{"efta_number": "EFTA02573553", "page_count": 2, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02573553", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02573553.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02573553", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "From: \nEd < \nSent: \nWednesday, August 14, 2013 6:03 PM \nTo: \nEpstein, Jeff \nSubject: \nSteve Cohen vs. the Federal Wrecking Ball \nThe Federal Wrecking Ball \nBy Edward Jay Epstein \nA bedrock principle of Anglo-Saxon jurisprudence is that there is a =resumption of innocence, This should mean that if \nthe government fails =o find incriminating evidence in an exhaustive investigation, they =annot punish a person for a \ncrime or confiscate his property. Yet, =rosecutors have found ways to bypass the absence of evidence when it =omes to \nWall Street, Consider the case of Steven A. Cohen, the founder =nd owner of SAC Capital Advisors, a ten-billion group of \nhedge funds, =o one can doubt that the six year investigation of him for inside =rading qualifies as exhaustive. \nIt originated with a highly-plausible theory that his =onsistently high trading profits resulted from an orchestrated \nscheme =f inside trading. To substantiate it, the SEC and Department of =ustice sought the requisite evidence. They \nsubpoenaed or otherwise =anaged to obtain 375 million pages of the trading records, =orrespondence and other \ndocuments of Cohen and his SAC funds. This =assive trove of documents, however, did not yield any usable evidence \n=hat Cohen was involved in inside trading. The Feds also employed =urreptitious means to attempt to find evidence to \nsubstantiate their =heory, including planting court-approved listening devices in =ohen's home to intercept his \nconversations, including ones with his =op lieutenants used plan his funds' weekly trading strategy, and =lanting a mole \nin his organization. The mole was Richard C.B Lee, a =ormer SAC employee, who, wearing a wire, proposed various \n\"trading =deas\" based on inside information to Cohen ( presumably scripted by =is Fed handlers.). Despite the \nprovocations, none of the bugging =roduced any usable evidence against Cohen. Finally, as is not uncommon =n Wall \nStreet cases, prosecutors attempted to induce former and =resent SAC employees to testify against Cohen, including \neight who had =een themselves charged with using inside information, Even though =ive of them agreed to cooperate \nwith the government, none were able to =rovide evidence that Cohen had known of their alleged inside trading, =ven \nwen by proffering it they might have spared them prison sentence. =As a result, the government had no evidence to \nsupport its theory in =ourt. Despite this embarrassing absence of evidence against Cohen, the =rosecutors did not give \nup. Instead, it shifted to plan B: targeting =ohen's corporation, SAC Capital in a two pronged attack. \nThe first prong was a Grand Jury indictment of Cohen's corporate =Ito ego, SAC Capital, for security and wire fraud. It \nalleged that =AC had encouraged its employees to seek illegally-obtained data by =roviding them with profit-sharing and \nthen not properly enforcing its =wn rules against using inside information. SAC Capital, which denies =his allegation, \nwill have its day in court to defend itself. \nThe second prong was a civil forfeiture complaint charging that =AC Capital engaged in a money-laundering \nconspiracy. Such civil =orfeiture complaints began as means of destroying the cash resources =f drug traffickers. It \nallows the government to seize all the assets =f a suspect without even proving that a crime has been committed. =ince \nit is technically leveled against the asset itself, the =overnment need only to assert is that the \"preponderance of the \n=vidence\" shows that it is subject to forfeiture. When this complaint =s tied to money-laundering it can be disastrous for \na financial =nstitution because the government can freeze or seize all its assets, =ncluding those funds loaned to it.. In \nthe case of SAC Capital, the =utative money-laundering stems from the allegation the illegal earning =ere investing in, \nand thereby intermingled with, SAC Funds. But even =f this occurred, was it the sort of money-laundering in which \nprofits =rom an illegal enterprise are disguised as profits from a legal one? =one of the traders had to disguise their \ncommissions, bonuses and =erformance compensation, nor did they represent them as anything other =han trading \nprofits. But the government does not actually prove there =as money laundering since this a civil forfeiture complaint. \nThe lethal part of the civil forfeiture complaint was its scope, =eeking not a specific amount but \"any and all\" assets \nof SAC =apital. At last count, according to its regulatory filings, SAC funds =eld some $51 billion in securities and loans \nfrom counter parties. To =e sure, U.S. Attorney Preet Bharara currently is not seeking to =reeze these assets, a freeze \nEFTA_R1_01743828 \nEFTA02573553\n", "char_count": 4722}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02573553", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "which could rip a Lehman-size hole in =he counter parties, and he has agreed to a Court Protective order =ying up about \n$5 billion of SAC's capital. But the government could =hange its mind at any time, since a footnote in the agreement \nstates =hat the protective order does not limit the ability of United States =O proceed with the seizure of all of SAC's \nassets at some future =oint. So a sword of Damocles I hangs over SAC Capital. \nEven if it demolishes his corporate alter ego. Cohen may well =urvive the Federal wrecking ball. He is after all a \nbillionaire many =imes over with an extensive art collection. My concern here is not =he fate of Cohen or SAC Capital. It \nis with the government's =xpansive use of money-laundering charges in civil forfeiture cases =hen it is unable to find \nincriminating evidence. \nas ever \nEd \nwww.edwardjayepstein.com \n<?xml version=.0\" encoding=TF-8\"?> \n<!DOCTYPE plist PUBLIC \"-//Apple//DTD PLIST 1.0//EN\" \"http://www.apple.com/DTDs/PropertyList-1.0.dtd\"> \ncplist version=.0\"> \n<dict> \n<key>conversation-idgkey> \n<integer>263056</integer> \n<key>date-last-viewed</key> \n<integer>0</integer> \n<key>date-received</key> \n<integer>1376503387</integer> \n<key>flags</key> \n<integer>8590195713</integer> \n<key>gmail-label-ids</key> \n<array> \n<integer>6</integer> \n<integer>2</integer> \n</array> \n<key>remote-id</key> \n<string>332384</string> \n</dict> \n</plist> \n2 \nEFTA_R1_01743629 \nEFTA02573554\n", "char_count": 1434}]}