{"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_count": 51, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA01657752", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA01657752.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 1 of 51 \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA \nCASE NO.:08-CV-80736-ICAM \nJANE DOE 1 and JANE DOE 2, \nPetitioners, \nvs. \nUNITED STATES OF AMERICA, \nRespondent. \nOPINION AND ORDER \nThis cause is before the Court on various discovery related matters. In response to \nPetitioners' first requests for production, the respondent Government asserted various privileges \nin three privilege logs and submitted nearly 15,000 pages of documents for in camera inspection. \n(DEs 212-1, 216-1, 329-1). Petitioners object to every privilege asserted. (DE 265). \nIntervenor Jeffrey Epstein supports the Government's assertion that certain grand jury \nmaterials should remain secret, and he moves to prevent disclosure of those materials. (DE 263). \nPetitioners filed a response. (DE 271). \nFinally, the Government objects to the relevancy of several of Petitioners' requests for \nproduction. (DE 260). Petitioners responded (DE 266) and filed a supporting supplement (DEs \n267, 268). \nThe Court has conducted its in camera review of materials submitted, has carefully \nconsidered the materials and the parties' submissions, and is fully advised in the premises. \nEFTA01657752\n", "char_count": 1258}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 2 of 51 \nI. Background \nThis is a case against the United States for allegedly violating the Crime Victims' Rights \nAct (CVRA), 18 U.S.C. § 3771, by failing to involve Petitioners (and other similarly situated \nvictims of Intervenor Epstein) in the process that ultimately led to a federal non-prosecution \nagreement between the Government and Epstein. (DE I). The parties and intervenors debate the \ndiscoverability of documents that show exactly what led to the non-prosecution agreement. \nIn March 2011, Petitioners moved \"to allow use of correspondence between the U.S. \nAttorney's Office and counsel for Epstein\" to prove their CVRA case. (DE 51 at I). Petitioners \nargued that the correspondence was relevant as it \"shows that the U.S. Attorney's Office was \naware of its statutory obligation to inform the victims of the non-prosecution agreement,\" and \nthat they should be allowed to use it \"as it sheds important light on the events surrounding the \nnon-prosecution agreement, which are central to the victims' arguments that the U.S. Attorney's \nOffice violated their rights.\" (Id. at 5, 6). The Court granted Petitioners' request and ordered the \nGovernment to \"[p]roduce responsive documents in response to all outstanding requests for \nproduction of documents encompassing any documentary material exchanged by or between the \nfederal government and persons or entities outside the federal government (including without \nlimitation all correspondence generated by or between the federal government and Epstein's \nattorneys)\" (DE 190 at 2). The Court also ordered the Government to produce all responsive \ndocuments \"other than communications generated between the federal government and outside \npersons or entities.\" U. If the Government claimed privilege over any of these documents, the \nCourt ordered the Government to (1) file \"a privilege log clearly identifying each document[] by \nauthor(s), addressee(s)\n... [truncated, 2094 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01657752/1 or ?id=EFTA01657752&page=1]", "char_count": 2094}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 3 of 51 \ndata,\" and (2) to \"submit all responsive documents withheld on claim of privilege to the court for \nin camera inspection.\" U. \nThe Government produced 1,357 pages of documents to Petitioners, filed three privilege \nlogs, and submitted nearly 15,000 pages to the Court for in camera inspection. \nDE 257 at \n2). The Government asserts that the documents submitted for in camera inspection are privileged \nfor reasons such as the privacy rights of non-party victims, grand jury secrecy under Federal Rule \nof Criminal Procedure 6(e),' and the attorney-client, work product, deliberative process, and \ninvestigative privileges. (DEs 212-1; 216-1, 329-1). Moreover, with the Court's leave (DE 257 \nat 4), the Government objects to the relevancy of several of Petitioners' requests for production \n(DE 260). \nII. Discussion \nDistrict courts have \"broad discretion in shaping the scope of discovery under \nFed.R.Civ.P. 26(b).\" Williams v. City of Dothan, 745 F.2d 1406, 1415 (11th Cir. 1984). The \nCourt will first address matters related to whether a privilege protects the submitted documents \nfrom discovery and then turn to whether any otherwise non-privileged documents are relevant to \nPetitioners' CVRA case. Specific rulings as to the submitted documents are found in the Table \nappended to this Opinion and Order. \nA. \nPrivilege Assertions \n1. Challenge to the Sufficiency of Government's Privilege Assertions \nPetitioners raise several general objections to the Government's privilege logs. They \nIn a previous ruling, the Court noted that Plaintiffs formally requested the release of \ngrand jury materials, but the Court reserved \"ruling as to whether the materials in question are \nprotected from disclosure by Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 6(e).\" (DE 257 at 3). \n3 \nEFTA01657754\n", "char_count": 1874}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 4 of 51 \nargue that the Government's logs are inadequate because they do not \"clearly identify\" the \ndocuments as ordered by this Court. (DE 265 at 2; DE 190 at 2). The Court has reviewed the \nGovernment's privilege logs and the documents that they describe, and the Court finds that the \nlogs—describing nearly 15,000 pages of documents— are adequate to facilitate a meaningful in \ncamera inspection and assessment of the asserted privileges. To the extent inadequacies may be \npresent, the Court finds that judicial resources would not be best spent by requiring the \nGovernment to submit a revised, more detailed log. See N.L.R.B. v. Jackson Hosp. Corp., 257 \nF.R.D. 302, 307 (D.D.C. 2009) (court may remedy inadequate privilege log by in \ncamera inspection of described documents or permitting party another chance to submit a more \ndetailed log). \nPetitioners also argue that the Government has failed to provide the factual underpinnings \nnecessary to hold that certain privileges apply, specifically the deliberative process privilege, \ninvestigative privilege, work product privilege, and attorney—client privilege. Discussed in more \ndetail below, the Court finds it unnecessary to consider whether the deliberative process and \ninvestigative privilege apply in this case as other, stronger, privileges are at play, or, as discussed \nfurther below, many of the documents over which the deliberative process and investigative \nprivileges are asserted are irrelevant to this proceeding. Regarding the work product and \nattorney—client privileges, and the Court has considered the materials submitted and the \nGovernment's arguments, and finds that the Government has submitted sufficient evidence to \nevaluate its claims of privilege. (See DE 238-1) (discussing documents prepared by the United \nStates Attorney's Office in anticipation of possible Epstein prosecution); see Stern v. O-Quinn, \n253 F.R.D. 663, 675 (S.D\n... [truncated, 2082 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01657752/3 or ?id=EFTA01657752&page=3]", "char_count": 2082}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 5 of 51 \npleading to decide application of work product privilege). The Court will therefore evaluate each \nclaim of privilege as it relates to the documents submitted. \n2. Grand Jury Secrecy \nThe Government asserts that many of the documents identified in its logs are protected by \nFederal Rule of Criminal Procedure 6(e), which governs the secrecy of grand jury proceedings. \nSee DE 212-1; DE 216-1 at 4, 6). These documents include subpoenas issued and documents \nreceived and prepared during the course of grand jury investigations into whether Epstein \ncommitted indictable federal offenses. (DE 212-1 at 1). Petitioners argue that the Court can (and \nshould) authorize disclosure in this case. (DE 265 at 17). \n\"It has long been a policy of the law that grand jury proceedings be kept secret .... The \nEnglish rule of grand jury secrecy has been incorporated into our federal common law and \nremains an integral part of our criminal justice system.\" United States v. Aisenberg, 358 F.3d \n1327, 1346 (11th Cir. 2004) (internal quotation marks omitted). \"Rule 6(e) of the Federal Rules \nof Criminal Procedure codifies this secrecy principle and prohibits the disclosure of grand jury \nmaterial except in the limited circumstances provided for in Rule 6(e)(3).\" Id. One such \nexception is Rule (6)(e)(3)(E)(i), which permits a court to authorize disclosure \"preliminary to or \nin connection with a judicial proceeding.\" Fed. R. Crim. P. 6(e)(3)(E)(i). Additionally, a court \nhas inherent authority to disclose grand jury materials beyond the literal wording of Rule 6(e)(3) \nin \"exceptional circumstances.\" Aisenberg, 358 F.3d at 1347. \"The district court has \n'substantial discretion' in determining whether grand jury materials should be released.\" Id. at \n1349 (quoting Douglas Oil Co. v. Petrol Stops N.W., 441 U.S. 211, 223 (1979)). \nWhether proceeding under Rule 6(e)(3) or the court's inherent authority, there are\n... [truncated, 2023 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01657752/4 or ?id=EFTA01657752&page=4]", "char_count": 2023}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 6 of 51 \nsettled guidelines for determining when grand jury secrecy may be broken. Id. at 1347. \nSpecifically, the parties seeking disclosure must show: \n(1) \"that the material they seek is needed to avoid a possible \ninjustice in another judicial proceeding\"; \n(2) \"that the need for disclosure is greater than the need for \ncontinued secrecy\"; and \n(3) \"that their request is structured to cover only material so \nneeded.\" \nId. at 1348 (citing Douglas Oil Co.,N.W., 441 U.S. 211, 222 (1979)). These demanding \nstandards apply even after the grand jury has concluded its operations. Id. The burden of \ndemonstrating that the need for disclosure outweighs the need for secrecy rests on the party \nseeking disclosure. Id. \"In order to carry this burden, the party seeking disclosure of grand jury \nmaterial must show a compelling and particularized need for disclosure.\" Id. That is, \"the \nprivate party must show circumstances had created certain difficulties peculiar to this case, which \ncould be alleviated by access to specific grand jury materials, without doing disproportionate \nharm to the salutary purpose of secrecy embodied in the grand jury process.\" Id. at 1348-49 \n(internal quotation marks omitted) (emphasis in original). \nAccordingly, the grand jury proceedings at issue are \"presumptively secret,\" see In re \nSubpoena to Testify, 864 F.2d 1559, 1562 (11th Cir. 1989), and Petitioners have the heavy \nburden of overcoming this presumption.' Petitioners argue that they have met their burden in \ntheir response to Epstein's motion to uphold grand jury secrecy. (DE 271 at 3). \nBecause the burden lies with Petitioners, Petitioners' argument that disclosure is \nappropriate because the Government \"has not attempted to defend its invocation of grand jury \nsecrecy\" is of no moment. (DE 278 at 10). \n6 \nEFTA01657757\n", "char_count": 1905}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 7 of 51 \nRegarding whether (I) grand jury materials are \"needed to avoid a possible injustice\" in \nthis case, Petitioners argue that \"an injustice may occur\" if the materials are not disclosed to \nthem. (DE 217 at 4). They argue that the possibility for injustice exists because this Court has \nalready recognized that aspects of this case \"must be considered in the historical factual context \nof the entire interface between Epstein, the relevant prosecutorial authorities and the federal \noffense victims—including an assessment of the allegation of a deliberate conspiracy between \nEpstein and the federal prosecutors to keep the victims in the dark on the pendency of \nnegotiations between Epstein and the federal authorities.\" (a) (quoting the Court's Order at DE \n189 at 12 n.6). They also argue that injustice may result without the grand jury materials because \nthe \"critical starting point for the victims' case\" is proof that the Government had an \"extremely \nstrong case against Epstein.\" (Id.). \nThe Court concludes that Petitioners have not met their heavy burden of demonstrating a \ncompelling and particularized need for the disclosure of grand jury materials pertaining to the \ninvestigation of Epstein. Materials that the Government presented in secrecy to a grand jury \nrelative to a case against Epstein are not part of the \"interface\" that occurred between Epstein, \nprosecuting authorities, and the victims. As the Court has already explained, the harm in this \ncase did not arise out of the Government's failure to secure a grand jury indictment against \nEpstein. (DE 189 at 10) (\"The victim's CVRA injury is not the government's failure to \nprosecute Epstein federally—an end within the sole control of the government.\"). Rather, the \nharm in this case arose from the Government's alleged failure to confer adequately with \nPetitioners before deciding to abandon a federal case against Epstein. U. The\n... [truncated, 2125 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01657752/6 or ?id=EFTA01657752&page=6]", "char_count": 2125}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 8 of 51 \nfinds that none of the grand jury materials produced has a bearing on the Government's alleged \nfailure to confer with Petitioners before electing to forego a federal prosecution. \nThe Court also concludes that Petitioner's asserted need to prove that the Government \nhad an \"extremely strong case against Epstein\" does not justify the disclosure of secret grand jury \nmaterials. Petitioners seek to use the grand jury materials as the means to an improper end—a \njudicial determination that the Government made an inexplicably poor decision when it decided \nnot to prosecute Epstein. \n\"[T]he Government retains `broad discretion' as to whom to prosecute.\" Wayte v. United \nStates 470 U.S. 598, 607 (1985). The CVRA incorporates this principle, providing that \nInJothing in this chapter shall be construed to impair the prosecutorial discretion\" of federal \nprosecutors. 18 U.S.C. § 3771(d)(6). Courts tread lightly where prosecutorial discretion is \nconcerned because \"the decision to prosecute is particularly ill-suited to judicial review.\" Wayte,\n470 U.S. at 607; see also 35 Geo. L.J. Ann. Rev. Crim. Proc. 203, 203 n.648 (2006). \"Such \nfactors as the strength of the case, the prosecution's general deterrence value, the Government's \nenforcement priorities, and the case's relationship to the Government's overall enforcement plan \nare not readily susceptible to the kind of analysis the courts are competent to undertake.\" Wayte,\n470 U.S. at 607 (emphasis added); see also Town of Newton v. Rumery, 480 U.S. 386, 396 \n(1987) (courts normally must defer to prosecutorial decisions about whom to prosecute because, \n\"[i]n addition to assessing the strength and importance of a case, prosecutors also must consider \nother tangible and intangible factors, such as government enforcement priorities.\") (emphasis \nadded). \nPetitioners asserted strategy of demonstrating that the Government had an improper \n8 \nEFTA\n... [truncated, 2009 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01657752/7 or ?id=EFTA01657752&page=7]", "char_count": 2009}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 9 of 51 \nmotive to hide its \"extremely strong\" case asks the Court to decide (or assume) that the \nGovernment did in fact have an \"extremely strong\" case against Epstein. As Petitioners point \nout, the Government has not admitted that it believed it had a \"strong case\" for prosecution. (DE \n266 at 8).3 In light of this refusal to admit the strength of the case, Petitioners seek grand jury \nmaterials to present to the Court the case for prosecuting Epstein. (a at 9). Basically, \nPetitioners ask the Court to interject itself in place of the Government and adjudicate whether the \nGovernment erred, and thus had a motive for hiding its error, when it decided not to prosecute \nEpstein. As the Supreme Court has articulated, \"courts are [not] competent to undertake\" the \nkind of analysis necessary to assess the \"strength of the case\" for or against any particular \nprosecution. Wane, 470 U.S. at 607; see also United States v. Armstrong, 517 U.S. 456, 465 \n(1996) (Judicial deference to prosecutors' decisions \"rests in part on an assessment of the relative \ncompetence of prosecutors and courts.\"). Nor is the Court competent to undertake an analysis of \nhow strong the Government perceived its case against Epstein at the time it decided not to \nprosecute. Stated plainly, whether the Government had a \"strong\" case against Epstein was for \nthe Government to decide in its sole discretion; the Court will not foray into matters related to \nassessing the strength of the Government's case against Epstein. \nIn response to Petitioners Request for Admission regarding whether the Government \nhad a case for \"federal prosecution against Epstein for many federal sex offenses,\" (DE 266 at 8), \nthe Government responded: \nThe government admits that the FBI and the U.S. Attorney's Office for the \nSouthern District of Florida (\"USAO\") conducted an investigation into Jeffrey \nEpstein (\"Epstein\") and developed evidence and in\n... [truncated, 2219 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01657752/8 or ?id=EFTA01657752&page=8]", "char_count": 2219}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 10 of 51 \nAccordingly, because the Court will not—and cannot—endeavor to assess the strength of \nthe Government's case against Epstein at the time it decided to enter into the non-prosecution \nagreement, the Court concludes that Petitioners have not shown that they will suffer an injustice \nin this case if they are denied access to materials that the Government presented to grand juries \nduring their investigation into whether Epstein committed federal crimes. Likewise, Petitioners \nhave not shown that their need for these materials is compelling or particularized to their asserted \ninterests under the CVRA. Therefore, the Court will deny Petitioners access to the materials over \nwhich grand jury secrecy applies under Fed. R. Crim. P. 6(e). \n3. Work Product Doctrine \nThe Government asserts that many of the documents submitted are protected by the \nattorney work-product privilege. (DE 212-1 at 1-21; DE 216-1 at 1-14). These documents \ninclude draft correspondences and indictments, as well as attorney research and handwritten \nnotes. (See, e.g., DE 212-1 at 2, 17). Petitioners argue that the work-product privilege is \nunavailable for a number of reasons. (DE 265 at 6, 8, 14-16). \nThe work-product doctrine traces its roots to the Supreme Court's recognition that \"it is \nessential that a lawyer work with a certain degree of privacy, free from unnecessary intrusion by \nopposing parties and their counsel.\" Hickman v. Taylor, 329 U.S. 495, 510 (1947). The \nprivilege is codified at Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(b)(3): \nOrdinarily, a party may not discover documents and tangible things \nthat are prepared in anticipation of litigation or for trial by or for \nanother party or its representative (including the other party's \nattorney, consultant, surety, indemnitor, insurer, or agent). But, \nsubject to Rule 26(b)(4), those materials may be discovered if: \n(i) they are otherwise discoverable under Ru\n... [truncated, 2035 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01657752/9 or ?id=EFTA01657752&page=9]", "char_count": 2035}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 11 of 51 \n(ii) the party shows that it has substantial need for the materials to \nprepare its case and cannot, without undue hardship, obtain their \nsubstantial equivalent by other means. \nFed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(3)(A). Although fact-based work product may be disclosed on a showing \nof \"substantial need,\" the court must avoid \"disclosure of the mental impressions, conclusions, \nopinions, or legal theories of a party's attorney or other representative concerning the litigation.\" \nId. 26(b)(3)(B). Such \"opinion work product enjoys a nearly absolute immunity and can be \ndiscovered only in very rare and extraordinary circumstances.\" Cox v. Adm'r U.S. Steel & \nCarnegie, 17 F.3d 1386, 1422 (11th Cir. 1994). In the context of government attorneys, the \n\"work-product privilege applies to ... discussions between prosecutors and investigating agents, \nboth state and federal.\" United States v. Zingsheim, 384 F.3d 867, 872 (7th Cir. 2004) (citing \nFTC v. Grolier Inc., 462 U.S. 19 (1983)). \nThe work-product privilege extends only to documents that an attorney prepares \"in \nanticipation of litigation.\" Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(a)(3)(A). Petitioners argue that the work-product \nprivilege does not apply to the submitted documents because they were not prepared \"in \nanticipation of [the instant] CVRA litigation.\" (DE 265 at 7). Retreating somewhat from this \ninitial assertion, Petitioners argue that \"[m]any of the documents at issue here were not prepared \nin anticipation of litigation, and certainly not in anticipation of the litigation about the Crime \nVictims' Rights Act.\" (a.). \nAlthough \"[s]ome older cases took the position that the work-product immunity applied \nonly to documents prepared in direct relation to the case at bar,\" 8 Wright, Miller & Marcus, Fed. \nPrac. & Fed. P. § 2024, p. 518 (3d ed. 2010), more recent cases \"have generally found that \ndocuments produced in anticipation of litigating one case rem\n... [truncated, 2055 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01657752/10 or ?id=EFTA01657752&page=10]", "char_count": 2055}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 12 of 51 \nif they were created by or for a party to the subsequent litigation,\" Underwriters Ins. Co. v. \nAtlanta Gas Light Co., 248 F.R.D. 663,668 (N.D. Ga. 2008). These cases rely on the Supreme \nCourt's dicta in Federal Trade Communication v. Grolier, Inc., that \"the literal language of [Rule \n26(b)(3)] protects materials prepared for ars \nlitigation or trial as long as they were prepared by or \nfor a party to the subsequent litigation.\" 462 U.S. 19,25 (1983) (emphasis in original)• see also 8 \nWright, Miller & Marcus, Fed. Prac. & Fed. P. § 2024, p. 519 n.47 (3d ed. 2010) (collecting \ncases). Similarly, the work-product doctrine applies regardless of whether litigation actually \nensued, so long as it can be fairly said that the document was prepared or obtained because of the \nprospect of litigation. See Kent Corp. v. N.L.R.B., 530 F.2d 612,623 (5th Cir. 1976) (holding \nthat agency documents produced when deciding \"to prosecute or not to prosecute\" were protected \nwork product, regardless of \"whether litigation actually ensured\"). \nAfter its in camera review, the Court finds that the majority of work-product documents \nidentified by the Government were prepared or obtained by the Government because of the \nreasonable prospect of litigating a criminal case against Epstein. (DE 212-1 at 1-21; DE 216-1 at \n1-12; DE 329-1 at 1-18).' This CVRA litigation and the underlying criminal investigation are \nintegrally related, and the work-product doctrine protects from discovery materials prepared in \nanticipation of either in the instant litigation. \n' The Government asserts that the work-product doctrine applies to documents prepared \nby attorneys in the Department of Justice's Office of Professional Responsibility (OPR) in \nresponse to Petitioners' counsel's request for an investigation into the Government's handling of \nthe Epstein case. (DE 216-1 at 12-14). Although these documents were prepare\n... [truncated, 2444 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01657752/11 or ?id=EFTA01657752&page=11]", "char_count": 2444}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 13 of 51 \nPetitioners argue that the work-product doctrine \"does not apply\" in this case for two \nadditional reasons. First, they argue that the doctrine does not apply in a case brought by crime \nvictims against the federal prosecutors who were bound to protect their rights under the CVRA. \n(DE 265 at 13). Second, they argue that the doctrine does not apply because the conduct of those \nprosecutors is a \"central issue\" in this case. a at 15). The Courts finds these arguments \nunavailing. \nFirst, Petitioners argue that the \"work product doctrine does not apply to claims advanced \nby crime victims that federal prosecutors have violated their public responsibilities under the \nCrime Victims' Rights Act.\" (Id. at 14). Because the CVRA compels prosecutors to make their \n\"best efforts\" to notify victims of their rights, Petitioners argue that the Government cannot \nwithhold documents that \"might allow them to protect those very rights.\" (Id. at 15). By way of \nillustration, Petitioners offer the case of In re Grand Jury Subpoena Duces Tecum, where the \nEighth Circuit broadly stated that \"the general duty of public service calls upon government \nemployees and agencies to favor disclosure over concealment.\" 112 F.3d 910, 920 (8th Cir. \n1997). \nA closer inspection of In re Grand Jury Subpoena reveals that it does not stand for the \ncategorical rule that the work product doctrine is inapplicable in cases against public prosecutors. \nThe statement on which Petitioners rely was made in the context of determining whether to \nrecognize a previously undefined privilege: \"whether an entity of the federal government may use \nthe attorney-client privilege to avoid complying with a subpoena by a federal grand jury.\" Id. at \n915 (emphasis added); see also id. at 921 (\"We believe the strong public interest in honest \ngovernment and in exposing wrongdoing by public officials would be ill-served by recognition of \n... [truncated, 2018 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01657752/12 or ?id=EFTA01657752&page=12]", "char_count": 2018}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 14 of 51 \na governmental attorney-client privilege applicable in criminal proceedings inquiring into the \nactions of public officials.\"). The Eighth Circuit did not purport to espouse a broad-ranging rule \nthat defeated existing, well-defined privileges such as the work product doctrine. This is \nimportant, as the Supreme Court has recognized that the \"work-product doctrine is distinct from \nand broader than the attorney-client privilege.\" United States v. Nobles, 422 U.S. 225, 238 \n(1975) (citing Hickman 329 U.S. at 508). In fact, the Eighth Circuit went on to consider the \napplication of the work product doctrine and concluded that it did not apply because the materials \nin question were not prepared in \"anticipation of litigation.\" 112 F.3d at 924-25. It did not find \nthe work product doctrine wholly inapplicable based on a goal of public disclosure. \nIn light of the well-established bounds of the work product doctrine—which grants public \nprosecutors \"near absolute immunity\" over their mental impressions in subsequent civil \nlitigation—the Court finds that the CVRA's mandate that prosecutors make their \"best efforts\" to \naccord crime victims their rights does not create a \"very rare and extraordinary circumstance\" in \nwhich discovery of protected work product would be allowed. See Cox, 17 F.3d at 1422. \nSecond, Petitioners argue that the work product doctrine does not apply because the \nconduct of the Government's attorneys is a \"central issue\" in this case. (K at 15). Some lower \ncourts have held that disclosure of opinion work product is \"justified principally where the \nmaterial is directly at issue, particularly if the lawyer or law firm is a party to the litigation.\" 8 \nWright, Miller & Marcus, Fed. Prac. & Fed. P. § 2026, p. 567 & n.I9 (3d ed. 2010) (collecting \ncases). To satisfy this showing, however, the party seeking disclosure of opinion work product \nmust make \"a far stronger \n... [truncated, 2181 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01657752/13 or ?id=EFTA01657752&page=13]", "char_count": 2181}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 15 of 51 \n449 U.S. 383, 402 (1981)); see also In re Doe, 662 F.2d 1073, 1080 (4th Cir. 1981) (even under \ncrime-fraud exception to work product doctrine, party \"must show a greater need for the opinion \nwork product material than was necessary in order to obtain the fact work product material\"). \nThe Court finds that Petitioners have not made the strong showing of necessity and \nunavailability required to disclose the mental impressions of counsel that might be at issue in this \ncase. (aes DE 265 at 16). Discovery of opinion work product is most often granted in bad-faith \nsettlement cases, where \"mental impressions [of the underlying counsel] are the pivotal issue in \nthe current litigation.\" Holmgren v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., 976 F.2d 573, 577 (9th Cir. \n1992). Other than by analogizing to bad-faith actions, Petitioners have not demonstrated how \ndelving in to the \"mental impressions\" of Government attorneys is pivotal to proving their \nallegations that the Government failed to accord them their rights under the CVRA. (See DE 265 \nat 15). Insofar as they seek to demonstrate that the attorneys' mental impressions should have led \nthem to conclude that prosecution was the best course, such inquiry cannot be allowed for \nreasons discussed above. Elsewhere, Petitioners assert that they can prove their case by \ndemonstrating a \"conspiracy between the Government and defense counsel to deliberately \nconceal vital information from the victims.\" (DE 266 at 7). Because of the availability of this \nmethod of proof, Petitioners lack a compelling need to gain access to internal Government work \nproduct evidencing its internal mental impressions regarding the Epstein matter. \nFinally, Petitioners argue that any work-product protection available in this case should \nbe negated because the Government's communications facilitated \"misconduct\" by depriving the \nvictims of their rights under the CVRA\n... [truncated, 2172 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01657752/14 or ?id=EFTA01657752&page=14]", "char_count": 2172}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 16 of 51 \nopinion work product is discoverable.\" Cox, 17 F.3d at 1422. The Eleventh Circuit has not \nindicated whether this \"rare and extraordinary\" exception extends to instances of \"misconduct\" \nin the form of violating a civil rights statute, such as the CVRA. Even so, the Court finds that \nsuch alleged \"misconduct\" does not rise to the level of conduct that triggers an exception to the \nwork product doctrine. See, e.g. In re Sealed Case 754 F.2d 395, 401 (D.C. Cir. 1985) \n(exception to attorney-client privilege applied where alleged wrongdoing included \"perjured \ntestimony, document destruction, and similar misconduct\"); United States v. Myers, 593 F.3d \n338, 347 n.I4 (4th Cir. 2010) (noting that exception applied where litigant \"defrauded\" public \ndefender by submitting false invoices). Petitioners' allegation that the Government failed to \naccord them their full CVRA rights—the allegation at the heart of this case—does not rise to the \nlevel of conduct sufficiently serious enough to displace the work product privilege. \nMoreover, Petitioners fail to set forth prima facie evidence that the Government in fact \ncommitted \"misconduct\" in this case. To invoke the crime-fraud exception, the party seeking \ndisclosure must (1) make a prima facie showing that the material was produced in the \ncommission of criminal or fraudulent conduct and (2) that it was produced \"in furtherance of the \ncriminal or fraudulent activity or was closely related to it.\" Cox, 17 F.3d at 1416; see also id. at \n1422 (noting that same \"two-part test\" applies in context of both attorney client privilege and \nwork product doctrine). Petitioners argue that the fact that the OPR \"collected information about \npossible improper behavior\" establishes a prima facie case of Government misconduct. (DE 265 \nat 7). An investigation into wrongdoing does not presuppose that wrongdoing took place. After \nits in camera review, the Cou\n... [truncated, 2170 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01657752/15 or ?id=EFTA01657752&page=15]", "char_count": 2170}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 17 of 51 \nMaterials constituting the opinion work product of the Government's attorneys shall \ntherefore be withheld from Petitioners. Certain documents that the Court considers fact-based \nwork product may be produced subject to relevancy considerations discussed below. \nB. \nRelevancy of Requests for Production \nIn addition to asserting privileges, the Government responds to Petitioners' first request \nfor production by arguing that many of the materials requested are not relevant to the instant \nCVRA litigation. (DE 260). \nRule 26 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure defines the general scope of discovery as \nfollows: \nParties may obtain discovery regarding any nonprivileged matter \nthat is relevant to any party's claim or defense—including the \nexistence, description, nature, custody, condition, and location of \nany documents or other tangible things and the identity and \nlocation of persons who know of any discoverable matter. . . . \nRelevant information need not be admissible at the trial if the \ndiscovery appears reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of \nadmissible evidence. \nFed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(1). \"Discovery should ordinarily be allowed unless it is clear that the \ninformation sought has no possible bearing on the claims and defenses of the parties or otherwise \non the subject matter of the action.\" Milinazzo v. State Farm Ins. Co., 247 F.R.D. 691, 695-96 \n(S.D. Fla. 2007) (citing Dunkin' Donuts, Inc. v. Mary's Donuts, Inc., No. 01-0392, 2001 WL \n34079319, at *2 (S.D. Fla. Nov. 1, 2001)). \n1. Request No. 1—the FBI File on the Epstein Matter and Indictment Material \nIn their first request for production, Petitioners seek the file generated by the FBI in the \nEpstein matter, including all documents \"collected as part of its case against and/or investigation \n17 \nEFTA01657768\n", "char_count": 1901}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 18 of 51 \nof Epstein.\" (DE 260 at 2). Petitioners also request that the Government produce all prosecution \nmemoranda and draft indictments prepared in the case. (LI.). The Government argues that such \nmaterials regarding its decision to prosecute Epstein are irrelevant to the issue of whether they \ndenied Petitioners their rights under the CVRA. (j ). Petitioners disagree. They argue that \n\"materials going to the strength of the Government's case against Epstein\" are a \"vital part\" of \ntheir case against the Government. (DE at 266 at 8). \"Those materials would directly \ndemonstrate that the Government had an extremely strong case against Epstein, giving the \nGovernment a motive for needing to keep the victims in the dark about the plea deal.\" U. The \nCourt concludes that discovery should not extend to these materials. \nFirst, the Court finds that all prosecution memoranda, research into indictable offenses, \nand draft indictments are protected opinion work product. These documents were created by the \nGovernment in anticipation of a possible prosecution of Epstein and evince the Government's \ninternal mental impressions, legal theories, and strategy concerning the issues presented by a \npossible prosecution. As discussed above, Petitioners have not demonstrated \"rare and \nextraordinary circumstances\" justifying an exception to this well-established protection. \nSecond, the Court finds that the information in the FBI's file regarding its investigation \ninto Epstein has no possible bearing on the CVRA claim that is the subject matter of this action. \nPetitioners assert that the relevancy of this material is to \"directly demonstrate that the \nGovernment had an extremely strong case against Epstein.\" (DE 266 at 8). As discussed above, \nthis Court is ill-equipped to decide that the Government did in fact have a \"strong case\" for \nprosecution and made a hard-to-explain decision to forego a federal\n... [truncated, 2144 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01657752/17 or ?id=EFTA01657752&page=17]", "char_count": 2144}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 19 of 51 \nrights under the CVRA, which does not turn on its decision whether to initiate a federal \nprosecution. See 18 U.S.C. § 3771(d)(6). Materials going to the \"strength\" of the Government's \ncase for prosecution—and whether the Government had a motive to hide an embarrassing \nmisstep in failing to prosecute—have no relevance to that inquiry. \n2. Request No. 10—Materials Proving that the FBI was Mislead about Likelihood \nof Prosecution \nRequest number 10 requests \"[a]ll documents, correspondence, and other information \nrelating to discussions between the U.S. Attorney's Office and the FBI concerning the status of \nthe investigation and the plea discussions with Epstein, as well as what kind of charges would \nappropriately be filed against Epstein,\" and \"[All documents, correspondence, and other \ninformation relating to the U.S. Attorney's Office's representations to the FBI and any other state \nor local law enforcement agency about how this case was being handled.\" (DE 274 at 5). The \nGovernment argues that communications it had with the FBI are irrelevant because the \"decision \non whether to prosecute belongs to the United States Attorney.\" (DE 260 at 3). Petitioners argue \nthat these communications between the United States Attorney's Office and the FBI lie at the \n\"heart of this case\" because they will prove that the Government mislead the FBI about the \nprogress of the Epstein case, and the FBI in turn mislead the victims. (DE 266 at 9). The Court \nconcludes that discovery should not extend to these materials. \nFirst, the vast majority of documents responsive to this request—communications \nbetween the U.S. Attorney's Office and the FBI—are protected from disclosure under either \nprinciples of grand jury secrecy, the opinion work product doctrine, or both. \nTable). \nSecond, the only portion of FBI materials which the Court has not found to be protected \n19 \nEFTA01657770\n", "char_count": 1986}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 20 of 51 \nby either grand jury secrecy or work product protection—the file folder labeled \"(Victims) \nAdditional 302's,\" P-012624-012653 (DE 212-1 at 21)—is not responsive to the instant request \nas it does not contain communications from the United States Attorney's Office to the FBI, \nwhich was then in a position to relay communications to the victims. Rather, these materials \ncontain fact-based summaries of statements provided by victims to interviewing FBI agents. \nThey are not relevant to this proceeding. \n3. Request No. 16—Materials Proving that Prosecutors had Improper Relationships \nwith Persons Close to Epstein \nRequest number 16 seeks materials demonstrating that persons inside the United States \nAttorney's Office had improper relationships with persons close to Epstein. (DE 260 at 3). \nPetitioners argue that these documents \"shown that a prosecutor working inside the U.S. \nAttorney's Office when the deal was being arranged left the office shortly thereafter and began \nrepresenting persons close to Epstein (such as his pilots).\" (DE 266 at 11). They argue that such \nmaterials are relevant to their CVRA case because \"if one of the prosecutors in the Office was \nnot working for the best interests of the United States, but rather for those of Epstein, that would \nbe clear evidence of motive to intentionally keep the victims in the dark.\" a at 11). The Court \nconcludes that production of such documents should not issue. \nAfter its in camera review, the Court finds that the documents discussing the issue of \nwhether an improper relationship existed between a former prosecutor and Epstein's co-\nconspirators are not relevant to this proceeding. The issue of whether a prosecutor violated \nethical canons by representing persons with close ties to Epstein after his retirement from the \nUnited States Attorney's Office does not bear on the issue of whether the Government violated \n20 \nEFTA01657\n... [truncated, 2004 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01657752/19 or ?id=EFTA01657752&page=19]", "char_count": 2004}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 21 of 51 \nPetitioners' CVRA rights during its negotiations with Epstein. The only impropriety to which \nPetitioners point occurred after the prosecutor's departure from the Government. The \nOPR—which opened an inquiry into the matter at Petitioners' counsel's request—closed their \ninquiry into the matter by noting that the OPR has jurisdiction to investigate allegations of \nmisconduct involving only current Department of Justice attorneys. (See P-013937.5 see also P-\n0013946). The OPR did not investigate the matter further, and it issued no factual \ndeterminations on whether a conflict existed before the prosecutor's departure. Any OPR \ncorrespondence regarding this inquiry that is not otherwise privileged is irrelevant to this CVRA \nlitigation. (See Table at P-013944, P-013945). \nIn the same vein, correspondence between the United States Attorney's Office and the \nOPR regarding self-reporting of conflicts alleged by Epstein's defense counsel are irrelevant to \nthis proceeding.' (DE 212-1 at 21-22); see Table at P-013227-013247). \n4. Request No. 18—Documents Concerning Recusal of the United States Attorney's \nOffice for the Southern District of Florida \nRequest number 18 seeks information about why the United States Attorney's Office for \nthe Southern District of Florida was \"'conflicted out' of handing various issues related to the \nEpstein case.\" (DE 266 at 11). Specifically, it requests \"all documents, correspondence, and \nother information regarding the potential conflicts of interest that the Justice Department \ndiscussed or determined existed for the USAO SDFL, as well as any referral that was made to \nThis is a draft letter addressed to Petitioners' counsel from an OPR attorney. The Court \nassumes Plaintiff's counsel received the final version of this letter explaining the OPR's reasons \nfor closing its investigation. \nIronically, Epstein's counsel raised conflict-of-interest concerns \n... [truncated, 2121 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01657752/20 or ?id=EFTA01657752&page=20]", "char_count": 2121}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 22 of 51 \nMain Justice or to any other District, including any documents that were transmitted to any other \nDistrict regarding the conflict and regarding what was to be investigated.\" (DE 260 at 4). \nPetitioners argue that such materials are relevant because they \"show why the victims did not \nreceive proper notifications about the non-prosecution agreement that the [United States \nAttorney's Office for the Southern District of Florida] negotiated with Epstein.\" (DE 266 at 11). \nThe Court concludes that the materials are not relevant in that regard. \nFirst, the Court finds that the responsive documents are shielded by governmental \nattorney-client privilege. The responsive documents are internal Department of Justice \ncorrespondences between attorneys for the United States Attorney's Office for the Southern \nDistrict of Florida and the Executive Office of United States Attorneys. (DE 212-1 at 22-23); \n(see Table at P-013248-13278). One of the Executive Office's functions is to \"[p]rovide general \nlegal interpretations, opinions, and advice to United States Attorneys in areas of recusals.\" \nOffices of the United States Attorneys, United States Department of Justice, \nhttp://www.justice.gov/usaoThousa/mission-and-functions (last visited June 19, 2015). The \ninternal documents that Petitioners seek relate to the provision of legal advice by the Executive \nOffice to the United States Attorney's Office for the Southern District of Florida regarding how \nto proceed in the Epstein matter given the initiation of CVRA litigation by Petitioners. These \ncommunications are solely between attorneys within the United States Department of Justice. \nThe communications do not constitute the commission of crime, fraud, or misconduct, but rather \nsimply advise how to proceed given that allegations of misconduct have been made, i.e., \nallegations that the Government violated the victims' CVRA rights. \nMoreover,\n... [truncated, 2098 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01657752/21 or ?id=EFTA01657752&page=21]", "char_count": 2098}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 23 of 51 \nconcerning whether the Government violated Petitioners' CVRA rights several years before. \nPetitioners speculate that the reason that the Southern District recused \"may have to do with the \nOffice's treatment of the victims.\" (DE 266 at 12). The Court has reviewed the recussal \nmaterials, and they do not indicate that the Office had to step away from the Epstein matter \nbecause of its handling of victims' notifications, but rather because of the perceived conflict that \nwould exist if the Office continued to investigate Epstein after the institution of CVRA litigation \nby Petitioners. The recusal materials have no relevancy to anything that occurred prior to the \ninstitution of the instant litigation by Petitioners. \n5. Request No. 19—Materials Related to Defense's Assault on Prosecution \nIn request number 19, Petitioners seek all documents supporting, or contradicting, a \nstatement made by a United States Attorney to the media that Epstein launched \"a yearlong \nassault on the prosecution and the prosecutors.\" (DE 260 at 4). After its in camera review, the \nCourt has not identified any documents that are responsive to this request that are not otherwise \nprotected opinion work product. No production under this request is necessary. \n6. Request No. 25—Initial Disclosures under FRCP 26(a)(1) \nFinally, Petitioners request that the Government comply with its obligation to serve initial \ndisclosures under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(a)(1). Although Petitioners have already \nserved their Rule 26(a)(1) disclosures (DE 266 at 13), and although this Court has repeatedly \nheld that the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure \"govern the general course of this proceeding,\" the \nGovernment maintains that the rule governing initial disclosures in civil litigation does not apply \nto it in this case. (DE 274 at 8). The Court disagrees. The Government shall serve its Rule \n26(a)(1) disclosures on P\n... [truncated, 2071 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01657752/22 or ?id=EFTA01657752&page=22]", "char_count": 2071}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 24 of 51 \nC. \nOther Considerations \nBefore concluding, the Court finds it necessary to address certain aspects of the \nGovernment's privilege logs. \nAs mentioned, the Court previously ordered the Government to provide Petitioners all \n\"documentary material exchanged by or between the federal government and persons or entities \noutside the federal government.\" (DE 190 at 2). Petitioners state that they \"have now obtained \nthe full text of correspondence between the defense attorneys and the prosecutors.\" (DE 298 at \n6). The documents produced for in camera review contain correspondence between the \nGovernment and counsel for both Epstein and Petitioners. Some of the documents were \ninadvertently marked as privileged; some of the documents bear handwritten notes of \nGovernment attorneys, and some are part of communication chains made up of both internal and \nexternal communications. The Table at the end of this order indicates instances where such \ncommunications appear. The Court requests that the Government certify within 14 days that \nPetitioners have been provided with all external communications. \nAdditionally, the Court has identified several documents that are asserted \"work product,\" \nbut which are nothing more than factual complications of information regarding victim \nidentification. The Court finds that Petitioners have a compelling need to know which \nindividuals the Government considered to be victims or potential victims at the time it negotiated \nthe non-prosecution agreement. As indicated in the Table, the Government should confer with \nPetitioners regarding the names of the individuals identified in these documents. If Petitioners \nhave not been previously provided with these names, then Petitioners should have production of \nthe indicated documents. The parties should stipulate to an appropriate protective order to \n24 \nEFTA01657775\n", "char_count": 1956}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 25 of 51 \nprotect the victims' identity. \nHI. Conclusion \nAccordingly, it is hereby ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that the Government shall \nproduce documents consistent with the following Table. It is further ORDERED AND \nADJUDGED that Intervenor Epstein's Motion for the Court to Protect From Disclosure Grand \nJury Materials (DE 263) is GRANTED, and Petitioners' Motion to Seal (DE 267) is DENIED in \nlight of this Court's Order at DE 326; DE 268 is hereby UNSEALED. \nDONE AND ORDERED in chambers at West Palm Beach, Palm Beach County, \nFlorida, this 6ih day July, 2015. \nKENNETH A. MARRA \nUnited State District Judge \n25 \nEFTA01657776\n", "char_count": 705}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 26 of 51 \nTABLE \nDetail of Privilege and Relevancy Holdings \nBates Range \nRuling on Privilege or Relevancy \nComment (as necessary) \n1:000001-000039' \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:000040-000549 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:000550-000621 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:000622-000693 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:000694.000781 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:000782-000803 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:000804-000854 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:000855-000937 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:000938-000947 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:000948-000982 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:000983-001007 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:001008-001056 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:001057-001959 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:001960-002089 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:002090-002169 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:002170-002246 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:002247-002265 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:002266-002386 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:002387-002769 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \nThe first digit indicates the box number, with an \"S\" indicating materials identified in \nthe supplemental privilege logs (DEs 216-1, 329-1). The numbers following the colon are page \nranges. \n26 \nEFTA01657777\n", "char_count": 1914}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 27 of 51 \n1:002770-003211 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:003212-003545 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:003546-003552 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:003553-003555 \nB \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:003556-003562 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:003563-003629 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:003630-003633 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:003634-003646 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:003647-003651 \nProduce victim identities. \nDocument bears no indication \nthat it was directly related to \ngrand jury presentation, and it \ndoes not exhibit the mental \nimpressions of counsel but \nrather the cumulation of facts. \nPetitioners should be provided \nwith the victim identities under \nan appropriate protective order. \n1:003664-003678 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:003679-003680 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:003681-003687 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:003688-003693 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:003694-003711 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:003712 \nProduce victim identity. \nContains nothing other than the \nwritten name of one victim. \nThe Court finds that no \nprivilege applies, and \nPetitioners should be made \naware that this victim was \nknown to the Government. \n27 \nEFTA01657778\n", "char_count": 1794}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 28 of 51 \n1:003713-003746 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:003747-003751 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:003752-004295 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:004296-004350 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy; also \ncontains no materials relevant or likely to lead to \ndiscovery of materials relevant to the instant CVRA \nlitigation. \n1:004351-004381 \nProtected from discovery by work product privilege. \n1:004382-004478 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:004479-004551 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:004552-004555 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n1:004556-004560 \nProduction not necessary; not relevant or likely to lead \nto the discovery of materials relevant to the instant \nCVRA litigation. \nContains factual information \nregarding the employment and \nwage history of Epstein's \nemployees, obtained during the \ninvestigation into Epstein and \nhis associates. No bearing on \nvictim notification or rights. \n1:004561-004565 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:004566-004716 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:004717-004722 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:004723-004725 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:004726-004819 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:004820-004959 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:004960-005059 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy; also not \nrelevant or likely to lead to the discovery of materials \nrelevant to the instant CVRA litigation. \nContains factual information \nregarding the call history of \nEpstein (and associates) to \nvictims, obtained during \ninvestigation into Epstein and \nassociates. Contains no \ninformation bear\n... [truncated, 2069 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01657752/27 or ?id=EFTA01657752&page=27]", "char_count": 2069}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 29 of 51 \n1:005060-005081 \nPartially protected from discovery by opinion work \nproduct privilege. \nAttorney handwritten notes are \nprotected from discovery; the \nunderlying correspondence is \nnot and should be produced. \nThe Government must certify \nthat Petitioners have been \nprovided the correspondence. \n1:005082-005083 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:005108-005193 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:005194-005300 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:005301-005331 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:005332-005341 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:005342-005387 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:005388-005442 \nExcept P-005420, protected from discovery by grand \njury secrecy and opinion work product privilege. \nThe victims list at P-005420 \nbears no indication that it was \nproduced to a grand jury and \nbears no attorney mental \nimpressions. Petitioners should \nbe provided with the victim \nidentities under an appropriate \nprotective order. \n1:005443-005496 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:005497-005556 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n1:005557-005576 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:005578-005583 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n1:005584-005606 \nExcept P-005590-005595 and P405596, protected \nfrom discovery by grand jury secrecy and opinion work \nproduct privilege. \nP-005590-005595 and \nP-005596 are correspondence \ndocuments sent to victim's \ncounsel. No privilege applies. \nThe Government must certify \nthat Petitioners have been \nprovided the correspondence. \n2:005607-005914 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n29 \nEFTA01657780\n", "char_count": 1928}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 30 of 51 \n2:005915-005977 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:005978-006050 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:006051-006065 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:006066-006220 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:006221-006222 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:006223-006522 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:006523-006802 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n2:006803-006860 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:006861-007785 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:007786-008120 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:008121-008139 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n2:008140-008298 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:008364-008382 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:08383-008516 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:008536-008542 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:008543-008549 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:008550-008615 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:008616-008686 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:008687-008776 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n30 \nEFTA01657781\n", "char_count": 1898}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 31 of 51 \n2:008777-008808 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:008809-008847 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:008848.008862 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:008863-008890 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:009104-009111 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:009126-008134 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:009135-009141 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:009141 A-00914 \n1C \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:009142-009152 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:009153-009156 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:009157-009208 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:009209-009213 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:009214-009271 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:009272-009354 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:009355-009403 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:009404-009536 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:009537-009574 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:009575-009603 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:009604-009711 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n31 \nEFTA01657782\n", "char_count": 1884}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 32 of 51 \n2:009820-009965 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:009966-010096 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:010097-010276 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:010277-010394 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:010395-010488 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:010489-010509 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:010510-010525 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:010526-010641 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nThe correspondence between \nthe Government and Epstein's \ncounsel is not privileged and \nshould be produced. The \nGovernment must certify that it \nhas been produced. \n2:010642-010650 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:010651-010659 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:010660-010757 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n2:010758-010793 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:010794-010829 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:010830-010853 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:010854-010876 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:010877-010920 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:010921-011049 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n21 \nEFTA01657783\n", "char_count": 1681}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 33 of 51 \n2:011050-011212 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:011213-011237 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:011238-011319 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:011320-011361 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:011362-011374 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:011375-011456 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n2:011457-011626 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n3:011627-011662 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n3:011663-012361 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n3:011699-011777 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n3:011778-011788 \nProduce victim identities. \nDocument does not exhibit the \nmental impressions of counsel \nbut rather the cumulation of \nfacts. Petitioners should be \nprovided with the victim \nidentities under an appropriate \nprotective order. \n3:011789-011879 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n3:011880-011922 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n3:011923-011966 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nThe underlying correspondence \nbetween Government and \nEpstein's counsel should be \nproduced without attorney \nannotations. The Government \nmust certify that Petitioners \nhave this correspondence. \n3:011967-012016 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n33 \nEFTA01657784\n", "char_count": 1697}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 34 of 51 \n3:01217-012055 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n3:012056-012088 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n3:012089-012129 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n3:012130-012150 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n3:012151-012167 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n3:012168-012170 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n3:012171-012173 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \n3:012174-012176 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nFinal versions of sent \ncorrespondence should be \nproduced. The Government \nmust certify whether Petitioners \nhave any sent version of this \ncorrespondence. \n3:012177-012178 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n3:012179-012188 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n3:012362-012451 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n3:012451-012452 \nProduce victim identities. \nDocument does not exhibit the \nmental impressions of counsel \nbut rather the cumulation of \nfacts. Petitioners' need \noutweighs investigative \nprivilege. Petitioners should be \nprovided with the victim \nidentities under an appropriate \nprotective order. \n3:012453-012623 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n3:012624-012653 \nProduction not necessary; documents are not relevant or \nlikely to lead to the discovery of materials relevant to \nthis CVRA litigation. \nThe Court has reviewed the \ncontent of the FBI \"302's,\" \nwhich are forms prepared by \nFBI agents to document \ninterviews. These interview \nreports summarize the various \nvictims' interactions with \nEpstein, and do not indicate a \nconveyance of information \nfrom the FBI to the victims \nregarding the likelihood of \nprosecution. \n34 \nEFTA01657785\n", "char_count": 1969}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 35 of 51 \n3:012654-012864 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n3:012865-013226 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy and \nopinion work product privilege. \n3:013227 \nProduction not necessary; not relevant or likely to lead \nto the discovery of materials relevant to this CVRA \nlitigation. \nInvolves OPR investigation \ninto Epstein's allegation that \ncertain prosecutors had \nconflicts of interest. Not \nrelevant to victims' CVRA \nrights. \n3:013228-013230 \nProduction not necessary; not relevant or likely to lead \nto the discovery of materials relevant to this CVRA \nlitigation. \nInvolves OPR investigation \ninto Epstein's allegation that \ncertain prosecutors had \nconflicts of interest. Not \nrelevant to victims' CVRA \nrights. \n3:013231-013239 \nProduction not necessary; not relevant or likely to lead \nto the discovery of materials relevant to this CVRA \nlitigation. \nInvolves OPR investigation \ninto Epstein's allegation that \ncertain prosecutors had \nconflicts of interest. Not \nrelevant to victims' CVRA \nrights. \n3:013240-013247 \nProduction not necessary; not relevant or likely to lead \nto the discovery of materials relevant to this CVRA \nlitigation. \nInvolves OPR investigation \ninto Epstein's allegation that \ncertain prosecutors had \nconflicts of interest. Not \nrelevant to victims' CVRA \nrights. \n3:013248-013251 \nProtected from disclosure by the attorney—client \nprivilege; also not relevant or likely to lead to the \ndiscovery of materials relevant to this CVRA litigation. \n3:013252-013253 \nProtected from disclosure by the attorney—client \nprivilege; also not relevant or likely to lead to the \ndiscovery of materials relevant to this CVRA litigation. \n3:013254-013257 \nProtected from disclosure by the attorney—client \nprivilege; also not relevant or likely to lead to the \ndiscovery of materials relevant to this CVRA litigation. \n3:013258-013259 \nProtected from disclosur\n... [truncated, 2336 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01657752/34 or ?id=EFTA01657752&page=34]", "char_count": 2336}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 36 of 51 \n3:013263-013271 \nProtected from discovery by attorney—client and opinion \nwork product privilege; also not relevant or likely to \nlead to the discovery of materials relevant to this CVRA \nlitigation. \n3:013272-013278 \nProtected from disclosure by the attorney—client \nprivilege; also not relevant or likely to lead to the \ndiscovery of materials relevant to this CVRA litigation. \nS:013279-013280 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013281 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013282-013283 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013284 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013285-013289 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013290-013292 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013293-013299 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nThe portions of this \ncorrespondence between the \nGovernment and Epstein's \ncounsel should be produced. \nThe Government must certify \nthat Petitioners have been \nprovided with these outside \ncorrespondences. \nS:013300-013303 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013304-013325 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013326-013329 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013330-013333 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013334-013337 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n36 \nEFTA01657787\n", "char_count": 1626}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 37 of 51 \nS:013342-013350 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nThe underlying correspondence \nbetween Epstein's counsel and \nthe Government should be \nproduced without attorney \nannotations. The Government \nmust certify that Petitioners \nhave been provided with these \noutside correspondences. \nS:013351-013361 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nThe underlying correspondence \nbetween Epstein's counsel and \nthe Government should be \nproduced without attorney \nannotations. The Government \nmust certify that Petitioners \nhave been provided with these \noutside correspondences. \nS:013362-013366 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nAny version of the letter \nactually sent to Epstein's \ncounsel should be produced. \nGovernment must certify \nwhether it has been produced. \nS:013367-013372 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nAny version of the letter \nactually sent to Epstein's \ncounsel should be produced. \nGovernment must certify \nwhether it has been produced. \nS:013373-013503 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013504-013507 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013508-013514 \nPartially protected from discovery by opinion work \nproduct privilege. \nOnly the top portion of P-\n013509 contains materials \ninternal to the Government—a \none-sentence email between \ntwo United States Attorneys. \nThe Government must certify \nthat Petitioners have the \nremainder of P-013509 and P-\n013510-013514, as these \ncommunications are between \nthe Government and Epstein's \ncounsel. \n37 \nEFTA01657788\n", "char_count": 1729}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 38 of 51 \nS:013515-013525 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nMy final version of the letter \nactually sent to Epstein's \ncounsel should be produced. \nGovernment must certify \nwhether it has been produced. \nS:013526-013527 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013528-013530, \n013532-013537 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013531 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \nS:013538-013553 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013554-013608 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013609-013615 \nProtected from discovery by grand jury secrecy. \nS:013616-013621 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013622-013643 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013644-013653 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013654-013745 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013747-013810 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013811-013833 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013834-013835 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013836-013837 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013838-013841 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege; also not relevant material or likely to lead to \ndiscovery of material relevant to the instant CVRA \nlitigation. \nThe underlying correspondence \nbetween Epstein's counsel and \nthe Government should be \nproduced without attorney \nannotations. The Government \nmust certify that Petitioners \nhave been provided with these \noutside correspondences. \n38 \nEFTA01657789\n", "char_count": 1839}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 39 of 51 \nS:013842 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege; also not relevant material or likely to lead to \ndiscovery of material relevant to the instant CVRA \nlitigation. \nS:013843-013844 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013845-013846 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013847-013849 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013850 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013851-013853 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013854 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013855 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013856-013857 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013858 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013861-013865 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013866 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013867-013868 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013869 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013870-013871 \nProduce; not protected from discovery by any privilege. \nOnly the top portion of the \nemail chain contains \ncorrespondence internal to the \nGovernment, and this does not \ndivulge any mental impressions \nor legal theories. The rest of \nthe email chain is between the \nGovernment and Epstein's \ncounsel. It should be produced. \n39 \nEFTA01657790\n", "char_count": 1615}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 40 of 51 \nS:013872 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nBesides internal Government \ncorrespondence, contains one \nemail correspondence between \nthe Government and Epstein's \ncounsel, which will be \nproduced at P4)13870-013871. \nS:013873 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013876-013877 \nPartially protected from discovery by opinion work \nproduct privilege. \nThe email correspondence at \nP—013877 is between the \nGovernment and Epstein's \ncounsel, and not privileged. \nThe Government must certify \nthat Petitioners have been \nprovided with these outside \ncorrespondences. \nS:013878-013879 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013880-013882 \nPartially protected from discovery by opinion work \nproduct privilege. \nOnly the top two email \ncorrespondences are internal to \nthe Government. The \nremaining emails, starting at \nthe bottom of P•013880 and \nrunning through P-013882, are \nbetween the Government and \nEpstein's counsel, and should \nbe produced. The Government \nmust certify that Petitioners \nhave been provided with these \noutside correspondences. \nS:013883 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013884-013886 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013887 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013888 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013889-013890 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:01389I \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n40 \nEFTA01657791\n", "char_count": 1680}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 41 of 51 \nS:013894-013898 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013899 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013900-01390I \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013902 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013903-013904 \nIdentical to the email chain at S:013870-013871, and \nshould likewise be disclosed. \nS:013905 \nPartially protected from discovery by opinion work \nproduct privilege. \nEmail correspondence at \nbottom of page between \nGovernment and Epstein's \ncounsel should be produced. \nThe Government must certify \nthat Petitioners have been \nprovided with these outside \ncorrespondences. \nS:013906 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:013909-013911 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013912-013914 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013915-013918 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013919-013921 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013922-013924 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013925-013927 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nThe final version of this letter, \nwhich is addressed to \nPetitioners' counsel, should be \navailable to Petitioners. \nS:013928-013930 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nThe final version of this letter, \nwhich is addressed to \nPetitioners' counsel, should be \navailable to Petitioners. \n41 \nEFTA01657792\n", "char_count": 1825}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 42 of 51 \nS:013931-013933 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nThe final version of this letter, \nwhich is addressed to \nPetitioners' counsel, should be \navailable to Petitioners. \nS:013934-013936 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013937-013939 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nThe final version of this letter, \nwhich is addressed to \nPetitioners' counsel, should be \navailable to Petitioners. \nS:013940-013942 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013943 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013944 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013945 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013946 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013947 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013948-013951 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013952-013953 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013954-013955 \nNot relevant or likely to lead to material relevant to the \ninstant CVRA litigation. \nS:013956-013969 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:813970.13971 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege; also, not relevant or likely to lead to material \nrelevant to this CVRA litigation. \nS: 13972 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:13973-13976 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nThe Government's Second Supplemental Privilege Log begins here. (DE 329-1). \n42 \nEFTA016\n... [truncated, 2006 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01657752/41 or ?id=EFTA01657752&page=41]", "char_count": 2006}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 43 of 51 \nS:13977-13979 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:13980 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:1398I \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 13982 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:13983-13984 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:13985-13989 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:13990.13991 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:13992-13994 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:13995-14010 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege; also, not relevant or likely to lead to material \nrelevant to this CVRA litigation. \nS:S:I4011-14025 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14026.14027 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14028-14030 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14031-01432 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14033 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14034 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14035 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14036 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14037 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n43 \nEFTA01657794\n", "char_count": 1532}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 44 of 51 \nS:14038-1404I \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14042 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14043-14044 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege-\nS:14045-14046 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14047 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14048 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14049-14050 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege-\nS:14051 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14052 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14053 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14054 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14055 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14056 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14057 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14058 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14059-1406I \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14062-14068 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14069 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege-\nS:14070.14074 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n44 \nEFTA01657795\n", "char_count": 1498}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 45 of 51 \nS:14075-14089 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14090.14102 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14103-14107 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14108-14134 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14135-14149 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14150.14156 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14157-15160 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14161 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14162-14170 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14171-14174 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14175-14203 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14204-14205 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14206.14216 \nPartially protected from discovery by opinion work \nproduct privilege. \nThe portions of the email chain \nfrom Epstein's counsel are not \nprivileged. The Government \nmust certify that this outside \ncorrespondence has been \nproduced. \nS:14217-14238 \nPartially protected from discovery by opinion work \nproduct privilege. \nThe portions of the email chain \nfrom Epstein's counsel are not \nprivileged. The Government \nmust certify that this outside \ncorrespondence has been \nproduced. \nS:14239-14242 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14243-14251 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n45 \nEFTA01657796\n", "char_count": 1670}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 46 of 51 \nS:I4252-14275 \nPartially protected from discovery by opinion work \nproduct privilege. \nThe portions of the email chain \nfrom Epstein's counsel are not \nprivileged. The Government \nmust certify that this outside \ncorrespondence has been \nproduced. \nS: 14276 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14277-14282 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14283-14284 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14285-14298 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14299-14307 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14308-14310 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14311-14329 \nPartially protected from discovery by opinion work \nproduct privilege; outside correspondence and P- \n014315.014316 must be produced. \nThe Government must certify \nthat the outside correspondence \nhas been produced. The \ncorrespondence at P-014315-\n014316 must be produced; this \nfact-based material is not \nopinion work product as it does \nnot reveal the mental \nimpressions of counsel, and the \ncourt finds that Petitioners have \na compelling need for the \ninformation contained therein. \nThis need also outweighs any \ndeliberative-process privilege \nthat may apply. It not \nprotected by the attorney-client \nprivilege, as the Government \nhas not demonstrated that FBI \nagent Kuyrkendall provided \nthis information in an attempt \nto secure legal advice or a legal \nopinion from the United States \nAttorney's Office. The \ncorrespondence must be \nproduced pursuant to an \nappropriate protective order. \n46 \nEFTA01657797\n", "char_count": 1725}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 47 of 51 \nS:14330.14337 \nPartially protected from discovery by opinion work \nproduct privilege. \nThe portions of the email chain \nfrom Epstein's counsel are not \nprivileged. The Government \nmust certify that this outside \ncorrespondence has been \nproduced. \nS:14338-14354 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14355-14361 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14362-14402 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14403-14414 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14415-14420 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14421-14428 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:I4429-14439 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14440 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:1444I \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14442 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14443 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14444 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14445-14447 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14448-14454 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14455-14456 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n5:14457-14464 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n47 \nEFTA01657798\n", "char_count": 1556}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 48 of 51 \nS: 14486 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14487 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14488-14499 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14500 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege-\nS:14501-14506 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14507-14508 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14509-14519 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14520 \nProduce. \nThe Government has not \nsupported its assertion of \nattomey-client privilege: the \nemail does not, in and of itself, \ndemonstrate that it was a \ncommunication between an \nattorney and clients regarding \nthe provision of legal services \nor legal advice. Petitioners' \nneed for this material \noutweighs any deliberative \nprocess or investigative \nprivilege that may apply. \nS:14521-14522 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14523 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14524-14550 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n48 \nEFTA01657799\n", "char_count": 1243}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 49 of 51 \nS:1455I \nProduce. \nThe Government has not \nsupported its assertion of \nattomey-client privilege: the \nemail, authored by an FBI \nagent, does not indicate that it \nis a client communication \nseeking legal services or advice \nfrom an attorney, the United \nStates Attorney's Office. \nPetitioners' need for this \nmaterial outweighs any \ninvestigative privilege that may \napply. This must be produced \npursuant to an appropriate \nprotective order. \nS:14552 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14553-14556 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14557 \nProduction not necessary as not relevant or likely to lead \nto material relevant to this CVRA litigation. \nS:14558 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14559-14562 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14563-14565 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n5:14566.14568 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14569-14573 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14574-14583 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14584-14622 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14623-14627 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n5:14628 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS: 14629 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n49 \nEFTA01657800\n", "char_count": 1563}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 50 of 51 \nS:14630.14631 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14632-14646 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14647-14649 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege-\nS:14650.14653 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege-\nS:14654.14655 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege-\nS:14656.14665 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege-\nS:14666.14693 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14694-14706 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14707-14711 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege-\nS:14712-14716 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege-\nS:14717-14721 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14722-14727 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14728-14742 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14743-14780 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14781-14800 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege-\nS:14801.14810 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14811-14829 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege-\nS:14830.14837 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14838-14843 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n50 \nEFTA01657801\n", "char_count": 1557}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01657752", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 330 Entered on FLSD Docket 07/06/2015 Page 51 of 51 \nS:14844-1485I \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14852-14864 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege; also not relevant or likely to lead to material \nrelevant to this CVRA litigation. \nInvolves self-reporting to OPR \nregarding Epstein's allegation \nthat certain prosecutors had \nconflicts of interest. Not \nrelevant to victims' CVRA \nrights. \nS: 14865 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n5:14866.14883 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14884-14886 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14887-14894 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14895-14900 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14901-14906 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14907-1491I \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nS:14912-14919 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \n5:14920.14923 \nProtected from discovery by opinion work product \nprivilege. \nThe Government notes that a \nredacted version has been \nproduced to Petitioners. (DE \n329-1 at 18). Only the \nunredacted version is \nprivileged. \n51 \nEFTA01657802\n", "char_count": 1331}]}