus, although Epstein's management style made him difficult to work with, and in many ways an overly demanding overseer of the \nFamily Office, there appears to be general agreement that Epstein played an important role in driving excellence and developing the\n... [truncated, 2063 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02730996/14 or ?id=EFTA02730996&page=14]", "char_count": 2063}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "DecheLLPrt \nApollo Conflicts Committee \nJanuary 22, 2021 \nPage 16 \nIV. \nRI .ACK COMPENSATED EPSTEIN BETWEEN 2013 AND 2017 FOR EPSTEIN'S BONA \n1,11E PROVISION OF TAX, ESTATE PLANNING AND OTHER RELATED SERVICES \nWith the assistance of legal counsel, Epstein and Black negotiated a written service agreement that was drafted by Black's counsel and \nsigned on February 13, 2013. Under this agreement, which was entered into between Black and Southern Trust Company, Inc., an Epstein affiliate, \nEpstein agreed to provide \"services deemed appropriate by [Epstein] and Mr. Black in connection with\" \"estate planning matters in respect of \nMr. Black's assets and estate.\" Those services included Epstein's work on the resolution of the complex 2006 GRAT issue starting in 2012. Although \nEpstein represented to Black that he generally charged clients $40 million per year for his advice, Epstein agreed to provide this initial work for \n$23.5 million, which was expected to be made in two installment payments occurring in 2013. Both of these payments were made to Southern Trust \nCompany, Inc.: the first payment of $15 million was made on February 15, 2013, and the second payment of $8.5 million was made on October 15, \n2013. \nGiven Epstein's success on the GRAT issue, Black and Epstein appear to have reached agreement on a second service contract in around \nMay 2013 containing a similar description of the scope of services to be rendered. It was also negotiated by legal counsel and multiple drafts were \nexchanged. Although this agreement appears never to have been signed, both Black and Epstein appear to have largely abided by the negotiated terms in \n2013. Pursuant to this agreement, Epstein continued to provide additional advice to Black and the Family Office in 2013 and 2014. In exchange, Black \nagreed to pay Epstein $56.5 million in five installment payments over 2013 and 2014. Black made the first two installment payments in 2013, totaling \n$26.5 million, but the agreement appears t\n... [truncated, 2725 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02730996/15 or ?id=EFTA02730996&page=15]", "char_count": 2725}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "DecheLrt \nL P \nApollo Conflicts Committee \nJanuary 22, 2021 \nPage 17 \nBlack did not pay Epstein in 2016. In April 2017, he made a final payment to Epstein of $8 million, which appears to be attributable to \ncertain tax advisory and compliance services provided by Epstein. From 2013 through 2017, Black was under the misconception that his payments to \nEpstein would be tax deductible (\"sixty cent dollars\") because this is what Epstein had told Black. Thus, Black erroneously believed that all of the \namounts he was paying to Epstein would be fully deductible on his tax returns. \nAlthough Black appears to have paid Epstein specific amounts for Epstein's work on the GRAT issue and the basis transaction, Black did \nnot generally view the payments he was making to Epstein as compensation for specific tasks. Instead, Black viewed the payments as compensation for \nthe overall value he believed Epstein was providing to him through Epstein's advice on trust and estate planning, tax issues, philanthropic issues, and the \noperation of the Family Office. In this context, although not every one of Epstein's ideas produced substantial value to Black, Black, as well as a number \nof witnesses, agreed that the value provided by Epstein to Black and the Family Office substantially exceeded the total compensation that Black paid to \nhim. However, it is clear that the compensation paid by Black to Epstein far exceeded any amounts Black paid to his other professional advisors. \nV. \n01.ACR' LOANED $30.5 MILLION TO EPSTEIN \nSeparate from the payments made to Epstein or his entities between 2013 and 2017 for services rendered, Black made two loans to \nEpstein, for $22.5 million and $8 million, respectively, in early 2017. These two loans were negotiated and documented by legal counsel. The loans were \nstructured as being made by BV70 LLC, an entity owned by Black, to Plan D LLC, an entity owned by Epstein. These loans were payable on demand \nfrom BV 70 LLC, were intended to be short-term loa\n... [truncated, 2088 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02730996/16 or ?id=EFTA02730996&page=16]", "char_count": 2088}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "IDechert \nApollo Conflicts Committee \nJanuary 22, 2021 \nL L P \nPage 18 \nBlack demanded repayment of the loans in full in early 2018. In response, Epstein repaid only $10 million of the outstanding amount. The \nremaining balance of the loans remained unpaid at the time of Epstein's death, despite Black's repeated demands for repayment in full during 2018. \nVI. \nBLACK AND EPSTEIN MADE CHARITABLE DONATIONS AT EACH OTHERS' REQUESTS \nThroughout their relationship, Black and Epstein each donated to charitable causes and encouraged each other to donate to charitable \ncauses. For example, on at least two occasions, Epstein made significant donations to the Melanoma Research Alliance, a charitable foundation \nestablished by Black and his wife, at Black's request. Similarly, Black made donations at Epstein's request to various scientific and charitable \norganizations, including the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Harvard University, the Arizona State University Origins Project, and the Peace \nInitiative Foundation. Black also made a $10 million donation to Gratitude America in October 2015, which was a charitable organization affiliated with \nEpstein.4 Black felt comfortable making this donation because he understood that Epstein was a strong proponent of scientific innovation. \nVII. \nBLACK CUT TIES WITH EPSTEIN IN 2018 OVER A FEE DISPUTE \nBlack and Epstein's relationship deteriorated between 2016 and 2018, largely as a result of a dispute over payment regarding the step-up \nbasis transaction. There appears to have been an understanding between Black and Epstein that Epstein would be compensated for some portion of the \nvalue conferred from any idea that originated from Epstein. However, although witnesses agreed that Epstein had played an integral role in completing \nthat transaction, there was a dispute over whether the idea for the transaction had originated with Epstein. Epstein claimed full credit for the transaction \nand demanded payment of $60 million, which wou\n... [truncated, 2487 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02730996/17 or ?id=EFTA02730996&page=17]", "char_count": 2487}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "DecheLrt \nL P \nApollo Conflicts Committee \nJanuary 22, 2021 \nPage 19 \nthat Epstein asserted the basis transaction had provided. Black's legal counsel disputed Epstein's assertions both that the idea had originated with \nEpstein and that the perceived savings could accurately be measured and quantified in advance. As discussed previously, Black agreed to pay Epstein \n820 million rather than the $60 million demanded by Epstein. \nFollowing that payment, Epstein sent numerous emails in 2016 and 2017 in which Epstein complained about the lack of further payment \nand attempted to pressure Black to provide greater compensation. Epstein's communications on these issues were lengthy and often included \nunsubstantiated assertions regarding work Epstein had purportedly performed for Black, the value of that work, and agreements that had purportedly \nbeen made relating to compensation. Epstein's communications also included extended warnings about a number of perceived issues affecting the \nFamily Office and Black's estate planning, coupled with assertions that Epstein no longer wished to play any role in resolving those issues. Epstein also \nwould invoke his friendship with Black in those emails, including by referencing personal matters that Black had shared with Epstein in confidence, \nalthough there is no evidence that those matters had any relationship to any of Epstein's criminal activity or to any of Black's payments to Epstein. \nEpstein's efforts to push Black for additional compensation proved unsuccessful, with Black refusing to provide any additional payment in \n2016 and agreeing to pay 88 million in 2017 to compensate Epstein for what appears to be work Epstein had performed relating to certain tax advisory \nand compliance advice. Both Epstein and Black repeatedly suggested throughout 2016 and 2017 that they should meet with legal counsel from Paul \nWeiss to address their payment dispute but such meeting did not occur until April 2018 largely because of delay caused\n... [truncated, 2571 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02730996/18 or ?id=EFTA02730996&page=18]", "char_count": 2571}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Dechert \nApollo Conflicts Committee \nJanuary 22, 2021 \nL L P \nPage 20 \nDue to the above fee dispute, the difficulty of dealing with Epstein, Epstein's failure to repay $20 million in loans and the realization that \nEpstein had mischaracterized his fees as being fully tax deductible, Black severed relations with Epstein by October 2018. \nviii. \nPUBLIC STATEMENTS BY BLACK AND APOLLO \nBlack and Apollo have made several public statements about their relationship or lack thereof with Epstein. For example, following \nEpstein's July 2019 arrest, on July 31, 2019, Black sent a letter to Apollo's limited partners (the \"July 31 Letter'. Black also made several statements to \ninvestors in quarterly calls. As part of Dechert's review, Dechert sought to verify the accuracy of these public statements. Dechert has determined that \nthe public messaging from Black and Apollo has been substantially accurate but, in two instances, may warrant additional context or clarification. \nIn the July 3I Letter, Black stated that \"From time to time, Mr. Epstein provided professional services to my family partnership and related \nfamily entities, involving tax, estate planning, and philanthropic advice.\"5 And in an Apollo earnings call on October 29, 2020, Mr. Black reiterated that \nEpstein provided \"professional services to my family partnership and related family entities, involving [estate] planning, tax, structuring of art entities \nand philanthropic advice.\" He further stated that Epstein's \"work extended over a period of six years from 2012 to 2017 and I paid him millions of \ndollars annually for that work.\" Black further asserted that \"There exists substantial documentary support for the services provided. All of Epstein['s] \nadvice was vetted by the leading law firms, accounting firms and other professional advisors.\"6 As detailed above, Dechert's investigation has confirmed \nthese statements to be true, based on both documentary support and the testimony of wimesses.7\n5 \nThis statement \n... [truncated, 2596 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02730996/19 or ?id=EFTA02730996&page=19]", "char_count": 2596}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "DecheLrt \nL P \nApollo Conflicts Committee \nJanuary 22, 2021 \nPage 21 \nIn the July 31 Letter, Black further stated that he \"was completely unaware of, and am deeply troubled by, the conduct that is now the \nsubject of the federal criminal charges brought against Mr. Epstein.\"8 As detailed above, Dechert's investigation has found nothing to contradict this \nstatement. While Mr. Black was aware of Epstein's guilty plea in 2008, he was unaware of the scope and extent of the criminal offenses that later \nsurfaced publicly through media reports in 2018, and that culminated in Epstein's arrest in July 2019, and suicide shortly thereafter. \nIn the July 31 Letter, Black also stated in pertinent part that: \"Apollo never did any business with Mr. Epstein at any point in time9 [and] \n[n]either Mr. Epstein nor any company controlled by him has ever invested in any funds managed by Apollo.\"10 He also stated that \"Apollo does not \nhave, and never has had, any relationship with Mr. Epstein.\" Dechert has found no indication that Apollo ever retained Epstein for his services or that \nEpstein ever invested in an Apollo-managed fund, and thus Dechert's review can confirm that these statements are accurate. That said, the phrases \n\"never did any business with\" and \"does not have, and never has had any relationship with\" are quite broad in scope. Dechert's investigation has \ndetermined that Financial Trust Company, a company owned by Epstein, purchased 263,257 shares in Apollo during its initial public offering pursuant \nto a directed share offering program \n8 \nSee also Transcript of July 31, 2019 Apollo Earnings Call; Black statement to Apollo employees dated July 26, 2019. \n9 \nSee also Transcript of July 31, 2019 Apollo Earnings Call at 14; Black statement to Apollo employees dated July 26, 2019; Transcript of \nOctober 29, 2020 Apollo Earnings Call at 7. \n10 \nSee also Transcript of October 29.2020 Apollo Earnings Call at 7. \nEFTA02731016\n", "char_count": 1952}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02730996", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "DecheLLPrt \nApollo Conflicts Committee \nJanuary 22, 2021 \nPage 22 \nmanaged by the lead broker-dealer in March, 2011.11 Black did not recall that transaction almost a decade later. Dechert has further determined that in \nthe early 2000's, Financial Trust Company invested in two other entities, AP SHL Investors LLC and AP Technology Partners LLC, which are not \nApollo funds and do not have any formal relationship with Apollo, but were formed by certain Apollo executives to explore investment opportunities \nthat Apollo chose not to pursue.12 In addition, in 2011, Epstein, through Financial Trust Company, appears to have invested in Environmental Solutions \nWorld Wide (\"ESWW\"), a small emissions control company, alongside Black and certain Black family members. Dechert has also determined that \nEpstein unsuccessfully sought to pitch business opportunities to certain Apollo senior executives, none of which were pursued by Apollo or those \nexecutives. While these facts do not render any prior statements false or misleading, it is clear that the facts informing what it means to \"do business \nwith\" or have a \"relationship with\" are perhaps more nuanced than might appear at first glance. \nRegarding Epstein's efforts to solicit business from Apollo or Apollo senior executives, Black stated in the July 31 Letter that he \"never promoted \nMr. Epstein's services to other Apollo senior executives ....\" Dechert's investigation reflects that while Black did not try to pressure his co-founders to \nuse Epstein, he did positively comment on the substantial value of Epstein's services and, at Epstein's repeated request, did try to introduce Epstein to \nhis co-founders. In the end, neither co-founder hired Epstein or consulted with him on their personal matters. In light of these facts, the statement that \nBlack \"never promoted\" Epstein is not false but could have been more precise. And it is clear that no Apollo employee other than Black ever seriously \nconsidered hiring Epstein, much l\n... [truncated, 2731 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02730996/21 or ?id=EFTA02730996&page=21]", "char_count": 2731}]}