{"efta_number": "EFTA01019075", "page_count": 8, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA01019075", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA01019075.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA01019075", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "From: I leevacation@gmail.com> \nTo: Lawrence Krauss \nSubject: Re: Krauss settlement agreement - revised draft \nDate: Sat, 20 Oct 2018 12:15:54 +0000 \nyes, terminate \nOn Sat, Oct 20, 2018 at 8:08 AM Lawrence Krauss c \nwrote: \nSo here is the situation.. I need to get retirement letter done before I go to bed tonight, by, say 1 am my time. Also, I would like to terminate Justin, \nand contact Kim and Cynthia and indicate that I will deal with them directly on redacting the documents. If you agree with this course, I suggest I \nsend that on to them after I send in the retirement letter. \nNext, given that they have specifically said that they are releasing both the settlement agreement (which I would have thought should be \nconfidential) and the retirement letter as early as Monday, along with the Provosts determination, which includes all the OEI results before my \nappeal, I think we need to do the full retirement letter with all the bells and whistles. Because otherwise the information that the material in the \nProvosts determination is wrong will not get out.. any letter I write to the president following my retirement letter will not be released to the press \nat that time, and if it gets out eventually, it will be after all this has appeared to the press.. So, we go back to plan  \nAl think. \nThoughts? \nBegin forwarded message: \nFrom: Justin Dillon eziMa \nSubject: Fwd: Krauss settlement agreement - revised draft \nDate: October 20, 2018 at 1:51:17 PM GMT+2 \nTo: Lawrence Krauss •,:\n> \nLawrence. \nThe deal s done—see attached. But re the PRR. I had a feeling this was gong to happen—they are going to release everything Monday and aren't going to wait for you to talk \nabout it next week. See below for details. \nIf you are going to handle this yourself. let me know. and I will tell Kim that you will deal with her or Cynthia directly and that you will respond substantively to her email. But now \nthat we nave signed the deal. I don't want to be sending emails you dictate anymor\n... [truncated, 4008 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01019075/0 or ?id=EFTA01019075&page=0]", "char_count": 4008}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01019075", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "However, pages 11-33 are just copies of various University policies referenced in the letter, which are publicly available on the University's website and which \nwe would therefore not redact. So you're really just looking at pages 1-10, which are the letter and the attached Determinations. I therefore hope you will be \nable to address this quickly so that we may consider your input before the release of the documents. \nPlease note that we will also be releasing the executed settlement agreement and your client's written retirement letter. \nBest wishes, \nKim \nKimberly A. Demarchi \njirobillo‘ Add ow to so me .11StirWS NIS \n,\nV swww.omlaw.com \nNorth Central Avenue \ntsI Moor \nTh\nt\nrob° \nFacsimile 6o2. \n. o \nFrom: Justin Dillon \nSent: Friday, October 19, 2018 1:32 PM \nTo: Kimberly Demarchi \nSubject: Re: Krauss settlement agreement - revised draft \nThanks, Kim. We'll get back to you about this early next week, once he's back from Germany. \nJustin Cacti \nKaiserDillon PLLC \n1401 K Street NW \nSuite 600 \n20005 \nOn Oct 19, 2018, at 12:52 PM, Kimberly Demarchi \n> wrote: \nJustin, \nIn terms of additional redactions, why don't you and Dr. Krauss mark up the documents to indicate what else you think should be redacted so we can \nconsider those potential additional redactions? I've reattached the copies for your convenience. \nThanks, \nKim \nKimberly A. Demarchi \nPr lilts  I Add ow Irv, tux ashlers.. lumk \n; °.>vww.omlaw.corn \n3929 North Central Avenue \n2.111.1koi \nTelephone \nFacsimile \nrz. \nti \nFrom: Justin Dillon \nSent: Friday, October 19, 20189:35 AM \nTo: Kimberly Demarchi \nSubject: Re: Krauss settlement agreement - revised draft \nKim, \nThank you for clarifying ASU's position. Attached is the Agreement, signed by both me and Professor Krauss. I did not make any changes to the non-redlined \nversion you sent. \nNow, as to the PRR response: Professor Krauss's concern is that what ASU proposes to release would invade the privacy of and disparage not only him, but \nother people, too—Ame\n... [truncated, 2590 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01019075/1 or ?id=EFTA01019075&page=1]", "char_count": 2590}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01019075", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Justin \nJustin [Mien \nKaiserDillon PLLC \n1401 K Street NW \nSuite 600 \nWash \non. DC 20005 \nOn Oct 18, 2018, at 11:47 PM, Kimberly Demarchi\n wrote: \nJustin, \nI have provided you with exactly what we intend to release, complete with the redactions that have been applied in preparation for their release. If you \ncheck those documents carefully, the OEI reports are not there. The only documents in that set that reference the allegations against your client are the \nletter from Dean Searle and the attached, brief descriptions of OEI's determinations. (See the file titled PRR Response part 2 at pages 1-10.) The other file \n(PRR Response part 1) includes only contract documents, including the non-renewal of your client's administrative appointment, which does not make any \nreference to the allegations. We would also expect to release the fully executed agreement (which you will have seen) and your client's written retirement \nletter (which we do not yet have). \nAt present, we do not intend to produce Dean Kenney's recommendation of dismissal (which has a longer description of the underlying allegations), the \nthree documents you sent this morning, or the OEI reports. I've explained to you why we believe we can withhold those documents under applicable law, \nincluding the University's interest in not chilling participation in investigations by identifying complainants or witnesses. I can't guarantee that we will \nprevail in our interpretation of the law, but that is our current plan. And the notice provisions of the draft agreement would apply to any future release of \npublic records, meaning that your client would receive notice if further documents were to be released in the future. \nShould your dient choose to make any statements, including releasing documents in which he names complainants and witnesses and makes statements \nabout them, he should be cognizant of both the non-disparagement provisions and the practical effect that such a release may have on the University'\n... [truncated, 3591 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01019075/2 or ?id=EFTA01019075&page=2]", "char_count": 3591}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01019075", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Cindy will not be available tomorrow to approve the form, so I've switched her name for mine since I am available to sign. I also added a missing underline \nin one of the headings. \nThe donations paragraph now provides for a return of funds to the donors rather than a transfer from the Foundation. That reduces the MU Foundation's \ninvolvement with determining to whom they can transfer. An added benefit for your client is that he doesn't necessarily need to have another organization \navailable to accept funds within 90 days — he just has to have the donors ask for their money back, and then he can ask them to re-donate it when he is \nready to do so. \nMy clients will not agree to add the effective date of retirement to the statement as that, without more, fails to convey that Dr. Krauss will remain on leave, \naway from campus, and without authority to take actions on behalf of ASU between now and May. They might agree to a longer statement that explained \nall those things, along the following lines: \nThe University has accepted Dr. Krauss's request to retire from his position as Professor at Arizona State University. His resignation will take effect \nat the end of the academic year, May 16, 2019. Until that time, Dr. Krauss will remain on leave, will not be on campus, and will have no authority \nto act for or on behalf of MU. \nTo the extent that your dient is concerned that the statement alone suggests he is leaving immediately, you should keep in mind that we are likely to need \nto release the agreement and your client's resignation letter at or near the time we make the statement, because of the pending public records requests \nand the ones we may get in response to the statement itself. So to the extent the press gets the shorter statement, they will get the full picture. \nThat brings me to the topic of public records, and your suggestion that ASU should release the three documents attached to your email so that Dr. Krauss \ndoes not do so. \nASU does not intend to r\n... [truncated, 5377 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01019075/3 or ?id=EFTA01019075&page=3]", "char_count": 5377}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01019075", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Justin \nJustin Dillon \nKaiserDoan PLLC \n1401 K Street NW \nSusie 600 \n20O06 \nOn Oct 17, 2018, at 9:22 PM, Justin Dillon \nwrote: \nThanks, Kim. This is a lot to digest, and Professor Krauss is currently on a plane to Germany. I will try to get back to you tomorrow, but I thought we were \ndone with manufactured deadlines now that we've been going back and forth in good faith for almost a week. Doing that strikes me as needlessly \naggressive, bordering on bad faith by your client, so I'd be grateful if you could tell them to cut that out and let us continue to do this the way we've been \ndoing it. \nThanks, \nJustin \nJustin Dillon \nKaiserDillon PLLC \n1401 K Street NW \nSuite 600 \nINC \nOn Oct 17, 2018, at 8:34 PM, Kimberly Demarchi ffi\n wrote: \nJustin, \nAttached is a revised draft agreement in clean and redline versions. My clients have authorized me to extend this offer through 5:00  p.m. Arizona time \nteCOMILLW,S=s2beL18 \nThe substantive changes are in two sections— the donated funds and the mutual release. Let me provide some context in the hope that it may be \nhelpful. \nWith regard to the donated funds, please understand that what your client is asking for is highly unusual. Gifts to the MU Foundation are irrevocable \nand the MU Foundation does not generally return or transfer funds absent unusual circumstances. In addition, because the fund maintained by the \nMU Foundation to accept gifts to support the Origins Project has had hundreds of donors over a period of nearly ten years, making a determination of \nhow much of any particular donor's funds are available for transfer is complex and must be done with appropriate care for the Foundation's accounting \nobligations and its obligations toward other donors who gave to the fund and have not consented to the transfer. This is different from a research \ngrant, which is accounted for individually and for which transfer is not uncommon as principal investigators move to different institutions. The attached \ndraft reflects the\n... [truncated, 3768 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01019075/4 or ?id=EFTA01019075&page=4]", "char_count": 3768}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01019075", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Kimberly A. Demarchi \nProfile I MA me to your llithess hook \nG`Www.omlaw.com \nata North Central Avenue \n...id Flog \nFacsimile 602.6 o. \nFrom: Justin Dillon \nSent: Tuesday, October 16, 2018 7:41 AM \nTo: Kimberly Demarchi \nSubject: Re: Krauss settlement agreement - revised draft \nKim, \nThanks for the quick response. And yes, I think that change makes a lot of sense. \nJustin \nJuan Dillon \nKaiser0lllon PLLC \n1401 K Street NW \nSuite 600 \nWaShi \non DC 20005 \nOn Oct 16, 2018, at 10:39 AM, Kimberly Demarchi' \nwrote: \nJustin, \nI think I understand where you're going with these revisions, and I will follow up with my clients. \nOne quick clarifying question, though. Should the paragraphs be broken up as follows, rather than having the sentence \"Only...? as part of \nsubparagraph (b)? \n4. \nIf, in the next 90 days, any of the following donors to the MU Foundation to support the Origins Project makes a request to transfer \nfunds (outlined below) to another nonprofit organization, MU will not oppose the transfer of funds and will request that the MU Foundation make \nthe requested transfer: \n(a) All funds from major donors (those who contributed or pledged $5,000 or more, including multiple donations from a single family) since \nJanuary 1, 2017; \n(b) unexpended funds from single major donors in excess of $300,000 since 2010. Professor Krauss will provide a list directly to the ASU \nFoundation of the donors that, to his knowledge, fall in these categories, and the ASU Foundation will be solely responsible for confirming its \nvalidity, and if necessary reporting back to Professor Krauss with names added or removed from this list. \nOnly requests from these individuals or groups will be considered for transfer. It is expected that this list will include fewer than 20 donors, and based \non the estimates available at the current time of ASU Foundation funds not expended as of October 2018, it is expected that the total available funds \nfor this purpose will not be less than $1 million dol\n... [truncated, 2959 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01019075/5 or ?id=EFTA01019075&page=5]", "char_count": 2959}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01019075", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Thanks, \nJustin \nJustin Dian \nKaiserDillon PLLC \n1401 K Street NW \nSu to 600 \n0005 \nOn Oct 15, 2018, at 9:31 PM, Kimberly Demarchi \nwrote: \nThanks, Justin. That's fine. \nKimberly A. Demarchi \nProfile I Add me to your address book \ng.‘i'vww.omlaw.com \n29_29 North Central Avenue \n21St Floor\nPhoeni x \nTelephone\nFacsimile 602. o. \no \nFrom: Justin Dillon \nSent: Monday, October 15, 2018 5:17 PM \nTo: Kimberly Demarchi \nSubject: Re: Krauss settlement agreement - revised draft \nThanks, Kim. Given the lateness of the hour here and Professor Krauss's travel schedule, I will get back to you tomorrow about this. \nJustin Dillon \nKaiserDillon PLLC \n1401 K Street NW \nSum 600 \nWashin ton DC 20005 \nOn Oct 15, 2018, at 8:00 PM, Kimberly Demarchi •:\n:• wrote: \nJustin, \nI've attached a revised agreement for your review. As you've requested, I've revised the disclaimer obligation to extend to any ASU employee, \nrather than just the Participating Employees. I've also made some grammatical and clarifying revisions to that sentence. \nI've also now gotten the information needed to respond on the proposed terms regarding donors who gave money to the ASU Foundation for the \nOrigins Project. As it turns out, there are hundreds of unique donors, many of whom have given small amounts of money over the last ten years. \nAgreeing to unravel exactly how much of each of those donors' money is left at this point in time just is not feasible. However, the University is \nwilling to agree that it would not oppose a request from the Black Family Foundation to transfer any of its donations that remain unspent and \nwould request that the MU Foundation honor the request. The MU Foundation would of course have to have final responsibility for calculating \nthe amount of funds unspent and available for transfer. I've made those revisions on the attached as well. \nPlease let me know your thoughts. \nBest wishes, \nKim \nKimberly A. Demarchi \nr of le I Add me to your addn,s; book \n<image002.jpg>292, North Central Ave\n... [truncated, 2030 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01019075/6 or ?id=EFTA01019075&page=6]", "char_count": 2030}, {"efta_number": "EFTA01019075", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "From: Justin Dillon\nSent: Monday, October 15, 2018 8:52 AM \nTo: Kimberly Demarchi\n> \nSubject: Re: Krauss settlement agreement - revised draft \nKim, \nI think what you propose is fine, but I think the word \"Participating\" in the last sentence is a typo. I think ASU is agreeing to, if asked, make the \ndisavowal statement regarding any MU employee (Participating or not) who purports to speak on ASU's behalf, right? That doesn't mean \nsuppression, of course—just disavowal. Let me know what you think. \nAlso, Prof. Krauss is flying to Mexico today, so just to manage your own timing concerns, I suspect we won't be inking this until tomorrow. He \nshould be fine once he's settled into the hotel. \nThanks, and feel free to call me if \nlike to discuss anything else. \nJustin \nJustin Dillon \nKaiserDam PLLC \n1401 K Street NW \nSuite 60O \n20005 \nOn Oct 15, 2018, at 1:11 AM, Kimberly De m arch \nwrote: \nJustin, \nI've reviewed your revisions, and I have some concerns about the non-disparagement provision. One of them (in the text preceding the lettered \nprovisions) is just grammatical, but the others are substantive. \nMU can't bind the participating employees not to speak in their private capacities. The most we can agree is that we will respond if they speak \nin a way that suggests they're speaking for MU, and clarify that they are not doing so. We also can and have proposed to agree to bind the \nrelevant administrators who would, by virtue of their positions, be deemed to speak on behalf of the University. \nIn addition, while I'm sensitive to your concerns about the difficulty of defining media, I think we can agree that the need for such correction \nwould only be necessary for statements that were in a public context. \nplease note \nThe information contained in this communication is \nconfidential, may be attorney-client privileged, may \nconstitute inside information, and is intended only for \nthe use of the addressee. It is the property of \nJEE \nUnauthorized use, disclosure or copying\n... [truncated, 2355 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA01019075/7 or ?id=EFTA01019075&page=7]", "char_count": 2355}]}