{"efta_number": "EFTA00800253", "page_count": 14, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00800253", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00800253.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00800253", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Olt LexisNexis° \nUser Name: DAVID SCHOEN \nDate and Time: Saturday, February 23, 2019 11:55:00 PM EST \nJob Number: \nDocument (1) \n1.  Doe v. United States. 2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 27215 \nClient/Matter: -None-\nSearch Terms: cvra and npa \nSearch Type: Terms and Connectors \nNarrowed by: \nContent Type \nNarrowed by \nCases \n-None-\nLexisNexis' I About LexisNexis I Privacy Policy I Terms & Conditions I Copyright © 2019 LexisNexis \nDAVID SCHOEN \nEFTA00800253\n", "char_count": 451}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00800253", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "No Shepard's Signalm \nAs of: February 24, 2019 4:55 AM Z. \nDoe v. United States \nUnited States District Court for the Southern District of Florida \nFebruary 21, 2019, Decided; February 21, 2019, Entered on Docket \nCASE NO. 08-80736-CIV-MARRA \nReporter \n2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 27215 \nJANE DOE I AND JANE DOE 2, Petitioners, vs. UNITED \nSTATES, Respondent. \nCore Terms \nnotification, email, rights, notice, Attorney's, letters, confer, \ncharges, girls, guilty plea, co-conspirators, non-prosecution, \ninform. summary judgment, crime victim, state court, \nnegotiating, deferred, notify, terms, federal investigation, plea \nagreement, law law law, individuals, damages, sexual, sexual \nabuse, proceedings, indictment, sentencing \nCounsel: [ol] For Jane Doe, Petitioner: Bradley James \nEdwards, LEAD ATTORNEY, Edwards Pottinger LLC, Fort \nLauderdale, FL; Jay C. Howell, PRO HAC VICE, Jay Howell \n& Associates PA, Jacksonville, FL; John Scarola, Searcy \nDenney Scarola Barnhart & Shipley, West Palm Beach, FL; \nPaul G. Cassell, PRO HAC VICE. \nFor United States of America, Respondent: Ann Marie C. \nVillafana, LEAD ATTORNEY, United States Attorney's \nOffice, West Palm Beach, FL; Dexter Lee, LEAD \nATTORNEY, United States Attorney's Office, Miami, FL. \nFor Roy Black, Intervenor. Jacqueline Perczek, Roy Eric \nBlack, Black Srebnick Komspan & Stumpf, Miami, FL; Jay \nP. Lefkowitz, PRO HAC VICE, Kirkland & Ellis, LLP, New \nYork, NY; Martin G. Weinberg, PRO HAC VICE, Martin G. \nWeinberg, P.C., Boston, MA. \nFor Martin G. Weinberg, Jay Lefkowitz, Intervenors: \nJacqueline Perczek, Black Srebnick Komspan & Stumpf, \nMiami, FL; Jay P. Lefkowitz, PRO HAC VICE, Kirkland & \nEllis, LLP, New York, NY; Martin G. Weinberg, PRO HAC \nVICE, Martin G. Weinberg, P.C., Boston, MA. \nFor Bruce Reinhart, Intervenor: Bruce Reinhart, Bruce E. \nReinhart, P.A., West Palm Beach, FL. \nFor Jeffrey Epstein, Intervenor: Jacqueline Perczek, Roy Eric \nBlack, Black Srebnick Komspan & Stumpf, Miami, [ig] FL. \nFor Alan M. Dershowitz,\n... [truncated, 3607 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00800253/1 or ?id=EFTA00800253&page=1]", "char_count": 3607}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00800253", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Page 2 of 13 \n2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 27215, 9 \nknowingly traveled in interstate and international commerce \nto sexually abuse Jane Doe I, Jane Doe 2 and others, they \ncommitted violations of not only Florida law, but also federal \nlaw. (DE 407 at I 2.) In addition to his own sexual abuse of \nthe victims, Epstein directed other persons to abuse the girls \nsexually. (DE 407 at 13.) Epstein used paid employees to find \nand bring minor girls to him. Epstein worked in concert with \nothers to obtain minors not only for his own sexual \ngratification, but also for the sexual gratification of others. \n(DE 407 at 18.) \nIn 2005. the Town of Palm Beach Police Department \n(\"PBPD\") received a complaint from the parents of a 14 year \nold girl about her sexual abuse by Jeffery Epstein. The PBPD \nultimately identified approximately 20 girls between the ages \nof 14 and 17 who were sexually abused by Epstein. (DE 407 \nall 4.) In 2006, at 1*4] the request of the PBPD, the Federal \nBureau of Investigation (\"FBI\") opened an investigation into \nallegations that Epstein and his personal assistants used the \nfacilities of interstate commerce to induce girls between the \nages of 14 and 17 to engage in illegal sexual activities. (DE \n407 at 15.) The FBI ultimately determined that both Jane Doe \n1 and Jane Doe 2 were victims of sexual abuse by Epstein \nwhile they were minors. Jane Doe 1 provided information \nabout her abuse and Jane Doe 2's abuse to the FBI on August \n7, 2007. (DE 407 at 16.) \nFrom January, of 2007 through September of 2007, \ndiscussions took place between the U.S. Attorney's Office for \nthe Southern District of Florida (\"the Office\") and Jeffrey \nEpstein's attorneys. (DE 407 at 1 9.) On February I, 2007, \nEpstein's defense team sent a 24-page letter to the Office \ngoing over what they intended to present during a meeting at \nthe Office the same day. (DE 407 at 1 10.) \nBy March IS, 2007, the Office was sending letters to victims \ninforming them of their rights pursuant to the C\n... [truncated, 5850 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00800253/2 or ?id=EFTA00800253&page=2]", "char_count": 5850}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00800253", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Page 3 of 13 \n2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 27215, •7 \nassaulting one of his coconspirators. (DE 407 at 1 2L) On \nSeptember 15, 2007, the line prosecutor sent an email to the \nEpstein defense team raising concerns about a resolution that \nwould not involve one of Epstein's minor victims and stating: \nI have gotten some negative reaction to the assault \ncharge with [a co-conspirator] as the victim, since she is \nconsidered one of the main perpetrators of the offenses \nthat we planned to charge in the indictment. Can you talk \nto Mr. Epstein about a young woman named [Jane Doe]? \nWe have hearsay evidence that she traveled on Mr. \nEpstein's airplane when she was under 18, in around the \n2000 or 2001 time frame. \n(DE 407 at 1 22.) \nOn September 16, 2007, the line prosecutor corresponded \nwith Epstein's counsel about having Epstein plead guilty to \nobstruction of justice for pressuring one of his co-conspirators \nnot to turn over evidence or complying [•8] with a \npreviously-served grand jury subpoena. (DE 407 at 1 23.) The \nOffice also stated. \"On an 'avoid the press' note, I believe that \nMr. Epstein's airplane was in Miami on the day of the [co-\nconspirator] telephone call. If he was in Miami-Dade County \nat the time, then I can file the charge in the District Court in \nMiami, which will hopefully cut the press coverage \nsignificantly.\" They also discussed having Epstein plead \nguilty to a second charge of assaulting a different co-\nconspirator. (DE 407 at I 24.) \nOn September 16, 2007, the line prosecutor wrote to Epstein's \ncounsel indicating that the Office did not like the factual basis \nfor the proposed charges as the Office was \"not investigating \nMr. Epstein [for] abusing his girlfriend.\" (DE 407 at 1 25.) \nThe correspondence further stated: \nAndy [i.e., AUSA Andrew Laurie] recommended that \nsome of the timing issues be addressed only in the state \nagreement, so that it isn't obvious to the judge that we \nare trying to create federal jurisdiction for prison \npurposes. \n... [truncated, 5582 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00800253/3 or ?id=EFTA00800253&page=3]", "char_count": 5582}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00800253", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "Page 4 of 13 \n2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 27215, *11 \nSeptember 24, 2007, and the NPA was being executed, \nLefkowitz sent an email to the line prosecutor stating: \"Marie \n— Please do whatever you can to keep this [Le., the NPA]\nfrom becoming public.\" (DE 407 at l 37.) \nOn September 24, 2007, Epstein and the Office formally \nreached an agreement whereby the United States would defer \nfederal prosecution [•12] in favor of prosecution by the State \nof Florida. Epstein and the Office accordingly entered into a \nNPA reflecting such an agreement. (DE 407 at 1 38.) The \nNPA provided that \"the United States, in consultation with \nand subject to the good faith approval of Epstein's counsel. \nshall select an attorney representative for [the victims], who \nshall be paid for by Epstein.\" The MIA also provided that if \nany of the victims elected to bring suit under 18 U..S.C. \n2255, they must agree to waive any other claim for damages. \nAs part of the NPA, Epstein would not contest the jurisdiction \nof the United States District Court and waived his right to \ncontest liability and damages. (NPA, DE 361.62.) \nAmong other provisions, the NPA expanded immunity to any \n\"potential coconspirator\" of Epstein's: \"In consideration of \nEpstein's agreement to plead guilty and to provide \ncompensation in the manner described above, if Epstein \nsuccessfully fulfills all of the terms and conditions of this \nagreement, the United States also agrees that it will not \ninstitute any criminal charges against any potential co-\nconspirators of Epstein, including but not limited to Sarah \nKellen, Adrian Ross, Lesley Groff, or Nadia Marcinkova.\" \n(DE 407 at 193] 1 40.) The NPA also provided that: \"The \nparties anticipate that this agreement will not be made part of \nany public record. If the United States receives a Freedom of \nInformation Act request or any compulsory process \ncommanding the disclosure of the agreement, it will provide \nnotice to Epstein before making that disclosure.\" (DE 407 at 1 \n41.) \n\n... [truncated, 5645 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00800253/4 or ?id=EFTA00800253&page=4]", "char_count": 5645}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00800253", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Page 5 of 13 \n2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 27215, •16 \n407 at 1 57.) That same day, the line prosecutor informed \nEpstein's counsel of concerns raised by the attorney \nrepresentative for the girls. Specifically, \"Mlle concern is, if \nall 40 girls decide they want to sue, they don't want to be in a \nsituation where Mr. Epstein says this is getting too expensive, \nwe won't pay anymore attorneys' fees.\" (DE 407 at 1 58.) \nAlso on that same day, the line prosecutor sent an email to \nstate prosecutors Lanna Belohlavek and Barry Krischer: \"Can \nyou let me know when Mr. Epstein is going to enter his guilty \nplea and what judge that will be in front of? I know the agents \nand I would really like to be there, 'incognito.\"' (DE 407 at 1 \n59.) \nOn October 3, 2007, the Office sent a proposed letter that \nwould have gone to a special master for selecting an attorney \nrepresentative for the victims under the NPA's compensation \nprocedure. The letter described the facts of the Epstein case as \nfollows: \"Mr. Epstein, through [*17] his assistants, would \nrecruit underage females to travel to his home in Palm Beach \nto engage in lewd conduct in exchange for money. Based \nupon the investigation, the United States has identified 40 \nyoung women who can be characterized as victims pursuant \nto 18 U.S.C. S 2255. Some of those women went to Mr. \nEpstein's home only once, some went there as many as 100 \ntimes or more. Some of the women's conduct was limited to \nperforming a topless or nude massage while Mr. Epstein \nmasturbated himself. For other women. the conduct escalated \nto full sexual intercourse.\" (DE 407 at 1 60.) \nOn October 10, 2007, Lefkowitz sent a letter to U.S. Attorney \nAlex Acosta stating, in pertinent part: \"Neither federal agents \nnor anyone from your Office should contact the identified \nindividuals to inform them of the resolution of the case, \nincluding appointment of the attorney representative and the \nsettlement process. Not only would that violate the \nconfidentiality of \n... [truncated, 5645 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00800253/5 or ?id=EFTA00800253&page=5]", "char_count": 5645}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00800253", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "Page 6 of 13 \n2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 27215, *20 \nEpstein in a timely fashion. Tomorrow will make one \nfull week since you were formally notified of the \nselection. I must insist that the vetting process come to \nan end. Therefore, unless you provide me with a good \nfaith objection to Judge Davis's selection [as special \nmaster for selecting legal counsel for victims pursuing \nclaims against Epstein] by COB tomorrow, November \n28, 2007, I will authorize the notification of the victims. \nShould you give me \nthe go•head on [victim \nrepresentative] . . . selection by COB tomorrow, I will \nsimultaneously [*21] send you a draft of the letter. I \nintend to notify the victims by letter after COB \nThursday, November 29th. \n(DE 407 at 179.) \nOn November 28, 2007, the Government sent an email to \nLefkowitz attaching a letter dated November 29, 2007 (the \napparent date upon which it was intended to be mailed) and \nexplained that \"I am writing to inform you that the federal \ninvestigation of Jeffrey Epstein has been completed, and Mr. \nEpstein and the U.S. Attorney's Office have reached an \nagreement containing the following terms.\" The proposed \nletter then spelled out a number of the provisions in the NPA \nincluding that because Epstein's plea of guilty to state charges \nwas \"part of the resolution of the federal investigation,\" the \nvictims were \"entitled to be present and to make a statement \nunder oath at the state sentencing.\" (DE 407 at 1 80.) \nOn November 29, 2007, Lefkowitz sent a letter to U.S. \nAttorney Acosta objecting to the proposed victim notification \nletter, stating that it is inappropriate for any letter to be sent to \nthe victims before Epstein entered his plea or had been \nsentenced. Lefkowitz also told the Government that the \nvictims should not be invited to the state sentencing, that they \nshould [*22] not be encouraged to contact law enforcement \nofficials, and that encouraging the attorney representative to \ndo anything other than get paid by Epstein to s\n... [truncated, 5686 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00800253/6 or ?id=EFTA00800253&page=6]", "char_count": 5686}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00800253", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "Page 7 of 13 \n2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 27215, *24 \nThe letter included a footnote 1.25] slating: \"Unlike the \nState's investigation, the federal investigation shows criminal \nconduct by Mr. Epstein at least as early as 2001, so all of the \nvictims were minors at the time of the offense.\" (DE 407 at 1 \n83.) \nOn December 7, 2007, defense attorney Lilly Ann Sanchez \nsent a letter to AUSA Sloman, requesting \"that the Office \nhold off on sending any victim notification letters.\" No letters \nwere sent in December of 2007. (DE 407 at I 88.) On \nDecember 13, 2007, the line prosecutor sent a letter to \nLefkowitz stating that \"You raised objections to any victim \nnotification, and no further notifications were done.\" (DE 407 \nat I 89.) On December 19, 2007, U.S. Attorney Acosta sent a \nletter to Lilly Ann Sanchez stating, \"I understand that the \ndefense objects to the victims being given notice of time and \nplace of Mr. Epstein's state court sentencing hearing. We \nintend to provide victims with notice of the federal resolution, \nas required by law. We will defer to the discretion of the State \nAttorney regarding whether he wishes to provide victims with \nnotices of the state proceedings. (DE 407 at 990.) \nIn January of 2008, any requirement that Epstein carry out his \nobligations under the NPA was 1.26] delayed while he \nsought higher level review within the Justice Department. \n(DE 407 at 1 92.) On January 10, 2008, Jane Doe 1 and Jane \nDoe 2 were sent victim notification letters from the FBI \nadvising them \nthat \"[t]his case is currently under \ninvestigation. This can be a lengthy process and we request \nyour continued patience while we conduct a thorough \ninvestigation.\" (DE 407 at 1 93.) The January 10, 2008 \nnotification letters did not disclose that the Jane Doe 1 and \nJane Doe 2 case in the Southern District of Florida was the \nsubject of the NPA entered into by Epstein and the Office, or \nthat there had been any potentially binding resolution. (DE \n407 at 1 94.) Other v\n... [truncated, 5668 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00800253/7 or ?id=EFTA00800253&page=7]", "char_count": 5668}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00800253", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "Page 8 of 13 \n2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 27215, *28 \nOn June 23, 2008, the line prosecutor sent an email to \nLefkowitz stating that the Deputy Attorney General had \ncompleted his review of the Epstein matter [*29] and \n\"determined that federal prosecution of Mr. Epstein's case \n[vials appropriate. Accordingly, Mr. Epstein ha[d] until the \nclose of business on Monday, June 30, 2008, to comply with \nthe terms and conditions of the agreement between the United \nStates and Mr. Epstein.\" (DE 407 at ¶ 105.) \nOn or about June 27, 2008, the Office called Edwards to \nprovide notice to his clients regarding the entry of Epstein's \nguilty plea in state court. (DE 407 at 1 107.) According to \nEdwards. the line prosecutor only told him that Epstein was \npleading guilty to state solicitation of prosecution. He was not \ntold that the state plea was related to the federal investigation \nor that the state plea would resolve the federal crimes. \nEdwards claims he was not told his clients could address the \nstate court. (Edwards Decl. '] 117-18, DE 416-1.) In contrast, \nthe line prosecutor claims she told Edwards that his clients \ncould address the state court. (Villafaila Decl. 1 38. DE 403-\n19.) \nOn or before June 30, 2008, the Office prepared a draft victim \nnotification to be sent to the victims. The notification was \ndesigned to inform the victims of the provisions of the \ndeferral of federal prosecution in favor of state charges. [*30] \nThe notification letter began by describing Epstein's guilty \nplea in the past tense: \"On June 30, 2008, Jeffrey Epstein ... \nentered a plea of guilty to violations of Florida statutes \nforbidding the solicitation of minors to engage in prostitution \nand felony solicitation of prostitution.\" Later, a substantively \nidentical letter was prepared for Epstein's and his counsel's \nreview. (DE407 at 1 110.) \nOn June 30, 2008, the Office sent an e-mail to Epstein's \ncounsel: \"The FBI has received several calls regarding the \nNon-Prosecution Agreement. I do \n... [truncated, 5646 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00800253/8 or ?id=EFTA00800253&page=8]", "char_count": 5646}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00800253", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "Page 9 of 13 \n2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 27215, *33 \ncontaining certain information about the NPA. (DE 407 at 1 \n128.) The line prosecutor responded: \"Without such an \nexpress Acknowledgment by Mr. Epstein that the notice \ncontains the substance of that Agreement, I believe that the \nvictims will have justification to petition for the entire \nagreement, which is contrary to the confidentiality clause that \nthe parties have signed.\" (DE 407 at 1 129.) That same day, \nthe U.S. Attorney's Office sent victim notification letters to \nJane Doe I and Jane Doe 5, via their attorney, Edwards. and \nto other identified victims of Epstein. That notification \ncontained a written explanation of some of the civil \ncompensation provisions of the NPA. The notification did not \nprovide the full terms of the NPA. [*34] \nOn July 10, 2008, Epstein's counsel continued to protest \nvictim notification as evidenced by an email to the line \nprosecutor stating, \"we respectfully request a reasonable \nopportunity to review and comment on a draft of the modified \nnotification letter you intend to mail before you send it.\" (DE \n407 at 1 131.) \nOn August 10, 2008. Jane Doe 1 and Jane Doe 2 filed a \nmotion seeking release of the NPA. (DE 407 at I 136.) On \nAugust 14, 2008, the line prosecutor emailed Epstein's \ncounsel stating that the court has \"ordered us to make the \nAgreement available to the plaintiffs.\" (DE 407 at I 141.) \nOn August 18, 2008, Lefkowitz wrote the line prosecutor that \nEpstein objected to disclosure of the terms of the NPA, but \nthat Epstein would \"cooperate with the government to reach \nan agreement as to substance of the notification to be sent to \nthe government's list of individuals. Based on the Agreement, \nthe information contained in the notification should be limited \nto (1) the language provided in the Agreement dealing with \ncivil restitution (paragraphs 7.10) and (2) the contact \ninformation of the selected attorney representative. We object \nto the inclusion of additiona\n... [truncated, 5775 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00800253/9 or ?id=EFTA00800253&page=9]", "char_count": 5775}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00800253", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "Page 10 of 13 \n2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 27215,1'37 \ndoes [*38] not create any right to notice of state court \nproceedings and, in any event, the Government gave notice. \nThe Government asserts it did not treat the victims unfairly \nand used its best efforts to comply with the CVRA, including \ncomplying with the Attorney General's guidelines for victim \nassistance. Furthermore, the Government \nargues \nthat \nPetitioners are equitably estopped from challenging the NPA \nbecause they relied upon the NPA in their state court civil \nactions against Epstein. Lastly, the Government contends that \nPetitioners are judicially estopped from challenging the \nvalidity of the NPA because they have asserted mutually \ninconsistent positions; namely, that the NPA is invalid in \nfederal court but was binding on Epstein in state court. \nH. Summary Judgment Standard \nThe Court may grant summary judgment \"if the movant \nshows that there is no genuine dispute as to any material fact \nand the movant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law.\" \nFed. R. Civ. P. 56(a). The stringent burden of establishing the \nabsence of a genuine issue of material fact lies with the \nmoving party. Celoter Corp. v. Catrett. 477 U.S. 317. 323. \n106 S. Ct. 2548, 91 L Ed. 2d 265 (19861. The Court should \nnot grant summary judgment unless it is clear that a trial is \nunnecessary, Anderson v. Liberty Lobby. Inc.. 477 U.S. 242. \n255. 106 S. Ct. 2505, 91 L Ed. 2d 202 (1986), and any doubts \nin this regard should [*39] be resolved against the moving \nparty. Adickes v. S.H. Kress & Co.. 398 U.S. 144. 157. 90 S. \nCt. 1598. 26 L Ed. 2d 142 (19701 \nThe movant \"bears the initial responsibility of informing the \ndistrict court of the basis for its motion, and identifying those \nportions of [the record] which it believes demonstrate the \nabsence of a genuine issue of material fact.\" Celotex Corp.. \n477 U.S. at 323. To discharge this burden, the movant must \npoint out to the Court that there is an absence of evidence to \nsuppor\n... [truncated, 5223 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00800253/10 or ?id=EFTA00800253&page=10]", "char_count": 5223}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00800253", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "Page II of 13 \n2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 27215, *41 \n18 U.S.C. § 3771(a1. \nThis Court previously held the following with respect to the \nCVRA: First, the rights under the CVRA attach before the \nGovernment brings formal charges against a defendant. Does \nv. United States. 817 F. Sapp. 2d 1337. 1341 (SD. Fla. 20111. \nSecond, the CVRA authorizes the rescission or \"reopening\" of \na prosecutorial agreement, including a non-prosecution \nagreement, reached in violation of a prosecutors conferral \nobligations under the statute. Doe v. United States. 950 F. \nStipp. 2d 1262, 1267 (S.D. Fla. 2013). Third section \n3771(d1(5) of the CVRA authorizes the setting aside of pre-\ncharge prosecutorial agreements, despite the fact that the \nparticular statutory enforcement provision expressly refers to \nthe reopening of a plea [*421 or sentence. Id. at 1267. Fourth, \nthe \"reasonable right to confer . . . in the case\" extends to the \npm-charge state of criminal investigations and proceedings. \nId. Fifth, the federal sex offense crimes involving minors \nallegedly committed by Epstein renders these Petitioners \ncrime victims under the CVRA. Id. at 1269. Sixth, \"questions \npertaining to [the] equitable defense's] are properly left for \nresolution after development of a full evidentiary record.\" Id \nat 1269 n. 6. \nHere, it is undisputed that the Government entered into a NPA \nwith Epstein without conferring with Petitioners during its \nnegotiation and signing. Instead, the Government sent letters \nto the victims requesting their \"patience\" with the \ninvestigation even after the Government entered into the \nNPA. At a bare minimum, the CVRA required the \nGovernment to inform Petitioners that it intended to enter into \nan agreement not to prosecute Epstein. Although the binding \neffect of the NPA was contingent upon Epstein pleading \nguilty to the state charges, that contingency was out of the \ncontrol of the Government. The Government's hands were \npermanently tied if Epstein fulfilled his obliga\n... [truncated, 5869 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00800253/11 or ?id=EFTA00800253&page=11]", "char_count": 5869}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00800253", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "Page 12 of 13 \n2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 27215,'45 \nspecifically excluded the right of victims to be informed of a \nnon-prosecution agreement. Prior to this amendment, this \nCourt held that the right to confer extended to the pm-charge \nstate of criminal investigations and proceedings. Doe. 950 F. \nStipp. 2d at 1267• see also 157 Cong. Rec. S7060-01, 157 \nCong. Rec. S7060-01, 57060 (CVRA co-sponsor Senator Jon \nKyl's 2011 letter to the Attorney General, explaining that \n\"Congress intended the CVRA to broadly protect crime \nvictims throughout the criminal justice process-from the \ninvestigative phases to the final conclusion of a case.\") \nThe 2015 amendment did not serve to repeal or restrict the \nobligations of the Government to confer with victims in the \nearly stages of a case. Instead, the 2015 amendment clarified \nthat certain events, such as plea agreements or deferred \nprosecution agreements, must be conveyed to the crime \nvictim. Put another way, the 2015 amendment codified what \nthe courts had been interpreting the CVRA to require, such as \nentitlement to notice of a plea bargain. See In re Dean. 527 \nF.3d at 394 (\"the government should have fashioned a \nreasonable way to [*46] inform the victims of the likelihood \nof criminal charges and to ascertain the victims' views on the \npossible details of a plea bargain\"); United States v. Oakum. \nNo. CRIM. 3:08CR132. 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 24401. 2009 \nWL 790042. at *2 (ED. Va. Mar. 24. 2009) (the statutory \nlanguage of the CVRA gives the victims' rights before the \naccepting of plea agreements). \nTo the extent the Government relies upon the \"interpretive \ncanon, expressio unites est exchtsio alterius, 'expressing one \nitem of [an] associated group or series excludes another left \nunmentioned\"' the Court is not persuaded. Chevron U.S.A. \nInc. v. Echazabal 536 U.S. 73, 80, 122 S. Ct. 2045, 153 L \nEd. 2d 82 (2002) (quoting United States v. Vonn. 535 U.S. 55. \n65. 122 S. Ct. 1043. 152 L Ed. 2d 90 (2002)1. \"The force of \nan\n... [truncated, 6011 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00800253/12 or ?id=EFTA00800253&page=12]", "char_count": 6011}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00800253", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "Page 13 of 13 \n2019 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 27215, *49 \nthe victim letters telling them that they had rights protected \nunder the CVRA. Nor would they have told Epstein's \nattorneys that it had obligations to notify the victims. In any \nevent, an agency's own \"'interpretation of a statute cannot \nsupersede the language chosen by Congress.\" Mohasco Corp. \nv. Silver. 447 U.S. 807. 825. 100 S. Ct. 2486. 65 L Ed. 2d 532 \n(19801. \nNext, the Court rejects the Government's contention that Jane \nDoe 2 is not protected by the CVRA because she made \nstatements favorable to Epstein early in the investigation? \nThere is no dispute that Epstein sexually abused Jane Doe 2 \nwhile she was a minor. Therefore, regardless of her comments \nto the prosecutor, she was a victim. See 18 U.S.C. S 3771(e1 \n(the CVRA defines a victim as \"a person directly and \nproximately harmed as a result of the commission of a Federal \noffense\")• In re Stewart. 552 F.3d 1285. 1288 (11th Or. \n20081 (\"to determine a crime victim, then, first, we identify \nthe behavior constituting 'commission of a Federal offense.' \nSecond, we identify the direct and proximate effects of that \nbehavior on parties other than the United States. If the \ncriminal behavior causes a party direct and proximate harmful \neffects, the party is a victim under the CVRA.\"). \nThe Court need not resolve the factual questions surrounding \nwhat and when the victims [*50] were told about the state \ncourt proceeding and whether a state court proceeding is \ncovered by the CVRA. Under the facts of this case, once the \nGovernment failed to advise the victims about its intention to \nenter into the NPA, a violation of the CVRA occurred. \nNor does the Court need to consider the Government's \nestoppel arguments at this time. These arguments relate only \nto the remedy, and not the determination of whether there was \na CVRA violation. Therefore, the Court will address this issue \nat the appropriate juncture. \nLastly, the Court will address the Government's ar\n... [truncated, 3696 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00800253/13 or ?id=EFTA00800253&page=13]", "char_count": 3696}]}