{"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_count": 128, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02726849", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02726849.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "782 \nIN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE SEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL \nCIRCUIT IN AND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA \nCASE NO.: CACE 15-000072 \nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS and PAUL G. \nCASSELL, \nPlaintiffs, \nvs. \nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ, \nDefendant. \nVIDEOTAPE CONTINUED DEPOSITION OF \nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ \nVOLUME 6 \nPages 782 through 909 \nWednesday, January 13, 2016 \n1:05 p.m. - 3:06 p.m. \nTripp Scott \n110 Southeast 6th Street \nFort Lauderdale, Florida \nStenographically Reported By: \nKimberly Fontalvo, RPR, CLR \nRealtime Systems Administrator \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726849\n", "char_count": 568}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "783 \n1 \nAPPEARANCES: \n2 \nOn behalf of Plaintiffs: \n3 \nSEARCY, DENNEY, SCAROLA \n4 \nBARNHART & SHIPLEY, P.A. \n2139 Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard \n5 \nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33402-3626 \nBY: JACK SCAROLA, ESQ. \n6 \njsx@searcylaw.com \n7 \n8 \nOn behalf of Defendant: \n9 \nCOLE, SCOTT & KISSANE, P.A. \nDadeland Centre II - Suite 1400 \n10 \n9150 South Dadeland Boulevard \nMiami, Florida 33156 \n11 \nBY: THOMAS EMERSON SCOTT, JR., ESQ. \nthomas.scott@csklegal.com \n12 \nBY: STEVEN SAFRA, ESQ. \n(Via phone) \nsteven.safra@csklegal.com \n13 \n--and--\n14 \nWILEY, REIN \n17769 K Street NW \n15 \nWashington, DC 20006 \nBY: RICHARD A. SIMPSON, ESQ. \n16 \nRSimpson@wileyrein.com \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726850\n", "char_count": 737}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "784 \n1 \nAPPEARANCES (Continued): \n2 \n3 \nOn behalf of Jeffrey Epstein: \n4 \nDARREN K. INDYKE, PLLC \n575 Lexington Ave., 4th Fl. \n5 \nNew York, New York \nBY: DARREN K. INDYKE, ESQ. (Via phone) \n6 \n7 \nOn behalf of \n8 \nBOIES, SCHILLER & FLEXNER, LLP \n401 E. Las Olas Blvd., Ste. 1200 \n9 \nFort Lauderdale, Florida 33301 \nBY: SIGRID STONE MCCAWLEY, ESQ. \n10 \nsmccawley@bsfllp.com \n11 \n12 \nALSO PRESENT: \n13 \nEdward J. Pozzuoli, Special Master \n14 \nSean D. Reyes, Utah Attorney General Office \n15 \nMarcy Martinez, Videographer \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726851\n", "char_count": 612}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "785 \n1 \nINDEX \n2 \nExamination \nPage \n3 \n4 \nVOLUME 6 (Pages 782 - 909) \n5 \n6 \nCertificate of Oath \n906 \nCertificate of Reporter \n907 \n7 \nRead and Sign Letter to Witness \n908 \nErrata Sheet (forwarded upon execution) \n909 \n8 \n9 \nPLAINTIFF EXHIBITS \n10 \n11 \nNo. \nPage \n12 \n26 Business card of Jeffrey B. Levy, \n792 \nEsquire \n13 \n27 2002 Article on Child Pornography \n810 \n14 \n28 Miami Beach Police Case Report Detail \n822 \n15 \n29 Document reflecting entry for \n877 \n16 \nDershowitz, Alan \n17 \n30 Santa Monica Police Report \n885 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726852\n", "char_count": 609}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "786 \n1 \nThereupon, the proceedings continued at 1:04 p.m. \n2 \nVIDEOGRAPHER: Going back on the record. \n3 \nThe time is 1:04 p.m. \n4 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n5 \nQ. \nSir, before we move on to the next topic, \n6 \nI want to make sure that we have finished the \n7 \nprevious topic. \n8 \nIs there anyone else who gave you \n9 \ninformation about Paul Cassell who you can identify \n10 \nat this time and did not otherwise this morning \n11 \nidentify? \n12 \nA. \nYes. So, immediately upon hearing of the \n13 \nfalse accusation against me, I recall now that I \n14 \nGoogled Paul Cassell and discovered that he was \n15 \ncalled a zealot at least three times on easily \n16 \naccessible published materials. \n17 \nSo, the term \"zealot\" in addition to \n18 \ncoming from individuals -- and you can get them on \n19 \nGoogle as easily as I can --\n20 \nMR. SCAROLA: The question was, was there \n21 \nanyone else. \n22 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n23 \nQ. \nI'm asking is there a person's name? \n24 \nA. \nThese people wrote articles. They have \n25 \nnames. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726853\n", "char_count": 1052}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "787 \n1 \nQ. \nWhat are their names? \n2 \nA. \nI don't recall them. You can get them. \n3 \nYou can just Google \"Paul Cassell\" and you will find \n4 \nnames of people who call him a zealot. \n5 \nQ. \nI think maybe my question wasn't clear, so \n6 \nI'm going to make it crystal clear. \n7 \nA. \nYes. \n8 \nQ. \nHave you remembered the name of any \n9 \nindividual who you did not identify by name or \n10 \ndescription this morning that provided you \n11 \npersonally with information about Paul Cassell? \n12 \nA. \nA man named Hobbs, H-O-B-B-S. \n13 \nQ. \nIs that a first or last name? \n14 \nA. \nThat's a last name. And he -- my \n15 \nrecollection is -- I don't know if he testified \n16 \nagainst Paul Cassell or he just wrote an article, \n17 \nbut he wrote an article calling him a dangerous \n18 \nzealot. \n19 \nQ. \nDid you speak with Hobbs? \n20 \nA. \nI don't recall if I spoke to him, but I do \n21 \nrecall reading his article or reading excerpts at \n22 \nleast from the article. \n23 \nAnd then I remember reading another \n24 \narticle, may have been on Slate or -- there are a \n25 \nnumber of articles calling Paul Cassell a zealot. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-34O8 \nEFTA02726854\n", "char_count": 1151}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "788 \n1 \nSo the name just didn't pop into my head. It was \n2 \nsomething, as I said earlier, that was part of his \n3 \nreputation. \n4 \nQ. \nOkay. I will break this into two \n5 \nquestions. One, what information did you have other \n6 \nthan human interaction that may have included \n7 \narticles or other things that you read? \n8 \nBut before I get to that question, my \n9 \nquestion is, have you recalled the identity of any \n10 \nperson that you did not tell us about or describe \n11 \nearlier this morning that provided you information \n12 \nabout Paul Cassell? \n13 \nA. \nI want to wait for the \n14 \nMR. INDYKE: Outside the privilege. \n15 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Excuse me? \n16 \nA. \nNot that I can recall at this time. \n17 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n18 \nQ. \nOkay. Are there other materials that you \n19 \nhave not yet disclosed during this deposition that \n20 \nyou read, that provided you additional bases for \n21 \nyour opinions about Mr. Cassell? \n22 \nA. \nYes. \n23 \nMR. INDYKE: Objection. \n24 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n25 \nQ. \nAnd are these materials that --\nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726855\n", "char_count": 1086}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "789 \n1 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Hang on one \n2 \nsecond. \n3 \nMR. EDWARDS: Outside of the privilege. \n4 \nMR. INDYKE: Okay. Sorry. \n5 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n6 \nQ. \nAre these materials that have been \n7 \nprovided already in discovery in this case? \n8 \nA. \nI don't know the answer to that. I don't \n9 \nknow what has been provided and what hasn't. I can \n10 \njust tell you that in the course of my career, I had \n11 \nread -- I had never met Mr. Cassell, but I had read \n12 \nhis articles, and they are aptly described as \n13 \nzealous. He once -- he was once described as \n14 \nsomebody who misused -- I think misused or uses \n15 \nfamily values to hide his zealotry. But I was \n16 \nfamiliar with his what are regarded as very extreme \n17 \nwritings. And that formed part of my opinion about \n18 \nhis zealotry, yes. \n19 \nQ. \nWhat was the timing of your reading these \n20 \narticles that helped to form a part of your opinion \n21 \nabout Mr. Cassell? \n22 \nA. \nVery soon after the allegation was made. \n23 \nNot only did I independently read, but people called \n24 \nme and alerted me to read this, read that. People \n25 \nsent me briefs and asked me to read them. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726856\n", "char_count": 1197}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "790 \n1 \nQ. \nSo one of the things that you took into \n2 \nconsideration in assessing the reputation or \n3 \ncredibility of Paul Cassell were various things that \n4 \nhe had written or that had been written about him? \n5 \nA. \nYes, and what people had said about him. \n6 \nQ. \nOkay. \n7 \nA. \nI mean, just to give you an example, if \n8 \nyou don't mind me just elaborating one second, as I \n9 \nwas getting lunch today downstairs, three people \n10 \ncame over to me. One of them said, I can't believe \n11 \nthose, and then he used the F word, scrupulous --\n12 \nunscrupulous, unethical lawyers who have done this \n13 \nto you, this is horrible, get them, they have to pay \n14 \na price, they ought to be disciplined. \n15 \nAnd I said, do you know me? \n16 \nNo, but I've been following this story. \n17 \nThis \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \nhorrible. No decent lawyer would ever do this. \n23 \nThis happens to me all the time. People \n24 \ncome over to me all the time and tell me what they \n25 \nthink of you and Paul Cassell. \nis just unbelievable. \nAnd then two other people, one of whom \noverheard it, said, I just want to join in on that. \nI don't know you, but I just want you to know that \nthe lawyers who did this are beyond -- they're just \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726857\n", "char_count": 1269}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "791 \n1 \nQ. \nOkay. Where were you eating lunch today? \n2 \nA. \nIn a Wrap [sic] around restaurant. \n3 \nQ. \nWhere is it located geographically? \n4 \nA. \nRight in the building. In the building. \n5 \nQ. \nAnd are these individuals that spoke to \n6 \nyou individuals who told you that they know either \n7 \nmyself or Paul Cassell? \n8 \nA. \nI didn't ask that question. It was just \n9 \n-- it was quick conversation and one of them said, \n10 \nI'll do anything to help. \n11 \nQ. \nOkay. What is the identity of the person \n12 \nwho will do anything to help you? \n13 \nA. \nHis name is Jeffrey Levy. He is an \n14 \nattorney here. \n15 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: \"Here\" meaning \n16 \nwhere? \n17 \nA. \nIn Fort Lauderdale. He's a family lawyer. \n18 \nJust out of the blue, I don't know him from Adam. \n19 \nBut this happens to me all the time. When I go to \n20 \nMiami tomorrow, I'll be walking down Lincoln Road, \n21 \npeople will come over to me and tell me about you. \n22 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n23 \nQ. \nOkay. Can you give me the cards of the \n24 \nother people that have given you these cards all the \n25 \ntime so that we can --\nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726858\n", "char_count": 1144}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "792 \n1 \nA. \nNo. The only reason I asked for this card \n2 \ntoday, I asked him for the card because I said, I \n3 \nwant to be able to mention this if I'm asked about \n4 \nit in the deposition. Would you mind giving me the \n5 \ncard? \n6 \nHe said, \"I'm thrilled.\" He went to his \n7 \ncar, he got the card, and he said --\n8 \nMR. EDWARDS: I would like to attach the \n9 \ncard of Jeffrey Levy to the deposition as the \n10 \nnext consecutive exhibit, which I believe is \n11 \n26. \n12 \n(Thereupon, marked as Plaintiff \n13 \nExhibit 26.) \n14 \nMR. EDWARDS: Can I see the exhibit? \n15 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Sure. \n16 \nMR. SCOTT: Can I see the exhibit, too, \n17 \nwhen you're done? \n18 \nMR. EDWARDS: Yes. \n19 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n20 \nQ. \nOn the back of this card, there is some \n21 \nwriting. Whose writing is that? \n22 \nA. \nMine. \n23 \nQ. \nThe writing, I think, says \"Scarola \n24 \nunethical e-mail\"? \n25 \nA. \nThat's right. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726859\n", "char_count": 955}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "793 \n1 \nQ. \nAnd does that scribbling of \"Scarola \n2 \nunethical e-mail\" relate at all to this card? \n3 \nA. \nNot directly, no. Not directly. \n4 \nQ. \nDid this lawyer, Jeffrey Levy, discuss \n5 \nwith you Jack Scarola at all? \n6 \nA. \nNo. He just discussed just the lawyers \n7 \ngenerically and their unethical conduct. \n8 \nQ. \nAnd the lawyers generically, he's talking \n9 \nabout the lawyers who believe \n10 \nA. \nNo. The lawyers who pretend to believe \n11 \nNone of us think you believe her. \n12 \nNobody I know thinks you believe her. \n13 \nQ. \nNobody you know thinks \n14 \nA. \nThat's right. \n15 \nQ. \nAny of the people you described yesterday, \n16 \nwhich is now inclusive of Brad Edwards, Paul \n17 \nCassell, Jack Scarola, Sigrid McCawley and David \n18 \nBoise, believe \n; that's your \n19 \ntestimony? \n20 \nA. \nThat's right, and Sigrid McCawley told me \n21 \nthat. \n22 \nMS. McCAWLEY: I'm sorry, I'm going to \n23 \nobject. This again -- so I have no idea what \n24 \ncontext, or if you're referring to a context \n25 \nwhere we were having settlement discussions, \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726860\n", "char_count": 1097}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "794 \n1 \nthat violates the seal order that's already in \n2 \nplace. There's a motion for sanctions pending. \n3 \nWe will be supplementing with this. \n4 \nYou know, how many times do we have to go \n5 \nover this, Alan? It's not appropriate. First \n6 \nof all, you're misrepresenting things. And \n7 \nI'll state for the record, I did not say that. \n8 \nBut secondly --\n9 \nTHE WITNESS: She's waiving privilege. \n10 \nMS. McCAWLEY: No, I'm not waiving the \n11 \nprivilege. \n12 \nTHE WITNESS: Yes, you are. \n13 \nMS. McCAWLEY: I'm denying the allegation \n14 \nthat you just made on the record. I'm making \n15 \nmy record that you are not entitled to discuss \n16 \nanything that deals with confidential \n17 \nsettlement discussions. Misrepresenting those \n18 \nis a violation of that, and I'll go back to the \n19 \njudge and get another order if I need to. \n20 \nTHE WITNESS: I was asked a question --\n21 \nMR. SIMPSON: Don't \n22 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Hang on. \n23 \nMR. SCAROLA: Could we have \n24 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Is there \n25 \nanything else, Ms. McCawley? \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726861\n", "char_count": 1098}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "795 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \nMS. McCAWLEY: No, not right now. \nMR. SCAROLA: Could we have the question \nand the answer read back, please. \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Let's go ahead \nand do that, just for purposes of \nCOURT REPORTER: \"Any of the people you \ndescribed yesterday, which is now inclusive of \n8 \nBrad Edwards, Paul Cassell, Jack Scarola, \n9 \nSigrid McCawley and David Boise, believe \n10 \n; that's your testimony? \n11 \n\"That's right, and Sigrid McCawley told me \n12 \nthat.\" \n13 \nA. \nThat's absolutely responsive. \n14 \nMR. SCAROLA: We move to strike the \"and \n15 \nSigrid McCawley told me that\" comment as \n16 \nunresponsive to the question that was asked. \n17 \nAnd we agree that it is clearly violative of \n18 \nthe Court order that has been entered with \n19 \nrespect to this matter. \n20 \nMR. SIMPSON: The question on its face \n21 \nasked about Ms. McCawley. It was Mr. Edwards \n22 \nthat injected her views into the question. It \n23 \nwas not the witness. \n24 \nSPECIAL MASTERPOZZUOLI: Go back up to the \n25 \nquestion. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726862\n", "char_count": 1073}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "796 \n1 \nTHE WITNESS: I'm happy to have it sealed \n2 \nif you want. \n3 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Hold on a \n4 \nsecond. Go back up to the question. \n5 \nCOURT REPORTER: \"QUESTION: Any of the \n6 \npeople you described yesterday, which is now \n7 \ninclusive of Brad Edwards, Paul Cassell, Jack \n8 \nScarola, Sigrid McCawley and David Boise, \n9 \nbelieve \n; that's your \n10 \ntestimony? \n11 \n\"ANSWER: That's right, and Sigrid \n12 \nMcCawley told me that.\" \n13 \nMR. SCAROLA: The responsive answer ends \n14 \nwith \"and that's right.\" Excuse me. \"That's \n15 \nright,\" period. \n16 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Give me a \n17 \nsecond. I'll grant the Motion to Strike from \n18 \n\"and\" all the way to the end. \n19 \nA. \nI'm also happy to have it sealed, if they \n20 \nchoose to. \n21 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Well, I don't \n22 \nknow what is going to come up, but it will be \n23 \ndealt with one way or another. \n24 \nMR. SIMPSON: The witness said we would be \n25 \nhappy to have it sealed, given that ruling. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726863\n", "char_count": 1031}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "797 \n1 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n2 \nQ. \nThis attorney, Jeffrey Levy, did he \n3 \nelaborate upon the basis for his offer to help you \n4 \nagainst the generically described unscrupulous \n5 \nlawyers, question mark? \n6 \nA. \nYes, he basically said these are lawyers \n7 \nwho are willing to make these outrageous charges, \n8 \nand lawyers shouldn't be making these kinds of \n9 \noutrageous charges against other lawyers, especially \n10 \nwhen they're irrelevant. And basically he seemed to \n11 \nknow a little bit about -- not much, but a little \n12 \nbit about the case. \n13 \nBut I use it as an illustration of people \n14 \ncoming to me all the time making these statements to \n15 \nhelp amplify my answer. It's why I can't remember \n16 \nnames. Normally I wouldn't have asked him his name. \n17 \nI only asked him his name because of your questions \n18 \nof me today. But every -- virtually every week --\n19 \nin the beginning, it was every day, people would \n20 \ncome over to me with these kinds of statements. \n21 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Okay. \n22 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n23 \nQ. \nBut is this lawyer's opinion, am I \n24 \nunderstanding that that -- that's something you \n25 \nweigh in to support your public statements that you \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726864\n", "char_count": 1250}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "798 \n1 \nhave made? \n2 \nA. \nI look at the totality of circumstances. \n3 \nI look at my professional opinion, I look at what \n4 \nI've read, I look at what I've told, I try to \n5 \ncalibrate, weigh everything for what it's worth and \n6 \nthen I come to an opinion. \n7 \nAnd my opinion that I arrived at was based \n8 \nat the totality of the circumstances that I was \n9 \naware of at the time I made this statement. And the \n10 \nstatement turns out to be true. \n11 \nQ. \nAnd Jeffrey Levy, whatever his opinion is, \n12 \nis one of the things that you're factoring in at \n13 \nthis point? \n14 \nA. \nNo, of course not. Of course not. \n15 \nQ. \nOkay. \n16 \nA. \nNot now, I don't have to factor anything \n17 \nin. I now know the truth. I now know from other \n18 \npeople that this was all part of an extortion plot \n19 \nand that the object of the extortion was Leslie \n20 \nWexner. But I'm aware of that now, so I don't have \n21 \nto base the opinion on anything else. \n22 \nMR. EDWARDS: Objection. Move to strike. \n23 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: I'm going to go \n24 \nahead and move -- grant the Motion to Strike. \n25 \nGo back up. Let me just see where -- because I \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726865\n", "char_count": 1191}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "799 \n1 \nwanted to find -- so from \"I now know from \n2 \nother people this is all part of an extortion \n3 \nplot,\" from there down, we'll strike. \n4 \nSo what will remain is \"not now, I don't \n5 \nhave to factor anything in. I now know the \n6 \ntruth.\" That will remain. \n7 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n8 \nQ. \nOkay. What are the identities of the \n9 \nother two individuals that you encountered during \n10 \nyour lunch break? \n11 \nA. \nOne of them is a woman, a lawyer and --\n12 \nMR. SCAROLA: He asked for a name. \n13 \nA. \nI don't know the names. I didn't ask the \n14 \nnames from anybody. \n15 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n16 \nQ. \nIs there a description that would help me \n17 \nlearn the identity of this person? \n18 \nA. \nShe was in her 40s, probably. She had \n19 \nshort, cropped hair. \n20 \nQ. \nIs this somebody who knew the lawyers who \n21 \nhad accused you by reputation? \n22 \nA. \nI don't know. I don't know. I'm just \n23 \ngiving you an illustration of what people tell me \n24 \nall the time. \n25 \nQ. \nOkay. During the lunch break, did you \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726866\n", "char_count": 1062}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "800 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n1 \nhave a chance to consider whether you were willing \n2 \nto waive the attorney-client privilege with respect \n3 \nto the identities of the individuals with whom you \n4 \nshare a privilege in the circumstance where you are \n5 \nthe client, that provided you information that \n6 \nhelped form the basis of your opinions about Paul \n7 \nCassell and Brad Edwards? \n8 \nMR. SCOTT: We've instructed my client not \nto waive the privilege. \nMR. SCAROLA: Both privileges? \nMR. SCOTT: Yes. \nMR. SCAROLA: And by \"both,\" I mean both \nattorney-client and work product. \nMR. SCOTT: Yes, sir. \nMR. SCAROLA: Thank you. \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \nQ. \nIsn't another reason that \npublicly that you could not have --\nyou have given \nthat anybody who \nknows you would know that you could not have and \nwould not have committed such an offense, you're not \nthat kind of person? \nA. \nThat's right. \nQ. \nAnd similar to what you did with respect \nto Paul Cassell and reading about what is public out \nthere about him to form the basis of your belief in \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726867\n", "char_count": 1140}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "801 \n1 \nhis credibility and reputation, you would agree that \n2 \nit's also fair to have done the same thing with \n3 \nrespect to you, correct? \n4 \nA. \nYes. \n5 \nQ. \nOkay. Is it -- do you or have you in the \n6 \npast enjoyed getting naked at clothing-optional \n7 \nbeaches in Martha's Vineyard? \n8 \nA. \nWhen I was --\n9 \nMR. SCOTT: Objection, relevancy to that. \n10 \nInvasion of privacy. Has no relevancy \n11 \nwhatsoever. I would like a ruling. \n12 \nMR. EDWARDS: It is reasonably calculated \n13 \nto lead to the discovery of admissible \n14 \nevidence. \n15 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: I'm going to \n16 \ndeny the objection, but give you -- latitude is \n17 \nnot unlimited. \n18 \nMR. EDWARDS: I understand. \n19 \nA. \nWould you give me a time frame? \n20 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n21 \nQ. \nSure. At around October 15, 2001, which \n22 \nis a time period we have agreed falls within the \n23 \nrelevant time period of this case. \n24 \nA. \nSo I have to give a lengthy answer to \n25 \nthis. There is a beach on Martha's Vineyard which \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726868\n", "char_count": 1053}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "802 \n1 \nhas traditionally been a clothing-optional beach. \n2 \nRumors are that Eleanor Roosevelt use to skinny dip \n3 \nthere. Many prominent people have skinny dipped on \n4 \nthat beach, and my wife and I have occasionally \n5 \nskinny dipped on that beach. Yes. Not in recent \n6 \nyears. \n7 \nQ. \nWere you asked at some point to represent \n8 \na woman by the name of Nikki Craft? \n9 \nA. \nYes. \n10 \nQ. \nAnd with respect to that representation or \n11 \nattempted representation, have you read the \n12 \nstatement that she has put out publicly regarding \n13 \nyou? \n14 \nA. \nI don't recall, but I can tell you what \n15 \nthe facts of the case were and why I turned down \n16 \nrepresentation, if you would like to hear it. \n17 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Let him ask his \n18 \nquestion. \n19 \nMR. EDWARDS: Sure. \n20 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Sure? \n21 \nMR. EDWARDS: No, no. \n22 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Oh, okay. Go \n23 \nahead. \n24 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n25 \nQ. \nHave you -- do you know that she has said \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726869\n", "char_count": 1035}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "803 \n1 \nthat she has written \"Does there exist for \n2 \nDershowitz an overpowering thrill of seeing the \n3 \nfemale nude such as to prevent him from seeing the \n4 \nissues from a woman's viewpoint?\" \n5 \nA. \nI think she also called me Mengele in the \n6 \narticle \nShe compared me to Mengele, the nazi \n7 \nkiller. She was furious that I wouldn't take her \n8 \ncase because she wanted to walk topless down the \n9 \nmiddle of the city in the middle of the street, and \n10 \nI don't believe in that. \n11 \nI had represented the nude beach in Truro, \n12 \nMassachusetts, where people want to go skinny \n13 \ndipping in private areas, but I do not believe that \n14 \nanybody has the right to be nude or topless in \n15 \npublic. I turned down her case. I never met her. \n16 \nShe wrote to me, and I wrote back turning down her \n17 \ncase. \n18 \nAnd she just went on a rampage against me. \n19 \nAs far as I know, she's never met me. She's never \n20 \nseen me. And she has just written, I remember, and \n21 \nattacked me. She went on the radio and attacked me \n22 \nall because I refused to represent her walking \n23 \ntopless through the city. \n24 \nQ. \nOkay. And part of that rampage was her \n25 \nunderstanding of your \"eager response to naked women \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726870\n", "char_count": 1275}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "804 \n1 \ncould be compared with that of a little boy let \n2 \nloose in a candy store\"? \n3 \nA. \nShe doesn't know me. That was something \n4 \nshe just made up. \n5 \nMR. SCOTT: I need a ruling on relevancy. \n6 \nBut, I mean, reading statements from people \n7 \nfrom articles and asking him about them is \n8 \ntotally irrelevant. Goes to nothing in this \n9 \ncase. \n10 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Ask your \nI'm \n11 \nhoping that you're going to tie this up to \n12 \nsomething. \n13 \nMR. EDWARDS: Sure. \n14 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n15 \nQ. \nCan you -- well, let's go back first. \n16 \nCan you provide me the articles -- all of \n17 \nthe articles on Paul Cassell that you have testified \n18 \nabout today? \n19 \nA. \nI'm sure I can. \n20 \nQ. \nCan you provide them to me now? \n21 \nA. \nNo. I told you I looked at them a year \n22 \nago. \n23 \nQ. \nBut it's fair for you to review those \n24 \narticles and tell me what is in them, correct? \n25 \nA. \nAt some point, but I'm not going to do it \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726871\n", "char_count": 1004}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "805 \n1 \nright -- I can't do it now. I don't have it in \n2 \nfront of me. \n3 \nQ. \nOn your Harvard website, is there a \n4 \ncompilation of articles which you've written in the \n5 \npast? \n6 \nA. \nI haven't looked at my website, but I've \n7 \nwritten, I think, over a thousand articles. \n8 \nQ. \nAt some point in time, did you write for \n9 \nHustler magazine? \n10 \nA. \nNo. \n11 \nQ. \nDid you publish in Hustler magazine? \n12 \nA. \nNo. \n13 \nQ. \nNone of your articles were published in \n14 \nHustler magazine? \n15 \nA. \nNo. I was once called the \"asshole of the \n16 \nmonth\" by Hustler magazine because I refused to \n17 \nrepresent Mr. Flint, and he had a picture of my face \n18 \ncoming out of the rectum of a donkey, calling me \n19 \n\"asshole of the month.\" But I didn't publish that, \n20 \nI assure you. \n21 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Tell me that \n22 \nwe're going to get somewhere with this, because \n23 \nthis is -- you know, see if we can tie this up \n24 \nin some form. \n25 \nMR. EDWARDS: Okay. Let me just put on \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726872\n", "char_count": 1049}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "806 \n1 \nthe record why this is reasonably calculated is \n2 \nthe statement was made by Mr. Dershowitz that \n3 \nhe's not the kind of person to have done this. \n4 \nTHE WITNESS: To have raped a 16-year-old. \n5 \nMR. EDWARDS: Our client -- our client has \n6 \ndescribed certain things about Mr. Dershowitz, \n7 \nand if those certain things that she has \n8 \ndescribed are consistent with things that he \n9 \ndoes believe in or has done in the past, then \n10 \nthat would add credibility to our client. \n11 \nTHE WITNESS: Would you tell me what your \n12 \nclient --\n13 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Hang on a \n14 \nsecond. \n15 \nMR. EDWARDS: I don't have to do that. I \n16 \ncan just discover on this subject matter. \n17 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: I'm going to let \n18 \nyou. But the idea that he might have skinny \n19 \ndipped with his wife is slightly different. So \n20 \nI would -- I mean, I don't see that as \n21 \nrelevant, but I'm going to let you continue. I \n22 \nmean, because it's not my role here to decide \n23 \nthat. \n24 \nBut I'm just saying to you that I get \n25 \nwhere you're going. So, proceed through this, \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726873\n", "char_count": 1150}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "807 \n1 \nbut let's get to -- this is going to be \n2 \nforever. I mean, because he's got a thousand \n3 \narticles published, you can go through each of \n4 \nthem and pick out whatever or whatever it is. \n5 \nSo let's \n6 \nMR. EDWARDS: There are two other things \n7 \nat issue here. One is at the time that these \n8 \npleadings were placed, what was our -- what was \n9 \nPaul Cassell and Brad Edwards' mind state. The \n10 \nother thing is Mr. Dershowitz has a claim for \n11 \ndamages to his sterling reputation. So to the \n12 \ndegree that there is some damage to reputation \n13 \ncaused by some other source, then that is \n14 \nsomething else that should be -- we should have \n15 \ndiscovery into. \n16 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: That's why I'm \n17 \nallowing the latitude. \n18 \nMR. EDWARDS: Thank you. \n19 \nMR. SCOTT: There is certain relevance to \n20 \nsome of that. I mean, going into a lot of \n21 \nthese different things is -- you know, it's \n22 \nyears ago into the past and things like that. \n23 \nIt's just ridiculous. It's irrelevant. \n24 \nAnd I think you get -- we're going to ask \n25 \nyou to make a decision on these things as they \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726874\n", "char_count": 1174}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "808 \n1 \ncome up if this is going on to go on for hour \n2 \nafter hour asking things over a man's life of \n3 \n70-some years. \n4 \nTHE WITNESS: Seventy-seven. \n5 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Ask your next \n6 \nquestion. \n7 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n8 \nQ. \nSure. Did you write articles on behalf of \n9 \nPenthouse magazine? \n10 \nA. \nI was Robert Guccione's lawyer on First \n11 \nAmendment issues, and he asked me to do a column \n12 \nevery month on First Amendment and justice issues, \n13 \nand I did that for 25 years, virtually every month \n14 \nwriting an article on justice and the First \n15 \nAmendment. \n16 \nQ. \nHave you ever written an article about the \n17 \nidea that viewing child pornography should not be a \n18 \ncrime? \n19 \nA. \nI can tell you my position. My position \n20 \nis that creating child pornography should be a \n21 \ncrime, but that viewing -- I think I wrote about \n22 \nviewing virtual child pornography; that is, \n23 \ncontrived images that are not real. And the Supreme \n24 \nCourt supported me on that position. \n25 \nSupreme Court has ruled consistent with my \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726875\n", "char_count": 1112}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "809 \n1 \nposition that when you have computer-generated \n2 \npictures of children that the focus should be on \n3 \nmaking of the pornography, which is a crime, but not \n4 \non the viewing of the pornography. \n5 \nAnd I have a view, a scientific view that \n6 \nI've published about, written many articles about, \n7 \nthat there is no relationship between the viewing of \n8 \npornography and commission of violent crimes. And I \n9 \nhave the data to support that. And I think I'm one \n10 \nof the leading authorities on that issue. It's an \n11 \nacademic issue of some considerable interest me. \n12 \nQ. \nYou're one of the leading authorities on \n13 \nthe issue that --\n14 \nA. \nOf the causation -- the relationship \n15 \nbetween viewing pornography and crimes of violence. \n16 \nQ. \nViewing child pornography? \n17 \nA. \nI would say in general. I don't know that \n18 \nI distinguish between that in the scientific \n19 \nresearch that I've done. \n20 \nQ. \nI'm going to go ahead and show you what's \n21 \nbeen marked as Exhibit 27. I'll show it to your \n22 \nlawyer first. Ask if you recognize it. \n23 \nMR. SIMPSON: Do you have a copy for us? \n24 \nMR. EDWARDS: That's my only copy. We'll \n25 \nuse it --\nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726876\n", "char_count": 1230}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "810 \n1 \nMR. SCOTT: You know, I asked \nI'm going \n2 \nto put this on. I asked yesterday to have \n3 \ncopies of exhibits. \n4 \nMR. SCAROLA: I think we do have a copy, \n5 \nbefore you get all exorcized over this. \n6 \nMR. SCOTT: By the way --\n7 \nMR. SCAROLA: I think we do have a copy. \n8 \nMR. SCOTT: Okay. And by the way, the \n9 \nthing you published from the Bench & Bar, \n10 \nit's -- you said it was in the exhibits. It's \n11 \nnot. \n12 \nMR. SCAROLA: I told you if it's not \n13 \nthere, we'll get it for you. \n14 \nMR. SCOTT: Yeah. I'd like it today, if \n15 \nyou could get it, because that's what you said \n16 \nyesterday. \n17 \n(Thereupon, marked as Plaintiff \n18 \nExhibit 27.) \n19 \nMR. SCAROLA: I said tell us what else you \n20 \nneed, and we'll get it for you. \n21 \nTHE WITNESS: So not only is my --\n22 \nMR. SIMPSON: Wait a minute. Hang on. \n23 \nThat's the witness's. \n24 \nMR. SCOTT: Is this the witness's copy? \n25 \nMR. SIMPSON: You can have this one, Tom. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726877\n", "char_count": 1003}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "811 \n1 \nMR. SCOTT: There's some notes on there. \n2 \nI don't know if you want them, but --\n3 \nMR. EDWARDS: I'll take it. \n4 \nMR. SCOTT: I think they're your \n5 \nquestions. I could be wrong. I could have \n6 \nhanded it to him, it would have probably \n7 \nexpedited it. \n8 \nMR. EDWARDS: I doubt it. \n9 \nA. \nOkay. I remember writing this article. \n10 \nIt grew out of a pro bono case that I did \n11 \nrepresenting a student. \n12 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n13 \nQ. \nDoes that article limit the opinion of \n14 \nthat viewing child pornography or children \n15 \nfornicating should not be criminal to virtual child \n16 \npornography? \n17 \nA. \nI think I say in the article -- I asked \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \ndemocracy. I say there is a potential here for a \n24 \nreal witch hunt. Child molestation is a serious \n25 \nproblem. The creation of child pornography is also \nthe question: But should it be a crime for someone \nwho has never and would never molest a child to view \nchild pornography? \nI think I raised that question. And I \ntalk about the dangers to the values of the \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726878\n", "char_count": 1105}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "812 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n1 \na serious problem. We don't know whether the \n2 \nviewing of child pornography is or is not a serious \n3 \nproblem, but many people think it is. \n4 \nSo, I don't think I take a definitive \n5 \nview. I am an academic. You're trying not only to \n6 \nput my ideas on trial here today, what I've written \n7 \nabout on trial; you're trying to put my advocacy on \n8 \nbehalf of defendants on trial, you're putting the \nSixth Amendment on trial, you're putting the First \nAmendment on trial. You're inviting the American \nCivil Liberties Union, the National Association of \nCriminal Defense Lawyers to intervene in this case, \nbecause they will not stand by and tolerate an \n14 \nacademic having his ideas put on trial or an \n15 \nadvocate -- I was going to say a zealous advocate, \n16 \nand I claim that, I am a zealous advocate, putting \n17 \nhis representation on trial. That is unAmerican. \n18 \nThat is McCarthyite and is beneath contempt. \n19 \nMR. EDWARDS: Object and move to strike. \n20 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Denied. Denied. \n21 \nMove forward. \n22 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n23 \nQ. \nIs Paul Cassell also an academic? \n24 \nA. \nPaul Cassell teaches and uses the \n25 \nstationery of law school as part of his --\nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726879\n", "char_count": 1271}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "813 \n1 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Answer the \n2 \nquestion. \n3 \nA. \nHe is an academic. \n4 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n5 \nQ. \nWhen was that article that has now been \n6 \nmarked as 27 written? \n7 \nA. \nCopyrighted 2002. \n8 \nQ. \nIs 2002 within the relevant time period \n9 \nthat we've defined in this case? \n10 \nA. \nYes, but I've written articles like this \n11 \nas far back as probably as 1967, and I've written \n12 \nthem probably as recently as the last couple of \n13 \nyears. I have a book which deals with the subject. \n14 \nI have a long Law Review article called \"Why \n15 \nPornography?\" \n16 \nSo to focus on that year seems to me as to \n17 \nwrench out of context the fact that this has been my \n18 \nview. I had a debate with William Buckley about it \n19 \nat Harvard University. I had a debate with --\n20 \ninterestingly enough, I had a debate with Ginsberg, \n21 \nthe poet, in which I took the opposite view in which \n22 \nI was very, very tough on child pornography, talking \n23 \nabout how much I despise it and hate it and think \n24 \nit's immoral and improper. \n25 \nBut just because I think something is \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726880\n", "char_count": 1142}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "814 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \nimmoral and horrible doesn't mean I necessarily \nthink it should be criminal. Unlike some people, I \ndon't necessarily associate my personal views of \nconduct with what I think should be illegal or who I \nwould represent. \nQ. \nHave you ever had any of your articles \n7 \nthat you have written removed from your Harvard \n8 \nwebsite? \n9 \nA. \nNot that I know of. That would be a \n10 \nviolation of academic freedom. \n11 \nQ. \nIs there any reason why the article that \n12 \nis now number 27 is, as of February of 2015, no \n13 \nlonger on your website? \n14 \nA. \nI doubt that that's true. I doubt that it \n15 \nwas removed. I don't think every article \nlet me \n16 \ntell you, unequivocally, I did not remove it, order \n17 \nit to be removed or know it was removed. I doubt it \n18 \nwas removed. I can't imagine why anybody would ever \n19 \nremove any article. I'm very proud of this article. \n20 \nQ. \nIs there any explanation for that \n21 \nparticular article being within the articles on your \n22 \nwebsite at some point and later no longer appearing \n23 \non your website? \n24 \nA. \nI don't think that's true. And if it is, \n25 \nI have no idea how it happened or why it happened. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726881\n", "char_count": 1239}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "815 \n1 \nIt's not something I would ever tolerate being done. \n2 \nThere isn't a single article I would remove from my \n3 \nwebsite. I'm proud of every article I've written. \n4 \nAnd I'm sure you will find many other articles. \n5 \nI don't know what my website includes. \n6 \nBut there is a book that's been written that honors \n7 \nme by University of Albany Law School and contains \n8 \nin the back all of my articles. I don't know that \n9 \nmy website does more than have a selection of my \n10 \narticles. So I would have to look. But I'm not \n11 \naware of it. I don't handle my website. \n12 \nQ. \nWho decides which articles are placed on \n13 \nthe website and which are taken off of the website? \n14 \nA. \nMy assistant, Sarah Neely. \n15 \nQ. \nIs Sarah Neely somebody who has been \n16 \ninvolved in any aspect of the defense of this \n17 \nparticular case? \n18 \nA. \nShe's just my assistant, she's my \n19 \nsecretary. She does all of my typing and does \n20 \neverything that I do. So she's been involved in \n21 \nevery aspect of my life since she worked for me \n22 \nabout eight years ago. \n23 \nQ. \nIs there anyone other than Sarah Neely who \n24 \nwould put an article up on the website or remove the \n25 \narticle from the website? \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726882\n", "char_count": 1266}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "816 \n1 \nA. \nNot that I know of. \n2 \nQ. \nAnd is she permitted to remove any \n3 \narticles from the website without your permission? \n4 \nA. \nI have no idea. I've never ever read my \n5 \nwebsite. I am not a web person. I don't know \n6 \nwhat's on my website. And she also does tweeter or \n7 \nTwitter. I have no idea. She circulates some \n8 \narticles, she doesn't do anything, I have no control \n9 \nover that. And I had nothing to do, nothing, zero, \n10 \nwith either placing the article or if it was \n11 \nremoved, removing the article. Zero percent. \n12 \nQ. \nOkay. Have you ever called for a complete \n13 \noverhaul of rape laws in Massachusetts? \n14 \nA. \nOne of my academic subjects that I've been \n15 \ninterested in for many, many years has been the \n16 \ndefinition of rape and the idea of consent. \n17 \nAnd I recently wrote an article calling \n18 \nfor affirmative consent to be required in all rape \n19 \ncases, making the point that it's far better than \n20 \nten consented-to rapes don't -- that ten \n21 \nconsented-to acts of sexuality do not occur rather \n22 \nthan even one unconsented-to act of sexuality occur. \n23 \nSo in other words, I've flipped the \n24 \nBlackstonian notion and say it's far, far better \n25 \nthat voluntary sex not occur in questionable \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726883\n", "char_count": 1308}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "817 \n1 \nsituations than even one act of unconsented-to sex. \n2 \nI'm very much a hawk on the issue of consent and \n3 \nwant to make sure that no sexual encounter ever \n4 \noccurs. And I teach that to my students. And I \n5 \nlecture my students about that. I think the laws of \n6 \nMassachusetts and the laws of many, many other \n7 \nstates are in a complete state of messiness, and I \n8 \nwould be thrilled to have an -- overall rape laws \n9 \nall over the county. \n10 \nQ. \nHave you included within your request for \n11 \na complete overhaul lowering the age of consent \n12 \nconsiderably? \n13 \nA. \nI know I argued in Florida -- we produced \n14 \nsome data in Florida that the age of consent is 18. \n15 \nAnd, by the way, this all happened way, way after \n16 \nthe events at issue. But that the average age of \n17 \ncommencing sex in the state of Florida is well below \n18 \nthat. And, therefore, there is a substantial \n19 \ndisparity in California, which has 18, and Florida, \n20 \nwhich has 18, between the actual activities that \n21 \noccur -- many, many acts of sexual conduct occur \n22 \nbetween the ages of 17 and 18, but the acts are \n23 \nillegal. \n24 \nI have for years, basically since the \n25 \nVietnam War when I argued this, said that when you \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726884\n", "char_count": 1290}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "818 \n1 \nhave tremendous disparity between the law in action \n2 \nand the law on the books, that creates disrespect \n3 \nfor the law. And so what I want to see is a change \n4 \nthat reflects the actual pattern of sexuality \n5 \ncommunity by community, state by state. That's been \n6 \nmy academic position. \n7 \nQ. \nHave you, as far back as 1997, advocated \n8 \nfor lowering the age of consent to 15, as something \n9 \nthat would seem like an appropriate compromise, \n10 \ngiven that reasonable people might disagree on \n11 \nwhether it should be as low as 14? \n12 \nA. \nI don't recall that. If you could show me \n13 \nwhat you claim I said, I would be happy to look at \n14 \nit. I don't recall that. I do not believe the age \n15 \nof consent should be 15. \n16 \nQ. \nOkay. Have you ever believed that age of \n17 \nconsent should be 15? \n18 \nA. \nI have no recollection of that. But if \n19 \nyou could show me what you claim I said, I will be \n20 \nhappy to look at it and read it in context. \n21 \nQ. \nThat's not a belief that you have today? \n22 \nA. \nThat's not a believe that I have today, \n23 \nno. \n24 \nQ. \nDo you currently have a place at 1500 \n25 \nOcean Drive, Miami Beach? \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726885\n", "char_count": 1212}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "819 \n1 \nA. \nI do. \n2 \nQ. \nAnd is that near a clothing-optional \n3 \nbeach? \n4 \nA. \nNo. Not that I know of. I'm not aware of \n5 \nany. \n6 \nQ. \nIs there instances where you have seen \n7 \nwomen lying out nude on the beach near your condo? \n8 \nMR. SCOTT: You know, really the relevancy \n9 \nof this is so strained. \n10 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: You really are \n11 \nstraining the relevancy. But go ahead. It's \n12 \nyour time. Go ahead. I'm not going to --\n13 \nA. \nAny human being who is not blind who has \n14 \nwalked on any part of South Beach has seen a vast, \n15 \nvast, vast, vast majority of men and women are \n16 \ndressed in totally appropriate bathing suits, and \n17 \noccasionally there are some who are not. \n18 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n19 \nQ. \nHave you, at your condominium complex, \n20 \nearned the reputation as somebody who goes out onto \n21 \nthe beach anytime there is a nude girl? \n22 \nA. \nNo. What you're talking about is last \n23 \nyear my wife ran for the condo board, and she ran \n24 \nagainst another group of people, and they were \n25 \nexchanging insults. And one of the women whose \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726886\n", "char_count": 1137}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "820 \n1 \nhusband was running against or -- Caroline made an \n2 \nabsurd allegation that everybody -- everybody in the \n3 \ncondo building not only booed her but virtually \n4 \nthrew her out of the building. It was a totally, \n5 \ntotally made-up lie. \n6 \nAnd the fact that you are relying on that \n7 \nkind of nonsense really confirms everything I \n8 \nthought about you. It really confirms everything I \n9 \nthought about you. \n10 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Let's move on. \n11 \nMR. SCAROLA: Not before we move to strike \n12 \nthat last comment. \n13 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: You know, I \n14 \nwould normally agree, but I'm going to let it \n15 \nstand. Go ahead and move forward. \n16 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n17 \nQ. \nOkay. Was there a circumstance, then, \n18 \nthat this individual named Wendy Dawson confronted \n19 \nyour wife and specifically told your wife that \n20 \nyou're a pervert -- is that something that you \n21 \nknow --\n22 \nA. \nYes. \n23 \nQ. \n-- to have happened? \n24 \nA. \nLet me finish. That happened, and my wife \n25 \ntold her what she thought of that, and everybody in \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726887\n", "char_count": 1114}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "821 \n1 \nthe condo, and she is now a completely ostracized \n2 \nperson. She also claims that I called her a slut. \n3 \nAnd her husband threatened to beat me up. And this \n4 \ncaused a lot of tension in the building. But I \n5 \nthink if you ask -- there are 104 tenants in the \n6 \nbuilding. I think 103 of them would tell you she's \n7 \na complete nutcase. \n8 \nQ. \nWell, did she in response to -- well, did \n9 \nyou confront her and specifically say, \"I'm going to \n10 \nruin your life. You don't know what I'm capable of. \n11 \nYou're going to be sorry that you said that to my \n12 \nwife\"? \n13 \nA. \nNo. \n14 \nMR. SCOTT: Can I ask what you are reading \n15 \nfrom? \n16 \nMR. EDWARDS: Sure. It's a Miami-Dade \n17 \npolice report that was made in 2014 by somebody \n18 \nat the condominium against Alan Dershowitz. \n19 \nA. \nNot somebody at the condominium. This \n20 \nwoman. \n21 \nMR. SCOTT: Can we mark this as an \n22 \nexhibit, please. \n23 \nA. \nAnd it was totally ignored, and the police \n24 \nsaid they didn't believe her. \n25 \nMR. EDWARDS: Sure. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726888\n", "char_count": 1081}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "822 \n1 \n(Thereupon, marked as Plaintiff \n2 \nExhibit 28.) \n3 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n4 \nQ. \nDid you know that this police report was \n5 \nmade against you? \n6 \nA. \nI think I was told that it was, yeah. You \n7 \nknow, I also had a report made --\n8 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Hang on a \n9 \nsecond. \n10 \nA. \nOkay. But I want to illustrate how many \n11 \nreports were made against me. I was charged with \n12 \nharassing students at Johns Hopkins University \n13 \nbecause I refused to acknowledge that Israel commits \n14 \nwar crimes. And as a result of my silence on \n15 \nwhether Israel commits war crimes, I was charged \n16 \nwith harassing students. Do you want to ask me \n17 \nabout that as well or other kinds of allegations? \n18 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n19 \nQ. \nWhen did that happen? \n20 \nA. \nThis happened about three months ago. \n21 \nAnother Arab group accused -- filed a Bar \n22 \ncomplaint against me at one point because I support \n23 \nIsrael, I am therefore a war criminal. \n24 \nA professor at Ohio University named --\n25 \noh, God, I can't remember his name now -- Boyle, I \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726889\n", "char_count": 1111}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "823 \n1 \nthink, accused me of being a war criminal. \n2 \nDo you want to go down the list of things \n3 \nthat I've been accused of? I acknowledge I am a \n4 \nvery controversial person. I'm a lightening rod for \n5 \ncontroversy and criticism. That bears nothing on my \n6 \npersonal conduct and integrity. \n7 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Go ahead and \n8 \nmove forward. \n9 \nMR. SCOTT: Did we mark that as an \n10 \nexhibit? \n11 \nMR. EDWARDS: Twenty-eight. \n12 \nMR. SCOTT: Thank you, ma'am. \n13 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n14 \nQ. \nAre you also familiar with somebody named \n15 \nNoam Chomsky? \n16 \nA. \nYes. He was my counselor at Camp Massad \n17 \nin 19- -- or counselor in my division at Camp Massad \n18 \nin 1948, so I've known him for 67 years. \n19 \nQ. \nThis is somebody who was voted the world's \n20 \nleading public intellectual, whatever that title --\n21 \nA. \nHe wasn't voted. He was named that. \n22 \nNobody voted on it. \n23 \nQ. \nAnd is this somebody who has repeatedly \n24 \nand publicly labeled you as a dedicated liar? \n25 \nA. \nHe and I have had an enormous and public \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726890\n", "char_count": 1101}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "824 \n1 \ncontroversy that's gone on for -- since 1970 when I \n2 \nfirst debated him. And the controversy is well \n3 \nknown. I've debated him on many occasions, and I \n4 \nthink beaten him on every such occasion. \n5 \nHe is a radical anti-American, hard left, \n6 \nAmerican hater. Virtual anti-Semite. And we have \n7 \nvery little respect for each other's views. That's \n8 \nin the form of public controversy, yes. But he has \n9 \nnever pinpointed -- in fact, in a recent debate, I \n10 \ngave the students list of ten -- a bunch of things \n11 \nthat he said, and I challenged the students to \n12 \nGoogle him for accuracy, and I got back dozens and \n13 \ndozens of responses saying that clearly he had \n14 \nmisstated all the facts, and they had checked my \n15 \nfacts, and my facts were accurately stated. \n16 \nQ. \nCan you tell me each of the days during \n17 \nbetween the period of 1999 and 2002 when you were in \n18 \nthe presence of Jeffrey Epstein? \n19 \nMR. SCOTT: Objection. Overly broad, \n20 \nasking him to comment about every time he's \n21 \nbeen with someone in three years. \n22 \nMR. INDYKE: Objection. \n23 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Darren, go ahead \n24 \nand make your objection for the record so the \n25 \ncourt reporter can get it. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726891\n", "char_count": 1278}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "825 \n1 \nMR. INDYKE: Objection based upon \n2 \nattorney-client, work product, and instruct not \n3 \nto answer. \n4 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Can you answer \n5 \noutside the privilege? \n6 \nA. \nI can describe to my memory the times that \n7 \nI was in his presence without describing the \n8 \nreason --\n9 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: The nature --\n10 \nA. \n-- I was in his presence. \n11 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: That's fine. Go \n12 \nahead. You can, because the question was --\n13 \nand go back and read the question so we can get \n14 \nyour question answered. \n15 \nCOURT REPORTER: \"Can you tell me each of \n16 \nthe days during -- between the period of 1999 \n17 \nand 2002 when you were in the presence of \n18 \nJeffrey Epstein?\" \n19 \nA. \nAnd that will require a lengthy answer. \n20 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Well, he's asked \n21 \nthe question, and if you can answer it outside \n22 \nthe privilege, because really all we're talking \n23 \nabout now is can you tell me the days. \n24 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n25 \nQ. \nJust the days. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726892\n", "char_count": 1056}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "826 \n1 \nMR. SCOTT: If you can remember. Can you \n2 \nremember specific days? \n3 \nA. \nI can remember some, yeah. So let me \n4 \nfirst say that I was never with Jeffrey Epstein \n5 \nduring that relevant time period on his island. \n6 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n7 \nQ. \nI'm not asking that question. \n8 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: No, no, no. \n9 \nListen, the question is, \"Can you tell me each \n10 \nof the days during -- between the period of \n11 \n1999 and 2002 when you were in the presence of \n12 \nJeffrey Epstein?\" \n13 \nMR. SCOTT: He wants specific dates for \n14 \nthree years. \n15 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: That is the \n16 \nquestion verbatim, because I'm reading it from \n17 \nthe transcript. \n18 \nA. \nOkay. During that period of time, we had \n19 \nlunch at Joe's Stone Crab. We have an entry in the \n20 \ncalendar, which they have. That was during that \n21 \nperiod of time. It was in Miami Beach. \n22 \nMy recollection is each summer during that \n23 \nperiod of time, he flew up to Martha's Vineyard and \n24 \nspent a part of the day with us at my home on \n25 \nMartha's Vineyard with me and my wife and my \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726893\n", "char_count": 1139}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "827 \n1 \nchildren, who were there, with -- at least on one of \n2 \nthose occasions with Ghislaine, maybe more. \n3 \nI think during that period of time, we \n4 \nattended a birthday party for Lord Evelyn Rothschild \n5 \nat which Prince Andrew was in attendance and Lady \n6 \nRothschild was in attendance. Those are the ones \n7 \nthat I can think of right now. \n8 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n9 \nQ. \nBetween 1999 and 2002, did you ever visit \n10 \nJeffrey Epstein's home in Manhattan? \n11 \nMR. INDYKE: Same objection, same \n12 \ninstruction. \n13 \nA. \nIt's possible. I know I visited his \n14 \noffice. He had an office at -- on Fifth -- Madison \n15 \nAvenue, I think, and he would call me periodically \n16 \nto come over to the office to discuss a matter and I \n17 \nwould go to his office. \n18 \nI'm trying to remember if I was at his \n19 \nhome during that period of time. It's very \n20 \npossible. But I have no distinct recollection of \n21 \nwhether I was at his home during that period of time \n22 \nor when it might have been. \n23 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n24 \nQ. \nHow many times have you been to Jeffrey \n25 \nEpstein's home in Manhattan? \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726894\n", "char_count": 1158}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "828 \n1 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: During what \n2 \nperiod of time? During the relevant of time, \n3 \nor are you expanding it? \n4 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n5 \nQ. \nWell, to the extent you can tell me, \n6 \nbetween 1999 and 2002, which I think you just told \n7 \nme, I'm not sure whether I was there or not, right? \n8 \nA. \nI don't -- I'm not sure whether I was \n9 \nthere or not. \n10 \nQ. \nSo let's just broaden it, then. How many \n11 \ntimes have you been to Jeffrey Epstein's home in \n12 \nManhattan ever? \n13 \nMR. SCOTT: Objection. I think that's \n14 \noverly broad. \n15 \nMR. INDYKE: Same objection, same \n16 \ninstruction. \n17 \nA. \nI'm remembering a time. I think I was at \n18 \na party at his house with Vera Wang and another \n19 \nfamous designer, and probably a hundred people. I \n20 \nthink that may have been during that period. \n21 \nI would say I've been at his home less \n22 \nthan a dozen times throughout. Could be a few more \n23 \nthan that, a few less. But it's in that range. It \n24 \nwould be, you know, once a year, maybe twice a year. \n25 \nIt stopped once I finished representing \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726895\n", "char_count": 1125}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "829 \n1 \nhim. Once I finished representing him, our nature \n2 \nof our relationship changed, and I was there only in \n3 \nspecific connection with particular legal questions \n4 \nthat he had for me. \n5 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n6 \nQ. \nWhen did you stop representing him? \n7 \nA. \nWell, I wouldn't say stop representing \n8 \nhim. I'm still representing him, but when the case \n9 \nwas actively over was when he -- we made the plea \n10 \nbargain and he went to jail. \n11 \nQ. \nLet me make it clear. When is the date \n12 \nthat you just described as the date when you stopped \n13 \nrepresenting him but that was the date when your \n14 \nrelationship changed and you no longer went to \n15 \nJeffrey Epstein's home? \n16 \nA. \nOn a social basis. \n17 \nMR. INDYKE: Same objection, same \n18 \ninstruction. \n19 \nMR. SCOTT: Well, I didn't understand the \n20 \nquestion, to be honest with you. If the \n21 \nwitness did, fine. \n22 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: You mixed the \n23 \ntimeframe. \n24 \nDid you understand the question about the \n25 \ntimeframe he was asking about? \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726896\n", "char_count": 1086}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "830 \n1 \nA. \nI think I do, yeah. There came a time \n2 \nwhen we made the deal --\n3 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n4 \nQ. \n\"The deal\" being the nonprosecution \n5 \nagreement? \n6 \nA. \nThe nonprosecution agreement. At that \n7 \npoint, my relationship with Jeffrey Epstein changed. \n8 \nIt was no longer primarily a social -- my \n9 \nrelationship with Jeffrey Epstein fit into three \n10 \ncategories. I was an acquaintance, an academic \n11 \nacquaintance, somebody who I met with him on \n12 \nacademic matters. On occasion, he would ask my \n13 \nadvice about legal matters. And that was between \n14 \nthe time I first met him in the summer of Leslie \n15 \nWexner's 59th birthday, whatever that year is, and \n16 \nthe time that he told me that he had a legal -- that \n17 \nhe was being investigated by the Palm Beach police. \n18 \nSo that's phase one. \n19 \nPhase two, I'm then primarily involved as \n20 \nhis lawyer between the time the investigation begins \n21 \nand the time the deal is struck. \n22 \nOnce the deal is struck, we get into phase \n23 \nthree, and during that phase, I rarely see him. \n24 \nIt's only when he calls me and asks me for advice \n25 \nabout the case, something about -- I can't get into \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726897\n", "char_count": 1228}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "831 \n1 \nwhat it is. But just general advice about the case. \n2 \nI think that's a fair assessment of the three phases \n3 \nof my relationship with him. \n4 \nQ. \nJust so that I understand when phase two \n5 \nended, is it when the nonprosecution agreement was \n6 \nsigned in late 2007 or when Jeffrey Epstein pled \n7 \nguilty in -- June 30, 2008? \n8 \nA. \nI think once the non- --\n9 \nMR. INDYKE: Objection. Same instruction. \n10 \nA. \nI think once the nonprosecution agreement \n11 \nwas reached in theory, once we had a handshake with \n12 \nSloman and with U.S. Attorney, and recall that the \n13 \ndeal was not only struck with Sloman and the U.S. \n14 \nAttorney, but my recollection is it went all the way \n15 \nup to Maine Justice in Washington that had \n16 \ninvolvement in the case as well, once this deal was \n17 \nstruck in principle, my role changed dramatically. \n18 \nI did not have a major role in drafting \n19 \nthe agreement, in implementing the agreement, in the \n20 \ncivil aspects of the agreement. At that point, my \n21 \nrelationship changed. \n22 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n23 \nQ. \nWere you one of the attorneys that was \n24 \ncommunicating directly with Maine Justice? \n25 \nA. \nI think I had. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726898\n", "char_count": 1234}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "832 \n1 \nMR. INDYKE: Same objection, same \n2 \ninstruction. Adding in any settlement \n3 \nconversations objection from yesterday as well. \n4 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n5 \nQ. \nOkay. So the degree to which -- haven't \n6 \nyou publicly made statements about what your role \n7 \nwas on behalf of Jeffrey Epstein with regard to the \n8 \nnonprosecution agreement? \n9 \nA. \nI don't have any current recollection that \n10 \nI made any such statements. I said I thought we \n11 \ngot -- we negotiated very hard, that it was a very \n12 \ntough negotiation. There was a series of \n13 \nnegotiations first with the State Attorney, then \n14 \nwith the Assistant U.S. Attorney, and then with the \n15 \nhead of criminal division and then with the U.S. \n16 \nAttorney himself, Maine Justice, and ultimately a \n17 \ndeal was struck. And I may have described my role. \n18 \nQ. \nA deal that you categorized as an arm's \n19 \nlength --\n20 \nA. \nDefinitely arm's length. \n21 \nQ. \n-- negotiation? \n22 \nA. \nYeah, very tough negotiation. \n23 \nQ. \nAre you unable to tell me, then, what role \n24 \nthat you particularly played with respect to that \n25 \ndeal? \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726899\n", "char_count": 1158}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "833 \n1 \nA. \nYes, I can tell you. \n2 \nQ. \nYou can or cannot? I can't hear you \n3 \nbecause your hand is in front of your mouth. \n4 \nA. \nWell, I need to know whether I'm entitled \n5 \nto, but I can --\n6 \nMR. SIMPSON: Darren? Are you instructing \n7 \nhim not to answer? \n8 \nMR. INDYKE: Yes. Yes. \n9 \nMR. SCAROLA: What is the basis of the \n10 \ninstruction not to answer about communications \n11 \nwith an adversary? \n12 \nMR. INDYKE: Settlement conversations, \n13 \nsettlement discussions. \n14 \nMR. SCAROLA: So the privilege that you \n15 \nare asserting is a confidential settlement \n16 \ndiscussion privilege that precludes discovery \n17 \nof the conversations, correct? \n18 \nMR. INDYKE: Correct. \n19 \nMR. SCAROLA: And you are instructing \n20 \nMr. Dershowitz not to answer on the basis of \n21 \nthat assertion? \n22 \nMR. INDYKE: Yes, as well as \n23 \nattorney-client --\n24 \nMR. SCAROLA: And as Mr. Dershowitz's \n25 \ncounsel --\nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726900\n", "char_count": 965}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "834 \n1 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Could you speak \n2 \nup, Darren, again. \n3 \nMR. INDYKE: Yes. And as well as \n4 \nattorney-client privilege and work product to \n5 \nthe extent it requires -- a response requires \n6 \nhim to invade any of those. \n7 \nMR. SCAROLA: Well, our position clearly \n8 \nis that communications with an adversary cannot \n9 \nbe attorney-client privileged communications. \n10 \nCommunications with an adversary cannot be work \n11 \nproduct communications. And we don't \n12 \nbelieve -- we don't believe any valid privilege \n13 \ncan be asserted to preclude Mr. Dershowitz from \n14 \nanswering the question about communications \n15 \nwith an adversary. \n16 \nSo, I want to know whether in addition to \n17 \nthe objection that is being asserted on behalf \n18 \nof Mr. Epstein, Mr. Dershowitz's counsel is \n19 \ninstructing Mr. Epstein [sic] not to answer \n20 \nthose questions. \n21 \nMR. SCOTT: Say that again. \n22 \nMR. SCAROLA: Yes. We know --\n23 \nMR. SCOTT: I'm sorry, I was reading an \n24 \nexhibit. \n25 \nMR. SCAROLA: We know what Mr. Epstein's \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726901\n", "char_count": 1101}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 53, "text_content": "835 \n1 \nposition is. I don't believe it to be well \n2 \nfounded. \n3 \nI want to know whether you are instructing \n4 \nMr. Dershowitz that he is not to answer the \n5 \nquestions; and, if so, the basis of your \n6 \ninstruction. \n7 \nMR. SCOTT: I'm not. He's following the \n8 \ninstructions of Mr. Epstein's counsel. \n9 \nMR. SCAROLA: Well, he's not obliged to \n10 \nfollow the instructions of Mr. Epstein's \n11 \ncounsel. \n12 \nMR. SCOTT: Well, I think he --\n13 \nMR. SCAROLA: Those instructions have no \n14 \nbasis in the law, and our position is they have \n15 \nno basis in the law. You are not obliged to \n16 \ninstruct him not to answer if you believe they \n17 \nhave no basis in the law. \n18 \nMR. SCOTT: I'm taking no position on \n19 \nthis. \n20 \nMR. SCAROLA: Okay. So is he going to \n21 \nanswer the questions or not? \n22 \nMR. SCOTT: He's not going to answer --\n23 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Hang on, hang \n24 \non, hang on a second. \n25 \nSo I would say the following: We can put \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726902\n", "char_count": 1018}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 54, "text_content": "836 \n1 \nthis in the category of the issues that have to \n2 \nbe dealt with subsequent, and I will overrule \n3 \nthe objection. \n4 \nHowever, I will share that I have had an \n5 \nopportunity to read the 11th Circuit opinion, \n6 \nand I would suggest that the -- particularly \n7 \nthe negotiation and the settlement privilege as \n8 \nasserted runs contrary to that opinion as I've \n9 \nread it. \n10 \nSo, at least to preserve the privilege for \n11 \nnow, I'll overrule the objection and place it \n12 \nin those -- that set of issues that you will \n13 \nhave to address later and will reserve. But I \n14 \nwould suggest to the lawyers --\n15 \nMR. EDWARDS: Overrule or sustain? \n16 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: I'm going to \n17 \noverrule the objection. \n18 \nMR. INDYKE: Your Honor, if I may respond. \n19 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Go ahead. \n20 \nMR. INDYKE: That 11th Circuit decision is \n21 \na decision regarding -- I believe regarding \n22 \nfederal rules, not Florida rules. \n23 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Yeah, I'm aware \n24 \nof the distinction. And that's why I'm going \n25 \nto allow you not -- I'm going to allow the \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726903\n", "char_count": 1152}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 55, "text_content": "837 \n1 \n1 \nwitness not to answer and allow that to be \n2 \nreserved for later on for the decision around \n3 \nthe set of privilege issues that have been \n4 \nraised in the last day and a half. \n5 \nTHE WITNESS: Including the privilege \n6 \nissue raised by Sigrid McCawley. \n7 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Hang on one \n8 \nsecond. Including -- there are four or five \n9 \nprivilege issues that have been raised \n10 \nthroughout the series of this deposition, and I \n11 \nwant to preserve it for the Plaintiffs so they \n12 \ncan deal with that either in front of me or in \n13 \nfront of the judge. And -- after more fully \n14 \nbriefed. \n15 \nTHE WITNESS: Your Honor, can we add to \n16 \nthat the McCawley privilege? \n17 \nMR. INDYKE: Your Honor, just one other \n18 \nthing for the record. \n19 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Hang on one \n20 \nsecond. Darren, hang on one second. \n21 \nMR. INDYKE: Yes, sir. \n22 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: That is \n23 \neither party can raise whatever they want, \n24 \nincluding Ms. McCawley. I'll let that stand on \n25 \nits own. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726904\n", "char_count": 1085}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 56, "text_content": "838 \n1 \nDarren, go ahead. You were going to say \n2 \nsomething. \n3 \nMR. INDYKE: The only point I wanted to \n4 \nraise in response to Mr. Scarola's point that \n5 \ndisclosure to an adversary would never be \n6 \nprivileged is that in any settlement \n7 \ncommunication, the settlement is with an \n8 \nadversary. \n9 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: I understand the \n10 \ndistinction and I understand Mr. Scarola's \n11 \npoint. And so since I am going to basically \n12 \nmove forward with the deposition without having \n13 \nthe witness provide an answer to the question \n14 \nright now, pending a future decision on these \n15 \nset of issues, so we can move forward with the \n16 \ndeposition. \n17 \nMS. McCAWLEY: And I just want to state on \n18 \nthe record that the sanction motions that we \n19 \nhave relating to the seal that's already been \n20 \ngranted is set for February 2, so the Court \n21 \nwill be hearing this issue on that date. \n22 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: And that -- I'll \n23 \nawait Judge Lynch's direction if it impacts \n24 \nanything within my role. \n25 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Thank you. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726905\n", "char_count": 1123}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 57, "text_content": "839 \n1 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n2 \nQ. \nI may be able to shortcut a portion of \n3 \nthis, then, because given that this litigation \n4 \narises out of a pleading filed in the Crime Victims \n5 \nRights Act case and relating to any role that \n6 \nMr. Dershowitz played in the negotiation of the \n7 \nnonprosecution agreement, I have a long series of \n8 \nquestions regarding what exactly he did, what \n9 \nexactly he did not do, who exactly he communicated \n10 \nwith at Maine Justice, the U.S. Attorney's Office, \n11 \nmeetings that he attended, the positions that he \n12 \ntook, all of those things, and rather than waste our \n13 \ntime going through every one of those questions to \n14 \nbe met this objection, if that's what the objection \n15 \nis going to be, I'll skip to another portion. \n16 \nIs that what I'm hearing? In terms of are \n17 \nwe taking that whole section of questions that is \n18 \ngoing to lead to a privilege objection and putting \n19 \nit in this basket to take up with the judge and see \n20 \nif that's an issue to comment on later? \n21 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: I would say it \n22 \nthis way, I can only rule on the question that \n23 \nis pending, first of all. \n24 \nSecond of all, as practical matter, the \n25 \nanswer is probably yes, considering that the \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726906\n", "char_count": 1308}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 58, "text_content": "840 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \ndeposition is not going to conclude today and \nso you're going to have to reset Mr. Dershowitz \nfor a time in the future that is likely to be \nafter you've received some other guidance on \nthese issues. Fair enough? \nMR. EDWARDS: Yes, fair enough. Thank \nyou. \n8 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: As a \n9 \npractical -- you know. \n10 \nMR. EDWARDS: Okay. I'll test out a \n11 \ncouple and see where we are and move on. \n12 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: There you go. \n13 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n14 \nQ. \nWho were the people at Maine Justice that \n15 \nyou communicated with on behalf of Jeffrey Epstein \n16 \nat any stage during the negotiations? \n17 \nMR. INDYKE: Same objection, same \n18 \ninstruction. \n19 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n20 \nQ. \nWho were the targets of the \n21 \nU.S. Attorney's investigation, as you understood, \n22 \nduring the negotiation that you participated in on \n23 \nbehalf of Jeffrey Epstein? \n24 \nA. \nNot me. I was not one of them. \n25 \nMR. INDYKE: Same objection, same \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726907\n", "char_count": 1037}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 59, "text_content": "841 \n1 \ninstruction. \n2 \nA. \nI can tell you one who was -- it's not me. \n3 \nMR. SCOTT: He's making an objection. \n4 \nMR. EDWARDS: To the extent that he's \n5 \nanswering that question by excluding anyone, I \n6 \nam making the argument right now that he has \n7 \nwaived any privilege objection whatsoever to \n8 \nthat question, and I'm asking him now to \n9 \ndisclose the names of all of the individuals \n10 \nwho were -- not were not -- were targets of the \n11 \ninvestigation. \n12 \nMR. INDYKE: I said Mr. Epstein has not \n13 \nwaived any objection \n14 \nCOURT REPORTER: Mr. Indyke, I can't hear \n15 \nyou. \n16 \nMR. INDYKE: I said, I'm sorry, but \n17 \nMr. Epstein has not waived his objection \n18 \ndespite any statements Mr. Dershowitz may have \n19 \nmade. \n20 \nMR. SCAROLA: And can we assume that on \n21 \nall occasions when the instruction is coming \n22 \nfrom Mr. Epstein's counsel that Mr. Epstein \n23 \n[sic] is not to answer, that you are joining in \n24 \nthose objections? \n25 \nMR. SCOTT: You know, you've characterized \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726908\n", "char_count": 1065}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 60, "text_content": "842 \n1 \nme twice incorrectly, Mr. Scarola. All I'm \n2 \ndoing is this: He represents this gentleman. \n3 \nThis gentleman's lawyer is telling him not to \n4 \nanswer. Okay? I'm telling him follow that \n5 \nlawyer's advice until there is a ruling. \n6 \nYou put me in a Catch-22. What am I \n7 \nsupposed to do? Rule on it and say you can \n8 \nanswer it and overrule this man telling him \n9 \nthis? \n10 \nMR. SCAROLA: Well, there may be \n11 \noccasion --\n12 \nMR. SCOTT: I'm not joining in their \n13 \nposition. I'm merely saying follow the \n14 \nlawyer's instructions until there's a legal \n15 \nruling on February 2nd, and then we'll be glad \n16 \nto come back and answer them, depending on what \n17 \nJudge Lynch says. That's all I'm saying to \n18 \nyou. \n19 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Hang on one \n20 \nsecond. Before we go back to \n21 \nMR. SCOTT: I've said it twice. \n22 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: And there has \n23 \nbeen -- there have been times when I found the \n24 \nobjection to be -- I overruled the objection, \n25 \nand the witness answered regardless. And so we \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726909\n", "char_count": 1101}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 61, "text_content": "843 \n1 \nneed to take them one question at a time. You \n2 \ncan either deal this in the subsequent sitting \n3 \nof Mr. Dershowitz or we could do it now. It's \n4 \nup to you. \n5 \nMR. SCAROLA: Well, let me explain the \n6 \nconcern that I have and the reason why I want \n7 \nthe record to be clear in this regard. \n8 \nThere are -- there is a party that is \n9 \nProfessor Cassell and there is an attorney, \n10 \nGeneral Reyes, who are here from Utah today at \n11 \nsome considerable expense. And there may very \n12 \nwell be a motion for sanctions that will \n13 \ninclude a request that expenses associated with \n14 \nthe retaking of Mr. Dershowitz's deposition be \n15 \nassessed against those responsible for having \n16 \nraised improper objections requiring the \n17 \ncontinuation of the deposition. \n18 \nIf you are not joining in what I consider \n19 \nto be spurious objections that have no \n20 \nreasonable basis, then it would not be \n21 \nappropriate to seek sanctions against you. But \n22 \nif you are joining in those objections, then it \n23 \nwould be appropriate to seek sanctions in the \n24 \nform of costs. \n25 \nI'm only trying to make sure that the \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726910\n", "char_count": 1191}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 62, "text_content": "844 \n1 \nrecord is clear as to whether you are joining \n2 \nin the objections or you are aren't joining in \n3 \nthe objections. \n4 \nMR. SCOTT: I thought I had made that \n5 \nclear before, and I've now made it clear a \n6 \nsecond time. \n7 \nMR. SCAROLA: That is that you are not \n8 \njoining in the objections? \n9 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Let me stop you. \n10 \nThe way people make objections, Mr. Scarola, as \n11 \nyou understand it, and I understand it, and \n12 \neverybody in the room, is when any lawyer \n13 \nobjects, they put it on the record. If there \n14 \nis not an objection made by a particular \n15 \nlawyer, then we -- I don't think there's an \n16 \nassumption that could be made one way or \n17 \nanother that they're joining or not. \n18 \nMR. SCAROLA: Well, the problem is that \n19 \nthe witness is not responding to the question. \n20 \nTHE WITNESS: That's a lie. I'm \n21 \nresponding to every question that the special \n22 \nmaster has asked me to respond to. \n23 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Guys, guys, let \n24 \nme stop you. I understand the Catch-22. I \n25 \nunderstand that this issue should be flushed \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726911\n", "char_count": 1151}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 63, "text_content": "845 \n1 \nout at a hearing, likely in front of Judge \n2 \nLynch, and then we'll get clarity on this \n3 \nissue. \n4 \nI will also suggest to the parties that \n5 \nfrom where I sit, you've asked me to come in as \n6 \nspecial master. I appreciate the delicacies of \n7 \nthe issue of the privileged communication, \n8 \nhowever it is asserted, whatever privilege \n9 \nparticularly is being asserted, and I want to \n10 \nbe careful and as considerate as I can. \n11 \nAnd so -- but unlike you, I have not lived \n12 \nwith this case. And so I'm trying to make the \n13 \nbest calls I can and also preserve the record \n14 \nfor you to take up at a later hearing where \n15 \nthese issues can get flushed out either by \n16 \nbrief and argument in a more fuller fashion. \n17 \nMR. SCAROLA: And I apologize if anything \n18 \nthat I have said suggests that you have done \n19 \nanything except properly fulfill your \n20 \nresponsibilities. \n21 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: No, no, no. \n22 \nMR. SCAROLA: So I want to be clear that \n23 \nmy purpose is to be sure we have as clear a \n24 \nrecord as possible as to who is asserting which \n25 \nobjections. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726912\n", "char_count": 1163}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 64, "text_content": "846 \n1 \nAnd it's my position that if Mr. Epstein's \n2 \ncounsel raises an objection that Mr. Scott or \n3 \nMr. Simmons considers to be baseless, then they \n4 \nhave an obligation to tell their client, this \n5 \nis a question that you should answer. \n6 \nIf they're not telling their client, this \n7 \nis a question you should answer, I think it's \n8 \nreasonable to assume that they are recognizing \n9 \nat least the colorable validity of the \n10 \nobjection. That's the only point I'm trying to \n11 \nmake. I made my statement, and we can move on \n12 \nfrom here. \n13 \nMR. SCOTT: And I will repeat my position. \n14 \nMy client has been instructed by the lawyer \n15 \nrepresenting a man he continues to represent \n16 \nthat he should not answer these questions, and \n17 \nI believe that he should not answer them until \n18 \nthe Court gets a ruling. \n19 \nAnd the special master himself has \n20 \nindicated that we need to get this resolved and \n21 \nit's delicate issues. That's all I'm saying, \n22 \nJack. \n23 \nThis is going to be done on the \n24 \n2nd anyway. You're coming back for another \n25 \ndepo. We all know that, so let's get it \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726913\n", "char_count": 1172}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 65, "text_content": "847 \n1 \nflushed out, let's get it ruled on, and then we \n2 \ncan come back and finish it off if the judge \n3 \nsays that. That's all I'm saying. \n4 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: You're going to \n5 \nneed extra time with him anyway. \n6 \nMR. SCOTT: You're putting me in a \n7 \nCatch-22. You actually need a rule as a judge. \n8 \nI can't do that. \n9 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Let's understand \n10 \nthe practicality of it that I'm not so sure \n11 \nthat you're going to get done today. In fact, \n12 \nI'm fairly certain now that you're not. \n13 \nNotwithstanding these open issues around \n14 \nprivilege. \n15 \nSo, to that extent, let's see if we can \n16 \ncontinue to plow through as best we can. \n17 \nMR. SCAROLA: Thank you. \n18 \nMR. EDWARDS: Okay. Thank you. \n19 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n20 \nQ. \nYou have defined your relationship with \n21 \nJeffrey Epstein using three categories that I wrote \n22 \ndown as, No. 1, academic; No. 2, lawyer; and No. 3, \n23 \nsubsequent to nonprosecution agreement, rarely see \n24 \nhim. \n25 \nA. \nSure. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726914\n", "char_count": 1062}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 66, "text_content": "848 \n1 \nQ. \nIs it fair -- is a reasonable presumption \n2 \nthat in the category No. 3, subsequent to Jeffrey \n3 \nEpstein pleading guilty and that case resolving, the \n4 \ncriminal case resolving, that you have not been to \n5 \nhis New York, Manhattan mansion since then? \n6 \nA. \nNo, that's not the case. I have been, \n7 \nyeah. Yeah. \n8 \nQ. \nHow many times in category 3, then, have \n9 \nyou been to Jeffrey Epstein's Manhattan mansion? \n10 \nA. \nI would say maybe twice, maybe -- maybe \n11 \ntwice. Maybe three, in that range. It's been how \n12 \nmany years now? It's been nine years or eight \n13 \nyears. Could be a little bit more than that. \n14 \nCertainly no more than once a year. Certainly no \n15 \nmore than that. Probably less than that. \n16 \nQ. \nAnd when you were at Mr. Epstein's \n17 \nNew York home subsequent to his guilty plea, were \n18 \nyou there in the capacity as his lawyer discussing \n19 \nattorney-client information or were you there in a \n20 \nnonlawyer capacity? \n21 \nA. \nAs a lawyer. \n22 \nQ. \nOkay. Was any of your communications with \n23 \nJeffrey Epstein during that period of time we just \n24 \ndefined non-privileged communications? \n25 \nA. \nYes. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726915\n", "char_count": 1213}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 67, "text_content": "849 \n1 \nQ. \nCan you share with me the nonprivileged \n2 \ncommunications that you have had with Jeffrey \n3 \nEpstein since his guilty plea in June 2008? \n4 \nA. \nWe discussed the Middle East. There was a \n5 \nmap on his blackboard that had been drawn in chalk \n6 \nby Ehud Barak, who had visited his home, and we \n7 \ndiscussed the potential for how the Middle East \n8 \nconflict could be settled. \n9 \nQ. \nWhen was that discussion? \n10 \nA. \nProbably six or seven -- six, seven, eight \n11 \nyears ago, something like that. \n12 \nQ. \nSo are we talking about 2009, 2010 is this \n13 \ndiscussion? \n14 \nA. \nNo, I don't remember exactly what year it \n15 \nwould be. It could be around there. Ehud Barak was \n16 \nno longer in office. So we'd have to figure out \n17 \nwhen he was not in office. \n18 \nQ. \nDoes it help if I can tell you that \n19 \nJeffrey Epstein pled guilty June 30, 2008, was \n20 \nconfined for a year and then was placed on \n21 \nprobation? Was it during the time that he was \n22 \nsupposed to be confined? Was it during the time of \n23 \nhis probation? Or is it sometime after all of that \n24 \nwas over? \n25 \nA. \nI don't remember. I do remember that he \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726916\n", "char_count": 1200}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 68, "text_content": "850 \n1 \ncalled me to come over for a legal reason. We had a \n2 \nlegal discussion, and then he showed me the \n3 \nblackboard and we had a discussion that was not \n4 \nprivileged. Had nothing to do with this case. \n5 \nQ. \nWas Ehud Barak at his house as well during \n6 \nthis discussion that you were having with Jeffrey \n7 \nEpstein? \n8 \nA. \nHe had been at his house. I don't recall \n9 \nspecifically if he was there at the time. We may \n10 \nhave said hello in passing. I don't recall. \n11 \nI think -- I can tell you this. Part of \n12 \nthe discussion occurred when he was not there \n13 \nbecause we were referring to his map and discussing \n14 \nwhat this meant and what that meant. But I think we \n15 \nmay have crossed paths, him going out and me coming \n16 \nin. \n17 \nMR. SCOTT: At some point, we'd like to \n18 \ntake a break. \n19 \nMR. EDWARDS: I'm just going wrap up on \n20 \nthis particular meeting, and then we'll take a \n21 \nbreak. \n22 \nMR. SCOTT: Okay. \n23 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n24 \nQ. \nThe time when that you're discussing where \n25 \nyou and Jeffrey Epstein were reviewing a map, is \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726917\n", "char_count": 1129}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 69, "text_content": "851 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nacademic \n1 \nthis a map that was drawn by Ehud Barak? \n2 \nA. \nYes. \n3 \nQ. \nAnd is this on a blackboard \n4 \nA. \nYes. \n5 \nQ. \n-- that is Jeffrey Epstein's blackboard? \n6 \nA. \nThat's right. \n7 \nQ. \nWhere in the home is this blockboard \n8 \nlocated? \nA. \nOkay. As you walk into his house, there's \na little office on the left side. And generally \nI've been called by his secretary, I go and I sit in \nthe office, and then she tells me that Jeffrey's \nready to see me and I walk in through the hallway \ninto a dining room. And he's usually sitting at the \ndesk in the dining room and there's a waiter person \nsitting there, hovering around. And that was the \nroom where this blackboard \nAnd that's where \nseminars where he \nwas. \nhe used to have his \nwould invite Nobel \nPrize-winning scientists and professors and other \npeople to have sessions. I didn't attend any of \nthose once the -- once the deal been made, once I \nterminated my role as his lawyer. \nQ. \nThis visit to Jeffrey Epstein's house \nwhere you discussed the drawing on the blackboard, \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726918\n", "char_count": 1171}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 70, "text_content": "8:2\n1 \ndo you know whether Ehud Barak was staying at \n2 \nJeffrey Epstein's house? \n3 \nA. \nI don't. I don't. \n4 \nQ. \nDo you know whether Ehud Barak, in the \n5 \ndays just preceding that, had been staying at \n6 \nJeffrey Epstein's house? \n7 \nA. \nI don't. I have no idea. \n8 \nQ. \nDo you know how long Ehud Barak had been \n9 \nat Jeffrey Epstein's house? \n10 \nA. \nI don't know that he had been. All I know \n11 \nthat he had been there for enough time to draw the \n12 \nmap, and I may have -- I've known him for a long \n13 \ntime. I may have said hello to him on the way in \n14 \nand out. I don't remember that specifically. I \n15 \njust remember that he had been there and I had asked \n16 \nabout the map and we had the conversation. \n17 \nMR. EDWARDS: You want to take a break? \n18 \nVIDEOGRAPHER: Going off the record. The \n19 \ntime is 2:22 p.m. \n20 \n(Recess was held from 2:22 p.m. until 2:36 p.m.) \n21 \nVIDEOGRAPHER: We are back on the record. \n22 \nThe time is 2:36 p.m. \n23 \nMR. EDWARDS: I'm going to go ahead and \n24 \nput this on the record that I'm turning over \n25 \nthe video transcript from the Miami Bench \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726919\n", "char_count": 1155}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 71, "text_content": "853 \n1 \n& Bar. \n2 \nMR. SCOTT: Thank you, Mr. Edwards. \n3 \nMR. SIMPSON: Thank you. \n4 \nA. \nCan I correct one of my answers on the \n5 \nrecord? You asked me if I was aware of a police \n6 \nreport, and I had no chance to read it. I've now \n7 \nhad a chance to read it, and it is noncriminal, and \n8 \nit says she simply wanted to document the incident. \n9 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n10 \nQ. \nWere you aware of that? \n11 \nA. \nI was not aware of that. \n12 \nQ. \nOkay. \n13 \nA. \nAnd I am now aware of that. It's a \n14 \nnoncriminal report and she wants it for the record. \n15 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Are you \n16 \nreferring to Exhibit 28? \n17 \nMR. EDWARDS: Exhibit 28, which is Miami \n18 \nBeach Police Case Report Detail. \n19 \nA. \nBut not a criminal report. \n20 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n21 \nQ. \nOkay. Either way, you were not aware of \n22 \nthat report having been made? \n23 \nA. \nNo, no, no, I was aware that there was a \n24 \npolice report being made. I never saw the police \n25 \nreport. I looked at it now for the first time --\nwww.phippereporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726920\n", "char_count": 1052}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 72, "text_content": "854 \n1 \nQ. \nUnderstood. \n2 \nA. \n-- during the recess. \n3 \nQ. \nOkay. Going back to the meeting we were \n4 \njust discussing between yourself and Jeffrey Epstein \n5 \nin Jeffrey Epstein's home, what year -- what's your \n6 \nbest approximation for the year that that happened? \n7 \nA. \nIt would just be a guess. I would --\n8 \nQ. \nOkay. You don't know? \n9 \nA. \nI don't think I know. I could probably \n10 \nfind out. \n11 \nQ. \nOkay. How long you were at Jeffrey \n12 \nEpstein's home during that meeting? \n13 \nA. \nMy general meetings with Jeffrey Epstein \n14 \nin the post deal period were about half an hour. \n15 \nQ. \nAnd --\n16 \nA. \nThey were business; in, out, done. \n17 \nQ. \nWas there anyone else in the room with you \n18 \nand Jeffrey Epstein during this meeting? \n19 \nA. \nYes. \n20 \nQ. \nAnd who was that? \n21 \nA. \nThere was a wait person who would bring \n22 \ncoffee and refill my coffee and ask if there was \n23 \nanything I needed, and then periodically a secretary \n24 \nwould come in and hand Jeffrey a note and he would \n25 \nlook at the note and scribble a note or decide to \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726921\n", "char_count": 1120}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 73, "text_content": "855 \n1 \nmake a phone call back. \n2 \nQ. \nDo you know the name of the waiter or the \n3 \nsecretary? \n4 \nA. \nWaiter, I never knew the name. The \n5 \nsecretary, I would know the name if it were given to \n6 \nme, but I don't know it offhand. I can describe her \n7 \nto you. \n8 \nQ. \nOkay. What's the description? \n9 \nA. \nShe's a very attractive 45-year-old. \n10 \nShe's been his secretary for quite some time. And \n11 \nI'm guessing the age, but it's in that range. Thin, \n12 \nblondish hair. \n13 \nQ. \nIs it Lesley Groff? \n14 \nA. \nIt could be. It could be, yes. Probably \n15 \nwas, yeah. \n16 \nQ. \nAnd did you speak with Lesley Groff while \n17 \nyou were there? \n18 \nA. \nI would usually go in, I would say hi, and \n19 \nshe'd say Jeffrey's busy, wait. And I would wait in \n20 \nthe little office. There would be books. I would \n21 \nperuse a book. And then she would say, Jeffrey's \n22 \nready to see you, and I would go into his -- he used \n23 \nit kind of as an office, an office-dining room area. \n24 \nQ. \nWas Lesley Groff also a target of the \n25 \nfederal criminal investigation? \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726922\n", "char_count": 1117}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 74, "text_content": "856 \n1 \nA. \nNot to my knowledge. \n2 \nMR. INDYKE: Objection. \n3 \nMR. SIMPSON: Darren? \n4 \nMR. INDYKE: Yes. \n5 \nMR. SIMPSON: Are you instructing on that \n6 \nquestion? \n7 \nMR. INDYKE: I am, on the same basis. \n8 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n9 \nQ. \nAnd --\n10 \nMR. SCOTT: If you have a hard time \n11 \nhearing, please speak and let us know, will \n12 \nyou? Because you got to tell my client what \n13 \nyour position is so he can understand it before \n14 \nhe responds. \n15 \nMR. INDYKE: I understand. \n16 \nMR. EDWARDS: Just so I am clear on what \n17 \nprivilege is --\n18 \nMR. INDYKE: I would be objecting on \n19 \nseveral projects, including attorney-client, \n20 \nwork product, I think probably those two, yes. \n21 \nOn those two. And I would instruct not to \n22 \nanswer. \n23 \nMR. EDWARDS: As to the question of was \n24 \nLesley Groff also a target of the criminal \n25 \nfederal investigation, the objection is \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726923\n", "char_count": 939}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 75, "text_content": "857 \n1 \nattorney-client privilege and the witness is \n2 \nbeing instructed not to answer? \n3 \nMR. INDYKE: And work product, because \n4 \nMr. Dershowitz would not have discovered any \n5 \nsuch information unless it was in connection \n6 \nwith his representation of Jeffrey. \n7 \nA. \nAnd I'm also not sure \n8 \nMR. SCOTT: Just \n9 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n10 \nQ. \nIs Lesley Groff one of the named \n11 \ncoconspirators in the nonprosecution agreement that \n12 \nis now a public document? \n13 \nA. \nI don't remember. I remember only_ \n14 \nI don't remember the other names. I \n15 \nremember there were four of them and, of course, I \n16 \nwas not one of them. \n17 \nQ. \nWas there anyone else at the home for this \n18 \nmeeting you are describing other than yourself, \n19 \nJeffrey Epstein, the waiter whose name you do not \n20 \nknow, and the secretary who we believe is Lesley \n21 \nGroff? \n22 \nA. \nThere was also a guy, a big guy who I \n23 \nthink may have been a security guy, because I \n24 \nremember he came to the door once and greeted me and \n25 \nhe looked to me like a security guy. And he was \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726924\n", "char_count": 1125}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 76, "text_content": "858 \n1 \nkind of on the opposite side of where the office \n2 \nwas, and I would see him from time to time. \n3 \nVIDEOGRAPHER: Let me interrupt for one \n4 \nsecond. Professor, could you put your mic on. \n5 \nTHE WITNESS: Oh, I am so sorry. I \n6 \napologize. \n7 \nVIDEOGRAPHER: No problem. \n8 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n9 \nQ. \nOkay. Do you know the name of this person \n10 \nyou are describing as security? \n11 \nA. \nI don't. \n12 \nQ. \nWould you know it if I said it? \n13 \nA. \nTry me. \n14 \nQ. \nIgor Zinoviev? \n15 \nA. \nNo. \n16 \nQ. \nIt's not Igor? \n17 \nA. \nNo, no. And there was also a driver, \n18 \nwhose name if you give me, I will remember. I think \n19 \nit has -- I think it's a Latino name. \n20 \nQ. \nJojo Fontenelle? \n21 \nA. \nThat's it. I have the ethnicity wrong, \n22 \nbut it was Jojo, yes. I never knew his last name. \n23 \nQ. \nIs Jojo Fontenelle someone that you \n24 \nunderstand worked for Jeffrey Epstein for a very \n25 \nlong time? \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726925\n", "char_count": 969}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 77, "text_content": "859 \n1 \nA. \nI don't know for a very long time. I know \n2 \nthat on occasion when it was raining or something, \n3 \nJeffrey would ask Jojo to drive me back to my house \n4 \nor something like that. So I was driven on maybe \n5 \none or two occasions by Jojo somewhere. That's \n6 \nreally all I know about. \n7 \nQ. \nHave you ever talked with Jojo about \n8 \n9 \nA. \nOf course not. I've never talked to \n10 \nanybody about \nuntil \n11 \nMR. INDYKE: Objection. \n12 \nA. \n-- until these false accusations. \n13 \nMR. SCOTT: Is there an objection? \n14 \nMR. INDYKE: There is an objection. To \n15 \nthe extent that response to that question would \n16 \nrequire Alan to disclose anything in connection \n17 \nwith his representation of Jeffrey Epstein, \n18 \nthen I would instruct Alan not to answer the \n19 \nquestion. \n20 \nMR. SCOTT: So if it's a nonprivileged \n21 \narea, please answer it. \n22 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: How would a \n23 \nconversation with Jojo be privileged? \n24 \nMR. INDYKE: It might be privileged if \n25 \nAlan is investigating, for example, what Jojo \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726926\n", "char_count": 1094}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 78, "text_content": "860 \n1 \nrecalls about \nor something \n2 \nlike that. I don't know. \n3 \nA. \nI had no privileged conversations. \n4 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Okay. \n5 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n6 \nQ. \nAfter these allegations were made, haven't \n7 \nyou already testified as recently as yesterday that \n8 \nyou did call Jeffrey Epstein? \n9 \nA. \nYes, but I had no contact with Jojo. I \n10 \nhave no idea whether Jojo still works for him or \n11 \nanything. I've not been to his -- I've not had any \n12 \ncontact with him, no. \n13 \nQ. \nWhen is the first time you met Jojo? \n14 \nA. \nI have no idea. \n15 \nQ. \nDo you remember if Jojo was working for \n16 \nJeffrey Epstein the first time that you met Jeffrey \n17 \nEpstein? \n18 \nA. \nI have no idea. I may have seen him three \n19 \ntimes in my life, Jojo. \n20 \nQ. \nOkay. We're right now still in what \n21 \nyou've placed as category No. 3, which would place \n22 \ntime period of June 2008 through present. \n23 \nA. \nI would put it a little back further than \n24 \n2008. Probably at the time the handshake deal was \n25 \nstruck with the U.S. Attorney's Office is when the \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726927\n", "char_count": 1123}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 79, "text_content": "861 \n1 \nnature of my relationship changed. \n2 \nQ. \nI'm going to describe some events for you \n3 \njust from what I know. \n4 \nA. \nOkay. \n5 \nQ. \nAnd only so that you can help me to \n6 \nunderstand when the date actually is. \n7 \nA. \nOkay. \n8 \nQ. \nHere are the things that I know. In late \n9 \nSeptember \nSeptember 27, 2007, the nonprosecution \n10 \nagreement is signed. \n11 \nA. \nOkay. \n12 \nQ. \nIn December there's an addendum to it that \n13 \nwas signed but later not attached. In January \n14 \nthere's an appeal to CEOS in Washington. So I'm \n15 \nwondering \n16 \nA. \nIn January? \n17 \nQ. \nRight. So I'm wondering if it is that \n18 \nJanuary 2008 period --\n19 \nA. \nThat's probably pretty close, yeah. \n20 \nThat's probably pretty close. I would have been \n21 \ninvolved in any appeal. \n22 \nQ. \nOkay. Okay. So at least to the last \n23 \npoint of an appeal -- I call it appeal, for lack of \n24 \na better word, but taking it up to Washington, \n25 \nyou're involved through whatever that point is? \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726928\n", "char_count": 1032}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 80, "text_content": "862 \n1 \nA. \nYeah. I mean, my role is primarily to \n2 \nprovide legal work. I did the legal part of \n3 \neverything. I wrote the law part of all the briefs. \n4 \nI was not in charge of the factual investigation. \n5 \nThat's not my expertise. My expertise is on \n6 \nstatutory construction, constitutional law and \n7 \nprecedence, and I wrote all the parts of all the \n8 \npleadings pretty much that dealt with any of those \n9 \nissues. \n10 \nQ. \nDon't you agree, though, that you made \n11 \npresentations to the State Attorney's Office and \n12 \nperhaps others about some of the underlying facts \n13 \nfor the victims and their credibility? \n14 \nA. \nAt the first phase when it was just me and \n15 \nlocal lawyers, and it was regarded as --\n16 \nMR. INDYKE: Objection. Sorry, guys, I \n17 \njust got back to my desk. Are we talking about \n18 \ndiscussion with the U.S. Attorney's Office, \n19 \nwith the U.S. Attorney? \n20 \nMR. SCOTT: No. I don't know if we are or \n21 \nnot. \n22 \nMR. INDYKE: Can you repeat the question, \n23 \nplease. \n24 \nMR. EDWARDS: Sure. The statement was \n25 \nmade that he was only involved -- at least my \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726929\n", "char_count": 1160}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 81, "text_content": "863 \n1 \nunderstanding of the comment was that he was \n2 \nonly involved in the legal aspects of it, and \n3 \nso --\n4 \nTHE WITNESS: I said primarily involved. \n5 \nMR. EDWARDS: So my question was, wouldn't \n6 \nyou agree that at some point in time, you met \n7 \nwith the State Attorney's Office and discussed \n8 \nwith them the factual background of some of the \n9 \nvictims? \n10 \nMR. INDYKE: Same objection regarding work \n11 \nproduct and also regarding settlement \n12 \ncommunications. And instruct not to answer. \n13 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n14 \nQ. \nOkay. And I assume at this point in time, \n15 \nwe're going along with that instruction? \n16 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: I don't \n17 \ndon't -- based on the question, I'm not so sure \n18 \nhe could answer the question outside of the \n19 \nprivileged information that's being claimed, so \n20 \nyeah. \n21 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n22 \nQ. \nOkay. In addition to the one occasion \n23 \nthat you've already described for us, in phase \n24 \nthree, which we've described as sometime in 2008 \n25 \nthrough present, what is the other -- what is the \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726930\n", "char_count": 1112}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 82, "text_content": "864 \n1 \nnext time that you were at Jeffrey Epstein's home in \n2 \nManhattan? \n3 \nA. \nThere were just a couple of times when I \n4 \nwould get a phone call and be asked to come over to \n5 \ndiscuss a legal issue, and I did. But I can't give \n6 \nyou times and dates. I might be able to check them. \n7 \nI might have kept time records, although I don't \n8 \nthink I was billing him at that time. But I might \n9 \nhave time records. \n10 \nQ. \nWithin -- after January of 2015 when you \n11 \ncontacted Jeffrey Epstein, that was in response to \n12 \nthe allegations that were made against you, right? \n13 \nA. \nHe contacted -- to my recollection, he \n14 \ncontacted me. What happened is I first got a phone \n15 \ncall from one of his lawyers. And then I got a \n16 \nphone call from him. \n17 \nQ. \nAnd your discussions, so that I'm \n18 \nunderstanding, with Jeffrey Epstein at that time, \n19 \nthe purpose of those discussions was for you to \n20 \ngather information from him to assist you in the \n21 \ndefense of the allegations against you? \n22 \nA. \nIn part. \n23 \nMR. INDYKE: Objection. Common interest. \n24 \nAnd instruct not to answer. \n25 \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726931\n", "char_count": 1170}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 83, "text_content": "865 \n1 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n2 \nQ. \nI'm -- just so that I'm clear, the \n3 \nobjection may stand, but just so that I'm clear, I'm \n4 \ntalking about a circumstance where you are the \n5 \nclient, not you were the lawyer. And I want to know \n6 \nwhat the communications are between you and Jeffrey \n7 \nEpstein where you are the client asking him \n8 \ninformation for the purposes of defending yourself \n9 \nagainst the allegation. \n10 \nA. \nI was always both the lawyer and the \n11 \nclient. I think I already said that. \n12 \nMR. INDYKE: The objection stands. \n13 \nA. \nI was always both the lawyer and the \n14 \nclient. \n15 \nMR. INDYKE: Objection. Common interest, \n16 \nattorney-client and work product. \n17 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n18 \nQ. \nCan you tell me any other times in phase 3 \n19 \nof your relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, as \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nQ. \nAre there any other people who were \npreviously defined, when you had -- when you met \nwith Jeffrey Epstein at his New York home and \ndiscussed any other nonprivileged information? \nA. \nI can't think of any other nonprivileged \ndiscussion. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726932\n", "char_count": 1135}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 84, "text_content": "866 \n1 \npresent at Jeffrey Epstein's home when you were \n2 \nhaving any of your privileged discussions? \n3 \nA. \nWaiter, secretary, security, staff. \n4 \nQ. \nWhere was the staff at the times when you \n5 \nwere having these privileged discussions with \n6 \nJeffrey Epstein? \n7 \nA. \nIn their various places. The security \n8 \nperson in his place, the secretary in her place, and \n9 \na waiter walking in and out. We generally stopped \n10 \nany substantive discussion when the waiter or the \n11 \nwaitress, the waitperson was pouring my coffee. \n12 \nQ. \nWas \nor \nor \n13 \nGhislaine Maxwell in the home at any of these times \n14 \nduring phase 3 of your relationship with Jeffrey \n15 \nEpstein? \n16 \nA. \nNot that I recall. \n17 \nQ. \nWere any of Jeffrey Epstein's girlfriends \n18 \nin the home during that time? \n19 \nA. \nNot that I recall. \n20 \nQ. \nWhat would we describe as the \nor what \n21 \nwould we define as the time period of phase 1 of \n22 \nyour relationship with Jeffrey Epstein? \n23 \nA. \nFrom August of the year that Leslie Wexner \n24 \nturned 59 -- let's see, he's a year older than I am, \n25 \nand I would have turned 59 in 2007 -- so this is \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726933\n", "char_count": 1186}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 85, "text_content": "867 \n1 \nprobably the summer of 2006. \n2 \nQ. \nNinety-six? \n3 \nA. \nNinety-six. \n4 \nQ. \nI'm with you. I'm keeping track of the \n5 \nmath. \n6 \nA. \nPut back a decade. Ninety-six, so it was \n7 \nprobably the summer of '96, and he came to the \n8 \nVineyard at the suggestion -- to visit a number of \n9 \npeople, but visited with me at the suggestion of \n10 \nLady Rothschild, whose name was then Lynn Forester. \n11 \nQ. \nIs Lynn Forester still a friend of Jeffrey \n12 \nEpstein? \n13 \nA. \nNo. \n14 \nQ. \nWas Lynn Forester then in 1996 a friend of \n15 \nJeffrey Epstein? \n16 \nA. \nYes. \n17 \nQ. \nDo you have insight into the reason why \n18 \nLynn Forester is no longer a friend of Jeffrey \n19 \nEpstein? \n20 \nMR. SIMPSON: Darren. \n21 \nA. \nI'm waiting for an objection. If none \n22 \ncomes --\n23 \nMR. INDYKE: I'm sorry. Can you repeat \n24 \nthe question? Restate the question, please. \n25 \nMR. EDWARDS: I'm asking the witness for \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726934\n", "char_count": 958}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 86, "text_content": "868 \n1 \nthe reason why Lynn Forester and Jeffrey \n2 \nEpstein are no longer friends. \n3 \nMR. INDYKE: Oh. Objection on the basis \n4 \nof attorney-client, work product. And I \n5 \ninstruct him not to answer. \n6 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n7 \nQ. \nHave you talked to Lynn Forester or anyone \n8 \nother than Jeffrey Epstein about the reason why Lynn \n9 \nForester and Jeffrey Epstein are no longer friends? \n10 \nMR. SCOTT: If it's nonprivileged, please \n11 \nanswer. \n12 \nA. \nYeah, I have spoken to Lynn Forester about \n13 \na number of subjects. I don't recall speaking to \n14 \nher about that subject. \n15 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n16 \nQ. \nDo you have the ability to answer the \n17 \nquestion as to why Lynn Forester and Jeffrey Epstein \n18 \nare no longer friends outside of privileged \n19 \ninformation? \n20 \nA. \nNo, I do not, no. \n21 \nQ. \nAnd you've told me --\n22 \nMR. INDYKE: Hello? \n23 \nMR. EDWARDS: There's no question pending \n24 \nyet. \n25 \nMR. INDYKE: Sorry. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726935\n", "char_count": 989}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 87, "text_content": "869 \n1 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n2 \nQ. \nAnd you've told me of some nonprivileged \n3 \ncommunication that you've had with Jeffrey Epstein \n4 \nand, obviously, you can't tell me of privileged \n5 \ncommunication you've had with Jeffrey Epstein \n6 \nbecause it relates to your acting as Jeffrey \n7 \nEpstein's attorney when that communication was had. \n8 \nSo am I correct in understanding that the \n9 \ninformation that would give you the ability to \n10 \nanswer the question why Lynn Forester is no longer \n11 \nfriendly with Jeffrey Epstein is privileged \n12 \ncommunication? \n13 \nA. \nYes. \n14 \nQ. \nThe first time that you met Jeffrey \n15 \nEpstein, was that in Martha's Vineyard? \n16 \nA. \nYes. \n17 \nQ. \nWas that at your place at Martha's \n18 \nVineyard? \n19 \nA. \nYes. He came to my house on Martha's \n20 \nVineyard. \n21 \nQ. \nAnd who did he come with the first time? \n22 \nA. \nGhislaine Maxwell. \n23 \nQ. \nWhat did you understand at that point in \n24 \ntime for Ghislaine Maxwell's role to be in Jeffrey \n25 \nEpstein's life? \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726936\n", "char_count": 1054}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 88, "text_content": "870 \n1 \nA. \nI thought she was his girlfriend. That \n2 \nwas my assumption at the time. \n3 \nQ. \nWas your assumption wrong? \n4 \nA. \nI don't know. \n5 \nQ. \nOkay. The way that you said it, I thought \n6 \nmaybe --\n7 \nA. \nNo. I don't -- I never -- they didn't \n8 \nhold hands. \n9 \nQ. \nThere is nothing since that date that's \n10 \nchanged the assumption that you had at that time, \n11 \nwhich is that she was his girlfriend in 1996? \n12 \nMR. INDYKE: Objection --\n13 \nA. \nNothing on privilege. \n14 \nMR. INDYKE: -- based upon \n15 \nattorney-client, work product, common interest. \n16 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n17 \nQ. \nWas anybody else with Jeffrey Epstein and \n18 \nGhislaine Maxwell on this first visit to Martha's \n19 \nVineyard? \n20 \nA. \nHis pilots. \n21 \nQ. \nWho were they? \n22 \nA. \nI don't know. \n23 \nQ. \nDo you know Larry Visosky? \n24 \nA. \nI remember meeting a pilot named Larry. \n25 \nQ. \nOther than his pilots, anybody else? \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726937\n", "char_count": 960}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 89, "text_content": "871 \n1 \nA. \nNo. None that I know of. He came to my \n2 \nhouse. They had a car at the airport. They took \n3 \nthe car back to the airport, my recollection, maybe \n4 \ntook a cab, I don't remember, but I know he was \n5 \nvisiting other people. So I don't know whether he \n6 \ndid or didn't have anybody else with him. But when \n7 \nthey came to my house, it was just him and \n8 \nGhislaine. \n9 \nQ. \nOkay. I'm going to go back to this, but I \n10 \nwanted to get something before we finished today, \n11 \nwhich is can you provide me all the telephone \n12 \nnumbers that you used to call -- not on your end --\n13 \nthat you called to reach Jeffrey Epstein in phase 1; \n14 \nthat is, prior to your representation of Jeffrey \n15 \nEpstein in the 2005 investigation? \n16 \nA. \nI will check to see. \n17 \nMR. INDYKE: Objection to the extent that \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \ninformation is privileged, attorney-client \ncommunication or those times where Alan has \ntestified where Jeffrey has asked him for \nspecific instances of legal advice. \nA. \nI can tell you this, that early on, like \nthe first six months of my relationship with Jeffrey \nEpstein, there was no privilege. That is, probably \ntook at least six months before he asked me any \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726938\n", "char_count": 1278}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 90, "text_content": "872 \n1 \nquestions that would be legal in nature. \n2 \nThe first six months, we talked about \n3 \nscience, we talked about academia, we talked about \n4 \nHarvard, we talked about Leslie Wexner, we talked \n5 \nabout various subjects. \n6 \nIt was only later on in time that, in \n7 \nretrospect, I think back, and I say these are \n8 \nquestions that were legal in nature and he was \n9 \nasking me them as a lawyer friend of his. \n10 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n11 \nQ. \nOkay. \n12 \nMR. INDYKE: Then my objection -- to be \n13 \nclear, my objection is to the extent that you \n14 \ngot that information in communications with him \n15 \nduring the time where he was seeking legal \n16 \nrepresentation on particular questions for you, \n17 \nI would object to that information. \n18 \nA. \nI understand. That's why I wanted to \n19 \nclarify there was a period of time that that wasn't \n20 \ntrue. \n21 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n22 \nQ. \nAnd I'm just asking for his actual \n23 \ntelephone numbers. \n24 \nA. \nI'll check. I don't have them --\n25 \nQ. \nJust so that my record is clear -- my \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726939\n", "char_count": 1088}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 91, "text_content": "873 \n1 \nquestion is clear for the record, I'm only asking \n2 \nfor you to provide Jeffrey Epstein's telephone \n3 \nnumbers that you would call him on during the period \n4 \nof time prior to your representation in 2005. \n5 \nA. \nOkay. I would say 99 percent of the time, \n6 \nhe called me. So it was mostly a one-way phone \n7 \nsituation, but I'm sure I have some numbers that I \n8 \ncalled or called back, yeah. \n9 \nQ. \nDid you have his telephone number --\n10 \nA. \nI had some numbers, yeah, and I can \n11 \nprovide those if I can find them. \n12 \nQ. \nIn fact, I think I've seen a piece of your \n13 \njournal \n14 \nA. \nProbably has the numbers, yeah. \n15 \nQ. \nIt has all of them blacked out, so is \n16 \nthere --\n17 \nA. \nOkay. That's no secret. I can give them \n18 \nto you. \n19 \nMR. SIMPSON: Just for the record, \n20 \nCounsel, anything withheld as privilege would \n21 \nbe on our privilege log, and counsel will \n22 \naddress that. \n23 \nMR. EDWARDS: Okay. Yeah, I'm not asking \n24 \nabout anything on the privilege log. \n25 \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726940\n", "char_count": 1062}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 92, "text_content": "874 \n1 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n2 \nQ. \nAll phone numbers with -- what would you \n3 \nhave to do to get me all the phone numbers that you \n4 \nhad for Jeffrey Epstein? \n5 \nA. \nAlmost certainly just have my lawyers \n6 \nunblank out the pages. \n7 \nQ. \nOkay. \n8 \nA. \nI don't keep old phone books. \n9 \nQ. \nDid you have --\n10 \nMR. INDYKE: Would you be using those \n11 \nphone numbers for the purpose of publishing \n12 \nthem? Because I would have an objection to \n13 \nthat. \n14 \nMR. EDWARDS: No. \n15 \nMR. INDYKE: Confidential information. \n16 \nMR. EDWARDS: I will agree not to publish \n17 \nhis phone numbers, especially his old phone \n18 \nnumbers from 1997. \n19 \nMR. INDYKE: Thank you. \n20 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n21 \nQ. \nDid you have telephone numbers for \n22 \nGhislaine Maxwell? \n23 \nA. \nNo. \n24 \nQ. \nDid you have a telephone number for \n25 \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726941\n", "char_count": 873}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 93, "text_content": "875 \n1 \nA. \n2 \nQ. \n3 \n4 \nA. \n5 \n6 \nNo. \nDid you have a direct telephone number for \nOf course not. \nMR. INDYKE: Objection. Objection as to \nactually all three to the extent that Alan has \n7 \nthat information based upon privileged \n8 \ninformation. \n9 \nA. \nI don't have the information, so it can't \n10 \nbe privileged. \n11 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n12 \nQ. \nDid you have a telephone number for \n13 \nJeffrey Epstein in Albuquerque? \n14 \nA. \nNo. There came a point in time -- no, I \n15 \nnever did, no. No, I don't think I ever did. \n16 \nQ. \nDid you have a telephone number for \n17 \nJeffrey Epstein at his residence in the island? \n18 \nMR. INDYKE: Same objection and same \n19 \nrequest as to confidentiality, if you do. \n20 \nA. \nI don't think so. Generally, I recall one \n21 \nnumber, I would call his secretary. I did not --\n22 \nfor example, did not have a cell phone number for \n23 \nhim. I would call his secretary if I needed him. \n24 \nIt was very rare that I called. And the secretary \n25 \nwould then call back. So I did not have numbers for \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726942\n", "char_count": 1084}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 94, "text_content": "876 \n1 \nhis various places that I can remember. \n2 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n3 \nQ. \nDid you have a phone number for Jeffrey \n4 \nEpstein's cell phone? \n5 \nA. \nI don't think so, no, I don't. Certainly \n6 \nduring that period, I did not. \n7 \nQ. \nWhen you would call Jeffrey Epstein's \n8 \nsecretary, what is the name of the secretary or \n9 \nsecretaries that you would speak to? \n10 \nA. \nDon't remember. The Groff person perhaps, \n11 \nbut I'm not positive. I just don't remember. \n12 \nQ. \nOther than Lesley Groff --\n13 \nA. \nI had a general number and I would call \n14 \nthat number. It was his business number, and she \n15 \nwould then arrange to have him call. Jeffrey is not \n16 \navailable, he'll call back. And then would call \n17 \nback. That was the general way in which I got in \n18 \ntouch with him. \n19 \nQ. \nIs Jeffrey Epstein somebody who, \n20 \nthroughout your relationship, has traveled \n21 \nfrequently? \n22 \nA. \nYes. \n23 \nQ. \nAnd so did you have a telephone number for \n24 \nhis airplanes? \n25 \nA. \nNo, of course not. I didn't have that \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726943\n", "char_count": 1083}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 95, "text_content": "877 \n1 \nkind of a relationship with Jeffrey Epstein. I had \n2 \na one-number generally business number and would I \n3 \ncall that and then I would get a call back. \n4 \nQ. \nHave you seen your -- the entry that \n5 \nJeffrey Epstein had for you in his journal? \n6 \nMR. INDYKE: Objection. \n7 \nA. \nI looked at all the entries he had --\n8 \nusually had 25 numbers for everybody. I don't know \n9 \nwhere he would have gotten those or how he used \n10 \nthem, but he apparently had numbers for everybody. \n11 \nQ. \nThat's what I was going to ask you --\n12 \nMR. INDYKE: Objection. Alan, are you \n13 \nbasing this upon information that you got from \n14 \nJeffrey or from information published by --\n15 \nA. \nNo, information that I got through the \n16 \ndiscovery. \n17 \nMR. INDYKE: Okay. Thank you. \n18 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n19 \nQ. \nHave you looked at the entry for yourself, \n20 \nAlan Dershowitz? \n21 \nA. \nDo you have it here? I would like to look \n22 \nat it. But I was always amazed by how many numbers \n23 \nhe had for everybody. \n24 \n(Thereupon, marked as Plaintiff \n25 \nExhibit 29.) \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726944\n", "char_count": 1114}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 96, "text_content": "878 \n1 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n2 \nQ. \nI'll show you what's 29. \n3 \nA. \nI have to look at that. \n4 \nMR. INDYKE: If you're going to ask Alan \n5 \nto pinpoint specific numbers, I would ask that \n6 \nyou not publish them in the deposition, if we \n7 \ncan figure out a way to do that. A telephone \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \nnumber, not a public record or something --\nMR. EDWARDS: I'll tell you this, I've \nisolated the page so as not to publish any more \nnumbers than necessary. And I would agree, if \nthat's something that Mr. Dershowitz wants, \nthat this entire page be sealed or protected so \nas not to unnecessarily disclose private \n15 \ninformation of others. \n16 \nA. \nThere are some of these numbers that are \n17 \nstill valid. I notice he has my number, he has my \n18 \nwife's number, my wife's car number. I mean -- as \n19 \nto everybody, he has just dozen of numbers. He's \n20 \nobviously obsessed with keeping everybody's possible \n21 \nnumbers. But it was a one-way street. I think I \n22 \nonly had -- I think I only had one of his numbers. \n23 \nI used one of his numbers when I wanted to call him. \n24 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n25 \nQ. \nAnd that one number that you had, can you \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726945\n", "char_count": 1217}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 97, "text_content": "879 \n1 \ntell me, was that a New York number, a Florida \n2 \nnumber, a Virgin Islands number? \n3 \nA. \nNew York number. \n4 \nQ. \nNew York number? \n5 \nA. \nYes, to his office on Madison Avenue. \n6 \nQ. \nThe only number that you had for Jeffrey \n7 \nEpstein that you remember? \n8 \nA. \nThat's my recollection. I may have had \n9 \nothers. \n10 \nQ. \nThat you remember was a New York telephone \n11 \nnumber? \n12 \nA. \nNew York telephone number, yeah. \n13 \nQ. \nOkay. And looking at the exhibit \nhave \n14 \nyou had a chance to review it so I can look at it? \n15 \nA. \nYeah, you can have it. \n16 \nQ. \nI think that you made a statement, I just \n17 \nwant too clarify for the record that he had all \n18 \nthese numbers for everybody? \n19 \nA. \nApparently, yeah. \n20 \nQ. \nBut if we look at this page, let's just be \n21 \nfair and accurate, he doesn't have a lot of numbers \n22 \nfor everybody, does he? \n23 \nA. \nHe has a lot of numbers for Jimmy Kane, I \n24 \nnotice. He has --\n25 \nQ. \nFor instance, let's say for \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726946\n", "char_count": 1037}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 98, "text_content": "880 \n1 \n[phonetic]? \n2 \nMR. SCAROLA: Do you want another copy? \n3 \nA. \nI have no idea who she is. \n4 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n5 \nQ. \nI'm not asking you to identify who any of \n6 \nthese people are. I just want the characterization \n7 \nof the number of numbers that Mr. Epstein has for \n8 \npeople just to be correct. \n9 \nA. \nI imagine it would depend on how many \n10 \nnumbers people have. I have an office, I have three \n11 \nhomes, I have -- you know, so he would have more \n12 \nnumbers for me. If he has somebody who he buys eggs \n13 \nfrom, they might have just a home number and another \n14 \nnumber. \n15 \nSo my feeling is that Jeffrey had \n16 \neverybody's number that he possibly could get, \n17 \nthat -- reviewing the whole thing, that's the \n18 \nimpression I certainly got. \n19 \nQ. \nWell, am I correct in presuming you would \n20 \nhave no idea, at least outside of privilege, how \n21 \nJeffrey Epstein obtained the telephone numbers of \n22 \nanyone else in the book other than perhaps yourself? \n23 \nA. \nWell, I know that he called -- at some \n24 \npoint, called my secretary -- his secretary called \n25 \nmy secretary and said, I want all of his numbers, so \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726947\n", "char_count": 1202}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 99, "text_content": "881 \n1 \nwe got -- he probably did that to everybody. He \n2 \ncalled assistants and secretaries and got \n3 \neverybody's numbers. I mean, I don't do that. He \n4 \ndid that. \n5 \nQ. \nWhen did Jeffrey Epstein have his \n6 \nsecretary call your secretary to get all of your \n7 \nnumbers? \n8 \nA. \nI have no idea. \n9 \nQ. \nDid he do it multiple times? \n10 \nA. \nI have no idea. \n11 \nQ. \nDo you know how he got the number for your \n12 \ncar? \n13 \nA. \nHe asked for it from my office, and I'm \n14 \nsure they gave it to him. \n15 \nQ. \nDo you see the entry \n16 \nMR. SIMPSON: Object on relevance. And \n17 \nwe're into our fourth day. This is one reason \n18 \nwe're into our fourth day, so I just object. \n19 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Overruled. \n20 \nA. \nGo ahead. What's --\n21 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n22 \nQ. \nDo you see that one of your numbers is \n23 \nlisted as all zeros? Do you know what that means? \n24 \nA. \nThe bottom one? \n25 \nQ. \nSecond to last. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726948\n", "char_count": 976}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 100, "text_content": "882 \n1 \nA. \nSecond to last, all zeros. I doubt that \n2 \nthat's a number. \n3 \nQ. \nWhen Jeffrey Epstein calls, does his \n4 \nnumber ever come up all zeros? \n5 \nA. \nI have no idea. I have no idea. I think \n6 \nI do recall that when he calls, at least sometimes, \n7 \nthe number is blocked, so I can't call back. \n8 \nQ. \nSometimes doesn't it show on the screen as \n9 \nall zeros? \n10 \nA. \nI don't know. That's not familiar to me, \n11 \nbut maybe. \n12 \nQ. \nOkay. But either way, for him slating an \n13 \nentry for you of all zeros, that is meaningless to \n14 \nyou? \n15 \nA. \nFor him what? \n16 \nQ. \nHim putting an entry for you as all zeros, \n17 \nthat's meaningless to you? \n18 \nA. \nProbably means he doesn't want me to have \n19 \nhis numbers to return. Probably means he's not a \n20 \nclose enough friend that he's willing to have me \n21 \nhave his number in return that he wants me to call \n22 \nhim back, but that's just a surmise. \n23 \nQ. \nOkay. After the Martha's Vineyard \n24 \nmeeting, when is the next encounter that you had \n25 \nwith Jeffrey Epstein? \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726949\n", "char_count": 1096}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 101, "text_content": "883 \n1 \nA. \nWhen he asked me to fly with him to New \n2 \nAlbany outside of Columbus to celebrate Leslie \n3 \nWexner's 59th birthday with President Shimon Peres \n4 \nof Israel, Senator John Glenn, Mr. Taubman of \n5 \nSotheby's, Leslie Wexner, Jeffrey Epstein, and maybe \n6 \none or two other men. And we sat around his table \n7 \nand had a very intellectual dinner, he showed us his \n8 \nart collection. And then we flew home. \n9 \nQ. \nWhere was that? \n10 \nA. \nI said New Albany, Ohio, right outside of \n11 \nColumbus. \n12 \nQ. \nThis was at Les Wexner's place? \n13 \nA. \nThat's right. \n14 \nQ. \nWhat did you understand the relationship \n15 \nof Les Wexner and Jeffrey Epstein at that time? \n16 \nA. \nMy understanding was that Jeffrey Epstein \n17 \nwas Leslie Wexner's financial advisor. He also had \n18 \na home -- Jeffrey Epstein had a home on the property \n19 \nthat at least he used. I assumed it was his, but \n20 \nI'm not positive. \n21 \nQ. \nDid Jeffrey Epstein ever recruit girls for \n22 \nVictoria's Secret? \n23 \nA. \nI have no idea. \n24 \nMR. INDYKE: Objection. To the extent to \n25 \nthe response to that information might require \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726950\n", "char_count": 1170}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 102, "text_content": "884 \n1 \nAlan to invade the attorney-client privilege, \n2 \nwork product privilege, common interest \n3 \nprivilege, I instruct him not to answer. \n4 \nA. \nI have no idea. I don't know. \n5 \nMR. SCOTT: His answer is he doesn't know. \n6 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n7 \nQ. \nHow is Les Wexner associated with \n8 \nVictoria's Secret? \n9 \nA. \nI think he's the CEO. Certainly the \n10 \nowner -- the general -- I don't know if it's a \n11 \npublic company or private company, but he is the \n12 \nguy, he's the guy who runs it. \n13 \nQ. \nWere you ever aware of any allegation \n14 \nagainst Jeffrey Epstein of using -- of holding \n15 \nhimself out as a recruiter for Victoria's Secret to \n16 \nsexually assault women? \n17 \nA. \nAbsolutely not. \n18 \nMR. INDYKE: Same objection, same \n19 \ninstruction. \n20 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n21 \nQ. \nHave you seen a police report to that \n22 \neffect? \n23 \nA. \nNo. This is the first \nliterally right \n24 \nnow is the first I've heard of it. \n25 \nMR. INDYKE: Same objection, same \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726951\n", "char_count": 1025}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 103, "text_content": "885 \n1 \ninstruction. \n2 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n3 \nQ. \nOkay. So, you never represented him in \n4 \nconnection with any such claim; is that right? \n5 \nMR. INDYKE: Same objection, same \n6 \ninstruction. \n7 \nA. \nI have no recollection. It's possible, \n8 \nbut I have no recollection. \n9 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n10 \nQ. \nJust so you know, I'm not saying that you \n11 \ndid. I'm just making sure it's not privileged. \n12 \nA. \nI have no recollection, yeah. \n13 \n(Thereupon, marked as Plaintiff \n14 \nExhibit 30.) \n15 \nMR. EDWARDS: I'll go ahead and mark this \n16 \nas Exhibit 30. \n17 \nMR. SCOTT: What are we looking at? Do \n18 \nyou have a copy? No, you don't. \n19 \nMR. EDWARDS: You don't want a copy? \n20 \nMR. SCOTT: Do you have a copy? \n21 \nMR. EDWARDS: Yeah, I have a copy. \n22 \nMR. SCOTT: Thank you. \n23 \nMR. SIMPSON: Can we have it? \n24 \nMR. EDWARDS: You can have it. \n25 \nMR. SCOTT: Oh, I'm not that --\nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726952\n", "char_count": 936}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 104, "text_content": "886 \n1 \nMR. EDWARDS: Cheer up. \n2 \nMR. SCOTT: I'm just -- I'm in a great \n3 \nmood. \n4 \nMR. SCAROLA: Closer we get to 3:30. \n5 \nMR. SCOTT: Mr. Scarola, we finally agree \n6 \non something. \n7 \nMR. SCAROLA: I knew we would. \n8 \nA. \nCan we have a date on this? \n9 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n10 \nQ. \nThere is a date on it. It's, I believe, \n11 \nMay of 1997. \n12 \nA. \nMay of 1997, before any of these things. \n13 \nI've never ever heard of any such allegation being \n14 \nmade against Jeffrey Epstein. He certainly never \n15 \ndiscussed it with me or mentioned it to me. \n16 \nQ. \nOkay. So you did not represent him in \n17 \nconnection with that allegation, correct? \n18 \nA. \nI don't think so. \n19 \nQ. \nOkay. When is the next encounter that you \n20 \nhad after the meeting in Georgia with Jeffrey \n21 \nEpstein? \n22 \nA. \nIt wasn't Georgia; it was New Albany, \n23 \nOhio. \n24 \nQ. \nOh, sorry. I thought you said Georgia. \n25 \nA. \nI did. I then corrected it to Ohio. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726953\n", "char_count": 994}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 105, "text_content": "887 \n1 \nI think the next one was when he invited \n2 \nme and my nephew, Adam Dershowitz, who was then an \n3 \napplicant for the space program, he was trying to be \n4 \nan astronaut, graduated MIT in robotics and \n5 \naeronautics, and Jeffrey invited me and him to go to \n6 \nthe launch of one of the space shuttles. And he \n7 \nflew us on his airplane along with an art dealer, a \n8 \nwoman who was the art dealer's significant other, a \n9 \nnumber of other people, and we flew to -- I think we \n10 \nflew into one of the airports, maybe the Palm Beach \n11 \nairport, in the big plane. \n12 \nAnd then -- maybe \nI'm not sure. We may \n13 \nhave flown directly to Cape Canaveral airport or \n14 \nsomething like that. We spent two nights at that \n15 \npoint -- we spent one night and then part of another \n16 \nnight, because we had to get up very early in the \n17 \nmorning. The launch was 4:00 a.m. in the morning. \n18 \nSo I think we spent two nights, one and-a-half \n19 \nnights, my nephew and I, I think we shared a \n20 \nbedroom, at Jeffrey's house. We went to the launch \n21 \nand then we left. We flew back commercially. \n22 \nQ. \nAnd when was that? \n23 \nA. \nYou can check out when the launch was. \n24 \nBut it was, my recollection, around 19, I don't \n25 \nknow, '97, '98, '99. Early in my relationship with \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726954\n", "char_count": 1344}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 106, "text_content": "888 \n1 \nJeffrey Epstein. \n2 \nQ. \nAnd who else was at Jeffrey Epstein's home \n3 \nwhen you stayed the night on this occasion? \n4 \nA. \nI think the art dealer was there. \n5 \nQ. \nWho is that? \n6 \nA. \nI don't remember his name. \n7 \nQ. \nOkay. \n8 \nA. \nI don't remember anybody else. We met \n9 \nwith Mr. Golden, who is the director of the space \n10 \nprogram \nAnd --\n11 \nQ. \nWas Ghislaine Maxwell there? \n12 \nA. \nI don't remember her being there. \n13 \nQ. \nOkay. When is the next time that you were \n14 \nin the presence of Jeffrey Epstein? \n15 \nA. \nYou're talking generally? \n16 \nQ. \nYes, going to go through the chronology. \n17 \nA. \nI don't specifically remember, but I can \n18 \ntell you that the next time I do remember was when \n19 \nhe lent his house to us, and my grandson, my \n20 \ngranddaughter, my wife, my daughter, my son, my \n21 \ndaughter-in-law, spent five, six days in Jeffrey \n22 \nEpstein's house in Palm Beach. But now I think \n23 \nabout it, Jeffrey Epstein was not there, but his \n24 \nstaff was there. \n25 \nQ. \nDo you know what year that was? \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726955\n", "char_count": 1100}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 107, "text_content": "889 \n1 \nA. \nI think it was Christmas of 1995 -- 2005, \n2 \nsorry, 2005. Christmas 2005. Over the Christmas \n3 \nvacation or thereabouts, maybe earlier. It was \n4 \nprobably earlier. \n5 \nQ. \nYou told me about what I've written down \n6 \nas the third time that you met with Jeffrey Epstein, \n7 \nwhich was '97, '98 for the space shuttle. And then \n8 \nthe next time that you believe you were in Jeffrey \n9 \nEpstein's presence was 2005? \n10 \nA. \nOh, I thought you asked about his house. \n11 \nI'm sorry. I misunderstood. \n12 \nPresence? Oh, I mean, probably a dozen \n13 \ntimes at Harvard during that period of time. He had \n14 \nan office in Brattle Square in which he would hold \n15 \nseminars. And I would get a call from his \n16 \nsecretaries saying Jeffrey would like you to come to \n17 \nthe seminar, it's at 12 to 2 at 1 Brattle Square. \n18 \nAnd I would go to offer critiques to \n19 \npapers. Once I presented a paper. People who would \n20 \nbe there included Larry Summers, the president of \n21 \nHarvard; and Henry Rosovsky, the provost of Harvard; \n22 \nSteve Kosslyn, the chairman of the psychology \n23 \ndepartment; a man named Church who decoded the \n24 \ngenome; and Stephen J. Gould, the well-known \n25 \npaleontologist. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726956\n", "char_count": 1267}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 108, "text_content": "890 \n1 \nAnd so we would have those seminars, so I \n2 \nmet with him periodically at Harvard. \n3 \nQ. \nOkay. Have you looked at the flight logs \n4 \nfor the flight that you mentioned with your wife and \n5 \nwhoever else went with you to the -- to Cape \n6 \nCanaveral? \n7 \nA. \nMy wife was not with me in Cape Canaveral. \n8 \nQ. \nOkay. Your nephew. \n9 \nA. \nMy nephew was with me, yeah. \n10 \nQ. \nHave you looked for that flight on the \n11 \nflight log? \n12 \nA. \nI have not. It's not within the relevant \n13 \ntime period, so I haven't looked at it. \n14 \nQ. \nOkay. And that's not really my point \n15 \nHave you looked for some of these other flights that \n16 \nyou've taken on his airplane and not been able to \n17 \nfind it? \n18 \nA. \nNo. Absolutely not. That's not the case. \n19 \nI've never seen any evidence of any missing logs \n20 \nmyself, any missing flight logs. \n21 \nQ. \nHave you looked for that particular flight \n22 \nthat you just discussed? \n23 \nA. \nNo, no because it was outside the \n24 \ntimeframe. Well outside the timeframe, yeah. \n25 \nQ. \nOkay. But only on the topic of whether or \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726957\n", "char_count": 1132}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 109, "text_content": "891 \n1 \nnot there are missing logs, have you --\n2 \nA. \nThat's not been something I've focused on. \n3 \nI was only looking at whether or not, within the \n4 \ntimeframe, who was with who on what flights, and I \n5 \nsaw that \nwas on some flights with \n6 \nother prominent academics, but never on a flight \n7 \nwith me. \n8 \nQ. \nDo you know who \nwas lent \n9 \nout to for sex by Jeffrey Epstein? \n10 \nMR. INDYKE: Objection based upon \n11 \nattorney-client privilege, work product. \n12 \nA. \nNo, I can tell you outside of the \n13 \nprivileged information. I can tell you outside of \n14 \nthe privilege. I can tell you outside of the \n15 \nprivilege that she has claimed to have had sex on \n16 \nnumerous occasions with Leslie Wexner, and was told \n17 \nby -- by Sigrid McCawley that --\n18 \nMS. McCAWLEY: I'm going to object to the \n19 \nline of questioning. \n20 \nMR. SCOTT: Time out. \n21 \nA. \nThat is from a statement made to me --\n22 \nMS. McCAWLEY: No, I just want to be clear \n23 \nbecause if we're going to violate the privilege \n24 \nagain, the order of seal. \n25 \nA. \nWe are not. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726958\n", "char_count": 1116}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 110, "text_content": "892 \n1 \nMS. McCAWLEY: I'm going to stop that \n2 \nright now because the only conversations I've \n3 \nhad with you are in the context of settlement \n4 \ndiscussion in this case. \n5 \nA. \nIt was not a conversation with Sigrid \n6 \nMcCawley. And please let me answer the question. I \n7 \nhad a conversation --\n8 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n9 \nQ. \nJust so we know what the question is, my \n10 \nquestion is --\n11 \nA. \nThe question is do I know whether she had \n12 \nsex --\n13 \nQ. \nNo, it's not. \n14 \nMR. SCOTT: Let's just ask the question. \n15 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Hang on. And, \n16 \ncourt reporter, please reread the question so \n17 \nwe understand. \n18 \nCOURT REPORTER: \"Do you know who \n19 \nwas lent out to for sex by Jeffrey \n20 \nEpstein?\" \n21 \nA. \nAnd the answer \n22 \nMR. SIMPSON: Darren had an objection for \n23 \nyou. \n24 \nA. \nOkay. I understand the instruction, and I \n25 \ncan answer the question. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726959\n", "char_count": 941}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 111, "text_content": "893 \n1 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n2 \nQ. \nI just want the names of the individuals. \n3 \nA. \nI can't just give you that. I can tell \n4 \nyou that \n5 \nQ. \nThat's what I'm asking for. \n6 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Hang on one \n7 \nsecond. The question is: Do you know who \n8 \nwas lent out to for sex by \n9 \nJeffrey Epstein? \n10 \nMR. EDWARDS: Right. The names of the \n11 \nindividuals is all I'm looking for. \n12 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: There's an \n13 \nobjection. Okay. Go ahead. \n14 \nA. \nI was told by John Zeiger, who was Leslie \n15 \nWexner's lawyer, that Sigrid McCawley claims that \n16 \nher client, \n, alleges that she had \n17 \nsex with \n-- and she said this, according to \n19 \nMr. Zeiger, very aggressively \n20 \nMS. McCAWLEY: This is revealing \n21 \nconfidential settlement discussions. \n22 \nA. \nBetween who? \n23 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Between -- I'm not going to \n24 \nreveal what confidential settlement discussions \n25 \nbecause that breaches a privilege. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726960\n", "char_count": 991}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 112, "text_content": "894 \n1 \nSo what I'm going to say is that we are \n2 \nnot entitled here to be revealing any \n3 \nsettlement discussions that have happened on \n4 \nbehalf of my client. I'm not going to allow \n5 \nthere to be testimony as to that. To the \n6 \nextent this involves Mr. Wexner's attorneys, \n7 \nthey are not present at this deposition at this \n8 \nmoment who you are mentioning, John Zeiger, \n9 \nwho's not able to object to this line of \n10 \nquestioning. You've had your client Jeffrey \n11 \nEpstein's lawyers on the phone the entire time, \n12 \nhe should be entitled to a right to object to \n13 \nthis before there's a revelation of any \n14 \nsettlement discussions. \n15 \nMR. SCAROLA: I want to know for the \n16 \nrecord that Mr. Dershowitz has chosen to \n17 \ndisregard the instruction that came from \n18 \nMr. Epstein's counsel. And that \n19 \nA. \nNo, I haven't. I have said this comes \n20 \noutside the privilege. \n21 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Stop. Let him \n22 \nput his -- on the record. Go ahead. \n23 \nMR. SCAROLA: Which is inconsistent with \n24 \nthe position that Mr. Dershowitz's counsel says \n25 \nthey were taking, and that is that they were \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726961\n", "char_count": 1185}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 113, "text_content": "895 \n1 \n1 \ngoing to respect those objections without \n2 \nevaluating whether those objections were or \n3 \nwere not well founded. Only noting it for the \n4 \nrecord. Doesn't call for any argument or \n5 \ndiscussion. \n6 \nMR. SCOTT: I don't agree with you. \n7 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Hang on one \n8 \nsecond. Go ahead, Mr. Scott. \n9 \nMR. SCOTT: I don't agree with your \n10 \ncharacterization at all. I totally disagree \n11 \nwith it. We haven't done anything inconsistent \n12 \nwith what I've said. \n13 \nMR. SCAROLA: Right. What you said is \n14 \nyou're going to honor the objections that have \n15 \nbeen raised by Epstein's counsel and allow the \n16 \nCourt to rule on those --\n17 \nMR. SCOTT: I have said that. \n18 \nMR. SCAROLA: -- without independently \n19 \nevaluating the validity of those objections. \n20 \nMR. SCOTT: Exactly. \n21 \nMR. SCAROLA: But now Mr. Epstein [sic) is \n22 \nindependently evaluating the validity of the \n23 \nobjection and the instruction and attempting to \n24 \ninsert information in the record that he knows \n25 \nis the subject of an order of the Court. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726962\n", "char_count": 1121}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 114, "text_content": "896 \n1 \nMR. SCOTT: And my observation is that the \n2 \nwitness began to answer the question, the \n3 \nspecial master and I both instructed the \n4 \nwitness not to respond until the question is on \n5 \nthe record and we can find out what was \n6 \nhappening. That's all I'm doing. I'm trying \n7 \nto preserve \n8 \nMR. SCAROLA: And he continued to answer \n9 \nanyway. \n10 \nMR. SCOTT: Well, I told him twice, and he \n11 \nthought -- he believes he has the right to \n12 \nanswer. I've asked him not to answer until we \n13 \nget a position from the special master on this. \n14 \nA. \nI'm answering it outside the privilege. \n15 \nMR. SCOTT: He's trying to say that it's \n16 \noutside that, and he wants to express his \n17 \nviewpoint. And I'm saying before he even does \n18 \nthat, Mr. Scarola, let the special master hear \n19 \nwhat he wants to do. That's all. \n20 \nMS. McCAWLEY: I want to add to the \n21 \nrecord. \n22 \nMR. SCOTT: Ad I'm trying to preserve --\n23 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Hang on one \n24 \nsecond. Hang on. Go ahead, Ms. McCawley. \n25 \nMS. McCAWLEY: I just wanted to add to the \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726963\n", "char_count": 1124}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 115, "text_content": "897 \n1 \nrecord that to the extent this is pulling in a \n2 \nconversation with Mr. Zeiger, who represents \n3 \nMr. Wexner, that he should be entitled to be \n4 \npresent for any objections to revelation of \n5 \ndisclosures of those conversations, the same \n6 \nway that Mr. Epstein, who has not appeared in \n7 \nthis case, has counsel on the phone objecting \n8 \nto every single question in this deposition. \n9 \nA. \nHow does she have standing to raise that? \n10 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Please. So \n11 \nlet's cut through this. First let me deal with \n12 \nwhat Mr. Scarola had to say. \n13 \nMy understanding of the objection and \n14 \nthe -- to the degree that Mr. Epstein's counsel \n15 \nobjected, it could only be to the privileged \n16 \ninformation that he asserts under whatever \n17 \nprivilege. \n18 \nMy understanding of what the witness began \n19 \nto answer would be outside of that privilege, \n20 \nor nonprivileged information. \n21 \nHowever, Ms. McCawley raises an issue \n22 \nbased upon a previous order of the Court. Am I \n23 \ncorrect? \n24 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Yes. \n25 \nTHE COURT: And the scope of that order \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726964\n", "char_count": 1151}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 116, "text_content": "898 \n1 \nwas? Please share with me. \n2 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Right. The scope of the \n3 \norder was to seal settlement \nconfidential \n4 \nsettlement discussions. And that's the scope \n5 \nof the order. There's still pending a motion \n6 \nfor sanctions with respect to that, which will \n7 \nnow be --\n8 \nTHE COURT: Hang on. And, Ms. McCawley, \n9 \nyou believe that the nature of the answer would \n10 \nfall under those settlement discussions and, \n11 \ntherefore, are subject to the Court's order? \n12 \nMS. McCAWLEY: I do. I believe that's a \n13 \npossibility, and that Mr. Zeiger should be \n14 \npresent to the extent that there's going to be \n15 \ncommunication of confidential nature to be able \n16 \nto make his objection, if he has one. \n17 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Well, I'm not as \n18 \nconcerned with that. \n19 \nDo you want to say anything else? \n20 \nMR. SCOTT: No. I am here to abide by \n21 \nwhat you say. I mean, I don't think that the \n22 \norder by the Court at this point applies to \n23 \nthis conversation, but with that said, if \n24 \nMr. Wexler [sic], the attorney, feels like he \n25 \nwants to make an objection or something, I'm \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726965\n", "char_count": 1176}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 117, "text_content": "899 \n1 \nnot -- you know. I don't know. \n2 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: There could be \n3 \n85 lawyers on the phone making all kinds of \n4 \nobjections. I get that point. But I'm more \n5 \nconcerned with the scope of the order, which I \n6 \nhave not seen, and I certainly don't want to \n7 \nrun the witness into an issue that will \n8 \nultimately be settled up. And I'm -- here is \n9 \nwhere I'm tending to go. \n10 \nSince we have open issues with respect to \n11 \nthe privilege issues that have been raised \n12 \nhere, and Ms. McCawley in good faith has raised \n13 \nthis as a potential issue that would be in \n14 \ndirect contradiction to what she believes is \n15 \nalready a Court order by Judge Lynch, whether \n16 \nthe witness agrees or not, that is subject to \n17 \nsome level of discussion and argument that's \n18 \ngoing to be before Judge Lynch, then I will ask \n19 \nthe witness to step down on the answer and let \n20 \nMs. McCawley deal with that, if she wishes, in \n21 \nfront of the Court. \n22 \nMR. SCOTT: Okay. \n23 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Fair enough? \n24 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Thank you. Yes. I do have \n25 \nto break. It's almost time for me to leave. I \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726966\n", "char_count": 1195}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 118, "text_content": "900 \n1 \ndon't know if you want to finish up a question, \n2 \nBrad, but I'm going to need to step out. I'm \n3 \njust concerned about stepping out, given the \n4 \nnature of where we are. \n5 \nMR. EDWARDS: Two more short questions, \n6 \nand then we can break. \n7 \nA. \nSo you don't want me to answer that whole \n8 \nother question? \n9 \nMR. EDWARDS: It's not that I don't want \n10 \nyou to. I think that are you being instructed \n11 \nnot to answer that. So we'll come back to \n12 \nthat. \n13 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Well, \n14 \nMs. McCawley raised an objection which she \n15 \nbelieves is subject to a previous Court order \n16 \nwhich I don't have knowledge of, and so given \n17 \nthat, and given the caveat that it was \n18 \nnonprivileged relative to Mr. Epstein's \n19 \ncounsel's objection, we'll let that be dealt \n20 \nwith subsequent since we have to come back \n21 \nanyway. \n22 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n23 \nQ. \nOkay. Is Les Wexner a party to a joint \n24 \ndefense agreement? \n25 \nA. \nNo. \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726967\n", "char_count": 1021}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 119, "text_content": "901 \n1 \nQ. \nOkay. That card that we've marked as 26, \n2 \ncan you just look at the back of it and tell me what \n3 \nis the significance of the writing on the back that \n4 \nsays -- can you read what it says? \n5 \nA. \nIt says \"Scarola unethical e-mail.\" It's \n6 \na reference to the fact that when Mr. Scarola wrote \n7 \nto me and asked me to waive the statute of \n8 \nlimitations, he engaged in an unethical act by \n9 \nwriting directly to a counseled client. And my \n10 \nunderstanding of legal ethics is that he was not \n11 \nentitled to write to me asking me to waive a statute \n12 \nof limitations instead of going through my lawyer. \n13 \nAnd if I was -- I just made a note to \n14 \nmyself that if I was asked about that again, I would \n15 \nmake a point that that was one of the reasons that I \n16 \ndeclined to answer a direct e-mail from a lawyer to \n17 \nan uncounseled defendant -- to a counseled \n18 \ndefendant. \n19 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: So I can be \n20 \nclear with respect to this exhibit that's \n21 \nmarked 26, the back of it contains handwritten \n22 \n[sic] that is yours? \n23 \nTHE WITNESS: These are my notes that I \n24 \ntook over lunch. \n25 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: That's all I \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726968\n", "char_count": 1237}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 120, "text_content": "902 \n1 \nwanted. \n2 \nTHE WITNESS: Just to remind myself. \n3 \nBY MR. EDWARDS: \n4 \nQ. \nOkay. Last question. Outside of \n5 \nprivilege, inclusive of the potential \n6 \ncommunication -- confidential settlement \n7 \ncommunication privilege that we just discussed, are \n8 \nyou able to answer the question: Identify the \n9 \nindividuals that \nwas lent out to \n10 \nfor the purposes of sex by Jeffrey Epstein? \n11 \nMR. SCOTT: That's the question that we --\n12 \njust led to this whole thing that Ms. -- that \n13 \nthe young lady down at the end, Sigrid, doesn't \n14 \nwant him to answer. And so you're going to ask \n15 \nit again and create this whole issue again \n16 \nafter he said no? \n17 \nMS. McCAWLEY: What I don't want -- to be \n18 \nclear, so the record is clear, what I don't \n19 \nwant him to do is reveal confidential \n20 \nsettlement communications that are already the \n21 \nsubject of a Court order. \n22 \nMR. SCOTT: But he's indicating --\n23 \nMS. McCAWLEY: You heard his answer -- let \n24 \nme just finish. You heard his implicating me \n25 \nand another lawyer in discussions, and what I'm \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726969\n", "char_count": 1132}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 121, "text_content": "903 \n1 \nsaying is those are the subject of an order. \n2 \nSo if he can answer that question without \n3 \nrevealing that information, he can answer it, \n4 \nbut he cannot go on the record and reveal \n5 \nconfidential settlement discussions. \n6 \nMR. SCOTT: Can you answer that without \n7 \ngoing to into what the special master does not \n8 \nwant you to do to preserve the record? \n9 \nA. \nLet me think about that. I can say \n10 \nthat --\n11 \nMR. SCOTT: Well, wait a minute. Tell you \n12 \nwhat. Let's take a break for a minute. Let me \n13 \ntalk to him. I promised you that you would \n14 \nhonor all the privileges, and I don't want to \n15 \ngo down this road again. So let's take a break \n16 \nright now. If that ends up the end of the day, \n17 \nI think that's where we're at. \n18 \nMR. SCAROLA: Because this is an issue as \n19 \nto which Sigrid has an obvious interest, we \n20 \nwill wait to get the question answered when we \n21 \nreturn. \n22 \nMR. SCOTT: I agree with you. I'm trying \n23 \nto honor her request, just like I honored this \n24 \nlawyer's request. \n25 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: I think that's \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726970\n", "char_count": 1143}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 122, "text_content": "904 \n1 \nright. Let's go. \n2 \nMR. SCOTT: That's what I'm saying. \n3 \nA. \nI would like to answer that question, \n4 \nobviously. \n5 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: I realize that. \n6 \nMR. SCOTT: Okay. We got that. \n7 \nMS. McCAWLEY: And she's only protecting \n8 \nherself, not her client. \n9 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Okay. Got it. \n10 \nMR. SCAROLA: Those are entirely --\n11 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Ask that be stricken. \n12 \nMR. SCAROLA: Those are entirely \n13 \ninappropriate comments, and we move that they \n14 \nbe stricken. They are not responsive to any \n15 \npending question. They are self-serving. They \n16 \nare themselves a waiver of privilege. To the \n17 \nextent that Mr. Dershowitz has the ability to \n18 \nwaive any privilege, those kinds of comments \n19 \nwaive any personal privilege he has. \n20 \nMR. SCOTT: We don't agree with that as to \n21 \nany waiver. That's it, then. \n22 \nMR. SCAROLA: I do have a Motion to \n23 \nStrike. \n24 \nSPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: With respect to \n25 \nthe Motion to Strike by itself, notwithstanding \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726971\n", "char_count": 1068}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 123, "text_content": "905 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nall the other argument you made, I'm going to \nset that aside, and I will grant the Motion to \nStrike for purposes of that. \nMR. SCOTT: Thank you. \nTHE WITNESS: Thank you. \nVIDEOGRAPHER: We're going off the record. \nThe time is 3:34 p.m. \nAditb„,-\nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726972\n", "char_count": 397}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 124, "text_content": "906 \nCERTIFICATE OF OATH \nSTATE OF FLORIDA \nCOUNTY OF BROWARD \nI, the undersigned authority, certify \nthat ALAN M. DERSHOWITZ personally appeared \nbefore me and was duly sworn on the 13th day of \nJanuary, 2016. \nSigned this 17th day of January, 2016. \nKIMBERLY FONTALVO, RPR, CLR \nNotary Public, State of Florida \nMy Commission No. FF 226848 \nExpires: 7/12/2019 \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726973\n", "char_count": 416}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 125, "text_content": "907 \nCERTIFICATE OF REPORTER \nSTATE OF FLORIDA \nCOUNTY OF BROWARD \nI, KIMBERLY FONTALVO, Registered \nProfessional Reporter, do hereby certify that I \nwas authorized to and did stenographically report \nthe foregoing videotape continued deposition of \nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ; pages 648 through 455; that a \nreview of the transcript was requested; and that \nthe transcript is a true record of my \nstenographic notes. \nI FURTHER CERTIFY that I am not a \nrelative, employee, attorney, or counsel of any \nof the parties, nor am I a relative or employee \nof any of the parties' attorneys or counsel \nconnected with the action, nor am I financially \ninterested in the action. \nDated this 14th day of January, 2016. \nKIMBERLY FONTALVO, RPR, CLR \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726974\n", "char_count": 786}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 126, "text_content": "908 \nJanuary 17, 2016 \nCOLE, SCOTT & KISSANE, P.A. \nDadeland Centre II - Suite 1400 \n9150 South Dadeland Boulevard \nMiami, Florida 33156 \nBY: THOMAS EMERSON SCOTT, JR., ESQ. \nthomas.scott@csklegal.com \nRe: Bradley Edwards, et al., v. Alan M. Dershowitz \nPlease take notice that on the 13th day of January, \n2016, you gave your deposition in the above cause. \nAt that time, you did not waive your signature. \nThe above-addressed attorney has ordered a copy of \nthis transcript and will make arrangements with you \nto read their copy. Please execute the Errata \nSheet, which can be found at the back of the \ntranscript, and have it returned to us for \ndistribution to all parties. \nIf you do not read and sign the deposition within a \nreasonable amount of time, the original, which has \nalready been forwarded to the ordering attorney, may \nbe filed with the Clerk of the Court. \nIf you wish to waive your signature now, please sign \nyour name in the blank at the bottom of this letter \nand return to the address listed below. \nVery truly yours, \nKIMBERLY FONTALVO, RPR, CLR \nPhipps Reporting, Inc. \n1551 Forum Place \nBuilding 200, Suite E \nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33401 \nI do hereby waive my signature. \nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726975\n", "char_count": 1277}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02726849", "page_number": 127, "text_content": "909 \nERRATA SHEET \nDO NOT WRITE ON TRANSCRIPT - ENTER CHANGES HERE \nIn Re: BRADLEY EDWARDS, ET AL., V. ALAN M. \nDERSHOWITZ \nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ \nJanuary 13, 2016 \nPAGE \nLINE \nCHANGE \nREASON \nUnder penalties of perjury, I declare that I have \nread the foregoing document and that the facts \nstated in it are true. \nDate \nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA02726976\n", "char_count": 392}]}