{"efta_number": "EFTA02645850", "page_count": 4, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02645850", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02645850.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02645850", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "From: \nJoscha Bach \nSent: \nFriday, July 7, 2017 1:31 AM \nTo: \nJeffrey Epstein \nSubject: \nRe: Joi \nDear Jeffrey, \nHere are some reflections. Of course I can only extrapolate over the =hings I get to hear and rationalize over the \ndistribution, and I am not =ctively trying to solicit opinions about you. \nPeople reflect in the categories they know, so when they discuss you, =hey will end up putting you in categories that fit \ninto their world =iew. (Which of course is also true for myself, I cannot know my blind =pots, but at least I am aware that \nI have no idea what it is like to =row up as an upper middle class Jewish boy in NYC.) \nThe first sentence of your Wikipedia entry introduces you as a sex =ffender, which due to contemporary America's \nfascinating difficulty of =ealing with all things sex related establishes a strong prior on you =eing a pariah. It is also pretty \nmuch the only thing that people =utside of your circles know you for. Their null hypothesis will tend to =e that you \ncombine the apparently suspicious trait of being wealthy =ith the apparently horrible trait of being too much interested \nin too =oung girls. \nThis is a very strange contrast, because there are probably very few =ontemporary individuals that have had the same \ncuriosity for and =nfluence on instigating foundational research across fields as you did. \nOnce people get to know you in person and are interested in you, they =end to either compartementalize the topic (as a \nsomehow difficult to =ccept aspect of an important friend), or treat it as somehow =nterestingly dark and edgy. It \nseemed to never have been met with =utright approval, and very rarely not been an issue at all, even when =t is \nbalanced against your sharp, original and interesting mind. I have =eard two people call you a savant, and you appear to \nbe somewhat =nscrutable and mysterious, to which the apparent darkness adds. Some =ighly moralistic Jewish \nintellectuals seem to see you as part of the =lock, but a black sheep, with relationships maintained because you are \n=oyal and reliable, but despite grave moral objections. \nThe smart college student may not have had enough life experience to not =ort people into good and evil, and may have \ndifficulty to assume that =ou could be anything but dangerous and corrupted by darkness. While she =ight be happy to \naccept any amount of nepotism from a female benefactor =s laudable mentorship and empowering feminism, accepting \nyour support =ould have meant to join into the corruption of the darkest imaginable =otions of patriarchy. Trivers was \nfaced with a similar sentiment when =e defended you publicly (even though it was to the tune of \"well he did =rong and \nserved a bit of time, not as much as we mortals would have, =ut still, and you should forgive him now\"), and Krauss (who \nin public =nternet discussions maintained that you did nothing wrong, and took =eavy flak for it). The general public \ndoes not seem to be able to =nderstand how morality is constructed (which of course would defeat the =volutionary and \nsocial purpose of morality to keep the public in =heck), so they won't be able to see straight. \nIf people are able to think outside of moralistic terms, they may simply =ark you down as an ephebophile but are bound \nto notice a few quirks. \nFirst of all, why did you let yourself get caught? In the German =urisdiction (and likely not just there) you may have not \nfaced the same =isks, and you are good at calculating risks. Multiply the risk of a relationship to a girl getting sour or \nhighjacked by an enemy by a =ufficiently large number of girls, and doom is almost certain. A power =rip? What does \nEFTA_R1_01882457 \nEFTA02645850\n", "char_count": 3699}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02645850", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "that recklessness mean for your relationships to others? =r is it simply due to having grown up in a different time and \nculture, =nd having not noticed how the culture has changed? \nThis relates to the second quirk: publicly showing off relationships to =ery young women. While rich nerds continue to \nhave concubines, it is =ither done discreetly, or framed as polyamory. Surrounding oneself with =ultiple young women \nwhile maintaining a power differential is =pparently only seen as acceptable for teenage rockstars or rappers in =heir \ntwenties, i.e. today's public norms do not allow for a large age =ifference (while a woman with younger men will \nprobably be seen as =eminist and empowered, which of course rarely happens). Showing that =ff is seen almost \nuniversally as crass (ie in bad taste). The people =hat have a friendly relationship to you are bound to interpret that as = \ncostly signal, since they usually cannot imagine that you are not =ware of the norms and the price you pay (unless you \nare aware of what =s really going on and let them in on your deeper reasons). If a mature =oman complains about your \nassistants, she is not going to refer to =heir youth and beauty which she will see as competition. Instead, she =efers to \nher culturally/morally entrenched distaste with the =rrangement. (Stephen Wolfram had the same objection, and \ninitially saw =hat as a reason to not meet up with you.) \nThe third interesting observation is that your relationships to young =omen appear not to be on equal footing but \ndominant-submissive, with =ittle apparent regard for hurt feelings. While you are brutally honest =nd direct with men, \ntoo, you don't come across as reveling in the power =ifference when interacting with men, or making an example of \ntheir =ntellectual and personal limitations in front of others. \nIt is as if you are attracted to women (as long as they are not too =omanly), but you don't like them very much. While \nindividual women gain =our respect, it seems to be much harder for them than for men, and it =s as if they are \ninherently less trustworthy. \nThe strange thing about these quirks is that it appears that you are =cting against your own interest with them. While I \nmight tend to be to =rusting with women (this trust is rarely violated though), you seem to =e mismodeling them as \nintrinsically dangerous. (Obviously, you are at =uch greater risk of exploitation by women than me, of course. In many \n=omen I wake somewhat motherly instincts.) The people that can only work =ith the media/wikipedia narrative fall into \ntwo groups: if they don't =otice you are acting against your own interest, they will consider you =vil. If they notice that \nyou apparently harm yourself, they should =ssume that something terrible happened to you in your childhood that =ot \nyou twisted. \nThe latter is also probably the only plausible path to possible =edemption in the eyes of the circles of the US \nintelligentsia. The =asiest explanation for your unusual choice of partners and the nature =f your public relationships to \nthem is obviously childhood abuse. If =ost of these people suspected that you suffered something unspeakable =t the \nhands of an adult female caregiver, and it just took you decades =o work through it (understanding that someone likely \nabused her, so she =urned against you etc.), they would be able to feel that they =nderstand you, and many more would \nfeel acceptance. Some people might =ven realize that you paid a much higher price than your purported =ictims. On the \nother hand, while such a story could probably be =lanted, I cannot imagine what that would mean for you and your \n=elationship to yourself. \nIn all these matters, the truth might be elusive and ultimately =rrelevant, except inasmuch as it concerns personal pain. \nWhat people =ee of you is that you are effective, reliable, ruthless, provocative, =wisted, sometimes utterly crass, \nunconventional, likely not vain, and =ompletely unafraid. You incentivize the people in our shared circle =xtremely well \nfor cooperation, by being generous, loyal, curious, =ntellectually interesting and benevolent. But to regain your place as \na =ocially accepted cultural force you cannot present an image as an =nrepentant and unevolving connoisseur of \nimmature girls. \nNo matter what the causal mechanisms and personal preferences are, the =rice that such relationships have for the \npublic image in 2017 is very =igh. (The notable philosopher Colin McGinn lost his tenure and chances =f future \nemployment over a harmless crush on a grad student, and MIT's =amous Walter Levin lost all his social capital due to an \nentendre to an =nline course participant.) Even the enlightened parts of society that =re accepting of all kinds of \n2 \nEFTA_R1_01882458 \nEFTA02645851\n", "char_count": 4799}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02645850", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "consensual relationships are uncomfortable =ith power differentials in erotic relationships. They mean that in the =yes \nof the public, you lose plausible deniability with respect to the =rue backgrounds of the accusations against you. \nOn a personal level: I cannot say how grateful I am for your unwavering =upport. I have gone through a pretty bad year \n(nothing like what =appened to you, of course). If there is ever anything I can do to help =ou, please let me know. \nWith kind regards, \nJoscha \n> On Jul 2, 2017, at 05:35, jeffrey E. <jeevacation@gmail.com> wrote: \n> joi laughed . and I believe a sincere laugh. . but .. Karyna =old me that i had left my shoes on. . in a Japanese \nhouse.. so . =ifficult to know \n> \nI dont spend much time thinking about how people perceive me. I =ry to maintain my own compass. I dont admit \nan age or power =ifference in my intereactions . In the past if i did things in =rder to satisfy someones perceptions ( \nwithin bounds) . I often ended =ith an unintended result. ex. I recently met very smart college =tudent . very cute. . I \ntold her I would help her getting grants. =he was insulted . and when pressed said she couldnt be bought. \n=oscha. \n. both you and I have lived the consequences of not being =ware of others motivations. perceptions etc . so I am happy \nto explore =our views. I rarely get insulted. so if you would like to give me =ome of yours , feel free. -- your funding \nis intact :) . no matter =hat \n> On Sun, Jul 2, 2017 at 3:48 AM, Joscha Bach •,\n:• =rote: \n> How did Joi react? :) \n> More generally, I would be curious to learn how you think that other =eople perceive you, and how much they can \nglimpse behind your curtain. \n> In the last three years, I have developed a lot more self-awareness, \n> =ot least thanks to you. (It does not mean that I now perfectly \n> =nderstand how others see me, but that I notice that my self model and \n> =he perspective of others, and the more importantly, my model of how \n> =thers model me, have serious discrepancies.) \n> — Joscha \n• \nplease note \n> The information contained in this communication is confidential, may \n> be attorney-client privileged, may constitute inside information, and \n> is intended only for the use of the addressee. It is the property of \n> JEE Unauthorized use, disclosure or copying of this communication or \n> any part thereof is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful. If you \n> have received this communication in error, please notify us \n> immediately by return e-mail or by e-mail to jeevacation@gmail.com, \n> and destroy this communication and all copies thereof, including all \n> attachments. copyright -all rights reserved \n3 \nEFTA_R1_01882459 \nEFTA02645852\n", "char_count": 2706}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02645850", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "<?xml version=.0\" encoding=TF-8\"?> \n<IDOCTYPE plist PUBLIC \"-//Apple//DTD PLIST 1.0//EN\" \"http://www.apple.com/DTDs/Propertylist-1.0.dtd\"> \n<plist version=.0\"> \n<dict> \n<key>conversation-idgkey> \n<integer>40010</integer> \n<key>date-last-viewed</key> \n<integer>0</integer> \n<key>date-received</key> \n<integer>1499391073</integer> \n<key>flags</key> \n<integer>8590195713</integer> \n<key>gmail-label-ids</key> \n<array> \n<integer>6</integer> \n<integer>2</integer> \n</array> \n<key>remote-id</key> \n<string>727774</string> \n</dict> \n</plist> \n4 \nEFTA_R1_01882460 \nEFTA02645853\n", "char_count": 570}]}