{"efta_number": "EFTA00793971", "page_count": 9, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00793971", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00793971.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00793971", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "Macon de Reya \nOur Ref: \nJUJHEVV/HAFAlan Dershowitz \nAfrica House \nYour Ref: \n70 Kingsway \nLondon WC2B 6AH \nDX 37954 Kingsway \nURGENT — NOT FOR PUBLICATION — STRICTLY PRIVATE & \nCONFIDENTIAL \nwww.mishcon.com \nMartin Clarke \nPublisher \nMailOnline \nNorthcliffe House \n2 Derry Street \nLondon \nW8 5TT \nDear Sir \nOur client: Alan Dershowitz \nLetter of Claim \nWe write further to previous correspondence in this matter. \n4 January 2019 \nBY EMAIL \nIn the absence of a satisfactory reply to our letters, we have been instructed by our client to \nsend you (in your capacity as Publisher of MailOnline) a formal letter of claim in accordance \nwith the Pre-Action Protocol for Defamation. \nFor the avoidance of doubt, the article that forms the subject of our client's complaint is the \none published on MailOnline on 18 December 2018 headed \"Second woman claims billionaire \nJeffrey Epstein 'directed' her to hove sex with lawyer Alan Dershowitz WHILE he was defending \npedophile on underage prostitution charge\" (url: \n, y II I \nCO \nI \n65097.13 SLE \n,in-; I \nis-Dill \n.L-JJ' Ly-EistL \nIVJj'L -A IT-\nDL \nLL \n \n). We attach a copy of the article for ease of reference (omitting the 'under-\nthe-line' comments). \nDespite our detailed initial complaint of 21 December, which requested that the article be \nremoved immediately from the MailOnline website, and our follow-up letters of 22 and 29 \nDecember, the article remains online to this day. \nIn the light of this, we start by observing that your newspaper's lackadaisical and dismissive \nresponse to our client's complaint stands in stark contrast to the seriousness with which he \ntakes this matter. Indeed, we cannot overstate — and you should not underestimate — how \nseriously he takes it. Both he and we are staggered at the indifference you have shown thus \nfar. \n51241084.3 \nMishcon de Reya is a limited liability \npartnership, registered in England and \nWales (number OC399969). authorised \nand regulated by the Solicitors \nSwitchboard: +44 (0)20 3321\n... [truncated, 2164 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00793971/0 or ?id=EFTA00793971&page=0]", "char_count": 2164}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00793971", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "M&con de Reya \nProfessor Dershowitz, as you must be aware, enjoys a distinguished reputation as a \npractising and academic lawyer, as a jurist, as a writer, and as a commentator on legal issues \nin the media (print and television). He possesses this reputation not just in the United States, \nwhich is his home, but also in this country, where your newspaper attracts its primary \nreadership, in Europe, and throughout the world more generally. He has worked hard for \nover 50 years of professional life to build up this reputation. Indeed, at 80 years old, he \ncontinues to work as hard as he ever has. \nAs such, you may not be surprised to learn that he regards it as completely unacceptable \nthat an ostensibly reputable, well-established and well-resourced British newspaper such as \nyours, should seek to destroy that reputation at this stage in his life by disseminating \nappalling falsehoods concerning him to its very large audience on the internet. Since this is \nso, he is determined to obtain from your newspaper the reputational vindication in respect \nof these falsehoods to which he is clearly entitled. \nAgainst this background, we turn to the offending article. \nDefamatory meaning \nIn its natural and ordinary and/or inferential defamatory meaning, the article means and \nwould be understood by readers to mean that Professor Dershowitz engaged in unlawful, \npaedophilic sexual relations with two girls. name) ; \n \nwho \nwere underage at the time (that is. below the legal age of consent) and who had been \ndirected to have sex with him by his paedophile client, Jeffrey Epstein, while he was \ndefending Mr Epstein on — and dishonestly submitting to the Court that Mr Epstein was \ninnocent of — underage prostitution charges. \nIt perhaps goes without saying that this is an outrageous slur, which could not be more \nserious in terms of its defamatory effect. \nIt is grossly defamatory of Professor Dershowitz in a personal sense, that is, in terms of his \npersonal reputation for prob\n... [truncated, 3225 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00793971/1 or ?id=EFTA00793971&page=1]", "char_count": 3225}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00793971", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Macon de Reya \ncaused — and for as long as it remains online and uncorrected — is likely to continue to cause \nvery serious harm to Professor Dershowitz's reputation. Having regard to the gravity of the \ndefamatory imputations and the extent of their publication by your newspaper, this is not \nonly an article which is likely to cause reasonable and right-thinking people to think seriously \nthe worse of Professor Dershowitz, but one which is likely to make them shun and avoid \nhim, personally and professionally. \nFactual inaccuracies / falsity \nFurthermore — if it needs to be spelled out — the article, in the defamatory meaning which \nwe have identified above, is entirely false. There is no factual substance to it whatsoever. To \nbe clear: \n( I ) Professor Dershowitz is not a paedophile and has never had sex or sexual relations \nwith anyone under the legal age of consent. \n(2) He has never had sex or sexual relations with either \nwhether in the context or at the time described in the article o \ntime. Insofar as Ms \nand Ms Roberts have alleged otherwise, each is lying, \nand demonstrably so. \n(3) He has never knowingly or dishonestly misled a Court, whether in the context of Mr \nEpstein's case or on any other occasion. \nNo tenable defence \nIn the light of the above, any suggested defence of truth would be misconceived, bound to \nfail and be apt only to aggravate the situation yet further (if that is possible). \nTo the credit of Mr Martin Wood, Group Legal Adviser of Associated Newspapers Ltd, who \nwrote to us in connection with this matter on 28 December 2018 (email, 15:24), he \nproposed no such defence. However, he did suggest — without providing proper particulars \nof the same — that your newspaper might be able to rely on reporting privilege by way of a \ndefence. \nWhile the burden of proof in respect of any such defence is on your newspaper (and strictly \nwithout prejudice to that burden of proof), our client's position is that any defence of \nreporting privilege on\n... [truncated, 2721 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00793971/2 or ?id=EFTA00793971&page=2]", "char_count": 2721}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00793971", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Macon de Reya \nmore accurately, declaration — of Ms Roberts forms any part of the publicly \naccessible record of any legal proceedings in which it was filed. \n(c) Thirdly, even if — which is denied — the reference in the article to Ms Roberts' \naffidavit was capable of engaging paragraph 5 of Schedule I, Part I to the Defamation \nAct 1996, it would not attract a reporting privilege under s.I5 of that Act. This is so: \n(i) because, under s. 5(3), that section does not apply to the publication to the \npublic of matter which is not of public interest and the publication of which is not \nfor the public benefit; and (ii) because your newspaper's publication was made with \nmalice. \n(d) In relation to (i), we invite you to consider (1) whether it can realistically be said to \nhave been of public interest or for the public benefit to recycle the dishonest \nallegations concerning our client made in Ms Roberts' affidavit without mentioning, \nas the New York Daily News did in the item on which your article was based, that a \njudge had ordered those claims to be stricken from the record (\"She (Roberts] \nalleged in 2014 that Epstein 'trafficked' her to Dershowitz... for sex — a claim that has \nsince been stricken from the record\"), or without making any reference to the plethora \nof information readily available on the internet and elsewhere from credible \ndiscrediting those allegations; and (2) the approach that Tugendhat J adopted \ntowards issues of this character in the case that Mr Irian Qadir brought against the \nMail on Sunday and MailOnline in 201 I, as reported at [2013] EMLR IS. \n(e) With respect to (ii), malice, it seems clear to us that your newspaper's dominant \nmotive and purpose in publishing its article was not to discharge any public interest, \n'watchdog', reporting role, but to publish sensational, salacious and attention-\ngrabbing allegations concerning Professor Dershowitz and thereby to injure him and \nhis good name. Furthermore, the inference of malice is st\n... [truncated, 3462 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00793971/3 or ?id=EFTA00793971&page=3]", "char_count": 3462}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00793971", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "(g) \n0 \nMthhcon de Reya \nAt no time during the hearing did Ms Maxwell's attorney, Ms Laura \nMenninger, state or suggest that Ms \nwas alle ing that she had \nactually had sex with Professor Dershowitz. Ms \nallegation, as Ms \nMenninger said, was strictly confined to one that Mr Epstein had directed \nher to have sex with him: see, for example, the article published concerning \nthe \nmatter \non \n19 \nDecember \nin \nthe \nMiami \nHerald \n(url \nhe \nd co \nsi,v,‘ \nc lc 223315075 L il) (\"Nowhere \nin the court case or the transcript does \nor anyone else allege that \nhad sex with Dershowitz\"). Your newspaper's article fails to make \nclear this important limitation upon what Ms Menninger told the Court. \n(ii) \nThe offending article also fails to make clear the significant\n that neither \nMs \nnor Ms Menninger were alleging that Ms \nwas under \nthe legal age of consent at the time Mr Epstein was said to have directed her \nto have sex with other persons: see, by contrast, the 18 December New \nYork Daily News article, which states \" \nhas sued Epstein and his \nalleged madam, Ghislaine Maxwell, saying they trafficked her for sex from 2006 to \n2007, while she was in her 20s\" (emphasis added). \nIn the premises, your newspaper's article cannot on any sensible view be \ncharacterised as a fair and accurate report of the court proceedings between Ms \nand Mr Epstein and Ms Maxwell. Even if it could, our client would contend, \nfor similar reasons to those stated above in relation to the references to Ms \nRoberts's allegations, that the article was not of public interest or for the public \nbenefit, and was published with malice. \nRedress / remedies sought \nIn these circumstances, if legal proceedings by our client for defamation are to be avoided, \nhe expects to receive from you and Associated Newspapers Limited as a matter of \nurgency the following redress: \n(I) The immediate removal from your website of the offending article and \nconfirmation in writing that this has been done. By \"immediate\", we m\n... [truncated, 2988 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00793971/4 or ?id=EFTA00793971&page=4]", "char_count": 2988}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00793971", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Miiihcon de Reya \n(a) To publish prominently on your website a correction and apology to Professor \nDershowitz in terms to be agreed in advance by us, reflecting all aspects of the \ndefamatory meaning identified above. \n(b) To join with Professor Dershowitz in the making of a statement in open court in \nwhich you retract and apologise for the libellous allegations concerning him \nwhich you have published. \n(c) To undertake not to republish those allegations or any similar allegations \nconcerning Professor Dershowitz. \n(d) To pay Professor Dershowitz substantial damages to vindicate his reputation and \nto compensate him (i) for the serious harm that has been done to his reputation \nand (ii) for the distress, hurt and humiliation that your publication has caused \nhim. We invite your proposals as to quantum. Having regard to the gravity of \nthe libels and the extent of their circulation, we anticipate that your offer will be \ntowards the top end of the conventional scale: cf Cairns v Moth [2013] I WLR \n1015 at [25] and the remarks of Nicklin J in the recent case of Monir v Wood \n[2018] EWHC 3535 (QB) at [236]. \n(e) To pay Professor Dershowitz's legal costs. \nPlease may we hear from you by return. We should not need to remind you that your \nnewspaper has been on notice of our client's complaint about the offending article since 21 \nDecember, which is already some two weeks ago. We therefore make it clear to you now \nthat in default of receipt of a satisfactory substantive reply to this letter within 14 days of the \ndate of this letter, our instructions are to proceed to issue proceedings for libel on our \nclient's behalf without further delay. \nIn the meantime, we specifically draw to your attention your obligation to preserve and to \nkeep safe all potentially relevant and disclosable documentation within your control, \nincluding electronic documents: see CPR PD 31B, paragraph 7 as to the latter. \nOtherwise, we expressly reserve all of Professor Dershowitz's rights on h\n... [truncated, 2267 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00793971/5 or ?id=EFTA00793971&page=5]", "char_count": 2267}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00793971", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "12/22/2018 \nSecond woman claims billionaire Jeffrey Epstein directed her to have sex with lawyer Alan Dershowitz I Daily Mail Online \nPrivacy Polley I Feedback le Like15,6M \nSaturday, Dee 22nd 2018 3PM 10•C \n6PM EC \n5•Day Forecast \nifictilOnline \nHome News U.S. I Sport I 71/8Sh0wblz I Australia I Femail I Health I Science I Money I Video I Travel I DallylealITV \nRoydl \nWorld Nt... \n- \nPictures Most read Wires Discounts \nADvERTSINENT \nSecond woman claims billionaire \nJeffrey Epstein 'directed' her to have \nsex with lawyer Alan Dershowitz \nWHILE he was defending pedophile on \nunderage prostitution charges \n• It was revealed in a November 7 telephone conference that \nwas \naccusing Jeffrey Epstein of 'directing' her to have sex \n• The New York Daily News is reporting that \nalleges that she was asked \nto have sex with Alan Dershowitz by Epstein \n• The transcript of that conference has since been sealed and will not be released \nuntil the end of the month \n• Dershowitz reviously denied a claim that he had sex with another Epstein \naccuser, \n• Roberts said that she was asked to have sex with Derhsowitz six times, starting \nwhen she was 16 \n• Epstein served less than two years in prison despite 40 women coming forward \nand saying they were forced into sex acts with the billionaire while underage \nBy CHRIS SPARGO FOR DAILYMAIL.COM \nPUBLISHED: 22:07,18 December 2018 I UPDATED: 06.57, 19 December 7018 \n533 \n240 \nshares \nVic er comments \nA second woman is claiming that she was 'directed' to have sex with lawyer Alan \nDershowitz by one of his clients, billionaire felon Jeffrey Epstein. \nwho is currently suing Epstein and his team of alleged enablers, \nclaims that she was trafficked by the pedophile starting in October 2OO6 and into \nApril fo the following year. \nIt was during this time that she was told by Epstein to have sex with Dershowitz \naccording to the New York Daily News. \nThat allegation was revealed in a November 7 telephone conference according to \nthe report, the tra\n... [truncated, 2521 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00793971/6 or ?id=EFTA00793971&page=6]", "char_count": 2521}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00793971", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "12/22/2018 \nSecond woman claims billionaire Jeffrey Epstein directed her to have sex with lawyer Alan Dershowitz I Daily Mail Online \nDershowitz would have been defending Epstein at the time of the alleged sexual \nkFeathered and fancy \nencounter, having been hired to work on the case in 2005 when a number of \nunderage girls began coming forward and telling police they were paid to have sex. \nScroll down for video \n• \n+1 \nFriends: Alan Dershowitz is being accused of having sex with a second Epstein victim (pair \nabove in 2OO4) \nThis makes \nthe second woman to allege that she had sex with Dershowitz \nat the behest of Epstein. \nalleged in a court affidavit that she had sex with the lawyer six times. \nDershowitz has denied that claim for years, and said that he only once received a \nmassage from one of Epstein's female employees and that the woman was not a \nminor. \nRoberts claims that she was just 16 the first time she had sex with Epstein. \nSHARE THIS \nRELATED ARTICLES \nARTICLE \nActress Penny Marshal \n'The most hated woman \n-who starred In Laverne \nin America': Killer Chris \n&Shirley... \nfill \nWatts.... \nThe case is back in the spotlight after a blistering expose in The Miami Herald that \ntook a look back at the allegations made against Epstein. \nThat piece included interviews with a number of Epstein's alleged victims. \nEpstein pleaded guilty to sex crimes involving underage girls and got 13 months \nbehind bars. \nWhat the public and his accusers did not know at the time was that he had secretly \nstruck a deal with federal prosecutors that spared him from charges that could have \nput him away for the rest of his life. \nWhen the deal finally came to light years later, it immediately raised suspicions that \nEpstein - a man who counted Bill Clinton and Donald Trump among his friends and \nhad some of the finest legal talent in America as his lawyers - had used his wealth \nand political connections to win special treatment. \n7 Stridly's Dianne \nBoswell displays her \ndancer\n... [truncated, 3814 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00793971/7 or ?id=EFTA00793971&page=7]", "char_count": 3814}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00793971", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "12/22/2018 \nSecond woman claims billionaire Jeffrey Epstein directed her to have sex with lawyer Alan Dershowitz I Daily Mail ()Mine \nin 2008 approved the secret deal. \nAcosta is now Trump's secretary of labor. \nEpstein, 65, reached the non-prosecution deal with Acosta's office while under \ninvestigation on suspicion of sexually abusing at least 40 teenage girls. \nUnder the deal, he pleaded guilty to two state charges, did his time in jail, paid \nsettlements to many of the alleged victims and registered as a sex offender. \nHe could have faced a far more severe penalty if federal prosecutors had pursued a \ndraft 53-page indictment that was never filed and included sex trafficking charges. \nSome of Epstein's accusers are now arguing that their rights were trampled under a \nfederal law that says crime victims must be informed about plea bargains. \nOne of Epstein's lawyers, Roy Black, has said there was no conspiracy to violate \nvictims' rights, and the plea agreement was 'no sweetheart deal by any stretch of the \nimagination.' \nEven if the plea bargain is nullified, the final decision on bringing charges would rest \nsolely with the Justice Department. \nOn Tuesday, Epstein settled a defamation lawsuit brought against him by a lawyer for \nsome of the accusers, Bradley Edwards, who said Epstein tried to derail his \nrepresentation of the women and ruin his career. \nIn settling, Epstein apologized and agreed to pay an undisclosed amount. \nEdwards said some of the accusers - some of whom say they were 13 or 14 when they \nwere molested - were prepared to testify in the lawsuit and may yet get their day in \nfederal court. \nCongressional Democrats are calling for an internal Justice Department \ninvestigation. \nAcosta has not commented about the case during the recent media coverage. He \nwas asked briefly about the non-prosecution agreement at his Senate confirmation \nhearing. \nAccording to court papers, Epstein had a Palm Beach mansion where girls were \nbrought for what they we\n... [truncated, 4182 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00793971/8 or ?id=EFTA00793971&page=8]", "char_count": 4182}]}