{"efta_number": "EFTA01246450", "page_count": 14, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA01246450", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA01246450.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA01246450", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "NO. 23838 \nIN THE INTERMEDIATE COURT OF APPEALS \nOi TUB STATE OF HAWAII \nROBERT COELLO and SARAN KELLEN, Petitioners-Appellees, \nv. TOM DONNAN, Respondent-Appellant \nAPPEAL FROM IH8 DISTRICT COURT OF TUE FIRST CIRCjit, \nHONOIULO DIVISION \n• (CIVIL NO. 1DSS 0C-1035) \nMEMORANDOM OPINION \n(Sy: Watanabe, Acting C.J., Lim and Foley, JJ.) \nRespondent-Appellant Tom Dorman (Dorman) appeals from \nan Order Granting petition for injunction Against Harassment (the \nInjunction.)' granted to Petitioners-•Appellees Robert Coello \ni/Tb. Injueetion wan granted pursuant to Kawaii Revised Statutas \n5 604-10.i rsupp. 20011, which provides, in relevant part: \ngSDAI-10.5 fovea to enjoin sod tcaporiariiy restrain \nhasaeseriat. (a) :or :ho purposes of this soctroN: \n•Courso of conduc•-• rears a pattern ct conduct composed of a \nstiles of arta oser any period of tine evidencing a continuity of \nporpnan. \n\"Norusimeot\" means: \n. \n. \n12) \nAn intonticoel er kneeing cootie et condact Cis-acted \nat an individual that seriously alai\"e or nistarba \nconsistently or ccocalual:y bath.rn Fla indlrldudi, \nnod that serene an legitimate pi-gooney provided LDat \nsuch encase et conchnt would etre. A realnnable parson \nto suffer anatinnal di \nSDI Ike MinLriel coots &hal: have power to ehjntn or \nprohibit or tempo-arily restrain harassment. \n(el \nAny person who ads beau sab)ocita to Assaf:anent nay \nperitien the distxlt.L coati ut Ltla d:strict In utica tie \npa:tritest resides for a temporary restraining ardex and an \ninjunction trod farther Ea:amens. \n(a) A petition tor relief from h r r rrr inept shall. be in \nwriting and sh►ll allege that a pas: set ox act, of kasaismenx may \nhave occurred. or that throats of harassment make it probable that \n(contioned...i \nZ d \n« £596559195 \nXV4 \nZ£:11 9I-80-LOOZ \nCONFIDENTIAL \nKELLEN-000003 \n3501.125-001 \nPage I of 14 \nEFIA_00064879 \nEFTA01246450\n", "char_count": 1875}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01246450", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "(Coello) and Sara, Kellen (Kellen) by the DlstrleL Court or the \nFirst Circuit, Honolulu Divl$:.on) (tbe district court), on . \nSeptember 2O, 2O00. \nOn appeal, Donnas contends that: (1) because the \nmatter arises from a real estate dispute, the district court \nlacks jurisdiction; (2) the Injunction unlawfully prohibits \nconstitutionally prt.e.cted activity; (31 the district court erred \nwhen it denied Donnan's Objections to Video Document and \nObjections. Lo Declaration of Petitioners; and (4) the district \nVf...corttnUed) \nacts ut haraenment may be itenloont; sae ;bull be ercreman'ed by en \naftidevIt fled( under oath Dr aka-mmtnt mid* uncles penally el \nperjury stating the specific, fac:s sod etrcunatences from en'.cd \nrelief is sosght. \n(el open petllion to a district ccurt under this section. \nthe court nay temporarily restrain the person or peteens trance In \nthe petition from harassing the petitioner upoa a determination \nthat there 33 probable cause tc believe that a paac act or acts Ise \nharasomect have eccurree or that a threat or threat, of haraaenent \nray be InnInent. The court say issue IX 0% parrs temporary \nrear.-alning Groot *Whet in ertting cr orally; p!ovidod :Eat ora: \neiders shell he reduced to vritlos by the cause of the next court \nday follselos oral issuance. \n(t) A temporary restraining order that 'et granted under \nthis umutton 00'1 ?eerie in *flee; at the discretion at the cacti: \noar a period not to exceed ninety days frox tho date the order :a \ngranted. A hcarLag on _he petition to ebjcln Terminer shall be \nneld within fifteen days after tae temporary rostra thing order it \ngrantee. Tn the event :hat service o; the teeporary rentreining \norder hue ant beer eflecled btfole the date oC ;he heuring an llmi \npetition Lt anjait, tan court may set a rev date for the bearing: \nprovided that ;be new daze /shell sot exceed 'ninety days from rho \ndata the tempority rcbtrainIng Order secs granted. \nThe car:nes raned it the potl:ion nay ;Ito or give CC\n... [truncated, 2482 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01246450/1 or ?id=EFTA01246450&page=1]", "char_count": 2482}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01246450", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "court denicd Donnen due procesis of lar and egual protectiot of \nthe .lag in vlolatiOn ot the Courteenta amendaert of the :bile(' \nStates Constitution and artiole I, section SI of the Hawaii. \nConstitution. \n/. BACKGROOND \nCoello and Kellen filed an Antended Petition fer Ra \nPatte TemPotacP Res‘rainLng Order and ter Injtnetion Against \nHaransw.nt (the. Petition) in the die hiet. court on August 24, \n2000. On the Petition, Coello and Kel±.en wrote the followitg \ndecaratlon detailing tue alleged harassment: \nSines kek,Lng gennegALw di tue udiae hOrdoritg Ni. \nDunrun es bonav, ge kage bad motstue \ntrott gegegel \noil) and county dopar:notat reeponding to reoplainan tron \nP.r. ;Doggen] 6  \n. \nSe, leid] Etno» SuateLy, \ntulldieg inepecsoce, firt dePortatnt, SePt. sp= band \nOkilikatken, Soger Deffie., eke., vite note [India; any fant \ner ~tg action, \nAfter toting onnorship, ve Rad to avlot \nDeanen'', (eiend, \nnellieon duo co non-paynent et rena \nfer S aon:te. Artes vanting ake toen Jet* Ot Aaq. ll\", \nbonnen a all hit ariene!» 6 tenesta on bli yard, sterten \nsniking valget. rattet i threiterne vommete tauende Sarah \natt sebert, -\"len ve zliterde4 om vidt*. They seid **trys \not_y Sitat behUn karage:ao us. Ang ve kave:ile segn govi:kå:tg \nyot. After seivoyina tue propercy ISnw, ve poeten sa* \ntnespesslas' alene On Degneg's Rico gt uer P:ODere.Y. Ttig \ngoter tann very nrch alten tray hut: the ILlatiOn part Of on,\npraperty belg:mnd kg teen. /hes! :ore otf eke signe t the« \nthea lp oez yard. usuil)y the onn et, matlette the ..u2W:ote \nit OgobAt's :nedlate 'Tiend & crlyamicn. Percy. We !ror \nto: the tafety pi Rarah, e younq roeure oho Corran i Si. \nStaut. Drite. per. ). S 3 (IWY3). p£0.:64,: \nDUE PROCESS AND EQU&L PROTECTION \nSeation S. go Fessen ',bold bo deprived or tite, libercy or \npr:perty \ndeo protest cf \nnet ot denlad eke egge! \npretection ed the kave, nor be ~tien the eapleyzon: of tre \npersen's civil right', or ba dlacriminoted against in the oxerclse \nthereof betona et r\n... [truncated, 2164 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01246450/2 or ?id=EFTA01246450&page=2]", "char_count": 2164}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01246450", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "'Wood* try \n\"any dolled bar •Bitch\" and alai* \nmode numeroue racial %aura :eying a* oat liker. U6, had to oo \nback across tbo corder. in addition to all thin, ovuzy Liao \n44.1 yQUVU \nbouv0 to go to the beech, snide 4 en aaaa al \n(sic) comments are mode by connun a tr1Oada toward Powart, \nSarah 4 their dogs. \nOn August 24, 2000, a temporary restrainirg order was entered by \nthe district court against Donnan and Donnan was notified that a \nhearing on the petition would be held on September. 6, 2000, at \n8:30 a.m. \nOr. September 1, 2000, Donnan filed s Motion for Order \nDeclaring Temporary Restraining Order Null and Void, Dissolving \nSame and to Pismias Petition and for Reasonable Attorney's Fees \nand Costs (Molion DeelarIng SRO Null and Void).. Donnan's motion \nSlated Lhal the Petition was frivolous, the district court lacked \njurisdiction over a real property dispute, and the :restraining \norder denied him his protected constitutional rights. Dennan's \nmotion came for hearing ca September 6, 2000, and was denied.' \nA hearing on the Petition was he:od September 20, 2000, \nat which the following evidence was adduced. \nCoello testified that he had purchased a duplex next \ndoor to Donnan's property. In order to setLle n property line \ndispute witn Donnan, Coello paid for an official survey of his \nproperty to satisfy Doman. 'Cool)* found our that he had more \nIlIbe 'Constable AbOndo A. tilsbiadEa resided. \n4 \n5 d \n« £596559195 \nXVJ \n££%11 54.-90-200Z \nCONFIDENTIAL \nKELLEN-000006 \n3501.125-001 \nPage 4 of 14 \nEFFA_00064882 \nEFTA01246453\n", "char_count": 1556}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01246450", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "yard than he originally thought he owned. During June and Jay \nof 2000, Cooke was visited by the police department, a building \ninspector, the Sunset Beach Fire Department, an inspector from \nthe Department of Land Otiiization, and the health department. \nThe visits were made in response to telephone calls from Donnan's \nresidence. No violations were found by any of these entities. \nThere were approximately 12 people residing on remnants property, \nOn Juno 19, 2000, Coello was given access to cienn out \ntne possessions of Malou Hallison (Mallison), who had been \nevicted in April from the adjoining half of Coello's duplex. \nCoen* had been awarded $803 from Hallison for payment of hack \nrent after.a summary possess;on hearing VD August 15, 2000. \nHelli=on was a friend of Donnan. \nThree hours after the August 16, 2300, hearing, Coello \nvideotaped Donnan and his guests arguing with Kellen across the \nproperty line. Men of the speech on L'ne videotape was \ntranscribed as indiscernible. Donnar objected to the admission \nof the videotape en the basic that the tape was edited and was an \ninvasion of Donnan's privacy. The district court overruled the \nobjection, and allowed one minute of the videotape to he played, \nstating: \nThe p¢rtions that are offing ahcwo to the Court are \nwediest, o- nnspliced and clam the taints perccn van one of \nthe pelLtionero, urn the petitioner our toting the video \nfroth the petitioner's own property, end the subject of the \nvideo was \npart Hr. Hannan. \n5 \n9 d \n« £596559L95 \nXVJ \n££VLL 9L -80-L002 \nCONFIDENTIAL \nKELLEN-000007 \n3501.1254)01 \nPage 5 of 14 \nEFTA_Ce064883 \nEFTA01246454\n", "char_count": 1630}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01246450", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "110) court finds Cis: tha avLaanur will be ada4ttsd a. \nw\nag agigagat, ant the Cant aattrulau the ofjossier. \nAfter viewing the videotape, Dorman again objected on \nthe ground that there was no harassment shown by Donnan on the \nvideotape. The district court did not find the videotape was \nthat instructive with respect to any acts of harassment and \nallowed !tithes testimony,. \nCoello testified that when ho ana Kellen warAed out to \nthe beach, Dunne° and his guests would yell volgaritien sad \nraoial slurs at and make obscene gestures towards Coeilo and \n'Kellen. Coello believed the enimosiT.y stemmed from an official \nsurvey that added to Coello's property end the eviction of \nDonnan's friend from Coello's property. \nKellen testified that Donnan had verbally harassed her \nby yelling racial slurs at her and had threatened future \nharassment. \nDonnan called Samson cantos (Santos), an investigator \nfor lne Hawaiian Humane Society, as the only defense witness. \nSantos testified that two complaints had teen made against Coen:, \nfor violations of the leash Law. Only one of tlw complaints had \nbeen made by Donnan.. Santos visited Coello throe times and round \nno violations, so the case had been closed. \n6 \nOIL d \n« £596559195 \nXVJ \n££:ll 9L-90-LOOe \nCONFIDENTIAL \nKELLEN-000008 \n3501.125-001 \nPage 6 of 14 \nEFTA_00064884 \nEFTA01246455\n", "char_count": 1348}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01246450", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "At the close ot evidence, Donnan moved to dismiss the \ncomplaint on the basis of inaufriciert evidence and lack CI \njurisdiction over a real property dispute. The district court \ndenied Donnan's motion and granted the Injunction for a period of \nthree years. The district court stated; \nVOX COURT: elelybe, clue Court does f%nel by client aid \naunrinula,2 OuSte,Ce that the an/pendent, Nr. canal, han \nSirenitenally ur knowingly ecoductem klartelt taunter, the \npatItIonert lo J nannAr whisk SOz1COsly niacin or dierw-ht \nThom by conskezett_y ot contInuslly tentie‘Ing the \nSedivldLute with ennpitiata \nthe building innvOttore, fix« \ndeparzwert, .and utl:liestten, watt sewage owpartaft“u, et \ncetera. Accoby \natIrb lo omving nn iftlitinato porpcse \notter than co Onknew the petitioners, and -hiet Is caused lLo \nOCSitStriere re sutt,,: egOilenel matrek, end reinnzab:y 4O. \ntherefore, tee COOrt is gninq to grant the nciat Of \ntejunction ve:oliloo N-. Dona« .:er a period ut th:e2 yntra \ntromp :ortber tarnenment el tie pets\".'.  \n . . . . \nAnd yin) scaptc: to yens mutioa if It is as \n[Cell's., Counsel), tc a:taxi:2 CD tSe hanta that this is \nreal property dispctt. the Court finds them the motion is \ngoing \nhe denied. thie le & matte: 0! taeaserseat which \nthe district cunt bee the pawia CO enloic aid wnich the \nCourt is gclug to enjo'.1 at title tine. \nWith respect tc any property disputant tbst does \nbelong In eircul: court aid the Cne:t Ls nos by this ardor \npreventive the respondent Iran :Slime a legitinote action \nwith sh,p<QC CO a <linnet.* ut a roperty line SP O.,a \nvOn:Ce easy. \nThe Order Granting Petition for Injunction Against \nHarassment vas filed September 20, 2000. Donnan riled his `trice \nut Appeal on October :e, 2000. \nII. STANDARDS OF REVIEW \nA. \nInterpretation of a Statute \nThe Jnnerpretation re a n'-utåte ie a quot.lon of Ito, \nreviewable et ono. \nWho« enstruirg c statute, cur foremost \nobligation in to ascertain and give effect to the \n•\n \n7 \nSL/9 d \n« £59655919\n... [truncated, 2112 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01246450/6 or ?id=EFTA01246450&page=6]", "char_count": 2112}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01246450", "page_number": 7, "text_content": ".eteoripn of the :ogislatusv. white is to es obtained \nprinatily icon the langnage contained in thc s.aruts \nlearnt. Aod we rest read a.atutory 'ananane In she \noontont CI Lbo entlre srarnto and C00AtIAU lk 10 * \nmanner honalasant with its purpose. \nEa Pa'aka' 0 Retina \nUse Commin 94 Mawari 31, 41, 7\nP.3d 1068, 1078 (2000) (internal quotation marks and citations \nomitted) (quoting .0mantifigskOun, 90 Hawari 152, 160, 977 9.2a \n160, 168 (1999)). \nB. \nAdmissibility of Evidence \n(0)1froxont arandaids of review nest be applies Ca \ntrit; conrt ~islets regarding Lk* addissib!\"ty of \nevidence, dnpandIng on the C0141100011:$ of the \nparticular rule of evidonc• at *** n * . ahrts \nappllewaon w! e parrAcular evIdentlgry rule car y'fald \nonly one norrant result, ran prOpos acandsrd fnr \nappell ate teylets is ine -spntivreng stundvnis• \n. Where the evicarn.lw.fy rang \nat 'EAU, concerns \nndMiAndb1;ity based apon Tclevanre, under 3nwell'i \nRotas of Evidence (OK.) Milos 431 and 4C4, the propet \nstandard of app0110.0 review is the rightfecong \net•ndard. \n. EvIcentlary Coniston, adaed on BES WIL. 403, which \nregatta a \";-mfr.'s* call\" on the part of the trial nears. \nare reviewed For ad abuse \nS:.annetlem. \nThe trial \ntears \nabuses Its discretion when It clearly exceeds the bonds at \nreaaon or disregards tales o: nrtacip's4 of law os prostiCC \nto the suhazoollal Potsizonc 00 a party lidgeel. \neani\ns.C1ar\nasna\ncE\ni\n, 85 &maid 336, 350-51, 944 P.2d \n1279, 1293-94 11997) (quoting State v. arced, 84 Hawaii 1, :), \n928 P.2d 943, 853 (1996)) '(citations and brackeLs omitted). \nC. \nDenial of Equal Protection and Dué Process \n\"Micro) no condamental rights or suspect \nclassifications arc involved, the rationa1 basis standard is \n8 \n5L/6 d \n« £596559L95 \nXV3 \nh£41 91-20-2.002 \nCONFIDENTIAL \nKELLEN-000010 \n3501.125-001 \nPage 8 of 14 \nEFEk_00064886 \nEFTA01246457\n", "char_count": 1866}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01246450", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "used. Only if there ^a no ralional basis to sustain Lhe \ncnallenged sratutes will there bo a violation of due process \nunder D.S. Coast. amend. XIV and Raw. Coast. art. 1, S 5.\" \ngashinaton v. Fireman's Fund Tns.  Companies, 68 Raw. 192, 202, \n708 F.2d 129, 136 (1985) (citation omitted). \nsa recogedre that, unless fuod4rielit,il rights o,\nseat:vet elawaltleulluns an 'zit:Yea-ad, us will apply lh2 \nraci.onal Mein .... \nA . re af rimier in osamlolno t dar-al et \ntotal proLattlec claim. Untie- -1“.A sandard. Lu proeai:. a \nparty OttlleiWnei ten nosnritntioeull.y OL a statutory \nelersitigation up ...Vial preiecttor grantee tea the await cs1 \nfl awing, wit, ‘ettylnelm clarity etat the e:anaisicutlot YL \nnot rwtloadlay trial:col to tie stem:P.02y purpose, 02 that cha \neicalbtagad ataniticaslon OCAS net rest WOO furet ground ar \ndIfXdranct baying a fair ere aultatantlal colatiot to rha \nob.;oct c the tas4ala,tan, and 1* Låttedicra no: arbit-ary \nand earlanua. \n;anav Bench Defense Fund v. City Council \n70 Haw. 361, 380, 173 \nR.2d 250, 262 11989) (citation omitted). \nIII. DISCUSSION \nA. \nJurisdiction \nDonnan contends that Hawaii Revised Statutes (HRS) \nS 801-5(d) precludes the dIstrict court from truing jurisdiction \nover issues of real propc,•ty ownership. Section 604-5(d) (Sup?. \n2101) states that \"(t)he distTicl. warts shall not have \ncognizance of real actions, nor actions in which the title to \nteal estate comes in quastion[.j\" \nThe statute gran.ing jurisdiction Ln the instant case \nis SRC S 604-10.5(b) (Sapp. 2001), which vests the dialtict \n9 \nWM. d \n« £59655905 \nXtli \nh£:Il 91-80-/OR \nCONFIDENTIAL \nKELLEN-000011 \n3501.125-001 \nPage 9 of 14 \nEFTA_00064887 \nEFTA01246458\n", "char_count": 1696}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01246450", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "comrtá with the \"power to enjoin or prohibit or temporarily \nrestrain harassment.\" \nFurthermore, at the September E, 2000, hearing en the \nNotion Declaring TRO Null and void, the district ccort stated the \nfollowing: \nTHE CCORP: the Corr: is tot, :be Court ir out :poking \nat boundary dkeynten. The Boort deer not have jurisdictien. \nI  \nith you, (Details, ComMo0j. Sr term* af detwcoln45g \n;wine tLkle «Galena Ur Ir lbeic'e ownerehlo in dirpusc, act \nin 100k:ag at oho TKO potItlec, theater rate! Pazticular \nstatederte we'ne here been side 4y eke Petittfnemrs, i.e.. \nthat DOnned, it'd Waged tar. WOOdh a0d all his f- Ienna \nand «nanee in b's yerd *totted malty vulgat, racial and \nthreatonán; co mmmm tot toward peatlonors which was !etc; \nrecorded on video. They pale they've only just begun \n \nLae ue ads es, haven't aeon any:hire yet. Tho.'s \nenough to Rave .ratted the Mt.) \nThe district court had jurisdiction over the Petition. \nB. \nConstitutionally Protected activity \nDonnan's second point states: \nMRS 5 604-12.5t1) en5elts the District Cektt from selecting \nout a virile of erlme and preventing his, under tno [heist \nof contempt, from telling the Renelule Pollee Department, er \nthe Humane Satiety ar °thee anthoritiee, when he is a victim \nof criminal conduct of no Onscreen violaticna at law. \nSection 604-10.5a) provides that \"(11:nihing in Cris \nteetion shall be cone:rued to prohibit constitutionally protected \nactivity.\" \nThe Injunction does not prevent Donnan from eallLng on \npublic safety autnoritico \"villein he is a victim or criminal \nconduct or he observes I/it:nations of law.\" Thel Injunction, on \nits face, prevents Donnan from: \n10 \nSI/Li d \n- \n« £596559L9S \nMid \nh£:LL 9L -80-G002 \nCONFIDENTIAL \n3501.125-001 \nPage 10 of 14 \nEFTA_00064888 \nEFTA01246459\n", "char_count": 1786}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01246450", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "A. \nContacting. :?restesiog or shy:Litany here/Mine \nPext..inner(a). “Con/...teLing° is (Wined to Inclagic \nid net lidiged co the teltyncoo, Mail. fecsiailer \npager. io.oraCt. etc. \nB. \nContacting, threstealag Cr harassing any forvan(S) \nshi:s residing at Petitiongr(1)' resioence. \nC. \nsneering add/or visiting the ?retinas of the \nPatlmioner(s), residence andJer the place of eke \nrotitinnerials employnenc. \nDorman was not enjoined from constitutionally protected \nactivity. \nC. \nAdmission of the Videotape into Evidence \nDonnan contends the district court erred when it \nrefused to suppress the videotape. Doncan arguas,\"[t]hc Video \nend the petition were acts of hate crimes and acts of revenge son \nretaliation against Dorman and cis tenant and friend because they \nhad followed the law and reported criminal violations thereof.\" \nHawaii Revised Statutes S 604-1.1.5(f) states that \n\"[t]he court shall receive all evidence that is relevant at the \nhearing, and may make independent inquiry.\" The district court \nadelted the videotape, stating \"[tyre Cnurt finds thit the \nevidence will be admithee es being relevant, end the Court \neverrnles the objection.\" \nThe videotape showed Kellen interacting with Dorman and \nDorman's guests and was, therefore, relevant. However, the \ndistrict court did not find the videotape was \"that instructive \nwith regard to any acts or harassmentl.l\" The district court \nfound clear and convincing evidence of harassment based on the \n11. \n51/Z1 d \n« £596559195 \nXV4 \nt£41, 91-90-200? \nCONFIDENTIAL \nKELLEN-000013 \n3501.125-001 \nPage 11 of 14 \nEFTA_00064889 \nEFTA01246460\n", "char_count": 1610}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01246450", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "testimony of the witnesses and other eviderce received, and not \nsolely on the videotape. fllhe district court was-correct in \nadmitting one minute of videotape as relevant to the allegations \nof harassment. \nD. \nEqual Protection and Due Process of Law \nDorman contenda ho was denied the right to defend \nhimself because he was \"prohibited from filitg any defensive \nresponse, including any counterclaim that would establish his \nright to a restraining order, damages, proof of ownership by way \nof adverac possession, a trial by jury and the right to have this \ncase determined in a Court of competent jurisdiction, namely, the \nFirst Circuit Court.\" \nDorman cites Ramil v. Keller, 65 Haw. 608, 126 P.2d 254 \n(1986), and Hovey v. Elliptt, 167 U.S. 409, 17 S. Ct. 841 (1837), \nin support of his argument. :n Ramia, the Supreme Court cf \nHawail upheld litigation-en ins sanctions after the defendants \nrefused to comply with discovery orders. 68 Haw. au 621, 726 \n1.7d at 263. In Hovey, the United States Supreme C•G.,rt found \ndenial of due process oC law, stating \"(a) sentence of a court \npronounced against a party without hearing him, or giving him an \nopportunity to he heard, is not s judicial determination of his \nrights, and is not entitled to respect in any other tribunal.\" \n:67 U.B. at 414, 17 S. Ct. at 845 (interval quotation marks \nomitted). \n12 \nSll£l d \n<.c £596599195 \nXVA \nh£Vll 9I-90-2.00Z \nCONFIDENTIAL \nKELLEN-000014 \n3501.1254)01 \nPage 12 of 14 \nEFTA_00064890 \nEFTA01246461\n", "char_count": 1497}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01246450", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "in contrast, ‘Jonnem was given the opportunity to be \nheard. Donnan was not allowed a counterclaim, but was not denied \nthe opportunity to file an adverse possession claim in circuit \ncourt. \nDonnan contends he was denied the right to a jury \ntrial. The right to a jury trial in civil essna guaranteed by \nthe United States Constitution applies to federal, not state, \ncourts. D.S. Const. amend VII. Trial. by jury in civil cases La \nguaranteed by the state constitution only whore the value in \ncontroversy exceeds rive thousand dollars. Haw. Coma. arm. I, \n$ 13. Docile and Kellen sought no monetary deranges .n this case; \ntherefnre, the value in controversy did not exceed five thousand \ndollars. Furthermore, HAS 9 634-10.6 does not provide for trial \nby jury. \nDonnan contends he was denied the right to subpoena \nrecords by way of deposition and written interrogatories; \nhowever, the district court granted a two-weeX continuance to \nallow Doman to produce the city and county agency records by \nsubpoena daces tecum. Furthermore, as the district, court advised \nDonnan, a hearing on a petition to enjoin harassment my not be \nheld later than ninety days after the date the temporary \nrestraining order is granted. 1183 % 604-10.5(fl. \n13 \n51/N. d \n« £596501195 \nXVI \nh£VII 9L-80-LOO2 \nCONFIDENTIAL \nKELLEN-000015 \n3501.125-001 \nPage 13 of 14 \nEFTA_00064891 \nEFTA01246462\n", "char_count": 1380}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01246450", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Dorman contends he was denied the sight to testify, yet \nthe record shows Donnan chose not to raze the witness stand based \non the advice of his counsel. \nDonnan's contentions are without merit. \nrv. CONCLUSION \nFor the foregoing reasons, the Order Granting Petition \nTor Injunction Against Harassment entered on September 20, 2000, \nby the District Court *t the First Circuit, Honolulu Div4mien, is \naffirmed. \nDATED: Honolulu, Sawari, April 9, 2002. \nOn the briefs: \nJoseph A. Ryan \nfor Respondent-Appellant \nRobert Coello and Sarah \nKellen, Pro se \nPetitioners-Appellees \n14 \nActing Chief Judge \nAssociate Judge \nAssociate Judge . \n51/S1 d \n<<.£5965991,95 \n>n \nh£4l 91.-00-LOOZ \nCONFIDENTIAL \nKELLEN-000016 \n3501.125-001 \nPage 14 of 14 \nEFIA_00064892 \nEFTA01246463\n", "char_count": 768}]}