{"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_count": 26, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA01139292", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA01139292.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Filing # 35429605 E-Filed 12/11/2015 10:08:04 AM \nIN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE \nSEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, \nIN AND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, \nFLORIDA \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEDWARDS, et al., \nPlaintiffs / Counterclaim Defendants, \nvs. \nDERSHOWITZ, \nDefendant / Counterclaim Plaintiff. \nDEFENDANT ALAN M. DERSHOWITZ'S \nMOTION IN LIMINE TO OVERRULE OBJECTIONS \nAS TO APPLICATION OF SETTLEMENT RULES \nDefendant Alan M. Dershowitz (\"Dershowitz\") respectfully moves this Court in limine to \noverrule objections to evidence asserted by non-party \n, \nsupposedly based upon the rules governing settlement discussions. The evidence includes \ncommunications by Dershowitz with Roberts's attorney, David Boies (\"Boies\"), in the presence \nof others who have no role as parties or counsel to anyone involved in this matter. Those \ndiscussions were not settlement communications and, regardless, are discoverable evidence. \nAccordingly, Dershowitz seeks a ruling in limine that Dershowitz's discussions with Boies are \ndiscoverable and may not be excluded from evidence on the grounds that they are \"settlement \ncommunications. \nFACTUAL BACKGROUND \nDershowitz's Communications With Boles \n1. \nAs set forth in the Affidavit of Alan M. Dershowitz, attached as Exhibit B, \nI \nEFTA01139292\n", "char_count": 1271}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Dershowitz has had multiple communications in person, by phone, and through videoconference \nwith Boies and others since May 2015 to discuss the untrue and harmful allegations made by \nabout Dershowitz. Dershowitz Aff., ill 3-4. Dershowitz had those communications with \nBoies - someone he has known professionally for many years — in the hopes of convincing Boies \nthat the allegations were verifiably incorrect and so that Boies might assist in getting Ow \npublicly recant her false statements. Dershowitz Aff.,11 2, 5. \n2. \nBoies repeatedly disavowed any ability to settle anything because he does not \nrepresent the Plaintiffs in this case, Edwards and Cassell. Dershowitz Aff., I 5. Neither \nEdwards nor Cassell, nor their counsel, Jack Scarola, participated in the communications \nbetween Dershowitz and Boies. Dershowitz Aff., \n13, 19, 24. \n3. \nOn the other hand, David Stone, who represents neither Boies nor Dershowitz \n(nor Roberts), but who is simply a mutual friend of both Boies and Dershowitz, did participate in \nthe in-person meetings, including the one that Dershowitz participated in via videoconference. \nDershowitz Aff., if 13, 19, 24. \nRoberts's \"Settlement Communications\" Objection to Discovery \n4. \nPlaintiffs in this action began taking Dershowitz's deposition on October 15, \n2015. During that deposition, counsel for non-party Roberts objected to Dershowitz's testimony \nregarding Dershowitz's communications with Mr. Boies, wrongly asserting that they were \nsettlement discussions and insisting that this Court address the issue, as follows: \nQ. ... Did they tell \nyou -- did you ask who contacted Leslie Wexner? \nA. The first answer was \nlawyer. \nI then subsequently learned that among \nthose who contacted Leslie Wexnees lawyers was \nDavid Boies and Sigrid McCawley. \nQ. Not Bradley Edwards, correct? \n2 \nEFTA01139293\n", "char_count": 1848}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "MR. SCOTT: Objection as to the form. \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \nQ. Correct? \nA. I was not given the name Bradley Edwards \nat that time. But was subsequently told by David \nBoies that Bradley Edwards and Paul Cassell --\nMS. McCAWLEY: I'm going to object to the \nextent this reveals any conversations that \nhappened in the context of settlement \ndiscussions. \nMR. SCOTT: Okay. Note your objection. \nGo ahead. \nA. That I was ultimately told by David Boies \nthat he had done an extensive investigation of the \nallegations against Leslie Wexner and had concluded \nthat they were --\nMS. McCAWLEY: Again, I'm going to object \nto this has happened in the context of \nsettlement --\nA. -- false. \nMS. McCAWLEY: -- negotiations. I'm going \nto move for sanctions if information is \nrevealed that happened in the context of \nsettlement discussions. \nMR. SCOTT: I don't know whether -- I \ndon't believe there were settlement \ndiscussions. But even if they weren't, they \nwould still be admissible. \nA. Let me continue --\nMR. SCOTT: For discovery purposes. \nA. -- that David Boies had done --\nMS. McCAWLEY: I disagree. I think we're \ngoing to have to take this to the judge, then; \nif we're going to reveal settlement \nconversations in this conversation, then we \nneed to go to the judge on it. \nSee Excerpts of Deposition of Alan M. Dershowitz, attached hereto as Exhibit A. \n5. \nThe issue arose again, with Roberts's counsel again wrongly insisting that \nevidence was non-discoverable as a settlement communication, as follows: \n... And -- and the very idea that I would \nstand and talk to Jeffrey Epstein while he was \nreceiving oral sex from S\nwhich she \n3 \nEFTA01139294\n", "char_count": 1651}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "swore to under oath, is so outrageous, so \npreposterous, that even David Boies said he couldn't \nbelieve it was true. \nMS. McCAWLEY: I object. I object. I'm \nnot going to allow you to reveal any \nconversations that happened in the context of a \nsettlement discussion. \nId. \n6. \nThe issue then came up a third time, with Dershowitz offering to answer a \nquestion posed by Plaintiffs' counsel, but demurring until this Court could address the \n\"settlement communication\" objection to discovery repeatedly posed by Roberts' counsel: \nQ. Okay. So it has been ten months since you \nallegedly became aware of that suboming of perjury \nand some eight months since your allegedly having \nbecome aware of the extortion plot, but you have \nfiled no criminal complaints against anyone, \ncorrect? \nA. To answer that question requires me to \ndisclose conversations I had with David Boies. I \nwould love to answer that question. \nQ. No, sir, it does not. \nA. Yes, it does. \nMR. SCOTT: Whoa, you can't -- how can you \nsay --\nBY MR. SCAROLA: \nQ. Whether you filed a criminal complaint or \nnot. \nA. Yes, it does. \nMR. SCOTT: Please, Jack, he can't say \nthat. \nA. It does involve conversation I had with \nDavid Boies. \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \nQ. Well, in that case, in light of the fact \nthat that is a matter that will be addressed by the \nCourt, we'll save that question for another time. \nA. I'm anxious to answer it. \nQ. And I'm anxious to get an answer. \nA. Well, I hope we can agree I should be able \nto answer it. \n4 \nEFTA01139295\n", "char_count": 1513}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Id. \n7. \nThe continuation of Dershowitz's deposition is currently being scheduled for the \nnext mutually convenient date for the witness and counsel. \nARGUMENT \n8. \nFlorida's rules of evidence and procedure that apply to discovery and \nadmissibility of settlement communications have no application here. First, the communications \nbetween Dershowitz and Boies are not settlement communications. Boies expressly stated that \nhe had absolutely no authority to settle the defamation action between Plaintiffs and Dershowitz. \nInstead, both Boies and Dershowitz confirmed with each other that the purpose of the \ncommunications were simply an opportunity for Dershowitz to provide documentary evidence \nthat = \nallegations about him were untrue, so that Boies might convince Roberts that she \nwas mistaken in naming Dershowitz in her affidavit that was filed in the CVRA action. \n9. \nThere is no claim or lawsuit that has been asserted between Dershowitz and \nRoberts. There is no claim that Dershowitz and Boies could be settling through the described \ncommunications since Boies does not represent anyone in litigation with Dershowitz. \n10. \nNor could the mediation privilege under Fla. Stat. 44.1011, et seq. apply because \nthe communications between Dershowitz and Boies were not \"mediation communications\" as \ndefined in the statute. See Ha. Stat. § 44.403(1) (2004) (\"Mediation communication' means an \noral or written statement, or nonverbal conduct intended to make an assertion, by or to a \nmediation participant made during the course of a mediation, or prior to mediation if made in \nfurtherance of a mediation. The commission of a crime during a mediation is not a mediation \ncommunication.\") (emphasis added). \nII. \nThe participants in the communications made no effort to protect their discussions \n5 \nEFTA01139296\n", "char_count": 1826}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "as privileged for settlement purposes. To the contrary, by including David Stone, who is not \ncounsel for any party involved, in the communications, the participants effectively precluded any \nlater assertion of privilege. Cf. Ha. Stat. § 90.502(c) (2000) (attorney-client privilege cannot be \nmaintained where disclosed to third party unless the \"disclosure is in furtherance of the rendition \nof legal services to the client\" and the third party is \"reasonably necessary for the transmission of \nthe communication.\"). \nMoreover, Boies never requested and the participants in the \ncommunications never executed a written confidentiality agreement for their discussions. \n12. \nSecond, even if the communications between Dershowitz and Boies somehow \nwere settlement communications, they are discoverable evidence. Inadmissibility at trial is not \nthe determining factor of whether or not the discussions are discoverable. They are discoverable \nif it appears they are reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence. Ha. \nR. Civ. P. 1.280 (b)(1); Amente v. Newman, 653 So.2d 1030 (Fla. 1995) (relevancy concept is \nbroader in discovery context than in trial context, and party may be permitted to discover \nrelevant evidence that would be inadmissible at trial if it may lead to discovery of relevant \nevidence). Because the permissible scope of discovery is so broad, a \"trial court is given wide \ndiscretion in dealing with discovery matters, and unless there is a clear abuse of that discretion, \nthe appellate court will not disturb the trial court's order.\" Alvarez v. Cooper Tire & Rubber Co., \n75 So.3d 789, 793 (Fla. 4th DCA 2011). Roberts, as the objecting party, would have a \"heavy \nburden\" to show that the trial court's order departs from the essential requirements of law. \nElsner v. E-Commerce Coffee Club, 126 So.3d 1261, 1263 (Fla. 4th DCA 2013). Plaintiffs have \nrepeatedly sought the information at issue in deposition of Dershowitz, presumably because they \n\n... [truncated, 2214 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01139292/5 or ?id=EFTA01139292&page=5]", "char_count": 2214}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "13. \nAdmissibility at trial is a different issue, and the discussions at issue here are \nadmissible for relevant purposes in any event. Florida Evidence Code Section 90.408 excludes \nevidence of an offer to compromise a claim which was disputed and statements made in \nnegotiations concerning a compromise when it is offered \"to prove liability or absence of \nliability for the claim or its value.\" The subject of the Boies/Dershowitz discussions was not an \noffer to compromise, and Boies expressly made clear that was not his intended topic of \ndiscussion and he had no such authority. Similarly, Florida Statute Section 768.041(3) states: \n\"The fact of such a release or covenant not to sue, or that any defendant has been dismissed by \norder of the court shall not be made known to the jury.\" None of the forbidden subjects — an \noffer to compromise, a release, a covenant not to sue, or a dismissal — exists here. Thus, even the \nmost remotely relevant rules do not provide a blanket prohibition on the admission of what Boies \nand Dershowitz discussed, provided that the evidence is relevant to a fact in dispute and that the \ntestimony is otherwise admissible under the Rules of Evidence. \nCONCLUSION \nAs shown above, the communications between Dershowitz and Boies, in the presence of \nothers who have no role as parties or counsel to anyone involved in this matter, were not \nsettlement communications and, regardless, are discoverable evidence. Accordingly, Dershowitz \nrequests that the Court rule in limine that Dershowitz's discussions with Boies are discoverable \nand may be used at trial, subject only to the rules of evidence concerning relevance and \nadmissibility. \n7 \nEFTA01139298\n", "char_count": 1700}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Dated: December 11, 2015 \nRespectfully submitted, \ns/ Thomas E. Scott \nThomas E. Scott, FBN 149100 \nThomas.scott@csklegal.com \nSteven R. Safra, FBN 057028 \nSteven.safra@csklegal.com \nCOLE, SCOTT & KISSANE, P.A. \nDadeland Centre II, 14th Floor \n9150 South Dadeland Boulevard \nMiami, Florida 33156 \nPhone: (305) 350-5300 \nFax: (305) 373-2294 \nRichard A. Simpson (pro hac vice) \nrsimpson@wileyrein.com \nMary E. Soda (pro hac vice) \nmborja@wileyrein.com \nAshley E. Eiler (pro hac vice) \naeiler@wileyrein.com \nNicole Audet Richardson (pro hac vice) \nnrichardson@wileyrein.com \nWILEY REIN LLP \n1776 K Street NW \nWashington, DC 20006 \nPhone: (202) 719-7000 \nFax: (202) 719-7049 \nCounsel for Alan M. Dershowitz \nEFTA01139299\n", "char_count": 717}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE \nI HEREBY CERTIFY that a copy of the foregoing has been electronically filed through \nthe Clerk of Broward County by using the Florida Courts eFiling Portal and thus served by \nelectronic mail (email) at email address: jsx@searcylaw.com, \nmep@searcylaw.com, \nscarolateam@searcylaw.com to: Jack Scarola, Esq, Searcy Denney Scarola Barnhart & Shipley, \nP.A., Counsel for Plaintiff, 2139 Palm Beach Lakes Blvd., West Palm Beach, Florida 33409, as \nwell as jonijones@utah.gov to: Joni J. Jones, Esq., Assistant Utah Attorney General, Counsel \nfor Plaintiff Cassell, 160 East 300 South, Salt Lake City, Utah 84114 this Ilth day of December, \n2015. \nBy:  sffhomas E. Scott \nTHOMAS E. SCOTT \nFBN: 149100 \nSTEVEN R. SAFRA \nFBN: 057028 \n9 \nEFTA01139300\n", "char_count": 767}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "EXHIBIT A \nEFTA01139301\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "1 \nIN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE SEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL \nCIRCUIT IN AND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA \nCASE NO.: CACE 15-000072 \nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS and PAUL G. \nCASSELL„ \nPlaintiffs, \nvs. \nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ, \nDefendant. \n \n/ \nVIDEOTAPE DEPOSITION OF \nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ \nVOLUME 1 \nPages 1 through 179 \nThursday, October 15, 2015 \n9:31 a.m. - 4:13 p.m. \nCole Scott & Kissane \n110 Southeast 6th Street \nFort Lauderdale, Florida \nStenographically Reported By: \nKimberly Fontalvo, RPR, CLR \nRealtime Systems Administrator \nEFTA01139302\n", "char_count": 527}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "82 \n1 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n11:23:52 \n2 \nQ. \nBut they wouldn't tell you who? \n11:23:53 \n3 \nA. \nThey wouldn't show me any letter. \n11:23:55 \n4 \nQ. \nThat's not my question. Did they tell \n11:23:58 \n5 \nyou -- did you ask who contacted Leslie Wexner? \n6 \nA. \nThe first answer was \n11:24:07 \n7 \nlawyer. \n8 \nI then subsequently learned that among \n11:24:11 \n9 \nthose who contacted Leslie Wexner's lawyers was \n10 \nDavid Boies and Sigrid McCawley. \n11 \nQ. \nNot Bradley Edwards, correct? \n11:24:24 \n12 \nMR. SCOTT: Objection as to the form. \n11:24:27 \n13 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n11:24:28 \n14 \nQ. \nCorrect? \n11:24:29 \n15 \nA. \nI was not given the name Bradley Edwards \n11:24:30 \n16 \nat that time. But was subsequently told by David \n17 \nBoies that Bradley Edwards and Paul Cassell --\n18 \nMS. McCAWLEY: I'm going to object to the \n11:24:43 \n19 \nextent this reveals any conversations that \n20 \nhappened in the context of settlement \n21 \ndiscussions. \n22 \nMR. SCOTT: Okay. Note your objection. \n11:24:48 \n23 \nGo ahead. \n24 \nA. \nThat I was ultimately told by David Boies \n11:24:52 \n25 \nthat he had done an extensive investigation of the \nEFTA01139303\n", "char_count": 1126}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "83 \n1 \nallegations against Leslie Wexner and had concluded \n2 \nthat they were \n3 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Again, I'm going to object \n11:25:05 \n4 \nto this has happened in the context of \n5 \nsettlement --\n6 \nA. \n-- false. \n11:25:07 \n7 \nMS. McCAWLEY: -- negotiations. I'm going \n11:25:07 \n8 \nto move for sanctions if information is \n9 \nrevealed that happened in the context of \n10 \nsettlement discussions. \n11 \nMR. SCOTT: I don't know whether -- I \n11:25:12 \n12 \ndon't believe there were settlement \n13 \ndiscussions. But even if they weren't, they \n14 \nwould still be admissible. \n15 \nA. \nLet me continue -- \n11:25:21 \n16 \nMR. SCOTT: For discovery purposes. \n11:25:22 \n17 \nA. \n-- that David Boies had done -- \n11:25:23 \n18 \nMS. McCAWLEY: I disagree. I think we're \n11:25:24 \n19 \ngoing to have to take this to the judge, then; \n20 \nif we're going to reveal settlement \n21 \nconversations in this conversation, then we \n22 \nneed to go to the judge on it. \n23 \nMR. SCOTT: Whatever you need to do. \n11:25:31 \n24 \nA. \nLet me continue the -- what he told me. \n11:25:33 \n25 \nThat David Boies had --\nEFTA01139304\n", "char_count": 1092}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "94 \n1 \nabsolutely, categorically lying. So I am completely \n2 \naware that never, until the lies were put in a legal \n3 \npleading at the end of December 2014, it was never \n4 \nalleged that I had any sexual contact with \n5 \n6 \nI know that it was alleged that I was a \n11:38:46 \n7 \nwitness to Jeffrey Epstein's alleged abuse and that \n8 \nwas false. I was never a witness to any of Jeffrey \n9 \nEpstein's sexual abuse. And I wrote that to you, \n10 \nsomething that you have falsely denied. And I stand \n11 \non the record. The record is clear that I have \n12 \ncategorically denied I was ever a witness to any \n13 \nabuse, that I ever saw Jeffrey Epstein abusing \n14 \nanybody. \n15 \nAnd -- and the very idea that I would \n11:39:18 \n16 \nstand and talk to Jeffrey Epstein while he was \n17 \nreceiving oral sex from \nwhich she \n18 \nswore to under oath, is so outrageous, so \n19 \npreposterous, that even David Boies said he couldn't \n20 \nbelieve it was true. \n21 \nMS. McCAWLEY: I object. I object. I'm \n11:39:40 \n22 \nnot going to allow you to reveal any \n23 \nconversations that happened in the context of a \n24 \nsettlement discussion. \n25 \nTHE WITNESS: Does she have standing? \n11:39:46 \nEFTA01139305\n", "char_count": 1186}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "107 \n1 \nA. \nWe actually talked about that. And -- \n12:11:47 \n2 \nQ. \nWho's the \"we\"? \n12:11:50 \n3 \nMR. SIMPSON: Don't disclose any -- \n12:11:53 \n4 \nTHE WITNESS: Okay -- \n12:11:53 \n5 \nMR. SIMPSON: -- lawyer-client \n12:11:54 \n6 \nA. \nI had conversations about that with \n12:11:55 \n7 \nappropriate persons, yes. And I discussed it with \n8 \nWexner's lawyers. \n9 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n12:12:07 \n10 \nQ. \nAre you answering yes to my question that \n12:12:08 \n11 \nyou have filed a criminal complaint? \n12 \nA. \nNot yet. \n12:12:12 \n13 \nQ. \nOkay. So it has been ten months since you \n12:12:14 \n14 \nallegedly became aware of that suborning of perjury \n15 \nand some eight months since your allegedly having \n16 \nbecome aware of the extortion plot, but you have \n17 \nfiled no criminal complaints against anyone, \n18 \ncorrect? \n19 \nA. \nTo answer that question requires me to \n12:12:40 \n20 \ndisclose conversations I had with David Boies. I \n21 \nwould love to answer that question. \n22 \nQ. \nNo, sir, it does not. \n12:12:48 \n23 \nA. \nYes, it does. \n12:12:49 \n24 \nMR. SCOTT: Whoa, you can't -- how can you \n12:12:49 \n25 \nsay --\nEFTA01139306\n", "char_count": 1113}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "108 \n1 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n12:12:51 \n2 \nQ. \nWhether you filed a criminal complaint or \n12:12:51 \n3 \nnot. \n4 \nA. \nYes, it does. \n12:12:52 \n5 \nMR. SCOTT: Please, Jack, he can't say \n12:12:53 \n6 \nthat. \n7 \nA. \nIt does involve conversation I had with \n12:12:54 \n8 \nDavid Boies. \n9 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n12:12:57 \n10 \nQ. \nWell, in that case, in light of the fact \n12:12:57 \n11 \nthat that is a matter that will be addressed by the \n12 \nCourt, we'll save that question for another time. \n13 \nA. \nI'm anxious to answer it. \n12:13:05 \n14 \nQ. \nAnd I'm anxious to get an answer. \n12:13:09 \n15 \nA. \nWell, I hope we can agree I should be able \n12:13:10 \n16 \nto answer it. \n17 \nQ. \nHave we exhausted your recollection of the \n12:13:20 \n18 \ndetails of conversations that you had with Rebecca \n19 \nand Michael? \n20 \nA. \nAbout the substance of what she told me. \n12:13:27 \n21 \nThere were many conversations involving would she do \n22 \nthis, would she do that. But the conversations, the \n23 \nsubstance we've exhausted. \n24 \nQ. \nOkay. Well -- \n12:13:40 \n25 \nA. \nThat is A, B, C, D, E, as I said, those \n12:13:40 \nEFTA01139307\n", "char_count": 1102}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "EXHIBIT B \nEFTA01139308\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE \nSEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT \nIN AND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, \nFLORIDA \nCASE NO.: CACE 15-000072 \nEDWARDS, et al., \nPlaintiffs / Counterclaim Defendants, \nv. \nDERSHOWITZ, \nDefendant / Counterclaim Plaintiff. \nAFFIDAVIT OF ALAN M. DERSHOWITZ \nREGARDING MEETINGS WITH DAVID BOIES \nA. Introduction \n1. My name is Alan M. Dershowitz. I make this declaration on personal knowledge \nconcerning my discussions with David Boies about \n2. I have known attorney David Boies, professionally, for many years. David \nBoies's law firm, Boies Schiller & Flexner, LLP, currently represents \nMMI \nhas made horrible, untrue accusations about me in \nan action pending in federal court (the \"CVRA action\"), where Ms. \nis \nrepresented by Bradley Edwards and Paul Cassell, the plaintiffs in this action. \n3. Since the Spring of 2015, I have had conversations with Mr. Boies about Ms. \n's accusations and the many ways in which they are verifiably untrue. \n4. Over the course of several conversations in person, over the phone, and on \nSkype, Mr. Boies repeatedly stated that he did not believe the allegations that Ms. \nhad made against me were factually true. He also stated that the \n1 \nEFTA01139309\n", "char_count": 1204}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "decision to name me in the CVRA lawsuit by Messrs. Edwards and Cassell was \nboth \"stupid\" and \"wrong\", that they had undermined the interests of their client, \nand that after reviewing the evidence I presented to him, he believed that Ms. \nhad mistakenly identified me. \n5. Mr. Boies repeatedly stated that he had absolutely no authority to settle the \npending case between me and Messrs. Cassell and Edwards. He told me that our \nconversations were an opportunity for me to provide documentary evidence \nthat Ms. \ns allegations about me were untrue, so that he might convince \nMs. =that \nshe was mistaken in naming me in the CVRA suit. I explained to \nMr. Boies that I was willing to provide him with the most minute details of my \ndaily life because I wanted Ms. iublicly \nto recant her false statements. \nAt no point since Ms. I\nmade public her allegations against me was I \ninvolved in settlement negotiations with Mr. Boies, nor is there any claim or \nlawsuit between myself and Mr. Boies's client, Min, \nto settle. There is, \nhowever, the critical matter of clearing my good name and restoring my \nreputation. \nB. Summary of What Mr. Boies Told Me \n6. When I first spoke with Mr. Boles regarding Ms. In \nallegations about me, I \ntold him that I was assembling documentation that showed that I could not have \nbeen in the locations where Ms. F= \nsaid she had sex with me. According to \nmy contemporaneous notes, Mr. Boies said that he was: \n\"very much upset at the fact that my name was included in the federal pleading... He \nproposed the following way of going forward. He would like me to bring my timeline of \nevidence to him, Sigrid McCauley and to \nn an effort to persuade Roberts that I \n2 \nEFTA01139310\n", "char_count": 1716}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "could not have been at the places where she claims to have had sex with me. He hopes that \nwhen she sees my evidence she will acknowledge that she made a mistake. He said it won't be \neasy for her to do that, but that it would be the best thing for her and her case to acknowledge \nher mistake. Again he repeated that if she refuses to do that, he could not ethically continue to \nrepresent her and would leave the matter to the other two lawyers. ... The meeting was entirely \namicable and I came away convinced that David Boles firmly believed that I have been falsely \naccused and wanted to make it right by getting me out of the case and by having her withdraw \nher false accusation.-\n7. At a subsequent meeting he told me that: \n\"the lawyers who put your name in the federal pleading, not only did a stupid thing that hurt \ntheir clients, they also did the wrong thing. They never should have accused you of so heinous a \ncrime without checking and double checking, the way I did with the person I called.\" \n8. He also told me that he believes that Messrs. Edwards and Cassell had a \"conflict \nof interest\" with their client Ms. \n9. At that same meeting, according to my contemporaneous notes, Mr. Boles also said \nin front of several witnesses that: \n\"His goal was to persuade \nthat she was mistaken in identifying me as a person \nwith whom she had sex. \ne said he tun s that she actually believes that, but she is mistaken. I \nchallenged his view that she actually believes she had sex with me, pointing to the fact that she \nhas also said that she had dinner with Bill Clinton and Al Gore and his wife on the \nisland. David responded by saying \"I have never challenged Virginia with regard to her \nstatements about Al and Tipper Gore and I am not vouching for her general credibility, but I \nthink she has come to believe the story about you.\" \n10. At the second and third meetings, I agreed to show Mr. Boies evidence proving \nmy location for the duration of the time period for which M= \nwa\n... [truncated, 3052 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01139292/19 or ?id=EFTA01139292&page=19]", "char_count": 3052}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "when I told him that Virginia had sworn that she gave Epstein oral sex while I stood next to him \ntalking to him. He asked Sigrid to show him the affidavit in which she made that claim and he \nseemed to be shocked by it.\" \nI I. On several occasions, I asked Mr. Boles what his next step would be and he told \nme that he and his law firm partner, Sigrid McCawley, would meet with Ms. \nand tell her that although she might believe she had sexual contact with \nProfessor Dershowitz, they had reviewed the documentary evidence and \"are \nconvinced that your belief is wrong.\" They said they would explain to her how \nshe could have, at her age and under the circumstances, \"misidentified \nsomebody.\" He said he would tell her that one thing is clear: \"Your conclusion is \nsimply wrong.\" \n12. Mr. Boles also told me that the documents he reviewed would \"make it \nimpossible for you to have been in the island, or on the ranch\" during the \nrelevant time period. \nC. Detailed Description of Meetings with Mr. Boies \nFirst Meeting with David Boies (19 May 2015) \n13. My first meeting with Mr. Boies regarding the allegations made against me by \nMs \noccurred on 19 May 2015 in New York. A mutual friend of ours, \nDavid Stone, arranged and attended the meeting. Mr. Stone is an attorney but he \nis not counsel for me or for Messrs. Edwards or Cassell (or fa). \n14. At the meeting, after I told Mr. Boies that my records demonstrated that Ms. \nallegations could not be true, he told me that he was very upset that \nmy name had been included in the federal pleading. He described the decision of \nMessrs. Edwards and Cassell to \"name names\" in the CVRA action as a self-\n4 \nEFTA01139312\n", "char_count": 1674}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "inflicted wound. Ile said that had any of MsM's \nrepresentatives asked his \nopinion, he would have opposed the inclusion of any names in the federal filing, \nincluding my own. \n15. Mr. Boles further stated during our meeting that he was now convinced that Ms. \nwas mistaken in naming me as someone with whom she had sex. He \nsaid that it was his obligation to try to persuade her to acknowledge that I could \nnot have been among the people with whom she had sex. He said that if he failed \nto persuade her of that, he would leave her representation to Messrs. Edwards \nand Cassell and no longer represent her. He said that although he is always \nreluctant to drop a client, especially in a pro bono case, he would feel \ncomfortable doing that in this case because she is adequately represented by her \ntwo other lawyers. He said that it would be a win•win both for me and for Ms. \nM\n, were she now to acknowledge that she had made a mistake in naming \nme. He said that he was convinced that I did not and could not have had sex with \nher. \n16. Mr. Boies also told me that Ms.=iad \ninformed him that she had sex with \nanother prominent individual, who had not been identified by name in the \nfederal suit filing. He did not name this individual to me at that time, but he said \nhe had spoken to him, and was now convinced that Ms. l=was \nmistaken \nregarding her allegations against him as well. He described Ms. Roberts as an \nimpressionable girl who was totally confused about who it was she had sex with \nwhile she was associated with Mr. Epstein many years ago. Mr. Boies said he had \npersuaded Ms. \nnot to name this third individual, and so far she had \n5 \nEFTA01139313\n", "char_count": 1673}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "accepted his advice. I learned the name of the prominent businessman whom \nMs \nhas also accused from one of Ms. Roberts' closest friends who called \nme. I confirmed the account with the businessman's attorney. \n17. Mr. Boles proposed that we should meet again at a later date, together with Ms. \nMcCawley, and perhaps with Ms. \nherself. Mr. Boles asked me to bring \nmy timeline of evidence, so that I might persuade Ms. I \nc that I could not \nhave been at the places where she claims to have had sex me. He said that he \nhoped she would see the evidence and acknowledge that she made a mistake, \nbut that it would not be easy for her to do so. \n18. After the conclusion of this first meeting, I called one of my secretaries, Ms. \nMaura Kelly, and dictated my recollection of events. I felt entirely confident that \nMr. Boles firmly believed that I had been falsely accused, and that he wanted to \nmake it right by getting Mse \nwithdraw her false accusation. \nSecond Meeting With David Boles (1 June 2015) \n19. After corresponding further with Mr. Boles and Mr. Stone, we agreed to all meet \nagain on 1 June 2015, together with Ms. McCawley, another woman from Mr. \nBoies's firm whose name I do not recall, and my research assistant. Mr. Maisel. \n20. 1 brought with me to the second meeting a timeline detailing my locations \nbetween August 1999 and September 2002—the time period for Ms. \naccusations against me—based on my financial and cell phone records, my daily \ncalendar, my wife's calendars, my class schedules, and other documentation. \n21. Before showing Ms. McCawley and Mr. Boles the timeline and the supporting \ndocumentation, Mr. Boles and I talked at length about the CVRA case, and he \n6 \nEFTA01139314\n", "char_count": 1717}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "reiterated many of the same points that he made at our first meeting. He stated \nthat he felt that the lawyers—Messrs. Edwards and Cassell—were facing a \nconflict of interests by suing me for defamation, while continuing to represent \nM= \nin the CVRA case. Mr. Boies stated that this meeting was a chance \nfor me to show him and Ms. McCawley the evidence that I had compiled proving \nthat Ms. \n' allegations in my regard were false. \n22. Mr. Boies reviewed the timeline for approximately an hour and a half, and \nrepeatedly asked to see the supporting documentation, in particular cell phone \nrecords. I told him that the records were quite thorough but that because the \nevents in question had happened over a decade ago, I was still working on \ncollecting documentation. He said that the more complete the records were, the \nbetter he would be able to persuade Ms \nthat it was impossible that I \ncould be the person with whom she had six sexual encounters. \n23. At the end of the meeting, Mr. Boies stated that he found the evidence extremely \ncompelling but that before he met with Ms. \nto try and convince her of \nmy innocence, he wanted the record to be as complete as possible. He told me \nthat: \"the lawyers who put your name in the federal pleading not only did a \nstupid thing that hurt their clients, they also did the wrong thing. They never \nshould have accused you of so heinous a crime without checking and double \nchecking, the way I did with the person I called.\" lie said that we should meet \nagain after I had assembled all of the relevant records. I agreed, and told him I \nwould be in touch as soon as possible. After the meeting, I wrote an email to one \nof my secretaries, Sarah Neely, documenting my recollection of events. \n7 \nEFTA01139315\n", "char_count": 1764}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Third Meeting with David Boies (6 July 2015) \n24. The third meeting took place on 6 July 2015. Mr. Boles, Mr. Maisel, Mr. Stone, \nand Ms. McCawley attended in person, and I participated by videoconference, \nthrough Skype. Over the course of the meeting, Mr. Boies conducted a detailed \nexamination of the timeline that Mr. Maisel had put together, and repeatedly \nasked to look at phone records and financial documentation. \n25. At the conclusion of the meeting, Mr. Boies told me that he would meet with Ms. \nRoberts in the near future and try to convince her that she had made a mistake \nin identifying me as someone she had sex with. \n26. Before and after these meetings, I have had numerous telephone conversations \nwith Mr. Boies about Ms. FM, \nincluding as recently as this weekend. \n// \n// \n// \n// \n// \n// \n// \n// \n// \n// \n// \n• \n8 \nEFTA01139316\n", "char_count": 853}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01139292", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "To: \nPeg* 10 dig \nRECEIVED \n12/10/2815 1@: 59AM \n2O15512.1091:00'52 EST \nWiley Rein LLP From Peggy Thorn \n• \n• . \nthat rain Siveniing or affirming under oatli to etruffiinktess of \nmade in this affidavit and that Ito punishment fit knowingly, \nfalse statement' indudesligeijad/or I \n01 \nprisOO \n*: \nII»cembet 10.2015 . \nAlan rd. Dorsliowi\"tt. \n) ,CP/ni,1416i Pel4 \nor affinnedopAsigned before me on \nby \n•KATNYMcSOLORICK \nPublic. State of Nevreidket \n.Qualified in Nassau County \nNo. 01:AC13312831 \nesion Swims 10/06/201S \nEFTA01139317\n", "char_count": 536}]}