{"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_count": 130, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA01116693", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA01116693.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Filing # 34801581 E-Filed 11/23/2015 05:53:31 PM \nIN \nTHE \nCIRCUIT \nCOURT \nOF \nTHE \nSEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN \nAND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA \nCASE NO.: CACE 15-000072 \nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS and PAUL G. \nCASSELL, \nPlaintiffs, \nvs. \nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ, \nDefendant. \nPLAINTIFFS/COUNTERCLAIM DEFENDANT EDWARDS AND \nCASSELL'S RESPONSE TO DERSHOWITZ'S MOTION TO DETERMINE \nCONFIDENTIALITY OF COURT RECORDS \nPlaintiffs/Counterclaim Defendants Bradley J. Edwards and Paul G. Cassell, by and \nthrough their undersigned attorneys, hereby file this response to Dershowitz's Motion to \nDetermine Confidentiality of Court Records. The records at issue are not confidential, and so the \nCourt should deny Dershowitz's motion in its entirety. \nThe court records at issue are three court filings by attorneys Edwards and Cassell \nin which they recite their client's (Mr. \nallegations that she was sexually \nabused by Dershowitz. These records are hardly \"confidential\" in this defamation case, \nwhere the \nparties \nhave \nclaims and counterclaims about \nthese sexual abuse \nAllegations. Rather, these records are an important part of this case, since they not only \nsupport the conclusion that Dershowitz abused Ms. \na\nl\n \nut also indisputably establish \nEdwards and Cassell's strong basis for filing the allegations on her behalf. Moreover, \ncontrary to assertions made in Dershowitz's motion, these documents have never been \nfound to be \"confidential\" by any other court. And Dershowitz has repeatedly referred to \nEFTA01116693\n", "char_count": 1520}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Response to Dershowitz's Motion to Determine Confidentiality of Court Records \nPage 2 of 20 \nthese documents, not only in defamatory statements broadcast worldwide, but also in his \npleadings before this Court and in recent depositions. Indeed, Dershowitz said in his \nmedia interviews that he wants \"everything to be made public\" and implied that Edwards \nand Cassell had something to hide. Accordingly, Dershowitz has failed to carry his heavy \nburden to justify sealing these presumptively-public documents. \nI. \nDERSHOWITZ HAS NOT JUSTIFIED SEALING ALLEGED \nDEFAMATORY RECORDS THAT ARE INTEGRAL TO THIS \nDEFAMATION CASE. \nIn his motion, Dershowitz never recounts the heavy burden that he must carry to seal the \nrecords at issue. To be sure, Florida Rule of Judicial Administration 2.420 allows for the sealing \nof \"confidential\" materials. But the Rule begins by recounting the overarching principle that \n\"[t]he public shall have access to all records of the judicial branch of government, except as \nprovided below.\" Fla. R. Jud. Admin. 2.420(a). This rule is a codification of the Florida \nSupreme Court's admonition that a \"a strong presumption of openness exists for all court \nproceedings. A trial is a public event, and the filed records of court proceedings are public \nrecords available for public examination.\" Barron v. Florida Freedom Newspapers, Inc., 531 \nSo.2d 113, 118 (Fla. 1988) (emphasis added). In light of this presumption of openness, \"[t]he \nburden of proof in [closure] proceedings shall always be on the party seeking closure.\" Id. To \nobtain a sealing order, the party seeking sealing must carry a \"heavy burden.\" Id. \nRemarkably, Dershowitz fails to acknowledge these well-settled principles. More \nimportant, he even fails to cite (much less discuss) the limited substantive exceptions to this \ngeneral principle of access — and which specific exception he believes applies to this \nEFTA\n... [truncated, 2009 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/1 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=1]", "char_count": 2009}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and CasselIs Response to Dershowitz's Motion to Determine Confidentiality of Court Records \nPage 3 of 20 \ncase. Accordingly, it is impossible for Edwards and Cassell to respond with precision to his \nmotion. \nThe exceptions that might arguably be in play in this case permit records to be maintained \nas confidential in order to: \n(1) \nPrevent a serious and imminent threat to the fair, impartial, and orderly \nadministration of justice; \n(ii) \nProtect trade secrets; \n(iii) \nProtect a compelling governmental interest; \n(iv) \nObtain evidence to determine legal issues in a case; \n(v) \nAvoid substantial injury to innocent third parties; \n(vi) \nAvoid substantial injury to a party by disclosure of matters protected by a \ncommon law or privacy right not generally inherent in the specific type of \nproceeding sought to be closed; \n(vii) \nComply with established public policy set forth in the Florida or United \nStates Constitution or statutes or Florida rules or case law . \nFla. R. Jud. Admin. 2.420(c)(9) (codifying the holding in Barron v. Florida Freedom \nNewspapers, Inc., 531 So.2d 113 (Fla. 1988)). The only exception that seems to even arguably \napply here is exception vi, which itself specifically provides that confidentiality is appropriate \nonly where disclosure is \"not generally inherent in the specific type of proceeding sought to be \nclosed\" (emphasis added). Of course, this lawsuit is a defamation action — involving \na defamation claim \nby \nEdwards \nand \nCassell \nand \na defamation counterclaim \nby \nDershowitz. Disclosure, discussion, and debate about the defamatory statements at issue lies at \nthe heart of the case. Accordingly, disclosure of these materials is \"inherent\" in the case itself. \nThe principle that defamatory material in a defamation case cannot be sealed is recognized \nin Carnegie v. Tedder, 698 So.2d 1310 (2d DCA 1997). Carnegie involved a claim and \ncounterclaim between two parties (Car\n... [truncated, 2072 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/2 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=2]", "char_count": 2072}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE I5-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Response to Dershowitz's Motion to Determine Confidentiality of Court Records \nPage 4 of 20 \nthe \nmaterials \nin \nthe \nrecords \nwould \nbe \nharmful \nto \nhis \nprofessional \nreputation. Carnegie recited subsection vi's restriction on release of materials involving a \nprivacy right, but noted that \"statements Tedder alleged were defamatory and damaging were \nallegations \nin \nCamegie's \ncounterclaim \nfor \nwhich \nshe seeks damages. \nThese matters were not peripheral to the lawsuit; they were inherent to it.\" Id. at 1312. Of \ncourse, exactly the same principle applies here: \nEdwards and Cassell for their client M \ne not peripheral to this lawsuit — they \nare inherent to it. \nTo see how \"inherent\" the sexual abuse allegations are to this lawsuit, the Court need \nlook no further than Dershowitz's counterclaim in this case. Count I of Dershowitz's \nCounterclaim (styled as \"False Allegations in the Joinder Motion\") contends that Edwards and \nCassell should pay him damages because they \"filed a pleading in the Federal Action titled `Jane \nDoe #3 and Jane Doe #4's Motion Pursuant to Rule 21 for Joinder in Action' . . . .\" Dershowitz \nCounterclaim at ¶ 14. Dershowitz's Counterclaim then goes on to quote at length from the \nJoinder Motion. His counterclaim contains, for example, this paragraph recounting the \nallegations: \nThe Joinder Motion then goes on to allege — without any supporting evidence — as \nfollows: \nsexual abuse allegations filed by attorneys \nOne such powerful individual that Epstein forced then-minor Jane Doe #3 to \nhave sexual relations with was former Harvard Law Professor Alan \nDershowitz, a close friend of Epstein's and well-known criminal defense \nattorney. Epstein required Jane Doe #3 to have sexual relations with \nDershowitz on numerous occasions while she was a minor, not only in Florida \nbut also on private planes, in New York, New Mexico, and the U.S. Virgin \nEFTA01116696\n", "char_count": 1995}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Response to Dershowitz's Motion to Determine Confidentiality of Court Records \nPage 5 of 20 \nIslands. In addition to being a participant in the abuse of Jane Doe #3 and other \nminors, Dershowitz was an eye-witness to the sexual abuse of many other \nminors by Epstein and several of Epstein's coconspirators. Dershowitz would \nlater play a significant role in negotiating the [Non-Prosecution Agreement] on \nEpstein's behalf. Indeed, Dershowitz helped negotiate an agreement that \nprovided immunity from federal prosecution in the Southern District of Florida \nnot only to Epstein, but also to \"any potential coconspirators of Epstein.\" Thus, \nDershowitz helped negotiate an agreement with a provision that provided \nprotection for himself against criminal prosecution in Florida for sexually \nabusing Jane Doe #3. Because this broad immunity wouldhave been \ncontroversial if disclosed, Dershowitz (along with other members of Epstein's \ndefense team) and the Government tried to keep the immunity provision secret \nfrom all of Epstein's victims and the general public, even though such secrecy \nviolated the Crime Victims' Rights Act. \nDershowitz Counterclaim at 1115 (quoting Joinder Motion at 4). \nRemarkably, having quoted at length from the Joinder Motion in his Counterclaim in this \ncase, Dershowitz now seeks to have that very same language from the Joinder Motion deemed \n\"confidential\" and sealed. Compare Counterclaim at ¶15 (block quotation above) with Motion to \nDetermine Confidentiality, Exhibit A at 4 (composite exhibit with proposed \"confidential\" \ndocument that includes paragraph beginning \"[o]ne such powerful individual that Epstein forced \nthen-minor Jane Doe #3 to have sexual relations with was former Harvard Law Professor Alan \nDershowitz, a close friend of Epstein's . . . .\"). Dershowitz cannot come before this Court and \nfile a counterclaim seeking damages from Edwards and Cassell for alle\n... [truncated, 2294 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/4 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=4]", "char_count": 2294}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Response to Dershowitz's Motion to Determine Confidentiality of Court Records \nPage 6 of 20 \nwhen the medical condition becomes an integral part of the civil proceeding, particularly when \nthe condition is asserted as an issue by the party seeking closure\" (emphasis added)). \nH. \nJUDGE MARRA'S ORDER IN HIS CASE DOES NOT REQUIRE THAT \nTHE RECORDS BE SEALED IN THIS CASE. \nDershowitz also appears to contend that Judge Marra's order striking some of the \nmaterials from the records at issue somehow requires that these stricken materials be kept \nconfidential in this case. Dershowitz's argument misunderstands both the scope of Judge \nMarra's order and its effect in this case. His argument rests on a truncated — and misleading --\ndescription of the events surrounding Judge Marra's ruling striking certain documents. A more \ncomplete description makes clear that Judge Marra has not determined the documents are \nsomehow \"confidential\" even in the federal Crime Victims' Rights Act case — much less in this \nseparate state defamation action. \nEdwards and Cassell filed the federal case pro bono on behalf of two young women who \nwere sexually abused as underage girls by Dershowitz's close personal friend — Jeffrey \nEpstein. In 2008, Edwards and Casell filed a petition to enforce the rights of \"Jane Doe No. 1\" \nand \"Jane Doe No. 2\" under the Crime Victims' Rights Act (CVRA), 18 U.S.C. § 3771, alleging \nthat the Government had failed to provide them rights with regard to a plea arrangement it was \npursuing with Epstein. Jane Doe No. 1 and Jane Doe No. 2 v. United States, No. 9:08-cv-80736 \n(S.D. Fla.). In the course of that case, on October 11, 2011, the victims filed discovery requests \nwith the Government, including requests specifically seeking information about Dershowitz, \nPrince Andrew, and others. Further efforts from the Government to avoid any discovery \nEFTA01116698\n", "char_count": 1972}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Response to Dershowitz's Motion to Determine Confidentiality of Court Records \nPage 7 of 20 \nfollowed (see generally Docket Entry or \"DE\" 225-1 at 4-5), ultimately leading to a further \nCourt ruling in June 2013 that the Government should produce documents. DE 189. The \nGovernment then produced about 1,500 pages of largely irrelevant materials to the victims (DE \n225-I at 5), while simultaneously submitting 14,825 pages of relevant materials under seal to the \nCourt. The Government claimed that these pages were \"privileged\" for various reasons, \nattaching an abbreviated privilege log. \nWhile these discovery issues were pending, in the summer of 2014, Edwards and Cassell, \ncontacted Government counsel to request their agreement to add two additional victims to the \ncase, including Ms. \nwho was identified in court pleadings as \"Jane Doe No. \n3\"). Edwards and Cassell sought to have her added to the case via stipulation, which would have \navoided the need to include any detailed facts about her abuse. Weeks went by and the \nGovernment — as it had done on a similar request for a stipulation to add another victim — did not \nrespond to counsel's request for a stipulation. Finally, on December 10, 2014, despite having \nhad four months to provide a position, the Government responded by email to counsel that it was \nseeking more time, indicating that the Government understood that victims' counsel might need \nto file a motion with the court on the matter immediately. DE 291 at 3-5. Rather than file a \nmotion immediately, victims' counsel waited and continued to press the Government for a \nstipulation. See id. at 5. Finally, on December 23, 2014 — more than four months after the initial \nrequest for a stipulated joinder into the case — the Government tersely indicated its objection, \nwithout indicating any reason: \"Our position is that we oppose adding new petitioners at this \nstage of the litigati\n... [truncated, 2036 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/6 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=6]", "char_count": 2036}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Response to Dershowitz's Motion to Determine Confidentiality of Court Records \nPage 8 of 20 \nBecause the \nGovernment \nnow contested \nthe joinder \nmotion, Edwards and \nCassell prepared a more detailed pleading explaining the justification for granting the \nmotion. One week after receiving the Government's objection, on December 30, 2014, Ms. \ni.e., Jane Doe No. 3) and Jane Doe No. 4 filed a motion (and later a corrected motion) \nseeking to join the case. DE 279 and DE 280. (Note: DE 280 is the first of the three documents \nDershowitz seeks to have declared \"confidential\" in this case.) Uncertain as to the basis for the \nGovernment's objection, the motion briefly proffered the circumstances that would qualify \nthe two women as \"victims\" eligible to assert rights under the CVRA. See 18 U.S.C. 3771(e) \n(defining \"crime victim\" protected under the Act). With regard to Ms. \nthe motion \nindicated that when she was a minor, Jeffrey Epstein had trafficked her to Dershowitz and Prince \nAndrew (among others) for sexual purposes. Jane Doe No. 3 stated that she was prepared to \nprove her proffer. See DE 280 at 3 (\"If allowed to join this action, Jane Doe No. 3 would prove \nthe following . . . . \"). The motion also provided specific reasons why Jane Doe No. 3's \nparticipation was relevant to the case, including the pending discovery issues regarding \nDershowitz and Prince Andrew. DE 280 at 9-10 (explaining several reasons participation of new \nvictims was relevant to existing issues). \nAfter the motion was filed, various news organizations published articles about \nit. Dershowitz also made numerous media statements about the filing, including calling Jane \nDoe No. 3 \"a serial liar\" who \"has lied through her teeth about many world \nleaders.\" \nhttp://www.ctui.com/2015/0 I /06/us/dershowitz-sex-allegationt \nDershowitz also \nrepeatedly called Edwards and Cassell \"two sleazy, unprofessional, disbarable law\n... [truncated, 2028 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/7 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=7]", "char_count": 2028}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Response to Dershowitz's Motion to Determine Confidentiality of Court Records \nPage 9 of 20 \nJanuary 5, 2015, Dershowitz filed a motion to intervene to argue to have the allegations \nstricken. DE 282. Dershowitz also argued that Ms. \nM\n \nhad not provided a sworn affidavit \nattesting to the truth of her allegations. On January 21, 2015, Edwards and Cassell filed a \nresponse for Mad \nJane Doe No. 4. DE 291. (Note: This is the second of the three \ndocuments Dershowitz seeks to have kept under seal here.) The response enumerated nine \nM\ns\nspecific reasons why Ms. \npecific allegations against Dershowitz were relevant to the \ncase, including the fact that Ms\needed to establish that she was a \"victim\" in the case, \nthat pending discovery requests concerning Dershowitz-specific documents were pending, and \nthat Dershowitz's role as a defense attorney in the case was highly relevant to the motive for the \nGovernment and defense counsel to conceal the plea deal from the victims. DE 291 at 17-26 & \nn.17. The response included a detailed affidavit from Ms=lo\n ut the sexual abuse she had \nsuffered from Epstein, Dershowitz, and other powerful persons. DE 291-1. On February 6, \n2015, Edwards and Cassell filed a further pleading (and affidavit from Ms \nee DE 291-\n1) in support of her motion to intervene. (Note: this affidavit is the third of the three documents \nDershowitz seeks to have declared confidential.) \nOn April 7, 2015, Judge Marra denied Ms. Giuffre's motion to join the case. Judge \nMarra concluded that \"at this juncture in the proceedings\" details about the sexual abuse she had \nsuffered was unnecessary to making a determination \"of whether Jane Doe 3 and Jane Doe 4 \nshould be permitted to join [the other victims'] claim that the Government violated their rights \nunder the CVRA. The factual details regarding with whom and where the Jane Does engaged in \nsexual activities are impertinent to th\n... [truncated, 2074 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/8 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=8]", "char_count": 2074}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Response to Dershowitz's Motion to Determine Confidentiality of Court Records \nPage 10 of 20 \nEpstein and the Government owed them CVRA duties), especially considering that the details \ninvolve non-parties who are not related to the respondent Government.\" DE 324 at 5 (emphasis \nin original). While Judge Marra struck those allegations, he emphasized that \"Jane Doe 3 is free \nto reassert these factual details through proper evidentiary proof, should [the victims] \ndemonstrate a good faith basis for believing that such details are pertinent to a matter presented \nfor the Court's consideration. Judge Marra then denied Motion\nto join the case, \na\nbut allowed her to participate as trial witness: \"The necessary 'participation' of [ \n. \nin this case can be satisfied by offering . . . properly supported — and relevant, admissible, and \nnon-cumulative — testimony as needed, whether through testimony at trial . . . or affidavits \nsupported in support [of] the relevancy of discovery requests.\" DE 324 at 8 (emphasis \ndeleted). In a supplemental order, Judge Marra stated that the victims \"may re-refile these \ndocuments omitting the stricken portions.\" DE 325. The victims have recently refiled the \ndocuments. \nIn light of this history, Dershowitz is flatly incorrect when he asserts that \"Judge Marra's \nOrder appropriately precludes the unredacted documents from being re-filed in this case on the \npublic docket.\" Confidentiality Motion at 3. To the contrary, the Order specifically permits \nfactual details about Dershowitz's sexual abuse of MMD \nbe presented in regard to \npertinent matters in the federal CVRA case. And certainly nothing in Judge Marra's Order could \nrender those documents confidential in this state defamation case, where the central issues swirl \naround Edwards and Cassell's good faith basis for filing the allegations. Indeed, the order is not \nbinding in any way in this case, because i\n... [truncated, 2055 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/9 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=9]", "char_count": 2055}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Response to Dershowitz's Motion to Determine Confidentiality of Court Records \nPage I I of 20 \nparty in that case), not as to her attorneys Edwards and Cassell. See Palm AFC Holdings, Inc. v. \nPalm Beach County, 807 So.2d 703 (4'h DCA 2002) (\"In order for res judicata to apply four \nidentities must be present: (1) identity of the thing sued for; (2) identity of the cause of action; \n(3) identity of persons and parties; and (4) identity of the quality or capacity of the persons for or \nagainst whom the claim is made.\"). \nIII. \nEDWARDS AND CASSELL WILL BE PREJUDICED IF THEY ARE \nBARRED FROM QUOTING FROM THE RECORD WHILE \nDERSHOWITZ IS PERMITTED TO FREELY REFER TO THEM \nWHENEVER HE FINDS IT CONVENIENT. \nDershowitz is also incorrect when he asserts that no prejudice will befall Edwards and \nCassell if the records are placed under seal. To the contrary, placing the documents under seal \nwould permit Dershowitz to continue to misrepresent and distort what is contained in those \nrecords while preventing Edwards and Cassell from correcting those misrepresentations. \nDershowitz has repeatedly referred to details in the records when he has found it convenient to \ndo so — treating the records as not confidential in any away. One clear example comes from \nDershowitz's recent deposition, where he gratuitously injected into the record a reference to a \nportion of Msedavit \nabout him watching a \nperform oral sex on \nEpstein. And then, having injected that gratuitous reference into the record, he proceeded to try \nto rebut the reference with confidential settlement discussions — but did so by mispresenting what \nanother attorney (David Boies) had said during the settlement discussions. So that the Court may \nhave the full flavor of the exchange, the narrow question to Dershowitz (by attorney Jack \nEFTA01116703\n", "char_count": 1906}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Response to Dershowitz's Motion to Determine Confidentiality of Court Records \nPage 12 of 20 \nScarola) and Dershowitz's extended answer are quoted in full — including Dershowitz's \nreference to the oral sex allegation that he now argues this Court should treat as \"confidential\": \nQ. \n[Y]ou [are] aware that years before December of 2014, when the \nCVRA pleading was filed, that your name had come up repeatedly in \nconnection with Jeffrey Epstein's abuse of minors, correct? ... \nA. \nLet me answer that question. I am aware that never before 2014, \nend of December, was it ever, ever alleged that I had acted in any \nway inappropriately with regard to \nat I ever \ntouched her, that I ever met her, thatilir \natwit\nter. I was \ncompletely aware of that. \nThere \nhad \nnever \nbeen \nany \nallegation. She claims under oath that she told you that secretly in \n2011, but you have produced no notes of any such conversation. \nYou, of course, are a witness to this allegation and will be deposed \nas a witness to this allegation. I believe it is an entirely false \nallegation that she told you in 2011 that she had had any sexual \ncontact with me. I think she's lying through her teeth when she \nsays that. And I doubt that your notes will reveal any such \ninformation. \nBut if she did tell you that, she would be absolutely, categorically \nlying. So I am completely aware that never, until the lies were put \nin a legal pleading at the end of Dece \nnever alleged that I had any sexual contact wi \nI know that it was alleged that I was a witness to e ey pstein's \nalleged abuse and that was false. I was never a witness to any of \nJeffrey Epstein's sexual abuse. And I wrote that to you, something \nthat you have falsely denied. And I stand on the record. The record \nis clear that I have categorically denied I was ever a witness to \nany abuse, that I ever saw Jeffrey Epstein abusing anybody. \nAnd and the very idea that I woul\n... [truncated, 2396 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/11 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=11]", "char_count": 2396}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15.000072 \nEdwards and Cassel Is Response to Dershowitz's Motion to Determine Confidentiality of Court Records \nPage 13 of 20 \nMS. McCAWLEY: I have a standing objection and, I'm objecting again. I'm \nnot going to \nTHE WITNESS: No, no, no. Does she have standing in this deposition? \nMR. SCOTT: Let's take a break for a minute, okay? \nTHE WITNESS: I'm not sure she has standing. \nMR. SCAROLA: Are we finished with the speech? \nMR. SCOTT: No. If he --\nMR. SCAROLA: I'd like him to finish the speech so that we can get to my \nquestion \nand then we can take a break. \nA. So the question -- the answer to your question is --\nMR. SIMPSON: Wait a minute. Wait a minute. Wait a minute. Please don't \ndisclose something that she has a right to raise that objection if she wants to. \nMR. SCOTT: Exactly. \nDeposition of Alan Dershowitz (Oct. IS, 2015) at 93-95 (attached as Exhibit 1); see \nSir\nas\nalso Deposition f A\nDershowitz (Oct. 16, 2016) (attached \nExhibit 2) (also containing \ndiscussion of Ms \nffidavit). \nThe Court should be aware that within approximately two hours of this exchange, Ms. \nMcCawley (David Boies' law partner) released a statement on his behalf, which stated that \nDershowitz was misrepresenting what happened: \"Because the discussions that Mr. Boies had \nwith Mr. Dershowitz were expressly privileged settlement discussions, Mr. Boies will not, at \nleast at this time, describe what was actually said. However, Mr. Boies does state that Mr. \nEFTA01116705\n", "char_count": 1519}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15.000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Response to Dershowitz's Motion to Determine Confidentiality of Court Records \nPage 14 of 20 \nDershowitz description of what was said is not true.\" Statement of Ms. McCawley on Behalf of \nDavid Boies (Oct. 15, 2015). \nMore broadly, the Court can readily see from this passage how Dershowitz is willing to \ninject into the record a part of Ms. Affidavit \nwhenever it serves his purpose — and, \nindeed, to characterize the part of the affidavit as \"preposterous.\" But then he asks this Court to \nplace the underlying affidavit under seal, so that the Edwards and Cassell stand accused having \nfiled a \"preposterous\" affidavit without anyone being able to assess the validity of Dershowitz's \nattack. \nDershowitz has referred to the court records that he now wishes to have the Court declare \nconfidential not only in his deposition, but also in his widely-broadcast media attacks on \nEdwards and Cassell. For example, Dershowitz appeared on the British Broadcasting \nCorporation (the BBC) and was asked about the allegations: \nWell, first of all they were made in court papers that they don't even ask for a hearing \nto try to prove them. They put them in court papers in order to immunize themselves \nfrom any consequences from a defamation suit. The story is totally made \nup, completely out of whole cloth. \nI don't know this woman. I was not at the places at the times. It is part of a pattern of \nmade up stories against prominent people and world leaders. And the lawyers in \nrecent statement challenged me to deny the allegations under oath. I am doing that. I \nam denying them under oath, thus subjecting me to a perjury prosecution were I not \ntelling the truth. Jam now challenging them to have their client put these charges \nunder oath and for them to put them under oath. I am also challenging them to repeat \nthem outside of the context of court papers so that I can sue them for defamation. . . . \nAnd I wil\n... [truncated, 2381 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/13 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=13]", "char_count": 2381}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Response to Dershowitz's Motion to Determine Confidentiality of Court Records \nPage 15 of 20 \nSimilarly, Dershowitz appeared on NBC's Today Show the morning after Edwards and \nCassell made a filing for Mslay \nthat the Edwards and Cassell — and \nwere all \"lying\" in the court documents: \nQuestion from Savannah Guthrie: In legal papers from the lawyers, they say you've \nhad, in fact, the opportunity to be deposed. \nAnswer from Alan Dershowitz: They're lying. They're lying. \nQuestion: They show letters in which they offered to depose you. \nAnswer: And they didn't show my letters in response saying, (a), if you ask me about \nmy legal relationship with Epstein and I'll be happy to answer. . . . And I responded \nthat I would be happy to be deposed if you could give me any indication that 1 would \nbe a relevant witness . . . . They will be proved — all of them (i.e., Cassell, Edwards, \nand Ms. \nto be categorically lying and making up this story. And it will be a \nterrible thing or rape victims. . . . We [Epstein and Dershowitz] had an academic \nrelationship. I was never in the presence of a single, young, underaged \nwoman. When I was with him, it was with prominent scientists, prominent \nacademics. And they're just — again — lying about this. I never saw him doing \nanything improper. I was not a participant. I was not a witness. \nToday Show, Jan. 22, 2015 (emphases added). \nAs another example, in Miami Herald, Dershowitz called the Joinder Motion that he \nseeks to have sealed \"the sleaziest legal document I have ever seen. They [Edwards and \nCassell] manipulated a young, suggestible woman who was interested in money. This is a \ndisbarrable offense, and they will be disbarred. They will rue the day they ever made this false \ncharge against me\" — i.e., Edwards and Cassell will \"rue the day\" they ever filed the Joinder \nMotion. Miami Herald (Jan. 3, 2015). \nEFTA01116707\n", "char_count": 1972}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and CasselIs Response to Dershowitz's Motion to Determine Confidentiality of Court Records \nPage 16 of 20 \nMost remarkably, Dershowitz took the public airwaves to represent that he wanted all of \nthe information surrounding the allegations to \"be made public,\" while implying that Edwards \nand Cassell had something to hide. For example, on the BBC he claimed that he \nwanted\"everything to be made public\": \nQ: \nWould you encourage that it now be made public? \nA: \nOf course, of course. I want everything to be made public. I want \nevery bit of evidence in this case to be made public. I want every \nallegation to be made public. I want to know who else she's accused of \nthese horrible crimes. We know that she accused Bill Clinton of being on \nJeffrey Epstein's island and participating in sex orgy with underage \ngirls. The records of the Secret Service will prove that President Clinton \nnever set foot on that island. So that she lied. Now it's possible to have a \ncase of mistaken identification with somebody like me. It's impossible to \nhave a case of mistaken identification with Bill Clinton. \nMy only feeling is that if she has lied about me, which I know to an \nabsolute certainty she has, she should not be believed about anyone \nelse. She's lied clearly about me, she's lied clearly about Bill \nClinton. We know that. We know that she's lied about other public \nfigures, including a former prime minister and others who she claims to \nhave participated in sexual activities with. So I think it must be presumed \nthat all of her allegations against Prince Andrew are false as well. \nI think he [Prince Andrew] should clear the air as well. \nIf you're squeaky clean and if you have never done anything like this, you \nmust fight back with all the resources available to you. And that's what I \nwill do. I will not rest or stop until the world understands no only that I \nhad nothing to do with any of this, but that she d\n... [truncated, 2337 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/15 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=15]", "char_count": 2337}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Response to Dershowitz's Motion to Determine Confidentiality of Court Records \nPage 17 of 20 \nAsk them [Edwards and Cassell] if they have any evidence . . . . They're doing it for \nmoney. She's getting money for having sold her story. She wants to sell the book. \nThey're trying to get into this lawsuit. They see a pot of gold at the end of the \nrainbow. They're [Edwards and Cassell] prepared to lie, cheat, and steal. These are \nunethical lawyers. This is Professor Cassell who shouldn't be allowed near a \nstudent. This is Professor Cassell, who is a former federal judge, thank God he no \nlonger wears a robe. He is essentially a crook. He is essentially somebody who's \ndistorted the legal profession. . . . Why would he charge a person with a \nsterling reputation for 50 years on the basis of the word alone of a woman who is \nserial liar, who has lied about former Prime Ministers, former Presidents, has lied \ndemonstrably. \nCNN Live (with Hala Gorani) (January 5, 2015). Of course, by placing \"the evidence\" in this \ncase under seal, De \n1 be free to continue to try and insinuate that Edward and Cassell \n— and their client, \nhad no evidence supporting the allegations against him, even \nthough a mountain et?: ence s ongly support \nnegations. See Deposition of Paul \nCassell (Oct 16, 2015) at 61-117 (Exhibit 3); \nof Pual Cassell (Oct 17, 2015) \n(Exhibit 4). \nCONCLUSION \nThe Court should deny Defendant/Counterclaim Plaintiff Alan Dershowitz's motion to \nplace documents regarding Ms. \ntions against him under seal. \nI HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing was sent via E-Serve \nto all Counsel on the attached list, this  \n25r° \n day of November, 2015. \n/s/ Jack Scarola \nJack Scarola \nFlorida Bar No.: 169440 \nAttorney E-Mail(s): \nPrimary E-Mail: \nSearcy Denney S \n2139 Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard \nEFTA01116709\n", "char_count": 1928}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15.000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Response to Dershowitz's Motion to Determine Confidentiality of Court Records \nPage 18 of 20 \nSEAN D. REYES \nUtah Attorney General \nBy: JONI J. JONES \nJOEL A. FERRE \nAssistant Utah Attorneys General \nBradley J. Edwards \nFARMER, JAFFE, WEISSING, \nEDWARDS, FISTOS & LEHRMAN, P.L. \n425 North Andrews Avenue, Suite 2 \nFort Lauderdale, Florida 33301 \nAnd \nPaul G. Cassell \nPro Hac Vice Motion Pending \nS.J. Quinney College of Law at the \nUniversity of Utah \n383 S. University St. \nSalt Lake City, UT 84112 \nAttorneys for Plaintiffs Bradley J. Edwards and Paul G. Cassell \nCOUNSEL LIST \nThomas Emerson Scott, Jr., Esquire \nCole Scott & Kissane P.A. \n9150 S Dadeland Boulevard, Suite 1400 \nMiami, FL 33156 \nEFTA01116710\n", "char_count": 793}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Response to Dershowites Motion to Determine Confidentiality of Court Records \nPage 19 of 20 \nAttorneys for Defendant \nRichard A. Sim son \nro hac vice) \nM \nE. Bor'a \nm hac vice) \nAshley E. Eiler (pro hac vice) \nWILEY REIN LLP \n1776 K St. NW \nWashington, DC 20006 \nEFTA01116711\n", "char_count": 356}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE I5-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Response to Dershowitz's Motion to Determine Confidentiality of Court Records \nPage 20 of 20 \nCOUNSEL LIST \nSigrid Stone McCawley, Esquire \n401 E Las Olas Boulevard., Suite 1200 \n, Esquire \nThomas Emerson Scott. Jr \nuire \nole Scott & Kissane P.A. \n9150 S Dadeland Boulevard, Suite 1400 \nBradle J. Edwards \n• uire \n,... \nFarmer Jaffe Weissing Edwards Fistos & \nLehrman, P.L. \n425 N Andrews Avenue, Suite 2 \nKenneth A. Sweder, E uire \n131 Oliver Street \nBoston, MA 02110 \nttomeys or \nan \ners\n squire \nAshley Eiler, Esquire \nRichard A. Simpson, Esquire \nIIIIIMIE \n1776 K Street NW \nWashin on DC 20006 \nAttorneys or A an M.Ders towitz, Esquire \nJoni J. Jones, Esquire \nMIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIL \n160 E 300 S \nSalt Lake City, UT 84114 \nI \nme s or at\n.IIIIPe \nI \nEFTA01116712\n", "char_count": 843}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Exhibit 1 \nEFTA01116713\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "1 \nIN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE SEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL \nCIRCUIT IN AND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA \nCASE NO.: CACE 15-000072 \nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS and PAUL G. \nCASSELL„ \nPlaintiffs, \nvs. \nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ, \nDefendant. \n/ \nVIDEOTAPE DEPOSITION OF \nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ \nVOLUME 1 \nPages 1 through 179 \nThursday, October 15, 2015 \n9:31 a.m. - 4:13 p.m. \nCole Scott & Kissane \n110 Southeast 6th Street \nFort Lauderdale, Florida \nStenographically Reported By: \nKimberly Fontalvo, RPR, CLR \nRealtime Systems Administrator \nEFTA01116714\n", "char_count": 525}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "93 \n1 \npeople that abused Virginia? \n2 \nA. \nI told you I never asked her the question. \n11:36:21 \n3 \nQ. \nAre you aware that years before December \n11:36:48 \n4 \nof 2014, when the CVRA pleading was filed, that your \n5 \nname had come up repeatedly in connection with \n6 \nJeffrey Epstein's abuse of minors, correct? \n7 \nMR. SCOTT: Objection, form, overly broad. \n11:37:16 \n8 \nA. \nLet me answer that question. I am aware \n11:37:17 \n9 \nthat never before 2014, end of December, was it \n10 \never, ever alleged that I had acted in any way \n11 \ninappropriately with regard to \n12 \nthat I ever touched her, that I ever met her, that I \n13 \nhad ever been with her. I was completely aware of \n14 \nthat. There had never been any allegation. \n15 \nShe claims under oath that she told you \n11:37:48 \n16 \nthat secretly in 2011, but you have produced no \n17 \nnotes of any such conversation. You, of course, are \n18 \na witness to this allegation and will be deposed as \n19 \na witness to this allegation. I believe it is an \n20 \nentirely false allegation that she told you in 2011 \n21 \nthat she had had any sexual contact with me. I \n22 \nthink she's lying through her teeth when she says \n23 \nthat. And I doubt that your notes will reveal any \n24 \nsuch information. \n25 \nBut if she did tell you that, she would be \n11:38:24 \nEFTA01116715\n", "char_count": 1317}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "94 \n1 \nabsolutely, categorically lying. So I am completely \n2 \naware that never, until the lies were put in a legal \n3 \npleading at the end of December 2014, it was never \n4 \nalleged that I had any sexual contact with \n5 \n6 \nI know that it was alleged that I was a \n11:38:46 \n7 \nwitness to Jeffrey Epstein's alleged abuse and that \n8 \nwas false. I was never a witness to any of Jeffrey \n9 \nEpstein's sexual abuse. And I wrote that to you, \n10 \nsomething that you have falsely denied. And I stand \n11 \non the record. The record is clear that I have \n12 \ncategorically denied I was ever a witness to any \n13 \nabuse, that I ever saw Jeffrey Epstein abusing \n14 \nanybody. \n15 \nAnd -- and the very idea that I would \n11:39:18 \n16 \nstand and talk to Jeffrey Epstein while he was \n17 \nreceiving oral sex from \nhich she \n18 \nswore to under oath, is so outrageous, so \n19 \npreposterous, that even David Boies said he couldn't \n20 \nbelieve it was true. \n21 \nMS. McCAWLEY: I object. I object. I'm \n11:39:40 \n22 \nnot going to allow you to reveal any \n23 \nconversations that happened in the context of a \n24 \nsettlement discussion. \n25 \nTHE WITNESS: Does she have standing? \n11:39:46 \nEFTA01116716\n", "char_count": 1185}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "95 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \nMS. McCAWLEY: I have a standing objection \nand, I'm objecting again. I'm not going to --\nTHE WITNESS: No, no, no. Does she have \nstanding in this deposition? \n11:39:47 \n11:39:49 \n5 \nMR. SCOTT: Let's take a break for a \n11:39:51 \n6 \nminute, okay? \n7 \nTHE WITNESS: I'm not sure she has \n11:39:54 \n8 \nstanding. \n9 \nMR. SCAROLA: Are we finished with the \n11:39:57 \n10 \nspeech? \n11 \nMR. SCOTT: No. If he -- \n11:39:58 \n12 \nMR. SCAROLA: I'd like him to finish the \n11:39:59 \n13 \nspeech so that we can get to my question and \n14 \nthen we can take a break. \n15 \nA. \nSo the question -- the answer to your \n11:40:02 \n16 \nquestion is \n17 \nMR. SIMPSON: Wait a minute. Wait a \n11:40:04 \n18 \nminute. Wait a minute. Please don't disclose \n19 \nsomething that she has a right to raise that \n20 \nobjection if she wants to. \n21 \nMR. SCOTT: Exactly. \n11:40:13 \n22 \nTHE WITNESS: Okay. \n11:40:14 \n23 \nMR. SCOTT: Ask your question. \n11:40:17 \n24 \nMR. SWEDER: Maybe you want to read back \n11:40:20 \n25 \nthe last couple of sentences. \nEFTA01116717\n", "char_count": 1038}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Exhibit 2 \nEFTA01116718\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "180 \nIN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE SEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL \nCIRCUIT IN AND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA \nCASE NO.: CACE 15-000072 \nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS and PAUL G. \nCASSELL„ \nPlaintiffs, \nvs. \nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ, \nDefendant. \n \n/ \nCONTINUED VIDEOTAPE DEPOSITION OF \nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ \nVOLUME 2 \nPages 180 through 333 \nFriday, October 16, 2015 \n9:18 a.m. - 12:26 p.m. \nCole Scott & Kissane \n110 Southeast 6th Street \nFort Lauderdale, Florida \nStenographically Reported By: \nKimberly Fontalvo, RPR, CLR \nRealtime Systems Administrator \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA01116719\n", "char_count": 580}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "181 \n183 \n1 \nAPPEARANCES: \n1 \nINDEX \na \n2 \n3 \nOn behalf of Mairatiflk \nExamination \nPage \nSEARCY. DENNEY, SCAROLA \n3 \n4 \nBARNHART & SHIPLEY. P.A. \n4 \nVOLUME 2 (Pages 180 - 333) \n2139 Pain Beach Lakes Boulevatd \nS \nDirect \nBy Mr. Scarola \n184 \ns \nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33402.3626 \nBY: JACK SCAROLA ESQ. \n6\nCertificate of Oath \n330 \n6 \njingscarcybw.com \nCertificate of Reporter \n331 \n7 \n7 \nRead and Sign Letter to Witness \n332 \n8 \nOn behalf of Defendant \nErrata Sheet (forwarded upon execution) \n333 \n9 \nCOLE. SCO1T & KISSANE. RA \n$ \nPLAINTIFF EXHIBITS \nDoieland Cate II - Sum 1400 \n9 \n10 \n9150 South Dadeland Boukvard \nMiani, Florida 33156 \nNo. \nPage \n11 \nBY: THONIAS EMERSON SCOTT— M. ESQ. \nthomasscon@sklegatrom \n10 \nI \nTelevision Interview Transcript \n193 \n12 \nBY: STEVEN SAFRA. ESQ. (Via phone) \n11 \n13 \nstevensafra€esklepleont \n2 \nExcept from Deposition of Alan M. \n193 \n14 \nSWEDE R & RC6S. LLP \n12\nDershowitz\n131 °titer Saco \n13 \n3 Photograph - 8x10 - Color \n194 \n15 \nBoston. MA 02110 \n14 \n4 Photograph - 8x10 - Color \n197 \nBY: KENNETH A. SWEDER, ESQ. \n15\n5 Flight Log Information Sheet \n198 \n16 \nkswederensvinkerosneorn \n16 \n6 Composite - Flight logs \n240 \n18 \nWILEY, REIN \n17\n7 Composite - Flight manuals \n240 \n17769 K Sava NW \n18 \n8 Photograph - 8x10 - Color \n305 \n19 \nWashington. DC 20006 \n19 \n9 Composite - Calendar entries \n306 \n20 \nBY: RICHARD A SIMPSON. ESQ. \nRSimsongmikyreinecen \n20 \n10 Composite - Calendar entries \n307 \nBY: NICOLE A. RICHARDSON. ESQ. \n21 \nII Compositc - Calendar entries \n307 \n21 \nnrichankoe44.40eyreincom \n22\n12 Composite - Calendar entries \n307 \n22 \n23 \n23 \n24 \n34\n25 \n25 \n182 \n184 \n1\nAPPEARANCES (Continued): \n1 \nVIDEOGRAPHER: Going on the record. This \n2 \nOn behalf of Jeffrey Epstein: \n2 \nis day two of Alan Dershowitz's deposition. \n3 \nDARREN K. INDYKE. PLLC \n3 \nThe date is October 16, 2015, and the time is \n575 Lexington Ave.. 4th Fl. \n4 \napproximately 9:18 a.m. \n4 \nNew York, New York \nBY: DARREN K. INDYKE, ESQ. (Via phone) \n5 \nMR. SCAROLA: Would you p\n... [truncated, 3037 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/27 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=27]", "char_count": 3037}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 28, "text_content": "185 \n187 \n1 \nA. Truth has many, many meanings and is a \n1 \ntranscript of the interview? We'd like to see \n2 \ncontinuum. The Supreme Court has held that \n2 \nit. \n3\nrhetorical hyperbole cannot be the basis• for \n1 \nMR. SCAROLA: That's exactly what I gave \n4 \nexample, of perjury prosecutions or generally of a \n4 \nyou, the photocopy. \n5 \ndefamation prosecution. \n5 \nMR. SCOTT: We're doing it right now. \n6 \nSo it depends on the context. You might \n6 \nMaybe we can move on and conic back then. \n7\njust look at the dictionary and probably get a \n7 \nMR. SCAROLA: No, I would like to proceed. \n8\nvariety of definiticas for it. \n8 \nMR. SCOTT: Then let's stop until I get a \n9 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n9 \ncopy of it. Because he -- I want --\n10 \nQ. Well, what I'm concerned about, \n10 \nMR. SCAROLA: I don't think that's \n11 \nMr. Dershowltz, Is not a dictionary definition. I \n11 \nnecessary because your client has told us that \n12 \nwant to know what your understanding of rhetorical \n12 \nhe has a superb memory and one of the things I \n13 \nhyperbok Is. \n13 \nwould like to know is what he's able to recall. \n14 \nAnd do you agree that pursuant to your \n14 \nIf he needs to refresh his memory. the \n15 \nunderstanding of rhetorical hyperbole, It Is an \n15 \ntranscripts will be here in just a moment, but \n16 \nexaggeration beyond the facts? \n16 \nI don't want to delay going forward. \n17 \nMR. SCO•IT: Objection, argumentative and \n17 \nMR. SCOTT: Do you need the transcript to \n18 \ncompound, throe questions. \n18 \nrefresh your memory? \n19 \nA. No.- \n19 \nTIIE WITNESS: Well, I have no memory of \n20 \nMR. SCOTT: You can answer. \n20 \nwhat specifically I said on a particular day in \n21 \nA. -- I would not agree with that definition. \n21 \na particular interview. \n22 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n22 \nMR. SCOTT: Since you hate a copy in front \n23 \nQ. Okay. Then define it for us, if you \n23 \nof him, why don't you just show him your copy \n24 \nwould, please. \n24 \nthen? Read the — ask your question and let \n25 \nA. I think I have already. \n25\n... [truncated, 4192 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/28 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=28]", "char_count": 4192}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 29, "text_content": "189 \n191 \n1\nairplane flights with Jeffrey Epstein. They have me \n1 \nto the transcription, the official transcription of \n2\non a number of flights, none-- let me emphasize. \n2 \nthat testimony, was that, quote: \n3\nnone within the relevant time period, none within \n3 \n\"Let me emphasize that the manifests that \n4 \nthe relevant time period. That is. there are no \n4 \ndo exculpate me do not show me flying wit \n5\nmanifests that have me on Jeffrey E \neon's airplane \n5 \nnot show me flying with a \n6\nduring the time t \nants to \n6 \nwomen.\" \n7 \nhave -- falsely c \nth me. \n7 \nThat was the testimony you gave under \n8 \nSo. yes, not only recall making that \n8 \noath. Do you stand by that testimony today? \n9\nstatement, but I repeat it here today. And it is \n9 \nA. The manifests that I saw corroborate my \n10 \nabsolutely t \nwhat I know. \n10\nown memory -- my own memory is as clear as could \n11\nand that is t \nup the Mire \n11 \nbe— that I never saw any inappropriately aged, \n12 \nstory, \n12 \n'Wagged women on any airplane to my knowledge that \n13 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n13 \nwere visible to me at any time that I flew. That is \n14 \nQ. Your Statement — \n14 \nmy testimony. yes. \n15 \nMR. SCOTT: What page arc you reading \n15 \nQ. Well, that's not a response to the \n16 \nfrom? \n16 \nquestion that I asked. Is it your testimony today \n17 \nMR. SCAROLA: Page 5. \n17 \nthat you never flew on a private airplane with, \n18 \nQ. Your statement was that you were never on \n18\nquote, \"any young women\"? \n19\na private airplane with this woman, which I assume \n19 \nMR SCOTr: Objection, foam \n20 \nwas a referc \net \n20 \nA. By young women, I obviously meant in Mat \n21 \nA. It is, \n21 \ncontext underage women. And underage women in the \n22 \nQ. Or any other underage girl? \n22 \ncontext of sexuality. And, yes, I — I stand by \n23 \nA. Thai's right. \n23 \nthat statement. \n24 \nQ. All right. How many times — \n24 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n25 \nA. Well, let me be very clear. I have no \n25 \nQ. Affright So your — your elarificadon \n190 \n192 \n1\nidea who was in\n... [truncated, 4423 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/29 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=29]", "char_count": 4423}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 30, "text_content": "193 \n195 \n1\nfirm about this — being on an airplane with anybody \n1 \nA. I don't remember that I flew with her or \n2\nwho I believed could be the subject of Jeffrey \n2 \nnot. I may have. But I don't recall necessarily. \n3\nEpstein or anyone else's improper sexual activities. \n3\nBut I did meet -- I remember meeting a woman named \n4 \nMR. SCAROLA: All right Let's mark the \n4 \n'is does not look like \nke the \n5 \ntranscript that we've been referring to as \n5\nwoman I 'net. \n6 \nExhibit Number I, please. That's the \n6 \nQ. Okay. So that's a — that's a different \n7 \ntranscript of the television interviews that \n7 \n8 \nwe'll be discussing. \n8 \nA. No, I don't know. \n9 \n(Thereupon, marked as Plaintiff Exhibit \n9 \nMR. SCOTT: Objection, fonn, \n10 \nI.) \n10 \nargumentative. \n11 \nMR. SCOTT: This is actually 2. right? We \n11 \nA. I have no idea. I do not recognize this \n12 \nhad one yesterday, an anicle from the British \n12 \nwoman. She's not familiar to inc at all. \n13 \nnewspaper? \n13 \nI can tell you this: Without any doubt. I \n14 \nMR. SCAROLA: No. It was not marked as an \n14\nnever met anybody dressed like this on any airplane \n15 \nexhibit. This is the first  exhibit that's been \n15\nor in the presence of Jeffrey Epstein or in any \n16 \nmarked. \n16\nContext — \n17 \nMR. SCOTT: No. I know that, but I thought \n17\nBY MIL SCAROLA: \n18 \nwe were going to mark that one. Maybe I was — \n18 \nQ. Did she have -\n19 \nI asked for that. Okay. \n19 \nA. -- related to this case. \n20 \nIt was an answer and counterclaim about \n20 \nQ. — more clothes on or less clothes on when \n21 \nthe allegation shown to the witness. \n21 \nyou met her? \n22 \nMR. SCAROLA: And Exhibit Number 2 will be \n22 \nMR. SCOTT: Objection, form. He said he \n23 \nthe transcript from yesterday's proceedings \n23 \nnever met her. Misrepresent --\n24 \nthat I have just referenced. \n24 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n25 \n(Thereupon marked as Plaintiff \n25 \nQ. When you met the woman that you're \n194 \n196 \n1 \nExhibit 2.) \n1 \nreferencing, did she have more clothes on or less \n2 \nMR\n... [truncated, 3745 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/30 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=30]", "char_count": 3745}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 31, "text_content": "197 \n199 \n1 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n1 \nographs identify the woman as \n2 \nQ. — that's a \nwoman. \n2\nt? \n3 \nyoung \nMR. SCOTT: Objection. You're cutting the \n3 \n4 \nwitness off. You're not letting him finish \n4 \nMR. SCOTT: Mr. Dershowin, take your \nS \nA. This looks like a picture out of a Playboy \n5 \ntime --\n6\nor Penthouse magazine. It does not look to me like \n6 \nTIIE WITNESS: Yeah. \n7\na person who is under the age of IE. or I? or IS. \n7 \nMR. SCOTT: — review the exhibits. Dont \n8\nBut I don't think you can tell anything from the \n8 \nbe rushed by Mr. Scarola. \n9\npicture. I think you can tell much more front \n9 \nA. Yes, it's aditto:sent — different \n10 \nmeeting somebody and being with them and having a \n10 \nspelling of the name. The Tatiana on the manifest \n11\nconversation with them. \n11 \nis spell \n12 \nMR. SCAROLA: Let's mark this photograph. \n12 \nTh \nph is \n13 \nif wc could, as Exhibit Number 4. \n13 \nI have no idea whether — \n14 \n(Thereupon, marked as Plaintiff \n14 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n15 \nExhibit 4.) \n15 \nQ. The last name -\n16 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n16 \nA. — they arc the same person \n17 \nQ. Does Exhibit Number 4 help you at all to \n17 \nQ. — is the same, \nht? \n18 \nrecognize this young woman? \n18 \nA. There's no last name. \n19 \nA. I've never -- I have no — no recollection \n19 \nQ. Well, read down a little bit further. If \n20\nof this young woman at all. \n20 \nyou would, Mr. Dershowitz. \n21 \nAll \nht. Would \ndescribe for \n21\nA. You mean as to a different flight? \n22 \nQ. \nri \nyou \nus, \nplease, the •\nou flew with Jeffrey \n22 \nQ. Yes, sir. Identifying the return flight \n23\nEpstein on November 17,2005? \n23 \nfor the sam \n24 \nA_ First, I want to emphasize that that's \n24 \nA. I have no idea that it's a return flight. \n25 \nthree years later than any of the issues involved in \n25 \nI have nothing on the record that suggests that it's \n198 \n200 \n1 \nthis case. I have no recollection of\n with \n1\na return flight. And it has different people on it \n2 \nthis woman. I saw the name \nm a manifest. \n2 \nSo I have n\n... [truncated, 3944 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/31 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=31]", "char_count": 3944}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 32, "text_content": "201 \n203 \nI \nthan three years aft \nlen \n1 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n2 \nfor -- \n2 \nQ. Is the last name on the photograph spelled \n3 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n3 \nexactly the same way as the last name on the flight \n4 \nQ. Mr. Dershowitz — \n4 \nlog? \nS \nMR. SCOTT: You're cutting the witness \n5 \nA. If you're talking °beet a flight log that \n6 \noff. \n6 \nI was not on that flight, thc answer is yes. \n7 \nMR. SCAROLA: Ile's not answering my \n7 \nQ. All right. Thank you very much, slr. \n8 \nquestion. Tom. \n8 \nNow, that flight log also shows you flying \n9 \nMR. SCOTT: Well - \n9 \nrepeatedly In the company of a woman named Tatiana \n10 \nMR. SCAROLA: I want to know whether the \n10 \ncorrect? \n11 \nlast name is spelled the same or it isn't \n11 \nA. rye only seen one reference ha \n12 \nspelled thc samc on the flight log marked as an \n12 \nNovember I?. If you want to show me any other \n13 \nexhibit and on the photographs. That's a very \n13 \nreferences. Id be happy to look at than. \n14 \ndirect question. It calls for a vary direct \n14 \nQ. All right, sir. Thank you. \n15 \nyes or no response. \n15 \nLet's go back to the —\n16 \nAnd this witness has demonstrated a clear \n16 \nMR SCOTT: Are we done with this exhibit? \n17 \nrefusal to respond directly to direct \n17 \nMR. SCAROLA: We are done with the \n18 \nquestions, which will result, when we resume \n18 \nexhibit. \n19 \nthis deposition, in our requesting that the \n19 \nMR. SCOTT: Okay. Then let's collect the \n20 \nCourt appoint a special master so that this \n20 \nexhibits so that we don't have a big — then \n21 \ndeposition doesn't take two weeks to complete. \n21 \nwell turn them over to the court reporter to \n22 \nMR. SCOTT: You know, Mr. Scarola, that's \n22 \nkeep safekeeping. \n23 \na nice speech and I appreciate it. \n23 \nThat you go, young lady. don't Rise \n24 \nMR. SCAROLA: Thank you. \n24 \nthose, don't get than wet. And well proceed. \n25 \nMR. SCOTT: I don't agree with your \n25 \n202 \n204 \n1 \ncharacterization. And if you recall. months \n1\nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n2 \nago I suggested a special \n... [truncated, 4001 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/32 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=32]", "char_count": 4001}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 33, "text_content": "205 \n1 \nthe source of that honest belief was? Identify any \n2 \nsource that attributed to \n.he \n3 \nstatement that Bill Clinton was with her at an orgy \n4 \non Jeffrey's island. \n5 \nA. We can provide you about, I think, 20 \n6 \nnewspaper articles and blogs which certainly raise \n7 \nthe implication that Bill Clinton had improperly \nparticipated in sexual activities on the island \n9 \neither as an observer or as a participant. The \n10 \nissue was raised on Sean Hannitys program. The \n11 \nheadlines in various British media had suggested \n12 \nthat \n13 \nIt's my belief th \n14 \nintended to convey that [monism \nwas \n15 \ntrying to sell her story to various media, which she \n16 \nsuccessfully sold her story to in Britain. that she \n17 \nwanted to keep that open as a possibility. \n18 \nAnd then when I firmly declared, based on \n19 \nmy research, that Bill Clinton had almost certainly \n20 \nnever been on that island, she then made a finn \n21 \nstatement that she -- which was a -- which was a \n22 \nperjurious statement, a finn penurious statement \n23 \nsaying that although Bill Clinton had been with her \n24 \non the island and had had dinner with her, the \n25 \nperjurious statement was that Bill Clinton had been \n207 \nClinton on orgy island, things of that kind. I \n2 \nwould be happy to provide than for you. I donl \n3 \nhave them on the top of my head. \n4 \nQ. There's a big difference between saying \n5 \nthat Bill Clinton was on Jeffrey's Island and saying \n6 \nthat Bill Clinton was at an orgy on Jeffrey's \n7 \nIsland, isn't there? \n8 \nMR. SCOTT: Objection --\n9 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n10 \nQ. Do you recognize a distinction between \n11 \nthose statements? \n12 \nMR. SCOTT: Font \n13 \nA. I don't think that distinction was ekarty \n19 \ndrawn by the media. \n15 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n16 \nQ. I'm asking whether you recognize the \n17 \ndistinction? \n18 \nA. Oh. I -- I certainly recognize a \n19 \ndistinction. \n20 \nQ. Oh, so — \n21 \nA. Let me finish. I certainly recognize a \n22 \ndistinction between Bill Clinton being on the \n23 \ni\n... [truncated, 4675 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/33 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=33]", "char_count": 4675}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 34, "text_content": "209 \n211 \n1 \nQ. Okay. So you now are withdrawing the \n1 \nYour client is doing everything he can to avoid \n2\nstatement that you made tha \nd \n2 \ngiving direct answers to these questions. \n3\nthat Bill Clinton was with h \n3 \nI would appreciate it if you would take a \n4\nJeffrey's island; that was wrong? \n4 \nbreak, counsel your client that the speeches \n5 \nA. I don't know whether she ever said that \n5 \narc not helpful to anyone, and especially not \n6\n!would not repeat that statement and have not \n6 \nhelpful to him. \n7 \nrepeated that statement based on her denial. As \n7 \nMR. SCOTT: If you want to take a break, \n8\nsoon as she denied it, I never again made that \n8 \nI'll take a break and I will advise my client \n9\nstatement and would not again make that statement \n9 \nwhatever I feel is appropriate, not what you \n10 \nQ. You — \n10 \ninstruct me to do. \n11 \nA. But I did reiterate the fact that she \n11 \nMR. SCAROLA: Okay. Well, if you think it \n12 \ncommitted perjury when she said she was on the \n12 \nmight help at all in the progress of this \n13\nisland with Bill Clinton. \n13 \ndeposition, then I do want to take a break. If \n14 \nMR. SCAROLA: Move to strike the \n14 \nyou don't think taking a break would be \n15 \nnonresponsive -. \n15 \nhelpful, I don't want to take a break. \n16 \nA. That was the perjurious statement. \n16 \nMR. SCOTT: Do you want to take a break or \n17 \nMR. SCAROLA: Move to strike the \n17 \nnot? \n18 \nnonresponsive portions of the answer. \n18 \nTHE WITNESS: I'm going to leave it to \n19 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n19 \nyour judgment. I'm happy to proceed --\n20 \nQ. You have made a reference during \na \na \n20 \nMR. SCOTT: Okay. I'll be glad to take a \n21\nN Interview to this woman, referring i \n21\nbreak.\n22 \ning a criminal record? \n22 \nMR. SCAROLA: Thank you. \n23 \nA. \nt's right. \n23 \nMR. SCOTT: I can't say - \n24 \nQ. Okay. What — what is a criminal record? \n24 \nMR. SCAROLA: Five minutes. \n25 \nA. Well• the way I used the term is that she \n25 \nMR. SCOTT: -- it will help you or \n210 \n212 \n1\ncommitt\n... [truncated, 3969 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/34 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=34]", "char_count": 3969}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 35, "text_content": "213 \n215 \n1 \n(Recess was held from 9:49 a.m. until 10:01 am) \n1 \nQ. That would certainly have been prior to \n2 \nVIDEOGRAPHER: Going back on the record. \n2\nFebruary 23rd of 2015, correct? \n3 \nThe titer is approximately !R0I a.m. \n3 \nA. Yes. \n9 \nMR. SCOTT: ifyou've finished your bagel \n4\nMR. SCOTT: Are you going back to the \n5 \nwe're ready to proceed. I think. \n5 \nexhibit now with the newspapers and --\n6 \nMR. SCAROLA: I think we arc. I was \n6 \nMR. SCAROLA: Not yet. \n7 \nactually ready to proceed a little bit earlier, \n7 \nMR. SCOTT: Okay. \n8 \nbut we'll proceed now. \n8 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n9 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n9 \nQ. Having reviewed the available airplane \n10 \nQ. Mr. Dershowltz, do you agree with the \n10\nflight logs, you are aware that Bill Clinton flew on \n11 \nbasic concept that one is presumed to be Innocent \n11\nat least 15 occasions with Jeffrey Epstein on his \n12 \nuntil proven guilty? \n12 \nprivate plane, correct? \n13 \nA. Yes \n13 \nA. Yes. \n14 \nQ. Ha \n:or been proven to \n14 \nQ. Have you ever attempted to get flight log \n15\nbe guilty o any crime a any me, anywhere, at any \n15 \ninformation with regard to Former President \n16 \nage? \n16\nClinton's other private airplane travel? \n17 \nA. I don't know the answer to that question, \n17 \nA. No. \n18 \nbee I do know that she was brought into the legal \n18 \nQ. Never made a public records request —\n19 \nsystem for stealing money from her employer and 1 \n19 \nA. Yes. \n20 \nthink ifs fair to characterize that as her having a \n20 \nQ. — under the Freedom of Information Act \n21\ncriminal record. yeah. \n21 \nwith regard to those records? \n22 \nQ. To the extent that anyone m tht interpret \n22 \nA. Well we have made a Freedom of \n23\nyour comment tha \nwas ever \n23\nInformation request. My -- my attorney in New York. \n24 \nconvicted of a crime, they would be drawing a false \n24 \nLouis Reek the former head of the FBI, has made a \n25\nconclusion as far as you know, correct? \n25 \nFOIA request for all information that would \n214 \n216 \n1 \nA. As far as I know. I do\n... [truncated, 4176 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/35 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=35]", "char_count": 4176}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 36, "text_content": "217 \n219 \n1 \ndemonstrably fake, but you could have easily \n1\nshe has a history of lying, knowing that she is \n2 \ndiscovered that the implication you were drawing was \n2\neasily suggestible, and they basically pressured \n3 \ndemonstrably false by simply taking one second and \n3\nher, according to my sources, into including me when \n4 \nGoogling her name as my wife did. \n4\nshe didn't want to include me. because by including \n5 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n5\nme, they could make a claim, false as it was, could \n6 \nQ. And so at 25 years old, she wasn't a young \n6\nmake a false claim that a person who negotiated the \n7 \nwoman? \n7\nNPA was also criminally involved with her. \n8 \nA. She was not the kind of woman that I was \n8\nThey also lied — lied unethically and \n9\ndescribing as underage. She was a mature, serious, \n9\nunprofessionally by saying that I negotiated that \n10 \nI think I said in my public statements a model. I \n10 \nprovision of the NM. which gave me, myself, any \n11 \nwasn't aware at the time that see was Viorking for \n11\nkind of • \n' \ncation had I had improper \n12 \nVictoria's Secrets, but Google demonstrates that. \n12 \nSex wit \nvhich, of course, I did \n13\nAnd I described her exactly, in exactly the right \n13 \nnot. And t t was ascot \nbases on which I was \n14 \ntams, a serious person. \n14 \ncertain that they had engaged in unprofessional. \n15 \nI always saw her domed when I saw her — \n15\ndisbarrable and unethical conduct by including that \n16 \nI saw her maybe on two or three occasions. dressed \n16 \nprovision, as well as including a provision that \n17\nappropriately. She was a serious adult worker and I \n17\nPrince Andrew was included because he, Prince \n18 \nthink you insult and demean her when you suggest \n18\nAndrew, pressured a United States attorney to try to \n19 \nthat anything other than that she was a serious \n19\nget a good deal for Jeffrey Epstein. \n20 \nadult when she flew on that airplane. \n20 \nThat is so laughable. How any lawyer \n21 \nQ. You were asked on the occasion of that \n21\n... [truncated, 4604 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/36 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=36]", "char_count": 4604}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 37, "text_content": "221 \n223 \n1 \n1\nwho made transcripts of them. \n2 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n2 \nQ. Did you turn them over to opposing \n3 \nQ. — \"who would tit Into this description? \n3 \ncounsel —\n4 \nThey and the woman got together and contrived and \n4 \nMR. SCOTT: The transcripts — \n5 \nmade this up.\" \n5 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n6 \nDid you make that statement on national \n6 \nQ. — in the course of discovery? \n7\ntelevision? \n7 \nMR. SCOTT: The transcripts we consider to \n8 \nA. Yes, and I just repeated it under oath. I \n8 \nbe work product. If you make a request to \n9 \nbelieve that to be the ease. I think that's exactly \n9 \nproduce, we'll provide them. \n10 \nwhat happened. And I think that my source has \n10 \nMR. SIMPSON: Just for completeness, they \n11 \ncorroborated that. \n11 \nwere also after your discovery request. \n12 \nBy the way, can I add at this point -- I \n12 \nMR. SCOTT: Request to produce, we'll \n11\ndon't mean to distract you, but I think the record \n13 \nconsider providing them. \n14\nwould be more complete if I indicated that I did get \n14 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n15 \na phone call last night from Michael, who told me \n15 \nQ. Is there an entry in any privilege log \n16\n17 \nthat \n' \n3 \nS phone calls and texts \nr \neying to persuade her not to \n17 \n16 \nthat identifies these allegedly privileged work \nproduct documents? \n18 \ntalk to me or cooperate with me and offering the \n18\nMR. SIMPSON: We will -- the lawyers will \n19\nhelp of a lawyer. \n19 \naddress the document production issues. But \n20 \nAnd I also -- although you didn't ask the \n20 \ntwo things, Mr. Scarola, first, they postdate \n21\nquestion. Mr. Scarola, I think for completeness and \n21\nyour request and you have said several times \n22 \nfullness, I do want to say that you asked me whether \n22\nthere's no duty to supplement. And second, \n23 \nor not I knew about what could be taped and what \n23\nthey're work product. \n24 \ndid tape record some of what \n24 \nMR. SCAROLA: Well, sir, if they postdated \n25 Illiec.] \ntold me, with ha \n25\na full and complete production, wh\n... [truncated, 4284 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/37 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=37]", "char_count": 4284}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 38, "text_content": "225 \n1 \nMR. SIMPSON: The flash drive is the same \n2 \nas the document production. \n3 \nMR. SCAROLA: So the answer is no, they're \n4 \nnot there; is that correct? \nMR. SIMPSON: Correct. \n6 \nMR. SCAROLA: Okay. And what's the \n7 \nexplanation for that? \nMR.. SIMPSON: I'm not going to debate this \n9 \non the record with you, Mr. Scarola. \n10 \nMR. SCAROLA: All right. Thank you. \n11 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n12 \nQ. Which conversation with Rebecca did you \n13 \ntape record? \n14 \nA. I tape recorded a conversation with her \n15 \npermission where she told me that she was pressured, \n16 \nshe didn't — where Rebecca told me that Virginia \n17 \nwas pressured and that she didn't want to name me \n18 \nbut she was pressured to name me, that she had never \n19 \npreviously named me. \n20 \nBy the way, I told this to Virginia \n21 \nRoberts' lawyer. \n22 \nMS. MCCAWLEY: Objection. To the extent \n23 \nyou're going to reveal anything that was said \n24 \nduring settlement discussions, I'm moving for \n25 \nsanctions, period. We're not doing this today. \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n227 \nA. I know what you know because I'm a logical \nt Virginia — I know that \nSly called this \nthis \nnd, rc \nknows her name. And you a \nlawyers are operating in psiv \nwhispering to each other, you're passing notes You \narc part of a joint legal team \nAnd if you want to know ha name, all you \nhave to do is ask Sigrid McCawley and she'll tell \nyou her name. I'm sure you know her name. And if \nyou don't know ha name, it's became you haven't \nasked. \nQ. Okay. Well, I'm asking you —\nA. fm not going to tell you -• \nQ. — and I'm telling you I don't know her \nname. \nA. Okay. \nQ. Okay? As an officer of the court, l am \ntelling you I don't know her name. And you are \nunder oath and obliged to answer material and \nrelevant questions, and I want to know what her name \nis. \nMR. SCOTT: I will provide you the name \noff the record, but fin not -- if he feels it's \n226 \n1 \nPlease ittstma the witne\n... [truncated, 3975 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/38 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=38]", "char_count": 3975}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 39, "text_content": "229 \n2 3 ' \n1 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n1 \nmoreaccomplished. \n2 \nQ. What's her phone number? \n2\nMR. SCAROIA: Let's take it easy and slow. \n3 \nA. Ha phone number is kno \n. . . \n3 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n4\nRoberts and presumably- and to \n4 \nQ. How did Michael ten you he knew these \n5 \nroved ph \n5 \npeople he didn't speak to were lawyers? \n6 \nSo all you have to do is \n6 \nvela phone call \n7 \nyou will get that. But I \n7\nft \nhis wife recchal \n8\nthink there's no reason to put her phone number in \n8\nn \nfrom her all through \n9\nthe public record so that she will receive massive \n9 \nthe night. And that they received phone calls as \n10\namounts of phone calls from the media. Scans to me \n10 \nwell from ha lawyers. One of them had a Miami \n11\nthat any — that a judge would try to prevent that \n11 \nphone number. \n12 \nfrom happening. I would hope so. And I'm — you \n12 \nAnd I don't know how he knew they were \n13\ncan get the name and the phone minter from my lawyer \n13 \nlawyers. But that's what he conveyed to me. All I \n14 \nas long as it's -- \n14 \ncan tell you is what he told me, and I'm telling you \n15 \nMR. SCOTT: We'll provide that. \n15 \nthat. \n16 \nA. -- done off the record, not so that the \n16 \nQ. Did you ask him for the phone number? \n17\ntwedia can see iL \n17 \nA. I did not. \n18 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n18 \nQ. Why not? \n19 \nQ. You just swore under oath that lawyers \n19 \nA. I didn't think it was appropriate or \n20\ncontacted Rebecca; is that correct? \n20 \nnecessary. \n21 \nA. I swore wider oath that I was told by \n21 \nQ. What was Inappropriate about asIdng for \n22 \nMichael that lawyers contacted Rebecca, yes. \n22 \nthe phone number to find out who was attempting to \n23 \nQ. Which lawyers? \n23 \ncontact this witness? \n24 \nA. I don't know the answer to that. \n24 \nA. I was not particularly interested in that. \n25 \nQ. Did you ask him? \n25 \nAll I was interested in was getting the truth from \n230 \n232 \n1 \nA. I did. \n1 \nthe witness and trying to prevent her from having a \n2 \nQ. And he said, I — \n2 \nmedia banage that w\n... [truncated, 4068 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/39 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=39]", "char_count": 4068}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 40, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n$ \n7 \n8 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n233 \nlimitations. yes. \nQ. You refused to waive the statute of \nlimitations with regard to sexual crimes, correct? \nA. I didn't refuse anything. I didn't feel I \nhad any obligation to respond to you. And I did \nnot. \nQ. So, you were asked to waive the statute of \nlimitations with regard to your sexual crimes and \nyou refused to respond? \nA. I was asked by you, utterly \ninappropriately, and what I had said -- and if you \ncheck what I said, I said if any reasonable \nprosecutor were to investigate the case and find \nthat there was any basis, I would then waive the \nstatute of limitations. I didn't waive the statute \nof limitations because you, a lawyer, for two \nunprofessional, unethical lawyers asked me to do so, \nwhat obligation do I have to respond to you? \nQ. Well, you have no obligation to respond to \nme at all, Mr. Dershowitz, except now while sou are \nunder oath and I am asking you questions and I would \ngreatly appreciate you responding to the questions \nthat I ask. \nMR. SCOTT: I think lies trying. \n235 \n1 \nQ. And by dropping the dint on the media when \n2 \nthey Bled it, you Intended to convey the message \n3 \nthat Paul Cassel: and Bradley Edwards intentionally \n4 \ngenerated the focus of press attention on that \nfiling; is that correct? \n6 \nA. Absolutely. Absolutely without any doubt. \n7 \nWhy else would they have brought Prince Andrew into \nthis filing? Prince Andrew had no connection to the \n9 \nNPA. no relevance at all. But they knew that by \n10 \nincluding Prince Andrew. this would ding my name \n11 \ninto every single newspaper and media outlet in the \n12 \nworld. \n13 \nIt Was outrageous for them to do this. \n14 \nParticularly because they did so little, if any, \n15 \ninvestigation, which will, of course, be determined \n16 \nwhen they're deposed. And -- and --\n17 \nQ. Well, you've already made that \n18 \ndetermination, right? \n19 \nMR. SCOTT: Wait. \n20 \nA. I'm convinced that -- that they\n... [truncated, 4510 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/40 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=40]", "char_count": 4510}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 41, "text_content": "237 \n239 \n1 \nA. It was whenever -- I'm not sure I ever saw \n1 \nMR. SCOTT: I think he's answered that \n2 \nthe date. He just quidcly showed me the e-mail and \n2 \ntwice. \n3\nI quickly looked at it. \n3 \nA. It came after. It came after. \n4 \nQ. The c-mall that you are referencing, in \n4 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n5\nfact, occurred after you had begun all of your media \n5\nQ. Thank you, sir. On January 5, you made \n6\nappearances with respect to this filing — \n6\nanother CNN Live appearance in an intervkw with \n7 \nA. Let niche very clear about — \n7\n11212 Gorani. Do you recall that? \n8 \nQ. — didn't it, sir? \n8 \nA. I do not =all the name of the person — \n9 \nA. Lel me be very clear about my media \n9 \nQ. Take a look at the transcript, if you \n10 \nappearances so that I— \n10\nwould, please, page IS. \n11 \nQ. How about just answering the questions? \n11 \nMR. SCOTT: Take a moment to review the \n12 \nA. I'm trying to answer the question. All of \n12 \ntranscripL please, Mr. Dasbowitz. \n13 \nmy media appearances -- \n13 \nTHE WITNESS: Page IS. \n14 \nQ. The question is: Did it occur before or \n14 \nMR. SCOTT: Take your time to review that. \n15\nafter your media — your media appearances? That \n15\nA. Yeah, that name is not familiar to me but. \n16\ndoesn't call for a speech — \n16 \nof count, I remember doing an interview, yes. \n17 \nA. It came — \n17 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n18 \nQ. — it calls for before or alter. \n18 \nQ. All right, sir. And during the course of \n19 \nA. It came before some and alter somc. Ii \n19\nthat interview, you said: \"There are flight \n20 \ncame, for example, before my appearance on the BBC \n20 \nmanifests. They will prove I was never on any \n21\nbecause they showed me the e-mail before they \n21 \nprivate airplane with any young woman.\" Correct? \n22 \ninterviewed me for the BBC. So sonic occurred —it \n22 \nA. Yes. \n23\noccurred before some and it occurred after sonic. \n23 \nQ. Go to page 17, if you would. \n24 \nQ. All right. So It Is your assertion that \n24 \nA. Uh-huh. \n25 \nthis single egnall that you have made \n... [truncated, 3992 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/41 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=41]", "char_count": 3992}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 42, "text_content": "241 \n(Discussion off the record.) \n2 \nTHE WITNESS: What's Number 6 then? Tin \n3 \nconfused. there were two. \n4 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n5 \nQ. Have you ever seen Exhibit Number 6 \n6 \nbefore? \n7 \nA. Exhibit Number 6. I don't believe so. It \n8 \ndoesn't look familiar to me. \n9 \nQ. No? \n10 \nA. It does not look familiar to me. \n11 \nQ. Did you bother at any time to review \n12 \ndiscovery that was produced by Bradley Edwards and \n13 \nPaul Cassell responding to requests for information \n14 \nthat supported the allegations \n15 \nA I'm not clear what you're as mg. \n16 \nQ. I want to know —\n17 \nA. In which case? In which case am we \n18 \ntalking? \n19 \nQ. This case. This case. \n20 \nA. Right. \n21 \nQ. Did you ever bother to review the \n22 \ndiscovery produced in this case responding to \n23 \nrequests for all of the information that supported \n24 \ntheir belief in the truthfulness of Virginia \n25 \nRoberts' allegations against you? \n243 \n1 \nexonerated by any flight logs that were innocent —\n2 \nthat were complete and accurate, of course. \n3 \nQ. So you made the public statements \n4 \nrepeatedly that the flight logs would exonerate you \n5 \nwithout having examined the flight logs to see \n6 \nwhether they were accurate or not; is that correct? \n7 \nA. Well, I knew — I knew that —\n8 \nQ. Did you say those things without having \n9 \nexamined the flight logs? \n10 \nA. I said those things having looked at some \n11 \nof the flight logs al some point in time. But I \n12 \nknew for sure that the flight logs would exonerate \n13 \nme because \nnew was \nv r on Jeffrey Epstein's \n14 \nplane wit \nany other young \n15 \nunderage sir s. \n. \n-new \nat to an absolute \n16 \ncertainty. And I was prepared to say it. fm \n17 \nprepared to say it again under oath here. \n18 \nAnd if your clients had simply cal led me \n19 \nand told me they were planning to do this, we \n20 \nwouldn't be here today because I could have shown \n21 \nthem in one clay that it was impossible for me to \n22 \nhave had sex with their client on the island, in the \n23 \nranch,\n... [truncated, 4391 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/42 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=42]", "char_count": 4391}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 43, "text_content": "1. \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n245 \nthat you were in the same place at the same time — \nA. Firs \nQ. — a \nMR. \n• question. \nTHE \nMR. SCOTT: Then you answer the question. \nAnd Mr. Search will by to. you know, keep the \nemotion down, rm sure, so we can get through \nthis with less acrimony between everybody here \nA. Your client has adamantly refused, as well \nas the lawyer --\nBY MR SCAROLA: \nQ. No, sir, that's nonresponsive to my \nquestion. \nMR. SCOTT: Wait a minute. \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \nQ. My question is: Do you deny that the \nflight logs corroborate \nplace at the same time \n1111/Ill\nA. So the question i \nand, therefore, I must answer in this way. Your \nclient --\nQ. How to build a watch? \nMR. SCOTT: Wait a minute, you're cutting \nhim off. He's been trying to answer the \n247 \n1 \nious to sec any tinrframes when \n2 \nclaims she was with me on the \n3 \nis \n,cams \nwas with mc on -- at the ranch, \n4 \nclaims she was with me on the airplanes, claims she \n5 \nwas with me in Palm Beach. And they will all \n6 \nconclusively --\n7 \nQ. You forgot -\n8 \nA. \n9 \n10 \nalso? \n11 \nA. No, I did not mean New York --\n12 \nQ. Oh. okay. \n13 \nA. -- because New York is ray different I \n14 \nwas, in fact, in New York for large periods of time. \n15 \nI was not in fact. on the island during the \n16 \nrelevant timcframc. I was not in the airplane in \n17 \nthe relevant timeliame. I was not in Jeffrey \n18 \nEpstein's Palm Beach home in the relevant timeframe. \n19 \nAnd I was once in the ranch but under circumstances \n20 \nwhere it would have been absolutely impossible for \n21 \nme to have had any contact with her. \n22 \nSo if you will give me the timeframe, I \n23 \nwill be happy to answer your question. But without \n24 \ntimcframcs, that question is an absolutely \n25 \ninappropriate question. And the answer to it is no. \n— New York. Didn't you mean New York \n246 \n1 \nquestion. \n2 \nA. Yotr client has adamantly refused, an:liter \n3 \nlawyers and your clients have refu\n... [truncated, 4110 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/43 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=43]", "char_count": 4110}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 44, "text_content": "249 \n251 \n1 \nflew down to Palm Beach during that relevant period \n1 \nQ. Which of the manifests are you referring \n2\nof time. \n2\nto when you claim what you have claimed about the \n3 \nSo I have a timeframe not that was \n3\nmanifests, Exhibit Number 6 or Exhibit Number 7? \n4 \nprovided by your client but that was provided by the \n4 \nA. I can only tell you that I have reviewed \n5\nexternalities of the case. And that timeframe \n5\nthe manifests and they show, to me, that I was never \n6 \ncoupled with the manifests clearly exonerate me \n6\non Jeffrey Epstein's airplane during the relevant \n7 \nwithout any doubt \n7\nperiod of lime. That's Al can tell you now. \n8 \nQ. I want to make sure that I understood what \n8 \nPm not in a position where I look at all \n9 \nyou just said. \"I never flew down to Palm Beach \n9\nthese documents now. If you point me to any \n10 \nduring the relevant timeframe\"? \n10 \nparticular trip that shows that I was on Jeffrey \n11 \nA. I never flew down and stayed at Jeffrey's \n11\nEpricin's plane. I would be happy to respond to \n12 \nhouse in Palm Beach during that relevant period of \n12 \nthat. \n13 \ntime. \n13 \nQ. There are two separate collections of \n14 \nQ. Okay. So you want to withdraw the \n14 \ndocuments purporting to be flight manifests for \n15 \nstatement that you never flew down to Palm Beach — \n15 \nJeffrey Epstein's plane. When you made the public \n16 \nMR. SCOTT: Objection. \n16\nstatements that you mode regarding the flight logs \n17 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n17\nor manifests exonerating you, were you referring to \n18 \nQ. — during that relevant period of time — \n18\nExhibit Number 6 or Exhibit Number 7? \n19 \nA. Lei me be -- \n19 \nA. I have no recollection as to which \n20 \nMR. SCOTT: Objection. \n20 \nparticular exhibits, which are formed for purposes \n21 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n21 \nof the legal case. I had reviewed. I know I had \n22 \nQ. — and what you want to say is, \"I never \n22 \nreviewed the manifests. Not only had I reviewed the \n23 \nflew down to Palm Beach and stayed at Jeffrey \n23\n\n... [truncated, 4400 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/44 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=44]", "char_count": 4400}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 45, "text_content": "253 \n255 \n1 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n1 \nMIL INDYKE: Objection. This is Darren. \n2 \nQ. Who told you that the manifests confirm \n2 \nAnything that relates to your conversations \n3\nthe accuracy of your public statements? \n3 \nwith Jeffrey — \n4 \nMR. SCOTT: If it involves lawyer-client \n4 \nTHE REPORTER: He's going to have to speak \n5 \nprivilege, don1 answer it. \n5 \nup. \n6 \nTHE WITNESS: Okay. \n6 \nMR. SCOTT: You're going to have to speak \n7 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n7 \nup a little bit more. Counsel. \n8 \nQ. You're refusing to answer? \n0 \nMR. INDYKE: Objection. This is Darren \n9 \nA. No, I would like— \n9 \nIndyke. Anything that Alan might have to say \n10 \nMR. SCOTT: Instruct you not to answer. \n10 \nto that, to the extent they are covered under \n11 \nA. -- to answer. But rye been instmcted \n11 \nconversations with Jeffrey Epstein, privileged \n12\nnot to answer. I would like to answer. \n12 \nunder attomey.client privileges as well as \n13 \nYou've made a statement -- \n13 \ncommon interest privileges. \n14 \nMR. SCOTT: There's no question pending. \n14 \nMR. SCOTT: Do you understand? \n15 \nTHE WITNESS: But he node a statement -- \n15 \nTHE WITNESS: I do. \n16 \nMR. SCOTT: But there's no question \n16 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n17 \npending, sir. \n17 \nQ. To which your response was: \"Sure, sure, \n18 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n18 \ncertainly I have been his lawyer and I did speak to \n19 \nQ. What does it mean to make something up out \n19 \nhim about It- I wanted to make sure that his memory \n20\nof whole cloth? \n20 \nand mine coordinated about when I was at his island. \n21 \nA. It means that nr \n21 \nHe was able to check I was able to check. I \n22 \nclients -- \n22 \nchecked with my friends who went with me.\" \n23 \n' \n• \nI asked you anything \n23 \nDid you make that answer to that question? \n24 \na \nI haven't asked you \n24 \nA. Yes. \n25 \nanything about my clients. \n25 \nQ. Disclosing the contents of your \n254 \n256 \n1 \nI want to know what the words \"making \n1 \ncommunication with Jeffrey Epstein, correct? \n2 \nsomething up out of whole cloth\" mean. \n2 \n\n... [truncated, 3803 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/45 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=45]", "char_count": 3803}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 46, "text_content": "257 \n259 \n1 \nA. The ongoing issues -- \n1 \nQ. — the last 10 years? \n2 \nMR. SCOTT: But nothing about \n2 \nA. I would say 15 --\n3 \nccovnunkrations. \n3 \nQ. Last IS — \na \nA. Right. The crigoing issues relating to the \n4 \nA. -- years. \n5 \nNPA, which continue to this day. And I regard \n5 \nQ. — how about the last 20 years? \n6 \nmyself as his lawyer basically on all those — all \n6 \nA. thaw -- I don't think so. \n7\nthose issues. \n7 \nQ. Okay. \n8 \nBY MR. SCAROI.A: \n8 \nA. As I stand here today. I have no \n9 \nQ. So, when the pleadings were filed in the \n9\nrecollection of ever being in New Mexico except to \n10 \nCrime Vitt' \n• \nrding your conduct in \n10 \nvisit the Ashes in January of 2000.\n11 \nrelationship t \nand Jeffrey \n11 \nI'm 77 years old. I've lived a long life. \n12 \nEpstein, you were an still are his lawyer in the \n12 \nIt is certainly possible that at some earlier point \n13 \nCrime Victim's Rights Act case; is that correct? \n13 \nin my life — I mean, I've been in most of the \n14 \nA. I certainly am bound by lawyer-client \n14 \nstates. But I have no recollection of ever being in \n15 \nprivilege and communications, yes. \n15\nNew Mexico. \n16 \nQ. Okay. You go on to say in that same \n16 \nAnd I can tell you unequivocally the only \n1 7 \ninterview: \"Only once in my life have I been in \n17\ntime I was ever at Jeffrey Epstein's ranch was that \n18 \nthat area,\" referring to New Mexico. \n18 \none time with my wife with the Ashes, with my \n19 \nA. Yes. \n19\ndaughter. And we only stayed there for an hour and \n20 \nQ. \"Only once in my life did my travel \n20\nthe house was not completed. It was under \n21 \nrecords show I was In New Mexico.' \n21 \nconstruction. And I certainly did not have any \n22 \nA. Uh•hula \n22 \nsexual encounter or any encounter with Virginia \n23 \nQ. Is that an accurate statement? \n23\nRoberts during that visit. \n24 \nA. To the best of my knowledge. I have no \n24 \nMR. SCAROLA: Move to strike the \n25 \nrecollectionof being in New Mexico other than \n25\nunresponsive portions of the answer. \n258 \n2\n... [truncated, 4259 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/46 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=46]", "char_count": 4259}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 47, "text_content": "261 \n1 \noften than we usually say. \n2 \nMR. SCAROLA: Yes. sir. \n3 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n4 \nQ. In interviews on January 4 and January 5, \n5 \nyou claim to have completed the necessary work to \n6 \nIdentify documents exonerating you within an hour \n7 \nafter learning of the accusations that were made, \n8 \ncorrect? \n9 \nA. I don't remember having said that. But \n10 \nwithin a minute, I had clear knowledge that every \n11 \ndocument in the world would exonerate Inc because I \n12 \nknew fort absolute certainty that every aspect of her \n13 \nallegation was totally false. That's why I \n14 \nchallenged the other side to produce videos, to \n15 \nproduce photographs. I knew that there could be no \n16 \nevidence inculpating me because I knew I was \n17 \ninnocent. So I knew that all of my records would \n18 \nprove that. \n19 \nFacts arc facts. And I just wasn't in an \n20 \ncontact or any sexual contact wit \n21 \nand I knew with absolute certainty that the facts \n22 \nwould completely exonerate me. And if your clients \n23 \nhad just called me, at the courtesy of simply \n24 \ncalling me, I would have been able to point them to \n25 \nProfessor Michael Potter of the Harvard Business \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n39 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n263 \nA. Where? Where? Can you point to that? \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \nQ. Well, I'm asking you, sir, based wain your \nsuperb memory whether you remember having said —\nMR. SCOTT: No, were going to do —\nBY MR. SCAROLA: \nQ. — on Jan — \nMR. SCOTT': lie's going to take a moment to \nreview the transcript and \nand that's any \nwitness is entitled to do that. So why don't \nwe take a break, hen review transcript and \nwell come back? We've been going an hour --\nMR. SCAROLA: Because I haven't asked him \na question about the transcript. \nMR. SCOTT: You've asked --\nMR. SCAROLA: I'm asking him a question \nabout his recollection. \nMR. SCOTT: Based upon what he said in the \ntranscript \nMR. SCAROLA: No. fm asking him whether \nhe has a recollection of having madc pu\n... [truncated, 4398 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/47 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=47]", "char_count": 4398}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 48, "text_content": "265 \n1 \nhave another hour. \n2 \nMR. SCAROLA: I'm almost ready to take a \n3 \nbreak. \n4 \nMR. SCOTT: Okay. \n5 \nMR. SCAROLA: Could you read back the last \n6 \nquestion, please? \nFirst of all. I move to strike the \n8 \nunresponsive speech. \n9 \nAnd now read back the last question. if \n10 \nyou would. \n11 \n(Requested portion read back as follows:) \n12 \nTHE REPORTER: \"Do you remember having \n13 \nmade those statements?\" \n14 \nDo you want me to read prior to that? \n15 \nMR. SCAROLA: No, that's fine. That's the \n16 \nquestion that I asked. \n17 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n18 \nQ. Is I he answer yes? \n19 \nA. I don't lung:tibia specifically. !do \n20 \ngenerally remember having said that your clients \n21 \n' \n\" \nconclusive proof that \n22 \nrag about Inc and that I \n23 \nf come, it was false--\n24 \nMR. SCAROLA: Tom — \n25 \nA. -- been able to uncover such proof. \n267 \n1 \nand then explained it but now you have it \n2 \ndirectly answered. So were \nwere at a \n3 \nbreak point. \n4 \nMR. SCAROLA: Thank you. \n5 \nVIDEOGRAPHER: Going off the record. The \n6 \ntime is approximately 11:01 a.m. \n7 \n(Recess was held from 11:01 a.m. until 11:23 a.m.) \n8 \nVIDEOGRAPHER: Going back on the record \n9 \nThe time is approximately 11:23 a.m. \n10 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n11 \nQ. When did you last travel from outside the \n12 \nState of Florida to arrive In Florida? \n13 \nA. The day before yesterday. I think. \n14 \nQ. And where did you travel from? \n15 \nA. New York. \n16 \nQ. When were you last in Boston, in the \n17 \nBoston area? \n18 \nA. About two weeks ago. \n19 \nQ. So, if anyone had represented that you \n20 \nwere going to be traveling from Boston to Florida \n21 \nthis past weekend, that would have been a \n22 \nmisrepresentation; is that correct? \n23 \nA. I have no idea what you're talking about. \n24 \nQ. Well. I'm talking about your personal \n25 \ntravels. If anyone had represented that you were \n266 \n1 \nMR. SCAROLA: That has nothing to do with \n2 \nthe question I asked — \n3 \nMR. SCOTT: Let's take — let's take a \n4 \nbreak like I suggested and well come ba\n... [truncated, 3961 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/48 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=48]", "char_count": 3961}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 49, "text_content": "A. I have — \n269 \n1 \n2 \nQ. — dining thecoarse of the deposition, I \n2 \n3 \nam permitted to examine It. \n3 \n4 \nA. I have lawyer-client privileged \n4 \n5 \ninformation in hem. so I can't give it to you. I \nS \n6 \ncan give it to you in a redacted form. I have a \n7 \nquote from David Bois in here, which I'm sure —\n7 \na \nMR. SCOTT: Don't -\n8 \n9 \nA. — nobody is going to want to sec —\n9 \n10 \nMR. SCOTT: Well make a copy and give it \n10 \n11 \nto you. \n11 \n12 \nMR. SCAROLA Thank you. Would you hand \n12 \n13 \nit to your counsel, please? \n13 \n19 \nMR SCOTT: On that note. hold onto that. \n14 \n15 \nTIIE WITNESS: But I need that back. \n15 \n16 \nMR. SCOTT: Of course. Don't worry. \n16 \n17 \nMR. SIMPSON: Hold on to it. \n17 \n18 \nMR. SCOTT: That's why I saw it to him \n18 \n19 \nbecause I'd lose it. \n19 \n20 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n20 \n21 \nQ. Before January 21.2015, what Information \n21 \n22 \ndld you have regarding what Bradley Edwards and Paul \n22 \n23 \nCassell had p \nInvestigating \n23 \n29 \nthe accuracy o \nlions \n24 \n25 \nagainst you? \n25 \n270 \n1 \nA. Well. first, I knew that anything they \n1 \n2 \ngathered -• \n2 \n3 \nMR. IN DYKE: Objection to the extent that \n3 \n4 \nrequires —\n4 \n5\nMR. SCOTT: Whoa. \n5 \n6 \nMS. MCCAWLEY: \nyou to disclose anything \n6\n7 \nyou gave --\n7 \n8\nTHE COURT REPORTER: I can't hem. \n9 \nI'm sorry, Mr. Indyke, can you repeat your \n9 \n10 \nobjection? \n10 \n11 \nMR. SCOTT: Can you say that a little \n11 \n12 \nlouder? \n12 \n13 \nMR. INDYKE: Darren Indyke. I would \n13\n14 \nobject to the extent Mal your answer would \n14 \n15 \ndisclose anything you -- you obtained or \n15 \n16 \nlearned or any knowledge you gained in \n16 \n17 \nconnection with your representation of Jeffrey \n17 \n18 \nEpstein. \n18 \n19 \nMR. SCOTT: Do you understand that \n19 \n20 \ninSIniction? \n20 \n21 \nTHE WITNESS: I do, yes. \n21 \n22 \nCould you repeat the question? \n22 \n23 \nBY MR. SCAROL A: \n23\n24 \nQ. Yes, sir. I want to know what information \n24 \n25 \nyou had regarding what Bradley Edwards and Paul \n25 \n271 \nCassell had done in the course of their \ninvest\n... [truncated, 4153 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/49 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=49]", "char_count": 4153}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 50, "text_content": "273 \n1 \nof outrageous, honible, inexcusable misconduct. at \n2 \nleast call the person and ask thcm if they can \n3 \ndispose it before you file a -- a statement. Not \n4 \neven asking for a hearing on it, not even basically \n5 \nseeking to prove it. just --just putting it in a \n6 \npleading as if scrolling on a bathroom stall. \n7 \nSo, yes, I had -- I had a great basis for \nmaking that kind of statement and I repeat it here \n9 \ntoday. And we will find out in depositions what \n10 \nbasis they actually had. And nn anxiously awaiting \n11 \nMr. Cassell's deposition this afternoon. \n12 \nMR. SCAROLA: Move to strike the \n13 \nnon-responsive portion of that answer. \n14 \nCould I have a standing objection to \n15 \nunresponsive --\n16 \nMR. SCOTT: Sure. \n17 \nMR. SCAROLA: — answers? That would be \n18 \nhelpful. Thank you. I appreciate that. That \n19 \nwill save us — \n20 \nMR. SCOTT: Absolutely. No, anytime. \n21 \nMR. SCAROLA: -- save us some time. \n22 \nMR. SCOTT: Thank you, sir. \n23 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n24 \nQ. The one portion of what you just said that \n25 \ndirectly responded to my question was you knew in \n275 \n1 \nyour assertion that the testimony of these two \n2 \nIndividuals completely exculpates you. \n3 \nA. Uh-huh. \n4 \nQ. The following question was asked of — \nMR. SCOTT: What you arc reading from? \n6 \nMR. SCAROLA: I'm reading from the \n7 \ndeposition transcript. \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n9 \nQ. The following question was asked of — \n10 \nMR. SCOTT: The deposition transcript --\n11 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n12 \nQ. —of Mr. Juan — Mr. Juan Akssl and — \n13 \nMR. SCOTT: fat me object to the —first \n14 \nof all, let inc object to this fonmi because he \n15 \nhas not been provided a part of the deposition. \n16 \nYou're reading portions from the deposition --\n17 \nMR. SCAROLA: Yes, I am. \n18 \nMR. SCOTT: -- which can be taken out of \n19 \ncontext. He has not had the ability to review \n20 \nthe deposition. This is inproper. \n21 \nMR. SCAROLA: Okay. \n22 \nMR. SCOTT: Cross-examination. \n23 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n24 \nQ. Do you recall the foll\n... [truncated, 4060 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/50 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=50]", "char_count": 4060}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 51, "text_content": "277 \n279 \n1 \noils and towels? \n1\nis a third-year student at Harvard, were anthem \n2 \n\"Answer: Yes, ma'am- \n2\nwith me. Thal was the only time that I stayed over \n3 \n\"Question: And did you ever have occasion \n3\nmore than one night. And I never stayed even one \n4 \nto go upstairs and clean up after the massages? \n4 \nnight during the relevant timeframe. \n5 \n\"Answer: Yeah, uh-huh. \n5 \nBut most importantly, he gives no \n6 \n\"Question: Did you ever find any \n6\ntimcframc. And clearly his reference to the sex \n7 \nvibrators In that area? \n7\ntoys is a reference to the part of the house that I \n8 \n\"Answer: Yes. I told him yes. \n8\nwas never permitted in and never entered. \n9 \n\"Question: Would you describe for me what \n9 \nQ. What Is the question that you think you \n10 \nIdnds of vibrators you found? \n10\nwere answering? \n11 \n\"Answer. I'm not too familiar with the \n11 \nA. Whether --\n12 \nnames, but they were like big dildos, what they \n12 \nMR. SCOTT: He was explaining to you \n13 \ncall the big rubber things like that \n13 \nexactly why he felt that that was \n14 \n(indicating). And I used to go and put my \n14 \ninappropriate, which is exactly what you asked \n15 \ngloves on and pick them up, put them in the \n15 \nhim. \n16 \nsink, rinse it off and put it in Ms. Maxwell — \n16 \nMR. SCAROLA: No. it is not \n17 \nMs. :Maxwell had in her closet, she had like a \n17 \nMR. SCOTT: Well, it is my recollection, \n16 \nlaundry basket. And you put laundry in. She \n18 \nso I don't know --\n19 \nhave full of those toys.\" \n19 \nMR. SCAROLA: Well, then —\n20 \nIs that testimony that exonerates you, \n20 \nMR. SCOTT: I think he was defending --\n21 \nMr. Dershowite? Is that what you were referring to? \n21 \nMR. SCAROLA: Let me try the same question \n22 \nMR. SCOTT: Let me — objection to the \n22 \nover again \n23 \nform. improper cross examination by taking \n23 \nMR. SCOTT: I think he was defending \n24 \nexcerpts out of depositions of witnesses. \n24 \nhis -- his position. \n25 \n25 \nTHE WITNESS: Right. \n278 \n280 \n1 \nBY MR. SCAROIA: \n1 \nBY \n... [truncated, 4290 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/51 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=51]", "char_count": 4290}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 52, "text_content": "281 \n1 \nWhat was his motive against you? \n2 \nA. I was Jeffrey Epstcin's friend and lawyer \n3 \nand, in fact -- well. 1 can't get into this. But I \n4 \ncan say this, l gave advice --\n5 \nMR. SCOTT: Be careful about anything \n6 \ninvolving --\n7 \nTHE WITNESS: Okay. \n8 \nMR. SCOTT: -- Mr. Epstein. please. \n9 \nA. He could easily have believed that I was \n10 \none of the causes of his firing. \n11 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n12 \nQ. So, he was -- he may have been angry al \n13 \nyou because you assisted in getting him fired? \n14 \nA. It's --\n15 \nMR. SCOTT: Objection, \n16 \nntischaracterization. \n17 \nA. It's conjecture. It's possible. But in \n18 \nany event, even --\n19 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n20 \nQ. It's conjecture, is that what you were \n21 \nabout to say? \n22 \nA. I'm saying I have -- I don't know what he \n23 \nwas thinking, but there is a basis for him believing \n24 \nthat. But most -- most important, even if you take \n25 \neverything he says as true, which it's not, it's \n283 \n1 \nA. Ycs. \n2 \nQ. A man who would never undertake to advance \n3 \nthe cause of a client whom he believed to be \n4 \nIncredible, right? \n5 \nA. Yes. Andaman who told me and a man \n6 \nwho--\n7 \nMR. SCOTT: That's it. \n8 \nA. Okay. And a man who believes I'm \n9 \ninnocent. \n10 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n11 \nQ. You know that Bob Josefsberg would never \n12 \nfile charges on behalf of a client alleging that she \n13 \nwas lent out by Jeffrey Epstein for purposes of \n14 \nsexual abuse while she was a minor to academicians \n15 \nunless he absolutely had confidence that those \n16 \nstatements were true - \n17 \nMR. SCOTT, Let me object —\n18 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n19 \nQ. -right? \n20 \nMR. SCOTT: -- that this is completdy \n21 \nirrelevant to the issues in this case. \n22 \nWhatever Mr. Josefsberg thinks has nothing to \n23 \ndo with this lawsuit. This is all your effort \n24 \nto try to put Josefsberg into this case to try \n25 \nto give some justification to your position. \n1 \n2 \na \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n282 \nexculpato\n... [truncated, 3657 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/52 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=52]", "char_count": 3657}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 53, "text_content": "285 \n1 \nrelationship with him and he has an ability to \n2 \njustify and explain his position in response \n3 \nMR. SCAROLA: If it's responsive to the \n4 \nquestion. \n5 \nA. It's responsive. And as far as the \n6 \nfilibustering is — \n7 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n8 \nQ. Do you remember what the question is? \n9 \nA. -- is concerned, I was here --\n10 \nQ. Do you remember what the question was? \n11 \nA. Yes. Yes. \n12 \nQ. What is the question? \n13 \nA. The question is — no, why don't you \n14 \nrepeat the question. \n15 \nQ. Yes, sir. \n16 \nA. So --\n17 \nQ. You know that Bob Josefsberg would not \n18 \nadvance allegations on behalf of a client that that \n19 \nclient had been lent out by Jeffrey Epstein to \n20 \nsatisfy the sexual desires of friends of Jeffrey \n21 \nEpstein, including academicians, unless Bob \n22 \nJosefsberg believed those allegations to be true, \n23 \nright? \n24 \nA. I believe that — I know that Bob \n25 \nJosefsberg would never maintain a friendship with \n287 \nthe people who the FBI had put on the — the list. \n2 \nI just don't know what his responsibility was. \n3 \nI can say with confidence that he would \n4 \nonly ad ethically and would. A. not represent \n5 \nnot make any false statements the way your clients \n6 \nmade than, and that I wish your clients had the \n7 \nethics of Bob Josefsberg \n8 \nQ. You then agree that if Bob Josefsbcrg \n9 \nadvanced the claims that I have described in a \n10 \ncomplaint on behalf of a client, he would not have \n11 \ndone so unless he believed those allegations to be \n12 \ntrue, having conducted a fair and reasonable \n13 \nInvestigation, correct? \n14 \nMR. SCOTT: Objection, asked and answered \n15 \nseveral limes. \n16 \nA. I don't know the answer to that question \n17 \nbecause I don't know the context in which he made \n18 \nthese arguments. All I do know is that he never \n19 \nwould maintain a friendship with me if he believed \n20 \nin any way that I was cne of the people that she had \n21 \naccused. \n22 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n23 \nQ. Did Alfredo Rodriguez, another one of your \n24 \nfr\n... [truncated, 4492 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/53 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=53]", "char_count": 4492}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 54, "text_content": "289 \n1 \nA. \nbelieve that. \n2 \nQ. — recall the following testimony — \n3 \nA. It wouldn't be true if he said it. \n4 \nQ. Yes. sir. Well, do you recall the \nfollowing testimony having been given by Mr. Alfredo \n6 \nRodriguez In a deposition that was taken on \n7 \nAugust 7,2009? \n\"Question: Mr. Rodriguez, you staled last \n9 \nlime that there were guests at the house, \n10 \nfrequent guests from Harvard. Do you remember \n11 \nthat testimony? \n12 \n\"Answer: Yes, ma'am. \n13 \n\"Question: Was there a lawyer from \n14 \nIlartiard named Alan Dershowitz? \n15 \n\"Answer: Yes, ma'am \n16 \n\"Question: And arc you familiar with the \n17 \nfact that he's a famous author and famous \n18 \nlawyer? \n19 \n\"Answer: Yes, ma'am. \n20 \n\"Question: How often during the six \n21 \nmonths or so that you were there was \n22 \nMr. Dershowitz there? \n23 \n\"Answer: Two or three times. \n24 \n\"Question: And did you have any knowledge \n25 \nof why he was visiting there? \n291 \n1 \nthat testimony? \n2 \nA. Yes. \n3 \nMR. SCOTT: Objection. This is totally \n4 \nimproper cross examination of a witness by \ntrying to use a deposition. The only purpose \n6 \nof doing this is to interject this into the \n7 \nrecord. which has no relevance and would not be \nadmissible at trial. And in any ease, he never \n9 \nactually has my client doing any of the thing, \n10 \nthat you've accused him of. \n11 \nGo about, let's go ahead and do it. \n12 \nAnswer the question. Answer the question. \n13 \nMR. SCAROLA: He did. \n14 \nA. Yes, I iumura....r that. \n15 \nMR. SCAROLA: He said yes. \n16 \nA. Yes. I remember that. yes. \n17 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n18 \nQ. And do you know why it was that back in \n19 \n19 - excuse me, back in 2009, August of 2009, four \n20 \nand a half years before you allege that this story \n21 \nabout you was being made up out of whole cloth, that \n22 \nlawyers representing Jeffrey Epstein's victims, \n23 \nIncluding Katherine Ezell, E-Z-E-L-L from Bob \n24 \nJosefsberg's office, who had filed the complaint \n25 \nalleging that you had — excuse me, that Virginia \n290 \n1 \n\"An\n... [truncated, 4018 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/54 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=54]", "char_count": 4018}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 55, "text_content": "293 \n295 \n1 \nexcerpts out of a deposition to try to imply \n1 \nDo you remember that testimony having been \n2 \nsomething when there's other parts that totally \n2 \ngiven? \n3 \narc inconsistent with that. And if you're \n3 \nA. I assume that when your clients used the \n4 \ngoing to do that, then he has the ability under \n4\ntrartsdipt as a basis for their false conclusion \n5 \nour rules to review the entire transcript of \n5\nthat I was guilty, they reed the whole transcripts. \n6 \nthe deposition and that's what fin permitting \n6\nnot just the --\n7 \nhim to do, just like when were in court. \n7 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n8 \nMR. SCAROLA: What Ian doing. \n8 \nQ. Every word. \n9 \nMr. Scott -- what I am doing, Mr. Scott -- \n9 \nMR. SCOTT: Don't interrupt him. \n10 \nMR. SCOTT: Have you read that now, sir? \n10 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n11 \nMR. SCAROLA: -- is reviewing the evidence \n11 \nQ. You don't need to assume that. I will \n12 \nthat was relied upon by Bradley Edwards and by \n12\nstipulate they read every word. \n13 \nPaul Cassell in coming to the conclusion that \n13 \nMR. SCOTT: Mr. Scarola, he's speaking. \n14 \nthe allegations that had been made by Virginia \n14 \nYou don't have a right to do this. \n15 \nRoberts were, in fact, credible allegations. \n15 \nA. And if you read every word, you will see \n16 \nMR. SCOTT: And I'm -- \n16\nthat its totally exculpatory. that I have no idea \n17 \nMR. SCAROLA: Because your own client has \n17\nwhether there were any young women in one part of \n18 \nacknowledged that this is information that was \n18\nthe house when I was in another part of the house. \n19 \navailable to both him and to them back in 2009. \n19\nIt's completely consistent with my testimony that I \n20 \nMR. SCOTT: And what I am doing is showing \n20\nhave never seen any underage women. Let's see. \n21 \nhim portions of the sank deposition that \n21 \nAnd if you read the whole transcript. \n22 \ntotally take a different position from this \n22 \nyou'll see. I think: \n23 \nwitness from what you have read, so that this \n23 \n\"Was Dershowit\n... [truncated, 4262 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/55 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=55]", "char_count": 4262}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 56, "text_content": "297 \n299 \n1\nBeach police depanment says. \n1 \nthis. \n2 \nQ. You never read those reports? \n2 \nA. Excuse me one second. \n3 \nA. I don't know which reports you're \n3 \nMR. SCOTT: You know, you think this is \n4\nreferring to. \n4 \nfunny and I think this man's --and I think \n5 \nQ. All of the reports about Jeffrey Epstein. \n5 \nthis man's --\n6 \nMR. SCOTT: Asked and answered yesterday \n6 \nMR. SCAROLA: I think it's inipmper for \n7 \nco this whole lint \n7 \nyou to be coaching the witness in the middle of \n8 \nA. I probably did not read all the reports on \n8 \nexamination. If you think that there's \n9\nJeffrey Epstein. rm sure I've read some of them. \n9 \nsomething that needs to be brought out, you do \n10\nI do not recall -- \n10 \nthat in cross examination. You don't feed hint \n11 \nMR. SCOTT: Be careful about any work -- \n11 \ninformation that you want him to be reading in \n12 \nattorney-diem privilege. \n12 \nthe middle of my examination of this witness. \n13 \nTHE WITNESS: Right. \n13 \nMR. SCOTT: No. But it's also true that \n14 \nA. I don't remember my name coming up. I was \n14 \nunder our rules, when you read portions of a \n15\nthe lawyer during that period of time. \n15\ndeposition, he has the ability to read other \n16 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n16 \nportions of the deposition which clarify the \n17 \nQ. To the extent that Bradley Edwards and \n17 \nanswers. That's done in every courtroom on \n18\nPaul Cassell relied upon detailed reports fromthe \n18\nevery time a witness -- you have selected \n19\nPalm Beach \nlice department in order to assess the \n19\nportions of it that am not accurate based on\n20 \ncredibility \nwould It be \n20 \nother portions and l am having him review them \n21\nreasonable for them to rely upon police reports? \n21 \nsince you did not offer him the deposition to \n22 \nA. I would hope that they would rely on all \n32\nreview. \n23\nthe police reports, including the ones that showed \n23 \nMR. SCAROLA: And that's what you do -- \n24 \nthat she was involved in criminal actions, including \n24\nMR. SCOTT: And I thi\n... [truncated, 4012 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/56 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=56]", "char_count": 4012}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 57, "text_content": "301 \n303 \n1 \n\"Certainly he knew they were there? \n1 \nA. Let me answer. 'Rely\" connotes to me that \n2 \n1 don't know, sir.\" \n2 \nthey would place a heavy emphasis on that to the \n3 \nThat's the best you can do? That's really \n3\nexclusion of ocher things and that it would be \n4 \nthe best you can do? You think a professional \n4\nenough. And so my answer is, yes, they certainly \n6 \nlawyer would make these allegations based on \"I \n5\nshould have read all the reports They certainly \n6\ndon't know. sir.\" \n6\nshould have read all the transcripts. But they also \n7 \nMR. SCAROLA: Is there a question pending, \n7\nshould have called me, they should have made other \n8 \nMr. Scott? \n8\ninquiry, and they should have made sure that they \n9 \nMR. SCOTT: He's reading — you asked him \n9\nread all of these depositions and reports in \n10 \nwhat he was reading-- \n10 \ncontext. \n11 \nMR. SCAROLA: Yes, sir. \n11 \nAnd ifyou're implying that there are FBI \n12 \nMR. SCOTT: -- front and I had him publish \n12 \nreports that in any way inculpate me, that's \n13 \nit. \n13\nI have from Former \ninconsistent with the information \n14 \nMR. SCAROLA: Yeah, I brow, and then he \n14\nChief of Assistant Jeffrey Sloman, who was prepared \n15 \nwent on to make a speech. So I know I don't \n15\nto file an affidavit saying that that wasn't the \n16 \nhave to do it. but I'm compelled to move to \n16 \ncase but was prevented front doing so by thc Justice \n17 \nstrike the unresponsive speeches. \n17\nDepartment. \n18 \nMR. SCOTT: And I consider these to be a \n18 \nMR. SCOTT: It's about noon now. So I \n19 \nresponse to the interrogation that you did \n19 \nguess we're heading — we're wrapping this up! \n20 \ntaking excerpts improperly and not having the \n20 \nMR. SCAROLA: Not quite yet. \n21 \nentire record in front of him, which he's \n21 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n22 \nentitled to do to make that the record is \n22 \nthat the allegations that \n23 \ncomplete. And I intend to protect him in that \n23 \nade against Prince Andrew were \n24 \nway. \n24 \nwell-founded allegations, c\n... [truncated, 4056 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/57 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=57]", "char_count": 4056}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 58, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n305 \nTHE REPORTER: Hold on. Hold on. \nA. -- the absence of any --\nMR. SCOTT: She can't take it down. \nTHE WITNESS: Sony. \n(Thereupon. marked as Plaintiff \nExhibit 8.) \nTHE REPORTER: les okay. Go ahead. \nA. And I want to note the absence of any \nphotograph of me wit \nBY MR. SCAROLA. \nQ. That's the photograph that you were \nreferring to? \nA. rve seen this photograph in the \nnewspapers. \nQ. Yes, sir. And the woman on the far tight \nof that photograph, who Is that? \nA. Ghislainc Maxwell. \nQ. The woman that you and your friend Jeffrey \nEpstein have traveled with repeatedly, correct? \nA. No. A woman who I may have traveled with \non two or three occasions. I can't think of more \ntimes than that that I traveled with her, but it's \npossible But not -- I wouldn't say repeated \noccasions. I've --\nQ. Well — \n3 07 \n1 \nTHE WITNESS: Excusc me, I need to a take \n2 \na vay quick bathroom break. \n3 \nMR. SCAROLA: That's fine. \n4 \nTHE WITNESS: Probably be two minutes or \n5 \nless than two minutes. \n6 \nVIDEOGRAPHER: Going off the record. The \n7 \ntime is approximately 12:03 p.m. \n(Sidebar held off the record.) \n9 \nMR. SCAROLA: While were waiting. let me \n10 \nmark the next numbered exhibits as well. That \n11 \nwill save us sane time. \n12 \nMR. SCOTT: What is this? \n13 \nMR. SCAROLA: Her calendar, his calendar. \n14 \nMR. SCOTT: Who's calendar is this, \n15 \nCarolyn's? \n16 \nMR. SCAROLA: Okay. This is Number 10 \n17 \nMR. SCOTT: Carolyn's calendar. \n18 \n(Thereupon, marked as Plaintiff \n19 \nExhibit 10.) \n20 \nMR. SCAROLA: This is Number II. \n21 \n(Thereupon, marked as Plaintiff \n22 \nExhibit I I.) \n23 \nMR. SCAROLA: This is Number 12. \n24 \n(Thereupon, marked as Plaintiff \n25 \nExhibit 12.) \n306 \n1 \nA. -- probably been in her presence fewer \n2 \nthan a dozen times. \n3 \nQ. I'm going to hand you —\n4 \nA. But just to be clear, what I knew about \n5 \nGhislaine Maxwell was that she was the daughter or a \n6 \nprominent British \n... [truncated, 3562 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/58 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=58]", "char_count": 3562}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 59, "text_content": "309 \n3 1 1 \n1 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n1\nDecember. \n2 \nQ. And can you determine from the calendar \n2 \nQ. One shows the subsequent two months and \n3 \nentries here where your wife Is during the period of \n3\nthe —\n4\ntime that's covered by these calendar entries? \n4 \nA. Okay. \n5 \nA. I would have to looks a panicular \n5 \nQ. — other one shows --\n6 \nentry. If it describes where she is. yes. \n6 \nA. Yes. \n7 \nQ. Okay. Well, tell me where she is. \n7 \nQ. — the preceding and following month, \n8 \nA. What day? \n8\ncorrect? \n9 \nMR. SCOTT: Which one? What point? \n9 \nA. Yes, that does look like it's December of \n10 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n10\n2000. yes. \n11 \nQ. The period covered by this calendar \n11 \nQ. Okay, sir. So look at the calendar and \n12 \nbetween December 7 and December 13. \n12 \ntell me where It appears your wife is during this \n13 \nA. What year? \n13\nperiod of time. \n14 \nQ. You know what, I can't tell you what year \n14 \nA. Thc whole period of time? \n15 \nIt is from these calendars. So you tell me. \n15 \nMR. SCOTT: Please read the exhibit, all \n16 \n1 suggest to you that this Is a calendar \n16 \nthe pages, thoroughly, so that you have a full \n17 \nfrom December of 2000, since the next two months at \n17 \ncontext. \n18\nthe top of the calendar are January 2001 and \n18 \nA. it says. A.D. in Boston. That means I was \n19 \nFebruary 2001. So let's assume that since it is a \n19\nin — in Boston. \n20 \npage from a calendar that appears to be December of \n20 \nIt says Charleston, New York. It says \n21 \n2000, that It's December of 2000. \n21 \nbook fair. It says book fair. It says A.D. in \n22 \nThat would be a reasonable conclusion, \n22 \nBoston. \n23 \nwouldn't It? \n23 \nIt then says the Halbrcichcs arrive. \n24 \nA. I have no idea. \n24\nThey — they were probably our guests. \n25 \nQ. You don't know? \n25 \n310 \n312 \n1 \nA. I don't know. I nimn,1 daft know -- you \n1 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n2 \nsaid you daft -- you can't tell what the year is, \n2 \nQ. Your guests at home in Cambridge, \n3 \nso .. \n3 \nMassachusetts, ighe \n4 \nQ. Well, I'm \n... [truncated, 3854 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/59 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=59]", "char_count": 3854}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 60, "text_content": "313 \n1 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n2 \nQ. Of the lint page of this composite is \n3 \nthat there is a notation that says Alan Dershowitz \n4 \nII:45 a.m., New York City, right? \n5 \nA. Eleven -- A.D. I I A5 and then there's a \n6 \nword that I can't read \n7 \nQ. How about a.m.? \n8 \nA. Oh, 5:00 a.m.. New York City. yes. \n9 \nQ. Okay. Thank you, sir. \n10 \nAnd the next page, where did — where did \n11 \nyour wife have opera instructions? \n12 \nA. I have no idea. We go to the opera in \n13 \nBoston, we go to the opera in New York, we go to the \n14 \nopera in Florida. We do a lot --a lot of opera. I \n15 \ndon't know what \"opera instructions' means. \n16 \nMaybe it would be best if you asked my \n17 \nwife about these things. It's her calendar. \n18 \nQ. I — I Intend to, sir, but — \n19 \nA. Sure. \n20 \nQ. — these are calendars that you produced \n21 \nas part of the evidence that you contend exonerates \n22 \nyou. So, I assumed that you had some knowledge of \n23 \nthe meaning of these pages. \n24 \nA. No. \n25 \nQ. But I may be wrong. \n315 \n1 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n2 \nQ. And you would appear in New York —\n3 \nA. Well, no --\n4 \nQ. — for those Court TV appearances —\n5 \nA. I would appear --\n6 \nQ. — on a regular basis, correct? \n7 \nA. I would appear wherever I was. So when I \n8 \nwas in New York. I appeared in New York, iota they \n9 \nwould do it by remote when I was in a different \n10 \ncity. And I clearly did some remotes for Court TV. \n11 \nQ. In fact, you took an apartment In New York \n12 \nfor purposes of convenience to facilitate your \n13 \nNew York Court TV appearances, correct? \n14 \nA. Totally false. \n15 \nQ. Did you have an apartment in New York \n16 \nduring this period of time in December of 2000? \n17 \nA. I had an apartment for -- I've had an \n18 \napartment in Ncw York for 30 — 30 years or more. \n19 \nBut I certainly didn't take an apartment for \n20 \npurposes of Court TV, no. \n21 \nQ. On Tuesday, December 12, the eau y is \n22 \nI:30, Jeff, correct? \n23 \nA. Right. Yeah. \n24 \nQ. And that's a reference to Jeffrey Epstein. \n25 \nc\n... [truncated, 3996 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/60 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=60]", "char_count": 3996}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 61, "text_content": "317 \n319 \n1 \nQ. December 11,2000, PB1 to Teterboro. \n1 \nthat, but that you were in New York at the same time \n2 \npassengers, Jeffrey Epstein — \n2 \nJeffrey Epstein -\n3 \nA. Wait a second. I have to find it. \n3 \nA. And that Carolyn --\n4 \nMR. SCOTT: Well, let him -- let him read \n4 \nQ. — and Virginia were in New York and you \n5 \nthe exhibit. \n5 \nwere — \n6 \nA. What — what's the date? \n6 \nA. And that Carolyn arranged for a massage. \n7\nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n7 \nQ. — having a massage. \n8 \nQ. December 11. \n8 \nA. And that my wife arranged for a massage. \n9 \nA. December II. Yes, I sec that. \n9 \nQ. No, I didn't say that at all, sir? \n10 \nQ. Palm Beach International Airport to \n10 \nMR. SCOTT: Well. that's what he's saying \n11 \nTeterboro? \n11 \nthat the record reflects. \n12 \nA. Right, yeah. \n12 \nA. The record --\n13 \nQ. Passengers, Jeffrey Epstein? \n13 \nMR. SCOTT: Don't cut him off. \n14 \nA. Right. \n14 \nA. •• reflects that Carolyn -- Carolyn always \n15 \nQ. GM, a reference to Chislaine — excuse me, \n15\nwanted me to have massages because she thought it \n16 \nGhislaine Maxwell, \n16 \nwould relax me. I don't like massages particularly, \n17 \nA. Uh-huh. \n17 \nbut whin Carolyn arranged massages, almost always we \n18 \nQ. And ET and Virginia, right? \n18 \nhad than togahcr at the swim time. We would have \n19 \nA. That's what it says. yes, sir. \n19 \nthe same masseuse, sometimes a man, sometimes a \n20 \nQ. And then we see three of the same four \n20 \nwoman. conic to the house and give us massages \n21 \npassengers leaving the New York area. \n21 \ntogether. \n22 \nA. Uh-huh. \n22 \nThe idea that my wife would arrange for me \n23 \nQ. To fly to another destination three days \n23 \nto have a massage with an underage girl for sexual \n24 \nlater on December 14, correct? \n24 \npurposes is so bizarre and absurd as to defy any \n25 \nA. Yes. \n25 \nkind of credibility, but go on \n318 \n320 \n1 \nQ. And let's look at the next page of your \n1 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n2\nwife's diary for December 13, the period of lime \n2 \nQ. Yes. Thank you ver\n... [truncated, 3667 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/61 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=61]", "char_count": 3667}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 62, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n321 \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \nQ. I'm sorry, maybe it is January n, but \nsome time between the I Ith and 12th, either on the \nlint or on the 12th, it's Court TV, correct? \nA. No, no, no. You're just totally--\nQ. It's the 12th - \nA. -- wrong -- it's the 12th, yes. \nQ. Okay. Good. Thank you. \nA. Ifs clearly stated on the I?. yeah. \nQ. Okay. And then on Friday, the 19th, a \nweek later, another Court TV appearance, correct? \nA. 19th. Yes. \nQ. Okay. And on the 26th on Friday, \nanother Court TV appearance, correct? \nA. That's what it says, yes. These were \nall —\nQ. During this period of time —\nMR. SCOTT: Whoa. Let — let him finish \nhis answer. \nA. These are all scheduled appearances. I \nassume that I did thaw These -- these were — when \nthey requested me to \nto do them. I would do them, \nyes. \nBY MR SCAROLA: \nQ. Okay. And It looks like you're appearing \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n323 \nMR. SCOTT: Wait a minute. Let him get to \nit. \nA. 2 of the composite. Page 2, and what —\nwhat day arc we on? \nMR. SWEDER: Do we even have it? \nMR. SCOTT: I'm sorry. Excuse me. Do we \nhave copies of this exhibit? \nMR. SCAROLA: I've given you ccpies of \neverything --\nTHE WITNESS: Were these produced in \ndiscovery? \nMR. SCOTT: I assume. \nA. Okay. What am we up to? What page? \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \nQ. Page 2 of Composite Exhibit Number 10. \nMR. SCOTT: Okay. Now, stop. \nBY MR. SCAROLA: \nQ. Tuesday, the 16th. \nMR. SCOTT: What year arc we talking about \nnow? \nMR. SCAROLA: 2001, the only year covered \nin this composite exhibit. \nA. Yeah, dinner foreign policy Epstein, that \nwas dinner we had at Jeffrey Epstein's house with a \ngroup of very distinguished foreign policy experts, \n322 \n1 \non a scheduled basis every Friday during this period \n2 \nof time? \n3 \nA. I don't think that was right. Yeah, I \n4 \ndon't think that was right. I think that they \n5 \ncalled me when they\n... [truncated, 3968 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/62 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=62]", "char_count": 3968}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 63, "text_content": "325 \n327 \n1 \nA. Who's — \n1 \nA. Uh-huh. \n2 \nQ. — of Composite Exhibit 10. \n2 \nQ. Okay. Or from 3:30 to 4:15, that would be \n3 \nMR. SCOTT: Let me see the page you're \n3\na playing time for you in Cambridge; is that \n4 \ntalking about so he can — \n4\ncorrect? \n5 \nMR. SCAROLA: I've given you the entire \n5 \nA. You'd be asking me to speculate. I can't \n6 \ncalendar. \n6\nspeculate based on my wires calendar. It says \n7 \nMR. SCOTT: Come on. Jack. \n7\nutility bill, Reservoir address. That suggests \n8 \nMR. SCAROLA: I've given you the entire \n8\nCambridge. Reservoir is ow house in Cambridge. \n9 \ncomposite -- \n9 \nQ. So, it would appear that this is another \n10 \nTIE WITNESS: So you're talking about my \n10 \nmanage that you got somewhere? \n11 \nwires — \n11 \nA. Butt would like to also say one thing. I \n12 \nMR. SCAROLA: Fourth page — fourth page \n12 \ndaft --1 at least wonder were these records \n13 \nof Exhibit 10. You have Exhibit 10. rye given \n13\navailable to your clients at the time they made the \n14 \na copy of that. \n14 \nfalseaccusations against me or arc they \n15 \nMR. SCOTT: I understand it and he has it \n15\nafter-the-fact constructs designed to simply try to \n16 \nfront of him and rm trying to get him to the \n16\nfind excuses to justify their false allegations? It \n17 \nright page. Thank you. Please take it down. \n17\nscents to me the latter is probably the case. \n18\nBY MR. SCAROLA: \n18 \nQ. And you are going to have an opportunity \n19 \nQ. Fourth page, Composite Exhibit 10. \n19\nthrough your counsel to ask those questions. \n20 \nA. Yes. \n20 \nA. And we will. \n21 \nQ. Friday. January 12. \n21 \nQ. And my clients are anxious to be able to \n22 \nA. Okay. mars very simple. We were both \n22 \nanswer those questions. \n23\nin Cambridge and I had a massage in Cambridge. flow \n23\nA. Not as anxious as I am to hear their \n24 \ndo I know that? Because it had basketball. And \n24 \nanswers. \n25\nthat's where I play and watch basketball was in \n25 \nQ. Okay. \n326 \n328 \n1\nCambridge. So probably I was in Cambridge if it\n... [truncated, 3963 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/63 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=63]", "char_count": 3963}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 64, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \n329 \nMR. SCAROLA: I'm giving you notice as to \nwhat you can do to do your homework. Okay? \nThey directly conflict with the witness's \nassertion that the flight logs exonerate him. \nIn fact --\nMR. SCOTT: Wait a minute. \nMR. SCAROLA: -- the fli hi lo \nthe \nflight logs corroborat \nassertions. \nMR. SCOTT: And I thank you very much for \nthat explanation and we look forward to \nresuming this at the appropriate time and \nresponding to that. \nTHE WITNESS: And that is a false \nstatement. \nMR. SCOTT: Thank you. \nVIDEOGRAPHER: Going off the record. The \ntime is approximately 12:26 p.m. \n(The proceedings ADJOURNED at 12:26 p.m.) \n331 \nCERTIFICATE OF REPORTER \nSTATE OF FLORIDA \nCOUNTY OF BROWARD \nI, KIMBERLY FONTALVO, Registered \nProfessional Reporter, do hereby cern fy that I \nwas authorized to and did stenographically report \nthe foregoing videotape deposition of ALAN M. \nDERSIIOWITZ; pages through 145; that a review of \nthe transcript was requested; and that the \ntranscript is a true record of my stenographic \nnotes. \nI FURTHER CERTIFY that I am not a \nrelative. employee, attorney, or counsel of any \nof the parties, nor am la relative or employee \nof any of the parties' attorneys or counsel \nconnected with the action, nor am 1 financially \ninterested in the action. \nDated this 16th day of October, 2015. \nKIMBERLY FONTALVO, RPR, FPR. CLR \n330 \nCERTIFICATE OF OATH \nSTATE OF FLORIDA \nCOUNTY OF BROWARD \nI, the undersigned authority, certify \nthat ALAN M. DERSHOWITZ personally appeared \nbefore me and was duly sworn on the libliday of \nOctober. 2015. \nSigned this 16th clay of October, 2015. \nS \nKIMBERLY FONTALVO, RPR, FPR, CLR \nNotary Public, State of Florida \nMy Commission Na EE 161994 \nExpires: 2701/16 \nOctober 16.2015 \nCOLE. SCOTT& KISSANE. P.A. \nDorkland Centre11- Suite140o \n9150 South Dodeland Boulevard \nMiami. Florida 33156 \nBY: THOMAS EMERSON SCOTT. JR. ESQ. \nRe: Edwards v. Denhovitz \nPle\n... [truncated, 3036 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/64 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=64]", "char_count": 3036}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 65, "text_content": "333 \nERRATA SHEET \nDO NOT WRITE ON TRANSCRIPT- ENTER CHANGES HERE \nIn Re: EDWARDS V. DERSHOWITZ \nAIAN M. DERSHOWITZ \nOctober 16.2015 \nPAGE LINE \nCHANGE \nREASON \nUnder potables orpetjuty. It:Rehm Art I have \nread the feregomg doctarcnt and that the that \naxed m ii ac true. \nDate \nALAN M. DERSIIOWIT2 \n40 (Page 333) \nwww.phippsreporting.com \n(888)811-3408 \nEFTA01116758\n", "char_count": 369}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 66, "text_content": "Exhibit 3 \nEFTA01116759\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 67, "text_content": "3 \n) \n1 \nAPPEARANCES CONTINUED \n2 \nAlso on behalf of the Defendant: \n1 \nIN THE CROAT COURT OF IHE SEVENTEENTH \n2 \nJUIRWIFCUI7 IN MD FCR \nCOADY. FLORIDA \n3 \nSWEDER 8 ROSS, LIP \nBY: KENNETH A. SWEDER, ESQUIRE \n4 \n131 Oliver Street \n3 \nCASE /83. \nCARE 15.000072 \nBoston, 14•ssechusetts 02110 \n4 \n6 \nFax  \n617.646.4466 \nFax: \n617.646.4470 \n5 \nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS and PAIL G. Catcall, \n6 \nE-mall: ksweder•sweder•ross.com \n6 \n7 \nPlaintiffs/Counterclaim Defendants. \n7 \nOn behalf of the Witness: \nvs. \n8 \n8 \nUTAH ATTORNEY GENERAL'S OFFICE, P.A. \n8 \nBY: TONI ). TONES, ASSISTANT \n9 \nALAN N. DERSEICIAITZ. \nATTORNEY GENERAL, Litigation Division \n10 \n10 \n160 East 300 South \nDefendant/Counterclaim Plaintiff. \nHeber w ells Building • 6th Floor \n11 \nF \n11 \nSalt Lake City, Utah 84114 \n12 \nTel: \n801.366.0100 \n12 \nFax: \n801.366.0101 \n13 \nE•m all: JoniJoneS• utah.gov \n14 \nVICEOTAPED DEPOSITION CF \n13 \n15 \nPAUL G. MRCP I \n14 \nTelephonically on behalf of Jeffrey Epstein: \n18 \nTAMS CH BEHALF OF DE 0FFEIDOM \n16 \nDARREN K. !NOTICE, PLLC \nBY: DARREN K. INDYKE, ESQUIRE \n17 \nVOLU1E I \nPAGES 1 to 151. \n16 \n575 Lexington Avenue \n18 \n4th Floor \n17 \nNew York, New York 10022 \n19 \nTel: \n212.971.1314 \n20 \nFriday, October 16. 2015 \n18\n21 \n1:33 p.m. • 0:31 p.m. \n19 \nAlso Present: \n22 \n20 \nDON SAVOY, Videographer \n110 Southeast 6th Street\nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS \n23 \n110 Tower - Suite 1650 \nFort laUderdale, Florida 33301 \n21 \nALAN M. DERSHOWIT2 \n24 \nCAROLYN COHEN \n22 \n25 \nTheresa Tcmaselli, FM \n23 \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n24\n26 \n(954) 331-4400 \nESQUIRE DEPOSITOR SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331.4400 \n2 \n4 \n1 \nAPPEARANCES OF COUNSEL \n1 \nINDEX OF EXAMINATION \n2 \n2 \nWITNESS \nPAGE \nOn behalf of the Plaintiffs: \n3 \n3 \nPAUL G. CASSELL \nSEARCY DENNEY SCAROLA \n4 \nBARNHART & SHIPLEY, P.A. \nBY: JOHN SCAROLA, ESQUIRE \n4 \nDIRECT EXAMINATION \n6 \n6 \n2139 Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard \nBY MR. SIMPSON \nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33409 \n6 \n6 \nTel: \n561.686.6300 \nFax: \n561.383.9541 \n6 \n7 \nE-mail: m e eel searcylaw •COIn \nINDEX TO EXHIBITS \n7 \n... [truncated, 3435 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/67 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=67]", "char_count": 3435}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 68, "text_content": "61 \n63 \nof ins \n1 \nQ. \nI would like to know why you alleged \" and \n011235 \n1 \nwas your basis for this? \n01.1067 2 \nother minors \"  given what you have said about your \nei on \n2 \nA. \nAll right \nSo the Initial \nbasis for it \nvinyl \n3 \nknowledge of the factual basis, so to speak, for that \no1 :o00 3 was —\n01 nos 4 \nallegation. \nociwo 4 \nMR. SCAROLA: First of all, let me object \non no. 5 \nA. \nOkay. \nThere \nare going \nto be — I ' m \ngoing \nto \noi out \n5 \nbecause Professor Cassell is not here as an \no1 „a \n6 \nend up giving \nyou nine reasons, \neach of which \nis \n011304 6 \nexpert witness and hypotheticals \nare \noil' n 7 \ncomplicated, \nso I just \nwant \nto — if -- if - \nI don ' t \n01.1301 7 \ninappropriate. \nYou ' re calling for speculation on \n00 17 Is 8 \nwant \nto be accused \nof -- of fi libustering \nor anything. \nvi no. 8 \nhis part. \nI ' m not going to instruct him not to \noi 1113 \n9 \nI just \nwant \nyou to know \nthat \nyou have asked \na broad \n011310 9 \nanswer, but it is an Improper question. \n0111 IA 10 \nquestion \nthat\n' s going \nto require \na broad \nand extended \n011114 10 \nMR. SIMPSON: \nI disagree, but you can answer \n011120 11 \nanswer. \nIt — it -- \n010,4 11 \nthe question. \nonus 12 \nO. \nAnswer the question. \n01131.1 12 \nTHE WITNESS: \nRight. \nSo the -- the factual \n011,23 13 \nA. \nOkay. \nThen I ' m going \nto \nto a -- I have \nes 13 n 13 \nbasis would\n— we are setting aside \n011177 14 \na — well, actually, \nI don ' t \n011131 14 \nattorney/client \ncommunications, \nright? \n011121 15 \nQ. \nLet me ask you this: \nBefore you refer to \nunit \n15 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \n01.1130 16 \nsomething \n-- \n01 on 16 \nO. I'm asking: \nWhat would you tell the judge? \n*inn 17 \nA. \nYeah. \nu 42.1 17 \nA. \nRight \nSo that \n— I -- I -- that\n' s \n011130 18 \nQ. -- please give me your best recollection \nof \nel lin 18 \nspeculative \nto -- I don ' t think \nI can give a fair answer \n0,1134 19 \nwhat the basis was, the factual basis that you had in \noi 17 30 19 \nat this point \nbecause \nthat \nwould \nhave Involved \ngoing \n0 nu \n... [truncated, 5648 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/68 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=68]", "char_count": 5648}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 69, "text_content": "65 \n01 14:61 \n1 \nsupports that allegation. \n01 1446 \n2 \nA. \nOkay. The privileged information, obviously, \n01 1414 \n3 \nyou're asking me not to reveal at this point. \nassns 4 \nQ. I'm asking you -- I'm asking you to tell me \n01. 144 5 \nthe nonprivileged information. And I'm not agreeing \nel Wm \n6 \nwith your privilege assertion --\nwise( 7 \nA. \nSure. \n01:1507 \n8 \nQ. \nbut for purposes of this question - \n01:1107 9 \nA. \nFor purposes of this question. \n011407 10 \nQ. \n-- I'm accepting it. \nisw 11 \nA. \nAll right. \n01:1606 12 \nQ. \nPutbng aside what you claim is privileged, I \noi Imo 13 \nwant to know everything that's the factual basis for \nemir 14 \nincluding the allegation about other minors. \nMill. 15 \nA. \nOkay. Privileged information which I'm not \n0111 17 16 \ndisclosing in any way would have interacted with a vast \nensss 17 \nbody of other information. \nn 1622 18 \nThe vast body of other information would have \n01:1624 19 \nstarted with an 89-page police report from the Palm \nfaun 20 \nBeach Police Department that showed for about a \nnue 21 \nsix-month period in 2005, there was sexual abuse of \nm ism 22 \nminor girls going on on a daily basis, In — whenever \nstun 23 \nJeffrey Epstein was in his Palm Beach mansion. \n01:15.4. 24 \nAnd on some cases, it was going on not once, \n0115.6 25 \nnot twice, but three times during the day. That -- let \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-4400 \n67 \n01 16 52 \n1 \nbegan, you know, I guess what we would call \not ma \n2 \nknock-and-talks, knocking on doors to try to get to some \noiler 3 \nof these girls, and they would get to the girls, and \n16/11 4 \nmany of them initially were — were afraid to explain \not i, \n5 \nwhat had happened. \nel ore 6 \nBut as they — as they continued talking to \n011744 \n7 \nthem, the girls began to explain that what was happening \nnun 8 \nwas, they were going over to Epstein's house under the \nseas u 9 \nguise of giving a massage, and when they got there, the \non2u 10 \nmassage was, in fact, sexual activity. \n.11 11 \nAnd for many\n... [truncated, 5931 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/69 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=69]", "char_count": 5931}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 70, "text_content": "69 \n01 ten 1 \nother powerful persons. For example, Ghislaine Maxwell \nanis 2 \nis there with him on all of these flights and apparently \ne,112, \n3 \nbeing involved in the abuse. \n• nr.. 4 \nIndeed -- and so you -- you have — you \nes nn 5 \nhave that. You also start to see on the flight logs, \n01 no 6 \nwhat to my mind are some very sinister things, \n01 1104 \n7 \nsuggesting that the pattern is not just confined to sort \n011•10 8 \nof, you know, the girls that are there In Florida, but \nas an 9 It — it Is extending more broadly. \n011141 10 \nLike one of the — to my mind, sinister and \nna 11 scary things on the flight logs is, we see, you know, \nsine 12 \n,o we know has been sexually abused, \nin nu 13 \nand we see Jeffrey Epstein, and then we see on the \nsi nu 14 \nflight logs one female. \nnu 15 \nThat's kind of an odd notation for a flight \n.nn. 16 \nlog because, you know, typically, I understand the \nante 17 flight logs, the purpose is, well, if something happens \n012001 18 \nwith the flight, or there's some question about who was \nmans 19 on it, you want to know who -- who the person was who \nlone 20 \nwas on the flight. \n012000 21 \nSo, to my mind, when I started to see on \nsin to 22 \nthese flight logs entries like one female, I viewed that \n00016 23 \nas a potential device for obscuring the fact that there \nanon 24 \nwas interstate trafficking of underage girls for \n1112011 25 \npurposes of sexual activity. Serious federal offenses. \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331.4400 \n70 \n011022 \n1 \nBut then that evidence extended, you know, \n012020 \n2 \nmore broadly than that. The evidence also started to \n011021 3 \nshow, again, if we talk just abo \n011011 4 \nthe -- that underage girls such \nwere \ncosta \n5 \nbeing flown Internationally fro , \nrboro \n0120 01 \n6 in Now York to -- to locations, just to pick one, you \nan \n7 \nknow, for example, In London, where again sexual abuse \n01100S \n8 \nwas occurring. \nO1101/ \n9 \nAnd so you started to put together this \n012001 10 \npattern of criminality th\n... [truncated, 6001 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/70 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=70]", "char_count": 6001}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 71, "text_content": "012443 10 \n01240 11 \n012443 12 \n017444 13 \n0 24 14 14 \n°12411 15 \nelute 16 \n01 003 17 \n01.23 12 18 \nstun 19 \nin :sir 20 \n012422 21 \n*Its,. 22 \n012624 23 \n04426 32 24 \nma>. 25 \n012343 1 \n012144 2 \n012347 \n3 \n012247 4 \n01230 \n5 \n01 23 4/ 6 \n01230 7 \n017321 8 \ninns, 9 \n017361 10 \n0/7347 11 \n0/2112 12 \n01230 13 \n0/ 23 •-•. 14 \n072117 15 \n412110 16 \nol no, 17 \nolio) 18 \n012401 19 \n02240 20 \n024 0$ 21 \nOS 07 22 \n0,2407 23 \n0124 0 24 \n012403 25 \nwe would be happy to make It available to you. \nMR. SIMPSON: And -- and I'll give you an \nopportunity to look at that --\nTHE WITNESS: Sure --\nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nQ. \n-- but I'm entitled to ask first about your \nrecollection. \nA. \nQ. \nA. \nQ. \nA. \nQ. \nA. \n73 \nOkay. \nBased on your recollection — \nRight. \n-. I want to know all the evidence --\nRight \nyou were relying on here. \nSo what — what I'm going to do is, I'm going \nto make a list here on my -- on my notepad of all the \nthings, and then I'm going to compare that with notes I \nhave here. There may be a couple things that I don't \ncover. \nQ. \nAs long as your counsel is okay with that. \nA. \nYeah. \nQ. \nYou understand you'll have to give that to \nme7\nA. \nYeah. \ngive you the notes —\nQ. \nAll right. \nA. -- and then I will compare with what I've got \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331.4400 \n75 \noinu 1 Mr. Epstein saying that she had been trafficked, \n°inn 2 \nsexually trafficked, you know, not just abused by \n010 44 3 \nMr. Epstein, but now being forcibly sent to, you know, \n471 2446 4 \nother people to abuse. \n01 x43 5 \nAnd In the categories of people that were \n14 \n010157 6 \nsexually abusing her were academicians, and I knew that \n°Inas 7 \nMr. Dershowitz fell within that category of -- of being \ncram 8 \nan academician. The — that complaint also Indicated \n02304 9 \nthat there \nI \nflight logs that would show that \nono. 10\nd been sexually abused in these \netas* 11 \nAnd that started to indicate to me \n0127+o 12 \nthat there might be what the la \nmon \n0x10 13 \nscheme or plan. And that, just \nas\n... [truncated, 5374 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/71 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=71]", "char_count": 5374}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 72, "text_content": "77 \n79 \n012105 \n1 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \n012114? \n1 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Yeah. \nsi :ea 2 \nQ. Do you want the question back? \nMOO \n2 \nMR. SCAROLA: -- who keeps jumping up and \non* 3 \nA. No. I'm just trying to remember what I was \n012010 3 \ndown and distracting everybody in the room? \n012.12 4 thinking about with -- with regard to -- \n012•12 4 \nMS. McCAWLEY: And there was also profanity \n0211s \n5 \nMR. SCAROLA: Do you need the response read \n•,nu 5 \nused earlier. I mean, we just have to settle \nmnir 6 \nback up to the point -- \n•, no 6 \ndown on this side, and take a deep breath, and \n01211. 7 \nTHE WITNESS: Yeah, if you would do that, \na me 7 \nlet him answer his questions. \n012420 \n8 \nyeah. I just -- \nMaw 8 \nMR. SIMPSON: Look, I mean, the same thing \na74.20 9 \nMR. SCAROLA: -- about privilege arose. \nawn 9 \nwas happening on the other side. \n012130 10 \nTHE WITNESS: Yeah. Let's just see what that \n01300 10 \nMR. SCAROLA: No, sir. \nauto 11 \none -- \n013000 11 \nMS. McCAWLEY: There was no profanity on this \n042121 12 \nMR. SCAROLA: Just read the last couple of \now® 12 \nside of the table. \n012102 13 \nsentences back, or the last two sentences. \nmato 13 \nMR. SCAROLA: No, no, no. There was never \n012.31 14 \nTHE WITNESS: Oh, I'm sorry. Now I remember \na ea 14 \nanyone who jumped to their feet at any time \na NM 15 \nexactly what I was thinking. \na via 15 \nduring the course of the last two days. The only \n012132 16 \nHow would we go find out whether Mr. Epstein \na mg 16 \nperson who keeps jumping up is Alan Dershowitz. \n0.2/35 17 \ne.2/,. 18 \nwas lending women, or in this case, underage \ngirls, to Mr. Dershowitz for sexual purposes? \n013013 17 \n0130 SI 18 \nHave him pass you a note quietly, if you would, \nplease. \n0:2/41 19 \nWell, the first thing I want to do was ask -- you \n013011 19 \nMR. SIMPSON: I will disagree with your \n01214$ 20 \nknow, I'd -- I'd go ask Jeffrey Epstein. \ncilia. 20 \ncharacterization, but let me say the \n012147 21 \nAnd so what I discovered when I started to \n013020 21 \nargumentation\n... [truncated, 5173 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/72 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=72]", "char_count": 5173}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 73, "text_content": "0131 C0 \ni \non,“, \n2 \n013113 \n3 \na n • \n4 \n81 \nfocusing on the witness, but everybody on this \nside of the room has been distracted by his \nunprofessional conduct. \nMR. SIMPSON: I'm not going to argue with \nan» 1 \nm-an 2 \n017064 \n3 \n011317 4 \n83 \nreview, in which he took the Fifth when asked questions \nabout Dershowitz. \nSo, at that point, in trying to figure out, \nyou know, whether Mr. Dershowitz was involved in \nOt 3110 \n5 \nyou. And I -- \n013120 5 \nsexually abusing, not onl \nin \n03114 6 \nMR. SCAROLA: Thank you. \nOT Us \n6 other girls, then you go d \nI, next \n*nu, . \n7 \nMR. SIMPSON: -- I disagree with that \nOur 7 \nlayer of the criminal conspiracy. \n013120 \n8 \ncharacterization. There is another attorney \nfin \n8 \nEpstein is at the top, so you go to the next \nCI 3172 \n9 \nsitting between us. We will pass notes. \na a» 9 \nlayer. These are, you know, basically the -- the women \nail» 10 \nMR. SCAROLA: Thank you. \na »13 10 \nwho, from what I could gather, were — were older than \nOt111. 11 \nMR. SIMPSON: And we -- and I believe, \na a* 11 the ago that Epstein wanted to sexually abuse. I think \n.313170 12 \nMs. McCawley, were you instructing not to answer \na a 0 12 \nthese were 22 and 23-year-old girls, so they had, you \n013130 13 \nor what was happening? What did you -- what were \nol um 13 \nknow, essentially aged out of being his sexual abuse \n01.31 34 14 \nyou raising? \na no 14 \nvictims, but they continued to — what they would do is \nOt 3134 15 \nMS. McCAWLEY: No. There was a lot of \nens 15 \ncollect girls for him under the age of 18, that I guess \n*tales 16 \nyelling going on here, so I was trying to make \n013333 16 \nwas in his target range. \n03137 17 \nsure that everybody was quiet -- \nareas 17 \nAnd so what — so the next person I \n18 \nMR. SIMPSON: All right. \na am 18 \nnwn \nt information from wa \n19 \n20 \nMS. McCAWLEY: -- so that the client could \nanswer. \noi mo. 19 \n01 Mel 20 \non a lot of these flight logs \n„ \nirls that -- or women and with \n21 \nMR. SIMPSON: All right. Let me back up. \n... [truncated, 5420 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/73 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=73]", "char_count": 5420}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 74, "text_content": "85 \n013679 \n1 \nwhat I'll refer to as the blank-check immunity \n01.3533 2 \nprovision. \n013014 \n3 \nThere was a provision In the nonprosecution \n0155 40 4 \nagreement that said, this agreement will prevent federal \n01.3510 5 \nprosecution for international and interstate sex \nor 45 43 6 \ntrafficking, not only of Jeffrey Epstein, and not only \nsinus 7 \nof the four women who were identified, but — and this \nmans 8 \nis a direct quote: Any other potential co-conspirator, \n01)553 9 \nclose quote. \nm. ass 10 \nAnd so that was unusual because what It — \nor so 11 \nwhat it seemed to be doing was that somehow this \n01.n14 12 \nagreement was quite out of the normal and had been \n013100 13 \ndesigned to extend immunity to other people that might \nen au 14 \nhave been associated with Epstein. \nsines 15 \nAnd I knew that that category included the \n014303 16 \npeople that were involved in negotiating this highly \n011x11 17 \nunusual provision included Mr. Dershowitz, who had been \n0'3414 18 \nheavily involved, not only in the drafting of the \nova sr 19 \nagreement, but had also been involved remarkably In \noram 20 \nattacking the credibility of these girls and saying \nnix 21 \nthings like, you know, it was — Epstein wasn't \nOt3120 22 \ntargeting minor girls, which just struck -- you know, I \n033433 23 \nwas -- I don't want to use a technical term, \n413035 24 \ngob-smocked, that a defense attorney with an obligation \nsus y 25 \nto tell the truth was making a factual representation \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954)331.4400 \n01'37 40 \n1 \n044/44 2 \n01.37.47 3 \n• 37s1 4 \n013755 \n013714 6 \n013741 7 \nneo 8 \nO13403 9 \n013401 10 \notsan 11 \nelan 12 \n0141115 13 \nelan 14 \nsoils 15 \n011430 16 \nman 17 \nO1.31141 18 \nova* 19 \nelan 20 \no,,. 21 \n014137 22 \noleo 23 \n01100 24 \n013041 25 \n87 \nthat are said there, but Alessi puts Mr. Dershowitz at \nthe nest of this international sex trafficking \norganization. Let's see. I think he said four or five \ntimes a year, two or three -- you know, two or three \ndays when he goe\n... [truncated, 6089 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/74 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=74]", "char_count": 6089}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 75, "text_content": "014121 2 \n034121 3 \n01,133 4 \n014134 \n5 \n014136 \n6 \n014130 \n7 \n01410 \n8 \n014145 \n9 \n014140 10 \n89 \n01.430S \n1 \naccording to a \nton later FBI report, Alessi \n014301 2 \nidentified information that was pertinent to the FBI's \n014007 \n3 \ninvestigation. \n014011 4 \nAnd so when I look at the little black book \n014014 \n5 \nthat I have seen copies of, there are a handful of names \no,40 \n6 \nin that black book that have been circled, apparently by \nono,: 7 \nMr. Rodriguez, and one of the names that's -- that has \n014025 \n8 \nbeen circled is Alan Dershowitz. And so that, to me, \n014030 \n9 \nwas suggesting that Mr. Rodriguez had identified, you \n01 4036 10 \nknow, Alan DershowItz as somebody who had information \nnon 11 about this \nthis international sex trafficking ring. \nera 12 \nBut just as a side note, but an important \neto 13 \nnote, when the -- the thing that was circled on the Alan \n014466 14 \nDershowitz page was not a single phone number \ne, 400 15 \nIndicating, you know, somebody had bumped -- you know, \ncoos, 16 \nEpstein had bumped into at one point. I believe there \n0140 36 17 \nwere 10 or 11 phone numbers that were associated with \nu 18 \nMr. Dershowitz that had all been circled and an e-mail \n014100 19 \naddress as well. \nDI 41174 20 \nSo that started to corroborate my sense that \n0, no: 21 \nMr. Dershowits was, indeed, a very close friend of \n0141'0 22 \nJeffrey Epstein. Now, I had then continued to do \n014114 23 \nthere's been reference today to, you know, using Google \noin ol 24 \nto do research and so forth. So I Googled Jeffrey \notn,o 25 \nEpstein and one of the things that pops up rather \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 381-4400 \n91 \n014232 \n1 \na lot of money. I mean, Epstein was identified as a \n01 402 2 \nbillionaire in this article, billionaire with -- with a \nin on 3 \n8, so the record is clear. \n014234 4 \nBut he said, look, if Epstein lost all his \nOleo 5 \nmoney -- I'm paraphrasing here -- I would be, you know, \nel coo 6 \nhappy to walk down, you know, the Coney Island Bo\n... [truncated, 6232 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/75 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=75]", "char_count": 6232}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 76, "text_content": "93 \n01404 \n1 \nfor the production had been carefully crafted to keep \nII 440 \n2 him out of it; in other words, to not produce the \n0,4411 3 \nOctober 2005 version. \n014603 4 \nThe other thing I - I began to discover as I \noi.ssos \n5 \nstarted going through some flight logs, Dave Rogers, who \n014103 \n6 \nis one of I think about three pilots that — that \n01010 7 \nEpstein regularly relied on to fly his — you know, he \n010 0 \n8 \nhad very fancy — to use the technical term -- Jets. \n...sir 9 \nThere were about -- there were about three pilots there. \n.).42, 10 \nOne of them had some flight logs and that — \nco 4324 11 that was Pilot Dave Rogers, if I'm recalling his name \nMen 12 \ncorrectly. And so later on in the litigation, the sex \noven 13 \nabuse litigation against Epstein, flight logs were \n°Ina. 14 \nobtained from Dave Rogers, and it was possible to -- to \nO1450 15 \ncompare \nI'm sorry. I don't mean to — I want to make \n01040 16 \nsure I get -- you know, the question is: How much can I \n01 40 17 \nremember and I'm trying to make sure I get — get it all \nIn. \n01410 18 \nCO 4145 19 \n04144 20 \nAnd so the flight logs were produced from \nDave Rogers. And so Dave Rogers produced some flight \nonssi 21 \nlogs, and some of the flights that he produced logs for \nDI \n64 22 \ncoincided with the logs that Mr. Dershowitz had provided \nm.sso 23 \nto the Palm Beach Police Department, and there were \nol.rol 24 \ninconsistencies. And so that, again, aroused my \n04.0 25 \nsuspicion that maybe Mr. Dershowitz when he had — \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-4400 \n014633 \n1 \n0100 \n2 \n01413/ \n3 \n014643 4 \n0100 \n5 \n01014 6 \n01044 7 \n014646 \n8 \n01060 9 \n014152 10 \noven 11 \n0, 46 1,  12 \nenv 13 \nnen 14 \n01006 15 \n0044 16 \n04701 17 \n0,47,1 18 \n014714 19 \n0100 20 \nO. OD 21 \n014724 22 \n04721 23 \n014724 24 \n04732 25 \n95 \nTHE WITNESS: Right. No, I mean, I want to \nmake -- I want to make clear that there was a lot \nof information that I was relying on in filing \nthis pleading, and -- and, of course, the later \n\n... [truncated, 5460 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/76 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=76]", "char_count": 5460}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 77, "text_content": "97 \n99 \nelms, \n1 \nAnother thing that I had, and I will not \n010116  1 going Into any confidential communications or \nGin 2 reveal any privileged communications here or any \nonion 2 trying to waive in any way, I knew that David \n011.1. 3 confidential information, but on December 30th, I \n01 531,1 3 Boles had agreed to repres-\nihai. 4 was aware that one of the preeminent lawyers in \noiwn 4 which gave me additional confidence in the fact \n014007 5 the Unites, \nhad agreed to \n015030 5 that I was also representing this young woman in \n014410/ \n6 represen \nnd given the vast \nci,om 6 her effort to bring sex traffickers to Justice, \n01011 7 amount of business that -- that, you know, tries \n015037 7 and those who had sexually abused her to justice. \n01411 8 to get in the door -- \n01 tO 41 8 \nAnd so those are things that come to mind \nmais 9 \nMR. SIMPSON: Could I interrupt? I mean, I \n.,w. 9 immediately as -- let me just take a second and \nmoo 10 think we are going towards a waiver here. \noin 10 see if there were other things regarding \n0,.01. 11 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Yeah. No, no, no, I do not -- \n015010 11 Dershowltz that -- that come Immediately \" \n01.4020 12 \nMR. SIMPSON: We can't have testimony \n41 3141 12 immediately to mind. \n014911 13 about -- \nel sun 13 \nOh, one of the things was in the Jane Doe 102 \n014021 14 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Yeah. \n0.310, 14 complaint, which alleged academicians that had --\n014022 15 \nMR. SIMPSON: -- this is one of the most \n01”14 15 that had abused -- sexually abused Jane Doe 3, \n01011 16 \nrespected people in the country, or lawyers In \n013110 16 there -- there were -- so that raises a question, \n014931 17 the country, and then you won't answer the \nelm. 17 obviously, of who were the academicians that Bob \n01.4020 18 questions -- \n015130 18 Josefsberg had Identified? \n014024 19 \nTHE WITNESS: Okay. \n401111 19 \nI can't recall, actually. Let me -- the \n01024 20 \nMR. SIMPSON: -- you said not to answer. \n01 6113 20 record should be dear, I can't recall \nm 492, \n... [truncated, 5420 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/77 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=77]", "char_count": 5420}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 78, "text_content": "015731 \n015214 \n015154 \nSluts \n015303 \n01002 \n013101 \n05 007 \n015303 \n03011 10 \n015113 11 \n0101$ 12 \nstun 13 \netsni 14 \n013372 15 \n01014 16 \n011331 17 \nmasa 18 \num 33 19 \n011130 20 \nciao 21 \n02010 22 \n020103 23 \neons 24 \nware 25 \n101 \n1 \nidentified Alan Dershowitz as someone who had \n2 \ninformation relevant -- and let's be dear, that \n3 \nthis is not a lawsuit about some contract dispute \n4 \nor something -- that he was someone who had \n5 \ninformation relevant to the sexual abuse of \n6 \nunderage girls and, indeed, they were asking \n7 \nquestions about what Information -- what \n8 \ninformation he might have. \n9 \nAnother -- I know, I remember now, there's a \nwhole other line of things that -- that I had in \nmind at the time, and I think since you want to \ntest my memory -- I'm not -- let me be dear. \nI'm not claiming I have a superb memory. I have \nan average memory, but this is a subject that's \nvery important to me, and so I've worked, you \nknow, very hard to get all the information. \nI would like to take a break. \nMR. SCAROLA: Sure. Take a break. \nTHE VIDEOGRAPHER: We are going off the video \nrecord, 3:27 p.m. \n(Thereupon, a recess was taken.) \nTHE VIDEOGRAPHER: We are back on the video \nrecord, 3:41 p.m. \nTHE WITNESS: I want to continue my answer. \nI'm sorry. I got emotional there for a moment. \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-4400 \n02-23 \n02525 \n03 Of \n020112. \n02000 \n02002 \n02034 \n020114 \n03001 \n030341 10 \n0040 11 \nmot« 12 \n020140 13 \nanew 14 \nwar. 15 \ncows: 16 \narm. 17 \n*flora 18 \nciarci 19 \n021407 20 \n0\n,011 21 \nann. 22 \n°nag 23 \n071031 24 \n21021 25 \n103 \nlet me clear all of that misunderstanding up. \n2 \nYou know, that's -- frankly, if I had gotten \n3 \nsomething like that, that's what I would have \n4 \nsaid. \n5 \nThe answer that came back was -- from \n6 \nMr. Dershowitz was something along the lines of, \n7 \nIf I remember correctly, well, tell me what \n8 \nyou -- you -- tell me what you want to know and \n9 \nI'll decide whether to cooperate, was I think \nthe phr\n... [truncated, 5559 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/78 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=78]", "char_count": 5559}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 79, "text_content": "105 \n107 \nstns. 1 \neverything. \n02 034 2 \nMR. SIMPSON: I'm -- I think I get to ask the \nawn 3 \nquestions, but I was going to ask the same \nnom 4 \nquestion. \n02 Ill. 5 \nMR. SCAROLA: Wonderful. We are on the same \nono 6 \npage. \nco no 7 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \na nn 8 \nQ. \nMr. Cassell, you -- you mentioned that you \nan:„ 9 \nhad something that you had prepared --\na,... 10 \nA. \nYes. \na,... 11 \nQ. \n-- that would summarize \n02016 12 \nA. Right \n011140 13 \nQ. \n-- your knowledge. \notitis 14 \nA. \nRight. \nsin.. 15 \nQ. \nAnd now that you have exhausted your \n02 \nSI 16 \nrecollection, could you produce that and let's Just mark \n02 I'S. 17 It .-\n02014 18 \nA. \nYeah, sure. \nono 19 \nQ. \n-- as an exhibit? \n02 030 20 \nMR. SIMPSON: We are up to Exhibit 3, I \n021110 21 \nbelieve. Cassell 3. \nozi?oi 22 \nTHE WITNESS: Right. Now, there -- there are \nolio 23 \ntwo parts to this --\nono 24 \nMR. SIMPSON: Can we mark it first and \nroom 25 \nthen --\nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954)3314400 \n106 \nmoot 1 \nTHE WITNESS: Yeah. I just want the record \nnum 2 \nto be clear, that I'm only looking — there's \n02 n .1 3 \nthere's a pre-December 30th section and a \naz u,o 4 \npost-December 30th section, so the top part is \n02 013 5 \nthe -- Is what I was working off of. \nmoll 6 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nnee 7 \nQ. \nOkay. \n02 $713 8 \nA. \nNow, underneath this is — you know, If you \novine 9 \nhave questions about what happened after December 30th. \nOZ 120 10 \nQ. \nSo you're -- you're prepared to produce the \n0212n 11 \nentire document, but you're clanfying? I don't -- I \noz an 12 \ndon't want to ask you -- If you're going to use it in \nnot 13 \nyour testimony, then we will mark the whole thing. \n02 02) 14 \nMR. SCAROLA: Mark the whole thing. You can \ncan 15 \nuse it. \nono 16 \nMR. SIMPSON: Mark the whole thing and I'll \nnun 17 \nask you about it. \n02030 18 \nTHE WITNESS: That would be great. \nO2O3119 \nAbsolutely. \nnon 20 \nMR. SIMPSON: All right. I'm Jag to ask \nCa )2 3S 21 \nthe court reporter to mark as Cassell Exhibit 3, \nen 22 \na one-page doc\n... [truncated, 4761 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/79 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=79]", "char_count": 4761}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 80, "text_content": "109 \n111 \neon>, \n1 \npeople who would have relevant information in the civil \nrunes 1 \nstrategy to sort of stall the investigation to say: \na 15 n \n2 \ncases, but when asked in deposition about \n021003 \n2 \nWell, we will get you Epstein; oh, we can't meet now; \na IS 29 \n3 \nMr. Dershowitz, he took the Fifth. \nonset \n3 \noh, we will get it now -- and then — and so forth. \non \n4 \nso I — I found it significant that for some \nnum 4 \nAnd one of the things that I noted from all \n011533 \n5 \na it 35 \n6 \npeople, he was willing to answer questions, but with \nregard to Mr. Dershowitz, he took his — he Invoked his \nes mos 5 \nonto \n6 \nthat was that Mr. Dershowitz, as Mr. Epstein's attorney, \nnever ultimately produced Epstein for a meeting with the \non>, 7 \nFifth Amendment right against compelled \n02%14 \n7 \nPalm Beach Police Department, having made another offer. \nono 8 \nself-incrimination presumably because revealing what he \n02 WU 8 \nNow, obviously, something could have happened \no ,s4. 9 \nknew about Mr. Dershowitz would, you know, cause \n02 *le \n9 \nthere. I mean, I don't -- you know, I don't know what \na: is.. 10 \ncriminal -- criminal charges potentially to be filed \na an 10 \nwas the communications and so forth, but as an attorney \natisst 11 against him. \nawes 11 \ntrying to get information and unable to do that, I had \nnisi, 12 \nThere was a common scheme or plan, and I'll \nawn 12 \nto make some reasonable inferences. \n72 ,000 13 \nelaborate on that in a moment, but yeah, one of — so \nRan 13 \nAnd so one of the Inferences ! began to draw \now,. 14 \nthis was another point. I mentioned that — that there \nawn 14 \nwas that this was a stall tactic by Mr. Dershowitz, and \nant u 15 \nhad been three efforts to get information from \nass. 15 \nIn my view, potentially, an unethical one, but I \nantis \n16 \nMr. Dershowitz by way of a 2009 deposition request, a \nasp 16 \ndon't — I don't think we need to get into that in this \n02 is 2> 17 \n2011 deposition request, and further follow-up \na is* 17 \nlitigati\n... [truncated, 6288 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/80 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=80]", "char_count": 6288}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 81, "text_content": "113 \n115 \n0220 lk \n1 \nJeffrey Epstein where -- where this seemed to be going \nto \n1 \nwhat his excuse was, but, you know, evaded the \nono 2 \non and was very dose to Epstein, staying at the mansion \n022231 2 \ndeposition and, in fact, later information came to light \n022222 \n3 \nfrequently. \ne2713 3 \nhe was hiding out in, you know, in the mansion of \nonn 4 \nAnd so she would, obviously, be -- I guess if \non,, \n4 \nEpstein while he's claiming he's unavailable for -- for \nonn 5 \nnoon 6 \nyou have Epstein at the -- the top of the — you know, \nthe kingpin of the operation, Maxwell would be, you \ncan* 5 \n022230 \n6 \ndeposition. \nSo -- so this pattern of Mr. Dershowitz, you \n0220 )0 7 \nknow, a close second or certainly at, you know, the \nnag 7 \nknow, where there were three attempts to obtain \n0220 32 8 \nhigher echelon. \n022144 8 \nInformation from him, if that's all I had, I guess that \n0720)3 9 \nSo, obviously, someone who would have, you \nsane 9 \nwould have been one thing. But what I had was a pattern \nCI 20 35 10 \nknow, very significant information about, you know, the \non« 10 \nof people who were implicated in this sex trafficking \n0>MM 11 \nsex trafficking, who were the other people that the — \nono 11 ring evading questions, you know, quite in violation of \n027011 12 \nthe girls were being trafficked to, what kind of abuse \n012247 12 \ncourt orders and depositions and things — I shouldn't \n071074 13 \nwas going on, you know, what kinds of sex toys were \n022254 13 \nsay court order — in violation of the deposition \n027044 14 \non.. 15 \nbeing used to abuse them, because I think It was in her \nroom or -- or adjacent to her room that many of these — \nomol 14 \nrano 15 \nnotices that were being sent and agreements being made, \nyou know, through counsel. \n07:047 16 \nthese devices were located, and so she would have had \nonaos 16 \nAnd then in addition to that, I had this, so \non,: 17 \nvery significant information to provide. \nran is 17 \nwhy — why would you think that, you know, there's this \n\n... [truncated, 5999 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/81 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=81]", "char_count": 5999}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 82, "text_content": "117 \n119 \nfano \n1 \nknow, law enforcement agencies in those countries, you \nrams 1 \nMr. Dershowitz was trying to do the same \nan... 2 \nknow, in England, or law enforcement agencies In this \n02200 2 \nthing and it is a difficult situation. \ncane 3 \ncanal 4 \ncountry, through -- through power that, you know, \nsomebody at that level, fifth I think In line to the \nonus 3 \nens sr 4 \nA. \nAll right. \nQ. \nSo I was not trying to make light of the \nnn IS \n5 British Throne, would have, you know, presumably access \ncame 5 \nquestions I'm asking you. \nGana 6 \nto levers of power that other people might not — might \nnum 6 \nA. Right. This Involves sexual abuse — \nnil \n7 not have. \nrano 7 \nQ. \nI understand that. \n022171 8 \nAnd so that Is the -- I believe is the -- the \nnum 8 \nA. -- of multiple girls. \nrarrrt 9 \ninformation that I h d oval ab e o me on December 30th \nrant* 9 \nO. \nI understand that. Your -- I understand the \nran= 10 \ninvolving not just \nt the entire sex \n022704 10 \nallegations that have been made.\n40 22 Ds 11 trafficking organl \n. \n02206 11 \nA. \nAnd your side keeps attacking these girls. \nen 4, 12 \nQ. \nOkay. And that -- just to clarify again, it \n012700 12 \nThat's why It's emotional for me. \n022142 13 \nexhausts your refreshed recollection as to both the \n02022 13 \nQ. \nThat -- that part is not true, but I will ask \n02230 14 \ninformation you were relying on as to the allegations \nrano 14 \nquestions --\nan 48 15 \nabout \nto the allegations about \n02113 15 \nA. \nI believe that part Is true. \nany 16 \nother minors; is that right? \n0070 16 \nTHE WITNESS: I would like to take a break. \n*mu 17 \nA. \nCorrect. \ncan is 17 \nI'm sorry. \nonss) 18 \nQ. \nSo I don't have to ask you separately about \n0277 If 18 \nTHE VIDEOGRAPHER: We are going off the video \n02206 19 \nRoberts? \n02201 19 \nrecord, 4:01 p.m. \nerns 20 \nA. \nThat's right No, and I gave you a heads-up, \nnmin 20 \n(Thereupon, a recess was taken.) \n00426 21 that was going to be a long answer. \n01041 21 \nTHE VIDEOGRAPHER: We are back on the \n... [truncated, 4895 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/82 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=82]", "char_count": 4895}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 83, "text_content": "Exhibit 4 \nEFTA01116776\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 84, "text_content": "154 \nIS? \n1 \nAPPEARANCES CONTINUED \n1 \nIN 111E CIRCUIT COURT OF TIE SEVENTEEV7H \n2 \nJUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN ttie FOR \nTelephonically on behalf of Jeffrey Epstein: \n2 \nMUSD COUNTY. FLORIDA \n3 \n3 \nCASE NO. \nCACE 15.000072 \nDARREN K. IN DYKE, PLLC \n4 \n4 \nBY: DARREN K. INDYKE, ESQUIRE \n5 \nEIRICLEY J. WORDS and PALL G. CASSELL. \n575 Lexington Avenue \n6 \n6 \n4th Floor \nPlaintiffs/Counterclaim DefendentS. \nNew York, New York 10022 \n7 \nvs. \n6 \nTel: \n212.971.1314 \n8 \n9 \nAM M. OERSHCWIT2. \n7 \n10 \nAlso Present: \nDefendant/Counterclaim Plaintiff. \ns \n11 \nDON SAVOY, videographer \n12 \n9 \nBRADLEY J. ED WARDS \n13 \nALAN M. DE RSHOw IT2 (Telephonically) \n14 \nVIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF \n10 \n15 \nPAUL G. CASSEU_ \n11 \n16 \nTAKEN ON REHM, OF THE DUBOW' \n12 \n17 \nVOI IRE II \nRYES 152 to 1,15 \n13 \n18 \n14 \n16 \n19 \n16 \n20 \nSaturday. October 17. 2015 \n17 \n21 \n8:32 0.m. - 12:14 p.a. \n18 \n22 \n19 \n425 North Andreae Avenue \n20 \n23 \nSuite..2 \nFort Lauderdale, FICr1C18 \n33301 \n21 \n24 \n22 \n25 \nTheresa Remelt S. SR \n23 \n24 \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n26 \n(954) 331-4400 \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-4400 \n153 \n155 \n1 \nAPPEARANCES OF COUNSEL \n1 \nINDEX OF EXAMINATION \n2 \n2 \nWITNESS \nPAGE \nOn behalf of the Plaintiffs: \n3 \nSEARCY DENNEY SCAROLA \n3 \nPAUL G. CASSELL \n4 \nBARNHART & SHIPLEY, P.A. \nBY: JOHN SCAROLA, ESQUIRE \n4 \nCONTINUED DIRECT EXAMINATION \n160 \n2139 Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard \nBY MR. SIN PSON \nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33409 \n6 \n6 \nTel: \n561.686.6300 \n7 \nFax: \n561.383.9541 \ne-mail: meo•seartylaw.com \n6 \nINDEX TO EXHIBITS \n7 \nOn behalf of \nEXHIBIT \nDESCRIPTION \nPAGE \n9 \nBONES SCHILLER a FLEXN ER, LIP \n10 \nBY: SIGRID STONE McCAWLEY, ESQUIRE \n9 \n401 East Las Olas Boulevard \nCassell's J.D. Exhibit No. 4 - document 203 \n11 \nSuite 1200 \n10 \nproduced by the witness \nFort Lauderdale, Florida 33301 \n12 \nTel: \n954.356.0011 \nFax: \n954.356.0022 \n11 \nCassell's 1.0. exhibit No. S - copy of \n229 \naddress book \n13 \nsmccawley.bsfIlp.com \n12 \n14 \nCassell's 1.0. Exhibit No. 6 - series of \n309 \nOn behalf of t\n... [truncated, 2857 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/84 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=84]", "char_count": 2857}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 85, "text_content": "1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \ncoccci \n5 \n030003 6 \ncoo e? 7 \ncomic 8 \n000011 9 \ncomic 10 \nCO 00 10 11 \n0003 111 12 \n00 03 20 13 \nCOM 23 14 \n030024 15 \n000024 16 \n000027 17 \n°cool, 18 \nCO C030 19 \n03 CO 31 20 \nrams 21 \nrams 22 \n030044 23 \n156 \nDEPOSITION OF PAUL G. CASSELL \nSaturday, October 17, 2015 \nTHE VIDEOGRAPHER: We are now on the video \nrecord. Today is Saturday, the 17th day of \nOctober, 2015. The time is 8:32 a.m. We are \nhere at 425 North Andrews Avenue, Fort \nLauderdale, Florida, for the purpose of taking \nthe videotaped deposition of Paul G. Cassell. \nThe case is Bradley J. Edwards and Paul \nG. Cassell versus Alan M. Dershowitz. \nThe court reporter is Terry Tomaselli, and \nthe videographer is Don Savoy, both from Esquire \nDeposition Solutions. \nWill counsel please announce their \nappearances for the record. \nMR. SCAROLA: Jack Scarola on behalf of the \nPlaintiffs. \nMR. SIMPSON: Richard Simpson of Wiley Rein \non behalf of the Defendant and Counterclaim \nPlaintiff, Alan Dershowitz. With me is my \ncolleague, Nicole Richardson, and Thomas Scott of \nCole, Scott & Klssane, also for Mr. -- Professor \ncon 24 Dershowitz. \ncocci* 25 \nMR. SCAROLA: Before we begin the deposition, \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-4400 \n157 \nCOCOS, \n1 \nwe were informed for the first time yesterday \nwon 2 morning of the existence of a recording of a \ncoccoi \n3 telephone communication between Alan Dershowitz \n010106 4 and a woman identified only as Rebecca. \ncool 10 \n5 \nThat Information was conveyed to us \n030413 6 subsequent to Professor Dershowitz's sworn \n000.44 7 \ntestimony that no recording existed, but now that \n0001.30 8 we know that the recording existed and that it \n030123 9 \nwas obviously made according to the \n0430123 10 representations given to us, prior to the \n0201x, 11 completion of the responses to our earlier \n01013, 12 \ndiscovery requests, I would like to know whether \n0301 34 13 it is the Defendant's position that It is \ncon 14 \nnecessary for us to propound a new discovery \ncool \n... [truncated, 5321 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/85 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=85]", "char_count": 5321}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 86, "text_content": "000012 \n2 \n000434 \n3 \n000430 \n4 \n0004 21 \n5 \n000442 \n6 \nMan 7 \n040447 \n8 \n000447 \n9 \nmao 10 \n00 0.41 11 \nCOMO 12 \nsis 13 \n034600 14 \nmama 15 \ntenet 16 \ncmitos 17 \ntents 18 \n00x11 19 \nD346 I/ 20 \ngic es I. 21 \n0004 24 22 \n63.:11) 23 \nCO Of 21 24 \n000120 25 \n6 \n7 \n000404 \n8 \nloom 9 \n000101 10 \nwow) 11 \n00040. 12 \nwag 13 \nCO 04 10 14 \n000a 14 15 \nMaw 16 \n0004 th 17 \nMaul 18 \n020420 19 \n000421 20 \n160 \nThereupon, \n2 \nPAUL G. CASSELL, \n3 \nhaving been first duly sworn, was examined and testified \n4 \nas follows: \n5 \nTHE WITNESS: 1 do. \nCONTINUED DIRECT EXAMINATION \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nQ. \nGood morning - \nA. \nGood morning. \nQ. \n-- Mr. Cassell. \nAs of December 30th, 2014, had you ever met \nwith \nen? \nQ. \nperson? \nA. \nOnce. \nQ. \nWhen was that? \nA. \nApproximately May 2014. \nQ. \nMay of 2014? \nA. \nYes. \n100422 21 \nQ. \nWho was present for that meeting? \nMaio 22 \nA. I'm just pausing for a second because \ndon't — I think we're - \nQ. \nI -- I'm not --\nA. \n- clearly not trying to get into \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331.4400 \n020420 23 \n010414 24 \n000410 25 \nAnd how many times had you met with her in \n162 \n000026 \n1 \nQ. \nAnd when you say 'all day,\" what time period \n00063, \n2 \nare you referring to? \nCO sr \n3 \nA. \n9:00 to 5:00. \n010533 4 \nQ. \n9:00 to 5:00. Okay. Md was that through \nwan 5 \nlunch; you Just stayed through eight hours; is that -• \nwon 6 \nwhat's your recollection of that? \n0303 41 7 \nA. \nYeah, I remember we were working very hard \nwan 8 on -- on it, so I think we had, if I recall correctly, \nman 9 \nhad lunch brought in and worked straight through that. \n0004 44 10 \nQ. \nAny other meetings in person with \nrem 11 \nMiss Roberts before December 30th of 2014? \nCOMP 12 \nA. \nNo. \ncater 13 \nQ. My telephone calls with her that you -- you \n030103 14 \nhad, obviously, before December 30th, 2014? \nD20007 15 \nA. \nI believe there were a couple of — of \n0204 (4) 16 \ntelephone calls. \nwow 17 \nQ. \nAnd can you tell us when those were? \nC00412 18 \nA. \nLet's see. Roughly September 2014. G\n... [truncated, 4788 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/86 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=86]", "char_count": 4788}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 87, "text_content": "0007211 \n010132 \n900722 \n000730 \nCOON \n030742 \n0007 .14 \n100718 \n000749 \n020753 10 \nwont 11 \ncows) 12 \nworse 13 \n0207$4 14 \nNom 15 \nruin 16 \ncome 17 \nmot ic 18 \nDoan 19 \n020014 20 \n020210 21 \nC00971 22 \n9009 29 23 \n000829 24 \n000029 25 \n164 \n1 \nalso going to follow Miss McCawley's instructions \n2 \non not answering on behalf of --\n3 \nMR. S \nollow the \n4 \ninstructions \nsel. It is \n5 \nnot his privi \nethically \n6 \nobliged to respect the direction coming from \n7 \n8 \n9 \nI'm -- I'm simply, \nMr. Scarola, making my record that the witness --\nMR. SCAROLA: I understand that. \nMR. SIMPSON: Right. We disagree. \nMR. SCAROLA: I understand, but you can \nassume the same way I have authorized you to \nassume that Professor Cassell will follow my \ninstructions, Professor Cassell will also follow \nall instructions concerning the assertion of \nattorney/client privilege exp \nby Miss McCawley on behalf \nMR. SIMPSON: All right. \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nQ. So, Mr. Cassell, based on that, I will assume \nthat If I ask you what you recall the discussion being \nat the meeting or at each of the phone calls, that \nyou're not going to answer those questions; is that \ncorrect? \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-4400 \n020904 1 \n02040* 2 \nmull 3 \nC001112 4 \n000415 5 \n030015 6 \nyews 7 \n0001113 8 \n000923 9 \neiveou 10 \n0, 09 a 11 \nCONN 12 \nay.. 13 \nwoe° 14 \ncon 15 \nmeta 16 \nbeau 17 \n00351 18 \nsons, 19 \ncon 20 \ntease 21 \n0)03 SI 22 \nwoo 23 \notos: 24 \n001006 25 \n166 \nand all that goes into the advice that they were \ngiving her and surrounding that advice, so I \nwould object to that. \nMR. SCAROLA: Could I have the question read \nback? \n(Thereupon, a portion of the record was read \nby the reporter.) \nMS. McCAWLEY: And I would like to clarify \nwhat case as well that you're referring to. \nMR. SIMPSON: All right. Let me ask the \nquestion, and -- and I will note for the record \nthat yesterday, the witness testified that the \nfact that Mr. Boles was representing Virginia \nRoberts was significant to him. So it's so\n... [truncated, 4807 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/87 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=87]", "char_count": 4807}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 88, "text_content": "00t01. \n1 \n001414 \n2 \n001102 3 \nono, 4 \n00 1113 \n5 \n001111 6 \n001111 7 \ncoins \n8 \n001111 9 \n00 11 11 10 \n,0112.3 11 \n001134 12 \n02 113313 \nto \n77 14 \n00112. 15 \n031131 16 \n<Own 17 \nCOHN 18 \n001140 19 \n00 ,,.2 20 \n0011 .6 21 \ntottilAlt 22 \neons, 23 \n001143 24 \n(ell% 25 \n168 \nspoken with any other lawyers at Mr. Boles' firm? \nA. My recollection Is, no. \nQ. And after December 30th of 2014, have you \nspoken with Mr. Boles abo \nallegations against --\nMS. McCAWLEY: Again, I'm going to object. \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nQ. -- Professor Dershowitz? \nMS. McCAWLEY: Sorry. I will let you finish. \nI'm objecting to this. I think it gets into \nthe substance of conversations under the \ncommon-interest privilege, whether there was a \nconversation, but you're getting into the \nsubstance of what the conversation was about, and \nI think that is a violation of her -- her \nprivilege. \nMR. SCAROLA: And just so that I can clarify \nour position on the record, I think that we can \nidentify the general subject matter in order to \nsupport our position that It falls within the \ncommon-Interest privilege. So we are willing to \nanswer the question about the general subject \nmatter to support our assertion of \ncommon-Interest privilege, but not get Into the \nsubstance of the communications beyond that. \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331.4400 \n0014 Si \n001434 \n00145) \nCOUS• \nca1501 \nMISC. \nCOiSOB \nWar \nCOON \n031510 10 \nC01111 11 \n00µu 12 \nocnu 13 \ncoon 14 \n°eon 15 \n*env 16 \nORO'S 17 \n001621 18 \ncon2. 19 \nW 162, 20 \n0)163I 21 \n00 1614 22 \nC01637 23 \n0216424 \nOlt ISM 25 \n170 \n1 \nrecord, 8:47 a.m. \n2 \nMR. SCAROLA: As it turns out, while we may \n3 \nreach some issue of privilege at some point in \n4 \nthis discussion, the answer to your pending \n5 \nquestion is, no, so there's no privilege concern. \n6 \nMR. SIMPSON: All right. I'll -- I'll ask \n7 \nthe witness for the --\n8 \nMR. SCAROLA: Sure. \n9 \nMR. SIMPSON: -- the -- the answer. I'll \nmove to -- I'll reask the question. \nTHE WITNESS: Sure. That will be good.\n... [truncated, 5024 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/88 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=88]", "char_count": 5024}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 89, "text_content": "172 \n001013 \n1 \ncommunications were not considered to be \n0016 /4 \n2 \nprivileged at the time that they were made, we \n001(40 3 \ncan answer questions about that. If they were \ncoins 4 \nconsidered to be privileged at the time they were \n001041 5 \nmade, we can't answer questions. \nooleo \n6 \nSo I can't tell you that there's a blanket \nCO NUS 7 \nassertion. We need to hear the question. \n02100 8 \nTHE WITNESS: I need the question back. \n20 \"0 \n9 \nMR. SIMPSON: All right. \nco Na 10 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \n0000 11 \nQ. What did you discuss with Mr. Boles about the \n02 \"33 12 \nallegations against Professor Dershowitz? \ncoma 13 \nMR. SCAROLA: And that is common-interest \nwin. 14 \nprivilege information and we do assert a \n0216o 15 \nprivilege. \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \n00001 17 \nQ. Did you discuss with Mr. Boies any \n*yin 18 \ndiscussions he had had with Professor Dershowitz? \n0%704 19 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Objection. \n0217410 20 \nMR. SCAROLA: Same objection. Same \n*eon 21 \ninstruction. \n001711 22 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \n1101712 23 \nQ. Did you discuss with Mr. Boles any documents \nmini 24 that Mr. Boles had reviewed? \nmina 25 \nMR. SCAROLA: Well, let me -- again, I don't \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-4400 \n173 \ncans) \n1 \nwant to be asserting a privilege to questions as \n• \n2 \nto which the answer is no, so you can answer \n01111 /1 3 \ngenerally as to whether the subject matter was \nco 1700 4 \ncovered In any discussion that you had with \n0/042 \n5 \nMr. Boies. \nDino 6 \nTHE WITNESS: Okay. \nDiva 7 \nMR. SCAROLA: Okay. If the answer is no. If \n03110 8 \nthe answer -- as I sink down In this chair, if \nto \nm 9 \nthe answer may be yes, you can't respond. \nCO 1150 10 \nMR. SIMPSON: I -- I -- that's a new version. \nmini 11 \nMS. McCAWLEY: I'm afraid -- yeah, I want \nto -- I'm sorry. I want to confer on that \nbecause I have an objection. \n/owe 14 \nTHE WITNESS: I have to say I want to confer, \n0411/04 15 \nI'm confused, too, so let's take a short break. \nMR. SIMPSON: Again, you're conferring on the \n11101 17 \nprivilege \n... [truncated, 4774 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/89 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=89]", "char_count": 4774}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 90, "text_content": "176 \n00 lls? \n1 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Yes. \n00 21 Sl \n2 \nMR. SIMPSON: Okay. \n002122 \n3 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \n002,02 \n4 \nQ. \nDid you discuss former Prime Minister Barak \ncones \n5 \nwith Mr. Boles? \n00220 \n6 \nMR. SCAROLA: Same objection. \narm \n7 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Objection. \nono \n8 \nMR. SCAROLA: Same instruction. \nCO 23 10 \n9 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nomit 10 \n0372,4 11 \nrota \n12 \nomn 13 \nQ. \nYesterday, you mentioned that one of the \nreasons that supported your conclusion that it -- you \nhad an adequate basis to allege in the joinder motion \nthat the allegations against Professor Dershowitz was \ntoms \n. \nes. \n032231 \nyou recall \n0122 If \nrepresentin \n032230 17 \nQ. \nAnd you said that because of how highly \nes, \nma*, 18 \n0.32245 19 \nmass 20 \ntons. 21 \n022744 22 \n007250 23 \n01725, 24 \n00\n \n2,13 25 \nregarded Mr. Boles was, I think you mentioned the Bush \nv. Gore case; Is that right? \nA. \nYes. \nQ. \nI used to work for his opponent in Bush v. \nGore case. They are both very good. \nA. \nI'm \ntrying \n-- I was trying \nto remember. \nI ' m \nsorry \nto take time, \nbut who was the other \nlawyer? \nQ. \nTed Olson. \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331.4400 \n177 \n037/ 54 \n1 \nA. \nTed, that\n' s right. \nThat's... \n032715 \n2 \nQ. \nBut that's a side note. \n00»62\n3 \nMy question is: Given your high regard for \n032303 \n4 \nMr. Boies, \niews as to the \n0023 07 \n5 \ncredibility \nmething that would \n032,10 \n6 \nbe import \nhe case? \n071 23 I?' \n7 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Objection. \n002312\n8 \nMR. SIMPSON: Are you instructing him not to \nCO 23 IS \n9 \nanswer? \n0323'15 10 \nMS. McCAWLEY: I mean, Is it a hypothetical? \nno 11 \nMR. SIMPSON: No. I'm just asking whether \n03.21.54 12 \nhis views -- those views -- I'm not asking what \n032310 13 \nthe views are. I'm simply asking whether those \n002323 14 \nviews would be Important to him. \n002323 15 \nMR. SCAROLA: You may answer that question. \ntoms 16 \nTHE WITNESS: Yes. \n002325 17 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nawn 18 \nO. \nAnd if I -- I may have asked this already, \n0013 30 19 \nbut did you discuss with Mr. Boles\n... [truncated, 5093 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/90 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=90]", "char_count": 5093}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 91, "text_content": "002/24 1 \n002032 2 \nCON15 \n3 \n011131 4 \ncon.; \n5 \n002142 \n6 \n<ono 7 \n101143 8 \n0030 44 \n9 \nCON 40 10 \n00710 11 \ncone 12 \n00201 13 \n00»» 14 \n01211/0 15 \n01127 01 16 \nconc. 17 \norno. 18 \n002707 19 \nown 20 \nm]>10 21 \n00211. 22 \n(0 212. 23 \n032123 24 \nCO 2? 13 25 \n180 \nanyone who told you that they, that person, had \ndiscussed the subject matter o \nallegations against Professor \nMr. Josefsberg? Just did you discuss it with anyone? \nMR. SCAROLA: Same objection. Same \ninstruction. \nMR. SIMPSON: Okay. \nMR. SCAROLA: If you want to rephrase the \nquestion to ask lam whether he had such a \nconversation with anyone outside the \nattorney/client or work-product privilege, that's \na question that we are obliged to answer. \nThe question, as you phrased it, is a \nquestion that we are precluded from answering. \nMR. SIMPSON: That's a very strange notion of \nprivilege. \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nQ. But let me ask it this way: Did you discuss \nwith anyone who is not an attorney -- let me rephrase it \na different way. \nYou testified yesterday about your \nunderstanding of the scope of the alleged \ncommon-interest privilege, correct? \nA. \nYes. \nQ. Putting aside the people within the scope of \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-4400 \n012$42 10 \n011145 11 \nCO2047 12 \ncons 13 \ncone 14 \nwan 15 \n012.62 16 \n032813 17 \nCOMO 18 \n00 29 00 19 \n0D2905 20 \n00».0 21 \nhad discussed with Mr. Josefsberg \n002910 22 \nlegations against Professor \n002020 23 \ncons, 24 \nMR. SCAROLA: Same objection. Same \n012923 25 \ninstruction. \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331.4400 \n182 \ntun 1 \nhelpful. So please just instruct him to answer \n012124 2 \nor not answer, and we will let the Judge decide. \n012127 \n3 \nMR. SCAROLA: Well, the instruction -- I only \n0:1207/ 4 \ngave the explanation in the hope that It might \n612131 \n5 \nfacilitate the examination and allow you to move \n012.33 6 \nto areas where you can get substantive \ngenie 7 \ninformation. \n0/2129 8 \nI apologize if you consider it a waste of \ncome 9 \ntime. So I will si\n... [truncated, 5049 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/91 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=91]", "char_count": 5049}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 92, "text_content": "033037 \n1 \nsown 2 \n00 30 40 \n3 \nQ. \nOkay. \ncorn 4 \nA. \nI -- I think the record should be dear, \nwows 5 I'm -- I'm an attorney and a law professor in Salt Lake \n0030 16 \n6 City, Utah, and my understanding, he's an attorney here \n03304/ \n7 \nin Florida. So I don't ordinarily interact with —\nsows, \n8 \nwith, you know, attorneys in Florida, other than the \n013364 \n9 \nones that I'm interacting with on — on this case. \nIns 10 \nMR. SCAROLA: Which is now occurring on a \noi 30 32 11 \nvery regular basis. \nLem: 12 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \n0 3101 13 \nQ. \nMr. Cassell --\n03 31,1 14 \nMR. SCOTT: No teaming, Mr. Scarola, please. \ntom, 15 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nQ. -- did -- didn't you testify yesterday that \nCO 3100 17 \nthe fact that Mr. 3osefsberg's firm had filed a \n033:,0 18 \ncomplaint against Miss Roberts, who is also your client, \nson,, 19 \nto be significant to your evaluation of the case? \nwan 20 \nA. \nYes. \ncon r 21 \nQ. \nAnd if it -- if that was significant to \ncost is 22 \nevaluation of the case, why are you telling us you don't \nC03120 23 \nnormally talk with attorneys in Florida? Doesn't he \n03)1 2$ 24 \nrepresent -- at one point, represent the same client? \nsena 25 \nA. Right. \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-4400 \n184 \nrecollection of talking to, you know, anyone who is — \nwho was in his firm. \n003101 16 \n013220 \n1 \nearn 2 \nGorr 3 \n003330 4 \n003237 \n5 \n003230 \n6 \n00)230 7 \ncores 8 \neons \n9 \ncons 10 \ntone 11 \n013316 12 \ntense 13 \n003302 14 \n003303 15 \n03301 16 \n003304 17 \n00330? 18 \ncones 19 \nto rn \n20 \n33 33 If 21 \n03 33 33 22 \n03 33 19 23 \n03 )3 II 24 \n03 33 31 25 \n186 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nO. \nHave you ever -- I'll rephrase the question. \nHave you ever discussed with Pt. Boles his \nviews as to whether or not Miss Roberts is mistaken in \nher allegations against Professor Dershowitz? \nMS. McCAWLEY: Objection. \nMR. SCAROLA: Same objection. Same \ninstruction. \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nQ. \nPrior to December 30th of 2014, had you \npersonally reviewed any of the flight logs that had been \nreferred t\n... [truncated, 5303 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/92 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=92]", "char_count": 5303}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 93, "text_content": "188 \ncoma 1 enforcement agency to provide flight logs relevant to \n00527 \n2 \nthis investigation. \nON 17 \n3 \nAnd rather than providing all the flight logs \ncon., 4 \nthat were available at that time, he appears to have \n03.3112 \n5 \nprovided flight logs that went from January 2005 through \nout' \n6 \nSeptember 2005, knowing that he appeared on an \nsemoi \n7 \nOctober -- I may be off by one month here — but on an \n063004 \n8 \nOctober 2005 flight log. \n00350e \n9 \nSo that, to my mind, had indicated that \nseen 10 \nProfessor Dershowitz was providing selective information \nwen 11 \nto law enforcement. Those concerns — this is, you \n0.3511 12 \nknow, there's — there's more to it. \nroe +0 13 \nThe other problem was that the flight logs \nern 14 \nthat Mr. Dershowitz had produced were inconsistent with \nwen 15 \nthe flight logs that Dave Rogers, one of Mr. Epstein's \ncon,, 16 \npilots had, so there were now inconsistencies on these \naux 17 \nflight logs. And it seemed to be -- it seemed to me to \ncone 18 \nbe surprising that during the period of time where \n19 \nnvolved, Mr. Dershowitz was not \nroue 20 \nght logs. \n00 330 21 \nNow, it is possible, I suppose, and that \ninns 22 \nseems to be Mr. Dershowitz's position, that the reason \nwest 23 \nhe's not on those flight logs is that he was not on \nmass. 24 \nthose flights. But given all of the information -- and \nwas S7 25 \n1 won't take your time this morning to go through — all \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-9400 \n189 \ncoat so \n1 \nthe information I had about this international sex \ncome, \n2 \ntrafficking organization, it seemed to me that it was \nto 36 05 \n3 \nalso possible that the sex trafficking organization, \ncoma \n4 \nwhich was represented by, you know, vast resources and \n00x0, \n5 \nthe ability to produce witnesses and documents and other \nwen 6 \ninformation that would \nwould cover up the existence \nwain 7 \nof this organization, had gone through the flight logs \n0)3012 \n8 \nand had made necessary alterations to— to conceal the \nmum \n9 \nsc\n... [truncated, 5891 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/93 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=93]", "char_count": 5891}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 94, "text_content": "C01022 \nC03935 \nC0414 \nOD 20'40 \n00 94 \n00»Y \n002844 \n00401 \n192 \n1 \nAre you now asking for an expansion of that \n2 \nresponse to include information that's been \n3 \ngathered since December 30th? \n4 \nMR. SIMPSON: I will take your objection to \n5 \nthe form. \n6 \nCan we have the question back? \n7 \n(Thereupon, a portion of the record was read \n8 \nby the reporter.) \nnen 9 \nMR. SCAROLA: And I object. The Question is \nvague and ambiguous because it fails to identify \nthe time period about which you are inquiring. \nwoos 12 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nO. \nMr. Cassell, as you sit here today, are you \nwen 14 \nprepared, based on the Information you have available to \nCO 4021 15 \nyou, to assert that Professor Dershowitz intentionally \ncio en 16 \nprovided misleading or doctored documents to a \ncoon 17 \nprosecuting authority? \n00423? 18 \nA. \nSo based on all the Information I have today? \nwoe 19 \nQ. \nYes. \n10 40 40 20 \nA. \nYes. \n00 404 21 \nQ. \nWhat do you base -- what Is the basis for \nCO 4044 22 \nthat conclusion, and Include information up until today? \n00404 23 \nA. \nAll right. So, obviously, that's an \ncows, 24 \n004051 25 \n44407 10 \n004009 11 \nO 401413 \nopen-ended question. \nQ. \nI --just answer the question, please, as \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954)3314400 \n194 \nC04201 \n1 \nAnother thing that happened during the \nC04110 \n2 \ndeposition, and I will not repeat what was said in the \n00014 3 \ndeposition, because there was immediately an objection \n034111 4 \nfrom Ms. McCawley, but there were two points in the \n40019 5 \ndeposition where Mr. Dershowitz made representations \noar \n6 \nabout what a New York Attorney David Boles would say, \n00422. 7 \nand I'm not going into any —\nnen 8 \nQ. \nI -- I just want to say if he starts talking \nm13s 9 \nabout it — \n0.4221 10 \nMS. McCAWLEY: No, -- I object to any \n024232 11 \nreference — \nCO433 12 \nMR. SIMPSON: -- then I get to ask all the \n00 QM 13 \nquestions if he should say anything. \n024244 14 \nMS. McCAWLEY: I think he's Just \n40429$ 15 \nacknowledging that \n... [truncated, 5434 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/94 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=94]", "char_count": 5434}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 95, "text_content": "198 \n198 \n004354 \n004316\n004440 \n004440 \n004402 \n004404 \n03 44 OB \n004409 \n14344 13 \n14144 17 10 \nal 4414 11 \n034421 12 \n03 44 30 13 \n00«N 14 \n0044 31 15 \n004434 16 \n03443? 17 \nOM* 18 \nwan 19 \n1:444.43 20 \nDemo. 21 \n4150 22 \ncons> 23 \n034459 24 \nCO 44 SI 25 \nv\n2 \nas an attorney who had \n3 \nrepresented Miss Roberts based on public \n4 \ninformation, and I knew that that would be a \n5 \ngross violation of Mr. Josefsberg's \n6 \nattorney/client obligations. And as a result of \n7 \nthat, it seemed to me that, once again, \n8 \nMr. Dershowitz was giving false Information under \n9 \noath in an effort to exculpate Nmself from the \nsex trafficking that he had been Involved with. \nIn addition to that, I learned during the \ndeposition on Thursday that it had, quote, not \ncrossed my mind, close quote -- I believe that's \na direct quote from Mr. Dershowitz -- to record a \nconversation with a woman allegedly named Rebecca \nwho had allegedly made certain statements. That \nwas on Thusday. \nAnd then yesterday, Friday, I learned that \nMr. Dershowitz, not only had it crossed his mind \nto make a recording, he had, in fact, made such a \nrecording; and in fact, had it transcribed; and \nin fact, turned it over to his attorneys. So, \nonce again, I had what appeared to be a false \nstatement under oath by Mr. DeS110Wit2 In an \nattempt to exculpate himself from the -- the sex \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-4400 \n00402 1 \nYou know, I also have -- I would like to \nson 2 \nrefresh my recollection and If -- if counsel --\n044410 3 \nthat's \n0044110 4 \nMR. SCAROLA: You can refresh your \nco.,', 5 \nrecollection on anything you need to. \nmay 6 \nTHE WITNESS: All right. I'd like to refresh \nvin it 7 \nmy recollection by looking at --\nwen 8 \nMR. SIMPSON: Actually, I -- I object to this \nm«n 9 \nanswer as nonresponsive. I haven't heard \nHum 10 \nanything about flight logs once. \nHan 11 \nMR. SCARpIA: You can continue. \nN«33 12 \nTHE WITNESS: These -- you know, these all 90 \nea MST 13 \nto the statements. \n00602\n... [truncated, 5496 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/95 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=95]", "char_count": 5496}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 96, "text_content": "200 \n00 4015 \nI \nSO I thought that was, again, a deliberate \nOC 48'1 2 \nfalse statement under oath designed to exculpate him \n00411 /2 \n3 \nfrom his criminal involvement in this international sex \nCO 41 01 4 \ntrafficking ring. \nCO .4.17 \n5 \nAt another point in the transcript, he was \n0341/3 \n6 \nasked, quote, -- no, I'm sorry. He stated, quote: I \nGOO 33 \n7 \nchallenge you to find any statement where I said I have \nCon 35 \n8 \nnever traveled outside the presence of my wife, close \n1041A \n9 \nquote, representing that there would be no such \neon 47 10 \nstatement there, when, in fact, I'm aware of an American \n*ono 11 Lawyer quotation attributed to him from January 15th, \nens., 12 \n2015, quote: I've been married to the same woman for 28 \n00146: 13 \nyears. She goes with me everywhere, close quote. And, \ncc 44 v. 14 \nagain, you know, this — I understand sometimes people \nox4is, 15 \nmay go away from their wife, but the American Lawyer \n13C 4211• 16 \nwas, obviously, on January 15th, 20 1 5, asking about: \n23 453. 17 \nWell, have you been outside the presence of your wife in \nCO 4201 18 \nsituations where you might have interacted with Virginia \n03 4211 19 \nRoberts? And that was the answer that he gave to the \n• \n20 \nAmerican Lawyer. \n▪ 43 11 21 \nAnd based on -- on my review of the flight \nte \n22 \nlogs, I thought that was, again, a deliberate effort to \ncon X 23 \nobscure and try to exculpate himself from his \nto 1131 24 \ninvolvement in this international sex trafficking ring. \n004199 25 \nThe — he also said yesterday: Nobody knows \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954)331-4400 \n202 \nlogs. And could refresh my recollection here by \no:\n9a \nso.s. \n2 \nlooking at, I think it's docket entry 291 of our \n1235041 \n3 \npleading that we presented on January 21st to \n093011 4 \nJudge Marra where we provided specific itemized examples \nco son 5 \nof inconsistencies between the Dave Rogers' flight log \nten \n6 \nand the — again, I'll call it, the Alan Dershowitz \neosin \n7 \nflight log, which was a selec\n... [truncated, 6101 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/96 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=96]", "char_count": 6101}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 97, "text_content": "00003 \n005302 \n1 \n2 \n204 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nQ. Before Wednesday of this week, you had none \n001307 \n3 of the information that you just described about \nWOW 4 \nProfessor Dershowitz's testimony, correct? \n006212 \n5 \nA. Correct. \n06112 6 \nQ. I'm trying to look at my notes here of your \nwon 7 \nlong answer, but one thing you Indicated that -- was the \n0330 8 \nfact that Professor Dershowitz gave long answers Is \n00 034 9 \nsomehow indicative of false answers or perjury --\nCOOS 10 \ncoon. 11 \nmom 12 \n1130 13 \n00040 14 \nono 15 \ntoss./ 16 \ncosio 17 \nono 18 \noosiu 19 \nmuss 20 \n003 6, 21 \nNSW 22 \ngown 23 \nmacs 24 \nman 25 \nMR. SCAROLA: That Is --\nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nQ. -- is that right? \nMR. SCAROLA: That Is an absolute \nmischaracterization of the statement that \nProfessor Cassell made. He did not refer to the \nlength of the answers, but rather their \nnonresponsiveness. \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nQ. Let me -- let me ask a different question. \nGo back to the flight logs themselves. \nA. Okay. \nQ. My initial question that got us going down \nthis line was: Isn't it true that the flight logs \nthemselves support Professor Derchow,tr' \nny that \nhe was never on a plane \nface \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-4400 \n206 \n06106 1 \nperfectly clear. \n006601 2 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \n006106 3 \nQ. My question, Mr. Cassell, is: You reviewed \noissii 4 the flight logs, correct? \n&sun 5 \nA. Correct. \nQ. You reviewed them in some detail, correct? \nA. Correct. \nQ. Is there any entry on those flight lines 33 \nC016 1? 9 \nlogs that you read as putting Professor Dershowitz and \n02021 10 \nMiss Roberts on the same plane? \n03023 11 \nA. No. \n003624 12 \nQ. And so your testimony about questions about \ncoups 13 the completeness and accuracy of those flight logs goes \nto whether the logs are -- let me rephrase that. \n00601 15 \nThe answer that you gave about your question \n00510 16 \nas -- your views as to the completeness of the flight \n001 ./ 17 \nlogs and whether they may have been changed in some \nrout) 18 \nways, goes to w\n... [truncated, 4927 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/97 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=97]", "char_count": 4927}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 98, "text_content": "208 \n00sn 1 \nA. I was thinking of that as well. \nCOO n 2 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nton 3 \nQ. \nLet me \nsoy yi 4 \nA. I wasn't --\nso rn \n5 \nQ. Let me --\naim 6 \nA. -- following their answer. \n0047 n 23 7 \nQ. Let me -- let me Just ask a different \n011717 \n8 \nquestion. \n00 67 22 \n9 \nA. Sure. Thanks. \ncon, 10 \nQ. \nYou testified that you have -- at some \nwins 11 length, about why you question the accuracy of the \nan.. 12 \nflight logs, correct? \nono 13 \nA. Correct. \nNun 14 \nQ. But I may be redundant, but you don't \nHuss 15 \nquestion that what they show on their face supports \ntesta 16 \nProfessor Dershowitz's testimony --\ntesta 17 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Objection. \ncosta 18 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \n00 6740 19 \nQ. -- that he was not on a plane with Virginia \nglob 20 \nRoberts? \noats 21 \nA. The \nyou know, the — the sex trafficking \nwars 22 ring run by Jeffrey Epstein has produced Epstein flight \ntabu. 23 \nhow that -- that Dershowitz and \n405644 24 \nnot on the plane, so... \ntosses 25 \ner to my question is, yes? \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331.4400 \n210 \nwino 1 \nA. I recall his testimony to that effect, yes. \nHint 2 \nQ. \nAnd you testified that no support for that \nor • vi 3 \nhad been produced in discovery; Is that correct? \niota* 4 \nA. That's my understanding, yes. \nowe \n5 \nQ. Isn't it true that in Mr. Alessi's \non \n6 \ndeposition, he describes that under oath and says that \n04%23 7 it happened? \n06 SI 24 \n8 \nk \nI don't have a recollection of criminal \n0050 21 9 \ncharges having been discussed in the Alessi deposition. \n613431 10 \nQ. Is it -- well, let me -- let me ask you: Is \nvises. 11 it your testimony that you understood that, in fact, \nresew 12 \nMiss Roberts had been accused of stealing money from her \n04 0« 13 \nemployer? \nCO 54 4? 14 \nMS. McCAWLEY: I'm going to object to the \n1•41 15 \nextent it gets into any conversations that you \n40440 16 \nhad with Virginia on any of these issues. \nwiry 17 \nTHE WITNESS: Yeah, I'm trying to -- if your \ncassis 18 \nquestion is about the Alessi depo, !don't -\n... [truncated, 4971 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/98 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=98]", "char_count": 4971}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 99, "text_content": "010101 \n010101 \n010103 \n01010/ \n010110 \n01 01 11 \n010111 \n01 Ot '2 \n010110 \nnot' 10 \n01:0123 11 \n01 0123 12 \n01,0123 13 \nOW 24 14 \n0101 25 15 \n°iv 24 16 \n0101 24 17 \n0101 21 18 \n0101 32 19 \ncows 20 \n010141 21 \n0101 44 22 \n*ono 23 \n010140 24 \nmow 25 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \nMR. SIMPSON: I move -- I move to strike as \n6 \nnonresponsive. \n7 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \n8 \nQ. My question went to whether -- let me back \n9 \nup. If -- if I'm -- unless I misunderstood you --\nMR. SCAROLA: The question was: Did he \nrecall the contents --\nMR. SIMPSON: I'm asking the question. \nMR. SCAROLA: -- of the Alessi deposition. \nMR. SIMPSON: I'm withdrawing it. I will ask \na new question. \nMR. SCAROLA: Okay. Thank you. \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nQ. I understood you in your -- the long answer \nthat you gave a while ago to suggest that Professor \nDershowitz had either testified falsely or failed to \nprovide relevant information on which he was basing his \ntestimony about Miss Roberts's arrest; is that right? \nA. Yes. \nQ. And that assertion would be incorrect if \nthere's a deposition in this case that all the parties \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-4400 \n212 \non this piece of the Alessi depo and It's not In \nthe answers to Interrogatories, it's hard for me \nto -- to give an answer to that. So -- so that's \nthe -- that's the concern I have. \n213 \nmorn 1 have that include that Information? \na, 0146 2 \nMR. SCAROLA: Mr. Simpson, there was an \non 3 \nexpress reference to an answer to interrogatory, \nmoo 4 \nand the absence of any reference to an arrest for \n010105 \n5 \ntheft in your client's sworn answer to \nmono 6 \ninterrogatory. That's --\nel 02 00 7 \nMR. SIMPSON: We -- we --\n0102 11 \n8 \nMR. SCAROLA: -- exactly what the testimony \n01 02 12 9 \nwas. \nMR. SIMPSON: If you object to the form, \nalma 11 \nplease just object to the form. I think it's a \nohms 12 \nproper question --\nurea 13 \nMR. SCAROLA: I -- I object \" \n010212 14 \nMR. SIMPSON: -- in our discovery response. \nones 15 \nMR. SCAROLA: -- I object to your \n°Ina 16 \nmisr\n... [truncated, 5129 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/99 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=99]", "char_count": 5129}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 100, "text_content": "216 \n218 \n01 101 \n1 \nQ. In fact, I think you testified yesterday \nLi wit 2 \nabout your duty with respect to Miss Roberts along those \nx1.47 \n3 \nlines, correct? \net ins 4 \nA. \nThat's right. \n01,11 40 \n5 \nQ. \nAnd so with respect to Professor Dershowites \n0111132 \n6 \nrepresentation of Jeffrey Epstein, he would have been \n20 ,07 7 \nacting unetNcally if he didn't attempt to negotiate the \n01 17 00 \n8 \nbest resolution for his client that he could, consistent \not 0c, 9 \nwith the law; Is that correct? \n01 1701 10 \nA. \nRight. Consistent with the law, yes. \nos Ins 11 \nQ. \nAnd so you wouldn't --\n0 009 12 \nA. I'm sorry. Let me just -- consistent with \n01 1711 13 \nthe law and with the ethical obligations of attorneys. \noi 1714 14 \nAttorneys cannot make, for example, false \nours 15 \nrepresentations when they are negotiating those kinds of \net ir le 16 \nthings. \n01 1710 17 \nQ. \nRight. The duty as a defense counsel, \na rid 18 \nProfessor Dershowitz's duty was to attempt to obtain the \n01 1777 19 \nbest resolution he could for Jeffrey Epstein consistent \nwith the law and legal ethics, correct? \nA. \nThat's correct. \nQ. \nAnd, in fact, If he had not done that, he \nwould have been acting unethically, correct? \nA. \nThat's correct. \nQ. \nAnd would you agree that it would be \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331.4400 \n01 101 20 \n41 17 14 21 \n01 17 34 22 \n1,214 23 \n01 17 41 24 \n01.1741 25 \n0000 \n1 \nMS. McCAWLEY: The location is fine. \nel wt. 2 \nTHE WITNESS: The location, once \nawed \n3 \npersonally -- once here In Florida, and then in \n01 1125 4 \nmy office in -- while in Salt Lake Oty. \nmini 5 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \npin= 6 \nQ. \nAnd are you able to place in time when you \nmo 7 \nreviewed these portions of the police report, other than \nbefore December 30th of 2014/ \nal UM \n9 \nA. \nNot precisely, no. \nQ. \nAnd do I understand correctly from your \ntestimony yesterday that that police report ts one of \nthe things you relied on to support making the \nallegations against Professor Dershowitz that are \nincl\n... [truncated, 5465 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/100 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=100]", "char_count": 5465}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 101, "text_content": "220 \n012110 \n1 \nAre you aware that the police report reflects \n012171 2 \nthat the woman I referred to who was hired to give \nei a \n3 \nmassages, told them that she never touched anyone \ne12126 4 \ninappropriately? \narts 5 \nA. I think that there are — there is \nei nu 6 information along those lines in the police report, yes. \n012114 7 \nQ. \nOkay. And so do you acknowledge that the \n01211/ 8 police report, on Its face, reflects both reports of \nmail 9 \nmassages that Involved improper sexual contact -- \n012145 10 \ncontact and massages that were perfectly legitimate? \n012,00 11 \nA. \nYes, but not in the same proportion. \n012154 12 \nQ. \nMy question wasn't proportion. The \nthe \nDI 21S1 13 \nreport on Its face, you understood, reflected that there \nanal 14 \nwere massages given at Mr. Epstein's residence that were \n012200 15 \nperfectly legitimate? \neine 16 \nA. \nSome — Novas basically a few isolated \n017711 17 \nexamples from what I could see. \n1112714 18 \nQ. \nSo you would characterize what was said in \nthe police report as \"a few isolated examples'? \n012721 20 \nA. \nWell, given the backdrop that they had - \n01222$ 21 \nQ. \nNo. My Question -- it's a yes or no \naims 22 \nQuestion. Is that how you would characterize it? \n022771 23 \nMR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. The witness is not \n*inn 24 \nconfined to answering yes or no, if yes or no \n01071 25 \nwould be misleading. \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(854)331.4400 \n111 22 14 19 \n012211 11 \n012401 12 \n012071 13 \n012414 14 \n012401 15 \nernes 16 \n012401 17 \n012401 18 \n017404 19 \n0124 „ 20 \n01 24 14 21 \n013411 22 \n01241.  23 \n0124n 24 \n}a 25 \nperson? \nelms \n012131 \n012140 \n012140 \n017442 \n012344 \n017341 \n017254 \n017314 \n222 \n1 \nA. That sounds accurate with the information I \n2 have, yes, she doesn't sound like she would fit his \n3 \ntype. \n4 \nQ. \nAnd so do you agree with me then --\n5 \nA. \nAnd she's over the age of 18, which is \n6 \nanother reason why wouldn't fit his type, so... \n7 \nQ. \nBut you acknowledge that -- that this \n8 \nwoman -- that the police\n... [truncated, 5488 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/101 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=101]", "char_count": 5488}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 102, "text_content": "224 \n226 \ncoma \n1 \n062612 \n2 \naddress book of Mr. Epstein? \nno \n3 \nA. \nPieces of it, yes. \nunto 4 \nQ. \nDid you review the entire document? \net 241I \n5 \nA. \nNo. \n012621 6 \nQ. \nDid I understand yesterday that you \nmoon 7 \ntestified -- did I understand correctly yesterday, that \n012626 8 \nyou testified that the fact that names were circled \nto n33 9 \nIndicated that those persons likely engaged in illegal \n01 70 31 10 \nsexual contact with minors? \n012641 11 \nA. \nMy — my impression is the names that were \n017044 12 \ncircled were circled by Alfredo Rodriguez when he was \noroon 13 \nbusted by the FBI for involvement, and he was asked to \n017661 14 identify those who would have information about the sex \nones. 15 \ntrafficking organization. And my — based on all the \ncrass 16 \nevidence I have, I believe the names that were circled \norno, 17 \nwere those who would have that kind of Information. \nosnre 18 \nQ. \nSo is it your testimony that if the name is \n017701 19 \ncircled, it indicates that they have information, or \nnu 20 \nthat they are criminals? \n012702 21 \nA. \nThat they would have information about the \ncilviz 22 \nsex trafficking organization, and that would probably \n271$ 23 \nmean that they were part of the organization. It may \nAV IS 24 \nmean that they were witnesses to what the organization \n0127e 25 \nwas doing. \nIn your testimony yesterday as the holy grail, an \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331.4400 \nAMA \n1 \nQ. \nWould It be a reasonable Inference, or a \n000 2 \npossible reasonable inference to draw, that \n01223. 3 \nMr. Rodriguez was trying to highlight people who would \ned no \n4 be of Interest to the Press for purposes of selling the \nel a as \n5 \nbook? \n• 0. \n6 \nA. No, because he was not talking to the Press. \nin no \n7 \nHe was talking to an FBI agent who had busted him for \n01 2110 \n8 \ncriminal activity. And so I was assuming that what he \n012664 \n9 \nwas trying to do, as many criminals do when they are \n012466 10 \napprehended, was give information to law enforceme\n... [truncated, 5578 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/102 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=102]", "char_count": 5578}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 103, "text_content": "0111044 \n1 \n01304. \n2 \n03 30 43 \n3 \n013030 \n4 \n0110M \n5 \n013014 \n6 \nMON \n7 \n013102 \n8 \n013101 \n9 \n01310? 10 \n01:3169 11 \n013314 12 \nits, 17 13 \n111:3110 14 \nu.3•2, 15 \n013115 16 \n1113124 17 \n013in 18 \n01)130 19 \n013311 20 \nw ar \n21 \nO13324 22 \n0,8,3 23 \nmay \n24 \n013430 25 \n228 \nunderstanding would be that if her — and this is --\ncould I ask a question about the circling \nor your \nrepresentation? \nIs the circling the same type of circling \nthat Is done for Mr. Dershowitz, for example? Is it the \nsame, you know, handwriting, same ink, same — same \nappearance? You know, if It's consistent with the \ncircling — are you representing k's consistent with \nthe circling? \nQ. \nMr. Cassell, we have a document produced in \ndiscovery that has various names circled. Looking at \nthe document, I don't see any difference among the \ncircles. Are you aware of any document --\nMR. SCAROLA: Could we have a look -- could \nwe see the document? \nMR. SIMPSON: Take a -- go off the record for \none moment. \nTHE WITNESS: We are going off the video \nrecord, 10:03. \n(Thereupon, a recess was taken.) \nTHE VIDEOGRAPHER: We are back on the video \nrecord, 10:08 a.m. \nMR. SIMPSON: Okay. Back on the record. I'm \ngoing to ask the reporter to mark as Cassell \nExhibit 5, a multi-page document. It's a copy of \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n1954)331 - 4400 \n013422 \nof\n013424 \n01930 \n1 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n230 \nall. \nQ. \nTake as long as you want to look at the \ndocument. \nA. \nSuper. Thank you. \netas, \n5 \nOkay. Yeah. I think I'm — I'm oriented \n013154 \n6 \nnow. But I haven't looked at the Love entry. \n613664 \n7 \nQ. \nMy -- my first --\n«MS7 \n8 \nA. \nI want to look at the Love — \n013111 \n9 \nQ. -- Question Is: Is this a copy of the \nwen 10 \naddress book that you referred to in your testimony? \nA\nHsu 11 \nA. \nYes.\nGlues 12 \nO. \nOkay. And if you would take a look at the --\n01)1104 13 \nI've marked the entries for Courtney Love. Take a look \noi *11 14 \nat that one. \n013013 15 \nA. \nAll right. I see it. \n0,1014 16 \nO. \nOkay. And then i\n... [truncated, 5230 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/103 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=103]", "char_count": 5230}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 104, "text_content": "01 0202\n014100 \n014101 \nMAIO \n014111 \n014112 \nOulu \nDune \nDula \n232 \nI \nare circled is, I would say, you know, 5 to 10 percent \n2 \nof the — of the names ball-parking in the dark. \n3 \nQ. Do you know whether this address book was \n4 Jeffrey Epstein's address book or Glenn Maxwell's \n5 \naddress book? \n6 \nA. I'm not certain exactly whose book it is. \n7 \nactually thought it was Alfredo Rodriguez maintaining a \n8 \ncopy of records in case he was worried that Epstein \n9 \nmight try to have him killed at some point, and so this \n• rt 10 \nwas his insurance policy, I think he said, against that \n014121 11 happening. \n%OM 12 \nMR. SIMPSON: Object to the nonresponsive \n014191 13 \nportion of the answer. \n4131 14 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \noirin 15 \nQ. Is the answer to my question: You don't know \n016134 16 \nwhether it was Jeffrey Epstein's or Glenn Maxwell's \n014110 17 \naddress book? \n0141)0 18 \nA. \nI don't know. And the reason I don't know \n014141 19 \nthat is because I actually believe it is neither --\n*taw 20 \nneither of their — that's -- is it one or the other? \noloa 21 \nActually, I think it's a third possibility. I think \nthis was Alfredo Rodriguez's Insurance policy against \ngetting knocked off by Jeffrey Epstein. \nQ. \nSo that's the view you have of the \n014201 25 \nsignifkance of this document? \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-4400 \n011145 22 \n.1•151 23 \nrims,. 24 \n024317 \n014317 \nO14324 \n01 as \n014124 \n014231 \n014312 \n014114 \nO1.334 \n014)M 10 \n014142 11 \n014341 12 \n014347 13 \n(won 14 \n014254 15 \n016402 16 \n014404 17 \not.i. 18 \n014410 19 \n01 \n12 20 \n014213 21 \n014415 22 \nO1 44 16 23 \n014110 24 \nO 4410 25 \n234 \n1 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \n2 \nQ. \nBut based on your testimony previously, you \n3 \nwould consider all of those facts to be evidence that he \n4 \nmay have been? \n5 \nA. \nThey are, you know, certainly things that I \n6 \nwould want to follow up on. \n7 \nQ. And --\n8 \nA. If I were running an -- we were in the \n9 \ncontext, I take it, of your question, you know, if \nsomebody is running an i\n... [truncated, 5234 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/104 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=104]", "char_count": 5234}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 105, "text_content": "0145 W \n1 \n236 \nthe company of his grandchildren, among other family \nor is le \n2 \nmembers? \nolds 3 \nA. I'm sorry. Which residence? Which Epstein \n010573 4 residence? \n014523 \n5 \nQ. \nPalm Beach. \n014525 6 \nA. \nCan you — can you restate? \n0/4575 7 \nQ. \nYes. \n4. \n8 \nA. \nI mean that's kind of a compound question. I \n014130 9 \nmean... \n014130 10 \nQ. \nWell, let me rephrase R. I will be dear. \n014531 11 \nA. \nYeah. \nmen 12 \nQ. \nWere you aware as of December 30th of 2014 \n0146 X 13 let me back up a moment. \n01041 14 \nA. Sure. \n01037 15 \nQ. \nYou indicated yesterday that part of the \n014540 16 \nbasis for your conduslon that this pleading -- It was \n014544 17 \nappropriate to file this pleading accusing Professor \n01450 18 \nDershowitz of misconduct was that he was a guest at the \ncorm 19 \nPalm Beach house, correct? \n014656 20 \nA. No. It was more than that. He was a \n01450 21 frequent guest, a frequent overnight guest. \n014001 22 \nQ. \nMy question is: As of December 30th, 2014, \n014001 23 \nwere you aware that Professor Dershowitz had spent a \n014.10 24 \nweek at the Palm Beach house with family members, \n014413 25 \nIncluding his grandchildren? \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-4400 \n014105 \n1 \n014712 \n2 \n1114210 \n3 \n014/ 14 4 \n014711 5 \n014733 6 \n014741 7 \n4100 8 \n014747 9 \n014743 10 \n01015 11 \n01470 12 \nAre -- during the period that Virginia \nmins 13 \nRoberts contends she was sexually abused, which I \n014002 14 \nunderstand to be middle of 1999 to middle of 2002 -- is \neiwit 15 \nthat consistent with your understanding? \noral. 16 \nA. \nApproximately, yes. \n014412 17 \nQ. -- how many times did Professor Dershowitz \na au 18 \nvisit the Palm Beach mansion during that period? \n01441? 19 \nA. \nMy understanding is In the neighborhood of —\n014:2, 20 \nwhat was it? Three to five times a year, staying two to \nis a a 21 three nights at a time. \n01 an 22 \nQ. \nAnd was that your understanding as of \n014120 23 December 30th of 2014? \n014032 24 \nA. \nYes. \niz 25 \nQ. \nwhat was the basis for your \n... [truncated, 5023 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/105 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=105]", "char_count": 5023}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 106, "text_content": "240 \net an 1 \nMR. SCAROLA: Could I ask for a \n014040 2 \nclarification? Are you looking only for direct \nHeti, 3 \nevidence and you want to exclude the \n0101144 \n4 \ncircumstantial evidence? Is that the way you \notitis 5 \nwant to •' \n0100•I 6 \nMR. SIMPSON: I'm asking. You can object to \n011•30 7 \nthe form. \n011046 8 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \no14en 9 \nQ. \nMy question Is: What was -- what were you --\n0. oil 10 \nwhat did you have in mind as supporting your conclusion \n014037 11 or tenet that he -- that Professor Dershowltz visited \n014002 12 \nthree to five times during that relevant penod? \n013004 13 \nMS. McCAWLEY: And I'm sum/. Can I just \nmath 14 \nplace an objection on the record. I'm going to \n01,10/ 15 \nobject to the extent that -- so that you do not \nreveal attorney/client privileged communication, \n014012 17 \nunless it's something that's already public that \nmai, 18 \nshe's revealed. \n013013 19 \nTHE WITNESS: Okay. Right. So I'm going to \n011017 20 \njust exclude -- I take it your question isn't \nHuns 21 \nasking about any communications. \nmax 22 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \n011022 23 \nQ. \nMy question is asking about that, but I \n01024 24 \nunderstand you're going to refuse to provide it. \nin an 25 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Unless it's already public. \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331.4400 \npl.., la 16 \n242 \n015123 \n1 \ncontext, in other words, information that was \n013123 2 \ngoing to be disclosed, not for advice, but \nwas 30 \n3 \nfactual information that she intended to \nits, a 4 \ndisclose, that's no -- that's not privileged. \noi stu 5 \nBut if it's something that she communicated to \nHite 6 \nyou in confidence with respect to getting legal \n4,.a 7 \nadvice, then that would be privileged. \n01301 8 \nTHE WITNESS: Right. Okay. So Juan Alessi ' s \n0131.43 9 \ndeposition, Alfredo Rodriguez's deposition, and \nHilo 10 \nthen considerable circumstantial evidence which \nwe don't have to rehash here involving the dose \n0131 9.11 12 \npersonal association between Epstein and \n01330313 \nDershowltz. \n01 SICO 14 \n\n... [truncated, 5255 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/106 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=106]", "char_count": 5255}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 107, "text_content": "244 \nasset \n1 \nA. \nRight. \nOu53 3? \n2 \nQ. \nThat because he visited, according to \n01 1340 \n3 \nMr. Rodriguez, several times a year in 2004, 2005, he \n011341 4 \nmust have visited several times a year in 2000 -- 19- '-\nMOM \n5 \nmiddle of 1999 to the middle of 2002. \net 0316 \n6 \nA. \nI didn't say must have. I said that that's \nte nu 7 \ngoing to be evidence of the common scheme and plan, and \nel On \n8 \nthen, in the absence of, you know, some falling out \nO15402 \n9 \nbetween people or somebody becoming, you know, more \nHues 10 \nassociated or Less associated with a criminal \n044407 11 \norganization. I mean, if you want to get into the \nHum 12 \ncircumstantial evidence, in 2003, there's an ankle on \noi 5415 13 \nwhich, you know, Dershowitz identifies himself — \ntestis 14 \nQ. \nLet me interrupt you because I'm asking --\nHens 15 \nA. \nOkay. \noleos 16 \nQ. \n— about \nmy only question is evidence of \nOISMS 17 \nhow -- not anything, whether engaged In conduct or \nei s4 n 18 \ndidn't engage in conduct, Just how many times he came \nel Si 26 19 \nduring this period. \ntin \n20 \nA. \nRight. \nelan 21 \nMR. SCAROIA: Excuse me, counsel. That's the \nel an \n22 \nreason why I asked you to clarify whether you \nMS4 30 23 \nwant to limit this to direct evidence or whether \nes use 24 \nyou want all of the evidence including \n11,54 35 25 \ncircumstantial evidence, because as we both know, \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331.4400 \n246 \nHesse 1 \nMR. SIMPSON: Really, objecting to the form \n011123 \n2 \nof the question preserves all of any problems \nre 6120 \n3 \nthere may be with the question. \n011627 4 \nMR. SCAROIA: No, sir. \n015617 5 \nMR. SIMPSON: We don't need a speech. \n01 5627 6 \nMR. SCAROLA: It doesn't. It doesn't. \n011637 \n7 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \n015533 \n8 \nQ. \nMr. Cassel, is it your testimony that, from \n01 56 3/ \n9 \nMr. Rodriguez's testimony about how often he says \nmen 10 \nProfessor Dershowitz visited in a 2004/2005 time frame, \nmess 11 \nit's fair to draw an inference about how often he \n• sses 12 \nvisited in\n... [truncated, 5640 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/107 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=107]", "char_count": 5640}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 108, "text_content": "248 \nel Hei \n1 \nA. \nNot \nyou know, let's break that down in a \n.us \n2 \ncouple pieces. \n414100 3 \nThe fact that his name is circled, if I were \n01 UN \n4 running an FBI investigation, I'd go send somebody to \na u io 5 \nsee what he knew about it, but no, it would take a lot \nOIL If \n6 more for me to become suspicious that somebody is \nel fit \n7 \ninvolved in — in sexual activity like that. \nMP IS 8 \nO. \nOkay. So you would agree with me then, that \n01162. 9 \nthe fact that a person often visited the mansion, the \nin saw 10 \nperson -- the fact that a person was a friend of \n• sari 11 \nMr. Epstein for 15 years, the fact that the person had \nol is 3? 12 \nstated publicly that: 'Mr. Epstein liked young women \n0114 Nf 13 \nalmost as much as I do myself,' and the fact that the \n1111.40 14 \nname is circled in the address book is not sufficient to \n• pin 15 \nraise a suspicion that that person engaged in sexual \nnue 16 \nmisconduct? \n01340 17 \nA. \nSo... \nHues 18 \nO. \nYes or no. It's a yes or no question. \n• swi 19 \nA. It requires — \nems: 20 \nMR. SCAROLA: You're not required to answer \n01 Sig 21 \nyes or no, if a yes or no response alone would be \nm son 22 \nmisleading. \nes sate 23 \nTHE WITNESS: The problem is the word \nm can 24 \n-suspicion' I'm not particularly suspicious on \n*ism 25 \nthose facts, but it -- you know, what do you mean \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-4400 \n250 \nnun I \nand energy In that, right. \n020112 2 \nQ. \nAnd you referred to your pro bono case. What \n020216 3 is your best estimate of how much money you have made \n021021 4 \nrepresenting victims of Jeffrey Epstein? \nnoon 5 \nA. In which case are we talking about now? \n0202 24 \n6 \na My -- any case representing a victim of \newe 20 7 \nJeffrey Epstein. \nWON \n8 \nA. \nI need to confer with \n010U \n9 \nMS. McCAWLEY: Yeah. I'm going to object. \n(awn 10 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \n4/0034 11 \nQ. \nAnd that -- that's a fact -- that's not a \nmoon 12 \nprivileged question. That's a factual question. \n021037 13 \nA. \nFactual. Well, there ar\n... [truncated, 5282 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/108 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=108]", "char_count": 5282}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 109, "text_content": "252 \n254 \nan 1. 1 \nTHE VIDEOGRAPHER: 10:38. \nsans, 1 \ncounsel of record in three cases and you were involved \nran u 2 \n(Thereupon, a recess was taken.) \nnun 2 in another case -- at least one other case in which you \nnu to 3 \nTHE VIDEOGRAPHER: We are back on the video \nnuns 3 \ndid not appear --\ncis 42 4 \nrecord, 10:49 a.m. \nnun 4 \nA. That's right. \n02100 5 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nit,.,. 5 \nQ. -- as counsel of record; is that correct? \nw,... 6 \nan a 7 \nQ. \nBack on the record. My question, \nMr. Cassell, was: What is your best estimate of how \n021900 6 \n*risco 7 \nA. \nThat's — that's my recollection right now, \nyeah. \nwine 8 \nmuch money you have made representing victims of Jeffrey \n021003 8 \nQ. \nAll right. How many of those cases have been \n023131 9 \nEpstein? \nnum 9 \nresolved at this point? \nomen 10 \nA. In which case are we talking about? \nsilos 10 \nA. All. All — of the four, I recall all four \n02/66. 11 \nQ. In -- in any case. Combined total. \nnun 11 have been resolved. \n02'1101 12 \nA. Okay. With regard to the CVRA case, that's \n021101 12 \nQ. Okay. Without telling me the amount, did you \n02170. 13 \npro bono, no money there. With regard to the other \n02 /t 12 13 \nreceive -- all four were settled; Is that right? \nst OW 14 \ncases, I'd like to answer your question, but due to \nsits 14 \nA. Correct. \n02 7710 15 confidentiality obligations that have been imposed upon em's 15 \nQ. Without telling me the amount, Is It correct \n021713 16 \nme by Jeffrey Epstein, in the course of negotiating \n021031 16 \nthat in all four of those cases, you received a legal \nto out 17 \nthose cases, I'm not permitted to answer that question. \n021227 17 \nfee? \ns,,.,, 18 \nMR. SCAROLA: We are certainly willing to \n4202s 18 \nA. I think that starts to call for a question I \net on 19 \nrespond appropriately to a court order in that \n020331 19 need to consult with my attorney about. \nnon 20 \nregard, but it requires a court order to release \n021030 20 \nQ. Simply the question of whether in each of \n0217 20 21 \nus fro\n... [truncated, 5007 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/109 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=109]", "char_count": 5007}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 110, "text_content": "022035 \n1 \n256 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \n022030 \n2 \nQ. \nI'm -- I'm trying to close a loop here. \n022040 \n3 \nA. \nYeah. \n=2040 4 \nQ. \nI'm asking whether you were involved in any \n02204 \n5 \nother cases in which claims have been made against \n022047\n6 \nJeffrey Epstein for damages that are still active; they \n122032 \n7 \nhave not been resolved? \n022013 8 \nA. \nSo we are talking civil cases, unresolved \n02010 9 civil cases against Jeffrey Epstein right now? \nerne 10 \n02102 11 \nten= 12 \n02,53 13 \nmice 14 \n022104 15 \nV12101 16 \n0202 22 17 \n0211 4 18 \nmills 19 \n0221 4 20 \n02 >In 21 \nOW 20 22 \n=:1 21 23 \n021121 24 \n072121 25 \nQ. \nUnresolved cases seeking money from Jeffrey \nEpstein. \nMR. SCAROLA: And to the extent that that \nquestion calls for matters that are of public \nrecord, then, obviously, you can respond. \nTHE WITNESS: Right. Yeah. None. \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nQ. \nAre there -- and I'm not asking for the name. \nAre there any not of public record that --\nA. \nWhat would be a \"not\"? \nQ. \nWell, if you had made a claim that's riot In \nsuit, for example. \nA. \nOh, against Jeffrey Epstein? \nQ. \nYes. \nA. \nYeah. No, I don't -- I don't think there's \nanything. Yeah, no — no claims against Epstein, right \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 3314400 \nrano 1 \n022244 \n2 \n022140 3 \n*onto 4 \n02 2213 5 \ncm.. 6 \n012301 7 \n022301 8 \nante 9 \n258 \nA. \nYeah. That hasn't been something that I have \nfocused on, no. I mean... \nQ. It is \nit is correct, is it not, that you \nanticipate that if you are successful in setting aside \nthe nonprosecution agreement that the names of \nadditional victims will become known; didn't you testify \nto that yesterday? \nA. \ni - I'm not — I must be confused here. \ndon't remember. \ntenor 10 \nO. \nWell, wait -- I don't want to -- you know, \n012301 11 let me ask the question -- \nants 12 \nA. \nYeah. \ncon* 13 \nQ. -- rather than my recollection. \nNew 14 \nA. \nYeah, yeah. That's what I'm not... \nown 15 \nQ. \nMy question is: Do you anticipate that if \nrants 16 \nyou're successful in setting as\n... [truncated, 5546 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/110 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=110]", "char_count": 5546}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 111, "text_content": "C8 75 SO \n1 \n02240 \n2 \n022852 \n3 \neau 4 \nnag 5 \n623416 6 \nmax 7 \n07708 \n8 \n022303 9 \n012505 10 \nnave 11 \nten, 12 \n07810 13 \nors .4 14 \n0285 0 15 \nnen 16 \ncenn 17 \n022521 18 \nRoo 19 \n022525 20 \n12260 21 \n022634 22 \ns7tn 3/ 23 \n02 24 52 24 \n012644 25 \nA. \nQ. \nA. \nQ. \n260 \nYes. \nIn all four, you met with the clients? \nIn three of the four. \nAnd were those three the three in which you \nwere counsel of record? \nA. \nYes. \nQ. \nAs of December --\nA. \nI believe I was counsel of record on all \nthree of those. I would have to double-check. I know I \nwas counsel of record in the federal case. The two of \nthem are state casts, I believe, that it was pro hac in \nthe state cases. \nQ. \nOkay. I won't ask you the names, but In the \nfour cases, what are the Initials of your clients? \nA. \nOkay. So the — the --\nQ. \nPut It this way: How are they identified in \nthe caption that you filed? \nA. \nWell, also the three that were filed, one \nwas — one was the initials S.R. I referred to \nMiss S.R. yesterday. That was the Jane Doe case in \nFederal Court in front of Judge Marra. \nThere were two state claims. I'll --\nidentify the clients as E.W. and L.M. \nQ. \nAnd then the fourth one? \nA. \nThe fourth one, I believe \nthe initial M. \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-4400 \n262 \noar. 1 \nfiring on December 30th d 2014, was the first time that \nearn 2 \nyou had ever, yes, ever on behalf \noar it 3 \nany other client, accused Professor \nr \nz or \n017725 4 \nPrince Andrew of sexual abuse in a public filing? \nears 5 \nA. If you're talking about direct allegation, \nsi 6 \nthat's correct. \n• \n31 \n7 \nQ. \nHad you ever pudic -- well, at no other time \n0227 26 8 \nthat -- you expected when you filed the pleating on \nono 9 \nDecember 30th, 2014, that it would be -- be something of \nan* 10 \npublic record that would generate publicity, correct? \norna 11 \nA. \nPublic record, the focus was not generating \ntenni 12 \npublicity. Of course, when you file an allegation like \nW2714 13 that, there certainly would have been — we \n... [truncated, 5636 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/111 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=111]", "char_count": 5636}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 112, "text_content": "02161 1 \n2914 \n2 \n02 39 67 \n3 \n0230021 4 \n021002 \n023004 6 \nawe? 7 \nawls 8 \n02 3039 \n9 \n01102$ 10 \naxis 11 \n023022 12 \n0032 13 \nsnow 14 \n31300 15 \n02300 16 \n023043 17 \n03041 16 \nmoo 19 \n03 3030 20 \n•230,1 21 \ncaw 03 22 \n023.04 23 \n02 3107 24 \n02 3„2 25 \n264 \nthat if you're in the presence of a convicted sex \noffender, or a sex offender and sex abuse is going on, \nyou would have obligations, for example, at a minimum to \nreport that, and it raises the possibility of other \ncriminal activity as well. \nQ. \nIs it your testimony, Mr. Cassell, that \ntelling a person that multiple people have identified \nyou as a witness to some activity is fair notice that \nyou, yourself, are acoised of engaging in criminal \nmisconduct? \nA. \nSo -- so you, I think, recharacterized the \nletter that went to Mr. Dershowitz in 2011. The letter, \nas I recall, doesn't say he is a witness. It says, if I \nrecall -- we can double-check the language — but I \nbelieve the language says: Numerous witnesses have \nplaced you In the presence of Jeffrey Epstein, underaged \ngirls, and Epstein. Then, you know, so at that point, \ngiven what we know in this case, given that at that \npoint in 2011, there had been an ongoing set of \nallegations against Mr. Epstein, I - I think your \nquestion doesn't — doesn't take into account this \nsurrounding context. \nNot to mention the fact there had been a 2009 \ndeposition request and a 2013 document request. \nQ. \nOkay. I think you accurately characterized \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331.4400 \n02 3203 \n1 \nova \n2 \n02310 \n3 \n021204 4 \nax„ \n5 \n023112 6 \n*13113 7 \nCs'. \n8 \nO13O \n9 \n021223 10 \nDrum 11 \n266 \nMR. SIMPSON: I'm sorry. You were right, \nyes. \nMR. SCAROLA: Can you Just Mow it to him? \nMR. SIMPSON: \nread it, and then if he \nwants to look at it, that will be fine. \nMR. SCAROLA: Thank you. \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nQ. \nThis is a letter from Mr. Scarola to \nMr. Dershowltz dated August 23rd, 2011. The second \nsentence says -- well, I'm going to read the whole \nthing. \n0232\n... [truncated, 5174 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/112 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=112]", "char_count": 5174}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 113, "text_content": "cams \n1 \nmass 2 \nnum 3 \n021311 4 \nMA 01 5 \n013401 6 \nmum \n7 \n02 34 04 \n8 \n013400 \n9 \n*02 03 10 \n268 \nbelieve, please provide me with any such reason. \nI am certain I can demonstrate to you that it Is \nfalse.' \nIs that consistent with your recollection of \nthe response? \nA. \nThat sounds about right, yeah. \nQ. \nSo Mr. Dershowitz did not ignore the letter; \nhe responded to it, correct? \nA. \nI think that's right \nQ. \nAnd go back to the first letter. \n023410 11 \nA. But, now, if we are — If we're talking \n0234 11 12 \nabout — yeah, there's that one letter and now there's a \ncoin 13 \nresponse letter, right. \ntax 14 14 \nQ. \nMy question to you Is: Does the statement to \n02 14 /I 15 \na person that \"we have reason tO believe that you have \non. 70 16 \npersonally observed another person In the presence of \nmm m 17 \nunderage females and we would like to ask you about your \nnu 36 18 \nobservations,\" put the recipient on notice that you, \nan 41 19 \nyourself, are accused of criminal conduct in abusing \nLem is 20 \nminors? \n023446 21 \nA. \nWell, it puts you on notice that you're a \n0234 49 22 \npotential, obviously, witness to this and then therefore \n0234» 23 \nyou could have potential Involvement. \nri ms 24 \nLet me give you a ample illustration. It'll \n0134n 25 \ntake about 20 seconds. If somebody says —\nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331.4400 \n*3636 \nman, \n023611\ncesso \nensin \n013142 \n07350 \n023151 \n012354 \n10 3357 10 \n02 33711 \n011310 12 \n623402 13 \ncaw. 14 \ncosto 15 \ncomer 16 \non. iz 17 \nonsu 18 \n02x%19 \ninn la 20 \nomen 21 \n011621 22 \nnsi 23 \n013133 24 \n011633 25 \n270 \n1 \nIn the context of this case, to say, you have \n2 \nbeen observed in the -- in -- by numerous \n3 \nwitnesses in the presence of a convicted sex \n4 \noffender and underage girls, and we would like to \n5 \ntalk to you about those observations, I think \n6 \nthat puts you on notice that you're in -- In --\n7 \nin jeopardy of -- of criminal activity, \n8 \nparticularly when you combine that with the fact \n9 \nthat there Is a dut\n... [truncated, 5546 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/113 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=113]", "char_count": 5546}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 114, "text_content": "272 \nCZ 37 40 \n1 \nA. \nI think it puts you on notice in the context \nea 370 \n2 \nof a country which has required people to report the \nC2 n4, \n3 \nsexual abuse of children, and somebody wants to talk to \n07370 4 \nyou about your observations of a convicted sex offender \nOW C2 \n5 \nwith underage girls, that that's going to be one of the \nsubjects that's going to be discussed, yes. \nQ. \nMy question was -- my Initial question was: \nDoes -- do the statements in this letter put the reader \non notice that you, personally, are accused of abusing \noraii. 10 \nminors yourself, not that you have In some knowledge or \n0224 0 11 \nevidence that someone else did it, but that you, \n022 \n12 \nyourself, did it; Is that a way to give fair notice? \n°nem 13 \nA. \nWell, in fair notice in what context? You \nGin \n14 \nknow, is he on notice that a lawsuit is going to be \n02,1 3' 15 \nfiled the next day? \n023832 16 \nSimply from that piece of -- that letter \n:emu 17 \nalone, they are on notice, you know \nI mean, I think \nCO MP 18 \nthat puts you on notice that there are serious \nea a 4! 19 \nallegations afoot and it would be in your best interest \n02 MO 20 \nif you hadn't done anything, to show up, attend a \nCC Ma, 21 \ndeposition, let all the facts come out so that everybody \n02 3.0 22 \ncan know them. \nCOM./ 23 \nQ. \nWould you agree that accusing someone of \n02 ao 5. 24 \nthemselves abusing a minor is different than accusing \nCC CO 0) 25 \nsomeone of having knowledge that somebody else did it? \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954)331-4400 \nOW Ca \n6 \nOl 31 It \n7 \n3.01 8 \n07,40; 9 \n274 \n024003 \n1 \nhis criminal associates were doing. And he thought that \n024005 \n2 \nMr. Dershowitz would have information and was trying to \n02401 3 \ncollect that. \n4 \nNow, whether the — the -- the tentades of \n024010 \n5 \nthe organization would extend so that they wrapped \n04043 6 \naround Mr. Dershowitz himself, I guess was the subject \nOrate 7 \nthat — that Mr. Scarola, I am assuming, was hoping to \nNNW 8 \nexplore. But Mr. Dershowitz\n... [truncated, 5821 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/114 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=114]", "char_count": 5821}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 115, "text_content": "024220 \n1 \n02 4223 \n2 \n024226 \n3 \nnen 4 \noxen 5 \n014132 \n6 \n024236 7 \n02463? 8 \n276 \nDoes that letter put Mr. Dershowitz on fair \nnotice that he's accused of being a sex offender \nhimself? \nMR. SCAROLA: Objection. Repetitious. To \nthe extent that you can improve upon the answer, \nyou can improve upon the answer. If you can't, \nall you need to do Is say that. \nTHE WITNESS: I -- and I'll try to --\n02e» 9 \nobviously, I want to be responsive --\nten 10 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \n0261.34 11 \nO. Let -- let me ask --\nmoo 12 \nA. -- to your question. \ntaun 13 \nQ. I'll ask you a different question. \nitt2 .1 14 \nA. \nI don't think that's a yes or no question \nnun 15 \nbecause of -- of you're including vague terms like fair \n024245 16 \nnotice and \nand those sorts of things. So -- but go \nrear, 17 \nahead and ask your questions and I'll — I mean, go \n02420 18 \nahead. \n024201 19 \nQ. \nYou're a former federal Judge? \n024255 20 \nA. \nRight. \nman 21 \nQ. \nA former Supreme Court law -- law clerk? \nray Si 22 \nA. \nYes. \ncross 23 \nQ. \nProfessor at a law school? \nono 24 \nA. \nYes. \n024201 25 \nQ. \nReading as -- reading the language of this \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331.4400 \n024417 \n1 \ncan 2 \n024454 \n3 \n424452 4 \n024444 5 \n04446 6 \n014504 7 \n014504 8 \nozesil 9 \nonso 10 \n04512 11 \noats 12 \n02 4525 13 \n024124 14 \n0246» 15 \n024524 16 \nma= 17 \n0245 0 18 \n0245» 19 \n4,.s 1. 20 \nC26530 21 \n024532 22 \nens» 23 \n024542 24 \n045 45 25 \n278 \nhaving abused minors? Can you answer that: Yes or no? \nA. \nNo. I think a yes-or-no answer would be \nmisleading, given the context of this case. \nQ. \nYou referred in your earlier testimony to --\nstrike that for a moment. \nYou referred in your earlier testimony to an \narticle that appeared today regarding \nProfessor Dershowitz's deposition testimony, correct? \nA. \nI don't think so. \nO. \nOkay. Are you aware that -- well, perhaps It \nwas Miss McCawley who referred to it. \nDo you recall there being a reference this \nmorning to an article being published about \nProfessor Ders\n... [truncated, 5239 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/115 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=115]", "char_count": 5239}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 116, "text_content": "02.4 40 \n024443 \n074646 \n01450 \n026654 \nDDSS \n024010 \n02 46 64 \nozstm \n9 \n024702 10 \n024703 11 \n*zoo 12 \nCOD 13 \n0247:03 14 \n01007 15 \n02 47 • \n16 \n02x42 17 \n024,14 18 \n024720 19 \n024723 20 \n02 47 24 21 \n0247.7. 22 \n0247 30 23 \nCI:t 47 37 24 \n024730 25 \n2 \n3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n280 \nsettlement discussions, Mr. Boles will not, at \nleast at this time, describe what was actually \nsaid. However, Mr. Boles does state that \nMr. Dershowitz's description of what was said Is \nnot true.\" \nA. \nQ. \nA. \nThat's the one. \nYou read that? \nYeah. I -- I learned of it -- yeah, I don't \nremember whether I read or how I got it, but yeah, \nthat's the one. \nQ. \nIn light of that statement by Mr. Boles, \nwould you agree that any privilege has been waived? \nA. \nI would not. \nQ. \nA. \nThat's -- that's a newspaper article. \nQ. \nIt's a pub -- it's a quote. Let me clarity. \nThat's a statement -- quoting a statement issued by \nMs. McCawley and quoting Mr. Boles as saying, \nMr. Dershowitz's description of what was said is not \ntrue, so that's a public statement by Mr. Boles saying \nthat Mr. Dershowitz's testimony is not true; is that a \nwaiver in your view? \nA. \nNo. And that would require — I'm with --\nI'm just putting you on notice, talking about notice, if \nyou want me to, I could give you the law professor \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-4400 \n282 \n02413 \n1 \nMR. SCAROLA: Why don't you start over again? \nAt om \n2 \nMR. SIMPSON: No. I Just want --\n02 40 \n3 \nMS. McCAWLEY: We disagree with \nwale \n4 \nyour characterization of that as a waiver. It \n074410 \n5 \nwas a statement that was issued in order to stop \n424612 \n6 \nthe waivers that Mr. Dershowitz was trying to \n074:1 \n7 \nengage in, and we -- we don't agree that's a \n61026 \n8 \nwaiver and we will not allow any testimony \n014617 \n9 \nregarding those communications. \n014424 10 \nMR. SIMPSON: Okay. I disagree with the \nervi3, 11 \nposition and the characterization, but I just \n02.443) 12 \nwanted to clarify on the record, I didn't have to \nnun 13 \nask t\n... [truncated, 5184 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/116 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=116]", "char_count": 5184}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 117, "text_content": "wan 1 \nwan 2 \n024016 3 \n0244.10 4 \n01500 5 \n025002 6 \nW IOU 7 \nCMOS 8 \nmoor 9 \nnu \n10 \n025020 11 \n075024 12 \nco son 13 \ncoin 14 \n025031 15 \na2103. 16 \n025035 17 \nmeow 18 \n05041 19 \n021045 20 \n02 50 \n21 \nrireeo 22 \n025091 23 \n025044 24 \nsnow 25 \n284 \nI've read it correctly. \nA. \nOkay. \nQ. -Epstein also sexually trafficked the \nthen-minor Jane Doe\" -- and that' \ncorrect? \nA. \nYes. \nQ. -- \"making her available for sex to \npolitically-connected and financially-powerful people. \nEpstein's purposes in lending Jane Doe, along with other \nyoung girls, to such powerful people were to ingratiate \nhimself with them for business, personal, political, and \nfinancial gain, as well as to obtain potential blackmail \ninformation.\" \nDid I read that correctly? \nYou did. \nWhat did you mean by 'obtain potential \nA. \nQ. \nblackmail information'? \nA. \nOkay. Let me just double-check. \nOnce the criminal organization had put the \nbait out, so to speak, to various people, and they took \nthe bait that -- you know, I'm -- I'm speaking \ncolloquially here. These are \nthese are young girls \nwho are being sexually abused. Once the criminal \norganization had gotten people to sexually abuse \nthese \nthese young girls, at that point, they had \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-4400 \n285 \ninformation that they could use to blackmail those \npeople and -- and then get favors in exchange. \nAnd that's Epstein at the head of the \norganization would be the one who would benefit most \ndirectly from the black -- the blackmail information. \nQ. \nAnd by \"blackmail information,\" do you mean \nthat Mr. Epstein then had information that he could \nthreaten to disclose if the other person didn't do what \nEpstein asked them to do? \nA. \nPrecisely. \nQ. \nAs of December 30th, 2014, if Miss Roberts \nhad access to publicity, she had exactly the same \nability to blackmail people; Isn't that Due? \nA. \nAbsolutely not. A billionaire has far more \nresources than a victim of child sex abuse, particularly \none that has been forc\n... [truncated, 5547 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/117 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=117]", "char_count": 5547}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 118, "text_content": "288 \n290 \n023461 1 \nMR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. To the extent the \n321613 \n1 \nPrince Andrew had sexually abused \now o 2 \nquestion calls for speculation, I object. \nMK 11 2 \ncorrect? \nmuss 3 \noust 4 \nMR. SIMPSON: No. I'm asking for his state \nof mind when he filed this document. \n02x,3 3 \n026421 4 \nA. \nThat was one of the allegations in here, \nsure. \n0254M \n5 \nTHE WITNESS: There's no doubt that -- \n023331 5 \nQ. \nAnd the allegations that Professor Dershowltz \nsass w 6 \nMR. SCAROLA: So the question is: At the \nmen 6 \nhad sexually abuse? \n025501 7 \ntime of the filing -- \n0234 31 7 \nA. \nThat's right. It was in a — what we were —\ngerm 8 \nMR. SIMPSON: Please -- please don't coach \none n 8 \nwhat we were starting to document and allege here was \ngesso 9 \nthe witness. \n4266n 9 \nthat terrible things that Epstein's criminal \nasses 10 \nMR. SCAROLA: No, I'm not coaching him. I \n033630 10 \norganization had done. \narmor 11 \njust want to understand the question. You're \n026630 11 \nQ. \nLet me refer you to page 6 — \nnom 12 \nasking what his state of mind was at the time of \n02610 12 \nA. \nOkay. \nnow 13 \nfiling? \n0224 47 13 \nQ. -- of your filing. It's the first full \nosit. 14 \nMR. SIMPSON: Did he -- did he anticipate -- \nor son 14 \nparagraph. \nosso 15 \nMR. SCAROLA: Because the other question was: \n071644 15 \nA. \nYep. \nQM 11 16 \nWhat do you -- what's your position today. \nroma 16 \nQ. I'm going to read it. \"Epstein also \nens\" 17 \nMR. SIMPSON: Mr. Scarola, really. \n0236Si 17 \ntrafficked Jane Doe Number 3 for sexual purposes to many \nnn,. 18 \nMR. SCAROLA: That's -- that's a different \n02 SG S6 18 \nother powerful men.\" \nawls 19 \nquestion. So I just want to know which one \nivory 19 \nA. \nOkay. \nens\" 20 \nyou're asking. \nor Hp 20 \nQ. \n\"Including numerous prominent American \nau.. 21 \naim, 22 \nDo you want to know his state of mind then, \nor his state of mind today? \n023700 21 \n02 tie 22 \npoliticians, powerful business executives, foreign \npresidents, a well-known prime minister, and other world \nwoo 23\n... [truncated, 4807 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/118 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=118]", "char_count": 4807}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 119, "text_content": "292 \n794 \n023816 \n1 \nQ. \nOkay. You felt that it furthered her legal \nMN 30 \n2 \ninterests to specify American politicians, powerful \nnu xi \n3 \nbusiness executives, foreign presidents, a well-known \nm%a \n4 \nprime minister and other world leaders; that was your --\nersi 0 \n5 \nyou — you believe that furthered her legal Interest? \n026841 6 \nA. \nYes. \nduo \n7 \nQ. \nOld you also anticipate that that would \ntown 8 \ntitillate the PreSS, so to speak, that there would be a \neau 9 \nlot of speculation on who these people are? \n023852 10 \nA. \nThat wasn't the — that wasn't the focus \nsus. 11 \nof the — those comments, no. \nnu \n12 \nO. \nYou said it wasn't the focus. Did you \n07%37 13 \nrealize it would happen? \nsun \n14 \nA. \nSure. I mean, this was a case that had \nmum 15 \nbeen already — this litigation \nhad been going on at \nova: 16 \nthat point for seven years and lots of people were \nresew 17 \nfollowing IL This is — this case is one of the most \nwoo 18 \negregious examples of a violation of Crime Victims' \ntossu 19 \nRights in the history of this country. \n4050%3 20 \nAnd so against that context, yes, there were \nCOW% 21 \ngoing to be people interested in every word that was \n0760111 22 \ngoing Into this pleading. Whether we had gone more \n025410 23 \nbroadly or more narrowly than what we did, people were \n0750/3 24 \ngoing to be interested in this. \none n 25 \nQ. \nAnd as of December 30th of 2014, Miss Roberts \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-4400 \n010431 1 \n010432 \n2 \nwain 3 \n03031 4 \n03%37 5 \n030437 6 \n030633 7 \nCO C633 8 \n03.1601 9 \n010111 10 \nores 11 \nmesa 12 \nwens 13 \nmesa 14 \nno. 15 \nmesa 16 \nwoo 17 \nwon.? 18 \nGin 19 \nCOOS MI 20 \n030103 21 \n030302 22 \nroses 23 \nwoos 24 \n030308 25 \nbreak. I appreciate that. \nQ. \nOkay. \nMR. SCAROLA: Could you just read back the \nlast question for me? I just want to orient \nmyself as to where we are. Thank you. \n(Thereupon, a portion of the record vas read \nby the reporter.) \nMR. SCAROLA: Yeah, I didn't I think the \nanswer was --\nTHE WITNESS: I guess \n... [truncated, 5666 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/119 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=119]", "char_count": 5666}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 120, "text_content": "296 \n298 \nnor is \n1 \nbut, obviously, Epstein and his criminal associates have \non \n1 \nintended to be a direct quote? \n11101/0 \n2 \nhad the ability to — to destroy the evidence that's \n00034 2 \nMR. SIMPSON: Back up. \n010721 3 \nbeen — that we have been trying to gather. \nnu \n3 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \n010711 4 \nQ. \nAnd in -- in your answer a couple of \nnom 4 \nQ. \nWhat is your understanding of Judge Marra's \nown 5 \nquestions -- \n031041 5 \nruling with respect to these allegations about Professor \nnon 6 \nA. \nI - I'm sorry. I shouldn't say \"destroyed.\" \n01144. 6 \nDershowitz and Prince Andrew? \nrun \n7 \nThey have been able to conceal would probably be a more \n0)0344 7 \nA. \nThat they were premature. \n03 0/ 30 \n8 \naccurate term, the — the evidence that we are trying to \nmins 8 \nQ. \nThat's your understanding of his order? \n030733 9 \ngather. \nonoa 9 \nA. \nYes. \n030733 10 \nQ. In my answer -- in my answer -- \nmono 10 \nQ. \nOkay. \nwen, 11 \nA. \nYeah. \nanew 11 \nA. \nAnd I — maybe I should — I see some \n030733 12 \nQ. \n-- in the question and answer, your answer to \nmod 12 \nskepticism there, so let me explain why I think those \n030131 13 \nmy question a couple ofquestions \no \nou talked about \n03100) 13 \nallegations —\n03 07 0 14 \nwhether Mr. Epstein a \nhave the \n03 100. 14 \nQ. \nYeah. Well, we can pull --\nworm 15 \nsame or equal ability to disc ose -- \n031001 15 \nA. -- are appropriate. \nwane 16 \nA. \nRight. \n011001 16 \nQ. -- we will pull out the order itself --\nwen, 17 \nQ. -- what these prominent politicians, \n031.01 17 \nA. \nSure. \n03010 18 \net cetera, had done, correct? \non 18 \nQ. -- at the appropriate time, but first, your \nono 34 19 \nA. \nCorrect. \nea loos 19 \nunderstanding Is that the Judge didn't find that those \n03 OSS 20 \nnoir 21 \na \nWithout attempting to make any comparison, \nyou would agree, would you not, that as of December \n03 low 20 \n031013 21 \nallegations, at the time they were made, were so \nirrelevant to the case, that they should be stricken \n030401 22 \n30th, 2014, Miss Roberts had the\n... [truncated, 5202 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/120 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=120]", "char_count": 5202}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 121, "text_content": "300 \n302 \n021120 \n1 \nAnd rather than say, My, we don't have any \n031341 1 \nthe United States Attorney for the Southern District of \nsally \n2 \nsuch documents, the U.S. Attorney's Office gave us the \nOen 46 \n2 \nFlorida to represent victims, correct? \nrens \n3 \nresponse indicating, to our view, that there were such \n0)1344 \n3 \nA. \nYes. Through the — through the NPA, yeah, \n031122 \n4 \ndocuments, and as you know, since you're one of \nuntil \n4 \nthere was an apparatus that led to his selection. \n011124 \n5 \nMr. Dershowitz's attorneys, we have drafted a pleading \n0113S4 \n5 \nQ. \nAnd does that answer reflect holding the U.S. \nnun \n6 \nnow to try and collect that information, that law \n031401 \n6 \nAttorney for the Southern District of Florida in that \nGall a \n7 \nenforce — federal law enforcement agencies have \nNum \n7 \noffice in high regard? \nGan,. \n8 \ncollected, and — and to figure out the appropriate way \n031404 \n8 \nA. \nSure. \n031142 \n9 \nto litigate that so that we can get that information and \n031401 \n9 \nQ. \nDo you contend that at the time the United \n011144 10 \nmove forward with the case. \n011411 10 \nStates Attorney for the Southern District of Honda \n031116 11 \nThat's just one example of -- of how the \nrotor 11 negotiated the NPA, they knew that Professor Dershowitz, \nor Jr,. 12 \nallegations, if they were premature at that point, are \n031420 12 \nhimself, had been involved in abuse of minors? \niniru 13 \nno longer going to be premature as the case moves along. \n0314n 13 \nA. \nI don't know exactly what Information they \nown 14 \nQ. \nIs It or is it not your understanding that \n031427 14 \nhad. I do know that we have been propounding discovery \n031201 15 \nJudge Marra ruled that the allegations in this pleading \nroux 15 \nrequests on all of these subjects, including \n011204 16 \nin front of you were so irrelevant to the pleading in \n., ,.n \n16 \nProfessor \nDershowitz's involvement, when the U.S. \n03, 04 17 \nwhich they were stated, that they should be stricken \n031435 17 \nAttorney knew. Th\n... [truncated, 5967 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/121 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=121]", "char_count": 5967}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 122, "text_content": "304 \nenteco \n1 \nI don't know. \n03 140 \n2 \nQ. \nAnd what they did with the fact that Courtney \n03 1404 \n3 \nLove and Donald Trump were circled, you don't know also, \n03 403 4 \ncorrect? \no tea \n5 \nA. \nThat's right. Fair point. \n01 'sw \n6 \nQ. \nBut somehow It's suspicious as to \none to \n7 \nMr. Dershowitz, but not as to anyone else? \nOa lea \n8 \nMR. SCAROLA: Objection. Argumentative. \nco xi, 9 \nTHE WITNESS: And I'm -- I'm glad to argue on \nOlt , 4 10 \nthat point, let me, because they --\nCl lc '4 11 \nMR. SIMPSON: I'll withdraw the question. \nman 12 \nTHE WITNESS: All right. Because I would \n(*tea 13 \nhave a --\noleic 14 \nMR. SIMPSON: Let \nOatc$: 15 \nTHE WITNESS: -- a substantial argument on \nmare 16 \nthat. \nOmni() 17 \nMR. SIMPSON: I -- I will withdraw the \nwar, 18 \nquestion. \n03 16 n 19 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \n01%24 20 \nQ. \nWith respect, again, to the \n$6 le 21 \nMR. SCAROLA: And I'll withdraw the \nOr. 12 22 \nobjection. \n03 16)2 23 \nMR. SIMPSON: Thank you. \n03 1.1.3 24 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nwas 25 \nQ. \nAt the time that you filed this joinder \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-4400 \n306 \n03 I/ 50 \n1 \ncertainly believe I have a good-faith basis, along with \nnay \n2 \nmy co-counsel, to explore that subject, and try to see \noi leo 3 \nhow someone who is fifth in line to the British Throne \n03 IOW 4 \nmight have been able to use the contacts and power that \nroam 5 \nhe has to influence a -- a -- a disposition in this --\nes nis 6 \nin the Crime Victims' Rights Act case that it would have \nawe 7 \nbeen favorable to one of his friends and potentially \ncolon 8 \nfavorable to himself. \nmen 9 \nQ. \nAnd -- and you have that view, \nmesa 10 \nnotwithstandng that the government had represented they \nnon 11 \nhave no record of that? \nwino 12\nA. \nThey didn't -- no, no, no, no. Let's not — \nnun 13 \nnot -- let's not slip and try to get me to admit \nnee 14 \nsomething that is not what the record reflects. The \ntattle 15 \ngovernment said they did not have documents. They did \nSI WO 16 \nnot say that they didn't hav\n... [truncated, 5556 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/122 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=122]", "char_count": 5556}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 123, "text_content": "032001 \n1 \n0330 04 \n2 \n037005 \n3 \n032000 4 \n033009 \n5 \n01x40 6 \n03x14 7 \n%V% \n8 \n02x72 \n9 \nmoat 10 \n0320/7 11 \n012077 12 \nman 13 \n03x30 14 \n012030 IS \n032034 16 \nnal 17 \n03 2031 18 \n031041 19 \n032041 20 \n032043 21 \n032041 22 \n032003 23 \n03104 24 \n0320% 25 \n308 \nhave gone about trying to — to put pressure for a — a \nfavorable plea deal. \nQ. \nAnd that's what you Just referred to as \nspeculation, correct? \nA. Well, your question said: Well, how would \nthey go do this? And I -- I -- I gave you my answer as \nto how I think somebody could well do that, yes. \nQ. And -- and your pleading doesn't allege how \nsomeone would do it; it alleges that they did it; isn't \nthat correct? \nA. Did what? \nQ. Let me -- let me rephrase it. \nA. No. I - I - the — \nQ. \nI -- I withdraw the question. \nA. Yeah. \nQ. \nWe only have about ten minutes here. There \nare a couple of things that I --\nA. Sure. Absolutely. \nQ. -- wanted to get before we -- we will come \nback to these when we resume. We have a lot more \nquestions. \nA. Great. I look forward to it. \nMR. SIMPSON: I'm going to ask the reporter \nto mark as Exhibit -- what are we up to -- 6, \nExhibit 6, a document bearing Bates stamp numbers \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331.4400 \n00222' 1 \ntritit 2 \n032200 3 \n0372 35 \n4 \n01%35 \n5 \n037242 \n6 \n037245 7 \n03724/ \n8 \n032251 \n9 \n032260 10 \n03 2204 11 \nay.. 12 \ncarte 13 \n01 2302 14 \n032303 15 \nware. 16 \non% 17 \n032304 18 \nonto 19 \n031110 20 \n03%01 21 \n11) 23 01 22 \n0321n 23 \n032325 24 \n032320  25 \n310 \nknow — I can't recall sitting here today whether \nNightline, is that an ABC program or NBC or -- or some \nother network \nQ. If you look at the exhibit, the e-mail in the \nsecond -- the bottom half of the first page, it has her \ne-mail address. Does that -- eabc.com? \nA. \nYeah, yeah, yeah. That's good. Thank you. \nQ. \nSo ABC. So in this e-mail on January 4th of \n2015, you told Miss Jesko of CBS News (sic] that --\nMS. McCAWLEY: ABC. I'm sorry. You said \nCBS. \nMR. SIMPSON: I'm sorry. \nTHE WITNESS: Th\n... [truncated, 5030 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/123 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=123]", "char_count": 5030}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 124, "text_content": "312 \n314 \n032427 \n1 \nTHE WITNESS: Well -- well, who — I'm sorry. \n032007 \n1 \nMR. SIMPSON: Okay. I --\nonto 2 \nWho was that? The speaker? I want to know who \nono 2 \nTHE COURT REPORTER: I can't hear. \n032432 \n3 \nis on the line here. Could somebody identify \n032102 \n3 \nMR. SIMPSON: I heard It and IT -- 11i \nCO 204 4 \nthemselves, please? \nono 4 \nrepeat it. \n032434 \n5 \nIf somebody is eavesdropping in my \nono 5 \nMR. SCAROLA: 'It was me who said IL' \n02.32 6 \ndeposition, I would like to know who it is. \n032646 6 \nMR. SIMPSON: \"And I thought my mute \n032440 7 \nMR. SIMPSON: No one has the call-in number \noin \n7 \nbutton\" -4 \n032447 \n8 \nother than counsel and parties. \n032440 8 \nMR. SCAROLA: \"I thought my\" --\n032.44 \n9 \nTHE WITNESS: So -- \n032303 9 \nMR. SIMPSON: -- \"was on.\" \n03)445 10 \nMR. SIMPSON: To my knowledge. \nores 10 \nMR. SCAROLA: -- \"mute button was on.\" \n030146 11 \nMR. SCAROLA: Yeah, but that -- \non 11 \nAnd that was Mr. Dershowitz making that \n0324144 12 \nTHE WITNESS: But who is that person? \n032409 12 \ncomment? \n032447 13 \nMR. SCAROLA: -- that doesn't preclude \n03239 13 \nMR. SIMPSON: Yes, it was. \n032470 14 \nsomeone from sharing that call-in number. And \n03 AM 14 \nMR. SCAROLA: Okay. Thank you. \n032.10 15 \nit Is appropriate that anybody on the line \n012412 15 \nMR. DERSHOWITZ: I was trying to instruct my \nslog 16 \nidentify themselves. \n0171314 16 \nattorney. \nwoo 17 \nAnd if the people on the line refuse to \n0)2614 17 \nMR. SCAROLA: Then we are ready to move on. \n02101 18 \nIdentify themselves, then it's our intention to \nme .4 18 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \ncant. 19 \ncut off the line, and the people who are \non,. 19 \nQ. \nHave you told any -- all right. \n012407 20 \nauthorized to be on the line can call back in. \ncnn 20 \nPutting aside counsel who are working with \n0339,e 21 \nMR. SCOTT: I agree with that. \n0)2629 21 \nyou, and putting aside those who you identified as being \nono 22 \nMR. SIMPSON: Could -- could the people on \n0)3632 22 \nwithin the common-Interest privilege — \nMI/2 23 \nt\n... [truncated, 5067 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/124 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=124]", "char_count": 5067}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 125, "text_content": "MIR \n1 \n03n. \n2 \n316 \nThere Is an intermediate category of \nbackground information as well, and I have spoken to \n03301? \n1 \non \n2 \n318 \nyour client, my client, or any Joint defense \ncommunications. You can't reveal that. \nono 3 \nsome reporters in that capacity, yes. \n01*74 3 \nTHE WITNESS: All right. So I'm going to \nrang 4 \nQ. \nAnd -- and -• and background means that it's \nawn 4 \nfollow that instruction and not answer. \ncanoe \n5 \nnot for attribution, correct? \nwan 5 \nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nCM i0 6 \nA. \nRight. The background means the reporter can \n03)44 6 \nQ. \nWith respect to the -- what's now still \nwan 7 \nuse the information, but shouldn't attribute it to a \nown 7 \nExhibit 2, the motion for limited Intervention --\non u 8 \nparticular person. \nwow 8 \nMR. SCAROLA: Let me lust observe for the \nCOX II 9 \nQ. \nAnd, in fact, you have -. \n03304 9 \nrecord that it's 12:02. I don't think we used \n032•10 10 \nA. \nOr let me -- let me just clarify. Some \n0,3101 10 \nthe three minutes that I said I was going to give \non,' 11 time — well, background, I think, you know, we are now \n0100 11 \nyou, but we will go to 12:03 anyway. \nonn 12 \ntalking about sort of — when I use the term \no,, 'o 12 \nMR. SIMPSON: This line of questioning will \nrow ;4 13 \n\"background,\" it would generally mean that this is \nrain, 13 \ntake a little -- a little time, so --\non n 14 \nran, 15 \nsomething maybe that you want to investigate and see if \nyou can confirm in other ways, but it shouldn't be \nOahu 14 \nmil. 15 \nMR. SCAROLA: Well, what's a \"lithe? Oh, \nso you •-\nwnu 16 \nsourced to — that I shouldn't be quoted directly \n03111S 16 \nMR. SIMPSON: five minutes. \nCONS 17 \nbecause they are going to have to find other — other \nNJ.* 17 \nMR. SCAROLA: So you prefer to wait then? \n0324.4) 18 \nsources that confirm that same information. \n033120 18 \nMR. SIMPSON: Let me ask -- I can ask you a \nan., 19 \nQ. \nOkay. And so my question is that it is true \n4)).22 19 \nfew questions here. \nono 20 \nthat you have spoken with a number of rep\n... [truncated, 5346 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/125 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=125]", "char_count": 5346}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 126, "text_content": "320 \n322 \n03 WV 1 \nQ. Let -- let me ask you a different question \n033434 1 \nvisiting? \n032243 \n2 \nthen. \n033414 2 \n\"Uh-huh. Answer. \n03 1343 \n3 \nA. Okay. \n033456 3 \n\"Question: How often did he come? \nno \n4 \nQ. By -- by submitting this brief with your name \n<flaw 4 \n\"Answer: He came pretty -- pretty often. I \n(01746 \n5 \nsigning it, you were representing that the factual \n033330 5 \nwould says as least four or five times a year.' \nm300 6 \nallegations, factual assertions, were support — are \noak. 6 \nAnd that's what Is cited as the support for \n03 pr.. 7 \nsupported by the record citations that are given for \n033.02 7 \nthe proposition --\nsputa \n8 \nthose, correct? \n033300 8 \nA. I'd -- I would like to look at the document. \ncorm 9 \nA. Yeah. I mean, obviously, when you write a \n0333 14 9 \nQ. I'm going to give you the document before I \nropot 10 brief, you're -- you're -- you know, you're trying to \n0333„ 10 \nask you to comment on it. \nono 11 represent that this is the best product I can come up \nOM 16 11 \nA. Sure. \n03304 12 \nwith. \non.. 12 \nQ. I will -- I will go beyond what was cited to \n031306 13 \nNow, you know, in a 40-page brief did -- \non it 13 \nthe court --\n03107 14 did — is there some, you know, error in citation or \n*34,4 14 \nA. Okay. \n031110 15 something like that? I have to -- I'm not perfect. I'm \n031314 15 \nQ. -- to put it in context. \n033317 16 sure that's a possibility, but, you know, I worked hard \n033320 16 \nA. But I mean, there's — this is a large — \nNun 17 to try to ut t \nether the best product that I could on \n013623 17 \nwell, that's what I'm saying. I would like -- my \n033322 18 \nbehalf o \nen I filed this brief. \n012324 18 \nrecollection is that there are number of parties to the \n012111 19 \nQ. \nn -- an n genera , when a lawyer signs a \n013521 19 \nAlessi depo --\nens 20 \nbrief, it's a representation to the court that the \n*rap 20 \nQ. No. My -- my only question is in this brief, \n0311711 21 citations to the record support the factual -- \n0)3511 21 the lawyer\n... [truncated, 4837 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/126 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=126]", "char_count": 4837}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 127, "text_content": "324 \n326 \n03,130 1 \ncouple of lines above it that do refer to Virginia \nnow 1 \nA. The lawyer — look, this is not the first \nCO 10311 \n2 \nRoberts, put it In the context \ncan 2 \ntime --\nwaist \n3 \nMy question is: Does that, fairly read, \nen \n3 \nQ. \nUrn not asking the 44\n0110/ \n4 \nconstitute testimony th•d \nProfessor \nmmari 4 \nA. -- a lawyer has cited the wrong line number \n03364 5 \nDershowitz were in the house at the same time? \n03 x11 5 \non a transcript or something, and if you're suggesting \nmaw \n6 \nA. Those three sentences, three lines. \nemu 6 \nthat — you know, I will concede that I cited the wrong \nmans 7 \nQ. \nWhat -- yes, what the brief cites. \nnun 7 \nline number for that particular assertion. \n011017 \n8 \nA. Those -- those three lines: \"Not sure. When \n03364 \n8 \nQ. \nAnd this is what I want to clarify: When you \n031703 \n9 \nMr. Dershowitz was visiting. Uh-huh. How often did he \n031143 \n9 \nsay the wrong line number, if you look at the quotation, \nnos 10 corner Those -- those three lines, I agree, that looks \n03,e.• 10 \nthere is, up above -- you cited 18 to 20 -- 22 to 25 .-\n033/10 11 like a miscitation there. I agree with you on that. \nowe 11 no, 18 to 20. I'm sorry. You cited 18 to 20 which is \n013714 12 \nQ. And isn't it true that -- first of all, \nmuse 12 -- do you see that? \nCO 3710 13 \nnothing else is cited in the brief or elsewhere to \nwiry 13 \nA. I do see 18 to 20, yes. \nCO 1722 14 \nsupport -- put -- put aside. \n033430 14 \nQ. And those lines don't refer to Virginia \nown 15 \nOther tha \nestimony, \n0330 Of 15 \nRoberts coming to the house, correct? \n03 1/743 16 \nthis is the only evide \ncourt to \n031102 16 \nA. Lines 18 to 20 do not refer to Virginia \n033/10 17 \nsupport -- \nCOM ICI 17 \nRoberts - oh, no, wait a minute. Now, this is --\n0137 31 18 \nA. \nNo, no, no, no, no. That would require a \n023/12 18 \nbecause when I look at it here, line 15: \n033734 19 \n30-minute answer. \nman 19 \ny recollection of V.R., \nmum 20 \nQ. Okay. I won't ask you a 30-minute answer -- \nCOM 20 \n... [truncated, 5214 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/127 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=127]", "char_count": 5214}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 128, "text_content": "328 \n330 \n034011 \n034020 2 \n01026 3 \n01402. 4 \n0022 \n5 \n04024 \n6 \n034021 7 \n010,1 \n8 \nright now. \nMR. SIMPSON: I've got --\nTHE VIDEOGRAPHER: Two minutes. \nMR. SIMPSON: Two minutes. All right. That \nwon't take --\nBY MR. SIMPSON: \nQ. I want you to look at the video of that --\nthat testimony. Would you play it, please, for the \n034013 9 \nwitness? This is from the videotape of the deposition. \n014016 10 \nTHE WITNESS: I do not want to watch Just 44\n0100 11 \nI want to watch -- what -- what I'm seeing here \n02100 12 \nas I dive into this, I would -- If you're going \n014045 13 \nto ask me questions about what's in these \n03400 14 \nparticular lines, I want to see -- I want to go \n040511 15 \nback. I want all of the -- the relevant parts of \n031064 16 \nmony played. And I \nocee 17 \na iev \nere \nproximately four points in \n03406. 18 \nthe transcript where she's mentioned, so can we \n04100 19 \nplay all four of those? \n02400 20 \nMR. SCAROLA: We are not going to do that. \nnon 21 \nWe have run out of time. Per agreement, this was \nNee 22 \nsupposed to stop at noon. \nown 23 \nMR. SIMPSON: Okay. \nroma 24 \nMR. SCAROLA: It is now 12:12, so this \n03410 25 \ndeposition is ended. There were a lot of things \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-4400 \n04154 \n1 \n01014 2 \n02410 3 \n4 \n5 \n6 \n7 \n8 \n9 \n10 \n11 \n12 \n13 \n14 \n15 \n16 \n17 \n18 \n19 \n20 \n21 \n22 \n23 \n24 \n25 \nMR. SCAROLA: Right. \nTHE VIDEOGRAPHER: We are going off the video \nrecord, 12:14 p.m. \n(Witness excused.) \n(Deposition was adjourned.) \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331-4400 \n0110 \n0)1113 \n031114 \n01410 \n034111 \n034110 \n011221 \n034112 \n014123 \n004123 10 \no3412. 11 \n031124 12 \n031120 13 \n034131 14 \n034135 15 \n11114113 16 \n034133 17 \n04140 18 \n034141 19 \n034143 20 \n0) 4140 21 \n329 \n1 \nthat I would have like to have finished with \n2 \nProfessor Dershowitz and wasn't permitted to do \n3 \nthat. So by agreement, this deposition is now \n4 \nover. \n5 \nMR. SIMPSON: It -- it's -- It's ending over \n6 \nmy objection and the witness's --\n7 \nMR. SCAROL\n... [truncated, 3581 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/128 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=128]", "char_count": 3581}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01116693", "page_number": 129, "text_content": "1 \n2 \nDEPOSITION ERRATA SHEET \n332 \n1 \n2 \n334 \nCERTIFICATE OF OATH \n3 \nPage No._Line No._Change to: \n3 \nSTATE OF FLORIDA \n)\n4 \nCOUNTY OF BROWARD \n) \n4 \nS \n5 \nReason for change: \n6 \n1, the undersigned authority and Notary \n6 \nPage No. \nUne No._Change to: \n7 \nPublic certify that PAUL G. CASSELL personally \n7 \n8 \nappeared before me and was duly Sworn on Saturday, the \n8 \nReason for change: \n9 \n17th day of October, 2015. \n9 \nPage No. \nUne No._Change to: \n10 \n10 \n11 \nSworn to before me this 19th day of October, \n11 \nReason for change: \n12 \n2015. \n12 \nPage No._Line No._Change to: \n13 \n14 \n13 \n15 \n14 \nReason for change: \n16 \n16 \nPage No._Line No._Change to: \n17 \n16 \n18 \nTheresa Tomaselli, RMR \n17 \nReason for change: \nNotary Public • State of Florida \n18 \nPage No._Line No._Change to: \n19 \nMy Commission No. FF 225528 \n19 \nMy Commission Expires 8/27/2019 \n20 \nReason for change: \n20 \n220190\n21 \nPage No. \nNo._Change to: \n_tine \n21 \n22 \n22 \n23 \nReason for change: \nZ1 \n24 \nSIGNATURE: \nDATE: \n2015 \n24 \n26 \nPAUL G. CASSELL \n26 \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \nESQUIRE DEPOSITION SOLUTIONS \n(954) 331.4400 \n(954) 331-4400 \n333 \nIP \n1 \nDEPOSITION ERRATA SHEET \n2 \n1 \nREPORTER'S CERTIFICATE \n3 \nPage No._Line No._Change to: \n2 \n4 \n3 \n6 \nReason for change: \n4 \nI \nTHERESA TOPASELLI. Registered Merit \nWailer aid Notary Public In and for the State of \n6 \nPage No._Line No._Change to: \n5 \nFlorida at Large. do hereptcertify that I was \nauthorized to and did re \nsaid deposition in \n7 \n6 \n7 \nsteroptpe: and that the ocarina pages are a true and \nere\ntranscription of my Shaltend notes of Said \nct\n \n8 \nReason for change: \n8 \nI further certify that said deposition ems \n9 \nPage No._Line No._Change to: \ntaken at the time end place hereinabove sot forth ard \n9 \nthat the taking of said deposition was coisenced ad \n10 \ncomPleted as heremabove set out. \n11 \nReason for change: \n10\nII \nI further certify that l an not an \nattorney or counsel of any of the parties. nor a 1 a \nPage No._Line No. \nChange to: \n12 \n12\n... [truncated, 2784 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01116693/129 or ?id=EFTA01116693&page=129]", "char_count": 2784}]}