{"efta_number": "EFTA02522653", "page_count": 7, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA02522653", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA02522653.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA02522653", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "From: \nLawrence Krauss < \nSent: \nMonday, February 26, 2018 3:49 PM \nTo: \nSubject: \nFwd: URGENT: BuzzFeed News inquiry re allegations of sexual harassment by \nLawrence Krauss \nThe correspondence from Ron Lindsey to Pete= Aldhous. \nDirector, The Origins Project a= ASU \nFoundation Professor \nSchool of Earth & Space E=ploration and Physics Department Arizona State University,&=bsp;P.O. Box 871404, \n=/a>Tempe, AZ 85287-=404 Assistant (Jessica): \n<tel \n> Origins Office \n(Cynthia):&nbs \n<tel \n> <=ont color=\"#000000\" \n<mailto \n&n=sp \nSent from my iPhone \nBegin forwarded message: \nFrom: Ronald Lindsay < \n<mailto \nDate: February 26, 2018 at 7:=7:07 AM PST \nTo: \n<mailto \nSubject: Fwd: Fwd: URGENT: BuzzFeed News inquiry r= allegations of sexual harassment by Lawrence Krauss \nMy corresponden=e with Aldhous. As usual, read from the bottom up. \n \nForwarded message \nFrom: Ronald Lindsay < \n<mailto \n»=/span> \nDate: Mon, Dec 11, 2017 at 7:21 AM \nSubject: Re: Fwd: URGENT: B=zzFeed News inquiry re allegations of sexual harassment by Lawrence \nKrauss<=r>To: Peter Aldhous < \n<mailto \n> > \nDear Mr. Aldh=us, \nAdam Isaak resigned because I had a public spa= with his girlfriend, Rebecca Watson, who had issued a \npublic call for CFI e=ployees to quit. (That dispute is a whole other story, tangential to your K=auss piece, so I will not get \ninto it here.) \nEFTA_R1_01660902 \nEFTA02522653\n", "char_count": 1382}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02522653", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Timin= is important here. The email from Pat was in March. The dispute with Watso= started in mid-\nMay, after which Adam stopped showing up for work. (He said=he was sick & then went on vacation, or vice versa). He \nthen then left s=me time in June. If the Krauss matter \"pushed (him] over the edge,\" then he=was tenaciously hanging \non to the ledge for a few months. \nThe email from Pat Beauchamp was in the first person and Pat indicat=d she was speaking for herself. (I \nfound the email exchange last night; I w=ll forward it to you.) Adam had never been shy about expressing his concern= \nto me -- he asked for raises, complained about the hosts on the podcast he=was producing etc. The notion that he and \nPat were working together but tha= he decided he could not reveal his participation is difficult to credit.</=iv> \nI will be traveling to my home this evening. Plan to=reach my home by 7:45, but if I don't answer right \naway, please try a bit l=ter. My number is: \n<tel: \n> . \nSincerely, \nR. Lindsay \nOn Sun, Dec 10, 2017 at 10=45 PM, Peter Aldhous < \n<mailto \n> wr=te: \nDear Mr. Lindsay, \nThank you for your response, which we will consider in detail. Shall we speak at 7.45pm Eastern \ntomorrow? Do let me know what number to call. \nTo answer your question, the CFI employee who resigned was Adam Isaak. He told us that he \nhelped Patricia Beauchamp draft an email to you outlining their concerns about inviting Lawrence Krauss on the 2014 \ncruise. \nHe explained that his resignation had a broader context, relating to his concerns about sexism \nand online harassment in the skeptical movement. But he said that CFI's continued embrace of Krauss, in the face of \nconcerns expressed by staff, was what \"pushed me over the edge.\" \nSincerely, \nPeter Aldhous \nOn 12/10/17 7:27 PM, Ronald Lindsay wrote: \n=ear Mr. Aldhous, \n=et me note a couple of things at the outset. First, I would be happy to speak to you \nregarding the allegations in your email. You can reach me at my cell phone number,\n... [truncated, 2046 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02522653/1 or ?id=EFTA02522653&page=1]", "char_count": 2046}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02522653", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "<tel \n> . However, I am unavailable tomorrow (Monday) because of prior commitments until \napproximately 7:45 PM. \n=ext, you should know that I'm not an employee of CFI nor do I have any authority to \nspeak on behalf of CFI. I'm writing to you from my personal email account in part to underscore that point. I do retain a \nCFI email address in part as a courtesy to me and in part because it serves a business purpose (for example, I still receive \noccasional emails addressed to the president of the organization). \n=urning to the substance of your allegations, first you should be aware that I take the \nissue of sexual harassment very seriously. This is confirmed by the fact that after I was hired by CFI as its in-house lawyer \n(a position I held prior to becoming president and CEO) I insisted that the organization adopt a comprehensive zero-\ntolerance harassment policy covering workplace harassment. Moreover, during the time I was president and CEO we \nhad three separate state trainings for the entire staff on sexual harassment issues. In addition, where necessary, we did \nnot hesitate to expend significant resources, including retaining outside investigators, to conduct serious, detailed \ninquiries into harassment claims. One such inquiry cost the organization over $40,000. Therefore, any suggestion that I \ndo not personally take harassment claims seriously is amply disconfirmed by my record. \n=egarding the alleged incident on the 2011 cruise, the first I became aware of it was \nwhen Pat Beauchamp, CFI =99s business manager and the employee responsible for cruise logistics, wrote to me in 2013 \nindicating she objected to inviting Lawrence Krauss on our upcoming Galapagos cruise. I found this strange, and I \nresponded to her almost immediately asking the reasons for her objection. She gave two reasons. The first was that \nKrauss did not pay sufficient attention to the guests on the 2011 cruise. I had heard this concern from one guest myself; \non the other hand, I also h\n... [truncated, 4687 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02522653/2 or ?id=EFTA02522653&page=2]", "char_count": 4687}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02522653", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "reasons for the staffer leaving. Ms. Beauchamp remained an employee of CFI (and went on the Galapagos cruise with \nKrauss). \n=ou mentioned also the comments that were made to me in March 2012 by Melody \nHensley. Let me give you the background for that. CFI was holding an event prior to the 2012 Reason Rally in DC. Richard \nDawkins, Jessica Alquist, Jamie Raskin, and Lawrence Krauss were scheduled to speak at the event. Melody Hensley was \nheavily involved in the planning for the event and in fact was tapped to make introductions for the speakers, including \nKrauss. (At the time she was in charge of the DC local branch.) During the planning for the event she gave no indication \nwhatsoever that she had any hesitation about introducing or dealing with Krauss. (I will forward you some email \ncorrespondence confirming this.) \n=s I recall, Krauss's schedule resulted in his planned arrival being a little later than the \nothers. As it turned out, he was even further delayed. At some point when it became clear that Krauss was going to be \nlate, Hensley turned to me and said, \"I know why Kra=ss isn't coming; he's embarrassed to see me.\" I asked Hensley \nwhat she mea=t by this. She said Krauss had made a pass at her several years earlier and she had rebuffed him. I asked \nfor some details. She said she was in a hotel room with him (I can't recall whether she said it was Krauss's hotel room, \nbut I t=ink it was), and that Krauss tried to kiss her. She pushed him away and said she wasn't interested. I asked if \nKrauss persisted; she said he did not. Thinking out loud, I believe I said something to the effect of 'well, if you want t= \nmake a complaint you probably can, although I'm not sure our policy at that time w=uld cover that.' Ms. Hensley said \nshe was not interested in making a formal complaint. \n=s. Hensley's statement that I \"responded to her with silence\" is absolutely false and I \ncategorically and= unqualifiedly deny it. We talked about her concern, as indicated. Ms. \n... [truncated, 3528 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02522653/3 or ?id=EFTA02522653&page=3]", "char_count": 3528}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02522653", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Subject: URGENT: BuzzFeed News inquiry re allegations of sexual harassment by \nLawrence Krauss \nTo: \nMr. Lindsay: \n<mailto \nI'm a reporter for BuzzFeed News who has been investigating sexu=l misconduct \nallegations against Lawrence Krauss. \nThe story concerns Krauss's actions towards students while a pro=essor of physics at \nCase Western Reserve University, as well as his conduct=in non-academic settings as a prominent figure in the skeptics \nmovement. I a= reporting this story along with two of my colleagues on the science desk, A=een Ghorayshi and Virginia \nHughes. \nOur story is about several allegations of sexual misconduct dating from 2=06 to 2016. \nOur reporting also goes into how the various institutions Kraus= has been affiliated with — Case Western, Arizona State \nUniversity,=the Australian National University, the New College of the Humanities and t=e Center for Inquiry, for which \nyou formerly served as president — h=ve handled complaints and concerns about his behavior during this time. \nOur story is corroborated by emails, university documents, official comp=aints, \ntestimony from victims and witnesses, and interviews with more than t=o dozen of Krauss's current and former \nacademic colleagues, student=, and peers in the skeptics movement. \nI am writing to you now because you are personally named in the story, a=d because \nyou had executive responsibility for CFI's actions during=the time of some of the alleged incidents. \nI wanted to offer you the opportunity to comment and/or respond to the m=in facts we \nplan to publish regarding your involvement as the former head o= CFI during this time. If you wish to comment on any of \nthese findings, we n=ed to hear from you as soon as possible. We are planning on publishing our story T=esday morning \nUS Eastern Time. \nBased on our reporting so far, this is what we plan to publish that conc=rns you: \nOne incident involving Krauss allegedly occurred in May 2011 on a </=pan>CFI \ncruise <https://www.youtube.com/watc\n... [truncated, 2054 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA02522653/4 or ?id=EFTA02522653&page=4]", "char_count": 2054}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02522653", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "\" \nAttendees had paid several thousand dollars to join a cultural tour=of the Greek \nislands, featuring lectures from scientists and writers, inclu=ing Krauss. \n\" \nKrauss allegedly propositioned a female cruise-goer, who rejected an=invitation \nto join him and his female companion for sex in their cabin. \n• \nNo complaint was made, but the incident was reported to a CFI staffe= at the \ntime. \n• \nCFI's leadership continued to embrace Krauss, making him \nchttps://www.centerforinquiry.netinewsroom=krauss_named_honorary_board_memberk an honorary member o= its \nboard of directors in December 2011. \n• \nBut at least two staffers were sufficiently concerned about reports o= Krauss's \nbehavior that they urged you not to invite him on a 2014 <=span>cruise \nchttp://action.centerforinqui=y.net/site/MessageViewer?em_id=49328.0> of the Galapag=s Islands. \n• \nIn June 2013, after you rejected their advice and invited him on the=cruise, one \nof those staffers resigned. \n\" \nAt a conference in March 2012, another woman, who at that point was a=so an \nemployee of CFI, told you about an incident in 2006 in which Krauss f=rcibly kissed and groped her in a hotel room. \nAccording to this woman, afte= she told you about this in person, you responded to her with silence. \n\" \nThe woman later told two other employees in CA's management=about the \nincident, and expressed her discomfort at having Krauss continue t= speak at events. \n• \nCFI continued to book Krauss as a speaker at its events. \nAgain, if you wish to comment on or clarify any of these points, please g=t in touch with \nus as soon as possible. If I do not respond immediately it i= because I am on another call, so please leave the best phone \nnumber to rea=h you. \nThanks, \nPeter Aldhous \n<tel \n<tel \n=span class=\"m_6530976094949947939m_-4897364513939S2S238gmail-m_-\n556482939=921005860HOEnZb\"> \nPeter Aldhous, PhD \nScience reporter I Bu=zFeed News \ntel: \n<tel \n<mailto \n6 \nEFTA_R1_01660907 \nEFTA02522658\n", "char_count": 1964}, {"efta_number": "EFTA02522653", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "www.peteraldhous.com <https://twitter.com/paldhous> \nRonald A. Lindsay \nSenior Research Fellow \nCenter for Inquiry \n<mailt \n> \nCell: \n<tel \n> \nPeter Aldhous, PhD \nScience reporter I BuzzFeed News</=> \ntel: \n<tel \ncell: \n<tel \n> \n> \n@paldhous<h> \n<https://twitter.com/paldhous> www.peteral=hous.com <http://www.peteraldhous.com/> \n7 \nEFTA_R1_01660908 \nEFTA02522659\n", "char_count": 364}]}