{"efta_number": "EFTA01659896", "page_count": 6, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA01659896", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA01659896.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA01659896", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "U.S. Department ofJustice \nUnited States Attorney \nSouthern District of Florida \nNovember 30, 2007 \nDELIVERY BY FACSIMILE \nKenneth W. Starr, Esq. \nKirkland & Ellis LLP \nRe: \nJeffrey Epstein \nDear Mr. Starr: \nI write in response to your letter of November 28, 2007, to Assistant Attorney General \nThere are a number of issues that must be addressed, but I believe that a history of the \nnegotiations with the various counsel for Mr. Epstein would best illustrate how the Non-Prosecution \nAgreement was reached. I then will address some of your client's attempts to attack the agreement \nthat he signed, and I finally will address how our Office intends to proceed.' \nAt the end of 2006, Guy Lewis contacted AUSA \nwhen he learned that \nshe was handling the federal investigation of Mr. Epstein. He asked to meet with her and she stated \nthat she believed such a meeting wapeiremature. In December? S[\nin Sanchez and Gerald \nLefcourt again contacted AUSA \nto set a meeting. AUSA \nrequested documents \nin advance of such a meeting, but the request was refused. Ms. Sanchez then contacted AUSA \nwho agreed to meet with Ms. Sanchez and Mr. Lefcourt. On February 1, 2007, Ms. \nSanchez and Mr. Lefcourt met with AUSAs \nand \nas well as a member of the \nFederal Bureau of Investigation, presented defense counsel's view of the case, and promised a \nwillingness to assist in the investigation. The Office was unpersuaded by their presentation, and the \ninvestigation continued. \nBy the late Spring and early Summer, the focus of the investigation left investigating the \nfacts of the victims' claims and turned more to Mr. Epstein's background, his asserted defenses, co-\nconspirators, and possible witnesses who could corroborate the victims' statements. \nThe \n'First Assistant U.S. Attorney \nis sending a letter under separate cover \naddressing some of the items in the correspondence from you and Mr. Leflcowitz, since he has been \ndirectly involved in discussions of those issues. \nEFTA01659896\n", "char_count": 1988}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01659896", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "KENNETH STARR, ESQ. \nNOVEMBER 30, 2007 \nPAGE 2 OF 6 \ninvestigation also began to look into financial aspects of the case, requiring the issuance of several \nsubpoenas. At that time, Mr. Lefcourt be an levelin accusations of improprieties with the \ninvestigation and sought a meeting with \n• who was then Chief of the Criminal \nSection. By that time, our Office had already received a proposed initial indictment package, which \nhad been reviewed by the supervisors in our West Palm Beach Office and by attorneys with the \nJustice De artment's Child Exploitation and Obscenity Section, but which was awaiting review by \nand \n. The Office deferred presenting the indictment to the grand jury \nto accommodate your client's request for a meeting. The Office also agreed to wait several weeks \nfor that meeting to occur to allow four of Mr. Epstein's attorneys to be present, and also provided \nMr. Epstein's counsel with a list of the statutes that were the subject of the federal investigation. \nOn June 26, 2007, \nand \nand two \nSpecial Agents with the FBI met with four attorneys for Mr. Epstein, specifically, Alan Dershowitz, \nRoy Black, Gerald Lefcourt, and Lilly Ann Sanchez. During that meeting, Professor Dershowitz \nand other members of the defense team presented legal and factual arguments against a federal \nindictment. Counsel for the defense also requested the opportunity to present written arguments, \nwhich was granted. The arguments and written materials provided by the defense were examined \nby the Office and rejected. \nOn July 31, 2007, \nand \nand two FBI \nagents again met with Roy Black, Gerald Lefcourt, and Lilly Ann Sanchez. On that date, the Office \npresented a written sheet of terms that would satisfy the Office's federal interest in the case and \ndiscussed the substance of those terms. That term sheet is attached hereto. As you will note, one \nof those terms was: \nEpstein agrees that, if any of the victims identified in the federal investigation file \nsuit pursuant to \n... [truncated, 3306 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01659896/1 or ?id=EFTA01659896&page=1]", "char_count": 3306}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01659896", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "KENNETH STARR, ESQ. \nNOVEMBER 30, 2007 \nPAGE 3 OF 6 \nMr. Epstein's counsel, still dissatisfied with the Office's review of the case, demanded to \nmeet with me and to have the opportunity to meet with someone in Washington, D.C. To \naccommodate Mr. Black, the meeting was put off until September 7, 2007, despite the fact that the \nindictment was ready for presentation to the grand jury. In the interim AUSA \ninvestigators met with the Chief of the Child Exploitation Section, \nagain, the evidence and legal theories of prosecution. Chief \nstrongly supported the \nindictment and even offered to join the trial team and provide additional support from his Section. \nand the \nto review, yet \nOn Se tember 7 2007, I met with irc .Leflcowitz and Ms. Sanchez, along with Chief \nand AUSAs \nand \n2 You and other counsel for Mr. \nEpstein again presented arguments regarding the sufficiency of the federal interest in the case and \nother legal and factual issues. Your arguments were discussed afterwards and the unanimous \nopinion of all of the attorneys present was in favor of prosecution. \nDuring the September t h meeting, your co-counsel, Mr. Lefkowitz, also offered a plea \nresolution. His offer, in essence, was that your client be subject to home confinement at his Palm \nBeach home, using private security officers who would serve as \"wardens,\" if necessary. Mr. \nLefkowitz expressed the belief that such a sentence would be particularly appropriate because, as \na wealthy white man, your client may be the subject of violence or extortion while in prison. \nFinally, both you and your co-counsel expressed the belief that Mr. Epstein's extensive charitable \ngiving should be considered in our prosecution decision. I summarily rejected these proposals, and \nindicated that the twenty-four month offer presented previously by this Office stood. I should add \nthat there were four other prosecutors present at the meeting, representing a combined experience \nof more than fifty years. Never had any of\n... [truncated, 3106 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01659896/2 or ?id=EFTA01659896&page=2]", "char_count": 3106}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01659896", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "KENNETH STARR, ESQ. \nNOVEMBER 30, 2007 \nPAGE 4 OF 6 \nInstead, Mr. Epstein elected to ne otiate the Non-Prosecution A eement, and on September \n12, 2007, counsel for the United States \nGarcia, and \nand counsel for Mr. \nEpstein (Messrs. Lefcourt Lefkowitz and Goldberger) met with State Attorney Barry Krisher and \nAssistant State Attorney \nto discuss a plea to an Information in the state court that \nwould satisfy the federal interest in the case. As noted on the term sheet of July 31', one of those \nessential terms was a guilty plea to a charge requiring sex offender registration. During that \nmeeting, the issue of sex offender registration was raised, and Mr. Goldberger told the federal \nprosecutors that there was no problem, Mr. Epstein would plead guilty to the charge of solicitation \nof minors for prostitution (Fl. Stat. 796.03), which was one of the statutes listed on the original term \nsheet. Although our Office had wanted Mr. Epstein to plead guilty to three different offenses, we \nagreed to this compromise? Of course, we later learned that, at the time Mr. Goldberger made that \nstatement, he incorrectly believed, based upon a statement from ASA \nthat Fl. Stat. \n796.03 did not require sex offender registration. \nThe parties then began working first on a plea agreement to a federal charge and, when it was \nclear that there was no guarantee the Mr. Epstein would serve his sentence in a minimum security \nprison camp, the discussion turned to a Non-Prosecution Agreement. Both the federal plea \nagreement and the Non-Prosecution Agreement included references to Section 2255 because neither \nthe contemplated federal charges nor the proposed state charges encompassed all of the identified \nvictims. If Mr. Epstein had been prosecuted under the planned indictment, the identified victims \nwould have been eligible for restitution and damages under Section 2255. As explained above, one \nof the United States' interests, which had to be satisfied by the Non-Prosecution Agreeme\n... [truncated, 3632 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01659896/3 or ?id=EFTA01659896&page=3]", "char_count": 3632}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01659896", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "KENNETH STARR, ESQ. \nNOVEMBER 30, 2007 \nPAGE 5 OF 6 \nattorneys agreed with this alternative. \nThe negotiation of the Agreement was lengthy and difficult. Mr. Lefkowitz and AUSA \nwent through several drafts of both a federal Plea Agreement and a Non-Prosecution \nAgreement. Throughout these negotiations, when a member of the defense team was dissatisfied \nwith the Office's position, it was repeatedly appealed through the Office. So several members of \n, currently chief of staff to Assistant Attorney General \nregarding the terms of the Agreement, including the Section 2255 \nprovisions. At the eleventh hour, when your legal team realized that Fl. Stat. 796.03 would require \nMr. Epstein to register as a sex offender, you sought to change the most essential term of the \nagreement — a term that Messrs. Goldberger, Lefkowitz, and Lefcourt had specifically agreed to at \nthe September I 2th meeting with the State Attorney's Office — askin to allow Mr. E stein to lead \nto a charge that would not require registration. When AUSAs \nrejected the suggestion, several members of the defense team appealed directly to me, which also \nfailed. When that failed, according to press reports, apparently Mr. Lefcourt \"leaked\" a letter \nintended for me to the press containing the reasons why he did not believe Mr. Epstein should have \nto register. \nPrior to signing the Non-Prosecution Agreement, Mr. Epstein's defense team included \nyourself, Ms. Sanchez, and Messrs. Dershowitz, Lefcourt, Lefkowitz, Lewis, Black, and Goldberger. \nAt least one other \"criminal law expert\" was involved in plea negotiations, and several associates \nat your firm conducted research on discrete issues. This impressive legal team reviewed the \nAgreement and counseled Mr. Epstein. Based upon that counsel, Mr. Epstein decided that it was \nin his best interests to enter into the Non-Prosecution Agreement, and the Non-Prosecution \nAgreement itself is signed both by Mr. Lefcourt and Ms. Sanchez as well as by Mr. Epstein. \nS\n... [truncated, 3249 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01659896/4 or ?id=EFTA01659896&page=4]", "char_count": 3249}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01659896", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "KENNETH STARR, ESQ. \nNOVEMBER 30, 2007 \nPAGE 6 OF 6 \nAccordingly, please provide us with a definitive statement, signed by your client, of his \nintention to abide by each and every term of the Agreement by close of business on Tuesday, \nDecember 4, 2007. By that time, you must also provide us with the agreement(s) with the State \nAttorney's Office and a date and time certain for the plea and sentencing, which must occur no later \nthan December 14, 2007. If we do not receive these items by that time, we will deem the agreement \nto be rescinded and will proceed with the prosecution. There must be closure in this matter. \nSincerely, \nR. ALEXANDER ACOSTA \nUNITED STATES ATTORNEY \ncc: \nFirst Assistant U.S. Attorney \nEFTA01659901\n", "char_count": 733}]}