{"efta_number": "EFTA01078948", "page_count": 14, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA01078948", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA01078948.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA01078948", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "IN \nTHE CIRCUIT COURT \nOF \nTHE \nSEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN \nAND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA \nCASE NO.: CACE 15-000072 \nBRADLEY J. EDWARDS and PAUL G. \nCASSELL, \nPlaintiff(s), \nvs. \nALAN M. DERSHOWITZ, \nDefendant(s). \nSUPPLEMENTAL ANSWERS TO DEFENDANT DERSHOWITZ'S FIRST SET OF \nDOCUMENT REQUESTS TO BRADLEY J. EDWARDS AND PAUL G. CASSELL \nPlaintiffs, Bradley J. Edwards and Paul G. Cassell, by and through their undersigned \nattorneys and pursuant to Rule 1.350, Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, hereby file this \nsupplemental response to Defendant, Alan M. Dershowitz's, First Set of Document Requests \ndated February 11, 2015 to Plaintiffs as follows: \nAll production materials as to which there is no objection are available for inspection and \ncopying at the offices of Plaintiffs' counsel as soon as the Defendant's past due production has \nbeen made available to Plaintiffs. \n1. All Documents Concerning the alleged \"character assassination\" referenced in \nparagraph 8 of the Complaint. \nSee complaint from Jeffrey Epstein v. Bradley J. Edwards. See also pleadings and \nresponse to Interrogatory #1 filed in this case. Plaintiffs have requested documents in the \npossession of Defendant Dershowitz which memorialize his character assassination of Plaintiffs. \nNumerous documents within the Defendant's still incomplete production reflect false and \ndefamatory assaults on the Plaintiffs' character by the Defendant. \n2. All Documents Concerning Dershowitz's alleged \"participation in Epstein's \ncriminal conduct\" referenced in paragraph 16 of the Complaint. \nEdwards and Cassell object to this request as being vague, overbroad, and unreasonably \nburdensome, as well as seeking irrelevant and inadmissible evidence and information not \nreasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence. Edwards and Cassell have \ncollected many pages of documents pointing to Dershowitz's involvement in Epstein's sexual \nEFTA01078948\n", "char_count": 1951}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01078948", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \nabuse of underage girls over a nearly seven year period of time, including legal work that they \ndid in connection with the long-running case of Does v. United States, 9:08-cv-80736-KAM \n(S.D. Fla. filed July 7, 2008) including Docket Entry 291 and all accompanying exhibits. See \nalso all publicly available materials in the long-running case of Epstein v. Edwards et al.,\n502009CA040800,0000vfBAO (Circuit Court of the 15 Judicial Cir. For Palm Beach County, \nFlorida), including for example Edwards' motion for summary judgment. See also all publicly \navailable police reports and investigative files generated in the course of the Palm Beach Police \nDepartment's criminal investigation of Jeffrey Epstein. They have also represented numerous \nvictims in civil actions against Jeffrey Epstein, which involved many pleadings which are public \ndocuments. Of course, these cases also involved numerous attorney-client communications as \nwell as materials covered by the work-product doctrine. \nSee also all pleadings, discovery responses and depositions in the following civil \nproceedings in which Jeffrey Epstein was named as a party: \nState Court in Palm Beach County: \n502008CA037319xxxxMB \n502008CA025129moothe \n502008CA006332xxxxMB \n502008CA028058xxxxMB \n502008CA028051mocMB \n502008CA020614xxmcMB \n502008CA006596xxxxMB \n502008CA005240xxxxMB. \nUnited States Southern District of Florida: \n08-80893 \n08-80232 \n08-80380 \n08-80994 \n08-80993 \n08-80811 \n08-80381 \n08-80804 \n08-80811 \n09-80469 \n09-80591 \n2 \nEFTA01078949\n", "char_count": 1682}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01078948", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \n09-80656 \n09-80802 \n09-81092 \n10-81111 \n10-80447 \nSee also pleadings and response to Interrogatories #1 and #2 filed in this case. \nOn information and belief, Dershowitz also possesses significant information that is \nresponsive to this request — information that Edwards and Cassell have requested from \nDershowitz in their requests for production. \n3. All Documents Concerning Dershowitz's alleged knowledge that the filing \nreferenced in paragraph 17 of the Complaint was \"an entirely proper and well-founded \npleading.\" \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 below. \n4. All Documents Concerning the alleged \"massive public media assault\" referenced \nin paragraph 17 of the Complaint. \nFor details regarding the massive public media assault, see Edwards' and Cassell's \nanswer to interrogatories #1 and #2. Because the media assault was conducted by Dershowitz \nhimself making statements to media sources of his choosing, Edwards and Cassell do not possess \ndocuments concerning the assault. \n5. All Documents Concerning the \"multiple national televised interviews,\" \n\"statements to and repeated by national and international print news sources\" and \n\"various other forms nationally and internationally\" alleged in paragraph 19 of the \nComplaint. \nFor details regarding the interviews, statements, and other similar communications, see \nEdwards' and Cassell's answer to interrogatories #1 and #2. Because the media assault was \nconducted by Dershowitz himself making statements to the media, Edwards and Cassell do not \npossess documents concerning the interviews and statements referenced here. \n6. All Documents Concerning the allegation in paragraph 20 of the Complaint that \nDershowitz's \"statements were false and known by him to be false at the time they were \nmade.\" \n3 \nEFTA01078950\n", "char_count": 1968}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01078948", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 below. \n7. All Documents Concerning the allegation in paragraph 21 of the Complaint that \nDershowitz falsely protested his own innocence. \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 below. Additionally, Defendant \nDershowitz is himself aware of the various television and radio programs on which he spoke \nabout the Plaintiffs, as well as other public statements he made, and is in a superior position to \nobtain video, audio and written transcripts of those statements to the extent they are not already \navailable and readily accessible on the world wide web. Plaintiffs are awaiting Defendant's \nproduction of materials not otherwise available. \n8. All Documents Concerning Dershowitz's alleged \"involvement in Epstein's criminal \nconduct\" as alleged in paragraph 21 of the Complaint. \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 below. \n9. All Documents that reference Dershowitz by name that Concern the allegations set forth \nin Paragraphs 24-31 of the 2015 Jane Doe #3 Declaration. \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 below. \n10. All Documents Concerning drafts of any declaration or affidavit of Jane Doe #3. \nObjection, immaterial and not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of \nadmissible evidence, attorney-client privilege, work-product doctrine. \nWithout waiving any objection, affidavits have been filed by Jane Doe #3 in Does v. \nUnited States, 08-80736. \n11. All photographs and video in the original, native format in which they were \ntaken (not a paper copy) of Jane Doe #3 with Dershowitz. \nNone in Plaintiffs' possession. \n4 \nEFTA01078951\n", "char_count": 1810}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01078948", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15.000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \n12. All photographs and video in the original, native format in which they were \ntaken (not a paper copy) not produced in response to any prior Request, of Dershowitz at \n(i) Epstein's Manhattan home in New York City, New York; (ii) Epstein's home in Palm \nBeach, Florida; (iii) Epstein's Zorro Ranch in Santa Fe, New Mexico; (iv) Little Saint \nJames island in the U.S. Virgin Islands; and (v) Epstein's airplane, on the same date and \ntime that Jane Doe #3 also was present at such location. \nNone in the possession of Edwards or Cassell. \n13. All photographs and video in the original, native format in which they were \ntaken (not a paper copy) not produced in response to any prior Request that evidence \nand/or show Jane Doe #3 was present at the same location as Dershowitz on that same date \nand time. \nNone. \n14. All Documents Concerning Jane Doe #3's presence at the various locations \nnamed in Paragraphs 24-31 of the 2015 Jane Doe #3 Declaration on the particular dates \nand times when Dershowitz was also present. \nSee Docket Entry 291 and attachments filed in Doe v. U.S., 08-80736. \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 below. \nAdditional responsive documents are subject to the attorney-client and work product \nprivilege. \n15. All Documents Concerning whether Dershowitz was present at the various \nlocations named in Paragraphs 24-31 of the 2015 Jane Doe #3 Declaration on the particular \ndates and times when Jane Doe #3 alleges to have been present. \nSee Docket Entry 291 and attachments filed in Doe v. U.S., 08-80736. \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 below. \nAdditional responsive documents are subject to the attorney-client and work product \nprivilege. \n5 \nEFTA01078952\n", "char_count": 1885}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01078948", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \n16. All statements, written or recorded, that Plaintiffs or Jane Doe #3 have provided \nto anyone that reference Dershowitz by name. \nSee documents referenced in Cassell's Response to Second Set of Document Requests \nand Supplemental Response to Second Set of Document Requests. Additional documents are \nsubject to attorney-client and work product privilege. \n17. All notes, writings, photographs, and/or audio or video recordings made or \nrecorded by or of Jane Doe #3 on the dates on which Jane Doe #3 allegedly was present \nwith Dershowitz, including but not limited to any diary, journal, or calendar entries on \nthose dates, regardless whether the notes, writings, photographs, and/or audio or video \nrecordings refer to Dershowitz. \nTo the extent that any responsive materials are \nphotographs or video recordings, please provide them in the original, native format in \nwhich they were taken (not a paper copy). \nNone in Plaintiffs' possession, custody or control. \n18. All notes of, or notes prepared for, any statements or interviews in which \nPlaintiffs or Jane Doe #3 referenced Dershowitz by name or other description. \nNone in Plaintiffs' possession, custody or control. \n19. All Documents Concerning communications between You or anyone acting on \nYour behalf and anyone from, or acting on behalf of, any media outlet Concerning \nDershowitz or this action, whether or not such communications were \"on the record\" or \n\"off the record.\" \nSee documents referenced in Cassell's Response to Second Set of Document Requests \nand Supplemental Response to Second Set of Document Requests. Additional documents are \nsubject to attorney-client and work product privilege. \n6 \nEFTA01078953\n", "char_count": 1854}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01078948", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \n20. All Documents Concerning any press release Concerning this action, the Joinder \nMotion, or Dershowitz, or Jane Doe #3. \nObjection as to \"all documents concerning\" in that it requests information not reasonably \ncalculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence; attorney-client privilege, work-\nproduct doctrine, overly burdensome, vague, harassing. \nWithout waiving objection, Dershowitz already possesses a copy of a press release sent to \nthe media by Edwards and Cassell on or about January 2, 2015, that read as follows: \nOut of respect for the court's desire to keep this case from being litigated \nin the press, we are not going to respond at this time to specific claims of \nindignation by anyone. As you may know, we are litigating a very important case, \nnot only for our clients but crime victims in general. We have been informed of \nMr. Dershowitz's threats based on the factual allegations we have made in our \nrecent filing. We carefully investigate all of the allegations in our pleadings \nbefore presenting them. We have also tried to depose Mr. Dershowitz on these \nsubjects, although he has avoided those deposition requests. Nevertheless, we \nwould be pleased to consider any sworn testimony and documentary evidence Mr. \nDershowitz would like to provide which he contends would refute any of our \nallegations. \nThe point of the pleading was only to join two of our clients in the case \nthat is currently being litigated, and while we expected an agreement from the \nGovernment on that point, we did not get it. That disagreement compelled us to \nfile our motion. We intend only to litigate the relevant issues in Court and not to \nplay into any sideshow. We feel that is in our clients' best interest and \nconsequently that is what we are doing. \nWe have every intention of addressing all of the relevant\n... [truncated, 2523 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01078948/6 or ?id=EFTA01078948&page=6]", "char_count": 2523}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01078948", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \nDershowitz already possesses a copy a press release sent to the media by Jack Scarola on \nor about January 7, 2015, that read as follows: \nMr. Dershowitz harshly attacks Mr. Edwards and Professor Cassell for not \ntrying to talk to him before naming him in legal papers. But, in truth, and as \nsupported by numerous documents, on at least three occasions since 2009, Mr. \nDershowitz was informed that he was a key witness in the litigation against \nJefficy Epstein and was requested to testify. We advised him at that time as \nfollows: \n`Multiple individuals have placed you in the presence of Jeffrey Epstein \non multiple occasions and in various locations when Jeffrey Epstein was \nin the company of underage females subsequently identified as victims of \nMr. Epstein's criminal molestations. This information is derived from both \nsomeone's testimony and private interviews. Your personal observations \nregarding such circumstances would clearly not involve any privileged \ncommunications, and it is those observations that will be the primary focus \nof our questioning.' \nDespite this notice to Mr. Dershowitz, he failed to respond or testify in any \nfashion. Mr. Dershowitz has not responded to multiple efforts to take his \ntestimony beginning in 2009. \n21. All Documents Concerning any assertion that Dershowitz was a \"co-\nconspirator\" with Epstein. \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 below. \nSee also answer to request #10 above. \n22. All Documents Concerning any assertion that Dershowitz negotiated the NPA \nfor his own benefit. \nDershowitz possesses, or has access to, all information regarding his negotiation of the \nNPA. Edwards and Cassell have asked him to produce this information, and will all be \nresponsive to this request as well. See Plaintiffs' Third Request to Produce to Defendant Nos. 2, \n3, and 4\n... [truncated, 2019 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01078948/7 or ?id=EFTA01078948&page=7]", "char_count": 2019}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01078948", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \nEdwards and Cassell also have received from the U.S. Attorney's Office from the \nSouthern District of Florida approximately 1000 pages of correspondence between that Office \nand Jeffrey Epstein's legal defense team (including Dershowitz) exchanged from approximately \n2006 to 2008 related to the non-prosecution agreement. Those documents are currently under \nseal by order of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida in connection with the \nDoes v. United States, No. 9:08-cv-80736-KAM. This seal has been requested by, and obtained \nby, Dershowitz's close friend, client and co-conspirator, Jeffrey Epstein, over the objection of \nEdwards and Cassell on behalf of their clients. Accordingly, Dershowitz should request that \nEpstein withdraw his request for sealing so that these materials can be produced to Dershowitz. \nSee also answer to request #2 above (including the NPA itself and its provision granting \nimmunity from prosecution to \"any potential co-conspirators of Epstein\") and to request #24 \nbelow. \n23. All Documents Concerning any actions allegedly taken by Prince Andrew, Duke \nof York, to influence the terms of the NPA. \nEdwards and Cassell have attempted to question Prince Andrew about his actions in this \nregard, but have been rebuffed by Prince Andrew and representatives of the British throne and/or \ngovernment. \nAll production materials as to which there is no objection are available for inspection and \ncopying at the offices of Plaintiffs' counsel as soon as the Defendant's past due production has \nbeen made available to Plaintiffs. \nEdwards and Cassell have propounded discovery requests seeking such documents in the \nCVRA case. See Request for Admission (RFA) (December 1, 2011) (asking the Government to \nadmit that it possesses \"documents, correspondence or other information refle\n... [truncated, 2341 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01078948/8 or ?id=EFTA01078948&page=8]", "char_count": 2341}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01078948", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15.000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \nDershowitz already has in his possession a request from Jack Scarola to take his \ndeposition, sent via email on January 3, 2015, which reads as follows: \nDear Mr. Dershowitz: \nStatements attributed to you in the public media express a willingness. \nindeed a strong desire, to submit to questioning under oath regarding your alleged \nknowledge of Jeffrey Epstein's extensive abuse of underage females as well as \nyour alleged personal participation in those activities. As I am sure you will \nrecall, our efforts to arrange such a deposition previously were unsuccessful, so \nwe welcome your change of heart. Perhaps a convenient time would be in \nconnection with your scheduled appearance in Miami on January 19. I assume a \nsubpoena will not be necessary since the deposition will be taken pursuant to your \nrequest, but please let us know promptly if that assumption is inaccurate. Also, \nnote that the deposition will be video recorded. \nKindly bring with you all documentary and electronic evidence which you \nbelieve tends to refute the factual allegations made concerning you in the recent \nCVRA proceeding as well as passport pages reflecting your travels during the past \nten years and copies of all photographs taken while you were a traveling \ncompanion or house guest of Jeffrey Epstein's. \nThank you for your anticipated cooperation. \nSincerely, \nJack Scarola \n25. All Documents Concerning any investigation of Dershowitz. \nThis request is vague and overbroad, since it is not clear exactly what the term \n\"investigation\" means in this context. \nWithout waiving this objection: \n10 \nEFTA01078957\n", "char_count": 1770}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01078948", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 above. \nSee also all depositions taken in all civil cases involving Jeffrey Epstein in which the \nallegations concerned his molestation of minors. \nSee also the criminal Palm Beach State Attorney's Office file regarding Jeffrey Epstein. \nSee also all books, articles and publications of or about Dershowitz which are in the \npossession of Dershowitz or in public circulation. \n26. All notes of any investigation of Jane Doe #3's allegations against Dershowitz. \nObjection, not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence; \nattorney-client privilege, work-product doctrine, vague, indefinite, overly broad, burdensome. \n27. All telephone records, including but not limited to records for any cell phone, for \nany telephone used by Jane Doe #3 between January 1, 1999 and December 31, 2002. \nNone in possession of Edwards and Cassell. \n28. All Documents Concerning Jane Doe #3's diary or journal. \nNo diary or journal is in the possession of Edwards and Cacsell. \nBeyond that and to the extent that the request for documents \"concerning\" an unspecified diary \nor journal, Edwards and Cassell object to this request because it is uncertain and overbroad, \nseeks irrelevant and inadmissible information and is not reasonably calculated to lead to the \ndiscovery of relevant and admissible evidence. Edwards and Cassell also object to this request \nbecause it seeks information that is protected from disclosure by the attorney-client privilege. \nEdwards and Cassell also object to this request because it seeks information that is protected \nfrom disclosure by the work product doctrine.\\ \n29. All Documents Concerning any actual or potential book, television, movie or \nother media deals Concerning Jane Doe #3's allegations about being a sex slave. \nObjection in t\n... [truncated, 2214 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01078948/10 or ?id=EFTA01078948&page=10]", "char_count": 2214}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01078948", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Edwards. Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \n30. All Documents Concerning Your retainer agreement with Jane Doe #3. \nObjection in that it requests information not reasonably calculated to lead to the \ndiscovery of admissible evidence, attorney-client privilege, work-product doctrine, overly \nburdensome, overbroad, vague, and harassing. \n31. All Documents Concerning any investigation of Jane Doe #3. \nObjection, in that this request is vague and overbroad, since it is not clear exactly what \nthe term \"investigation\" means in this context. \nAlso, objection in that it requests information not reasonably calculated to lead to the \ndiscovery of admissible evidence, attorney-client privilege, work-product doctrine, overly \nburdensome, vague, and harassing \n32. All Documents identified in Your responses to Dershowitz's First Set of \nInterrogatories to You in this action. \nSee the documents and answers provided to these requests for production of documents. \n33. All Documents Concerning Your claim for damages in this action. \nSee the documents and answers provided to these requests for production of documents \nand the answers to interrogatories, all of which support a claim of statements that are defamatory \nper se. \nCassell withdraws his claim for special economic losses relating to lost wages and \ndiminished earning capacity. \n34. All Documents referred to or relied upon by Plaintiffs to prepare \"Jane Doe #3 \nand Jane Doe #4's Motion Pursuant to Rule 21 for Joinder in Action,\" which was filed in \nthe Federal Action as Docket Entry #279. \nObjection in that it requests information not reasonably calculated to lead to the \ndiscovery of admissible evidence, attorney-client privilege, work-product doctrine. \n35. All Documents referred to or relied upon by Plaintiffs to prepare the Complaint \nin this action. \n12 \nEFTA01078959\n", "char_count": 1962}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01078948", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No.: CACE 15-000072 \nSupplemental Answers To Defendant Dershowitz's First Set Of Document Requests \nto Edwards and Cassell \nPlaintiffs relied on the various defamatory statements made by Alan Dershowitz to \nprepare the complaint. See, e.g., Answer to Interrogatories #1 and #2. \nSee answer to request #2 above and to request #24 above. \nTo the extent that materials are sought regarding communications with legal counsel, \nobjection under the attorney-client privilege and work-product doctrine. \nI HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing was sent via E-Serve \n2•r\nto all Counsel on the attached list, this \nday of  \nfroV, 2015. \n13 \nEFTA01078960\n", "char_count": 706}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01078948", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Edwards, Bradley vs. Dershowitz \nCase No. CACE 15-000072 \nCOUNSEL LIST \nSi id Stone McCawle , Es uire \nThomas Emerson Scott Jr. Es uire \nKenneth A. Sweder, Es uire \nRichard A. Sim son, Es uire \nEFTA01078961\n", "char_count": 207}]}