{"efta_number": "EFTA01083777", "page_count": 17, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA01083777", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA01083777.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA01083777", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "BEAUDIN / \nGANZE \nJuly 15, 2013 \nRichard Kahn \nHBRK Associates Inc. \nNew York, New York 10022 \nRE: \nZorro Ranch — Pool/Natatorium System Analysis \nProject #9357.00 \nEXECUTIVE SUMMARY \nconsulting engineers, inc. \nBeaudin Ganze Consulting Engineers was tasked to investigate/analyze and provide recommendations for \nthe ongoing issues related to the existing pool area/natatorium conditioning system. The Existing system \nis not maintaining industry standards or owner/user required space temperature and or humidification \nlevels. The mechanical system components are not regional and are problematic related to service and \nmaintenance. \nThe site investigation determined that the existing pool conditioning unit is currently inoperable and at the \npoint of diminishing return on repairs versus replacement. Recommendation is replacement with new unit \nsized to pool room/Natatorium conditions and desired temperatures and humidity. \nOptions for levels of replacement are provided within the report for determination of next step. BGCE \nalways recommends the full modifications to help insure that the end result is a system that function to \nthe best of the owners expectations. BGCE is also aware that budgetary and scheduling constraints have \nto be accounted for. \nThere are specific baseline modifications that are required for any of the proposed options to perform to \nany degree of pool space conditioning. The baseline modifications in general are to provide a vapor \nbarrier to control moisture migration into the surround structure and to assist in condensate control. \nSincerely, \nMorgan Royce, PE \nAssociate Principal \nMBR:mbr \n7007 Wyoming NE. Suite F-2. Albuquerque. NM 87109 .p. \nALBUQUERQUE \nAIBUOIROUE \nDENSER \n10111CORINS JENSON \nWA \nwwwlsce corn \nC Istc*of .nibed kAtarlacu Wnsn Eto:acnr Sumseuty6xx \nEFTA01083777\n", "char_count": 1834}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01083777", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Zorro Ranch \nStanley, NM \nPool/Natatorium System Review \nPREPARED FOR: \nRichard Kahn \nNew York, New York 10022 \nBY: \nBEAUDIN GANZE CONSULTING ENGINEERS, INC. \n7007 Wyoming NE. &Ate F-2. Albuquerque, NM 87109 • p. \nALBUQUERQUE \nllBUOLIEROI DOM FORICOUINS \nEFTA01083778\n", "char_count": 268}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01083777", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "BEAUDIN/ \nGANZE \nconsulting engineers. inc. \nTABLE OF CONTENTS \nSection \nPage \nIntroduction \n3 \nExisting Conditions \n4 \nAnalysis \n6 \nRecommendations \n8 \nBenefit to Cost Comparison \n10 \nDrawings \nSUP I \n11 \nSUP Total \n12 \nSUP Option I \n13 \nSUP Option 2 \n14 \nSUP Option 3 \n15 \nSUP Option 4 \n16 \n2IPagc \nEFTA01083779\n", "char_count": 314}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01083777", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "BEAUDIN/ \nGANZE \nconsulting engineers. inc. \nINTRODUCTION \nBeaudin Ganze Consulting Engineers was tasked to investigate/analyze and provide recommendations for the \nongoing issues related to the existing pool area/natatorium conditioning system. The Existing system is not \nmaintaining industry standards or owner/user required space temperature and or humidification levels. The \nmechanical system components are not regional and are problematic related to service and maintenance. \nA site investigation/interview was performed in May of 2013 with Brice Gordon. Owner/User requirements \nspace temperature/humidity and pool temperatures were confirmed and documented for use in the analysis. \nExisting conditions were noted and available record drawings were made available for use in the analysis. \nRecords of repairs, previous recommendations from manufacturer/contractors, and material quotes were made \navailable for use in the analysis/recommendations. \nA ductwork camera inspection was performed by JB Henderson to insure that the existing ductwork was in \ngood condition and was not collapsed or restricted in anyway. The inspection determined that there were no \nobstructions visible and that the ductwork was in good condition. \nCalculations have been performed in the selection of the proposed replacement equipment to insure viability \nof connection to the existing utilities. Modifications to the existing system are noted within the report. \nWage \nEFTA01083780\n", "char_count": 1474}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01083777", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "BEAUDIN/ \nGANZE \nconsulting engineers. inc. \nEXISTING CONDITIONS \nThe Pool area was completed Circa 2000. The pool area appears to be an upgrade from the original spa room \ndesign. There is little documentation related to the alterations made between the spa room to the present pool \nroom. \nA pool conditioning unit was installed to provide conditioning of the pool space. The unit's operating \ncapacity was scheduled to be a Nominal 5 Ton unit capable of 25 pounds per hour of water with 2,400 cfm air \nflow at 0.60 inches of external static pressure. The unit power is 208 volt 1 phase 60 hertz with 56 full load \namps and an MOCP of 70 amps (fuse size). The unit is water cooled through the main building condenser \nloop system. The unit is designed to draw a percentage of outside/ventilation air in through a common non \npressurized ventilation air duct/plenum that also serves the remainder of the building conditioning systems \nwith ventilation air. The unit is controlled through a room thermostat/humidistat and is connected to the \nbuilding control system. The unit is provided with condensate drainage. The unit is not connected to the pool \nheating water system located in a separate area. The unit is fully ducted to the pool room through separate \nsupply and return galvanized sheet metal duct systems. The unit is located in a central mechanical room \nlocated in the main building adjacent to the gym/pool. Refer to attached SUP 1 drawing for reference. \nThe pool room is ducted from the pool conditioning unit through a single below grade supply duct (16\" \ndiameter per design) that supplies five floor registers located at sole exterior wall with doors with integral \nwindows. Return air is ducted back to the pool conditioning unit through two side wall and two ceiling return \ngrilles located opposite the supply. There is no mechanical exhaust from the pool area. \nThe pool area is fully enclosed with five French doors leading to the exterior and a single French door leading \nt\n... [truncated, 3234 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01083777/4 or ?id=EFTA01083777&page=4]", "char_count": 3234}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01083777", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "BEAUDIN/ \nGANZE \nconsulting engineers, inc. \nWet Deck Area — Approximately 460 square feet \nRoom Volume — Approximately 22,000 cubic feet \nII \nI \na \nIS \ngoiairic \nPictures: Natatorium Layout \n5IP a g \nEFTA01083782\n", "char_count": 214}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01083777", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "BEAUDIN/ \nGANZE \nconsulting engineers. inc. \nANALYSIS \nBy simple observation of the pool conditioning unit maintenance/repair records it is apparent that the unit is \nnot maintaining the pool area at the desired/standard space conditions. The unit is at the end of its useful life \nbased on standard engineering practice and based on the amount of repairs the equipment has received over \nthe recent years. \nThe question is not whether a new unit of sufficient capacity should be installed; it is whether a new unit can \nbe installed in the existing system conditions and performs as desired/needed to maintain the standard space \nconditions. The answer is not likely without additional modifications. \nThe best way to approach what modifications should or could be performed is to look at the standard design \npractices and compare against the existing pool setup. \nIndoor Pools or natatoriums are one of the most difficult facilities to design. They are designed for human \ncomfort and enjoyment. And for this reason they have to consider human health and the health of the \nbuilding. \nComfort related to this installation is primarily based on the desired temperature of the water and space. Per \nthe occupied/unoccupied conditions stated the facility is within standard practices, nothing out of the norm. \nHumidity control related to this installation is based to the space relative humidity and is a direct relation to \nthe comfort conditions and physical conditions of the pool. The optimum condition is 40-60% and is in line \nwith the requested level. This condition is the primary driver on sizing of the pool conditioning equipment. \nIndoor air quality requirements are typically related to commercial natatoriums but recent studies also \nrecommend for residential facilities. Indoor air quality relates to the chemicals being used in the pool water \nquality and the amount of people expected in the pool. Certain pool chemical can produce byproducts that are \nbest mitigated using fresh ai\n... [truncated, 4111 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01083777/6 or ?id=EFTA01083777&page=6]", "char_count": 4111}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01083777", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "BEAUDIN \nGANZE  /\nconsulting engineers, inc. \nthe vapor pressure of the water air mixture will permeate through almost any structure or material to \nsome degree, including concrete. If allowed to condense within the material the material will typical \nexperience an adverse effect. Most common is cracking, mold, and efflorescence (cement materials). \nIt is unclear of the insulation level, presence of a vapor barrier or the arrangement of these materials \nthroughout the natatorium. \nOn this same note interior surfaces that are likely to produce condensate are washed with supply air to \nabsorb condensate and increase the wall surface temperature before damage can occur. This is \nprimary driver in the configuration of the air distribution system. Windows, skylights, areas of low \ninsulation values require air washing to increase the surface temperature. In large volume pools air \nmovement or air change rates typically provide for all other wall ceiling surfaces when vapor barriers \nand insulation are provided. But area/volumes in ceilings that allow for pockets of stagnant air must \nalso be air washed or broken up to insure condensate does not form or if it does that it is absorbed in \nthe air stream and the surface temperature is increased. Pockets of trapped or stagnant are can have \nrelative humidity levels that can exceed 80% even when the system return is reading 50%. At this \ntime the only surfaces that are provided with an air wash are the windows. \nHealth is related to all the factors discussed. If too hot or too cold or too humid it can cause adverse effect to \nhumans. If condensation forms within structure it can cause mold growth, rust structures, cause excessive un \naccounted weight to structures, all potential health concerns. \nNatatoriums are also one of the most costly facilities to maintain and operate even when constructed properly \nto all design requirements. If anyone of the above factors is not considered correctly then the costs and likely \nrepairs \n... [truncated, 2286 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01083777/7 or ?id=EFTA01083777&page=7]", "char_count": 2286}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01083777", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "BEAUDIN \nGANZE  /\nconsulting engineers, inc. \nRECOMMENDATIONS \nThe following are mechanical/electrical/plumbing recommendations arranged in order of least cost only. \nRanking of solution is typically directly related to cost but will be discussed later in the report. Costs are to be \nconfirmed by contractor/supplier and are opinions at this time, not quotes. For any of the option to be viable \ncertain building element or architectural changes are required. These are considered to be baseline \nrequirements for any of the options presented. \nBaseline: \nProvide a water/vapor barrier in the form of a coating that is applied to all the existing interior surfaces of the \npool walls and ceiling (One common Manufacturer is Tnemec). Seal all air leaks from the exterior to interior; \nthis includes the air leak from the supply duct into the wall cavity at the water isolation valves. \nCost: To be determined by Architect/Contractor dependent on desired final aesthetics of the area but owner. \nPicture: Access panel to Wall Void — Air Leakage into chase from supply duct below grade. \nOption #1 \nRefer to SUP Option 1 Drawing \nInstall a new pool conditioning unit in the exact location of the existing and connect to the existing system \nconditions (specifically ducting, condenser water, electrical). The new unit will be capable of removing 36 \npounds per hour of water at occupied conditions, 95 MBH total cooling capacity, and 67.1 MBH sensible \ncooling capacity at altitude. Unit air flow is 3800 cfm at 1.5 inches external static pressure and with a variable \nfrequency drive motor for operational turn down during non occupied conditions. \nAdjustments to air release rates at the supply diffusers, outside air intake and condenser water flow rate. \nIntegration of new unit into existing control system for monitoring operation. \nModifications are required to the electrical service at the unit to increase from a 70 amp breaker to an 80 amp \nbreaker. In addition reconfiguration of ductwork a\n... [truncated, 2220 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01083777/8 or ?id=EFTA01083777&page=8]", "char_count": 2220}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01083777", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Cost of Installation/Modifications/adjustments to systems: \nTotal Cost: \nOption #2 \nRefer to SUP Option 2 Drawing \nSame as Option #1 but to include the following: \nBEAUDIN/ \nGANZE \nconsulting engineers. inc. \n$23,000 +NMGRT \n$69,000 +NMGRT \nInstall an exhaust fan capable of 600 cfm continuously from the pool area. Preferred location of the exhaust \nintake is above the spa. This unfortunately is not economically viable. \nAlternate locations of the exhaust fan are: \n1. In the wall cavity of the exterior wall (requires access panel, interior/exterior grille, power, \nducting, control). \n2. In the Pool Equipment Vault (requires concrete wall cut, grille, connection to existing exhaust \nduct, power, and control). \n3. Multiple other options dependent on available budget. \nOption #1 Cost: \nCost of Exhaust: \nTotal Cost: \nOption #3 \nRefer to SUP Option 3 Drawing \nSame as Option #1 but to include the following: \n$69,000+ NMGRT \n$5,000 + NMGRT \n$74,000 +NMGRT \nInstall a new return path from the pool with exhaust; utilize the existing return air path as a supply air path. \nPool heating water from the pool conditioning unit will be provided. \nThe existing wall patch located at the common wall of the mechanical room and pool shall be used as the new \nreturn air path from the pool area. A soffit shall be created to enclose the new return duct with multiple high \nreturn grilles. The path will also allow for piping from the pool conditioning unit to the pool water heating \nsystem. The path will also allow for the relocation of the existing humidistat/thermostat to the exterior wall by \nallowing for a conduit path. The existing return air path will be modified to provide supply air to the ceiling \narea using the two existing side wall grilles (the ceiling returns will be capped). The exhaust fan will be \nlocated in the pool equipment room. \nOption #1 Cost: \nCost of additions: \nTotal Cost: \nOption #4 \nRefer to SUP Option 4 Drawing \nSame as Option #3 but to include the following: \n$69,0\n... [truncated, 2237 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01083777/9 or ?id=EFTA01083777&page=9]", "char_count": 2237}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01083777", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "BEAUDIN/ \nGANZE \nconsulting engineers, inc. \nCost of additions: \n$8,000 + NMGRT \nTotal Cost: \n$97,000 +NMGRT \nBENEFITS TO COST COMPARISON \nFirst it has to be stated that the only insurable way that a natatorium can be maintained to user expectations is \nthrough maintenance of the pool temperature and water chemistry. Any drastic change in these conditions will \ncause the remaining components to become ineffective. Second is the space temperature and understanding \nthat the pool conditioning system is selected base on set temperature and humidity points. Alterations to these \npoints will keep the system from performing as designed. \nBaseline requirements if not incorporated will continue to cause degradation of the structure and surfaces of \nthe natatorium and surrounding areas. It will also not guarantee that the pool conditioning system is size \nappropriately. \nOption 1 is the minimal modifications that can be done with the hopes of maintaining the natatorium at the \ndesire conditions. This is less of an option as it is a requirement since the current unit is essentially defunct. \nThe benefits of the option are a pool conditioning unit that is sized to handle the pool conditions. The negative \nto this option is a larger horsepower supply air fan to overcome increased duct static pressure caused by a \nnecessary increase in air flow to the space. Subsequently air noise through the floor grilles will increase based \non the 50% increase in air flow. It is unclear as to what level of noise will be experienced. This is similar at \nthe return grilles. It is still likely that the ceilings will form condensation in the winter. It is a guaranteed that \nthe pool odors will continue to spread to the adjacent spaces of the house. \nOption 2 will benefit beyond option 1 by controlling the odors currently released to the adjacent house and \nwill provide an increased level of indoor air quality. The negative to this option are the same for option I. \nOption 3 will benefit beyond Op\n... [truncated, 2745 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01083777/10 or ?id=EFTA01083777&page=10]", "char_count": 2745}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01083777", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "OUT4 I 1,V Ant p4CT \nFool. LCMCIA1014941-1\nUNIT -VErCenat.. \nt\nJ \nA \nCoore,finte.WA-re-g-\n171 ft...4.i AN° 17 0Weg-\nZO Oar/ \nor-1 \nefirlit-t• F+1 \n \nWAtt-\nfoal, bit& \n1 \nerie4\n44 \npi o \n10.0 \nart. Lk_ \nWrtir-/•.a \n12•XT \nair \n91a\nJ. {C\nr\n \n--\nIttr \nilk•ToL L.le. 74e \nctot- \nr t . \nas-nAL nseemeni FLoora 14-&-r-1 \ner..-LLe- W • \nplaog. +or  r\nst.4 t4, 5-S \nexteAnlexhavni-\n&cm petnalif raw • \natesz \n+v. -4.+. \nAr. \nTiP 2 4 \n100 re Or \neicHisier \nAst IrriNe \n \n7,\nc etr4ANLI worrvief..) \nct ea-rtitra.4 --r-frz \nRAIL \nTeARSCM-0...\n=—aIL`IrcfiiI \n I1 \nf\nFICACY ea. \nTHIS \nSET \nOF \nDRAWINGS \nLABELED \n'SUP', \nFOR \nSUPPLEMENTAL, \nIS \nPREPARED \nBY \nTHE \nGENERAL \nCONTRACTOR AS A SUMMARY OF VERBAL INFORMATION, \nDIRECTIVES AND SKETCHES PROVIDED BY THE OWNER AND \nHIS DESIGN CONSULTANTS \nP1 1 ISA NOTES\"'\n itC4.- \nS CA \nCOLME) -Waal' 01 Ye CB-9•fre.L0 \n'Pratt \"1 /4 - FitalgaaMtr. \ncorr. \n \n- \nLcH, r-4.4cm ex7c: \nwLectz - T \nr.0 rt./..0.0 \nti sr.= F \ntrce...e.enapmes\n)\n.... \n j---cv-Adin& Key \nPer \n) \n9. \ni l l \nIn \nZORRO RANCH \nStanley. New Mexico \nDescription \n1 \nA \nK0e \n:>•9.11 \nDate 3.899 \nEFTA01083788\n", "char_count": 1106}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01083777", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "wrordea fit V4101-\nNPW UNIT \nCo/toed-I-0 \neiwrhey \neoGiCOCe•c7 \nt-tew \nkivuodlit-f- Jortistg.60.1-\n(A1-) 11-&kit141 ri \nk 5 \nAfro pool \nIn \nwofutiiiee, \nFitutaniT \nI \nAn4 coemedee! \n40 Pool 14ecifoi \nepteriemi \nV-0\n-L-\nfi\n6 i;1.1_ 1ht \n21sTeP. t,,Je 1-1,1 \nPLAsTful. FY.-\npeloCttled .11SI \nOVA) walLa-\nfrAiefra wl \nfee. \nfa I \nEY•itsd-ar \nfkg. ItITAHZ \n- \n6A L.GOI \n—4. Vey \nTars-Ace \ni t \nTHIS SET OF DRAWINGS LABE-LEO 'SUP'. FCR \nSUPPLEMENTAL. \nIS \nPREPARED \nBY \nTHE \nGENERAL \nCONTRACTOR AS A SUMMARY OF VERBAL INFORMATION, \nDIRECTIVES AND SKETCHES PROVIDED BY THE OWNER AND \nHIS DESIGN CONSULTANTS \nP.115I-1 '\" a;\n ES \ncc, woe, -It-Rex' Of 7s Cer.3•S 4e.j1.o \nP..62112 212:-L- LArs veArs \nNF-T \nersotc^ \nery y. \n-\nC.71C. \nLATH.,...icm 247.Z >3 \nFLctt ,_ 7-4.-veAvne rsm2m9 \n4 (24:4,243 \nkXe.12.Cribq \nYa \nr.t \nKE-7-\nZORRO RANCH \nStanley. New Mexico \nDescription \n<-1 \nQS,/ ..)•o•nl \nDate \n3 . 8 . 99 \nEFTA01083789\n", "char_count": 917}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01083777", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "FPM \n3. \nPAK!' \nf ie.,SE \n00 \ngo \n°.• 0 \nEl 0 \na \n1 \nZORRO RANCH \nStanley. New Mexico \n13\nBradbarY\nStatiMI I \n0 \nEFTA01083790\n", "char_count": 126}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01083777", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "-4 \n0 \n1 \nyS \nBradbury \nYin Len Wax. \nEl Stamm I \n00 \nPART \nalksEMENr \nFL-(=\":=Fz. 1=1-.s..14\nZORRO RANCH \nStanley. New Mexico \nEFTA01083791\n", "char_count": 141}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01083777", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "wI\nµ if-01 \n0 UT4 \nDog. \n1-1011*-V \nEV11/.54., \n(AnclAiot4M-Iti -\"\\\nt\nGoppatk76K.WATele_ \nAND \nrovveg-\nsunif-4-\"TI of-1 \n6'; \n- \neAtrm Form  Ea44171J\nTool \nwht, \nr'17\nfooL.1-0,4ya I \n471.44-evvi \n\"I\nto-o \nL \n&TEA IA6 71...e \nrt-oSTBR. \nii \n!reit, f-t Option) ak- ._. \ni \nI \nI \nl\n \ni \nimLA-f. ie...sttiett ,\nim eat i-ti-11.1 .1P \n4 1 4-•• G cve \n-rw-vt QM, >a. \n..car\nTwee.r\ns. \ni'vrto \nL I r\\1 \npe,f-w-z-iv Tel \nEire/ \nr‘lociAl-edt 1-6mi,tt.A. 1 \nf flier roc/ ki\nUhk/e4FrirL \nrA'se-triEnT I=LooFa \n000g- \n44/7 F11 \nLi g.; \n, Cr\n•\ni.442 \nF-frf \nexPAni exA \npap \nl\nlet 4-\n11'4 \nteAttniler \nNO. irrin•tce)t \n-\n7721.'=1. iti=1;• \n6A-i7\ne \n-TAtact \nP+\n.O \nvie 141 -ty \ns:CrE.:5 \nSPA \nCOL,no \ncn \n \n 2.)44..5.:4\"yar* 3,4(04.\nydr. it. O. \n' , VOL. 1-474, \n- \nr \nF.A.vzAo \n&XL-WM .1y,\nREV LX.O.. \n4 \n_ \n9.1\n3mzAce-rL \ni \n, \np\ns \nTHIS \nSET \nOF \nDRAWINGS \nLABELED \n'SUP-, \nFOR \nSUPPLEMENTAL. \nIS \nPREPARED \nBY \nTHE \nGENERAL \nCONTRACTOR AS A SUMMARY OF VERBAL INFORMATION. \nDIRECTIVES AND SKETCHES PROVIDED BY THE OMER AND \nHIS DESIGN CONSULTANTS \n \n ~CCi 4nO t F11-,+,15 \nexerzcrse \n•\n \nKey \nYe: \nZORRO RANCH \nStanley, Nen Mexico \nDescription \n2\ncev \nDote 3.8-99 \nEFTA01083792\n", "char_count": 1167}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01083777", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "- \n- — — \nigUl \nvgir \n2,400 \nart9, \n32;o\nQQ\na9 \n0<\ngo, \ne0h.\no \nPARzr L e3L5Emeur \nF1-<=ttor:=-. PL.'-\ng0 \na 00 \n• \" • \n0 \n00 \nZORRO RANCH \nStanley, New Mexico \n1914 *V \n4I1 W.170 \nBradbury I Won Sim Groom \nU stamm \n' \nEFTA01083793\n", "char_count": 232}]}