{"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_count": 28, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA01111095", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA01111095.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Filing it 35180835 E-Filed 12/04/2015 03:19:02 PM \nIN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE \nSEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN \nAND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA \nCASE NO.: CACE 15-000072 \nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS and PAUL G. \nCASSELL, \nPlaintiffs, \nvs. \nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ, \nDefendants. \nPLAINTIFFS, BRADLEY I EDWARDS AND PAUL CASSELL'S \nMOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON LIABILITY \nPlaintiffs, Bradley J. Edwards, Esq. and Paul G. Cassell, Esq., by and through their \nundersigned counsel and pursuant to Rule 1.510, Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, hereby move \nfor (I) partial summary judgment on the issue of the false and defamatory nature of the \nstatements at issue in this defamation case, as well to the presumed damages from those \nstatements, with respect to both of claims against the Defendant, Alan Dershowitz, and (2) final \nsummary judgment as to Dershowitz's First Amended Counterclaim against them, and in support \nthereof state as follows: \nI. \nINTRODUCTION \nAs the Court is well aware, this case involves a defamation action filed by two attorneys: \nEdwards and Cassell. They contend that the defendant, Alan Dershowitz, defamed them by \nrepeatedly claiming in worldwide media broadcasts and other widely-disseminated statements \nthat they had engaged in conspiring with their client to make up sexual abuse allegations against \nDershowitz. The pleadings and discovery taken to date show that there is no genuine issue as to \n*** FILED: BROWARD COUNTY. FL HOWARD FORMAN. CLERK 12/4/2015 3:19:02 PM.**** \nEFTA01111095\n", "char_count": 1513}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 2 of 20 \nany material fact that these statements were false and defamatory. Moreover, Edwards and \nCassell are entitled to litigation privilege for the statements they filed in court on behalf of their \nclient. Accordingly, Edwards and Cassell are entitled to partial summary judgment on their \ncomplaint and final summary judgment on Dershowitz's First Amended Counterclaim. \nWith regard to their complaint, Edwards and Cassell are entitled to partial summary \njudgment on the specific issue of the false and defamatory nature of the statements made against \nthem. They have provided ample evidence that they had a powerful basis for believing their \nclient's sexual abuse allegations — and were accordingly justified in filing a legal document on \ntheir client's behalf which contained those allegations. As a result, the undisputed record \nevidence establishes that Dershowitz waged a baseless international media assault on the \nhonesty, integrity, and professionalism of Edwards and Cassell. In particular, Dershowitz went \nso far as to repeatedly accuse Edwards and Cassell of criminal misconduct in actively suborning \nperjury and fabricating the allegations of misconduct against him — acts that would warrant their \ndisbarment from the legal profession. The undisputed record evidence supports the conclusion \nthat Edwards and Cassell reasonably believed the sexual assault allegations against Dershowitz \nto be true, which is all that is required for the court to enter partial summary judgment here. Put \nsimply, Dershowitz has made highly defamatory allegations that have no basis in fact. Indeed, \nhis lawsuit was merely a desperate measure by a child abuser to avoid the stigma of the \ndisclosure of his misconduct. Dershowitz's charges against Edwards and Cassell were and are \nnothing short of a far-fetched fictional fairy-tale — a preposterous claim lacki\n... [truncated, 2032 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01111095/1 or ?id=EFTA01111095&page=1]", "char_count": 2032}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 3 of 20 \nsupport. And the statements that he made attack the chosen profession of Edwards and Cassell — \nthe practice of law — and therefore carry with them a presumption of damages suffered. \nAccordingly, the court should grant plaintiffs' motion for partial summary judgment on the \nissues of the false and defamatory nature of Dershowitz's statements, as well as the issue of the \npresumed damages that flowed from those statements. \nWith regard to the First Amended Counterclaim, the undisputed material facts establish \nthat Dershowitz's counterclaims against the Plaintiffs are barred by the absolute litigation \nprivilege. \nThe conduct of the attorneys Edwards and Cassell that forms the basis for \nDershowitz's counterclaim for defamation is nothing more than filing a well-founded motion in \npending federal court proceedings on behalf of pro bono clients. In his recent deposition, \nDershowitz has conceded that the allegations were relevant to the federal court proceedings. As \na result, that filing is indisputably protected by Florida's broad and absolute litigation privilege. \nConsequently, plaintiffs' motion for summary judgment as it relates to the pending counterclaim \nagainst them should also be granted. \nARGUMENT \nII. \nEDWARDS AND CASSELL ARE ENTITLED TO PARTIAL SUMMARY \nJUDGMENT ON THE PENDING PRIMARY CLAIM BECAUSE THERE \nARE NO MATERIAL DISPUTED FACTS AND THE UNDISPUTED FACTS \nESTABLISH THAT DERSHOWITZ REPEATEDLY BROADCAST FALSE \nAND DEFAMATORY STATEMENTS ABOUT THEM. \nA. \nThe Summary Judgment Standard. \nRule 1.510(c), Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, provides that a court may enter summary \n3 \nEFTA01111097\n", "char_count": 1768}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 4 of 20 \njudgment when the pleadings, depositions and factual showings reveal that there is no genuine \nissue of material fact and that the moving party is entitled to judgment as a matter of law. See \nSnyder v. Cheezem Development Corp., 373 So. 2d 719, 720 (Fla. 2d DCA 1979); Rule 1.510(c), \nFla. R. Civ. P. Once the moving party conclusively establishes that the nonmoving party cannot \nprevail, it is incumbent on the nonmoving party to submit evidence to rebut the motion for \nsummary judgment. See Holl v. Talcott, 191 So. 2d 40, 43 (Fla. 1966). It is not enough for the \nopposing party merely to assert that an issue of fact does exist. Fisel v. Wynns, 667 So.2d 761, 764 \n(Fla.1996); Landers v. Milton, 370 So.2d 368, 370 (Fla.1979) (same). \nMoreover, it is well-recognized that the non-moving party faced with a summary judgment \nmotion supported by appropriate proof may not rely on bare, conclusory assertions found in the \npleadings to create an issue and thus avoid summary judgment. Instead, the party must produce \ncounter-evidence establishing a genuine issue of material fact. See Bryant v. Shands Teaching \nHospital and Clinics, Inc., 479 So.2d 165, 168 (Fla. 1st Dist. Ct. App. 1985); see also Lanzner v. \nCity of North Miami Beach, 141 So.2d 626 (Fla. 3d Dist Ct. App. 1962) (recognizing that mere \ncontrary allegations of complaint were not sufficient to preclude summary judgment on basis of \nfacts established without dispute). Where the nonmoving party fails to present evidence rebutting \nthe motion for summary judgment and there is no genuine issue of material fact, then entry of \njudgment is proper as a matter of law. See Davis v. Hathaway, 408 So. 2d 688, 689 (Fla. 2d Dist. \nCt. App. 1982); see also Holl, 191 So. 2d at 43. \n4 \nEFTA01111098\n", "char_count": 1901}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassel Is Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 5 of 20 \nB. Dershowitz's Statements Concerning Edwards and Cassell Were False and \nDefamatory and Have Absolutely No Factual Basis. \nIn support of this motion, Edwards and Cassell incorporate each of the attached Exhibits \n— notably including attached Exhibit 1, which is a summary of some of the most important \nevidence; Exhibit 2, which is a sworn affidavit from their client, Ms. Giuffre; and Exhibit 3, \nwhich is deposition testimony from Cassell. These extensive materials establish the considerable \nsupport upon which Edwards and Cassell relied to file allegations on behalf of their client, Ms. \nNevertheless, this is not a complicated case for granting partial \nsummary judgment. To the contrary, this is a simple case for partial summary judgment because \neach and every one of Dershowitz's verbal attacks against Edwards and Cassell lacks any merit \nwhatsoever and is defamatory per se. \nOf course, one element that a defamation plaintiff must establish under Florida law is an \n\"unprivileged publication (to a third party) of a false and defamatory statement concerning \nanother.\" Mile Marker, Inc. v. Petersen Publishing, L.L.C., 811 So.2d 841, 845 (Fla. Dist. Ct. \nApp. 4th 2002). Mother element that a defamation plaintiff must establish is damage to the \nperson that ensued from the publication of the false or defamatory statement. Id. \nWhile Edwards and Cassell are entitled to summary judgment on other aspects of their \nclaims, in this pleading it is only these two elements on which Edwards and Cassell are seeking \nsummary judgment. \nAs the undisputed facts establish, Cassell and Edwards received a well-founded \nallegation that Dershowitz had sexually abused Ms. Roberts. They then filed those allegations - \n5 \nEFTA01111099\n", "char_count": 1878}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 6 of 20 \non her behalf — in a pending case where those allegations were pertinent. Dershowitz then went \non a worldwide media rampage, claiming that the allegations were so unsupported that, by \nmerely filing them in court for their client, Edwards and Cassell's demonstrated that they lacked \nfitness to engage in their chosen profession: the practice of law. Dershowitz's allegations are \nclearly and indisputably false, as established below. \nAnd it takes no real effort to understand that Dershowitz's statements (recounted in \nExhibit #1 and elsewhere) are obviously and indisputably defamatory. \nDershowitz had \nrepeatedly said, for example, the Edwards and Cassell have conspired to create false charges \nagainst him and should be disbarred. Because these defamatory statements involve the conduct \nof two attorneys in their chosen profession, Dershowitz had committed defamation per se and \ndamage is presumed. It is well settled in Florida that defamation \"is actionable per se is, without \na showing of special damage-if it imputes to another . . . conduct, characteristics, or a condition \nincompatible with the proper exercise of his lawful business, trade, profession, or office . . . .\" \nCampbell v. Jacksonville Kennel Club, 66 So. 2ed 495, 497 (Fla. 1953) (citing Restatement, \nTorts, Section 570). \nBecause this case involves defamation per se, \"liability itself creates a conclusive legal \npresumption of loss or damage. Therefore a finding of liability for [defamation] per se, coupled \nwith an express finding that the [defamation] was intended to injure plaintiff and did in fact \ncause injury, authorizes the jury to consider and assess punitive damages without any finding of \na specific amount of compensatory damages.\" Lawnwood Med. Cm. Inc. v. Sadow, 43 So. 3d \n6 \nEFTA01111100\n", "char_count": 1931}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassel Is Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 7 of 20 \n710, 729 (Fla. 4th DCA 2010). Accordingly, for purposes of summary judgment, there need be \nno record evidence of any specific loss attributable to Dershowitz's tortious conduct Edwards \nand Cassell are automatically entitled to summary judgment on that aspect of their claim. \nTHE RECORD EVIDENCE \nIn light of the foregoing principles, three kinds of evidence are relevant to Edwards and \nCassell's motion for partial summary judgment First, Edwards and Cassell must establish the \nabsence of any dispute that their profession is the legal profession. Second, Edwards and Cassell \nmust establish the absence of any dispute that Dershowitz has imputed conduct inconsistent with \nthe proper exercise of their legal duties. And third, Edwards and Cassell must establish the \nabsence of any dispute that Dershowitz's statements were false and defamatory. Ample and \nunrebutted evidence supports each of these three points, which is summarized in the \naccompanying video presentation (Exhibit #1), the contents of which are incorporated herein by \nreference. \nEdwards and Cassell's Chosen Profession is the Law \nEdwards and Cassell are both attorneys. In answering the complaint, Dershowitz appears \nto concede this fact See Defendant Dershowitz's Answer to Complaint at ¶¶ 2-6 (conceding \nCassell is counsel in a Florida victims' rights case and has held other legal positions); id at ¶¶ 6-\n10 (conceding the same as to Edwards). \nMr. Edwards has established by affidavit (see Exhibit #14) that he is a named partner in \nthe law firm of Farmer, Jaffe, Weissing, Edwards, Fistos & Lehrman and a Board Certified Civil \n7 \nEFTA01111101\n", "char_count": 1767}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 8 of 20 \nTrial Attorney. He has tried more than 75 jury trials. He has been profiled in The Best Lawyers \nin America, recognized by the National Trial Lawyers Association's \"Top 40 Under 40,\" and by \nthe National Academy of Personal Injury Attorney's \"Top 10 Under 40.\" In 2015 the National \nAssociation of Distinguished Counsel selected Mr. Edwards as one of the nation's \"Top One \nPercent.\" Mr. Edwards is rated AV by his professional peers through the Martindale-Hubbell 0 \nPeer Review Rating system. Before entering private practice, Mr. Edwards was a trial attorney \nat the Broward County State Attorney's Office, prosecuting many violent criminals. In his \nprivate practice, he has handled numerous cases on behalf of victims of sexual abuse and other \ncrimes, including a number of pro bono cases. \nProfessor Paul G. Cassell has established by affidavit (see Exhibit #15) that he is the \nRonald N. Boyce Presidential Professor of Criminal Law at the S.J. Quinney College of Law at \nthe University of Utah. He graduated from Stanford Law School, where he served as President \nof the Stanford Law Review. He clerked for then-Judge Antonin Scalia when Scalia was on the \nU.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit and then for the Chief Justice of the United States, \nWarren Burger. Cassell then served as an Associate Deputy Attorney General with the U.S. \nJustice Department and as an Assistant U.S. Attorney for the Eastern District of Virginia. Cassell \nthen joined the faculty at the College of Law, where he taught full time until he was sworn in as \na U.S. District Court Judge for the District of Utah in 2002. In 2007, he resigned his judgeship to \nreturn full time to the College of Law, to teach, write, and litigate on issues relating to crime \nvictims' rights. He is a co-author of the law school casebook, Victims in Criminal Procedure \n8 \nEFTA01111102\n", "char_count": 1998}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 9 of 20 \n(Carolina Academic Press 3d ed. 2010). Cassell has handled pro bono numerous Crime Victims' \nRights Act cases in district and appellate courts across the country, including a recent pro bono \ncase he argued to the U.S. Supreme Court for a crime victim (Paroline v. U.S.). He is a member \nin good standing of the Utah bar and handles legal cases on a paid and pro bono basis in Utah \nand elsewhere. \nDershowitz Has Made Defamatory Statements Alleging Conduct Incompatible with Proper \nExercise of Edwards and Cassell's Profession. \nAs established beyond dispute from reviewing the first few video clips in the attached \npresentation, Dershowitz has defamed Edwards and Cassell by repeatedly alleging \"conduct, \ncharacteristics, or a condition incompatible with the proper exercise of [Edwards and Cassell's] \nlawful business, trade, and profession.\" Among other things, Dershowitz alleged that Edwards \nand Cassell failed to minimally investigate the allegations they advanced on behalf of their client \nand even that they sat down with her to contrive the allegations. The attached video clips \nprovide some illustrations of the assault on the Plaintiff? professional fitness, but other \nstatements Dershowitz has made in prominent national and international media including equally \ndisparaging false statements: \n\"[Edwards and Cassell] are lying deliberately, and I will not stop until they're \ndisbarred . . . . \nNew York Times — January 3, 2015 \n\"[Edwards and Cassell] manipulated a young, suggestible woman who was \ninterested in money. \nThis is a disbarable offense, and they will be \ndisbarred. They will rue the day they ever made this false charge against me.\" \nMiami Herald — January 3, 2015 \n9 \nEFTA01111103\n", "char_count": 1855}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 10 of 20 \n\"They [Edwards and Cassell] are lying deliberately, and I will not stop until \nthey're disbarred,\" \nBoston Globe — January 4, 2015 \n\"If they [Cassell and Edwards] had just done an hours' worth of work, they would \nhave seen she is lying through her teeth. . . . They're prepared to lie, cheat, and \nsteal. These are unethical lawyers. This is Professor Cassell who shouldn't be \nallowed near a student. . . . He is essentially a crook. He is essentially somebody \nwho's distorted the legal system. . . Why would he charge a person with a \nsterling reputation for 50 years on the basis of the word alone of a woman who is \nserial liar. . . If they just checked the records, they could have known from \nthemselves that she was lying about me. . . . So we can prove it without any \ndoubt. That's what's so absurd. That's what's so strange why two experienced \nlawyers would file this kind of statement knowing it was untrue. These [Cassell \nand Edwards] are virtually the equivalent of perjurers and they have to be taken \nout of the legal profession. They can't be allowed to have a bar card to victimize \nmore innocent people.\" \nHalts Gorani — CNN Live (Jan. 5, 2015) \n\"There was no contact, no contact whatsoever. And I will prove it conclusively, \nand then I will bring disciplinary charges and prove that these lawyers knew that \nthis was false, could easily have checked, and didn't. And the end result will be \nthat these lawyers will be disbarred.\" \nVice News — January 5, 2015 \nSo they [Edwards and Cassell] and the woman got together and contrived and \nmade this up. They have been talking to the woman for years. She never alleged \nme before. She never made any mention. Many of the others were mentioned \nbefore. \nFirst time my name was mentioned was a week ago. . . . I've never \nseen two lawyers like Paul Cassell and Brad Edwards engage in such unethi\n... [truncated, 2408 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01111095/9 or ?id=EFTA01111095&page=9]", "char_count": 2408}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and fl ccells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 11 of 20 \nThey will be proved -- all of them [i.e., Cassell, Edwards, and Jane Doe No. 3] —\nto be categorically lying and making up this story. And it will be a terrible thing \nfor rape victims. They have put rape victims in a terrible position. Because when \nI unequivocally that they sat down and made this all up, tragically it will hurt all \nrape victims. . . The lawyers are lying through their teeth when they say I've \nrefused to be deposed. . . . We [Epstein and Dershowitz] had an academic \nrelationship. I was never in the presence of a single, young, under-aged woman. \nWhen I was with him, it was with prominent scientists, prominent academics. \nAnd they're just — again — lying about this \nToday Show — Jan. 22, 2015. \n\"Now, your own rules of the profession, which I read coming in this morning, \ninclude as a professional I will always avoid personal criticism of another \nlawyer. And yet these two lawyers — Brad Edwards, from, whose partner \nRothstein is now in jail for 50 years for a Ponzi scheme involving the same case, \nand a guy named Cassell — filed this . . . allegation again me in passing without \ndoing even the most minimal of investigation, which would have proven \nconclusively that I not only didn't, but couldn't have, possibly done it.\" \nSpeech to Dade County Bar Association, Feb. 20, 2015. \nClearly Dershowitz has attacked Edwards and Cassell's conduct as attorneys and even their \nfitness to continue to be members of their respective bars. \nDershowitz's Statements Were False \nThe record evidence eliminates all doubt that Dershowitz's statements were false. The \nsworn affidavit of \n(identified previously as Jane Doe #3), attached and \nincorporated herein as Exhibit #2, unequivocally contradicts Alan Dershowitz's protestations of \ninnocence and his malicious statements made against Edwards and Cassell. \nHowever, \nDershowitz has d\n... [truncated, 2268 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01111095/10 or ?id=EFTA01111095&page=10]", "char_count": 2268}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 12 of 20 \nEdwards and Cassell are seeking summary judgment. But while Edwards and Cassell will \nestablish the truthfulness of Ms. \ncharges at trial, this is not an issue that the court need \nreach to before granting the summary judgments that Edwards and Cassell seek in this pleading. \nThe central issue upon which Edwards and Cassell's complaint rests is not whether Ms. \nclaims were true, but instead whether Dershowitz lacked any basis whatsoever to \nsupport his claims that Edwards and Cassell not only knew that her statements were false but \nindeed actively participated in fabricating false statements. The record is completely devoid of \nevidence to support the existence of any such basis. \nAs to the counterclaim the central issue upon which summary judgment turns is whether \nthe Plaintiffs'/counter-defendants' filing of \nGiuffre's affidavit in the Crime \nVictim's Rights Act cases had any reasonable relationship to the issues in that federal \nproceeding. That issue has been expressly conceded by Dershowitz. \nMS. \nSWORN CLAIMS \nMs. \nhas submitted a sworn affidavit, not only attesting to the truthfulness of her \nallegations against Dershowitz but also about the fact that she told her lawyers about these \nclaims. With regard to her allegations, Ms. \nexplains that: \nHarvard law professor Alan Dershowitz was around Epstein frequently. \nDershowitz was so comfortable with the sex that was going on and that he \nobserved me in sexual activity with Epstein. \nI had sexual intercourse with \nDershowitz at least six times. The first time was when I was about 16, early on in \nmy servitude to Epstein, and it continued until I was 19. \nThe first time we had sex took place in New York in Epstein's home. It \nwas in Epstein's room (not the massage room). I was approximately 16 years old \n12 \nEFTA01111106\n", "char_count": 1944}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 13 of 20 \nat the time. I called Dershowitz \"Alan.\" I knew he was a famous professor. The \nsecond time that I had sex with Dershowitz was at Epstein's house in Palm Beach \nI also had sex with Dershowitz at Epstein's Zorro Ranch in New Mexico \nin the massage room off of the indoor pool area, which was still being painted. \nWe also had sex at Little Saint James Island in the U.S. Virgin Islands. \nMother sexual encounter between me and Dershowitz happened on \nEpstein's airplane. Mother girl was present on the plane with us. \nI have recently seen a former Harvard law professor identified as Alan \nDershowitz on television calling me a \"liar.\" He is lying by denying that he had \nsex with me. That man is the same man that I had sex with at least six times. \nSince I filed my motion in the Jane Doe 1 and Jane 2 case, my credibility \nhas been attacked, including attacks from Alan Dershowitz on me and on my \nattorneys who believed in me. I am telling the truth and will not let these attacks \nprevent me from exposing the truth of how I was trafficked for sex to many \npowerful people. These powerful people seem to think that they don't have to \nfollow the same rules as everyone else. That is wrong. \nSworn affidavit of \n(Exhibit #2), at ¶¶ 24-31, ¶ 71. \nThe assertions of sexual abuse are more than adequately corroborated by compelling \ncircumstantial evidence which is detailed at length by Cassell in his deposition. However, the \nCourt (like the jury who will ultimately hear this case) need not ever decide whether Dershowitz \nsexually abused Ms. \nto rule in Edwards and Cassell's favor in this motion. Regardless of \nwhether Dershowitz sexually abused Ms. \n, Edwards and Cassell clearly had a good faith \nbasis for relying on the sworn representations of their client — and Dershowitz had absolutely no \nbasis for repeatedly asserting on numerous worldwide media\n... [truncated, 2341 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01111095/12 or ?id=EFTA01111095&page=12]", "char_count": 2341}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 14 of 20 \nworth of work, they would have seen she is lying through her teeth.\" Accordingly, regardless of \nwhat happened between Dershowitz and Ms. \ninside of Jeffrey Epstein's mansions, on his \njets, and on Epstein's exclusive private island, the undisputed record evidence establishes that \nEdwards and Cassell had every right following their detailed investigation to rely on Ms. \ncredibility. Even more significantly, there is no record evidence contradicting the \nPlaintiffs' assertions that they did not fabricate Ms. \nsworn account of her interactions \nwith the defendant Dershowitz. \nThe good faith basis for Edwards and Cassell's reliance on Ms. \nallegations is \nlaid out in detail by Professor Cassell in more than 50 pages of sworn testimony during his \ndeposition. See Depo. of Paul Cassell (Oct. 16 & 17, 2015), at 61-117 (Exhibit #3). Some of \nProfessor Cassell's significant testimony is included in the PowerPoint presentation included as \npart of the record in support of this Motion. Cassell's testimony includes the following \ninformation that he and Edwards relied upon in believing the truth of \nallegations: \n• \nThe Palm Beach Police Department put together an 87-page report based on \nwitness interviews and other evidence documenting sexual abuse of dozens of \nminor girls occurring in Epstein's Florida mansion — a location where Ms. Giuffre \nsaid Dershowitz had abused her (see Exhibit #4); \n• The Palm Beach police report showed the sexual abuse was occurring on a daily \nbasis and, indeed, in some cases as much as two or three times in one day in \ncircumstances that would have made it obvious to a visiting guest that young girls \nwere coming to the home for sexual purposes; \n• \nFlight logs for Epsteiz\nivate jet showed that Epstein (accompanied by Ms. \nMaxwell) flew Ms. \nto the New York City area, a location where Ms. \nsaid Dershowitz had \n... [truncated, 2047 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01111095/13 or ?id=EFTA01111095&page=13]", "char_count": 2047}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 15 of 20 \n• \nEpstein's flight logs appeared to be disguising the identity of all of the passengers \non Epstein's plane by using such notations as \"one female.\" \n• \nA very well-regarded Florida lawyer (Bob Josefsberg), who was selected by the \nU.S. Government to represent the victims of Epstein's sexual abuse, had found \nMs. \nto be credible and in 2009 filed a civil complaint for her alleging not \nonly sex abuse by Epstein but also by \"academicians\" (see Exhibit #6) -- a group \ninto which Dershowitz fell; \n• \nShortly after Josefsberg filed the complaint for Ms. \nalleging \n\"academicians\" had abuse her, one of Josefsberg's partners, Ms. Ezell, began \nconducting depositions in Epstein-related cases asking about Dershowitz's \nawareness of sexual abuse; \n• \nDershowitz showed up on flight logs for Epstein's private jet, including a flight \nwith an (apparently young) woman named \"Tatiana\" who did not appear to serve \nany business purpose for Epstein; \n• \nWhen asked about Dershowitz, Epstein took the Fifth rather than indicate that \nDershowitz was not involved in any criminal activities (see Exhibit #7) — a fact \nfrom which an obvious adverse inference could be drawn that Dershowitz was, \nindeed, involved in Epstein's crimes; \n• \nIn moving down from the top of \nstein's criminal conspiracy to the next \nechelon \nthree women \n— Sarah M, \nAdrianna Mucinska, and Nadia \n- all took the Fifth when asked about Dershowitz's awareness of \nEpstein's sexual abuse of underage girls or whether Dershowitz was involved in \nmassages with young girls (see Exhibit #16); \n• \nMucinska, and \nwere all covered by a highly unusual non-\nprosecution agreement (negotiated by, among others, Epstein defense attorney \nAlan Derhsowitz) that provided immunity from prosecution for sex trafficking not \nonly to Epstein but also to his \"potential co-conspirators\"; \n• \nOne of Epstein's ho\n... [truncated, 2321 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01111095/14 or ?id=EFTA01111095&page=14]", "char_count": 2321}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 16 of 20 \n• \nAnother Epstein household employee, Alfredo Rodriguez, said that during the \ntime of his employment (2005), Dershowitz visited Epstein's mansion at the same \ntime as \"massages\" by underage girls were occurring in the mansion (see Exhibit \n#9); \n• \nWhen Rodriguez was arrested by the FBI trying to sell Epstein's \"little black \nbook\" of contacts and phone numbers, he appeared to have circled the name of \nAlan Dershowitz as someone who had information about Epstein criminal \nactivities (see Exhibit #17); \n• \nDershowitz had indicated in 2003 that he was an extremely close friend of Epstein \n— indeed, that the only person outside his immediately family with whom he \nshared drafts of his books was Epstein; \n• \nAttempts had been made to depose Dershowitz or otherwise obtain information \nfrom him about his knowledge of Epstein's sexual abuse in 2009, 2011, 2013, and \nJanuary 2015, and he had avoided all those efforts (see Exhibit #10); \n• \nDershowitz had told the Palm Beach Police Department that he was going to \nmake Epstein available to answer questions about sex abuse of underage girls, but \nthen repeatedly rescheduled those meetings, ultimately never producing Epstein -\na pattern of deception that appeared to be designed to deliberately delay the \ninvestigation; \n• \nDershowitz's pattern of avoiding depositions (and helping Epstein avoid \nquestioning) was consistent with a pattern of other persons who were involved in \nEpstein's international sex trafficking organization evading efforts to obtain \ninformation from them; \n• \nMs. \nhad alleged abuse by other powerful friends of Epstein, including \nPrince Andrew, and there was a photograph showing Prince Andrew with his arm \naround Ms. Giuffre apparently taken in London (where she said the sex abuse had \ntaken place) (see Exhibit #11). \nDepo. of Paul Cassell (Oct. 16 & 17, 2015), at 61-11\n... [truncated, 2211 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01111095/15 or ?id=EFTA01111095&page=15]", "char_count": 2211}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 17 of 20 \nallegation to them as far back as 2011 before they were representing her. But equally clear is the \nfact that Dershowitz engaged in intentional misconduct, because of his lack of any basis for \nattacking their professionalism. Dershowitz served as Epstein's defense counsel during the \nnegotiations that lead to his guilty plea and associated non-prosecution agreement. Dershowitz \nuniquely would have been aware of the compelling evidence against Epstein — and no doubt \nwould have taken a keen interest in the evidence that would have connected him with Epstein's \ncrimes. Most notably, since then, Dershowitz has yet to provide any evidence that he relied upon \nin January 2015 for his claims that Edwards and Cascell had conspired with their client to make \nup allegations against him. And the idea that if Edwards and Cassell \"had just done an hours' \nworth of work, they would have seen she is lying through her teeth\" is laughable in light of the \nmountain of evidence supporting her allegations — as well as Dershowitz's refusal to be deposed \nregarding his knowledge of the sexual abuse of Epstein's victims and his personal inability to \nobtain exonerating evidence. \nAnd what does Dershowitz now claim was the support for his media tirade against these \ntwo capable lawyers? As the Court can readily confirm by reading even a small snippet of \nDershowitz's deposition, it was very difficult to get him to answer questions directly and \nspecifically. (As a result, Dershowitz's deposition will continue on December 9 and 10.) \nHowever, Dershowitz never provided any basis for his attacks on Edwards and Cassell. See \ngenerally Depo. of Alan Dershowitz (Oct. 15, 2015) (Exhibit #12); Depo. of Alan Dershowitz \n(Oct. 16, 2015) (Exhibit #13). \n17 \nEFTA01111111\n", "char_count": 1905}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15.000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 18 of 20 \nMoreover, some answers were successfully extracted which leaves no doubt that \nDershowitz's defamatory statements about Edwards and Cassell were made without any basis. \nSome of these have been collected in the attached PowerPoint presentation, which shows \nintentional misconduct — specifically, a series of deliberate lies -- by Dershowitz, apparently \ndesigned to conceal his culpability. For example, Dershowitz claimed that the flight logs would \n\"exonerate\" him. But he had never even looked at them before attacking Edwards and Cassell. \nSee Depo. of Alan Dershowitz at 239-42 (Oct. 16, 2015) (Exhibit #13). Dershowitz also stated \nin his media appearances that \"[a]s far as the planes are concerned, there are flight manifests. \nThey will prove I was never on any private airplane with any young women.\" Nana Gorani - \nCNN Live (Jan. 5, 2015). And yet a flight log shows Dershowitz on a flight with a young woman \nnamed \"Tatianna.\" Dershowitz also was forced to admit in his deposition that whenever he met \nwith Epstein, part of the Epstein \"entourage\" were woman whom he described as being between \nthe age of 25 and 30. \nDershowitz also stated: \"I've been married to the same woman for 28 years. She goes \nwith me everywhere. People know that I won't argue a case or give a speech unless my wife \ntravels with me.\" American Lawyer, Jan. 15, 2015. And yet the available flight logs for \nEpstein's planes do not show Dershowitz's wife on a single flight while showing Dershowitz \ntraveling without his wife on numerous flights — including a flight with \"Tatianna\" on it. \n18 \nEFTA01111112\n", "char_count": 1735}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No • CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 19 of 20 \nDershowitz also stated \"I have never been alone . . . with Jeffrey Epstein.\" UMAR \nNews, Jan. 5, 2015. \nAnd yet (among other occasions), a flight log shows Epstein and \nDershowitz traveling together — alone. \nDershowitz said \"I never got a massage from anybody. It's made up out of whole cloth.\" \nBut on Local 10 News (Jan. 22, 2015), Dershowitz said he got a massage but \"kept my \nunderwear on.\" \nBased on evidence such at this, there is no doubt as the false defamatory nature of \nDershowitz's statements against Edwards and Cassell. \nCONCLUSION AS TO PLAINTIFFS' CLAIMS \nPartial summary judgment is appropriate in this case, particularly because Florida law \nprovides strong protection for a person's reputation. As the Fourth DCA has explained in \nupholding a punitive damages award in a defamation case: \nFlorida's unusually high protection of personal reputation derives from the \ncommon consent of humankind and has ancient roots. It is highly valued by \ncivilized people. Our state constitution and common law powerfully support it. \nThis is a value as old as the Pentateuch and the Book of Exodus, and its command \nas clear as the Decalogue: \"Thou shall not bear false witness against thy \nneighbor.\" The personal interest in one's own good name and reputation \nsurpasses economics, business practices or money. It is a fundamental part of \npersonhood, of individual standing and one's sense of worth. In short, the \nwrongdoing underlying the punitive damages in this case has Florida law's most \nsevere condemnation, its highest blameworthiness, its most deserving culpability. \nFor [defamation] per se, reprehensibility is at its highest. \nLawnwood Medical Center, Inc. v. Sadow, 43 SO.3d 710, 729 (Fla. App. 4th DCA 2010). \n19 \nEFTA01111113\n", "char_count": 1890}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 19, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and CasselIs Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 20 of 20 \nThe record evidence and law described here provide clear support for the conclusion not \nonly that Dershowitz sexually abused Ms. \nbut also indisputably that Dershowitz made \nfalse and defamatory statements by alleging that two experienced and capable attorneys who \nthoroughly investigated and believed Ms. \nallegations in good faith should be disbarred. \nEqually obvious from the surrounding circumstances is the improper motive behind Alan \nDershowitz's high profile media assault. In his own words: \n\"There's an old saying: \n`If you have the law on your side, bang on the law. \nIf you have the facts on your side, bang on the facts. \nIf you have neither, bang on the table.' \nI have never believed that, but I do believe in a variation on that theme: \nIf you don't have the law or legal facts on your side, argue your case in the court \nof public opinion.\" \nAlan M. Dershowitz, Taking the Stand My Life in the Law \nWith neither law nor facts available to defend himself against charges of gross \nwrongdoing, Dershowitz followed his own prescription and took his defense to the court of \npublic opinion where he had an audience willing to ignore both law and facts. The lawyer \nvictims of Dershowitz's attacks remained temporarily silenced by their personal unwillingness to \nabandon their faith in the legal system or the interests of their pro bono client. They filed this \naction to protect their interests, and the record evidence now supports their entitlement to partial \nsummary judgment on the issues that Dershowitz made false and defamatory statements about \nthem and, in addition, that the Edwards and Cassell suffered presumed damage because these \nstatements are defamatory per se. \n20 \nEFTA01111114\n", "char_count": 1853}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 20, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 21 of 20 \nIII. \nEDWARDS AND CASSELL ARE ENTITLED TO SUMMARY JUDGMENT \nON THE COUNTERCLAIM ON THE BASIS OF THEIR AFFIRMATIVE \nDEFENSE OF LITIGATION PRIVILEGE. \nAs the Court is aware, Edwards and Cassell have pending a motion to dismiss both \ncounts of the First Amended Counterclaim on the basis of litigation privilege and other \narguments. In this motion for summary, Edwards and Cassell specifically incorporated herein by \nreference the arguments advanced there. If for any reason the Court were to find that the motion \nto dismiss could not be granted based on the litigation privilege, Edwards and Cassell are clearly \nentitled to summary judgment on both counts of the First Amended Counterclaim for many of \nthe same reasons articulated there — as well as based on new evidence outside the pleadings, such \nas the fact that Dershowitz has admitted that the allegations Edwards and Cassell filed were \nrelevant to the federal case \nUnder Florida's litigation privilege, \"absolute immunity,\" a party and her attorneys are \n\"exempted from liability to an action for defamatory words published in the course of judicial \nproceedings, regardless of how false or malicious the statements may be, as long as the \nstatements bear some relation to or connection with the subject of inquiry.\" Zuccarelli v. \nBarfield, 165 So. 3d 830, 831 (4th DCA 2015); see also Levin, Middlebrooks, Mabie, Thomas, \nMayes & Mitchell, P.A. v. U.S. Fire Ins. Co., 639 So. 2d 606 (Fla. 1994). The immunity \nafforded to statements made during the course of a judicial proceeding extends not only to the \nparties in a proceeding but to judges, witnesses, and counsel as well. Id. The litigation privilege \napplies in all causes of action, whether for common-law torts or statutory violations. See \n21 \nEFTA01111115\n", "char_count": 1918}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 21, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 22 of 20 \nEchevarria, McCalla, Raymer, Barrett & Frappier v. Cole, 950 So. 2d 380 (Fla. 2007). \nDefamatory statements made by lawyer while interviewing a witness in preparation for and \nconnected to pending litigation are covered by the absolute immunity conferred by the litigation \nprivilege. See DelMonico v. Traynor, 50 So. 3d 4 (Fla. Dist. Ct. App. 4th Dist. 2010), review \ngranted, 47 So. 3d 1287 (Fla. 2010). And because it appears to be undisputed that Dershowitz is \na \"public figure,\" he must carry the extra burden of proving his defamation counterclaim by \n\"clear and convincing evidence.\" Zorc v. Jordan, 765 So. 2d 768, 771 (Fla. 4th DCA 2000). \nThese authorities effectively narrow the issue on the pending counterclaim to the \nresolution of a single question: did the filing of Ms. \naffidavit in the \nCrime Victim's Rights Act cases currently pending the Federal District Court for the Southern \nDistrict of Florida have \"some relationship\" to that proceeding. \nDershowitz has himself \nanswered that question in the affirmative on multiple occasions during his recent deposition: \nQ: \nYou were asked on the occasion of that same Don Lemon CNN interview \nwhat possible motive the attorneys, Brad Edwards and Paul Cassell, could \nhave had to have identified you in the pleading that was filed in the Crime \nVictim's Rights Act Case. Do you remember that? \nA: \nThat's right, yes. \nQ: \nAnd your response was quote — \"They want to be able to challenge the \nplea agreement. I got the very good deal for Jeffrey Epstein.\" \nDid you make a response? \nA: \nYes. \nQ: \nSo, you recognized as of January 5, 2015, that the reason why the \nstatements were filed in the Crime Victim's Rights Act case was because \n22 \nEFTA01111116\n", "char_count": 1856}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 22, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 23 of 20 \nthe Crime Victim's Act case had, as an objective, setting aside the plea \nagreement that you had negotiated for Jeffrey Epstein, correct? \nA. \nThere were multiple motives. One of the motives was crassly financial. \nThey were trying to line their pockets with money. But as I also said, and \nI said this over and over again, they profiled me. They sat down with their \nclient, knowing that she has a history of lying, knowing that she is easily \nsuggestible, and they basically pressured her, according to my sources, \ninto including me when she didn't want to include me, because by \nincluding me, they could make a claim, false as it was, could make a false \nclaim that a person who negotiated the NPA was also criminally involved \nwith her. \nsss \nYou stated, quote: \"If they,\" referring to Bradley Edwards and Paul \nCassell, \"could find a lawyer who helped draft the agreement\" — \nA. \nRight. \nQ. \n-- \"who also was a criminal having sex, wow, that could help them blow \nup the agreement.\" \nDid you make that statement on — \nA. \nYes. I just repeated it now, yes, under oath, yes. \nDepo. of Alan M. Dershowitz (Oct. 16, 2015), at 217-220 (Exhibit #13). \nFor all the reasons previously advanced, Edwards and Cassell are entitled to have both \ncounts of the First Amended Counterclaim against them dismissed — as they argue in their \npending motion to dismiss. But in addition, a motion for summary judgment is the proper way to \nintroduce Dershowitz's concession and other evidence to the Court. And given the obviously \nundisputed concession that Dershowitz made in his deposition, summary judgment is also \nappropriate on Count I of the counterclaim because of litigation privilege. \n23 \nEFTA01111117\n", "char_count": 1838}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 23, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 24 of 20 \nAnd then, with summary judgment appropriate on Count I of the pending counterclaim, it \nalso follows that summary judgment is also appropriate as to Count II as well. As explained at \ngreater length in the motion to dismiss, nothing in the record established any disputed fact \nshowing anything other than that Edwards and Cassell did not make out-of-court statements \ncontaining actionable defamatory allegations against Dershowitz. Moreover, in ruling on this \nsummary judgment motion, the \"allegedly defamatory words must be read in the context of the \nentire publication, and if the documents could not possibly have a defamatory effect, the \ncomplaint may be dismissed . . . .\" Zorc v. Jordan, 765 So. 2d 768, 771 (Fla.4th DCA 2000). \nDershowitz has simply collected snippets of emails to try and cobble together a viable \ndefamation claim. But when these snippets are each read in context — as this Court must do in \nruling on this summary judgment motion — it is clear that Edwards and Cassell were not \nengaging in a media dialog with Dershowitz, but instead simply representing their client and \ntrying to avoid an out-of-court statements about Dershowitz. \nFor example, Dershowitz \nremarkably tries to allege that Edwards and Cassell defamed with the statement that \"out of \nrespect for the court's desire to keep this case from being litigated in the press, we are not going \nto respond at this time to specific claims of indignation by anyone.\" \nFirst Amended \nCounterclaim at ¶ 32. Moreover, Dershowitz tries to claim a defamation occurred when Cassell \nsent an email to a journalist stating \"I represent . . . the young woman who was sexually abused \nby\" Prince Andrew and Dershowitz. This statement, read in context, was nothing more than an \nidentification of Cassell's client in a way that permits a media representation to understand who \n24 \nEF\n... [truncated, 2011 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01111095/23 or ?id=EFTA01111095&page=23]", "char_count": 2011}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 24, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 25 of 20 \nis being discussed. See Cassell Depo. at 310-12 (Oct 17, 2015) (Exhibit #3). And in addition, \nEdwards and Cassell were simply making a \"fair report\" about properly-filed legal pleadings \nthat, as Dershowitz's concession in his deposition demonstrates, were relevant to the case at \nhand. For all these reasons, summary judgment in favor of Edwards and Cassell is appropriate \non the First Amended Counterclaim. \nCONCLUSION \nFor the foregoing reasons, defendant, the Court should grant defendant Bradley J. \nEdwards, Esq., and Paul Cassell, Esq. partial summary judgment in their favor on the issues of \nthe false and defamatory nature of the statements alleged in their complaint, as well as the \npresumed damages that flow from them. The Court should also grant summary judgment in their \nfavor on the First Amended Counterclaim filed against them by Dershowitz. \n25 \nEFTA01111119\n", "char_count": 1020}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 25, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 26 of 20 \nI HEREBY CERTIFY that true \nect copy of the fo \nDing was sent via E-Serve to all \nCounsel on the attached list, this \n•ay of November 015 \na \nar No.: 169440 \ney E-Mail(s): isx@searcylaw.com and mep@searcylaw.com \nary E-Mail: s_carolateam@searcylaw.com \nearcy Denney Scarola Barnhart & Shipley, P.A. \n2139 Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard \nWest Palm Beach, Florida 33409 \nPhone:f 5611 686-6300/Fax:(5611383-945 I \nSEAN D. REYES \nUtah Attorney General \nBy: JONI J. JONES \nJOEL A. FERRE \nAssistant Utah Attorneys General \nBradley J. Edwards \nFARMER, JAFFE, WEISSING, \nEDWARDS, FISTOS & LEHRMAN, P.L. \n425 North Andrews Avenue, Suite 2 \nFort Lauderdale, Florida 33301 \nTelephone (9541524-2820/Facsimile (954) 524-2822 \nE-mail: brad®oathtojustice.com \nAnd \nPaul G. Cassell \nPro Hoc Vice Motion Pending \nS.J. Quinney College of Law at the \nUniversity of Utah \n383 S. University St. \nSalt Lake City, UT 84112 \nTelephone:80 l-585-5202/Facsimile:801-585-6833 \nE-Mail:cassello@law.utah,edu \nAttorneys for Plaintiffs Bradley J. Edwards and Paul G. Cassell \n26 \nEFTA01111120\n", "char_count": 1194}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 26, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nEdwards and Cassells Motion for Summary Judgment on Liability \nPage 27 of 20 \nCOUNSEL LIST \nThomas Emerson Scott, Jr., Esquire \nThomas.scott®csklegal.com; \nSteven.safra©csklegal.com \nCole Scott & Kissane P.A. \n9150 S Dadeland Boulevard, Suite 1400 \nMiami, FL 33156 \nPhone: (305)-350-5329 \nFax: (305)-373-2294 \nAttorneys for Defendant \n27 \nRichard A. Simpson (pro hac vice) \nrsimpson@wilevrein.com \nMary E. Borja (pro hac vice) \nmboria@wilevrein.coM \nAshley E. Eiler (pro hac vice) \naeiler@wilevrein.corn \nWILEY REIN LLP \n1776 K St. NW \nWashington, DC 20006 \nPhone: (202) 719-7000 \nFax: (202) 719-7049 \nEFTA01111121\n", "char_count": 674}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01111095", "page_number": 27, "text_content": "EVIDENTIARY SUPPORT FOR PLAINTIFFS' \nMOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT \n1. \nVideo Presentation. \n2. \nAffidavit of \n3. \nDeposition of Paul Cassell (Oct. 16 & 17, 2015). \n4. \nPalm Beach Police Department 87-page report. \n5. \nFlight logs for Epstein's private jet. \n6. \nJane Doe 102 Complaint. \n7. \nExcerpt of Jeffrey Epstein Taking The Fifth when asked about Dershowitz. \n8. \nDeposition Excerpts of Juan Alessi. \n9. \nDeposition Excerpts of Alfredo Rodriguez. \n10. \nDocuments reflecting efforts to depose Dershowitz regarding his knowledge of Epstein's \nsexual abuse in 2009, 2011, 2013, and January 2015. \n11. \nPhotograph showing Prince Andrew with his arm around Ms. Giuffre. \n12. \nDeposition of Alan Dershowitz (Oct. 15, 2015). \n13. \nDeposition of Alan Dershowitz (Oct. 16, 2015). \n14. \nAffidavit of Bradley J. Edwards. \n15. \nAffidavit of Paul G. Cassell. \n16. \nDe osition excerpts  of Ms. \nMs. Adrianna Mucinska, and Ms. \n17. \nAlfredo Rodriguez Copy of Jeffrey Epstein Telephone Directory. \n28 \nEFTA01111122\n", "char_count": 1003}]}