{"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_count": 46, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA01203823", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA01203823.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "PROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril10,2015 \n1 \nIN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE SEVENTEENTH \nJUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR \nBROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA \nCIVIL DIVISION \nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS and PAUL G. CASSELL, \nPlaintiffs, \nvs. \nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ, \nDefendant. \nCASE No.: \nCACE 15-000072 \nPROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE \nHONORABLE JUDGE THOMAS M. LYNCH, IV \nFriday, April 10, 2015 \n9:05 - 9:55 o'clock a.m. \nBroward County Courthouse \n201 Southeast 6th Street \nRoom 950 \nFort Lauderdale, Florida 33301 \nJERROLD Wm. SEGAL, Court Reporter \n°ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203823\n", "char_count": 591}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "2 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nAPPEARANCES OF COUNSEL \nOn behalf of the Plaintiff: \nJACK SCAROLA, ESQ. \nSEARCY, DENNY, SCAROLA, BARNHART & SHIPLEY, P.A. \n2139 Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard \nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33409 \n561-686-6300 \nOn behalf of \nTHOMAS E. \nSTEVEN R. \nof the Law Offices of \nCOLE, SCOTT & KISSANE, P.A. \nDadeland Centre II \nSuite 1400 \n9150 South Dadeland Boulevard \nMiami, Florida 33156 \n305.350.5320 \n305 373 2294 Fax \nthe Defendant: \nSCOTT, ESQ. \nSAFRA, ESQ. (via speakerphone) \nCo-counsel: Defense \nMARY E. BORJA, ESQ. \nof the Law Offices of \nWILEY REIN, LLP \n1776 K STREET NW \nWashington, DC 20006 \n202.71 .42 2 \nApril 10, 2015 \n2 \nESQUIRE \nSOL uT IONS \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions. corn \nEFTA01203824\n", "char_count": 807}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n3 \nProceedings in the Matter of Bradley J. Edwards and \nPaul G. Cassell, Plaintiffs, vs, Alan M. Dershowitz, \nDefendant. \nFriday, April 10, 2015 \nTHE BAILIFF: Please, remain seated. Everyone, \nplease come to order. Court is now in session, the \nHonorable Thomas M. Lynch, IV now presiding. \nTHE COURT: Good morning, everyone. \nMR. SCAROLA: Good morning, Your Honor. \nMR. SCOTT: Good morning, Your Honor. \nTHE COURT: We are here on case number CACE \n15-000072, Bradley J. Edwards and Paul G. Cassell, \nPlaintiffs, versus Alan M. Dershowitz, Defendant. \nMR. SCAROLA: That's correct, Your Honor. \nTHE COURT: Now, I see that someone is on the \ntelephone? \nMR. SCOTT: Yes, Your Honor, that's one of my \nfolks. \nTHE COURT: That's okay. I just wasn't sure \nwho, but I knew someone was appearing by phone \ntoday. \nMR. SCOTT: Yes, Your Honor \nTHE COURT: And my friend, Diego, here will be \ntaking this chair. This is \"Bring Your Kid to Work \nWeek,\" but since my kid is probably trying a case \n0 ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203825\n", "char_count": 1195}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n4 \nright now, I decide that he's probably working \nanyway. Now, let me see \nMR. SCOTT: Your Honor, from my firm, Steve \nSafra is appearing by telephone from Cole, Scott, \nKissane. \nTHE COURT: I'm going to put him on the line in \na moment. \nMR. SCOTT: Thanks, Your Honor. \nTHE COURT: Good morning. Can you hear me? \nHello? Can you hear me? \nMR. SAFRA: Good morning, Your Honor, yes, \nthank you. \nTHE COURT: For the record, counsel, if you \ncould please tell us your name? \nMR. SAFRA: Steven Safra and I work with Tom \nScott and I'm available if he needs assistance, but \nI'm not lead today. \nTHE COURT: Okay, that's very good. Thank you. \nMr. Safra, you may have some difficulty in hearing \nthose individuals that are not real close to the \ntelephone today because our equipment doesn't work \nvery well. \nMR. SAFRA: Okay, Your Honor. \nTHE COURT: Just let us know if it's a problem \nand if it is a problem and if it's necessary for the \n°ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203826\n", "char_count": 1145}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n5 \ngentleman to hear everything, then we'll have to ask \nyou to come a little closer to the telephone. \nMR. SAFRA: I appreciate that, Your Honor. \nTHE COURT: Sure, sure. \nNow, we have two motions to hear this morning \nPlaintiffs' Motion to Compel, as well as the \nDefendant's Motion, as it relates to depositions. \nMR. SCOTT: That's correct. \nMR. SCAROLA: Yes, Judge. \nTHE COURT: So which one do you gentlemen want \nto do first? \nMR. SCOTT: I think, the depositions, Your \nHonor. \nMR. SCAROLA: That's fine. It was the first \nfiled of the motions, Your Honor, so I don't have \nany problem dealing with it in that order. \nTHE COURT: Okay. That's fine, thank you. \nMR. SCOTT: Judge, do you prefer that we each \naddress you from here or should be use the podium up \nthere? \nTHE COURT: Oh, just make yourself comfortable. \nMR. SCOTT: Okay. Your Honor, as you know, we \ngave the Court a book on all of the pleadings and \nthings. Has the court had an opportunity yet to \nlook at that? \nOESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203827\n", "char_count": 1189}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n6 \nTHE COURT: I have reviewed the motions. I've \nactually reviewed everything that's been filed, but \nI haven't reviewed the book yet. \nMR. SCOTT: Okay \nWell Your Honor, the first \nmotion is really \nTHE COURT: Plus, I'm going to reserve ruling \nor at least I'll likely reserve. \nMR. SCOTT: On the both motions? \nTHE COURT: Probably. \nMR. SCOTT: Okay. Judge, the first motion \nthat's up for hearing is actually our Motion to \nCompel the deposition of Mr. Paul Cassell and a \nthird-party witness, the Jane Doe witness, prior to \nthe deposition of my client, Mr. Alan Dershowitz. \nAnd the factual background around it, is that \nthis case was filed on June 6. Then on June 7 --\noh, I mean on January 6 -- and on January 7 Mr. \nScarola sent me an e-mail and asked if I'd accept \nservice. I did it one day later, on January 7. \nThen on the 9 of January, Your Honor, he sent \nme a Notice of Taking Deposition of my client, Mr. \nAlan Dershowitz. On that same day we sent Notices \nof Taking Deposition of his client, Mr. Cassell and \nalso of the Jane Doe third-party witness. \nYour Honor, I might point out to you that the \n0 ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEP0 (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203828\n", "char_count": 1326}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n7 \nCourt has appointed a commissioner and she has been \nserved with a deposition -- with a subpoena and a \nlawyer representing her has filed a Notice of \nQuashing that, which is going to have to be heard by \nthe Court. \nTHE COURT: Okay. Now, I didn't read that. \nMR. SCAROLA: Yes, that actually just happened, \nYour Honor. \nTHE COURT: Because I recall signing -- I don't \nknow if it was electronically or otherwise, but I do \nrecall signing an order -- Colorado, I think. \nMR. SCAROLA: Yes, Colorado, it is. \nMR. SCOTT: Colorado it is. So Judge, the issue \nis the following: Mr. Scarola says that, \"I, by \njust a matter of an hour or two, and within the \nthree days, noticed your client first and so your \nclient should go first.\" \nOur position is twofold, Your Honor. Number \none, that the rule does not contemplate that, Rule \n1.310, and the reading of that rule -- and I'm going \nto paraphrase it, Your Honor. It's actually in \nfront of you. I'm not going to read it all, but the \nway that I paraphrase it, that rule 1.310 provides \nthat a Plaintiff may only notice a Defendant for \ndeposition within thirty days after service of \n°ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203829\n", "char_count": 1344}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n8 \nprocess, if the Defendant has otherwise initiated \ndiscovery, which we had not done yet, or is about to \ngo out of the state and thus be unavailable for \ndeposition, which is not in this case, applicable, \nas he is a resident of Miami Beach. \nSo Your Honor, Mr. Scarola and I actually have \na different interpretation of the rule. I will tell \nyou, Judge, that I have researched it and I spoke to \nJack and Jack has researched it and we cannot find a \ndirect case actually interpreting that particular \nrule. \nTHE COURT: There isn't -- well, I haven't \nfound it either. \nMR. SCAROLA: So now that's three of us. \nMR. SCOTT: Well, it comes down to a question \nof how you interpret it, Judge? I think it says \nthat a Plaintiff may only notice -- and that means a \nNotice of Deposition for depositions within thirty \ndays after service of process. \nAnd the way that we interpret that rule, Judge, \nis that he has to wait thirty days after we respond \nin order to file it. I think that Mr. Scarola's \ninterpretation is, \"No, I don't need to do it, so \nlong as the deposition is held within thirty days.\" \nThat in a nutshell, that is what the dispute is \n°ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203830\n", "char_count": 1362}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n9 \nhere, Your Honor. Your Honor, we think that the \nintent clearly was to provide at least thirty days \nfor the Defendant, before he can be noticed for a \ndeposition, to have an opportunity to prepare, to be \nnot placed in a situation where if he were to answer \ntoday, you know, and/or the Plaintiff could notice \nhim, for example, with a Complaint and then \nliterally within ten days after responding to the \nComplaint or so, to have his deposition taken. \nI think it's a breathing space -- unless the \nDefendant, himself or herself, initiates that. And \nI think it just makes sense that that's the correct \ninterpretation of the rule. Otherwise the Plaintiff \nwould always practically have the first opportunity \nto take the deposition and the whole thing would be \nmoot. \nBut Judge it's your interpretation and you're \ngoing to do it the way you think it's done. \nTHE COURT: I was hoping one of you would come \nup with a case, but I couldn't find one. \nMR. SCOTT: No, no, Your Honor, and I really \ntried and Mr. Scarola tried too. We have a second \nposition too, Judge, which is this. We think that \nno matter how the rule is interpreted, that you have \nthe inherent discretion under Rule 1.280(c) to let \nOESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203831\n", "char_count": 1420}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n10 \nthe Defendant -- I mean to let the Plaintiff go \nfirst and the Defense go secondly. \nHere, you know, the Defendant did not initiate \ndiscovery and here we think that where the Plaintiff \nhas made the accusation of the defamation, where the \nPlaintiffs' client, Jane Doe, the third, is also the \naccuser, that the Defendant is really entitled to \nknow before he has to give a deposition -- the \nDefendant is entitled to know when it is that these \npurportedly acts of misconduct occurred, to feel out \nwhat their position is, especially when they took \nsuch prompt action, within three days, and to have \nthose depositions taken before he, the Defendant, is \nplaced in that position of having to respond. \nI think this is necessary in order to narrow \nthe issues and in order to narrow the scope of the \ndeposition and things of that nature. I would also \nsay to you, Judge, in this case in particular, the \nDefendant is a public figure and he has been fifty \nyears in the community as a leading lawyer and he \nshould not be subject to deposition of this nature \nwithout at least having had the opportunity to hear \nwhat the accusers have to say. \nSo Judge, it's almost like actually flipping \nthe burden of proof, so we think that this situation \nOESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203832\n", "char_count": 1461}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n11 \nis one where, you know, from an equitable standpoint \nthat it should be the Plaintiff first, and then the \nDefendant second. \nJudge, I found one case which I provided to Mr. \nScarola earlier. Just yesterday, I actually went \ndown to the law library and it's been a long time \nsince I did that one -- and I found a case -- a case \ncalled Klein vs. Lancer. It's a 2nd District case, \nYour Honor. May I approach? \nTHE COURT: Sure, of course. Thank you, very \nmuch. \nMR. SCOTT: Yes, Your Honor. \n(Handing) \nThis is a case in which a -- it was actually a \nslander suit, just like this one. It's not a long \nopinion, but basically, in this case the judge ruled \nthat the Plaintiff's deposition had to go before the \nDefense's deposition and the Plaintiff took a cert \npetition to the Court on it -- and from a slander \naccusation. And the court said, \"The trial judge \ndid not abuse the discretion granted to him by a \nFlorida Rule of Civil Procedure 1.380(a)2 when he \nlimited Petitioner's ability to proceed in deposing \nRespondent. Because that is so, there was no \ndeparture from the requirements of law.\" \nOESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203833\n", "char_count": 1319}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n12 \nTHE COURT: Okay. \nMR. SCOTT: So here's a case where, clearly, \nthis trial judge in this case, back in 1983 in the \n2nd District agreed with this -- made the Plaintiff \ngo first and the Defendant afterwards. I provide \nthat just to show the Court that that's the closest \ncase that I could get on this type of an issue, Your \nHonor. \nTHE COURT: Well, I've actually had the very \nsame issue before. \nMR. SCOTT: So Judge, I would also say one \nthing, and I don't know if you have yet had an \nopportunity, but when this case was first started \nMR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. I'm very sorry to \ninterrupt, Your Honor, but I'm really a little bit \nconcerned that we have a half hour set aside for two \nmotions today and a significant portion of that time \nhas already been used by Mr. Scott. \nMR. SCOTT: I guess, please, give me three more \nminutes, Judge? \nTHE COURT: Sure \nGo ahead. \nMR. SCOTT: I apologize. When this Complaint \nwas filed, in paragraph 17 -- and I think that this \nis very important for the Court -- paragraph 17 of \nthe Complaint says, \"Immediately following the \nOESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203834\n", "char_count": 1285}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n13 \nfiling of what Dershowitz knew to be an entirely \nproper and well founded pleading, Dershowitz \ninitiated a massive public media assault on Mr. \nEdwards and Mr. Cassell.\" \nI bring this to your attention because, Judge, \nthe truth is that they initiated that accusation in \nthe case before Judge Marra and in that particular \nlitigation, they filed a Motion to Intervene. \nTHE COURT: Right. \nMR. SCOTT: And in the course of that Motion to \nIntervene they blasted not only Mr. Dershowitz, my \nclient, mostly, but they also blasted Prince Andrew; \nthey blasted the President of the United States, all \nof which was totally unnecessary to that litigation. \nAnd it was that fact -- that fact that led to \nmy client responding publicly, because he had been a \npublic figure for fifty years, in order to defend \nhimself. This week -- this week Judge Marra entered \nan order in which -- and I'm going to quote from it \nbecause I think it has a lot of relevance -- and I \nhave a copy for the Court. \nTHE COURT: I've read the news report, but not \nthe order. \nMR. SCOTT: Yes, and I have a blowup of certain \nportions of it, which I think it's highly relevant \n0 ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203835\n", "char_count": 1365}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n14 \nto this case. \n(Handing.) \nTHE COURT: Thank you. \nMR. SCAROLA: I'm sorry, but are there copies \navailable? \nMR. SCOTT: I sure do, buddy. I wasn't going \nto forget you. \nMR. SCAROLA: I wouldn't let you. \nMR. SCOTT: You and I have had too many battles \nin the past. \n(Handing) \nMR. SCAROLA: Thanks. \nMR. SCOTT: Judge, in that order I highlighted \nthree portions and I'm only going to read now from \ntwo. What the judge did was to, basically, strike \nevery accusation and sealed it, involving my client \nand all of the things, saying that it was completely \nunnecessary. It was not required and, in effect, he \nwas saying -- and denying the Plaintiffs that -- Mr. \nCassell's Motion to Intervene. I think that Mr. \nScarola was actually a part of that case? \nAnd Your Honor, it's really important to see \nthat what Judge Marra, who by the way is a very \nconservative excellent judge, who has had this case \nfor eight years now, and has ruled constantly for \nOESQUIRE \n800.211.DEP0 (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203836\n", "char_count": 1167}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n15 \nthe victims in this case on major motions -- \"at \nthis juncture in the proceedings these lurid details \nare unnecessary to the determination of whether Jane \nDoe and Jane Doe 4 should be permitted to join the \nPlaintiffs' claim that the government violated the \nrights under the Crime Victim Protections Act. The \nfactual details regarding with whom and where Jane \nDoe engaged in sexual activities are immaterial and \nimpertinent to the central claim, that is, that they \nwere known victims of Mr. Epstein and the government \nowed to the CVRA duties, especially considering that \nthese details involved non-parties who are not \nrelated to the government's actions. These \nunnecessary details shall be stricken.\" \nTHE COURT: Okay. \nMR. SCOTT: And the third one -- the second \npage is just the ruling. On the third one I gave \nyou it says, \"Regarding the declarations in support\" \n-- no, that's not the one I want. \n(Perusing document.) \nOkay. Here it is now. The second one, Judge, \nis where it says, \"As mentioned Mr. Dershowitz had \nmoved to intervene in that case to clear his name \nafter these accusations were made.\" Judge Marra \nsaid, \"As mentioned, Mr. Dershowitz moves to \n0 ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203837\n", "char_count": 1396}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n16 \nintervene for the limited purposes of moving to \nstrike the outrageous and impertinent allegations \nmade against him and requesting a show cause order \nto take to the attorneys that have made them. \n\"As the court has taken it upon itself to \nstrike the impertinent factual details from the Rule \n21 motion and the related filings, the Court \nconcludes that Mr. Dershowitz's intervention in this \ncase is unnecessary. Accordingly, the Motion to \nIntervene will be denied. Regarding whether a show \ncause order should issue against the attorneys\" --\nwhich Mr. Dershowitz had requested -- \"the Court \nfinds that its actions of striking these lurid \ndetails from Petitioner's submissions is sanctions \nenough -- sanctions -- sanctions against the \nlawyers. \n\"However, the Court cautions that all counsel \nare subject to Rule 11's mandate that all \nsubmissions be presented for a proper purpose and a \nfactual contention have evidentiary support and that \nthe Court may, on its own, strike from the pleadings \nany redundant, impertinent or any scandalous \nproceedings.\" \nTHE COURT: I do have one question? \nMR. SCOTT: Yes, Your Honor? \n0 ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203838\n", "char_count": 1346}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n17 \nTHE COURT: I really don't know what, if \nanything, that would have to do with this cause of \naction? It's quite a unique cause of action in a \nFederal suit, as I understand it? And the striking \nof those accusations, which is understandable to me, \nnotwithstanding the fact that I'm not really very \nfamiliar with that cause of action -- I'm not sure \nwhat, if anything, that would have to do with this? \nMR. SCOTT: Well, I think, Judge, that what I'm \ntrying to say to you is that it was really those \naccusations that led to this whole lawsuit, because \nhe -- when they did that, Mr. Dershowitz, being a \npublic figure had a complete weekend nightmare of a \ndeplete publicity nightmare, with people calling him \nand things like that. And he responded by defending \nhimself and trying to do it. \nAnd so now if these things hadn't been put in \nthere by the same lawyers who are now suing my \nclient, we wouldn't even be here today. And I think \nthat that just goes to show you -- and I bring that \nto your attention, Judge -- that the equity argument \nthat I did, that at least given this type of ruling \nby such a conservative judge -- and you know, I've \nnever actually seen a judge strike things sui sponte \nlike that and just dismiss a pleading like that. It \n0 ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203839\n", "char_count": 1479}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n18 \njust shows you that it's the right thing to do in \nthis case, to have Mr. Cassell and to have the \naccuser, his client, Jane Doe 3, be deposed before \nmy client, Mr. Dershowitz, is deposed. Thank you, \nYour Honor. \nTHE COURT: Thank you, very much, counsel. \nMR. SCAROLA: Your Honor, let me begin first by \nacknowledging that the Court has discretion to order \ndiscovery. \nMR. SCAROLA: There is no question about the \nfact that whatever ruling Your Honor were to decide \nwas appropriate with regard to the ordering of the \ndiscovery is not going to be disturbed except under \nextraordinary circumstances, by any appellate court \nand I would assure Your Honor, that that's not a \nmatter that we would consider subject to an appeal. \nThere are very good reasons why the order of \ndiscovery here should be the order in which the \ndiscovery has been noticed. Although Mr. Scott has \nrepeatedly paraphrased Rule 1.1.310 as prohibiting \nthe noticing of a deposition within thirty days of \nthe service of a Complaint, that's simply not what \nthe rule says. I will quote directly. \"Leave of \nCourt granted with or without notice, must be \nobtained only if the Plaintiff seeks to take a \nOESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203840\n", "char_count": 1392}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n19 \ndeposition within thirty days after service of the \nprocess.\" \nSo Your Honora, a deposition cannot be taken \nwithin thirty days. A deposition may be noticed \nprior to thirty days, but it may not be taken under \nthe terms of the rules, within thirty days, Your \nHonor. Service was obtained by consent on January \n7. The earliest, under the rule, that we would have \nbeen able to take Professor Dershowitz's deposition \nwould have been February 6. \nWe sent a Notice of Deposition to depose Mr. \nDershowitz well outside the thirty day period of \ntime, on February 25, and accompanying that notice \nwas a letter. And that letter is, in fact, attached \nto the pleadings that Your Honor has already seen. \nAnd what that letter said was, \"If this date is \nnot convenient, we are willing to move it to a more \nconvenient time. We move it up or we'll move it \nback.\" And in light of Mr. Dershowitz's repeated \npublic proclamations that he's extremely anxious to \nbe able to be deposed to be able to vindicate \nhimself, we will do it as early as you want to do \nit.\" \nNow, during this period of time Mr. Dershowitz \nwas taking every opportunity that he possibly could \nOESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203841\n", "char_count": 1373}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n20 \nto appear before every audience that would have him, \nYour Honor, to defame Mr. Bradley Edwards and Mr. \nPaul Cassell. And I want to be sure than Your Honor \nis really focused on what this defamation case is \nreally all about. \nThis defamation case is about two lawyers who \nare working, pro bono, to vindicate the rights of \nmore than forty women who were sexually abused and \ntrafficked by Mr, Jeffrey Epstein over an extended \nperiod of time. And Mr. Jeffrey Epstein, through \nthe work of Alan Dershowitz, had obtained an \nextraordinary agreement from the federal government. \nThat extraordinary agreement said, that, \"If you \nplead guilty to one state court claim and serve, \nbasically, one year on house arrest, we will grant \nyou immunity from any federal prosecution and we \nwill grant all of your co-conspirators immunity from \nany federal prosecution, as well.\" \nYour Honor, that deal, if entered into, without \nthe consultation nor with an opportunity to be heard \nby any of the victims of Jeffrey Epstein, in spite \nof federal law provisions that expressly state that \nthose victims must be consulted and they must have \nan opportunity to inform the Court as to their own \nposition with regard to a plea bargain. \n°ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203842\n", "char_count": 1439}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n21 \nThe position that the federal government took \nwas there was no indictment the and Crime Victims \nRights Act is actually only triggered by the filing \nof an indictment. Judge Marra has absolutely \nrejected that position and the 11th Circuit Court \nhas also rejected that position. And there is a lot \nof active discovery in that case. \nNow, Jane Doe number 3, she moves to intervene \nthrough Bradley Edwards and Paul Cassell, her two \npro bono lawyers. This action has nothing to do \nwith monetary damages. It is simply an action about \na right to be heard, to set aside an extraordinary \nplea deal, and to have an opportunity to be heard \nbefore those claims are disposed of. \nTHE COURT: I was a little confused with the \nfacts in the state case? If I recall, there was a \nplea to one count and an eighteen months sentence or \nsomething like that. \nMR. SCOTT: Yes. \nMR. SCAROLA: I think eighteen months is right, \nYour Honor. He actually served --\nTHE COURT: Well, he served about eighty-five \npercent? \nMR. SCAROLA: Yes, sir. \nMR. SCOTT: It was a state court pleading. \n0 ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203843\n", "char_count": 1287}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n22 \nThey had cases in both the federal and the state. \nThey took it to the state and they pled guilty there \nand he got an eighteen months sentence. \nMR. SCAROLA: And it was served mostly on house \narrest. \nTHE COURT: Okay. \nMR. SCAROLA: So in light of the scope of the \nactivities that were engaged in, on the number of \nvictims, and extraordinary plea deal, so Jane Doe \nnumber 3 moves to intervene. Allegations are made \nin a sworn Affidavit to support the intervention and \nbasically what Judge Marra has said is that, \"The \noriginal pleading that was filed in this case \naddresses the concerns of all of the victims of \nJeffrey Epstein. We don't need to have Jane Doe \nnumber 3 and Jane Doe number 4 moved into this case \nbecause their rights are already being protected \nunder the terms of the pleading that currently now \nexists.\" \nAnd then he also says, here in a section that's \nincluded in one of these quotes that's been provided \nto Your Honor, \"Jane Doe number 3 is now free to \nreassert these factual details through the proper \nevidentiary proof should Petitioners demonstrate a \ngood faith basis for believing that such details are \n°ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203844\n", "char_count": 1359}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n23 \npertinent to a matter presented for the Court's \nconsideration.\" \nOne of the matters being presented for the \nCourt's consideration is the extent to which Alan \nDershowitz was a co-conspirator of Jeffrey Epstein \nand negotiated an unusual plea deal that immunized \nall co-conspirators. So it remains to be seen, the \nextent to which those representations do or do not \nbecome relevant in the federal action, but that \nreally has nothing to do with the case before this \nCourt. \nBecause whether Jane Doe number 3 ultimately is \nproven, if she ever is, because this may well be a \n\"he said - she said\" type circumstance, where Alan \nDershowitz says, \"I never ever had sex with this \nyoung woman\" and she says, \"Oh, yes, you did\" and \nit's never actually proved conclusively one way or \nanother -- but that's really not the heart of this \ndefamation case. \nTHE COURT: Right. \nMR. SCAROLA: What Alan Dershowitz was saying \nrepeatedly in front of every audience that he could \ngather and because of the profile that he enjoys, \nthat meant every national morning news show, every \nmidday national news show, every afternoon national \nOESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203845\n", "char_count": 1342}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n24 \nnews show, every evening national news show, every \nlate night national news show -- just about every \nsingle talk show he could get on, he said over and \nover again, repeatedly, \"These lawyers knew at the \ntime that this Affidavit was filed, that it was \nfalse. They fabricated it together with Jane Doe \nnumber 3. They did it to just enhance their own \nreputations and they did it for selfish, economic \nreasons. They all lied. They knew that they were \nlying at the time and they engaged in conduct that \nrequires their disbarment.\" \nSo the issue is not whether Jane Doe number 3 \nlied. The issue is whether Paul Cassell and Bradley \nEdwards were liars? Whether they knew at the time \nof filing of the this pleading that it was actually \nfalse? That's the focus of this issue in this case. \nSo when the Court is making a determination, \nYour Honor, as to who ought to be deposed first, \nwhen Mr. Dershowitz is repeatedly making these \nassertions, when his counsel is placed on notice, \n\"Please, stop your client, so that this litigation \ncan be conducted in a reasonable fashion\" and Mr. \nDershowitz continues to defame Mr. Cassell and Mr. \nEdwards on every occasion that he possibly can, I \nthink it's very reasonable for us to say, \"If you \nC ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203846\n", "char_count": 1461}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n25 \nsay these folks are liars and if you say that you \nhave already gathered the proof that they are liars, \nthen we ought to find out what export he has for \nthat. But let me move on from there, if I could? \nTHE COURT: Sure, but we do have another motion \nand the good news is one of my hearings was canceled \nso actually do we have a little bit more time, but \nnot a lot. \nMR. SCAROLA: Thank you, Your Honor. I'll be \nbrief about this. \nTHE COURT: That's fine. \nMR. SCAROLA: One of the conditions -- one of \nthe predicates that they want the Court to adopt \nbefore Mr. Dershowitz is deposed -- they don't want \nMr. Dershowitz to be deposed before Jane Doe number \n3 is deposed. However, Jane Doe number 3 is living \nin Colorado. Jane Doe number 3 has been served with \na subpoena and there has already been a Motion for a \nProtective Order that's been filed with regard to \nthat deposition including or particularly addressing \nthe scope of the duces tecum that's attached to that \nNotice of Deposition. \nShe is actually represented by separate private \ncounsel. Separate counsel has offered to have those \nissues resolved by this Court, but that offer has \nOESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203847\n", "char_count": 1370}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n26 \nnot been accepted by opposing counsel yet. We don't \neven know when or how those issues are going to be \nresolved. Ordinarily, absent a stipulation, they \nwould have to be resolved in Colorado. Again, we \nreally don't even know how long it's going to take \nto resolve those issues and the last thing we want \nto do is to have Mr. Dershowitz's deposition being \ncontingent upon an undeterminable delay relating to \nJane Doe number 3. \nI will tell you, quite frankly, whether Paul \nCassell is deposed before or after Alan Dershowitz \nis of less significance to me, except that he is \nalso out-of-state and that will also require some \ncoordination. And I want to get Alan Dershowitz's \ndeposition taken as quickly as possible, because I \nam hoping that the taking of his deposition will \nslow down the juggernaut of defamation, the ongoing \nassault that continues on almost a daily basis, \nuntil such time as he is placed under oath and is \nactually confronted with regard to the accusations \nthat he has made. \nSo for those reasons, Your Honor, because I \nbelieve that the rule clearly allows us to take a \ndeposition, noticed before thirty days, but after \nthirty days, because our notice went first, because \nOESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203848\n", "char_count": 1424}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n27 \nthe focus of this case is really on Mr. Dershowitz's \nhaving made statements that cannot be supported \nabout the Plaintiffs having been knowing and been \nintentional liars and co-conspirators, we would ask, \nrespectfully, that we get to depose Mr. Dershowitz \nas soon as possible. I'm sorry I've taken so long, \nYour Honor. \nTHE COURT: That's okay. Mr. Scott? \nMR. SCOTT: One minute. Judge, in the federal \ncourt action -- I think that it's been pending for \neight years -- eight years later these -- through \nMr. Cassell's law firm, they filed this Motion to \nIntervene. And to repeat, it contains accusations \nthat are totally irrelevant against my client --\ntotally irrelevant, not needed for any reason, other \nthan to just make my client look bad and to gather \npublicity by filing that. \nTHE COURT: Well, that's what the federal \njudge, essentially, ruled. \nMR. SCOTT: Absolutely, that's what he ruled. \nAll I'm saying is that, put into that position, a \npublic figure like Mr. Dershowitz, and faced on a \nweekend with phone calls coming out of nowhere -- he \ndidn't even know that the darn thing had been filed. \nAnd he responded the only way he did, by denying it \n0 ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203849\n", "char_count": 1388}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n28 \nbecause he had to, as a public figure placed into \nthat position. That's why it was so important to do \nit and to continue to do so when these issues come \nup. I mean, he's defending his name of fifty years. \nThank you, Your Honor. \nTHE COURT: Well, like I said earlier, I'm \ngoing to reserve and I'll let you know, probably, \nMonday or Tuesday, but we do have a motion and some \nargument on that? \nMR. SCAROLA: Yes, thank you, very much, Your \nHonor. This is Plaintiff's Motion to Compel their \nProduction of Documents. \nTHE COURT: Go ahead. \nMR. SCAROLA: As the motion itself reflects, we \nserved a Notice to Produce on the Defense and after \nmore than forty-five days have elapsed, Your Honor, \nwe still had not received any discovery. There was \nan exchange of communications with opposing counsel. \nThe Response that we got to the Request to Produce \nhas some very basic flaws to it. First of all, it \nraises some general objections and it says that all \ntheir Responses are made subject to those general \nobjections. \nThe result of that is we don't know whether we \nare getting everything or if we are not getting \nOESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203850\n", "char_count": 1335}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n29 \neverything, because the objections are not at all \nspecifically stated with regard to our individual \nrequests. \nIt also says that whatever production that is \ngoing to be made, is going to be made subject to \nprivilege. However, there is no privilege log. We \ndon't know whether we are getting everything or \nwhether some documents are being withheld on the \nbasis of privilege? \nIt also says that production will be made, but \nwith no indication as to actually when production \nwill be made. I called these defects to opposing \ncounsel's attention weeks ago, and I said that an \nindefinite Response that, \"Production will be made \nsometime in the future,\" when the rules require \nproduction to be made within thirty days after the \nrequest is made, is absolutely inadequate. I said, \n\"Can you tell me when you have the documents ready \nand I'll come and get them? I didn't get a Response \nto that request. \nNinety days elapsed after the filing of the \nRequest to Produce and just last night, on the eve \nof this hearing, we got a whole bunch of documents \nthat I have not had a chance to review in their \nentirety. They are not, as far as I can tell, \n°ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203851\n", "char_count": 1368}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n30 \ndivided on a request by request basis, and they \nconsist almost entirely of pleadings filed in the \nCrime Victims Rights Act case, newspaper articles \nand yet the substantive requests that were made \nstill have not been responded to. I'm told by Mr. \nScott that his client is still in the process of \ngathering the documents. \nYour Honor, I am entitled to production within \nthirty days. I certainly should have had production \nwithin forty-five days and I certainly should have \nhad the production now within ninety days and yet I \nstill don't have even a representation, as to when \nthe full production will be made of the substantive \nmatters that have been requested, Judge. \nThese requests are very specific and they are \ntied into the statements that Mr. Alan Dershowitz, \nhimself, has publicly made. Those statements are \nidentified in the Request to Produce. He talks \nabout specific documents which he claims that he was \nable to gather within one hour of these accusations \nhaving been made against him, which he says actually \n\"conclusively prove\" his innocence. \nNow, at the very least, I ought to have the \nsame documents that he said took him just an hour to \ngather after the allegations were made, but I still \n0 ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203852\n", "char_count": 1442}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n31 \nhaven't gotten any of those. I haven't gotten any \nof his travel records. I haven't gotten the \nairplane manifests. There's a statement that he \ndoes not have custody of the airplane manifest, but \nis made also subject to this general privilege \nobjection. Now, I don't know whether he has them or \nif he doesn't have them because I have no privilege \nlog. These Responses are patently inadequate, \nJudge, and in light of the efforts that have been \nmade to try to get this discovery and to work these \nmatters out, and I assure you, I don't blame Mr. \nScott personally. I'm sure that he has been doing \neverything that he can to get this information from \nhis client, but unless and until an order is \nactually entered establishing a very short deadline \nand unless and until sanctions are imposed so that \nMr. Dershowitz is aware of the fact that he going to \nhave to begin to pay for his extraordinary disregard \nof his discovery obligations, these problems are all \ngoing to continue. \nTHE COURT: I was under the impression, as it \nrelates, for instance, to the flight manifest, that \nhe responded that he actually did not have those \ndocuments? \nMR. SCAROLA: He does say that he doesn't have \n0 ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEP0 (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203853\n", "char_count": 1413}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n32 \nthem, Your Honor, but that's subject to the general \nobjections, and the general objections would allow \nhim to not produce them. \nTHE COURT: Okay. \nMR. SCAROLA: So that's the difficulty that we \nhave in that regard and he also claims a privilege \nwith regard to that Response. \nTHE COURT: I'm not sure if he claims privilege \nbut we'll get there. \nMR. SCAROLA: All right, Your Honor. That \nbasically conclude my presentation, Your Honor. \nTHE COURT: Okay. \nMR. SCAROLA: I don't think that I need to go \nthrough these individually? The Responses are \nreally boilerplate -- the same thing over and again. \nI will produce without any deadline. I'm producing \nsubject to all my privilege claims and he is also \nqualifying it by saying that, \"These things are not \ncurrently in my possession.\" Well, Your Honor, \nthat's not really a satisfaction of his discovery \nobligation. \nTHE COURT: Thank you. \nMR. SCAROLA: Thank you, sir. \nMR. SCOTT: Judge, let just start off by saying \nthat we have not received one document from the \n0 ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEP0 (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203854\n", "char_count": 1238}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n33 \nPlaintiffs, just -- at all. Also basically their \nposition up until -- just what I heard Mr. Scarola \nsay -- \"We are not producing anything unless you \nare.\" So I want you to understand nobody has any \ndocuments. We were actually the first one to \nproduce and we produced documents yesterday. Okay? \nNumber two, Judge, in our Response we clearly \nsay -- nobody is hiding anything. \"We will produce \ndocuments related to the false and irrelevant \nallegations asserted by the Plaintiffs on behalf of \nJane Doe.\" \nWe say, \"We will produce documents of the \nfailure by the Plaintiffs to investigate carefully \nthe allegations about the Defendant before \nasserting.\" We also said that we would prove the \nDefendant's statements identified in the Complaint \nthat are the subject. Almost -- if you look through \nthe Responses, we say that, but what our problem is, \nis the scope of the entire thing. There is no \nlimitation, whatsoever, in the Request to Produce as \nto time -- nothing. I mean, this thing goes back \neight, ten, twelve years -- there's nothing. \nWe said to them, \"Okay. Why don't we do this? \nWe'll produce in a time frame of the events \nconcerning the accusations of slander. We will \n0 ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203855\n", "char_count": 1411}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n34 \nproduce all of the events, documents concerning the \nsix accusations that Jane Doe says she had sex with, \nwhich is the relevant frame here, because we don't \nhave any idea as we sit here today -- we have no \nclue as to when any of these accusations about my \nclient having sexually assaulted Jane Doe number 3 \never occurred. So he has to go back and produce ten \nor fifteen years worth of documents? I mean, the \nlitigation has only been going on for eight --\nTHE COURT: Counsel, do you think there's a \nreasonable limitation, timewise? \nMR. SCAROLA: Your Honor, the limitation is \nactually built into the requests. If you look at \nthe requests they are all tied into Mr. Dershowitz's \nown statements. He is the one saying, \"I have \ndocuments that prove this.\" And everyone of these \nrequests or almost all of the requests ask him, \n\"Which documents were you referring to in your \nAffidavit?\" \nTHE COURT: Okay. \nMR. SCAROLA: Those are the documents so the \nlimitation is built in and that's all. \nTHE COURT: Go ahead. \nMR. SCOTT: You're asking good questions, \nJudge. I don't mind. I prefer that. \nOESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203856\n", "char_count": 1314}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n35 \nTHE COURT: Go ahead. \nMR. SCOTT: But Judge, what I was saying is \nthere really is no limitation here. This woman has \naccused my client of six things but she can't even \ngive us the date, and what concerns me is that if we \ndon't even know when the date is, or when the events \nare, then how do we produce the documents relevant \nto it? Tell us when these things occurred? Give us \na time frame, whatever it is -- 2004 to 2006? This \nis when it occurred. These are when the events are, \nso he can do it. But they want travel logs and \neverything. I mean, it's ridiculous for him to go \nthrough all this when we don't even know when these \nevents allegedly occurred? \nSo we need some kind of -- that's why I asked \nthe Court, tell us -- have them tell us when these \nevents occurred? Otherwise, they're just going to \ngo around the corner and depose my client and then \nthey're going to say, \"Oh, based on what we've just \nlearned from you, this is when that happened.\" \nAnd that really just goes back to my earlier \nargument, Your Honor. \nTHE COURT: Let me ask you this --\nMR. SCOTT: I just want to say one thing more, \nJudge. My client, Alan Dershowitz is a very public \nOESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203857\n", "char_count": 1386}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n36 \nfigure. He has even had death threats over this and \nall types of things. He's concerned. He is very \nconcerned about producing documents on a basis like \nthis so I want to make sure that that is absolutely \nin there. \nNow, as far as the production of documents is \nconcerned, we filed an Affidavit. I don't know \nwhether the Court read it but you've got to read the \nAffidavit, Your Honor. \nTHE COURT: If it was attached to your Response \nthen I did? \nMR. SCOTT: Yes, it's in there. It's attached, \nYour Honor. \nMS. BORJA: I've got an extra copy. \nMR. SCOTT: Oh, you've got an extra copy? \nMS. BORJA: Yes, I've got an extra one. \n(Handing) \nMR. SCOTT: This is what he says, under oath. \n(Handing.) \nTHE COURT: Thank you. \nMR. SCOTT: And we have two problems. Okay? \nNumber one is when he moved down here in 2013 -- he \nleft --\nTHE COURT: (Perusing document.) \nI apologize. Just for the record, I didn't see \n0 ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEP0 (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203858\n", "char_count": 1124}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n37 \nthis before. \nMR. SCOTT: Judge, please, there are a lot of. \ndocuments, and you've got a lot of cases. That's \nwhy I brought these things with me. Basically, he \nis, right today -- when he moved down here he left \nall of his documents up in Massachusetts in his old \nhome. He has not had an opportunity -- he is up \nthere, literally today, trying to go through and \ntrying to find the documents in order to produce \nthem. But the bigger problem is this and the reason \nthat Ms. Borja is here -- she's co-counsel -- is \nHarvard University. Some documents are tied up in \nthe computers. He doesn't have a computer. See, \nthe computers are all at Harvard Unviersity and we \nhired a company to try to go into those computers, \nto get the documents. \nWe've been negotiating with Harvard to do it, \nbut there has not been any agreement yet on that \nbasis. It's by a third-party, not by us, and we are \ncontinuing to try to work that out so that we can \nget into the computers and get the documents from \nHarvard. And we've even hired an IT company to do \nthat, but they have not been very forthcoming. \nThere has not yet been an agreement and it's not \nunder our control, but we are making every effort to \n0 ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203859\n", "char_count": 1416}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n38 \ndo that. \nThere's one other thing, Judge. They're seeking \na lot of documents if you look at the Request to \nProduce -- many things are not related to this case, \nbut relate to the underlying federal litigation, \ninvolving the original plea deal and things of that \nnature. That has no bearing, whatsoever, in this \ncase and so we think that that should be taken out. \nNow, as far as this waiver is concerned \nTHE COURT: One question? \nMR. SCOTT: Sure. \nTHE COURT: Let me just jump right in here? \nMR. SCOTT: Sure. \nTHE COURT: Do you anticipate ever having a \nprivilege log? \nMR. SCOTT: Absolutely, yes, but what we said, \nJudge, and what the case law says and if I can hand \nyou what the 4th District says -- yes, we are going \nto file a privilege log, but the cases say -- and \nthis is a 4th DCA case -- but until you decide today \nthe scope of production, then no privilege log is \nrequired. It wouldn't make sense, because how do \nyou know --\nTHE COURT: I really just didn't know if you \nanticipated one or not? \n0 ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203860\n", "char_count": 1232}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n39 \nMR. SCOTT: Absolutely, yes, and we are going \nto file the privilege log, but we couldn't do it \nuntil we got some sort of a determination on the \ntime frame of the production and also the nature of \nthe production, when it's limited, and based upon \nthat, we will then do the privilege log and that's \nexactly what the 4th DCA says. So until that's \ndecided, there's really no need for a privilege log. \nThere's no waiver. \nTHE COURT: How long do you think that it's \ngoing to take for Harvard to make their decision \nwith access? \nMR. SAFRA: I brought along the person who's \nbeen dealing with them. \nMS. BORJA: Judge, I have a call scheduled --\nwell, actually, I have had many calls with Harvard, \nwith their general counsel's office, which is the --\nthey have final say over or access to the Harvard \nUniversity documents. Their concern has to do with \nthe federal requirements for student privilege. We \nare working diligently with them. I have a call \nwith them, with their IT office, with our document \nvendor next Tuesday and I am hoping that I can get \nHarvard University's IT and their general counsel \noffice to agree to it, but I don't control them, but \nOESQUIRE \n800.211.DEP0 (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203861\n", "char_count": 1380}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n40 \nI am doing everything that I can, Your Honor. \nTHE COURT: Of course, I understand. I'm just \ntrying to get a flavor, as to the time? \nMS. BORGIA: If we can get an agreement with \nthem next week, then we will immediately have our \nvendor start pulling the electronic documents out of \nthe Harvard University system. We'll need to then \ngive access to Harvard's general counsel's office, \nso that they can then claw back any required student \ndocuments, subject to their federal privileges for \nthe students. And once Harvard University makes the \ndocuments available to us, then we can review for \nresponsiveness. We can then produce a privilege \nlog, et cetera. \nMR. SCOTT: We can do a rolling production. \nMS. BORJA: I intend to do it. We've started \nour rolling production, as counsel had mentioned, \nyesterday. He hasn't even gone through all of those \ndocuments. So we're really doing everything that we \ncan. I'm using my best efforts. I understand the \nneed to get this done and nobody wants to get it \ndone any more than I do. \nTHE COURT: All right \nI'll tell you what. \nI'm going to reserve ruling on this. Give me \nuntil -- I know I'm not going to get this done by \n°ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEP0 (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203862\n", "char_count": 1389}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n41 \nMonday, so give me until maybe Tuesday or Wednesday. \nMR. SCOTT: Judge, take a few days. I'd rather \nyou get it right. \nMR. SAFRA: Your Honor? \nTHE COURT: Yes, sir? \nMR. SCAROLA: Your Honor, just a few seconds on \na privilege log issue to, perhaps, help you out? \nTHE COURT: Sure. \nMR. SAFRA: If Your Honor was to narrow the \nscope to the six instances of the alleged times when \nthis misconduct allegedly or purportedly occurred \nand excise out any documents after the filing of \nthis defamation action and Mr. Dershowitz's legal \nrepresentation of Jeffrey Epstein related to the \nfederal action, which has nothing to do with this \ncase, then we do not anticipate privileged documents \nbut those documents are irrelevant, otherwise, and \nprivileged as to a client, and Mr. Jeffrey Epstein, \nwho would have to waive the privilege. \nMR. SCOTT: That's it for us, Judge. Thank \nyou, very much, for your time. \nTHE COURT: All right. Yes, sir? \nMR. SCAROLA: May I, like, a minute or so, \nJudge? \nTHE COURT: You can, just as soon is I finish \n0 ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203863\n", "char_count": 1252}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n42 \nup this note. \nMR. SCOTT: Jack always needs to get the last \nword in. \nMR. SCAROLA: Well, especially when it is my \nmotion. \nTHE COURT: I'm sorry. Go ahead. \nMR. SCAROLA: Oh, that's quite all right, Your \nHonor. Your Honor, I simply want to point out at \nthis point that almost everyone of these requests \nties directly to the statements that were made in \nMr. Dershowitz's Affidavit and just asks for the \ndocuments that relate to those specific statements \nby Mr. Dershowitz. I don't know how I could impose \nany greater limitation, than to say, \"Give us the \ndocuments that support what you, yourself, have \nsworn to under oath.\" \nNow, with regard to the airplane manifests, \nthat's request number eight, and the Response is, \nthe Defendant responds that he has, \"No responsive \nnon-privileged documents.\" \nTHE COURT: Right. \nMR. SCAROLA: So he is asserting a privilege \nwith regard to the manifests, but he is not telling \nus by virtue of a privilege log, what the privileged \ndocuments are. And so it is entirely improper to \n0 ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203864\n", "char_count": 1246}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n43 \nassert a privilege over non-existent documents. And \nif the documents don't exist, then he doesn't have \nto assert a privilege. And if they do exist, if he \ndoes, then he is required to provide a privilege \nlog. \nWhat the 4th DCA says is that If the Court has \nto first determine relevance, you don't have to have \na privilege log to documents that are challenged on \nthe basis of relevance. These challenges aren't \nrelevant challenges; none of them are, but yet the \nprivilege is asserted with regard to this production \nwithout any privilege log. And that's improper. \nThose privileges have been waived by failing to \nproperly assert them. Thank you, sir. \nTHE COURT: I did have one more thing I wanted \nto ask? \nMR. SCAROLA: Yes. \nTHE COURT: I know that I didn't go on-line and \nreview it this morning, but I do know through some \nconversations with my assistant, that we do have \nsomething upcoming? Is that a motion to dismiss? \nMR. SCOTT: Yes, the counter-claim. \nTHE COURT: Okay. \nMR. SCOTT: We're setting that. \nMR. SCAROLA: And we also have other discovery \n0 ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203865\n", "char_count": 1283}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n44 \ndisputes that haven't been resolved yet. \nTHE COURT: I'm sure. What? You actually have \ndiscovery disputes? Really? Oh, my. \nMR. SCOTT: I know that it's hard to believe. \nTHE COURT: Yes, ha, ha, ha. \nMR. SCOTT: Especially, on a Friday after a \nlong week. Thank you, Judge. \nTHE COURT: All right. So we'll have a hearing \non that and then I guess whatever happens with the \nColorado attorney? \nMR. SCOTT: Judge, I just want to say one more \nthing -- that we got a request last night or just \nyesterday when she filed the objection to the \nsubpoena, to consider having you hear it. I do \nbelieve that you will be the one. I just have to \nrun it through the ranks, but I just wanted to let \nyou know that it wasn't like a month ago and we \ndidn't do anything. \nTHE COURT: Oh, no, no, I understand. I just \nwanted to get the lay of the land, because some \nthings are moving slowly and some things are moving \nfaster. Let me get a copy of this Affidavit. \nMR. SAFRA: Your Honor, the Affidavit is there \nas Exhibit C to our opposition to their Motion to \nCompel. \n°ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203866\n", "char_count": 1272}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n45 \nTHE COURT: Oh, okay, because when I read that \nknew I didn't see it, at least in my copy? \nMR. SCOTT: It's one of the exhibits but you \ncould have missed it. \nMS. BORJA: There are three exhibits. \nMR. SCAROLA: Your Honor, I have two blank \norders and also envelopes. Do you want me to --\nTHE COURT: Let me explain what I usually do. \nAfter I make my decision, I indicate that to my \nassistant who then simultaneously notifies both \nsides and requests orders, so we'll do it that way. \nMR. SCOTT: Thank you, Your Honor. \nMR. SCAROLA: Thank you, Your Honor. \nTHE COURT: Have a good day everyone. Off the \nrecord. \nTHE REPORTER: We are going off the record at \n9:55 a.m. \n(Proceedings concluded at 9:55 o'clock a.m.) \n°ESQUIRE \n800.211.DEP0 (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203867\n", "char_count": 929}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01203823", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nPROCEEDINGS \nEDWARDS vs. DERSHOWITZ \nApril 10, 2015 \n46 \nCERTIFICATE OF NOTARY \nSTATE OF FLORIDA \nSS: \nCOUNTY OF BROWARD \nI, JERROLD Wm. SEGAL, Court Reporter, Notary \nPublic in and for the State of Florida at Large, do \nhereby certify that I was authorized to and did \nstenographically report the foregoing proceedings \nin the above styled cause as set forth above; that the \nforegoing pages, numbered 1 to 45 inclusive, constitute \na true and correct transcription of my shorthand \nreporting of the proceedings and the statements made by \nthe involved parties. \nI further certify that I am not an attorney nor \ncounsel of any of the parties, nor a relative, nor \nemployee of any attorney or counsel connected with the \naction, nor financially interested in the outcome of \naction. \nWITNESS my hand and official seal in the City of \nPlantation, County of Broward, State of Florida, this \n16th day of April, 2015. \nSD \nWel tlaa \nOwn pew Pa • lin \nOs en.... arm \nI-• \nPIP MINI \nPail lisp mai May ea \nJERROLD Wm. SEGAL \nCourt Reporter and Notary Public \nOESQUIRE \n800.211.DEPO (3376) \nEsquireSolutions.com \nEFTA01203868\n", "char_count": 1209}]}