{"efta_number": "EFTA00788364", "page_count": 19, "url": "https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00788364", "pdf_url": "https://epstein-data.com/pdf/EFTA00788364.pdf", "pages": [{"efta_number": "EFTA00788364", "page_number": 0, "text_content": "W. CHESTER BREWER, JR., P.A. \nATTORNEY AT LAW \nSUITE 1400 \n250 AUSTRALIAN AVENUE SOUTH \nWEST PALM BEACH, FLORIDA 33401.5056 \nTELEPHONE (561)655-4777 \nPAX (561)2354691 \nOctober 19, 2017 \nVia eCourtesy \nThe Honorable Rodney Smith \nDade County Courthouse \n73 West Flagler Street \nCourtroom DCC1401 \nMiami, FL 33130 \nRE: \nJean-Luc Brunel, individually and MCI Model & Talent Miami, LLC vs. \nJeffrey Epstein, Tyler McDonald, Tyler McDonald D/B/A/ YLORG \nCase No.: 14-21348 CA 01 \nDear Judge Smith: \nPlease find enclosed a courtesy copy of Defendant, Jeffrey Epstein's, Response to Motion \nfor Ruling on Service of Process on Defendant, Jeffrey Epstein without a Hearing. Because the \nPlaintiffs attorney, Mr. Titone, is asking by way of his motion that you rule on his motion \nwithout a hearing, we are concerned that Mr. Titone may provide his motion to you directly. We \nare very much opposed to Mr. Titone's motion and therefore we have filed with the Clerk the \nattached response. \nThank you very much for your consideration of this situation. \nVery truly yours, \nW. CIS \nBRE \nJR., ESQUIRE \nWCB/msk \nEnclosure \ncc: \nMr. Joseph Titone, Esq. \nEFTA00788364\n", "char_count": 1153}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00788364", "page_number": 1, "text_content": "• \nFiling # 62990957 E-Filed 10/18/2017 12:26:18 PM \nIN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE \nELEVENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN AND \nFOR DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA \nCASE NO. 14-21348-CA-01 \nJEAN-LUC BRUNEL, individually, \nand MC2 MODEL & TALENT \nMIAMI, LLC. \nPlaintiffs, \nvs. \nJEFFREY EPSTEIN, \nTYLER MCDONALD, TYLER \nMCDONALD D/B/A/ YLORO \nDefendants. \nDEFENDANT, JEFFREY EPSTEIN'S RESPONSE TO \nMOTION FOR RULING ON SERVICE OF PROCESS ON DEFENDANT JEFFREY \nEPSTEIN WITH ATTACHED ORDER \nCOMES NOW, the Defendant, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, by and through his undersigned \ncounsel, and files his response to Plaintiffs Motion for Ruling on Service of Process on \nDefendant, Jeffrey Epstein, Without a Hearing, and states as follows: \n1. \nThe Amended Complaint in this mutter was filed January 2015. After almost \nthree (3) years, the Plaintiff has never properly served Defendant, Jeffrey Epstein. \n2. \nOn October 16, 2017, Plaintiff; Jean-Luc Brunel, through counsel, filed his \nsecond Motion for Ruling on Service of Process. This motion is essentially a re-file of Plaintiffs \nMotion for Ruling on Service of Process filed March 16, 2017. \n3. \nThe single major difference between the October 16, 2017 and March 6, 2017, \nfilings is that Jean-Luc Brunel is now asking that the court grant his motion without a hearing. \n4. \nFully aware that Jeffiey Epstein opposes both motions for Ruling on Service of \nProcess, counsel for Plaintiff has failed to inform the court of any opposition, thus implying by \nomission that the motions are agreed upon. Nothing could be further from the truth. \nEFTA00788365\n", "char_count": 1570}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00788364", "page_number": 2, "text_content": "Jean-Luc Brunel, et al. vs. Jeffrey Epstein, et al. \nCase No.: 14-21348-CA-01 \nResponse to Plaintiffs Motion for Ruling on \nService of Process on Jeffrey Epstein \n5. \nIn response to Plaintiffs prior Motion for Ruling on Service of Process \nDefendant, Jeffrey Epstein, filed his Memorandum in Opposition to Motion for Ruling on \nService of Process. Mr. Epstein maintains his prior positions with regard to Plaintiffs failure to \nproperly serve him in what is now 2 years and 10 months after the filing of Plaintiffs amended \ncomplaint. A copy of this Memorandum is attached as Exhibit A. In the seven months that have \npassed since Mr. Epstein filed his Memorandum in Opposition, Plaintiff has never even \nattempted to set his motion for hearing. \n6. \nAlso in response to Plaintiffs prior Motion for Ruling on Service of Process and \nbrowse the Plaintiff had failed to comply with this court's order of October 5, 2016, Defendant, \nJeffrey Epstein, filed a Motion to Dismiss. As grounds for the Motion to Dismiss, Mr. Epstein \nrelied on the express terms of this Court's October 5 Order that if service were not effected by the \ndeadline specifically provided in the Order, the case was to be automatically dismissed and \"no \nfurther order of this Court shall be necessary.\" Copies of this court's Order and Epstein's \nMotion to Dismiss are attached hereto as Exhibits B & C respectively. In the seven months that \nhave passed since Mr. Epstein filed his Motion to Dismiss, Plaintiff never once opposed the \nautomatic dismissal of this case. \n7. \nIncredibly, although Plaintiff was clearly informed on December 7, 2016, that the \nPlaintiffs last attempted service on November 17, 2016, was ineffective, Plaintiff has not made a \nsingle attempt to properly serve Mr. Bpstein since that failed November 17th attempt \n8. \nThe additional time to obtain proper service which was so graciously granted by \nthis court has long since run. Rather than attempt to obtain proper service, the Plaintiff has filed \n... [truncated, 2304 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00788364/2 or ?id=EFTA00788364&page=2]", "char_count": 2304}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00788364", "page_number": 3, "text_content": "Jean-Luc Brunel, et al. vs. Jeffrey Epstein, et al. \nCase No.: 14-21348-CA-01 \nResponse to Plaintiffs Motion for Ruling on \nService of Process on Jeffrey Epstein \n9. \nGiven the flagrant violations of Florida Statutes dealing with Service of Process, \nthe Florida Rules of Civil Procedure, this Court's Order of October 5, 2016, and Plaintiffs \nattempt to mislead the court by not informing the court that there was opposition to his motions \nand an outstanding Motion to Dismiss; this matter should be dismissed with prejudice. NOTE: \nThis claim has already been dismissed by operation of this Court's Order of October 5, 2016. \nWHEREFORE, Defendant, Jeffrey Epstein, moves that the court dismiss, with prejudice, \nthe claims of JEAN-LUC BRUNEL, individually, and MC2 MODEL & TALENT MIAMI, \nLLC. \nCERTIFICATE OF SERVICE \nIT IS HEREBY CERTIFIED that a true and correct copy of the foregoing has been \nelectronically furnished via email and/or E-ftle on the Vi day of October, 2017 to Joe Tyrone, \njoctitone708@comcastmet. \nW. CHESTER BREWER, JR,Ill. \nCounsel for Epstein \n250 S. Australian Avenue, Suite 1400 \nWest Palm Beach. FL 33401 \n(561) \n(561) \nE-Mail: \nBy: \n \n/s/ W. Chester Brewer. Jr. \nW. CHESTER BREWER, JR., ESQUIRE \nFlorida Bar No. 261858 \nEFTA00788367\n", "char_count": 1264}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00788364", "page_number": 4, "text_content": "r \nIN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE \nELEVENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN AND \nPOR DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA \nJEAN-LUC BRUNEL, individually, \nand MC2 MODEL & TALENT \nMIAMI, LLC. \nPlaintiffs, \nvs. \nJEFFREY EPSTEIN, \nTYLER MCDONALD, TYLER \nMCDONALD D/B/A/ YLORO \nDefendants. \nCASE NO. 14-21348-CA-01 \nMEMORANDUM IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR \nRULING ON SERVICE OF PROCESS \nHaving already once received this Court's indulgence for Plaintiffs' total \ndisregard of Florida's procedural rules governing proper service of process and a 120-day \nextension of the time within which to effect service (effectively providing Plaintiffs with a 2-year \nservice window), Plaintiffs again ignore Florida's jurisdictional prerequisites with their improper \nservice attempt. They have disregarded this Court's new service deadline even after receiving \nprompt and repeated notice from the undersigned counsel of their improper and ineffective \nservice attempt, and, now that the deadline has long passed, ask this Court to bless their \nmisconduct for a second time. \nService of process in this case is governed by Florida law. Florida Statutes Section \n48.031 (I)(a) requires that service of original process be made by personally delivering a copy of \nthe complaint, petition or other initial pleading or paper to the person to be served, or by leaving \nthe copies at his or her usual place of abode with any person residing therein who is 15 years of \nage or older and informing the person of their contents. Plaintiffs have not met a single one of \nthese requirements in this case. \nWhen Plaintiffs first filed their complaint in August 2014, Defendant Jeffrey Epstein was \nnot even a party. Plaintiffs amended their complaint in January 2015 to assert two non-business \ncounts against Mr. Epstein personally and caused a summons to be issued on February 9, 2015. \nIn more than two years since Plaintiffs amended their complaint to include Mr. Epstein as a \nparty, they have not made a single attempt to serve Mr. Epstein at his resi\n... [truncated, 2454 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00788364/4 or ?id=EFTA00788364&page=4]", "char_count": 2454}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00788364", "page_number": 5, "text_content": "Process in connection with that failed attempt. The undersigned counsel promptly filed a motion \nto quash on behalf of Mr. Epstein in April 2015. Plaintiffs waited a full year to respond to that \nmotion to quash and in their response, perhaps conceding that the attempted service was \nimproper, asked this Court to disregard the procedural rules and order that Plaintiffs be permitted \nto serve Mr. Epstein through legal counsel (not the undersigned) not even of record in this case. \nAfter Plaintiffs failed to appear at the hearing that Plaintiffs themselves scheduled on Mr. \nEpstein's motion to quash, on July 28, 2016, this Court granted Mr. Epstein's motion to quash. \nThereafter, Plaintiffs sought a rehearing, claiming that they did not realize that the \nhearing they themselves scheduled was proceeding, and on October 5, 2015, this court kindly \ngranted Plaintiffs a full 120 additional days within which to properly servo Mr. Epstein or the \nmatter would be dismissed without further order of this Court. \nAlthough Mr. Epstein's affidavit confirming the location of his residence in the U.S. \nVirgin Islands was filed as part of Mr. Epstein's original motion to quash, Plaintiffs ignored it. \nOn November 17, 2016, Plaintiffs chose instead to make only their second service attempt in the \n647 days since the original summons was issued to Mr. Epstein (and Plaintiffs' one and only \nservice attempt during the period of extension granted by this Court) by leaving the summons \nand amended complaint with a non-party at an office address, which was clearly not Mr. \nEpstein's personal residence. \nAmong the multitude of procedural defects in connection with \nthat failed attempt, there is simply no legal authority for substitute service on Mr. Epstein in this \nmatter by leaving process at an office address. \nFlorida Statute Section 48.031 (2)(b) does allow substitute service under limited \ncircumstances that are not applicable here. Under Section 48.031(2Xb) substitute service is \nper\n... [truncated, 3900 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00788364/5 or ?id=EFTA00788364&page=5]", "char_count": 3900}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00788364", "page_number": 6, "text_content": "The motion and notice filed by Plaintiffs assert that service is impossible on Little St. \nJames, because this is a private island. Such assertion is absurd on its face, as service of process \ntakes place routinely on private property. Little St. James is one of several residential says in the \nU.S. Virgin Islands. The mode of tmnsportatlon to such cays may be by boat rather than car, but \ncertainly service of process is possible on any of them. Access to such cays by boat is common-\nplace in the U.S. Virgin Islands, and Little St. James is well-identified and easily located on any \nmap. As is evident from the photograph of Little St James provided by Plaintiffs in connection \nwith their motion, the Island features a sizable dock by which those arriving by boat may access \nthe Island. That dock effectively serves as the front door to Little St. James, and as with any \nprivate residence, there was absolutely nothing preventing a process server from proceeding to \nthe front door and inquiring of Mr. Epstein. Access to Little St. James was certainly available in \nthis case and should have been attempted, but never was. \nAs a further example of Plaintiffs' defective service, Florida Statute Section 48.031 (5) \nrequires that a person serving process place on the first page of at least one of the processes \nserved, the date and time of service, and his or her identification number and initials for all \nservice of process. Nowhere in the notice or the documents attached thereto is there any \ninformation or indication that this requirement was complied with in Plaintiffs' failed and \nimproper attempt at substitute service. \nIn addition, Florida Statue Section 49.031 (1)(a) requires that the person serving the \nprocess inform the person served of the contents of that which is being served. Nowhere in \nPlaintiffs' motion, notice of service of process or the papers attached thereto is it indicated \nor stated that Plaintiffs complied with even this basic requirement. \nOn Decemb\n... [truncated, 3718 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00788364/6 or ?id=EFTA00788364&page=6]", "char_count": 3718}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00788364", "page_number": 7, "text_content": "CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE \nIT IS HEREBY CERTIFIED that a true and correct copy of the foregoing has been electronically \nfurnished via email and/or E-file on the 30th day of March, 2017 to Joe Titone, \njoetitono708@comr,ast.net. \nW. CHESTER BREWER, JR., P.A. \nCounsel for Epstein \n250 S. Australian Avenue, Suite 1400 \nWest Palm Beach, FL 33401 \n(561) 6554777 - Telephone \n(561) 83 - \n- \nE-Mail: \nBy: \n \n/s/ W. Chester Brewer, Jr, \nW. CHF,STER BREWER, JR., ESQUIRE \nFlorida Bar No. 261858 \nEFTA00788371\n", "char_count": 500}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00788364", "page_number": 8, "text_content": "W. CHESTER BREWER, JR., \nATTORNEY AT LAW \nSUL111 1400 \n250 AUSTRALIAN AVENUE SOUTH \nWEST PALM BEACH, VLORMA 31401.5086 \nTEUTPHON13 (RS I) 65SAM \nFAX (561) 8354691 \nDecember 2, 2016 \nVia Email: joetitone708(geomcastnet \nJoe Titone, Esq. \n621 S.E. 5th St \nPompano Beach, FL 33060 \nRe: Service of Process \nDear Joe, \nDecember 7, 2016 \nVia Email: Metitone708acomeastnet \nJoe Titone, Esq. \n621 S.E. 56 Street \nPompano Beach, FL 33060 \nRe: Service of Process \nDear Joe: \nI have had an opportunity to review the Notice Service of Process that you filed in the Jean Luc Brunel/Jeffrey Epstein \ncase. From my review it is clear that once again the attempt to serve runs afoul of Florida Statutes 48.031, as well as the \nholding in the Third District in HAUSER VS. SCHIFF, I have attached a copy of that case for your ready reference. \nIt is now almost two years past the January 2015 filing date of your clients' amended complaint Joining Mr. Epstein as a \ndefendant to the original action filed in August 2014. I remind you that no attempt was made to even serve Mr. Epstein \nuntil March 10, 2015. The required Notice of Service was never filed with the Court in respect of that attempt, which \nyou, yourself, conceded in your later filed Motion for Reconsideration was improper service. After rescheduling the \nhearing on Mr. Epstein's April 29, 2015 Motion to Quash four separate times, you failed to appear at the July 27, 2016 \nhearing on that Motion which was delayed for morn than a year after its original filing date. The court granted Mr. \nEpstein's motion in your absence. \nAt the subsequent October 5, 2016 hearing on your Motion for Reconsideration, you sought pardon from the Court for \nyour failure to appear at the July 27, 2016 hearing on Mr. Epstein's Motion to Quash. You sought to excuse your \nabsence, claiming that doe to a brain issue you somehow misunderstood the date on which you were M appear even \nthough it was you, yourself, who cancelled the prevl \nin -aNaAnlati I' \" n \"\n 2016 \n... [truncated, 2116 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00788364/8 or ?id=EFTA00788364&page=8]", "char_count": 2116}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00788364", "page_number": 9, "text_content": "The Court's grant of an additional 120 days for service in deference to your medical issues did not confer on you a license \nto continue to disregard the Jurisdictional perquisites of proper service, with which you have failed to comply oven after \nhaving had 681 days to do so. The failure to properly serve Mr. Epstein again is evident from the face of your Notice of \nService of Process. No response to your clients' Amended Complaint is due or should be expected unless and until proper \nservice is made. I remind you that the Judge required such service be made not later than 120 days following his October \n5, 2016 order. \nPlease be guided accordingly. \nVery truly yours, \n/s/ W Chester Brewer. Jr. \nW. Chaster Brewer, lair \nAttorney at Law \nOne Clearlake Centro \n250 Australian Avenue South \nSuite 1400 \nWest Palm Beach, FL 33401 \n1. '561.655.4777 17 561.835.134a\nEFTA00788373\n", "char_count": 885}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00788364", "page_number": 10, "text_content": "-40mith rEAMIRR, APPelf/Mbi• \n• !kit daft ..4 pl itwor \n; \n,Haan Apartimmt Hotel, dippelite, \nDistrict Court \nAppeal' \nFililds; • \nJet .11, ISTI. r. r \nI • Defendant hi,. civil minim! Moved. to \ndiamies for lack of jurind[ddiet dteir iho \nperson and inaufficieat service of process. \nThe Circuit Court, Dade County, Paul Bak-\ner, J., denied the motion to diantisa, and \nplaintiff' apperchal. The District Court of \nAppeal, Sack, Moran, Associate Judge, held \nthat aubstrtated service of 'Prdtiess at /de-\nfondant's office 'upon a secretary therein \ndid 'not' Comply with applicable statute or \npm:deka& • \n• \n' \n•• • \nSubstituted • eervieu • of ennInen3 sad \ncomplaint at defendant's place of business \nwas insufficient where summons and com-\ne:at were merely left with defendant's \nsetretag: Wesel FAX .4 \nZ. Proem owt7 \n•: \n' \n• • ; \n• • \nStatutes governing substituted service \nof\n must he strictly construed had \nmust be strictly complied • with.. West's \nF.S.A. 4 18.031. \na. Preece sole \n.For -purpose .or statute, providing 'for \nabbilittited process, \"Orrin of the family\" \nmay be a visitor for prolonged period in \nabode of 'person • to be served, bat person \nactually served most be residing in his \nhome. Wart's F.S.A. I 48.081. \nSea Pultation Words and Phrases \nfor other Judicial constructions and \ndefinitions. \n\" \n. \n• \n• \n• . \nm \n• Chavolo & Feldman; Miamratul.BoWard \nHerewith, Tallahassee, for 'Swell:tit:I.\n•• \n; : WHAM/311'i; WHIFF \nI • I : \n• • \nFla. 531 \npeanaii\"s4l \na \nlts I \nSmith, Mantras, Bmlth,'Parker & Werner, \nhe linger, Miami Beath,. for:appellee. \n• \n• \n. \n. Before :HENDRY; t 7., PEARSON, 7, \naid SACK,: MARTIN,: Associate ludas, \n• \nSACK, MARTIN,. Associate Judge.\n• In ad attempt to perfect para\n. \n°nil fiery\n. ioe \nof proof:ea tiPoithe appellant, Cite Freddy \nCarrera -went to the Office of Fleetwood \nIt urines Agency, on the Bth 'flair of sea \n'Biscayne •Boulevard, Mkmt, fdr, Carreras, \nttpoh his arrival spoke to a secretary 'lad \ninformed her he had come to\n... [truncated, 3444 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00788364/10 or ?id=EFTA00788364&page=10]", "char_count": 3444}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00788364", "page_number": 11, "text_content": "532 Fie. \n341 SOU\"fitERN RE \n19/2X The term \"usual place of \nabode\" contained, in Section 48.031, Florida \nRestates (1976) means where the person is \nactually living at the.time of service. State \nv. Heffernan, 142 Fla.- 496, 196 So. 146 \n(1040). Furthermore, a \"person of the fain-\nCy\" may bo a visitor for a prolonged period \nto the abode of the person to be served, but \nthere is no queetkm that the peraon actually \nserved must be raiding in his hide. . Sang-\nr. Me.Elnea, 278 Sold 675 (Fla.8rd \nCoots v. Maryland Casualty \nCompany, 806 Sold 694 (F12.11d D.C.A. \nW76). \n. In light of the foregoing, there Is no wity \nthis court can construe substituted write \nof proms at a man's office upon a sate-\nfiery therein to constitute compliance with \nthe terms of Section 42031, Florida Stat. \neta (1975). This is so, notwithstanding a \nfailure to show the office in question was in \nfact the appellant's office and a conclusive \nshowing that the process server tailed to \n'inform the secretary as to the contenM of \nthe papers. \nTherefore, the order' appealed is hereby \n!evened, and the cause Is remanded to the \ntrial court for further proceedings not in-\nconsistent herewith. \nReversed and remanded, with dliroctiont \nAnthony John PEDONF., Appellant, \nv. \nThe STATE of Florida, Appellee. \nNa 74-441. \nDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida, \nThird Dlatriet, \nJan. 11, 1077. \nRehearing Denied Jan. 27, 1977. \n, \n• \n, \n• • \n, \nDefindant with convicted .before the \nCircuit 'Court :for pule County, Man FL \nroans,..2d SERIFS \n,.. \n• \n• \nSchwartz, J., of burglary, robbery, attempt-\ned murder and grand larceny, and he ap-\npealed. The District Court of Appeal held \nthat evidence that defendant and accom. \nplies gained •entry through trickery rather \nthan breaking and entering did not proecnt \nreversible error its regards burglary convic-\ntion but that it could not be said that pre. \ntrial ertieidnient to complaint to change \nono count from aggravited assault to at• \ntempted first-degree murder was \n... [truncated, 3218 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00788364/11 or ?id=EFTA00788364&page=11]", "char_count": 3218}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00788364", "page_number": 12, "text_content": "IN THE ELEVENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT OF FLORIDA \nIN AND FOR DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA \nCIVIL DIVISION \nJEAN-LUC BRUNEL \nCivil Action No.: 14-21348 CA 01 \nSection 34 \nPlaintiff, \nvs. \nJEFFREY EPSTEIN, \nTYLER MCDONALD, TYLER \nMCDONALD D/B/A/ YI.ORG \nDefendants. \nORDER ON PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR REHEARING/RELIEF \nTHIS CAUSE having come before the Court it is hereby ORDERED AND ADJUDGED: \nTHE MOTION IS \n\"\"\"Zif-7/175\".7\n• P./Ai-WWI-1 . \nM \n-12.4eVre-6 \n/20 \n,A4 r< \n-TO \nT \n-s- .--Ier..//c.f4\"7. \n44\" \n4-4-7zili c{ \n.% abrtio •-r \notelri-\n---/-7e-•:,) \n41/4\n(4/ / .i \nT—Aelt7-• \n--/-1,,Aw. \n7/nu mw-rnsCe shil.t, \nLae /D./sr p 1 A-4 - 0 \n1  \n4  \nPR-FT /-141/44- . , Gm\n'ilieri‘ir-7? 10-01 -'7? \nAP* _77,9_s ed- i.rn P \n.1 iti 4 Ar dAscista-41,9,' \nDONE AND ORDERED in Dade County, Miami, Florida, on \nthis -5- day of  \nO croseg. \n• , 2016. \nRODNEY SMITH \nCIRCUIT JUDGE \nCopies Furnished: all counsel of record \nThe Honorable Rodney Smith \nCircuit Court Judge \n23 \nEFTA00788376\n", "char_count": 966}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00788364", "page_number": 13, "text_content": "IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE \nELEVENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN AND \nFOR DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA \nCASE NO. 14-21348-CA-01 \nJEAN-LUC BRUNEL, individually, \nand MC2 MODEL & TALENT \nMIAMI, LLC. \nPlaintiffs, \nvs. \nJEFFREY EPSTEIN, \nTYLER MCDONALD, TYLER \nMCDONALD D/B/A/ YI.ORG \nDefendants. \nDEFENDANT JEFFREY EPSTEIN'S MOTION TO DISMISS \nCOMES NOW, the Defendant, Jeffrey Epstein, a resident of the United States Virgin \nIslands, by and through his undersigned counsel, and files this Motion to Dismiss, and. as good \ngrounds therefore states as follows: \n1. \nOn October 5, 2016, this Court ordered Plaintiffs to effect service on Mr. Epstein \nwithin 120 days of the date of that order (i.e., by no later than February 2, 2017) and ruled that if \nPlaintiffs did not effect service within that time period, this case would be dismissed with \nprejudice and \"no further order of this Court shall be necessary.\" As fully explained below, \nDefendant Jeffrey Epstein respectfully moves to dismiss all claims by Plaintiffs against him in \nthis Action because, even after the undersigned counsel gave Plaintiffs timely and repeated \nnotice of their improper and ineffective service attempt, Plaintiffs took no action to comply with \nthe Court's service deadline. \n2. \nIn complete disregard for Florida's procedural rules and Florida Statutes Section \n48.031(1)(a), on March 10, 2015, Plaintiffs improperly attempted to serve Defendant Jeffrey \nEpstein in New York by leaving process with a woman at a location that was not Mr. Epstein's \nEFTA00788377\n", "char_count": 1532}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00788364", "page_number": 14, "text_content": "usual place of abode. Plaintiffs never even filed a Notice of Service of Process in connection \nwith that failed attempt. \n3. \nThe undersigned counsel promptly fded a motion to quash on behalf of Mr. \nEpstein in April 2015, which motion included Mr. Bpstoin's affidavit confirming the location of \nhis residence and usual place of abode in the United States Virgin Islands. \n4. \nPlaintiffs waited a full year to respond to that motion to quash and in their \nresponse, perhaps conceding that the attempted service was improper, asked this Court to \ndisregard the procedural rules and order that Plaintiffs be permitted to serve Mr. Epstein through \nlegal counsel (not the undersigned) not even of record in this case. \n5. \nAfter Plaintiffs failed to appear at the hearing that Plaintiffs themselves scheduled \non Mr. Epstein's motion to quash, on July 27, 2016, this Court granted Mr. Epstein's motion to \nquash. \n6. \nThereafter, Plaintiffs sought a rehearing, claiming that they did not ream that the \nhearing they themselves scheduled was proceeding, and on October 5, 2015, this court kindly \ngranted Plaintiffs a full 120 additional days within which to properly servo Mr. Epstein, The \nCourt fIzther ruled that if service is not effected within that time, this matter would be dismissed \nwithout prejudice and that \"no further Order of this Court shall be necessary.\" \n7. \nPlaintiffs made no attempt to comply with the procedural requirements of Florida \nStatutes Section 48.031(1)(a) and refused to oven attempt service on Mr. Epstein at his U.S. \nVirgin Islands residence and usual place of abode. Instead, on November 17, 2016, Plaintiffs \nchose to make only their second service attempt in the 647 days since the original summons was \nissued for Mr. Epstein in this case (which was Plaintiffs' one and only service attempt during the \nperiod of extension granted by this Court) by leaving the summons and amended complaint with \na non-patty at an office address, which was clearly not Mr. Eps\n... [truncated, 2042 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00788364/14 or ?id=EFTA00788364&page=14]", "char_count": 2042}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00788364", "page_number": 15, "text_content": "8. \nFor the numerous reasons cited in Mr. Epstein's Opposition to Motion for Ruling \non Service of Process, Plaintiffs' November 17, 2016 service attempt was improper and \nineffective. \n9. \nOn December 7, 2016, the undersigned attorney informed the attorney for \nthe Plaintiffs that the November 17, 2016 service attempt was improper and ineffective in \nthat it did not comply with the statutory prerequisites of Florida Statutes Section 48.031. \nCopy of December 7, 2016 letter attached hereto as Exhibit A. \n10. \nRather than attempt proper service even a single time before the expiration \nof the extended service window granted by the Court, Plaintiffs chose to do nothing until \nwell after that window dosed. Having received the letter from Mr. Epstein's counsel on \nDecember 7, 2016, a full two months before the expiration of the extension period, \nPlaintiffs certainly could have filed their Motion For Ruling On Service Of Process on \nDefendant, Jeffrey Epstein, With Attached Order, before the expiration of the service \nwindow, so that if the Court found, as it should, that Plaintiffs' service is defective, Plaintiffs.\nwould have had sufficient time before the window closed to effectuate service properly. \nInstead, and as they have done for'the past two years, Plaintiffs chose to nothing until well \nafter the service deadline expired. Now they ask this Court to again indulge their flagrant \ndisregard for procedural law and the orders of this Court and hold that proper service has \nbeen obtained, even though, to do so would fly in the face of Florida law. \n11. \nBecause Plaintiffs have faikid to oven attempt proper service on Mr. Epstein for \nwell over two years following their January 2015 filing of the amended complaint first joining \nMr. Epstein as a party in this action, the Court should enforce its October 5, 2016 order and \ndismiss this matter as against Mr. Epstein. \n12. \nMoreover, because Plaintiffs actions demonstrate a flagrant disregard for the \nprocedural requir\n... [truncated, 2092 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00788364/15 or ?id=EFTA00788364&page=15]", "char_count": 2092}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00788364", "page_number": 16, "text_content": "WHEREFORE, Defendant Jeffrey Epstein, respectfully requests that this Court dismiss \nthe Amended Complaint as it pertains to Mr. Epstein, with prejudice and for such further relief as \nthis Court find just and proper. \nCERTIFICATE OF SERVICE \nIT IS HEREBY CERTIFIED that a true and correct copy of the foregoing has been electronically \nfurnished via email and/or E-file on the 30th day of March, 2017 to Joe Titone, \njoetitone708@comcastmet. \nW. CHESTER BREWER, JR., ■. \nCounsel for Epstein \n250 S. Australian Avenue, Suite 1400 \nWest Palm Beach, FL 33401 \n(561) 6554777 - Telephone \n(561) 83 \n- Fax \nE-Mail: \nBy: \n \n/s/ W. Chester Brewer. Jr. \nW. CHESTER BREWER, JR., ESQUIRE \nFlorida Bar No. 261858 \nEFTA00788380\n", "char_count": 716}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00788364", "page_number": 17, "text_content": "W. CHESTER BREWER, JR., M. \nATTDRNBY AT LAW \nSUITS 1400 \n250 AUSTRALIAN AVENUBSCYJIII \nWEST PALM BEACH, FLORIDA 47401.5086 \nTBIZPHONE. (MO6554W \nFAX (561) 83S4891 \nDecember 2, 2016 \nVia Email: joetitone70S®comeast.net \nJoe Titone, Esq. \n621 S.E. 5th St. \nPompano Beach, FL 33060 \nRe: Service of Process \nDear Joe, \nDecember 7, 2016 \nVia Email: ioetitone708Zeomcast.nel \nJoe Tttone, Esq. \n621 S.E. 5u' Street \nPompano Beach , FL 33060 \nRe: Service of Process \nDear Joe: \nI have had an opportunity to review the Notice Service of Process that you filed in the Jean Luc Bmnelllettrey Epstein \ncase. From my review it is clear that once again the attempt to serve runs afoul of Florida Statutes 48.031, as well as the \nholding in the Third District in liAIJSER VS. SCHIFF. I have attached a copy of that case for your ready reference. \nIt is now almost two years past the January 2015 filing date of your clients' amended complaint joining Mr. Epstein as a \ndefendant to the original action filed in August 2014. I remind you that no attempt was made to even serve Mr. Epstein \nuntil March 10, 2015. The required Notice of Service was never riled with the Court in respect of that attempt, which \nyou, yourself, conceded In your later flied Motion for Reconsideration was improper service. After rescheduling the \nhearing on Mr. Epstein's April 29, 2015 Motion to Quash four separate times, you failed to appear at the July 27, 2016 \nhearing on that Motion which was delayed for more than a year after its original filing date. The Court granted Mr. \nEpstein's motion in your absence. \nAt the subsequent October 5, 2016 hearing on your Motion for Reconsideration, you sought pardon from the Court for \nyour failure to appear at the July 27, 2016 hearing on Mr. Epstein's Motion to Quash. You sought to excuse your \n• absence, claiming that duo to a brain issue you somehow misunderstood the date on which you wore to appear oven \nthough it was you, yourself, who cancelled the previ \n1.. •.4....4”1\"4 \n 2\n... [truncated, 2117 chars — for the full page use /api/corpus/document/EFTA00788364/17 or ?id=EFTA00788364&page=17]", "char_count": 2117}, {"efta_number": "EFTA00788364", "page_number": 18, "text_content": "The Court's grant of an additional 120 days for service in deference to your medical issues did not confer on you a license \nto continue to disregard the Jurisdictional perquisites of proper service, with which you have failed to comply even after \nhaving had 681 days to do so. The failure to properly serve Mr. Epstein again is evident from the face of your Notice of \nService of Process. No response to your clients' Amended Complaint Is due or should be expected unless and until proper \nservice is made. I remind you that the Judge required such service be made not later than 120 days following his October \n5, 2016 order. \nPlease be guided accordingly. \nVery truly yours, \nIs/ W. Chester Brewer. ✓r. \nW. Chester Brewer, \nAttorney at Law \nOne Clearlake Centro \n250 Australian Avenue South \nSuite 1400 \nWest Palm Beach, FL. 33401 \nT j 561.655.4777 VI X561.835.8691 \nEFTA00788382\n", "char_count": 884}]}