{"efta_number": "EFTA01325051", "page_count": 20, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA01325051", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA01325051.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA01325051", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 329 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/23/2015 Page 1 of 2 \nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT \nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA \nCase No. 08-80736-Civ-Marra/Matthewman \nJANE DOE #1 AND JANE DOE #2, \nPetitioners, \nv. \nUNITED STATES OF AMERICA, \nRespondent. \n/ \nUNITED STATES' NOTICE OF FILING SECOND SUPPLEMENTAL PRIVILEGE LOG \nPursuant to the Court's June IS, 2013 Omnibus Order (DE 190), the Respondent, United \nStates of America, by and through the undersigned Assistant United States Attorney, hereby gives \nnotice of its filing of its Second Supplemental Privilege Log. The index has been marked with \nBates Numbers P-013970' thru P-014923. \nThe documents referenced in the Second Supplemental Privilege Log will be delivered \ntoday to the Chambers of U.S. District Judge Kenneth A. Marra for a pane in camera review, \npursuant to the Court's Omnibus Order. \nRespectfully submitted, \nWIFREDO A. FERRER \nUNITED STATES ATTORNEY \nBy: \nslA. Ma•ie Villafaiia \nA. MARIE VILLAFA&A \nAssistant United States Attorney \nFlorida Bar No. 0018255 \n500 South Australian Ave, Suite 400 \nWest Palm Beach, FL 33401 \nTelephone: 561-820-8711 \nFacsimile: 561-820-8777 \nann.marie.c.villafana@usdoj.gov \nPlease note that, while preparing the Second Supplemental Privilege Log, the undersigned \ndiscovered an error on the Supplemental Privilege Log, that is, the last entry states that the last document \nbears Bates Numbers P-013956 thru P-013846. The correct Bates range for that document is P-013956 \nthru P-013969 [14 pages]. \n1 \nSIDNY_GM_02 742858 \nEFIA_00229507 \nEFTA01325051\n", "char_count": 1576}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01325051", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 329 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/23/2015 Page 2 of 2 \nCERTIFICATE OF SERVICE \nI HEREBY CERTIFY that on June 23, 2015, I electronically filed the foregoing \ndocument with the Clerk of the Court using CM/ECF. According to the Court's website, \ncounsel for all parties are able to receive notice via the CM/ECF system. \ns/A. Marie Villafaiia \nA. MARIE VILLAFA&A \nAssistant United States Attorney \nSERVICE LIST \nJane Does 1 and 2 v. United States, \nCase No. 08-80736-CIV-MARRA/MATTHEWMAN \nUnited States District Court, Southern District of Florida \nBrad Edwards, Esq., \nFarmer Jaffe Weissing Edwards Fistos Lehrman \n425 N Andrews Ave Ste 2 \nFort Lauderdale, FL 33301-3268 \nbrad®pathtojustice.com \n954-524-2820 \nFax: 954-524-2822 \nPaul G. Cassell \nS.J. Quinney College of Law at the \nUniversity of Utah \n332 S. 1400 E. \nSalt Lake City, Utah 84112 \n(801) 585-5202 \nFax: (801) 585-6833 \nE-mail: casselp®law.utah.edu \nAttorneys for Jane Doe # 1 and Jane Doe # 2 \n2 \nSDNY_GM_02742859 \nEFTA_00229508 \nEFTA01325052\n", "char_count": 1033}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01325051", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 329-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/23/2015 Page 1 of 18 \nJANE DOE v. UNITED STATES \nCOURT FILE NO. 08-80736-CV-MARRA \nSECOND SUPPLEMENTAL PRIVILEGE LOG - BOX #4 \nBates Ran e \nDescri tion \nPrivil \ns Asserted \nP-013970 \nthru \nP-013971 \n11/29/2006-12/1/2006 emails between Marie Villafaiia and prison \nemployee regarding attempted contact with potential witness \nWork Product \nInvestigative Privilege \nPrivacy Act \nP-013972 \n5/18/2007 email from Marie Villafaiia to Man Menchel informing him \nof intent to subpoena Roy Black's private investigator and steps taken to \nobtain DOJ authorization \nWork Product \n6(e) \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-013973 \nthru \nP-013976 \n5/18/2007 emails between Marie Villafafia and expert witness regarding \nsecuring pre-indictment consultation contract \nWork Product \n6(e) \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-013977 \nthru \nP-013979 \n5/21/2007 email from Marie Villafana to Myesha Braden (CEOS) re \n2423(b) charging question \nWork Product \n6(e) \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-013980 \n5/21/2007 email from Marie Villafaiia to Matt Menchel and Jeff Sloman \nregarding guidance on grand jury presentation \nWork Product \n6(e) \nDeliberative Process \nP-013981 \n5/22/2007 email from Andy Lourie to Man Menchel and Jeff Sloman \n(cc: Marie Villafaila) re letter received from Gerald Lefcourt discussing \na meeting to discuss Epstein investigation \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-013982 \n5/23/2007 email from Jason Richards to Marie Villafaiia re extradition \nresearch \nWork Product \nA/C privilege \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-013983 \nthru \nP-013984 \n5/23/2007 emails between Karen Atkinson and Marie Villafana \nregarding decision to meet with counsel for Epstein \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nPage 1 of 18 \nSONY_GM_02742860 \nEFTA_00229509 \nEFTA01325053\n", "char_count": 1844}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01325051", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 329-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/23/2015 Page 2 of 18 \nBates Range \nDescription \nPrivilege(s) Asserted \nP-013985 \nthru \nP-013989 \n6/14/2007-6/21/2007 emails between Marie Villafafia, Karen Atkinson, \nAndrew Lourie, Matt Menchel, and Jeff Sloman regarding addendum to \nPros Memo, grand jury presentation and changes to indictment, and \nmeeting with counsel for Epstein \n6(e) \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-013990 \nthru \nP-013991 \n6/26/2007 email from Marie Villafafia to Jeff Sloman, Man Menchel, \nand Andrew Lourie addressing arguments regarding interstate nexus for \n2422(b) charges \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-013992 \nthru \nP-013994 \n7/3/2007-714/2007 emails between Marie Villafafia and Andrew Lourie \nregarding extension of time to respond to subpoenas requested by Lilly \nAnn Sanchez and possible resolution of case \n6(e) \nWork Product \nInvestigative Privilege \nDeliberative Process \nP-013995 \nthru \nP-014010 \n6/12/2007-716/2007 series of emails between Marie Villafafia and \nAUSAs Serene Nakano and James Cott re an earlier unrelated \ninvesti • ation of E i stein \nWork Product \nInvestigative Privilege \nPrivac Act \nP-014011 \nthru \nP-014025 \n7/312007-7/1312007 email chain between Man Menchel and Marie \nVillafafia regarding disagreement on Menchel's plea negotiations and \nwritten request for meeting between USAO management and victims \n6(e) \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014026 \nthru \nP-014027 \n7/16/2007 email from Marie Villafafia to Matt Menchel and Andrew \nLourie regarding correspondence from Roy Black and Motion to Quash \n6(e) \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014028 \nthru \nP-014030 \n7/18/2007 emails from Marie Villafafia to Andrew Lourie and Matt \nMenchel regarding Motion to Quash grand jury subpoena and \nsupporting affidavit filed by Roy Black \n6(e) \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nInvesti • ative Privile • e \nP-014031 \nthru \nP-01403\n... [truncated, 2324 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01325051/3 or ?id=EFTA01325051&page=3]", "char_count": 2324}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01325051", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 329-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/23/2015 Page 3 of 18 \nBates Range \nDescription \nPrivilege(s) Asserted \nP-014033 \n7/19/2007 email from Marie Villafafia to Andrew Lourie and Matt \nMenchel regarding planned service of target letters \nWork Product \n6(e) \nInvestigative Privilege \nDeliberative Process \nP-014034 \n7/26/2007 email from Marie Villafafia to Matt Menchel and Andrew \nLourie regarding proposed changes to the indictment \n6(e) \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nInvesti ative Privilege \nP-014035 \n7/31/2007 email from Marie Villafafta to Jeff Sloman, Man Menchel, \nand Andrew Lourie summarizing proposed plea terms as per Menchel \nrecommendation \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014036 \n7/31/2007-8/2/2007 email chain between Jeff Sloman, Matt Menchel, \nAndrew Lourie, and Marie Villafana regarding plea negotiations \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nInvesti ative Privilege \nP-014037 \n8/212007 email dram Marie Villafana to Jeff Sloman, Matt Menchel, \nand Andrew Lourie with draft response to Epstein counsel regarding \nagreement \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014038 \nthru \nP-014041 \n8/2/2007 emails between Man Menchel, Jeff Sloman, Andy Lourie, and \nMarie Villafafta regarding letter received from Lilly Ann Sanchez \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014042 \n8/3/2007 Email from Marie Villafafia to Matt Menchel, Andrew Lourie, \nJeff Sloman, and Karen Atkinson regarding draft response to \ncorrespondence from Epstein counsel and planned investigative steps if \nagreement cannot be reached. \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014043 \nthru \nP-014044 \nEmails dated 8/6/2007 from Marie Villafaila to Cyndee \nCampos/Frederica Devlin and Jeff Sloman regarding Man Menchel's \ncorrespondence prior to his departure. \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014045 \nthru \nP-014046 \n8/7/2007 email chain between Marie Villafana, Cyndee Campos, and \nAlex Acosta regarding meeting to discuss Eps\n... [truncated, 2137 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01325051/4 or ?id=EFTA01325051&page=4]", "char_count": 2137}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01325051", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 329-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/23/2015 Page 4 of 18 \nBates Range \nDescription \nPrivilege(s) Asserted \nP-014047 \n8/7/2007 email from Marie Villafaila to Andy Lourie regarding deadline \nset for Epstein plea and Epstein's plan to demand a meeting with CEOS. \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014048 \n8/7/2007 email from Marie Villafatia to Andrew Oosterbaan regarding \nEpstein meeting \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014049 \nthru \nP-014050 \n8/7/2007 email chain from Jeff Sloman to Andrew Oosterbaan, Marie \nVillafalia, and Alex Acosta regarding Epstein meeting \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014051 \n8/8/2007 emails between Marie Villafatia and Andrew Oosterbaan \n(CEOS) regarding case staffing and plea negotiations \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014052 \n8/8/2007 email chain between Andrew Oosterbaan, Alex Acosta, Marie \nVillafaiia, Cyndee Campos, Jeff Sloman, and Andrew Lourie regarding \n\"The meeting on Epstein\" \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014053 \n8/8/2007 email from Marie Villafaiia to Drew Oosterbaan regarding \nplea negotiations, guideline calculations, and assistance in preparing \ncase for trial \nWork Product \nInvestigative Privilege \nDeliberative Process \nP-014054 \n8/8/2007 email from Marie Villafaila to Alex Acosta, Cyndee Campos, \nJeff Sloman, Andrew Lourie, and Drew Oosterbaan regarding planning \nmeeting with Epstein counsel and service of target letters \nWork Product \n6(e) \nInvestigative Privilege \nDeliberative Process \nP-014055 \n8/10/2007 Electronic correspondence from Marie Villafatia to expert \nwitness regarding topics for expert testimony \nWork Product \nP-014056 \n8/10/2007 email from Marie Villafaiia to Andrew Lourie regarding \ntarget letters and staying motion to compel production of computers \nWork Product \nP-014057 \n8/30/2007 email from Marie Villafalia to Jeff Sloman\n... [truncated, 2403 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01325051/5 or ?id=EFTA01325051&page=5]", "char_count": 2403}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01325051", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 329-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/23/2015 Page 5 of 18 \nBates Range \nDescription \nPrivilege(s) Asserted \nP-014059 \nthru \nP-014061 \n9/6/2007 emails between Marie Villafaila, Jeff Sloman, Andrew Lourie \nDrew Oosterbaan, and Rolando Garcia regarding status of plea \nnegotiations, draft agreements, and need to confer with victims \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014062 \nthru \nP-014068 \n9/10/2007-9/14/2007 emails between Marie Villafalia, Andrew Lourie, \nJeff Sloman, Karen Atkinson, Rolando Garcia, Shawn Ball, and Alex \nAcosta regarding final plea negotiations, finalizing details with State \nAttorney's Office and final revisions to indictment package \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \n6(e) \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014069 \n9/10/2007 email from Marie Villafaila to Jeff Sloman and John \nMcMillan regarding Acosta inquiry about FBI investigation into State \ngrand jury proceeding \nWork Product \n6(e) \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014070 \nthru \nP-014074 \n9/11/2007 emails between Marie Villafafia, John McMillan, Drew \nOosterbaan, Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, and Jason Richards regarding changes \nto the draft indictment and status of plea negotiations \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \nAttorney-Client Privilege \nP-014075 \nthru \nP-014089 \n9/10/2007-9/11/2007 emails between Marie Villafaila, Alex Acosta, and \nJeff Sloman regarding modifications to the proposed Non-Prosecution \nAgreement \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014090 \nthru \nP-014102 \n9/13/2007 emails from Marie Villafafta to Andrew Lourie, Alex Acosta, \nJeff Sloman, Rolando Garcia, and Karen Atkinson regarding plea to \nfederal charges recommending 18 USC 403 or 1512(d), or 47 USC \n223(aX1XB); response that Epstein was only willing to plead to assault \non the plane; and rejection of facts supporting assault on the plane \ncharge \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014103 \nthru \nP-014107 \n9/13/2007-9114/2007 emails regarding Marie Villafana research \nregarding v\n... [truncated, 2404 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01325051/6 or ?id=EFTA01325051&page=6]", "char_count": 2404}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01325051", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 329-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/23/2015 Page 6 of 18 \nBates Range \nDescription \nPrivilege(s) Asserted \nP-014135 \nthru \nP-014149 \n9/19/2007-9/20/2007 emails between Marie Villafana, Andrew Lourie, \nand Rolando Garcia regarding plea negotiations with counsel for \nEpstein \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014150 \nthru \nP-014156 \n9/20/2007 emails between Marie Villafaiia and Andrew Lourie \nregarding plea agreement to federal charges and factual proffer \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014157 \nthru \nP-014160 \n9/21/2007 emails between Marie Villafaiia and Andrew Lourie, Rolando \nGarcia, Karen Atkinson, and John McMillan regarding revisions to the \nnon-prosecution agreement \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014161 \n9/21/2007 email from Marie Villafaha to Alex Acosta, Rolando Garcia, \nKaren Atkinson, and Andrew Lourie regarding review of Epstein \nindictment package \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014162 \nthru \nP-014170 \n9/24/2007 series of emails between Marie Villafaila, Alex Acosta, and \nAndrew Lourie regarding plea negotiations and revisions to non- \nprosecution agreement \nWork Production \nDeliberative Process \nP-014171 \nthru \nP-014174 \n9/23/2007-9/24/2007 series of emails between Alex Acosta, Marie \nVillafaila, Andrew Lourie, Rolando Garcia, and Jeff Sloman regarding \nproposed revisions to non-prosecution agreement \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014175 \nthru \nP-014203 \n9/20/2007-9/24/2007 emails between Alex Acosta, Marie Villafatia, and \nAndrew Lourie regarding revisions to the non-prosecution agreement \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014204 \nthru \nP-014205 \n9/24/2007 emails between Marie Villafana and Rolando Garcia \nregarding notifying Palm Beach Police Chief and victims about \nagreement \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014206 \nthru \nP-014216 \n9/24/2007-9/25/2007 emails between Alex Acosta, Marie Villafaila, \nAndrew Lourie, and Rolanda Garcia regarding Leflcowitz email about \nkeeping agreemen\n... [truncated, 2410 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01325051/7 or ?id=EFTA01325051&page=7]", "char_count": 2410}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01325051", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 329-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/23/2015 Page 7 of 18 \nBates Range \nDescription \nPrivilege(s) Asserted \nP-014239 \nthru \nP-014242 \n10/18/2007 emails between Marie Villafafia and Jeff Sloman regarding \nEpstein's request to delay his change of plea \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014243 \nthru \nP-014251 \n10/19/2007 emails between Jeff Sloman and Marie Villafaila regarding \nSpecial Master's Selection of Attorney Representative \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014252 \nthru \nP-014275 \n10/22/2007-10/31/2007 emails between Jeff Sloman, Alex Acosta, and \nMarie Villafaila regarding negotiation of Addendum to Non-Prosecution \nAgreement and drafting of correspondence regarding scope of Special \nMaster's duties and selection criteria \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014276 \n10/31/2007 email from Nesbitt Kurykendall to Marie Villafana \nregarding attempts to interview additional witnesses/victims \nWork Product \nAttorney-Client Privilege \nInvestigative Privilege \n6(e) \nAlso contains information subject to \nprivacy rights of victims who are not \nparties to this litigation \nP-014277 \nthru \nP-014282 \n11/2/2007-11/5/2007 emails between Marie Villafafia and Jeff Sloman \nregarding drafting 11/5/2007 letter from Sloman to Lefkowitz \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014283 \nthru \nP-014284 \n11/5/2007-11/7/2007 emails from Marie Villafaila to Jeff Sloman \ninquiring about status of matter and contact by Epstein investigators \nwith victims \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014285 \nthru \nP-014298 \n11/8/2007-11/14/2007 emails between Marie Villafaila, Jeff Sloman, \nKaren Atkinson, and Jason Richards regarding response to objections \nraised b E stein counsel and efforts to char e date for \nit \nlea \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nAttorne -Client Privile e \nP-014299 \nthru \nP-014307 \n11/14/2007-11/19/2007 emails between Marie Villafafia, Jason \nRichards, Jeff Sloman, Rolando Garcia, Alex Acosta, and Karen \nAtkinson regarding communicati\n... [truncated, 2251 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01325051/8 or ?id=EFTA01325051&page=8]", "char_count": 2251}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01325051", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 329-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/23/2015 Page 8 of 18 \nBates Range \nDescription \nPrivilege(s) Asserted \nP-014308 \nthru \nP-014310 \n11/19/2007 emails between Marie Villafafia, Jeff Sloman, and Rolando \nGarcia about efforts by Epstein's counsel to change date for change of \nplea \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014311 \nthru \nP-014329 \n11/19/2007-11/28/2007 emails between Marie Villafafia, Nesbitt \nKuyrkendall, Jason Richards, and Jeff Sloman regarding drafting victim \nnotification letter of upcoming plea \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nAttorney-Client Privilege \n6(e) \nAlso contains information subject to \nprivacy rights of victims who are not \nparties to this litigation \nP-014330 \nthru \nP-014337 \n11/28/2007 correspondence between Marie Villafafia, Andrew Lourie, \nDrew Oosterbaan, and Rolando Garcia regarding Leflcowitz 11/27/2007 \nemail discussing presentation to DAAG \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014338 \nthru \nP-014354 \n11/29/2007-12/1/2007 emails between Marie Villafafia, Alex Acosta, \nJeff Sloman, Cyndee Campos, and Andrew Lourie regarding draft \nresponse to Jay Leflcowitz and victim notification letters \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014355 \nthru \nP-014361 \n12/3/2007 emails between Marie Villafaila, Alex Acosta, and Jeff \nSloman regarding history of plea negotiations and drafting response to \ncorrespondence from Jay Lekowitz and Ken Starr \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014362 \nthru \nP-014402 \n12/3/2007-12/5/2007 correspondence between Alex Acosta, Jeff \nSloman, Marie Villafafia, Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, Cyndee Campos, and \nAnnette Castillo about drafting and sending the 12/4/2007 Acosta letter \nto Ken Starr \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \n6(e) \nAttorney-Client Privilege \nP-014403 \nthru \nP-014414 \n12/6/2007 emails between Marie Villafafia, Andrew Lourie, Cyndee \nCampos, Jeff Sloman, Alex Acosta, Karen Atkinson, and Nesbitt \nKuyrkendall regarding correspondence from Ken Starr, request for a \nmeeting \n... [truncated, 2388 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01325051/9 or ?id=EFTA01325051&page=9]", "char_count": 2388}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01325051", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 329-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/23/2015 Page 9 of 18 \nBates Range \nDescription \nPrivilege(s) Asserted \nP-014421 \nthru \nP-014428 \n12/6/2007-12/7/2007 emails between Marie Villafaila, Nesbitt \nKuyrkendall, Jason Richards, Jeff Sloman, Cyndee Campos, Annette \nCastillo, Karen Atkinson, and Shawn Ball regarding request from State \nAttorney's Office for draft plea proffer \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \n6(e) \nAttorney-Client Privilege \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014429 \nthru \nP-014439 \n12/9/2007-12112/2007 emails between Marie Villafaiia, Jeff Sloman, \nJason Richards, Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, Annette Castillo, Karen Atkinson, \nand Rolando Garcia regarding drafting response to personal attacks and \nupcoming meeting with Ken Stan• \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014440 \n12/11/2007 email from Marie Villafafta to Jeff Sloman and Alex Acosta \nregarding call with lawyer for Jane Doe #2 (T.M.) \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014441 \n12/12/2007 emails between Marie Villafafta, Frederica Devlin, and Bob \nSenior regarding planning indictment review \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \n6(e) \nP-014442 \n12/14/2007 email from Marie Villafafta to Jeff Sloman, Alex Acosta, \nand Janice LeClainche regarding state cases mentioned by Epstein's \ncounsel \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014443 \n12/14/2007 email from Marie Villafaila to Alex Acosta, Jeff Sloman, \nRolando Garcia, and Karen Atkinson with draft letters to State \nAttorney's Office and victims \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014444 \n12/17/2007 email from Marie Villafafta to Jeff Sloman inquiring about \ncase status and informing Sloman regarding agent concern about victim \nnotifications \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014445 \nthru \nP-014447 \n12/19/2007 email from Marie Villafaiia to Alex Acosta and Jeff Sloman \nsummarizing research into other cases where individuals were charged \nwith violating 2422(b) based upon the use of a telephone \nWork Product \nDeliberative Proc\n... [truncated, 2376 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01325051/10 or ?id=EFTA01325051&page=10]", "char_count": 2376}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01325051", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 329-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/23/2015 Page 10 of \n18 \nBates Range \nDescription \nPrivilege(s) Asserted \nP-014455 \nthru \nP-014456 \n12/19/2007 email from Marie Villafafia to Alex Acosta, Jeff Sloman, \nand Janice LeClainche regarding challenge to state charge raised by \nEpstein counsel during 12/14/2007 meeting \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \n6(e) \nAlso contains information subject to \nprivacy rights of victims who are not \nparties to this litigation \nP-014457 \nthru \nP-014464 \n12/20/2007 emails between Marie Villafafia and Jeff Sloman regarding \ninquiries from State Attorney's Office regarding Epstein plea to state \ncharge and facts supporting state plea \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \n6(e) \nAlso contains information subject to \nprivacy rights of victims who are not \nparties to this litigation \nP-014465 \nthru \nP-014485 \n12/18/2007-12121/2007 emails between Marie Villafafia and other \nAUSAs regarding other instances of charging 2422(b) based on the use \nof a telephone as a \"facility of interstate commerce\" \nWork Product \n6(e) \nP-014486 \n12/21/2007 email from Marie Villafafia to Jeff Sloman with thoughts on \nrecent correspondence from Jay Leflcowitz raising concerns about \ninterpretation of the Nonprosecution Agreement \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014487 \n12/27/2007 email from Marie Villafafia to Alex Acosta and Jeff Sloman \nregarding proposed approach to providing potential notice of breach of \nnon-prosecution agreement \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014488 \nthru \nP-014499 \n12/27/2007 emails between Jeff Sloman, Alex Acosta, Annette Castillo, \nKaren Atkinson, Rolando Garcia, and Marie Villafafia regarding Jay \nLefkowitz letter of 12/26/2007 \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014500 \n1/2/2008 email from Jeff Sloman to Alex Acosta and Marie Villafafia \nregarding telephone conversation with State Attorney's Office about \ndelay in Epstein state plea. \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014501 \nthru \nP-01450\n... [truncated, 2324 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01325051/11 or ?id=EFTA01325051&page=11]", "char_count": 2324}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01325051", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 329-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/23/2015 Page 11 of \n18 \nBates Range \nDescription \nPrivilege(s) Asserted \nP-014507 \nthru \nP-014508 \n1/2/2008 emails from Marie Villafafia to Alex Acosta and Jeff Sloman \nregarding renewed plea negotiations for federal plea agreement \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \n6 e \nP-014509 \nthru \nP-014519 \n1/3/2008 emails between Marie Villafafia, Alex Acosta, and Jeff Sloman \nregarding Alex Acosta telephone conference with Jay Lefkowitz where \nLefkowitz admitted that he never intended to have Epstein plead guilty \nto an offense that required sex offender registration. \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014520 \n1/3/2008 email from Marie Villafaila to Nesbitt Kuyrkendall and Jason \nRichards regarding renewed plea negotiations and press coverage of \nEpstein matter. \nAttorney client privilege \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014521 \nthru \nP-014522 \n1/7/2008 email from Marie Villafafia to Alex Acosta, Jeff Sloman, \nRobert Senior, Karen Atkinson, and Rolando Garcia regarding proposed \nadditional investigative steps in Epstein case. \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \n6(e) \nPrivacy Act \nP-014523 \n1/9/2008 email from Jeff Sloman to Drew Oosterbaan, Alex Acosta, and \nMarie Villafafia regarding informing Jay Lefkowitz that a CEOS \nattorney would join the SDFL team regarding the Epstein case and \nwould review the prosecution and defense materials. \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014524 \nthru \nP-014550 \n1/9/2008-1/14/2008 emails between Marie Villafafia, Drew Oosterbaan, \nMyesha Braden, Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, and Jason Richards regarding \nassigning a CEOS attorney to the investigation, meeting with the CEOS \nattorney and victims in Florida, the results of the meetings and planned \nadditional meetings, and revisions to the indictment in light of the \nmeetings. \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nAttorney-client privilege \nInvestigative Privilege \n6(e) \nP-014551 \n1/17/2008 email from Nesbitt Kuyr\n... [truncated, 2540 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01325051/12 or ?id=EFTA01325051&page=12]", "char_count": 2540}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01325051", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 329-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/23/2015 Page 12 of \n18 \nBates Range \nDescription \nPrivilege(s) Asserted \nP-014553 \nthru \nP-014556 \n1/25/2008 emails between Marie Villafafia and Myesha Braden \nregarding press coverage of case and strategic decisions regarding \nrevisions to initial indictment \nWork Product \n6(e) \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \nAlso contains information subject to \nprivacy rights of victims who are not \nparties to this litigation \nP-014557 \n1/25/2008 email from Nesbitt Kuyrkendall to Marie Villafafia and \nShawn Ball regarding research for purposes of issuing grand jury \nsubpoenas. \n6(e) \nAttorney-client privilege \nInvestigative Privilege \nAlso contains information subject to \nprivacy rights of victims who are not \nparties to this litigation \nP-014558 \n1/29/2008 email from Marie Villafafia to Drew Oosterbaan and Myesha \nBraden regarding status of meeting in DC and concerns regarding delay. \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \n6(e) \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014559 \nthru \nP-014562 \n1/28/2008-1/29/2008 emails between Marie Villafafia and Myesha \nBraden regarding scheduling victim interviews on 1/31/2008-2/1/2008 \nWork Product \n6(e) \nInvestigative Privilege \nAlso contains information subject to \nprivacy rights of victims who are not \nparties to this litigation \nP-014563 \nthru \nP-014565 \n1/30/2008 emails between Marie Villafafia, Alex Acosta, and Jeff \nSloman regarding Lefkowitz email about lawsuit filed against Epstein \nby one of the victims identified during the state investigation. \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \n6(e) \nAlso contains information subject to \nprivacy rights of victims who are not \nparties to this litigation \nPage 12 of 18 \nSDNY GM 02742871 \nEFTA_00229520 \nEFTA01325064\n", "char_count": 1777}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01325051", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 329-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/23/2015 Page 13 of \n18 \nBates Range \nDescription \nPrivilege(s) Asserted \nP-014566 \nthru \nP-014568 \n1/31/2008 emails between Marie Villafthia and Nesbitt Kuyrkendall \nregarding interviews with victims. \nWork Product \nInvestigative Privilege \nAttorney-client privilege \nAlso contains information subject to \nprivacy rights of victims who are not \nparties to this litigation \nP-014569 \nthru \nP-014573 \n1/31/2008-2/1/2008 emails between Marie Villafafta, Jeff Sloman, Alex \nAcosta, Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, Jason Richards, and Alan Santiago \nregarding results of additional victim-witness interviews and requesting \nintervention with CEOS to move review process along \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \n6(e) \nAttorney-Client Privilege \nAlso contains information subject to \nprivacy rights of victims who are not \nparties to this litigation Investigative \nPrivilege \nP-014574 \nthru \nP-014583 \n2/20/2008-2/21/2008 emails between Drew Oosterbaan, Marie \nVillafafta, Robert Senior, Jeff Sloman, Sigal Mandelker, Karen \nAtkinson, Alex Acosta, Rolando Garcia and Myesha Braden regarding \nstatus of CEOS plans to meet with counsel for Epstein and status of \nindictment review \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \n6(e) \nP-014584 \nthru \nP-014622 \n2/12/2008-2/22/2008 emails between Marie Villafaiia, Nesbitt \nKuyrkendall, Jason Richards, and Myesha Braden analyzing facts \ngathered from grand jury investigation and discussing strategy for \ndrafting revised indictment \nWork Product \nAttorney-Client Privilege \nInvestigative Privilege \n6(e) \nAlso contains information subject to \nprivacy rights of victims who are not \nparties to this litigation \nP-014623 \nthru \nP-014627 \n2/25/2008 emails between Marie Villafaiia and Caroline Heck Miller \nregarding ethical issue about whether or not to present proposed revised \nindictment to new grand jury \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \n6(e) \nP-014628 \n2/25/2008 email from Marie Villafaila to Jeff Sloman, \n... [truncated, 2256 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01325051/14 or ?id=EFTA01325051&page=14]", "char_count": 2256}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01325051", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 329-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/23/2015 Page 14 of \n18 \nBates Range \nDescription \nPrivilege(s) Asserted \nP-0 I 4629 \n2/26/2008 email from Marie Villafaila to Myesha Braden regarding \nCEOS review and draft indictment package \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014630 \nthru \nP-014631 \n2/26/2008 email from Marie Villafafia to Jeff Sloman regarding Jeff \nSloman's 2/25/2008 correspondence to Jay Lefkowitz further extending \nthe plea deadline for Epstein \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \n6e \nP-014632 \nthru \nP-014646 \n2/21/2008-2/27/2008 emails between Marie Villafafia, David Weinstein, \nRobert Senior, Karen Atkinson, and Rolando Garcia regarding notifying \nDOJ's Civil Rights Division regarding the status of the case and the \nplanned indictment, and the draft written notification \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \n6(e) \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014647 \nthru \nP-014649 \n2/28/2008 emails between Marie Villafaila and Susan Roe regarding \nrelated investigation, potential investigatory leads, and CEOS review \nWork Product \nInvestigative Privilege \n6(e) \nP-014650 \nthru \nP-014653 \n2/27/2008-2/28/2008 emails between Marie Villafafia, Nesbitt \nKuyrkendall, and Jason Richards regarding review of evidence received \npursuant to subpoenas and planned interviews of additional potential \nvictim-witnesses \nWork Product \nInvestigative Privilege \nAttorney-client privilege \n6(e) \nAlso contains information subject to \nprivacy rights of victims who are not \nparties to this liti ation \nP-014654 \nthru \nP-014655 \n2/29/2008 emails between Jeff Sloman, Marie Villafafia, Robert Senior, \nand David Weinstein regarding continuing investigation and status of \nCEOS review \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \n6(e) \nP-014656 \nthru \nP-014665 \n3/4/2008-3/5/2008 emails between Nesbitt Kuyrkendall and Marie \nVillafafia regarding search warrant and victim contact with attorneys \nWork Product \nAttorney-client privilege \n6(\n... [truncated, 2196 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01325051/15 or ?id=EFTA01325051&page=15]", "char_count": 2196}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01325051", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 329-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/23/2015 Page 15 of \n18 \nBates Range \nDescription \nPrivilege(s) Asserted \nP-014666 \nthru \nP-014693 \n3/5/2008-3/6/2008 emails between Marie Villafafia, Alex Acosta, Jeff \nSloman, Drew Oosterbaan, Robert Senior, Myesha Braden, Rolando \nGarcia, and Karen Atkinson regarding meeting in DC, additional \ninformation to prepare for meeting, and new information from ongoing \ninvesti • ation \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \n6(e) \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014694 \nthru \nP-014706 \n3/10/2008-3/12/2008 emails between Marie Villafafia, Robert Senior, \nMyesha Braden, Krishna Patel, Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, E.J. Yera, and \nKaren Atkinson about Epstein attempts to contact victims and finding \ncounsel for victims \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nAttorney-client privilege \nP-014707 \nthru \nP-014711 \n3/12/2008 emails between Marie Villafafia, Drew Oosterbaan, and \nMyesha Braden regarding CEOS meeting with Epstein counsel \nWork Product \nP-014712 \nthru \nP-014716 \n3/14/2008 emails between Marie Villafafia, Rolando Garcia, Karen \nAtkinson, Frederica Devlin, and Shawn Ball regarding complete \nindictment package for Robert Senior final review \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \n6(e) \nP-014717 \nthru \nP-014721 \n3/12/2008-3/17/2008 emails between Marie Villafafia, Nesbitt \nKuyrkendall and E.J. Yen regarding search warrant application and \nexecution of search warrant \nWork Product \nAttorney client privilege \nInvestigative Privilege \nAlso contains information subject to \nprivacy rights of victims who are not \narties to this litilation \nP-014722 \nthru \nP-014727 \n3/14/2008-3/17/2008 emails between Marie Villafafia, Nesbitt \nKuyrkendall, Jason Richards, and Robert Senior regarding corrections \nto indictment package and proposed grand jury presentation \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \n6(e) \nAttorney-Client Privilege \nAlso contains information subject to \nprivacy rights of victims who are not \nparties to this litigation \nPage 15 of \n... [truncated, 2051 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01325051/16 or ?id=EFTA01325051&page=16]", "char_count": 2051}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01325051", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 329-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/23/2015 Page 16 of \n18 \nBates Range \nDescription \nPrivilege(s) Asserted \nP-014728 \nthru \nP-014742 \n3/1412008-3/1912008 emails between Marie Villafafia, Nesibtt \nKuyrkendall, Jason Richards, Robert Senior, Jeff Sloman, Karen \nAtkinson, and Rolando Garcia about Epstein attempts to contact victims \nand finding counsel for victims \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nAttorney-client privilege \nAlso contains information subject to \nprivacy rights of victims who are not \nparties to this litigation \nP-014743 \nthru \nP-014780 \n3/19/2008-3/21/2008 emails between Marie Villafafia, Drew Oosterbaan \n(CEOS), Alexandra Gelber (CEOS), Jeff Sloman, and Robert Senior \nabout meeting between Esptein counsel and CEOS and follow-up \nquestions \nWork Product \n6(e) \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014781 \nthru \nP-014800 \n3/19/2008-3/27/2008 emails between Jeff Sloman, Bob Senior, Karen \nAtkinson, Rolando Garcia, Nesbitt Kurykendall, and Jason Richards \nregarding waiting for DC's decision regarding Epstein's challenges to \nNPA; status of ongoing investigation; problems with Epstein's counsel \ncontacting victims in the guise of deposing them for the state criminal \naction; and securing pro bono counsel for those victims to represent \nthem in connection with the depositions \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \n6(e) \nP-014801 \nthru \nP-014810 \n3/28/2008 emails between Marie Villafaila, Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, Jeff \nSloman, Robert Senior, and Karen Atkinson regarding status of DC \nreview of case and preparing for grand jury presentation \nWork Product \n6(e) \nInvestigative Privilege \nDeliberative Process \nP-014811 \nthru \nP-014829 \n3/31/2008 emails between Marie Villafafia, Jeff Sloman, Robert Senior, \nand Nesbitt Kuyrkendall regarding status of ongoing investigation, \nplanned presentation to grand jury, continued delay in awaiting decision \nfrom Washington, DC, and problems with victims being hara\n... [truncated, 2517 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01325051/17 or ?id=EFTA01325051&page=17]", "char_count": 2517}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01325051", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 329-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/23/2015 Page 17 of \n18 \nBates Range \nDescription \nPrivilege(s) Asserted \nP-014838 \ndint \nP-014843 \n414/2008-41712008 emails between Marie Villafaiia, Robert Senior, \nAndrew Oosterbaan, and Jeff Sloman regarding status of CEOS review \nof E stein matter \nWork Product \n6(e) \nDeliberative Process \nP-014844 \nthru \nP-014851 \n4/10/2008-4/18/2008 emails between Marie Villafatia, Robert Senior, \nKaren Atkinson, Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, and Jeff Sloman about continued \ndelay in presenting case to grand jury due to failure to receive decision \nfrom DC, status of grand jury presentation and ongoing investigation \n6(e) \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014852 \nthru \nP-014864 \n4/1112008-4123/2008 emails between Marie Villafaila, Jeff Sloman, and \nDexter Lee regarding self-reporting to OPR false allegations of ethics \nviolations \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nPrivacy Act \nP-014865 \n4/29/2008 email from Marie Villafatta to Robert Senior, Jeff Sloman, \nKaren Atkins, on Rolando Garcia re grand jury presentation \nWork Product \n6(e) \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014866 \nthru \nP-014883 \n4121/2008-5/1/2008 emails between Marie Villafaiia, Robert Senior, Jeff \nSloman, Karen Atkinson, Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, and Drew Oosterbaan \nabout continued delay in presenting case to grand jury due to failure to \nreceive decision from DC, status of grand jury presentation and ongoing \ninvestigation, staffing of case for purposes of trial, and meeting to \nprepare for grand jury presentation \n6(e) \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014884 \nthru \nP-014886 \n5/2/2008 emails between Robert Senior, Marie Villafaiia, Karen \nAtkinson, Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, and Jason Richards regarding \ndevelopments in Epstein investigation and impact on grand jury \npresentation \n6(e) \nWork Product \nAttorney-Client Privilege \nInvestigative Privilege \nDeliberative Process \nP-014887 \nthru \nP\n... [truncated, 2296 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01325051/18 or ?id=EFTA01325051&page=18]", "char_count": 2296}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01325051", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 329-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 06/23/2015 Page 18 of \n18 \nBates Range \nDescription \nPrivilege(s) Asserted \nP-014895 \nthru \nP-014900 \n517/2008-5/9/2008 emails between Marie Villafafia, Robert Senior, Jeff \nSloman, Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, and Jason Richards regarding awaiting \napproval from DC and status of ongoing investigation \nWork Product \n6(e) \nDeliberative Process \nAttorney-Client Privilege \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014901 \nthru \nP-014906 \n5/15/2008-5/16/2008 emails between Jeff Sloman, Marie Villafafia, and \nRobert Senior regarding receiving final approval from DC \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nP-014907 \nthrti \nP-014911 \n5/19/2008-5/22/2008 emails between Marie Villafafia, Karen Atkinson, \nRobert Senior, and Jeff Sloman regarding preparation for grand jury \npresentation; communication with S/A Kuyrkendall regarding plea \nnegotiations; and status of ongoing investigation \n6(e) \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014912 \nthru \nP-014919 \n5/23/2008-5/27/2008 emails between Marie Villafafia, Robert Senior, \nJeff Sloman, Karen Atkinson, Nesbitt Kuyrkendall (FBI), and Jason \nRichards (FBI) re status of investigation, indictment review, grand jury \npreparation, and Epstein's attempt to revisit plea negotiations \nWork Product \n6(e) \nDeliberative Process \nInvestigative Privilege \nP-014920 \nthru \nP-014923 \n8/15/2008 email from Marie Villafaila to Alex Acosta, Jeff Sloman, \nRobert Senior, Karen Atkinson, and Dexter Lee containing draft \nresponse to 8/15/2008 email from Jay Lefkowitz regarding \nimplementation of the NPA. (Redacted version produced to opposing \ncounsel) \nWork Product \nDeliberative Process \nPage IS of 18 \nSDNY_GM_02742877 \nEF1'A_00229526 \nEFTA01325070\n", "char_count": 1750}]}