{"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_count": 40, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA01191873", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA01191873.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 1 of 40\nUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT\nSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA\nCASE NO. 9:08-cv-80736-KAM\nJANE DOE #1 and JANE DOE #2,\nPetitioners,\nVS.\nUNITED STATES OF AMERICA,\nRespondent.\nPLAINTIFFS RESPONSE TO MOTION FOR\nLIMITED INTERVENTION BY ALAN M. DERSHOWITZ\nCOME NOW petitioners Jane Doe No. 1 and Jane Doe 2, as well as movants Jane Doe\nNo. 3 and Jane Doe No. 4 (\"the victims”), to respond in opposition to Mr. Dershowitz's motion\nfor limited intervention (DE 282). Dershowitz moves to intervene to strike a proffer made by\nJane Doe No. 3 of facts that support her pending motion to join this action. The Court should\ndeny the motion. Dershowitz has not established any direct interest in this Crime Victims'\nRights Act (CVRA) action that would entitle him to intervene as of right under Fed. R. Civ. P.\n24(a). Nor has he met Rule 24(b)'s standards for discretionary intervention for four reasons:\nFirst, Dershowitz has another forum in which to litigate and defend his reputational interests - a\npending defamation action regarding this very case; second, Dershowitz (and other persons Jane\nDoe No. 3 specifically alleged abused her) have not availed themselves of other opportunities to\ndefend their reputational interests; third, Dershowitz lacks any basis to strike allegations that are\ndirectly relevant to pending issues in this case; and fourth and finally, Jane Doe No. 3 attests in a\nAs promised in their motion to join (DE 280), Jane Doe No. 3 and Jane Doe No. 4 do not seek to expand\nthe number of pleadings filed in this case. If allowed to join this action, they would simply support the\npleadings already being filed by Jane Doe No. 1 and Jane Doe No. 2 - including this opposition.\n1\nEFTA01191873\n", "char_count": 1784}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 2 of 40\nsworn affidavit (attached as Exhibit 1) that all her allegations are true - an affidavit consistent\nwith compelling corroborating evidence.\nBACKGROUND AND COURSE OF PROCEEDINGS\nBecause this case has been proceeding for more than six-and-a-half years, it is useful to\nsummarize some of the events pertinent to Dershowitz's intervention motion and Jane Doe No.\n3's related and pending motion for joinder. As the Court is aware, on July 7, 2008, a young\nwoman identified as Jane Doe No. 1 filed an emergency petition to enforce her rights under the\nCrime Victims' Rights Act (CVRA), 18 U.S.C. § 3771, alleging that the Government had failed\nto provide her rights with regard to a plea arrangement it was pursuing with Jeffrey Epstein. The\nCourt rapidly held a hearing. During that hearing, victim's counsel (having previously made a\nproffer of the relevant circumstances to Government counsel) orally moved to have Jane Doe\nNo. 2 added into the case as another \"victim\" under the CVRA. Government counsel had no\nobjection to adding her to the case, apparently believing that, in light of the sexual abuse\nperpetrated against her, she met the “victim” definition in the statute. DE 15 (Tr. July 11, 2008)\nat 14.\nThe Court then instructed the parties to attempt to reach a stipulated set of facts. Over the\nnext several years, the Government took conflicting positions on whether it would stipulate to\nfacts provided by Jane Doe No. 1 and Jane Do. 2, ultimately refusing to stipulate to any facts.\nSee generally DE 225-1 at 2-4. Unable to obtain stipulations by the Government, in 2011 the\nvictims filed a summary judgment motion alleging 53 proposed undisputed facts (DE 48), along\nwith a motion to have the Court accept those facts because of the Government's failure to contest\nthem (DE 49). On September 26, 2011, the Court allowed the case to move forward. DE 99.\nThe Court, however, declined to accept victims' argum\n... [truncated, 2060 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/1 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=1]", "char_count": 2060}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 3 of 40\nbecause of the Government's failure to contest their facts, directing instead that discovery should\nproceed. Id. at 11.\nIn light of the Court's direction, on October 11, 2011, the victims filed discovery requests\nwith the Government, including requests specifically seeking information about Dershowitz,\nPrince Andrew, and others. Further efforts from the Government to avoid any discovery\nfollowed (see generally DE 225-1 at 4-5), ultimately leading to a further Court ruling in June\n2013 that the Government should produce documents. DE 189. The Government then produced\nabout 1,500 pages of irrelevant materials to the victims (DE 225-1 at 5), while simultaneously\nsubmitting 14,825 pages of relevant materials under seal to the Court. The Government claimed\nthat these pages were \"privileged\" for various reasons, attaching an abbreviated privilege log.\nJane Doe No. 1 and Jane No. 2 objected to those claims of privilege, see generally DE 225 and\nDE 265, and also to the Government's failure to specify in its privilege log the names of all the\npersons involved in the materials (DE 265 at 1-2). These issues remain pending today.³\nIn the summer of 2014, undersigned counsel for Jane Doe No. 1 and Jane Doe No. 2\ncontacted Government counsel to request their agreement to add an additional victim to this case:\na young woman Jeffrey Epstein sexual abused when she was under age. On August 20, 2014,\ncounsel sent a letter to U.S. Attorney Wilfredo Ferrer requesting the Government's consent to a\nstipulated motion to simply add her into the case (as had been done earlier with Jane Doe No. 2).\nCounsel attached a draft proposed motion that would have blandly recounted that she was\nsimilarly situated to Jane Doe No. 1 and Jane Doe No. 2. See Exhibit 2. The proposed motion\n2 Jeffrey Epstein also attempted to block discovery of materials in this case, leading to an Eleventh Circuit\nruling that the victims' disc\n... [truncated, 2261 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/2 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=2]", "char_count": 2261}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 4 of 40\ndid not include any of the facts surrounding her abuse, relying instead on a stipulation to secure\nthe Court's anticipated approval.\nThree months later, having received no response from the Government, victims' counsel\nsent an additional letter to Mr. Ferrer, requesting agreement to add an additional victim to the\ncase - a young woman identified in current pleadings as Jane Doe No. 34:\nDear Mr. Ferrer:\nI sent you a letter in August requesting your office's stipulation to our\nadding Jane Doe # [4] in this case. Unfortunately, we did not receive a response\nfrom your office. We are hopeful that your lack of a response was simple\noversight.\nIn addition to following up on the August letter, we are now requesting\nyour Stipulation to the adding of Jane Doe # [3] as well. Her true name is\n[redacted].... As we expressed in our personal meetings a couple years ago, we\ndon't understand the tactical decision to be adversarial to victims of known sexual\nabuse on every point in this litigation. Now that many of those issues we\ndiscussed have been resolved in our favor, it seems to make even more sense to\navoid engaging in unnecessary battles that could only serve the purpose of\ndelaying the victims' rights to have this case resolved on its merits.\nAs I indicated in my August letter requesting your stipulation to the\nadding of Jane Doe #[4], adding Jane Doe # [3] will also not delay matters, so long\nas we can stipulate to her being added. Without a stipulation, we foresee\nlitigation over this point, which will produce nothing but additional delay - and\nfurther question about your Office's commitment to full protection of victims'\nrights under the Crime Victims Rights Act.\nYour office is very familiar with [redacted] and her circumstance. She\nwas sexually trafficked and abused by Mr. Epstein (and others at the direction of\nMr. Epstein) not only in this jurisdiction but throughout the United States an\n... [truncated, 2962 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/3 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=3]", "char_count": 2962}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 5 of 40\nSee Exhibit 3. Weeks went by and the Government - once again -- did not respond to counsel's\nrequest for a stipulation. This prompted a further email from counsel to the AUSA's handling\nthis matter to inquire about the status of request:\nWhen we spoke a few months ago, I told you that we represented [Jane\nDoe No. 3] and were considering adding her to this suit. At the time of our call\nwe asked if you would agree to our adding her, and I understood that you would\nhave to check with others. Consequently, I sent a couple of letters to Mr. Ferrer\nthat I have attached to this email. I was hoping for a response letting me know\nthat the Office would not oppose the amendments adding Doe 3 and 4.... I realize\nour 11/19 letter asked for a response by the 10th. However, I was hoping you\ncould give me some indication whether we will get an answer before the 10th\n(and perhaps what that answer will be), because if there will not be an agreement\nto adding these Plaintiffs then I want to get the Motion prepared.\nSee Exhibit 4; see also Exhibit 5 (short response regarding trying to get an answer).\nOn December 10, 2014, despite having had four months to provide a position, the\nGovernment responded by email to counsel that it was seeking more time, indicating that the\nGovernment understood that victims' counsel might need to file a motion with the court on the\nmatter immediately: \"The U.S. Attorney is on travel and I do not have an answer for you on\nwhether the government will agree to the addition of two new petitioners. I appreciate you not\nfiling your motion until December [15], 2014. If you need to file the motion, we understand.\nThanks.\" See Exhibit 6.\nRather than file a motion immediately, victims' counsel waited and continued to press the\nGovernment for a stipulation. See Exhibits 7, 8, and 9. Finally, on December 23, 2014 - more\nthan four months after the initial request for a stipulated joinder\n... [truncated, 2216 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/4 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=4]", "char_count": 2216}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 6 of 40\nBecause the Government now contested the joinder motion, undersigned counsel\nprepared a more detailed pleading explaining the justification for granting the motion. One week\nafter receiving the Government's objection, on December 30, 2014, Jane Doe No. 3 and Jane\nDoe No. 4 filed a motion (and later a corrected motion) seeking to join the case. DE 279 and DE\n280.5 Uncertain as to the basis for the Government's objection, the motion briefly proffered the\ncircumstances of Jane Doe No. 3 and Jane Doe No. 4 that would qualify them as “victims”\neligible to assert rights under the CVRA. See 18 U.S.C. 3771(e) (\"For the purposes of this\nchapter, the term 'crime victim' means a person directly and proximately harmed as a result of\nthe commission of federal offense ..\"). With regard to Jane Doe No. 3, the motion indicated\nthat when she was a minor, Jeffrey Epstein had trafficked her to Dershowitz and Prince Andrew\n(among others) for sexual purposes. Jane Doe No. 3 stated that she was prepared to prove her\nproffer. See DE 280 at 3 (\"If allowed to join this action, Jane Doe No. 3 would prove the\nfollowing....\"). The motion also provided specific reasons why Jane Doe No. 3's participation\nwas relevant to the case, including the pending discovery issues regarding Dershowitz and Prince\nAndrew. DE 280 at 9-10 (explaining several reasons participation of new victims was relevant\nto existing issues).\nAfter the motion was filed, various news organizations published articles about it.\nDershowitz also made numerous media statements about the filing, including calling Jane Doe\nNo. 3 \"a serial liar\" who \"has lied through her teeth about many world leaders.\"\nhttp://www.cnn.com/2015/01/06/us/dershowitz-sex-allegation/. Dershowitz also repeatedly\nDershowitz argues that Jane Doe No. 3 violated Local Rule 15.1 by failing to attach a proposed\namended complaint. DE 282 at 2. But Jane Doe No. 3 was simply following \n... [truncated, 2146 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/5 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=5]", "char_count": 2146}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 7 of 40\ncalled undersigned legal counsel for Jane Doe No. 3 \"two sleazy, unprofessional, disbarable\nlawyers.\" Id. On January 5, 2015, Dershowitz filed the pending motion to intervene. DE 282.\nDISCUSSION\nDershowitz's motion to intervene relies on Fed. R. Civ. P. 24(a) (mandatory intervention)\nI.\nand 24(b) (permissive intervention). Neither argument for intervention is well-founded.\nDERSHOWITZ'S ALLEGED \"REPUTATIONAL\" INTERESTS DO\nSATISFY RULE 24(A)'S REQUIREMENTS FOR INTERVENTION AS OF\nRIGHT.\nNOT\nDershowitz first claims that he meets Rule 24(a)'s requirements for mandatory\nintervention. Rule 24(a) requires that the Court allow a person to intervene in a case if that\nperson \"claims an interest relating to the property or transaction that is the subject of that action\nand is so situated that disposing of the action may as a practical matter impair or impede the\nmovant's ability to protect his interest, unless existing parties adequately represent that interest.\"\nDershowitz contends he meets Rule 24(a)'s requirements because he has a \"reputational\" interest\nin the matter, specifically an interest in contesting Jane Doe No. 3's allegation that Jeffrey\nEpstein trafficked her to Dershowitz for sexual purposes.\nNumerous courts have declined to allow a mere \"reputational\" interest to justify\nmandatory intervention. For example, Calloway v. Westinghouse Elec. Corp., 115 F.R.D. 73\n(M.D. Ga. 1987), denied a motion to intervene where the alleged interest was a doctor's \"own\nreputation and academic credibility.\" Id. at 74. The court denied intervention because \"a\nwitness' interest in his reputation alone. . . does not constitute the required 'interest relating to\nthe property or transaction which is the subject of the present action' necessary to allow\nintervention as a matter of right. To find otherwise would invite intervention every time a court\nis required to determine the credibility of a witness.\" Id\n... [truncated, 2054 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/6 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=6]", "char_count": 2054}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 8 of 40\n1084, 1093 (1st Cir. 1986), affirmed the denial of the Church of Scientology's request for\nintervention in part because \"the church \"merely claim[ed] a generalized injury to reputation\n[that] identifies no legal detriment arising from a default judgment against Hubbard.\" Id. at 1093\n(Coffin, J., concurring). See also Edmondson v. State of Neb. ex. rel. Meyer, 383 F.2d 123, (8th\nCir. 1967) (\"The mere fact that Edmondson's reputation is thereby injured is not enough [to\nsupport intervention]. Edmondson's representative has pointed to no legal detriment flowing\nfrom this possible finding of the trial court, and we can find none.\"); Forsyth County v. U.S.\nArmy Corps of Engineers, No. 2:08-CV-0126-RWS, 2009 WL 1312511, at *2 (N.D. Ga. May\n8, 2009) (denying intervention because an \"interest in protecting its reputation . . . is not direct,\nsubstantive, or derived from a legal right\").\"\nThe Court has previously considered - and rejected - a similar effort to intervene on a\n\"reputational\" claim. That claim was made by Bruce Reinhart who like Dershowitz - had\npreviously represented Jeffrey Epstein's interests in related litigation. Reinhart moved to\nintervene in this case to contest the victims' allegations that Reinhart (a former prosecutor in the\nU.S. Attorney's Office investigating Epstein) received confidential, non-public information\nabout the investigation. The victims specifically alleged that Reinhart had \"joined Epstein's\npayroll shortly after important decisions were made limiting Epstein's criminal liability\" and that\nReinhart had gone on to improperly represent Epstein-related witnesses in various civil suits.\nSee DE 99 at 12 (discussing DE 48 at 23). Reinhart filed a sworn affidavit admitting that he had\nrepresented Epstein-related clients, but claiming that he did not possess any such confidential\ninformation. He sought to intervene to challenge the victims' arguments.\n\"Dershowit\n... [truncated, 2391 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/7 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=7]", "char_count": 2391}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 9 of 40\nAfter a hearing, the Court denied Reinhart's motion, finding that his interest in litigating\nthe validity of the victims' allegations was too attenuated to support intervention. DE 99 at 13.7\nThe Court's rationale applies equally here and should lead the Court to deny Dershowitz's\nmotion. Dershowitz claims that his situation is distinguishable in view of how \"harmful\" (DE\n282 at 6) he believes the current allegations are. But the degree of indignation at allegations is\nnot a sound basis for allowing intervention. As the Court previously explained, it \"cannot permit\nanyone slighted by allegations in court pleadings to intervene and conduct mini-trials to\nvindicate their reputation.\" DE 99 at 13.\nDershowitz does have an alternative ground he could try to advance for intervention. As\nJane Doe No. 3 pointed out in her motion to join the case, Dershowitz personally helped to\nnegotiate the non-prosecution agreement (NPA) at issue in this case, which bars his prosecution\nin the Southern District of Florida as a \"potential co-conspirator of Epstein.\" DE 280 at 4\n(quoting NPA at 5). The Court has previously allowed Epstein to prospectively intervene in any\nproceedings that might involve invalidating the NPA. DE 246. Dershowitz can make a similar\nmotion if he identifies himself as a potential co-conspirator involved in crimes covered by the\nNPA. But lacking such an allegation, his existing motion does not allege any concrete\nimpairment of his interests supporting mandatory intervention.\nII.\nDERSHOWITZ HAS NOT SHOWN THAT THE COURT SHOULD ALLOW\nPERMISSIVE INTERVENTION UNDER RULE 24(B).\n7 During the hearing on Reinhart's intervention motion, the Government stood silent about the accuracy\nof Reinhart's affidavit. Much later, after the Court had denied the motion, the Government admitted that\nit possessed information contradicting Reinhart's sworn affidavit. See DE 225-1 at 9-10, 43-45 (\"*in\nansweri\n... [truncated, 2254 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/8 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=8]", "char_count": 2254}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 10 of 40\nDershowitz also contends that the Court should exercise its discretion to allow permissive\nintervention in this case under Fed. R. Civ. P. 24(b). The rule grants discretion to the court to\nallow intervention by a person who has \"a claim or defense that shares with the main action a\ncommon question of law or fact.\" Fed. R. Civ. P. 24(b); accord Mt. Hawley Ins. Co. v. Sandy\nLake Properties, Inc., 425 F.3d 1308, 1311 (11th Cir. 2005) (permissive intervention allowed\nonly where \"a claim or defense and the main action have a question of law or fact in common\nand the intervention will not unduly prejudice or delay the adjudication of the rights of the\noriginal parties.\"). A district court's ruling on such intervention is reviewed only for abuse of\ndiscretion. Stone v. First Union Corp., 371 F.3d 1305, 1309 (11th Cir. 2004); see also AT&T\nCorp. v. Sprint Corp., 407 F.3d 560, 561-62 (2nd Cir. 2005) (“[a] denial of permissive\nintervention has virtually never been reversed\" because of the considerable discretion afforded to\ndistrict courts).\nIn ruling on a motion for permissive intervention, the Court must consider all relevant\nfactors, including \"the nature and extent of the intervenor's interest.\" Perry v. Proposition 8\nOfficial Proponents, 587 F.3d 947, 955 (9th Cir. 2009). Here, Dershowitz lacks a \"claim or\ndefense\" in common with the CVRA action. Instead, Dershowitz intends to advance satellite\narguments, including raising questions about the credibility of crime victims that the\nGovernment apparently does not intend to present. 8 Allowing his intervention would thus create\na clear risk of adding undue delay to what is already a long-running case. Cf. id. (affirming\ndistrict court decision to deny intervention that would \"consume additional time and resources of\n8 For example, in the media Dershowitz has called Jane Doe No. 3 - an alleged victim of international sex\ntrafficking while she \n... [truncated, 2266 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/9 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=9]", "char_count": 2266}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 11 of 40\nboth the Court and the parties that have a direct stake in the outcome of the proceedings\").\nMoreover, several other important factors weigh against allowing intervention.\nA. DERSHOWITZ CAN LITIGATE HIS REPUTATIONAL INTERESTS IN A\nPENDING DEFAMATION ACTION IN BROWARD COUNTY CIRCUIT\nCOURT.\nIn the opening paragraph of his court pleading, Dershowitz claims he has \"no remedy\" to\ndefend his reputation. DE 81 at 1. And yet, in his statements to the media, Dershowitz has made\nclear that he intends to defend his reputational interests in a pending defamation action. The\nCourt need not allow duplicative litigation on the same reputational issues.\nAfter Jane Doe No. 3 filed her motion to intervene, Dershowitz attacked her in the media\nas a \"serial perjurer.\" He also repeatedly named and attacked her attorneys - i.e., undersigned\nlegal counsel Edwards and Cassell - branding them, among other disparaging names, \"two\nsleazy, unprofessional, disbarable lawyers.\" Dershowitz repeated his attacks on numerous\nworldwide media outlets, saying such things as victims' counsel \"are prepared to lie, cheat and\nsteal. These are unethical lawyers\" (CNN Program \"The World Right Now with Hala Gorani,\"\nJan. 5, 2015) and that counsel \"willfully and deliberately made this up in order to gain a\nlitigation advantage, [to] line their pockets with money\" (The Last Word with Lawrence\nO'Donnell - MSNBC (Jan. 8, 2015).\nFollowing these statements, on January 6, 2015, attorneys Edwards and Cassell,\nrepresented by Jack Scarola, Esq., filed a defamation action in Broward County Circuit Court.\nSee Exhibit 11 at 17 (alleging Dershowitz has \"initiated a massive public media assault on the\nreputation and character\" of undersigned counsel, by \"accusing them of intentionally lying in\ntheir filings, of having leveled knowingly false accusations against [Dershowitz], without ever\nconducting any investigation of the credibility of the\n... [truncated, 2058 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/10 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=10]", "char_count": 2058}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 12 of 40\ndiscovery requests on Dershowitz, as well as a notice of deposition. Dershowitz has yet to agree\nto a deposition date.\nthis\nFaced with a defamation action against him, Dershowitz stated that he was \"thrilled\" by\nthe development because it \"gives me a chance to litigate the case. I can expose their corruption.\nI can show how fraudulent the allegations are. This makes my day.\" Wall St. Journal Law Blog,\nhttp://blogs.wsj.com/law/2015/01/06/jane-doe-lawyers-sue-dershowitz-for-defamation/ (Jan. 6,\n2015); see also UMAR News, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KXzcxsiQv7Q (Jan. 4, 2015)\n(\"I just need a legal proceeding... to call witnesses... to prove my case\" (emphasis added)).\nGiven that Dershowitz has the opportunity to litigate his concerns in the other case,\nCourt need not- and should not allow permissive intervention in this one. See, e.g., Morgan v.\nSears, Roebuck & Co., 124 F.R.D. 231 (1988) (declining intervention in one case where\nlitigation on a similar issue was already underway elsewhere). Permissive intervention in this\ncase would, for example, presumably lead to Dershowitz (and, in turn, undersigned legal\ncounsel) seeking duplicative discovery to that which is already being sought in Broward County\nCircuit Court. One forum is enough to litigate reputational issues.\nB. DERSHOWITZ SHOULD NOT BE ALLOWED TO INTERVENE IN THIS\nACTION WHEN HE HAS DECLINED TO DEFEND HIS REPUTATION IN\nOTHER ACTIONS.\nDershowitz also claims that he has not been given an opportunity to address his\nconnection to Epstein's sex trafficking. DE 282-1 at 3. This is untrue. Indeed, Dershowitz has\nbeen given (at least) three separate opportunities to provide information concerning his\ninvolvement in Epstein's offenses. Because Dershowitz has not availed himself of any of those\nprior opportunities, the Court should deny his motion to intervene now.\n2009\n12\nEFTA01191884\n", "char_count": 1954}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 13 of 40\nOn about September 17, 2009, one of undersigned counsel (Brad Edwards) arranged to\nhave Dershowitz served with a subpoena for deposition in connection with a civil case brought\nby one of the underage females who had sued Epstein (Doe v. Epstein, No. 9:08-cv-80893-KAM\n(S.D. Fla.)). At that point, Dershowitz understood that counsel for many of Epstein's victims\nbelieved that mounting evidence pointed toward his role extending beyond merely being an\nattorney for Epstein. That deposition ultimately did not occur, and Dershowitz made no effort to\nprovide information about his knowledge of relevant information.\n2011\nIn 2011, in the state case of Epstein v. Edwards (No. 502009CA040800XXXXMBAG\n(Palm Beach Cty. Cir. Ct.)), counsel for Edwards (Jack Scarola, Esq.) contacted Dershowitz to\nseek his cooperation in answering questions about his knowledge of Epstein's sex trafficking.\nOn August 15, 2011, Dershowitz indicated that he wanted more information before would decide\nwhether to cooperate: \"If you would let me know what non-privileged information you would\nseek from me, I would then be able to decide whether to cooperate.\" See Exhibit 12 (emphasis\nadded).\nOn August 23, 2011, Scarola sent a letter to Dershowitz, explaining that there was no\nintent to inquire about attorney-client information, but adding: \"[w]e do, however, have reason to\nbelieve that you have personally observed Jeffrey Epstein in the presence of underage females,\nand we would like the opportunity to question you under oath about these observations.\" See\nExhibit 13. Dershowitz declined to cooperate, so on September 7, 2011, Scarola again sent a\nletter to Dershowitz, noting that while there was \"no obligation\" to disclose the basis for wanting\na deposition, the reason was that \"[m]ultiple individuals have placed you in the presence of\nJeffrey Epstein on multiple occasions and in various locations when Jeffrey Epstein was in t\n... [truncated, 2019 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/12 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=12]", "char_count": 2019}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 14 of 40\ncompany of underage females subsequently identified as victims of Mr. Epstein's criminal\nmolestations. This information is derived from both sworn testimony and private interviews.\"\nExhibit 14. Despite providing Dershowitz with the basis for wanting his deposition, and the\nassurance that questions regarding privileged information would not be asked, Dershowitz did\nnot cooperate.\n2015\nAfter Jane Doe No. 3 moved to intervene in this case, Dershowitz said \"what they\n[victims' counsel] have done is so under-handed. . . not giv[ing] me an opportunity to disprove\nit. That's Kafkaesque.\" UMAR News, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KXzcxsiQv7Q.\nFollowing public statements such as these, on January 3, 2015, attorney Jack Scarola\nimmediately sent an e-mail to Dershowitz, requesting an opportunity to take his deposition:\nDear Mr. Dershowitz:\nStatements attributed to you in the public media express a willingness,\nindeed a strong desire, to submit to questioning under oath regarding your alleged\nknowledge of Jeffrey Epstein's extensive abuse of underage females as well as\nyour alleged personal participation in those activities. As I am sure you will\nrecall, our efforts to arrange such a deposition previously were unsuccessful, so\nwe welcome your change of heart. Perhaps a convenient time would be in\nconnection with your scheduled appearance in Miami on January 19. I assume a\nsubpoena will not be necessary since the deposition will be taken pursuant to your\nrequest, but please let us know promptly if that assumption is inaccurate.... Thank\nyou for your anticipated cooperation.\nExhibit 15. As of the date of this filing, Dershowitz has completely ignored this request, while\nsimultaneously continuing to publicly protest his inability to challenge the allegations against\nhim in a legal proceeding.\n14\nEFTA01191886\n", "char_count": 1910}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 15 of 40\nIn light of these opportunities that have been extended to Dershowitz previously to\nanswer any questions about his knowledge of (and even participation in) Epstein's sex\ntrafficking, his claim that he needs a forum in this Court to defend his reputation rings hollow.\"\nFor the sake of completeness - and to show a sinister pattern - it is also worth noting that\neach of the other four individuals Jane Doe No. 3 identified by name in her motion (Jeffrey\nEpstein, Ghislaine Maxwell, Jean Luc Brunel, and Prince Andrew) have also all been afforded\nopportunities to explain themselves - and all four have declined to take them.\nEpstein. The Court is familiar with Jeffrey Epstein's repeated invocations of the Fifth\nAmendment when asked questions about his sexual abuse of young girls, including Jane Doe No.\n1, Jane Doe No. 2, and Jane Doe No. 3. See generally Exhibit 16 at 1-7.\nMaxwell. In 2009, undersigned counsel (Brad Edwards) served Ghislaine Maxwell with\na subpoena for a deposition in a civil case against Jeffrey Epstein. After extensive discussion\nand coordinating a convenient time and place, as well as ultimately agreeing to a confidentiality\nagreement prepared by Maxwell's attorney, at the eleventh hour Maxwell's attorney informed\nthe undersigned that Maxwell's mother was very ill and that consequently Maxwell was leaving\nthe country with no plans to return. The deposition was cancelled. Yet a short time later,\nMaxwell was photographed at Chelsea Clinton's wedding in Rhinebeck, New York, confirming\nthe suspicion that she was indeed still in the country and willing to say anything to avoid her\ndeposition.\n9 The difficulty in scheduling this deposition also fits into a pattern for Dershowitz. In around 2005 to\n2006, Dershowitz was Jeffrey Epstein's \"primary\" lawyer. When the Palm Beach Police Department\ntried to interview Epstein, Dershowitz pretended that Epstein was willing to answer ques\n... [truncated, 2246 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/14 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=14]", "char_count": 2246}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 16 of 40\nBrunel. In 2009, undersigned counsel (Brad Edwards, representing Jane Doe) served\nJean Luc Brunel with a subpoena for a deposition before this court in Doe v. Epstein, No. 9:08-\ncv-80119-KAM (S.D. Fla.). Brunel's attorney asked counsel for Jane Doe to postpone the\nscheduled deposition date. Jane Doe's counsel agreed, and then Brunel's attorney cancelled the\nrescheduled deposition date. Brunel's counsel represented that Brunel was outside the country\nand thus unavailable. But later sworn deposition testimony revealed that Brunel was actually\ninside the country at this time - indeed, he was hiding at Epstein's Palm Beach home. All this\nwas brought to the Court's attention via a motion for sanctions. DE 483. This is just another\nexample of the inner circle of Epstein's friends refusing depositions to answer questions.\nPrince Andrew. In 2011, Jack Scarola, representing Brad Edwards in the Epstein v.\nEdwards case, faced procedural impediments to obtaining a sworn deposition from a member of\nthe British Royal family. Accordingly, he publicly invited the voluntary testimony of Prince\nAndrew, explaining: \"We would be very keen to speak with Prince Andrew, given his\nrelationship with Jeffrey Epstein.... We have reason to believe that Prince Andrew has been in\nthe company of Mr. Epstein while Mr. Epstein has been in the company of under-aged children.\"\nhttp://effiefolkerts.blogspot.com/2011/03/convicted-paedophile-jeffrey-epstein-is.html.\nPrince\nAndrew never responded.\nTwo weeks ago, after Jane Doe No. 3 and Jane Doe No. 4 moved to join in this action, a\nspokesperson for Prince Andrew denied Jane Doe No. 3's allegations, without providing any\nexplanation of what the Prince was doing with this minor girl late at night in a private setting.\nAccordingly, on January 14, 2015, Jack Scarola sent Prince Andrew a certified letter requesting\nhis voluntary cooperation in answering questions about his se\n... [truncated, 2052 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/15 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=15]", "char_count": 2052}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 17 of 40\n3. See Exhibit 17. The letter requested an opportunity to take a statement under oath from\nPrince Andrew. Federal Express has informed us that the letter has been refused by the recipient.\nIn light of these avoided opportunities by Dershowitz - as well as Epstein, Maxwell,\nBrunel, and Prince Andrew - to answer questions under oath regarding Epstein's trafficking of\nyoung girls, there is no good reason that the Court should now allow a special, discretionary\nopportunity to intervene to respond to the allegations.\nC. DERSHOWITZ SHOULD NOT BE ALLOWED TO INTERVENE TO STRIKE\nALLEGATIONS RELEVANT TO ISSUES PENDING BEFORE THE COURT.\nThe Court should also deny Dershowitz's motion for intervention because it would be a\npointless exercise.\nCiting Rule 12(f) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Dershowitz seeks to intervene\nto strike \"immaterial, impertinent, or scandalous matter.\" DE 282 at 7. Dershowitz contends\nthat Jane Doe No. 3's allegations regarding sexual contacts with him \"have nothing to do with\nany relevant issues in this case.\" Id. at 3. Courts generally \"disfavor the motion to strike....\"\nMoore's Federal Practice § 12.37[1] (3d ed. 2014) (internal citation omitted). \"Striking\nallegations from a pleading ‘is a drastic remedy to be resorted to only when required for the\npurposes of justice,' and only when the allegations to be stricken have 'no possible relation to the\ncontroversy.\" Larise Atlantis, Inc. v. Pac. Ins. Co., No. 10-61583-CIV, 2011 WL 1584359 at *2\n(S.D. Fla. 2011) (quoting Augustus v. Bd. of Pub. Instruction, 306 F.2d 862, 868 (5th Cir.1962)).\n\"If there is any doubt as to whether the allegations might be an issue in the action, courts will\ndeny the motion.\" In re 2TheMart.com, Inc. Sec. Litig., 114 F. Supp. 2d 955, 965 (C.D. Cal.\n2000) (emphasis in original). Just as with a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim, in\nruling on a motion to strike \"the Court m\n... [truncated, 2072 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/16 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=16]", "char_count": 2072}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 18 of 40\npleading party.\" Id. Any motion to strike by Dershowitz would be meritless, because Jane Doe\nNo. 3's allegations are pertinent to at least eight pending issues.\n1. The Pending Motion to Intervene.\nOf course, the first reason that Jane Doe No. 3 made her allegations was to support her\npending motion to join this action. As the Court has seen from the chronology recounted above,\nvictims' counsel engaged in months of efforts to reach a stipulated motion for joinder by Jane\nDoe No. 3 and Jane Doe No. 4 that would not have required reciting any specific factual\nallegations. The U.S. Attorney's Office refused to provide any answer to that request, until\nfinally tersely objecting (without providing any rationale). Once the joinder motion became\ncontested, Jane Doe No. 3 then needed to proffer allegations supporting her entry into the case.\nTo join this CVRA action, Jane Doe No. 3 must first show that she is the \"victim\" of a\nfederal crime, 18 U.S.C. § 3771(e) - and, further, that the crime is one that implicates persons\ncovered by the NPA. Jane Doe No. 3 alleged that she was sexually abused by Jeffrey Epstein.\nBut she also focused much of her joinder motion on the fact that she was the victim of a \"sex\ntrafficking scheme\" organized by Epstein. DE 280 at 3. To prove she is a victim of sex\ntrafficking in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1591, Jane Doe must demonstrate that she was recruited,\ntransported, or harbored while under the age of 18 and \"cause[d] to engage in a commercial sex\nact.\" Accordingly, she briefly described the trafficking scheme, including identifying several\npersons to whom she was trafficked (i.e., Dershowitz and Andrew). 10 The fact that Dershowitz\n10\nIn his motion, Dershowitz alleges that Jane Doe No. 3 identified these two names solely to stir up\nmedia attention. DE 282 at 2. But Dershowitz does not address the obvious reasons for the identification\n-i.e., that he was an attor\n... [truncated, 2501 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/17 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=17]", "char_count": 2501}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 19 of 40\n(and Prince Andrew) engaged in a \"sex act\" with her is simply a required element of her proof\nthat she is the victim of a sex trafficking crime.\nSexual trafficking is not the only crime that could support Jane Doe No. 3's joinder in\nthis case. There are also various federal sex offenses, such as travel with intent to engage in\nillicit sexual conduct, 18 U.S.C. § 2423(b), which Jane Doe No. 3's proffer supported. And\nperhaps most obviously, Jane Doe No. 3 was the victim of a conspiracy under 18 U.S.C. § 371.\nDershowitz, of course, was a co-conspirator against her thereby directly implicating the NPA.\nIn her pleading, Jane Doe No. 3 alleged only the fact that a sex act took place, not the nature of\nthe sex act nor any \"unnecessary detail.\" Begay v. Public Service Co. of New Mexico, 710\nF.Supp. 2d 1161 (D. N. Mex. 2010). \"\n2. The Pending Discovery Issues.\nAnother reason Jane Doe No. 3 cited in her pleading for specifically naming Dershowitz\n(and Prince Andrew) is that the Court has before it a pending discovery dispute involving\ndocuments relating to these two people. See DE 280 at 10 (citing DE 225 at 7-8 (discussing DE\n48 at 16-18)). As the Court is aware, on December 1, 2011, Jane Doe No. 1 and Jane Doe No. 2\npropounded a Request for Admission (RFA) asking the Government to admit that it possesses\n\"documents, correspondence or other information reflecting contacts with the Department\nthe names that she did include. If the Court would like proof of this assertion, counsel would request\nleave to provide an ex parte, sealed submission of the names of the other immediately recognizable\npersons who either observed or participated in the trafficking of Jane Doe No. 3.\n11 Where sexual issues are relevant to a case, they must not be stricken. See, e.g., Zdenek v. School Bd. of\nBroward County, No. 07-CV-61110, 2007 WL 4521489, at *2 (S.D. Fla. Dec. 19, 2007) (\"given the\nEleventh Circuit stand\n... [truncated, 2678 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/18 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=18]", "char_count": 2678}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 20 of 40\nbetween May 2007 and September 2008 on behalf of Jeffrey Epstein by ... (b) Andrew Albert\nChristian Edward (a/k/a Prince Andrew, Duke of York); (c) Harvard Law Professor Alan\nDershowitz.\" While the Government denied that it had documents reflecting contacts by Prince\nAndrew, it specifically admitted possessing documents reflecting contacts by Dershowitz. Gov't\nAnswer to RFA #6. The two victims further requested the Government admit that it possessed\n\"information (including telephone logs and emails) reflecting contacts between Bruce E.\nReinhart and persons/entities affiliated with Jeffrey Epstein (including . . . Harvard Law\nProfessor Alan Dershowitz). The Government admitted this fact. Gov't Answers to RFA #16.\nThese RFA's tie into a major discovery battle that is currently before the Court. Related\nto the RFA's, on October 3, 2011, Jane Doe No. 1 and Jane Doe No. 2 propounded Request for\nProduction (RFP) #8, seeking \"all correspondence, documents, and other information regarding\nEpstein's lobbying efforts to persuade the Government to give him a more favorable plea\narrangement and/or non-prosecution agreement, including efforts by . . . Andrew Albert\nChristian Edward (a/k/a Prince Andrew, Duke of York), [and] Harvard Law Professor Alan\nDershowitz.\" The two victims also propounded RFP #21, requesting all documents relating to\nthe NPA, including documents in the Government's possession from \"defense attorneys\nrepresenting Epstein (including . . . Alan Dershowitz)\" and from \"agents acting in support of\nEpstein (including... Andrew Albert Christian Edward (a/k/a Prince Andrew Duke of York)).\"\nThe Government responded to these (and other RFPs) by asserting privilege over 14,825\npages of documents that it provided to the Court. 12 But contrary to the Court's specific direction,\nthe Government did not provide a log that \"clearly identifies each document[] by author(s),\naddressee(s), recip\n... [truncated, 2195 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/19 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=19]", "char_count": 2195}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 21 of 40\nthere is no way to determine which of the documents that the Government has provided to the\nCourt are responsive to which of the victims' discovery requests - including which documents\nrelate to Dershowitz. See DE 265 at 1-2. The Government then asserted a host of privileges,\nincluding qualified privileges, such as deliberative process privilege, investigative privilege, and\nthe work product doctrine. Qualified privileges require the Court to engage in a far-ranging\ninquiry that balances competing interests. As the victims have recounted in their (currently-\npending) objections to the Government's assertion of privilege, the Court must weigh such things\nas \"the 'seriousness' of the litigation\" (DE 265 at 9), \"the importance of the information sought\nto the plaintiff's case\" (DE 265-1 at 22), and whether there is a \"compelling need\" for disclosure\n(DE 265 at 14). Clearly Jane Doe No. 3's allegations factor into this balancing of interests about\nproduction of documents relating to Dershowitz (and others).\n3. Motive\nWhen the Court ultimately rules on the underlying substantive issue of whether the\nGovernment violated the victims' rights, motive will be a central issue. The Government has\nrepeatedly asserted benign motivations for not revealing the NPA to the victims, and the victims\nhave strongly contested those assertions. See, e.g., DE 266 at 10 (\"Motive is clearly in dispute in\nthis case....\"). The NPA itself contains several unusual provisions that invite debate over how\nthey came into existence - such as the \"confidentiality\" provision that illegally barred disclosure\nto the victims and the \"blank check\" co-conspirator immunity provision discussed immediately\nbelow. An important question is whether these strange provisions were crafted accidentally - or\nas part of a deliberate plan to keep the victims in the dark, as the victims are contending. See,\ne.g., DE 48 at 11 (alleging that\n... [truncated, 2162 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/20 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=20]", "char_count": 2162}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 22 of 40\nresulted from allowing a politically-connected billionaire who had sexually abused more than 30\nidentified minor girls to escape from federal prosecution with only a county court jail sentence\").\nThe fact that an important attorney on the defense team had strong personal reasons for resolving\nthe case without a public trial bears directly on this question, by showing motivation to reach a\nsecret deal. Dershowitz's need to keep his abuse secret, and his direct personal knowledge of\nEpstein's abuse, also goes to issues revolving around whether the defense team engaged in a\n\"yearlong assault on the prosecution and prosecutors,\" as alleged by former U.S. Attorney\nAlexander Acosta. See DE 266 at 12. 13\nIssues pertaining to motive can always be pursued, particularly when a case is in an early\ndiscovery phase. See, e.g., Gelabert v. State, 407 So. 2d 1007, 1010 (Fla. 5th DCA 1981). And\n\"motive is always relevant in a criminal case, even if it is not an element of the crime.\" United\nStates v. Hill, 643 F.3d 807, 843 (11th Cir. 2011) (internal quotation omitted).\nWhen speaking not to the Court but rather to the media, Dershowitz has clearly admitted\nthe relevance of Jane Doe No. 3's allegations about him to issues of motive. Speaking on CNN,\nfor example, Dershowitz stated that he was being \"targeted\" precisely because his involvement\nin Epstein's sexual trafficking would help \"blow up\" the plea agreement:\nIn his Supplement to his Motion for Limited Intervention, Dershowitz claims that only information\nrelevant to this case is information known by the Government before September 24, 2007 - the latest date\non which, according to Dershowitz, the Government made the decision not to pursue federal criminal\ncharges against Epstein. DE 285 at 1. Dershowitz appears to be unaware that the Government told the\nvictims well after that date that the Government was still \"investigating\" the case. DE 48 at \n... [truncated, 2923 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/21 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=21]", "char_count": 2923}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 23 of 40\n[The victims] want to be able to challenge the plea agreement. I was one of the\nlawyers who organized the plea agreement. I got the very good deal for Jeffrey\nEpstein. And if they [i.e., victims' counsel] could find a lawyer who helped\ndraft the agreement who also was a criminal, having sex - wow - that could help\nthem blow up the agreement. So they sat down together, the three of them- these\ntwo sleazy, unprofessional, disbarrable lawyers, Paul Cassell, a former federal\njudge [and] current professor, and another sleazy lawyer from Florida, Brad\nEdwards ... and said who would fit into this description: A lawyer, who knows\nEpstein, who helped draft...? Ha, Dershowitz! So they and the woman got\ntogether and contrived and made this up. 14\nSimilarly, on the Meredith Vieira Show, Dershowitz alleged that allegations against him \"fit the\nprofile\" of what it could take to vacate the plea. 15 Of course, Jane Doe No. 3 (and her attorneys)\nare prepared to show they did not \"contrive\" the allegations. Dershowitz's name was not drawn\nfrom a hat. Rather, he was added to the pleading because Jane Doe No. 3 identified him as one\nof her abusers. And once she proves the truth of her sworn allegations, then as Dershowitz\nhimself colorfully puts it - the victims have additional relevant evidence that will help them to\n\"blow up\" the plea.\n4.\nThe NPA's \"Blank Check\" Co-Conspirator Immunity Provision and the Scope of\nthe Remedy that the Victims Might Obtain.\nJane Doe No. 3 explained in her motion to intervene that Dershowitz helped negotiate a\nNPA that contained a sweeping provision that provided immunity in the Southern District of\nFlorida not only to Epstein, but also to any potential co-conspirators of Epstein.\" DE 280 at 4\n(quoting NPA at 5).16 This provision is very unusual - a proverbial \"blank check\" blocking\nfederal criminal prosecution of people who are not specifically identified - raising an inf\n... [truncated, 2505 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/22 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=22]", "char_count": 2505}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 24 of 40\nthat the defense team may have had ulterior or unidentified motives for pressing for the\nprovision.\nMore broadly, knowledge of the persons who are covered by this provision is directly\nrelevant to the scope of the remedy that the victims may be able to obtain from the Court if they\nprevail on the merits of their claim. The Court has already received briefing from the victims\nand the Government on the remedy issue - and has prospectively allowed Epstein to intervene on\nany issue involving rescission of the NPA. DE 246. The victims all intend to seek rescission of\nthe co-conspirator provision as part of any relief in this case. The fact that several of Jane Doe\nNo. 3's sexual abusers - i.e., Dershowitz, Maxwell, Brunel, and Prince Andrew are currently\ncovered by the provision will thus be relevant to the scope of the remedy that the victims can\nobtain and the persons that they can seek to have prosecuted.\n5. Interface Issues.\nThe Court has previously ruled that the victims' CVRA claim \"implicates a fact-sensitive\nequitable defense which must be considered in the factual context of the entire interface between\nEpstein, the relevant prosecutorial authorities and the federal offense victims ....\" DE 189 at 12\nn.6. Part of that \"entire interface\" is Epstein's defense team- which included Dershowitz. And\nJane Doe No. 3 is one of the victims - indeed, an international sex trafficking victim. Her\nimportant factual allegations about extremely serious international trafficking crimes being swept\nunder the rug in a dubious and secret non-prosecution agreement provide a critical piece of the\n\"factual context\" that the Court must consider.\n6. The \"Crime/Fraud\" Exception to the Attorney-Client Privilege and Other Privileges.\nJane Doe No. 1 and Jane Doe No. 2 have specifically raised the argument that a\ncrime/fraud/misconduct exception applies to the Government's assertion of attorney-client\n24\nEFTA\n... [truncated, 2009 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/23 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=23]", "char_count": 2009}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 25 of 40\nprivilege over various documents. DE 265 at 5-6. Based on Jane Doe No. 3's allegations,\ncommunications between the Epstein defense team and the Government appear to furthered a\ncrime - i.e., Dershowitz's conspiracy with Epstein to engage in, and conceal, sex trafficking.\nAnd Government prosecutors' internal discussions may have unwittingly furthered that crime.\nSee In re Grand Jury Investigation, 445 F.3d 266, 275-76 (3rd Cir. 2006) (attorney's lack of\nknowledge of the crime being furthered not relevant to crime-fraud exception).\n7. Right to be \"Treated with Fairness\" Issues.\nIn his \"supplemental\" pleading, Dershowitz seems to assume that the victims are raising\nonly a claim about their right to \"confer\" with prosecutors. DE 285 at 1-2. But Jane Doe No. 1\nand Jane Doe No. 2 also have a much broader, over-arching claim of a violation of their right \"to\nbe treated with fairness\" under 18 U.S.C. § 3771(a)(8). See DE 48 at 36. Jane Doe No. 3 was\nknown to the United States Attorney's Office at the time of the Epstein investigation, as\nevidenced by her inclusion in the NPA's attachment identifying known victims. The fact that\nJane Doe No. 3 a victim of international sex trafficking - was kept in the dark about the plea\ndeal will provide further evidence of a violation of the right to be treated with fairness. The\nscope of her abuse - and the fact that the prosecution of crimes against her in the Southern\nDistrict of Florida is now blocked by an agreement negotiated by one of her abusers - also all go\nto violations of the fairness right.\n8. Jane Doe No. 3 Will Be a Witness for Jane Doe No. 1 and Jane Doe No. 2 at Trial.\nFinally, the record in this case should reflect that Jane Doe No. 1 and Jane Doe No. 2\nintend to call Jane Doe No. 3 as a witness in any hearing or trial that the Court may schedule in\nthis matter. The Government's violation of her rights is clearly evidence of a common sche\n... [truncated, 2022 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/24 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=24]", "char_count": 2022}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 26 of 40\nor plan to keep crime victims in the dark, made admissible in any hearing by virtue of Fed. R.\nEvid. 404(b).\nFor each of these eight reasons, Jane Doe No. 3's allegations against Dershowitz are\nplainly relevant to this case and therefore his attempt to intervene to strike them is futile. 17\nD.\nDESHOWITZ SHOULD NOT BE ALLOWED TO INTEVENE TO\nSTRIKE JANE DOE NO. 3'S ALLEGATIONS BECAUSE SHE HAS\nSWORN TO THEIR TRUTH AND THEY ARE ALL SUPPORTED BY\nSTRONG CORROBORATING EVIDENCE.\nDershowitz finally claims that he should be allowed to intervene because Jane Doe No.\n3's allegations against him are false. In support of this position, he attaches a carefully-crafted,\nself-serving declaration. But a litigant's mere claim that contrary allegations are false provides\nno legal basis for striking them. See Moore's Federal Practice § 12.37[3A] (3d ed. 2014) (\"Rule\n12 does not provide any authority to strike pleadings on the basis of falsity\" because doing so\nwould \"effectively [be] a resolution on the merits, which is not appropriate at the pleading\nstage.\"). At early stages of litigation, \"[t]he court accepts all well-pleaded allegations as true\"\nand views factual allegations \"in the light most favorable to the non-moving party.\" Johnson v.\nNobu Associates South Beach, LP, No. 9:10-cv-21691-KAM, 2011 WL 780028 at *2 (S.D. Fla.\n2011). In any event, to rebut Dershowitz's false claims directly, Jane Doe No. 3 now provides\nher own sworn affidavit, attached as Exhibit 1,18 repeating under oath the allegations that her\n17 A ninth reason now also exists that the allegations are relevant, given that the Government recently-\nraised the argument that the Jane Doe No. 3 has failed to meet a six-year statute of limitations specified in\n18 U.S.C. § 2401. DE 290. Jane Doe No. 3 will contest whether that statute of limitations even applies.\nBut Jane Doe also intends to raise an equitable estoppel argument that the s\n... [truncated, 2513 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/25 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=25]", "char_count": 2513}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 27 of 40\nattorneys proffered in her earlier motion - i.e., that Epstein sexually trafficked Jane Doe No. 3 to\nnumerous persons, including Dershowitz. If the Court believes it would be useful, Jane Doe No.\n3 requests an evidentiary hearing to prove she is telling the truth 19 and directs the Court's\nattention the following substantial information supporting her sworn statement. 20 To be clear,\nwhat follows is just part of the compelling information supporting Jane Doe No. 3's allegations.\nAny assessment of Jane Doe No. 3's sworn statement (and Dershowitz's protestations of\ninnocence) must begin with two incontestable facts: First, Dershowitz is an extremely close\npersonal friend of Epstein's. In fact, in 2005 (before the scandal of the criminal prosecution\nbroke) Dershowitz stated \"I'm on my 20th book.... The only person outside of my immediate\nfamily that I send drafts to is Jeffrey.\" The Talented Mr. Epstein, by Vicky Ward, in Vanity Fair\n(Jan. 2005). Dershowitz has also been quoted as saying that, even if Epstein went bankrupt, \"I\nwould be as interested in him as a friend if we had hamburgers on the boardwalk in Coney Island\nand talked about his ideas.\" Vanity Fair Reminds Us When Jeffrey Epstein Wasn't a Creep, by\nRay Gustini, in The Wire (June 21, 2011).\nSecond, Jeffrey Epstein brazenly abused numerous girls in his Florida mansion, his New\nYork mansion, and several other places that Dershowitz apparently admits he visited. See DE\n282-1 at 1-3 (Dershowitz affidavit discussing visits to Epstein). Proof of the notorious abuse\noriginally been a victim of Epstein's sexual abuse while a minor. She is now a well-known actress whose\nidentity we have unilaterally protected in this context.\n19 Jane Doe No. 3 asks that the evidentiary hearing be held after discovery phase in this case is completed,\nbecause she believes that the Government possesses significant information that, if disclosed, would f\n... [truncated, 2779 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/26 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=26]", "char_count": 2779}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 28 of 40\nstarts with the NPA, under which Epstein agreed to register as a sex offender and provide\ncompensation to approximately forty girls who he had sexually abused. Additional girls who he\nabused (such as movant Jane Doe No. 4) were not included in the NPA. Combined with the\nsworn testimony in the underlying civil cases, the NPA demonstrates persuasively that Epstein\ncommitted hundreds and hundreds of acts of sexual abuse against young girls - ostensibly\n\"massage therapists\" - during the relevant time period. See Exhibit 16 at 2 (collecting\ntestimony). A small sample of the girls that Epstein sexually abused includes Jane Does Nos. 1,\n2, 3, and 4, as well as S.G., A.D., V.A., N.R., J.S., V.Z., J.A., J.E., M.L., M.D., D.D, and D.N. -\nall girls between the ages of 13 and 17. Id. at 7-8.\nGiven the astonishing number of victims, and the detailed descriptions from many of\nthem, Epstein's abuse of young girls clearly occurred on a \"daily\" basis. See Ex. 1 at ¶ 17.\nIndeed, according to his scheduled appointments, evidenced by the message pads retrieved by\nthe Palm Beach Police Department, on some days Epstein engaged in sex with multiple girls.\"\nIn 2009, one of Epstein's household employees, Juan Alessi, was deposed about the\nparade of young \"massage therapists\" entering Epstein's Palm Beach mansion. He started\nworking for Epstein in about January 1999. He testified that Jane Doe No. 323 was one of the\ngirls who came to Epstein's mansion regularly when she was in the age range of 15 to 19. Juan\nAlessi Depo. at 46:21-47:4, 48:18-25, Jane Doe No. 2 v. Epstein, No. 9:08-cv-80119-cv-KAM\n(S.D. Fla. Sept. 8, 2009) (excerpts attached as Exhibit 18).\nAlessi also saw many celebrities came to the Florida mansion, including not only Prince\nAndrew and his wife Sarah but also \"a very famous lawyer that I'm sure you know, Alan\nUpon request, victims counsel could provide the Court with these materials for revi\n... [truncated, 2195 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/27 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=27]", "char_count": 2195}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 29 of 40\nDershowitz.\" Id. at 70:9-25. Alessi testified that Dershowitz came to the mansion \"pretty often.\n.. at least four or five times a year\" and would stay \"two [or] three days.\" Id. at 73:22-25. Jane\nDoe No. 3 came to the house when Dershowitz was there. Id. at 73:18-20. And - importantly -\nDershowitz got massages while he was visiting Epstein's home. Alessi answered \"yes\" when\nasked whether Dershowitz \"had massages sometimes when he was there,\" and explained that\n\"[a] massage was like a treat for everybody.\" Id. at 74:1-4. The private, upstairs room where\nDershowitz got his \"massages\" was one that contained a lot of vibrators - Maxwell had \"a\nlaundry basket... full of those toys\" in that room. Id. at 76:11-15.\nIn 2009, one of Epstein's most trusted employees was also deposed: Alfredo Rodriguez,\nthe butler at Epstein's Palm Beach mansion. Rodriguez testified under oath that Dershowitz was\nat Epstein's mansion when underage girls were there to give massages. Alfredo Rodriguez\nDepo. at 278:13-25, 279:9-280:2, Jane Doe No. 2 v. Epstein (excerpts attached as Exhibit 19). 24\nRodriguez also testified that Dershowitz stayed at the house in his role as Epstein's friend, as\nopposed to being his lawyer (id. at 279:5-8; 385:1-6) and that Dershowitz was present alone at\nthe home of Jeffery Epstein, without his family, in the presence of young girls. Id. at 199:12-13,\n279:9-12, 426:16-25, 427:1. In fact, Rodriguez described that when the underage girls would\ncome over, Dershowitz would drink wine and read books on the couch. Id. at 426:16-25; 427:1.\nAs is familiar to this Court, after Rodriguez's deposition, he attempted to sell a 97-page\ndocument that he appropriated from Epstein's computer. The document contained Epstein's\ntelephone directory - as well as a list of apparent young girls in various locations, including\n24 According to press reports, Rodriguez recently passed away. See \"Houseman who c\n... [truncated, 2353 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/28 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=28]", "char_count": 2353}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 30 of 40\nFlorida, New York, New Mexico, and the U.S. Virgin Islands. An FBI undercover employee\n(UCE) set up a meeting with Rodriguez to exchange $50,000 in \"buy money\" for the document.\nFollowing the exchange, the FBI arrested Rodriguez for obstruction of justice related to the\nattempted sale of this document (which Rodriguez called \"the Holy Grail\"). According to an FBI\nagent's ensuing report, Rodriguez \"discussed in detail the information contained within the book,\nand identified important information to the UCE.\" See United States v. Rodriguez, No. 9:10-cr-\n80015-KAM, DE 3 at 5 (S.D. Fla. Dec. 9, 2009). While all of the details of the verbal\ninformation explained by Rodriguez to that agent have not been disclosed,25 the documents have\nbeen. While there are hundreds of names, addresses, and phone numbers in the document,\nRodriguez apparently circled only a select few entries. For instance, he circled each of the\nsections listing the girls that provided \"massages\" for Epstein in various locations. This includes\nthe various confirmed under-age Florida victims. Additionally, a few other individuals in the\nbook were circled. The logical presumption is that Rodriguez circled specific individuals,\nidentifying them as persons who were involved in the illicit activities. One of the few people\nRodriguez circled was Alan Dershowitz. See Exhibit 20.\nMoving up from household help to the next echelon in Epstein's criminal conspiracy,\nthree individuals the NPA lists by name as Jeffrey Epstein's co-conspirators are\nand Adrianna Mucinska. Extensive investigation demonstrated that\nparticipated in several of the sex acts with underage girls (including Jane Doe 1) and\nand Adrianna Mucinska were heavily involved in procuring underage girls for\nEpstein to sexually abuse. See, e.g., Exhibit 16 at 12, 20. Of particular relevance here, all three\nthat\n25 It has been disclosed that Rodriguez said that \"he had witne\n... [truncated, 2272 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/29 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=29]", "char_count": 2272}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 31 of 40\n26\nimplicated Dershowitz by invoking their Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination\nwhen asked questions about Dershowitz's connection to Epstein's abuse - including a specific\nquestion about whether Dershowitz had been involved with massages by young girls.\ntook the Fifth when asked:\nHave you seen a gentleman by the name of Alan Dershowitz at the home of\nJeffrey Epstein before?\nDo you know Alan Dershowitz?\nAre you aware of friendship between [Alan] Dershowitz and Jeffrey Epstein?\nWhen [Alan] Dershowitz comes to Palm Beach, he stays at the El Brillo mansion,\ndoesn't he?\n[H]as [Alan] Dershowitz ever been there when young ladies came to give\nmassages?\nHas [Alan] Dershowitz ever been the beneficiary of those massages [given by\nyoung ladies at Epstein's mansion]?27\nDepo. at 211:16-18, 317:5, 436-37:25-1, 437:9-10; 437:18-19, 437-38: 25-1, Jane\nDoe No. 2 v. Epstein, No. 8:09-cv-80119-KAM (Mar. 24, 2010) (emphasis added) (excerpts\nattached as Exhibit 21).\npled the Fifth when asked:\nDo you know what Jeffrey Epstein's relationship is with Alan Dershowitz?\nThat's somebody [i.e., Dershowitz] who you know to have stayed at Jeffery\nEpstein's house on many occasions, correct?\nAnd also somebody who you know to have been at the house when E.W. was in\nJeffrey Epstein's bedroom getting sexually abused, correct?\n26\nOf course, in a proceeding such as this one, the victims are entitled to an inference in their favor when a\nwitness takes the Fifth Amendment rather than answer a relevant question where that witness is\nassociated with the other side of the case or otherwise in an adverse position to the victims. See, e.g.,\nLiButti v. United States, 107 F.3d 110, 124 (2d Cir. 1997).\nInterestingly, defending the deposition of\nwas Bruce Reinhart, a former prosecutor in the\nU.S. Attorney's Office when the Epstein NPA was negotiated. Reinhart had confidential, non-public\ninformation about the prosecutio\n... [truncated, 2061 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/30 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=30]", "char_count": 2061}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 32 of 40\nAlan Dershowitz is also somebody that you also know to have been at the house\nwhen L.M. was being sexually abused in Jeffrey Epstein's bedroom, correct?\nGenerally, Alan Dershowitz is familiar with Jeffrey Epstein's habit of engaging in\nsexual acts with minors on a daily basis, correct?\nWhen Alan Dershowitz was in town, Jeffrey Epstein did not break his schedule\nfor Alan Dershowitz, meaning he continued to sexually abuse minors despite Alan\nDershowitz being a guest in the house?\nDepo. at 56:22-25; 57:1-25, 58: 1-10, Jane Doe v. Epstein, No. 9:08-cv-\n80893-KAM (April 13, 2010) (excerpts attached as Exhibit 22). And Adrianna Mucinska took\nthe Fifth when asked:\nHave you ever met Alan Dershowitz?\nWhen Alan Dershowitz stays at Jeffrey Epstein's house, isn't it true that he has\nbeen at the house when underage minor females have been in the bedroom with\nJeffrey Epstein?\nHave you ever flown on the airplane [privately owned by Jeffrey Epstein] with\nAlan Dershowitz before?\nAdrianna Mucinska Depo. at 37:6, 37:8, 81:25, Jane Doe v. Epstein, No. 9:08-cv-80893-KAM\n(Mar. 15, 2010) (excerpts attached as Exhibit 23). 28\nFinally, moving to the top of the conspiracy, Epstein himself has been questioned\nrepeatedly, taking the Fifth when asked about Dershowitz's awareness of underage girls. For\nexample, when Epstein took the Fifth when asked during his deposition \"[h]ave you ever\nsocialized with Alan Dershowitz in the presence of females under the age of 18?\" Jeffrey\nEpstein Depo. at 90, Epstein v. Edwards, No. 502009CA040800XXXXMB (Palm Beach Cty.\nCir. Ct. Mar. 17, 2010) (excerpts attached as Exhibit 24). Indeed, going a step further, on\nOctober 8, 2009, Epstein took the Fifth when asked whether he even knew Dershowitz was a\n28 Mucinska also took the Fifth when asked about the involvement of Prince Andrew, Ghislaine Maxwell,\nand Jean Luc Brunel. Id. at 37:3, 85:12, 85:13.\n32\nEFTA01191904\n", "char_count": 1984}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 33 of 40\nprofessor at Harvard. B.B. v. Epstein, No. 502008CA03731XXXXMB, Epstein Depo. Tr. at 122\n(Palm Beach Cty. Cir. Ct. Oct. 8, 2009).\nIn short, all the key conspirators in Epstein's sexual trafficking ring who could be asked\nabout Derhowitz's involvement took the Fifth. 29 This “[s]ilence is . . . evidence of the most\npersuasive character.\" United States ex rel. Bilokumsky v. Tod, 263 U.S. 149, 153-54 (1923)\n(Brandeis, J.), quoted in Baxter v. Palmigiano, 425 U.S 308, 319 (1976). And that silence takes\non an even more sinister cast when combined with the fact that Epstein's sexual interest in young\ngirls would have been obvious to someone like Dershowitz, Epstein's close personal friend who\nwas present at the very locations when abuse was taking place. See Ex. 1 at ¶ 17.\nAdditional credibility to Jane Doe No. 3's sworn statement is provided by clear evidence\nof a common scheme or plan, admissible under Fed. R. Evid. 404(b). As is clear from the\nevidence recounted above, Jane Doe No. 3's allegations against Jeffrey Epstein are\noverwhelmingly corroborated by numerous other girls and Epstein's private flight logs\ndemonstrating Jane Doe No. 3's travel with him while under 18 years old. In addition, her\nallegations against Prince Andrew are strongly corroborated. For example, while Buckingham\nPalace has recently denied that Prince Andrew had sexual contact with Jane Doe No. 3, it has not\nattempted to explain what led to the Prince having his picture taken with his arm around a 17-\nyear-old American girl at night in London in an intimate setting in a private residence. Nor has\nthe Palace explained what Ghislaine Maxwell is doing there and who took that picture - while\nJane Doe No. 3 has provided a sworn affidavit that the photographer was Prince Andrew's close\nfriend (as well as sex trafficker and now-registered sex offender): Jeffrey Epstein. Jane Doe No.\n29\n-\nAs noted earlier, two other key \n... [truncated, 2133 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/32 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=32]", "char_count": 2133}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 34 of 40\n3 has also made strong, credible claims against Jean Luc Brunel - corroborated allegations that\nparallel those made by others. See Exhibit 16 at 22.\nIn contrast to this interlocking web of corroborating evidence, the Court should examine\nwhat Dershowitz says in his affidavit - and, more important, fails to say. The Court will notice\nthat Dershowitz devotes only a single sentence in his affidavit to his activities at Epstein's Palm\nBeach and New York mansions. See DE 282-1 at 3 (\"As to Mr. Epstein's homes in New York\nCity and Palm Beach, I categorically state that I never had any sexual contact with Jane Doe\n# 3.\"). The Court may immediately wonder about the following questions: How long did\nDershowitz spend at these homes? Was he with his wife and family, as he has suggested in\ntelevision interviews? How many times was he there overnight? Did Dershowitz ever see any of\nthe dozens and dozens of young girls whom Epstein was sexually abusing? Did Dershowitz ever\nget a \"massage\" from one of these young girls?\nThe Court may also wish to contrast Dershowitz's very narrow affidavit with his more\nsweeping statements to the media. On popular television programs, Dershowitz has emphatically\ndenounced Jane Doe No. 3 as a liar and said he can prove \"conclusively\" that he has never even\nmet her. 30 Yet in his sworn affidavit, Dershowitz does not repeat that broad claim.31 Nor does\nDershowitz ever address his knowledge of other young girls, in addition to Jane Doe No. 3,\nabused by Epstein in those houses.\n30 See, e.g., http://www.cnn.com/2015/01/05/europe/prince-andrew-sex-abuse-allegations/index.html (\"Q:\n\"Have you ever met this woman named [Jane Doe No. 3]?\" A: \"No. Absolutely not, I don't know who\nshe is.\"); CNN News Day\nhttp://www.cnn.com/videos/tv/2015/01/05/bts-newday-alan-dershowitz-prince-andrew-sex-scandal-\nallegations.cnn (Jan. 5, 2015) (\"I never met this woman. I never touched her. I wa\n... [truncated, 2545 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/33 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=33]", "char_count": 2545}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 35 of 40\nIn his affidavit, Dershowitz also cagily states that he sent a letter to an attorney who was\nseeking a deposition, recounting that in that letter he (Dershowitz) said he was \"not a witness to\nany alleged crimes.\" DE 282-1 at 3. But Dershowitz does not repeat under oath the broad claim\nthat he never witnessed any alleged crimes - presumably because he is aware of certain child\nabuse reporting obligations that might be at issue if he did so.\nAgainst this mounting evidence of guilt, Dershowitz suggests in his affidavit that aircraft\nflight manifests will exonerate him. DE 282-1 (\"I was on that plane on several occasion as the\nmanifests will show, but never under circumstances where it would have been possible to have\nsex with Jane Doe #3.\"). In media statements, Dershowitz has repeatedly brought up the\nmanifests as proof of innocence. 32 Coincidentally and remarkably, it was Dershowitz himself,\nacting as Epstein's attorney, who personally collected and then provided flight manifests to the\nPalm Beach Police Department. See, e.g., Police Detective Joe Recarey Depo. at 281, Jane Doe\nNo. 2 v. Epstein, No. 9:08-cv-80119-KAM (Mar. 19, 2010). (excerpts attached as Exhibit 29)\nDershowitz provided manifests covering just the 10 months: January 1, 2005, through October\n17, 2005, During civil litigation, believing that these flight manifests were grossly incomplete,\ncounsel subpoenaed Epstein for complete flight logs. Epstein failed to provide any information\nat all. Counsel were then forced to request flight logs from Epstein's various private pilots.\nOne of Epstein's pilots, David Rogers, provided certain flight logs covering some flights\nfrom a much broader time frame: 1997-2005. This production confirmed that the flight\n32\nSee, e.g., The Today Show, Jan. 5, 2015 (\"She claims I had sex with her in the airplanes, manifests of\nthe flights will show I was never on the airplanes with her.\"); Hala \n... [truncated, 2191 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/34 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=34]", "char_count": 2191}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 36 of 40\ninformation Dershowitz provided to police was incomplete. A comparison of the flight\nmanifests and logs confirms that the flight logs provided by Rogers were also incomplete. A\ncursory review of both logs reveals that together the logs produced cover only a small fraction of\nthe flights taken and the passengers on board. While this is obvious for multiple reasons, a few\nexamples may help to make this point. For instance, the flight records provided by Dershowitz\nfor a February 3, 2005, flight from CMH (Columbus, Ohio) to PBI (Palm Beach, Florida),\nindicate that in addition to Jeffrey Epstein,\nand Jean Luc\nBrunel, on board were three \"females.\" The existence of these three \"females\" is conspicuously\nabsent from the Rogers' logs. Compare Composite Exhibit 25 with Composite Exhibit 26\n(Rodgers Logs). Other flights, such as the March 18, 2005 flight from New York to Florida,\ntaken by Maxwell, Epstein and\nare missing altogether from the Rogers logs.\nLikewise, flights that appear on the Rogers logs are missing from the logs produced by\nDershowitz. Multiple examples lead to the clear conclusion that all produced logs are\nincomplete and may well have been heavily sanitized. For example, on February 9, 1998,\nDershowitz flew on Epstein's private plane from Palm Beach, Florida, to Teterboro, New Jersey.\nOne of the passengers is listed as \"1 female.\" Exhibit 27. Who is that \"female\" - and what is\nher age? Similarly, Jane Doe No. 3 appears on a July 16, 2001, flight from Santa Fe, New\nMexico to Teterboro, New Jersey, along with Epstein, Maxwell and\nYet there is\nno earlier flight that would have landed Jane Doe No. 3 in New Mexico. According to the logs,\nthe next flight is from Palm Beach to the U.S. Virgin Islands on July 23, 2001, although Jane\nDoe No. 3 does not appear. The impression is that she remained in the New Jersey area.\nHowever, on July 28, 2001, Jane Doe No. 3 is on a flight with Epst\n... [truncated, 2119 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/35 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=35]", "char_count": 2119}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 37 of 40\nThe flight logs provide evidence of some of the individuals who were on some of the\nflights nothing more. Accordingly, it would not be surprising to find that some of these flight\nlogs do not mention Dershowitz, because they were likely designed to hide evidence of criminal\nactivity or perhaps later cleansed of such evidence. With that said, some interesting things do\nappear in the flight logs. Unlike any other of Epstein's numerous criminal defense attorneys,\nDershowitz appears in the flight logs for flights on Epstein's private planes produced by pilot\nRogers on numerous occasions. Dershowitz also appears on flights with various females,\nincluding Epstein's known procurer of underage girls,\nAnd, in contrast to recent\nmedia suggestions by Dershowitz, his family does not appear on any of the flights with him.\nJane Doe No. 3 is listed on the logs as a passenger at a time when she is under age 18.\nWhile the logs do not show Dershowitz on the same flight with her, it is abundantly clear that the\nlogs do not contain evidence of all of the flights that she was on and that they are grossly\nincomplete. The flight logs do confirm that she was transported by Epstein to Florida, New York,\nLondon, New Mexico, and the U.S. Virgin Islands - locations where she states under oath that\nEpstein forced her to have sex with various individuals, including Dershowitz.\nFinally, in Dershowitz's vociferous attacks on Jane Doe No. 3, the Court will see an eerie\nparallel to the Jeffrey Epstein criminal investigation. Back in 2005, when the Palm Beach Police\nDepartment was first investigating Epstein's sexual abuse, it interviewed more than a dozen\nminor girls. These girls all provided information about abuse similar to the abuse that Jane Doe\nNo. 3 says she suffered in Florida. The Department accumulated overwhelming evidence\nplacing underage girls at Epstein's residence with no obvious legal purpose. The log\n... [truncated, 2165 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/36 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=36]", "char_count": 2165}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 38 of 40\nRather than acknowledge sexual abuse of these girls, Dershowitz blustered down to\nFlorida to meet with the State Attorney and to viciously attack the credibility of these victims -\nto call them liars, defame them as prostitutes, and convince the State Attorney that these girls\ncould not even believably establish that they had ever even gone to Epstein's mansion. See, e.g.,\nDepo. of Police Chief Michael Reiter at 53-55, 102-06, B.B. v. Epstein, No. 502008CA037319\nXXXX-MB-AB (Palm Beach Cty. Cir. Ct. Nov. 23, 2009) (excerpts attached as Exhibit 28); see\nalso Depo. of Police Detective Joe Recarey at 301-302 and 309-10, Jane Doe No. 2 v. Epstein,\nNo. 9:08-cv-80119-KAM (S.D. Fla. Mar. 19, 2010) (excerpts attached as Exhibit 29) Later,\nDershowitz would write to tell the Justice Department that\nLetter from Gerald Lefcourt & Alan Dershowitz, July 6, 2007 to U.S. Atty.'s Office for the S.D.\nFla (attached as Exhibit 30). Now, nearly a decade later, there should be no doubt in anyone's\nmind that the minor girls who cooperated with the authorities told the truth about their sexual\nabuse inside Epstein's home -- and that Dershowitz's attack on their credibility was duplicitous.\nIn fact, according to credible eyewitness testimony recounted above, Dershowitz was clearly\npresent in the home while some of these girls were being abused. The Court should not allow\nDershowitz's similar bullying tactics to succeed in this case. 33\nCONCLUSION\nDershowitz's motion for intervention (DE 282) should be denied.\n33\nIn the media, Dershowitz has said that he will prove that Jane Doe No. 3 is lying \"beyond any doubt by\nphysical and documentary evidence.\" The Last Word with Lawrence O'Donnell - MSNBC (Jan. 8, 2015)\nhttp://www.msnbc.com/the-last-word/watch/alan-dershowitz-on-allegations--totally-false-\n381942851573. The Court should compare this media assertion with the materials that Dershowitz files\nalong with his \n... [truncated, 2029 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01191873/37 or ?id=EFTA01191873&page=37]", "char_count": 2029}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 39 of 40\nDATED: January 21, 2015\nRespectfully Submitted,\nBradley J. Edwards\nFARMER, JAFFE, WEISSING,\nEDWARDS, FISTOS & LEHRMAN, P.L.\n425 North Andrews Avenue, Suite 2\nFort Lauderdale, Florida 33301\nTelephone (954) 524-2820\nFacsimile (954) 524-2822\nE-mail: brad@pathtojustice.com\nand\nPaul G. Cassell\nPro Hac Vice\nS.J. Quinney College of Law at the\nUniversity of Utah\"\n332 S. 1400 E.\nSalt Lake City, UT 84112\nTelephone: 801-585-5202\nFacsimile: 801-585-6833\nE-Mail: cassellp@law.utah.edu\nAttorneys for Jane Doe #1 and Jane Doe #2\n*This daytime business address is provided for identification and correspondence purposes only and is\nnot intended to imply institutional endorsement by the University of Utah\n39\nEFTA01191911\n", "char_count": 794}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01191873", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 40 of 40\nCERTIFICATE OF SERVICE\nI certify that the foregoing document was served on January 21, 2015, on the following\nusing the Court's CM/ECF system:\nDexter Lee\nA. Marie Villafaña\n500 S. Australian Ave., Suite 400\nWest Palm Beach, FL 33401\n(561) 820-8711\nFax: (561) 820-8777\nE-mail: Dexter.Lee@usdoj.gov\nE-mail: ann.marie.c.villafana@usdoj.gov\nAttorneys for the Government\nThomas Scott\nthomas.scott@csklegal.com\nCOLE, SCOTT & KISSANE, P.A.\nDadeland Centre II\n9150 South Dadeland Boulevard, Suite 1400\nMiami, Florida 33156\nTelephone: (305) 350-5300\nFacsimile: (305) 373-2294\n-and-\nKendall Coffey\nkcoffey@coffeyburlington.com\nGabriel Groisman\nggroisman@coffeyburlington.com\nBenjamin H. Brodsky\nbbrodsky@coffeyburlington.com\nCOFFEY BURLINGTON, P.L.\n2601 South Bayshore Drive, PH 1\nMiami, Florida 33133\nTelephone: (305) 858-2900\nFacsimile: (305) 858-5261\nAttorneys for Alan Dershowitz\n/s/ Bradley J. Edwards\n40\n40\nEFTA01191912\n", "char_count": 1000}]}