{"efta_number": "EFTA01112352", "page_count": 11, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA01112352", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA01112352.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA01112352", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Filing # 35619897 E-Filed 12/16/2015 02:53:37 PM \nIN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 17th \nJUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR \nBROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA \nCIVIL DIVISION \nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS, and \nCASE NO. CACE 15-000072 \nPAUL G. CASSELL, \nPlaintiffs, \nv. \nALAN DERSHOWITZ, \nDefendant. \nMOTION TO STRIKE AND FOR SANCTIONS \nNon-Party \ny and through undersigned counsel, hereby moves for this \nCourt to enter sanctions against Defendant, Alan M. Dershowitz in connection to his filing the \nMotion in Limine to Overrule Objections As to Application of Settlement Rules, Filing ft \n35429605 E-Filed 12/11/2015 at 10:08:04 a.m., and to strike Defendant's affidavit, pleadings and \ngrant attorney's fees t\nila \nnd hereby states as follows. \nINTRODUCTION \nAlan Dershowitz intentionally and wrongfully submitted a misleading affidavit to this \nCourt, knowing that Non-Part \nhad a standing objection to the disclosure of \nconfidential settlement discussions. Dershowitz filed the affidavit with the sole purpose of putting \nit in the public record so he could feed falsehoods to the media. He submitted this affidavit full of \nmisrepresentations, betting that the consequences from this Court for his deliberate violation of the \nsettlement privilege will not be harsh enough to offset the benefit he received by feeding false \nEFTA01112352\n", "char_count": 1314}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01112352", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "information to the press. The Court should make clear to Dershowitz that his calculation is \nmistaken. \nFACTUAL BACKGROUND \nDavid Boies, representing non-part \nDefendant Alan Dershowitz, and \nDavid Stone, an attorney representing the interests of Dershowitz, met together to discuss the \nclaims concerning litigation involving Dershowitz, Brad Edwards, Paul Cassell anc.= \nIn partaking in these meetings, it was Non-Party-lawyers' \nclear \nunderstanding that the communications with Mr. Dershowitz were settlement discussions for the \npurposes of resolving claims concerning these individuals. See Exhibit I, December I I, 2015. \nDeclaration of David Boles. \nFollowing those meetings, Defendant Dershowitz was recently deposed in the above-\ncaptioned matter. During the course of his deposition, Dershowitz attempted to interject into the \nrecord non-responsive answers that disclosed the confidential settlement discussions with David \nBoles. Counsel for Ms. Roberts plainly instructed Dershowitz that these matters were confidential \nand, if that was disputed, the issue needed to be presented to a judge for resolution. \nMS. McCAWLEY: Again, I'm going to object to this has happened in the context \nof settlement --\nA. — false. \nMS. McCAWLEY: -- negotiations. I'm going to move for sanctions if information \nis revealed that happened in the context of settlement discussions. \nMR. SCOTT: I don't know whether — I don't believe there were settlement \ndiscussions. But even if they weren't, they would still be admissible. \nA. Let me continue --\nMR. SCOTT: For discovery purposes. \nA. — that David Boles had done --\nMS. McCAWLEY: I disagree. I think were going to have to take this to the judge, \nthen; if we're going to reveal settlement conversations in this conversation, then we \nneed to go to the judge on it. \nDeposition of Alan Dershowitz, Vol. I, (Oct. 15, 2015) at 81-84 (emphasis added). \n2 \nEFTA01112353\n", "char_count": 1915}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01112352", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "A few minutes later, counsel for Ms. Roberts raised the same objection when Dershowitz \nagain attempted to interject settlement discussions into his deposition answers. And Dershowitz's \ncounsel (Mr. Simpson) agreed that counsel had the right to raise the objection: \nMS. McCAWLEY: I object. I object. I'm not going to allow you to reveal \nany conversations that happened in the context of a settlement discussion. \n*** \nMR. SIMPSON: Wait a minute. Wait a minute. Wait a minute. Please don't \ndisclose something that she has a right to raise that objection if she wants to. \nR. SCOTT: Exactly. \nTHE WITNESS: Okay. 11:40:14 \nMR. SCOTT: Ask your question. \nDeposition of Alan Dershowitz, vol. 1, (Oct. 15, 2015) at 94-95 (emphasis added). \nIn light of these clear objections during the deposition. defendant Dershowitz, knew \nthat \nlawyers had lodged objections on the record to Defendant \nDershowitz's wrongful attempts during his deposition to reveal confidential settlement \ndiscussions. Nonetheless, in spite of that objection, on the morning of Friday, December \nII, 2015, Dershowitz intentionally disregarded those objections and filed an affidavit in \nthis Coun's public file, outlining what he alleges' were conversations between Defendant \nDershowitz and David Boics. \nOn Saturday, December 12, 2015, the New York Times placed on its websitc a story \nthat included statements from Mr. Dershowitz's affidavit wrongfully characterizing and \ndisclosing settlement discussions. This story appeared in the print edition of the New York \nTimes on Sunday, December 13, 2015. \nImmediately after the release of Dershowitz's Affidavit, on Friday. December 11, 2015, \nNon-party \ntied an Emergency Motion to scat \"Exhibit B. Affidavit of Alan M. \nDershowitz Regarding Meetings with David Boies\" until such time as the Court can hold a hearing \nShockingly, Defendant Dershowitz submitted and r oath an affidavit that contains a number of statements \nthat were \"misleading,\" \"taken out of context,\" or \"flat\n... [truncated, 2084 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01112352/2 or ?id=EFTA01112352&page=2]", "char_count": 2084}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01112352", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "to Mc on the settlement privilege. Non-pafta \nw moves the Court to enter \nsanctions against Defendant Dershowitz for purposefully making public confidential settlement \ndiscussions made under the auspices of confidentiality and for the admitted purpose of resolving \nclaims. \nARGUMENT \nIt defies common sense for Dershowitz to claim that the discussions at issue were not \nsettlement discussions.'- The parties represented at these discussions have wholly opposing \ninterests related to ongoing litigation (and potential litigation). In shorti\nas \ncome forward to report sexual abuse she suffered as a minor child at the hands of Jeffery Epstein, \nAlan Dershowitz and others in relation to a Crime Victims Rights Act case in the Southern District \nof Florida (the \"CVRA suit\"). Thereafter, Alan Dershowitz proceeded to defame Ms. Roberts' \nlawyers, Bradley Edwards and Paul Cassell, who were pursuing justice on behalf of the minor sex \nabuse victims in the CVRA suit. In response, Brad Edwards and Paul Cassell filed the defamation \naction, pending before this Court? After that the defamation action was pending. Mr. Boics had \ndiscussions with Dershowitz in an attempt to resolve the litigation. It is hard to image what other \npossible basis the meetings could have had. \nMr. Dcrshowitz argues that his discussions with David Boies were not settlement \ndiscussions. lie also claims Fla. Stat. § 90.408 only attaches to the admissibility of settlement \nnegotiations at trial, yet publically filing confidential settlement discussions with the court \nFlorida courts adhere to the time-tested adage: if it looks, walks, quacks and swims like a duck, that is \nwhat it is. N. °reward Hosp. Dist v. Eldred By& Through Eldred, 466 So. 2d 1210, 1211 (Fla. 4th DCA \n1985) approved as modified sub nom. Eldred v. N. Broward Hosp. Dist, 498 So. 2d 911 (Fla. 1986); see \nalso BAIC Industries, Inc. v. Barth htdustries, lac., 160 F.3d 1322, 1337 (1 Ith Cir. 1998). \n3 Courts confronted with this issue have he\n... [truncated, 2482 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01112352/3 or ?id=EFTA01112352&page=3]", "char_count": 2482}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01112352", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "frustrates the purpose of that statute. \"The purpose of (Fla. Stat. § 90.40811s for counsel to \ncommunicate freely in an effort to settle litigation without the risk that any statement made will \nhe used against his clients.\" Rubrecht v. Cone Distrib., Inc.. 95 So. 3d 950. 956 (Ha. 5th DCA \n2012). Here, Dershowitz filed with this Court, and made public, alleged statements of David \nBoies in order to use them against his opponents in this litigation and in his press battle. \nDefendant Dcrshowitz intentionally submitted his affidavit in an effort to misrepresent \nwhat transpired and then fed that information to the press from the Court record. Indeed, the face \nof his motion demonstrates that he knows Non-Pa \nas standing objections to \nthe revelation of settlement discussions and he intentionally and knowingly submitted an affidavit \nattached to his motion outlining what he claims to be his version of those settlement discussions. \nIf there was ever a case of intentional bad faith litigation conduct — this is it. \nThe Florida Supreme Court has given courts broad discretionary power to sanction panics. \nBreaching confidentiality warrants sanctions. Parauzino v. Barnett Bank of S. Florida. N.A., 690 \nSo. 2d 725, 729 (Ha. 4th DCA 1997) cause dismissed, (Ha. June 2, 1997) (sanctioning a party for \nmaking public discussions that took place during mediation by striking its pleadings and \ndismissing the case with prejudice: if the trial court were to allow this willful and deliberate \nconduct to go unchecked, continued behavior in this vein could have a chilling effect upon the \nmediation process.\"). Similarly, allowing panics to publically file discussions that took place \nduring confidential settlement negotiations over the other party's objections would have a chilling \neffect on settlement negotiations. Therefore, the Court should strike Dershowitz's pleadings as a \nsanction. \nThe trial court possesses the inherent authority to impose attorneys' fees against an \nattorney\n... [truncated, 2289 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01112352/4 or ?id=EFTA01112352&page=4]", "char_count": 2289}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01112352", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "privilege. Attaching his Affidavit with his distorted version of the settlement negotiations' was \nsimply a vehicle for him to falsely portray settlement discussions to the press in an attempt to \nprejudice this Court and tarnish the reputations of the attorneys involved. Dershowitz showed bad \nfaith, abused the litigation process, and should therefore, at a minimum, pay attorneys' fees for \nnon-party Virginia Robert's efforts to seal this filing and efforts to have it struck from the record. \nThis Court should not countenance this obvious attempt to violate and frustrate the stated purpose \nof Florida statutes. See Rubrecht. supra. 95 So. 3d at 956. \nFinally, in addition to striking Dershowitz's pleadings. striking his affidavit, and awarding \nattorneys' fee- \nequests that the Court admonish Dershowitz that any further \nviolations of confidentiality orders and obligations will be met with even more severe sanctions. \nDershowitz has previously written: \"There's an old saying: `If you have the law on your \nside, bang on the law. If you have the facts on your side, bang on the facts. If you have neither, \nbang on the table.' I have never believed that, but I do believe in a variation on that theme: If you \ndon't have the law or legal facts on your side, argue your case in the court of public opinion.\" \nAlan Dershowitz, Taking the Stand: My Life in the Law (2013) (emphasis added). Dershowitz \nhas demonstrated that he is taking a page out his book and willing to reveal confidential \ninformation in his effort to win his battle in the court of public opinion. The Court should not \npermit such impermissible tactics to succeed. \nCONCLUSION \nWHEREFORE. Non-Party \nrespectfully requests that this Court grant her \nMotion for Sanctions and strike Dershowitz' pleadings, or, at the very least, strike \"Exhibit B, \nAlan Dershowitz' Affidavit\" in support of Defendant Alan M. Dershowitz's Motion in Limine to \nOverrule Objections As to Application of Settlement Rules, Filing # 35429605\n... [truncated, 2037 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01112352/5 or ?id=EFTA01112352&page=5]", "char_count": 2037}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01112352", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "at 10:08:04 a.m., and award attorneys' fees and costs, and admonish Dershowitz that any further \nviolations of his confidentiality obligations will lead to even more severe sanctions. \nDated: December 16, 2015 \nRespectfully submitted. \nBOIES, SCIIII.LER & FLEXNER LLP \n401 East Las Olas Boulevard, Suite 1200 \nFort Lauderdale, Florida 33301 \nTelephone: (954) 356-0011 \nFacsimile: (954) 356-0022 \nBy: /s/Sigrid S. McCawlev \nSigrid S. McCawley, Esq. \nFlorida Bar No. 129305 \nAttorney for Non-Party \n7 \nEFTA01112358\n", "char_count": 513}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01112352", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE \nI HEREBY CERTIFY that on December16, 2015, a true and correct copy of the \nforegoing was served by Electronic Mail to the individuals identified below. \nBy:  /s/Sigrid S. McCawley \nSigrid S. McCawley \nThomas E. Scott \nThomas.scottaicsklegal.com \nSteven R. Safra \nStcven.safra(Mcsklegal.com \nCOLE. SCO1T & KISSANE, P.A. \n9150 S. Dadeland Blvd., Suite 1400 \nMiami, Florida 33156 \nRenee.naikiecsklecal.com \nShellv.zambo@cskleaal.com \nRichard A. Simpson \nrsimnson@wilevrein.com \nMary E. Borja \nmborialiiwilevrein.com \nAshley E. Eiler \naeiler(awilevrein.com \nWILEY REIN, LLP \n1776 K Street NW \nWashington, D.C. 20006 \nJack Scarola \nSEARCY DENNEY SCAROLA BARNHART \n& SHIPLEY, P.A. \nJSX \nearcvlaw.com \n2139 Palm Beach Lakes Blvd. \nWest Palm Beach, FL 33409-6601 \nAttorney for Plaint fffs \nCounsel for Defendant Alan Dershowitz \n8 \nEFTA01112359\n", "char_count": 861}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01112352", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "EXHIBIT 1 \nEFTA01112360\n", "char_count": 24}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01112352", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF TIlE 17th \nJUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR \nBROWAR D COUNTY. FLORIDA \nCIVIL. DIVISION \nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS, and \nCASE NO. CACE 15-000072 \nPAUL G. CASSELL. \nPlaintiffs, \nALAN DERSIIOWITZ. \nDefendant. \nDECLARATION OF' D ‘‘ II) BOIES \nMy name is David Boles. I make this Declaration on personal knowledge in \nresponse to the Affidavit of Alan M. Dcrshowitz executed on December 10, 2015 and filed in this \naction on December I I. 2015. \nAlthough much of what Mr. Dershowitz asserts in his Affidavit is misleading, \ntaken out oft:tiniest, or is flatly untrue. until the Court has ruled on Mr. Dershowitz's contention \nthat the discussions were not settlement communications. I will restrict my response to matters \nrelated to that issue. \n3. \nThe entire purpose of my communications with Mr. Dershowitz, as I understood it. \nwas to attempt to resolve Inc litigation between Mr. Dershowitz and Messrs. Edwards and Cassell. \n4. \nI was not told, one way or the other, whether David Stone IS actually been \nretained by Mr. Dershowitz as counsel. However, I was explicitly told that Mr. Dershowitz had \nasked Mr. Stone to participate on Mr. Dershowitz's behalf, and on a number of occasions Mr. \nStone both received communications from me to pass on to Mr. Dershowitz. and passed on to me \ncommunications that Mr. Dershcmitz had asked him to convey to me. \nEFTA01112361\n", "char_count": 1380}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01112352", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "3. \nDuring our discussions, Mr. Dershowitt and I exchanged a number of entails \nincluding emails that included proposals and counter proposals for resolving the litigation between \nMr. Dershou it z and Messrs. Edwards and Cassell. If the Court believes it is appropriate to do so. \nI am prepared to submit those emails to the Court for its review for the purpose of detennining \nwhether or not Mr. Dershowitz and I were or were not engaged in settlement communications. \nI declare under penalty of perjury that the tbregoing are true and correct to the best of my \nknowledge. \n• \n, \nExecuted ;his  i i \n cay of December. 2013. \n/7, tA4/ \nDAVID BOIES \n2 \nEFTA01112362\n", "char_count": 667}]}